davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04
WHITMAN TO ANNOUNCE
APPOINTMENTS MONDAY
Meanwhile GOvcrnOr-clcct Will
BcWin First Message to
legislature.

COY elect Whitman said Yesterday That
1. expected To- announce tho selection uf
"a state Superintendent of Pubic Work..
e military starr and p".Nat" secretary
or Mrrda, II. Goy"'uor- secretary is
li,c,v t. br VIII ,n y Or.. c't" editor
Of tho II1b.r'.
Although NJ Whitman las offc."d 'a'
position Of pjstr.,' Nt'ur.,t OF th.s rolrty
20 George " N.eh,r~n.,u former NJ
torucy -,ieucrai. !, B.. gui likely that the
latter VIII accept IN" ofir". The "ii'',
b: is understood. Was made some time
ago. aud Nj Whitman feels strongly that
Mr. Wickcrsham would make a. excellent
q prosecutor nm New York as b" was an
able Attorney General The obstacle I'D
the way of Nj Wickorshams acceptance
j. believed To- be- an agreement he has with
ms law partner, Henry ". Taft
Mr. Whitman, however, is s'lN trying
to persuade the former ATTORNEY General
TO withhold his hnal refusal Of the Office.
but il Is not thought by WickerShams
friends that II. Will Ice successful In the
event that Mr.. Wickorsham Will not ac-
cept the Govoruor-elect viii probably -p-
point some one other than ia" candidates
for the job now IN ,hc District Attorneys
office for the sake Of malrta,u,ug har-
mouy,
Instead ot going on, Of town for the
week end Mr. Whitman will stay At home
the LEGISLATURE II" Will not try To- make
II blanket message Syycying AL phases
Of suggested legislation II will 10" fol-
lowed by other MESSAGES dealing with
specific topics.
Thaddeus e. Sweet, Spca,er ~ tho AS
scmbly. called ON MI Whitman last night
and offered suggestions a. 20 legislation.
MIR Sweet fivors abolishu- the Depart
mcnt uf Efficiency and Economy and Tn"
Fire Mti~hdls office and thinks IL might
Ice well to max" changes in the CpnserNa-
ton Commission he also favors the es-
Enlistment of a state constahularN.
senator J. Henry Walters of syracuse.
who is a rival OF senator James Emerson
as candldat" for chairman Of the Sen
ate Finance Committee. saw Nj whitman
yesterday other visitor We" Attorney
Gcneral-elect Woodbury., thorough Pres T.
dent Marcus NJ Marks, who wants the
Legislature to pass q public markets bill
Congressman James Parker Of Washing
ton county and N>Srmblyman-rlcct y ;
Ldudou Of pouchk"rpsir
The two plain clothes policemen who
are guarding the apartment nous" ~ ~
Madison avenue where Mr. Whitman lives
were ASSIGNED 10y Commissioner Woods
at tho request of the owner Of III" house
! who had heard that threats of a bomb had
been sent In Mr.. Whitman.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04
CR0PSEY FIRM ABOUT
"HANDPICKED JUDGES
Bar Associations investigation
of His Remarks Expected
to BE Extended.

