davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The Richmond Virginian. (Richmond, Va.) 1910-1920, 1910-04-13
CHAPTER TX

ltdt vi SNkA&1 LAHIeUE0
Chalioner had progressed with
uncommon haste. the fourth
a day finding all the witnesses
heard and the case ready to sum up
to the jury. Brief and to the point had
been the states cnse-made up out Of
Pemmiean's evidence and the confes-
sion of the prisoner. But In the prose
cutor's presentment Of his evidence
there had been an undercurrent as I'M
usual as 1t was unexpected. Every
question that he hurled at Pemmican
had hidden meaning; every Inter
rogation point had sting hidden In ita
tail Not that he made any attempt
to switch the issue or to sidetrack
the facts, but II was clearly apparent
that from start to finish he was max
ing supreme effort to include within
his facts. to embrace within the issue
and to place on trial. together with the
prisoner, one other cuiprit In this cele-
brated case Cradlebaugh's.
However, Ii such were the prosecu-
tors chief purpose 1t failed Thorne.
the counsel for the defense. who rep
resented more than one client 10 this
case, met him at every turn. parried
his every thrust.
And upon such occasions Graham
Thorne from the coupsers table In the
front had flashed a triumphant glance
ut Peter Frederick. and Peter Broder-
lex In turn from his seat In the rear
of the courtroom would return the
gaze with a smile. the brilIiancy Of
which was outshone only BY the big
diamond that blazed from whore n
rested comfortably on his highly COZ
ored shirt front. To these two--not In
the least interested In the outcome Of
the trial. so far as Challoner was con-
cerned-the case was highly satisfac-
tory. There was no crevfce h the
mystery Of Cradlebaugh's IN which
Murgatroyd could insert the thin edge
of wedge Its foundation stiH r.
manned mistaken after the impact OF
his battering RAM The ChaIl0ner casa
was to be the Challoner case and moth
ing more.
On Pemmican OF the low brow leav.
ing the Witness stand be had giancs4
expectantly toward the counsel for thu
defense. Throughout the trial thera
was In his manner peculiar defer
ence toward Thorne which hSd beea
there from the FIRST day.
"Snrely you're not going to detain
me any longtry' whispered Pemmicas
to the officers. who had placed them
selves on either side OF him. sWhati
You're not going 10 let me 9oT"
mot on your lffers remarked one az
them genially. and. showing to thu
prisoner d slip Of paper which be drew
from bis pocket, There's ! warrant
for your arrest"
Pemmfcan looked b<wlldered
1.-THE chiefss begua his raid on Gro
dlebaugh's. and you're ono Of ths
main gays"
Pemmtcan stammered suIkiIy:
"And-and the prosecutors e0in' to
lock me up after All I've done FOR
him &
That's whatr' replied tho o6scsr.
.'UnIoss you ean Gst hail
"C0Hf0nnd en-. exriaimed FSmmE
can. 'sThsy won't 50 my bailt'
The detective placed his ear Quie6
close g Psmmican. ss
.:Mho wont 70 youg. han q ~ g.
ried intersstedlys n
The Richmond Virginian. (Richmond, Va.) 1910-1920, 1910-04-13

tain they are suitable to the dignity
and splendor of that Son on whom We
trade with the Father.
What creates our faith in prayer If
not the life giving words of the great
Teacher on prayer? The personal tes-
timony OF thousands of witnesses sub
stimulates the force OF paryer. God
truly knows. our needs, but He also
knows our need to petition-He 20
grant.
Cooperative interest in this plan OF
soul-life it has been His wisdom to
establish. He is the Eternal Listener,
the Continuous Pardoner He daily re-
members our frames. Day by. day He
pardons our frailttes.
Selfish Prayers.
The selfish petition. the vain eZoist's
The Richmond Virginian. (Richmond, Va.) 1910-1920, 1910-04-13

before the trial wen 80 over the testi.
mony carefully, You zee. I'm most
particular about this case" McGrath
entered and took Pemmican away.
The Richmond Virginian. (Richmond, Va.) 1910-1920, 1910-04-13
THE AUTUMN.

