1. Approves the Commission proposal as amended;
2. Asks to be consulted again should the Commission intend to amend its proposal substantially or
replace it with another text;
3. Instructs its President to forward its position to the Council and Commission.
2. EC-Mexico association agreement *
A5-0066/2000
European Parliament legislative resolution on the proposal for a Council decision on the Commun-
ity position within the EC-Mexico Joint Council on the implementation of Articles 3, 4, 5, 6 and12
of the Interim Agreement on trade and trade-related matters (5965/1/2000 Ndash COM(2000) 9 Ndash
C5-0076/2000 Ndash 2000/0024(CNS))
(Consultation procedure)
The European Parliament,
Ddash having regard to the proposal for a Council decision (COM(2000) 9 Ddash 5965/1/2000),
Ddash having regard to Annexes I to XVI and Joint Declarations I to XV (COM(2000) 9),
Ddash having regard to Article 47(2), last sentence, Article 55 and Article 133 ofthe EC Treaty,Ddash having been consulted by the Council pursuant to Article 300(3), first subparagraph, of the EC Treaty
(C5-0076/2000),
Ddash having regard to Rules 67 and 97(7) ofits Rules ofProcedure,
Ddash having regard to the report ofthe Committee on Industry, External Trade, Research and Energy
(A5-0066/2000)
1. Approves the proposal for a Council decision;
2. Instructs its President to forward its position to the Council and the Commission and to the govern-
ments and parliaments ofthe Member States and the United Mexican States.
3. Annual legislative programme
B5-0228, 0229 and0230/2000
European Parliament resolution on the Commission’s annual legislative programme for 2000
The European Parliament,
Ddash having regard to the interinstitutional declaration on democracy, transparency and subsidiarity of
25 October 1993 by the European Parliament, the Council and Commission (1),
A. noting the Commission’s work programme, which constitutes an indispensable interinstitutional
instrument for the programming and coordination of the Union’s activities in a transparent and effi-
cient way,
B. whereas the European Parliament has powers to monitor implementation ofthe legislative programme
at certain intervals, while being closely involved in defining political priorities and in monitoring
implementation ofthe requisite measures,
(1) OJ C 329, 6.12.1993, p. 133.29.12.2000 EN C 377/323 Official Journal of the European Communities
Thursday 16 March 2000
1. Encourages the Commission to pursue its efforts to improve the legislative planning process and asks
it to include in the annual work programme, for the sake of comprehensiveness and efficiency, all the
proposals and actions proposed, the legislative proposals under way and the report on the implementation
ofthe Commission programme f or the previous year;
2. Calls on the Commission to use its right ofinitiative not only to propose new initiatives but also to
revitalise the legislative proposals pending before the Council and to keep Parliament informed of the
reason for the impasse in each case;
3. Calls on the Commission to ensure, before submission of any new proposal, that such proposals
comply with the principles ofsubsidiarity and proportionality;
4. Calls on the Commission to schedule more stringently than in the past the codification of Commun-
ity law and to submit specific proposals for the future;
5. Regrets that, despite Parliament’s right to ask the Commission to submit any appropriate proposals
on matters on which it considers that a Community act is required for the purpose of implementing the
Treaty, the Commission has so far shown very little diligence in following up Parliament’s requests bypresenting a legislative proposal;
Foreign and security policy and multilateral trade
6. Encourages and supports the Commission’s efforts to pursue its internal restructuring with a view to
developing its ability to deliver results in the field of conflict prevention and crisis management effectively
and on time in order to meet the new goals set in the Amsterdam Treaty;
7. In this connection, asks the Commission to review and identify non-military crisis-response tools
such as humanitarian aid, monitoring ofthe democratic process: electoral f ollow-up, institution-rehabilita-
tion and public security, and to establish effective mechanisms for rapid coordination and deployment,
bearing in mind the need to adapt decision-making processes, especially those involving financial decisions;
8. Urges the Commission to provide for rapid emergency aid to Mongolia, under the agreement with
that country via the TACIS Programme, in order to combat the suffering of humans and livestock in
Mongolia caused by the extreme cold (−45 °C);
9. Urges the Commission to prepare the creation of a special budget fund for civil crisis intervention
and to present a plan ensuring that sufficient amounts are available in future EU budgets to respond to
civil crisis situations;
10. Urges the Commission to begin a comprehensive debate on the restructuring ofthe external repre-
sentation of the EU which should respond efficiently to the needs of a future European foreign policy;
11. Welcomes the initiative for the protection of the Community’s financial interests outside the Union
in the form of a cooperation agreement with Switzerland; hopes that this type of initiative will speedily be
extended to other countries, especially those that benefit from substantial financial assistance from the
Community;
12. Takes the view that preparations for the fourth meeting of the Euro-Mediterranean Foreign Minis-
ters and the Heads ofState or Government represent a good opportunity f or strengthening the BarcelonaProcess, revitalising, in particular, the negotiation ofpartnership agreements with Algeria, Syria and Leba-
