COUNCIL RECOMMENDATION

of 18 June 2021

delivering a Council opinion on the 2021 Stability Programme of France

(2021/C 304/10)

THE COUNCIL OF THE EUROPEAN UNION,

Having regard to the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union,

Having regard to Council Regulation (EC) No 1466/97 of 7 July 1997 on the strengthening of the surveillance of budgetary positions and the surveillance and coordination of economic policies (1), and in particular Article 5(2) thereof,

Having regard to the recommendation of the European Commission,

Having regard to the resolutions of the European Parliament,

After consulting the Economic and Financial Committee,

Whereas:

(1) On 20 March 2020, the Commission adopted a communication on the activation of the general escape clause of the Stability and Growth Pact. The general escape clause, as set out in Articles 5(1), 6(3), 9(1) and 10(3) of Regulation (EC) No 1466/97 and Articles 3(5) and 5(2) of Council Regulation (EC) No 1467/97 (2), facilitates the coordination of budgetary policies in times of severe economic downturn. In that communication, the Commission set out its view that, given the expected severe economic downturn resulting from the COVID-19 pandemic, the conditions for activating the general escape clause were met. On 23 March 2020, the ministers of finance of the Member States agreed with the assessment of the Commission. The general escape clause has granted Member States budgetary flexibility to deal with the COVID-19 crisis. It has facilitated the coordination of budgetary policies in times of severe economic downturn. Its activation allows for a temporary departure from the adjustment path towards the medium-term budgetary objective of each Member State, provided that this does not endanger fiscal sustainability in the medium term. On 17 September 2020, in its communication on the 2021 Annual Sustainable Growth Strategy, the Commission announced that the general escape clause would remain active in 2021.

(2) On 20 July 2020, the Council adopted a Recommendation (3) (‘the Council Recommendation of 20 July 2020’). It recommended France to take all necessary measures, in line with the general escape clause, to effectively address the COVID-19 pandemic, sustain the economy and support the ensuing recovery. It also recommended France to pursue, when economic conditions allow, fiscal policies aimed at achieving prudent medium-term fiscal positions and ensuring debt sustainability, while enhancing investment.

(3) The 2021 Council Recommendation on the economic policy of the euro area indicates that fiscal policies should remain supportive in all euro-area Member States throughout 2021 and that policy measures should be tailored to country-specific circumstances and be timely, temporary and targeted. When the epidemiological and economic conditions allow, emergency measures should be phased out, while combatting the social and labour-market impact of the crisis. Member States should pursue fiscal policies that are aimed at achieving prudent medium-term fiscal positions and ensuring debt sustainability, while enhancing investment. Member States should pursue reforms that strengthen the coverage, adequacy and sustainability of health and social protection systems for all.

(4) On 18 November 2020, the Commission adopted its opinions on the 2021 draft budgetary plans of the euro-area Member States, which were based on a qualitative assessment of the fiscal measures. The Commission was of the opinion that the draft budgetary plan of France was overall in line with the fiscal policy recommendations set out in the Council Recommendation of 20 July 2020, and that most of the measures included in the draft budgetary plan supported economic activity against the background of considerable uncertainty. However, some measures did not appear to be temporary or matched by offsetting measures.

(5) Next Generation EU, including the Recovery and Resilience Facility, will ensure a sustainable, inclusive and fair recovery. Regulation (EU) 2021/241 of the European Parliament and of the Council (4), which established the Recovery and Resilience Facility, entered into force on 19 February 2021. The Recovery and Resilience Facility will provide financial support for the implementation of reforms and investment, entailing a fiscal impulse financed by the Union. It will contribute to the economic recovery and to the implementation of sustainable and growth-enhancing reforms and investment, in particular to promote the green and digital transitions, and will strengthen the resilience and potential growth of the Member States’ economies. It will also help public finances to return to more favourable positions in the near term and will contribute to strengthening sustainable public finances and to growth and job creation in the medium and long term.

