13. Strongly disapproves of any secret operations on EU territory that affect the privacy of EU citizens; is
deeply concerned that such operations should be taking place without the citizens of Europe and their
parliamentary representation having been informed; urges the USA and its intelligence and security servicesto act in a spirit of good cooperation and notify their allies of any security operations they intend to carryout on EU territory;
14. Asks its Committee on Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs, together with its Committee on
Economic and Monetary Affairs, to hold, as soon as possible, a joint hearing of the ECB, the Commission,the Council, the European Data Protection Supervisor and other private and public parties that are involvedin the affair in order to uncover what information they may have had;
15. Instructs its President to forward this resolution to the Council, the Commission, the European
Central Bank, the governments and parliaments of the Member States, accession countries and candidatecountries, and the United States Government and the two Chambers of Congress.
P6_TA(2006)0318
Integration of immigrants in the European Union
European Parliament resolution on strategies and means for the integration of immigrants in the
European Union (2006/2056(INI))
The European Parliament,
—having regard to the Commission Communication of 1 September 2005 entitled ‘A Common Agenda
for Integration —Framework for the Integration of Third-Country Nationals in the European Union’
(COM(2005)0389),
—having regard to Article 13 of the EC Treaty,
—having regard to the EC Treaty, which confers on the Community powers and responsibilities in the
spheres of immigration and asylum, and in particular to Article 63(3)(a) thereof,
—having regard to the Presidency Conclusions of the Tampere European Council of 15 and 16 October
1999, of the Laeken European Council of 14 and 15 December 2001, of the Seville European Councilof 21 and 22 June 2002 and of the Thessaloniki European Council of 19 and 20 June 2003, whichstress the importance of developing cooperation and exchange of information within the framework of
the newly-established group of national contact points on integration with a view in particular to
strengthening coordination of relevant policies at national and EU level,
—having regard to the Hague Programme adopted by the European Council on 4 November 2004, which
set the objectives to be implemented in the area of freedom, security and justice in the period
2005-2010,
—having regard to the informal ministerial meeting in Groningen on 9 November 2004, where ministers
responsible for integration policy met for the first time,
—having regard to the Common Basic Principles for immigrant integration policy in the European Union
adopted by the Council of the European Union on 19 November 2004 (
1),13.12.2006 C 303 E/845 Official Journal of the European Union
Thursday, 6 July 2006EN
(1) Document 14615/04 of 19 November 2004.
—having regard to the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union, and in particular Articles 18,
20, 21 and 22 thereof,
—having regard to Rule 45 of its Rules of Procedure,
—having regard to the report of the Committee on Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs and the
opinion of the Committee on Employment and Social Affairs (A6-0190/2006),
A. whereas the challenge of integrating immigrants is one to which the EU has risen before; whereas a
quarter of a century ago, most of its immigrants were southern Europeans; whereas today, southernEurope is a thriving part of the Union and its citizens are no longer perceived as immigrants, though atthe time many considered them alien and ‘unintegratable’ ; whereas the accession of their countries of
origin to the Union strengthened the EU as a whole; whereas likewise, citizens of the new MemberStates are now full EU citizens,
B. whereas today the Union faces an integration challenge of a different sort, in that it can no longer
assume that most of its immigrants will eventually become integrated as their countries of origin jointhe Union,
C. whereas the number of immigrants in the EU is estimated at 40 million, and their descendants total
millions more; whereas this growing population is extraordinarily diverse but confronted by similarproblems: their rate of labour-force participation is well below average and their success rates in schoollag markedly behind; whereas they are politically under-represented at all levels of government, includingin Member State political parties and in European institutions,
D. whereas although these over 40 million immigrants might be seen as the EU's 26th Member State (and
