Judgment — ECLI:EU:C:2004:598
Date: 2004-10-07
Language of the case: French
Court formation: Second Chamber
Based on: Treaty establishing the European Economic Community (1957)
Subject matter: Environment;External relations;Pollution
Concepts: General;Environment;The various agreements concluded by the Community
Procedure: Action for failure to fulfil obligations - successful
Origin: France

Summary of the Judgment 1. Actions for failure to fulfil obligations – Action for a declaration that a Member State has failed to comply with a mixed agreement concluded by the Community and the Member States – Protocol for the protection of the Mediterranean Sea against pollution from land-based sources – Jurisdiction of the Court – Admissible (Art. 226 EC; Barcelona Convention, Arts 4(1) and 8; Protocol for the protection of the Mediterranean Sea against pollution from land-based sources, Art. 6(1) and (3)) 2. International agreements – Community agreements – Protocol for the protection of the Mediterranean Sea against pollution from land-based sources – Obligation on the States to limit such pollution – Scope (Protocol for the protection of the Mediterranean Sea against pollution from land-based sources, Art. 6(1) and (3)) 1. The application of Articles 4(1) and 8 of the Barcelona Convention for the protection of the Mediterranean Sea against pollution and Article 6(1) and (3) of the Protocol for the protection of the Mediterranean Sea against pollution from land-based sources to discharges of fresh water and alluvia into a saltwater marsh falls within the Community framework, even though such discharges have not been the subject of specific Community legislation, since those articles are in mixed agreements concluded by the Community and its Member States and concern a field in large measure covered by Community law. The Court therefore has jurisdiction to assess a Member State’s compliance with those articles in proceedings brought before it under Article 226 EC. Mixed agreements concluded by the Community, its Member States and non-member countries have the same status in the Community legal order as purely Community agreements in so far as the provisions fall within the scope of Community competence. In ensuring compliance with commitments arising from an agreement concluded by the Community institutions, the Member States therefore fulfil, within the Community system, an obligation in relation to the Community, which has assumed responsibility for the due performance of the agreement. (see paras 25-26, 31) 2. Article 6(1) of the Protocol for the protection of the Mediterranean Sea against pollution from land-based sources, in conjunction with Article 1 thereof, imposes a particularly rigorous obligation on the Contracting Parties, namely an obligation to limit strictly, by appropriate measures, pollution from land-based sources in the area caused by discharges of, inter alia, any substances even of a non-toxic nature which may become harmful to the marine environment. The strictness of this obligation reflects the nature of the instrument, which is designed in particular to avoid pollution caused by the failure of the public authorities to act. The scope of the obligation must be construed in the light of Article 6(3) of the Protocol which, by setting up a regime of prior authorisation by the competent national authorities of the discharge of substances referred to in Annex II to the Protocol, requires the Member States to control pollution from land-based sources in the area to which the Protocol applies. Accordingly, a Member State which fails to take all appropriate measures to prevent, abate and combat heavy and prolonged pollution of the Mediterranean Sea area, and which fails to take account of the requirements of Annex III to the Protocol concerning the authorisation regime for discharges of those substances by not amending its national arrangements following the conclusion of the Protocol, fails to fulfil its obligations under inter alia Article 6(1) and (3) of the Protocol. (see paras 50-51, operative part)