davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
New-York tribune., 1909-03-26
BOYLES In PITTSBURG.
OFFICERS AVOID SHARON.
Return to Pennsylvania Without Er-
tradition-Woman Identified.

Pittsburg, March 2S-Fearing for the safety OF
prisoners If they were taken TO Sharon or rne
county seat at Mercer, officers tonight orooshI
James H Boyle and his Wife accused OF honap-
ping Willie yyhitla, TO the Allegheny County jail
here.
They were brought here IN a special Pullman
car from Cleveland by way Of Youngstown ana
New Castle over the Pittsburg and Lake Erie
Railroad and arrived at 9:45 2. m The prisoners
were guarded in their by sixteen detectives and
officers.
II was the unanimous opinion Of the officers en-
gagged on the case that II would be safer not 70
take any chances by exposing their prisoners 10
the wrath of the Sharon populace
On the arrival Of the train here the prisoners
were placed in an automobile belonging TO Herry
Perkins end rushed TO the county Jail. boyle
was manacled and guarded by two detectives but
the woman was allowed to walk quietly pesiae
Harry Perkins Mrs Boyle chatted quite freely
with the officers and seemed TO be IN happy frame
Of mind
On the arrival at the Jail Mrs. Boyle looked around
and said: This looks q little better than Cleve-
land anyway"
II Is the intention OF the officers TO keep their
prisoners IN the jail here for several days and
at some time when the public is not expecting 1t
TO remove them TO the Mercer County jail s'There
they will be kept until the grand jury conVehes'
the third week in April.
Coming down on the train to-day Boyle talked
freelr out the woman talked little and refused TO
give any clew TO her past She stated however
that she originally from BrookIyn n y
please say that I do not get up on tables and
dance won't you?" said Mrs. Boyle TO a news
paper man in the parlor car. And say also that
I never made the remarks attributed 70 me-"
You mean about there being he'll IN Sharon?'
Yes" and she smiled il she enjoyed It. Il
guess that's what Sharon had, wasn't Il? But 1
never blasphenled. And never was burlesque
actress nor have I ever been on the stage at all
Ibid you know any Of tho Whitla family or their
relatives before you saw them in ClevelandT'
II never saw any of them except the boy. before
yesterday.
II came from New York. No, wasn't born
there. I don't think I to say where was
born have lived IN the West good while and I
met Mr.. Boyle there. We were married about a
year ago: couldn't say exactly.
Yes I was educated in q convent and spent
several years there. What convent1 Well. l
think I'd rather not say. 1t might be embarrassing
70 the nuns. you know.
You see I've been instructed not 70 say any
thing about myself or this matter You're news
paper MANI Well, some OF the things the papers
have said about have been simply terrible. and
I wish you would give the correction that am not
the vulgar person some have made me out to be.
You recognize position here; IL is bad
enough without talking too much about IL. No,
am sorry. but ! don't think I'd care TO say any
more about myself than I have told you
New-York tribune., 1909-03-26
SAYS NEW HAVEN Is NOT INTERESTED

A man associated with the New Haven Railroad
xasa that there was truth in the report pub
.shed yesterday 6hstthe company was couternplat-
ing asking the Public Service Commission for per-
mission 10 construct a subway from e point IN The
ye-onx 70 lower Manhattan He added that the New
Haven had sll 81 could attend TO at present with
out building subways. that it was not contemplate
Ing building any, and that, in his opinion. there
vras not a ghost Of a chance that II ever would
build any
Fse pointed oft that the road row landed fits pas
renrsrs q. z1d street. where they could take the
existing subway and easily reach the lower part
n. Manhattan and that when the proposed exten-
.fo7s 10 the existing saabways built they would
practically be able to go wherever they wished in
The city from this point Ultimately. he said when
.e proposed bridge fron1SThe Bronx 10 Long Island
WIS built the New Haven would be able TO run its
trains down the Long Island shore 10 junction
vim the Pennsylvania tunnels under the East
River. ana thrs be able 10 land its passengers at
Nth street. ir Manhattan.
New-York tribune., 1909-03-26
JUDGMENT AGAINST D. E. CAMERON.
Obtained by Hyman Goldman for So, ,429-
Original Order Issued in England.

