davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
New-York tribune., 1922-05-06
Three Justices as Art Critics
Reject Portrait OF Miss Cornell
Judgment for $1,000 Obtained by William O..
Burton, Painter, Reversed by Decision That
the Picture Is Not a Good Likeness

BY decision Of Justices Wagner,
Cohslan and Guy, sitting as the Ap.
pellate Term OF the Supreme Court,
William Q. Burton, an artist. who OBJ
tained q Judgment for 81 900 against
Mrs. Claire J, Cornell for a portrait Of
her daughter, Claire, must have his
suit tried again in the Municipal Court,
for the justices Of the higher court.
acting as judges Of art as well as Of
law. have decided that the portrait was
not q good likeness and reversed the
Judgment OF the lower court.
Mr Burton, who lives at 1855 Park
Avenue and at Elbervn, \. J., is a son
Of William s. Bcrnhcimer, a brewer,
but had his name changed. He studied
at TIE Yale School of Fine Arts, the
AIT Students League. the School Of
Applied Arts and in rars.
Mrs. Cornell who had commissioned
the artist to paint hoy daughter, not
only refused to accept the portrait, but
after Mr, Burton obtained Judgment
against her before Justice LSuer in the
Municipal Court. sued him 20 recover
corteiu property used in creating the
background for the portrait, valued by
Mrs Cornell al S1oo. This consisted of
Chinese lamp. a pieto Of Chippendalc
furniture and 4 Chirese Jade necklace
Burton said he was holding theac ar
tcics pending payment Of tho Judgment
against Mrs. Cornell Alleging that the
artist had converted her property. Mrs
Cornell obtained an order Of arrest in
her civil action. which was served
New-York tribune., 1922-05-06
100000 Face
Double Trolley
Fare i'm Queens
half of Surface Line Users
Would Have to Paw
Twice TO Reach Manl,at-
tan Under the New Plan
Hearing Set for Monday
Segregation Of the Sseinwav
Lines l. Proposed: Norii,
Beach To sse Cui Of

About half 1ho COO ooo troi,oy vs.r.
5. o.,~..,, '''00 ''o'''I users
." queens VIII nave to pay two fares
shd cnange cars to reach Manhattan
after a. II. Wednesday Il plans ON
barked unon ycstoraa. b.. o.e.;o,. 20
- ,'',' ""F - o'''0'a 10 OF
me nc" aoTk & Queens County Rail
way Company and receivers for the
Steinv'ay lines are successful.
S. W. Huff and Robert c. Price, re
Gently appointed receivers for the
Steinway lines. intend 20 segregate
their part Of the system after that
time and charge an extra fare Oh it.
v. G. Wood. president Of the New
ofk Queens County Railway Com
psny. aud A. G.. Peacock. counsel for
the compeuy, who Hled notice &C the
Intended segregation with the Transit
Commission yesterday. agreed after a
New-York tribune., 1922-05-06

bers Of The Thompson cabinc, before
they leave for home
New Workers have a scent fare
Mayor Thompson said in the first in
terview he has granted since his ar
rival. "There is no reason that | see
Why We in ChicaCo should not be able
To ride at the same rate. Officials ac-
companyinC me and Mayor Hylan arc
going 10 explore the New York subway
sy8tem and ride in the elevated trains.
After we have ridden about New York
City on scent tariffs We shall be able
to INQUIRE of the Chicago companies
why VIC cannot ride for 5 cents there.
1t will be the most practical way OF
getting to the question.
Hopes to Cooperate
"Al Of us appreciate the great re-
ception you gave us to-day, and we
shall return to Chicago feeling sure
that the bonds Of friendship will re
main unbrokcn and that we shall CO.
operate with each other as we have
done in the past in solving our respec-
tive problems.'
Mayor Thompson received many Invi-
tations to social functions yesterday,
hut rejected all Of them on tie plea
that traction matters required MS en-
tire attention.
Mayor Hylan Will entertain Mayor
Thompson and his party TO- day vt
luncheon at the Whitehall Club. White
hail Building, at noon. Following the
luncheon the officials Of both cities
will board tho tug Corrections of the
Department of Correction. for trip
around the harbor. Deoarking at the
foot Of Bay Ridge Avenue. Brooklyn,
they viii 60 to Villepigue's Inn,
Shoepshcad Bay where Mayor Hylan
will be host at q shore dinner.
Commissioner Harkncss. Of the
Transit Commission, issued Z state
ment last night in regard to The ac-
tion of the Board OF Estimate in re
jcctng the elevated extension con-
tract.
"Despite efforts to obscure it," he
said. "the issue in this case is plain.
The Transit Commission has no power
10 alter this contract. and the Board
Of Estimate, Of course, is we'll aware
Of that fact.
New-York tribune., 1922-05-06
Thompson Says Big Issue
Is ''lnterests rs. People"

