The Caldwell tribune. [volume] (Caldwell, Idaho Territory [Idaho]) 1883-1928, 1912-05-10
President Mel ormick Makes a
Reply to Charges.
Ne DEFENDS THE ORGANIZATION
Statement Issued In Connection with
the Governments Suit to Dis
solve International Har.
vester Company.

suit in the federal court at st. Paul,
Mimi, April 30. against the Interna.
tional Harvester company, alleging
violation Of the Sherman law and max
ing the general charges that are Gus.
tomary in bill of this kind. and ask.
ing for whatever reliefs are consid.
cred necessary by the court. The bill
is very long one and therefore can
not be reproduced. but it sets forth,
In effect, that the Harvester company
is a monopoly in restraint Of trade,
has used oppressive methods in fore
ing it's agents to handle its goods ex-
clusively, etc. To these charges Pres
ident Mccormick has made the fol.
lowing reply:
"The International Harvester case
differs radically in its facts from all
the so-called trust cases heretofore
decided under the Sherman law. The
International Harvester company was
organized in 1902 for the purpose of
securing economy in the manufacture
and sale Of harvesting machinery, and
Of increasing the foreign trade. It
had no water in its capitalization, and
1t has earned only a reasonable return
on it's capital,-less than z per cent
per annum on the average. The prices
OF it's machines are now substantially
the same as IN 1902, Notwithstanding
an increase of Is per cent in raw ma
terial prices and 30 per cent in wages.
The company has caused a large saw
ing to American farmers in the cost
Of agricultural Implements. It has in
creased the foreign trade in agricul-
tural implements four-fold in nine
years; its foreign sales in 1911 were
over $42,000,000. It has not sold cheap
or abroad than at home. It's treatment
Of it's customers, it's employees, its
agents and it's competitors has been
in accord with the highest standard
Of ethics and honorable business meth
DDS. To the farmers it has given bet,
ter service and better machines; to
agents and dealers, less hazardous
and fluctuating business and to it's en-
ployes it has given higher wages, i'm.
proved and sanitary working condi.
tons. insurance against sickness, &C
cident and old age. and share in the
profits.
1.-THE charges Of misconduct found
In the bill have been met and dis
proved by the company in other cases;
and they will again fail, because they
are untrue. The supreme court of
Missouri. in a suit in which those
charges were fully gone into. said:
ION the whole, the evidence shows
that the International Harvester COM
pany has not used its power to Cypress
or injure the farmers who are its GUS
TONER'S"
"And again:
"The price Of harvesting machines
has not increased in proportion to the
increased cost Of construction or the
increased merit Of the machines, and
respondent has brought other farm i'm
plements into trade"
1.-THE evidence also shows that the
machines manufactured by the Inter-
national Harvester company have been
greatly improved In quality and the
Item OF repair material has been re-
duced in price and placed within closer
reach OF the farmer
1.-THE organizers Of this company
acted under the advice Of able counsel.
and In the sincere belief that they
were violating no law. II under later
decisions 1t should be held that the
law was violated, II could only be
through the creation Of q power to op-
press which has never been exercised.
More than six years ago the COM
pany asked for it, investigation by the
United States government. and opened
al Its books and records for inspec-
uon' and furnished all information re-
euested. No suggestion OF any change
IN Its business methods has been made
20 1t by the government at any time.
recently. q full and frank discussion
OF the whole situation has been had
between the representative Of the gov
ernment and the company. In an hon
est desire upon both sides to avoid
nugation. Some plan may yet be
FOUND which will obviate the necessity
VI any protracted litigation by salts
lying the claims made under the sher-
man act without ssriously impairing
the economic advantages and benefits
secured by the organization Of this
company, No form OF reorganizat ton,
however. was suggested BY the govern
Eble. $500
Inc government has been careful
avoid embarrassment to the foreign
Oas,ness from the litigation; the bill
makes no attack upon. and seeks no
snanss In. the export business Of the
,V0mpany. The Ming Of the bill win
~ no way iAtsrfsrs With the companys
eTrylng On ~ hsnnA~au~ ~ ~arnn -