The Ely miner. [volume] (Ely, Minn.) 1895-1986, 1923-07-27

must expand, providing additional To-
comottves cars, terminal and other fa-
cilities which mean added investment
Investors cannot be expected to put
their money into enterprises that do
not yield reasonable return-nor will
they-and it is necessary that in the
future, investors may be made to feel
that the savings they put into railroad
properties are a safe and secure in
westment. Continued attacks on rail-
roads. with the intention of destroying
their credit, will do incalculable harm
to the nation"
He summed up what has been ex-
perienced under the Transportation
Act as follows:
1. "An adjustment of all freight
rates and passenger fares to the new
level required TO put the railroads
upon a sound economic basis and meet
the increased labor costs.
2. "a sudden and unexpected decline
in traffic which introduced new dir
ficulty into the situation so that the
operations for the year 1921 were dis
appointing because they yielded a lit
tie over one-half of the intended in
terest upon the investment.
3. Reductions in rates and adjust
ments in wages in an effort TO meet
the changed conditions of traffic"
And then, after reviewing this and
other pertinent facts, he asked: DO
we want the Transportation Act to be
continued? or, Do we want 70 destroy
It? The answer involves the whole
question of the public's interest in the
subject of transportation and how IL
may be best served. The public's In
terest is primarily centered upon the
amounts they must pay as passenger
fares and freight rates. These are de-
termined by four factors, namely, ~
Wages; (2) Fuel and Material Costs;
! (3) Taxes, and "a Interest on Invest
ments. If these four elements are just
and reasonable, it follows that the
rates themselves must be just and rea-
sOnable. If the rates themselves are
too high, then one of these four fac
tors is being overpaid. The public is
I Just now confronted with rates ap-
proximately fifty per cent higher than
in 1917, but from every reasonable
/ economic point of view, these rates
are fully justified by comparison with
the general price levels of other COM
modities, and particularly Of other
services. There is at the present time,
no perceptible slackening up of COM
merce due to the so-called high freight
rates, and the bare fact that the COM
merce of the country is moving freely
is evidence that the freight rates them
selves are fully within the value OF
the service rendered TO the public.
1.-THE Rule of Matchmaking, Section
15a of the Law. should be upheld by
every right-thinking citizen, and when
the full knowledge reaches the Ameri-
can public that it is a measure con-
forming strictly to the Constitution
and as just and reasonable as human
intellect can conceive, it will meet
with popular approval"
Mr.. Finley emphasized the fact that
st was necessary and is still neces-
| y,
| the railroad field, that the Congress of
| the United States, speaking for all the
people, should assure investors in rail-
road securities that the administrative
authorities will fix rates upon a basis
that will afford fair return. and that
| the holders of railroad securities will
not be relegated to the impracticable
~ nffD I,I
through the ordinary channels of liti-
cation.
"While there Is no guaranty con-
tanned anywhere in the Transportation
| Act. yet Section 15a does express the
policy of giving fair treatment with
out the necessity of litigation.
ITO repeal the Transportation Act
now would amount 20 a legislative
declaration that the Interstate Com
merce Commission was invited TO do
an unconstitutional thing. to-wit fix
! rates that would not produce a fair
return upon the value of the property,
! for the most that is contained in the
| Transportation Act upon this subject
! is found in paragraphs two and three
of Section 15a, and they may be
analysed briefly as follows:
! 'First-It is provided that the Inter-
state Commerce Commission shall fix
rates which will produce fair return,
as nearly as may be, upon the value OF
the railway properties devoted to the
| transportation service.
t.
lied, from time to time. to determine
what percentage or rate of return will
constitute fair return.
"To now repeal that portion of the
Transportation Act referred to would
amount TO a declaration by the people
of the United States that they were
not willing to have their administra-
tive officers fix rates that will produce
a fair return, even as that fair return
is determined by the Interstate Com
merce Commission, on the present
basis of 81 per cent.
81 do not believe that the people of
the United States, when properly APP
prised of all the facts, will permit
their representatives in the Congress
of the United States, through legisla-
ton, to announce that it is the pur-
pose and policy of the Government to
deny fair return upon fair values OF
railway properties. Such would be
the effect at this time of repeating
Section 15a of the Act TO Regulate
Commerce.
'The TRANSFORMATION Act undertake es
to establish, by government sanction,
the elements within the cost Of trans
portation, two Of which, wages and in
terest on the investment, have had
considerable public attention drawn to
them by propaganda of organized la
hnr- the hand md raoIitiniana