davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
Honolulu star-bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu, Hawaii]) 1912-2010, 1914-01-08
NEUTRALITY-SUSPICIOUS.
LEAGUE ISSUES REPORT
FOR WORK IN DECEMBER

The report of the Anti-TuberCulOsis
League, setting forth statistics cover
ing the work done by the organization
in Honolulu and the territory during
December, was issued this morning.
The report for the district of Honolulu
shows that 10 cases were placed un-
der supervision during the month, 19
new cases were reported and IS deaths
recorded.
OF the new cases handled in the
district Of Honolulu, seven were Japa-
nese, seven were Hawaiian, three were
Chinese, one Filipino and one Ameri-
can. Deaths in the same district were
Chinese three, Hawaiian nine, Filipino
2, japanese |, Portuguese /, making a
total of 16. The summary of cases
handled in districts other than Homo
lulu follows:
Oahu-New cases, three; died with
in the month, one; total deaths for
December, four; registered cases,
three; unregistered cases, one. Ha-
Waii-New cases, eight; total deaths,
one; number registered cases, 1. Maui
New cases, nine; died within the
month, 2; total deaths, eight. Kauai
New cases, five; total Deaths, two.
Following is the summary for the
territory:
New cases, A; died within the
month. 6; total deaths, 81; registered
cases, p; unregistered cases, 9; new
cases placed under supervision, 16;
new cases not placed under supervi-
sion. %. Summary of the new cases
by nationality-Japanese, Is; Hawaii
an, IS; Chinese, 3; Filipino, 4; Amer
ican, l; Portuguese, 2; Korean, /.
Honolulu star-bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu, Hawaii]) 1912-2010, 1914-01-08
of Toxic Rehearsal
viii Be Held Tonight-Sev-
eraI Meetings Scheduled
CARNIVAL MEETINGS TO-DAY.

Mardi Gras ball committee meets
at 4 O'Clock this afternoon in room
rs, Young hotel building.
PyrotecnnieaI display committee
meets at S o'clock this afternoon at
the 'EIks' Club.
Water carnival committee meets at
1880 o'clock this evening in room IS,
Young hotel building.
Second rehearsal Of the mayor Of
Toxic" will be held at 7:3o o'clock
this evening, Waikiki dining room,
Young hotel building.
Under the direction of sonny"
Cunha, those persons interested IN
the production of the Mayor of To-
kio" will meet in the dining room in
the sixth floor of the Young hotel
building at 7:30 o'clock this evening
for the second rehearsal. At the inI-
tial rehearsal, Monday evening, more
than So persons were present, all Of
whom at one time or another, have
been prominent in local amateur pro-
ductions. Mrs. Charles Crane has
been appointed to the leading role
and, wn1le an announcement Of the
other players has not been made, it
is believed that sufficient material
will be on hand this evening in or
der that number of parts may be
assigned.
The chorus of the Mayor of To-
kio" will without doubt be the larg-
est of its kind ever assembled in
Honolulu. According to Mr.. Cunha,
the peanut ballet will consist OF
the prettiest girls in the city, and
there is still room for number of
young ladies in the chorus The
beautiful grounds of Oahu College
Will be the scene Of the production
and arrangements are now under
way for the seating of a large num-
Der of people the committee in
charge OF the production is composed
of a. r. Cunha, chairman; James A.
Wilder, Prof. A. r. Griftlths, +. {.
Vaughan and Charles D. Wright
Aquatic Committee Meeting.
The committee appointed by DireC-
or-general James d. Dougherty to
have charge Of the aquatic carnival
in the harbOr during the week of
celebration, will hold its initial
meeting at 80 o'clock this evening
in room As. Young hotel building. 1t |
is expected that this feature OF the
carnival will go as far as to OutdO
the annual Regatta Day, if the mem
hers Of the committee carry out the
plans which they now have in mind.
Besides the swimming events, there
Honolulu star-bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu, Hawaii]) 1912-2010, 1914-01-08
additional Gable on page twelve)

