New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1908-11-28
GOLF FAVORITES WIN
DOUGLAS GETS A SCARE.
Robbins Forces Him to Play Extra
Hole at LakezcOOd.
rRv Tsler-aph % n r-fsun..


Lakewood y =. Nov. Z7-Fzv0rfres survived
the first and second rounds az match play IN ths
open golf tournament ar the Country Club %
Lakewood to-day. and the four who earned their
places in the seminal bracket for The chief CUP
were all metropolitan district aruareurs-J P.
Knapp and Fred Herreshoa. OF Garden Cgty:
Findlay : Douglas. Nassau and Paul Waterman.
Englewood- They VII meet named to-rn0rr9vv-
In addition 70 match play IN four divisions
consolation handicap for a cup presented by ira
Those defeated in the first round as vel as rhs
non-quaihers we're eligible and H 5 Jennings.
Of Garden City. with card Of so-l2-7s
AS IS frequently the way. Iare starters figure n
close matches such the case with P s P
Randolph and D " Taylor Of the home club.
who bracketed az the bottom o. the fourth
sixteen When they finished ali square on the
home green darkness overlook them. and further
play was postponed by mutual agreement until
to-day
Several extra hole matches marked TIRE Efforts
OF the contestants in the various divisions One
Of these IN the first set had Douglas and Arden
" Robbins. OF Garden CITY. principals They
were never more than a hole apart. being al
square az the eighth and the sixteenth and Doug
las stood dornie I on the eighteenth tee. only
have Robbins square accounts with a 4 for the
home hole The former national champion then
on the nineteenth green
J. P Knapp. another Garden city man. rad Al
easy tine in the morning. as John Reid. r.. who
led the field in the qualifying round rad % re-
turn the city and dsfauIted- Herreshofr won
quite handiIy from Merrill X Waters. OF the hons
club. BY up and % play The former went oUr
in &c. when he stod Up. and par figures FOR the
next i've holes left him winner b Up and 70
play.
Later in the day Herreshof defeated Walter
Snedley. OF Atlantic City The former struck .
great pace n foUr-ball match thursday a1IsE>
noon going cut n IS and back "a FOR =
stroke better than the amateur record for rns
links
The summary OF the play today follows.
First sixteen ,arst round,-J- P Knapp. Garden C-y
ningz Nassau 6ea- Jasper Lynch. LazsUoot 2 y 15a
10 play. Waiter suledlsy. Atlantic CRY osaS =, y
Ksndan Deal ~ and % P 715. 90 s7 "a
play. Howard r whitney Nassau, oea5 Iheo11o-s
Iaseaeer Csaaq ~ 15 n Ro5sins cIa-5en 61ry
tle hoiesl. Pau Nat-rTa7 80 "a 1-S1
beat J G Batteson lakewood. ID 1s Hoeza- -
Second round-AnapD 6ear J=a1ings : % 90 - go
P lay, 5e2 VlbSeJ % and . 6lay watzzaa
Second sixteen zrst rouna-G- ssg5t Lakszood 0e4s
Parish r. shinnecocS 6eat a sou+aeriaat 1rsie-
= G Brunei Rie5naona county uD Mss%seag.
3 s Bottone Fox HIS. bsa. 9 z F. NsCa5n Erie
good " 1nd . y 2ay ~ aaa . 7ay Z 4
EoEres' Psiaaei2hia bsas 5s5aasi sat : fss
ssco6d r5und-scor, seat Pa--+sa. g2 z aoIssa;
snare McSweery. azd % PLAY go "a 60
Boltons and 70 pay- Forest 0eaI Hoo0er' Cd
an Thit q sixteen carzt rounHary MasE-y Atlantic
NcC7ure Albany. bsat ? @ Robbins. Atlantic
CITY up s9 a9a 70 Forest Hill beat c GEnsts
"XzasZ' s III Sa Rt4zs9ood beat : G Pznd=-eurd-
"4E u Ysss 2 Fox His G. Fraser. Ls-
= C,1+Is- lakewood beat Heller Forest H. -
water Wilson EngIevood- beat James A ISns- Bal
t1srol. up and 70 pa5 -. - - -,..h.,-4
Brown. Philadelphia Non -IlI-, u b 1--
son shtnrecock by default - - -,
Philips. A-3lena1y "a
- , ria beat Brown 8 I'D ard .
70 E9a4rH sixteen FIRST rount-E Z 7ls7v-l 17nrciA-
rsar Rfve-rou. a and 3 . pay
FOX EIius beat ? = Pni1lsl E1zaoer--
: Condor vykagyL bea- z 2 N-ClsilaH- Fox
4s@ 20 FOX FIIls bea. :. z Fase-. Richmond
cogn' sP 1sa F,v---on beat q Fa--eI Laksvood-
p aad srs e Nassau beat c Johnson Fox Hf1A
p end z 951sofph. Philadelphia beat .. : wr4rs.
Lakewood u ard ! % play - 7--s.-.-
. U TAYLOR. LakeToo-- Won TON - "A ''-----7'F
lakewood BY default , -
r575o1 bear Hardy. u and 70 play sLsvsns 90
Busch. and 1 70 play- Hlaraol2h ana -@s1o' I'LL