davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1913-09-23
BRYAN AS PHlLANTHR0PlST
Said To Be Paying for Four
Young Mems Education.

Washington Sept. 22.-DurinS brief
defence Of Secretary Bryan's lecture
tours. Senator MARITIME told the Senate to-
day that some Of Mr.. BIyan's liked
charges" were for the education Of sew
eral young men.
"A few years ago Mr. Bryan was main
tanning and educating two boys from
Japan" declared Mr.. MARITIME and to-
day ] believe he Is educating three or
four yourg men"
II have not talked with Mr.. Bryan,
said Senator MARITIME after his statement
on the floor, but / believe he is now edu-
eating and supporting at least four young
students | believe. further. that out Of his
own pocket he ~ supporting "A missionary
in every Independent foreign missionary
field"
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1913-09-23
GARRISON HEARING GOES
OVER TO THIS AFTERNOON
Assembly Bent on Trying to
Keep Sulzer Agent in
Penitentiary.

| From "A star Correspondent ~ The Tribune
Albany. Sept. 22.-James c. Garrison,
Governor Suffers press agent. who was
arrested for contempt by order OF the
Assembly on Thursday night. is still con-
fined I'm the Albany County penitentlary.
He had hoped to regain his freedom
through habeas corpus proceedings. which
were 10 have been argued before Justice
Cochrane. Of the Supreme Court, at Troy
this afternoon. Justice Cochrane. how
ever, postponed the argument on the mo-
ton of James \. Parsons, Deputy Atto''
ney General. who represented the Assem-
bly,. until 2:3o p. m. tomorrow.
Gilbert l.. Zoe, OF New York. and John
L. McDonough, OF this city, who appearea
for Garrison. objected 10 the delay, pu'
the court said that the proceeding was
entirely too important TO be settled huf'
riedly. Mr. Parsons said that he had jus'
been called into the case and that the
officers Of the Assembly had not had sur
ficient time To prepare to oppose the Gar
rison writ. lie added that they were IN
no mind TO let the prisoner have his nss
dom without fight
Members OF the Assembly at the Cspr
tol to-day said that they had no douo'
that the application would be quasher
I'm which case Garrison will have 10 re'
main in Jail during the pleasure oil wv
Assembly. If that body does not re'o"'
its sentence he will have 10 stay tne''
until final adjournment. This au'0'
matically releases him, but the indieS
tons now are that the final ludgmen'
will not take place for two months I"
least
Garrison was taken TO Troy by shei"
Peasley after his attorneys furnlshed
$1,000 bond to insure his safe return i"s
prisoner. who had been confined ID NV
hospital ward. was not anxious TO mar
the trip, saying that he was stilI IN p'V'
physical condition. the Shcrin, ho"e'''
thought differently, and Garrison accom-
panied his attorneys TO the courtroom y
Justice Cochrane. where they fouhu
curious crowd awaiting them. OWNS
the connection between his arrest anu w
Suzcr impeachment trial.
Garrison spent most OF the day IN WIZ
ing out points which he thinks eau V
used TO good advantage by his attorne'"
and he looked we'll In spite OF the INV.
which caused him removal 10 the hosp'
ward Sheriff Peasley was represented y
j. Sheldon Frost, OF this city. VINO 80.
he had no intention of entering in'o -,
argument unless the position oil
Sheriff were questioned By any oi
other lawyers I'm the case.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1913-09-23

that may be transacted by either mouse
of any character.
"Now there would be force In that ar
gument II there were not other tacts tha'
really abrogate the force OF the areu-
ment and tend to establish contrary
proposition"
After giving his Interpretation OF the
meaning the trainers Of the CONSTITUTION
intended to convey, Judge Cullen con-
cluded:
.I think that when il was SAID tha'
the Governor shall submit business ior
consideration to the Legislature, II was
the Governors business that was meant
not that of the Legislature, not OF t'e
Senate. But it gave the Assembly, '"7
right to impeach.
81 therefore am Of the opinion that th's
right does not come within the hini'a-
ton of the constitution. We must give
reasonable construction Of IT, and' 30
construed. these subjects all relate u
what the Legislature as body can 40
and not to the power vested In one Drahch
of the Legislature. vote no."
Senator Wende his only opponent
hadn't much argument to offer. He SAD
"Mr. Presiding Judge. as read INC
constitution the Assembly at some time
had an absolute right of framing THESE
articles OF impeachment That risht sN-
listed up to the time that they TOOK an
adjournment sine die, and when they
adopted the resolutions adjourning sine
die they foreclosed their right TO any
question Of impeachment or to act upon
anything else. if they were to be calieu
together in extraordinary session. except
such subjects as the Governor would pre-
sent. | therefore vote aye.
Because OF the understanding that TINS
was tentative vote though so over
whelming. the roll was called "a second
time. The final vote was exactly the
same Then Judge Cullen told the court
he thought II much better TO have the re-
suit announced Immediately than to hold
II until tomorrow and have people specu-
latlng and guessing about the courts ac-
ton. Thereupon the court went into open
session again and the result was an
nounced.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1913-09-23
FUSIONISTS PLAN RALLY
Ratification To Be Held at
Cooper Union Monday.

