davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-10-10
LOBERT F,ST BisE mN>ER.
cincinnati Hail PLAYER wakes Record an
the patlgN

go, I>',rI. CO., % NNe- 'ha PIrtsburg.
'.urIuus'' bah gam" rE>dAv there va. a
'".d meet iisu- obafr ~ tho Reds wa
timed m ~ t.i -n,rrd- n circuit II the
nl - breaking fHa racUrt for this feat by
.u".'i'r "f second lhr record was
IUH.r' The ,HuInuAf man al-p ran
Is' '1f'- ~ %" 'Hr' % % pa - nall sat and
-uu"- ti- 1ifr" 'H- gI'ru - IG second.
lu '"" 'f-' Ir.aI. r|uuItR Tho base 10th
lp'..r' 1ud tHWrN.I' uf pi''-bury made A.
seconds awTp"lI .u-r N tho rIn IN
10 long 4 -fau'" rhrntIng sheldon Ts-
.".ua uf ~" ESan-NIIlv Central ! sagu.
team made 80 feet me H,,~ - i.st Iu,h
better Than John iiafrS'H record male
'HHr'F wears ago IN fgu trials again.,
mo end N' faIi.b q" bSs' me record Ittt
Hf'H o." " nd 900 h'- iaNvt 10 fy.o more trfals
Nr smashed the old max 'nIu. ms rrat
80 ur' going ini feet IUtbe~
BOO b" "rut and run ~ rr-' contest ."hert
Hn4 Miller of cincinnati 'Isd. zach making
70 Hnd- uuo-'ifu NJ = -s.ruuft Ialarr
-'. r.t"rd Iu fI" fHsP tt'ftuu ,4ut.-t
I..H Rowan Won sIfr W 'e.f o.. n he
"n.l t"H- no. com" Un1T ~" record made.
.. NIrr MITCHELL 900 ~ Mitchell H.,
'.uu"'"d. hI' tal.~d FOB "ual l.~ pld mars
N'l'Hu won %" AGO.. r.tls throwing con.
f"-' 'uf ,t'.i.r- ',H-rtI " va If be- uttrh..r. To-
control .nu'"-. ruu ra~trrt won tu f..
.....H '.rr. u- ,.u'"y' Tor u.IfH.ld.r-
Mos u' '.' r"u,h'r- nv hu.N fI, T|ff-
'.rr COO. .u.|ruH'. ...l.N ,nmu.'sd
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-10-10
SOCCFR.
Cisn MeDenalds Defeat the HoIIyu cod,
In Amateur League s:ama.

A. Marquette oval BROOKLYN yestsrdsv
Clan Mcdonald Of BROOKLYN. champion. on
the New York Amateur Association Zoo,
hall League. encountered the Hollywood
Inn eleven Of Eonker-, holders Of the cham.
pion-hip for 1909. in the second round OF ths
nrst division series. ~ he two teams we're
tied for the lead the interest was especially
keen After fine struggle the CIan
McDonalds won goals ~ q
shortly after plsy began fythgoe scored
for the Clans from nice centre from King.
This proved 20 he the only goal scored -
thi- period After the reStart IN. i,oiIw ~
woods took possession Of the ball and Nro,,id
have scored but for the f,ns work on WiIson
~ EoaI, Tor me home team Three minutes
before the end Of the game uastis inside
right Of the Clan McDouald- scored the ma
goal Of the day from a pass N ~ Ross
The cameron Football club defeated the
Columbia eleven ~ Van Cortlandt psTk
Yesterday afternoon. 2 goals 20 ir a fast
Tai". ,nr minhi" after plRv started 4
Wander WeEhe scored for the Columhias
the hail being passed from Iurren az on side
left few minutes later Goodman so,,a-
nred for the aver after a nice ,sntr.
by scott. I'ennt~on, centre for th, Came
closed IN the second period Of play IIaVss
again tied the score after a lssautfstti mn
half the length ~ the field rh,. cameron
forward lne4 then took the of.uatv. anJ
BAILEY scored the winning goal after ~
up IN front OF the Columbia net
" variation oval. HrookIyn yaztardav
anernoon. IN" cameron Ke-~Ty~- took The
Af'7dia hi~il"- INTO cau'p. , - - Al Of
The goal- wsFs Tailed ~ M. ..goUd b.lT
" illtaUson scored two ~ them tar- 70.
credited With the ofn-r
w fhr -~"Nnu section league ra,, t,r.,-.t
~ Van t0rtlandt pHrk. The UrogsT,,p.
we're returned Tho vi'tpr- over ~. :,
George eleven. - Eosl- -
" Norrts Vars, Newark. Yesterday after
noon, the Newark Yield club jstss,sJ ~.
scotteh Americans. goal % 4. In a
hanoEAi league GAnAo.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-10-10
Rt'TNG ON TRE >PEEDW ~.
Inner Guard Gets HAM AZ wIImar- Other
Brushr. ~ the Day

