davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
New-York tribune., 1921-11-03
Seennan Beats Davis

Sol Seeman dacisively outpointed
Davis IN the twelve-round go at the
Hunts Point S. c. last night. Davis.
subbing fer Nelson, proved game
fighter, and though nearly knocked out
in the seventh and eighth quickly came
back to last the twelve rounds
Jimmie Weiner knocked out Sailor
Taylor in the fourth round of the
first match, and the next bout, between
Jimmie Taylor, an old-timer. and
Mickey Noonan. kept the crowd on their
feet. Taylor lacked his former pep
and was outDointed
New-York tribune., 1921-11-03
Knockout for NcTig,ye

MONTREAL, Cue, Nov. 2.-Mike
McTigue, Of New York, holder of the
Canadian middleweighr boxing title,
knocked out suck" Grouse. Of Phila-
delphia. in the fourth round OF a
scheduled ter-round bout tonight
Grouse was floored twice for count
of nine in the third round and took
the full count in the fourth after d
right hook TO the Jaw.
New-York tribune., 1921-11-03
Afeno Beats SpeiIer

The senli-hnal boxing bouts Of the
Brooklyn College Club, held st the
armory of the I'd Field Artillery in
Brooklyn last night, furnished lots of
excitement The feature bout was be-
tween r Affeno, of the Paulist A. c..
and l. Speiler. OF the Clark House, in
the 11s-pound class. The judges
awarded the decision to the former
after three rounds of hard fighting.
The finals will be held at the same
place tomorrow night.
New-York tribune., 1921-11-03
Working ON New PLAYS

NEW BRUNSWICK, N. J.. Nov. =
The Rutgers eleven will not play this
wesk, but will practically hold the
when they grapple with Notre Dame
and n. Y. u. Coach Foster Sanford
will drill his squad thoroughly this
week N the more compactness styIe of
play, usually SO prevalent in the San
ford coached eleven, but which was
forsaken for the open style of play OF
late
New-York tribune., 1921-11-03
E.ehigE Punfer Improves

BETHLEHEM, Pa, Nov. 2.--If prac~
tice makes perfect, Lehigh will be we'll
fortified with kicker in the game with
Muhlenburg here next Saturday. The
putting of Slower has been erratic all
season, but he allowed considerable i'm
provement to-day. In an effort to brush
up this department Coach Click spent
long afternoon with Storer, Mellin-
ger, Johnny Lees and Harry Rote.
New-York tribune., 1921-11-03
Ioin Football Rally

Crew and basketball practice were
called off at Columbia yesterday by
Coach Rice and Coach Deering, to give
the men on the squads an opportunity
10 join the football rally held on South
Field. AS a result the initial practice
for the yeariing basketball tossers was
POSTPONED TIL to-day
New-York tribune., 1921-11-03
WESLEYAN Squad Increased

MIDDLETOWN, Conn. Nov. q
Coach Martin is trying to bring out
some good understudies for Foster,
the star Wesleyan center. Atkins and
Conway have been added to the vars
ity squad in this capacity and are
showing up we'll. Al Fricke is being
tried at quarterback, with Parsons and
Maruano
New-York tribune., 1921-11-03
Critics Agree That These Three Rank at Top:
Yonkers Boy Easily the Outstanding Sensation
of Year; Almost Entitled to the Second Place
Tennis Leaders of Last Three Years
By Fred Hawthorne

William T. Tden 3D. of Philadelphia Johnston Of Cali
forn and Vincent Richards Yonkers, the lawn tennis u
ed
There logical against the placing
OF these the three every other PLAYER
the country The
Richards form the placing them when
comes to making the ranking o
New-York tribune., 1921-11-03
Penn DesIfcases Boathouse

PHILADELPHIA Nov. 2.--The new
boathoase of the University Of Penn
sytvgnia, which will house sixteen
shells, was dedicated to-day. It 10 To-
Gated on the schuylkill River, in Fair
mount Park, and has accomm odations
gor 25o men. with lockers and rowing
facilities.
New-York tribune., 1921-11-03
Bouts Hereabos1ts

