davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The Cook County news-herald. [volume] (Grand Marais, Cook County, Minn.) 1909-current, 1919-05-28
lpplicants,
The State of Minnesota To The Above
Named Defendants:

The State Of Minnesota To The Above
Named Defendants:
You are hereby summoned and re-
CURED to answer the application of the
applicants in the above entitled pro-
ceeding, and to file your answer to the
Clerk of said Court, in said County.
within twenty days after the service
OF this summons. upon you. exclusive
OF the day of such service. and, if you
within the time aforesaid, the appli-
cant in this proceeding will apply to
the Court for the relief demanded
therein.
Witness. Geo. Leng, Clerk of said
Court. and the Seal thereof, at Grand
'Marais.. in said County. this 7th day
of April, A. d. 1919.
GEO. LENG,
Clerk of District Court.
(Seal of District Court, Cook Co. Minn.)
ARNOLD & ARNOLD,
Attorneys for Applicant.
The Cook County news-herald. [volume] (Grand Marais, Cook County, Minn.) 1909-current, 1919-05-28
Applicant,
Defendants.
The State of Minnesota to the Above
Named Defendants:

Named DefendantS:
You are hereby summoned and re-
CURED to answer the application OF
the applicant in the above entitled pro.
ceeding. and to file your answer to the
said application in the office OF the
Clerk of said Court. in said County.
Of this summons Upon you exclusive Of
the day Of such service. and. II you
fail to answer the said application
cant in this proceeding win apply to
the Court for the treHef demanded
therein.
Witness. Geo. Ieng, Clerk Of said
Court. and the seal thereof. at Grand
Marais. in said County, this Asst day
OF May A. d. 1919. : i'.'.
GEO. LENG,
Clerk of the District .CoHft.
(Seal of District Court. Cook County.
Minnesota -:
ARNOLD & ARNOLD,
Attorneys for Applicant. So
The Cook County news-herald. [volume] (Grand Marais, Cook County, Minn.) 1909-current, 1919-05-28
Applicant,
The State Of Minnesota To The Above
Named Defendants:

me state Of Minnesota To The Above
Named Defendants:
You are hereby summoned and re-
CURED to answer the application of the
applicant In the above entitled pro-
ceeding. and to file your answer to the
said application In the office of the
Clerk OF said Court, in said County,
Of this summons upon you exclusive Of
the day of such service. and, il you
fail to answer the said application
cant in this proceeding will apply to
the Court for the relief demanded
Court, and the seal thereof, at Grand
Marais., in said County. this 7th day
Of April, A. d. 1919.
GEO. LENG,
Clerk Of District Court.
lSea1 of District Court, Cook Co. Mimi
ARNOLD & ARNOLD,
Attorneys for Applicant.
The Cook County news-herald. [volume] (Grand Marais, Cook County, Minn.) 1909-current, 1919-05-28
NOTICE OF LIS PENDENS.
STATE OF MINNESOTA
)ss.
County Of Cook,
IN DISTRICT COURT
ELEVENTH JUDICIAL, DISTRICT

Counties Land Conn
pany. a Minnesota corpora
tleh, Plant
Sophia H. Bohanon, Executrix
and Trustee of the estate of
John G. Bohanon, deceased
Sophia H. Bohanon, Charles
Bohanon, John Leonard b.
hanon, Annie Bohanon,, Sadie
Bohanon, Horace Bohanon.
clinton Bohanon, Edith Far
nam, Raymond Bohanon, Roy
John Bohanon, Eugene p.
Bohanon, Archer Bohanon.
Henry M. Farnam. l. ].
Flynn, Henry I. Wombacher.
Richardson Realty Company,
a corporation, william p.
Harrison, L. M. Carlson,
Gustavus Stevens, Lydia M.
stevens, Marcus Simpson,
Grant IL. Stevens, Royale H.
Stevens, Lavina Stevens, Una
Stevens, Nicholas McPhee,
Michigaumi Iron Company, a
corporation, John T. Rich.
James A. Hurst, Albert
Hurst, Harrison Geer. Will
liam B. Williams. Michael
Kelly, George G. Howe, Cook
County Iron & Land Com
pany, a corporation, John @.
"A. Crosby, Charles J. john
son, Higgins Land Company,
a corporation. Cedar Supply
f P~lpWood Log O. c SSrRS1nt'on a.
corporation. Margaret Grif-
fin Rust, Margaret Griffin
Rust. Henry r. Ketchem and
Hugh J. McClearn as sTrus-
tees for Margaret Griffin
Rust. Caramel Ruth Rust,
Kathryn Mary Rust and
Cameron Ralph Rust under
the last will and testament
of c. r. Rust, deceased,
Caramel Ruth Rust. Kathryn
Mary Rust. Cameron Ralph
Rust. Myrtle Simmons, Well
lington R. Burt. Z. L. SIM
mons, American Realty Com
pany. a corporation. North
American Iron Company. a
New Jersey corporation,
State of Minnesota, The
County of Cook, Mary Pagan,
Jennie Krojanker. The Mar
ais Investment Company. a
corpora ton, Edward Lynch
and all other persons and
parties unknown claiming
any right. title, estate, lien
or interest in the real estate
described in the complaint
herein,
1ofop1o >,
The Cook County news-herald. [volume] (Grand Marais, Cook County, Minn.) 1909-current, 1919-05-28
nv ota.e " minnesota 10 Inc ABOVE

