davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
New-York tribune., 1908-05-10
WASHINGTON SOCIETY NOTES.
[From The Trtbune Bur.au.l

[F'rom The Ir1b!ne BuTtauI
Washington Nav a-Sepstor and Mrs Elkins
have as their house guest Mrs George F. Baker
of New York. for whom they invited number OF
guests to dinner tonight.
Captain and Mrs Frederick W Sladen enter
tanned at dinner at the Chevy Chase Club tonight
1antain and Mrs Surnmerlin. Mr.. and Mrs Ma
thaniel Francis Mr. and Mrs. William Croshan
Denny Mrs. Van Vechten Olcott Mrs William ~
Brooks Lieutenant Butler. L. S n. and Mrs Lef-
ferts, OF New York.
Mrs. Truman II. Newberry and MISS 'aroI r
Newberry wife and daughter Of the Assistant Sec
Yetarv OF the NAVY left Washington this morning
for Virginia Hot Springs. where they will stay
week days.
Mr. and Mrs. Henry Cleveland Perkins had
number of diplomats and others al dinner to-nish''
Mr. and Mrs. Arnold Hague returned 10 Nash-
fnzton to-day from their summer place at Newport
which they have been making ready for the season
New-York tribune., 1908-05-10
THE CONVENTION ROSTER.

The Tribune's list Of delegates-elect TO the
Republican National Convention, published to-
day, shows that the final stage in the contest for
the control of that body has been reached, more
than four-tifthS of the members OF the con
yention having been chosen. There to be
$50 delegates, and up TO yesterday evening; ex-
Guiding one Congress district in Georgia and
one in Louisiana and the Territory of Alaska,
which have not vet been heard from, $50 dele
gates had been selected. OF these 4lS-a lit
tie over half-are directly committed to Mr.
Taft's support, having been elected by con-
yentions which instructed for him or passed
resolutions expressing preference for MN rs
q candidate or-as in half dozen cases-hav-
ing publicly expressed an intention to support
him in connection with their elections From
The Tribune's Taft column are excluded some
fifty delegates who are likely TO support Taft
but are as yet not explicitly and definitely
committed
In the districts not heard from last night and
In the states and districts which are TO hold
conventions this week 100 delegates are TO be
chosen. They are distributed as follows among
the states and territories: Alaska. ,; Arkan-
sas >: California. 20; Georgia. .: tdaho, o
Louisiana, ID: Maine, >: Massachusetts, :
Michigan, IA; Montana, 6; New Jersey -
New York, .; North Carolina, ,; North Da-
kota s; Ohio G: Oregon S; Texas. 80: WASH
ington 10. 1t is not unlikely that Mr. Taft VIII
get under instructions. II votes in Mlchl-
gan . in Arkansas. 6 in Montana, in ldaho'
s in North Dakota, 10 in Washington. Ill
Oregon Il in Louisiana, 6 in Ohio. in Alaska
and . in North Carolina, giving him 496 votes
in the convention. His friends also confidently
expect him TO secure the 56 votes of California
and Texas and :, of the votes from Georgia.
The results of last weeks conventions and the
apparent sentiment in most of the states whe re
delegates are vet to be chosen confirm the accu-
racy of The Tribunes forecast OF week ago ana
leave no doubt that Mr.. Taft is the favorite for
the Presidential nomination of substantial ma
iortv of the Republican party.
New-York tribune., 1908-05-10
THE DIPLOMATIC CORPS.
rr-,, 1,b. Tribune Bureau.

from The Tribune bureau
v,rosbi,,+o, Nav 9-Baroness Won SterhDu'S
s,a,,a q tea at the German Embassy this Afternoon"
which afforded society people an opportunity 10 s
poodby to her and to the Ambassador, as wen DC
to Captain Hebbinghaus, naval attache. anu ~ ~
Hebbinghaus and Miss Iangham. all OF whom "io
,o.rire washington next week. Nine. Hebo'nghaus'
whose husband Is TO be transferred froih "asn
ington to another diplomatic post in july asslsceo
Baroness Won Sternburg in receiving ana 'a'9'
IanChan presided AT the tea table. Ihere "eio
.nrin, towers in profusion- The Ambassador ana
baroness Won Sternburg will leave Washington oi
Wednesday for New York. preparatory 10 saiiiie'
CAPTAIN and Nine Hebbinghaus will spend fhlch
of their in visiting out OF town frienos
sailing for Germany.
The British Ambassador and Mrs Bryce VIII san
from New York on July for England. wnere theS
will spend the rest of summer, returning mere
late in the fall.
The Belgian Minister and Baroness Moncheurs )
dinner party at the legation tonight was followed
by bridge
New-York tribune., 1908-05-10
SOCIAL NOTES FROM NEWPORT.
IHy Telegraph 20 Ths Triourel

