davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
New-York tribune., 1911-02-25
CORNELL WINS DEBATE
Defeats Columbia and Pennsy''
vania in triangular Contest.

Cornell University was VICTORIOUS As'
night in her debate with Columbia UnTer-
stty AZ the Horace Mann Auditorlan'. "
this city. This was one o! the uiahs1H
debates occurring last night between tsSHs
representing Columbia, Pennsylvania aaa
Cornell. TIE question debated was 'shou.@
the Ownership OF Forest ana Mineral i-ahos
Be Retained by tho Federal Governmth''
The Cornell debaters were L. = HeH'
] A. Sourwine ana II. l.. GTif.;h. Colun''
bia was represented by'A. J. Teasiee' -
s. Harris and r. c. Hunter. The wlnhlns
team took the negative side OF tie quss'
ton.
Philadelphia, Feb 2i.-Ihe Columbia Il''
versity debating team. which Upheld tse
negative Of the question. Resolved. 1Hs'
the ownership Of forest and mineral aAoS
now belonging 10 the United STATES y.
,he several states should he retslle; Z!
the federal government" won the dee
sion over the University OF PennsyVah'-
team here tonight. Columbia's team oVn'
ststing Of Il Davenport. c. +. Helm aHa
G J. Ruch. The University OF PenayE
vania team was composed Of samlel ''os
snhaum. FrederisN koschwitz and FfahA
Parker. Jr.
Ithaca. y. Y, Feb ?i.-cornell Unive''ny
won from the University OF Pennsy''"''~
IN the triangular debate to'night.
New-York tribune., 1911-02-25
SUES TO GET HER MONEY BACK
Wife Says Husband She Divorced Got
$4,000 70 Invest In Good Thing"

Mrs. Amelia Saloracn, who recently OBJ
;ained divorce from Joseph Salomon, an
oalcer Of tire American Rattan ard Reed
Company Is suing her former husband for
s27D0J she said she gave him TO invest in
American Tobacco Company stock. The
plaintiff. by the way, il collecting $50 a
month alirnony from Sslomon.
Mrs Saiomon said on the stand in the
Supreme Court yesterday that in July
ls09. her husband came 10 her and said he
had q coed thin; - the sock market
American Tobacco, he scid was due for q
rise He asked for s25060, and said the
more he invested the more ne would make
on the Investment. Thcreupon, the wife al
leges, she gave him check for $4,000
i..ier. after they had separated. said Mrs
saloiaon, they met a. the Hotel Knicker-
cocker. lie asked tor all the money
checks and securities that she had say.
ing Il she didn't produce them he would
get his bpother TO 6epose him from the
company with which he was connected
declaring according 10 Mrs. salomon
Then III De left nigh and dry, and so
will you"
The defendant says the money and stocks
we're bis own. and he had n right 70 take
and keep them.
New-York tribune., 1911-02-25
IS He DUKE OR MONARCH?
Jury Must Decide-Big St. Ber-
nard Meanwhile YaWns in Court.

While the justice, jury, lawyers and Ltt-
gants in the City Court yesterday We're
irving 70 determine whether Elkwood
Monarch was the Duke OF Richheld. OF
vice versa, the subject Of the controv 2rsY,
q huge St Bernard dos, just slept and
didn't display any more enthusiasm than
a Polar bear in a hot July sun. Od2e he
yawned II any human being had yawned
that way in court he would have been fined
for contempt OF court.
The controversy over the ownership II
the dog was between John Stokes. on lie
one side, and Montifore G. Kahn and Mr.
and Mrs. Lee Hyman on the other side
Stokes, who is suins 10 get the dog. said
he bought the alleged Elkwood Mor1rca
from the Ieilgate Kennels, and that ne
was stolen from him. Last year he VS.
tied the bench SHOW the Westminsted. Ken
mel Club, and there was the subject OF
the present controversy on eXhibilicn, n"
said, under the name OF the Duke Of Rich-
field.
The defendants said they bought the dog
from a reliable kennel and that Stokes !
claim was q case OF mistaken idectty.
Witnesses appeared for both sides, tie
question of pedigree and age figuring prom
inently in the dispute. on Monday the tIry
will receive the case and decide who is the
Tightful owner.
New-York tribune., 1911-02-25
HExAMER MARRIED AGAIN
Hoboken Riding Master, Di-
vorced, Weds New York Woman.

