COMMISSION OF THE EUROPEAN COMMUNITIES 
Brussels, 27.01.1998 
COM(1998) 31 final 
Commission Working document 
RESEARCH AND STANDARDIZATION 
Greater consideration of the 
prenormative dimension 
in Community research programmes 
in order to foster 
the sustainable growth, competitiveness and interoperability 
of products and services to emerge from research 

CONTENTS. 
1. Introduction 
2. The need for standards 
2.1 Economic and social usefulness 
2.2 International trade 
2.3 Economic impact of standards 
3. Situation of prenormative research in the Commission's specific programmes 
3.1 Information technologies and communications 
3.2 Industrial technologies and materials 
3.3 Standards, measurements and tests 
3.4 Agriculture and fisheries 
3.5 Biotechnology 
3.6 Environment and climate 
3.7 Prenormative activities of the J.R.C 
4. Increasing the effectiveness of Community prenormative research 
4.1 Coordination between the specific programmes of the 4th R&D framework 
programme 
4.2 Research specifically geared to standards 
4.3 Prenormative research and the environment 
4.4 Prenormative research and intellectnal property rights 
4.5 Prenonnative research and innovation 
4.6 Transfer ofresults to standards bodies 
4.7 International dimension of prenonnative research 
4.8 Dedicated calls for proposals of the specific SMT programme 
4.9 "Key actions" of the 5th Research and Development Framework Programme 
5. Conclusions 
1. INTRODUCTION 
Being one of the tools of quality12,3 in the same way as measurements, testing, management 
techniques and quality assurance, standards are in a strategic position to promote the 
competitiveness and interoperability of products and services4. 
Standards thus provide a bridge between the technical domain and the regulatory and 
economic framework. 
The development of new standards and their implementation depend on preliminary research. Their 
bridge function should thus be taken into account in the selection, direction and content of research 
projects. 
This bridge function is a two-way affair: one the one hand, prenormative research5 promotes the 
development of new standards while, on the other hand, the standards create the conditions for 
better dissemination of the results of the research. In both cases a specific strategy is needed to 
make the results usable by the standards bodies. 
2. THE NEED FOR STANDARDS 
2.1 Economic and social usefulness 
The advantages of standards have led to them being adopted in many industrial areas. Standards are 
indispensable tools in providing commerce with a platform for good working practices. They are 
also the tool of choice for protecting consumers and the health, safety and environment of citizens. 
They make for economies of scale and facilitate the interoperability of products and services. 
General safety of products 
The framework Directive 92/59/EEC leaves it to the European standards to 
define the technical specifications applicable to the products in question. The 
establishment of these specifications and the implementation of the standards 
require prior research in numerous fields: ergonomics, construction, 
engineering, toxicology, biomechanics, etc. 
Quality is now recognized as being a strategic instrument/wr excellence. As such, it has become one of the key 
factors in the competitiveness of companies and thus their capacity to innovate. Quality and innovation are 
inseparable. Quality is also a guarantee of the competitiveness of services closely connected the health, safety 
and environment of European citizens. 
European quality promotion policy for improving European competitiveness (SEC (96) 2000). 
Benchmarking the competitiveness of European industry (COM (96) 463 final, 9 October 1996). 
Services: In this document this term covers all technical services: public or private services with the exception 
of services in banking, insurance, distribution, education and training. 
Prenormative research: All R&D activities including demonstration projects needed to establish a standard plus 
the activities required for proper implementation. 
Green Paper on Innovation (COM (95) 688 final, 20/12/95). 
Although it is very difficult to quantify their economic impact, the significance of standards for industry 
and services is undeniable. For example: 
• the use of standardized techniques allows manufacturers to save time and money in developing their 
own techniques; 
• standardization offers a choice of many equally valid solutions which often exist side-by-side and, as a 
result, it facilitates the design and production of equipment; 
• the fact that products and components available on the market are consistent with standards gives 
potential customers exact knowledge of their technical characteristics, thereby enabling them to make 
the right choice in terms of quality and price; 
• standardized specifications for appliances or components facilitate "'interoperability". i.e. they allow 
consumers to use appliances and equipment from different sources. 
In Europe standards have mainly been developed by the CEN, CENELEC and ETSI1 l'.sing different 
approaches: 
• First and foremost, standards developed at the request of industry in order to establish a coherent 
market and to define rules and a common framework conducive to trade. These standards enable 
manufacturers to establish universally-recognized specifications for design. performance. composition. 
tolerances and other characteristics. 
