davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
Evening times-Republican. [volume] (Marshalltown, Iowa) 1890-1923, 1913-12-16
FIFTY MINERS ElgIOl q ijlli(lili
Explosion In Colorado Jsspa1assa
Lives of Large Nun,bsr es EmplesAD
-Disastse Near Newcastle -sNeiNo
Owned by Rocky Mountain Esel
Company.

-O3eAstoe Near Newcastle -7N4t0o
Owned by Rocky Meuntain -
Company.
Grand Junction. Colo. Dec. 1s,---AAs
explosion today At tho Vulcan mine as
Newcastle Colo. east Of here. 70 re-s
ported to have entombed between for
ty and fifty miners. Tho mine 10 owned.
by the Rocky Mountain Fuel Company.
Explosion Deep IN Mine.
Grand Junction, Dec. lS.-An ex.
plosion in the Vulcan mine of Tths
Rocky Mountain Fuel company, one
and one half miles east Of here at 1910
this morning entombed Mine Foreman
L L. Crawford. Fire Boss L. walters
and at least thirty miners. This ,es-
innate was based on a hurried check sAf
the companys rolls. Some officials
express a belief that the number in the
workings would reach forty. Only
about eight Of the men in the mine Aro
foreigners.
Charles S. Meerdink. mining superin-
tendent. with Ave companions equipped
with helmets at once began an explor.
alton Of the workings.
1t was believed the explosion occur-
red at least $500 feet from tho por.
tai OF the main tunned but whether Il
was caused by dust or gas has not been
determined.
Evening times-Republican. [volume] (Marshalltown, Iowa) 1890-1923, 1913-12-16
PAVE cRoss-s1ATE ROAD
Rivsr.to .Rivsr Highway Association
Unanimous In Ratification Of Plan 70
Build Permanent Hard eursaesd
Road Across Iowa = Committee
Named 70 Carry on Work.

Colfax. Dec. IA permanent hard
surfaced river-to-river road within
few years was tho goal which tho
Invertebrates Highway Association
decided to attain ct t4s annual meeting
at Colfax late yesterday.
A resolution by +. r. Hopkins. Of
Guthrie Center. to Immediately begin
q campaign to pave the road with
brick or concrete was unanimously
adopted and the directors In each
county were named on q committee to
carry forward the work. Legislative
committees will also be named and Il
is hoped to bring the road to . per.
manent level within q year.
o. III. Carpenter was elected vice
president to succeed C.. M. Beem. Of
Marengo. resigned and tho election Of
Officers was postponed until IN sd-
1ourned meeting IN january TO be held
in Grinnell.
Evening times-Republican. [volume] (Marshalltown, Iowa) 1890-1923, 1913-12-16
PARDON FOR MAURICE EhRIeHr

Governor Dunno, Of illinois, Extends
CIsmsney TO Two convicts.
Springfield. ILL.,. Dec. 16.-Maurice
Unr3ght, sentenced to life imprison-
mont in tho Joliet penitentiary for the
Vincent Altman murder in Chicago,
and Joshua Tedford, tho former Chi
cago police. who escaped serving q
penitentiary sentence thru q clerical
error. were pardoned today by Cover
nor Dunno.
Evening times-Republican. [volume] (Marshalltown, Iowa) 1890-1923, 1913-12-16
SIX HURT IN COLLISION.

Strese cars Collide IN Heavy Fse q
Council 0lusge.
Council Bluffs, Dec. 1e.-E. 6. WI4nN
motorman. was perhaps fatally tn3ufoa
and Grover Smith, passenger -
tously crushed, while four Others weee
painfully hurt In q collision io1 IT,
street cars here today during heqAy
fog which has enveloped the cit
day.
Evening times-Republican. [volume] (Marshalltown, Iowa) 1890-1923, 1913-12-16
MRS. RExRoATs FRIEND SLAIN.

