The Sentinel=record., 1909-10-19
'DENoUNcEs 5ANNARD AS A WooDRuFFIAN; oAYNoR AS
 A TAMMANY FOLLOWER.
If Barnard Is Elected the Trusts Rule the City; If Gaynor, the Thieves,
 Is Hearts Idea as Ex.
 pressed Last Niefit.

New fork, Oct f3.--Wllliam k. Hearst, independent nominee for may. or of New York, and Otto T Barnard, the Republican nominee, both of whom are heading the fusion ticket. motored through Harlem tonight and delivered series of rapid fire speech es in support of their candidacy
 Hearst spoke at four places and Barnard spoke thrice.
 As has been his wont, Barnard con- fined himself briefly 10 business Is. sues. Hearst spoke at length and con tinued his denunciation of w. ] Gay- nor. the Democratic nominee, although he found time prefer to Barnard as machine candidate.
 "I have got into this fight to defeat both Gaynor and his Tammany ma chine and Barnard and his Woodruff machine" he said And I do not want MT. Barnard to forget, in the heat and excitement of the campaign that he is just as much of a machine candidate as Judge Gaynor is. He may not be the candidate of the same kind of machine. and 1, for one, cannot see the difference in black. ness between the Tammany kettle and the Woodruff pot
 MT Barnard was not nominated at the fusion conference. The fusion conference was broken up. He was not even nominated at the Repubi- can convention. That had not yet been held He was appointed and annointed the candidate of the Noble Order of Wpodruffians and created a Knight of the Checkered Waistcoat al Jacks, in the early hours of September morning.
 Now, Mir. Barnard is a candidate, but he Is not an anti-Tammany can. didate. If Mir. Parsons statement of the deal between Cannon and the Re publican machine, with Murphy and the Tammany machine, can be be. aeved, Mir Barnard was nominated not to defeat Tammany but to elect Tammany. If Mir. Barnard is elected MT. Woodruf's pet trusts will get the city and if Judge Gaynor is elected he Tammany pet thieves VIII gec tie city
 In the rest of his speeches MT. Hearst defended himself against the thrust by ex-Judge Gaynor that he was endorsed by Tammany when he ran for governor against Hughes.
 Grover Cleveland, he said, "was Va consistent foe Of Tammany Hall. yet he ran for governor of the state on a Democratic ticket. I ran for governor of New York state as mucn foe of Tammany Hall as had run for mayor foe of Tammany Hall the year before"
 He declared that although nominat ed by the Democrats he fought Chas F. Murphy throughout and at no time surrendered to Tammany.
 Why didn't Judge Gaynor fo as I did?" he continued.
 Why didn't Gaynol denounce Mur phy and McCarren2 He had plenty os time to do it before McCarren got sick"
 Hearsts attack of Barnard tonight gives the fight new angle, for here bofcre both have maintained what might be called truce in view of the fact that both are attempting to de- feat Tammany Barnard has at afl times refrained from crlticising Hearst. Ill his speeches tonight the Republican nominee said in part.
 T am candidate for mayor be cause good many people think the city hall needs d business man. I am 3 business man of ten years legal training and some knowledge of how city bonds should be sold. The issue is Tamnany graft and waste"
 MT Barnard expressed keen regret tonight when shown dispatch from Albany that Governor Hughes wousd take no part in the campaign here.
 " Ii is matter of very great regret to me that tho governor does moi care