New-York tribune., 1922-06-18


sion. IS ! par putting ny cos, o.
the hall ! got her attention for :.
men' s1d said: "i cann5' 70 ~.
without telling you that ths p,,,.
Who touched you vas no' Jour nsrs
but ne. ard The voice you hoard o..
not yogr riothefs. be Mrs. Johrvrr
ard. without waiting for ary comn,,.
departed.
The following corfesponde1c. IA
since fako, piece 49, ~ publ, s,..
mory would certainly have b's 80
coined 'a tae cver' ~ ny hsg.sg s..,
converted" by this psrformsre,. ! ~.
s'aer that an right ir g.v.rg
cosrt o. De-. even though 80 fnz
ras '6o opposite ~ vha' SIP 4rls
hoped 'ni expected;
December g. ifn.f
"My Dear Conan Doyle ~
thank yol ard Lady Conan Doy. =
your ao,p.ta.ify yesterday ard fsf ~,
kindness % arranging pr mo- - as
part in the 'eance.
AS yog kHo7 ! wsr' o. .' r.'s q
o.eo and sympsthote mIri r.asY
sour BOOK had produced = very ..rs.
effect s7or me anl rad .r-.1.s 1,
toward azrccnrrt gs'e It' 'a'sv,,,.
lion n the phi'os,phy ~ sp.r.,ss'.ss
Ny experience oftrs ses1cs sss .s.,
nothing 90 weaker that .norsss.ss, u
! it has doEe nothing 20 strengthen q
because an convinced tfat IRA. IA,
pened a, the house in H.gsga,s IA
itt'e or nothing % 10 Tiin wsi, "a.
have written about vas .a ,sr.
fec,.y calm and observsr' mad iave
IN extremely highly trained mrf,a'
ear. abrormaily senf'iy, 20 as,,.l.u
IN dialects ard Dronsrciar5-. .in
also = long experience ~ orgir pl,a
rosonators ar3 frc acoustic cgec,s =
,rbes.
~ can say o. orcc f- yca a5sl, ~
sesrce thar ro MAJ. feffstio- - sss.,.
natural force occurred is-re. ,,,t re
origin ana ~etsei o, pr'dl-tio, p, s..s
mar.icf'a'or1 ar did occur v,,s r.s.s.
.y apparent % ms. T. my srss. regret
! came % tro clear ee-e'sslsa Eat,
r.th ono possible exception, re 7.s-
Pc present were -seossciogfly .u.
very willingly dsee.uas 'aen,>.va
ard ono arotter
Friendship Shattered By
Guests Aet.oas a. Sitting
You VII. ro, 10 pleased r.'s ~
for 'ais. 5u, carro, bs aryts.rz l,u
.han candid wi,, yog - ye- so s,i.
v'nced an vror~ ard car .s,rss.u
me 70 a ssance whcrs 7 an Nss'g .
500 naturalization of ,e-s sssy
may siterwsri BE- able - tel yos is-e
thing mors abo4, it n ar . ~
anything - tha, kind n,s's ,iAv
wa.t until 7 haee seer - t,ior, ,,!'S
you what nave 20 ,e,, ssos, 81. x.
currenees yesierday aNsra,e-
yours sincerely.
"FlLSON T0uNGT
Dear Sir: vas shocked isl
amazed 20 learn from Nrs .sr
you had admitted % ts- sf.er =,
seance tha. yos rad been 7rosse.a
bogus phenomena ard had seized Il,
trumpet ,h.s interfering ai;h re prs
eeedisss ard spo.Hng the si't.ng
could not have conceived yss capa5ls
as my guest, of ae'i-s i- sgss man
ner fear ,ha. ,h.s vrp.sasa,, .se'
der. mgs. p, ,hs end o. our ,eqlaia
aace. have apo.ogIzed % Mrs. Joas'
son and the o;tsrs.
Yours faittiuliy
a. CONAN DOYLE
p. ST. held this over for ,g,a.y-
four hours lcs, should seem . VITA
in anger"
l5th Dsesmtss, 1911.
Dear Coran Doyle Yosf i,.,sf.
which ,a.nk silly in forr ast rTFy
in spirit shall nor prevent re iic=
saying that Go no, aceer, yesf $50
.gration ~ my conduct o, tbs sears
You asked nc 20 come ard see tH
myself; blt as We were IN g..ea aifs'
ness was lc.t % rely on NY ssa"i q
touch and hearing % dctcc. 81. dFssS
fraud that was prasi.cct spos ~
You evidently do rot ever wiss
hear what discovered; bss IS ?,
nave taken upon yourself 20 'spologi's
for me % people whom % ns; kr'''
/ mus, v.nd,eate myse.f. There vs' q
compac, or suggestion TIA, ,hls v~
conspiracy Ia wh.ch Z was % ,ois .
TIA, ,he test of common sense VI
not 20 be applied. yog invited q, a..
Z The result o. rs application IS W.
your letter suggests. YOUR science. p
fear is IN a bad way. But ;or ne ~
poor woman would hsve gone home .
the belief that her dead mother Ia
touched and spoken % heg. and thsi
regard as 4 rather sinister matter
Il shall publish th, facts With ~
letter % you and yours 20 me- ss'
you vii. be free % make whai re7l
you Ike. Yours sincerely,
"FiLsON YovNGs
Sir: To publish Proceedings ~fs'
are ths resu!, Of . private iavita'''.
70 private house Is quite consli'ea'
with the res, o. your conduct. ls'
only credulity shown b. any Of ~