davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The evening world., 1918-06-27
FRANC TOPS GERMAN MARK.
Austrian Defeat Cause. Drop on
swiss E~xchsnRe.

GENEVA. June 27.-The German
mark Is now worth less than the French
franc on Swiss Exchanges for the first
time in fifteen months. on the Geneva
Bourse Allied Exchanges cotinuo TO
Increase. While those Of the Central
Powers a-e decreasing, despite efforts
by Berlin sad vienna TO raise the value
of their exchanges.
The decrcasa In eTrhanRe On thA Gem
The evening world., 1918-06-27
AN OLD

From the Philadelphia Bullet.n)
cleopatra used to study the effects
OF poisons by administering them TO
her unfortunate slaves"
why was she never punished for
her crimes2'
We'll. she was so good looking
that the District Attorney evidently
thought there was no use bringing
her 10 trial"
The evening world., 1918-06-27

trial Powers began when news OF the
Austrian defeat on the Piave reached
Switzerland.
The St. Joseph observer. [volume] (St. Joseph, Mo.) 1906-1932, 1918-01-12
ORDER OF PUBLICATION

In the Buchanan County Circuit
Court Court to the January Term' A. d.
State of Missouri, County of Blu
chanan, ss
L. Everett Christie. Plaintiff
VS..
Beatrice Christie ....... Defendant
Now at this day came the plaintiff
by his Attorneys. and II appearing to
the satisfaction Of the Circuit Court
that said defendant, Beatrice Christie,
is a nonresident Of the state of Mis-
souri,, and does not reside therein, 1t
is ordertd that said nonresident de-
fendant hE notified by publication, as
required by law, that said plaintiff
has commenced his suit in this Court
against said defendant by petition and
affidavit the object and general ma
ture of which iI to obtain a decree OF
divorce from the defendant on the
grounds of desertion and abandon
ment, without "A reasonable cause, Tor
the space lpf more than one whole
year next Before the filing of plain
tiff's petition in this cause; that un-
less the said defendant, Beatrice
Christie, shall be and appear at the
next term of this Court, to be begun
and held at the Court House, In the
City Of st. Joseph in Buchanan Coun-
ty. State Of Missouri, on the 9TH day
Of January, 1918, on or before the
third day OF said term, to answer
plaintiffs petition, the same Will be
taken for confessed as to her and
judgment rendered accordingly.
1t is further ordered tnat a copy Of
this order be published in The st.
Joseph Observer, a newspaper pub
| l!shed. I'm the County of Buchanan, for
four weeks successfully. the last In
sertion Of which to be at least fifteen
days before the next January, 1913,
term of this Court.
A copy. Attest:
ROSS c. cox,
| (SeaD Clerk.
BY Emmett !. Grouse, Deputy Clerk.
| Sherman C owen, Attorneys for Plain
tiff
The St. Joseph observer. [volume] (St. Joseph, Mo.) 1906-1932, 1918-01-12
ORDER OF PUBLICATION

In the Circuit Court of Buchanan
County, Missouri. January Term. 1918.
North St Joseph Real Estate, Loan
and Investment Company, a corpora
ton ......s.......,., ,.,..... 'flalntlt
vs..
Cora NJ. sharp, Elbert r. sharp, j.
w. Carson, and the unknown heirs,
dcviseos, donces. alienees. immediate,
mesne or remote, voluntary or invol-
untary grantees Of Cora NJ. sharp,
deceased ..............D Defendants
ORDER OF PUBLICATION
The state OF Missouri, to Cora NJ.
sharp, Elbert B. Sharp, and the un-
known heirs, devisCes, donees, alien
ees, immediate, meme or remote,
voluntary or Involuntary grantees of
Cora VI. Sharp, deceased:
You are hereby notified that an ac-
tion has been commenced against you
in the Circuit Court Of the County OF
Buchanan. i'm the state of Missouri,
affecting the title to the following
described lands and tenements to-wlt:
Lot twenty-three (23), and all of the
unnumbered lot lying north of said
Lot twenty-three, all i'm the west half
Of Block forty-threo f3) in Saint
Joseph Extension Addition. an addi-
ton to the city Of Saint Joseph, Bu-
Chanan County. Missouri, which said
action is returnable on the first day
of the next term of this court to be
/ held at the court house in the city OF
Saint Joseph, in the county and state
aforesaid, on the 7th day Of January
1918. when and where you may APP
, pear and answer or otherwise defend
such action; otherwise plaintiffs pc
tition will he taken as confessed and
! judgment rendered accordingly.
ROSS c. cox,
(SealO Clerk.
| BY Eugene Roseburg, Deputy Clerk.
The St. Joseph observer. [volume] (St. Joseph, Mo.) 1906-1932, 1918-01-12
ORDER OF PUBLICATION

