davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The Pensacola journal. (Pensacola, Fla.) 1898-1985, 1911-12-28
CHRISTMAS cANTATA
a. TIE SAN CARLOS

There will be a beautiful Christmas
cantata tonight sung by the children
Of Christ church. at the San Carlos
hotel, the exercises to be in the con-
vention hall. Mr.. William Paekharn,
organist at Christ church, has been
training the young voices to a fine
point of perfection, and the pretty
holiday festival is sure to be an in
teresting and impressive one.
The Pensacola journal. (Pensacola, Fla.) 1898-1985, 1911-12-28
MISS SUE DlSHMAN
Is EXPECTED.

The many friends of Miss Sue Dish
man will be delighted to learn that
she is expected in the city on Satur-
day from Henderson, Kentucky, to be
the guest of Mrs. J. F. Taylor. She
is a Pensacola girl, having left for
Kentucky four years ago. Those who
knew her as a charming school girl
will be pleased to know that she has
developed into an equally charming
young lady.
The Pensacola journal. (Pensacola, Fla.) 1898-1985, 1911-12-28
PATTERSoN.M,coRn.

The following wedding cards are
out:
Mr.. and Mrs. John Howell Patter-
son request the honor Of your pres
ence at the marriage of their daughter
Jean Munnerlyn and Mr.. Guyte Pierce
McCord, on the evening OF Thursday,
the eleventh of January, nineteen hum
dred and twelve, at eight o'clock,
Presbyterian church, Muscogee. Fla -
Enclosed with the invitation is this
card:
AT home after the seventeenth of
January. Tallahassee, Fla"
Miss Julia Lee. of Pensacola, will
be one of Miss Patterson's brides
maids.
The Pensacola journal. (Pensacola, Fla.) 1898-1985, 1911-12-28

midst of the battle as he leaves the
disabled flagship Lawrence in the
foreground 10 TRANSFER his battieflag
to the EiagaTs. III the Fight N order
TO renew the fight. The yunG8l cut
strip three inches Wiz.e and thirty
inches long from TIE CO-nur near the
artists signature. Il Is believed that
the object OF the miscreaBt was mere
Iy revenge, as the piece of canvas cut
from the painting was dropped on the
The Pensacola journal. (Pensacola, Fla.) 1898-1985, 1911-12-28
Nh. NJ. L, ROCH
ENTERTAINED.

Ms. N. L. KOCH entertalned at q
hoIlay dinner yesterday in honor of
her granddaughter. Miss Elmire Bell.
VIII is spending Christmas week with
he family here. She is a student at
Benont college. Nashville, Tenn, and
ha many friends in the city who
al interested in her rapid progress
tire.
The Pensacola journal. (Pensacola, Fla.) 1898-1985, 1911-12-28

The Barracks and Pi1iiatheas Of the
First Methodist church will enjoy a
Christmas tree and program tonight
at the church at o'clock. The mem
bers and friends Of the church are
cordially invited to be present.
The Pensacola journal. (Pensacola, Fla.) 1898-1985, 1911-12-28
FOR PENSACOLA
GUESTS

Justice and Mrs. Frank A Monroe
entertained few friends informally
on Christmas evening in honor of
their son-in-l law and daughter, Mr.
and Mrs George Williams, of Pensa-
cola. Fla, and their sons, Messrs.
Adair Monroe. of Cleveland, Ohio. and
Winder Monroe, of Greenville. S. c.,
says a New Orleans exchange.
The Pensacola journal. (Pensacola, Fla.) 1898-1985, 1911-12-28

aid and Mrs. Van Buren,, all of Gou
verneur. New York. spent the past
week with Mr.. w. J. Mcdonald. They
are on their way to California. where
they will spend the winter.
The Pensacola journal. (Pensacola, Fla.) 1898-1985, 1911-12-28

sairs leading to the painting. The
picture was painted by order of con-
gress in 1855. It cost $4,000. A re-
ward of 800 has been offered for the
arrest Of the vandal. The suggestion
has been made that the canvas was
cut by some one who had been anger
ed by the debate CT the abrogation Of
the treaty with Russia or that it was
done by q discharged employee.
The Pensacola journal. (Pensacola, Fla.) 1898-1985, 1911-12-28
MR. AND MRS. HERVEY

Mr.. and Mrs. George H. Hervey
have returned from Mobile, where they
attended the family reunion at Hervey
Farm. They arrived in the city yes
terday on the afternoon train.
The Pensacola journal. (Pensacola, Fla.) 1898-1985, 1911-12-28
PoSTPoNES ITS
REGULAR MEETING.

