The evening world. [volume] (New York, N.Y.) 1887-1931, 1912-11-18
tire. others accuse. All cen ssS 10
that each u bed and each Of tAsm
wicked 10 . DEGREE

thst eech 70 he'd ana each Of tAsm
wicked 10 . degree
"Of course, ycp have understood that
"Jack' Rose and his story furnish the
crux Of this case lie is the motive.
the genius. the constituencies piotte'
and designer. you are asked to be.
lieye ,his self-conf essed murderer and
his co-piotters. all Of them self-cen-
fsSsed mu- derers"
Hayins aid his respects to the
States Witnesses ar. wahie declared
that he would tear down the logic al
the peoples case by practically confn.
Ing himself to the prosecutions evi-
dence Taking up the etste's esidenoe.
the sunmen's defender referred NJ nrst
to the meeting at the Cafe BeauS Arts
between Lefty Louie" and "whitey"
Lewis. Jack Rose. Harry WALTON and
Sam Paul
-They send for those hoys" Mr..
e'ahle elaborated. 'to urge upon them
that aose had had nothins 10 do with
ths framing" Of Jack" Zeiis. Why
did they send for these boys 20 toll
them that-becaure they were innocentf
No. bui because they ware guilty.. be-
cause they had framed Jack" zeliG
ana acre afraid Of the consequences.
Had Rose ren innocent would he have
bothered with these boys7 No. Why
should he' There would have been no
suspicion-po cause for him 70 fear the
gunner. Yes tdroppins his voice In in
toninr his sarcasmD. the eunrnea.
SARCASTIC IN CALLING HIS
cLieNre GuNMGM.
Il say gunner ~ that In the picfur~
you are offered: that II the Action
that Is held up t. you. Gunmsn' Fear
ie~s. Wild. iifs-disressr ding men. Hut
what Is the evidence? will tell yon
the evidence In tina: one OF these boys
wac shot In the back and the othar In
the left heel In a Chinatown shooting
ARRAY. Dangerous Gunmen. heroes
VINO run. aad one shot In the ha ok
That IL all the evidence you have OF
their badness. Lefty Louie shot in
the neci ana Whitley Lewis shot
through the hack Of his coat
That. gentlemen. Ia all the evidence
YOU have that these defendants are
fIefds incarnats-that they ran away
vfeA buneis Tying at their rear. After
that shooting care they come 10 this
i,uid,ne with Jart' ZeiiE. What or-
4 uf-es' them Z~iiG was shot as he was
!cavinr the building. shot IN the hack
"Ar6 thsss ssarSy wss shspdrc's
gray niur1eS cor Ssauding - TIE
curb. near this IN misd 6satls-
mon. the gray naydsr eaS Was
there when 4SliG 0a0 0hSe q tAs
back: the murder esr Was there
when thai CAinaHowu shooting o.
CURED. and she 0aeooe SoR W0o
present on,mous 0pscere - deaeA,
WHOM usrmAA 8ossEt8a3 wa0 shoe
70 death.
sYes. wheW0vsr ehsrs We maR-
DER 20 he done for Jaok Rose aal
his resrsr o,uN crowd you wouid
asd the Rig fray car not far swaV.
sAvs AL or RoSeO AcrioNe
INDICATED HIS QUILT.
Mr.. wahse took up the testimony ~
the gunner that when Rose had caiish
Mt Lefty" I1ouie's mt IN the Bronx.
Rose had protested that he had nothing
To do with the Oh natown shooting. This.
the LAWYER DECLARED was another ad-
MISSION 81 0utse There had bern No
occasion for him 20 deny his connection
With thu shestinG ~ theranhsrin Cafs
any NOR. than there had been nerd for
him'to deny tie z&lig "frame-,sp." q ~
(Rose, had been innocent Reference
was made 20 the fact that the PeoDie
had failed 10 call wsbber, Walton and
s,chepps 20 cerroboraAe Roesio direct
testimony. Only NJ the last moment had
they been caiisd On ne stand. Thsn thtyi
came. pursued wahie. TO deny and not
to sec,,se--dsny TINT they had fS-sl ths
shots; to deny Implications that would
make their iamnaitv ssipsisfna ss1ss-
lees.
TAXING up Roses statement that the
Ennmen had 49, with him - the Oar
den restaurant 10 kill Rosenthal q week
ar % besove me merder. Mr. wah,~
ridiculed Roses testimony On that poiRt
AZ p,eposteress. Raising me voics 10 IN
shrillest pitch and Sounding the aT|
With his arm ths big attorney said:
They have net put IN me tota of
evidence to show that Herman Rosenthai
was At the Garden Restaurant that
night. You hAve Ross's statement ana
that only to hose the assumpt.on that
these boys bed been asked 10 muu1er
Herman Rsss1thal ~ that time. WISH
her says Ne ai1n't know % the plan
vsilon hndn't lizard Il discussed. And
6ehepps-oh. vsa schepps was tansesat
a sny guity tsow'edss-
THE truth b. GentlsHsAn. thsf Shsrs
was no murder plot np to that ane
There was no need of murder ~ that
time n was not until Herman Roaso-
thai made his sMdav1t 70 the New Yorik
World and 0aa atout % Ret MS srheme
Of vsugeance against Rose -nd the other
gamblers whs had crowded him ont
befo.- the Grand Jury that they begaa
to think Of mcrdsf.
D.. WALES IDEA OF TIME PLOT
WAS MATCHED.
4 h was NOT us4il Ross heard from the
llps Of Becker that fbere was Q subpoena
out for hian shAs ~ bad any casss TOR
fear.
"But wAss ~ hsaea Of TIE sal.
posna he began 70 1sel shs hss
breath Of ne vengeance OF the lAv
% his faos. Aaa ~ was the Same
With Wsebsg. vaalsu ana ocAepps
whss t',ey haarA ebsy Wsss 70 ret
sutpoenasa
You viii recall that evsa than they
did not hurry their plans TO murder
Ne. they went 10 Dora 0ueerts 10 act
an affidavit mat would impeach Rosen-
thal's veractty. They could not have
thought ~ Innrder un,il tmm eiiafsty
after they aaH Dora Hiihsrt AftSr thew