davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
New-York tribune., 1910-11-10
TENER'S PLURALITY GROWS
Republican Candidate in Penn
sYlvania May Lead by 10000.

Philadelphia. Nov. 9.-Complete returns
from sixty of the sixty-seven counties in
Pennsylvania, with estimated pluralities
from the missing counties, show an ap-
parent plurality for John X. Tener Repub-
Ican, for Governor of Pennsylvania, of
81 .464
The counties from which complete returns
have not been received are Allegheny, Arm
strong, Chester, Lawrence, Mercer. Monroe
and Wayne. Excluding these counties
Tener polled an unofficial total vote of 34S,-
209; Berry. the keystone candidate for Gov
ernor, 316.745. and Webster Grim, the Demo
cratic candidate 1856
Estimated returns from the seven missing
counties give Mr.. Tener a net plurality of
2,035, making Tener's plurality for the state
33, 499. OF this plurality Philadelphia gave
Tencr 45,1e6 and Allegheny approximately
1910 Mr.. Tener carried IS counties. Mr..
Grim 3 and Mr. Berry the remaining 40 All
other Republicans on the state ticket are
elected.
The complete returns show that the So
cialists polled an unusually heavy vote in
many parts of the state. receiving. for in
stance, In Northumberland 1857 for Slav-
ton, their candidate for Governor: 2.534 in
Schuylkill County. 1,719 in WestmoreIand
and 1886 in Beaver.
New-York tribune., 1910-11-10
SENATOR DICK DEFEATED
Democrats Capture the Ohio
Legislature by Safe Majority.

Cleveland. Ohio, Nov. 9.-The Democrats
in addition to electing Judson Harmon for
second term as Governor, have un-
Goubtedly elected the remainder of their
state ticket. They will have a majority OF
the Legislature of ten on joint ballot, and
in consequence Senator Charles Dick, Re
publican, will be succeeded in 1911 by a
Democrat
The campaign for the seat of Charles
Dick. prosecuted with vigor by the Repub-
Iicans until yesterday, was taken up by
the Democrats to-day. The Democrats in
the Cleveland delegation to the Legislature
just elected have pledged themselves to
vote for Brand Whitlock. Mayor of To-
ledo, or Atlee Pemerene, elected Lieuten-
ant Governor yesterday. Former Congress
man John j. Lentz. OF Columbus and John
r. Mclean, of Cincinnati, also command
support in the legislative majority.
Harmcns plurality over Warren g.
Harding, Republican, is still in doubt to-
night, but sufficient returns are in to show
that it is the largest ever given by Ohio
to a Democrat. The latest estimates give
Harmon a margin of $4,000 over Harding.
The next Ohio Congressional delegation
will contain thirteen and possibly fifteen
Democrats out of the 81. as Congressman
H p. Goebel, in the I'd District, and Paul
Howland. in the 20th, are being hard
pressed by their Democratic opponents.
New-York tribune., 1910-11-10

bash" or by the veteran candIdats. John
W Kern
Returns from Montana are stil1 fIrcoun.
plste. and the fate Of Senator Thomas ri.
Carter still hangs in the balance. with hIs
political opponents loudly procIsimlng his
defeat
The present Republican strength IN the
Senate Is 80. as against % Democrats. Ths
indications are. therefore. that the Senate
which will constitute the upper house OF
the SD Congress will stand 20 Republicans
10 42 Democrats. situation which will give
the insurgent Senators the balance of power
and make possible an interesting variety
OF political combinations.
Among the notable figures destined to
disappear from the upper chamber are Sen
ators Nelson w. AIdricn. Eugene Hale
Chauncey NJ. Depew. Nathan 3. Scott and
probably Albert J. Beveridge.
Senator Elmer Burkett. of Nebraska viii
be succeeded by Gilbert NJ Hitchcock. A
Democrat and a member Of the present
House. and Senator Julius G. Burrows will
give place to Charles r. Townsend. a Re-
publican and a member OF the present
House
New-York tribune., 1910-11-10
SOCIALIST GAIN IN CALIFORNIA
Entire Republican Ticket Elected by
Majority of 10000.

