Norwich bulletin., 1920-03-19

ratification vote on the peace treaty tomorrow, the senate broke from con troi of the republican leaders todag and unexpectedly swept into the re publican reservation program decla- ration of sympathy for sef-goVern- ment in Ireland
 The proposal won out in committee of the whole by vote of SS to 36 after an sll-day debate On a necessary second vote. this action was confirmed later l5 to 3s.
 During the debate democratic lead CTS supported the reservation and the managers on the republican side op- posed it because it included a general declaration that this nation adhered to the princin7e of the self -determina- tion offpeoples On the first roll call 2. democrAts and + republicans. in cluding the irrA~oncilable foes of the treaty. voted for adoption. while 20 republicans and IS democrats were TO corded in the negative
 Revival Of the Irish question pro- lnnKhd into the night the senate's task of putting into final form the resolu tion of ratification on which Ii is plan ned 10 bring a vote tomorrow. One after another. a long list of lniscella nco1s reservations were voted down with the leaders bent on completing their task before adjournment.
 
 wns net generally regarded as having heea influenced by the days develop ments. though a number of republi- cans counted on 10 vote to ratffy. in- cluding Senator Lodge of Massachu- Eeits the party leader. expressed hit ter disapproval of the Irish reservation in it's final form. On all sides the prediction was made that the treaty would fail tn receive the necessary two thirds though some senators thought that on a second roll call, which probably will be taken before the attempt. to ratify is given up, enough democrats to put 1t through would join the ma tority.
 The teyt of the Irish reservation as introduced by Senator Gerry. demo crat, of Rhode island, and adopted by the senate. follows:
 'In consentirg to the ratification oi the treaty with Germany the United States adheres. to the principle of self determination and to the resolution ot sympathy with the aspirations of tht Irish peopls for 2 government of theil owr choice. adopted by the senate June 6. 1919. and declares that wher such government is attained by Ire. land. a consummat'on it is hoped Ii at hand, 1t should prompaly be admit ted as a member of the League of Ma t!ons"
 The roll call of the Gerry resolu ton follows:
 For Adoption:
 Republicans Borah, Brandegee CApper, Colt, Curtis, France, Freling huysen, Gronna. Johnson (Califor nia); Jones (washington) La Fol lette. Mclean. McNary, Moses. Nor ris Sutherland and Wstson-17.
 Democrats-Ashurst. Gerry, Gore Harris, Harrison. Henderson Hitch cock. Kendrick, Kirby, McKellar, Nu gent. Phelan. Pittman. Ransdell Reed. Sheppard Shields, Shit (Maryland); Smith (South Carolna) walsh (Massachusetts). and wals (Nontanaj-21
 Total for adoption-ss.
 Against Adoption:
 Republicans-Ban Calder, Cum nins. Dillingham;. Edge, Elkins, Hal, Harding. Kellogg. Kenyon, KeyeI Lenroot. Lodge. New. Page. Phipp! Wadsworth-20.
 Democrats-Beckham, Dial. F1et cher, Gay. Jones (New Mexico; Kinl Myers. Pomerene. Robinson. Srnit (Georgia): Swanson, Thomas, Tram mell. Underwood. Williams and wol cott-total 1s.
 Total against-se.
 Of senators absent and paired was announced that Senators Culbel son. Texas: Johnson (South Dakota) Overman. North Carolina; Owen, Ok lahoma. and Stanley. Kentucky, den ocrats. favored the resolution and tn: Senator Fernald, republican,, Main opposed it. H}
 The position of other senators n, voting wae not stated.
 Additional votes for the measure o 
 Senators Fernald. Maine; McCcrmicl Illinois. and Shoot, Utah. republican and Johnson. South Dakota: Owe Oklahoma. and Stanley, .Kentuck democrats. who did not vote on tt nrst roll call Senator Page republ can, Vermont. changed from oppos ton to support Of the reservation. I opponents gained the votes of Sens tors Glass. Virginia; Overman ar Simmons. North Carolina. democrat and Warren, Wyoming republican
 Before the second vote. two flti efcrts to amend the reservation wei made. A motion by Senator Calde republican. New York. to strike q, the clause dealing with self -detezm nation. was tabled. 51 to 30, and { amendment b- Senator Sterling. r pubiican- North Dakots. 10 elinaina the Dhrace exp-esaln~ hope for. COT r+sTnmation os 1rish freedom. was [, bied 70 10 IT.
 Afte- a final attempt to modify fl republican reservation to Article IT, had failed in the senate late toutr rea6frmed b. 2 vote Of 54 to 25 adopfior of the reservation.
 All of the opponents of the Artic Ten reservation on the final vote we democrats. Tcrty republicans we toincf by II ee11nerats ir it's adoptic The deuccrs ts who voted for the re ervatica were AsIiurst Chamberla! Gerry Gore. He1de-sor, Kendric NuTsr. Phelan Pittnar. Pomerer Read. Shields. Smith (Gcorgia) al Waish tMassachusetts> All .4upporte-a of the Simmons Ar Se Ten substitute wera democ-a Five demccrats-G0re. oktafcnn Reed. Missouri: Shields. Ten~esa. Walsh. Mnssnchueetts a-d William Mississipp!.. voted with the repab cars to tarie the '-,-o7csai sR
 Senator Lodge said the, sira-sc sfbstitnte wss "ritaiiv de.ccure' that it barred thc Gsa 0. Anar.c military forces cn;y uade- Arzh Tsn. while the Lodge reservation i gFfet tfet- i,Ne for nar r1i-9ese tsfd