Alexander Philip Hexamer. a wealthy
riding academy master, Of Hoboken. was
quietly married on Thursday night TO Mrs.
Adelaide OConnor Eagan. OF New York.
The ceremony was performed in the rec
tory Of the Church OF Our Lady Of Grace.
Hobcken. by Monsignor Kelly. So quietly
did the wedding occur that not even the
intimate friends Of Hexaner knew Of It
until yesterday.
Hexamer is one OF the best known Of
Hobcken's citizens. He came into proni'
nence about two years ago, when no
brought an action against his wife IN New
York, naming Burgstailer. the opera
singer, as correspondent. The suit wss
later dropped. however, and Mrs. Hea'
amer subsequently went TO Europe ABOUT
the time that Burgstaller returned io'bs
native land. Hexamer then brought a sse.
ord action for divorce on the grounq ao1
desertion and obtained q dec ee.
Hts friends were aware OF the triendsnlp
existing between Esxarner and Mrs. Ezan'
but they did not dream that ne eonte"i'
plated a second weddins.
New-York tribune., 1911-02-25
STUDENTS HAVE GRIEVANCE
Washington Irving High School
Girls Want French Course,

The girls Of Washington Irving High
scbcG have grievance. committee ap-
pointed 20 ,ell the public about u consists
OF Miss Rose Golcstein. of 40. % Mont
sorncry street. ard Miss Florence Tok, Of
No. =. oTsytu sueet
1--WE want 70 study the French Language" ."
said the committee yesterday and they
reuse us TINS course"
"lney teacn IS cooling" said Miss Tolk.
"Our teacher to-aa pst some sugar lh
some water ana then addcd the wn.te ~
an egg ana said y VAS fio1Lng Island
Now. what 6ood IS that
"1cs .uc stster0o, she put a capsule
In cupful Of hot water and said il was
be4f tea" said Miss Godstein.
Then In q lew ~ usAnp words the con-
n1'ttee explained the 4 ie, ence. Eoi ell
down 10 hard pan, tie trouble Is that the
arjs are not permitted g take course Of
French durirg The academic term gnle,
ftsv start thtir first year Vith the subJeci
1'bev want 70 lie allowed 20 take ~ French
dorins their see'nd year IhsE cay IN nat
obioh they sent 10 the Board az Educa-
lion, although other schools have the
New-York tribune., 1911-02-25
FOOD DEALERS HAVE FEAST
Speaker Rejoioes Drinks Are Still
TWp for a. Quarter.

TIE prdS,ah of the high cost Of living
rested lightly on the members OF the New
Ycrk branch Of the Natonel Lcague Of
Commission Merchants last night. when
they held their annual feast with singing
and other noise az the Hotel Knekerbocker.
President y. II Bahrenourg was toast
master and attempted 20 impress q serious
air upon the oinEr., declaring that the re-
aponsi5!lties OK commission men as dis.
tribute-s Of the necessities Of life were not
70 he subordaated 70 4 desire for private
gain. He said q; was the duty of the mer.
chants 20 welcome proper governmental
regulation OF food velues
Arthur Brisbane dsr4!led the serious at
nosphere that began to pervade the meet.
ing BY declaring that he was grand
farmer" himself, for had he not planted
a hundred acres with thirteen barrels Of
potato seed and reaped seven barrels Of po-
tatoes which the commission men would
not BUY al any price? Then he grew really
SERIOUS but the diners were in too happy
O frame Of ra!nd 10 take the rest OF his
political economy so seriously az TO sao'
dep The occasion.
Charles o. Mas declared that as good
Republican he iopuSiated the iInputai'n
that the high cost Of living was due to the
tariff. AS q lover OF mankind he had higa
words Of praise fer the philanthropies !
Nathan straus, and that personally he re-
:oiced that while everything else haa gone
ur drinks were still two for a quarter
ghen IN a tragic peroyaIion he called upon
the cenrl.ssion men 10 follow their hisA
duty and give 10 this starving nation free
csobasts."
Other speakers were William Carroli and
william c. Reed. There were over two
hundred members Of the association pres
.nt. Among the guests Of honor were
Nathan Spaus and I. ~. Fisher Of tie
Epreau 6! Standards at Washington.
New-York tribune., 1911-02-25
PROF. G.. w. GCcTT's WIFE SUES
In Divorce Action Names S:enographer
of Congressional Library Custodian.

