New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1914-05-30
Inc mreuins ~ s"s
STATE COURTS.
SUPREME COURT.
AnnelIaie DiyIsion-Iirst Department.

Appellate Division--tirst Department.
DECISIONS.
Oakland Mfg cor q Idnde Co-Judgment
reversed and new trial ordered before anotns'
referee. with costs To appellant TO abide event.
opinion by lngraham' i. =. a.
Breuchard ct al as admrs/Rudlger ~ az
Judgment and order reversed. with costs anu
complaint dismissed with costs opinion ty
People. etcIJohn n Acknowledgements at
hrmed. Opinions by Hotchkiss j., and lhsra-
ham. i. j. -,
I ment reversed with costs, demurrers sustained
with costs. with leave TO plaintn 10 herse
amended complaint on payment OF Sosts ~, III
this court and in the court below. opinion W
Mclaughlin, J. -.
DryerHopper. Register, etc. ct al-Judgment
ordered for plaintin as Indicated In orhioh'
Opinion by IAughlin, ].
Brinley/Nevins-Judgm and order reversed
and new trial ordered. with costs 10 appellant
TO abide event. opinions by MclAughhh' -
and lngraham 7. J. ungraham, T. j. d's-
sentlng).
People. etc/Benjamln Fein-Judgment re
versed and new trial ordered. Opinion ~
Pearse/ National Lead Co implicated with
George A Pearse ct al-Judgment reversed
with costs and judgment ordered for appenant
dismssing the complaint upon the merits WIN
costs. Opinion by bowling, j.
Barry Mulhall-Judgment and order reversed
without costs. and complaint dismissed with with
out costs. Opinions by iotchkiss and DOW
ling. -. Dowling, j., dissenting.
Sarah Ralya/City OF New York-JudSmsnt
and order reversed. with costs ind complaint
dismissed with costs. opinion by Laughlin. j.
Adele Heisenbuttal/ Observation-Disclosures ma
order reversed. with costs and complaint CTS
missed with costs. opinion by Hotchkiss, j,
In re Penelope McCrea-Decree mo9ned as
directed In opinion and as so modified al
firmed with costs to appellant Abbott ana 10
the executor payable out OF the estate Opih-
People, etc Acknowledgement and orders
affirmed
Charles S Hirsch, as exr. etcHLouise
, u+fh et
Judgment affirmed with costs 10 respondent
Louise $ Bucki and TO the executors plaintiffs
to be paid out OF the fund opinion Dy
Martha T Brown Arbogast & Bastian Co
impld etc. Judgment and order afiirmed' Win
costs Opinion by Laughlin. j. ,
lines Getty/Roger Williams Silver co. Juds-
ment and order reversed, with costs; ana cor
plant dismissed with costs opinion py seo ti ..
Renault Freres Selling Branch. lnc/se~ell *
Alden. Judgment and order afhrmed' Win
costs. IL.
costs verdict reinstated, so much OF me l1as
ment as dsmissos complaint against Defendant
Weber reversed. and Judgment ordered on Se.
dict. with costs TO appellant against respondent
Weber. opinion by Scott, j. ia.
Maria Bruno .inch. as receiver. etc. Judg-
ment ana order affirmed with costs.
Carmolo Bruno/Linch as receiver etc
Judgment and order affirmed with COSTS
Zarch /Zarch Judgment affirmed. with cost,
Mary i. Mccormick, as aamIlS ol N,-,ai
Judgment and order reversed, ana new t'ls'
ordered. with costs TO appellant, 10 acme ever,
opinion by Ingraham. =. J. Lanshhh anu
People. etciMorris Rothstein and H'rry Biz
Judgment affirmed al, -,
Annie Paulis/ Codinston Co. Judgment and
order affirmed with costs. -, "a
McCull.n/ McCullen. Judgment REVERSED az"
decision modihed as indicated In opinion
Opinion by Laughlin, j. IN .
Elizabeth. Atkins, as eNtrx' e,c' et avg -
Trowbridge ct al. Judgment and order re
Versed with costs, and complaint dlsIhlsseu'
with costs Opinion by Scott j. -
Netie Wintersteen, as admrx/C or l.
