davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The New York herald., 1922-07-03
Bathers on the Beach.

Among the bathers was Mr.. E. Coster
Wilmerding. who Is making his twenty
first annual visit over the Fourth. He
is the guest of Mrs. Chester Griswold st
Crossways Others on the beach were
Mr.. and Mrs. Walter w Price. Mrs.
Riley Miles Gilbert, George Ledlie. who
is a guest of Mrs. George c. De Witt at
Nighbrink; Mr.. and Mrs. Frederick A
Snow, Mrs. John Wolfe. who was in
hydrangea blue chiffon crepe Mr. and
Mrs. Henry e. Coe. Mr.. and Mrs. II.
Rogers Benjamin. Mr.. and Mrs Grosve-
nor Nicholas. Mrs. Frederick Martin
Davies. who wore white china crepe and
a white hat trimmed with red flowers
Mr.. and Mrs. Robert Potter Breese, the
latter in china pink foulard figured with
white Mr.. and Mrs. Vincent S. milford.
Mrs. Charles r. Henderson. Mr. and
Mrs. Duncan s. Ellsworth. Mrs. John
Magee Ellsworth, the Misses Elizabeth
and Matilda Van Rensselaer, Ellsworth,
Mr.. and Mrs. Devices w. Dilworth, Mrs.
Richardson Dilworth. a recent bride, who
wore gown of hydrangea blue cretonne
with pattern Of large figures; Mr. and
Mrs. Gardiner Brown and Miss Kathe-
rine Vernon Brown.
Also. Mr.. and Mrs. Channing Wiley,
Mr.. and Mrs. A. w. ). Cochrane. Mrs.
Henry G. Trevor, Messrs. Seth Spragu.,
Norman Henderson. Mr.. and Mrs r,d :
nund S. Twining. Mr.. and Mrs. Howard
Elliott. Mr.. and Mrs. Leonard NJ.
Thomas. who arrived last night. DR. and
Mrs. Henry James. Mr.. and Mrs. Clark
son Potter. Mr. and mrs. Ten Brock,
Mr.. Terhune and Mrs. Charles G..
Francklyn. DR.. and Mrs. w whlteh. ad
Gilfillan with whom were Miss Isabelle
Watts and Franklin Gregory.
Princess Clan Battista Rospiglosi.
who was Miss Ethel bronson is visit
ing Mrs. Thomas II. Barber at her villa,
Claverack House.
Mrs. Robbins Gives Dinner.
Mrs. Henry Asher Robbins gave n
welcome home dinner tonight at Asher
House for her son-in-law and daughter,
Mr.. and Mrs. Theron X Strong. Mrs.
Riley Miles Gilbert gave a luncheon
for Mr.. and Mrs. Donald Fairfax Cam
mann and Mrs. f. Norman Whitman.
her son-in-law and daughters. Mr.. and
Mrs Leonard NJ. Thomas. who are at the
Gables. will give a dinner tomorrow
night.
Mr.. and Mrs. Vincent S. Multord gave
n luncheon at Shinnecock Hills Golf
Club for Gen. Charles /. De Bevoise and
the Misses De Bevoise.
The colony was represented tonight
ct the invitation concert given In the
Parrish Art Museum under the auspices
of the Southampton Choral Society.
The artists were Mrre. Berthe Era,
cramatic soprano. Cornelius Van Wet.
cellist, Francis Moore. piano, and Archl-
bald Robinson, organ.
one of the principal numbers vas
the Bach-Gounod Ave Maria. sung
by Nine Erza with accompaniment OF
cello. organ and plan. Several nm
6red persons of the sumner and err
manent colony were in the audience
Miss Maria J.. Brooke. daughter OF
Mrs g. Hayes Brooke OF New York is
visiting Miss Betty Condor, daughter OF
Mr.. and Mrs. Thomas G. Condon
The New York herald., 1922-07-03

Betty Gerard. Mrs. Gerard wore pearl
gray chiffon satin with hat to match.
The New York herald., 1922-07-03
IN MEMORIAM.