In the Buchanan County Circuit
Court to the January Term. A. D..
1918.
state of Missouri, County of Bu-
chanan, IS.
Coda q. Smith. ....... Plaintiff
Samuel Nj. Smith. h.......D Defendant
Now at this day came the plaintiff
by her Attorney, and 1t appearing to
the satisfaction of the Judge of the
Circuit Court that said defendant,
Samuel NJ, Smith. is n nonresident OF
the state of Missouri. and does not re-
side therein, II Is ordered that said
nonresident defendant be notified by
publication, as required by law, that
said plaintiff has commenced her suit
in this Court against said defendant
by petition and affidavit, the object
and general nature of which Is to OBJ
tain n decree of divorce from the
bonds of matrimcny contracted with
the defendant, as alleged in said pc
titlon, on the grounds OF indignities
and cruel and barbarous treatment,
such as to endanger her life and rem
der her condition in life wretchedly
unhappy and uncomfortable, to-wit:
that defendant has threatened to shoot
plaintiff: that defendant was fire.
uuently i'm an intoxicated condition;
that defendant has repeatedly abused
pitlllllls ltldI he mas lTeQutnllg Cuio-
ed plaintiff, and called her vile and
indecent names; that during most of
the time plaintiff has lived with de-
fendant, he has continually nagged at
her and quarreled with her, and pur-
sued her with petty and contemplate
accusations; that unless the said
Samuel NJ. Smith, Defendant, shall be
and appear at the next term OF this
Court, to be begun and held at the
Court House in the City of ST. Joseph,
in buchanan County. State of Mis-
souri,, on the 7th day Of January, 1918,
on or before the third day OF said
term, to answer plaintiffs petition, the
same viii be taken for confessed as to
him, and judgment rendered accord
ingly.
1t IS further ordered, the a copy OF
this order be published in The St
Joseph Observer, a newspaper pub
lishe1 in the County of Buchanan, for
four weeks successfully, the last in
sertior of which to be ut least fifteer
days before the next January, 1918
term OF this Court.
a copy. Attest:
ROSS c. cox,
(SeaD Clerk.
BY j. l., McMenamy, Deputy Clerk.
James c. Growney, Attorney for Plain
The St. Joseph observer. [volume] (St. Joseph, Mo.) 1906-1932, 1918-01-12
ADMINISTER NTOR,s NOTICE

Notice Is hereby given that Letters
of Administration. upon the estate OF
Charles Schultz, deceased, have been
granted to the undersigned. by the
Probate Court of Buchanan County.
Missouri, bearing date OF the 18th day
OF November, 1917.
All persons having claims against
said estate are required to exhibit
them to me for allowance, within six
months from date OF said letters, or
they may be precluded from any ben
eft Of such estate; and II said claims
be not exhibited within one year from
the date of the publication OF this no
tice, they will be forever barred.
PAUL r. SCHULTZ.
(Seal) Administrator.
true copy. Attest:
ChRs. q. Consodine. Clerk OF Probate
The St. Joseph observer. [volume] (St. Joseph, Mo.) 1906-1932, 1918-01-12
ADMINISTRATORS NOTICE

Notice IS hereby given that Letters
Of Admins slratiOn, upon the estate of
Walter Ken-eTski, deceased, have
been granted to the undersigned, by
the Probate Court Of Buchanan Coun-
t., Missouri. bearing date OF the goth
day Of November, 1917.
All persons having claims against
said estate are required To exhibit
them to me for allowance, within six
months from date OF said letters, or
they may be precluded from any
benefit OF such estate; and II said
claims be not exhibited within one
year from the date Of the publication
Of this notice, they will be forever
barred.
Attest: A true copy.
OLGA KENGERSKI,
(SeaD Administrator.
Chas. G. Consodine, Clerk.
The St. Joseph observer. [volume] (St. Joseph, Mo.) 1906-1932, 1918-01-12
EXrCrTOR,s NOTICE

