title: Evolutionary Significance and Conservation Implications of Vocal Dialects in North Island Kōkako (Callaeas wilsoni)

authors: Bradley, David William

subjects: North Island Kokako

abstract: Kōkako (Callaeas wilsoni) are endangered, duetting songbirds endemic to New Zealand and are confined to a small number of managed mainland reserves and offshore islands. Each fragmented population exhibits distinctive vocal traditions. Conservation of the species is centred on intensive site management of introduced mammalian predators – the current leading cause of kōkako population decline – followed by re-establishment of populations through translocation. Translocated populations are often sourced from multiple areas, leading to an artificially created scenario of secondary contact between behaviourally diverged populations.

I studied the consequences of kōkako song traditions, and the effect of population-specific behaviours on conservation of the species. During a transfer of 20 birds from two distinct "song neighbourhoods" (c. 25% between-neighbourhood phrase sharing), I explored the utility of neighbourhood specific acoustic playback as a conservation tool in preventing excessive post-release dispersal. I found that birds dispersed less far than predicted by a random walk model, yet were no more attracted to same- than different-neighbourhood song playback. These results suggested that while playback appeared to reduce dispersal, this effect was not driven by neighbourhood-specific song. Following release, kōkako also used the available habitat disproportionately, preferring to remain in the short term, and to establish breeding territories within a forest type similar to that where they were caught. The vocal differences I detected between the neighbourhoods at the source sites were also insufficient to promote assortative mating following release. The findings of this experiment confirmed that neighbourhood-scale song variation does not act as a barrier to gene flow, or inhibit post-translocation population establishment.

To assess whether more distinct vocal differences between populations (c. 5% between-population phrase sharing) represent more salient signals to kōkako, I performed reciprocal stereo playback experiments in two populations frequently used as translocation source sites. In one experiment I tested for discrimination between local and foreign dialect duets and found that pairs responded vocally to local duets with less delay, and produced more song phrases, with a lower diversity, compared to playback of foreign duets. This suggested that local song represented more of a threat to pairs than unfamiliar song. In a second experiment I presented pairs with two types of synthesised local-foreign mixed-dialect duets; each stimulus differed depending on the sex of the local duet stimulus component. I found that pairs responded with equal overall strength to both stimuli, and did so in a qualitatively similar way to pure local duets. As pairs did not discriminate between these stimuli, this indicates that if mixed-dialect pairs form, they should be able to effectively communicate with, and defend against territorial intruders. From an evolutionary perspective this further suggests that dialectal differences might not prevent gene flow in kōkako if pair formation between dialects can occur. Importantly, these findings also suggest that animals translocated for conservation purposes need not necessarily exhibit homogeneous cultures to acquire and defend resources.

Sexual selection leading to positive assortative mating based on song dialect may act as an isolating barrier to gene flow, thus promoting speciation. From a conservation perspective this process could be problematic by hindering population establishment following translocation of a small number of individuals from multiple sources. To assess this tendency in kōkako, I harnessed an existing 18-year data set from reports prepared by the New Zealand Department of Conservation documenting multi-source translocations to six sites from 11 source populations. Based on these reports, in each breeding season at each site I compiled a list of the possible same- and mixed-dialect pairs that could have formed, which I then compared to the actual pairs in each season. In doing so, I statistically confirmed that, following release, kōkako pairs form assortatively based on dialect more often than expected by chance. However, mixed-dialect pairs did form in low numbers at two sites, either when an existing "core" population was present at the time of translocation, or following the release of a captive-reared sub-adult bird with potentially plastic song. These results suggest that sufficiently large differences in a sexually selected behavioural trait, such as song, can inhibit gene flow between populations.