Mayor Thompson and Corporation
Counsel Samuel Ettleson. of Chicago.
spoke at the transit meeting Of the
Board of Estimate yesterday. Mayor
Hylan followed their remarks with 4
brief address in which he criticized
tho Subsidized press" those news
papers, he explained, which are in favor
of the interests and who "sey nice
things about an official if he is for
the interests" but who resort "tb abuse
and yilijication if he shows dispo-
sition to DC for the people" Mr. Ettle-
son tod the story OF the "tra ction
fight by the city authorities in Chica.
60. Mayor Thompson said in part: g..
ut is a great privilege and a per
Ttral pleasure to come to this great
City of New York to renew my &C
quaintauce with your great Mayor.
whom we in Chicago recognize as the
mar of the people of the City of New
J fork. From my experience in public
life am more and more Impressed
every day with ono great thought-ir-
Ic8pectlve Of our parties or whom we
follow from political standpoints -
there is arising in both the major par
ties Of this great country Of ours a
great division, and that division. as I
sec it, is within the party between
tHoSc men who stand with the interests
and those men who stand with the
people
Message to the World
You have that here in New York;
and Il is eXcmplified not only in this
meeting to-day but IN the wonderful
F,ote given to Mayor Hvlan in his re
election The Oeople Of this city spoke
IN no uncertain terms when they re-
eler'e4 N%yoI Hyian and said to the
9eople o the United States and
TO the people Of the world: We. the
peopIa. %il stand b. public officials
VINO stanG b. us,' wnen that great vot.
was cast for Mayor Hylan and by THAI
wonderful compliment OF over 100000
majority the people OF New York on
couragod public men in public life to
continue tho fight in their behalf and
that they. would not be forgotten when
ciecuon day came around.
AS J have sat here and have heard
this diacussion and compared il
With the things that are going on in
1hicago an only more impressed
ttan ever that the people OF New York
''iN p'OpiC u, we lily or Nhlcago
rave q great deal in common and the
friendship Chat exists between vour
Mayor and tho Mayor OF Chicago and
through thst large!y the people Of New
io1k and the people of Chicago, that
'TEcn these two great cities ioin hands
on these two most important Issues,
that when we so to Washington or
when You go TO Albany or when we 20
to Springfield. H., we will be heard and
we will be given much more consider
alton than as though we stood alone.
New-York tribune., 1922-05-06

Katherine Lawrence, Suzanne Pearson.
Mrs. Augustus Tyler and Mrs. Edmond
Moore The record shows that the
agreement between Mrs. Cornell and
Mr.. Burton was that If the painting
was satisfactory the artist was to re
ceivc $1,000, and if not he was to re-
ceive no compensation. There wcro
six sittjngs. When the portrait was
delivered at the country residence of
Mrs. Cornell, at Rye, 1t was rejected
Joseph T. " ood attorney for Mrs. Cor
neil, explained that when the picture
was delivered his client was i'll, and
that on his advice it was rejected with
out being shown to Mrs. Cornell.
". j. Ralston. formerly an art dealer
and now freight broker, testified as
IN expert for Mrs. Cornell and gave it
as his opinion that tho work of Mr.
Burton waa not good likeness Of Miss
Cornell. He thought it was "most
amatcurish." Leslie Saalburg, an art
ist. "a a witness for Mr.. Burton. on
the other hand. testified that he con-
sidored tho painting "a correct likeness
and good picture
Court Couldn't Sec likeness
Mrs Cornell offered. on the trial Of
the suit, to leave the settlement Of tie
controversy to amy artist and if he
decided chat the portrait was a good
likeness Of her daughter she would
pay for it, Justice Lauer did not ac.
ccpt the offer, deciding the matter for
himself BY awarding Judgment 10 Mr.
Burton.
In deciding the appeal OF Ms Cor
nell in hor favor the Appellate Term
SAID: "On the argument of tho appeal
before this appellate court, b. the con-
scnt Of both counsel, the subject of the
portrait was present, and it was stipu-
lated that in determining this appeal
the members of tho court might COM
pare the original with the portrait. As
the result Of such comparison we are
of the opinion that tho preponderance
of evidence is entirely with the defend
ami in establishing the fact that the
portrait painted by the plaintiff is not
proper portrait likeness Of the de
tcndant's daughter"
New-York tribune., 1922-05-06
| 300 TO Sail on Homeric

