davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The Washington herald., 1912-02-12

What's in a name?'' is an old, old
query, but since the selection of William
B. Mckinley to be the Taft manager in
the open, the sentimental citizens have
insisted that even the name of McKin-
ley will have a moral effect for good
among Republicans the country over, es-
peciaIly' among conservative voters who
have not forgotten the business revival
that followed the great campaign Of 1896
and the subsequent domination OF party
affairs in practical way by that Will
lam Mckinley and his chief of stan,
Mark Hanna
Every other Republican at the Capitol
and at the downtown assembly places Of
politicians had something to say about
the mere sentiment of the Mckinley
name associated with the Taft cam
paign.
The one hope was that the Illinois
manager may develop some Of the Mark
Hanna methods OF campaign manage
ment. II was evident that .he new leader
is impressed with what is expected of
him, for he was an early breakfast call
er. at the willard yesterday. and in con-
sultation with political wise ones from
many States long before some OF the
statesmen resident at the hotel had
finished their grapefruit. 1t was noted.
too. that every Republican who happened
to reach the hotel early enough to meet
The Washington herald., 1912-02-12
Serious Business.

To guard against mistake or fiaw,
In any clause or line,
It takes a lawyer now TO draw
A proper valentine.
The Washington herald., 1912-02-12

Now in his fifty-sscond year. NJ. Poin-
care. Is a broad-shouldered. weII-set-up
man. with mustaehe and short beard
The Washington herald., 1912-02-12

From the Boston Herald.
Secretary Wilson seems to be up. for
carrying concealed reports.
The Washington herald., 1912-02-12

Solicitor McCabe, ,in Washington. seems
born to make trouble, as the sparks fly
upward.
The Washington herald., 1912-02-12

There ought to be the opportunity for
a lot of play on words about muck rak-
ing in connection with the Everglades in
vestigatiOn.
The Washington herald., 1912-02-12

From The Charleston News and Courier.
Secretary Wilson never drinks. but the
Department Of Agriculture certainly is
loaded.
The sun., 1912-07-21
QUEENS GAMBIT DECLINED.

The nrst eight moves In this and the three fol-
lowing games are Identical with those I'm thr
s,,k hi -veic oh
The sun., 1912-07-21

td) As hIack Intended 70 remove the knight even
without compulson, u more useful move mig hi
have been made inskad Of the attack on tie
Uishop. BIKE or B-k2 for Instance,
lbl There Is no Blhdfaden Ia Marshall's conduct
Of the game.
initiated with whites IL, Bxkt,
ID, II 49, QxR IN. then II; R-R dis. ch.
Nl K-R might be considered.
" P-QRt would be followed by 29 R-K: "a
R-k, R-OR, &c,
ieJ IL ". ..R-Bs ch, then n. XXX. and II n.
RyR. then white would get the opposition.
IN The game was given up As drawn after
blacks nlty. third move, but the cn,l Icing de
iectvey recorded. We leave II out.
4. A
The sun., 1912-07-21

White--5 Pieces
White to play and mate In 3 moves.
PROBLEM NO. 2,s. by y. MAXIMow.
Black P!ecks
The sun., 1912-07-21

Correct solutions to both these problems re-
cclvri from Smoke Shop. New Britain Conn :
6 Mate. East Orange, y j; Miss * Z De,parr.,
New York city; kohtrt II. HlSon. T. D. LOTUS
New York; : :, Lane. New York city
correct solution received 20 40 273 from Nor
man !. Perry. nroniiyn. y y: G. j winchester.
bc'lpurt. l. |. ". q stevens brooklyn. Y
correct solutions received TO No az fro,r Rob
crt bawcrman. NcW York city: Charle- W MI
hc"gan, NLN York city
NJ i''onal correct solution received to No.
2'2 from II. II Cleveland lakcIille. Conn.
CoRREsPoNnENCE.
W. q. stevens In sending your solutions give
the principal variations OF tlire, movers hnd IN,
kc' MOI" only 10 two movers
Harold Elliot New Rrichton v Y-Tur Srx
can looS A. positions only, II they are property
diagrarnct ''
\ = Btv>owe-Wc shall look at the rnue In
question and let yon know In due time
CHECKERs
No. lse, by Capt Frank Roy 10 II. 25 IS
"a Y v" 10 80. is t-ii - 81
~ 81. -, Sig. 5-lt, ard white wins
RORkHr II. HixoS.
The sun., 1912-07-21
as he loses q piece as played. The game. a very
bad one, Is over nov.