his invitation TO the effect that he
did not care at present to take part in
the party councils and that he espe-
cialIy desired personal recommends
tons for those seeking appointments.
When committeeman Pacheeo. Ben
kahaIepuna and J. Fl. Wilson came
from the conference they declined to
discuss the conversation that had
taken place, the chairman even de-
cIining to dfYuIge the names sabnit-
ted to Governor. Pfnkhan The list
was received by the latter. however
and placed on fife.
! While declining to make public the
fist, the governor remarked But you
know my position on these affairs.
think / Iiadesft very plain and II was
IN writing, so there can be no misun-i
derstanfiing or INSTRUMENTATION OF
what said
. One of the members OF the tefritor-
iaI committee calling on the governor
this morning stated that the list OF
men endorsed for cabinet offices BY
the committee and presented to the
chief executive this morning was the
Honolulu star-bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu, Hawaii]) 1912-2010, 1914-01-08
PACHECO ET AL
VISIT GOVERNOR
AND RECOMMEND
Endorsements Made for Posi-.
tions To Be Filled by Pink
ham-Eyeryone Silent =

The Democratic, territorial com
mittee, headed by its chairman, NJ. G..
Pacheco called on the governor. this
morning and presented the list Of
candidates for appointments which
that body recently prepared and en-
dorsed. This was in the face of the
new executives statement a few days
ago to the SO leading Democrats as
sembled in the executive chamber at
Honolulu star-bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu, Hawaii]) 1912-2010, 1914-01-08
Or. FRED BAKER OF
SAN DIEGO TO TALK
BEFORE PROMOTERS

AT the weekly meeting of the Ha-
waii Promotion Committee to be held
at $3.50 p. m, Friday in the rooms OF
the Chamber of Commerce, Stangen-
wald building, Honolulu, Dr. Fred Ba-
ker OF San Diego, Cal. will give an
interesting description of the begin
ming and present status of the San
Diego Biological Association located
AHA Jolla. California. DR.. Baker is
Of the opinion that conditions are
most favorable for the establishment
of snch' line of work in Honolulu.
All Sing, a Chinese convicted at
Hilo of opium smuggling, took the poor
convict's oath before United States
Commissioner Davis today and was
discharged, after serving a sentence of
five months Imprisonment at Oahu
jail, and an additional 30 days in lieu
of the court costs, which had been
assessed against him.
Honolulu star-bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu, Hawaii]) 1912-2010, 1914-01-08
u. P. Stockholders Are Lucky

YORK proposed distrbu
Of
the directors the approved q the
100000 Of Baltimore Ohio stock viii be distributes rata among
will
distribution takes place April 4
Honolulu star-bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu, Hawaii]) 1912-2010, 1914-01-08
Must Pay For Fair Stock

FRANCISCO, sprsekss for
subscribed for $4,000 Of few months
exposition
its Suit brought compel him TO
exposition in todays de-
8
Honolulu star-bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu, Hawaii]) 1912-2010, 1914-01-08
Lakes Storm Costs 1000 Lives

NJ 8-Wh life todayo
first
public. r.
Honolulu star-bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu, Hawaii]) 1912-2010, 1914-01-08
TWENTY SAVED FROM SEA
BY GERMAN BARK after OWN
VESSEL, BURNING, WAS LEFT
Battle Abbey Carrying Coal Across Pacific Catches Fire and
Captain, Family and Crew Take to Boats lust in Time
rAssoeiarcd Press cabIel

ASTORIA Ore JAN "a spectacular rescue from the sea under
arrived with 20 picked from boats which they had taken
refuge
daughters the
Australia
all
exploded
Honolulu star-bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu, Hawaii]) 1912-2010, 1914-01-08
These Baseball Pitchers
Needn't Worry About Tariff

CHICAGO aWassr leading pitcher Of the Amer
outlaw
$4,000 and Of $4,000
Wood
league
Honolulu star-bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu, Hawaii]) 1912-2010, 1914-01-08
1915 Exposition Employing
Thousands; Has Big Payroll

SAN FRANCISCO the
5000
dollars getting "the show will employ ooe
people, L sEs.s
Honolulu star-bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu, Hawaii]) 1912-2010, 1914-01-08
On Way Back To
Calumet To Get Revenge

