Arizona republican., 1909-07-09
REPUBLICAN INSURGENTS
Nine Were Against Meas ure - Aldrich Rebuked Beveridge For Assuming He Held in Keeping the Party's Conscience.

Washington, July S,-The tariff bill passed the senate just after II o'clock tonight by a vote of 45 to S4 Re- publicans voting on the negative were: Beveridge of Indiana; Bristow of Kan sas; Brown of Nebraska: Burkett of Nebraska; Clapp of innesota; Craw- ford of South Dakota: Cummins of Iowa; Deliver of Iowa; LaFollette of Wisconsin; Nelson of Minnesota.
 McEnery of Louisiana, was the only democrat voting in the affirmative
 Yeas-Aldrich, Borah, Bourne. Brad ley, Brandegee, Briggs. Bulkely, Burn ham, Burrows. Burton, Clark of Wy oming; Carter, Crane, Depew, Dick, Dixon, DuPont, Elkins, Flint, Frye, Gal finger Gamble. Guggenheim, Hale, Hepburn, Johnson of North Dakota Kean, Lorimer, Jones, McCumber, Mo Emery, Nixon, Oliver, Page, Penrose, Perkins, Piles, Scott, Smith of Michf- gan; Shoot. Stephenson, Sutherland, Warner. Warren, Wetmore, 45.
 Nays.Bacon. Bailey, Bankhead, Beveridge. Bristow, Brown, Burkett, Chamberlain, Clapp, Crawford, Culber- son, Cunmins. Daniel, Deliver, F'leteh- CT, Foster, Frazier. Gore, Hughes, Johnston of Alabama; LaFolette. Me Laurin. Martin, Money. Nelson, New lands, Overnan, owen, Shively, Sim mons, Smith of South Carolina Stone, Taliafero, Taylor, 34.
 Mir. Gore delivered a final denuncia- ne as exemplified in the bill. He com pared MT. Aldrich to the shepherd of a hungry flock, saying that his lambs had all been tanned until theey would eat out of the hand. Said be: Mary had one lamb and it followed her to school one day; the chairman of the finance has 50 lambs and they follow him every day.
 Suggesting that the president should promptly veto the tariff bill in fairness to his campaign pledge, Mir Gore said: Tt might not be so far reaching a prophecy to say that the next president of the United States may be an African" This adroit reference to Roosevelt was received with laughter.
 The failure of the senate to keep the promise made to people by the republican party respecting the re- vision of the tariff downward, was the theme of MT. Beveridge, as the debate on the pending bill was drawing to close. "Our vote" he said, shall be cast in harmony with our party's pledges as voiced by our partys leaders and the national president"
 Mir. Beveridge was answered by Mr. Aldrich, who said he had often seen men interpret their own judgment as the judgment of the party.
 ''The republican party is a party of majorities,' he added, and the views of the majority in matters of legisla- tion control party policies. The sen ator from Indiana does not speak for the republican party, and he has no right to call here the name of the president of the United States in sup port of any suggestion which he has made''
 MT Aldrich declared that the pending bin is a fulfillment of party pledges. If senators wished to vote against the bill, they should not attempt to speak for the party.
 MT. Crawford delivered a vigorous protest against any attempt of Chairman Aldrich to prevent the re- publican senators from the exercise of their judgment.
 Tt will take more than the senator from Rhode Island to read the state of Minnesota out of the republican party" said MT. Nelson, amid ap- plause, which called down the gavel of the vice president with the an- nouncement that such expressions were not permitted. Mir. Nelson said he did not care to be lectured by the senator from Rhode Island.
 The bill was then put on its pass age and passed, 45 to 34.
 On the motion of MT. Aldrich, the vice president announced the senate conferees: Aldrich, Burrows, Penrose Hale and Cullom, republican; Daniel Money and Bailey, democrats,
 The senate then adjourned at 11:1s