The Montgomery advertiser., 1909-10-21
WHIRIWnW CAMPAIGN
THREE NEW Y0RK MAYOnAIrY
 CANDIDATES MAy1n srEnCnEs.
HearnG nounarA an1 oaynee apeak te neg CFUw0D-TAmnanv Deaeoneea by 3anunr1 e S>Doe1ety fer
 Rr~mol1on oG onaff .s

New York, oct. ao.>srAis was anoth- CT night of whirlwtnd epeech making in the municipal campaign. but the three candidates, bfou9ht out nothing new in the way of personai attacks. William R.. Hearst the Iudepsndsnt nominee. delivered four spesches in New York; Otto T. Barnard. the Re- publican nominee. spoke thrice in Brooklyn and then appeared at Carne- gle Hall. New York, before . big fu~ sion gathering, and William J. Gaynor. the Democratic nominee. appeared at the Academy of Music. Brooklyn. for his third speech of the campaign.
 the same speech at all four places. He opened with an attack on Gaynor and Tammany, reviewed his efforts in be- half of the people through his news papers and concluded with this appeal: ::
 'In this campaign you should not vote for any friend or fayorite. but for a man who will. in your opinion. do the and the most for the best and honest interest of all your fellow citizens."
 In his address in Brooklyn. former Justice Qaynor referred smilingiy to his first visit 10 Tammany Hall last night T have bearded the tiger in his den." he said. Dand have faced that dreaded animal without a qualm and I am now convinced that nothing on earth can make me afraid"
 Covering the same ground. so to speak. as Hearst. he devoted the first part Of his speech to an attack on the editor, whom he referred to as "bel- lowing demagogue, who has never yet read the city. charter"
 Of Senator McCarren's illness, he said:
 we send out our sympathies tonight cwt, .Un have not all of us been able to agree with him at all times. we can remember the good he has done"
 The ex-Justice again announced his staunch support of hls associates on the Democratic ticket. some of whom have been criticised severely, particularly George F. Roche. Tammany nominee for Justice of the Supreme Court.
 The Bar Association of New York of- ficialiy denounced Rosche as mot it for the office." but Gaynor tonight stood by the ticket in the following words:
 T can say tonight, on my own be- half and on behalf of my associates on the Democratic ticket. that if elected. we expect to lead New York city a long step forward and upward, toward good government. New York city should be leader of the country. as the best gov erned city of the United states, and ic shall be if we are able to make 1t SO.
 When former Mayor Seth Low. a Re- publican, who was one of the principal speakers at the Carnegie Hall meeting. mentioned Hearst5 name there was an outburst of cheering. T am glad you applaud MT. Hearst" " said Mir Low, because he Is fighting with us In this campaign against Tam many"
 Mir. Barnard spoke:
 "Tammany is just Q society for the promotion of graft. They are not Dem ocrats. They have lived by the people, and on the people and for themselves. but think the people are going to kill 1t this trip. For example. let me tell you a little tale of cast iron pipe:
 Three years ago cast iron pipe was at its highest price. &s3 to $s4 per ton. Business men held of and would not buy 1t. Every one knew that price could not hold.
 "Tammany Hall bought 1s,s00 tons at the top. a difference in this purchase of just s22T.ooo. The pipe was laid north of and south of the Harlem river to the banks. for s1.oss.ooo. They never