HouGHToN a-cnares president West
guard Of special deputies
which he sunnaarh de-
He
Calumet
gpuah
Honolulu star-bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu, Hawaii]) 1912-2010, 1914-01-08
Yale May Change Plan OF
Managing Her Activities

IN "A N Yales athletic
advocating the
instead number
Thrfou employed various ander0aduste
actv tiles Of the s
Honolulu star-bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu, Hawaii]) 1912-2010, 1914-01-08
California Citrus Crop Large

today
millions the
dtional twelve
Honolulu star-bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu, Hawaii]) 1912-2010, 1914-01-08

tconanued on page tvo9
The Bridgeport evening farmer., 1914-04-29

Flower and Vegetable Seeds
 JOHN RECK & SON.
The Bridgeport evening farmer., 1914-04-29
FAIRFIELD
fs.ne,cfal to me Fa.rmer.)

Frzirfield. April 29-Awaiting officers frorn this town. to bring them back 10 +be f,lrisdictfon of Connecticut two .-v,ev. who stole horse ana buggy 9owne5 bv Miss Carrie Bunnell are still socl<ed I'D at White Plains, N. Y One <,e inc men is said to be Joseph shit HrofF who was arrested in Stamford foT. s,orse theft in 1900 and was sen fenced to three years in states prison for that crime. Miss BunnelFs horse and buggy have been returned to her. The meeting of the Parenf-Teacn ers' association will be held tomorrow affernoon- It was, called for Friday but was postponed until tomorrow De- cause of the state convention or teachers on Friday
 Rev. J. T. Garland of New York was a recent visitor in town
 Harry Carroll has been appolnfeo an inspector by the Board Of health
 Charles Potts, who has been III at his home for some time, is much ,lna- = Mrs. A. J. Hull is entertaining friends from New York and Brook
 Franlr Parrott is spending a few days with friends in Rye N Y
 Miss Marron Ge has returned to ner home after spending several days as fl4e guest of friends in Hartford
 Frank B.. Banks is i'll at his home n '7'1sTz. 1Trss A. A. Kenny and grandson ! 1,sIte returned to their home after spsnding several days with relatives in Hartford-
The Bridgeport evening farmer., 1914-04-29
STEPNEY

Rev. Alfred Boutwell, of Bridgeport. was an over night guest of MT. and Mrs Mi1on Hawley last Wednesday,
 Harmony Grange met Thursday evening and the first and second de- grees were conferred a class of three after which the following pro- gram was presented. Song by grange; debate, Resolved, that the present school system is more beneficial to the pupils than that Of 20 years ago ence B. Burr, Mabel l.. Morgan; neg ative. Alex Sinclair and Ambrose Hurd. Reading, Anna Hawley, and solo, Miss Vera Hubben.
 Miss Catherine Reitter was recently visitor in Albany, where she attend ed the wedding of a friend
 Quite a number of people from this fighting fire in Hopewell woods. Stu dents from the Sanford school assist ed in putting cut the fire, but consid- erabIe damage was done in the woods belonging to Ralph Benedict, Charles Beck, R P. Morgan and others
 The Ladies' Aid society of the Methodist church will hold meeting and supper on Thursday afternoon of this. week at the home of Miss Car oIyn GarIick It is expected that, en- broidered shirt waists will be for sale.
 C. E. Osborne purchased Jersey COW from Herbert Joyce last week.
 Frederick Provost moved his house hold goods to Shelton on Monday
 Mrs Edward Lee and daughter of Bridgeport spent a. few days last week as the guests of Mir. and Mrs. Wilbur French.
 Miss Mabel Gilbert, who has spent several weeks with Mrs. Carrie FL well, has returned to her home in eNewtown.
 Some Of the schools in town will not be in session on Friday, as the teach CTS will attend the county convention in Norwanx
The Bridgeport evening farmer., 1914-04-29
MAaIM0TH ASSEAdRIsY AT
 EAGLES CARNIVAL CLOSE

