davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1911-05-17

and no exceptions or limitations can he
added without placing in the act that
which has been omitted by congress.
Congress Should Act
H the act ought to read as con-
tended for by defendants. congress Is the
a process OF judicial legislation wholly
unjustfiahle. The public policy Of the
government ls to be found in its stat
utes, and when they have not directly
courts The conclusion which
We have drawn from the examination
above made into the question before MS
is that the antitrust act applies 10
railroads, and that 1t renders illegal all
agreements which are in restraint of
trade ~ commerce. as we have defined
that expression. and the question then
arises whether the agreement before us
is Of that nature
And they held that it was. But the
controversy did not end there. Two
west. as the joint traffic case, decided
There the question was whether a
certain traffic agreement in that case
was In violation OF the antitrust law
This court, with care and dciibera
tion. and also with a fun appreciation
OF their Importance, again considered
cislon majority of the court once
more arrived at the conclusion it had
first announced, and, accordingly 1t de-
HIGu tlS appIlSdlipu'
Make It Emphatic.
NOW for the third time. says the
court. back in 1891 the same argu-
mcnts are employed. and the court Is
again asked to Tccant its former opinion
and to decide the same question in di-
rect opposition to the conclusion arrived
at in the trans Missouri case In fact,
so close was the Lewiston of this court
when the matter was under advisement.
together with the views OF some Of the
judges in the lower courts. that we were
led to most careful scrutiny and ex-
animation of the arguments advanced by
both sides, And it was after such an
examination was made that the court
came to the conclusion it did,
1T is not now alleged that the court.
on the former occasion. overlooked any
argument for the respondents. or mis-
applied any controlling point. 1t is sim
arguments from the opposite view the
court arrived at an erroneous result
which, FOR reasons already stated, ought
to he reconsidered and reversed. As we
have twice already deliberately and earn =
estly considered the same arguments
upon your attention, IL would hardly be
expected that our opinion should now
change from that gracefully expressed
No New Views Pressed.
"If anyone will take the trouble TO run
through the briefs and arguments OF
these TWO cases, they Will be perfectly
satisfied that view is now pressed
upon the court. either in the opinion Of
the majority, or in the arguments of
counsel, that was not brought to the at
tcntion OF the court In the two cases.
one decided in 1896 and the other In
1898,
''That being the state OF the law, what
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1911-05-17
CHAMBERLAIN HYDE
PLEADS NOT GUILTY

NEW YORK MAY l6-Charles A.
HYDE. the city chamberlain today plead
ed not guilty TO an Indictment super
him and was given until Nav Is ITO to
change his plea.
The new indictment charges that Hyde
used the power of his office 10 induce
Joseph G. Robin. as principal shareholder
Of the Northern bank of New York, To
make loans TO the Carnegie Trust COM
pany and that the arrangement between
them was ito the benefit and advantage"
Of Hyde. thereby constituting bribery,
under the penal code.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1911-05-17
TWO IS DEATH TOLL
IN AUTO DISASTER
Mexicans Are Killed Outright ;
Chauffeur, Reported Dead,
Terribly Injured.
snecIal TO The Tribune.

10
MODENA. Nav l6.-Later reports
covering tho automobile joy ride AT Lund
on Sunday morning show that only two
fatalities resulted. Two Mexican lnborers
were killed outright and another, not pre-
vlousy reported has q broken arm and
shoulder.
Station Agent O'Donncll was taken Oft
the northbound train at Milford for med =
not survive the train ride TO Salt Lake
City, He was again placed on Salt
Lake bound train last night In pre-
carious condition. Ole Blomeren Of Salt
Lake. the chauffeur, reported killed suf-
fcrcd "A rupture OF the main artery in
his wight leg and portions OF his left leg
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1911-05-17
CONTEMPT CASE
IS NOT DROPPED
District of Columbia Supreme
Court Takes Action i'm
GOmpers Case.
LABOR LEADERS MUST
AGAIN FACE CHARGES
Opportunity to Reopen the
Case Is Quickly Taken
by Judge.

