davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
Imperial Valley press., 1939-11-16
Death Provides FDR 5th
Appointment to us.
Supreme Court

WASHINGTON, Nov. 16.
(UP)-Supreme Court JUS
tice Pierce Butler-one of the
two remaining conservative
members of the nations high
est court-died early today after a
long illness. He was 73.
His death creates the fifth vacan-
cy to occur on the nine man bench
during Franklin D. RooSevelt's Sec
ond term as president. Appointment
of Buffers successor will make a
majority of the court Mr.. Roosevelt's
appointees. The others are justices
Hugo L. Black, Stanley F.. Reed
Felix Frankfurter and William O
Douglas.
Butler died at Garfield hospital
at Ala am. He had been a patient
there since Sept. % for treatment
of a bladder ailment.
His condition turned suddenly
Continued on Page 6, Col. g.
Imperial Valley press., 1939-11-16

WASHINGTON, Nov. 16 (UP)-
Nomination of Attorney General
Frank Murphy to be an associate
justice of the Supreme Court and
promotion of Solicitor General Rob-
ert H. Jackson to cabinet rank
appeared likely today to follow the
death of Justice Pierce Butler.
Butler died two hours before
dawn today in a hospital room and
his passing marked the quiet end
of a political contest that wracked
the nation. He was 70.
With confirmation of his sue
cessor, Mr.. Roosevelt will have put
five New Deal justices on the high
bench, an absolute majority of the
court which he sought to influ-
ence in 1887 with plan to expand
its membership to Is. Butler was
the last but one of the extreme
conservative group which helped
Junk NRA, AAA and other New
Deal structures in 1885
Butler was a Democrat, Catho-
Imperial Valley press., 1939-11-16
Ed Law Formally
ResiqIls State Job

SACRAMENTO Nov. 16. (UP)-
Edward H. Law of El Centro today
resigned as state senator from I'm
perial county, creating fourth va
cancy in the upper house prior to
the special session of the legisla-
ture expected to convene Jan. Is.
Law was appointed recently as
assistant U. S. district attorney for
Southern California.
Laws resignation added to spec
ulation whether Gov. Culbert Olson
will call special elections to fill va
cancies in Imperial, Orange, Shasta
Trinity, and Amador-Alpine-El Do
RADIO counties. The Republicans now
command % to IA majority in the
upper house.
olson was represented as being
against calling special elections fol-
senators unless there was more as
surance that Democrats had good
chance to win.
Imperial Valley press., 1939-11-16

'UIlTec QdyS dllC1u VI oiiC oSA1S~>AS~
Gate because of credit OF Three
days in federal custody in 1881.
The department of justice said
that Capone had been transferred
today from the federal correctional
institution at Los Angeles.
The brief announcement did not
explain how Capone WIS brought
east from California but subsequent
ly it was stated that the prisoner
was brought to Lewisburg by train.
The mystery of Capone's where
abouts and when he was being re-
leased was cleared up by the an
nouncement of James v. Bennett,
director of the bureau of prisons.
Bennett announced this morn
ing that Alphonse Capone's SEN
tence having expired today, he was
discharged from the u. S. peni-
tentiary at Lewisburg, Pa, to his
relatives" the announcement said.
Officials of the federal peniten-
tiary at Lewisburg announced. how
ever, that AL Capone "iS not now
and never has been" in the prison.
Reporters stationed at the peni-
tentiary since last midnight said
there was no trace of Capone ard
that no unusual activity was noted.
"It's all news to me-" Ella Fin
kelstein, secretary to Warden Hen
ry c. Hill said when informed OF
| the announcement in Washington.
1--WE haven't seen Capone around
here"
4
She said Hill was "out of town..
A few hours later DR.. Clyde Frost,
superintendent of the Union Men,
orial Hospital at Boston, announced
that Capone had been brought there
as a private patient and turned
over to DR.. Joseph E. Moore for
treatment. He refused further COM
ment on the former gang lords con-
dition. Capone has been reported
suffering from pareisis, which
causes mental alterations
Capone was taken to the hos
pital by members of his family.
The former dapper gangland
chief, who used to pay large sums
for loud silk underwear, was dressed
today in a cheap suit which the
federal government gave to him as
Continued on Page 6, Col. ID
Imperial Valley press., 1939-11-16
Grand Jury Cons
Albert Pond Case

