The Yale expositor., 1911-05-18
A CASE in EQUITY.
copyright. 1895. by J. B. Lippincott Col
VI.
BY FRANCIS LYNDE.

n RELUCTANT SAMARITAN.
Robert Protheroe was not the man to
let n good resolution warp in the cool
ing. He was self-made, in the sense
that he cwed his parents little beyond
the fact of eXistence; and the world,
after its wont with waits, human or
otherwise, had tempered him in salt
ish bath of adversely and sharpened
him upon the grindstone of experience.
Having made shift TO climb some in
considerable distance up the slippery
hill of knowledge by his own unaided
eXertions, he fell easily into the habit
of thinking himself more capable than
other men. The demonstration was
simple and conclusive. He had proved
his ability to wiring a measure of sue
cess out Of adverse circumstances where
others, with all the advantages of pre-
paratory training, had failed. He was
too kind-hearted to be cynical, but he
could not help making comparisons;
and they were usually unfavorabe to
those who inspired them.
In the short conversation on the ho-
tel veranda, Protheroe had taken
Thorndyke's measure with a consider
able degree of accuracy, and but for
the enlistment OF his sympathies lie
might have been inclined to look upon
the New Yorker as person who would
probably serve, upon better acquaint-
ance, to point the moral of another
comparison. AS it was, however, crit
icism was swallowed up in charity,
and 10 minutes after leaving Thorn
dykes room Protheroe was galloping
out one of the prospective streets,
which, turning abruptly around the
shoulder of Johns mountain, became
a country road leading u2 the valley
of the Little Chiwassee. His destina-
ton was a small farm--the home of
the Duncans-lying six miles up the
valley; and his object was to prevail
upon his friends to open their doors
to the sick man.
There was a small romance at the bot
tom of the Scotchman's settlement in
Alabama. Duncan had been a school
master in Lanark shire, and Martha Kin
ross was first his pupil and later his
sweetheart. Martha was the laird's
daughter, and the laird, having a just
-sses3 for worldly gear, objected to
the penniless pedagogue. For once in
q way, Duncan put his hereditary eau
ton under foot, gave up the school,
married the girl, and together they ran
away from the laird's wrath and from
the old world. Once over seas, the win
tiers of Quebec became a sufficient pre-
text for farther wanderings, and these,
being aimless, ended as well in Alabama
as elsewhere. They had bought the
worn-out farm in the Little Chiwassce
valley before Elsie was born, and the
chief motive in its selection was one
which neither Duncan nor his wife
would have acknowledged. The mar
row valley was Scottish glen; the sur
rounding mountains were the hills of
Lanarll magnificd somewhat by the
kindly perspective Of time and distance;
and it was within the compass of a mere
" practical imagination TO transform
the small river into Scottish burn.
Not to be outdbne in a matter OF
sentiment, the valley had repaid the
parents in kind by giving what a mild
climate and inspiring scenery may give
toward the cnQONInCultO the ItcI.
Elsie Duncan was comely and passing
fair to look upon, as the native-born
daughters of aliens are wont to be;
moreover, she was simple and true
hearted, thinking that there were no
mountains like her own mountains and
few men as good as her father. She
was the apple of Duncan's eye, and for
her sake he had turned 'schoolmaster
again, giving her what she had other
wise gone wanting in a bookless land.
Without having been pointed thither-
ward, Duncans efforts to lift his
daughter above the educational level
of the neigbborhood brought about
n result which was not the less crafty
ing because il was unforeseen. The
book-learning raised barrier between
the girl and the mountain and valley
youth which was more impossible from
their side than from hers. and until
Protheroe had stumbled upon the Dun
can homestead on one OF his prospect
ing journeys there had been no suitors
nj the farmhouse. Nor is IL quite fair