davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The Rock Island Argus and daily union. (Rock Island, Ill.) 1920-1923, 1921-10-05
KNIGHTS TEAfPL.AR.

5E stated CQHCLAFE OF ROCK
Island Commandery 10. Is,
.,.-v, knights Tenapiar will be held
S~&. the second . Monday OF each
" $ $:ssss ! & 'f 4sss;: sss
The Rock Island Argus and daily union. (Rock Island, Ill.) 1920-1923, 1921-10-05

20 C1NVUNATtNlkN On hOGA
Island Chapter No 1S. r A.
NJ. will be hs4d On the first
Tuesday of each month at
z 80 D. m J. c. Sca1Lnnger.
e h p *. Il. Ash, secretary
The Rock Island Argus and daily union. (Rock Island, Ill.) 1920-1923, 1921-10-05

lock ISLAND CHAPTER. NO. 269.
Or<ier Eastern Star.-RegulAr meetings.
Second Wednesday of eacn month VB-
isinE Stars welcome. Mrs. Josephine
Mace. W. M: Mary r. Kre4s. secretary.
The Rock Island Argus and daily union. (Rock Island, Ill.) 1920-1923, 1921-10-05

ROCK ISLAND AERIE NO. 956. FRATER
mad Order of Eagies.-Regular meetings
first and third Tuesday of each month
1T Eagles home. Fourth avenue an6
Twenty first street Prank Wlch. W. k-i
Joseph GFoteg1S, secretary.
The Rock Island Argus and daily union. (Rock Island, Ill.) 1920-1923, 1921-10-05

Rock ISLAND COUNCIL NO. 20, b. 6 s.
M-The stated assemblies OF Rock Is
land Council No. 20, e. & $ M. WILL
be held on the third Wednesday OF each
month W. J. Spencer, T. l. M; Q. u.
Hildatraradt recarIter.
The Rock Island Argus and daily union. (Rock Island, Ill.) 1920-1923, 1921-10-05

FOR NEUTRALITY-SUSPICIOUS..
~~~~~->>~~~-~~~~~-~~~
GARAGE. 1920 TWENTIETH STREET
MODERN GARAGE, CEMENT DRIVE
1906 Seventeenth street B. L 3616X-
EUREKA VACUUM CLEANEAs- PHONE
Is. 1. 1851.
The Rock Island Argus and daily union. (Rock Island, Ill.) 1920-1923, 1921-10-05

ROCK ISLAND LODGE NO.
COS, A. r. & A M-Stated
meeting first Friday OF each
month B. p. Record. W IL;
a. s. BoImAa. secretary.
Phoenix tribune., 1921-01-15
Phoenix Federation Notes

Phoenix Federation Notes
The Phoenix Federation of C. w G.
held their first meeting January 9th
at the Second Baptist church and the
following officers were elected for the
ensuing year: Mrs Jessie James.
president; Mrs. Georgia Owens, first
vice-president; Mrs Nola Hamilton,
second vice-president; Mrs. Ella NJ
Brown, third vice-president; Mrs. Gus
sic Manning, recording secretary;
Mrs. Lynn Ross Carter, corresponding
secretary; Mrs. Ada Jones, treasurer.
The following cluls were incorporated
on December 6, 1920: Goldinol, Char
ity, Dunbar and Progressive, with the
object Of moral, intellectual and spirit
ual uplift of our women, girls and
boys. This group has launched CAM
paign for $4,000 to purchase a build
ing, tennis court and. playground. The
building committee has several sites
in view and just as soon as it is
selected the public will be notified.
The members are very much enthused
over the proposition and at their first
meeting last week $3.50 was sub
scribed. Beginning next week they
will publish names and amounts sub
scribed
Mrs. Jessie White Passes
Relatives Of Mrs. Jessie White re-
ceived word that on December 25 she
was severely burned by the flames
from gas stove and died December
o. She was with her mother in
Dewey, Oklahoma, at the time of the
accident and the remains were ship
ped to her old home in GAINESVILLE.
Tex, for burial Mrs. Jessie White
was the wife of James White Of this
city, one of the sons of Mr.. and Mrs.
T. ]. White of 612 South Third ave-
nue.. A baby 10y was born to the
union and he is with his grandmother
in the east.
C. M. E-News
Last Sunday all services were well
attended at the C. NJ E. church. Rev.