Judgment affirmed, with costs. co. 10 or
Theresa Senior. an infant, etc/star 90 vi
der reversed with SO costs and disbursements I
and motion granted with Slo cos,s. VIZ aod 10
TO defendant 20 withdraw demurrer anu ~
answer on payment Of costs IN 'nis aooi' ~
in the court below. Opinion per curtain yudr-
Helene Pagenstecher/Alma carson. 'u"s
ment affirmed with costs. - 49,
People ex rel John W McGloin/ PstroiTYe Men
Benefit Association OF the Clty OF We" ioiN'
Judgment affirmed with costs ,..,x,,..,
The Lambs, Inc/AIarie DRESSER judgment
affirmed with costs. 49, Mt. :. al
respta Judgment affirmed with costs.
! Kettier/McDermott Dairy co. judgment and
order aiirmsa with costs; ,.,a,,,,or, A.
Schmidt /Siemund, impld, etc. judgment a.
frmed with costs with leave TO defendant 70
withdraw demurrer and TO answer on ps SIo,
OF costs in this court and in the court neion ;
Fannie Light Louis Fischer. Judgment ana
order affirmed with costs ,.,a,o,. 70
Bolognino/ julia shetland Judgment -.
ycrsed and new trial ordered with costs 70
appellant to abide event. Opinion by Claihe .;
His Majesty the sultan of Turkey, e.
Haroutyoun Tiryakian ct al. as eArs. ~.
Judemcnt reversed with costs and demurrer
overruled with costs, with leave 10 delen "a
ants to withdraw demurrer ana 10 ahsW The
payment OF costs I'm this court ana IN t"e
court below opinion by Iaughlln, j. .
Lorenz Reich Alexander cochran 81
al indy. etc. judgment reversed with costs,
demurrer sustained with costs. with leave 10
/ plaintiff to serve an amended cohipidint pa
payment of costs in TINS con court anu III WV
Leopold/Hote Shelburne. Inc. SO msch 1,,, OF
determination reverses judgment OF Cieg
Court affirmed: SO much thetepi d % Win
complaint reversed. new trial oI1eIeu VIZ H.,
costs of appeal to abide event opihion ~
'S Campbei IMcNuity RIOS. inpld. etc. Judg-
/ mont reversed and new trial ordered win
costs to appellant TO abide event Op'hioh
''A Anna /, Wann. as surviving trustee, 'etc/
[ Louis u AMY e al, inpld. etc. order az
nrmed with so costs and disbursements WIN
leave to plaintiff TO withdraw demurrer anu
/ to answer on payment OF cos's III tnlS ''N''
and I'm the court below. -,
Brush/N y II q y r r ct al Judg-
| r,fnt Affirmed with costs Opinion by Scott. j.
Dessan as eXr. etc/Hirsch ct al as eArs
etc Determination reversed with costs m
this court and in the Appellate Term, ana
order Of City Court affirmed. opinion per
Mabel whittemoreIThe Equitable Trust
| Co as successor. etc. Judgment ordere1 LOT
/ plaintiff. as indicated In opinion opinion ny
/ acknowledgement Co/Elias Gottfried ct al.
! Judgment and order affirmed. with costs.
! O'Nen/C of Y Judgment and order ar
fTmed. with costs. s
/ pcoplo. etc/Moe Abelson Judgmen; reversed.
demurrer oyerTuled, ana case renamed 10
I court Of Special Sessions. 10 proceed IN &C
cordance with opinion. Opinion by clarke. y.
/ Cohen Rothschild ct al. order reversed, Win
$40 costs and disbursements and motion de-
Mod with SO costs Opinion by Lau2hlln' j.
I London q Southwestern Bank. Ltd/White.
/ order affirmed with $40 costs and disburse-
| meuts Opinions by Scott. J., and lngraham'
p J. Nngraham =. j. dissenting)
! / n Gray/GTay. order reversed, with 80
costs and disbursements. and motion denied,
/ with $40 costs. with leave TO plaintiff 10 renew
I on uavment Of counsel fees and all accrued
! alimony opinion boy iaughlin. J.
/ RothschidH + 81 al. order reversed
/ with $40 costs and disbursements and motion
! granted 20 extent indicated in opinion. Opinion
I nv scott J. Concurring memorandum by
/ Iaughlin. j. Ongraham. r. j.. dissenting)
/ Emma L SulyFrinany & 90. order re
versed. with SO costs and disbursements ana
motion denied. with $40 costs. Opinion by
Henrietta Eisenhach. also known as Elite
J Eisenbach Mutual Life Insurance co OF New
PROPOSALS.