New-York tribune., 1919-09-18
npion Barnes Has close Cau or T;,,lxe
Cincinnati Man
Gives Long Jim
| A Hard Battle
Macdonald, Hutchinson, Ed
gar, Mcleod, West, Me-
Lean and French Win

Tim Barnes. the cstern open cham
MON. was forced to produce the best
sho.s frem his bag of tricks to s.ave
os defeat in the second round of the
championship tournament of the Pro-
fessional Golfers Association on the
links Of the Engineers Country Club
yesterday.
At the end of the first eighteen holes
long jim stood 3 down to Otto Hack
harth. Of Cincinnati. A handicap like
.ha. is sufficient to worry almost any
one. but Barnes. fighting mad when he
snished the morning round. was still
lacking for trouble as he went to the
srst tee in the afternoon, and the way
he proceeded to burn up the course
going out literally overwhelmed his
opponent.
Others to safely survive the round
were Bob Macdonald, Of Evanston;
Jock Hutchison, Of Glen View; Doug
las Edgar, OF Atlanta, the Canadian
open champion; Fred Mcleod. of Co
,ambia; James West. of Rockaway;
George Mclean, of Great Neck, and
ymmet French. Of York Of these
what looks Ike the star match for to-
dsv is the meeting between those old
side partners. Macdonald and Hutchi-
son. Barnes IS also bound to meet a
stubborn opponent in French, who is
playing his usual consistent game. Nc
Lean meets West and Mcleod takes on
Edgar.
Tom Mcnamara was clearly of his
game. and after he Won the first hole
in the morning. never had a chance
against Hutchison. who cut loose at
great clip. Beginning with the second.
Jock had seven holes in 2j strokes,
two under fours. He turned for home /
up by winning the ninth. and although
Tommy Mack managed to hold his own
coming back, Hutch SON maintained the
advantage OF i up at the end of the
round having made the trip in 76
In the afternoon the situation was
much the same. Hutchison always hav-
ing great advantage on the drive and
laying his approaches UP with a dead
hness that gave his opponent few open
ings. The Glen View man reached the
turn in 80. and by that time had in
creased his advantage 70 & ZIP. Nc
Namara won the tenth hole in 3. and
after half in at the eleventh, Jock
won the twelfth and the match.
French and Tom kerrigan. of ST.
wanoy. had il hammer and tongs all
day Had it not been that he lost his
bail among the rocks going to the
dogs lee ninth hole. French would
have been out in good figures As it
was, he stood all square at the turn
and took commend again By winning
the eleventh in . thanks to twelve
foot putt. and the twelfth IN 4 He
finished the round / up.
Macdonald ended the morning ses-
sion 3 up OF George Fotheringham.
thanks to four stymles, two Of which
were laid hy the .asc-Namod player
himself. A. one hole, Fotheringham
returned the compliment by laying the
New Evanston pro" q stvrie. Mac
donald was 50 to the turn having We
the long ninth. with 6. after his
third shot 0verran the green = the
point he stood 3 up. FotheriAgham last
his ball ct the I've fth, and at the H-.t
lost the hole after another stymie
which Was has own doing. Macdonald
made the round n - to 50 for the
former Sou'h African champion
After luncheon, Fothcringham showed
no disposition TO curl up and quit, on
the contrary. he fought so hard tina.
he had the match evel five holes from
home, hu- the tricky li,clc fourteenth.
which has been SO severely criticized
proved to- much l9r fotherlngh ana
he lost thai. as we'll as the fifteenth.
due to an approach
Two halves followed, leaving Mac
donald winner oy and margin
After the match, Fotheringham de
elared that Macdonald was the longest
driver he ever saw.
The summary follows:
Seconi ioune-Jim Barnes sunset HIN
oea' Nlt9 n4cltbarta. Cincinnati Up and
1- 10 pa sweet French. York heat Tom
fnssrrisan S."aroy, : up, Bon Ma Donald.
GsaHsien G,an o.~i George Fotlerius
ven Cove. up aud TO play. Jock
ha-ehison Glen tfee. haat Tom NJ
HNaansra- Ha.ra- 5."anoy. Up and : to playi
Douglas Edgar Atlanta beat Harry
Taoa FTslaspttoH. kleAwouu. up ana to play
SFea 4cl-"oa Columbia. beat tieorge Cor
yyoN; ahnainOlss H. up. James West
10 no .kawSy, beat Wilfria Reid, Whining
5oh' Up and 70 play. George Mclean,
1reat Neck, beat Nike Brady Oakley &