t1) Not without risk. but anything short Of a
downright bad move "a preferable 30 n dun game,
Nh Boldly answering with an immcdatc,toun-
ter attack.
game.
ID, An extremely di'Hcult game. requiring the
masters.
ul The best place for the rooh. y q. K-R,'
then 27 B--E'3 followed b. II KS
" " AZ KSR then s r rs E-KtI.
40 PAKt. P1r; ~. Rsp, k-pA; 81: RK7, With
draw, As played. he kept possibility ofw'nn'ns
still In hand
10, Maroc,y play: now his last trump card.
securing draw.
hl highly Interesting game.
Evening journal., 1912-07-20
MET And WED
In TWO WEEKS

Speed in so far as courtship and
marriage are concerned, Isn't entire-
ly the prerogative Of highly
tempermental people, as witness the
record OF two young York road peo-
pie.
George Watkins, Of Keenan, street,
La Mott, was introduced TO Miss Ellz-
abeth Meary, of Oak Lane, Pa, while
both were indulging in a plate of ice
cream in a Philadelphia suburban
"parlor" two weeks proceeding Tues
day last. Other plates of ice cream
followed the same evening, but
on other and successive evenings
Their friends hardly expected that
an outing planed for last Tuesday by
the young people meant a trip to
Wilmington and visit to the Rev
George L. Wolfe, with the perform
ance of the marriage ceremony.
The young people returned to the
cuburban section, and Watson admit
ted teh marriage last night. The
young couple will live on North S6th
street, near Greene, Philadelphia
Evening journal., 1912-07-20
A
DIFFERENCE
Which DO You Consider the
Best and Why?

Since the publishing OF our talks
on The merits Of Dry Cleaning and
advising the public against allowing
their clothing aud valuable garments
to be secured. there has been some
comment on the results to be OBJ
tained. Now there Is vast differ
ence end We know the result and
the appearance OF the garment after
it has been subjected TO the different
forms But We feel confident that the
public does not and cannot tell when
q suit comes from the cleaning estab-
ishmcnt whsther n has been dry
cleaned OF secured. Hundreds and
thousands of suits have been scour-
ed and double that amount have been
dry cleaned; In all cases, no doubt
the customer has been pleased with
his or her suit upon It's return from
the cleaners. but VIC doubt very
much il they can tell II il has been
secured or dry cleaned What We
are anNious 70 know Is If the public
can tell what difference the garment
has in appearance after It has been
subjected to the two forms aud their
candid opinion as TO which OF them
is the best and give their reasons
why one is superior 10 the other
We use hut one form Of cleaning
and that is the Rebuilt System Of
Dry Cleaning and through this sys-
tenn We are able TO clean the most
delicate garments without the least
fear OF damaging them or changing
the color. Consult us for any ad-
vice on cleaning or dyeing by phone,
card or in person. Wilmington Steam
Dye Works, zoe West Fourth street.
Phone connection.
Evening journal., 1912-07-20
NEWS OF The
WEEK in REALTY

