davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30

as heretofore, then what becomes OF
the continued ''Fcdcral bunch protest
alton that the church is not in politics
and that the people have nothing to fear
from church interference in politics 7
Did that mean merely that so long as
the church supported the "Fcderal
bunch.' the "Fcderal BUNCH was CON
tent. and that the minute the church
fails to support the Federal bunch
that ''bunch = sets mp n wall? That is,
the Federal bunch is quite content
as long as it is receiving church sup
port. and il is deep down in the dumps
whom that support goes elsewhere. That
sort of "no church in politics. is the
curse of Utah now as heretofore. But
the outcry Of the organ OF the "Fed-
cral bunch " at the manifestation of the
church in politics is at once glaring
hypocrisy and a complete admission Of
all that the American party has charged
in this regard.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30
CHURCH ORGAN sNEAKINEss.

One of the most interesting things
that has appeared in the editorial col.
umns of the Dcscrct News is the. fol.
lowing, in its issue Of October %, 1909;
The church Is an ecclesiastical organ
iZallon and has never attempted TO con-
troll the city or the state IL is true the
first organization in this valley was ccclc-
Siastical. and it necessarily took some
time before tlIc city could bn iucor-
poratrd. but after the organization of
the municipality the church never tried
10 dominate or control tho city.
Now, that is untrue, as arc most of
the statements which have recently
been made by the major church organ.
We will first mako answer TO The false
assertion that the Mormon church has
never attempted TO control The State
1--WE presume that the word ''Tcrri-
toryi' will not be objected TO by thc
News. because It's reference TO carly
history world Indicate that il intended
to cover the matter from the very be
ginning.) II is. assumed That no better
example could be produced in this sub
.lcct THAN that which is presented in
the person and activities Of Brigham
Young, whom the News has seen fit
recently to drag into the present con
trovcrsy. President Young Of the Nor.
mon church was also governor Of the
Territory of Utah. As the News says,
"the first organization in this valley
was cccleciastical; but even after the
civil government here WAS supposed TO
have been organized, the president Of
the church continued 10 he the COVER.
nor. And not only that; but VIC have
HIM saving, in 4 sermon which he
preached in the Mormon tabernacle in
this city on February is, 1850, (see
Journal of Discourscs. volume ., pages
ls3 and 1881.
The newspapers are iceming with state
mcnts that 1 said. president Pierce and
all he'll could not remove mo from office -
Governor Of Utah Territory just as long
as He lGodl wants me 10 be; and for
that time, neither the President of the
United states, nor any other power, can
prevent il. have been Cow
crnor OF this Territory ever since it has
had one, and in all my official iranSac-
tions ] have acted in accordance with the
priesthood | never VIII infringe upon IL
with anything ! may operate In in any
office: let them all 20 By the board. be-
fore l Will nc brought into a situation
that viii cause me 10 infringe upon my
priesthood. in al! my doings as an elder
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30
NO FAULT TO FIND.

.,
inc feal ng"' IN INC PreSeh' cam.
p''eh appears no" 10 oe 'oi'," w
anu 10 ne oc'"'eii ''o wv ]"o'''a'
u '"G ) "Sio"'s - 'o' '''V'" P'''>'
inc e!ec''o" 'e'u'"S,
h'i' e'r" OF t"eso l'''''"N Plo
'e",' - ""' i""'y VIZ '"1 ~ 80
panty ''I" N"o"' !" i'l' ',''v
- Nv ''"' I''''' - -. '"""n' ~,
CAV" - ie''l'S my '''t.i sLi .'IY ,n
o'"ei '""u 'is"'' ~, % '9'"o' Wv
,Tau pa - - So 49, -.
."'', ''c'"' '"o ''',',' ~, ,p,' Ie'.aI
:" 49,? ivy ~ ~" | ant,.
49,, -, ,.,;sra,,..,',,. an oIos.as
-, -, -
-. 90 -. a., h,,;noss
-.
49,. Io,.,,.o
a.,
- - I,l. 80, t..a,sa ra,on ,rao
80 - ''''.' l1"n.' D'',p".L a5
' 49, -, ,.,r,,
-, nj. .I..;. ~
,-.'',., i,l a,.,,5
-. e ;-;..,.
-, u, g a.. 1-ait.5
c.. :. 80 \,.,,ro,I,. t,;y
- 49,. -. ,sr e.,,;,,, f,,,1t ,,i,l,
a.. n.r;aan ,ar,,. ar ,orl,
m I,n othor hand no two r,otior,
a. ..,,,.. Ill. 90
rLa ..rala.,I t,,,aar,, ,,1.,,o5 =
Ell. J ,,..a,. .r;o1. - ho
,'h,,r,h nal;,;oianS 1asf ,.c,r rrhcn t,cv
olIiad G.o oLmrab a.;n, ,I,a Iianor -
-. ,l d. ,Ltn;,oJ ,.;a,or,.
~ ,,.t;.t ,,s@ hoa,t,I,urn;na rro,, anJ
~. 20 -. I.a,. M a,.
ea,,, - .I,as. .,.o t,ot;onr &C ,ho o,,no.
'.,.o 80 IVY -. ,',, ,I,,;,
49,, ..a, J,,.. ast ma Meet
So. T,,' -. 49,, ,,.,naL a-oan La. Lad
,; -, ~
ssI, Co. '.'5 -, ~. ,', ,,,,.,,-,,,,,.
= ,'a Ia,,. .Gp,a,II;aan, aarG. ~
- 49,, - 49,
.t,,t., I;.,.t -, ',.;,,an
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30
THE COUNCIL PARAMOUNT.

