davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04
Rcd Carnation RivRlIcd.

Toastmaster Tlerncy paid a tribute 20
the distinguished and brilliant dean 90
the hotel business. George g. Boldt. that
brought forth whoops a. .oud as the Wal
dorf has heard IN long time. NJ. Boldt
In the meantime bowling his head modestly
and permitting his complexion to swap
colors with his red carnation until the
carnation actually began to appear pink
IN comparison.
Mr.. Carlisle told how much more won
derful are the roads built before and since
he became state Highway Comm ssioner,
especially since, than any other state
roads in the country Mr.. Page laid stress
ON the Automobile Clubs slogan. see
New York state first and told the hotel
men how much it would he 10 their ad-
vantage to sing the praise OF the auto
mobile roads o. the State.
Vt the speakers table were Francis
Y Balm. George H. Sweeney. President
Thomas Green OF the New NorN CITY
Hotel Association. County clerk William
= Schneider Fred ". Rockwell OF the
Ten Eyck, Albany, and the Rev. James
r. WATSON.
Besides President McGlynn aud Treas
urcr Tlerney the hotel men during their
midday convention reelected George \.
Farnham of Saratoga Springs vlce-presi-
dent. Mark Caldwell secretary and \. II.
Rcnnie of Albany assistant secretary.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04
Pessunisn Butchered to
Make Hotel Mems Feast
Who Cares for Cost of High Living When 1t Can Be Made
Out Of Countrys Progress and Prosperity? Is
Toast of Four Hundred at Dinner.


Cod. Tortue verte claire a rAnslaise, a
lot OF that raids. celeri and smandeo fxin's.
straight through filet de sole a la Travt-
alta whole group of Medallion de filet de
boeuf aux champienons, not to mention
slathers of boiled pommes and some of
hose haricots and Boitrlne de-
But John McGlynn. reelected president
OF the S.ate association during the after
noon. is. up and Grating. Toastmaster
Edward NJ Tierney of Binghamton. re-
elected treasurer yesterday, introduced
President John az he had introduced the
other speakers. State Highways Com
missioner John y. Carlisle. William Page,
preslden: OF The Now York Athletic Club,
and Mr.. Boldt.
"a pessimist." said Mr. McGlynn. to
Gull bu- a few OF his many thoughts that
brought forth applause. is a man who
pulls down all the blinds and then kicks
about the darkness
Every body--Mr. McG!ynn naturally
had something TO say about the war early
has his idea of the way that war ough;
to be fought 60 20 the bar OF any OF
your hotels and hear them discussing Il
between drinks. They fight the war al
most as hard as they fight the highballs
one man will tell YOU about having the
fieet bottled IN and the rest get right
into the ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS naturally
In anything bottled
Farmer Brown brings two dozen eggs
to town" Mr.. McGlynn concluded his
argument that there is no real reason
for financial depression. He sells them
for so cents dozen. That's more money
than he ever got for eggv before in his
life
He buys 10 cents worth Of oats for his
horse. lie buys ten cigars for another
10 cents and Therefore has a dollar left.
He takes that and buys a green velvet
hat that looks az II ii cost S.. Doesn't
everybody get the best Of IT. The fellow
that buys the eggs at 60 cents gets so
cents a dozen for them The man that
sells the farmer the hat makes 40
cents net profit on l.. The farmers got
the funniest hat in the reighhorhood and
the man that sells him the cigars knows
that the mex; time he comes to town he'll
buy pine"
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04
GOT PAID FOR "ACHE"
LIKE NINE. YALERI'S
Miss Atlee Testifies Pullman
Company "Settled" for Suf-
fering After Meal.
BRAISED BEEF FROM CANS

