title: This is simply what I do: Peirce's real generality meets Wittgenstein's rule-following?

authors: Legg, Catherine

subjects: philosophy

abstract: Wittgenstein’s discussion of rule-following is widely regarded to have identified what Kripke called “the most radical and original sceptical problem that philosophy has seen to date”. But does it? This paper examines the problem in the light of Charles Peirce’s distinctive scientific hierarchy. Peirce identifies a phenomenological inquiry which is prior to both logic and metaphysics, whose role is to identify the most fundamental philosophical categories. His third category, particularly salient in this context, pertains to general predication.

Rule-following scepticism, the paper suggests, results from running together two questions: “How is it that I can project rules?”, and, “What is it for a given usage of a rule to be right?”. In Peircean terms the former question, concerning the irreducibility of general predication (to singular reference), must be answered in phenomenology, while the latter, concerning the difference between true and false predication, is answered in logic. A failure to appreciate this distinction, it is argued, has led philosophers to focus exclusively on Wittgenstein’s famous public account of rule-following rightness, thus overlooking a private, phenomenological dimension to Wittgenstein’s remarks on following a rule which gives the lie to Kripke’s reading of him as a sceptic.

text: This is simply what I do: Peirce's real generality meets Wittgenstein's rule-following? Wittgenstein’s discussion of rule-following is widely regarded to have identified what Kripke called “the most radical and original sceptical problem that philosophy has seen to date”. But does it? This paper examines the problem in the light of Charles Peirce’s distinctive scientific hierarchy. Peirce identifies a phenomenological inquiry which is prior to both logic and metaphysics, whose role is to identify the most fundamental philosophical categories. His third category, particularly salient in this context, pertains to general predication.

Rule-following scepticism, the paper suggests, results from running together two questions: “How is it that I can project rules?”, and, “What is it for a given usage of a rule to be right?”. In Peircean terms the former question, concerning the irreducibility of general predication (to singular reference), must be answered in phenomenology, while the latter, concerning the difference between true and false predication, is answered in logic. A failure to appreciate this distinction, it is argued, has led philosophers to focus exclusively on Wittgenstein’s famous public account of rule-following rightness, thus overlooking a private, phenomenological dimension to Wittgenstein’s remarks on following a rule which gives the lie to Kripke’s reading of him as a sceptic.

year: 2003-01

title: Root Biomass under Range of Pasture Swards -Implications for Soil Carbon Stocks

authors: Jordan, Olivia Margaret

subjects: root biomass

abstract: Soil carbon (C) is the largest terrestrial store of carbon, greater than all other pools combined. Root biomass is recognised as an important contributor to the accumulation of soil C and recent studies have suggested that a higher diversity of plant species with higher root biomass may increase soil C content. Maintenance of soil C stocks is important as losses can contribute to increased greenhouse gas emissions. Furthermore soil C is important for maintaining soil quality. Much of New Zealand agricultural land is under pastoral grazing and is the greatest contributor to national greenhouse gas emissions from land. The potential for storing additional soil C in pasture soils is poorly understood. This study has assessed root biomass and carbon contents of soils under a range of pasture diversities and species composition to determine whether (i) there is greater root biomass under increasing plant diversity, (ii) changes in root properties between diversity treatments are evident and (iii) there is variation in root biomass between seasons. 
Soil samples were collected from an existing small plot trial managed by DairyNZ and Landcare Research containing 14 different mixtures of pasture species (three replicates per treatment). From each plot, fifteen soil cores were taken to a depth of 60cm, and bulked by 10cm depth increments. Root characteristics were determined after removing soil via scanning and analysing with WinRHIZO©, and subsequently root biomass determined following oven drying and weighing. A sub-sample of soil was also taken for C and nitrogen (N) analysis by combustion furnace. 
While there were no significant differences in root biomass with individual treatments, plots which had a presence of herb species chicory and plantain, resulted in a lesser root biomass when compared with plots without herb species. This would imply that while the use of herb species is desirable for above-ground production and drought tolerance, they provide limited potential for increasing C input to soil. Root characteristics determined that the use of tall fescue as a base grass resulted in a reduced root length density (RLD, root length per volume of soil to 60 cm), specific root length (SRL) and an increased average diameter compared with ryegrass based pastures. These characteristics promote increased root longevity in soil.

text: Root Biomass under Range of Pasture Swards -Implications for Soil Carbon Stocks Soil carbon (C) is the largest terrestrial store of carbon, greater than all other pools combined. Root biomass is recognised as an important contributor to the accumulation of soil C and recent studies have suggested that a higher diversity of plant species with higher root biomass may increase soil C content. Maintenance of soil C stocks is important as losses can contribute to increased greenhouse gas emissions. Furthermore soil C is important for maintaining soil quality. Much of New Zealand agricultural land is under pastoral grazing and is the greatest contributor to national greenhouse gas emissions from land. The potential for storing additional soil C in pasture soils is poorly understood. This study has assessed root biomass and carbon contents of soils under a range of pasture diversities and species composition to determine whether (i) there is greater root biomass under increasing plant diversity, (ii) changes in root properties between diversity treatments are evident and (iii) there is variation in root biomass between seasons. 
Soil samples were collected from an existing small plot trial managed by DairyNZ and Landcare Research containing 14 different mixtures of pasture species (three replicates per treatment). From each plot, fifteen soil cores were taken to a depth of 60cm, and bulked by 10cm depth increments. Root characteristics were determined after removing soil via scanning and analysing with WinRHIZO©, and subsequently root biomass determined following oven drying and weighing. A sub-sample of soil was also taken for C and nitrogen (N) analysis by combustion furnace. 
While there were no significant differences in root biomass with individual treatments, plots which had a presence of herb species chicory and plantain, resulted in a lesser root biomass when compared with plots without herb species. This would imply that while the use of herb species is desirable for above-ground production and drought tolerance, they provide limited potential for increasing C input to soil. Root characteristics determined that the use of tall fescue as a base grass resulted in a reduced root length density (RLD, root length per volume of soil to 60 cm), specific root length (SRL) and an increased average diameter compared with ryegrass based pastures. These characteristics promote increased root longevity in soil.

year: 2015

title: Participatory data design: managing data sovereignty in IoT solutions

authors: Bowen, Judy

subjects: computer science

abstract: Within the software engineering community, deciding how to collect, store and use personal data has become about more than just understanding our users. This paper considers ethical data use which includes cultural considerations and data ownership rights. We discuss indigenous data sovereignty as a concept and how it potentially impacts technological solutions that gather personal data from users. We propose an extension to typical user-centred design processes which we call participatory data design. This incorporates the use of frameworks and tools that specifically focus on managing data within the cultural context it is gathered from. We also present a specific example of how we have used this approach in the context of a data collection project from M¯aori workers in New Zealand forestry. We conclude with a discussion of the wider implications of this approach.

text: Participatory data design: managing data sovereignty in IoT solutions Within the software engineering community, deciding how to collect, store and use personal data has become about more than just understanding our users. This paper considers ethical data use which includes cultural considerations and data ownership rights. We discuss indigenous data sovereignty as a concept and how it potentially impacts technological solutions that gather personal data from users. We propose an extension to typical user-centred design processes which we call participatory data design. This incorporates the use of frameworks and tools that specifically focus on managing data within the cultural context it is gathered from. We also present a specific example of how we have used this approach in the context of a data collection project from M¯aori workers in New Zealand forestry. We conclude with a discussion of the wider implications of this approach.

year: 2022