New-York tribune., 1910-07-23
MQ0NSH|NE WINS 4 BLUE
Beats Mir. VanderbiIt's Lord
Brook at Bay Shore.
FANTASY OUTSHINES SONIA
Emile Antony Shows Her to Ad
vantage and Carries
OFF Ribbon.

Moonshine. a comparatively new horse,
owned by c. W. Watson, carried everything
before her in the open harness class at the
Bay Shore horse show yesterday afternoon
and defeated Reginald C. Vanderbilt's bay
gelding Lord Brook and De Witt c. Flan-
agans Lord Russell. It proved a hard class
to decide. and again and again the judges
sent the horses around the ring. The mare.
however showed in clever style and never
made mistake With splendid conforna-
ton and irreproachable manners, it was
impossible to beat her. and Mr.. Vanderbilts 9
champion had to be content with a red rib
bon, while the imperial Lord Russells
rosette was no better than yellow.
After carving away THE Brooklyn Daily
Eagle" challenge cup in the final competition
last year, Kitty Grey and Norma won a leg
the new trophy again yesterday IN the
challenge class. The Fairmont Farms en-
tries had first and third choice, leaving sec
ond honors to Paul A. Sorg's Puritan Maid
and Precise. The last named pair were go
ing well and it looked like a toss up for a
time but Kitty Grey and Norma finally
outstepped their SNOWY rivals and refused to
relinquish a single leg the silver trophy
Seuuatogue FARMS chestnut mare Fan
tasy and Andrew Morisons Sonia came to-
gether again in the class for saddle horses
over Is and under 15.2 hands and battle
royal ensued No mare ever had more per-
feet conformation than Sonia. and in this
class conformation counted % per cent, put
when the two were sent into the ring 10
show manners and training it was apparent
to the most casual observer that tantasy
was the mare for first choice she SIDE
stepped right and left. changed her lead
-4r
and in fact did everything that was re-
ouired of her in the best poss1oie lolih
Emile Antony had the mount, and ne fairly
piloted her to victory with his horseman-
ship.
decision which proved decidedly un-
| pop,,lar with every one excepting the
;r5gae uas made in the ladies' saddle
| class when Watchful. a bay gelding owned
nv Mvron H Oppenheim. defeated MISS
| Hubbs's Irvington Molly BaWn. Miss Laura
| StanIey's Martini and Miss Claire Knapp S
| Zulal with Mrs Belle Beach Balm up.
| In the novice class on the opening day
| of the show Martini was picked to wear
| the blue. and he made a better showing
| Yesterday in the ladies' class. with MISS
| Stanley up than he made IN MS opening
/ performance. Zulal, too, was good, out the
| Judges were evidently looking for bulk' as
| that was about all that Watchful had IN
! his favor
Miss Helen Prentice. the pucky little
| horsewoman who has had such bad-mah-
| nered mounts ever since the show opened,
| had a bad fall yesterday while schooihg
| Prince Henry Although scarcely able to
walk. she insisted on riding in the ladies'
hunters class. and captured yellow ro-
settle with Follow Me. from the Torne
| Brook stables.
| This class was by J. E. Dav1s's gray
mare Country Girl. which earlier IN the
dav had twice heard the fatal word Gate,
presumably owing to a slight larneness'
She was shown in the combination and
heavy saddle class. but was not allowed
| to compete until the hunters classes
where she won both jumping contests and
defeated Ouandry and Pinkun Elvts.
The summaries follow:
class ~ combination harness and saddle
horses: local: -rize s25)-First. sequatogut
FARMS ch. m Irvineton Molly Bawn: second
third. Miss Claire A Knapp's b. m. zulal
fourth Seauatogue FARMS ch- g. Glorious
Class II pairs Of harness horses; first prize
500. second prize s2O,-Ffrst, Farmont Farm S
mon, me, Farms ch ms chatrerbox and Ringing
Be.ls third, Quaker Farms br m Lady sd;,~. Of
Ps5I Sorgs h. ms tease and Torment.
! class - saddle horses. 15.2 hands or over
/ ,Ip to carving 300 pounds first prize SO; sec
ond prize. s20l-Ffrst. Adolph Vogts blk g.
! Midnight: second. George Watlen and Bernard
C;unther's ch. z Prince Royal; third ]. Parker
| Kirlfn's ch g Red Prince fourth. Mrs James
b Mckay. jr.'s.. ro. g. Jack Frost
! class Gharness horses. over l5.2 hands;
first prize $50. second prize. s2o)-First, Fair
n.cnt Farms ch Moonsnire; second. eanGv
Point FARMS b. g Lord Brooke; third De Witt
| . Flanagan's b. z Lord Russell: fourth. Miss
+ Carlsles chestnut gefding-
class 81 saddle horses in competition for
the cha llenge Durham cup: manners to count %
per cent conformation and action 81 per cent
rrn IN he won twice bv the horse before
g. becomes the property Of his owner)-First.