title: Incorporating critical pedagogy into the scholarship of teaching and learning: making the journey alongside our students

authors: Grant, Suzanne Lisa Parker

subjects: management studies

abstract: In this paper we draw on our teaching and learning experiences in the management classroom, to illustrate how reflective teaching practices and experiential learning can be used to incorporate critical pedagogy into the SoTL. The exercise described within is one which, at first glance, appears very simple and straight forward, and is perhaps the most basic example of all our experiential practices. However, we found this simple exercise to have powerful learning and reflection effects for both the students and ourselves. This experience, and our subsequent pedagogical reflection, reaffirms the need for educators to remain present in the classroom, and reflective about the impacts of their teaching practices on students.

text: Incorporating critical pedagogy into the scholarship of teaching and learning: making the journey alongside our students In this paper we draw on our teaching and learning experiences in the management classroom, to illustrate how reflective teaching practices and experiential learning can be used to incorporate critical pedagogy into the SoTL. The exercise described within is one which, at first glance, appears very simple and straight forward, and is perhaps the most basic example of all our experiential practices. However, we found this simple exercise to have powerful learning and reflection effects for both the students and ourselves. This experience, and our subsequent pedagogical reflection, reaffirms the need for educators to remain present in the classroom, and reflective about the impacts of their teaching practices on students.

year: 2010

title: The identification of threshold concepts and their application in curriculum development: Exploring threshold concepts through the context of engineering education

authors: Morgan, Alan Alexander Harold

subjects: Threshold Concepts

abstract: Threshold Concept (TC) theory was introduced by Erik Meyer and Ray Land in 2003 and states that every discipline of study contains troublesome concepts that transform the learner when they come to be understood. This transformation will concern either the learner’s thinking about the discipline and/or their perception of the discipline. Five characteristics were originally proposed that can help to signalise TCs, which are, troublesome, transformative, irreversible, integrative and bounded.

This thesis explores both, the in-depth ways in which TCs have sought to be identified, and to what extent the role of TCs in curriculum development has been studied. This was done by exploring researchers’ thinking in regard to the importance of each of the five TC characteristics, the data collection methods and participants that were included in their studies, and the extent to which they attempted to study TCs in relation to the development of curricula. Engineering education TC studies formed the context through which I attempted to answer the research questions. The first method I used to obtain my data was to carry out a systematic quantitative literature review (SQLR) of peer-reviewed TC research articles that were published between 2003 and the present day. From the relevant 147 papers that resulted from my database searching, I narrowed this down to the 15 articles that related directly to engineering education. The SQLR data was then used to inform the semi-structured interviews that I conducted with three TC researchers in the field of engineering education.

The findings suggested troublesome and transformative to be the TC characteristics that are the most essential of the five to consider when seeking to identify TCs. This finding was based on the fact that they were the two characteristics most highly referenced in the SQLR literature and were the ones thought most important by two of three of my interviewees. The inclusion of  multiple types of participants and data collection methods were found to be common and effective practices amongst TC researchers. Again, this finding was supported with the SQLR data and by all three interviewees. Lastly, it was discovered that, despite TCs being considered the potential centrepieces of a curriculum, there is a lack of TC studies focussing on the role of TCs in curriculum development. There existed no studies within the SQLR literature that held this aspect as a sole focus.

text: The identification of threshold concepts and their application in curriculum development: Exploring threshold concepts through the context of engineering education Threshold Concept (TC) theory was introduced by Erik Meyer and Ray Land in 2003 and states that every discipline of study contains troublesome concepts that transform the learner when they come to be understood. This transformation will concern either the learner’s thinking about the discipline and/or their perception of the discipline. Five characteristics were originally proposed that can help to signalise TCs, which are, troublesome, transformative, irreversible, integrative and bounded.

This thesis explores both, the in-depth ways in which TCs have sought to be identified, and to what extent the role of TCs in curriculum development has been studied. This was done by exploring researchers’ thinking in regard to the importance of each of the five TC characteristics, the data collection methods and participants that were included in their studies, and the extent to which they attempted to study TCs in relation to the development of curricula. Engineering education TC studies formed the context through which I attempted to answer the research questions. The first method I used to obtain my data was to carry out a systematic quantitative literature review (SQLR) of peer-reviewed TC research articles that were published between 2003 and the present day. From the relevant 147 papers that resulted from my database searching, I narrowed this down to the 15 articles that related directly to engineering education. The SQLR data was then used to inform the semi-structured interviews that I conducted with three TC researchers in the field of engineering education.

The findings suggested troublesome and transformative to be the TC characteristics that are the most essential of the five to consider when seeking to identify TCs. This finding was based on the fact that they were the two characteristics most highly referenced in the SQLR literature and were the ones thought most important by two of three of my interviewees. The inclusion of  multiple types of participants and data collection methods were found to be common and effective practices amongst TC researchers. Again, this finding was supported with the SQLR data and by all three interviewees. Lastly, it was discovered that, despite TCs being considered the potential centrepieces of a curriculum, there is a lack of TC studies focussing on the role of TCs in curriculum development. There existed no studies within the SQLR literature that held this aspect as a sole focus.

year: 2019

title: Te Mata Ira—Faces of the Gene: Developing a cultural foundation for biobanking and genomic research involving Māori

authors: Hudson, Maui

abstract: Te Mata Ira was a three-year research project (2012–2015) that explored Māori views on genomic research and biobanking for the development of culturally appropriate guidelines. A key component of this process has been to identify Māori concepts that provide cultural reference points for engaging with biobanking and genomic research. These cultural cues provide the basis for describing the cultural logic that underpins engagement in this context in a culturally acceptable manner. This paper outlines the role of two wānanga (workshops) conducted as part of the larger project that were used to make sense of the Māori concepts that emerged from other data-collection activities. The wānanga involved six experts who worked with the research team to make sense of the Māori concepts. The wānanga process created the logic behind the cultural foundation for biobanking and genomic research, providing a basis for understanding Māori concepts, Māori ethical principles and their application to biobanking and genomic research.

text: Te Mata Ira—Faces of the Gene: Developing a cultural foundation for biobanking and genomic research involving Māori Te Mata Ira was a three-year research project (2012–2015) that explored Māori views on genomic research and biobanking for the development of culturally appropriate guidelines. A key component of this process has been to identify Māori concepts that provide cultural reference points for engaging with biobanking and genomic research. These cultural cues provide the basis for describing the cultural logic that underpins engagement in this context in a culturally acceptable manner. This paper outlines the role of two wānanga (workshops) conducted as part of the larger project that were used to make sense of the Māori concepts that emerged from other data-collection activities. The wānanga involved six experts who worked with the research team to make sense of the Māori concepts. The wānanga process created the logic behind the cultural foundation for biobanking and genomic research, providing a basis for understanding Māori concepts, Māori ethical principles and their application to biobanking and genomic research.

year: 2016