The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1910-10-06
HEARST MEN VOTE DOWN DEAL
STRAIGHT TIIkET, ne iDED ~
HOPPER lND HE tRST.
Oiher Candidate 20 Bc Named TS-m"r.
rev vote Was 3I1 TO % Against the
II-arst.RoeSr'e POeI NaRS IDrie-
gatr> Thrratc nc,I to Holt the lea CUE.

IlrarSt.uOoSeN cit POol NanS brlr.
Eatrs Threa Icac,I to Holt the Tea Eur.
The Independence League state con
Ventlun m Coop"r Union after a turbulent
, 81 SION aud boots for Stlmsou voted early
: this morning to put M a straight ticket
ana reject the Hearst Roosevelt deal
The vote was gi2 70 o. aga,n-, the deal.
A. - % NJ T. O'Loughhn of Kings
nominated John ! Hopper, the State
chairman. as the Leagues candidate for
Governor William 4. Coakley seconded
the motion aud Hopper Wa~ nominated by
reclamation
Then Bernard Nolan nominated Hearst
for Lieutenant Governor. aud he was
nams,I bv acClamation
The convention aiIou-n'd - t"-n"r-
row night. when - viii meet at the Park
Avenue Hotel To- c.n,pl"'" IN" ticket.
A. had been expected from the spirit
displayed a. ia. meeting in the Park
| Avenue Hotel nu Tuesday night "i the
State committee. when there was AT
marked hostility shown - making any
dlCker with Roosevelt and his ticket,
the convention was disposed tn resist
it, orders William x Hearst IN wire
less dispatches from the Maur-taniI
has Instructed his representatives here
that he wished the league 10 Indorss
Stmson and the rest Of the Republican
ticket with th- exception of the candidate
for Lieutenant -GovsrnoT. whose pla""
h. directed should be kept oT''n. pr-sun'-
ably for himself So that Il would give ham
an opportunity 10 take an active part
in the campaig IN from -" platform
II Wa apparent AZ s,-h as IA" after
noon =, ssIou opened yesterday that the
programme. indprsing IN" Republican
ticket had no favor IN IA" eyes Of the
crowd John J Hopper. chairman II
m. State committee. told the convention
that th. defeat ~ Murphy was the dcsir-
ahl. -ud even under tn conditions of
supporting tin. Republicans.
Tn" evening nesting was oTon '" the
pubic and hy m" time the CooT"r Union
crowd had worked itsrlf up va two hours
~ waiting the dissatisfaction which II
siderable nuInl@r of IN. a. delegates.
such a. wanted 10 do what Mr. Hearst
wanted The upstate m"ml-rs were
particularly hallgerenI
There wasn't anv trouble about perma-
nent organization or about Adopting
platform for direct nominations, refer
snciuH. INITIATIVE and recall Herbert
IamburR presided Tn. trouble came
H.. "A
resciuunn for - straight ticket from top
TO bo,'om Then came an hour of speech
making only those speeches which
favored the resolution got half a hearing
from the cr, Nd Even the Rev Dr Ivan
Merlin Ion.- of Syracus- GO very httle
a, anti,n when he SUGGESTED that 'he IN
a, r-emrn, II part of'h- Republican ticket
wa fh.. b-.. way 80 beat Murphy
Delegate after d-i"gnt- ARCS. and said
that ~. world Uut enter MT" any compact
= the sort. and insisted that Il has ale
Rianc- wa To continue o. The Independence
League that organization mast pnt
straight ticket IA thu field
They .lIi that the league should lie
continued a. an Ind-p''ud-ut hudy ana
not - Roosevelt adjunct They
Threatened a. i.ult IN" organization unless
they were I..rinltt'-i - hay" a straight uut
lrdeg. nd"nrr I.'-aRu" ticket
VIZ Hearst > Spok-snrn tried 70 head "a
the up-Sia'-rs 10y asserting that Mr.
H-IrSI under no cirrumst would
head a thiri ticket and that for that
r.a-uu o. Nuuld Ne l.-tter - JOIN forces
~ith thu Republican parry ShIch. like
Nr Hearst WAS OPPOSED tu Murphyi-m.
and allow Nr Hearst To- l-C1m- factor
in the campaign Ivy going On the l.agu-
ticket Tor llsut-nI -G"ysrnor
The apps Al however. vas hp~lsd down.
and at midnight he convention b-gsn 10
yot. on tn. resolution - PM a straight
ticke' ~ IA" h"d SON" - The up
\, at.,r- = aid that they did not brli-N-thit
VI Hears vas the only man IN the Lea que
wh could head the ticket and g. VAS IN
fact suggested 10y several ~ th"~' TIN,
Chairman Hopper - the state Commits"
would b. an acceyHahl" c,ndidat" for
Governor
Mr. Allan ~ support q his own mo-
ton aid thai ~ Saratoga II wash Z any |
better thau a. Rochester. for their buss
ism was .uthr,H-d supreme aud lh-o- !
a., ~ th. First was GA the throne Fred /
.rick Oakss 80 SUFFOLK tried - ge, q 3
h.aring 60 tell about the principles that .
grttIA'sd Mr. Hearst. but the crowd .
wanted g. get =" voting.
4 don't b~ll"ve t',d IA. Black Hprs. /
Cavalry IN this stat" - any h.'',"r rhtp .
Tarnnany. said Mr. Allan. and I cannot
So. Why It should he thouEh' IN place .
10 discuss the adviSability - supporting
a ticket promulgated al q convention
py.~ which Eiihu Root yr'.sid-i
Mbau the roll call Logan n vi A. NOT ed
hat the eadar- were sticking by their
earlier intenti"ns Both Shearn and
I;oIltnn voted against straight tickle,
Mat h.w iipylau alternate for Mr. Hearst
casi hi- vote ipr u
Then came the roll call and the vote
u 2I2 to- ". and the nominating began
M SRt\D SIZES NOI ELIST.