davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26
Indolent Officials.

Despite The utter inadcquaoy OF their
own hospitals ami attendants, the Turks
appear unwilling TO make use Or the
European corps OF volunteers TO anything
Ike the extent they might. Certain ncdi-
ca! units sent from England. although
IDundlntN provided with equipment
have been unable To m half The beds
owing To the Incidence or impotence Of
the ottoman officials.
"Thosc in charge o. the English mcdi-
cal corps nave been asked 10 send part
of their staff for service among the
refugees While they cannot entirely re-
iect this proposal because ,he condition
oi the refugees is depioiab!e ncverlhc-
less. the request has been met with a
deal OF harsh comment, the workers de-
clarin% they came out TO care FOR the
wounded. not as soup distributors.
One English corps with 200 empty
beds went out to the bywoys looking for
wounded and brought in one Turk with
his ankle shattered. lie Is nov being
cared for by four surgeons and sixteen
nurses. in addition TO several dressers
and assistants.
,':Thc lone patient is being led on
chicken broth. meat Juices and other
dclicacics, and is liberally supplied with
cigarettes.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26
FOREIGNERS WORK
IN CHOLERA CAMP

CONSTANTINOpLE. Nov. -. - 4
group OF American and English yolun-
to"rs are working cncrGcticaly mt tho
cholera camp at san Stelauo where n
Greek school has been converted into a
hospital The Rev. Or. Frecw. n Scotch
pastor Major Surgeon Ford, l.. :. A..
clyde S. Phillips. Secretary of the Amer
lean Embassy Naurice Barring. dressed
III scnmcus overals and jackets and
Miss AT and Nine, Schneider. both aged
and frail, comprise the party. DR., Frcew's s
Greek servant Is acting as interpreter.
TIL" minister. with twinkle jn his
cy" said today:
''Thc9c women arc working mo 10
death They don't take lunch themselves
OF permit me 10 have any. We Aavc zoo
patients here and We had more than thai
ycst crday."
This little band OF Foreigners IS pro-
vldng everything for tho cho strick
cn-blankcts, cups. soup. These workers
are unable To give individual treatment.
for tho building Is crowded with dead
and dying. but the Inmates arc fortunate
as compared with those occupying tents.
where the cold saps their vitality.
Several Turk Red Crescent doctors arc
now superin; ending the building OF vast
sheds al san Stcfano. Some of these arc
completed. Red Crescent attendants
have been put 10 work removing the
bodies from II shed near to the school
II VIII require many cartloads before
the place Is cleared
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26
Question of Insolvency.

Naturally said Mr.. Belmont The
secure the existing liability laws which
give them the right TO sue for DANA ges
and the right OF trIal by jnrJ. pause when
thoN see the claim that through the
present system In the state OF Wash
ingion The man is assured his compensa-
uon. and IL raised In their minds the
question. how may tho injured workman
hc guaranteed his compensation IN case
of Insolvency on the part of his en-
plorers"
'Wc recognize the unfortunate state
oi affairs which permits so-calied dummy
corporations 10 conc into existence aud
That undoubtcdly effort must b. made To
protect the wage Garner against any
such. A corporation with $4,000 paid
no capital siock may proceed 80 do n
business Of 81 900, OOO and il an employee
becomes injured. the amount Of his
compensation or damage would wipe the
corpora Llon ont of nyisfanCe
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26
Officials Not Sanguine.

The Constnntinoplc correspondent OF
The Reuter- Telegram company in u late
dispa ich says:
"Ofhclal circles are not vcvy SanpJlinc
rs Ia The result OF the meeting OF the
l!"nipotcutiarIcS, \ high official tonight
expressed the opinion that there was not
more Than a , per cent chance or urriy-
In. al an agreement. unless Bulgaria
very materially modified her demands,
which was not very probable
THE truce viii last. If necessary, forty
ople is likel,- To prov.. n stumhIInr h,orI-
II is understood the BulEarians have
prepared 10 waive the abandonment of
the TchatalIa lines. but will insist upou
tho capltula ton OF Adrlanoplc. The
Turkish delegates are equally determined
That Adria none shnl rnmnlu Tllrlilsh.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26
FILES NEW COMPLAINT
AGAINST MRS. Inflow