Rational use ofenersv in buildinss 
Between 1986 and 1993 twelve national buildings rcsearch centres 
joined forces in a JOULE project (non-nuclear energy) to dewlop 
a series of test cells for innovative building components (e.g. 
super-insulating or smart glazing) and a reliable and rapid 
procedure ofmeasuring the optical and thermal properties of these 
components. 
The consortiuin cooperated actively throughout the entire period 
with the CEN's Technical Committee 89 in order to establish 
standards on the thermal performances of buildings and 
components. The cells are currently operational and managed by 
an EEIG. 
JOULE! Joint Opportumties for Unconventional or Long-term Energy Supp'iy 
EEIG European Economic Jnterest Groupmg 
Secondly, standards mandated by the Commission which have been developed to implement new 
approach European Directives2. 
CEN European Committee for Standardization 
CENELEC European Committee for Electrotechnical Standardization 
ETSI European Telecommunications Standards Institute 
Council Resolution: "New approach to technical harmonization and standardization" (O.l No L 1 "i< 4.6.1985). 
These standards, which are principally performance standards1, enable manufacturers to demonstrate 
that their products are consistent with the essential requirements set out in the directives. Many of 
them have needed prior research or post-research work to solve implementing problems. Numerous 
examples illustrate these activities throughout this document. 
Food packasins 
In 1992 some 28 million tonnes ofplastics were used in the EC as packaging for foodstuffs 
which hadto complywith the provisions ofDirective 89/109/EEC, namely: 
a) not to containinatefoodstuffs through any transfer ofconstituents; 
b) not to cause unacceptable changes to the composition of the foodstuffs; and 
c) not to rob the foodstuffs of their organoleptic properties. 
The CEN is currently working on the standardization of 33 analytical methods of 
quantifying the level of contaminants. These methods are being developed as part of a 
research project in the Standards, Measurements and Testing Programme and are 
supported via the preparation of certified reference materials. 
Thirdly, ISO/EN 9000 and EN 45000 standards to define the organization of quality and systems of 
laboratory accreditation. These standards have made for procedures to evaluate the conformity of 
products and services which are mutually recognized by the Member States. A similar approach was 
adopted for the standard ISO 14001 which implements an environmental impact assessment procedure 
for industrial activities and services. 
ISO 9000 standards were first published in 1987. They have since become widely 
recognized by the industry and the services sector and have been adopted by almost all 
the members of the International Standards Organization (ISO). 
A survey run by Mobile Europe Ltd showed that at the end of 1995 more than 127 000 
certificates had been issued throughout the world and that the number was growing 
constantly. 
ISO 9000 certification is often required for major public works contracts and many of 
the big manufacturing industries have introduced quality systems which are applicable 
to all their suppliers. At present this certification of such systems is not limited solely 
to big companies, it also includes small and medium-sized enterprises and is rapidly 
being extended to the services sector. 
Another survey run by the Manchester Business School in 1995 showed that ISO 9000-
certified companies had a higher turnover than the national average and a four times 
better chance of surviving the current economic recession. 
Finally, standards connected to the development of high-technology sectors [information society 
(including satellites2) or biotechnology]. These standards are very important to the competitiveness of 
industry and services in that they give preference to the European approach at world level. 
Standards which establish the general framework of a system arc called performance standards as 
opposed to product standards which dcscribe in detail a product or a proccss. The flexibility of the 
standards allows industry to producc compctitive products and services at world levcl while fostering an 
innovative approach in continually evolving areas and inspiring confidence in users and consumcrs. 
Preparatory document on "EU action plan : satellite communications in the Information Society" (COM(97) 91 
final, 5/3/1997). 
Mobile communications 
In 1993 the value of output in the EC in telecommunications equipment was 
ECU1S 425m, 16% more than in the USA and 53% more than in Japan. This 
reflects the development of standards such as ISDN (Integrated Services Digital 
Network), GSM (Global System for Mobile Communications) and DECT (Digital 
European Cordless Telecommunications), allo/European origin. 
RACE and its suecessor, ACTS, are currently working on the development of 
standards for the Universal Mobile Telecommunications System (VMTS). These 
should integrate domestic and prqfessional services whereby individual pieces of 
equipment will be capable ofproviding multimedia mobile services. 
