Arizona republican., 1910-12-07
THE RISING
 STRUCTURE Making of the Constitution
 Going on Apace RECALL QUESTION AGAIN
Democrats, Who Would Strike It Out in Spite of Gloomy Outlook and Linn tied Time, Have Not Yet Given Up All Hope.

There were no developments in the constitutional convention yesterday in respect to the recall; that it. no such developments as those who have been trying to have it eliminated thought might take place and there is not a flattering prospect that there will be any though those democrats who have been moving in that direction. last night had not given up hope and were working more feverishly than ever.
 They have not received much en- couragement from any source. It is practically certain that there can be no modification of the recall article and it is entirely certain that there can be no separate submission. The republican members would oppose that and though they would prob ably join in a movement for the total elimination of the article. they would prefer not to have the sub ject brought up again in any form. Therefore. as to the recall. it must be a clear back down or nothing.
 When that article was reached in the course of the consideration by the committee of the whole, of such articles as had come from the print CT. Dr. Tuthill moved an amendment, relieving the judiciary from the Oper atiOn of the recall. He quoted an address by President Taft in which the latter advocated an untrammeled judiciary and he took it from that that the president would not approve constitution that disgracefully trammeled the judges. He did not believe that congress would approve such a constitution.
 There were no other remarks in favor of the amendment but Mir. Feeney offered a unique argument against it. He believed that on ac- count of the meager salaries which had been provided by the cOnstitu- ton for the judges. a class of men would be secured which would make the recall very desirable.
 The motion was defeated by the following vote:
 Ayes. 14-Baker. Cassidy. Cooper. Curtis. Franklin. Hutchinson. Kingan. Langdon. Orme. Pusch. Scott, Stan dage. Tuthill. Wells
 Nays. 32-Bolan. Bradner. Cobb. Coker. Colter. Connolly. Crutchfield. Cunniff Cunningham, Feeney. Gold water. Ingraham. Jones of Yavapai, Jones of Maricopa. Keegan. Kinney. LOvin, Lynch. Moeur, Moore. Morgan. Osborn. Roberts. Short. Sims, Simms, Tovrea. Weinberger. Wills, Winsor. Wood. Mir. President.
 Messrs Doe. Jacome and White of the republicans were absent Prob ably two democrats who were not in the chamber would have voter for the motion and no doubt several who voted against it would have cast their votes for it if there had been a probability of it's success.
 This article will be before the con vention today on the report of the committee of the whole when prob ably the final effort will be made to secure it's amendment or elimination.
 The convention spent a considerable part of the time in a waiting attitude. There was a limit tO what the printer could do According to the rules which required that the constitution should be brought before the convention in its entirety. there was nothing On hand and would not likely be for some days.
 MT. Goldwater suggested that the convention take up such parts of it as had been acted upon in the whole committee. The committee the night before had gone over the preamble. the declaration of rights, state boundaries, distribution of powers. the legislative proposition. the initiative and referend- um, and a part of Legislature"
 Accordingly final consideration of these articles was begun. NOtwith standing they had been threshed over time and again. other efforts at amend ment were made and now and then the need of it was seen. But there were no attempts at essential change and before II o'clock all of the articles had been passed, presumably for the last time. though there will be more time until the convention has finally ad burned
 The republicans voted generally against every article. Messrs. Ellin- wood and Webb voted with them against the declaration of rights. the latter stating that he did so because the matter contained therein was quite E<NtiN liiilS lO WhANh liC declaration related was fully treated of elsewhere.
 An ordinance relating to the election on the ratification of the constitution was brought in by a special commit tee It prescribed the duties of all of ficers who are supposed to have any thing to do with the election ma chinery. MT. EllinwoOd sought to amend that part of the ordinance con- corning the duties of boards of super