davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
Daily press. [volume] (Newport News, Va.) 1896-current, 1907-05-28
SCATH|AG ATTACK UPON
LODGE HOME BUFFETs
Rev. ". AsbuFy Christian Declares
That Institutions Do More
Harm Than Saloons.
5LiHEs INDIVIDUAL MEMBERS
INDIVIDUAL MEMBERS
Men Connected With Organization,
Says the Preacher, Are as Much
Saloon Keepers as the Man Who
Conducts an Open Bar-"PrIncipIe
Against Policy"

In Il sermon delivered before :,
large audience Sunday night Rev.
w. Asbury Christian, pastor OF the
Trinity Methodist church, made Il
scnthlng attack upon lodges which
conduct buffcts in their homes. He
declared that such organizations
were conducting social clubs under
the pale of responsibility. and were
taking young men into their midst on
the prctensc of fratcrnalism to sell
them liquor seven days In the week.
The speaker said that every mem
Der of such an organization was as
much saloon keeper us the man who
runs an open bar and that such
lodges or societies did more harm in
a community than any saloon, and
that The buffet feature of them, should
be abolished.
Principle against Policy" was the
subject of Rev. Mr.. Christians SCI.
mon. He said that, especially tho or.
flee holder should be guided by prin-
ciplc and not socallcd policy, which
compelled him to set his saids to the
varying brcczes of public opinion.
The speaker said that tho country
was to he congratulated upon the
TACT that principle and not policy nc
tuaicd It's chief executive In his Of
ficial acts, and declared that more
office holders of his stamp would
greatly aid tho nation.
Daily press. [volume] (Newport News, Va.) 1896-current, 1907-05-28
SEVENTY TARS DESERTED
FROM CRUISER ST. LOUIS
Ono-Tcnth Of Entire Crew Was Miss.
ING When Weasel Left Hampton
Roads. ..,r' $50

E.,,. .. b.
When the new United States pro.
tected cruiser ST Louis put to sea
from Hampton Roads Sunday for her
trip around Cape Horn to Marc Is
land. nearly onctenth OF her entire
crew had been posted in the ships
log as desertcrs. About 40 or tho
ships quota Of ESQ men had failed
to show up when the new cruiser
weighed anchor and 1t Will he nee.
essi,ry for recruits to be assigned to
her when she reaches Mare Island
navy yard.
Report has 1t that the assertions
resulted from dissatisfaction of tho
tars over tho strict discipline OF Com.
mander Nathaniel r. Usher, commands
er of the vessel
Most of tho assertions from the
ship occurred in Hampton Roads, but
IT is, understood that some of the
sseanien left her while she was recent
~ ut the New York navy yard.
Daily press. [volume] (Newport News, Va.) 1896-current, 1907-05-28
END OF MRS. M'kfNLEY
WAS CALM AND PEACEFUL
Passed from Life to Death Without
Visible Strussle-WllI Rest by
Husbands Side.

CANTON, OHIO, May 27-Mrs. VIII.
liam Mckinley passed from an uncon-
scious state into eternal sleep at her
homo at 1:05 o'clock yesterday after
noon. Her dissolution was without
tlnge of pain, without tho least strug.
gle, and void of any indication that
she knew of anything transpiring
about her.
with the exception Of short periods
of scmi'consciousness at three inter.
walls, She had been inscnsiblc since
last Tuesday. She showed such re.
markable vitality, however and the
stimnlants and concentrated nourlsh-
ment acted SO effectively that her dc
mise was prolonged nearly two days
In the hope against any probable
ground for hope that she might with.
stand tho attack and recover her
normal health.
All of Saturday night her watchers
expected death would occur. At
O'Clock Sunday morning 1t WAS
thought by her attendants for awhile
that dissolution had set In, but she
responded to treatment and rallied.
A ceasccss vigil was kept by rela.
tivcs and friends at her bedside, and
when She died there were near her
Mrs. Nj. G.. Barber, her sister; Mr.
M. G. Barber, Mrs. Luther Day. favor
ftc niece and namesake of Mrs. Nc
Kinley; Justice and Mrs. William r.
Day. Mrs. Duncan, sister of President
Mckinley; Drs, Portmap, Eyman and
Rixey, Secretary Cortelyou and tho
four attending nurses.
Secretary Cortclyou Is directing the
funeral arrangements. The funeral Is
to be ut tho Mckinley home at 2
O'Clock on Wednesday afternoon. 1t
is to be as simple as circumstances
Will allow. Although not yet definitely
stated, Dir. Buxton, pastor of Mrs. Nc
Rinley, will probably deliver the adj
dress. Other pastors, including DIR.
G. -. Manchester who delivered the
Mckinley Grafton and was Grand
Army of the Republic comrade of Nc.
Rinlcy, will probably assist.
The body of Mrs. Mckinley will he
placed in the receiving vault in West
Lawn Cemetery which now holds the
remains of her husband. Later both
bodies will be removed to tho Nc.
Kinloy mausoletm on Monument Hill.
President at Funeral.
Official steps are being taken to
have a suspension of business during
the funeral of Mrs Mckinley Wednes-
day afternoon. During the short stay
the President and cabinet members
and Vice President and Mrs. Fair.
banks, will be provided for at the
residence of Justice and Mrs. William
r. Day. whose residence is but three
doors from the Mckinley home. Spe.
cial precautions will lie taken for their
|safety.
Daily press. [volume] (Newport News, Va.) 1896-current, 1907-05-28
NEWS NOTES FROM
EXPOSITION GROUNDS
Another Large Crowd In Spite Of Bad
Weather-Prosress on Build.
ingc and Exhibits.