Probably the largest crowd ever gathered in Eagles, hall was present 1ast night when the big carnival r,vf1IeRs Bridgeport aeries Fraternal Or der Of Eagles, has been conducting, carns to q. close The lower ante roazns of the big building had been f4s.arissforrned into grin rooms and there refreshments. were served while some of the best known vaudeville and cab aret performers entertained. dn the main haIl more than 3,oo0 dancers trfpped the light fantastic until mid- night Every room in the big build ing was 50 closely crowded that it was diff5cuit to move about
 It was midnight before the big crowd began to disperse- Much fa- vorab1e comment on the decorations, the dance music and the arrange ments in general was heard The carnival was one of the must s1Cc- cessful entertainments ever given by Bridgeport aerie and a tidy sum will be added to the treasury in conse- quence.
The Bridgeport evening farmer., 1914-04-29
TRUMBULL

Pupils who were perfect in attend ance in Room No 1 of White Plains school during the month of April in- clude Katherine Burton. Marjorie Can non, Mildred Cannon, Lillian ImnoH, Frances Linley, Kenneth cannon, Ar thur French, Willie French, George Macho1owski. Otto Macholowski and Erie Peterson.
 The meeting of the Women's Home and Foreign Missionary society which was to have been held Wednesday, afternoon has been postponed until next week.
 Mrs Charles Ensign entertained the Sewing club at her horne in the Cen ter this afternoon.
 The Ladies, Guild of the Nichols Episcopal church will hold a. whist Friday evening at the home of Chas. Booth in White Plains. The pro- ceeds are to be used towards the new parish house.
 The senior class of the Bridgeport High school Of which F. Merrill Beach is, member, will be entertained at hisIshome in Daniels Farm.
 Harry Trusdale, of Bridgeport, is building a small house on the lot which he recently purchased and will occupy it until ready to build a lar ger one.
 Mrs. Laura Beach, of Bridgeport, is visiting her grandfather. William O. Beach. Miss Mabel Beach, who has been spending the winter South. has returned home.
 Albert Wilson, of Daniels Farm, is planning to build a house on the land near his shop.
 MT. and Mrs Herbert Flint, Of Daniels Farm. are enterta ming. their dAughter
The Bridgeport evening farmer., 1914-04-29
A SPLENDID REMEDY
 FOR BLADDER TROUBLE

am pleased to testify to the merits of Dr. Kilner's Swamp-Root, which I had occasion to use for bladder trou- ble, which my physician was unable to relieve
 Four ffty-cent bottles of your rem sdy effected a complete cure. -.-~. ssS Yours4 truly,
 PETER VAN DENSE,
 GreenviIle. Mich. State of Michigan, County of Montca1n1, ss., The foregoing hos this 18th day of July, 1909, been subscribed and sworn to before. me a Notary Public in and for Montealm County, Mfchigan.
 FRED A. GLEASON,
 Notary Public.
The Bridgeport evening farmer., 1914-04-29

Flower and Vegetable Seeds
 JOHN RICK X SON.
The Bridgeport evening farmer., 1914-04-29
By Dr. Henry M. Pollock Superintendent of Norwich. (Gonnecticut) State Hos pitaI.

The approved cornerstone in the structure of penology is no longer re- venge but self-d defense.
 theoretically to be assured of a complete defense against the wrong doer, society must surround itself with a triple wal1;s the first the certainty that for a, varying time the wrongdo- CT will be kept under surveillance; the second the assurance that during this period he will be made self-support- ing; the third, the belief that ere sur vellance is removed he will have un- dergone moral regeneration. Lack ing in one of these society is not fully protected.
 Practically it may be Impossible to close every breach in these walls but at least our energy should be directed to making them as secure as possible
 Connecticut under her probation system, in her industrial school for boys and girls and in her reforrnatory and prison has made an effort to erect this triple defense, and so far as sen { timent and circumstances will permit has made each as secure as possible, but in her county jai1s only the wall of surveillance has been raised. even the foundations are lacking for those of support and regeneration.
 40 PER GENT. DRUNKARDS.
 An a naIysis of the commitments to Connecticut's county jai1s will disclose that more than forty per cent were for drunkenness. A further investi- ga,tion will reveal that the drunkard during his stay is supported in idle ness at the expense of the taxpayer, or at the best is spasmodically en- gagged in comparatively unremunera- tive labor, and that when released he is weakened mentally, morally an1 physically, and goes out with only his | thirst strengthened and with every fibre tissue and organ of his body 1 craving the stimulation of alcohol Should it occasion wonder that he is again presented to the court for re- sentence, and that again and again he makes the same journey until a crime
The Bridgeport evening farmer., 1914-04-29
WHY IT SUITS PARTICULAR
 PEOPLE,.