Notice is hereby given that Letters,
Iestamentary, upon the estate OF AL
bert Fossen, deceased, have been
granted TO the Iniersigned, by the
Probate Court Of Buchanan County,
Missouri, bearing date OF the sth day
OF November, 1917.
All persons having claims against
said estate are required TO exhibit
them 10 me for allowance, within six
months from late OF said letters, OF
they may be gTec!uded from any ben.
Git ~ such estate; and II said claims
he not eEhib!ted within one year from
the date o' tho publication OF this no,
tice, they viii be forever barred.
4 ,rue copy. Attest:
p LOUIS VOSSEN,
'SeSD Executor.
chas. G, coniklins. Clerk o' Probate
The St. Joseph observer. [volume] (St. Joseph, Mo.) 1906-1932, 1918-01-12
ORDER OF PUBLICATION

In the Buchanan County Circuit
Court to the January Term, A. D.,
1915.
state of Missouri, County of Bu-
chanan, ss.
Charles N. C1awson. ...... Plaintiff
VS..
Jessie o. Clawson. .... Defendant
Now at this day came the plaintiff
by his Attorney and 1t appearing to
the satisfaction OF the Circuit Court
that said defendant, Jessie o. ClnWsOn,
Is a nonresident Of the State OF Mis-
souri,. and does not reside therein, II
is ordered that said nonresident de-
fendant be notified by publication, as
required by law, that said plaintiff has
commenced his suit In this Court
against said defendant by petition and
affidavit, the object and general ma
ture Of which is to obtain a decree OF
divorce from the defendant on the
grounds of desertion and abandon
ment, without a reasonable cause, for
the space OF more than one whole year
next before the filing of this petition;
that unless the said defendant shall
be and appear at the next term of this
Court, to be begun and held at the
! Court House. In the City OF st. JOS
eDh, In Buchanan County, State OF
Missouri, on the 7th day OF January
1913, on or before the third day OF
said term, to answer plaintiffs petit
tion, the same will be taken for CON
fesssd as to her and judgment rem
dered accordingly.
II is further ordered, that a copy OF
this order be published In The 81
Joseph Observer. a newspaper pub
lished In the County of Buchanan, for
four weeks successfully, the last in.
sertion OF which to be at least fifteen
days before the next January 1918
term OF this Court.
A copy. Attest;
ROSS c. cox,
| (SeaD Clerk.
BY Emmett ]. Grouse, Deputy Clerk
IL. w. sullinger. Attorney for Plaintiff
The St. Joseph observer. [volume] (St. Joseph, Mo.) 1906-1932, 1918-01-12
EXECCTRIX'S NOTICE

Notice is hereby given that Letters
Testamentary, upon the estate OF
Philip Ernst WenZ. deceased, have
been granted TO the undersigned, by
the Probate Court Of Buchanan Coun-
ty, Missouri. bearing date OF the 9TH
day Of November, 1917.
All persons having claims against
said estate are required to exhibit
them TO me for allowance. within siS
months from date OF said letters, OF
they may be preCluded from any ben
eft of such estate; and II said claims
he not exhibited within one year from
the date OF the publication Of this no.
tice, they will be forever barred.
A true copy. Attest:
NELLIE WENZ
(SeaD EXecutrix.
Chas. G. ConsOdine, Clerk Of Probate
The St. Joseph observer. [volume] (St. Joseph, Mo.) 1906-1932, 1918-01-12