San Francisco. Nov. 9-Jate returns DO
not alter materially the indicated pIuraHtv
for the entire Republican state ticket IN
yesterdays election of from 20.0o0 % 5otss
Only one-haR OF the total precinct returns
are in These cover the cities and popu1ous
regions and returns from the sparsely set
tied counties probably Will not affect ths
result.
The defeat Of Theodore Bell Democratic
candidate for Governor. in the city Of San
Francisco. where IL was generally Thought
he would have heavy vote. is ascribed 20
the large Socialist vote.
In San Francisco Hiram Johnson. Repub-
Hcan. for Governor. received Z&s52 votes;
Bell. Z360s. and J. o. Wilson, Socialist. 9-0-
Political observers say that the Socialist
vote was drawn largely from Bell. The So
ciaIist vote in this city four years ago was
2.O13. Unofficial estimates place the Social
ist vote of Los Angeles at 1OOce. as against
g OF four years ago.
New-York tribune., 1910-11-10
FALLS FROM 81" TO STREET
Victim Was Dragged by Train
Until Clothing Gave Way.

Dragged for block and a half by a
Broadway elevated train in Brooklyn. an
unidentified man fell from the structure
to the street and was fatally injured last
evening. DR.. Mengen, of the German
Hospital, who responded to an ambu-
lance call, found that the mans skull
had been fractured and that he was in
ternally injured.
The man boarded train at the Kos
ciusko street station Because there
were no seats he started to back out on
the platform Before he could get out,
however. the guard had given the bell.
The mans coat was caught in the gate.
and before it was released by the guard
the train had pulled out.
Despite the cries of the passengers the
guard failed to give the signal to stop.
and the train continued to Gates avenue
before the mOtOrman knew anything
about the accident The mans coat was
torn. and he fell to the structure and
then 10 the street No arrest was made.
New-York tribune., 1910-11-10
sTUBBS'S PLURALITY OVER 1000
Republican Governor of Kansas IN
doubtedly Elected

Topeka, Kan, Nov. Ex-Governor " r.
Stubbs. Republican, tonight Is leading
George II. Hodges, Democratic candidate
for Governor. by s,4S3 plurality on returns.
almost complete. from ninety-three of the
1G5 counties in the state The probability
is that Stubbs's plurality Will exceed 10.Go@.
Definite figures have not been received on
the rest Of the ticket, but it is conceded
that other Republican state candidates won
by approximately 25.Ooo-
The complexion Of the next House OF
Representatives is in doubt. The Senate.
which is elected only in Presidential years.
is Republican The eight Republican Con-
gress candidates were elected
New-York tribune., 1910-11-10
LANDSLIDE IN ILLINOIS
Democrats Make a Clean Sweep in
Cook County.

Chicago. Nov. 9.-The result OF yesterday &
election in Illinois furnished one of the
greatest surprises in the entire country. AL
though pictured as in the best shape of any
state in the Middle West, from the Repub-
lfcan standpoint. nowhere was the Demo-
cratic landslide more pronounced.
The Democrats made d clean sweep In
Cook County. For the first time in fourteen
years the party reigns supreme here. With
pluralities ranging from 1900 to 25.0O0, the
Democrats captured the offices of Sheru,
County Treasurer. County Clerk Probate
Judge. County Judge. County Superintend-
ent of Schools and. In fact, every county
office. The Republicans did not elect sin
gle candidate on the county ticket
Aside from the county offices, the election
was important to the Democrats as lndicat-
ing their chances of electng a Mayor OF
Chicago next spring.
New-York tribune., 1910-11-10
BARNES ON PARTY'S DEFEAT
Democratic Victory Was a Vote
Against One Man Power. He Saws
IN Telegranh tn Thn Trihnl