The meeting OF the Shakespeare
club has been postponed until the
second week in January, when Mrs.
Morris Bear will entertain the MEM
bers. The hostess will lead the dis
The Pensacola journal. (Pensacola, Fla.) 1898-1985, 1911-12-28
GUESTS OF
Mr.. =. c. BRENT.

Mr.. and Mrs. r. s. Manley and
children, of New Orleans, spent
Christmas in Pensacola. They were
guests of Mrs. Manley's father, Mr..
F. C. Brent
The Pensacola journal. (Pensacola, Fla.) 1898-1985, 1911-12-28

Miss Miriam Burgoyne is spending
the holidays with friends and relatives
here.
The Pensacola journal. (Pensacola, Fla.) 1898-1985, 1911-12-28

cussion on the final scenes of CAS- You
Like It." When the study of this play
is completed Hamlet" will be taken
up.
The Pensacola journal. (Pensacola, Fla.) 1898-1985, 1911-12-28
MR.. AND MRS. LELAND j.
HENDERSON TO ARRIVE TO-DAY.

Mr.. and Mrs. Leland ]. Henderson
are expected to arrive today from
Apalachicola, to make their home
here. Mr.. Henderson is the newly
elected secretary of the Pensacola
Commercial Association.
The Pensacola journal. (Pensacola, Fla.) 1898-1985, 1911-12-28
PERSONAL MENTION

The Pastime Euchre club held a
pleasant meeting last night at the
home Of Mrs. Elizabeth Rady.
Mr.. o. G. Clement, Of the San Car
los hotel, has returned from Mont
gomery. where he spent Christmas
with his family.
Tho NTiScaS 20 Taona NToDon-
The Pensacola journal. (Pensacola, Fla.) 1898-1985, 1911-12-28

The Misses Kate ard Jeane Melon
The Cairo bulletin., 1911-09-02
MAKE FIGHT COMPLAINTS
New York Athletic Association To
Pass On Disorders of Wells
Brown Bout.

New York, Sept. Consideration
of the complaints concerning dis
orders on the streets surrounding
Madison Square Garden and alleged
6isQ ders inside the garden at the
Brown and Wells fight Wednesday
night, was taken IN at meeting OF
the New York State Athletic Com
mission this afternoon. Action was
postponed in order to give chance
for those interested in promoting
boxing to be heard.
Patrick M. Powers, representing
the club which managed this contest
volunteered to appear before the
commission tomorrow
frank S. O'Neil, a member of the
commission said that the commits
sion felt that the matter should not
be allowed to go unnoticed as some
of the objects of the commission ace
to see that the contests are held in
an orderly manner and to provide
for the comfort and safety of the
patrons by regulating the sale OF
tickets.
The Cairo bulletin., 1911-09-02
CARTER ATTACKS
. FOUR statesmen
Representative From Oklahoma Gre
ates Excitement When He Tries
To Punish Men, Whom he Says
Insulted Daughter.

Washington, Sept, 1,--Repre-
sentative Charles d. Carter of Okla
homa, created excitement in the
heart of the shopping center today
by assaulting four clerks, one of
whom he alleged insulted his eigh-
teen-year-old daughter, Miss Italy
Carter, who was with her father on
a shopping expedition.
Having dealt summarily with four
clerks Carter, who is seyen-sixteenths
indian sent his daughter home in an
automobile and proceeded to the
nearest police station to explain the
incident which led up to the trouble
He was not detained and regards the
incident closed unless the four sales.
men demand an investigation.
Uses Walking Stick.
Representative Carter struck the
first clerk with his fist and when
three OF the young mans companions
came to their friends aid, the Okla.
homa congressman brought his walk
ing stick into play and welded II
vigorously, he was master of tho
field
The Cairo bulletin., 1911-09-02
IN SECOND TORNADO
II. NJ. Smith Of Cairo Has More Elk.
pericnoe While sojoarning in
South Dakota.

