davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1919-11-16
Newton Expects to
Uphold Validity of
State Income Tax
Jerome L. Cheney Named to
Argue Case for New York
in Federal Court; Quick
Decision Is Hoped For

ALBANY. Nov 15.-With the inten-
ton of clearing up the question as to
the constitutionality of the non-resi-
dent sections Of the new state income tax
law in time for the next Legislature to
act in case OF an adverse decision. Attor-
ney General Charles y. Newton desig-
mated his first deputy, JeromeL Cheney,
to argue the appeal from the Knox de-
cision in the United States Supreme
Court. Deputy James S. Y. WINS will
assist him in the argument, which has
been set for December s.
The consttutionality Of the law
was attacked shortly after it's enact
ment this wear by the Yale & Towne
Manufacturing Company, Of Connecti-
cut. and United States District Court
Judge Knox declared it unconstitu-
tional IN its application TO nonresi-
dents
Flaws Alleged in Law
lowing grounds:
That it is beyond the sovereign
power of the state to levy q general i'll
come tax upon non-res identS
That the act discriminates against
citizens Of other states.
That in violation of the Fourteenth
Amendment of the Federal Constitu
ton it denies to non-residents the
equal protection of the law.
That the act violates the commerce
clause OF the Federal Constitution.
That it impairs the obligation Of
contracts in violation Of Section of
Article 10 Of the Federal Constitution.
The income tax law permits residents
to make certain deductions for losses
and provides for exemptions up to
Il
$1,000 for resident married men, with
5000 for each dependent. Failure to
make these concessions TO non-resi.
dents was made the principal ground
| For the attack on the validity Of the
law.
Hit at ''rax Dodgers
The state authorities in drafting the
law attempted to cut off the escape o.
so-called e'tax dodgers" who derive
their income from sources within the
states. These very provisions which
New Jersey, Connecticut and othe,
States. These very provisions which
were designed to prevent tax evasion
~ tho iulure were Immediately made
the object Of legal attack.
-, After designating First Depu;s.
Cheney TO argue the case III the high
est court, Attorney General Newton
made this statements:
II believe the income tax law, q
finally passed by the Legislature. j
constitutional Because of this belief
determined months ago to carry tn
case to the United States Suprem
Court. 1t is my aim to clear up tn
question of its validity in time for tn
Legislature to act, in the event Of
decision adverse TO the state by tn
United States Supreme Court.
"Mr. Cheney has made an exhaustiv
study of the income tax law. He know
his subject, and, am confident, vii
succeed in establishing the constitu
tionality of the act in its presen
form"
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1919-11-16
Thanksgiving Day
To Be Celebrated
AT Sulphur Springs
Autumn Holidays to Find
Large Numbers of Social
Leaders at Noted Resort;
Many Dinners Are Given
Special Correspondence

Special Correspondence
WHITE SULPHUR SPRINGS, w. Va,
Nov. l5.--Interest is centering on
Thanksgiving holidays at White Sui
phur Springs. Many plans Cor Thanks
giving festivities have been formu-
lated and there will be many parties
here from New York, Philadelphia and
Washington.
Mr.. and Mrs. Lorenzo f. Wood
touse, of East Hampton, L. l., who
always como in November for their
&s.tumn visit, will be here for over
thanksgiving. Mr.. and Mrs. William
II. Porter, who arrived the first of
November, are here for a months stay
and will spend their Thanksgiving at
the Greenbrier as they did last season.
Robert Livingston Gerry comes from
Newport, and Mrs. Peter Goelet Gerry
will be here from Washington. The
Larz Andersons are prominent this week
in the Washington set at the Green
bricr.
Prince Of Wales Popular
The visit of royalty has added to the
Greenbrier's prestige and had the visit
Of the Prince of Wales only been an
available suite in the Greenbrier would
have been Immediately engaged for his
visit. which starts to-day The prince,
Of Wales grandfather, the then prince,
danced in the Old White ballroom with
all Of the Southern bellies during his
visit and his well-known democracy
and good fellowship are quite equaled
If not surpassed by the demo
cratic ways and genial manner Of the
young prince.
Mr.. and Mrs. Alan Corey, of New
York, who spent two days at the Green
orier, returned to town this week with
James Ford johnson, jr., who came
down to join them. Mr.. and Mrs.
Corey entertained at several lunch
con parties during their stay here,
Thursday they gave q luncheon at the
Casino for Mr.. and Mrs. Johnson and
Mr.. and Mrs. Sydney Whelan.
Mr.. and Mrs. christopher D. Srnithers,
OF Glen Cove, are popular members of
the New York set at the Greenbrier
and have entertained for several
friends at dinners in the Greenbrier.
Before his return to New York, Edward
r. Stettinius was guest of honor at a
luncheon given by Mr.. and Mrs. Smith
ers at the Casino.
James Cresson Parrish and his son,
James c. Parrish, jr, who is we'll
known to Metropolitan golfng sets, are
here from Southampton, L. l., for a
visit of several weeks. DR.. j. Henry
Lancashire and Miss Lila Lancashire
have come from New York to spend
November at the Greenbrier.
Mrs. Cornelius Vanderbilt Is an in
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1919-11-16
Autumn Season at
Hot Springs Nears
Its Halfway Mark
Meeting of Hunt Club Big
Success, Arrivals From
New York Are Taxing Big
Hotels to Full Capacity
Spsotal Correspondence


