davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-02-04

THE LLOYD Y. BARTLEYS
are co-Chairmen Of the Valentine
Dinner Dance which will be run
Oft at the Detroit Golf Club the
evening OF the fourteenth when
scores Of dreSSv folk Will surge
into the place 10 dine AT Z and
dance from Q until ] a. m. to f..
John Stewards orchestra
with a fashion parade sand
wiched-in somewhere along the
line.
Assisting the BartleyS al their
gracious tasks as patrons and
patronesseS you'll find
Mr.. and Mrs. Carl Brecr Mr.
and Mrs. Howard A. Coffin. Mr.
and Mrs. Marvin f. Coyle. Mr..
and Mrs. Francis c. DittriCh
Mr. and Mrs. John J German.
Mr. and Mrs. Howard T. GRADER.
Mayor and Mrs Edward J.
Jeffries Jr. Judge and Mrs.
Arthur j. Lacy. Mr.. and Mrs
Harry a. Mcdonald. Mr.. and
Mrs. Vaughan Reid. Mr.. and
Mrs T. Melville Rinehart, Or.
and Mrs. Henry r. Steinbach.
Mr.. and Mrs. 6 A. Strickland
Mr.. and Mrs. William A Sells.
Mr. and Mrs. Donald r. Valley
and Or. and Mrs. Harold Hen
derSon
Bids 10 same feature an aste-
risk which reveals the legend:
The Fashion Show will CON
tain quite an element Of surprise
and interest for the men,"
Hmm-m-m
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-02-04
Miss TooIin,
Friends Back

BY JACK OLIVER

THAT BRIEF but merry be-
tween semester vacation for
Miss Barbara Toolin and friends
has come to a close and today
finds them arriving back at
Marymount Junior College and
cracking open those somewhat
neglected books.
Miss Toolin, daughter of the
j. M. Toolins of Grayton road,
brought back from school her
two roommates,' Miss Mary Jane
O'Reilley of St. Louis. Mo. and
Miss Clair Mclaughlin of Fair
field, Conn, and they've all been
experiencing a most gratifying
whirl.
The Toolins, who bade fare
well to this trio Tuesday evening
when they left for Tarrytown,
n, Y. will be seeing their daugh-
ter next Easter when she comes
home for another short stay.
BUSTING OFF 10 the East
this week are Mr.. and Mrs.
George Renchard Of Arden Park
who are bent, first, on several
days whirl in New York City.
From there, they'll move on TO
Washington, y. c.. for a visit
with their son and daughter-in-
law. Mr.. and Mrs. George Rem
chard Jr., who make the nations
capital their home.
The former Stellita Stapleton
has become periodically emersed
in important Red Cross work
and puts in Seven-hour day
five days a week attending 10
her wartime activities.
JUSTLY THRILLED Young
woman in the Northend is Miss
Virginia Montague C"Monnie" 10
her pals who'll he leaving 10
attend the Notre Dame J-Prom
Friday.
She'll he the guest Of Vern
Pellauchoud and will be ele-
gantly set-off by pale pink net
and silver lame at the JIG.
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19
Determined TO Learn
If She Had Grievance

Holland familiar with the
vagaries Of human nature from
his long experience as a law en-
forcement agent, determined to
see II the Hawleys knew
whether the missing woman had
some grievance, either real or
fancied, that might cause her
TO leave home.
Sixty-year-old Irwin Hawley
and his aging wife assured the
detective that Gertrude had al
ways been entirely devoted to
both Mary Annette and her hus-
band.
Both the HawleyS and the
Moshers lived in Battle Creek,
Mich, and their long standing
friendship caused them each
year to take neighboring houses
at Gulfport for the winter
season.
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19
Hurries 10 Search
Through His House

Mosher. war veteran who
had never wholly recovered from
his combat wounds, nervously
threw on a robe and hurried
through the house hoping
against hope that his wife may
have fallen asleep on the living
room couch.
His l4-year-old daughter,
Mary Annette. awakened by his
frantic stirring. joined him, and
together they scare h ID the
house from cellar 10 garnet.
dog. too, was missing.
After leaving the house, they
stopped at the Hawleys. nearest
neighbors and closest friends.
They were unable 10 throw
any light on the mystery OF Mrs.
Mosher's disappearance because
they had attended a movie and
had returned at IL without see
ing any one they knew.
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19

