New-York tribune., 1911-11-26
THE DAY WITH THE JUDGES
Many Surprises in the Awarding
of Championships.

PEELED to meet the imperial Nala in .he class
which called for champions over 15.2 hands
that they mad 20 concede defeat.
Judge Moores entries had 10 their credit
twenty-three first prizes, four champion
ships. five seconds and four reserves. be-
sides a number of yellow ribbons which
were given in classes where Judge Moore
had several entries. With these ribbons
went a sum total OF more than $500 be-
sides innumerable silver trophies.
J. W. Harriman's horses had TO their
credit a half dozen frsts, three seconds.
two championships and one reserve. Lady
Dilham won in the championship exhibition
OF harness horses not exceeding Is hands,
but when she was shown 10 pole with her
little brother, Elegant DIlham. she had TO
abdicate in favor Of Phyllis and Menella.
Z. r. Stotesburys roadsters had an un-
precedented success. They added to their
string a half dozen blues. three reds. two
championships and reserve. Charles Bum
and the Belton Farms divided the honors
in the pony classes, each having eight blues
and a number Of reds and yellows
Mr.. and Mrs. W A. McGibbon's saddle
horses headed the list. with seven blues,
three reds and a championship. As soon
as Rosare came out of the ring with her
championship ribbon, James Mclean offered
Mr. McGibbon a good round sum for the
little novice mare, and she went TO join his
string.
The championships in the light and heavy
weight saddle classes were decided just
after the recess yesterday afternoon. and
there was surprise in store for the habit
ues In each class. Among the heavy
weights Mrs. II. L. Pierce's big 1G-hand
Panama with Godfrey Preece up. was
chosen 20 wear the badge of the champion
and he put in second place the popular
Avoca. who won similar class at Lons
Branch. Avoca is owned by Georg Gus
tav Rohlig but was ably handled by George
Won KarIouski. Among the collection OF
champions We're Kildare. DR. Hickey sun
burst and Premier
Even more of a surprise vas the de-
cision in the light weight division. which
brought out Rosalie from the stable Of w.
A. McGibbon; Indian Flower. Rosabel, Con-
Gdante. Mobile and Queenlght RosabeL
who is the property of Mrs McGibbon, has
been the favorite. although she was un-
crowned on Friday by Confidante. II was
believed however, that the judges would
follow up their Judgment, which had placed
the passe Indian Flower ahead Of all prom
ising asprants in tbe entire week. To the
delight Of every ode who can appreciate
real merit IN the final elimination Rosalie
was selected to wear the champion rib
bon, and Indian Flower was picked for the
reserve. Three we'll known horsemen. who
are really from Missouri, and whose names
are a syuonyme for good Judgment in the
equine world. remarked that the Judges
had still been extremely lenient with the
deposed Indian Flower, who, no doubt, had
d good disposition. RosaHe, the winner, /
is a real novice who until five weeks ago
had never had a saddle on her back She
is a distinct thoroughbred type and Mr.
NIcGibbon very wisely has allowed her TO
keep intact the wonderful tail with which
nature has endowed her.
The awards follow:
Glass SIS pairs Of shetland ponies. not eS-
ceed!ng 46 inches. four years or over first prize
$50. second prize, $40 third prize S2Ol-First /
Charles T.. Bunns blk. e. Grandee and hancette; I
and ro. m Locust; third, Miss Grace T. Watts !
br. ms. Frolic and Dame Fortune, fourth, How |
ard s. Starretts blk. S. AgunaldO ana Beauty.
class ll2 ponies under saddle, T. hands and
not exceeding 131 hands: first prize, $50, secona
prize, $40. third prize, S2Ol-fHst Fayne Unit !
D.
smiths br. ~. Merry Lass. tnird' GuWaIq -, n |
Gerken's e.. Donsy; fourth; MISS Helen |
Gertrude Alexander's b. <. Peacock. H. 40 |
class l16 shetland ponies, not exceeding 40 |
inches 10 be shown under saodle. nIst PtI1e'
$50: second prize. $40 third prize S2Ol-flrst |
Mrs John Gerken's D. g Gar ssco,I, eilda tqi -
81 Bunn's CHI Gazellei third, Miss Helen
Starretts blk. m. Ester. , .., /
GLASS % shetland stations. 10 be shown Win |
three Of their get; first prize, $50. second prize
ST5. third prize. S35l-First. Miss Ahee l. |
Bunn's blk Prince Of Wales seGono risinors Ssa'T
rar77's Blk s. Elersle Of Elsinore; fourth' /
Howard staIrett's blk f. Agunaldo ..-- -
age IN TO carrying 200 pounds, 70 hounos, 70
bo iudred for their conformation. qual,y, lilaI
rot 70 be shown over the jumps hrst prlze'
800 second prize $50 third pri1e, s-yI-r g
Adam Becks br. z Hydro, ,St rie3isnant
o,',e a R4ard's br. g. Duke Of Ashley. -
class i34 hunters, not over se',I lis 80 -, % |
s-s nm IN carrying l6J pounds. 10 honn4s s,nn0 w.