HOT SPRINGS, Va, Nov. 1b.--No-
vember has reached its usual success
full midpoint in this lovely Allegheny
resort Arrivals continue daily and Q
climax to the season 10 not expected
before Thanksgiving.
Mr.. and Mrs. Columbus O'Donnell
Iselin arrived early in the week for
their autumn visit in Hot Springs, and
DR.. Carlos Macdonald is hero to en-
Joy a two weeks rest and mountain
adventure. Mrs. Stephen Suydam Whit
ney, with Mr.. Stephen Whitney, came
carly in the week. Mr.. and Mrs. Francis
G.. Landon also arrived. Mr.. and Mrs.
Cortland W. Handy, Mr.. and Mrs
Theodore s. Watson, who came for q
dying. visit; Mr.. and Mrs. A. w. Flint
and Mr.. and Mrs. David Ives Mackie
are mid November visitors.
Mr.. and Mrs. Francis <. Laimbeer
arrived from New York by automobile
Mrs. Gardiner Sherman Is at the Home
stead until December. Mr.. and Mrs
John Il. prexel and w. Hude Nelson
are here for the late autumn season
Mr.. and Mrs. Frederick NJ. Delano, Mr.
and Mrs. Charles p. Day, Gilbert e
Thorne, J. Amory Haskell and Elon
Huntington Hooker came early in the
week.
Many at the Homestead
Mrs. Cornelius Tiers is here with
Mr.. Tiers Mr.. and Mrs. Charles Stclle
Brown. Mrs. Winthrop Burr and Mrs
f. K. Lancaster are arrivals from New
York. DR.. and Mrs. Frank S. Babbott
jr., are at the Homestead from Brook
lyn to remain six weeks. Miss Rosa
mond Roberts came on Wednesday 70,
two weeks.
Governor-elect Edwards Of New Jer.
sey is at the Homestead with party
for two weeks' rest after his cam.
paign. Another celebrity ut the Home
stead is Mgr. James E. Cassidy, the
noted New England prelate, whose
work among the mill people in Tal
River has earned him much distinction
Mrs. Charles Baldwin took party
Of five to Valley View for luncheon
Tuesday.
The hunt of the Fassifern Hunt Clul
came off with much excitement and a.
the breakfast which followed in tn,
nists to enjoy oldtime Virginia cook
ing in old-tme Virginia surroundings.
Returns to New York
James j. Van Allen, who has been a
the Homestead the last three weeks
left late in the week for New York
John L. Hobble, the playwright, is a
the Homestead.
Mrs. Lanier Dunn has closed her cot
tage and has returned to Richmond
AIRS. Dunn will shortly start for Ger
many to visit her son, Captain Mckee
Dunn. who is with the American Arm.
of Occupation at Coblenz. Mrs. JOIN
J. McCook closed the Pillars yesterda,
and with Miss Harriet McCook starte'
for New York. Mrs. Edgar II. Brigh
returned from New York Monday an,
has closed Brightview, starting yester
day with Mr.. Bright for New Orleans
Mr.. and Mrs. Matthew l.. Akers hav
closed Upland House and started 70
Louisville.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1919-11-16
31oodMo,,.*;44