H. NJ Smith of 70S Thirty-sixth
stgect lumber inspector for the e. IT..
Atwood Lumber Co., says he has
about concluded that he is not going
TO die by the tornado route. He re-
turned home yesterday from Antlers
South Dakota, where he spent the
rast three weeks with his relatives.
sunday two weeks ago he was in the
great tornado that created 50 much
havoc and destruction ia South Da~
kota, in which seven people were
killed outright and many injured.
He says the approach OF the storm
was seen in time for all the mem
bers of the household and the farm
hands to get into the cellar OF the
house There We're "a people con-
gregated there They had only been
in the cellar bht a few minutes when
the tornado struck the house level
ing Il to the fiIst floor and carrying
Off portions OF il a distance Of q
mile or more Not one of the occu-
pants of the cellar was harmed Mr.
Smith lost all Of his clothes, except
what he had ON One freak Of Tho
storm was the handling Of his suit
case, When the crash came
his suit case came tumbling into the
celler almost at his feet, but 1t hat
been emptied Of its contents
Mr.. Smith, it will be remembered
occupied the house in Cairo Oh
rwcnty-ffth street that was turned
upsidedown by the storm last year
Not an inmate at the time was harm
ed
The Cairo bulletin., 1911-09-02
ELEVATOR DROPS; 4 HURT
Lift in Masonic Temple, In Chicago
Falls From Eighteenth Floor. :.
to Basement.

Chicago, Sept. -Four men We're
injured two seriously when a passen-
ger elevator fell eighteen stories in
the Masonic Temple this afternoon.
The car was in charge of Jacob Sch
midi, the operator and his three
passengers when it descended from
the top Of the building. AT the
eighteenth floor the car became un-
manageable and plunged to the bot
tom of the shaft.
Schmidt and Jacob Dolski were
seriously injured.
DR.. Frederick A. Jefferson and
Alexander Scholmek were slightly
injured.
The Cairo bulletin., 1911-09-02
HARTMAN LINES
DEFY UNIlN|STS
Julius Kruttschnitt, Spokesman for
Railroads, Ends Conference by
Saying His Lines viii Not Reco3-
nize Brotherhood.

San Francisco, Calf. Sept H.
The Southern Pacific Railroad Co.
through Julius Kruttschnitt, vice
president and director Of mainte-
nance and operations Of the Harri-
man lines, absolutely rejected today
a demand for recognition OF the
Federation Of Shop Employees, COM
prising five unions and $500 men
A conference lasting three hours
and twenty minutes was terminated
by Kruttschnitt's final answer aud
following it the union representa-
lives went into session by themselves
to consider the strike vote, which
they may accept as binding or may
reject refusing to sanction a strike
Conference Is Held,
Those who conferred today fol
railroads were Julius Kruttschnitt
e. g. Calvin, yice-president and gen
eral manager of the Southern Pa
cific; W. r. Scott, assistant genera
manager, Fl. J SMALL r. Il. Clear!
! and f. G, Ahorn. for the unions ap
! peared J, W. Kline, internationa
! president of the Blacksmith's Union
and spokesman for his colleagues
NJ f Ryan, general president OF th'
brotherhood Of Railroad Carmen; J
A. Franklin, international preslden
Of the Boiler Makers Union; j. y
Rucklew, vice-presdent Of the In
ternational Association of Machin
lists, and J y. Crane. vice-presiden
of the local sheet metal workers
auion, who represented bis craft iy
the absence Of President Michael Q
sullivan of the international organ
ization
The Cairo bulletin., 1911-09-02
$685. REPORTS WRECK
Additional News of SeaDamage From
Coast Storm Received by
Wireless.

Washington, Sept. 1--Relayed IS.
o. S" messages which continue to
reach Revenue Cutter Headquarters
tell of the loss Of vessels in the gale
which swept the South Atlantic
coast on Sunday and Monday last
and the heroic work of ship which
went out to give assistance.
1t is believed final report will
show the toll OF the hurricane will
be greater at sea than at first sup
posed Any disabled or abandoned
vessels yet unaccounted for are be-
lieyed to be drifting north with the
gulf stream.
Revenue cutters are standing TO
sea all along the coast from Key
West to Norfolk to assist these,
The Cairo bulletin., 1911-09-02
Trial Of Alleged Wife Murderer May
Conclude Saturday When He Is
Placed on Stand-sessions to Be
Longer.
LAWYERS N ARGUMENT
Defense Wishes to Have Defendant
Rest Over Sunday Before Sub
hitting His Story-Another New
Witness Is Found.