ARRANGEMENTS are being made for
notification and ratification meeting Tor
the fusion candidates. TO. be held at
Cooper Union on Monday night. 1t VIII
be under the joint auspices Of the organi-
cations connected with the fusion move
ment
Collector Mitchell Controller Prender-
CAST and Borough President McAneny
will speak.
II was said yesterday that Collector
Mitchell would not make formal declara-
ton of his principles until that Tune ne
probably will outline his attitude toward
William Randolph Hearst In that speech
Henry l.. Stimson. former Secretary oil
War. will preside. Among other speakers
will be Job f.. Hedges. who VIII SPEAK
for the Republican organization; Tlmothy
L. Woodruff. for the Profressives, and
Frederic r. Coudert for the inde-
pendent Democrats.
Representatives Of forty independent
Democratic organizations, meeting AT
fusion Headquarters yesterday, organized
the Allied Mitchell Leagues of Greater
New York. County Clerk william T.
Schneider was chosen chairman. lie VIII
open Headquarters in the Long Acre
Building. 42d street and Broadway
Among the organizations in the move
rnent are the Cleveland Democracy, the
Young Mems Civic League, the Hun
garian League Of the city OF Ne" forh'
the Colored Mems Democratic League
and the Washington Heights Business
Mems Association.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1913-09-23
PRESIDENT TO VOTE TO-DAY
He and Garrison ana Tumulty
to Support Governor Fielder.
[From M TrIbune Bureau.

Washington. Sept. 22.-The President.
the Secretary of War and the secretary
10 the President, Joseph p. Tumulty will
go to New Jersey tomorrow TO vote in
the state primaries. President Wilson win
vote at Princeton, while Secretary Garri-
son AMI No Tumulty will cast their bal
lots in Jersey City. All three will vote
for Governor Fielder
Professor Stockton Arson, a brother q
Mrs. Wilson. will accompany the Presi-
dent to Princeton where the party is due
TO arrive at 1926 p. IN.
Two interesting visitors who were well
coined warmly by thePresidcnt were the
Misses Elizabeth NJ. and Ellen ID. Bel
lamy. OF Wilmington. Del, who were his
childhood friends. They were recognized
by the President. whom. they said. they
called Tommy in other years.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1913-09-23
CAMPAIGN CAMPS OPEN.

Three Democratic headquarters for the
coming municipal campaign will be opened
to-day. The headquarters for the city
ticket. where. II is understood. Chairman
Mccall, Representative Metz and Repre-
sentative Goulden will have offices. will be
in the Hotel Martinique. An organization
OF college men. some OF the same group
who worked for the election of President
Wilson. will open headquarters In the
Forty-second Street Building The Ed
ward Il. Mccall Association. Of which
Colonel Jacob Rupert is one OF the or
ganizers. is To conduct Its campaign from
the Imperial Hotel
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1913-09-23
NEW ..AVEN CHANGES DENIED
Road Announces That Bardo and
Whaley Will Not Resign.

New Haven. Conn. Sept 22.-The latest
development in the negotiations between
the adjustment committee of the Brother
hood OF Engineers and the officials Of the
New Haven concerning changes In the
rules governing the promotion OF fremen
TO be engineers and Of advancement of
engineers TO selected runs is said to be an
offer Of the engineers to accept the new
rules, if General Manager G. l.. Bardo re-
tires.
There were rumors yesterday that Mr..
Bardo and Mr.. Whaley, in charge of the
operation OF the road. would resign, but
the New Haven issued statement to-
night denying that either man intended to
leave the road.
The new rules - which the engineers
object were made effective by General
Manager Bardo September II.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1913-09-23

