Albuquerque morning journal., 1922-01-31
RULING
IS RENDERED BY
SUPREME COURT
Booze Stored in Private
Warehouses Cannot Be
Withdrawn BY Owners
For Their Personal Use.
(By The Associated Press.)

Washington Jan. 3O.-IntoXicat-
ing liquors stored in government
bonded warehouses cannot be with
drawn by the owners for their per-
sonal use, the supreme court today
held in 4 decision delivered by
Justice McKenna, and dissented to
by Justice McReynolds. Such liquor
can only be transported from the
bonded warehouses, Justice Nc
Kenna stated, ito a wholesale drug
gist for sale to him for purposes
not prohibited"
The court in a previous decision
held that owners could withdraw
from private warehouses liquor for
their own consumption or for the
use OF their family or their bona
fide guests. Today's ruling marks
a wide distinction between private
and bonded warehouses,
Justice MCkenna said "more
ownership was not the equivalent"
to possession and declared that uu-
der the Volstead law there must
be ownership and possession in
ones private dwelling, and that
character cannot be assigned to
the bonded warehouses of the gov
ernmcnt" The cases did not, he
said, have the effect Of dcpriving
those who held warehouse certifi-
Gates of their property without due
process of law. nor did it amount,
he added, to the taking of private
property for public purposes with
lust COmDpnSatiOn
I'eLel liIiS 10 'lle C9n'eIlt'ou -
Itlt piot,IpItIoii sliiIlIl'llSI anu .iIe
oI.'tetlu 49, II "i'pIigu ~ i'Huo
mo-. u, ~ t,l su anu 10" .,'l,s
Iu 49, I''e II Nv
IiIg Ia" peI.l,,i9 I.; tlieC'l.g, Win pe
VIZ "" .INli,S .ii,S 'l.t p -"
vsseil l'at alli ~ u'eS VI 'mslI go ~ -
80 10 ,ioTS ~ S. t'l, +ia fi-!' oo,,t
49, 80. 5i5 ,.' S,''S' " ,'.,,( . ~ I
"as ny uls sposeu ~ 80, 80 ,l'g rto
IlT,l17 VI INC 10
y as my "gre an az" 80. g.' ~
ne Ioi 'ilgl ''eCisi9il o. t''e eoS' IA
me ua.aonal pr4nlolliuIt ,]Il4 ctaTa, ,ou.
ing ~ l.o' l,"it % ainI i'1 y"
wltlGn petilIitS o!,e !? Of7e So .'. " 10y Iia
oD.''i!,Te ltq.'oi t.l I,i7 ''t,' ,j,lbt
.iCe HiGNeIIL'a ~, asSyI 'tu o.+o,J t.t,S 10
S"liuoL St We 'olI9'l l!.,d1 uvu - 'Ns'!'u NV ~
!! ~ uoI9 ioL 50 ~, Sl.011'u, oi ~ 20
1t InoIe po'IlteuI2' III Ii..Vi,'Io'l ~
illaHe al poi,Ie" Ii,..I'i, wa viL,',99
purluIiisa vi rs u"9'Il.Ie' e'' ., T.,
LeClaiI IIs ~ ~ ~. i,,tu L'
uisasI IeTilieIIt WIN t,ie plgt.'uS ~
CIslon 'hat Iiquo IA PI ~ az a.
houses Cpulu os ID IUI'y NJ, GU ~
owners u tIleIi it'9Iq :, 20 ~
ou9c'It -N 5sry ..o'H' "a
SeIleu 'nat II lIle 49, ~ M t.,e ItlI -
uo"n PS Liie T0ui ~ tt'''. r,,,,, ~
soou, IT Woulu PEI I.iiI ',l,,i o%,1C1S ~
wllllul"w l5qIoI IloLl' , '4ilat' tbat nniase
Iiousea %iIu ne Sl5 81 ,.;o,,, ID ~ .hn,,ld
s.g sEGiS rooh ] w. Forr,,or. DO
- ailNiS "5S.iri r,,,t %" -" oaeos 1ioIror
ClsioIl. III tIiS ~ go, a,,arC,,,o,t Wv, r,arc.
was e.i'. u'7Cen ~ ~, W. stotIto
houses as ~ 4llit'Eu 49,. ~ 'lt &C., Goriod
ne saln, puc otse oi.i,,. TTIie' - l,o,Io ha-
Lne pt itiltsg o,.oIansa % I"Mi.5 10 not CON
tdGSu ts,t5,. .na va I,te Itro11ine, nor an
u iDIsol ,,,ota ~ 10 ,'o,, an outhuiId-
a. a.. 'iIor o.,rda4a', 'l.tl tbnrnvritl, "
Ing 49, ttara {riroi,,oy nreeant cases
ma - ~. .,,srooted tho remark
II, - r,,o,. oI,,s of tbo Fortv-second
90. 80 I,','it,o+,N ,-,oraLorea IN at
$50 l,s w - .e +l,o dwoiiings Of all
untno,s rttI. - ,,itbont regard IN dis
49, %. ~ >, - oantivuod referrine, TO
~ 80 Tu;,,ata t,t 1.aroborea invoIved in
~ ~ tan,,,a,, doo,sior boIdipy Iiouor
a,,l5 e,lv - 49, '.'0 t,onenartad +he,, "n1ight
Lo,.n oG,U o,oeor, a eafor course"