Atlanta semi-weekly journal. (Atlanta, Ga.) 1898-1920, 1909-10-22
Hearst Speaks Four Times, Ban
nard Three, and Gaynor Once
Latter Calls Independent Nomi-
nee Believing Demagogue.
NEVER EVEN READ
THE CITY CHARTER
'Tammany a Society for the Pro-
motion of Graft" Barnard De-
clares, Relating Instance of Pipe
Laying and Paving.

NEW YORK. Oct. 2.--Lsst night was
another of whirlwihd speeeh-making in
the municipal campaign, but the three
candidates brought out nothing new In
the way of personal attacks. William r.
Hearst. the Independent nominee, deliv-
cred four speeches in New York; Otto T.
Barnard, the Republican nominee, spoke
thrice in Brooklyn and then appeared at
Carnegie hall, New York, before a big
fIAion gathering. and William ]. Gaynor.
the Democratic nominee, appeared at the
Academy OF Music. Brooklyn. for his
third speech OF the campaign
Mr. Hearst delivered substantially the
same speech at all four places. He open
ed with an attack on Gsynor and Tam
many. and reviewed his efforts in behalf
Of the people through mis- newspapers.
In his address in Brooklyn, former Jus
tice Gaynor referred smilingly to his first
visit TO Tammany hall last night.
"I have bearded the tiger In his den, !"
he said, land have faced that dreaded an
innal without a Qualm, and am now con-
WINGED that nothing on earth can make
me afraid"
Covering the same ground, so 10 speak.
as Hearst, he devoted the first part Of his
speech 10 an attack on the editor, whom
he referred to as a believing demagogue.
who has never yet read the city charter.
STOOD BY RoEsCH. ~
The sx-iustice again announced his
stanch support of his associates on the
Democratic ticket, some OF whom have
been criticised severely, particularly
George +. .Roesch, Tammany nominee for
justice of the city court.
The Bar Association Of New York. Off
ciaIly denounced Roesch as mot fit for
the office" but Gaynor last night stood
by the ticket in the following words:
II can say tonight. on my own behalf
OF my associates on the Democratic tick
ct, that IL elected. we expect to lead New
York city long step forward and up
ward, toward good government. New
York city should be leader OF the country,
as the best governed city OF the United
States, and II shall be II we are able to
make it So"
HEARST Is CHEERED.
When former Mayor Seth Low, Repub-
Iican, who was one OF the principal
speakers at the Carnegie hall meeting.
mentioned Hearst's name there YVES an
outburst of cheering.
Mr. Barnard said in part:
'"Tammany is just society for the pro-
motion of graft. They are not Demo-
Gratis. They have lived by the people. on
the people for themselves. but think the
people are going to kill it this trip. For
example. let me tell a little tale OF cast
iron pine
Three years ago. cast-iron pipe was at
IT'S highest price. $50 to $S4 per ton. Bust
ness men held off and would not buy 1t.
Every one knew that price could not
hold.
''Tammany Hin bought 1880 tons at
the top a difference IN this purchase of
just s227. 800. The pipe was laid north of
and south Of the Harlem river to the
banks for S1.O6s. 600 They never got per-
mission from the war department to con-
meet under the Harlem river. No water
has, or can run through the pipes. Il all
lies idle, losing $4,000 to $4,000 year in
terest on the investment. no service and
no income, and now II Is apparently for
gotten. You tar payers don't see IL. be-
cause Il is buried and out OF sight
Let me ask one question. Wouldn't
a business man get a permit to cross the
river before he spent the million dol
lars -
McCarren, Lying III in