Go. sit upon the lofty hill.
And turn your eyes around.
Where waving woods and water wild
DO hymn an autumn sound
The summer sun 10 faint on them
The summer flowers depart
Sit stili-as all TRANSFORMED to stone.
Except your musing heart.
The dearest hands that clasp our
hands
- aaheir preSusree may DO Ger.
The dearest voice that meets our ear
That tone may come no more!
Youth fades; and then. the joys or
youth.
Which once refresh'd our mind.
Shah cUue--as. on those signing
woods,
The chtliing autumn Wind.
= - - - 1Ixfk xfaulJ 1sls11e
The Richmond Virginian. (Richmond, Va.) 1910-1920, 1910-04-13
THE QUALITY OF PRAYER

Prayer is the souls natual attitude
forward God.
1t is the spirit-food of elevation to
humanity.
1t acts as a cleanser of the atmos-
phere of the mind.
II the quality of conditional prayer
The Richmond Virginian. (Richmond, Va.) 1910-1920, 1910-04-13
81 RED MOUSE
A Mystery
Romance
-

copyriatit. 1909, by Dodd.
Mead q Co.
Continued from Yesterday,

(Continued from Yesterday
Murgatroyd patted the. wallet.
1T was Colonel Hargraves' pocket
book" he said. 81 thought you. rec.
ognized It"
.'Never saw 1t before, counselor" he
repeated salkily. ..never saw IL be-
FORE
lyon must have seen it." persisted
Murgatroyd. "It's pretty well worn,
aifd he must have carried tt a long
time. He was one Of Your patrons
The fact Is, Pemmican," he went on,
"this wallet was the occasion Of my
sending for you just now. l am In
formed that when Hargraves last car
ried it the wallet was full Of bulls, and
when he was found in the street il
was quite empty. It is mere detail.
but should like to know whether
Chailoner robbed this man as well Us
killed him"
Pemmican slowly shook his head
Cant help you out" he answered,
''for l never saw the wallet. don't
know"
Mnrgatroyd went or on another
tack.
Very well, then. But there's an
other thing that you may clear up,
By the way, Pemmican, perhaps you
don't know that Challoner has con-
fessedY''
Pemmican cried joyfuny:
Confessed? Gee, that's goodl
Great! 1t just had to come to thatg
Yes" conceded Murgatroyd. "but
there's another thing which bothers
me, though l don't know that II COM
piicates matters exactly. It's mere
detail again. Chalioner says he shot
his man La Reem A In Gradiebaugh,s.
You say the quarrel took place there.
that Hargraves went out first and that
Chaloner followed him. Hargraves.
as we know. was found dead In the
street above. That's right, isn't lit"
Sure" returned Pemmican positive
ly. Il didn't see him fire the shot
Nobody saw that It's good thing.
though, because between you and me,
prosecutor. Notwithstanding my testi-
mony, l thought that you'd have some
trouble in making out case. Cir.
cumstances Is something. but they
amt everything. you know"
Murgatroyd seemed satisfied. Now
he leaned toward Pemmican and said
eonfldentially:
''Pemmican, I want your testimony
IN this case. want II right. Have
rigarf"
Ton orA
You can depend on me. I'll tell the
truth, the whole truth and nothing but
the truth. 81 help me- His gaze re-
turned again to the pigskin wallet on
the desk. But, say, never saw that
thing before"
Murgatroyd picked UP the wallet
"Pemmican. suppose | were to ill
this with-weli. say. $4,000 and give
1t to you" he said loudly. how would
you testify in this case. eh?"
But" protested Pemmican. Il new
er saw $4,000 In it. No.
NO" repeated Murgatroyd. 'sbut II
you should right now hare It flled
with $4,000. how would you testify
for mey'
Pemmiqan stolidly shook his head
and answered:
ITO the truth. counselor. I'm an
honest man."
Murgatroyd still persisted.
How much would you take. Penn |
mican." he went on. Ito swear that
Challoner did not commit this crimeY |
Pemmican started back in alarm and
once more shook his head.
Counselor. I'm an honest man." he I
answered doggedly.
Murgatroyd gave 1t up az bad job.
You're honest. all right. Pemmican,"
he said. You must go back now. but /
The Richmond Virginian. (Richmond, Va.) 1910-1920, 1910-04-13
DAINTY FROCK FOR CHILD


be
children
The Detroit times. [volume] (Detroit, Mich.) 1903-1920, 1910-05-30
BALLINGER's LAWYER
DENoUNCEs PINCHoT EFT AL
Attorney vertrees Says There Was No
inference Of Wrong Doing In Bal
liners Service.

