davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
Bogalusa enterprise and American. (Bogalusa, La.) 1918-19??, 1920-04-22
MAKING IMPROVEMENTS

The Bogalusa Steam Laundry is to
have some extensive improvements
made during the next few months,
Most of their machinery, which is
now heated by gas, will be replaced
with steam machinery. Several of
she most modern machines have been
purchased and when all are in Oper-
'tion the plant will do even better
work than at present.
Bogalusa enterprise and American. (Bogalusa, La.) 1918-19??, 1920-04-22
CITY FURNITURE PURCHASED

A committee composed Of City At
torney Talley, Commissioners Cas-
sidy and Wadsworth and City Clerk
Bean went to New Orleans last week
where they purchased some new fur
niture for the City Hall. Thew re-
port many kinds of office furniture
cannot be secured and that al prices
are extremely high.
Bogalusa enterprise and American. (Bogalusa, La.) 1918-19??, 1920-04-22
!. .ERATWE STORE OPENS

eIS y perative Stores Co, Inc.
ssrSs,.ae store of ". G. Dorsey
$780, ~ 5ogalusa, was opened
N N N last saturday and it re-
.. sa1ra sales force to handle
astss DIR. Di&an, the man
nge 5th mat the stoTS. had done
sssE BUSINESS y than he expected.
AZ y the cooperative com
Il ~ Principally by EN-
l ~ y. 0. G, N. shops.
salpnlents of new mer-
Hbss i expt cted to arrive this
NM ney eADect to offer some
Bogalusa enterprise and American. (Bogalusa, La.) 1918-19??, 1920-04-22
RAMsER vFPY SICK

August Ramser, one of the best
known employees of the N. o. G. N.
shops, and well known and popular
citizen, is reported to be in serious
condition at the Bogalusa Hospital.
His many friends hope for a speedy
receiver.
Bogalusa enterprise and American. (Bogalusa, La.) 1918-19??, 1920-04-22
PARKER ELECTED

Here is some sensational political
news. John M. Parker was elected
governor of Louisiana Tuesday. j.
E. Bateman was elected sheriff of
Washington parish.
Very few votes were cast in Be-
galusa, owing to the fact that the
nominations which were made on
January 20 were equivalent to cleo
tiOn
Bogalusa enterprise and American. (Bogalusa, La.) 1918-19??, 1920-04-22
sPEKENtiIER BUYS HOME

]. A. Spekenhier, the accommO uaJ-
ing cashier of the First State Bank,
has purchased the H. e. Roster home
on Louisiana avenue and will move
to the new home at an early Gate.
It is one of the contest places IN the
city, with an abundance of artesIan
water.
Bogalusa enterprise and American. (Bogalusa, La.) 1918-19??, 1920-04-22
Johnson VISITS CITY

Prohibition Director Jess johnson
came up Tuesday to cast his vote in
the general election, look after bust
ness interests and visit friends.
Bogalusa enterprise and American. (Bogalusa, La.) 1918-19??, 1920-04-22

D. B. Haven, of the sales depart
a1ent of the Great Southern Lumber
Company, has returned from an ex--
tended business trip to st. Louis and
vicinity.
The evening world., 1920-08-05
MANIAC
COMMON CRIMINAL,
IS JUDGES RULING
Court UpholdS Jail Sentence
For Nan Whose Auto Kills
Brooklyn Baby.

The conviction FOR reckless driving
with a jail sentence of thirty days,
from which Harold Hoff OF No. IS
Powell Street, Brooklyn, appealed af-
ter his examination before Magistrate
Fish in the Traffic Court, was sus-
tained to-day by County Judge Mitch
ell May in Brooklyn.
On Jue II Honf's car collided with
that of Harry Swiryn Of No. G92 De
Kalb Avenue. Brooklyn, at VIII
loughby and Marcy Avenues, accord
Ing to witnesses. Hoff's car jumped
the curb and struck a baby carriage
in which was the child of Samuel
Heyman OF Ma. 8 Vernon Avenue,
Brooklyn. The baby died from It's in e.
iuries. Swiryn also was given a
thirty-day sentence.
In sustaining the Hoff conviction
Judge May said, in part: Nothing
should be done to discourage the full
est use of the automobile for pleas
ure and for business purposes, but
nothing should be left undOne TO
compel proper respect for adherence
10 the laws, and one who violates
them must recognize that he Is no diff
ferent from the ordinary criminal who
menaces life. health and property.
The speed maniac, the inebriate
and the Incompetent have no right
upon the highways"
The evening world., 1920-08-05
TENANT SOVIET"
INJUNCTION ASKED
Brooklyn Landlords Say Occupants
of Apartments Hang Out
"Rent Strike" Signs.