Albany, Nov. 9.-In an editorial tonight
William Barnes, jr.. commenting on the
election, says:
lndIvldualism in politics is accountable
ior the defeat of the Republican party in
THIS state. The trend in that direction was
indicated III 1908. when Charles r. Hughes
received plurality of only So 1862 for Gov
ernor, while William II. Taft received a.
plurality OF POP 6O2 1t is possible that the
party was fated to be defeated even IL
RooSeVeltism had not been injected into
the situation. That factor turned possibil-
lty INTO certainty and gave the Democratic
victory the overwhelming proportions that
are in evidence
The vote by which the Democratic can
dldates were elected was cast not so much
for the Democratic party as against the
one man power that had become dominant
in the Republican party. The American
people hate dictatorship 1t killed Will
lam j. Bryan in his own party. 1t means
the political death of any man in any
party who attempts it.
And now it behOOves the party to accept
this defeat as wholesome lesson and un-
dertake the task of restoration upon the
only basis upon which a party can Sc
curey rest that of organization in which
the leadership and counsel OF many consti-
tute the power that insures solidarity and
strength and In which solitary individ-
ual may presume to dictate to all the rest
If the lesson is taken to heart it will be
worth the price.
New-York tribune., 1910-11-10

II. Hotchkiss. Of Buffalo. February Ia.
.lal2: $1,000. three years
Superintendent OF Banks. Orion II.
= Cheney. Of New York; November "a.
1912: $1,000. three years.
l. Public Service Commissioners. LIST Dis
--1rict, Edward NJ. Bassett. February l.
= 1911. and William McCarroll, February
: /, 1912. S15.o0e. five years.
Public Service Commissioners I'd Dis
trict John y. Carlisle, of Watertown.
February 1. 1911, and John r. olmstead.
. OF Buffalo. February 1. 1912: $4,000.
p five years.
Commissioner Of EXercise-Maynaro q
y. Clement. of Canandaigua, May > 1911.
$1,000, five years. has the appointment
Of 2 deputy. second deputy. thirteen spe-
cial deputies and sixty special agents.
Superintendent Of Public Works
Frederick Z. Stevens, Of Attica, Decem-
her 81. 1910. $4,000. has the appointment
OF q deputy and three assistant superin-
1endents.
Commissioner Of Agriculture-Ray-
mond A. Pearson. Of Ithaca. April 16.
1911. $4,000, three years, has the ap-
pontment of such assistant commission
crs as he may deem necessary.
Commissioner of Forest, Fish and
Gsme-H. Leroy Austen. temporary ap-
pointment, $1,000, four years.
Two State Tax Commissioners-Fran
Z. Perley. Of White Plains, January L,
1911: Egburt Z Woodbury., jamestown,
January s, 1912, $4,000. three years.
Commissioner of Labor, John Will
iams. of TItics, October ,, 1911. 5000
four years: has the appointment Of two
deputies.
Water Supply Commissioners. Charles
Davis. Of Saugerties, May ,, 1911; Milo
NJ Acker, Hornell. June 3, 1917, So,ooo,
five years.
Health officer of The Port Of New
York. DIR. Alvah II. Doty, February %,
1911; total compensation, out of which
some expenses are TO be paid, Sl2.oOo,
four years. u
Commissioner of Highways. Robert
Earl. Herkimer. February Il, 1911.
5000 six years
II is probable that the result of the
vote on the proposition to bond the state
for s. 10000 in aid Of the Palisades
Park project toward which Mrs. Edward
H Hartman has contributed a loooo-
ecre tract and 81 ,090,G00, viii not be
known until the State Board of Canvas
sers meets next month. The same is
srue Of the constitutional amendment
!aoroviding for the election OF two addl-
Tional Judges of the Court of Appeals
hand for increasing the salaries OF the
i,nembers OF the court. Both, II is ex-
Epected- were carried.
New-York tribune., 1910-11-10
MR.. WATTERSON'S VIEWS
Advises Democrats Who Have
AT Last Seen the Light.
NV Tel graph 10 TIE Tribune.

