davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1915-01-28
JUVENILE COURT
BILL PROPOSED
DELEGATE MoRELAND INTRO
DUcES MEASURE ENIARGING
POWER OF COURTS.
Would Not Create New Office But
Would Make Criminal and Cir
cult Judges Responsible.
Special Dispateh TO the InteIigencer.

epeSiai TO the I~ntelligencer.
CHARLESTON, W. Va, Jan. Fl
\ Juvenile court bill has been intro
duced in the House by Delegate James
X. Moreland, OF MorEantown. Il Is
numbered House bill No. 1893.
The bill In its essential features fol-
lows largely the one introduced in
= by Delegate Warth, OF Cabell
county and which "a passed by tho
House at that session but fa!led Of
passage In III Senate by reason OF
the congested condition Of its calen-
OAR during the last few days of the
term. The bill creates no additional
or separate court tut gives the cir.
cut and criminal court OF the state
the jurisdiction OF a Juvenile court. the.
record OF which is 10 be kept separate
~ IN a juvenile court record book.
The Judge OF the Juvenile court NAV
dispose OF the Juv nle case either by
surrendering him - the regular tribu-
nal IN exceptional cases where the
juvenile methods have proved inef-
Iectiye or where the crime committed
is serious. The trial by the juvenile
court or by the regular tribunal is lcf,
10 the discretion OF the Judge in all
cases depending upon the particular
case n the facts and circumstances
surrounding IL Where the crime com
mitted was due TO boyish pranks or
thoughtlessness OF youth or deIin-
quency In the offender. the court may
dispose OF the child in whatever way
ne thinks best as to punishment or
probation.
Probation Officers.
For the purposes OF the act the.
fnnmRn On 81 H- 5000
state may appoint probation officers.
ana IN the smaller counties OF the.
state ne may make fuch appointments
with the sanction and authority Of he
county or commissioners and 'rs.
county superintendent Of free schools
inc duties Of the probation officers
aTe 70 see mat the probation rrivl-
loges are not abused. that the ORDER
ol the court are carried u and 20
investigate cases.
After submission 20 The vofr-a
juvenile homes or schools for doifn.
gueuts may be established hut only
u the people of the county express
their desire Tor such by vote.
In Thirty-sis States.
Thiry-siX staIes ut tho Union now
have juvenile courts There Is said
10 be 100000 cases In tho United
states coming before the courts
whore the onense Ia due 90 tho youth
~ the culprit or lack Of parental con.
troll and which should not ho punished
hy confinement In jail or prison ln
most % which cases probation works
reform.
The experience Of judge ben V
lindsay With bio Juvenile court OF
Denver made him celebrated through
out the world. and while tho first
juvenile court was cstabIiahf ouIy
about twenty years ago. it now exists
in some form OF other in practically
every civilized nation Norway and
sweden are the exceptions Russia
has a very effective one
Already petitions arc being received
hy The Legislature askInr for thr on.
actment Of such a law
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1915-01-28
M'GILL CASE TODAY
Man Charged With Feloniously As.
Saulting David Long. to Be
Tried In Criminal Court.

George McGin will be arraigned in
criminal court this morning TO answer
an Indictment Of feloniously and ma
nclously assaulting David Long. At
NaFWoud. last fan. McGW was ar.
rested al Martins Ferry. Re az first
refused 20 come back without e1tradi.
non papers. but later agreed 10 come
back without thcm.
McGiH has engaged Attorney ]. r
iiahdlan and thccr promises 10 bs
some 'iun In the way Of legal battles
alI through the trial McGiu Is under
oond and 30 b. not expected that tho
case will finish today.
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1915-01-28
WARRINGTON

