davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
Perth Amboy evening news., 1918-07-19
German Success Is Undone.

OCGulan SUCCESS Is OnuOnC.
8y Untted Prsss
WITH THE FRENCH ARMIES IN
THE FIELD, July 1g:-with one
wide sweeping smash the French and
Americans undid practically all that
had been accomplished by the last
German offensive; in fact, they
brought that effort to a standstill
while advancing themselves. tearing
through the enemy lines al some
points to a depth of six miles. Some
of the most spectacular cavalry
charges In history have contributed
to the allied movement. The Franco
American success is so complete that
It foreshades the time-now regard
ed as inevitably approaching-when
the Germans must give ground every
where.
The Germans already are reported
to be rushing up reserves. Their Of
fensive aimed at Epernay and thence
toward Paris now seems hopeless of
realization. The attack between the
Aisne and the Marine yesterday began
at daylight and al 7 o'clock French
aviators wirelessed that IL was a sue
cess. Before Q o'clock French head
quarters was listing town after town
as recaptured. BY . P. NJ. this was
a long list.
At many points the men were pro-
ceeded by tanks. adding TO the sur
prise and CONSERVATION Of the Ger
mans. The initial surprise was such
a blow to the enemy morale hat pro-
per counter attacks were attempted
In only a few instances. and then IN
q half-hearted manne hat failed to
have any apparent effect
Courchamps was attacked by the
Germans twice. but each was re-
pulsed easily.
One of the most satisfactory ac-
complishments was the advance to-
ward Soissona The. French and
Americans took and held Montague
de Paris. overlooking the city.
There has been no opportunity yet
to total up the prisoners taken at all
points. but when this is done IL viii
further emphasize the value OF the
present allied effort In contrast to the
German three-day offensive near
Rheims.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1918-07-19
Afternoon Patrol
OF Girls League
viii Meet Today

The meeting of the Afternoon Patrol
of the Girls Scouts will be held his
afternoon at 4 o'clock in the club
rooms in the public library. The Even
ing Patrol will meet Monday evening
at 1880 O'Clock instead of tonight
owing to the Girls Patriotic League
party to be held there tonight. The
members of the patrols are expected
to know something of the history of
the American flag and the ten scout
laws before the meetings.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1918-07-19
AT PORCH PARTY

The Womans' Foreign Missionary
Society of Simpson M. +. Church held
a porch party yesterday afternoon
from 8 to 5 O'Clock at the home of
Mrs. James Noe in Water street. Tho
ladies' are sewing articles for a babies
hospital in China and a number of
were completed yesterday.
D2ffty refreshments were served and
d Silver Offering taken. Mrs. William
was chairman Of the commit
lee in charge. The next meeting viii
be held in August at the home of Mrs.
Charles II. Seguine in Rector street.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1918-07-19
Makes III Pairs Of PdjamaS

Mrs. Meyers. Of 43s Amboy avenue,
made one hundred and eleven pairs
OF pajamas since May 81. This Is
proof of what women can accomplish
at their home. There Is great need
of home sewing. Anyone who has
done any children's sewing car help
out on the garments for the little
refugee children. lust call for them
at the Red Cross and take them
home.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1918-07-19
Rapid Advance Made
FRANK j. TAYLOR
UNITED Press STAN Correspond

FRANK j. TAYLOR
UNITED Press stan correspondent)
WITH THE AMERICAN ARMY
IN CHAMPAGNE. July IS (s;26 A
M.):-Ameriean and French troops.
after organizing yesterdays gains
during the night resumed their onen-
sive between the Atsne and the
Marne at 4 o'clock this morning. The
allies pushed forward behind a roll
ing barrage on the whole front from
scissors TO Chateau Thierry driving
the Germans before them. At the
hour of cabling new reports had been
received OF the extent OF the new
gains. Airmen report huge explosions
and fires in Soissons-evtdently the
destruction OF the ammunition dumps
and supplies by the enemy prepare
tory 70 the evacuation OF the city.
One American unit pressed forward
50 rapidly yesterday afternoon. II
was learned today. that they over
took q party OF captured Frenchmen
who were working On the roads a.
der German guards. Ihey cAptur8@
the hochns and released tAQ French.
who seizsd th4 AFmA ~ their 1ormes
captQru and pressed 1orHnF4 win
Perth Amboy evening news., 1918-07-19
DANCE A