thFr'c- W".1na's lUer Cuard .NS b..
Last N"dre-G,v. r. ~" opcrlng maj.
.r'" ~ o." $50 -or slowed Hank Xii
rt'rI.N'S Wuulr 10 Nat l.ul IN -'r,fgh,
heats hr ',ms ou' on no Speedway
Yesterday morning and terained ~ laurels
/ NIimar and 30 "v ret were no. willing 20
.uu, s'de defeat after ~lugla battle TvI,a
~" Two fi-t seldinss measured strides
nI' Inner t'uard had eyerythiug his own
nay eni .' Of - hs plso --d
l'".'" r. ||'.. DIT 1oi have h.- usual
-.'', ...'0 1r'u-a Nurpir.S rhestr,it trar'ar
Nir. '.a.. 'u' .r-t"9t h" trIsd 'onclu-
iriv WORTHY r"r,s, ..rricd the lad
90 br''sh - 49," ..r,tfef Iyps' ~ tho rr-i
newt nm ~" mar" stayed on her feet and
'r'''~e -tH"niid hslt 0.Ile hI"h would
nos" r",'"u ary'rtns l"-- speedy han
-" trt- r"'tin- >"nper NJ ~trlu- nor
lrtn"- SULLIVAN n1uJIsi IenNer while.
r'y NHr'hN .s- 10 NJ hands ~ Dave
= } o. rl7oo h. rs'hrnsd from Furor,c
eng b. hd Do. .'ne .I9'r" katc N"lson.
several brushes nnd NE VICE defeated
" A",' Id sp".1F NY :" ding I'r
ID. and when he beard Mr Eirv
-.EIng "r' 10 mS t'tIng, which j. b..
90. ~ squirting hun ~ -he wont ~ m
-. rfr and .ou'd rot r,1"h her stride as,IT
The hoU0rs we're "'st between thN.a ~ n
,I r.rnl- ,hrisophst TIA, Fe'ts', Who
Tine u''," mare va- ro' satisfied WIN a
o. -'I'. victor" 1'i 40 Wed 20 oIr tarid-
q 'ho-' Who s,p 'Ne. S6i~h TIA, She Vas
o n." - 'n 10. for 49," shove d ~. way from
,'rr' 'r .n.-N and i"d n" au -asy length
o." ,"u. ~ brought w new orc called
Er'It"f Nllr't nd %" 'pok good 'lrt
.. '.r r4,.rr ~ ars' Encounter va Win
Gro ed we'll matched VA The. ver. Ta.E
~. '"., rLrh' 'or . ', ~" 7nish l. hooked
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-10-10
EIGHT HITS, LAJOIE'S ADIEU
CLETELANDER mars LOOO IN
DAYS DOUBLE HEADER,
which -. Louis divides WITH Maps The
Detroits Heat white SOY American
LeaEuc schedule Comes 90 an End
mo Athletics 90 Course Won.