MANNlNG1apN, W. Va. Jan. 2T.-A
we pretty home wedding took place A.
the home Of Mr. and Airs. VIM. Nust yes
terday afternoon at $3.50 o'clock. when
their aughte leila NJ. became the
vile OF Charles ~ DouEham. Of Nixon.
W wyoming. The bride was becomingIy
attlred In a beautiful gown Of royal blue
satin and lace and carried a bouquet Of
pink ros = She was attended by her
niece. Miss Edna Nost. who was gnwned
IN blue wolfe and carried pink roses.
SIR. Doughan has been a resident Of
Warrington for several months. being
ehploy-d at Mayors tonsorial parlor4.
Mr r ~. Mayors vas best man and the
ceremony was performed BY Rev. e. o..
pastor Of the II. T.. church. Of
Nhich the bride h a member. Mrr
Il WI and faVorably known
mere. having resided here all her life.
lhey were the recipients OF many b al
tliu4 and ustul presents and Will mike
their home In Warrington.
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1915-01-28
TOBACCO USERS NEED
TO WORRY MUCH NOW

Another reform movement? II il
reported that a number Of Wheeling
ties are perfecting a local here 10 To
afhliated with h main one al New
York known as the Anu-Public To-
bacco league. The principal object OF
the society Is TO prevent by Law men
from using tobacco In public places
and streets. as II Influences youths TO
follow their habits.
II Is said that about two years ago
such a society was organized in New
York and that a number OF societies Ia
nearly every state in the union have
been formed.
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1915-01-28
NEWS BRIEFS

ODD FELLOWS TO vIsrr-The
members 81 Wheeling and Abrahams
Of the local order Of Odd
Elbows Will be visitors at Hebron Camp,
40 - al Martins Ferry this evening.
TO sELEcr CONVENTION DATE
The executive council OF the ohio county
sunday school association will meet
tns evening 70 arrange for the holding
or the annual county sunday school
convention a. well as selecting the date
In DERAILNEHr -Four
toeded freight cars were derailed at
Welis PIT. one mile below CIarington
Yesterday morning on freight train No.
-. No one was Injured and IL was
some time before the track was opened
Tor ranic
the proximity OF the Leuten season the
Columbia club has decided TO postpone
Easter.
AssIsrIHo TIE PooR-The Asso-
ciated Charities at the present time Is
said to be a. desperate al al any time
during the winter season.
GUARANTEES MAY HOLD The
discovery OF q number Of cases Of the
foot and mouth diseases in the Union
Stock Yards At Chicago, may result in
the maintaining OF all present govern
ment guarantees throughout the coun-
try.
TRACTION CARS OFF TRAcK-On
Tuesday evening at Thi~rty-niuth street
lines two cars were thrown on the tTa.s
by bricks that had bulged awards due
TO the thawiuE and freezing weather OF
the past few days.
CONSIDERING MEMBERsHIP AM
PAIGE-The members OF Park Division
Side, are considering another campaign
Tor new members
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1915-01-28

y distressing accident occurred this
morning about II @ lock-. when Vincent
Niehaus. the five year old son OF Mr..
ano MIS- george Niehaus. Of Clayton
aaultlon collided with "A sire { car at
the intersection OF High and Clark burg
streets. while coastiuE down High
street.
The child's head was badly cut and Il
- leAI q MS skull - fractured. The
parents were notlutd and acrounsnt-d
ny br. Moore the child wa taken on IN.
return car TO Cooks hospital. where AN
operation was performed.
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1915-01-28
About People
Movements OF individuals 20
and From :l,s City.
AT Il HOTELS.

