New-York tribune., 1913-07-20
MOLLY BAWN WINNER
At ISL|P HORSE SHOW
DOLPHIN and Kildare Next Best
in Combination Class at
Old Grounds.
SUBSTITUTE JUDGES ACT
Regulars Go to Luncheon and
Fail to Return in Time
Roy Hartsell Appears
in Four Roles.

Ill L Jul 1SOANS'
For the first time in several seasons the
show horses paraded before the judges at
oakwood Park yesterday, and except for
the absence Of the harness horses. it
seemed quite like the old Bay Shore Horse
Show. which was for a number Of years
a feature Of the season. The new institu-
tion is called the Islp Horse Show. but II
Is held on the old grounds. which are sit
uated between Islip and Bay Shore
Judging began at 1880 a. m. and con-
tinued until dusk. with an intermission for
luncheon. AS there was nothing edible TO
he found on the grounds. the judges ana
spectators were compelled to journey In to
Bay Shore for luncheon. Combination
harness and saddle horses were called for
o'clock. and when at 2I5 W. r. Grace
Charles ! de Bevoise and F. s. Won Stade
had not returned TO resume their task oil
judging. CARL Burr and Gurney c. Cue
were asked to act as substitutes. MI
Burr and Mr. Cue had judged the con
testants in harness when the adJudlcators
arrived There were five horses in the
class and FIVE judges, and as cach judge
seemed TO have a different idea Of what
constituted a good combination horse, the
exhibition threatened TO last for the re-
mainder Of the afternoon.
Miss Dorothy Hubbs rode the beauuful
chestnut Molly Bawn. from the Sequa-
togue Farm. and she was placed ahead OF
Mrs. George A Ellis. jr. 5, Dolphin MISS
II. D. Atterbury's Champion Kildare was
a disappointment in harness. The one
fault that any one has ever found with
him as a saddle horse is that he looked
bit "harnessy." tie travelled much better
under saddle than he did in harness, how
ever. ard was third choice in the ribbons
Miss Marjorie Hubbs rode Francis Nc
Donald from the Sequatogue Farm and
took an ". G.
The SeQuatogue Farms won many olues
and a few reds and yellows. Frances Nc
Donald made her debut In the novice class
early in the day, and here she defeated
Dolphin. which was placed ahead of her
later in the day. There were two classes
for hunters. heavy and light weight. sam
uel WilIets had three entered in the hSht-
weight division. Black Bird, handsome
mare. made clean performance and de-
f,ated Allan Pinkertons roam Taxi, ana /
Red Bird. also from Mr.. Wilets stable.
Roy Hartsen. chestnut gelding. from /
the stable Of Harry r. Peters, proved 70
be exceedingly versatile. He appeared in |
the novice saddle class in the heavy
weight polo pony class, in the exhibition /,
Of road hacks and again in the polo
game. and he never failed to get in the |
ribbons.
Miss Marion Holins rode her brown |
gelding Peter the Painter TO victory in |
the exhibition Of road hacks. This was |
one Of the strongest classes Of the day |
in the class which called for saddle |
horses 152 hands or over Miss II. d. At |
terbury won a notable victory with Kill |
dare He was placed ahead Of Mrs. Mar |
garet l. Barrett's Redlight and Mrs |
Charles F. Cartledge's MALTA
Horace Havemeyer won the exhibition |
Of lightweight polo ponies with an added !
entry called Angelo. Harry T. Peters
showed My Lady. and William K. Dick |
was up on Silver Side.
There was a half-nnile race, free for all. !
with four entries. Former. a handsome
black gelding, owned by Charles Doscher;
Allan Pinkerton's Cherry. S. F. Roths
child's Lokomis and Thomas Pursehouse's
Zera Kessler, an added starter There
were many fake" starts. but finally they
got away, with Former. In third place.
Before they had reached the first turn
ne was leading, and he finished twelve
lengths ahead Lokomis was second. and
zers Kessler was right at his shoulder.
Cherry dropped out at the quarter post
Among those noticed on the lawns and
in the boxes were Mrs. W. Tyson Hay
wood Miss Marion Hollins. Mr.. and Mrs.
Charles F. Hub5s. Miss Marjorie Hubbs.
Mise Dorothy Hubbs. Mr.. and Mrs. Balfe,
J. Mifien Wharton. Mr.. and Mrs II. b.
Holiins. Miss Hopeton D. Atterbury. Miss
Margaret Weyher. Percy Drury. Lewis
z. Waring, Mr.. and Mrs. William Dyke
1nan. Mr. and Mrs. S. T. Peters, Mr. and
Mrs II. Weeks, Mr.. and Mrs. II. T.
Havemeyer. Mr.. and Mrs. Harry T.
Peters Mr.. and Mrs. f. c. Blum Miss
Alice Blum August Cordier, Miss Alice
Cordier. Mr.. and Mrs. J. F. Carlisle,
Allan Pinkerton, Mrs. Robert Pinkerton
The summaries follow;
Novice SADDLE horses not exceeding 5
hands; prize cup)-First, sequatosue Farms
Er. m. Frances Mcdonald: second. Harry T.
Peters's ch. &. Roy Hartsel; third. Mrs.
George A. Ellis. Jr's, ch. 3. Dolphin: fourth,
Thomas PursehouSes ch. m. Zera Kess!er.
Harness ponies (to be driven by a child
not over fourteen years OF age: prize cup
First Harry T. Peters's b. g. Neddie; sec
ond. Miss Marion Hollins's b. m Daisy;
third Miss Natalie Peters's Rr.. &. Pharaoh
fourth Miss Betsy Dewals 70. g. Sand.
Saddle ponies Go be ridden by children
not over fourteen years Of agel-First. H.
Hutton's b. e. Little Ed second Harry T.
Peters tr.'s b. &. Neddie; third, Miss Natalie
peterss gr. e. Pharaoh fourth Miss l.. Hol-
ins's br. m. Pebbles.
Novice SADDLE horses. over IS hands,
First Mrs. Charles r. Cortledge's b. e. Nolla;
second. sequstogue Farms ch. g. Flash
third. Mrs George a. Ellis. Jr's. ch. 8.
Henry Bright; fourth, william X. Dickss
heavyweight hunters - First. Lawrence
Smith Buffers b. <. Hero; second Allan
Pinkerton's b. <. Talisman.
Lightweight hunters-First, Samuel VII !
lets's blk m Black Bird second. Allan Pink
ertons 70. &. Taxi; third, Samuel Wiletss
b. M. Red Bird.
Heavyweight polo ponies-First Harry T.
Peterss ch. z. Roy Hartsel. second. Harry
T. Peterss gr. z. sterlington: third. J. F.
Carlsles gr. 8. Myrtle: fourth, Allan Pinker-
saddle horses (over 10 hands and not ex |
ceedins 1872 hands, - First, Sequatogue |
FARMS ch m. Fantasy, second. Richard 2. /
Sause's b. z. sunbeam. third. Sequatogue |
FARMS ch. < Sir Bedouin. fourth, Sequa- /
togue Fsrms's ch. & Flash.
Saddle horses 1872 hands or over-First. |
Miss H. d. Atterbury's hr. e. Kildare. second |
Mrs Charles F. Cortedge's b. g. Nolla |
Arthur II IaWrences ch. VayRfde |