Grand jurors went into a hud-
die Thursday, supposedly to con-
tinue their investigation of the
charge that Albert S. Pond mis-
appropriated irrigation district
funds while employed as a water
clerk at Calipatria.
They adjourned at noon with the
announcement that they planned
to meet again at 1 pm.
Imperial Valley press., 1939-11-16
Murphy Probable
Court Appointee

lie and a mid-westerner. Murphy
fits that prescription precisely. And
not only would his nomination to
the court complete the entrench-
ment of New Deal philosophy there
for at least a generation, but 1t
would give the president an oppor-
tunity to honor Jackson further
1t is believed that he would be
as eager to do that as to shift his
New Deal attorney to the judiciary
Imperial Valley press., 1939-11-16

"I am particularly interested, be-
cause I would have to dig the new
ditch myself" he pointed OUT.
The council refused to alter the
ordinance and ruled that the par
sonage must have a separate con-
nection to the main line, but they
did grant the church free install
lation. This was done over Mayor
H. w. Fawcett's argument that a
dangerous precedent was being set
in that other churches had not
received similar treatment.
The vote was Charles Blalack
Gordon Scriven and Harry Sones
yes, Fawcett and P. L. Moore no.
Imperial Valley press., 1939-11-16

mander G. Fl. Fl. Small, W. n.
Rhodes, and Race Director E. C.
Harris.
Jones denied the allegation that
the radiator on the car he drove was
not stock model as was alleged at
the time he was disqualified.
He contended he was entitled to
first place money as the winner OF
first place was disqualified, auto
matically giving him, Jones. first
place. He contended the first prize
money should not have been given
Y. Uchimiya.
The plaintiff declared he asked
Imperial Valley press., 1939-11-16

race officials II 1t would be salts
factory II he used radiator no
formerly had used in a similar race
sponsored by the post. He said no
was told he could do so.
Jones was quoted as saying even
if his radiator had not been q stock
model, that was carrying techni-
calities too far as some OF the cars
had sparkplugs and other parts not
placed In them by the makers.
The suit was filed In ri centro
justice court.
Imperial Valley press., 1939-11-16

Rev. Mr. chester Eymann and C0un-
cilmen came when the pastor said:
IT realize you have building regu-
lations that prevent connecting the
parsonage sewer to that of the
church and 1 sympathize with you
in that you are doing everything
in your power to protect the tax
payers money.
"But on the other hand, I am
doing everything in my power to
protect Gods money!!
The minister pointed out that
a ditch already had been dug from
parsonage to church for the sewer
line before he learned that this is
contrary to regulations.
Imperial Valley press., 1939-11-16
Dock Tieup Shunts
Business From ST..
To Southland City
Strike Costs Bay City
Thousands of Dollars
In Lost Commerce

SAN FRANCISCO, Nov.
16. (UP)-Losses exceeding
hundreds of thousands of
dollars daily were reported
by business interests today
as strikes of dock clerks, ware
housemen and marine firemen par
alyzed the commerce of San Fran
cisco bay ports.
The Intercoastal Freight associa-
ton of San Francisco distributors,
and the Pacific Coast Waterfront
Employers association reported the
economic loss of the tieupS affected
not only business and industry but
labor as we'll.
The diversion of shipping to Los
Continued on Page 6, Col. g.
Imperial Valley press., 1939-11-16
Wiser Reflected
By Farm Bureau

SAN DIEGO, Nov. 49, (UP)-The
city of Stockton was selected as the
convention site of the 1910 Cali
fornia Farm Bureau Federation, and
Ray B. Wiser of Butte county was
reelected president of the organ
ization for his third term, it was
reported from the election meeting
of the 2lst annual convention OF
the federation here today.
Imperial Valley press., 1939-11-16
Germans Find New
Reasons For Diet

BERLIN, Nov. Is. (UP) - The
Deutsche Allgemeine zeitung ad-
vised readers today that eating
more brown bread would cure
"blackout blindness" which has re-
suited in large number of acci-
dents.
Brown bread contains high per-
centage of vitamin A which 'en-
ables the human eye to see in semi
darkness and darkness" the news
paper said.
Imperial Valley press., 1939-11-16
Hungry Burglars
Loot I.V. Dairy

