New-York tribune., 1910-11-22

1i1,od for several years with Miss Hvs-
lon's grandmother, and a few weeks he
fore his disappearance had taken Miss
1-,,., Enright, his ffancae tn sac the
Critchleys
/ The Critc1leys. Miss Hyslop and Rea-
/ ean came together last night fo- the first
t,-,e since the discovery of the body in
( tine trunk Thomas CritchIev and Rea-
gan work for Frank c White. while
william 6. Critchley and Miss Hvslop
came there to see Thomas and his wife
Say Description Fits Lewis.
What do You think about Lewis.
.wilr?" asked Tom" as his brother
entered the store
Lewis is in the trunk" Win re-
pied. "and my two boys say so, too.
What do you Think"
Il think So" said Tom"
That's what I think Reagan said.
Anybody who ever knew Lewis would
say so. That description fits him ex-
actly and finding the trunk with him in
it explains his disappearance in 1905,
when the police couldn't find him
What do YOU think, Flossie?' her
uncle asked Miss Hyslop
Il think ii was Lewis" she said. The
description is just like him"
1T was Lewis Mrs. Critchlev agreed.
Its just as Pat says. Anybody who
knew him would know that it is Lewis -
Cloudsley had given his verdict some
time before. Expurgated it follows:
What gets me is what was in that
note, but he's the
fellow in that trunk and
you can bet Your -- on that.
don't understand what he was doing
over there with the Meaghers. but -
The Critchleys and Miss Hyslop sup
ply the information about the teeth.
Lewis lived for several years with Mrs
Sarah Hyslop. grandmother of Miss
Florence HysIop, at No. 466 Second ave-
nue.. leaving there at the time Of Mrs,
HvsIOp's death, early in 1902. Miss Hys-
Iop's father was william Robert Hyslop.
q dentist at No. aga Second avenue. and
he made 4 set of false teeth for Lewis.
My father died five years ago" Miss
Hyslop said last night, but mother has
the record of the teeth. and We all knew
Lewis He was like q son to my grand
mother and lived there with her as
though he were her SON I remember
when my father made the teeth for
Lewis, but I was only a little girl then,
and I don't remember just what they
were
He had plate across the front of
his mouth said Reagan. Il remember
that
And he had gold cap OH one of the
teeth said William g. Critchley. L
asked him about it once. and he told me
that he had a gold cap put on one of the
lower teeth on the left hand side SO that
it would look like he had real teeth"
Knew Him Last as q Collector.
The missing man had not been 4
waiter for several years before his dis
appearance in 1905, according to the
Critchleys and Reagan, and the last
known OF him he was a collector for an
instalment furniture house.
4
big instalrent furniture houses when
he disappeared" said Reagan. L knew
that from some things he said TO me. He
was in the insuran nee business before
that and then he became q. collector. l
knew ne always had plenty OF money"
Yes. He always had plenty Of money"
said Tom Critcflley, But never knew
whether he had SO or $4,000. He
wasn't = man to talk very much about
himself
Cloudsley thought Lewis was an ac
countant because he kept his hands
clean.
He used 70 go out about $50 or
O'Clock in the morning" CIoudsley said.
and come home around s o'clock at
night When he went out at night he
wore evening clothes and an opera hat
and white gloves, and everything just
right. if he was going 10 the theatre or
the opera think he vas bookkeeper