The White Star liner Homeric will
sal! to-day for Southampton via Cher
bourg with 1900 passengers.
Robert Sllvercruys, charge d'affaires
Of the Belgian Embassy, who is sa-
loon passenger, has in his personal care
gift to Nine. Marie Curie from,
friends in America. 1t consists of two
very delicate instruments for testing
rad'um, galvanometer and an assay
balance, made only in this country
While visiting here last year Nine.
Cure saw instruments of this type,
which she greatly needed in expert
mental work she is doing with the
radium presented to ner by the women
cf the United States.
Anna Pavlowa, The dancer. also is
naSSen9cr
New-York tribune., 1922-05-06
Old Songs Favored a,
Concert by Yale Clubs

The annual concert of the Yale Glce,
Banjo and Mandolin Club was held last
night at the Hotel Astor. The concert
was followed by dance.
1t was to the old songs that the Glee
Club devoted itself during much of It's
program. The members sang "Annie
Laurie" "Suwanee River" "The Span
ish Cavalier" "Integer Vitae" Meath
tho Elms." "Amici" and "Old Man
Aoah.' They sang other songs. too
among them one with many verses. one
of which went:
Mint it shame to shm1nie on SUNDAY
When YOU got Monday, Tuesday Wednes-
day. Thursday. Friday. SATURDAY.
j.. n. Hall, of the class of "a, did
banjo speciality.
New-York tribune., 1922-05-06
ADVERTISEMENT

poison spreads through the whole ~.
TEN; ogans become affected; .a.
brain Sfos-s down. Any one Of n.ny
seriouS diseases is likely to follow.
Figft constipation with K.ilosr,
Brant For, Bran is natures on,
'NeRer. cleanser and purifier. |,
~ Eorrect the most chronic caut
coAf patton if it is eaten regulsrb,
il WI prevent constipation if lii.
is saten each day. For mild css.,
two tablespoonfus daily; in chroni:
cases. eat Bran with each meal. Ysr.
physician will recommend Kellogyi
Bran for constipation.
Kellogg's Bran is fine FOR childr.r
helping them grow big and robust.
kellogg's Bran is deliciousiy seu
as cereal, sprinkled over your fsyer
lte cereal, or used in baking and cook
ing. 1t makes wonderful pancas..
mullins, raisin bread. etc. See recipes
on each package! Buy Kellogg's Bn.
at your grocer's
New-York tribune., 1922-05-06
Hylan and Murphy
Warned TO Keep
Hands Off Bronx
Democrats in That Borough
Resent Attempts to Force
Nugcnt as County Leader
Instead of Sheriff Flynn

