davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The Barre daily times. (Barre, Vt.) 1897-1959, 1911-05-29
POSTMASTER HATCH DEAD.
Well Known Citizen Of Chelsea Died
Saturday.

Chelsea, May 29.- On Saturday morn
ing this community was greatly sad
dened to learn Of the death Of Deacon
Willard s. Hatch which occurred dur
ing the early hours Of the morning. 1t
was generally known that Mr.. Hatch,
who had been in decline for several
months, had failed more rapidly dur
ing the past few days but his death
was not expected so soon and il came
as great shock TO his immediate fam.
lily and his multitude of friends. The
cause OF his death was valvular disease
Of the heart, caused by rheumatism
Mr. Hatch who was just past sixty
two years old, had always lived in
this town where he conducted gro-
eery and crockery store and for the
past ten years has most efficiently
served the public as their postmaster.
In politics he was a staunch Repubi-
can; he was member and deacon sof
the Congregational church and mem
Der and past master of George Wash
ington Lodge, i & A. NJ, and was
its treasurer at the time of his death.
The funeral was held from the Congre-
gational church, this afternoon at three
O'Clock Besides his widow, who was
Miss Sarah Burgess. he is survived by
one son, Edward B Hatch, who is in
the employ of the Vermont Marble
company at Proctor, and one daughter,
Miss Emma Hatch, who resides at
home and is the assistant postmaster.
He is also survived by one brother,
George e. Hatch, of Milford. N. M.
and four sisters, Mrs. f. d. Barnes
OF this town Mrs, Sarah Bennett Of
Springfield, Mass, Miss Ellen Hatch OF
Boston, and Miss Susie Hatch, who Is
q teacher in South Africa. The deep
est sympathy of the entire townspeople
Is extended to the bereayed families,
and in his death the town has lost one
Df its best citizens and the government
Z most faithful and competent Off
sial.
The Barre daily times. (Barre, Vt.) 1897-1959, 1911-05-29
WILLIAMSBURG

Horace Farnham of Montpelier visit
ed his mother here yesterday.
Mr.. and Mrs Nat abbott and child
of East Corinth were ever Sunday visit
ors at Hiram Drury's. Miss Eastman
came with them and is to remain a
while.
Miss Helen Kimball of Richmond is
with Miss Mile Drury Tor few days,
George Edison aud family of Mont
pelier were visitors at his brothers,
Charles Edison, yesterday.
George Goodrich went to Montpelier
Saturday and accompanied Mrs. Good
rich home. She is gaining rapidly.
There will be a union Sunday school
institute on Monday, June 5, under the
auspices Of the Vermont Sunday School
association. 1t will be held at the
Congregational church in the afternoon
and evening The annual meeting Of the
Williamstown Sunday School association
will be held at the same time.
Miss Ruth Angel, daughter OF Rev. ].
O. Angel, who remained at Stowe to
complete her high school course, came
home to be with her parents over Sun
day and Memorial day.
On account OF Tuesday being Me-
mortal day, the young peoples meeting
at the Congregational church will be
put over till Thursday evening, and sll,
both young and old are invited
Joseph Scholield. son of Rev William
Schofeld, is quite i'll at his home in
Enfield, n. H., and reports as to his
condition are not encouraging. Mr..
Schofeld is a railroad engineer, having
been in the service quite a number of
years, and seems to have broken down
under the strain.
The Barre daily times. (Barre, Vt.) 1897-1959, 1911-05-29
EXERCISES AT HIGH SCHOOL.
Patriotic Program Given at Spaulding
To-day.

Pre-Memorial EXERCISES We're held by
Spaulding high school to-day, beginning
at ii o'clock Several members of the
student body read selections bearing
on the great problems which faced the
country during the trying times of the
Civil war. Supt O. D. Mathewson,
with few explanatory remarks, intro
duced each reader The program was
as follows: music merican hymn,
school chorus; THE Impending Crisis"
Helper. Miss Stebbins; Secession"
Alex. Stephens, Mr. Hagan; "'our
Withdrawing from the Union' jeff
Davis, Mr.. Watt; music, The Soldier,
school chorus; First Inauguration"
lincoln, Mr. Tayntor; @The Necessity
of Union Stephen Douglas, Mr.
Waterman; "Stonewall Jackson" Miss
Hooker; music, Tenting on the Old
Campground. senior boys; Gettysburg
Address" Lincoln Mr. Adie; Second
Inaugural Lincoln, Miss Inglis;
Tribute to Lincoln" Beecher, Miss
Tierney; music, My Native Land, school
chorus; Mother and Poet" Mrs.
Browning, Miss Lavelle; music Amer
lea, school chorus
The Barre daily times. (Barre, Vt.) 1897-1959, 1911-05-29
TOMORROW AT PARK.
Some Big Trotting Events and other
Interesting Features.

