Resolution of the European Parliament

containing the comments accompanying the decision on the discharge to the Director of the European Agency for Safety and Health at Work in respect of the implementation of its budget for the financial year 2003

THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT,

having regard to the Court of Auditors' report on the annual accounts of the European Agency for Safety and Health for the 2003 financial year together with the Agency's replies [1],

having regard to the Council's recommendation of 8 March 2005 (6851/2005 — C6-0069/2005),

having regard to the EC Treaty, and in particular Article 276 thereof,

having regard to Council Regulation (EC, Euratom) No 1605/2002 of 25 June 2002 on the Financial Regulation applicable to the general budget of the European Communities [2] and in particular Article 185 thereof, and to Council Regulation (EC) No 1654/2003 of 18 June 2003 amending Regulation (EC) No 2062/94 establishing a European Agency for Safety and Health at Work [3] and in particular article 14 thereof,

having regard to Commission Regulation (EC, Euratom) No 2343/2002 of 19 November 2002 on the framework Financial Regulation for the bodies referred to in Article 185 of Council Regulation (EC, Euratom) No 1605/2002 on the Financial Regulation applicable to the general budget of the European Communities [4] and, in particular, Article 94 thereof,

having regard to Rules 70 and 71 of and Annex V to its Rules of Procedure,

having regard to the Report of the Committee on Budgetary Control (A6-0074/2005),

A. Whereas the European Court of Auditors (ECA) stated, in its abovementioned specific report, that it obtained reasonable assurance that the annual accounts for the financial year ended 31 December 2003 were reliable and that the underlying transactions, taken as a whole, were legal and regular.

B. whereas on 21 April 2004 the European Parliament gave discharge [5] to the Director of the European Agency for Safety and Health at Work (the Agency) in respect of the implementation of its budget for the 2002 financial year and in the resolution accompanying the discharge decision, the European Parliament, inter alia:

- insisted on the need for the Agency to improve the programming of its activities so as to reduce the large amount of carry-overs of appropriations,

- invited the Agency to use experience gained in managing the 2002 SME Funding Scheme so as to ensure greater rigour and better value for money in subsequent schemes,

1. Notes the following figures for the accounts of the European Agency for Safety and Health at Work for the financial years 2003 and 2002:

Revenue and expenditure account for the financial years 2003 and 2002

[6] [7] [8]

NB: Differences in totals are due to the effects of rounding.

Source: The Agency's data, the tables present, in summary form, the data provided by the Agency in its own accounts.

(in EUR 1000) |

| 2003 | 2002 |

Revenue

Community subsidies | 11641 | 12324 |

Other subsidies | 66 | 252 |

Other revenue | 157 | 81 |

Phare revenue | 824 | 0 |

Total revenue (a) | 12688 | 12657 |

Expenditure

Staff — Title I of the budget

Payments | 3245 | 3024 |

Appropriations carried over | 87 | 136 |

Administration — Title II of the budget

Payments | 1146 | 1140 |

Appropriations carried over | 186 | 247 |

Operating activities — Title III of the budget

Payments | 2559 | 2030 |

Appropriations carried over | 5859 | 5623 |

Phare expenditure

Payments | 548 | 0 |

Appropriations carried over | 502 | 0 |

Total expenditure (b) | 14131 | 12199 |

Outturn for the financial year (c = a – b) [6] | – 1443 | 458 |

Balance carried over from the previous financial year | – 1108 | – 2185 |

Appropriations carried over from the previous financial year and cancelled | 766 | 609 |

Sums to be re-used carried over from the previous financial year and not used | 1 | 0 |

Payments against commitment cancelled in 2002 | – 191 | 0 |

Exchange rate differences | 4 | 4 |

Adjustment entries | – 16 | 7 |

Outturn for the financial year before economic adjustment (d) | – 1987 | – 1108 |

Budget revenue to be recovered | 850 | 0 |

Other revenue to be recovered | 3 | 0 |

Acquisitions of fixed assets | 207 | 0 |

Depreciation [7] | – 186 | 0 |

Miscellaneous expenditure | – 1 | 0 |

Economic adjustments (e) | 873 | 0 |

Balance for the financial year (d + e) [8] | – 1113 | – 1108 |

2. Records with satisfaction the efforts made by the Agency which resulted in a significant reduction of carry-overs of its operating appropriations; shares the Court's view that the carry-over rate for those appropriations is still high; expects the Agency to deploy greater efforts so as to reduce further carry-overs;

3. Calls on the Agency in this respect to put in place a plan to reduce carry-overs, providing for yearly reduction targets compatible with the implementation cycle of its work programme;

4. Invites the Agency to clearly indicate which among its operational activities could be best served through financing by differentiated appropriations;

5. Reiterates its call to the Agency to apply a tighter programming and improve monitoring of its operational activities; invites the Agency to continue its efforts with a view to defining better focused and more realistic objectives, in operational terms, as was suggested in the Commission's evaluation of the Agency in 2003;

