davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
Evening star., 1939-07-01
Dorothy Dix Says
Wife Should Be as Affable Home
With Family as She Is Outside

Dear Miss Dix: I have a wife
who is as different outside of the
home as she is in it as day is
from night. Abroad she is an at
tractive, good looking, intelligent
woman who is tactful in dealing
with people and makes herself
agreeable to all with whom she
comes in contact. But the minute
she enters the home she drops her
pleasant, affable nature at the door
and commences to complain and to
nag, usually beginning with the
children and ending up with fight
with me because l refuse to take
her part against the children when
she is unreasonable. I suppose she
loves her children in her way. but
she is never willing to do anything
for their pleasure. and when
youngster of Is or a son of 20 wants
to bring his friends into the home
for meal she refuses. because
she says it will be too much trouble,
although she frequently entertains
her friends and clubs and commit
tees. If the children leave their
books or clothes on chair she
flies into passion and berates them
in her anger. She is so fault finding
that it has come to the place where
they actually hate to see their
mother come home. Not long ago
she took trip and I was left
at home with two daughters. The
younger girl said to me one day:
isn't it nice to be alone, Daddy?
l hate to think of mother coming
back. And the older girl, who
works away from home, but comes
in for week ends. has frankly told
her mother that she does not intend
to come home unless there is some
lessening of the nagging. AS for
myself, I have long since passed
out of the picture, yet I still love
my wife and crave her affection.
The last few years have been full
OF worries and anxieties for me,
as they have for all businessmen,
and I would have liked to have
come home to a place that was
full OF peace and happiness and
to a wife who would have shown
me some affection. but instead of
that I have returned at night to
a home of strift and a wife who did
not give me even a word of well
come. For myself I can say that
Evening star., 1939-07-01
Only Prisoners to Be Fed

SANTA FE, N. Mex, July l (lP).-
Inmates of Santa Fes de luxe new
city Jail can do no more entertain
ing.
1T has developed that meals are
being served in the city Jail to
others than prisoners" complained
Councilman John w. Chapman.
The council took steps to see that
the city feeds only prisoners-and
not friends who drop in to pass the
time of day.
Evening star., 1939-07-01
BY BARBARA BELL.

Sweet simplicity is a keynote of
charm in this design that shows you
new, smart and very easy way to
make the favorite print that you'll
depend upon to insure your looking
your prettiest on important after
noon dates. The snug little rig
hugging bodice whittles your waist
line to seductive smallness, the bias
skirt ripples to graceful fullness,
from slim hips. Broad-shouldered
sleeves, and a youthful, flattering
square neckline complete its charm
The diagram shows you how simple
this dress is to make, and your pat
tern includes step-by-step sew
chart.
This dress will be lovely in silk
print, taffeta, linen, handkerchief
lawn or the thin wool which has
recently received royal approval.
Barbara Bell Pattern No. 1659-B
is designed for sizes IL, IA, Is, 10 and
20. Corresponding bust measure
ments 80, 80, "a, SO and 80. Size IA
Evening star., 1939-07-01
Miss Merillat Married
To Mr.. c. E. Carpenter.

Miss Norma Robey Merillat
daughter of Mr.. and Mrs, Charles
Norman Merillat, and Mr.. Charles
Evans Carpenter of Takorna Park
D. c., son of Mr.. George Carpenter
of Newburg, Md, and the late Mrs
Carpenter, were married last eve
ming, The wedding took place in
the Trinity Episcopal Church in
Takoma Park, the rector, the Rev
Reno S. Harp, officiating at $50
o'clock. Mr.. Richard Cornell sang
before the ceremony, accompanied
by Mrs. Ruth Vanderlip, organist,
who played the wedding marches.
White gladioli decorated the church
which was lighted by candles.
The bride was given in marriage
by her father and her wedding
gown was of white lace made over
satin after princess model. The
sweetheart neckline was caught at
each side by cluster of pearls and
her tulle VEIL edged with lace, which
covered the long train of the gown,
Evening star., 1939-07-01
Mrs. Smith Hostess

