davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
Twice-a-week plain dealer. (Cresco, Howard County, Iowa) 1895-1913, 1912-10-22
Youthful Robber Dying.

Minneapolis, Oct. 81. = Realizing
that death is near, Lloyd P. Foster.
who was shot and MORALLY wounded
by Patrolman Martin Johnson Of the
East Side station early Sunday morn
ing when he attempted to make his
escape after having been caught in
the act of burglarizing a drug store.
asked the head nurse at the City hos
pital to summon priest. The bur-
glar, who is but twenty-one, confessed,
received absolution and was baptized
in the Catholic faith.
Twice-a-week plain dealer. (Cresco, Howard County, Iowa) 1895-1913, 1912-10-22

Springs this year. One would not
know that ageneral election waste be
held in few days. A few candidates
have been extending the glad hand and
distributing cigars, showing their INTEL
est in the men who have a vote this
fall.
The Royal Neighbors are planning
for great time in the Opera House,
October 18th. There is to be play
and basket social; no doubt it will be
fine.
Mrs. Geo. Hall is suffering with
rheumatism.
The city marshal is filing up some Of
was greatly needed.
MIR. and Mrs. Horton took an auto
ride out to their farm near Granger
Wednesday.
Mrs. Upton and daughter, Mrs. E.
0. Jones. Mrs. j. e. Roberts, and Mrs.
Anna Smith were among our Cresco
visitors Saturday.
Miss Knudsen came home from near
Spring Valley, where she is teaching
school, Friday. H. H. Sanborn went
for her by auto.
A. Taute and wife, who reside in
Patton. came Thursday morning to
visit their son, l.. Taute, who resides
south'of town. They have been visiting
a son in North Dakota, and report
snow storm that caused the farmers to
stop threshing.
The smiling face of Myron Converse
was seen on our streets, Wednesday.
Mrs. Alice Hungerford, who resides
in Fayette, was calling on friends.
Thursday. She owns farm north
west OF town.
Phoebe Perry left Saturday for few
days visit with her slsters who are
teaching in Lyle, MINI.
Albert Jones was down few days
from Minneapolis. returning Saturday.
His father accompanied him expecting
to remain through the winter.
Henry Foulkes mother has come to
live in Lime Springs. She has rented
the Kaiser house for the winter, and
will live with son and his family who
are expected to arrive soon from South
Dakota.
Mrs. Flemming, Supt. OF Schools of
Moore, and Mr.. Praus, came with the
foot ball team from DEBORAH Saturday.
The game was an exciting one, some
The score was 81 to in favoc of De-
corah.
John Jones and wife, of Chester,
were calling on friends, Monday.
Mrs. Platt is assisting her husband
in the depot, since Lyman Carpenter
went to Des Moines.
Twice-a-week plain dealer. (Cresco, Howard County, Iowa) 1895-1913, 1912-10-22
Girl on Hunger Strike.

London, Oct. Fl. Miss Helen
Craiggs, daughter of Sir John Craiggs.
of a big firm Of accountants. locked up
to do nine months hard labor for at
tempting to burn Cabinet Minister
Harcourt's house at Oxford. imme.
diately began q hunger strike.
Chemist Called an lmposter.
St. Paul, Oct. 21.-At the request Of
st. Paul authorities, Thomas Nc
Manus, secret service agent OF the
United States. treasury department.
visited the hospital where the man
supposed to be Dr.. George E. Goode,
federal chemistry expert, was taken
after he was found unconscious in St.
Paul Friday night, in an effort to
Identify him. Mr.. McManus declared
that the suppoSsd DR.. Goode is not
Goode and is not in the employ of the
government. Mr.. McManus cannot FIX
reason for such an act of imposi'
ton.
Twice-a-week plain dealer. (Cresco, Howard County, Iowa) 1895-1913, 1912-10-22
Auto PLUNGE. From BRIDGE.

Fargo, ~ D., Oct. 21.-Clarence
Wood of Armenia, N. D., had miracu
lous escape from death when an auto
mobile which he was driving, collidet
with the railing Of bridge across tn,
Cheyenne river. The accident occur
red six miles north of Fargo, the ma
chine leaping from the bridge ant
plunging down 20 foot embankment
pinning Wood beneath it, The gaso
line in the tank exploded and set fire
to the car Wood pulled himself clear
OF the wreckage and crawled half {
mile to farm house.
Twice-a-week plain dealer. (Cresco, Howard County, Iowa) 1895-1913, 1912-10-22
A TRIBUTE TO HERO NEwsBO1
THOUSANDS ATTEND FUNERAL
OF BILLY RUGH.
Crowds, With rear-Dlmmed Eyes, Join
In Singing Hymns in Streets
Of Gary.