With favorable weather conditions to-
morrow, the Gentlemen's Driving club
expects to have some of the best
racing ever seen at the track for so
early in the season. Among the en-
tries for the several CLASSES to be
raced. the best horses in this vicinity
are all entered and several from Bur
lington and other nearby cities. Al
billiard, 2:I2h, owned by Page
brothers. and one Of the best race
horses ever bred in Vermont, viii be
seen on the track and show some of the
speed that has placed him in the 2:l3
class. There is probably no better
racing prospect in New England to-
days than this fellow.
&. C. Bonnette. who win make the
flight in his new biplane, has been busy
fol the past two days limbering up the
various working parts of the big
machine and testing the engine that
there may be no trouble from that
source With a clear day, no doubt the
largest crowd ever seen on the grounds
will be in attendance
The Barre daily times. (Barre, Vt.) 1897-1959, 1911-05-29
TWO NEW TRAINS.
On Barre Branch of Central Vermont
After June rs.

The summer schedule of trains over
the Central Vermont will necessitate
two extra trains on the Barre branch.
one of which viii leave at 2:0s in the
afternoon and the other at s in the
evening Both of these trains will con-
meet with main line trains going south
The schedule will go into effect on
June 25th and though not definitely
fixed, ii will bep ractically ss follows:
South bound connections, and II 80
in the forenoon, 2;0s. and 1855
North bound connections, a. m,
3;l5 p. M, 5:45 p. m, and
Pals a. M The train which leaves
now at $40 in the morning viii leave
at s o'clock and the LAS will leave at
1880. The sos viii leave at 3;l5 and
the two night trains remain the some
The Barre daily times. (Barre, Vt.) 1897-1959, 1911-05-29
WOMEN INJURED.
When Thrown From Carriage at Wall
lingford.

Rutland, MAY 20 While returning
from East Wallingford where they
lad been decorating the graves of their
dead members, party of four mem
bers of the Kearney Relief Corps OF
Walhngford had narrow escape ye-
terday afternoon when a surrey in
which they were riding overturned,
spilling ali into the road and seriously
injuring three in the party Mrs Hub
bard Willard who recently recovered
from an operation, suffered an injured
knee and also suffered from the shock
Mrs. Theodore Holden was bruised, while
Mrs Frank Hawkins was badly hurt
about the bead and face The other
woman Mrs John Burdick, escaped, as
did the driver, Roy Twine
The accident occurred when the
driver was forced to turn out for an
other vehicle aud one OF the forward
wheels gave way.
The Barre daily times. (Barre, Vt.) 1897-1959, 1911-05-29
TOTAL WRECK
OF ONE CAR
And in This Most Of the Nine
Deaths Occurred
IN WRECK AT McC00k, NEB
East and West Bound Passenger Trains
on Burlington Railroad Came To-
gether This Morning, One
The Colorado Limited.

Denver, Colo, May 2o.--At least nine
persons were killed and twenty were In
jured this morning in headon col
lision between an east bound and a
west bound passenger train on the Bur-
lington railroad, at a point ten miles
east of McCook, Nebraska. The west
bound train was the Colorado Limited
express. The day coach on the Limited
was totally wrecked, and in this car
most of the fatalities occurred The
tourist and baggage ears We're thrown on
their sides. On the westbou train
the tiremen, brakeman and an ex-
press messenger are reported TO have
been killed.
The Barre daily times. (Barre, Vt.) 1897-1959, 1911-05-29
JAIL SENTENCE
OF FIVE MONTHS
Imposed on Angelo Calderara, Who
Pleaded Guilty to Charge of Sell
ing When Arraigned To-

Angelo Calderara pleaded guilty in the
city court this forenoon to the charge
OF selling and was sentenced to the
county jail for not less than five or
more than six months. Following three
disclosures, made recently to the prose-
cutting officers, a raid was made at Cal
dearra's house at 50 River street at 10
o'clock this morning by Deputy Sher-
ifs A. NJ. Morrison, H. d. Camp and
Fl. j. Slayton. Two half barrels Of
beer were seized and Galderara was TAX
en- on warrant issued by States At
torney J. Ward Carver,
The Barre daily times. (Barre, Vt.) 1897-1959, 1911-05-29
PRAYER SERVICE HELD.
And Remains of Mrs. w. E. Haskins
Were Taken to Danbury, N. H.