Foley's Honey and Tar Compound is prompt and effective for coughs. colds. croup hoarseness. bronchial coughs and throat troubles Thomas verron, Hancock. Mich, writes: "Fo- ley's Honey and Tar quickly relieves tickling throat and stops the coughs with no bad after effect It con tains no opiates and is pure That's. why it suits particular people. Hin- dle.s Drug Store--Ady.
The Bridgeport evening farmer., 1914-04-29
Letter to- Dr. Ka1lszzer @ Go. BtuathantOu,
 New York

Prove What Swamp-Root W1n Do
 For You.
 Send ten cents to pr. Kilmer 6 Co, Binghamton, N T.. for a sample size bottle It will convince anyone Xou will also receive booklet of va1- z1able information telling about the Kidneys and bladder When writing be sure and mention the Bridgeport Daily Farmer. Regular fifty -oent and mne-doI7ar size bottles feT salo at all &ruM MtMEMm.=.A A1ga
The Bridgeport evening farmer., 1914-04-29

Henry T. Willis. tariff expert, died at Southampton, L. I.
The Bridgeport evening farmer., 1914-04-29
PATENTS TO UNDERGRADUATES

Through the office of A. M Woes ter, solicitor of patents Charles A. Bates has patented a push-switch: Frank O. Hoagland, a cartridge and F. A. Hawthorne, lamp.
The Bridgeport evening farmer., 1914-04-29

Representative Mcclellan of Ten nessee, introduced a Dill authorizing President Wilson to give preference to medal of honor men in appointing officers to the volunteer army.
The Bridgeport evening farmer., 1914-04-29
POINTS OF INTEREST

We are displaying the choicest pat terms in new dainty white embroid- cred lawn shirt waists at B- H. Dillon pRs O., 1,105 Main street--Adv.
The Bridgeport evening farmer., 1914-04-29

A hock of homing pigeons owned by George Richardson, of Newton Centre, Mass, flew from Amherst to Newton Centre, a distance of no miles in one hour and 50 minutes.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1914-10-20
Real Estate Transfers.

CoUNTY-May E. Smith to T. Towson
Smith. lot II: square 545S; so; ,,r
Pairo, lot ~. square 1885; $40
CONDUIT ROAD-John F. Green ct
ux. to William A; Hazel. part lots
coLuM \ H H II c. F
Hugo to Elizabeth Y. Hugo, lot "a
block. q: SO.
VILLA PARK-Clara A. Marden to
w W;!liam Sass s; Robe lot 49, square
LAN1ER HEIGHTs-charles E. Wire
ct al. to Louise D. FINLEY. lot 42s'
FAfRv1Ew MISUNDERSTANDING W
81. So and part lot SO. block /: $40
COLUMBIA HE1GHTs-Mary S. Logan
to Johnson HELEN. part lot 6s'
block 81: SO.
RENO-Annie George. ct vir, Cumber-
land. to Dudley Banks. lot H.
square 1913; SIPS.
SEVENTH STREET NORTHEAST be
tween D and f streets-Kennedy
Bros. to Ida F. Drury. lot 1913,
square S62; $40.
Rust ct al. trustees. to Kennedy
Bros. lot 1885, square so31: $500.
MERIDIAN HILL-Aaron Johns ct ux.
to Agnes V. Scott, lot IA. block 3;
$40.
f STREET NORTHEAST between 9Th
and 7th streets-Kennedy Bros. to
Otto c. Brahler. lot 173. square S62;
$40.
NO, 2o7 K STREET NORTHEAST
Summerfield G. Nottingham. execu-
tor, to William w. Edwin l.. Sum
merfeld G: and Katherine S. Not
tingham. Elizabeth N. Henderson
and Ida E. K. Henderson, part lot
3. square 1858: ST.
NO. 931 l STREET NORTHWEST
Charles Brickwedde, trustee. to Hen
rietta Brickwedde and Edward Voigt,
part lot 9. square 373: $1,000.
NO. 125 18th STREET NORTHEAST
Patrick D. Holmes ct ux. to Marie C.
Willis. lot 81. square 1894: $40.
ADDITION TO ANACOSTIA-Alexa
Sharper to George F. Pyles. lot rs.
block /: $40. ....
NO. ST. c STREET NoRTHEAsT-
Margaret Cornell to Walter S.
Pratt. jr.. lot 90. square s17: $40.
THIRTEENTH AND G STREETS
SOUTHEAST-Georg A. Berry ct
ux. to Florence NJ Berry, part lot %,
square 1920; $40.
NO. 1895 U STREET NORTHWEST
Margaret D. Dugdale ct vir, H. Kir-
kus. to H. Latane Lewis, lot 2o2.
square 204: SO.
NO: 1885 9 STREET NORTHWEST
I STREET NORTHWEST between oath
and 25th streets-Almanza s. Lind
say ct ux. to Mary ]. MARI, lot 1913,
square %: $40.
BARRY FARM-Alice E. Luckey to
Clarence w. Tignor, lot A. section
3; $40.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1914-10-20
wH1TNEY's HORSES ARRIVE.
aarmonicum, Called Best Splinter in
England, Among Lot.