tEy Iclegrarn 70 ms AI4NA-oj
Newport r I. MAY a-Mrs. Alfred G Ns-f.r'
ti1t was the guest of Mr. and Mrs sar1usl J.
wasstaff in Boston on Friday night and vas ons
Of tboss to bid Mr. and Mrs Wagstaf goodoT
when they sailed to-day for Bermuda Mrs Van-
derbit returned 10 Newport to-day and entertainer
at dinner at Harbourvtew tonight
Mrs r d Hitchcock. Of New York, is here loos-
ing for cottage for the summer
Mr. and Mrs. A. q. Byers, OF Ph1ladelPhia5 M
and Mrs Day. Of Boston. and A. z. Ne~oof OF
New York were registered at the Musnchinssr
King cottage
Mrs II. Mortimer Brooks was hers to-day. n
spectinS Rockhurst. her summer home Later s1s
returned to New York whence she Will saH fos
Europe.
Mrs William Grosvenor and Miss Grosvsnor Es
visiting in Providence for a. few days
Hawkhurst has been opened and IS In readiness
for Mr. and Mrs William G. Rocker when tneT
arrive.
MIR. and Mrs A. H. omstead returned today
for the summer
Mr. and Mrs. Pembroke Jones will arrive On
May IS.
Edward J. Bervind and Mr.. and Mrs. H Casini
De Rhan returned 20 New York to-day.
Mrs E c. Hartshoru Is the guest OF A Living
ston Mason.
Craig BiddIe arrived to-day and IS at ths
Muenchinger King cottage
Peter F. Collier has leased the summer Eorne %
Charles Astor Bristed for the summer.
New-York tribune., 1908-05-10
NOTES FROM TUXEDO PARK
IBv Telegraph to The Tribune ]


,r.so park \ Y MAY s.-The cold. rainy
weather of the last few days has delayed the
rival of many of the cottagers AIthousn there ars
bright prospects for a good summer at tuxedo. tbs
Iateness of the has caused postponements in
1nanv cases All rooms at the clubhouse have been
or,a,o5 from Nav Is and there viii be few villas
unoccupied.
The committee on entertainments has arranged
for series Of interesting events during the season.
and the horse show. which takes place on June %
and ~ will be one Of the largest social affairs.
Nearly every cottager Will entertain during that
week Pierre Lorillard Jr-. IS secretary ana AZ
raadv nearly all Of the boxes have been engaged
The golf links are now in good shape and are well
,a+-onIzed hv the residents. There viii be series
of club handicaps next month
NE Alfred O. Vanderbilt returned 20 the French
villa this week from Newport She VIII go abroad
for the early summer
Aronp the cottage arrivals this week were NJ.
s,a Mrs Richard DeIafeld, who are at Brook
Farm: Mr. and Mrs. y. Thayer Robb, who are in
the McKtm cottage: Mr. and Mrs A r. Julllard.
in their villa on Tuxedo Lake: Mr. and Mrs Alonso
Potter in the Hull cottage; the Rev MI and Ms.
a. w Douglass Mr.. and Mrs George F Baker.
Mr.. and Mrs R F. Cutting and Nr- and Mrs
Fersythe Wickes-
NJ and Mrs ?. LoriIIard Barbey have moved TO
the ballard Smith villa. and J. Montgomery Hars
has taken the small Barley cottage for the sum-
roar Mr. and Mrs Barley will go 10 Switzerland
early in the summer
Mr.. and Mrs. Z. s. Lee havs vacated the Lir-
ingston cottage and at the club, and NJ ana
Mrs H o. HavemeyeT. jr-. are az the Garrison
House for the summer
Among those who are expected next week ars
Mr. and Mrs Theodore Frelinghuysen, Mr. am
Mrs NewboId LIE Roy Edgar. NJ and Mrs j. D.
Tavng IT Mr.. and Mrs. Richard Mortimer and
Mr. and Mrs Henry : Redmond
Mr. and Mrs George Grant NasoS sr-tved IN
THURSDAY at the J Henry Smith villa foT the SUM-
uer. Among other arrivals This week vers Nr.
and Mrs r {. Deveau. Mr. and Mrs Merle Md
dIs.o- Miss CaroIine Drayton. Mr- and Mrs G. W
FORSYTH Mrs Webster Edgar. Miss Nancy Wait
man. Mr. and Mrs. Q. J. Wells, Mr. ard Mrs
Ernest E Iorillazd. D1r- and Mrs. j Gordon Doug.
lass Nr and Mrs. W E Dodge. Orne Wilson ard
New-York tribune., 1908-05-10
FLIGHT WITH AEROPLANES.