Gary, Ind, Oct. 21.-The funeral Of
Billy Rugh, the newsboy who gave
his crippled leg that skin might be
grated onto, the body of Miss Ethel
Smith thereby saving her life, was
held here and practically all Gary and
many people from surrounding towns
attended. No building was large
enough to accommodate the crowd and
the services were held in the street.
Four brass bands played funeral
dirges, six uniformed policemen were
pail bearers and fire department au-
tomobile was the funeral car. while
company Of llrenen carried the dow.
srs. Mayor T. y. Knots and the coun'
cilmen and ether leading men Of the
city with barred heads, walked at the
head Of the procession which convey.
ed the body to the railway depot where
It was put aboard train for Rock
Island, Ill.
Many women were In the line, which
required more than an hour to pass
the bier placed in the middle Of the
street. Miss Smith was not able to at.
tend but her father and brothers were
In the audience.
Led by the church choir and with
music furnished by two bands that
had donated theif services, the crowd
reverently sang old gospel hymns as
Rev. j.. M. Avann stepped into the fire
department automobile and utilized its
seat as his pulpit. The throngs Of
persons upon nearby porch roofs join.
ed in the singing.
The pastor likened the dead man to
''the christ who saved others, yet
Himself could not save"
What means this concourse Of PEG.
ple?" he asked. "Why has the heart
of Gary been touched as never beforei
We are told man Is dead.
'Why, men die every day. Yet this
man had no office and was almost un.
known. He was only newsboy. But
he made the great sacrifice. He risked
his life, then gave it that a girl whom
he never knew might live. His was
the sacrifice Of one who loved his fell
low man. In life his CHEEKY smile and
kindly greeting were worth going a
mile to see and hear. In death he
has attracted An ,assemblage to pay
him tribute that would not gather for
self-centered man. This was the
spirit Of Rugh, the spirit Of self-sacri.
flee, and if you are inspired by it, my
words will not have been in vain,"
Tears dimmed the eyes of the thou
sands as they united in singing, Jesus
Lover of my Soul.
Twice-a-week plain dealer. (Cresco, Howard County, Iowa) 1895-1913, 1912-10-22
Rain prIvee In Threshers.

Crookston, Mimi, Oct. 10. = All
threshing has been stopped by gen.
eral rain here. The harvest Of fax
has also been stopped and the situa
ton is serious. Four days of thresh
Ing this week has been the best week
this fall. Continued rains will mean
heavy loss on the flax crop, the most
paying crop the farmers have, as We
weather did not damage the uncut
fields. The potato crop will also sui
fer, as many fields were just getting
dry enough to dig.
Twice-a-week plain dealer. (Cresco, Howard County, Iowa) 1895-1913, 1912-10-22
Farmers Prosperous.
otficiaIs Cautioned by Dix.

Little Falls, N. Y, Oct. Glover
nor Dix took hand in the dispute be-
tween the local authorities and So
cialists here by sending message to
Sheriff Moon and Mayor Frank Shall,
calling for their attention to the con.
stitutional provisions regarding the
rights of free speech and holding pub
lie assemblies.
Twice-a-week plain dealer. (Cresco, Howard County, Iowa) 1895-1913, 1912-10-22
ALLIED FORCES
WINNING BATTLE
puLGARlANs TAKE GENERAL
POSITIONS At THE POINT
Y OF THE 6AYoNET.
sERv1ANs DRIVE TURKS
Routed Army Pushed Across Morava
vaIley-Greeks Victorious In
Four-Hour Battle Of
Mt. Olympus.