The American Tea que schedule vas
completed yesterday. The Athletics. who
won the pennant with 10, victories and a.
defeats. finished o. points ahead OF the
HiRhllnder-. The DetToit-. Who came IN
third Attributed their failure to "a -
pitching The boston Red SoO finished
a poor fourth. The Clevelands tried *
perinents and changes all the year aud
we're never seriously considered. rne chit
ago vi lts SoN got such poor start that
In spite % hne brace near the end 81 the
- mpaiLn they could not overhaul the
Clevelarids. The Washingtons At one tlm.
we'll vi In the Ts"e. did better than usual
bat weakened In the hst month The
~ Louis Browns. composed of inferior
material. we're never IN the hunt and Nerc
destined 10 be last from the outset
Larry layOie IN the doubl. header ye~teT-
day with the Browns cracked ont eight
hits in eight times up They say that gives
him the auto over " Iobb b. q small
margin. but only the official batting aver
ages Will prove that
~. LoUts "A. l.. 8 CLEVELAND. sHFiRsr o,Mr
1T LOrts Oct. 81 Louis and Cleveland
broke even In to days double header. The locals
taxing the nrst game. tn 4 and losing the sscond.
to a. lAiole's hitting MAS the feature IL
got eight hits In eight times al the bat and \
sacrifice. too The scores:
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-10-10
COIIDN'T iPPLrWHirITkNEW
That Was the TrouhIN With the Cornell
Team. Coach Reed says.

lrH,rN. oct. @ The team was afraid
to ~" the nsN foothsl V knew IN the game
against on"rhn and oou-aquen'ly failed
- score. ~a,d Dan E@vd. the Cornell coach
tu commenting on Saturdays result The
bows 'tN Get dvas from the old ~ L.
game. and that method NJ play il not pro-
uu"tlN" ~ results Iu mat the runner -
robbed ~ tu'erf renee an line pl'ugiur
W" ar" not h' >'orira grd but naturally
Disappointed ~ the wa The team
oIt nor get enough NNfk last wsek There
vvrr not enough ~ytt Uage- instead NJ
TOO mach work HvNslftsr vc are gong
?" HrN" them every afternoon. ant look
!oT = return % form
Ranges Iu the .lueDU are expected to-
WOrruH ~sagraNe VI, ~ coached IN the
signals aud On p8-NTne ~ that hs rau play
'"ufr" 10 good shape hHyt week He saved
90" tea. from 70 ~Hpfy but .. behind tn
Others 900 u"tr|pvw"Nf CHAMPAIGN Will
ltN" - NEir harder ~ hoid left guard and
Il".1r' - 20 be groor0cd for one of th-
'Htt - .pfu w|. nu ua'N IN The lfusup
10 '"r h1'f'H,k lvY,H viii pIl, lef end
rgh' along IN" '"1h got a good lesson
i's ,urtIus fhIns
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-10-10

the Quakers exhihhFd some aptitude in
tc, hntcal details and q good frame 81 md.
Another team that Appears tn have come
along considerably within a week - Dart
mouth cornell ami the NAVY ran into
Que at those -na ~ NhtCh generally com"
>h"uld drriN" much good FROM the expert
"n'e even Il tho, discovered that they
weren't A. good ~ 'uNr thought thrN we're
Nl'h glowing ac'NOnt- had been hratd
~ the Navy material that the team fail
IRE - scor. on RUtser~ va- the nearest
wt'n defeat and Michigan with = -lin,
iNfee points agaluNf ase are Neste rn
teams that emerge tTpnl Haftle IN a chss
tened frame of mtRd. brown Il travel
iittl" scoring ability, The PLAYING OF the
BrunoniapS has not Men In keeping appaT
emily With the Material
play m the HRCNRrd-Williams game
showed lack NJ knovIedIe of the rules
Williams man was tnr offender. one of
nr-t named man vEli@d for the mufer
- recover when uuusr the new T'ile~ he
had right To fall % " himself Last wear
this wasn't tho rule and the Williams man
~ N"wtpu. the " lI,taW- coach. says
nv 90" way, thai h. has no auATterbaCk
"" hp- u rishi and gtf hRiibsCk and n right
Hn' ."'' 'llltu,k klfh'r NJ the halfbaCk-
o. rs 'uhe the hal. frN'u the snapper back
'U fH, uN"u,r N. ioyt hark- take q semi
'he tN'r"wliIr- II thS Senicircie and the
''o f".'hsck- a foot Nr two further hack
srd II..i~ the 80 halfhacks Only in
having man 10 'al the signals Is there
= - Burr or M Harvard coaching
stan - 20 with tvphNjd fever az hts home
IN RrookiIue. Mass HIs illness wayinter-
Tor" With tho coachinE plans
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-10-10
CROSS-COgNTRY RI'NNING.
Week, spins of the Glencoe 4. e.. Morn.
InEside =. q. and Pcnnsnt A. 4.