Have you daughter or son that
you expect to start in business?
Following is a partial list of some of the
institutions that require the services of MANY
young women and boys. You can place them
with any of these concerns with every feel
ing of safety Look at the classified advertise
mcnts in to-day's Tribune for particulars: New
York Telephone Co., Charles William Stores.
Western Union Telegraph Co., Saks & Com
pany, Gimbel Brothers, Hearn's, Abraham &
Straus, Bloomngdalc Brothers, Lord & Taylor,
Western Electric Co.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1919-11-16
COUNTRY BOARD WANTED
PINEHURsT. n. G.

COUNTRY BoARD.-Desirasle coupl. want
high-class plain board two rooms and
private bath with family Of refinement hav-
or near 81 onxvlle: satisfactory price for
desired accommodations. Answer A., Box
49, Tribune Office
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1919-11-16
INSTRUCTION

! Look where
! you will at
\ the professional
\ practice Of Ac-
] c0untancy, at
\ private business, at
\ the Federal Govern
\ ment or the various
! state and municipal
\ governments-Post-war
] conditions show the need
\ Observation-Disclosures
men and women
Men and women who are
\ qualified to systematic,
\ organize, supervise;
\ Men and women who have
\ learned how to reason
\ soundly. plan intelIigently.
\ and direct efficiently;
\ NJ Ell and women whose
n native abilities, technical
\ training, and practical ex-
n perience qualify them to
n serve and earn in Account
\ ancy practice and in the
n larger positions of organ
n lied effort.
n Pace Institute, III its day and
y evening classes, gives technical
y focus to vocational ambition
q and energy - organizes waste
n time and converts it, not into
n by-products but into ma jor
y products - capacity, position,
n Hcome!
n You are cordially invited 70 visit Pace
ri Institute, TO meet It's teachers 70 Ia
81 spect Its classes. Enrollments rnar
III stili be made in November classsA
\ Pace & Pace
n 80 Church St. New York
The Lake County times. [volume] (Hammond, Ind.) 1906-1933, 1919-12-23

her position as teacher In the Kinder
garten at Stieglitz Park. She Will
be succeeded by Miss Carrie Gillette.
who will be transferred from the Main
kindergarten A Miss Taylor has
been secured to succeed Miss Gillette.
Rudolph Herakovitch was chosen as
Writings Pershins boy BY the Chica-
go American. As the result Of this
honor the boy was accorded royal en-
tertainment on Saturday when Perish
ing made his visit to Chicago. He
was met at the train with a taxi. at
tended the banquet the Congress no.
tel and had the honor Of shaking
hands with General Pershing
Stanley Koloski was arrested az $40
Davidson Place by officers Parker and
Niziolkiewicz on the charge Of grand
larceny. Koloski was charged with
having stolen battery from Father
Coarbach's automobile. several months
ago Koloski was released on a $500
bond 70 appear today for trial
Ahmet Mustasa was placed under ar
rest al 40 18TH street bv officer
Wieniski on complaint OF Mamat Uaui.
charging him with surety of the peace
he was relea sed Oh 500 bonds finnish
ed by Assman Allen.
The Lake County times. [volume] (Hammond, Ind.) 1906-1933, 1919-12-23
ROBERTSDALE