Sofia, Oct 21.-The Bulgarian fore
es operating against Adrianople have
driven the Turks back to the forts
forming the outer line Of the defenses
They took 100 prisoners. The general
advance Of the Bulgarians continues
Several positions on the heights were
taken at the bayonet point. In the VII
lagos the Turks are Selling Bulgarian
officials and holding them for ransom
Replying to telegram from his cab
lnet, King Ferdinand sent the follow
ing message: II am convinced that
our incompatible and valiant army
sprung from q people like the Bulgart
ans whose self-sacrifice for their ma
tional ideals is without equal In his
tory, will fight and destroy the eternal
enemy of the Bulgarian race. Our
brothers from the other eide of the
Rilo Dagh and Rhodope mountains
will at last receive light from the au'
rora OF liberty. Long live the valiant
and victorious Bulgarian army; long
live the valorous Bulgarian people"
Servian Forces Victorious.
Belgrade.-The Servian army under
the crown prince has captured Rulya
Heights. strategical position to the
south of Bujanoratz. some miles be
low Vranya.
An official report from the general
staff at Nish says the Servians have
taken all the trenches in the Turkish
territory around Vranya and the
Turks have been driven back across
Morava valley.
Details have been received Of .
treacherous act by Albantans on the
Eervian posts near Prepalatz. forty
miles 10 the south of Nish, on Thurs
day. Albanian irregulars who constt
tuted the attacking party, were re-
pulsed and hoisted white nag when
Servian captain with q white flag ap
preached the regulars opened fire,
killing an officer and IL men and
wounding 40. The Servian artillery
Immediately shellsd the enemy, killing
200.
Turks Flee esfore Greeks.
Athens.-After four hours. engage.
ment the Greeks Saturday dislodged
the Turks from the strong positions
which they had taken in the defense
Of Ellasona, at the foot Of Mount
Olympus, and occupied the town.
Crown Prince Constantine was In per.
sonal command and received q hap
tism of fire. The Greek troops
showed great courage. Their losses
we're small
PLAYA Reported Captured.
Cettjnje, Montenegro.-It Is official.
" announced here that the Montene-
grin forces captured the town Of Pla'
va Saturday. The battle lasted two
days.
Turks cannonads varna.
London.-The Turkish warshipS
fred 100 rounds at Varna. but without
effect. says q Sofia dispatch to the
Times. Two Bulgarian torpedo boats
then issued from the harbor and en-.
gagged the Turkish squadron. one ship
Of which withdrew. 1t is believed that
she was struck by torpedo but not
seriously damaged. Eventually the
Turks proceeded to Baltchik, Is miles
to the north, where they INDUCED in
another harmless bombardment.
Twice-a-week plain dealer. (Cresco, Howard County, Iowa) 1895-1913, 1912-10-22
Baseball Fan Wants To Die.

Chicago, Oct. 19.-Feeling that life
would be only an empty dream il the
Sox lost the city series and having
carefully figured out that with Lange
pitching their chances against the
Cubs would be nil, Charles Robeck,
one hour before play time, babe fare
we'll to the baseball world and turned
on the gas.
Twice-a-week plain dealer. (Cresco, Howard County, Iowa) 1895-1913, 1912-10-22

The candidate for Congress in the
Fourth District on the Democratic
ticket is Hon G. A. Meyer of Winnie
shiek county. Mr. Meyer is young
man of excellent qualifications, and
stands we'll throughout the district.
He is making splendid campaign for
Congress, and reports from the district
indicate that he will win over Mr..
Haugen. City Free Press.
Twice-a-week plain dealer. (Cresco, Howard County, Iowa) 1895-1913, 1912-10-22

chicaaoan Dies at Age Of ITO.
Chicago, Oct 21.-Joseph Marshi,
carpenter. died ct his home here. 10
years old. He was born in Germany
and came to this country when he was
40 years of age.
Twice-a-week plain dealer. (Cresco, Howard County, Iowa) 1895-1913, 1912-10-22
Club Women Choose Fargo.

Grand Forks, N. D., Oct. 1s.-Farge
was selected Just before adjournment
for the next meeting Of the North Da'
kota Federation Of Women's clubs.
Mrs. H. A. Preslsr was elected secre'
tary and tho remainder of the time
was given over to discussion OF the
endowment fund. to the raising Of
which Mrs. N. G. Young, the retiring
president, will give much Of her time
during the coming year.
Twice-a-week plain dealer. (Cresco, Howard County, Iowa) 1895-1913, 1912-10-22
300 Persons Near Death.