cause there was so little of IL,
ne found it difficult 10 determine
whether ii was Mrs. Patterson's.
On Friday, November 3,
Prosecutor Johnston ordered an
inquest and asked Frank 4.
Jeanette, Mt. Clemens justice,
to preside.
Here. Coroner Raul again at
tempted TO interfere, declaring
he was going to preside but a
compromise was reached and
Bert V. Will. then the second
county coroner, was named.
Several hundred persons
crowded the small courtroom TO
hear details of the inquest.
The testimony could be con-
sidered damaging but there was
certainly nothing definite link
ing the husband with his wife's
death.
Veteran reporters and invests
gators, expecting verdict say
ing the slayer was unknown.
were shocked the night Of
November "a when Merlyn
Davenport, foreman of the jury
of three men and three women.
declared:
"We find that Mrs. Patter-
son came TO her death from
wounds from q knife in the
hands OF Herbert Patterson"
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19
Broodine Over Misdeed
Finally Snapped His Mind

On Jan. 9. 1910. Hawley was
indicted for first degree murder
but he never has been tried
for the crime.
Confinement and brood Ing
over his misdeed snapped his
mind and he became mentally
incapable of realizing the mean:
ing of a trial.
DR.. II. Mason Smith, engaged
by the state. studied the pris-
oner and eventually reported
that Hawley was hopelessly in
sane and that his condition
would get worse instead of bet
ter with the passage of time.
Today Irwin Hawley stares
with vacant eyes from a barred
cell in Chattahootchee - that
flows from the high Blue Ridge
TO the Gulf of Mexico-and he
is unable TO comprehend its
beauty.
This Is his punishment for
robbing his friend of the COM
paniship and care OF a loving
wife.
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19
Death Prompted
by Jealousy, Robbery

Was her death prompted by
Jealousy? Robbery?
There was no evidence Of at
tack.
AS for robbery, il is true her
purse was open but the two
diamond rings she wore on her
finger were not molested-or
couldn't the slayer rem owe
them?
AS far as could be aScer-
tanned, there were no other men
in Mrs. Patterson's life. The
Patterson couple had lived to-
gether for 25 years and SEEM
ingly happy. according 10 friends
and relatives.
Her death is mystery once
so aptly described AS:
Rich in theory. poor in
clues"
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19
Murderer Shielded
by Morning Mist

But the mist that covered the
slayer's entrance that fateful
morning seems 10 have shielded
him TO this day.
Bad judgment and inexperi-
ence aided the slayer's flight.
state police files reveal.
Roy j. Kaul. local undertaken
and a Mscomb County coroner.
unfortunately assn ed full
charge of the investigation.
Two hours after police arrived.
the Patterson household was
impeccably clean.
Kaul handled funeral and
burial arrangements, too, and ii
wasn't until five hours later that
Ivan Johnston, Macomb County
prosecutor, was notified Of the
murder.
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19
Forced Firmly Back
Into Nearby Chair

Saunders walked up behind
the man and firmly forced him
back into his chair. From under
his arm he took a newspaper
wrapped bundle and laid 1t on
the desk.
Holland opened It slowly and
at the same time watched Haw-
leys eyes bulge.
These three rags were taken
from the nostrils and mouth Of
Mrs. Mosher this morning." ex-
planned Holland to his ashen-
faced visitor.
Notice how neatly they At
the tall OF this bloody shirt
the shirt that was found stuffed
In Che tool compartment of your
automobile by Mr.. Saunders
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19
Body of Attractive Matron
Found Nude, MutiIated

But the case never came to
trial. Johnston had not antici-
pated the jury's verdict and the
verdict was as surprising to him
as IL was 10 Patterson, investi-
gators and newspapermen.
With Patterson in Jail, denied
bail because of the charge and
his wife's mother supporting his
innocence, the prosecutors office
worked feverishly trying TO
whip into shape some kind Of
case.
Then followed a frequently
adjourned examination in justice
court presided over by Justice
Frank Jeanette. Most of the
testimony was a repetition of
the inquest.
The states case was weak
ened, reporters agreed. when
Jeanette ruled that testimony
revealing the results of an ex-
animation of Patterson's blood
stained car was not admissible
as evidence.
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19
BY AL KAUFMAN

