davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The Madison journal. (Tallulah, Madison Parish, La.) 1888-current, 1921-11-19
MORE "REc;rRoCITY"

Older voters of Tallulah can remem-
Der when one Of the two great politi.
cal parties made a great to do about
reciprocity" In this day one sell
dom hears It mentioned, and yet we
believe nothing better was ever de-
signed as Q stimpulant to business.
We don't mean the reciprocity be-
tween nations, as the politicians used
to argue for and against. But we
mean reciprocity right here at home.
1t means reciprocating, and recipro-
eating means when the other fellow
patronises you it is up to you to re-
ciprocate--to patronize him. IL you
need something that is sold here at
home. buy 1t here, and the man you
buy II from, IL he Is the right sort Of
man. will turn right around when he
needs what you have to sell and buy 1t
from you. That is reciprocity in its
fullest sense, and 1t means that It
won't be long before our dollars are
circulating at q rapid rate, and yet
not leaving the community. For there
are q mighty few things a human be-
ing can need or desire that can't be
had right here from our home mer-
chants. And our farmers can supply
most everything that the merchant
doesn't keep in stock, OF cannot order.
Another thing, buying from each
ether and trading with each other
enables all Of Us to pay each other
with . greater degree Of promptness
The Madison journal. (Tallulah, Madison Parish, La.) 1888-current, 1921-11-19

and that makes for progress and
prosperity. Money thus kept in cir
culation stimulates outside interest,
and pretty soon trade from other COM
munities commences to find its way
here. Let's try a little more recipro-
city right here at home-a little trad
ing with each other and less with the
stranger whose only interest in Us Is
to get all the money out Of US he pos
sibly can.
The Madison journal. (Tallulah, Madison Parish, La.) 1888-current, 1921-11-19
NOTICE TO BIDDERS

A contract for repairs to the Court
house will be let at the next regular
meeting Of the Police Jury on We'd
nesday, Dec. 7th, 1921, and bids will
be received up to nine o'clock a. m,
on Dec. 7th. For specifications ap-
ply to the office Of, the Police Jury.
P. o. BENJAMIN, Secretary.
Tal'ulah, La, Nov. 4th, 1921.
The Madison journal. (Tallulah, Madison Parish, La.) 1888-current, 1921-11-19
DISSOLUTION NOTICE

Public Notice: II d
By order Of the BOARD Il thst a
tors, notice is hereby given ven ! SAB I
suant to the laws OF Ins ,;us eut
Louisiana, ITALIA Bena .a,rres.siss
pany, Inc :, a corporatl1Sn, V virtss
and existing under ana S'rouiS1S
the laws of the State OF
has been dissolved. ,,,, csovstsf
JESSIE B. ERWIN
The Madison journal. (Tallulah, Madison Parish, La.) 1888-current, 1921-11-19
TRESPASS NOTICE

Public notice is hereby sl'ts -
Walnut Grove, Leonard ana II
Plantations in Madison ~ 4
POSTED against all kinds 9,,, o. y .
passing. Anyone found guiisy = %
passing on the above proper; A j
prosecuted to the full extern G y
Est. W. N. Sui
The Madison journal. (Tallulah, Madison Parish, La.) 1888-current, 1921-11-19

Best Stock Beets. Second, Mis-,
Elmira Montgomery.
Best Cane Syrup, First, Alder,
SEWER.
Best Sorghum Syrup. First. ]. W
Lewis; Second, Albert Sewer.
Best Five Stalks Sugar Cane, First
Len Davis; Second, ]. H. Devine.
Sunhower Seed, Second, r. K
The Madison journal. (Tallulah, Madison Parish, La.) 1888-current, 1921-11-19
Best Hand Painted China, Second
Mrs. Black, Tallulah.