A prayer service for Mrs w f.
Haskins. who died Friday afternoon,
was held at the home on North Main
street at o'clock this morning, Rev
J. W Barnett officiating, and the body
WAS taken on the $40 train to Dan
bury, n H., where the funeral serv-
ices will be held at o'clock Tuesday,
Many friends attended the service at
the home this morning The pail bear
ers were +. G. Wetmore, George L.
Bates. Walter Perkins and w f.
Humphrey
The following is a list of the floral
tributes: Pillow of Easter lilies and
roses, family; wreath and mound, the
Smith. Whitcomb & Cook company;
roses, Mrs ] X Daggett; roses Mrs.
Newcomb; carnations and roses. Mrs.
John Turner; white carnations, Mr.
and Mrs w e. Humphrey; white
carnations, Mrs Maiden; carnations,
Mrs. Eli Densmore; roses Mr. and
Mrs. o. D. Shurtleff; carnations Mrs
C. D. Carpenter
The Barre daily times. (Barre, Vt.) 1897-1959, 1911-05-29
ACCUSED OF SELLING.
Charles Shadroui was anaigned in the
City Court This Morning.

Charles Shadroui was arraigned in
city court this morning on the charge
OF selling to which he entered plea
OF not guilty and furnished bail for
his appearance for a hearing next Mon
day morning Shadroui has been want
ed by the officers since his place on
Granite street was raided last March.
At the time of the raid Shadroui was
not at home and though the police had
been looking for him ever since he had
not been back home until he wa seen
there Saturday by Officer Carrie A
bottle OF whiskey was found at the
house BY the officers who did the raid
inu
The Barre daily times. (Barre, Vt.) 1897-1959, 1911-05-29
MISS DORA A. HILTON.
Death Came Suddenly This Morning at
Waterbury Hospital.

Miss Dora A.. Hilton, native Of Mid
dlcsex, but who has been residing in
Barre for the past two years, died sud
IDENTIFY at the hospital in Waterbury
this morning, the cause being heart
trouble She was taken to the Water
bury institution three weeks ago, from
the home of her sister. Mrs Charles
a Lundgren. where she had been ten
dcrIv cared for Miss Hilton was AZ
years Of age and Mrs Lundgren is
the only near relative surviving Ar
rangements for the funeral have not
been completed, but the burial will be
in Plainfeld beside the bodies of her
parents
The Barre daily times. (Barre, Vt.) 1897-1959, 1911-05-29
Rebel Leader Postpones Trip to
Mexico City
THE EXCITEMENT is INTENSE
Madero Himself Ascribes Another Rea-
son Besides the One Generally Cred
ited-Three Insurrecto Chiefs Are
Included In the Plot.

FL Paso May Revelations of an
alleged plot to start another revolution
IN Mexico after overthrowing the lead
ership of Francisco /. Madero, jr., and
preventing his journey to Mexico City
created intense excitement throughout
the insurreeto army to-day. That Mad
ero has been advised OF certain facts,
not generally known, is believed to ex-
plain the delay in his departure to
the capital to consult with de la Barra
concerning pressing governmental prob
lems, although Madero himself declared
that he postponed the trip merely to
nwait the installation of the provisional
governors The plot is said to include
three insurrecto chiefs operating in
Coahuila
The Barre daily times. (Barre, Vt.) 1897-1959, 1911-05-29
FIRE IN AMUSEMENT
PARK CAUSES DEATHS
John Boettinger and Unknown Man
Asleep in Lodging House When
Fire Broke Out, Probably
Perished. Loss s2so,ooo.