WASHINGTON, May 16-The SUI
on it's own initiative today instituted
proceedings for alleged contempt
against President Samuel Gompers, Vice
President John Mitchell and Secretary
Frank Morrison Of the American FEEDER
alton of Labor The sentences Of I'M
prisonment imposed on these men by the
court were yesterday revoked by the
supreme court of the United States
and the case remanded to the district
supreme court.
Mr.. Gompers, when told of the action
of the district court. said:
Not Running Away.
Justice Wright can go Just as far
as he likes. He will fnd we are not
running away-not even from him.
The supreme court of the United
States, IN setting aside the sentences
of Imprisonment, held that the case on
which the lower court had acted consti-
tuted r civil contempt against the Buck
Stove and Range company and that the
offenses were punishable only by fine
to be recovered by the wronged cor
poration.
Justice Lamar in handing down the
opinion, called attention TO the fact.
however. that if the lower court felt
aggrieved it could have brought Grim
iual contempt proceedings in the prem
ises and have inflicted a jail sentence.
The opinion, in conclusion. read:
"The Judgment of the court of ap'
peals and the supreme court of the
District of Columbia are revoked and
the case remanded with direction that
the contempt proceedings instituted by
the Buck Stove and Range company be
dismissed. but without prejudice TO the
power and right Of the supreme court
Of the District of Columbia to punish by
proper proceeding contempt, if any,
committed against If. -
Advantage Is Taken,
Tho lower court has been quick to
take advantage of the opportunity af'
forded 10 reopen the case. As the labor
dispute which brought the case into
court has been ended, it was presumed
thc matter would be allowed to drop.
Justice Wright of the district supreme
court who imposed the sentence on
Messrs. Gompcrs. Mitchell and Morri
son. IN instltuting the proceedings anew
today. appointed Joseph j. Darlington,
Daniel Davenport and James M. Beck,
counsel for the Buck Stove and Range
company, as & committee to inquire
" forthwith into the "question of
whether the labor leaders had violated
the court IS ordcr'' The committee was
instructed TO report to the court
whether in the opinion of the committee
the labor leaders were guilty of con
tempt in violating the injunction
against the publication Of the so called
boycott list in the American Fedora
zionist, the official organ of the labor
federation.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1911-05-17
Bryan Discusses Decision.

TORONTO, Ont. May l6.-Wiiam j.
Bryan. here on a lecture tour. said today
rcsar riding The Standard OIL decision.
This decision Is likely To make the
trust question more Of an issue than il
has been In recent years. While on the
iace OF ii the decision seems a victory for
the government. II virtually amends the
antitrust law by constituting IL TO pro-
hibit; not restraint of trade, but only
such restraint as the courts, after each
lengthy litigation, may decide to be un-
reasonabl ble,o
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1911-05-17

decree OF the cour; and that all the com
panics embraced in tho courts decree
viii carry on their business as usual un-
Ger the direction Of their own officers
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1911-05-17
CAR Is DYNAMITED
AND TWO ARE KILLED

OKLAHOMA CITY May ls-An inter
Urban car on A line three miles north
nest n Okla homa CITY is reported to
have been dvnanited tonight and two
cercnns wilicd ane several injured
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1911-05-17

John d. rockefeller would a.
if he should spend his entire
trying to Hrn-are better Ia
than Cham berlain s Collie. ChoIo
Diarrhaea Remedy for diarrhoe,
entery or bowel complaints. IT,
ply impossible, and so says eve
that has used it, Sold by all de,
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1911-05-17
May Be Deemed Menace.