BOWERS. I'm ever loving memory Of my
friend. Edna NJ Bowers. who passed away
July s. 1919 NJ. NJ. X
The New York herald., 1922-07-03
Jeweiry.
Sooo pEvvAPp

for return of bracelet containing about 5C
diamonds. lost June 30, between East 36tf
RI and Park av. and 3sth ct. MARCUS a
CO. hth av. and alth It,
The New York herald., 1922-07-03

Miss Anne Morgan, who Is in France
will return to New York in October.
The New York herald., 1922-07-03

Mr.. and Mrs. Allan w. Dulles have
gone to Princeton to be guests OF Mr..
and Mrs. Joseph Dulles. Later they
will go to Newport
The New York herald., 1922-07-03

LosT-Two SKIN MINK FUR,
Grand Central Station. July I liberal re-
war6s- Return cashier Hotel Plaza.
The New York herald., 1922-07-03

The Assistant Secretary of War. Mr.
J Mayhem Wainwright, and Miss
Wainwright have Joined Mrs Vain
wright at their home at Rye. ". Y.
The New York herald., 1922-07-03

Judge ind Mrs. Elbert H. Gary are
guests of Mrs. Gertrude D. Ritter at
Manchester. VT, over the Fourth
The New York herald., 1922-07-03

Mr.. and Mrs. Vanderbilt Webb will
socn leave Peekskill. N. Y. and go to
the Adirondacks.
The New York herald., 1922-07-03
Wearing Apparel.

LOST-Fur neckpece. baum marten. Friday.
June 30. Goth Century taNicah between 43d
and g1th sts.; suitable reward. CANS, 30
Riverside Drive.
LoST-Sabe neckpiece and umbrella in ta1i
(Orarse and Black. Call Lafayette 2iT3.
Reward
The New York herald., 1922-07-03

Acting Secretary of the Navy Roose-
welt Is at Gettysburg for the Marine
maneuvers.
The New York herald., 1922-07-03

The Ambassador OF Brazil, Mr..
Augusta Cochrane de Alencar, is spend
ing several days motoring and will re-
turn to Washington this week
The New York herald., 1922-07-03

Mrs. Henry o. Havemeyer has re-
turned to Stamford. Conn, from a visit
t. Islip, L. l.
The New York herald., 1922-07-03

Mrs. Samuel J. Penniman will go to
the White Mountains on Wednesday.
The New York herald., 1922-07-03

The Minister OF Norway and Nine
Bryn and the Misses. Bryn have gone
to Skyland. Va, for the summer.
The New York herald., 1922-07-03

Mrs. Rushton Peabody has left by
automobile for Narragansctt Pier. where
she will spend the summer.
The New York herald., 1922-07-03

Under Secretary OF State Phillips
Mrs. Phillips and their children are al
Beverly Farms, Mass, for a brief visit.
The New York herald., 1922-07-03
WASHINGTON.

Attorney-General Daugherty and Mrs.
Daugherty are at their home in Column
cus. Ohio. for the Fourth.
The New York herald., 1922-07-03

Mr.. and Mrs. Sherwood Aldr:ch will
start July Is for Wyoming, where they
will spend several weeks en- a ranch.
The New York herald., 1922-07-03

Mrs. John 3. Trevor is at Glen View
ler house in Yonkers, n. Y.
The New York herald., 1922-07-03
Wore Unusual Combination.