JAMESTOWN EXPOSITION, May
2I--'Thc attendance at the Exposi-
ton is growing steadily and there
was large attendance today In spite
of the unfavorable atmospheric con-
dltions. Many of the visitors today
had previously visited the Exposition,
and many expressed surprise at tho
wonderful progress which has been
made upon the buildings and exhibits.
The thousands of flags which rlii.-
ter from the staffs OH the Exposition
buildings were at half mast today,
Daily press. [volume] (Newport News, Va.) 1896-current, 1907-05-28
Them, and they will add much to the
beauty of the grounds.

Professor Goldsworthy gavean or.
gan recital in the Auditorium at 4
p. m. today. This was his first re-
cital here, and he was heard by a
large and enthusiastic audience. He
VIII be here for the remainder OF the
week, and those who hear him are
sure of rare musical treat.
Daily press. [volume] (Newport News, Va.) 1896-current, 1907-05-28
Entertainments Postnoned.

The entertainment which was 10
have been given by the Oscar Straus
Z Society In Y. NJ. II. A. hall tomorrow
night has been postponed until We'd
nesday night June IL, because or tho
death of Mrs. b, Grant, mother or A.
Grant. one OF the most active mem.
bers of the society.
Daily press. [volume] (Newport News, Va.) 1896-current, 1907-05-28

Rev. Mr.. Watkins has returned tc
Spartanhurg. S. c.. after n visit t.
his sister, Mrs. Mary c. Reynolds
on West avenue.
Daily press. [volume] (Newport News, Va.) 1896-current, 1907-05-28

Tho work on the Georgia building
is being rushed with all possible
speed. Every effort is being made
to have 1t completed by Georgia
Day." which is June 10. This build
Ing is Il replica of Bullock Hall,
Roswell, Georgia, tho home of the
mother of President Roosevelt.
Daily press. [volume] (Newport News, Va.) 1896-current, 1907-05-28

The West Virginia building will be
completed by Thursday. The furui-
ture and fixtures for this building
have already arrived, and the work
OF installing them will begin ut once.
This building is one Of the most beau
tiful to be seen On the grounds.
Daily press. [volume] (Newport News, Va.) 1896-current, 1907-05-28

The scent of roses pervades tho
breath of the girl that takes Hollis.
tiers Rocky Mountain Tea, Bright
eyes, red lips. good health follow its
use. 35 cents, Tea or Tablets. ]. C.
Gorsuch & Co.
Daily press. [volume] (Newport News, Va.) 1896-current, 1907-05-28

The concerts of Phinncy's band con
tinue to attract large crowds.
Daily press. [volume] (Newport News, Va.) 1896-current, 1907-05-28

