davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1911-05-02
DEBATE IN SENATE.
Three Hour Speech by Stone of Missouri
on Reciprocity Bill,


WASHINGTON, May I'm three
hour speech Senator Stone OF Missouri
In the senate today denounced what he
regards an unjust propaganda to defeat
tempt. he said was being made to alarm
the American people by painting rne
ruin that would follow the free ImDorta-
tlon OF Canadian goods. "the product OF
cheap labor"
This contention. he said. was untrue,
and he submitted statistics to show that
both labor and livestock were higher
When Mr.. Stone concluded Senator
Galllnger asserted that the Missouri
senator had proved conclusively that
cost OF living which II had been contend
ed reciprocity would bring TO the United
States. Mr.. Stone replied that he had
not contended that reciprocity would be
OF great benefit, but had undertaken to
show that it would produce no great
injury
Of revenue" Mr.. Gallinger retorted Mr.
Stone urged that the great benefit to be
derived from entering into reciprocity
courage freer trade with that country,
opening the way 10 freer trade with the
world. He said he hoped to have an op-
portunity TO vote for the house free list
Mr. Cummins agreed with Mr. Stone 8
conclusions regarding prices in Canada
and SAID ,,, he was a CONVINCED the passage
tion in the cost OF living
Mr. Stone contended that American la =
Dor Is in no special danger from labor in
Canada. and replying TO Mr.. Page OF
Vermont, he said IL appeared to him
from government figures that farm
wages IN Canada are so per cent higher
than In the United States.
Counting out the lowering effect of the
small wages paid negro labor in southern
states Mr.. Gallinger said the American
wages paid near the boundary line are
from 25 to 30 per cent more than across
the line. He contended that generally
prices were higher in Canada than In
this country.
Messrs Galinger Smoot Warren
Jones, Hepburn. Cummins Martin,
Bailey and Bacon discussed the range Of
prices on dairy cattle,
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1911-05-02
Address of Attorney General
Wickersham Before Univer-
sity Class of 1911.
DECLARES WE ARE A
LAW-RIDDEN PEOPLE
Cabinet Member Denounces
Those Who Urge Amend
ment of Constitution.

PRINCETON. n. j., May 1.-Attor
ney General Wickersham scored the
recall and the so-called progressive
movement in an address here tonight
before the Princeton class of 1911.
owe are in truth law-ridden peo'
plc," he said; "and this tendency is
encouraged and stimulated by those
who seek popular favor by pointing
TO easv remedies for obvious ills. Not
satisfied with the everswelling volume
of statute laws we are now urged to
tinker with the constitution.
EThere is much clamorous advocacy
of measures to limit the powers OF
those charged with the administration
Of our highly complicated government
and TO increase the direct intervention
of the public in the conduct of its
operations, It is sal that IN the
working Of representative government
representatives do not represent the
people.
People Win in the End.
Representatives being human al
wavs will, from time to time, fail in
their duties, but in the long run our
representative bodies must and do give
expression to precisely what the ma
tured thought of the majority of the
people demands.
GAS education continues to be wide
spread the people will continue to take
M active. intelligent interest in public
| affairs. But the business of governing
highly complex modern civilization
to be conducted with the best results
to the greatest number. will always
require the absolute devotion and en-
tire attention of an increasing number
of men The vision Of truth and jus.
tice has never wholly failed before the
| eyes Of the people Of the United States
In the period Of their greatest material
progress they pause to consider wheth'
er their institutions are securing JUS
tice between mnn and man.
Riches Cause Inquiry.
"The laws of state and nation alike
during this period Of great Industrial
| progress had been nodded to facilitate
the conduct of business on a colossal
scale. Here and there occasional peaks
of garnered riches rise high above the
plain and, like the robber barons Of the
Rhineland. great masters OF capital sit
onthroned upon them But their very
height lifted them up where all men
could see and begin to question how
they came there.
"Temporary abuses max be correct
| ed. but effective government cannot be
conducted through the spasdomic inter
vention Of popular uprsings.
"ln q country whose government is
based on manhood suffrage any abuse
can continue only until majority of
| the people are convinced that it is
| wrong. Then there is bound to be a
change.
eft is in putting clearly before the
| people the nature of civic ills and the
character and effect of proposed RENE.
dies that men who have had the benefit
| of systematic university training muy
best Justify their advantages.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1911-05-02
suFFRAG|ST STATES
CORRUPT, SHE SAYS
Miss Seawel, Southern Novelist,
Thinks They Are Worse Than
Other Commonwealths.
ARGUES AGAINST SYSTEM
Women Cannot Fight to Maintain
Vote and Shouldn Have It,
She Declares.
ARGUES AGAINST SYSTEM
Special to The Tribune.

