"éSfPfa» 
COMMISSION OF THE EUROPEAN COMMUNITIES 
Brussels, 28.01.1998 
COM(1998) 32 final 
COMMUNICATION FROM THE COMMISSION 
TO THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT. THE COUNCIL 
AND THE ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL COMMITTEE 
ON FOOD, VETERINARY AND PLANT 
HEALTH CONTROL AND INSPECTION 

1. INTRODUCTION 
This Communication indicates the progress made to date with the action outlined in 
the Commission's Communication on Consumer Health and Food Safety (COM 
(97) 183 final) of 30 March 1997. It also describes the future action that will be 
taken in the light of the recommendations made in the report of its Inspection 
General Services (IGS) on "A study of the food safety control bodies" on 13 
October 1997 (referred to simply as the "IGS report" throughout this 
Communication). 
The Commission reiterates its whole-hearted commitment to the maintenance of 
acceptable food safety standards, and the protection of consumer health. It is 
strongly of the view that consumer health protection can best be achieved through 
an effective, working partnership between the food industry, the official control 
services at national level and the Commission itself, within the framework of an 
effective legislation. Each group must accept its responsibilities to ensure that food 
safety is given the highest priority, and to act in a transparent manner to provide 
consumers with the highest level of confidence. 
The food industry, at all stages of the production chain, needs to develop effective 
monitoring and self-policing systems to ensure that food is produced in compliance 
with EU food safety legislative requirements. Member States, by developing co­
ordinated control programmes covering the whole of the food production chain, and 
the introduction of audit-based control systems to monitor the situation in individual 
premises, will be able to discharge their fundamental responsibility for consumer 
health protection at the national level. The role of the Commission is essentially to 
"control the controls", for which the Member State authorities retain the central 
responsibility. The Commission will concentrate on controlling the manner in which 
Community legislation is being applied in practice by national authorities through 
the use of audit techniques designed to monitor the performance of the competent 
authorities throughout the food production chain. Nonetheless, it must be recognized 
that the application of the full range of these controls by the Commission will 
always be challenging. 
Bearing in mind the above comments, the Commission endorses the 
recommendations made in Chapter V of the first part of the IGS report. It considers 
that the report, which supports, and expands upon, the actions already taken by the 
Commission in recent months, forms a sound basis for further development of its 
control and inspection services. 
2. THE STRUCTURE OF THE COMMISSION'S FOOD, VETERINARY AND PHYTOSANITARY 
CONTROL SERVICES 
2.1 Commission Office or Agency? 
The proposal (COM (96) 223 final) for the establishment of a Veterinary Inspection 
Agency has been withdrawn by the Commission. Neither the final report of the 
European Parliament's temporary BSE follow-up committee, nor the Economic and 
Social Committee, nor the IGS report, considered that any additional advantage 
would be gained from the establishment of an independent Agency. 
z 
The IGS report noted that food safety control services must enjoy an adequate 
degree of independence if they are to offer an acceptable level of impartiality and 
objectivity in their findings. It also noted that these goals were best achieved 
through the establishment of a clearly defined legal and official status for the control 
services, covering their mission, the functions and responsibilities of personnel, the 
procedures, the working techniques etc. 
By retaining the Commission's food safety control responsibilities within its own 
services, the necessary distance can be maintained between these services and the 
national authorities who will be the subject of its control activities (a situation that 
can be better achieved by an Office than by an Agency). Furthermore, the 
Commission is accountable to the other Community institutions and to consumers, 
whilst avoiding the risks of isolation from the decision making process that might 
follow from the establishment of an Agency. The development of the management 
and operational changes outlined in the earlier Communication, and further 
developed here, will ensure that the services act in a transparent, and independent, 
manner. 
The Commission has therefore come to the conclusion that control and inspection 
responsibilities will continue to be undertaken by the Food and Veterinary Office 
(FVO), under the overall responsibility of the Commission. 
2.2 Commission initiatives 
The two Decisions which are to be adopted by the Commission before the end of 
January lay down rules on the performance of veterinary on-the-spot checks in both 
Member States and third countries. These provide a public commitment by the 
Commission and Member States to accelerate the processing of mission findings, 
and to ensure that these findings, and recommendations for action following from 
them, are made rapidly available both to the European Parliament and to the general 
public. 
If it is found to be necessary, the Commission will prepare guidelines, based on best 
practices, to assist Member States in developing co-ordinated control programmes 
covering the whole of the food production chain, and the introduction of audit-based 
control systems, 
Furthermore, the need for additional controls at Member State level in respect of 
food safety standards for non-animal origin foodstuffs, eg. fruits and vegetables, will 
be examined by the Commission in order to assess whether further action is needed 
at national or Community level. 