Miss Mary O'Brien, eO6 Myrtle
Ave-, Brooklyn, N. Y, writes:
"Peruna cured me In five weeks
of cafarrf7 of the stomach, after
suffering for four years and DOCTOR
ing without effect. In common with
other grateful ones who have been
benefited by your discovery, say,
An hail to Pernna.
Mr.. IL. j. Henneman, Oakland, Neb.,
writes:
~ waited before writing to you about
my sickness, catarrh of the stomach,
which had over year ago.
"There were people who told me 1t
would not stay cured, but / am sure
that am cured, for 1 do not feel any
more i'll effects, have good appetite and
am getting fat.
$50 l am, and will say to all, am
cured for good.
II thank you for your kindness.
"PerGna Will be our house medicine
hereafter"
Catarrh of the stomach is also known
in common parlance as dyspepsia, gus
tritis and indigestion. No medicine will
be Of any permanent benefit except 1t
removes the catarrhal condition.
Nervous Debility.
Miss Irene Smith, 10 Minnesota Ave-,
Randle Highlands, Washing ton, d. G.,
writes:
"Peruna cured me Of catarrh Of the
head and stomach and nervous debility
from which l suffered for two years."
Daily press. [volume] (Newport News, Va.) 1896-current, 1907-05-28

The cadet corps of Marysville Col.
leSc and Fork Union Academy gave
battalion drills on Lee Parade today,
which were witnessed by large
| crowds.
The beautiful building of the Ne.
gro Exposition and Development Com
panN Is nearing completion. The side
walls are completed, but some of the
rool remains to be put on. When
completed this building will cost
approximately $4,000.
new jail building has been
erected on the northeast corner of the
grounds. and will soon be ready Tor
occupancy.
The Confederate reunion takes
place in Richmond May 30.31 and
June IL. A representative will In
Nite the veterans to visit the Exposi-
ton and 1t Is expected that some ten
thousand will come from Richmond
to see the Terccntcnnial. All of the
| state buildings are preparing to re.
ceivc their home veterans and famI-
lies.
Tho Mary Baldwin Alumnae Asso.
citation and the Colonial Danes will
DO at the Exposition June 4. and will
meet at the Inside Inn.
June the General Federation of
| Woman's Clubs will visit the EXposi.
ton. 500 strong, and meet at the inn.
juno Z the Women's National Press
Association ami the Pen Womens
League will meet, and National Press
Association has from June s to June
10.
June Ia the American Institute of
Homeopathy will bring $50 members.
The rain of SATURDAY night ami
Sunday had very beneficial effect
on the sod of Lee Parade. The grass
had become worn and showed signs
OF dying at several places on tho big
parade ground, but Monday, after the
rain, 1t all came up fresh and green
and looked as though there had not
been a drill on it for a week or
more.
Daily press. [volume] (Newport News, Va.) 1896-current, 1907-05-28

The exhibit of the st. Louis Educa
tional Society arrived today, and Will
be placed In the East Annex OF the
Auditorium.
Daily press. [volume] (Newport News, Va.) 1896-current, 1907-05-28

offices for rent in silsby Building
5-1S-12t.
Daily press. [volume] (Newport News, Va.) 1896-current, 1907-05-28

The large brick pcdcstals. over
twenty feet in height, which are be.
Ing erected in front of the Audito-
rum, are nearly completed. Large
flower pots will be placed on top III
Daily press. [volume] (Newport News, Va.) 1896-current, 1907-05-28

offices for rent In Silsby Building
6.1S-f2t.
Daily press. [volume] (Newport News, Va.) 1896-current, 1907-05-28
OBSERVATION-DISCLOSURES
sS SOrial-PeFsOHal ss

2-o0.aQQQ2QpQQ2QQL-QH-9RQQQQ-QQ
Mr.. L. f. bishop has gone to New
York on business.
Daily press. [volume] (Newport News, Va.) 1896-current, 1907-05-28

Offices for rent In sllsby Building.
5-1S-12t.
Daily press. [volume] (Newport News, Va.) 1896-current, 1907-05-28

Results are sure and swift,
Results are quick and lasting:
1t penetratcs the heart of disease.
That is what HOLSTERS Rocky
Mmountain Tea does.
j. c. Gorsuch & Co.
Daily press. [volume] (Newport News, Va.) 1896-current, 1907-05-28

