 Singer Chris Brown created an answer song titled "Cinderella", replacing some of the verses and part of the chorus of "Umbrella" with his own lyrics. This version is the official remix. This version has been performed as a duet between Brown and Rihanna when he joined Rihanna on a late-2008 tour in the Asia-Pacific region. R & B / hip-hop singer The-Dream, who wrote "Umbrella", recorded the demo with a slightly different intro and instrumental.
