Albuquerque evening herald. [volume] (Albuquerque, New Mexico) 1911-1914, 1912-06-01
RARTH LEADS FIGHT
AGAINST MONEY
APPROP PRIATED
FOR CHARITY
Senate Passes Finance Bill
Practically Unamended De-
spite Vigorous Opposition Of
BernalillO County Member.
MAKES NO PROVISION
FOR MOUNTED POLICE

Especial Telegram 90 EvenlnE IIcrnldl
Santa Sc. y. H., June THE som
ate this morning passed senate bill
No ~. the finance bill. which passed
practically rs introduced with tho
exception Of "a few minor amendments
including some furnishings for the
executive mansion and small ap-
proprlat0n for q printing deficit An
acrimonious debate WAS precipitated
when Mr. Barth attacked appFopria-
tions for charitable institutions in-
emdod In section eleven He raised
the issue Of the separation of church
and state and was severely scored by
Mr. Holt Republican leader. and by
Mr. Ninkic, prominent Democrat
MIR. Hinkle told Mr.. narth that ne
could not commit the Democratic
party 90 any such stand ard he|
said The only thing omitted from tho
finance bill which ought TO be there
was an appropriation 60 establish
kindergarten for would-he siatesinBn.
Mr.. Barth replied that he would go
before the people of ChaVes county
against Mr.. Hnkle on the strength
OF their respective records Ia the leg
isiature.
rhe fight was prccipitn;ed when
MIR. Mubry moved 90 strike out all 81
section wherein Some $50 600 was
appropriated to various urphanageF
and hospitals senator Barth Sec
because this section appropriates
money fpr private and secular lnsu-
tutl0ns He charged that II WIS dam
gerOus in the extreme 90 set such an
example and said that it was an un-
warranted use Of public fundH for
scctarinn schools and hospitals. and a
direct Violation OF the terms OF the
constitution. He Alia; FIS We are
going 90 live in state whore the
church ia separated from the state
We cannot continue 90 appropriate
public funds la this way He then
said hts remarks We're not directed
AZ auy particular sect Mr. Mnhfi
said that he supported the conautu-
fiOnt but that hc waa nos proaa pl
tht fact l7e said aarfituiaf atrfiun
of the constitution had been pointed
out go him as permitting Legislature
20 make such appropriations. McNoy
said ID wHs the only thing ne found
that was wrong with the constitution
Mr. Holt then read the provisions oi
the constitution which llmits Hppfo-
prlntiOns OF that kind strictly to ap-
prOpflatious, made ln compliance with
the act of 1909. Mr.. Holt then ana
ipxcd she situation. He said he was
much surprised that ana member
would arise on the floor 81 the sen
ate and publicly oppose AppFbpfn.
tions for such purposos. he salu
anyone knowing conditions I'm the
state could not consistently oppose
that section, he said that poor or,
phan children must be cared Tor ana
hc said that anyone Ia doubt aa Ia
che necessity FOR these appropriations
ought 10 60 60 the saniteriura la san
Ia he and soc i2S orphan girls VINO
are being cared for as though ny
their own mothers Ana then' nc
said, they should 20 from .h"t .ld ori
and see tho pitiful cases that arc
being cared for purely out Of charity
and without hope of reward ~ an,
manner Mr. Hollis speech was quite
lengthy. and az ite conclusion Senator
Uinkic took the floor ana denounced
the pnrth- MRbry combination and
praised the noble work Of she SIS
tcrs of Charity He said iinfth hnu
Mabrs could moi commit the Demo
cratic pariv 90 any such a stand. ht
said they might think tnht iheN Mst'
the Democratic party, bat he siiid bt,
fore thoy got done thep would I'm"
uui they were not
"AiI President" he said. Ito ms
way of thinking there has necn unll
one thing left out of TINS hlu en-
that is an appropriation Tor the hih'
dorHarton Tor some ot our Wouia-"'
staieamcn'
With this PARTING shot he sat down
Senator Mabry declared That hpN
and Hlnklo had placed mmHelt hnt
Mr. Hafth in the wrong light h'
Mr HELD in "a few words, pfaise'
the Chlidr0n's Home society and shlt
ht was sorry that under tAe tefhl
og the constitution no nppi0lfitN"
could be made for S. iarth thgl
charged "narth- -hBlting. iie mHu'
am attack an the Chlldren's Homo go
ciety. charging that the head ~ thh
tnntttutiOn had refused tu make hi
accounting for five thousand dollar
Appropriated In 1909, ana sald INA pa.
the press had charged lhAi thtft ~
only six children In the rnteiNinl
home IA any time. He explained hl
position in opposing section III an
wound up hy telling senator hink
that he wac ready 90 go before ~
real Democrats 81 ChaNes count9 o
their records as shown hy the sen
ate journal The bin passed, ~ =
o. AldridEe. Evans, MphrN Mc'v
and KAmpf0 voting no. Mr.. Nnmer
asked tn have tho biil amended I
include the insurance department
other amendments proposed hy Az
Hurth were: Bureau ~ immiHrhu9t
mounted police. assistant 90 th
trnvelinr auditor and "a strike ot
the $4,000 for the corporation com
other bills passed by the senai
we're H 81 lSa. governing commvr
ltyaceuulaf, senate substitute 20
hi. n. llg 90 regulate procedure
capital eases senate bill ISL
stringent ihcl law
The senate b. meeting this hiiei
noon,
Tllc HOUSE.
The houae met and adjourned UNI
Monday. Tholc WAS apparent cphi'
sion among the members ana
though the house had Two speViHi 9'
ders. helms the drainage bills, th'
were unased over uutil next week
uftECr ELECTION
non /. =. SIN NTOil
House blu so. AZ hy Mr Carte
which provides for an absolute dlfe'
preference vote for United states ~
afore bl the peuple Of tho new stat
was paascd ln the house hy N"
of 3t Ga 3.