Mrs. Norman P. Smith enter
tained Tuesday afternoon for Mrs.
John Hanks of Fairfax, Va, who
will leave in the near future for
the Philippine Islands. The guests
included Mrs. c. H. Marvin, Mrs.
Gilbert H. Grosvenor, Mrs. Albert
Graham, Mrs. Phillip Poland, Mrs.
Russell McNitt, Mrs. w. H. Collier,
Mrs. N. B. Ames. Miss Helen Dunn,
Mrs. Elijah Anthony, Miss Barbara
Ames, Miss Helen S. Smith, Mrs.
B. w. RichWine, Mrs. J. H Roe and
Mrs. w. Y. Handy.
Evening star., 1939-07-01
Notes From the Social Calendar WASHINGTON and Its
Mrs. Norma Britton
Goes to Arkansas

Mrs. Norma Hardy Britton, widow
of Mr.. Edward Britton, who was
secretary to the Secretary of the
Navy, Mr.. Josephus Daniels, during
the World War has been at her
former home at Pine Bluff, Ark
where she was called by the death
of her father, Mr.. w. T. Hardy
June "a. Mrs. Britton was accom-
panied by her sister, Mrs. Florence
Ottman, also of Washington,
Mrs. Ottman and Mrs. Britton re-
manned through the week to be
with their mother after the services
for Mr.. Hardy Tuesday.
Evening star., 1939-07-01
Mrs. Nichols Wed

= OF interest to Washington society
is the marriage of Mrs. Temple
Harris Nichols, daughter of Mr.. and
Mrs. A. L. Harris, and Mr.. Sydney
Rhodes Prince, which took place
at the Presbyterian Church of the
Covenant. Greensboro, N. c., Thurs
day evening.
Only the immediate families were
present. Mr.. E. E. Norris was Mr..
Princes best man.
Immediately following the cere-
mony Mr.. and Mrs. Prince left for
New York and will sail today for
England. When they return they
will reside in Washington.
Evening star., 1939-07-01
Cuban Rotarians
Are Supper Guests
At Embassy

The Cuban Embassy was the
scene Of gay party last night
when the Ambassador, Senor DR..
Pedro Martinez Fraga, entertained
at buffet supper in honor of
delegation of Cuban Rotarians who
are in this country for the Inter-
national Convention of Rotarians
in Cleveland.
Receiving with the Ambassador
was Sonora de Valdes Rodriguez,
wife of the Counselor of the En-
bassy, who wore a becoming dress
of rose-beige lace with short puffed
sleeves and long, flowing skirt.
An orchestra played popular
Cuban tunes as the guests arrived
and later there was dancing in the
ballroom.
Pink roses and white snapdragons
were used on the long buffet tables
and garden flowers in variety of
colors banked the mantlepiece. In
addition to the Virginia ham, lob
ster salad and dainty sandwiches
there were many other delicacies
and the special Cuban dishes were
popular with the guests.
DR.. Ramon Larenzo, director of
the Rotarians of Santa Clara,
headed the group of Cuban visitors
Invited to meet the honor guests
were prominent Rotarians, as we'll
as a number from the diplomatic
set
Among those present were DR.. and
Sonora r. Lorenzo, Mr.. and Mrs. L..
Hazza, Mr.. and Mrs. A. Guerra, Mr..
and Mrs. j. Menendez, Mr.. and Mrs.
Francisco Lewis, Mr.. and Mrs. j.
Esperon, Mr.. and Mrs. L. Chasing,
Mr.. and Mrs. A. Barrero. Mr.. and
Mrs. L. Gonzales, Miss Blanca R.
Rodriguez, Miss Carmita Artime,
Miss Emilia Delgado. Miss Haria
Esperon, Miss Violeta Esperon, Miss
Maria A. FreXes, Miss G. Gonzalez,
Mrs. Hortensia Polo. Miss Mercedes
Lescano, Mrs. Angelina Sera, Miss
Raquel Cid, Miss E. Vazquez, Miss
Margarita Vazquez, Miss Emilia
Vazquez, Miss Josefa Gonzalez, DR..
Julio Esperon, Mr.. Jesus j. Lopez,
Mr.. Raul Lopez, Mr.. Alfredo Lewis,
Mr.. Alfredo Lewis. jr; Mr.. Elizardo
Gomez, Mr.. Eulilio Gomez, Mr..
Francisco Frexes, DR.. Juan B. Sed
Mr.. Augustin Gonzalez, Mr.. Antonio
Jordan, Mr. Andres MUSCLE, Mr..
Ricardo Ros, Mr.. Jose Artime. Mr..
Manuel Godinez and Mr.. Emilio
LemuS.
Evening star., 1939-07-01
Mrs. Joseph Low
To Make Milk Study

