The New York herald., 1921-04-09
NAVY FOILSMEN ARE
TIED WITH COLUMBIA
Each Has Won 18 Bouts and
Lost 6 i'm Intercollegiate
Title Tournament.
BECKER Is UNDEFEATED
Annapolis Fencer Goes
Through Preliminaries and
Semi-Finals at Hotel AstOr.

Columbia and Navy foIlsmen were
tied at the close of the preliminary and
saJni-final bouts of the intercollegiate
fencing championship at the Hotel Astor
last night. Each won is bouts and lost
s. with Becker of the Navy the only
undefeated competitor Loundes OF Co
lumbia, who substituted for Nahon at
the last minute, held his own to the
semi-finals, when he suffered two de-
feats The Annapolis boys won the
intercollegiates last year and are IA
vored~ to carry off honors this time. The
summary:
I CoLUItBrA-Lowndes, Columbia. defeated
Hertzberg. Dartmouth, 7-3; Barss. Harvard.
, So: Shears, Navy, 9-S; Bishop, Yale,
6--4: Hittlnger. Penn. 6-i; Walker. Yale
G-t.
Bencoe Columbia. defeated Liaio. Dart
mouth 12-9; Chandler. Navy. &c: Mac
kenze. Yale. 10; Rhodes. Penn. So.
Farley. Columbia, defeated Brewster, Har-
ward, 10-S: Weld, Dartmouth, o-b. Ramoo.
HARvARD-ordway. Harvard. defeated
Rhodes. Penn, 12-6; Liaio. Dartmouth, s-2'
7AS seSso0e' Columbia ILL ohahaieF' navy
Brewster. Harvard. defeated Weld. Dart
mouth. 17-16: Rambo. Penn. 1913.
Barss. Harvard, defeated Hertzberg. Dart
mouth, 1913.
Boyce. Harvard. defeated Hittinger. Penn.
l1-9. BiSnOp, yale, 1T.
YALE-Walker. Yale. defeated Weld, Dart
mouth. ii; Farley, Columbia. 9-3; Rambo.
Penn. TO: Brewster. Harvard. lis.
90 mackenzie, faIe, defeated Ghanoier; Maay'
Harvard, 5-+.
Bishop, Yale. defeated rIertzberg. Dart
NAvY-Becker. Navy. defeated Rambo.
Penn, 60: Farley. Columbia, 49, Brewster.
Hsrvard, ~; Walker, Yale I'll.
BiShDD.
Ill: Hertzberg, Dartmouth. 5-3: ordway
Harvard. lilo.
Nose, Navy. defeated Liaio, Dartmouth,
e-3: Brewster. Harvard. So.
Navy CIinches sabre Title.
The sabre competition In the afternoon
practically resulted in four cornered
tie for Individual honors among Guider
and Malstrom OF the Navy. Reaves of
Columbia and Walton of Pennsylvania.
Guider, with a record Of six victories and
only one defeat suffered at the hands OF
Capt. Reaves of Columbia. led the field
with the other three named close behind,
each having lost but single bout
Malstrom and Walton each turned in
five wins. while Reaves left the strip
victorious four times.
The Navy clnched the sabre team
championship with eleven victories out
OF possible fourteen. with one bout still
TO be fenced Pennsylvania. with eight
triumphs. IS in second place. with Co
lumbia close behind. but neither COM
bination has a chance to overhaul the
leaders.
Few of the duelling sword bouts were
run off and the majority of them will
be contested tonight.
The competition for the DIR. James b.
Clemens novice medal brought forth one
of the largest fields that has yet aspired
for the coveted honor Granfeld and
Floyd. both of theg Naval Academy,
worked their way into the finals after
strenuous competition, together with
Watson of Harvard and Plumley OF
Yale. Granfield, with a clean record,
carried off the gold medal, Watson took
second place, with Floyd third. The
summary:
Intercollegiate STANDARDIZATION. Navy. de-
feated McCay, Yale, ! TO q; Davenport.
Eeaves. Columbia. to A; Ferreira. Coum-
bia. 10 2. Ciulder. Navy, defeated McCay.
Yale. to ]: Cooke, partmogth, tgS,, to 2;
70 3: seabr-ght. Penn to 9: Ferreira. Co
iumbia, to 8. Reaves. Columbia, defeated
to- to 3: seabrieh;. Penn. 10 :: Guider
Navy. to ). walton. Penn, defeated Nc
Cay, Yale. to I Malstrom. Navy. % q;
Cooke, Dartmouth. TO 2: Davenport, Yale,
70 3; Ferreira. Columbia, to ]. Sea-
bright. Penn. defeated McCay, Yale, TO :;
Cooke. Dartmouth. Z TO q davenport. yale.
to /. Ferreira, Columbia, defeated Nc
Cay, Yale, I TO .; Cooke, Dartmouth. Z TO 3.
Davenport. Yale, defeated Ferreira. Column
his, II 10 2. McCay, Yale. defeated Cooke.
Dartmouth, 10 ). Cooke, Dartmouth, failed
TO win a bout.
Clemens Medal Entrants.-Col l..
Barrett Y. o. Brown, ". Rood, +. w. HUI
ber, H. T.. Blerschenk, A. w. FrioburE.
New York Military Academy-E. Johnson.
George Pease. II. I. Cook, II. Sturhani, L.
Navy-G. r. ciranfleld. ". M. Floyd.
New York Athletic Club-H. l.. Hutchinson,
w. Bowman.
Yaie-H II. Plumley. w. NJ. Morris
HarNard-f. X. Watson.
uartmouth--Chnpman.
Brette School--Nelson.
I:raden School-W. Glenn.
Qualified for Semi i-fnals-tiranficld. Plum-
ley. Johnson. Brown, Floyd, Watson, Bar-
rett, Nelson.
Qualified for Finals - Granfield. Floyd
Plumicy, Watson.
Results Semi-finais--First strip-F1oyd de-
rented Watson. 10 >; Nelson. TO q. Wnt
son defeated Barrctt, 10 4: Nelson, 10 J.
Barrett defeated Floyd. To .; Nelson, O q
a Nelson defeated Watson.
second sirip-ciranficid defeated Plumley.
10 =. Johnson, , TO 4. Brown, TO >. Plum
ley defeated Johnson. TO q. Brown, II g
r. Brown defeated johnson, TO q. John
son failed 20 win n bout.
Finala-C;ranfied, Navy. defeated watson
Harvard. g to 4; Plumley. TO ?; Floyd,
pirmiey. 20 10 II: Floyd. Navy, 20 :.
Floyd. Navy, defeated Plumley. Yale, 10 70
n. Plumley failed 70 win bout.