davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
Evening star., 1949-04-26
6lri Photographic, Fined S.
In Night Club Dispute

AkA<4 gstseaeSg sssasg At tfps ! "a
FSss asA1a YESTERDAY Was Gxz~s
- tsx hcSnx GgsSwSssg y an ewv
rasfai x$ae seaa
szgSxGtx sS ssss1ss1ssE ~
fNsSaserzHaa n r CAs8A IN NJ.
raaS4Ess.l g>esSgt. Mas fssaoea AsvsH
= lkpo1 FtStaTvs as hszz 4Esa hss
waie ~ aaey wtgv reasasAl2nS sssrSf
;c,asTtls @x44@afsk KEssesesass - t2ss
tSssgzs SATURDAY nlEl7g
&hxn tfss ~z<aAn sts&sTsrSa ~gss
.tss rngssssS9 81 afslA . aGas$4ls assssw
sscf t3as n4gness# asvseg~1 Il las
essagst - 1T R4gy4narat~ FNR.
Gkatsas testified AaAs Aeest
sgaA{e taeS4 1sst pass4gTs h&sk &Na3
rs4gSsa tts YAfts
Az gntaA Saa }Ag,ss ssAAFKN shss
p,arss aSAsasa M4ss Atesy ht tlsF
or~t1sEy peS'kxaakn Nas dismissed
es .1Gksse Seasl, Stte accepted lsrg
eacnteut4oa tktas Nsss SAs sSsNr,
Tx defendant .3tes - tAss is@o
block q. Iwentklh ssScet y W.
Evening star., 1949-04-26

the information was to be used to
the injury Of the United States
and to the advantage Of q foreign
power"
Dismissal Motion Denied.
Judge Reeves brushed aside
the contention Of Defense Coun-
SCI that the indictment is invalid
because o majority Of the grand
Jurors who voted for 1t last month
were Government employees. He
dismissed the motion.
Mr.. Palmer expressed amaze
ment that 10 out Of the $50 We
niremen currently available for
jury service In District Court are
Government employees.
Evening star., 1949-04-26
Beayerbrook AssaiIs
Cold -5houIdering' o|
Duchess by Royalty
L. 80 a,.na as.s.sa tax.a

LONDON, April - "A n~@ pro
tess agains royal cold ssscal<ars-
tng" cf the Dsaehrss es w2raas<r
was seacca Last n1glss by t&sFd
Beasesevook , Eswrsas Standard
A few fsoarx earlier TIE toruatr
Wallis wayssead Sanspsoa ard asf
husband. Gree England Edward
WIZ. returned 10 France from a
socially xsal 10 dsys in st,e Essg las,,
countryside,
SAd a Standard caislmanlss Slas
has gone away without beanx r..
eeised In royal circles Thls IN a
fact which. ] an sure, is regretted
by the people generally
Declared Innocent Party"
Throughout the /. years q. her.
marriage 10 the Duke. this Amer
lean lady has behaved with dignity
True. sae has bern married be-
fore: but she Was tfe snaoSrng
party In the divorce proceedings
that ended her marriage 10 Mt
Ernest Simpson.
In royal circles q dlSilne ,aon Is
drawn between the innocent ana
the guilty Tn divorce.
The innocent are not aeealre<i
from the royal inelosure al Aseot
the guilty are.
Nevertheless. several persons
are recognized by the royal fam.
lily who have been the. guilty
parties. Last week. SIR Laurence
and Lady Olivier ~ere in a small
private party with Princess Eliza
beth and Prince Philip.
Few Jeiners for Crusade.
SO II Is hardly consistent that
the Duchess Of Windsor should be
excluded from the eourtesies ex~
tended TO those who have been d.
sorced."
The Standard had suggested The
day before the Duchess arrived in
England that the cold shoulder
ing" should stop II found no
jolners for Its crusade. however,
Actress Jill Esmond divorced
Olivier In 1910 Miss Leigh's mar.
riage 10 a London barr.ster waS
dissolved the same year. The
marriage OF the oliviers followed
q few months later.
Evening star., 1949-04-26
Sullivan OffersNew Resignation
ToProtest Hating { Corrier Work

