Arizona republican., 1918-05-29
IF |. W. W., CAMPBELL
 PAY ARE DEBATED

That section of Governor Hunts message to the legislature relating to thc Bisbec depOrtations re-cchoed in the senate yesterday morning nearly throughout the morning session The feNerberatons were louder and more threatening than they had been at any time. II all came about through the rc-introduction of a resolution by Senator Campbell dcnouncing the l. W. W. The resolution differed only from that introduced into the house by Mrs. O'Neill and that in the senate by Mir. Roberts, by the insertion after "l. w. w of the words and pro- German agitators." Under suspension of the rules the resolution was ad- vanced to second reading over the objection of Mir. Winsor who coun- sclcd delibcration. He said that he would vote for the resolution or any resolution dcnouncing the l. W. ". or other violators of the law. evadcrs Ot the law or enemies of the govern ment, but he thought that there was no need of haste.
 Dr. Ferguson of Santa Cruz be- lieved otherwise; that such enemies could not be denounced too quickly Or too vigorously and he saw no need of proceeding to that task with de- liberation.
 Senator Campbell Explains
 Mr. Campbell explained why the resolution had been introduced. He said that he had withdrawn the former resolution because of the mis- interpretation given it by some ol the newspapers which described it as ar B4 nrl- Campbell declared that in introducing it he had not the governor in mind So when it was represented to him that this construction had been placed upon it, at the suggestion of Senator Roberts and others, he had with drawn if.
 A few days later, however, Mir. Roberts introduced the same resolu- tion. He therefore thought that the senator from Cochise had not acted in good faith and that the resolution brought in by him was intended for something more than to convey the senate's destestation of the l. W. W. At this point there was q violent colloquy between the senators, MT. Roberts instead of addressing the chair turned to Mir. Campbell. Presi- dent Claridge then intervened.
 The most torrid remarks of the session were offered by Mr. Sutter of Cochise alluding to the governor without mentioning his name He said, among other things, When a man in high position in a public utterance criticises those who have been and are opposed to the l. W. w. and without a word of criticism of the I. w. W. that man is favoring and in favor of the l. w. w"
 MT. Winsor Reiterates
 Mr. Winsor reiterated that he was opposed to the I. w. w. and all other enemies of the government, be they the highest in position in the state But the enemies of the government he said, could not be controlle3 by resolutions. If legislation is nes 'ed to hold them in check, he said, let the senate legislate in favor of a reso- lution so worded as to hit all violators of the law and all those hindering the government in the prosecution of the war After remarks by Messrs. Wilk- inson, Hall and Colter, the matter of suspending the rules was reverted to President Claridge ruled that 13 votes would be required to suspend the rules and 10 to pass a measure by a majority.
 In a further debate. Mir WinsoI announced that he would introduce a resolution amending this one or an other resolution condemning all those who deserve the contumely of al honest, patriotic citizens.
 'Is that a promise or a threat?' asked Mir. Sutter.
 Both" replied Mir. Winsor.
 The debate on the resolution was resumed. Mir. Rutherford spoke ir favor of it.
 He gave as one reason why he wa. in favor of it, public interest in tn,
 Continued on Page Three