davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1912-11-22
DR.. MCDONALD AT
Y. NJ. c. A. SUNDAY

DIR. c. II. McDanold. pastor OF the
second Presbyterian church. will ad-
dress the mems meeting AZ the Young
Mems Christian association SUNDAY AZ.
ternoon al As O'Clock. This will be
DIR McDonald's last Sunday in the
city as he goes TO his new charge ar
Ashtabula next wees Or Mcdonald
has many friends among the associa-
ton men who will be glad 10 hear
him on sunday afternoon T. " linn
will be the leader Of the meefig and
G. >. Morrison Will have charge Of the
singing
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1912-11-22
Famous Pint of Cough
Jyrup" Receipt
No BETTER Remedy AZ Any Price.
Fully Guaranteed.

Make a plain syrup bv mixing one
pint Of graduated sugar and J., pint Of
warm water and stir for two minutes
Put p, ounces 81 pure PineX ifftv
cents WORTH in n pint bottle. and mn II
up with %" sugar syrup. This givct
You family supply 81 the b..t cough
syrup az saving If s.. L. never apoiIs-
Take i.asPooaiul every one, two or
three hours.
The effectiveness 81 this siupIe rer,e5v
- -urrrt-lng. lf sens 20 take hold in.
rtAntlV. art viii usually stop the most
obstinate cough ia - hours. II tone,
np 20" faded appetite and j. lust LAM.
tive enough 20 be- helpful in a c0upD.
and ha- q pleasing taste Also excellent
Tor bronchial trouble, throat tickle. -ore
lungs and a7thma, and an uneaualeI
remedy for wlcoping cough ami croup.
This recipe for making cough remedy
with IincV and Sugar syrup cor
strained h0nevl i- prime favorite in
thousand. II homes IN tho United states
and canada. The plan has been imita-
t'i. though mover auccCe-fullv. II you
trv II. use only rsnuine PineS. which -
inc most valuable concentrated com
pound y Norway white pine extract and
j. rich in riaiacol and al fhe natural
healing riro element. Othsr nrerara.
tons will not work I'm fhis rcrine
A guaranty - absolute safisf,ctior
~ money promptly refunded. roca with
tfi- rcoine. Your druggist has pinev.
or will rrt " for vou " not. end 10
Inc fin'v Co, IT, Wayne. Ind.
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1912-11-22
NcCluskey Reception

Mr. AMI Airs william oliver Mrglus-
Key. uf COL Nprth Main street. entertain
81 with an afternoon ana evening receI-
on on .NfSiay ~ compliment -
their son Mr. William -. Mrt'f.Sk.v II
aui iiS bride. who was formerly Miss
Mari" br4Hdfas~ The p4riurS where fn..
r's~iNinr line was formed. were heau'i-
fully decorated iu pink AMI Whit. Win
'hr} san'netuums FREEDOM inafius These
blooms were artistt..tIly arranged about
-" rooms and produced q pleasing Of
feet The dining room was prs.-ilv dec
GRATED 10 red and green and tho rsIsrs
were carried u4t ia the luncheon aud
stsZ
lu tie afternoon tho hours were from
. fu AMI Too DO" even. they were from
10 10. lu O." afternoon 10 assist IA.
hFlf" AMI groom and tie host and
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1912-11-22
Eli Club Ladies

The LAZY Elks we're entertained bv
Mrs william Windsor on "Wednesday
and I've hundred was the diversion
The ladies were entertained in the
parlors Of the Elks club on Fifteenth
street and the arIh. proved most On.
Joyahlc- Manager Peter Hubcrstick
seived a delicious luncheon TO the
ladies' ana tho prizes were awarded
70 Mrs. Charles Fricse. a pair Of white
nd gloves, and Mrs Anton Jefferson
Won second. a handsome comb
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1912-11-22
To Depart Woman.

SN$ FRANCISCO. cal Nov -
Mrs Ward Carter. of London. VINO
was arrested yssterday 80 o. fashionable
hotel. ami taken Too fH" feradHI teufipr
station as an undesirable alien. VIII
10 d-ported ht tho steamer Nii.. sallira.
November 81. according tp immigration
'ufrf1IT auUuuuseuieIf today She must
iuHk" her waE home o. another route.
tnsu cross the United States. the Of
frttl- saw
Nrs. Carter viii be- given transport
alton @" Shaug Hal. where she took pas
sage
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1912-11-22

