The Guthrie daily leader. [volume] (Guthrie, Okla.) 1893-1996, 1910-02-17
Build the vladue,
~~~~-~~~-~------s---~--s~--~-E
a pERNlCtOuS INJUNCTION

~ FNENNt&f0NN fNNAtS& i1'F
10 The maus engaged IN private
business ami cnnlptilel % be satisfied
with 4 return OF frnm two or three
to ten o. Twelve per eeul 90 his Nl
seslment, aud MhN copSSggAr hplSalt
'oNeeptionalS 4,ruikAld MIlalIhyot'ts
can he Gsuged N lhu lSSef faie, N
ccGr guihtg thar ates uaaeS whicN
1 saltaAi msbcs fem ~ be Us nct
cynt profit cu ilS volume W business
are yonflsoa'ofS anpeaes not litile
iecullar
The miine ~ United States Circuit
Judge liook as aHsnopcea al 81
l.ouis "a rehruary il thc Oklahoma
Fasc csse makes this declaration
The ngaposed Injunction sga,ass OK
lAhnma's iMtns applies III ihe iNlascss
os thr tSnf Uniay&aa 4 Santa re eonS
ranA as well as ot ,hc otAer 00m
fsnles Interested In The ease The
iaguges ShuwiaS the profits IN tAc
business al the Gulg. Colo ada 4 san
IN he company. contained Ia it's
sworn statements mado "a the statc
corporation commlsS on ana presented
10 .Ndge Hook on page "a al tse dc
semdants recawa n the case, cseicS
az wh'ch are n ,he hands Of many
ettornayS aud newspapers ot the
state show that instead a. he.ug
sanfiseatcvy the rates haze neued
that company pso(iss, ON tae revenue
basis. thft would hook so g0ea ,o this
average business mar as to be be.
ANnd hope ef attainment, And the
socallea revenue basis, upon waiet
aeesc profits are computed, has al.
Ways been eNnteaiaa for anu upheld
by he Shiewdest railroad legal lights
Ks the proper one for arriving at cen
cluSions IN such meters
Tho statement OF earnings ol the
sulf Colorado 4 Santa re company
for the fiscal wear ts1s shows the
ryoiltS on The oklahoma ln,sastate
business or business originating ana
cempleled within the state. 10 hayS
been s9i.s5lsA The profits ~ OK
lAhomas proportion et the companN's
Interstate business. incoming business
originating IN Oklahoma and Carried
to the state Tine or lhc reverse there
q, wvre sseA,ssS,Ss This. the Whole
Profits, iRlfas ase S0a Interstate. On
she y0mnanss hNsmsNS dome lN lhls
SsSse, amounted q ss5eiNs.ls.
Instead N he,pg tanfiSeai0rN. o.
less than au or Mary and re Sanahls
l'gogsl upon thc investment 'RyelyCa
she~e nreiitS wJre equivalent to rc
surn et iSs& per cens on the capitaii
fssioN ~ tNe evMpaNy as shown ~
tee bslaneo shcef ~ lee average can
alsSiten paw a.ile Nf inc aul ic s
return 81 iNNl pcr ceHl ol ihe sclua
s>9St u ihc gai'rVsa Az ShswR hs ils
sta,emeM ~ thc aetgage vost lw
,niie +
HAD she GHH Colorado 4 Sanla 81
cempaas GOac uN bnSmess "a, sll eN.
eng whai lt Aid withM lAc state oi
OklSlsuma, and had les volmWe o h,1
sucSS and r9leS charged eccn MIA
the cNsoNls pnae to h0ve been thV
agsNNs NelNme am rates MVNNy3. 80
rcr ceag ei sAe u~eiP,s f'om wAa'
was really lMsgas'ale h'tsWcsS. anJ
SAM pcr cvat " be n~slpls laf What
~"S 'sai.F f'ste4St's" e"sieesS NeV'N
- 'ssSas''ea = e'eef p'"sN m etN''
Nn'"s III sNPfl N"'sss rV"'VS'@ NN
te's eSailMhs 'N NA'snef'R W 'Ss'
l,',SS v,fsiesttRs Ai'0 V'NP'e''a 'N
snES sa'r '0tN NSs ~ 'Neits w H.N
~, asa ~ eAesS ael4af vosleVN io'
seaslNsSs Ns'S.''''''i'k in t'NiAaAt's oa'
Aek atAN.aS'ssl 9n's.Nt sl,e SsS'H 9Hfif
mas @N ethss nl peNf
~ sfs l0sa 81 tNtse ieaisilaiss'it
f&E3reS 8sitt IA tbs tr't- az fHfs lt.Eti
0 u + 49,, -
sa~6 sAs tet9sw S'&!ta NaaitRsr NaA'
NsNN ff1 af iai3aFss s0t
SSN'RSs af HsFafcSatsi W ANN tS
n.y. tteshi VI sAaMH fHaA Nt