Arizona republican., 1919-11-14
SENATE ADOPTS
Continued from Page onel

tCOHllnueu IEOIu L age OilCJ
reservation follows:
For adoption:
Republicans: Ball Borah, Brande-
gee, Calder. Capper. Colt, Cummins,
Curtis, Dillingham;, Edge, EllSins, Fall.
Fernald, France, Frelinghuysen, Gron-
ma, Hale. Harding, Johnson, Califor-
mia: Kenyon, Keyes, La Toilette. Len
root, Lodge, McCumber, Mclean, Nc
Nary, Moses New, Norris, Page. Pen
rose, Phipps. Poindexter, Sherman,
Smoot. Spencer, Sterling, Sutherland,
Townsend, Warren and Watson.
Total, AZ.
Democrats: Gore, Reed. Smith,
Georgia. and Walsh, Massachusetts.
Total 4. Total for, as.
Against adoption
Democrats: Ashurst, Beckham, Dial,
Fletcher, Gay. Gerry. Harris, Harri-
son, Henderson, Hitchcock. Johnson,
South Dakota; Jones, New Mexico;
Kendrick. Kirby, Mcclellan, Myers,
Nugent, Overman, owen, Phelan, Pitt
man, Ransdel Robinson, Sheppard,
Smith, Maryland; Smith, South Caro-
lima; Stanley. Thomas, Trammell,
Underwood, Walsh, Montana; Will
liams Wolcott. Total 80. Total
against, 49,
Sixteen senators not voting were
paired as follows:
For Adoption; James, Washington;
Kellogg, Knox, Mccormick, Nelson
Newberry and Wadsworth republi-
cans, and Shields. democrat.
| Against: Bankhead, Chamberlain,
| Culbertson, King, Pomerene. Simmons,
! Swanson and Smith, Arizona, demo-
Gratis.
One vacancy in Virginia.
Democrats Fighting Stubbornly
The administration forces fought
/ stubbornly through the day and into
| the evening to secure some modifica-
! ton of the committee measure, but to
all of their proposals the united re-
/ publican organization remained ada
mant. Finally forced to yield, Demo-
cratic Leader Hitchcock put into the
senate hopper a set of five reserva-
tons on which he will ask for a vote
later as a substitute for the committee
program
The reservations cover withdrawal
the Monroe doctrine, article 10, do
nestle questions and voting equality
in the league.
A sharp parliamentary battle was
L precipitated by the democratic cloture
proposal, which had been drafted at d
1
replace the one drawn up yesterday
The original plan was to propose {
cloture upon the treaty itself. but i
was decided to confine it to the com
mittee reservations when the point wa,
raised that it might otherwise defea
the democratic plan to vote down thu
committees ratification resolution anC
then offer one acceptable to the ad
ministration.
In the conference considerable diff
ference of opinion developed over tn
! alternate plan, but % signatures Wer
secured to the petition which is neces
sary to get a cloture vote. When
J was filed by Senator Hitchcock how
ever, objection was made by Senate
Norris, republican, Nebraska, that tn
r cloture rule could not be applied to on
feature only of the measure. Presiden
Pro TEN Cummins, presiding. sus
tanned the point of order, Senate
Hitchcock appealed from the ruling
and on motion of Senator Lodge tn
, appeal was tabled, A to SO.
The republican petition, althoug
l prepared yesterday by the mild reser
walton group, was not presented unit
just before adjournment tonight.
calls for limitation of debate on tn
. WiOit litdty dIu CdlIlcS the SlS NATURE
I. of the following republican senators
Abandon Night Session Plan
h Lodge. Massachusetts: Phipps, Colo
: RADIO; Ellsins. West Virginia; Curt
e and Capper, Kansas; Edge. New Jer
:. sey; Townsend, Michigan; Jone
e Washington; Norris, Nebraska; Calde
t New York; Kellogg and Nelson, Min
: nesota, Hale, Maine; Lenroot. Wis
h consin; McNary, Oregon; Ball, Della
r ware; Sterling, South Dakota; Cum
: minis and Kenyon, Iowa; Moses an
n Keyes. New Hampshire; Spence
: Missouri. McCumber. North Dakota
a Colt, Rhode Island; Watson and New
= Indiana; Smoot. Utah; Mclean Con
: necticut: Dillingham;, Vermont, an
: Harding, Ohio
4 The petition was admitted withor
r objection and was ordered to lie owe
k under the rule until Saturday when
pA vote must be taken without debat