davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
Tombstone epitaph., 1912-04-28
Newsy Items
From Pearce

Pearce, Ariz., April g, 1912.
 A baseball game was played in Pearce Saturday afternoon between Light and Pesrce the former winning by score of 10 5.
 A very enjoyable social dsnce was had at Huddy Hall Saturday night and all who attended report 8 good time. The Monmonier Orchestra of five pieces furnished the music.
 Misses Josephine McPherson and Nsthsbiel Larson and Walter Mel. gren of Tombstone attended the dance here Saturday night.
 Sheriff Harry Wheeler of Tomb stone was among the Pesrce visitors Saturday.
 Editor Kemp oi the Wilcox Range News was i3 town Friday having been over to see the cattle roundup st the Hudson ranch.
 A band of Apsches from the San Carlos reservation, whc are employed in railroad camp betw en Courtland and Pearce got hold of quantity of 6rewater yesterday vert on the war- path and made things lively for while. There were bloody noses, {, bruised faces. perhaps broken bones and for time it appeared that the result would be serious. A hurry call was cent to tie sheriff's office in Tombstone. Sheriff Wheeler and Deputies powe and ksfferty arrived on the scene and the fgh, qnieted down, and later the redskins pescably went into their camp on the railroad !.
 The officers have information where the Indians secured their liquor and I arrests are expected to follow.
Tombstone epitaph., 1912-04-28
TUE sDAY
HOUSE

T. com rittee o! the whole, John son's bill prohibiting 'rus,s was rec- commended for passage
 New bills introduced.
 By Graham-Relsting to sinking artesian wells in the Sulphur Spring Valley.
 By Linney-To smeud revised statutes, relating to construction |, maIntsinance and improve mems on public highways.
 By Jones-By request; to amend revised statutes iD reference to stste- wide prohibition and county options including incorporated cities.
 By Bfooks-A constitutional man date bill relating to public 'aLds O. al! sorts owned hy the .tate.
 By Johnson-|onserving the pub lie health and providing for the 'um- iestion of all second hand furniture before its being offered for sale
 By Barker-Detaching a portion of Gil4 county and anuexing # to Pinal oouuty.
 By Wesse!-To pension school teachers of over a5 year's service.
 4 resolution introduced by Lewis extending an invitation 10 Kate Ber- nard, state commissioner of charities, 70 address ,he bouse. was unanimous lv ainnfed
Tombstone epitaph., 1912-04-28
From Tuesdays Daily

JF JacauemsD, CP Moore and Dr R D Herend,ne of r,sbee are m the city ss witnesses b fore the grand jury
 Attorney W B Cleary, the pioneer Arizona advocate of popular rights doctrine, is ID the city on business be- fore the conrt
 Officers Bailey, Brooks and McRae Of Lowell aid Bisbee are in the city AZ witnesses before the grand jury.
 Eugene Gilpin and Richard Toye of Lowell are court attendants today ] Louis Bostwick is in the ci from 1 Bisbee.
 " E King of Bisbee is over from the copper camp on court duty. Lawrence P:coleiti, prominent business man of Tucson arrived in Tomhstone last evening on 6 several day'- visit.
 40 Weill of Mexico City is visi- tor in Tombstone today on business. Mi.s Emma Scranton returned to- day from days visit with friends at Fairbanks.
 J 5 Pope of Douglas sas among the county sest arrivals on the noon train on co1rt business.
 Eugene Grey of Bis bee is in Tomb stcne this week on court busioess.
 RM Davis of of Denver is among the con mercIal men in Tombstone today.
 Mrs B Grace and little daughter returned home today from few tay's visit ~itt friends in Bisbee and Doug las.
 Si Bryant vas an outgoing pas -enger for Braw ey, Gel. today, where he hss large property interests.
 Lee sugish and Lewis Radovich were among the arrivals from B.sbee.
 Frank Malinor IS noted among the court visitors from Bisbee.
 Ds'e Graham, one of the Bisbee pio- neers i. in he ci'y today.
 Eugene Cs-o is in attendance on court today from Bishee
 The Male Chorus of the Congregs- tional church, will meet for practice thi. evening at 7:30 o'clock.
Tombstone epitaph., 1912-04-28
Doings In the
 Legislature

