6. Joint Employment Report for 1999
A5-0046/1999
European Parliament resolution on the Commission’s draft Joint Employment Report 1999
SEC(1999) 1386 /dash C5-0215/1999)
The European Parliament,
Ndash having regard to the draft Joint Employment Report (SEC(1999) 1386 Ndash C5-0215/1999),
Ndash having regard to the Commission recommendation for the Council recommendations on implement-
ing employment policy in the Member States (COM(1999) 445),
Ndash having regard to the conclusions of the Presidency following the special summit in Luxembourg
on 20and 21 November 1997, the Cardiff summit on 15 and 16 June 1998, the Vienna summit on11 and 12 December 1998 and the Cologne summit on 3 and 4 June 1999,
Ndash having regard to the resolution of the European Council of Amsterdam of 16 June 1997 on growth
and employment(
1),
Ndash having regard to the resolution of the European Council of Cologne on 3 and 4 June 1999 on the
European Employment Pact,
Ndash having regard to its resolution of 18 November 1998 on the Commission communication Ndash Proposal
for Guidelines for Member States’ Employment Policies 1999(2),
Ndash having regard to its resolution of 11 March 1999 on the communication from the Commission to the
Council, the European Parliament, the Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of theRegions, ‘The EU economy at the arrival of the euro: promoting growth, employment and stability’(1999 annual economic report)(
3),
Ndash having regard to its resolution of 4 May 1999 on the European Parliament’s contribution on the
European Employment Pact and on the Commission’s communication on Community policies in sup-port of employment (under Article 127 of the EC Treaty)(
4),
Ndash having regard to Articles 2, 3(2), 125, 126, 127, 128, 129, 130, 137(1) and 141 of the Treaty estab-
lishing the European Community,
Ndash having regard to the report of the Committee on Employment and Social Affairs and the opinions of
the Committee on Women’s Rights and Equal Opportunities and the Committee on Economic andMonetary Affairs (A5-0046/1999);
A. whereas nearly 60million people are living below the poverty line in the Member States, and this
constitutes a threat to social cohesion and to the European social model,
B. whereas, although the Community created 1,8 million additional jobs in 1998 by means of its
employment-policy initiatives, the relative level of youth unemployment still varied markedly acrossthe Member States and in two instances no improvement was registered at all and whereas the overallfigure of 19,5% remains unacceptably high, which means that considerable and sustained efforts are
still required to reduce youth unemployment perceptibly,
C. whereas in 1998 only a few Member States managed to significantly reduce long-term unemployment
and it is still the case that approximately half the unemployed persons in the European Union areunemployed long-term and whereas, therefore, preventive measures must be pushed through on asustained basis in all Member States to reduce long-term unemployment,
D. whereas less than half the population of working age between the ages of 50and 64 are employed
and whereas, therefore, coherent strategies are needed to combat the exclusion of older workers fromthe labour market,
(1) OJ C 236, 2.8.1997, p. 3.
(2) OJ C 379, 7.12.1998, p. 88.
(3) OJ C 175, 21.6.1999, p. 296.
(4) OJ C 279, 1.10.1999, p. 111.7.6.2000 EN C 158/43 Official Journal of the European Communities
Thursday 4 November 1999
E. whereas tax systems and benefits must be redesigned in such a way as to encourage jobs,
F. whereas throughout the Union only about 40% of workers are employed in the services sector, com-
pared with over 54% in the US, a difference which accounts for more than 36 million jobs andwhereas, therefore, the employment potential of this sector in the EU has still not been exhausted,
G. whereas over the last decade the implicit rate of tax on labour has risen by about six percentage
points to its current level of 43% and whereas, therefore, measures to reduce the tax burden onlabour, without jeopardising the financial stability of State social security schemes, are one of themost pressing tasks of the Member States,
H. whereas modernisation of the way in which work is organised, combined with an effective reduction
in working time, can help increase productivity, competitiveness and hence the growth in employ-
ment, and also improve living and working conditions; whereas, therefore, the partnership approach
to modernising the way in which work is organised should be further developed, particularly with theaid of a thorough analysis of the various experiments in the reduction of working time which areunder way,
I. whereas additional and better targeted initiatives need to be undertaken which are aimed at enabling
disabled people to find and retain a job on the open labour market including giving special priority tohealth and safety policies aimed at preventing the occurrence of occupational accidents and diseases,
J. whereas the strategy of gender mainstreaming was endorsed by the Beijing Platform for Action, which
called on governments and other actors to promote an active and visible policy of mainstreaming agender perspective in all policies and programmes,
K. whereas Member States’ commitments to equal opportunities between women and men, and to gender
mainstreaming, have not been translated into practice in a satisfactory way, and, therefore, unaccep-table barriers of a fiscal, educational, cultural and social nature remain, hindering the access of womento the labour market and their progression within it,
L. whereas there is a need to pay particular attention to the quality of employment, as far as stability and
security are concerned, and therefore both quantitative and qualitative criteria must be developed atnational and European level,
M. whereas it should be remembered that European labour markets are different from each other and that
specific guidelines may be more or less relevant for the individual Member States,
N. whereas in its draft of the Joint Employment Report the Commission records some progress but also
numerous shortcomings in respect of implementing the employment policy guidelines at nationallevel,
Conclusions on the implementation of the Luxembourg process
1. Calls on the Commission and the Council to improve the relationship between the broad economic
guidelines and the employment guidelines with regard to their content, their timing (by discussing andadopting them simultaneously), and the relationship between the Council committees involved;
2. Expects the Commission and Council to submit their proposals on the employment guidelines at a
time agreed with Parliament;
3. Believes it would be very useful for Parliament to participate in developing the employment policy