4
Best Six Maps East Carroll, Madi.
son and ,Tensas, Second, 'Tauulah
High School.
Best Six Maps Of Louisiana, First,
Tsllulah High School.
Best Ten Specimen Handwriting,
First, Tallulah High School.
Best Four Books on Corn, Cotton,
ETC., First, Tallulah High School.
Best Group Manual Training Work,
First, Tallulah High School.
Domestic Science
Half doz. biscuits, Second, A. l.
Vance, Tallulah.
Best Yeast Bread, First, A. L.
Vance, Tallulah; Second Blanche Pat
ric, Tallulah.
Apron, Machine Made, First, Ethel
Dean, Tallulah; Second. Mary Dean,
Sewing Bag, Second. Mary Dean.
Best Bingham Dress, First, A. L.
Vance, Tallulah.
Specimen Embroidery, First, venie
Cason, Tallulah, Second Leonora He
bert, Tallulah.
Best Six Button Holes. First, Ethel
Dean, Tallulah: Second, Dixie Kirk
patrick, Tallulah.
Agricultural Department
Ten Ears Calhoun Red Cob Corn,
First, A. F. Graves.
Ten Ears SEntell White Dent, First
A. E. Kell; Second, \. s. Holloway.
Ten Ears Mosby Prolific Corn,
First. A. s. Holloway; Second J. E.
Fur.
Ten Ear. Hastings Prolific, First.
Albert Sewer.
Ten Ears any Prolific Variety,
Second, Albert Sewer.
Sweepstakes Ten Ears, First A. F.
Graves.
Best Fifty Ears Any Variety. Sec
Ten Ears Pop Corn, First, Albert
Sewer; Second, A. 8. Holloway.
Bale Native Grass Hay, Second,
]. e. FUR.
Bale Clover Hay, First. Arnett
Browder.
Three Sheaves Oats, Second, F. 8.
Voak.
Three sheaves Peanut Hay. First,
Albert Sewer.
Three Sheayes Clover Hay, Second.
R. X. Boney.
Three sheaves Broom Corn, Second
Frank Jordan, Jr.
Three Sheaves, Rice, Second, Dale
Ellis.
Bundle Sorghum, First, J. w. Lewis
Peck Red Oats, Second. Albert
Sewer.
Peck Rice, First, E. J. Thompson
Second, Dale Ellis.
Peck Red Clover Seed, First, A.
F. Graves; Second, R. X. Boney.
Peck White Clover Seed, First, F.
8. Voak; Second, r. X. Boney.
Peck Soy Beans, First, F. S. Voak.
Peck Whippoorwill Peas, First, A.
B. Thomas.
Peck Clay Peas. Second. A. B.
Thomas.
Peck New Era Peas. First, NJ. W.
Leave.
Peck any Other Variety Peas, Sec
ond, J. II. Devine.
Peck any Variety Peanuts. First,
B. P. Folk.
Display Named Varieties Pecans,
First, Sam Fl. James: Second Mrs..
J. II. Alexander.
Best Stuart Pecans, First, Sam II.
James; Second, Mrs. J. H. Alexander.
Best Schley Pecans, Second, Sam
II. James.
Best Money Maker Pecans, Second,
Mrs. ]. H. Alexander.
Any Other Named Variety Pecans,
First, Mrs. ]. H. Alexander; Second,
Sam H. James.
Display Black Walnuts, First, Don
Alexander; Second, A. b. Thomas.
Best Half doc. Pears, Second, Mrs.
E. T. Purnell.
Japan Persimmons, First, Mrs. N.
T. Holt.
Best Artichokes, First, Mrs. N. W.
Thomas.
Best String Beans, First, Mrs. Jas.
r. Linton.
Best Of. Dry Shelled Butter Beans,
First, Mrs. Albert Kirsch.
Largest Pumpkin, Second, Smith 4
Sewer.
Best doz. Okra. Second, Mrs. Jas.
r. Linton.
Dozen, Radishes. First, Mrs. Jas. R.
Linton.
Spring Planted Irish Potatoes, First
J.. H. Alexander; Second, Leonard
Alexander.
Best Peck Sweet Potatoes, First,
Mrs. N. w. Thomas.
Best Stock Potatoes. First, B. p.
Eolk
The Madison journal. (Tallulah, Madison Parish, La.) 1888-current, 1921-11-19

The time has rolled around again
when the amateur hunter can climb
the fence and then drag the gun
through after him.
The Madison journal. (Tallulah, Madison Parish, La.) 1888-current, 1921-11-19

The principal use to which love
seems to be put these days is sup
plying material for divorce suits and
novels.
The Madison journal. (Tallulah, Madison Parish, La.) 1888-current, 1921-11-19