Judge Augustus n. Hand and jury
| in the United states District Court heard
| yesterday the details of the trip OF the
Pullman car Cadmus. Capt. William II.
| Hall. which left the West Shore Terminal
| In Weehawken on August 10, 1910 for
Lake Mohonk In the Catskills. IL was on
| this Journey that Nine. Della NJ Valeri,
a vocal teacher OF l744 Broadway con-
| tracted her four year "tummy ache" for
which she is suing the Pullman Company
for $4,000
From the testimony taken at the first
| session Of the trial IL developed that Nine,
Naeri had AZ least two companions In
misery on the train. Both Miss Susan
Boyce and Miss Caroline l.. Alice testified
that they had suffered from headache and
nausea after eating OF the provisions in
! tho buffet OF the Pullman car. II seems
that the article OF 'itt which the three
women had in common was praised beef
Miss A'lee lives at 80 broadway, White
Plains She said that she felt the effects
VI the food most when riding in horse
drawn carriage from the railroad station
to n hotel at Lake Nohonk.
How did YOU fee, that night asked
Carl Steadman Brown. attorney for the
plaintiff
81 can't swear os to that" said the wit
ness. but the Pullman Company settled
with me soon after"
Miss Atlee offered no information as 10
Z VIVA NitUf NNP Did'Fi WI I'I SN'll''I
ache. or what was moro to the point. how
| much the Pullman Company gave her
for y
Nine valerl will probably tell on cross
examination Of he- loss Of pupils bccaus"
of her stomach acNe She says she taught
Latella Martin and other opera singers ~
note.
one Of tho most interesting witnesses
on the stand Yesterday was Skipper Billy
Han IL the Cadmus Skipper Hall who
Is co.orcd, but only family said he had
been q Pullman potter 70 some time
and "kuowed good victuas' when he saw
them ON the eventful cruise Skipper
BillN said he had served two meat orders.
two soup orders and no oranges or table
water.
There's q discrepancy somewhere. Nine
Nalcri said she had both oranges and
table water. Her two corrohorative wit
rcsscs said th,y had hraised beef which
ought to have made three portions.
Skipper Etlly however did admit tina,
ha had received the praised beef I'm cans.
Mne Naleri testified that she insisted on
! having IL fresh and received assurances
, that u was fresh.
\. tilt over the question of whether the
Pullman company offered q warranty
with It's food almost resulted N tho dec
laratou Of mistrial II was finally
stipulated 10y tho defence. however. that
an implied warranty went with the food
Or Herbert Emsheimcr ~ Ninety sec
ou1 street and broadway qualified as an
expert ON "tuuTy aches" by showing
that As receiving physician Of Mount
SINAI Hospital some time ago he received
/ %. 600 patients He then went into a long
explanation NJ the sNmptomatic difference
between food poisoning. train sickness
. and indigestion. which was intended TO
, show that the plaintiff dil not suffer from
tran sickness on the Cadmus.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04
GLYNN DISMISSES
VOORHIS CHARGES
Governor Issues Statement ON
Findings Generating
superintendent.

tLB.Nv. Dec 3-ActInE upon IN, roc-
omme ndation contained In the report of
Commissioner John u. Mcmahon. who was
appointed TO investigate the charges
against John II. Noorhis. stat superin-
tcndent of Elections, Gov. Glynn to-day
signed an order dismissing thes- charge
IN" Governor gave on; the following
statement concerning MS action 90 the
matter:
Judge Mcmahon has hcsrd witnesses
on both sides with the most psinstuEiug
care. and the hearings before him lasted
from June "a 10 September
I'm his report "a mo he states that seven
charges were made against Superintendent
Noorhis First. that he appointed uuf,
deputies second, that ne as~i-ncd these
deputies tn districts whore they lived
third that he and his deputies failed 70
use Their powers t. insure fai~ elections
fourth, that he refused and failed - in
Nesti.ato charges OF Fraudulent reEistra-
ton flfth. that he refused 20 furnish tho
names of deputies or ten whcr" they were
assigned sixth, that %" and his deputies
harasSed and emh9rra~ Sod the in,"st!-
gators Of the Honest Ballot Association .
seventh. that no WAS v!ifuny urelfc,u,
and grossly unfit
Judge Mcmahon has taken testimony
upon all Of these charges, and after listen
ing 10 witnesses for both sides rrcom-
meuds that every charge loo dsu ssed "
The Governors statement quotes Judge
McMthon's findings on Specific charges
and the conclusion Of his report
All other allegations contained i'm IN.
complaints against Supt, Noorh,s.' saws
Judge Mcmahon. did not constitute
charges, and his report ends with his
conclusions as to the personal fitness of
Supt. Noorhs
He is strong, physically active and
firm, says Judge Mcmahon His t"sti-
mouy AT the hearing was given in =
straightforward manner. and his actions
and demeanor We're characterized hN car
nsstncss and trutntuluess
THE record of Mr. Noorhis for ability
and honest and efficient discharge of OFF,
Cial duties is attestrd 10y the CONFIDENCE
repoSed N him during a period of forty
years hS men in high station having
the selection and appointment OF of'i-
Gals"
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04
ATLANTA SHOOTING
TO Be INVESTIGATED
Victims Family Accepts Car.
hart EXOneratiOn. but Police
Press Inquiry.
MANY MYSTERIOUS PHASES