its fifth largest in terms of population), and the EU's concern and efforts to integrate this populationshould be equivalent to EU commitments to integrate accession countries, the Union has, in trying toovercome this integration challenge —the failure of which could undermine the EU socially, economic-
ally, and politically —committed precious few resources; whereas not only must long-term funding be
allocated to the new European Fund for the Integration of third-country nationals (COM(2005)0123),
but it should be ensured that the relevant Commission DGs earmark of their funding towards EU inte-gration policy,
E. whereas the European Union's commitment to integration has long been curbed by the commonly-held
idea that ‘integration is local’; whereas, in fact, integration is just as global in its implications, especially
when it fails, since the failure by a single Member State to implement successful integration policies canhave adverse consequences for the Union as a whole, for example:
—under-employment of immigrants, weakening the entire Union economy and thwarting fulfilment of
the Lisbon agenda;
—high- and low-skilled workers needed by the EU, seeing how inhospitable Europe can be to them,
being driven into the underground economy or into the arms of the EU's economic competitors;
—absence of effective integration policies, leading to negative perceptions of immigrants and to defen-
sive immigration policies;
—fear among citizens subverting respect for human dignity, freedom, democracy, equality, the rule of
law and respect for human rights, including the rights of persons belonging to minorities;
—perceptions and prejudices about immigrants who have not integrated undermining the Union's
successful enlargement,13.12.2006 C 303 E/846 Official Journal of the European Union
Thursday, 6 July 2006EN
F. whereas the success of integration will strengthen the Union's economy in the face of global competition;
whereas the Union, while cognizant of the need to prevent brain drain, will attract the workers and
entrepreneurs its economies need, as well as the scientists and students who are the bedrock of its abilityto innovate; whereas EU cities will be safer and communities stronger where a focused, consistent andadequately-funded integration policy applies; whereas xenophobic tendencies will be diminished andrespect for the fundamental rights of all fortified; whereas Europe's position in the world will be
enhanced,
G. whereas local, regional and national authorities play an essential role and whereas their responsibilities in
areas such as town planning, housing and education have a direct impact on the integration process;whereas such authorities should become more closely involved in the European debate; whereas through
the Community Structural Funds the European Union provides important support for initiatives taken at
these levels,
H. whereas there is no such thing as one clear-cut solution for successful integration in the European
Union; whereas local, regional, and national authorities (and especially urban centres, where the majority
of immigrants is concentrated) should have the ability and funds to determine and implement preciseintegration measures, and Member States and the Union as a whole must zealously develop integrationstrategies and monitor the effectiveness and outcomes of these integration measures in a more activeand effective way, thereby ensuring the implementation of integration strategies whose outcomesadvance the Union's common interests, and to this end the Commission must carry out the proposed
research to map levels of participation and integration across the EU,
I. whereas integration is a ‘two-way process ’that presupposes both the immigrants' willingness to, and
responsibility in, integrating into their host society and EU citizens' willingness to accept and include
migrants, and consists in integrated actions aimed at influencing the behaviour of both immigrants and
host societies on all relevant levels and mobilising resources on both sides in order to implement poli-cies; whereas this two-way process involves a mutual commitment, with both rights and obligations, forthe host society and immigrants,
J. whereas the priorities that guide EU actions in the field should include:
—improving the employment prospects of immigrants and reducing the employment gap with the host
population, including through the provision of appropriate information and training programmes bypublic authorities and social partners and the recognition of immigrants' training and professional
qualifications, while taking into account particularly the situation of migrant women, among whom