Reed City, Mich, Oct. 21-Three
hundred persons miraculously escaped
death when Grand Rapids and Ish.
peming passenger train left the rails
and plunged down an embankment
near here
Twice-a-week plain dealer. (Cresco, Howard County, Iowa) 1895-1913, 1912-10-22
Farm for Rent.

The los acre farm, known as the
Nichols estate, five miles Northwest
of Cresco. Every acre of this farm
will raise corn. Also good buildings.
Address LUERs & CLARK Co.,
Cresco, Iowa.
Twice-a-week plain dealer. (Cresco, Howard County, Iowa) 1895-1913, 1912-10-22
BOY WH0GAvEL
FOR GIRL IS DEAD
BILLY RUGH DIES IN GARY HOS
PlrAL AS RESULT OF BRAVE
SACRIFICE.
WAS A PENN1LEss TRAMP
Swim Grating Operation Proves Sue
cess and Ethel Smith Will
Recover II 10
Said.

Gary. Ind, Oct. 19.-Billy Rugh, the
crippled newsboy whose withered leg
was amputated a few weeks ago to
save the life of a girl he never had
seen, in a skin grating operation Is
dead of pneumonia, which resulted
from the administration Of ether at
the time of the amputation.
Ethel Smith, the girl whose life
was saved by Rugh's sacrifice, was
sent home from the hospital week
ago. She has completely recovered
from the effects Of the terrible burns
received when the engine of a motor
cycle, on which she was riding with
her fiance, exploded and her clothing
caught fire. Skin from Rugh's leg was
grated on her body.
Rugh came to Gary few years ago,
a penniless tramp. He made a liveli'
hood here selling newspapers on the
streets. He had to be trusted with the
first bundle Of papers he vended.
Offers Leg to Save Girl.
One day he read in paper as he
stood on . street corner that Miss
Smith had been taken to hospital so
severely burned that she probably
would die If someone did not come to
her rescue by permitting bits Of skin
to be taken from his body to be graft
ed onto hers. Rugh looked down at
his withered leg.
1T isn't doing me any good" he
said, and started for the hospital.
"Cut my leg of. Doc" he said to the
surgeon attending Miss Smith, "and
use the skin to fix up that poor little
girl"
The surgeon gasped and stood look
Ing at the cripple. Such heroism isn't
common in these days. Rugh had no
hope of a reward. There was to be
none-not as men generally speak of
rewards.
do you realize what such an opera
ton may mean for you?" the doctor
asked.
"sure; but I'm game. I'll take a
chance. Why shouldn't !? Just think
Of that poor little girl there-doomed.
unless some gink comes along who 10
willing to help out"
Leg 10 Amputated.
The withered leg was amputated.
Ethel Smith rapidly recovered. Billy
Rugh lay on his cot fighting for his
life. The ether had so seriously irri.
tated his lungs that he fell an easy
prey to pneumonia.
Ethel Smith came to see him. She
brought him flowers. Once she knelt
at his bedside and, taking one of his
brown hands in both her own, she
kissed him reverently. Then, attend
ants, accustomed as they are to seeing
heartrending scenes, turned away.
That's all right, little girl" said
Billy Rugh, and smiled up at the girl
for whose life he was to give his own.
Don't you worry about me. I'm all
right"
From far and near came presents to
Billy Rugh, money, trinkets, flowers
and messages Of appreciation Of his
heroism.
"This isn't bad world, is it," he
asked the doctor one day as he held a
big bunch Of roses in his hand, which
Chicago woman had sent him.
Folk are folks after all"
Twice-a-week plain dealer. (Cresco, Howard County, Iowa) 1895-1913, 1912-10-22
For Sale I

Duroc Jersey male pigs for sale.
Bred right and priced right. Pedigree
furnished. GEO. S. BARKER,
Z. D. No. 6, Cresco, Iowa.
Twice-a-week plain dealer. (Cresco, Howard County, Iowa) 1895-1913, 1912-10-22
w. c. T. U. Opens Convention.

w. c. T. U. Opens Convention.
Portland, Ore, Oct. Educational
exercises in the cause Of temperance
were held by the Women's Christian
Temperance Union, which is holding
its Thirty-ninth national convention
here.
Twice-a-week plain dealer. (Cresco, Howard County, Iowa) 1895-1913, 1912-10-22

