davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The Washington herald., 1907-11-19
Majestic-asiCn OF the Four,

The study of crime and its apprehen-
sion has ever been an attractive field to
the novelist and playwright The name Of
Conan Doyle stands foremost in such lit
erature, and his hero. Sherlock Holmes.
will doubtless live for many generations.
The announcement that the Purnell Com
pany was to produce sign of the Four, ."
a drama based upon the Doyle book. was
sufi1cient TO draw a large audience 10
the opening performance The result OF
their labors is difficult to pass upon. At
ter so splendid piece as Nell Gwynne"
one Is apt TO be over critical. OF course
every interest centers about the person.
The Washington herald., 1907-11-19

cessfUl a character actor as Gillette, Mr.
Munnel had no end of a task. His work
was conscientious and won applause
from his hearers. Miss Purnell. as Mary.
has so little 20 do that she was unable to
distinguish herself. The feminine honors
belong to Miss Deshon. who was most
capable as Mrs ShOlto. Mr. Murphy
again made love 10 Miss Hyle. and both
came through the ordeal creditably. Mr..
Pickens beamed from wikhin very much
OF a blue uniform, and only occasionally
misbehaved- We believe he IS reforming.
The Tonga OF Mr.. Redding was a clever
character bit. Between the acts Mr..
Bewley yielded to HIS desire 10 be funny
AT the expense Of good taste. Songs sucn
as his should not be allowed at this
house, or any other.
The Washington herald., 1907-11-19

/ from pretty. is in filthy rags, and her
face is all cut and bleeding
1t is on par with the rest of the con-
struction Of this play that In the second
act. eight months later Houston Street
Moll should make her appearance in
virginia. white. II is only a few DAYS
until the wedding of Miss Thompson and
Douglas Aines, her secretary. but the
man makes love 10 Mol and tries TO
kiss her, and Miss Thompson catches
them The man puts the blame on Mol.
and she is about to be condemned when
she begs for one more chance. and asks
Miss Thompson 10 come and see her at
the next evening. Then she makes
an appointment with Aines, and he
agrees to come. This is MOlIs self
flee; she is going TO convince Miss
Thompson that the man she loves is un-
worthy of her. In the meantime. Moll
has become engaged to the red-faced bar
tender.
The third act is IN MoH's room. Con-
spicuous among the furniture is a large
picture Of the Madonna Here comes
Aines and Miss Thompson, but she does
not get there until Bill HubbelI. the bar
tender. has caught Mol and Aines kiss
ing. Then there is another fight-sensa-
uonai this, for the lamp is smashed.
though no one is hurt. Aines is con-
demned: MoI is condemned. She picks
up bottle Of whisky and cries:
Me fer the booze, good old soak. a fight in the
street. and don't care where | 1nisht 20
Then she catches sight OF the Madon-
ma picture, and the curtain finds her
falling dramatically on her knees before
IL.
The last act sees everything straight
ened out Every one believes thai Mon
acted for the best, and the bartender.
who has been drunk all night comes
staggering In and takes her in his arms
Beautiful story, isn't II? Inspiring in
tone' lofty in sentiment, ideal in concep-
ton. Ugh!
throughout the piece Miss Walsh has
some lines that give the tone and char
acter or the piece TO a nicely.
A swell chance got ter be happy. Oh. know
l kin easy get rid O myself"
You 70 to HI"
Not by a d sghtP'
! done me best and got it in the neck
The whole play is on par with these
characteristic sentences, only in the plav
the profanity is spelled out. not sug-
gested.
The central idea Of the fallen woman
trying TO save her benefactor from q bad
marriage by carrying on filtration with
the villain is, Of course. borrowed and
borrowed badly, from Pinero's '"The Cav
Lord QueX, only Pinero is too shrewd
a judge of human nature to make his
roue propose love TO an unattractive
and unWashed girl. The situations are
absurd, the characterization of the indI-
yiduals impossible; the dialogue. exceDt
Tor some bits of low comedy here and
there. is simply inane, where Il is not
positively vulgar.
one cannot judge of acting by seeing
players in such piece Miss Walsh got
all that could be got out of such a
character. Mr. Travers as Aines was as
and as much unlike a normal
human being as possible. Alma Kruger
as Miss Thompson was not bad, and Ina
Brooks as the spitfire Miss Ilanner
showed capabilities OF better things Mr.
The Washington herald., 1907-11-19
Chase's-PoIite vaudeville.