Mrs. Joseph Low has been ap-
pointed representative Of the Dis
trict Voteless League of Women
Voters to confer with a committee
OF citizens making a study of the
milk situation in Washington. Mrs.
M. O. Lorenz league president.
made the appointment at a board
meeting yesterday.
Mrs. Lorenz also announced the
appointment of Mrs Paul Appleby
as chairman of the leagues depart
ment of government and child well
fare next year and Mrs. Frederick
Guthelm as chairman of finance.
Evening star., 1939-07-01

(32) requires 37s yards of 39-inch
material, "a yards of lace banding
Ior y yard of contrast.
Send Is cents for Barbara Bells
spring and summer pattern book!
Make your own smart new frocks
for street, daytime and afternoon
with these simple, carefully planned
designs! It's chic, it's easy, it's eco
nomical to sew your own. Each pat
tern includes a step-by-step sew
chart to guide beginners.
Evening star., 1939-07-01

her hair.
The ushers were Mr.. Jack Fluhrer,
Mr.. Hal G.. Sours, Capt. Frank M.
Forsythe and Maj Adolph Stell-
horn, all of Columbus.
A reception was held in the May
flower Hotel, after which Col. and
Mrs Beightler left for wedding
trip, the bride wearing turquoise
blue crepe with knife-pleated
jacket to match and cranberry
color hat and purse. They will live
in Columbus, where Col Beightler
is director of highways for the State
of Ohio. He was graduated from
the School of Engineering of Ohio
State University and served over
seas during the World War He
came to Washington. where he was
in the war plans division of the
War Department, having graduated
from the General Staff School at
Fort LeavenWorth and the Army
War College here. Mrs. Beightler
has served in the secretarial staff
for Senator Herring and for former
Senator Daniel F. Steck, the late
Senator Louis Murphy and former
Representative w. c. Ramseyer, all
of Iowa.
Gov. Bricker was accompanied to
Washington by Mrs. Bricker, who
was among the guests at the we'd
ing. and others from out of town
were Mrs. Frank Forsythe and her
daughter, Miss Virginia Forsythe;
Mrs Adolph Stellhorn and her
daughter, Miss Barbara Stellhorn;
Mrs. Jack Fluhrer, wife of the secre-
tary to Col Beightler; Assistant
Director of Highways in Ohio and
Mrs. Hal G. Sours. Mr.. Leon Lich-
lenstein. Capt George Forester, Mr..
and Mrs. Robert Dodge, brother-in-
law and sister of the BRIDEGROOM:
Cadet Robert S. Beightler, jr., son
of the bridegroom. who received an
honorary appointnment to the mill
tary academy at West Point and will
enter there tomorrow, having gradu-
ated from the Greenbrier Military
School; Miss Betty Lawrence and
Mrs. Henry from the office of Gov.
Bricker: Mr.. Reed Wheeldon and
Mr.. Harry Veal. all from Columbus.
Other guests at the wedding were
Mrs. Beightler of Marysville, Ohio,
mother of the bridegroom: Mr.. and
Mrs Richard Wilson and MI and
Mrs. Ray Murphy of New York City;
Mr.. Rush Kress of Ossining, N Y,
and Mr.. and Mrs Fred Fox and Mr..
and Mrs. John Margolis of Philadel-
phia. Also attending the wedding
were Senators and Representatives
from Ohio and Iowa.
Evening star., 1939-07-01
Dance for Visitors

Mr.. and Mrs. Ward Lee Calhoun
are entertaining this week end in
honor of Mrs. Harvey Locke, and
they will be hosts tonight at din
ner and dance in their home Mr.
and Mrs. Calhoun are just back
from Miami, where they met Mrs.
Locke, a former resident of this
city and the daughter of 1t. Comdr
William Carson of Washington.
Evening star., 1939-07-01