When Dwight Madison. 2l-
year-old newspaperboy, walked
into the St. Clair Shores home
of Herbert Patterson the morn
ing of Oct 20, 1899, he set the
stage for a murder mystery that
seems destined in Michigan
homicide annals as another per-
feet crime.
Mrs. Farrell Patterson, 49,
year-old attractive matron, had
been stabbed and slashed. She
fought like tigreSs against her
knife-wielding slayer, as evident
from the numerous wounds on
her body. arms and hands, but
was finally overcome.
When ST. Clair Shores Police
Chief Harold Lanstra responded
10 Madison's frantic call he
found Mrs. Patterson nude. save
for house slippers and a bras
siere. Her Powered housecoat.
blood-stained by the numerous
knife-rips, was In the kitchen
sink.
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19
B1'''.IT'ERRYH
Friend Confesses
Staying but Never
Goes to Trial

of the posse came upon the
mutilated object Of their search.
The former attractive Mrs.
Mosher had been so brutally
battered over the head and face
that she was scarcely identi-
fable.
The fiend who had committed
the crime had used the dog
leash TO garrote his victim; and
TO make death triple sure had
stuffed rags into the mouth and
nostrils OF his victim.
With that he dropped to one
knee and carefully extracted the
gags.
Unfolding them gingerly on
the ground three pieces were
seen TO be fragments Of a single
piece, which by design and
shape had undoubtedly been
torn from the tail OF o mans
shirt.
"Outside OF the natives on the
peninsula we have $4,000 men
visitors this winter; now all
we've got TO do II TO ind one
who has o shirt with the tall
missing" remarked Saunders
caustically.
"No, It's not quite as bad as
that" corrected Holland.
"Look here. This will elimi-
nate quite q few OF the tourists"
AS he spoke he forced open
clenched fist; and in the half
open palm were clustered a half
dozen gray hairs.
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19
Neishbor Volunteers
To Help With Hunt

Mr.. Hawley volunteered TO
help with the hunt.
When this proved unsuccess-
full they began a methodical
search OF the streets without
success, and then phoned police.
The telephone shrilled Police
Chief L. p. Holland to wakeful-
ness at 4 o'clock that morning.
"Was the dog on q leash ?"
qucried Holland when Mosher
arrived.
Gertrude always walked him
with a leash. He was n fine
watchdog and was devoted 10
my wife. II any stranger at
tempted 20 harm her Buddy
would defend her."
Hawley volunteered 10 take
Mosher and his daughter home
and the police chief left for his
Office 10 organize searching
parties 10 cover the outskirts OF
Gulfport during daylight.
Holland called his chief
deputy. Sid Saunders. and gave
him instructions TO recruit as
many civilians as he could mus
ter into posses 10 scour the
town and its suburbs.
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19
Macomb Deputies
Find Bloody Sheet

Two Macomb County deputies
found a bed sheet with blood
stains in the vicinity Of st. Clair
Shores. On October %. investi-
gators found a pair OF Patter-
sons brown shoes and light
trousers marked by stains. What
looked like bloodstains were
found in Patterson's car. too.
Authorities learned Mrs. Pat
terson spent the evening prior
10 her death at a cocktail party
in Crosse Pointe.
Patterson said his wife be-
came i'll and they drove home.
Patterson said he left the home
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19
Husband Summoned
From Auto Factory

Detective William Eaton. DR..
LeMoyne Snyder and two Ma
comb deputies started for the
murder scene while Johnston
waited 10 question Patterson.
who had been summoned from
his engineering work at De-
troit automobile plant. n
When tho deputies and state
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19
Pirate Rendezvous
in Florida Becomes
Locale of Murder

CULFPORT, one of Florida's
~ gems. lies close to the tip of
the Pinella peninsula between
the Gulf of Mexico and the for
mer pirate rendezvous, Tampa
Bay.
At 2 o'clock in the morning Of
Dec. 6, 1889, George Mosher
awoke fwrom an uneasy sleep TO
find, for the first time in 20
years of married life, that his
wife was not asleep beside him.
He recalled that he had re-
tired at 9 o'clock, a few minutes
after Gertrude had left to take
Buddy. their Boston bull ter
rier, for a walk.
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19

Letltld LdnuOn SuHmeu IL up HiCciy
with:
IL loved him as woman loves,
reckless OF sorrow, sin or scOrn."
In 1908 a passage from Europe
to the United States in the steerage
could be purchased for $40. In that
year 857, 046 immigrants from Europe
were admitted into the United States.
If you can say the following three
times in quick succession you don't
have to send me a snapshot of your
dog
'The STRIPPING stranger strayed
straight toward the struggling
stream"
Now there's a pill to enable
people TO stand intense heat better.
It's called the "beat-the-heat" pill
and is made of vitamin G concen-
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19

police arrived, Raul, TO complete
his bungling efforts, had en-
balmed the body.
Lea Zea. Macomb County
fingerprint expert, was unable
to discover any prints.
The remains Of Mrs. Patter-
sons clothing were taken TO
East Lansing for an examina-
ton by Doctor Snyder. Mean
while the prosecutor questioned
Patterson.
Johnston questioned Patter-
son closely on the fact that one
side of Mrs. Patterson's bed APP
peared not to have been slept in.
well, I always pat out the
pillows and rearrange the sheets
when I leave bed" he said.
ITS just my nature and ! cant
stand TO see n messy bed"
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19
Stuffed Rags in Nose
And Mouth OF Victim