BRAWLEY. Nov. 16-Burglars
who looted the Russell dairy were
either abnormally hungry or getting
ready to start a store
They looted the place of Is pounds
of butter, Is dozen eggs, and 10C
pennies in a raid on the dairy
west of town Wednesday night.
Imperial Valley press., 1939-11-16
Victim Improving

Mrs. Andrew j. Mead, Ell Cen
tran injured in an automobile ac-
cident Tuesday, was said to be i'm
proving Thursday. She Is pat
lent at Ell Centro hospital.
Imperial Valley press., 1939-11-16
Cana Chieftun Delivered
Across Continent to His
Fumi|v: Linked to Murder
Three Days Credit Given Bootles Era
HoodIum on Sentence For Tax Evasion;
Mvs+ery Surrounds Transfer to East

WASHINGTON Nov. 16. (UP)-The department O.
justice announced today that AL Capone, the onetim
Chicago gangster chieftain released to his family
this morning at the Lewsburg, Pa. pententiary.
Capone has completed his sentence, having done 81
Imperial Valley press., 1939-11-16
Tin Lizzy Derby
Ruling Contested

Suit to collect $780, first place money in the lin Lizzie
Derby at the fair grounds Nov filed against boyce
Aten American Legion post Thursday by Leroy jones'
disqualified winner of second place.
He the post through their representatives Com
Imperial Valley press., 1939-11-16
Plea by Porson
Splits City Vote

parsons plea split decision at meeting OF the
Ell Centre city council Wednesday night
AS result the Four Square Gospel church at Eighth
and Orange streets will receive $3.50 connec-
ton free charge Climax of the discussion between the
Imperial Valley press., 1939-11-16
Moore Deaton Appointed
On Library Board Here
DAAalM!NNee AMBl!Ne
IMPORTER

Play Acting
It took Mittens quite spell to
learn that you can't even believe
in pictures.
The elderly white cat belonging
to Mrs. Phil Remington was at
tracted one day by a picture IN
the Remington home of the Lion
and the Mouse, in which the king
of beasts was placidly holding the
mouse in its mouth. Apparently
Mittens thought to herself:
"If a NANCY old lion can do 1t,
why can't I? What's he got that
1 haven't got?"
The only way to find out was to
try, so Mittens sought, found and
conquered a wee mousie. Carrying
the still alive creature to the pic
ture. Mittens assumed a pose that
was, in her eyes, leonine.
Probably overcome by the urge
to appear as smugly angelic as
the lion, Mittens loosened her jaws
a trifle That was all the mouse
needed. He squirmed and made q
flying chew at his captor There
followed a surprised squawk from
Mittens and a quick gulp.
The mouse was gone on the ali,
mentary highway and the benign
expression on Mittens face had dis
appeared even more quickly. Nit.
tens took one last enigmatic glance
at the picture. licked her chops ane
padded grandly away, giving tht
lion a flick of her tail.
Old Never-Hit-
what are you figuring, you
income taxi" asked Mrs. E. L. Tag
CART, and her husband peeked ou
of barricade of record books ane
penciled foolscap and explained:
woman, you are now privileged
to observe a master prognosticatol
in the act of predicting the future
I do it with numbers and nativ'
inability and arrive at the resul
of football games that will not b.
known by the unenlightened unit
next Saturday"
Indulgently, Mrs. Taggart tapped
her spouse on the head with a flat
iron and said:
"Give me that list of football
games"
Quickly she went through th'
list checking off winners and losers
all the time keeping up running
conversation something in this wise
Iowa! That's a nice name
and Princeton, I like their hair
cuts Southern Cal I'll take be
cause I'm patriotic :. and Missouri
for no reason whatsoever.
Results, after the unenlightene'
had been enlightened:
The Omnipresent Taggart: L
right, five wrong.
La Belle Hit and Miss Taggart
II right, three wrong.
Odd Behavior
From a telephoner who preferrei
to remain cloaked in an aura o
mystery, we learn that Raymon,
Clark, who resides near Melolanc
was sighted driving a truckload Q
tin cans down the Dogwood roa
AWAY from the city dump.
The telephoner would like t
know why, and we're mildly curiou
too. Is there any money in it?
Imperial Valley press., 1939-11-16
Nazis, Reds Keep Up Buster While
Fighting Fronts Remain Inactive;
Allied Blockade Holds Initiative
German Threats to Launch Great Offensive
Remain Only Threats; Communists Continue
War of Nerves Against Standpat Finland
- BY JOE ALEX MORRIS -
United Press Foreign News Editor