Chesterfield Court House, Va, Sept.
/ Henry Clay Beattie, ,ir., indicted
for the murder OF his wife did not
take the stand today in his own be-
half as was expected. but the asser+
tioa was made just before court adj
1ourned that the defense would con-
clude its case tomorrow with the
prisoners testimony
An argument ensued between the
coansel for both sides as to whcther
the cross examination of the accused
also could be finished tomorrow and
1t was obvious that the defense
wished to have the prisoner rest over
Sunday before the attack upon him
by the prosecution could be begun.
Sessions to Be Longer,
Judge watson announced that he
would hold court later than usual
tomorrow evening if necessary to fin
ish the case, but an agreement was
reached to suspend Judgment or
holding the night session until the
testimony OF the accused had been
presented,
Court will be delayed tomorrow
morning by reason OF taking depo-
sition from Mrs. M, Steiger, who is
i'll at her home near the scene of the
crime and who, it is claimed. saw the
alleged bearded highwayman p-owl-
ing around the day Of the murder
New Witness Found.
Except for the impromptu adrnis-
SION of Douglas Beattie, brother OF
the accused, that he would have de
stroyed evidence of the murder, the
most interesting development of the
day was the discovery of witness
by the defense. Joseph Casselberg
of Richmond, Va.
II was rumored tonight, however
that Casselberg may not be called
because of conflicting reports con-
cerning his probable testimony.
The Cairo bulletin., 1911-09-02
WOMAN ADJU0GED INSANE
Mrs. A. G. CoonS Of Des Moines, Ia,
Who Threatened Traction Mana
ger, Sent to Asylum.

1es Moines, Ia, Sept. lit was
decided today to take to the asylum
Clarinda, Mrs. A, G. Coons Of pes
Molnes, who, armed with a hat pin
is said to have threatened the life
Of j. r. Harrigan, manager of the
Des Moines City railway Wednos-
day.
She was found to be insane by the
Polk county commissioners of insan-
ity yesterday Mrs. Coons is said &c
have threatened to kill Mr.. Harrigar
because Of his attitude in the recent
street car strike.
The Cairo bulletin., 1911-09-02
PARSONS INVITES FOLK
Mayor Asks Ex-Governor Of Mis-
souri, to Attend Opening of
FernbaHk Dam.

Mayor George Parsons returned
last night from a business trip to
St Louis. While in that city he
net Ex-Goy Folk and gave him an
invitation to attend the opening of
the Fernbank Dam and the conven-
tion of the Ohio Valley Improve
ment Association next week
He replied that he might accept
the invitation and would notifyS the
secretary if he could attend Mayor
Parson, who has made excellent
reservations at one of the best hotels
in Cincinnati, assured him that he
would be well taken care Of, If he
decided to attend
The Cairo bulletin., 1911-09-02
Wins Shorthand Contest.

Buffalo, N. ", Sept 1.-The / COM
mittee in charge Of the speed con
test held here under the auspices OF
the National Shorthand Reporters
Association today awarded the short
hand writer cup to Nathan Behrin
with an average OF 96.S accuracy
Nathan Bottoms, the only contes-
tant to qualify got $50 for aecur-
acy Bottoms still holds the record
of 269 words a minute.
The Cairo bulletin., 1911-09-02
Will Tell Attitude.

Beverly, Mass, Sept. 1.--When
President Taft visits the National
Conservation Congress at Kansas
City, Mo, Sept. IS, it is probable he
will make clear the administration
future attitude on Alaskan affairs
1t is expected that in Kansas City
or possibly a few days before, the
president will meet Secretary Fish;
er, who now is in Alaska and is
counted on for first hand accurate re-
port of conditions in the nations
northern territory.
The Cairo bulletin., 1911-09-02
Wrecked Boat Floats.