6. Notes the Agency's explanation as regards its efforts to carry out its work programme in cooperation with a reduced number of topic centres; invites the Agency to present in its Annual Activity Report for 2004 an analysis of lessons learnt through its work with the topic centres, referred to in the provisions of the Agency's founding regulation, explaining the advantages and shortcomings of this model of cooperation; furthermore, invites the Agency to highlight in its report the added value of the results so far obtained; encourages the Agency to further strengthen monitoring and control of costs declared by topic centres and to ask for a certification of their work by an external auditor as the ECA has suggested;

7. Regrets the absence of an equality plan and expects the Agency to develop a plan shortly in order to become an equal opportunities employer; expects the Agency not only to consider equality issues at the stage of recruitment but also to work proactively and on a long-term basis to promote gender equality;

8. Welcomes the Agency's commitment to communicate information on its activities to citizens and the hopes to see further measures to develop and strengthen the Agency's strategy for information and communication;

General points addressed to the Commission and the Agencies

9. Recalls its position that while it supported the Commission's efforts to establish a limited number of models, at least for future "regulatory" agencies, it took the view that the structure of current and future agencies merited in-depth consideration at interinstitutional level; also stresses that before the Commission defines the framework conditions for the use of regulatory agencies an inter-institutional agreement should spell out common guidelines; this should happen before setting up a harmonised framework for the structure of the agencies;

10. Notes the Commission's position [9] with regard to delegating responsibility for the execution of tasks to bodies, including agencies, other than the Commission's core administration; takes the view that this does not answer Parliament's call for in-depth consideration at interinstitutional level of the structure of existing agencies; therefore invites the Commission to provide clarification on this point and on the future overall Interinstitutional Agreement related to the new arrangements to be set up within or in parallel with the Financial Perspective [10];

11. Invites the Commission to organise and perform in the medium term, e.g. on a standard three-year cycle, a cross-cutting analysis of the evaluations carried out on individual Agencies in order to:

(a) reach conclusions with regard to the coherence of Agency activity with EU policies in general and as regards the synergies existing or to be developed between the agencies and Commission departments and the avoidance of overlapping between them;

(b) make an assessment of the broader European added value of the Agencies' outputs in their respective area of activity and of the relevance, efficiency and effectiveness of the Agency model in implementing or contributing to EU policies;

(c) determine and enhance the impact of the Agencies' actions in terms of the proximity, accessibility and visibility of the EU to its citizens;

12. Expects such an overall analysis to be available by the end of 2005 so as to cover the three-year period from the time of the introduction of the new Financial Regulation and the consequent new framework in the Agencies' system;

13. Invites the Agencies to participate actively in such a process and to cooperate with the Commission, providing the necessary input on matters that they feel are of substance to their functioning, role, remit and needs, as well as on any matter which could help to improve the whole discharge procedure, with a view to contributing to the success of such a process and increasing the accountability and transparency of the Agencies; invites Agencies to present such input also to its competent committees;

14. Calls on the Commission, in parallel with this exercise, to present by the end of 2005 at the latest, proposals for changes to be made in the existing Agencies' Constituent Acts with a view, inter alia, to optimising its relationship with the Agencies; such proposals should aim at:

(a) increasing communication between the Commission and the Agencies;

(b) establishing or expanding cooperation in defining needs to be covered and objectives, outputs to be produced and the strategy to achieve them, and in setting standards for monitoring and evaluation;

(c) enhancing complementary action, better organising the necessary resources and their effective allocation to produce results, and devising a communication strategy for dissemination of those results;

15. Emphasises that, before any decision is taken to propose the creation of a new agency, the Commission must undertake a strict evaluation of the need and added value of the function of this Agency, bearing in mind existing structures, the principles of subsidiarity, budgetary austerity and the simplification of procedures;

16. Expects the Commission to present swiftly the guidelines concerning staff policy of the Agencies that Parliament had requested the Commission to present before the end of the 2005 budgetary procedure;

General points addressed to the Agencies

17. Expects to receive from now on, from each of the Agencies, the report summarising information on the audits carried out by the Internal Auditor, the recommendations made and the action taken on these recommendations in accordance with Article 72(5) of Regulation (EC, Euratom) No 2343/2002;

18. Invites the Agencies to make further efforts to apply correctly the staff regulations and rules applicable to other civil servants with regard to their staff (recruitment procedures and relevant decisions taken, personal files, calculation of remuneration and other entitlements, promotions policy, percentage of vacant posts, quotas for respecting gender equality, etc.);

19. Notes that, in general, the respective percentage of male and female employees in the overall staff composition of the Agencies shows that an imbalance between men and women exists; regrets that men make up about one third of staff and are over-represented in high grade positions while women are generally over-represented in low grade positions; expects the Agencies to take immediate and effective measures to correct this situation;

20. Calls on the Agencies to ensure that all the relevant provisions of Directive 2002/73/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 23 September 2002 amending Council Directive 76/207/EEC on the implementation of the principle of equal treatment for men and women as regards access to employment, vocational training and promotion, and working conditions [11] are introduced in their respective staff policies;

21. Expects the Agencies, in response to the relevant observations of the ECA, to comply fully with the budgetary principles as set out in the Financial Regulation, in particular those of unity and budgetary accuracy; calls on the Agencies that have not yet done so to fulfil the Financial Regulation's requirements on accounting matters and to strengthen further their procedures as regards internal management and control with the aim of increasing accountability, transparency and European added value;