RACE Research in Advanced Communications in Europe 
ACTS Advanced Communications Technologies and Services 
2.2 IpternatiQnal frade 
The establishment of the big internal market in Europe, the ratification of agreements from the 
Uruguay Round and the existence of the World Trade Organization (WTO) are accelerating the 
removal of technical barriers to trade (TBT),1 in particular by way of the code of good practice. 
The Community has thus set two fundamental objectives: 
• firstly, to reduce or prevent the establishment of protectionist standards or technical barriers on 
markets outside the Union; 
• secondly, to promote the development and adoption of standards and regulatory approaches 
among its partners which are compatible with or even based on European practices. 
These concerns of the Community are coming increasingly to the forefront, for example, in the 
transatlantic dialogue within the Transatlantic Advisory Committee on Standards, Certification and 
Regulatory Policy (TACS). 
EXTRACT FROM THE TACS REPORT OF JUNE1996 
The establishment ofa transatlantic market needs the adoption ofa multiple strategy, 
including, in addition to the mutual recognition of agreements, greater use of 
international standards, the elimination of certification procedures and double 
verification, the development and use of common industrial standards, the use of 
functional standards in regulations and directives and greater transparency, 
participation and cooperation in theprocess ofdrafting standards. 
To sum up, theprinciple to be adopted should be "once verified accepted by all". 
Community external trade policy in the field of standards and conformity assessment (COM (96) 564 final). 
International standards make for economies of scale not only for nultinational coinpanies but also for 
SMEs which export or supply parts incorporated in units for export. 
In short, standards reduce barriers to trade and assist the development of markets in the 
economic areas where they are applied. 
2.3 Economic impact of standards 
The first figure shows the importance that European organizations attach to international 
standardization.1 This is reflected by the number of secretariats within the ISO. 
The other three figures show the progression in the annual production of standards by the three 
European standards organizations to meet the needs of industry. 
CEN - Annual prod. of standards Secretariat of international technical groups 
by region (end of 1994) 
Tapan 
Europe \ ^\^ 
64% \ Others 
7% 
North 
/ America 
J 26% 800 
700 
600 
500 
400 
300 
200 
100 
0 
CENELEC - Annual prod. of standards ETSI-Annual prod.of standards 
mm m m 
The economic impact of adopting a standard can be illustrated by numerous examples, one of them 
being the mobile telephones now seen everywhere (see box on previous page). 
In a similar area connected with data transmission Japan has also had success with the vehicle 
guidance system. Since the display panels have been standardized some 400 000 vehicles have been 
fitted with the system. 
The ISO secretariat conducted a study using the PERINORM database (produced by AFNOR, DIN 
and BSI) on the significance of normative work in certain technical areas.2 This study compares the 
number of standards produced between 1965 and 1994 in a given economic sector and the import and 
export volume in US dollars. The results, as presented in the following examples, suggest that in some 
sectors the normative effort is limited, in particular in the construction industry. 
1 Report on the progress of European standardization (SEC (95) 2104). 
2 R. Weissinger: ISO standards and international markets; a preliminary analysis of their correlative development. 
May 1995, ISO, Geneva. 
In contrast, in the services sector such as health and medicine where significant normative work would 
not normally be expected the effort is proportional to or greater than the increase in trade. 
Ui g 
« .2 
13 
Z Construction Health and Safety 
3000 l:.:.:.:v:::::.:.:.:v:.:::-^ 
32 
UJ g 
E = 
z 
co ^- ^ r^ 
ISO 
BPORT/I^PCRT 
Packaging and Distribution Mechanical Engineering. 
3000 
E« 
EE 3000 T 
In Europe the 25 000 standards (adopted or in preparation - i.e. five new standards per working day) from 
the CEN, CENELEC and ETSI are a clear sign of harmonization and economic integration. 
This effort also has an effect on harmonization at world level, given the agreements concluded by the 
European standards bodies with the ISO. The final two graphs show the degree of transposition between 
ISO/CEN and ISO/CENELEC. 
CEN CENELEC 
In conclusion, it can be said that the European strategy consists of combating protectionist standards 
and promoting the adoption of international rules and standards, thereby providing European 
manufacturers with access to the world market without barriers. The production of new, specific 
standards requires prior research which the Community must support. 
