Arizona republican., 1915-08-23
DO NOT AGREE
 ON SINGLE REPORT
Became Apparent Some time Ago Would Be Un- able to Reach Uniform ConcIusion-NO Report is from the Majority
ASSOCIATED PRESS DIsPArcHl

CHICAGO, Aug. 22.-Summaries of
 the reports, three in number of the United states commission on industrial relations as to findings and recommen- dations for the information of congress,
 were made public here tonight.
 The commission, which ceases to eX- ist tomorrow, was composed Of three representatives each of the employers, the employed, and the general pubIc. It became apparent some time ago that they would be unable to agree on single report, and it is said that none of the reports given out tonight can properly be called majority report. The personnel of the commission fol- lows Frank P. Walsh, Missouri (chair- mann, John R. Commons, Wisconsin,
 and Mrs J. Borden Hartman, repre- senting the public; R. H. Aishton, Llli-
 nois, Harris Weinstock, California, and S. Thurston Ballard, Kentucky, repre- senting the employers, and John B.
 Lennon, Illinois, James O'Connell,s sDis- trict of Columbia, and A. B. Garretson, Iowa, representing the employed. The report of the representatives of the employees. known as the staff" re-
 port drawn up bv Basil M. Manly, di- |
 the commission, was signed by Com lmissioDers Walsh. Lennon, O'Connen and Garretson. In connection with the
 main reports these commissioners is
 sued three Supplemental Opinions and | Suggestions" as follows: One by MT Walsh. one by MT. Garretson, and one bv Mir. Lennon and MT. O'Connell jointly.
 The report of the commissioners rep resenting the public and the summary thereoi. were written by Commissioner Commons He and Mrs Hartman signed it without reservation. Commis sioners Ashton, Ballard and Weinstock approved it in large part and in part their dissent to portions of it. and to the Manly report are expressed in the so-called Weinstock report, signed by Weinstock, AishtOn and Ballard. The reports are identified as the Manly, or staff report the Commons, or report of the commissioners for the public, and the Weinstock report which among other things expressed dissent from the findings of the other two re- ports.
 The Manly summary finds that the causes of industrial unrest group them selves almost without exception under four main sources which include all the
 others. They are:
 "1 Unjust distribution of wealth
 and income
 70. Unemployment and denial of op- portunity to earn a living. ! "3. Denial of justice in the creation | in the adjudication and in the admin
 istration of the law.
 A. Denial of the right and oppor
 tunity to form effective organizations Remedies are suggested.
 On the same subject the Commons report says:
 "The greatest cause of industrial un- rest is the breakdown of the labor laws and the district of our municipal, state and national governments on the part
 of a large portion of our people" The
 report outlines a plan for remedying conditions through the institution of permanent industrial commission and advisory council" with comprehensive powers
 The Weinstock report dissents from
 the recommendation that the secondary l boycott should be legalized, finds that
 employees have many just grievances
 and are thoroughly justified in organ
 izing. It explains the prime objections l have to recognizing and dealing with
 organized labor as follows: Sympathet- ! ic strikes juris6ictional disputes, labor union politics, contract breaking, re-
 striction of output, prohibition of the | use of nonuniOn- made tools and mater | ials, closed shop, contests for suprem- acy between rival unions, acts of vio | lence against nonunion workers and the (Continued on Page Three)