Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1909-04-03

oustrlal aysttm FOR ~ years. he said
Before the passage OF the Dlngley
Dill tho tanning business OF this coun-
try was IN healthy condition. but
since the imposition Of the duty the in-
dependent tanners. who were dependent
on the home trade. have become die
cnururud ana many of them have Him-
ply hocomo workmon Tor the monopoly
which The duty created"
Tie opposed the reduction of the duty
ON solo and boiling leather from 20 per
cent Co 3 pet cent
1T ls humiliatnE 90 hear a cry COINS
ina MO from the south FOR protection
on some nrticlce. especially sugar and
hIdct because they happen tn hC Irn.
ducCd 30 that section" said Mr spirht
of MIfslrslppl. 'IG' he argued. "the
bin would put shoes on the FREQ llsi ne
hamera would not De so glaringiy in-
consistent"
AR splght dii not agree with those
opposins The reduction off the duty on
] lumber gnd Doe wanted bagging and ties
put 0n the free HIST
The h.n, in tho opinion of Mr Bow-
| ems Of NlHsissippl did not honestly rep
resent the Republican pledges Hc said
oprtoiu favored Interests had been cared
tor while Che neCuHs0rIeS nf Nfp had
| been taxed ont OF proportion
Ma. kHnsdell of Louisiana pleaded fHr
1 q duty of 5h cents % pound ON cotton
importatione, deprecated the free entry
| oi Philippine sugar and defended The
| policy of Clifford piurhot OBJ regard tl
! conservation Of the forests
CAN'T DEILVEE GOODS.
Maintaining that Do was % protco-
/ ZIONIST, even Co the point OF ths stand.
| patter MT Langley OF Kentucky de-
/ clarod ne was still unconvinced that am
| OF The provisions of The Payne bin were
/ IN FUN accord with the doctrines of thc
| Republican party. They have failed
/ 10 convince Doc said. shat the pro-
| posed reduction Of the duty ON lumber
! is in accordance with those doctrines.
| he asserted Chairman Payne would bc
unable "to deliver the goods" THAT
I the reduction I'm the lumber schedule
! would Increase the wages of lHboriuc
/ men, Mr. Langley denied
ABUSE OF TAXING POWER.
The Republican party" said Mr..
| clayton of Alabama, "has debouched the
! manufacturers OF the country hy holding
! out % them by proHchment and by poli-
cy, that the government has Tho right
! to abuse the taxing power so as t1 hand
/ out special faNors 20 them The vov-
| eminent he declared had mo- right 90
| tax. except 90 raise revenue
The Payne bill charged MI clayton.
was sectional I'm that 81 gave TO New
England free hides. coal and lumber.
He argued that. while such fayors were
| being handed out, iute hagsug. cotton
ties and kaiuit. the German fertilizer.
should be restored 20 tho free list m
order that the bagElng trust may not
have the benefit OF e. tairff ON iute. The
grain farmer OF the west he said. had
his binding Irvine free boy Republican
| legislation and there was no reason
why jute baggng ana cotton ties
should not be free.
Mr.. Clayton maintained that the pres
cnt condition OF the country grew out
OF vicious Republican legislation and
that the Payne bin was O. false pre-
tense offered by the Republicans To- re-
doom their promises for substantial
tariff revision"
Mr. Clayton charged that distin-
guished senator from Rhode Island,
"a state 90 small that We Democrats
I'm Alabama, who chew tobacco. can
spit across II, and who dominates
tho whole Republican party, Is I'm Sc
cret conClave with q select few. and
is making a trn bill which an Re
publicans viii swallow
The chairman, MIR. Currier Of New
Hampshire, admonished Mr. Clayton
not 10 violate the rule about referring
20 the other branch Of Congress
Mr. Clayton insisted De had kept
within the rule, and continuing. said
that Senators Elkins and Scott. as well
as Democrats, had been excluded from
the finance committee room.
is IL not a fact interjccted Mr..
I Burke Of Pennsylvania. that while Re-
publican members OF the committee are
conducting their Investigation. the ME
| nority members OF that same commit
tee are pursuing the same course on The
same linos?'
81 hope they are. On self-defonse
was Mr.. Claytou's response, accompa-
| MED by Democratic applause He
I said that ~ when a lot OF Rcpubli-
cans get together iu some conspiracy
against tho welfare of tho people 10 he
hOoves the Democrats 10 get together
| themselves. anywhere. az any time
Pursuing his inquiries. Mr. Burke
asked II Mr.. Clayton was charging that
such a conspiracy was being enacted
THAT rs my deliberate Judgment.
against the welfare of the people of
| the United States answered the
Alabama member.
Mr clayton declared he was not go
| ing 10 open up o. school ~ ethics, Tie
said that IL always happened that
| hit dog howled.
Whenever YOU tank about the abuses
| OF the Republican PARTY" he said,
| land bring the country face Co face
| with a realizing sense OF what the
| machinery OF your party is doing To
| tho people. the iniquity that Il has
I heaped upon them and what n pro-
poses 10 DO. YOU get mp and howl. and
| suggest questions OF ethics that are
/ wholly unethicaL'
WHY DOES He HOWL?
els that the reason the gentleman
/ from Alabama is bowling queHed
/ MI Madden, I'D
Mr. Clayton pictured Nh. Payne
/ coming DOB Monday with the backing
/ of the rules committee and making
! ready to pat the bin through
/ 90 suppose ho added. "nr Cane
/ non viii stand by the bedside and De-
| viii say privately something to the
| rank and hle of his party who want
/ committee pretermeut next December,
/ a power we tried 90 take from him,
/ ana . wish we had taken % away ami
/ ~ 500 had done $50 we would have your
| Republican party boo state of be
/ tWCenity'
/ Mr. clayton referred % the Iowa
/ idea and was interrupted by Mr. Ken
] BAN Of Iowa with the remark that
/ there was "no idea in loWH that did
not indorso protection
This lcd to uu exciting ooN'Quy iu
/ which AIR. clayton referred Mr. kou-
| Dahl 90 Senator Cumwins
Nh clayton sgid hc had boon told
| thut Senator Cummius has mado The
statement 'fhat same tariff had robbed