Rv Tel graph 10 lie lTlpulle.l
Louisville. Nov. 9.-Henry Watterson IN
The Courier-Journal" will say In part TO-
morrow:
The people still rule for the Demo-
Gratis; it never rains but it pours. Ihis
election secures us against the peril ailke
of the one party oligarchy and the one man
power II gives assurance Of thA survival
of wise and genuine Democratic leadership
it tells the country that after years OF
inglorious speculation on the popular
credulity marked by one after another OF
disappointing paramount issues as with
disheartening rainbow chasing. the Demo-
cratic leaders have seen the light.
Taking a long look backward and seek
Ing to shape the future by the instruction
Of our various misleading in the past. the
way ahead ought to be tolerably plain. We
shall not have the ma jOrities in the two
houses of Congress to control, we can only
in the lower house foreshadow and fOrmu-
late legislation with this lower house of
the new Congress, therefore. an eXtraOrdi-
nary responsibility will rest: upon its wis
dom or folly will depend the election of
Democratic President in 1912.
THE one great question which has proved
a stumbling block to all parties is the
tariff: if we go to pieces on any rock we
shall go 10 pieces there. But with firm,
clear sighted man in the Speakership such
as we believe Champ Clark will show him
self TO be. and sure footed, courageous
and conscientious Ways and Means Com
mittee. a measure of revenue reform may
be constructed on which we may go 10 the
country united and confident
1.-The true Democratic gospel as to the
tariff is laid in the basic principle that the
government has right in equity or law to
levy and collect dollar of taxation except
for its own support This is an exact con-
tTadictiOn of the doctrine that taxes may
be levied for the benefit or protection of
favored industries and preferred classes.
The Republican party stands for the latter,
the Democratic party stands for the former !;
thus the issue between protective tariff
and a revenue tariff is absolute and in
cisiVe.
But we have had nearly fifty years of a
protective tariff. Hundreds Of millions of
money have been invested and are yet en-
barl<ed upon the facts of this Hundreds
of thousands of people look to it for their
prosperity and support. 1t cannot he pre-
cipitately Withdrawn. If we are 10 change
our policy from a protective system to a
revenue system 1t must be done so
gradually and with such regard for the
business of the country. which stands
greatly in need of rest. that the final tran
sition shall be as the passing from one sea
son to another, every interest warned be-
forehand and fully prepared"
New-York tribune., 1910-11-10
PINCHOT TALKS ON ELECi'o~
Rebuke to Reactionaries' Gays
Former Chief Forester

Discussing Tuesdays elections ifo" '''0
progressive, nont Of view. clifford Pm
chot. the former Chief Forester
United States. said yesterday:
THE lesson of this election Is
the country as a whole it is ali over ii'''''
ing rebuke to the reactionaries' ai''
mistakable demand for the kind OF pioe' '9'
for which the insurgents stand Inc i'
turns / have seen Indicate that not '''
gle insurgent Republican canoiu"''
Governor was defeated. and that WIN ~"
exceptions. every stand-pat hep
candidate was beaten by DeInoei a. ,,e
Elections for Congress tell the
story. There are exceptions but theE ~
not change the great general fact
orl,, serious resistance which the Repu'ii
cans were able to make to the great Deino-
cratic landslide was made by the men WIN
we're frankly and fearlessly insurgeh'.
.yyhere the administration was Idc'o'
!, Tho caunsicn. as In Ohio and New hoih'
the Democrats won. Where the hep
cans did not support the administrator %
in California, Kansas and Wisconsin, '''0
Republicans won. .ho
1T is clear that the people resent 'iie
failure of the Republicans to stand between
them and the domination of the great lilte'
state and public service corporations anu
that they believe that Congress mas no'
kent faith with the people in regard 10 inc
tariff The iniquitous schedules OF tile
Payne- Aldrich tariff. under whlch II II
harder for the average man TO obtain the
necessities of life than it was before are
evidently the heaviest burden the hepuo-
lican party has had to bear.
when the Republican Congress and the
Republican President broke their faith with
the people by approving this law they mace
their own defeat inevitable. BY refusing
relief to the people of the country they
forced them to go to the Democrats. 1t is
perfectly evident that the Republican party
must be reorganized on vigorously pro-
gressive lines or must go out of business
altogether"
New-York tribune., 1910-11-10
BEvER|DCE DEFEATED
Indiana Legislature Democratic
by a Majority of 90.
KERN WILL GO TO SENATE
Twelve of the Thirteen Congress
men Elected Are Dem
ocrats.