Undaunted by the fate O. his "di- vorce- -me-quick" bill, Senator Lovin l iuttoduceds measure which, if passed will make Arizona a competitor of New Mexico for prize-fghts, which would be permitted up to 25 rounds.
 Senator Chase withdrew former bill introduced by him in reference to prOvid ng for the protection of game and licensiDg of hunters, and intro- duced a new bill covering the same subject
 Senator Lovin also iDtr6 duced a bill providing fer proper respect to the national flag and prohibiting its use for advertising purposes and one mak. ing it crime for any one to directly CT indirectly aid ID the com mission oi an offense.
 Wood Of Yavapai introduced bill to provide for the assessment of pro peIty and collection Of taxes thereon iu ihe coun y in which the property ie located. where such property hss been omitted from he tax roll
 Lewis bill relating to electric light plants and the hours of labor for ems pioyes thereon, was passed with B sftirr ative votes.
 To the committee of ihe whole, with Kane iu the chsi.. Linney's bill to amend Ihe revised statutes relating O civil procedure was recomm ended fsvorsbly.
 kane's desert land bill in relation to the adoption of the Carey act for the develop ent of land along tine Col- orado river, passed.
 The Hunt county measure is in the hands of the committee. It ie be- believed the bill will be killed.
Tombstone epitaph., 1912-04-28
nd attach it to Pinal county.

nd attach 1t to Final county.
 By Jones, an act to create Orange county. and defining it's metes and bounds. with provisions az to its or. gspizstion
 By Graham providing for a state inr spec:or of scales. weights and meas ures. The United States standard seal are sdorted as the standard for the state, and in cities of less than 5oOo population the stste inspector has full and complete control Cities of 5000 or more have the privilege of selecting their own inspector. who shsl' serve for one year, the s'ste in- spector's term Of office being fixed at two years. Its provisions extend t all classes of produce and to alectnc light, gsss and water plnnts.
 By Saxon. amending present lave in reference to the collection Of delin- quent taxes.
 By Irvine, providing for control of all school and university lands; also one relating to domestic relations, providing for slimony.
 By Barker. by request, amending the revised ststutes relating to the qualification of electors and tho chal- longing of voters
 Lynch's bil, providing for the edu- cation of the deal and dumb, and an appropriation of 8 900 or thnt pnr- pose, recommended for passage.
 (Continued on pape thrrei
Tombstone epitaph., 1912-04-28
Marriage Of
 Popular Couple

Another Tombstone romance cul minated in happy wedlock today when John E Pope, popular and well known Dougias citizen wooed and won the heart and hand of Mis-. Vora Johnson, one Of Tombs.one'e fairest daugbt rs.
 Rev Deck of the Congrega'ional church pronounced the words 'h-t united them as one, just ss the gray dawn announced the coming of day, the event also signaling the lsunch- ing o! . happy twain on life of mat rimonial bliss. IL was Cupid's way the couple had planned to outwit their irieuds and the early morning wedding was performed. a delightful ~edding breakfast served and an auto in w-iting speeded the bridal party to Fairbabk; all before 6 a. m
 The groom is an engineer on the E :. P. & 8. w., whose popu arity is co-ex- tensive with the host of friends who know him. The bride is daughter of MT sud Mrs Sam Johnson of this city is 6 charming young iady, an accomplished pianist and general fav- orite with sli.
 The newly eds ill make their  home Q, Douglas and they take with them the best wishes ard hearty con- grstuiaticne of numerOue friends.
 With Cupid ct the pilot, may the clearance ever give the happy couple right of wsy run on the main line ol lifs's hsppiness. is the wish of the PRosPEcToR.
Tombstone epitaph., 1912-04-28
News From the
 Cochise Stronghold