Mrs. Mary Donnan Wilson, accom-.
panied by her granddaughter, little
Miss Alice Gayle. left yesterday Tor
Richmond, en- route to White Sulphur
Springs, where they will spend sew
cral months.
Miss Helen Grace Lcylandcr of this
city. VIII this evening receive her Ill.
plona and degree Of bachelor of Arts
from the Womnn's College. Richmond.
ut the commencement exercises which
VIII be held In the Richmond Academy
of Music.
Mr. l." A, Meyers has returned from
business trip to Winston. Salem,
N. G. pss.,.,..t..
Mrs. Stearnes and Mrs. Baskerville,
OF Salem, Va, are the guests of Mrs
b, Il. Stcarncs.
Daily press. [volume] (Newport News, Va.) 1896-current, 1907-05-28

The cadet corps of Marysville Col
iege and Fork Union Academy gave
battalion drills on Lee Parade today
winch were witnessed by larg,
crowds.
Daily press. [volume] (Newport News, Va.) 1896-current, 1907-05-28

Many exhibits for the -Prcsby.
terrain building have arrived. This
building is admirably located and
those in charge extend every courtesy
to visitors, a large number of whom
visited 1t today.
Daily press. [volume] (Newport News, Va.) 1896-current, 1907-05-28

William Mckinley, wife OF the mar
tyred President
completed by Thursday. The furni.
ture and fixtures for this building
have already arrived, and the work
This building is one of the most beau.
tifuI to be seen On the grounds.
Tho work on the Georgia building
is being rushed with all possible
speed Every effort is being made
TO have 1t completed by Georgia
Day." which is June 10. This buiId.
ROSWELL Georgia. tho home of the
iilother OIL fresluent Roosevelt.
Many eNniDts Tor the Pan-Prcsby-
terrain building have arrived. This
building Is admirably located and
.hose III charge extend every courtesy
10 Visitors. large number OF whom
Tho coo,,a So,,n c,,.
,no,,i coI ~ y, o nv, Saroilna hegi-
Inv viii No oro,'i p'oh uoiiii I
s eli, row ,ume s"s n1 =, al me EXpo-
rnn;,mont VIII " nc. 49,. ~ . ,t 4. ms
missnrv b,,t vii h ano 10 o"t u, co OH,
nim Ton, wa '''''' iiess III INC
rho vorm,rt c. .,,u,,. J.,
purn Food hm,,din@ e s uHa'n no IN tns
,,d,r Du''uihs was completed
Tho bu,Id,,r wh,c,, 8, ro,,
nv Tho TrnvnI,ors, pra,ou,i, s electeu
lion is noarinr comniottin'1 AS Hw'si,t
not ne onsti,, Ing :. 1ol,plet.ioii; While
Il ia newortboiess se vnr oi .nG sr0nhGs'
sjrnod md viii ha ~, ua. . ue'
comnlctcd pe''S "he''
MI,
10 S.>SeNu W tic otd'c Vi west
NlrSinla Is nearing completion 10
Daily press. [volume] (Newport News, Va.) 1896-current, 1907-05-28

as mark of respect for the late Mrs.
William Mckinley, wife of the mar
tyred President.
Daily press. [volume] (Newport News, Va.) 1896-current, 1907-05-28

The Second South Carolina Rcgi-
mcnt Col. ii. II. Thompson command
Ing. Will be encamped at the Expo
sition from June q to July z. This
regiment will not carry It's own COM
nissary but will have mess in the
Big Tent.
Daily press. [volume] (Newport News, Va.) 1896-current, 1907-05-28

Offices for rent in sllsby Building
Daily press. [volume] (Newport News, Va.) 1896-current, 1907-05-28

The Vermont State exhibit In the
Pure Food building was completed
today.
Daily press. [volume] (Newport News, Va.) 1896-current, 1907-05-28

Tho building which is being erected
by the Travellers Protective Associa-
ton is nearing completion. While
not ms costly as some of the other
buildings to he seen ON the grounds.
II Is nevertheless very artistically de.
signed and will be very pretty when
completed.
The pioneer express. [volume] (Pembina, Dakota [N.D.]) 1883-1928, 1907-02-01
THIEF BEHIND PORTRAIT.