Nazis and Communists kept Europes war OF words
going full blast Thursday but the fighting fronts were
Quiet In Berlin authorized German sources declared that
Imperial Valley press., 1939-11-16

Butter: Los Angeles Sc; but
terfat, Imperial valey fob. ranch.
grade A, 42c, manufacturing milk
34c; route gathered cream s0,1c.
L. A. hays U. s. No. l sf6.-Si7;
U. s. No. 2 leafy s14-14.50; U. 5. No
2 $12-S13, Mpls. cash flax s1.S0.
The Tacoma times. [volume] (Tacoma, Wash.) 1903-1949, 1939-03-03
Loesed-OH Lend

WRITE Or cal! for booklet o; logged
land Ia West Nah Tor SAFE on eaSy
terms WeTerhEeusef Timbsf CO
The Tacoma times. [volume] (Tacoma, Wash.) 1903-1949, 1939-03-03
Repairs

J p THOMPSON " D. Skin DIS.
eases Blood tests. e33hs PACIFIC
The Tacoma times. [volume] (Tacoma, Wash.) 1903-1949, 1939-03-03
Fender and Radiator Repairs
Floor Sanders Rented
Kodsks Films Finishing
cAcnlAkl KODAK STORES
~ ~ W. NJ ol0 Broadway
Massage

BATHS AND MASSAGE FOR health.
expert attendants 1928 SO YAK
ina. apt 207 Mhln 65o3.
The Tacoma times. [volume] (Tacoma, Wash.) 1903-1949, 1939-03-03
Farm. and Acreage

FOR REsT-<0 acrss all cleared
Good outbuildlngs and orchard
? D /. Boz sac EuumrlaW.
Wash
The Tacoma times. [volume] (Tacoma, Wash.) 1903-1949, 1939-03-03

RADIO REFRIGERATOR WASHER
repairs D. Heck. Free estimates
Z Phone MA 1907 1861 Broadway
The Tacoma times. [volume] (Tacoma, Wash.) 1903-1949, 1939-03-03
NAN Sisl Tor Miss sdtsser
Real Estate for Sale

LOOK EN- OVER
SOUTH TACOMA
CORNER cath and Lawrence. nice
family home. beautiful yard With
fruit trees. shrubs. etc. Priced
70 set Al 81 $50 Reasonable
terms
LINCOLN HIGH
5l2 SO. s5TH. 3-eedrcom home In
good condition; two lots Toe
down. balance $is2S per month.
FERN HILL
1891 so. PARK: broom eunes-
low.type home 4 level lots; TO-
down. balance Sf3l7 per month.
MCKINLEY HILL
e02 EAST WRIGHT. ; rooms. ?
lots on corner, basement and
furnace. TO- down. balance
$50 20 per month
See NJ. Jensen At
:. A. VANE s CO.
REALTORS
In Growing South Tacoma
GA 1898 sun. 4 Ewes. BR 2sle
The Tacoma times. [volume] (Tacoma, Wash.) 1903-1949, 1939-03-03
Washers

4 WASHING MACHINES
d.. Vacuum cleaners repaired
ne ~oiiS Parts for ali makes
5EACTIGAM 4 MARTIN nc
So s He.ens AYE BIZ 1919
The Tacoma times. [volume] (Tacoma, Wash.) 1903-1949, 1939-03-03
NEW BUNGALOW. s.. 500

81 $50 SOUTH END $3.50
$500 DOWN. SIS MONTHLY
COZY arm. bungalow, located
near 56th and J on paved street /:
liv. rm.. din. nm. bedroom, kit
chen, 3-piece bath. inlaid limo
leum lot 40xi00 win submit
offer OF 81 100 cash. Agent.
William. Main el3s DAYS. PR
096s evenings.
The Tacoma times. [volume] (Tacoma, Wash.) 1903-1949, 1939-03-03
You'll Find the Here That Meets Your Needs Buy Now Before Prices
Main Slsi for Mis- .dtas.r
Real Estate for Sale