o letter 10 the SECRETARY O. IN
tense inouirtng about II,
Backed sy vinssa and Camsen.
Two HOUSE committee chair
man. Representative vinson O!
Armed Services and Representa-
tive Cannon Of Appropriations.
approved Mr.. johnson stand.
Mr.. vinson. who In past years
Was one Of the strongest defend
ers OF the Navy. said
The Navy with this big carrier
would have been trespassing into
the field Of strategic ooEnhing.
which belongs 10 the Air Force "
Mr.. Cannon declared the huge
iiattop would have been a sitting
duck for enemy oosnoers and
submarines.
Secretary johnson says he
acted after receiving the views
Of the Joint Chiefs Of stan. who
are the military chiefs OF the sery-
ices. plus Gen. Eisenhower. Ac-
tually. the Secretary asked them
to review the matter last week
after the formal keel-laying Of
the carrier had attracted public
attention. He was told then they
had not previously approved II,
What seems to have happened
Is this:
The Joint Chiefs did approve
some time ago the split In air
craft procurement by which both
Air Force and Navy we're author
lied to buy airpower The Navy
also had. at that time authorixa-
tions for about IL vessels. inelud-
Ing the battleship Kentucky. a
sister ship Of the Missouri
Last year the Navy told the
Senate committee II would not
build those vessels. thus freeing
tonnage for the aircraft carrier
that they deemed more desirable.
The Senators consented TO the
switch and authorized what ad-
ditional tonnage the carrier re-
quired.
Senators suggest that the Navy
may have, assumed 1t had the
tacit consent Of the Joint Chiefs
to buy It's airpower In whatever
form 1t thought most desirable.
They can see that the Navy would
view this as an internal matter.
not one which had to be reviewed
by the Joint Chiefs.
1t Is recalled that former De-
tense Secretary Forrestal testified
that he. the Navy and the Budget
Bureau had approved the carrier.
but he did not mention the Joint
Chiefs. Mr.. Forrestal. incidentally.
had also approved 1t when Sec
retary Of the Navy: he was In q
sense umpiring his own ball game
The Joint Chiefs report has
not been made public. They are
understood to feel that since the
President Is limiting the defense
budget. the carrier. whose eventual
cost and usefulness are both
highly conjectural. can be omitted.
Evening star., 1949-04-26
Labor.
Continued From First Pase.>


bated under q rule permitting
eight hours of general speech
making. Thereafter. 1t win be
open for amendment. with each
speech limited to five minutes. AT
this point the Republicans and
Southern Democrats supporting
the Wood bill will move to SUBJ
stitute 1t.
Minority Leader Martin pre-
dicted most Republicans would
vote for the substitute.
He warned. moreover. that II the
substitute is voted down, the
House viii be occupied at least 10
days in considering amendments
to the Lesinski bill.
Essentially. that measure would
kin the Taft-Hartley Act and re-
enact most Of the old Wagner Act
with some changes recommended
by President Truman.
Evening star., 1949-04-26
Continued From First Page

white House Is soon after his re-
turn a. he could check person
ally On the facts
He Is understood to feel that
the abandonment Of the carrier
In one thing. but that the dosns
of II without prior consultation
with the service concerned II
something else again Both 10y
atty to his service and his own
self-respecs are said TO have die
tated the new communication.
MAY Accept kesignatiea.
The President early last eve
ming had not made Up his mind
what 70 do about II. He Is re-
luetsnt to lose Mr.. Sullivan. But
probably in the interests Of har-
mony at the Pentagon he will ac-
cept the resignation.
The Navy Secretary is an excel
lent executive. . good Democrat
and personally popular st the
White House. But he does not
like what Is being done 70 the
Navy, and all hands know 1t. So
long a. present Developments were
but o gieam In the columnists
eyes, he kept quiet. The order and
the manner Of Its issue have
brought action.
Cancellation OF the carrier.
whose eventual cost has been esti-
mated to reach more than $780,
900, 900. Is Mr.. Johnson's first big
test rs q strategist. an executive
and Q Judge Of public opinion. The
Sullivan reaction indicates that
he has failed In tact. which ad-
mittedly Is not his strong point.
What he has done. however. Is
to act swiftly and courageously in
the long dispute between the Air
Force and Navy over what targets
naval aircraft should attack In .
war. The Air Force has con-
tended that the Navy should not
have . carrier big enough for
heavy bombers. that heavy bomb
ing was the Air Forces Job.
The johnson decision repre-
sents q tremendous victory for the
Air Force. The President ap-
proved 1t, but 1t may be examined
by the Senate Armed Services
Committee.
Senator Gurney. ranking Re-
publican. reminded the committee
in executive session yesterday that
Congress had authorized the
Navy to build the giant carrier
and was kept fully informed re-
earding 1t. He demanded an air
ins Of all the circumstances Of
the cancellation.
However, the committee chair
man. Senator Tydinss, Democrat.
Of Maryland. said that he re-
garded the johnson decision as
final.
But II any committee member
wants more information on It,"
he said. II will be glad to address
Evening star., 1949-04-26
Gambling
Continued From First PaseJ

