The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1912-03-21
THEFT OF GLOVES
tos.sisasd from r.asA p.S.J

packages and that one was the shirt
The Big Fight.
The witness then told OF meeting
Mr. Hathaway. in front OF the theatre
on Jefferson avenue In company with
samuel Dorsey and his attorney j.
Howard Holt. 80
We saw him and I asked him II !
cosld see him. 1 asked him TO 20 TO
Woodburns. with me and he walked
TO the rear OF the store. Charles
Voitie and Sam Dorsey. came in later
Mr.. Holt. asked him IL he knew Mr..
Arnold. and he said No. I asked him
about the AFFAIR and he said he would
answer at the proper time. He would
not talk.
"DIrty Lying Cur"
Finally Mr. Holt, turned TO him
and said: You are a dirty lying cur"
Il wanted TO talk to Mr. Hathaway
and convince him that he was mis-
taken.
when Mr.. Holt said that he start
ed after him and told him TO take his
glasses on. stepped IN front OF MT.
Holt and Mr. Hathaway struck Sam
Dorsey in the eye"
did not Hathaway try to hit Mr.
Holt and some one intertered and the
blow hit Dorsey"
mo; they were standing several
feet apart"
Did Mr. Holt call Hathaway a d.
- of a b."
I don't think so. think I would
have heard It II he said it,
Did also you not ask Hathaway to
make a signed statement
Rough Language Used.
Mr.. Hathaway started out the door
Mr.. Holt followed and I followed Mt
Holt. think Mr.. Dorsey and Voitle
followed, for they were present when
We went TO the Big Store. He asked
me to come over to the Big Store He
called Mr.. Holt a s. OF a band Mr.
Holt called him dirty lying cur"
Did not Mr.. Hathaway say when
he went in the store: This cur has
called me namesT"
81 would not say what he said
Hathaway threw a cigar at Mr. Holt
In the office. Mr.. Holt then picked
up something on the table and Hath
away boosted that he could lick up
the town"
Did not Mr.. Holt say to him: You
d. lying s. of a b."
Il don't remember. We had not
been trying TO get Hathaway TO sign a
statement in the Big Store"
Mrs. Hathaway.
In response TO a question by Mr..
McCamic, as to seeing Mrs. Hathaway
and securing = statement from her.
Mr.. Arnold said:
With Mr. Rhoads. ! walked to Mrs.
Hathaway's and she was not at home
They suggested that she was probably
at the home OF her sister, Mrs Peters,
and we went there. We went there
and she was there. Her husband was
not. ! said: Mrs. Hathaway. this is a
very serious AFFAIR. IL not only az.
fects me. but my family. and | want
20 get matters satisfactorily settled.
| asked her after she said she had
not charged me with taking the gloves
Is she would sign a statement, and
che said yes"
Did you say this is a very serious
matter and there are thousands and
thousands OF dollars behind II and we
are going TO fight it,"
Examining Gloves.
NO. | said there were thousands
OF people interested"
In reply 70 a question concerning
Mrs. Hathavay's condition. the wit
ness stated that she was n little ner-
vous but did not display any great
excitement Mr.. RhOads wrote the
statement. and Mrs. Hathaway signed
II the witness said.
Replying 10 question about his
next conference with Mr. Hathaway.
Mr.. Arnold said Il went 10 Mr.
Hathaway and said. brother. I have
nothing against you and maybe I can
convince you that you are wrong. He
finally consented to listen and | said.
] walked 10 the glove counter after
making some purchases in the store
and had my gloves in my right hand
] took a pair OF mine out 10 show my
wife that the gloves In the box. marked
less. we're Just "a good az the ones
had
one Of the clerks came up and ]
was talking about the cost OF the
gloves 10 him. and ! nut my gloves in
my pocket Mr.. Hathaway asked me
y had put my gloves in my pocket
three time. and told him may have
put them IN two or three times He
said ] know an a man has IL his char
r'.f and reputation. and don't want
~ drag 30 down. lie then said he
dif not know ~h"' her the gloves we're
mine or the stores
you Stole Gloves"
Did he not say during the cOnver
saton 7 don't know Arnold but 10
you arc the man you are the man
thar stole tho gloves
Yes. think he said something i.ae
that"
And "a no. 81 char time Holt call
Mr hathaway a dying s.ofbe-
ESQ "
did you not s.s.f SIR urf-uar al,
OH" Zfth ~ December ana ask hin. %
Sign a payer
hfs be cons. r..fsd .re rras-
h.f % uas Dot .ats.1rf1rs end 4-...I
BIN fo add something OH. Dol rsf. s..i
Here a letter aas Intrlf ICED Dbl ff.
defense uhi~h Hr Iofgrar ar.-s
flf fhe witness H.... ...t .t. Ir4t
fH0 Tires ufra rI. fr t.a r.rar .t
fte tine F aHs urftfI IA tra.a
stated fhn. POI ler rel f.. .aft.- .f,a.
W Hofruar rr'..eI f. maze .re
changes
uhaf ssarr f. r.. s..
Too -ro.r. peer .rt .r.
rers#s
TIE defense mon U.,. rt n. OLA.
Mr trnrf ls r.ff.-. ... -. ......
.nn aa E- f before .. .......
rrarrr. geo a.rr.r 600 H.t DID,. .