WASHINGTON, May 2s.--A vigor-
Gus defense of Secretary of the Inter
Tor Ballinger's policy in regard to the
Cunningham claims as Single mind
Ell, honest and straightforward. was
the basis of the argument today be-
fore the congressional investigating
committee by Attorney J. j. Vertrees,
counsel for the Defense"
The Tennessee lawyer bitterly ar
ralgned that Pinchot- Carrie ld-Glavis
OUTFIT" denounced them as foolish
Missionaries and held up Secretary or
the Interior Ballinger as a public ser
want without a peer.
Vertrees declared that there had
never been presented to the land Of
fee a more valid claim than that OF
the Cunninghams. He insisted that
even IL Ballinger had been censurable
for grossly unethical conduct In draw
ing an AFFIDAVIT for Clarence Cunning
ham, the committee has no Jurisdic-
ton to investigate that matter. On
the other hand, he declared, there was
no inference Of misconduct In Bal
fingers services to the claimant.
He denounced Garfield scathingly as
being the tool OF Pinchot. He declar-
ed that when Garfield found that he
was not to be secretary under the
new administration, he grew revenge
full.
"Pinchot. Pinchot the pure. control
led Garfield Just as he pleased" Yer
trees cried. Everything that was wild
with reference TO a tree or a reserve
he did at Pinchot's direction"
The Detroit times. [volume] (Detroit, Mich.) 1903-1920, 1910-05-30
ROOSEVELT SAYS HIS
VIEWS HAVE NOT CHANGED
In Letter to Leading Insuraent He
Practically Endorses Fight Against
Speaker Cannon.

WASHINGTON, May 2S.-At the
capitol today representative OF the
United Press was shown a letter just
received from Theodore Roosevelt
practically endorsing the fight against
Speaker Cannon and the house or
ganization and inviting one OF the
most influential insurgents to meet
him In New. York after his arrival
Coupled with this comes the an
nouncement today on excellent author
fly that Roosevelt has accepted an in
yitation to be the guest OF honor at
a banquet, June %, TO be given by
Robert J. Collier. editor OF Golfers
Weekly, which has made such a bit
ter fight against Secretary Ballinger
and the present administration. The
significance of these two indications
as 10 Roosevelt's present attitude i'm
pressed itself deeply on insurgents
and regulars at the capitol
The letter was in answer to a nine
page exposition OF the insurgent posi-
ton sent to Roosevelt. There are
only Ave lines In RooseveIt's reply
He says In effect:
"You know my views on the insur-
gent situation. They have not. changed
since last talked with you. I wish
to see you In New York Immediately
after my arrival"
The Detroit times. [volume] (Detroit, Mich.) 1903-1920, 1910-05-30
SAYS USE OF KNIFE ON
WOMAN WAS UNNECESSARY
Jury In Tecumseh Returns Verdict In
Death Of Miss Anna Kineaid. OF
Three Rivers.

TECUMSEH, Mich, May 2S.-The
jury has returned a verdict setting
forth the belief that Miss Anna Kin
caid, OF Three Rivers, came TO her
death ''as the result Of an unnecessary
operation performed by Dr. Grin X.
Thompson, of Chicago, assisted by a
woman known to US as Nellie Brott,
and who acted as nurse during Miss
Kincaids illness" The organs Of the
exhumed body. which were sent TO
Lansing, have not yet been reported
on, but when the body was removed
from the grave in the Tecumseh GENE
terry a wound So by s inches was
found, the left breast having been re-
moved. II Is said the treatment was
for cancer.
Miss Kincaid left her home at
Three Rivers, where she had spent the
greater part OF her life, and went to
Chicago on the morning OF March q,
No one knew where she was going and
not until nine days later did her
become known. On that
day a letter arrived at Three Rivers
asking that a tin box containing life
insurance policies and bonds aggre-
eating $4,000 which had been In a
savings bank be sent to her address
at once.
The Detroit times. [volume] (Detroit, Mich.) 1903-1920, 1910-05-30
LOVE AFFAIR LEADS TO
CELL IN POLICE STATION
John kuIz Raises Rumpus Because
Rival Wins Out and Police Are
Called

