Evening times-Republican. [volume] (Marshalltown, Iowa) 1890-1923, 1919-11-15
SEVERAL DEMOCRATS
DESERT WILSON
Vote With Republicans For Prsserya.
tion Of ooetrine-othsr Reservations
Adopted--cloture Agreed To and
Work Of Completing Treaty Ressr-
vations Will Be Observation-Disclosures
Within Short Time. ~.

shut down debate on the peace 'tTeatS
was adopted today in the senate:
Republican and democratic leaders
voted together for. the cloture, which
means that no senator may speak ih
all more than one hour. 1t Was esti-
mated the step would bring final ac-
tion in one week. The vote was IS to
16. '-."~-
The action invoking cloture for the
first time in the senate's history re-
suited In Immediate speeding up OF
the , reservations program. the next
reservation on the list being adopted
within one minute without debate or
roll call. The text of the reservation
follows:
"No mandate shall be accepted by
the United States under article AAll.'
part one, or any other provision of the
treaty with Germany except by action
Of congress-"
Democrats Seek TO Amend.
The committee reservation relating
to domestic questions was then adopt
ed. An amendment by Senator Hale
SO as to make 1t include questions OF
the boundaries Of the United States
was adopted, So to 40, on party lines.
Taking up the Monroe doctrine reser-
walton the senate voted down., SO to
43, a motion Of Senator Hitchcock te
declares the doctrine In no way Ina
paired or affected BY the treaty.
Onlt. two stlenocpats. Reed, Of Mis-
souri,. ana Shields. OF TennesHees stood
with the republicans for the. commit
tee draft. 81 ..5. q,
Another substitute for. the Monroe
doctrine offered by Senator Ptttman
democrat. of Arizona. proposing thai
the. United States reserve for Its owl
consideration any question coming un'
der the doctrine, also was voted down
| So to AZ. sS,.Ss efs
Monroe boetrlna> Prsssrved..
| d The committees Monroe doctrine
reservation was adopted by vote O
f55 to a3.\ -,
The roll cali revealed the greateA
democratic strength yet shown for an!
part OF the reservation program, nine
| democrats voting for adoption. the!
! were Chamberlain. Of Oregon; Gore. 9
Oklahoma; Kirby, of Arkansas; Owen
/ Of Oklahoma: Reed, Of MISSOURI
| Shields, of Tennessee: Thomas. Of Col
orado; Trannell, of Florida, and Walsh
OF Massachusetts s-t 4sjTr 'tfsy
In taking up the committee reser
walton relative to control over dornes
I tic questions, the senate by q vote
| AZ to SO rejected a substitute by Sen
| ator Hitchcock. -.
Marshall Rules on. Cioture. @
! Quoting from the constitution, IN
vice president held that the right
! the senate to Nadvise and consert y
the making on treaties could not %
taken away by any strained constfuc
tion Of senate rules. w -. :
"As long as majority OF senator:
want to try to ratify In some way,
said the vice president "the maJort
Of senators have the power to Ac'
| Adoption Of the cloture rule will no
prevent ajority from attempting; 7
ratify the treaty in some way, altho
| will end the debate within the tim
provided by the rules. -55. i
| Reservation on Shantung Voted.
| The Shantung reservation wa
| adopted without change. A Nsubstitut
by Senator Pittman, Of, Nevada, wa!
ldefeated, so to 30. On the Shantuns
reservation the vote was go to ~. Ftv'
democrats Gore, Reed. Shields, Walsh
! Of Massachusetts, and Thomas vote
with the republicans for ADOPTION. ant
one republican, McCumber, voted Will
the. democrats. 3r.1 .r.1 4.
| The reservation giving, congress aai
thority to .reEulate appointment 10
delegates to the league also was adopt
ed. The vote was o3 to 40. Senator
Gore, Reed, Smith, Of Georgia, Walsl
and Shields voting with the fepu!D
licans. n
orsat Britain Not Disturbed.
I London, Nov. 15.-The adoption p,
4 a.. II-s4a,S s,to+o. saAnfa az the. reSAr