Arizona republican., 1911-01-07
THE COURT IS SURPRISED
Government Counsel States That Dissolution Is Asked For Under the Wilson Tariff Act as Well as Un- der the Sherman Law.

, Wa-uu-ru Jan ."rT argum.ut n tu, proposed r|-~.ut..u of th, -o- called -T,bt.r, Trust began late foe Ias u -arr.m. e.ur, A- E,.r ago. sH,u tn. dI--.lu.ou suit was ar-a,G ,a- first tm. h..,a. tN, court $, today J e. Mel;guo..-. special a--.-au, attorney general mad, rh. oIauu- aldr.-- IT.. naH ..- sou- ,rud.d h.- r.uares when ,.. court iaauuru.a mr Nenaas
 Gy arrangement ru.u~. nu both sides agreed Co ,aue.aa, ta, ar-u m.ut- u ru.., hours This H.N bring q. ..,-, ta. lr.-.urt- '.au about thr-. ...I..H N,4u.~dat. Nr tasr rm. tn. Standard n. dis -.I.t.u -ut rI be. taken ur cpr .rE argument
 A' i,.~r u.. important result Ht- accomplished m tl. first f.. mu- nt.- NeE,.unu- -rosr H- surprised -sr. uf th. m,mn.r- of m. court nH saving that dissolution was asked tnr uat .uIv under CT. Sherman aur.- trust Jaw. hut under rH- Wilson trt act
 N.E.gr.IG- r.I# tu.. court that rHi- Ra- rh. Hr-t ..-. that aaa ...r r..u brought under tn. Wilson rur a.'. This h- explained. .rr.-. ts ..- stances ot restraint rt trad. uh.r. au anrr.. Ha- . part Iu.. ...- cI.~-.au Hrd rtr,u rIa,. u 'u-t eases whether tn. H.r.-. f.-'r...t nf trfj. .a tu. sherman mr-tru-f IaE vs- equivalent rt restraint rf .,Hr,t.rIn.
 seH..uora- gaar.. a.t that ... Wilson a.t Hr- a .Hu-r.--..raH a. ,.rI,rtarl.n ut tH. sherman aet r..--- .I four E.ar- Ir.....- and that HI doubt uI .t- meaning had n..r r moved b.. a~.u- f.. iurt-, restraint uC fra. ,nup,ttt.nu \.Hr'. ..' tH, ;.mr NDE.. uu.I- spoke lr devoted n.a-.. tY tue H.-t.. %. tb. t,htr.p trust" from ta. rm, ur tar first NnI- -.rtcm T.nt,.. ,awT#.- u1~ nrrau- fz.d m l,rn .r tl- alleged purpn-. uf eti..tug t.- u.u,lnIy 70. tH. cigarette trade. down tr tn- m,,r- rYratlnn .u lHuf 70. ta, u.A American Tobacco company. upla.u- ,pu- ItuE. controlling ~rztg-t.E- ,,upaal.. interested Iu various branches rr tl- t"baeo' business
 THr trad. uf tH. world u tobacco. had been r1r..l,i our. h- said tho American .tr.-t- taking th- Tur.a Stat.- and Cuba for it's own. tN. British trust. Great Britain Ireland and tl- l-I. %. Man. tHc British American Tupt..p comru. organ z.d Two .tru-t- carrying tu, tpbar- op business pr,r tae rest ul th, world H, alleged that competition u the pur.Ha~. of leaf tphaco1 hal been eliminated u th- United Stat.-
 The sut under tH. sherman anti tru-t law tu di~~ull" th, ~,-caII,d "Tobaecu trust" uJs instituted u Ieu7 in tn. circuit court pr tn. United States fur th. southern dis uict 'i Now York. Th. prncredru-s was brought hN th. department ri justice against mor. than sixty cur- poratous ud a number uf udiytd- ual defendants headed by James E Duk,
 The process ui nrGtuizatinu uf tu. combination alleged Go be unlawful spread over many years lt began in January. 1>"o Then th. first Amer icau Tobacco company was irtur- p"rated for th" rurpuS. it is alleged. oi taking over tho business or five independent cigarette plants
 In l>3>. thc Continental Tobacco company WAS incorporated rpr lh. alleged IurpuS. or taking oyer trr plug tobacco business of sth, Amer ioan T"bacc" company and tn, bus ness "f fiN" other plus t"bacc" cou- ccru~
 In 1000. tu. American Suunr com pany Was incorporated for the alleged purpose pf taking over the snuff bu~i- ness of th" American Tobacco com rntpauy aud of t.,, COP three iud,- pendent Snuff manufacturers
 Tn 1901. th, American Cigar com Iany was incorporated for tlc aI- legged purpose of taking over th, cigar business nr the American To- haccp company and au independent manufacturer of cigars.
 Tn the same year the Cou~pIidat.d T"hacc" company was incorporated for the alleged purpose of taking over as holding company in eN- change for it~ bonds SubstarrHIIv an "f the stock pf tr. American To- hacc" compauy aud tH" Continental Tphtccu company
 lu 1r".. tho American Stoei, ,pr- rauy was incorporated for th. a'- legged purpose nf taking over tE, st'gie business of th- American Ci-