davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The Spokane press. [volume] (Spokane, Wash.) 1902-1939, 1910-05-14
FOURTH INNING.

Seattle -: 0
Spokane-Weed flies to Frisk :;
Flood out, Raymond to Adams; Ost-
dick hits; .Nordyke goes to sleep
and the Seattle team en- masse tag
him out. No runs.
Seattle-Lynch flies to Davis !;
Frisk walks and goes to second on
a passed ball; Akin walks; John
ston out, Flood to Nordyke; Shea
out, Flood to Nordyke. No runs.
The Spokane press. [volume] (Spokane, Wash.) 1902-1939, 1910-05-14
FIFTH INNING.

FIFTH INNING.
Vancouver .......... 0
For Tacoma Gaddy struck out.
ROckenfield flew out to Flanagan,
Pat making a fine running catch.
Mott hit a little pop to Breen, but
Rick fumbled it. Mott stole second.
Bassey struck out. No runs.
| For Vancouver Lewis hit a
grounder to third, but Coleman's
throw was low to first and Lewis
was safe. Gardner hit a grounder
to lansing and Lewis was forced at
| second. Swain hit one to Rocken-
field and he touched second and
threw to Mott in time to make a
double play. No runs.
SIXTH INNING.
iaCoind ............
For Tacoma Hartman struck out.
Stevens was given pass. Stevens
stole second. lansing knocked a
grounder to short, Stevens going
to third. Coleman hit a grounder
to Scharney. No runs.
For Vancouver Breen was given
| base on balls. Breen stole Sec
ond. Streib was given a pass also.
Breen stole third. Streib going to
second. Flanagan struck out,
Bobby James flied into left, Bassey
| making a good catch and throwing
| Streib out at second.
The game was called in the
sixth to allow a locrosse game to be
played.
The Spokane press. [volume] (Spokane, Wash.) 1902-1939, 1910-05-14
FIFTH INNING.

Sppkane ......... ............ 0
SuAttle .....,...,...... ....... U
Spokane-Bonner fans: Davis
flies to Frisk; Cooney out to
Adams. No runs.
Seattle-Hendricks fans; Ray
flies to Weed: Adams out, Cooney
to Nordyke. No runs.
The Spokane press. [volume] (Spokane, Wash.) 1902-1939, 1910-05-14
SECOND INNING.

SPOKANE ........ |
oedtlie .......... U
Spokane-Nordyke hits for two
bags; Weed sacrifices; Flood
bunts; Hendricks boots the ball, al.
lowing Nordyke to score; Flood
safe on first; Ostdiek out, Bennett
to Adams; Bonner out, Raymond
to Adams. One run.
Seattle-Lynch flies to Cooney;
Frisk hit by pitched ball; Akin
forces Frisk at second; Johnston
forces Akin at second. No runs.
The Spokane press. [volume] (Spokane, Wash.) 1902-1939, 1910-05-14
THIRD INNING.

Spokane ......... ........... u
oNptAiN "
Spokane-Davis walks; Cooney
hits; Cartwright sacrifices; Kip,
pert hits to pitcher, who cuts off
Davis at the plate; Nordyke out,
BeNnett to Adams. No runs.
Seattle<Shea out, Cartwright to
Nordyke; Hendricks singles to
fence; Raymond out. Cartwright to
Nordyke, Adams safe on fly;
Adams steals second; Bennett flies
to Kippert No runs.
The Spokane press. [volume] (Spokane, Wash.) 1902-1939, 1910-05-14
FIRST INNING.

spokane ....... ............
Seattle ....... @
Spokane-DaviS flies to FriSk 3;
COOney hits for two bases; Cart
wright out, Bennett to Adams ;
Cooney scores on wild pitch; Kip
pert flies to Johnston. One run.
Seattle-Raymond out, Cart
wright to Nordyke; Adams out,
Cartwright to Nordyke; Bennett
out. Cartwright to Nordyke. No
runs.
The Spokane press. [volume] (Spokane, Wash.) 1902-1939, 1910-05-14
FOURTH INNING.

