New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1917-10-16
Three Unearned TallieS Cine Chicago Final Game;
Benton Pitches Great Ball, Betrayed by Support
Eddie Collins Brainy Work
Features Series-Outwits
Great Hcinic Tim"

past and carromed off the right field
wall for three-bagger This fine hit
scored Rariden and Burns. Another hit
probably would have settled Faber, but
Benny Kauff very foolishly picked out
a ball that almost brushed him. His
lunge to hook II into the right field
stands resulted in rldiculously
measly foul to Gandil.
There was plenty of action. but lit
tie progress till Heine Zim and Robbie
spilled the beans in Chicago's fourth.
Eddie Collins singled, with two down,
in the first, but Jackson rolled weakly
20 Herzog. In New York's half, with
only one out, Herzog singled to centre
field Kauff swung az low lnshoot
and famed. Zimmerman lined 70 Jack
son.
In the second, after Benton whitfield
Felsch with curve after the count had
gone to three and two, Bob Gandil
poked a single into centre field. Her
zog made a grand stop that ruined a
base hit for Weaver. Zimmerman made
even more sensational play OF
Schalk's wicked jolt.
Schalk Makes Great Play
This same Schalk made a smart play
the second section of the panorama. He
. snatched up a spinner that would have
gone foul in another second and nailed
the batter at third from an awkward
position. Robertson hit half-heartedly
to E. Collins. Holke connected with q
fast one for a double TO left, Jackson
making a fine try as he bumped the
wall. Rariden, however, swung at the
first one and rolled weakly to Eddie
Collins.
Nobody got on in the third. Benton
famed Faber and McMullin. Faber re
turned the compliment 10 his rival II
was in the fourth that Zim broke loose
with a rashness hard TO believe. His
low throw put F.. Collins on second.
Robertson's muf of Jackson's easy
hoist sent Eddie to third. Then came
tho stupendous bone" OF Zimmerman,
already described in detail. After de
livering the pinch blow that scored
Jackson and Felsch,. Gsndil was caught
trying to stretch his single on Robert
sons fine throw TO Herzog. Weaver
fled to Burns. Schalk singled to left
and Faber drew a base on balls. j.
Collins was thrown out by Fletcher.
Fletcher scratched hit TO Weaver
in New York's half Of the fourth. But
two were already gone. Robertson
went after the first pitch, a curve, and
skied 10 Felsch Rube Benton got the
side in the fifth, Kauf making a
stylish catch of McMullin's hard hit
liner.
Big Chance in Fifth
Then in the ffth came New York's
one great chance. Holke struck out
on three pitched balls. Rarden and
Without both strolled after being in the
hole for two strikes. George Burns
offered at the first pitch, ball away
inside, and rolled 70 Weaver, whose
toss 10 L. Collins forced out Wilhoit.
Then Herzog placed a wicked line drive
into right field that got through J. Col
Inns for three bases. The hit scored
Rariden and Burns and put the Giants
on the heels OF their conquerors. IL
was the one occasion on which the
packed stadium had a chance 20 ex-
ercise its lung power. kauf ruined
the rally by trying FOX home run from
a pitch that almost hit him, the eX-
pected homer developing into a pop
foul 70 Gandil
Poi. Perrit, got off poorly by passing
Felsch in the sixth Rsriden, however,
/ helped out his battery mate when he
fooled Hap's attempted pilfer through a
fine peg to Fletcher Gandil whitfield
while Weaver rolled lszily to Herzog
In the second half Robertson got his
only hit Of the day. But two were out.
Holke rolled 10 Collins.
Bone BY Holke
A "boner" by Holke ruined a mighty
clever play on the part OF Herzog in
the seventh inning. Schslk wormed a
pass out of Perritt, but Poll frightened
and struck out Faber. Memo Leibold,
who had succeeded J. Collins. raised a
puny pop-up TO Herzog. When the lat
ter saw Leibold was not running out
the hit he trapped the ball. lie threw
% Ho!As IN plenty Of time for the lat