THAT is the one case. While this
happens To be a case Of an overshadow-
Ing combination OF such vast wealth and
enormous power that il may fairly be
deemed a menace 10 The general business
interests OF the country; but this diff
ference ought not 10 induce us to depart
from a settled. wholesome rule which,
being faithfully observed will guard the
Integrity and secure the safety of the
nation and Of its institutions against the
attacks Of those who would undermine all
law and who would for the sake Of pres
ent advantages and ends be willing TO
undo tho work Of the fathers
why do | say undo the work of the
fathers? II there is any feature in our
governmental system that is esteemed
among the nations OF the earth it is
that provision Of the federal constitution
which divides the departments OF gov
ernment among three coordinate
brsnches-legislative, executive and ju-
dicial. and neither branch has the right
TO encroach upon the domain OF the
other.
Practically the decision today-I do
not mean the judgment. but parts OF the
opinion, are 10 the effect practically that
the. courts may. by mere judicial con-
struction. amend the constitution of the
United states or an act OF congress,
That. ii strikes me, is mischevous. and
that is part OF the opinion that j espe-
cially object to-
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1911-05-17
Asked to Change Rule.


words OF the statute. this contract or this
agreement is In restraint of Interstate
trade. 1t may be. but ii Is a lawful re-
Etraint OF trade, II Is n lawful re-
straint'
within the last hour at any rate de-
cision has been handed down for this
court today In which, In n case arising
under The safety appliance act, il was
said that such and such was the safety
appliance act, such and such was It's
meaning: that this court has declared
1t In a case decided four or FIVE years
ago. Now we said in reply to that:
" In view of these facts we are un-
wiling to regard the question as 10 the
meaning and scope of the safety appli-
ance act. so far as IL relates TO auto
matte couplers on trnnsmoving interstate
traffic, as open to further discussion, II
the court erred in the former case, It is
open for the parties TO apply, for such
an amendment Of the statute as congress
may, in lis discretion. deem proper. This
court ought not now disturb what has
been so widely accepted and acted upon
by the courts as having been decided in
mat case. contrary course would cause
Infinite uncertainty. If not mischief In
the administration OF the law In the fed
eral courts.
IT is quite true that what was said
in that case concerned only the lives and
the limbs or railroad employees and pas
sengers, However important the law
may be We VIII not consider the question
as 10 whether this former construction
Is right, because II we are wrong, 20 to
congress and get the legislation.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1911-05-17

Dance. Wandamcre, Friday.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1911-05-17

was To happen? What were these gen
temen TO do2 Why. there was nothing
ieil to them. This court having three
times heard this question argued and
reached conclusion. there was nothing
left for them but TO 90 10 congress and
get the Sherman act amended
The most alarming tendency OF this
day In my judgment. far as the safety
and integrity OF our institutions are con-
cerned. Is the tendency To judicial leSjs-
lation, so that. when men having vast
interests are concerned. and they cannot
get the law making power OF the coun-
try to pass the Legislation they desire. the
next thing they do Is TO raise the ques-
tlon in some case to get the court so To
construe the constitution or the statutes
as To mean what they want II To mean.
That has not been our practice.
The court. In the opinion in this case.
says this act OF congress means and
embraces only unreasonable restraint OF
trade-a FIAT contradiction to what this
court has said fifteen years ago that con-
gress did not intend
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1911-05-17

strengthen the antitrust law or 10 solve
problem that yesterdays decision
seems TO have made more veXatious than
ever.
The Washington herald., 1911-12-28
HASKIN ELECTED
PRESS CLUB HEAD
Two Hundred Votes Cast at
Annual POW-wOW.