TONIGHT
Jamaica s. C.-sfiiiy Kid Herman vs.
xounE Hoffman, IS rounds.
Columbus =. C.--Eddie Fletcher -.
Red Monroe, IL raunds.
FRIDAY
Madison Square Garden Charley
W ein~rt VS. Harry Greb, 16 rouRsls: Eay
Aeise.r vs. Young Bob F'iszsimmous, 9
rounds.
Brnokiyn College CIuh-Amaseur bouts
at I'd Field Artillery.
SATURDAY
Rink 9. Chilly shade ~, Frank
Moran. IL rounds
Walker $ G. WiIIic Crysfau vs.
Jimmy Flynn. IL rounds.
Palace of Joy--i5uddy Jackson 90
Joe De Costa. 10 rounds
A5th Kegt-, Brooklyn Johrry
sfounE) Shaen vs.. Kid Raah, 10
rounds.
Commonwealth S. C.--Dnve Shade
w. Jimmy Kelly, IL rounds.
New-York tribune., 1921-11-03
Springfield College Beats
Army at Soccer. 4 to I

WEST POINT, Nov. 2.-SpringfeId
Y NJ. c. A. College beat the Army at
soccer to-day by 4 to / Grassis's fine
work for the collegians was the fea-
ture- The score al half time read
TO in Springdeld's favor. The Army
scored in the last Ave minutes of play.
The line-up.
New-York tribune., 1921-11-03
Brennan Gets Drision

PROVIDENCE, Nov. a.--Bill Bren-
nan, of New York, was given the de-
cision ovar Dan Dcwd, Of Boston, in a
twelve~round heavyweight fight at
Mariaville tonight.
New-York tribune., 1921-11-03
". 7. A. c. 3-Mile Run Sunday

The fourth and final Of the series
of three-mile runs being held by the
New York Athletic Club with view to
developing distance runners will be
held next Sunday at Travers Island.
Pelham Manor, n. Y, starting at $3.50
n m
New-York tribune., 1921-11-03

LExgmeTeM THEA. Sgss ST. 4 l-rx. ro-NIGHr
LENylS-PCL.E, ssmnln sasinSo
Atirutautcu tle0 usxsrrsd AssfA ~ p IS,
New-York tribune., 1921-11-03
Operation for Raw Sci,aILe

CHICAGO. Nov. Ray Schalk, star
catcher with the Chicago Americans. is
convalescing in hospital to-day, after
removal of his tonsils and another
minor throat operation.
New-York tribune., 1921-11-03
Among Richards's Victims

Here are some OF the men whom
Richards numbers among mis- victims
this season; Tilien. Williams, Ku
magae, Davis, Bob KinseY and Frank
T. Anderson. When he was defeated by
Willis Davis in the final round Of the
Southampton tourney Richards WAS
suffering from badly liberated tooth
and had been advised against playing
by his physician. Williams, who evened
the score by triumphing over Richards
after the latter had vanquished him at
Agawam, was enjoying one Of HIS rare
days on the courts, and was squarely
entitled to the victory.
Williams, in my opinion, is entitled
to the No. position. If you will study
the tournament results of 1921 you
will observe tina. Williams put in ar
I, sually busy season TIE mon vino
New-York tribune., 1921-11-03
Associate of Rickard
Fined $1,000 in Ohio

COLUMBUS, Ohio, Nov. "A fine OF
$1,000 was imposed in the Federal
Court here to-day upon Frank Flour
moi, OF New York, an associate OF Tex
Rickard, for bringing into Ohio films
of the Dempsey-Carpentier fight in
violation OF Federal law. Flournoi
pleaded guilty TO the charge in the
hope that the films may be shown in
Ohio.
Before being shown the pictures
must be approved by the State Film
Censorship bureau.
New-York tribune., 1921-11-03

OMAHA Neb.. Nov. 2.-FederaI
Judge Woodrough to-day announced
he had fined Clarence Gray $500 on q
charge of bringing moving pictures OF
the Dempsey Carpenter fight from
Jersey City TO Nebraska Gray pleaded
guilty two months ago.
New-York tribune., 1921-11-03

Tilly (Kid) Herman. the California
welterweight will meet Young EotT-
man, of Richmond Hill, in the star
fifteen-round bout at the Jamaica
Sporting Clnb tonight. There will be
one ten and one six-round preliminary
encounters
The evening herald. (Klamath Falls, Or.) 1906-1942, 1921-08-15