Indianapolis. Nov. 9.-SenahDr A J. Bev-
eridge's hopes for another term at Wash
ington went glimmering tonight. when
late returns showed concIusiveIy that the
Democrats yesterday elected a majority of
the members Of the Indiana Assembly.
which will meet next January to choose
Mr.. Beveridge's successor
According to the latest figures. the Demo
Gratis will have majority on Joint ballot
of %. John W. Kern was indorsed last
spring by the Democrats for United States
Senator. and in all probability he will be-
came the colleague of Senator Shively,
also Democrat.
1t is conceded tonight that the Demo
cratic state ticket was elected by a plural
ity OF about 1900.
OF the thirteen Indiana Congressmen
twelve will be Democrats. Edgar Dean
CrumpacIzer. of the eth District. was the
only Republican elected.
Senator Beveridge tonight admitted that
the tide was against him. He wrote the
following statement:
Fortunes OF war; II is all right; twelve
years of hard work; clean record; am
content"
For the first time in thirteen years the
Democrats have control of every branch OF
the state government. the two United
States Senators and all except one member
Of the Congressional delegation.
Governor Marshalrs term has two years
to run. The next State Senate will be
Democrats by ten and the House Demo
cratic by twenty-five The programme of
Democratic legislation as announced IN the
party's platform includes repeal Of the
county option law and the substitution Of
a law providing for city. ward and rural
township option units.
New-York tribune., 1910-11-10
NO LANDSLIDE IN MINNESOTA
EheriIa:t, Republican, Elected Governor
by Over $4,000.

st. Paul. Nov. 9.-WhiIe Republican can
didates were going down to defeat before
a Democratic landslide elsewhere. condi-
tions were reversed In Minnesota, where
Adolph O Eberhart defeated his Demo
cratic opponent. James Gray, for Governor
by an oldtine majority. For three state
elections pr'or to this the late John A.
Johnson. Democrat carried the state by
Overwhelming majorities.
The latest figures show that Eberhart has
been elected by more than 5000 lie car
ried every county in the state. The Lesis-
la,ure is Republican.
All of the candidates for Congress who
have been elected are Republicans, except
Congressman Hammond. Democrat
New-York tribune., 1910-11-10
LITTLEToN DEFEATS COCKS
Carries Three Counties with 1856 Plu
rality-Wife HELPS Him.

martin w. Lttleton. the lawyer, who as
inc democratic candidate. put up strong
Isnt against W. w. Cocks for Congress
aiit, e ist -Dslstrict, was elected with a piur-
"'iiS ~. .. nar.i f,SN' over his opponent ,.
Nassav y"Irled IISd the three counties. Queens ms
district During his camnsien Mrs. Little
their iSohalIy called on the voters an aIo
ing tbeN,e bTes and gave them pamphlet, 'ei,,
elected why her husband shoniu oe
New-York tribune., 1910-11-10
F0SS'S PLURALITY. $685.
Revised Figures in Massachu-
setts Increase Democrats Lead.

Boston. Nov. 9.-Revised returns for Gov
ernor from the entire state We're as fol-
lows: Eugene II. Foss Oem), go, ,14S: Eben
s. Draper Rep9. 1S7,16i. Foss's plurality.
81. .9S7.
Complete returns for Lieutenant Gov
ernor are: Louis A. rockingham (Rep).
l9S,2s2: Thomas F. Cassidy Dem). 1876, l5S
Frothingham's plurality, 5.134.
The next Legislature will stand as fol-
lows: Senate, Republicans, -; Democrats.
10: House, Republicans. lbs: Democrats, Ill.
and Socialists, l.
The new Legislature Will decide whether
United states Senator Henry Cabot Lodge
shall be given another term. and in the
joint convention the Republicans will have
153 to l26 votes for the Democrats.
New-York tribune., 1910-11-10
BAss's PLURALITY INCREASED
Revised Figures Give New Hampshire
Republican Nominee Z 600

concord. X. IL. Nov. 9-PracticaIly com
pie1e returns from yesterdays state cleo
ton slightly amplify The extent of the Re
publican victory The revised figures give
Robert =. Bass. the Republican nominee
for Governor. a plurality Of very nearly
7ea1 With $50 out of go towns and wards
in the state heard from. the result stands
Bass RepD. for Governor. 42.59S.
carr tDemA. for Governor. 35.549
rurrier and SulloWay. both Republicans.
have been returned TO Congress. the former
~ 3 plurality Of 5000 and the latter 10y
plurality Of somewhat less than loo
The next Legislature VIII be overwhelm-
inEly Republican.
New-York tribune., 1910-11-10
INSURGENTS I'M CONTROL
Democrats Gain Nine Seats in
Senate-BeVeridge Beaten.

