Tulsa daily world. [volume] (Tulsa, Indian Territory [Okla.]) 1905-1919, 1911-09-19


Importance Judge brennan ''I"" 20
no Introduction, HIS hblllty ~ wen
known. his legal attainmcnts mat
go, - ...,,... ,...,,,,,,,, 10 "a IA studaut
W w ''''''
ui government ANA more yet, ne ~
In hearty sympathy with the most
80 tb.. ,.,.,,r.gstya pr,,ogopda that
W WV P'h''''''' ~ ''."n"''" '.''
mas h''"Ile 80 Hl"INru uuI'Hb NV
past few years. He IS most decidedly
entitled IA prnfound consideration.
.....'''I.. Az. ,,,'.,lI "a,
Il'H '''''I i'IloN's lH' WIZ" ''"''I
his objections but the morning OF
the day ON which his letter was writ
'''
Yen ln'I' appeared an 'd't"rlal III the
World which subjects il squarely to
HIS administrations and for this rea-
e,, hama ca, t,..it,.1 g., ,,,,t,,,t,,
'"' i''' '"' w. "'' '"''
lhr position taken as best ] might,
The controversy has thus early
-, r.,,,.,.,.a -. .,,.t,,,.,,,.
:" NV '"'
Tor Two reasons,
/ The space required exceeds the
lIr,its ~ tbo .dIt,rt,t.
30 II seems ialf 10 meet an hphesl
open critic on his own grOund-sim-
plv AS a coutributor
Judge Brennan's letter follows:
FDTrOR WoRtn. .,, .,r,,,I,. il, no.
cord win, IN. urinc,,t.. aJ,.,,t.1' b'. ,rIo
World ana tho Eausa. I,,,. So" 'yo,'id
ikr IA rnntinuo 80 y .iii,
have observed articD.s and eIitor,,Is in
The Kapsus Citv Sta, ,,,,b r.,.r',,,' ta tbn
CousiIiution ana ,b' raJar,I G,,,rts ,,hicb
from ,r,r "a I'm, 49,. @ -, ,t,,
would MOI he oo,C,s,3 "I ,Ji,'ar,'
,,bnol hny A. ,,,,' D! ~" go
Of misunierstandiny tr. IN lind n. on
has in mind y"nr iss,,e -, ha iau IN
slant routnI1pd r.Tr,,, 'u tdit,,i,I
frn,n tb, Ga la ,,E ',,,' ' " IL,
tbat van ,dnrtsJ tbo '"s ,I,. o''r
tanned
ThIs ,r,ioI, .hu. ,.....,.. h. p..,t,
ne arrlird IA r,Jar,l '' -,
IA out.tior tbn n,,,ino ,,',,i' III, Pr,,,,,s
IN mss nro, ma i,,,"ii,,,, i,;,
lat,vr ,paitn'.rts W., ,,t,r W." va ,6.,
Ion of ,ho r,nrfs ,b ,,,,r ~ ,,''S ,inr'l,
dnt.. statut,s M EJ,,,i ,,iu 'o, rinJI,.
giy. me- IA. roai tss,,. ,, W. !o" ",iiu''
sr,,cis. qtg Gs,i,,',i,s "'i,,'s 'is,ouSn '','
Gtntn ,or,,,n ,b, sa ,,,d ,','"a s . ",,D
soun libert, rho FqJrT.l CnrstitrtiYr j. a
spcrifr drlryatinn ne ,.rt,.,,l,r ,,,',,., .,J
tuuprr,s bns nat Le.n a',tGnrij,d b, tha
people to exercise any more WLat tribuunI
sbuiI .e, ,rho, Co,T,,.,ss g. .r,,l -,
tbau tL. un,rsr ds1rc,ted g., i, ~ ,'.,,,
lnnL ,,ro, tbayo 5,S 1i.,t''o', ~ 90 ~
povcr IN the FedoraF Gnr.,i,,it,,,,s
and nrcessarvI Dn vou I1oL nnor tb,.
