The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-10-25

How did he know that she was I'm the
office? The shades were down II 1t had
been an outside he would have waited
until she came outdoors.
"On the other hand, II you suppose that
{ was an enemy OF DIR. Carman's ask you
II II Is reasonable to suppose that with
the shades down and not knowing that
the doStor was In the office ne would have
taken such CHANGER
ION the otlaer hand you have Mrs
Carmans coming home from the city tired
and irritable She went upstairs after
supper, put on her kimono ana sat down
at the photograph. Elizabeth was prac-
Using on tho piano. The noise interfcre1
with her hearing She called out to Eliz-
aoeth to stop practising Five or ten
minutes li-er the office window was
broken and the shot fired.
why II Mrs Carman could not hear
well over the photograph did she buy II
outright when her lease had yet two
months to run? No. gentlemen of the
jury, Mrs. Carman Is an unusual woman
1t requires an unusual woman to spy upon
her husband by means OF a photograph
and to make such elaborate and crafty
preparations for It's installation"
The Morning session.
The morning session was taken up by
-tnosses called by the defence to uphold
Nr contention that 1t was a man who
ro' Mrs Bailey. Several witnesses said
.nv had seen A strange man about the
ICE. There was also a lot OF testimony
bout bloodhounds. their ability to follow
scent and what they had done the night
2 the murder. John J. Dunbar, n Free
rrt policeman, testified that there were
"ly "A few people on the lawn when he
81 there. two hours after the shooting
:. was contradicted by County Detective
anon and Roland ". Lamb. President OF
report village.
John G. Quinn, for whom the husband
{ Mrs Bailey works was asked IL DR.
'nrmau had not told him that the hand
hicn held the pistol was womsn's hand.
Nn objection started an argument and the
matter was taken under Amusement until
I'VE afternoon session. wpn Justice Kelby
ruled that Quinn might answer. He said
DE- Carman did tell him that This testi-
mony was introduced to impeach the credi-
hllity Of Dr. Carman. who had testified on
Friday that II was masculine hand that
held the revolver.
Case Goes TO Jury.
II was rot until after o'clock that the
jury got back from its dime and the
first nights session began. Mr. Graham
objected to several remarks made by Mr..
Smith In summing up. which he said were
not justified by testimony. This took hot
a few minutes. and Justice Kelby then
arose and began his charge to the jurV.
BY some means or other more women
had squeezed themselves into the court
room than on any other occasion and
all Of them seemed 30 he quite as much
absorbed by the Justices remarks as
the jurymen thevselves.
Mrs Carman did not look as II she
was following the Judge very closely or
even trying to, For the first time she
betrayed nervousness and during much
of the Justices charge her fingers played
with her lips or constantly twined and
intertwined In her lap
Counsel for Mrs. Carman had handed
Justice Kelby a list OF instructions which
/ they wished read TO the Jury. They
were further application OF most OF
| the things with which Justice Kelby had
I already charged the jury. but he read them
/ through despite this. These Instructions
y AS presented by counsel were worded In
rather involved language and as they
were read the brows OF the Jurors were
sorely knitted There were sixty-twC
/ OF them.
Justice Kelby's charge took forty min.
/ utes and the jury went out at GAS
/ o'clock