hl"" mar You nav" oVerdoue. hut n you meet An
"'P'an'dhc" aud simply cannot think of his name d,
you connect mat also with your overwork9 Or d.,
you Simply Eel annoyed a. your loss of memory and
l"t g. 80 that ~
woman whom know is overvorking She il
iu larry good physical condition. will NOT
ADMIT mat sh" is otertaNinr herself But notice thst
whenever she wants to speak anyone ~ her chill
ur'h she mas 10 pauf" moment before can select
in" right name. and often calls the child b ia brothe-
or sisters name instead Of US own
NEa'. th" U''t az saving The exact opposite %
NIIai you mean. Hot when cold. sumner
when sou want to say winter and so on Z have found
DID W' o"n cas-" ~ least fo De- a reminder that am
"'erWorki1E SOM" people who have . bit of doing
' ana ihhi believe. ie usually thai their con
dItnn h y LiIn below nar
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1912-11-22

lh't Unused feeling that nahir,
I'D dd" What Of
"H' s another d flag fhc
what do neon r slow Wei mean IL rteraI,
DO tou oo n limo
ctc. ~ro.s t-4-e
Fo outdoors o san
ADD
eliza.
. recrr.t
cf Providence Bob of rho r,sf
90
ID
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1912-11-22
= = - 't7F. : Vie - = y .s.s
The DAILY CHIT-CHAT
By Ruth Cameron

70 szax
actually
j peey broken down a OF overwork ~ ~
No said the doctor YOU
Naur" has The mos.
physical
ven "" d"I
danger which 10
for instance IT, ~ the
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1912-11-22

Tho members ~ the :, ,,,,......
. rrs'el choir enjoyed their annual
Ia"hsElVlhs dinner IN the SUNDAY
'ColnS OF me church on Thursd.y
''"'hk ana The table was arranged
shape The decoration
,I' ErHoW Jonquils and French has.
- OF me howcrs were placed a-
,ii,'I aus on IN" table. The Chancal
.ap' sI OF ne 81 Mathews church
rtI''u thr dinner. and beside. tho
nl"St dehclous baked turkey an ia.
iHahASEiNlHg delicacies we're served
anu me members % the choir All
JiSlIce To the sumptuous spread ,
S""'' program was feature OF tb..
t''n!hg ana following the dinner d..
lnenlberS or the choir left for a.,
S'o''ish Kite Cathedral. where tb,,
sdnE IN The operetta In Dave ~,
va The ladies who served .bo
.!hher We're Mrs l. W \ SfryLc-
MIS- \. $ Hare. Mrs Joseph nm.
Mn Mrs W. ". COX. Miss PAM, n
sell Miss Elizabeth brown. Miss Ala.
i,fo"n"' Miss Alice Caldwell NJ
Waine -"'ii
There Were covcre 40 di,,o- g.
the following '''
- ~ ,'.l'- Charles Ronneson
u''''s Nhrrnf luhn Sfraftpu
Tuner , unninEh1m lhos Williams
49,. ', ~. IolIinrwood Paul .
''o"'I' NI'fion Robert Ponnor
''lIIln ku -"U Stewart
H.. ''''nF J. vs. $ S'ryker
~. ''i'-'F % 50 browne
Edward llsbrauk louis p-,ot.,..
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1912-11-22
CHOIR DINNER
AT ST. MATTHEWS
ot ST Mathews Vested
Cho'r Enjoy Thanksgiving
Dinner

Young Peoples Informal Da,,.
r'on observation-disclosures
HeeePtion-Mrs. Sands Entertain.
The Wheeling intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1903-1961, 1912-11-22
stupp Orchestra Concert

" -~te.
i'''''e n List Mi-- Miller.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1912-03-21
Calls Issue Fairly Defined.

"Mr. Taft fairly defines the issue when
he says that our government is and
should be a government of all the people
by a representative part of the people
This is an excellent and moderate de-
scription of an oligarchy. 1t defines ouI
government as a government of all OF
the people by few of the people. Mr.
Taft in his able speech, has made what
is probably the best possible presenta-
ton of the case for those who feel in
this manner. Essentially this view diff
fers only in its expression from the view
markedly set forth by one of his support
ers, Representative Campbell. Repre-
sentative Campbell, in public speech in
New Hampshire. in opposing the propo-
sition to give the people real and effec-
tive control over all their servants, in
Guiding the judges, stated that this was
equivalent to allowing an appeal from
the umpire to the bleachers. Doubtless
Representative Campbell was not himself
aware of the cynical truthfulness with
which he was putting the real attitude
of those for whom he spoke. But it I'M
questionably is their real attitude. Mr.
CampbelfS conception of the part the
American people should play in self
government is that they should sit or
mission, but should have nothing to say
as to the contest which is waved in the
arena by the professional politicians
Apparently Mr. Campbell ignores the fact
that the American people are not mere
onlookers at a game, that they have q
vital stake in the contest and that de.
mocracy means nothing unless they art
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1912-03-21
impulse of temporary majority of al
electorate.
Declares Criticism Unfounded.

