davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The Fargo forum and daily republican. [volume] (Fargo, N.D.) 1894-1957, 1908-11-20
.QUIz.zING
ROCKEFELLER
Kellogg Jss Examines the
Oil King Today
1882 AGREEMENT ADMITTED
JOHN .. SAYS AMOUNT OF MONEY
MADE DOES NOT DETERMINE.
WHETHER BUSINESS IS HAZ.
ARDoUs OR NoT-FAcTs AND
FIGURES uNDIsPUTEp.

New York, Nov. 2O.-Rockefeller was
again on the witness stand when the
hearing was resumed today His
cross examination was at once begun
by Frank B. Kellogg special assist
ant district attorney. - y -
In response to questions about the
hazardous nature of the oil business
owing to the possibility Of failure TO
supply. Rockefeller said that the pro-
duction OF crude oil in the Pennsyl-
vania field has, steadily increased from
1862 to 1900. Kellogg read figures from
an official report showing that the
Pennsylvania field reached in It's high
est point of production in 1900.
Rockefeller denied that the supply OF
crude oil had al%ays been ample and
asserted that It had fiuctuated but that
the supply is larger now than when he
was actively engaged in the business.
"You have been prosperous since the
beginning" asked Mr.. Kellogg.
Millions in Dividends.
Yes" aA ..-... ..-.
do you consider business hazard
Gus that on an original investment of
$67, ,O0o, 900 paid dividends amounting
to $5s1, ,ooo,0 900 and had lent surplus
of $500, ,oo0, ,Ooo7% -
II do not understand that the
amount Of money made determines
whether the business is hazardous or
not" said Rockefeller,
He was then asked about the trust
agreement Of 1882 and whether the
trust certincates did not show a value
of S70.ooo,ooo ana that the stocks held
under . the agreement had an actual
value Of s55, ,710,sss. Rockefeller said
he believed these: figures to be correct
Earnings Mere Enormous.
Kellogg asked: s.eas
"The record shows that uD to 1906
the net earnings Of the company were
ksss1, s22!sO4. What was the dividend
In tsO2g'
81 should say about 40 per cent
.sThat was about $4,000, DOOR
"That would be $1,000,000 in favor
of the poor old Standard" said Rookie
feller. He added that the net earn
ings for 1907 were approximately $780,
600, 900.
Kellogg again asked II he considered
business risky on such showing,
and Rockefeller. again retorted that
the profits did not determine the risk.
1t is evident that the business was
prosperous. He assented to Kellogg's
figures showing that the company
earned s4sO, 100000 from 1899 to 1906.
Adding the earnings of 1907 would
give total earnings of $57O,000,000.
Fires Are Only Hazard.
Then where does the hazard of the
business come in?', asked Kellogg.
';In the first place, since the first
refinery, was built. more than fifty
years ago, we have been prepared al
any moment, daysor night, to hear a
fire alarm. We are deling with very
explosive product. Fires are constant
ly occurring"
''But, your profits were above your
fire losses, which have been charged
to the profit and loss account?"
'Yes, SIR"
The Fargo forum and daily republican. [volume] (Fargo, N.D.) 1894-1957, 1908-11-20
ENGLAND near
WAR WITH india
PAIL MALL GAZETTE WARNS MA.
TON AGAINST LURKING
REVOLUTION.

London, Nov. 2o.-Tearing aside the
mask to which the British war office
and the British press have been en-
deavoring to conceol the real gravity
of the state OF affairs in India, the
Pail Mall Gazette to-day warns Eng
land or the danger lurking ia the. In
dian situation. I.
1T cannot be long before the gov
ernment is forced to take comprehen-
sive military precautions in India"
declares The Gazette.
The situation there has grown SO
alarming that 1t now is impossible to
minimize the danger which faces the
British government.
The Fargo forum and daily republican. [volume] (Fargo, N.D.) 1894-1957, 1908-11-20
HARMAN CASE IS
STARTED TODAY
MAN FROM cAssELToN, cHARe-
ED WITH UNsPEAKAsLE CRIME
IS NOW HAVING HEARING
COMPLAINING WITNESS is A
cAssELToN CLERGYMAN.