Substituted His Eyes for Thos. il
the Picture and Made Rich Haul.
A Russian official named NJ. Lox.
tieff on returning home with his wife
.bout 2 o'clock in the morning was at
traeted by strange noise in the draw
ing room, as If chair had been
pushed. An examination by candle
light revealed nothing amiss, and a
search in the other rooms had tho
same result.
They returned to the drawing room,
where large portrait of Nine. Lok-
tieff's grandfather, in the uniform of
a Uhlan officer, was standing against
the wall. fhe young wife glanced at
the portrait and uttering a scream,
rushed from the room.
What's the matter?" asked her
husband, greatly surprised.
Il just thought the portrait was
looking at me with real eyes," an
swered the wife, who was trembling
violently
Her husband laughed at her child
ish fears. Half an hour passed before
Nine. Loktieff came to herself, and
then remembering that she had left
her purse in the drawing room with
e6 in it, she took candle and brave
ly entered the room in her search for
it. A wild Shrek followed. Her hus-
band rushed in and found his wife ly.
ing In dead faint on the floor. With
the cooks help he carried his wife to
bed. While he was nursing her he
told the cook to search the room
carefully, but she did not find any.
thing suspicious.
The next morning M. Loktieff, look
ing more closely at the portrait, found
that the eyes had been cut out and
the portrait had been moved little
from the wall. Further investigation
showed that many valuables were
missing. The thief had hidden him.
self, it seems, behind the portrait and
was watching the couple all the time
through the eyeholes of the portrait.
The pioneer express. [volume] (Pembina, Dakota [N.D.]) 1883-1928, 1907-02-01

she's yours nov, Aloysius Bralnlgi,wryvaj
yours now and forever !,
Does she K he stainmered, and
broke down. (! "a "A S.;:
II told her I'd tell ye. She fell, upon
her knees to hold me back, ana / told
her she was an imposter and she ran
away. Put on your hat, Mr.. Brang.
vyn. and escort me home 81 1 ls!.s
Aloysius obeyed, and on the way the
little Irish lady. walking demurely al
his side, looked up and asked him: Il
'Ye're quite sure ye love her? O.
"Yes," he answered and she said
afterward that she never hoped to see
again such a transfiguring smile -
nm quite sure of that"
'Stay here moment" said Belle,
ushering him. into her little dining
room. He heard the swift rustling Of
her skirts as she raced upstairs, and
even her excited cry Of "L!lian!" be-
fore the door Of the upper room closed
behind her.
There was pause which seemed
long to his impotence, but at last he
heard the rustic Of skirts again, and
in another instant Belle came in radi:
ant and alone. She called him by a
motion of the hand, and as he obeyec
the gesture she pointed to door.
In there"
He entered, and she stood before
him with both hands outstretched, he
eyes and lips and gesture one divin,
appeal.
Lillian" he asked her, Lillian, is
this true?"
"True?" she answered. True tina,
l love you? Oh, yes, dear Aloysius. ]
have loved you always"
He took her in his arms and she
grew to him in long tranced EN-.
brace. He kissed her on the forehea
as If to set seal there and looked into
the happy humid eyes.
"My beloved Is mine," she whis.
pered, "and l am his" Her beautiful
face ell afiame with bushes and her
eyes smiling through her tears, she
raised her lips to his.
(The End.)
The pioneer express. [volume] (Pembina, Dakota [N.D.]) 1883-1928, 1907-02-01
lnviaorate the Digestion.

To invigorate the digestion ana
stimulate the torpid liver and bowels
there is nothing 30 good az that old
family remedy, Brandreth Pills. which
has been in use for over century.
They cleanse the blood and impart new
vigor to the body. One or two every
night for q week will usually be all
that is required. For Constipation or
Dyspepsia, one or two taken every
night will afford great relief.
Brandreth's Pills are the same me
laxative tonic pill your grandparents
used and being purely vegetable are
adapted to every system.
Sold In every drug and medicine
store. either plain or sugar-eoated.
The pioneer express. [volume] (Pembina, Dakota [N.D.]) 1883-1928, 1907-02-01

