Bisbee daily review., 1914-04-05
Sunday Morning, April 5, 1914.
INDUSTRIAL SCHOOL SCANDAL.

Investigation the State Industrial School has been held in spite of tho recalcrancyif worse-of Gov Hunt and his is-minded colleague on the Board of Control Charles R. osborn The shocking revelations brought forth by State Auditor J. C. Caaghan the third member of the Board are no less to be depored than the shocking revelation that the continuance of corrupt administration the institu tion by of his political henchmen receiving formationso the Callaghan report it-that condi tions the School called for immediate attention Through undispued records of his own actions writes a destructive indictment against him self In moving to trial the against Governor Hun; before the of public opinion the charges taned in the indictment. is pertinent to ask him:
 Why did you send a special emissary. Adjutant Gen eral Harris the institution early as September 1913?
 Was because your suspicious were aroused that all not well there?
 What was the report made to you by Gen. Harris?
 Why did you dispatch your private secretary on mis sion of investigation thirty days following the visit of Gen. Harris?
 Was it because your suspicious renewed?
 What the secretarys report?
 Why did you decline to cooperate in the investigation proposed by MT. Cahaghan?
 Did you any influence either personal official in assisting Mir. Calaghan?
 Did you impede him seek to impede him in the ne gotiations prior to the public hearing of March 19?
 Do you intend take steps the immediate removal of Superintendent whppe?
 Do you believe that by so doing you will be morally relieved of whatever guilt may attach to you tion with the affair?
 The evidence adduced by investigation disclose. conditions which their excessive profgacy be yond the bounds of those derections which difficult to check in many public institutions These conditions covert and therefore difficult of uncoyering They hedged around with the secretiveness us ually attendant immortality. They were so hssran that knowledge of them property within thu sullied precincts of the School
 Governor Hunt had only to glance the ledgers O the institution his capacity Chairman of the Boar of Control to the garing comparisons in the ac counts for the months February 1913 and February 1914 In the former. the daily per capita cost wa s1Os; in the latter sl6O Here increase in COS of maintenance of fftyhve per cent
 The yaunted humanitariansm accredited to Governo Hunt In his socalled prison policy is dscreded and th insincerity of it unmasked by the unhoy practice which, through his negligence a supervisor were pei fnitted to exist in the Industrial School Sworn test mony has 1t that cruel corporal punishment was | vogue; that the whipping post and handcus and dur geon confinement were employed; and specific mentio is made of the case girl who was handcuned nigh and day The report that, "the handcuifs wer apnled at the express command" of Superintendent Whipple MT Calaghan thus comments on this phas of the investigation:
 CT venture the assertion that in no similar instituo i'm inc United States or any other Christian country inc civilized world can examples be found of such ba barous punishment and depryations calculated to eaus stunted growth being inflicted upon helpless and gro' ing children Here indeed, concrete illustrations ina invocation of relics barbarisn regarding %hlc much has been recently heard, condemned as to adn and hardened criminals it is true but apparently san ,,oned or condoned in of delinquent juveniles
 If is incredible Of belief that Mir Callaghan has Tn ai deerea coored his report The public cannot do ohe ,,se tan accept it in the form in which t is made pu nc The facts are sworn facts. The relations or oo eruor liunt to the institution are known relations TT encouragement of the institution was tue manageme