Police Arrest Man Who keved Friend
Of Tango Tsaehsr.
Chicago, Dec. 1e-O. G. Huey was
arrested last night In connection with
the death Of Mrs.. Anna Leland, who
was shot to death In her home here
early yesterday. The police declared
that In many respects the causes lead
inG to the death Of HFs. Leland Were
similar 70 those resulting In the MUIR
Evening times-Republican. [volume] (Marshalltown, Iowa) 1890-1923, 1913-12-16

PAGE ONE.
Tsissrapssie Nsssss
National COMMITTEES Considers COM
promise ~
Certain to Formulate Reforms.
U. 8. Intsrcedes In Behan q Span
iards.
Many Perish in salvation Army y1rs.
Capitol Grounds Extension Upheld.
Reactionartes Bumped by High
Court.
Mine Horror in Colorado.
Carahaos Send Apology.
PAGES TWO. THREE AND FOUR.
lows News:
Christmas Fire Warning.
Disastrous Blaze at Mason City.
Seventy Per Cent Cured at Oakdale,
Colfa1 Bank May Not Reopen.
Iowa Farmers Going East
Railroads. Must Pay Special Drain
age Tax.
PAGE FIVE.
General News:
Youthful Crop Champions.
Redfield Outlines Anti-Trust Pro-
gram.
PAGE SIX.
Editorial:
The Big Noise II over.
It Works 1t Davenport.
Fewer Medical Schools.
Topics Of the Times.
PAGES SEVEN. EIGHT. NINE.
City Nsws,
New German Hospital About Com
pleted.
Advertising Ball Of Twenty-Five
Years Ago.
Jolt to Spark Plug Makers.
Former Marshall County Boy Famed
as Engineer.
PAGES TEN, ELEVEN. TWELVE.
City News:
More Prizes For Festival.
Christmas Stocks ofIer City Values
Poultry Show Succass
Talk About Town.
PAGES THIRTEEN, FOURTEEN,
FIFTEEN.
City News:
Short Course Attendance Small
Anson still Holds Country's Batting
Record
A Prisoner Of War ON Christmas.
General and Brief City NewA
Three Iowa Pestnnastsrs Named.
Special to Times Republican.
Washington, Dec. 1.-THE presiden,
today nominated the following Iow1
postmAstsrs:
wallace NJ. Higbes. FsirbankA
Jay Sullivan. Fonkaneils.
John J. Dunlevy. LAnstnG.
4
Evening times-Republican. [volume] (Marshalltown, Iowa) 1890-1923, 1913-12-16
Full Pardon For Dr.. Morton.

Full PARDON for Or. MORTON.
Warrington. Dec. 16.-Dr. William
=. Morton. who served term In tho
Atlanta penitentiary with Julian Haw-
thorne. for completely In mining stock
selling frauds, has been pardoned by
President Wilson to restore his Civil
fiehts on December 10,
Evening times-Republican. [volume] (Marshalltown, Iowa) 1890-1923, 1913-12-16
Removal Of pie.ur. Simple.

Removal ct Picture Simple.
Paris. Deo 1.-THE police and the
Officials OF the Louvre Sive full cred
anoe to vincenxo Perugia's story Of the
theft OF NMona Lisa" The authorities
have closely examined all tho details
and md nothing 70 cast doubt upon his
narrative.
Seymour de Ricci. an art expert. de-
scrtbed today the experiments made
Immediately after Mona Lisa" was
stolen. A dummy picture Of the same
st1e ana weight, from thirty-fve to
forty pounds with the frame, was cas-
lily removed BY police official, who
carried It twenty yards 70 the stair case
where the frame was subsequently
found. Tho operGt1sm required less
than ono minute. Another onlcaaI ac-
cstomed to transp1Eting pictures did
tho same thing In fusnty seconds.
Il has bson pro1s6 that Pexsxsa had
aaDasssd tin-rehanglne Tho Mona Lisa
some time bsfere eA1 tkS1t s..
Z The p6Ofurs &a1honk .4ts 4rssnA II
about sssehty- y-ons zSss wide s. thirty
lnchO high ana swsiehs fve pounds
The pat1ge1ngs,ls on wood less than an
inch thick.
Evening times-Republican. [volume] (Marshalltown, Iowa) 1890-1923, 1913-12-16
UNDERTAKES TO SEE THAT GEN.
ERAL VILLA TREATS ALL
FOREIGNERS ALIKE.
REBEL OFFICERS BELIEVE
VILLAS ACTS JUSTIFIED
Think spaniards Whose Property Was
confiseatsd Wsrs Husrta Sym
pathixsrs - eays United States Will
Have No Reason 70 Complain
Refugees Reach Ei Paso.

