davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
Perth Amboy evening news., 1912-07-06
MAKE YOURSELF WE'LL AGAIN

If you have thin, poor, impover-
ished blood, weak and unstrung
nerves, Rheumatism, Neuralgia or
Kidney Troubles, and are without
your usual energy and vim, you
should take the very best medicine.
DIR. GRINDLES BLOOD AND
NERVE PURIFIER
Is the Best Medicine, 1t Makes the
Weak strong, the Sick Well.
DIR. GRINDLE, the we'll known
specialist in the treatment OF nerV-
Gus and chronic diseases, can be
consulted at his Office, where he has
been located for over thirty years,
at III West Twelfth street, between
9Th and 7th avenues, New York.
CONSULTATION FREE, Medicine 81
Perth Amboy evening news., 1912-07-06
AN EASY WIN
BY CRESCENTS
Defeat Columbia Nine OF
Trenton Score 10 TO 6. y
Special to the EVENING NEWS.

Midtown, July 6.-With Clayton
Smith, the schoolboy slab artist at
his best, the Crescents had no trout
BILE in finally winning from the CATH
Ollie nine of Trenton, Thursday, here.
G.. Crabiel showed class with the
stick, whaling out three safeties out
of five chancesU .kr cmfwyp shrdlu
og five attempts. The Gazettes, who
were booked for the morning did not
appear. Here's why the score was
10 to 6 in favor of the Locals:
Crescent q n 49,
Perth Amboy evening news., 1912-07-06
CYCLIST BENZ NOT To
RIDE DURING SUMMER

"Bilr' Benz, the clever little cy-
clist of Prince Bay, S. l., has an
nounced to his many friends on the
island ard in this city that he will
not enter any ~ofe lSsses this sea-
son. Mr., Benz hae -R9peen tram
ing. His side partner IDS ns9p Twill
epic several contests before the
close of the season.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1912-07-06
NEWARK C0L0RED TEAM
LOSE AT SOUTH RIVER
Special TO the EVENING NE I'VE.

South River, July S.-By star
fielding and hard hitting the repre-
sentative nine of this place downed
the Newark Colored Giants on Miller
field July A, by a 5 to 2 score. Ross
the South Riverites twirler, received
gild-edged support.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1912-07-06
WATER POLO is
A GOOD SPORT

Water polo will be a new sport
INDUCED in by athletes in these parts
Johnny" Anderson, of the Dexters,
"Riyies." are hunting up players and
some interesting doings are promis-
ed when the teams get organized.
The boys will probably be seen In
action. tomorrow at Bayard's Beach.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1912-07-06
80 10 10 27 10
UU IU II II IU
Columbia A. O., Trenton.

CoIumbai A. CT 0 0 0 2 0 0 2 o 8
Two base hits Zimmerman, Fine,
Kahill. Left on bases Crescents s,
Columbia Z. Bases on balls, off
Smith q, off Tusay 1, off Dillon l..
Struck out, by Smith 6, by Tusay 1,
by Dillon L Doublep lay, Carlin.
Costigan. npire, Hoffer. Time Of
game l hC s So minutes.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1912-07-06
T. A. G.. MEETS
PORT READING
Battle Today on T%ottsnvills
OvaI--Romer Pitches.
eoiar TO the EVENING NEWS.

Special TO the EVENING NEWS.
Tottenville, S. l., July 6.-The T.
A. C. will play the Port Reading
A. c., this afternoon on Totem
vile Oval. Romer will occupy the
slab for the locals, which means
that the visitors will have to show
some star playing to do any scoring.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1912-07-06

Two base hits, Scinski, Linck 2,
Harmon. Left on bases, H. A. c.,
4; N. A. c., 8. Bases ON balls, off
Turley, l. Struck out, by Hurley, 8;
by Scinski, 6. Double play, Dolan,
Linck and Mcdonald 2. Umpire,
Groves. Time of game, 1 hour, 80
minutes. Attendance, 500.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1912-07-06
APPLE" PITCHES FOR
SOUTH RIVER CROWD

Mighty interesting news breezed this
way from South River last night via
South Amboy and the Raritan waters.
The message was understood to say that
Harry Apologize, of the Frankhns, will
be on the slab for the South River base
ball nine against the Athletics of South
Amboy this afternoon.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1912-07-06

