The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1914-12-25
Bronx
APPELLATE DIVISION DECISIONS.
Complete List Handed Down Nes-
terday by the r4rst Department.

terdny by the rrrst Department.
The Appellate Division. First Depart
ment. announced yesterday the following
decisions:
spplt Judgment and order reversed and
new trial ordered, costs TO appellant to abide
event opinion per curtain Settle order
on notice
Louie Ettlinger. respt. vs.. National Surety
Company, spp,t JSdsmS,n. and order al, a.
Helen Klein. appit;. We Prudential Inspr-
anee Company Of America, respt Jutg-
ment affirmed with costs. No opinion. order
Frances NJ. Cavanaugh indiv.. &c respt..
vs. Josephine a MurphS ct a.; appus JUG
opinion. order hied.
Bank OF the Metropolis resp,., W. George
MSLesh; spP, Judgment and oy oIaer Az a.
Hack Bros & Co. respt., vs.. Theodore
starrett Company. !mpd, appit Judgment
affirmed. with costs. No opinion. order
MED.
People ex rel. william A. Smith. rel. vs.
Rhinelander Waldo as Commr. respt; Writ
$50 costs AND and dsSarsemts,s 80 opinion
order nied.
Helene Dosa,al as. admx.. respt.. VS.. II.
armed, '' with "e costs. 10 opinion Spowlins
j.. and Hotchkiss, J., dissenting and voting
the ground that there is no proof OF he de,
fendants neghgenee or OF the aosenee OF
\ CDntTlDukofF negligence on kuN par VI N.AV
PLAINTIFF order nlcd.
Robert /. rishe' appl,, ~ F.ore e'',,
costs No opinion. order filed.
A.sens American Portland Cement Works
respt., vs.. New Jersey Dock, and Bridge
nqasnF Go%R1ny p99pnon J43 GiGer NED
Joseph a. Bake. respt. vs.. Gus Elevator
company. apt JHdsmehta , aihrmea' Win
In the matter Of George H. Morgan, de,
ceased. Decree affirmed, with costs No
opinion. order fled.
People ex rel Cornelius Mcnamara. rel
vs. Rhinelander waldo a. Cammr. respt'
Wr s "a and ana Psqsgc@s 80
| James sullivan. an infant respt., vs
Jacob RGppert spplt Jqdgment and order
affirmed with costs No opinion order
died.
PEG ex rel Patrick Reiliy, re-. ". Rhine
/ lander waldo as Commr; respt. WIN az ~
missed and p,oeeedimgs Sihri"sa " a5Iphpn,ssgn '
order t aied
Joseph Tauber, respt. vs.. Welsh Maehin,
wSsh Inc" new 1P Pps O1Se2sa costs to sp
pellsnt to abide event on ground that rs
was not sustained by tho evidence. Settle
order on notice
Harry Etshails. resp,.. We. james F Fargo
9MeLaashiin, J.. dissenting order hod
ASsa , 4 Bishop y 9m Ss JAMS G.nSp b SsGs
! 20 tar as appealed from reversed, With 81,
costs and disbursements. opinion per cur
lam order nled.
Jsmes O. Ba,terson. rsspt, vs. Harr'
Raymond ct ak appSts . 05 6sta moa arTm a
without costs opinion per curtain settl
order on notice.
siestricd salomon e, al, applsr vs Her
aiirmed. with costs No opinion, orde
hlsd
! 80 Ifshn pDininI
Order died.
A. schwoerer & sons, respt, vs. sylveslte
Ross Jr, apPIib 0raSr sthrmSa W,TGi 10,
Harry A. Astle,, e, al, .respt., vs.. Ponclan
Y appi, order afhrmed. with $40 cost
and disbursements No opinion oFde
: died.
Berth, ,0s sS"sS oras sf'P sirm.a L01 Win req.
costs and disbursements, No opinion, 'Mc
, Laughlin, j.. dissenting order h.ed.
Gutts Percha and Rubber Mig. Co spPlt
rsspt order affirmed, WITH SO costs Is "a an
clifford F. McAvoy So trustee respt, "
TIDE Water Oh CO. sPPit order rrverse sec
t,on deUe tU'S With tIo costs win leave
pIsintitr upon payment OF such costs 10 RI
new on proper papers opinion per euriaH
Hosting Machinery CO, applt ys FEEDER
: Terra Gotta Co. repst, order affirmed Wit
so costs ana disbursements no opinion
order filed.
J Midtown Contracting Co. applt, VS.; Lou
= Goidsticker and another, respte order al
nrmed, with $40 costs and disbursement
. No opinion order filed
. Milton saxson rcspt, vs. y " o. &
orders reversed. with $40 costs and a.,
bursements and motions granted with 81
0 costs. No opinion orders filed
Robert g. Ryan, respt. VS. Mary c.
0 Clark. Indy, &c. applt. order aiflrme'
70 With $40 costs and disbursements withor
!, preiudice to motion by defendant as state
D In opinion. opinion per curtain ord'
: hled.
michael +. whaien, resp,o W. City c
q New York, applt order affirmed, wit
$40 costs and disbursements. No opinloI
order nled,
Marshall A. Barney. respt, vs.. AlexandC
'. &. Chessin, appt order reversed with 81
r costs and disbursements and motto
: granted, with $40 costs No opinion" Oh
4 der Med. -,
/. rcspt. order affirmed, Win $40, costs an
Is disbursements 80 opinion. order hled.
4 Abraham Greenberg. respt. VS. Mey'
= GqdSe,g impld s9Pt 0ra,T sft'rms
=. The same VS.. Goldberg Greenber
10 order affirmed, with $40 costs and al
bursements. No opinion. ORDER Med. ma,
Ma rssp pT's order APP sftfmss Sh SO m
and disbursements. No opinion Ord
- Anlsim Adzerycha respt. vs.. Holbroo
N Cabot A. Rollins Co. sppit Order affirme
q Matter OF Samuel Leow. respt.; vs. Jof
4 7, Fetherston as comm, spPia ORD