This criticism is really less a criticism
of my proposal than q criticism of all
popular government. 1t is wholly I'M
founded, unless it is founded on the be-
lief that the people are fundamentally
untrustworthy. If the Supreme Court S
definition of due process in relation to
the police power is sound, then an act
of the legislature to promote the colIec-
tive interests of the community must be
valid, if it embodies policy held by the
prevailing morality or prepOnderant
opinion to be necessary to the public well
fare. This is the question that 1 propose
to submit to the people.
MIR. Taft's position is the position that
has been held from the beginning of our
government, although not always so
openly held, by large number of repu-
table and honorable men who, down at
bottom. distrust popular government,
and, when they must accept it, accept
it with reluctance, and hedge it around
with every species of restriction and
check and balance, SO as to make the
power of the people as limited and as
Ineffective as pOSSible
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1912-03-21
Restates His Position.

so that no man may misunderstood
me, let me recapitulate:
I'D I am not proposing anything in
connection with the Supreme Court of
the United States, or with the Federal
Constitution.
"(2) l am not proposing anything hav-
ing any connection with ordinary suits,
civil or criminal, as between individuals.
"C3) 1 aH not speaking of the recall of
judges.
20 / am proposing merely that in a
certain class of cases involving the police
power. when state court has set aside
as unconstitutional a law passed by the
legislature for the general welfare, the
question of the validity of the law
which should depend, as Justice Holmes
so well phrases it, upon the prevailing
morality or preponderant opinion-be
submitted for final determination to a
vote of the people. taken after due time
for consideration. And l contend that
the people in the nature of things, must
be better judges Of what is the preponder-
ant opinion than the courts, and that
the courts should not be allowed to re-
verse the political philosophy of the peo-
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1912-03-21

in my program are wrong because they
intrude into the sanctuary of the judici-
airy. The first is the recall of judges;
and the second, the review by the people
of judicial decisions on certain constitu-
tional questions. / have said again and
again that | do not advocate the recall
of Judges in all states and in all COM
muntieS. In my own state L do not ad-
yocate it oh believe it to be needed, for
in this state our trouble lies not with
corruption on the bench. but with the
effort by the honest but wrongheaded
Judges to thwart the people in their
struggle for social justice and fair deal
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1912-03-21
Replies to the President.

1.-THE President of the United States,
Mr. Taft, devoted most of a recent speech
to criticism of this proposition. He says
that it lis utterly without merit or utility,
and, instead of being in the in
terest of all the people. and of the
stability of popular government, is SOW
ing the seeds of confusion and tyranny
(By this he. of course, means the tyranny
of the majority-that is. the tyranny of
the American people as a whole.) He also
says that my proposal (Which. as he
rightly sees, is merely proposal to give
the people real, instead of only a
nominal, chance to cOnstrue and amend
a state constitution with reasonable
rapidity) would make such amendment
and Interpretation depend on the fever
ish, uncertain and unstable determination
of successive votes on different laws by
temporary and changing majorities.' and
| that it lays the AK at the foot of the
tree of we'll ordered freedom, and sub
jects the guarantees of life, liberty and
property without remedy to the fitful
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1912-03-21

such marked chara cteristcs' as Col
Roosevelt whose personality. he SAID,
might cloud the issue. To this Col. Roos'e-
Selt replied:
II can only say that I wish somebody
else whose suggestions would arouse
less antagonism had proposed il. but
nobody else did propose it, and SO }
had to. | am not leading this hight as a
matter of esthetic pleasure. | am lead
ing because somebody must lead or else
the fight would not be made at all.
Il prefer to work with moderate, win
rational conservatives, provided only
that they do in good faith strive Tor
ward toward the light. But when they
halt and turn their backs to the light
and sit with the scorners on the seats OF
reaction. then l must part company
with them. We, the people cannot turn
back. Our aim must be steady, wise
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1912-03-21

Recall of Judges.
MY opponents charge that two things
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1912-03-21
What He Stands For.