3. SITUATION OF PRENORMATIVE RESEARCH IN THE COMMISSION'S SPECIFIC 
PROGRAMMES 
One of the principal objectives of these specific programmes is to strengthen the scientific and 
technological bases of European industry, as enshrined in the Treaty on European Union. 
The first area of activity of the 4th Research and Development Framework Programme (1994-98) 
comprises 15 specific programmes. All the specific programmes refer to prenormative research. That 
said, the way in which this research is carried out and the importance actually attached to it vary 
considerably from one programme to another. 
3.1 Information technologies and communications 
This specific programme fully integrates prenonnative research in its strategy, thus making for 
complete interoperability of products and services. A series of consultation and exchange mechanisms 
witli the European standards bodies (CEN. CENELEC, ETSI) have been set up. 
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGIES AND COMMUNICATIONS 
Advanced Informatics in Medicine (AIM) 
By setting up technical committees and working parties with the CEN and EJVOS, AIM has 
prepared a work programme and initiated the development of specifications for a broadfield 
ofactivities relating to the establishment, protection and exchange ofpatents. 
Technology Initiative for the Disabled andElderly (TIDE) 
Preliminary studies have been undertaken to develop TIDE and these have led to mandates 
for the ETSI, CEN and CENELEC and concerted action projects as part of the COST 
organization. 
Advanced Transport Telematics (ATT/DRIl/EII) 
Ten working parties have been set up to identify the subjects relating to this programme and 
these working parties have prepared the requisite documents for the technical committees of 
CEN and CENELEC 
ESPRIT 
The scientific managers responsible for this specific programme are asked 
to identify the possible links between existing projects and standards in 
order to improve the utilization of resulis or the development of ne>v 
technologies. Studies are therefore undertaken under the "Accompanying 
measures" section which could lead to the defmition of new priorities for 
research, changes in activities for the standards organizations or, via the 
technological coordination groups consisting of representatives from the 
Member States, the issue of new standardization remits. In the STEP 
(Standard for the Exchange and Representation of Product Model Data) 
and CNMA (Communications Network for Manufacturing Applications) 
programmes these activities apply to both research and demonstration 
projects. 
3.2 Industrial materials and technologies 
The specific BRITE-EURAM III programme covers broad technological and industrial sectors. It 
does not specifically finance prenormative projects, but it includes prenormative aspects in the criteria 
for evaluating projects for selection (optimization and dissemination). During the research phase the 
Commission's scientific follow-up calls for a check of the possible impact of the work in progress, 
either on the creation of new standards or on the use and development of existing ones. All in all, 
some 26% of the projects financed are of great to very great benefit to the standards needed by 
industry, a quarter of them accounting for the specific programme's success stories. 
•~i 
BRITE-EURAM III: Technical inspection ofaircraft 
In 1992 the cost of servicing the undercarriages ofthe European fleet exceeded ECU15 000m, 
Thisfigure will probably be over ECU 24 000m in theyear 2000. 
The standardized inspection procedures (for big as well as small aircraft) recently developed 
under the BRITEprogramme will minimize human error and maximize reliability. At the same 
time they will make for more efficient use of resources and, consequently, more profiiable 
operating ofthe air fleet. As inspection is a keypart ofthe cost of servicing aircraft andthus an 
important aspect on purchase, thefact ofhaving a standardized and more competitive systemfor 
European aircraft should lead airlines to purchase entirely European fleets. 
BRITE-EURAM III: Manufacture ofcar seats 
The aim of the project initially was to reduce the design and 
development time of seats using a concurrent engineering method. The 
specifications for seats developed in this project now form the basis for 
standards used for the comfort and safety of passengers. The success of 
this new process is such that it is already being used by Lear 
Corporation to the benefit of several car manufacturers. 
3.3 Standards, Measurements and Testing 
The specific "Standards, Measurements and Testing" (SMT) programme is the only one designed to 
develop tools to support the Commission's quality promotion policy. Being horizontal in nature, it is 
involved in all physical, chemical and biological sectors where measurement and test methods need to 
be developed. It promotes activities linked to prenormative research and has also helped to improve 
standards in various important areas and, as such, the smooth operating ofthe internal market, e.g. in 
the control of raw materials (break resistance of metals), the characterization of manufactured 
products (sound insulation of windows) and better quality of services (control of the microbiological 
quality of bathing water). This programme is also responsible for research into and production of 
Certified Reference Materials (CRMs). The aim of developing numerous CRMs is to guarantee the 
implementation of standards and directives (see box). 
