The evening world., 1912-02-19
HIS PROPERTY WOULD REVERT
TO his RELATIVES.

S;or'd &c G,e with the tudg ne,t OF
i~n1Aal.$ s'll resting agsinst him. no
win ne -. S:m wurll be legal in
ts.' : ntr and lis property here would
isve., 20 Ne =, ~.Si!ves.
NJ. s1c"r,p was represented by
Jose, ?, II. Choate jr.. an auburn haired
Youth d! manners resembling IN suaviiy
ana gen, llity ,hoso Of his distins u!sa.d
la.tG5.
NJ. tjaltnc-'s lawyers arc Hugh Gor-
don i.i'cr, =. \. Ware, William y. Reed
e this city ari W. Giinan Dunn of
charlotte %s,ilic, Va.
Lawyer Ware opened the Chaloner
SIDE % the case. lie dwsl: on the
achievement Of Mr.. Chaloaer as a bus!-
ness man. educator and author. ~.
Ware custod "Cisloner on Insanity as
conclusive proof nat the lunacy laws OF
THIS STATE give a man charged with
insanity NJ proper opportunity tn prove
hts sanity. He also referred "a Mr.
chaloner's narrative Of his Blooming
dale experience -Four Years Behlnl the
,Bars.'' as In itself proper evidence that
M. ClialoNer was mt all times able %
take care OF himself and his property.
"a man In this state who is guilty o:
murder may forfeit his life or be con-
fined In prison for life said Mr.. Ware.
But ne may not he tried in his absence
a. Was Chaloner. though lie was at
White Plains. and the Shcrlff's Jury
(which adjudged him insan was only
miles away. Either death 81
life imprisonment Is preferable to the
Q t TO which Mr.. Chaloner's brother
condemned him."
TELLS ABOUT TROUBLES WITH
HIS FAMILY.
Mr.. Ware said Mr.. Chalmers trouble
with his family begun, when as a young
man he had a fight with Winthrop As
cor Chandler in which Winthrop got q
cut on the head which" said Mr.. Wall.
the brother has still. apparently. q
lively memory"
There was a bigger Lreach in the fam
lily when Aieda Emme.t. w. A. Chanler.
Robert NJ. Chanler. Winthrop Chanler
and Louis Chanler were not invited to
Customers wedding when he married
Auelie Rives. nov the Princess Trou-
bstskoy. Margaret Chanier, a sister,
was the only member Of his immediate
family there. This. SAID Mr.. Ware, was
because winthrop Aston Chanler had
ssut him q copy of The Quick and the
Dead" with scruilious marginal notes.
The man went on TO say that ON Dee
G. 1905. q meeting Of h Roanoke Rapids
power Company. an industry built Wy
hy Mr.. Chaloner, was held in the Hote'
Xsnsington. In that meeting winthrop
Astor Chanler approached Mr.. Chaloner
who was lying Ill on a bed, and at
tempted TO strike him with clenched hst
Chaloner deposed his brother and sale
that he meant to demand an accounting
o. his fathers estate. only n account
Ing having been made by the executors
his brothers. In ten years.
MADE A WILL OieiNHERirlNS
HIS RELATIVES.
Mr.. Chasoner made Q viii which dis
lnhsr4ted all but one of his brothers a n
sauters and left me bulk OF his prop
erty 20 the University Of Virginia
stanford White, after IN aOquain
lance of several years. visited Mr.. Chal
, Oner in Virginia and cursed him 70
burying himself in h country N be
nan leading up to h4s ffnally success
fA effort to get MI. Chaaoner * 50
back to New York.
"Just before chat" said MI. Ware
"Nr. Chaloncr and his brother. William
Aston Chalooee. were travelling In tn
compsrtment Of . Pullman car. Nj
Chaioper saw Q paragraph in O news
paper accusing william A. Chanler an
the trainer Of his racing stable OF dts
honesty in racing the horse Salvacea
w. A. Chanler dh not seem to resen
the criticism and to Mr.. Chaloner's dia
gust and they quArrelled and did NO
speak for years."
stanford White and . DR.. Fuller wen
10 Virginia on the same train with Wiz
throp A. CHAMBER and with Mr.. Chanie
In the background persuaded him I
come to New York, With W. 4. Chnnle
IN conceaiment ON the same train. Nj
ware called stanford White IN
',sfephistopheies" OF the conspiracy.
,..H&li!tk IS4 fY3se ~ s ~. DAAe5!..
IS4 =: c. ~ = * ! g