Charged with one Of the most bes-
tial crimes that has ever been recorded
In Cass county, James Harman Of
Casselton is having his hearing this
afternoon in district court.
Harman was arrested last August
in Casselton, citizen of that city
claiming that he found Harman out
raging little 4-year-old girl, daugh-
ter Of a Casselton clergyman It is
said that Harman was completely un-
der the influence of liquor at the time.
The case was called at 2 o'clock
this afternoon. Attorney R. M. Pol
lock is representing Harman and
States Attorney Barnett is .rross-
cutting the case.
The Fargo forum and daily republican. [volume] (Fargo, N.D.) 1894-1957, 1908-11-20
s50,O0O,OOO IN
new COMBINE

New York, Nov. 2o.-Oficial confir-
nation Of the formation OF a merger
OF fertilizer plants into corporation
with a. capitalization or $4,000. 900. is
expected this week. Both acid and
chemical companies will be concern
ed. 1t is said.
The merger will be Incorporated In
New Jersey and the capital win be al
vided. s2B.o00.000 preferred. and an
equal amount OF common stock.
The Fargo forum and daily republican. [volume] (Fargo, N.D.) 1894-1957, 1908-11-20
new CURE FOR
WHITE PLAGUE
succINlMiDE or MERCURY HAe
DONE VERY GOOD
WORK.

Minneapolis, Nov 20.--Succinimide
OF mercury is not phrase for the lay
man to ,iuggle with any dexterity. but
to the sufferer from tuberculosis IT
will speak hope, If the infantile stage
Of it's use in the treatment OF the
disease proves that ii II worthy 10 be
declared a specific. DR.. w. H., Bucher,
s1.geon in the navy, who is a guest
OF his cousin, J.. g. Bell. brings first
hand news OF the success with which
the succininide OF mercury is being
used at the naval hospital for tuber-
cllosis near Les Anfmas, Col. eighty
miles from Pueblo.
Incidentally DR.. Bucher speaks most
highly of the interest manifested In
Minneapolis In the subject OF tuber-
culosis cure and prevention, and which
Is so substantially backed up with
material aid. He declared yesterday
u the Minneapolis club that he has
seen more real interest here than else
where and that he wished 1t might
Be 30 highly developed In other parts
OF the country
The Wright Treatment.
Succinimide Of mercury Is an Eng
lisf preparation Its use in tubercu-
losis cases is called the. Wright treat
nert as ii was discovered and applied
~ DR.. B. Il. Wright, surgeon OF the
navy The discovery was made In
treating consumptive patients for 9TH
81 diseases. AT the new naval hos
pital ii is voluntary treatment, end ~
applied intra -muscularly. AZ sailor
ers.x.kf..,sa7 asf paRN IL.
The Fargo forum and daily republican. [volume] (Fargo, N.D.) 1894-1957, 1908-11-20
BANK CLOSED,
CASHIER HELD

Monticello, KY. Nov. 20. The Citi-
gems National bank has been closed,
its cashier, Chas w. McConnaghy, ar
rested and a search instituted for AS
sistant Cashier e. I. Winfrey.
McConnaghy was taken TO Somer-
set Thursday for hearing before United
States Commigsioner Cook.
The shortage is estimated at $22,-
900. The deposits are said to have
amounted to $4,000.
The Fargo forum and daily republican. [volume] (Fargo, N.D.) 1894-1957, 1908-11-20
NO MORE SILKEN
HOSIERY FOR Her

repressed financially but vigorous as
ever in spirit, has appeared in classic
Roston to dely that she has myster-
ously disappeared from Butte, Mont.
Abandoning silk stockings for cotton
ones to help Ameri an industry, Mary
announces with characteristic COM
plaisance that she 10 preparing an
other assault on The Literary Foibles
OF the World"
The Fargo forum and daily republican. [volume] (Fargo, N.D.) 1894-1957, 1908-11-20
FOOTBALL TOMORROW
Two City Teams, the Stars and
the independents, to Meet at
2.30 p. M.