Mr.. and Mrs. John Sparks are
here for a visit with friends and
relatives from their home In east
ern Oregon.
Mr.. and Mrs. Bert Withrow and
Mr.. and Mrs. viii Houston spen,
the weekend at tho Lake O. the
Woods.
/ Mr.. and Mrs. Sam Holden and
Mr.. and Mrs. NJ. s Lester have re-
turned from q vacation trip to the
coast They report q wonderful time
In spite OF Its having been much
colder at the coast than here.
Mr.. and Mrs. Max Chilcote and
Miss Mollie and Zena Donaldson
made q trip TO Crater lake yester-
day. They report that the Park
country was visited with a hail and
rain storm and that the lake was
quite gray instead Of the usual blue.
Miss Irene Saatamsu and Mrs.
p. C. Markley were passengers on
this mornings outgoing train bound
Tor . vacation trip TO San Francisco.
Nh. r. =. Brown and two child
drsn OF Ashland. who have bsen
spending the summer here, left
for the Rogue river valley city this
f ...
Mrs. w. G. Dalton and her sis
ter Mrs. Dousherty. who has been
here vistins for some time left on
the morning train. Mrs, Dalton will
spend some time In San Francisco
and Mrs. Dousherty will 90 on to
her homo In okishoma.
The evening herald. (Klamath Falls, Or.) 1906-1942, 1921-08-15
SHE DREADED TO
SEE NIGHT CONE
MISS MAUDE WILKINS OF PORT.
LAND SAYS LIFE WAS A BUR-
DEN. NOW LIKE DIFFERENT
PERSON.

I'm only on my second bottle
Of Tsnlsc. but the relief have al
ready received has been 30 wonder
ful I want 10 let everybody who
suffers like aid know about this
good medicine" said Mis- Mauds
Wilkins. ioIs Glenn Ave-. Port.
land, Ore.
For years didn't eat . meal
without suffering sgonies after
wards. and at times I had awful
spells Of nausea and was unable TO
retain even q glass Of water on my
stomach. had raging headaches
nearly every day and often such
binding spells Of dizziness that
would have to grab hold OF some
thing to steady myself. I used to
dread to see night come as / knew
It meant hours OF restlessness for
me. and was SO worried and mis-
tainly the best OF all medicines. I"
Just q burden.
I'm Just like q different person
now, for Tanlac has benefited mo
In every way. My appetite Ia ra-
venous and ! never have Q touch
OF indigestion. In fact my health
now seems to be perfect. but I'm
going to take q little more Tanlsc
Just to be sure that that my re-
covery Is complete. Tanlac is cor
80 per cent under tho 1890 price.
Tanlsc is sold oy druggists every
wh0re
The evening herald. (Klamath Falls, Or.) 1906-1942, 1921-08-15
THE STRAND

The historical events OF 1896
when Texas won her fight for in.
dspendepce from the yoke OF Santa
Anna, then dictator of Mexico, fur.
nish the inspiration for Martyrs
Of the Alamo" supervised by d.
w. Griffith, which will be shown
Tuesday and Wednesday at the
Strand. In producing this spec
tacls the director has taken Q leaf
from Thomas A. Edison's book and
has set out to teach, more history
In IL minutes with motion pic
ture than teachers and textbooks
can drill into scholars In . month. !"
Famous pioneers of the Alamo
days are reproduced with fidelity.
The story Of tho SLAUGHTER which
The evening herald. (Klamath Falls, Or.) 1906-1942, 1921-08-15

able Assurance society OF Now
York. Of which John Houston has
been tho representative for somc
tino. viii operate . general insur-
anco busineas with offices In the
SusArman block. win Houston has
but recently returned from caiifor-
nia where he and his family had
boon for the wiutcr.
The evening herald. (Klamath Falls, Or.) 1906-1942, 1921-08-15
NEW INSURANCE FIRM
FORMED; BUYS AGENI /,

According to information rcceiv.
cd this morning John and VIII
Houston have purchased the insur,
ance business Of Paul BoEardus
and In connection with tho Equit,
The evening herald. (Klamath Falls, Or.) 1906-1942, 1921-08-15
WEATHER RECORD

Hereafter The Herald will publish
The mean and maximum tempsra-
ures and precipitation record a. TAX
On By the U. 9. Reclamation service
tation. Publication will cover the
day previous to the papers Issue. up
70 6 o'clock OF the day.
The evening herald. (Klamath Falls, Or.) 1906-1942, 1921-08-15

inspired the slogan. Remember the
Alamo!" and the quick revenge
taken by the Texans is told with
true regard for history and the re.
quirements OF dramatic climax.
The evening herald. (Klamath Falls, Or.) 1906-1942, 1921-08-15
MARKET REPORT

