Albuquerque evening herald. [volume] (Albuquerque, New Mexico) 1911-1914, 1911-05-15
Chief Justice White Reals De.
cision Whereby Government
Sustains Legality OF Anti
Trust Law.
REMEDY REMAINS
FOR CONSIDERATION
Document is Volumnous One
and States That Re.Crgan:.
zation of Big Concern Show
ed Restraint OF lrade.


o"' t'c"i"g u-r.ia \. q. L~ns~d " sr-,
Washington May ~ tt.c surr,int
court this afternoon rendered - de-
tlsi"h aftifming "a, decree u "a,
standard pil case. thereby giving
'"mpi't' victory tor tho government
Tho decision. which Wns very Nohl-
min"us was read hN Chi,f Justir,
Whit,
tr|riN - declared that by a r,of-
sanitation n Sew J,rs,A "a, stan
dard 'iI company gave primo ra,ir
evidence ut "a desIr, tu control ana
n' ne poll, the oil trade. ana tnat %
inrt1'r Investigation showed couclus-
N'N ,Hat there was presumption of
" combination in restraint of trade,
Thr ehi,f Justice said tn, onN
question ihat Remained tor CONSIDER
alton VAS an adequate remedy
At o'clock Justice Whit, began
4" deliver thc up.nion ~ ia. .uprrmc
court "a ia, suit over the di~spiution
"i the standard on organization.
II was 'hl,l lustic, Mhitc wno had
Ion, his v'icc To- tn. refusal ol the
court tu dissolve th, eu-cal,d sugat
trust WHOM H., famous knight case
Was before thu court a., also deli,
'led disscnting opininn when the
northern Socgrit,,s company uas di,-
solved bN th, court ~ heing Zoo ,iola-
ton OF the sherman aut-ttiist lass.
On thr knight case thc standard
oit company depended mrsciy tor
support ON IN, majority vpinion boz
tho northern ~ccurltic, case Tho gov
"tnmcpt hnd founded much 10 IL.
hope u wac c'id,ut that AttDru,,
',n,ral Wickoraha who had direct.
"d th" RoN,tumsut- natil. durIus 10,
lai'r stas's. was not drught.d when
tA' nlcf Justice began. bat hc main.
aiu,d som, hour. ot s.rccss
chief Justi,, White first wen, int.
uu extensive recital of en-, facts in
IN Dasr and theu n,id that "a, rour,
had lurisUctiou over Tho suli. S. hich
had bucn questioned Do, tho standard
pu yomrRn, thirt Justir, White
said from thr bruch that tn, puut,u-
uous ucro as divergent as th, ends
of the earth IT, spoG, oI a "iuueh
"i testimony and laW. Th. ont, puint
n which the two sides ,t.r, ia ac-
cord was that "a, ufst aud second
cttonT of tho sherman ueti-tTusi law
,,nu ,lled tb, ease.
The chirf iu>tic, said the .omt
seized ON THIS point as ba.i. nu
Nhich e. WORK out decision
TtkinI up thr Two sections. tho
chief Justice ucgin confederation nt
The nw promising To- crme later t.
o. application ia tin present ,A.,
~, frst tOuh up TN common law
which dealt with the problems rais,d
hN tlit sherman antl-trust law II.
lhrn anai4zri the case ana read thr
decision
The decree oi thr lower court is
modified n t few la.t,cuHr.. witch
the chiet justir, declared W,r, slight
JNsti'" Harlan ammo .iucou that %,
would render 70 dissenting opiniuu
tn omni"n holds that There need
not no au absolute cessation oi inter
plhir com iHert, iu petroleum aud it,
products bH such vast agencies as .,rc
embraced in thc standard pil com-
binauon. result which might arise
moon That portion uf Tho deere, vh hich
cnjoins the carr>ine np 81 Interstate
t'nln"rrc not unly bN the Now Jer-
sex corporation hut hN an suhsidiur,
companies under dissolution of the
combination through transfer of It's
""ck~ ~ accordance with the rcrrcr.
The court also ,,tcnds tn. Tim,
,r"in on" month to- siN months. IN
which the dissolution may tnkr.plar,
Fhr Wuil which called forth todn,
d"' isiun Wns instituted In 1905 lu the
niten states circuit ouurt for the
Eastern district - Missouri II was
brought ~ the nam" at tho tinted
states Thc immediate object was IL
dissolV, the standard pil Compans or
New Jersey.
From the very beginning the husi.
noss and the lcgnl worlds rrcognizrd
mat the sat pui the sherman anti
'rusi law "a tho most severe t.st To
Which II had been subjected The
law had hren uu the Statut, books
sine" isn0 ana has been tn basis nf
some Is suits passed upon bS the su-
prem" ruurt of the United states.
iNat TIE law wJN constitutional WAS
hcccptod as settled N these d.cisiops
nut. simplc az lh' words of the stat
ut" seemed, there Mas an absence OF
uhHniinltN IN resard TO iis .nierpr,tt-
ton Nitb that situation confronting
w" goNcrnm.nt and iu, defendants
IN" Aiii war howuu with the general
belief that thu entiro business world
wound irri IA" rti,gt uf The outcome
"i the siaaniic struggle
Tl'' government rlalmcd that two