Over 100 couples enjoyed dancing
in Pulaski hall last night to the
strains of Biega's ten piece jazz band.
in conjunction with the con annual
novelty shirtwaist rance of the Phoney
Adams Association held in that hall
last night. The affair. as usual, was a
monster success. ven more so than
in former years.
The hall was decorated with
streamers Of red, white and blue. A
prize waltz was held. The winners
were announced as Miss Edna Thyg-
sen and James Kirk.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1918-07-19
sfay Force Big German Retreat
IA H~{fsA praa

LONDON. July 10: (3:23 p. Nj
That the Franco-American offensive
may force the Germans to retreat on
the entire Rheims front where the en-
envy has used twenty-three reinforce
ment divisions (276.o0o men). or use
their total OF reserves. was the belief
expressed In military circles here this
afternoon. II was also stated that
Crown Prince Rupprecht probably
win start an Immediate Offensive on
the British front in an effort to re-
trieve the Rheims disaster.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1918-07-19
within Mile of SCISSORS


Bg Special corrssp0n4esG
LONDON. July is:-The French
and Americans are within q mile q
Scissors. 1t was learned authorita-
lively today. They have moved for
ward all along the line between the
Aisne and the Marne. their greatest
penetration al last reports being
eight miles. One American division
took Veray and Is reported TO have
advanced three miles beyond.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1918-07-19
New Auxiliary Chairman

At the last meeting of the Slovak
Auxiliary Of the Red Cross Miss Anna
HYDE was elected chairman in place
of Mrs. Pauline Stanick, who tender
ed her resignation on account OF her
distant residence and her inability
to attend the meetings. The meeting
was held Tuesday night in Kozusko
hall. About a hundred members were
present.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1918-07-19
OBITUARY
Mrs. Marie Anne Anderson.

Mrs. Marie Anne Anderson. seven
teen years old. wife OF Edward Ander-
son Of State street. died Wednesday
night at the city Hospital. Mrs. An
derson, besides her husband. Is sur
vived by an infant son. her mother,
Mrs. Marie DeBockler, three sisters,
Mrs. Albert Miller, Mrs. Herman Pc
terson and Miss Frances DeBockler
and four Brothers Frank. Joseph,
Charles and william DeBockler. Flu
neral services will be held Sunday af-
ternoon IT 3 o'clock from the home
OF her mother, sSs Neville street Rev.
Wilbert westcott viii of1ciate and the
fnterment will be In Alpine cemetery.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1918-07-19
81 Italian Bombing Planes
Make Effective Raid on POIa
en Un.ted Press

ID DHited FTe8d
ROME, July 19-Fifty-four Italian
planes. which were accompanied by
speedy hydro-airplanes. all under the
command of the famous poet. Gabriel
.d'Annunzio, made a successful raid
on the Austrian harbor of Pola at
dawn Wednesday, it was announced
here today. Five tons of bombs were
dropped on military establishments as
workers arrived to begin their days
labor. italian warships were standing
out to sea ready to dash to the assist
nnce of the bombing forces should any
help be required.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1918-07-19
Small Fire Last Night.

The fire department was called out
last night at about 8 o'clock in re-
Spouse to an alarm. rung in from box
40. when a youngster playing with a
Japanese lantern, brought II too close
to the home OF A. Morello of 472 State
street. setting fire to the house. The
damage was trifing.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1918-07-19
Bonlbard POIa

VIENNA. July 19:-Admission Il
made In the Austrian official commu-
|nication issued today hat Italian
airmen again have bombarded Pola.
Austria's naval base on the Adriatie.
The communication follows:
Early Wednesday several squad
.rons of enemy ~airplanes and ~
planes dropped about 200 bombs on
Pola. Two persons were killed and
several wounded.
The damage was Insignificant"
Perth Amboy evening news., 1918-07-19

Colonel Marlborough Churchill Is
the new army censor. Censorship
has been placed under the military
Intelligence section of the general
stan, with Col. Churchill. head of the
section, as chief censor. Genera
Frank w. Mcintyre, who has been
acting as censor. will his du-
ties as chief OF the bureau of insular
Affairs
Perth Amboy evening news., 1918-07-19
Praise for Rutgers, Men.