Mrs. Edward Van Ingen wore an un-
usual combination of white foulard with
a Chinese willow pattern in black and
small black hat trimmed with paradise
;.lumes Mrs Goodhue Livingston, Jr.'s,
costume was of orange colored chiffon
and Miss Audrey Hoffman had a gown
Of hydrargea blue taffeta with henna
colored blouse Her hat was blue.
Mr.. and Mrs. Bradish Johnson Carroll
ard MI. and Mrs. William A. Hamilton
came with Mrs. George Leary. Mrs
Hamilton wore a gown Of pearl gray
crepe and a hat to correspond. Mrs.
Carroll also was In gray.
The Hon. Hilda Wynne, In lilac ac-
Gordon pleated foulard. with hat to cor
respond. came with Mr.. and Mrs. Her
man Dierks, whose guest she is. Mrs.
Dierks wore white linen embroidered in
red and a hat of white erin combined
with red Mrs. Alfred L. Schermerhorn's
costume was of mustard colored crepe,
her hat Of black Neapolitan straw being
topped with black paradise plumes. Mrs.
Victor Mapes wore salmon colored bro
caded crepe and hat 70 match.
Miss Julia Brown Fincke. who is visit
ing Mr.. and Mrs. Harold wall, came
with her fiance Mr.. Frederic +.
Hun phreys. She was dressed In palest
ecru chiffon. Mrs. Frederic II. Belts
brought her son and daughter-in-law.
Mr. and Mrs w. Rosseter Belts. Mr.
and Mrs. Joseph Earle stevens, who are
leaving next Saturday for California.
came with Mr.. and Mrs Harry Pelham
Robbins. With MIR. and Mrs De Lancey
Kountze were Mr. and Mrs. Robert ID.
Pruyn, for whom they gave buffet
luncheon later at Wnona.
Mr. and Mrs. Julian NJ. Gerard were
accompanied by their small daughter.
The New York herald., 1922-07-03

The Secretary of the Treasury. Mr.
Andrew w. Mellon. has gone to his
home In Pittsburgh for the Fourth.
Miss Ailsa Mellon Is at Southampton.
y. Y. with her cousins. Mr.. and Mrs.
Edward p. Mellon.
The New York herald., 1922-07-03

Mr.. and Mrs. F. Egerton Webb are
the guests of Mr.. and Mrs. Horatio S.
Shonnard at Oyster Bay, L. l., until
Wednesday.
The New York herald., 1922-07-03

Miss Helen Woodrow Bones is the
guest of one time President and Mrs
Woodrow Wilson.
The New York herald., 1922-07-03

Mrs. Hamilton Mex. Twombly and
Miss Ruth V. Twombly. accompanied
by DR.. and Mrs. Allen M. Thomas, will
sail tomorrow for Europe
The New York herald., 1922-07-03

Mr.. and Mrs. John D. Rockefeller, Jr..
their daughter. Miss Abby Rockefeller.
and sons Nelson, Winthrop. Lawrence,
David and John d. Rockefeller Sd, will
&C to Seal Harbor. Me-. on Wednesday.
The New York herald., 1922-07-03
AMERICANS IN LONDON.
Miss Mabel Gerry Gives Lunch con
for English Friends.

Special Gable to THE New YORK HERALD.
Copyright, 1922, by THE NEW YoRK HERALD.
The New York herald., 1922-07-03
PERSONAL INTELLIGENCE.
NEW YORK.

NEW YORK.
Mrs. John B. Trevor is at Glen View
her house in Yonkers. n. Y.
Mrs. Samuel J. Penniman will go to
the White Mountains on Wednesday.
Miss Anne Morgan, who Is in France
will return to New York in October.
Mr.. and Mrs. Vanderbilt Webb will
soon leave Peekskill. N. Y, and go to
the Adirondacks.
Mrs. Henry o. Havemeyer has re-
turned to Stamford, Conn, from a visit
t. Islip, L. l.
Judge ind Mrs. Elbert H. Gary are
guests of Mrs. Gertrude D. Ritter al
Manchester. VT, over the Fourth.
Mrs. Rushton Peabody has left by
automobile for Narragansctt Pier where
she will spend the summer.
Mr.. and Mrs. Sherwood Aldr.ch will
start July Is for Wyoming, where they
will spend several weeks en- ranch
Mr.. and Mrs. F. Egerton Webb are
the guests of Mr.. and Mrs. Horatio S
sbonnard at Oyster Bay. L. l.. until
Wednesday.
Mrs. Hamilton Mex Twombly and
Miss Ruth V. Twombly. accompanied
by DR.. and Mrs. Allen NJ. Thomas, will
sail Tomorrow for Europe.
Mr.. and Mrs. John D. Rockefeller, Jr.
their daughter, Miss Abby Rockefeller
and sons Nelson, Winthrop, Lawrence
David and John d. Rockefeller Sd, will
&C to Seal Harbor. Me-. on Wednesday
Mr.. Ogden L. Mills will open the villa
CT his father Mr.. Ogden Mills, in New
rort to-day. and will have as guests foi
the summer Miss Barbara Sands anc
her brother, Mr.. Winthrop Sands.
Mr.. William V. B. Kip will sail fol
Europe on board the Mauret,nia or
July IS. He will return in August ant
join Mrs. Kip and his daughter, Miss
Cornelia V. Kip. in the White Noun
tains. His house in Cedarhurst. L. l.
Will not be opened this summer.
The New York herald., 1922-07-03

Mr.. Ogden L. Mills will open the villa
CT his father. Mr.. Ogden Mills, in New
rort to-day. and will have as guests for
the summer Miss Barbara Sands and
her brother, Mr.. Winthrop Sands.
The New York herald., 1922-07-03
D l E D
In Memoriam.

Bowers. Edna NJ.
New-York tribune., 1922-12-30
Of NetCdrk Bay
Bridge Expected To-day
Secretary Weeks Obtains Full
Report on Railroad Pro.
pOsal From Army Engineers

From The TrtbaHs'f WasHm0foa Bure0u
WASHINGTON. Dec. 20. Approval
by the War Department Of the appliea-
tion Of the Central Railroad OF New
Jersey 10 build n bridge across Newark
Bay is expected 10 be granted to-m0r-
row by Secretary Of War Weeks, be-
fore whom detailed report on the
question was laid to-day by Major
General Lansing H. Beach, chief Of
engineers. Granting OF the applica-
tion has been vigorously opposed BY
the municipal authorities Of Newark,
who declare that the proposed bridge
will be a menace to navigation and un-
able 20 meet the traffic demands upon
IT, Tho Newark authorities desire the
construction Of a tunnel under the
bay TO relieve congestion. The rail-
road now operates a bridge across the
bay, which IL desires to replace with
q larger structure.
Secretary Weeks indicated to-day
that he would likewise approve the
sale OF a parcel Of ground adjoining
the War Department base at Newark 70
tho Submarine Boat Company, which
owns n large strip Of property along
side the government tract. The legal
department OF the army Is now draft
ing contract Of sale, which Is ex-
pected 20 be signed By the War Secre-
tary tomorrow.
New-York tribune., 1922-12-30
Negro Youth Slayer
OF Mrs. Brigham To
Be Tried January 4
Defense Counsel Agree to
Tentative Date; I9-Year-
Old Maintains Attitude
of Bored Indifference

