davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10
Notice of Summons.

CCPREME COURT. NEW YORK COUNTY-BF,N-
- jamin ". Foster Plaintiff against George H. Foster
Edgar Foster Maria Foster, D. Foster and
Helen Foster Buckley observation-disclosures: To the
above named Defendants each You
hereby summoned compls int in this ac-
tion. and to Of the Plain
tiffs attorney within twenty
this summons exclusive Of the day of service: in
Of your failure appear. judgment will
be taken against by default the relief demanded
IN the complaint.
Dated October 2. 1905
LOUIS T. DOYLE,
Plaintiffs Attorney,
Office and Post Office Address
No. III Broadway.
Trinity Building, Manhattan,
City II New York
To Defendants George II. Foster Edgar H Foster
and Helen Foster Bulkley; The foregoing summons is
upon you by publication. pursuant
Of : Blanchard. Justice O Supreme
York dated 9Th day O October, 1908,
with the complaint the ONCE Of Clerk
County Of New York.
Dated October 9th, 1898
LOUIS F. DOYLE.
Attorney for Plaintiff.
Trinity Building
Ill Broadway.
Borough of Manhattan.
CIT. of New York
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10
RAILROADS
NEW JEgsEY eEgraai

" y w O1s1a - - = ~ sd IIJNL =
Two HOUR TRAIN TO PHiLADEsLPEfIa
EVERY HOUR on THE H0rP
FOR PHILADELPHIA L. " 27D
ST. 30 80 $40. $50. $50. 10 g
$50. so 40 $50. $50. $50. 80 10 F. z z'e
.. sundays. $50 $50. o 50 n n
u, o N 1250. 30. 20. $50. 4s
~. LIBERTY ST .-13O. $50. Z 20 ss,
sc. 90O. l0o0s 100. ti1G a M 10
noon, 100. 10. ZG0 800 & -. 4 90 sao
600 T.0G. 400. 300 p m T. - mlfnfzss'
Sundays 80. 500. 9.00. 1000. 100 a. =
y 30 noon. 100 ? 20. 300. %. 3 % sss'
% : 90. 9 90. 10 20 e m II Is rus9-f...
FOR BALTIMORE AND WAsHINCsTey
L5O. $50. 80. SO , n. asi.y- Lv. La
ERTY ST. J 20. sen. 1000 a. m. f5a
noon. 200 900 500 100 p. m. daily.
FOR LAKEWOOD AND LAEFfft-Rz-
aniy,. 20. $50 SO. $50 40 40 - e.
ouiyJ D. IN. Sundays. A2o. 30 m d.
D. n Lv- LIBERTY ST. "A % ~
a n 100 sats 0nlyI. I'D. 2 go. 40 g
FOR ATLANTIC CITY u. y a,
sT:-95O a m. $3.50 sats on.yJ zs
D. N. sundays. 950 a. IT.. 2 20 O. m. =
LIBERTY ST 1000 A. m f' D. a..
oplyJ. 2 20 .. n Sundays. 1000 a =
FOR LONG BRANCH. AsRrRT P4pT
Lv. ". 23D ST 80 %. fi-2D a r- n "a
Sats. onIy). 2. 90 20 on. 8 %. : - = -
p. IT. SUNDAYS. . % = u, 2 -. z. 20 :. -
Lv LIBERTY ST 400. s31 II sO
N % Sats onlvj. 20. 4f5. go. 2 n aas
D. m, u 81 Midnight. SUNDAYS 400 az
a H. 4 %, 9 80 q m
Time tables NAV b obtained - soro-f-,
Offices Liberty So tET Z3d e. rar r----t
sea 3f44s. Piers 10 and 81. y T. = &c.
House 245. 434. 200. lc5f Broatl7-sy -
2o5 2sf FifTh Av 278s T----F A. ~
west 125th St 245 columbus Az vs-
York court 81 3s3. 2ff F9itar e. -
N0strand Av.. BROOKLYN 60 Br9sfrs-
williamsburg New York -ransss- -
calls for and checks baggage to dssrine.s7-
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10
IN THE AUCTION ROOMS.
Tro Interuale AUenHe Houses Sold
for S64,5O0.

