The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1915-11-20
APPELLATE COURT DECISIONS
Complete List Handed Down !
First Department Division.

Nv Nv Al6 WIZ tl'i
vn yesterday by the Appellate Divi-
sion. First Department:
ingraham. Z. J.: Mclaughlin. Laughlin.
Clarke and Scott. u.
People, eS REL Mary B.. DIN. appellant,
dent. order reversed. writ Of habeas cor
pus sustained and relator discharged.
Opinions by Laughiin. j. and Ingraham,
Ingrsham, p. J.; Mclaughlin. Laughlin,
Scott and Bowling. u
swift. impleaded. appellant. Judgmen, AT
frmed with costs opinion by Scott. }.
mclaughlin. j.. dissentingJ order Med
lngraham, p; j.; Laush'in' Clarke Scott
Alexander J. Munro, appellant. vs. Thu
Brads,reet Company. respondent. Judg-
appellant to abide event. Opinions by
tLaushlin. j. and 1ngrsham.. =. J. Gngra-
han: + T. and Clarke j. dissenting
Isidor Lang, respondent, vs.. Hudson &
Manhattan r. i Co. appellant. Deter
and complaint dismissed with costs. op!n-
ion per curtain. order filed,
jIsdsm.n, " snd order reversed w,pRS c eos,s
and complaint dismissed with costs. op!n-
ion per curtain. order hled.
susanna F.rment. respondent. ". Roches-
ter & Pittsburgh coal & Iron Co. appel
costs. opinion by Lsughlin. J. order
Ned.
Matthew sulin. respondent. VS.. Rochester
Judgment and order reversed, new tri,i
ordered. oos;s to appellant TO abide event.
op,inion by Lnauxh'n; +. SFdsr hled,
Clarke and Scott, JJ
Universal Audit 60. Of New York, re-
Judgment reversed as indicated IN opinion
and demurrer oycrrulci, with costs To
appellant with leave to respondent on
and 20 reply to counterclaIms opinions
by clark; J.. and lnsraham. p J. ln-
Settle order on notice.
lnrrsham; J. j. Mclaughlin Laush'in'
Augusta Doctor and another. rcspon
dents. ". Augustus : Hughes, implicated.
and disbursemcnta against the appellant,
Augustus :. Hughes. opinion by Scott, j.
order Med.
Ingraham. r. J.; Mclaughlin. Laughlln.
Ernestlne Noah, appellant, VS., The
Rowery %saying. bank. respondent Judg
ment and order affirmed with costs. NJ
opinion. order Med.
Abraham Klein. respondent. vs.. Mary l..
reversed. new trial ordered. costs 10 appel
liant to abide event. Opinion by Scott, j,
William J, p. Mccrys,al. as admins
traitor, respondent. vs.. Georg" +. Weller,
appellant. determination and Judgment
the Appellate Term and complaint dis
missed with costs, Opinion by Clarke, J,
Kelso Il Co. respondent. VS.. Charles A.
Ellis and another, appellants. Judgment
and order affirmed with costs. No opinion.
OTas. G.cd.
People ex rel. William H. Helms. re-
spondeni. vs.. Charles Ruetiman. appellant.
Judgment affirmed. No opinion. order
hler
Ditmas --al'S 20. respondent. vs.
George X. Bris'Or, appellant. order AZ.
Armed with so costs and disbursements
with Ion Va In lpfe pAlnt Ia Withdraw do
murrer and to answer on payment of
costs. No opinion, order Mod,
York, appellant, ". Henry Ncugass, i'm
pleaded. respondent. determination ar
firmed with cost. on Tenement Hou-e De
partmcnt '. McDevitt cas- y y, 1907,
order filed.
Luke V. Lockwood respondent, vs.. l.. $
Steel Corporation. appellant. order AZ,
rrmed with $40 costs and disbursement
on Lockwood ". L.. :. Steel 60. t2Os y, y,
s75! and Travis vs., Knox ,rerpczone GO,
Florence Waskowski. respondent, vs.
Georgc Bockhaus, appellant Judgment
and order affirmed with costs, No opinion.
Bena Auto Import CO.. appellant, -
jesse froelich, respondent Judgment ana
order affirmed with costs, No opinion.
cherls, + Rogers. RESPONDENT, vs kn'ek-
11t uSsmen ana order reversed. npw ,rial
ordered. costs to appellant to abide event,
unless Plaintiff stipniates to reduce yer.
| UT ~ A'fu' III Nv 'N'hA Nhtk nlf
as so modified and order affirmed Without
costs. Gngraham.. p. j., and Mclaughlin.
j, dissenting and voting for reversalb
No opinion. Settle order on notice,
philip Brownstein, respondent, vs. Ken
jamin sussman, appellant Judgment ar
hrmed with costs NO opinion, order
filed.
James peyenish, respondent vs.. Imperial
Investing, Corporation, appellant. Judg.
complaint dismissed with costs. Opinion
per curiam. order hled.
Frederick j, Shalek, respondent. vs.. ].
Edward letter, impleaded, appellant, or
der affirmed with so costs and disburse-
ments on opinion OF shearn, j, at special
Term. order tlcd.
Fuchs. appellant Judgment affirmed Win
costs. No opinion. order tiod.
wyanoak Publishing co, appellant. ,Iudg
mcnt affirmed with costs. No opinion
order filed.
Hank Of United states, respondent, vs.
Morris Goldstein ct al, appellants. Judg
ment affirmed with costs. No opinion
solomon schina.i ct al, respondents, vs.
Louis Schinasi. ct al, appellants, order
reversed with SO costs and disbursement
and motion denied with 80 costs, opin'
Margaret kcssler. respondent, w, North
River Realty co, appellant, order modi,
fed as directed IN opinion, and as modi'
Ned affirmed without costs, opinion b,
( Scott, !. settle order on notice.
Sotirios A. Tours 1T al, appellants, vs.
Demctrios Karantzalls ANA another, ~
spondents. order reversed with so cost.
and disbursements and motion grantee
with so costs, with leave to defendant t.
withdraw demurrer and to answer on pay
ment Of costs. opinion by Scott. J. ords
nisd,