New-York tribune., 1922-11-25

S 81 Other game l'aS ao1ss OF "lli q
4 r.soa, attempting in any way eoS
..st tha result, save TO say the
Aas better chance than at ane
s .srsa for the last thrce years, it
4 .nrsar that the Army, if 1t WINS,
Hte,y TO do so by a comfort
~ ~ rsarssn than is the Navy. The
ssss 80. nscpls say they have O better
M-, .ssn for three years, and last
Il woa BY single touchdown.
81 b II ,hss iugic amounts 20 anything
-, vii be harder game for the
Y lsAipmen to win. The Army has
- Isrse stra ght games to the Navy
I he Cadets believe they will end
i ~ string TO-DAY West Points last
sssry vas in 1915. no games being
q ssgsd In 1917 and 1918.
& Eoveyer, the Navy can recede sev-
z mi degrees from last years excellence
Il ri still be a big afternoons handful
q D. The best. The players will fight
Inst as hard and just as relentlessly,
u ;hisb they II need to do, for this game
IA stand-off in determination and
i gssined effort.
ID Both Strong on Defense
Il Ihe defence on both gides Is very
soug. and two better lines won I
szs together this year. Save by mis-
q Bsnee. thege Will have TO be finesse
q * strategy for either Go cross the
q asrs .goai line, but forward nassing
q s snd running and clever maneuyer-
81 kg behind the line make the field
q snesAe and strategy pretty broad.
& looks as If the scoring outlook,
8 R5e from field goals, depends mostly
b diversity of attack and that each
u fse will have need for all of its re-
slrcss.
& Ihe Navyfs running game against
4 issn State YVES not good, but to help
Il ss sailors were forward pass well
4 ascuted and we'll chosen as 20 time,
4 han Stata fumbling and Penn States
ros judg ng of several long Navy
4 skss. The Army against Yale showed
u as fine squirt, and against Auburn,
4 ltsam that heat Centre, also showed
q aience Of an attack likely to de-
i sop into something formidable.
u There liant the speed in tho Army
xkAeld there is at Annapolis, but the
q lagy backs have not impressed, me az
u sking with the combined gurenesa
I'D force Of the Army's backs. The
4 pssntial ability Of the West Pointers
d gain ground steadil5 seems greater.
Il Both are above the average IN GOOD
q assution with the forward pass and
81 gs It with nice judgment as part or
8 he assortment OF plays.
j The Navy on end running strikes
4 With speed and quickness and usually
aa' good interference to help Rarchet,
4 tas fastest back on either side. If the
Et9 i the Navy, the soldiers will
hssthard time stopping it's end run
niag EN3etaos OF tackle. There will
y sitasg Of work fore the Army out
Sos1 ana backfield defence. An alert
4 aeaes will be required to stop the
isFs passing and end running.
Also Il is probable the Navy will
\ hFa harder time than heretoforee
Eszg its plays started. The Army's
igsard line is aggressive and alert on
assaee. the sort to throttle hostile
Egs In their incipiency, and not slow
stiyining a rivals purpose. In vigor
md continuity Of drive the soldier
ssn has shown 60 better advantage
VI, fall than the Navy-shown, in
Eors4 better punch. On the other
haad, the Navy, we'll equipped in
anergency plays. has shown no little
snsek Of going forward when apparent
Y ssumped.
Army Better in kicking
he midshipmcns kicking-and the
seEing game has been prominent in
We tactics of the recent big games
US been TOO erratic for il to be listei
the eqnti Of the Army's as weapon
Srday. Wood, of che Army, is one Of
Me pest punters of the year. He is
consistent and kicks so that the punts
can De we'll covered, which thew nearly
Siways are Cullen, OF Annapolis, can
S,Ss Ssa Iursner, but more height and less
u.Slsnee would be vastly better for his
@lo' and other downfield men.
AZ IaFcaet Vas not in good trim @ while
sa sss ano wss catching punts poorly,
sasY say 10 ts fit now, but even so he
ut ~, naye TO be a near-sure catch %
so.u MS own with Smythe, a top
sts sqsshef at receiving kicks, Barchet,
M any sort of chance for a geta-
sssy, ,s more likely TO run them back.
Sas army is the better team in the
msalag department and in the aeri1i
game as a whole.
me Navy. on form and thus Far. is
a iIs eettsf equipped on the ends OF the
sas' !aylor and Parr are frst-ciass
ssa crafty, too, and the former Is
sstss.a1uNefully. quick and vigilant. He is
a'elssa and covers ss much ground
s. aeelense SO any line man of the year.
49, rather put it over Goodman, the
10y 1sckie, last year, but the latter
se'hg better this year.
me end playing of Parr and Taylor
ksaes aigher than that OF White and
,S.ock: or the Army. but though
a.. OF the Navy, Is q tackle of the
H. aass. the Army appears to have
oettef Of It with Mul!igan and
fsasa to match against Boiles and
sis.., iss or walker, whichever is the final
Cadet Guards Excel
~ a ans guard, Carney, of the Navy.
experienced. but pair for pair
ssIsy ard Winkjer, Of the Navy. and
ssss5 and Farwick. of sne Army--I'd
ssssI sssl pave the latter for steadiness.
SsSS. SSea, at center, Is good, but !
gsss.. whether any better than
AM sssswss Of the Navy. On paper the
ssas.a aile is stronger, and it has been
ANrs enough In reality TO suit any-
slss1 M yeL seeing the Navy line in ac-
Az skes one wonder IL there are
7Ess s9sf ones ard, IL SO. where +!
soas,Ssoas. sos better on the Geld than in |
4 is.sS.a,yy backfeld has more dash.
Dot i 'hhifticr hticr and faster individuallv
geod'. pssster s.r as cooperative Quartet
atl.isa .a'cking and no inconsiderabIe |
he 20 thrust through openings in |
Rsn s..0ke MAKE him an Offset to Rarebet
kssd sa p the Navy mans greater |
see /, narchet is more dangerous
tess vh gets loose, and he is at his |
AZ en tne Army is the other team
sayths quarterback pure and simnIs
Asssae rs az efficient as cagro,5 pS .piS