Evening bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu, Hawaii]) 1895-1912, 1912-04-15
TEST
Vote IS Won
Continued from Page ~

that there were present delegates
holdlhg certncates OF erection whose
names were not on the roll ana moved
tnat Iheir names ne added. Chair-
ina, cooper ruieu tnat 'hey eouId De
they hau cer'iHcates'
w c. Achi then rose and moved that
the name OF l.. Weinzheimer be strick-
en- from the roll on the ground that he
was not citizen when he was elect
ed from Lahaina, and was not elected
according to party rules.
NJ. +. Prosser raised point of
order that this could not be done by
the convention at that time, but was
up to the Credentials Committee.
Chairman Cooper sustained the
point at once.
II. l.. Holstein Jumped to his feet
and declared the point was debateable.
1--WE want fair play" declared Hol-
stein, and then the cheers broke out.
Holstein asked that Cooper withdraw
his ruling.
Cooper started to call for q vote on
the ruling but Holstein Immediately
said that no appeal had been taken
and simply reiterated his request that
the ruling be withdrawn.
THE Chair will allow debate"
ruled Cooper.
Achi then opened the debate trans
lating his own remarks. II was ev-
ident that the scrap was on for every
point.
Il have the record here before me
showing conclusively that MIR. Weinz-
heimer was not citizen when he was
oil "A asln ,.I Al .s.,l.t
document.
According to the rulings of the
party. he was not qualified" he in
sisted. Cooper asked that Achi's mo-
ton be reduced to writing and Achi
Immediately did so.
John Wise arose and declared, I'VE
also want fair play" bringing up the
argument that the objection must 20
before the Rules Committee. The
Frear faction got in their cheers then.
I'VE will abide by the decision of
the committee" he said. and moved
that Achi's motion be tabled, and G.
A. Rice of Kauai seconded IT, This
Immediately provoked another qucs-
tioning of points of order.
George X. Carter rose for informa-
ton.
There are a few of us here who
are lone buffaloes," he said, "and we
want to know when the question is to
be settled whether names should go
on" and here he stumbled and said
Temporary payroll instead of TEN
porary roll" The innocent break
caused roar of laughter. when is
this to be decided?" he repeated.
The Chair put the question of tabl-
ing Achi's motion and there was tu-
multi of both ayes" and noes" Al
division and roll call was then called
for.
WeinZheimer did not vote. The
ayes won. SO to 10. The first blood.
slight as II was, was drawn by the
Frear forces. 80 .l IS
Harry Murray then moved that the
question OF Weinzheimer's eligibility
be referred TO the Credentials commit
tee, this carrying Achis motion with
1t. The motion was carried quickly
without any more skirmishihg.
cooper then called Tor nominations
for temporary chairman. Judge Dole
rose ana IN rev words nominated
w. W. Harris.
George X. Carter rose to introduce
H. H. iio'S'eIm' ne pInIseu MS am
IVY as Pa'l'uiiieh'ai'a Ia" anu eul'eu
10 I., 'n'ee "' " m, 49, 49,, So
WIN M"i w INC NUM- '"e"
anu os"eTs 40 wen, ,-,
rreu nechIey secoHueu hoisteln
nomination anu iooN 0oSasioh W reiel
W tIe uos ea'ihs ,o's h,e,hho,
.ne I,u""l'ahs were u"ooeu ny Il" AZ
'eTnoon paper; -
pechley "i"ue " N'sorous speeo" ~
i'awu,ian.
Desna "'on r .'at Tue mountainous
ne cloSeu' inere was no u'sseh' u
inns.
.oopel lhen asNeu the ues'Ie VI .he
convention us 10 voting Ath'nSoh
nioNeu ioF u pa'io,, anu oonn WISE
iio'eu 10 "ihenu the morton 10 make
Ihe No,ihs On announcement ny easn
uelesa.e. IL was tne mrs. CRASH Oh 'he
open anu cioseu oaiiot hethous:
rreu pechiey rose anu ueciareu that
,he wisest metnod was the closed Dai-
iot' as wou'u remove Tue ueiesa'es
IRON ,ae rear Oh .heir empowers.
NJ r. rrosser declared that secret