The Guthrie daily leader. [volume] (Guthrie, Okla.) 1893-1996, 1911-01-11
OPENING or COACHES
THE ISSUE INVOLVED
Lack Of Evidence Showing
Necessity for Commissions
Order, Court Says

In setting aside the ruling OF the
corporation commission requiring rail
read companies to have passenger
cars opened d, each end dming stops
at certain classes of stations, the
supreme court in It's syllabus hand
ed Gown today, says
when the corporation commission
does not file with the record of ne
case q written statement OF the reas
ems upon which an order appealed
from is based, as required by Sec
tion ~, Art 9, of the constitution
and such order is entirely unsupp0rr
ed by any evidence, Il mus be SET
aside
The opinion is by Associate Justice
Kane The commission issued Order
$50 few MONTHS ago ana the rail
roads secured a stay pending appeal
The order was designed TO require
opening Of coaches at each end at all
important stops. The commission
sent no evidence to the court to show
that such an order was necessary
while the roads put in statements
from many Witnesses that there was
no necessity for such an order and
that il would not materially aid the
travelling public The order is dead
Other decisions by Associate JUS
tice Kane are
Robt Burns, Receiver, VS.. D. Il
Toney-Stephens county; dismissed
Robt. Burns. receiver VS.. G. w
Yaught, Stephens county affirmed
J. n Leard VS. e r Askew, Choc-
taw county affirmed.
First National Bank Of Mill Greek
Us j. W. lands, Johnston county;
reversed and remanded.
MINI. Threshing Co. VS.. John Hum
phrey, Garfield county; affirmed
Daniel Goter VS.. C. e. Ulrich, coun
ty court Okmulgee; affirmed.
L. Stinchcomb VS.. j. H. Myers, Ok
lahoma county; affirmed.
state Life Insurance Co., VS.. II
Showing, Marshall county: reversed
and remanded. "A life insurance pol
icy is not forfeited for nonpayment
of the premium under the forfeiture
clause, where promissory note has
been accepted by the company fol
the same
First National Bank of Stonewal
VS. w. p. jeffrey. Pontotoc county
reversed and remanded
Thompson & Rose VS.. Tyler Love
county; affirmed.
First National Bank Of Anadarkc
V w II Masterson Caddo county
affirmed
American Express Co, VS.. State
National Bank. Oklahoma county; af
hrmed
w G. Blanchard VS.. c. G. Anderson
McClain county, affirmed.
st. Louis and San Francisco Ry co
vs. William Houston, Caddo county
affirmed
Jennie j. Scraper VS.. William Bogg
Okiuskee county; affirmed
First National Bank Of Claremnre
vs. G. NJ Keys. ct al, four cases
Craig county; dismissed.
BY Associate Justice Turner
!. e Walls and w T. Essex VS.
Emma l.. harrington, Oklahoma coun
ty; affirmed
Kansas CITY Southern Ry co, VS.
State; reversed
State, ex rel VS.. J. D. Armstrong
original proceeding of ancillary in
junction, dismissed
r. r. Bohannon VS. r = Wilson
1iilman county: dismissed
Comrs. OF Harper county VS. Comrs
.uf Woodward, Woods and Ellis, TO
division OF county assets: report o
special Master win Linn modified
land approved.
G. L. Ellis VS., O. G. Armstrong
Texas county: affirmed
J. r. Partridge vs.. w r. Dykins
Oklahoma county; affirmed.
Com National Bank vs. III w Lat
ham, Oklahoma county, affirmed
First National Bank Of Guymon
VS.. Levi Arnold, Texas county; al
trmed
c. A. McNabb VS.. J W Hunt, OK
lahoma county; reversed.
! Ben Brinsley VS.. VIM. Mafafiey
Tillman county: dismissed
g. A. Harrison VS.. ]. II. Osbcrn
pontotoc county; affirmed.
| BY Associate Justice Hays
j f. Crutchheld vs. j. S. Martin
Craig county; affirmed.
e. II. Westenhaver VS.. Pioneer Te
& Tel Co.; reversed.
Board of County Commissioners
Kingfisher county VS.. Guarantee Stat
/ bank and six other banks. from Kinl
fisher county court; dismissed
School District No. /. Pontoto
county Us. J. r. Van SAINT; dismissed
Frank f. Lamb VS.. s. F. Baker, Oh