The Sentinel=record., 1912-11-28

of these communication It was charg- ed Fogel contended mat the umpi-es were crooked and that the Philadel. phia team was getting rotten deal :"
 The resolutions as adopted by the league follow:
 Upon consideration of the charges Heretofore filed against Horace S Fogel and of his answer thereto, and of the evidence offered in support .f said charges and in defense thereof the National League of Professional baseball clubs, does hereby, find that he. the said Horace S. Fogel is guii-y of said charges and of each specifica. ton thereof, except specifications three and five, which are dismissed because the communications referred to in said specifications are provieg- ed; and
 Whereas, after the filing of sail charges and before the hearing there- of. the said Horace s. Fogel, resigned as president of the Philadelphia ball club thereby withdrawing as the rep resentative in this league of said club. and.
 V resignation said Horace $. Fogel. ap- peared in person and by counsel and was afforded every opportunity to and was urged by this league to produce any and all proof of the charges made by him reflecting upon the hon. esty and iairness of the methods. anu the practices and rules of this league and upon the integrity of it's ofticia.s and umpires and of the charges and threats made by him in the letter to the league club presidents of Oct. 1g. lsl2; but he, the said Horace $. F5- gel, had produced no evidence what. ever which tends to support his charg. es, rehecting and threats thus maue.
 Therefore, be it resolved.
 l. That this league hereby cen sures and condemns Horace s. Fogcl Tor the utterances and publications made by him while president of the Philadelphia club of this league.
 2 That he, the said Horace s Fogel, be, and he is, hereby forever excluded from further participation ia the councils of this league as the rep fesentative of the Philadelphia club or O. any club. and
 5. That these resolutions be spread upon the minutes of this league and a copy thereof duly certified be furn- ished to each club composing the Ma tional league.
 Be 1t further resolved that the sec- retary of the league be and is here ny directed to give to any one inter- ested, free access to the complete stenographic minutes of this hearin ': and whereas, the jurisdiction of this league to pass judgment upon the charges just disposed of has been brought in question vherafofe Be IT further
 Resolved that this Ieagne is not a body of limited powers, whose au- thosity is restricted by the powers expressly enumerated in it's consu- tuition, As voluntary association ofI the representatives of organized pro fessional baseball, we have the same powers that appertain to in- dividual men and associations of men. Whenever the representative of any club falls short of this high principle which should be the standard of all modern business men and sportsmen, t becomes the privilege and duty of this league to say to the clubs com posing 1t and to the general public that such person will not be admitteari 10 its councils. We don't say to the 1 clubs who shall represent them in Inc meetings of this league, but we 10 reserve the right to say who shall 1 rot represent them when the person | so excluded shall be proven to be un- 1t to discharge the high duties de- volving upon him in our delibera ions"
 Negotiations for the exchange of some Cincinnati players for shortstop | Tinker of the Chicago club were still | going on tonight and final confer ence of the interested parties in the | ieal will be he'd tomorrow.
 A report today that inc deal was If. was denied.
 A representative from all the Ma .ional league clubs will leave here tomorrow evening to attend the fu neral of the late John T. Brush at