New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1911-07-01

dispute marred the semi-fnal round
match in the first beaten eight between
Charles Rowe, Of Dunwoodie and H \.
steiner. q Inwood i seems that while
PLAYING the seventeenth hole, where Rowe
stood dormio Steiner's ball was accident
7llv kicked by his own caddie. In the
argument that ensued Rowe is quoted as
having said 10 Steiner, III give you the
hole any way" After that, Steiner claims
no played the hole carelessly and did not
Try 70 win il Assuming that he had won
the hole Steiner went on and won the
home hole, squaring the match. Extra
holes were then played and Steiner finally
won on the twenty-hrst green. 1t has
been claimed that when Steiners caddie
kicked the ball it cost the player a stroke
also that Steiner failed to win the hole
with that penalty imposed. The com
nnttee reserved its decision last night
A hard fought match resulted from The
meeting OF James ~. Foot, OF Apawamls,
ana Il o. AuLer, Of DunWoCOie in the
eeni-hnal round Of the second sixteen.
They unisned al square, Dotn getting
Il On the extra hole Foot won.
The summary follows.
Firs1 sixteen second rolndJ--N " SWORDS,
If. Oakland. beat r.. Il McAdoo. Ards-sy; 4 up
sna 70 pay, GaI3.aeI mn a ma - 1aT
E-dt = rIr~tHNL. -44>4rF v ~ ~--~ ~ 49,
". " Taylor Aros.-y peat g Z. ,Giiletl'
r. gsitustol beat r r N1ndy. Ardsley, ) 10
'. sen.-t ma, round-white bea, Swords W and
. 70 play. Taylor beat Mo.=an, uy ana D. 10
Beaten eight; 4rst sixteen Carst sognd)g s,,, s
xfds9 5-Tb bsa5 a -a4 4rsvis IS SArassy up ana
ssz So .,sas up aq9 52 pog; G sr5 2.
-....-..4. ...4 beaten calculation bga,
Mclaughlin. ~ and to play Rowe-steineE'
second sixteen second roan0-H Bole. Knoll
good beat Il L. Dovnej, ApaWamIs' Up j.
< ~ 4n4 : 70 play. g. II Bell. ., Andrews,
beat Z shaw Aresle! ~ aAd !. 80
I. NAcr Dun7ooiis tcat Robertson
5! sem "a ro5uEd@Boo bsst Bsl up ana 2
70 Pa e Gg os1 secSa5 sxte5n rs FOUND
psrE' > up and / 10 p.ag. NJ Pierson. Ards
3 70 play; Donald Carr New York Colt Club.
oeat c. n. Matt-e.sOn. Alus.ey, = UP az 20
paw ayosi + o g d5 Fl Fn'y Crawford beat Y" A
seTi-fnal 1ound-P.rson beat Relyea, up
and 10 pay, Carr beat Riley, ID 20 holesl.
Third sixteen second round,-M Brown,
New York University, beat :. Peace, Ardsle!t
up ana % play n Fs ~ :, Ardssy y-.t beat
roW, Poweton, beat rs. u. Helstoa. Ardsley 3
up and 70 play; q. 4. Pogson FOX Hills. beat
4. T. Mccain, Nassau. by default
Seminal rounc- Brown beat Fitch. 3 up and
Z 70 play; Treyarrow beat Pogson, up and q
70 play.
Matby Wykagyl. beat ". r. Egbert, Scottish
American, ] up; g " FairchId. Manhattan.
beat 4. Russell. Ardsey. by default. G Y
Morse Rutland. beat B. Catlin Fox His
no and ] % play, J T. Tcbu, tON Hls. beat
4 Andrews. FLUSHING / up.
seni-fna round-Fairchild beat Maltby. 1 up
20 holes. ToG.a beat Morse. / up.
Fourth sixteen second roundl-B. L. Feiton,
purwoode. beat J. : Speaker, Ardsey, 3 p
and 10 play. a Litchenheim Wykagyl beat
r 5 B!ele Ar5s.ey, ! up p " Tarletor. oak
lard. beat A. D, Lawrence. Dunwooaie by &C
falt. T. d. Iilt Ardsiey, beat " Gressick.
r.ottish-Anericar. W and 2 70 play.
Seminal roUnd-Li tchenhem beat Pelton.
ID and ! 20 play Tarlston beat Tilt. up and !
- play.
Hartwig New York Golf cub beat J. B. E.
rneu6orf, Apawau.is up and 3 70 play. Eugene
Taentine. WykagyL beat c. N Cohen, Holly
--ocd BY default. D. Dallam. Arcsley, beat @
D Flamien Enelewood, = mp and 10 play; T. N.
uodson Ardsley. beat C. a. SpoNord Apavamis'
semi-dnal round fourth sixteeny-Hartwig beat
valentine : up Hodson beat Dsllam NJ and I
t1Iiay-