Any AFFAIR or happening. or cir
cun1atance. which II too small to
make . Went AID. worth while ~ an
adjusting force n tao small to
WoEEy AbQuk
Perth Amboy evening news., 1912-07-06

Boston, July Bill Sweeney,
the star second baseman of the local
National league team, is out for the
batting honors of the parent baseball
organization. During the past week
he has set the hitting pace for the
men in his circuit by making twenty
Perth Amboy evening news., 1912-07-06

Ed Walsh in the last engagement
with the Chicago White Sox, that be-
ing one-third of all the hits made off
the big spitballer by the Boston club.
Local experts are of the opinion that
iris is the greatest outer gardener
in the country, not ven barring
Cobb.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1912-07-06

INTERNATIONAL LEAGUE.
At Jersey City: r. II. n.
Providence o 0 l l 0 0 9 0-5 10 0
Jersey City.0 0 0 l / 0 0 l IA II l
Batteries-Dygert, Bailey, LATTE and
Schmidt; Doescher and Wells.
At Newark: r.. II. e.
Baltimore % 0 0 2 | 1 II Is l
Newark 40 0 2 0 0 l % 6 2
Batteries-Walker and Bergen; Schsrdt.
McGinnity and Higgins.
AT Buffalo: r. H. Z.
Toronto 80 0 2 1 IA 8 0
Buffalo .....0 0 2 0 0 % l 0
Batteries-Lush and Graham; Fullenwe-
der and Mitchell.
Observation-Disclosures game postponed on
account OF rain.
MnrMn OF TILE rr rrpQ
Perth Amboy evening news., 1912-07-06
CLOSE VICTORY
FOR HUGUEN0T
Exciting Fl Game With Ma
tionaI A. C.--Big Crowd.
Special to the EVENING NEWs.

Huguenot, J&y6;SThe game on.
> ulsMlk fd1nao.ue with DR.. Stln talK-
mgMeBut4 pnswha is. in chaErcA
tally in favor of the locals is .
planned in the following:
Hupueuot A. O. ~
Perth Amboy evening news., 1912-07-06

Any anal or happening, or CIR
cumstance, which Is too small to
make q Want AID. worth while as an
adjusting force Il too small to
worry about.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1912-07-06
KEYP0RT YACHT CLUB
nine IS EASY WINNER
,etsy 70 re EyHYNa =

Keyport. July 8.-The Keyport
Yacht Club baseball team defeated
the local Celofed Giants on the Cut
lery diamond Thursday afternoon by
. score Of 8 to 4
Perth Amboy evening news., 1912-07-06

Any affair, or happening, or cir
cumstance which Ia too small to
make a want ad. worth while as an
adjusting force is too small to worry.
ahput
Perth Amboy evening news., 1912-07-06
BASEBALL.
Results o. Games Played In National
American and Other Leagues.

NATIONAL LEAGUE.
AT New York: r Y. y.
New York. 3 2 0 0 0 0 0 l '-8 z
Brooklyn 20 0 0 0 l 0 0 0 o. s 2
Observation-Disclosures and Meyers; Bar
ger, Kent and Miller. Umpires-Brennan
and Emslie.
At Boston: r. II. Il.
Phila'phia o / 3 0 2 0 3 0 Ito Is l
Boston 80 0 0 0 0 90 7 !
Batteries-Rixey and Killifer: Tyler,
White and Rariden. Umpire-Eason.
AT Pittsburgh: n. Fl. e.
Pittsburgh o 3 0 2 0 1 l 1T IA 0
Cincinnati o 0 1 0 0 l 0 "a 8 2
Batteries-O'Toole and Simon; Hum
phries and McLean. Umpires-Klem and
Bush.
At st. Louis: n. H. n.
Chicago 20 0 2 0 0 0 o. Z 0
st. Louis 20 0 0 0 0 0 90 s /
Observation-Disclosures and Archer; Har-
mon, Bresnahan and Bliss. Umpires-Rig-
Ter and Finneran.
Perth Amboy evening news., 1912-07-06
LEAGUE.