II ibid / ever tell you about my great.
uncle who u II the pension bureau at
sWashingtony'' asked q mAtter-of-fact
individual Of his friend.
H His friend did not recall Any such
Information. mi, n, .asi 5S
H "He 10 90, coming next birthday
the mattsr6f.fact man won't on. ..FI61
been IN the bureau ever since All.
drew. jackson swore BY the Eternal"
Must Be pretty husky aS'' Fl
Slightly. He's never BEEN sick but
once since he got that Job
Fortunate old man M +,
"de scared mo nearly e. death
when he was sick. Caused me !
whole lot az trouble, besides.
II got wire from him that he
didn't expect 10 live and had writ.
ten. Same day I rot q letter IN which
he wrote that he had a LOT some.
where In Greenwood. Wanted me
to 60 over and look Il I'M. make nee.
essary preparations and await or
ders.
Z took q day OF. found the spot.
and told the man in charge to await
my phone message before he pre.
pared the grave. He misunderstood
me. The next day / got mes.
sage from him saving the grave was
ready.
Il waited several days and no It'd
ings came. All quiet on the Poto.
mac. Just about that time had a
2urry call to 60 to Buffalo. I ex.
pected to be back in "a hours. and
left instructions to cover the stu.
alton in case a corpse arrived be.
The pioneer express. [volume] (Pembina, Dakota [N.D.]) 1883-1928, 1907-02-01
Frank.

Miss Robinson Ito stranger Mt reccp-
tion)--Do you see that plain looking
girl over there? She has just got mar
ried. I'm sure wonder what her hus-
band married her for.
Il have no doubt he married her for
her money" REPLIED the stranger.
ooh, wouldn't think so badly of
him as that" said Miss Robinson.
"But ! ought to know" replied the
stranger, you see, am the man who
married her"
The pioneer express. [volume] (Pembina, Dakota [N.D.]) 1883-1928, 1907-02-01
MANY BELLIES AT CAPITAL.
Ethel Rooseveit's Debut Would Find
Her in Brilliant Company.

Like all the Roosevelts, Miss Ethel
rides beautifully. She used to have
a piebald pony. but now that she is
Miss Roosevelt she has q blooded
mare, Lady Dancer, on which she
often takes canter in the afternoon.
She can skate as we'll as ride, AMI
likes tennis immensely.
If Miss Roosevelt makes her debut
at the White House, which all feel
is only fair to her, she won't be with.
out experience. She has played the
hostess. many times before. In the
winter there are many parties at the
White House for young girls and
youths of her age. and Miss Ethel
always receives her guests as to the
manner born.
Such is the new Miss Roosevelt.
If she has the same good fortune
as her elder sister, she may make her
first public bow next winter. She
will be II then, just the age of Mrs.
Longworth when, as Miss Alice, she
came to New York and christened
the kaiser's Meteor.
II Miss Roosevelt does come out
she will be in brilliant company
of buds and bellies, for Washington ia
alive with them. For example, there
is Miss Marguerite Shonts, daughter
OF the engineer of the Panama canal,
and Miss Williams, and Miss Frances
Goldsborough, and Miss Edith Root,
daughter of the secretary, and Miss
Frederick Morgan. beauties all.
The pioneer express. [volume] (Pembina, Dakota [N.D.]) 1883-1928, 1907-02-01
Senator ltadn't Missed Il,

DR.. Edward Everett Hale, chaplain
If the senate. usually listens for an
hour or SO daily to debate. taking !
sort Of fatherly interest in the mem.
bers. as the chaplain Of q boys school
might. The story goes that Or. Hale
once asked q certain senator with 1
good deal, Of solicitation e the was q
church member. The senator was lad
TO b able 70 say that he Wa. Two 81
three days later. according to5 the
story. DR.. Hale required to the sub
ject and asked the name of the church,
The senator gave q name. Two o1I
three days later again d. Hale re
marked With resretS tint "a hid Looked
up that church and that IL - aprf,
To- And that tshad been burned tl6wn
!i1s ysars bsfor< md nsyef rebuilt u;
The pioneer express. [volume] (Pembina, Dakota [N.D.]) 1883-1928, 1907-02-01
ors Physician Enough.

The latest story about Senator Pet.
tus of Alabama is. of how he was
overcome with vertigo some time ago
while working on law case in his
Alabama Office. He recovered in q
few minutes and his clerk said he
was going to send for q doctor. "All
right" said the octogenarian, 'but
don't get more than one" When the
doctor arrived the senator said: "You
are the only doctor here, are you?
You're sure there's only one Of you:"'
"Oh, yes, senator" said the physi.
clan. who thought the old gentleman
had some confidential Communication
to make. I'm mighty glad of it,
the senator said. with sigh Of relief.
Il am sure I'll get well IL there is
only one Of you fellows here, but ]
could not survive a consultation"