The date for the trial Of william Z.
Battle, the nineteen -year-old negro un-
der indictment In Orange, y. j. for
the murder on Wednesday Of Mrs.
Charles +. Brigham, Of 25e Fuller
Street, Orange, was tentatively set yes
terday by Judge William Stiekel in
the Court Of Common Pleas at New
ark as January 4. To this date Bat
ties counsel, John A. Bernhard, for
merly Assistant Prosecutor, and Assem-
blyman Oliver Randolph assented.
Battle maintained yesterday his atti-
tude OF complete indifference TO the
crime, which he has admitted, and It's
probable consequences TO himself, He
listened with no show Of emotion while
Assistant Prosecutor ]. Victor dAlioia
read the indictment which was returned
against him after only eleven minutes
discussion by IN Essex County grand
jury on Thursday night. Previously,
in the Police Court at Orange, he had
displayed the same bored attitude
when Judge Ovidio {. Bianehi referred
70 the murder o. Mrs. Brigham as "the
most beastly, wicked, lowest, most aw-
ful and most dastardly crime ever COM
mitted in this community"
Judge Bianchi praised the work Of
Detectives Timothy Cronen and Thomas
Burns, who made the arrest, and whom
he thanked In the name OF all the citi-
zcnB Of Orange for their work on the
case. Il feel there would have been
a great fear Ia the hearts Of every
woman In the community until the per-
pctrator Of this crime had been appre.
hended,' he said. This fear YOU have
dispelled by your quick capture Of this
man, and you arc entitled 10 great
credit for your excellent work. II the
grace Of God had not left this seven
year-old girl, Virginia Brigham, 10 tell
that she had talked with this man Ia
her home on the afternoon OF the
crime this fendish murder probably
would have remained an unsolyed mys-
terry"
Battle spent Thursday night In Or
ange jail, where he ate and slept well.
lie was examined in Newark yesterday
morning BY DR.. Walter s. Washington,
an Rlienist, at the direction OF the
prosecutors Office. DR.. Washington
reported him 10 be sane.
New-York tribune., 1922-12-30
WMOppOSe KIGn AbettOr
AS Speaker OF House
Bay State Congressman Says
Southern Democrats Must
Tell rHOp They Stand

WASHINGTON, Dec. 20. Repre-
sentative Galliynn. Democrat, Of MassA-
ehusetts, declared in statement to-
day that Democrats who 90 before the
party eadeus as candidates for Speaker
OF the House in the new Congress will
be called upon by Northern Democratic
Representatives 20 say where they
stand on the question Of the ku-KluS
Klan.
"SIark you" said Mr. Galiiyan, 1--WE
are going 10 watch Ku-klux Democrats
from the Southland. whether they come
from Texas or any other state, and
they will get no support from Demo
Gratis In the North unless az the caucus,
which will be called 20 select the
party candidate for the Speakership,
these men pronounce their absolute
and unequivoeal opposition 20 the in
famous organization which at present
holds the front page in our daily
newspapers.'
Mr.. Gallivan declared that while he
had no candidate Of his own he would
not support Representative Garrett, Of
Tennessee, acting Democratic leader,
because OF his vote against the sol
der bonus. lie said he also opposed
Mr. Garrett because be voted for an
amendment TO the retirement act,
(which would prohibit any Federal
employee from receiving the benefits
thereof, II he had at any time been
allied with any labor union, or any
organization Of such a character"
New-York tribune., 1922-12-30

A visitor trudged up the five flights
Of stairs at $40 East 18th Street yes
tcrday and. pausing a moment for
breath. raped on the door Of the top
noor front. Inside was room Of pov.
erty. and seemingly a swarm Of little
children clad in pitifully ragged cloth
ing, crawling about the floor. In this
room Antoinette. the eldest Of six
children, had written letter ad-
dressed to santa Claus, Police Head
quarters"
"Just dropping you these few lines" F"
the letter said, 80 let you know that
you kept US al downhearted yesterday.
All other little children got so many
things from Santa Claus and me and
our brothers and sisters we're so down
hearted that Santa Claus forget us
ard did not come 20 Us. Why Is IT,
We could not help II because our poor
mother was so sorry for us as papa
Is not working for two long years with
sciatica and rheumatism and cannot
buy Us nothing, so please send US
something. at least, for New Years.
am the oldest. Rose, eleven, Mary.
New-York tribune., 1922-12-30
Two Birthdays