AMERICAN LEAGUE
At Washington: r. H x.
Wash'ton 20 100000 l. II s
New York. q o. 0 100000 5 6 l
Batteries-Engle and Williams. Johnson
and Ainsrnith; Fisher, WARRIOR and Swee-
ney. Umpires-Evans and Westervelt.
At Philadelphia: II. H. Z.
Phila'phia o 2 0 0 0 0 0 Ia 6 l
Boston .....1 0 l 0 0 0 0 @ 4 /
Batteries-Houck, Coombs and Egan;
O'Brlen and Carrigan.
Second game: n. II. L.
Boston .....O 0 0 2 / 1-B /
Phila'phia L 0 0 / 0 l 0 % 8 8
Batteries-Collins and Carrigan; Morgan.
Pennock and Lapp. Umpires-Egan and
O'Loughlin.
At Chicago: n. H. r.
Chicago 81 0 0 II u s
Detroit .....0 0 1 l 0 0 0 0 ID /
Batteries-Walsh and Kuhn; Works and
Stanage. Umpires-Hart and Connolly.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1912-05-06
STOCK MARKET REVIEW
Good Support Given-The Out
neutrality-suspicious.
Crops.

Viewing the stock market as whole
during last week II acted very well, and
II would be difficult to find much in its
action to cause apprehension. Ignoring
the wage question. which should have
some effect, the market should DO bet
ter, as with al the bad news, OF which
ordinarily there would have been enough
TO cause q bad break, the declines were
comparatively slight. If the organizers
Of this bull movement desire to push
prices further up the scale they have
good base Of operations, as the action OF
the list as a whole on Friday and Satur-
day last will materially influence the
scattered bears and cause them to hest
tate before jumping in over their heads.
If, however, the ring masters decide that
liquidation is in order lower prices VIII
be the order, though it les not look as II
serious break is imminent from last
weeks performance. There are no indl-
cations Of money hardening. and loans
are easy, so the question OF banking
support is not a factor again't higher
prices. Prices may he held around the
present level until the outcome OF the
miners convention and the result re-
garding the arbitration Of the demands
of the railroad employees. There are
many reasons why II would be good
thing to have a strong stock market
but, like the weather, the market
changes. 1t is temperamental and re-
fleets the deductions of big interests,
who, by education along financial and
business lines, are able TO see further
than ordinary mortals We can only
follow; we cannot lead.
Overhanging the market until II mas
been made public will be the govern
ment's crop report. 1t is one OF the
sentimental issues Of the market. and It's
near approach at any time is reflected In
the markets action. The crop scare Is
en- annual occurrence and is used both
for and against the market, according to
the movement desired. The copper
metal market at present is quiet, appar-
emily waiting. possibly for the settle
ment of the railroads action regarding
the identification Of many Of their lines,
which was checked by the panic.
From the foreign markets the infor-
nation received is encouraging, and
prices of American issues are holding
firm though quiet. Some issues have
been active but there is d tendency to
await the outcome Of our labor troubles
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1912-05-06
RAILROAD AND OTHER STOCKS.


49, with the hsh anu ~" '
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1912-05-06
THE BUSINESS SITUATION
Obstacles Which Retard Return
of Prosperity.

Tho Rache Review has analayzed the
question Of the countrys prosperity in
rather an unfavorable light, in view OF the
several factors which hang as cloud over
the business situation. The following ex-
tract from The Review" follows Hresen-
tation Of political factors:
Another obstacle which might he viewed
ss adverse TO business revival is The labor
situation. Neither has this apparently had
great weight with the progress OF business
The settled conviction seems TO be that
some way out Will be found with ref
erence 10 each of the problems or this
character which presents itself This view.
early maintained, has proved true so far
and will probably continue TO do so.
1T is 10 be contended that the labor sit
walton has never been liquidated since the
panic of 1907, and for long time liqui-
dalton with revision of wages downward
was looked for. This did not materialze
and now we are getting revision upward
The demand Of the locomotive engineers
having been passed on 10 arbitration, the
railway fremen now come forward asking
for still larger increases There is said 70
he a rivalry between the two organiza-
tions strike of pressmen has been
started in Chicago. II is perhaps unfortu-
nate that at the first sign OF business pros
perity the trades unions take the opportu-
nifty 10 jack up their prices before the busi-
ness community has begun to realize many
Few profits. The danger in all this is that
Sfoprietors, anxious TO take advantage or
rsyiving volume. will make settlements with
tAe workers at such higher figures as Will
make impossible any profit, even with the
business increased heavily. We shall then
be continuing as we have been Tor two
years, doing large business without profit,
and the ultimate result of this must be dis
astrous. AS far as the railroads are con-
cerned. II these demands Of the workers
turned over to arbitration are met even
in part, there is but one remedy on an
economic basis. and that is to permit the
railroads to raise rates, which. I'm fact,
should have been done long age"
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1912-05-06

