The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-06-27

0nly By sluaB e AlazH 90 Prouhhsa CAn
n Ne umaaGstood.

WY " .NNMI MMMAA ulNU NNWNNNNNNNNA " ~
n Ne UnaaEstoaa.
"a -,n w.,-,, a.. ,r,,v arr a.. wall.
80 ~ ~ iN...' a. - a., - r.. az
49, /. s.lyiv .cc,,,.,s dsanl,,on ~ s,at.
so,,,.l,.,s t.i.S n go =, coov,y A.. tr,,s
.n,i 81, .,.,...slo, A. $500 .ocis,,sm a.
!. !. W., ~ SS"0''''o' " W
Modern socialism ID primarily . protest
agalRat the present methods Of the distTi-
button Of wealth. against capitalism 40
economlst divides wealth into four parts,
wares. rent. Intarosf and pFoata. There
,re thr.s f.canrS sssuntl.I "a modern Dro-
duction. namely. labor. land ana capital
and the holders of Ne lAsi two. land ana cap
ltnl. receive to-day IN the distribution Of the
n-,',,,., J. 49, ,ronortl,n aatlmatad Al
~. - ...,-i a. 80 l.,.--
~ y % ~ y ~ 800 an VI '' ''
NOw modern socialism eOniaAda that the
h.lI..,. ID 49, T, -, $780,. go ana cant
~, ~ .s',ss -, A. 1870,
81 ~ ne. 1u-y sa.' ~, - ,,,',,,,,.., /.
much Ia lars. FOR what they contribute 10
nr,A,,c.s,. 80 !. r,sdS a, OV, laral prlvllags
- - 49,. ..-.i,,... an
OF monopoy' tne. a. iaoo. ,,l..s -.
wealth iaoor seonsd receive = ~. asI 80 80
49, ~ 49,. ~ :. - -. ,o-dsv
-, ~. 49, y, .A. 49,, -.-s l,tsrs.s
Inv Msuupsat n'aus 49, 49,. -.
and DrOhts, the trinity OF usury' result JON
larnl priv,leae or monopoly and are simply
StT.-sn, 1900. ~ Isvv,na tribute for the
49, =, -. -. 80 ,,,,vn
use o. eaplAL Ins pI'nS'v,s 49, =. -.
oY Adam smith IN the eas.I cnap9sfs " 49,
Wealth Of Nations that labor - We Hus
measure Oh price, and the econ0uAlo prln,
ctplaa Of modern socialism Are lofleal
deduction nom that propo9Iien. 49,
asaaotions we're nrat mace ndepenpeaiy
foandsgs and thinlSera Of the mOvsHaen!.
Ramaly, Josiah Warren, an Amerlcag, n =,
ProudhoA, q Freedman. and kari MarA'
German Jew. -,,.,-,
me treatment Of eoclety By political
economists has generally been a. y ehl.S'
and Of the dintTibHtion Of wealth. az " q 70
day. but those three men insisted upon 90.
ing 81 aocisty and the distribution o. weaItn
A. they should be. Mhle a9Ieetng " @tn
premises that tho oxiatlhs order Of ne az
iFibntlOn Of wealth vas most unjust ana ne
result OF lagal privilege, - has been said,
they differed radically IN tner Ietaegtss
They al held that each pToducer ahoun ~
that thS natural WaRs Of labor 10 lts product.
and that this product or WaGo n the only
lust source OF income, not counting OF
course lnheritanoesO o. gifts. They saw, how.
ever that lsrss psSRrsSss SI se psSS tSs
Tis6tfTl owners Sy The holders Of legal priv
ileRn. which a. I have said assumed IN
~ chief lorna interest. rent and profits
Privileges, II is maintained. y ne anu tl tncsis
aral rule 81 competition, because privilege
enables ~ holder 70 extract part OF the prt-
Vats property Of others. How 70 ave LABOR
lts due. how 70 restore Justice IN the disui-
button that was the question.
