The sun., 1916-12-02
APPELLATE COURT DECISIONS.
Complete List Handed Down BY
First Department Division.

down yesterday by The Appellate d.
vision, First Department
Elizabeth Marker, rs administrators. &c.
respondent. vs.. Long Island Railroad Go
aud new trial ordered with costs to ap.
pellant to abide event. Opinion per cur
and voting for anirmsncc., osder nled.
Same vs.. same. order reversed and mo-
LauEhlin. J. ,Dowiins. j. dissenting
Anna Peterson. respondent. vs.. George
D.. EiGhmic. appellant. Judgment ami
order, reversed. new trial ordered. costs 30
appellant to abide event. opinion by
People ss rel. ssmu.i rloersheimcr. 70.
spondent. W. Lawson Purdy 81 al. ~ com
m issioners ttsSss. 1914: taxes, l.lsp. dp-
and disbursement in each case and mo.
tons granted with costs In each case.
2pi".TGn n ~ sSS,. and d PSsr'n sei d. 'p0"''
.pondent, ". lawson Furdy :; al. IS com;
with siO costs and disbursements ana wri,
dismissed with costs: opinion oy. scott
and Dow;ins II. 'pO~lins, j.. dissent
Giuseppe Tu1.ec suing; &c, rsspondent.
vs.. American building co; OF Baltimore,
In opinion. and as modiaed AFFIRMED. vim
$1,000 fund; Opinion by bowling. J.
dent. &c, plaintiff. Va. Joseph q, Robin 81
al. defendant, Tho'nas k"l,y AND sno'her,
spondents. Judgment affirmed with cost.
. rsspondentS against appellants opinion
Elizabeth X Sanford and another,
plaintiffs, Ns BronN Bore Iiuildcre, Inc.
a:tendsn,s; JGdsmcn, ord'rSd for p.o'I-
settle order on notice. go,
Catherine Thompson. appellant. ". M
nois surety CO., respondent. Judgment te-
Nsrset new trial ordered. costs To npIp4=
liant TO abide event. opinion by Laughlin.
J. order hled.
der reversed with costs to appellant 20
abide event and matter referred TO official
referee. opinion by Dowilns, j. Settle
Marlin l. s,iner and another, appel.
lants. vs.. Tennessee copper. Co, rcspon,
dent. order reversed with SO costs ANA
d. bursements and motion denied With So
costs and attachment reinsta'cd. opinion
by Lsughiin. J. order Med.
The same ~. the same, same W same.
Same Us. ZANE. Orders reversed with slo
costs and disbursements and motions de-
MED with $40 costs and attachments re-
instatcd. opinion per curtain, orders
People es rel. A. Baird & Sons. rcspon'
d.nt..Ns william 4. PropdrrsH-t ~ 'oiup-
troller, appellant. order modified n stated
in opinion and as modified affirmed with
out costs, Opinion per cur'am. settle
Adolf Goiis,ein, respondent, -. Ellen ',
Dullsrd. appellant. order reversed with
$40 costs Anl disbursements ann motion
| denied WITH SO costs ana BIZ OF cost. as
taxed re'nststed. opinion by rage j.
order MED.
Joseph Naughton and another, respondents.
order reversed with 80 costs and diShurs"'
inents and motion dcn.ied with go, costs.
Opinion by I.aughlln. j. orjer iIod,
Nrchibaia : WHITE. respondent, ". A..
thur Is i.nayh ct a. nrr'''.usi S''s'
Rawson l.. Wood ct al. respondents, ".
Josiah NJ. fiske 81 AL spp"'''nls In"s
men, affirmed with costs opinion by
Ieoncilo valenti, an infant So, spn"I-
liant, vs., Henry Mtslnser' 81. al, rei,p2n'
! men, and order in each cas-" reversed aud
new ,risis ordered Win costs to npPrusn,'
Hogsson srothers, appellant, Vs.. Frank
,, spisksrman respondent, 'nHsm"n. re,
appelian, to abide event. opinion by
Davis, j. order nlcd.
Morris syrkin, rc,spondeni vs. Twins
Kcsnrr ct al, appellants. lnds mont re-
verscd and complaint dismissed with costs
to the sppeilant. opinion by bowling, J,
Edith Mssee, respondent. ys. Horace ".
costs and complaint dismissed With costs,
In tho matter. OF Thomas Mcnonongh,
appellant. vs., New Amst'rdam Casualty
Co. respondent. Deere" reversed wi !
i'FAF " ''<
proceeding RENTED to Surrogate Court,
Opinion by bowling, \. order Med.
In the nPtier 1T John r Nann"ck, de
ceased. order reversed with costs to tho
Comptroller and matter RENTED to sur
~rogaies Court, Opinion by Page. !. order
hled.
Johnston Heating co, respondent, vs.
Board Of Education, North Hampstead Sc,
appellant. judgment and order reversed
with costs and complaint dismissed with
costs Opinion by Davis, !. order hled.
william J.. fongEman. appellant vs.
Judgment affirmed with costs, Opinion
by Scott. J, Settle order on notice.
Alexander Deutsch, appellant, vs., Rob.
ert Hoe Estate 60, respondent, Judg,
ment affirmed with costs. Opinions Ivy
Page and Scott, il. 'scott. j, dissenting
Florence $, Fi,hian, respondent. VS.. Deg
non CONTRACTING Co, appellant, Deter
mination' OF Appellate Term and iudEment
and order OF city Court reversed and
complaint dismissed with costs In all
courts opinion by Davis, J, Settle order
on notice,
Minnie u. Pearson, appellant W.. Henry
Pearson, rsspondcni, order affirmed. NJ
The e. " vcnner CO. appellant. vs..
southern Hallway "a. respondent. Judg
ment and order affirmed with costs. NJ
opinion, order filed.
lsnt., vs. Annie V, Elkema 4 a]noti,or.
respondents. Judsmtnt snirmed Win
a, II. :Ss. Order filed. 49,
The People, &c, respondent, W A..
mour company, sppe'isnt. Judgement az
nue.. order affirmed With 80 costs and