non and concluding such agreements with Egypt;
13. Welcomes the Commission’s activities to maintain the momentum behind a WTO-led process on
further trade liberalisation as part of an intensive dialogue with developing countries on ways of improving
their position in the trading system and on the treatment ofenvironmental and social issues; recalls the
EU’s declared objective ofpromoting sustainable development and calls on the Commission to present
detailed proposals on how this dialogue should be pursued;C 377/324 EN 29.12.2000 Official Journal of the European Communities
Thursday 16 March 2000
14. Calls on the Commission to promote and safeguard the values of cultural diversity within the
framework of the WTO negotiations;
15. Demands that the Commission submit to Parliament, for its assent, any agreement on WTO acces-
sion reached with important trading partners;
Enlargement
16. Welcomes the intention ofthe Commission to present a communication strategy so as to ensure
a broad understanding ofenlargement both within the Member States and the applicant countries and
hopes that this will lead to greater involvement ofall sectors ofsociety in the process ofenlargement
and integration;
17. Demands to be informed regularly by the Commission of progress in negotiations for the accession
ofthe twelve countries which are applicants f or membership ofthe European Union;
18. Calls on the Commission to develop a strategy which seeks to engender stability and development
in countries which adjoin the enlarged European Union; calls, especially, for cooperation with countries
such as Russia, Ukraine, Moldova and Belarus and those ofthe Caucasus to be stepped up;
19. Supports the view that pre-accession funds should be used in a more decentralised way, thereby
enabling local and regional authorities to play a more active role in the planning and implementation of
projects;
Economic and Social Cohesion
20. Insists on improved monitoring and coordination ofeconomic and monetary policies; regrets, in this
connection, that no new initiative has been proposed in the economic and financial sector; reiterates ear-
lier calls for greater involvement of Parliament in this process in order to compensate for the democratic
deficit in this crucial area of policy;
21. Welcomes the Commission’s commitment to restoring full employment and securing social cohe-
sion; emphasises that the Union and the Member States must intensify their work on modernising social
protection and promoting social inclusion as matters ofcommon concern;
22. Urges a revision ofthe Directive on collective redundancies, which needs to be strengthened and
instrumented by possible sanctions against companies infringing the Directive;
23. Welcomes the announcement ofa new Social Action Programme and takes the view that it will
require additional legislative proposals to develop it;
24. Welcomes the Commission’s commitment regarding regional policy in the implementation ofthe
Community Initiatives Interreg III and Urban II, in the development ofthe regions by establishing
the important lists of regions eligible for Objective 2 status as well as in setting out a new policy for the
outermost regions and islands ofthe European Union;
25. Calls on the Commission to take all the measures required to ensure that the principle ofaddition-
ality is fully respected in the current programming and implementation process under the Structural Funds;
26. Welcomes the Commission’s commitment to publish a Fifth action programme on gender equality;
expects the Commission, nevertheless, to adopt benchmarking for gender equality in all areas of policy,
implement gender mainstreaming in internal reforms and in the enlargement process and take initiatives
on reconciling professional and family life for women and men;
27. Calls on the Commission to take a legislative initiative in order to implement the Treaty provisions
relating to services ofgeneral economic interest;29.12.2000 EN C 377/325 Official Journal of the European Communities
Thursday 16 March 2000
Single market, information society and tax
28. Considers that greater harmonisation ofcivil law has become essential in the internal market and
calls on the Commission to draw up a study in this area;
29. Calls on the Commission to make f ull use ofthe provisions ofArticle 153 ofthe EC Treaty relating
to the protection ofconsumer rights and to present the requisite proposals;
30. Asks the Commission, in its forthcoming ‘Legislative package on public procurement’ and its inter-
pretative communication on public procurement and the environment, to allow for effective social as wellas environmental conditionality for procurement by public authorities of different political levels, as longas such conditions are not intended to distort competition;
31. Demands the rapid introduction ofmeasures to counter piracy and counterf eiting in the internal
market with a view to encouraging innovation, especially in the small businesses sector, and reminds the
Commission that a European patent which is cheap and rapidly effective is still a matter of the utmost
urgency;
32. Supports the Commission’s approach calling for greater cooperation in the management of radio
frequencies but opposes any reallocation of powers;
33. Insists that the Commission should take full account of Parliament’s recommendations in its new
proposal on postal services;
34. Supports the creation ofa European Research Area and calls on the Commission to take the mea-
sures required for the development of European scientific potential,
35. Insists on the implementation ofthe e-Europe initiative specifically by elaborating an integrated