San Francisco, May % John Boet.
finger and man whose name is un-
known are believed to have persisted in
a fire that destroyed the cltutes in
San Francisco's. largest amusement re-
score to-day The men were asleep in
IA lodging house Other occupants were
seriously injured by flames The loss
is quarter Of million dollars.
The Barre daily times. (Barre, Vt.) 1897-1959, 1911-05-29
SPEED KING
PROVES 1T
Bob Bunnan Goes Mile in 1885
Seconds
AT THE INDIANAPOLIS TRACK
The Great Racer Drove 200 Horsepower
Benz Car to Beat One-Year-0 old
Record Established by Bar
ney 0ldfeld.

indianapolis, Ind, May 2O.- Bob Bur.
man, the speed king driving a 200
horsepower Blitzen Benz ear, this morn.
ing established new worlds record
for one mile, going the distance in 35:35
seconds. The previous record was 35:63
aud was held by Barney 0ldfeld. The
latter record was made by 0ldfeld in
this city on May 30, 1910, one year ago
tomorrow.
The Barre daily times. (Barre, Vt.) 1897-1959, 1911-05-29
COULDN'T GET BAIL.
Actus RaymO Charged With Attempted
Criminal Assault.

Highgate, May 20 Actus Raymo
was arraigned IN justice court Saturday
afternoon on the charge Of attempted
criminal assault on Retta Bingham
aged IA years He was placed under
bail Of 5000, which he was unable to
furnish and went to county Jail to
await the next session Of county court,
The Barre daily times. (Barre, Vt.) 1897-1959, 1911-05-29
PORTUGAL TOO IRRELIGIoUs.
Pope Sent Message To-day to Roman
Catholic Bishops of the World.

Rome, May 20 An encyclical, ad-
dressed by Pope Plus to the Roman
Catholic bishops throughout the world,
strongly deploring the anti-religioss att
titude of the government of the Por-
tuguese republic, was officially pub
lished at the Vatican to-day.
The Barre daily times. (Barre, Vt.) 1897-1959, 1911-05-29
ONE SAILOR KILLED.
Torpedo Boats Collided and Were Con.
siderablv Damaged.

Liel Germany, May % Two Ger
man torpedo boats arrived here to-day
ia damaged condition, having been
in a collision near Skagen, Denmark.
One sailor was killed.
The Barre daily times. (Barre, Vt.) 1897-1959, 1911-05-29
Notice to shop Stewards.

Granite cutters rooms will be open
Wednesday etening for the purpose of
taking dues or any other business. A.
NJ. Smith, secretary.
The Barre daily times. (Barre, Vt.) 1897-1959, 1911-05-29

The sewing meeting Of the woman's
missionary society of the Congregational
church will be held with Mrs. II. G.
Woodruff Wednesday at 2;S0 p. m. Re
ports OF the Middlebury convention win
be given.
The Barre daily times. (Barre, Vt.) 1897-1959, 1911-05-29
Order Of Exercises To-morrow.

Following the parade TO Elmwood
cemetery tomorrow morning, public
exercises viii be held at the opera
house the orator of the day being S
Hollister Jackson. The order OF ex-
efeises will he as follows;
Selection by the band ...,......a...
Reading general orders ............
......... Adiutant L. II Thurston
Salute to the dead ..............
...,.4.....A Adjutant l.. II Tnrston
Solo ....... Miss Barbara Maynard
Tribute to the unknown dead ....
............ Comrade A. J. Baldwin
Reading President Lincoln's Gettys-
burg address Comrade 4. j. Baldwin
Selection by the hand ..............
Prayer ......s Rev J. ". Barnett
Singing. "Americar .....s............
Address ..........S. Hollister Jackson
Solo ........ Miss Barbara Maynard
Benediction .-.-..- ...-.
The Barre daily times. (Barre, Vt.) 1897-1959, 1911-05-29
NO PAPER TOMORROW.