PORTLAND. Aug. ib.---CAttle
stcady and unchanged; hogs as
cents lower. prime light Sii.7s and
Si2.2s: sheep steady and unchans-
cd. .a 8..
The evening herald. (Klamath Falls, Or.) 1906-1942, 1921-08-15

Mako that Idle dollar work! Put
Il In the bank.
The evening herald. (Klamath Falls, Or.) 1906-1942, 1921-08-15
AN INVESTMENT

I have several blocks Of lots
surrounding tho Malin high
school that I will sell for
business and residential pur-
poses. thus 'sferlng to tho
people Of Klamath county an
opportunity to mako n reai In.
vestment. I will soil these
lots for SIS ana up. on the
instaiiment plan, the terms TO
suit the purchaser. No inter
est will be charged and will
pay tho taxes until deed 10 do
livercd to buyer.
Maiin 10 situated IN the csn-
ter OF ono Of the richest dis
tricts In tho world. II u back
Cd BY progressive and conssr-
vative citizens. II has q future
that assures DEVELOPMENT 10
. degree that viii make this
property worth many timcs
the price I am selling Il for.
when oil IL discovered. Maiin
will be found to be IN the vsry
heart Of the fold and tho
biseest produoep VIII bs at
Its door.
II you are looking for somo-
thing that will pay you big
returns. you can make no mis-
take in buying Msiin proper.
ty.
For further informatiou.
write or zee
A. KALINA
MALlN. Oso.
The New York herald., 1921-02-20

power to deal with the public utility
companies by the Legislature for a
period of sixty years.
1T may be that there are three men
within the city of New York who would
qualify for such a commission as has
been proposed to exercise the functions
of the Board of Estimate and Appor-
tionment in transit matters. If so their
names may be made known and they
have as good an opportunity 20 be
elected members of that board and exer-
else all of the powers which the Lesis-
lature may release to II, as any other
men in the city"
The Comptroller argued that the Con-
stitutlon contemplated city operation Of
utilities in the section referring to power
TO incur debts for such utilities, where
the phrase Is used. (which yields to the
city current net revenue"
troller that the Legislature had the
power to interfere with the exercise Of
ownership by the city OF public utilities
"by requiring the City OF New York to
lease such properties to private corpora
tions for operation" Such leasing OF
the lines is a part of the Miller plan.
THE very essence of ownership is do
mnion," the Comptroller declared. I'm
less the City of New York can exercise
dominion over its properties, il may well
be said II has been stripped OF its owner
ship by the Legislature without its con-
sent
The New York herald., 1921-02-20
TO TIE UP TROLLEYS
IN ". J. JITNEY FIGHT
Workers Threaten Strike If
Paterson Cars Stop.

A threat TO call Statewide strike Of
trolley men in New Jersey employed by
the Public Service Railway Company in
case Thomas N. McCarter, the presi-
dent. executes his threat to withdraw
trolley service in Paterson because of
the war with the jitneys was made
yesterday by William Wepner. head of
the Analgamated Association of Street
and Electric Employees of New Jersey.
Mr.. McCarter issued an ultimatum to
city officials of Paterson at a confer
ence few days ago declaring that the
company was operating lines in Pater-
son al a loss because of the iitneys. He
said unless the jitneys were taken out
of streets in which Public Service COM
pany tracks were laid Paterson service
would be suspended.
The announcement of Mr.. Wepner fol-
lowed q mass meeting of trolley EN-
ployees In Newark Friday night. He
said that the issue was whether jitneys
or the trolleys should survive and that
the time has come for a showdown"
IL the merchants of Paterson thought
the jitneys could carry the traffic he
wanted to give them an opportunity 10
prove 1t. If President McCarter aban-
dons Paterson service general strike
vote involving 1000 members of the
union employed on all divisions OF the
company will be taken.
The New York herald., 1921-02-20
TRACTION MEASURE
UNDER CAREFUL STUDY
County Legislators Name
Committee; Delay Action.

