New-York tribune., 1912-04-21
JUDGE MOORE Wins BLUES
Entries Sweep the Ring at
BROOKLYN Horse Show.
LADY SEAT0N A CHAMPION
Mrs. William McGibbon's Rosa
bel Captures Titular Rosette
and Other Awards.

Roth of the tri-color rosettes In tne harhSs'
classes went 10 Judge Moore. Lady Seaton
and Robin Hood were the only two entr'es
In the championship class for horses Over
Isl, and II was no difficult matter TOT tne
Iitt,e mara TO defeat her stable COM
panion. although she was BY no means at
her best.
Neither was Nenella travelling in her
usual form IN the smaller division of cham
MONS She had to compete with Baronet
and Satire, from the stable OF j. summer
Draper, however. and neither OF them put
M a performance which could overShado"
the dainty mare
There was more enthusiasm in the e1hi-
bitlon Of champion saddle horses over loi
hands than was seen during the entire
show. Mrs. J. g. McKay's Lady Deoona"
was at her best and had won earlier In the
dav. but the judges seemed to look WIN
favor rpon the beautiful little mare Fan
tasy. from the sequatogue Farm. Not so
the railbirds. They applauded the Lady so
yociferously that finally the boxes and gal
lery took I'D their cue, and the puloihs
resounded :,
The mares were unsaddled and Juoseu
for conformation, but the judges could hot
eet ayay from tho fact that Lady Deponair
was perfect as she appeared In the iihs'
and the coveted tri-color went to her
Mrs William McGibbon's Rosabei was
a good winner. Besides her champion 'iD-
ho,, eho nut 70 her credit several blues.
>,o,ab,o among them was the one In Class
"a where she had to meet J. Parker kir-
inns oueonlight and Emil Seeig's Mark
Hanna.
IN the first decision Rosabel was hrst'
oueenlight second and Mark Hanna thiro'
but il was not long, however, before some
ono said to be Mr.. Kirlin, protested the
auard on account of the size Of Rosabel.
When the standard was produced and the
horses put under ii Rosabel was louru u
be we'll within the regulations, out queen
light was disqualified. This gave the sec
ond award to Mark Hanna, with MISS van
Wyck up.
The first class of the afternoon was also
protested Tho judges at first picKed All@n
pinkerton's Corn Cob to wear the olue' oul
urs Iobn Gerken believed that he was 100
large to compete in that division ana 80 II
proved. He vas disqualified ana tne nr't
nrize was given 10 the dlminutlVe gray
mare. Donsy, owned by Edward and caro-
lyn Gerken. ,,,.,,o
Lord seaton won his first leg on "Ihe
Rrooklyn Eagle" Challenge Cup, Dull tic
hoo st,,I two more TO win before his owner
can claim the trophy. The conditions caii
for borsss suitable for and driven to gig
This class was won in 1910 and 1911 by J. ~: ":
Harriman's regal Nala.
The awards follow.
Class ls combination harness and SADDLE poII.S pIe
under N2 hands nIs, prize; |5o' see3on corn Cob:
second. Ddward and Carolyn Gerkens 81
Dousy. g. n.rds. omen
only TO members OF Riding and Driving sanm9,
frst prize. SIS: second prize, Slo)-f1r,.. Trs
tosus Farms ch. IN. Fantasy, secohG. 9hG.. Mrs
lam n. Dykman's ch z. Marmion.
Class 80 9Snes under lSs hanSs sFs nRI Rich
"a TS,mhle us b. m Busy Bee; second Ed
ward and Carolyn Gerkens sr. m: Dousy; sr..
Glass dharness horses over ri9st io.I William II.
Moorc's b. g. Robin Hood; second, Emu Ss.'s 81
b. M Royal Victoria: third. James Mcleans Or
T. Sir Rossiter; fourth, J. Sumner Draper Gu <
Ct Class Fl SADDLE horse, over 1872 hands; first
prize. $50; second prize. S2o,-t1rs' Mrs; .; D.
third, q. K. Jacobs b. m. Mar Garden; fourth
william \ Dykmans .h Marin MSrmi0T IN harness.
nrst prize, SIS; second prize, sto)-First Edward
and Carolyn Gerken's b. 6. Gar: second Howard
s. starretts blk. s. Asninaldo; third Mrs How
ard Sarretts blk. m. Tootsie
Glass 43 Saddle horses 1872 and not exceed:
ing 15l hands,; (open only to members OF
the Riding and Driving Club)IFirst aa seauta
Miss Margaret q Rouss's b. m. Roxle; third.
