New-York tribune., 1909-06-10
WOOL DUTIES NOT CUT
DOLLITER TRIES IN TAIN.
Tao "Maurgents" Join the AIdrich
Forces on T0tes in Senate.
From The Tribune Bureau. ]

Washington. June 9-Senator Delivers repeated
efforts reduce the duties in the wool schedule
proved unavaing to-day. On every rollcan the
Finance Committee had a ma jority ranging from
ten to thirteen Early in the debate the Iowa
Senator made frequent references TO agreement
entered into I'm lS61 between the shepherds and the
weayers To work in harmony for duties on wool
and woolens. Whether the alleged agreement of
more than forty years ago actual or mythical,
The rocalls to-day revealed that in the application
Of the protective policy toward Schedule h the
Senators from the wooen manufacturing states of
the East and of the wool growing states of the
West are in perfect accord. Mr.. Aldrich held his
forces in line every vote and two Senators who
d rule cast their lot with the insurgents
Joined him. They were Messrs Gamble and Craw-
ford, of South Dakota
The votes on the wool schedule were taken be
tween speeches made by Senators Warren and La
Toilette Mr Warren spoke length in the early
part Of the day in support of the schedule. Late
IN the afternoon Mr. La Toilette took the floor
and began d general attack on the citadel OF pro-
lection" After speaking for more than an hour
he surrendered the floor temporarily. and resumed
his speech at the night session.
In the interval between the speeches of Senators
Warren and La Toilette, short speeches were made
by Senator Dolliver in support of his amendments
all Of which were voted down.
The first rollcau the Finance Committees
amendment TO restore the DingIey of 80 cents
a pound wool ton wastes and other wastes. The
House separated these wastes and fixed the duties
al
amendment was adopted 20 to 30. Senators Brown
Beveridge. Rurkett. Rristow Clapp. Cummins
DoIliver La Toilette and Nelson voted in the mega
tive.
The second roIlcall was on Mr. Delivers amend
1nent TO restore the House rates on shoddy, noils
wool extract. yarn waste. thread waste, etc. This
was defeated, - to 81. Nine Republicans voted for
the Dolliver amendment and Senator McEnery, a
Democrat voted against it. Mr. Doiver made \
short argument against the amendment restoring
the DinRley rate OF 10 pound woollen
rags mungo and focks but did not ask for roll
call and the amendment adopted. The House
reduced this duty TO SIX cents a pound
Mr.. Delivers fourth unsuccessful effort TO amend
this schedule made when Paragraph 2i2 was
reached His amendment to reduce the rate on
wool tops was defeated y to y Again Mr.. Nc
Emery voted with the majority. nine Republicans
voting for the DoIIiver amendment vote was
about be taken Mr.. Delivers substitute for
Paragraph 313, providing for the assessment II
duties the wool contents Of yarr
instead Of the weight OF the yarn, when Mr..
Ia Toilette interrupted the proceedings and began
his long speech.
Mr Warren's speech was comprehensive review
Of the wool industry and relation the protec
tive tariff. He declared that the duties recon-
mended by the Finance Committee were absolutely
necessary TO protect the wool of the West,
maintaining the prosperity OF the growers
dependent upon the prosperity Of the woollen manI-
country, which Mr. " = said he suspected was
largely organized the plan OF Colonel Sellers
as he had heard nothing OF II until the senator
from Iowa had called his attention 10 IT.
Ia TOILETTE ATTACKS SCHEDULE.
~ - -, - 49, - -,
= - 80" -, - -, -, -
- -, -,, -. -, - -,
-. - -, - -. -. -,
- a. -, -, -, - - -.
-
--e "uS'' anu 'il>'' 9eu ma ~ e" was "e'.s
aue ' - Gus ''e "OO, u. NE S'''e 80
5..- S--9 p ,--.,,l,. -.ls-. ., m, I,l4-,-t,
on 'o-'' ~ M, ,I 10 10, -" ~ 'I9 -
"a So 49,, a.. ,'t.z.5
flr7 gt+5ciar, +tre -, ,fs .'fsf.+s rIa ,,,,a,
~
81" 1-a' M 7'',,'l '''l'- WY me u1'' %" a''S
0'.e' q. 'SS ian o. 'e"'' a i'u'n was 40 PEI
IN w !'s uu'\ Oh <a'.'s '%,"eu al over o.
e, po--G " - r l'.,i X" ma
- -. ~ g. - -, - -
- al Ii'H III 7ii'', "''N ~ S',SNfi ule "ise'"-
Si senator DGl sae' 'i'lle Nj "a I"i'e''e inter
ap''H iit fAl4aiali"i many MI Snlo"t Tfi"i'
fa WIN lmpaueHc' 'Aal ne was trying 'e answer
f'ioeius ''e senator lIoiH WISCONSIN uoe9i
" an d" a"s"ti' ne ADDED
NJ -" F'e''e '-piivH lI'' re wanted an answer
"'' u'N" Nai-' i'ipe Ni7ail. ne SAID 'I'e 'eie-
= IN 'e' -, - nam W. S'hi''H pH owners "I
| ~ az" Ga -, ~. ''" iea' a'ihr
why '''' i''" 'i''' 'aiieS s"EseS'e" MI " ar
heCarse' Iel'I'eu MI. Ia oiielle' 'hey nave
The senator rom yyiscors ts r,rn.n, ,s,
faofiro t.4sf.ses revlia5 vl,