New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1912-06-20

American people he will cease TO in'erle'
with the delivery Of reasonable ana az
cent argument
we will have order n this convention or
the members responsible for disorder WI
suffer in the estimation Of the American
people" he added. and he was Loudly
cheered.
Then in the midst Of new tumult RUM
climbed on q chair and demanded recogni-
ton.
A point Of order he shouted
state It" commanded Chairman Root.
II is that the mention Of personaiitieS
Of Penrose and Finn is not IN order
The gentiemens point is not well taken
The gentleman will be seated AZ once
ruled Root
Flinn stood daharflv FOR minute, but
then sat down
Record Heard for RooseVeltItes
Nv Hsmenvav soon ended after this. ana
vas followed b. George L Record OF Ne"
Jersey. for the Roosevelt side ot the srgu'
ment. dealing with the Arizona ana Indiana
cases. which he had aided the Roosevelt;
forces in presenting before the nauonai
committee.
4 double convention vas held IN Arizona
Mr. Record said In Cochise and Maricopa
countie, the Taft men had been IN the mi
nority, and had then selected their own
delegates 20 the state convention. The rec
ignition ~ theFe contesting delegates, he
said gave the Taft forces control Of the
convention.
Mr. Record declared The Roosevelt sorce5
vsra willing 20 submit their cases ~ me
decision Of credentials committee u all
contested delegates both Taft and Roose-
Welt men. we're excluded from To'irG on me
reports Of that committee.
The great crowds in the galleries became
restless during Mr.. Records argument "
was luncheon time. and as the proceedings
had been exceedingly tame many NJ the
SPECTATORS we're leaving the building Sena
tor Root appealed again End again Tor
quiet.
Governor McCiovern NJ Wisconsin saio the
call Of the luncheon appealed TO him ana
he moved a recess until p m.
No. No" cried hundreds Of voices and
the motion was not put
II YOU recognize the night 81 commit
tee 10 pass on the right OF state delegates
~ sit IN q national convention resumed
Mr. Record. when order was restored, you
have established government by minority
You are submitting to a partial and packed
tribunal cases where tho verdict is reached
before the evidence ~ submitted
An outbreak in the Indiana delegation FOL.
lowed the assertion Of Mr.. Record thai IN
one district in Indianapolis tho returns were
made IN by the officials without oven open.
Ing the ballot box.
William = English. delegate from the
Eth District. leaped 20 his feet and III" en-.
tire delegation broke into an uproar.
Indiana Men in a Row.
.rbere was no contest IN that district
shouted English WILDLY, waving his hsiS IN
tho air you know there was no contest
there"
william Holton Dye Roosevelt man IN
tho Indiana delegation. sprauE To- MS t""'
and shouted AZ English.
The latter yelled back Liar, liar liar.
and started toward Dvo, but other mem
hers seized the two men aud kept them
dpar;
In nll Mayor shank. 81 Indianapolis
shou,ed from his seat to- Record on tho
stage. "If YOU keep on youll get scrai
out Of me
So much disorder had occurred In the gal
leries that Chairman Root ordered re-
c.ss until all who desired to do 50 could
leave the building
The delay totallcd hftcen minutes and
then Mr.. Record resumed his argument at
lacking the right Of the contested men on
tho Indiana delegation 10 SIT in the conyen-
ton In conclusion ne said the party was
facing the greatest crisis in it, history.
we don't want to he driven out of the
marty either by force or conscience he
said and added But II We are to permit
an outside body to pack this cQgvention
and 10 carry that packing through to
Presidential nomination. the conscience oi
the American people viii revolt
LAUGHTER Relieves Strain.
Robert f. Morris. Of Arizona, then spoke
en- defence Of the Taft delegates from that
state His description CT the row MADE
nv the Roosevelt forces In tn" Arizona STATE
a,,,,.ortion caused much merriment. lie
soId the Roosevelt men at the end ol the
convention marched out OF the nan.
"Rolted." called a voice from the noo'.
"yes and we remained and passed every
parliamentary move that was necessary
An that remained was parliamentary prac'
,ice " he cried. amid renewed laughter
Tho next sneaker was Thomas II. Devine
-, colorado a member of the Taft forces
and slated for chairman Of the committee
On credentials. He sat in the sessions OF
the Republican National committee Dr. wv
representative of Colorado.
Mr. Devine declared the fourteen mem
hor, ~ the committee had listened to
Leir matters voices and signed STATE
n, the contents Of which they did not
nnou lie said Governor IGadley had too
hin, ne expected to SAY something "'C,
about the national committee ai'''
seated his Missouri delegation
"put II seems To have been one OF those
Missouri gcntemen's agreements ~ !.
added which he stands for only ""'" II
is TO his own interest
John u. MacKay, Tart deIeea'e-a'
large from Michigan, asserted 'ha' w.,
Roosevelt men were neither open hoI ia''
minded i'm their consideration OF tiie coi'
tests, He told Of the bolt OF the Noose'
Welt men from the Wayne County cohNeh'
lion. and defended the regularity OF 'he
Michigan delegates at-iarge contes'eu ny
the Roosevelt forces.
Mr.. MacKay declared II the Republican
party was still an adherent OF the square
deal no question could he raised as 10 th'
right of the Taft delegates-at-large TO 81
In the convention
NJ. l.. Calvin, Of Kentucky spoke III be-
half OF the contested Telegates from ths'
state. asserting that the contests were
trumpet up for some Interior purpose
A round OF applause greeted James L
Watson. who concluded the argument
against the Hadley motion From the gal-
lery came shout OF "Hooray for Sunny
Jim"