some new points. The main point at issu.
between the attorneys seemed to n.
whether the act of the Assembly in brln,.
ing the impeachment was judicial fuoo.
ton rather than legislative. The IA.
fence contended that an impeachment va,
equivalent to an Indictment by grand
jury, and that the Assembly performaa
the function OF an accuser, not on :,
judge.
ITO say that II is acting judicialls..
said Mr.. Marshall, seems TO be entirelv
at odds with the very conception OF !,
judicial act
Counsel for the prosecution argued tho,
the act of Impeachment constituted "ths
initiation Of judicial action" After thsv
have instituted these proceedings" sa,S
Judge Parker, then the High Court O,
Impeachment comes into existence by TIA
provisions OF the constitution"
THE Legislature being In session said
Mr. Bracket, does not mean that N,
Assembly Is In session as a separate body
The Assembly may exercise the power 10
impeach independently when and where !,
chooses. In the present occasion. thera.
fore, we need not be much troubled with
the question as to how the Assembly NAV
convene for the purpose OF impeschmep,
II cannot at this moment fail TO recall
the remark OF Charles Sumner upon thu
trial of President Johnson-Charles Sum.
ner. who when all the questions with r..
spect to form and procedure and technl.
cal objections had been made. burst out
with the one question that should be con.
sidered here, as he said 1t should be con.
sdered there Great God" he said, 4,
there any question possible except is hi,
man gulty?'
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1913-09-23
PRIMARIES IN MASS. TO-DAY
Only Governorship Contest Is
on Republican Ticket.

nominations in to-morrOw's state pri-
maries closed tonight. The only impCr-
tant contests are for Governor on the
Republican ticket in which Colonel Ever
cit c. Benton is opposed by Congressman
Augustus p. Gardner. and for Lieutenant
Governor on the Democratic ticket, be-
tween Il. p. Barry and Richard II. Long
Lieutenant Governor David I. Walsh is
an unopposed candidate tor head of the
Democratic ticket, and Charles s. Bird
will lead the Prosressives for second
time.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1913-09-23
sULzER SUPPORTER oUsTED
Tammany Elects Chairman OF orspS'
County Democratic Committee
TBy Telegraph to The Tribune.

Goshen, n. Y, Sept. 22-Georse
Ketcham. of Warwick. for sixteen yea's
chairman of the Democratic Comhn'.
for Orange County was defeated ioi -
election at meeting OF the comh,s.s
here to-day. William p. Gregg, Oh
Jervis, was chosen to succeed MI
cham. but not until the latter haa ""
the floor and declared that the 49,,
against him was brought about by h''
being a follower of Governor Sulzer
Arthur A. Mclean, OF Newburgh' ~
urer Of the Democratic State ComIn''''"
led the OPPOSITION to Mr. Ketcham.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1913-09-23
Met in Regular Session.

The constitution gives the Assembly
the power TO impeach. 1t was in regular
Session. | use regular session In the sense
that II was regularly convened, in re-
Spouse to call by the Governor Now.
having the power of impeachment, IT
could exercise that at any time unless
we find another provision in the constitu-
ton which restricts 1t or forbids It, That
provision Is claimed to be found In the
fourth section of the fourth article of the
constitution. in which 1t IN said:
"'At extraordinary sessions no subject
shall be acted upon except such as the
Governor may recommend for considera-
ton
Does that apply to this power of i'm
parchment? IL is argued, of course,
that this Is not an ordinary legislative
power except in the sense that anything
that Is done by the Legislature is legis-
lative. The counsel for the respondent
contend that this includes all business
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1913-09-23
NEW mitchell LEAGUE.

The Mitchell Democratic League, with
headquarters at No. 4e Fifth avenue, is
being organized by the following well
known Democrats: Steven b. Ayres. J.
Hampton Dougherty, w. L. G. Gaillard
Stewart G.. Gibboney, Bert Hanson
Lamar Hardy, Raymond " Ingersoll, AL
bert B. Kerr, John J. Kindred, William
Lustgarten. Walter L. McCorkle and John
j. Murphy.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1913-09-23
GAYNOR MEN ENDORSE MCCALL

The Gaynor Citizens League met in
executive session In Arlon Hall. Arion
Place and Broadway Brooklyn. last night
and Endorsed the following ticket: Ed
waSd Il. Mccall for Mayor Herman A.
Metz for Controller George McAneny for
President of the Board of Aldermen,
Henry h. Ketcham for Surrogate. Charles
S. Dewey for County Clerk and Andrew
}. Corsa for Register The vote in favor
of these candidates was 20 to /.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1913-09-23
IMPEACHMENT OF SULZER
UPHELD By 81 TO | VOTE
Continued from first pnge.

he took office. But nobody'-not even
the Sulzer awyers-has much OF a
notion, in view OF the courts action
tonight, that this argument VIII nave
any weight with It. So the case VIII
come now in a short time to a trlai vi
the facts and the examination OF Wit
nesses to prove whether the Governor
did steal his campaign contributions TOT
Wall street speculation and then per-
lure himself by failing TO account 1or
them in his sworn statement to tho
Secretary of State.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1913-09-23
Draws on His Fancy.