Frederic J. Haskin was elected presi-
dent of the National Press Club at the
annual election. which took place yes
terday. The vote polled exceeded by
sixty-twO that of any previous election
in the history of the rganIzation. Two
hundred ballots were cast The polls
were open from 10 o'clock in the morn
ing until o'clock in the evening.
Other officers elected were: John T
Suter, vice president; Oswald F. Schuette
G. A. Lyon, jr.. treasurer:
II. c. Stevens. financial secretary and
Ira E. Bennett. Arthur J. Dodge, H. L.
Dunlap. and Jackson S. Elicit. members
Of the board of governors.
The vote was as follows: For president
MIR. Haskin. l16; Ernest G. Walker. So
For vice president-Mr. Sutev. 49,: Robert
II. Patchin. 43; z. q. Walker, .; Mr. Has
kin. 5; 3. r. Howard !: Z. E. Paine. l:
A O. Hayward. l. For seCretary-Mr.
1871; Ralph A. Graves, /; Earl
|: John f. Monk. |: John Callan
OLoughlin. l. For treasurer-Mr. Lyon,
1875; Mr.. Haskin. l; A. D. Marks, l. For
W. Steckman, !; A. c. johnson, l; John
T, Suter. l. For members of the board
IF governors-Mr Dodge, 149; Mr.. Ben
lett 121: Mr.. Dunlap. III: Mr.. Elliott, 80:
Leroy T. Vernon. -; Gus J. Karger, 5S:
\. d. Marks. 80: Earl Goodwin. 81: George
f. Miller. %: George W. Summers, rs;
F. A. Walker. %; Henry R. Jones, 13.
The judges were Henry f. Eland, chair
nan: Otto Praeger. Austin Cunningham,
A. \. Van BenschOten. and ]. B. Small
wood
The Washington herald., 1911-12-28
REAL ESTATE TRANSFERS.

Washington Highlands-Charles G. Taylor to John
G. Bunn. lot .. block 8. SO.
Seventh street southeast, between F. and streets
William g. johnson et al. trustees. to William
\. Simpson. south half lot RI square anS. 81 ,6Cn.
Twenty third and streets northwest Philip H
Christman 10 Samuel 6. Carroll. rHrt lots 3 and
81. square 90 So
Massachusetts, Avenue Heights-American Security
and T1st Company et al trustees. to Henry R.
Lemly lots Is and l.. square 1895. so. Same to
Amaryllis Gillett. lot !. square 1882. SO.
Tenth and II streets nCrtheast-Israel s. Miller ct
TX. 10 Simon Jacobson and Reuben Goldstein,
lots p and 33 square $50 So
CorcOran street northwest; between FOurt zenith and
Fifteenth streets-Ssmuel W. Townsend ct ux to
Theresa +. Wilson and Josephine T. Whitehead
cnc-third interest in lot IS. square 2os. sl3O.
Bcnhcim COUrt-Washiugton Loan and Trust Com
pany. trustee. 10 William Z. CoTen. Howard r.
Van Law. and Eugene A. Jones. trustees Of the
Aonzo .. Bliss properties. lots l6 and L. block
J. Washington Heights. S.
No. s4 A street southeast-Marvin A. Custis ct al.
TO Frank w. Vedder. lot 10. square 90. SO.
Massachusetts, Avenue Heights-AmeTican Security
and Trust Company et al. trustees. TO Clarence
II. Reizenstein lot :, square 1906
Dcbhins' Addition-SquarC ls, lot So; Alexander
Mitlsr and wife to William T. Morrison. SO.
Rosedale and ISherEOod-Blocx 10, lot 25; James II.
Murphy u Annie F. O'Brien. SO.
Potomac HeightS--Block 14i9 lots II and l3 Poto-
Heights Land Company to John T Couu-
GILL SO.
Takoms Park-Rlock s ior :; Sue F. Chapman to
Franklin W Chase $40.
Rhode Island Avenue Terrace-Block 1872 lot };
Mary A Harvey to Frank T. Freeman SO
Square lols-Lot q; Iva A. Heany to Leo D.
Miner SO
Kalorlms HeiThts-squsrr s. lot 30: Porter J. Nc
Square l2-Tot 10: Samuel !. Shoemaker ct al 10
Augusta Rics. $40
The Washington herald., 1911-12-28
ASK FOR AUTHORITY
TO WIDEN STREETS
Commissioners Devise Plan
for Cutting Red Tape.