Stamm-J. W. Bull. New Martins.
Vile; ]. W. Bryan. Follansbee: Chas.
Holman. Harrison. o.; J. f. Carpen-
ter. Troy. o.. A. r. Gilmore, Hun
dred; Wayne Franklin. Ira NJ. Frank
lin. Brewster. o.: A. d.. Ayers, Hun
drcd; w. W. Mcfarland. Fairpoint,
o.; c. A. Kildon. Bethesda. o.
Grand central-John o. Cole.
Smithield. o.; r. II. Read. New Phil.
adelphia. o.; James Peabody, Fair.
mont: Georgia Koom. weems, o.; A.
u. Herrold. St Cloud; J. W. Wright.
Belmont. o.
meLure-L. C. Kincheloe. CIarks.
burg; F. f. Barber. Brewster. o.; j.
II. Duncan. Dillonvile. o.; w. r.
Goodsell. Charleston: A. r. Clayton.
Newark; a. L. Frosch. Little Hook
ing: Joseph VI. Johnson. Mansfield. O.
srunswiek-A. J. Ashmore. Zanes-
vile. o.; II. c. Schultz. Littleton:
Charles r. Soliday, Woodsfeld. o.;
!. J. Campbell. Littleton: Henry Ed
munds. Adena, o.: F. F. French.
Clarksburg.
Mr.. and Mrs. Arch Gaines. of So
IWenty-fourth street. are the proud
parents OF a nine-pound baby boy.
Miss Helen Bailey spent Monday
ana Tuesday at the home of her
grandmother. Mrs. Deborah White. al
C~olerain.
Miss Gladys Dexter. OF Providence.
K. J., Is a guest of friends in the city.
Mr and Mrs. Henry Kochert. Of
S~tcubenVille, are guests OF relatives
on North Main street.
Secretary \. T. Arnold, OF the West
Nirginia Sunday School Association
viii return this evening from Sutton
and will on Saturday leave for Pres
ton county. where he viii spend sew
eral days In the interest Of Sunday
school work.
Mr.. Joseph Dorer Is detained at his
home on Jacob street an Of
illness.
Mr.. Louis Duga has resumed his
duties IS stenographer at the Penn.
sylvania freight station. following a
visit Of a few days spent at Pitts
burgh.
Mr.. Thomas W~astings. repairman at
the b. q o. shops. is of duty on &C
count o. an injured hand.
Mr.. William Boswell. an employe Of
the Pennsylvania railroad. is detained
AZ his home in North Wheeling on ac-
count Of illness.
Mrs. Mary Rogers. OF this city, Is
the guest Of her mother. Mrs. A. D..
Work in Sistersville.
Mrs. Sara Drum &C. the guest OF her
parents and children.
Mrs Frank Weaver. OF M~oundsville.
spent Wednesday in the city. the
guest OF friends.
Miss Marios Riester r. the guest OF
friends in Parkersburg for a few days.
Mr.. James Ewing left for Charles
ton. 10 the interest OF the workmen's
compensation law.
Hand and Mrs. T. s. Bailey left for
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1915-01-28
NEW AUTO cLUs
New Or~'r vaNo~ B~'r7 Formed %
Cr.'- Va"ry Ohio

or-e a T H.fH'yeV Of fr,
O. U Nr..r h.. HI'rr r"Hf. Ia n.e
nr .rr on detailed report NJ mo work
Irrs % hIH organization FOR tho Noble
county fOhioI Automobile Association
iu compliance with a request received
Yesterday from Nj Pred Combs Of
neIle Valley. Ohio who i7 assisting ir
norfecilrg on auto club in that
section
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1915-01-28
OPEN CAMPAIGN
Ohio Valley General Hospital viii
Begin Campaign for Funds
on February ?

a campaign for funds will be in
auguratcd BY the Ohio Valley General
Hospital. beginning February 2. and
continuing for ten working days The
different committees are now organ
lied and have secured n large room
Boz the Huh building for he~adquartcrs.
through the kindness Of Mr some
born.
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1915-01-28
NEW ZEPPELIN TO
SALUTE THE EMPEROR.

GENEVA. VIA r.r Jan O. fe %
M -Tho newest and fastest Jr r4 n
IIrIEihIe balloon raf r.rafrrHf
hIInf equipped Per war and H o.. stated.
with Count I.rrn1.n aboard f#r
FricferIchsfHfau fHia m1rnIrr Ir fine
weather f1 raIrfe Emperor william 17
Dts birthday TIH H'rfrfIf. arHrr.
gIorNH RuI Join flr Nuffl aaa aerial
feet
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1915-01-28
OF CHANCE MUST STOP
In THIS CITY, SAYS LEYLAND
ORDER WAS ISSUED TO ALL
MEMBERS OF THE DEPART.
MENT YESTERDAY.
This Includes Punch Boards, Dice and
All Other Forms Of Gambling,
Says the Order.