TIE committee appointed 10y the presi-
den. Of tnc Brooklyn Bar Association to
investigate remarks made by District At
tor1cy ,~np-cy on the circuit case may not
cnnfut itself TO a single side Of tn" case.
TIL District Attorneys stand has placed
the committee In more or less of guam
dairy II had thought that the committee
would br called upon 20 decide merely
whether MIR. cropsoy exercised good taSi"
In refer .ug In a political speech to hand
picked JudGes' the lap friends of Ed
ward NJ Circuit NoW, however NJ Crop
sey says he meant every word and is quite
willing to make a formal complaint against
the justices involved. although he THINKS
this should be- don, 10y some one not 80
closely associated with the case.
Ia his criticisms Mr. CrnpScy 'Np'cSSI!
stats IL as hi opinion that non" OF the
Justices was moved by material cunsiderd-
ton Ia favor circuit but thdt inc! Were
swayed 10y friendship.
Former Justice Marcdn, whom the l'is-
trict Attorney charges with ents'ulhtlhE
the first indictment against Mr.. Grou''
comes in for the s,'Ncrcst criticism IN the
statement retd to tn" comm!tte, MI. crop
sry. +, Is said. referred TO some OF Justice
Narcan'S rulings AS outrageous and &C
u
tice Rlackmar was criticised for s'ndlng
the case back To- Justice Marcan over tht
District Attorney protest, and judge
Dixie for paroling Mr. Grout when he was
arraigned the second time on the indict-
mcnt charging him with perjury IN con
nection with his duties as president oi
the Union Bank,
Justice Scudder did wrong, tho District
Attorney holds In permitting Mr.. Grou'
to inspect the minutes of the Grand jury
referring to Justice benedict, who pub
licly ctnsured him recently for his re-
Elections on the bench, Nj Cropsoy said
81 won't tell you all think of justice
BENEDICT. think that his utterance wa
no part of his decision-that ii was abSr'
lutcly gratutous. offensive, unJudicidl anC
an unmanlv act.
Former chief Justice Edgar NJ cullen
| chairman of the investigating committee
when asked Yesterday whether the com
mittec would avail Itself of the docu
mentary proof offered by Mr.. crops y II
substantiation OF his charges replied:
81 suppose so" Whether tine Judge
would be invited to answer Mr. CropseN
would De decided to-day, he said.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04
BLAMES OPERATORS
FOR COLORADO WAR
Ex-senator Patterson Also Saws
AmmOnS Gave Troops Too
Much Power.
LUDLOW ATTACK PLANNED

DENVER. Dec. 3.--"To my mind. the re-
sponsibilty for the violence and all the
results Of the calling out of the militia
rests upon the refusal Of the operators
even to meet the representatives OF their
men," was the emphatic statement made
to-day by former United states Senator
T. NJ. Patterson, 49, a witness before the
Federal commission ON industrial rela-
tons
Mr.. Patterson was on ;he witness stand
most OF the day and he made several
startling assertions He told in detail
of several attempts he had made as adj
wiser to Gov. Ammons. to bring about
settlement and indicated that In the
early part of the strike he was the power
behind the Governor.
The ex-senator contradictcd GOV. Am.
mons's statement that the continuation
OF the strike was due 10 tho miners de-
mand for recognition Of the union. lie
said the union chiefs were willing %
waive that. but tho operators refused TO
meet them or treat with them.
H. also criticised GOV. Ammons for
permitting Adjt. Gen. Chase To have IN
brided control OF the troops in the field
and said that Chase had violated the
Governors orders against permitting
strike breakers to enter the field. The
attack upon Ludlow. hc said. was pre-
meditated by the soldiers and was not
accidental
Before Mt Patterson took the stand
James II. Dalrymple state Mine lnspcc-
tor gave startling testimony. He said
the death rate in the Colorado mines was
larger than in any other State and at
irlbuted this largely to the fact that the
state laws were not enforced Law en-
forcement, he asserted. was a matter OF
choice with the companies. He also de-
clar,d that in his opinion the men could
not better their working or living con-
ditious without the aid of q union.
Gov. elect Carlson. who told the com
mission Yesterday that he believed indus
trial problems should be- handled 10y the
state through "a central board. announced
to-day thai this would be his chief poi
icy IN office and that he would ask the
Legislature 10 pass a law based on tine
Wisconsin industrial act.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04
mo WORK" SHAMES
CITY, SAYS BRUERE
Reflection on Civilization Here.
He Tells Women of Civic
Federation.
MISS MORGAN THERE: kNITS