legal framework for the development of electronic commerce which guarantees an equitable balancebetween the interests ofthe industries concerned and those ofconsumers;
36. Welcomes the announcement ofa communication on a strategy seeking to improve the operation
ofVAT in the internal market; insists that work on the simplif ication ofthe value added tax system and itsstraightforward application to electronic commerce should be speeded up;
37. Invites the Commission to envisage new legislative initiatives with a view to combating harmful tax
competition between Member States; awaits with great interest the Commission’s communications on tax
strategy, the review ofthe code ofconduct f or business taxation and the communication on making eco-
nomic policy supportive ofenvironmental sustainability; calls on the Commission in this context to pro-
pose specific measures in favour of outermost regions pursuant to Article 299(2) of the EC Treaty;
Agriculture and fisheries
38. Calls on the Commission to involve and inform Parliament on all aspects of negotiations on agri-
culture within the World Trade Organisation and on the negotiations concerning agriculture with the
CEECs in the context ofenlargement;
39. Asks the Commission to present without delay proposals aimed at simplifying Community legisla-
tion and implementation provisions within the CAP, in order to guarantee transparency and efficiency;
40. Insists that financial obligations entered into by the European Union under the CAP must be met in
full; asks for solutions to be found to specific sectoral problems arising from the application of the CAP;
urges the Commission to reconsider its intention ofreducing expenditure under heading 1 by € 300 mil-
lion;
41. Reminds the Commission ofthe importance ofthe countryside programmes and calls f or imple-
mentation ofthe rural development measures as soon as possible;C 377/326 EN 29.12.2000 Official Journal of the European Communities
Thursday 16 March 2000
42. Welcomes the intention ofthe Commission to integrate environmental considerations more f irmly
into the CAP and calls upon the Commission to present specific legislative proposals to achieve this aim in
the common agriculture and fisheries policies, including clear provisions for the precautionary principle;
43. Calls on the Commission, in pursuit ofits objective ofimproving the competitiveness and sustain-
ability ofthe common f isheries policy in the context ofincreasing globalisation ofeconomic activities,
to pay particular attention to preserving direct and indirect employment and to improving working con-
ditions in that sector;
44. Asks the Commission to continue its efforts so that a fisheries agreement with Morocco may be
signed as soon as possible;
Environment
45. Welcomes the Commission’s continued commitment to integrating environmental considerations in
other sectors and Community policies, to be followed up by specific proposals; calls on the Commission to
be particularly vigilant with regard to Structural Fund projects, enlargement and trade;
46. Calls on the Commission to come forward with a proposal for a Sixth Environmental Action Pro-
gramme with quantified targets and timetables, as already requested by Parliament during the discussions
on the Fifth Environmental Action Programme;
47. Asks the Commission to include in its programme the following proposals:
Ddash Proposals for establishing maximum limits in respect of the flexibility mechanism provided for in the
Kyoto Protocol (including the trading ofcontamination licences),
Ddash Proposal for a directive on soil protection,
Ddash Proposals for transferring the responsibility for supervising common legal standards (inspections) to
the European Environment Agency,
Ddash Proposal for the amendment of Directive 98/70/EC on fuel quality, with a view to reducing sulphur
content to 10 ppm per litre,
Ddash Proposal for a directive on the prevention and repair of damage to the environment (replacing the
proposed White Paper on civil liability in environmental protection matters),
Ddash Proposal for a Framework Directive on noise policies,
Ddash Proposal for a Directive on waste from electrical and electronic equipment,
Ddash Speeding up of the process for evaluating and modifying the common list of substances annexed to
Directive 91/414/EEC on pesticides,
Ddash Detailed review ofDirective 92/43/EEC (Fauna, Flora and Habitat) on the conservation ofwild f lora
and fauna, in the light of its application in the Member States;
Food safety, public health and consumer confidence
48. Welcomes the many ambitious and far-reaching programmes set out in the areas of food safety,
public health and consumer confidence but emphasises the need for quality over quantity and reminds
the Commission that problems still remain in implementing and monitoring existing legislation;
49. Supports the full application of the precautionary principle in all matters of food safety and calls,
in this context, for the continuation of the existing moratorium on new GMO releases;29.12.2000 EN C 377/327 Official Journal of the European Communities
Thursday 16 March 2000
Transport and Energy
50. Supports the Commission in its ambitious programme regarding transport policy, especially the
substantial improvement of air traffic control in European skies and the improvement of transport safety,especially in the maritime sector and on roads;
51. Notwithstanding the long awaited announcement ofa proposal f or a directive on renewables, calls
on the Commission for clearer signs of a shift in its energy policy towards the promotion of renewable
energies, including market penetration and easier network access, in view ofthe contribution ofrenewable