2.3 Transparency of operation 
Transparency can best be guaranteed by ensuring that the FVO works in a manner 
which respects published operational standards, and which is open to outside 
scrutiny. Based upon the recommendations of the IGS report, a Manual of 
Procedures, covering all aspects of the FVO's activities, is being developed. This 
will be supported by the development of effective internal management controls to 
monitor the implementation of the Manual's requirements. 
3 
Article 214 of the Treaty of the European Community lays down certain principles 
that must be respected in terms of the release of information, on individual 
undertakings, but, within these confines, the FVO will make every effort to ensure 
that its findings are freely available. An internet site for the FVO, which can be 
accessed via the DG XXIV home page through the Europa server, is being 
established. 
The FVO will publish an annual report of its activities for general distribution. A 
copy of the report will be placed on the internet, and widely circulated. 
Discussions with consumer and producer associations will be organised regularly to 
discuss the outcome of the inspection programmes. 
3. THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE FOOD AND VETERINARY OFFICE 
3.1 Human resources 
The IGS report (SEC (97) 482/3) of 11 March 1997, recommended that the 
Commission's control services required a total of 202 posts, including 127 A grade 
posts, to meet their commitments. The Commission has accepted this 
recommendation and will progressively make these posts available such that the 
FVO can take on board the full range of its responsibilities. In addition to the efforts 
made to redeploy staff within the Commission, the role of the Budgetary Authority 
in providing 35 posts, and credits for 12 auxiliaries, in the BRS 1997 is 
acknowledged. 
3.2 Working procedures 
The action outlined in the earlier Commission communication (COM(97) 183 final), 
regarding the standardisation of working procedures and the development of mission 
prioritisation system is being developed. Once this work has been completed, it will 
form the basis of the FVO's standard working practices, and be incorporated into the 
proposed Manual of Procedures. 
3.3 Control over the whole food production chain 
This approach was widely supported in the countries visited by the IGS team during 
its inquiry. It will involve the development of small, multi-disciplinary, inspection 
teams to respond to the priorities identified under the mission programme. Each 
team will be staffed to allow it to cover all elements of the chosen sector, from 
animal feed processors, through health and welfare standards on farms, markets and 
during transport, to the processing, storage and distribution of the foods concerned. 
It is also proposed to develop a small number of emergency teams, specially trained 
in epidemiological and investigation techniques, whose main function will be to 
respond immediately to food, public health, animal health and plant health crises 
both in Member States and third countries. 
In undertaking these controls, the protection of food safety is the central element. 
However, where there is a direct link between food safety and food quality 
standards, the controls may include the latter element. 
v 
3.4 Audit and inspection procedures 
For the sake of efficiency, transparency and in application of the principle of 
subsidiarity, the FVO will, as far as possible, perform its control duties by means of 
audits of the bodies responsible for consumer health protection in both Member 
States and certain third countries (those where agreements between the European 
Community and the third country concerned on sanitary measures applicable to 
trade have entered into force). 
Audit visits will routinely include inspections at individual processing premises to 
allow an assessment to be made of the performance of the competent authority, 
individual inspectors and control systems. They will also include checks to ensure 
that the operational records presented to the FVO inspectors fully reflect the reality 
of the situation ("reality checks"). 
In third countries for which no agreements between the European Community and 
the third country concerned on sanitary measures applicable to trade have entered 
into force, the FVO will assess the ability of the official control authorities to ensure 
the respect of the standards laid down in Community legislation, including visits to 
individual farms, markets, processing establishments etc to assess compliance on-
the-spot with the relevant legislation by producers, transporters and processors. 
When inspections are carried out in third countries, the relevant provisions of the 
WTO-Agreement on the Application of Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures, and in 
particular Article 8 and Annex C thereof, shall be respected. 
3.5. Internal controls 
The IGS report recommended that the FVO should take account of the principles 
outlined in EN 45004 (General criteria for the operation of various types of bodies 
performing inspection). In light of this, and as part of its commitment to the 
transparency of its internal, management system, an internal Quality Team will be 
established within the FVO. Particular attention will be paid to ensure that the 
Quality Team enjoys a status that is independent of the Office's internal 
management structure, as is required for such structures under EN 45004. 
The changes to operational and management procedures, and the expansion of the 
Office, has meant that a structured staff training programme is being implemented. 
3.6. Co-operation 
The FVO will work closely with other bodies involved in the monitoring of 
compliance with Community legislation in Member States and third countries, and 
internationally. It will seek to develop improved co-operation procedures with 
interested parties to ensure the most effective use of its resources in the performance 
of its control and inspection duties. 
<) 

ISSN 0254-1475 
COM(98) 32 final 
DOCUMENTS 
EN 03 05 15 
Catalogue number : CB-CO-98-049-EN-C 
ISBN 92-78-30710-6 
Office for Official Publications of the European Communities 
L-2985 Luxembourg 
G