Twice-a-week plain dealer. (Cresco, Howard County, Iowa) 1895-1913, 1912-11-01
.CORTE[YOU IS mum
WHY DOESN'T HE TELL WHAT
HE KNOWS CONCERNING THE
ARcHeoLp cHARGES7
LOOKS DARK FOR ROOSEVELT
Assuming the Standard OIL Man Told
the Truth, Al Others Concerned
Are Involved In What Was Ma.
tional Disgrace.

Where is Cortelyou and what has
he to say regarding the Archbold
charges? Alone of the living partici.
pants in that famous deal, he has
kept silent. Yet 1t was to him that
Mr. Bliss reported, and to him that
Roosevelt appealed" In his letters
and telegram. He knows and should
tell whether Archbold has concocted
this story In order to cast discredit
upon Roosevelt and the Progressive
campaign or is reciting facts. His
apparent unwillingness to say any.
thing on this case is certainly an
alarming phase Of the situation. 1t
can be construed In either way, for
or against Roosevelt. Cortelyou's
loyalty to his old friend and patron
may make him reluctant to expose
that friend. On the other hand, he
is now president of the New York
Gas company, brought to New York
by Frank Vanderbilt, president Of the
National City bank, and II he were
minded to dispute Archbold, his new
alliances might give him pause. Yet
IN the very nature Of things he must
speak and give his version Of the dis
pute. Without his testimony or with
It even the affair may not be settled.
Indeed, it bids fair never to be set.
tied. One item remains for Mr.. Arch.
bold to produce and that is Mr.. Bliss's
receipt That certainly ought to be
somewhere in the Standards files.
and II It is not found the failure to
find 1t will be cited as a point in Mr..
Roosevelt's favor. Thus far the col.
onel's denials have lacked substance
and verisimilitude. In the old days
he was lavish with documents and
other material with which to over
whelm his critics. Now he INDUCES
In lurid adjectives. The case looks
dark for him.
But. assuming that Archbold told
the truth, 1t looks almost az dark for
all others concerned. Mr.. Archbold
acknowledges or claims that he gave
the money with the distinct under.
standing that Roosevelt should know
Of 1t, which means that the president
Of the United state6 was thereby to
be put under Obligations to the
Standard Oil company. Quid pro quo.
clearly. Later there was demand for
more and when Archbold hesitated.
Mr.. Bliss feared the Standard people
we're making a mistake"-which
freely translated, meant that unless
they came down again they would
feel the pressure Of governmental dis
favor. In other words. blackmail
And in this Matchmaking were In
volved the president and his adjutants
In the antitrust hunt on the one hand
and Mr.. Archbold and his ramifying
associates on the other.
Dear Mr.. Bliss" was involved, too,
In sense, for he later expressed to
Mr. Archbold his deep regret at the
presidents actions, bewailing his own
failure to influence him. Mr. Cortel-
you is involved too. for he must have
known what was going on, at any
rate during the campaign. There
were thus two parties to the trans
action, the bribe-givers and the BRIDE
takers. All the brige-givers seem per-
fectly at ease in their consciences at
their action. regarding 1t as simply .
phase Of politico-commercial life How
their acts will appear to posterity
and to the world at large may be an
other matter The only justification
for them lies in the fact that they
were approached by the other side
In the beginning. That, Of course, IL
usual, but not invariable. Then, too.
they had courage enough to refuse
to be bled still more. although warned
that they would suffer for 1t. But It
all shows the horrible plight Of poll
tics in this country and is disgrace
to the nation. How the London
dailies and weeklies will exult at
these revelations! How especially
will the Saturday Review rejoice at
a justification of almost every fling
1T has made at American corruption!
Can anything be said in reply? Very
little. We can only construct lila.
bolical plot by Archbold, Penrose, ct
al, to ruin Mr.. Roosevelt and the
Progressive cause. There are very
few things to justify such a theory.
Among these IL the death of Mr..
Bliss and the. fact that his books -