The Montgomery advertiser., 1909-11-13
SILVER DOLLAR SALOON CASE
Fsrii6cations of the State Prohibi
 ton Laws Become FImer.
szriel Brethern, of Montgomery, Are Given m opportunity to Prove Ownership of Property Found
 in the Place in Question z The Opinion.

Concurring,. in the essential. with the opinion rendered last week by Judge w. H. Thomas in the Kahn and Alexander liquor cases. chanceiloraL ID Gardner, of the Southeastern Charicery Division. Friday issued decree in the Silver Dollar saloon case upholding the injunction feature of the weakiey- Fuller prohibition law and refusing to quashs the writs of seizure by which the goods which were taken from the raided place are held.
 To Griel Brothers and B. s. Griel. however. he granted opportunity to prove alleged ownership of property In the saloon.
 The opinion of the chancellor in up- holding the writes of seizure and the injunction feature is thought to es- tabiish the last Qualification against violation of the prohibition laws. Seizure of. property and termination by judicial construction of the laws.
 The decree of the Chancellor is:
 This case was submitted at the last term of this court upon motion of complainant to disallow and dismiss the petition of Griel Brothers Com pany and B. S.. Griel and the demur- rers of complaint to said petitions, and upon motion of respondents to quash the writ of seizure heretofore Issued in this cause and their motion to dissolve the temporary writ of in Junction heretofore issued in this cause. and upon motion of respond ents for replevy of personal property seized upon execution of forthcoming bond. and same was held for consid- eration and decree.
 Upon consideration of the petition of Grief Brothers Company and B. s. Griel as to their alleged ownership of certain property now in custody of the court under the writ of seizure, the court is of the opinion the said petitions are sufficient, and that therefore the motion of the State to disallow and dismiss the same and the demurrers of the State to said peti- tions. should be overruled and denied
 Tt is therefore ordered. adjudged and decreed that the motion of the complainant to dismiss and dfsallow the petition of Greil Brothers Com pany and B. S. GreiL be and the same is hereby overruied and denied.
 Tt is further ordered. adjudged and decreed that the demurrers of com plainant to the petitions of Greil Brothers Company and B. s. Greil be and the same are hereby overruled.
 Tt Is further ordered that the com pAdAudltl AiOy diAS cdAu pCtANhun6 III thirty days from the enrolment of this decree.
 Upon consideration of the demur- rers of respondents to the bill of conn pIaint as amended the court Is of the opinion the demurrers xare not well taken. It is therefore ordered, ad- judged and decreed that the demur- rers of defendants to the bill as amended be and the same are hereby overruled.
 'rhe court Is further of the opinion that the motion of respondents to quash the writ of seizure heretofore issued in this cause and the motion of said respondents to dissolve the in- junction heretofore issued in this cause and their said motion for exe- eution of forthcoming bond are moi well taken.
 'Tt is therefore ordered. adjudged and decreed that the motion of re- epondents to dissolve the temporary Injunction heretofore issued in this cause, and the motion of the respond. ent to quash the writ of seizure here.