barred the telephone company
from removing the phone under
any conditions. He said that was
broader than his earlier ruling
which referred only to restraining
the telephone company from re-
moving the phone on the basii
Of q letter from Mr.. Fay.
Judge Pine had made the point
In his earlier opinion that the
telephone company might have
sufficient evidence Of Maryland law
violations on the basis Of what was
brought out during the Injunction
hearing to remove the phone on
the company's own initiative. He
said at the time he had seen nc
evidence to show the phone was
being used to violate District
gaming laws.
After turning down q proposed
order handed him by Assistant
United States Attorney Ross
ODonoghue as well rs the one
prepared by Mr.. Miller's counsel
Myron Enrich. Judge Pine told
the lawyers ITO. get together and
prepare q new order for his sigma
ture later today.
A short time later, the lawyers
conferred and said agreement had
been reached on n draft that was
expected to meet the judge q
specifications.
Fay Delays Decision.
Mr.. Fay said earlier he would
not make q decision on appealing
the Injunction suit until he sees
the wording Of the order Judge
Pine signs.
Mr.. Miller was the first Of scores
Of telephone subscribers to 90 into
court to save their telephones after
Mr.. Fay notified the telephone
company he had competent evil
dence" the phones Of 324 SUBJ
scribers have been used for gam
bling.
In Maryland. 23 telephone SUBJ
scribers have petitioned the Pub
lie Service Commission for orders
restraining the telephone company
from stopping their service.
The telephone company 1iled IL
answers to complaints Of these
subscribers yesterday. One other
answer was filed late last week
ANA several more are expected In
the next few days, The commits
sion ID not expected to decide what
action it will take until al the
answers are in.
In the latest answers. t0e tele-
phone company told the commits
sion its action in notifying SUBJ
scribers their phones would be
removed was based on advice from
Mr.. Fay
Evening star., 1949-04-26

Of the service Of these gentlemen
and Of some others mentioned In
the article, I feel confident that
all OF the newspapermen listed
served with diligence In the vari-
Gus code departments and !ofices
of the elected officials In which
they were employed. '
y at seems u me grossly unfair
to- these men to insinuate that
there was anything improper In
their employment. The State must
choose its administrators from the
competent business and profes-
sional man Of the STATE snd surely
those whose experiencea - IN the
publishing business should not be
excluded from public service"
Comment sf Editors.
Comments Of the editors when
asked what they did for the money
paid to them follow:
Robert L. Stubbs. Illinois State
Register. Springfield. $5.260-"I
wrote quite q few speeches Tor
Gov. Green"
Victor L. Smith. Argus. Robin
son, $l7.53o-"I was an investiga :
tor on gasoline tax for the State
revenue department. Had 10
counties"
verle w. Kramer, Warsaw Bull
letin, Warsaw. Slo.s33-"I report
ed on different telephone compan-
les to the Commerce Commission
Lewis A. Randolph. Macomb
Journal, Macomb, t5,500-"Walter
Rosenfield Estate director Of pub
lie works and buildings) asked me
II I'd like to do some writing on
safety. I did"
Sam Little. Hillsboro Journal.
Hillsboro, e1o,747-"I worked on
CO. ordinating al the newspapers
Evening star., 1949-04-26
Hoover
t.Gcontinued .Tlosua sxIfst f1seD'