Thompson was at his best and
preached two powerful sermons. Mr..
Heath, the noted baritone singer, was
in attendance and rendered a number
of beautiful selections at each service.
Financially it was a banner day,
enough money being raised to pay
the current installment on the street
debt. Next Sunday Rev. Thompson
will deliver two special sermons.
Everybody is invited to attend.
Phoenix tribune., 1921-01-15
INNOCENT BLACK MAN
ACCUSED OF RAPE, FREED
BY WoMAN'S CONFESSION

Dallas, Texas, Dec. 3O.-"Don't
hang an innocent mani"
With these words Mrs. Gertrude
Clark confessed yesterday to District
Attorney Maury Hughes that she
framed" charges of attempted Grim
Iinal assault, burglary and robbery
against Walter >Stegall, Negro.
Mrs. Clark did it, she said, to "save
her home" According to Hughes,
she told him she wanted to conceal
her physical condition from her hus-
band by Stimulating an attack Of ner-
vous prostration.
But when county sleuths found she
had pawned her wedding ring six
days before the alleged robbery, she
broke down and admitted she tied
herself to her bed, told a story of
attempted assault and later identi-
fled Stegall as her assailant.
Stegall was to have been tried next
week He was held under heavy bond
since his indictment by the grand
Jury.
Phoenix tribune., 1921-01-15
CLUB NOTES
By Ms. N. 3. Holt
By Marion Noble


The holidays are over and the club
women again are taking up their
work after a round OF dinner parties,
dances and afternoon affairs.
Mrs. w. H. Williams OF ITO East
Jefferson street entertained the S. /.
A. club with Japanese luncheon. A
large number of members were pres
ent, also several visitors. Among the
visitors were: Mrs. Elizabeth of Chi
cago, Mrs. Johnson of Oakland, Mrs.
Katie Johnson and Mrs. Clifford
Starks from Mrs. Williams old home
in Little Rock, Ark. Some very en-
couraging remarks were made by the
visiting ladies and we were indeed
pleased to have them with us. Lest
we forget, all the honors OF this at.
fair are not due the hostess, for Mr.
Williams, better known as Patrolmau
Williams, both planned and prepared
this luncheon for his wife and as
sisted in serving us. We shall be
glad of another opportunity to at
tend a luncheon at this home.
The Christmas and New Year must
have been very happy and prosper
Phoenix tribune., 1921-01-15
GLOBE-MIAMI
BY Modesto Young

Rev. W. F. Watkins, Mr.: c, F. Wat
kins, Mrs. City, Mrs. Humphrey ane
Mrs. Hayward of Miami were visitor!
in Globe Sunday.
The citizens Of beMiami have
organized N. A. A. c. P. club.
The A. NJ E. church gave a chitter
ling supper Friday.
Miss Simpson left for Phoeni,
where she was called to her mother
bedside
The members of the Baptist churcf
were glad to receive Mrs. Stevens a.
a new member. She was baptized b.
Rev. W. F. Watkins Sunday.
Rev. w. F. Watkins preached +:
noble sermon Sunday evening. Ever.
one left feeling they had been vel
benefited.
I wish to place the Tribune in ever!
home from January, 1921, to January
1922. For information write Box 1883
Modesto Young.
Phoenix tribune., 1921-01-15
:. :. = :: :. = :. :. :. :. :. :. :. :, ;.
:. MRS. HoLT's EXPERIENCES :.
= = :: :. :. :. = :. :. = = :. :. :. =.


:: MRS. HoLT's EXPERIENCES :.
= = : :. = : = = :. :. :. :. :. :. :.
By Mrs. NJ. E. Holt
Note: An efficient equipment for
dressmaking has been carried out in
Mrs. Hollis own home. She brought
to her home an understanding how the
sewing room should be kept, gained
from the study of domestic art in
Prairie View State Normal and Indus
trial College, and she is sure that the
directions given here, if followed, viii
prove successful.
The Sewing Room
Every woman who sews or has sew.
ing done at home should have a light
by day and the artificial light should
be properly placed and shaded. The
floor should be covered by a clean
sheet or linen rugget-sometimes
called crum cloth. This covering
keeps light-colored material from be-
coming soiled, and also enables you
to leave the sewing room in perfect
order at the end of the day, for the
scraps and the threads can be picked
up in the cloth.
