The Mena weekly star., 1907-07-18
.[ND[NCE IN REBUIIAL
n.feose in Haywood Case Rests and Prosecution Begins its Sec
 ond Inning.
u,Ny PASSAGES BETWEEN COUNSEL
,,,row for Defense Made Objection After Objection to States Witness gu. Without Effect-Nine Witness :. Were Examined in the First Two Hours Saturday.

Two Hours SdtuFody.
 Boise Id, July 14.-Contradiction, ,a,neachment and rebuttal became ,be order of the day when shortly ofter the opening of court Saturday morning counsel for the defense of william D. Haywood rested their case and the state commenced the second innings.
 The rebuttal brought out flock of witnesses whose evidence, short and snappy, kept the courtroom well keyed up. j. H. Hawley conducted tho examination for the state. and E. Richardson again took the lead as cross.examiner. Hawley, vigorous and aggressive; Richardson, quick and at times showing irritation. to- gether provided number of inter esting passages. Good humor was mingled with grave insinuations, and short passages between counsel promptly suppressed by the court. Objection after objection was noured into the record by counsel for the defense. Clarence Darrow assist ed Richardson in keeping interest stirred to the point of excited antici- nation and the morning session was generally lively.
 Nine witnesses were examind in the first two hours, the most interest ing being August Paulson, formerly a partner of Harry Orchard In the Her cules mine and now a rich banker of Wallace, Idaho.
 The afternoon session opened with arguments as to the admissibility of certain documents end court sat Intil s.30.
 With the opening of the court Sat urday Attorney Richardson sprung a decided sensation by announcing that the defense rested. At adjournment Friday afternoon MT. Darrow had announced that powder expert would be put on the stand to testify in regard to the Bradley explosion in San Francisco. The change of plans took the states attorneys entirely by surprise and there was some delay in beginning the case in rebuttal. We did not expect this declared Mir Hawley, leading counsel for the state, land our witnesses were not notified to be here at this early hour
 TAe witnesses began to struggle in however, and soon John c. Rice was recalled to the stand. He testified
 that in November, 1905, Orchard did not wear a mustache. This was in contradiction of one of the witnesses
 for the defense who swore he heard
 Orchard make threats against Stcun
 enberg, describing Orchard as a man
 with large mustache.
 The next witness was Dan Gainey
 of Walla Walla. Gainey lost both Of
 his feet in the Independence depot
 explosion. He lived in the CoeuI dAenes in 1898 and 1899 and room 
 ed part of the time with Orchard
 Gainey said that Dominick Flynn, who
 testified he was playing poker with
 Orchard on April 19, 1S99-the day
 Of the Bunker Hill and Sullivan ex
 plosion-had told hip in converse
 ton that he had not seen Orchard
 since February, 1899.
 Interest in the rebuttal case was
 materially quickened by the calling Of
 August Paulson, of Wallace, Idaho
 one of the owners of the Hercules
 mine, in which Orchard once held a
 one-sixteenth interest. There was a
 iong argument between counsel as to
 the witness ability to tell when Orch
 ard ceased to exercise any control oi
 'he mine. Paulson said he could not
 remember the exact dates but that
 alter early in the spring of 1898 Orch
 ara had nothing further to do with
 tne property, his interest being sue
 ceeded by Dan Gardener. now
 wealthy man from the production ol
 the mine.
 The defense claims that Orchard
 nad a personal motive against Steun
 ehoerg because of the loss of this
 property when he was driven out ol
 .ae country as part of the 1899 trou
 "es. The state claims Orchard solt
 Out his interest a year or so before
 the trouble started.
 The deed by which Orchard trans
 'erred his interest in the Hercules
 nllne to Gardener was admitted il
 evidence over the protest of the de
 lense. It bore the date of March '
 1888
 raulson was cross examined bu
 onelly and left the stand as tn'
 luncheon adjournment until 1880 D
 m. was ordered.