The Montgomery advertiser., 1907-07-21
P { BY LAWYERS Hawley and Darrow in Conoquy.
 BOTH MEN VERY ANGRY Counsel for Defense Says Opponent
 Willfully Made Misstatement. Speaker Shakes Finger h Face es Haywood's Representative and De. hounces This AS . Deliberate FalseAoel.
B0TH MEN VERY ANGRY

Boise. Idaho. July 2o-James IT Hawley, leading counsel for tn. State or Idaho. presented the first argument to the jury in tho case against Will. lam D. Haywood, and spoke for n..r,v e'sht hours, distributed over three se.. sions of court. Even when the .,,. noon session today had extended far oeyond the customary time limit. avery orI =. .ne court room was occupied was spoken ~ Aast "oro
 None listened more attentively to the arsument than Haywood, the defends ant and none showed less emotinr from time to time he took coniom. notes In small book and freouentIv naoe suggestions to one or the oths- oI ms counsel, seven of whom wero in court today. "'o !"
 throughout the day MT. Hawlev us.d an almost conversational tone Tha analysis Of testimony In contradicfton or oichard's story concluded freouent. " with the denunciation of witness af. ter witness as wilful perjurer or suiity or intentional falsehood. When ne mad spoken five and a half hours MT Hawley reached Caldwell. where. at the closa of the year, 1905. fhe preparations for the murder of ste"o nenoerg were afoot His voice now found a sympathetic note and as he told or the last moments of the Gov ernor. the crowd leaned forward to catch the speakers every word.
 MT. Hawley's peroration was im- pressive. There was no attempt at any night Of oratory. but only strong nestness when he pleaded for an hon est judgment for honest men of Ida ho.
 During MT. Hawley's speech he argued the truth of Orchards
 He argued the truth of Orchard . story and said two men in particular might have been brought to contrsdict him. but the defense was afraid to pro- duce either Pettiboue or AdRrnA. ana he said Adams had been brought to Boise from Jail in shoshons County in order that the defenss might use him as a witness. i,f G- -
 White to the lips. Clarence Darrow sprang into action. Tho statement Is false and counsel knows it," he shouted.
 Hawley took a step closer to tho de- close to Darrow's face said: When counsel says that. he utters a de- liberate falsehood."
 Judge Wood with a sharp command and insistent warning patched up a temporary peace.
 Hawley Continues.
 Continuing today the opening argu- men for the state in the case of William D. Haywood. which, after two months and a half of hearing. is about to be submitted to the jury, James H. Hawley, chief prosecutor, first de- voted his attention to the alleged at tempt to wreck train on the Florence and Cripple Creek railroad. This was one of the incidents of the Colorado labor troubles testified to by Harry Orchard.
 testimony" said Mir Hawley. but it was absolutely immaterial to the issue here involved. But the defense has taken this incident and has tried to build up out of 1t conspiracy on the part of the mine owners against the Western Federation of Miners Or chard admitted that he had reported the alleged attempt to detectives in the employ of the mine owners associa- has brought two women witnesses here to testify that they saw Orchard in one of the detectives rooms on many oc- casions. These women saw this man but casually over five years ago. but they come here and swear positively as to Orchards identity and to the number of his visits. Such evidence as this speaks for itself.
 Doesn't Deny Orchards Work
 Orchard undoubtedly was trying to secure money from all the sources he could and 1 am not going to defend him for his double dealing in taking money from both the Western Fedora tion of Miners and the railroad com pany. l am not here to paint Harry Orchard in anything but his true colors There is but one claim we make for him and that is that he has told you the truth. Tis fact has been indelibly fixed by all the circumstances in the case"
 MT. Hawiey said immediately after the train wrecking incident Orchard was found again in the Western Federation of Miners