1.-THE first thing I noticed was
that his leash was missing. l
examined him closely and saw
that his hair was matted with
blood"
1--WE been expecting some
thing like &C." returned Holland.
Get all your men together and
we'1 concentrate on tho scrub
north of town. I'll be right out"
An hour later two members
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19
; Autopsies Fail
TO Reveal Proof

Doctor Snyder, 70 low in &
three autopSies on Mrs. Patter-
sons body and minute inspec-
ton of Patterson's clothing,
announced that he could not
definitely state that the blood
matched.
On Jan. 3, 1910, Jeanette
dismissed charges and Patter-
son walked out of court a free
man.
Johnston seemed pleased as
did every one else connected
with the case.
Today. these question remain
unanswered:
Who was Mrs. Farrell Patter-
sons knife-wielding slayer? a
man or n woman
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19

prepared To night and ole Tor 1g
Donald Nelson's boyhood hero
was Jake Beckley Of the Cincinnati
Reds. Jake was the next to the last
maj or Lacquer to wear mustache.
The last was 'Frenchy" Bordagray.
1t is also said of Mr.. Nelson that
he learned to play golf from a book:
Alex Morrison's New Way to Better
Golf" And learned so well that he
was able to beat Sammy Snead In q
driving contest.
I'll have to get that book. i
don't play much golf, but like to go
out to driving range and sock out q
few long ones.
ETHEL LEVEY. One of the
many San Franciscans to become
world famous as an entertainer. Ethel
was George M. Cohan's first wife.
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19
Conviction Partly
Justified on Return

After this interview Holland
felt convinced that Mrs. MoSher
would never be found alive; for
II she was as happily married as
the Hawleys reported, she would
certainly have informed her
loved ones OF her whereabouts if
she were still alive.
Hardly had he set foot in his
Office on his return than his
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19

There's no use In sailing"
growled Holland, because the
manager Of the movie saw you
enter the movie with Mrs. Haw-
ley and he would have forgotten
IL IL he hadn't seen you come
out . minute or two later.
ut struck him as peculiar
and II was peculiar because you
were attempting to establish an
alibi for murder! You coveted
your neighbor's wife!
"YOu knew that the attrac-
tive Mrs. Mosher took her dog
for an airing at about 3 every
night, and you knew further
that she trusted you, so that II
you offered her q lift she would
take It."
Hawley jumped TO his feet.
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19
Saunders Briehtens
Az Chiefs Discovery

Saunders frightened at the
discovery:
That's hne! We can send
these TO Inspector Mitchell Mt
ST. Petersburg for microscopic
examination"
When Chief Holland returned
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19

about $40 the following morn
inc. All seemed we'll when he
left but the newsboy made his
startling discovery about four
hours later.
The stains on PatterSon'S
clothing were blood. all right,
Doctor Snyder learned. but be-
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19
Ladies, Why Hide Your Age?

whats all this about complaining they
have to tell their for rationng applications on
anything else:" writes Chicago bachelor.
"Why should a female be ashamed to tell her age?
younger than she really Is II is to her credit
There Is perhaps probability that many when
marrying their husbands their and
spot But they should remember the old saying; Oh
what tangled when first practice to deceive
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19

She appeared with George THE Governors Son. Running
for Office" Little Johnny Jones" and George Washing
Jr."
SECOND LIEUT.. HELEN SUMMERS Army nurse
She was at both Bataan Corregdor. Lieutenant Helen
is Brooklyn girl.
RISE STEVENS Only Metropolitan Opera star ever
born in the Bronx forget when mentioning her to
pronounce her first name "Ri-say."
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19

