New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1917-11-29

Lnville. Henry r. Rosenblatt' Meyer
Davenport, I. Isabel hhoN' JhAoh =,
TapoI, G. NJ Smith, Anna VI.
Uudes Pauline $ Banks. Charles W. p.
ParelhofT. Bernard NJ opperman. Melvin {.
Mufson Thomas Kaufman. 5.
Walrath. Philip l.. Mason. Gabriel H.
RleumenthaI Frances Iut-. Alice
Cromnelin Edith a. Patterson, George W.
IindIof Johanna NJ Senet. VI.
kovar, Abraham j. Russell. Anna l.
Ieyene Harry Abbott, Mary
Jackson. Eugene Mayman, J. H.
Rosenberg. pobert w. Tropp. j. N.
Gutenberg, BENZ Oppenheim. Irene
Kahn Jeanette Davis. Mary 49,
Bludinger Israel Perman. Cyrils
Greenberg. Jacob Heller H.
Eaton Mary T. Covelio. v.
Perlstein. Philip Horowitz. b.
Buskin. n T. Delaney. Edward c.
Cohen, Beatrice Newman. Mrs. K
Schwartz. Bessie Schneer. A. Henry
Helpern. Edna Salzane' Francis
Luria. N, A. Cleaveland. Cornelia W,
Mirbeels NJ Cohen, David II.
Iicbterman r. Yokel Arthur
Ham. Charles Barasch. motifs
Newman Charles Krane, Daniel g.
Weinneimer Minnie Slnberg george
Horwitz. Benjamin HYDE Chas. W.
Berenberg David p. Rosenberg, Joseph
Mirsky Israel Newman.
Lefkowitz Abraham Smith Marion A.
Keller. Franklin J. Stark, Jennie s.
Bucbbinder Samuel Pemser. Henrietta
Jabonower. Joseph Kelly. Frank B
Glassberg. Benjamin : Works. Austin NJ.
Lester, JAY ID. kurZ, Mlcnhel
Schmalhausen. Samuel Samues. Ray
Thomas Harrison C. Lindemann. Elizabeth
Hochderfer Mary j. Greenfield. Nancy ;
Jacob A. Gertrude Wolfer. Gertrude
II has been decided by the informal COM
mittee having in charge the circulation Of this
protest that the names should appear on a
continuous sheet, since several copies con-
tanned bu' one TO two or three names Every
name appearing above was signed TO an den
tical protest, excep, one, which was written
in letter giving authority 10 sign.
(Sgned) HENRY R. LINVILLE,
Jamaica High School,
April 80, 1917. For the Committee).
1t will be observed that among those pres
ent are the three teachers who have been
suspended on charges of disloyalty and soon
will be tried-Samuel Schmalhausen, Thomas
Mufson and A. II. Schneer. Of the six teach
ers transferred to break up the evil commu-
r.cations that corrupt good teachers several
figure in the list of signers.
have interested myself in an effort TO as
certain how this document would be regarded
by parents, professional men, business men
and the man in the street Out of 1876 TO
whom it has been submitted up to date all
but three have declared in writing that they
regard the signers as dsloyal, that their in
huence in the public schools is harmful to
the young and that the best interests of the
school children of New York require that the
services Of those teachers should be dispensed
with.
Meanwhile it has been ascertained that two
Of the signers are loyal and have entered the
war service Of the government. and a third
has gone TO France as an ambulance driver
for reasons best Known to himself and not to
be stated here. 1t is believed that several
loyal teachers have been hoodwinked into
signing the protest, and II so ii is hoped that
they will take immediate steps to clear their
records Of the effects Of their associations
with men whose loyalty now is subject to in
vestigation.
DR.. Tildsley never had seen the protest un-
I'll n copy OF il was placed in hi hands last
Sunday night. VIM. T. H0RNADAY.
New York, Nov. rs, 1917.