New-York tribune., 1919-12-22

whom she endeavored to claim protec'
ton or, else she intentionally mad
the false statement that the HUSBAND
was dead in 1909.
Upon the conclusion Of the second
hearing al Ellis Island the record In
the case was forwarded to the Com.
m IS ioncr- General of immigration
Anthony Caminetti. for review ane
final action and on Friday, December
to report at Ellis Island and surrender
herself to the imm grafton authorities
for dcportation, the Department oi
Labor having acted upon the case ant
concluded that she was an alien advo
eating and teaching the doctrine OF
"ana, chy."
Emma Goldman hastily returned te
New York from speaking tour or
December 5, 1919, ard presented her
self at .El is Island at which time she
was taken into custody and her release
upon bond refused. Her counsel imme-
diately sued out a writ Of habeas
corpus be fore Judge Mayer and o.
Monday. December 8 1919, a hearing
uron the writ of habeas corpus was
set to be heard before Judge Mayer
At this hearing the government was
represented by United States Attorney
Francs G. Caffey. special assistant tc
the Attorney General, JOIN Edgar
Hoover and w. J. Peters law Office
CT the Bureau oe Immigraton At this
proceeding the judge found that there
was no grounds for granting habeas
corpus and, there fore, remanded Emma
missioner of immigration at Ellis
Island.
Immediately counsel for Emma Gold
-
Wednc sday, December 10. 1919, counsel
Justice Brandeis for the purpose of
arru ng the writ of error. At this
rrocec ling the Department of Justice
was repre- sented by r. P. Stewart.
ssistant Attorney General, and John
Edgar Hoover, special assistant to the
Attorney General. Justice Brandeis
considered this matter of such nature
that he referred it to the entire Su-
preme Court.
Stay of Deportation Order
Briefs in the proceedings were filed
with the Chief JUS ice of the Supreme
Court on Wednesday afternoon, De.
cember 10, 1919, at o'clock m. and
on Thurs lay aftcrnon, December H.
the Chief ustice stayed the deportation
proceedings for one week in order
hat counsel for Emma Goldman might
if he so desired, present the record to
TIE Supreme Court on December IS,
1919. The Chief Jus ice. however,
refused to allow the subject to be re-
lea~od on hail nendino this stay
Counsel for Emma Goldman refused
to avail himself of the opportunity to
resent the record to the Su RENE
Court, with the result that on Decem-
Der IS the stay in the deportation was
vacated
Immediate sters we're then taken to
secure the deportation of Emma Gold
man, and she is included among those
selling upon the transport Buiord tor
Russia.
Alexander Bcrkman: At the hearing
before Judge Mayer on December the
government was represented by United
States Attorney Francis G.. Catfey. spe-
cial ass stlnt to the Attorney General
John Edgar Hoover, and W J. Peters,
law officer of the Bureau of hmm .gra-
ton
After argument on the case, Judg
Mayer decided that there were no
grounds upon which the writ OF habea
corpus could be sustained and, there
fore, remanded Alexander Berkman to
the CUSTODY of the Commissioner o.
Immigratic On at Ellis Island. Immedi-
atclv counsel for Berkman sued out q
writ of error. and on Wednesday. De
cember 10, 1919, counsel for Alexande =
Bcrkman appeared before Justice Bran