Arizona republican., 1910-12-08

not be approved. He denounced the governor and declared that he and Senator Bailey would be "a good pair to draw to-"
 In conclusion. Mir Parsons said that he preferred the good opinion of his constituents and tiff they per sisted in well doing they would be met on their return with brass bands.
 Mir Wood spoke of the iron clad instructions of the Yavapai delegates and he again read an editorial from the Democrat confirming the opinion of the advocates of the recall that they were right
 Mir Webb replying to MT. Parsons statement regarding messages from home said that he had received many advising him to do the thing he now wished to do. submit this matter to the people. As to the delegates from Yavapai and Gila county, MT. Webb said that they were allowed no choice in the matter but he urged those who were not so bound tO sup pert the Cassidy motion as one likely to make statehood more certain.
 A Defender of the Texan.
 MT. (ulIill lllbuSl III with the purposes of Mir. Parsons could not subscribe to his diatribe against Senator Bailey whom he re- garded as the ablest and brainest man in the United States senate and a true friend of Arizona But for the work of Senator Bailey said he. we would not now be here framing a constitution" Mir Cuniff added by way of a postscript that whatever might be the views of the Texas senator. the convention had received no instructions from him while they had received most definite ones from their constituents
 Dr Tuthill replying to the state ment that the Yavapai delegation had been rigidly instructed pointed out that the people of that county could not have been firmly set in favor of this recall. otherwise Judge Wells would not have been elected. Turning to the danger of that feature of the recall article including the judiciary, Dr Tuthill quoted the following from the message of President Taft:
 'I wish to renew my urgent rec ommendation made in my last annual message in favor of the pressage of law which shall regulate the is suing of injunctions in equity without notice in accordance with the best practice now in' vogue in the courts of the United States. I regard this of especial importance. first. because it has been promised. and. second. because it will deprive those who now complain of certain alleged abuses in the improper issuing of in functions without notice of any real ground for further amendment and will take away all semblance of sup port for the extremely radical legis- lation they propose, which will be most pernicious if adopted. will sap the foundation of judicial power and legalize that cruel instrument, the secondary boycott"
 Do you think" asked Dr. TuthiI that that man will approve d con- stitution with such a provision in it?"
 The Cassidy motion was defeated by the following:
 Ayes. 17-Baker. Cassidy. Cobb. Cunningham. Curtis. Franklin. Jones' F. A. LanGdon. Lynch. Moeur. Orme. Osborn. Scott Sims of Graham. Standage, Tuthill. Webb.
 Nays, 3O-Bolan. Bradner. Coker. Colter. Connolly. Cooper. Crutchfield. Cunniff, Feeney. Goldwater. Ingrahma, Jacome, Jones of >Yavapai. Keegan. Kinney. Lovin, Morgan. Parsons. Pusch. Roberts. Short. Simms of Co., chise. Tovrea. Weinberger. Wells. Willis, winsor. Wood. MT. President.
 The Last Feeble Effort.
 One more hopeless effort was made by Mir Lynch to strike out the pro vision with respect to the judiciary and when that failed the question of the final adoption of the article went with the following result, ayes. 3S: nays. 9. Dr Tuthin alone voted with the minority.
 This statehood coffin nail having thus been clinched Mir Roberts in- troduced a resolution censuring Gov ernor Sloan for having expressed his sentiments regarding the constitution in the Washington interview. The resolution looked to the forwarding of copies of it to the president of the United States and all the mem bers of congress. In the opinion of Mir. Cunningham such a proceeding would he most unwise and the motion for the adoption of the resolution was indefinitely postponed.