The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-05
APPELLATE DIVISION DECISIONS
Complete List Handed Down Nester-
day by the First Department.


The following decisions were handed
down by the Appellate Division. First
Department. yesterday:
WILLIAM II Kins ". George II. Broad
hurst rsr,Sdent. judgment reversed. new
trial ordered, costs to appellant 70 abide
insrsham. Z. j settle order on noticc.
John Ia Msrea respondent VS. Atlantis
10 u Pi to abide event; opinion By
The People , ss rel kd~ xS j. far RELY
Rss .ss &C. TSsa' M Wa old. af mem
/ with SO costs and disbursements, on the
M HihSI decided b IN. coar, Of Appeal.
NqY Il. d i,i, order nisd y. Fred.
.rits s"t Lsnea.'sr' A. f.s TpR%' judgment
and order reversed, ne" TIA. ORDERED co.'s
Laushiin. ,Dowllns ana ilotchkiss J. j.
disssntnsj settle order on, notice
compIoller. respondent order aT!rmei.
by Hotchkiss. J. ungraham. T. j. dissent
In tn, matter OF wi,iism Emmett
superintendent, &c. respondent. Richmond
Radiator company, appellant order mod
ned as stated In opinion Snd as mSIinsd AZ
ham. P j ana Ho,chk.ss, oHotcnAi's.
Hens.sisef l. Cirii. 4; receiver! appel
ments opln.on 10y Mclaughlin. j order
filed -,...,.
o'S ha'' w f.S 4qo'H' caRaPa"e
company respond'nt Judgment n,. Tetsr'' a.
abli. event opinion boy clarke. J. Settle
Catherine 81 FuNe- ~ admS appellant
vs. Mucshy & Gibson AMI another. resp"n-
denis JadEment ana order r,yeFsed' ,b brm
event. opinion by SCOTT } settle order
Julia Ksay and another. appellant v.
Nj hael Sru.h respondent prle- AZ
opinion by LauEhun. order ned.
Thomas u'der>n. respondent. - Thomas
80 'S So.,. a lhS d,.eursemsn,. ana motion
denied. with SO costs ami demurrer sus
tanned opinion by Mclaughlin. }. settle
Ihorna. ,ra,mer r.sponaen& -. A ,,tHa
mcn men and order reversed new new 'rs ordered
cost. to appellant 20 aba" event opinion
! Rudolph G. vor Bc>cr. respondent. " Nin q.
isret Nils COMPANY, 1ppe' ant Judgment
snd "r4,r rSyers"d S6 r's's o sTG COW rI
t iaurhlln, J se,te order On NOTICE
!, simon Gufsky r"spondcnt :" ran
with so costs and disbursements and mo.
ION. .rs9,ed win 80 a. Go opinion by
, Cnor'es Horvi,l appellant; ". Hor,h Brit.
ish & Mercantile Insurance company OF
l.enssn and Eh,oh,rEh T,...nde3r @ ,dg.
q incr affirmed without cost. pp'nion hy
q Mclaughlin, J. -, sr'to. order on. wolfe.
= John 4 Anderson. defendant order of
NJ Iasigrc ,;ny r'srr,.i ana G,de, "' ny
a ana G''hursou~7's % srp",' order u' VI
Justice r"Sc r"vers'd with So COT, '"1
by 'Norkc. ! ~~''., uri.r. ur notice
G.ore. r A-rh',, and So. '"-. -.spor
= order re,erssd si'h $40 cost, euI ,.,Nu--~
: men's ana motion d-ui"d w''r - costs
. opia,an 10y ,M'i".es6t.o. "-arr o.'i
= Western Union re'ee-aph r"rr.0'. arp'i
J 'unt order modified rs y.'~i iu "-i"'
10 and as mcin.d .fh.w"l Ni'h"u' ,'s'-
- Op'nion per curi,'n sect" order ou ro'ioe
It fHny Fi'k o. a., "rP' IN, So J"mcs @
70 new trial ordered costs 20 appellants .