(6) On 3 March 2021, the Commission adopted a communication providing further policy orientations to facilitate the coordination of fiscal policies and the preparation of Member States’ Stability and Convergence Programmes. The overall fiscal stance, taking into account national budgets and the Recovery and Resilience Facility, should remain supportive in 2021 and 2022. At the same time, given the expectation that economic activity will gradually normalise in the second half of 2021, Member States’ fiscal policies should become more differentiated in 2022. Member States’ fiscal policies should take into account the state of the recovery, fiscal sustainability and the need to reduce economic, social and territorial divergences. In view of the need to support a sustainable recovery for the Union, Member States with low sustainability risks should gear their budgets towards maintaining a supportive fiscal policy in 2022, taking into account the impact of the Recovery and Resilience Facility. Member States with high debt levels should pursue prudent fiscal policies, while preserving nationally financed investment and making use of grants under the Recovery and Resilience Facility to fund additional high-quality investment projects and structural reforms. For the period beyond 2022, fiscal policies should continue to take into account the strength of the recovery, the degree of economic uncertainty and fiscal sustainability considerations. A refocusing of fiscal policies towards achieving prudent medium-term fiscal positions, including by phasing out support measures in due course, will contribute to ensuring fiscal sustainability in the medium term.

(7) In its communication of 3 March 2021, the Commission also took the view that the decision on the deactivation or continued application of the general escape clause should be taken as an overall assessment of the state of the economy, with the level of economic activity in the Union or euro area compared to pre-crisis levels (end of 2019) as a key quantitative criterion. On the basis of the Commission’s 2021 spring forecast, on 2 June 2021 the Commission considered that the conditions for continuing to apply the general escape clause in 2022 and for deactivating it as of 2023 were met. Country-specific situations will continue to be taken into account after the deactivation of the general escape clause.

(8) On 30 April 2021, France submitted its 2021 Stability Programme, in line with Article 4 of Regulation (EC) No 1466/97.

(9) In 2020, based on data validated by Eurostat, France’s general government deficit was 9,2 % of gross domestic product (GDP), while general government debt increased to 115,7 % of GDP. The annual change in the primary budget balance amounted to -6,2 % of GDP, including discretionary budgetary measures of 3,3 % of GDP in support of the economy and the operation of automatic stabilisers. France also provided liquidity support to companies and households (such as guarantees and tax deferrals, which do not have a direct and immediate budgetary impact) estimated at 17,4 % of GDP; the actual take-up of the public guarantees in 2020 is estimated by the Commission to be roughly equivalent to 6 % of GDP.

(10) On 2 June 2021, the Commission issued a report under Article 126(3) of the Treaty. That report discusses the budgetary situation of France, as its general government deficit in 2020 exceeded the 3 %-of-GDP Treaty reference value, while its general government debt exceeded the 60 %-of-GDP Treaty reference value and did not diminish at a satisfactory pace. The report concluded that the deficit criterion was not fulfilled and the debt criterion was not complied with.

(11) The macroeconomic scenario underpinning the budgetary projections is cautious in 2021 and 2022. The 2021 Stability Programme projects GDP growth at 5 % and 4 % in 2021 and 2022 respectively, whereas the Commission projects GDP to expand by 5,7 % and 4,2 % in the same years. For 2021, the higher growth expected by the Commission is due to a higher contribution to growth from domestic and net exports than in the 2021 Stability Programme. Specifically, the Commission envisages a less dynamic private consumption, whereas investment and exports are expected to expand more quickly than in the macroeconomic scenario in the 2021 Stability Programme. For 2022, the higher growth projected by the Commission is mainly due to a higher contribution of net exports to growth, whereas the overall contribution of domestic demand is set to be broadly similar to that in the 2021 Stability Programme.

(12) In its 2021 Stability Programme, the government plans a decrease in the general government deficit from 9,2 % of GDP in 2020 to 9,0 % of GDP in 2021, while the debt ratio is planned to increase to 117,8 % of GDP in 2021. According to the 2021 Stability Programme, the change in the primary budget balance in 2021 compared with the pre-crisis level (2019) is set to amount to -6,2 % of GDP, reflecting the discretionary budgetary measures of 4,0 % of GDP in support of the economy and the operation of automatic stabilisers. These projections are in line with the Commission’s 2021 spring forecast.

