Arizona republican., 1921-07-16
How They Voted The roll call follows:

The roll call follows:
 For recommittal - Republicans: Ball. Borah, Brandegee. Calder. Cam eron. Cummins, Curtis. Dillingham;, Edge. Ernst. Fernald. Fre1inehuyseh. Gooding. Hale. Kellogg. Kenyon. Reyes. Knox, Lodge. Mccormick, Me- Kinley, McNary. Moses. Nelson. New. Nicholson. Norbeck. Oddie. Penrose- Poindexter. Shortridge, Shoot Stau- field. Sterling. wadsworth. Warren Watson, Undiana) Weller and WH- lis-39.
 Democrats; Dial. Glass. King. Myers. Simmons, Swanson. Under wood and Williams-.s. Total for recommittal-47-
 Against - Republicans. Bursum. Capper. Elkins, Harreld. Jones. tNashington) Ladd. Lafollette, Nor ris and Sutherland.-e-
 Democrats: Ashufst. Brousxard. Caraway. Culberson. Fletcher. Gerry. | Harrir. Harrison. Heflin. Hitchcock. Jones' tNew Mexicol: Kendrick. Me- Kellar. Pittman. Robinson. Sheppard. i Stanley. Walsh. fMassachusetts). Walsh. (Montana) and Watson. tGeorgia) 20. Total against recom-. mittal-29-
 It also was announced that Sena- ] tors Phipps. Republican of Colorado. and Townsend Republican of 1Iichi- gan, who were absent, were paired in favor of recommittaI and that Sena- tors Reed of Missouri. and Trammeli. Florida. Democrats were paired against recommittal.
 Plans Weekly Motion
 An effort for an order directing early return of the bill to the senate | <l<E<. <.1 r~-- <-rE motion of Senator Kenyon, Republi- can of Iowa. to have the bill brought back early in January being rejected. Senator Pittman. Democrat of Ney4- da, thereupon announced that he would maFe motion every week hereafter 10 bring back the bill from committee
 Stormy clashes between Demo-
 cratic opponents and Republican advocates of reeommittat marked
 the closing debate But they were
 mild as compared to the scenes
 which followed the roll call.
 Among the incidents was . chAl-
 lenge by Senator Mccumber. Re-
 plblican of North Dakota,
 champion of the bill, to Senator Reed, Democrat of Missouri, fo
 settle . question of veracity tout
 sioe" and shouts of "sit down.
 made to Senator Mecumber by
 Sen ator Watson, Democrat,
 Georgia.
 Senatorial dignity andwrules were lost in the confusion. A half dozen senators were speaking at once. clamoring for recognition by the vice president To add to the din. mid summer storm broke over the capitol. pouring torrents of rain on the glass root of the senate while lightning flashes vied with it's lighting system. Senators could be heard only with difficulty.
 I Wage Two Hour Wrsnele
 The TOW broke when Senator Me Cumb-r was recognized by the vice president to explain the effect of the bills recomnittal Senators Robin son. Democrat of Arkansas and Reed. declared that. there being no bill. or other business before the senate. NIT. McCumber's speech was not in order. but the vice-president ruled in order of MT. McCumberA '
 For two hours the parliamentary and personal wrangling continued Senator McCumber standing bv his guns and finally concluding his speech. The senate by virtual party vote. of 3s to 27, also sustained the vice-presidents ruling.
 There were many tense moments especially when Senators McCumber ! and Reed walked toward each other on opposite sides of the aisle. Sen. ator Robinson and others, however, | stepped between them This. oc- cured when Senator Reed, referring } to Mir. McCumber's invitation for dis cussiof of their differences 'ioutsides t declared:
 ? 'T never saw blackguard yet who did not want to go outside to settle. I Senator McCumber then left his r seat and moved toward Senator Reed. while Senator Williams. Democrat of Mississippi. called Mir. Reed "to , order" Senator Robinson. declaring that the personalities did mot re- , fleet credit on the senate" suggested that both senators go over the record , and delete their remarks. Both sem ! ators finally agreed to this. Senator Reed saying he did not wish any re- iflection to stand. He said. however. that the outside is so large that ft is generally considered safe place" ' T can say with absolute assurance l to the American people. and ths American soldier" Senator McCurr g ber said that this bill-wiIl he ones Unto law, and I am certain that il {.