Thirty-four Rutgers students from
the classes OF 1919-1921 underwent
training at Plattsburg camp and
twenty-seven won high merit, one of
which Is a local Lad, Morris Goddard.
The commander states: These stu
dents have shown by their progress in
military that they are worthy of spe-
cial commentator. They are consid-
cred as good material for reserve OFF,
GERS after receiving further training.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1918-07-19
Elect New Officers

Al the last meeting of the st. Mary's
Auxiliary of the Red Cross the follow
ing officers were elected: Mrs. George
Reynolds, chairman; Mrs. Patrick
Burke, vice chairman; Miss Mary
Lewis, secretary. and Mrs. Frank Van
SICKLE, treasurer. The next meeting
will be held on Monday, July 20.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1918-07-19
Pleased with Bureau

Joseph Spitz, n of the commits
sioners OF the State Department of
Labor. of Jersey City. visited the
local office of the federal. state. mu-
nicipal employment bureau yesterday
and was extremely pleased with the
work the local Office has been doing
since its establishment in this city.
The work of trying to ecure labor
ers for the large number of indus
tries here Is still going on and the
interpreters are doing their utmost to
secure men in New York.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1918-07-19

MAY "a is the anniversary Of the
landing Of Ferdinand de Soto in Flor
ida In 1889. He thought he was on
the path to a tabled fountain, by bath
ing In which he could regain his lost
youth. Instead he found only morasses
and impossible swamps.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1918-07-19
Event for Camp RaTitdn

At a meeting Of the War Camp
Community Service at Camp Raritan
last night 1t was decided to hold an
entertainment in the arena at Bon
hamtown on tho night of August 2.
Just what the entertainment will be
will not be known until after a meet
ing of the entertainment committee
some time next week.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1918-07-19
Lutherans Meet Tonight.

The Young Lutherans of the Grace
English Church will hold a meeting
tonight in the church basement. A
very interesting program has been ar
ranged. The committee in charge Is
composed of Andrew Sindet, chair
man; Charles loft and Fred Ernest
Perth Amboy evening news., 1918-07-19
IIeut. whitbcck Back.

Lieutenant J. r. Whitbeck has re-
turned to the command of the United
States Coast Guards stationed in this
city after enjoying a ten-dayS fur
Tough.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1918-07-19

A prevalent superstition in parts Of
Europe Is that bees win either fly away
or die on the occasion Of q death In
the family unless someone knocks at
their hive and tells them about II.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1918-07-19

Don't imagine that you're getting
all the hard luck Or all the good luck.
because that never happened to any.
body and never win.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1918-07-19
Rcncwa Elks LICENSE

NEW BRUNSWICK. July 19:-
Judge Peter F. Daily today granted
a renewal of their liquor license to
the b. p. o. Elks. No. 7s4. of Perth
Amboy.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1918-07-19

LONDON. July 1s:-The food con-
troll board has ruled that extra ra-
lions will be allowed ~expeotant
mothers. Nursing mothers win be
allowed to use the rations obtainable
for the infant. They will be given
priority In milk and meat distribu-
ton.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1918-07-19
Cam or

The undsrsigned desire 10 thank
Major James Dandy Post Sons OF Vet
Grams. Wesfmfnstes~ Cadets. Ladies
Auxiliary q q Of VI. for lowers and
sympathy. Alao Rev. W. Westcott and
underkakeF Eerd 0Arretaou tor aer-
JOHN H. LING
IC9NEN M NN4.
ANNIM LING DoXx*
Richmond times-dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1914-current, 1918-02-01
LEAVES CHILD AT HOTEL
One NIonth-OId Girl, Turned Over TO
Police, IL Taken to Nir-
Sinia Hospital.