Best Fifty Bolls Long Staple Cotton
First, ]. w. Lewis.
Best Two Stalks Short Staple Cot
ton. First, G. w. Webb.
Cslorsd Dspartns,s
Best Ten Ears Calhoun Red Cob
Corn, First, Johnnie Griffin; Second,
Andrew Franklin.
The Madison journal. (Tallulah, Madison Parish, La.) 1888-current, 1921-11-19

One thing about the traffic police
man on the streets Of our big cities
they always win every argument they
get into.
The Madison journal. (Tallulah, Madison Parish, La.) 1888-current, 1921-11-19

Ever now and then we run across
a woman who is so contrary that she
opposes the thing she is in favor OF.
The Madison journal. (Tallulah, Madison Parish, La.) 1888-current, 1921-11-19

What has become Of the old-fash-
Toned man who claimed to be loyal
to his home parish but wouldn't take
his home town paper!
The Madison journal. (Tallulah, Madison Parish, La.) 1888-current, 1921-11-19

A fashion note says women will
wear their skirts longer. Yes, prob
ably two or three months longer.
The Madison journal. (Tallulah, Madison Parish, La.) 1888-current, 1921-11-19

We've observed that the average
man is willing to celebrate anything
if it's at your expense.
The Madison journal. (Tallulah, Madison Parish, La.) 1888-current, 1921-11-19

1t looks like some people go to the
moving picture show just to practice
reading out loud.
The Madison journal. (Tallulah, Madison Parish, La.) 1888-current, 1921-11-19

About the sursst way to cover up
a public abuse Is to have congress
investigate it.
The Madison journal. (Tallulah, Madison Parish, La.) 1888-current, 1921-11-19

One of the worst things about liv-
ing is you have to die to find out
what a nice fellow you were.
The Madison journal. (Tallulah, Madison Parish, La.) 1888-current, 1921-11-19

AS a general RUE the man who
scolds his wife in public is afraid to
scold her when they are alone.
The Madison journal. (Tallulah, Madison Parish, La.) 1888-current, 1921-11-19

More than one Tallulah resident ID
supposed to have ability when in fact
he hasn't anything more than gall.
The Madison journal. (Tallulah, Madison Parish, La.) 1888-current, 1921-11-19

That new beer ruling is going to
mean a lot of work for the shops
that can print prescription blanks.
The Madison journal. (Tallulah, Madison Parish, La.) 1888-current, 1921-11-19

It's hard to convince the father Of
twins that two heads are better than
one.
The Madison journal. (Tallulah, Madison Parish, La.) 1888-current, 1921-11-19
sEcRETARrs REPORT OF THE LEvEE BOARD

To The Honorable President Member, - ~ - A'NA'
Board Of Commissioner Fifth District
Gentlemen: - - -'e' DS'S"'
have the youthe following repo Of re.ns. and
disbursements by this Board for the
The Cordova daily times., 1921-09-28
MAHONEY IN INTRIGUE WITH ANOTHER WOMAN
 WHILE ON HONEYMOON
CBv Associated Press)

SEATTLE. Sept 2S.-A letter was introduced at the Mahoney murder trial to show that the defendant had been carrying on an intrigue with an other woman in St. Paul at the time he was supposed to be on his honey moon. Evidence was submitted as an alleged indication that the state was correct in it's theory that Mrs, NIahoney was slain before her husband went to St. Paul.
 Mahoneys counsel outlining the case the defense will set up after the state had rested this morning, declared it was prepared to prove that Mrs. Mahoney was seen alive after April Is. the date on which the state alleges she was slain.
 The defense also declared it would provo that the body found in the Lake Union trunk was not that of Mrs. Mahoney. '.- '" -
The Cordova daily times., 1921-09-28
UNITARIANS TO MAKE
 IMPORTANT CHANGES ~'> AT BIENNIAL MEETING
.lBy Ags5eiatea FfessT

ttETROIT, Sept 2S. important changes in the government 6f the Uni, tarian church are to be discussed here at ths Twenty-nintf benhlal conference of tfe church October 4.7. inclusive. according to announcement of church leaders The meeting. to be attended by about TOO delegates from the United States and CanAda. is de scribed in the official call tor the conference as "one of the cross foads in American Unitarianism.
 Chief Justice William Howard Taft of the United States supreme court. president of the conference, will de- liver one of the chief addresses.
The Cordova daily times., 1921-09-28
SHIPBUILDING ENDS
 AT CALIFORNIA YARD
CBy Associated Prcss)

