The Hardin tribune-herald. [volume] (Hardin, Mont.) 1925-1973, 1943-06-10

tanned a promise from Chairman
May of the Military Affairs commit
tee for immediate hearings on his
amendment to the Selective Service
act and the block McNutt' move
was loon heavily under way.
AS you know. Representative Kill
days bill is aimed to make depend
ency the basic cause Of deferment
while McNutt's move was to estab.
lish participation in the war effort
in field. factory or the armed forces
as the principle governing the order
of induction.
McNutt's order set the boys in the
non-eSSential businesses hammering
at the doors of the United States
Employment offices all over the
country and CONSERVATION and con-
fusion reigned.
Then up spoke Mr. Kilday. The
attitude of those favoring the meas
ure to draft the single men first. ev-
erywhere. before the married men
and the others with dependents 60,
is this: They say they do not want
the Selective Service act made a
weapon to force men into essential
jobs. They claim the act was never
SO intended.
Legislation, they say, must be
passed after careful study which will
/ lay down a manpower program;
military service is an honor as well
as a duty. 1t must not be used as a
threat.
KIaay's Vews
talked with Representative Kill
day before the hearings began.
He was optimistic ever Cuicl; COM
mittee acceTt;nce Ct his bill though
he said he didn't want to hurry the
hearings and he realized all sorts of
opposition might develop. He point
ed out that his would not
alter the present deferments, that it
doesn't mean. as some seemed to
think. that single men. deferred
under the present deferment rules,
will be yanked out Of their jobs and
thrown into the army. Opponents
say. however, in some cases. this
will be the actual effect.
Whatever the effects on agricul.
ture and industry may be if the bill
passes. it will sink the present Man.
power commission program without
a trace and with all hands or board.
There is plenty of public appeal in
the Kilday measurable argument
that it is more important to keep the
family together than to fill quotas
for industry or the army and the
navy, the argument that there is no
authority in the Selective Service act
to do what the Manpower commits
sion order is aimed to achieve,
namely, to state what job a mar is
to hold. And that side of the argu-
ment has particular appeal in a con-
gress exceedingly jealous of its pre-
negatives, sworn to prevent usurpa-
ton Of its powers by the admins
trative branch.
A Prediction
Last week. | reported the predic-
ton by a keen observer of this whole
problem to the effect that one more
desperate measure would be at
tempted by tie NanpoWer commits
sion before it would be forced to step
aside for some other agency McNutt
acted, and within "a hours of that
prediction, the military affairs com
r3ittee announced hearings on the
Kilday bill, looks very much like a
bird of i'll omen echoing the second
part of the dire predict!on-the end
of the ManpoWer commission as an
agency with any power of initiative
left. To many high army officials,
there is grim satisfaction in what is
happening. Long ago, it was init
mated that sooner or later the mill
tary would have to take over the
whip hand and settle the manpoWer
question in its WI way. Some mill
tary men would be quite happy to
have the Kilday measure pass.
sweep everyone draftable into the
armed forces and then do it's own re-
ALLEGATION. screening out the men
necessary 10 industry and agricul-
ture and furlough them back as mill
tary needs. first and the industry's,
second, demanded.
One a imagine. however, how
union labor would like to see khaki
and navy blue manning the stamp
ing machines and the lathes beside
the Workingmen in civvies. Labor's
objection to the bill was expected
from the first.
And so We have a four-way clash:
Legislators. Manpower commission,
Military, Labor.
Once more. a labor draft looms
as the headlines say.