City Chamberlain Bruere told the MEM
bers of the womens department Of the
National Civic Federation at Their lunch
con at the Colony Club yesterday that
Unemployment had become a chronic con
dition In this city and that the problem
is of more Importance than the, relief of
European war sufferers
The idea" he said. that IN the mos.
prosperous and commercial city of Amer
lea strong. able bodied men sh uld he
unable to hrd work IL a reflection on our
civilization"
Commissioner of Correction katharine
y. Davis cjmplmcntcd the vacation war
relief committee on its success in finding
employment for women She said that
lsck % employment is the first step to-
ward prison for many and that 10 pro-
vide jobs IS - prevent crime.
The report Of the committee said that
120 girls are being employed daily at tho
has boon received FOR their remuneration
and 10 buy materials To he made mo
garments for war sufferers In EuIorc
Whilc this and ,ther reports were being
read Mss Anne Morgan and many Of
those present went ON w.;h their knitting
TO- the soldicr.
\ resolution was adopted on nc d-a,h
Of Mrs Woodrow Wilson. expressing mo
fedcratlonS sorrow. il sympathy wiki III"
President and i,s appreciation of Mrs
Wilson's work
permanent welfare exhibit OF the
Employers Welfare Department Of the
National Civic Federation was opened
yesterday or the thirty fifth floor OF the
Metropolitan Tower. There were ad
dresses des riding various phases OF the
work and motion pictures illustrative OF
d." sociological work OF the Ford Motor
Company were shown. The pictures
showed tho homes Of workmeu who have
benefited by the profit sharing pan OF
IN" company.
Chairman William r Wilcox announced
tina. e ac;.cl working exhibit would be-
maintained There are 20 be frequent
conferences on welfare work md q train
ing class Tor welfare students
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04
KNOX SAYS STATE
PERSECUTES THAW
Ty-Sccrctary as Counsel Argues
constitution FOrbids
EXtraditiOn.
FIGHTS NEW YORK APPEAL

w,suiNGToN, Dec. 3.-Asserting that
under tho Constitution OF the United
states person cannot be eNtradited I'M
less charged with crime in the state from
which he fled and declaring that Harry
Trav cannot be held to be an insane per-
on for the purpose of combining him In a
,i,dhnuse and sane person capable OF
.,iue for the purpose OF extradlting him
from New Hampshire to New York for
,,i,L philauder q. Knox. former Secre-
,,tv OF state flied his brief in behalf OF
T-,w with the clerk OF the supreme
Court to-day.
Mr. Knox has been retained by the
THiv family to argue the constitutional
uuc,tibu involved in the appeal taken by
tpc state of New York from the decree
OF :hc Federal court Of the District of
Ncw Hampshire. which held that Thaw
could not he extrsdited. Mr.. Knox in
s.sts that 10y the New York statute the
act Of an insane person Is declared not to
.e crime and that Harry Thaw occupies
Re status Of an insane person IN the
STAT, OF New York.
The Thaw case was advanced oy the
supreme Court aud set for argument IN
december as soon after December : as
can bc reached following cases that
lad been assigned for argument on or
atlsr that date.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04
VILLA LOSES GUAYNAS.
sonora CT, su-rsndc< 10 a.n.
Iturbc After Being shcIIcd

El PNso. Tex. pec. 3.-Carrancistas
arc successfully carrying onward their
campaign IN sonora against the Villa
Mayturcua forces. Under ten. Iturbe
they began shcllug Guaynds carly to-
day and the city soon surrendered
Col. obregou. 4 brother of ten. Nlvaro
Ohregon. attacked Hrrmo-illo 1t is said
that Ohreeon Will proceed To Naco and
form a junction with lin II he Is success
ful On taking the state capital
Emilio NasIueZ ioiuez Is coming here
from san Antonio H. was visited las.
night by delegation OF Iaplta followers
headed 10y T. Arr.zga. who was recent.
appointei IIpdta's agent AZ Washington.
shortly at.er midnight. according 20 the
rrpot's from san Artoniu, Gomez left for
~ paSo
I'll" garrison AT EUseutda Lowe CALI
foruia. Ia. mutiu,cd against Pau;llcou
NNilez the Niilstt commander Of Love-
California and Av.icz rs Nod. Car
ranCstaS SAY
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04
STANDS UP FOR FORD PLAN.
Proat sharing system Has Made
Good, Says John lee.

