The Twin City star. [volume] (Minneapolis, Minn.) 1910-19??, 1913-07-25
new LIGHT ON
HAYNES AGENCY
Young Ad. Man Untor Fire Of
Publishers.
EXPLAINS HIS METHODS.

Advertising Concern Made by TIT
Chairman Of the Executive Commit
tee National Negro Press Association
Who Says the Agency 10 Reliable.
BY N. BARNETT DODSON.
New York.-Having received letters
from q number Of publishers in refer
ence to the responsibility Of the
Haynes Advertising agency in this
city, considered it my duty to make
personal investigation In order to
furnish the members Of the National
Negro Press association with impartial
and accurate information. To my
mind an advertising agency Ia subject
only to the control Of the periodicals
which 1t represents.
had the pleasure Of calling upon
the Haynes Advertising agency a few
days ago and was most cordially re-
ceived by Mr.. Haynes, who is the
proprietor Of the business. After a
few brief preliminary remarks I stated
tation Mr.. Haynes in the most intelli'
gent way outlined his method Of op-
Grafton.
Mr.. Haynes says: This agency is
the outcome of nearly two years strug-
gle against many obstacles. One Is
that Of general racial prejudice, which
is a universal handicap. Another most
vital feature is that in a number of
cases we have not been able to get
accurate and efficient service from
many of the colOred publishers. The
methods Of general advertising have
been greatly changed in recent years.
The most important additional feature
is the key SYSTEM which has been
adopted by all Of the big advertisers.
BY this method each medium carrying
an advertisement is recorded by the
advertiser and Is known by different
numbers. For instance, one publication
Is known by department 6, another is
known by department "a, and so on.
This system enables the advertiser
to systematically check up replies
from each medium carrying his adver-
tisement, thus showing the actual re-
suits Of each individual periodical in
which his advertisement appears. This
one feature alone has created extra ex-
pense In stamps, stationery and time,
corresponding with publishers, in
structtng them to insert key num-
bers' correctly. We have written as
many as six letters to some of these
publishers on this one point before
we could make them understand 1t.
Advertisers will not pay for any
newspaper advertisements until suf-
acient proof of insertions is estab-
hshed. This important feature has
been entirely ignored by many.
"A great many who have been car
rying advertisements from this Office
have failed to send in voucher copies
bearing the advertisement. This also
has greatly disturbed our routine"
I was then shown sufficient proof
that legal action had been started
against an advertiser in order to make
collection for publications that had
compiled with instructions by insert
Ing their proper key numbers and
sending In voucher copies Of their
publications. In this particular case
Mr.. Haynes claimed that he had mott
fed the publishers to whom he was
Indebted that he would be personally
responsible for all bills If collections
We're not made within a limited time.
Mr.. Haynes further said: 1.-THE su.
premacy Of this agency has been made
possible by my most comprehensive
combination rate plan, and careful
study and experiment have proved that
my system is the most effective and
productive service to offer the big ad-
vertisers. There Is no individual
Negro publication having enough cir
culation to interest the big advertiser;
consequently the com bination of from
ten to a hundred publications offer
Ing a combined circulation of many
thousands is absolutely the only propo-
sition that will attract the attention Of
the big advertiser to this class Of pub.
lication.
From an ethical standpoint It IL
not improper, unsafe or unwise In
grouping together any number Of pub
locations In order to accomplish thing
that could not be done otherwise. I
might add that through my most favor
able connections with the United Pub
fishers association and many Of the
large white advertising agencies of
the country I am quite confident that
within short time this esta blishment
Will be creditable asset to the colored
publishers Of this country. My advice
10 the colored publishers throughout
The country Is to give more attention
to circulation. That is the essential
chord on which the big advertisers
play"
Mr. Haynes is a member Of the Ma
ional Negro Press association, and his
ong practical experience In business
should give him first hand knowledge |
Is to business principles, and believe |
hat his agency Is absolutely reliable |
md offers the most tangible and prac-
ical proposition ever before brought !
o the attention Of the big advertisers.
1t present about one-third Of the
olored periodicals Of America are
represented by membership In the Ma.
ional Negro Press association