An injunction against a so-called
Tenant Soviet OF twelve mcinbers
was asked by Max and Rose Cutes,
owners of apartment houses No S5l-3
stone Avenue. Brooklyu, Of Justice
Squlrcs to-day. II is sought TO re
strain the twelve tenants from hang
ing out rent strike" signs, intimidat-
ing tenants who are willing 70 pay
rents and resisting all efforts at collcc-
Non from themselves.
According to the affidavits the own
ers tried TO dlspossess the twelve sew
oral months ago hut the proceeding
was delayed under the recent rent leg
iSlation. From that time until now. aC-
cordiuG TO Cutcs and his wife Meyer
Fishbein and Clcven others named have
made it Impossible TO rent apartment
to new tenants by threatening violrnc,
10 them
According to the affdavts the head.
OF families complained of have aEitated
extreme soviet principles to the *
tent OF organizing the block into an ace
lively revolutionary body at block par
tics denOunCing landlords, Eroncrs
butchers and milk dealers as capital
lists who should be strung to lamp poles
and tortured to death" Provision deal
urs who have been bl0cklsted by the
Soviet were barred from the neigh
bOThOOd. IL iS asserted
The evening world., 1920-08-05
PORT OPEN OR UNION,
THIS CASE TO TELL
Buyer Injunction to Go to u. S.
Supreme Court No Matter What
Judge Hand Decides.

The question whether the Port OF
New York shall bo opon or controlled
by labor unions in the operation and
handling OF its shipping and freight is
likely to be determined. il was declared
in Federal District Court before Judge
\. n Hand to-day, by the injunction
proceeding Instituted 10y Samuel Buyer
Of Samuel Buyer g. Co, manufacturers
Of No. 935 Broadway. Tho case came
up to-day on Buyers application that a
temporary injunction against inter-
ference by unions obtained by him a
month ago be made permanent,
The defendants are the international
Brotherhood OF Teamste,Y,, Chauffeurs,
Stnblcmen and Helpers The I.ongshore-
mems Association, and the Old Domin-
ion Transportation Company They are
represented Dy James l., o. Neill, 4. :.
Gilbert aud steven A. -. Jones. Wal
ter Gordon Merritt, Chairman OF the
Law Committee OF the Citizens Trans
purtouoA Company. appears for the
plaintiff
Judge Hand asked for briefs and
continued the temporary injunction
pending his decision. Prediction was
made by tho attorneys that nothing
8Ao"t CT q United States Supreme Court
. ruling viii satisfy both sides.
The evening world., 1920-08-05
K. c. PARADE
BEFORE BIDDING
PILGRIMS ADIEU
Lay Plans to Fight White
Plague at Closing Session
Of Convention.