have been faithful husband
and good provider. and my chill
dren adore me. and we should have
had happy home if my wife and
the children's mother had only CO.
operated little with us. Is there
any cure for such a situation?
A HUSBAND.
Answer am afraid not. The
French have proverb to the effect
that there are men who are angels
of the street and devils of the home.
and that applies equally to women.
There are women who seem to get
sadlstic pleasure in making their
homes hells on earth for those con-
demned to live in them. I have been
in many Of these where I wondered
at the patience and the fortitude of
the husband and the children who
endured the grinding tyranny that
despotlc women exercised over them,
who bore the revilings and insults
Of shrew and who meekly suffered
themselves to be nagged to death.
And, personally. I have been di-
vided between admiration for their
endurance and contempt for their
lack of backbone, because there was
no need for their g-drawn-o out
sufferings. All they needed was the
courage to put their cruel ruler in
her place and make her understand
fully and firmly. that if she didn't
behave herself she would get fired
Any woman who can make her
self agreeable abroad can make her
self pleasant at home Any woman
who can be diplomatic in handling
other people can use a little tact in
getting along with her husband and
children. And she would be as
polite to her own family as she is
to strangers if she knew that hold
ing her job depends on it.
A man may submit to being hem
pecked himself, but he hasn't any
right to let his children be so
motherpecked that they leave home
to get away from it. So I advise
you to summon up enough intestinal
fortitude to tell your wife that if
anybody has to get out of the home
it won't be you and the children.
DOROTHY DIX.
Evening star., 1939-07-01
Mrs. Snyder Guest
OF the ClarkeS

Mr.. and Mrs. Aubrey l.. Clarke
have as their guest Mrs. William H
Snyder of Miami, Fla, who will re-
main with them several weeks.
Mr.. and Mrs. Clarke and their
guest will spend the week end and
holiday at the formers country
place at Possum Point, near Quanti-
co, Va.
Evening star., 1939-07-01
Mrs. Thorn Hostess

Mrs. Alfred Pembroke Thom en-
tertained informally at dinner last
evening in honor of Mr.. and Mrs.
George l.. Stanley of New York,
who were recently married and who
are Mrs. Thom's house guests at
Pembroke Park, her home on Van
Ness street.
Evening star., 1939-07-01
Col. R. S. Beightler Weds
Miss Claire Springer;
Gov. Bricker Is Best Man
Ceremony Performed in Memorial
Chapel at Walter Reed
Hospital

The Governor of Ohio, Mr. John w Bck
for COL Robert Sprague
Beght OF Marysvie, Ohio at his Springer
daughter OF late
The wedding took place the at Walter
Reed Hospital Chaplain o. c. Oliver officiating O'Clock White
carnations filled the altar
which light.
Senator Clyde
marriage Her wedding Chanlv
made with tght-hed bodice heashaped nkne
sleeves The full skirt
train In the back Her veil held
fngep net veil which fell her
with shower of lilies of the valley
S. Harold
Is Maron of
Chevy Nd matron of honor
with small turquoise blue buttons having
skirt
the bridegroom pink
dephinm gypsopha
Evening star., 1939-07-01
Blair-Denton Wedding
In Stamford Yesterday.