Chief Of Police Leyland Yesterday
Eave out the final order concerning
candy boards, dice boxes and other
forms OF gambling that are claimed
10 be prevalent in the city. Tho chief
said last night that the statement ap-
pearing In b evening paper TO the
effect that IAN forms OF gambling
must cease. be they poker games or
punch boards" was entirely correct.
This cleanup order came immedi-
ately following n second conference
with three OF the cleanup" commit
tee yesterday morning. The commit
tee yesterday was composed OF Mr.. J..
y. Citizen Rev. r. L. Brininstool and
Dr. =. A. Hildreth. The chief saws
that the law Is plain on these forms
Of gambling and that he has the sup
port of all good citizens OF The city
in the work.
The chiefs order TO his officers was
Notlfy everyone that m OF
chance. dice shaking. punching boards
and gambling In every form must stop
at once"
Complying with this order. the Of
hcers started on their work OF notiH-
cation Immediately after the order
was given and from all appearances
last might. II was being pretty general
ly obeyed. The rattle Of dice was
growing DINNER and DINNER; the
board to punch for candy had disap-
peared n more than one person
found himself stuck with a bunch OF
Goods on his hands. n is not thought
that anyone will oppose the order.
Sweet are the uses OF adversitv 10
quoted the confirmed duoter.
7 believe 81" rrtortcd the dissatisfied
me but somehow or other. Z don't
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1915-01-28
WIN Lecture.

one OF the anti-saloon workers Of
Canton. o.. will lecture In the ". G. T. u.
hall sunday afternoon at 3 o'clock. under
the auspices OF the Colerain Union Sab
bath school.
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1915-01-28
novelty shower.

4 party Of young ladies gave a novelty
shoNer ior Mrs. Albert Stewart at the
home Of Mr.. and Mrs. y. n UamiIton
iast evening. Mrs. Stewart was former
~ Miss Anna Yeagcr. who's wedding
louh place some time ago. Many pretty
ceiNcd by the newly wedded couple.
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1915-01-28
rRAcrIoN CABS oFr TRAcK-
G0LERAIN


COLERAIN. o.. Jan. 27-Thc Farm
ers Institute was a great success. the
afternoon and evening sessions were
well attended. the hall being filled 70 its
upmost capacity.
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1915-01-28
Death Of child.

Phiilis. the 2 year old daughter OF
Rev. and Mrs. J. o. Huff OF jericho.
died last night at . o'clock from an at
tack Of mombranous Group.
The remains Will be taken 10 their
former home In East Liverpool. Ohio.
FOR interment.
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1915-01-28
ALMOST FATAL C0ASTING
ACCIDENT ON SOUTH SIDE
RIVER NEWS

Coin down. That's what old man
Ohio river f. doing At present and he
viii Keep on the decline until the snow
mclts sufficiently or heavy rains fan ~
utc within the neat fe~
Ca O. rivers above are falling.
Llite Ice was running Ia the Ohio
yesterday. The river at this point telt
"A ltal loot yesterday. the stage being
> ic,t 2 inches last night.
Few tow buats with empti,s ar. uaas-
lng up Tor the Pittsburgh harbor. The
arrived early yesterday morn
ING from Pittsburgh tor Charleston. The
LIotfty came w last evening from Mat
nHIuras ana Will leave this morning AZ
1850 O'Clock for that point.
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1915-01-28

makes sick
skins we'll

No matter how long you have been
tortured r#1 ..frur,I by itching
l1rnI raw or v h.mar
300. on bod. .r
G H' .r
o. &c s.s o. I. l..r
Ir f..tv.v r ute.
.I almost Dsgry c.so galr rs.n g,.r
uel so quickly sou feel ashamed Of
t.s money you throw avay on useless
treaturnts Avoid limitations.
PEE mol O.Hfr-rf ard EsrIr4I SEQ sis-f
rHsT rinuIHs Eartfrr'a arf "snFrar a.U
ll aI draEEsIa prstcIud b. deeteF
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1915-01-28

