The star. (Reynoldsville, Pa.) 1892-1946, 1908-01-01

iV biiCItOlo VI tut
Metropolitan Company have come to
recognize that the loss of fares due
to dishonesty of conductors and their
failure to collect Is the most impor-
tant factor with which they have to
deal in reorganizing the surface rail-
ways of Manhattan and the Bronx.
This realization has come to them
as result of investigations that
have been going on for months of
the extent of the pilfering among the
men, and it is one of the reasons why
the traction managers look with par
ticular interest to the coming trials
of the Montreal or pay-as-you-enter
car, on the Madison avenue line, for
this car is supposed to make dishon-
esty on the part of conductors as
near an impossibility as anything can
be when mere mechanical device is
pitted against human ingenuity.
Several months ago there was
case In the divorce courts here which
opened the eyes of good many of
the gh-Metropolitan direc-
tors who had not previously looked
into this phase of the situation. The
wife of New York City Railway
conductor was suing for alimony, and
in her bill alleged that, although her
husbands salary from the company
was but SIS week, he ought to pay
alimony on a $50 a week basis, as
he knocked down" $35 week on
the side. There was a disposition to
believe at first that this was an exag-
geration, but subsequent results have
contradicted such conclusion.
Loss More Than Ten Per Cent.
The official estimate is that the
New York City Railway Company.
under the conditions that prevail at
present, loses more than ten per cent.
of its gross income by reason of the
loss of fares through dishonesty and
failures to collect. For the fiscal
year ended June 80. 1906-the latest
for which figures have been issued
in detail-the gross earnings Of the
New York City Railway were SAL
9S7,943, its operating expenses $12,-
624.7S2, and its deficit, after paying
charges including the rental of seven
per cent. on the stock of the Metro
politan Street Railway, was s2,212,-
997.
1t has been testified in the inves-
tigation of traffic conditions by the
Public Service Commission that the
deficit was over $3,00O,000 in the
fiscal year ended June 80. 1907, after
the company had paid its rental of
S3,629,00O. Inasmuch as the loss in
surplus-all charges having been
paid out of the fares actually re-
ceived by the road-the ten per cent.
of gross receipts which the New York
City Railway did not get contributed
upward of $2,000,000 Of the aggre-
gate deficit. In other words, had 1t
been received the New York City
Railway would have earned upward
of four per cent. on the stock of the
Metropolitan Street Railway Com
pany on the basis of the official esti-
mate.
Applied to the financial condition
OF the holding company, the Inter-
borough metropolitan, this lost s2,-
100000 or more of money would
have produced an even more interest
ing result. The Interborough-M Metro
politan, according to its report for
the fiscal year ended March 81 last,
showed deficit of s1,347,4S9 after
payment Of the dividend of five per
cent. on its preferred stock. Had
tie company enjoyed the full receipts
of the surface lines it could have
paid its preferred dividend and have
had upward of 100000 surplus in
addition-not very large amount,
to be sure, on 800, 900, 900 of COM
mon stock, but still something better
than deficit of million and third
after paying the dividend on the
preferred.
discharged For Dishonesty"
What part of these enormous
losses is due to failure to collect
fares and what part to the dishonesty
of employees is entirely a matter of
estimate and was admitted to be such
by officials of the nterborough-Met-
ropolitan Company, who discussed
the subject yesterday. A compilation
of figures showing the number of con-
ductors discharged by the New York
City Railway during the last three
years and a half throws good deal
of light on the subject, however, and