The Morning Tulsa daily world. [volume] (Tulsa, Okla.) 1919-1927, 1919-11-20
Lodge Resolution Re-
jected Twice; Refuse
Approval.
WRANGLE PROLONGED
Democrats Proposals All
Rejected by Solid Re-
publican Lineup.
WILSON FOR REJECTION
President Writes Hitchcock
and Democrats Support
His Stand.
MARSHALL 0VERRUlED
Rulings in Favor of Dem
ocrats Are All Promptly
Turned Down.
WILSON FOR REJECTION
MARSHALL OVERRULED

WASllINGTON. Nov. ~ Rsufi-
cation Of the peace treaty with the
reservations framed by the republi-
can majority and objected 10 by
President Wilson, was voted down
I'm the senate late today with the ad
ministration senators lining up solid
ly against H.
The ratification resolution which
would have required "A two-thirds
majority for adoption mustered only
80 votes to b6 against It, Its sup
porters were 80 republicans and
four democrats.
The result WAS 10 place the trosty
In u parliamentary status which its
enemies declared amounted at lehst
temporarily TO rejection. It's friends,
however. had hopes of revising II at
another session of Congress
After the ratification vote, the re
publioans permitted their resolution
in exactly the form rejected TO come
up for further consideration but ~
the session extended into the even
ing the solid republican lineup which
had held throughout the day against
rcpeatet democratic compromise
proposals. showed no signs OF Yield j.
ing
letter From Wilson.
A letter from President Wilson
advising administration senators To
vote against ratification Of the
treaty with tho foreign relations com
mittee reservation was laid before
conference OF the adminlHtraiion
senate forces today by Democratic
Leader Hitchcock.
The committee program, the presi-
dcut wrote, would provide not Tor rh-
tification "hut rather for the null
Glcation Of the treaty"
immediately tho presidents let
ter became public, Republican Lead :
cr Lodge declared he did not believe
the senate would "obey tho orders
Of thc ntesldont who undertakes 10
command the senate 10 Ntify me
treaty without The reservations which
II and made II safe for
the United states
Immediately after the senate met.
Senator Lodge formally presented
tho resnu,ion of ratification con.
talning tho 10 reservations adopted
by Il majority Of tho senate. Debate
began and several senators tooh
part Later in the day vote was
reached on the Lodge resolution
OF ratification which was re1ece1'
In order to put the treaty into
parliamentary situation where an
other vote could bo had after efforb
at oompromise, tho senate then
voted 10 reconsider its action. Tho
motion was male by Senator Need'
democrat Missouri. and was adopt.
cd by the vote OF the democrats ana
mild reservation republicans.
81 thn RECOMMENDATION
was merely 10 bring the committee
resolution back to tho same status
Il occupied before the ratification
roll call Tho vote was So 10 80
Refus, tn Adjourn.
An effort by Democratic Leader
Hitchcock To have tho senate ad-
journ at this state failed. the mia
rcserya,ionists lining up with mo
other republicans against the ad-
journmcnt motion The vote was bl
TO ~.
The roll cali on the Lodge reeo-
luton follows.
For adoption:
Republicans Ball, calder, Cap
pcr. colt, Cummins Curtis, Dll-
lingham Edge Eikus Frellng-
huysrn. Hale. Harding, Jones,
Washington. Kellogg, Kenyon,
kcycs. Lcnroot. Lodge. Mc'um-
Der. Mclean, NcNnry, Nelson.
New. Nevberry. Page, Penrose,
Phlups. Smoot. Spencer. sterling,
Sutherland. Townsend NadH-
worth. Warren and Watson as
Democrats Gore, shields,
Smith. Georgia: walsh, MasaIchu.
setts. t--Toml SO,
Against
Republicans - Bornh, Irande-
gee. F,rual1, France, Grunua
Johnson. california; Knox. La
Toilette. McCoruirk. Moses. Nor
ris PpindcNter, sherman.
Democrats -- Arhurst. Bank head.
EcoEhrm, Chamberlain. CulbHrsou,
Dial Fletcher. Gay Gerry, Harris,
Harrison. Henderson. hitchcock. Nc
Eu'lar. Nyo-s SIEonN Dycrman.
rhellu Piumun. romcrcne, Rams
den. Reed, Robinson. sheppard. Sim
mons. Smith Arizona. smith. Mary
land: Smith. South Carolina. Stanley,
swanson. Thomas TraWmeN. Under
wood. walsh. Montana, Williams and
" Wulcott--i2
Senator rail. republican ~ New
Mo- lpu the uuI, absent m"m bcr.
WIS OPPOSED tu tho Indg" resolution.
rc.rriluE tp, announcement by Sena-
tor curtis republican, whip
senator Hitchcock sought 20 offer
70 4rl ~ .pHHl"umiso rrs"ry1iinns but
a point 81 order bt Republican
COSTlNUED ON PACE THIRTEEN