The biggest of ye~terdays packs mus
tered ~ me t,lsncUe 4 &. Headquarters
A. I.u'h street near SECOND avenue and the
club 'ours" ~ aho az three and half
mlr- was covered after 'he runners
broke away through the crowds that lined
the roadway II. Crooks. who - now run
ming unattached. made tire pace for about
q mile soon aftervard Harry Jensen
the long distance man II he pastime 4 & .
put up steam snd vent INTO the lead FOR
a time he was pressed by George Hooley
81 the home club. Tom Nelson ~ the Irish
\ aud Tom harris a sturdy Glen
,oe runner Harris led for a shor' spell
after tho pack turned for home hut Jensen
drew ou' easily IN IN. last couple Of hun
dred wards and Won by fifteen yards from
HoOiey. The summary.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-10-10
J'OIO.
R-sls anal BIw~s PIAy nj RSckauay Hunt.
ting club, Former winning.

Crp,HHrE~r. T. I Oc' o Good polo
sa- PLAYED On the Geld 81 the Rorkauay
IluuiInE ,.uh ms WpT ming Team. from
IN" i.p'.tvav aui Meadow Broot clubs
crossed ualI.t-
he teams hnrd up - tho Reds and HIna-
on ne side ~ rho Reds vaz " tlltsm N
HayaId. SeNard tsrsv. Rene ~ NOntaEn~
4 = Noss. u Morgan. FoHhaU kesns
snd ID Martin. Jr. The REDS Won. - goals
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-10-10
American League Stsnhl1 4:
and-rbmt's Horses score In Franc.

.>1s,,ai CrbIs Drspr'.h FOO TN ~..
HNrt,. Oct . There v.rs fr r'sar
starters IN 'h" race for tho rriN d- 4. N..sd o.
a Boi~ q" BoulogH" rp.dty l- 500. vn-
hy Ruru-rhid'- Iemplsr NtuG.rn... .
~"-am" Ms uud. HLd to...,, Mar
Antp.u" fhfrl In. ...k ar- Arr. E.-..
b.N"Ill and " 0uflIauI
IN. rae" for o." rrfy SOM Ip.rau 20.
suited ~ a dead heat Ne'vH.. t.su,,s
t,raud S"ign"ur and NluIrrr.F.- IHufrs
lsNEl"r'- Made ~ England Nae .N.rl
u.' lo'kry- wen" H.nrN - Sell ana GtfU
here Nsfy ten - trFeT.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-10-10

Totals rs iU'2I 10 To'als ia y Il ,
None ont when winning run was made
Cleveland 10 ID a. 90 % Cd d. 4
~ Louis % % a. ~
Runs tlr' Gland Hruulie GranrN. Jackson
lAlOie - Louis Corridor orig. Hartyrll
:? Two base hits Jackson Corridrn t,rtyy.
GrAney stephens Three base hit- ia Ill,
Ortggs sacrifice MI stephens stolen base
brunkie, NioNal GHggs Wild pitch Handing
struck out By Nelson. d., Handing =
Len On basFs - l0uiS. y Cleveland / ~
pire Evans. Time hour ami - minutes
CLEVELAND. = ~. Lovts SECOND a.Ng
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-10-10
G,OI
FinaI Tournament Of season for News.
paper club To-morrOu

