Arizona republican., 1910-11-29

posed the sale of any of the state | lands last Saturday and was based ' on the fact that the memorial was
 not necessary. They said that the
 settlers were already protected in the public lands proposition that had
 been adopted. On the other hand it
 was shown that the convention or the legislature could not afford the settlers the relief asked for Messrs
 Orme and Ellinwood described the
 omission of this provision from the
 enabling act and the opinion of sen l ators and representatives that such legislation as was asked for was nee
 essary.
 Mir. Cunniff objected not to the spirit but to the form of the memo | rial which stated that the settlers
 nave put everything they have" into
 the improvements. MT. Cunniff said
 that the convention was a dignified
 body and that the congress of the United States was another dignified body. Therefore any communication
 that passed between them should be dignified document. He also ob- jected to the language of the memo
 rial ''instructing the delegate in con gress." The memorial was adopted by a vote of 41 to 7
 Medical Bill Passes.
 It had been expected that there would be a spirited contest over the proposition prohibiting the discrin-
 ination by the legislature against any
 school of medicine or form of heal
 ing. This proposition had been in-
 definitely postponed The vote by which it was done had been recon
 sidered and the bill was set for ac-
 ton on Saturday But other matters
 crowded it over until yesterday. No opposition developed It quietly went
 to a vote and was recommended for adoption by a vote of 90 to IS
 There was an interesting struggle over substitute for proposition 5S reported from the committee on cor porations other than railroads. It was hoped by the more advanced corpora ation regulators that private corporations which had escaped the supervision of the proposed corpora tion commission last week might yet be brought within their power The ] large mining companies were espe- cially aimed at.
 The first section of this proposition provided that the records, books and files of all corporations shall be at all times liable and subject to the fun visitorial and inquisitOriaI pow CTS of the state, notwithstanding the immunities and privileges of the bill of rights. secured to per sbns and individuals"
 MT. Goldwater who had led the fight against the corporation com mission bill in behalf of other than public service corporations offered to amend this one by the insertion of the. words. @public service" before corporations" Chairman Ingraham of. the standing committee said that it was necessary that. the state be given power to stick its nose" into the business of private corporations. otherwise there could be no such in vestigations as the Armstrong inquiry which uncovered the insurance rot tenness in New York The statement was also made that the proposed pro vision was in the constitution of many states. MT. EillHNOou, m Ttply' Sdlu that there was no such provision in the | constitution of New York or in that of any other state in this blessed l union except that of Oklahoma
 MT. Curtis said he would favor an l amendment which would bring the | financial institutions under such su- pervision by the state as had been | proposed but he would oppose the | extension of the power over all cor porations large and small.
 Mir. Lynch believed that the pro- | posed legislation was unnecessary. The | was a creature of the | state and in its creation. the state could impose such terms and condi- | tons as seemed best
 Mir. Roberts proposed an amend ment to the GOldwater amendment including banks, trust companies. building and loan associations and guaranty companies. The amended