Bronx Democrats. incen8ed at the
efforts Of Charles F. Murphy and Mayor
Hylan to name a now county leader,
have sent word to the City Hall and
Fourteenth Street to keep hands OF
the Bronx and give the Democrats there
a little Of the home rule the Mayor
talks about
For two months the influence Of the
Mayor and the leader Of Tammany Hall
has succeeded in preventing the execu-
tive committee Of the Bronx Demo
cratic County Committee from voting
tor new leader, because the majority
OF the committee has been in favor Of
choosing Sheriff Edward J. Flynn.
The Murphy -Hylan crowd has been
backing Stephen A. Nugent, an old
line Tammany war horse. The most re-
cent attempt on the part Of the Mayor
and Fourteenth Street to dictate the
selection Of Mr.. Nugcnt was when the
Mayor appointed him few days ago
to the Tax Commission at salary a.
$500 year. although he is drawing
o pension from the city.
Mr. Nugent's friends in the execu-
tive committee have been using this
appointment in final effort to put
him over as proof that the Mayor want
ed Mr.. Nugent named.
n
ccnsed the friends OF sheriff Flvnn.
who np TO the time OF his election 20
the shrievalty, was a member Of the
Assembly, ranking Democratic member
Of the important Judiciary Committee.
and one Of the recognized legal experts
Of the House
Sheriff Flynn is thirty-eix years Old
and the leader Of the Younger and
progressive element in the Bronx Dem
ocratic party. His opponent has been
on the city pay roll for mora than
quarter of a century and i~ strongly
supported by the 'mossbacks" Of the
party. There is a third contender. Tn
der Sheriff Thomas ]. O'Nei1
The Flynn faction has determined on
forcing the issue next week. whcn
special meeting Of the executive commit
tee will be called and a vote forced
The election Of Sheriff Flynn as the
nav leader is assured. according TO
those who made an impartial canvass
yeste rday.
Sheriff Flynn had only bare major
ity until Mayor Hylan appointed his
rival to the Tax Commission. That
was at once resented by the Democratic
leaders in the Bronx who had been sup
porting Mr.. Nugcnt because Of Old
friendship for him and he nov, has
hardly corporal's guard behind him in
the commttee-the district leaders
who go to Manhattan for their orders.
The election OF Sheriff Flynn to the
leadership. despite the fact that he has
had q majority Of the district leaders
with him, has been prevented at the
New-York tribune., 1922-05-06
One-Cun Bud Balle1u Slain as
Police Chief Gets DruW First
Former Deputy Sheriff a, Ardmore, With 8 Notchcs
in His Pistol, Too Slow for Once With Six-Shootcr
and Plane Bears Body to Southwestern Graveyard

ARDMORE, Okla. May > (By The
Associated Press). Bud Ballcw, known
for years as one Of the fastest and one
of the most fearless ono gun men Of
the Southwest, WAS borne home to-
night in an airpiane. the victim OF a
man who beat him to the draw.
Bellcw. former Deputy Sheriff here,
the notches on whose gun bore tcsti-
mony that he had killed at least eight
men and had been The victor Of count
less other gun fights, was reputed for
his quickncss on the draw in the early
days of outlawry in the Southwest.
To day j. w. Mccormick, former Texas
ranger and now Chief OF Police at
Wichita Falls, Tex. drew and fred
first.
bud took in too much territory to-
day and for once was too slow on the
draw" was the opinion expressed by
many here tonight.
Ballew's prowoss with n six shooter
was reputed in this section as second
only to that of his chief, former Sher-
if Buck Garrett, under whom Ballew
scrved as a deputy for ten years, until
Garrett was ouStcd from othce seVeral
months ago. BalleW was afraid of only
ono man, and that man WIS his chief
When Bud went on rampage here and
in surrounding towns it usually was
Buck Garrett that took away his guns
Cracking Of Guns Warning
Lurid streams of gunfire and the
cracking Of pistols told Ardmore and
other towns many times that Bud Bal
lew was con tear 1t was Buds de
light, after imbibing, to shoot up
town in true Wild West fashion Cti-
zens made way when Bud was out to
indulge in his sport. But when Buck
appeared Bud became meek.
Residents sometimes take visitors
down the main street Of Ardmore and
New-York tribune., 1922-05-06
hylan in Evening Togs
v atches Fire Fighter
Mayor. Driving Up Broad~n
Halted by Blaze at Seven.
teenth Street

aiayor Hylan in evening dress An :,
wa up Broadway n an automobil. ~
night was halted ny cavalcsd. 49,
apparatus under Deputy Chief H., va
responding TO ar alarm from the MI NJ
ing At 1875 to 13o West Sev.n+.s.ss s.
Street. occupied by Samu.l Es-. ~
women s wear manufacturer. and Pnr
& Forst. cloak and suit makers '''
The blaze was spectacular, ne..r
tating use Of water towers and ss.s,
ladders. Fire started in TIE ba.snr
and spread through three Aoors 10
ously damaging stocks in both .,,s
iishments. During the operation, >
The Fire Department Mayor Hylan u
IN his car drawn against th. curb A..
watched the work. When Deputy cIi,i
Ross announced the fire under esn,,.
the Mayor waved gloved hand A..
shouted Good work" a. Z. r.,rr.
his way uptown.
New-York tribune., 1922-05-06