11IC oluIC UI MIIlIlESUCG TO TIC ABOVE
Named Defendants:
You are hereby summoned and re-
applicant in the above entitled pro-
ceedhg., and to file your answer to the
said application in the office Of the
Clerk of said Court, in said County.
within twenty days after the service
of this summons upon you exclusive
Of the day of such service. and, If you
within the. time aforesaid. the aDpii-
cant in this proceeding will apply to
the Court for the relief demanded
therein.
Witness. Geo. Leng. Clerk of said
Court, and the Seal thereof, at Grand
Marais, in said County, this 7th day
of April, A. d. 1919.
Clerk of District Court.
(Seal of District Court. Cook Co. Mimi
ARNOLD & ARNOLD.
Attorneys for Applicant.
The Cook County news-herald. [volume] (Grand Marais, Cook County, Minn.) 1909-current, 1919-05-28
Applicants.
The State OF Minnesota to the Above
Named Defendants:

me otate OF minnesota to the Above
Named Defendants:
You arc hereby. summoned and Re.
CURED to answer the application Of. Gle
applicant in the above entitled iprc.
ceealns, and to file your answer toS the
SAID application in the Office OF tbs
Clerk s'of said Court. in said Co,tnt1.
within twenty days after the setytc6
or this summons upon you exclusive o.
the day OF such service, and. IL sYoa1
fail to answer the said application
within the time aforesaids the appHs
can't IN this proceeakuB Swdll apply e.
therein. =
Witness. Geo. Leng. CLERK. .of ssata
court. and the seal thereof. at GEand
OF April 1919.
Clerk ofsDistrict Caurt.
(Seal Of District Couft. fsdofI1n1intv
Minn.) -.
ARNOLD e ARNOLD.
Attorneys for Applicants. 4-3o
The Cook County news-herald. [volume] (Grand Marais, Cook County, Minn.) 1909-current, 1919-05-28
Plaintiff,

H. B. Postlewaite,
= Plaintiff,
VS..
Samuel McClelland, James G..
Harris, Charles e. Ingraham,
also all other persons un-
known claiming any right,
title. estate, interest, or lien
in the real estate described
in the complaint herein,
Defendants.
The Cook County news-herald. [volume] (Grand Marais, Cook County, Minn.) 1909-current, 1919-05-28
Torrens No. res.
STATE OF M1NNEsoTAl
County OF Cook.
DISTRICT COURT
ELEVENTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT

