New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1915-01-01

STATE.
SUPREME COURT.
Aspellafs Dlvislon--1d Department.

Appellate Okklon-ld OepaftmtN
Joseph n MAYER, as receiver. ,tetMs,ropoitan
Traction Go e Al Indignant. affirmed Without
Chester Counts Gusishtee and SAFE Deposit Go
c, a. eIs stcfThs securus. Go ., a. LAVA" 80
judgment modified. % directed n opinion. ana. as
20 modified, judgment affirmed. With COS" 70 pan
tins Opinions by Mclaughlin. }, and ihgrshan'
PJ unsfahsia. = ]. and Lsushlin. }. dissentlnE).
Sanitary Fireproohns and Contracting 20, Isns
viii costs Opinions By ClTte snd MeLausniin'
u tMoLsushnn and bowling, w. dsSsnun,s ijl,.-,,-,
and srsi reversed and new , ordered win costs
! 10 appellant 70 abide event. opinions By lnsrahA9'
[ ? ). and Bowling. tMeLsushiin and po"nls' d.
Fiere hmsnua/ciy Q, New. York. impd siih
L9pis kofa 1s Ct T. "a A' ho No 10 fI ARMED With
. costs TO respondent Judgment In Action 10 a.
yersed Win costs 70 appellant S1 spssapis
With costs. Opinion per eudsm; - -, ,.u.,,.,.
llar John Cort De'erniin,tion Of hpp,.s
aud Clarke. u (ClArke and DoElins' j. ahseA'-
a d s,s,son Board o. Education. etc. JudgInent
rcversed with costs and judgment directed IN IaNof
o. defendant. dsrnissing complaint upon the hofis'
M ] Sauefbrmn. lrIHarford Life Insurance.
Judgment modified. directed IN opinion 40 ,i a.
J. sfi lngraham. J tlngraham, I }. disseh5plsI;
AIics l. Ripley ot al. a. e1r. etc GUARANTY Tru,i
F. Grned Win cost TO plaintiffs ard guardian al
uicm. PAYABLE out 81 the csiate. opinions " Ss4''
and Laughlin. u uaughlin ana Do"llhs' 90 US
Bianeh NeuhrchIw J MeHush e a.; impld
win Lev oaet re,ersen' sn.tst,sd wit6
$40 costs. with lese TO respondent TO smena on
payment q cost IN this court and IN ths so4I' W
low opinion b. LIughlin. J tlnsrAhnn' j. as
sentngl. -.
reversed and new trial ordered Win costs to appel
liant 10 abide event opinion by Aelaushnn.
M Fraser ct al s!f q L ,s oS,a,oi p'1 and
modified ,fmed wt5 ao;is 70 2, Appellant Rott
'5 Geoigs G ys8 Tyl' h. a. sur,. etcI L Lewis.
impld otc Order reversed. With $40 costs ana as
bursements and demurrer sustained. with $40 costs
! with leave 20 defendant 10 amend answer on pay
ment OF costs opinion by Mclaughlin, }.
/ c Buchby1, NJ Berkeley. Judgment modihed IS
directed In opinion. and a. modified affirmed. with
/ out costs. opinion Der eJism. -. 49,. =, ID .
state Board Of Tar COnmrs, & Of Y, interyenof-
respt Orders affirmed. With costs. opinion py
I Hoichkiss j mclaughlin aud Scott, ~ dissent on
/ People eI rel a II Il HWoodbuTy' .Oo
HcnTy i Conditional Hesly. Judgment and
order reversed and new thai granted. With costs TO
| appellant % abide event opinion BY Laughin, J.
Williams ct aLNf" a9'e Son mer .iS, d,sms"ed
/ with costs 70 appellant IN all courts. Opn4lon "
Mar RandolphJAnmstadt W Field. Determine.
ton OF Appellate Term sustaining demurrer 20 third
defence affirmed: determination az 70 nrst 5 snI
| Cont sffrmed Oh Mon by Mclaughlin. J.
Carrie Lchtensten/ Auglsta-Aike Ry Elee;
gsbs,ertt and motion denied with $40 costs
/ gith leave 10 plaintiff 70 amend complaint on pay
ment Of costs IN this court aud IN tho cOur below
i BTodsky1C D Halock order reversed. with
SO costs and disbursements ana m9Ioh sfAn'eu'
= De 81 Belts Emma NJ Bets. order reversed
with $40 costs and dssursenehts ana mG,on
Orth ct AIM Kaesche ct al. as sslrs. ete
implicated with Gertrude Miethe ct al sgds IasI
reversed and judgment directed IN favor o. PLAIN,
TINS With costs In this court and -, IN iss coqT
below Opinions By scott and Ho,eha's' d.