SO. TACOMA DIST.
CLOSE TO schools. stores and bus
very attractive 5 room hunga-
low, on two fun lots. enclosed
with hedge and picket fence
ms property has been com-
pietely reeonditioned and Is
ready for occupancy. Has large
pleasant living room and a den
panneled in ply wood. nice bed
rooms, complete bath and cahi-
net kitchen. = basement: large
garage with cement floor. For
complete information see e n
jerks. GA 40l2
GEO. D. POE S co.
2lo Jones Bldg MA eiel
s-ACRE RANCH-BARGAIN
LOCATED miles out: land all clear
ed, nice 5-room modern house with
bath, As neat a. pin outside ana
inside. ehickonhouse Tor $50 birds
small barn. etc s2,a5o. terms
Might trade even for city property
HERE'S A GOOD BUY
A DANDY Groom house and 4-roam
house in the rear. The large house
Is in the pink OF condition. one OF
those older-type comfortable houses
that YOU delight in calling home
Beautiful lots all kinds OF tree
fruit shrubbery and flowers. two
bis fish pools. We arc throwing
IN The small house AZ this price
s2975. easv terms
uUNnDy pr.rvxs 10
IA Puget Sound Bank Bldg MA 1902
LOOK 500 DOWN
CUTE coy bungalow for newly
weds. wired for electric range.
for electric hot water heater:
cement foundation. fun base
ment, garage in basement. ?
lots. Pay $50 per month in
GLIDING interest. Move right in.
BR 1898 us Fidelity Bldg
FOR SALE-One acre with some fruit
trees. good garden soil. Apply $40
No. Orchard
FOR SALTWATER WATERFRONT
see Comfort 4 Davis Rust Bids
TELL THEM YOU SAW IT IN
THE TIMES
The Tacoma times. [volume] (Tacoma, Wash.) 1903-1949, 1939-03-03

GARDEN TINE Pea home. i0-A
3 cuiF. homo orchard siO0 u a.
mo Price ell $50 f2teis Tao ave
The Tacoma times. [volume] (Tacoma, Wash.) 1903-1949, 1939-03-03

1877 fgDOR Ford ssdAf $50. los
tnli~sss kzesiisns condition. tsI3
soFih 1sth Is
The Tacoma times. [volume] (Tacoma, Wash.) 1903-1949, 1939-03-03

Dr. WEISFIELD 4 GOLDBERG CAS- J
repair your watch throE = sNsS
Special iow repair prices EoS
WEISFIELD & GOLDBERG
e25 Broadway
The Tacoma times. [volume] (Tacoma, Wash.) 1903-1949, 1939-03-03
Novelties

ALASKAN NOVELTIES SHOP We
duplicate anything out OF wood
Phone PR 1874. 8o3 So Adams.
The Tacoma times. [volume] (Tacoma, Wash.) 1903-1949, 1939-03-03
Patent Attorneys

r l. ELLIOTT e2e Rust Bid BR 4l4.
Patents Trademarks. Free ADVICE
The Tacoma times. [volume] (Tacoma, Wash.) 1903-1949, 1939-03-03

COAL at very lov cost Egg nut Sc
ese lump. 81. BR 37ss. evenings
COAL-Monsfch. Mckay Bone c-5
upi wood Hillsdsle Fael Ga 1926
HEAVY plsner ends. hester wooc u
% worth. or oy cord GA o7&s
UPLAND re slab. tTo cords 70. sio
GA o2i5
The Tacoma times. [volume] (Tacoma, Wash.) 1903-1949, 1939-03-03
Reel Estsfe Wanted
Love Hain't On His Side

n YOu have q Aoss< for sale cal
HsudFT Realty Co. Ma ii01
The Tacoma times. [volume] (Tacoma, Wash.) 1903-1949, 1939-03-03
Upholstery. Rug Cleaning
Watch Repairing

C.cL BP 2o65
The Tacoma times. [volume] (Tacoma, Wash.) 1903-1949, 1939-03-03

10 ACRES e-roosn houes lot n.
fruit barn. electricity PR 1854
Greenbelt cooperator. (Greenbelt, Md.) 1937-1954, 1939-03-16