Af'er authorizing action for the
erection OF a St,O0O.0OO tuberculosis
sanitarum. ordering Tie drafting "
an expression Of unqualified support
for tho Irish cause 10 be sent 10
Eamonn de Valera Of the Irish Re
public, and hearing speeches in which
the Irish cause was declared TO be an
American question, the knights OF
Columbus this afternoon adjourned
their Supreme Convention at the Hotel
Commodore,
Following luncheon the 500 dele
gates left the Hotel Commodore Tor
the parade through the city in 100
automobiles and on board the steamer
Highl ander in tho big send on to
the delegation OF officers being sent
abroad to present a statue Of I'atay-
eLte to the City Of Metz, to present
tokens Of esteem to Cardinal Mercier
and to have an audience with Pope
benedict XIV
The Police Band and a squad OF
motorcycle police led the procession
in Park Avenue to 10th Street, west
to Fifth Avenue, south .to Eighth
street, to Lafayette Street, to Broad
way and thence 70 Pier A, North
River. where the Highlander Nwa1ted
to carry the knights 10 the French
liner Leopoldina and 70 carry down
the bay those remaining here, waving
bon voyage to the overseas delegation
on board the steamship. The Loo
poldina was 10 sail late this afternoon.
DISTRICT Attorney Pelletler. Supreme
Advocate, was instructed TO draft 2
resolution 10 be submitted 10 Presl-
dent De Valera, expressing unduali-
! fied support od the ordeT. Josepi.
| Scott, a lawyer OF Los Angeles, called
upon the convention TO rise in the
might OF their manhood and 10 be
! counted TO a man true Americans N,
espOusing the cause OF IAberty."
I'VE the citizens of the same coun-
| try which produced Thomas Jefferson
and Abraham Lincoln, win not deny
the great prlnciple which they pro
nounced, that God Almighty never
crt4tted one man big enough to holt
his felloY men In subsection" hait
Scott. The question of Irish freedom
is an American question. Tho bUyi
Of the glorious seth who struck tina
great blow at the HIndenburg line
wanted not only 10 smash that line
lbut 10 make forever certain that an!
nation that advocated hypocricy an,
suppression, whatever It's race o
CLINE, be wiped off bhe face OF tn
earth. We should feel that their sac
rifice was in vain II ireland Is no
given her independence"
A. L. Joyce OF indiana made 'oon
tesslOn' TO the convention that N
once admired John Redmoud's ul
tlmaliatic policies. but had beel
shocked at British coercion piac
tised In Ireand.'
James A. FllherLy. Supreme Granl
The evening world., 1920-08-05
NEW TRENCH RIFLE TESTED.
Tried Ont In Jersey nj Last of
Governors Days.

Gov. Edwards OF New Jersey, mill
rarv and civil guests arc at camp
Edwards Sea Girt, to-day to celebrate
The last of this seasons Governors
pays. There was a review Of tn"
troops this afternoon by Brig Gen.
bird W. Spencer, Inspector General Of
Rifle Practice. \ luncheon was given
nv COY Edwards to many OF the
quests before the military features.
4 new type Of shOrt-rauge firearm.
.d igned especially for trench use, riot
dutv and nirplane work, was tested
ON the rifle range to-day. The now
weapon IL made In two sizes. both Of
which use the .45-calibre rifle omuni-
tlou third tyre, to use. the 80 cal
'Thc inventor is Gen. John T. ThUmp
ON, chief az Ordnance of the War. De
uartmcnt GoN. f lwardS will bid fare
,,rU TO tho troops tomorrow
The evening world., 1920-08-05
FRIEND
TO AID WIFE HELD
ON BIGAMY CHARGE
princess Pat" Regiment Sur
vivor Sought Bail for Bride,
the Mother of Five.
WON BY WAR STORIES,
Veteran WeiS "Other Girl"
After Being Upbraided by
Admirer for Flirting.

John B. Miller. one Of the twelve
Princess Pats" who survived the
famous fight on Vimy Ridge, and who
was wounded and sassed in Flanders
was arrlisned in the jefferson Mar
iet Police Court to-day, charged with
burglary by Detectives Hamley and
Coleman OF the Truck Squad
The deteotiges arrested Miller yes
terday afternoon IN East Houston
Street, when his actions with a large
bundle aroused their suspicious. In
vestigation disclosed that the bundle
contained $500 worth Of jewelry aud
clothing said to be taken from no. 6l
Morton Street.
To the detectives and reporters MI
Ter said that he and three companions
left Jersey City early in the war and
went to Buffalo where they met a
stranger who gave them drinks.
When they came to" they were
wearing the uniform Of the Princess
Pat" Regiment, and on their way to
Halifax to go overseas.
After he was wounded Miller said
he was six months In an Dnglish
hospital and four months in q Ca
madam hospital, after which he came
back to New York and got work fn
the Peck Memorial Hospital, Twelfth
and Albany Avenue. Brooklyn.
There, according to his account, his
stories of the war won him many
friends among women, and several
weeks ago one of them upbraided
him for flirting with another. There
upon, he says, he married tho other
girl at once. After three weeks OF
married life he discovered, no asserts
that his wife was married and had
Ave children.
'Her husband showed up, he said
and mad her arrested ON q charge OF
blgamy." She Us now held in River
head undor $1,000 bail. When
found that out / decided there waI
nothing for me to do but stick tC
her, so I went over to Morton Street
10 sec "a friend and get money TO gC
! to- Riverhead and arrange for her bal
1 IL could waited for a while bu
my friend didn't show up so I tool
some of his things, intending TO PAW
| them, 90 to Riverhead, help my wifi,
and then come back and make 4
| clean breast OF II all 10 my friend
! go to work and repay him as soon a!
| could. But the detectives were tot
quick for me. guess | can pay my
debts like | have always done"
! Miller has discharge papers ant
photographs TO slTbstantiate his story
OF service overseas.
The evening world., 1920-08-05
new CITY WAGE
PLAN ADOPTED;
2O-22 P. C. BOOST
Board of Estimate Puts O. K.
On Substitute for Sched-
ule Hylan Vetoed.
CRAIG LOSES FIGHT.
Curran Amendments Are Voted
Down-USual Tilts at
Public Session.