Good Quarter Section for Sale
One of the best improved farms, and
all good land, within one mile Of Cres-
CO. 5tf Myron Converse.
Twice-a-week plain dealer. (Cresco, Howard County, Iowa) 1895-1913, 1912-10-22

There is no testimony against me ex.
cept in the TO rm of hearsav statements
of men who are dead.-Mr. Roosevelt.
Mr.. Morgan. who gave $l5O,O0O, is
not dead. Mr.. Prick, who gave $780,
600, is not dead. Mr.. Gould, who gave
500, 900, is not dead. Mr.. Sheldon,
who has testified to the Morgan, Gould
and Frick contributions, is not dead.
Mr.. Odell, who has testified to the
$l6O, 600 Hartman fund, is not dead.
Dubuque Telegraph.
Twice-a-week plain dealer. (Cresco, Howard County, Iowa) 1895-1913, 1912-10-22

Gov johnson Carefully Guarded.
Chicago, Oct. 19.-Twenty-five 20
licemen escorted Governor Hiram w
Johnson from the Grand Central rail
way station to his hotel.
Twice-a-week plain dealer. (Cresco, Howard County, Iowa) 1895-1913, 1912-10-22
WarshIp Destroyed.

London, Oct. ia Turkish war
ship was reported blown up by a mine
at the entrance to Varna harbor.
Twice-a-week plain dealer. (Cresco, Howard County, Iowa) 1895-1913, 1912-10-22
35o, ooo Blaze In Canada.

$5U,OUO 8Iaze III Cdndod.
Hanley, Sask.s Oct 21.-Fire which
did damage estimated at $4,000 broke
out in the bushes district here, de.
stroying several stores and the post.
office
Twice-a-week plain dealer. (Cresco, Howard County, Iowa) 1895-1913, 1912-10-22
Wanted.

To buy a good gentle horse, weigh
ing from HOO to 1900 lbs.
RALPH CLARK, Cresco.
Twice-a-week plain dealer. (Cresco, Howard County, Iowa) 1895-1913, 1912-10-22
French Aviator Killed.

Bordeaux, Oct. 21.-A French avia
tor, Amedee Lacour. was killed while
giving an exhibition of fancy flying
ut Musician.
Twice-a-week plain dealer. (Cresco, Howard County, Iowa) 1895-1913, 1912-10-22
100000 Baptist Fund.

Minneapolis, Oct. 19.-Baptist state
workers who met at the First Baptist
church unanimously approved the
plan to raise $3,000,00O annually for
home and foreign missionary work.
Twice-a-week plain dealer. (Cresco, Howard County, Iowa) 1895-1913, 1912-10-22

Writing from Waterloo, Boies, now
in his eighty-fifth year. says on the
subject of politics:
Gas far as am concerned the over
shadowing issue in this campaign is
Theodore Roosevelt. To me his sue
cess would mean an immediate danger
to our form of government, for if tie
dag ever comes when one man can fill
the place of president in this republic
sixteen years out out of twenty it will
require but one more step and that a
short one, to make his occupancy a
life tenure, and that day will mark the
downfall of the greatest of all democ-
racies in every country of the globe
and in all the ages of the world"
Twice-a-week plain dealer. (Cresco, Howard County, Iowa) 1895-1913, 1912-10-22
Favor Vote, for weman.

Favor Vote0 yof women.
Milwaukee, Wis.,, Oct. 21.-Every
prospect is that the coming general
election will see Wisconsin vote fol-
suffrage.
Twice-a-week plain dealer. (Cresco, Howard County, Iowa) 1895-1913, 1912-10-22
CRESCO MARKETS
Corrected twice q week. J

''Our great corporations held the
balance of power in the United
States. "-Pinchot.
They did in 1904, when Col. Goose
welt, who appointed Pinchot to the
cabinet, was elected to the presidency.
That year. according to the testimony
of Geo. R. Sheldon, treasurer of the
Roosevelt national committee, they
contributed ISL per cent of his cam
paign fund.
The Leon reporter. (Leon, Iowa) 1887-1930, 1912-02-08