~. +z-o FIVE story fathouses. with stores. No.
a1As tn 11s2 Jntervale avenue, plot 10oxSox lr-
regular, were sold yesterday at auction IN the
Resl Estate Exchange Salesrooms. Nos Il and 10
yesey street 20 Grace Hardie for sS4S" Inc
amount due was about $500. The other auction
results were follows:
Rv Bran !, KennsIIy: 125I and 1888 Ffankin az
mas n OF 1ssth T66Il6s TX irres two sly avg rs
sd vacant; Pauline Samuel HeitoTe1z et a.
Ysx Slversteir- atty; J. Hasbrouck- ref; srnt que
ls ss4 "a taxes etc $3.50; prior mtses, $1,000 10 'he
Eozintin Sls.49l. -. 80. -. Xxx c
Bv samuel Goldsticker: 7e7 and 7es f6lst st loo
81 FNorest IS 6x476 q: sty dWe rs allo
Etor,s. P Decker Harriet Both ct al: wagner d a
rftvx II Shaer. ref. due. 81 80 taxes ETC So
s;h n prior rtEs 500. Peter Both, party IN
81.
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10
PrODOS0Ls.

-@-7-------"----@-~->>--7
PROPOSALS WILL BE RECEIVED AT THE BUREAU
L of Supplies and Accounts. Navy Department Wash
lngton G, until 10 o'clock a m. october 90 1908
publicly opened Immediately thereafter. to furnish
the navy yard, New York. y y. quantity
supplies, follows: Sch 3S2: Undershirts-Sch.
lard, salt. evaporated apples.
Sch 421: Coffee crates.-Srh 426; Gassvare-Sch 429
Steam pipe-Sch. 43O Braid grommes, needles clothes
stops-Sch. 43t: Salt soapsa2h 453 Jackknives
blackng Applications for proposals should designate
schedules desired by number Blank proposals
be upon application the pay office.
New York y Y. o o the Bureau Z. B. ROGERS,
Faynna General l. s. y. 1916 OS
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10

MACHINIST. instrument. model
metal pattern maker; mechanical. electri
cal: wide experience; shop, factory. main
tain: inventive; references; reasonable. Ad-
dress Charles Wolpers. 123 Hoyt st,
Brooklyn.
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10
Excursions.
Citations,


U1HE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK.
l. by the grace of God free and independent to
Henry Morgan Tford, Wesley Hunt Tlford, Richard
Curd Tilford Edward Alfred TIlford. Mary Trotter
Chastain, Frank Vincit Tnford. Elizabeth Taylor
efersten and of kin Of Catharine Hunt
Tilford. deceased. send greeting: Whereas, Henry
TiIford. of the City Of New York has lately
applied Surrogates Court Of County of New
have certain instrument in writing: bearing
date the day OF August A. \. 1903 relating to
both real and personal property duly proved as the
last Testament of Catharine Hunt Tilford
lat Of of New York, deceased, therefore
YOU nd cited appear before
Surrogate of County of New York at his Office
he New York. the 18th day of November
one thousand hundred and eight past
o'clock in the that day. there to
attend the probate Of said last Will
And such of you : hereby cited under the
age of twentyone years required appear by your
guardian, you have II you have none ap-
pear apply for 10 be appointed. event
Of your neglect failure do guardian will be
you in the proceeding.
n testimony whereof. of
the Surrogate's Court of the said County
to be hereunto affixed. Witness. Hon. Charles
H. 81 II. Beckett a Surrogate Of said County
of New York. at said county the 18th day OF
September, in the year Of LORD thousand nine
hundred and eight. DANIEL J. uOWDNEY,
Clerk of the SurroEates
HAWRESWORTH E KIRTTAND. Attorneys fer Peti-
toner. 10 Broadway. New York City.
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10

ELEVATOR RUNNER. 49, White; expert
enced steady place; first class reference;
can do porter's work julius Weber. 14G7
jefferson ave. BROOKLYN.
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10
FILE PLANS FOR CITY MILK BOOTH.

Park Commissioner Smith has submitted to Build
inss Superintendent Murphy for approval the plans
sor the proposed milk booth to be erected by the
city .n Toupkins Square Park. for the distribution
~ steriIized milk It is be % feet in diameter
end Is feet high octagorai IN shape. with an orna-
r,sutal roof from designs by Theodore E. Nideto'
IS architect the city. II Is TO have conpleoe
plumbing pIart which the commissioner wishes
sDpe-sntendent Murphy 10 pass officially
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10
R1rYs THE WARRINGTON.

