New-York tribune., 1910-09-25
CHAMPION DOGS BEATEN
BauqhfeI Patrice and NoSegay
Nightshade Oethroned.
JUDGES DECISION CHEERED
Dunnollie Snowflake and Wales
colt Invader Win at Whippany
River Club Show.

The second annual dog show OF the Wh1p-
pany River Club. which was held on the
grounds of the Morristown Field Club. was
brought to a close yesterday afternoon
More than 576 dogs representing fifty-four
breeds were shown. and the competition
was keen. The rapidity with which the OF
ficias worked on Friday left little work
for them yesterday. and the programme
was hurried along without hitch.
John @. Bates, who promoted the show
made an elaborate entry in the Irish ter
rier class, and was rewarded by capturing
first place in the class with his Blarney
Irishman. while Newry Fergus won the
reserve in the same event Blarney Belle.
a sister to BIarney Irishman- Won the re-
serve in the class for bitches.
The competition in the class for West
Highland White Terriers vas particularly
keen. and the Judges paused long before
awarding the prize TO Mrs. a. s. Alexan-
der's DunnolIie Snowflake over y. Al
bright's champion BaughfeI Patrice- There
was little to choose between the brutes. and
, il was only after a long consultation that
the officials decided to dethrone the cham
pion. The decision of the officials caused a
ripple of surprise to rise from the audience,
| but the critics about the inclOsure agreed
| with the decision. and after the surprise
| had passed away the audience Joined in
| hearty applause for the winner.
| Nor was BaughfeI Patrfce the only cham
| pion to taste the dregs of defeat. Nose
| gay Nightshade. the champion Scotch ter
rier from the kennels of R. Fl. Williams,
was forced to dip his colors to Walescott
| Invader, entered by the Walescott Kennels.
Invader Is also champion in his class, and
the audience looked forward to the meeting
! 1c 7ad Z
the minute for the event, and showed to
the best advantage. Perfectly at home in
the show ring, the dogs looked at their
human critics as if to challenge their right
to criticise. 1t looked very much like {
case of splitting straws, but the judges
| finally decided in favor of Invader.
The summaries follow:
Retrievers-First. LAnsdowne Devonsie Darket
no reserve.
Doberman dogs-First, Mrs. H. l. Mapes'f
DOberman Dix; reserve. H Won Berge's Dober-
| man Prinz EfteI. Bitches Doberman Ken
nel's Duchess Chica de Dober1nan; reserve, Her
Scotch terriers-First waIescott Kennels
Walescott Invader; reserve. X ID. WlIilaI1s WI an,
West Highland white terriers-First. Mrs A
ander's Taiisman' Bitches, Mrs. A. S Alex
| ander's Dunollie Snowflake; reserve. A. Al
Dr1ghtS Baughfeu PatrfCe-
Dandie Dinmont terriers-Ffrst r. j. Bolster
| EarlstOn Jack; reserve.
| Schipperkes-First, Colonel T. Denny's Blacko
reserve, Colonel T. Denny's Barker Bitches
Colopel T. Denny's Wilhelmina; reserve, Colone
| T Denny's F1eyette
| English toy spanels Cblack and tam, dogs
First, Mrs W. w. Hadley's St. Patrick; no re
serve. Bitches-First, Mrs A. Reynolds Cona
| Hng's Rodanthe Advocate; reserve, Mrs "A
| Reynolds Conkling's Carteret Maude Adams
English toy spaniels (Orange and white), dog
First, Miss Anna b. Lewis's Lansdowne Sailo
| Boy. Bitches-First, Mrs Auguste :. VatableI
| Ma mzelle; reserve.
| English toy spanies (white, black and tam
| dogs-First. Miss Ella Van Benthuysens Hi
Royal Nibs: reserve
japanese spaniels, dogs-Mrs. F. II. Brender
sohn's Meto; no reserve. Bitches-F1rst. Mrs
| A. !. MouIton's Mouton Toto; no reserve.
/ Pekinese spaniels-First, DR.. H w. Haskell
| Ichi Ban: reserve, Miss c. Bryce's Tai Cheng
| Bitches-First DR.. II. W. HaskelIs Cheng.
| Toy poodles-First. Miss Edna NJ Cassidy
| Miss Rufies; reserve, Mrs. z. Warmers Bah
| Girl.
| Yorkshire terriers-First. Mrs NJ Jennings
Little Boy Blue; reserve, Mrs NJ Jennings
| Beauty.
| MaNese terriers-Malta Pura Kennels Some
| kin reserve, Miss X Stitzkins Kitty ID