Special to The Tribune.
NEW YORK, May Estates having
woman suffrage are the most corrupt in
the world" says Miss Molly Elliott Sea-
well. the southern novelist, on anti -suf-
fragist
Utah and Idaho have failed to put
a stop to polySamy. The five suffragist
states show an abnormal divorce rate.
"A wife's maintenance is her cquiva-
lent for vote. III she acquires Il vote
she must give up her right to mainte-
nance.
Already, Miss Seawell says. the women
in the four suffraSist states of Utah
Colorado, Idaho and Wyoming have been
deprived of enormous property privileges.
Women In the United States occupy
a far more favored condition than those
In any country in the world she de-
clares. But in no country IS woman
suffrage so utterly unWorkable as under
the American system OF government. The
cardinal principles OF woman suffrage are
In direct conflict with the cardinal prin-
cipIes OF the government of the United
States.
The first is the suffrage contention
that voting is moral right. The supreme
court of the United states has decided
that voting is rot a moral right. but a
privilege.
Second. women voters would newt
ably become privileged class. their ex-
cmption from military and naval duty
making them such. The first fundamcn-
tai of our present form of government is
that there shall be no privileged classes
among voters.
"rhe two basic reasons against woman
suffrage in the United States are
'First-No electorate has ever existed.
or ever exist, which cannot enforce
IFS own laws.
"Second-No voter has ever claimed,
or ever can claim. maintenance from an
other voter
Miss Seawell insists that the normal
voter must he physically able to make
n n.
II necessary. and he must be able-t To carry
out by force the effect Of his ballot.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1911-05-02
APPoRTIoNMENT OF MONEY.
Nearly sa5,ooo Distributed for a Variety
OF Worthy Purposes.
BY Associated Press.

BY Associated Press.
P1TTSBURG, May Thirty five
awards In recognition OF acts OF heroism
were made today at the spring meeting
OF the Carnegie hero fund commission
and the issuance of nine silver and
twenty-siX bronze medals was authorized.
In addition the money accompanying the
medals amounts to S34.100 and pensions
TO widows Of heroes total Sl310 annually.
or the large amount $1,000 is given to
George K. Muir of Grand Rapids. Wis.
who was awarded a bronze medal last
January, Muir is now suffering from tu-
berculosis at Wales. Wis, and the COM
mission makes the money award TO care
for him
The money is apportoned as follows.
$4,000 for worthy purposes; $4,000, liqui-
datlon Of mortgages, $4,000 for other in
debtedness; $4,000, purchases OF homes:
fits, and $1,000 for restoration of health.
In nine instances the heroes lost their
lives and the award Is made to a mem
Der of the family
Since the inception of the hero COM
mission 1891 cases have been refused
recognition, 4s7 have been granted and
Ss3 cases are still pending
Today's awards include;
rescue Donald G. Ball. aged 5, from run
away team al Bellingham. Wash. Sep
tember II, 1906 Sustained injuries. but
child escaped Bronze medal and $1,000
August Wesley aged 81 (ded) at
tempted TO save two men from suffoca-
ton In mine at Bingham Canyon, Utah
November 81 1908; Silver medal held
Hugh Burns, aged 22 (died). accom-
panied Wesley in entering mine. Silver
medal held for nearest Of kin when
found
Joseph Robesa. Jr.. aged 30 (dieD
Cherry, III, November Is. 1908, Silver
medal to father.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1911-05-02
Debate in the House Drifts
From Free List Bill to Ca
madam Reciprocity.
ISSUE IS RAISED BY
MADDEN OF ILLINOIS
Senate Also Discusses Pact
With the Dominion and Its
Probable Effect.

