New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1912-06-22

ond call. voting with the TAFT mon to tab'
/ the minority report.
/ The vote vas 6oj 10 lsi this time. and
the big Taft victory called ont cheer.
! The plan OF Governor lIadley 10 force \
rolcall on tho motion 70 adopt tho major
III, report was abandoned after this de-
cisive vote, and the report vas put through
/ viva voce.
/ Pending further report from the com
mittee on credentials Senator Root an
nounced the convention would rest arms.
/ Governor McGovcrn stated that tho
change in Wisconsins vote was due TO the
| fact that tho Wisconsin members OF tho
national committee and OF tie committee
on credentials had sustained IN" contested
delegates
! we have no facts on which 20 dispute
! their judgment and therefore vot" 20 sns.
| tain them" no said
! \ similar explanation vas made On he
! half ~ ldatJ Chairman Cruzeu ~ The
| Idaho delegation said:
we are Republicans and Nc arc NOT 20
ing TO s.t IN our seats without voting
Arizona's List Confirmed.
i'c q lllHI| Isi''l " -HF'l l'.II d-t|. tl -sf
O'Clock. and the report on the Arizona con.
tests Was presented seating TAFT delegate
NJ. sullivan. Of Ohio, was recognized e.
present the Vows OF the minority on tho
Arizona cases and read bricf statement
The same parliamentary tactics that
marked tho Alabama cases vorc folloo 81
Sullivan moved the adoption Of The
minority report, and Watson moved that
it be tabled 4 rollcar was demanded
Idaho and Wisconsin switched hack r.
the Roosevelt column on this proposition
but the minority report was tabled. -
10 90. and rollcall was not Iomande'
when the motion 10 adopt the nlaiorit'
report was put and carried.
A viva voc" vote adopted motion b.
Watson 10 table IIadlcy's motion ~ sub
stitu'c the minority for the ma iority rcpor
IN tho 5th Arkansas District Anoth"
viva ,oce vote adopted the majority ropor
and ROLES was avoided
California Stirs Delegates.
". T Doycu of WASHINGTON. brough
I'm the credentials committees report N
the th California District seating the ~
Taft delegates end moved i,s adoption
The report set forth that the vote in IN
Attn Congress District elected Tryon an
MeyerGcld. Taft candidates although fl
the state wide vote tho Roosevelt delegate
received a majority of 1850 Tho commit
tee held that the state primary Law whic
did not provide q vote by districts coul
not superscdc the call issued b. the ma
tional committee, which distinctly provide
for representation In the convention b.
Congress districts
Groans boots and Kisses from the Call
fornie delegation greeted the statement Il
the report that the California primary lay
would i'm effect enfoIce tho unit rule 4
it, delegation and the further statomeu
that the national convention. and not stat
laws. Is the supreme source Of party regu
larity
Hugh r. Hslbert Of Minnesota brough
In the minority report. donouncing the seat
ing Of the Taft delegates as the "tyranul
cal overthrow OF the Will OF the people q
California
This is case Of the most nagrant in
Justice" he shouted, "and should not b
tolerated"
Mr. Halbert tried 10 make a speech, bu
was forced to desist by disorder.
Mr.. Watson. the Taft floor leader. NOV
that the minority report be laid on tn
table but PENDING that nc asked tha
twenty minutes be allowed for discussion
His motion was greeted with jeers an
cries Of "Hadley! Hadley! iiadley,'
The Missouri Governor rose from hi
place on the stage, and the noise subsidized
Senator Root put the request for unani
nous conacnt for debate, and II va
granted.