Tomorrow being Memorial day. no
paper will be issued from this Office.
Wednesdays Issue will contain full ac-
counts Of the days doings
The Barre daily times. (Barre, Vt.) 1897-1959, 1911-05-29

Big sale of new ttyle waists in all
over embroidery. sPecias price 9S cents.
Paris ShiTtwaist house.
The Barre daily times. (Barre, Vt.) 1897-1959, 1911-05-29
Band Concert Program Tomorrow Night

The following is the program of the
band concert to be given by the Barre
Citizens band tomorrow evening in
the park;
- ,,,ar,eor
Arizona republican., 1911-04-10

"A acres in northwest quarter. section
p. township l north. range east
JH. Kinney and wife to I. J. Kinney
deed. lot l.. block 16. Mt. Pleasant
Add
Robert B. Black to Gus Z. Bell. deed
east half. northeast quarter. northeast
quarter, section 80. township > north
range east.
NJ. II. Sherman Investment Co. Ia
Anita Lame. deed To- lot 10. block IS,
Collins addition.
Tweed Co. TO Home
Builders. deed To lot 8. block 3. Ken
ilworth place
A. H Burning and wife To Glen
w Burning. deed To- northwest quar-
ter of section Is, town 1 south. range
s east.
y. Friedline and wife to Isaac
Rude. deed TO lot % Monte Vista
place.
Emma Grigs and husband To Eliza
beth Jameson. deed To lot Is, block
II. Bennett place
j. W. Walker and wife To J. A and
r. L. Drane. deed To northwest quar-
ter Of northwest quarter and north
half of southwest quarter of north
west quarter of section "a, town >
south. range 3 east
l.. II. Graw and wife 70 NJ. s
Grau. deed To lot 1 Bancroft place.
Valley Bank. Trustee. To L. 5. L
T. * L. Co. deed to lot 20. block
Arizona republican., 1911-04-10
FEEL LIKE GIVING UP?

Dark days come when the kidneys
are sick. A bad back makes you
miserable all the time.
You awake tired. lame and sore. 1t
is a task TO get dressed. II hurts so
to bend over. 1t is agony to straight
en- up again.
All day the dull. throbbing ache
keeps up, varied with stabs of pierre
ing pain when you twist or turn;
whirling dizzy spells, specks and
spots dancing before the eyes. miser-
able headaches and a dead tired or
languid feeling.
You have no appetite for meals.
can't work, can't rest, and are an
moved with too frequent urination,
and a burning scalding pain in max
ing passages.
At night the suffer retires, hop
ing for sleep that either does not
come, or is troubled and fitful. Sew
eral times during the night you
awake with a desire TO urinate.
No wonder that so many people
who have bad backs get respondent
and nervous. They too often do not
know that it is sick kidneys that
cause it all.
There is prompt relief in using
Doan's Kidney Pills. a few doses
Arizona republican., 1911-04-10
AdtW@1pttiiSin@ Talks
The Readers Of The Repu
By JOHN IRVING RoMER. Editor Of "Piuter' Ink."

to the kind of patronage he desired.
In short time he SECURED JUST
THE SORT OF TRADE he had been
shooting blank-cartridge advertise
ments at for year.
1t takes loaded ammunition to get
any kind Of game, from bear to a
bObolink Of course you must select
APPROPRIATE ammunition. Bear
shot would scatter a bobolink all over
the place, and bird shot wouldn't have
much effect upon bear.
So pick out the RIGHT KIND OF
OFFERS for the trade you are after,
bat always see that your advertise
ments CONTAIN these offers.
Don't go to the other extreme, and
make your advertisements nothing but
a price-list of goods. Remember that
cartridge must have POWDER as
well as shot, to drive the bullet home.
Your talk on store policy, on the ma
ture and value of your offers, is the
powder in your advertisements. And
the more INTERESTING you make
that talk. the more CONFIDENCE
you INSPIRE on the part Oh the puDllc,
the more EFFECTIVE your offers
will be-
Mr.. Merchant, the trade is there,
waiting for you. The local newspaper
is an effective weapon always at your
hand. But it's UP TO YOU to supply
the ammunition. Use good powder and
solid shot, and your advertising will
get RESULTS.
Arizona republican., 1911-04-10
POWER TRANSMITTED
FROM HAYDEN TO RAY
FORCE OF SIXTY MEN OPERAT-
ING DRILLS
Twenty Stamp Mill Now Reducing
Ore at Venezia Mine, in
Yavapai County

The big compressor wheels at the
Ray mines made their first revolu-
tions Sunday. Power was turned on
at Hayden twenty miles away and
he pOnderous machinery responded.
The practical result Of months of
labor and expenditure of vast sum
Of money were demonstrated, says
the Ray Copper Camp.
OF course there is much to do yet
before applying the quickening touch
of electric power to the various parts
of the big mine. But the prelimin-
airy and necessary work of bringing
$4,000 voltage, alternating power to
the mines mouth has been accom-
plished
AS rapidly. as they can get to it
and the operating department under
Superintendent Gates, the new power
will be applied to the underground
drills and hoists and whenever II can
be advantageously used. On this
trip, General Manager Jackling saw
the machinery at Ray turned by
power from Hayden. On his next
trip, if everything goes well. he will
see ore brought into the new bins
Arizona republican., 1911-04-10

SUFFERINGS
Dumb Chills, and Other Serious
Symptoms, Complicated the Ill
ness of Miss Rutherford,
Formerly of Atlanta.