Judgment was directed by Justice O'Gorman. 70
be entered In the Supreme Court yesterday against
Duncan Even Cameron. on his default 10 appear
and answer an action brought against him by
Hyrnan Goldman foot Of a judgment obtained
by him in the Supreme Court OF Judicature, in
England. The Judgment directed yesterday IS for
g 80 with costs. The summons served On
Cameron at his home in Rosebank. Staten Island
The records in the case contained certificate OF
Lord L.oreburn, the Lord Chancellor OF England
certifying that the signature OF "Alverstone, C. J.
to the Judgment roll made under the proper
authority Baron Alverstone. the lord chief JUS
tice OF the Kings Bench Division OF the Supreme
Court OF Judicature.
Samuel p Goldman. OF No 3s Broadway at
torney for the plaintiff. submitted deposition IN
which he said the Judgment upon which the sulr
was founded obtained IN the Kings Bench d.
vision the Supreme Court OF Judicature. in Eng
land on November IS. 1906. and was against Duncan
Even Cameron. 1t also said that Peter B. Olneys
Cauneron's lawyer had offered 20 settle the 1udg-
rnent for 81 so and costs. which was refused
second offer OF $500 and costs was subsequently
made and refused. and the suit 70 recover the fulL
amount IN the American courts was then nstiIuIsc-
New-York tribune., 1909-03-26
PLAN CAUCUS ON RULE
HOPE TO CLOSE DEBATE.
Opposition to Hosiery and GIoues
Schedule Irritates Committee.
rFrom The Tribune Bureau.I

Washington March Z-The effort which vaa
made to-day by the leaders in House Of Repre-
sentatives and by Representative Dwight the party
whip" to obtain agreement for the bringing IN
of a rule TO close the debate the tariff bill and
shut on other than committee amendments was
with strong objections from many Representa-
tives. Many OF the Republicans. who are dissatis-
fed with some Of the schedules IN the BILL are
openly saying that until they get some assurances
OF change they will not support rule. There Is
little or no objection TO closing the debate and
allowing the bill, a whole 20 go to vote but
there is strong objection 70 the proposal 70 limit
amendments to those which have the approval OF
the Ways and Means Committee
IN view OF the attitude OF the Republicans. II is
intended to call party caucus Saturday or
early next week. in which the objectng members
may thrash out their differences and reach soma
conclusion TO the form OF rule and the tina
for a the bill. The leaders believe that the
differences can be adjusted IN caucus They are
not disposed as yet TO surrender the proposal to
limit the amendments 70 those approved by the
Ways and Means COMMITTEES. because they feel that
any other course would result IN keeping the House
IN session all summer.
The Ways and Means Committee Will begin hold
ing meetings tomorrow TO consider the auend-
uents which have been urged by members Of the
dominant party in the House which have been
suggested by the discussion OF the bill IN the
try since il has been made public The members
OF the committee have already practically decided
upon a number OF amendments which have 70 do
customs act.
Members OF the committee BIT impatient
under the crusade which has started in the Middle
West against raising the duties on hosiery and
Hrornen's gloves They say that they made
haustive invests CATION OF the possibilities offered b.
increasing the duties these articles and decided
that they could well bear the additional burden.
They point out that when the duty was raised
mems gloves IN the Dingley bill the only result
was TO cause the erection OF factories in ts cOUn
try instead Of the continuance OF importation,
condition not undesirable. One member OF the Ways
and Means Committee said this afternoon that It
was proposed. II the present fight kept Up. cal
TO Washington q number OF large department store
managers and drygoQds JObbers- These men Will
be subpenaed to appear before the committee The
committee will seek show that they response
Bile for the crusade and that they have pecuniary
interests IN the foreign manufacture OF both won-
ems gloves and hosiery. The information now in
hand points directly to drygoods 5obbing and de-
partnnent stores In New York. Chicago and St.
Louis
New-York tribune., 1909-03-26
WOULD KNOW ABOUT JURY MINUTES.
Jerome Starts Inquiry Into How King Com
mittee Got Hold of Them.

District Attorney Jerome started an investigation
yesterday to ascertain how the King committee got
hold of the minutes OF the grand jury OF January
1908, which incorporated in the charges pre-
sented to Governor Hughes against Mr.. jerome.
Mr.. Jerome says there court order issued
so far he learn. giving permission to the
counsel 10 the King committee any other men,
ber OF the committee 20 see the minutes OF that
grand Jury.
The grand jury of January, 1905 investigated the
Ice Trust. James w. Osborne. Assistant Special
Attorney General. conducted the Ice Investigation
before the grand jury. and according to Mr.
Jerome, Mr.. Osborne and the court had the only
copies of the minutes OF that grand jury No one
else. Mr.. Jerome says, had q right to see these
minutes.
In his efforts TO find out just how the King COM
mittee got 10 these minutes Mr.. jerome called
before the grand jury yesterday Macdonald De
Witt, lawyer who has an Office with Clarence ].
shearn. and Miss Hubby a typewriter in Mr..
De Wits office.
Franklin Pierce, counsel for the King committee.
said last night at his home, No 312 West 1891
street. that stenographer had been sent 20 Mr.
osborne's office and that he had copied the min
utes. -1
New-York tribune., 1909-03-26