The Christmas Csntata VIII be Civ
en- At the Auditorium on Tuesday ev-
ening at 1870 O'Clock sharp. Invita-
tion are extended 70 an
Oscar Todd OF Indiana boulevard
left for Brazil. Ind. the latter part OF
last week to visit with his parents and
expects to reurn for the holidays
Let US get your 1920 Auto License for
you order now and get a low NUM-
Der Russell +. smith. 5oe New York
Avenue. Waiting 12-15-6
Mrs T Winkelreid OF the Geneva
House entertained number of girls
at dinner on Friday evening In hon
or or her daughter AIarraret's hf-
teenth birthday anniversary The
young folks spent the evening IN
dancing and playing games or ali
kinds. The guests present were Mar
garct Cunningham. Mildred aud EN-
ma Water. Margaret Tsggert. Dorothy
and Ruth Lesser. Helen Miller, Irene
Wright. Ornilla Glenn. Marie Smith
Violet sudhom and Margaret winkei-
reid
Mrs. II. Beavens spent Saturday in
Chicago on business.
Mr. and Mrs. II. Rubin OF Chicag go
spent sunday at tho George BadeI
home on Myrtle avenue
Mr.. and Mrs. John Blaui Of Ham
mond visited the formers parents,
1Tr. and Mrs. John BlauI. ST., Of Rob
erts avenue over sunday
Mr.. aud Mrs. 4 N NIartz of Myrtle
avenue. entertained friends at a Buncs
party one evening last week. tho out
Of town guests were Mr.. and Mrs Og
rem of East Side. prizes We're awarded
first to Mr. A Judson and second tc
Mrs ogren After the games Mrs
Martz served a dainty luncheon.
Mrs. Ed. Bader of Myrtle avenue
Saturday visiting friends in Chicag,
The little son OF Mr. and Mrs. G
Eggers Of Lake avenue. has been a
the sick list for the past few DAYS
Mrs r. Grass and Mrs r McCsrt1
The Lake County times. [volume] (Hammond, Ind.) 1906-1933, 1919-12-23
HOBART

Miss Marie Traeser who was taken
TO the Mercy hospital at Gary last
week viii undergo an operation today
A son was born the latter part OF
last week 70 Mr.. and Mrs John Thy
en-.
Miss Ethel Halstead vlsited with
friends in Chicago over sunday
The Hobart Ice Company have start
ed harvesting ice
The I. Whist club viii meet this
week Tuesday evening with Mrs
Julia Johnson
The Lake County times. [volume] (Hammond, Ind.) 1906-1933, 1919-12-23
Wolf. Fox, Lyon, Baer
Enlist in the Marines

BUFFALO ~ y. Dec. 25-''wolf,
Fox. Lyon" called the sergeant as he
uhsered three recruits into the Marine
Corps recruiting ONCE here
1T sounds like a menagerie" said the
recruiting officer 20 the sergeant. DO
you think were signing UP animal acts
for a circus?"
NO sir" replied the sergeant, "but
there Is still one more man to sign up,
captain"
BRING him in"
Baer" shouted the sergeant and the
fourth recruit entered.
The four recruits were James E. Fox
of Gates. y. Y; James Baer Of Erie. Pa
George r Wolf. of Warren. Pa: and
Charles Lyon Of Rochester. y. Y
The Lake County times. [volume] (Hammond, Ind.) 1906-1933, 1919-12-23

and 9Irs charles Naet Of Roberts az
en1=. waM known Whiting boy who
enlisted ia the service shortly after
hts graduation from high school and
I 81 eat several months in France. The
---ung couple are remaining here until
Christmas y ight when they viii leave
tcr Wood atver. Ill. where they have
purchased home and where Mr. Naef
has taken position with the stand
ara OIL Co.
HOUSE
one Desirable house Cor rent IN
stsirllrz PARK. House has never been
occupied mother SIS per month, tele-
phone whiting - or call SOC 18th
Street 1921
The vv = A OF the Maecabees will
ha-s their meeting on next Friday af-
t=rno5n AZ 200 p. m. sharp instead
OF On morrow eening. which is Xmas
E-e
The sea Gamma Upsilion Sorority
Mill have their Christmas party at the
home of Miss Lucille Daeghng IN La
porte avenue this evening.
Harry Manath was placed under ar
rest by OFFICER Benak charged with
passing street car on the wrong side
With his auto truck when esaid car
wac unloading passengers. Manath
was released on a SIS cash bond.
Mrs Alex Vincent OF Ohio avenue.
has returned from seven weeks visit
with relatives in New York and Penn
syIvania.
Miss Louise Mattern has resigned
The Lake County times. [volume] (Hammond, Ind.) 1906-1933, 1919-12-23