Washington. Dec. 1s.-Thru repre-
sentations to General Villa by Amer1-
can Consul Letcher and thru messages
+ conveyed by the American consul at
Hermosillo to General Carransa, the
United States has successfully inter-
ceded in behalf Of spaniards who CONF
planned Of mistreatment when Chihua-
hua City was occupied BY the consti-
tutionalists.
All advices to tho state department
today say foreigners generally. with
the exception Of the spaniards, have
been respected, and this government.
on request Of the Spanish ambassador.
has undertaken to SEQ that, Spanish
subjects will be given the protection
accorded to other foreigners
Say They Wsrs Husrta sympathixsrs.
Juarez. Mexico. Dec. te.-Rebel lead
ers IN Juarez today are hopeful that
information would come from Gen.
Francisco Villa Of his future attitude
toward foreigners In q less serious as
pect than that which resulted in the
expulsion OF Spaniards and the tak,ne
ov.- ~ 4h... ,,o,.... ~. -,
forces.
General BenavtdeA left by villa In
commana at Juarex. considereA that
v,,,a,. .c+. .,... h...a -. ...-,.....
w = son.4ss10A
tas9 tns spaa1sn merchants OF Chihua-
hua had 4i6e6 the federal troops, had
taken . strong stand In favor Of I'm.
49,. -. 800.
n. s.t,.,s ~ ss.,ss.. - 81" sHss,y IN NinA IIs
w.. ,>onAS.s,% Sk.se-Ss ~" ssNH.... ss.S. ~
H,irnsns - sss,. -. -. .s1.
v1.1cn :. ~ -. sesSs ~ 1r.s,c ~
tnr. aet,4,,Ss ~ .en.s.. .s..ss .S ~ -
- s~:..tS ~ s.xss. ~ s. l.1r
~. A"ss.. = .sxH.sl..1l..u % " WIN =
Evening times-Republican. [volume] (Marshalltown, Iowa) 1890-1923, 1913-12-16

semS;y 70 believed during the biennial
period and not exceeding these without
creating . debt within tho meaning OF
the ooastithtto1.
4. xAASvysrys sact Of tn gsnsral -
ts1nH 4. :te ibesspea In the Aght q the lvs
authorizes the executive council to is-
sue certificates or warrants against the
levy Of taxes IN 1919 and 1914 and for
any deficiency In such taxes to pur-
chase the ground and improve the same
such deficiency not exceeding $3.50. 600.
The court points out that its duty Is
merely to construe. apply and interpret
the law, not to enact It and that 1t
has no concern with the wisdom or ex-
pediency Of the act extending tho capi-
tol ground. That question was for the
general assembly alone to settle.
No Deh1 Created.
'%Surely the oct ought not to be con-
strued a. authorizing the creation Of q
debt In excess Of the limitations con-
tained in section two, article seven Of
the constitution" says the court. Even
II this would not suffice 1t Is not to be
assumed that the executive council
would issue certificates exceeding such
limit. Every act Of the general as
sembly !s to be read in the light Of the
constitution and the limitations con-
tanned therein are as effective as tho
written into legislative act. The ju-
dietary II not the only department OF
government upon which the duty Of
SCbserving and obeying the provisions
AAf tho constitution davolves. Each Of
ne other departments. legislative and
4 Dc.lt1ve. are under precisely the same
xNgation to know these and obey. ana
tAght not to be said that such obli-
46n rests more lightly on the ono
lpn the other. All are representa-
4 e1 the people with different func.
& perform and tho the courts are
! II sltonstitution itself made the hnal
& ttors, in constituting its terms and
21kSfpreting its meaning. 1t Is never to
be lost sight Of that until the contrary
appears beyond reasonable doubt, the
courts VIII proceed on the theory that
the legislative and executive depart
ments have obeyed its commands and
will yield to its injunctions."
The opinion was written by I.add, all
the other six concurring.
atats's Position Upheld.
From the very first Attorney General
Cosson, with the memters Of the state
executive council, took the position
that the act as a whole was constftu-
tional and that It was well within the
province Of the state to anticipate the
taxes levied for the full biennial period
Tor which the legislature has author.
ised levies. and that with the levies for
the biennial period ana the $3.50. 900 be-
yond which reaches to the constitu-
tional limit Of . debt. the work could
Evening times-Republican. [volume] (Marshalltown, Iowa) 1890-1923, 1913-12-16
NEW THEORY FOR THEFT

Italian Painter Suggests That "Mona
Lisa" May Have Been Taken From
Louvre to Conceal Badly Executed
Rsstorations - Finds Rstouchss Of
Which There 10 No omieial Record.
Florence, Italy. Dec. 1e.-Signor
Chini. the Italian painter. writes to .
local paper today urging the theory
that tho THEFT Of the Mona Lisa" was
simulated. in order to conceal some
badly executed restoFattons Of the pic
turs." He states that he himself de-
tscted on the picture some retouches
Of which there 10 no official record. He
thinks It would be interesting to es-
tablish whether all the traces now vis-
ible wero distinguishible before the
picture left the Louvre.
Evening times-Republican. [volume] (Marshalltown, Iowa) 1890-1923, 1913-12-16
T.-R. BULLETIN
Noticeable News Il Today