In the matter OF the ,applica.
F ton of :. Northerna C0unfies
t. Land Company; asAEdHnesotS &
corporation. to register the
title to.>.theeS following de-
seribed- real estate. situated
in Geek County, MINNESOTA
Lot One in Section Twenty.
township Sixty-f1ve North.
Of Range One West OF the
Lots One. Two. Three, hour,
in =: Section Twenty -one.
Township S1xty.11veI North,
Of Range One West OF the
+ 4th p NJ. -.-s
North half of the Northeast
quarter. and North half OF
the Northwest quarter OF
+ Section TWenty-nine, Town
ship SiXty.flve North OF
Range One West of the 4th
p. NJ.
Applicant,
Frank G. Wilson, Mary T..
Hallock. NJ. w. Earhart. w.
Il. HALEY. and all other per-
sons or parties unknown,
claiming any right. title,
estate. lien or interest in the
real estate described in the
application herein.
Defendants.
The Cook County news-herald. [volume] (Grand Marais, Cook County, Minn.) 1909-current, 1919-05-28
SUMMONS. 8.
STATE OF MINNESOTA 81
~ )ss. Z.
s. County Of Cook
4 IN DISTRIcT COURT Ez
ELEVENTH. JUDICIAL DISTRICT
Northern Counties Land Con- 81
X .pany. Minnesota CORPORA,
ny ton, =" ~ -. Platntiff.

Counties Land Cons
pany. Minnesota corp0ra-
z ton. e. RI ~ Plant
Sophia H. Bohanon. Executrix
and Trustee of the estate of So,
John c.. Bohanon, deceased
;. Sophia H. Bohanon,a Charles
.Bohanon, John: Leonard Bo-
. -hanOn. Annie :BohanOn,- Sadie
Bohanon, Horace B6hanOli,
Clinton BOhanon,u Edith9 Far
nam, Raymond Bohanon, Roy 8.
Bohanon. Frank Bohanon.,
John Bohanon. Eugene e.
Bohanon, Archer Bohanon,
Henry NJ Farnam. g.; j..
gym y henry l; WombaGher,
a corporation, lWillian"5R:
Harrison, L. M. Carlson.
stevens. Marcus Simpson.
Grant II. Stevens, Royaie H.
Stevens. Lavina Stevens, Una
Stevens, & Nicholas -. McPhee.
Michigaumi Iron Company, a.
corporation, John T.. Rich.
James a: Hurst. Albert
liam B. Williams, Michael
Kelly, George c. Howe, Cook
County Iron &c Land Conn
=. pany, a corporation. John O.
A. Crosby. Charles j. john
son, Higgins Land Company,
g corporation. Cedar Supply
Pulpwood Log Company. a
corporation, Margaret Griffin
RUST. Margaret Griffin Rust.
Henry r. Ketchem and Hugh
J. McClearn as TrusteessfOr
Margaret Griffin Rust. Cara
mel Ruth Rust, Kathryn
Mary Rust and Cameron
Ralph Rust under the last
will and testament of G.. r..
Rust, deceased, Caramel
Ruth Rust. Kathryn Mary
Rust. Cameron Ralph Rust.
Myrtle Simmons. WELLINGTON
X. Burt, L. L. Simmons.
American Realty Company.
corporation. North American
IRON Company. a New Jersey
corporation, State Of Mime
sofa. The County Of Cook
Mary Pagan, Jennie Kro,
tanker, The Marais Invest
ment company. a corpora
tlon, Edward Lynch and all
other persons and parties
unknown claiming any right.
title. estate. lien or Interest
IN the real estate described
IN the complaint herein,
Defenda n
The Cook County news-herald. [volume] (Grand Marais, Cook County, Minn.) 1909-current, 1919-05-28
STATE OF MINNESOTA,)
County of Cook. }
DISTRICT COURT
ELEVENTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT

r. f.. Frost, Plaintiff,
Ella Mayh ew Townsend,
George H. Mayhem, Edith
MAYHEM Strom. Hugh J. Nc
Clearn and Margaret Wake
lin: also all persons UNI
known having or claiming
an interest In the property
described in the complaint
herein, Defendants.
The Cook County news-herald. [volume] (Grand Marais, Cook County, Minn.) 1909-current, 1919-05-28
TOrrens No. 40.
STATE OF MINNESOTA,
County of Cook.
DISTRICT COURT
Eleventh .In6icial niStrict

DISTRICT COURT
Eleventh Judicial District.
In the matter of the applica-
ton Of AHchigaumi Iron Com
pany, a Minnesota corpora
ton, Theodore NJ. Helinski
Jennie Krojanker and I.
Freimuth, to register the
title to the following de-
scribed real estate, situated
in Cook County. Minnesota,
namely:
Lots Two, Six, Seven and
Eight, and Southwest Quar-
ter of Northeast Quarter, of
Section Three, Township
sixty-four North. Of Range
Five West Of the Fourth P.
NJ.
Applicants,
Cary T.. Mordux, Cary E. Mou-
lux, Cary e. Moulix, Eliza
Mordux, Eliza Moulux, Eliza
Moulix. and all other per-
sons or parties unknown,
claiming any right, title,
estate, lien or interest in the
real estate described in the
application herein,
Defendants.
The Cook County news-herald. [volume] (Grand Marais, Cook County, Minn.) 1909-current, 1919-05-28

STATE OF MINNESOTA,
=. County of Cook. s>e-,-.-, ~r,.s
DISTRICT. COURT 4.
Eleventh - judicial District.