DouglassviIe. Tex.-"Five years ago,
l was caught in rain at the wrong
time" writes Edna Rutherford of
Douelassville, Tex, and from that
time was taken with dumb chills and
fevers and suffered more than / can
tell
Il tried all the medicines that l
thought would do me any good, and
four different doctors. but got no re-
lief. so l began to take Cardui.
4 have now taken six bottles of
Cardui and am wonderfully improved.
! feel better than l have in many
months and am thankful to your won
derful medicine"
There is a reason why Cardui is
SO exceptionally successful in relieving
women's troubles, after other medi
cines fail, and that is, that it contains
rare herbal ingredients, which have to
be imported especially from Europe
and which by their specific action on
the womanly organs, help to strength
en- and restore them to health.
Cardui is more successful than 9TH
er medicines because it is different"
1t is in a class by itself. 1t is not
cure all. but a woman's medicine,
tonic for weak women.
1t does one thing, and does it we'll
That's the secret of its 80 years of
success.
y. B.-Write to: Ladies Advisory
Dept, Chattanooga Medicine Co, Chat
tanoOga. Tenn. for Special Instructions,
and 64-page book, Home Treatment
for Women" sent in plain wrapper, on
request
Arizona republican., 1911-04-10
NEW HAT MATERIAL.

There - a new hat material which
is being very successfully used in the
spring models. IL is called mulleau
and is like lawn in texture. but il has
more body and at the same time is
much more pliable IL is thick enough
To conceal the wire, which is very
desirable feature, and one layer OF
mulleau is equivalent to three or four
of either chiffon or maline. The heavy
texture Of mulleau makes it very
desirable coloring over which 10 use
transparent filmy draperieS.
Arizona republican., 1911-04-10
RECORD OF TRANSFERS
A Reported BY the Arizona
Abstract & Title Company,
. 114 West Washington St.

Lewis Raffe To Bly, f. Wood, deed,
lots and ;. block \. West Lawn Add.
Lewis Raffe to Maggie G. Wood. deed.
lot 8. block \. West Yawn Add.
Nathaniel A Sanders and wife to
Liberty NJ. +. Church. South, deed.
90x7O feet in southeast corner south
welt quarter. section 80, township 1
north. range west.
: NJ Milanes and wife tC G. W.
Goodman. deed, lot IS. Highland Add.
A. +. James and wife To PIX. Cons.
& Supply Co. deed, lot Is. block r.
Woodland Place.
Maria Miller to julius Herman, deed,
Arizona republican., 1911-04-10

Advertising a retail store without
giving specific offers Of merchandise
is like SHOOTING WITH BLANK
CARTRIDGES. You may make a lot
of noise, but you don't hit anything.
And when you fail to get results it
is manifestly unfair to put the blame
on your gun-the newspaper that carr
ries your advertising
SPECIFIC OFFERS of merchandise
are the only real ammunition of the re-
tail advertiser. The growth and sue
cess Of the department store is due to
the fact that department store adver-
Using has always been LOADED TO
THE MUZZLE with this hot shot Of
specific offers of goods at stated prices.
No matter what class of trade you
are after, you need real ammunition
Just the same.
A certail retailer opened shop in
Philadelphia to cater to the highest
class of trade. For whole year his
advertising consisted of smoothly
wOrded invitations to visit his shop
and inspect his wares. He was afraid
if he made special offer in any OF his
advertisements he would be barred for
ever from the patronage of the elect.
At the end of year he WOKE UP.
He decided he had had enough of sat
mosphere," and would like to dis
place some Of it WITH CUSTOMERS.
He commenced putting SPECIAL OF
FERS DAILY in his advertisements
offers of character that would appeal