New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1915-09-05
His Selections Meet with
Approval of the
Exhibitors.
PROCTOR'S DOROTHY
GETS MANY PRIZES
Wins a Blue Over Mrs. Rainey's
Champion Salex, to the
Surprise of Many.

benched at the third annual dog show
Of the Islip Kennel Club yesterday,
placed in tents back Of the stand at
the grounds Of tho Islip Polo Club
better known as the old Bay Shore
Hor7e Show Associations feld-and
the judging rings were on the lawn.
There was an especially keen inter
est in the placings Of the judges, as
they included many we'll known ex-
hibitors who made their first appear
ence in that capacity, Of whom George
W. Quintard was perhaps the most re-
nowned. He judged fox terriers. the
breed in which he has been sweeping
all before him for two seasons with
the greatest string Of the wire-haired
sort ever gathered in an American
kennel.
Yet The new Judge revealed good
sense and did not dwell too long in
making up his mind. Quintard's selec-
lions as the best Of the smooths were
! ]. B. Able's Oxford Stormcloud and
George Raper's Runswick Radiance,
the English-owned dog being shown BY
Mrs. r. F. Mayhem, who has had be.
( since the Mineola show. In wires Mrs.
Row A. Rainey's Conejo Parcel Post
was put up as the best dog and j. B.
Able's oxford Ridgwsy Dorothy as the
best Of the opposite sex.
Able has been a noted Chicago ex-
hibitor for q long while and as "a
part owner Of E. H. Ingwersans ken
mel, but he now lives at Tappsn,. n. 7.
When the variety classes and m
classified specials were Judged later
by G. Muss Arnolt, F. S. Sternberg
and W. NJ Jones as a THO, Quintard's
choice Oxford, Ridgway Dorothy, as
the best in that division received an
unexpected Endorsement; they not on y
ratified the selection as the est fox
terrier but also gave the variety class
for terriers, toys barred, 20 her.
The trio selected the Airedale Brlck-
field Molly for second and the West
Highland white terrier Firenze Rose
bud as third in this class, but gave
only a highly commended to Mrs.
Rainey's Guycroft Salex, which was
condemning with faint praise, for salex
on the last two appearances won as
/ the best of all breeds at the recent
Newport and Southampton shows.
Dorothy is a neat, outstanding young
dog, but the experts failed to agree
that she or the other two should have
beaten the well furnished lnterna-
tional champion Salex.
Dorothy also won W. Ross Proctors
cup for the best transporting dog,
Harry T. Peters's trophy for the test
terrier and, as a elimination OF hon0rs,
the presidents cup, the gift OF Gee:ge
A. Ellis, jr., for the best dog al the
show. =,
The placing was in keeping with all
the results this season about New
York. fo- il is a wire-haired fox ter
rier year as to a first claim on the
best at the show trophies. The Lis
more Kennels Irish setter Lismore
pierdre won Franklyn L. Hutton's
trophy for the best sporting dog.
among other successes. and william
Zeigler's trophy for tho best toy was
won by Mr.. and Mrs. W. c. Thompsonls
Yorkshire terrier Oh. Gatenby's ST:
Wilfrid's King, to the discontinue OF
the exhibitors of the higher priced
Poms, Pekes and Brussels Grittons.
W. Ross Proctor judged Sealyhams,
The breed he has virtually put on the
American show map through the IN
portations from Wales, such as On. ivo
Caradoc. In winners dogs ne placed
Mrs Mary Willet's Locust Lane BOD
Sawyer over Eftingham Lawrenees
Braewood Temperance, the dog that
made a sensation last July by beating
Two Caradoc, with James Mortimer
judging, at the Gedney Farm SHOW.
Irish terriers from John G. batess
kennels swept both winners classes,
ard in Airedales the Westminster show
winner. Theodore 0fferman's forks
Master Key, was again to the fore. Dr.
James E. Hair, who judged the Engisn
and Irish settlers, pronounced tnemi
high in quality, but light in quantity.
The Windholme Kennels Dalmatians
were a grand collection, and Muss Ar
/ nolt very properly gave everything IN
sight TO them. Mrs. Willets IS the
former Long Island exhibitor, and now
resides in Virginia. She judged the
Sealyhams at the Devon show, and mas
a fine group of them in the LOCUST
Lane Kennels.
/ A black pug was a novelty, for since
the days when Mrs. Howard Gould en-,
deavored to make the breed fashion
thew have not been benched, at least
not near New York. The specimen on
/ view. Miss Grace T. Hadley's Abdul II,
won in the miscellaneous class. ~ vas
a tie for the distinction OF oslng lne
smallest dog at the show between Mhe'
Rose Carreno's toy black and tan YER
rier Karno Yuban and Mrs. Z. u; Az
woods Chicuelo, which took It's chsm'
pionship yesterday with points 10 spare.
Pekingese brought old fayorites 70
the front in Mrs. NJ. E. Harby's Nan
/ king Pao Kwei and Tsai Noke OF Bray
wick. but there is mystery about the
Young Nowata Dolly, placed reserve oy
Judge Sternberg in winners, bitches
/ about which no particulars were fur-
nished. Mrs. Hardy also owns this one,
and seems TO have picked up rear
~ Pomeranians, Sternberg selected
! On. St. Julien for winners, dogs, SHOWN
in full bloom Of coat, and the puppy
Banner Flyaway Kim, owned py .hs
Swiss Mountain Kennel, was reserYe'
For winners, bitches. Ofley Mite sun.
flower won over Fox Hills Aurora p9t
the orange had more ringside friends
than the sable Aurora Is me nan.
for this rudy coated Pom, Tor 'he
color is deep and unshaded ana OF ~
markable vividness.
Frederick |. Hamm, who judged .ns
French bulldogs, was also an exAlDiloi
wearing the ermine for the hrst uHle;
He gave winners, dogs, 10 the typiea'
a. Pourouoi Pas, entered ~ Mrs. No
riene Denturk and bought on the eve
of the show by II. Hubert, and da9gh'
ter OF this dog. John +. Haslems Men'
sande. captured winners, bltenes.
George F. Parker, also making mrs,
appearance as . judge, had sme
entry in Boston terriers ana ole ~
upset any favorites, as ne seleV,,sJI
Crown Prince III and Ralby's beautiia'
Girl as his types.