Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1911-02-13


ties of the National Capital
Ii Is a question of considerable DOUBT
whether Mr.. Olcott's effort Will be
crowned with success.
Republicans Who Voted No.
Following is list OF those republi-
cans who today registered themselves
against considering the Mccall bill.
Austin OF Tennessee. Barnard of lnd1-
ana, Rartholdt of Missouri. Bennett OF
New York, Bradley of New York, Burke
of South Dakota, Burleish OF Maine
Caldcrhead and Campbell OF kansas
Capron of Rhode Island. Carey OF WIS
consn. Chapman of Illinois. Cole or ONO
Creager of oklahoma. Currier of New
Hampshire, Dalzell of Pennsylvania.
Dawson Of Wisconsin, DAVIS OF
Minnesota. Dawson of Iowa,
Dodds OF Michigan, Durey and Dwight
Of New York Ellis of Oregon, Elvins OF
Missouri. EngIebright of California, Essen
IF Wisconsin. Bassett of New York. Focht
II Pennsylvania. Fordney of Michigan
Foster of Vermont. Fuller OF LIMOS.
Gaines of West Virginia. Gardner OF
Massachusetts. Gardner of New Jersey
,ioehel of Ohio, Good of Iowa. Graham
of PENNSYLVANIA, Grant of North Caro-
lima, Griest of Pennsylvania. GUERNSEY OF
Maine Hanna of North Dakota. Hawiey
of Iowa. Hayes of California, ho'lns
worth OF Ohio. Howell of ltal'
rey of Washington. Johnson of ONO
Keifer of Ohio. Kendall of Iowa. Ken
nedv of Iowa, Kennedy OF ohio, klnkaid
of Nebraska. Knapp of New YORK Nopp
OF Wisconsin. Kronmiller Of Maryland,
1afean of Pennsylvania, Langham OF
Pennsylvania. Langley of kentucny. Lind
Bergh of Minnesota, Lowden of Illinois,
Lundin of Illinois, Mcclure of Oklahoma.
Mclaughlin of California, McLaushiin OF
Michigan, Malby of New York. Martin OF
IN..lya HoS of TannaSSnp Ill.
Ter of Minnesota, Mondell of Wyoming,
Moore of Pennsy lvania. Morgan of Mis-
souri,, Morgan of Oklahoma. Monkey OF
Illinois, Murphy of Missouri, Olcott OF
New York. fearre of Maryland, llckett
of Iowa. Plumley of Vermont, Pratt Of
Pennsylvania, Pray of Montana. Prince
OF Illinois. Rodenberg of Illinois. Scott of
Kansas, Simmons of New York, Slemp of
Virginia, Snapp of Illinois, Southwick OF
New York, Stevenson of Minnesota.
Sterling of Illino S. Sulloway of New
Hampshire. Swasey of Maine, Thistiewood
of Illinois, Thomas of Ohio. Polstead of
Minnesota. Wanger of Pennsylvania,
Webb of North Carolina. Wiley OF New
Jersey. Woods of Iowa, woodward of Vir-
ginia and Young of New York.
Democrats in Negative.
: Although the democrtic caucus unani-
mously declared in favor of the reci-
procity agreement the following demo-
Gratis voted today against taxing up the
Mccall bill:
Aiken of North Carolina; Alexander of
Missouri. Moreland of Missouri, Car.in of
Virginia, Clark CT Florida, Dupre of
Louisiana. Garner of Texas. Gowdin OF
North Carolina, Goulden of New York.
Hammond of Indiana, rage of North
Carolina. Pou OF North Carolina. Pujo
Of Louisiana. Rothermal of Pennsylvania,
Ellerbe Of South Carolina, Espotinal Of
Louisiana.
The bill is first being considered as in
committee of the whole House on the
state of the Union. All bills affecting the
revenues are thus considered. Speaker
Cannon called Representative Mann of
Illinois to the chair to preside over the
committee during the consideration of the
measure.
by recognizing Mr.. Mccall and declaring
his motion to take up the reciprocity
bill a privileged matter had shown dis
position to help the cause along to a
vote. despite the sentiments against reci-
procity, which he expressed in a letter
to the Illinois legislature on Saturday.
Mr.. Hill Gets Floor.
Representative Hill of Connecticut. one
OF the republican members Of the com
mittee on ways and means. was recogniz-
ed for one hour in support of the reci-
procity agreement. He explained the
measure in great detail. When he began
TO speak the House was in much confu-
sion. MIR. Hill asked for close at .ention
Come over on this side.' suggested
representative Fitzgerald OF New
York. democrat. We'll listen to
you. and this is where you'll get your
votes" he added.
MIR. Hills opening argument in favor
OF the agreement followed pretty
closely the lines laid down in and the
facts set forth in the majority report
from the ways and means committee.
He was interrupted from time to time
for questions.
Asked If he was in favor of free trade
with Canada. Mr.. Hill said he favored
unrestricted trade with every country
where the cost of production did not diff
Ter from that in the United States
Mr. Hill declared that talk of injury to
various interests in the United States as
q result of reciprocity was based on
apprehension and not on facts.