Because they had not had time to
study the bill for carrying out the tran
sit plan of Gov. Miller, the conference of
New York county members of the Legis-
lature. with Samuel S. Koenig, county
chairman, and various district leaders,
postponed action yesterday. A commit
tee was appointed to make a careful
study of the measure and report next
Saturday, with such suggestions for
modification as they deem wise.
One amendment sure to be suggested
is the addition of provision that there
shall be no change in rates prior 20 a
careful investigation and public hear
ings.
The committee to study the subject is
composed of Senators William Duggan,
Schuyler, NJ. Meyer and Ward " Toll
bert, and Assemblymen e. Il. Rayer,
Noel B. Fox. Sol Ullman and Joseph
Steinberg.
Jacob A. Livingston, Kings county
leader. conferred with State Chairman
George A Glynn yesterday and said he
had the situation there well in hand. 1t
is quite probable that certain of the city
legislators will vote against the bill fof
reasons peculiar to their individual dis
trict-. 1t is well understood however,
their votes will not be needed 10 pass
the measure.
The New York herald., 1921-02-20
CORPORATIONS SAY
TRANSIT MEASURE
BUNFAIR TO THEM
Dest Answer Possible Is
Given to Contrary Cry OF
Hylan's Cohorts.
ALREADY PROTESTING
City Is DOubly Protected at
Least Three Times on
Rate Changes.
CAN'T DEFY COMMISSION
Tammany Blocks Printing of
Copies of Bill, Fearing
Publicity Test.
CAN'T DEFY COMMISSION
Special Despatch to THE NEW York HERALD
New York Herald Bureau.
Albany, Feb. 10.

Special Despatch to THE NEW York HERALD.
New York Herald Bureau.
Albany, Feb. 10.
Answer to the charge made by the
Tammany-Hylan propagandists in
New York that Gov. Miller's transit
bill is drawn in the interest of the
corporations is found in the protest.
coming from the companies. Their
first careful reading of the bill, re-
leased yesterday to the public. has
convinced the corporations that they
are getting the worst end of the bar
gain at every point.
Not only is the city fully protected
by general provisions in the measure
but doubly to safeguard the public.
the language OF the bill specifically
places the burden of proof for all rate
changes squarely on the corporations.
In every instance where provision is
made for touching rates, whether of
railroad or gas companies. the new
law lays the duty on the corporation
TO prove beyond all question that the
proposed increase or decrease is abso-
iutely necessary and provides a series
OF notifications and conditions which
do not leave a loophole of escape to
the company which might try to put
over something on the city.
Further study of the bill shows the
remarkable thoroughness with which
the Governor and his associates haye
The New York herald., 1921-02-20
MANY JOIN TO BACK
MILLER ON TRANSIT
Well Known Persons Become
Members of Citizens AS
sociatiOn.

Many well known citizens have asso-
clated themselves with the Citizens
Transit Association being formed to
support Gov. A1iller's solution Of New
York clty's transit problem. A meet
ing for organization will be called
to order by Gen. Oliver B. Bridgman in
Exhibition Room No. of the Pennsyl-
vania Hotel at 4:30 tomorrow after
noon.
The first mass meeting of the associa-
ton will be held III the Town Hall or
Thursday evening. The speakers Will
be announced later by George III. Bel
OF go Madison avenue.
Among those who have joined the
movement are:
Frederick II. Allen. Augustus Barnes
Frank D. Biodgett, Gen. Oliver y. Bridg-
man, f. IL. Baldwin. Fred Il. Crawford
John V. Donahue, Guy Emerson. George
Teatherstone Charles a, M GIa"ni"er' M'chae
lie Roy Hardness, Nelson Holland, Stanley
NJ Isaacs. Cyrus p. Keen, O., G. K1rehhoi
Jr.. Nathan Lemleini r w; A9ro c,,,s rh9ioas Hnns
kins Miller, A. Parker Nevin. Harry d.
Odell, William Emory Petit. the Hon Lewis
scmple. olin ]. stephens. Charles IL. Strong
William j. fully; -,.,, -
Judson G.. Wall, Travis II. whitney, Ere
mont Wilson, Peter Fucker, Charles s.
Aronstan, George Il. Bartholomew, William
II. Bolton, George s.. Brown, M. J. Butler,
lanes Stewart Cushman. Edmund Dwight
Noise L. Erstein, Colin M Ferguson, Louis
Frank. A. NJ Gitterman. II. A. Guinzburg,
Stuard Hirschman, Stanley H. Howe John
= i. w. W Kendrick. w. H. Kniffin, Hon.
Jefferson NJ Ievy.- George McAneny. VIII
lam Mas, Herman A. Metz. Col. +. A.
Moiitor, Newman S. Lang. Albert Ottinger,
Charles Pierson. T. IL. Roberts. J. f.
Rowan, DR.. ]. Gardner Smith, Fred Sterry,
Leslie j. Tompkns. Paul Il. Vernon John
T.. Wallace. LIE Baron S. Willard, George 4.
Wilson.
Jules s. Bache. George IL. Bell, James j.
Bondy pr George w. Brush, Joseph Cohu,
r. Fulton Cutting, II. u. Edwards, Grosve-
nor Farwel George A. Fisher. Fred r.
French, Ralph Goddard, Albert Il. Gunther.
Jr. Ely A. Hershfeld Charles Bukley Hub
bell, Nathan S. Jonas, r. S. Kent, a. krei-
ling, Max II. Lewis Leo II. Mccall, William
i. MacRate. L. Moore.
William Fellowes Morgan. William w.
Niles John W. Paris, james II. Post. Fred
eric Sturges Robinson. Louis Runkel, Il. A.
c. smith. Frederick A.. Stokes, Henry X.
Towne, Royal Victor, George Dudley Wa
ring, G. II. Wilcox, Mrs. Ada NJ. Wolff.
George Barr Baker. Harry Bester, Paul j.
Bonwit, Dick Butler.
Edwin =. Conklen, Thomas c. Desmond.
Iclwood Eiiis. l.. w. Francis. Irving H.
Fisher, II. l.. Gardner, George II. Gray,
Frank A. Horne, Leo 8. Joseph, Ingalls,
Ilimball Robert G. Langdon. Merton f.
The New York herald., 1921-02-20
PLANS FOR REROUTING
BROOKLYN LINE FILED
Boring Under Long Island
Freight Yards Avoided.