WASHINGTON. May 1.-~Speecles on
the farmers free list bill In the house
today again sounded the note OF Can
adian annexation, traversed the whole
range OF argument concerning Canadian
reciprocity already disposed of by the
house. and came hack at times to spec
ify upon or support OF the free list bill,
which has been pending for six days and
gives promise Of continuing for several
more
At times less than a score of members
were on the floor. Democratic Leader
Underwood at adjournment expressed
the hope that a vote may be reached
Thursday or Friday, but many members
wish TO speak and all desired time will
be given,
Mr.. Madden of Illinois, In an hour s
speech. touched the annexation Issue.
My hope is that II we can can have
ada" he said. "some day this relation
ship may blend the two peoples into
one harmonious whole; and that the ter
part of the United States, as 1t should
be. / have always believed we should
be one people. under one flag and under
one form OF government. and II will be
better for US when such thing happens.
If 1t ever does"
Mr., Gillette OF Massachusetts, and Mr..
Dyer of Missouri attacked the free list
because 1t put, jutee bagging upon the
making industry OF this country.
Democrats questioned Mr.. Gillette
sharply about the 'bagging trust but he
said II did not exist.
Mr.. Burleson of Texas demanded to
know If the whole bag making industry
was not controlled by three firms that
parceled out the quantity each should
make. Mr.. Gillette did not believe SO.
Mr.. Cox of Indiana supported the bill
and attacked opponents OF reciprocity.
Mr.. Longworth of Ohio assailed partic-
ularly the Democratic proposal to put
boots and shoes on the free list. He
said machinery upon which America S
advantage had rested is being installed
abroad and the United States can be
flooded with foreign shoes.
Mr.. Rucker of Colorado Oemocrat)
who voted against the reciprocity bill.
attacked that measure in O speech IA :
vorius the free list bill, He said he had
been criticised for not abiding by the
action of the Democratic caucus in favor
Of reciprocity. but explained that he op-
posed the measure because he believed
it unfair Ito the farmer"
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1911-05-02
Labor Leaders Declare There
Will Be No Attempt to De-
lay Dynamite Trials.
CLARENCE DARR0W SURE
TO BE CHIEF COUNSEL
McNamaras to- Be Tried Sep.
arately: No One Permitted
10 See McManigal.

Los ANGELES. May 1.-Unless it
be otherwise decided by Attorney Lee
Rappaport, counsel for the international
Bridge and Structural Iron Workers
association, there will be no mo-
tions for change of venue in the
dynamite conspiracy case, or any other
technical points TO delay the trials of
John and James Mcnamara.
The labor leaders interested in the
defense of the Mcnamara brothers were
so busy in connection with the strike
of carpenters. which began today, that
they gave little time to the affairs of
the alleged dynamiters. But Andrew
Gallagher, secretary of the labor coun-
ell of San Francisco, said that Kappa.
port would be given charge of the case
Immediately upon his arrival, and that
the Indianapolis attorney would remain
In charge until the arrival Of Clarence
Darrow.
Gallagher declared there was no un-
certainty about the coming of Darrow.
Darrow to Be Chief Counsel.
"He will be here, and he will be
chief counsel In the case he asserted,
although it had been previously stated
that Rappaport was coming partly TO
review the situation for the benefit of
Darrow and that the latter would de-
eide whether or not he would enter the
case, according to the report he re-"
ceived
Gallagher also said that while there
was no prospect Of a general strike In
this city. one might be declared at any
time, although such q movement on the
part of organized labor would have no
connection with the dynamiting case.
No one visited the McNamaras to-
day, and District Attorney Fredericks
said that no one would be permitted to
see McManlgal. who is alleged to have
testified in the trial of the McNamaras,
The Mcnamara brothers probably Will
be tried separately. There was some
discussion on this point today In the
district attorneys Office, but nothing
definite has been decided even on the
question of ARA gnment.
The district attorney, it is understood,
Judge Willis. who presides in the Grim
inal department of the superior court.
Judge Willis IS court room is in the Hall
of Justice, which is connected with the
county prison by "bridgc Of sigbs. -
If arraigned before Judge Willis, it
would not be necessary to take the men
out on a street rs would be the case If
they were arraigned before Bordwell.
in whose court the indictments were
returned
Will Let McManigal Alone.
Arrangements have been made for
Rappaport 70 interview the McNamaraS
tomorrow morning In view Of the dis.
trict attorneys declaration that no one
would be permitted to see McManigal.
no further effort will be made by rep
resentatives of the defense to talk to
him,
1t is possible. according to Gallagher,
that Samuel Gompers will como to Cal
ifornia in June. Gallagher said that he
is due here on an official visit, but the
certainty Of it depends upon the result
of the supreme court S action on cases
against him and others.
Replying to reports TINT the defense
Continued on Page Two.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1911-05-02
INDICTMENT OF GREAT
IMPORTANCE HANDED UP
Sensation About to Be Exploded in Case
of the Carnegie Trust
Company

