New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1912-06-21

a
chicago. June 2O.-The Taft FORCES
turned the tables on the Roosevelt au-
,-.. T., .bo committee on credentials
to-day, when they insisted on hear''lS
eli the evidence IN the contested caseS'
l., order 70 show how fair they we're de-
,ormIned 10 be the Taft members sain
they were willing to go Thoroughly INTO
every case.
When the followers ~ the colonel real
,zod ,vrat silly thing they had done
last night they tried 10 got the commit
foo 70 limit the number Of cases that II
would consider. saying they were WHINE
stand on the action of the natloh1'
committee on the other contests.
The COMMITTEES will sit all night III
every case decided so Ear the natiohh'
committees work on contests. when mas
been so violently assaulted by Colohe'
Roosevelt and his followers, has been
UNFOLD This has been done by q com
,,i,toe appointed by the convention ana
made up Of persons entirely dl'eren'
from those who considered the evidence
or the national committee.
The real test vote in the committee
showing the relative strength OF the
Taft and Roosevelt forces. % to Ia.
came on the seating OF the Arizona dele
cation. The vote in detail follows:
FOR ROOSEVELT DELEGATES.
, :, clair. Illinois T. r. Nc
,,orr,lck represented 10y John HedN ,.
Nfsipc J,ssc ". Libby, Minnesota, HuFh
r Ualbert. Missouri, Jesse IoiIeTloh, ~
hrotEa. H. r. Sackett: New Jersey. =.
~ ,a,5 vis. Nor,h Carolina. g. ". CoNles'
Eoytb Dakota. ". :. Lauder. ONO John !.
sullivan: oklahoma. oanlti N1I'"I
gon 4. Y. swift. Pennsy wanna, Lex I'D "a
SItchcIl. South Dakota. ; y way anu
NCst Virginia, Harry ShaN.
ror THE TAFT DEbbGATES.
,nr,,a Alexander G.. Birch; hrkansas.
- Ma va t.rarCer. colorado Thomas ~ De
Inc, Connecticut. : Henry Roranechi pJl
me. Edmurd -.'. choll; Florida, ~ D.
Mcfarland. Geo lieh,y ya nI"'iS Dewitt:
I IIa,,t;rky, ii J calvin: Louisiana; W; 1.
nH't.. Michigan T.. ". Atwood; MlsslSHI
ii. l. b MoseleN,;, M2 on W,II IA IS New
Strum hire Fred. W Estabrook; New MeS-
t ia" Hugo seaberg; New York; feorg" =,
s,t,l,,. Rhode Island George w Ld", IN
Sn"tb Carolina. r. r. Tol6ert' IvSTary,len:
John r: Early e texas Vermont. !. GRAY
Et Tan: Virginia. l.. i. Summers; MasfnihhT
inn II T. Doyell: Wisconsin. = H. oni sui =
wyoming. r NM, W; Mcn' Of Columbia Aaron
ShaShrIu'" Hawaii Charles \. Rice, mn i,-
INNINGS. Thomas I. Harugan' NJ"
Rico, s Hannoc l, no member; =.
. ApSeu. - MARYLAND: Francis j. hehe!'
SG.iitnrnia. Ralph Harris. kansas ,r,,ora
's!i an, or ,,n,,S,ngNRobert Z Morrison Arizona
!, Fol,.,,e Backs Committee
Senator La Toilette has reviewed INC
,,aoco IN all the cases that were con-
s,derea worthy OF making a hgh' 'oi pS
tho Roosevelt forces. He has uec'ueu
,ha, the action Of the nationai 'oiii'l''
TOO IN each case was perfectly JuS''".u
Az result he has suggested u D
rad, the wisconsin member OF the
arodartials committee, that he would 90
wcr 10 support the national comnl'''ee
accordingly Mr. Cady is voting Win the
Taft forces. ,-.-,.,
Tho case in the 9th Alabama District
,,,ntcb led Colonel Roosevelt TO denounce
,,,o r,embers Of the national committee
when they seated the Taft delegates was
tho first that came up to-day. AFTER
thorough consideration Of the evidence
taking three hours or more, the credeh-
tisls committee decided, by vote OF Oh
n IT,. TO sustain the action OF the ma
tionai committee
Realizing what n spectacle they had
made OF themselves in boiling the com
r,ittee on credentials last night just be-
cause The volatile Heney, of California
got il into his head that the Taft forces
wanted 10 shut Off debate, the Roosevelt
committeeman came back his morning;
that is all returned except Heney, Way
q; south Dakota, and Darlington. OF
Maryland ,-,.,..
There had never been any disposition
,, rho mart OF the Taft leaders To- sup
nrnss debate The bolt Of the Roosevelt
members occurred before the committee
had adopted any rules whatever. After
they had gone II was lccded nonlinaily
to give thirty minutes TO state cases and
dCteen minutes to districts cases. but
actually to give all the time the contest
ants should ask.