Taken together, my findings suggest that vocal variation among fragmented, allopatric populations may influence a species' cultural and genetic history, and could affect the success of conservation strategies. However, as kōkako pairs can form across dialects, and postnatal dispersal sometimes occurs between areas with different song traditions, complete genetic isolation of populations is unlikely to occur. Further research on the timing of song-learning in kōkako, dispersal patterns, and vocal plasticity in territorial adults will greatly advance our knowledge base and shed light on the function and conservation implications of song dialects in kōkako.

text: Evolutionary Significance and Conservation Implications of Vocal Dialects in North Island Kōkako (Callaeas wilsoni) Kōkako (Callaeas wilsoni) are endangered, duetting songbirds endemic to New Zealand and are confined to a small number of managed mainland reserves and offshore islands. Each fragmented population exhibits distinctive vocal traditions. Conservation of the species is centred on intensive site management of introduced mammalian predators – the current leading cause of kōkako population decline – followed by re-establishment of populations through translocation. Translocated populations are often sourced from multiple areas, leading to an artificially created scenario of secondary contact between behaviourally diverged populations.

I studied the consequences of kōkako song traditions, and the effect of population-specific behaviours on conservation of the species. During a transfer of 20 birds from two distinct "song neighbourhoods" (c. 25% between-neighbourhood phrase sharing), I explored the utility of neighbourhood specific acoustic playback as a conservation tool in preventing excessive post-release dispersal. I found that birds dispersed less far than predicted by a random walk model, yet were no more attracted to same- than different-neighbourhood song playback. These results suggested that while playback appeared to reduce dispersal, this effect was not driven by neighbourhood-specific song. Following release, kōkako also used the available habitat disproportionately, preferring to remain in the short term, and to establish breeding territories within a forest type similar to that where they were caught. The vocal differences I detected between the neighbourhoods at the source sites were also insufficient to promote assortative mating following release. The findings of this experiment confirmed that neighbourhood-scale song variation does not act as a barrier to gene flow, or inhibit post-translocation population establishment.

To assess whether more distinct vocal differences between populations (c. 5% between-population phrase sharing) represent more salient signals to kōkako, I performed reciprocal stereo playback experiments in two populations frequently used as translocation source sites. In one experiment I tested for discrimination between local and foreign dialect duets and found that pairs responded vocally to local duets with less delay, and produced more song phrases, with a lower diversity, compared to playback of foreign duets. This suggested that local song represented more of a threat to pairs than unfamiliar song. In a second experiment I presented pairs with two types of synthesised local-foreign mixed-dialect duets; each stimulus differed depending on the sex of the local duet stimulus component. I found that pairs responded with equal overall strength to both stimuli, and did so in a qualitatively similar way to pure local duets. As pairs did not discriminate between these stimuli, this indicates that if mixed-dialect pairs form, they should be able to effectively communicate with, and defend against territorial intruders. From an evolutionary perspective this further suggests that dialectal differences might not prevent gene flow in kōkako if pair formation between dialects can occur. Importantly, these findings also suggest that animals translocated for conservation purposes need not necessarily exhibit homogeneous cultures to acquire and defend resources.

Sexual selection leading to positive assortative mating based on song dialect may act as an isolating barrier to gene flow, thus promoting speciation. From a conservation perspective this process could be problematic by hindering population establishment following translocation of a small number of individuals from multiple sources. To assess this tendency in kōkako, I harnessed an existing 18-year data set from reports prepared by the New Zealand Department of Conservation documenting multi-source translocations to six sites from 11 source populations. Based on these reports, in each breeding season at each site I compiled a list of the possible same- and mixed-dialect pairs that could have formed, which I then compared to the actual pairs in each season. In doing so, I statistically confirmed that, following release, kōkako pairs form assortatively based on dialect more often than expected by chance. However, mixed-dialect pairs did form in low numbers at two sites, either when an existing "core" population was present at the time of translocation, or following the release of a captive-reared sub-adult bird with potentially plastic song. These results suggest that sufficiently large differences in a sexually selected behavioural trait, such as song, can inhibit gene flow between populations.

