New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1913-05-07
REVIEW TROTT|NG CASES
Board Begins May MEETING Al
Murray Hill Hotel.
MANY COMPLAINTS MADE
Billiken, Owned by Ladd, Nat
Identified, and Winnings
Must be Returned

The board OF review OF tho Nau.-,
Trotting Association which is cb...,
with the settlement OF all questions a..
Ing within the association. began its w..
meeting yesterday at the Murrav tys
Hotel. The members OF the board nr...-.
were r. f. Johnson, president. OF Levi.
ton. Ky; w. II. Gocher, secretary. H.,.
ford, Conn: Samuel Mcbride. OF Toro,,.
Can; Horatio n. Balm, Poughkeen,,.
n. Y: William Russell Allen. st. Lol,
Mo; John Early, Nashville, Tenn. ana
Fred Postei, Detroit, Mich.
A number OF complaints were co,,,
cred by the board during the day a.,
after an executive session lasting u,,u
after 7 o'clock IL was given out thar n.
reinstatement of L. G.. Marshall, Of To.
wanda, Penn. who was temporarily >.
instated by the president In 1872 Va,
made permanent.
In the case OF Ralph r. Tomlinson n,
Falkland. Ind. who appealed from n.
decision Of the judges at the meet Of III.
Tri-State Fair Association, at Memnh.
I'm free-for-all pacing race in which h.
had entered Gay Patchen at Memub,,
on September %, 1912. it was ordered thu,
the first and second money be paid 10 n.
horses which were declared to be win.
ners of the same. The Judgment a,
the board was reserved as TO III,
wrong done Tomlinson and his hons
which was first, with the recommendat,o,
that the association and the starter TAX,
such steps as may be consistent with IN.
rules OF the track and the starter to ngh.
said wrong. The case was continued.
In the matter Of the Identification Q,
the chestnut gelding Billken, owned By
T. r. Sadd. OF Willimantic, Conn. he
horse not having been identified to III.
satisfaction of the board, Ii was ordered
that his winnings. amounting TO S,SSZ
be returned for distribution TO the par.
ties entitled TO the same, the said horse
called Billiken and his owner 10 stand
suspended until the order is compiled
| with.
In the cases OF A. r. Martin, Of T..
conderoga, y. Y. and f. Mack, ..
Nashua, n. H.. the testimony before ihs
board was that +. Mack sent bar
gelding called MIR. Mack" 2:2r.. 10 Mar.
tin at Ticonderoga. Martin took the
horse to a non-association winter meet.
ing at Malone. y. Y, and won race
or two with him. and shipped him from
there TO Montreal The horse wen
race there, but. II was said. some o.
the racing men there recognized the horse
as Hal L.. alias w II. Pointer. 2:llk. eI
PEELED, and told Martin all about his nsT
horse. Martin sent the horse home went
back to Malone and returned the mOng
he had won there. then went down %
see Mack about it. The case against
Martin was dismissed: that against Msek
was continued.
The application for the reinstatemeii
Of the bay gelding Storm, suspended a.
Rockport, Ohio. on October p last FOR
year. was denied.
Frank Grapenten. OF Detroit was "
dered reinstated upon the return By an
OF the money won by his bay mare. Jess
c.. s725 in all, on the tracks Of ontar@
West Virginia and Maryland IN 1910
The application Of J. 4. RhOades. G
Phonixvile. Penn. who was expelled
MAY, 1912, under the accusation OF slaff
Ing a horse. F. O H., 2:l6is. under 10
name of Willing, for reinstatement vas
denied.
Guy r. Lingafelt and Martin NORGE
Of Holidaysburg. Penn. ard c. I. Mi'a,
of Altoona, Penn. who had been aceu'H
OF disappearing the time in race
which they acted as tlmekeepers, mao'
application for the removal OF expulsion
and It was granted.
The board will continue It's sessions to
morning at 10 o'clock.