sse, - Sbovyn over the jumps; first prize siVo |
ccrd rrize 500: third prize. S25l-FlIst Jul'dI
Morris's br. g. Megantic seToHq' I'srobart sacb-
at5ys b m. sylvia FOX; fourth Mrs. Thomas |
Hitchcock ?, p,o,s5s1iSsd hunters. that have been
-..1sTlv hunted in 1910 and 1911 Win SOM ,9T
-sSornized pack OF hounds ln cops',.-UrI ,,+ Is |
the AlII % @orT3ation - per cent: 20 be ridden
- snateurs)-First. Henry La.' LawIenCJ ~ E.1T,-
= Pinkun; second GITorG I,3ii cb 2 GioversviIIe
tIIrtb Major Joseph KhgouT .. y te,5s and
class % pairs Of ponies @ snoFv 20 500. sec
nov eAJeeuS S5o, third prize. S2Jl-F1rst, beIlCh
49, ~, -,,' br Is Masterkey ana Nas'e ''is Ston
ond, IRVING SiopeP. Jr: third. Iryington Farms
s. Irviugtor Jackdaw ana IIvins,cn e.
Tcrd. fourth, Mrs. George w Aeue' '
Tine I IS pairs Of harness horses over 10 t5o
and not exceeding l5.2 hahus' Rirst Will
o. II Moore's b. ms. LADY AGChlaHo "a a'1 -;onor
i. AN ii' second Mrs J. 5. Waishs d. ss' oi'o'
Bright asI si IrQnabout horses. not under 10 % ana
t Ieessdlng 1872 hands; horses 10 cD-t, -. - 500
not eA-t,,tr~euta so usr cent nfst PIlAe 49,
cent sPp1i,e''-S50 sPpIe 500 third prize. S25,-First 70
T,s~d NcLean's b. Z. enapshgyt, Cao~,e Wat
Walu lua,s 2 Little Prince, third' 6e9Ige wa
9atLas0 Florham Knight; fourth MIS-. D. 9 /
5yslshis br N. Honor Girl o.. .o-s.s oysr 142
Clsss tOU 20, Feeding 152 hands, up 70 carry
ta'. 800 ,,o-inds. manners TO count % Per Sei-i
side saddles 70 be used aFsI Pz deorg Gus
prize 81; 81 Nh ab q Avoca, ridden by Miss ellen
Rasmussen; second, MTs; y FFs,-,'s ~ pr.
S5,5e S4noll 81 1ridden BY Miss Mary Thompson. -os
class So collections OF Ihree .iSgIe bar1ess.
uol sc+ion the property OF one owner n.sIti
j1e 500: second prize, 500 thIFq PIlzes.
-flrsS' ~ ~ seaton and b. g. Robin Hood second. |
p s,,r1Dsr I praper's br. e. Baronet or m aatIre
"a Rillington Ninble third. Edward NJ
She Sa,9s % n 2 PRIDE Of Pride. b. &. Rife and B.
SnspsnSc II0 c,eayyweight champion saddle horses
Clas1 a.s1,v,.i+ion for the Champion cup'-FlFkt' |
Mr.. II. l. Pierce's ch Panama reserve
Seorr Gustav Rohlis's ch. 3. Avoca z,..-,,i,,
Cgss. iii (aisdle and light Teignt dlaH'Pioi Pc,
saddle horses prize eup,-First, Edn,srd TiIsp Nc
%Jb6or's blk m. Rnsalie. reserve Eu"a'u ~
r ssr's ch m Indian Flower 80 . - So. or
Sjsss So hsrness horses over 10 d ana 4oe -.
ossSing is hands rst ariIs' slOo; secT.r p.s
80 ,ti-d rr1ze s25)-First, Avondal9 am , -
Naia: second. William Il Hoorss . & osH-
easter. third, william II. Moores Q; lgii,orts
S so,,r+b ryni seelig's : b. Royal Nlctofla
Class i2e Candy hgIt.Ts 20 s9a De pTIonaStn.ss
ers, nrtzs 500. second prize. 500; third pTizs p'