The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1915-06-05
APPELLATE COURT DECISIONS.
Complete List Handed Down by
First Department Division.

The following decisions we're handel
down yesterday by the Appellate Di-
vision, First Department:
Alfred c. Beatty. appellant. w. Gussen-
nelm exploration Company ct al, respon-
dents. Judgment reversed with costs, and
}udgment ordered in favor of plaintiff as
lowance as against the Exploration com.
pany. Opinions by Scott. j.. InEraham,
+ j. and and M Metaassiin. J. SH ..sn,9nr
settle order on notice.
William II, Davis. appellant. Va. Rich.
snirmed with costs opinion by Ne.
dd]agshIlp: J. Clarke. s., dissenting
ortcn O. OFT. respondent. v,. Baltimore
Order reversed. with 80 costs and dis
Lsgsh,in. :, Order died:
p. HiisT Work rs rs cSsn,y Sa, W | nsn. :g-
appealed from reversed, with costs and
Opinion by Mclaughlin. J. scttis order
nen,a%in P; pus... respondent. v. Fed
trial ordered. with costs to appellant to
Frank N wear. respondent. vs.. Theresa
armed With costs Opinion BY McLaush-
Andrew Robinson Company. re,pon.
dent. vs.. Security Mutual Life Insurance
as directed IN opinion, and as modified
affirmed without costa Opinion by Laugh
In J. tsGot,. J. di.'entingj settle
Callahan estate. respondent. vs.. anhai-
tan KaiIway company ct al. appellants.
bursements, and motion denied. with SO
costs. Opinion by Mclaughlin. J. order
German American Coffee Company. re-
spondent. VS.. William r. Johnston, appel-
liant. order modified as directed in opin-
costs iS9i ana ana di %SSrs.n Sn'Fm ae s Wi,s Mo
op!nion by Mclaughlin. J. Settle order
charles b B.rk,ey, respondent. vs.. TO-
seph II. S. Muller, impleaded. appellant.
order reversed. with $40 costs and dis.
costs. opinion by Mclaughlin, j. order
filed.
Everett, p. K.tchum. respondent. Va.
reversed. with SO costs and disbursements.
and demurrer sustained. with 80 costs.
Compi aiat' on no Pssinsin to o. 'e so.;. Am IN ,s,i
court and in the court below. Opinion by
Texas, neutrality-suspicious. vs.. Ida NJ
Fleitman as sdministratrix. SC. impleaded.
appe!lant-respondent. order reversed with
sustained with $40 costs, wi.h leave TO de-
PENDANT TO servo an amended answer on
payment of costs in this court and In the
missed with 80 costs opinion by Ne.
LauGhlin. J. order fled
order affirmed with $40 coats and dis
hursements, No opinion. order filed.
LGono1a FnifarG respondent; vs.; George
lam f Fulford. respondent. VS. Same. ap-
pellant. Judgments and orders reversed
and nov trials ordered with cost. 70 APP
kiss y. Gnrraham. T. j.. and Dowiins,
j" dissenting orders filed.
Joseph j; wifacr Q, al, defendants. Juds.
tons hy Mclaughlin and .Ltotehk,ss, ~.
Morris Rose. plaintiff. va. Solomon
SSrh'Ge,a dsiendag. Judgment, ordered
John Pierce. appellant. VS., George A.
M HnGcms ~ eSGeG,riS' &C.: rc1sEondcpt
laughlin, J. order Med.
Thomas A Shiels. respondent. vs. Anne
ns,e %2rn S"' Of Is E sSTsi &C. TpTS''" Dns
judgment % city Court reversed and com
PLANT dismissed. with costs TO appellant in
az Conrts, Opinion by Mclaughlin. J.
George G. Claussn. appellant, VS.. TIL.
4 Surety Company. respondent.
Judgment and order affirmed with costs
upon the opinion OF Hamilton Odell. ref
cree. C~Hotchkiss. J. dissenting Dis
scn,ins opinion by Hotchkiss. J Order
John smyth as Admr.. appellant. Va.
lorkshire Realty 4 Construction Co. i'm
order affirmed with costs, No opinion.
Max Jane e, al. appellants. We. Stephen
hrmci with SO costs and disbursement
with leave 10 plaintiffs 10 serve umcndei
complaint on payment OF costs In this
court and In the court below. No opinion.
order Med.
The People. &c, respondent, vs. Frank
ilrmet, No opinion. order hied.
Mary \, Reynolds. respondent. vs.. John
D. reynolds appellant Judgment mod,-
ned afnrmci without costs. op,n,on n'J per
.eniinE memorandum BY Dowiins.s J. s.,.
spondent vs., Catherine r, chenows.h ct
ne Msn, ." snismsd S %iiA sd.': Na op lnss,
jams s Alexander E, al. app.,i.p.,
respondent. Judgments affirmed With
coi,s, No opinion Orders hied
.p G1t!.a sH va r. ssGi%'" Esn 80; COM re.
With costs, No opinion, order
Maurice handler, appellant. ordor al
hrmed, with so costs and disbursements
and TO answer upon payment OF
costs IN this court and In the court below.
opinion order iled.
Rooecca Schoeufeld. appellant We. Mott
Avenue Realty Company and Isidor Levy,
re pondeu;s, Judgments and orders re-
ycrscd ana new trial ordered with costs
10 appellant 70 abide event. Opinions by
Scott. j.. and ingraham, i. J. lIngraham. |
Margaret Lane. as administrators. &o, |
respondent, vs.. Lion Brewery OF New York
city, appellant. Judgment and order az.
with costs. No opinion, Clarke and
u, dissenting on tho ground that
thore IL no evidence OF freedom from
ncgligence.) Order a!ed.
solomon Siber'eld. appellant. VS.. Walter
kohn, respondent. Judgment and order
q nIrmei with costs, No opinion, order
ARENAS Ward. respondent. N. Morris
Park Estates. appellant. Judgment and
order affirmed with costs. No opinion,
Order filed.
Morris Park Estates. respondent, Va. 10
order reversed with costs. morion Tor
on the pieadings denied. with
30 costs to appellants, and case remittod
10 Special Term FOR determination OF tho
matters for which the defendants are
legally accountable, Opinion by Clarke, J.
order on notice.
People eN rel. Interhoroush Rapid Tran
sit Company, appellant vs. Lawson Purdy
~ al, as commissioners &c, Respondents.
order affirmed with costs. No opinion
Ralph ", Carroll. respondent. W. the
Ni'y of New York, appellant. Judgment
md order affirmed with costs, No opinion.
iutrhhi>s. j, iisssnting.j Order uict.
l. r IIuppnrsNrd R-1us a r,n,n. O..