Plans have been completed by Ros-
coe c. Tindall, architect, for a modern
printing office in Kennett Square for
Charles Hadley. It is TO be mis-
sion style building 25 feet square and
two stories high. It will be con-
structcd Of hollow tile with a stained
shlngle roof and will cost about
S35OO
The four houses on the northeast
corner Of Twcnty-fourth and Madison
streets, designed by Mr.. Tindall for
Mrs Lillian Tindall, are nearing COM
pletion. They are TO cost about $12,-
600. and will be modern IN every par
ticular W. J. Johnson is the con-
tractor
Plans and specifications for alter
ations and additions to the residence
of Albert Rothchilds, on West street.
between Eighth aud Ninth streets, have
been completed by J. and NJ Kennedy
who will advertise for bids next week
Extensive improvements are TO be
made by the Street Department OF
Berlin, Nd, IN the next few months
on the streets Of the town. This Is
the first street work that has been
done In tho city for two years, and
there has been a demand by the resi-
dents Of the town that the bad condi-
ton Of the streets be remedied.
Herbert Hatton, consulting engineer
Of this city, will have charge Of the
work, and is drawing the plans. In
few days he will advertise for bids
u is expected that the new improve
ments will cost about $4,000 The
city will also spend about $4,000 ON
It's water and light departments
Elmer b. Mcdaniel has sold.
through O. g. Gooden, real estate
broker, to the Wilmington Automo-
bile Company the stable, No. 1i0-112
West Eleventh street. for $4,000. The
price is said to be the highest ever
paid for a stable in Wilmington The
acquisition OF the stable increases the
automobile company's holdings all the
way from Tenth TO Eleventh streets.
Mr.. Mcdaniel will continue his stable
business there as usual until Octo-
Der.
The following additional properties
were sold recently through the Good
iH AkHnNN
No. 2l4 connell, to Ellen McLaugh-
lin. for $4,000
No. 9Ol Adams street, to z. c. Clark,
$4,000.
No. sos East Third street, TO John
Putczkus. S1,500.
No. 1907 Poplar street, to John
Hahn. Sl.525.
No sos Windsor street. to George
Miller $3.50
No. 1919 Delaware avenue. to Mar
garet Lundy s275O.
No, 2906 West Second street, 10
Elizabeth Hayden. S1.450.
No. 224 North Harrison street, 10
Bridget Clancy. Sl,625
No. 70i Monroe street, to Amanda
Hammond, $500.
Richardson Park house TO Edgar
Harvey. S2,700
Lot, Sixth street and Ogle avenue.
TO Alfred Swan, s1,300
Country residence near Brandywine
Springs, to George Starr, $500.
Evening journal., 1912-07-20
FENTON BEACH

Twenty members Of Troop No. "A
Boy Scouts of America, pitched camp
on the beach front Lear the light house
reservation to-day and will remain
two weeks. The camp will be known
as Camp Raymond L. Woiven. The
advance guard Of the boys arrived ON
the beach at o'clock and Immediately
proceeded TO get things ready for the
main body of Scouts which arrived
later in the day. The boys will bc
commanded by Scout Master Frank
NJ. Heal, who joined them at
o'clock
A considerable portion Of the new
boardwalk has been completed, while
the new bath house at Recreation
Beach is entirely finished The floor
ing Of the dance hall will be com-
pleted to-day.
Work will be started on another new
cottage on Monday TO be occupied hy
its owner the remainder OF the sea
son.
The Misses Amanda and Alice Pal
mer have Joined their brother, George
Palmer, at the Chick-Ho- -Hoc-Kee
Lodge, for the remainder of the sum.
mer.
Miss Audrey Stayton, daughter Of
Albertus E. Stayton, holds the record
for the largest catch of crabs of the
pier. The crabs are beginning 70 r'ig
TO some size and the sport is good.
Water was struck at a depth of four
teen feet in the grove, where a well
was driven yesterday.
Harry Schrade is building q back
porch TO the Dorothy" Cottage.
Wants .re o,,cl IN action and cosI
Evening journal., 1912-07-20
nrsn1nr1oNs or RnspEoT

AZ the meeting Of the Volunteer Fire.
mems Relief Association held on tbs lath
inst the following resolutions were
adopted
Whereas. Death having visited us for the
first time. snd severed the association OF
ono Of its noble and true members in
JOSEPH X. ADAMS,
Who passed away on tho 18th day OF july
1912 Therefore be n
Resolved. That IN che death Of eur late
fellow fireman and member, the associaticn
has lost one Of iis members who haA always
been faithful and ei6ci.nt IN enc workings
Of the late company, Of which the deceased
was ono q the oldest members. having ine
hirhest esteem Of Ell the members, as vel
- an Who were acqusinted and had occasion
10 sfsocisto with the deceased one Be II
Resolved, That We do most sincerely ~
press our most heartfelt and profound sorrow
Tor his untimcly death, and ofer our deep
csf svmpsthy 70 his zricf.ttricken family IN
their sad bereavement.
Reroived. That our Erief is universal, ana
20 testify the respects Of thc inemherf 81
the volunteer Firemen's Relief Association.
that We now adjourn, and that copy o ne
ssro bo conveyed 20 tho femily OF the
W j. Lutr.
II. Y. Farrell.
(Cammittee) H. Meponough,
y y McGoidrick
Al. Cross.
Evening journal., 1912-07-20
FISHERMEN
HAVE GOOD LUCK
Large Catches Of Trout by
Net Are Reported From
Delaware City