\ new move preud!ns tne delayed
hearing of Genevievc Inflow, accused of
completely in the killing OF Eddie
White, n public chauffeur. ON last Octo-
ber ., was made yesterday, a complaint
charging Mrs. Inflow with st-dcsrec
murder was sworn To before Justice OF
the Peace T.. w Harris by Police Inspcc-
tor Carl a. Carlson.
Caleb \. Inflow, the Bingham school
teacher, husband OF Mrs. Inflow, was
given preliminary hearing before JUS
tlce II. S. Harper soon after his arrest
and held for tho district court. The case
OF tho wife is being taken before another
justice. for the reason that the evidence
to be used against her has already been
largely brought out In the hearing of her
husband,
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26
PEACE AGREEMENT
YER Y IMPROBABLE

LONDON, NoV. 26-Thc Times corrc-
sppndcnt ut Tcbataija sends tho follow
ing:
"rhc Turks have recently piled Tho
pick and shovel with such good WilI thai
J am more and more convinced that eN-
ccpt IN tho event OF pressure from an
OTHER quarter. the allies will not risk
the losses which direct operations against
thc Tchatnlja lines will entail
Il cannot In the interest OF fair play
indicate the positions OF the second and
tilird lines OF entertainments. but Their
strength must prove an Important factor
IN the current negotiations and il def
niicly confirms my contention that.
Whatever the cause Of the delay, the Gul-
Sdrians lost their real opportunity dur
ing tho first week OF November
There are signs of the approach oi
winter. which will add yet another diff
Guilty 10 the many with which the in
vnder has had 10 cnntcn6 i
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26
Foreign Doctors Meet.

Tie foreign doctors have met 10 con-
slider what advice could be offered the
government respecting precautions
against tho spread OF the disease. The
cholera the correspondent adds. Is rigging
nj AdIianople and is spreading among the
The losses 10 TURKS and Bulrariaps
buve hoen enormous. but the dcmorali3a-
zion OF the main Turkish army has not
extended Ia 'thc garrison at hdrlanop'e,
which daily displays desperate gallsntry
+, mas succeeded several times In winning
back lost ground. where the seventh
division under the Bulgarian general:
Y EhirI<ho0 has retired four miles, and on
Inc lafl ba nix. where Il Servian division
has sustained heavy losses.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26
Fund His "Pet.

current charities. he said his
7s the hero fund" adding. II
NAT one up all by myself"
q the visitors commented upon
dng very Young for q man OF
y whereupon he laughed and
ny greater years | am coming
4 higher opinion OF the human
|ause ] know So many in II who
lined TO almost angelic heights. -
[4meSie said he bad been IN re-
Kilograms and letters of con-
ION upon his birthday all day
|lhcn he quoted q couplct from
~ 10 evidence mis- state Of mind
|ene noted up in one corner Of the
D inscription. one OF many forming
|1round the library. This Inscrip-
~ THE highest form OF worship
1 u service TO man.
glad YOU saw that" said Mr..
y "That appears in Franklin )
H found in his private books. Ii
Luthcr's well known sermon.
.ncclares We cannot serve God (:
no aid from us. We can do our
Service for our felloWmcn.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26
CHIDESTER MODESTl.Y
GIVES OTHERS CREDIT

judge John T. ChidostcC Of Richded,
Hho has been spending = few days In
Salt Lake. is buslly denying that he
should have the credit for tho sweep
ing Republican victories In southern Utah
this year The Judge has been receiving
congratulations from his tricpds on the
result In southern Utah, but hc declares
that the credit should not be his. but
should 20 10 the various county chair
men. TIc was particularly warm In his
praise Of the work of County Chairman
ParIcy MaSleby of Sewer county, where
the county WAS transferred from the
Democratic To rhc Republican column.
SEWER county gave the largest Repuhi-
can plurality or any county in the state
except Salt Lake.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26

the soldiers not TO night Tor the traitorous
government. One delegate even under
took the task OF an attempt against the
lives of the sultan and his ministers
by bombs.
The communication. While declaring in
dulgence towards such agitators would
be . crime against the nation. repudiatcs
reports that the government is anImat Cd
by political animus against the party it.
self, proof OF which. IL says, can he
found Ip the decision of the government
10 lihcrate those against whom there is
not sufficient evidence Of guilt
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26
ITR0YS SLEEP
'sIs Lake City People Testify 10
This.

