New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1912-09-07
NDFF TO CALL WALDO
AND GAYNOR EARLY
u.ves Case Seems to Require
riyina Responsibility for
Orders to Inspectors.
wuITMAN'S NEW EVIDENCE
salvation Army Lassie and Up
state Elk Saw Murder of
Rosenthal-More Facts
for Becker Trial.

mstice Gor decided last night. largely
N.csusc of the Developments of the police
-, If Captain Hayes, that both Com
-,,doner Waldo and Mayor Gaynor
,.,1 be among the first witnesses called
,,.,-e the John Doe" inquiry.
r,om the trend Of Hayess testimony IT
4. ,ow assured that the denoted inspector
GILL testify before Justice Goff in those
r-OOeedings that the responsibility for the
o,ss condition of the town rests with Com
..,..ioner Waldo because of his orders as
- gambling and disorderly houses and ii
=. sxpected that other inspectors when
,,fiAd as TO why they permitted similar
additions in their districts will get from
wdsr IN the same way.
Rack OF that. it is believed. lies the re-
,OonsiSility Of the Mayor for the condi-
lions because Of his Instructions to his
psNce Commissioner along the lines OF
NJ. "outward dccency" and personal lib
srtv" IDEAS. and il is now proposed 10
have Mayor Gaynor explain 10 the ex-
t,ordinary grand jury just what he
nsapt BY those instructions and just why
h, stuck TO that programme in the face
At the fact that gambling and vice were
oOsratlng almost openly.
district Attorney Whitman said last
rsht that he did not believe he would at
,.D5 am Of the sessions of the Hayes
rial al Police Headquarters. He believes
that TIE proceedings against Hayes in the
s.partment were vitiated before they re-
umsd yesterday by the previous rein
r,iement. and both on that ground and
n the ground that First Deputy Commits
sioner Mckay was allowed to preside at
The trial in the face of the fact that he
vas 10 he called as a witness for the
defence. the District Attorney is con-
ylneed that no police penalty inflicted on
Hates will hold in the courts.
Mr. Whitman is Of the opinion that Mr..
Mckay should not have presided at the
trial so long as there was the slightest
suggestion from the defence that he was
10 be called as 2 witness.
TIE District Attorney will have talk
today with the Salvation Army girl who
turned up on Thursday as one of the eye
Witnesses Of the Rosenthal murder He
does not intend to allow her name to be-
come public until he produces her az
witness In the Becker trial, but he learned
yesterday that her evidence viii corrono-
rate in every point the story told by
Ciovsnni Stanich. who was able to iden-
tfy each Of the four murderers.
Il is b. the mouths OF these two Wit
nsssss that Mr. Whitman expects to re-
flie the rumored story that the defence
vii advance testimony purporung TO at
tribute the actual shooting OF Rosenthal
10 Harry Valnsky. The Salvation Army
gih and stanich can each OF them Identify
poatlvsly the four gunner Of the murder.
District Attorney Whitman admitted
last night, In answer TO questions as TO
his case against Becker, that he had not
made public and would not until the trial
a mass Of evidence duplicating Becker
which will come from other sources than
the quartet now in the West Side prison
Robe. Weber. Vslinsky end Schepps.
Dora Gilbert. the first wife of Herman
Rosenthal, will be witness for the state
IN the Becker trial. and will. it IS said.
deny the substance Of the AFFIDAVIT pro-
cured from her q few hours before the
murder By Jack" Rose. In a talk with
Assis XE9tQT-
day she said that the affidavit was
brought TO her house on that night just
preceding the murder already made out,
and she signed it without knowing its
contents.
Assistant District Attorney Goldman
wired Mr.. Whitman from Troy yesterday
mat he had found another eyewitness 10
'he murder. This man, an Elk, was VS.
Ting at the Elks Clubhouse on July 10
and is. and saw the four murderers SO
closely that he has satisfied Mr.. Goldman
nat he can Identify them.
ar. Whitman heard from Governor DIX
Yesterday 10 the effect that another ex-
rsordinsry term of the Supreme Court
mad been ordered, with Justice GoH desig-
mated This will carry with IT an extra
ordinary grand jury, which will be con-
'sned October I, and the John Doe" pro-
ossdings will therefore be postponed I'M
u after the Becker trial.
lie District Attorney conferred yester-
Jay afternoon with Allan Robinson, OF the
Citizens Committee; Alderman Henry IA.
Oaran. chairman Of the aldernanic IN
Jury; Robert S. Binkerd, secretary OF the
SlV Club and acting secretary OF the
Vluzens' Committee; Joseph p. Cotton
w. counsel TO the same. and Emory X.
Sackner counsel TO the aldermanic COM
nittee.
The District Attorney had a short talk
Hse night with Arthur Reed. the prison
preacher, who. through Jack" Rose, put
nm On the track OF the Salvation Army
s'l Who was an eyewitness Of the muir
ssr' Mr.. Reed lives at NO. 800 West 9th
street. and he came TO assure Mr.. Whit
"&n mat the stories circulated yesterday
a.Isrnoon TO the effect that he had been
Vnered 300 TO keep the young woman
".uless away from town were false. He
,a The District Attorney that II any
N o. any. kind should be offered to
'a ne would lose no time in putting the
's''sr before the proper authorities.
''ehographic reports OF the proceedings
'he Curran sldermanic committee were
S"'aeted for yesterday by the alder
,en' the bid OF the State Law Reporting
"sshcy winning the Job.
WIPE SAYS HE WON'T RETURN.
rfeeton. Eng Sent 6-ThoTnas Cnune