; wife were arrested in Cleveland The money was
carefully placed in a safety deposit box. to remain
till It may be needed evidence in the kidnapping
trial Mr.. Whitla came on the same train with the
prisoners as far as Youngstown. Word that the
prisoners were being taken to Pttsburg reached
here early IN the morning and all interest In the
Sharon end of the case was at once lost for the
time being.
Yesterday and last night sensational disclosures
expected TO occur in Cleveland. 1t is ap-
parent now however. that none OF these antici-
pated developments is going 10 materialize. The
kidnapping exciting but the develop
ments limited at yesterday would have been start
ling. They did not come. and. while everything
pointed for time In that direction, deductions were
wrong.
The woman under arrest in the case is not the
whose Identification would have caused SEN
sation here. It is believed now that she Is some
Western woman. who married Boyle. and is un-
known to members OF the Whita family Her re-
mark the time OF her arrest at Cleveland, that
There will be hell in Sharon when Buhl hears OF
It" has It is generally said now, special signi-
hcance.
It has now been established without doubt that
the woman now held at Cleveland is the same who
accompanied Boyle 20 this city recently for the
purpose of attending the funeral OF John Boyle,
OF the shenango House. an uncle. Al that
time Boyle introduced the woman as his wife.
There IS a reward OF $4,000 from the state OF
Pennsylvsnia for the captors OF tho kidnappers.
and several thousand dollars additional from news
papers about the country. The question as TO who
Is entitled to the reward interests large number
OF people. When Detective Perkins, OF PittsbuTg.
whose agency has been prominent In the case.
was asked for his views he said:
II believe the Cleveland police authorities are
entitled 10 the reward. Captain Shattuck and De-
tective Wood certainly made the arrests, and 1
don't care rap where they got their information
They did a clever piece of work. In fact, wish to
compliment and congratulate Chief Koher and his
men on the admirable manner In which they have
handled the case
Willie Whitla was the marble king OF Sharon to-
day. He received 81 50 witness fees fer appearing
before the grand jury in Cleveland To this amount
he added the II cents that 'Jonesy" gave him. and
now he is investing in marbles. The weather was
such to-day that he could not play outdoors, but
he and several Of his boy friends had the game OF
the year indoors at the Whitia home.
In a statement tonight District Attorney Lin
niger said that the Whtla family did not know
Mrs. Boyle. and that he believed that only Boyle
and his wife were concerned IN the crime "I
charge both the Boyles with kidnapping IN this
state. he said. They will be brought 20 the tail
Mercer. and after their formal arraignment will
be held to await the action OF the grand jury,
which meets the third Monday IN April. have
heard that Mrs. Boyle has been indicted for kid
mapping in Ohio. but the legal phase Of develop
ments do not to discuss She could be held
for conspiracy here well kidnapping"
New-York tribune., 1909-03-26
INDEPENDENT ORE ROAD.
Reported Object of $4,000, ,o0e
Jones & LaugIbm Bond Issue.
rRr Telegraph to<The Tribune.l ]


,,,..,-. asa-ob q5-Thei Jones & Laughlin Steel
ron,ranv announced to-day that the company nae
soid 70 The First<Trust and Savings company, %
Cbicaro and Blair & Co. OF New fork. S-s'oo"oOo
OF bonds on the plant In Statement lle coih-
pany says a-.
h.s accumulated in large amounts In the banks
n5 II seems prI9pitous time TO make the ISSUE
We don't anticipate any large expenditures Tor ne"
work at the present time. but wish TO be ready
when times improve TO complete plans winch We
have decided upon"
n WAS learned mere tonight that these planneo
improvements consist in the building OF railroad
<-arn Geneva Harbor Ohio. to Pittsburg- When the
,nea steel market was declared by the Unlteo
states Steel Corporation B, F. Ogden. traffic man
arer Of the Jones & Laughlin company, said:
saT,hls means the death OF Pittseurg as a steer
centre There is differential OF 81 IL oeI"eeh LAs
oosn.. and Pttfsburg The United States Steel Cor
-orstton can lay down Nesaba at their plant at
Carv et lust 81 Is ton less than we can lay down
.he same ore in Pittsburg AS it taxes two tons OF
-re 20 make ona ton of Steel the steel corporation
At Gary can make steel just & 3 a ton cheaper
shan we can make It in PTrtsourg.
While every official Of the Jones q Laushnn
o,-,aanx declares tonight that there is no truth
4 the statement that il is TO build railroad per-
sons In q position TO gknow assert that this Is not
only the intention OF the corporaton' but thst
most Of the right OF way has been secured anu
.hst the road will be started shortly.
The road will start ar Geneva Haroor. nine miles
se+ ~ Asbta;,ula and end at Pitts5urg- The Jones
a I,aughltn people have obtained right OF way
almost 3n an air line cutting down an ordinary
tractaea of 1ss miles less than 10 miles
Irnmense docks TO be erected al Geneva mar
bor and Il is expected that me Jones o. 1aue1' 1'4.
railroad which is to be known under the name OF
-te y1it+shurr Niles & Western Railroad. VIII also
transport ore other independent steel concerns
in the Pitts5urg district
New-York tribune., 1909-03-26