ATLANTA. Dec. 3-while the members
OF the Galloway family indicated to-day
that they would be satisfied with the YER
dict OF the Coroner's Jury which ex-
onerated W. y Carham in the killing Of
James y. Galloway in Carhart's apart
ment early on Wednesday. the police say
they will push the investigation 20 clear
up mysterious points
Chief Of Detectives Newport Lanford
said he had detailed two plain clothes men
on the case II is said the police are not sat
tsf1cd because the Coroners jury heard
only three Witnesses
The Jury's finding was based upon the
explanation OF Carhart that he thought
the man In his apartments was a burglar.
The police say they do not understand
how II was thar Carhart who said Gala
way had been his friend and associate
for fifteen years. failed to recognize him
when only ten feet away in the partial
light.
No one has explained Calaway's
presence in the apartment or how he
entered It. The only theory offered bv
Mr. Carhart was that the door was care
lessly left unla;ched
Major Frank f.. Galloway. brother of
the dead man. refused either to affirm or
deny the statement attributed to him that
he did not believe the shooting acci-
dental III" also declined TO discuss any OF
the aspects of the case. There seems TO
he reason to believe. therefore. that the
galloway family will not press the mat
ter further.
CHIEF Lanford. however. said there were
so many mysterious phases Of the shoot 70
ing and so much that has not been salts
factorily explained that there ought to he
thorough Investigation.
callaway's funeral was held at 80
o'clock this morning the service being
conducted At the home of his brother.
Major Frank Galway. At 80 Las: Four
teenth street. DR.. e. - wilmer rector
of st Luke's Episcopal Church. oficiated
The body was taken to his former nome in
Lagrange for interment
large number Of friends attended the
funeral and among them we're some IF
Atlan,a'S mos; prominent business men.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04
COSMO HAMILTON IN
BOLTON DIVORCE CASE
En- ~lishman Named as Core
spondcnt When Engineers
Son Gets Decree.

WHITE PLAINs y. Y. Dec 3.-'iny
Reginald Bolton. son Of Reginald Pelham
Bolton. a prominent consulting engineer
of 80 Liberty street. Manhattan. has been
granted final judgment of divorce from
his wife. Julia Bolton. in which 'osmo
Hamilton Of Buckinghamshire. England
IS named as correspondent. The decree
was signed by supreme Court Justice
Isaac y. Mills on the report OF the ref
cree. Alvin ). Hall.
: Considerable effort was made TO keer
the divorce action secret because Of the
prominence OF the parties involved. The
story became known, however. when Mr.
Bolton sought possession of his two chill
dren Justice Mills decided that the son
'tiuv Richard Montgomery Bolton, shall
remain with his father, while the daugh-
ter Katherine Louise Bolton, is given into
thu custody OF the mother. The couple
were married in New York on Novem-
Der 10 1907. II is said that the plaintiff
now resides at the Hotel Gramatan IN
BronNvile The whereabouts of the de-
PENDANT is not revealed. but 1t is reported
that she is in England,
According 10 the testimony given by
, Edward \. Billings, room clerk at the
seville Hotel ! NeNlS-clentn Stt'A anu
Madison avenue, New York Hamilton and
Mrs Bolton registered there on Septer'
Der 20. 1919 as Mr.. and Mrs Bolton
Boston one of the exhibits submitted
bv tho plaintiff was a letter written by
Mrs Bolton to Hamilton Its salutati"r
was. My dear darling Cossie." and Il
WAS signed Your girl july
Among the things she wrote was this
- love and adore YOU and shall as long
as live. | must come first always Ir
your mind and heart, and not only flrs
but to the exclusion of everything en-
ccpt your work and family"
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04
HOW BAD AIR AFFECTS HEALTH.
T.. 4, NinsIow Describes Expert
monts in Ventilation.

JACKSONVILLE, Fla, Dec. al. \. Wins
low. chairman of the New York state
Commission ON Ventilation told the Ameri-
can Public Health Association to-day how
uVerhc2tcd, poorly ventilated rooms reduce
ed'Gi"uGy, spoil appetites and ruin health
sc sad that In experiments conducted
IN a spcD tally fitted room throughout the
last year physical work was reduced IL
per cent by raising the temperature from
6S To- - degrees. This effect was not
noted if the room was kept cool he said.
even II tho air was staguant for eight
rour~- The subjects were served with
standard !uurheous, and 1t was found that
they dt' more when the air was fresh
than when II Was not changed The en-
perlmcuts viii be continued in new
Z hoolhousc IN New York city.
Prof Charles I, Sedgwick of Boston,
named 10y thu advisory committee for
president, will he formally elected to-mor-
Tow Rochester was named AS the mex;
meeting place OF the convention.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04

