The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-05-12
BOARD or REYIEW CASES
Fines Reunited Agalnat I.sVingtoa Drivers
--.ludEes Admit Error

---lndget Admit Ffror
/ Applications from horaa owners and
drivers for reinstatement were the chief
matters acted On 10 the judicial way By The
board OF review Hf lhe National Trasiins
Association yesterday az the Murray Hill
Hotel. The acting officials we're President
2. 2 johnson. Lexington. NY. Secretary
" Y. Gorher. Hartford. Conn. y. u. Wall.
Ottawa. Canada. representing The Eastern
district: De Forest Settle. syracuse. o. the
Atlantic district. and ". Russell Alec. 81.
louis Central district. The sessions we're
executive. but David Bonner. John w.
Shults. n. X. Balm Of Poughkeepsio and other
horsemsn Of distinction had he freedom
Of the council chamber
The case Of most interest Vas the april
cations Of the drivers Thomas W. Murphy
and Thomas Nolan 60 the National rrOtting
Association to be released from the hnes
imposed On them by tho judges at the Lex
iugtop meeting last fall Each had been
dnrd $40 Tor not driving 10 win In the three
yrar.old ffoiting division of the Kentucky
Fumrity. bat the Judge, subsequently, de-
cidrd thut they had made wrong decision.
IA dues are paid 10 the National TrOiting
Association and there IL rule that when
NANAANa NNNNN AlNAANNNa ~ a AAAAN NANAAAAN ~
cannot hc removed ~ mndiAed without the
consent " the board ~ review. All the
judges could do was ~ advise the board
Why lhev thought an error had BEEN made
and 10 usge the cancellation Of tho fines.
The board RENTED both fines.
ln the stand hat day we're ]. G. Lime
man. Lima. OHIO. n. 4. Estiu. Lexington,
Ky. and \. J. keattng, New York, the sal
AIRED Judge on the Grand Circuit and q
liouing that Murphys fine be RENTED. but
l.inneinnn voted ln the negative regarding
Nolan. who won out on the votes 81 Estill
ana heating The ease had been chrriesi
over from the December session and Neat
lng vt- the only 0ne At the principals pTes-
Cni yesterday
tstr.yna, nolan driving. had taken the
fret and second heats OF the race M 3oo',
and ,O5 me latter q worlds race record
Tor "a tlTes- vpaT-Oti trUtting lilly. baroness
Virginia, the ultimate winner 81 the rhcr,
I'M shed lasi In his heat, Murphy driving,
and tho Judges tined him the SO for not
trying 10 win tho beat. Murphy suhse-
guentlr "Nplnwcd that Baroness virginia
hal mad" q ur''ah a. the had OF the rtrrtch
ana when b" suw Il vas impossible 20 b
with the lradsr- he nad not urged the MY,
The Judge had overlooked the Drrak AMI |
When Jtsy learned Murphy had told the
Truth were sorry they had fined him hich |
b. 40 here vas 20 hat incident
baroness Virginia kept on aud won TIE !
third and fourth heats IN eus aud 2li'.,
Z .arcyuu byiuE third and seventh. In each .
h'at Nolan cot a good start but drqpp"d
nans quickly. then coming with a rush and
driving tzareyua in the most desperate
fashion Hence his fine after the fourth I
heat 70 developed O. the Satisfaction NJ I
'h- Judges that Nolan SsS merely too 4
nervous 10 do hims-lf Justice " = j. I
Stol,~ brrrder Of the ally. being one Of ,
ho-s 90 testify anxiety o. win and nervous I
uss aud ~ thry did not wish 10 give an 4
honest man v black eve. the majority vote 4
was for Cismency The stake was worth 4
sitm0
-Nolan hasn't driven In r,Any takes and Y
had never been IN front for hig money .
before. said track follower Ht the session. I
~" i'nr of losing cot him ratified.
Zoe temporary rrinslaiefnent ot y. 4
porlloit. Montreal Canada. aud Bert e. .
Wells. New Vineyard Me. both under "a
lulsion. as ordered cont inued for the scr /
,ud year 2 le Fayr. Montreal. Was more .
fortunate lie vase Npelled IN taD for
having q y-d the hav uacer Prince toa chest
lut and started 1im in q slow class ~ W0r-
9ssfrr Mass - " " Ten years II punish.
uent for one offence the hoard deemed
imrl" and IL taNre sac retn-latsd
There vas a rs.u-al 20 remove the ban ~
,Nrul. rn from " retrauii ~ Greenfield,
Mae. incurred m Iletemher, 1911 We
Fsrf 20 ono in tha preceding spring and
lou sbi Th1dr Burns. u.s.. racer. and
lnrtn"r named Mack. no record They
must have rot niNed Gaming on for Ie-
rau'f = n trouble Tor racing the fast one
De- Nu'h Reinstatement vas also denied
% n Hobhs Point Norfolk. Va. Nho az
'ypelic1 Iast December for racing HdglgQ,
o., a. lr,sn Lad 10 slow classes az Red.
rrl and Gslly Va
2 a. West.pr Rochester. y. y proved
nal ts had JARED Frazier 2,Ei IN
o,1I meeting Is Pride of Rochester inno-
emily 'nd b. va- reinsraisd.
Tho aNpuis.On of John Nc Arthur, LIVER
vol Midland proved that the hand Of The
\ 1ttanaI TrOffiug Association rearhes
russ ffe sea- he obtained an eNport
o.. ir.g'e IN fal-.. inform ~ ION and SHIPPED
.u 70 fn tserraug an alleged ~ iety belle
iy FEuf-If'iuu. dam nv Merton N,sI
2g.N.I 8- Peter Ilsyn. HAVE de Craze
id FOR DIT W. Ml-- l-ir Palmer George
iTIruu. .. n' 7 ir oniuiu. Nd a. Arts
.- rsf uu MARI The ohenre occurred
&c. -rr..r and Ni-, Palmer and 'n~ horz"
.crr Hu1 .HrU 80 the DeDeWher session.
Ie driver Ini"r mo rules nov receiving ne
fur fala
bon pF-rrt ~ 3 rHa'o. under expulsion.
far'0.I Torres '4sS -na-0n M the name OF %
.rlou. " u.N"N NJ Springviile. y. y.
r .ran. gates Leon DyEert, q sixteen
nlr-Dg hO. cNprlls1 Last season because
rtIr Hiri rared ln hi- name ~ Erie, Pa,
b" .t1r being ovn"i hy Nav Admur.
t- r..ustafed n vas proved that Leon
las a' his home IN sprrngyills ant know
orning about the race Game Hird BE- still
UHrr be ban bstnstateinents we're handel
90 % charles CASSIDY and George
~ HIou. both o. Altoona Pa uE1 ai 70
.#or ne mere in I10s gave 0u' the lime W ade
t,a.arr 1iiounwenf me board of review
sD'n fsf I-Nf- j. Powers Of ~Trin gfPh.
.t.s treasurer and " u Gocher serre-
IH The former has hern treasurer nf
boo Nqf.uua' irlff'ur Nss1riafiOn since
80 amt the Hf,f rotary hHt 81 -iut so