II would be difficult to arrange a better
bill than that presented at Chase's this
week William Courtleigh dished up
Peaches" Bessie Wynn served the
cream; Salerno passed the wine; the Ca
mile Comedy Trio and other talented per
formers furnished the fun. Peaches -
one OF the best sketches on the vaudeville
stage to-day-certainly far ahead of any
other seen here this seasons by George
Hobart, and was the comedy handed out
by the Lambs at recent 'gambol" The
plot revolves around a girl-"Peaches.' -
De 1t understood. is a girl, and of course
the center OF attraction. The lines are
bright and witty. the comedy scintilatine
ana clever situations predominate. AS
presented by William Courtleigh. an ac-
tor OF distinct ability. supported by a
company Of capable players, Peaches
pleased the palate and tasted like more
1t made decided hit. AS John Henry.
The Washington herald., 1907-11-19
RAILROAD CLOSES THEATER.
Takes the "Secret Orchard" Scenery
on TO Richmond

With carload of scenery for the Sc
cret Orchard" company at Richmond,
Va, the Belasco Theater was dark last
night. The company came from Phna-
delphia Sunday, and the car Of scenery
was attached 20 the same train.
When the car reached Washington Il
was dropped in the yards. and, owing
TO the congestion as a result of the
transfer to the New Union Station. this
car was inadvertently hitched to a South
ern train and taken TO Richmond. IT
was not until yesterday noon that its
absence was discovered, and il was then
TOO late to have it brought back for
last nights performance
The Belasco was practically sold out
last night. and among those who had
seats for the performance were the
Italian, Austro Hungarian. Russian. and
British Ambassadors and the Chinese
Minister The advance sale of seats has
been large, and il viii be difficult for
some Of the stockholders of last night
to have their tickets changed. The PLAY
VIII open here this evening.
The Washington herald., 1907-11-19
ARMY AND NAVY.
Army Orders.

Following changes IN Coros Of Engineers ordered:
Capt CLARKE 5. SMITH. from cuba 20 Yicks-
burg relieving Cart GEORGE NJ. HOFFMAN.
Second Lieut. CHARLES n ROCKWELL. from
engineer. school. Washington Barracks. % Ha-
Vans, for duty with companies Second Battalion
Of Engineers. now in Cuba.
First Lieut. LENyIS NJ ADAMS. from engineer
school. Washington Barracks 10 Pittsburg-
Capt SALMON T. DCTTON, coumissary. from
Chicago % san Francisco; thence 10 Philfprines
January ;, 1913. relieving Caps. WILLARD D.
NEWBlLL, euumlssaTy, who VIII proceed 20
San Francisco.
Capt WILLIAM r. GROVE. eonnissary. from 81
Louis % Military ACADEMY. relieving Capt
THOMAS FRANKLIN. canlmisSary Who VII
proceed 20 san trSnclsCus thence 20 PHILIPPINES
March 5. 1905. relieving MAJ. HUGH ]. GAL
LAGHER. commisszTy. who viii proceed 70 san
Francisco.
Recruits GEORGE H LONG. cavalry. and LAU-
RENEE BAILEY Coast A-tiT srv Cons f-nu,
recruit deTOt. Columbus Barracks. to General
Hospital. Washington Barracks for duty with
Company c. Hospital Corps.
Supervising and Examining Dental Surg JOHN H
HESS. from General Hospital. Preside Of san
Francisco. % Fort Lezreuwo-th.
ReslEnation Of Second Lieut. ERNEST STECKER
Philippine Scouts. accepted. 20 take effect De
cembeT =.
Sergt First-cIass DANIEL MILLEN. Hospital
Corps. from General Hospital Preside Of san
Francisco to depot Of recruits AID caSuals. Fort
,.----' ---le'lts setse- Alirs-CiaS> INA o
PHILLIPS. Hospital Corps who VIII proceed TO
the Philippines.
First Lieut. JAMES ". EYERINGTON. Twenty
sixth Infantry 10 General Hospital Presidio Of
San Francisco.
Capt MATTHEW c. BUTLER. Jr.. Seventh Car-
airy, 20 General Hospital Washington BarTaczs.
Recruit EDDIE SKINNER. cavalry. recruit depot.
Fort SlocUm. having enlisted under false p7e-
lenses. discharged without honor from the army.
Second Lieut.. ANDREW ". SMITH, transferred
from Ninth 10 Third Cavalry
Second Lieut.. JAMES I. WATLAND. transferred
from Third to Ninth Cavalry
Private John McHUGH. Hospital CorLs. Fort
WRdsWoTth. 10 Fort Lesvenvorth.
Post CommiSSary Sergt- JOHN KOTWALL. from
Philippines 20 Fort Huachnca
Post Commissary Sergt CHARLIE REDLINCi. from
san Francisco % Fort Logan
Post Comnaissary Sergt- FRANCIS WEBSTER.
from Camp Capt. John Smith, jamestown ExDo-
stion, 70 Fort Constitution.
The Washington herald., 1907-11-19