Though the experiments which the Wright
brothers are conducting on the Carolina coast
essentially private like the shop tests OF
invention which can be tried indoors, it is
reported that the government will send repre-
sentatiyes TO watch them. Captive balloons
have amply demonstrated their utility for the
observation of an enemys position and move
flying machine ought TO prove even
more efficient in such service. 1t was for that
very reason thst Congress appropriated money
10 cover the expense OF the last of Pro-
fessor Langley's aeronautic ventures, that OF
1e0S. There is certainly much propriety
- ~ In keeping alert 10 the possibilities Of
flight by mechanical agencies. especially as the
unquestioDed success of the Wrights is a
handsome rndcation Of Professor Langleys
theories. Their device. like his, is an aeropane.
At present the Dayton inventors are prac-
tically without q rival in their own special field
on this side of the Atlantic. Professor Bells
-'tetra bedral kite" differs widely in form and
somewhat in principle from the Wright
chine. The former is composed of multitude
of small cells of peculiar shape The latter con-
slsts of only two outstretched horizontal sur
faces. one above the other. 1t begins 10 look,
foo. as If the Wrigbts had surpassed the best
performance of those foreigners who have been
working with aeroplanes. Santos Dumont, after
q few promising achievements. has apparently
relaxed if he has not entirely abandoned,
further effort Farman who won the Deutsch
prize for the first circular voyage with IN aero
plane covering distance of a kilometre in
France, does not seem TO have travelled more
than mile yet with his machine. In Europe
the best record is that of Delagrange, who has
10 his credit a continuous trip fully four miles
in length. Ii is now pretty we'll established
that as long ago 1904 the Wrights made a
number of successful voyages near their home
i'm Ohio one of them measuring twenty-four
and one-ffth miles. II they have not done even
better than this in the last few days, their past
performance is unmatched. and an even more
brilliant feat may be expected whenever the
wrights are ready to attempt it.
Whether the aeropiane will prove superior to
the fype of airship with which Santos -Dumont
was at first so conspcuously associated the
seif-propeled gas bag, is question yet TO be
answered Various influences have tended TO
interrupt the development of the aeroplane.
Among them were the fatal termination of
Iilienfhars exceedingly instructive ventures in
gliding down an aerial toboggan slide and the
seeming failure of Professor Langley five years
ago In the mean time Santos -Dumont has had
n host of imitators, conspicuous among whom
are fle Lebaudy brothers, who constructed La
Patrie for the French government, and Won
both Kinds OF airship has been carried further
n lust comparison of their merits. in respect
10 -cost. speed. facility in manGuyring. the
s.i,ance Of accident and other important charae-
fs<zsticx viii not be. feasible. II is not too
New-York tribune., 1908-05-10
THE NEWS THIS MORNTNG-

