The sun., 1918-01-18
SENATE AGAINST
GARFIELD PLAN:
VOTE Is SO TO 10
Action on Coal Order Taken
Upon Resolution of -
Hitchcock.
HARSH TERMS EMPLOYED
Democrats and. Republicans
Alike Condemn Measure
in Debate.
HARSH TERMS EMPLOYED

n. -
vote vhic. sbou.d r..i, -, .
,.,..
J." oPpos'''oh 20 IN"
Adfninis'fation, To-day placed itself OIL
record agains; the drastic order of the
Fue, Administrations o,,-.,,tr It,, T.,
y..-,., 81. ''
cuH'''ai ac'''i'ies OF 'he country Tor
49,, :"
introduced ny Sena,or Hitchcock ,xoh,
,,l,i, a., -, ,,,....,-
''' ''' "e' 'N'''''''H'"''o' ''
matt Tor fve days the pTomulgstion OF
The order tina; reasonable discussion os
tho ouos,,o, Nigh, Il. re-,,,,..d
-N'er series OF "e'a'es' one on me
merits OF the ordo u Itself and the other
on a verbal re,or, nv Senator Reed
,,,o, p, .,. ,r,,,;.t,,., -. nu ,,.,
c.-o.,a radar,, ~, .a,,,,',.,.
;nr in ,n ,r,s-;r, ho, ,iaa, a,
Nv. eoo- =, rs..,,,,,,r ,.. ,.es. ".
vn,. =, "a o. 90 r., nna. ~
80, -, ,,o .s'.. h'' n. Tn,
ann p.,,,,,, liz, ,,sts
ir ,,,,.h... go .,
Sa,.,n-. ~, 80 .,,n,.
,,,,;on n.,i,n a,.u,rn,,,,, ~ o.ir-
- .,.,.,n ~. ,,,s.,s.a,;,, ~ .,s -
- 80. ' .;
,h., .hair .a.,..., .n ,.n. e.. ~, 80,
,,,i,n n-.-,;..,.s ,,,.n ,ho 90,
,n,, ~ ,As.,S... ,,.nuaL ~ ~,
,ar, - .sa'ei, o,,.s,s
,.hi,h ~, s,at,,., ~ I.v. Ars,s, .o,.
yc,,d n hin, ara $50. y orr,or.ur,,,
varo ,rn,la1 tn ra,.., .bc Ia,. itseis
.hev vo,,,d vo.. its rennsI
sharp Denunciation by Knox.
ag,ins, ,ho ,u., nrdar ,,.,. ~ ,rtsr,n-
Iatin,, IN ~. d.h,to ,rh.ch r-scoded n.
ras.axe of IN. Is.chcock reso,u,ion bv
Senator Knox ,par who said. Il
million German soldiers turned loose in
the United states could not work the
havoc this fuel order will create"
Senator Reed chairman of N. Cor,-
mit,ee on Manufa,tires, conducted the
debate in favor Of the Hitchcock reso,u-
ton after the hearing OF the Fuel Ad-
minis:rator. He reported 10 the Senate.
virtually word for word. the statement
as to the reasons for the fuel order as
field. He was helped out by Senator
Ndrdaman tM!es), who had assisted In
the examination. and was opposed by
single spokesman in Opposition TO the
resulruoh VINO was heard.
ne ueoate "nich foi'o"ec l'r. Gar
meiu aramatlc appearance before the
"ahuiHc'uTes Coninittee lasted less thar
,No "ourS' The nnai vote on the resc'
.utioh came az me end or senator Joness ;
Ge'c''cc OF .the fuet Administrators act
Inc attainment or the senate follows:
Amrmat've--Senator Bankhead. BecS-
nam. Gerry. Gore. Hitchcock, MckeNar.
Martin. owen, Pomerene, Reed. Sauls-
pury. shields, smith (Ga.), Smith (Md) y,
smith Is. c., Stone, Swanson. Thomas,
Tliiman. Underwood. Nardaman and
Noicott-Democrats. ~; Brandegee,
Calder, Cumpins Curtis. Fernald. Fre-
linghuysen, Gallinger, Hale. Harding
johnson tCal). Jones tWash.). Kellogg,
Knox. McCumber. Mclean, McNary,
Nelson. New, Norris, Poindexter. Sher.
man, Smoot, Sterling. Sutherland. Town
send. Wadsworth Watson and Weeks
Republicans, rs. Total. so.
Negative Ashurst, Cha mberlain,
Fletcher. Hardwick. Johnson Is. d..
Jones tN. M, Kirby. Lewis. Myers
Phelan, Pittman. Ransde!l, Robinson
Shafroth, Sheppard and Simmons
Democrats. 16: Borah, Gronna and La
Follette--Republicans 3. Total. 10.
Garaeid Explains Position.
Dr Garfield arrived n, tho C,ni,nl
lust before . O'Clock. having heen
hastily summoned by the Committee on
Manufacturers 10 explain hi. order rha
examination began almost i,nmedisteiy
"The Surpose OF the order said Dr
Garfield, "is not 10 Interfere in The
slightes, with the loading OF Goa, nj
the mines This is made clear In the
am n n fNf ha hst not