In the matter Of the -~applica-
ton of The. Marais Invest
1aent Company, i a MINNESOTA
MS. Fras,k H Hasaay Fred !; S ~
Bradley; Charlotte Charlie ! w. w: EDDY.
dy Cotchett. Robert 3: EDDY,
lanes T'adS 16 e: Eddy t,dw Caroline
tee under the last will and
testament of Henry M. Brad
ley. deceased and; Charles H.
Bradley. to register the title
to the following deScribed
real estate, situated in Cook
County. Minnesota, namely:
Lots Six, Seven, Eight and
Nine, and South Half of
Southwest Quarter. of Sec
f ii n T ivy nins "4 ea1 Lots
Seven and Eight and South.
Quarter of Section Twenty
nine, North Half of North
west Quarter and North Half
Of Northeast Quarter of Sec
ton Thirty-three; in Town
ship Sixty-five North OF
Kaaga p ?w NJ. East of the
Northeast Quarter of South
east Quarter. South Half OF
Southeast Quarter. Southeast
quarter, OF Southwest Quar-
ter. and Lots Three, -Four,
Five. Six and Seven, of Sec.
ton Thirty-one, Lots Three.
Four, Five, Six, Seven and
Ten of Section Thirty-three.
Lots -Four. Six. Seven and
Eight and West Halt of
Southeast Quarter of Section
Thirty-fOur. Lot One, South
Half of Northwest Quarter
and Northeast Quarter of
Southwest Quarter Of Sec
ton Thirty-f1ve, in Township
Slxty-hve North. Range
Three East of the Fourth p.
NJ.
Appllcan
John L. Dolsen, Frank H. DOL
sen, Landon B. Dolsen, Sarah
L. DOlsen and Robert Bruce
Dolsen. sole heirs of John L.
DolSen, deceased. Mary E.
Hallock, Hershell H. Hatch,
F. l.: Finkenstaedt. Richard
son Realty Company. a COR
poration. William P. Harri-
son, and all other persons or
parties unknown, claiming
any right, title, estate, lien
or interest in the real estate
described in the application
herein,
Defendant
The Cook County news-herald. [volume] (Grand Marais, Cook County, Minn.) 1909-current, 1919-05-28
TOrrens No. III.
TOrrenS No. III.
STATE OF MINNESOTA,
County Of Cook.
DISTRICT COURT
Eleventh Judicial District.

In the matter of the applica-
ton Of Northern Counties
Land Company. a Minnesota
corporation, to register the
title to the following de-
scrlbed real estate situated
in Cook County. Minnesota,
namely:
Lot Eleven fractional South
east Quarter of Southwest
Quarter) Of Section One.
Range One East. of the
Southeast Quarter OF South
Thirty, Township Sixty
three North, Range One
East of the Fourth r. NJ.
Lots Five and Six of Section
North. Range One West of
the Fourth P. NJ.
Applicant,
Richard bowman, Roderick r.
Macfarlane. William p. Har-
rison. Caroline Swift Harri-
son. F. D. McMillen. Allan H.
Ash. James La Berget, And
rev st. Martin. Moses Zim-
norman, and all other per-
sons or parties unknown.
claiming any right, title.
estate. lien or interest in
the real estate described in
the application herein,
Defendants.
The Cook County news-herald. [volume] (Grand Marais, Cook County, Minn.) 1909-current, 1919-05-28
Toffens No. 171
STATE OF MINNESOTA
County OF Cook y
DISTRICT COURT,
Eleventh Judicial District

In the matter of the .-applica.
ton OF ) Northern Counties
Land Company a Minnesota
corporation, and William III.
Cruikshank to register tho
title to the following de-
scribed real estate. situated
in Cook County. Minnesota,
namely:
North Half of Northeast Quar-
ter and Lots One and Two
Of Section Tweatyxfo1f,
Township Sixty-dve. Range
Five West Of the Fourth p.
Applicants.
William Henry. Charles II.
Neff. L.. M. Carlson, and all
other persons: or@partissrsan--
known, claiming any right.
title. estate. lien or interest
in the real estate described
in the application herein
: DESCENDANTS.
The Cook County news-herald. [volume] (Grand Marais, Cook County, Minn.) 1909-current, 1919-05-28
OF MINNESOTA
County Of Cook. }
DISTRICT COURT.


ELEVENTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT
r. f. Frost, Plaintiff.
VS..
Ella Mayh ew Townsend,
George H. Mayhem, Edith
Mlyhew Strom. Hugh J. Nc
Clearn and Margaret Wake
lin; also all persons I'M
known having or claiming
an interest in the property
described in the complaint
herein,
Defendants.
The Cook County news-herald. [volume] (Grand Marais, Cook County, Minn.) 1909-current, 1919-05-28
The State of Minnesota To The Above
Named Defendants:

The State of Minnesota To The Above
Named Defendants:
You are hereby summoned and re-
CURED to answer the application Of
, the applicant in the above entitled pro-
ceeding, and to file your answer to the
said application in the office Of the
Clerk of said Court. in said County.
-Aof this summons upon you exclusive of
the day of such service. and. if you
fail to answer the said application
within the time aforesaid. the appli-
can't in this proceeding will apply to
the Court for the relief demanded
therein.
Court, and the seal thereof. at Grand
Marais, in said County, this 7th day
of April, A. D. 1919.
GEO. LENG,
Clerk of District Court.
(Seal Of District Court. Cook Co. Minn.)
ARNOLD & ARNOLD,
Attorneys for Applicant.
The Cook County news-herald. [volume] (Grand Marais, Cook County, Minn.) 1909-current, 1919-05-28
T0rrens No. 164.
STATE OF MINNESOTA,
County of Cook.
DISTRICT COURT
Eleventh Judicial District

In the matter of the appl1ca.
ton Of Northern Countess
Land Company. Minnesota
corporation. to, register the
title to the following de-
scribed real estate. situated
in Cook County. Minnesota,
namely:
Lots One. Two, Three and
Four. of Section Four:
Township Sixty-four, North.
Range Three East OF Fourth
P. NJ.
Applicant,
John Mcleod, State of Minne-
sofa, and all other persons
Or parties unknown, claim-
ing any right, title, estate,
lien or interest in the real
estate described in the ap-
Dlication herein,
Defendants.
The Cook County news-herald. [volume] (Grand Marais, Cook County, Minn.) 1909-current, 1919-05-28

DISTRICT COURT
Eleventh Judicial District.
In the matter of the applica-
ton of Split Rock Mining
and Investment Company, q
Aiinnes ota, corporation,
Northern Counties Land
Company, a Minnesota corp
Grafton. and East VermilliOn
Land Company, Minnesota
corporation. to register the
title to the following de-
scrlbed real estate,~ situated
in Cook County, Minnesota,
Lot Four of Section Twenty
two, Township Sixty-one
North. Range One East of
Fourth p. NJ.
Applicants,
Charles Boyden, John NJ. Mill
lar. North American Iron
Company, a New Jersey cor
poration, Samuel B. Barker,
Aura w. Barker. Union Ma
tional Bank Of Chicago,
banking corporation. Fred A.
Brown, George II. Mayhem.
Grand Marais 6 Northwest
ern Railway Company, q COR
poration. and all other per-
sons or parties unknown,
claiming any right. title.
estate. lien or interest In the
real estate described in the
application herein,
Defendants.
The Cook County news-herald. [volume] (Grand Marais, Cook County, Minn.) 1909-current, 1919-05-28
TOrrens No. 1877.