10 
SMTJ CettiteàR*ferenùeM<*e*m (CRMs) 
Ihe Standards, Measurements and Testing programmer m conjunction with the JRC> has 
dëvetaped ctose to 400 CRMs in the sectors ofthe environment, health and safety at work, agri~ 
fiHtfMffi, mkwbiafygy* ttomtdtefae, properfiefùftmtria& ete, Mwe thm 90 àthet ÇMMs are 
cttrrentïyBewgprepareÂ 
These CRMs, i&ongwith tkose produced by the JRC m tkenuctear $ectar> are sold/distiiouied By 
thelRClRMMaskeyetementsfor: 
thecomparabtiuy ofthe results oftaboratory measurements; 
th» appUcatwn4>fnumetvusstandards; 
the imptmenta&ttn àfÇùmmtmty îmvm health mdmvirmmentalprûtêction; 
the mutuat recognuwn af results and the applxcaûon of quality assurance and laboratory 
açûTtditaÛûn systems. 
SMT: Oualitv of bathing water 
The microbiological quality of water is the 
most important parameter taken into account 
by the EC Directive on Bathing Water to 
determine the quality of bathing zones 
throughout Europe. A prqject launched by the 
specific SMT programme in 1992 has 
improved the methods of measuring the 
microbiological quality of water and made 
recommendations in conjunction with DGXI 
to improve the comparability of measurements. 
The results of the prqject will be used to 
develop a European standard on the 
performance of methods of measuring the 
microbiological quality of water. SMT: Fire safety of upholstered seats 
Fires in homes involving upholstered seats such 
as settees are particularly dangerous and cause 
numerous deaths every year. At the request of 
DGIII (industry) the specific SMT programme 
began a prqject in 1993 designed to develop test 
methods for measuring the fire performance of 
upholstered seats. The prqject was successfully 
terminated at the end of 1995, and DGIII 
believes that the results will help to develop 
European standards on the fire performance of 
upholstered seats, thereby helping to improve 
the safety of consumers in Europe. 
The specific SMT programme aecepts prenormative research projects in its annual calls for proposals. 
For the 4th FWP it has also developed a svstem of dedicated calls for proposals. This will help to 
meet the R&D needs required to implement European regulations and directives as well as to develop 
standards. The subjects to aid standardization are selected in conjunction with the standards bodies 
(CEN, CENELEC and ETSI). To this end, the CEN has set up a consultation structure of its 
technical committees (CEN-STAR) which will enable it to make an inventory and draw up a list of 
priority RTD subjects. 
n 
CEN-STAR 
The CEN/BT WG 70 t(STAndardization andResearch (STAR)" was set up in 1992 in order to: 
• prepare guidelines to develop a more efficient link between cooperative R&D and European 
standardization, the ultimate aim being to improve the speed and quality of the standardization 
process; 
• promote these guidelines by participating in thepreliminary consultations of R&D programmes. 
The CEN-STAR committee is made up ofthe chairman of the sectoral committees ofthe CEN and of 
theplanning committees, assisted by the secretariats ofEFTA, EUREKA, EUROLAB and Commission 
representatives (DGs III and XII, JRC) and any otherparties involved in standardization. 
Dedicated call: Sample of subjects proposed by the CEN and the General Directorates 
ofthe Commission for the dedicated call of 27.11.1997: 
Test method to determine the action of disinfectants on organic materials in contact with 
drinkingwater. 
Bite test for cltildren 'sproducts, in particular toys. 
Fatigue crack growth rate qualifying criteria ofrails for railways : test conditions to be 
optimised 
Assessment ofexotic quarantine pest risk to the European Union plant health : analytical 
methods 
3.4 Agriculture and fisheries 
A certain number of prenormative activities can be found in the specific "Agriculture and Fisheries" 
programme. These cover in particular the areas of foodstuffs, use of agricultural products for non-
food purposes, and determination of acceptable levels of impurities in food. 
Tlie increase in the number of standards for analytical methods clearly illustrates a need and can be 
taken as a sign of progress. Alternative solutions are nonetheless necessary to establish performance 
criteria in place of reference methods. 
