Arizona republican. [volume] (Phoenix, Ariz.) 1890-1930, 1920-02-22
Labor Pressure Ineffeetiva

There never was any doubt as 70
the outcome leaders said. although
the effect of pressure from labor lead
ers against adoption Of the bill was
variouSly interpreted Representa- tive
Kitchin. democrat, North Carolina. IN
the closing argument against the bill,
declared that labor leaders had caused
at least a dozen members who were
opposed TO il, 10 rally 10 its support
During the debate in which
more than a score OF representa-
tives took part, Chairman Esch
declared that the roads would be
handed back to their owners on
March !, regardless OF whether
congress enacted legislation mean
while, but he warned the house
that defeat of the bill at this
stage would put half the roads Of
the country in the hands of re-
ceiVers in three months. Repre-
sentative Pou. democrat, North
Carolina, pointed more gloomy
picture by declaring that the
country would see the greatest
financial disaster in years VI t
gave up the railroads without en-
actment of laws which would give
them the right to earn fair re-
turn.
Representative Kitchin said his on
position was not in compliance TO the
demands OF Mr.. Gompers' He ag-
tackled the .insidious propaeands~ ~
which, he said, railway interests had
conducted and declared the question
Of government ownership was not in
volyed-
Whether this bill is adopted OF re-
jected." he said, we have IT from
Mr. Esch that the roads VIII so back
to their owners on March l.
The vote for the adoption OF the
conference report showed 204 repUbli-
cans and 45 democrats supporting H.
The opposing vote included Is5 demo
Gratis, % republicans, one independ-
ent, and one prohibitiOnist The rulI
call followed:
How They Voted
For the bill:
republicans - Aekerman. Anderson.
Andrews. Maryland; Andrews Ne
braska: Anthony. Bacharach. Barbour.
Begg, Benham, Bland, Boles. Bowers.
Britten, Brooks, Illinois: Brooks. Penn
sylVania; Browning, Burdick. Bur
rouEhs, utter, Campbell. Kansas: Can
non, Chindblom, CHRISTOPHER. Co9e.
Cooper, Copley, Costello. Crago. Gran
ton, Crowther. Currie, Michigan. Dale.
Dallinger, Darrow. Dempsey. Dickin-
son. Iowa; DoWeH, Dunbar. Dunn. Over
Eschols, Edmonds. Elliott. Eslsron-
Esch. Evans. Nebraska: Fairfield. Fezs
Focht, Foster, Freeman. French. FulEer.
Illinois: Fuller, Massachusetts, Car
land, Glynn, Good, GOodau. Goody-
koonthz. Gould, Graham. Illinois
Green. Iowa: Green. ssachusettz-
Green. Vermont: Griest, Hadley, Ham
ilton, Hardy, Colorado; Harreld. Haw-
ley, Hayes, Hernandez. Hickey. Her
sey, Hicks, Hoch. Houghton. Hulines.
ull, Iowa; Hustled, Hutchinson. Ire
land, Jefferes, Johnson, South Da-
kota; Johnson, Washington. Jones.
EOEar7r7 1rTra ar-f-a I'll
Kelley, Michigan; Kendell Kennedy.
Rhode Island; Kiess, Kinkaid, Kraus.
Langley. Layton, Lehlbach. Little
Longworth, Luce, Lufkin. Luhring Ne
Arthur, McCullOch, McFadden. Nc
kenzie, Mckinley, Mclaughlin. Mfchf-
gan: Mclaughlin, Nebraska Ne
Pherson, MarCrate, AacGresor. Mad
den, Magee- Mann, Illinois; Mapes
Merritt Michener. Miller. Monahar-
Monden, Moore, Ohio: Moores. In
diana; Morgan. Mott. Mudd. Murphy.
Nelson, Wisconsin: Newton. innesota-
Newton. Missouri: ogden. Osborne
Paige, Parker, Peters. PIatt. Porter.
urnel Radcliffe. Ramsey. Ramseyer.
Randall, Wisconsin: Reavis. Rcber.
Reed, New York; Reed. West Virginia.
Ricketts,, Riddick. Robson. Rodeberz
Rogers, Rose, Rowe. sanders. New
York: Sanford, Sells Shreve. Sie-eI.
Sinnott, Slemp, Smith. Idaho: Smith.
Illinois, Smith, Michigan: Smell. SJeen-
erson. tephens. Ohio: Stines. Stron-.
Kansas; Strong. ennsylvania. Sumner.
Sweet, Swope. Taylor.
Tennessee; Temple, Thompson. Ohio
Tiison. Timberlake, Tincher. Tinkhau.
Treadway, Vale. Ware, VestaT-
Nolstead, Walsh, Walters, Ward.
Wason, Watson, Webster. Wheeler.
White, Kansas: White Maine. VIII
Jams. Wilson. Illinois; Winslow. Wood.
Indiana; woodward, Young, North Da-
kota; Yates, Ziehlman- Totals. 204.
Democrats for; Benson, Black, Can
trell, Clark. Florida; Cleary, Coady.
Crisp, Davis, Tennessee: Dewalt
Drain, Dupre, Eagle, Flood, Goodwin.
Harrison. Hoisman. Hoy. Holland
Johnston, New York
Kettner, Linthicum. Lergan. Montague
Moore, Virginia: Nelly. Olney. Over
street, Padgett, Park. Parrish, Pel
Pou. Rayburne, Saunders. Virginia.
Small, Smith New York: Steele, Sui
livan. Taylor, Colorado; Upshaw, Ven
able, yelling. Woods, Virginia.
Wright. Total a.
Grand total. 249.
Against. republicans:
Those Who Opposed Bill.
Baer, Browne, Burke, ClassOn. Davis
Minnesota; Denisons Ellsworth. Euer-
son, Freaer. James. Keller. Kelly. Penn
sylvania: King. Kleczka, Lampert. Ma
(CoptiD1Ied an pace II es--fsr-- 81