The Washington herald., 1922-12-06

would have the time for a tho
sollege teams. But pre-suppose
unity could be provided, we w
resitancy.
The selections, which were ap--
1roached gingerly because Of the
-reat showing Of many players dur
.ng the season and because Of the
limits imposed in making choices for
eleven men. are for an all-around
team, offensivly and defensively.
h-rr. Navy -. L. z. Gray. Princeton
Treat Princeton L. T'.-.. Mehahon.
oiekenson. Primo L. G. Hubbard. Har.
BOwser. Pitts. Center. .Garbisch, Army
5.aiisn. brown. R T. =. Baker. Prince.
White, Army R. e.. Human, Yale
Hu.lI. Harvard. q; B; ;smythe; Army
Drummer. LsFay. n. II. b. Jordan. Yale
ksw. Cornell r. n. Wood. Army
A consideration of the deeds of the
men on both these elevens leads to
the concern that they would furnish
a terrific contest if pitted against
each other. The first eleven. how
ever. would be our choice to win.
BOTH MEN FAST.
Parr and White are splendid de-
tensive and offensive ends. Both are
fast downfield. both tackle hard. and
both are clever receiving a forward
pass and in running. There was lit
tie to choose between Parr and
White and Gray and Human on GO
ing downfield and for alertness and
IN tacklinG. But White and Parr
were much better on receiving and
running with the forward pass. Both
starred in this respect in the Army
and Navy game.
Treat stood out above all tackles
I'm the East. He shone against Chi
cago. Harvard and Yale.
II was Treat who recovered a FUN
bIe by Gehrks that paved the way
for Princeton touchdown.
Gulian At the other tackle caught
the eye Of all close observers in all
the games Of Brown by his sensa-
tional tackling and all around work.
BROWN STAR BETTER.
McMahon. of Penn. State. and
Baker. Of Princeton, are as good as
Guilan in strength and speed, but
the Brown luminary seemed the bet
ter on breaking through and smear
ing plays. In truth. however, his
edge over the second team pair is
very small. Guilan is the quicker
first team guards, did wonderful
work for their team in all games.
They outplayed their opponents in
virtually every game. Dickinson
outplayed Hubbard, OF Harvard. by
n wide margin. And the Princeton
left wing, because Of him, was the
strongest in the East. He also was
wonderfully inspiring captain.
Breidster did wonderful work for
Army. being fast and strong. and
also stood out as team leader.
welch and Hubbard. second team
choices. starred repeatedly. but both
are more than shaded by the first
team choices. in our opinion, Welch
cut great holes and blocked splen-
didly for Colgate against every team
hut Cornell Hubbard shone every
where above his opponent except
against Princeton.
Bowser. Of Pitt, is hailed quite
generally as the best rowing center
OF the East and a fast and accurate
passer that has no superior His
margin over Garbisch. Of Army,
however. is small The Army cen
teF's kicking ability-his placement
goal won for Army over Navy
makes up in part for his lack as a
ground cover compared with Bow
ser
BJ ELL Is GENIUS.
Buell.. Of Harvard. At quarter
back. is a genius as field general
He iS wonderful manipulation of
nlays. Without him Harvard was
inpotent. with him. team to be
reckcned with at all times Har-
ward was beaten by Princeton after
he was injured: he was in when it
10 al
ward passer and a runner. IL need
be
Smvthe, Of the Army is a smart
leader, too. and a star at forward
Passing and running back punts.
We hold, however. that Buell. can
get more out Of team and is not
inclined 10 orr as much.
The backtield Of Owen. a great
plungeT. splendid runner. a field goal
Kicker, passer and great on the
defensiv"-an all-around star; OF
Drummer. leading scorer of the East,
2 drop kicker and 2 passer. and Of
kaw, A tremendOuh ground gamer
and inspiring open field runner, a
wonderful intercepter Of forward
passes and a kicker, is truly an un--
bes "a BILE one.
This trio Of backs have the edge
on W 4lSOns JOTCan ana W GOD. nut
on the second team. The latter trio
are splendid line smashers. can run
and pass. and Wood stands out as a
punteT However. our first team
selection has done and would do.
We believe, the greater things
The first team and the second
team. too, but particularly the first
team. would be great on defense,
great on Offense in the running and
aerial attack and most capable in
the drop kicking deparamtnt 1t
would he great. too. defensively
against the forward pass. Kaw has
spoiled more than any other player
in the East. and Owen. Drummer and
Buell. are smart diagnosing where a
pass is going and getting there.
WERE OTHER STARS.
others entitled to honorable men,
tion are: Ends. Stout. Of Prince
ton; Jenkins. Of Harvard: McRae,
of Syracuse; Eddy, Of Yale: Mahaney,
II Ill