LOS ANGELES HARBOR. Cal, Sept. 2S.-The launching soon of the 1.GOO-ton flush deck freighter West Chopaka at the Los Angeles Ship. building and Drydock Company, will mark the completion of a four year building program which comprised the construction of thirty $500 ton freight, CTS and five freighters of the West Chopaka type
 Twenty $500 ton freighters, in addi- ton to six freighters and oil taukers constructed under private contract. were built by the Southwestern Ship, building Company. The launching of the tanker La Pursima ended the con struction program Of that yard.
The Cordova daily times., 1921-09-28
POLICEMEN GOT SLXRAKEOFFS
 ON BOOZE
CBy Associated Press)

CHICAGO, Sept 2S-The system whereby policemen are alleged to have obtained half dozen take-offs on the same case of whiskey was re. lated in the government investigation of the police department A score of persons, mostly policemen, testi- fled. One charged the members of the police force with being organized in bands and pillaged cars under the pretext of confiscating liquor. which they then sold to bootleggers. who were later raided and held up for po- lice money. When the places were raided the liquor was seized and re- sold
The Cordova daily times., 1921-09-28
LEWIS FORCES WIN -.
 MINE WORKERS SCRAP
tAis&4A A1S.Gs8
,Rv Assoclnted PressO

INDIANAPOLIS. Sept. 2S. - The United States Mine Workers coRyeR tion voted to direct Alexander Howat president of the Kansas miners, to or der the Kansas strikers back to work, This Is considered a vic" tory of the administration forces un- der President Lewis.
 Howat issued a statement saying he would not obey the convention order Tho only way we will ad- wise our men to return to work will be under the same customs and con, dltions prevailing before the strike" he declared. t~'S'
The Cordova daily times., 1921-09-28
Trailing Man Believed Gardner
tRy Associated PresRl

TACOMA, Sept 2S.-The police, postal officials and special agents of the railroads are attempting to pick up the trail of a man believed to be Gardner, who robbed garage near Chehalias and disappeared in an au. tOmohile stolen at Raymond The police at Raymond believe Gardner was there and point out that the proprietor Of a lodging house, where a man an swering the bandits description was sheltered. has disappeared. IL is be lievcd that the proprietor took Gard ner's letter to the San Francisco Bul letin
The Cordova daily times., 1921-09-28
TRIP ENDS IN JAIL
 ONBORDER
 ~
TET I 4U s-.

tBy nterhalional News Servicc)
 ALBUQuERQUE. N NJ, Sept. 2S From a castle on the Rhine to a dirty cell in the dilapidatel County jail at Albuquerque, New Mexico. is synopsis of the story of the aged Baroness Victoria Wolff von Toten- worth, the last chapter of which was written here when agents of the department of justice arrested her for entering the United States with out passport as she stepped from the train which carried her from the Mexican border. With her was her son. Erwin Dathe. former Ger man army officer,
 The mother and son sailed from Germany on Dutch steamer, land ing at Vera Cruz. Mexico. They travelled by rail to Juarez, Mexico from Fl Pasco. Texas Learning that they could not obtain passports they walked along the banks of the Rio Grande and crossed the border north of Fl Pasco, according to the story of immigration agents.
 The fifty-mile hike between Juar- ez and Las Cruces. New Mexico. ov CT mountains and across desert stretches was made with extreme diff fiCulty Dothe was forced to carry his aged mother time and time again when her feet refused to carry her through the deep desert sand. They said that only the hope of starting life anew in the United States carried them on.
 The baroness told immigration of ficers that her first installment of her misfortune came when she learned that her husband had gam bled away thr." fortune at Monte Carlo. He committed suicide and left his titled wife alone to face eviction from their home. At this time their son was stationed in China. As soon as his discharge could be obtained he joined his mother in Hamburg, Germany. and they left for the United States, with just enough money to pay their fare here.
 Living is impossible in Germany" said the baroness. as she pleaded with officers to be allowed to remain here q am good cook would rather be a cook in America than de pend for my living on my friends in Germany"
 The two well be deported to Ger many.
The Cordova daily times., 1921-09-28
CAN'T AFFORD ICE FOR
 ARMY IN HAWAIIANS
,By Associated Press)