Not q punster, he works the humor
of a situation 10 the full, usually as
the butt of his wife's jokes"
If your proposal of marriage has
been rejected don't be too discouraged.
Try again. Even Abraham Lincoln
didn't measure up to one girls idea of
a husband. Mary Owens refused his
offer of marriage and said later in ex-
planation:
"Mr. Lincoln was deficient In those
little links which make up the path OF
a wOman's happiness"
Queries from clients:
Q-What price of cigar do you
smoke?
A-All prices from cents to
three for dollar. smoke cigarets,
too.
n VIZ, L. xx,1v~.an annt;n,a ~
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19

such screwy when male opinion is against 1T
A-Women don't anything about male opinion -
hats The great object Of most is to look dcrent
other women. tailored tend to mako them
look alike they rely dizzy hat make them stand out
from the rest of the females Anyway that what claimed
by Horses Women Research Department.
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19

tates The Nazis using something similar aid q
desert fighting
The "We Wanna Get Married Club of Pittsburgh ha:
made the following by Whyte Melville its official poem
For eUerbththg created,
In the bounds Of earth and sky
Hath such longing To be mated
~ must couple must die.
ey kint
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19
How Donald Nelson Learned Golf

postage stamp issued in Berlin bears pictures Of
Hitler, the king of Italy and the emperor of japan.
Who it said:
IAN Irishman doesn't know what he wants. but he n
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19
Patterson Arrested
by State Troopers

Patterson was at the home
Of Elmer Cummings. an uncle
who lives in Hart. when three
state troopers arrested him on
murder warrant issued by
Prosecutor Johnston following
the coroner'S jury verdict.
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19
Hollands Demesnor
Changes in Flash

Eyes, that's right" Hawley
said.
He reached into his pocket
and produced two red stubs
which he rendered TO his ques-
toner.
Holland accepted them with:
Thanks. Swell picture,
wasn't it? Tell me about IT,"
Hawley turned to his wife
and said:
TELL him about IL Honey"
In a fash Hollands demeanor
changed. He shot a command
that made his mild-mannered
visitor jump.
Don't ask her. You answer
IT,"
Northumberland II l
haven't forgotten already.
Maybe II my wife just gives me
tho name I might remember"
At a signal from his chief
Saunders walked over TO Mrs.
Hawley, and led her gently
from the room; after which he
resumed his seat in the back
ground.
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19
A True Detective Story

while i was paying you a visit
this morning. Is this still some
kind OF nonsense:
you're q hard man TO con-
vince, but you'll talk after you
SEQ this evidence--this In what
trapped YOU"
The chief opened a drawer of
his desk and brought out a
jewelers. envelope. He opened
II out with thumb and fore
finger and exposed several gray
hairs. The accused swallowed
hard. then collapsed.
Finally he blubbered:
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19
Aida Stains Favorite

Stains favorite opera is Aida" Hitlers Is Wagnert
die Mestersinger Nurmberg Der fuehrer has heard
this opera than $50 times.
AS to the extent loves when she really loves
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19
Unso|ved Crimes Of Michigan
St. Clair Wife Fights
Knife Murderer in
UnsoIved Crime

This is another IN the series
Of Miohi0dH's Nnsolvsd crimes.
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19
I've Been Mad About
Her for Long Time

OF did it, killed her because
I've been mad about her for
years and she always resisted
me. Last night was de-
termined IL she resisted me once
again I'd kill her. hammered
her to death and stuffed the
rags I'm her mouth and nose.
az wanted to make sure that
nobody would ever find the
hammer, so i threw It of the
municipal pier"
The slayer, now a spineless
bag of bones, assented to sign
aeon fession and Saunders
left TO make arrangements for
the salvaging of the murder
weapons.
Oliver Eady. diving expert,
agreed to make the attempt and
the following morning dove re-
peatedly to the bottom of
Tampa Bay while the killer
issued instructions from a seat
on the bulkhead. Eady finally
brought up the hammer.
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19

THE average person of Is has lost four teeth Those
i who 40 have usually lost 10 teeth OF their AZ How
you doing?
London newspapers description of Jack Benny follows:
Benny Kubesky Benny Is a sad-eyed, y-hared
man with a who adopts sef-deprecaory stye
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19
on The Side
By e. u Au,G,.,
If at 40 You Have q Teeth Left.
Your Record Tops the Average <

EyeS, look your last!
Arms. take your last embrace!
And lips, o you. the door, the doors Of breath
Seal with righteous kiss.
Detroit evening times. (Detroit, Mich) 1921-1958, 1942-07-19

When next Chief Holland APP
peared at his office door he
called for Saunders and the two
were closeted for Is minutes.
Holland later asked the Haw-
ley's some innocuous questions.
Then he looked at his watch and
rose with the remark:
There was another point on
which I wanted Information but
can't recall IL ut the moment.
I'd appreciate it' II you would
stop at my office In about an
hour; IL may como back TO me
by then"
Holland seated the couple
conf orta bly, in his office;
Deputy Saunders sat incon-
spicuously in the background.
This morning." began the
chief easily, "you told me that
YOU went to the movies and
arrived homo ut IL O'clOck--ls
that right"