~ Lake City Peoplc Testify 20
This.
|san I sleep at night
aches and pains Of u bad back
a you have TO get up from uri.
bubbles.
z kidneys are at fault
Fnem working Alright with Doan 5
Pills.
ls proof OF their efficiency:
X Booth. 81 South Twelfth
~ Salt Lake City, Utah. says:
Oppllc statement ! gave in 1905,
ending Doau's Kidney Pills still
pod ] still take this remedy oc-
F and find that it keeps ME
erious kidney trouble. There
rhess across the small oi MY
"a 1 did not rest well. could
uoWn without changing my po'
very lew minutes and when ]
Z. sharp twingcs dartcd through
oa9s Kidney Pills, procured at
nJobnson 5 Drug Store, went
'vot OF my trouble at once. and
not long before / was able 10
sn comfort. Continued use en-.
s:rected my trouble. improving
s,.lon IN every way
,e at Schramm-J Johnson g Drug
'Ail Lake City, Utah, and by all
frice, 50c. Foster Milburn
aa'o' New York, Sole Agents IuI
lied States. -
Hr the namc-Doan Sand
olner. advertisement
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26
<ts Reforms.

g necessarily will he REFORMS in
q administration. but when any
! me OF having fears on that ac-
|<ith business, or fears OF any kind.
<nile
Don't need protection on steel,
4 protection that is everlasting is
IKE The only protection that
/ BE- given is 10 infant Industries
||on is only good when it protects
.llurers struggling TO gain foot
food of the people should never
q Luxuries should bc taxed TO
best They are only purchased
\ |f'ch and never by the poor. so
ould be made 10 pay as high as
, expected that the philanthropic
Esler might have some charities
pfce. bat he declared that there
[hlng new in that line 10 talk
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26
Sortie Repulsed.

SOFIA, Nov. 25.-The Turkish forces
n, Adrlanoplc made Il snItlc yesterday
garlan lines. but were repuIscd with con-
sidorp bic losses The BulPu rlans have
drawn closer their circle OF Investment
now approaching within two-thIrds o! a
,,lIe NJ iie
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26
MANUFACTURERS WILL
HOLD SOCIAL TONIGHT

An educational and social membership
meeting OF the Manufacturers asspcla-
ton will be held tonight nj the Vermont
building, -. II. Collett, secretary has
sent out invitations To al members re-
qucsiing them TO 20 10 the meeting with
their women folk.
Lewis +. BOYLE of tho International In
dustrial association viii deliver nn a.
lustratcd lecture on Utah Industries
Aftcrward a Dutch lunch will he enjoyed.
Tnn niceiinr VIII begin nj S O'Clock.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26
Council of War.

EIElIN. Montenegro NOV. ga pro-
longeJ council OF war was held here to-
day. King Nicholas presided and the
Bulgarian minister was in attendance.
Important decisions were taken with re-
spcct to future operations against Scu~
tlyi,
General Vullotltch VIII take command
OF the MontenesTin center.
General MartnoNitch. who attended the
council lett Immediately for the Monte
ncgrin positions near Tara bosch 10 con-
llnIIe cncIG clic npcrnlLunS.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26

ginning OF the siege cannot be less tnIn
| 900 killed and wounded.
Tho hospitals for the wounded are
sufficient, but provision for the cholera
patients is dangerously inadequate.
Bodies Of those who perishcd from this
disease are often moi removed Tor Il
whole day. and arc buried at night in
the old Turkish cemetery. The MariiHa
is poisonous. and there are vessels in
which TO boil il sufficient only FOR tic
seventh division. IT is feared Austria
WIN establish d quarantine almost immc-
dintclN.
y Constantinoplc dispatch TO the Daily
News says.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26
Consul Is Missing.

VIENNA. Nov. @5,-Tbe representative
nf tho Austrian foreign Office, who was
dispatched November 20 To Prisrcnd to
nnd the Austrian consul, Prochaska,
concerning whose treatment by the Ser
vians there has been much trouble, has
been unable to locate The consul.
AZ tie suggestion Of a Seryian official.
the Austrian courier waited for Pro-
chaslea at Gskup two days. AS tho con-
sui did not arrive there. the courier
soughi To take Il train TO NcrlSOvltCh.
but tile Scrvan authorities sa!d conn
munication with that place bad been In
terrupt cd
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26
Servians Resting.

BELGRADE. Nov. 25.-rhe Scrviaa
troops seem 10 he resting aftgr five
weeks OF strenuous advance and fight
ing,
iCaI. is regarded AS having improved
Tho semi official Prayada, dealing with
the ProchasSa affair, uses the most con-
clllatury language towards Austria.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26
Rumor Of Murder.

VIENNA. Nov. 25.-.N rumor spread
today thai tho Austrian consul al Pr,s-
reud prochasla. had been killed by Ser
Wan troops. There is no confirmation to
this The military journal says the Aus
triau squadron i'm Turkish waters has
been ordered home.
\ Belgrade dispatch reports a con-
ference today between Premier PaChitch
and the Austrian minister, but adds That
no formal negotiations rcsutcd.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26
Will Aid Bulgars.