HONOLULU. Sept. 2S.-Uncle Sam is too poor to buy ice for his army in Hawaii. according to a new order issued from military headquarters here
 When the wave of economy hit the war department some time ago, one of the things that suffered here was ice The result was an order that no more ice would be furnished by the army to its offices and as a result, heads of departments and clerks have passed the hat to obtain funds where with to ensure continuation of the ice mans trips to their water coolers.
The Cordova daily times., 1921-09-28
WAS APT PUPIL
 AT POODLE TOP
Gnternational News Seryice)

international News SerytCe)
 ATLANTA, Ca, Sept 2S.-Judge Andy Calhoun, of the local police court, became acquainted with the "toddle top" when eight young men were arraigned before him on charges of gaming. He took the top and examined the metallic hexagon- al closely, gazing at the symbols thereon.
 "P1. T2, P3, T3" he read aloud as he turned the top in his hand
 The eight young men watched him closely as he then twisted the top for spin on his desk. When 1t stopped spinning and fell the star looked up at him.
 What does that mean?" he queried.
 That means take all someone answered
 "Twenty-five and costs" he smiled back and called the next case. 7.
The Cordova daily times., 1921-09-28
BRADY RESTS CASE AGAINST
 MOVIE ACTOR
tBy Associated Pressl

SAN FRANCISCO. Sept. 2S. - The district attorney rested his case against Roscoe Arbuckle yesterday afternoon. declaring that sufficient tes- timony had been adduced to warrant holding the defendant to answer to Inc murder charge. Before adjourn ing the court to ? o'clock this after noon Judge Lazarus denied the mo tion to dismiss. withholding his de cision on the murder charge. Alice Lake testified that when Miss Rappe was found in distress crying "I am dving." that Arbucke said to her You are crazy. Shut up or l will throw you out the window" s
The Cordova daily times., 1921-09-28
SWEETHEARTS' QUARREL
 LANDS MAN IN HOOSEGOW
By International News service)

(By International News Service)
 WORCESTER. Mass. Sept 2S.-Ef- forts of Justice Winfred H. Whiting to patch up a quarrel proved unsuccess- full in district court when John H. McGahey. nineteen years old, was ar raigned on charge of accosting on complaint of his former sweetheart, Annie Smith. of Parish Place. Miss Smith is seventeen years old. Me Gahey told the police they would have to lock him up to keep him away from Miss Smith. and they locked him up. The case was continued.
The Cordova daily times., 1921-09-28
ORDER INQUIRY INTO SINKING
 SUB R-6
(By Associated Press)

LOS ANGELES, Sept 2S. - Pacific fleet headquarters announced that the sinking of submarine Re was caused by opening the inner torpedo door while the outboard shutter was open and the failure of the interlocking de vice to work. J. E Dreffein. of San Pedro. was drowned when thrown from the coming tower Vincent Spalsburg, of Powers Lake, North Da- kota. was trapped in the craft. Ad- miral Eberlee announced that q court of inquiry would be held.
The Cordova daily times., 1921-09-28
NORMAL CONDITIONS
 PREVAIL BY SPRING
C8y Associated Press}

NEW YORK, Sept 2S.-Charles E. Bedford, president of the Vacuum Oil Company, and John Wanamuker, both notable figures in industrial and mercantile circles today predicted i speedy return to prosperity with plenty of work for all.
 Wanamaker declared: The busi- ness revival of the past week will be expanded into a business revival of years and years"
 Bedford predicted normal condl- lions will prevail by spring.
The Cordova daily times., 1921-09-28
STOPPED TRAIN TO DELIVER
 BOOZE
CRy Associated Press)

SEATTLE. Sept. 2S.-Ben A. Ben son. conductor, Arthur Kirkham, brakeman. w N. Wall, engineer. and Anthony Siyiello. express messenger, on the Great Northern railway, were indicted on the charges of conspiracy for alleged deliberate stopping" a train at Richmond Beach, near here, for the purpose of unloading liquor from British Columbia at a spot near the Seattle Golf and Country Club,
The Cordova daily times., 1921-09-28
VETS SET FACES AGAINST EVIL
 FORCES
CRy Assocratcd PressD