The room should be furnished with
comfortable straight chairs, a table
large enough to lay out a skirt or
coat for cutting and sewing. If it
is a regular sewing table, you can
keep your shears, pins, ETC., in the
drawer. The table should have a
smooth, hard, even surface, and
should be of comfortable height so
you can sit with your feet under il
as you would sit at a writing table.
Never sew with your work on
your lap. 1t makes you sit in a
fatiguing position, strains your eyes
and back and stretches and crumples
your work. Lay your sewing on the
table, letting the table support its
weight.
A big chest drawer is useful.
Keep one drawer for buttons, boxes,
hooks and eyes, bones, etc.; another
for patterns and a third for leftover
pieces OF material as long as the
garment is in use, in case you wish
to mend or alter it. There should be
hooks on the wall, coat and skirt
hangers, and a silkoline curtain to
draw over dresses etc, that are left
hanging over night.
Phoenix tribune., 1921-01-15

zona. Christianity and cooperation
will score another victory for the
general good of all during 1921, espe-
cially to colored enterprises, which
should and must have the support and
cooperation of the race in order to
best succeed.
We are here in Columbus, busy
preaching and teaching the word OF
Christ, that some good may be ac-
complished.
You may send us 40 copies of The
Tribune each week.
Phoenix tribune., 1921-01-15
WATCH PHOENIX GROW

FOR SALE = 1S-room apartment,
coming business property; s12,5O0;
$500 cash. VIII rent for $50 per
month
Three small houses, lot 100x100 Ft.,
$3.50 cash, 500 per month.
Fine lot, palms, fruit, date palms;
$3.50; $3.50 cash and SIS per month.
Also business chances at Acre City
for Blacksmith shop, Furniture store,
Hay Grain and Feed; will assist the
right man to secure his stock.
NJ. H. SHELTON,
215 West Washington st.
Phoenix tribune., 1921-01-15
c. NJ. E. Church.

Corner Seventh street and Jeffer.
son. NJ Thompson, pastor. Resi-.
dence at 112 South Seventh street.
Phone 4s69 Sunday school at 10
a. m. Preaching at II a. m. and
p. m. Epworth League at $50 p. m.
Teachers meeting every Tuesday
night. Prayer meeting every
Wednesday evening.
Phoenix tribune., 1921-01-15
sHAMPooINe AND MAssAoINc

sHAMPooING AND MAssAGINc
We are prepared to care for men az
we'll as women customers and special
lze in Manicuring, Hairdressing, Shan
pooing and Massaging. Five years ey
perience in the business. Phone 1249
sor appointment. Mrs. w. J. Jones
i19 East Washington.
Phoenix tribune., 1921-01-15
CHURCH DIRECTORY
A. M. (. Church.

Corner Second street and Jeffer-
son. T. ]. Sanford, pastor Resi-.
dence, 113 South Second street
Phone 61S. Sunday school at 10 a.
m. Preaching at II a. m. and p.
m. Christian Endeavor at 6:15 p. m.
Prayer meeting Wednesday night
General class every Sunday at 1915
p. m.
Phoenix tribune., 1921-01-15
Antioch Baptist Church.

21 East Madison street (upstairs)
c. A. Gilmore, pastor Residence 429
East Washington. Phone 2643. Sun
day school at 10 a. m. Preaching at
IL a. m. and p. M B. Y. P. U. at
$3.50 p. m. Prayer meeting Wednes.
day evening.
Phoenix tribune., 1921-01-15
cHtRoPooIsT

MISS MOLLIE MORRISON, Scientific
Chiropodist All ailments of the
feet carefully treated. Corns, bun
ions, warts and ingrown nails re-
moved. viii call at your home if
desired. Phone 1888. Parlors, SIS
South Second Ave.
Phoenix tribune., 1921-01-15

GUS for the editor, Judging from the
way he is smiling 1t seems that
Santa Claus didn't forget him. More
anon.
Phoenix tribune., 1921-01-15
TRANSFER AND EXPRESS

IF YOU WANT a load of wood OF
kindling; want your trunk moved
or want any hauling done, call 1850
and ask for Geo. NJ. Finley, the
Transfer Man. Stand, IT South
Fourth st.
