New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1915-02-21
williams Denies P. S. G..
Had Star Chamber
Turns on Associate.
CONFLUENCE USED,
IS MAYORS REPLY
calf IN Commission Shown by
Pate Case Criticisms. R. T.
Defcd Fender Order.

Prssidsn' NcAnenE ""' o'"e''' WV"
4, came back TO inc Iuo''e "e'N'0e
r.-nissioa q was generally under
..3hs smoke with his masters voice
C.-n,ss,ouc~ Williams. who inter
3D.. --o-aod;rrs Of the legis-
4 r9p'eu -...... ..o..o--
/ stvs investigating commune
l,v 10 deny euphatcaNy that there
ans. .r,-ort.rt conferences of the
ss'' 90 ..,,.h M, 1ol+bie va.
Commlss''" ~ -,
rot invited was JUST "O''' ~ 'OO
. ;,eludcd ,a the quotation marks
l. ,,.ss SHIN. oF bv William Hay
sheu ~ ha4 ID, MIND
uTd. ne s'A'.' -,
,.vstely later commissioner MAI
B.. ,rl.H ought % be the last
'' ...s .o +s1k about secret
ntn ID .'' l-.,
r,5sv.
~ 5o,,. l...4r lust what Mr.. Williams
.....,.,,os ,,.,+h me- -" said
mean g. H., ro
Mayor Mitchell, 'n ms once "heh "e
,,.rd VIA. tho Comm issioner had said
a-.. s.-.--uet5on was that Mr.. Malt
''' -. IA +bor went
be ea"' '--...,:.-,,,, "a effected
BACK 70 ,'' p.'.'', 49,. ms told
youf Vows .'' wa!
MAYOR Answers Williams.
aTbst s not So" shot back the
MAYOR. If know nothing OF the IN
..r1sj rantic= OF the Public Service
COMMISSION. have understood that
Commissioner Naltbie. was more or
is,s isolated there. This is so perhaps
because he was not 1Tiendly WIN tne
corporate interests. hno" ho'n'"s
Of any conferences nee ,..,,. o,rforrod with
as, ~ -. ,,,e,+ors before the
Ar A.-.l.t 80 Voyor repljod:
Oo ..l ''s.,u'.' Ill The conferences
w .,...L b;r, wore on transit
hA'e ."- -. Lafo.re .ba BOARD of
mst'e'> '""- N'..;-,.;a~or Williams is
Lstli.".-' ~. i'.. -, On frequent
nist"he"' a. '' '.''
y. ,,,t.- o.. fr5snepdept a
PIT NaI1u'v -, and whom he
lyO'I0 20 Loca,1eo Of his own
ukes acUon IL - o'
Pisohai 90" 49, -ls,,..5 90 5iscrss his
Mr- MlIcheI 80 - -ronosition 10
Nti'uoe IVA - ,,ork from
- co,,.,co Commission 10 q
ne Public service OTIu'". - ,ioIor
ward 70 DC H"l".N -. ~ i oo
You shaH KhO" my si."0 oo,tod "a
o. the stahu. - ~ Lie
o1rteous lnE''",'"H Io.' o..;.S,do
htTe committee 20 E''e d. "''
en- The matter ,,.,.L;. mil, ro,uyr N
Comhl ssloAy l ..,;,4cn "a.
ne stand "hen lhy . 1,.,.',t,yV r,orn-
tsmes rs hearing on "'G.,'SSL.aS gr a. -,
ifg. The Mayor may ne ne"iu V"
Thursday.
Rate Case Opinion ThwaTted.
a, a. h.,r;r,, roetordav Colonel
az 1'e .I.t..a+ed hat tho famous
49, ~ F5isor rate case. which
vpIH' S,l, -. 30 i,-t ccmnIeted was
WI -H"ri IL. tocaueo the latter
glse'l0e''i ~ .. secpra the data
tsu ho' - hand the
ne net",H ...:.i,o,,t ,,;,,i,g the de-
toihthl 'o''c. - :, ,ro,,ld savo
ANS OF NJ op."'O''' 80 ...,,,,,ors IN
some s. 0oo'0oo " year 10 con. Comsu nart ~
Asnhat'aA ana u'e "'S'''"
The Bronx. c.,- .n,.r,or,.r
further eNlhlprl. .. ;u -, "', ras the
mat eHls Us IN ("V =, o', .ll -, U;Il-
lemafk MADE o! comm .''a.,,t -
isms, when hc heard 'hlS statement ~
reportor. !, a. .0au
ms op."i ~. 80, aS GOO There are
,wsn,y.e,rf, thousand consumers in
Nsnbattan and The Bronx whose bills
40 L. ,her Sl 40 q month. The opin-
Ns Of COMMISSION Maltbio will be of
m sdvartarc whatever to them" he
S.clarod
~" tho hearing was over. Colonel
gsvvsr5 cot on the record the story
AZ ,hc fSbt 10 make the Brooklyn
Rsnid Trar.it COMPANY put tenders on
h sprfscs cars The agitation was
started ir zoos AN order a. issued in
ISOa aud tbrouob a drcary record of
moSifcat;or. adiouraments and eX-
tension of time has come down TO the
n-sso,, 80 Finally an extension
rvSers IN ,.-au4oj N hermit the
eomnsry ,g have until January. 1916,
N 60 -. inter cars. nd until July,
1917 IA foufn its summer cars with
fenders
a. ,b,, was vour star perform
,n,s'n soi5 Mr. HAYWARD, as he
-. -sI - clooe
ust w.ltb;a defend
u "pnen NOI''I' ~ ~ ,,,'rs,,ed in this
" wv Us "C nc" r he would do
ls''ei, nc "So J =, on 70 do over
80. 90
" uul,. L..
renders sur ""''"''
"A man would have peanut oraih
rafting Ground in bushel basket II
he could not improve on something ne
had done once!' snapped the witness
with as near an approximation to heat
As he had exhibited.
Much was made by Colonel Hayward
q an opinion rendered by Commission
,f Maitbie on October 27, 1913, IN
Which he drew a pathetic picture OF
ae wrecking Of humanity by the un,
t,ndercd ears Of the y. X. J. lie READ