OF Indiana boulevard were in Chicago
on business tile latter part ~ the
week.
Mrs. Shade and daughter Mrs A
Hendrickson Mrs Augusta Eggers
and Mrs. q Buehier were among the
Chicago shoppers on Friday
Gust and Clarence Egsers or Rob
erts avenue are spending a few days
at Clinton. Iowa the guests OF rcla-
tives
Mrs. Roy wittsr and daughters
Mabel and Evelyn visited the former :
parents in Hammond over sunday.
The Lake County times. [volume] (Hammond, Ind.) 1906-1933, 1919-12-23
STAR THEATRE TONIGHT

Enid Bennett in VIRTUOUs THIEF.
also Mutt and Jen and Fox News
Tomorrow william Farnum in THE
LAST OF THE DCANES. also a Sun
shine comedy. 1881
The Lake County times. [volume] (Hammond, Ind.) 1906-1933, 1919-12-23
HOW ABOUT THAT HOME
ron esunESTvRFA

A horne for rent on Atchison avenue
bath and basement and attic; $50 per
month. phone Whiting Al or call 500
10th street. 1891
The Lake County times. [volume] (Hammond, Ind.) 1906-1933, 1919-12-23
Whiting
Advertisements
Are Winners

nnd are accepted by The whiting News
e.. 62z. A1pth ST.. Phone ISs-W.
The Lake County times. [volume] (Hammond, Ind.) 1906-1933, 1919-12-23
NORTHERN INDIANA GAS & ELEC-
l9-20-3 TRIO COMPANY.

FOR RENT:-Electric Lighted Garage
TAO Atehison avenue. 1888
The Lake County times. [volume] (Hammond, Ind.) 1906-1933, 1919-12-23
IMPORTANT
ANNOUNCEMENT
To OR CONSUMERS


The congestion in our offices around
the 18th of each month forces US to tho
adoption Of new schedule for issuing
our mo2thiy bills for gas and electric
ity beginning January LIST. 1920.
Meters win be read on each working
day OF the month and the reading re-
corded and bills mailed within two 90
days thereafter. These bills viii be
subject to discount If paid within
twenty days after the date OF reading
OF the meter
The only difference this plan VIII
make TO the consumer IS to bring the
last discount day. twenty days after
the date Of reading OF the meter in
stead of on the 18th OF the month as is
the present practice.
THE LAST DISCOUNT DAY WILL
BE PLAINLY STAMPED on EACH
BILL
We solicit your best cooperation IN
carrying out this plan, as it will as
ssst US in rtndering better service In
the monthly delivery OF over 10000
bills and avoid delays to our consumers
due to the present congestion in our
offices on the 14th and 18th of each
month.
NORTHERN INDIANA GAS & ELEC-
1905 TRIO COMPANY.
FOR RENT:-ElectriC Lighted Garage
TAO Atchison avenue. 1928
WANTED AT oNCE-By family with
two small children. Furnished
house. apartment or light house-keep-
ing rooms, phone 27s or cali at FEEDER
al Bakery. Whiting. 1888
Arizona republican., 1919-07-01
Legal Advertising