guidelines and, jointly with the Commission, monitor implementation of the European employment initia-tives in the Member States;C 158/44 EN 7.6.2000 Official Journal of the European Communities
Thursday 4 November 1999
4. Acknowledges that evaluating the employment policy guidelines calls for a substantial administrative
input, but considers that the annual monitoring cycle should be retained in order to ensure that MemberStates are unremitting in their efforts to promote employment;
5. Calls on the Council to adopt, unamended, the Commission’s draft recommendations on implemen-
tation of Member States’ employment policies, and calls on the Member States to take these recommenda-tions into account, as a matter of priority, in their National Action Plans;
Conclusions on coordination between employment and economic policy
6. Underlines the fact that the implementation of Economic and Monetary Union is a powerful tool for
increasing the performance of the economy and creating a good climate for new jobs;
7. Believes a substantial improvement in the ability of the policy areas to engage in a dialogue is essen-
tial and expects better coordination between the actors at both national and European level in the fields ofemployment and social policy, economic policy and finance, environment and structural policy;
8. Expects full recognition and closer involvement of the European Parliament within the existing insti-
tutional framework in developing and implementing the European Employment Pact, and its full involve-ment in macroeconomic dialogue Ndash if appropriate, also by means of an Interinstitutional Agreement;
Conclusions on active measures to create jobs
9. Points out that there are clear distinctions between direct and indirect measures by Member States to
promote the labour market; expects Member States to pursue their employment policies in a morebalanced manner;
10. Supports the call made by its Committee on Employment and Social Affairs for financial aid for
regional and local employment initiatives;
11. Considers that the financial and/or fiscal aid granted to enterprises should be monitored better to
ensure that it genuinely helps to create jobs rather than assisting restructuring and relocation accompaniedby redundancies; considers that such monitoring, in which representatives of the two sides of industry
should be involved, must be regular and public;
Conclusions on the Guidelines
12. Points out that measures to satisfy the employment policy guidelines must benefit everyone, includ-
ing special target groups;
13. Calls on the Member States to involve the two sides of industry more closely in the process of
implementing the employment policy guidelines;
14. Strongly supports the proposal for a new guideline on communication and information technology,
and points out that this is a clear example, in view of its implementation, of the need to boost public andprivate investment in a more pro-active way;
15. Takes the view that the concept of lifelong learning needs to be strengthened in the employment
guidelines, and calls on the Commission to devise verifiable minimum targets for participation by thelabour force of the different age groups of both sexes in further training;
16. Requests the Member States to gear their training systems more closely to the requirements of the
labour market; in particular, initial and further training should be targeted more closely at the service
sector, which has high growth potential;
17. Calls on the Commission and the Member States to develop feasible alternatives to taxation on
labour, as already suggested in the White Paper on Growth, Competitiveness and Employment and in theMonti working party on taxation;7.6.2000 EN C 158/45 Official Journal of the European Communities
Thursday 4 November 1999
Conclusions on the employment strategy and social protection
18. Believes that the link between employment, quality of job creation and social protection must be
strengthened in the framework of the Luxembourg strategy;
19. Calls for common minimum social standards not only with regard to terms of employment but also
in various other areas of employment and social legislation, e.g. right to give notice, integrating the dis-abled into the world of work and the right of workers to be consulted on matters concerning their enter-prises;
20. Considers that minimum information standards include information about the development of pen-
sion entitlements;
21. Calls on the Member States, if the retirement age is raised by an amendment to the social security
legislation applicable to unemployed workers, to ensure that the latter enjoy precedence in employmentprogrammes, so that they do not remain deprived of both employment and pensions;
Conclusions on equality of opportunity and mainstreaming
22. Calls upon the Council and the Member States to enhance national capacities and strengthen legal
and institutional frameworks for mainstreaming gender into employment policies;
23. Calls upon the Council and the Member States to set targets Ndash based upon the average of the three
most successful Member States in this respect Ndash that measure the inclusion of women in training pro-grammes;
24. Calls upon the Council and the Member States to develop a set of benchmarks and criteria for the
implementation and evaluation of gender mainstreaming in national employment policies;
25. Calls upon the Council and the Member States to create benefit incentives that encourage female
participation, by extending availability of parental and child care benefits, and taking child care costs intoaccount in means testing of benefits to low income families;
Conclusions on evaluation
26. Regards the introduction of specific quantifiable targets, including at EU level, based on bench-
marks, as a distinct improvement to the employment policy guidelines; therefore expects more Commun-ity-wide targets to be set on the basis of the existing guidelines;
27. Expects the Commission and the Member States to formulate the targets in such a way as to permit
evaluation;
28. Repeats its call, in view of the proposals submitted by the Commission, for comparability of
national statistics in order to facilitate uniform appraisal and appropriate monitoring of application ofthe employment policy guidelines;
29. Calls on the Commission and the Member States to make their statistical systems relating to
employment factors comparable by the start of the year 2000, in order to enable implementation of theemployment guidelines to be uniformly evaluated and properly monitored;
*
**
30. Instructs its President to forward this resolution to the Commission, the Council, the Economic and
Social Committee, the Committee of the Regions and the two sides of industry at European level.C 158/46 EN 7.6.2000 Official Journal of the European Communities
Thursday 4 November 1999