/ DicklnsoniD J Tyson, impld, etc. Judgnent
! and order reversed and new trial ordered; VIII
costs to appellant 10 abide event. unless pla,nuu
stipulates 10 reduce verdict 10 an amount equlIa-
lent 70 a commission Of "a per cent; 10 "hlch
event the Judgment a. 80 modified and Tie order
/ Ion. Laughnn and Dowlinz u. dissenting ana
'0c5"ff MafRsjJ stolts. as president, etc. order
affirmed. With costs Opinions BY McLaug,nnlh ana
/ Hotchki5s. u. (nraham. p j. and Hotchnss' .
W v Farley, as state Comr. etciA Bgttner.
lmpld etc judgment ana order Te'e,se s. Sn me
defendant. Buttner. to abide event opiniton oy
/ Mclaughlin J. Haughlin sud DoWlnS d. us
ssivin. as admr ectBer,hs sslVin impeaded
etc order reversed win SIU eo, rs s doonds1i o
the pleadngs granted with $40 costs. Vpll!.qn
Dong .S 0id9 notion for Judgment
for defendant the plcadings granted Win slV
'o1 Tie R RD,&S'' L ON Metz Judgment affirmed
r,tb cdets vi,b leave 10 defendant 70 amend on
I payment of costs m this court and IN the 40uI.
below. Opinion by Laushin' j. 'lhgfahAm' %
Re Kara simon. deed. order snirmed. with
/ NeS Amsterdam Casually COZ Van yechten
olcott, as receiver etc. Judgment for plainth
with costs. as stated In opinion. Oplnon uy
National National Surety COZ BreqehaId, ygdsmsn; al
Lswyers' surety Co Of TIE Ayrsut. impld
! etc Judgment reversed, With costs ana NO mouVh
denied with $40 costs VP9nlon GSS,d SisS Ell
Judgment reversed and new trial ordered, win
costs to appellants 70 seds syenl r OplIfns
/ Mclaughlin and HotchklsS' d. NhoSch~iS'' -
S6IpIeS Construction and supply COM Mayer
e, al Judgment affirmed. with costs. opinion oy
L' Yors Manufacturing Co/M Mayer ct al Juds-
| mont ARMED. with costs opinion per curtain
/ &C Jennings IDegnon Construction Co. Judgment
/ and order reversed and new trial ol9eIe1 YIN
costs 10 appellant 70 abide event OplMoh " BIC
Re NY Re l4sth st and Overlook Terrsc &c,
Order reversed to extent indicated 10 opinion WIN
$40 costs and disbursements. and motion granted
as stated IN opinion. QpinCn oy poyxhns u5,r0.,,
"a otdet reversed and new trial ordered With
costs 70 appellant to abide event opinion " NC
NJ9Ss'' Andfews/Asa Bird Gardiner. JUDGMENT rs
yer,ed and nes rs 1 a9io, WIN b1 g aG
pe4snt p 10 Seiue IPaul,nS Pspp Judgment ar
miHnsrttne oplpiop by McLsugliIln. J.
lord Electric ColBarber Asphalt Paving Co
Iudgpep, reversed. with costs. with leave TO plain
TN TO sever action on payment OF es"is " , ui'
lin J. and lngAham. J. unUaham' ). ana
DI Fnns II Ford iIohn WsnAm.ker Judgment and
order reversed and new trial granted with costs 70
appellant 10 abide event Opinions by Lalshiin ana
Hsrrs Kirshman Crawford -Piummer. Co. Orders
affirmed. without costs opinion uy Moaos,. 49,,
reversed with costs 70 appellant Judgment Of Mu-
nicipal Court reversed and new thai ordered. Win
costs 70 appellant 10 abide event. Opinion BY
DI HOTEL folding Corwetherbeo 4 Wood. judy
ment ordered f0r defendant. With costs. opinion
"GusfSnty trust Co. IAutossle, Gum and Choco--
late Co Judgment ordered Tor defendant without
hSof Philip Co 1''New Yorker stats zeituns"
order reversed to the extent stated ~ oploa Tiin ~
$40 costs and dsoufie@e ,bSr, 70 co WIN leave 70
defsndant to withdraw demurrer ard 70 answer "a a,
indicated II PPiaG1 0Pi d sso aus d,sisntins
and voting TO sustain the demurrerS to all the
'A Eijsp McGaire. as adm1H r T. Judgment and
I order affirmed. with costs. No opinion; -
j. r shaushnessy/City Of, New YORK Judgment
peliant 70 abide event opinion BY Scott J. TN
graham. =. j. dissenting ~, ~ r,..... =.
commr Wit dismissed and proceedings affirmed.
with $50 costs and disbursements No opinion,
L PerlgfT Williams Judgment anrned'
we Cora M II Cartel Marin. Judsnen! and order
reversed new tnSl ordered. costs 70 appellant 70
abide event; Opinions by HotehkiSs and Laushlin.
-. (seott dissenting r...,,.. Ard am rud,-
r,snt and orier sfnrned with costs No opinion;
/ GScott and Hotchdss. ~ dissenting on me ground
that 4 vas error 70 elcuae aeend ns 't ,SH ~,
which wss charged
ave and Gerard ave, iooIlt Vulcan R.n 4
/ Sonstruction Co so Henry Lewis Morris ct A.
1914. ~