Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1931-11-27

n ClCNCn III Id I1GCCoOdAJ w
take into account not only
men but teams Competition il
how so keen that on any winning
big college eleven all the players
must be good. ANY man who
Stands out on a strong eleven
which plays strong opposition
must he very good.
For that reason you cannot fairly
pick Campiglio, West Liberty, ovel
Erickard, Harvard. You don't know
bust how Campiglio would be on Har-
ward but you are pretty sure Orchard
would star for West Liberty.
Irrespective of scores, the strongest
leans in the East probably are at theiI
Apeak, Pittsburgh, Harvard, Yale, Army
dartmouth, New York University; COZ
gate, Fcrdham, Bucknen, Cornell. Co
@umbia, Pennsylvania, Holy Cross, SYRIA
Ncuse, Carnegie, Brown, Temple, George
Blown Lafayette, Villanova and perhaps
ID couple more. We have not tried to
name them in order.
The only unbeaten team in the East
AS Bucknell. The elevenS with the
hardest schedules were Army, Dart
mouth, Pennsylvania, Harvard, Yale,
New York University, Pittsburgh and
Earnegie. There is not an eleven named
(which has not one or more stars, and
Ehere are plenty of teams not named
9with at least one star.
THERE viii be disagreement with with any
do Is to be honest according to
your lights. Bucknell, for instance,
played an exceedingly hard schedule
afor its class, and while tied by Geneva,
ffemple and Villanova, defeated George
Nown, Washington and jefferson and
Fordham. But we frankly believe that,
while deserving tremendous credit,
when Bucknell beat Fordham it beat
q more powerful team, and we think
there are several other elevens in the
East stronger than BuckneIl. We may
be wrong. But now we want to give a
list Of players we considered before
picking the All-Eastern eleven. Here
it is:
Ends-Riblett, Penn; orsi Colgate;
BarreS, Yale; Conroy, Fordham; Co.
luc2i, Holy Cross; Hudson, Georgetown;
Hageman, Harvard; Collins, Pittsburgh;
Hugret, N. Y. U.
Tackles-Price, Army; Quatse and
McMurdo, Pitt; Schiebel, Colgate;
Marter, Bucknell Colehower and Soko-
lis, Penn; Hardy and Kopans, Harvard /;
Concannon, N. Y. u; Wilbur and Hall,
Yale; Martinez-zorilla, Cornell,
GuardS-Tindan, Syracuse; Summer
ward; Grenda, Columbia; Rotan, Yale;
Healey, Fordham; Milne, Villanova
Centers-Tuttle, Navy; Chalmers, N.
=. u; McDuffee, Columbia; Reuter-,
lafayette; Hallowell, Harvard; Reese,
Temple; Daugherty, Pittsburgh; Gil
bane, Brown.
Quarterbacks - Morton, Dartmouth;
Wood, Harvard; Whittock, Temple;
Cramer, Syracuse; Mezza, Bucknell;
O'Connell, Holy Cross; Ferraro, Cornell;
Doyle, West Virginia; Fowle, Williams !;
Hewitt. Columbia; Marsan, Brown.
Halfbacks-Kavel, Carnegie; Crick-
ard, Harvard; Stecker, Army; Mccall,
Dartmouth; Viviano, Cornell; Reider
land Heller, Pitt; Murphy, Fordham;
ERutgers; Halsted, Lehigh; Schluns,
Wesleyan; Cadigan, Amherst; Bush,
Massachusetts State.
B: Fullbacks - Perina, Penn Hinkle,
kNBucknen; Lister, Colgate; Abee, N. Y.
.; Campiglio, West Liberty; Garbank,
Allegheny.
NURTTER elimination brings the
ends to four-Orsi, Barres, Riblett
and Colucci. We will take the first
1.-Two. OTsi and Barres are about all
ENDS should be, extensively and defen-
6iyely. Each has been invaluable to his
Eteam.
There is not a man in the list who
is rot great tackle, yet two stand
out. Hardy has been a tower of
strength in the Harvard line all year.
SArny and Texas, Dartmouth, Holy
Gross and Yale have tried Eo move him
out of the way, but none ever gained
more than yards before Hardy brought
the runner down. Quatse, Pittsburgh,
ds a tackle who has been thorn in
the side Of opponents. Even Notre
Dame could do little with the Pitt
aine.
We have not seen many outstand-
Ding guards. One good one has been
Eummerfelt, Army. He has done his
Job and protected his territory in a
manner appreciated by those who know
his worth. He weighs 100 and handles
himself splendidly. Grenda. Columbia
IDS our other guard. He can take care
of himself in any company. Chalmers,
New York University, our choice for
center, was the best man in his strong
Zine.
Although no one has more admira-
tion than we for Barry Wood, a great
player, who beat Army practically
single-handed, we pick Bill Morton
Dartmouth, for quarterback. Morton
is a great kicker, great passer and
can run, block and tackle.
Orchard, our first choice for half
back, to us is the best back in the
East. Reider, Pitt; Stecker, Army;
Viviano. Cornell, and Booth, Yale, all
are good, but We pick as our other
halfback Murphy, Fordham. Crickard
and Murphy would suit us.
Perina, Lister and Abee are power
full fullbacks, but the eleven should
have at least one man from the East's
only unbeaten team, so we take Hinkle
Bucknell. He has played splendidly
during his entire foot ball career, and
any coach would be glad to get him
Morton, Orchard, Murphy and Hinkle
that's our backfield and we stick to it
kCopyright, 1881, by the North American
Newspaper Alliance, IncJ