Cochise Stronghold. April B, 1912
 Mir Sperling has re turned to his homestead from several months visit in Kansas City aud wss glad to return. Mir Sperlins says that ha would not trade his homestead here for the best farm Tn Missouri.
 Chief Deputy Assessor Harry Ross spent Sunday over in this dis. trict on his annual assessing tour NIT Ross took up piece of orchard land in the Stronghold canyon Mon- day, and in ends 10 improve the same mmedistely. His family will spend the summer months this year here.
 President Jones Of the Stronghold Telephone company states that new line will be in operation within sixty dsys. Twelve telephones have been contracted for and before the line is completed, it is expected there ~ill te more than tweuy phones on this line, which will connect ~i'h the long distance line at Pesrce
 Petitions are being prepared Tor q new county road from the furee, re- serve line in tbe Stronghold canyon running on a section line east to the schocl house. Those owning lands along the new highway are planting shade trees along the entire stretch Of the new road which will be known as the Stronghold Boulevard.
 A meeting house is being planned fer the district and about s5O0 hss been subscribed toward the building Of same. The house is to be open free to all church services. Sunday school and other neighborhood doipgs.
 This d'strict ~ill De enjoying good singing 90 Jn. A male guar cite and 6 mixed double q :artette will soon be delightiuliy entertaining our people ct tbeir sccIals apd entertain me n,s.
 On Sunday. May 5, there will be picnic in the picturesque Stronghold Canyon and good time is sotici- psted.
 A Young Men's Club is being or panized with oyer twenty members. Tha first official meeting of the club will be held next Monday evening at the school house.
 Deputy Sheriff Gatliff Of Pearce has f led on l60 acres in this distric. and will start improving came tbis week,
 The round-up of the Three c and Coronado Cattle companies was at | Noonan's Saturday night and Sunday night at the Stronghold, and from here it moved to the Sulphur Spring.
 The farmers of the Sulphur Spring Valley are now busily engaged in planting their spring crops, and in- dicstioDs are that the largest acreage in the agricultural history Of the vsl- ley will be put in. he two Iredom- insting crops in the section this yesr will be milo maize and sorghum cane {. alt nough quite good acreage of beans will be put in. A conservative estimate gives the probable numher of acres to be planted this year ss twice tbkt Of last
Tombstone epitaph., 1912-04-28
Cochise Senator
 Makes Brief Visit

State Senator W ? Sims and wife of Bisbee are in the county seat today on court business having arrived last evening, Senator Sims is one of the leaders in the upper house and has been prominent in advocacy of pro- gre-sive measures called for by the ccns itut.on. The senator is ierninst the woman suffrage bill ard teiore leaving on hIs trip here paired his vote with Senator Worsley an advo- cate oi the measure.
Tombstone epitaph., 1912-04-28

Kate Berntr I'd, 6 member of rh . Oklahoma stste board of charities and correcties. and q ..enber Of the Americas Prison Reform association is spending few weeks iu Florence : She addressed the inms'es oi the peDi. tentiary there, delivering . lee ure which ~as greatly appreciated by the prisoueys,
Tombstone epitaph., 1912-04-28

The fire department of Miami has received new hose reel, wound upon thoroughly up tc date hose cart. Six bundred feet of hose are wound about the spindle, enough added to the present equipment to make the fire protection complete,
Tombstone epitaph., 1912-04-28

Several hundred cases against the santa Fe Rsilsosd company for sl- ieged violations Of the eighteen hour 'a~ gre sef for rriai st Phoenix. be- ginning May l2 If the rsilroad should b~ found eui' y on all of tbs counts the government could collect nearly . million dollsr- in fines. The United States attorney thinks the tr,sf of these cases may occupy the at teptiou of the court for . month.
Tombstone epitaph., 1912-04-28
0oings ia the
 Superior Court

Sup0ttVi VOuts
 Cour, opened this morning and | roll call showed 6 number absent and excused. The Sherff's return was made as follows:
 Floyd Wilson Thomas Donovan Mike HanDon William E Stark | Jos Schwertner Bk Riggs Vim K Shsdley J H Warren Mark Whitaker CM Moss John Imslsnd Carl l. Smith Willis Dye Owen Williams E . Stodgili W K Robinson K V Seaver CAP Brown Albert W Cot. rell H NJ Woods
 Ollie Sin pson
 Joe Schwertner and "A r Brown, grand jurors, were excused.
 Aspecisl venire ol seven was order ed issued Ieturnsble at once to com plete the panel snd the sherff made return as follows: A l Schuster sam Morgan Harry Berkowiis Sine, ,Gailen E Hsttich Chas Batchelder Joe Knox
 The grand jury was organized at 10 80 with c F Mos- of Benson az foreman and the jurors retired A, once to begin the work teiOre them.
 The case of Harris vs Hsrris for divorce was tried and decree issued to pls ntitf. The case oi Williams vs Coihurn. testimony was heard aud judgment entered for the defendant.
 The case of Outer V. Williams Nss ses for Ma 6.
 Amorg the two hundred and scme odd cases now pending trial on the civil docket, the iollO%ing figures have been compiled showing the total nnmbeI of each class Of litigation to heard:
Tombstone epitaph., 1912-04-28
SENATE

