Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1915-09-09
GOLF CHAMPIONS LOSE
CHANCE IN THE FINALS
Misses Hyde and Rosenthal Beaten
in Second Round by Mrs. Bar
low and Miss Edwards.

ONWENTSIA GOLF CLUB, LAKE
FOREST, Ill, September 9-Two of the
five champions who entered the second
round of the women's national golf
tournament on the links of the On
wentsia club were brushed aside here
yesterday. They were Miss Lillian B.
Hyde of South Shore, the metropolitan
leader, and Miss Elaine Rosenthal, the
Ravisloe girl who a few weeks ago won
the Western Golf Association title.
Whatever else Mrs. Ronald H. Barlow
of Merton does, she will be remembered
this year for what she did to the New
York favorites. Miss Marion Hollins and
Miss Hyde. The finish of Mrs. Badlow
Tuesday against Miss Hollins was worthy
of a champion. but even that was ordl-
nary as compared with her winning
stroke against Miss Hyde yesterday. II
takes nerve to lay an approach stone
dead after playing seventeen holes with
out being able to gain an advantage.
Miss Rosenthal Plays Poorly.
Miss Rosenthal owed her elimination
to generally poor playing. The west
ern champion did not display any of the
prowess she used recently a Midlothian
in winning her title as the best golfer
west of Philadelphia. Her tee shn.
were good. as rule, but her work with
the irons was poor. MISS t-u p" t.'u., Il
sister of Kenneth and Donald, the Mid
lothian stars, was steady if not bril-
liant, during the whole round
AS the situation stands. the women
will meet in the third round today in
the following order: Mrs. Gavin VS..
Miss Eleanor Allen, Mrs. Barlow VS..
,iiss +. Pearce. Miss Edwards VS.. Miss
Stirling and Mrs. Vanderbeck rs. Mrs
Beifeld.
v,,bn RI
Miss Stirling as a championship pos
sibility were again gratified at the way
the southern title holder acquitted her
self against Miss Laurie Kaiser, the
Chicago district champion. On several
| occasions Miss Stirling got trapped.
but the recoveries were usually worthy
of a champion. Probably her best SHOT
of the match was a full iron at the
She missed the try for 3, but even so
won the hole.
Plays Poor Short Game.
poor short game was Mrs. Hurd $
excuse at the finish of her match with
Miss Eleanor Allen. When the first
named came to this country as Miss
Dorothy Campbell one would not want to
see better putter. Miss Allen. by the
way. has already a semi-fnal medal.
Frank l.. Woodward, president CT the
United states ioif ASSoclatioii, was taken
ill Tuesday night. and did not Put in an
appearance. Howard ". Perrin. one of
the vice presidents. and Howard Whitney
were in charge. The summary:
Championship second roGnd,-AlGs- W. y
GAVIN, shirley Park. England, beat Mrs. Caleb f.
Fox, Huntington Valley :: up and = 10 play;
Miss Eleanor Allen, Oakley, beat Mrs. j. '.
Hurd. Pittsburgh. 4 up and 10 play: Mrs. Ron
aid II. Barlow. Merton, beat Miss Lillian i.
Hyde. South Shore. up: Mi.s Y. Prarrc. fi"Ss-
more beat Miss Caroline Painter. Midlothian q
up and pay: Miss .AleXa Stirling. Atian.e,
beat Miss l.. Kaiser, FIoSsmore I up and q to
play: Mrs. c. II. Eanderbeck, PHILADELPHIA
Cricket. beat Mrs. W. coi1ham Inverness, M
| and e 10 play: Miss NJ. Edwards. Midlothian.
beat Miss Elaine Essential. Ravisloe 2 mp Mrs.
f.. Refeid Ravisioe, beat Miss Elizabeth Alien.
Rock Island up.