davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The Stark County Democrat. [volume] (Canton, Ohio) 1833-1912, 1909-12-16

SEC Gilt Leatherette Boxes, for
gloves and handkerchiefs, only
Necessares, made of ivory rings,
ribbon, scissors. needle cases csc
Wood Burning Outfits, values in
this lot $500 to $3.50 each $3.50
$3.50 Partisan Ivory Kraftwood and
Hardwood, Brush, Comb, Mirror
and Manicure Sets, your choice
.................. SS'So
Ebonoid Shaving Stands, with mug
and brush complete, $500 value
'.'''. ''''''''' .'''' %''O9
SEQ pieces cd. Art Linens,
French and German Cluny, val
ues to S1.9S, choice ........95c
Fancy FTn'cuehins, Pillow Tops.
ribbon trimmed, values to $l.75,
80. ....'..'.... ...'''''.' see
$1.75 large all leather Carriage
Bags, metal and leather cover
ed frames .................. 94c
SOC Boxes Perfume, Atomizers, CT,
gar Jars, Puff Jars, with metal
top ..........,....... 39c
1000 regular SOC Boys and Girls
Books, special Friday ...."42c
Regular 50 Children's Desks,
solid oak, and blackboard S1.25
$3.50 Doll PerambuIators, leather
hood and leather upholstered
OBSERVATION-DISCLOSURES. $2.9s
2 - fall
Dolls, % inches long ......$3.95
$3.50 Folding oo-carts, 1910 model
with hood, rubber tires ....$a.es
Mays regular 1Sc broken Coffee,
mild and delicious, only....15e Ib
Mays 500 ooIong and Gun Powder
Tea for one day only .....29c
CSC Of Mrs, Potts Sad Irons with
stand and handle, only ..... sec
English Decorated Teapots, values
3Oc, Soc and 40c, choice ,....,25c
s29s Chatting Dishes, nickel or
copper, wrought iron stand S2.6s
$3.50 Chocolate Pots of fine china,
dainty border decoration ..$2.s9
$500 Haviland China Cottage
Dinner Sets, neat decoration.
.................. $13.98
Reading Lamps, gas or electric,
complete, values IS to $3.50,
.'''.'.'' '''.'.'''. .''''. $4,000 Po'SO
$3.50 S-inch Cut Glass Bowls, excel.
lent cutting. choice .... .$s.9s
Knives and Forks. triple silver
plated, regular $3.50, special at
...............$2.6s dox.
The Stark County Democrat. [volume] (Canton, Ohio) 1833-1912, 1909-12-16
Motion For Receiver oxerruIed.

Judge Harter has overruled the mo-
tion filed by David Messner for the
appointment of a receiver for the
Malone Oil G. Gas Co. on the grounds
that the company had not been
shown insoivent. The plaintiff was
given leave to amend his petition to
charge insolvency and a continuance
was granted till the next term Of
court
The Stark County Democrat. [volume] (Canton, Ohio) 1833-1912, 1909-12-16

COLUMBUS--Grayson H. Osborne,
defaulting teller of the Huntington
National bank, appeared in United
States court and entered a plea of
guilty to charge of embezzling $685.
600. Judge j. r. Safer sentenced Os-
borne to six and one-half years in the
federal penitentiary at Leavenworth,
Kan,
The Stark County Democrat. [volume] (Canton, Ohio) 1833-1912, 1909-12-16

Henry B. Huffman, SO, clerk, Canal
Fulton; Bertha May Essig, SO, Jack
son township.
Amos H. Cholley, %, farmer, Louis
Vile; Eva Oyster, 20, Louisville.
Clyde e. Buchtel, 81, cabinet maker,
Canton; Nevada E. Johns, 23, Green
town,
William G. Rees. 26, boiler maker,
Alliance; Bessie w. Chain, %, Alli-
ance.
The Stark County Democrat. [volume] (Canton, Ohio) 1833-1912, 1909-12-16
Prnhate court calendar.

Final account of Elizabeth Kings.
bury, guardianship filed.
Final account of Thomas c. Snyder
estate filed.
Fourth account of guardianship of
Otto Frank and others filed.
The Stark County Democrat. [volume] (Canton, Ohio) 1833-1912, 1909-12-16
w 2. rimksn Sued.