are just as much . burden on
our national economy ~ any
other Government expenditure" !"
The former President suggested
covering more people under the
present social security system and
increasing grants to. States for
helping the needy, but he called
for q drastic change in financing
the system.
He suggested that 1t should 20
on "pay-as-you-go" basis
eliminating further accumulation
of the social security trust fund.
It is presently about 10000, 900, :
600.
He said under the trust fund the
social security beneficiaries actu-
ally pay twice for their benefits
He said the Government spend,
the trust fund and substitutes
Government bonds or II. O. US
for the money. then later redeems
the bonds out Of tax money"
Mr.. Hoover proposed establish
ing an independent research
body" to conduct . years study
of ID Federal old-age and retire.
ment. t2) State aid to needy. and
CD such independent" security
systems as veterans. civil service
railroad, private insurance and
company-union BENEFITS.
"A careful study" he said
might disclose an entirely differ
ent system which would avoid the
huge costs Of administration and
the duplication"
His letter was In response to Mr.,
Doughton's request for comment,
Evening star., 1949-04-26

Madagascar now prohibits ad-
mittance Of children under 16 to
theaters unless accompanied by.
adults.
Evening star., 1949-04-26

from Carlinville south to Cairo.
assisting those needing help on
legal publications. Yeah. We
printed news and editorials from
Green headquarters"
H. B. Smith. Independent. New
man. on payroll for total Of si2.-
372 as a field investigator In High
way DiyisionAa'1 worked In the
Multigrnph Division Called on
newspapers" sa
w. H. Thomas. Mount Morris
Index, treasurers investigator, $50
. month--"My duties we're very
light. I'd sooner mot tell. what
they were" t-e-s r~-t.
Got Raise In Pay.
Harold J. cruger. Elmhurst
Leader and other DuPage County
newspapers. superintendent Of
printing! acted In executive
capacity. I let State contracts
and bought all the paper. The
salary was $500 to start. and
later $500
William z. Beck. jr., Whiteside
Sentinel. Morrison. clerk in au-
ditor's once. s2.250-'My pay
.x ~x1nr that ao..ra II Was
about 1880. I inspected mort
cages and things in the court
house"
John o. benson. News Dis
patch. Minonk. messenger. Vet
erans' Commission. S4s37o--"I did
publicity work"
Bernard L. White, Republican.
watseka. clerk. auditors ONCE.
81, 3,85o--"My duties7 Just check
ing. There wasn't much work
Evening star., 1949-04-26
CHRISTIAN SCIENCE
READING ROOMS

kkAOiNO kOOMt
iSoI ia.. NV q
1874 csnasstiev, Ave-. nv
III E S.. Nc
tAth and o Sta. NV
col esisrsss siss
18th 81. and Psvk Resd. NV
s,sss ssss ssss.
! l67e Wlsssnsin Ave, NV q
t5iy 4 S.. NV
wAsARseroN
Also Christian Science Reading
Rooms In Bsthesda. Hsa,sssitis.
Silver sprias. Alexandra, Aslsns-
sen. and sthS nearby eommans-
ts~s.
Iaf~mstiss sercsvriss fyss pub
lie Lectures. sAlgyA services. sas
ether CArisf,aa Scisaos sesaafsss
10 asailahls in these Reems-
Evening star., 1949-04-26

-. - ~. NJ. q -. ---.,...
Evening star., 1949-04-26

the task Of qualifying the jury.
At the request OF Mr.. Palmer,
Judge Reeves asked the prospec-
tive Jurors II they would draw any
inference Of guilt from the fact
that Miss Coplon knew the Soviet
engineer, Gubitchev, and that =
social relationship existed be-
tween them" -
eve don't deny It." Palmer said.
Judy Coplon is going TO get on
the witness stand and tell you al
about 1t. The defendant was with
this man many times"
Assumes Lack of Prejudice.
None Of the prospective jurors
made . move after Judge Reeves
put the question and he said he
would assume. by their silence that
the DEFENDANTS relationship with
the Soviet engineer would not
create any prejudice n their
minds.
Mr.. Palmer then asked the Judge
to determine whether any Of the
prospective jurors had any feeling
against the Russian people because
Of newspaper information they
may have read about strained
relations between this country and
Russia. The jurors. by their silence.
again indicated they had no feel
ing on the subject.
The trial began yesterday and
most Of the session was con-
sumed with arguments over Z
defense motion to dismiss the in
dictment. charging that the At
tractive defendant removed secret
documents from Government fiel
with intent and reason 70 eeiieva
, 1949-09-16
MODERN ETIQUETTE
Q. When writing a social let
by Roberta Lee

