The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1915-05-15
APPELLATE COURT DECISIONS.
Complete s6s< Handed Down by
Firat Depart ment Division.

fir~t Department Division.
The following decisions were handed
down yesterday by the Appellate Di-
vision. First Department:
Bartholomew Dunn. ..,.y- .,.,n;. vs.. city
of Soy rors s15 psyers ond
motion denied, with $40 costs. Opinions
by insraham. L. j.. and L,ughlin, j.
tLaushlln, and Scott ". dissenting
Joseph Meishan respondent, W.. Emf.
grant Industrial Savings Rank. appellant.
Snd STd s"rmed po wh eoss
Mclaughlin ana Bowling. u. dissenthgD
order fled.
deceased. Decree modified as directed In
opinion and az modified affirmed without
costs Opinions by Clarke. j.. and tnsrs-
ham. = J. Ungraham, =. j.. dissenting
Locomobiio cYmpany. OF America. re-
spondelt W. Edwin Nichols. Appellant
ion by. Scott. j, tpowiing. j.. dissenting
upon the ground OF an accord A. salts
faction between the parties o,se, h,ea
appellant vs.. Harry Coopcrman, :sspon.
don't. order affirmed. With $40 cot ash
disbursement. Nc opinion. order aled
appellant W.. Joe Duhc respondent. 9ah,e.
appellant vs. Morris t.auti ordets az
rrfned, With $40 costs ana diSOurseTsh u
No opinion. orders flied
People ex rel Egbert =. Woodbury.. Z
torney -Gonoral. &c. appellant w. Petei
lenarcls. Justice OF the Suprems COW; =
missed and respondents authorized 20 pro
coed In the matter az II the , aitsrnsti ~.
wri' had not been issued r opinion py
Frederick ~ Mandevii!e. as executor.
Sc. respondent. w.. Alfred DOeneh g. a.,
appellants order affirm d With 80 costs
Wilhelm schans;rom. respondent, "
nS,it,ouaI, appellant. order affirmed win
,iO oosts and Disbursements. No opinion
order nied.
sponient, vs.. Richard :. Hoffman appe' ,
ant order reversed, with $40 costs and
ii-bars-mcnte, and motion granted op'h-
M nfH NO. HAITI, 6 s;hed i: e; al de,c-tant..
Hattie schcuer ct al. appellants. JOY -,
connolly as receiver. responder. orr
lnirmei with sio costs and disbursement
NJ opinion. order hled.
Harry " rhnips. appc4!ani vs.: Amer;
son. "Reminiscences OF Insurance. &C., ap-
opinion and as modinsI affirmed, With
ont costs opinion Pc curtain. settle
Milton Wei. respondent. vs.. G. Dexte'
Richardson. appellant. order modified ol
denying motion 10 strike on thirty -fourt!
paragraph 30 amended ansNef' hhi o'
striking out IN. provision % the order e,
uu!rlne defendant :, serve an amended
aufvcr, ami a. modified Affirmed. Wtnnu'
Corby Commission COMPANY. app"!Aut
" John Gni,2m. rs.rondeLTi 0faSr a;
H Yi Spin, on G-Ger firl. ''''
Horny B,dnhfD5;. respondent We Ben
jamn Feeh,@T resP"n4t.nt. mo, 0Tae T,nT re-
lion that defendant within ten DAYS pal
trial Zee and give an andsrts .s, ~
ina. may be- obtained the cause TO %
restored TO The shor, csuse Calendar "'
Malcke Building Corporation imp eadsa
co.;s an, disbur'emea's' No opinion
John J. o.N-i, -sspona'9n;; -ac " ,n hsG
os' the he astior 20 iaSa. md a., SO nodine,
, affirmed. "!.ho'' pets. 80 "pinio,
U.4ughiin ana Oft. ~, dissent'nS' Set
Ar;Ehur y. Wsrner spp''la5pri,, s w. G SIS,,I
o. psrtieu'srs A. required by order o
special Term entered Aus. .. l,li, ah'
.rkips Gai The p'c syd.h.e 10 ana e as
m1I!led affirmed WIKI 40 costs ana Gis
anraernent. to respondent No opinion
Maric bui.sy appe.ant. -. Edwar,
puIIsy res-oudcnf order reversed, win
~ costs and disbursements aEa m''ioi
s %enisi G "rier niiSSd. ~
Martha y Flynn. appellant ", TIT
usn.ed. aithou; coz a. without pr"Jui'e'
20 application by p.a.ntlr 70 colEpyu Ap9'r'
m,ny unpaid siuce July /. 1914. No op'h
Ia In the matter ~ Anthony Mc0uade. re
apandent Va James VI. Morrow e. al,
~, anpeNan.s and order affirmed, viii
SO costs and disbursement No op'n
Be-naPd schnitzl.- - a.. respoEdent-
v Henry wades e, AZ 1RR %s .,i mIdS
2n sr iss' %inin In q ve Day SSy aie 2'Py
uourccment Of thn 9ecisiP: ~ : .I,n
s,ipgiaton be NO; MED WITHIN nns, me ,i ,'%
men.s. X, opinion. settle order oil
Paul NJ. Ale, respondent. " VITAL Bcg
suis,, Inplceded, apo liant; order A.
! drmed with 80 cos;s and d'shNrSciheh''
Hermun St,nzeshe'mer. respondent y,
: samuel TreeEer, appe liant, nrher ~
/ nrmeJ win 40, costs aud disagreement
Hairy IT, Hurlbu, g, al, ,rsspon,dsn,'
ys Ida X. s,e.ic I al, defendants. harr
Wisrns appcl'IH,l 1rasr fesy ni n,o Mis
! l,uted with 80 costs, "ithoui preJuli'
| % any OF the proceedmss heretofore HI"
= herein. - opinion Ofier hleu.
! ,rpieshcd. ~. Motion TO dismiss appoa
! granted unless appeilun; comply WIN Term
stated In order order Med.
! The People. &C., -. George A. Scott Mo
Ion 20 dismiss appeal granted orde
bernard La,lner W.. wonderland Anusc
men, COMPANY Motion TO dismiss apes
1 denied without costs. order Alca
spT,aue .. a.. Motion TO dismiss sppss
granted with $40 costs, Order h.ed.
Harrle r I.indeherg =, "a vs. rhoma
, NJ Hodgens, Application denied with 81
J.nie jacobs "a, Niei Kenyon. Appnca
ton denied with 80 costs, order slsned.
! David HOFFMAN -. Nav York Railway
COMPANY. Application denied with ~
William TarnSm 70, william Harri
son Motion grLpied order sled
German Amer can ctnee compo y VI
John OMEN, Aio:lor sraScd qgs'iion
Ye,ia 2eItl!n'ys. Isidore ID. Morris,a Z
al. Motion denied with 80 costs. ie
Stephen X, Watts vs.. poull Miller :,
Katherine =. Lildenan O. executor. SC
VS. Helena Il. Richter. Motion d"nie
With 80 cost. order aled.
Laura Gloy-r as Adm ~, rs, Bank
with so costs. order Med
Giovanni Guintini vs., Alex Thompson
Motion denied with 80 costs. order iile'
Andrew J. brown SO. orvill Thompson
susanna SchleiCh as AdmS,. &c, W, Fh'
schleich. Motion denied with $40 cost
order llod.
solomon stern w. Metropolitan Life II
surancc COMPANY, Motor granted an
plaintiff stayed from proceeding With r'
animation pending deierminl'!on Of Rppe,
from order, with leave 70 plaintiff "a NOV