On ground hog day once more we
might make firm resolves to live
Alright. The ground hog is our
boast and our pride, and we should
let him be our guide; our imitation
he deserves, so let us mark his skill
full curves and follow in his shining
tracks and reach the goal or break
our backs. He doesn't shed the
briny tears about the weather all
the year; he let's the climate go it's
way unhindered, save on Grounding
day; then he energies from his lair
to see if things be foul or fair Just
once a year he casts his eyes pro-
phetic on the bending skies, then
weather topics he forgets; he never
walks the floor or frets. We human
chumps, in heat and rime, discuss the
weather all the time; we fool with
goosebones half the day, and when
we put these traps away We study
Foster or Irl Hicks, or almanacs or
fiddlesticks. This waste of time is
most absurd; the grounding is q
wiser bird. Walt Mason.
The Leon reporter. (Leon, Iowa) 1887-1930, 1912-02-08

F.. f. Osborn, who lives on the old
Billy Grogan farm, 8 miles southeast
of Leon, will have a sale on next
Monday, Feb. 18th. He was in Leon
Monday having The Reporter print
sale bills for him, and by an error
the bills were printed to read that
the farm was located northeast of
Leon instead of southeast, and a few
of them had been posted before the
error was discovered. New bills were
at once printed to replace them, and
if any of the first ones are left posted
up you should remember that the
farm is 8 miles southeast of Leon,
3 Y miles southwest of Woodland.
The Leon reporter. (Leon, Iowa) 1887-1930, 1912-02-08

Train service was again demor-
allied last Saturday and Sunday on
account of the snow. On the K. &
w. line the north bound Des Moines
train which left Leon Saturday only
got as far as Van Vert, remaining
there over Sunday. They went to
GAINESVILLE again on Monday. The
evening train from Des Moines Satur-
day was stuck in snow drift at St..
Charles from Saturday until Monday
afternoon. On the Charlton branch
the Saturday afternoon train did not
get to Charlton until 3 o'clock Sun
day morning, and the evening train
due at Leon at 9:02 passed through
here Sunday morning at 3 o'clock.
They had two coaches, four engines
and snow plow. But on Monday
both lines were opened up and trains
were about on time.
The Leon reporter. (Leon, Iowa) 1887-1930, 1912-02-08

CAPT. J. D. Brown and wife enter
tanned Department Commander Lot
Abraham, of the Iowa G. A. R. at
their home in this city over Sunday,
and on Sunday Mrs. Brown served a
big turkey dinner to number of the
old army comrades of her husband.
The old boys ate such dinner as
they never dreamed of during the
days of the war, and the afternoon
was spent in telling "reminiscences of
army days and cracking jokes until
they sounded like volleys of musket-
ry. Capt. and Mrs. Brown are great
entertainers and are never happier
than when they are entertaining some
Of the old army boys.
The Leon reporter. (Leon, Iowa) 1887-1930, 1912-02-08

In our account last week of the
p. f. O. banquet an annoying mis-
take was made, when we said a his
tory of the society was read by Mrs.
J. w. Harvey, when it should have
been Mrs. J. l.. Harvey, who is one
of the best known members Of the
society in the state, and by reason of
song which she dedicated to the
P. E. O.'s and which has been sold
widely, has a reputation among the
members Of the society all over the
country
The Leon reporter. (Leon, Iowa) 1887-1930, 1912-02-08

/ read with great interest those
items taken from the Reporter of
twenty-five years ago, said one of our
subscribers the other day, but why
don't you print more of them. Bless
your soul, dear reader, if you would
come in and take a look at the old
papers of twenty-five years ago you
would not ask such a question, as
there was not much news printed in
the papers of those days, and single
page of The Reporter of today con-
tains more news items than the en-
tire paper did twenty-five years ago.
The Leon reporter. (Leon, Iowa) 1887-1930, 1912-02-08

Mr.. T. J. Hickman. of Corydon,
visited a couple of days in this city
last week at the home of his parents,
Mr.. and Mrs. Kim Hickman. He had
driven over in company with J. w.
Snyder, of near Corydon to look at
a farm which the latter gentleman
was contemplating buying.
The Leon reporter. (Leon, Iowa) 1887-1930, 1912-02-08

| Attorney G. w. Baker went to
Mt. Ayr Monday evening, where he
is assisting in the prosecution of the
case of State VS.. Kelley, the defend
ant being indicted for rape. This is
the case where two of the prominent
attorneys of Mt Ayr and hotel
proprietor were recently indicted for
conspiracy, it being charged they at
tempted to get the prosecuting wit
ness to leave the state and not ap-
pear against Kelley.