@. When writing a social let
ter, is it proper to close the letter
with Respectfully yours?
A. No. This form is used only
when writing business letters, or
when an employee is writing to
his employer. If the person is of
eqqual social position, it would be
better to close the letter with "Sin-
cerely yours.
@. If one is asked to fill in at
the last moment, and the circum-
stances are plausibly explained,
should one accept?
A. Yes, and without hesitation,
if free to do So.
Q. Is it all right tot use the fork
for taking butter from the butter
plate?
A. No; if there is no butter
knife provided, use the tip of the
eating knife.
, 1949-09-16
LESSON in ENGLISH
by w. L. Gordon
Words Often Misused

Words Often Misused
Do not say. 1T is not as large as
we thought. Say 1T is not SO
large as we thought" Use so after
a negative.
Often Mispronounced
Thames english river). Pro-
nounce temz, e as in men.
Often Misspelled
Foul (impure). Fowl (bird).
synonyms
Conquer, defeat, subdue, sub
jugate, surmount, overpower, over
come, vanqquish.
Word Study
"Use a word three times and it is
yours" Let us increase our vocab-
ulary by mastering one word each
day. Today's word:
PREJUDICIAL; tending to injury;
damaging. "His going away was
most preiudial to the affairs Of
his business"
, 1949-09-16
WoMEN's

law regarding the removal OF
garbage which could be pro-
perly enforced.
Mr.. de Castro said further,
without an adequate law to
control the putting out of gar
bage and its disposal and with
out better equipment, the inn
mediate transfer would not re-
suit in any improvement in the
existing situation. He said,
however, that every effort is
being made by the Administra-
ton within the limits of its IA
cilities to improve conditions
and that a draft of a law or ap-
propriate rules and regulations
will shortly be sent to the Mu-
nicipal Council for considera-
ton.
, 1949-09-16
COUNCIL

O0ONN4A
their determination to have a
showdown on the issue.
TIE controversy grew out
of a letter sent to the Council
by Herbert Haywood, protest
ing the School Boards action
in dropping him from the
faculty of the Christiansted
High School for misconduct
and asking that the matter be
investigated.
The Council sent an invita-
ton to the Board to discuss
the matter with them in COM
mittee of the Whole; when the
members failed to show up
the lawmakers authorized the
Chairman to issue subpoenas.
The second set of subpoenas
require their presence today.
The Key West citizen. [volume] (Key West, Fla.) 1879-current, 1949-04-29
CLASS "B"
Bamboo Room To
Play VX-l Flyers
Softball Tonight
(Bayview Park
CLASS "A"


Softball games scheduled for
tonight at Bayview Park are, in
the first game, the Bamboo Room
will tackle the VGI Flyers and
in the. nightcap the Blimp Ron
will play the Naval Hospital.
In the first game, the Bamboo
Room will go into first place or
tied with the Veterans in last
place and the Flyers will go to
first place or if they lose tie with
Adams Dairy for second place.
So the fans can see what this
game means to both clubs. The
Flyers will depend on Henson,
who shut out the Adams with,
only three hits. last Tuesday and
The Bamboo Room will start out
with diminutive Claude Valdez,
who has lots of stuff and speed
when right.
Valdez may be right tonight.
The fans know the rest OF the
club and they need no introduc-
ton. This game will start at 7:30
p. m.
In the nightcap the Blimp Ron
will play the Naval Hospital.
This game also should be a cork
er, for the loser will sink into
the cellar and the winner will 20
into a tie for second place with
the OP-DEV-STA. 1t may be
Martin that speed ball artist and
Butch or Brister for the Blimp
boys and those Blimps sure fly
nigh sometime and when they
come to earth, just look out.
The Key West citizen. [volume] (Key West, Fla.) 1879-current, 1949-04-29
Key Yesters
Invited To Naval
Baseball Game