Leaving her onc-month-old girl baby
il charge of maid at Hotel Richmond
Al q o'clock last night, Mrs y. w. Will
lams. giving her address, in register
ils. as Washington, stated that she
"aa going out TO shop, hit did not re
turn. Late last nigh; the hotel an
thoriticS became anxious and reported
the matter 10 the police. Officer Iosa-
nau. Of the First Police station. was
sent for the child. aud carried it to the
Virginia Hospital where II WAS being
cared for last night.
Mrs. Williams camc Ia tho hotel at
room yesterday and went out shortly
aftcrward. She returned and remained
for time, when she lott again and
stated that she WAS going shopping.
II Was learned last night that during
the afternoon She had called At the
Richmond Male orphan Asylum and
ought to have the child cared tor there.
she was, of course, refused. At the
orphanaGc the woman stated that II
WAS not her child. and that il had been
left with her ny woman who had
trickcd her into caring for il. The
authorities at the orphaEagc stated
that the child Was very pretty. The
woman was apparently about thirty
years old.
Richmond times-dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1914-current, 1918-02-01
GRENADE SCHOOL CAPTAIN
is INJURED BY EXPLOSIVE
Captain G. L. Moore Struck by Piece
OF Observation-Disclosures Are
Taught Boxing,

CAMP LEE, VA. January 3l.-The
hrst accident to the training OF tho
members of the division occurred this
morning. when Captain Grover T..
Moore. Of the division school OF arms,
was painfully. though not seriously. in
Jured. when struck by a fragment from
Il hand grenade. y small piece OF cor
rugatcd iron struck the instructor on
the nose. cutting it, severely and ncccs-
stating Immediate medical attention.
Iaptain Moore is from Washington.
The bombs are charged with dyua-
mt instead OF tho more deadly L.
y, i. When ono is thrown Il il ncces.
"ary that every one seek cover One
'ncmocF OF the class threw bomb and
captain Moore failed TO hide himself in
the trenches or in a shell hole
Zach member of Company l. Three
Hundred and Eighteenth Infantry. all
O. whom arc Nirginians. arc receiving
boxing instructions. The work is be
ihc directed by Lieutenant X. 4. lI-
gins. who WAS known to every foot.
ha fan in the country Shorty lIir.
GINS when he was chosen by Walter
Camp for his All-American team. Lieu.
tenant Higgins wls then a member OF
tie Penn state eleven
l.. u. murphy. now physical director
Tor tho camp, has been notified tina, he
has been appointed captain Cap,.in
MurphN Is IN charge OF all athletic
80 ~ sohip' nav ING Reci sen,
nero by the commission on training
camp activities.
tsealiHlnE that numbers OF citizens
OF Richmond aud other places viii rur.
chase Smilcago" books. although thcy
'iaNc no personal friand III the army
=. &. Pinchney, director Of the Red
cross, has placed the Red Cross or.
2auizaiton at their services Auy
books that may be forwarded TO the
Red Cross win DO distributed by Mr.
Pinchncy or his assistants among
worthy men Of tho division WHO have
not received them from their ow,
friends
Richmond times-dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1914-current, 1918-02-01

ausrters In England tina; exaggerated
accounts or the strike have been cir
culated by the German government IN
order to influence the engineers on the
Clyde and other centcrs in England
who have threatened to lay down their
tools unlcss the government gave sat
isfactory ISlarantccs that II open peace
Negotiations. as we'll as tho pacinsia
III the entente countries generally
there must have been, and sttli is,
very considerable stoppase OF work in
important war industries.
The strike, which was begun IN Ser
lin chiefly because of dissatisfaction
over tho delay IN carrying out tho
Pruss.an franchise reform, has more or
less spread throughout the provinces
and, according 10 Hamburg Socialist
paper. a state OF siege has oeen &C
c,arcd in that city and its Vicinity
where strikes have occurred i'll the
Vulcan shipbuildinG works ana '"e
plant OF Blohm & Noss
Richmond times-dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1914-current, 1918-02-01
SEPARATES NAVY-YARDS
FROM NAVAL DISTRICTS
Secretary Daniels Divides Authority at
Norfolk, NOSton. New York
md Philadelphia.
BY Associated Press.
A.1.srN>- y 80

