New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1915-05-02
WALDO'S man LEADS
POLICE LIST AGAIN
Lieut.. Enright and l66
Others Qualify for Pro-
motion to Captaincy.
COMMISSIONER WOODS
SENT HIM TO DESK
Haerle. Honor Man, and Honest
Dan" CoStigan Pass
Examination.

Henry Moskowitz, president OF the
Civil Service Commission, announced
Yesterday that 167 of the 1886 police
usutenants who entered the examina-
.ioD FOR promotion 10 the rank of cap
tain have qualified. The list is headed
nv Lieutenant Richard +. Enright'
president Of the Police Lieutenants'
Benevolent Association.
Enright has not enjoyed under
Woods the high favor in which he was
held by former Commissioner Waldo
In N.aldo's administration he was Of
teisllv designated as in charge Of the
Bnreau Of Repairs and Supplies, but
xss the man Waldo depended on for
advice and was often consulted by
Mayor Gaynor.
Waldo made desperate efforts to ap-
,oirt Enr;kht a captain, but his exit
from the commissionerShip occurred
and Dick Enright remained a heuten-
ant. -.
..rsrts' dinner in the Waldorf at the
time that the inspectors indicted IN
tLs Harlem graft scandal were awaiting
trial. and the organization OF which
Tnright was the head was criticised for
;,vitinq the inspectors TO the afalr'
when Mayor Mitchell was elected En-
,igbt gave Up hope Of being advanced.
Shorty after the appointment OF
Ar.bur Woods as Commissioner the ex-
nected happened, and Enright was sent
n desk duty in Flatbush. Now the
Members of the department are won
dsrinp what Woods will do. If he feels
ca inclined the Commissioner can pass
over Enright in making promotions.
This is the third time that Enrlght
has been on the eligible list.
Another interesting case facing
Woods is Lieutenant Joe O'Connor, who
headed the last list, and is well up on
the new list. O'Connor was dismissed
from the department in 1912. lie was
rsinstated in 1918 by the Appellate Dl-
vision. but in the meantime had opened
cabaret and restaurant IN the len
derloin. which was raided. O'Connor
was placed al the head Of the list when
rsinstated. but Waldo appointed seven
canfsins without making" him.
lieutenant Honest Dan" Cosugan
;s .bir+v-ffth on he list. i is GER
tainty that as soon as he can be reacned
Commissioner Woods will appoint him.
George Haerle, the crack shot OF the
department. who shot and killed man
after the man had murdered Detective
Gusrnieri. is ffty-one on the list.
Lieutenant Thomas J. Tunney, VINO
figured prominently in the arrest OF
The anarchists in the st. Patrick 5
Cathedral bomb plot, is seventh on the
list. Edward +. McNally, who has been
on desk dutv on the central detective
desk at Headquarters for some time, Is
second on the list
The following is the list of those who
attained a percentage Of 50 or oetter'
E.1rs, 500. McNauy. SO 20; Thomas v yndeNr-
nm q -. Charles =. Norhruq IS W .-, byuls =
T1rSsy SIS. Maurice Haunou. $50; James j.
Wal S, 30 Walter EAuse. $50 C4ar,es -. HeSG'
$50. J1lu Kelly. N..96; Elwsrd j. Dflihpseg'
SIT jeremiah Butler $40 C44Ies - IyI rHl'i'
s,stett 81 s6- Edwin H. West. S7.2j: Thomas
MD9aa'd s. 10. Richard Gry. s. Michael X
Ksij. % g1, George keuf, 500 FeT.y Du e-lI
Thomas N-Cui-e S. o. lanes shaw. sSS.99SS:
Thomas T. Walsh. So -; Michael Lyons. So ;
George ]. sullivan 500 5gsaph ACSHai S...,'
Ue-. Holm Duane Sc %. Philip Cirord. $50
Charles Zanes 50 u. james + Mu4igan. - -
samuel Bolton. sslo. William Bauer: a-Ie WI
Rsnfts IS SO. james McCau.ey. s. s.; Fred W.
Holm Sc s.. Louis Rochester. t55&, ] fuI'"
Braiy $40. Benjamin Austin. $40: Thomes
NaskeE SO; IoseF49 Lo9n1a1 :, 40 Geo.
BusbJ. s. 30. Joseph OConnor. Sa-.l' Muiity =.
Ws,zsostr y O.. william Morhsn 50 o., Patrick
Joyce E.o7. william Il. Gilhooley. IS; John l.