Tulsa daily world. [volume] (Tulsa, Indian Territory [Okla.]) 1905-1919, 1915-03-10
Senate To Discuss
Cases In Secret


mont ~ tie .o'" in open c".i' w'''
Austin. E.A.mnr. hiot'l. I;hssI"'
game. Ey,tuor. Hartford. Cur'Hn.
Davidson ~ TU',a, Davidson IL NUS
kogcc. Edwards Hickman. Hsliam.
Logan McAlcst,r, Mcintosh. Me
Mochan Mitchell O'Neill Thomas
. WutrluS. and Wilson =: ElU,dltu.
Those who voted ~ favor ~ ~.
!! .nruu,'m"u; ui IA" vote ~ "r"n court
w,r" Jarrett. tta:" "i Seminole,
tNls" "E E"watl. Chn'. Go'!"N.
Davis, EIu"ns"n. l.cIis. Fr,nklin
lugh Russell E'ar. SHAW. Su'h're
tn. Tu,k'r and wilson Of Dewey.
Senator shaw mao" objection I" IA"
provision for an executive session fer
discussion and N"'" GA II, MuL.ur"
Is 'u' >'Ni'" a., u count =: iNrcdch.
.u.n' senator HGrfnrd pointed - N"
practice ot courts holding secret sc,-
..u's ;"r '"nIor'uc" On their opinions
h"i'I" handing them down.
Wants Proceedings Open.
senator Tucker said ho wanted III"
tWhul, proceedings up'u. He said hc
wanted any member ~ m" court per-
i'i''.d Z" sh"w how h" voted "n aUv
..ouHr IN am Impeachment proceed
.up,. ~ .u ar" 'r.HClnG "n InUriG
.dargci.Us ground IN thus arranging
80 shoot "a man from "mrush.' Ii"
said. 'lf . man ever jid ~" a wrong
that Justified IL and nh1 t" XII him
would want him :" know before he
died that had ilicd him Ii an Of
!.cihl of th!. state does - wrong ihinE
for which u" should l." removed from
office | want him aud an the people
u' ~" stat. To- know thar helped I"
T.moy" him from U'ir". IL h." lie
Ct'|..'l accused I N.,If him and d.
cgNbody IN ~" stat" I" know that ]
voted 90 Hc.uH him"
Senator Suth.rIIU said that each
I"'' q; every senator Oh each count
UE every charge ought to hc mad"
fully public ~ ~. record at the sen
Al" as = court. II" said that there IL
No pr.rcdcn; IN the world for secrecy
~ such matters-thut m" constitution
con'cmr'I'es publicity for IN" N"t" III
- provision that a conviction shall
=" had only hy iw"-thi,!S No'" of
~" senators present. let III" world
/, turw what We are doing" said the
WtGouor senator. I'VE may d"lIhrr-
, AZ" III secret If We wish, hUf tn"
record should l." open IL tn" pC"pl"
as in how We may Vot" ~ thos" i'm.
, '",chmont eases. There * not u
s,nglc precedent IN the world for III.
secrecy that j. suggested You have
=, ..,,,,,. Y.,,h ~, ,',,.,I,,,,''',.
s,,',., I|r,.,, ,,,,.,I ,',I'r,, E,
,,,,,,r r,,,rL II. r,frr,.I :, ~"
! vote ~ the Impeachment "f rr'si-
dent johnson. II" told uf other cases
, ana cited the practice uf III" former
Impeachment proceedings ~ this
state under IL" constitution.
Senator fdm"us"n ut Chandler said
,tlai u, wol.ll have To- N.;. ,eaius; ;h.
oil e.! ,ts passage !; II contained the
l secrecy provision '"rNn year, alu,"
,, D." continued. with ~" accused be-.
:Ug" NE a'4 Ms Wii" directly IN front
oi WS d,~t. | ar"," ~ my lllc" Iih"
a mtT and voted guilty. II t. an
insult {" tn's hody - cumrar" Il T."
i pet: ~ -'a'i iuGy. Us ht. been
dove. W" ought :" l." IL III" open.
4 '.i- matter, ass pr'c' lent and the
constitution provide"
several "'h'i senators discussed
the provision u caused much ~.
i'i' ana the L'"Ii" Wa straight ana
pointed.
>, OBJECT Ia Mileage"
In another part Of tn. hil' ~. "A
provision. that senators, shall u, en-.
,'.al 1. their mileage Thi. MS
Objectionable ;o hut a few senators
Senator wilson of canadian pointed
: "u' that the scrat. is here now and
~" provisions "i me h'l "f" 1" III"
f, 'I''' 'h'' 'h'N WIZ Always u" ~
session "n'h 'ni''"'hin'ni proceed
''..' axe h'tHh ana moved thit the
: -" "'''" "i ni!'ds" h' stricken
from ~" hii 'n III" ground that
'N'i" would hr ." 'f,V'! incurred II
getting - Tho Impeachment pre-.
'.,.j.u'. H." had hr' few support
81. - H.. protest and IN. ril. was
: ;Assai permitting the senator's anil
'h.ls" mauarprs f. ,"ll,,, m.i.a."
: TOR the .mr,a,h'u.rt courts. Under
. ~. ,N ,.,. ....,t. 49,. >. /. ,~..,n.
I'D ytf'. .re. Iee.a',.r,. =. ~ .,..
. ,,.,, ana -ay hold .r,, .1',.,,.
,y.,,. 81 ~. ,rri.l8,u,..
' ,Lss I,s,, i.,,.,, ,.,,,,r ,.,,,.
-, .,..