Dr- B F,arquhar Curtis has bought the Warning
ton apartment house, Nos Isl and l6S Madison ave
nue through Pease & Gilman for Howard Mott
Potter The same brokers also recently secured
for Dr.. Curtis loan Of 10000 from the Title
Guarantee and Trust Company, on the northwest
corner Of Park avenue and sd street, a five story
apartment house The loan is for three years at
az per cent and will be assigned 10 the Bo~ery
Savings Bank.
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10

ELEVATOR BOY or HALLBOY-By neat
respectable white boy. 252 West Attn St
care of silva.
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10
BOARD AND ROOMS

FURNISHED ROOMS for youns -
81 80 Up. weekly. steam. showers ,-s.
phone, music gymnasium privIegcss, -. Z.
Sc 20. references required I41 = A'A--
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10
RECEIVER OF RENTS NAMED.

Justice Blanchard. Of the Supreme Court yeseer-
apponted Nathaniel Levy receiver OF the rents
Of Nos q and q Monroe street. q SIX story oehe-
-neut house pending action brought by JACOB
T-;ScheI against FIyuon A. Brody and others 10
foreclose mortgage Of s21,0e0- There is prior
mortgage on the property amounting to $4,000
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10
BUILDING LOAN CONTRACTS.

sirnpsou St e s. 10o6 fl Of Freeman ST 40x1oO;
city 1Iyoti60 M0r'Ssge GoTpa2 SIS ooo
elIy St 2 n Of Dongwood SoXlOu'
same loans Iongyale Construction ComPeny.- +oUUo
D44y ave ,an %sbIis sonsin Company So 900
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10
RALTINORE & CFT0 z

ROYAL BLUE LINE TRAINS
Every other hOu- on tbs even ho5-s-
TO BALTIMORE AND WASHNGT0y
Direct Connections IN New Cnion sta-ss-
Washington. with all Lines S0gta
Leave New YORK Daily % s. IfS'vs,
wASHINGTOS. Sfpe-s. 1l-50 pu I "a a.
WASHINGTON. Diner. TO an s0a
wASHI%GTOSs. Diner. $50 an 1000 a.,
WASHINGTON. Diner, I1-50 an - - N,
WASHINGTO$. BUtcst l-s0 pm 209 N
(ParlOr car y z TO RichTlcud. Va
ROYAL LTD" Diner. $50 pu Ag9u-
WASHINGTON. Dfne-. $50 pm 900 -
WASHINGTON. Buffet, $50 pm T09 %
through Daily Trains % t-e Wss-
CHICAGO. PITTS SRCRG. 80 an s00.-
CHICAGO. COLUMBUS. fl-5) am I2005s
PITTsRCRG. CLEsVFL'D- $50 9u1 4OG -
-'PITTSBCFG LIMITED % pm 7O05-
GIN ST LOUIS. LOTTSN-s f1-50 Du 30 a.
GIN. ST-LOCIS. LOUSY. go an 10 % a.
CIN. ST LOUIS. .LOCTSV-- $50 Pm 500 -
Onces. "a. 424. 1900 Broad way. 8 ASS.
House. los Greenwich St. % 5,h Az. 81
Grand St, y 7. 343 Fulton St. RroczIT..
West 25f St and liberty 81
After Q ? IT Sleeping Car P-se-vaffs,,
and fuiI information regarding -rains e.
can be obtained at Bureau o. Inr0r-natio-
3 & o. P r. 23d St- Terminal 'Pho-s
Number 3144 Chelsea
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10
ESTATE SELLS A BLOCK FRONT.

The Reilly estate has sold the block front on the
west side Of St Nicholas avenue, between 1soth
and list streets 1t has frontage of 296 feet on
the avenue snd 100 feet each street
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10

MAN. German. so. single. honest and in
dustrlous, good appearance, we'll edu-
Gated. speaking and writing English flu
entity, wants good steady place. Stein
hagen. 130 East 50th st.
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10

DRFSSMAKER and SEAMSTRESS.-By
colored girl: in private family three days
n week + brown Young Womens Chris
tian Association. las West 03d ST.
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10

ELECTRICAL ENGINEER--Fou years
experience with telephones telautographs,
dynamos, storage batteries. oil engines and
electric lighting; three years experience
niSh best of references; willing to start
with moderate salary; good technical edu-
ca ton; married: % years old. T. J. May,
5T5 East 161st st
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10