John kuIz Raises Rumpus Because
Rival Wins Out and Police Are
Called
John Kulz loved In vain, and his
little affair Of the heart landed him
in police court Saturday morning.
This sad circumstance was due largely
to the fact Johns rival in love, one
Valentine Styka. OF No. 1862 Military
ave-, was already welded TO the oo-
ject of Johns love.
Kulz had vowed the wedding would
never take place. In his pocket he
had an iron slug, which the police
say was intended for Valentines
head. Friday night Kulz repaired TO
the saloon conducted by the father
of the adored one at No. 996 Military
ave.
In heated terms, he told the saloon
keeper that Valentine would be dead
before he should wed the the girl.
But while John was regaling him.
self with strong drink, thus putting
himself in proper frame OF mind
for a meeting with his hated rival.
said hated rival was being quietly
married to the girl. The ceremony
was performed In Valentines resi-
dence.
John proceeded to demonstrate his
chagrin In such a forcible manner
that Motorcycle Officer Thoma !
Creedon was called.
He placed Kulz and one John Mig.
| due under arrest. Police Justice JET.
fries placed the hearing for next Tues
! day
The Detroit times. [volume] (Detroit, Mich.) 1903-1920, 1910-05-30
Doc Show at state Fair.

Dog fanciers will be pleased 10 learn
that the state fair management has
closed arrangements with the ST. Clair
Kennel club. a newly.formed local or.
ranization to conduct a big dog show
I'm connection with the state fair Sept.
1924. The show will be under the
auspices and rules Of the American
Kennel club. and the best judges oh
tainable will make the awards. Be.
sizes the customary ribbons there will
be cash prizes and special cups in
various classes. One OF the main
buildings on the Midway will be de-
voted exclusively to the dog show and
there will be over 500 dogs in the ex.
hibition.
The Detroit times. [volume] (Detroit, Mich.) 1903-1920, 1910-05-30
WILL GO UP LIGHT.
Big Carriers viii Try To Make Trip
Rather Than Wait for Coal careoes.

CLEVELAND, o., May ga few
boats are wanted at the head OF Lake
Superior 10 take wheat to Buffalo at
the market at that figure. A number
OF big carriers will be sent up the
lakes light today rather than wait
two days for coal cargoes and there
will be some delay at ore loading
ports in the early part OF next week.
Some OF the ore carriers that arrive
at Lake Erie ports today will be held
over the double holiday Dock man
ayers say there, will be a big jam at
this end OF the route Tuesday. Lum
Der carriers are having trouble getting
cargoes.
The Detroit times. [volume] (Detroit, Mich.) 1903-1920, 1910-05-30
MAURER BROTHERS FINED
FOR AsSAULTING GEO. CLARK
Latter Claims That His wife FIRE.
quentiy Visits One Of the De-
fendants-Sues for Divorce.

Joseph Maurer was fined $25, with
the option OF 60 days In the House
of Correction, and William Maurer was
fined $40, with the option OF 80 days,
In Police Justice STEMS court, Satur-
day morning, for assault and battery
upon George Clark. who lives on
Clark said that his wife was con-
stantly going to visit Joseph Maurer
at No. 539 Catherine-st. He says he
with her for this and
that on one occasion last week. he
Swallowed her to the above address.
Clark was crouched In front of the
residence, when he was discovered by
the Maurer brothers and by Edward
Marx. brother-in.law Of the Maurers.
They jumped on Clark and beat him.
Marx was acquitted Of the charge.
Clark has fled suit for divorce.
The Detroit times. [volume] (Detroit, Mich.) 1903-1920, 1910-05-30
Headache

my father has been sufferer from sick
headache for the last twenty Eve years and
never found any relief until he began
taking yonr Cascarets. Since he has
begun taking cascarets be has never had
re headache They have entirely cured
HIN. cascarcts do what you recommend
lI,s.n 20 do. ! viii give you the privileges
al ntinr his name ,"--E M. Dickson,
+, - Resl1cr ST.. w. Indianapolis, Ind.
b>.,1ss frlss.sls, Potent. r..,. Coed.
~ 49, 80. Never cold q b1lk The gen.
..,s . -, SsssS sssE Is
The Detroit times. [volume] (Detroit, Mich.) 1903-1920, 1910-05-30
For 2 Short Hours Only
Tuesday From g Toll
Women S Coats
$8.75
Thar IRE Actu1Up U0rtk $40
That Are ActaaLy Worth $40

