Eagle River review. [volume] (Eagle River, Wis.) 1890-1927, 1922-10-13
WHAT BECAME OF A. T.
STEWARDS BODY?

WHEN Alexander 7. Stewart died,
w on April 10, 1876, in New York
city, he was credited with being one
Of the richest merchants in the United
States, for his wealth was estimated
at more than S40,0OO,0OO, including
real estate which, alone, was assessed
at over $5,0O0,0O0. The bulk of his
estate was bequeathed to his widow,
with a million dollars as a personal
gift to the executor, Henry Hilton.
The Stewart funeral eliminating in
the interment of the body in st.
Marks churchyard, New York city, was
one of the largest and most impressive
ceremonies of its kind ever held in
the city-and then, some two and a
half years later, Judge Hilton, the
executor of the Stewart estate, cleo
trifed the police with the announce
ment that the grave had been rif1ed
and Mr.. Stewards body stolen.
Upon examination, 1t developed that
an even greater mystery surrounded
the affair than appeared upon the
surface During the early autumn Of
1873, Judge Hilton, learning that the
grave had been slightly tempered with
and fearing the depredations of
ghouls, had caused the Stewart head
stone to be removed to another por-
ton of the plot, although it was not
thought wise at that time to disturb
the remains. The knowledge of this
change was confined to four persons,
but Notwithstanding this, the eXcava-
ton had been made with almost math-
ematical precision, the earth having
been cut away straight down to the
leaden case which enclosed the coffin.
This case had been opened, the lid
of the coffin had been unscrewed and
the body taken presumably being
carted off in wagon of which the
tracks were still visible nearby.
The most searching inquiries on the
part of the police failed to reveal any,
one who had seen the grave-robbers at
work, for they had chosen stormy
night and it was not until several
hours after daylight that the watch
man had discovered the footing of the
merchants grave. The ghouls had
left behind them only a newspaper,
an iron shovel and bull's-eye lantern
none Of which bore any distinguish
ing marks, nor could they be traced
by the detectives assigned to the case.
It appeared to be impossible that the
body of a dead man could be carried
across New York city without attract
ing the slightest notice or that 1t
could be re-interred or concealed with
out detection-but this is precisely
what took place, for nothing definite
was ever learned Of the fate of the re-
mains.
Judge Hilton refused to countenance
overtures for the return of the body,
declaring that neither he nor the es-
tate would be blackmailed and, when
a reward of $4,000 was finally offered
1t was made with the distinct under
standing that it was not for the body
itself but for information which would
lead to the detection Of the persons
who had committed the depreciation.
The executor of the estate advised
Mrs. Stewart to have no dealings
whatever with the men who had
stolen the body of her husband and
the widow, who is said to have been
extremely affected by the blow, fol-
lowed this advice during the ten re-
naming years of her life.
Some time after the violation of the
sanctity of ST. Marks churchyard, the
impression was allowed to gain preva-
lence that the body had been re-
covered and that it had been rein
tered in the vault Of the beautiful
cathedral at Garden City, Long Island
But those who attempted to secure
proof of this report found that they
were blocked at every turn and the
question Of who stole the body of A.
7. Stewart and what disposition was
made of it remains unsolved to this
day.