Criticisms Of the profit sharing system
OF the Ford Automobile Company in De
trot were answered laSt night by JOAN
Lace Mr. Ford's personal representative,
before the Advertising Mems League ~
tine Aldine club. M Lee asserted that
the profit sharing plan was not adopted for
commercial considerations and was no,
patornallst.c I'm its effect Nj Foisl's
purpose, lac said, is TO make better citizens
and 10 help break down the traditional
barrier between cuplulcr and ,mployrc.
cor our i.UnU Wprkmcn,' he said, "Ni
ner cent are now sharing profits. Tho
great majority own their homes and have
bank accounts The fear ana worry that
make for poor work have been largely
eliminated
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04
ARIZONA ALIEN LAW
OPPOSED BY BRITAIN
Limitation Of Foreign Employ.
ccs Causes Ambassador to
File a Complaint.
TREATY BREACH DOTTED

WAsHNGToN. Dec 3--The controversy
with Japan over the California alien land
law was recalled here to-day upon the oc.
casion of repre- sensations being made TO
the state Department by Sir Cecil Spring.
Rice. the British Ambassador regarding
an Arizona law limiting the employment
OF aliens in that state.
Though compelled by regard for Canada
and Australia 10 give tacit consent to laws
directed against the increased establish
inent OF japanese on this continent. the
British Government now finds itself in tn.
position Of protesting against an Arizona
laW understood to have been drafted for A
similar purpose
The Arizona law limits 10 20 per cent
the numhcr Of alien employees Of any hrw
OF corporation in that state. requiring
that so per cent. nf such employees snail
he American citizens either by birth o.
naturalization.
AS japanese are no. regarded n. eligible
for citizenship by naturalization this law
prevents the employment Of large rumbcrs
of japanese lahnrors on railroad cou.truc-
ton. in mines Or other projects In Arizona
and T. is such an infuN Of japanese laho,
that the Arizona law is understood TO hay.
been framed to- prevent Labor in;eres ts
arc understood 10 have been responsible
for the law
Til" law has affected. however many
British residents Of Arizona employed in
ranches and in mines. These have drafted
petitions TO the British Government pro-
testing against the law. These documents
tho british Ambassador has placed in the
hands OF the state Department
While il is understood the British Am.
haSSddnr's representations DO not merit
, tho term Of formal protest IL is re.
t!d'd as amounting Ia much tho Jam.
thiug. There is no doubt thst tie ron
iosentatious wll, lead to q diplomatic dis.
"usS.on quite Ike that with japan %
Rardng the California law. bur II is no
expected that the discussion viii be "A
a"ut" 80 that with Japan
. Tho charge will he Il. IN tho California
! Jaiduase case, that Treaty rights have
been violated by the Arizona law and "a .
/ ther" Is discrimination against British
subjects. A. TIA" treaty o. lSll between
: -ho United States AMI Great Britain. the
i only on" governing such questions. Is not
! -p"y NJ ou this particular question. Il Ia
, doubtful II The Tinted States will admit
| toat tuer" Is amy treaty violation Tive
| treaty gives British only the generally de-
hurd rights ~ liberty Of residence and
| trad" ana protection thereof, but Al
| ways subject 10 tn" laws and statute,
| OF 'h's country
Even shouts - trea'y violation he es.
tHhhshed. however. wh!cn is not cv-
! 20 ted. Their" WI, arise tho further oucs.
! ton % the power OF the Federal GOV.
| crumeu' to prevent H. This vs. ono
I OF 70" chief issues in the California CON.
rov"rsy anl II Wa generally AZ eed
: that TIE Federal Government has NOT tns
. authority Over the states to prevent the
- 'riment and enforcement ut such Laws,
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04
MRS SLINGSBY TAKES STAND.
Declares freddy" IL Her SOIL
adopted, say Dispositions.

