New-York tribune., 1910-11-09
TAMMANY HALL REIOICES
Triumph for Decency and CON-
mon Sense Mr.. Murphy Says.
THE RETURN TO SANITY
District Leaders Gather IN 4th
Street, Where Cram and Co
halan Mount Guard

after the returns came N last nignr
-raurauv Hall vas crowded throughogs
the evening both upstairs iu -ne big naii
and down iu the executive committee rooms.
-,%ue rHe private Office q The leader vas
alyo fr-aded b-- the exuitaut disrrict Lad
ers and other supporters o. tne ticket
After hearing the first returns in his once
vvrifher +hev were carried from me e.
ecu-iva committee room by J. sergsans
Cram. who. win Dan COhaian. formed ths
leaders personal oodyElard, Murphy rim
soIs came into the executive room ard
whispered 10 Tom smith. se--ecar- Of 70
organization. who was reading me rHrnrna
that ne was going out 90 dinner
He returned q Jew minutes after q. olocx
srd got an ovation from the crowd W1ica
had gathered bv that time ne tarried ous
8 minute with -he ordinary supporters g
7-a-,r,anv- however. and. crossing the hsI
TO his own of1cs. had a consultation win
hts two advisers and prepared a statement.
Returning 20 the executive committee room,
he ffsraned 20 further returns and -nen -
sued the statement which read as follows
The election Of the entire Denoorafi1
+i~xAt in the state IL a signal triumph %
decencv and common sense.
ssI+ marks the return % sanity ara
healthy conditions fn our public life. ara
Incidentally shows that The false proDhsts
oF noise and OF filth I'm spite ~ al hers
fofnr efforts 70 deceive and fOOl the people
are buried together IN the same grave.
hope they may not greatly disturb eaeH
other there I'm deciding between themselves
vrnf.h was the more responsible Sor -1elE
memorable defeat
The victory is decisive enough 70 "a
shared by All decent citizens, and PAGES
upon the Democratic party -ssponsiotli-P
to which I fee assured ic VII respond
in a manner To satisfy the best interests q
progress and good government IL New E1-s
state"
Thomas. F, Smith secretary os TaumaHs
Hall. read the reports IL the executive ca1-@
rnittee room. sitting behind ,he well knows
long table with Judge Grain and an ars
countant who feured tns averages ss1@
ator Thomas F. Grady. rle 0ld TammarT
war horse. has always been q familiar dz-
ure Al the reading 0f -he returns. and -
task IT was 10 snu0uuee wra- effect the -s~
turns from each set ~ districts had -soI
the general average Las- night l1ws~e-s
He was absent ron mis- accustomed places
and Paradise JlrlU-H Oliver made only .
couple OF brief visits 20 the hall
While the returns received by relezrz-D-r
ticker and telephone, as weu a. py speeial
messenger. were announced they were seTS
first across the hall 20 Charles P MUr -,
. then upstairs where there was q c0-sJ--..-.s' -
shifting crowd. Thousands climbed "a
stairs and walked down again after is-1r-
iuz FOR q few minutes -- -l- spell i1.uds'5
VINO held forth upon the S-ea- victory and
-re el9-ies OF Tauuar- HaT and -n- D--.-
Ocra-i- party at large
among those vlr received the -.ta---5
. s1IIi~au's partner. Dudley Field EaIou-. a
Assistant Corporation Counsel who "a
taken an active pa-- f.. --.e -,---Ja--a- .-i-
gresham Cor-v. who c- ne il just AFTER 3
election was announced. and y. iIlia-. Sl-s
me- CoutroII-r-=I-c-. who exclaimed a. l4
. .ougratulat@G ~-1sres5uau 'oury. +Ia
American people have redeemed -7-a4
selves
AS The returns came -r from T-iea- fr17
and Rome. showing -aa- chose ei--s -zi
gone in tavo- " DIX. there was some -H-
-husizsu. There was am air OF uD-asin-s7
which hung over the asseroa-ase which vas
. constantly increased by district leaders nd
active workers. until bulletin came -1 an
T u0lnc-a- that the whole -.ck-- was 0r'ps
{ ef,s-- s.ar7eE Then rra cheers broke J7osss
and when the returns from All parts II -
greater city came in. showing s-eac- Fiss
iu the -iGe OF DIX usjo-i-l-~. -17-7-7as
zrea- rejoicing
The result III Newourg. showing onE
small plurality FOR Sriusor- were E-asted
with cries II Good cor Odeii- The an
rouuc4uer- that Serene r. Payne's Ho1a
city had gone for DIX provoked a1or7sT
. outburst
When the returns c0- Supreme C71-s
f-lsrice showed thar John J. Delary Vss
uev there was -ne biggest 0emous--a-o1
If rr7 evening. bur rcis was even sur
passed when II was announced -1a- He--
b4-- Parsons admitted his defeat. The con-
-es- h-rveen william : Bennet and Henry
George was watched with the closest IN
-a-esr. and when che returns showed
t George leading bv q large margin tre-s
were rereat-I ourbu-sts OF cheering
/ Torn smith almost started = -to- vr-7
/ ne read q telegram addressed 20 Cha~.-s
z 1Iuru.-. from Oyster Bay. as follows
/ ''Roose-eI-.s 0vr district gives D-V 9
I Srirrsgn -5S Beaten TO q F~azZle- Tiers
were cheers and landcl lappl-C and stamp
I iuz Of fes-. and then more cheers, w-t-7
continued ror several ninures- and the
( telegram was sent upstairs 70 be ~sad -'
the larger -hrorc up there as che has-
-ht-r SO rar heard.
/ Reports Indicating the election NJ Ler@"-
+ cratic governors tu NfasSacnuset-z- N@~
rs-za-. Connecticut and Ohio also p-o6u-=f
81 +7-Sr. 5errons--a-ion and rhtS vas Pc.
+ -ea-az when -re news was ~orlrluuicars6
+ - -D4 big crowd upstairs. The news ron
r7,-4-.-, vas sro-re- .1r-rt- which rtcsied
-re ,-776. and provoked an 7r-o--s-
/ When f- was announced -1a- otX would
-rohanrv have r7odoo ma iort-v -rsre vas
great rejoicing and a few minutes la1a-
. -,-a-rs- r, Murphy came IN and rece-v-1
,.p-oa-ious applause. Hs made bis way IN
--. end 5g -he Ions table and s-'e. .H'-s N
.sy- minutes -cngratu. .att-E lis leaders .'.-
candidates and -ertiuE -HHr ror--f'''-
tio1s-
Wien another telegram FROM oyster ',eF
-r-,,-r.-d the probable defeat OF ''.
. r.sr-.ve.-.s friend. C5r=ressr1an vs. we
Cocks. .ne ueopIe werc w.'d win oeASn''
and many started out t1 JeU che srot news
-. -r-,- tr.ruls outside
The gallery OF -ae upstairs "al' ran
-rsr nv -.ts time. and men below Nep' ''.u-
f-e s.f when they got cold and ual.rchins ol1
qrat- after they z1t warmed CD q oit oy
~. sea- OF the han and chat Of the oratorF
f-,~r the platform. walcl srew iAe u'r'
-s,.-srf as tha results announced were 20
more favorable
shortly after 10 O'Clock Nr- Murphy ana
1H#. MH