The Board of Estimate to-day
adopted the new 1920 per cent. sal
ary increase plan for $4,000 city en-
ployees. which Is n substitute for the
fiat 20 per cent plan defended by
Comptroller Craig and vetoed by
Mayor Hylau The new schedule was
approved by a vote taken at a public
meeting Of the whole committee,
vh.-l Will be followed by q formal
session Of The Board this afternoon
when this action will be indorsed.
Comptroller Craig voted against the
schedule President Curran OF Man
haitian did not vote.
Before the final vote was taken
there were several verbal tits in whion
Mayor Hylan, Comptroller Craig and
Currau participated Comptroller
Craig repeatedly pleaded for twenty
four hours time in which TO examine
The figures According 20 the Comp
rroller. these figures were kept locked
IN tnr back room of a printing shop
until the last minute and then rail-
loadod through.
Currln proposed several amend
luents to the new plan. One was the
substitution Of $500 for the $500 in
crease Tor higher paid city employees; ;
another that the q per cent, increase
to applicable to all employees up to
S20CQ a year instead OF $500 a year.
\ third Gmcndmou, provided that the
percentage rates Of Increase apply the
same 70 those who receive main
tenance as to those who do not re-
ceive maintenance. Curran's amend
nents were defeated.
Eaycr IIy4an tcld the Manhattan
Borough President that he knew he
was not serious when he introduced
them and that TREY were presented
purely for pc,.Jcal effect.
When Mayor Uyldu called him TO
crder for discussing the schedules
during = roll-cAil, Comptroller Craig
told tne Mayor that il he continued
TO deny tho right Of free speech IL
might be n necessary to have a Supreme
Court Justice conduct the proceed
ings' of the Board OF Estimate. May
or ftNIdu LtIuSSu W pSluilb LoPuLy
Comptroller Frank Prial to speak.
lI@al is head of the OWL Service
Forum and an advocate OF the fat 20
pc cent. plan.
Tho now salary schedule. which Will
Nocumr effective Aug. 20, follows:
Employees receiving $1,000 or less
get nn increase Of c2 per cent. (mini-
mum S2OO) S1,5O1 to 81, increase
Of 20 per cent; $4,000 to $1,000 in
crease Of $500 each; over $1,000 in
crease not to exceed $500,
Employees receiving maintenance
one half of above rates minimum
$1,000; part time employees, the same
as above but no minimum.
Equivalent percentage of increase
for employees receiving S2,500 to
$500 are:
The evening world., 1920-08-05
TWO HELD IN AUTO KILLING.
Newark Woman, struck Ia Front
Of Home, Lett by Driver.

Accused Of being the operators OF
an automobile which killed Mrs. Dora
KnUUeman OF 40. i6j Hunterton
Avenue. Newark, In front ~ her home,
Two young mon describing themselves
AS Albert Sanders and Fred Schnitzer
we're held Io-day bv the police Of High
land, n j., for the Newark authorl-
ties. As Mrs. Knobelman stepped off
the curb yesterday afternoon. an
automobile driven ON the wrong side
Of the street struck and killed her Two
hatless, Coatless, buisteruusly singing
men in the car drove Off without stop
ping.
Dr. D. n Shack. of No. 4lO Bergen
street who, IT Is alleged, had treated
one for cut 1eW minutes before the
killing and had warned The pair not to
drive, gave a description to the police
The evening world., 1920-08-05
TINY GIRL TAKES
JOHN DIS NICKEL;
BOY SPURNED ONE
Chauntey N. Depew Also Ac-
cepts and Takes a Lucky"
Coin for Wife.