]. Henry Wheeler, a contractor,
sued William r. Timken, vice presi-
dent and treasurer of the Timken
Roller Bearing Axle company, We'd
nesday for $4,000 damages.
The Stark County Democrat. [volume] (Canton, Ohio) 1833-1912, 1909-12-16

Why not subscribe for the Morning
News7
The Stark County Democrat. [volume] (Canton, Ohio) 1833-1912, 1909-12-16
N~%N~N%N%~NA4% = :
T'VE LIVED TOO LONG,"
SAID DAVID BLOTT

Youngstown, O., Dec. vs.
(SpIO-"lve lived too long"
This was the often repeated
complaint Of Daniel Blot, 81,
farmer, who lived with his son
in Garfield township, Mahon-
ing county. He committed sui.
eide by cutting an artery in
his arm.
The Stark County Democrat. [volume] (Canton, Ohio) 1833-1912, 1909-12-16

All members Of the family read the
News.
The Stark County Democrat. [volume] (Canton, Ohio) 1833-1912, 1909-12-16

Here of tie good things in literature that
intensely interesting
be classed substantial gifts.
The Stark County Democrat. [volume] (Canton, Ohio) 1833-1912, 1909-12-16

>~>~>u~>%>~%~%%>
The Stark County Democrat. [volume] (Canton, Ohio) 1833-1912, 1909-12-16
"Cyrus Hall McCormick-His Life

o,,J xTTo-,1-,, BY Herbert N. Casson.
0AL1 IN The life of this great
man deserved to be written by such a capable
biographer-and the work fully merits reading
by every American. timely illustrated. Price,
$3.50.
New-York tribune., 1909-02-21

attention than was paid to any of the animals.
All the BOYS II town seemed to be gathered around
the hotel They would stick their heads in the door
and look at and then ScoOt away to gather IN
little crowds and talk. The town band got out
along about dark, though After that we attracted
no more attention than epic poet would get at
baseball game Even the Docs professional over
coat failed to keep people interested in us
THE wizard fixed it up with the proper authorities
that could give show IN the taIr grounds.
and early the next morning he and | hustled down
to about finding place where refined family
entertainment could be held There was building
that had been put up for the prize stock but 1t
hadn't all been taken, they let us have one end
of it. next to a stall where there spotted bull
that had all the prizes as good as won, If size was
to count for anything
We got big piece of canvas to use as partl-
ton between and the bull and by the time the
gates opened ready for business. The Doc
painted me UP to look like a wild man, and put
bushy wig me. and then | got out IN front to
make a spiel about the wonderful show we had on
the inside That will always be one OF the darkest
chapters of my life 1t was hard to imagine how
Clytie after seeing me in that makeup, could
care for me again and couldn't help thinking that
an able bodied who would get his living in
that way hadn't much right to the decent features
and white skin the good Lord had given him.
pUT l have always remembered a line that |
- learned in school, Act well your part" As long
as had to play the part thought act it we'll
could so whoOped and danced and pounded dish
pan the Doc had borrowed somewhere. And all would
have gone well, L guess, II lady who was hoping
to get the prize for the most artistic crazy quilt
hadn't come along. carrying her two-year-old baby.
1t got frightened into spasms and the wOmanS
husband who, we afterward found out. had a local
reputation as a rough and tumble fighter wanted
to whip me. The excitement he created and my
own performance seemed to keep people from want
ing to spend money TO go inside So our receipts
for the first afternoon only two dollars and
sixty cents
7ACHARIAH." said the wizard when
- opening for business the next day we must give
them something more exciting than they've had 1t
Is duty to get the money away from these
people faster than have been getting it. If
don't, many OF them will be squandering cash for
tntvpes that they'll be ashamed of in after years
for stuff to eat that might them to become pess
New-York tribune., 1909-02-21

