The sun., 1913-10-27
f4ennessy Called Sulzer Crazy, Says Quinn
afftds,Ns in support Of hts dental:
SrArr OF New voRk.
COUNTY ~ NV yoRk, s..

affidavNs in support Of hts dental:
SrArF OF New voRk.
COUNTY ~ NV YoRk. s..
Charles r. Murphy being duty s,orn
saws live AZ 3ob East Seventeenth
street, Borough of Manhattan. city VI
New York
I have been, Informed that one. Hen
messy has stated that Hon Edward r..
Mccall paid money To mo in consideration
Of his nomination to the~Supreme Court.
Such statement Is unauaiinedly false.
az never asked for. nor d'd I ever re-
ceivc from Judge Mccall, himself. or from
any person ON his behalf, directly or in
directly. any money or thing cf value at
any time.
CHARLES r. MuRruv.
Sworn to before me this ssth day ~
October. 1913
WILLIAM J. GLAckEN.
Notary Public Kings County.
Certificate filod in New York county.
i35 81 Marks avenue.
Brooklyn. October -. 1919
DEAR JupGH MCCALL: have seen In
the papers that Mr.. Hennessy says ! WAS
In your office the day he called 7 have
known him some years and remember ono
day last summer seeing him at the office
Of tho Public Service Commission I was
waiting to see YOU when he passed.
through the waiting ROOM and spoke TO
mo There was another gentleman with
him. They passed into your room before
did and and were with YOU not to ex.
coed ten or tw, I've minutes. when they
came out together.
II is not true that Mr.. Henncssy stayed
with YOU over an hour. Sincerely yours,
EMILY !. kEARR.
state of New York.
city. County Of New York
Emily l. Kearr being duly sworn says
that she wrote and has read the foregoing
letter and that the same is true in every
Sworn before me this 25th day NJ Octo-
her, 1918.
WILLIAM J. GLAckES.
Notary Public Kings County.
Certificate filed In New York county.
State Of New Yo.k
County ~ New York
George W P,unk,U heine dulI sworn
says. I live at 323 West Fifty.first street
in the Borough Of Manhattan. city Of
New York. and have known Judge Ed
ward r.. Mccall only since hts election in
1909 during that whole time I have
never spoken to him except to say Good
morning or Good afternoon
II il absolutely and outrageously
false to say that he ever paid me dol
lar AZ any time for any purpose The
statement made by q Mr.. 1iennessy tina,
met Judge Mccall AT the HOFFMAN House
is likewise false. have not been in the
HOFFMAN House for twenty years.
Judge Mccall has never lived in the
district where I was leader to my knowl-
edge. and | have never seen him excep,
to SEQ him pass through the court house
corridor on his way from his chambers
to the cour. room or AS he entered or left
the building. GEORGE w. PLuNKIrr.
sworn to before me this 2sth day of
October. 1918. WILLIAM J GLAcKEN
Notary Public. KINGS County. Ccr;h-
cate filed In New York County
state of New York.
County of New York So
John J, McNally. being duly sworn.
says;
! reside at 3sc For, Washington ave-
nue., Borough Of Manhattan. city Of New
York. and have known Judge Edward +
Mccall for over thirty years.
] was Il candidate for the position Of
confidential agent in the State Prison
Department of the State OF New York las,
summer and saw Mr. Hennessy several
times in relation to the appointment. AS
! had known him for over three years.
AZ one of these meetings I told Mr. Hen
messy that Judge Mccall had known me
for many years and he suggested that
] ask the Judge to recommend my ap-
pontment to the Governor so that he
might ask the Superintendent of Prisons
TO appoint me.