Sentence:  One afternoon the local reverend and Curtis are tossing the football around at the park. When the reverend <WSD>overthrows</WSD> the ball, Curtis demands that Jasmine put down her book and throw the ball back. This is the moment where Curtis is handed a glimpse of her potential as a football player and begins his quest to inspire her to play. 
Meaning of the word marked with <WSD> tags:  To throw (something) so that it goes too far.