New-York tribune., 1919-09-19

his professional title, defeated Emme
hv 8 up and to play, and as re
in the semi-tinal to-day.
The tall Scot surprised not few by
beating his old side partner, Jock Hutch
;son. by 8 to 2, for the opinion that
Hutch had little something on Mac
donald was practically unanimous.
In the lower half of the bracket Fred
will meet George Mclean. the Great
Neck "pro" Both won their matches
by wide margins yesterday, Mcleod
taking the measure of Douglas Edgar,
the Canadian open champion from At
lanta, to the tune of and 6. and Nc
Lean disposng of James West, of Rock
away, by up and to play.
Mclean Loses Ball
Mclean played the best golf of the
morning, as even after losing his ball
at the second ho'e, he reached the turn
in SO. where he stood l up. Coming
back, he set site pace, making the last
nine in 81 for rs.
In the afternoon the Great Neck "pro"
made the turn in Sc, and settled &C
counts on the eleventh hole Mcleod
finished against Edgar in blaze Of
glory with three So at the tenth.
eleventh and twelfth holes, after being
up at the turn.
Things we're never dull from the
time Macdonald and Hutch left the
first tee il the morning, for it was a
case c: o0e fine shot sfter another.
After having the first hole in par 4 ,
Macdona a the 4l2-yard SECOND had
tie bad fortune to send his second
ssot INTO q bunker. After playing
well cut OF the sand he was laid
siyr,ie BY his opponent, and putting up
closely he again had his way TO the cup
hsrred by Hutchinson, who laid him
.nothor stymie
In trying to get past. big Bob
krocked the o-her's hail into the cup
80 that Hutchlson won in 5 to 6. The
!saustfE 20 fey squared acc UNITS by
Winning the fourth, after Hutchson
~. III trouble with sliced second
sho;
Hutchison, after being up at the
eighth, .os' his ball st the long ninth
rad turned for home up. Macdonald
Tan The torth. fourtseNth. fifteenth
ard sixteenth, while Hutchison won
tfe eleventh and thirteenth, so that big
Eob finished the morning round I up.
having gone out in rs to 70 for his
opponent
Macdonald in Trouble
They halved the first hole after
luncheon and Macdonald Won The sec
ond and third in "b1d" threes thanks
70 long ructs on cach green. The next
FIVE holes were halved. and Hutchison
wen the ulatn when his opponent got
in trouble among the rocks. Al that
point Macedonia d stood up, both hav
ing made the turn in 80.
Hutchisou cut his opponents lead
TO ore a little later by winning the
short tenth in 3. but he proceeded 10
get himself in wrong by slicing his
drive from the eleventh tee to the
woods. Hutch" called it an out of
bounds, but the general opinion was
That 1t was lost ball. Macdonald.
however magnanimously told his op-
ponent to tee another ball and call
the first shot out of bounds. This
was dome. bat as Bob made no mis-
takes he Won the hole in to 5.
No" up again, Macdonald cortin-
ued to play masterful golf, for even
when his drives did 20 wandering
MS powers OF recovery never failed.
They falved the twelfth and thirteenth
In par As, but al the short fourteenth
both played tawlessly, each man hay
Ing putt for 2.
They haiund IN Z hu+ ,ubor NToc
donald pulled has drive to the rough
at the fifteenth and supplemented that
by getting trapped on his second shot
II looked as if Hutchison's opportu-
nifty had arrived. The Glen View man
however. was trife strong on his
approach, though he had much the
easier third shot
From the sand Macdonald laid q
rare niblick shot to within less than
two feet Of the pin, and then not tc
be outdone Hutch" chipped ur
equally close, so that it was halt
in l.
Fails to Make Green
TO tie sixteenth and what proved
10 be the last hole Of the match, Joel
sealed his own doom by pulling al
approach 20 the side Of the hin, anl
then falling TO make the green on 1
too delicately played mashie shot. The
nsl! stopping on its way down the bill
hob. making no slip, won the hole il
y FOR The seven inward holes playe'
Macdonaid's card showed one under 4s
Inc card read as follows: