Evening star., 1919-11-14
Roll Call.

Roll Call.
The roll call on adoption of the
reservation follows:
For adoption:
\! Republicans-Ball, Borah, Brandegee,
Calder, Capper, Colt, Cummins, Curtis,
Dillingham;, Edge. Elkins, Fall. Fernald,
France, Frelinghuysen. Gronna, Hale,
Keyes, La Toilette, Lenroot, Lodge, Nc
Cumber, Mclean, McNary, Moses, New
Norris, Page, Penrose, Phipps, PoindeX-
ter, Sherman smoot. Spencer. Sterling;
Watson. Total, AZ.
Democrats-Gore, Reed, Smith (Geor-
gia) and Walsh CMassachusetts). Total, 4.
Total for, 46.
| Against adoption:
Democrats-Ashurst, Beckman. Dial,
Fletcher, Gay. Gerry, Harris, Harrison,
Henderson. Hitchcock. johnson (South
Dakota), Jones (New Mexico), Kendrick,
Kirby, McKellar, Myers, Nugent, Over
man. Owen: Phelan' Pittman; Ransdell,
Smith (South Carolina), Stanley,
Thomas, Trammell, Underwood, Walsh
(Montana), Williams ard Wolcott.
Total, 33.
! Total against, 80.
| Sixteen senators not voting follow:
| For adoption-Jones Washington,
Kellogg. Mccormick, Nelson. Newberry
and Wadsworth. republicans, and
Shields, democrat.
| Against-Bankhead, Chamberlain, Cul-
berson, King, Pomerene, Simmons,
Swanson and Smith (Arizona), demo-
Gratis.
One vacancy in Virginia
Administration Men Fight Hard.
| The administration forces fought
stubbornly through the day and into
! the evening to secure some modifica-
tion of the committee measure. Final
ly forced to yield, Democratic Leader
Hitchcock put into the Senate hopper
a set of five reservations, on which he
will ask for a vote later as a substi-
tute for the committee program. The
reservations cover withdrawal, the
questions and voting equality in the
league.
The republican petition for cloture,
although prepared by the mild reser-
just before adjournment last night
1t calls for limitation of debate on
F! the whole treaty and carries the sig
nature of the following republican
senators:
Lodge (Mass.), Phipps (Col), Elkins
CIV. Va.). Curtis and Capper (Kan.),
Edge IN. J.). Townsend (Mich), Jones
(Wash.), Norris (Neb.), Calder IN. W,
Kellogg and Nelson (Minn.), Hale
(Mo.), Lenroot (Wis.). McNary (Ore.),
/ Dali \bCl-Js OLCIlluS 10. D.Js CuIHIHlHS
and Kenyon Gowa). Moses and Keyes
IN. H.). Spencer (Mo.), McCumber
IN. d.. Colt Or. IL. Watson and New
(Ind.), Smoot (Utah), Mclean (Conn.),
Dillingham; (Vt) and Harding (Ohio).
Vote to Be Taken Tomorrow.
| The petition was admitted without
objection and was ordered to lie over
under the rule until tomorrow, when
a vote must be taken without debate.
Should a two-thirds majority favor
| cloture, no senator then could speak
more than an hour in all until final
ratification roll call had been reached
motion by Senator Walsh -(dem.,
Mont.), to amplify the reservation,
mustered only four votes.
Other Amendments Also Lost.
| On all Of the other proposed amend
ments and substitutes the vote was
virtually the same. no republican
| to five democrats helping vote them
down. A motion by Senator Thomas,
| democrat, Colorado, to assume the
| article x obligations for five years,
tor Walsh, democrat, Montana, to ex-
| tend the articles guarantee to the
small buffer states of central Europe,
was lost, A to 80, and one by Senator
Mchellar, democrat, tennessee, to ex-
tend aid in protecting Alsace-Lor-
raine, went out, As to So.
BY a vote Of A to 80 the Senate
rejected substitute by Senator
Hitchcock which would declare the
recommendation of the league coun-
Gil to be merely advisory" and a
similar proposal by Senator Owen,
democrat, Oklahoma, failed, "A to 33.
Mr.. Hitchcock's final effort at amend
ment-a motion to add a resolution
drawn some months ago by Senator
Knox, republican, Pennsylvania, rela-
tive to the nations duty in any Euro
pean emergency, was rejected, As to
"a. Senator Knox voting with the
other republicans against 1t.
Hitchcock Reservations.
The substitute reservations present
ed by Democratic Leader Hitchcock are
as follows:
That any member nation proposing
to withdraw from the league on two