1--WE stand against all tyranny. by the
few Or by the many. We stand for the
rule of the many in the interest of a
of us, for the rule of the many in a
spirit of courage, of common sense, of
high purpose, above all in a spirit of
kindly justice toward every man and
every woman. We not merely admit. but
insist. that there must be self-control on
the part of the people; that they must
keenly perceive their own duties as well
as the rights of others. But we also in
sist that the people can do nothing IN
less they not merely have. but exercise
to the full, their own rights.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1912-03-21
FEEL SIIAKY. HEADACHY, BILIOUS
OR CONSTIPATED? TAKE CASCARETS.

liver delayed fermening
in sick stomach Poisonous matter instead OF beng
blood When reaches
and that dull awful throbbs
sickenng headache
the by stimulating the liver and making the
clear head for months Don't
forget the
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1912-03-21

LAS Lincoln announced of the Dred
Scott decision in his debates with Doug
las: Somebody has to reverse that deci-
sion, since it is made and We mean to
reverse it, and We mean to do ii peace
ably Was Lincoln wrong? Was the
spirit of the nation that wiped out slavery
the fitful impulse of a temporary ma
jority'?
Il stand on the Columbus speech. The
principles there asserted are not new,
but 1 believe that they are necessary to
the maintenance of free democratic gov
eminent. The part of my speech in
which / advocated the right of the people
to be the final arbiterS of what is due
process of law in the case of statutes
enacted for the general welfare will ulti-
mateIy, 1 am confident, be recognized as
giving strength and support to the courts
instead of being revolutionary and sub
versive.
Says He Was Forced to Lead.
'If my critics would only show the
same sober judgment of which they de-
clare the people at large to be incapable
they would realize that my proposal is
one of moderation and common sense, :"
Mr.. Roosevelt continued
Col. Roosevelt quoted the remarks of
William Draper Lewis. dean of the Law
School OF the University of Pennsylva-
mia, who approved Mr.. Roosevelts plan
Of popular recall of judicial decisions
regarding constitutional amendments, but
declared it unfortunate that the plan
should have been proposed by man OF
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1912-03-21
able and willing to show that they a
their own masters.
No Wish to Be Unkind.

II am not speaking jokingly. nor do 1
mean to be unkind; for l repeat that
many honorable and we'll meaning men
of high character take this view, and
have taken it from the time of the forma-
ton of the nation Essentially this view
is that the Constitution is a strait-jacket
to be used for the control of an unruly
patient-the people. Now 1 hold that this
view is not only false but mischievous.
that our constitutions are instruments de-
signed to secure justice by securing the
deliberate but effective expression of the
popular will, that the checks and bal
ances are valuable far, and only so
far, as they accomplish that elaboration,
and that it is a warped and unworthy
and improper construction of our form OF
government to see in 1T only means OF
thwarting the popular VIII ana OF pre-
venting justice.
Mr.. Taft says that every class should
! have a voice in the government. That
seems to me a very serious misconceptlon
of the American political situation. The
real trouble with us is that some classes
have had too much voice.
Functions of the Judiciary.
| THE same principle applies when Mr..
| Taft says that the judiciary ought not to
| be representative OF the people in the
sense that the legislature and the exec
| utive are. This is prfectly true of the
Judge when he is performing merely the
ordinary functions of a judge in suits be-
| tween man and man. 1t is not true of the
| Judge engaged in interpreting, for in
stance, the due process clause-where the
| Judge is ascertaining the preponderant
opinion of the people (as Judge Holmes
states it,. When he exercises that func-
ton he has no right to let his political
philosophy reverse and thwart the will of
the majority.
Mr. Taft's position is perfectly clear.
It is that we have in this country a
special class OF persons wiser than the
people who are above the people, who
cannot be reached by the people, but
who govern them and ought to govern
them, and who protect various classes of
the people from the whole people. That is
the old, old doctrine which has been acted
upon for thousands of years abroad. and
which here in America has been acted
upon sometimes openly, sometimes secret
| ly, for forty years by many men in pub
| lie and in private life, and l am sorry
| to say by many judges; doctrine which
| has in fact tended to create bulWark
| for privilege, a bulwark unjustly protect
| ing special interests against the rights
of the people as whole.
! Reversal of Decisions.
Regarding the proposition to reverse
court decisions, Mr., Roosevelt remarked:
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1912-03-21
ROOSEVELT HITS
BACK AT CRITICS
Declares the Issue Is Whether
the American People Are Fit
for SeIf-Government.
SAYS TAFT ADVOCACY
is FOR AN OLlGARCHY
Speaks at Carnegie Hall, New York,
Under Auspices of Civic Forum.
STICKS TO COLUMBUS SPEECH
First Address Since the Public An
nouncement of His Willing
ness to Accept Nomina-
ton for President.
Roosevelt Replies to Taft.