owner TO Chief Kohler. who had brought him into
the case when the woman IN the sweatoox admit
here.
The woman is declared to have been cast on by
her father when she fell into associations OF which
he did not approve three years ago. Her uncle
says her mothers name is Mrs Catherine McDer-
mott and that a brother. William. is IN chicago
hank Two sisters are living one recently married.
in Chicago and another IN Indiana town.
She began 10 live at a pace her father would
not cosntenance, and he cast her off, said the yes
sci man tonight. The family had not known
where she had been. She has married Boyle in
the last three years. He is not her equsl socially
or in the way Of education"
New-York tribune., 1909-03-26
FURTHER CUTS IN STEEL PRICES.
Market Said To Be More Deuloralized than aT
Anv Time Since Open Competition Began.

There was further reduction yesterday In the
rice Of certain finished steel products the most
trnnortant being in steel bars, which were cut 10
h 10 q hundred pounds. This is reduction OF S@
ton from the price ruling fer the last fe" "eeA'
and Of se ton from the price ruling when the open
market declaration was made by the United STATES
Steel Corporation.
Concessions are also being Inare, II is reported
In structural terial, sheets, tin plates ana olets
and prices of these products now at the lowest
level il years The price of structural steeI-sZl ~
a TONS 10 50 cents ton lower than the price
eSta blished at the OF the change IN price Oi-
icy The price Of Southern iron broke TO S19 90 q
tor Yesterday actual sales having been nlade at
that figure. which is the lowest level southern iron
hss reached in the current downward movement
III is said in the trade that the steel market IS
more deroralizad at present than at any time since
fhe open market was declared and that contnua-
.ion Of the present weakness viii force the closing
OF many mills Manufacturers no longer appear
10 Be sure tha. the price OF steel rails VIII be
maintained at SIS ton, and the general expecta-
ton IN the trade is that the price OF rails viii
have TO come down.
Fethlehen Penn, March 25-The Bethlehem Steel
Company announced q 10 per cent cut in the wages
OF furracernen to-day. go into effect on April !.
about one hundred men are affected
New-York tribune., 1909-03-26
STATE TROOPS TO COLLECT TAXES.

Frankfort, KY, March 25--On receipt OF word
from Tax Collector ]. W. Peck to-day that he has
been prevented by mobs and organizations from
collecting railroad taxes In the counties OF Carter
Eovd ana Elliott Governor Wilson announced to-
day that he would the state militia to assist
In the collection OF these taxes. He has sent word
10 tho officials of the three counties to meet him
here on Saturday and show cause why he should
not send soldiers to see that the tax collector is
not nnoIested in the performance OF his duty.
Tha railroad taxes which a number OF the coun-
ties In the state owe heavy and have been
unpaid for many years.
New-York tribune., 1909-03-26
MRS. BOYLE IDENTIFIED.
Anna McDermott, Daughter Of q
Wealthy Chicago Man.
rBy Telegraph 70 The tribune ]

loy AeAeSrdpn 10 Inc AlipNAe-I
Cleveland. March 25-The woman kidnapper of
asE3iIly' whftla has been Identified here Anna
McDermott daughter OF wealthy Chicago bust
ness man, convent educated and reared in home
of luxury. Her mothers half brother, millionaire
vessel owner of this city identified her in Central
police station to-day, hidden where the twenty
tvvo-yearold prisoner already identified by BILLY
Whitla as the woman TO whom his abductor
brought him last Thursday night could not see
him The vessel owners brother also Joined in the
Identification.
She's my half-slster's daughter. said the vessel
New-York tribune., 1909-03-26
CITY NEWS IN BRIEF.

