Evening bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu, Hawaii]) 1895-1912, 1909-01-14

HleulCHl WltHtSSeS, WIN IHe eNCCp-
ton of short statements made by Of
ficers Kalakiela and Luahiwa. In
his REORGANIZATION of the medical
experts DR.. Atcherley showed him
self to advantage, though he insisted
on coming back always to the great
leprosy-cure secret, which has been
the cause of his undoing.
MagoOn asked Emerson II the
facts Of the case would Justify the
sending of Dr. Atcherlcy to the In
sane Asylum under all the circum-
stances.
Il think he should be committed to
the Insane Asylum or be charged
with criminal offensc," answered
Emerson.
81 think he should be committed TO
the Insane Asylum" he added. at
would be wrong to charge him with
an offense."
DO you think that when r. Miner
Harrison went out TO Kalihi and
made some trouble in native house
that he should be committed to the
Insane Asylum" asked Magoon.
"lIe went to the asylum" broke in
Cathcart, and the Harrison COMPARE
son was left out.
DO you think DR.. Atcherley
would be likely to commit acts of
violence?" asked Magoon.
1T is possible" answered Emer-
son. "HIe would be quite likely to.
He labOred under the dclusion that
Or. Wayson was his enemy, and that
he could take extreme measures
against him."
"Atcherley said DR.. Wayson stole
his remedy and was using It," said
Emerson in answer to question as
to- what Atcherley had told him. "Hc
cited instances Of actions of the
Board of Health. lie felt that Way
son was his enemy. lie always spoke
in polite way Wayson, he said,
was always rapping about his house
at night"
what are DR.. AtChcrlcy's delu-
sions?" asked Magoon.
Well" answered Emerson, 81
don't believe DR.. Wayson stole his
remedy"
"Well / do!'f Numbered Magoon.
you believe Wayson stole it," cut
in Cathcart.
well, ! think he has It," retorted
MagOon. "He may not have stolen
It, but he has the remedy"
IL expect you think Atcherley
heard voices from the sewer, too?'
asked Cathcart.
At this point Dr. Atcherley cut In
with technical questions relating tn
various phases Of insanity, which
brought about the impression that
the patient was better founded In the
science than the expert.
"Ah, you are not very familiar
with the subject" said Atcherley I'm.
ally, very politely.
Il certainly am" retorted Emer-
son, hotly.
well, give us the causation of
phranoia."
II am not Obliged to do so. We
don't always know the causes of dis
eases"
The Court cut in with a question
as to where all this led.
'IIe has given me the use of alCo-
hoI as II cause of paranoia," said
Atcherley. AS matter OF fact, 1t
has never been known TO be So"
Emerson said It had.
We'll, If ! show you a book which
says It has not, what have you to
say" asked Atcherley.
"I'll say the man who wrote the
book does not have the same Views
as | have"
and you are more likely to be
right than the book"
II don't say So"
What is the proper pill dose for
morphine given by the U. s. pharma-
cCpia?" asked Atcherley.
II don't know. don't remember"
DR.. Atcherley continued to put DR..
Emerson through a rigid medical ex-
animation, which proved rather I'M
comfortable.
Ex-Assistant Chief of Detectives
Luahiwa testified that he had been
sent on Sunday morning to listen ia
the voices which DR.. Atcherley heard.
lie had stayed there quite a while
but had failed to hear them.
DR., Collins was the next witness
called.
do you consider that DIR. Atcher-
ley is of unsound mind?" asked Cath
cart
81 consider him to be of unsound
mind" answered Collins.
do you think it warrants his be.
ing detained In an asylum"
IL consider that It does"
ION what do you base your opinion
Of DR., Atcherley?"
'fIe has delusiOn of persecution
that DR.. Wayson has done him an in.
jury, and he deduces from that that
his only means of retaliation Is to dc
HIM an injury-is to shoot DR.. Way
son. 1t was the only way in which
could retaliate, said Atcherley
when We examined him"
"TIe told me that DR.. Wayson had
been Instrumental in stealing some
remedies. and also some photo
graphs" said DR.. Collins, In answer