LONDON. Nov. ga Belgrade dts
patch To the Standard says two moro
divisions. abou, 10000 strong. FROM the
crown princes army at Monastir are pro-
ceoding by rail. by way OF Sa)oniki and
Dcmotca, TO reinforce the BulgarianS at
Adranoplc and Tchataljo
There are $4,000 Turkish prisoners at
NJnunSIil
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26
Noted Welsh,nan Dies.

Word was received yesterday from
Cardigf. South Wales. telling that Alvir
Edward Thomas (CochfarD had diet
there November Is Mr. Thomas was th,
first lord mayor elected from Wales. lie
had never been In Salt Lake City, al
though he once came TO America, and
as far west as Chicago. He has relatives
In Spanish Fork and Utah county, and
his wife, Madam Hughes Thomas, viii bc
remembered by the citizens OF Salt LAX.
as tho director Of The ROYAL Welsh ladies'
choir tbo, appeared In the salt Lake
lhcatcr last April,
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26
Traitorous Young Turks.

ONSTANTINOPLE, Nov 95.-A long
public communication is published cy-
plaining the governments action against
the party of Union and Progress. II as
serts that in the demonstration of stu
dents and others around the porte on DC
tubcr Z. demanding war. there were nu-
merous influential young Turks who en-,
dca vored TO infiamc the populace by ;lc-
cusng the government OF selling the
country.
Police Inquiries proved that ut the de-
parturc OF the army FOR the field OF bat
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26
([N CARNEGIE
AGE OF Il
haster Bears His Years
|sll, Is Cheerful and
Decidedly Optimistic.
IS on THE TARIFF.
1--WE Don't Need Any
tection on Steel;;' Re-
Ives Congratulations.
5 ON THE TARIFF
,tional News Service.

.srnati0nal News Service.
/ YORK. Nov. 25.-Andrew Car
rho is - years old today. spent
4 lhe morning IN experimenting
.nsfer OF sl2j. j.ooo.0oo IN securities
|czrnegle corporation OF New York.
h 10 take charge Of all % Mr., Car
phIlanthropies, Tonight the iron
xayc dinner 10 eighteen OF his
innate friends.
dlence with a group OF newspaper
Ac called a; his Fifth avenue man
b. Carnegie expressed his views
raj subjects. lie was decidedly
Nc. He said that any person who
/ that, as result Of the recent
the country WAS going TO the
MS was sadly mistaken.
pick our kings and we always
ID ones" he said lauChinEly.
Z who do not like our American
our American wines. our clothes
n. should be made 10 pay hi.h
/ Imports. Don't worry about the
ny advice 10 all. There Is no
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26
TURKS SLOW TO SIGN
THE DEATH WARRANT
Continued from Page Oue)

agreed not 10 commit themselves in nd.
vance on any OF the Balkan questions
second that Austria Hungary had mobi-
lized five army corps. This docs NOT
correspond with the facts as everyone
may gather from the official Vienna and
BUDAPEST explanations. Third. that \ lis-
! lila~ hungary cuntemplateS sending an
mit.matum 10 Belgrade IN a few days
lilS-assertlon Is untrue FOR the \ lba man
and Adtiatlc questions will be discussed
ON! Win other questions arising from
events IN the Balkans
1t is particularly irresponsible to dis
lurb public opinion with such untrue re-
ports al a Time when the governments Of
az tle great powers arc earnestly en-
dcaVoring to lind u pacific solution Of
a truly difficult problem"
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26
Denied by Russia.

ST PETERSBl.RG. Nov. "a The for
cign office has issued Il denial OF re-
ports published in German pcwspa pcrs
OF Russian preparation for war and hos
tilly toward nelghboring states.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26
OLUMBIA ALUMNI IN
UTAH ELECT OFFICERS

The Columbia Alumni in the state OF
Utah gave their annual banquet at the
University club Saturday night An en-
thusiastic crowd of doctors lawyers, en-
gincers and professors assembled and
paid tribute to their alma mater The
following annual officers were elected;
Dr. Alvuh Lewis president, Girard y,
Roscnbatt, vice president: Charles II.
DnoliliIn. secrctnrN and .rGaNurGr.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26
Damage Case Transferred.