Money conditions in London are very
easy and loans on stocks can be maoe
st reasonable rates. Berlin money mat
ters are also better and the French mar
ket has a cheerful appearance. To-davs
movement Of prices on the New iorH
Stock Exchange will be watched care
fully, as some indication of its real sup
mort should be in evidence. Until the
action Of prices indicates the positi'e
trend, the word caution" should De
nlsced where il can be easily read.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1912-05-06
BEET SUGAR CO. THRlVES
Big Increases in Gross and Net,
with S518,600 Surplus.

Preliminary figures Of the results OF op-
Grafton of the American Beet Sugar COM
pany for the fiscal year ended March ol'
1912. show gross earnings of S,9S29'S' COM
paring with sS,3A.792 for the preceding year'
and total income of s9,o6.l9S. Expenses
taxes interest and other deductions agsre-
gated 81. SO SO. leaving a balance Of S,S.o'.
573 available for dividends an increase y.
sss, .et4. After payment OF dividends OF
cam O0o on the preferred and $4,000 on the
common stock and appropriation OF e''e''"
for additions, betterments and deprecla.'on'
the net surplus for the year was s'i>'V
The balance available for the con'""'
stock. after paying the preferred dl'idehds.
EQUALS 1880 per cent. against l's per oeu'
earned or the same volume OF STOCK IN wv
fiscal wear ended March Il. 1911.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1912-05-06
NEW YORK BANK STOCKS

00uota,ions furnished by s. u. p. Pell & Co. 80
Wall street,
Transactions in the last week on the New
York Stock Exchange in stocks OF local
banks were as follows: The National Bank
Of Commerce, sixteen shares. at 200; the
Fourth National Bank, seventy-two shares,
at colIl and 2o2. and the National City Bank.
ten shares. at 49,
At the weekly auction sale Of securities
on Wednesday there were no sales Of bank
stocks. Ten shares Of stock of the Home
Trust Company were sold at 100 and 4oig
shares Peoples Surety Company at o.
Closing quotations for stocks of loca!
banks, trust and mortgage and surety COM
panies follow:
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1912-05-06
RIO TRAMWAY'S YEAR.

The Rio de Janeiro Tramway' Lish' ~.
Power Company reports for the year ena.'
December 81, 1911. gross revenues u
$50 81. against slO,s6o,1so for 1910; operauns
expenses SG,lS,2S9, comparing with s0''o'Yo,
and net revenue s6,76IoS. Total lnco' u.
was $751; ,so7. and after deduc'ins S0'V'a
for interest. taxes. expenses ana Val'v ~.
charges, the years surplus was S''Ve''"'
osainst g 2S7 1iS for the preceding year
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1912-05-06
FINANCIAL MEETINGS.
NOTICE OF SPECIAL. MEETING OF STOCK
HOLDERS OF
BETHLEHEM STEEL CORPORATION.

4 Special Meeting of the Stockholders OF
bethlehem steel Corporation will be held at It's
principsl Office, No. 763 Broad Street, Newark.
New Jersey. OF Tuesday, May Ia, 1872, at IL
o'clock noon. for the following purposes. VIZ
On To authorize the pledge by Bethlehem steer
C'ornorstio Of the whole or any part of It's
holdings OF the capital stock OF subsidiary
companies to secure the guaranty by said Cor
pcration Of the payment Of the principal ana
interest OF Ave per cent. 3O-year mortgage
bonds OF Bethlehem Steel Company OF an issue
limited 10 $50. 600 900. and to approve the pur-
chase and sale of some of said bonds by said
Corpora ton: and ~ 10 transact such other
business as may properly come before the
meeting
For the purposes Of the meeting the books for
The transfer Of the capital stock Of said Cor
porstion. both preferred and common, VIII De
1912 and will be reopened a 10 o'clock A. NJ.
on Wednesday May -. 1912.
Dated Newark, y. j.. April -. 1912
Jones Secretary.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1912-05-06
LARGE INCREASE IN IDLE CARS.

