The sun., 1910-06-28

We wish 70 do our duty toward securing
justice. and no more. n the 0overnmen
shall decide to eNtradits him on Italy
request We will release him and he can h
rearrested and taken before q UniteC
states Commissioner
Jud e. Paul Charlton. father Of IN,
prisoner. came hack 90 New York very
quietly last night He saw no one hu
he counsel. ex-senator Edwards. and hil
cons counsel. r Floyd Clarke
II was evident YESTERDAY that the Law,
yers defending Charlton depended al
most wholly upon the hitch between the
State Department and Italy over the
extradition treaty to save Charlton. r
Floyd Clarke insisted that the defenoe
would take no advantage " teChni-
cAlities.
-Charltnn's arrest A. he came oH the
steamship he sad. was illegal and
without warrant of iaw "a anv lawyer
knows There was nothing ~ holdhim on
We could have got hun az once with
q writ of fabeas corntR and smuggled
him tn safety had We been depending
on techniCahties and had Judge Charlton
not sorupled "a do such "A thing But his
father would not hear of II Instead
of squeezing him % liberty we have not
eEertsd ourselves at all but have allowed
him 10 be Imprisoned tO await the laws
orderly action
Knowing this boy's anteoedents II
n inconccivahle 10 us that he could have
done murder tnless h. were insane We
are endeayOring g. ascertain n he ~
To do - will take some time yet
II he Is insane he surely ought not % be
extradited Therefore We will ask that
the hearing in his case he set over tor
while
A consultation was held yesterday
between Emil + Fuchs. Capt SCOTS
lawyer. the Italian Consul, SignOr di
Rosa and his lawyer. Umherto Mosseli
County Prosecutor Garven and his as
aistant. George T Yickers. az which the
course ~ events az tO-davs hearing was
outlined The Italian Consul promised
% present evidence ~ tho crime and Of
the request ior extraditl6n. the County !
Prosecutor said be- would show Charl- |
tons relation - the crime and Lawyer |
Fuchs explained Capt Scott's plans
II was agreed that Charlton must ne |
held prisoner The County prOsecu- =
TOR wishes u hold him the essential sixty /
days The Italian Consul cOncurs. for |
by that time a decision will have been |
reached about eNtraditiOn or else Il will /
become impossible through lapse u time
Lawyer Fuchs said that. acting Tor Capt l
SCOTT he would try n have Charlton /
held for sixty days II by the end Of |
that time he Is eXtradited well and good
II eXtradition falls through. as Is eH-
pected Capt Scott and his LAWYER will I
try their hest 20 have Charlton ad Judged
insane and committed % a public asylum
and not 10 some private institution II
he shall az any time be declared sane
they will endeavor 20 have him extradited.
whether Il he month or years from
now
Charlton himself IL worse than ever.
according 10 DR. William Jerome Arhtz. !
police surgeon and insanity expert re-
tanned by Judge Charlton. DR.. Arlitz
saw Charlton yesterday as he has every
day since his arrest DR. Arhtz was the
only visitor the prisoner had all day
Judge Charlton arrived In town too late
last night TO see his son
Dr.. Arlitz said that Charlton had not
recovered m any way from his nervous
breakdown of Sunday night The nhysi-
ciAn had already declared him 10 he
suffering from dementia adolescens
Yesterday he went further and said that
i was not only dementia adolescens,
form ot paranOia, but denentis adoles-
nens OF the confessional tyne In addi- I
hon 20 This. according 20 Dr. Arlity. ha
e victim of neurasthena and n tuber.
culOsis in the penultimats stage. The {
1octor said yesterday that amid All Of ,
,hess diseases Charlton showed unmis-
lakable symptoms Of belated hebaohra-
Ma. which is the insanity of puheacencs
l8e added that Charlton was az all times !
psychotic a. well as neuro-
1c. The two other alienists DR. Edward
J. Fisher and DR. Charles l. Dana. are
'pheotic ana will not express any opinion I
or several DAYS.
But the pathology Of self did not con-
ern Charlton Yesterday. He apent the :
lay waking and sleeping IN the same q
'ereistent dare. his eyes directed mostly :
4 the ceiling. He slept soundlv and ate a
veil. He read and made some progress
nth his poem.
Charlton Converasd with his celI mate. {
Jllie Burke. the saiebl0wer. due 10 serve
even years. Title Burke zaid n Deputy C
Warden Devhn that Charlton made him n
lervous II,
During his examinations when he gets
rrought un'' asked Devlin
Examination grInted Burke les 4
ons :,
just what bothsrs you7' tho deputv u
FArden persisted 4
he is reciting poetry replied Burke 4
nth rlaintIve AIR. Hes asking me :
bout y and am not used n poetry Il a
isconcerts me
Charlton came up about this time and =.
ned
Warden. I want you % listen n this d
have been working n over In my head =.
/ 10 not good. hut I want your opinion
u promises well for labor ,
Ayou n uaharp, ~ W. shall des,roy Z,
moment hath Of deep. trsnslrreat Iov D
4 rnOnent brief and brilliant in Its ,t.v a