o ahide vent Opinion per curtain S"''A
= Herman M.rNowi',. srr~iar'. y, r.,'ur
20 lAndeman Ts,ponicn, 3rd'r 'fhrm"'
m ing ] dissen,irel ord~r r.,i
70 Robert | Cur-An respondent IS Angus
70 opp.nh"im'r. imP'eaact app. ant judo
t. costs opinions 4y M.i"HEh.'n 'ui Ho''h
NJ Richardson pres appellant " Joseph II
4, Nand"rg-if'. re'p'nn'u' Judgment rcv"rs"d
~ abide event On'nion ,, Hp.rhki-, J IN
30 rrsham and bow 'ns. ! dissent
10 len ~ May Sore- imp c,d'd orpc .a0'
N. 20 app'l,n' ." abide even, opinion b
s. DOW Ing J. Sc''" order on r0;rr
n Mirsar., T'' p4s.io. [g'n"SG'",s r, VI
ant order affirmed with SO costs aud 3 ..
Sn u Win .ra'e TO arp...ant to Win
% costs Opinion BY LAugh.in !. Ordc
. Tenement House Department Of New Yorp
, appellant, V, Lucy A Mcpeyi't, rrspondcn'
Determination stnrNed with costs Opinion
Mci%urhiin ana powli n' u ,'@ a.sSr am
al The same .. so, ,oo & 20. Manha,,,
al An DO
or SO costs ana disbursements 40 opinion
Iioh,rt Mlele respondent ". sal.r
3, a H@rr"Ssi n, a. wpB'"6nt judgment an
81 H%,chkis'' = or Gea" a ,'''' o'"''"
~ IN ~ he"s r. A,.'rjGo re;Pomasn, nine
on Judgment reversed aud complain, Gismi,se.
y, WITH costs Opnion by Hoichkss SCI
q, william Rosen1weig respondent "
Os Se'en'g fGH,ih SFes, Holding Comrsny ,
n.S i- o oa9fd4s5 c S.n 1,'er -
ss lants to abide ''.rt opinion by Clarke.
az Rose @ HARRISON, respondent " Ga
g ian in G-asr r. Se.hin Ana A Ss2 Gprc
-, srtiir order on notice ."
III 20 defed D"}"''" Ja fi Of
plalnun v. BRADLEY il rh'ynps II al t.
"; those appearing IN ,Ss am az, raia S6Gs o,
"a OF the estate Options nv lngr,haul. =.
To- and Downing, tpoNiiug & scott !
- dissenting order r.ei
=, Emcine Roach, respondent ~ Ot'o l.,
~ renee aud another. appellants Judgmei
81 modified as directed IA opinion and ~ mod
"a / ned affirmed, with costs 20 responder
'' opinion bv Downing. Settle order d
- notice
he In the matter OF Ludlow av.rn. ord.
m ! reversed. With $40 costs aui dIshursruprf
Irr and report oi commissioners cnnhrua
10 opinion hy Scott !. Settle order on motto
Alpha P"rtant Cement Comrany rospo,
. d"ut, y, Hnh,l'l MO Construction q,
81, aGpellau Judgment affirmed, with cost
RI Ths. NE - New York, rc>pond,rl y
at. mont affirmed, with costs No op.n,o
OF George Morls. appeuanr. - city OF ~e
'gt affirmed, with costs No opinion. ora
TT hed
Tho People az rel Martin Davis r.'aic
y vs william y Baker As commissioner r
mt spondent Writ dismissed and prorcrdluI
cs affirmed, with $50 Gusts and disbursement
No opinion. order Gei
samuel Rosennaum appellant, Va p
Roth ~ ~. respondent Judgment and ORD
reversed, now trial ordered. costs 20 ann,
~, Ian TO abide event Opinion by Clarke,
Ies ceased pccree anirmed. with coats, ori
" ION hy powline ! unsrahSm. p, j. al
re-. EVELYN \ stump as adminls'tatriv, plni
'2S nc. ~ william Burns. defendant T.