Formal approval OF plans for the al
teration of the route of the Bushwick
section of the Fourteenth street East
ern rapid transit line. eliminating the
necessity Of building under the Bush
wick avenue or Varick street freight
yards of the Long Island Railroad. were
filed yesterday with the Appellate Di-
vision of the Supreme Court. The spe-
cial commissioners appointed to recon
slider the route were Theodore l.. Froth-
ingham. George w. Chauncey and Theo-
dore G. Christmas. No further delays
in the construction operations are ek
pected
The revised routing provides for a
turn under Mckibbln street to a point
east of White street. where the line
will emerge to the surface and will
thence pass TO Grattan street to Thames
street and thence to the right of way
Of the Evergreen branch of the Long
Island Railroad. These tracks will be
used
A station will be established in the re-
located section at Bogart street, at the
junction of Flushing, Varick and Irving
avenues.
The New York herald., 1921-02-20
CRAEG ASKS MILLER
FOR DELAY OF YEAR
Comptroller Wants Municipal
Operation Submitted to a
Vote i'm November.
FAVORS UNIFIED SYSTEM
Reviews Transit Troubles
Back to 1860 in Plea to
Halt Reforms.

In a letter to Gov Miller Comptroller
Craig last night suggested that action
by the Legislature on the bill embody-
ing the Governors transit solution
should be deferred for year and that
the proposal of the Comptroller for
municipal operation be submitted to the
people in the form of n referendum next
autumn. The Comptroller argued there
should be no misunderstanding of the
desires of the people of the city in a
matter SO vitally affecting every hour
of their existence.
The Comptroller already has submit
ted bills to the Legislature providing for
such a referendum and to make II pos
sible 10 carry cut his idea of municip Al
operation of a unified system. which
would include the present dual subway
lines and such surface lines as were
needed to complete an adequate system.
For the division OF authority on tran
sit matters, upon which Gov. Miller in
his message laid much of the trouble
here, Comptroller Craig said the Legis-
lature was TO blame. He went at length
into the transit history Of the city. going
back to the days of Gov Morgan.
For more than sixty years" he
said, "as the result OF legislative policy
begun in 1860 the people of the city
of New York have been stripped of any
effective voice in regard to their daily
transportation, and there has never been
a time during that period when the
municipal authorities could effectually
provide proper transportation without
first going, hat in hand. and procuring
the consent of one or more traction COM
panles, whose rights and existence rest
solely upon an erroneous legislative poll
icy toward the city of New York"
Criticisms aimed at the action of
the Board Of Estimate and Apportlon-
ment in regard to transit matters or at
the personnel of such board are without
force when it Is considered that that
board, as the duly elected representa-
tives of the people of the city Of New
York, has been stripped of any effective