The Plymouth tribune. (Plymouth, Ind.) 1901-1911, 1909-07-15


was taken at IL p. m. 1t resulted 45
for to "a against the bill. Ten Re
publicans voted against the measure.
On the final poll senators voted as
follows:
For.
Aldrich, Borah, Bourne, Bradley,
Briggs, Bulkeley, Burnham, Burrows,
Burton, Carter, Clark CWyoming),
Crane, Depew, Dick Dixon, Dupont,
Elkins, Flint, Frye, Gallinger, Gam
Die. Guggenheim, Hale, Hepburn
johnson, Jones, Kean. Lorimer, MIC
Cumber, Oliver, Page, Penrose. Per
kins, Piles, Scott Smith CMichigan),
Smoot, Stephenson, Sutherland,
Warner, Wetmore, Republicans; Nc
Emery, Democrat.
Against.
Bacon, Bailey, Bankhead, Chamber
ain, CuFberson Daniel, Fletcher,
Foster, Frazier, Gore. Hughes, John
ston, McLaurin, Martin, Money,
Newlands, Overman, Owen, Shively
Smith (South Carolina), Stone Talia-
ferro, Taylor, Simmons, Democrats; !;
Beveridge, Brown, Burkett, Clapp,
Crawford, Cummins. Dolhver, La
Folette, Nelson, Republicans.
The Republicans voting against the
bill follow: Beveridge, Indiana;
Bnistow. Kansas; Brown and Bur-
kett, Nebraska; Clapp, Nelson, Min
nesota; Cummins and Dolliver, Iowa;
LaFolllette, Wisconsin, and Crawford
of South Dakota One Democrat,
McEnery, OF Louisiana, voted for the
bill.
To keep the house from getting the
bill before it goes to conference, SEN
ator Aldrich had adopted immediate
Y after the vote was taken resolu-
tion disagreeing with the house on
its tariff bill and inviting confer
ence. Bailey protested, but unavail-
ingly. The conferees named by Vice
President Sherman were Senator'S
Aldrich, Burrows, Penrose, Cullom,
Hale, Daniel. Money and Bailey.
Senator Aldrich hurled his defianse
at president TAFT and his challenge
o the bolting Republicans before
the vote came on the tariff bill.
Aldrich's Def.
Il have seen OCCASIONS" said he,
when individuals thought they were
wiser 1han their party | have seen
men change from one party TO an
other party. The Republican party is
party OF najonties and the views
OF the majority control party pol9cies
and government The senator from
Indiana does not speak for the Re-
publican party He has no right to call
the president TO support his views.
Those who represent the states
that are Republican represent the
party The bill carries out to itS let
ter every pledge OF the Republican
party. | suggest to the senators who
vote against this bill that they cam
not attempt to speak for their party
without protest from the states that
can, however, and will elect Repub-
lican president"
Beveridge Protests.
Senator Beveridge had charged that
| the tariff bill was not a revision and
, was a clear violation of the party
Jledges made in convention platform
and the spoken promises OF President
raft He said that the people had be-
iieved in the president; that there was
TO be revision downward OF the
.ariff and that President Taft believ-
ed it.
There has not been," declared Mr
Beveridge. THE people who elected
Mr.. Taft are protectionists, the pres
dent 1s prCtectionist and we Re-
publicans in this senate who oppose
this tariff bill are protectionis,s and
follow our president Woe be it to
any party that breaks its pledged
faith with the people The secret oi
success OF the Republican party N
the past has been that it has kept Is
| pledges TO the people and they have
trusted it,"
Where Bills Differ.
The Aldrich bills offers a corpora
tion dividends of corporations hav-
ing profits Of more than $1,000 for
| the graduated income tax carried in
the Payne bill
1t re-arranges the maximum and
minimum features of the bill under
which low tariffs can be given ma
| lions favoring trade OF this country
House experts charge in this rear
angement the minimum plan of the
| Payne bill Is dropped and the maxi
mum bee the minimum under
she Aldrich scheme
Aldrich proposes customs court
of appeals for review of contest
customs cases whose. decision sbal
be final.
| Aldrich submits redraft of the in
ternational revenue tobacco tax law:
increasing the duties on snuffs, to-
baccos and cigars from 90 to so pei
cent
Duty on Hides.
The Payne drawback provision al
lowed on manufactured articles from
imported raw material is rejec ted
Aldrich submits the Dingley plan bu
throws 1t into conference for modifi
cation.