Bisbee daily review., 1910-01-07

come 70 nm ana tell m that iiie was not worth hving: and that there seemed to. be something preying ca his m nd at all times and he you'd ask him what it was he would say 1, that it was matters in his ] f. thai | he did not care to talk about; he was . morosc and despondent; that Billy was the best boy that he ever had work for himfi that he loved him: that there was something about the boy /, that appealed to = sympathy; and ! when he was asked if he saw any i difference in his personal appearance now and when he mad his trouble ne [ stated: Billy Pfannkuche, why he ia just the same dsar. old boy and have always loved him: that he hal | often sad he was fond of Mrs. Hoy and the children ant always spoke in the highest terms of them all; stated that the boy seemed to be nervous and would come in six or seven tIn's during the day and si down for a few moments in an abstracted way and would suddenly jump up and seem cheerful again. Stated that at O. a time De Ford and he had some words in the machine room: and that De
 Ford asked him to go out to dinner with him and Billy told him to so
 to hell and also told him (Nan Eato D
 10 go to hell, that this lead him .
 believe that there was somethin
 wrong with the boy. because he had
 always showed a great fondness TOT
 him and would cone and tell 4 $
 troubles to him when. perhaps, he
 would not go to anyone else: at thls
 time he told defendant that he mad
 better go to California and he sad
 that he would if he could get thi5 money from Hoy: this was shortly De fore the shooting and he told the Doys
 that if Billy Pfannxuche did not leave he would do something that he would
 not be responsible fer. He stated hs
 had had eighteen years experience un newspapers; asked if ke was re porter al any time said. oh, yet: as1- ed if he had ever visited or rathe- what sort of places he had visited ig
 the course of his profession. He s'afcd that he had visited morgues lnsane , asylums. district attorneys offices and
 everywhere; and was asked that during such experience, II ne ever ! ad occasion to observe the acton 0 people in jails and insane asylums;
 slated that he had. (Here long ar
 gument followed. after the jury had been excused. as to his right to testify
 to this since he had not qualified as
 an alienist Attorneys Williams and
 Cleary made some cutting remarks at
 one another The district attorne accused the counsel for defense Of be-
 ing insane and Cleary answered back
 and said Tt takes a thief to catch
 a thief" and that an insane man al
 ways proclaimed his sanity. insinust-
 ing that the district attorney was in
 sane as a retort. Words of this kind
 passed between them but in a friend lyl way. 1he district attoriIg? related
 a little incident that was told by an assistant superintendent of an asylum
 about how a man had shied at one Ot
 the keepers and walked right past the
 crazy man and stated that th s woUii
 often Cccur ,n ihc course oi ones
 lifej
 The witness was allowed to -1sweI the question upon the return of the
 jury and replied that he knew the de- ie1dant vas in a very nervous cOadi-
 ton and that the best thing for him
 10 do was to go 10 California. that hr
 would do something that he would not
 be responsible for.
 Direct examination ended here end cross-eXamination was taken up u-
 the district attorney He was asked
 along the same lines but in cross eN- . animation. stated that prior to the trouble he seemed 10 have @ suspicion Of Mir Hoy, but declared no auimosi- ty toward him: asked ir be could q s- tihguish between Illusion and dclusio1 as 1t was termed by an alienist: and was asked if he thought defenda1 g actions arose from an Illusion or ia- l fusion and hc said that he thought [ they arose from a fact: stated that de- ' fendaut never disclosed 70 him WnIt | the trouble in his life was. That hls thoughts seemed uncolIecJed. When asked if the union trouble wzs HOt | held at the door Of Hoy he replied | that it was rot. that just prior 10 the 1 trouble Pfannkuche was not the Billy | PfaRnkuche of old that his cordial manner had disappeared. and wh1l ! asked if it was not fact that Pia ain- | kuche was considered by all as haI | tempered man; he replied that ne | was one of the sweetest tempered l boys that he had ever known that he | learned to love the boy dearly and made this very strong. (TIere 8 num- E Der also showed emotion of those m K the court rooml Was asked # he | ever bad words with Hoy himself end he replied that he had not. ;ns ! first he spoke with Mr. Hoy was ! when Hoy discharged him saying that i he was not a good man. Asked if h.
 had any love for him after this ne | replied by asking the district attorney. Would you. under the circum- 1 stances?" Mir Williams said: ~I an | asking. you that question: and he re | piled very emphatic No" Asked
 if he hated him. replied that he ha;- ed no man: asked if his feeling
 against Mir. Hoy was not of the same l intensity as his love for defendant. | stated that you could soon forget ono who was not your friend: that he sim ply passed Hoy mp; that a man for ] gets his animosity, but he never for gets who his real friends are. He stat | ed that he thought Pfannkuche very peculiar af times as he would sit b. | himself and suddenly jump up as above stated
 C. K Eleriek testified substantially | as follows: Stated that he was no;
 well acquainted with Pfsnnkuche: that
 at one time in particular he observed his conduct. this was al meeting
 in the composing room of the Miner. when Pfannkuche made a speech
 which lasted about three hours. aRd
 when asked if it was a coherent
 speech. replied shs; it would not have