The damage suit of Annie Il. Is.
Huu.:hton against the Chief Consolidated
Minin;, company for injuries TO her son.
Jumcs Bcddinrneld aged 20 years. has
been transferred from the Filth district
court In Juab county TO the United states
court in salt Lake. Bcddinglicid WAS
operating Il cage the night ol April 20
In the Tintlc district and bis left arm
was crushed His mother is suing for
SIS 600
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26
SAYS JEWS IN TURKEY
REQUIRE ASSISTANCE

The New York branch of the Alliance
Israclitc Upversello Is sending ont pc
tltions for help for the Jewish sufferers
I'm Turkey. The plea. which Is dated Mt
New York city, November 90 1912, states
that the alliance has already sent to tho
sufferers more than 100000 francs. and
has been helping them FOR more than tlttN
wears. The appeal is closed wtn tho
Abatement He gives twice who gives
N
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26
Message to Kaiser.

BERLIN. Nov. 26-The Lokal Anzeiser
says the Russian major gen ncral, Tchaia-
chef, win leave Berlin tomorrow for
'rsarskoc- Sclo. II is believed he bears
Il personal message from the German
emperor 20 tho Russian emperor.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26
COMPELLED to Retire.

Early Thursday morning. after a hei.e
actually entered karaSac. n suburb OF
Adiianopic. where street hghiing cnslicd.
but were compelled To retire, Ine BuI =
rnrlan and Servian lusseS since Inc ne-
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1912-11-26
ners Have Narrow Escape.

*ESBA RRE, Pa. NoV. 25.-TMen-
neh mad narrow escape from
!lombed by a caye-in at Il mine
nernOm Coal company near Pitts
aitcrnoon. Twelve OF the men
gured before being rescued, two
osly that they had 10 he taken
Xzpltal.
The Daily Ardmoreite. [volume] (Ardmore, Okla.) 1893-current, 1912-04-17
|NHER|TEOLANOSU|TS
ARE DECIDED VOID
THE SUPREME COURT RULES
AGAINST GOVERNMENT
VERSES DECISION.

Washington, April l6.-The su
/ preme court today decided the fourth
of the five test appeals IN the 3O00t
Indian land suits
The decision holds that so-called
"iull-blood inherited land" suits are
declared void and must be dismiss
ed
The other three suits were decided
in favor OF the government.
The fifth suit to De decided is
the Seminole Suit involving the
freedmen restrictions.
In the decision today, which was
in the case OF j. ;. Mullen and w.
b. Jansen, the supreme court holds
against the government, reyerses
the decision of the appe;;ate court
and atfirms the decision of the cir
cult court, which originally threw
the case out of court
The supreme court finds that the
bill is without equity as against the
appellants for the reason that the
conyeyances We're not executed in
violation OF any restrictions imposed
by congress"
This case involved the sale of
lands allotted to heirs and there is
no restriction upon the right OF alien
alton expressed in the statute
SAYS the decision: Had the lands
ancestor. one-half of them. consti-
tutins homestead, would have been
free from restriction upon his
death"
The Daily Ardmoreite. [volume] (Ardmore, Okla.) 1893-current, 1912-04-17
,rdmore, Wedne sday Apri! II, 1912
TIE FLOODED DISTRICT.

The suggestion of E. F. Yoakum,
the railway president and builde-'
ina, the dredging machinery which
has been used in the construction
work upon the Panama Canal, and
which is now lying idle, be transfer
led 10 this country and be put "a
No-x in DREDGING the bed of the Mis-
sissippi river and building up ana
STRENGTHENING the dikeS, or levees on
either side. seems most good and
Ntmely one
For years and years. ever since
;he settling O; the river ho,Iom
country in fact. the government has
gone about the protection OF the vast
area Of land subject 10 oyernow ana
total inundation in a desultory and
half hearted way. No steps which
seemed calculated to lead TO the final
protection OF these lands have ever
been taken. Every eight or ten
years, or fifteen at most the rush OF
. waters following a winter of heavy
SHOWS in the mountains come down
upon the district subject to inunda-
tion and the contract built levees go
ont before the rush OF waters. melt
ing away like so much sugar Some
Of the very richest agricultural lands
in the United States, II not the very
richest lies in this territory made
Quate protection renders this land
well nigh worthless as an investment
and endangers the lives OF the per-
sons living in the district as we'll aS
sweeping away the personal savings.
The Country's government are
spending Millions OF dollars annually
upon far less commendable schemes,
and the suggestion OF Mr. Yoakum
seems both timely and opportune. As
this gentleman says the covernmen.
has on hands this machinery and it
can put it to no better use Should
II be sold it would he gobled up by
some set OF contractors with pulls
with certain engineers and the money
return therefor be little or nothing
Why not adopt the plan suggested