What promises to be an interesting
game of football has been scheduled
the Independents On the grounds OF
the Fargo college.
The teams are composed Of the
first and second teams OF the Fargo
high school, divided so that there will
be an equal number Of experienced
players In both teams, and 1t will un-
doubtedly prove one ofxhe gcrappiest
games Of the season
The Fargo forum and daily republican. [volume] (Fargo, N.D.) 1894-1957, 1908-11-20

Chicago, Nov 20-Seven track Ia
borers on a hand car were run down
by a Chicago, Burlington & Quincy
railroad passenger train between
Highland and LAGRANGE, Ill, today
and killed. Three of the seven men
met death instantly and the other four
The Fargo forum and daily republican. [volume] (Fargo, N.D.) 1894-1957, 1908-11-20
u. S. COMMISSIONER
PAYS FINE OF $500

Sioux Falls, s. o., Nov. 2o.upon a
plea OF guilty, Judge Garland Of the
United States court has imposed "a
fine OF $500 on Former United States
Commissioner Anson wasar of Dallas.
8. D., for using his commissioners pos
tai frank on postal cards OF private
nature. wasar, was several days ago
removed from Office by Judge Garland
The Fargo forum and daily republican. [volume] (Fargo, N.D.) 1894-1957, 1908-11-20
seven LABORERS ON HAND CAR
MEET DEATH near Chicago

died almost Immediately afterwards.
There were ten men on the hand
car. The others escaped with slight
injuries.
The accident is said TO have been
due to mistake on the part OF the
laborers who put their car on the
wrong track. ., ...E
The Fargo forum and daily republican. [volume] (Fargo, N.D.) 1894-1957, 1908-11-20
Are Candidates.

Bismarck, N. D., Nov. 20.-Major
John H Frame Of Grafton, is here
attending the militia officers meeting,
and incidentally sizing up the chair of
the speaker Of the house, he being a
candidate for that job He says he
has not yet definitely announced him
self but is in the hands Of his friends.
The Fargo forum and daily republican. [volume] (Fargo, N.D.) 1894-1957, 1908-11-20
COUGAR KILLS
THEIR CATTLE
NORTH DAKOTA FARAaERs ARE
ENGAGED in HUNT FOR
BIG BEAST.

sherbrooke. NJ. ID. Nov. 2o.-Con-
.sternation reigns IN a large section OF
Steele county on account OF the pres
ence OF cougar that II killing live
stock
At Hope band oe hunters organ
lied and spent day looking for the
animal. which - OF large size.
It IL hoped that when sufficient
snow falls the cougar can be trailed
to his lair. TN
The Fargo forum and daily republican. [volume] (Fargo, N.D.) 1894-1957, 1908-11-20
TAFT HAS MADE NO
SLATE FOR CABINET

Hot Springs. va, Nov. 2O.-"I
wish you would just say that my
cabinet Is not made up nor slated.
No one has been decided upon for
any place in it and no offers of any.
cabinet positions have been made
to any one.
This was the response OF Presi :
dent Elect Taft today to the state
ment from minneapolis that Frank
B. Kellogg had been invited to be-
come attorney general in the Taft
cabinet.
The Fargo forum and daily republican. [volume] (Fargo, N.D.) 1894-1957, 1908-11-20
PRINCE CHING
REPORTED SLAIN
DEATH DUE TO SAME cA8AL
WHICH DOOMED EMPEROR
AND EMPRESS.

Paris. Nov. 20.-Rnmors OF the MUIR
der of Prince Ching and Yuan Shi
Kai. grand councillor By high Chin
ese official. are printed in today's Par
is papers. The accounts are indef-
mite and conflicting.
The Fargo forum and daily republican. [volume] (Fargo, N.D.) 1894-1957, 1908-11-20
AUTO PARTY ENDS
DIsASTROUSLY
TWO DROWNED AND SIX MUIR
! ED WHEN "RED DEVIL" LEAPS
IN RIVER IN CHICAGO;

Chicago, Nov. 20.--Two persons
were drowned and six Others rescued
from the water today when an. auto
mobile in which they had been speed y
ing toward Chicago, swerved from its
renee avenue bridge, over the Calumet
women. all living at 21D6 Armour ave-
nue. All were thrown into the river.
The Fargo forum and daily republican. [volume] (Fargo, N.D.) 1894-1957, 1908-11-20
Turn 10 the Rioht. tienceforth.

Turn to the Right, Henceforth.
II you are made OF anything but dirt
II you've soul that other souls can
hurt,
Turn to the right, henceforth, whoever
passes;
It's death to drop among the Iawless
cIassesl
Men lose, who lose the friendship o.
the law.
A blessing from each breath Of air
they draw:
They know TIL advantage of a good
square face,
When theirs has been disfigured by
disgracel
From THE Convicf's Christmas
Eve. by Will Carleton.
The Fargo forum and daily republican. [volume] (Fargo, N.D.) 1894-1957, 1908-11-20
Busy With MiIItia Law.