Taken together, my findings suggest that vocal variation among fragmented, allopatric populations may influence a species' cultural and genetic history, and could affect the success of conservation strategies. However, as kōkako pairs can form across dialects, and postnatal dispersal sometimes occurs between areas with different song traditions, complete genetic isolation of populations is unlikely to occur. Further research on the timing of song-learning in kōkako, dispersal patterns, and vocal plasticity in territorial adults will greatly advance our knowledge base and shed light on the function and conservation implications of song dialects in kōkako.

year: 2012

title: Targeted memory reactivation, errors, and sleep-dependent memory consolidation: Implications for off-line motor learning

authors: Jahnke, Tyler Jovarn

subjects: Sleep

abstract: Memory consolidation benefits from sleep and is fundamental for motor learning. However, sleep-dependent consolidation occurs for a range of motor memories, some of which may be associated with successful practice trials and some of which may be associated with unsuccessful practice trials, or errors. Consequently, the aim of this thesis was to investigate whether it is possible to enhance sleep-dependent consolidation rates by constraining the learning environment in order to regulate errors during practice.

Chapter 1 reviews literature relevant to this question. Chapter Two presents an experiment in which we investigated whether sleep-dependent consolidation is likely to result in a higher rate of learning when many successful trials occur at the end of practice compared to when many unsuccessful practice trials occur at the end of practice. Results showed that the Successful-trials group displayed significant improvements in performance following a night of sleep, whereas the Unsuccessful-trials group did not. We concluded that sleep resulted in better learning in the successful trials group than the unsuccessful trials group because memories of more successful trials and fewer unsuccessful trials consolidated. A serial-position effect may explain these findings; however, more work is needed.

Chapter Three presents a follow-up experiment in which we used the same apparatus and protocol as in Chapter Two. However, we incorporated targeted memory reactivation to promote greater off-line consolidation of successful trials in the successful trials group, and of unsuccessful trials in the unsuccessful trials group. Results showed that both groups displayed significant improvements in performance following a night of sleep. We concluded that targeted memory reactivation may have augmented consolidation of successful trials at the expense of unsuccessful trials, but more work is necessary. The role of dopamine in memory consolidation was discussed.

The results of this thesis provide some support for the premise that it is possible to enhance sleep-dependent consolidation rates by constraining the learning environment in order to regulate errors during practice. Theoretical and practical implications of the findings are discussed in Chapter Four.

text: Targeted memory reactivation, errors, and sleep-dependent memory consolidation: Implications for off-line motor learning Memory consolidation benefits from sleep and is fundamental for motor learning. However, sleep-dependent consolidation occurs for a range of motor memories, some of which may be associated with successful practice trials and some of which may be associated with unsuccessful practice trials, or errors. Consequently, the aim of this thesis was to investigate whether it is possible to enhance sleep-dependent consolidation rates by constraining the learning environment in order to regulate errors during practice.

Chapter 1 reviews literature relevant to this question. Chapter Two presents an experiment in which we investigated whether sleep-dependent consolidation is likely to result in a higher rate of learning when many successful trials occur at the end of practice compared to when many unsuccessful practice trials occur at the end of practice. Results showed that the Successful-trials group displayed significant improvements in performance following a night of sleep, whereas the Unsuccessful-trials group did not. We concluded that sleep resulted in better learning in the successful trials group than the unsuccessful trials group because memories of more successful trials and fewer unsuccessful trials consolidated. A serial-position effect may explain these findings; however, more work is needed.

Chapter Three presents a follow-up experiment in which we used the same apparatus and protocol as in Chapter Two. However, we incorporated targeted memory reactivation to promote greater off-line consolidation of successful trials in the successful trials group, and of unsuccessful trials in the unsuccessful trials group. Results showed that both groups displayed significant improvements in performance following a night of sleep. We concluded that targeted memory reactivation may have augmented consolidation of successful trials at the expense of unsuccessful trials, but more work is necessary. The role of dopamine in memory consolidation was discussed.

