The Detroit times., 1911-03-01
SENATE, BY VOTE d
46 TO 40. REFUs[<
T00UsTLOR|nEh|
Beveridgs Resolution Declaring Goa(
Of Illinois Nan Vacant Because q
Alleged Bribery in His Eleodeu ;
Il Defeated.
Vote Ii Taken This Afternoon q
4. Accordance With Truce That
Ended Filibuster.
THE ROLL CALI

TsnJ. no; Bankhsai Dem. xia'j. ns:
sssS 1dsho, Yes yss BeS1ns BaS s:D gss esse oss
ksS fkssSlsy sp no Ry bris:. 10; a.
Yes; y '' Brown oSi s5issSw sssS ss HspJ k;s y.!:
eRsD sSsaeisS S.s sRsP: Conn, sn,D no; nc Bur surkstf
HI. no; Burrows (Rep., Mich. y, MOI
Burton (Rep. chio). yes; Carter (Rep>
tRep. Wyo.). no: Clarke tDsm.. Ark
yes: Crane tRep., Mass9. no; crav1
f9sd fpsm eEEsp Es 8; D.G ,, yes; cnlbsy:er
NO; cummins iRep.. la Yes; curtls
lRep., Kas.). no; Davis lDem.. Axk q
yes; yssn De8psw Esp, NJ -; no; plsk
vtS. no; Dixon ekep. aj" Mont.5. no: d.
Fla ), no: Flint tRsp.. calf. no: Zoe.
Tsnn5. s% absent: M Frye ns tRsp. p..'ss asins5 se
Galnnser Rep. N. II. }. mo-. dsmblu
SRep. 8 Do. -; Gore (Dem-. okla),
genheim (Rep, ceio.}, no; Hale tRsp~
Johnston tDem, Aia.). no; Jones (Rep.
EaFaii:;,ts Masai2; yes; ;Rse Kean w wSEsp, ~ = no;
-; Mccum6sr sRsp. N b. no no: ~ Hsr.:
MI yes Nsisony Ns yea sEep M1Hig %iggn ps en-
Newlands tDem.. New. yea: Nixo6
(Rep, New, no; Oliver REP, Pal.
NO. overman (Dem., n. CO. Yes; Owen.
yes; Payntsr tDsm.. Ky5. no: Fsnres:
(Rep. Pa. no; Percy ODem., Aisa y.
yes; Perkins w tReps Calf, no; Pil:s
n ~, yes; Scott Okep,, W Val. no;
shiveiy Dem. Ind.). yes; simmoni
no; smith iRep.. Mich.1, yes: Smith
no; Stephenson aRepD' Wis., mo no. % sson:
utahJ,. yes; swanson lDem.. va.). YES:
Taliiaferro tDem. Fia), absent; fay-
Tor tDsm. TENN. yes; Thornton tDsn,,
wyo.). no; Watson Dem.. w. va. j. no.:
wstmore tRep. r, ~. NO; Young {Rsp.
NOT VOTING.
Adrich (Rsp.. r. ID, absent; Rrex~
Ter tDem.. Tenn.l. absent; Lorimer
1Rep.. Ilis.), refrained: Terrell tDen1.
ca. absent; Taliarerro tDem. Fla.).
! WASHINGTON. March by u
vote OF 46 to 40, the senate this after
noon refused to adopt the Beyeridge
resolution unseating Senator Lorimer.
OF Illinois. #
Throngs OF spectators crowded the
senate wing OF the capitol early today
and all the galleries were filed when
the senate convened. A. futile effort
! was made by Senator McCumber (Rep..
N. d. to limit speeches on the Lori
mer case to fifteen minutes each. He
said so many senators had not been
heard that an opportunity should be
Afforded them to speak.
Senator Owen (Dem., Okla) opened
for the opposition. He sharply criti-
cised him for not appearing before
the investigating committee He said
Lorimer had unquestionably been'
elected by bribery and corruption. He
had telegram from Gov. Deneen de-
nying all the allegations made By
Lorimer I'm connection with the elec-
ton OF Speaker Shurtleif and the or
ganization OF the Illinois legislature.
Il wish photograph Of these W,
cant seats could be sent out to the
American people," said owen. Il am
not speaking now to the senate. T.
am speaking to the master Of the
senate"
Senator Simmons (Dem., N. CD. fol-
lowed In support Of the committee'n
report. He said Lorimer's speech was
remarkable and enduring.
With Lorimer not voting, the four
absentees would have balanced each
other. II was announced on the noor
that Frazier and Terrell would have
voted AYE" II present. On behalf OF
Aldrich and Taliaferro II was said
about the capitol that they would
have voted "No" -.
Senator Smith rep, Mich.). said
he could not shut his eyes to the evi-
dence, showing overwhelmingly that
bribery, debauchery and corruption
were rampant In the Illinois legisla-
ture. He said he appreciated the
pathos OF Lorimer's personal appeal
and believed all that he said. Despite
his assurances, he believed the cleo
ton of Lorimer was accomplished BY
fraud.
Senator LaFollette was the last
speaker.
When the time for the vote arrived,
LaFollette was discussing the imp0s-
sibiiity of tracing brfbe money.
IL could not tell where the money
sent into wisconsin to defeat my elec-
tion came from except that l know
that some OF II came from Wall-st-"
As these words sounded through