The Ely miner. [volume] (Ely, Minn.) 1895-1986, 1910-07-15

@: 5sssSs 9 s77757 -
!.
OQ T is the custom to speak OF II
f,M-1 United States senate as the mo
EWp vi | digniied legislative body in II
IPAN E | world while on occasions Il
l0III EE | house of representatives has bee
INp HS described as bear garden" II
Ip>H UM senate is ordinarily dignifed d
lIIlM IA | Lucrative body, but nevertheless
~ is mistake to look upon the hou
u of representatives in any way, e
cept on the rarest occasions, as {
assembly given to disorderly pr
cedure. There have been within the last fe
months many scenes of intense excitement
the house, times when personal political and ia
tional temper has run high and when there WI
the high spirited excuse" for scenes borderil
on the tumultuous. In the main, however, throut
all the temper-trying times of the attempt
shear Speaker Cannon of his power. and dur
ing the intense moments of the debate on the
railroad BILL the members succeeded in holding
themselves in check, and in giving an exhibit
ton of self-restraint that was admirable. On
only few occasions within the space of sew
en- years that one correspondent has watched
proceedings in the house, have there been per-
sonal encounters on the floor between mem
bers In only one instance really could these
affairs be spoken of personal encounters,
for in only one case were blows exchanged
A former minority leader of the house and
one of the leading members of his party, ex-
changed blows, but the matter was personal
one and not political one, and it might have
happened outside of the house as well as in
side. 1t was not brought about by the heat of
debate, but by long continued friction which
engendered heat enough to cause an explo-
sion while the house was in session. One OF
the parties to this physical encounter is now
dead and the other, next March, will take his
seat in the senate of the United States. Their
names probably will suggest themselves at
once.
There are many hot-headed members Of the
lower house of congress, and some of these
"temperamental ones" are leaders In their re-
spective parties. AS leaders, however, these
men long ago learned that If they were to
maintain leadership they must keep check
on their tongues and a check on their birth
right willingness to enter on a scrimmage
The members of the house realize that men
laboring under excitement, will say things that
they will be sorry for in minute, and SO fire.
quently, words that positively are insulting
are overlooked by the offended member for
few minutes in order to give the offender
chance to get his faculties back and apologize
If he does not apologize, though he generally
does, the one who feels himself aggrieved has
his own way of securing retraction, either by
appeal to the house, or direct appeal, some
times made in pretty sharp language, to the
member who has offended.
One of the most exciting times in the house
of representatives in recent years was YER
bal encounter between Representative Bourke
Cochran, Democrat, of New York city, and Rep
resentative John Dalzell, Republican, of Pitts
burg Bourke Cochran is known as one of the
greatest orators of the United States, and John
DalZell is known of the ablest debaters
the Republican side of the house of repre-
sentatives, small man physically, but abso
lutely fearless. Dalzell is of the chief adj
vocates of protection.
The New York member attacked the con-
sistency of the Pittsburg member in speech
and said some things about the Inconsistency
of the Republican party. To Dazell, this
seemed to give the opportunity that he wanted
He stood on the floor of the house and &C
cused Cochran not only of inconsistency but
practically of using his gift of oratory, first
to uphold one side of question, and then to
uphold another, and the Pittsburg man did not
try to conceal the reasons which he thought
were responsible for the change of opinion and
the change of attitude on the part of the man
whom he was criticizing.
In that speech against Cochran, Dalzell was
waspish. There were men the floor who
expected fully to see Cochran attack him.. not
verbally, but physically, but. the New Yorker
Sat through the speech, and when it was ended
arose in his own place. The New Yorker con-
tented himself with saying that if he were
guilty of the charges which the Republican
member had made against him, he was not fit
to stay in the house of representatives and he
demanded that congress as a matter of per-
sonal privilege to him, should make an in
vestigation of his conduct, make report there
on, and If he were found guilty, the fact should
be published to the country.
The house refused to take any action on