Evening capital news. (Boise, Idaho) 1901-1927, 1912-12-10
GREAT BRITAIN SENDS
Her PROTEST.

4 u
CONTINUED from First Pare).
----
owned by Canadian railroads or whose
owners may be guilty OF violating the
sherman antitrust act. He holds that
TINS section OF the act cannot apply to
British shipping, but only to United
states vessels.
He indicates that underlying the OBJ
Jection TO the exemption from toll of
american coastWise ships Is an appre-
nehslon tnat IN tne future the principle
might De extenoed 10 cover American
SHIPS IN tne foreign trade.
Terms OF treaty.
Otnerwise the note Is devoted almost
en'ney u q" eiiore 10 demonstrate
'nat any such exemption OF American
snippns as - proposed is IN oirect con-
lHct Win tne terms OF the Hay Paunce-
lorle treaty anu ina. PRESIDENT tart
was cieaIly wrong Wnen ne TOOK the
oorr.'ay .iew'
Inc nr'.isn note mignt De summed
up as q oennition OF the dinerences
ue'"eeh 'he 'wo governments regard
ing .ne construction OF the hay
auhoeioI,e .reat', "lnoins up win a
poposa, tha' .ne issues De settieo ny
, a'io,i' i'hey canHot pc aoJusted
~ inu.uai asreeihene ior "nicn way
o I, open.
oretary AnoA nstened attentiveiy 10
.he ieauihs VI tne note ana promised
" !ahe Tie ihdtter unoer consideration,
", nc oush' "ouio require some
mas oeen strohsy intfnated
49,. .n... ma. was 'he pres
ih,eh',oii " set'ie TINS linpor-
.a'l question oetore CLOSING MS admin
STRATUM ei.ner py recommending that
nc eo'e asree " submit IL 10 arol-
'ie'iol' y. preierapiy 'oy the more olrect
.'eahs Vi an agreement between the
wv iia.,oiis'
oit HuWaro grey begins MS note with
.ne s.a.eiiieh' 'hat 'iie presioent does
ho' luiiy appreciate the british point
ot view ana mas misunderstood the note
" ou.! 0. ne says II Is not the case
mat inc BRUSH government seeks to
prevent .ne unl.eo otates from grant
ins supsioies 10 us own shipping pass
ING through .he canai. nor ooes II seek
~, " uepfNe .he ohi'eo otates OF any
iueiy WHICH IS open eltner 10 them-
seiNes Vi ayh o'ner Hation 10 encourage
IT'S owi siiippihs OF own commerce by
me purpose OF the uhlted
S.a'es III negotiating 'he nay !Paunce-
io'e uea'S WAS " recover 'heir rreeoom
VI ae.ioii anu optaln the right Whlch
lhey hau surrendered III the clayton
ou'"e' treaty u coiistruct the canai
'hsi'iseives'
D". 'iiis co,npiete iioerty OF actioh
was ~ We ii''ii'eu pS the maintenance
vi 'he important principle OF equal
treatment ior poth Engilsh ana United
o'a'es Ships'
JOINT rroteet'on.
me "oru CONTAMINATION IN the pre-
aiho'e vi 'Ie ay-fduhce1ote treaty is
nv" eohi'"eo " peiiiserenl operations
ou' ielers 10 .he system OF equal rights
ioi winch arlIeie eight provinces. JOINT
pi o'ee'ioi anu equal treatment are tne
oins n,at'eis aiiuued 10, 10 "hlch that
nv. a'iNalioi must reier.
eei'aihly was not the lntention OF
me oi'i'eu otates government, says
or EDWARD Grey' that any response
my III 'heh pio.ec''oii Oh 'he caha'
Iiouiu a''acif 10 .nefh III the future
tSeu'ra'i~ation' therefore. must reter to
me system Oh equai rights.
ms NIUE hectares 'hat the situatlon
eiea'eu ny the SUBSTITUTION OF the hay
iauiiceio'e treaty lot tne clayton Bull
weI treaty was iaen'lcai with that re-
euitiis iioii 'ne pouiioary waters treaty
=, i'o' pe'"eei Hreat britain ana ire
oh!'eu S'a'es' "hich III priei provides
.hal 'he pouhoary waters shouid DE
iiee anu open 10 commerce applying
eauahy ana wi'nout discrimination TO
.ne inhabitants, SHIPS vessels ana boats
VI Dotn countries out all SuCn