No if you have already bought Summer Coat
should make point the remarkable values shall
Tuesday morning AS coats will be extremely
this and distinct styles will be required for
various occasions
materials there is choice of Pongee and Taeta Silks
English light Covert and plain twiled Sege in black and
the most desirable we'll Shepherd pads Both full
length models be had with long rolling
notch enriched with little touches OF braid and
fancy buttons. COME PREPARED TO BUY TUESDAY:
YOU'LL FIND EVERY COAT A WONDER BARGAIN, but
come early for there only so the collection Second
Floor
The Detroit times. [volume] (Detroit, Mich.) 1903-1920, 1910-05-30
Golden Business Opportunities" Is

Golden Business Opportunities" IL
the title Of the Grand Trunks latest
publications, issued by the commits
sIoner OF industries. II Is a concise
treatise on business openings In
Western Canada, and contains a fund
OF facts and valuable information. A
Quarterly Bulletin" has also been t..
sued, which tells OF specific business
openings In Western Canada for the
cobbler or coal dealer. llyeryman or
laundry man. baker or banker, law
yer. doctor or general merchant
These publications may be had for
the asking. Apply to q. w. Watson,
l24 woodward.ave.. Detroit, Michigan.
The Detroit times. [volume] (Detroit, Mich.) 1903-1920, 1910-05-30
Four Concerns File Articles.

Articles Of incorporation were fled
Saturday by the following concerns:
East Side Realty Co., capital $25, 900.
cash paid in $4,000: @. Storz & Co
who will deal in oils. capital. $500,
cash paid in, $2,vv0: Precision Instru.
ment Co., capital. $4,000, cash pail
in, $4,000; Stanley Power Wagon Co,
capital. $4,000. cash maid In. SZ.vU0.
The Detroit times. [volume] (Detroit, Mich.) 1903-1920, 1910-05-30
plays With Matches: Fatally Burned.

Playing with matches in the absence
of her mother, two-yearold Clara
Ruckowski was probably fatally
burned in her home, No. 29S Thirty.
second-st., Saturday morning. The
mother had gone to a nearby grocery
store, leaving the baby in the care OF
her four-year-old son. DR.. r. J. Sa.
bowski. No. 1927 Michigan-ave.. who
attended the child, says there is bur
n slight chance for her recovery.
The Detroit times. [volume] (Detroit, Mich.) 1903-1920, 1910-05-30
Tuqmen CO On Strike.

ASHTABULA, o., May 2S.-with a
large feet OF freighters waiting, every
harbor tug of the Great Lakes Tow.
ing company az this port was put out
OF commission yesterday. A disagree.
ment between the tug management
and the firemen early, resulted In Are
men on all tugs refusing 70 work.
The Detroit times. [volume] (Detroit, Mich.) 1903-1920, 1910-05-30
May Finance Turkish Projects.

NEW YORK, May 2s.-Turkey is
likely to be the latest country opened
up by American capital. Representa-
tives OF J. p. Morgan & Co., Kuhn,
Loeb & Co., and the National City
and First National banks are now con.
sidering a proposal from the Turkish
government TO finance big railroad
projects in the empire and the con-
struction OF mammoth water works.
tramways and similar public projects
I'm the various cities.
The Detroit times. [volume] (Detroit, Mich.) 1903-1920, 1910-05-30
Two injured When seaffoId Falls.

J. B. Patterson. No. 1s4l Vinewood.
ave-, and ]. L. Hickey, No. 1249
Twenty-third-st.. were injured Satur.
day morning, when the scaffold on
Woodland-ave.. gave way. Both men
were taken to their homes.
The Detroit times. [volume] (Detroit, Mich.) 1903-1920, 1910-05-30
DENIES BAssETTs STORY.
Master Of Steamer Siemens Says He
Did All He Gould for Goodyear Crew.

Master Of Steamer Siemens Says He
Did All He Could for Goodyear Crew.
PORT HURON, May 2s.--A general
denial Of the statement credited TO r.
II. Bassett, steward of the steamer
Goodyear, that the Siemens did NOT
offer aid TO the drowning crew OF the
former boat, is made by Capt Nc.
Elroy, OF the Siemens, in a letter re.
ceiyed here.
Capt. McElroy says life preservers
were thrown to the victims OF the
wreck and everything possible done to
save them, but the efforts were ham
pered by the heavy fog. Capt. Gibson.
OF the steamer Wood, will testify In
confederation OF Capt McElroy's state
ment
The Detroit times. [volume] (Detroit, Mich.) 1903-1920, 1910-05-30
MIIwaukes otfieIaI seeks INFORMATION.