Inc last regular tournament ~ the New
York Newspaper Golf Club will Da held
to-morroW a. Van 'oT'landt Park Plans
are under vav 20 hold team match the.
same day aga mt N" Bo-'on Press Coll CIuh
which has challenged no New Yorker.
and htg heetst"ak dinner gIll h.. held al
the Van tortlandt golf house ~ nixhi
for the first tim" IN" members Of tho
New York Newspaper Golf club viii play
for he COOPER up given by t"orga toOpar
Di ~" H'frh The PLAYER making The
lowest net sore IN IN" uualtfV ing round
III get log on the trOphN Anv PLAYER
getting no l-g- on y bsfoTr tho last t1Irna. .
uruf uf Irli vii Obtain p"ruiiu.uf II-
bN any PLAYER bafor" hat tim" the indiy.d dual
IUu"f- 100 meet 90 match pIay Tor the
.ui Al u-' SCORES b~loN - shall count a.
The 'hIrF.fwp PLAYERS Vifh tho lowest
n"f -'.uI"- o.. fn0rrBA Tor eighteen lpla.
sllI qualify Tor 90" regular monthly match
Tournament. Ih"E viii H. d., ds,l INTO
pfiy" viii 10" gwen 10 tho wlHn"r 81 each
iiNi~'"u. Their" viii also h.' q priz. for the
test net -'UrH.
CO." si,rH ,"nue'Itton Tor the rre- sleui'a
1000 - %" t'aE land tUlf lIU vas held
fsa-'"rtt. afternoon IHs .,Ilf-a vas h.,
.".-i ,"rdrI"r AMI = .arF" 'ruRd TUNED
@, go T.ho'.s, . i? r ? T'If"TSa, l p.
-. r. ~ 10 Gu-iur N. = To- 7H ID b.
wrn .r. - T.. y 10 ,mIsr 20 10 = r T.
N'f'' h.ls,r %, - ". ,r y" E.,.- %
Gsriner VIM, q. q - w " gwitr ,os " :,
L. sSsslsG a -. < I. Baa SSss' iiS ~ o.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-10-10

Hunt.PtttsbnTs Wilson Cincinnati AIuref
Modified q Lobert, Clarke Two has hit
hohhbel Three basc hits clarke. tar7 me-
Home run Wilson stolen bass IoheTf Uot
hiSsi Double play Mo- rthy. Miller and Ms
neT. Sacrifice hits Campbell. Mitchell CoTrorsn
Clarke SHurk Out-By Beebe hy Wfi,e
l,eft on bases Cincinnati. o. Ifttshurg q m
plrr In chicr-breunan. Field umpire . ., .iis
Time ! hour and ~ minutes
CHICAGO ~ o.. . NJ Lorts ~ tra
feated ~. Louis In . close and rEri,tnS ,.
70 dsS me .Ios Won out In the ninth. Whcr
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-10-10

Two out When winning rrn va> made
So Louis : - q % o. "a a , ,
Chicago. u % - % - a.
Runs n Louis Higgins. FIHs B-trh-r ,bi
eago- beaunlont. Holman. thansr Goi~ -,
hase hits steele. ~ ans. Schulte TnLrt Itr-
norman SacTinre hits kDn-'rhN TfrL.r s,.i"
Ithii. Zimmerman Double plaN /f11u-,,,s..
Tinker anu Hofr an Irf on Els-s. ~ / 80,
". thiraGo. 10 Nild Pitch ,o.r ~ b. ri,rt..
~ toir. FNans Impl-r iu rhief tYsi..
Fieh umpire ObaS lime hour ana . .
minute e''' ."
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-10-10

Ire run Of the MornIuK-lde 4 = resulted
IN ~ptrited tri-sle b.fweeu Harry Mr( ,tnn
81 the New FORK Z. Frank Masterson
MohawA \ &. and John schroeder Of th.
home club. and the gong MS good that
record for the course Of three aud three
fourth. miles His time was 10 minutes
- seconds MA-tsrson and Schroeder held
onto the Mercury Foot runner tilI the lasT
half mile when hs -purfsd and drew away
he Mohawk man can . In second about
nfty Yards behind the leader and schroeder
Wa close ~ IN third place. The summary
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-10-10