ohDIh oB ttBiIlOtIioN
In the Buchanan County Circuit
Court to the January Term. A D.,
1913.
State of Missouri. County of Bu-
chanan.
Sally Watkins ...........P Plaintiff
vs..
Elmer G. Watkins. ..,. Defendant
Now at this day came the plaintiff
by her Attorney. and ii appearing to
the satisfaction Of the Circuit Court
that said defendant, Elmer G. Wat
kius, Is a nonresident Of the State of
Missouri, and does not reside therein,
it is ordered that said non-resident
defendant be notified by publication.
as required by law, that said plaintiff
has commenced her suit I'm this Court
against said defendant by petition and
affidavit, the object and general ma
ture Of which IS TO obtain a decree of
grounds OF indignities. such as to rem
der her condition as his wife intoler-
able, In that the defendant since July
OF 1917 has deserted plaintiff without
any cause and that before and since
said date has failed and refused to
provide for her; that he has frequent
ly cursed plaintiff and called her vile
names and has frequently beat her
with his fists. endangered her health
and caused her distress in mind and
body; that unless the said defendant
shall be and appear at the next term
/ OF this Court, to be begun and held
at the Court House, in the City Of St
Joseph, in Buchanan County, State of
Missouri. on the 7th day Of January
I191S, on or before the third day OF
said term, TO answer plaintiffs petit
tion, the same will be taken for con-
fessed as TO him and judgment rem
dered accordingly
| II Is further ordered, that a copy OF
this order be published in The st
Joseph Observer, a newspaper pub
lished In the County OF Buchanan, for
four weeks successfully. the last in
sertion of which to be at least fifteen
days before the next January, 1918
term OF this Court.
A copy. Attest:
ROSS C. cox.
| (Seal) Clerk.
BY Emmett ]. Grouse, Deputy Clerk.
Oscar ID. Mcdaniel. Attorney fol
Plaintiff.
The St. Joseph observer. [volume] (St. Joseph, Mo.) 1906-1932, 1918-01-12

Notice is hereby giyon that Letters
Of Administration upon the estate OF
Jno. W. Raney deceased. have been
granted to the undersigned, by the
Probate Court OF Buchanan County
Missouri, bearing date OF the 7th day
Of November, 1917.
All persons having claims against
said estate are required to exhibit
the INTO me for allowance, within six
months from date OF said letters, OF
they may be precluded from any ben.
eft OF such estate: and II said claims
be not exhibited within one year from
the date OF the publication OF this no
tice, they will be forever barred.
A true copy. Attest
MRS. KATE RANEY,
(SeaD Administrative.
Chas. q. Consodine. Probate Clerk.
The St. Joseph observer. [volume] (St. Joseph, Mo.) 1906-1932, 1918-01-12
ORDER OF PUBLICATION

"Vt5' 1....,. ,,;.,,,,t.
IN, IN IiS ..I. = nuCi'aI,'n .,,. OUu"IS ,o3S
'Vguit Jan ttL!"' -, -, & 30 1u-
.'te u' "iSS""''' 'o""'9
"',,l,is - ,,..,. p,,i,,iff
N''i TIA >. N'lS'"' '''''
,.,- ,, VI, r,s,,,1,,,t
sit + 'aIu' -, 80, 49,, ,,I,t,,ttff
,.'rE ", ',!ls u'l ti''i.' 'I'e p.i,,i,' "a
~. .,.s'.t,'' 49, ~ ,'iT IL t,ii', ~ tbs
I..,.,Stt ,,,,,,., ,.,, '.. 5crari,,t
y,.i,, T., y,.,t'.,., - rcsidert nf
49,. .t.,, ,,i.s,,.,,t ,,,i -, not
,o,i l., ,t,,r,i,, ~ ~, ',,'io,si tb9t said
- V'''i i', ,tiri,5 nv
,...It,'.t.,' ,..'..,,.,,.i iot, tbnt
MINUTE, i.,, .,,,,,,H,t bcr suit
a., a. ,,'.,t Ia S,,r,ndart hv
,ic+jti,,, o,,I SffiIa'.i, ~ oi,{ect ana
'.yr,,...I ,,,,',ro ',s ,,.,,;., a., 80 ohtain
49,, 49, di,..,,.., -, SorCndant
,u th. .,',i,,is ,t N, ,iieritics s,,'b as
-. , We 49,. a., i;c, i,,toI-
-, a., - .t ~ ins,,l,,t
..itr,..I ~ ,'l''' ~ r,irod
49,, -, .,.,,-,.t i,j,,tiff
,,,J ,t,,t sh, ,,..,, 'lI'',.',.,liad 10 gyorlS
~ s,,,,1,,,, o,..n,r. tbot dcf,rd,nt
The St. Joseph observer. [volume] (St. Joseph, Mo.) 1906-1932, 1918-01-12
VS..