DELAWARE CITY, Del, July 20
Fishermen are catching trout now
with nets. One party from here re-
Gently caught over three dozen trout
with hook and line. Fishing with
hook and line is also being enjoyed
by many fishing parties in the canal.
Bass fishing has also grown very
popular
Arthur Heathers who was injured
recently, is improving.
Mrs. William Ball, Miss Mildred
Ball and Miss Louise Droescher we're
Wilmington visitors on Wednesday.
James H. Clark, owner of the
Majors Wharf" az the foot Of Clin-
ton street, has placed notices. for
bidding trespassing upon the wharf
and thus ending swimming from that
point
In addition TO the improvements
which were recently completed at the
Presbyterian Church, new floor has
been commenced.
Albert Hemphil, who recently be-
came member OF tho Boy Scouts OF
Pennsylvania, is now enjoying q
camping trip with his companions at
Chsdds Ford, Pr.
The new storage battery car for the
line operating between here and New
Castle has been finished. The car Is
built with double trucks. Is 80 feet
long and is a combination freight
and passenger car. The car is of the
latest type and has the latest inn
provements.
A pleasant trip on the tug Dixie
owned by the Southern Transports
ton Co., was given by Captain Car
row on Tuesday evening.
Arthur Davenport, Of Philadelphia,
was a visitor here on Thursday.
James II. Clark, is having improve
ments made TO his building at the
foot of Clinton street
William Ball, proprietor OF the Del
aware City Hotel has bought the g.
yoar-old colt Prince March. The colt
promises much speed.
Twilight service will be held on
the green in front OF the chapel OF
the Methodist Episcopal Church. be-
ginning next Saturday evening, july
81, at GAS o'clock, and continuing
during the summer. The Rev. G. n
Jones VIII conduct the services.
Work on the road on Fifth street
has not been begun yet. as tho farm
ers are busy with their crops.
The annual picnics OF the Presby-
terian Church and of Christ Episcopal
Church were held at Augustine Beach
on Thursday.
The dance given by the DUPONT
Dancing Club on Wednesday night
was largely attended. Music was
furnished by the Thirteenth Coast
Artillery Corps Band.
Soldiers at Fort Mott, n. j., and al
Fort Dupont were paid on Friday.
Grabbing is being very much on
ioyed here
The dance given by the Fort Dupont
Post team on last Saturday night net.
ted s4S.50.
The annual picnic of st. Paul's
Catholic Church will take place a
Augustine Beach on Thursday. july
25th.
All the farmers about here report
large hay crops.
George A. Bilger of Cape May, n
j.. Howard Smith. OF Cape May; Fl
Meyers. of Chicago; A. Dixon, OF
Wilmington; W. A. Harrison, Of VIII
mington; John A. Heckert, Of Sha-
mokin and J. G.. Davis, Of Auburn
n. Y, were recent guests at the Del.
aware City Hotel.
Evening journal., 1912-07-20
REsoLurroNs on nrsPEor.

At tho meeting Of the Volunteer Fire.
men Association held on the ] 3lh inst, the
following resolutions were adopted.
Whereas. Death having visited MS fer the
second time. and severed the association OF
one Of its noble and true members In
JOHN NAY,
who passed away on the 18th day Of July,
1912. Therefore, be IL
Resolved. That 10 the death OF our late
fellow fireman aud member, the association
has lost one Of its members who has always
been faithful and efficient IN tho workings
Of tho late company. OF which the deceased
was ono Of The oldest members, having tho
highest esteem 81 al the members, as well
&C. all who we're acquainted and had occasion
60 associate with the deceased one. Bo IL
Resolved Thai we do most sincerely eN-
press our most heartfelt and profound sorrow
for his untimely death and offer our deep
est sympathy 90 his grcf-sirickcn family 10
their sad bereavement.
Resolved. That our grief Is universal, ana
10 testify The respects Of tho members Of
the Volunteer Firemen's 8 Relief Association.
that NC now adjourn, aud that copy of the
same be conveyed 20 tho family Of tho
deceased
.s. T. Luty,
NJ. v Farrell.
(Committesl H. McDonough
T. J. McGoldrict,
A j. CrocH.
Evening journal., 1912-07-20
nrArH on MRS. 4. E. TuTH1LL