energy to competitiveness, environmental protection and security ofsupplies;
An area of freedom, security and justice
52. Calls on the Commission to improve the planning of European Justice and Home Affairs policies by
means ofclose cooperation with Parliament at a very early stage (e.g. scoreboard, joint action plans andprogrammes, joint Green or White Papers), in order to avoid hasty decision-making as well as loss of
credibility of the EU institutions in this field, and to ensure that, in future, the decision-making process
allows for thorough scrutiny of policies and their impact;
Education and culture
53. Emphasises that the Commission’s programme ofwork does not make any explicit ref erence to the
creation ofa European educational and cultural area;
54. Regrets that, alongside the implementation of framework programmes for education, culture, young
people and the audiovisual sector and the information and sports policies, not many measures and actions
are envisaged to strengthen these policies, although they are essential for the establishment of European
citizenship;
Internal reform
55. Welcomes, in principle, the declared intention ofthe Commission to concentrate its resources in
future on a range of core tasks; believes, however, that such a reform move must meet several conditions:
(i) it must contribute towards enhancing the transparency ofpolitical responsibilities at European level
relative to the national, regional or local levels ofdecision-making and policy implementation, espe-
cially for the general public,
(ii) it should not be misused as an excuse for political inactivity in certain areas nor as a pretext for
avoiding difficult policy issues,
(iii) it needs to be developed in close consultation with Parliament, including close dialogue between indi-
vidual Commissioners in their areas ofresponsibility and the appropriate parliamentary committees in
the run-up to the reform;
56. Insists that a genuine and long-lasting reform of the Commission, as called for by Parliament, must
be established as soon as possible in order to restore public confidence in the European institutions;
calls on the Commission to take f ull account ofthe views ofthe European Parliament bef ore any proposals
are put forward to change the Staff Regulations of Officials of the European Communities and recalls that
it is Parliament which has the final say on any new staff resources which might be requested;
57. Is ofthe opinion that the draf t regulation concerning public access to documents ofthe institutions
is too restrictive; calls for more detailed provisions on transparency in the spirit of the Amsterdam Treaty;
*
**C 377/328 EN 29.12.2000 Official Journal of the European Communities
Thursday 16 March 2000
58. Calls on the Commission to submit the proposals referred to above and to inform Parliament of the
progress ofthe legislative programme and ofany changes or delays, in order to improve both the trans-
parency ofthe decision-making process and interinstitutional cooperation;
59. Instructs its President to forward this resolution to the Commission, the Council, the parliaments of
the Member States, the Committee ofthe Regions and the Economic and Social Committee.
4. EU Charter of Fundamental Rights
A5-0064/2000
European Parliament resolution on the drafting of a European Union Charter of Fundamental
Rights (C5-0058/1999 Ndash 1999/2064(COS))
The European Parliament,
Ddash having regard to the decision ofthe European Council on the draf ting ofa European Union Charter of
Fundamental Rights (C5-0058/1999),
Ddash having regard to its position as representative ofthe peoples ofthe European Union,Ddash considering that the Union should strengthen the protection ofthe rights and interests ofthe nationals
ofits Member States through the introduction ofa citizenship ofthe Union (Article 2 ofthe
EU Treaty),
Ddash having regard to the fact that the Union must respect fundamental rights ‘as they result from the
constitutional traditions common to the Member States, as general principles ofCommunity law’
(Article 6 ofthe EU Treaty),
Ddash having regard to the Preamble ofthe United Nations Charter and the Universal Declaration on Human
Rights adopted by the UN General Assembly in its resolution 217 A (III) on 10 December 1948 in
Paris,
Ddash having regard to its numerous initiatives in the matter off undamental and citizens’ rights, in particular
to its resolution of12 April 1989 on the Declaration ofFundamental Rights and Freedoms (
1),
Ddash having regard to its initiatives in the matter ofa constitution f or the European Union, in particular its
resolution of12 December 1990 on the constitutional basis ofEuropean Union (2) and its resolution
of10 February 1994 on the Constitution ofthe European Union (3),
Ddash having regard to the conclusions ofthe Cologne European Council and the conclusions ofthe Tam-
pere European Council,
Ddash having regard to its resolution of16 September 1999 on the drawing up ofa Charter ofFundamental
Rights (4),
Ddash having regard to its resolution of27 October 1999 on the European Council meeting in Tampere (5),
Ddash having regard to the outstanding importance ofthe f orthcoming enlargement ofthe Union and the
Intergovernmental Conference,
Ddash having regard to the setting-up on 17 December 1999 in Brussels ofthe Convention to draf t a Euro-
pean Union Charter ofFundamental Rights,
Ddash having regard to Rule 47(1) ofits Rules ofProcedure,
(1) OJ C 120, 16.5.1989, p. 51.
(2) OJ C 19, 28.1.1991, p. 65.
(3) OJ C 61, 28.2.1994, p. 155.
(4) OJ C 54, 25.2.2000, p. 93.
(5) Texts adopted at that Sitting, point 15.29.12.2000 EN C 377/329 Official Journal of the European Communities
Thursday 16 March 2000