NdutOuNtl U
For Tacoma lansing hit a
grounder to Bobby James. Cole
man hit fast grounder to Schar-
ney Bliss struck out No runs.
For Vancouver. Streib hit beau
ty for two bases to right field
Flanagan flew out to center. James
singled to left Capron flew out
The Spokane press. [volume] (Spokane, Wash.) 1902-1939, 1910-05-14
WATERS THINK
STRIKE HALF WON

With over one-half of the restau-
rants Of the city lined up under the
new wage contract, the striking
members of the cooks, walters and
waitresses' allied unions are hope
ful today as to the eventual success
of their efforts to secure better
wages and improved conditions.
There is energy. activity and
feeling Of anticipated success in evi-
dence at all times at the headQuar-
ters of the allied crafts, on the sec
ond floor of 722 First avenue. A
constant stream of the striking ho-
tel and restaurant employees Is
trooping up and down the stairs;
there is an almost continuous ses-
sion of the Joint executive board of
the three unions. and but few idle
moments are permitted to pass
about headquarters. Word that
some obstinate member of the res.
taurant trust had given in and
signed the scale ia generally
greeted with cheers. When Katie
or Nellie or Mamie enters and tells
OF discourteous treatment at the
hands of some "bloated bondholder"
engaged in the restaurant business
there are generally Kisses Of indig-
nation.
VERY MUCH IN EARNEST.
One thing Is apparent about the
headquarters of the strikers-they
are very much in earnest. They feel
that their cause is just, that their
demand for wages Is fair, and that
fair and impartial public will
eventually step in and ask that JUS
tice be done. The striking cooks,
walters and Mattresses are prepared
for long and hard fight, II the sit
uation requires It. They have the
backing OF the trades unions of the
Continued on Pace 2.)
The Spokane press. [volume] (Spokane, Wash.) 1902-1939, 1910-05-14
EIGHTH INNING.

Spokane-Cartwright out, Ben
nett to Adams; Kippert singles !;
Nordyke out, Akin to Adams; Ben
nett makes a neat one-hand stop of
Weeds liner. No runs.
Seattle-Frisk out, Keener to
NOrdyke; Akin flies to, Weed;
Johnston out, Cooney to Nordyke.
No runs.
The Spokane press. [volume] (Spokane, Wash.) 1902-1939, 1910-05-14
AMERICAN LEAGUE

At Boston, r. II. f.
Detroit ............. . + 0
Boston ....... 3 s 4
Batteries-Mullen and Stanage I;
Cicotte and Carrigan.
At Washington r. II. f.
OieNtldHu ........
Washington ........ z
Batteries-Joss and Clarke /;
Johnson and Street.
At New York> r. II. f.
81. LOUIS ...........
New York .........l4 II
Batteries-kinsell Petty, How.
ell and Stephens; Vaughan and
Sweeney.
At Philadelphia r. II. f.
Nnlcd6o '.'.'''' ..'.'. II
Philadelphia .... ...... 8 3
Batteries-Walsh and Payne
Plank, Coombs and Thomas, Lapp.
The Spokane press. [volume] (Spokane, Wash.) 1902-1939, 1910-05-14

in MAJOR
LEAGUES
NATIONAL LEAGUE.

At Pittsburg- r. II. f.
Philadelphia .. 6 13 0
Pittsburg ........:. . Z
Moren and Doom;
Adams, Maddox and Gibson and
O'ConnOr.
At St Louis r. II. f.
New York .......... 3 9 1
st. Louis .......... 9 ~ .
Batteries-Raymond, MarQuard.
Crandall and Schlei; Salee and
BreSnahan.
At Chicago r. II. E.
Boston .. .....4 9 2
Chicago .... . 3 3
Batteries-CurtiS and Graham;
Overall, Ritchie and Needham, Ar
cher.
The Spokane press. [volume] (Spokane, Wash.) 1902-1939, 1910-05-14
TACOMA wins
SCORE TO O-GAME CALLED IN SIXTH INNING
GROUNDS GIVEN TO LACROSSE GAME.