Phoenix tribune., 1921-01-15
ing winter

The high cost of living is not down
to bottom level, but 1t is showing
signs of getting on the downward
rungs of the ladder.
Phoenix tribune., 1921-01-15
Second eaptIst Church.

Corner Fifth street and Jefferson.
E. D. Greene, pastor. Residence 1884
East Jefferson. Phone 1879. Sun
day school at $3.50 a. m. Preaching
at IL a. m. and p. m. B. Y. P. U.
at p. m. Prayer meeting every
Wednesday evening.
Phoenix tribune., 1921-01-15
Church Of God.

Corner Fourteenth street and Mad.
ison. Elder L. L. Britton, pastor.
Residence 1907 East Jefferson. Sun.
day school at 10 a. m. Preaching at
IL a. m. and 1880 p. m. Services also
are held on Tuesday and Friday
nights of each week. beginning at
7:30 o'clock.
Phoenix tribune., 1921-01-15
COLUMBUS, N. M.
BY Rev. Jno. Fears

by rev. JnO. FeaTS
Considering the political unrest of
1920, the G. o. P. translated the num-
Der "13", having elected the chief of.
ficials of the nation and the COVER
nors Of both New Mexico and Ari-
Phoenix tribune., 1921-01-15

With coal at ever so much ton
fresh air disguised as ventilation is
going to cost lot of money this COM
ing winter.
Phoenix tribune., 1921-01-15

Big league baseball has become
fouled from filthy lucre. But, fortu-
nately for the sport, the game on the
back lots is still clean.
Phoenix tribune., 1921-01-15
HISTORY WoRLp WAR

Every lover of good literature should
have a copy of Kelly Miller's Historv
If the Negro In the World War. J.
.ontains Seven Hundred Seventy-six
pages Of good matter and One Hun
dred Twenty eight illustrated pic
lures. Cloth binding, s275; morocco,
$3.50. Earl Johnson, agent. sos So.
Fifth Ave. Phone 464s.
Phoenix tribune., 1921-01-15

Prices of hats for men indicate that
mems headgear may yet come into
the dignity of being called millinery.
Phoenix tribune., 1921-01-15

Having completed course in Hair
and Scalp Treatment, shampooing and
facial massaging, l am prepared to
give the Poro System of hair and
beauty culture. Graduate of the Poro
College of St. Louis, Mo. Mrs. ]. E.
Gault, 1717 East Jefferson ST. Phone
SsOs.
Phoenix tribune., 1921-01-15

1t is reassuring to learn that this
winter there will be fuel enough for
everybody who has money to burn.
Phoenix tribune., 1921-01-15

Paper clothing is to be shown here.
Under the present circumstances 1t
appears to be sinful waste of paper.
Phoenix tribune., 1921-01-15

FOR SALE-Girl's bicycle; large
size; dirt cheap. Apply 21s East
Madison st.
Phoenix tribune., 1921-01-15
To Our Readers

No person is in a better posi-
ton to know the attitude of
the business concerns of a
community than the one who
solicits the advertisements
and comes in personal contact
with the heads of the busi-
ness concern.
When the advertisement of a
business firm is carried in the
Tribune, it not only serves
as an announcement of the
special prices or the line of
goods handled by that con-
cern, but it is a Direct Invi-
tation to members of the race
to patronize the business
place; further, it is assurance
! of fair and courteous treat
ment.
! Go Where You Are Invited
Phoenix tribune., 1921-01-15

PIANo TUNlNe AND REPAIRINe

FOR RENT-9-room cottage on Madi.
son street; bath and two screen
rooms. See Smith about it, 81 s.
18th st.
The Bottineau courant. (Bottineau, Bottineau County, N.D.) 1895-1929, 1921-08-18
How Camel Got His Hareip.

In 1.-THE Women Of Egypt Mrs.
Elizabeth Cooper, the author, says
that when she decided to ride a camel
and he was brought to the door she
tried to make friends with him, and
continues:
Il walked around him and examined
him closely. He smiled at me with
his harelip, which, if tales are true,
he obtained legitimately. When Allah
created the first camel he was lonely
and went around moaning and groan-
ing over his fate. 1t was then that
the sour, dissatisfied look came to his
face that is a distinguishing mark OF
all camels. Allah became sorry for
him, seeing what a fine disposition
was being ruined, so he sent a genie
to tell him that q spouse was being
created for him. The news delighted
the lonely camel SO intensely that he
smiled and smiled until he split his
lip, and it has remained thus ever
since"
The Bottineau courant. (Bottineau, Bottineau County, N.D.) 1895-1929, 1921-08-18
GREAT PLAYS "FIRsT NIGHTS"
elk Occasions That stand Out Prosnl.
nsntiy In the ArtIstlo History ~
Of France.

