The sun., 1913-10-27

4 NEVER OFFERED HELP
WANTED RYAN'S NAME HID


Allan A. RYAN replied with An emphatic
denial last evening to tho story which
William SuIzer told on the stump on Sat
urday night
In A statement issued from the Hotel
Plaza hc said that Candidate Su'zer
"bcggcd" for the $4,000 contribution
which Mr.. Ryan gave him Mr. RNan
also denied as frank falsehood the
statement Of Mr.. Sulzer that hc. Ryan,
called up the Governor and wanted TO
help him with his defence at the impcach-
ment trial.
Mr.. Rvan's description Of the interview
over the telephone varies greatly from
the story told by the Ex-Governor. MIR.
ry.n savs that ,;oy. S,,lzcr called up Mr..
Ryan o'h'' u, Mammalian see"i's Il" W.
a., ,,,,,on.., ., N, pxo, n, his hmm,
- =. ,,.,,.,,,. ,.,,,,,,,,..
W ou'''' " '''" -! = Wv ,, 'o
r. Ryan secretary an" ny "r' ''o""'"'
Alan RHans secretary
Thcreupon. MIR. Ryan. not caring 10
speak on the telephone to Mr.. Sulzcr uu-
less , third person was present. went TO
,bo ,ouu,rv home ,t George ". Morgan
NJ, nav, ,,,o,,,., r.,r by and had
g., -. -, a.. ,,......'..... 49,, 80. 49,,
W. - w.
phoi'e' ln'h M Hu'Ht' ihs's'," upon a'
ihte'Nle" IN Ne" ,otN
NJ that Interview GOV. Su1cr. says Mr.
Ryan, asked Mr.. Ryan to solicit the aid
o. United States senator Root, OF De-
lanccv SicnI of William, Rarns. Jr and
o,so -, ,,d,o >.,.u ,o s,,,, ,h i,,,,,,.,,t
- 80. a., ,,
.'' '' "E"" ~
'uhs' '~''" I" o'' 's"ao' w MurPh! -
eau on th' tilaL Mr. Ryan l'luscd 10 d.
any ~ these things. hut agreed TO find oui
wha, the attitude of the Republicans was
toward the Governors trial. That nc did
,h,nuvb I.o,nu,l J., o,i,e vho lo,,
"''''.'' '"""''' ''' ''', MAN nav '''''''o
Sulz.r. who kent il but Mr. RYAN r.pro.
luces Il word fo, word
IiUw Ryan Came tU Testify.
Nv pvan ,,,s an ir,.r.s,,,y .to,.,. -.
'.''' "' ,.''' 'to' "'
% Nv ''" ".u :, we as
al .I' '''a.i,''' ',' ~ " ',', ~,
~ ~ '""s ," ~ Iouns'. ~ "
Su,~e'' ~ s"'" ',a' vi "'',"n ''si'''
oo"'i d. ''an'"'ls'u anu 'o,u nv" 81"
Gov Su,~et intended TO tahe .he STAND a
'ne H'a' ''u u" VI o'"', on''ou,'o'''
which ne had rseeNicd ana had not oeei
ous up oE 'ne rrawleS committee
Juds" ferfI'k' Nj hNaN says Nishe'
10 erect an affahs'hleh' ny Whlch NJ
tNans name would not M mentioned
Mr. Ryan SAID ne l"ld Gov. Suizer. ol
learning OF that prom' ditated move. tina
the moment the Impeachment boar,
learned of the contribution the mana2et'
would subpoena him Nj. Ryan told tn,
Governor and the Governors attorne'
trat in the event of being called - II wit
ness he would tell the whole tguth con
cerninc the affair and keen nothing bacl,
4,
day i'm the preparation OF his statement
He revro,e i, once and then not satisfied
with IT, dictated II a second time Herr
il tho statement IN full;
Mr.. Ry.n.. Statement.
at'en''on mas nerh ca'lea 10
speech made pN MI Su'@er 'dst h'sh
wnich Is reporter III tn's norniHs He"S
papers. IN inns sPcec" MI ou'"el sa!
that ne is giving me true s.orF regarding
my contribution OF sio'oo" 10 MS cam
Palen Iuho ana resaro'hs ms e"oi'S "
have his trial stopped, Without hesita
o" '"' ''' '' NV 'e''''
VI" u wv ,.,,.., ,,.;,. S,,,.
"u "o .a., 10 Nv" ~. 80. i.'N,, % ~
IN no ~as ~ ,', ;., ~ ",s ~. H...'..
~ n,s 49, 80, ,.,.
Noiu"sereu no f, 'nlo',''a'"a' aka'ns' gu.
~.s" - ". ~, .i,,..,''.,' ~ ",''
"a' w Nv @ ,.. az" ""'"'
SUN ,nta Nv N' S.,,s,,, .
a." nv ny" ps ~ .an'''nt'" v
rounse, .o1 ."r so".a ". ",aI,ase.s u, Wv
.,'ipe"u.". Ia "s"ns'
mat .ne ".anase's "" no. ~ '"e ",
Io."a..on auou. ny 'olI'' .ou''on u,lt'
atter tne! nau .esteo 'ne,r case anu una
tney gov me 'nicrniauon .nen from Iude
herricR. MI, su,ser cou.,se,, VINO cam
10 MT etancnne'o anu .oo mn, tnat Sul
her was so,hk on 'h' w,.hess stanh IN MI
own pena,, anu "ou'n 'est1F ABOUT sew
"rai cont,'pu.'ohs '"at 'ne managers ha'
no Hnowieose o,. @ ana among otners
contT'outoh OF @io,o"" from me- ana Her
rick ASKED S'ancn"e'u 10 agree tnat ~he'
SuIser shou'd tahe the stand he SHOULD
De perm'ttco 10 'esti1N 10 having re
ceiVed my contributor nut should no
be forced~'o give my name 10 the court
The managers refused 10 enter into th,
deal, but II WAS through the making o
this proposition that the managers Learned
Of my contribution.