No one who has the welfare of this
city at heart wants the splendid work
of the American party in uphniiding
the city and pushing il TO the front,
10 stop. And vet it would stop rs
certainly as night follows day if re-
dictionary. obstructive City Council
should be elected Al know this by
tho course OF the opposition members
now in the Council. They have done
their utmost. in opposing the $60O,OO0
bond issue last year, aud in other ways,
to head off rhc public Improvements
under way aud contemplated,
Ii is reasonable assumption that
other opposition Councimen would do
the same as is done by the opposition
members now in the City Council. The
duty of The voters, therefore, is plain.
Since the election of an opposition
Council would set progress back, such
opposition must he defeated. The way
the only way-to defeat it, and to
keep Salt Lake City moving forward
in the splendid progress which the
American party inaugurated and has
maintained with cyer-growing force
and vigor, is TO elect an American
Council. 10 sustain the hands of Mayor
Bransford in his good work for Salt
Lake
Voters of the American party, of
course. see the need of this, And yet,
we must continue to impress il upon
them And VIC wish TO impress it with
especial force upon that numerous class
of citizens who. not heretofore acting
with the American party. have assured
Mayor Bransford that they will vote
for him this year. To all these we
say that they viii largely fail of their
purpose unless they vote also for the
whole American ticket Including
Couucilmcn; for it is useless TO vote
for Mayor Bransford and at the same
tinic tic his hands by clecting an oppo-
siton Council Consistency, as well rs
business sense, requires that in voting
for Mavor Bransford the vote should
also carry with ii the support of those
who will help him 10 carry out his
policies
4 vote for Bransford kills itself
if il is also cast for opposition Coun-
cilmen. Vote the American ticket
straight. and let us have 8 harmoni
Gus, helpful, busincss-likc administra-
ton, ono that VIII be unit for Salt
Lake and for the continuation Of the
splendid progress which is now so cvi.
dent in all directions.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30
TRIBUNE, MORNING OCTOBER

OF Israel. as holding the keys OF the
priesthood TO this generation, IT / con-
ttnuc 10 be the Governor OF this Terri
tory, l shall magnify my office by my
priesthood.
VIII the Ueseret News name n Gentle
Governor of Utah who has ever been
elected by the citizens of this common
wealth? Have these elected by the Nor.
mon people not always "magnlicd their
Office by their priesthood ~ Is II not
true that, while Brigham Young hypo-
critically declared that he would hold
the governorship during the pleasure Of
the Almighty, he also claimed the right
TO designate what that pleasure was?
The lying of the church organ only be
comes the worse when it is easily proved
to be unintelligent lying-thc false
hood of fool
AS TO Salt Lake City--well. as they
say. "It is TO Taught"
The story is too long 10 relate it in
its every dctail-aud perhaps the Des-
eret News depended upon that circum
stance to clear itself of any danger Of
successful contradiction. But, now, if
the church organ viii explain away
those little financial transactions be
tween Salt Lake City and President
Brigham Young, wherein Young would
clean out the city treasury 10 help
church work, it win confer at least one
favor. Then if it win 20 through the
municipal rccords-as The Tribune has
done many timcs-and inform the pub
lie why it was that it was almost an
impossibility to segrcgato the accounts
of the city from the accounts Of the
tithing office. except to make the city
the loser, another service will have
been performed Then it should tell us
why il was that the priesthood ran
moonshine whiskey stills under the
city's name and authority, meantime
robbing tho United States of its proper
revenue from that source. and flooding
the town with ''Vallcy Tan through
the medium Of tho Getty Liquor
Store" upon whose Intel was tbe en-
bem of the "alIseeing eye' and the
inscription, ''lIoincss to the Lord. =
The church organ ought, in all common
sense, to explain why il was that n re-
porter of The Tribune, who had been
exposing n continuation Of these rotten
ncsses, was ordered out Of the city coun-
ell meeting in September, 1873, under
the terms Of vicious and liberty
sQuclching resolution introduced by
Apostle Joseph L. Smith
In fine, viii the News tell us why
il was That scarcely Sunday sermon
was preached in the tabernacle for forty
years except therein some high diGni-
tary Of the church, or some mean satrap
of the higher priesthood cursed and
damned United States officials, unless
that course was in pursuance OF de
termination to dominate Territory,
counties, cilics, towns and villagcsi
But, as it seems now TO be true, tho
News has become so reckless that, hav-
ing no haven Of truth to which to fec
for safety, it seeks refuge in falschood.
And ii IS apparently unparticu!ar as to
the vilcncss or utter Stupidity of its
Iics
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30