The net surplus of idle freight cars on
the railways of the United States and
Canada on April %, as reported by the
American Railway Association, was 13s,SSl,
against 1889 two weeks previously. an in
crease Of 69,492. The gross surplus, or total
number Of cars idle. was 1916. against
sl,s43 a fortnight earlier. and the shortage
decreased in the same period from 5.55i to
1906 The coal car surplus increased in
the two weeks from 1880 to 1862. or by
1882: and this increase. due TO the sus-
pension Of operations In the anthracite and
btuminous coal fields. represents most OF
the aggregate surplus. The number Of
freight cars idle in the Northwest is about
that normally reported at this season.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1912-05-06
NEW GILLIAN WHEAT REGION.

Santiago. May 5.-Ramon Bartos - 49,.
president of chill. oficiated to-day At .s'
Inauguration of tho extensive WoiNS -, ~
new port of san Antonio, 10 INC 60 Ca
Valparaiso. The new works VIII ar. VA,
ciutIes for the opening up of great 49,
region. Many Diplomatic represe .,
aud government officials we're pfese"'
the ceremony.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1912-05-06
DIVIDEND NOTICES.
THE PENNSYLVANIA X. X,

THE PENNSYLVANIA X. X. co.
Philadelphia, May ], 1912
TIE Board &C Directors has this day de-
clsred a quarterly dividend Of One and one
half per cent. (Seventy-hye cents per snare)
unou The Capital Stock of the Company. pay
able on and after May 81. 1912, to stockholders
as registered upon the books Of the Company
a. the close Of business May 4, 1912. Checks
pilI be mailed to stockholders who have filed
permanent dividend orders.
JAMES r. FAHNESTOCK. Treasurer
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1912-05-06
GUARANTEED STOCKS.

,p,,rishea by Bingham Lawrence Co.. No
III Broadway
The Marion daily mirror. (Marion, Ohio) 1892-1912, 1912-03-14
REVIVAL SERVICES
CLOSE AT EPWORTH
Very Successful Meetings Have Been
Held.

The evangolistlo services which have
been in progress at Erworth Meth
odlst church for the past two weeks
came To- a ciose All the Wednesday ev-
tning meeting.
Tho services have been conducted
by the church pastor, Rov G. u. Hav-
ighurst. and have been highly success
full over 1876 accessions have been
made to the church roll since the op-
enlng OF the meetings, and many other
conversions were made.
"Wednesday night, Rev Havighurst
took for his subject, Now Is the Ac-
cepletl Time" Two very strong con-
versions were made. and numerous
others responded to the pastors in
vitation to seekers. An evangellstic
sermon viii be preached Sunday night
and the revival splritswill be kept
fresh in the hearts Of the congrega-
ton.
The Marion daily mirror. (Marion, Ohio) 1892-1912, 1912-03-14
AN INCOME
TAX LAW UP
A Bill to Supply the De-
ficiency of Revenue if the
Free Sugar Bill Should
Become a, Law
Become a Law.


