Tulsa daily world. [volume] (Tulsa, Indian Territory [Okla.]) 1905-1919, 1912-02-21
NOT A QUESTION
FOR JUDICIARY
sUFEENE COURTS DECi-loN ON
INITIATyE fND RII1H-
TNDUM 80 -IEIKI-I
SANE MATTER IN OKLAHOMA
Judse T.. J. HlmCr. ON --prme
Benrli Befofe statehood. Had o.
Pa. on Identical I4cts


The Supreme -r .t tas -rta4
-stes o1 Io1c-y ...-sl -t-t tas
provision lr trs Oregon .sLa.t t.t..l
llf me .rllsf4ts nd referee -la s.as
s political question and -.t a .-l..'al
ers and therefor. t-. case moving
tte validity = t-a r.ta ..-s--lt.. .1a-
provision vac r.s. .asal on tt=
ground htt me F11leYe court bad
ro jurisdiction ,a dasrrIue tnst
g- ssuoa. The ssr. Question vas bee
fore -he slpreus court - Oklahoma
40 tfe Jun. Term ~ lrl- untn the
t-s same ouerir- arose go The eals
g Frartz arairst t.-rF. .s Jk. g-r
Ir frl. case D s..s f.g.rt tH prevent
th+ admission n The Territory n
Oklahoma sa-9 ne ur.ar on the
pro Ind -hst -ra Oklahoma e1rs..t8-
zion rrsussd f-- me Initiative and
fsfarerc and r. was rrrf-1led
iha' is Vas '' ~ iir con-
-.A ~ ine ra rs -e
'..fi I'D me case was
"i-'el ana h- -.th lF --
Gaze SO ii--H"F- sl-As
-i-.he' ID Gle s- i---s A--.,-N'
h1
D-' one t-t'- remains anu
ihat 4f H n. Ii1i'--- --l-s.-' u
'.-n i+D---4,1t -A i''''
se .- me r'''' -
-.l '- me ~- Ha Ii'''-
I--l-
-As 1Llle9 s-@.'s si---- s-a' az
~ "'eiF f--le DO l's --
mean 1o'H. 9l
ana ss-iloh y ---~ A--- AK
pro1loes mar
no --1N
can ID iofin' abi i-=f+ 10
u t'''l OF pol''--a' '-s"-' I'D
u ia-s " 'o4o' --- f1-- --
pIEAaA' 70 we --r
hIie9 Hla'es sD1 ln7 Pm - -
me DeeiaTaiioh u 4hoeI'i 'e''-s'
Who Shall Decide?
This leads IL 70 the INQUIRY IN
whom ia lodged the u0wer and ay-
thoritv TO decide when the go.err-
rpsn, is rerlihllcsu in form
In ,hs e.ase of luther ~ Borden.
How, ~. the supreme court Of the
United States suesking by Chief Jus-
tfre Taney saws.
The fourth section of the fourth
article ~ he constitution ~ The Init
Cd states proyideg that the United
s,.tes shall guarantee 10 every state
I'm the un,on republican form o,
s,,e,,,,er, and sbau nro-ec, each
a. ,bcro sgsfnst invasion. and on the
a,,I,cs,ion n, the legislature or Of
.bs ovec,t,,e 6when ,ba legislature
.cs,,o, he co,venaa, ag,,nst donYes-
&, ,io,eroa
.r.nder ,bis article ~ the cons,itu-
IT. 4, 20 ,.i,b co,grsss n decida
,,ha. .o,..-rrn.,,t "a The established
aaa q, go For as the 1-nitas
c.. ,,aas 20 o.cb stat. re.
r,nhi,co, vov.-nrrent congress must
,,,oo.s,-,,,, d.ciAa What govornp,ehnt
q os,ahl,s.d f., Tho s,ste bsrore {, can
.d.,orr,,no ,,ta,bor 4, Ga renpblLoan ar
No, And ,yhen The senators and rem.
rasa,,,,i,.os ~ state are admitted
mt ,ha corro,Is ~ tho I-nion the
an,hor,ty ~ ,be govarnmant under
wbLcb ,bov are annolnted as wen az
,,s ra,nhiic,r character ,s racogniz-
"a by ,bo nronar Constitutional an.
,bort,y Ana r.. deolsion ia binding
~, a,.r,, otber denar,,,er, n, he gov
..,,,,o,t ana corld not he o,estionad
,r t,dicisl tribunal"
Ard T., -r.,ag "a white wau -sn
,,,. ,,,rror,o co,,r, ~ tho r-ni,ed
CO.. "a o,o.sl,.,, 20 roi,ora,o tbio
...,,,. d,,.ri,o ,,.baro T., is e,id.
"p,, ,bo rower to csrry into ef.
TO-, tho clsrse ~ e,,rartv ,s nrI-
,,,.,tr,. legislative mover ana r.sides
r., co,,rass Under tho fourtb ar,l-
.,Io ~, ~. ..orstitu,lor and rey,s ,pitb
,l,,.r,ss 80 d..ide vba, ,o,.rp,o.p,
60 "a. .sta,,Iisnod ono I'm state For
80 ~. t,i,cd states guarantees N
..., CO.. ron,,t,Ii.a,, ,,o,.o-,,,,o,,,
.,o,,,ross ,,,st necessar,lv doc,da
,,.b,, so,.err,,on, is established In
IN. s,s,o bofora II can determine
whether II is ranthIJoan or mot,
4, Inobling SO, Provision
p,. sac,lor ,our ~ the enabling act