The District Commissioners Yesterday
sent to Congress with their Endorsement
a draft of a bill authorizing them to
open. extend, and widen streets, avenues,
and highways in the District without the
enactment of separate legislation for each
improvement At present, in order to eX-
tend or widen a street, it is necessary to
have a bill enacted by Congress. This
plan causes great delay and inconven-
fences to persons living in the vicinity of
the proposed improvement
The bill provides that condemnation
proceedings to acquire the land neces-
sary for the proposed improvement shall
be instituted in the District Supreme
Court, and the entire amount found to
be due and awarded by the jury in any
such proceeding as damages for the land
condemned, plus the costs of the pro-
ceedings. shall be assessed by the jury
benefits. The bill further provides
that the amount awarded as damages for
the land condemned shall be paid en-
tirely from the revenues of the District
and shall be repaid to the District from
the assessments for benefits.
In a letter to Senator J. II. Gallinger.
chairman of the Senate District Commit
tee, accompanying the draft of the hill.
the Commissioners state that ii would he
their intention under the terms of the
bill to select such streets as in their
judgment the public interests require tn
he opened and to institute the necessary
condemnation proceedings. The Commits
sioners add that they believe the enact
mcnt of the bill would he in the public
interest. They say that all improvements
would he strictly in accordance with the
standard highway plan.
The Washington herald., 1911-12-28
SIONS.

The popularity Of Old Point Comfort
as resort is attested by the great num-
Der of Washingtonlans seeking a rest
and recreat ton during the Christmas
holidays. who are engaging accommOda-
tions at the famous Chamberlin Hotel
This charming resort is always enlivened
during tie winter months by the pres
ence of war vessels OF every description.
from the midget torpedo craft to the
modern Dreadnought. The handsome
modern steel steamers NOrthland and
Southland of the Norfolk and Washing
ton Line, leave Washington daily at ~
D. m, arriving at Fort Monroe COld
Point Comfort next morning about $50,
Norfolk, a m This line Is featuring
weekend trips. including stateroom and
hotel accommodations at Old Point Com
fort, at reduced rates. The city ticket
office. in the Bond Building. 720 Four
teenth street northwest, will furnish full
Information and literature. Phone Main
1870.
The Washington herald., 1911-12-28

purify the blood. And there's nothing
so humiliatinE as face that's ali
"bToken out" and spotted.
StUart's Calcium WATERS will clear
the most obstinate complexion. because
they go right into the blood and re-
move the cause Of the trouble The
blood IS Cleansed of all impurities and
foreign substances and these are
quickly eliminated from the system
You'll notice a wonderful change in
few days-yOu will hardly know your
self in week.
And Stuart's Calcium Waters are atr-
solutely harmless to any one Their
ingredients are Just what a physician
preSCribes in most cases of skin erup-
tiOns and poor blood. These waters
are put up in concentrated form.
which makes them act quickly and
thoroughly.
Begin taking Stuart's Calcium Wa
fers to-day and then look al yourself
in the mirror in a few days. and find
all those awful pimpIes. blackheads,
acne, botls, liver spots. RASH eczema
and that muddy complexion rapidly
disappearing and your face cleared
llk- the petal of a flower.
You can easily test StUart's Calcium
Waters for yourself. We will cheer
fully mail you a trial package free. if
You will just send us your name and
address. You can get the regular sized
package for so cents in any drug store
Write for the free package to F. A.
stuart Co, l75 Stuart Bldg Marshall.
Mich.
The Washington herald., 1911-12-28
ANACOSTlA.