So low. Ocean breezes mlnglc with the
balmy atmosphere and keep the air fresh
and delightful the year round.
Cuba Is superior to and far better
for citrus fruits than Florida. and even
better than California. because of the alb
sence Of all danger Of frost In Florida
occurs with great damage to fruit trees:
but in Cuba, which IS located so much
farther south and in a tropical climate.
frost and the freezing Of fruit trees are
Unknown.
The Washington herald., 1907-11-19
The Lyeeum-BurIesque.

William 3. Watson. that joyful and
eccentric comedian. heads his own com
pany az the New Lyceum this week. The
burlesques are tuneful and are carried
through with A vim and dash. ''Krouse-
meyers Alley" the opening burletta, has
been seen here before, but was never
theless pleasing and diverting.
In the oliO Swan and Bambard. In an
eccentric comedy act, were well received
and the Bijou Trio gave a pleasing com
bination Of comedy and harmony.
"Krousemeyer's Christening" continua-
ton Of the first burletta. closed the per
fOrmance.
The Washington herald., 1907-11-19

Island Of Cuba; and is situated upon one
or the best macadam roads in the island.
which runs from Havana to the town and
bay of Madrid Havana is a most beauti
Iul city. and perhaps has more tourists
during the winter than any city in the
Western Hemisphere.
The entire I,I36. 52-acre tract is
beautiful rolling land. excellent, rich soil.
well drained, and having three streams
Of water running through it. No body OF
land better adapted for the culture Of
citrus fruits can be found on the island
or elsewhere
The Washington herald., 1907-11-19

Commander H. c. GEARING. detached navy
yard. Mare Island. November %. to naval sta
ton, Csvite.
Commander H. S KNAPP. detached War Caller.
70 West Virginia. as chief Of star.
Assistant Surgeon c. l. WICKES, detached reCruit.
ing station, Kansas City. TO recruiting station.
Orraha-
BOa.sNain J. HE'LL detached Canonicrs home
anC wait orders
Gunnvr L. c. HULL. detached Indiana 70 Naval
Hospital. New Port Lyon. Colo, for treatment
Chief Carpenter c. S. KENDALL, detached navv
yard. Mare Island, TO Buffalo
Grief Carpenter W. W ToLES. TO navy vars
Mare Island.
Carpenter S. FLoATHE. detached Buffalo. home
wait orders
Warrant Machinist W. p. LITTLE. detached Pan
thez and continue Naval Hospital. New York.
MOVEMENTS OF VESSELS-The following move
ments Of vessels have been reported 70 the Bu.
Of Navigation:
Acknowledgements l6-Calfornia AT Brrnerton-
Wash: Saturn and Pinta. at Mare Islam! AZ
bany. at La Union. San Salvador. November II
Rainbow. Galveston, and Chattanooga. at Vlsdi-
vostok
seiled-NoTenber le-Sterling. from Portsmouth
\. H. for Lambert Point, Va. November II
oulrOs from Shanghai for Ningpo.
The Washington herald., 1907-11-19
COlumbIa-"Coming Thro, the Rre.n