The results of this thesis provide some support for the premise that it is possible to enhance sleep-dependent consolidation rates by constraining the learning environment in order to regulate errors during practice. Theoretical and practical implications of the findings are discussed in Chapter Four.

year: 2022

title: Science-practice roadshow 1: Summary perspectives from centralised entities and agencies

authors: Serrao-Neumann, Silvia

abstract: Flooding is Aotearoa-New Zealand’s most frequent natural hazard, regularly damaging buildings and infrastructure networks, and causing months of disruption to communities and businesses (Hutchings et al. 2019). Also, floods have indirect, cascading, and more intangible impacts (Lawrence, Blackett, and Cradock-Henry 2020), such as the withdrawal of future investment or the emotional stress of recovery. flood risk is predicted to rise quickly due to the combination of climate change and rapid urban intensification (Ministry for the Environment and The Flood Risk Management and River Control Review Steering Group 2008). 

Currently, there is no consistent approach to accurately determine flood risk on a national scale, nor how this may be changing as the climate warms. Instead, flooding risk assessments are done for individual catchments or locations, with the goal of managing and mitigating on the local scale. Local and regional governments vary widely in their capability and capacity to undertake this work (Ford, Berrang-Ford, and Berrang Ford 2011) and, thus, significant differences in data availability and modelling approaches mean that integration of results to gain a pan-region or nationwide picture has not been possible. 

The ‘Mā te haumaru ō nga puna wai ō Rākaihautū ka ora mo ake tonu: Increasing flood resilience across Aotearoa’ research develop a detailed nationwide model that could inform strategic and co-ordinated nationwide decision-making and regulations to support improved resilience to flood risk across the country. Utilising new methods and advances in computer processing and automation, the programme is developing a dynamic risk modelling framework that will assess flood hazard for every catchment in the country and under differing climate scenarios. The model will account for the risks to both built infrastructure and communities so that a fuller understanding of societal costs and impacts can be established. The model’s utility for supporting decision-making will be investigated using an initial set of scenarios for environmental planning, policy settings and infrastructure investment options. Two overarching themes across all of the research - Mtauranga Mori and Uncertainty – are designed to utilise the diverse knowledge systems available to develop tools that are relevant for communities throughout Aotearoa-New Zealand, and to take into account and communicate more clearly flood risks. 

Improved resilience to flooding across Aotearoa-New Zealand is a key outcome sought by the research programme, however it cannot be achieved by research alone. Instead, knowledge and information developed within the programme must be utilised by practitioners in their work to assist communities to plan for, manage, mitigate and avoid flood risks. New knowledge from the programme must be incorporated by practitioners into further tools, policy and decision-making frameworks. This knowledge translation however is not a straight forward process (Dilling and Lemos 2011). Cultural, behavioural and cognitive differences between those who produce and those who utilise knowledge mean that research outputs may not fit the requirements of their intended users, and thus, uptake of research outputs may be compromised. Conversely, strong engagement of knowledge users in the knowledge production process is known to increase the likelihood, and impact, of knowledge implementation. 

Stakeholders are key members of the programme’s research team, representing views across central and local government, engineering, planning consultancies, emergency management, insurance and banking industries, and Te Rūnanga o Wairewa (Banks Peninsula). To broaden the range of stakeholder perspectives, and to facilitate relationships across the programme, we have established a boundary organisation – Te W Te W . Boundary organisations (Guston 2001; Kirchhoff, Esselman, and Brown 2015) are forums that bridge between the two relatively different social worlds of knowledge producers (researchers/scientists) and users (practitioners/policy makers). These forums create and sustain legitimate space and collaboration for knowledge/information to be co-designed, co-produced and co-disseminated (Serrao-Neumann, Di Giulio, and Low Choy 2020). Within our programme, Te W Te W is responsible for organising and facilitating communication and collaboration activities – events (Science-Practice oadshows), communications channels such as an electronic newsletter and website, and learning opportunities. Through this organisation, we are fostering trust, legitimacy and capacity for information use so that our research results will be usable, useful, and used. 