AIR: Biodiesel - atiernative renewable fuel without risk 
Biodiesel is made up of vegetable oils and products derived therefrom, 
extracts of non-food agricultural products. It may be used as such or 
mixed with conventional diesel to provide a cleaner renewable source of 
energy. Despite thefact that in 1994 only 65 000 tonnes were produced 
the AIR demonstration project aints at establishing platfornts for the 
future exploration ofthe market. It is in this context that it also sets out 
to define physico-chemical parameters for mixtures of fuels as a 
contribution to future European standards, to runfield tests for a range 
of cars, to study the impact on the environment and to define a 
European strategyfor large-scale production instdllations. 
12 
3.5 Biotechnology 
The specific "Biotechnology" programme includes a sector on prenormative research in bio-safety to 
assist the regulation of biotechnology at European level (managed by the Directorates-General for 
Industry, Agriculture and the Environment). The regulation of biotechnology is generally considered 
to be one of the most important factors for the competitiveness of the biotechnology industry in Europe 
in the spirit of the precautionary principle. 
Biotechnoloev 
Prenormative research also involves the development of new in vitro 
approaches in pharmacotoxicoloev which avoid animal experiments. 
This research is carried out in conjunction with the European centres for 
the validation of new methods (ECVAM: European Centres for the 
Validation of Alternative Methods) of the JRC in Ispra and the in vitro 
testing industrial platform (IVTIP) with about 20 companies in the 
toxicology sector. 
3.6 Environment and climate 
The specific "Environrnent and climate" (E&C) programme sets out to foster the development of 
environmentally friendly products, technologies and services and to promote the definition of 
environmental quality criteria. Its research activities fall Vvithin the spirit of the Commission's 5th 
programme of action for the environment and sustainable development and also in a more general 
framework in connection with certain activities of the OECD (tests on chemical products). Several 
fields of activity are concemed, in particular the protection and improvement of the quality of water 
and air and the risk management of industrial activities. Prenormative research in the E&C programme 
is closely coordinated with the activities of the JRC and the specific SMT programme. 
Incineration ofhazardous waste: 
The European directive on the incineration of hazardous waste (94/67/EC) sets 
maximum emission limits for several toxic substances and, among other things, 
obliges the Member States to control the rate of emission of dioxins from 
incinerators. Three standards prepared by CEN lay down the procedures for 
sampling and measuring dioxins and a set ofnine certified reference materials is in 
the process ofbeing produced in conjunction with the specific SMT programme. 
E&C: air pualitv 
The results ofthe APHEA and PEACEprojects concerning limit values for S02, Nox 
and suspended particulates in air indicate a correlation between the level of these 
pollutants in the atmosphere oftowns and cities and respiratory and cardio-vascular 
diseases. These limits could be used to revise the values adopted by the Commission 
(Directives 80/779/EEC and 85/203/EEC) and the WHO. 
13 
3.7 Prenormative activities of the JRC 
The Commission undertakes direct R&D activities by way of its Joint Research Centre. The latter 
contributes to the activities of normative research in several fields, including advanced materials (in 
conjunction with the specific Industrial Materials and Technologies programme), structure stability 
and the environment. The JRC has opened a dialogue with the CEN-STAR to improve the utilization 
of the results of its research through standardization. 
JRC: Seismic protection 
Collapsing buildings, bridges and other structures due 
to earthquakes result in economic and human loss. 
The JRC's test laboratory ELSA is working together 
with 18 European laboratories, as part of the 
networks established by the specific mobility and 
training of researchers programme, to test buildings 
(mock-ups or full-scale models) or other constructions. 
The aim is to develop and validate improvements 
concerning "Eurocodes" (Directive on construction 
products). This installation is unique in Europe. 
4. INCREASING THE EFFECTIVENESS OF COMMUNITY PRENORMATIVE RESEARCH 
4.1 Coordination between the specific programmes of the 4th FWP 
The various specific programmes of the FWP do not have a coordinated policy where standards bodies 
are concerned. If all the normative needs required to develop a European quality promotion policy for 
products and services are to be taken into account, all the specific programmes and JRC should have 
some form of communication structure with the standard bodies and the users of standards. This 
would guarantee the harmonious and effective inclusion of the normative dimension in research 
projects. 
RECOMMENDATION 
A mechanism to improve communication and coordination between the specific research and 
innovation programmes, the JRC and the economic operators involved in standardization. 
