Manchester Democrat. [volume] (Manchester, Iowa) 1875-1930, 1914-12-30
HOBSON'S PLAN LOSES AFTER
+. Il. LONG F'eAr-vorE 1917
": TO 1889. y
BALLOT is 60 VOTES SHORT
Two Thirds Majority Needed to Adopt
U. S. Prohibition Perpendicular
+ Engages In Bitter Exchanges During
D Long Debate on the Floor. IA.

eSSssAAASs
An affirmative vote Of two-thirds was
required to adopt the resolution.
The house had struggled with the
question for more than ten hours OF
remarkable debate. ~. E. n
! It was one Of the most stirring. con-
tests of recent days in congress. Rep
-resentative Hobson closed the general
debate, which was participated in by
all the house leaders, many Of whom
were repeatedly cheered by men and
women in the crowded galleries.
Before the final roll call Representa-
tive Hobson presented an amendment
which was adopted, giving to "the con-
gress and the states concurrently the
power to enforce the prohibition pro-
vision by needful legislation y. -
i An amendment offered by Repre-
sentative Adamson to give the states
absolute control Of legislation under
the proposed prohibition amendment
was voted down on a rising vote, 179
to 49,. 49, 80 4 i#@ - .>- ''-&
3 AS a vote was ordered on the reso-
luton itself, Representative Hobson
made a final dramatic move. "s ",
"Mr. Speaker" he said, 81 wish to
ask whether any member of this house
who has financial interest in the
question now pending, who owns stock
In distilleries or breweries, who owns
saloon or who has property leased
to liquor interests, can under the rules
vote on this question:" S-. ..
The speaker explained that the
precedents held that il a member was
affected as one Of a class, the rule
would not prevent his voting, but that
such questions were usually left to the
member himself. ,{syr =: IT, s-'.53si .
An amendment by Representative
Mann to submit the prohibition
amendment to state conventions called
for the purpose was defeated in ris-
ing vote, 1877 to 1893. This was the first
vote of the night, Mr.. Mann de-
manded yea and nay vote and the
long roll call was begun. ~ 2s. "a
The Mann amendment was defeated
on the roll call by a vote Of 210 to 1885,
the advocates OF the Hobson resolu-
ton generally lining up against It.
e Another amendment presented by
Representative Mann proposed abso-
lutte prohibition of the manufacture,
transportation, Importation and sale
Of intoxicating liquors" for any pur-
pose. @ r.
If we are to have prohibition" MI
Mann said. "let US have prohibition
that will prohibit" - e..
The amendment was defeated on
rising vote, 209 to II, after sharp ex-
change between Representative Mann
and Hobson. sl"7.. I'll
Following this. Representative Hob
son offered several perfecting amend
ments to his resolution. The. hrst
altered the phraseology Of the first sec.
ton Of the proposed constitutional
amendment and included prohibition
against any deportation" OF intoxi-
eating liquors. It was adopted with
out division. &;
s Representative Morrison's substitute
to prohibit interstate commerce In in
toxicating liquors was defeated. 213
to Al. is5.i% '<'
The prohibition issue, long q state
problem, came for the first time be-
fore congress. s,5t5s, 80
1 Members and spectators when they
entered the chamber were attracted
by the unusual display of large num-
Der Of posters arranged on easels In
front of the speakers desk: In large
type, easily read across the hall. were
legends such as these: alcohol has
more Il victims than tuberculosis
Crime is caused by drink and
Liquor fills the asylums. d.
The rule to take up the resolution
carrying the amendment was adopted
without roll call. {. IN
The only war talk in the debate came
when Representative Campbell OF Kan
sas referred to the fact that the car
Of Russia had prohibited liquor OF all
kinds throughout his empire. He also
read the speech Of Emperor William
eli Germany to the German naval ca
diets on the subject of self-restraint
in the matter OF drinking. d T. q
.e.-E .tI~>,- Asrscy