Zip went another seasons record last
night when the New York State Hotel
Association. composed OF the flower OF
what a lot of us Victorian English
scholars call bonifaces. from all over the
State. gathered more than 400 strong In
The grand ballroom of hotel called the
Waldorf Astoria run by hotel man
whose name s said to be George 6. Boldt.
and wound up their twenty eighth annual
convention with a blowout VI magnih-
cence.
The ECSTASY OF the dinner and the high
pressure oratory did not enter. however.
INFO the establishing OF tine wor,t's record
Hut the hotel men did do this-;hey were
the first assemblage OF diners Of the
present season to struggle through a
beautifully complete evening without once
so much as suggesting that they all tear
loose and sing. Its a Long Way to Tip
perary.''
OF cours, the fact that right under the
guns on one side sat August Luchow.
George Heydenrech. Joe Hcsdorfer. Gus
tave T. Spreckel and Nathan Schweitzer
and with Henri Charpentier and NJ. lie N
Fourner-not 20 mention old Anglo
Saxon stock represented by President John
McGlynn Of Troy. George O'Hanlon and
John A. Moriarity-- under the guns on the
other side. nobody wanted to
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04
HELLENSTEINAT
INQUIRY GIVES
LIETOPOLICE
COrOner'S Dpnials Called Out
i'm Connection With Deaths
of Women.
ASKED WHY JURY DID
NOT PASS ON FACTS

Coronor Herman Hellenstcin gave the
lie TO three policemen yesterday at the in.
curry into his Office which Commissioners
OF Accounts Leonard NJ. Wallstein Is con-
Quoting The Coroner's dcnials were
called forth by fresh instances OF deaths
that may have resulted from doctors
nlalpractice-deaths in which there was
no jury to pass on the facts. although the
law required jury The disclosure Of the
Coroncr's method of handling these cases
caused Commissioner Wallstein 10 eN-
claim:
Coroner, this is about he eighth case
Of = woman dying with evidence OF crime
that We have come across where II seems
to me the facts require considerable ex.
PLANTATION"
Such explanation IIellcnstein didn't
make lie fell back on the repetition tina:
81 always tell the District Attorney and
consult with him before closing a case
The District Attorney says, however. he
never heard Of some of these cases
Noun. Sinai Hospital reported. in the
death OF Anna kucers on October 90. 1913.
A rumor of malpractice Dr. Leblanc, Hell
lensteins physician. said there was evi-
dence OF crime. Two persons swore 80
the names OF woman doctor and midi
wife Detective Joseph T.. Skelly says he
told HelleuStcn this and that Hellenstein
told him no. TO make any arrest. saying
he would summon the doctor and midwife
and investigate.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04
BUYS $12.6sO,OO0 c. P. NOTES.
American syndicate Takes MIS- IL.
sue Of Canadian Company.

\ syndicate headed by the Gusranty
Trust Company OF New York Brown Bros
& Co. White. Weld & co and Colgtt-,
Parker 4 Co. has bought sl2S90 600
Canadian Pacific Railway Company g!
per cent equipment trust certificates. -'.
turing IN equal s"m!-dnnual lnstalm, 80
OF $4,000 each "u july |. 1918, 90 sri
including July |, 1875
|, is understood that an Offering vi
bc made IN the near future on about 5
per cent. basis.
Brown Bros. & CO. and T. Low
STOKES arc forming a separate 50 du.a's
20 handle the selling in the STATE % Penn
sNiNau!a.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04
SUSPICIOUS FIRE ON ISLAND.
PoIicr inVcstiGntinG Binzc In stables
of Hospital.

The police and fire marshal have been
asked tn Investigate the origin OF sus-
picious fire which broke OUT shortly before
O'Clock last uight IN the stables of
the Metropolitan Hospital On Blackwcll's
Island Forty horses are housed in the
buildings, but the fire was cXtnguishc
before II had gained hradway and none of
the animals was injured
The Are is the third at the hospital
within a month.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04
MAD BULLDOG BITES TWO
shot In hallway After Long Chase
by pntrOlman.

A mad bulldog BIZ two men yesterday
afternoon before Il wa slot after a long
chase by Patrolman Buns. in the nall
way OF 6.5 West Furty-siNth street
Dr Robinson of Polytechnic Hospital said
the dog had rdbirs. 50 Fred Grifenking,
"A stahleman at sos West Forty -slAth
street, and Thomas Dalton of 800 West
Forty-tnird ,treet ware taken to Willard
Parker Hospital for treatment
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04
Women's Trade Union Ball.

dAV h., offi,ors Of the Momc' Trade
Union lcaSue for It's NTH tnuull ball
which VIII No attended 10y visiting sucst'
from hrtncn", 80 the league in different
cities and VIII be- held tins evening At t.e
Amsterdam opera House. IN Forty-fourth
street west Of Eighth avenue.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04

Edward spies. 30 year, old, committed
suicide yesterday afternoon At his rome
at 5'S fordhim road, The Bronx. by cut
ting his throat He had not been able to
get work and was despondent because
upon hissWife fell the burden Of providing
{ 80 the home.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04
Glasses CIink Neutrality.

