The Detroit times., 1914-09-18
i've Heard Things Rejecting
On Your Good Standing" Is
Retort Courteous of
4 Famous Sleuth
POLOGIES FORCED
FROM PAIR BY COURT
|efense Wins Victory When
4 "Brennan's" Reports Are
I Ordered Produced


|mand for the reports made by
brennan" on the progress OF his
tn to test the honesty OF the aid
nen as the witnesses for the prose-
Ion insist on terming 1t.
1.-THE defense Is on q fishing ex-
iition.' interrupted the prosecutor.
We have right to know IL those
PORTS vary from the testimony Civ
here by Burns and Brennan in
ted Mcnamara. Those reports
ong to the people and are not the
peity OF Mr.. Frazer"
This same question came up when
-ennan" was on the stand several
20 ago. The judge reserved de-
lon at that time.
Must Produce Reports.
have determined that the defense
right to have those reports
duced In court" ruled the Judge.
| understand that the defense
fntains there are many descrep-
lies between the notes and the tes-
ony. / will rule on whether the
tiers are material as they are
light out In cross-examination."
This was decided victory for the
ense.
Those reports contain information
corning other people and Mr.. Nc
mara has no right to secure that
Prmation involving other crimes
ether men," insisted the prose-
br.
The state, the counsel for the de-
be and myself will go over the re-
~. ..,kIl l.
fdential," said the Judge. "As far
Gilman is concerned these reports
competent TO test the veracity Of
BurIs' testimony"
he defense Immediately subpoened
prosecutor for the reports.
ia your business. Mr.. Burns, you
1, necessary. do you not, to sane
lying and Misrepresentation as q
ms to an end?" was McNamaras
question to the witness.
call II subterfuge." answered
hs.
call II lying and misrepresenta-
exclaimed Mcnamara.
Gall II what you WILL" was the re-
k OF the witness.
Tou know what Brennan's methods
In this case?" continued Nc
hara.
as far as | directed him, yes"
Fcu knew that he misrepresented
name and occupation?"
Not Connected With Wabash
lrns admitted that Brennan" was
connected with Wabash and never
any Wabash money in connec-
with the bribery.
knew Andrew Green put up the
ley, but did not know where he
IT," was the gist of Burns answer
fire of questions from McNa-
cNamara appealed TO the Judge to
ion the witness against loqua-
8 answers.
four honor can control the injec-
OF extarnious matter into these
vers," said Mcnamara.
want to be careful he doesn't do
framing on me-" interrupted
hs.
lou do the framing" yelled Nc
ARA
Fou do It, yourself" retorted
hs.
Calls Burns Dirty scoundreI.
ou do 1t yourself" exclaimed Nc
ara In white neat. you know
are dirty scoundrel when you
that"
have had things refiicting on your
ding" fiared Burns.
he court interferred at this stage.
fr. McNamara's standing In this
b above reproach." observed
Judge. He has always conducted
belf as a gentleman. and I want
to apologize to him for having
you heard things about him that
ct on his standing"
rms expressed his willingness tn
pgize.
tow want Mr.. Mcnamara to
bgize to you,.' continued the
3. "Otherwise shall fine him. I
no language OF that kind In this
tNamara deferred apologizing.
hwhile Burns rendered a second
bgy to the court.
ands That Mcnamara Apologize.
viii stop the trial II you do not
bgize," said the Judge to McNam-
"The witness has apologized and
are no better than he is"
am very sorry that I called him
was McNamara's response.
hat Is not It'll want you to apol-
TO Mr.. Burns" insisted the
/. Mcnamara did so. and q re-
was taken.
ter recess Mcnamara again went
Burns, asking him to name one
that Brennan" did without the
ttion OF the witness.
did not tell him to arrange a
pot with Schreiter and I stopped
replied the witness.
Pgarding instructions Burns gave
imam" during the investigation of
ban, the witness said he told him
De q suitable cover and event
approach them in regard to
matter OF legislation TO see II
Aldermen would accept money for
votes.
Approved Of BrIbe Plot.
admitted that he approved OF
plan to approach Gilman and
him q bride for his vote. Also
limited sanction OF other misrep-
Nations made by Brennan" to
the honesty of Gilman by OFFER
him money for his vote.
That did you meet with Thomp-
Green and others tor In Van
- Office on the morning OF July
was one OF McNamara's ques-
p witness said q discussion took