Thered been some mention of this Serena girl
in wears back. but the first warnln he'd had OF her
comm East was the other day when she sends him
her card and address indcatin that if he still
in the stepuncle business was the time to make
good And 1t was a few words in the southwest
corner Of the vistn card that had got him curious
All it said was Interpreter of The New Thought
Maybe she's canvassin' for some magazine,
says /
Pyramid thinks that's likely to be it. and goes on
10 state how he has sent word to her that he have
to ask her to do the cain this time.
New-York tribune., 1909-02-21

lust sure exactly how they did stand, not havln
kept track Of the family since they begun moy1n
around in the West.
As near as he could remember sister had married
potatobug professor from some agrcult raj college
and the last he'd heard of them they was out IN
two or three times: but as he never got much
thanks for it he'd made up his mind to let No.
do his own hnarcin'. 50 about the only COrreSpon-
dence that passed between sister and Mr.. Gordon
was a Christmas exchange of q hfty-dollar check
for a ten-Cent New Years card.
New-York tribune., 1909-02-21

I suppose 1 shall have to help her out, says he
If she has come on from the West, probably She
broke by this time Anyway. III be glad to give
her enough to take her back
Just dote on your relations. don't YOU says
L About how old Is-that Is. how Tar does Ann
date back,
shes somewhere between twenty-five and
thirty" says he. and unmarried. taught school
for awhile You can imagine the type
One OF the mirror crackers. eh- says / With
a voice like the squeak of a dry axle and figure
C9rFras1 5r g1gg y
New-York tribune., 1909-02-21
w I z A R D

mISts Have YOU ever cF1S-lrred nov
much faIrer. brighter. and happier tnlS
world would be than -- - II people
money could always be taken away from
them lust as they were about o. Squan-
der II for stuff that the human Ever was
never made to grapple with Whenever
| succeed II InuerCept,u- a quarter on rs
way to the pie counter. l feel that L am
a benefaCtOr / shall eudeaT1r now 70 %
a little benefacting while YOU remain II
charge OF our temple 9l Art
He took ClytIe and went away, oI-
came back before long with a coupe
OF horse blankets By fastening them
70 a rope. he made a curtain. and tnen
he ordered me 70 90 ou- and tell tHe
people about " The wonderful hypnolN
performance that = about % oegn'
ladies and gents. on the inside
That seemed % take fairly well Inc
dimes came freely, and IT wash Ions
before We had crowd / was 50 ouSl
barking and handling receipt that naI
no chance To see what srCt HI a PER
formanCe the Doc was giving nuI L
must have been all right. t1- ne PeoPl5e
who passed out seemed % be 1Ied VIII
wonder. and ! noticed that some d
them came back the second time. Fol-
tune kept busy smiling ON rs -i-l ai9i'S
toward the end OF the atter- On. WL.eN
the Doc hypnotizei "A young man "--O
looked as If he had GOT hrs -~t-niIS o-
a farm and seemed - -uc mostly y
muscles. The place was as -c-- 3- peoPls,
p 4."ae= aFf e
New-York tribune., 1909-02-21

a could get II. / ndQ C-D~cI ---- --'-
gone inside to see the show
Ladies and gents" said the wizard. / am now
going to exhibit the wonderful erreI- ~ iL,-',N
matter Here YOU see before YOU splendid spec
men of physical development. / intend -t.i,e7 anu
gents TO demonstrate before Your wondering Ei-9
the superiority of the intellect over brute L'Ire
Will the heaviest man IN the audience please -'--
forward, :
After some Coaxing. man who must have He-g'td
nearly three hundred pounds pushed through -
the front and the Doc ordered The hypnot-zcI IdIl
hand to pick him up 1t seemed to be easy The
big man was raised two three feet from the 100.
and tossed over to side as # he hadn weighed
more than twenty pounds The people thought ].
was great; but the Doc told them the wonderful
part of the performance was still TO come .
You have seen how easily our friend has handled
the heavyweight he said 81 VIII now by the
mere exercise of my VIII make HIM as weak as
child Will some good friend kindly send us a.? us
hat"
lust then l noticed q who had pushed me
y women and children aside and got % the front
His face looked familiar to me. and was trying %
remember where | had seen him before when lhe
Doc whispered.
Here's that deputy sheriff with his warrant Be
ready for troube
Then he turned and asked again for a hat. The
deputy handed his over. the Doe taking u -i-
putting it down so that 1t rested on the crown
Now" he said Il VIII exhibit the tugaclouS
futility of the fundamental fuOreScence a. COM
pared with the adhesive assimilation pecu-ldr u
the nil niSi boHr. Or. as the poet SAYS
How wonderful is man He bows ms back
And moves the mighty mountain tr2" itS base
And then he steps upon carpet tack
And tears of weakness trickle down his tace-
1t will now be impossible for the subject % MI ~
common deer. lid. or as It Is commonly Ai''"-'
hat. Try it. Henry. +.-
Henry took hold of the hat and strained 0"l
couldn't raise it Il
viii YOU kindly stand aside Just little sad
the Doc to the deputy sheriff 50 that the LaOi'7
and children may See?'
The deputy pretended not to understand tliI ~
meant. and the wizard SAID II AGAIN -
4 paid nv money to get in here and that ny
hat YOU re usin" " the man with the warrant a. a.
swered as he chucked his elbow into an old Lau' =
stomach. making her gasp.
question of paying your way in or OF lending H0-'
The Washington herald. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1906-1939, 1909-11-14
By c. w. HECox,