vs..
Now at this day came the plaintiff
hv her Attorney, and it appearing to
the satisfaction OF the Circuit Court
that said defendant Joseph lie Roy,
is a nonresident Of the State of Mis-
souri,, and does not reside therein, It
Is ordered that said nonresident de-
fendant he notified by publication. as
required by law, that said plaintiff has
commenced her suit in this Court
against said defendant by petition and
a sfidavit the object and geenral ma
ture of which is to obtain decree of
divorce from defer. s. nj on the
grounds of such ind. ynities as to rem
der her condition in life as his wife
Iintolerable in this, to-wit: that de-
fendant used alcoholic liquors to eX-
cess and almost continually and that
when under the influence OF liquor he
was extremely abusive, quarrelsome
| and insulting to plaintiff, that he
stayed ont late at nights, and often
/ left plaintiff and their children and
stayed away for months at a time
leaving them without food and cloth
/ ing ana in destitute circumstanI es;
that unless the said defendant, Joseph
T.e Roy shall he and appear at the
mex, term OF this Court, to be begun
and held at the Court House, in the
lily of st. Joseph, in Buchanan COun-
IS state of Missouri, on the 9TH day
OF January, 1918, on or before the
third day Of said term, to answer
plaintiffs petition, the same will be
takcn for confessed as to him and
I Judgment rendered accordingly.
II Is further ordered, that q copy OF
/ this order be published in The st
] Joseph Observer, newspaper pub.
! lishpd in the County OF Buchanan for
four weeks successfully, the last in
sertion of which TO be at least fifteen
days before the next January term OF
this Court.
A COPY Attest:
ROSS {. cox,
(Sean Clerk.
BY stella Whitehead, Deputy Clerk
DuvaH & Boyd, Attorneys for Plain
tiff
The St. Joseph observer. [volume] (St. Joseph, Mo.) 1906-1932, 1918-01-12
ORDER or PUBLICATION

In the Buchanan County Circuit
Court to the January Term, A. D.,
1918.
state of Missouri, County of Bu-
chanan, So.
Elizabeth Harrington go. Plaintiff
VS..
Clarence Harrington .,. Defendant
Now at this day came the plaintiff
by her Attorney, and II appearing to
the satisfaction OF the Judge of the
Circuit Court that said defendant,
Clarence Harrington, is a nonresident
of the state OF Missouri. and does not
reside therein, II is ordered that said
nonresident defendant be notified by
publication, as required by law, that
said plaintiff has commenced her
suit in this Court against said defend
ant By petition and affidavit, the OBJ
ject and general nature OF which is to
obtain q decree of divorce from the
defendant on the grounds that de-
fendant wholly unmlndful of his du-
ties as the husband of plaintiff on
said - day OF Oltober, 1911, aban-
doned and deserted this plaintiff
without any tLst cause or excuse, and
ever since said date has lived separa te
and apart from the plaintiff and mas
not at any time since said date fur
nished any provisions or support for
plaintiff or contributed I'm any man.
ner thereto; that unless the said
Clarence Harrington shall be and ap-
pear at the next term OF this Court
to be begun and held at the Court
House, i'm the City OF st. Joseph. in
Buchanan County, state of Missouri
on the 7th day Of January, 1918, on
or before the third day OF said term
to answer plaintiffs petition, the
same will be taken for confessed as
to him and judgment rendered ac-
cOrdingly.
1t is further ordered, that a copy
of this order he published in The st
Joseph Observer, a newspaper pub
lished in the County of Buchanan
for four weeks successfully, the las
insertion of which to be at least fiji
teen days before the next term of thi'
Court.
A copy. Attest:
(SeaD ROSS c. cox.
Clerk
BY Eugene Roseburg, Deputy Clerk
| f. NJ SWartZ, Attorney for Plaintiff
The St. Joseph observer. [volume] (St. Joseph, Mo.) 1906-1932, 1918-01-12
EXECITOR,s NOTICE

Notice is hereby given that Letters
Testamentary, upon the estate Of Elsie
Brach, deceased have been granted
to the undersigned, by the Probate
Court of Buchanan County, Missouri
bearing date of the 9Th day Of Novem-
ber, 1917.
All persons having claims against
said estate are required to exhibit
them to me for allowance, within siS
months from date OF said letters, Oh
they may be precluded from any ben
eft of such estate; and If said claims
be not exhibited within one year from
the date OF the publication OF this no,
tice, they will be forever barred.
A true copy. Attest:
HERMAN ID. BRACH,
(Seal) )Executor.
Cha o. Cnnsndlna Nlerk ~ Prnhat ta
The St. Joseph observer. [volume] (St. Joseph, Mo.) 1906-1932, 1918-01-12
ORDER OF PUBLICATION