Professor George Winfield Scott, Gus
todian OF the Congressional Law Library
who was formerly a professor In George
Washington Univers.ty, and is connected
with research work of the Carnegie In
stltute is being sued for a divorce by his
WIFE, Mrs. Annie W. Scott. who was mar
ried 10 him in 1901 in Scranton. Penn. AT
the time OF the wedding Scott was q stu
dent In the law school OF the University
OF Pennsylvania. Mrs. Scott names as CO.
respondent Miss Clara HctoPp. formerly
the defendants stenographer.
The piaHtin says tnat until recently her
husband had an apsi tment ~ No 40 West
l2ist stIect, and was lelturing on Internal
toLal law at Columbia University Miss
Lotoup, who denies the changes q the
wife. says that she was associated with
Piolesso Scott in some literary work. ana
that when she met Mrs. scott IN California
he latter showed great friendship for her
The husband also denies the charges %
Mira. Scott.
The Appellate Division og the Supreme
Court ordered the professor 10 pay his
wife 500 Counsel fee. instead of $500. Al
originally ordered. and 800 a mcnth all
mony. pending the trial OF the suit.
New-York tribune., 1911-02-25
MISS ARNOLD DEAD: FLYNN
Father, However, Thinks Griscom
.Ought 10 Have Been Seen.

The seventy.th,rd Gay Of the absence Of
Dorothy Il. c. Arnold brought out some
reversals of opinion yesterday by those
who nave been most closely connected
with the seprch Deputy Commissioner
Flynn. to whom the krnolds told their
story first. said yesterday he had changed
his former opinion that the missing girl
was alive and well, and believed now that
she must be dead.
He based this new opinion solely or the
theory that i she were alive now some one
would have tv this time taken advantage
of the opportunity to claim th2 $1,000 re-
ward offered ty her father for information
leading 10 her discovery.
1t the ssras time. the opinion Of Francs
r. Arnold appeared 10 have changed, be-
cause, though he had been steadily saying
his daughter was dead, It was said for
him Yesterday that he now believed his
representatives. had neglected an important
opportunity when they failed to get at and
question George 5. Grscom. ir.
II was pointed out to Mr.. Arnold yester-
day that no one representing the Arnold
family had questioned the younger G.is-
CON since he returned TO this country, and
that Eoger OMera, the PittsoUrs detective
who was looking after the Grscoms' inter-
ISIS. was on recorG as sayinS he believed
the g!Yl was alive O'Maya has talked
with the younger Griscon. Nr. Arnold's
,nly objection TO having one Of his repre-
sentarives put Gri.com, jr.. through the
third degree" was thes he dreaded the
attendant renewal Of publicity should lie
send a man to Atlantic City for that pur.
pose.
According to one report from the New
Jersey resort, Dorothy Arnold had 6een IL:
Atlantic C.ty up 10 the time that Gris.o
r.. went there. but had then left because
she wanted 70 get away from any chance
meeting with the reporters and detectives
who followed "Junior' there. This story
also related that about three days after
Griscorn's arrival. and after Miss Alncld
had moved along, a trunk with her na.ns
on il WAS shipped out Of Atlantic City by
EXPRESS. The name Arnold had heen
covered with g foreign hote! label, which
SIC Cd out prominently in the dozen or 50
more travel worn toreiGn labels then on
the trunk.
These ard other stories which reschec
Mr. Arnold's ears yesterday almost brought
him TO the point OF directing one OF his
LAWYERS to sec and Question the younger
Griscorn as TO what communications he
has had with the girl since he took up his
quarters IN the Chalfonte Hotel. in Allan
tic City.
Dy. Ienjamin Arnold. who was acting as
a physician ir Flower Hospital when Mss
Marjorie Arnold VISITED there zen days
ogo. - out OF that Institution for the
N esert. The Authorities s,ated that DR..
Arnoids retirement had nahing 20 do
with the publicity given The visit Of his
cousin. bit that he was substitute in
tcrne theIe. and that the doctor for whom
he was nling in had rotuInod recently.
New-York tribune., 1911-02-25
MUST ABATE NOISE NUISANCE
Justice Rules Against Edison Company
After Seeing Plant Himself

