Arizona republican., 1921-05-02

a native of Nebraska. He later practieed medicine at Salt Lake City and then went east to fit himself as a specialist. He took several post graduate courses on eye, ear, nose and throat diseases at the Manhattan hospital in New York. Sometime later he took another course at the county hospital in Chicago. He had an inn mense practice here, patients coming from all sections of this and adjoin- ing states to obtain treatment from him. He was fl years old.
 He was a member of the Maricopa county, Arizona state and American Medical societies; a Fellow of the American College of Surgeons; member of the American Opthomolo s1cal society, and a member of the Arizona club. a director of the Phoe- nix Country club and of many na- tional societies of nose and throat surgery. He was also a member of Fl Zaribah temple, Mystic Shrine, which organization will be in charge of funeral services. He was a mem Der of the Arizona rifle team that won the American civilian champ ionship a few years ago, and was an enthusiastic golfer.
 ( had not been completed last night, it will probably be held Thursday from the Episcopal Trinity Cathedral. The body will be entombed here, pending final burial later at the old home. Funeral plans will not be complete until the arrival of relatives, now en route to Phoenix. it was said last night.
 Leaves Wife and Daughter
 The deacesed is survived by the wife and one daughter, Dorothy. a student at the University of Arizona. Mrs. Brownfield, although severely shaken up in the accident. remained at her husbands bedside throughout the night and did not return to Phoe- nix until nearly o'clock yesterday morning. Dorothy, notified of the condition of her father last night. did not reach Phoenix until nearly g o'clock Sunday morning, several hours after her father had dled. Both Mrs. Brownfield and the daugh- ter stood the shock remarkably well. it was said
 Dr. Brownfield's body was brought to Phoenix about s o'clock yesterday morning from Mesa and was taken to the A. l.. Moore undertaking rooms.
 Mrs. Goldwater was brought to Phoenix by ambulance about 10 o'clock Sunday morning. Her con- ditfon, attending physicians say, is quite serious but they believe that recovery is only matter of time. The shock of the accident has com pletely shaken her nervous system it was said
 John R. Kibbey and MT. Goldwater. although sustaining painful bruises. returned to Phoenix from Mesa Sat urday night after receiving first aid treatment at the Mesa Community | hospital, where they were taken fol- l lowing the accident.
 | Soft Earth Caused Fatal Crash 1 The version of the accident, as re- lated in Sunday mornings Repub- l Iican, was substantially correct, it was said yesterday. Mrs Goldwater 1 eastbound on the Tempe Mesa road
 was attempting to pass a team, also | eastbound. In so doing, she turned
 too far to the left, the outside wheels | leaving the concrete road and strik- ing soft earth. The car sweryed and turned over, the momentum carry ing it completely over and right side-up. Mrs. Goldwater clung to the steering wheel throughout the ordea
 and was found in that position in 6
 semi conscious state when the cal
 had stopped.
 ! ACl- DIV ti1itld liett- been caught underneath the machine
 as it was turning and his head
 caught between a seat and the pave.
 ment. His body was some distanc,
 to the rear, on the pavement.
 Two other cars, carrying Phoenix |, people, were a short distance behind Many of the occupants witnessed tn,
 accident and were among the first tt reach the scene. Dr. Brownfield wa
 rushed to the Mesa Community hos
 pital, where first aid treatment wa ' administered by Dr. J. M. Greer o 1 Mesa. Other Mesa physicians wer , soon at the bedside and were joined by many Phoenix doctors, anon, hem Drs. Bannister and R. w. Eaton