Residens of KEY West are in
vited to attend baseball game
between he Fleet All Weather
Training Bnit, Atlantic, and the
Universitl of Miami Frosh at the
Naval Bae baseball field Satur-
day, Apra 80 at 2:30 in the af-
ternoon, ccording to Lieutenant
N. G. Knox, officer in charge of
the team
The FMtulant team was the
southern district champions of
the ComAirLant play-off in Nor
folk, Virginia, last year. From all
reports, he University of Miami
Frosh has a powerful team this
year ant should prove to be
strong competition Tor the raw
tulant team.
Lieutenant Knox plans to use
The Key West citizen. [volume] (Key West, Fla.) 1879-current, 1949-04-29

kinks out of the routine that most
couples experience when they
haven't golf courses available.
Frankly, I'm looking for a
swell turnout of couples ] this
summer. The old place could
stand few more doubles hoof-
in it around during the summer
golf slump that apparently moves
in on every course this time of
the year.
The Key West citizen. [volume] (Key West, Fla.) 1879-current, 1949-04-29
LUsITANIA LIFEBo
TO BE MOVED S

BROADSIAIRS. Engl11d--
gAP)-The village council has de-.
cided 70 move its principal ubnu-
ment. a hfeboat from the Inflated
liner Lusitasia. Brought to this
southeastern England resort
years ago as . n7efnehto of the
tragic sinking of the Liner, the
lifeboat Is to be shifted 10 -
more suitable spot These are
the reasons given BY The council
ors:
Visitors who arrive In q fes-
tive spirit do not want 10 see the
town decorated with dead mems
RATS L is nearly 80 years since
this sad tragedy of the sea occur
red and there have been even
worse horrors in the late war. II
is menace and a danger to the
children who play in e."
The Key West citizen. [volume] (Key West, Fla.) 1879-current, 1949-04-29
DODGERS TOP LEAGUE
BY DEFEATING GIANTS
Yankees Keep Up
Torrid Pace In
American; Red Sox
Beat Athletics
ss,ceioI 10 TAe C.slsen,


NEW YORK, April 29.-Brook-
lyn Dodgers went to the top Of
the National League standings
yesterday by slugging out 10 TO
2 victory over the New York
Giants.
The New York Yankees in the
American kept up their hot pace
by defeating the Washington
Senator's, 6 2, for their eighth
win against two losses.
Boston Red Sox won yesterday
over Philadelphia Athletics, II to
5, being paced by Ted Williams.
st. Louis Browns beat the Detroit
Tigers, 8 to 6, despite a home run
by Johnny Groth, Detroit's sem
sational young outfielder.
Boston Braves won yesterday
from the Phillies, 6 i; St. Louis
Cardinals beat the Pittsburgh Pr
rates, 4-2, while the Cincinnati
Reds whipped the Chicago Cubs,
20.
The scores:
The Key West citizen. [volume] (Key West, Fla.) 1879-current, 1949-04-29

BEAUMONT, r. x. = (AP) -
Following the rough s.airpiane
flight of the Brooklyn Dodgers
from Vero Beach, Fla, to this
city, "a new type of salesman
showed UP at their hotel. He had
pill to prevent motion sick
ness. The Dodgers declined with
thanks.
The Key West citizen. [volume] (Key West, Fla.) 1879-current, 1949-04-29

his star pitcher and says he has
the team in fine condition for
the game.
Flee All Weather Training Unit
Atlantic is commanded by Com
mander w. E. Ellis. USN.
The Key West citizen. [volume] (Key West, Fla.) 1879-current, 1949-04-29
SENIOR SOFTBALL
(BaYview Park. Night !

First Game: 1880
FRIDAY
7:30-Bamboo Room VS.. VX-l
Flyers.
9:O0-Blimp Ron VS.. Naval Hos
pital. Y
MAY 3
First-Naval Hospital VS.. In
dependents.
Second-Bamboo Room VS..
Adams Dairy.
MAY g.
First-BlimpRon VS.. Op-Dev-
Sta.
Second VFW VS.. VXI
MAY g.
First-BlimpRon VS.. Indepen-
dents.
Second-Bamboo Room VS..
VIEW.
MAY =
First-Naval Hospital VS.. OPP
Dev-Sta.
Second-Adams Dairy VS.. VXI.
SKATING
Bayview Park. Night
FRIDAY
7:30 to 900 pm. l.
TENNIS
BaYview Park. Afternoons +.
and Nights ~
Daily play.
SHUFFLEBOARD
lBaYvisw parkl
Daily play.
The Key West citizen. [volume] (Key West, Fla.) 1879-current, 1949-04-29

The kodiak bear. a species dis
covered on Kodiak Island in 1895,
is the largest and the American.
which is increasing in numbers
because it has been protected BY
law