tors in said City, the words "Yes" and No" shall be printed in suct. manner that said electors of said City may clearly express their approval or disapproval of the proposition so to be submitted, substantially as required in Section 6, Chapter XIV, of the Charter of the City of Phoenix
 Section G. The Clerk of the City of Phoenix is hereby authorized, in structed and directed to post at least five copies of this Ordinance and the Notice of Special Election in five pub lie places within the City of Phoenix, at least twelve days prior to the date of the election hereby called and di- rected to be held, and shall post a copy of said Ordinance and Notice of Special Election at each of such polling places, provided, that in addition to the posting of said Ordinance and the Notice of Special Election, publication of said Ordinance shall be made in the Arizona Republican" being news paper published in the City of Phoenix, Arizona. and further provided that pub lication of the Notice of the Special Election herein provided to be given. shall be made in the said Arizona Republican, being the newspaper desig- mated by the Mayor for that purpose, for not less than thirty days prior to the day of said election.
 Section T. That the Mayor and Clerk of the City of Phoenix are hereby au- thorized and directed to cause a no- tice of Special Election to be posted and published as hereinbefore provided, and the said Clerk is hereby further authorized and directed to effectuate the various provisions hereof
 Section 8. The preservation of the public health. welfare and safety of the City of Phoenix, requires that this
 ordinance shall become effective i'm mediately, and an emergency is here by declared to exist, and this ordinance is hereby declared to be exempt from 1 the Referendum provisions of the City Charter and this ordinance shall take effect and become operative from and after its passage and approval by the Mayor
 Section g. Ordinance No. 266, passed | by the Commission and approved the
 11th day of June, 1919, is hereby re- pealed.
 Passed by the Commission of the City l of Phoenix. this 18th day of June, 1919. Approved:
 PETER CORPSTEIN, 1 Mayor. Attest: FRANK THOMAS, l City Clerk.
Arizona republican., 1919-07-01

It makes no difference what your wants may be, you can have them SUD- piled by using and reading The Repub- lican Classified Pages-Arizona lead ing advertising medium.
Arizona republican., 1919-07-01
Turkish Baths
Veterinary

DIR. H. o. RAMSEY. 115 W. Jeffer- son. Phone 776 Res 2770 7-n
 DR. J. c. McGRATH, Veterinarian Tel 42e5. 401 West Jefferson. If
Arizona republican., 1919-07-01
Money to Loan
Money to Loan

Unlimited funds to loan on improved Salt River Valley ranch lands and in- come business property.
 DWIGHT B. HEARD REAL INSURANCE
 LOANS
 CENTRAL & ADAMS If
Arizona republican., 1919-07-01
W4 EFE'RON CU.
 lO09 E. Madison. Phone 1892. tf

FURNITURE-W pay full value. in cash, also sell on commission anything of value. Phone 2093. Sales Wednes. days and Saturdays. Jefferson St. Auc- ton House, 1st Ave. and Jefferson St
 If
Arizona republican., 1919-07-01
Legal Advertising


 qualified property taxpayers of the City of Phoenix, Maricopa County, Arizona, who in all other respects shall be quali- fled electors in said City for their de- termination. to-wit:
 Shall the Commission of the City of Phoenix, Maricopa county, State of Arizona, be authorized to create an in- debtedness for and on behalf of the said City of Phoenix, and upon the credit thereof in excess of four per centum of the value of the taxable property of said City. but not in excess of fifteen per centum of the value of said taxable property of the City of Phoenix. by issuing negotiable coupon bonds of said City in the amount of One Million Three Hundred Thousand Dollars, for the purpose of acquiring funds for the purchase, construction and installation of a waterworks sys- tenn. to be owned and controlled eX- clusively by the said City of Phoenix. Said bonds to consist of thirteen hun dred bonds. numbered one to thirteen hundred, both inclusive. in denomina- tions of One Thousand Dollars each; which bonds shall bear the date of their issuance; shall be payable to bearer, and bear interest as evidenced by cou- pons attached thereto at the rate of , per centum per annum, payable semi annually on the first days of January and July beginning January l, 1920 at some bank in the City of New York, State of New York, and said bonds shall mature January l. 1850"
 Section A. That said special election shall be held at the regular voting places within the City of Phoenix, which have been designated by ordi- nance No. 270, as follows;
 First Precinct: Adams street school Second Precinct: Central school building.
 Third Precinct: s35 North Central avenue.
 Fourth Precinct: Monroe schoo, 1 building.
 Fifth Precinct: Northwest corner 1 Second avenue and Madison street
 Sixth Precinct: City Hall. l That said election shall be conducted | by such election officers as shall here after be appointed by resolution of the 1 City Commission, and shall be con- i ducted in the manner prescribed by law and the vote shall be counted. can vassed and returned and the result as- | certained as provided by law. i Section 5. The form of ballot which
 shall be provided by the City Clerl 1 to be used at said election shall bt | substantially as follows:
Arizona republican., 1919-07-01

FLOWING OR LISTING to do with 4669 If