The Guthrie daily leader. [volume] (Guthrie, Okla.) 1893-1996, 1908-03-31

had been opened by the grand jury
as they believed Illegally We. your
minority wish to report that there
never was an evidence before this
c0mmitteCt5 or Subcommittee - s.i,sw
what boxea had been opened by said
Grand jury,-and for these reasons we
Recommend that w. IT, r. Allen be
allowed TO retain his seat as member
Of this House believing him to be
the duly elected Representative from
Alfalfa county
BOYLE,
WILSON.
SANDS,
Cf4APPELL.
Mr. Tiloltson moved "That the aft
davits submitted by the minority e.
port of the Committee on Privileges
and Elections be read and that Mr.
Ghappell be permitted to read same "a
his argument in connection with this
contest
Mr. Whitehurst moved to table The
motion to table lost by the following
vote.
Ayes-Anthony Ballard, Beck But.
Ter, Briggs, Brown, Bryan. Carson.
Casteel, Cope, Durant burst, Faulkner.
ilAtilot ilditl0OI wi fiUEHtSI4 IadIIt
Hawkins, Hendrickson. Hudson. JapD.
Jarrett Jesse, Johnson. Lindsey, Lon.
don Martin Murdoch McCalla, McFI.
haney. Paschal. Pendefsraft Rainey.
Reeve, Riddle Rider. Skeen Smith (of
Delawarel, Stettmund, Tandy, Vande-
venter, Whitehurst Williams (0f
.Comanche Mr.. Speaker Murray
Total--43
Nays Abbott. Armstrong tof Choe.
taw). Armstrong (of Kiowa). Ashby.
Baldwin, Boyle, Branson, ChaDpell.
Crouch Day. Deyerle, Earle. Earley,
Ellis Evans Ezzard ERASER. Harrisln
(of McCurtain), Hobby Holland. Hut
dleston. Jones, Lockwood. Manus.
Moore McAdoo. McCants. Norvell.
IO'Neal, Porter, Ratliff. Ross, Sands.
shearer Sherman Smith tof Dewey.
Smith (of Custer), Smith (of Wash
ital Snelson. Stagner, Stivers, Stone.
Swengle Tabor Tiloltson Utterback,
Vandaveer Watrous. Williams (of
Pushmataha) Wilson
Total-50,
Absent II Allen Cor sequoyahj
Banks. Bo@dre. Broom. Chastain, Dur
ham. Fisher King Oreutt Putnam,
Smith (of Grant, Stevens, Turner
Vortman. Whitson.
Total-l5.
Not voting Allen (of Alfaifa).
Mr. Bryan moved as substitute
for the Tiloltso motion THAT all testi.
money taken officially in this ease ns
read before this House and considered
in the case"
The Bryan motion lost by the fol-
lowing vote:
Ayes-Anthony Armstrong (of Choc
taw) Ballard Beck Briggs. Brown
Bryan. Bntler Carson Casteel COpe
Deyerle Durant burst Faulkner IIar
ris, Harrison tof Hughes, Hart. Haw-
kins, Hendriokson, ltudson yapp Jar
rett Jesse, Johnson Lindsey London
Martin, Murdoch, McCalla, MsElhaney
Paschal. PendergTaft Rainey, Reeve
Riddle Rider. Ross Skeen Smith (of
Delaware). Stettmund Tandy Vande.
yenter, Whitehurst, Whitson, Val.
liams Of Comanche). Mr.. Speaker
Murray
Total-47
Nays-Abbott. Armstrong (of Kio-
wa). Ashby, Baldwin, Boyle, Branson,
Chappell Crouch Day Earle Farley El-
lis Evans, Ezzard, Fraser, Harrison COT
McCurtain), Hobby, Holland, Huddles-
ton Jones Lockwood Manus, Moore,
McCants, Norvell Smith (of Cnsterl.
Smith (of Dewey, Smith (of Wash.
ita), Snelson, Stagner. Stiyers, Stone.
Swengle. Tabor Tillotson. Utterbaels
Vandaveer. Watrous. Williams (of
Pushmataha) Wilson.
Total-47
] Absent - Allen (of Sequ0yah}.
I Itas.lc
ham. Fisher. King Oreutt Putnam,
Smith (of GranO Stevens, Turner,
Workman
/ Total--14
Not voting-Allen tof Alfalfa.
Total-l
The question the REQUIRED upon the
motion of TillotsOn which motion pre-.
vailed by the following vote:
Ayes-Abbott. Armstrong (of Choc.
taw), Armstrong (0f Kiowa). Ashby,
Baldwin. Boyle, Branson. Chappeil
! Crouch. Day, Deyerle. Earle, Ear.eY.
Ellis Evans. Ezzard, Fraser Harrison
(of McCurtain) Hobby Psiiand. Hnd-
dleston, Jones, Lockwood, Manus. Me-
Adoo. Moore, McCalds, Norvell ONE 4
Porter. Ratlif Sands Shearer Sher
man. Smith Cof Dewey, Smilh (os
CUSTER, Smith tof Washltal, Snelson.
Stagner, suvers, SCSne. Swengle Ta-
bor Tilolison, Utterbaek. Vandavees.
Vandeyenter, Watrous. Williams (oi
Pgshmataha) Wilson.
Total-5O.
Nays Anthony Ballard. Beck,
Briggs. Brown, Bryan, Butler, Carson.
Casteel Cope Durant burst Faulkner
Harris, Harrison (of Huebes) Hart,
Hawkins, Hendrickson, Hudson. Japn.
Jarrett, Jesse Johnson Lindsey. Lon.
don. Martin. Murdoch, MeAdoo. Mccall.
la, McElhaney. O'Neal, l'aschal P0r-
ter, Pendergrait, Ratllff. Rainey.
Reeve. Riddle, Rider. Ross. Sands.
Shearer Sherman. Skeen. Smith Of
Delaware. Ststimund. Tandy. White.
hurst. Whitson. Williams Of Comanche.
Mr. Speaker Murray.
Total-44.
Absent Allen (of sequoyahl.
Banks. Bowdre Broome. chaafain.
Durham. Fisher King. Orcutt. Putnam.
Smith (of Grant,. Stevens. Turner.
Workman,
1otal-l4
Not voting Allen (oi Alfalfa
! Total