Arizona republican. [volume] (Phoenix, Ariz.) 1890-1930, 1919-11-09

Gratis voting for it or paired i
Holding the whip hand by safe ,
majority, the republican leaders swept
aside every suggested modification and
carried the reservation through ex-
actly as approved by the foreign rela-
tons committee. The republican SEN
ators of the mild reservation group
led a stubborn fight to alter IL, but
after they had failed. voted for adop-
ton The final count was $50 TO 35,
and pairs announced for the absentees
showed the entire senate membership
TO be divided 55 to Al. Five demo-
Gratis Senators Reed, Missouri; Gore,
Oklahoma; Smith, Georgia.; Walsh,
Massachusetts, and Chamberlain, Ore
gon. voted in the affirmative, while
Senator Shields, democrat. Tennessee.
was paired in favor of the resolution.
Is First Of Fourteen
The first Of fourteen reservations,
proposed by the committee to carry
out a program, which its sponsors say
has been pledged a safe majority,
provides:
"The United States so understands
and construes article one that in case
Of notice OF withdrawal from the
league of nations as provided in said
0~tio'e the United States shall be the
sole Judge as to whether all its inter-
national obligations and all its obliga-
tions under the said covenant have
been fulfilled, and notice Of withdrawal
by the United States may be given by
a concurrent resolution of the congress
Of the United States
Following is the vote in detail:
For adoption:
Republicans: Bell, Borah, Brande-
gee, Calder, Capper. Colt, Cummings,
Curtis, Dillingham;. Edge, Fall Fernald,
France, Gronna. Hale. Harding, John
son Of California; Jones Of Washing
ton; Kenyon, keyes. Knox, La Fol-
lette, Lenroot. Lodge. Mccormick, Nc
Cumber. Mclean, McNary, Moses, Nell
son. New, Newberry, Norris, Page,
Penrose. Phipps, Poindexter. Sher-
man. Smoot, Spencer Sterling. Town
send. Wadsworth. Warren and Wat
son-45
Democrats: Chamberlain. Gore,
Reed. smith OF Georgia, and Walsh Of
Massachusetts-5. Total, so.
Against-Republican None.
Democrats: Ashurst, Culberson
Dial, Fletcher. Gay, Gerry, Harris,
Harrison, Henderson, Hitchcock. John
son of South Dakota, Jones of New
Mexico, Kendrick, King, Kirby. Nc
Kellar Myers, Nugent Overman,
owen. Phelan Pittman. Pomerene,
Robinson, Sheppard, Smith of Arizona,
Smith of Maryland, Smith Of South
Carolina, swanson, Thomas, Tram
nell Underwood, Walsh, Montana;
Williams and Wolcott. Totals, 30.
The eleven senators not voting were
aligned as follows: For adoption:
Republicans-Elkins. F'relinghuysen
Kellogg and Sutherland: Shields,
democrat, Tennessee.
Against -. Democrats: Bankhead,
Reekham. Martin, Randel, Simmons
and Stanley.
The fight to alter the reservation
conferred on its concluding clause. The
democrats and Senators McCumper'
North Dakota, and Nelson, Minnesota,
OF the mild reservation repuolleans'
orgued that the executive should have
o,voice in deciding any questions of
v,ithdrawal. Three proposed amend
rnents on the subject were rejected by
rnaforitles ranging from six to 90.
Senator Nelson proposed that joint
reaolution instead of a concurrent reso-
ln,ion be stipulated for notice Of with
draval so that the signature of the
,,resident would be required He de-
clared "intense partisanship nae
twisted the language OF the reservation
ca as TO put a slight on President VII
son while he is on sick bed, brought
down by his hard work to re-estaollsf
peace. so ,a+or,af
+bt no "motive of hostility had m
fiuenced the framing Of the reserva-
lion. should the provision ever be IN
,olSed. he said, It was apt TO be re-
nnblican and not democratic presl
4 dcnt whose power was curtailed. sen
y ,tors Nelson and McCumber alone OF
INC republican side. voted for the mo
zion and il was defeated As 10 3s.
senator Walsh, democrat, Montana
+ben proposed 10 strike out entlren
.ho congressional authorization. Hi
cotton was beaten, 40 TO 81. a slmiia
,notion previously by Senator Thomas
sor,ocrat. Colorado. was Withdrawn
NJ Thomas saying he was sure ]
would fail
A motion by Senator Gore to EN-
mower either the president or congres
- rive notice OF withdrawal wa
voted down, 6s to is, gaining scattere'
srnport from both sides Of the cham
bor Senator King, democrat utar
,noved 10 make the provision relativ
- Judging obligations applicable 10 al
.be league members. but that wa
heaten, 50 to 30.
A