New-York tribune., 1915-09-22
Citizens Union Comments
on Manhattan and
Bronx Members.
SOME KIND WORDS
FOR REPUBLICANS
Bill AbOlishing COrOner's once
Carries Great Weight in
Report on Records.


AssemLlymen on the bill abolishlng
the Office Of Coroner and on the bill
weakening the building regulations IN
the report Of the committee on legis-
lation Of the Citizens Union concern
ing the work o. ne members from
Manhattan and The Bronx. This re-
port. made public last night. has some
kind words 20 say Of all seven Repub-
Lean members and HnGs more than
usual Of good in the records OF the
Democrats. although some Of them are
credited with poor record of votes
The phrase voted TO abolish the
Office Of Coroner and otherwise made a
good record OF votes Is frequently
used. Those voting tor the building
regulations bill were censured
Assemblyman FRANCIS p. Stoddard.
Republican, OF the 18th District, IS
called Intelligent and capable KIND
words are given to Alfred +. Smith.
Democrat OF him it said he is "intelli-
gent and capable" The individual rec
ords as given follow:
AuA%uW Frs.k upcm. 10h District. New
member ot one aGii spI1,Gi,,J Loc1~ oi'
%,,'"ei"1s rst1,+,,O' ,d,e "' '''''''1
Biu' H. Nau.ce Dem -1d DEno Ne" bagl, mfi
:o-n' r drugs supported Lockwood bill. Record
o.. yg;o- roor olro'ed ao2.i,hms coronst, .
EolRhL. Mart" hep. l'th pllrlc,l ,N Ne" n'9in
eer; fJr ,arpor O; lockwood bin record of votes
az =, ~, ,..h n,.,ri.,,
CALLAHAN: Joseph Dem a'ln ~ -. !, .
poor opposed abolishing coroner Supported
IOc:r cod bil.
CAMPBELL Jane. {. Dem llih District IN
,oarh :r of ,er' Ksq' ofoo1 %, ,%,si f ni p ad
coTKIIvG Howard Rep 2e,h District. con.
scicuticus and pansiskug legislator hc'of' o.
votes good ..... ,n.n, os,, n,.,,,.,, In.
troiuced Objectionable bis Voted to i abolish 5o,
caloner' and Otherwise made goGd Tecqra sv
member. i Introduced bin hostile to civil service
opposed ab"li'hing ''t"ne' '"' '.'''"'' ''''
D0N0HIE Charles y. Dem: 9th Districtl. sup
ported Lockwood Dill voted 10 aOo''" 'o'0"''''
DONOvAN. Dennis G, Dem. 3oth District >eS Ne"
member Failed 10 show any value a. a lesl''a'or.
aud usefui member Fathcred bill 70 abolish ,i,,I
nuisance of tracks al grade OF Nes' Nde elu "ii,
10 deprive Snern oi Ices. hhSpI ICY 'o' '"''''' VI
member. Supported lockwood blI ana @ppoSsu
abolishing coroners. Otherwise fecoid "' 'o'e'
good n o.. D,.,,,r x.,,
member opposed lockwood bill Record Of votes
good ,,-, m o,h n,s,-,cr Now
member. supported Lockwood bill. other'i'c
FRlEDLAND. Walter ~ Dem. lolh ., pis,rs, I.o;,,{
ness go. ,,.,-,.., ,o,,,,
GOLDBERG Mark tDem., lsih DiSnlCJ, n,ll',I ~
and perseyerlng lntf0iu,eu sOlue III d n,be,
legislation. Voted 10 abolish coronefs anu othe'
wise made good record Of votes n,..,.., vo,.d 3,
abolish coroners. Record Of vote IN Assembly
good; In cities tommitlee ,s nit,c Inersc
hEHRlGAN Sohh ,,; ,Dsa,; g., vote sesin.t shoiish
tive ana tetDo'e Ht'vp, ~ ~. 0 oo'd
ing roIoners recu,1 =" te- III Dts,rict, All %
hikhNAN IN" IN. introdurei objectlonabIe specia
bills. opposed aboi'hins coro"rr' he'o'' D
votes poor ,,. ,ner "a Dis,rtctl New
MARASCO. Carmine J. DEM 90 al usc,,d M
member. supported LOCKWOOD oi"- "'
,C,S Wre "St ,s.,,, q fnem 10th District. Esrnes
ard effective sdtocAIe o' oJ .i,,, ahoIishine coro.
ported Lockwood ollli Vyp,es Vype1 1,ir
ne,<>. net,<> A. vsu,,re tDem ith District. New
Henber; inIV,u,,H ,,H Supnorted lockwood bill.
ie'tionable l0cSl uil ,.t and otherwise made
opposed sbolishlng eoIo"''' "
bad record oi tof,. - ,D,ro 9Th District Op-
MELLlGoLi ,,,.r. Is'eI Recori of votes poor.
poSed aoo,ishihS r''VIS Inem ggd District New
MILLER. hsm hsmd,,ol ~; I"-kuood bill Record OF
3 yn,ss moor ,, ~.