The Daily Missoulian. [volume] (Missoula, Mont.) 1904-1961, 1910-06-10
SUBSTITUTE IS DEFEATED
Ma lority Measure Is Lost. Large
Detection Among Democrats Being
Reeorded-Votirg Upon Several Mo.
tons involved in Disposition Of
New Law Follows Long Debate.

house tonight passed the postal savings
bank bill as recently agreed upon by
the republican caucus of the house. Not
Il single republican voted against the
!. easurc on the final roll call Prior to
this action. the house by | 10 to 1886. re-
jected the democratic substitute for the
bill proposed by the majority. The
voting upon the several motions in
volved In the disposition of the meas
ure followed six hours OF debate In
which many republicans and democrats
recorded their view upon the bill of the
majority and the substitute supported
by large portion of the minority.
Democrats Desert.
The large detection among the DEM
ocrats was shown when the democrat
ic substitute was voted upon. II of
them joining the republicans In voting
against the measure. Most of those
were opposed to a postal savings sys-
TEN of any kind. Those democrats
were Brantley OF Georgia. Broussard
of Louisiana Burgess or Texas. Carlln
of Virginia. Flood of Virginia. Foss of
Massachusetts. Garrett of Tennessee.
Gill of Maryland. Gillespie of Texas
Hammond of Minnesota. Harrison OF
New York. Hay of Virginia Jameson OF
Iowa. Korbly of Indiana, Lamb OF Vir-
glnia. Latta Of Nebraska McHenry OF
Pennsylvania. Moon of Tennessee.
Slayden Of Texas. Talbot of Maryland.
and Turnbull Of Virginia.
With Republicans.
I,p Ia
Nebraska. insurgent was the only
member who voted with the democrats
for their substitute. ON agreeing to
the bin as proposed by the majority
Of the house as a substitute for the
senate measure. the vote was i75 To 1906.
ON this vote. 26 democrats Joined the
republicans as follows:
Aiken. South Carolina. Ansberry.
Ohio; Ashbrook Ohio. Cox. Ohio
Foss. Massachusetts Foster. Illinois
! Hammond Minnesota; Hanna. North
| Dakota, Hayens, New York. Henry.
, Texas; Hitchcock, Nebraska: Hughes.
! New Jersey: Johnson. Kentucky; Kin
kead, New Jersey; Mcguire. Nebraska: /:
/ Moss. Indiana; Nicholl, Pennsylvania (.
/ OConnell. Massachusetts: Pou. North
I 'hlbllHhs hduShfil 1khtk
er Colorado. SABBATH. Illinois: Sharp.
/ Ohio; Sulzer, New York: Taylor. col
orado and Touvelle. Ohio.
Six republicans Joined the democrats
In voting against the proposed bill OF
the majority. as follows: Gronna
! North Dakota; Hubbard. Iowa; Len
root, Wisconsin; Nelson. Wisconsin
+ Norris, Nebraska. and Wood, Iowa.
After a motion OF Mr. Moon of Ten
nessee 10 recommit the bill to the com
/ mlttee which reported II had been de
feated. the house voted on the final pas
sage, the vote being 1876 to 10i, "a dem
ocrats voting with the republicans, as
follows.
Aiken. South Carolina. Ansberry
I ohio; Ashbrook. Ohio. Cox. Ohio: Foss
Massachusetts; Foster. Illinois; Ham
mond. Minnesota. Hayens. New York
Henry, Texas; Hitchcock. Sebra ska
Hughes, New Jersey. Klnkead, Now
Jersey; Maguire. Nebraska; Martin
Colorado; Moss. Indiana: Nlcholl
Pennsylvania. O'connell. Massachu-
setts;; Ransdell, louisiana; Rucker
Colorado; Sabath, Illinois; Sharp Ohio
Sulzer. New York, Taylor, Colorado
Touvelle. ohio