THAT would be n sad day in our judi
cial history when reliance upon the con-
stitution and the law Of the land were 10
be regarded az technical or were TO be
condemned and deemed unworthy. so
long as our people may proudly boast that
this is a government of laws and not OF
men, so long will it's liberties be preserved
and its institutions perpetuatcd. But
whenever the time shall come when the
Ignorance Of the mob. It's passions and its
prejudice or when considerations Of mere
political expediency may prevail against
the word of the organic law; when the
time-honored concepts OF the process oil
law and the law or the land shall be
treated as mere jests and become the OBJ
iects of derson and contempt when the
usurpation by one branch Of the govern
ment of the powers which belong 10
another may be regarded with equa-
nimity, then the nour of disintegration
will be at hand. and II will only require
one endowed with the necessary audaci
10 ride roughshod over the ruins of the
constitution and ;hat system Of govern
ment which has made OF us a people,
happy, law-abiding end free, will give
way to the hysterical caprices OF tyranny
and despotism.
with all solernnity we express the con-
fidence that this tribunal will not b.
swayed from a proper and due regard for
the mandate Of the constitution by the UNI
worthy suggestion that 10 do so is to per-
NIT a technlcality 20 triumph. To dismiss
the articles OF impeachment which have
been presented TO this tribunal for lack
of Jurisdiction would not be "A triumph OF
technically. II would be vindication of
that sacred instrument 10 which We all
owe fealty. and upon the security OF
which. as the foundation of our political
existence. depends the welfare of our be-
loved commonwealth"
Alton u. Parker. with courtly bow to
President Cullen. his successor as Chief
Judge of the Court of Appeals. began the
argument for the Assembly Board of I'M
peachment Managers. He said that the
Sulzer counsel based the entire case on p
m.sapprehension oil the situation. a con-
fusion of the Asscmbly's legislative func-
tons and its quasi-judcial function In
beginning impeachment proceedings. He
said that the constitutions grant OF power
TO the Assembly to impeach was "as
broad as the language could make II"
apd nowhere was there any limitation as
to time or place.
Amplfied by Bracket.
There was nowhere any suggestion that
the Assembly ever could be without the
power to impeach the Governor In an
extraordinary session or at any other
time. Such lack. he said. would destroy
the balance Of the entire scheme of gov
eminent The Assembly could not act on
Legislative matters without the Governors
direction, but IL could impeach.
This argument was amplified by ex-
Il
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1913-09-23
Might Lead to Anarchy.

1T is urged by tho learned counsel for
the managers that the Assembly has the
inherent right 10 meet at any time and
present articles of impeachment From
that doctrine I dissent i'm toto 1t is true
that 1t is the Assembly that has the right
given it By the constitution TO impeach.
but the Assembly does not consist Of the
individual members OF it's body except
when they are duly assembled. That Is
plain elementary parliamentary law. IL
Is also the common law applying to all
bodies.
The individual action even OF ma
jority does not constitute the action OF
the body. whatever 1t may be, unless all
parties have had an opportunity to attend
and he heard Any other rule, II seems To
me. would cause, or might cause. mex
tricable confusion I'm the management OF
public affairs.
IF we assume that any member of the
Assembly may convene that body, or the
Speaker. for the purpose OF impeachment,
the body so meeting would have no power
10 protect Itself. II would be scene OF
disorder. and II so. before there had been
any election OF a Speaker. one member
might convene II at one spot and one at
another. II would lead to anarchy. The
extreme that has been suggested, that IA
Governor might commit treason. while it
IL theoretically possible to imagine il, is
quite improbable. and | think little weight
should be given TO 1t. Anyway. extreme
cases do not control the construction of
statutes or constitutions.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1913-09-23
Dramatic Scene Follows.