special 10 THE EVENING JOURNAL.
MILFORD, Del, July 20--Mrs. A.
r Tuthill. after an illness Of several
months Of heart trouble, died at her
home last night aged 75 years. She
was the wife of A. f. Tuthill, for
mer superintendent of the Baptist
Sunday school, and an enthusiastic
member of the Sakimas Tribe OF
Red Men.
Funeral services weer held this
afternoon from her late residence. the
Rev Mr.. Savage and Rev. W. r. Now
bray officiating. Mrs. Tuthill is survived
by husband, one daughter. who lives
at home, and one son, Charles T. Tut
hill, who is in the employ of the
government at Washington, d. c.
Evening journal., 1912-07-20
STRICAEN WITH APPENDICITIS.

Harry Barber. a grain merchant Of
Pennsgrove, was stricken with appen-
dicitis while returning home from
Wilmington on the steameT Ulrica on
Thursday and is now in St Joseph's
Hospital. critically III after an opera
ton. Mrs. Barber IS at her husbands
bedside.
Evening journal., 1912-07-20
NEWARK FINES SCHOOL TAX.

Special to THE EVENING JOURNAL
NEWARK, July 20.-At a meeting
of the Board Of Education Of Newark
last night the tax rate for school pur-
poses was fixed at $3.50 on the 500 or
assessed valuation. AS the rate was
not increased beyond $3.50 the board
will now get the $500 from the trus-
tees OF the Newark Academy.
The total assessment for school pur-
poses is about s33O,OOO, an increase OF
$4,000 over last year.
Evening journal., 1912-07-20
BULLET CL0sE no HAND.

Special to THE EVENING JOURNAL
GEORGETOWN, Del, July 20
While Walter Conway. son Of Mr..
and Mrs. Richard Conaway of Kim
mey street. was attempting TO remove
bullets from pistol which he had
taken from a sideboard, the weapon
was discharged and ball grazed his
left hand. Mr. Conway is brother
OF Mrs. NJ. B. Hickman. of No. sos
Concord avenue, Wilmington
Evening journal., 1912-07-20
FINANCIAL AND COMMERCIAL.

BY The United Press
NEW YORK, July 2O.-The market
opened steady
c. /. Hudson G Co. say:
Take profits on any bule and do
not buy back except on weak spots. &"
F. d. Lackey & Co. say:
1T is expected a batter range of
prices will be seen next week"
Evening journal., 1912-07-20
ANOTHER MR. pICKERsON.

Alfred Dickerson of Marshallton.
called at THE EVENING JOURNAL
Office today and requested publication
Of the fact that he is not the A. Dick
erson, who is advertising in these col
umns thai he will not pay any bills
except those contracted by himself
Evening journal., 1912-07-20
ALL.STARs TRra nLFORD.

Special to THE EVENING JOURNAL
MILFORD. Del. July 20-The ALI
stars. of Washington, D c., defeated
Milford yesterday to 2. William
Ramsey. of the firm OF Smith & Rom
sey acted as umpire Of strikes and
Norman Shaw of the bases.
Goldsborcugh Isaacs had all of the
horses, carriages, vehicles and all Of
his personal property seized by
Sheriff Raughley.
Evening journal., 1912-07-20

The hosts Of home helpers who play
such an important part in many
households are in most cases engaged
through the Want Ads.---Adv.
Evening journal., 1912-07-20
BANK CLEARINGs.

Clearings Of the local banks for the
week ending today. amounted to SlS,-
1889 as compared with sl6,729.4S,
for the corresponding week of last
year.
Evening journal., 1912-07-20
DEATHS.

