The Hawaiian gazette., 1908-11-03
An Open Letter to-
~
the Voters Of Oahu
Continued from Page one.) '

Continued one)
Kinney, can't be- believe it possible that
Cahca standing and with the recommendation that ne OOus "
me- ca be guilty of such a thing n.
coLBuRNs APPEARANCE EVIDENCE OF TRUTH.
Mr. kinney replied hotfoot
chcat with his out and trembling from
demand would have believed that he tcONur was
heard nothing more of and
statement made by Mr. Kinney gave Mr. caA the benefit of the
doubt 4 i41 sst'e.i'5
THE ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS IN CIVIC sT CHARGE AGAINST (.
Upon the regnng General
telephone asking his
there whereupon Governor Dole said to me:
appointing Mr. cathcart to the
position Knowing that acquainted with him.
want if know anything against him. or of any reason why
] replied q know nothing of my knowledge Il
Mr. then sad Have you heard anything against hmi
Mr. Dole said: .lwhat have you heard,o
which had previously had
with Mr. Kinney concerning Kapolani Estate matter
A. M. BROWNS STATEMENT. 1T
still Arthur NJ Brown was usheed
nto rooms a seat close by u.s. ~
appointment and in the Of the conversation said: M
be to the Office That is your feeling is it
Mr. Browns
Mr.. Dole cAnlingworh the opnoni
whether Mr. chilngwoh was present at
thought Dole he does not remember
chngworh that he not but made statement to
Mr.. concerning Cathcar, Waikiki, E
confidence in Mr. catheart but as did not
Cathcart the benefit of the doubt
Does failing appoint him Mr. Cath
cart resigned his office Of deputy
cahca presented support of them He
not holding any Office paid particular having
responsibility in the matter.
ELECTION OF TWO YEARS AGO
question knowing of these things did not op
proof him. cobu charge mans word against
crcumanal evidence Mr. Brown was
supporting election there to expect
from him. the Advertiser was then vigorously opposing Brown
election.
was in position any opposition cathcar
election had wanted to- and although shaken my confidence
In him, Iwastir unconvncd that he corrupt
CONDEMNED OUT OF HIS OWN MOUTH
In January February election AT
in Washington Mr. Cahcar being
called and the course of the
and its editor toward him. saying tina
unfn Cathcart did not deserve at their hands, tina
entitled to their support
asked what by saying
Mr. said
when that Royis Grand Jury and Judg
against him9,
replied 81 do"
CONFESSED TO FIXING" AN INDICTMENT
all that could head off tina
believing malicious without foundation and whe
and the Grand Jury directed me to draw al
fatally defective and would hav
if conviction had taken place
Cathcart Did this at Walter g. Smiths request
y of what ddf'
replied nothing told him
telling that will know that it should not lie tn
houth of Mr. Smith to me'
was asounded
part violated his oath AHOr
deliberate viang the Indictment and the will of the Gran
whom he Individually thought ought not
indicted.
Immediately upon would do this could b
ty doing things with which he had been charged
aforementioned Indictment came to ra
Dole having become convinced that was without foundation
Isonaly nolprosed it,
INCREASED SUSPICION OF cATHcART.
discussed tn
b Walter Smith that Mr. Catht
ton in office growing and more suspicious that he was frequent
stories that he could not reconcile with Mr. chea honesty
Smith of the statement made by cathcart to He wa
that he had had nnton before that Nj
such thing. res
information which Mr. Smith caused no variation IN his