to Mott. Scharney flew out to
Rockenfield. No runs.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1910-01-08

| tion pursuant 10 judjcia! sale or other le-
gal proceedings. In ORDER Ia prevent the
IN eXccss OF the lair value of the prop
erty Which is the subject OF such reor-
eaniZa.iou.
believe these suggested notifications
in. and amendments To- gnc interstate
! commerce act would make it complete
and effective measure Tor securing rcs-
| sonableness of rates and fairness OF rrac-
ttces In the operation OF interstate rail
road lines. without undue preference TO
any Individual OF clnss over any others:
ana would prevent the recurrence OF many
OF the practices which have given rise
IN Inc past to SO nucn public incon-
Neuicnce and loss.
by my direction the attorney general
has drafted bill 10 carry out these rec
concentrations which will be furnished
upon request TO tho appropriate commit
tee wherever it may he desired.
Ia addition TO the foregoing amend
ments TO the Interstate commerce law.
the interstate commerce commission
should hc given the power. after 4 hear
| Ing 10 determine npon the uniform con-
srruction Of those appliances-such as sill
stops. ladders roof nsndholds. running
boards and hand brakes on freight cars
lhe tralnmen in the operation Of trains,
the defects and lack of uniformity i'm
which are APT TO produce accidents and
injuries 10 every rlainman. The won
dcrful REFORMS effected in the number OF
swjtchmen and trainmcn injured by coup
linz accidents due to tho enforced intro
pu"bon nl SdlelN CoUnICrS rs n demon %
stlation Of what can DC done IL railroads
arc compelled to adopt proper safety ap-
pli5nccs.
Employers Lila bility,
The question has arisen in tho opera
tion OF the interstate commerce en-
ploNars' liability act aS 10 whether suit
can bc brought against the employer com
uany In any place other than thai OF lis
home office. The right To bring tho suit
under this act should be as easy or on
forcemcnt as the right of = private per
son not In the company's employ 10 sue
on an ordinary claim and process in such
suits should hn sufficiently served II
upon the station agent Of the company
Opon whom service is authorized 10 be
made To bind tho company in ordinary
actions arising under the state laws. BILLS
for both the foregoing purposes have been
consldcred by the house Of representa-
tNeS and have been passed and are now
before the interstate commerce committee
OF tho senate.
I earnestly urge that they be enacted
into laws.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1910-01-08
Continued from Page One,

sitions of stock does not exempt any
road from prosecution under tho anti
trust law.
Stocks anusl be issued at par value
for money paid or for property or ser
vices, rates at full value, under an in
qUiry BY the federal authority who
shall supervise all stock and bond IS
sues,
The message, in fun, follows:
TO the Senate and House of Representa- :
tjVeS:
withheld from my annual message
diss=zsiou OF needed legislation un0cr
The authority which congress has TO
regulate commerce between the states
ana With foreign countries and said
ihaL l would bring rhis subject matter
10 your attention lalcT in the session.
Accordingly, | beg To submit TO YOU cer-
tain recommendations as 10 The amend :
Iueuts 10 the interstate commerce law
ana certain consideration arising out
ot the opera tionS of the antitrust law,
sIgzcstng the wisdom OF federal incor-
pora tion OF industrial companies.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1910-01-08