1O5TH ST. 80 W.-Iarge and sna4i .-.e,-i,i ..ei
with board. running water.
food: 81 up. single
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10
LOsT-BaNKBoORa

BkNKBOOK No. 2I2. CSC Of Harlem Saw
flgs Bank lost, l25d-124th SITS and 80
Eve.
JOST.-Bankbook No. $40 .655 OF Dry Dock
Savings Institution Any person having
claims usson said book IS called upon 70
present the same TO The bank within thirty
days. or the said book viii be declared can
celled and sxtlnguished and q new one is
sued IN lieu thereof.
LOST. Bankbook No. I6I. 49s OF Harlem
Savings Bank. Payment stopped. Please
return book 20 bank
LOST OR STOLEN.-Ra book No. 567, 2is
q tie German Savings Bank in the city
Of New York. corner 4th ave. and 18th 81.
ISSUED 10 Catherine K9ehlFr- All persons
sre cautioned against negotiating the sane
II not returned 20 the hank on the 3lst day
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10
THE BRONX BUILDING PLANS.

Baker ave. n E, 225 fl Of Garfield st; two 2
story brick dwelling houses. 20x52 each;
tect total 1906
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10
DESKS AND OFFICE FURNITURE.

ALL AT BARGAINS.-Rollt desks. fat
top desks, bookcases. tables. settees
vardrobes. office partitions. repairing re-
hrizhinE Noethiger K Crsss. 2U9 Centre
St. 766 Spring.
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10
OCEAN STEAMERS
wnRTH eEsNsN LLOYD.

EDKTE iEKNAN IaU "
Fast Express Service.
pT.y1OrrTH-CHERB BOl fRG-Bttz4at =. = ~
Kaissr wrn. IIOct 70 Cecilie -.
sT',,,t,- Cs,.rf.,,, Passenger Service
BREMEN DIRECT. 10 a ~, %
r,arbsroSsa oct fOtKurfuerst- --- -tlct- -
Fried. d Or oct % Main WV -
Mediterranean Service II
c.rR.TTAr-NAPI.ES .ES-GENOA. at - =. = ~.
X AIbert oct 10 X Luise ---- 80 - .,
p. Irene. oct. "a K Albert 80
From Bremen Piers on 90 ana ~
HobOken- ---r.,-c,
n q, LLOYD TRAVELLERS Chs>'SFn NJ
OELPICUs & CO, No. . broadway y L
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10
IOST-BANKBOOKs.

LOST OR STOLEN--BankbOois No. 462. CGI
Of the German Savings Bank IN the city
OF New York. corner 4th ave. and 14th St.
Issued 10 lsak Teiteihaum. All persons are
cautioned against negotiating the same. IL
not returned To the bank on the goth day
sued
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10
Country Property for Sale.

Gently improved, and purchased by a client
for investment.
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10
WATCHES AND DIAMONDS.

FER line .....-............ IL cts.
HIGHEST PRICES for diamonds. precious
stones, old gold, jewelry. Established
1873 Mrs. Lynch's Son. 945 Broadway
ADVERTISEMENT and subscrfption, n,
The Tribune received at their Uptown
Office, No. 1864 Broadway. befweeu 36th
ana Sfth SITS until o'clock y. y. Ad-
vertisements received at the following
branch Offices at regular Office rates uatil s
o'clock 2. m. viz: 2e4 sth ave, $. e
cor sd ST.: lb3 9th ave. cor. 18th at rDI
East 14th st. 257 West 43d ST hefuean
ith and Sth sves-: 263 West l25th st lo35
3d ave: 1926 3D. ave. G1st st I7Os
ls5 ave. near ssth st; l6I East 125th St
American District Telegraph cfics.
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10
TYPEWRITERS.

--~----
VICTOR VISIBLE. 20 Nassau 81: cara-
Iozue free: all makes taken part pay
raent: bargains in UnderwoOds. Remtns-
tons divers. Smiths
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10

LOST OR STOLEN.-Bankbook No 5s5 2I3
Of the German Savings Bank in the City
Of New York. corner 5th ave. and 14th ct,
ISSUED TO August Ffihres. All persons are
cautioned against negotiating the same. II
not returned 10 the bank IN the 3lst of
October. 1905 q duplicate will be issued.
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10

LOST or STOLEN handbook No. 4e7 9O3
OF the Emigrant Industrial Savings Bank
Payment stopped. Please return book to
bank, No 81 Chambers st
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10
pREssMAKINo AND MILLINERY.

