New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1910-07-01
the acceptance of the adverse report, 81
to 63.
The Vote in Detail.
The vote in detail follows:

Ayes: Republicans-Boshart. Burgoyne, Cal
Ian, Coffey, Connell, Dana Delano. Eboets
EsT f[ay Macs
Donald Marlatt. Merritt. Nolan, Parker. G. w
Philips Phillips shea N Smith. stiTsrs
weinstein e II. White, Whitley. Whitney
wlIsnack; Yale F L. Young. Speaker Wads-
Democrats-Boylan. Brenna. Caughlan. Don
nelly, Farrell. Fay. Foley. Friend. Fris6ie. Ger
Racket aeafn HercR Hoey Sakson Jossp
J. Levy. J. Levy: Maniey. MeCue. McEliigott
' ) oSe Ne A oNe Rosan same
shortt. a. E. Smith. spielberg,' Walker. Wende
Noes: Republicans. F. Allen H. E. Allen
Argetsinger Barden Bates. Baumes. Bennett
Brainerd. c. F. Brown. G. W. Brown, Cheney
FIlIey. Garfein, Glore Goodspeed, Green, Hig-
gins Holden, Kopp. Lansing Lee, Lupton. Mac
Murray, odell. Perkins Pitkin. Reed, Roberts
Shepardson. Stevenson, Sullivan. Sweet, Ihomp
son; Thorn 7, Van olinds' Ward, Weber Weiiand
Democrats-Abbey. Chanler. Cosad. Croker
De Long; Evans, Keller ellie McGrath' Patrie' from
bly,, l. II. White, Wright-12
observation-disclosures. Total, g.
The absentees were Conklin, Doherty
and z. Young. Republicans. and Beck and
HARDWOOD, Democrats.
These members, who opposed the measure
It to-day: Argetsinger, Baumes. G. w
Brown, r. II. Clarke, Higgins. Kopp, Mac
Gregor. Odel. Roberts and Weiland. Re-
publicans and L. H. White. Democrat.
At the regular session the Cobb bill was
defeated by a vote of As to 81. The Hin
man-Green bill was beaten by ST to n.
Speaker Wadsworth Glad.
Speaker Wadsworth was frankly glad "a
the turn things had taken. He declared
that If the Senate passed the Cobb bill with
the Griscom amendments and sent it back
to the Assembly he would fight as hard as
ever to down 1t once more.
1.-The action of the Assembly to-day
Speaker Wadsworth said, should not be
considered a gratuitous slap at the eX'
President OF at the Governor. The Assem-
bly, feels that 1t gave the fullest and mos
deliberate consideration to primary reform
at the regular session. There never has
been a more honest verdict rendered thar
that by the Assembly in the various roll
calls of the regular and special sessions.
The supreme issue is whether the AS
sembly shall swallow its convictions anC
deliberately reverse its honest judgment
and thereby announce to the legislatures
of the future that the legislative brancf
of the government, supposedly Independent
can be coerced and forced to occupy a sec
ondary position in our system OF govern
ment. II is question far beyond that Of
the merits or dement's Of direct primaries
The prestige of this Legislature and of al
legislatures to come is at stake.
ut should be understood that the Assem-
bly, is actuated IN its action by the sin
cerest convictions. and is willing to present
the broad question of It's rights and pre-
negatives, in addition to that of the merits
and dement's of the primary bills, to the
people this fall. That is the logical tri-
bunal''
The Speaker was asked whether he be
lieved the action Of the Legislature would
have any effect on Colonel Roosevelts po
litical future.
II have nothing to say on that point" he
replied.