in this solutiOn Kari MARI turned one way
toward authority and established The foun-
dalton OF state socialism which has been
happily described 81 the doctrine that al
he G Cover M Mt rsgSTdlsas Of individual
choice MARI concluded that the only
Way 10 abolish privilege and class monopO-
lies vas, 81 has been said by another. 20
and commeTcial intsresta, al productive
and dlsiTibutive agencies in one vast mon
oDolV In the hands Of the state All com
ostlfion and individual initiative muat ~
1870 merchapt banksC and Inanufas-
,,irsr All isNd and raw material, an tools
s@d as.ocirs al production must belong 20
lie ~fSts Ths individual may OWn the
nToAs,Sts 70 ba co1@umed, but not the means
~ ~ nsoi,,ci1S tbem' lie nav own H.
riotkss mt not the machine that makes
fhsm - food. but not the tOola that pro
dIcs n livery man viii be 81 employee
i've 10 male ! rroai out 81 themselves
49,, hi1s, a,,,sf y. done On the cost min
sl,.a. ,. ~ bs.is that iahor i m, trUe
o,.-suSe az price The state will be sn-
.S.-s n, ~ doctyjSe resi-. Wpon he y bor
-, All ~, '.vi5is has ssked WhIeh 9hor
S,sts Tkers Il q rrsat difference In me
selcieney oh diHsrsnt workers, and Which
sss.......,,l-.( A. ~ ~ eaEswS Again ths ZANE
$1,000 $1,000, 80 sIo,,st a. 49, ipon soms
$3.50 '.tii ,.ss,,,.,s foTSv b,,sbeis AZ WheSt III
,ki -. S."siis =, erhsr 100 M vIill nTosl,,cs
M ,s.',,, S,,sbSis, snd nav thsS = ~
value q the Sascs 70 RS 1,sssis.sa labor
eSstf hsN 49,. - .ii 49,. s,..,a L.
- -ll,:,,.s - ~ d,S1Tihntles M SSIsitb
$3.50 n, AT hoyitv Pvoidbon and warren
ushsl .i s.s;,.'"ah,c snsSchisn ar MAJ
may hksw'ie es tsrnsa tS' .s sossS .,s,
NJ nie u, ~. sssirs M men shogld Ss mS1sSsi
~ ins', v,aass ~ WI 10y A"u
ihas W. ~ ~ ~, is,.s.s,n.r q, IT,
t.'t a., A. -. ~
i', -, -, hsgs r.f.rri "a
rs.,ns = rent: interest ere; q, nd gES. rested
~ - sa-sss,il.@, tbis .1thSStrv "a NsST
49,, ~ y, ,i.tTov 4 1iisrs1 sad s,s
t,i, .,,sS q. 49, Hs bsld ihai frsS on,.
pe,i,ioH i9 sll freely rfPsSd1ciels Foods
oS'o " e
aa, ~. ,,s,,l, ~ ,s..,,,,ss ~, ~,
arivisS asSs. dawn ,SwaSj ne s,srvStIS1
point, nd ~ r1asSs y 49, 81 31.iHsgs
" 49, n. - -, a 49, go
~, $500. - "a ~ ny =. ~
...eiIsus..Si ss,,s EsSSlg, ~ 80 ~ IA
$500 ,1, .,onay and al he,sse rsnf and
"A s.,s - ~ No. Z. ,oi1,t ~ tbs 49,.
~ s'o ~ ~. ,..s,.,s I'm tsss '"s
49, - I 49,. .hs,s-,, -,autad IN .nn-.-
-. !, 49,. M ',.s.s's-,, Iii -sSpsl,I
~ N. st.ts tS,s sSriSliSiR@ ~ e@nSFssiS
p,,,,.i ,,,,id mi = 49, On .,,sh 4 Man -
40 isSoi,,si b,sf ~ aimed nsvs,sS sl.-ss
- go L. S-Fss't. ~ S..aiiS,S M. -
9cis5 ~ ~ trstssd AZ 4 '1Is9S a. jT.osS,-