The marriage of Miss Anne Meem
Peachy Denton to Mr.. Farnham
Blair in Stamford, Conn, yesterday
is OF more than usual interest in
washington, where the bridegroom
makes his home and where the
brides aunts, the Misses Peachy
live. The wedding took place in st.
Johns Episcopal Church, the rector,
the Rev. Gerald Cunningham, off,
ciating before an altar which had
no decoration except the Easter lilies
in the altar vases.
The bride was escorted bv Mr..
Charles H. Drayton. jr, and given in
marriage by her mother, Mrs. Harold
Pomeroy Denton, widow of Mr.. Dem
ton, prominent editor and lecturer.
Her wedding gown was of white sat-
IN made on medieval lines with
train. Her tulle veil was held by a
coronet Of orange blossoms and she
carried a prayer book covered with
lilies of the valley.
Mrs Robert Walsh Emott of Nor
ristown. N. j.. was matron Of honor
ano wore turquoise blue mousseline
de sole with Watteau hat to match
and she carried bouquet of summer
flowers. The brides other attendants
were Mrs. John Morse Rea and Miss
Jane A. Mckay of New York. They
were dressed in peach color mousse
line de sole, their Watteau hats
matching the dresses and they car
ried old-fashioned bouquets.
Mr.. Bindley McMillin Gillespie of
Erie. Pa, was best man and the
ushers were Mr.. Cyrus Woods
Thomas and Mr.. Malcolm w. Starr
of New York. Mr.. Robert w. Emott
OF Morristown, N. j., and Mr.. DON
aid Warner of Stamford.
Mrs. Kay Cammack, godmother
of the bride, was hostess to the two
families and the wedding party, en-
tertaining in the garden of her
country home near Stamford imme-
diately after the ceremony.
Later Mr.. and Mrs. Blair left for
a wedding trip. the brides travelling
costume being suit of aquamarine
silk with which she wore burgundy
accessories. They will live in WASH
ington.
Mr.. Blair is son of Mr.. and Mrs,
Robert S. Blair of New Canaan.
Conn.,, and was graduated from the
Asheville School in North Carolina
and attended the University of vir-
ginia. He is with a patent law Arm
IN Washington. Mrs. Blair was
graduated from the Laurel School
in Cleveland and attended Bryn
Mawr College She Is a direct de.
scendant Of the Rev. Richard Den.
ton, one OF the founders Of Stam-
ford, Conn, and through the ma
ternal side comes from a long line
OF distinguished Virginians.
Mr.. Paul A. Blair and Mrs. Z.
Charlton Graves of Washington
were among the out-of- town guests
and others included Mrs. Wallace
Farnham Of Hartford, Mrs. Charles
H. Drayton of Charleston, 8. c.; DR..
Samuel B. Grubbs Of Indianapolis,
Mr.. Frederic s. Peachy of Cam
bridge, Mass; Mrs. Rathbone Gard
ner Of Providence, r. l.; Mrs. Fred
erick G. Phillips Of Cleveland and
Mrs. 5indley McMillin Gillespie Of
Erie.
Evening star., 1939-07-01
BOrt.RednOnd

The marriage IS announced OF
Miss Mildred Roselee Redmond OF
this city to Mr. William Lewis Bort
son of Mr.. and Mrs. Harry Bort
which took place last evening at 8
o'clock. The Rev. C. A. Brubaker
of Mount Zion Baptist Church Off
ciated
Evening star., 1939-07-01

was held by coronet of seed pearls
with clusters of orange blossoms at
each side. Her bouquet was of bride
roses and lilies of the valley.
Mrs. Carlisle H. Robey, aunt of
the bride, was matron of honor and
wore rose color embroidered mar
quisette and a doll hat to match,
and carried Killarney roses. Miss
Dorothy Mccarthy was maid of
honor and had a similar costume
TO that of the matron of honor in
chartreuse and carried yellow roses.
The bridesmaids were Miss Cath
crime Fritter, Miss Georgia Nau,
Miss Kathleen Gwin and Miss Mary
Smith. They were dressed in frocks
of lace and net, two in peach color
and two in romance blue Their
doll hats matched their dresses and
they carried garden flowers. Peggy
Jones, cousin of the bride. was flower
girl, wearing a quaint frock of blue
net with a pink ribbon in her hair
and carrying basket filled with
rose petals.
A'AA' NAAAoAi " oOuSclldl Vi SllVeT
Spring, Md, was best man and the
ushers were Mr.. George Carpenter.
lr.. OF Newburg, Md, brother of the
bridegroom; Mr.. William B. john
son, Sd, of Washington; Mr.. Robert
F. Eldridge of Chevy Chase, Md,
and Mr.. Carlisle H. Robey, uncle
of the bride.
A reception was held in the home
OF the brides parents, which was
decorated in yellow and white, and
among those assisting were Mrs.
F. l.. Carpenter of Elkins, w. Va.
slster-in-law of the bridegroom, and
Mrs. Vera Jones. aunt of the bride,
/ Mr.. and Mrs. Carpenter left later
Tor wedding trip the bride wear
Ing navy blue and white marquisette
with accessories to match. They
Will make their home in Takona
Park, Md. Mr. Carpenter is a grad
uate of Glasva High School at
Faulkner, Md, and the Bliss Elec.
trlcal School, where he now is a
member of the faculty. Mrs. Car.
! penter was graduated from McKin-
ley High School and both Mr.. and
Mrs. Carpenter are members of old
southern Maryland families.
Evening star., 1939-07-01
Ken to Publish Lost
Issue on August 3
Hy the Associa . ted Press.

