New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1914-07-15

the girl would tell the "u'"
uninfuenced.
sh. was served with the subpoena
ard taken TO Mineola last THURSDAY
only 70 get her away from 'n"u
In Freeport. ,., Az.
Cell. sat quietly In the Dis'rict AZ
.an.v,. Office while she was waitlns
so's before the grand jury. sne 9id S
~, sssrn 10 be nervous. Mr.. onleh uN
no question her. As soon as the JUL
nv bsd returned from their luncneon;
NJ smith took the girl into the grahu
1ory roU,n s.cret here that Celia faced
stent;cal audience. The grana III
IA road Celis's testimony peiote
Sn-ansr Merton, the affidavit shy
stoned for Mrs. Carman's oounseI; sne
thew Knew of the charges the oeie"'~
mad made Of kidnapping. e..
The girl had not been ions On .ao
. stand. however, before every Jul Y's sSn
WAS hanging on her WORDS anu ~
feeling Of hostility. The tribune
respondent is reliably told' hao u, la
peared. The girl told her story ur .
Nr. Smiths quiet questionInS iurv
strairhtforward way. The graho Jury
hscsme convinced that she was al las'
doing her best to tell the truth
Tells Her Own Story.
Mr.. Smith. realizing his own hone 81 y
had been called into question .!
nh.~r~s Of "kidnapping" and framing
m y was careful to let Celia tell ner
story In her own way with as niue
Questioning as possible. 1t can De saIn
~ D;strict Attorney did not ask
Ibis witness a single leading cues
t;onp during her entire examination
The girl was not reluctant wlthess'
neither did she appear over ANXIOUS "
Celia told of preparing and serving
s;,,nor for the Carman househoiu lues-
Ja,, ,irbt June 80. She told how tne
Sa,o;lv dispersed after the meal, anu
"a tbat DR.. Carman went into, MS Oh
6ce 20 attend TO the patients VIM WIN In
then sitting in his waiting room. -;ad
those details her story had not Vei sSe
in any material point from the ohe '"'
told at the inquest. AZ, c.-men
Then she said that ME- Oa.na Ia
,re,t upstairs to her own ROOM as SIC
,houcht. The witness said she nc,
went into the Kitchen al'ei
the supper dishes vben the
49,
n;st ~ Attorney, after inqulrlhg
,.hatber she had heard the souno OK a
800 and receiving her affirmative ah
s,yer asked this question:: -. .ho
and Won see any one come INTO wy
,,;..bon Immediately after you heaiu
'n cs,;a told the grand jury that MRS.
60, entered the kitchen oy the
ontrance almost immediately aaTeI
10 hasrd the sound of the shot; me
sas;d said Mrs. CarInan stopped anu
.siked IA her for moment o, n"o'
go her some instructions ana 'heh
went upstairs. ....rr,ntad
a. ,,;tness with sharp questioning; !.
can he said on the best authority ma ma
.Sn cross-examining by the jurors ola
W confuse the girl. She dld ho'
Ibsree her story in any important oe-
tsil and the Jurors sat back 10 hs'e"
10 the rest of her story. &.
celia according TO The Tribunes IN
sormants told the jurors that when
NJ Carman entered the kitchen she
Ala not have a revolver in her hana.
aftsr Mrs. Carman's conversation
With her. the subject OF when Is hoC
Known. the maid, she testified, went 70
her room and went TO bed.
II is understood that Cella toio tne
grand Jury at length how she mao COM ny
20 sion the affidavit which George NJ
81. I evy prepared and asked her 10 sign;
she also said that she had noI "anteu
IN 90 back to Freeport last lhuIsu "a
when she was taken in the car Oy tle
nrosecution's detectives. and tnat she
did not want TO go back again 10 inc
Carman home, ,JL s+orv
After the girl had finished her SOY
she was taken quietly from th1 ~
house under the escort whlch DI1us ,.S
w. tbere Tonight her Whereabouts
are known only to the ohcials. IheS
roiis's story overshadowed all else
,o'dav II is the one subject OF dis-
cnssion and speculation on Long ISL
and tonight.
Carman Tells Old Story.
Next TO her in Importance as wit
ness was DR.. Edwin Carman' ne WOO
n;obt Mr., Smith changed his mind
about requesting the physician to sign
a waiver of immunity. He had looked
further into the law and had reached
the conclusion that DIR. .Carman would
cain no immunity for himself by test-
fvino in case which involved no
charge against him.
n took an hour and quarter Tor
,hc musician to give his story to the
jurors. IL is understood tonight tnat
he made no amplifcation. He told the
Jurors lust about what he had told the
nistrict Attorney and the Coroner at
the inquest, and nothing that shed any
new light upon the case.
The first witness IVES G. Fairfield, q
surveyor, who had prepared charts'a ana
mans of the Carman house, lawn, the
Office and the outbuildings, etc.
DR.. Carman and Celia Coleman were
followed by Madeline Bailey, the
prettv seventeen-year-old daughter OF
Inc murdered woman. William ID. Bal
lev her father, escorted her to the
Grand Jury room and did his best to
Comfort her and keep her calm under
all the excitement of the crowd and
The swarm of photographers who were
snapshotting every one connected with
the case.
Madeline's testimony, it is said, had
simnlv TO do with her answering the
telephone when the Bailey house was
called up the night of the shooting
from Dr. CaTman's residence, and Mr..
BAILEY was told that his wife had been
seriously injured. -,
William d. Bailey followed his
dsuebtcr. He told of receiving the tel
enhone message and Of going over to
Freeport and finding there that his
wife was dead.
The seventh witness was Mrs. KIM
hall. a cousin of Mrs. Bailey. 1t is
II IL 4nn+ifind that DR. Carman Wis