COiumbia-"COminET ThrO' the Rye.u
The Rork company. which is presenting
George V. Hobarts musical comedy
Coming Thro' the Rye" has every rea-
son to be fiattered at the reception given
It's efforts al the Columbia Theater last
night In the first place. this one OF
many shows of this class comes without
big reputation, and also lacking the
usual galaxy Of headline favorites. While
some OF the ideas in Mr.. Hobarts book
are original, and a. Balwin Sloane's mu-
sic IS catchy, even though reminiscent.
the general tone of Coming Thro' the
Rye is not up TO two-thirds OF the
musical comedies seen recently. Vpon
the work OF Frank Lalor who as Mott
the tailor, has a role rich In cOmic3l
possibilities Of which he makes the most
depends very largely the success. Of the
show Mr.. LalOT has not been~in Wash
ingtOn since he made us laugh at s.Tbe
Show Girl, but he is pleasantly remem-
bered as a naturally gifted comedian.
one who gains his laughs through Quiet
and legitimate methods. His song
Clancy is one of the most telling
bits in Coming ThrO' the Rye" and II
Must BE Love" was also cleverly sung.
MI Toler and a chorus rendered the
very effective ''MoOlharri" song. which
was often redemanded. Miss loves
singing Of My Broncho Boy from the
saddle OF a miik-white horse was 2
charming bit Of stage business.
Miss Sallie Stembler, although burdened
with the conventional Mrs. Malaprop role
is the most engaging personality OF the
feminine contingent. She has a fresh
roliicking humor that takes very well in
the character of breezy nouveau richie
Miss Eveleen Dunmore, as LoIeta. a
model; Miss Harvey. as Countess Chris
tiana; Mr.. Harry Burgess, as William
Cactus Claude, cowboy; Vincent Mac
Carthy. as Spayce. a press agent, and
Fred Tiden. as Lord Battersea. com
pleted the cast of actors OF as diversi-
fed collection of characters as even
musical comedy may produce. and Com
Ing Thro' the Rye" stands pretty stead
lily upon a foundation of good fun and
whistleable music. IT Is a performance
calculated to give dull care an off night.
The Washington herald., 1907-11-19

Maj. W. c. NEVILLE. to command marine bar
Taeks. nSvy yard. Washington D. C.
Lient- Col GEORGE BARNETT, detached cor,.
mand q marine barracks. navy Yard. Washing
ION, ID. C., report in person to the brigzdier
general, conlmandant-
First Lieut. WALTER \. HILL, detached marine
barracks. navy yard. Norfolk, Va, 20 duty with
First Prov. Regiment Z. S. Marines. Cuba.
The Washington herald., 1907-11-19

Thomas p. Cleaves. clerk OF the Sen
ate Committee Appropriations Who has been IN
tor scne weeks past. has received visit from his
land Ne
The Washington herald., 1907-11-19

We have all the advantages Of
shipment and transportation that can be
coast Of the Island OF Cuba, and right at
the beautiful harbor ana bay Of Mariel.
only thirty-fve miles from the city Of
Havana, with steam and electric lines
and a short water route 10 Havana. We
also have much cheaper freight rate to
fornia, and several days shorter tine In
getting fruit products 70 market
The Washington herald., 1907-11-19
CARS TO KENSlNcToN

Cars from 18th s. md y. Y. aEs. every Is min
Pass Rock Greek BTidge and PARK. main entrance
Zoo and Country Club TO Chevy Chase Lake Con-
meet with Hsnsington cars Round trfp ticSsts.
Sc ct FuSselfa
The Washington herald., 1907-11-19

Howard as the bartender did some good
character work. and Jesse Ralph as Mrs.
F1nnerty carried of the comedy A very
well done little bit was the servant of
William Wadsworth.
But no acting could make such a play
as this worth while. If il We're better
done, little bit better in construction. il
might be vicious; as it is. it is simply
vulgar
FROM Thursday night on Miss Walsh
VIII play The KreUtzer Sonata"
HECTOR FULLER
The Washington herald., 1907-11-19

For Mt. Vernon, Alexandra. and
Arlington, Washington, Alexandria
& MtVeTnon Ry. Sta, I2th& Pa. av.
TRAINS FOR Mt. VERNON OyEEK DAYS.,
10. II A. NJ. Il NOON. l AND Pm
TRAINS FOR ALEXANDRIA AND AIRING
Ton DAILYl EVERY % MINUTES.
The Washington herald., 1907-11-19
...t Service TO CALIFORNIA
ARIZONA. NEW SrExICo A~D rrx,S

