The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1916-03-15

Justice Greenbaum last evening after he
had postponed his dinner 10 hear the
argument Of the two rival factions Of the
Ancient Order of Hibernians as to which
hold the annual ST. Fatrick's Day
parade IN this city o. Friday. lie will
make his decision to-day.
The " worlH "in America and q
valuable bit OF theatre property al l16th
street and Fifth avenue form the bone
OF contention. Both sides finally ad.
mitted this. although at first they tried
10 maintain that ,ncir argument was us
10 VINO shouii ne marshal Of the parade,
tn. permit was issued to tho Ancient
Order VI Hibernians. New York County,
by Police Commissioner Woods al Mayor
Mltchefs order. The Ancient Order Of
Hibernians IN America. New York
County. therc'pon applied for AN in
junction TO prevent the other faction,
which they assert is composed Of mon
suspended from the national organisa-
ton because OF non-paymcrt Of dues,
from using the permit for n parade. Az
application was also made for "A manda-
mus on Commissioned woode to issue the
regulars" a permit M cancel the FIRST
one.
Words 'ia America" the Basis.
The words 'in America" are the dis.
u~nguishing marks OF the two bodieA
The national organization contains them
In Its name and the 'outlaws'' omi.
them. It rs said. The property. owned by
.nS.u ols"",A'.1on osiore tne
- ~, !" We n,p'e 'ne supJec.
srn"u", pos' siues vene'e INA,
-. .,. .ne
.w,rs., ''N. 20 u..'u.ns u.o
. ,-,o rIn. =, ~ na: law
ertv wh0n the case IN triad
~. rn.nJ.a ~. 49, -
Tim HAL i"s,.r =, .s" 80, (" lily.
w.. lev 80. 49, w" "
s.w s,r.,, ,h.,r 49,. ." TO-
W. Roior,cr kann.,v nr..,a.n,
a., ~. ...m,..." No','., pIe~ue"'
pou.- r,r.Iia, a. a.Sn ~.
.a,,.I - .,'o."eS II" 81
w. nnm"u.n ~ H.. a..
49,. n" .Nr,a."en ms' ''H' vac
-" VI ''',n'a"s III H'nsI-
-. o'"u.u W 800 anu th"t 'he
Wv iorh county n''.s'on had neid a
'".a"e eNe'' .ear 1T 'nis Guy 'or se'.
enty years. Under u city ordinance OF
parado up,s.. com,,ai,, 4. r,ds
aSs,ns, tho ce,.h,.,,o, ,s ,ut..r,,
Tn. o,dir,,c. nroyid.s ,,a, a.. -.
..,t,.,tan ".ti i, -. - ~.
- .S,u ~
y.sis,on, Gt,v ra,ron ru,.a, I.m
800 - ~, 80 -, -,
~ wv 81. 49, ~.
~ "Ppsa'' e.ue",o'eu eNpt"'I no.
ms VIZ nut inpera''..' out Justice
riee"oau'" Cut nun S'o'' y. oeeiafink
,ha' soch was MS interpretation Oh the
Jaw.
MT Dohe!ian argued mai s'hoo the
ifeiy men mad oeen thrown our OF ,he
nationa! Organization they could NJ
longer represent the irish teoi'e n
that the duly accredited HioerniAns,
headed by Roderick Kennedy. known AS
the Ancient order OF hibtrhians IN
America. New YORK County. must get
the parade permit.
Mr.. OConrell argued that these sus-
pended men form tnc iocal society. tae
Ancient Order Of Hibernians. New York
County, which has heretofEe p~araded.
n that their standing with the national
body matters not. Furthermore. he ar.
gued. their suspension WAS Illegal and
will be invest igated at h coming con-
vention.
Justice Quisses Both SIDES.
.Ar, YOU In the Ancient Order OF
yt,hsrrians 4, America. or are YOU out
OF ity' demanded Justice ~Greenbaum.
"W.'re in IT," sfr. O'Connel, replied.
."rh,n WHY won't YOU march In the
name ~ the Ancient Order Of H.bernians
In America his Honor pursued.
I'VE wont" was All n. got.
Then he tried Mr.. Donellan.
."rhe permits OF mast Years hav. al
WAYS been made ou, TO the Ancient
Order OF H!bernlans, New York county.
w,thou, the words IN America" he
said.
THAT Was before these men were sus-
pended." said Mr.. pone,lan.
Then why won't you march with