BY the ASSociated PreSS.
NEW YORK, July 1.-The weekly
magazine Ken" win suspend pubh-
cation with the August issue, Editor
Arnold Gingrich announced yester-
day.
Evening star., 1939-07-01

Mrs Otto Torney Simon has gone
to Canada, where she is spending
the summer months at McGill Uni
versity IN Montreal.
Mrs. w. A. Liddell. her son, Mr..
w. A. Liddell. jr.. and her daughter.
Miss Betsy Liddell of Lee Heights.
have gone to Wellfeet, Cape Cod, to
spend the summer.
Evening star., 1939-07-01
Social Notes of Interest
To Diplomatic Set
In the Capital
Sonora de Alfaro and Brother Are
On Motor Trip to Canada;
Marlers Leave Capital

Ecuador accompanied
by her brother Arturo Pug left
The Ambassador remaining at their Mayfowe
Lady have gone to Canada where
the Minister will recupeate from illness will
Legation, A. Riddeu is Charge
dAfaires.
interesting family
City a cottage
ing July and August
Justice and Mrs Sutherland
and have taken house sockbdg where they will
the summer months
William plan
mountains before they their after Congress
Charge and
Sunday during of
and Nine Peu the latter cousin of Herr Thomson M and Nine
country
They will sail from with Norwegian
royal party to return to their home il Oslo.
Charge dAfaires Don Qunanila
went Gettysburg Sonora Quntana
family their
The Counselor Norwegian en-
tertan this afternoon from o'clock reception farewell
OF Mrs Tyrggo Slqueland Chicago Mr. and Mrs Knudn
married last Norway
where they month before
Turkey
guests
will
biscuits and other Norwegian dishes
Members
have been invited to good-by to the popular couple
time They will be Washington
Secretary Embassy Countess Roberti with
Canon Strings
for the week end and holiday.
The Atache of the Embassy
today fortnight during which he will
spend some time at the Worlds
Evening star., 1939-07-01
War Orders Placed

The British war Office has placed
orders totaling s2,50O,0O0 in North
ern Ireland for ticking, kitbags and
other articles.
Evening star., 1939-07-01

BARONESS PIANTONI
1t simply astonishing
ngs odd bits OF dispose This
Of tranges crocheted Of
handle It be made larger joining
pattern envelope complete
tated directions with diagrams
what material and how much will need.
obtain stamps
coin service and postage Address orders the
Editor Of The Evening Star.
Evening star., 1939-07-01
Points for Parents
BY EDYTH THOMA

When parents are teachers, the
results are mpdnionship and
triendltness; 1Dhen parents are fault
finders, the results are iH-WiH and
dntdqoniSms.
Evening star., 1939-07-01
Big Fish Caught

A beluga, a species of sturgeon,
caught recently in the Caspian Sea,
weighed 1,500 pounds.
The Waterbury Democrat., 1939-08-14
Real Estate For Sale
Houses For Sale
Off Hamilton Ave.

A nice 1-famlly house or rooms and garage, price $3,500.
The Waterbury Democrat., 1939-08-14
ADDITIONAL SPORTS =.
OVERLOOK GIRLS TENNIS TOURNEY

First round matches in the third annual Overlook Women's Tennis tournament will begin tomorrow morning at the Fulton Park courts. Mrs. Anna Moran Genua, seeded number one player, and three oth- CTS have drawn first round byes.
 Mrs. Genua will be defending her Overlook title for the third year. Mrs. Burns, Kay Wolff, Marguerite Weidorn, Peggy Jay, Dora Eurell, Kay Shukis and others are prepared to offer her competition of the sternest type and the matches should provide spectators with a fine brand of tennis.
 The players will be competing for the beautiful J. Francis Smith trophy, 8 fourteen inch silver sta- tuette which will be presented to the winner after the finals either Sat- urday or Sunday of this week.
 Earrings
 The pairings as announced today are:
 Tuesday; Kay Mcknight vs Frances Weidorn 10:30 a. m.
 Christian Kelly vs. Kay Kaslaus- kas 10:30 a. m.
 Margaret Wallace vs. Dora Eurell 500 p. m.
 Doris Nelson vs. Marie Mullen 6:00
 Mrs. Pierpont vs. Helen Shukis 500.
 Peggy Mahoney vs. Mary Louise Parsons TOO.
 Josephine Russell vs. Elaine Gra- ham 700.
 Arlene Chatfield vs. Susan Sulli- van TOO.