The Sentinel=record., 1912-11-16
GUN MEMS CASES WILL BE SUM- MED UP TODAY AND SENT
 TO TRIAL JURY.
EVIDENCE AGAINST lNFORMER
Some Witnesses Indicate That States Witnesses Were the Ones Who Fired Shots Into Body of
 Herman Rosenthal

New York. Nov. 15.--The case for the defense in the trial of the four men accused of Killing the gambler Herman Rosenthal, was completed to- day.
 Harry Vallon and Bridgie Webber and an unidentified stranger had fired the fatal shot at the gambler, that three of the defendants, "Gyp the Blood Lefty Louie" and "Whitey'' Lewis, were on the scene only as Innocent spectators and that the fourth, Dago Frank, was not there at all.
 'Dago Frank, a diamond pin fash Ing, from his tie. gold watch chain dangling from a waistcoat of tue latest cut. told cn the stand as the first witness of the day, the story that purported to be his alibi on the night of the murder.
 He left Gyp, Lefty, and Whitey. at Bridgie Webber's poker rooms just after ne mysterious stranger had in- vited them all to go to the hotel Met
 
 see Jack Rose, he sard. He went to the home of his girl, he swore. When he got there he found that she had been arrested and he went to the police station to bail her out. It was not until then he heard of the nslrder of Herman Rosenthal.
 Then followed testimony from the lips of woman which corroborated the stories told yesterday by the other three defendants, that Webbes and Vallon were the real gunmen in the case. The witness was Mary Kidd, who was selling newspapers, and who swore that she saw four men fitting the description of Rose, Webber. Vallon and Schepps, in a group of the hotel, and the shots fired came from that group She did not see the four defendants there al all, she said. John Hickey. a bar tender swore he saw Rosenthal shot at by a man whose description in some particulars fitted that given by the gunmen of the mysterious strangers and others of 'TBridgie' Webber. He saw other men fire but could not see their faces, John Reis- Ter, barber, testified that he saw "Bridgie" Webber running from the Escene.
 Were any of those four men standing in front of the theatre or any of those three whom you saw shooting among those defendants? asked MT. Wahle.
 T didn't see any of them" Mrs. Kidd replied, and added that she had visited the West Side prison where Rose, Webber, Vallon and Schepps are locked Up to see if she could identify any of the quaTtette as the real gunmen. She couldn't do SO 1 she dec.ared.
 Mrs. Mary Kydd, who followed Reisler on the stand in the afternoon testified that she saw four men stand ing in front of a theatre adjoining the hotel shortly before the murder She offered them papers, they told her, she should move on, and she did so. Soon she heard shots. T turned around and saw three men fire shots, she said. They were of the group l saw at the theatre One was tall and had a bald head | Mrs. Kydd then gave a description of Rose, Webber, vallon and Schepps The man who filled Vallon's des- | cription, was drunk, she said. Mrs. Lefty Louie Rosenberg. blond haired, pink checked, doll faced, tes tified next. She corroborated the story of her husband and the other l gun men. Her sister, next tesGhed that the gunmen had been in Rock away the Sunday before the murder Alexander Luhan, brother of Morris Luban, one of the states eye witnes ses of the murder, testified that his borther was in Brooklyn at the houi Rosenthal was killed
 So did Bertha Feldman, Alexander Lubans step-daughter. Chas Pint messenger boy, testified that he de livered message at "Dago Franks home about five minutes of 4," ths morning of the murder.
 Giovanni Stannish was then re ca led and Rose, Webber, Vallon ant Schepps were brought into the cour room and lined up. After the quaTte had answered to their names so tha the jury might recognize them, Stan
 sh was asked if he had seen an, of them in the vicinity of the Metro II pole at the time of the murder.
 T did not he replied.
 The gunmen turned in their seatl and the sneers and savage glare, t&t passed between the two guar tettes who faced each other in on' room for the first time since thei arrest. excited the keen interest o the spectators
 The informers will be called in re butta by the state tomorrow was upon the understanding tha