The Woather.
Sun rises Dec. II at 7:l9. sets at l:3l.
Iowa-Generally fair tonight and
Wednesday,: not much change In tenn
perature; moderate variable winds.
Evening times-Republican. [volume] (Marshalltown, Iowa) 1890-1923, 1913-12-16
STATE LEGISLATURE AND OFF.
GALS UPHELD IN CAPITOL
EXTENSION suiT.
aoxLEv cnoawp DEFEATED
ON EVERY CONTESTED POINT
Act Hold Not . Create Osbt In Excess
q csnseitutienal llmitations- -eur-
ehase % Ground and Making ef linz
premsvenss = Proeesd % contsm-
plaasd by lsaisiatIve Enactment

Special to Timsg-Rspuolican.
Des nloinas, Dec. 1.-THE state Of
lowa u not to DO denied tho right ia
make public Improvement and to en-
large tho capitol grounds and pay tor
same with . millGge tax.
The supreme court upholds the en-
tire ac4 reversing Judge Hunter entire
and Judge Applegate 20 far 40 he held
contrary to tho spirit and purpose Of
the legislature.
The decision was by unanimous
court
The executive council may proceed
with the public Improvement issuing
certificates to the extent Of the two
year levy ana S25o.ooo beyond. The
court decided:
1. That section two OF article seven
Of the constitution authorizes the gem
eraI assembly to create . debt not ex-
ceedins $25o.0oo to meet an expense It
may authorize.
2. That an Indebtedness in excess Of
that amount II prohibited by that sec
&ion and II the act for tho extension
OF the capitol grounds were to bs con-
strued to authorize the issuance Of cef-
ttdcates payable after tho biennial per-
iod In excess Of the amount this would
be In violation Of said section.
3. That the lxecuttve council may
issue warrants In any amount payahe
The Madisonian. (Richmond, Ky.) 1913-1914, 1913-10-28
LEAVE PUERTA PLATA
U. S. WARsHIPs PREVENT GER.
MAN SHIP ENTERING HARBoR.
Complications Expected to Arise by
Action Of Communicable Re.
port at Washington.

Cape Haitien. Oct. 1S.-American
warships blockading the port Of Puerta
Plata refused to permit the German
steamship Syria, from Sanchez, to en-
ter the harbor Thursday.
The situation at Puerta Plata Is con-
sidered critical. The city is threat
ened with attack by land and sea.
Foreigners are taking refuge on board
vessels in the harbor.
The revolutionists have been ad-
vlsed by the American commander to
stop hostilities. Otherwise, he says,
troops will be landed. The American
consul at Puerta Plata is urging all
American citizens to leave thte city.
War operations were resumed when
the rebels refused to accept the terms
of a treaty of peace that was brought
about by James M. Sullivan, the Amer
lean minister.
Washington. Oct. 1s,-No rtt'-s
been received at the Ntate asJsysls d
on the reported action of anSrN Ia
warships refusing to permit thu Ger
man steamship Syria to enter Pderta
Plata. II this has been done compli
cations with the German government
over the sis.et,cn there probably will
arise. -
The Madisonian. (Richmond, Ky.) 1913-1914, 1913-10-28
TELEGRAPHlC
NOTES

Highland Light. Mass, Oct. TO-
Four men are believed to have lost
their lives when the coal laden barge
Sumner B. Meade was driven ashore
near the Cahoons Hollow life saving
station, eight miles south OF here.
Springfield. ILL.,, Oct. 1s.-Bruce
Mounts, son of former State Senator
w. L. Mounts, was killed and A. Craw-
ford. Jr.. son of A. w. Crawford Of
the state board Of equalization. was Sc
riousiy injured by Mounts automobile.
Atlanta, Ga, Oct. 16.-Julian Haw-
thorne, the writer. completed his
term in prison here at midnight Tues
day. He left for New York in the
morning. He is the picture of health,
having gained more than thirty
pounds In the prison. Il have nothing
to say OF my plans" said the writer.
Champaign, ILL.,. Oct 10. =. Sui
lican, Urbana merchant, was arrested
charged with the murder of w. Larry.
The arrest followed the alleged discov.
cry that Sullivan owned the revolver
found beneath the body.
The Madisonian. (Richmond, Ky.) 1913-1914, 1913-10-28
CINCINNATI MARKETS