Hancock, Mich.,- Sept. l.--Tht
steamship Moreland, the largest
boat ever sunk in the great lakes,
which was wrecked in Lake Superior
year ago, has been floated and towed
into this port. She is 600 feet in
length and cost 100000. The steam
ship WI De repaired and put bash,
into the service.
The Cairo bulletin., 1911-09-02
cENSORS SHOW MANAGER
Coroner's Jury Investigating Canons'
burg Fire Holds No One Criml-
nally Guilty

Canonsburg, Pa, Sept. IA eoro-
ner's jury which held an inquest to-
day into the panic during the NOV
ing picture show at the Canonsburg
opera house last Saturday night
when 26 persons were killed and
scores injured. tonight returned a
verdict censoring the manager of the
show and the state department of
factory inspection.
The jury was utable TO find any
person or persons guilty criminally.
The Cairo bulletin., 1911-09-02
Charles Selden Promoted.

Baltimore, Md, Sept, I 1--Charles
Selden superintendent Of telegraph
Of the Baltimore 4 Ohio railroad,
has been advanced to the position Of
general inspector of transportation.
He will continue in the discharge ot
the duties as superintendent OF tele-
graph Mr. Selden is widely known
in the telegraph fraternity Of this
country,
The Cairo bulletin., 1911-09-02
Student Dies Suddenly.

Kansas City, Mo-, Sept. LII. A.
Hoover, 60 years old, who came here
from Fredericktown, Mo-, recently
enrolled as a student OF local phar-
macy school, was found dead in his
room this afternoon. Heart disease
was the cause OF death
The Cairo bulletin., 1911-09-02
Want Wells in London.

New York, Sept. George Nc
Donald, manager Of Nat Wells,
champion English light weight, who
defeated Knockout Brown Wednes-
day night. announced he had re-
ceived by cable an offer of $4,000
for a bout in London between either
Wells and Mcfarland or Wells and
Wolgast. .s
The Cairo bulletin., 1911-09-02
Jobn B Bosrn Dies.

Springfield. ILL.,, Sept. i.--Major
John b. Bacon, chief clerk of the
state treasury. offciated here today
He was aide dc camp to Gen. John
r. Morgan Of Alabama during the
civil war.
The Cairo bulletin., 1911-09-02

San Francisco, Sep. ! Five in
ternational presidents Of railway
unions are here to confer Sept !
with julius Kruttschnitt, vice-presi-
dent of the Hartman lines, regard
ing the demands made by the unions
under threat of strike on the entire
Hartman system.
The presidents are j. A. Franklin
of the boiler makers, M. T Ryan OF
the carmen, j w Kline of the black
smiths, NJ O'Sullivan of the sheet
metal workers and j. L. d. Bucka-
low Of tfe machinists.
The men Insist that Kruttschnitt
recognize their five unions as fed
Grated body in the conference.
The demands viii be the same as
those already granted by the big
eastern roads.
The Cairo bulletin., 1911-09-02
Dryden's Wise Words.

iii habits gather by unseen degrees.
as brooks make rivers. rivers run 70
eas.--Dryden. 4
The Cairo bulletin., 1911-09-02
Wife, Son and DAUGHTER See ). r.
Frisbie Hurled to Death At Nor
ton, Kan, when His Machine Be-
comes Unnanageatle.
LIVES FOR AN HOUR
With Crowd Hooting and Cheering
He Asocnds in Disabled Curtis BIZ
plane After Escaping Serious In
jury in 4o-foot Drop.

Norton, Kan, Sept, ii. f. Fris-
bic, q Curtis aviator, was killed by
fall at the Norton County fair.
Frisbie met with an accident yester-
day and only went into the air
again today when driven to Do 50 BY
the taunts and cheers of the crowds
Ffisbie fell about 100 feet and the
engine of his machine upon him
crushing his left side and chest. He
fingered for about an hour before he
died
trisbio has been giving exhibit
tions here for several days Yester-
day his machine acted badly and he
had fall of about forty feet, but be-
yond bruises he was not injured
He Feared Danger.
He was skeptical about the ability
OF his machine to stand another
fight today and announced he would
not take the air this afternoon, but
when his statement was communi-
Gated to the crowd there was an
angry demonstration.
The spectators hooted and shouted
"fakir" and refused to listen to eX-
plantations.
Fribies announced that rather
than have the crowd go away with
the impression that he was not will
ling to do his best, he would at
tempt the flight,
He ascendtd without difficGity,
and obtained height of 100 feet but
in attempting to make turn the
machine tipped and Frisbie lost
control.
Machine Strikes Barn,
AS he came crashing to the earth
the spectators could see the aviator
trying to right his machine, but as it
approached the ground one of the
wings crashed into barn and the
bi-plane, glancing off, struck the
earth with t'risbie underneath.
Physicians hurried to the aviator's s
assistance expressed the opinion at
once that his injuries were fatal.
Fribie's wife, son and daughter
We're witnesses of the accident. Mrs.
F'risbie Is nrostrated. Tonight she
bitterly denounced the action OF the
spectators in forcing her husband to
make flight with disabled ma
chine,
The Cairo bulletin., 1911-09-02
.SOPV|TH WINS
|. BIG FLIGHT PRIZE
Plum of $1,500 Awarded Him for
Ride of Thirty three Miles in
QuicAest Time-Julges Disquali-
fy White.

