The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1916-01-23
JUDGES NEED HELP
TO PICK BEST DOG
Call In Referee at Jersey show
and He Gives Prize to
'Pert's Beauty.
DECISION WELL RECEIVED

A divergence ~ opinion among the
judges who were deciding which dog
was the best in the show caused no
little interest at the closing or the nrst
open match Of the recently organized
Hudson County Kennel club At Union
nm. \. j., Friday evening. All of the
winners i'm the various breeds were In
In. ring for this honor and the Judges,
Nessrs. Stokes. Lynch and Goodman.
eliminated all but Herbert l.uscomhs
Cocker spaniel bitch. I'crts Beauty :
i. g.. Able's wire FOX terrier, tone)o
Duchess. and Mrs. william &. Thonp-
sons Yorkshire terrier. Champion ST
Wilfred's King. .
When II came to deciding the best OF
these three, however. the Judges couln
not agree. and after many arguments
among themselves rs to the relative
merits of each they had to cav II
referee to help them decide this mo-
mentous question. Al>a Rosenberg was
selected from the talent AT the ring
side. and after he had given the three
Judges his opinion the Cocker spaillel
received the trophy. reserve gong 70
the Yorkshire terrier. TINS decision met
with the approval OF thoS" at the ring
side. AZ rert's Beauty is an unusual
Cocker bitch. She Is particularly good IN
neck and shoulders. has tremendous rln'
4, ~rrofuse coat. wonderful quarters, a
good head, and the only fault that
those who want 10 he hypcrcritical can
and with her Is that she might he a
trife shorter Of back.
Th reserve winner, ST. wired s klng,
IL a remarkable Yorkie and has been
a big winner at recent Die ehows' lie
won as the best toy In the show. best
terrier and best transporting dog, his
owner taking home a number OF hand-
some trophies.
]. II. Able had a trio 81 good fox ter
| riers entered and was successful with
| them. Conejo Duchess won the special
| going to the best fox terrier, and OK
ford Sure shot the cup for best novice
terrier of any breed.
The show was a marked success and
al, of the classes filled well. James
Anderson had a fine lot Of settlers 10
pass on, there being no less than hf'"en
shooting dogs entered. several or them
1 Of good quality. The outstanding dog "t
the lot was the bitch Jersey Belle. owned
hy Frank Jack. She has u"ver been on
the bench hcfnrs. her activities being
| confined to the field. hut her owner was
so elated with her success that he prom
lseS tn bring her out AZ some or the
| coming big shows. She wOu tn" Cup for
best setter and was the recipient or
many fattering remarks from those who
admire "A good setter,
In ecker spsnieiS "A blue roam puppy
shown by l.. Rees caused q stir and she
promises to make up INTO a good one.
Rest of the lot was easy for Fert's
Beauty, an unusually good one all over,
A big entry of French bulldogs and
Boston terriers greeted Judge julius
Eangmann. In the former breed Fred
erick Poffet'S ,amin Rivals Son VIZ.
with Hugo of lIaworth reserve. The
winner scored in fureface and bone, Mrs.
s. G. Reynolds's Duke Pourquoi Pas,
Il good sound dark brindle. was another
Frcnchy Of merit. I'm BostonS j. j. Bar
rett's Highhall's Sensation met nothing
to contend seriously with him for win
ners, Charles c~onstantine's kinky bein.
the runner up. best Boston bitch was
Louis ROdc'S Dina, which was placed
reserve to Highball's Sensation for best
Boston in the show,
\ number of high class i~omcranians
made interesting judging In that breed,
Winners dogs Was Swiss Mountain Ken.
nel's Banner Sable l.a1dio and best OF
The opposite sex Miss Elsie Hydon's
Atom Pumpkin, u high class little bitten
which heretofore has hurt her chances
for winning by not showing. She seems
to have overcome her timidity and or
this occasion showed in the ring like q
veteran. The awards
Airedalo Tcrriers-Judge Thomas Lynch
Winners dogs, i. r., Colburn's Mike Oorang
winners bitches, Heathcote Kennels
Heathcote Patricia; reserve, Andrew
Spott's Jr's Regalia Cav cav.
Bullterriers-Judge, Thomas Lynch
winners dogs, Harry A. Karr's Penrod
winners bitches, Andrew Spott's Elm
Court Tommy Flyer III.
Fox Terriers Judge, Thomas Lynch
winners dogs and bitches ,smooth haired)
Heathcoate Kennels iieathcote Sands
park. reserve, Emil Pctcrs's Duchess.
Fox Terriers-Winners logs and bitche
1wire hHiredt, j. u Ablc's Comet
Duchess; reserve. same owners Oxfor,
Sure shot.
Irish Terriers--Judge. Thomas Lynch
Winners dogs, c. Cregan's u.
scottish Terrisrs-Judge Thomas Lynch
Winners dogs. Boyden Kennels NcWcas
tie Peeler,
French Bulldogs-Judgc. julius Fang
mann-Winners dogs. Frederick Ponet,
Gamins Rivals Son: reserve. Haworth Ksn