our tcllowmcn by our example and
moral qualities. We had better not pro
pose coercion. There should be no at.
tempt 10 return TO the Oldtimc Blue
laws. civilization found it necessary 10
abolish IL they [mcmbcrs
of the W. G, +. L. engaged in temper,
ance work would work privately, each
one in her own surroundings, against
The bad habits. they would have more
success than they can hope 10 achieve
by protests, resolutions, petitions, and
declamationS.
On March 81, 1906, the News referred
IN this contemptuOus manner TO the
supposed futility of women < work in
politics III general, and more partic.
uIar1y as applied TO opposing the polit
ical ambitions OF "thc Lord IS an.
nointcd:n "'The expected impression
upon the United States Senate through
the forwarding OF petitioners signed
by lcgions Of religious women, asking
for the expulsion from that body Of Sen.
ator Reed Smoot. does not seem to have
been made to the extent intended and
expected.
Take the course Of the News all the
way through from its very beginning,
and 1T has been one of constant bclittlc
mcnt of womankind. II thought no
woman really good but that one who
would submit herself TO the lcchcrous
purposes of tho polygamous priesthood.
1t has always attempted TO hide behind
womcn's skirts 10 escape the couse.
duenccs OF its own dcviItry. In fact,
10 the News. woman has always occu-
pied the position of n mere convenience
TO be used or abused by towards who
have neither the courage TO fight their
own battles nor the decency TO keep
unodcnding women free from admixturs
IN their unclean assaults.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30
WOMEN AND MINISTER'S.


On Wednesday evening tho DcScrct
News editoriallv made n ptcous appeal
To dcnominatjonal Christian people IN
this city. 1T first made totally false
presentation. pretending that IT por-
traycd the actual condition here and
then went OIL TO say: .And right here
VIC take the liberty of submitting 10
the Christian voters. and especially TO
the women, whether this awful state
of affairs is III their view desirable -
The role of pious snivcllcr suits the
News TO a tee But what n wonderful
change of heart toward Christian wo-
men that hvpocritical organ has expert
cuccdl In respect Of this change of
attitude, The Tribune viii call the at
tcntion Of The public TO The following
uttcranccs of the church organ. written
and printed by the News during the
progress of the Smoot controversy, and
which arc in utter contempt and dcTl-
sion Of Christian ministers and Chris
tian women all over the land;
On July II, 1905, it said; ''lts fre.
qucnt rawlings with other phrases of n
similar sort. bctray the hand that
framed the nonsense for these women
and preachers 10 father, or mother,
whichever YOU please. and they show
how easy it is TO get voters 10 a rcso
luton or signcrs 10 n petition, no mat
ter what folly and falschood either
NAV contain Entertaining that man
or of opinion concerning Christian
ministers and Christian women, il is
readily guessed that the News lmagincs
these good people 10 be so "casy =
that they may be brought TO support
any sort Of falschood that it has mind
TO put out.
On December JIG, 1909, the News
spoke derisivcly of "the clamors of
religious sectarlcs, male and female, y
simply because their voices were raised
against the brazen intrusion Of the
Mormon church into the affairs OF state
by forcing Mormon apostle upon the
Senate of the United States. where he
had no business to be, and where he
ought not to be now.
On February 8, 1906. the News dc.
ridnd the women IN this language:
"Wben the matter comes forward for
action in the Senate. il is possible that
some Of the members of that body VIII
be found to have too little backbone 10
resist he plcadings of so many Of
the women of the land, but VIC hope.
for the sake of rational and constitu-
tional government, that nothing but
the real merits of the case viii be con
sidcred when vote is finally taken,
We do not expect the church organ to
present the matter now under consider
atiou in such n manner as that IT must
he decided upon ITS real merits; but IL
such an impossibility should defy all
natural law by coming TO pass. we viii
risk the judgment of the ''womcn Of
the landD whom il once hoped the Sen
ate would ignore.
On February 9, 1906, (aDd this goes
to the hypocrisy Of its present pretend.
ed attitude upon The liquor question. as
well rs to show what little regard it
has for good women generality. the
News said "If we cannot influence
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30

