The daily Alaska citizen., 1920-01-24
THE TREATY VOTE

ngS on the erSalllCS treaty and the vote on the various resolutions of ratification. The Lodge resolution read as follows:
 "Resolved (tWo-thirds of the senators present concurrng therein). That the sen ate advise and consent to the ratification of the treaty of peace with Germany con ciudcd at Versailles on the 18th day of June. 1919. subject to the following reScr- vations and understandings, which are hereby made a part and condition of this resolution of ratification, which ratification Is not to take effect or bind the United States until the said reservations and ml-I derstandingS adopted by the senate have. been accepted by an exchange of notes as a part and a condition of this resolution of ratification by at least three of the four principal allied and associated powers, to- wit Great Britain, France. Italy, and Japan.'
 Then followed the fourteen for eign relation committee reservations.
 The vote on this resolution as shown by the roll call resulted as follows, yeas 39, nays 5, not voting one. The vote was divided as follows:
 Yeas, Ball, Calder, Capper, Colt, Cum mins, Curtis, Dillingham;, Edge, Elbins, Frelinghuysen, Gore, Hale, Harding, Jones, Wash. Kellog, Kenyon, Keys, Lenroot, Lodge. McCumber, Mclean, McNary, Nell son, New, Newberry, Page, Penrose, Phipps Shields CDem Tennessee), Smith (Dem., Georgia), Shoot, Spencer Sterling, Sutherland, Townsend WadsWorth, Walsh Dem., Mass.), Warren, Watson.
 Nays, Ashurst, Bankhead, Beckman, Borah (Rep), Brandegee Rep.), Chamber lain, CuIberson, Dial, Fernald, Fletcher, France, Gay, Gerry, Gronna, Harris, Har rison, Henderson, Hitchcock, Johnson RepD, Calf, Johnson, So. Dak., Jones, New Mexico, Kendrick, King, Kirby, Knox (Rep.), LaFollette Rep), Mccormick Rep), McKellar, Moses Rep), Myers, Norris Nugent, Overman, Owen, Phelan, Pittman, POmdeXter Rep.), Pomerene, Ransdell, Reed Robinson, Sheppard, Sher man (Rep.), Simmons, Smith, Ariz., Smith, Maryland, Smith, So Carolina, Stanley, Swanson, Thomas, Trammell, Underwood, Walsh, Mont, Williams, Wolcott. Not vot- ing, Fall. The latter senator was not pres ent during the session.
 In the list of those names voting nay, will be found many senators, twelve or thlr- teen, whose votes were cast in favor of the reservations of the senate foreign relations committee. Five such senators were on the committee itself and aided in the prepara- tlOnS of the eservatiOnS-SenatOrs BOrah, Brandegee, Knox, Johnson, of California, and Moses. One members of the commit tee, Senator Fall even neglected to attend the days proceedings. After having drawn up the reservations and reporting favor ably on them, they refused to vote for a ratification resolution containing them. All of them did so because they were opposed to the treaty in any form.
 The Lodge resolution of ratification was able to muster but little more than One-thlrd of the votes of those present. A resolution for unqualified ratification in troduced by Senator Underwood was fin ally allowed to be introduced after parlia- mentary fight lasting hours. The result showed 5 against and 3S for, failing by the same proportion that the Lodge reso- mtion had failed
 The final disposition made of the treaty then came as follows:
 Mr. Lodge-One moment, l yielded to the senator from Alabama (Mr. Under