Bismarck, N. d., Noy. 2O.--~The COM
mittee Of officers appointed at the last
National Guard association meeting 10
prepare revision OF the state militia
code, ID In session here and hopes to
draft q law satisfactory to the guard
and the legislature at the coming ses-
sion.
The Fargo forum and daily republican. [volume] (Fargo, N.D.) 1894-1957, 1908-11-20
MOORE IS not GUILTY
Man Charged With Beating Cream
Restaurant Out Of Board 5iIi
Is Discharged

Thomas Al. Moore, who was charged
with defrauding the Cream restaurant
out Of a board bill had his hearing
before Judge Miller at o'clock this
afternoon and he was discharged. the
Judge holding that there was no in
tent to defraud and that Moore was
not guilty as charged.
The Fargo forum and daily republican. [volume] (Fargo, N.D.) 1894-1957, 1908-11-20
HURL CHILDREN
FROM WINDOW

New York. Nov. 20. Eleven children,
including babe IN arms, were caught
-.s e,1lls oI policemen early today
afay ts,ey had been hurled, from win
dows by terrifed mothers, az IRE
ragged in a tenement Ia South First
street, williamsburg. one bog OF ten
years perfshed.
The Fargo forum and daily republican. [volume] (Fargo, N.D.) 1894-1957, 1908-11-20
on ono Ruaineas Trip.

G. A. Grettum leaves Saturday night
for. the twin cities Chicago. Kansas
City and New Mexico, on business
and will be gone for some time.
The Fargo forum and daily republican. [volume] (Fargo, N.D.) 1894-1957, 1908-11-20
FRENCH CRUISER
Is On The ROCKS

French cruiser Conderan Is on rocks
of Corsican coast to-day da'rip,- a
heavy storm and her position II crit
tca1 Theirs was no loss oi nle.
The Fargo forum and daily republican. [volume] (Fargo, N.D.) 1894-1957, 1908-11-20

Laporte, Ind, Nov. 20.-The state
rested today in the trial Of Ray Lam
phere, accused Of the murder Of Mrs.
Belle Guinness and her three children
by setting fire to her house, when the
defense finished the cross examination
The Fargo forum and daily republican. [volume] (Fargo, N.D.) 1894-1957, 1908-11-20
WAR ON new
TARIFF CERTAIN
HEARINGS ALREADY SHOW THAT
BUSINESS INTERESTS ARE
NOT UNITED.

washington. Nov. 20. Aithough
they have only begun, the tariff hear
Engs before the ways and means COM
mittee in this city already show the
groups into which the American public
will divide itself as soon as the work
OF enacting new tariff law is taken
up by congress, next spring.
Nearly all OF the manufacturers thus
far heard have declared themselves
entirely satisfied with the present.
schedules, and some of them have even
suggested that they be increased. This
class of men, while small, has back Of
it large mass OF wage earners, and
its arguments are supplemented BY the
familiar demand for the maintenance
Of the american standard OF living"
in the homes of laboring people. A
considerable body of labor therefore.
1t is predicted here, win indorse the
demand for no radical reductions of
duties.
The importers, on the other hand,
are almost without exception In favor
Of reductions While the manufacture
ers find thei- profits In high schedules.
which shut out competing manufactur-
ers OF the old world, the importers find
their profits, in large part, In unhamp-
cred access to foreign markets for
manufactured products. Back Of the
importers stand the consumers, repre-
senting the great bulk OF the popula~
tion
The Fargo forum and daily republican. [volume] (Fargo, N.D.) 1894-1957, 1908-11-20

OF Deputy Sheriff Anstiss. The deputy
testified to admissions alleged to have
been made by Lamphere following his
arrest. The defense is considering
whether it shall put Lamphere on the
stands
The Fargo forum and daily republican. [volume] (Fargo, N.D.) 1894-1957, 1908-11-20
Still q Local Issue.

