The Grenada sentinel. [volume] (Grenada, Miss.) 1868-1955, 1910-04-29
TWO REPORTS ON BRIBERY
MAJORITY SAYS PERCY WAS HON.
ORABLY AND FAIRLY ELECTED.
Minority Says Whisky, Patronage and
Undue Influence Were Used to Defeat
Vardaman.

In the house Chairman Herbert
Holmes of the probing committee pre-
sented the following majority report:
I'VE have examined sixty-seven wit
nesses, and all the testimony, including
questions and answers, is now being
transcribed by the stenographers and
will be published, as heretofore provided
for by resolution Of this house. In the
examination of witnesses we nave spared
no tim or expense in trying to arrive at
the truth, bringing witnesses here from
all parts of the state and running down
each rumOr that came to our knowledge,
and examined every witness that we had
any knowledge of whom was supposed to
know, or even if it were rumored that he
knew, any facts that would aid us in our
investigation.
after what we believe to be a full
and thorough investigation, we have
been unable to find any evidence of q
single instance where the vote of a mem.
Der was %corruptly influenced, and because
thereof voted for some candidate other
than his own choice.
I'm the opinion of your committee,
Senator Leroy Percy was fairly and
honorably nominated by the Democratic
caucus. Respectfully submitted,
"HERBERT HOLMES, Chairman.
Van B. BODIE.
I'M. P. FOY."
Minority Report.
The minority report, prepared by
Messrs. A. c. Anderson apd Lee NJ.
Russell, was as follows:
1--WE, the undersigned members of the
house investigation committee under the
FOy resolution of March 10, 1910, beg
leave to submit the following minority
report:
"We preferred that our committee sub
NIT to you the full and complete tram
scribed notes of the stenographer with
out comment, for the reason that each
of you and each citizen of the state is
fully competent to draw his own con.
illusions from the testimony.
1--WE take it that if you desire a re.
port at all you wish only that we pre-
sent to you in the concise form the ma
terial things brought out in the inves.
tigation. There is too much evidence
to 60 into detail as to it all. We SUBJ
NIT some of the most important as we
view it.
"First-We believe that undue influ.
ence by the improper use of liquor was
used upon at least one member of the
house. This member was changed from
his original conviction, and, being I'M
fortunately addicted to the use of strong
drink, was by this improper influence
ov~erpersuaded to vote against his real
"Second-The evidence shows. further,
that in the other instances other mem
bers of the legislature were approached
and asked if money or political position
would persuade them to change their
vote, and this, as We believe, was very
improper.
"Third-Even the patronage of the
government is shown to have
been brought into play and used in the
caucus. We say, however, that we nave
no evidence that any federal official
knew that such was being done.
"Fourth-We submit that the execu-
tive patronage of Mississippi was used
telling effect. We do not mean by
This statement that our chief executive
promised any office to any person to
influence any vote; there is no evidence
that. But we do say that the gov
conferred and advised continually.
ind this was well known to every mem.
Der of the caucus, with all the 'opposi-
'ition' candidates, their friends and
members of the caucuses to the best
Methods to solidify the opposition and
% persuade some members supporting
Vardaman to change their votes,
vas highly improper. In view of the
fact that Gov. Noel, as
tated in his evidence before the com
.nittee, and in his public utterance, that
things being about equal he would
ppoint his friends, we believe from the
violence submitted that under the in
ense state of feeling hat existed
throughout the caucus this state of af-
airs had a strong tendency to prevent
in casting the ballot.
"Fifth-The evidence shows also that
ONE men during the caucus changed
heir votes. Their explanations therefor
re in evidence, and while we do not im-
ugn their motives, we call your atten-
to their testimony.
"Seventh-Whisky was used excess
lively during the caucus, but there is no
rNnf that mn -
ensed in the headquarters of any of the
andidates. LEE Nj. RUSSELL.
"a. G. ANDERSON"
ercv and Vardaman vii c+rr,c ch.% l.