The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-06-24
TROUBLE FOR JOCKEY DUGAN
KEENES TRAINER, ROWE
NAMES FORMAL CHARGES.
says slF Jolln JohnsoRJ Rider PuFposely
Interfered Win Masketie ~. Powers
Makes Protest % Foul Against King
James In same Race AZ sheepshead.

James In same Race AZ sheepshead.
The running Of the Sheepshead Bay Han.
dican. one mile. ID the COney Island Jockey
Clubs track yesterday bristled with rough
riding and enGed in a controversy that will
have 10 BE- settled by The stewards Of the
Jockey Club. Trainer James Rowe. who
handles James X. keene's stable. has pre-
terred formal charges against Jockey
Eddie Dugan. in the employ Of August
Belmont. and cites Dugan's tautios on the
Beverages stables Sir John johnson
In yesterdays race
When s. e.. Hildreths King James. sup.
poSed by the wise men, won this event
by half a length from Mt Keene's Masketis
In "a IS. saualling the track record, v.
Powers, who roda the keene mare. hurried
before the stewards with a protest Of foul
against the winner. at the same time dsolaF-
inE THAI shilling, who rode the Hildreth
horse, had struck Masketts over the nOss
with the butt end Of his whip a. the last
sixteenth pole was reached Powers also
said that Maskstte had been carried wide
by Sir John johnson and DuRan az the
head OF the stretch and that che had also
been bumped BY King James near the
end Of the journey
Tho stewards interviewed shilling. Who
denied Powers charges and also stated
that Maskette had almost knocked the HI
dreth horse down on the baokstretch. The
stewards did not deliberate long before
they dismissed PoWersa protest and ordered
the red board up. But that only increased
the anger Of Trainer Rowe. who insisted
thae u the race had been truly run Maskett0
would have won easily.
Mr.. kcene will have 70 do something
about this rough riding exclaimed Rowe.
or he can engage another trainer. I've
preferred charges against Dugan. for he
deliberately took care OF Masketts BY
constantly interfering with her Il IL about
time that these tactics we're stoppedl-
Rove complained to Mr.. Belmont several
DAYS ago that DuEan was purpOsely inter
terng with various hOHes and that the
matter should he taken up ny the stewards.
But nothing was done. luRan's tactics
IN yesterdays race prompted hundreds
on the lawn 20 ask these questions.
Why did he interfere with Maskette7
Why didn't he try to keep his own horse
next 10 the rail instead Of carrying the
keene mare wide al the head Of the stretch
and at the same time letting shilling come
through on the rail with King Jamesg What
was behind Il ALP In fact what has been
behind other queer looking races won BY
horses backed by a certain cliaue?-
When the race WAS started Sir John John
son and Mary Davis went 20 the from,
Powers Kept Maskette close up. with King
james not far away. As soon a. Maskptte
9esah % make her run aud oyeThauied Sir
John Johnson DuEan swung his mount ,
away from the rail- aud carried the keene
mare vide. Then shilling saved many
lengths by slipping through on the rail al /,
ne head OF the stretch with the Hildreth /
horse. who showed vast Improvement
over his previous races. Maskette then !
got away from sir John johnson and went
after KING James. A. tho sixteenth pole /
Z h"y came together with a bump aud many /
spry iaiors sad shilling vas 70 blame. The /
collision threw Maskeite on her stride and 7
Just about beat her. a. King James reached .
The wire nall length TO the good Izar, .
a neEiected outsider ran fair race aud .
vac .s., thlrd, elght lengths away, beating sir .
Mr. keene's Cow. a black nlly by Dis ,
gus" ~ Mildred, 10 I, after a ragged 7
start ~ the third race. Tor maiden tWo- /
ycaT-Oids, i've furlonRs futurtfv course /
Won rather easily by three lengths IN iOi I
X tarman.s Rye straw, ~ 20 Z, Ia a drive !
nailed the place BY hall a length from .
samuel Rose DR.. puenner, a good thing 1
frin. Cal ~. george Odom's star sprinter. !
handigHp, 90 siA aud a half uTlOngs main I
tussk lie paCked l2s pounds and under I
patient handling by Mctiee he trailed be- I
mind the paCema kers 4. CarmHn's .
Maya llue, n y Duryea's Dreamer and .
Leopold kahn's Ben Loyal. 10 the head Of
the stretch. In the last Few jumps he man
q gtd o get his head IN front. ~, time being
J ~ Dreamer was - ond. a length and a
hail VA front Of Magazine
Waterway in spite Of me rumOF that he
wouldn't 10. NOntne stespleH base handi,aU,
- about TWO and q naf miles When Hsider
let him down the NatereNel geldlng ran
away from he Nelkin, ; 20 3 and beat
her ia breeze by thirty lengths Ia SIS
Monte carlo 49, third badly beaten. after
croWding lapplngton INTO barrel marA
on the hd, kztret b, which made the latter
throw Jockey Taylor on his head
thiraRO O'Bren and his turf assO, iates 7
put over q good thing in Perry johnson in
The nfth nee, for platers, 40 a mile ana fur
long on the grass he WAS 0utTun by Cant Z
swanson 20 the headol the stretch bat when
'lass took 0n the brakes Perry Johnson
forged 20 the front 10 win by a length and
l half Ia ht capt swanson was second
three lengths before check a long shot
hildTeth'@ Montgomery, cold favorite
had no speed this time and Was badly
NC ankles crack K ally Round the World
NJ prohibitive odd=. tings nncd In front
all the way ia the last race the Xcphyr
Stakes. for fwO-veHr -Olds, ave furlong4 .
fuluritv course She vas on the hit all tho
way beating Mr. GOlightiy by four lengths
IN Uje Is. N L. ShAw's Adrian, second