Herman c. Schultz, assistant city
clerk Of Milwaukee, was In the city
|Gaturday, looking over the city's
method of keeping its accounts and
osking for suggestions with the OBJ
sect Of lettering the system used in
his home city. He has been In Pitts,
burg and Cleveland. For Cleveland
and Detroit, he had nothing but praise,
hut with reference to the methods I'm
vogue In Pittsburg, he declared sim.
lnly: The less said the better"
The Detroit times. [volume] (Detroit, Mich.) 1903-1920, 1910-05-30
New speclmens for Aquarium.

r. ]. Conway, director OF the Belle
Isle aquarium. has returned from e
trip to the Atlantic ocean, where no
went fishing for specimens for the
aquarium. He procured more than "a
score OF deep-sea animals and fish. in.
oladinR n sea lion.
The Detroit times. [volume] (Detroit, Mich.) 1903-1920, 1910-05-30
ATTICA CITIZENS DENY.
Man Arrested On Charge Of Using
Mails to Defraud Not Known Here.

ATTICA. Mich, May 2S.-The peo-
pie of this place are incensed over the
report that there is headquarters for
counterfeiters here. z. A. Starkloff
and George w. Post are under arrest
In Philadelphia on a charge of con-
spiracy and using the mails to de-
fraud.
IL is alleged Starkloff mailed letters
from here offering to furnish spurious
government notes. No such man is
known here.
The Detroit times. [volume] (Detroit, Mich.) 1903-1920, 1910-05-30
nIerlot FILea 60 MlIes-

PARIS, May 2s.--Louis Bleriot to-
day new IN his aeroplane from Tours
a. Etamps, 90 miles The flight was
not timed
The Detroit times. [volume] (Detroit, Mich.) 1903-1920, 1910-05-30
sAcINAws POPULATION $4,000.

SAGINAW, Midk, May 2S.-(Spe-
cial) Saginaw population is given
az 10000. against $4,000 ten years ago
Bay Cltys population Is $4,000.
The Detroit times. [volume] (Detroit, Mich.) 1903-1920, 1910-05-30
hMuSE M ENTs.
TEMPLE B ss. cn RsTsa'' seats
CARNIVAL, OF ROSES"
NaudeviIle's Most BeautifuI Pnntomi'
On pIcnpIE

20 PEOPLE.
Claud G. Fannie Usher: Hoey Lee;
Four Readings; Belle Davis Il Picks
Cross & Josephine; Hastings * WILSON,
Saona: Microscope Pictures
NEAT wEEK-Fio Irwin q Co. I'm
Geo. AIDES Masterpiece, "Mrs. Peck
han's Cnrouse."
Martinsburg statesman-democrat. [volume] (Martinsburg, W. Va.) 1906-1921, 1910-01-07

Wheeling W. Va, Jan. l.-Con-
gresham William P. Hubbard is a
candidate fer the United States Sem
ate against his fellow tswAsman
Nathan =. Scott.
No authorized statement has ~ yet
come from Mr.. Hubbard, but last nigh
all his close political friends freely ad-
mittsd that the candidacy had been
anally decided upon.
Several followers Of the Congress.
man have made the positive statement
that the Hubbard candidacy ihad be-
come political fact. At the Mcclure
last light nothing else was talked
about iby the politicians who make
the hotel their gossip exchange clear
ing house.
From ia sclose friend of Congress-
man Hubbard 1t il learned that he
will make strong demand for state
wide primary on the senatorship, Nj
the only fair and square method Of de-
termining between him land Senator
Scott and the other candidates for the
Senate who are expected TO follow the
Hubbard entry into the big battle OF
/ 1910.
! The Hubbard people are cenfiden,
at least they claim to be confident, OF
the result. They declare they will have
most Of the southern section Of the
! state provided no local candidate
pears. AS to Msnn, they claim to have
assurances that he will not be candi.
date at this time, though he may enter
the list tive years later against Elkins.