New-York tribune., 1909-04-06
,essfal hopers. .ae vote resulting Ayes, as: noes,
THE RULE REPORTED.

THE RULE REPORTED
~ ,Iis point the Relies committee reported the
Ions waited order. vhich reads as follows:
Resolved That immediately upon the sdoptii3Iri i;Ii
hereof General debate on House Rule l,45N-a pII
10 provide revenue equaliZe duties anu .1
.g,e si,u be ciosed and size House shall re
solve itself 'nto committee OF the Whole tIoaS ~ - IL
F,i Tor amendment under the fveminute rule bIt
Se'n GO n 5e- al . Tine and ls preference shall
given amendments 10 FaT - 'IilS ,iVt ,,j
70s gamber). Isl. 441i2 t1idesl. ~ 'barieS) a4I
e2S charley lnaltb- e,.-.3-
hs1 an amendment shall be voted on ,S TO Seeioa
So, wit Strike out The IroNlSo SIId, les 5e m
new paragraph No Ss12 the ielt0Mlis s,,, al
l,etroleur and its products 2 per cent d"
Tilst said specified amendments shall take preee-
'e7- T. i oIsder3tion Of said bin for amendment
"a, 80 .-,,ti5 ,,,t ster than FRIDAY. April q.
~, ~ y-ficb time the said bill. with all
aspenaments that shall have been recommended py
[is r,,Tnr5itfee Of tie whole House the state
~ the i-nian. shall be reported to the House. and
previous question shall lhen e .'i' a.
ordered. said amendment and sald blL l" It's
engrossnent. third reading a7la hnal passage.
~ so. - r. Ti4.e iiI55be~ Oh hsrlev barley malt.
ie and coffee any Of them. irrespective OF tAe
adoption or rejection IN committee OF the whole
and tie vote luor7 an other amendments in gross
That the daily hour OF meeting hereafter shdd De
y O'Clock noon
when the rule WAS reported Nj Dalzen explained
fl in detail.
Evidently referring &c Mr. Clark, Of Florida, Nj
Fou Of North Carolina. said that any man who
supported the bill belonged the Republican side.
Remarlzing that he placed his patriotism above
seIhshness. Mr. Cushman, OF Washington. defended
she special order He warned the members against
putting lumber the free list.
FITZGERALD Wft1ACIS- COLLEAGUES
Republican handclaps greeted Mr. Fitzgerald. Of
New York. the Democratic member OF the
committee on Rules lie said the minority leader.
Mr. Clark. had refused him tiE1e to speak, where
upon he sought and received time from the same
as eo Ie-3er Mr..
Dslzeli Whatever differences J may have with
nFv party associates in the House. he said Il shall
settle an appropriate time think TO my own
satisfaction NJ. Fitzgerald denounced the Payne
bill Which. said. did equaiize duties. He
declared that ne spoke in behalf Of the great con-
suming public
Mr Clark. Of Missouri. argued that every mem
Der Of the House had the right TO vote the bill
from a 10 u II members insisted tying their
hands he said they could DO 50. but he would not
When you go hack your constituents he ex-
claimed. don't he so cowardly 70 undertake TO
lay this whole thing N1r. Cannon" He called
attention Ia The outrageous raises in hosiery and
gloves
Answering all the arguments against the rule
Chairman PAYNE declared that the Republican party
would be held responsible for the bill befor- the
country That fact he said had weighed upon the
committee in the preparation ef the bill He as
sorted that every fact and every source Of infor-
nation had been sought IN order that q bin might
he presented that would do simple justice 10 the
people of the United states the conslimer and the
laborer. Responsibility the Democratic side, he
said different It is theirs criticise not
70 construct" he declared If the Democrats had
shown some diligence. courage and pa atriotsn he
said they would have presented the country their
idea Of tariff bill. He defended the glove and
hosiery schedules about which SO much had been
said and declared that under The bill they would
nc sold oheaply they were to-day with Amer
ican worknen and better workmanship. He plead
I'd with his colleagues TO look beyond their districts
and for Gods sake hasten the passage Of the BILL
DALZELL CLOSES DEBATE
Debate brought 10 a close by Mr. Dalzell
Who insisted that the country desired action and
talk lie then moved the previous question, but be
the vot. WAS announced Champ Clark moved
10 reoommit the rule and became involved IN a
controversy with Mr.. Dalzen and the Speaker over
whether tle motion in order Mr. Clark. amid
Democratic applause. quoted from former de-
siSion Of Speaker Cannon, holding that similar
suotion 10 r,coInmit in order, In elaborate
decision Speaker Cannon held that the in cues
sion was on an ordinary rule. This is an
dinary rule he said and Mr.. CIarks motion
overruled
ON The motion for the previous question the
Democrats forced a rollcal.
The vote resulted: Ayes. 1856 noes 1s5: present. /
and the previous question accordingly was ordered
Another rollc;H then forced by the Demo
Gratis on the adoption Of the rule.
Tae order MAS adopted: Ayes. f9s: noes, Us.
present. L
speaker cannon then ordered ilat the Dlli ne
taken I'd and considered for amendment Nj Ford
uey. of Michigan. at once moved strike the
couluervailing provision Of the lumber schedule
snag was Immediately encountered by Mr.. Payne
moving that The committee rise. This for the
purpose Of laying tie bill aside and moving an ad-
journment- the Democrats stoutlv resisted and
aVsiled themselves Of all parliamentary tactics TO
ThWsrt him.
Air Pavne's motion prevailed. Ie2 10 l4s and he
immediately thereafter moved TO adjourn The
Democrats forced another Tollcal. The motion
however carried and the House adjourned
until tomorrow