To make concrete Illustration.
Massachusetts wants free hides. in
order that its big shoe manufacturers
may buy their raw materials more
The Fargo forum and daily republican. [volume] (Fargo, N.D.) 1894-1957, 1908-11-20
WARDS FATE IS
IN JURY'S HANDS
CASE WENT TO THE JURY AT
11.2o THIS MORNING AFTER A
LONG, BITTER FIGHT BY THE
TWO ATToRNEYs--ALl5I Is.
WARDS SOLE DEFENSE.
WARD NOT GUILTY.

3:45 p. m. = The jury in the
Ward case brought in verdict of
of mot guilty at 3:45 o'clock this
afternoon.
The Fargo forum and daily republican. [volume] (Fargo, N.D.) 1894-1957, 1908-11-20

Continued On Page Fourteen.
The Fargo forum and daily republican. [volume] (Fargo, N.D.) 1894-1957, 1908-11-20

continued on Page a.
The Washington times., 1908-03-11
.OUINTUPLETS ALL BOYS,
.:PHOTOS FOR PRESIDENT

SIREsTON. No, March u.-Quiutup-
lets were born 10 Mr.. and Srs. John
Cahoon, OF this place. The babies are
strong. healthy boys. and weigh about
six pounds each. The father runs
saw mill near here and weighs shout
$50 pounds. The mother IS a small no
man and does not weigh more than iSf.
Mr.. Cahoon says be VIII send Pres
dent Roosevelt a Photograph OF the
boys as soon as Il Is possible 70 have
one taken Both Mr.. and Mrs. Cahoon
were born near here, and the parents
OF both live in SiksstOn- This IS The
first case Of multiple births in the his
tory Of either family.
The Washington times., 1908-03-11
SURVIVOR OF THE MONITOR
CELEBRATES BATTLE DAY

PHILADELPHIA. March 11-WnHam
burst. OF 1916 George street. one Of the
three Survivors OF the crew Of the Mon
itor, quietly celebrated the anniversary
OF the famous "cheesebOx's" fight with
the Merrimac on March 9, 1862. He is
seventy-two years old, and is employed
at the Paramount park pumping station.
On the morning of the battle burst
was detailed to convey orders from
Lieutenant Worden. who was In the
coming tower. 10 the gunners. He was
standing on the deck when a shell shat
tered the tower and wounded Lieutenant
Worden, and he carried the officer to
a place of safety. For this act he was
commended on the following day by
President Lincoln.
The other living members OF the crew
are Michael Mooney. who is in a sol
diers' home in California. and the Rev.
Ellis Roberts, OF Danviile. Pa.
The Washington times., 1908-03-11
POSTAL SAVINGS BANKS
FAVORED BY COMMITTEE

Senator Carter, head Of the subcom-
lnittee Of the SgRate Posto1ices Commit
tee. which is IN charge of postal saw
ings bank legislation, said today that
the subcommittee would report a bill
to the main committee in a short time.
He expects within a week OF so that a
favorable report on a postal savings
bin viii be made from the Senate Post
offices Committee TO the Senate.
Senator Carter says he has no doubt
the Senate will pass a bin on this sub
ject The House, however. Is not looked
on as favorable 10 postal savings bank
legislation. Representative Overstreet
chairman of the House POstofflces Com
mittee was asked about the outlook for
passage of a bill by the House. He said
he did not expect anything would be
put through this session.
The Washington times., 1908-03-11
WILD CAT IN HIS BARN
NEARLY KILLS FARMER

HAZLEToN, Pa, March u.-Attacled
BY wildcat as he went to the barn to
feed his stock. John Wittacher, OF
Conyngham Valley. was almost killed.
The cat got into the barn during the
night. and as Wittscher entered with a
bag Of chop on his back. the animal
pounced upon him. Under the weight
OF the catamount and the bag. Vita
cher fell to the floor and for n few
minutes there was a fierce struggle
between the man and the beast
Finally Wittacher got up and, selling
& large board that lay on the floor, dealt
head, when the animal fed Wittacher
was badly scratched about the face and
hands. and was severely confused about
the body.
The Washington times., 1908-03-11
Rats Steal Gems
In Mobile Home Of
Honduras Consul