Perhaps the most striking events In
the artistic history of France have
been the first performances Of certain
of the great French plays. In a few
cases, also, these occasions have
marked the beginning Of new epochs
In the social history Of that country.
There have. it appears, been but six
unforgettable first nights since theaters
established In Paris. The first
occurred In 1887, when Comedies lie
Gid" took the capital by storm. Forty
years later Racine's "Andromache"
created q similar sensation. On the
eve Of the Revolution, in 1874, Beau
marchais' Marriage Of Figaro was
received with such delirious enthusi-
asm that three persons were sti1ed
in the rush for seats. In 1880 Victor
Hugo, in spite of the determined OPP
position Of a large body Of reaction
aries, set all Paris In an uproar with
his "Hernani." These names may be
borne in mind: Corneille, Racine, Beau
marchais and Hugo. Three Of them,
at least, have no superiors In the
history Of French literature. Each has
one amazing dramatic triumph to his
credit. The other two Of the six great
first nights were December %. 1897,
and February z, 1910. The occasions
were respectively the performances of
"Cyrano de Bergerac" and "Chan-
tecler," both by Edmond Rostand.-
Philadelphia Ledger.
The Bottineau courant. (Bottineau, Bottineau County, N.D.) 1895-1929, 1921-08-18

SA&A EEN NEaA 12 GE4 AE &1 AE&E - &k
man-not unless he wants to be the
object OF smiles like any other inc0n-
gruity. II may not be just. but It's so
Moreover. It Is perfectly just Ia q vast
majority Of cases.
Ninety per cent Of the business men
who deceive themselves into the no.
tion That they are tired because they
overwork are tired because they don't
take-care Of themselves, and they don't
take care Of themselves because they
are too lazy and indolent to do #. In
other words, many q so-called business
man allows himself to be chronically
tired, an outwardly respectable hobo
In q white collar. He plays the fat
boy. An unsympathetic world has q
way Of telling the fat boy that # he
will eat less, take some exercise, shake
his liver and act like a normal boy he
will yawn less.
Everybody with good sense knows
that work, other things being equal, is
q remedy for most Of III Ills, and not
the cause of them. 1t can become 9TH
erwise only by a ~perversion Of thought.
The Nations Business.
The Bottineau courant. (Bottineau, Bottineau County, N.D.) 1895-1929, 1921-08-18

sands OF acres of land that would have
lain Idle II II hadsnot been cultivated
by the boys and girls yielded more than
$500 an acre.
The educational value % the chill
dren vas Tar greater than the value
Of the food products. That value Ia.
cluded health, physical yigor, habits 81
industry. knowledge o. plant life and
OF the phenomena and forces Of m
ture, and the beginning OF the under.
standing OF the fundamental moral
principle that every one should gladly
contribute to his own support BY
his W labor.
The United States bureau Of edu-
cation will not be able TO follow up
this work this year as fully as It has
for several years past" writes +. p.
Claxton, United States commissioner
Of education. ebut | hope the interest
Of children, tearhars, supefinteny.ents
and school boards will not lag and that
the time will soon come when this
Scho0l-directed home garden work will
be recognized as q necessity and an
essential part !of the education Of chill
dren in all cities. towns and Industrial
villages"
The Bottineau courant. (Bottineau, Bottineau County, N.D.) 1895-1929, 1921-08-18

The extent to which federal aid has
been applied to the trails varies In
the different states. Naturally, the
Western states are using much more
Of the federal appointments in de-
veloping roads Of this character than
the Eastern states. This is due to
the fact that the routes in the East
ern states already had been improved
to q large extent before the roads
were selected by the pathfinders. This
was not true In the West, where long
stretches Of the selected roads were
still in an unimproyed condition when
they were designated.
Nevada leads in. its use Of federal
funds on roads OF this character.