22. Encourages the Agencies, especially those whose activities have points in common with the activities or missions of other Agencies, to strengthen their cooperation, thus opening up opportunities for developing synergies; invites them to formalise, where appropriate, such cooperation through specific agreements (joint declarations, memoranda of understanding, decisions on joint planning and actions/programmes presenting complementary characteristics) so as to ensure that there is no duplication of work, that each Agency's output is clearly identified and that the result of joint efforts maximises the added value and the impact of their work; expects to be informed regularly on this issue;

23. Calls on the Agencies to pay special attention to procedures for the award and management of contracts; invites them to take all appropriate measures as regards their administrative structures in order to strengthen their internal control procedures, channels and management; takes the view that such measures may include, where necessary or feasible, the setting-up of specialised units entrusted with the task of advising, on the basis of risk analysis, on how best to prepare contract award procedures, to ensure monitoring and to carry out follow-up, as required; on this matter, calls on the Commission and the ECA to strengthen cooperation with the Agencies;

24. Notes the difficulties to which some Directors, in particular of the "newly created" Agencies, referred with regard to the Agencies' compliance with the calendar and deadlines for reporting as set in the Financial Regulation; invites the Agencies' Directors, in the perspective of the forthcoming review of the Financial Regulation to be held in 2005, to inform its Committees on Budgets and Budgetary Control of the difficulties encountered so far so that these may be considered in the framework of the review; expects the Directors to make specific proposals for alternative arrangements as to deadlines that may best suit their functioning requirements while respecting the reporting obligations of the Agencies as provided for in the Financial Regulation;

25. Notes the positive response by the Agencies' Directors to the call by Parliament's committee responsible for preparing discharge for the establishment of a more precise system of communication, in particular as regards the transmission by the Agencies to that committee of documents relating to the Agencies' reporting obligations; takes the view that better organisation of such communication will strengthen its cooperation with the Agencies and enhance democratic control;

26. Invites the Directors of the Agencies from now on to accompany their annual activity report, which is presented together with financial and management information, with a declaration of assurance concerning the legality and regularity of operations, similar to the declarations signed by the Directors-General of the Commission;

27. Invites the Agencies to develop a comprehensive strategy of communication addressing the need to make available, in the appropriate form, the results of their work to the general public beyond the presentation of such results to the Institutions, Member States' competent services, specialists, partners or specific beneficiaries; calls on the Agencies, in view of the development of such a strategy, to intensify their cooperation and exchange information on best practice aimed at achieving this goal; expects its competent committees to be duly informed by the Agencies, before the next discharge exercise, on the progress made in devising such a strategy in order to ensure the effective and timely monitoring of their activities;

General points addressed to the ECA and the Agencies

28. Welcomes the ECA's initiative to add a table to its specific reports on the Agencies presenting summary information on the competences, governance, resources available and products/output of the particular agency; takes the view that this enhances the clarity and transparency of the work of these Community bodies, while providing a useful basis for comparison, where appropriate, with a view to helping set up the harmonised framework for the Agencies that Parliament has called for;

29. Invites the ECA and the Agencies to strengthen their cooperation in order to enhance the procedures and technical tools to improve the sound management of all the budgetary and finance issues, with the view to establishing a methodology that prepares the ground for a positive budget discharge from the start of the process; expects to be informed regularly of the progress made and the implementation of best practices;

30. Calls on the ECA and the Agencies to enhance transparency in the procédure contradictoire prior to the ECA's final report, so as to avoid any contradiction or ambiguity which could jeopardise the credibility of the whole exercise; in this respect, invites the ECA and the Commission to propose a feasible way of updating information on the improvements made and/or the problems found, from the time when the ECA's preparatory report is first discussed until the time of the decision as to whether to grant discharge, in order to offer the most accurate picture of the situation of the Agencies.

[1] OJ C 324, 30.12.2004, p. 1.

[2] OJ L 248, 16.9.2002, p. 1.

[3] OJ L 245, 29.9.2003, p. 38.

[4] OJ L 357, 31.12.2002, p. 72.

[5] OJ L 330, 4.11.2004, p. 8.

[6] Calculation according to the principles of Article 15 of Council Regulation (EC, Euratom) No 1150/2000 of 22 May 2000 (OJ L 130, 31.5.2000. p. 8.

[7] In 2003 the Agency depreciated its fixed assets for the first time.

[8] The negative balance is due to the fact that carry-overs are still being treated as expenditure, without any economic adjustment. A rough estimate of the adjustment to be applied suggests that the actual balance for the financial year is of the order of a EUR 1 million.

[9] As set out in Annex 1 to the Communication from the Commission to the Council and the European Parliament "Building our common future, policy challenges and budgetary means of the enlarged Union 2007-2013", (COM(2004) 0101, p. 38).

[10] See Annex to the Commission's report on the follow-up to 2002 Discharges (COM(2004) 0648, p. 108).

[11] OJ L 269, 5.10.2002, p. 15.

--------------------------------------------------