John NJ. BsdweIl.
Mrs. william Finnorty.
Jane N. Hughes.
Patrick Ryan.
BEDwELL--In this city, on July 10, 1919
John NJ. Bcdwell. in his 63rd year.
Relatives, friends and members Of Dia
mond Council, No. ., Jr. o. c. A NJ, srI
invited to attend the funeral services At bill
Monday afternoon, July %, at 4 o'clock. In
terment private at Silverbrook cemetery.
FINERTY-In this city. on July 10, 1919
Helen, wife OF William r. Finerty.
Relatives and friends arc invited 10 NJ
tend the funeral services al hor late resi-
dence, no, A00 South Head street, Of
Monday afternoon, at $50 O'Clock. Inter
nent al kivcrvicw cemetery
HUGHEs-In this city. on July IS, 1919
Jane NJ. widow OF John II. Hughes, in bel
53rd year.
Relatives. friends and members Of Dia
m0nd State Lodge. No 1. Order star q
Bethlehem are invited 10 attend the funera
from her late residence No. 6Z3 West fhirI
street. on Monday afternoon July %. 81 ..sl
O clock Services az It, John 2 4
church ~ g O'Clock. Iuterm mt Wilmingtol
and Brandywine cemetery.
RYAN--In this city. ON July is, 1919
Patrick Ryan
Relatives and friends arc invited 20 al
tend the funeral FROM the residence Of h
son.in.law, John r. Dorchcrty, n. ". CoH
Reed aud jackson streets, on Monday mord
ing. at 9 o'clock Requiem mass at 81
Paui's church. Interment at Cathedrd
cemetery.
Evening journal., 1912-07-20
FINANCIAL AND COMMERCIAI

Reported Daily by r. d. Lackey &
Co.. brokers and bankers. members
Philadelphia stock Exchange. St2
Market Street.
AZ ,s,f,.t- ,,,,.t,.,o..
Evening journal., 1912-07-20
qu1oK coNsuMpr1oN.

Brazilian Balm has Gu t.oussncs-nev.
eY lost ease; also eatarrh, typhoid. scarlet
fever reasles and oil other contagious dis.
sAses. KILLS THE GERMS.
B. J. JACKSON q CO.. Chemists .Areada.N.Y
Evening journal., 1912-07-20

The Wants arc of vital interest to
Evening journal., 1912-07-20

THE WILTSHIRE yiiiFsls.'s yiiss.,.s Az : BsasgP
>. Private baths; hot ard cold rnnnins va.
ter in rooms eicvators; music spceiai $3.50
NJ weekly SS.5o up daily. Booklet
SAMUEL. ELLIS
Evening journal., 1912-07-20
Fireprooi
HOTEL NERYlNE

New York Ave. ist house from Beach,
Private baths. hunrin- wstfr IN rooUs
Bathing Allowed irom Hotel
hatsf. o. m daily. So 20 sif.so ~sstiy
Evening journal., 1912-07-20

ATLANTIC CITY ASsoRTs
Evening journal., 1912-07-20
CbancellOr's Attitude.

'@hAhNNAANA = hNlAUNtf
Chancellor Curtis also read a state
ment Of his attitude setting forth that
he Is still open-minded as to the
Journal entry and enrolled bill doc
trine and that he will file his opinion
accepting one or the other doctrines
prior TO the next regular session Of
the Srnreme Court. Chancellor Cur
tie IN his oninion. said:
The retitioner urges as one ground
reinst the right 10 take his land the
Failure Of the legislature 70 comply
with the constitutional requirements
lor the validity Of the passage Of the
Act under which the corpora
tilon seeking TO take his land
WIS incorporated. In the argument Of
this point. counsel referred only TO
the case of Rash-Allen. For the petit
toner. It was urged that applying the
principles Of that case the Act was not
validly enacted. and for the defen-
dants that the two cases can be dis
tinguished and, further, that the Act
was validly enacted. whether the doc
trine adopted in that case by the
court, or that advocated in the dissent
ing opinion. be applied here.
The case Of Rash vs. Allen was
heard by the FIVE law judges. sitting
as court ia banc land not including
the chancellor who Is never a mem
Der of that court 20 determine cause
then pending in the Superior Court
and there three members Of it adopted
Brownsville herald. [volume] (Brownsville, Tex.) 1910-current, 1912-10-12
TO TEST POSTAL REGULATION.

The New York Journal of Com
merce has instituted proceedings to
test the validity of the recent act OF
congress requiring newspapers to
make public exhibits of their private
business twice a year.
Newspapers generally will be
grateful to the Journal of Commerce
for taking the lead in this matter.
1t IS hard for anyone who has OBJ
tanned his ideas of the freedom OF
the press from the fathers of the
press from the fathers of the consti-
tuition to believe the law is consti-
tutional.
Newspaper people cheerfully obey
the law like other good citizens. but
they have something more than a
faint suspicion that the act COM
planned Of il not a good law.