Daniel Rosendcrf. who lives next 10 the
New York Edison plant IN East SD street.
sued FOR an injunction on the ground that
the noise and vibration Of the machinery
lcpt his family awake az night After
having made three trips 70 tha plant Jus
tice Eranger deeided yesterday 10 give
the company ninety days TO remedy the
nuisance and ordered that the defendant
pay 10 the pla.n,ir Ses7 for the loss OF rental
values OF the house owned by Rosendorf
Justice Enansor said that when he
visited The scene cf trouble he found the
LWiLe of the petitioner sick. and that the
machinery OF the Edison plant mado con
si6elable noise bur he detected no vibra-
lfinrs He learned also that me company
lad built noise pfooi walls ans was in
stallng other noise killins devices.
New-York tribune., 1911-02-25
TURNS TABLES ON LAWYER
Miss Grunspan Alert After Four
DAYS on Stand.

A little tired after having spent four
days on tho witness stand. Miss annette
Bertha Grunspan, who Is sung William
English Valling rich Socialist. fer gN-
GO for alleged breach OF promise, showed
yesterday by her clever cclIoquy with coun-
sci for the defence at the trial IA the Sd.
preme Court that at least her mind was
as alert as ever and the lawyer acknow.
edged her cleverness while she was under
severe cross-examination.
Miss Grunspan had told on the stand o..
her studying az several schools at the ex.
pense of Walling. who. she said, wanted
her TO be able q male good appearance
among his friends when they were married
Walllng's lawyer tried to find oGt just how
much she had studied before that and
knew about famous authors, among them
Voltaire and Hugo, for she said Walling
liked her on account OF her knowledge e,
literature. The intelligent answers seemed
t. surprise the lawyer Now and then The
plaintiff would fail 70 remember some date
OF the text OF some conversation with Wall
ing.
At one point Walling's lawyer made a
dsparaging remark apropos OF Miss Grdh.
spans memory. She set the court In rear
Of laughter by saying: Don't make such
a remark, SIR. Maybe you will feel better
after you have dined. My memory IS tired.
I admit after beins four days on the stand
and further dates did not interest ME when
Mr. Wallng was promising to marry me.
II they had, or If I thought they would,
assure you | would have kept them for
you
Miss Grunspan said that she had lest the
marquiso ring that Wailing had given Ger
as an engagement ring. She said the ies-
ing of anger she felt when Wailing f.st
spoke to her on the street in Paris as she
was going home from her work was "a
feetlng one" The case VIII be resumed
on Mondav
New-York tribune., 1911-02-25


provision contained in the existing treaty
recognizing the right OF each country 10
regulate immigration
The third article contains the right 10
appoint consular officers except in those
places where it may not be convenient
70 recognize such ofticers."
Article " is the usual guarantee OF re-
ciprocal freedom CT commerce and naviga-
tion. Article V provides that import ou'
ties shall be regulated either by speclal
arrang ernentS between the two countries
o. by tie internal legislation OF each.
Article VI exempts citizens from transit
duties and other charges not imposed On
nationals
Corporations are dealt with in Article
VII. which permits them to appear IN
courts subject. to the laws Of each coun-
Try. although it is stipulated that reTmk7
sion 10 corporations 10 transact business
must remain subject TO local laws.
Article VIZ provides that there shall be
no discrimination between the vessels Oh
the two countries in their right TO carry
imports without being liable to otEer o.
HIGHER charges Of duties than nation Il
vessels. The same rule is applied to ex-
portatiCn and to the payment Of export
duties. bounties ana drawbacks.
Articles IN, X, XI, XII and XIII re-
late to shipping, the general purpo.t De-
ing to prevent any discrimination between
tie vessels Of the two countries, althoush
the coasting trade Of the two countries Is
especially excepted.
Article XIV promises that any trade OF
navigation privilege extended TO another
country shall be enjoyed by tho signatories
20 this treaty. Article XIV confers protec-
ton for patents. trademarks and desisns'
The other three articles provide that TINS
treaty shall supeIscde the treaty OF lesb
when It becomes operative on July H. lsll'
and shah remain IN force twelve years
At the end CT twelve years the treaty also
continues operative unless six months no.
tice 10 the contrary is given. Ratinca-
,icns must be exchanged in Toxic mot
later than three months from the present
date"
a protocol continues existing tariff rela-
tiens pending the conclusion OF the special
tariff arrangements referred TO IN the
treaty.
New-York tribune., 1911-02-25
CALL MRS. F|SKE WRONG
Cats Not Bought from Children
at Wellesley.
DENIAL FROM PROFESSOR
Actress Said College Showed
Little knowledge Of Duty
to the Young.
fnv Telesrarh % The Trlbune.l !

