The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-12-12
PLACE HUPPUCH WILL TAKE
i>hTD 10 NCfrED JOHN y.
,,pII,IE on y. y. CONFUSION.
Iar,man, Nrn Think That the senator.
nip l. '.oinS To Gerard Who Missed
me TO, rrnorShip tsaynor's antin to-
NV krrp Sonr Eyes on shrpa raj,

~aN krrp nOnr fyr> On shepa raj.
..ru,r --l.ct DIX and Mrs Div dIn.d
.-l"riS IN ! rooklyn last evening
I . .t.rrUoOn at the Hotel Manhattan
N .. md "A consultation with Winfield
JOBS: ..n chairman OF the Democratic
49,, ,o'pnltt.e.
Nr SIN ruch has been asked to s,lrc..,.i
y orlisle ~ Water,own on tn. up.
:, p. o. rIc Service Commission. Mr.
ia.,-.r- term expires in February
a.. ish"s appointed MIR. Carlisle to
ra. ,rturv created lat. last summer bv
~, -.suatton OF Thomas NJ. Osborne.
,i.r1nar II the Democratic State League
Mr. '.a-t-ls was chairman OF the executive
rorr rec 81 the State committee in the
oay- David b Hills supremacy. After
m. .~l."gie Hall convention Iot April
iss VI Carlisle Joined the home ril.
conference which met AT Utica in the,
.pr--; It that year to protest against tn.
action "f the Carnegi. Hall convention IN
dsy.arIng sixteen State committeeman
AMI o. adopting a resolution giving IN.
couvrution the authority To- nam. Stat.
rnr.Gfts-men. MIR. Carlisl. wa. also ON.
Of nv. prGanil,r> Of the Democratic State
Gag AZ Saratoga IN the fall of lano
VI Hupp'ich told his friends that h..
believed he could arrange his bu-in-S,
AL and TAX. thu post. When he doe,
b. w., retire a. chairman of the Stat,
,om-u,rt."
GrugE" " Batten of Lockport. Demo
rrli.D state commit German for M. Forty
seventh senate district. comprising Nj.
asara AMI Orleans counties, and other
in't'0L'e~ If Charles + Murphy wer. AT
the kuirksrbocker Hotel All w.r. N
toSn 10 look after patronage for their
d-frj''S Al were interest I'D also IN the
onf'nm" II the United ~ aies S-nat orship.
am nearly all had talked with Mr. Murphy
q Ms afr"rnoon headquarters IN Del
mouIco-
NJ Murphy while cont inuing 10 r.fl-..
10 cypress publicly preference. for
United STATES Senator IL constantly with
Supren. tour just 10. Gerard For "A
wees and more the two men have dinrd
'OG'r her almost every evening Mr.
Murphy has begun 10 tell his lntima-.s. rr
rainier 20 recall to hem. -orn.- If he inner
der ill- of the Rochester convention
B-tor- gong to tia. convention Mr.
Murphy rattle favored IN. nominal ION
Of Ju-''c- Gerard for Governor His
mind was open on the subject. but If he
'9h ''' any " Nd~ justice
Gerard II turned nur when Mr. Murphy
amt hI- friends reached Rochester thai
lu.rIc- Gerard was not we'll known ~,
ny sat" Democrats. and after he availa-
bii'v of all candidates had been discussed
Mavor Gaynor stepped To IN. from; and
suggested MIR Dix.
An obstacle To Justice Gerard : uoml-
nation at Rochester was stated to he IN.
- "a.
toward MIN In 1905 rammany cap
u!rsd III" primaries Of the independence
L-igg- and Mr. Hearst followers lost
their rltle and took the nam. of IA. Civic
Alliance Justice Gerard decided later
tina; Mr. Hearst's followers were entitled
{" 'n-Ir original name. independence.
League On the eve 81 the Rochester
convention Mr.. Hearst announced that
Justice Gerard's nomIns tion FOR Governor
would Os received with high favor hv
tGe Independence L"tEI- Thl- an
npIncem.nt It was stated settled Iu--
10" Gerard's fate. Nomatt.r hoa friendly
tH- Justice and Mr. Murphy had been
Mr. Murphy and hi- adviser, ,i..Id.i
a. Rochester to test Mr. Hearst strength
~ n" State. Justice Gerard was irnrn--
Gar~iy dropped from further "on-,d.rl-
10 md eventually Mr.. DIX. who m 1919
b.. pubhciy proclaimed that h" would
o. tie for Hearst Tor Governor. wa-
selected a. the candidate for Governor
VI DIN's plurality on election dav VA
- ''l while the vote IN tn" ..ntIr.. stat"
g. VI Hopper. Mr Hearts, CANDIDATE
;.r r0:-rnor. was but jj.r'1 III total
=. q / sOO. 100
Mayor Gaynor il strong for Edward
shepard for United States Senator
T.. -.cr."d Mr.. Dep-w. Within day or
~ b" = personally tn suggest Mr. Sh-p-
aid availability 90 Mr. Murphy. SOM.
= Nav1r Gaynor'- friends hav" Expressed
~" opinion that Mr.. Murphy n h. favor- |
any candidate. for United States senator. |
'sy0-s shepard Mr.. Murphy won -Iy |
VOID IN the subject. but ms IntImat"- |
go" . - their opinion that n he has |
'a1urt" II - Justice Gerard. whom |
:" rad II" -er aside At Rochester wiz
ART 80. = IN" r.-"o'u-.- to his u tn" |