New-York tribune., 1909-10-19
GAPNOR IN HERTZ CASE.
Red Light District Decision Dis
cussed by .Mr. Ilins.

William NJ WINS let 1t he known at the Civic AL
lance meeting in the Harlem Casino, 124th street
aho seventh avenue. last night that he would not
answer attacks made upon him. He was not an
ISSUE ne said This was Of the places on Mr.
Hearsts itinerary, but after the candidate had
come ana gone the audience paid all its attention
10 the man who was Republican candidate for
Mayor four years ago
Mr.. WINS said he was convinced on tho rigbt of
election in 1905 that Mr.. Hearst had been chosen
Mayor. and because he was cheated out of it at
una sI@iime' the speaker said, the Civic Alliance can
dioste should be elected this year. Before this
william A De Ford had declared that Mr.. Hearst
was the real fusion candidate for Mayor
After saying that he was looking for some in
telligent view of the city and its requirements
from Mr. Gaynor, Mr.. WINS continued:
Aud in all of his speeches I have found no such
Wora; 1 have heard him retell the story of the
have heard him talk about the necessity for ballot
reform, @ in which he had no part. whereas and
was was ever drawn in this country He said that
Because we are telling the truth about TammaSy
Han; because We are tearing down the veil from
he has ever defamed the city. and from what rs
point fG Of vhaSe b has has he defamed it? He judge
and its good name when the good name of the city
bench.
Two Incidents calling attention to alleged be-
trayals of the public interest. were then cited
among the decisions of Mr.. Gaynor. and Mr.. WINS
said:
And now this is the man who denounces those
Ing the last six years of Tammany government,
Hall You have spent over 500 900 Of the pro
ceeds Of our borrowing capacity. and have used
ways This from the man who has been willing
to deal With @ one Sne Of Mr. Hearsts emp9yes who is
which he performs as condemnation commissioner
What, let me ask you has Judge Gaynor
actually done? You have heard what Mr.. Hearst
has done nothing except that which makes against
Tns OF se & sng 0Te in eJ bs Of tbe a
night how he passed upon a pre-arranged case
which defnition would be adequate 10 permit ali
the racetEack gamblers TO escape and to nullify
Now let me call your attention to two
excitement in the town because of what was
known the community between the politicians
the lover East Side After the police had closed
up 3 OF places "a an nC ocsr Tas aGe ron
standing in front of one OF them and warning
woman oms in New York Rosie Hertz. # was at 3D.
s,paef and ID the RowerT and was known as the DTV
Dock Hotel. The application was made 10 Judge
ton. and then publicly announeed from the bench
be- that IT would be necessary for the Court itself
If ike visit the place :" order to see what 1t was
WINS sdlu tliab "lei MI HaSiioi NiS'''u 'i0
place he saw nothing out of the way and some
days later issued injunction. But the speaker
said the police obtained sufficient evidence to con-
vict the person who conducted the house on the
very night Mr.. Gaynor there.
Mr.. WINS closed his speech by saying that Mr..
Gaynor not fit for Mayor. that Mr.. Barnard
was fit If he could be elected, but that Mr. Hearst
was not only qualified. but would be elected.
Charles s. Whitman the fusion candidate for
District Attorney. spoke length the issues OF
the campaign. Other speakers were Mr. De Ford
and John Wesley Gaines.