D7EssM cut and At the hrst
lining free OF charge; pcrfec tint guaran-
+Aed suits made from IS up; also out oy
the day. Mrs. White, 2433 sth ave
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10
Furnished Il partmentS to Let.
Long Island Real Estate for Sale.

WRITE FOR BEAUTIFUL NEW BOOKLET IN
w coIors with map and automobile route to Long
Beach. 225 Fifth ave. New York.
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10

JANITOR or sUPERINTENDENT.- Office
building hotel. apartment house; Eng
ush-American: thorough mechanic: total
abstafner: references best; bond secured 4;
always reliable. W Sprow, 2SS3 Broadway
New-York tribune., 1908-10-10

DpEsSNAKING.-Ou by the day; hours.
to 3; terms So per day. address, oy
letter. Miss n. Hughes, S42A Madison ST..
Brooklyn.
Los Angeles herald., 1908-12-18
TARIFF CONTROVERSY

TN HE controversy between Carnegie
and Schwab on the subject of tar
Il iff on steel suggests dispute be-
tween the potter and the clay. Schwab
is not only Carnegie's protege, but Car
negie's pupil. The views he is express
ing today with regard to the tariff were
Mr.. Carnegie's views before the founder
Of the Pennsylvania steel industry de-
cided he would better buy his soul''
1--WE quote his own words) by setting
about the task of administering his fors
tune.
Mr.. Carnegie has no doubt puzzled
his junior partners, because he has ex-
hibited dual personality. When he
retired from business, his mind became
occupied with various philanthropies
He talked with new associates. He
spent his time amid new associations.
He found it was a very human world
he lived in, after all, and not huge
manufacturing industry with the angel
Gabriel at the superintendent's desk
keeping profit and loss account.
Mr.. Carnegie's views on the steel
tariff are those of a sound. sane, mel
lowed citizen of the United States. Mr..
Schwabs views are those of a Grad
grind. who sees national catastrophe in
the diminution of the profits of the
steel trust. It is natural that Schwab
should pit the views Of the Carnegie
of yesterday against the views OF the
Carnegie of today, but it is, equally
natural there should be a considerable
divergence of opinion between the
views of a man who was in business
for what is was worth, and constantly
influenced by hard business associates
of the finty caliber of the wretched
despots who ordered the state troops
to fire on the Homestead strikers and
those of a man who is subject to the
softening and refining influences of the
higher civilization, and is spending his
time with librarians, professors, sci
entists, students and bookmen. Schwah
says, "Grab more" Carnegie says,
LET go, enough is as good as a feast
Which is the humanitarian patriot
and the friend of Americanism and
American industrial workers?
Los Angeles herald., 1908-12-18
HERALD CHRISTMAS

NJ AGNIFICFNT was the response
IV of the produce exchange mem
LiA bers to an appeal to take part
in the entertainment of poor children
at The Herald's Christmas festivity.
This great exchange, which repre-
sents a most important part of the
Industrial life of Los Angeles, made a
contribution of most gratifying and
substantial kind To the members
The Herald expresses its appreciative
thanks. We would also take this op-
portunity of thanking all subscribers
to the Christmas fund and contributors
of donations. Santa Claus wears
broad smile as he thinks of the sue
cess which is sure to attend The Her
AIDS festival as a result of the gem
erous preparations made for it..
But he is still worrying over one
matter-and The Herald, as his stew
ard, is naturally worrying also. we
need shoes, shoes, shoes. We would
like to be able to give comfortable
shoes. to scores, dozens, yes hundreds,
of children of Los Angeles who hardly
know what it is to have good shoes on
their feet or who run barefoot in days
of chill and mud and rain as well as
in days of sunshine. And we don't
need to tell our readers that even in
the loveliest part of California we
may have chill and mud and rain. We
have more sunshine than any other
community on earth.
Do you realize that the very abund-
ance of sunshine makes 1t all the more
difficult for children who are insult
ficiently clothed or badly shod to en-
dure weather that is even in the least
degree unpleasant? With a fall in
the temperature they suffer. With a
plashing downpour of rain, which
conpels them to wade through chilly
mud, they are in serious danger of
severe illness.
A pair of shoes may save child's
life. Who will give a pair of shoes
to Santa Claus for one of his Los
Angeles children? Who will give
dozen pairs? We do not care to re-
strict or limit the amount Of the gift.
We can use SHOES, and the more we
get the greater will be the number
oe the barefoot or badly shod children
of Los Angeles who will be made
happy and comfortable for the winter.
Los Angeles herald., 1908-12-18
TRUE BRAVERY