(13) In response to the COVID-19 pandemic and related economic downturn, France has adopted budgetary measures to strengthen the capacity of its health system, contain the COVID-19 pandemic and provide relief to those individuals and sectors that have been particularly affected. This forceful policy response has cushioned the contraction in GDP, which, in turn, has curtailed the increase in government deficit and public debt. Fiscal measures should maximise support to the recovery without pre-empting future fiscal trajectories. Therefore, measures should avoid creating a permanent burden on public finances. When Member States introduce permanent measures, they should properly fund them to ensure budgetary neutrality in the medium term. The measures taken by France in 2020 and 2021 have been in line with the Council Recommendation of 20 July 2020. Some of the discretionary measures adopted by the government over the period 2020 to 2021, and announced for 2022, do not appear to be temporary or matched by offsetting measures. Beyond the horizon of the Commission’s 2021 spring forecast, in 2023, the cumulative remaining impact of those non-temporary measures is preliminarily estimated at around 1 % of GDP, mainly consisting of a permanent reduction in taxes on production, the increase of civil servant wages, mainly in the healthcare system as well as capital transfers. Those non-temporary measures also include investment of approximately 1/10 % of GDP, which is expected to support medium-term potential growth, and thus sustainability.

(14) The 2021 Stability Programme assumes investment and reforms financed by grants under the Recovery and Resilience Facility amounting to 0,7 % of GDP in 2021 and 0,9 % as of 2022. The Commission’s 2021 spring forecast includes in its budgetary projections estimated grants of 0,8 % and 0,4 % of GDP in 2021 and 2022, respectively.

(15) The established indicators of fiscal adjustment set out in Regulation (EC) No 1466/97 need to be considered in the context of the current circumstances. First, there is significant uncertainty surrounding output gap estimates. Second, there is a need for fiscal policy to stand ready to rapidly adapt to the evolution of the COVID-19 pandemic, shifting from emergency relief to more targeted measures once health risks diminish. Third, the current context is characterised by a significant policy response to support economic activity. In the presence of sizeable transfers from the Union budget (such as those from the Recovery and Resilience Facility), the established indicators do not capture the full impulse provided to the economy by fiscal policies. Against this background, the structural balance does not appear adequate in the current circumstances. The expenditure benchmark also needs to be adapted (5) and complemented with additional information in order to fully gauge the fiscal policy orientation.

(16) As in the approach pursued in the assessment of the 2021 draft budgetary plans, temporary emergency measures have been excluded from the expenditure aggregate. These crisis-related temporary emergency measures support health systems and compensate workers and firms for the losses in income due to lockdowns and supply chain disruptions; their reversal by the public authorities is contingent on the return of the public health and economic situation to normality. To assess the overall fiscal stance at the current juncture, the sizeable transfers from the Union budget (such as those from the Recovery and Resilience Facility) should be included in the relevant expenditure aggregate. The overall fiscal stance is therefore measured by the change in primary expenditure (net of discretionary revenue measures and excluding crisis-related temporary emergency measures), including expenditure financed by grants under the Recovery and Resilience Facility and other Union funds. Going beyond the overall fiscal stance, the analysis also aims to assess whether national fiscal policy is prudent and its composition is conducive to a sustainable recovery consistent with the green and digital transitions. For that reason, particular attention is paid to the evolution of nationally financed primary current expenditure and investment.

(17) In its 2021 Stability Programme, France’s general government deficit is planned to decrease to 5,3 % of GDP in 2022, mainly due to a discontinuation of the temporary support measures adopted in 2020 and 2021. The general government debt ratio is planned to decrease to 116,3 % of GDP in 2022. While the debt projection is in line with the Commission’s 2021 spring forecast, the deficit projection is above the Commission’s 2021 spring forecast, mainly due to the lower deficit expected by the Commission in 2021 and the slightly less favourable macroeconomic scenario in the 2021 Stability Programme. Based on the Commission’s 2021 spring forecast, and on the basis of the specific methodology that reflects the above-mentioned challenges, the overall fiscal stance — including the impact on aggregate demand in 2022 from investment financed by both the national and Union budgets, in particular the Recovery and Resilience Facility — is estimated to be neutral (6). The positive contribution of expenditure financed by Recovery and Resilience Facility grants and other Union funds is projected to decrease by 0,3 percentage point of GDP. Nationally financed investment is projected to provide an expansionary contribution of 0,2 percentage point of GDP (7). Nationally financed primary current expenditure (net of discretionary revenue measures) is projected to provide an expansionary contribution of 0,2 percentage point of GDP.

