Arizona republican., 1921-11-18
HOUSE BREAKS WITH HARDING
 ON TAX RATE
INSURGENT REPUBLICANS DISREGARD PRESIDENTS REQUEST AND ADOPT SENATE AMENDMENT PROVIDING 50 PER CENT SURTAX RATE
Republican A. p. Leased wIrel

WASHINGTON, Nov. 17-Disre- garding the expressed wish of Presi- dent Harding, the house today voted POI to 173 to eccept the senate amend ment to the tax revision bill fixing the maximum income sur tax rate at 50 per cent on incomes of $200,- 600 or more.
 Ninety-four Republicans, most of them from the middle and far west, joined with the practically solid Dem ocratic minority in supporting the am andment. Announcement of the re- suit brought applause from both sides, with some Democrats cheer ing.
 Three hours before the vote was taken the house listened to the read ing of letter from President Hard ing to Chairman Fordney of the ways and means committee, suggesting the house and esenate compromise. The executive said he still believed the original house rate of 32 per cent was nearer to a just levy and the more promising one in returns to the public treasury" but that in view of the legislative situation he thought 1t wholly desirable" that there be a compromise at 40 per cent.
 Immediately after it became known r. Fordney, spokesmen for the insugent Republican,. said that the letter would not affect the result.
 They had claimed 93 Republican votes. or one less than was cast for the amendment
 THE ROLL CALL
 For amendment, Republicans: An- derson, Andrews, Nebraska; An- Do ,,,1 Boies, Brennan, Brooks, Illinois; Browne, Wisconsin; Burtness, Camp bell. Kansas; Chalmers, Christopher son, Clague, Classon, Cole, Ohio; Col ton, Cooper, Wisconsin,; Cramton, Curry, Davis, Minnesota; Denison, Dickinson, Dowell, Evans, Faust, Eos ter, Frear, Fuller, Funk, Gensman, Graham. Illinois; Green, Iowa; Hau- gen, Hoch, Hull. James, Johnson, South Dakota: Kearns, Keller, Kelly, Pennsylvania; Ketcham. King, Kim kaid, Kleczlza, Kopp, Lampert, Law renee, Lineberger, Little ,McCormiclz. Mclaughlin, Nebraska; Maloney Moore. Ohio; Morgan, Murphy, A. P Nelson, J. M. Nelson, Ogden, Patter- son, Misso dri; Ramseyer, Schall Rhodes, Tickets Robison, Schall Scott, Tennessee; Shaw, Sinclaidr Sinnott, Speaks, Stafford, Steenerson Strong, Kansas; Summers, Washing ton; Sweet, Swing, Thompson, Tin cher, Towner, Voigt, Volstead, Wal ters, Wheeler. White, Kansas; Vii. Hams, Williamson, Wood Indiana; Yates. Young, Zihlman-94.
 Democrats-Almon, Aswell, Bank head, Barkley, Black. Bland, Virgi- nian; Blanton, Bowling, Box, Briggs Brlson, Buchanan, Bulwinkle, Byrnes South Carolina; Byrons, Tennessee; Cantril, Carew, Clark, Florida; Cochran, Collier, Collins, Connally Texas; Crisp. Glen, Davis, Tennes- see; Dominick, Doughton, Drewry Driver, Dupre. Favrot, Fields, Fish CT, Fulmer, Gallivan Garner, Gar rett, Tennessee; Gilbert. Goldsbor. ough, Griffin, Hammer, Hary, Texas; Harrison, Hayden, Huddleston, Hud. Apeth, Humphreys. Jacoway, Jeffers Alabama; Johnson, Mississippi; Jones, Texas; Kincheloe. Kindred Kunz, Lanham, Lankford, Larsen Lowery, McChntic, McDuffie, Me Swain, Martin, Meads, Montague Moore, Virginia; O'Brien, O'Connor Oldfield, Overstreet, Padgett, Park Georgia; Parks. Arkansas; Parish
 (CoOtinI1ed o,, yooa oN