The sun., 1916-11-18
APPELLATE COURT DECISIONS.
complete List Handed Down b,
First Department Divi.,ov.

First Department Division.
n Following decisions were handed
down yesterday by the Appellate hi.
vision. First Department.
wi,.,sm FieItmar; su!ns &c. re.
as appealed from reversed with slo eo.ts
and disbursements and motion granted
with VIZ costs to the extent stated In opin.
a oya., Up,n,on by Mclaughlin J. Settle
Joseph :. Lesser. respondent, vs.. Inter.
der rsS.r .sa'' and 3D. v ct &c., a aiS,s,ss. v 81;
Costs 10 appellant. Opinion by Page. j.
John $. Melcher. respondent. vs.. Tn.
Ocean Accident 4 Guarantee Corporation.
Ltd.. appellant. judgment and order re-
versed with costs and the complaint dis
missed with costs. opinion by Laushiin.
Max schwartz. respondent. vs.. Santiago
termination Of. Appellate Term reversed
Win costs; judgment. OF City Court re-
yersed With costs and Judgment directed
Diminishing the complaint on the meri,s
with costs. Opinion by Laushlin. J. Set
Bruno. appellant, Judgment and order
f'versed and new trial granted. Opinion
= smith: J. CLARKE, u. and Scott. j"
dissenting Seize order on notice.
Luke V. Lockwood as executor. &c. re-
.pondent W y; y; Life INSURANCE Co.
and complaint dismissed upon the merits
with costs. Opinions BY Clarke. p. j.. and
smith. J. tsn!th. J.. dissentinG.) Settle
Joseph De sme,. respondent. vs.. Julian
p. Niles. appellant: Judgment and order
missed with costs. Opinion b, Page. j.
Order nled.
n, william !, , sssIrs, .:.DonssG', Us. , JOB.
m.nt and order reversed and new trial
ordered with costs TO appellant to abide
s s.sGi:, Dn 'a iAl p'. aunt Of s'i EscS; 70 to r ssiss
event the judgment, rs so reduced and the
order appealed from are ar!Tmsd Without
Ing and Voting for reversal and new trial.
settle order on notice.
Matthew A., Kane e. al. res 'ondents, or
der affirmed wish $40 costs disburse-
,insniaI Insurance. Co., appellant, Judg-
ment affirmed with costs. opinion BY
Louis y. L,eberman ct al. respondents.
W.. Graf Realty Holding Co.. Inc, appel:
liant Jpdgnsn, and order reversed and
to abide vent. opinion BY Scott. J. Or
der hied so r.,nor,sr,, :, v,o
Chieca and Louis chieca. appellants. Judg-
ment anormed. No opinion. order filed.
Fr sS,, d,se' Co a" i ins.ai s,p Ssfiii r.'D0I 1Ias:
ment and order affirmed. with costs. No
opinion. Order Med.
The People, &e,i respondent. vs. Lus.o
w. $ss;S,. S !; $;i: :; 4. Fem s::.s sJgss;,an,;;; as Ss:
mcnt and order affirmed, with costs. No
opinion, order nied.
souri. Kansas a Texas Railway Company.
appellant. Judgment affirmed. with costs.
no opinion. order hled.
appellant. judgment affirmed. with costs.
No opinion. order filed.
MS sosn p Z son. ap rs,Psnae" J'ud xs and d
order affirmed. with costs No opinion.
In tho matter Of Frank Leslie. &c. Order
Affirmed. with 80 costs and disbursenents
TO each respondent appearing and eng u
brief herein. opinion by Scott, J. Order
Hannah n. Eiser. responder, vs., John
n; B. Boyis :, a., :ppeii.n's; impisaded
Judgment affirmed. with costs. against APP
pellant John II. u. Boyle individually. No
pemsrest Co, respondent: Judgment
affirmed. with costs. No opinion. Order
len. Wolf. az .dmln,,tr.,rix; rsspon-
'mpleaded. &c. appellant. Judgment and
ot sii.aSeth Valentine. appellant. VS.. Jno.
.r,rm.a'' wi,S so Gosh. and disSar.ement..
No opinion. order Med.
nS SsSrs !, k e. spp re- nSps'H,jj uS IL rE'" ans
order reversed and new trial ordered. with
costs 10 appellant to abide event: Opinion
by Scott oLauEhlin' j. dissenting
Michael 'o'conneii. respondent. VS.. Jacob
4 YounEs. Inc. appellant. Judgment ana
order affirmed. with costs NO opinion
Eva j, sla,ter. Al. sdmlnistratrix. &c.
, ,on RIssr \. N : f cSmp SfS. appei nS%.
Judgment and order affirmed. with costs.
No opinion. Oder Med: .o,,.,,. =.
Aa An.pssa s D'f Hashs. .ssi o., sppslian,:;
Judgment r.v.r.:d and juasmsn, directed
e 1IvS Snon Of ,S ssf m.li,.' w h's" cost. in 'e sni.
sS1I Scott ss' .n q r. F.s; So? j. asss.. J." dis
trail Consumer. Wine s Liquor co: re-,
..:ps%S:n'. S; n:m j. M' i%S dIS:, sons n.
aimed with costs. No opinion Order
s. sssi RRl'''RSiIs s:. g. sSs.,r .;'D'"iS .pi..a .,i
spondsnts. Order modified as statsi in
onInton and as modified affirmed WI. hout
costs. Opinion per curiam' Settle order
same vs., same, Appeal dismissed with
oT %iIlia% a. u!man, appellant. vs.. Meaor.
Hudson Rst,sJ. respondent. order reversed
t Min denied with 80 costa and the war;
rant rsins,stsd, Opinion per curtain.
o'Xn. Paekags Grocery Stores Co.. Inc.
spneils nj, vs.. Hugh McAtamnsy. respond:
snt. order reversed With w costs and
costs. Opinion by Scott. J. Settle order
on osism Scot. Company. appellant. vs.,
yspssd with 80 costs and disbursement
ana motion for temporary Injunction
orasr on %S" J sidney bernstein. an at
tornsy.' Procesdlns dismissed. Settle order
Matter Of GEORGE Y, Smith. an attorney.
Motion granted. Settle order or notics
u W:,.'s srs csrss"'s Order isi.st. Co.
iEstSsn Berger. "; Ns.isc.i Arshi;