Technical High School football coach.
It was a well-played game. Virginia
won because she was stronger in every
department than Georgetown.
So far as team work was concerned.
there was little TO choose between the
two. OF course the team work of the
winners showed up much better from a
spectacular viewpoint, owing TO their
superior strength. Virginia ezcelled
Georgetown in the personnel OF her team.
every position being filed by master.
Not only did she, like Georgetown. have
good team work, but brilliant individual
work as we'll y
In receiving punts, Virginia had a pair
OF wonders, while Georgetown was ex-
tremely weak. The onesidedness OF the
score was due to the difference between
Virginia's excellence and GeorgetOwn's
weakness in this feature OF the game
In the back field. Virginia has a trio
who work together ike clockwork. This.
coupled with their strength and speed.
made a combination which was we'll
nigh impossible 70 stop.
In the end positions. Virginia has a
fast pair. especially her left end, who
seemed TO be able to elude his opponent
without effort and get down the field IN
der punts, either to nail the runner IN
his tracks or TO recover a fumbled ball
In the line. Virginia was more agrees
sive. and was able to open up the OPP
ponents' line with apparent ease.
1t was this superiority in the line and
The Washington herald. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1906-1939, 1909-11-14
VTRGTNIA'S TEAM WORK
COULDNOT BE SMASHED
Morse, Hatchetites' Quarter Back, Gipes His
Impressions of Battle.

TO run high This is excusable In big
men, bur often on line plunges the run
ner entered the line erect, only TO be
thrown Immediately. Added 20 this there
seemed 70 be confusion In the back field.
which undoubtedly did much 20 lose
ground The fOOtwork was at times very
poor, the backs starting irregularly and
frequently interfering with the runner.
The line men played well and left their
feet on tackles. Under distinctly adverse
conditions Bowen's punting was excellent.
he having plenty OF time 20 get his kicks
or, usually boosting the ball for a good
gain.
With such warm weather. the work OF
both teams is 70 be highly commended.
In consequence. however. a great deal
more work was wasted and injuries were
greater than would have been manifested
on snappy. cold day.
Georgetowns only bid for a touchdown
was marred by the fumbltng Of subst-
tute players. which was due partly 10
overanxiety. Capt. Stuart played a
plucky game, and deserves great credit.
At no time did Georgetown show any
signs OF letting down.
Virginia won because OF better con-
dltiOn and heavier and faster men.
The Washington herald. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1906-1939, 1909-11-14

Quarter back x tho GoOrEs Washington football
tram
The most noticeable feature OF Viz
ginia's play was the display at all times
OF an excellence OF team work. The In
reference. while not fast. was compact
and blocked long enough 10 allow the
runner 20 pick his opening. on line
plunges nearly every play save one or
two Virginia men licking the runner.
and IN many instances from 4 TO yards
were added. Capt. Yancey. Stanton. and
Christian certainly make a fine combina-
ton
Yancey's plunging easily classes him
with that OF Houser. OF the Indians. and
Hodgson. Of V. p. l. Stanton Is a won
derful man on end running and open field
work. and Christians interference gave
stanton an opportunity. Many yards
might have been added II the runners had
taken chances IN skirting the side lines
instead OF hurriedly cutting In
The Georgetown back field seemed e
cut In too quickly and showed a tendency
The Washington herald. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1906-1939, 1909-11-14
RACES At BERWYN.
Interesting Card for TrOtters Mt
AutoviIIe Track.