LENOX, Mass, Aug. 5.--When
John D. Rockefeller offered Brian
Howe, the little grandson of the
proprietor of the Hotel, Aspinwall.
a bright new nickel, the young
ster shook the oil nagnate,s hand
from his shoulder and spurned the
coin.
But little girl, E)dmee Reis-
niger. didn't hesitate a second
when the nickel was offered her,
She pocketed it. thanked Mr..
Rockefeller prettily and even lis
tened to his advice on how to
save money.
Then Mr.. Rockefeller tried his
luck on his old friend Chauncey NJ.
Depew. When he offered Mr.. De-
pew a 1920 Ave-cent piece FOR
good luck" the former Senator
not only took it, but got an extra
one for Mrs. Depew.
The evening world., 1920-08-05
DENIED SHE FIRED HOUSE.
brooklyn Woman accused of Arson
Pleas Not Guilty.

Mrs. Adele kruse Of No. 2l6 Llnwood
street Br0oklyn, to-day pleaded not
guilty 70 charge Of arson in the
hrst degree when arratgned before
County Judge Monahon. Mrs. Krl6s
was accused Of setting a firs IN a house
at No, 2983 FGton Street. Brooklyn.
Whore she said her husband, John
Henry KTlse had gone with another
woman. Mrs, kruse was said 10 have
followed the couple 10 the house, and
TO have set the Are with the intention
Of frightening them, The flre was
confined TO the stairs and did little
damage
Mrs, Krug alleged TINT juSt before
her 70 sign over her dover rights m
his favor.
The evening world., 1920-08-05
QUICK MOTORMAN
SAVES MAN ON az"
Stops Train, and Salesman VINO
Fell or jumped From Plat
form Escapes Death.

\ southbouuJ Niutp Avenue elevated
u1m was pulling m,p :bs 3iih Street
station ct oflocL this morning when
man OH the platform Jumped or fell
IN front Of it tovis Wallace. the mo-
tormau. made q quirk stop and the man
suffered only bruises and a cut foot.
At Bellevue Hospital after refusing
Tor some tine 10 IDENTIFY himself. he
finally said u, was Toward Weldin. No.
207 East Logan Street Philadelphia, a
salesman out. OF wo b lie denied he
had at,cmptra suicide. saying he be-
came d,E2y and ia.i
Tile motofniau Insisted it was
Jump, uud not q very good jump too.
Tor he says Wallace almost cleared
both rails.
The evening world., 1920-08-05
AUTO DRUNK CASES
DOUBLE IN DRY" 1920
New Jersey Has Revoked t25
Licenses for Intoxication SO Far
This Year.

TRENTON, Aug. 5.-The number of
men who have lost their automobile
licenses for driving while intoxicated
has been twice rs great since January,
when the Eighteenth Amendment be
came effective as during the whole
of last year. There have been 1875
revocations in this State for this cause
to date this year.
Sixteen of the licenses were revoked
In q single day. last week. Driving while
under the influence Of liquor has become
such a menace, according to Motor
Vehicle Commissioner Dill. punishment
bv iail sentences Is to be urged in al
dillon TO revocation Of license.
The evening world., 1920-08-05
SAVED BY HIS WIFE
WHILE SWIMMING
She flowed Crippled Husband 10
Shore, Holding Him by
the Hair.

Arthur Clement OF No. 1856 st. Mark
Avenue, Frecport, l.. l., was swimming
with his wife In Randalrs Bay last
night. Clement lost one leg In rail-
road accident years ago. His other leg
suddenly became helpless through
cramps while IN the water with Mrs.
Clement. A. he sank he seized his
W,tc but she knowing this would drag
her down. TOO, managed to shake loose
from his grip and swim around behind
him. Clement disappeared beneath the
surface. When he came up again his
wife seized him by the hair and towed
HIM TO shore.
H. was unconscious when dragged
out OF the water, but was revived BY
"A pulmOtOr and taken home
The evening world., 1920-08-05
three boys Playing on BrOOIlyr
I'ler Are Missing.