DAVIS ISLAND DAHL feet, sta
~tiOuary. clear.
cloudy.
PARKERsBURG-I42 feet. falling:
cloudy.
on CITY feet. stationary: cloudy.
NAltltEN-L7 feet. stationary: fair.
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1915-01-28

Sweet are the uses or adyersitv 10
quoted the confirmed uuoter.
believe 81" ratortcd the Dissatisfied
one but, somehow or other don't
iJ"-Philadelphia Ledger.
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1915-01-28

ciated Charities at the present time Is
Kept busy assisting the poor which Is
said to be as desperate as at any time
during the winter Heaann.
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1915-01-28
PoBTPoNE MINarnrLa-OnIn


Columbia club has decided TO postpon
the proposed minstrel show until ate
Easter.
Gunnison news-champion., 1915-07-23

has been regularly made sssce.
II the peoI,le of the county ar~
Wiling to pay this sum for an
audit in addition to the regular
audit bv state officials. II they
want to pay this sum to a man
who has already made an audit
by virtue of his olhce, thea. they
may praise these two county
for their acts. II
they do not believe that such
actions by these commissioner
we're justified. and if they object
to this particular contract in
volving this large sum for this
audit, then, they should hold
these two county commissioners
responsible 1t is for the tax
payers to decide
Gunnison news-champion., 1915-07-23
TAX VALUATIONS IRE Qvts-
TONED By STATE EXPERTS

Two Representatives of the Colorado
State Tax Commission have been in
Gunnison during the week, looking over
the valuation records of Assessor W. T.
Hartman and comparing them with last
year. with other counties and with
county records.
Mr. John T. Brown and Mr.. Rudolph
johnson are the gentlemen and they
assert that while the county valuations
are generally all right, that in their
opinion ranch land is not high enough.
They claim that comparison shows that
on certain pieces of property valued by
the assessor at sl97, $50, trust deeds are
outstanding for s2O1, 900. On another
bunch of property assessed at $39, 225,
there are mortgage deeds recorded for
$3s, 54s, and on still another group of
ranches, assessed at sl47. 755. the con-
sideration named in recent warranty
deeds amounts to $240, SAC.
1t is claimed that this proves assessed
valuations are too low.
Gunnison news-champion., 1915-07-23

Frank E. Dean and wife came up
from Grand junction in their car to en-
low the celebration. They arrived late
Thursday evening.
Gunnison news-champion., 1915-07-23

question: the d,scretian ~ q
board ct county commissioners w
ordering an audit on = cert asn
existing state of facts. Also a
taxpayer has a r,ght to ohjs-st to-
the payment G given sum oi
money Tor a particular audit. A
court may not sustain that
objection but the Taxpayer has
right 10 iBterpose it. the lsw ts-
ing as it is nov and as announced
IN this recent decision.
The county officials who We're
IN office at the time when the
commissioners made the contract
with NulRix did not object to an
audit. The TACT that Whslen
and Wiley as majority members
d the board afterwards asked
Mulnix to make an audit by
Nhtur VI uts Otfl't SHONtu tfidt
an audit was not objected to.
Nor do any of these officials fear
IN the least any action by Mulnix
because of the audit he has made.
What was objected to was the
fact that the order made by Me
Dowell aud Gillaspey appeared to
be purely a political audit and
act. Further objection was made
because OF the exorbitant sum
that these commissioners agreed
to pay Mulnix, the sum being
Sis, s,WO. 90 for an audit going
back six wears This objection
was merited because the ordering
of this audit was one OF the first
acts of these commissioners after
going into Office TLey did not
wait for a time to look into the |
affairs of the Offices. and, in the
course of their business, ascer-
tain something of the conditions
OF the county. No they did not
do that, but instead Immediately
after going into Office ordered an
audit just as if it was a settled
policy of a political organization.
They did not even wait until July I
when a regular audit OF state
officials was to be made which /
would have given them some
idea as to the Justification of a
further audit. 1t seemed to be a |
studied attempt by these two
officers, as representatives OF
party, to Immediately use their
Office and the peoples money to
blacken the records of officials
from another party.
Now every man must answer
for his acts Gillaspey and Me /
Dowell put the machinery in
operation which involves the ex-
penditure by the county OF
S1S00.O0 for an audit which had
been made regularly before and
Gunnison news-champion., 1915-07-23
COLORED SINGERS