Under a senate rule adopted severa days ago, this is the las, day allowed for the introduction Of bills, except by committees, and the following were introduced:
 By Wood of Ysvapsi- Relating to public service corporations, providing for their regulation and fixing penal ties for violation of the same. the b Il having an emergency clause attached.
 By Worsley-Relsting to qualifca- tion of electors and to voting aud challenging at elections. By Worsley-Providing for the i'm provemeDt of public lanes, alleys and co on structiun oi sidewslks in munici psiities.
 By Hubbe l-Authorizing Apache county 10 iss, Q bcs de for building . court house.
 WEDNESDAY,
 Woman suffrage was given it's fna' quietu-, so fer as the present legislature is concerned, by senate prstponement yes erday.
 By c B Wood creating a stste home for destitute, eless, deprsved women and for neglected and absn- doned children, and making sppro- pristiens for their maintenance; pro- viding for boulevard districts.
 By Davis. an act requiring life in- sursnce companies doing business in Arizona to pay occupation tex and to provide method for computing the same.
 The bonse voted 74 to II iu favor oI !, compulsory segregstioo oi negro child ren. Now segregation is optional in the couptiee. The bouse voted to allow ~omen to hold che offices ol county school superintendent. By Barker. to take siiee from Gila
Tombstone epitaph., 1912-04-28
SmuggIers Caught
 With the Goods

Two Mexicsns alleged to be part oi e band of organized smugglers operat. ing betseen Douglss and Fl Tigre. were tsken into custody ls,t evening between 7apd 8o'clock by Inspector Gould of the local customs eervice The arrest foiiosed \ long sbsdowing expedition and resulted in the men b. ing captured with two gunny sacks filled s,th merchandise and several huudst de rounds of revolver ammuni- tion.
Tombstone epitaph., 1912-04-28
K Mau din to SJ Johnson

Speed Douglas prop .... 2000 .. w " Poindex,er ;o W L Witty, Benson prop . 10 .. c O Tevis to J W Pardue, Bowie prop ... 1900 .. SJ White, NJ A and w A ulasrock to E Suit, land 10 ..
 QUIT CLAIM DEED E Smith to Mrs R Wal teIs, land. ..... 9 .. E w Wilkerson toJ F Bo. mar, land .... .. g .. Of Grant. Mary F and W McPherson to McPhersou COrp'n, Blsbee prop. ..... 10 d.
 BILL OF SALE NJ A Crawford 10 DC Craw- ford, live stocE %. ...... 320 ..
 CONTRACT O. sale ot real estate L Knox with l. Gibson Tomb stone prop. 300
 REALTY MORTGAGE R Speed to $ ate Nut B X L Assn, Douglas prop . l200 Q. L Vssques .o E W Graves Douglas prep ...... 500 .. SATISFACTION OF MORTGAGE State Mu. B ( | Assn 10 c c Montgomery .......- 900 Q.
 BILL OF SALE NJ Benderacb to Bisbee Trad ing Co, Bisbee prop .... 600
 US PATtNT U $ to Fat O'Hsgsn, land
 Q c. DEED E W Bilkerson to Wm F. lrusD, land. ....... lu
 WARRANTY DEED Greene Cattle Co to Boquillss Land & Cattle Co, San Rs- fsel del Vslle Grant, con- tsining IT 474S5 acres .. 10 ..
 BARGAIN AND SALE DEED Greene Cattle Co 10 Boquillss Land & Cattle Co, live stock ..-.... .. ... ,l0 Q. SATISFACTION OF MORTGAGE G c Dnncsp to A R Carlson
 RELEASE Trust deed. c Walker to Greene Cattle Go .... =.
 WARRANTY DEED E c Curtis to E F Cur,i., Douglas pIop .... 10 .. Ariz & Mex Rlty Go to Ross Bound, Douglas prop .... l75 .. M D and H NJ Tescbout to k H Paddock, Douglas prop. 10 .. Int Land X Imp Co 10 E c Curtis, Douglas prop. .. 3eO Prov Nut B & D Assn to JF McDermot, Douglas prop. 10 ..
 Q.C.IEED D Higgins to w E Serv;s, land c E Bslcher to William E Cooper, Bisbee prop .. 300
 POWER OF ATTORNEY H NJ Teachout to Mrs H NJ ItECHOub
 WATER LOCATION Mabel C Richards approprist. es water from Cedar Creek Fife c Osens sppropristes water from wash between h ntian and Cedar creek.
 AFFIDAVIT Of Frank Payals. mines .. -
 cHATTEL MORTGAGE Following to Stan Furn Go. for furniture: F. A Clark 63 Is Ch..FaircIough. .... I36 50 Mrs A c Grinty. .. 54 |. W J Njchoi .. 72 45 NJ Camp to J NJ Mcknight live -tock .... 2z50 ..  Several hundred cases against the santa Fe Railsosd company for al legged violations Of the eighteen hour 'a~ gre sef for ,risi at Phoenix. be- ginning May l2 If the rsilroad should he found eui' on all of tbs counts the government could collect nearly . million dollar. in fines. The United States attorney thinks the .t of .hasa c..as pnav orcnnv tha f.
Tombstone epitaph., 1912-04-28

