The sun., 1913-10-07


Nas not even a ruinor that one OF thcae
Rine from the Ryan interests. The young
man testified with the utmost reluctance
in fact he was angry at having IN
testify at all that he VAS pUlc
Mr.. Stanchficid had ~ hard time getting
at the kernel Mr Ryan was willing to-
he frank. but III" lawyers Of the defence
shut him Off with vollcSs of objections
Finally Mr. Stanchhcd had to go back
a little and prove that telephone voice
which Mr Ryan heard IN October Iol:.
was really William suffers. ono ~
Judge Ucrrick's questions was Are you
sure 81 wasn't Lamars, David Iamars'
II was At this time that Mr.. Suzer
said 60 Allan Ryan. "Tcl your father
am tho same old Hill" remark which
made the members of the court laugh
until Judge cullen stornly raped with
his gavcl
Mct;lone in the witness chair quoted Mr..
Sulzcr as having said that he wanted to
make a personal campaign and needed
money. lie wanted $500 or las much
moro as hr could get" The next day
Mr.. Mctione handed tho candidate $4,000
in bills Mr. Sulzer thanked him and in
>ttcd him to call at the Peoples House
" he ever went to Albany. and besides
cent his regards to Allan RYAN.
TolA A. A. uyau N0t IN Vcsttev
Mr. Stanchheld having found out what
he wanted. recalled Mr. Ryan. The wit
ress told or conversation with Gov.
t;uizer about u week before the impeach-
iuent court convened. lie said the Gov.
error advised him In case ne was sub
1,1naed not to pay any attention to 1t
V'.a"S' WV ','pede"'ne". was '',a"' an"
%u,s court hau no rlen' 10 us MN
This was struck out. but Mr.. Ryan was
hrv 10 i,auopce him as to his tes,imonv
hf he obcycd the subpoena.
Neither Mr.. Ryan nor Secretary McGlone
was cross-examined. but the lawyers for
fhc defence conferred together over the
disclosures and at one point Austen q.
Fox told Judge Cullen that he and his
sssociates were considering the advisable
fty OF asking the presiding Judge to ex-
press disapprobation OF the manner in
which the testimony concerning Senator
Root and Mr.. Barnes WAS brought out.
MIR. Stanchheld in the course OF his
futile fight To preserve for the record
punvent testimony az to tho Governors
attempted political manipulation said:
! 1T is competent to prove that man
attempts to influence In any way the ac-
zion Of this court" and Senator Brown
insisted that 1t Is due to the people OF
me state and TO the country that there
should he no f'inchng.
The vote to expunge the testimony was
regarded as one or the most interesting
and signihcant OF the trial II lookd for
une as II 'h'er Judge cullen
was coinE 10 ne oVerruied Tor tne nrst
t'n" IN me 'riAi. vi tne eighteen Notes
,aeainst MS ruhng one was ny Judge
werner re'entIE designated py the Re-
-tppeais. Judge bart'ett. thc Democratic
dSigmee Tor the same place voted to
sustain Judge cullen.
x s,
WV" SS""c~"''
All the Judges but Judge Werner were
with Judge Cullen. and were all but
ten of tn. Tammany Senators Five Re-
publicans voted to keep the testimony in
the record and two Sulzcr Democrats
Senator's Duhamel and Wcnde suppor ted
Tho testinonv ~ Rv,p Nc,.,or.
anu NeahF was 'naue possipic ny Judge
,u''en asse" w request from John
~. s'""cn''I" '"a' 'he PROSECUTION ne
"n""u " rrope'' .'e 'aHe lo w" pres,
;,,,,,n,. a"
,.r,, "'o "o'e"'e
lads, f-,,,., .,.,;,.,, ,b,, !, r.. oa
u,ssihIo If IL tender, 10 hcar M, tho ,,n.
ne.rhment ,r,ic,as
.Cx- Senator Uinnsn's onepjnr sneecb
for the ocfcnc. v.ss thercforc dei.ye,,
until . a., o'clock His reoIv To the prose
c,iticns case was about what was .x
pecied. lie said that little or no evidence
would bc offered AS to Impeachment
articles three. tour. 1--WE, seven and eight.
as the testimony against the Governor was
too weak to require answering
He said, for instance. that tho prosecu-
ton had not supplied a scintlla Of proof
tn support IN" charS" that Gov Sulzer had
romtni'tcu crime IN relation to his Stock
ESchang' bill, Tie asserted that the
cnsrees 81 hrlninG Witnesses We're sup
.r, ruttcu ohF ny 'nsinuati"n and lnnuendo.
n ~. .,.' q" d,t.r',s Mh'ch IN" detence did
o.oao a., ~, H%'"'",' % rn.u''lcr upon were the
nrno, !. cI,',...', ,,,f MmereI'' ','c ''oN
n,i-, s.,,on,,. Ia,",,s - '"i,. 'i''',
with 'annIying rn,,r,hr,,"ns 20 III. ,,, @ az"
dcscribcd as Ia;.nrv '"' "'e'
Mr.. Hinman's Openins
~, t.,,. .
.h., ,ha Ian. t 49,. ''"''' ~ : ''''' NJ VIZ
TO make sworn statement of con,ribu-
the moncy no, rpor,ed @ ' was s' n"psor.l n.pse .i
gifts. He pictured the Governor as a trus-
tee FOR himself who could not he held
accountable for his trusteeshlp He said
that the law does not compel an ac-
counting. the (;overuors Sta,.p.p, Al. , -.