by Associated Press
WASHINGTON, January 31.-A new
policy for separating tho administers
ton of navy-yardS from naval districts
was announced Tonight by Secretary
Daniels in orders directing important
changes i'll commanding personnel.
Rear-Admiral Augustus i. Fcchtelcr
Is ordered as commandant of the Nor
folk Navy-Yard. succeeding Rcar-Ad-
miral Walter Mclean, who will con-
tinue to command tho NTH naval dis
trict at Norfolk.
Rear-Admiral Spencer $. Wood is
designated to command tho first naval
district at Boston. relieving Captain
William Il. Rush. who remains as com
mandant of the Boston NaNy-lard.
Rear Admiral John II. Mcdonald is
assigned to command the New York
Nary-Sard. succeeding Rear ADMIRAL
Nathaniel Il. Usher. who viii continue
as commandment os tho third naval dis
trict ut New York
Rcar-Admiral James NJ. Held is APP
pointed commandant Of tho fourth
naval district at Philadelphia. relieving
Captain George Cooper. who VIII re-
main az chief OF star.
This division said Secretary Dan
icls, which is ncccssitatod by the mag
Eitudc of the naval activities IN the
districts, has for its purpose the sen
aration OF the industrial feature OF the
district work. which Will be handled 10y
the navy-yRrds. from the military and
marine features. whica VIII he admin
istcred by tho district commanders
Richmond times-dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1914-current, 1918-02-01
GOVERNMENT PLANS
SUBMARINE CHAsERS
Ford Motor Company Given Con
tract for Building Sew
eral Scores.
DANIELS WANTS MORE MEN
Also Asks Training Stations at Nor.
folk and Pelham Bay Be Enlarged
TO Provide Men to Man Mcr.
chant Ships.
TBy Associated Pres,.1

ny HsSuci1too fresS.l
WASHINGTON. January 3l.-Now sub
marine fighters or s powerful tyne arc
about to he turned out in tho United
States In large numbers. After testi-
flying to-day before the House Naval
Committee on the naval appropriation
bill. Secretary Daniels authorized the
statement that contract for several
scores" OF the new craft have been
placed with the Ford Motor Company.
of J'ctroit lie described them as half
way between a destroyer and "A aubma-
rinc chaser" 200 feet long and equipped
with latest discoveries for combating
submarines.
All parts OF the ships except the en-
gines arc TO be fabricated in Detroit
and tho parts shipped to the scaboard,
where they will be assembled. in con-
ncction with Mr.. Danielss renewed rec
cinmcndation for a large increase in
both temporary and permanent en-
listed personnel OF the navy, II was
learned 10 day that the department
plans extensive enlargement OF several
existing training stations. Plans al
ready have been approved for enlars
ing the Pelham Fay. y. T.. and Nor
folk. Va. stations. Five thousand men
are now at Pelham Bay, and $1,000 at
Norfolk.
Secretary Daniels said that the navy
now has $4,000 men under instruction
viii have men enough TO supply crews
lot only for tho entire naval conStruc-
ton program as now contemplated. but
also for tho hundreds or merchant ships
which AFRO to he placed under his super
vision
Richmond times-dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1914-current, 1918-02-01
THE NEW TRIPLE
COMBINATION

Treatment for tie blood, nerves aud
liver purifying, strengthening. cleans
ing. winning tn wa" wonderfully Just
now-is:
Hoods Sarsaparilla. tho superlatire
blood purifier and appetite Givcr.
known for over 90 years.
Fcptiron. the superlativc pepsin-nux-
iron-cc!ery nerve. blood and dig cst!vc
tonic.
Hoods Fills. tho superlative family
laxative for hiliousncs- constipa ton;
pleasant, cary. elective.
What are your troubles? IL euch at
TO need all three medicines. why not
have perfect. well.roundcd relief by
getting the combination?
If YOU need only one medicine. sc.
II and take it-but do II noS-Adv
Richmond times-dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1914-current, 1918-02-01
STATE HIGHWAY SYSTEM
Is APPROVED By STUART
Last Omcial Act of Retiring Governor
Is to Sign Series Of Good
lSopd1 Lava


