Bisbee daily review., 1912-02-29
DISAGREE
 ON SELECTION OF
 BASKET BALL TEAM
Ei PaSo and Bisbee Au- thoritieS Hold Differ
 ent Views
ALL SOUTHWESTERN


 Physical Director E. N Robinson of the Bisbee Y. NJ. C. A. who refereed the basket ball games in the Gouth- western basket ball tournament in which the Bisbee team was Lot en- gagged was asked yesterday by ,ne Re view to select an All-SOutnwesteln basket ball team MT. Robinson was unanimously voted by the players to be the best referee of basket ball in the southwest and his selection of an All-Southwestern team will be given general recognition in the southwest.
 Mir RObinson's selection follows:
 L. Robertson, E. P. II. S. forward.
 Chenoweth, F. P. Nj. |, forward.
 Johnson. F. P. Ri. ]. center.
 F. Champion. Bisbee guard.
 Roy Brenton, Bisbee, guard.
 This was the line up that was picked by Physical Director Mitchell of the Fl Paso. Y NJ. C. A.. also.
 II is all a matter of opinion, Mir. Robinson said. but the selections of Messrs. Robinson and Mitchell may be accepted as being less biased and more nearly correct than any other selec- tion.
 The Fl Paso Herald's sporting editor selected the following:
 Wayne Chenoweth F. ?. M l., for ward.
 Robert Hoover. E. P. NJ. l.. forward
 Mortimer Johnson, E. P. M l., cen ter.
 Lace Rumsey, Fl Paso "Y". guard. Harold King. Fl Paso "Y', guard.
 The Herald's choice for a second team was as follows:
 Jose Peralta, Fl Paso 'Y'', center.
 Lee Evans. Fl Paso ~, forward.
 Vernon Lyman. E. P H S. forward.
 Frank Champion Bibee. guard.
 Roy Benton. Bisbee. guard.
 This selection was made Of course for home consumption and is absolute. " no good for practical purposes. For instance it gives the Fl Paso M. l., three places on the first team. yet assumes the other two men of the championship team are not good enough even for a second team, the scrub team"
 The two guard positions in the Heralds estimate are given to the Fl Paso '. NJ. C. A., a team which the Bisbee team had no trouble in de- teating by the score of 21 to 9. As a matter of fact. the Fl Paso ''Y's' second team scored the only points in that game that were made against Bisbee. The Herald's selections will do for pink tea favors, but as an im- partial all-southwestern selection it is about as unfair as Jim Corbetts dope"
 The claims of Louis Robertson Of the Fl Paso high school, picked by Robin son and Mitchell of the Fl Paso and Bisbee gyms, are entirely overlooked by the Herald in its selection and the place is given Hoover of the E. P. NJ. l. T have been watching Rob ertson for two seasons" said Robin son yesterday and l predicted last year that he would be a star in another season and his work in the tOurna- ment justified my prediction. Hoover is a good forward, but ! should not give them a place on the first team. The Herald does not even give the Fl Faso high school boy a place on the second team. This notwithstanding that Louis Robertson has the sea sons record for free throws, his score being 31 points.
 Johnson of the F.. P. M. l. who is accorded the center posi- tion on the All-SOuthwestern team, was picked last year on the all-star New England team and holds the New England record for the largest number Of baskets made in one game, twenty two.