Corn-No. 2 white 701@71c, No. 8
white 70@70Rc, No. white 6Sh %
691sc, No. 2 yellow 701a @71c, No. 8
yellow 70q701ac, No. yellow 69R %
70Rc, No. 2 mixed 70h Q7lc, No. 8
mixed 70@701sc, No mixed 6SB @
69lsc, white ear 73@76c. yellow ear
73M76c, mixed ear 73m75c.
Hay-No. l timothy $1,000, stand
ard timothy $1S0l9. No. 2 timothy
$17@1S, No. timothy $15@16, No. 1
clover mixed $16.50@17.50, No. 2 clio
yer mixed l450015.5O, No. / clover
SIS, No. 2 clover $13.
Oats-No. white 42@421ac, stand.
ard Az @42c, No. 3 white 41@41hc,
No. white 39@40c, No. 2 mixed 40h
@41c, No. 3 mixed 40@40bc, No. 4
mixed SS1a @391Ac.
Wheat-No. red 9394 @95c, No. 3
red 91@92c, No. red S3@91c.
Poultry-Hens, heavy, lac; hens,
light, 11@12c; springers, large I3c;
sprlngers, small, Ice; turkeys, young,
S lbs and over, 19c; turkeys, old, 1870
1Sc; turkeys, light, 15@17c; geese,
7@lOc.
Eggs-Prime firsts Csc, firsts 26Is 20
&c. ordinary firsts 231a @24c, seconds
1Sc.
Cattle-Shippers, S665@S; butcher
steers. extra $7.35@7.65, good to
choice $6.25@725, common 10 fair
$4.50@G; heifers, extra $6.75@7, good
to choice s5.75@6.50, common to fair
$45006; COWS, extra $6@625, good
to choice s5.25@5.75. common to fair
$3,25G5; Gamers, $3@425.
Bulls-Bologna S525@6.10, extra
$G.2546.35, fat bulls $6@6.35.
Calves-EXtra $1,000, fair to good
S.50@ 1925. common and large s4.25
@9.75.
Hogs-Selected heavy SS.35@S.45,
good 10 choice packers and butchers
$S.40Qs.45, mixed packers $8.3O@S.40,
stays $4.25@7, extra s7.15Q725, com.
mon to choice heavy fat sows $4,000
7.75. extra s7.S5. light shippers 1925
@S.l5; pigs (l10 lbs and less) $3.50
OF.
sheep-Extra s4.25@44O. good to
choice $3.75q4.25, common to fair SO
$3.50.
Lambs-Extra $4.25Q4.40, good TO
choice s650@6.90. common to fair So
M6.25.~
The Madisonian. (Richmond, Ky.) 1913-1914, 1913-10-28
TRAIN PLUNGES
FROM TREsTlE.
RAILS SPREAD AND ALL THE
CARS LEAP INTO A DEEP
GULcH.
One Hundred Persons Badly Injured
Coaches Catch Fire Almost
Immediately.

Western Newspaper Union News Service
Mobile, Ala.-At least 32 soldiers
were killed and more than 100 badly
Injured when a special train, carrying
IT'S enlisted men of the United States
Coast artillery, jumped the track at a
high trestle near here, according to
a report received by Assistant General
Manager NJ. ]. Wise, OF the Mobile &
Ohio railroad
The train was a special running as
the second section of regular pas.
senger train on the Mobile & Ohio
railroad. The soldiers were bound
from TT. Morgan for Meridian, Miss,
to give an exhibition drill at the Ala
bama-Missssippi State fair.
All available physicians, ambulances
and dead wagons were gathered at the
terminal station to assist the corps OF
medical men on the scene.
The wrecked cars are in a ravine,
60 feet deep. The suffering of the in.
jured has been terrible, although the
soldiers who escaped injury have done
noble work. The trestle on which the
train was wrecked was destroyed.
The Madisonian. (Richmond, Ky.) 1913-1914, 1913-10-28
HIT BY ENGINE.

Dayton, O.-When within sight Of
their home, and while returning in
their automobile from a visit with rel.
atives in the country, Walter Kreitzer,
30 years old. of Trotwood, o., and his
wife Ruth, 90 years old, were struck
by Eastbound Limited Passenger
Train No. 20, on the Pennsylvania line,
and instantly killed. Their foir-year-
old son Wilbur sustained fracture Of
the skull, which, it is said, will prove
to be fatal. The automobile was
thrown 100 feet up the street. The
bodies of Mr.. and Mrs. Kreitzer were
decapitated.
The Madisonian. (Richmond, Ky.) 1913-1914, 1913-10-28
MESSAGE HARD TO INTERPRET
Commentators Differ as to the "Won,-
an Jezebei" In the Third Chap
ter of Revelation.