Anyway. Gus and Joe and George
clnked glasses happily with Henri and
Leon and with John McGlynn and the
Other Brltlshers and not once was ITS
a Long Way to Tipperary" even 80 much
as started. Bu; there were those sitting
near the Hon. Peter i. McElligott who
said tina; repeatedly as the orchestra
leader 60: up TO launch another tune
Assembly man Peter would clear his throat,
fidget expectantly-and then sink back
in disappointed way when the orchestra
began some other song.
Throughout the talks numbered NJ
the convention held in the Astor Gallery
of the Waldorf during the day and when
the oratorical waters began 90 come
down from LAHORE after the coffee and
cordials last night Old Gen. Busne 80
Pessmlsni was slapped on the wrist again
and again. star orator John McGlNnn
especially walked right up tdemosthenes i
caiy spcaklngD to odd Man ressim'sn.
raised the ag. d lads high hat. slammed
him with an oral nightstick on the head.
replaced the high hat over the lumr
raised and gladly counted ten while the
pessimism party passed away.
In fact there WAS but on" slightly dark
moment throughout an evening OF light
someness. and The shade was but COM
parativa That was just when everybody
sat down TO dinner Just for a moment
1t seemed that something had gone
slightly wrong with tho electric lighting
system. Nhereat Mr.. Bodt. who was sit
ting at the speakers table. for moment
looked perturbod
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04

But when it was found that the cause
was merely the fact that honorable Guest
Diamond lin Eradv had thouChtlesslS
covered between s2S.0op and $3.50
worth of eWelry with corner Of his
napkin every one brcathed easier. bia-
mond Jim hastily removed the napkin
corner from the BRADY scenery and there
WAS more light again.
There must have been something in the
prosrerity talk one heard throughout the
speeches. Al any rae the hotel men were
a Ole to- run through snacks of nourish-
meut -hat ranged through Huitres de Cap
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04

The Coroner says this ism, true There
IVES no jury. The District Attorney saws
he got no report of the death. The names
OF the decor and midwife accused are
pencilled az the bottom OF the death Ger
rfcate. llcllenstein thinks the hand Is
that OF George Wahl. his clerk The
Coroner could not say whether he ever d d
question th' two accused persons. The
dead WoWan'S sister. who took hcr 70 tho
hospital seems not to have been ques-
TONED. The Coroner says he doesn't know
tho doctor and midwife named hut los
not deny a conversation about the dea IL
before being apprsed OF II officially His
verdict was crime by some person un-
known"
IN tho case of Annie kcdrney. who died
at It. Lakes Hospital on November 10,
1910. the coroucrs office was informed
the day before the death and IL is recorded
that IIellcustoin went to get the woman's
after burial were tho police set to work.
and then according TO Detective John r.
INood. they were not told of any state
meut 10y The dead woman.
Flood ~wosrs HelleuStoiu sent a clerk
to him with = typewriter paper which
he wanted him To sign. The paper said
thai Flood had found no cause for sus-
pectluE crime IN ms investigation ~ the
ease. Flood a -ked the District Attorney
what to do and was told not 10 sign. "a
he didn't The policeman says HELEN
stein then sent to him to ask why he
wouldn't gn and Flood replied that he
had already reported fully OF the cas-" 10
the Police Department and the District
Attorney.
Ilel'ersteiu says nc never ,cnt to Flood.
The Clio messenger. (Clio, Mich.) 1907-current, 1914-04-17

troll of the Panama canal in the interest
of the American people. Speaking of
the tariff, he said that he did not lay
claim to great knowledge about it but
was impressed with Lincoln's logic,
viz.: that when we buy an article
abroad we get the article but the for
eigner gets the money, whereas, when
we produce and buy the article at home
we have both the article and the money.
Mr.. Groesbeck told briefly of the build
ing of the S. & F. Ry. and paid nice
compliment to our fellow townsman, C.
A. Arnold, who, because of his indus
try. was taken from a job as street car
conductor and entrusted with the con-
struction of the new road, measuring
up to the responsibilitie of the posi-
tion in the most able manner. The
speaker told of how enthusiasm is grow
ing in the republican party, said there
was no question in his mind but that it
would be overwhelmingly successful in
the elections this fall.