4.2 Research specifically geared to standards 
Many prenormative research projects in Europe are never submitted for the various programmes of the 
4th FWP. This is because the parties in question do not know that these projects are eligible since 
there is not sufficient information about the various programmes. Only the specific SMT programme 
is very active in the prenormative sector. However, it does not cover all needs since it is limited to 
measurements and testing. This situation will only get worse if Community research does not give 
wholehearted support to a quality policy where standards are an essential tool. The areas of 
prenormative research eligible in the various programmes should therefore be stressed. 
14 
RECOMMENDATIONS 
Make programme participants not or barely active in tlte field of standardization aware of the 
potential ofstandards where utilization ofresults is concerned 
Make proposers aware, at the preliminary evaluation stages, ofthe importance of the normative 
dimension (especially inprojects with quality objectives) for utilization ofresults. 
4.3 Prenormative research and the environment 
According to the objectives ofthe 5th programme of action for the environment "For a sustainable 
development", prenormative research should be promoted in the field of environmental protection. 
This applies in particular to research projects on industrial materials and technologies. Concern for 
the environment involves both the scientific and technical aspects and the socio-economic impact of 
projects. 
RECOMMENDATION 
The parties and participants involved in specific programmes need to be made aware ofthe need 
to take account ofthe environmental dimension ofthe results of research projects. 
4.4 Prenormative research and intellectual property rights 
For the normative dimension to be integrated in specific R&D programmes the fact has to be taken 
on board that prenormative research is not by definition an obstacle to the protection of intellectual 
property rights. Early dialogue and cooperation between researchers and standards bodies can 
remove any problems of intellectual property. The implication of this research on the property of 
results and their dissemination needs to be spelt out during the negotiation of research contracts and 
agreements between partners. Conflicts rarely arise for performance standards or standards 
providing a basis for the interoperability of new technologies. 
This aspect of relations between research and standardization was covered by a memorandum 
published by CEN/CENELEC in 1992 (CEN/CENELEC Memorandum No 8, 1992/03). A major 
conclusion of this memorandum was that potential conflicts are rare, given the areas and objectives 
of standards. A procedure guaranteeing copyright was drawn up. 
RECOMMENDATIONS 
Improve communication between researchers and standards bodies to fdcilitate the protection of 
intellectual property rights when the results of research are transferred to standards bodies1. 
The First Action Plan for Innovation in Europe (COM(96)589 final, 20/11/1996). 
15 
4.5 Prenormative research and innovation1 
Rather than acting as a brake, creating an environment which is conducive to innovation will promote 
performance standards and voluntary agreements, improve the juxtaposition between tlie establishment 
of standards and scientific and technical development and increase the awareness of the authors and 
users of standards, especially SMEs. 
RECOMMENDATION 
Member States are asked to encourage the adoption of voluntary standards between 
manufacturers and suppliers andto opt, wherever possible, for performance standards. 
4.6 Transfer of results to standards bodies 
The results of Community research projects (direct action by the JRC or indirect) can be optimized 
through standardization. This will depend both on the transfer of the results to the standards bodies 
(authors and users) and on the phasing of research with the various preparatory stages. 
Presentation of results and the method of transfer must be set out at the project design stage. 
Experience with the specific SMT programme has shown that researchers rarely make this 
presentation effort, either as regards the content, the form of information, the identification of CEN, 
CENELEC or ETSI committees, the inclusion of these committees in identification or the utilization of 
research results. 
To remedy these shortcomings, proponents have been asked to include, at the proposal stage 
(evaluation criterion), all the requisite information and all the means to be used. A clause has also been 
added to contracts to guarantee communication between researchers anti standards bodies. 
RECOMMENDATIONS 
Guarantee that when projects are evaluated relations with the standards bodies and an expression 
oftheir needs are recognized 
Guarantee that the conditions are included in RTD project contracts for the transfer of results to 
standards bodies. 
Guarantee that as projects unfold purely normative activities are carried out in parallel with the 
research. 
TJie JRC must guarantee transfer ofthe results ofits research to the standards bodies. 
4.7 International dimension of prenormative research 
Being a tool to improve the quality of products and services, standardization, as mentioned above, 
comes witliin the framework of world trade rather than the Community. This is especially so of 
emerging and enabling technologies. In this case it is essential for prenormative research to be part of 
a supra-Community context. There should thus be collaboration with participants from third countries 
in order to guarantee the acceptability of standards to emerge from this research. In this way, 
standardization, while taking account of the economic and socio-cultural needs of the partners, can 
make for a European approach at world level. 