the unemployment rate is often higher,
—enhancing educational and language opportunities for immigrants and their descendants, including
through funding from Commission DG Education and Culture, eventually eliminating the perfor-mance gap with others, recognising, inter alia, that children of immigrants studying in a differentlanguage and trying to adapt to new customs may encounter more difficulties in the learning processthan their schoolmates, which may, in turn, lead to difficulties in their adaptation to and integration
into society, and also recognising that even migrants who already have high-level qualifications may
still need to adapt them to what is required in the host society,
—increasing political and civic education, participation and representation of immigrants in all appro-
priate domains of governance, civil society and decision- and policy-making,13.12.2006 C 303 E/847 Official Journal of the European Union
Thursday, 6 July 2006EN
—fighting racism, xenophobia and discrimination against immigrants, especially in the workplace,
schools, housing, health, public services, the mass media and politics, increasing mutual respect and
understanding of each other's similarities and differences and facilitating access to information onequal rights and opportunities tailored to linguistic needs,
whereas the EU institutions should ensure that their well-meant initiatives do not simply become
symbolic policies with no added value,
K. whereas promotion of fundamental rights, equal opportunities for all and non-discrimination are of key
importance to integration; whereas the proposal to make 2007 European Year of Equal Opportunities
for All and the plans for a European Year of Intercultural Dialogue in 2008 are major awareness-raisinginitiatives that will help to achieve these objectives,
L. whereas there is a clear link between a successful EU integration policy and the European Union's endea-
vour to develop a legal immigration and migration policy; whereas the first practical step should be toimprove coordination between the authorities responsible for the admission of immigrants and theauthorities responsible for the integration of immigrants,
1. Urges the Commission to ensure the effective implementation of the existing Directives linked to inte-
gration, notably Council Directives 2003/86/EC of 22 September 2003 on the right to family reunifica-tion (
1), 2003/109/EC of 25 November 2003 concerning the status of third-country nationals who are
long-term residents (2), 2000/43/EC of 29 June 2000 implementing the principle of equal treatment
between persons irrespective of racial or ethnic origin (3) and 2000/78/EC of 27 November 2000 estab-
lishing a general framework for equal treatment in employment and occupation (4); whereas many Member
States lag behind in effectively implementing these Directives, and it is critical for the Commission tomonitor more rigorously both the transposition of integration-related Directives and the effectiveness ofadministrative practices that implement the relevant legislation in the day-to-day lives of immigrants;
2. Welcomes the Commission proposal to establish the abovementioned European Fund for the
Integration of third-country nationals for the period 2007-2013 and urges that use of this fund follow sixconcrete principles, namely:
a) a single annual focal point should define disbursements, allowing the Commission to develop a critical
mass of expertise and more rigorously to assess, evaluate, and invest in programmes; target investmentareas should include reducing the employment gap between immigrants and others, improving immi-grant participation and performance in education, advancing the education and employment prospects ofwomen, language and introductory programmes, health, housing and urban living and enhancing poli-
tical and civic participation of immigrants;
b) the fund should favour initiatives with the greatest potential to be broadly applied throughout the Union;
c) the Commission should dedicate a reasonable and defined percentage of the fund's resources each year to
underwriting evaluations by independent experts of the effectiveness of the programs financed by theCommission;
d) once these experts have identified promising programmes, immediate priority should be given to disse-
minating and adapting best practices from these programmes for use in other Member States;13.12.2006 C 303 E/848 Official Journal of the European Union
Thursday, 6 July 2006EN
(1) OJ L 251, 3.10.2003, p. 12.
(2) OJ L 16, 23.1.2004, p. 44.
(3) OJ L 180, 19.7.2000, p. 22.
(4) OJ L 303, 2.12.2000, p. 16.