Huns- Detroit 'raNf1fd. klrke Chicago
LwthnE Two has- nit Mullin Three base
htS crawford. NHlct' Sscrin,e hit /eder
SUuCk ui-HN DOnON an, a. bN ChOnurAu 1 h,
lange : First base on balls or Donovan s.
on lAngr. T. Double play Mclean aud Mullen
lrft on bases-Dctru' a. chicago. : Hit by
pitcher b Donovan Chonn-sU. tup'rr in
chief Perine Held umpire sheridan nme
! hour and ~ minutes
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-10-10
NATIONAL LEtGIE.
ChicaGos and Cincinnatis uin on Pc.
nuItImats Day.

iNNiNNAll o. FlTINNtN0. ].
CTNcfNNAri. oct The Reds won tho Anal
game OF inc season from The Pirates 'hls after
noon due TO fred Berbe's nA-terfuI pIirbtry
The Pilates only run vas sco rel on a homer Is
lls0n who hit me ball clear IN the fisht ne td
isnet White Vas hit hard besides bslfg Mild
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-10-10

4 pack Of about thirty turned out for the
Pennant 4. 4. run Two unattached rum
neT- did all the pacemsking They we're
Harry smith and 4. burri.. close on their
heels ran - Bobtkis Of DE Witt Clinton
Htgh school and several time. he made
attempts to forge To the front hut Smith
and Burrt- always had too much pace for him
on the ran for home smith forced the gait
aud he gradually left BurTis and finally
won hy more fhHn ID yards BObtkls
gave Hurris u chase for second place but
the latter scrambled In With an advantage
Of about tventy yards. The summary
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-10-10
Game- srhednI~d far Te-,Ia,.

NATtuN a. tEs8rR
Philadelphia IN New Ncrk Chicago IN :, t,,.t.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-10-10

ss.: e sIi g. S &: H s:s.s ss
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-10-10

Speedway are having q large -trip Of me
back stretch Of it- two mile mOtorf rome
Ia'h ,oIn ~ ana rrsurfhc"d, a. some in
Na- nr-t huilt last year. Gangs Of lahoTsru
are also makinR minor repairs 90 the entire
course IN order that " will he in the best
possible condition for tho race meet on
November ,, and 5 There are now
thlrty-siH cars entered for the various
cylinder I.ogler, and Simplex The
atlanta men hope 10 get the entries Of a
number 81 the drivers who piloted cars IN
ih" Vanderbilt cup and fairmOunt PARK
road races
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-10-10

The Motor Racing Association will CON
duct = series Of indoor tournaments in the
CITY clubhouse Of the association ~ sNa
Vest Fiftv-eighih street these will ron.
si-t OF pool and billiard masChe- bridge
fan tan. pinochls JOURNEYS and chess and
checker competitions 4 number ~ vaIu-
able trophies have been offered for the
tournaments. which will be started after
the FIRST winter entertainment IL held At
the CluhhOns. on Thursday evening
The Vinita daily chieftain. [volume] (Vinita, Indian Territory [Okla.]) 1902-1913, 1910-02-24

see our friends. We wish more would
come and oftener.
The Fifth years have been getting
acquainted with diacritical marks this
week.
Buck Frazer is back in school. He
has been missed for a fortnight.
On the day of the blizzard we had
but few scholars on account of mis-
understanding whether we should
have school.
There is a prediction abroad that
in the near future there viii be a full
line of politicians developed among
our boys as they are certainly some
good debaters.
The fifth years have taken their
final examination in history most of
them making good grades and are
now taking up agriculture
Retha Herndon visited with the
Rafferty, girls Wednesday night.
The ninth year arithmetic class has
been having lot of fun borrowing
money, writing notes and discounting
them.
The Vinita daily chieftain. [volume] (Vinita, Indian Territory [Okla.]) 1902-1913, 1910-02-24

