New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1914-07-16

Att'A A'ftf f'f NtI'f~ |.N ~ .i - wv
fore 10 to-morroH. including DR. Run
cic. who said that Mr. Carman told
him OF the dictog'a ph The night OF INC
shooting. Rut 30 far rs INC District
Attorney ?. concerned, mis- case Wa
complete when Farrell walked out Of
the jury room
The other witnesses to-day we're Or.
Crimmcr and Dr. phipps. Henry DC
bau. Hazel Coomb5. Hannah Kahn.
Florence Eaynor. Castor Boz S"nndu. '
manager or the photograph compan
which sold one of its instruments 10
Mr.. Carman: Percy Smith. Charlie
Adams and Coroner Corodon Norton.
Pm case an indictment is handed
down against Mrs. Carmau n rs IlkclN
THAI L viii bc received Immediately by
Justice Van Siclcu. OF the Ma &u
County Supreme Court.
Should the Indictment charge mur-
der m a lessee degree or first degree
mausiauChtcr counsel for Mrs. Carmau
will ash that snc be admitted 70 ball.
and the District Attorney, While he
/ will usis. upon q very high sum, VIII
not oppose this motion.
\ first degree charge VIII mean maj
Mrs Carman remains IN the Nineola
Jail.
If indicted. Mrs. Carmau viii prob
ably 60 TO trial in September before
Justice Kclby
Two grand jurors were excused to-
day at their own request. They arc
AlVah Smith, who has a contract when
needs his attention. and Daniel Is.
RaNnor. a close friend Of the Carmans.
He wished 10 take no further part N
the deliberations Of body which he
+ thought might be called upon to return
an indictment.
DR.. Carman and Mrs. Carmans coun-
sci. Mr.. Levy, went over to the Nine
ola courthouse this morning TO be on
hand for Whatever might develop.
When the crowd around the courthouse
scnsed the importance of Farrell's tes-
timony both men made attacks upon
the District Attorney and his methods.
Plea by Mrs. Carman.
The attorney then read petition
sent the grand jury by Mrs. Carman.
She said in part:
"l do respectfully petition the grand
jury now investigating the murder of
Mrs. Lulu j.. Bailey for permission to
20 before your body and make a state
mcnt in reference to any knowledge ]
may have i'm reference 20 tho charge
against me. | make this petition vol
unfairly and hereby waive any I'M
runity which would ordinarily be af-
fordcd to me by reason OF making any
such statement, and ] want no protec-
ton Of any kind afforded me by reason
Of any such statement ! may make be-
fore the grand jury
DR.. Carman during the course Of an
hours talk brought out one entirely
new point He said that there we're
two blows struck the glass OF the win
dow by the person who did the shoot
/ ing. He had this TO say of the District
Attorney:
Smith certainly went for me in the
grand jury room. He had it in for me
and | had il in for him. ! met him
every time half way.
"Why, Smith came TO Mrs. Carman
after the shooting and he told her he
believed both of us had nothing to do
with this crime. He said. Mrs. Carman,
come as a friend and not as Dis
trict Attorney and then he double
crossed her. He said but for certain
things he could have hushed the ma
/ ter up. He told me he was going 70
get Burns in the case because II would
/ look better for him.
"Why doesn't he let the little girl
and Mrs. Powell go before the grand
| jury? Why don't he let Bardes? Be
cause he knows Bardes would ruin
Celia's story Why don't he let my
wife testify? It's because he's afraid
to let those jurors see her. He knows
If they do they won't indict her.
"Will you tell Us about that scene at
the Freeport Club the night of the
Lincoln Day dance, when Mrs. Carman
got Jealous of your attentions 10 other
women ." he was asked.
Il 49, y o,.ly
there with a girl, and also three other
girls" he said, 1.-TWO of them patients
of mine. ! introduced that old batch
to the girls and his partner rebuked me
/ for it, Then | danced with one Of the
/ girls, and Mrs. Carman did not like the
/ whole business That's the story
DR.. Carman said that he had been 10
White Cannon Tavern and Abrams's
/ Road House for late suppers, but never
went out with a strange woman and
had never been anywhere with Mrs.
Bailey. 81 merely touched Mrs. Bailey
on the shoulder with my hand as she
was going OUT he said.
Reverting again 10 Celia, Dr. Carman
said: 81 never had anything to do with
her. I hardly ever spoke TO her, except
TO say good morning
Dr.. Carman laughed heartily at the
"jest" which now he thinks his friend,
Garland Gaden, Framed up" on him.
This Joke was the firing OF three
shots at him on a night when they were
both out together in his auto.
81 have been thinking that over" said
the physician. land have come TO the
conclusion that it was one Of Gaden's
Jokes. ! believe he got me to duck so
that ne could fire those shots without
nv seing him. But if IL was joke, IT
was poor one for me. ] was nearly
scared to death II Gaden put that over
| was an entirely innocent party. lie
didn't tell me what he was gong to DO
He then reiterated his statement tina.
Mrs. Carman was innocent and trait
her appearance before the grand jury
would result in her freedom.
"If she goes on trial she Will be ac-
quilted" he concluded.
Detectives in the employ of the Dis
trict Attorney were looking tonight
for Mrs. Helen Corby, daughter OF Mrs.
Ida " Powell. They had subpoena
summoning her before the grand jury
Powell Fears Kidnappcrs.
p Mrs. c. l.. Corby, her mother-in-la~,
said that she was Al bridge party on
the night Of the shooting, but TOD"
Powell. her father, who had been d.
vorccd by Mrs. Powell said his daugh-
ter started 70 90 to a moving picture
show that night, but on the way heard
what had happened at the Carmdn
house and went there.
81 have come here TO protect her
from the detectives, who may kidnap
her" he said. when God had finished
creating. after he had made the rattle
snakes and vampires, he had a lot OF
substance left, and Of this he put
tumors into some people where others
have hearts. IL the detectives, who arc