last three meetings by vote, =,
secretary and treasurer Of II. VI u,
tee. Daniel A. Carr is tyeasrsn sonni,
Hylan apPointee, who holds tn. :.
Of Commissioner Of Corrections a. os.
Commissioner Hamilton and NJ
"hile not having vote in the s.,..r .ar
Of the county leader, have bv ,9;s'ec'i's
their Office ballot on all otb.r.'as 81
tons, and theirs have been tho 9as
votes on motion to adjourn w.. ss;.cidiss
been always put before tho In iu
reached the order Of business ~ "se'i's
the leader is elected N Whit.
New-York tribune., 1922-05-06

ture, they want subway. McAncny
says the city hasn't got the money to
ouIId tho extension as a subway. but
VIC are prepared TO give the money if
the contract can be changed" (Ap-
plau5o, lattles. bells.)
0cut >,,,..,.
'""' N' VI '>o'"'i's'
ormer AideTman Charles II. 'lau-
geTl' VINO headed the Eastern Division
ocie&aNoh' ana several others spoke
~ 5aVor q the subway extension.
Ma"or Thompson followed the discus
slon &itcnt1Vely
Arc YOU WIlIln& TO nave tine resolu-
lioh sent peck TO the Transit Commis
son, naming a :. SUBWAY instead Of an
e!eNated "a. foSd asked Mayor hy an.
w ce1oa'3'E are feSponded MI
II = p'o' anP,HuSe' rattlee' peiIs)'
. paI!d ,. j . .tonnet, former Repre-
~" "ONI i""! e"e h"Sh"'ch SocNol,
delegation Wien he declared that there
had been 81 attempt to tranfer the
government Of the city to Albany in
'he person OF one man.
We are threatened With removal il
"e Go not go ahead and approve these
contf&et5, sald the Mayor
oefy the GoNo1nor toi emove an
bv = naioritv Of more +han 400 o00 ;,
shoited O'Connc1l lAnnlansc rait]cs
bojs1
The Two mayors exclaimed cianccs
and smiles.
ar H. "sN uu' C9 w.? oI ~ lF,'l
+ho ii''SlI No'"' '!iI ~ ,oI. .,lu
+ba co,tron, A. roI rofa,, ~ 0nit,, t,1s
we co''fact' d" YOU PFeIet @ an cleN2tcd
"TEe snbva@ or nothing', the crowd
shouted hack
Mr., Dooloy. Of the Irvine Civic Al.
sociatior road Letter n,Tno7tino -
be from transit Commias;onrT rT' loan JlIs y y
O'Pvsn in which bn favorod - snh,,,o,,
bnt nointod on, tLot the conna.+;nn
Win tba Nvrtln A,nn,,o o,o,,otnd H., I;,,,.
might be made bv y MOVING nlatform
o, or an ~ escaiafor NV 20 P'''' VI III
Won micbt t,v q slide Co,,nt,o,lor
Craie, sugqestcd
vote To Repair Roofs, Anyway
". G. Fullem, associate counsel for
the Transit Commission, was hissed
when he began to reply to the other
speakers on behalf of the commission,
ana was heckIed by members of the
coafd and the crowd Every time he
Urea 70 say 3omethlng there vas >
n1o'sy oNIoreaE' and Aldermanlc Presi-
New-York tribune., 1922-05-06

