The evening world., 1913-09-18
/ d." Judge cuasn sbeu addressed


ton in that court oy vir'ue OF essiSn'
ment from the supisms Cou1I s
'auesuon has zen eu ~n
u"uer vac ~ $3.50. srC..,
members OF ,n's Sosrs Oh .mps~. .
io',
.,.e..'. 80. ss.1.....S -, shs ~.
s snS..n.. A. . Iii srnm Shs
49, $500 49, 800. 49,.
80. 80 A....i. .,6
Judges OF tnc Ccuft Q. 49, suu
.he Nons','u.on 20 ~.S 60.
duties as Judges OF tns O"p'sne 0'"r'
snail CEASE
Bui i hno thet usoer tne Cons u'u
uoh OF isss0e.oe ~ VI
peas WIS .o"'u -. .,..s.a
> Drowned wnen "nere .ou
. JUDGES ahn TOUT ssoso Oh tne guy. '"o
Nour. cnansns -.
"ehoe's o' .ns Sou' Of 49,
was an impeachment OF ono MT. DorAh'
Q Canal Commissioner. and all or the
Judges OF the supreme Court who we're
sitting IN the Court Of Appeals at that
-stime sat IN The Court OF Impeachment
- Therefore. - have said. I am en-
kSirsly clear that the gentlemen who
hsve been Judges Of the supreme Court
Hand VINO ere ssuang by virtue Of the
designation of the Court OF Appeals are
In every respect - fully Judges OF the
Court Of Appeals - those that are
elected
''Sttli. that 10 my individual opinion
oaiy. and Of course tho judgment OF
the majority a the court muss con-
troll. Therefore II any member OF the
court entertxlns . contrary opinion he
q will please ne and object 70 their be-
\ Ing sworn. In which case ! VIII pas
0hsir names. and aftsr the othet mem.
-bsrs Of the court are sworn suomit "
ito the court to dSermins wne'nsr
they are members o. the eour. .,
not II no objection Is msae
shall assume .ha' ": .ss. ~ ~. m.m.
\ cord j" 'n.' ~ ,n..,hr.,,
Der" o' '"s ,'-.s a.
ana sn." go" =" .r.s, ,hos.
..n,,.,,s, =. ,isr,r names are called"
n Alton n. Park0 arose and addressed
\ the court
"Whue this 10 not exactly IN line
4 With the direction which you have
\ giyen." he SAID, IL trust you will per-
NIT me to cay on behalf Of the counsel
h for the manassrs and the managers
\ themselves, that while there WAS some
n doubt In the minds OF some, there was
no doubt about the desirability to have
h Justices Hiscock. Chase and Miller Git.
D.Cady Herrtck. for the 6ulser side.
Z also assentsd, saying:
\ may It please the Court. We had sup.
= posed this vas q matter In which coun-
h Ell haA no concern. but aftsr what has
Z been said Il 10 due to the court TO say
that counsel for the respondent have
:. considered this matter and have no
doubt about the legality OF che learned
gentlemen sitting ~ members OF the
court. nor have they any doubt about
ths desirability OF having them act"
WEINBERG TAKE the OATH IN
= lphA0eYNAl ORDER.
rn., ,n .t,,ct .iohabs1icsl order.
,oag.. ana SENATOR. without dating
a.. 80. c.,,.d a. IN. h., ara IN zach
.,.,,, Y,,,.. C,,,,., r.n..tah IN.
-, -, 80 49, .Au,r,.,.,.h N
-. w. 49, -, 1900. r,.-.
-. a.. u...,.L .h,.,,.,
~ - -
", 49,
49,. ~.
-, %
&c !scsoHs 70 ~ ovs.as.uos % sos
SoeTv sAa WE 1sHssaouon OF we
OeuU eves ne fssDeeessS"
Under the view the presiding Of
"eer tahes OF tne STATUTE Judge Cu''
u ION repheo' 'he manners OF 'he Cour'
20 must De sworn peiore any proceed'hss
se TAKEN. ana " there 10 any Vaid
oo'e.'o" anu respondent mas rsht 70
en.e"xs' ~ 70 ~"'ch 'he pres"'hS
,on .,, =, ,.s- t., 49, 49,, :,
vii, n. reserved % , ,,,.r s,.s...
'Of course we Weld 10 the iudgmen
OF the presiding officcr," said Mr. Her
rick. but We preserve our rights. as
\ understand Il, to challenge at a prope