Boston, Feb 2i.-The authorities of
wellesley College are much wrought NJ
over the statement Of Mrs. Minnie Mod
dern Fiske that she understands th't
children Of wellesley are paid for fur
nishing cats for dissection purposes.
Mrs. Fiske docs not know what she
is talking about" said Professor Robert
son. professor Of zoology at Wellesley
College. You cannot make il too strong
in saying that we do nothing of the kind.
Mrs Fiske says she understands we
DO this. She misunderstands, and che
does not quote her authority for the
statement, because she can have none.
Buy cats from the children around
here? No, indeed Of course, we have
course in zoology here and we get cats
and other animals to d.ssect. but never
heard Of any money being given children
for supplying the creatures. We get all
our animal supplies from regular col
lectors who make avbusiness Of provid-
ing science laboratories. These collec-
tors are not even in this neighborhood.
Of course, do not know how they get
the cats, but at any rate the children Of
Wellesley are not affected morally or
any other way"
Mrs. Fiske calls Wellesley College nom
progressive and out of key with modern
civilization. She says It shows little
concern for morality and little knowledge
Of its duty toward the young.
What warrant" she asks. has
Wellesley to blunt and pervert the minds
Of children by teaching them TO think
that dumb animals have no rights that
human beings are bound TO respect?
"I understand that the college needed
cats in its courses IN anatomy. and that
the children of tho town were raid for
all the specimens they brought to the
college. Consequently. the children have
been stimulated 10 activity in getting
the animals and no voice mas been raised
against this barbarity."
Chief Patrick Beatty. Of the Natick
pollce. was greatly incensed at the report
that small children he'd acted as cat and
dos snatciers for the vivisection squad
of Wellesley College. and said:
Il shall Investigate, and if ! find II IS
SO I will prosecute TO the limit"
He detailed plainclothes men TO look
into the matter and report. Later the
detectives returned and had a lorg con-
sultation with the chief When seen by
q reporter. Chief Beatty said number
Of Suspicious ciTcumstances had oc-
cured. but nothing on which ne could
base an action.
AZ present Chief Beatty is inclined
L, thirk that he will suspend action I'M
less something new turns up.
New-York tribune., 1911-02-25
ARRESTED FOR EXTORTl0N
Hotel Man Says Prisoner Got His
Property from a Woman.

Detectives Howry and Tecskowski OF the
Central Office. arrested q man last night
who said he was Thomas a. IN 4nnon.
forty-seven years old, a builder, and gave
his address as the Continental Hotel. on
the charge OF extortion. Edward Rieffel
formerly. II was said, an DHice' IN the
German army tnd who lives al no. SI4
West l57th street, made Ehe eompiain..
The arrest followed some complicated
tran actions regarding the Monument
Hotel, l23d street and Eighth ay,au5. l>rt.
tel asserted the MOTEL was his ofo2e.tv. Ths
blot,er entry ct headquarters stated that
Shannon induced Carrie Brandt 10 sign
papers giving the hotel 10 him. Sno had
power OF attorney from Riefrel
New-York tribune., 1911-02-25
LIES. BY WHITE MOTHER
His Treasures Buried with Qua
nah Parker. Comanche Chief.

