New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1910-11-18

for which Louis W Winans paid $4,000 in
1868. earned some interest on the invest
1ncnt for the first time yesterday afternoon
in one OF the breeding classes at the horse
show N Madison Square Garden. Mr.
Winans thus taCitIy admitted that the win
ner of the Great American Handicap at
Readville two years ago has been retired
from light harness racing. Mr.. Winans
campaigns a stable Of tTotters on the Con-
tinent and although ne started Allen Win
ter several times he was handicapped so
heavily on his American record that he
failed 20 get in the money.
The six trotting stations entered in the
opening class were the attraction Of the
morning. They included last years win
ner, Mograzia, owned by Miss X. L. Wilks.
Of Canada: Sir Robbins and Roouefort
Mograzia had to hand over the laure1s to
Allen Winter yesterday and be content with
a red ribbon
The Thoroughbred class for stations
brought out a fine lot which included ten
from the Canadian Bureau Of Breeding
This Is the first time that thoroughbreds
have come across the border to compete
and Masterman. a son of Hastings-Lady
Margaret, bred in this country by August
Belmont. carried away the first prize
Major W A Wadsworths Shot Gun, which
won in the same class last year. was de-
throned by the newcomer, but he accepted
second honors with the best possible grace.
After sending Lord Baltimore from the
ring twice since the show opened once for
kicking IN a class where manners were
especially considered and once because he
showed signs Of Iameness. the judges took
him back into favor once more. Shown
with Ny Maryland to pole. he defeated two
of Judge Afoore's entries ard Dignity and
Manhattan. from the stable of Paul A.
Sorg- When one Of the judges was ques-
toned in regard to the matter he replied
that he had never seen them GO better in
their lives.
It looked almost as though the judges
had esta blished a precedent when they re-
! versed their decision in Class 10 A which
vas judged on Tuesday and was decided in
| favor of None Nicer with Fairy Queen sec
ona- A protest proved that None Nicer
bad not been registered. and the first choice
/ fell Fairy Queen But that was not
all for the following day, in judging hunt
/ ers in Class 40. Lieutenant Geoffry
/ BTOokes English mare Alice gave spIen-
/ did performance and yet failed to gain any
! recognition from The judges When II
! finally was brought to the notice of the
! Judges they made an official announcement
! stating that the absence of Alice from the
! lisL of prize winners was due to an over
sight on the part of the judges, who
promptly laid the question before the ex-
/ ecUtive committee Of the National Horse
/ Show Association, with the statement that
Alice had scored equally as well as May
! fair which took second prize. James T
/ Hyde. the secretar-, announced yesterday
1 morning that the executive committee
would do something more substantial than
! express regret for the oversight and would
/ present 4 cup as an extra prize TO Lieu
tenant Brooke.
/ Lady SeatCn was quite Irresistible in the
| ladies' phaeton class and one disput-
! ed the Judgment Of the three men in the
! ring when they placed her ahead of the
brilliant Lord Baltimore. Mrs, A Z. Kel-
Ter drove the Moore entry, and before she
had circled the tanbark half dozen times
she was called into the centre Of the ring
which station means the approval of the
judges Next came Lord Baltimore. with
Mrs. c. ". Watson at the .reins; then
/ Manhattan. with Mrs. Belle Beach Balm in
! tho drivers seat and lastly Miss Caroline
! Bryce, driving ROYAL Victoria Mrs. Ju-
lius Walsh with that good little geding
Honor Bright. and Miss Ellen Rasmussen.
driving Alfred Vanderbilts Queens Favor.
were among those who failed 10 score
No one outside the Enclosure had the
least idea as TO how the judges arrived at
2 conclusion in the saddle class for horses
under fifteen hands It was by Some sub
tie process of elimination for after sending
from the ring Glass Doll. Sarno. Martini
Sunshine and Directoire, they picked Atter-
ton bay gelding. from the stable of Will
lam McGihbon to wear the blue Mr. Nc
C:ihfon has owned many champions but
Attention does not appear to he in class
with hem.
The awards in fun follow
Class hackney stations. Years old or oyer.
1':1 hands and over first prize. sl5o. second
Mackay's en-. : Land O i}-lrns- by Matthias,
second, Reginald g Ns1derhlt's n. Tiger
Lille by Fashion. third Fiorhan stud Farm :
n : Lord Marlborough. by ,;aurnlede. fourth
, George r Brews1er's hr- Cudham Gentleman.
Class champion hackney stations in com
y lhr hloraes the property - IN @p1er1 FL
/ JVilliam whites Oh. $. oxford hv Cadet
class urotting stations four years old OF
over. first pTlze. $40. second prize, SIS; third
! Alien winter ~ t-d Winter; second. Miss n
: l. Wflkss b :. Moerszia ny Moko. third. Ho
fourth James T. Haines's b R0quefort by
Mokc-
z class thoroughbred stations three years old
or over; hrst prize SEQ second prize, 500;
third prize, SOU tsl' n : Masternan, b,
? ! II+inys exhibited by the Canadian %atlonal
bureau Of Breeding le,.,, second. Major " A
= " tdsS 3. Gray's CHI = Advance e;,iaL,i
al,rh Henry Rea : ch- :. raokenthorpe
lass le2 SADDLE horses over 10 hands ,
: aS I'D or over up TO carrying 100 pounds
< geaIs sc 500. second prize. $40. rhtrd ,,riza
81 Hen Rea "a En- -, m Indian Flower:
= secoh";; IRA Nor IS ch. z. Lord AIr,-. fcnrtb
Mss fMTsecIb1oas blk Three ebe.rs 'o'' H.
class 90 pairs OF Shetland and ponies registered
not *, "a. third prize, s2o,-First Mrs = q
prize 81 h. Aberdeen II ptttsford and Rres
Hswles Is!ttzfn-d. second. Miss tiraee :, w.
say OF t'rolic and Dame Fortuna fhrd How
br. ms ctarrprt's Blk. Besuty ana Hnstar
Brow" "a .pairs Of mares seldings. lo Ia
! / Class ,,rs hrougharns. horses to comm ~
shown proug halas - per cent harness. Is