tempt by a use OF their prepopdcratinc
temporarily at undue low prices. 10 drivo
out OF business their competitors. or
u thcN attempt by exclusive contracts
aesllng except upon such contra cts. or
by other mclnods Of 4 similar charac-
Ter 10 use the largeness OF their re-
sources and the extent of their output
compared with The total output rs a
menus of compelling custom and fright
enlos Oh composition then they disclose
q pu'po2e To restrain trsoC and 90 cs-
thbish q monopoly and violate the act.
Thc object Of the antitrust la~ was
10 suppress the abuses Of business OF
II was not 10 Interfere with a great
volume OF capital which concentrated
unner one orsa anizatiou, reduced the cost
or production and made It's profit there
py' and took no advantas" OF its size
by methods akin TO duress 10 stihc COM
petition with il.
Draws Plain Distinction,
Wish 10 make this distinction as en-
nhatic AS possible. because | conceive
,nat nothing could happen more dostruc-
iNc 10 the property Of this country tina
tn" loss Of that economy In production
winch has been and will he effected III
all manufa curing lines by the employ
uent of large capital under one man
aeemenl, do not mean 10 say that
there Is not a limit beyond which the
economy OF management by the enlarge
mont of plant ceases: and where this
happens. and combination continues be-
youd this point rhe Vcry. fact shows in
tent 10 monopolile. and not 10 ccono-
mize.
fho orisihal purpose OF many Combina-
tons OF capital in this country was not
confined 10 the legitimate aud proper OBJ
lcct OF reducing the cost of production.
On The contrary, the history Of most
trades will show al times Il fcvcrish dc
sire TO unite BY purchase. combination
or otherwise, all the plants in the coun-
try engaged in the manufacture Of 4
particular kind of goods The Idea VAS
me that thereby monopoly could he
effected and control Of prices brouG ~
about which would inure to the profit or
those engaged in the combination.
Tho path of commerce Is strewn with
fallurca Of such ombiuatiu Their
projectors found that the union OF all
the. plants did not prevent competition.
especially where proper economy had not
been pursued III the purchase and in
The conduct Of the business after the aG-
crcea ton MAS complete. There was
enough, however. OF such successful
comb blnatons To arouse tho fcars OF good.
patriotic men as 10 the result of r con-
tinuance of this movement toward the
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1910-01-08
Observation-Disclosures.

. I therefore recommend that the
Interstate commerce commission be
. empowered whenever any pro- =,
: posed increase Of rates is fled, at
: once, either on complaint OF Of
: its own motion, to enter upon an
investigation into the reasonable
: moss Of such change, and that 1t be
. further empowered in its discre-
: tion to postpone the effective date
!. of such proposed increase for a
: period not exceeding sixty days
: beyond the date when such rate
: would take effect,
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1910-01-08

been Investigated BY the courts. where
! as The people arc deprived of amy sucil
| remedy with respect TO action by the
carriers they point 10 the provision OF
I The Interstate commerce act providing
Tor restitution to the shippers by cari-
e!s OF excessive Ii les charged i'll cases
where the orders OF the commission re
ducing such rates are affirmed. IL may
be doubted how effective this remedy Is.
Experience has shown that many, per
haps most, shippers do not resort 10
proCeedlu to recover the excessive
rates which they may have been required
TO pay for the simple reason that they
have added the rates paid TO The cost
OF the goods and thus enhanced the
price thereof 10 their customers. and
,liat the public. in effect has paid The
bin
Some Needed Restrictions,
On The other hand the enormous vol
umc al transportation charges. the great
number Of separate tariffs filed annual
ly with the Interstate Comerce conmis-
sion, amounting 10 almost 200 900. and
the impossibilitY of any commission su-
pcrNisins the making OF tariffs III ad-
cry transportation line within tho United
States 10 the extent thai would be nee
e-ssary IL their active concurrence were
required in the making Of every tariff
granted. Should be conferred In very
limited and restricted form
| therefore recommend thzt the inter
state commerce commission be empoNr
ercd whenever amy proposed increase o.
rates IL nied, Al once. either ON com
plant or OF its own motion, 10 enter
upon an Investigation into the reason
abIeness OF such change and That IT r"
further empowered I'm its discretion L"
postpon the effective date of such pro
posed increase for period not exceed
ne Sixty days beyond The date whom
such ralc would take effect. II. within
this time. it shall deternlns that such
increase l. Imrcs sonablo. II may then.
by its orocr. either forbid the increase
al all or iN the maximum beyond which
il shall not be made. tf, on The other
hs nd. at the expiration or this time. ihe
commission shall not have completed its
Investigation. then the rate shall take
effect precisely Is it, should under tho
existing Ian and tho commission may
continue its Investigation with such re-
sulis rs would hc req lizcd under the
law as II noN stsuds
Question OF Routing.
The claim is very earnestly advanced
by some large sSsocia tions Of shippers
that shippers of freight should bc nm
powered To direct The route over which
their shipments should pass 10 destina
ton, ami In this connection IL has heon
urged that The provisions OF section II
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1910-01-08

