New-York tribune., 1909-10-15
MORE GAYN0R HISTORY
DE FORD TELLS WHY JUS
IICE rs WITH TAMM1NY.
Wants To BE Governor and Presi-
dent-IJins Says He Has Only
Begun HIS attacks.

/ by the Civic Alliance things that they
! knew about Justice Gaynor. There was no
room to spare in the big hall. Mr. WINS after
! he had announced that the candidate of Tam
many was not the only possible savior OF the
! city, said that what he had said so far about
him was only beginning. There was still a
fortnight left to say other things With en-
| phasis Mr.. WINS said
He has been many years on the bench and
! dont hesitate to say that he has been bad
judge. 1 don't hesitate to say that he has been
a poor judge.
because he has earned a reputation of it's
1 klnd-God help him-as Judge he is endeavor-
/ ing to impose upon the community that reDuta-
! uoh as OF value as municipal expert II is
/ just as absurd as If some one should appear and
assert claim to being great surgeon because
/ he was successful chiropodist."
| Every point made by Mr. WINS was nunc+,,-
ated with ringing Cooper Union cheers They
nave way of seeing points, the men who
gather there and all evening they interrupted
with expressions Of approval as we'll as an
plause. 0P
MI AVlhs mad a good word to say for McCar-
rem not because he ever agreed with him or his
4"e.ious' Dut because he fought fairly. He also
toid OF the negotiations when an effort was r,ade
10 bring about a union of other independent
FORCES with the Committee of One Hundred and
tne committees refusal to accept Gaynor unIess
/ ha
'ie uecHhed a Tammany nomination
MR.. IvINsS SPEECH.
His Characterization of the extustica.s rooa
at thls failure to become the only candidate g
said: MI WINS
man. nave 6 Geme here tonight in the cause of no
New York ays r come in the cause OF the city Of
you sba and and Of whom give you my promise
H1t Gaynor insists that he is the sole othI
he the bsd bar when he rst eae afae
Christian Chi he eame H5deF o the OF r1 the
Der that f1om frGokIyn Sa as as reporter; and remem
lam 1eIoeTate calculation I'm the interests of VIII
success it Was si1 mat to make that calculation
monopoly of fPGsitTn Rno%eyne Where he have
on ne the has hrd the n, monopoy neither He has been
20 say that he has been bad Judge o iU1 % hStaIe
po6r pd 90 not hesitate say that he has been
say that he Yet % lost a0 a0 39t hsstate 70
where II 9 wa friend of the people under conditions
ms 'iie"oShp Tor himself ended '''N
KNOWS NOTHING OF CITY Arr,,ns
Mf WINS said that while Gaynor made tho
cialm that he knew about the citv's affairs +ha-.
was not man less qualified to discuss the ~.
sahlzation of the government Of the city. of Ne,,
YORK than he. Then ne said:
lily b9t because he has earned a renutation =, -,
to impose updn hlF9S Inn Judge he is endeavorng
some one Should a6noa 1t is Just absurd as if
nioe 10 the claim of a great surgeon becsI svII ms
W. " SeceeSsfu chiropodist in a manicure sb@0 nc
He believes that if conTnce TSe OF ma Ives
reached tbe ie5lSt @ can denonunce him. and he has
valuable than convincing. o' Is more
BRINGS UP DIVORCE. STORY
One HundreG SG@G az and q, MT meR6e5s the of
a ia ing worked until O'Clock in the mornfp @rSolS. sons.
could ge ey p,aeG in New York city where they
JACK Mr. G tynOr denounced them For "bS1LJi,y, bai,,
from man who has nothing WhateysT on is that
man n, eS b no right whatever say where anT ofber
reT4rds Of the divorce court this state examfned ee
got to stop He cannot go on defamfne ayh0r ab has
baUa @ asSrrt si hin3self as model of uprghtness
nave ALREADY shown what his attitude ~ in +h
G GaSe OF the racetrack gamblers I have shown to
tuition of tho state of New YORK i me Sonsti-
fro of t r ~ for the purpose securing con-
n 6e on ss gong thT"9sh his day after day.
his political funeral ''''' ''oUr "hich precedes
EXPLAINS HIS POSITION.
The speaker said that Mr.. Hearst had no de-
sire TO be Mayor, but that he did want 70 heat |
ISmmany and all its works. Concerning bic |
own status he said:
him moT four you %aaTs may 1 ask Why who opposed 10
is perfectly ceI aso and tqks S this position My
S dersStandng did not believe that Mr. Barnard |
only Mr. BannIrd and Mr. GaTnor IN mere fho "15 %aI
bi1 mr. P GaynoT would win and would carry with
nonii 1 thfopy Is this That man who can take the
moral stasbsmus such an extent that ster lrGe he
one tbi i GGe 9 ne can only cure the disease by seeing
Qualification for the office a disqualification for
could possibly be offered than this fact: Mr. Metz
Facien to a9aofy Ko9a GshfsS P fo That
6rear Ere and very dear and splendid old friend
shown himself 10 be entirely Hnamensh GiS; o a mas
many Hall he has demonstrate that his will is his
is his disqualification. Consequently. he cannot be
nominated Go down the entire line
TAMMANY WANTS TOOLS
and hirelings men who viii take orders "I and t6s
moment it is demonstrated that these men will not
ming They have no further chance
ed M hi 9SI3F , SKS bi f t pa technlGal kRow
City and he lacks the temper which hts him for it,
thousand members Of the bar who would vote for
Justice GagRor top or MAYOR b IoT no other reason on
think need anything more about that
no re sreae P advocate II naS is an
Scts @ Ir5aK M oote re3IS fTo crnT TT ss 6 IN one Ian
as though he did not find it within his own grasp
TO say his own things in his own
OPINION ON GAYNOR's DECISION.
Now. ta-night 1 am perfectly sure that Mr. Gay
nor is saving some thnEf TIN bS about me that are quite
as r1d 1ng Mr S synS f9T
the reason that years tried 20 read his deci-
ways lost and so don't read his speeches. and
what ne saws does not disturb me,
A very distinguished citizen said to me to-day,
a. But IL is a very bad thing To dscredit man who
has been as prominent in public life as he. l said:
''Wy dear sir you are wrong. IL is very good
tbi1y To discredit a man who has been for years
nosi5r as that which he was not. and who has
been bringing the Office which he has held. itselI,
into discTedtt
WHY HEARST QUIT GAYNOR
William A. De Ford. who was introduced as
one who had much to do with the passage of the