The sun., 1909-06-19
ph,,ade,phia, q; Detroit. !.
Washington, 3; st. Louis, o
CLEVELAND. lo:NEw YORK u.L)A

Five runs in the eighth innin9 clinched
yesterdays ball game for the Clevelands.
The New Yorks had a fighting chance to
win it up to that time. and were making the
most of that chance. but decision by
Oloughlin in the eighth. a decision that
had an important bearing on the situatio n,
caused Kid Elberfeld to storm and be put
out Of the game. The result was the inf1eld
"a. broken up by substitutions. the New
York team went up In the air and the Maps
let ty with volley OF hits. mostly to left
field, that brought them to the plate with a
prolonged rush. '...
OIoughlin, who was umpiring on the
bases, got the wrong foe us on the play en-
tirely when he called Ball safe at third in
the eighth. The decision was palpably
aud manifes;ly wrong. There was abso-
luey no doubt that Elberfeld touched Bali
with the ball before the latter got from
second bsse to third base and that Ball was
out. Maybe players werein o O'Loushiln'sl slime
of vision, but even then Ball was not so
close to the bag that the play SO much as
looked close One seldom sees such a
laundering decision by an experienced UNI
pre. s-,.
The score wus S TO 4 in favor of the Cleye e.
lands when Ball led of in the eighth inning.
He plant ed his second two bagger in left
aud ran for third when Easterly sacrificed
toward Chase. Chase pounced on the ball
and sailed 1t over to Elberfeld. 1t was q
low throw, but the Kid stopped it and had
Ball blocked sauarely of the bag when the
latter slid The ball was on the ground
right underneath the players andElberfeld d
picked il up instantly and touched Ball
with it. Then Bali scrambled TO the bag
and o'Loughlin motioned him safe.
Elberfeid had made a splendid play in
getting Ball and be was in no benign mood
up oe" to The Umpire and emphasized his re-
ss Tss oab wss fs q SonS Hasn
went to third base and Vaughn to short
and the Cleyelands unloaded seven hits
before the turbulent inning came to close
one out had the correct decision been made
instead Of one on third and one. on first and
6sf Stna bee she sed asa
not the affair had no inspiritins efsc. on !hs the
New and h fs5scs sssn wS RS, wheS
more f.reiesl than Q oIoushiins decision.
In the fourth inning O'Longhlin had
sd ,1s Tg1ne back sfs Of 'fsd1s trd sbase sd sG
BE- overslid the bag and was toucned by
EIh.rfeld before he could get back. That
qns made eT ne. q one he
Ssrin en '1'Hf IN h. Fourth inning. Win Chase
On third Epsls a. bsi and NOBODY Sy.9ad Gut two SD
Engle Along essne. another ball which
swep, foot outside the plate. Eng,e starting
for St EHi M,E 70 and ,ab SeSoa ksJn nssies essd
reduced considerably: Ga.
pop bottle was heaysd cay # 3LHnsh,,D
spd crowd gathered around him after
The game as he went. 70 his dressing room,
4 missile that looked IKE 2 piece q ,I paper gs1
remsrks. 4 body guard escorted Silk TO
tie dressing roon, and st stood sensry ,an unit,
Those Cleveands ran on the field as u
they thought they really earned the gsme.
did their first scoring In the fourth inning
Brocket!'s ,wdness hepled them. lie
rasied Brsdsy and tnsn Turned ,b;,d Soss
hill The fyy was 80 deep ,n ,hss Tuner ibirG
%fas tsfSnd vefscn Ha IT, HhshmsN ne ssOe w.Rsi
advanced on Balls ont and he and Turner
'Ged S.w seE shs sS to sos ps in
ri,ch let Eiberfeld come IN and Chase go g
lhird. Chase was left there on Ens!e
:. EseasD sss and ers S 10 s VIII i,se ises
out in the fifth and two on Brockett pur.
roseR passed l,aJolc ana conneo 9 ninCHphn
INTO raising fiy 10 Engle. The New Norks
,,nade run on two ba ssers by hietnow ana
HenptHl, -
Each side tailed twice in the sixth, the
Lleyelands on hits by Ball and Easterfy,
roller from Goode For New York Chase
SINGLED and rode home on triple by Engle
IN the right field fence. Engle came IN on
an ont Cotton Tnrner' made a supern
stop Of Laporte burning grounder and for
an encore Yet an easy dribble from Kleinow
roll through his legs. kleinow Was out
get 10 first base. Subsequent events were
100 much for our harried hiiltoppers, The