Every man, according 20
Charles Lamb. has two birth-
days-the one, his own natal
day-the other, the First OF
January. when with the birth
of the New Year we wipe out
old regrets, old scores, failures
and worries and make brand
new start. The January rejg-
venation is good for business,
good for the individual. Every
sign pointing towards 1923 is a
good sign-for a prosperous
year.
Knfckerboeker has celebrated two
birthdays its business birthday
and the birth of the New Year in
New York for nearly half century
serving thousands of old and new
Knickerbocker families The Com
pany's New Year Resolution for
1928 is: Day by Day, In every wsy,
10 serve better and better.
New-York tribune., 1922-12-30

ishcd product IN the making Of which
the individual had but a small, mon
otonus part"
The radio is all very we'll, he as
serted, but many Of the programs
broadcast by IL are not uplifting.
Speaking OF the thcater, he mentioned
Shakespeare. and then asserted even
the best plays Of the day are but tenn
porary affairs. with most Of them
about as helpful and witty as The Sun
day comic supplements
lie termed the newspapers as conf
posed Of about two.thirds crime" and
athletics as something one should in
dulge In as "A matter OF personal ox-
crcise, but not 20 u look at.
The lecture was given In commcmo-
ration OF the sixty-eighth birthday an
niversary of the late Dr. Henry VI.
Leipziger, who az his death on De-
cember 1, 1917, left trust fund FOR
the lectureshiD.
New-York tribune., 1922-12-30
Nip TGIierSinC Congress
ReGSSured by BiGntOn

IRON Ths Tribuuo's Woshingfon DHrfna
WASHINGTON, Dec. D.
Government officials and mem-
bers Of Congress who trifio with
the Eighteenth Amendment are
not likely 10 be held up 10 public
obloquy on the floor Of the
House, Representative Blanton,
Of Texas, assured them to-day.
The Texas member voiced the
opinion that Representative Up
shaw, Of Georgia, who charged
that violation Of the Volstead act
was general in Washington,
would not "giye away any Of his
colleagues" II called upon 20
prove his charges. DIR. Blanton
said Representative Hill, OF
Maryland, who took umbrage at
Mr.. Upshaw's remarks, was
"only seeking newspaper notori-
ETY."
Does tho gentleman indorse
the charges made by Mr.. Up.
shawl" challenged Representa-
tive Hill.
"Ridiculous" Blanton replied,
New-York tribune., 1922-12-30
Killing of Brooklyn
Girl Continues to
Puzzle Detectives
Theresa Mccarthy Met Her
Death Playing With Re
volver or Playmate Acct
dentally Shot Her, Theory

Detectives will continue to-day their
investigation Of the death Of Theresa
Mccarthy, ten years old. who was
found shot 20 death Tuesday in the
dining-room Of her home al tec Nor.
gan Avenue. Brooklyn.
The detectives seemed positive last
night that the child met death in one
Of two ways-she either shot herself
while examining lhe small revolver Of
Benjl.nin Prendcrville, roomer at her
home, which had been left under his
pillow, or was shot with this revolver
By some child who was in the apart
ment with her about noon Tuesday.
The homicide charge against Prem
derville, who was arrested Thursday
night after admitting that he was the
owner OF three rcyolvers kept IN the
house, was changed TO a technical one
OF murder when he WIS arraigned yes
tcrday before Magistrate Gcismar IN
Bridge Plaza Court. Though there Is
no suspicion that he killed the child, n
short affidavit, signed by Detective
Thomas Devery, OF the Greenpoint
police station, set forth that the
Brooklyn postofiec clerk was "impli-
Gated in the death Of Theresa MeCar-
thy" Prendeville was held without
bail for examination next Friday.
Il is recalled by detectives that the
revolver which caused the death OF
Theresa was found, according 10 Prem
derville's story, on tho bed in his room,
while Theresa was lying across the
dining-room floor. about twenty feet
away. The detectives arc working on
tho assumption that after shooting
herself or being shot by playmate she
walked this distance before she fell.
The lot at Olive Street and Orient
Avenue. Brooklyn, into which Prem
derville hurled his three revolvers' ae-
eording 10 his story 20 the police, was
searched Yesterday without result.
The funeral Of Theresa was held
from her Morgan Avenue home; sery-
ices were conducted at st. Ceeilias
Roman Catholic Church and interment
was In Calvary Cemetery. Reports OF
"A reconciliation between tho enila
parents were not borne out by their
sctions at the funeral
New-York tribune., 1922-12-30
KIGn 'NightgOiCn' Offer
Jeered by Catholics
speelai Dl,ealsA 70 ne Trlbvne

