He is the life and soul of the community, his congregation just love him. So when he accidentally shoots and kills his wife Janet while carrying some guns upstairs in their own home, the good folk of Vincent are heartbroken. But the police suspect that there’s something not quite right about Tim Tillman, and decide to dig deeper. They discover that the popular pastor has been living a double life. There’s evidence of a long-term, long-distance affair and a criminal history. But there’s no hard evidence linking him to the murder of his wife. Two years of meticulous police work lead to his arrest and eventual conviction in 2009.