When Mr.. Marshall got through WIN
his efforts TO have the articles or I'M
peachment voided it was just o:40 D.
m. He sat down, wiping his foreheau'
The honora bic Senator'S shifted in their
seats and stretched their legs, realizing
that the decisive moment had come
Judge Cullen stopped looking through
a couple Of books and some papers ana
leaned forward over his desk, LOOKING
keenIy over his glasses at the rest or
the court He spoke in slow SehtIe
voice. which, however. carried no mint
OF INDIGESTION.
MY brethren, of course you VIII
readily appreciate that the point when
has been discussed before us is OF the
utmost importance. II goes to the very
foundation of this proceeding. There
fore II is that this should he decided
by the whole OF this court, and the pre-
siding member Of the court does not
feel inclined to use the power granted
under the rules 10 decide II in the hrst
instance. though ne mas no HcS''"'''''
IL the members want IT. in expressing
his opinion. as he has no wish to evade
any responsibility. You have the power
TO clear the court for private consulta-
ton under the rule, and even II 1t Is
not cleared any member has the right
10 debate this question
Thereupon Judge Collin moved thai
the courtroom be cleared for private
consultation. There was shulliilig
and scurrying as the audience went odt
of the galleries and the correspondents
left the Senate chamber. Even tho
anterooms and vestibules were emptied
Of all save court officers posted at the
doors
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1913-09-23
Judae Cullen Explains Vote.

Inside there was a brief discussion
as 10 the precise form in which the mo-
ton should be brought up for vote.
Finally it was decided hy Judge Cullen
that IL should come on the question
shall the motion 10 dismiss the i'm
peachfnent articles be granted on
that the roll was called. Judge Bart
lett. the second man. voted mo- on thc
understanding that II was tentative
vote and he might like 10 give his rca-
sons later on. Judge Chase also re-
served the right To voice his views II
when the rollcall was ended he found
anything left uncovered.
Judge Cullen. I'm explaining his vote
with the view Of ex-senator Bracket
and Judge Parker, for the board Of
Impeachment managers. that the As
sembly might legally have convened
itself and adopted the impeachment tr-
ticles. such "A contention was not 10 be
held. he said. as ii would lead TO an
archy. But that was not, after all. the
real question before the court
Judge Cullen's opinion. in substance.
was that the provision OF the constltu-
ton which limited the acts OF the
Legislature I'm extra session TO such
subjects AS were recommended TO il by
the Governor should be given "A rea-
sonable construction. II upheld the
contention Of the prosecution that the
provision referred 10 the Legislature
as whole and not to the Assembly as
an independent body.
80 Construed" said Judge Cullen,
these subjects all relate TO what the
Legislature as body can do and rot
TO the power vested in one branch Of
thu I.pgislaturp
Virginia gazette. [volume] (Williamsburg, Va.) 1893-192?, 1913-01-02
BUSINESS ASSOCIATION TO BEGIN
WORK OF new YEAR FRIDAY night
A REVIEW OF PAST YEARS WORK AND PROSPECTS
OF THE FUTURE FOR WILLIAMSBURG

The AsSociaEon during the CON-
ing year will no doubt attempt %
locate Industries here. Il wia give
is attenuon aud influence 70 secnrizg
for Williamsburg public improve
meats along every line. Wide
nothing definite has been suggested.
the shortnes Of the life Of the organ
iEahon preventing reaching CUT for
the many things needed. when thoss
things that arc COW before Il have
been accomplished. new fields Of
sndeavor will DC entered with az
earnesrnes& leading. il IS hoped to
better things for the Hrtl< CITY.
The Association would request
the cooperation Of al farmers ada
cent to the city. Il nust have their
assistance Il they hope 70 be bene-
fitted by the work the body has
outlined for il. In order to make
the Association the success hoped
for. al men must oecomr It's active
supporters.
One OF the greatest needs OF this
section lis immigration. We need
more farmers 20 develop the idle
land. To get this new bIood we
shall have 10 place our advantages
before those looking for homes.
The Association Will cooperate with
and Rssist in every manner possibls
this phase Of the situatiou. Those
northern and western farmers alrgady
located among rs can do more 20
bring others than any other indnsncE-
The more thew bring here. the mare
likely those a ready here are 70 DC
successful.
AT the mee-ing Friday night. a
new president will probably DC
elected and the conceusns Of opinion
IS that a progressive and earnest
man will DC CHOSEN tor the office.
All members ar- urgently requested
70 ba present u take part IN the de-
hosrarions of the Association anc "a
SEE thar no mistake IS made ia the
selection OF a president.