press competition; non-competition as
the result of the acquisition of prop
erty is, the defendants insist, not a
violation of the statute.
Another difference between the two
cases lies in the fact that the Stand
ard Oil company is charged with Of
fense against the Sherman law alone;
the Tobacco corporations are charg,
ed with offending also the Wilson tar
iff act of 1894. which extended the
application of the antitrust law to
any conspiracy in restraint of trade,
one party to which was an importer
Furthermore, the government is seek
ing to establish the rule that a cor
poration entering into an agreement
abroad which in purpose conflicts
with American law, gains no immunity
from the fact that such an agreement
is lawful in the foreign country.
1t is suggested that the commodi-
ties handled by the Standard Oil
company may be more properly call
ed 'necessaries of life" than those
dealt in by the tobacco corporations.
Attorney General Wickersham in
his argument of the Tobacco case ex-
pressed the opinion that a different
element would enter into the trade in
an absolute necessity of life, as dis
tinguished from one that was not a
necessity, because such commodity
was charged with a public use, just
as much. if not more, than what is
called public utility companies"
AS the result of the hearing in the
circuit courts, other differences were
either made or became apparent.
In the tobacco suit, the court did
not find sufficient evidence to hold
that there was monopoly in the trade
in question, although it did hold that
there was a combination in restraint
Iof trade. In the Standard Oil case
the court was unanimous in finding
that there was an illegal monopoly, in
addition to there being a conspiracy.
The Vinita daily chieftain. [volume] (Vinita, Indian Territory [Okla.]) 1902-1913, 1910-02-24
wHITE OAK SCHOOL ITEMS.

Several presevering ones having
earned perfect attendance certifi-
Gates for four months past, were
pleased and greatly encouraged. This
is good thing and puts new life and
energy in the minds of the pupils.
A small program was rendered on
Washington's birthday. and quite a
few visitors were present in spite of
the inclement weather We are so
|engrossed with our regular school
work that we scarce find time for
extras
We are all happy to have Mamie
Chitwood back at school again after
an absence Of several weeks.
Mr.. Poindexter looked in on us
Monday afternoon. 1t does us good to
The Vinita daily chieftain. [volume] (Vinita, Indian Territory [Okla.]) 1902-1913, 1910-02-24

dissimilar that the court might find in
favor of the government in one case,
and against it in the other.
The two cases are alike in that they
are proceedings in equity to enjoin
alleged violations of the law of the
land-neither is in its essence a Grim
inal action; in neither does the gov
ernment seek to procure either i'm
prisonment of individuals or exemp-
larry fines upon the defendants. In
both suits the charges pressed are
those alleging unlawful combination
and conspiracy in restraint of inter
state trade and commerce, and con
tinuing monopoly or attempted mono
poly. of important elements in inter
state commerce.
The STANDARD Oil company of New
Jersey is attacked as holding com
pany7 Out Of its 100000 capital
istock. over ss7,OOO,OOo was exchang-
ed in 1899, according to the govern
ment figures, for stock in nineteen
other corporations. engaged in the
various branches of the petroleum bus
mess, owns its own shops and sells
the manufactured products. In the
case of the Standard Oil company
the raw product is to an extent pro
duced by the corporation; in that of
the tobacco combination the raw ma.
terial is purchased.
While the Sherman law does not
specifically prohibit the organization
of holding companies, the supreme
court declared in the Northern Sc
curities case that the holding COM
pany constituted an organization in
restraint of trade and commerce.
The government charges that from
the time of the Organization of the
Standard Oil company in 1899 a mon
opoly was obtained; that in fact for
years prior to that a virtual monopoly
had existed, and that the various
forms which the conspiracy alleged
against the oil company has taken,
have been merely adaptations to the
changing needs and conditions OF the
times.
| In the tobacco case it is alleged that
Originally when the merger was con-
summated in 1890. there was mon
lpoly only in the cigarette trade; the
defendants claim that the control of
the business then secured has since
materially dwindled.
The Standard Oils counsel have
contended that the corporations which
in 1899 entered into the greements
complained of had long since ceased
to be competitors In the tobacco
case, the defendants contend that
their acts have been confined merely
to the acquisition OF manufacturing
property: that manufacturing corpor-
ations are under no legal obligation
to compete = the prohibition being
against specific agreements to sup