Alma record. (Alma, Mich.) 1878-1928, 1914-01-22

which have passed the point up to
which combination may be CONSISTENT
with the public interest and the free
dom of trade, cannot always be dis
sected into their component units as
readily as railroad companies or sim
! liar organizations can be. Their dis
solution by ordinary legal process may
oftentimes involve financial conse-
! quences likely 10 overwhelm the So
| curlty market and bring upon 1t break
down and confusion. There ought 70
| be an administrative commission ca,
| pable Of directing and shaping such
! corrective processes, not only in aid
Of the courts but also by indepndent
! suggestion. if necessary.
Make Punishment Certain.
InasmuCh as our object and the
spirit of our action In these matters
Is to meet business half way in its
| processes Of self-correction and dis
| turb it's legitimate course as little as
! possible we ought 10 see to it, and the
! judgment Of practical and sagaciouf
men Of affairs everywhere would ap-
plaud US if we did see TO 1t that pen
alties and punishments should fall
not upon business itself. TO its confu-
sion and interruption, but upon the
individuals who use the Instrumental
tiles Of business TO do things which
public policy and sound business prac-
tice condemn Every act of business
is done at the command or upon the
initiative OF some ascertainable per
son or group Of persons. These should
be held individually responsible and
the punishment should fall upon them.
not upon the business organization at
which they make illegal use. II should
be one Of she main objects OF our leg
islation to divest such persons OF
their corporate cloak and deal with
them as with those who do not rep
resent their corporations. but merely
by deliberate intention break the law.
Other questions remain which VIII
need very thoughtful and practical
treatment. Enterprises, in these mod
ern days OF great individual fortunes,
are oftentimes interlocked. not by
being under the control Of the sans
/ directors, but by the fact that the
greater part of their corporate stock
is owned by a single person or group
Of persons who are in some way In
timately related in interest
Holding Companies.
I'VE are agreed, ! take it, that hold
ing companies should be prohibited.
but what of the controlling private
ownership Of individuals or actually
cooperative groups OF individualsf
Shall the private owners OF capital
stock be suffered TO be themselves in
effect holding companies We do not
wish. | suppose. to forbid the pur
chase Of stocks by any person who
pleases 10 buy them in such quaint
ties as he can afford. or in any way
arbitrarily to limit the sale of stocks
to bonafide purchasers. Shall we re-
quire the owners of stock when their
voting power In several companies
which ought to he independent Of one
another would constitute actual con-
troll TO make selection in which ot
them they will exercise their right to
vote? This question / venture for
your consideration
There is another matter in which
imperative considerations of justice
and fair play suggests thoughtful
remedial action Not only do many
Of the combinations effected or sought
to be effected in the industrial world
work an injustice upon the public In
general they also directly and seri
ously injure the individuals who are
put out OF business in one fair way or
another by the many dislodging and
DISCRIMINATING forces Of combination.
/ hope that we shall agree in giving
private individuals who claim to have
been injured by these processes the
right to found their suits for redress
upon the facts and judgments proved
and entered in suits by the govern
ment where the government has upon
its own initiative sued the combina-
tons complained of and won its suit
and that the statute of limitations
shall be suffered to run against such
litigants only from the date of the
conclusion OF the governments action
Individual Justice.
ut is not fair that the private liti-
CANT should be obliged to set up and
establish again the facts which the
government has proved He cannot
afford. he has not the power to make
use of such processes Of inquiry as
the government has command Of
Thus shall individual Justice be done
while the processes of business are
rectifed and squared with the general
conscience.
"I have laid the case before you, no
doubt as II lies in your own mind, as
It lies in the thought Of the country.
What must every candid man say OF
the suggestions have laid before you,
OF the plain obligations of which I
have reminded you? That these are
new things for which the country Is
not prepared? No: but that they are
old things now familiar, and must OF
course be undertaken If we are to
square our laws with the thought and