The First Action Plan for Innovation in Europe (COM(96)589 final, 20/11/1996). 
16 
RECOMMENDATION 
Examine the possibility, in conjunction with the economic operators (IRDAC, CEN, CENELEC, 
ETSI, etc), of opening up prenormative projects to non-European partners to guarantee their 
adaptation and acceptance, as well as the transfer ofresults, at international level 
4.8 Dedicated calls for proposals of the specific SMT programme 
Promoters and producers are rarely enthusiastic about normative research. Furthermore, in the 
Commission's conventional mechanism for calls for proposals the rate of success is poor, and thus 
researchers are not encouraged to build projects along these lines. The pilot project for dedicated calls 
in the specific SMT programme, on the other hand, meets the specific needs of prenormative research. 
The introduction of this system of calls has required standards bodies to set up a selection process for 
their topics and priorities with every guarantee of fairness and transparency. The criteria and 
mechanisms for selecting topics are specific to each body, depending on their structures and rules of 
operation. The Commission, for its part, organizes an evaluation independent of the topic submitted 
and the technical documents that accompany them. In addition to the specific nature of the topics, this 
system could apply to the "urgencv" of problems to be tackled, with a shortening of the time span 
between the selection of the topic and the commencement of research work. 
Being entirely horizontal in function, the specific SMT programme could assist the other research 
programmes and provide a coordinating function for prenormative activities. 
RECOMMENDATIONS 
Identify prenormative research needs in the specific programmes which have been identified 
during the implementation ofthe 4th FWPand at JRC, indicating the urgency of the problems. 
Adapt selection procedures for the topics and projects ofthe dedicated calls, especially in urgent 
cases. 
4.9 Kev actions1 ofthe 5th Research and Development Framework Programme 
Since standardization is of strategic interest at the European level, prenormative research has obvious 
added value. Consequently, the results of a prenormative research project in one of the thematic 
programmes ofthe 5th FWP could be of interest to other projects or other programmes or structures. 
Similarly, other quality tools developed in the thematic programmes or at the JRC (e.g. new measuring 
instruments, new methods of measurement and control of production, results of impact studies on 
processes or products, etc.) should, together with prenormative research projects, form part of a 
coherent whole which should be coordinated. 
Optimisation of approaches and investments needs global coordination of resources and research 
projects in support of standardisation. Given the wide subject matter of standards, this coordination 
must transcend the structures of RTD programmes and integrate them in projects geared to regulations 
(directives, etc). 
l Commission working paper "Towards the Fifth Framework programme: scientific and technological objectives"', 
COM(97) 47 final, 12/02/97. 
17 
A strategy of this kind should, for example, be put in place in each thematic programme of the 5th 
FWP, backed up if needed at the level of "key actions", so as to take account of the needs of 
prenormative research. 
RECOMMENDATIONS 
A capability should be provided for in each thematic programme ofthe 5th FWP, backed up if 
needed at the level of "key actions", which ensures the monitoring of prenormative projects and 
other projects developing tools in support of quality such as : measurements, tests, management 
and quality assurance techniques...; 
Member States should be prompted to step up tlteir information activities to make the economic 
operators involved in standardisation, including SMEs, aware ofthe role played by standards in 
optimising and disseminating results. 
5. CONCLUSIONS 
The approach to and investment in community RTD need to be optimized and coordinated in order 
to promote the normative impact. The measures proposed above should be seen as priorities for 
improving prenormative research and the quality of structures and standards. Some of these 
recommendations require fairly significant changes whereas others could be put into effect quite 
quickly. 
In order of priority, these are as follows: 
- To set up a mechanism to improve communication and coordination between research and 
innovation programmes, the JRC, and the economic operators involved in standardization; 
- A capability should be provided for in each thematic programme of the 5th FWP, backed up if 
needed at the level of "key actions", which ensures the monitoring of prenormative prqjects and 
other prqjects developing tools in support of quality such as: measurements. tests, management 
and quality assurance techniques...; 
- Member States should be prompted to step up their information activities to make the economic 
operators involved in standardisation, including SMEs, aware ofthe role played by standards in 
optimising and disseminating results. 
18 
ISSN 0254-1475 
COM(98) 31 final 
DOCUMENTS 
EN 15 01 10 
Catalogue number : CB-CO-98-024-EN-C 
ISBN 92-78-30235-X 
Office for Official Publications of the European Communities 
L-2985 Luxembourg 
11