New-York tribune., 1920-09-07
Protest Holds
Up C'aledonian
Trophy Award
Victory of knights of St.
Antony Novice Is Ques-
toned by St. Anselm's

The handsome trophy which was to
be given to the team scoring the high
est number Of points at the sixty
fourth annual track and field games
OF the Cafedonian Club yesterday az
ternoon at Celtic Park, Long Island, was
taken over by the registration COM
mittee Of the Amateur Athletic Union
pending further investigation.
/ The st. Anselm's club officials had
protested the victory of 0. F. Anderson,
Of the knights of st. Antony, in the
10O-yard novice. If the protest is up
held st. Anselm's will get the trophy.
AS it stands the knights of ST. Antony
have first place, with 1e points, one
point more than St. Anselm's.
The question to be decided is whether
Anderson had broken his novice. ST.
Anselm's claimed that he scored in the
American Legion meet at Babylon, L.
l., and IS therefore ineligible to COM
pete IN novice races. J. Ostendorf, ST,
Anselms athlete, was second, and if
Anderson is disqualified it will add two
more points to his clubs score, giving
them eighteen counts. The medals for
this event were also withheld
In the other novice event at q half
mile, the winner, J. ShiIloo, was also
disqualified, as he competed in an A.
A: U. event without having registered
with that organization. F. Cailington.
unattached, was moved up to fourth
place.
There were no sensational perform
a oh 60;
come through in every event. In the
one mile walk, L. Labowitz, Of the Pas
time A. c., starting from the honor
mark, finished second. after a vain
attempt to overcome the large hRndi-
caps. II. Lolson, of the Ninety-second
Street Y. NJ. H. A, with a handicap Of
4o seconds, was the winner.
The two-mile run proved to be the
most interesting event Of the after
noon. Andy Crsw. Of the Brooklyn A.
A., and E. Garvey, the Paulist dis
tancer, started from scratch, but the
handlcaps were too large to overcome.
Garvey managed to finish in fourth
place, but Craw quit in the stretch af-
ter he was hopelessly out of it. Jimmy
O'Connor, who won quite a few dis
tance events this spring and summer,
finished third behind G. Williams, St.
Christopher A. c., and A. Mack, of the
Knights of st. Antony.
The Paulist A. c. won the one mile
relay in minutes 81 As seconds, af-
ter a thrilling bid by the Morningside
A. c. team. Dan Shea, of the Pastime
A c.. won the running high jump with
handicap of seven inches. His actual
leap was feet 6 inches. B. Lichtman,
also Of Pastime, finished fourth in the
shot-put. The summaries:
l99-yard novice. A; A. Won by o, r.
dorf. St Ansem's a. G. second F. Will
iams lar unattached. ln 'htrh p Roan"; 8.
one-inil" walk. handicap. A A U-Won
by H. Lolson. Ninety second street 7. NJ.
II. A. li5 secondsl L. Lah3dtz. Pastime
third: H. ,Morrel, Morn!ngside A. {. 90
~. l.ooo-yard handicap A. y. U.--won by
w. -, crunien, knights OF St, .Antony- GO
Seim-s A. c; 642 YARDS. third; T. Gallagher.
Knights k,a,s OF Of st; Antony t42 yards). fourth
s3o-yarl novice--Won by 7 shilIoo un-
1'''chTa a W; Go'nwin una'taehef second:
Reich unsttached. foa2th. Tine. ri '''ra os Is.
Shii!oo Was diafualtficd because unregfs-
Sered' and F, Cali.ngton. unattached. was
', 31o-yyar4 handicap. a. A. J'-won by
~ y, ,.aia Lazy - Anseltl.s a c. q, yarlsl: q.
Dsf;+T - Tt:r, oifnr@s s A. I2 yards! second
third: Z. Hosmer. Glencoe a. c. q yarGsI
Sogrth. TI.h ,,,1I Tine g. rs
by 9. Williams. st Christopher A c. G3S
yards) A. 4 Mack knights of - An.
tony 200 yards), second. J. L O'connor.
.iarvey. Pau!!st a. G. (scratchj fourth
-W.n W. ",s b. I:,-y FISH,! race h9n4icap a 4; %
MeTn'ats!'e G,, A. { g. P4tef. 7 erSney: @sns3:
l.. Me liIit 't.yE