The Richmond Virginian. (Richmond, Va.) 1910-1920, 1911-11-09

| NEW YORK. .ov. ITO tina -
prise ofthe lawyers on both sldao 81
the case. Judges IAacombe. Noyss an9
Coke to-day announced that they hA0l
! finished consideration OF the Tohacc9
Trusts plan Of dis1ntergration ana
REORGANIZATION, az orGered by the 0os
preme Court Also to the surpfio4s
of the counsel for the government AMI
for the Independent tobacco Interests
that protested against accordance o.
| approval in written opinions that
varied only az to details. On all eo-3
sential points. they are In agreemenks
| The outcome OF the Circuit Courts
APPROVAL will be that the 6uprena0
Court at Washington will have to -
view the entire work OF the Cireut1
Court before It can be definitely known
strenuous and long drawn out EFFORT
to bust the trust" wi take r.
| That the Independents will plead
earnestly for a review OF the appoinfo0
| plan by the Supreme Court was made
| plain late this afternoon when their
counsel learned what had been done
by Judges Lacombe, Moves and Coke
Felix H. Levy, who is associated with
Louis D. Brandeis, Of Boston. ~ coun-s
sci for several large and powerful
groups Of Independents. said:
The disposition which the Circu1e
Court has made In the matter In uHsA
satisfactory, and shall advise the IN
terests I represent to take such stsp4|
as may be necessary to procure r.
view by the Supreme Court OF 10
United States. S
Reject Radical Terns.
In view OF the fact that the coux44
respected two or three OF the moeQj
radical notifications prescttb~1 ~
Attorney General Wickersham - ~
condition president to the approval 60
the plan by the Department ok Iun2s
tioe. It Ii generally believed that -
will take the initiative In the apps 4
to the Supreme Court. ]. G. McIeGS
holds. the special assistant attognG
general. who prepared tho guvea ~
pents case against the big comhtnnks
ton and prosecuted II through the -
preme Court. could not be induced eoSs
night to ray what the probable ae17SS|
tude Of the government will b. ~
u known. however. that from ~ tnS0E
cspuon Ar. McReynolds has 80
earnestly opposed to the plan.
Ira Morris. --ASident Of the In6ns
pendent Tobacco salesman's -
citation, which organisation 1o1n
other Independents tn oppoans tnfB
plan. said: -
The Circuit Courts Decision : -
tareiy unsatisfactory to the Indspea11|
Vs.S s~c0SNS SAS0kS8t0. W0 0DWOV0
VIII not bring about the condtt1o
which the Supreme Court ordee{ <
The new conditions which the Cnro a
Court directs to be crested w1l1 SGSS
% conditions Of real compstlt1on. ~
trust VIII continue IN control ok t1k2
tobacco trade Just a. eRectualfy -
tho governments suit had never -
brought. 'ss.S
Tnsts In Cooerol ysssisS
g. ~
troll will be moro binding ~ f. 81
fective than before, becaueo tho rs.ss7991i
conditions Will be under the lena15G
sanction OF the court. The cornrsS K
stockholders OF the Americas TohaS
company. whose actions In the Y
nave been controlled by the twnn1 s.
Itinue in full control Of the nsnsss5 IL
parts OF the combination ss;s$
Mr. Morris then gave axpreasson Ss;S|
the nrst time publicly to An ontn5 sss;S;S3
|coHcerning Attorney-General WIck1
shams course that In common ar1,x3s52
the men and interests that have Il
hoping Tor real dissolution 81 ~
tobacco trust General objection =
Deen expressed at the attitude ~ 17I
attorney general In this matter. :
saio. " u Fair to assume thak
Circuit Court was largely fnflraGSss
by HIS attitude In reaching go
clusion which II has reached. IT.
Moves IN his concurring opinion. ai1
am also influenced. II nat \ 1757i3
troiled. by the position taken ~
attorney general sSSS3 T.
While the Independents have 60
reason to feel keenly disappe1r
Wall Street. on the other hnal
no doubt very much pleased Z *
Mr.. Morris Attitn1A
$3.50