Albuquerque morning journal. [volume] (Albuquerque, N.M.) 1903-1926, 1912-11-20
Mon Who ActlaIIy Did Killing
Of Gambler RosenthaI at Be-
hast Of Police Lieutenant
Wait Sentence Of Court
Jury DELIBERATES
ONLY TWENTY MINUTES
Convicted Thugs Hear Report
WITH StoIid Indifference to
Electric Chair That Probably
Awaits Them.

LlC0tllO ~ C''0''
A.oifc I hpn1
f'"
,o, sn.c,,i Ieased Wire
Il'y N"f''"t Wi, %ov ig.-"Gvp the
Nt .i,|f,, n,,io y .Dago Frank
llnpd, I",is lilled Herman
and m hi'es .,s,,,hlor ~ tho insti-
ltoseh'n't ,.harlee Recler and. like
,,nst pay the penalty of death in
,tD electric chair The jury which
WIZ i,non hearing the evidence against
fhe four eunmcn so decided TO-DAY
When it returned against them Z Ner-
dicf OF murder in the llist ueSre'
nfter hat twenty minutes % drAper@
ton. The jury was not brought pa'h
IA the court room for ht'N minutes
after reaching verdict as the court
had ADJOURNED Tor 'uhch'
The eunmen heard the verdict win
sut show of emotion They STOOD az
the bar looking straight ahead as 'he
foreman Of the jury rose 10 MAKE
known the results oi us utlheitt ,"ii9'
ana they continued 10 stare stolidlN IN
front Of the bar untll the lvtl'i ~ w
proceedings was concluNeu' roiilini
Maeislrate cnarles ~ W a ",'l,' 3,,,t
sci Tor the GUNNER, nni'4u''' n,aia+
ne would apl'N"l l'''ii' ,,.'ii, MANN,
ana As IN IN" rHNe - ~ ~ ft
may clapse 9elole 'n'" ui''i''''' ~
is aeleflIlllleu
The quick verdict came as sur
prise 10 everybody The Jury IN the
case of Lieutenant Dharl5s l'eVNsi ~ ~
liberated heaTN SVNth nVN'9 ,,t' ~
reaching = Yei1lN r. + n" - nv t,',i
sing seh'etlceQ ~ ~ 'to1,'i' ,,,,'.i(, ''''''
tor hAtlhf llls'lF''''u ~
Justice GOff reminded ihe PRISON
ers untll iVi5o ~ w ~,
ne wiz llN 'h' u'9 ~
sentence
The entire proceedings IN couI'
after tNe lnrN came II o0'up'"u Vii,
seven hllNutca' ne ~ 'i''''',i'S 1
brought ~ ~ luui Mai,'Vi,' .,tl.4 mli' = ,i a,
hc'nah- lheN neaIu w .,,,,'i
laees hhlloNVp' s'ai 'i'f ~ "'
ON the way back TO their cells Il Il
except Whitley LOWS Waikeu eIntl
Lewis went with bowed head. Ihe
crowd in the court room received thr
verdict without demonstration ana IN.
neWs caused no visible eNclenlen
when ii reached the thf"lS oulSluV
the building.
FOR moro than three hours TODAY
snnron1e Justice Goff charged the
irr, in Inc case of the four gnnmen
accpsed az murderin4 Herman Rosen-
nFl f. ~ etate's informers com
niftod ma crime MS the defense con-
fonds 10 asked was ii reasonable 60
assume that the informers would in
,te the gunmen as Witnesses
.te r. r,aa h,s ,ioa ba said
~. tb o,t,,,,,o ala ~,
.t.l4tt ~, dia ~ ~ 90 further
a i,, ia'- ,hat ~ had actnaliv seen
~" Me9i '"o ~ '1,.p ,,sods of the do
4''5''i' ~ ''''
nat shall say appnes TO an tllv
uelenaanls ana QhlN m one eAs', Slia
separate one lrom the otneIs, SalV
duSslce Hoit m opening ms auufeSS'
sHermnn Rosenthal was shot to
death under circumstances of excep-
Vailon and schcnns so, TO these -four
defcndants 'You ala the murder
These four defendants say. We admit
tins murder hut you committed IT, 1t
is n ronarl,abla situation. thes. two
groups Of men accusing the other
Rose has taken the witness stand
ana acknovlcaued participation in the
crime Ia WAS n remarkable narrative
that he told. can You saw that men
constructed and conceived this plot
without there heing fonnd a grain of
truth in u2 From the defendants
Themselves we learn that Rose feared
them
THE defense accuses Rose Of con
stmctng the story to save his own
life n ts f.r VA, 20 GOV in hearino
use lhcriminate himself IN telllne
ruth to s1nnort his story wv vh~ther i
was fn,fe in,,oi,oti,,,
"Rpar in mind tb,+ posa dia no,
testify that ba saw no dofendante
shoot Rosenthal wonld he have