Arizona republican., 1920-03-16
bY TWO TO ONE VOTE APPROVES
 |. ]. ?. STAND
Action Ends For Present Move For Ratification By Compromise T h i n k Treaty Will Go Into New Deadlock-Final Vote By End of Week
IRepubIican A. p. Leased Wire1

WASHINGTON, March 15.-Re-
 affirming its disagreement with
 President Wilson on the domnat-
 ing issue of the peace treaty con
 troversy, the senate adopted today
 by a vote of more than two to one
 the new article ten reservation
 framed by republican leaders.
 its action ended, at least for the
 present, the effort for a compro-
 mise that would insure ratification
 and the senate's decision was ac-
 cepted generally as hastenins the
 treaty toward another deadlock,
 from which it could be released by
 verdict at the polls next No
 vember.
 Fourteen democrats voted with the united republican membership for the reservation, but this defection from administration ranks fell far short of the number to ratify. It was con ceded that others probably would swing over on the ratification roll call. but administration leaders, back ed by a definite assurance that the new reservation was unacceptable to the president evidenced no apprehen- sion that their forces would dwindle beyond the danger point.
 Does Not Assure Ratification
 The vote, 56 to 2e, showed on its face a two-thirds majority for the reservation. but it by no means indi- cated two thirds would vote for rati- flea tios on that basis. Included in the majority were irreconciliables. hold ing about a score of votes which on the ratification roll call are expected to be cast against the treaty.
 Ehe reservation. adopted after many efforts to modify it had been defeated by the united republican majority. fol- lows in general form the one adopted last November. It says:
 '.The United States assumes no ob- liza ton to preserve the territorial in tegrity or political independence of any other country by the employment of its military or naval forces. its re- sources, or any form of economic dis crirnination, or to interfere in any way in controversies between nations, in- cluding all controversies relating to territorial integrity or political inde- pendence, whether members of the league or not, under the provisions of article ten, or to employ the military or naval forces of the United States, under any article of the treaty for any purpose. unless in any particular case congress, which, under the constitu- tion, has the sole power to declare war or authorize the employment of the military or naval forces of the United States, shall. in the exercise of full liberty of action, by act or joint reso- lution so provide"
 The roll call follows:
 How They Voted
 For adoption: Republicans: Borah Erandegee, Calder, Capper. Colt, Cum mins, Curtis, Dillingham;, Edge, El4ins Fernald, France. Frelinghuysen Gronna, Hale, Harding. Jones ot Washington: Kellogg, Kenyon, Reyes Knox, La Toilette, Lenroot, Lodge Mccormick, Mclean. McNary, Moses New, Norris, Page, Phipps, Poindexter sherman, Shoot, Spencer, Sterling Sutherland Townsend, Wadsworth Warren and Watson, AZ.
 Democrats: AshurSt. Gerry, Gore Henderson. Kendrick. Myers, Nugent Phelan, Pittman. Pomerene, Reed Shields Smith of Georgia; and Walsh of Massachusetts, 14.
 Total, 56.
 Against: Republicans: None.
 Democrats: Beckham, Chamberlain Conner, Culberson. Dial, Glass, Harris Harrison, Hitchcock, Johnson of Soutf Dakota; Jones of New Mexico; King Kirby McKellar, Overman, Owen
 (Continued- on Page Three)