The Salt Lake herald-Republican. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1909-1918, 1909-10-19
Abuses the Republican Candi-
date for Mayor of New York
as Well as Tammany's Man,
While Delivering Speeches.
BUSINESS ISSUES THE
THEME OF Mr.. BARNARD
William M. WINS Replies to the
Charges Made by Henry
George Jrr and Colonel
AmOy-GaynOr Speaks,
CAMPAIGN AT FEVER HEAT

New York. oct. 1S.-William r. Hearst,
independent nominee for mayor, and Otto
r. Barnard, Republican nominee, both of
whom a~e heading the fusion ticket,
dashed through Harlem tonight ana de-
livered a series of raj id fire speeches. IN
support of their candidacy. Hearst made
four addresses and Barnard three.
Barnard confined himself to business
issues. Hearst spoke at length ana con-
tinued his denunCi1uOn OF william Gay
nor. Democratic nominee. although ne,
for the first time. referred to Barnard
as a machine candidate.
Il have got into this fight to defeat
both GaynOr and MS Tammany machine
and Barnard and his Woodruff machine,
he said, land do not want Mr., Barnard
TO forget in the heat ana excitement OF
the campaign that he is just as mucn
a machine candidate as Judge Gaynor.
He may not be the candidate of the same
machine, but he is the candidate OF the
same kind of a machine. and l for one
cannot see the difference in the blackness
between the Tdmmany kettle and the
Woodruff pot
Nomination of Barnard.
Mr.. Barnard was not named at the
fusion conference. The fusion conference;
was broken up. He was not even named
at the Republican convention. That had
not yet been held. He was appointed ana
anointed the candidate OF the Noble Or
der of WOOdTuffianS and created a knight
of the Waistcoat at Jacks in the early
hour Of q September morning.
Now, Mr.. Barnard s not only not an
independent candidate, but he is not even
an anti-Tammauy candidate. If Mr.. Par
sons statement of the deal between Can
non and the Republican machine with
Murphy and the Tammany machine can
be believed, Mr. Barnard vas named, not
10 defeat TammanY, but to elect Tam
many. If Mr.. Barnard is elected. Mr..
WOodruffs pet trusts will get the city,
and if Judge Gaynor is elected, the Tam
many pet thieves Will get the city
The Tammany Endorsement.
Hearst defended himself against Gay
nor's remark that he was Endorsed by
Tammany when ne ran for governor
against Hughes.
Grover Cleveland" he said, was a
consistent foe of Tammany Hall, yet he
ran for governor CT the state on a Demo-
cratic ticket l ran for governor of New
York as much a foe of Tammany Hall
as i had run for mayor foe Of Tam-nany
Hall the year before
why did not Judge Gaynor do as
did? Why did not Judge GaynOr denOUnce
Murphy and MCCarren? He had plenty
Of time to do it before McCarren got
sick"
Hearsts attack on Barnard tonight
gives the campaign a new angle, for here
tofOre both have maintained what might
be called a truce in view of the fact
that both are attempting to defeat Tam
many,
MIR. Rannard's Speeches.
Barnard in his speeches tonight said in
part:
I am a candidate for mayor because
a good many people think the city hall
eds a businessman | am q business
man with ten years of legal training and
some knowledge of how city bonds should
be sold. The issue is Tammany and graft
and waste
William NJ. WINS. who, although not a
candidate himself. has laid the ground
work for a major part of the personal
attacks in the campaign, kept his place
well in the calcium of charge and counter
charge during the day. Accused last
night by Henry George, jr., of trying to
persuade his father to withdraw from
the maYOralty campaign of 1886 in con-
sideratiOn of a seat in congress offered
by Tammany, he faced yet another charge
made by Colonel William y. AmOry. for
meT secretary of the Third Avenue Rail-
way company, AmOTy, in an affidavit
attacked MIN as representing Thomas F.
RYAN in blocking Investigations in New
York He declared that Twins was paid
S-GO00 by the commission FOR shielding
Ryan in the public service investiga-
TONS
I am convinced" he said, that Mr..
WINS at that time had an understanding
with Ryan or his representative for the
deliberate suppression of the facts"
In reply WINS issued a statement to-
night in which he says:
Il am sorry for him Colonel Amory).
Tor he could not take such an oath il
De were really responsible. As a matter
of fact. ! have not seen Mr.. Ryan or
any of his associates for months except
as l have met his counsel in court as
my adversary"
Gaynor spoke toby with personal lib
eTty.' Hearst and police misrule as his
principal topic.