A Democratic gain of nine seats in the
Senate is practically assured as a result of
Tuesdays landslide. The states which seem
certain TO replace Republican with Demo
cratic Senators are New York. New Jersey,
Maine, Ohio, West Virginia, Indiana, Mis-
souri,, Nebraska and Montana.
Both sides are still claiming control of
the Indiana Legislature on joint ballot. and
the official count may be required to deter
mine whether the Hoosier State is to be
represented by 1.-The boy orator of the Wa
New-York tribune., 1910-11-10
SOUTH DAKOTA REPUBLICAN
Governor, Congressman and Majority
in Legislature Reelected

Sioux Falls. s. d. Nov 9--I.ate returns
make il certain that the Republicans have
made a clean sweep in South Dakota
Governor Kesscy is reelected and the re
rnainder Of the state ticket Is also elected
Republicans also elected their two nonli-
noes for the State Supreme Court and a
large ma j0riiy OF the members OF the Leg
lSlsturC.
Congressman Martin and Burke Repub-
licsns. are reelected. indications are that
none Of the Republican ma iorities will run
f-ndrT I. (a1l 70 u 0sA
New-York tribune., 1910-11-10

GENEsEE. RENSSELAER,.
c. Bryant, X l. Sired c. Filley, r.
?. 'B. c. Lansing r
GREENE
.J L. Patrie, ID. RICHMOND.
w. A. Shortt, d.
HERKIMER.
]. Bredenbecker, ID. RoCkLAND.
q. A. Blauvelt, ID.
JEFFERSON
/ T.. W. Day. ID. LA =" II fNr>4>>"
% q Jones. r I. "F. J. Gray. r.
?. 'E. A. Merritt ,jr. r
KINGS.
I. E. r. Terry. d. SARATOGA.
. sW J. Gillen. D. w. NJ. Martin, ID.
? IN A. O'Neil. d
~, Do,a,.a SCHENECTADY.
s. A +. Lent. r. j. e Meyers IL.
- -, - sCHOHARIE.
,,aI I'D. D. Frisbie. D.
8. az. O'Connor. ID. SCuIryLFR
10 F NJ. Ahearn r. c,.. ~
IL. sW w. Colne, r.
IL S. W. Frye, d. SENECA
g. -JH. Donneny,D. &C. w Cossd n
"A. -James Z. Fay, ID.
i5 81. J. O'Neill, ID. STEUBEN.
16. J. + Jameson, ID. 1. Thos Shannon, R.
II. sE. A. Ebbetts. r. . John SeeIev n
IS. A W. Hon. r.
70. J SchiHerdeckr, d. SUFFOLK.
60 G. F. Carew, D. /. DIV. C.Talmage, R
q. H. Heyman, ID. 2. F. Scheide, D.
Q. J. T. Geatons, d.
%. L. Goldstein, D. SULLIVAN.
y. X Evans, D.
LEWIS
r. e. Gregg, D. TIOGA
Otis S. Beach. D.
J. c. Winters, r. iohFhlNS.
u.0rcoN NJ McDaniels. D.
sK b. Delano, r. OLo Elk
o,-,oZ /. G. Washburne, d.
]. sE H. White, r. O. 49,
2 S. L. Adler, r. WARREN.
v Pappert. r HE. II. Brereton, r.
T. &C. W. Phillips, r. WASHINGTON.
5. W. I. Keys H. 81. S. Parker, r.
MONTGOMERY. WAYNE.
r. A. Brace d. Yeomans. r.
NASSAU. wEsTCHEsTER.
H H Holman, d. !. H. W. Haines, r.
NIAGARA. ?. "w. S. Coffey, r.
n L Could n 3. sF. ~. Young, r.
. IA Corstan+,e l. -J. A. Goodman, R
oNE1D. WYOMING.
1. 81. w. Manley. d. n a. fieiee' H.
2 'H. E. Allen. r. YATES.
8. %. c. Cross, r. Frank Collin. D.
'Renominated