AkIZ0AA, NEW MEXICO. AND TEXAS.
HiSh-elsss Standard Equipment also moss modern
Tourist Sieeping Cans Personally Conducted Withour
ChAnge- BERTH. So Rates and steamer ressrFa-
tons 70 japan. China the Philippines ard Around
The World A J. POSrON. (5enl. Asent 81 Pena.
Ave \. W, 9o5 18th ST. \. "
The Washington herald., 1907-11-19

We have secured LI36.52 acres
OF the best land in the Island OF Cuba. Of
which 1890 acres will be planted i'm PINE
APPLES, lemons. GRAPEFRUIT. and
ORANGES; 800 acres in PineappIes. coo
acres in Lemons, 2o0 acres in Grapefruit.
and 200 acres in Oranges. Our object is to
hold. develop. and improve said land and
to market the fruit products therefrom
for the large profits in the business.
The land is located about thirty
five (55) miles west of the city Of Havana.
on the north coast OF Cuba, in the Dis
trict Of Mariel, Province Of Pinar del Rio,
Palestine daily herald. [volume] (Palestine, Tex.) 1902-1949, 1907-08-16

Sd, "Rexall" Remedies are sold at
low prices because they are free from
heavy manufacturing charges, jobbing
profits, and the heavy expense of being
advertised separately, as formerly.
Palestine daily herald. [volume] (Palestine, Tex.) 1902-1949, 1907-08-16
SPECIAL CHURCH NOTICE.

We expect to continue our meeting
at Pleasant Grove until next Sunday.
After the IL o'clock service we will
then move over to Lone Pine and con-
tinue few days there. Will begin
the meeting at Shaid's Chapel next
Thursday night, instead of the night
before. as previously announced.
The third quartely conference will
be held at Shaid's Chapel on the
fourth Saturday and Sunday before.
We earnestly urge all the official
members to attend, as there will be
some very important business to
transact this time.
The meeting will be protracted after
the quarterly conference. Invite your
friends and relatives to attend.
] wish also to announce that Bro.
Campbell of Jacksonville will preach
next Sunday at Neches at IL o'clock
and at night We hope our people
there will give him a good audience.
w. w. HORNER, Pastor.
Palestine daily herald. [volume] (Palestine, Tex.) 1902-1949, 1907-08-16
POINTED PARAGRAPHS.

Even a deaf man can hear money
talk.
Sunshine of happiness is not a
freckle producer
There are times when very little
is more than enough.
How easy il is to suggest a remedy
for other peoples ills.
If you have anything to say to a
mule, say il TO his face.
And the bottom of a cup of Joy is
seldom far from the top
Fortunately for the average man
his brains are not on exhibition.
With some people trying TO make
both ends meet is an endless task
Tempted and tried, won and tied
then divorce proceedings and alli-
mony.
An ideal woman is one we fire.
quently hear about but seldom see
about.
There's nothing like a little broth.
er for taking the conceit out of a
pretty girl.
Why is il that a married woman sell
dom has any use for a pretty female
servant
Fortune knocks but once at a mans
door Misfortune knocks early and Of
ten.
A little learning is a dangerous
thing, but lot Of ignorance is still
more dangerous.
It's time to stand from under when
the man who knows it all starts to
tell you all he knows
One thing that makes a man admire
a woman is his inability to guess what
she will do next
Lots Of people who have opinions
but not convictions ought to be con-
victed for having such opinions
Marriage is sometimes a failure be-
cause man is unable TO think of the
right excuse at the right time
Palestine daily herald. [volume] (Palestine, Tex.) 1902-1949, 1907-08-16
FOR CATARRH = MUCU-TONE

The chief ingredients of Mucu-Tone are
Gentian, Cubebs, Cascara Sagrada, Glycerine,
and Sarsaparilla.
Gentian is recognized in medicine as one
of the greatest tones ever discovered. 1t is
the foundation on which Mucu-rone is built.
Gentian combines in high degree the tonic
powers of all the known bitters,' with none
of the disadvantages applying to them.
Cubebs have long been recognized as
specific in the treatment Of all catarrhal condi-
tons. Its action is prompt and its benefit
almost invariable. In whatever part Of the
body the infamed or diseased condition of the
mucous membrane exists, the use of Cubebs
has been recommended by the best physicians
for many generations.
Cascara Sagrada is especially introduced for
its necessary laxative properties.
The combination Of these with Glycerine
and Sarsaparilla makes Mucu-Tone n remedy
that attacks catarrh from every point. gradu-
ally restores and rebuilds the diseased tissues
TO their former health and strength, promotes
digestion and creates a normal appetite.
Bottle, soc.
Palestine daily herald. [volume] (Palestine, Tex.) 1902-1949, 1907-08-16
COTTON eINNERs, ATTENTION.
Texas Bureau of Cotton Statistics.