Where you when the gifts went out?" That
question has probably dropped from the lips every
one Of us at time during the past few days.
Little do realize how much depend those
Silent servants"in house which only become
spicuous during their absence.
Tt is quite disooncerting to have the hero Of the
story you are reading hanging by his heels
thousand foot precpce only to be plunged into sudden
darkness yourself. The mental anguish you through
waiting to if he is saved is probably nothing to
the throes hero suffers dangling head down for
hour All because little button init butt.
Then there the lady who had her clothes in the
washing machine when PITT just like that. But she
very philosophical when interviewed Said she,
didn't really want to wash anyway"
Would have liked to a little mouse in the local
theatre long about that time. Wonder if the local
flaming youths took advantage Of the darkness to
"Pitoh little WOO.
near tragedy occurred in my own household. That
is ut took such Importance it looked
like tragedy to me. With guests coming for dinner
at nine O'Clock their first (and you the
Importance Of first impressions). Here am caught
just putting my dinner in the what
eventually be ice In the frigidaire. Now if
that doesn't look like tragedy to any self-respect-
Ing housewife. We11II Oh yes, made out.
had dinner SO late and they starvation
that if we had given them a Of sardines they
would probably called it the most
they ate". And the ice cream Oh we drenk
that!!!!!!!
few members Of the stronger all for erect
ing sign in the square. mo parking after $500
PM" If you don't get my point, walk from the drug
store to the food store any pretty day between the
hours Of l:Oo to $500 pm.
An interested spectator suggests that the local
firemen draw straws to determine who shall
honor of riding the front seat of the firetruck
Greenbelt cooperator. (Greenbelt, Md.) 1937-1954, 1939-03-16
a. Salt o the Earth
Dorothy Se1ter

or maybe 1T could be done alphabetically. In any
case it seems that Bery always steals the show by
arriving at the fire first. How about a little
action boys??
Social activities rather the downgrade what
with the lenten and the natural mi d-Earch
slump" But few have braved the doldrums.
Mrs. Peter Carroll of LA Eastway entertained
few friends at bridge last week. tables
played during the evening.
Mrs. Ben Perelzweig Of Crescent Road is just back
from visit with relatives in New York City. She
York in general. Of wou1dn't her know
but don't you envy her, dol!
Mrs. Wells Honeycutt entertained her bridge club
last Wednesday evening at her home TIC Parkway. Two
tables played during the evening with first prize
going to Mrs. Wade Snyder, and second prize lrs
William Harrison. Nice going "Weeze" for someone
who doesn't like BRIDGE"
We going to miss Mr.. and Mrs. R. E. Baughman
and Family of TIC Ridge who are being trans
ferred to Bay City, Mchigan. Mr.. Baughman has al
ready left. He will be joined next week by the
Mrs., end Herbert and brand new baby Dennis
Ne1ll who ere leaving Sunday. We know you Ill be
happy in your home but friends hate to see
you 60.
We want to extend sympathy to MIR. H. A. Bone
OF 2o-D Crescent Road who called home Illinois
because Of the death Of his father.
Mrs. George Carnes and Mrs. R.L.Kincheloe enter
tanned ten ladies at benefit luncheon LATTER
home. &c Crescent Road, last Tuesday, The proceeds
from the luncheon ere to be added to fund a new
organ for the Greenbelt Community Church.
Jimmy NcCar1 entertained about twenty-four Of his
young friends at birthday luncheon home, I'd
Crescent Road Saturday afternoon The party was in
honor Of his eleventh birthday. The boys played
games during the afternoon joined by Dr.. McCarl. Jim
received number of lovely Gifts.
Evening star., 1939-12-11
Court
Continued From First Page. }

cided by the court today brought
again before the high tribunal the
so-called celebrated 'Nardone Case" :"
on which the court first gave its
ruling that interstate wire-tapping
was outlawed by the Communica-
tions Act.
In this case, Frank c. Nardone,
Nathan w. Hoffman and Robert
Gottfried were convicted in Federal
District Court in New York Of
smuggling alcohol.
After the Supreme Court had re-
versed that conviction, they were
brought to trial and again convicted.
On this occasion. they appealed to
the Supreme Court on the grounds
that evidence that had actually
been obtained by wiSe-tapping was
used in the second trial. The lower
court said that, although the Fed
eral Communications Act rendered
inadmissable as evidence telegraph
and telephone message themselves,
it did not make incompetent any
evidence which had become acces-
sible because of the overlapping.
Justice Frankfurter delivered the
opinion of the court in this case
and Justice McReynolds announced
a dissent. Justice Reed took no
part in the consideration of the case.
ANY claim for the exclusion of
evidence logically relevant in GRIM
inal prosecutions is heavily handi-
capped" Justice Frankfurter said.
ut must be justified by an over
riding public policy expressed in the