Omitted Press Leased Wire)
Washington, March 14.--Iclatly in
favor of an income tax, but doubling
constitutionality of such a measure,
the house Democratic ways and means
committee presented its "excise tax
BILL" which is practically an income
tax law, to supply the $4,000, 600
revenue to be lost II the free sugar
bill is passed.
The report argues at length that
the proposed measure is not techni-
cally an income tax. 1t holds the
taxation "an extension of the cor
poratlon tax law to individuals. firms
and co-partcnerships." in order to Sc
cure lower sugar prices for the peo-
pic. Explaining tho system OF tax
alton, the committee says:
The revenue for support of the
government, as raised by taxation. is
now almost equally divided between
customs and excise duties These tax
cs are solely on sonsumptlon. Prop
orty, and the income from property as
such, pay no part of these sums. TN
der n system of national taxation
based wholly on consumption, wealth
necessarily escapes it's fair share Of
the burden Of supporting ihe govern
mont which gives wealth tho neces-
sary protection under which II in
croascs its gains. on the other hand.
when he purchases for himself and
family, the necessities Of life, the
man Of meagcr carninfs contributes
out of hi sdaily wage to the support
of the government"
The report argues that while She
supreme court has held an income
tax void, Il has held the corporation
tax constitutional, ana that extension
Of the latter must therefore be con-
stftutional. The measure taxes the
amount Of income from "buslness"
done by the individual in order to
escape the supreme courts condem-
nation OF the income tax.
"As deGneds by the supreme court
in tho corporation tax case" the re-
port explains, the term business en-
braces everything about which q per-
son can be employed. This dehni-
tion is sufficiently comprehensive to
allow but comparatively few to
escape where the earnings are in ex-
cess of $4,000 per year. A person
having an income Of less than $500 a
year would pay nothing; while a per-
son whose bulness earns $4,000
would pay no tax on the first $4,000
and on tho second would pay only
$50 q year"
The Marion daily mirror. (Marion, Ohio) 1892-1912, 1912-03-14
MILLIONAIRE
MEAT PACKERS
Have Announced They Will
Submit no Evidence in
Their Defens.
tunIted Press 1oased wlrol

chicago, March 14.-Aitcr eighteen
hours OF almost continuous confer
ences attorneys for the ten million
aire packers, charged with criminal
conspiracy In restraint of trade, today
announced before Fedcral Judge Car
penter that they would submit no evil
dence I'm defense of the case present
cd against luhom by the government
Attorney John S. Miller made tho
announcement after Judge Carpenter
and the attorneys for the government
had been drawn into the conference.
The court then adjourned until
Monday to give hhc attorneys time to
confer regarding instructions Of the
jury and the arguments.
Attorneys Levy Mayor and Miller
refused to comment on the confer
cnces held last night and today saying
that they were satisfied What the gov
omments case would fail when the
Jury had listened to the arguments
for the packers.
The real reason for the sudden ter
mlnatlon OF the case, however. Is gem
orally admitted to be duo to tho re-
fusal of the packers headed by j.
Ogden Armour. to tallo the witness
stand for the defense and submit
probably 10 n ruthless cross-eXaminu-
iion by the government attorneys.
Judge Carpenter intimated that the
attorneys would not he limited in their
arguments The addresses to the jury
probably Will consume a week.
When court adjourned yesterday
after nearly score OF motions for
the striking out Of testimony had
been oyerruled by Judge Carpenter,
the packers ana their attorneys be-
can the series OF conferences which
ended IN Judge Carpenters chambers
with determination to rest the case
today.
IN was stated that Edward Morris,
who had not contributed to the $780,
400 defense fund Of the allied packers,
was determined that a fun defense be
submitted The National Packing and
Swift groups favored a curtailed de-
fense, while tho Armour defendants
insisted than the case DO rested.
An agreement was almost erached
that a curtailed defense be put on In
which mono OF the defendants would
take the stand Attorney Mayer, who
lhad been absent, returned to lthe con-
ference at this point and declared, II
( Is said that such n course would sure
| ly preil.dice. the caso more than any
| evidence uhe government could pro-
duce Then 1t was decided to rest
and rely on the arguments.
! The hechnical charge against the
packers is conspiracy to commit acts
in restraint of trade. in violation OF
| tho sherman ANTITRUST law. The
maximum punishment is fine of $5,-
600 or one year in jail, or both fine
and imprisonment
The Marion daily mirror. (Marion, Ohio) 1892-1912, 1912-03-14
IllIllls md 1Intchcr.

Cincinnati, March 13,-John Killits,
United States Judge at Toledo, Ohio,
sent TO the United states circuit court
Of appeals at Cincinnati today his
answef TO an application made by
Attorney Charles A, Thatcher of To-
ledo, b mandamus the Judge
Thatcher who was disbarred by
Kllits. says the judge failed to read
proceedings IN the Ohio supreme court
;hat ended in Thatcher's dlsbarmenl
in the state court,
Killits made q general denial but
admitted he had changed Thatcher's
bil of exceptions because, he said, IT
contained extreme trivialities."