The evening world., 1911-02-18
Michael and Annie Marrone
Lose Their Counter Pleas
for Freedom.
A REMARKABLE RECORD.
Female Serpent DISTURBED tn
Happiness of Italian Darby
AMI Joan.

Tfat a spanking and aHo:hc- honey.
moon. instead Of q legal separation. is
Whist Michael and Anuic Msrronr mos
need r. tire gist ~ supreme court Jus
fi-e Ncwburger's decision after hearing
the plaint ~ tlr. couple to-day.
Michael sued Annie Tor separation on
the ground % dcsertion. Annie brought
a counter claim. csnrging 6rucity on the
pr, OF h-r husband.
",s neither of she parties 20 this ac-
ton appe,Is 70 be free from fault
ss.d Justice Newburger. no relief can
be gran;ei. The complaint and counter
claim must therefore be Dismissed
In what Is perhaps the most remark.
able memorandum ever submitted 60 q
Justice OF the Supreme Court Wahle a.
krlngel. counsel for Annie. summed up
the marital differences Of the couple as
follows:
Annie. fifteen years OUNCE than
Michael. became his wife on July ,,
1898. Annie entered Michael's home
and was received by Michael's father,
brothers. cousins and aunts with the
welcome when penniless giri-wives
have always received by these heirs Of
a. accepted confirmed bachelor. She
was probably punished as children and
cLild-wivcs have always been 10y saoll-
ings and beatings.
Stood IN zee ssary Risk"
But Annie endured. She WAS young
ana buScm: she continued faithful to
Michael. cooked for him and his fam
ny. washed ana scrubbed. scwed Jn his
buttons. worked in his variou stores.
sold green groceries and dry groceries.
made mango and helped In his busiress
prcyres-. content to receive his bestinzs
And stand for his abuse as a necessary
risk of her calling and occupation
But one day. evil In their lives. Nj.
chael's fancy took him to Gsns,voor;
Market. and he found that there was
needed a dispensary for spaghetti. gar
Nlic-tsintcd and oil-tlnted foods with
cochineai. or log.wood colored ws:ci,
alias Chant; and he bethought h!ia az
Annie. young. with sparkling eyes. ruby
lips. rosy cheeks. raven hair and full
some contour, and he dreamed OF Annie
pouring wine for and stringlng spaghetti
around a full house of his compatriats-
and In tive background he saw gold.
Is n Annie would not, and so the
u OF Gansevoort Market shone on
the winter of the discomfort OF this
prospective Italian Darby aud Joan.
And Annie vas miserable. and she
was sad. because Michael only saw
yellow gold and not the blush OF her
shame.
The Female Serpent Cones.
"And with the spirit OF discomfort
came INTO this italian Garden OF Eden
q female serpent Of the species Esposl-
Ia. who tempted Annie with the JOY Of
the great beyend to Esposita Annie
eonhded her troubles. poured out her
fesr' and her tears oand probably some
Mine). and as ESpositas have ever
done. she advised flight with freedom.
= " zane tn pass In the Indian
simmer OF r11. on a warm afternoon,
while Michael was enjoying his siesta.
with dreams sweetened by thoughts OF
Anaie and ~gold-hnnic left.
And 80 these two. like wandrrin.
children. came 10 court. and each told "A
story.
Yes. Michael had been true. said
Annie.
And Annie? Where were the shauod
lspsthat had whispered foul accusation
against MIehael's Annie7 Gagged wiz,
their own lies.
THE Judge looks deep into the hearts
OF these two, and he knows OF VIVA
iley have scre ueed-a spanking eapI
and another honeymoon"
Annie, since LEAVING her husband. m.
lived With her brother, Antonio Messuri
at No. :i-3 First avenue.