a couple Of fellows in Denver arc
SUNG Salt Lake police Officials for
money because they were arrested here
as yagrants We can't blame en-
much. Evidently they want money
enough to get out of Denver.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30

Mr.. Rockefeller has contributed a
million dollars TO u fund for invcstiga-
tion Of tho hook worm disease II viii
be all right, however. with the school
boy If he docsn I disturb the
- hockey worm
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30
Where Tine Tribune Is on Sale.

Bnghsm-E, II. Lovescy.
Eureka-Jas L. Ford.
Park City-A. Morning. 49,,
Murrsy-ENcelstor Stationery CO. inu
osdenN2dsSS Washington avenue,
Provo-Utah News Co. ~,
New York Clty-Waldorf-A Astoria Ho'-
allng's, Broadway and 3sth st. IN
Chicaco-CSicaEo Newspaper Agency -"
Madison 81. Empire News STAND Auu'-
torium. Palmer House.
Washington d, C,-Columbla ~ @ Mo
Agency. National News Agency New
Willard News Stand oo,
Omaha-Barkalow Bros. Union tepo''
Gates News CO., 160i Farnham ST.
Kansas City-World Toma news Co'-,,,.
Portland-Bowman News Co. Rose lily
News co. Oregon News Co pod
Los Angoles--Amos News Co ~. ~: -
foN Hotel Hayward; W. MenoSSN WEI Scus
San F-ancisco-Hotel St Francis Soms m,s
stand y. wheatley' uniteu news
oaEisnd-Anos News Co. Athens News
scsttle-A. 1serlls Amos News CO.
Acme News Co.. Jas. n heuern'"'
Spokane-Wido World News Co
Tacoma-TreEo News Co.
Deuvcr-Browu Palace Hotel n 7. ban-
sen KendriclS Book and stationery Co.,
s, wldon western News Agency.
Eoisc-Boise Book and Music 20, -
Bonetti. Edmond Salmon, Idanha ho'e''
Poca leIlo-Rook Store Pharmacy.
Sutte-Keefe Bros. p. ., News S'ano'
Jno. c. Evans. -
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30

Queen Alexandra is said 10 favor
Doctor Cook in his claim of having
found The north pole; and nobody on
earth viii doubt that the splendid lady
has always been woman of good
sense.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30

Apostle Smoot s "Mouthr prints re.
productions of signed agreements and
receipts. and so on, in fraud scheme
OF ITS own concoction; but whoever may
be entitled TO it viii doubtless feel
vastly more safe when he has the real
money in hand.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30

Why is il that the Dcscret News has
nothing to say concerning the fact that
president Of a stake in Zion has un.
lawfully married the young daughter of
his first counselor the mock ceremony
having been performed by Mormon
.puostlrp
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30

Gebhardt, tic New York murderer
polygamist, contcsscs 10 having killed
several women, but still insists that he
VIII not 60 to the electric chair, Welt.
nc shouldn Just QUO plain, straight.
forward hanging would be good enough.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30

The Deserct News revivcs some of
It's own lies against the old Liberal
party as evidence" of the sins of
that party. But au old lie Of the
News Is no better than a fresh ono:
and the public has ample evidence
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30
For Coupcilmen.