NEW YORK May 1.-The grand jury
Investigating the failure of the Carnegie
TrlIs, company handed an indictment TO
Justice Davis In the criminal branch OF
the supreme court today.
The Indictment was marked n, A.
which means mo arrest
District Attorney Whitman, when
asked If II bench warrant would be Is
sued. said:
THE indictment is OF such great i'm
portancc that | have left everything In
connection with IT, 10 the discretion Of
Justice Davis"
II Is reported the Indictment is OF moro
consequence than any other so far found
by this grand jury. but the name OF the
accused man. II was said. would not be
revealed until an arrest is made,
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1911-05-02
CARTER OF MONTANA
TO DEFEND WHISPERS

WASHINGTON. May both Sides i'm
tomorrow nights congressional debate in
the National Press club on the question
whether ''Whiskers Are n Creator Detri-
ment to Man Than Il Bald Head" have
undergone changes, and the final lineup
Is.
NEUTRALITY-SUSPICIOUS. Taylor OF Tennes
see and Representative Longworth.
Ncgative--Former Senator Carter OF
Montana and Former Speaker Cannon
Mr.. Taylor replaces Mr.. James OF Ken =
lucky. detained by n speech making trip.
and Mr.. Carter supplants Senator Kern OF
Indiana. detained by illness In his Indl
ana home.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1911-05-02
MCPHERSON CLUB
ADDRESSED BY BRYAN
7p declares Outlook Was Never
Hri9hter for Success Of
Democratic Party.

AulNES. Ia. May I,-Declarins
outlook never was brighter for
~ OF the Democratic party and
tdrty had exceeded the widest
me enthusiasts in the election
=, mlulorltr In the lower house OF
Wliiam j. Bryan tonight de-
v optimistiC address 10 the mem :
<lie Iowa Jefferson club at its
anquet here.
'oeu Out that there was not only
n,aJorlty In the lower house of
put that II was united ma
'<'"ne Tor progressive Democratic
y Stated that the success Of the
~ IN Tie senate was greater than
iiu also declared that while The
IN the minority there, with the
~ progressive Republicans II
ms legislation.
ai also predicted great things
Lty In the campaign OF 1912.
en unde n short address this
10 the members OF the JEFF
RD at tho business meeting. go.
snere TO the Y. NJ. c. A. build
|-rgtone. ms -
psciion with this ceremony he
" otficials of the local building
,,.i 70 cancel tho engagement
-Sus n mat the structure WAS be
py non-union labor. This Mr.
~ ~ iett at 1910 o'clock tonight
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1911-05-02
CREDITORS ALLEGE
HIDING OF ASSETS

NEW YORK May 1.-An involuntary
petition in bankruptcy was filed this
afternoon against j. Il. Reichmann. for
mer president of the Carnegie Trust
company The creditors nllege that the
total liabilities are S2.000.000. with as
sets of 500. 900. Conceament OF prop
crty is alleged in the petition.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1911-05-02
ST CASES HANG FIRE.
Expected on 18th or 2eth OF
the Present Month.

|tNGTON. May 1.-The supreme
burned today until May 10 with
'uneing an opinion in either the
a oll or the Tobacco suits. On
4pinlons viii he announced and
VIII then adjourn until May
I.nal day OF the present term.
~ decisions" are expected on
'1ese days.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1911-05-02

Continued on Page Two.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1911-05-02

THERE is always more busi-
ness to be had for the ask.
ing. That s why the 9iver-
tiser gets the busineSa.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1911-05-02

"a is the most energetic
orksr you can employ.
The silver messenger., 1911-09-12
TALK ON PERPETUAL MOTION
for Critical Opinions on lts
Practicabiiity.