Three, cleyon-year- old Brooklyn boys
we're reported to the police to-day a.
missing. 1t is feared they may have
Ircn drowned They are Thomas Mi
rhpIsIsy. 80. 23S FRANKLIN Street; Leon
Eamsh. No G5 Freeman Street, and
Nicholas Ma.rodina, 40 7l3' Franklin
-rc,t They are said TO have been
nst sceu playing M the pier at the
.oot of dupont street II they are no
Suu4 soon tle laraor squad win Ice
..uod upon 90 drag for .hom.
The evening world., 1920-08-05
SANDWICH MEM
AS PROFITEERS' FOES
Prot. Grimshaw Suggests Way to
Cut Food Prices ON Washing
ton Heights.

Or. Robert Grmshaw Of West l77th
Street, a special lecturer in New York
University. suggests as "A remedy
against proftccrinB IN retail sales Of
vegetables, fruits and fish, that sand
wich men" be posted near the doors of
dealers with Dlacards giving lair prices
for that day.
the plan he says he will try IL out HIM
self next week on Washington Heights
at his own expense, and that he win
get the daily fair prices himtell from
Washington Market. He urges ErOups
Of citizens to try the same plan iu thc!r
neighburhOOds to check pruutecr.ng.
The evening world., 1920-08-05
NuuitHuiH Keeps Up 2a-KnOt Aver
NO On ERRtcrn Trip.

, Tho steamship Aqutania, which left
bnrr last Saturday for Southampton.
VAS avcraged 1888 knots an hour for
II distance OF 2,l2S miles up to noon
yesterday. according to a wireless mes
-arc from, nor Captain, received here
ta.Gr5 rive vua fur ihc - hours pre-
ir3 Ico.. Mor a,.77 ,3}, ~ "a ss,hi
70 arrive a. southampton early TO-
morrow morning,
The evening world., 1920-08-05
Wage Conference mt Ellis Island.

Anthony Caminetti, Commissioner
General OF immigration, arrived from
Washington at Ellis Island to-day TO
complete conferences with the em-
ployees and Commissioner Wallis Of the
immigration station on a rcadjustment
OF wages CommlgglQu,r Gcnargl Cami-
hsLu u concerned also about the diffi =
Guilty In getting competent help az Ellis
Island,
The evening world., 1920-08-05
williamsburg bridge Service
Friday.

William s, Minden, General Manager,
announced to-day he expected partial
service would be resumed ~ the B. Il.
r over the williamsburg Bridge to-.
morrow night, lie added that due to
the rapiulty with which the railroad a
repairTutn were following the wOrkmen
OF the Department OF Plant and Struc-
turee I'm making repairs, normal ser
vice probably would be resumed Mon
day
The evening world., 1920-08-05
BInHe on Steamship Garth.

Spontaneous combustion IL given as
the cause OF a fire which started to-
day In the forward hatch Of the
steamship Carib OF the Atlantic, Gulf
ws1 soSedaed Ss dI to "S for ne casa sa o.dSg
Wit o. - nora 0BrE1 rs munrFd a.
..,a. Ell Lha9, E4et ilYcp, Ile hro.
boat Thomas Wiilett extinguished the
blaze,
The evening world., 1920-08-05

James cannon OF No. 92l Prospect
Place, Harry Hitler. a barber of No.
81 Underhill Avenue. and Ernest To
shack OF No. $50 New York Avenue,
Broo,Ilyn, were held without bail in the
Gates Avenue Police Court, Brooklyn,
to-day tor the alleged theft Of Az au.o-
niobNe valued ~ $500 aud SiPht new
itrs FiuCd a. $500 fgutn ths Lexington
Auto Service station, No, B2o Atlantic
Avenue, Brooklyn.
The evening world., 1920-08-05

knight. was empowered 10 appoint a
committee to investigate conditions
Of the organized night made by medi-
cal organizations against the white
plague. The ultimate object OF the
Is 10 determine the
pracAicabilfty Of the organization
building a national santarium for
ttI1berruiosis long considered By
members II this institution n rec
commended IL will not cost less than
81, ,Ooo, 900.
The evening world., 1920-08-05
cIesr Col. mant In nersdem ca.s.

Lieut.. Col Charles G. Cressoh. judge
Advocate At the court martial OF Co.
John l.. Hunt. charged with negligence
In connection with the escape Of Grover
Bergdoll, the wealthy Philadelphia
Stacker, announced yesterday that Major
Cen Robert Lee Bullard. commander OF
the Department Of the East. had APP
troved the courts verdict OF not Rulity.