The Newark star and Newark advertiser. [volume] (Newark, N.J.) 1909-1909, 1909-11-22
SHOENTHAL GUEST
OF FRIENDS At
LARGE BANQUET
New Surrogate HOnored at DIM
ner in East Orange on
Taking Office.

Men prominent in affairs of Essex
county enjoyed a dinner given satur-
day night in honor of Surrogate-elect
Isaac Shoenthal at English's, East Or
ange The banquet was a non-partlsan
affair, n during the evening, in al
dition to an excellent menu, the diners
listened to e~ulogistic speeches.
Major Shoenthal was given an ova-
ton when he arose to voice his APP
probation, and told his auditors of his
gratitude for the splendid vote given
him by citizens. irrespective of poitl-
cal or other Affiliations or November 2.
The affair was a success, and the men
who attended the function gave the
several speakers warm applause.
Mayor Arthur b. Seymour, successor
Of the former executive of Orange, was
toastmaster. Owing to the illness OF one
of his daughters, Judge Thomas A.
Davis was unable to be present. He
was a member of the committee in
charge OF the function and was to
have given a talk on 1.-THE judiciary
and the Surrogate" In his stead. Sem
ator Harry v. Osborne consented to
respond to the topic and made an ex-
cellent %impromptu address.
Lieutenant Martin Conboy. Of East
Orange, spoke on 1.-THE Military Man
in Public Life" Tax Collector Frank
A. O'Connor, of West Orange, made a
speech which was applauded. Several
other speakers made informal al
dresses, among them Un~dersherlH
Charles Reilly, City Counsel William
A. Lord. Frank P. Mylod anf Absalom
P. Bacilman. John A. Rush spoke for
1.-THE Press
Patrick Aloysius Smith, councilman
elect of the First Ward. Orange, sang
several songs. When the name of john
C. Fineran was mentioned by one or
the speakers as deputy surrogate ne
was roundly cheered.
The gathering included representative
men from all walks in life. There were
many Newark folk in the group and
Others from different sections of Essex
County. Professor Albert Benzler gave
musical selections.
Among those at the affair were;
N. j. Burton, Thomas F. Brennan,
John J. Bolan, David Abrams, F. L.
Baldwin; Frank y. Boettner. j. A..
Birkholz, Michael Barry, A. F. Burt,
Robert Baxter. Charles w. Brown.
Chief James Bell, Harlan w. Brush,
John j.. Bracken, Valentine Braun,
Michael Blessington, James A. Clark,
Thomas M. Cusack, Oar Coleman,
Owen Casey, P. J. Clossick. w. A. Cal
houn, Daniel Coleman, jr.. Daniel A.
Dugan, J. l.. Davis, J. l., Davis, jr..
Charles II. Davis Joseph Di Beneditto.
Charles Fl. Ely, Laurence T. Fell.
George Flynn, Bernard Ford, Eugene
w. Farrell, Joseph FREDERICK, ]. c. Fin
eran, Harry Friend, Henry A. Guenther,
A. o. Howe, R. A. Hamilton, l.. b. NJ.
Haag, W. F. Hamilton, Thomas P. Hig-
gins. James F. Hyland. Charles Ippo-
Ito. Frank H. Jamison, Andrew Kelly,
Eugene A. Kelly. James P. Kelly, S.
J. K1auber. DR.. d. A. Kraker, John t.
Kelly. John W. Lane, Charles A. lie
Master, Michael Loprete, DR.. FREDERICK
Iuongo. James p. Mylod. Frank A.
Maloney. DR.. S. A. Muta, James Ma
guire, NJ. J. Murray. Joseph McDon-
ough. Joseph Mccarthy, Martin Nc
Quinn, John r. Otterbein, Alfred F.
Osborn, Cornelius O'Donoughue, Colonel
George P. Olcott, d. L. Pierson, Walter
Patteu, Moses Reichman, P. Regain,
Lafayette S~hoenthal, George E. Spottis-
woode, F. C. Sham. Captain Charles G.
Squier, S. J.. Shaw. Stephen Stetson,
John Seymour, William H. Simpson, P.
r. Timpson, Richard L. Tobin, James
Underwood, William Underwood,
George Underwood, Peter Underwood,
Arthur Virian, Jacob Weber, A. Grant
Channel, Joseph Heisler, f. Edwin FL
we'll, George w. Foster, Thomas Kear-
ney, John r. Monahan. Joseph d. Mo-
riarty, Councilman r. T.. Murray, Law
renee McCabe, G. A. lie Boeuf, Frank
p. Shalvoy. James Sullivan. Samuel
Waldron and Frank Y. Walsh.