This report summarises the discussion and perspectives shared at the first Science-Practice Roadshow held in October 2021.

text: Science-practice roadshow 1: Summary perspectives from centralised entities and agencies Flooding is Aotearoa-New Zealand’s most frequent natural hazard, regularly damaging buildings and infrastructure networks, and causing months of disruption to communities and businesses (Hutchings et al. 2019). Also, floods have indirect, cascading, and more intangible impacts (Lawrence, Blackett, and Cradock-Henry 2020), such as the withdrawal of future investment or the emotional stress of recovery. flood risk is predicted to rise quickly due to the combination of climate change and rapid urban intensification (Ministry for the Environment and The Flood Risk Management and River Control Review Steering Group 2008). 

Currently, there is no consistent approach to accurately determine flood risk on a national scale, nor how this may be changing as the climate warms. Instead, flooding risk assessments are done for individual catchments or locations, with the goal of managing and mitigating on the local scale. Local and regional governments vary widely in their capability and capacity to undertake this work (Ford, Berrang-Ford, and Berrang Ford 2011) and, thus, significant differences in data availability and modelling approaches mean that integration of results to gain a pan-region or nationwide picture has not been possible. 

The ‘Mā te haumaru ō nga puna wai ō Rākaihautū ka ora mo ake tonu: Increasing flood resilience across Aotearoa’ research develop a detailed nationwide model that could inform strategic and co-ordinated nationwide decision-making and regulations to support improved resilience to flood risk across the country. Utilising new methods and advances in computer processing and automation, the programme is developing a dynamic risk modelling framework that will assess flood hazard for every catchment in the country and under differing climate scenarios. The model will account for the risks to both built infrastructure and communities so that a fuller understanding of societal costs and impacts can be established. The model’s utility for supporting decision-making will be investigated using an initial set of scenarios for environmental planning, policy settings and infrastructure investment options. Two overarching themes across all of the research - Mtauranga Mori and Uncertainty – are designed to utilise the diverse knowledge systems available to develop tools that are relevant for communities throughout Aotearoa-New Zealand, and to take into account and communicate more clearly flood risks. 

Improved resilience to flooding across Aotearoa-New Zealand is a key outcome sought by the research programme, however it cannot be achieved by research alone. Instead, knowledge and information developed within the programme must be utilised by practitioners in their work to assist communities to plan for, manage, mitigate and avoid flood risks. New knowledge from the programme must be incorporated by practitioners into further tools, policy and decision-making frameworks. This knowledge translation however is not a straight forward process (Dilling and Lemos 2011). Cultural, behavioural and cognitive differences between those who produce and those who utilise knowledge mean that research outputs may not fit the requirements of their intended users, and thus, uptake of research outputs may be compromised. Conversely, strong engagement of knowledge users in the knowledge production process is known to increase the likelihood, and impact, of knowledge implementation. 

Stakeholders are key members of the programme’s research team, representing views across central and local government, engineering, planning consultancies, emergency management, insurance and banking industries, and Te Rūnanga o Wairewa (Banks Peninsula). To broaden the range of stakeholder perspectives, and to facilitate relationships across the programme, we have established a boundary organisation – Te W Te W . Boundary organisations (Guston 2001; Kirchhoff, Esselman, and Brown 2015) are forums that bridge between the two relatively different social worlds of knowledge producers (researchers/scientists) and users (practitioners/policy makers). These forums create and sustain legitimate space and collaboration for knowledge/information to be co-designed, co-produced and co-disseminated (Serrao-Neumann, Di Giulio, and Low Choy 2020). Within our programme, Te W Te W is responsible for organising and facilitating communication and collaboration activities – events (Science-Practice oadshows), communications channels such as an electronic newsletter and website, and learning opportunities. Through this organisation, we are fostering trust, legitimacy and capacity for information use so that our research results will be usable, useful, and used. 

This report summarises the discussion and perspectives shared at the first Science-Practice Roadshow held in October 2021.

year: 2022-02