First Wsrd-J. 3. Moretou, J. w. Nc.
Second Ward-E. G. o 'DonnclI, c, II.
Reed
Third Ward-William z. Davis, Tom
Matthews.
Fourth Ward-W. Mont. Ferry, Wal.
ter g. Lyme.
Fifth Wsrd-Martin L. Mulvey, Mark
Rerdall
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30

We Will give Elder Joseph j.. TAYLOR
one moro opportunity to "come
through = with at lcast one thousand
dollars out of that. celebrated heap of
new polygamous reward money,
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30

y couple of Americans have becu
arrested in Paris for assuming "bor-
.rowed" titles. They ought TO be- It's
bad enough to own 'cm by right.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30

Wboop 'em up, breihrcn. We re-
member the time when you used 10
shoot up the town: so we wouldn t
be at oil surprised if now. in your
older days. YOU merely want 10 ste
frin I'm -
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30

hud the block teacher is now able
10 bear his testimony to the effect that
1t is The desire Of the brethren to
tie 'em mp.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30

Never mind; Just nice little rain
like that only makes rs appreciate
more than ever the glory of our In
dlan summer
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30

anyway, 1.-The brethren" will find
that il didn pay 10 ihus swap polit.
ical horses in the middle Of the stream
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30

Isn't it a bit funny for honrc-dc.
stroying polygamists 10 appeal 10 de
cent women for their corntcnance and
sunpOri
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30

Nevertheless, II Doctor Cook succeeds
IN establishing his claims there will
bc whole lot OF distinguished scram.
bliug for quiet corners.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30

Amcricsnism has made good in The
progress race; so why does anybody
want tosciyc Mossbacldsm any chance
nj all,
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30

Down in thc Bloody Third;
Yah, vc hs goi TO lie dem oop'
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30

Not only do they seek 10 have "a
plurality OF wives but some of en-
appear TO even want a majority.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30

If YOU want progress 10 continue.
don I vote with the '"Tic. 'cln-uDs.'
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30

If either OF the church organs saws
il, the other SAYS Me. TOO, -
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30

Uncle Sol Kimball would, but he
Z" dassn I.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30

We re ONTO you. Mr. Tie 'cm.up.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30

Yes. it., out-"Tic 'cm up.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30

every day of the enormity Of its
present lies.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30

Arc YOU going 10 vote 10 ''tc 'cm
up'
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1909-10-30
AMERICAN TICKET.

For Mayor ohm S. Brsnsfor'l.
For Harper J. DiDiuny.
For Auditor-Rmdolph Aft.
For Treasurcr-Gidcnu Snyder.
For Rccordcr-Beu $. Riycs.
Blue-grass blade., 1909-06-13
BLUE GRASS BLADE.

especially of the Episcopal denomination, not prone
to investigation The in permitting such state
ment to be published and thus aording those who did
know opportunity to read what he had said In his
church Rev. Hough SAFE The danger from pub
lcity There would have been scarcely any point to his
fabulous story unless conversion alleged To have
permitted infde, who Exceptionally brilliant
man. to have remained infdel, would have done his
profession good, hence, the alleged conversion
At this point prone to ask Rev. Hough the
of the frst president of this pet scheme of Ingersos"
He might also state of the places at which he ecured
When and where did the alleged conversion take place Is
this converted Freethnker still in the land OF the living
If will Rev. Hough give his and address that
may communicate with him!
In the first place. no "National Freethought College,
established at Liberal Mo- There was, indeed,
Freethought society which held regular meetings. and it
had its officers including president If this is what is
meant will Rev. Hough state? But there hundreds
of similar societies in existence throughout the United
States today if this became miserable failure
what Rev. Hough give regarding other and
Freehought societies organized since that time
and in existence and operation now Assuming for the
sake of argument that it miserable failure" how
many miserable failures" recorded concerning Eps
cOpal churches in America. If such argument is good
in instance, is it not also good in the other
Rev. Hough may depore the "athestc tendency of the
age but if the story he has related about Liberal No. be
true he ought not to feel the slightest fear. "He
finally converted bespeaks fearful apprehension lest
fat job should slip away from him. 1t is the soace of
presty fools, who seeing danger shut their eyes in
the hope of not having to recognize it.
But spoke of vanity, and asserted that Rev.
Hough had his plethora of very suspicious brand of that
article This gather from the fact that he exploits his
purity" in the paper along with the report of his
Judging from his physiognomy he ought to be planting
posholes in the dark of the moon instead of relating
ignorant congregations incidents that had any actual
occurrence selling the truth for miserable of poage
Such cannot be put in the penitentary, but if the
Christian could prove his religion re there would be
satisfaction in knowing that somewhere in this universe
there was sulphurous hell where ends bowling lie, and
that the warnest section would be reserved for him.