Bisbee daily review., 1915-12-11
SCARBOROUGH CASE GOES
 ID JURY
Fate of the Alleged Murderer of John Clinton in the Hands of the Jury, After Lengthy Argu- mentS By Counsel.
CAL COX CASE TO START
 TODAY IN SUPERIOR COURT
Opinion Is Divided as to What
 Jury Will Decide; Few Are of
 the Opinion That the Extreme Penalty Will Be Given.

Penalty Will Be Given.
 TOMBSTONE. Dec 10 (SpeciaD - The case of the State vs George Ed ward Scarborough went to the jury this evening about o'clock. The case opened this morning by the defense putting on two witnesses, the princi. pal one being pr II. II. Hughart, who testihed that it was his opinion that a man. having the wounds that Clin- ton has received in the upper portion Of his body and lying on his face. could not have uttered the words Mama, bring the rifle and kin him. He has shot me" 0s were testified to by the little Clinton girl as the words that her father had used after he had been shot. lt was the doctors opinion uLt Clinton would have died almost immediately or would have had such hemorrhages that would have prevent ed him from making any such state ment
 The question of who subpoenaed Cal Cox and why he was not used caused considerable discussion among the counsel The state admitted they did have him summoned. Attorney Ives took the stand and stated they did not have him summoned but the State did and then did not use him. In reply to a question. on cross-eXami- nation by Mr. Cleary, as to why they did not use him, Ives replied; "We did not have to as we have already proved Scarborough innocent"
 The state put on a few witnesses in rebuttal and the ease was closed at the noon recess, as far as the intrduc. tion of testimony was concerned
 At the opening of the court, after the dinner hour. the opening argu- ment was made by County Attorney Ross who, for nearly an hour, address ed the jury as to the facts in the case. He asked for a verdict of conviction al their hands He was followed by Senator Ives, for the defense, and the closing argument for the state was made by w. B Cleary.
 There seems to be a vast difference of opinion as to what the verdict of the jury will be, ranging all the way from acquittal to murder in the first degree. There are very few who ex press an opinion that the jury will bring in a verdict innicting the death penalty That the defense has been very strong one is admitted by all while the prosecution left no facts out in showing that the killing was delib crate and premdated, and should re- suit in a verdict of murder in the first degree.
 Judge O'Connor of Nogales, arrived this morning and will preside in the hearing of the trial of the Cal Coz case, as Judge Lockwood did not want 10 try it as he had heard a part of the 1 evidence, at the time Of the hearing of the writ of habeas corpus when the application for bail was granted. It is expected that the jury, in the case. will be selected by tomorrow 1 evening and the beginning of the in troduction of testimony started or 1 Monday morning. II is the opinion that the Cox case will not take so lonl as the Scarborough trial although tho largest part of the same witnesses will be used by both sides.
 Special Venire Returned.
 A special venire of eighteen iurorl was returned this morning by Sherif Wheeler and contained the followin. names; Frank Vaughn William Paul son, J s. Williams J. E Berkstead Henry Bennett, II, E. Dugan, Harr, Macia, W. L. Cook J. o. Denton E, McDaniels. D. Williams. s. Nj. Harris Afford Hoskins, P G. Madiean. C. l. Fucker, Sam Morgan Louis Kueken becker and Frank Willard
 Marriage Licenses.
 The following marriage license have been issued out of the clerks of flee during the past few days Gu, s. Shipley to wed Mary N Whaley both of Lowell; John C. Stahl. to wel Ona Hastings, both of Douglas: Pete IJ Whielilian. to wed Della Lewis both of Douglas; Fred Klatt. of Low ell, to wed Beatrice Conc of Bisbee Clarence NJ. Pomery of Mesa, to we Doris V Robertson of Benson. vii fam Jowles to wed Winifred Wilson both of Bisbee.
 New suits Filed.
 Celia Finney of Bisbee has brough