STATE OF MINNESOTA,
County of Cook.
The Cook County news-herald. [volume] (Grand Marais, Cook County, Minn.) 1909-current, 1919-05-28

The Marais Investment Com
pany, corporate w. r.
JamisOn, Fannie 3. Jamison,
Michael Kelly. +. c. Clough,
j. b. Sattler. e. G. Glow, and
all other persons or parties
unknown, claiming any
right. title. estate. lien or
interest in the real estate
described in the application
herein,
10 =,
The Cook County news-herald. [volume] (Grand Marais, Cook County, Minn.) 1909-current, 1919-05-28
STATE OF MINNESOTA
)ss.
County Of Cook. =
;, DISTRICT COURT
ELEVENTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT

H. B. POstlewaite,
The Cook County news-herald. [volume] (Grand Marais, Cook County, Minn.) 1909-current, 1919-05-28
TOrrens No. 165.

STATE OF MINNESOTA,
County of Cook.
The Cook County news-herald. [volume] (Grand Marais, Cook County, Minn.) 1909-current, 1919-05-28
DISTRICT COURT
Eleventh Judicial District.

In the matter of the applica-
ton of Northern Counties
Land Company, a Minnesota
corporation, Sattler Brothers
Company, a corporation,
Theodore NJ. Helinski. Marie
Sattler. and Pulpwood Log
Company, q corporation. to
register the title to the fol-
lowing described real estate,
situated in Cook County,
Minnesota, namely:
Northeast Quarter of Southeast
Quarter of Section Nine, and
East Half of Southwest
Quarter and Northwest
Quarter of Southwest Quar-
ter OF Section Ten. all in
Township SiXty-four North,
Range Four West Of Fourth
p. NJ.
nnlfoa
The Cook County news-herald. [volume] (Grand Marais, Cook County, Minn.) 1909-current, 1919-05-28

OF MINNESOTA
County of Cook.
The Cook County news-herald. [volume] (Grand Marais, Cook County, Minn.) 1909-current, 1919-05-28

DISTRICT COURT
Eleventh Judicial District.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1919-08-11

is by no means famed for his supposed
player whose throw falls into the glove
lightly and gives the other fellow
plenty of time for making the play.
The reason for that has never been
explained. 1t may be that the thrower
unconsciously twists the ball as he let's
it go, but in that case 1t should curve
Sweeping Side-Arm Throw.
Take, then, Mickey Doolan, who
played short for Brooklyn on various
occasions. Mickey has the most beau
tiful sweeping side-arm throw we ever
saw, and the motion was totally differ
cnt from that of Maranyille. Which
has the better form? There amt no
such animal as form" in baseball, as
1t is applied to golf md other sports.
Doolan made his reputation OF the
side-arm stuff. OF course he could
throw from other positions. but that
a the efficient element which made
him u star for ten years, although he
seldom batted over $50.
Smith Throws Overland.
Another case is that Of j. Carlisle
(Red) Smith OF the Boston Braves.
Smith for nearly ten years has been
a third baseman. The best asset of a
third haseman is supposed TO be an
underhand throw; yet Smith has al
ways been an overland thr0wcr. He
never learned the other style, and does
not use any other to this day. Ii
"form," as ordinarily understood, had
counted, Smith would have got
ten a job on an amateur team.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1919-08-11
InneIders Who Have Their own peculiar way Of throwing.

What is the better form in baseball,
to throw ~underhand, side arm or over
handed? We will not venture an
opinion. We leave that to the pundits
of the pastime-and to the golf play
ers, writes Tom Rice In Brooklyn
Eagle.
In their recent series with the Bos-
ton Braves, the Brooklyn Superbns
had to face the shortstop work of Ma
ranville. We will venture the opinion
that Maranville is the best thrower we
have ever seen. In that we are sup
ported by the Brooklyn papers. Larry
Cheney remarked that Maranvllle
could shoot a ball faster and with
more accuracy than any other athlete
he knew. Larry was right.
Meanwhile Ia a Puzzle.
Meanwhile seems to get the ball
away without making half of the usu-
al motions. He can shoot under or over
handed, but his best trick Is ip-shoot-
ing from a sort Of side-arm overland.
That Is not a clear description, but
1t is not our fault. Maranville's throw
has always been a puzzle, even to play
ers on the field with him. He seems
to push, rather than throw, the ball.
Another popularity is that the play
ers on the same team say he has a
light throw. That is, 1t hits the re-
ceiver's hands without Earring them.
Why thot should be so is one of the
mysteries of baseball. 1t is notorious
in the profession that a throw from
some players will nearly knock the re-
ceiver down, ven when the thrower