point out bullet-picrccd buildings
which stopped some of Buds bullets.
During the trial of Clara Smith Ia-
mon hero for the killing OF Jake L.
Hamon, Republican National Commit
tceman from Oklahoma, Bud was ap-
pointed by Garrett az tho personal
bodyRuard of the defendant.
The night Clara Smith Hamon was
acquitted dinner was given by the
defense and TO celebrate the victory
Bud shot holes in the ceiling Of the
restaurant, according TO some Of those
present
Ballew became one Of the famous
Garrett deputies after he opposed Gar
rett for Office in an election. a short
time afterward nc made himself Car
retts right-hand man when he saved
the Sherff's life in a fight with two
alleged bandits near here. Garrett
pursued the bandits in the dark He
overlook them and when they drew
guns Garrett refused to give up.
DUSTY" Mills, one Of the men, was
preparing to shoot Garrett when Bal
lew arrived Ballew beat Mills to ehe
draw and another notch was added to
Buds gun. Later. in an Ardmore cafe.
BalJew shot Dow Brazil to death.
While Wounded, Kills His Man
IN Hcaldton, an oil town, Ballew
killed an alleged bandit named High
note, after being being shot twice
through the abdomen. In his wounded
condition Ballew calmly poked his pls-
to under Highnote's Jaw and fired.
Ballcw was wounded another time
when he killed Pete Bynum in the oil
fields. Ballew entered a resort where
Bynum was reported staging holdup
Ballew's body reached the flying field
here this evening and scores Of per
sons werew aiting. Ballew was five
feet, eleven inches in his stocking feet.
He bad red curly hair and his smiling
face and boisterous laughter won him
hany friends. Before his death ne be
came moderately wealthy and owned
stock farm near Lone Grove.
New-York tribune., 1922-05-06
ADVERTISEMENT
ADNERilSt1fNl ADVERTISEMENT
Natures remedy Tor constipation
will give you permanent relief!

Thousands upon thousands of peo-
pie are to-day suffering from consti-
patton in all its hideousness; few
realize either the cause OF their con-
dition or what it will eventually lead
to- Ask the average man or wtman
if they are constipatAd and they Uill.
answer "No;" This VgeY<frmly bcf
lieve. But, se first thSs shs ply #
clan asks hisR RasNnt is Let i1e ssae
your tongue VI thse tongve is coated
he knows the pAE lent suffering from
conssspation'
coated,stoaSte, bad breath-
they are constipation signals, Star,
the use of natureA remedy BRAN
kellogg's Bran, cooked and krum bled.
as fast as You can. You must elimi-
nate this dangerous condition because
1T goes from bad to worse, Toxic
New-York tribune., 1922-05-06

. better chance with you"
The pictures were cnthusias tically
received and at the end of the session
Mr.. Hubert and others suggested that
they be shown all over town, with an
opportunity for the spectators 10 ask
questions, as was done last night.
The Raymer enterprise. (New Raymer, Weld County, Colo.) 1910-19??, 1922-10-26

Leather vests and sheepskin coats
at popuiar prices. We have them at
Seldins.
The Raymer enterprise. (New Raymer, Weld County, Colo.) 1910-19??, 1922-10-26
OLD FASHIONED HusK1He BEE

The Christian is going to hid a
pair Of corn husking bees next Sat.
urday; one at Joe Meyers place east
Of town. the other on the D. L. Jones
place suthwest Of Raymer.
Tha proceeds of the days work
will go 10 pay for the piano at the
Christian church. The Christian
Workers will serve dinner at both
places.
Then. on Saturday. November 4th
a rummage sale will be given for the
support Of the church expenses.
There will be chickens, at least
one Poland China boar, eligible ia
register, and numerous other arti.
Giles. A complete list will be given
next week.
Any article for the sale should be
listed with the committee, or at the
Enterprise office. Committe are a.
follows: J. w. Johnston, D. McCorkle
VIM. Halling, Joseph Sherer, c. E.
Beans. Mrs. G. G. Miller and Mrs.
J. r. Smathers.
The Raymer enterprise. (New Raymer, Weld County, Colo.) 1910-19??, 1922-10-26
RECEPTION PLANNED
FOR new PASTOR

The Ladies' Aid have decided to
give a reception for Rev. Wood at
some time In the near future. It is
a little late in the arrival Of the pas
tor. but there has been a good deal
going on. At the meeting OF the
Aid Friday evening. Nov. Bird, was
selected, but at the time IL was not
known that the Demcratic Rally
was to be on that evening. We have
no authority to change the date, but
we have an idea that 1t will be
changed to the evening following.
However. as to that watch the paper
next week for announcement.
They wish US to announce that
all are invited to attend and that
It will be held In the Auditorium.
The Raymer enterprise. (New Raymer, Weld County, Colo.) 1910-19??, 1922-10-26

How about your heavy underwear?
VIII be ni.ased to show you our line.
Sldins.
The Raymer enterprise. (New Raymer, Weld County, Colo.) 1910-19??, 1922-10-26

Mrs. Cliff Dannatt went down to
Morgan last Saturday and spent Sun
day with her husband.