cache. Okla. Feb. 24.--Dressed in a
buckskin suit. with his favorite war
bonnet, jewelry and relics by his side,
Ouanah Parker. chief Of the Comanche
Indians, 'who died yesterday. was buried
to-day by the side Of his white mother
in the Indian cemetery at Post Oak
Mission
indians chanted weild dirges. consign-
ing the body Of the chief to the Great
Father. The Rev. A. J. Becker, mis-
sionary, preached the funeral sermon.
More than a thousand persons. includ-
ing hundreds Of Indians, attended the
funeral. Among the jewelry buried with
the chief was a diamond brooch pre-
sentod to him by cattlemen.
New-York tribune., 1911-02-25
COLGATE WINS DEBATE
Defeats Hamilton and Union, "@A'
Hamilton Beats Union.

Utica, y. y. Feb. 9t-Hamil'oh .'
defeated Union az Clinton and Coisa'; y.
versltv defeated Hamilton collese To-
u,or tonight IN the ,ntercollesiate aess.'
An the question Of the initiative and se'S
endum. Union had the ahirmAuNe Md
the question at Clinton ana ha""''
the Affirmative asalnst Colgate
schenectady. y. (. Feb A-lhs rol.
cone.e debating team was defeated 0y;1. a..
gate here tonight in the second annual A. A..
bate OF tho triangular intercoyegssisSi Agate ale
hating league. which consists Q. Union
University. Hamilton College anu
College.
New-York tribune., 1911-02-25
wild BILL" KILLS REBEL
Hatfield Teudist Murders Comrade in
Insurgent Army.

Mexicali. Mex. Fe5. ?4.--''Wild Bill" Hat.
field. one Of the famous Mccoy Hatfield
feudists Of Kentucky. who is an American
recruit in General Leyva's rebel army.
shot a Mexican insurgent named Francisco
last night. Hatfield used an suomatic gun.
and the victims face was shot away.
Francisco was taken 70 the International
line by his comrades and rolled across the
border He was picked up by the Red
Cross attendants and taken 10 the hospital
in Caleixico. where he died. Nothing was
done with Hatfield by the rebels.
One hundred insurgents marched out OF
Mexicali last night 10 form jun,ture
with the advance guard OF sixty sent out
On Wednesday. With the detachment went
Gene, al Leyva, who will operate against
Fnsanada
New-York tribune., 1911-02-25
PRINCESS IRENE's ROUGH TRIP
Steamer Drops Propeller, Runs Into
Gale and Arrives Hero 4 Day Late.

After c7e .! the roughest t.irs in the eS-
persence Of Captain Won Letten- Petersen,
her commander, the PRINCES Irene. OF tie
North Germtn Lloyd Line, came into pert
yesterday with broken propeller and one
CAV lote. The steamer arrived from Naples,
Palermo Genoa and Alsiers.
= day teiove arriving at Gibraltar she
drcpped one ot tie blades Of the port pro-
psller, bat docking facilities could not be
had there. and Captain Won Letten-Peters-
sen continued TIE voyara with his crippled
sn!o. On Mcnday the Princess ran into
southwest gale which tossed her about
until Wednesday. The steerage passengers
were Ior ,ed below decks.
Among the passengess or the Princes
Irene ye.e Alexander MacLean editor OF
The Jersey City Evening Journal; Al
bert Frazer. United States Consul az Val
encia, and Albsrt Robert United States
Consul AZ a siers.
New-York tribune., 1911-02-25
BACHELORS TO GO UNTAXED
Legislative Committee Reports Against
Penalizing Single Blessedness.

Boston reb. 24-Bachelors over thirty
Ave wears OF age living IN Massachusetts
VIII not be compelled 10 purchase with s.
their freedcm from matrimonial bon-s If
rh4 rerort of the Committee on Taxation
arairst suCh a measure. and Sled Win the
genate to-day, is accepted by the Two
Lrancnes - re les statute.
- rcro~t OF no committee which heard
nvrnSrops arguments IN favor OF sueh q
,sy yeas ursn' nous oGinst ne bill