The annual Christmas entertainment
of the Sunday school department OF the
Anacostia Methodist Episcopal Church
was held last evening in the edifice at
Fourteenth and L streets The church
was beautifully decorated with ever
green's and flowers and the building
was crowded. .TabIeauX. instrumental
and vocal selections and recitatiOns
furnished the entertainment. and each
child was presented with a box of can
dy. Arthur B. Suit, superintendent of
the Sunday school, was in charge Of the
arrangements. Rev. Samuel W. Graf
fin. pastor. gave a brief address.
Mr.. and Mrs. Frank G. Lindsay. Of
Mount View place. have visiting with
them Mr.. and Mrs. John Lindsay, OF
Lexington. Va.
The embroidery class of Anacostla
was entertained Yesterday afternoon at
the residence of Mrs Edmond Mallett.
Ga L street northwest, this city. Mrs.
Mallett is the Instructor of the class.
which meets on each Wednesday after
noon.
Anacostia Council No. 16. Junior Or
der OF United American Mechanics, has
chosen the following officers for the
next six months. James w Crawford
councillor: Lebanon Griffith. past cOun-
CilOr; Charles Smith, vice COunCilo~;
r. A. Estep. recording secretary: James
d. Simpson, assistant recording secre-
tary; James Z. Frye, financial seCre-
tarY; L. A. Parker. treasurer: Earl
Hutchinson. conductor; r. II. Norton,
warden; James r. Burch. inside SEN
tinel: George Robey. outside sentinel:
William ]. Mitchell. chaplain: l.
Jones. c. r. Brooks. and r. a. Sansbury.
trustees. The new officers will be in
stalled at A meeting to be held on Tues
day evening next in Masonic Hall
Much preparation has been made by
the Young Mems Club of St Teresa's
Church for the holiday dance to he
given by that club this evening in the
assembly hall of the parochial school in
V street.
The inmates OF the Christian and Ele-
nora Rupert Home for the Aged, in
Good Hope road. in Anacostia, were
given an entertainment and luncheon
yesterday afternoon by Mrs. Leopoldina
FaCius and Mrs Marie de Grain. of
members OF the Ladies Aid
Society. The entertainment consisted
of instrumental and vocal selections.
and was in charge of Mrs. Lulu Davis
Mr.. and Mrs. Charles A. Stevens. of
Chester street. have visiting them Mr.
and Mrs Stevens, of Pennsylvania, the
formers parents
The Washington herald., 1911-12-28
VEST POCKET ESSAYS
VERMONT Author rn of "Lt Good 0La Siua,t"

Vermont is one of our most popular
pocket edition States. 1t is one-half of a
philopena-New Hampshire being the
other-and is slightly smaller than Nye
County, Nevada, though considers ably
more prominent, socially
Vermont has the best foundation of
any State. 1t is solid marble and the
humble Vermont farmer could go out
back of his barn and blast the ingre-
dients for a royal palace out of his COW
lot If he had time. Agriculture in Yer
mont is conducted with dynamite, pick
axes and ChannelinG machines and the
farmer has to treat his farm as if il
were a parlor carpet in order to keep
from wearing all the soil off of it's beau
tiful stone subsurface. Vermont has some
of the thinnest skinned farms in the
world and some of the thickest skinned
politicians.
The population Of Vermont is about
5000 people, most Of whom We're born
there. The State is not annoyed by i'm
migration. On the other hand almost
every day the population of some Yer
mont town goes down to the train to
bid good-by to some citizen who is 60
ing West to buy farm large enough to
balance calf IN without sacrificing the
potato patch. Vermont has supplied the
ancestors for hundreds Of thousands of
Western people. and is regarded with
great affection everywhere west of New
York. TombstOnes and ancestors are, in
fact, its greatest exports. The soil of
Vermont. when properly cut and polished,
makes beautiful tumbstones, and the
Vermont boy. if caught young enough and
Transported to some Western State. be
comes 4 Congressman with scarcely any
effort.
Vermont is located on twenty-four
branch line railroads and Lake Cham
plain, and has skyline Composed Of the
Green Mountains, which beats New York