The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-06-04

declared mat u Would - Tar ueNeet toI
IN. Senate 20 vote on the pending amend
usuf without any suggestion that Judges
cannot l- trusted
senator hal. 'hereupon arose and paid
btgl 0r.Ir.fs fn Chief Justice Fuller NJ
sid
4 30 me- assume that Il ~ the intent
and ymyrsc - the author ~ this amend
nert r, cast reflection on IN" Chief
Justice hgt w. ought not IN enact any
lAw 'E.' ,an nv psrverslon be- construed
~ Cd reflection on the gr'at chief Justice
" th. court The present Chief Justice
Ia. been holding iust1gr with an even
hand f,r MANY wears. and there never
has laau a Suggestion that hs lives not
measure up m every gp-pe"t 10 the high
'tanments and traditions NJ that great
one No amendment that can be
construed ~ reflection VA the Chief
Justice should "a touched hv tho senate
II the United states The present Chief
Justice has made &. great maine mr. hlm-
SELF and rt should 20 down IN history.
Lei The senate ,Ill fbi, amendment by
great maIorifv
senators clay. RaNnn and Beveudgs
fastened t0 add t1eir assurance that no
reflection was Intended ON Oh" thiei
Justice
senator Gore .ald be saw No reason
% pIt ou airs about rne amendment.
when be though. involved merely a
prac-cal question he -atd d. agreed
with Thom-s jefferson rhl' Judges are
a. honest AZ 1fher men aud not more 90
The amendment was voted down. y
70 50
An amendment offered hv senator
Ia Toilette tn prevent the appointment
81 any person A. q member NJ the proposed
Court ~ Commerce who owns stocks or
bonds IN any railroad or who has any
relation with any common carriers was
defeated the vote being - m favor and
70 against
An echo " senator - Follstte- last
sumner Chlutsu0uI career was heard
when several senators questioned IN.
nrOpEIptv Of member IT congress
singing out senator u- Representative
hon g roll call vpt. Tor rhe 'gihCauun 1T
Chautauoul audiences senator Ia fol-
lette nd not dodge bat announced that
he not univ bold M frr rha bench, ~ audi
enoss tie rrr1rd Vote n. Senators md
Repra-sntatives bu' 10, ard that hs
would continue N dn go IN the future
! have rad rh- roll oyslI vote made
IN Congress o. numerous audiences sad
The Wisconsin Senator In presenting
these records I have made un comment
and have SIMPLY lsft in. facts a. the
people wholrr always capable II forming
their own conclusions
senator GgIlIu.er asked % u Nl- t.ir Goo
read before great thtutauUu. audrnre
the vote = Sarainr. when u The nature &
II N ms reasons that lC'uatsd the vote
Couli Not bp pr. -eutnd Hr did uui believe
that any person appointed on tho com
mere rUur' would hniG -.cUriti,S ot .
raiTpaG> AMI for that rpa son he aid h.
would vote aggiast the amendment
Sen.t,r L., Follrtf" sad in rruiy iha'
tAFrc ntd b"sn Instances 90 Federal
Judge holding railroad securities and .
thai m Huc clss "a iefsrli Judge Was So .
SENSITIVE about this matter that Ne had .
Withdrawn srusn the Cs~s W., did not
beleye ilsai To" ii',s, -en~r of horror sna-
gesisd-by NsttstJT t,llireer wrutd run-
tool "a the Cas-s ot certain Judges, he ,
said II was wel' 90 make t inpUss ihle 2
faT Judges On th- 'ouvt 1T Commerce
- h"t securities rat might Influence
them
An amendment providing Tor boiler
TufarIfHU tIen Vas Intrpd cod hv SeUa-
tNr - tHllstt' Ouf was withdrawn when
sstralC" was given by Senator Elkns .
thai Oh, Interstate Jbmrurrst' COMMITTEE,
would g.'bn flr neat v-rs rspcr' tll .
containing Do" rEar' PROVISIONS - the
pend'g amendment
bI-Cuss,u0 r on. numerous a. FolIsfts
amendment consumed nearly tho entire
dsy bgl t.n N-uHfs Tad been figuring IN
bringing The lul % % vote surely bv y
O'Clock just about tho lime 'htr nvrrv.
BODY wac incest hopeful senator New.
lands Jumped Ip ana started t0 urge
he national Incorporation idea for about
tho twentieth ',W"
the Nevada senator 10 ,ut short his 70
marks uu' they wsr. rs no pu-pdse
Senator A'drDh went over ant whispered
90 hun rha pc could have au ave ard uu
on hls amendment la.Hr senator EIkIus
sat Gown Hv senator Nsw .ancs .f1 after
tuggir a. 1ls cua' 'aIl 'o get hiz attention
pieadcI sIfb uIm u an Upderton. Inc
Senator rom Nevada SIMPLY snie|
AMI CoLtuuei with lIs speech senators
laughed outu GIN a. these laCJDs 'o cali
OF Senator NeViaUi- After obtaining
. promise that his amendment would D."
adOpted IN the form OF resolution the F.
Senator from Nevada brought M remarks
20 an END and his Amendment on beng
put 90 a vote was defeated
MaEv Senators de~arts frr ~erar.
chamber tor the restau-arr a. 30 DIS.
cusslon progressed. fHr understanding
beng that tn-rp wOu.u no. o. .r.f.rla..
n ght session Following -rfech by
Senator Rarpr vt Geo ga 100 1rHos.rou
% me bill senator BorIH ad'rsasoT Tho
benate ln opposition ip mo court ~
commerce Ur1v1s on he appaafr.t 'p mo H.
senate not 90 CuauEr al aruieas ana
revereI institution OFT tho Government
without grea auI .mneIHrr reason.
n YOU re"U NOR" ta-rrII Judge
SAID Serafo. Bran. .aruuIu' fnerr. az.
N there are arg Jur~e, moon patart
LnHrTT. @ If..s.H.l tina H.a........ .
Of the people f0T tHr.. .lurr- our u.,r-
cal svsteu s ." adm .~,l ON off rln ,.v. .- P
iza7 vor J.. 80 Hu.l property have
Awavs bepu "ufratef % 'aur court.
and thev have leeu -Icoos.hIl. n
remained !nr The great railway sys-
tens d. Cngga'f on irr laS me corri
OF CON arCr ''atuTD f.r tlpir Dwr use
Sera .r VERY. Democrat NJ Indiana
oondemned the bIl and annOunce-i that
be would vote against ~
senator Gore characterized the measure
a. a founding that had heen lef, on the
senate doorstsp. lie said that Francis
Lvnie StetECu and Victor NorOwitz had
drawn The antitrust bln ami he wanted
70 know What distinguished corporation
attorne-s hal drawn tho railway bill
Senator SWwoE' 81 North Carolina
commended features u the bill and re-
Offered lis physical valuation amendment
i wac again voted doSu and a roll call
vote was denied the senator.
4 neE long and short haul amendment,
offered Nv senator Hevhuru. also was
voted down. The ayes hengl and the
noes ~
senator IA FoIlet,e came forward
once more with his physical valuation
proposition. This was the fourth time
thai he had introduced u IN the
present -esslon Of Congress and this time
b. HH.4 - !