Miss Laura Hulst Murrs br. m. Lady Psrlais;
class 2 Gharncss horses over Is and not sex,
ceedins 152 handsl; first prize: $50; second
prize .e0DS %tllG% Pha H. b.
a Grangelt; third james McLean's ch. m.
Barbara; fourth. Philip Liyingston's b. s.
Glass 20 SADDLE horses over Is and not ex:
ceeding 1872 hands,; first prize. $50; second
prize, S2O)--First. Mrs, W, A. McGlbbon's b.
Fantasy: third. /. NJ. Newsasss b. g. watch
full; fourth, z. b. Ackerman's Dr. g. Beau
class ~ Combination horsesl: (open only
TO members Of the Riding and Driving Club
First. Mrs Charles +. Holm's b. g. West
Tia: third, Miss Tiilie NJ Whitings blk &.
Max; fourth Miss L. H. Murrs b. M. Lady
Class 80 (polo ponies 10 be shown with
bali and malleD: (perforr ance 10 count IS
per cent, conformation % per cent?; hrst
prize $50 second prize ssCFIs nsDTS Godfrey ncs
gan's b. x. T Y. third. Godfrey Preece's b.
m. Patience; fourth Edward Kings Oh. g.
Glass 8 (glg horses. for Brooklyn Eagle"
challenge cup); mus: be won three times oy
SaSi' won in isio si and and islt by Avondaie Farms
Noia)-First, william ". Moore's b. g. Lord
ssoton; second. Philip Lvingston's b. g. Gran.
Fashion; fourth, Philip Livlngston's b <.
class "a Cponies. 1872 and under I42 hands
First Mrs George LedereT's b. m. Sweet
Rriar; second Morris c. Rangers ch. m. Vanity;
LIEUT. Asn W. Wmties SGS
Glass 3s Jumpers; best Performance over
jumps at feet inches; first prize. $50; second
Mlleady; second, S. c. Prizes b. <. King Modred;
third, Aylward Riding Acade:ny's br. g. Sham
class l (harness horses. i42 and not exceed
ing rs hands; first prize. $50: second prize. 500
First William II. Moore's b. m. Menella sec
James Mciean's Leader OF Fashion: fourth. j.
sumner Draper's br; g. Beronet.
Class q SADDLE horses unlocked. 81 hands fsl1
First. Mrs. NJ. Barret,'s ch. m. Redlight. second
Harold c. Parsons en- IN. Portia third, G. l..
Railey's ch. &. Coniston fourth, Miss Bonson's
Glass p (saddlc horses. 1t.2 and not exceeding
81 hands; women TO ride. using side saddles;
w. A. McGibbon's b. m. Re sabel; second. Emil
seeliss CHI g: Mark Hanna. ridden by Miss
louise Van Wyck; third, Miss Margaret b.
Glass II champion harness horses, over 10
hands: prize sweepstakes)-First. William n.
Moore's b. m. Lady Seaton: reserve. William h.
MoOre's b. z. Robinhood.
Champion saddle horses. r.? and not exceed
ing 10 hands; prize sweepstakes-first M,s; w;
A. McGbbons h. m. Rosabel: reserve. Coionel
Railey's h. m Luana.
Glass 10 champion harness horses "a ana
not exceedin9 X hands; prize sweepstakes)-
First. William II. Moore's b. IN. Meneha; re
serve ]. sumner Draper's br. nj. Satire 49,
Class - champion saddle horses; over ,cs 40,
hands; prize sweepstakesI-First. Mrs James
r. McKay's ch IN. Lady Debonair reserve
Sequatogue Farms ch m. Fantasy
ARUNDEL CREW IN TRAINING