e) efforts should be supported among Member States to coordinate their integration efforts and exchange
best practices should be supported;
f) there should be a focus on the integration of newcomers, ensuring nevertheless that programmes that
target second and third-generation immigrant descendants also receive funding; programmes aiming to
help refugees as they prepare to enter and integrate into EU societies should also be considered;
3. Welcomes the reference in the abovementioned Commission communication to the Common Basic
Principles (CBPs); is of the firm belief that the CBPs represent a sound set of recommendations which
should be the foundation of EU integration policy; regrets that Member States have failed to follow up theCBPs in any meaningful way since their adoption in 2004; calls on the Finnish Presidency to put the CBPsback at the heart of the agenda, especially those principles relating to employment (no. 3), interaction(no. 7) and participation (no. 9);
4. Welcomes the Commission's proposal to promote an annual Integration Forum to facilitate the
exchange of best practice, especially in policies where the EU has a limited role to play but where someMember States operate policies which could offer guidance to others; considers that this Forum should seek
the participation of representatives from all the authorities involved in integration, being local, regional,
national, or EU authorities, as well as of immigrants themselves;
5. Calls on the Commission to clarify, expand and coordinate responsibilities for integration across DGs,
including reviving and maintaining a cross-DG working group on integration and defining the precise inte-gration responsibilities among the various DGs; further calls for action to be taken to make the newEuropean Integration Fund and the European Social Fund complementary;
6. Welcomes the Commission's recognition of the need for research into and a mapping exercise of
Member States' integration policies and levels of participation of immigrants; considers that this informationis a pre-requisite for any EU policy aimed at fostering better integration in the EU and that, for such amapping exercise to be of use, the terms of the EU debate on integration need to be clarified, given that the
word ‘integration’ itself is open to many different interpretations;
7. Calls on the Commission to create a permanent contact group of immigrant representatives, experts,
NGOs and others to advise it on all policies related to integration;
8. Calls on the Commission to place special emphasis on promoting immigration and diversity in the EU
and on mainstreaming integration at all times through its communication strategy and initiatives; calls on
the Commission and Member States to launch information and awareness-raising campaigns to improve
understanding of migration and of the economic and social contribution immigrants make to society;
9. Calls on the Commission to establish rigorous monitoring mechanisms for the evaluation of integration
programmes in the Member States, including through the use of independent experts, and to launch a
rigorous and practical biannual report on migration and integration that:
—focuses on rigorous indices that measure Member State performance with respect to the CBPs on
integration,
—makes Member State reporting of accurate and complete data obligatory; in the absence of such data,
alternative means of gathering data consistent with the Report's indices should be developed,
—enhances the role of national contact points and their cooperation with independent experts,13.12.2006 C 303 E/849 Official Journal of the European Union
Thursday, 6 July 2006EN
—looks to the United Nations Development Programme's Human Development Report and the European
Inclusion Index as models,
—is released at the annual meeting of EU integration ministers;
10. Encourages the Commission to consult, as appropriate, migrant communities in defining and imple-
menting European aid and development policies in their home countries;
11. Asks the Commission to multiply research and analysis initiatives aimed at understanding what works
in integration and to ambitiously expand effective efforts to disseminate best practices in cooperation with
Member States and local authorities, not only through the proposed website but by as many other reason-able means as possible;
12. Calls on the Commission and Member States to utilise the broad potential of Commission delegations
and consular authorities throughout the world to assist in integrating potential immigrants through familiar-
ising them with EU and Member State culture, history, language and civic rights and responsibilities;
13. Stresses the importance of the composition of the European institutions' staff and the Member States'
public administrations reflecting the composition of the Union's and the Member States' populations;
14. Urges the Council to use the bridging clause of Article 67(2), second indent, of the Treaty to give
Parliament co-decision powers on integration and legal migration and qualified majority voting in the
Council; considers that it is important for Members to have the power of co-decision on integration policy,
given that they represent the political voice of the EU, and considers, therefore, that they should representthe opinions of both immigrants and citizens and should share responsibility for making integration policyin the EU legislative process;
15. Urges the Council to make permanent the annual meeting of integration ministers, inaugurated by the
Dutch Council Presidency at Groningen in November 2004;
16. Calls on the Member States, when making their final considerations on the EU Fundamental Rights
