The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-09-04


'r..s .affr fsls.as. DO a.Irs--.. =.
f.ar.t $50 go .s-.fsrsf.f '...s. a..
..asr .a H..H#f .fUa.a a
.rsrt.sss Isss..r 81 f..s ..... "a
ts ..ssrsf H % ..a .-a. =
~sr-rf
~ H.H asH .F.f
Hf % "a .H...a
10 .H.....F
e.. .s
o. .as.n +H. Hars .a ....
....af.E.H1. # #H .a
tfas frrs rH.ffI .s..H. s#.. lei.
aH..H HH..s .H
81 IIas.H r...a'laf f.HH #."
800 "f=s-Hf f.r....H ...
HHsa..a .HIa ..fF. ..a
s.#H a".f |.# ...#. ".. ....
coo #asI-taIfssr rf.fs .HI
n frlHfrr H- sa.i-f .sH.aH.... . I'd.
...e-rrHarf W.H-a .- ....
f...e-r#HHrrF Haa rra-rfssf ....
.fst "Hsfffv frtrr"f HH HH. .
go #..|rF .Hz srtr.a.l # cot .. 4
f..ifl.i Hs4f fra ss s a."..saf .. ...-.
sl.H t as #tH Ha sf.a.HF
f1.H rfar sFHt .fa.faIl.n .I.I .s "H.. .
UFH roo 20 enc rsa1r..s t. ..sr... ..asa.t
q #..1fr. fs .iHI T.f even |.s..as %,
r.lsrr.sI ri ...|a. i s1.I .H.sar ....
emo ftHfa fol .r..H.I 90 ..f .ras ..f .
atH.u Hs rarH.sI s.#. ..I ...H l.
HI-.-I Nf.ra.#Hr w. ua-a..r .....,
t. though bel #.fa fH. tIfr .f s.. H..,
Its-If sH .-rt-itf- aH.t atHr-Hrer tIsa d
disregard no facts 20 q 49, ~f-----.
r tFina. ms -urH ti-r~gnr.i 'srfs =,
q EN- i-nt legislation
tn. frame q u.rt sfHrs -'a.s,
through HI- remarks .1 r--r~r' 2 -
torhh=r at-a ~ 'h. eject that go s.
pF-fn- tu4rt
~. m. s-ssufs ras.r - ST pew. rr-t -
HHIs~ FOOL Hs rrrIeliirI
- slls pu~yr Z. 'r dstsrr1 ra So
shatIs. rr not there has bs.sn on ,h4.s
and secondly. sHath-r fh- las covers u.
abuse ~. Supf-w. court has POI r1s-r
20 permit nr upi % - -tH anything -
.oI- poser - 'r interpret tho las ant 40.
ply 10 - interpreted o. tn" fact. a., uruy~i
But Mr. Roosevelt -ay. 40 ana 'h-a
-ruut- 40 the theory ct liberty 'H -.
tract. 20 90 with your person ant yrr
work - You Will - long ~ 10 49, MI,
munitv. notwithstanding tho tact ma,
tia, liberty - tn" fundamental considsra.
ton - Tho democratic strIggl" f0r the
last To- years
So again he u.-. these wor,iz
Their ~. -. o. r~ruIr ,cupo ry no sr,,. -.
reilr-i ~ Iupo'~Hcr ne or.y roHb which %
have poWrr
Tho supreme Court 81 the United STATE.
has no discretion whatever boz rr-p.ct u
permitting action by the state II 10 not
q permitting body. nor yet body that can
REFUSE - permit It, function - 90 con.
-tru~ state law and determine Wh"ther
or not ~ fails within or without thu pro-
visions - IN. national Constitution look.
ing t. that very natInuali-n which Mr.
Roosevelt - now advocating and IN
thus case. not believing i'srf - -
leg -ia'ive body. and entertaining very
different theory - orderly government
from that entertained by Mr. Roosevelt.
., merely decided that the liberty pro-
footed ~ the Federal Constitution wAs
impaired and IN view ~ IN" fact that The
at was doubtful. that ~ would XIV" -hh-
erty- the h"n"f Of the doubt
NJ Roosevelt concludes his attArs by
Chara "t"rlSing th"--' two cases n. Icing
In -9agrant and direct contradiction 20 he
spirit and needs ~ the times The spirit
and need 81 tho times - legality. possibly
now more than ever before II the Sa-
preme court - 20 usurp IN" function II
Congress and adopt Nj Roosevelt per-
sonal view instead " the historic consti-
tutInnal view. th"n the more hySt~ricA
and consequently the NOR" dangerous he
state ~ the public mind ta given moment
that hysteria j. 20 10 adjudicated into lAw
IN disregard of TIRE permanent welfare ct
the nation.
This 10 tho ultimate and necessary ir-
plication 81 Mr. Rooseyalt's teaching. and
as such Rs ! said NJ the beginning. 70
nothing less than revolutionary.
W VI IvINs.
NV YORK September :?