IN the BuCnanan county rlTcAil
Court, January Term, y. D., 1913.
state Of Missouri. County Of Bu-
chanan, SIS.
Alice Kolbe, an infant. by Anna
Richardson, as her next friend, Plain
tiff.
Vs.
George A. Kobe. ...... Defen liant.
Now at this day came the plaintiff
by her Attorney, and it appearing to
the satisfaction Of the Judge Of the
Circuit Court that said defendant,
George A. Kobe, Is a nonresident Of
the State Of Missouri. and does not
reside therein, 1t is ordered that said
nonresident defendant be notified b.
publication, as required by law, that
said plaintiff has commenced her suit
in this Court against said defendant
by petition and affidavit. the object
and general nature Of which i5 to OBJ
tain a decree Of divorce from the de-
tendant on the ground OF indignities
such as TO render her condition in life
intolerable In this, to-wit: that de-
fenlant made false representations as
to his financial standing and has fail
ed and neglected TO support plaintiff;
that she has been compelled TO live
with her mother and work TO earn
her own support; that defendant was
sullen and refused to talk to plaintiff:
with other women; that Unless the
said George A. Kobe shall be and
appear at the next term of this Court,
20 be begun and held az the Court
House, IN the City OF Saint Joseph, in
Buchanan County state OF Missouri,
on the eth day Of January. 1918, on
or before the third day OF said term,
TO answer plaintiffs petition, the
same Will be taken FOR confessed as
TO him and judgment rendered ac-
cOrdingly.
1t is further ordered, that a copy
OF this order be published in The 81,
Joseph Observer. a newspaper pub
llshed in the County Of Buchanan, for
four weeks successfully, the last in
sertiOn OF which to be at least fifteen
days before the next January. 1915
term Of this court.
A copy. Attest,
ROSS C. cox.
(SeaD Clerk.
| BY Stella Whitehead. Deputy Clerk.
Lindsay & Lindsay. Attorneys fol
| Plaintiff
The St. Joseph observer. [volume] (St. Joseph, Mo.) 1906-1932, 1918-01-12

One OF the late ones: II lost five
beans last night" said ths stingy
young man. I'm not surprised at IT,"
said friend. "You oughtnt TO try to
eat them with a knife. They fall off
every time"
The St. Joseph observer. [volume] (St. Joseph, Mo.) 1906-1932, 1918-01-12
ORDER OF PUBLICATION

In the Buchanan County Circuit
Court 10 tho January Term, A. D.,
1915.
State Of Missouri County Of Blu
chanan, ss
Edith Roeres Plaintiff
vs..
Henry Reeves. .......... .iNcfendant
Now ar this day ,ame the plaintiff
hv her Attorney. and II appearing to
the satisfaction Of the Circuit Court
that said defendant. Henry Reeves.
is q nonresident Of the state Of Mis-
souri, and does not reside therein, II
is ordered that said nonresident de-
fcndaGt be notified by publication, as
required bv law, that said plaintiff has
commenced her suit this Court against
sail defendant by petition and affi-
davit. the object and general nature
of which IS to obtain decree Of di-
vorcs from the defendant on the
ground OF dareTti0n and abandon
went. without a reasonable cause, for
the suaCa oS more than one whole
year next before the filing Of this pc
tit!on: that unless the said defendan Mt
shall be and appear at the next term
OF this Court to be begun and held at
the Court House, in the city OF St
Joseph, in Buchanan County, State OF
Missouri on the 7th day OF January
1918, on or before the third day of
said term. to answer plaintiffs petit
tiou. the same will be taken for con-
feSseI as 10 him and Judgment rem
Gored accordingly
II Is further ordered. that n coDy OF
this order be published in The St
Joseph Observer, q newspaper pub
lished I'm the County Of buchanan, foI
-Four weeks successfully. the last in
sartion Of which TO he at least fifteen
days before the next January. 1915
term Of this Court
A copy Attest:
ROSS =. cox,
(S"sn Clerk.
/ BY Emmett J. Grouse, Deputy Clerk
/ HObson HO1r. Attorney for Plaintiff