The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-09-21
90, RT or APPEILS r,C,NCIES.
en- Appeal for the InanImsuS Reoomlna-
ton 0f judge Nann.

F-ar1 ~ i'hrng i'ggs.
There are two vacancies on the Court ~
Appeals 10 he Allsd by popular election this
year one Eau sed by expiration ~ the reEu-
lar fourteen wears term of Judge Irving q.
Nann. the other hy the death 81 Judge I'd
ward 7 Bartlett
TIE Court ~ Appeals a. elected nv the
people consisted 81 four Republicans.
Haight. NAnn. Bartlett and Werner and
three democrats. cullen. Gray and Willard
bartlett there are. however. two Repub-
hcan supreme court Justices serving bv
d-- gnation 81 the Governor on tho court
of Appeals bench. chase and hts"oCk.
Therefore tho tour Of Appeals, which ny
popular election was bur one majority Re
publican. has nv the action of Republican
Governors been made rOu To one Repub-
h,an
4 Democrat should therefore a. a mat
ter ~ course be nom mated 10 IN he place
1T the late Judge Edward Z Bartlett. "
the Republicans Choo-" 20 concur 80 much
the better for them II not. 80 much the
worse for them the people will understand
that Justice and propriety dictate the cleo
ton OF a Democratic Judge of tho Court OF
AIp"al- n this time
- NJ have an end. however. 10 sugEes-
tons that 'he Democratic state convention
should withhold from 'udge Irving q.
Nann the nomination which j. 80 Justly
III due iurist OF rip" years. man OF
the highest prohity ana ,rpartialitv IN hs
long service upon the bench. Judge who
SHOWS no distinctions ~ party or politics
IN his ludtcial capacity. Judge Nann has
richly earned tho croWulng compliment
,Vhtch has been given N 'hl- state 10
feN such men a. Andrews. Rapallo. tarl,
- Brien and the two liArtlet'-' OF being re-
elected rfor the three YEAR service TO
which bv reason - age ne j. limited bv the
concurrent action ~ both his Republican
and HE Democratic fellow citizens The
bar throughout ~" state expects TINS the
press - practically unit for 1t
All indications are that this state = about
to go Democratic that W. near tho edge Of
the Wilderness and may view the Promised
Land Their. - nothing better calculated
to condemn rs to smother score OF years IN
the desert than would he SON" project Of
grabbing Judge Nanns judicial ermine 81
this time when all seems 40 bright for the
Democracy Next 10 another carnegie
Hall knockdoWn and dragoUt manhsn-
ding OF lawful delegates and state commit
teernen 20 di-place Judge Nann would be the
prtla " nner for all around stupidity
suppose he Repu oltcsns have a. rule
been but ui'le inclined 10 do the right thing.
and 70 rrciprocate. by renominatinE Demo
cratic Justices m New York CITY. for
example 80 much the WorS. for them all
mos thluE- are among 'l.' = hggffihA l'ah
OF offences for which they are Hhog' to
-.a''le up
Tho people are not turning good lUdges
ont 81 oni,e 20 punish the Republicans OF
TO av~nge oar grievances
Richard croker defeated Augustus Van
We, aud elected Theodore Roosevelt for
Governor IN Ists the moment when be de-
81 ned 10 roommate lVstIc- Da.E
Il Odeu. Ir ra n.' 'omua-Sed ii-
own defeat for reelection fnr Governor 10
lpu. whom 10 refused zoo rrHou'nl'~ Iudg"
.lorn clinton Crsy Tor 90" Iorr' ~ Appeals
and tn-t-'st Eypu e ut-. stn k"p oll IN
nomination lice people r"-I", 'rd juds-
ttrtr
In .saS lH -.su- lad favored Demo. rat.
..,- ant T.u-. had been u.lf"N 81 fo nn
a Republican wlI,pNer
The p.ppls ar. Icalru- ~ 'He.- .vdtCiar''
Noe b-,,dc 'hat party OF that uohtirIan Who
IN such a wear gs this shall "ndeaNur 20 make
th. nd oIaI ~rrn n. = partisan graz bag
10 the fate ~ Davies and scripture - soon
forEo''ens
The Republicans on their record IN state
ard national AFFAIRS. are beaten before 'h"v
start Shir ne i--U- 20 that Of returning
= Just upright and ahle Iudg" and we'll.
49, mu~'n 10 ~