The Hawaiian star. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu]) 1893-1912, 1911-12-08
DIR. SCUDDER SCORES

This morning the Advertiser which did not have the grace c re-
publish Dr. scndde Die rS S2"g nc" S ,n
Yet it did not reveal single of DR. Scudder points
Instead it displayed frctu and quculous state of mind With
abundant ren the paper that the honorcd pastor and editor
SHOULD taken the trouble to learn few facts not naming them
and that he has gone off on tangent not pointing out a ne
ton deliberate mo and 2SSgI "''''S " 's'" TO I'll" sam
Nor does this reveal the whole Advertisers illogical
processes Dr. Scudder gracy told in further retuaion that
though he is a doctor Of well divinity there others
quite learned medical way as he is and that his way OF udg
ber b his motives he god he is bringing the civ closer to COM
plete Federal control the Advertisers whole plea rebual
all logic which intended to convince intelligent
public that Dr. scuder and The Friend wrong and the banana
cutting coterc which whitening under the buke Of cenihe men
like DR. Brigham Father Matthias Dr. WHc2M the Entomoosts
Fulaway Swe and Muir the findings OF Dr. Gorgas who raises
about his hospitals Panama and the physicians who have
this coee which is also emNe by inc common sense OF the people
who difference the deroers do in mosquito breeding
meo[PoraIGo % @ ry saw boo to Dr. Scuddr and be dome
scientific reports order by calling him full O bugs This would
have saved space gone the long article has convince the
public .,.:., 49,, ,,;.,. = r,. ,, /
lays propositions which the mzzed scouts So
AippantIy
That doubt exists as to the genuosnsss Of the two'
reputed yellow fever here that all the attendant circumstances
in Honolulu and Yokohama given the entire incident air of
uncertainty Is that moderate statement and as to the existence
of grave doubt true one? Or something influenced BY nor
H. That the centerng of attention the banana such tiny
san water was 50 suggestive Of the Noble Duke Of YORK. that very
deep nothing OF of injustice widely prevails among
Ill That the alleged danger banana culture had been sub
med combined wisdom Of the health and insect experts
before the order issued would have been
better public policy any dsnterested dis
with this? Does reflect upon the quality of Dr. Scudder
medical education? Is going off a tangent? -"
w. That the arbitrary and the
tolerated mainland community from
what we know of mainland exhibited when San Francisco
demanded the withdrawal of Federal doctor who began the
buboc plague compagn there and got the request granted by e
dent Mckinley; ~
v That the statement of Dr. Ebert about the presence of
quito Wggers closed bamboo sections MunchauSen tale
Does anyone believe story? the
credit it, Is not Dr. Scudders characterization Just?
VI That thousands of banana absolutely unnfesed BY
mosquitoes destroyed without the slightest attempt
them harmless Has anyone the hardhood deny this? Is not
knowledge? "''''
VII That the of the real culprit Or Currie) when
miserable this Scrio-comedy exclusion OF
CurS hating and testimony from the Advertiser itself tend
to show that the opinion of the morning about the same
that of other listeners? Has that testimony been since help
out the alleged logic OF the crusade? If why not?
NI hat IS regetabe that the public has gained the impress
SION u determined effort has been made by those charge
campaign TO prevent facts from coming Does
Porary think this regreabc? will the paper which admits
L "hed the favorable news about Ahupoko eight
'It 81 inc Citizens committee deny that the impression exists
"t TINS city mot convinced that the campaign
conducted IN accord with scientific truth Who
statement Anybody but those and the coterie
nave aued themselves the informed public opinion
hat Honolulu has been kept from getting together the
aSqto crusade because of lack of broad sense
uc part OF the crusaders What else pray tell has divided intelligent
oDn on n
majority Would exhibition sense have been re-
CeNe m mat way by the kind of people DR. Scdder speaks for
30 Advertiser
stands unattended better reonder
Board OF Health ahead with
work the legislature intended do when apart the revolving
fund.- the better for the public veal
CONSTITUTIONAL MONARCHY FIRST