New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1915-07-10
NEW YORK COUNTY.
SUPREME COURT.
Angallats DlVision--ist Dspartm snt.

Appellate DNision--i ut Department.
DECISIONS
A Flschc/M Fhcllsndcr et al. Impleaded with II
o W.tipenn ct al judgment affirmed. with costs.
l. Spencer 81 81 az. as trustees etclCarolire
spencer implicated with l. spencer. Alb ct Al.
Judgment aud order affirmed. with costs. Opinion.
p. J.. and Laughlin. J.. dissenting)
yof.ed. Win costs and complaint dl'missSd. with
costs. opinions by Mclaughlin. j.. and lnsrahaln
Julia W Liuleg Kirby. iinreaded. ETC. JIdg.
and Clarke. ~. dissenting Dissenting opinion
o 4 Crossing Musical Instrument Sales 60
Judgment reversed. with costs. and complaint dis
missed with costs. Opinions by Ingraham. r. j..
People e1 rel 4 Cantor County Board Of Can
win 80 costs and disbursements % inierYenor
II Iccflu-serIII r C. Watson. err, etc Order
rerrcI with $40 costs and disbursements. and
motion denied. With $40 costs. Opinion b'
4 Finkelgen /Iroquol, Door Co Judgment
and order affirmed with costs. Opinions BY Nc
Laughliu. j.. and lngraham. 7. !. InTshaio
McGuInnss'. Rodgers & Hngerty Inc. JudE
ment aud order reversed. with costs. and com
plant dismissed. with costs. opinion by Clarke. J
G. ID sherman Tie People. etc. impleaded yuds
ment reversed with costs. and complaint dismissed
Win ,e,o.ts; Opinion per curtain -.
mcnt and orders reverted and new trial ordered
with costs 70 appellant % abide event Opinion
I
cts oi New Yordtn'on News co. Judgment AZ
afm.d. with costs Opinion Oy Laughin. J. IN
graham. +. J.. ana Scott J.. dissentingJ Dissent
r. " Zieger deceased. Decree modified as in
d'ca,ei in opinion, with costs TO appellant Opinion
! p KolhrcnerIH d Bob ct al Judgment and NJ,
der reversed and new trial ordered. with costs
! % appellants 70 abide event. opinion by Laugh
= " sothman ct alrH NJ warI ct al. implicated
c,c. Order reversed. with SO costs and disourse
H..H|H H.fa ~ n
I iou hy Mclaughlin. j.
TIE People. e'c.W Sanger. Appeal dismissed
opinion hy Mclaughlin. j.
. ! Na-uireIW " Barrett as president. etc. Juds
mcni and order reversed. with COSTS and compia amt
% miveI. with ,..'s. Opinion by Mclaughlin. J.
Cox 90 al n Crder 81 a. Judgment auo
order an med with costs Opinion Uy Laugh
I iil Orler GlcI
g p HmIT-.e- rIith Tile Co. Judgment and
order reversed. a.tl costs. aud complaint dis
mi ,ed with costs. opinion ty Bowling. ].
! Georgia G AreherlEquita5le Life Assurance So
c,eiy u the Orler affirmed. with SO costs
and dlsiurHn-nts. WIKI leave 10 defendant
servo amended answer on payment Of costs IA this
court and In court below. Opinions by McLaughlln
J.. InTaham T. J., and Hotchioss j. lngahan
p j., dissenting. IlOtchkss j.. dissenting IN part
/ Sarah MarsionIB + Fn'5le Judgment and or
der reversed with costs. and complaint dismissed
with costs. Opinion 10y Laughlin. J.
et aI as errs etc impleaded with Charlotte Rosen
baum. Judgment reversed. except 70 costs. and
judgment directed for appellants stated IN opin
on With costs 10 appellants payable Out OF estate
/ ] BlairITlr5o- Electric Construction Co ct al
/ order affirmed with SO costs and disbursements
I 70 answer ON paymea. Of costs in this court and
/ IN court below. 0aughin. J.. dissenting
] Kahn et al Mailer Brothers. judgment and
order reversed. with costs. and complain. dismissed
With costs. opinion hy Bowling.
Champe Andrew. Asa Bird Gardiner Judgment
/ reversed and ncv trial ordered with costs 70 ap
/ pellants 10 abide evcnt Opinion by Laushlin. }.
