The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1911-02-14
||}ITE BEGINS
|II.IlEC|PR0C|TY
Hsuse of Congress Votes
sI,Iunsdiate Consideration
n BY Large Majority.
urRATs SUPPORT
,I The M'CALL MEASURE
pp,nt Of Hill of West 'Ir-
ai,. and Reply of Gaines
d West Virginia.

,.uNcroN. Feb is'-The house
n ls5 to l21. decided today 10
.iiate consideration OF the NC
N esryIng out the reciprocity
aI,h Canada. No agreement
,.,cbed as 10 the limit OF de-
rlue the vote 10 dlsplace the
] .r,.r for today on the house cal
"a take up reciprocity cannot be
.s,, an cxect indication OF the
=, On the bill, It is regarded as
,,y,O1imately so. The vote aSains. s.
,n The measure today came altiios'
INN The Republican side.
rs~ocra,s voted almost solidiy Ior
IN, consideration. Some OF the
ss.,os who voted against diSplac,
|. . rscular order are not expected
~ themselves on record against
r-eIr al a linal vote.
vs(sII OF Massachusetts, VIII nan
4. i'm, for debate IN favor OF the
a III Dalzell OF Pennsylvania vii!
~ ljIs capacity for the opposition
=, O'clock il was stated that no
$, ~ souN be made 10 get the meas
1 : vote today.
4 NlI ls ms, being considered by
-, IS a committee Of the whole.
". Mann in the Chair.
.,,p, Cannon called Representative
4 4 Illinois 20 the chair TO preside
4 q. committee during the considera-
1 q he measure.
4 4. earlier proceedings Mr.. Cannon.
|~r'zrir,ng Mr, Mccall and declaring
.-rEt 10 take up the reciprocity bill
|,sxsd matter, had shown q dlspo"
. 20 help the cause along to vote
|fn ,hs sentiments against reciprocity
IS Ls expressed In a letter 10 the
Es legislature on Saturday.
|k-txniatiye Hill of Connecticut, one
II. Republican members Q. the COM
= a Ways and means. was recoe
= tg obs hour In support OF the reci-
ID agreement. When he began TO
3 lls houre was In much confusion.
4 u HIT asked for close attention.
|[,es over on this side" suggested
<az,aiiye Fitzgerald OF New York,
|1&nl We'll listen to you. and
you will get your votes"
Majority Is Large.
D vs,lng on the motion TO take UP
/ rdproclty measure was followed
/ o. ksenest interest, On a yea and
NE there are always two calls
"a The alphabetical list
fs end Of the flrgt call IL was seen
" feciprocity advocates were win
vu,s was then: Ayes. ITS; noes.
" end Of the second call the vote
t,zouneed as l95 to 12l.
vas later changed TO 1876 10 12l
tTtt. a clerical error.
talIsis OF the vote TO take up the
fnl showed this result:
-S.puhlcans. so; Democrats 1856.
esl-Republlcans. lo1: Democrats.
nal l2l.
2publican Insurgents attitude to-
iSlprocity was shown ny the fact
tftr H.
Argument of MI. Hill.
Hills opening argument in favor
,sieement followed closely the
" down and the facts set forth
majority report from the ways
hs committee He was inter-
,Nn time 10 time, Asked il he
eL a'or OF free trade with Canada.
az eald he favored unrestricted
~ every country where the cost
|resctlon did not differ from that I'm
l,t.d States, ' '''' -
u oeclarcd that talk Of injury
|, - interests in the United States
III, u reciprocity was not based
~ T said no amendment could be
us Oil except in the wood pulp
9 suhout disturbing ths whole
ai with Canada. Ife refused 10
ne wood pulp clause leaving
LA slsssshtatlve sls.sssh Mann OF Illinois.
|1rstmsunI, uIea earnestly for support Of
s,ss.., ssai. saying 1t would bring the
"A iM.nE ,inE people Of North Ameri-
Ne sL ~ d, commercial union. which
nm !. n,,1 ,n1lsunct advantage to both
80 ,sa a.ea out applause by saving
IL tsarT forget an eloquent speech
isurs aiu :, speaker Cannon make on
=. \. VI me United States. The
Il Soea' %la' had declared that the
esnes4 america would one day
hten6sa Titnin this country and
X In nus Vision TO include the
D.. western hemisphere.
Aepls Of Mr.. Gaines.
IN yfnlns tDsn speech against the re-
Hi Gaina. was made by Repre-
3, nemhs. OF West Virginia. a Re
ltt OF the ways and means
\ f'ass D1ss.. said n. the consideration o, the
hf nn ,daa with Indecent haste -
u 10 tha a had been given 10 the
' contents OF The Mccall
= s1oss o,,s,t asserted that there was
e,at Ti,h OF reciprocity" In the
lToye iii, Sdhada. He declared he
Tree ;,rr., 10 be the case n he
tbemsss,.. II the Democrats ha d
va and 90, up under A caucus
bad not III pressure from a high
~. "en applied to the Re
sae 10 sal said Mr.. Gaipes, "1 do
yfptectiop o's Tor n measure that
9 Which o, 10 all manufactured d
lhe f,Sd Snd then forces free III 'do
4 aan amend, products. | propose
tie Tsen9 dment to put the nr,d !.
sant 10 60. trust OH the free list
soI Ara zee zee What the ca,Iru.-tIoS
Gaines SSo,nS to do about n !" ''
& sound nd"ounced the agreement
He =, tshd pretonse OF rec.
ttnislep, sa,d s he had been abIe
lbA srrsoch srarch to find only twc
,eslsa bv bvSiSCsment where the dnt,
At ot CTR T. preferential tariff ''tn,f HnT
sohpste. ."ese Items could Great @
'ap s.ai Clark 1ntorvenes.
ssTtSpsf9asssSntsa,iye ~ chamn c,o =,
= s.'rpptess essoSte SI, for the first time
Mas az al, air, Gaines to ask! ..1
9ant Tor '1 make 1t out. how d,
als'' -" british and Canada,
!! 'sswsr esH:t that replied Mr.
sTok IN F. : tell what cont;,t,om, % I,l
doesn't t,sland ,snd or Canada ''
'Sn IN those m ,i TACT that there 4
ploces tend to weake,
usa on Page Two.