:. ,.;or If
:. Through all our consideration ,s ~
:. this crave question, however, we
:. mnst insist that the suppression o
= competition, the controillng %
!. prices and the monopoly OIL AZ
:. teupt to monopolize in interstaat
:. commerce and business ave nUs
:. only unlawful but contrary 20 Viz
:. public good. and that :tncy nntii n,
y be restrained and pun'sneo '11''
= cndod
:.-:;...-.-+-.s-ii--s.:;;.-.'.'i-..-ss's
cept in good faith the federal ehaf's'
rsderal compulsory license 'aN, ~ Ia
90 substitute for a federal incoI pJ, ~. t,,a
l js unnocpxsary except 10 reaCm q
Ind nf corpora tion which oE .5 vf
,Lc considerations already soE cor
- adynn;ag, voluntarily oi @ ~ cor
,,o,,tion Law. while the otber s.oss Al
rorations doing an Interstate ,'s ,.r,,Ia
,ot need the supervision OF .,,,id onl.
ion OF a federal license. ana W.
80 -. ',,,,,cce.ss;.'Iy nuriered thelse lop
.rha ,ttnrncv general. At my su7,s7iIi am,
d,sfi.d a federal corporation ~. 4,
ii, ~ tLe views | have g!.s,.,si.
~, iorib and it will be at nc ,e,sn u,s q
ian al tho appropriate gon'nTIr,.,FT1 Tr.FT.1
.opcrcss. RIO,
Thc Whitc House, jan " '''V'
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1910-01-08

=
!. Monopoly destroys competition
: utterly, and the restraint Of the
= full and free operation Of compe-
: tition has 2 tendency TO restrain
:. commerce and trade. A combina-
: tion Of persons, formerly engaged
: IN trade AS partnerships or cor
i poratioDs or otherwise, Of course.
!. eliminates the competition that
: existed between them, but the i'll
: cidental ending of that competi-
+ tion is not TO be regarded neces-
Z. sarily as A direct restraint OF
= trade, unless of such an embrac-
+ ing character that the intention
= and effort TO restrain trade are ap-
= psrcut from the circumstances. or
= arc expressly declared to he the
+ object Of the combination.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1910-01-08

: The commerce court should be
: empowered in its discretion to re-
!. strain or suspend the operation of
: an order Of the Interstate COM
: merce commission under review
: pending the flnal hearing and de-
: termination Of the proceeding, but
: no such restraining order should
: be made except upon notice and
after hearing, unless in cases where
: irrcparablc damage would other
. wise ensuc to the petitioner,
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1910-01-08
Question Of Routing.

: I think that the law should pro
:. vide that a carrier. upon written
!. request by An intending shipper,
= should quote in writing the rate
: or charge applicable TO tho pro
:. posed shipment under any schedule
: or tariffs to which the carrier is
: party. and that, If tho party
? making such request suffer damage
!. i'll consequence Of eithor refusal or .
: omission to quote the proper rate,
!. or III consequence of misstate-
: ment Of the rate. tho carrior shall
!. be liable 20 q penalty IN some rea-
= sonable amount. say $3.50, TO az
!. crue to the United States and to
: brought by the appropriate dis
: trict attorney.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1910-01-08

: What is, however. Of supreme
: importance is that the decision
= of such questions shall be as speedy
!. as the nature of the circumstances
!. will admit, and that uniformity
: Of decision be secured so as to
bring about all effective, systematic
: and scientific enforcement of the
: commerce law, rather than conflict
: ing decisions and uncertainty of
= final result.
+ For this purpose I recommend
: the establishment Of 4 court OF the
: United States composed OF FIVE
!. Judges designated for such purpose
7 from among the circuit court
: Judges Of the United States, to he
: known as the United States court
: Of commerce, which court shall be
: clothed with exclusive original iur-
i isdiction.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1910-01-08
Should Extend Power of Court.