rns,r,a';,n az YOU 'oA upon tMne M
ns yitat and nocoss,,,'1 ne "a a. !, ne1
necessary that sone tr;h,psi ho ot',tIisheJ
that vii d.,armi,, aar5i'' 20 LiSh,J
ruIrs wbetber nor,i.,,I"e ~ ,,S :,
bv Topgross ia ,'thi, tr'b ''Ja'Iu'e JIaa 80
pGwrrI Snn,ress is ,rohEi,ad ~, a. rou
stit,,tin, tram asi,' e. poo, 80 ,"o o~
Tbs 10 dafi,,nd f ~, M al "a tosa aG'o 14a"
that cr;ns whicp rot "ni'n t,In ,''i,r
royr,i,,ed Wi,ho, ""S ~ ~. ,T..i NJ
proLiLit,on Coraress co,,id ,',s ,,,h Ia,,'
Thn Wnr'd v'nSnld 'u piI p"Ie ''e" H 80" w. :
tbe courts IL smrh stst,'ia 4 ,,ay o, "ppva' ,r
Cnnyr..s a,d ~ ,ha ,, '' %. P".,,p - ?,
it~t spcb ." 'rossi",, r go 70
Uowayer tbess Siat,t,a o'u'n "e ;ei; useI'
dnted ~ TGn,. aro ,es,i,,,t;,,I o.
INA ,ho ,oy, ., WV ~ L' 10 L w w
ghsob,tnI, void r,nrs,i NV e., vao,
mnst ,oI,o tr1,,, sr,,i - 80 W 'nat ;
Innal o' o,.,,tio, ns "S ~.
,ollo,r its enac,non, M Jaw wa" S"'I'y ~
soiJ " 'a a,.er, ~ nv s1ine niuy pv pv
liher,v fo,,nj in tbs C"msti,''t;a " P''So"''
Thc Co"stit,t;o,, ., ,b' a,,ai 49,.
ra,;s,i,1 Va. " tne IeN'rsl Staies @ "re
stituti",, ',an ia' we Ieu'Ia. Goi
are limi,ati0ns S,,.a ,o,ia
Ia,islat,r ot' nj IT, pW" - '"' go
- - VI pN'''ouha p"Hs's s'"'u'c
~, So W. wy pio"'O''o'l yohl".H'u IN III
,rH,,,,,I os,J u,a, a,,s".'J"' 5"uu'u "ot sulne %
I,'i,I,,', ~ l t'"' Wv pa w T ,, "
Ia,, H,,,.r, a,,u ,He IHc' ana Tue
.,;,,,i,,,s "'''' VI """' '''''"'! are No"'
M ha;,,.., ~. .., a..
t"|v "a'','S NAV t"N,,opeS .hls s'I'ts VI
"i.'N'.S ~ 'u1 hahS"h Ory 9'"r uoes not
"pp pp at THi,"s,..'I ~ .nt "'u''t you qNuie'
"Ti,. - W 's'' M,'''' e'"' s'Is .ne same 10 'ne
,,a, W. ''' p"Pv'. ISL "'ItE W
| 50 "u"H ~ 'H''l ISSUES WIN reference 10
't',, ~" iim'I'a t",' auuyg'I ne P'oPle We
1 s'uI! '"k ""' ing l-'' ,"t issue u.
n'aG g''"r' ~ ln's power OF the courts
W oN 40 "'""""' VI aucii important sun
!to'S u ouS p''ng rvie'teu 70 as showing
Wv ntN'SSi.I VI N''a' thch hhou!u eue
sest th't Is very unfortunate argument
~ 10 support tHe hec"'., lhr guarantees ol
ihg t9hs,'uu9h are the SaiSsuards OF our
t tnu,''Iuu' ,ha, sHG personal notr,! SePar9t,
rom lna' oi tue mass OF lne people' IAuei
lhe guidance OF our constitutional SAFE
guards ana 'ne influence OF lhr common
law system lhulNldual Hn'iE mas grown
10 a state OF perfection IN TINS country
Wno''S u"Amo"h 10 Any o'"er so-'"'ltu
hepubUc. Inc constitution contains ht
leter ul my rights II popular cIainoi
could inspire IeslHIauNS enactment ron
the Hla'e LoglSnturt OF uNlAhoma IN Viola
/ non OF We constitution would want some
othtr Judge lhasl one snO!trt TO lhe SAINT
popular vote to pass upon ITS Vahdliy;
consider your environment IN oklah'ma
ana your WeHNhoWh ana oiltn eAptess''
/ opinion OF 'he l'gsiatnre ana lts legislative
| ehhctm"us- "A body OF men VINO nave shoWr
a very strong Inclination TO wholly disre
sard 'he provisions OF mat constitution
/ which iheE profess to reverence consider
that our supreme Court Is the one bright
! SHINING Slar IN me democratic hrmam"n
OF ,ns stare ana ,ha' u mas risen "ooN'
p"r!yiSm ana parry slriie ana mas pro
ceeded on the brondest ana highest possible
| gr1und-in so doing II has often 'invalt