The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-03-07
DIVISION DECISIONS.
List Handed Down Yesterday ~ the
First Department.

The following decisions were handed
down by the Appellate Division. First De-
partment yesterday:
, chsries r Aver re,pondeni. vs.. PAU !;
costs and judgment directed for defendant
opinion by iss,,,ham: r ), n aposlinE' j.
Thomas A. Lewis. suing. Ae. respondent
W Thomas A. Matthews ct al. appellants
and as nodIned affirmed. with costs TO APP
peiiant. Opinions by lnsraham. p j..
ho;ehkiss and Dewilng, ~ uow ,,t ana
Mary Drucx.r as ..eeu,r,x. appellant. vs.
Manhattan Railway Company e. Ell. Esther
Davis. respondent Judgment affirmed, with
costs. Opinions by insraham. r. y. ana
a lssniin j. 4rss. aiea and 49,
LArkin Company, appellant Va Termnai
ns ors.r with by
Lsushiin' J. 'ciaEke' j. a'ssentns'' oFd'f
Anthony Duny. respondent VS.. George W.
Inch as recr, appellant. Judgment re-
y.rsed, with cost, and somp,a,nn, d,sin's'ed
s S,.h s orasr on op no,is. ""f"'"
United States Fidelity q Guaranty Com
psny. plaintiff ". CaInes.s rrn.. s9 orI,,sg
Opinion by Scott, J. Settle order on notice.
dered for pisintin AS stated In opinion. with
costs Opinion by Scott. J. settie order
Joseph Desnan. .respondent. vs.. General
Accident. Fire a Life Assurance Corpora
,ion. Ltd. appellant. Judgment and order
reversed with costs and complaint dis
missed with costs Opinion by McLaush-
I'm; J. SETTLE order on notice. No.
ceased. Order affirmed. with go costs and
disbursement opinion by Scott. J. Order
Hammers,ein Opera Company, app.llsn,.
W. David Belasco and another. respondents
Order reversed With 90 cost. and dis
costs. opinion by Mclaughlin. J. Order
In the Matter of tine Carnegie Trust Com
pany. re security Bank OF New York.
order modified "a directed IN opinion. an.
mssnsI "fh1msa with M e's o.,n aaa
by LAughlin. ]. Settle order on notice.
Tss gsGS Mur,ss Jsms. r. rhomp
son and James h. Husssy. appellants. AZ
TO defendants sweeney. Mur'ha and Thomp.
Hussey. Judgment reversed and defendant
discharged. Opinion by Scott. J. Settle
james Gibney. respondent VS. Rodser. .
Hassr,y. Inc. appellant. Judgment, re-
yersed. with costs and complaint dismissed,
James c: Ecksr,, respondent. VI. Richard
ana r c1S.r w pPs ons opinion 81
Mclaughlin. J, Order filed;
APPELLANT. 'e'I1%asn vs.
costs. Opinion by HotchLi.s, j. settle Or
vn I%1's s.. s'esss ss :s% Ssmpa Ts:
appellant, The Franklin Contracting Com
End s1a:% spe:.i.a ron y el.iS!isi Z,
CONTRACTING COMPANY, and Judgment and
Wood frsssrvins Company reversed. win
| costs to said defendant and complaint dis
missed with costs. opinion by Mclaughlin
Granville Gibbons. appellant. w. New York
Central Hudson River Railroad Company
| respondent. judgment reversed and new
event. opinion by scott. J. Settle orisi
Henry Bsrsauis. respondent. vs.. Oregon
| Apartments Company ct a.. impleaded. 40,
with costs and complaint dismissed with
| costs Opinions BY Mclaughlin. j.. and In
graham =, J; Insraham. p. j.. dissenting
KOCH. Settle order on notice.
the city Of New York. appit. Judgement and
missed with costs. Opinion by Scott, j
Of Judgment and order but dissenting from
dismissal Vt complAinO. Settle order on no
Henry l.. Preston. respondent W. Flor
9. Hobbs, appellant order reversed viii
80 costs. with leave to plaintiff to Withdraw
Hoichkiss. j. Order MED, '"''" VI
Morri. Park Estates. respondent. W
Fanny Fsbricsnt .ppsilsnt. Same Va Same
ments No opinion. Orders hled.
seaman Transportation Company. appellant
dered, costs to- appellant to abide event
op!nion per curtain. Settle order on notice
william 7. Emmet. supsrintsndsnt, DC.
w. sS.r w;' FIX S'S
/ ed dtsburss ~ Aal wotlon donioA M