Fhe act should empower tbc cnief ius-
iirG Al any time when the business or
The count of commerce does moi rouiljrc
re Judges designated 10 that court 10
the circuits 10 which They respectively
belong: and ii should alao provide for
Assignment in the court OF conIrncrre of
such additional amount as is NECESSARY
TO bring their annual compensation IN
10 ,v60. The regular sessions Or such
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1910-01-08
Happy Medium Possible.

!. The original purpose of many
!. combinations of capital in this
!. country was not confined to the
: legitimate and proper object Of
!. reducing the cost of production.
: On the contrary, the history Of
: most trades will show at times
!. feve,ish desire to unite by pur-
!. chase, combDl alton OF otherwise,
: all the plants in the country en-
: gagged in the manufacture OF
: particular kind Of goods.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1910-01-08
ANTITRUST LAWS;
FEDERAL INCORPORATION

There has been a marked tendency in
business in this country for forty years
last past toward comhins tion of capital
and plants In manufacture, sale and
transportation. The moving causes have
been several.
First. it has rendered possible great
economy, second, by 4 union Of former
competitors II has reduced the proba-
bllity OF excessive compc ctition: and, third
K the combination has been extensive
enough and certain methods i'm the trest-
ment Of competitors and customers have
been adopted the comhlners have secured
monopoly and complete control OF prices
or rates.
4 combination successful in achieving
complete control over a particular line
of manufacture has frequently been called
trust. ] presume that the derivation
OF the word Is TO be explained by the fact
that a usual method OF CARRYING ont the
plan Of the combination has been to put
The capital and plants Of various indiN ID
nails, firms or corporations, engaged in
the same business, under the control OF
trustees.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1910-01-08

o. jUdfes 10 enable this court 10 nc CON
st:tuted IL will bo necessary 10 author
ize the appointment OF five additional cir-
cut judges. who, for the purpose OF sp-
polntment. might he distributed 10 those
circuits wheic there IS az Tie present
;iTne the largest volume OF business. such
as the second. third. fourth, seventh and
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1910-01-08

. But such All Investigation and
!. possible prosecution Of corpora
. tions. whose prosperity OF de
struction affects the comforts, not
: only Of stockholders. but OF mil
: lions Of wage carners, employees
: and associated tradeamen. must
: necessarily tend to disturb the con-
: fidence of the business community,
: TO dry up the now flowing sources
: Of capital from its places OF hoard
: ing, and produce halt in our
: present prosperity that will cau5c
: suffering and strained circum-
stances among the innocent many
for the faults OF the guilty few.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1910-01-08

Of the interstate commerce acI, which
now empowers the commission. after
hearing on complaint, To establish
through routes and maximum Joint rates
10 be charged. etc, when no reaSona-
ble OF. satisfactory through route shall
have been already established, be amend
cd so as TO empower the commission 10
take such action. even when one en-
istinC reasonable aud Satsfs ctory route
already oXists, il II be possible 10 cs-
rs shiist aodtional routes, This seems TO
me to be = reasonable provision. | know
~ no reason why 2 shipper should not
have the right To elect between two or
more established through routes 70 which
The initial carrier may he party and
10 require HE shipment 10 bo trans
ported 70 destination over such route or
routes ss he may designate for that pur-
pose. However,. in tnc eNcrcisc of this
right the shipper should he subject 10
such reasonable regulations rs the inter-
srnte commerce commission may pre-
scribe.
The Republican platform OF 1905 de-
cIarcd iii favor Of amending The inter
state commerce law. but so always
10 ma intnin the principle or competition
between naturally competing lines and
avoiding the common control OF such
means whatsoever.