Interesting Card for TrOtters ut
AutOviIIe Track.
Special g This Washington Herald.
Hyattsyille. Nov. 13-The crack trot-
tiers and PAGERS OF Southern Maryland
and Washington will clash at the Auto
VILE Driving Park. near Berwyn. Prince
George County. next Wednesday. and It
is expected that the events will be the
nveliest that have occurred IN this sec
ton for years.
The feature event will be a match race
between Kushan and Russell G.. two
high-class steppers. and the owner of the
winning nag will take the entire gate re-
ceipts.
The second race for a purse OF $50 will
be between Red Rock. Alma, Emorystone,
and LinkwOod May.
For the third race Bob R.. Red Bell,
Cora Virgins, TriIby. and Axis are en-
tered.
The fourth race will be fought out by
Country Boy Beecraft. Royal X, and
Miss Kushan. while the fifth race. for
colts. will be between Sallie, Helen c.,
and Autoville. A free-for-an mule race
is being arranged. Edward Daniels and
R f. Beall, jr.. OF Berwyn, are arrang-
ing the meet.
The Washington herald. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1906-1939, 1909-11-14
BY ROBERT F. HILL.

Washington en- masse turned out 20 see
the annual football battle yesterday be-
tween those two old rivals. Georgetown
and Virginia Old "grads" and young
grads" sweet young girls and calhike
young freshmen escorts. business men,
club men, professional men. every kind
OF man more or less that one finds in
this city, sat or stood around the rec
tangle where the historic match was
played
Eight thousand strong they were &C
cording to the men who took in the
tickets. This is a rough guess. based
on an incomplete counting OF the admls-
sions. II is probable that the crowd was
fully 1000 larger than that A noisy.
good-natured. yelling. cheering crowd it
was. determined that II its fire and spirit
could be transmitted to its teams. they
would be lifted so far above themselves
that they would dare, like the Titans OF
old. 10 conquer the gods themselves.
East stand Picked.
On the east stand were the adherents
OF Virginia. and on the west were the
loyal. hopeful cohorts Of old Georgetown.
The stand on the north seemed TO be
filed impartially with men from both
colleges, accompanied by many girls.
Long before the game began the
crowd had assembled in the stands and
was Willing away time as best 1t could
with the aid OF two bands and unlimited
enthusiasm. 1t was a perfect day for
cameron the spectators point OF
view. One could cheer in a loud and
boisterous fashion without becoming
overheated. and yet one could also SIT
still without feeling as II perched on the
top of the north pole.
Probably there never was game be-
tween these two rivals which brought
forth as many feminine enthusiasts as
yesterdays. over on the Virginia side
il looked, to quote one sarcastic individ-
ual. "as If somebody'd turned a semi
nary loose"
Flags orange and blue and flags blue
and gray were waved aloft like so many
wonderfully colored leaves IN an uncer-
tain wind Girls TO the last were armed
with pennants bearing either a huge
glaring V or an equally large and no less
prominent c.
VIrRinIa's Denfening Cheer.
Somebody would begin Virginia.
Virginia" and host Of pennants would
arise above the crowd much as a snow
storm begins on the stage. Mechanically,
they would wave right-left, rIght-left,
in time 20 the yell. Then would come
the stentorian ''Hoya hoya saxa; hoya
hoya, Georgetown" and from the other
side Of the field would spring, as if at a
magician's call. a mass Of blue and gray
The Washington herald. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1906-1939, 1909-11-14
DETAILS OF THE PLAY.
FIRST HALF.

;
First downs-Georgetown, p Virginia, 9.
Gained by rushing ba-Georgetown 80 yards Virginia I48
yards.
Punts-Georgetown for $40 yards, of 40 yards
EACH Virginia. for yards average of yards EACH
Penaltes-Georgetown for yards Virginia for 50 yards
Kckofs-Georgetown for e5 yards Virginia, for IS
yards.
SECOND HALF.
First downs-Georgetown, 3; Virginia, 3.
Gained by rushing ba-Georgetown, IS yards Virginia "a
yards.
PuntsGeorgetown for go yards average of 8 yards
EACH Virginia 10 for 800 yards average of yards each
Penaltes-Georgetown for 80 yards Virginia, for
yards.
Forward passes-Georgetown, for 70 yards.
Neutrality-suspicious. for las yards
The Washington herald. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1906-1939, 1909-11-14
GAME IN DETAIL.