Metropolitan Life Insurance Co William II Reed
ct al. committe.. enc. judgment directed Tor plain
+
james A Grant et ai/Grecns Consolidated Copper
Co q. al mpleaded. etc. Judgment affirmed viii
costs; eighth conclusion Of law reversed. Opinion
Trianiie Waist Co/Beatrice Todd Judgment an
order reversed. with costs. and Judgment directed
for plaintiff for nominal damages as stated 81 Opin
ion. opinion by Lsughlin. o..
Alice e. william, Emily d Van Wagenen ct al
iup,cdded. etc. judgment affirmed with costs
upon Pine opinion OF GicgcHrh, J. In court below
CO. Judqner. and order reversed. aid new tha
ordered. with costs o. appellant TO abide event
Robert ilolmes ct alIEdwatd Smith impeaded
etc. order reversed with SO costs and tlspuI Sc
mont. and motion denied with $40 costs. with leay'
20 plaintiff 90 serve amended complaint on payment
of costs in tIi, court and In cour- below oiAHloi
U" Robert iiIo.mcs ct alIIIush Camp ct al I'm
/ pleaded etc. order reversed with $40 costs an,
a ,hursemeufs ami motion denied. Wltu Slp cosls
With leave % plaintiffs 10 serve AMENDED cGiap. ei
below Opinion hy Mclaughlin. j.
People cx rel C'a.ie Asphalt PaTng co. relatoI
Alfred W seaman ct al etc WI sIs'4 an, u
award set aside and proceeding returned 70 boM'
OF Assessors 90 make an award on t2timJiy ~.
evidence before H. with $50 costs and disbursement
/ 10 rclator. opinion by Ingraham. 7. j. ~ ~
! George W Young L Mortsass and Trust Go
I Order affirmed with co Is 10 respondent 90 solI
event % new trial Opinion by Mclaughlin =
/ nsnry Henirickson'O 'Bden Construction g.
. Judgment reversed and nov trial ordered. VIZ
/ S1.t. M autt,lsn. 10 abide event Opinion b.
/ Clarke. Iagraham. p J. disssntlnsl. ...,,,,,,,,
Francis C2ley a. al. slr'l,Ns ~ ,,.t.
/ Lincoln O. Valentine Charles Schmidt et al JUG
ment amt order affirmed. with cos-s. ,r,..,,,o,,,,
I RariI Transit co. Julgm no affirmed WIN COSTS
Filth l. Sas,e order u United Commercial Iras
! and new trll ordered. with costs % appellant :,
abide event Opinion by Clarke, lihsraA11iu ,
/ j. and scott 4. concurnns aud voting 10 ai5rds
San.ael $ Watson Jacob b Ross Judgment re-
vef.ed and new trial ordered. WIN .os ~ @ip''
Peter Polite tt 81 Time. square l@pr9Sslen
Co. order reversed. with $40 cost, ant asp 6I
i,o br sou. llI0tchldss. = oissentingl.
'p.,.le. &c Joseph Es3n Judgment affirmed
BRIDGET C.a.E, n rman UhL Judgment anu o'ue
LANES siart Jacob Lebeman Judgment directed
a, s-ated Boo opinion. Opinion By po"liAi, SS...,,.
Ilm., : Msug. as evr 'tc Emigfalt lndu'1s i.t
sarir-, ra.k Judgment and order affirmed VIII
co,t, Opinion by Hot,h,iss. j. ,,.-..., q a.,
JSeg5 Hq.1Hg ris1 s' All az -ied viii costs
' r-,.iro A..i..,rt Bronze Co ilenncey Realty -
ct a. Jno1Tisa 3,u,'D1,J y, A. etc Iuterbo-ougt
People H} J'-h S.- -, ii-,.fet Tor pla!ntir
Rapid TRANSIT 90. fi.,jgi-. snJ DoViiug
f.r so V'lI'".
D. ~, "lins' ~, stevens Iutzs. e;c. Judg
mont eaI qrlsr a..iiii I, s,r,ors,, ef al judgment
LoAl-e h.,.4-i ~ san to.ts Gugraham p j. az,
Scott. j. ol',e"...t. 40. pr,s In. Determine.
BENJAMIN ~ ".ll' Nc A''
ti.E l7rinsd WIN '0I''s,t . e F,sra- as err. etc
SlA-hI@ - ~ ss,i,L costs
JuIs4eIy S,s ,I..c ,icersai Motor Truck Co. i'm
i.4u {. i,jy,,cnt and order affirmed. viii
George Blttef~oiR e. ,.,, ~, a,,6lney General oi
ID N.t.,l ~ - Iud.r.art affirmed. Wit.
Tie :. ate o. NrH lo-. ''1e''-.--
Gusts. ui e.Ai-" %. ,ti, A U,--c- Iuizmeu'