New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1912-06-22


q somebody on this platform
Before these two men were aLlc 10 rui
under the primary law" he continued
both they and the men they were u
represent were forced 20 pledge Themselves
70 abide hv the preferential vote Of thu
state. President Taft did that, and If ~
now accents the vote Of these two men il
| this convention he will be guilty OF higi
! treason"
/ Hency declared it was absolutely i'm
! possible under the returns Of the election
| to decide what the vote was in ali IN
! dividual district. adding:
! mo one but tho thirty-e'ght MEMBER
OF the national committee who voted u
scat these men and the other men Whos'
! seats have likewise been stolen would at
/ tempt 20 discover that vote
! Uenev concluded with the statement tha'
! Tryon received fewer votes than TOUR
! teen other Taft delegates in 'alito'na
| who failed of election
/ Payne Answers Heney'
Representative Serene +. Payne Of New
| York. author OF the Payne tarin act was
! greeted with mingled cheers ana hoot'
| 4, nc appeared to take up the argument
! for the Taft delegates.
Where's Aldrich?' Yelled man l"
/ the gallery.
MIR PAYNE asked for patient hear ins
and said tho two Taft delegates did no'
81, with tho california delegation because
| tho chairman OF that delegation "ould
not give them tho scats to "h''h '''
were entitled
III, declaration that the Taft delegate
had been seated by tho suprcm" Ia" 81
national Rcpubllcanism was Sr''''1 WIZ
a prolonged chorus Of Kisses StoahS an"
hoos The demonstration grew unu' son
ator Roo, took a hand with THIS "arhOb
NO cause in a Republican national con.
vs,,,on vas ever won hy drowning NP''''
on either side. -,
NJ, PAYNE reviewed party preceden' H'"
tho t,mo OF Lincoln to show that INC 10
,,o,,l conventions had always assumed Nv
r,o,, =, direct the manner OF s"I''unE
delegates --...,-,. 49,,
IIo declared the statewide primary "a"
ca, ,orcod through tho california Leg
,ya,ure because ot fear OF IN" I'''''
,.I, MON mat Tan would gct s'''fal .,
.,o ,,,rr.ss districts under 'h" m'''"
-.f,.,,rr delegates oy districts
.,.,. dam, YOU elect rour Presidential
electors that way asked '''
r.o california delegation. ...
.r.,,,,.c Va, lly" uo c"n'o. '.'' '''.
! r,,or,cI rayu" a.,r
A. watson. who then too" "P inc "
.--,,r,.,, asserted the Caii"rh" 10
-, INV, tho effect ~ enforcing 'h' '''
-,,, aud he declared such . I'.' ''''
,,.,..r r-ry.il I'M a national convention
/ Unit rrl, o., primary =. r' '"'''' ''''
anil vrc %, decree of convention 7''
! watson 'l' 81 rohhng en-" f'V''.
/ r,rrrc.s district of tho night 8" 20. "h.
,,.o,r tcrcsato4 slaII bo Shall Oh" maj''l'
-. ,,gclc, decree and determine "h'
,h. delegated from san Fran
-.
/ -. s,li some delegates
/ Tho state ls not sovereign over %"
--c,, di,,r,r,.~ Watson concluded
t,,,.o, Talk. OF Revolution.
,.,..., Ga.
This question Governor 49,
next speaker SAN ~ '''
question 81 seating iNo lnnl' ''ua' '
gates Dos r"p"N 81 '''''''''' v"
dcntials or b. action OF TINS ''h'e"''''
Tho question goes +" tie very ro'' vi ~
publicsnism. II Is. shall tie pNopI" r'''
"lou men ~ III" East may SN''' =, "'
now progrtSsivlsm that Id' ono ''F,
giant out Of the West. ne VIM "n'
au thinking men TO-DAY recognize ''a' ~
revolution Ia on I'm TINS 'oNhuN' an" P''
grcssiNisn II sure ~ ''''''''
Johnson declared In" present '"nNeh'lo
lad demonstrated IN" absolute n"ce'7''
loi extending the Fr's'dehlla' pr''eI'n'
primary ana 70" "At""'' w" ''I ''' =. 1--WE
lem
Nv ,,,,..,, ,,,,,,...,.. t,,, Nh,
d'''P''' 80