New-York tribune., 1910-04-28
INSURGENTS WILL STAY
Invitations TO Join Democratic
Party Spurnec.
noLLlVER ANSWERS RAYNER
Saws Republican Fold Is Large
Enough for All Elements
Bailey in Controversy.


80. .. f.e discussion. From II until =
,rfo-l. Senators Rayner. Dolliver and
-.r-. debated the question OF party reg
,..--. .o a large and attentive audience.
--e-o Wa general exodus from the Aoor
s-5 Galleries when Senator Rristou was
-,,e-- -zad 20 discuss the interstate COM
~--- -irT and = recess of half an hour
So taken IN order 20 supply an audience
o.. she kansas Senator. he talked for an
,..r- and = hsf on freight discrimination
go vr close hrs remarks on this subject
fr---o-rov-
Tho political debate vas begun hv sen
s-0r 70 --ner. Uho. In submitting some OBJ
So zf.ors ON the railroad bill. took oc-
rs-or to discuss fbe question Arc the in
..-r~~re fu earnest or have they Just been
e--r= snd roGuetting with u.s. Tho
-rs- and Senator. who fs one of rhe most
s--r--a rine speakers on the Democratic
So ~rr this query I'm mock seriousness
end t-r- proceeded 20 comment on the DO
r-rz. METHODS of some o. the insurgents
-rr usrtad 70 know the future intentions
r. -e-s-o-~ ReveridE~ DoIIi,-er and others.
vr.F -re- 5oIn rhe Democrats and heir
s-r- alt -h~ Republicans TO rout. or --o-e
--r- merely -onclirE and ca-esSinE the
-.r0---v only 20 return 70 rheir own marty
rs
Tz.re- fornsily invited the insurgents 10
-a.r rre 0enoc-stic party. He iutersperxed
fs speech with drou comments which
r-rz-e amused rhe Senate and the ga
r#rs
Dr. Fs-0e~e speech vas received with
f-o7-= @' r1e insurgents and Senator Dol
f-r- was selected 70 reply. IN = vigorous
t1r=rr DO declined the invitation - ,of7
t#r H0ro0-sc,. He said there had been ~
srre between the insurgents and the
Democrats except that PROMPTED r,- he
r---e 0f honest mon 20 90 the greatest
0r-- good for me people NJ DolIf,-s-
f~-.0e1 IRE u1inorlt~ party for its sins Of
omission and commission. charged II with
t---s-s ~ IRE public interest and declared
t--. -re only hsndicsn o. the Insurgents
~s st the Democrats had supported
f-r~ I'M tne course they we're pursuing 70
purge re Republican party of bad leader
"- Bailey WAITING ~ the Door.
Delivers speech aroused Senator
Fr sud he replied with spirit F5e de
fr--11 -Er Democratic party ana said that
IRE --.- ~ Democratic victory was ~
hard fe -eferred 70 rhe Msssa acnrIzet-s
f-- Nrv York Congress elections sr6 de-
s7-rr that the insurgents were riding % \
N-lfN lDlfleu ne DernOr-arv. Mr.
Fse- said that the Democratic siysenSions
'- s'A we're not so serious as the prezent
ascension in the Republican ps-tv. The
o-rs-enoes uere not over details but in
rcI-ed fundamental principles You are
-0- s--onE enough 20 fight Us and AZ the
sane -ne hght yourselves" sad Nr
-ser. addressing the insurgents -.,co
ran an claim the protection Of ire Gag
v-r- = IS firing on "a. You may win when
.o- s-e defending the Republican ra~rv
s-t SIS reco-d. but YOU cannot win when
.7- a-e attacking lts record ana It's lead
er. Hsyner's invitation 70 the insurgents
- 'oin rh- Democrats was renewed ~ NJ.
BAILEY. who sai6 &c would stand on the
f-ont doorstep End bic tho disgruntIed Re
--orcsns erte-. lie ssid that while there
we're no Democrats IN the Senate who wore
-s7ablicsns- he was persuaded that ther.
-s-e some Republicans who were Demo
c-ets IT is tine for an exchange Of rrfs-
cre-s.- he SAID. IN conclusion. and r an
wiling 70 declare a treCe while this ex-
C----- Is being made"
serstor Esyner's Invitation.
~0.runE out that IN almost AL p-elirni-
rs-~ moves on various measures before TIE
present Congress the insurgents and tne
rr~o~-s-s had stood together. NJ Rsyner
rsf that when the Snsl vote Is taken
r-~- -1e bill itself they seem IeisureIy %
t.z- szsv from u.s. Nov." he added.
--a question u.s. what CO our friends
-~rs-- Are they m earnest. - are they
-~-'v flirting and coouetting With us2 Is
merely a temporary engagement. or is 10
-e-rancrt love feast
-- -te senior Senator from Indiana for
.arre embracing uE simply for the
ecstasy anc transport Or the moment or
t- 30 wiling 70 unite With Us IN the bonds
- -oI-. political vedIock? would ike 20
L-ov from him what his future intentions
s.- Whenever Va have voted with him
have noticed that he cast radiant smile
shs- Is fun or meaning in our direction.
t this merely the symptom ~ no
r-a~'s-v passion, ~ IS d. ne token oi
-r-~-uent sTection7
.r ~o not know ho- the rest - my col
'esF es Feel. but 7 an becoming weary o.
--.~- fond 81 and car .ssed. only 70 be 70
-r.#-1 sno deserted -hen the supreme
-.r--.--f arrives When listen 70 The siren
.rr ~ The intrepid snd dsshing insur-
z~-.- FROM Iowa Y am thrilled with the re
rz-1zl ~ tho crimes - the Republican
-s--- knew 81 a. along before they tod
--+ r1sv have -ecltsd II with such
F..--z-i- fe~vo- and VTth such narrowing
r-.-.re that r7e nd. Eusnt blood has surged
F.-r.zr M veins. and they have M 7ro-
f..-ae-t s,-'pst'v for belonging - a party
.-s- Is governed by such dc-norsiizing In
@.ar.es-
-f- Fa--e- trsr To~-s'l- inV--eo ths 'n-
t.-----r -0 come into -7e Democratic
camp we oNer -oU = part he SAD
.---+ fs rerfs--Ir pure and thst has nsss-o
f~. ord +ne Stage - temptation "e want
r~. end vsu- sou rsdl-
-rrrggr -rsr- rleepless nights. Nj Ray
v.er- or he hsd thought over hrs
-.-re-f--o- A. N--f re had been ~ f1e
er.-.rr -rs. -re Democrats might them
-oT-~ -re problem n~ going over -
--r H-erl-revrs h1s+ their e1re~fen~- ln con
r~r- er --rh frn railroad rate bin ha0
tr~7.- trern frsf rHe~ could nof pursue
-..- course with ASSURANCE ~ safety
u-U - re~s LED ' 10 SAD. 'tnst -
-.r -- road rate densra. rnds~ the leader
--.r ~ President Roosevelt We 1olnNo
bends u-H-r tf.e fnsI-Eeut forces - the 1e-
E.-frs- ra~-- the at V-ords NJ Roose-
rrr ea.c 20 30 pr~- "a pe-e Conferrir
49, -ra critical situsrior WeTs. Vow, 10
r~' gre up f1- shtp.
'Tr President. 7 took his sd-1c-. s0c
Pc ror give un TO ship. hrlt re snip ga
ur rr Th~ ufrf-r before 80 vote vas
-ssr- re F~esioerf vas oUf tn rfeoost
uH. sl.l carlo ce-as0~ from Rhode Teis ID