NEW YORK, October 20.-An i'm
portant consignment of horses belong
ing to Harry Payne Whitney arrived
here yesterday the steamship Min
newaska of the Atlantic Transport line.
The star of the lot was Harmonicum, a
four-year- by Observation-Disclosures
chord, which was considered the best
sprinter in England. There was a
highly bred three-year-ol by Spear
mint, a Derby winner, out of Miss
Hamburg, and fourteen yearlings- The
yearlings are mostly by Broomstick
and Hamburg. All were in good con-
dition when examined by DR.. r. w. Nc
Gully. The horses will be taken from
the ship today and will spend the
winter at Mr.. Whitney's stud farm at
Brookdale, n. J.
Jack Joyner, who trains for Mr.. Whit
ney In England, did not come with the
horses and according to private advices
he will not leave England. This indi-
Gates that Mr.. Whitney will not give
up his English stable entirely, though
the fact of his bringing over SO many
horses assures that he will pay more
attention to the American turf in fu-
ture.
The yearlings which have arrived are
In plenty of time to be entered in most
of the important two-year-old stakes
for next year
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1914-10-20
THE COURTS.
Supreme Court of the United States.

Tuesday. October 20. 1914.
Present: The Chief Justice. Mr.. Jus
tice McKenna, Mr.. Justice Holmes, Mr..
Justice Day, Mr.. Justice Hughes. Mr..
Justice Van Devanter. Mr.. Justice Lamar,
Mr.. Justice Pitney and Mr.. Justice Nc
Reynolds
Frederic P. Vose of Chicago. Ill ;
Austin Victor Cannon of Cleveland,
Ohio. and Felix E. Alley of Waynes-
willie, N. c.. were admitted to practice.
No. $50. Mohawk Overall Company ct
al. plaintiffs in error, agt. Hooker, Cor
ser & Mitchell Company: motion to dis
miss or affirm submitted by Mr.. Charles
c. Fits and Mr.. Robert c. Bacon for
the defendant in error in support of
the motion and by Mr.. William Dewey
Loucks for the plaintiff in error in op-
position thereto.
No. SIG. Commonwealth Trust Com
pany, plaintiff in error. agt Albert A.
Trocon ct al. partners. etc, ct al; mo-
ton to dismiss or affirm and for dam
ages submitted by Mr.. William c.
Scarritt for the defendants in error in
support of the motion, and by Mr.. Carr
w. Taylor for the plaintiff in error in
opposition thereto.
No. APO. Northern Pacific Railway
Company, plaintiff in error. agt. state
Of North Dakota on relation Of T. F.
McCue, attorney general, and
No. 421. Minneapolis, st. Paul and
Sault Ste. Marie Railway Company,
plaintiff in error, agt. state Of North
Dakota on relation of T. F. McCue, at
torney general; argument continued by
Mr.. C. L. Young for the defendant in
error