speeloi DispascA 20 The Tribuae
BALTIMORE, Dec. 29.--Nei-
ther Catholics nor members Of
the Ku-Klux Khan here are much
stirred by Imperial Giant Clarke's
announcement that followers Of
the Church Of Rome may be given
title 70 Klan nightgowns. The
announcement was characterized
as "buncombe" by Archbishop
Michael j. Curley.
A canvass Of Klan officials dis
closed that the announcement Of
the proposed change in policy
came as a surprise. None would
comment until more details we're
received.
Archbishop Curley character
lied the idea Of a Catholic join
ing the Klan as "too silly to dis
cuss." lie said Giant Clarke
would find little support in Eng
land, France and Italy for an
international" Klan.
New-York tribune., 1922-12-30
Life Is DeteriOrating,
Beck Says in Lecture
Theater, Press, Radio and Aih-
letics All Come in for Criii'
cism by Ex.Ohicial

James Nj. Beck, former Solicitor
General Of the United States, appear
ing last night in Town Hall as the
first lecturer for the Henry II. Leip-
ziger Memorial Lectureship, expressed
considerable dissatisfaction with mod
ern human character and institutions,
particularly the theater, the press,
radio and athletics.
The title Of Mr. Beek's lecture was.
The Lost Sense Of Values" and the
general theme was that. despite the
strides man has made in mchniccai
invention, his ehaaeter has deterior.
ated. The speaker said the man Of
to-day Is neither the citizen nor the
father that the man Of 1850 was.
Machinery may be a good thing FOR
production, Mr.. Beck added. but Il Is
bad for the soul, ~as now great num-
bcrs OF men perform routine tasks
With machines and seldom see che IN
New-York tribune., 1922-12-30
Bronx Wins Suit TO Get
Parkway Funds for 1923
Supreme Court Justice Holds
City of New York Must
Find Money Demanded

The vacuum created in the spending
mower OF the City OF New York BY
the Cour. OF Appeals decision holding
that the city had no power to place q
tsx on bank stock and which Comp
troller Craig and his colleagues Of the
Board OF Estimate have cited IN reies-
inc 10 make certain appropriations TOT
The 1929 budget cannot be used 20
dcpv tho request Of the Bronx Parkway
Co,nmissior for a salary appror riation
of Sf2s 600. In so holding yustiee
Narsb. Of the Supreme Court, slso de-
cided Yesterday that the Board OF Esti-
nate must find somewhere the SoOl 'VVV
reouestcd By the Bronx Parkway Com-
rnission 10 meet the expenses OF I'M
nyovine lands purchased By the COM
mission during the year -s~,.
Tbe commission brought mandamus
proceedings similar 20 those bfoVEne
+, tbc Colleoe OF the City OF New
York and Hunter College 20 compel
the Board Of Estimate 20 honor its
rsouest for necessary funds. Justice
Marsh granted the writ OF mandamuS
as 10 both sums asked BY the c0mih's
sion. .h.
1928 salaries Of the commissioner. .,5,na Tho
employees, Justice Marsh sara; ln'
city's duty 20 furnish the funds re
questod being mandatory " Is no.
even a defense 20 this proceeding tnal
the budget already has reaehed its
constitutional limit. In that event "
is the duty Of the Board OF Estimate
10 make roadjustment in the items
over which they have discretionary
control. Not even q recently diseog-
cred liability 10 make refunds for IL
legally collected bank taxes can de-
feat the right OF the petitioner"