Bismarck daily tribune. [volume] (Bismarck, Dakota [N.D.]) 1881-1916, 1913-02-16
SENATE
Continued from Page one.l

NSohlinue0 lIUHi Iake Oue.)
also made the claim that cigarettes
we're 10 more harmful to an adult per-
o than the use OF tobacco In any
other form.
Mr.. Hanley arose to second the no
ton of the gentleman from Sheridan
and stated that he did not think that
the senate should attempt to limit the
prohibition to one class or national
ity, and took the stand that cigar
cites were the national smoke of q
large part of the population of the
state.
Mr.. jacobson in supporting the
amendment said that they should not
try to legislate against the poor man
who could not afford cigars but was
forced to accept the comforts to be
gained from the cheaper smoke in the
shape of Il cigarette. Garden in talk.
ing against the amendment said that
the idaa of the bill was not so much
to prevent the sale of cigarettes to
adults as it was to prohibit and pre-
vent the free distribution of cigarette
papers to the minors of the state and
called their attention to the fact that
those who desired to smoke the little
white smokes that the parcels post
was an established fact and they
could send ont of the state.
Senator Davis speaking again in
sisted that, the proposed amendment
was not a laughing matter and that
he was serious in the matter, and
when a rising vote a called for on
the amendment Hanley insisted that
there be a roll call and the same
was ordered, with the result that it
was a tie, with two senators, Gibbons
and Englund absent from the senate.
Those voting aye were Messrs. AL
hrccht, Bond, Bonner, Carter. CASHIER,
Davis, Ganssle, Gronvold, Hanley, Ho-
version, Hughes, jacobson, kretchmar,
Leutz, Iinde, Loftssgaard, Mcbride, Nc
Lean, Plain, Porterfield, Talcott, Tur-
ner, Vail. Young.
Those voting nay were: Messrs, Al
len, Barnes, Bronson, Clark, Davidson,
Duncan, Elken, %IG!lingson, Garden, Gill
bert, feckle. Helgeland, Hookway, Hy-
land, Mcdowell, Mudgett, Nelson, Ov-
crson, Putnam, Steel, Thoreson, TRACE
ton, Wartner, Williams, Mr.. President.
The president voted no and the
amendment was declared lost. Davis
at this point asked for a call OF the
senate for the purpose of bringing in
the absent members, and the request
was granted and Senators Gibbons
and Englund returned to the chamber
from a committee meeting they had
been attending. Hanley then asked
for a reconsideration of the vote by
which the amendment was-lost and
on a division being called for the
motion was lost, but HanleY called
IOT a Toll call Ol tLc HhOIAol w ASSoH
slider and it was granted with the fol-
lowing result:
Those voting aye were Messrs. Al
brecht, Bond, Bonner, Carter, Cashel,
Davis, Ganssle, Hanley, Heckle, 40
version, Hughes, Jacobson, kretschmar,
Eeutz, Linde, L~oftsgaard, Mcbride, Nc
Lean, Nelson. diversion, Porterfield, Tai
%ott, Turner. Vail, Young.
Those voting nay were: Messrs. AL
len, BarHcS, Bronson, Clark, Davidson,
Duncan, Elken, Ellingson, Englund, Gar
den, Gibbons, Gilbert, Gronvold, Hedge
land, Hookway, Hyland, Mcdowell, Mud
gett, Plain, Putnam. Steel, Thoreson,
Trageton, hVartner, Williams.
Senator Hanley here moved that
action on the bill be deferred till
Monday. Hookway stated that he did
not see the necessity of deferring the
matter as it had already had consider.
able discussion and that in that dis.
cussion practically every practice OF
parliamentary procedure had been
broken and styled the present pro
ceedings as being only an effort to