NtoRda Lava.
Governor stuart yesterday approved
tho following bills:
Scnat bill lt--AutliorizinS tho Board
or Supervisors of Culpepper County
TO pay Off certain road bonds from
sinking fund
Senate bill lt--Authorizing the
Council OF the city of Portsmouth to
issue bonds to build schoolhouses.
House bin 2--Dcclaring the lot on
which the courthouse of Grecnvillc
Is situated, in the town of lGmporia.
to be a part or all threo magistcrial
districts in the county.
Senate bill Exchanging the time
for holding courts In the Twenty sec
ond Judicial District.
House bill l--AuthorizinS the Board
of Supervisors OF Augusta County to
issue time warrants to discharge float
ing debt
Senate bin 4o--1ncreasinE the sal
aries OF judges OF Circuit Courts.
Senate bill "l--Authorizing tho use
of tho convict road forco III aid OF
tho state highway system.
Senate bill :"--hcceptins the terms
OF tho act of Congress for Federal aid
To good roads.
Senate bill, 23-Establshins the
state highway system. which was the
last b:ll signed by Governor Stuart
Richmond times-dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1914-current, 1918-02-01
WANT SoCIsLlsTlC AHMr
TO FlGHT uIN lMFEItl\LisN

PETRoGRAp. Wednesday,, January
3o.---The Moscow Council OF work
mems and soldiers Deputies has de-
clared the German peace proposals UNI
acceptable. and has suggested that the
Council Of National Commissioners or
~ani=o Socialistic army 10 hGht
against German imperialism.
Representatives OF fori%-siN reSi'
ments Of Don Cossacks addressed the
Congress OF Soviets. promising unlim-
tied grain in exchange for cloth. nails.
implements and other manufactured
products. They said that the enemies
or General kaledincs now were in con-
troll or the Don basin and that great
coal supply was ready 10 be moved
toward Tctrograd.
Richmond times-dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1914-current, 1918-02-01
CANNED GOODS RULING
New Regulation to Negotiate Sales
Uccomcs Operative Feb
rudry 1.
,Ry hssoCiatet Fress !

WASHINGTON. January 3l.--Thc food
administrations ruling, prohibiting the
sale Of canned foods for future dcliv-
cry before February /, VIII permit can
ncrs and Wholesale sroccrs to n"soti-
ate sales on and after Tomorrow.
Gamers arc to be required to nah 9
frequent reports of sales made, ana the
prices at which they sell arc 10 he
subject TO revision hy tho food admin .
iStraticn in ease tho? represent more
than n reasonable advance over tho
average cost of tho seasons pach Of
each Gamer.
Richmond times-dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1914-current, 1918-02-01
.Ioina .ANIntiou Cornr.

y. Noolncr Calisch. tho twenty year.
old son OF Or. ard Mrs. Edward y.
Galisch has successfully passed tho cS-
summation tor aviation service and is
awaiting ordcrS TO report. pc. and
Mrs. Calisch'S eldest son. Harold. is a
member OF the Medical College OF Nir-
ginia hospital unit and their nephew.
pr. Henry +. Calisch who resided "
them during his stay Of several years
in Richmond il with the coast artil-
iery, stationed at Fortress Monroe.
Richmond times-dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1914-current, 1918-02-01
Joseph w. Folk YSc.irps.

WASHINGTON, January 3i.-Joscph
". Folk to-day sent 10 the Interstate
Commerce Commission his rca;s nation
az the commissions chief counsel. 10
take effect before February -. lie will
return Ia his home in st. Louis to bo.
come general counsel OF the Chamber
OF Commerce there.
Richmond times-dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1914-current, 1918-02-01
PARIS CONFERENCE WILL.
NOT DRAW IT WAR .tiMs

LONDON, January 81 Replying 10 a
question In the House OF Commons to.
day, Andrew Ecnar Law. Chancellor OF
the ESche1ucr, said tho assertion that
the war aims OF tho entente powers
were to be drawn up by x conference
aiitins In Paris was incorrect.