MAGISTRATE House. in the Harlem court. yester-
day adjourned March 80 the hearing in the cases
OF the four Cinnamon accused OF beating Detectivs
Beck Because OF his injuries Beck was unable %
appear in court
4 mass meeting Of the practising arehitects o.
greater New York will be held under the auspices
OF the New York Society OF Architects at the
Grand Union Hotl next Tuesday.
New-York tribune., 1909-03-26
DEpEw SUBMITS COFFEE RESOLUTION.
IFron The Tribune Bureau.I

Washington. March Ex-senator DePew to-day
introduced resolution calling on the Secretary OF
State 10 send TO the Senate all correspondence be-
tween the State Department and the Republic OF
Cuba relating TO the question OF recognizing coffee
roasted in the United States. The resolution
offered at the request Of the Maritime League OF
New York
New-York tribune., 1909-03-26
NO SCANDAL IN SHARON.
Suspicion of Local Woman Proves
Unfounded.

Sharon. Penn. March 5-James P. Whitla re-
turned home tonight, bringing with him the money
which was recovered when James Boyle and his
New-York tribune., 1909-03-26

when the message came TO my ofhcelthis morn
ing he said. 81 do know that Mrs Lorlilaro
vas much alarmed over the condition OF her
heart. She had suffered considerably. "heh
she visited Paris last summer she sought an
eminent specialist whom she consulted as TO her
condition. but when she returned 10 America
she had been IL frequently I must decline 70
discuss any other phases Of the case"
Arrangements for the funeral are incomplete,
but * is said the body VIII be taken 70 New York
1or burial
Mrs. Pierre Lorillard. jr-, was. before hei i10A
riaEe. Miss Caroline Hamilton, daughter Oh
George Hamilton and played leading roie IA
the social life OF Tuxedo. which owed lts eAls'-
enoe rs a colony to her husbands tather. SH0
>vas particularly fond Of music, gave numerous
musicals both at her place at TUXEDO anu a.
her house In town, and some years ago d'-
.rac.ed much attention by writing clever gon-
ing .one which she set TO music OF her own
,crnrositiou and which sung at q gollihs
ouadrtIle at Tuxedo. in recent years MY anu
Mrs. Ioriuard have been IN the haot OF spenu
ing a portion Of the winter and early spring 44
washington, usually taking house there 'Oi
the season.
Mrs I,oriIlard's death places in mourning
ssrpe family connection. related as she was 10
.he Kernochan, Kent and Barley fannihes' q
-,,s1, as m Mrs Cecil Barring who was Miss MAUI
r.or;ilard, and who now makes her home III Eng
land. where her husband is heir 70 his oro1nei
<arldona Of Revelstoke.
Mexico weekly ledger., 1909-09-16
AvpRAN

Wm Armstrong q Kansas City
Is vtsltiAg T. B. Mallory.
R. B. McDoasA win leave Tuesday
for Louisville. Ky.
Dr.. John Maddox Of Middle Grove
IS IN Moosrly hospital with typhoid
fever.
J. J. LittrsIl. three Of the Car.
penter children and Mrs. Fred vii.
son each are down with the typhoid
|feTer.
Born, Friday. TO Mr.. and Mrs,
Jno. Estsce. a daughter.
Miss Myrtle White has gone to
Klrksvipe to enter the Normal
school.
Miss Eliza Mallory and W. T. Odds,
Of sedzlia. win be united In mas
rage Sunday. Sept 10.
Bruce Pollard sold a yeariing mule
to W. II. Pollard for SIPS.
Mrs. MobeEly bought the Jas.
Mann farm, crop. household goods,
horse and buggy for $1,000. The
farm coslsted of 50 acres.
George Pollard Is improving his
farm property.
R. D. CroSwhite sold a good
Jersey COW to T. B. Robinson for
$40.
w. Baker sold lambs to Foun-
tain & Bsrtee for S. 1-2c.
Mexico weekly ledger., 1909-09-16
DULY.

Here are congratulations to the
Duly School House district, having
treated their school house and out
buildings TO a fine coat of paint,
and their teacher, Miss Golden EN-
erson, one of Audrain county's best
teachers is to be congratulated on
being the best house keeper and
with the help Of her bright pupils
keeps their beautiful play grounds to
perfection.
After four years of regular attend.
ance at Duly school, Otto Neider.
schultz left last Friday for Wentz.
vile where he has entered into the
Parochiai school. Otto has a host
Of friends that wish him success and
goes well recommended by his teach.
ers, having won six presents and a
scholarship medal that was awarded
to him by his teacher, Miss Emerson
Otto is a grandson of II. T. Neider-
schultz, founder OF the Eve Luther.
an church in north Mexico, and a
successful farmer.