The Thirtieth Legislature passed a
law creating Bureau of Cotton Sta
tistics in the Department of Agricui-
ture The object of this Bureau is
directly to benefit the cotton grower
by furnishing accurate information in
regard to the condition of the Texas
cotton crop during the period when
this crop is actually being marketed.
The fact that Texas produces one
third of the entire cotton crop of the
United States will at once show the
need of such a Bureau and the i'm
portance to the cotton grower of the
information to be furnished by it,
This information is to be based upon
actual figures whose accuracy is
sworn to. There is to be no guess
work or estimating about any part of
It.
The plan devised for the collection
of these statistics is as follows: Be
fore engaging in the business of pub
lie ginners, each ginner shall obtain
from the county clerk of the county in
which gin is located certificate
free OF cost showing that he has
taken the oath prescribed by this law.
The oath provides that the ginner
snail make correct reports 10 Ine COn-
missioner of Agriculture. The county
clerks are to send to the Commission
er of Agriculture the certificate num-
Der, name and postoffice address OF
each ginner that qualities. The Com
missioner of Agriculture shall send to
each ginner blanks and envelopes for
the official cotton report. The ginners
shall make their reports between the
1st and Bird of each month. On the
Sth of each month the Commissioner
of Agriculture shall open and compile
these reports in the presence Of three
witnesses, appointed by the governor
for this particular purpose. The re-
suit shall be published at eleven
o'clock a. m. on the ninth of each
month. The law places a severe pen
atty upon all ginners who fail to COM
ply with its provisions.
Palestine daily herald. [volume] (Palestine, Tex.) 1902-1949, 1907-08-16
FINED UNDER NEW LAW.
Two Men Pay ss4.5o Each For Drink
ing Liquor on Passenger Train.

Hillsboro, Texas, Aug. 14.-Special
Officer J. A. Jones, in the detective
service Of the Missouri, Kansas G.
-'fcxss fsfways- 1pany, arTesred two
men on a south bound passenger
train on the road named, between Fit
Worth and here, for violating the new
law which prohibits drinking intoxi-
eating liquors on passenger trains.
They were placed in Jail here over
night and this morning pleaded guilty
to the charges, also of drunkenness,
and fines were assessed aggregating,
together with the costs, $3450 for
each. Failing to make payment, they
were Teeommitted TO jail.
Palestine daily herald. [volume] (Palestine, Tex.) 1902-1949, 1907-08-16
DALLAS TRAGEDY.
James S. Williams Shot and Killed
Sam L. Parham Arrested.

Dallas, Texas, Aug. Thames S.
Williams was shot and instantly kill
ed this afternoon at 1:20 o'clock in
the Postoffice flats on Commerce and
Ervay streets. Three wounds from a
3S-caliber pistol were inflicted. Four
shots were fired. The body was sent
to Hillsboro tonight on instructions
from his father, s. S. Williams. He
was % years old. A shot struck him in
the mouth, the ball coming ont at the
back of the neck Another was in the
back and the third in the left side
Sam L. Parham was arrested and
an affidavit made against him charg-
ing murder.
Palestine daily herald. [volume] (Palestine, Tex.) 1902-1949, 1907-08-16
Men Past sixty In Dancer.

More than half OF mankind over
sixty years of age suffer from kidney
and bladder disorders, usually enlarge
ment of PROSTATE glands. This is both
painful and dangerous, and Foley's
Kidney Cure should be taken at the
first sign of danger, as it corrects ir-
rcgularitics and has cured many old
Palestine daily herald. [volume] (Palestine, Tex.) 1902-1949, 1907-08-16

which have been having q hard time
with the pure food aud milk situation
will have "A chance tD correct some Of
The abuses. The adultoHtion of milk
is punishable by a Jail sentence
The taking effect of the bin was
postponed until September ] in order
30 let some OF the merchants get rid
OF their stycks Uf goods which could