Dan Cupid is busy in the district and two weddings are slated for the merry month of Msy-
Tombstone epitaph., 1912-04-28
TOMBSTONE EPiTAPH
 PUBLISHED EVERY SUNDAY.
RECORDS OF
 COCHISE COUNTY
struments Filed With the County
 Recorder

hec0f0er THE RECORDS GIVEN IN BRIEF
 WARRANTY DEED A w Flickinger to G Mustain Douglas prop .. c Mustain to G Fliekinger Douglas prop ..... =. s Levy to M c High. Bisbee prop .................. lu .. c Dshlquist to W $ Dixon, Douglas pTnp ..... ... 10 .. R s Msclay to W w Holme Douglas prop .......... $50 .
 sHERIFF's DEED H c Wheeler to G H Wad- leigh, Douglas prop ...... l6os .. .. H c Wheeler to Bank oi Bs- bee Douglas prop .... IA 43
 QUIT CLAIM DEED M M Medigovich 10 Copper Queen Con Min Co, min prop in Warren NJ D .... 10 CG Gilpin to c A Grunow, land 10
 MINING DEED Marks to H K & G Han. niger, Warren min prop. 1000 ..
 REALTY MORTGAGE H A Huddleston to E R Fisher, Douglas prop ~ 250 .. E Gsbilondo to w w Holmes Douglas prop ..-......... 5oO MJ Cutler to Cit Bank X Trust Go, Bisbee prop ... 100 ..
 cHATTEL MORTGAGE fC Moore to Bank of Doug- las live stock ... 2500 Q. SUBTRACTION OF MORTGAGE VIC Cochran to F Nsvsre te J Litchfield to R Riddle. ~ Cit Bank and Trust Co .oM Cutler .......... Mrs JC Ryan to De E Cook State Nut B & LAssn to R LOokie .-.-.-.... 2UuU Wm Cowau to Mercner .. Prov Nut & L Assn to F Aercner
 ADMINS TRATOK's DEED Mary Hsworth to Blanche, Thornturg, Wilcox prop. l9S 25
 MINING DEED DO Williams 10 s Angius, prop in Warren M D.. 10 Q. U Stole Wolf, l,nd ...
 REALTY MORTGAGE NJ Scott to First Nst1 Bank of Douglas. Douglas prop. 5000 H Rasmuhsusen to W.Il:ox Bank X Trust Co, Wilcox prop. .......- .. BOT .
  SJ Johnson to V Hart, l45 acres land ............... 1900 .. MLeverich to Thos Allsire, land ... .... l440 .. M E Lever,ch to H Diers, t6OO 1o' % c Haz.lwood to A Hsvens, Douglss prop. ..-....-.-. M wv Holmes to F. Gabilondo Douglas prop ......--. 'o ..
 DEED PB Zsigler 70 NJ F Dicus.  Santa Fe Pacific K R Co to Mary E Leverich. land az sregatipe about 752O.l3 acres. .-.-. .ioooo -. M.ry E Lsvericb to William RiRgs. land in aggregate 532O 80 scrcs l5969 e.
 LOCATION WATER RIGHT W spsrks and H NJ Cisrksoo appropriate water from Nil. Ter Canyon ....-..--.-- =
 REALTY MORTGAGE wv Holmes to N Hsmpe. Dougias prop ...-. iooV .. . ,- SUBTRACTION OF MORTGAGE Aris Beuk < Trust co to W c Corey --.'....'
Newark post., 1912-06-05
THE END OF TUBERCULOSIS
Physicians Lack knowiedge.
BY GEORGE ". COTTIS.

