The sun., 1916-01-06


are unable to bring themselves within
the catesories OF exemption under tne
pil, ana VINO therefore should De deemed
one recognized IN tho,r duty OF moral
ana national obligation In the hour OF
the greatest stress in our history7'
Loud protests inter,,ipted the reading
OF the hill, the Interruptions lasting sew.
eral minutes. The Premier spoke for
Hfty-fiye minutea
II IL impossible 10 predict tho fate
Of the btli. AithoueN its MASSAGE II
sImost assured, Il is certain that II will
sati.sv neither the com puj.,oui>t., who
6eIieve II ina {P1rleNt. nor the voIuntsv.
Ssts. Who. deterniseN on the ouestlou Of
vrtnelpIe. upboid the .Rritish birthright
n 1reeAcv., Ana o,pose every torn Of
ro.svi,,o.
The onno~,t,on VA, ,ed nv Sir John
si,,,on xrbo has inst res,pnad from, the
Cabinet a. Home Secretary. lie smoke
synwsd,.,e,v af,er pre,r,er Asou,,b al,
John de,,yered a .cathinp Arrangement
81 invd Derhv. rsnort Ills oppoaition
90. dire.,,ed NO, aV.ins, tho Coverp
want nea.urs' but ara,ns, the D.rbv
r.ruor, ,he ag,,roY ~ uvhich he d,rouncoi
=. on,,r.,, .rron.o,. ana n,i.i.adins
7, ,,,,. a, ,n.rn.c,.d sc.n. - see ,he
>,,-,,,sr I,,,,. Sa,ro,ary ,,h,, ,,. g., a.
a.. s...,.. -. -. ..,-, =, o,>o-a
a.. - ,no n.rh,. schonoa ,,,oio,,,,, ~.
s"na,n. -. o.n,,s,.,,
,Ns
Heseh' '"s'no~"on'
Hie attack stirred the House deeply
but Sir John based his arguments upon
apparently irretutab bic facts He held
the members attention throughout. Dur.
ing his entire speech no one left his seat.
Only when Sir John Simon said IL was
curious, to say the least, that Lord
Derby's total figure should end with four
nourhts was there n demonstration of
Aisapnroyai
The inslnuation was clearly resented
nv many t'ndis,,lrb.d with grea, logic
msrking his every word. sir John pro-
ceeded 10 tear tho Derby report 10 pieces.
lie exn,.ined that the total op,,re os
,hosa who hnd no, en,is,ea had beer on
,a,nsa hv a.ductiny tho n,phar N, ,hos.
vho eni,s,ed in Lord perhy.s scheme
snd,rv ,n Soysn,hsr fro,, tho total azure
snno,,ncsd by m. national ndminis,ra.
eIor In Auc,,s,
u. con,snded tina, M accoun, had bean
s.Lsn n, ,hs .rriy.I, n nd d.parture. dur-
,n~ ,hs ,b,ae months intery.ninp between
,h... ,u,o a,tes No attention bod h.or
n.ta ~ cha,ssa :, ,ho Zoe, ,,a, Tho
..ss,ra.,on d,a No, ,,.,ud. ,u ,r.n ,,iv.
- All. eo,,r,ry nb,,o ,hs Auy,,s, evura.
IA ,,o,,,da nrl.s,. ana ,hou..,d. a.,
~ ~, 1900 80 do ,r,ii,arv
80, -, ',,,,,n,. ,un.,,cs :. "a 80,
.r.a,.
e.. ,n aro,,,,,, ,.-or,,,or
- - Int, 90 s,,n,,or, ,.oa,,',,,'
eau ne as -
80 sa,nr,,,nad =, arn,.. a.,
~. ."a. -. .,. go.
W, 49, .o,,ra,. a..
w ' .',.i,,a, a. ,,a nsrh., :.
unan ..ose .,a.e ,o,a ~. '''
, =, y 80 ca, - ..,.Si,h
-, :, rov.r ,.,,i ! y.,,, ne ~. AS, 90
ah.y ~. ,.w ~, , ri," ,h. Uo,rn g..
r.tsry hos, duty i, Win he 70 enforce
a.. ~. ra.,.,, 40, ,',h,sS
al, nrnhiht, sr,,.nounu,s,n, ,aiL -. 4,
80 r.,,t, -, ,.,,,,n,,, ,a,L, -
- par,,,. 80, ,'r,,,,,,.n, .sa, l.,
~. 49,, ,aii.r,. i,.,,rs, 20 .h. .,,ach
-,h .n,,,,r,, ,,oo
Iohn R.J,rnnJ .,,ou,c.d ,b., tho
,,,.n n,r,, could ,n, survivor, Eve COW,
nn,.,o,, Mi
..,, IA, ,,,. 49, r...,, ro,,.. ,,., ,
s.,. -. .rnn,rca Eva. ,,,. nar,v .a-,o,
s'.. ~. ,,i,,.. "a ~ 1.s,onS
"Irs,s nj rsv,ra, ,h,. -, b., - IA
.ha .,,i -, -, ,n sa..r,.nn 90 - a..
a.d, a,a ,,,oc.ss,,,, ts.,,. Soho,,.
s.w.v.r ,a. shnvn ,S., ,his Vii, !:
nco.ssa,, so- 't,'. ,',,r,,osa pran,,a-
A.o,,t,. ,,,,,.,,, h.,.;,a a.,,,,a, 4, .,o .
.t,. .,.i A., ,. -
hs h.d s,t,.r h.,i.y. u,o 80. ,o'da,.
n,ora soidiar. ,b,p zoe c,r ,raip .on,n
ana nrovids yi,, ,,,ic.r,,,
John niIo, s.id
"vo ar. ,.t.d :, ,aon, con.,r,,,,,u
h,indfo,d h.c,usa ,he pr.,,i.r h.s h.sn
tran,,.d ,,,, n ,i.dg. n. .,,,as, -. -
hore ,i,.a, Th. T,,,I, 80 ,ha - a.
30, ,.cL 20 ,,., !, ii, ,,,h 80 t
hSat o,,,,,,,,,,i ,., i.,,a,i go. -,
S,,,,i o., ,,.t,ho,,, .,iti.r, ~,
So -, a...,h -, q, n,,,', - -. Wv" =,
.n -, W - W, ,'',I
lonS axo
step ought TO he 10 clear out tho War
Ofnce
bonar Law. coionial Secretary ana one
Of the leaders of the Ulster Unionists
said he believed the bill WAS necessary
TO win Tn. war
Three months ago, said he. IAN ca
animation o: the figures Of the men In
the army ana ot those Required convinced
number OF my colleagues that It was
no longer possible under the existing
system to get the necessary number OF
men to supply the army
The Premier added the Colonial
Secretary, is convinced that compuls'or
Is a matter Of national necessity. and II
the House decides tnsIt no national neees-
sity exists then the House must make ul
its mind that the war will have to be
finished without the assistance Of the
present Premier
J. H. Thomas Laborite member OF
the House, asserted that conscriptior
was repugnant to the workers, ana tha'