Capt Stuart lost the toss and elected
10 defend the south goal. At exactly
2.40 O'Clock Capt. Yancey kicked OF to
Vlyman, who ran back 10 yards before
he was tackled. Carrigan gained yards
through Ceyer, and on a delayed pass
Vlynan advanced the ball a yard and a
half between Harris and Cecil Wymard
punted TO Gooch, who fumbIed. but
Stanton saved the ball for Virginia. vir-
ginia was penalized 5 yards for off-side.
on fake kick. Stanton fumbled. and
Bowen punted TO Carrigan, who was
nailed in his tracks McNulty slipped
outside Cecil for 4 yards. Virginia was
again penalized for off-side. McNulty
failed to gain at Elliot's end. but Vlyman
was good for 4 yards through Geyer
placing the ball on Georgetown's 45-yard
line Wymard punted to Stanton, who
ran back u yards.
Virginia started right here to rip up
Georgetown's line. On a delayed pass
Continued on Page 2, Column l.
The Washington herald. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1906-1939, 1909-11-14
FOOTBALL RESULTS YESTERDAY

At washinZton-GoorgstoWn o. University Of Viz
GINA Il
Yale. II: Princeton. O.
Harvard, Z: Dartmouth.
Pennsylvania, s: Michigan, -
Cornell. 6; Chicago. s.
Harvard FrCshrnen. u Yale Freshmen, q
FOrdham. 80. Rensselaer, PO,ytechnic, G.
Williams. y; Amherst, O
Dickinson, 8: Buclieil g.
At Annapolis-St- Johns CoIlere 90. Mount 81
Joseph College. O.
At Annapolis-Navy. l.: Western Reserve. G.
Az Lansing. Mica.-Michigan Agricultural College
); Marquette O.
At syracuse-Colgate. G: Syracuse s
At Brunswick. Me--BOWdoin. 2: University q
Maine O.
At Brooklyn-ErsSnus Hal. II: Bows High. s.
At Bedford. Mass.-Tufts Is: Bates Z
Carlisle, IS; Gettysburg. 0.
Trinity. y: Wesleyan. O
A. Madison-Minnesota- 81: Wisconsin. 4
A. Evanstoa-Illinois. So Northwestern. O
At Columbia-MissOuri. q Drake. 6.
The Washington herald. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1906-1939, 1909-11-14

Coach Hecox of Tech Praises Winners BackfieId
and Ends.

IN the back field which made Il possible
for Virginia 10 carry the ball success
fully by straight football. while for the
same reason Georgetown was compelled
TO rely almost entirely upon onside kicks,
double delayed. and forward passes. AL
OF which were we'll handled.
The Washington herald. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1906-1939, 1909-11-14
ST. Johns, SO; Mount ST. Josepb,s. q

st. Johns, 6Sj Mount ST. JOseph's, o.
Special to The Washington Herald.
Annapolis, Nd, Nov. lS.-The football
team Of Mount st. Joseph's College. Bal
timore. proved an easy foe for the fast
St Johns College aggregation here to-
day. the locals piling up the large score
OF 50 TO o. To-day's game was not a
regular one on the st. Johns schedule.
but the visitors consented to come to
Annapolis and Ill the date caused by the
cancellation Of the annual st. Johns
Maryland Agricultural College game on
account OF scarlet fever at the latter in
stitution.
The Washington herald. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1906-1939, 1909-11-14
OLD YALE SWEEPS
TIGERS OFF MAP
Princeton Battered to Pieces
by 17-tO-O Score.
TED" COY is THE STAR
New Jersey Team Never Have
LOOk-in.
TED" COY is THE STAR

Wonderful Full Back Proves I'm
pOrtant Factor in ElPS victory.
Cunningham Only Once Within.
Striking Distance 10 Try Drop.
Kick e PrincetOn's Punts Blocked.
and Touchdown and Safety Result.
The Washington herald. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1906-1939, 1909-11-14

Continued on Page p Column 4