New-York tribune., 1919-11-02

Crippled Union
Team Outpia>s
Blue and White
Dawsons Warriors Look
Weak and Li.tless Until
Canapary's Appearance

The crippled Union eleven hold
Columbia 20 II scoroless tie yesterday
afternoon on South Field In slorq.
listless game played in tho ram. TIE
Blue and White gridders. although out
weighing their rivals ten pounds %
a man. played spritless game. beinr
content at all times - hold their own
with the aggregation which Sol Ne.
ger had patched up for the contest
In the absence of Captain CanaparF
and Eddie Quigiey the local eleven
looked very weak, display a. raggea
brand of football a. has ever been
seen on South Field.
For the first three periods the ur.
state team had "a decided advantag.
over the Nornineside eleven ard three
ened 10 scol" ore two occasions. o.
upon the appearance OF captain Cars
parry in the last quarter I'D the Coium
blans play auY tiud OF footbali, sho
lng little OF the gore that enan
them 20 defeaf Amherst las' wee.
Canaparv twice got WITHIN kicking z
ance Of the goal. bat ms etsort "a
each time.
The field vas slippery and mud
from the long ram. which conrnu.
throughout the contest. maA ng fa-
play impossible. The condition was
the advantage OF the Mornings side e
defe. however because of their super ..-
weight. but il avaiied them nothing
Previous 10 me appearance - Cara
parry the only Columbia man ro -1..
anything at ali was Charlie Shaw
the third period he cot away from tr
|
yards but wae dowrei bf Nit-rer g..
the 3O-yard lne Ie should haze
scored on this ran. bar haif "A doze"
Columbia men. r'rr ong WItr
made no afte'nl 70 give nim interff
ence. shaw again pu' away In -re s-
quarter Tor gain ot twenty lalat
but the Columbia backs couIa NET n, 3
him ont
Columbia was penaAzed a. leas- a
dozen times for on--lat pay when ttet
started drives down the field. ru p
whatever chances ites had 20 scor
At all times fne Blue and Mni.e stos-,
either ignorance of fh. rules or
great disregard for them on two ot
casions Nhen tMon VS. forced 20 sie.
rom far back her otr tsrritort
Columbia PLAYER irterfefred with ~.
man Who Was nicA % Z. gilin- nIou Tbs
ball and losing me opror.unitt of eet
ting the pig a.n in The enemy tern
tory. Such playing ia ab~o Hteiy ir
eNcusable, a. there nottlnr 20 be
gained by IT,
The Union eleven was a far different
proposition han HE Columbia eieve~
expected TO meo- 7 rc backs mr. fh.
line with "a CRASH. rre fre men dor
under the plays and fnelr fac. ng va
hard and sure. L. frIs team lad more
.tf
o the contes. world nave nrobAb
been lar direfenf
The irst time trat eftnef team came
near 10 scoring Was in tne -scond pt
rod. Thornton. nno was Very much o."
form all afternoon In hi~ kicking
punted outside 70 uon or tNc 3o-Ear
line Nittner frreN erNard ps
70 hoffman. netting -.eu- yards o.
tho ueNt pia. Niftiaf tatet a Ions
pass. Intended ior fe onf-tr"fchei
arms of Nottma'i. Who N.- tanalne hc
hind the Columbia goa lire. bat Eccle =
dove through iae arr. l1s knocking
the bali 70 ore -'de Asan Thornton
nuuted oF side. giving 'fo ball 70
The Maroon team started ri xh' back
Witinor made siN gard. 1F eft tack
Lyman wen, ih~ouEn fHe o-ncr sidc
for thirteen yards Wiftacr tncn threw
"a forward pass 20 lyman. hrIre eing 'fr
ball TO The 2o-Nari iin fn, refer Be-
dectccfed holding by lrio. oa the ne
play. which brought tto Ns-ors bac
to the 60 yard hne. ~here .nes lost IT,
ball.
With the advent of Canapary ~ th-
contest a. the end of tire third perlon.
the Blue alna Whl.c uaie rheir -eriou-
ef'o"t 20 score
They had received the hsI na a nur
ON ihc iO- yari mark Shaw hes'
pulled him do~a tanapats -t,n went
through guard for nlfeen sad more
Two downs produced bar tards SD
Canapaly elected 20 .ica hc ffF
vas poor. bounding over the a, s,hc..
Lyman recovered for nor
Agal n tne ia-t 0"~ioa. atfer ID 10.
ward rln bV SHAW. @st bar ''o m.r
utes to play. Columbia -of oit.in s.st.
iug q is-ance Again tananar1 droprf
bach. WITH The fate fa. game re-ti E.
on him. His AIcb Nent wsde and t.t
game ended.
Che .ne-ur.