INDIANAPOLIS, Sept 2S Com mander-in-C Chief w. A. Ketcham. of the Grand Army of the Republic. spoke against every indecision at tack on free government and urged comrades to "set faces like flint against all Notwithstanding Bolshe- yism. I. w. w, anarchism. Ku KluX Klan or whatever their name may be-"
The Cordova daily times., 1921-09-28
Man Appreciated
 Power of Press
Unternational News seryice)

Gntcrnational News Seryice)
 BUCYRUS, O., Sept. 2S.-"ls this the news room?" inquired a mans voice over the telephone in local newspaper office.
 Tt is." was the reply.
 Well, say. do me a favor" said the voice. My wife and I are go- ing to Lakeside for a week. but don't publish 1t because some one may break into my cellar during our absence and steal my private stock"
The Cordova daily times., 1921-09-28
MISSOURI GOVERNOR
 TO AID UNEMPLOYED
GBy International News servIce)

tBy International News Servicc)
 JEFFERSON CITY. Sept 2S.-Gov- crnor Hyde is taking steps to remedy the unemployment situation in the state of Missouri The governor has been holding a series of conferences with State Highway Engineer Alex ander Graham on the proposition of finding work In the state highway de. partment for fc ner service men who want jobs.
The Cordova daily times., 1921-09-28
ARMY RESERVES NUMBER FOUR
 MILLION
CBy Associated Pressp

WASHINGTON. Sept. 2S-The gen, eral staff plans for the organization of the army reserves were made pub lie today. They show provision is made for twenty-seven divisions. az. gregating about 4,25O,OOO men. in which will be included all wartime and national army divisions preserving their number and insigna.
The Cordova daily times., 1921-09-28
GIRL BRINGS SUIT
 AGAINST BETRAYER
Dy International News scrvlco)

LITTLE ROCK, Ark, Sept. 2S.-The value of broken hearts varies. Miss Florence Beebe, twenty-two and pret. ty, declares her heart-broken, as she alleged 1t to be. by Grady Greene, auto salesman-is worth $25,00O
 Her suit. filed in Pulaski circuit court here, charges Greene with breach of promise. Greene is named as the father of Miss Beebe's unnamed baby He denies the allegations.
The Cordova daily times., 1921-09-28
Wife Writes Gardner
 To Go Back to Prison
l}y AssociQtcQ Press)

SAN FRANCISCO. Sept 2S.-Mrs. Dolly Gardner, wife of Roy Gardner, who escaped recently from the fed cral pcnitentiary at McNeil island, has written him a letter through the Daily Bulletin of this city advising him to return to the penitentiary Ito prove to President Harding that you have ended your criminal ca reer" -"" r~
The Cordova daily times., 1921-09-28
GOOD HEADWAY FOR RELIEF OF
 JOBLESS MEN
tBy Associated Press)

WASHINGTON, Sept. 2S. - The progress made today by the unem- ployment conference indicates pros pects for the completion of the emer- gency relief program earlier than expected. The conferees said the work of shaping committee reports is being accomplished so rapidly that it is believed most of them will be ready by the end of the week.
The Cordova daily times., 1921-09-28
NIGHT SESSIONS HELD BY SENATE TILL PEACE
 TREATIES APPROVED
Bv Associated Prcss)

WASHINGTON. Sept 2S. It is understood that President Harding has approved the plans of senate Republicans to expedite ratification of the peace treaties. The program
 CoEtemplates night sessions begin
 ming tonight and continuing until op- ponents of ratifcations are willing
The Cordova daily times., 1921-09-28
Prisoner Communing With Spirits
lBy AssocIateA Presal

CHICAGO, Sent 2S. Wanderer when told hQ uust hang on Friday re- fused te discuss the case, saying he Was too busy communing with the spirits,
The Cordova daily times., 1921-09-28
CASHIER IS CHARGED
 WITH ROBBING BANK
,Rv Associated Press)

SPRINGFIELD, Mo. Sept. 2S.-R. F. Melton, former cashier of the Bank of Charity, Dallas county, was arrested here today charged with Il wing robbed the bank and set fire l. the building which was destroyed July 31.
The Cordova daily times., 1921-09-28
CARL WANDERER MUST SWING
 FRIDAY
CBy Associated PresS

SPRINGFIELD. Ill. Sept. 28.-Carl Wanderer, convicted of the murder of his wife and unborn child and ragged stranger in a fake holdup, will hang September 30, Governor Smalls office announced in denying a elem enCy appeal