Agency, seriously to consider a role for the agency in promoting trust and good relations within neighbour-hoods and to develop this role organically through the successive annual programmes envisaged for theagency;
17. Urges the Council to reconsider the Commission proposal to apply the open method of coordination
to integration policy; in this respect, calls for the involvement of Parliament in the whole procedure;
18. Urges the Council to establish a comprehensive and forward-looking framework directive on legal
migration, with due regard to the need for integration;
19. Encourages Member States to assign responsibility to a single cabinet minister to monitor immigrant
integration policies, to ensure that policies are mainstreamed throughout agencies at all levels of government
and to consider the appointment of a High Commissioner on Integration or an Integration Ombudsman in
each Member State to coordinate implementation of policies, disseminate information to migrants, reviewmigrant complaints and take action to correct problems;
20. Calls on every Member State to provide an audit of all government agencies at every level that have or
should have responsibilities related to immigrant integration;
21. Calls on the Commission to examine the possibility of incorporating the integration of third-country
nationals in the future multiannual programmes of the Fundamental Rights Agency;13.12.2006 C 303 E/850 Official Journal of the European Union
Thursday, 6 July 2006EN
22. Calls on Member States to encourage the political participation of immigrants and discourage their
political and social isolation; in this regard, calls on the Commission to carry out a legal review of existing
provisions relating to European civic citizenship in the various Member States as well as of current MemberState practices regarding the right of long-term resident immigrants to vote in local and municipal elections;
23. Calls on Member States to establish transparent, humane, fast and reasonable procedures for the
granting of long-term resident status, for family reunification and for the naturalization of long-term resi-dent immigrants and their children, taking into account especially the fact that many of those children areborn in the territory of a Member State;
24. Draws the Member States' attention to the dependent legal status of immigrant women joining their
spouses under family reunification and calls on Member States to review their legislation so as to ensurethat spouses and children are granted an individual status and work permit independent of that of the prin-cipal legal status holder at the earliest opportunity in order to guarantee and protect their rights fully andfacilitate their social integration;
25. Encourages political parties, trade unions and civil society as a whole at national level to include immi-
grants as full members at all levels of their respective structures;
26. Is in favour of integration programmes applied by certain Member States involving a mutual commit-
ment by the host country and immigrants; hopes that immigrants can in this way be made more aware ofthe European Union's fundamental values and be enabled at the same time to acquire basic knowledge onthe functioning of the host society; stresses the importance of encouraging the learning of the host society's
language and organising civic education courses;
27. Encourages Member States to strengthen anti-discrimination and anti-racism laws, enforce existing
ones and consider appropriate affirmative action legislation for migrants in all appropriate fields, using
those Member States where affirmative action has been a success as a guide;
28. Calls on Member States, in order especially to prevent the potential maltreatment of immigrant
women, to provide them with easily accessible information as regards the legislation of the host country on
gender equality and the rights and protection that derive from that legislation, including the available legal
and administrative remedies;
29. Calls on Member States and regional and local authorities to stimulate interaction between immigrants
and their host society by promoting, inter alia, shared fora, intercultural dialogue, seminars, exhibitions and
cultural and sports activities; further calls for the creation of new, or the support of existing, structures toallow immigrants to integrate into the host society in order to avoid the social exclusion of newcomers andof those who have already settled but who find it difficult to integrate; moreover, calls for support to beprovided to migrant organizations in their territories and for the strengthening of ties with the migrants'
home countries;
30. Encourages Member States to make provision for integration-related measures for refugees during the
reception phase, such as language courses or voluntary work activities, taking into consideration the fact
that the integration process for refugees starts during the reception phase;
31. Stresses the importance of developing a comprehensive framework for European civic citizenship with
the cooperation of Parliament, the Council and the Commission;
32. Stresses the importance of establishing annual hearings on integration with the participation of Parlia-
ment, national parliaments and civil society, especially NGOs and immigrant associations, in order to eval-uate the effectiveness of the Union's integration efforts and assess developments regarding immigrant inte-gration at Member State level;
33. Instructs its President to forward this resolution to the Council, the Commission and the governments
of the Member States.13.12.2006 C 303 E/851 Official Journal of the European Union
Thursday, 6 July 2006EN