The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-04-19
NOT BATTLE In THR COMMONS
OERIEN AND LLOID-GEORGE
IHiRGE FALSE noon.
H,aN rIcrceIy Assails Redmond and
Nsauith Denies PrOmIsIng the Irish
= Nn,thInk But Thcy Decide ts sup
port budget Vote aaS 20 7z3.

NV. n the House Ot Commons to-day
n vnlch the seeding Irish msnber-
o., 4 leading Part. MeSzTs. Asquith.
4 IL ... George and Balfour also con-
o. ing their share to the eAcitemsnt
~. Hrusa was crowded u listen 10
lam 'Brien's statement IN regard
- famous interview with Chancellor
,f n, Exchsqusr Iloyd-OsoTga. III"
Fr...- e Wales and many psers were
r-....nt in the galleries and Ambassadors
AL. foreign Ministers iiled the dis
TINS ~h'.i strangers gallery.
Nuam O'Bri@n Il will - recalled
NJ. %, rcrtaln statements a. to what
IoyI-Irsorga sald the Government would
q 800 order To- win Irish support for the
midget. Mi OBrIen said at a msetinx
II .nrA CITY that after the first interview
VIII Mr. Lluyd-Ci"Orge liz hat sent hun
a stter m regard To- what the lrish wishsd
IN -eturn for their support 81 the Govern
rsr- Nj . Brlen sad that afterward
h. had a second interview with MIR. Lloyd
George al winch ne read this letter aloud
he Chancellor IT the EAcheQuer said
N reply that h. had never received this
s,'.r and that u hat never been read to
nm Thereupon MIR OBrisn declared
hat he would make MS reply to the
Minister n the House II Commas.
NJ Brien began has statement to-day
bv SAVING that ou the day after he made
h. speech IA the Commons. February -
b.. Vls asked To rl.-at a high oiliccT vt the
Government AMI IA discussed the si;,Il-
'lr with this 90 0pr FOR an hour. Sub
s-.lsul.y he was . sk,',i t. meet the Chan
,e..r II iha ENchelucr Mr. Lloyd
IT,. g lie iii ~ 81 IN" private house
a. ,rlrlucuJ member Il tho Ministry.
A. 'h.s u.r;ug. Mr. O'Bricn sad. the
,u,ur.l.~ t the ych"lu~r distinctly
st.'.-i that Le slN no serious difference
t.'v-er .- own views ..ni thnsa Il the
% B-.-r.'..> a. tu the. budget and land
purchase and asked them II pat their
proposals ru writing. promising - lay
tr.-,. proposals before John Rcd-uond.
Join B.iI.n md I. =. O'Connor. the
ether IRISH leaders,. u see II some agree
men, could b" arrived at.
Mr q B-iru continued thrt after h. had
r.r.lvet an animation that th Nationalist
leader refused Ia meet him and that II
va, ~ 'r'I' that a VA. gain had been made
y with The Government he decided Co make
IT, matter pIhlic. At h., second in, ar-
yles with the Chancellor " the Ex-
ct.-lI"r He read out every word Il the
\ ..,t.- which h" had drafted for pre-enta-
tor 70 Mr. I.iovd-Ge"rge.
Wien that gentleman. knowing that
thr-.. parts e that interview took piece
without witnesses, denied ~ knowledge
4 q taa letter referred to IL ralsei AN issue
q 'rI,hfulness and straight dealing
which he Mr.. O'Brien, was right willing
70 allow to he judged by those who knew
tie Jnancellor ot the ENcheluer and
Uo.a mo knew him.
. Ia the face Of such -ho" King divergence
te'V~-n private professions and public
g.. n. he MIR - BTi-vi did not know wha'
tie honorable gentleman's code IT honor
va. bat b. knew u wa> not his MIR.
4 q b1en's'. ~" was. perhaps unWI>s'
r. 'rJIsting himself AI1i' ! a." SECOND
-'srview with IN" gem "'rsu Nhp had
N uAI" such an absolutely unjust ana shro-
\ t.',.v brutal charge against ui-s
Instead Of gaming gr"a' 'prc'ssiuus.
- Mr. O'Rrien. ireland was now 20 get
.'..ry exceTt a couple 1T crumbs. winch
ve-.. % he dropped from the treasury
'.s.. lf concluded Mr. O'Brtsu. there
49, any tOubt lef' a. To the 'rtIf II What
D. sad the Government could appoint .
,..-. ? .rnrnIttee 20 prove IN" qus-'I -.
l14..tlpr Of tn ENrIsI'G'r LIDv l.
Ut re. who roar amid loud M,u,E;'s'Hf
ctCnrs sa.i the honorable mem .'rt mad
maize ys.Nr the part Il IN. Iuf"-v i"V
" -4'ai him RI Il ,ovd- ipor q,
had 20 trIs' entirely ~ his memory m
i regard - one put II tine hundred iut~--
we've 10 had hsld with al sorts II pie
! IL aai never heoE gi-"n away "N0"T' On
'h. 'orasl0n. Mr. OBrien had putt
Hs.e1 AZ account of private interview
NI'.r4' asking permission and hs alone
W. '-a HOUSE II Commons vas guilty q
ID done this
..n'nuIg Mr.. LIoyd-GeorRe said Mr..
o Be-. rtt friends m the Tory press
among the enemies Of his country
I'.I cheers and cries 81 Who ara
To-. 'r- Tory party. continued the
CHANCELLOR, winch had thwart"d all the
Ia ..rt. separations OF ireland. a party
w. "a, flt ou...r.d when Mr. - Brisn Wa-
49, -lng the personal honor Of Minister
IN 49, their sens. 81 fair play They
Gu, ...l ~" attack before they had even
h@arl vnat the Minister had To say for
r..-'f
e. 90" second interview. Mr. I lovd-
70 sad Mr. . krien read what p,Ir-
;'".7 '' 10 a memorandum of wha' pur-
j. .r -p nav" taken place al the first
20 r. .H. iI' he Uhe speaker stopped
hir 49, sad hat not only did ne not make
~ 49, .Il' that he was not m posi-
o.. ' MAJ" promises II the honorable
~ "rrafI had letter 20 write 90 him he
- .. .ar" lent o. along.
DO i.ryt-G-orze said that among the
m. ..s ~t.rr had prompted him 10 500.
y" ..-a 'n~mi srs was not only his con-
'"r.. .. me budget but tina, he viewed
'a an-rur the prO@T.ects 81 a quarrel
''. ''.H 'Ho democracies. He was not
a-.a the part he had taken in ORE
. .- .a' fa'Id and hs asked the House
.. h- account % the transact ion
'.- . .,rfs.'.v truthful one The Chan
'," FNche'lu-r wound up by
q.
.. OPP received letter from the
sng'I"rar The frs ! heard
" . .- UI- when { read ~ IA the
- -. t.. .- ! nav" absolutely no recol-
r'td.ng anv letter 20 me
D.. ~ s'"r 20 statement by Mr..
"a .lti referred a. some length
20 .. .r. gam . the Ministry ith the