~ GORGE FREETH and the men,
IN bers of the Venice lifesaving
" crew deserve the thanks of the
community for their heroic rescue of
Japanese fishermen caught in a gale.
For Freeth application will be made
for Carnegie medal. He deserves it.
His work was equal to that of the
bravest of the brave. History presents
no instance of heroism that is greater.
over and over again he dared the waves
and battled with the tempest for hui
man lives. And not for the first time
was his heroism demonstrated. This re-
markable man within the last two years
is known to have saved or helped to
save approximately fifty lives along
the shore at and near Venice.
Here is bravery of the kind which
can be talked of without apology. Far
greater than the daring of the battle
field, it concerns itself with the preser-
walton and not with the destruction of
life. Indeed, thought Of in connection
with such deeds as those of Freeth, the
alleged "heroism" of the battlefield is
relegated to its proper place, We hard
ly like to mention 1t in the same breath
or sentence with the true bravery illus
trated by Freeth. Such sacred heroism
as his should not be known by the same
word as the man-killing "heroism"
of war. Peace hath her victories FAR
MORE renowned than war, and the
r,rao tasf ,oca oaf.,I yfctorv fOy. which the
laurel may be proudly worn is that
which by imperiling a chivalrous and
heroic life preserves the lives of fellow
human beings-in" this case of alien
blood and race.
BRAVE GEORGE FREETHl
Citizens of Los Angeles must cor
daily back the Venice chamber Of
commerce in its application for a Car
negie medal for this Hero Of Peace.
Los Angeles herald., 1908-12-18
BELIEVES STORES SHOULD
BE CLOSED AT 10 O'CLOCK

LOS ANGELES, Dec. 14.-[Editor
Herald: Your appeal in behalf of
store clerks for little easement of
their holiday time burdens is noted
with hopes that it may have its ef-
feet.
Those who go to and fro in Los An
geles stores cannot fail of being i'm
pressed by the superiority of the peo-
pie who wait on them. They are pos
sessed of the patient politeness and af-
fability belonging with good breeding
and intelligence. Why should this class
be so sadly, unnecessarily overworked
in the providing of a happy time for
others? Why, by reason of cruel de-
mands on them, be shut out from their
rightful, restful share in this happl-
ness?
AS stated by The Herald, many of
them are entirely exhausted by the
closing in of Christmas eve.
Could not this be changed, an en-
lightened and progressive city like Los
Angeles taking the initiative? IT. in
order to give full chance to shoppers, it
is necessary for stores to keep open
evenings during the Christmas week,
could they not be closed promptly at
10? And why not closed entirely on
Christmas eve, thus giving our faithful
servitors a chance to enter fittingly on
the enjoyment of the Christmas fes-
tival?
Much is being done for the children,
Will not a Christian community show
Christian consideration for these Of
'aiE sio"'"' M H. c.
Los Angeles herald., 1908-12-18
"voLUNTARIES" WANT LABOR
TO HAVE ALL IT PRODUCES

LOS ANGELES, Dec. 17.-LEditor
Herald: Charles U. White asked a
good and pertinent question, and be-
cause of delay that l am not respon-
sible for, the answer to it has not been
published. So Mr.. White decided 1t
could not be answered and has so
stated.
His question was: "How do you pro-
pose to make it possible for the penni-
less and propertyless worker to CO.
operator"
The answer that every voluntary" "
as he calls us, would make is: Let
every man refuse to work unless he
receives his full share of the product"
And as his share is all he produces 1t
is all he Is entitled to and all we ask,
and we will be satisfied with nothing
less.
If all who work or cooperate get
their proportionate share of the prod
uct no one is injured and no one will
object except those who want to live
off others.
If Mr.. White thinks this is wrong
let him say why. But let him not be
so unfair as to call c. F. a voluntary
in order to find something with that
label that he can answer.
c. #. is not a voluntary" He never
said he was, and no one who knows
anything of the voluntary" theory
would mistake him for one. Tn fact,
the 'rVoluntaries" have much more in
common with Mr.. White than with
c. F.
Mr.. White owes the "voluntaries" an
apology for the unjust things he said
of them in his last letter, and I hope
he will make it. C. II. SPRADING.