CoNGRESS-Senate: Debate was practcally
concluded on the agricultural aPprepIianIo Oh
nav" was defeated. House: A child labor
law for the District Of Columbia was pssse9
and the Porto Rican Commissioner cohaeilneu
the treatment of his people
FoREIGN.-Winston Spencer Churchiil'
President of the Board of Trade in the recon
structed Liberal Cabinet was returned TO far- G
lament from Dundee by majority on -'.VS-
- The Tribune's correspondent in LONDON
SAWS that Mr.. Ascuith's attempts 10 avert d
return 10 power OF the tnlonlst paIIS aie - Ie
Sarded in Conservative circles as fruitless.
The foundation stone of a new city, 10 supniant
Ceftinje as capital of Montenegro, was LAID on
the Adriatic Sea by the Prince of Montenegro
DoMESTIC-Admiral Robley d. Evans was
succeeded in command of the Atlantic battleship
feet by Admiral Thomas and left San Fran
smoke at mammoth mass meetings at North
Tonananda and Niagara Falls. y. Y, at which
he advocated the passage Of the anti -rdcetrack
gambling bills and attacked the bosses - A
medal with the Presidents head on one side
will be presented to Isthrrian Canal employees
having rendered two years service ~ Dr.
Long, Coroner of La Porte County. Ind. who
assisted in the past-norteT examination Of the
body supposed be that of Mrs Guinness. said
fftv pounds less than Mrs Guinness, and that
the latter alive - An unlnStrucfed dele
cation 10 the national convention Of the 1nde-
pendence party was chosen by the Massachu-
eetts state convention held in Faneuil Hall.
Boston A Buffalo high school athlete
was arrested in Rochester charged with abduct
ing a sixteen-yeer-old girl The Speaker
Of the Arkansas House Of Representatives as
sunaed Office as Governor while the acting Gov
ernor was temporarily absent, and compiica-
lions are expected.
CITY-Stocks were active and advancing.
The annual parade of the New York
Police Department was held. - New Ro
chelle n1anufa cturer committed suicide while
his family waited luncheon - Many promi
men guests Of The World" at the
celebration Of the quarter century Of Joseph
Puitzers ownership and editorial direction.
- The taking OF evidence in the charges
against District Attorney Jerome was finished
before Commissioner Hand - United States
Attorney Stirnson contended in the case Of Pri-
waite Reid that the President had the right 70
dismiss him account of the Brownsville
incident. - Controller Metz said he
holding up city contracts until July 1 because
Of lack of money. - The Public Service
Commission announced its intention Of order
tng traction lines in this city to operate
more cars at certain periods of the day
10 assure all passengers a seat.
THE WEATHER.-Fair to-day and to-rnor-
row. west winds. The temperature yesterday:
Highest, IS degrees; lowest. as.
New-York tribune., 1908-05-10
TTENELS IN JERSEY CITY.

After much negotiation an agreement has
been reached between the government of Jer-
sey City and the company operating the Hud-
son River tunnels and subway concerning the
use of the Jersey City streets by the latter cor
poration. The original proposal Of the tunnel
company was for perpetual franchise ac-
cording to the old system, and not many years
ago it probably would have been granted to it
as a matter Of course. But a new light has
dawned upon municipal administrations, and
Mayor Wittpenn has seen it, and so he insisted
upon limiting the franchise to a term Of years
The term finally agreed upon is long one
being no less than ninety-nine years, but 1t at
any rate establishes the principle of limited
franchises
Moreover it is not fat grant for ninety-nine
wears at q fixed rate without revision or quail
ification. Every twenty-five years the fran
chise must be renewed, and at such times its
terms and conditions may be modified to suit
changed conditions Of traffic. 1t is understood
that the Mayor at first wanted such renewals
to be made at ten year intervals, and to some
the twenty-five year periods may seem too long
Yet at any rate, the principle of periodical re-
vision is established, and the advance over
tho old system of Interchangeable and perpet-
ual charters is enormous.
The transaction is on the whole creditable to
the civic sense of Jersey City and will doubt
less proye profitable to that city. 1t marks a
distinct advance In its municipal methods Of
dealing with corporations and of administering
those franchises which among the most
valuable forms of public property. Nor is it
of least interest TO observe that the corpora
lion which has without official aid constructed
the splendid tubes under the North River IL
New-York tribune., 1908-05-10
IN THE CABINET.
-. ,rha 1.rih1,ne Rnreau.