1t Is easy to say that perpetual mo
tion is impossible, but not always SO
easy to tell why. A correspondent Of
Power describes 4 scheme OF his own
devising and asks for critical opinions
upon 1t, telling why 1t will not work"
He says:
In the sketch shown two grooved
pulleys are attached to the standard
and carry the rubber tube. at equal
points on which are attached cylinders
which contain heavy plungers; these
plungers slide in and out of the cylin-
ters as they pass the top and bottom
centers. the plungers being heavy
enough to slide out by their own
weight at the bottom against the pres
sure Of the water
The connections from the tube to
the cylinders allow the air to pass
freely from one OF the cylinders to
the other when the plungers are slid
The air In the tube Is supposed to be
at atmospheric pressure at all times,
and the tube to be stiff enough to
Withstand the water pressure without
collapsing.
AS shown in the sketch, the three
cylinders on the left-hand side which
are going up are open, while the three
on the opposite side which are going
down are closed. The other two are
passing the centers, and as all Of the
cylinders are OF the same weight, It
will be seen that as there are always
an equal number on each side the
weight Is practically balanced at all
times, and during portion Of the
time there will be four on one side
open. and like number on the other
side closed; the plunger OF the cylin-
der that Is passing the top center will
close about when 1t has reached the
The silver messenger., 1911-09-12
l@ @NOTESO OF M|
science 3.
INVENTION

Most spiders have eight eyes. a few
species having but six.
Mans kinship with the ape has been
proved by the blood test.
Gout and rheumatism are said to
yield to radlum treatment.
A man generally reaches his heav-
lest weight at forty years.
Nine millions per year are spent
on the maintenance of roads In Eng
land
In six out OF the last 10 years the
deaths In France have exceeded the
births.
The children of Japan are taught
to make use of both hands indiscrim-
inately.
A French economist writes to a
Paris journal that America has no
real money.
or all the publications in the world
6S out of 100 are printed in the Eng.
lish language.
The value OF phonograph records
sent abroad during 1910 was s2.700-
$50, more than double that of ths
previous year.
The working bee lives six months
the drone four months and the oueen
bee four years.
1t Is estimated that every square
mile of the oceans Is inhabited by 12O
100000 living creatures.
The tallest and the shortest people
Of Europe. the Norwegians and tn
Lapps, live side by side.
A German invention has succeeds
In making an excellent substitute fol
whalebone. It Is composed of leather
A stifr spring has been invented b,
woman to replace the familiar cur
tain rod, with the advantage that i
adjusts itself to any width window
| frame.
The silver messenger., 1911-09-12
WRITE TO DEFY AGE
Missouri Song Author Gives
verse-Making as Recipe.
Mrs. Hull Was Born In missouri
sixty-Nine Years Ago-she Enjoys
Composing Verses for Her
Own Amusement.

st. Louis Mo.-Ponce De Leon dld
unwisely when he went floundering
through the swamps OF Florida IN
quest of the fountain of life. in which
be hoped to renew his youth. 10
achieve enduring youth, freshness OF
mind in old age and serenity OF tenn
GER. he should have stayed in Spain
and written poetry.
Verse-makipg as an antidote to olo
age is recommended by Mrs. Lizzie
Chambers Hull of st. Louis. Who, 69
years young, defeated all competitors
In Governor Hadley's contest for the
words of Missouri state song. Her
stanzas, because of their clear SIM
plicity, historical sincerity and quiet
depth Of feeling, obtained a prize OF
$500 by unanimous accord OF the
Judges Contestants entered not only
from every section OF the United
States, but from Canada, Australia
and New Zealand
When Mrs. Hull was - years old,
Henry Wadsworth Longfellow lee
tured before her class on "Poesie."
She was pupil at Louis Agassiz's
School for Young Women at Cam
bridge, Mass, out OF which grew Rad
cliffe college. oliver Wendell Holmes
and Wendell Phillips were also lectur-
ers at the seminary, and among the
Missouri girls school companions
were Longfellow's daughters. a
daughter of Doctor Holmes aid Miss
Emerson, a relative of Ralph Waldo
Emerson.
In this environment, she fell into
the habit of writing verses. not as
profession, but as a diversion and
recreation. Just as another girl.
when wearied or lonely, would solace
herself by playing the piano, or sing
Ing, or reading book. so Miss Cham
bers. as she then was, found comfort
and society In putting her emotions
and ideas into metrical form. She
soon acquired the same facility In
rhythmical composition which one BY
practice obtains In performing the