NVff INT VVTF TITNVVTTW TO 7 HF ~ y
LoNpoN, Dec. 3.-h III" continuation
to-day Of the chanCery proceedings
brought by Lieut.. Charles Rcynaud
Sllnesby to establish the legitimacy of
the boy he says Is his son. Mrs, Slingsby
testified that she gave birth to the boy
in the home of Mrs. q. II, Blan, nurse
in san Francisco, She produced Teddy
the boy in question. In court and de
clared dramatically that he was her son
The boy is "A bright, curly haired child,
I years old, She dcuied that III" child
was adopted
Dispositions by Mrs, Bla.n and Or W,
W Fraser of san Francisco werr read to
the effect that no child was born to MIS-.
Slingsby and that they adopted hoy
through Dr. Fraser The mother of the
child. the dispositions declared. was LII
Han Anderson,
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04

'Thc blame must attach 70 state
agencies which are thereby admitted to
b either inefficient or defective"
Further along in his brief Mr. Know
says
Adm ssions such as the one just quoted
49, not wanting in this case TO show
'h tie cal purpose of the continued i'm
~ 80 mcut Of the appellee in the insane
as lun Of New York Is TO inflict pun
is1men. upon tho appellee for the commits
son NJ an act which u New York Jury
MA declared was not crime under the
p cumstHucos Of the case. This IL in
ienSliied by other facts appearing in the
'ecord which seem to evince a DISPOSE
ION 70 take vengeance on the accused
t"r his alleged Initial crime. purpose
heretofore practically unhampered."
VI Knox IL rather severe on the New
York authorities and even on the courts
Ir that State:
IF Is not without significance that when
row, for the first time. the appellee has
5" dred before tribunals and commissions
other than those local TO tho place in
hitch the initial act was committed a
nearing hothAs 10 the alleged dangerous
nature of MS insanity and as to the le-
EaN'y ~ his detention. the courts and
..ons before which he has come
" declared his continued custody inn
p op'r srd have pronounced him no longer
Ct danger 20 the community in which he
Nty be"
" Knox says the purpose of the state
- New York 10 eNtraditing Thaw Is not
{" t'r him for the crime of conspiracy
30 'scap" but to secure his return to
M''oawau
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04
WIFE SUES MOTHER. IN.LAW.
Ash. $4,000 Damages for Alleged
Alienation OF Husband.

MrS. Margaret McAlLstcr tiled suit IN
tn, supreme Court Yesterday Tor S'""o"
damag from ner mother-in-law, MR..
charlotte McA,istcr. on the ground that
,h, aliouat.d IN, affections of Tn" plain
tIM's husband Edwin McNlistcr.
Ire couple We're married at M"utlc'Il"'
Y y. on February .. 1913. and the
plaintiff says she was happy uut'l she
was taken 20 the defendants home +"
live. She says her husband beat her ~
tho irstigatiun ~ his mother and that
tie mother once threaten. u to cut hcr
,p v.th 4 butcher knife
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04

\ few shots have been fired. There
have been few robb,ries. and Iaratstas
who have violated the law are being
treated as others.
The general public seems to he some
what amazed AZ the forbearancc practiscl
by the Zapatistas. There has existed a
general fear that many horrors would be
committed by the southern rebels
The Iapatista soldiers ar" ragged and
hungry for the mos part. Many Of them
marched into the city wearing only white
drawers and thin shirts. They have con-
sequentY suffered great deal from the
chilly temperature of the capital after
the warm climate Of southern Mexico.
Th,v have not received any pay for a long
time.
city before leaving The palaces We're
stripped Of furniture and the treasury i
empty. The Hapatn leaders have declared
themselves unwilling TO dopreciate The
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04

M KNOX points out that the courts of
New York have held tive times in the last
SIX years that Harry Thaw Is insane and
subject to confinement in an asylum and
thst he had been held In confinement as a
dangerous lunatic FOR six years prior to
his escape. lie contends that the supreme
Court cannot overlook the obvious legal
effect of these facts. any more than the
Federal Court for the District of New
Hampshire failed to do and that the court
must concede that the state of New York
has no legal claim upon Thaw that VIII
sustain extradtion.
He discusses in his brief the contention
made by attorneys for the state of New
York that the wealth of the Thaw family
has been used to scandalize the admins
sufficient answer that in every legal pro-
ceeding brought to secure the release OF
ThaW-hve in all--the state succeeded in
retaining custody of him. He observes
that these facts of record do not rrove
the power of wealth 10 sway the court.
Nj Knox calls attention to the fac, that
the only legal victory Thaw has ever won
WAS the decision from the Federal court
for the District OF New Hampshire.
wherein the Judge held that the state NJ
New York could no; claim that Thdw
was insane for the purpose of holding him
IN madhouse and then assert that he was
4 criminal and necessarily sane for the
purpose of cNtraditing him to punish him
fJr walking out Of confinement through
an omen door.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04