rF,ron1 The Tribune Bureau-I -
washington May s.-Mrs. William H. iaIt &c
gone to Cincinnati, accompanied oy her S-s;1.
SON. Charles Taft. to remain a week W "
Secretary Taft i. in Panama
Mrs Garfield wife of the Secretary OF 'he III
terror. will give picnic party at the 6reat ~ ans
of the Potomac. few miles above was '0''
next Wednesday. ,rs
The Secretary of Commerce and LABOR anu - -
Strauss dinner guests to-nisht were ''e .-ra.ar,
.,,,ha~sador and Mrs James Bryce, the Secretary
Of the Interior and Mrs Garfield Senator ana hr'.
BuIkeIey. Senator and Mrs. Clay Rear Aoiiii" " a. aH
Mrs. Clover, Mr. and Mrs James Harlan anu MY
resentative and Mrs. Weeks.
New-York tribune., 1908-05-10

virtue or of decorum, while it would afford
greater liberty of conscientious action and would
free q large part OF the Church from the re-
proach of disreg1rding the Book Of Discipline
Whatever decision the conference may reacn
this and other matters will no doubt De
reached in the eminently direct and businesslke
manner characteristic Of the quadrennlal Meth
odist parliament, and will conduce to the con-
timed prosperity and growth of that active and
efficient Church.
New-York tribune., 1908-05-10
AT THE WHITE HOUSE.
rFrom The Tribune Bureau

TF[rom D..,,
Washington May 9.-President anu VIE - =,
Welt are expected TO return 10 'he 80 -i.o L-rot
,1h.n,.-,. co1ntv Va. On Monday afternoon 'he
president will deliver an address at the corle. lsr
stone laying of the Bureau of American pun;.c
sirca the presidents departure Thursday noiiiiNs
no vord has been received from him.
New-York tribune., 1908-05-10
WHERE HUGHES IS NEEDED.
,rnr, The WaverIv Erea Press.

Prom The WdVerIy Free TreSs
MANY newspapers, notably The New-York Trib-
une see in the present situation what they be-
lieve to be insurmountable reason why Hughes
should succeed himself as Governor. They do not
believe he can complete his work In his present
term and look upon him man who has very
distinct duty to perform and destiny fulfil
that can be done nowhere but in the chair OF the
Governor Of New York State. The people Of New
York would like to him President. but they
will have no cause for complaint if they still
have him for Governor, and 1t may be that 1t is
in his own state that he do his best work and
is most needed
New-York tribune., 1908-05-10

both willing and eager to extend its system IN
Jersey City entirely at its own expense anu
under these restrictions. In that fact there Is
a suggestive object lesson worthy the CONSUL
Grafton of other municipalities when may pe
inclined TO fear that they could not get sultapie
transit facilities unless they made unconditohai
surrender TO the CORPORATIONS which would pro-
vide them
New-York tribune., 1908-05-10
IN THE BERKSHIRES.
[By Telegraph to The Tribune J


Ienox Mass. May 9.-The Berkshire Hills rssorls
will be I'm full swing next week The in-ush OF -
tagers this week has taken Leuox by surprise ana
announcement ~ made that mid-Msy viii IND
great many OF the largest villas open for the WHO'S
season. Mrs. George Westinghouse. always an cary
conner Is at Erskins Park: Mr.. and Mrs. Frank n
Sturgis have opened Clipston Grange and Ms
Helen Parish is her West street villa
In PfttsheId Mr. and Mrs William Poilack ns's
opened HolmesdaIe their country estate
jsrenvills L. Winthrop. OF New York. who c~n'
The EIms has been appointed tree warden of Len0A-
Very lately MIR. Winthrop created out OF ms fo'1-
Fsobeston place one OF the most beautiful COUNTY,
estates in the Berkshires. which he Is prersrns
occupy His knowledge OF forestry and bis enrnuS
asm over the care of trees on the public streets -
to his being named official earetaksr Of ths Len'-
elms- ,4~
In Stockbrdge with the opening Of the Red -.
Inn, many guests and cottsgers are besfnnlns -
pear MIR. and Mrs. r. B. Bowker. DR.. anu - -
W. c. Thompson. Mr.. and Mrs. F. l. "aTen
Mr. and Mrs. Frederic Crowninshield. OF We" w.
arc their summer home =, "A
Mrs UYIiian, NJ. Kendall. Of New York
Spring Lawn in Pittsfeld for the summer n'1
The Rev and Mrs. Haslsrt Mcktn and -. -
McKin, of New York. have arrived NJ tns -.
Hotel Mrs James r Jesup and Mrs Z a -
mont of New York. will come TO Lenox Ao'''
the entire season. x.,x.
MI and Mrs Henry rvison Parsons OF No"
are at their country estate In Stockoriose- a
Mrs Edward Anthon. who had taken - "a
the Bishop cottage has decided not TO e'" 80.
Ienox because OF the death OF nef sou" CIV
Charles Coster the broker in New forS v.rs
Mr. and Mrs s Dudley Riggs. Miss z L. ,.~.n<
and S. d Riggs. ir.. OF Phadephis, are
an automobile tour OF the Berkshire HIS. IN
Mrs. Henry Phipps. OF Morrsstown' " - 10
Miss La Montague. OF New York. as her
also arrived in I.enox on a motor trip xsk.
Mr. and Mrs. Theodore w Luiins. OF -s
are at their country place in stocknrioss. yox
Mr. and MrsA Carl DeCiersdorn OF W. r,,t n
how. ,sa ed the Cboate cottage on Prospect hu 4
stockbridSe. and Mrs. DeGersdorf has ai
the inn a.. rhsf9
Mrs Charles McBurney has returned "a -
Farm from New York, where sne
funeral of Albert stickney. late OF tnsl e''
New-York tribune., 1908-05-10
THE PEOPLES GOVERNOR.