The Williams Colored Singers gave
Gunnison folks the finest treat in their
line which an audience has listened 10
since the famous Fisk Jubilee singers
gave two concerts in the old Methodist
church IN 1880. That was a long time
ago. but a great many heard both
troupes of artIsts and express an un-
animous opinion. There was no weak
spot in the program. The 400 people
who heard it were delighted from start
to finish. The singers were not only
generous with their encores, but went
up to the Normal and gave treat to
the students without charge,
Gunnison news-champion., 1915-07-23
DOCTOR NINE IS VALUED
IT VERY HIGH FIGURE

Ed. N. Rogers, mining expert of
New York City, accompanied by the
superintendent of the Smuggler mine
at Aspen rs personal Representatives of
ID. NJ. Hyman, were outgoing passen-
gers on the Rio Grande Saturday, hav-
ing just come in from a second inspec-
ton of the new ore discovery at the
Doctor mine 1t is understood that the
owners of the lease have been offered
something like = hundred thousand for
their showing. but are holding out for
double that sum- There are fourteen
four horse teams now hauling ore and
twenty-five more wanted at once,
Gunnison news-champion., 1915-07-23

One of the prettiest cars seen on the
Rainbow Route this year was a five
passenger Cadillac which stayed from
Saturday till Monday at Eastman's gar
age. 1t was owned by L. C. Jinke. a
retired business man of Chicago, who is
on three months trip through the
westr He was delighted with this coun-
try and the good roads over the noun
tains, and his only regret va. that not
having practiced the art of trout fishing
he did not have much success in that
sport this trip.
Gunnison news-champion., 1915-07-23
Glory m The. Waste
{ Funds

Certain statements were made
in last week issue OF che Guani-
son Republican concerning the
case of Theodore Davis. Tax
payer. The Board oi County
Commissioner os Gunnison
County. and II T.. MulHix. The
News-ChampioR told the interest
ing story of this case two weeks
ago, aud stated that two men on
a foruer board of couRty com
nsisssoDers We're responsible for
the expenditure by Gunn'son
county which the decision of this
case in fsvor of the county in
volved. because these two men
contracted for the audit. The
decision 81 the court of appeals
in this case involves the exI,endi-
ture by Gunpison county II
sO0.O0.
A consideration of the facts of
the case and other facts relative
to the auditing the books Of the
county shows that IA. T.. Mulpix
wl.o prosecuted the ease in the
couri ii appeals to compel the
taxpayers a this county to pay
him the exorbitant sum OF
x1sOOOO to make an audit is
the same man who madean audit
of the books during the present
year by virtue of his Office as
state auditor. Another fact is
that Mcdowell and Gillaspey
went into office in January 1913,
and that a regular audit by state
officials was due in July OF that
same year. And no county
official had a right to question
the regular bienniel audit BY
state auditors, until there was
some reason to question it and
that reason has never been
shown A further fact which
must be shown is that immedi-
ately after number of the old
officers went out of Office in 1915,
the board Of county commission
ers composed of W. II. Whalen,
Elmer Wiley and W. A. Gillaspey
requested the auditor of state.
III. L. Mulnix to make an audit.
10y virtue OF his office, as soon as
possible.
The NewslChampion is not
questioning the court of appeals
as To its sound and well studied
decisions, and in this case it's de-
elsion that the Board OF county
commissioners have a right to
order an audit. But We hold
that any taxpaye, has a right to