Eighty-three per cent Of its entire
mileage of approved federal-aid roads
lies on one o the other Of the trails
which cross the states. On these
roads Nevada will spend 30 per cent
Of the federal money which has been
granted to her.
Indiana is q close second, with 50
per cent OF Its entire federaIaid mile
age and s. per cent Of its money aid
The Bottineau courant. (Bottineau, Bottineau County, N.D.) 1895-1929, 1921-08-18
English Place Names.

The charm of English place names
is not only In their bewildering va-
riety but in the fact that almost all
Of them seem indigenous. At any
rate, they are all rooted deep, from
whatever original soil they came.
Latin and Danish names have been
weathered and mellowed in SO many
centuries of English history that one
remembers only with an effort that
they r not English in origin. Only
the, Norman names have the slightest
tincture of foreign suggestion about
them. French is still q rather tender
exotic which needs to be trained
against the sunny southern wall OF
the language. Beaulieu does lot seem
to belong naturally In Hampshire.
But even to domesticate the names
from the three or four other Ian
guages Is no small triumph Ia verbal
NEUTRALITY-SUSPICIOUS. Science Mon
itOr.
The Bottineau courant. (Bottineau, Bottineau County, N.D.) 1895-1929, 1921-08-18
INTENDED 10 ADVISE RULER
Cabinet Of President Of the United
States q Copy Of Old institu-
tion Ii Europe.

From the earliest times the king
Of England was assisted in his gov
eminent by a body Of men known as
the "privy councir'-men whose adj
vice was sought in the gravest and
most delicate affairs Of state. But.
with the gradual increase Of the demo-
cratic character of parliament. the
real government of the nation be-
came more and more vested in the
kings parliamentary minister's, while
the rank Of prfvy councillor came to
be bestowed as a purely honorary dis
tinctiOn upon men to whom little
was confided. As a result the soy
ereign res0rted for advice to his
principal ministers and hence arose
the custom Of selecting the leading
parliamentary members Of the party
In power. When the United States
government was formed this idea Of
giving the ruler the assistance and ad-
vice Of q group of picked men was
borrowed from the British system,
while the word "cabinet" was taken
from the French, where it signifies
q small cabin or room-kings and
other p0tentates being accustomed to
consulting with their ministers in q
private oom or ."cabinet."-Colum-
bus Dispatch. !.
The Bottineau courant. (Bottineau, Bottineau County, N.D.) 1895-1929, 1921-08-18
horticultural
4. Points
TREE-REPAlR WORK sLlGHTED
Due Is Times 20 UnfavorabIs Expert
sncss With Dishonest or Incapable
Horticulturist

At present t~res-repair work has not
received the recognition and approval
from tree owners that II deserves.
This may be due at times to unfavor-
able experiences with dishonest Or ig-
norant tree surgeons, at other times
to the reluctance Of the owners TO
spend much money In preserving their
trees. or from their ignorance OF the
Dement'S that. may result when tree
repair work is properly done.
Reliable tree surgeons are doing
much in q practical way to educate
the public as to the benefits Of tree
repair work. Afew states have laws
regulating tree-repair work on . COM
imercial basis. :
The United States Department of
Agriculture invites correspondence
concerning methods Of ~tree-repair
work, and Il prepared to advise for
or against any particular method 70
far % experience and the results Of
experiments permit. Farmers Bulle-.
lin 117S on tree surgery will be sent
ehANC Va 0kptkNuIIVu SHgE W. "E7#;i Z&H X
Tree owners are urged to remember
that the necessity for tree-repair work
10 e 20 years hence may be reduced
Materially BY promptly attending to
he fresh injuries Of today,
Most persons can, ut least with .
very little preliminary practice on thu
simpler types 81 work, undertake ordi-
GARY tree surgery provided they are
familiar with the use OF a gouge and
mallet, q saw and q paint brush. a
steady head and ability to climb win
be necessary for work In the top Of
the tree.
A. badly diseased or injured tree
should be removed and replaced BY q
healthy one unless there Is some very
special reason for trying to preserve
the tree.
Two axioms Of tree-repair work
that should be borne In mind constant
" e that prompt treatment OF
freshly made wounds is the surest
and most economical method Of pre-
venting disease and decay In the fu-
ture, and that all wounds made In tree
surgery should be cleaned, sterilized
and protected from infection Just as
thoroughly as in animal surgery. and
for the same reason