AS to the message TO the church In
Thyatira, In the third chapter Of the
book of Revelation, It is an obscure
know so little of the prevalent Gus
toms and heresies of that time. Com
mentators differ as to the woman
Jezebel," some claiming that she was
heather priestess, who stood for all
manner of licentious rites and evil
practices, and others that she was the
leader of the Nicolaitans, division
of the church that claimed to be none
the less Christian because it tolerated
some heather customs, like eating
meat offered to idols, offering incense
to the statue of the emperor joining
social clubs, which were numerous In
those days, and which often fostered
much debauchery and even licentious-
ness. Many of these clubs were con-
nected with the trade guilds. and on
this account Thyatira, which was fa-
nous for these guilds. offered special
temptations to the Christians who be-
longed to these guilds. to condone.
even II they did not approve. the I'M
Christian practices of many of the
members.
The praise accorded In the first part
of the message to the church of Thy,
atira seems to give color to this inter
probation, for the Son Of God himself
says: Il know thy works, and love,
and service, and faith, and that thy
last works are more than the first"
II is thought by many that the Nj
colaitans, though their doctrines were
wrong. and their complaisance toward
the practices Of their heather neigh.
bors was most dangerous. yet were
still active in good works. and per
haps WED with their stricter and more
Buritanical church members In acts
OF benevclence and subscriptions TO
all good causes so that the last
works were more than the first"
The Madisonian. (Richmond, Ky.) 1913-1914, 1913-10-28
SULzER IS REMOVED
oUsTED GOVERNOR OF NEW
YORK DENIES ALL CHARGES
-GLYNN SWORN IN.
SAYS BOSS" WROTE VERDICT
Court Of impeachment by Vote Of az
to II Removes Chief From Office
Refuse to Bar Him From Further
Positions.

Albany, n. Y, Oct. 1S.-William Sui
ger ceased to be governor of the state
Of New York Friday He was removed
from office by the high court of i'm
parchment by vote of 43 to ~. two
members not voting.
Martin II. Glynn, lieutenant COVER
nor, was sworn In as his successor,
the first in the history of the state to
step into its high office in this man.
ner. Robert F. Wagner, Democratic
leader Of the senate, became lieuten-
ant governor. The verdict of the
court was that Sulzer was guilty OF
=. classification, perjury and an attempt
u suppress evidence against him. or
all other charges he was acquitted.
the court unanimously voting him not
guilty of the four remaining articles
of impeachment
BY a virtually unanimous vote the
Impeachment tribunal also decided
that Sulzer should not be punished by
disqualification to hold office of honor
and trust II th.s stcte in the future.
This would have been the extreme
penalty under the law.
The ousted executive was served
with copy of the verdict of the court
at the executive Observation-Disclosures
by himself the peoples home"-at
night
Good. thank you" he said to the
sergeant-at-arms of the senate, who
delivered the document
The outgoing executive issued a
statement in which he denounced the
tribunal which had removed him as
"Murphy's high court OF infamy."
Murphy controlled the assembly
and ordered the impeachment" Sulzer
said. HE controlled most of the mem.
bers OF the court and dictated proce-
dure and wrote the judgment. He was
the Judge and Jury; the prosecutor
and the bailiff."
He entered a general denial OF all
the charges in the impeachment ar
ticles, denied he had ever asked Allan
A. Ryan to obtain the influence OF
Murphy or Republican State Chairman
Barnes to stop the trail; said the tes-
timony of Henry Morgenthau could be
explained; asserted that every dollar
that had been given him during his
campaign had been properly accounted
for; that he was $4,000 in debt; that
he had been faithful to his trust"
and that he handed back to the peo-
pie the commission they gave me un.
furnished and unsullied."
Governor William Sulzer was con-
victed on Thursday by the high court
OF impeachment on three counts The
final vote was 80 TO Is. He was de-
clared innocent Of the charges con-
tanned In article 8.
Presiding Judge Edgar NJ. Cullen,
who will shortly retire from the bench,
voted mot guilty" on every article and
rendered a long opinion in explaining
his votes. The eight other judges of
the court of appeals were divided.
Washington. Oct 20.-Application
for review Of impeachment proceed.
ings never has been presented to the
Supreme court. There Is said TO be
no federal law for this.