New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1915-05-11
Court Admits Most OF Evil
dence of an Alliance
with Murphy.
OFFENCE ENDS
IT'S TESTIMONY
Plaintiff Expected TO Call His
First Witness Against Roose-
Welt To- day.

Wf G.. Le 'f.t4a.tN'+ '"rN S"I"."NI' a.
.aa,t o. kinder shape to-day. Touched
By che philosophers stone Of Justice
Andrew. ., may traasmo;e into cues
tons O.. TACT to- Che libel SUIT jury
mach o. t-' pt'-"ooseVe.t testimony
Which .s a.v molten ana unstable
Shading '.e meaning Of the word as
Henry }. "o.1' 81 NJ. Barnes ooun-
SELL proceeded "',n ms motions 10
strike or testimony 10Y me defence
Justice Andrews Die upon 4mpropn-
ETY. Ne implication OF pe'Hn'ary gam
vas cor'-..ei d" the "o'I corruption
s. Do We've. II. and j. an improper
alliance s..-cd 30 was sufficient to ad-
MT @. .'a-' some OK '"' evidence OIL
''. .'.-...
.,l...-.. .',' o..,,:1.I
n''' .''. ...
'"'' ~ w 49,
n''! -. ----''t d. -'''''''"'' an" 81
jim J.. BOO evc.t AS 10 the hands OH
,,~.e--.-- ..- Barnes was said 20 have
.., ~ .r.-,,L,. ,,.ho, .bo olo.
s,'-.- "... ' WV
ton @ 'r.,ei states senator came
before Den rattle Legislature in
.o.,
TIC ssne general 'enoency was
shown .y Justice Andrews IN retain
;r- - # C.o-re b. ArDew's testi-
r,.. ---. - =. ~olo.;r. - +bo
Mo-!' '"-- t''' 90 ''''e ~ '''N
conversation WIN AT. Barnes on SEN
s.o- C-a-.er's change Of heart con-
tr.. 49,. ....oo.-o.,. h!l
'e''''s --'' ''''' M NV
tie c..-, refused 20 strike out. Justice
Andrews said il bore upon the plain
80, ,-...-.-.. - ~. ro-.,. a1.boueb
[9.,...- -, a..;.,,5a
CHS I'D i'"'0.''' 90" 40
towar- racetfack legislation.
WINS oh'| ohe NOTION
o. bis Eve motions 10 strike out
.......,.,. o.ro~.5 IN tho ColoDol,s be-
go r.,t. i.
hA' --.' wa" Ky 40 W ANY
es,oc o. one. mat related 10 eX-
Senate Arnew's testimony on the bl-
IaIIsaH c.a-loN 70 e-ec. Jo'han T.
AIDS pres dent pro TEN OF the senate
George J." DlcSinSon account OF
eonvei alton with M barnes IN W%h'ch
the la.'es gave his views on uifect
~ Err.-ro- Hvrbes in that direction.
was allowed 20 remain.
A: t.r close q the afternoon session
NJ Wo.T -ook UP the testimony given
By eY-S.ra'-rs Human, Davenport and
NewcrrH. Walter T. Arndt and Henry
c Men cu. vino told q the efforts 10
dete., -1e Human-Green direct pri-
mary t.. and the hard and last lines
wh.-- separated rs friends ana oppo-
ner's. REGARDLESS OF party aihAauons.
A. ir 'ae case o. the a.leEed agree
me-, q. Pr. AuTpHy : psHGcIalS
iIet hand IN the cho'ce OF OAI'eG
STATE, senator me attorney argued
thtt i.t N0ie ana t''ehCAHI CIIcuH-
same. E-e--tl no PROOF o. any OOI4uPI
comb t-'.
bei.te pr. Won oHp!eIeu ms ar
guHeit ...am ~. WINS VINO haa
been uu..'r over Jusuce ANDREWS ;
rendering % corrupton'' ,lnterrup'ed
nm w.'r q request for CehnIuon OF
he Troublesome word.
justice Andrews. although he did not
withdrew h.s earlier Interpretation, an
no1UCet that his business az that mo-
mert wa. deciding motions and he
d.tr't intend 20 define anything II TINS
case tia. bee didn't have to.
mn Al Ami,
WI -''h .r
Il ls not likely tnat ne Will De sue
eesstuI m dlsmlssing the question 80
easily Ar. harness attorneys were
t1ken eoack al the oooStacIe W tI con
Tonted them, and Will pIoDaOIy 6tIhg
up me issue tomorrow. Inc ~oro haa
robust IheAols loOk "hen tney HIsI
scanned IL 10 Colonel kooseyeits state-
mem ana iHeF are ioa'h 70 oe!4eve tha'
cause fre CoIorel Thought him guilty
Q. an "Imrrcpr.etv."
Beyond saving that, for the purposes
Of his rulings. d corrupt alliance might
be con .acred AN improper alliance and
earned uo couuotation of pecuniary
gam. Justice Andrews did no defining.
The lawyers for both sides are in
!rnore-rt ~ i,.t bou, Gov toward their
several ideas Of corruption" he may
carry the meaning Of improper"
Dr. No.H Rot about half through
with his motions to-day. The printing
evidence Will probably be the last he
Will assaL Il is expected that Mr.
harness frs, witness will take the
''""H tu-laDiiOW. august beImOht -
on the way 20 Syracuse, from Lexing-
ton, Ky, al the request Of the Barnes
attorneys State Senator Elon r.
brown and Cx-State Senator James j.
Ffaw.ey, Taumany leader, are under
subpoena hy the plaintiff.
When tie defence rested, at 3:l7
o'clock this afternoon. IL had been three
weeks, lacking dav. since Colonel
Roosevelt Wont on tho stand rs their
first witness. They had been exactly
fourteen court DAYS in presenting their
slle Of the case