Boston, Mass, Sept 1.-THE plum
of the third day of the Harvard
Boston aero meet, the $1,500 prize
for the thrty-three mile flight tc
Boston Light from the Squantam
Field went to Tom Sopwith, who
broke the record of "a minutes, Is
seconds set last year by flying in 81
minutes and 33 seconds
Claude Graham White was consid-
cred to be winning but was dis
qualied. Earl Oyington, who came
in second in 35 minutes and 30 sec
onds was the only other man to
finish and took the second prize OF
$3.50,
Beachie Furnished Thrills,
Lincoln Beachie today furnished
the most thrills. After taking first
money for rising to two thousand
feet in 5 minutes and Is seconds, he
volplaned head foremost 1890 feet
sopwith took second in the altitude
tests,
First place in the quick startin
contest also went to Sopwith.
The Cairo bulletin., 1911-09-02

Il 10 SO Easy.
Most people who begin at the. bot
ON stay there.
The Lake County times. [volume] (Hammond, Ind.) 1906-1933, 1911-08-07
WAYS AND MEANS
FOR HOSPITAL
Friends of Institution That
Deserves Help Are Ask
ed to Attend.

Tonight the friends of Mercy hospital
will meet at the Gary Commercial club,
where pursuant to the call of Acting
President H. F. MacCracken of-the club
ways and means will be devised to raise
the $4,000 necessary to keep the hos
rital in Gary.
1t is expected that the meeting will
be well attended as the friends of the
hospital embraces every class, race ard
creed in the city. w. II. f. Parry, the
brick man. last week started the ball
rolling by offering to subscribe 800 if
4 certain number of business men did
likewise.
In addition to whatever efforts the
public will make through various
church., benevolent and fraternal So
cieties the Gary Commercial club will
also have an active hand in the money
raising. The following is the CONNER
cial clu- committee on hospital funds
President H. S. Norton. Vice Pres.-
dent II. +. MacCracken, Secretary A. d
Schaeffer. John A Brennan. A. S. Hess
Mayor T E. Knots, John A. Gross. gen
oral manager American Sheet and Tir
Plate mills. William P. Gleason, gen
eral superintendent Illinois stee
works, George NJ. Hunter, general man
ager American Bridge company plant
and Alderman w. S. r-euer.
The Lake County times. [volume] (Hammond, Ind.) 1906-1933, 1911-08-07
ERSKINS IN
AUTO ACCIDENT
CONTINUED from Page IL

their is very high shrubbery and 1t is
almost impossible to see what is COM
ing down the road.
Just as Muller reached the boulevard.
the Schlosscr Bros. Co. wagon from
South Chicago was coming down the
thoroughfare Muller dashed across in
front of the wagon to get on the righs
of the road. Behind the wagon came
Albert De Wolf Erskine of the Harbor
cago i'm his big $500 touring car. In
the machine with him was Mr.. Olsen
also of the Harbor Building Co. of In.
diana Harbor.
Erskine coming up behind the wagon.
attempted to get past. so he swung oat
just in time to collide with Muller's
Brush runabout. Erskine's machins
was fairly wedged between the
Sch1osser wagon, and Muller's machine.
with the result that the axle was bent
way out of shape and otherwise dam
aged to such an extent that it was not
until O'Clock before the machine was
fixed so that they could proceed On their
journey to Chicago and it was then
only fixed temporarily. The wagon was
given a good bump, but being very
heavy it was not damaged The worst
of all was the Muller machine. which
was completely put out of business.
The wheels were taken right off and
how Muller escaped being injured is
surely a miracle.
According to Constable Muller no one
was at fault and the men have made a