New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1915-09-02
@'Wg-The-z7a
& :x,Ad!% ! ~ + +
Conducted by Samuel Hopkins Adams.

department, devoted separating the sheep of
advertising from tSe sossssnd hanging bell the goats
II deal, With very topic serious
Its honest sndeavor will be with fairness, either
prin, where that ine.pcdient by letter all fair
while reserving the right plead
when TINT the right 1t asks nothing for its
service. the confidence of correspondents giving
their .sndsdd will be
lated Please clearly whether prefer TO have
withheld printed communication,
will be Address. Advisor The Tribune New York
your Advisor column IN The New York Tribune Of today is
eTcepton advertisement Zegeld
Tribune incidentally zsfd Tolues lis only
who & a. .. .1 s % from &c " B asss
Places you SSGsP 'enSara s Of printing What is meant
a aq omitted %'4 for rSasoDs explained below
Theatre Which advertised a. the sooies ea in the World
dseinS cities and beeEc With countless others that the New Am
ds% il a.taGd 591e claim At " times this beautiful thea
o5s, r. % j ssa5. =. ps sss, fair & sa
would S SSs ;'1 KNOW 6S' | S9i'esS
Amsterdam Theatre has the zegfed FQies o>
Business Manager ziegfeld FOlle New merd
c. SIS criticism against reckless of The
uperlatve advertisements Mr. Harrisons
ducton praises highly and doubtless con-
enou The ater encomiums very well have been left in
his letter instead Of being buepencied had he CARRIED
c. B. Ss letter to make peg B. s. actually said
that - .tber theatrical claim Of greatest success New
true great production only moderate
$3.50 ~ ~ -, NJ risn,s attention Is paicularlv directed
Obviously couldn't both be right claiming the super
aive Further Amsterdam proclaimed itself the
coolest world manfestly guework at best Hence
Is. y
c. B. objects the most successfu Mr. Harrison
reo in substance and exceptionally successful
which matter other performances
NAV also be exceptionally successful c. B. S eritcses the coolest
Of the Amsterdam Mr. Harrison replies
that the delightfully."- comfortable SO other theatres
ground Mr. Harrison powerful and convincing peader
lint his ground not B. think that he will hardly
though he have convinced himself
And bv the way hide his identity under his
initials Had his anonymous would have fueed down TO
Advisory wastebaket Mr. Harrison have the
m Meantime venture TO call to his at
correspondents fact that the ordinary
rules Of controversy apply to this column The hr rule courtesy 1"
ones adversary
The Advisor has pointed out the singular e
Of the OF MI
Of number newspapers and magazines Edoray Mr. Hearst
advertising he
eepest Inevitably good Mr. Hearst and the bad Mr. Hearst
conflict at times thereby ahodng spectaCie paul te
ds celebrating the ungOdy For example here are ree
exhibits Of HearstineSs =, ,,., ,.; 4o
Exhibit A-The notice the good Mr. Eearst advertising rate
ments" -. A.. az. ~
ce tvp fraud the good Mr. HearSts good maya
Good Housekeeping -,
Exhibit letter from Paul E. Wilkes the bad Mr. HearstS
the proprietor of Get Sim denounced
as fake by good M Hearst urging that Get Slim advertise IN
the bad Mr. Hearst's very bad Sunday American
0nerWben in bright Hearst is fake advertise
ment not objectionable?
Answer-When pay the Hearst price