MOBILE, Ala, March 1.-THE resi-
dence OF Ramon Niada. former Hon
duran consul. Is infested with thieviug
rats. That this IS regarded as d fact
was shown last night when diamond
rings and jewelry, said TO be valued at
more than S4O0, We're recovered from a
rats nest.
For some time members Of the family
have lost, under mysterious circum-
stances, pieces az jeWelry. Efforts 10
discover the thief or manner IN which
the 5ewelry was taken from its accus-
toned place were futile. Finally IL was
suspected that rats might have had
something TO 90 with the disappearance
OF the isWelry.
The Washington times., 1908-03-11
HITCHCOCK At CAPITOL
TO ADVANCE TAFT BOON

Frank II. Hitchcock, campaign man
ager for Secretary Taft. was in evil
dence at the Capitol yesterday after
noon, where he was engaged in pro-
noting the Taft movement. Mr. Hitch
cook saw various Senators and members
Of Congress and learned what he could
about the situation In different States.
Mr.. Hitchcock talked in a most san
guine manner. He took the ground that
The outlook for the Taft nomination was
extremely good, and that he regarded il
as a practical certainty that Mr.. Taft
would be nominated. Il is asserted by
the Taft leaders that Mr.. Taft has been
getting some substantial additions TO his
following from the members OF the Sen
ate.
The Washington times., 1908-03-11
VETERAN FOUND ILL;
IS RETURNED TO HOME

James Marshall. sevehty-eight years
old. an inmate OF the Soldiers home,
who had been missing since yesterday,
was found early this morning in the Vi
ciuity OF the Benning race track.
The aged man was suffering from eN-
haustion, and was taken to the Casu-
atty Hospital in a police ambulance.
Later he was taken to the home.
The Washington times., 1908-03-11
BOLD EAGLE ATTACKS GIRL;
TERRIER HURT IN FIGHT

POTTSTOWN, March 11.-Attacked by
a large bald eagle, Carrie E. Upde-
grove, thirteen-y ear-old daughter of
George IIpdegroYe. OF North Coventry,
had a narrow escape from death. She
had gone to the wagon house. when the
eagle swooped down upon her. She hur-
riedly ran Inside and escaped.
a fox terrier standing near by was
badly injured. The eagle sank its talOns
into the animals back.
The Washington times., 1908-03-11
STEPHEN B. SMITH ILL.

Stephen p Smith. a retired farmer OF
Faquier county. Va. is seriously I'll in
his home Hilton" near The Plains.
The Washington times., 1908-03-11

foc BELTS-Childran'S Patent Leather Belts
the popular Buster Brown styles With dip front
and large nickel harness Buckles. Choice OF 4 n
red or white. Made Of jJuble-faced patent Ekk(
leather. Regular price, &C. Tomorrow at....... ~
The Washington times., 1908-03-11

Dop'l be "out" 20 all OF Times want
ads that "cail on you"-or you'll be
'oat OF pocket"
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1908-07-26

cipal street welcomed 1.-The Hero Of
New Orleans" veterans of the civil war
in the army blue were on every hand
We were delighted with our chiefs
reception. when. to our establishment,
a procession, headed by band of mu-
sicians playing Marching Through
Georgia" filed into the square opposite
the railway station. Just in the rear of
the band were two stalwart standard
bearers. each carrying a huge silver
spoon at least ten feet above the heads
of the crowd. We were all aghaSt and
expected the general to be very indig-
nant, when he burst into the heartiest
laugh we had heard from him during
the campaign. Good said he. Cap
ital."
No candidate for the presidency or
any other office was ever greeted with
such proof of the hatred of his logical
enemies.
Straw Vote Born.
1t was during the peoples party
campaign that the now time-worn
straw vote story was born. A pencil
fiend. after carefully canvassing a
Pullman car express loaded with silk
stockings" came upon section hard
going through to the next water tank.
The knight of the pick was seated in
the end of the combination smoker
when approached by the seeker of po-
litical forecast information.
MY good. man." said the canvasser,
whom do you intend to vote for next
November"
"Who will 1 vote for? Why. Cleve-
| land. of course. Who else would / vote
for?"
Why" said the pest. II have been
through this entire train. and you are
the only man on the train who will not
vote for Blaine"
Have We? Well. to HI with this
train. You wait till the gravel train
comes along and see who they'll vote
| for"
And it was the gravel train that de-
livered the goods for the Buffalo can
| didate. but they never considered Gen
| eral Butler as a serious proposition and
consequently did not vote for him.