From The New York World
Whether not the Legislature again refuses
TO pass the anti-racet ack bills, Governor Hughes
should be renominated order that the reforms
he stands for shall be carried through to compile
ton. The anxiety OF the petty Republican bosses
TO discredit him in the eyes of the party shows
that they want candidate and Governor who
will be more serviceable to them and less faith
.fu 70 th. people whose interests they n,isrepre-
sent --~-
New-York tribune., 1908-05-10

The Senate is strong for limiting the author
fzation Of batteships. but when 1t comes 70
abolishing a dozen or more pension agehcies'
which the pension bureau no longer neeos anu
wants TO dispense with, the argument Ior econ
omy loses its potency We hope that the House
of Representatives Will stand firm against
continuation of these useless agencies
New-York tribune., 1908-05-10

It is something of reflection upon the prac-
+rca1 business sense of America that there should
he need of such conference as that which the
President has called for this week at WashilS-
ton. 10 consider ways and means for conserV-
ing our natural resources. but since there Is
need of It. the calling of such a meeting IS an
act of high and patriotic craftsmanship "hlcn
should be productive of much GOOD Tor the
nation.
New-York tribune., 1908-05-10
Ntm71prk Daily Gribm,1r
SUNDAY, MAY 10, 1908.

This newspaper is oicned and paofshea ny
The Tribune Association, Neso YORK corpoIo
sion Office and principal place OF business, i'io-
uue Building No. f5s Nassau street, Netc ORR;
coden MfFIs. president; NathdnieI Tuttie, sec
,eto-u and treasurer. The address Of the Off
Ger. is the Office Of this newspaper.
New-York tribune., 1908-05-10

Fifteen of the ringIeaders In the recent riot al
the University of Michigan have just been dis
missed from custody, their fond papas having
paid the costs of the episode which ended IN lne
wrecking of theatre and several shops. 1hlS
magnificent triumph of justice viii teach 'he
wicked youths the great lesson of their
lives viz. never, never to sin unless they have
cash enough to settle with the injured parties IN
case Of arrest.
New-York tribune., 1908-05-10
About People and S0cfof A'7c'denfs.

Burial Hoffman. l. Chauncey McKeever. W H,-
old Brown and Miss Clementina Furniss and Ne
de Barril.
New-York tribune., 1908-05-10

The leasing of Delagoa Bay, If effected VIII
mean that the Transvaal will enjoy under Brit
ish sovereignty an inestimable benefit wh1ch lt
assiduously but vainly sought under Boer con-
troll The bargain ought to be sooo olie loi
both parties Portugal getting more out or the
rental than she does at present out of occupa-
tion of the port and the Transvaal reaplnS
great profits from such ready access TO the sea
New-York tribune., 1908-05-10

soon however to accord TO the Wrights the
heartiest praise for the ingenuity and persist
ence with which they have labored.
New-York tribune., 1908-05-10

The arrest Of man for checking his horses
heads to a cruel height is a commendaoie INCL
dent which might properly be multiplied many
times.
New-York tribune., 1908-05-10

George W. Vanderbilt. who has been In town n.
a few days staying at the ST. Regis. has LEFT h.-
for the south and returned to Biltmore " C.
New-York tribune., 1908-05-10

Mrs Pierre Lorillard has arrived in town and 4,
staying at the Gotham