(18) The quality of Member States’ budgetary measures appears particularly important. Fiscal structural reforms aimed at improving the composition of national budgets can support potential growth, create much-needed fiscal space and help to ensure fiscal sustainability over the longer term, including in view of climate change and health challenges. On the revenue side, the COVID-19 crisis has reinforced the importance of reforms for more efficient and fairer public revenue systems. On the expenditure side, it has made it even more crucial to increase the level and quality of sustainable and growth-enhancing investments, in a manner consistent with serving the objectives of enhancing growth potential, economic and social resilience and the green and digital twin transition. The national recovery and resilience plans will allow improving the composition of national budgets.

(19) According to the 2021 Stability Programme’s medium-term budgetary plans, the general government deficit is planned to decrease from 4,4 % in 2023, to 3,9 % in 2024, 3,5 % in 2025, 3,2 % in 2026. The general government deficit is planned to no longer exceed 3 % of GDP in 2027 when it will reach 2,8 % of GDP. Based on the 2021 Stability Programme, the overall fiscal stance — including the impact on aggregate demand from investment financed by both the national and Union budgets, in particular the Recovery and Resilience Facility — is estimated at 0,4 % of GDP in 2023 and 2024 on average. The programme does not include the information required to estimate the contributions of Union-financed expenditure, nationally financed investment and nationally financed primary current expenditure to the overall fiscal stance. The current estimate of the 10-year average nominal potential growth is 2 ¼ % (8). However, this estimate does not include the impact of the reforms that are part of the recovery and resilience plan and could therefore boost France’s potential growth.

(20) The general government debt ratio is planned to increase from 117,2 % of GDP in 2023 to 118,0 % in 2024 and to 118,3 % of GDP in 2025, before reducing to 118,2 % and 117,7 % of GDP in 2026 and 2027, respectively. In light of the high debt ratio, which is projected to only gradually fall over time, France is considered to face high fiscal sustainability risks over the medium term, as per the latest debt sustainability analysis.

(21) In view of the currently still exceptionally high degree of uncertainty, the fiscal policy guidance should remain predominantly qualitative. More precise quantified guidance for the later years should be provided in 2022, if the degree of uncertainty has sufficiently declined by then.

(22) The Council has assessed the 2021 Stability Programme and the follow-up by France to the Council Recommendation of 20 July 2020,

HEREBY RECOMMENDS FRANCE TO:

1. In 2022, use the Recovery and Resilience Facility to finance additional investment in support of the recovery while pursuing a prudent fiscal policy. Preserve nationally financed investment.

2. When economic conditions allow, pursue a fiscal policy aimed at achieving prudent medium-term fiscal positions and ensuring fiscal sustainability in the medium term. At the same time, enhance investment to boost growth potential.

3. Pay particular attention to the composition of public finances, on both the revenue and expenditure sides of the budget, and to the quality of budgetary measures in order to ensure a sustainable and inclusive recovery. Prioritise sustainable and growth-enhancing investment, in particular investment supporting the green and digital transition. Give priority to fiscal structural reforms that will help provide financing for public policy priorities and contribute to the long-term sustainability of public finances, including, where relevant, by strengthening the coverage, adequacy and sustainability of health and social protection systems for all.

Done at Luxembourg, 18 June 2021. For the Council The President J. LEÃO

(1) OJ L 209, 2.8.1997, p. 1.

(2) Council Regulation (EC) No 1467/97 of 7 July 1997 on speeding up and clarifying the implementation of the excessive deficit procedure (OJ L 209, 2.8.1997, p. 6)

(3) Council Recommendation of 20 July 2020 on the 2020 National Reform Programme of France and delivering a Council opinion on the 2020 Stability Programme of France (OJ C 282, 26.8.2020, p. 62).

(4) Regulation (EU) 2021/241 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 12 February 2021 establishing the Recovery and Resilience Facility (OJ L 57, 18.2.2021, p. 17).

(5) In particular, the four-year smoothing of investment used in the expenditure benchmark does not allow for the proper assessment of the fiscal support for the recovery provided by nationally financed investments.

(6) A negative sign of the indicator corresponds to an excess of the primary expenditure growth compared with medium-term economic growth, which indicates an expansionary fiscal policy.

(7) Other nationally financed capital expenditure is projected to provide a neutral contribution.

(8) Estimated by the Commission, in accordance with the commonly agreed methodology.