The times dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1903-1914, 1912-11-21

New York, November 20.-Otl was
poured ON the troubled waters at the
horse show to-day. the decisions OF the
judges throughout the day being more
in accord with the popular idea. pro-
duced results that grained the crowd
and served to soften the feelings or
those who made the hostile demon
stratton in Madison Square Garden on
Tuesday afternoon.
Az ]. W. Hartman did not show to-
day. there was no opportunity to MAKE
up to him the loss Of the blue by Lady
DiIham and Elegant Dilham, and IN
fact IL was stated at the garden that
Mr.. Hartman himself had no fault to
ana with the decisions VI the judges
in placing Meneila and Phyllis over
his sterling pair Of harness horses.
The gathering gloom Of the faces OF
the English visitors was partially eis-
PEELED when Miss Mona Dunn at last
received 4 blue. WEIGH her pluck In
coming 20 far mer<eec. in the class for
ponies under saddle. Miss Aauj Preece,
the eiGht-year-o daughter OF God
frey Preece. rode Merry Lego for the
English horsegiTl Of the same age. and
the combination was an excellent one,
for II took the fancy OF the spectators
and drew forth applause during the
evolutions that was redoubled when
the blue was awarded
Later In the day the English horse
men, who had almost forgotten now
to smile. were mirthful In the extreme.
for In the most enhancing class OF
the afternoon q previous decision OF
the Judges was partially reversed ana
the English marc Sceptre was placed
above Miss H. d. Atserbury's Dual
victress Patricia Good manners was
the essential factor In the success OF
Sceptre. ana In this particular the for
e;ener easily outclassed the American
entries, which included last years
champion. Rosaliel, Q mare that mas
not been previously defeated this SEES
son
These victories convinced the Eng
lisb sdhereptS that they were mis-
taken in supposing there was any
pretudIce ON the part OF the Judges
s~a!nss the horses that crossed the
pond: thus perfect harmony was re-
stored, ss least In the ranks OF the
sachlera
There vas re,rsbutive justice too Tor
IT SALISBURY, Of Philadelphia whose
pa,r OF roads.ers. although winners
las, wear got the gate on TUESDAY
RUBY, one OF the pair. when SHOWN
alone scored 6istinctyeiy Over W. %
Y. Hodman's Tene-f1e. The victory
vss veil received sy those who have
re9rstsed the exclusion Of Mr.. Stotcs-
burys pssr. end further that . SEMI
oS{lc'sl explsuaxion showed the reason
Tor their being overlooked II appears
,has Q yesr ago when Ruby and Nor.
csta Won, u was against the judgment
o. the veterinary. DR.. IL c. GIL The
Judges over-ruled hira. however. and
he was not asked TO act sr that ca
pacify this year. The vet appears 70
have been Justified. for 8; was stated
TIA. one Of the juAgss. James d CA.'
larry. .ssfs,eA that Norea;A wss IN.
souad ana investigated By the prssen'
veterinary sustained the Judge 20 th'
pair was sent out % the ring
Tho afternoon crows vas the pes'
% the week 20 Ear. and Tire spirited
work % the srcs,ers gave them mncf
90 er;huse over. Eober; Goelct
aovic. wtnn.r. Gail Constantine. thoue'
she did not via o prize VS. source
Of much enjoyment 90 she crowa- sc
1 IN making the csrcvis g the TRACK ses
kDs 80 hesl steadily sssDsS ssvAss