'Mr. Taft fairly defines the issue
when he says that our government
is and should be a government Of
all the people by a representative
part of the people. This is an eX-
cellent and moderate description of
an oligarchy. 1t defines our gov
eminent as government of all of
the people by a few of the people,"
Mr.. Taft again and again, in
quotations 1 have given. and else
where through his speech, eX-
presses his disbelief in the people
when they vote at the polls. In
one sentence he says that the
proposition gives powerful effect
to the momentary impulse of
majority of an electorate and pre-
pareS the way for the possible ex-
ercise Of the grossest tyranny
Elsewhere he speaks of the fever
ish uncertainty and unstable de-
termination of laws by temporary
and changing majorities'; and
again he says that the system 1
propose would result in suspension
CONSTITUTIONAL
guarantee according to popular
whim', which would destroy all
possible consistency in constitu-
tional Interpretation. I should
much like to know the exact dis
tinction that is to be made between
what Mr.. Taft calls the fitful i'm
pulse of a temporary majority
when applied to question such as
that 1 raise and any other ques-
ton.
Mr.. Taft's position is perfectly
clear 1t is that we have in this
country special class of persons
wiser than the people, who are
above the people, who cannot be
reached by the people, but who
govern them and ought to govern
them; and who protect various
classes of the people from the
whole people,
THEODORE ROOSEVELT.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1912-03-21
Reversal Of Decisions.

Regarding the proposition to reverse
court decisions. Mr.. Roosevelt remarked:
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1912-08-10

c,rt,pued on siIth page, hfth column.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1912-08-10
JUDGE RECALLS DECISION
Was Stockholder of Company III
Whose Favor He Ruled.

Boston, Aug. 9.-After having heard
the application Of the Gilmore Electric
Company for an injunction against tho
General Electric Company and having
decided against the petitioner Judge
Loring. of the Supreme Judicial Court
to-day remembered that he was
stockholder in the General Electric
Company. He rcscinded the action he
had taken and said that the matter
must be presented to some other judge
The Gilmore company asked that The
General Electric Company be compelled
specifically to perform contract 10
furnish the plaintiffs with lamps.
Last week the Gilmore company hled
in the United States District Court an
attachment for S3,OOO,0oO against the
General Electric Company, alleging
that the latter company had violated
the Sherman antitrust law in trying
TO stife competition and breaking a
contract with the plaintiff.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1912-08-10
AGREE ON ONE BATTlESHlP
House Democrats Compromise
on a Super -Dreadnought.

Washington. Aug. 9.-Battleship and
no battleship Democrats in the House
to-day practically reached compro-
mise by which provision will be made
in the naval appropriation bill for one
SUPER -Drea drought. AS a result OF the
understanding a petition was circulat l.
cd for q caucus next Wednesday night
II is expected the difficulties by that
time will have been smOothed out ana
there will be no hitch in putting
through the programme.
The two battleship champions are
said 10 be insisting as price for theif
surrender that the ship TO be authorized
shall be more powerful than any no"
af,oat or contemplated. The proposal
will be fought, however as there Is d
strong conviction among many mem
bers Of the Naval Affairs COMMITTEE
that smaller and faster battleships OF
the cruiser -Dreadnought type are pre-
ferable to those of heavier armament
and slower speed.
Assurances are reported 10 have peeh
given by enough members opposed 10
battIeships 10 insure quorum al the
coming caucus. AT the previous eau
Gus enough remained away TO preNeh'
anv business being transacted.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1912-08-10
"FITz" TO RACE RED MAN
Boston Mayor Will Run Against
Olympic Star.

Boston. Aug. 9-Mayor John F. Fllz-
gerald is to run race with Jim
Thorpe. Of the Carlisle Indian School
who has Just returned after starring In
the Olympic games. The race will take
place tomorrow afternoon at the car
nivaI of the Boston Elks. In Fenway
Park. II will be a lI-yard dash and
both men will bc on scratch. Asked
whether he wanted handicap the
Mayor replied:
81 do not. am as good runner as
he. and he will have TO go some to keep
up with me
The only condition that the Mayor
IMPOSES is that the race shall start ut
4 o'clock. "F'itz" has done number
of athletic stunts recently. lie has
flown in an aeroplane, driven a trotter
TO victory and taken the high hurdles
in a steeplechase. He Is some runner
too-for Office suffering defeat hut
once.