We may provide all the restric-
ton we wish, we may provide
hospitals and enact laws, but we
are making bricks without straw
unless we provide for funda-
mental, early diagnosis. am not
afraid to say that Is per cent of
the practicing physicians in New
York today are unable to dag
nose incipient tuberculosis. that
a majority OF them do not cor
recty diagnose even quite ad-
vanced cases and that some do
not make proper diagnosis
even after death. So 1t will be
n step In advance II we can pro-
cure expert physicians to exam
inc patients in each county with
out expense. And If we can
have early diagnosis by these
expert physicians. these expert
agnosticianS. the smaller coun-
ties OF the state will be greatly
benefited, for they are sadly in
need OF such assistance.
Newark post., 1912-06-05
THEEND OF TUBERCULOSIS
Civic Loss Through School
Sickness.

BY DIR. LEONARD P. AYRES.
Figures from Germany. Eng
land, Sweden and seven Ameri-
can cities Indicate that in the
average city school system the
children who are In need of such
treatment as that afforded by the
open air schools constitute from
3 to s per cent OF the entire
school membership. This means
that Albany, for example, should
have open air schools In sutb-
Client numbers to care for 300
children. while New York city
needs accommodation for 10000.
When such figures as these are
mentioned the objection Of ex-
pense looms high at once, but 1t
must not be forgotten when we
are considering expense that
thousand children Of school age
die each year Of tuberculosis In
New York city. On the average
they have each had about six
years Of schooling. for which the
city has paid about $3.50. This
means q quarter of a million dol
lars loss each year In the great
city In money expended on edu-
eating children who die of tuber-
culosis before growing up. A
quarter Of million dollars
year spent In open air schools
designed to prevent this fright
full waste would go far toward
meeting the entire expense.
Newark post., 1912-06-05
THE END or TUBERCULOSIS
Stamping Out the Plague.

By JOSEPH a CHOATE.
| do not think there is any
greater or better cause now set
before the people OF New York,
the people of this great state,
than to save themselves from
this terrible plague. and they can
do it if they will The cities
have already accomplished much.
New York and Boston and Lon
don have reduced by one-half
the death rate from this particu-
lar evil. 1t exists where it has
been unchecked and unstudiod
and uncared for in the rural dis
tricts of the state and in the
smaller cities of the state
Newark post., 1912-06-05
THE END OF TUBERCULOSIS
The Value of Fresh Air.
By BENJAMIN FRANKLIN.

By BENJAMIN FRANKLIN.
1t 4. recorded of Methuselah,
who, being the longest liver, may
be supposed to have best pre-
served his health, that he slept
always In the open air, for when
he had lived 500 years an angel
said unto him. Arise, Methuse-
lah and build thee an house, for
thou shalt live yet 800 years
longer" And Methuselah an
swered and said: IF | am to live
but 500 years longer it Is not
worth while to build me an
house. ! will sleep in the air as
| have been used to do" Physi-
clans. after having for ages con-
tended that the sick should be
given fresh air sparingly. have
at length discovered thar it may
do them good II is therefore to
be hoped that they may in time
discover likewise that it is not
hurtfnl to those that are in
health and that we ni&y then be
cured Of the a;,opnohin that at
present diStreSSe$ weak minds
and makes them choose TO be
stided and poisoned rather than
leave open the window Of Il bed
chamber or put down the glass
of a coach. Confined air, when
saturated with perSp:rable mat
ter, will not receive more. and
that matter must remain in our
bodies and occasion diseases.
(From a letter TO Il friend on
the Art of Securing Pleasant
Dreams.")
Newark post., 1912-06-05

THE noisy waves are failures,
but the great silent tide is d sue
cess. DO you know what it is to be
failing every day, and yet to be
S1lre that your life is, as a whole
in it's great movement and mean
ing, not failing. but succeeding" ?"