There is keen interest IN the Thaw
case Recently Harry Thaw sent to ea n
senator and Representative and O many
other officers of the Government an appeal
which purported to have been prepared by
himself
Mr. KnoN's brief sets out TWO basic con-
tent.ons ON behalf Of his client:
"First--Thdt interstate rendition does
no, lie. excep, upon charges Of crime. and
that the acts here charged do not con
s,.tute a crime within the meaning Of
mo Federal Constitution.
"Sccond--That where. ~ here. tho
papers submitted by the demanding STATE
set forth facts which on their fac"
negative the fact sof criminal response
billy, the accused is entitled 20 be dis
cha sed from custody upon duly in
sttuted writ Of haheas corpus"
In his reply 20 the charg" made ny tire
attorneys for the state Of New Yor'i and
particularly by the AttorneyGenersl that
tho wealth of the Thaws had been used
10 s'andalizc the administration OF he
law Mr.. Knox says:
III the officials OF New York consider
that Justice has at any time failed as
actins, this accused. tho responsibility
therefor must fall on them.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04
Goes to Attack PucbIn.

Goes to attack PUcblR.
Villa soldiers took Pachuca Yesterday
and Iapata, who arrived three DAYS ago,
left to-day with powerful force 20 attack
Francisco Cos. whose 10000 Carranzistas
hold puebla
There is perfect harmony existing be-
tween Gen. Villas followers and the Iapa.
tistas. According to declarations. Zapata
has driven the army OF Carrinza along
the Mexican railroad lin" As far as
Apioaco. The Carranzis;as are reported
TO he ruthlosslN destroying the railway
in many places.
Delegates have arrived AZ the capital
bringing assurances OF recognition for the
now Government from the Governors ~
Mlchoacan and oaNaca. Villas leader.
lauro Mendez. is reported to have de-
fcated cesircn Castro. tho Constitutional.
Isl, near Calpulapam. IN the state Of
fuehla. In the cngagemcn. 10 Consti-
tutionalistS were killed and eighty. Iapa.
tiStaS
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-04

currency by issuing guaranteed notes
Taxes against real estate are expected
as means of raising cash for the Gov
eminent.
The Seattle star. [volume] (Seattle, Wash.) 1899-1947, 1914-06-29
HOUSE USED FOR IMMORAL
PURPOSES, SAYS JUDGE, But
He ISN'T GOING TO CLOSE IT

Although the court finds that the
house was occupied at various
times for immoral purposes. Judge
Ronald Saturday signed the conclu-
sion Of law In the rcd.llght case OF
Nancy Shaw against Bertha Wig
gins. declaring that the lhttera
premises shall not be closed up un-
der the terms OF the abatement law.
The reason assigned is that the
premises have not been a nuisance
since the submission 81 this case 10
the court, nor are the same "A nut.
nance At the present time"
In the findings Of fact, the court
alleges that most Of the roomers Ia
the Virgins home have been law
The Seattle star. [volume] (Seattle, Wash.) 1899-1947, 1914-06-29
WHAT CAN LONESOME GIRL
DO? MANY READERS TELL US

what shall Lonesome Giri' do
Shall she give up the rich young
man" with whom she has 10 roman
tically fallen In love. or shall she, a
poor working girl, keep up hoping
that the wish ofsher heart viii come
true. Lonesome Girl" asked Gym
thia Grey for advice.
The Star is asking the readers 10
solve this problem In a real ro-
nance. and for the best letter OF $50
words will give 81.
To-day batch OF letters brought
the first answers. and they are d.
yided into many opinions.
Here is one letter
"it 10 often said that real
friendship 10 priceless, there
fore | would advise Lonesome