davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
Evening journal. [volume] (Martinsburg, W. Va.) 1907-1913, 1907-11-16
DAMAGE SUITS FILED
MI. MuRdey Asks $4,000 From
Dr.. Minghini and 7. 7. lemeR.
he ALLEGES FALSE IMPRISONMENT
Mrs. Annie C. Miller Sues Berkeley
Lime & Stone Co. For $4,000
For the Death of Her Hus-
band at Quarries.

Two important civil suits were FL
ed today with Circuit Court Clerk L.
Dew. Gerhardt, one being the suit OF
Joseph Z. Munday against DR.. w. Z,
Minghini and Constable Thomas T.
Lemen in the sum of $4,000 each for
false imprisonment, and the other be-
ing the suit of Mrs. Annie c. Miller
against the Berkeley Lime C Stone
Co, in the sum of $4,000 for the death
of her husband, c. w. Miller, who was
killed at the Bessemer quarries some
time ago while at work.
The suit OF Mr.. Mundey against DR..
Minghini and Constable Lemen is the
outgrowth of some trouble at the Mum
dey bakery about two years ago Mr..
Mundey was in financial difficulties,
and an attachment was levied against
his effects by DR.. Minghini, owner OF
the building. Constable Lemen serv-
ed the papers in the case, and it was
alleged that Mr. Mundey offered some
resistance on the ground that the Off
GERS had no right to serve the papers
or consummate the order of the court
during the night As result of the
affair Mr.. Mundey was arrested and
spent the night in in the county jail
He bases his suit on the charge that
his arrest and Imprisonment was not
justifiable. This case will come up at
the next term Of the Circuit court
and promises to be decidedly inter
esting.
The suit of Mrs. Miller against the
limestone company is the outgrowth
of an accident at the Bessemer quar-
ries several months ago, which re-
suited in the death of her husband
Mr.. Miller was at work, when a fall
of rock inflicted injuries from which
he died. The plaintiff alleges that
the accident was due to the negligence
of the company
Attorney D. W. Snyder represents
Mr.. Mundey in his suits against DR.
Minghini and Constable Lemen, AMI
Faulkner, Walker & Woods represent
Mrs. Miller In her suit against tho
Limestone company.
Evening journal. [volume] (Martinsburg, W. Va.) 1907-1913, 1907-11-16
DEATH OF AN OLD RESIDENT
MR.. JOSEPH BRAITHwAITE Ex-
PRED AT GERRARDSTowN.
Was a Native of Frederick County,
But Had Resided In This County
For Number of Years.

Mr.. Joseph Braithwaite, one of the
Oldest residents of the southern por-
ton of the county, died late Thursday
night at the home of his daughter,
Mrs. David Crawford, at Gerrardstown,
aged so years. Death was due to the
infirmities of his advanced age.
Mr. Braithwaite was q native of
Frederick county, but had resided in
Berkeley for number of years. He
was well known and respected.
Surviving are the following child
ren: Mrs. David Crawford, of Ger
rardstown; Mrs. Abraham Jackson, of
Bunker Hill; Mr.. t. Braithwaite, of
Martinsburg; Mr.. William and Mr.
Beverley Braithwaite, of Inwood.
The funeral was held this morning
at Pine Grove Methodist Episcopal
church. The services were conduct
ed by Rev. J. +. Ely, and interment
was in the neighboring cemetery.
Died While Visiting Parents.
Mrs. Anna G. Williams, wife of A.
70. Williams, of Middleburg, Va, died
suddenly Friday afternoon while on
visit to her aged parents, Mr.. and
Mrs. T. o. Wyndham, in Winchester
She was so years old. Besides her
husband and parents three brothers
and three sisters survive.
Death of An Infant.
The infant daughter of Mr.. and
Mrs. Lee w. Wilmington, Of South
Water street, died last night.
Evening journal. [volume] (Martinsburg, W. Va.) 1907-1913, 1907-11-16
MARRIED on FRIDAY
Miss FauIkWe|I Becomes The Bride
Of Popular Railroad Man..
CEREMONY WAS PERFORMED HERE
Quiet But Pretty Event Solemnized
at the Home of the Brides Sis
ter, Mrs. ]. Peer, on South
Spring Street.

Miss Alice May Faulkwell, the es-
Unable and popular daughter Of Mr..
ana Mrs. G. w. Faulkwell, residing
in Berkeley county, near Hedgesville
and Mr.. Roy e. Myers, a well-known
young Baltimore & Ohio railroad
brakeman, also resident of Berkeley
county. were the principals in a
quiet but pretty wedding, which was
solemnized Friday night ut the home
of the brides sister, Mrs. J.. Peers, on
Spring street, this city.
The ceremony was performed by
Rev. W. B. Evers. Of this city in the
presence of number Of friends and
relatives of the contracting parties.
Miss Carrie Shipper, of st. Paris,
Ohio, was the bridesmaid, and Mr.. B.
f. Benner, of Martinsburg, was the
best man. A reception followed the
wedding.
Mr.. and Mrs Myers will reside in
this city. The bride is a member OF
a swell-known Berkeley county fam
lily, while the groom is popular
Young railroad man, with many friends
here.
Evening journal. [volume] (Martinsburg, W. Va.) 1907-1913, 1907-11-16
M0RGAN'S TOMATO CROP FOR THIS SEASON
Statistics Show That The Value Was Greater Than The Apple Crop Of
Berkeley County -s,ne Very Interesting Figures.

Cross Roads Canning Co., q can
neries,) 81 cars.
William A. Rockwell, 80 cars.
e. L. Rice, IL cars.
B. E. Dawson, s cars.
Joseph p Hovermale g canneries)
2s cars.
d. L. Harrison, IA cars.
p w. Atkinson. 10 cars.
G. w. Biser G. canneries) cars.
Ridersville Canning Co., "a cars.
P. T. holland & Co., 5 cars.
Luttrell Bros. cars.
Michael Bros, cars.
Continued on page 81
Evening journal. [volume] (Martinsburg, W. Va.) 1907-1913, 1907-11-16
CHANGES IN THE SCHEDULE
ONLY TWO TRAINS AFFECTED
AT THIS POINT.
New Baltimore g. Ohio Schedule
Will Go Into Effect One Minute
After Midnight Tonight.

The winter schedule of the Balti-
more C Ohio railroad will go into eff
feet at one minute after midnight to-
night, but there will be very little
change in the time Of the arrival and
departure of passenger trains at Il
point.
The only eastbound train that will
be affected is No. 46, which has been
arriving at 8.12 p. M, but which will
be due here hereafter under the new
time card at 740 p. m.
The only westbound train affected
is No. AZ, which has been due here
at 713 a. M, but which will be chang
ed to 6.21.
Evening journal. [volume] (Martinsburg, W. Va.) 1907-1913, 1907-11-16
OF DEAD MAN NOT FOUND
Remains Of H. NJ Miller Killed Thursday Might still at the Wien
Undertaking Establishment Wires Are Kept Hot

Notwithstanding the efforts of Under
taker Wien to locate the relatives of
Fl. M. Miller, the printer killed Thurs
day night near the Hedgesville tower
by Baltimore & Ohio passenger train
No. IA, no one connected with the
dead man has come forward to claim
the body.
kilograms to Cumberland brought
B. F. Walters, secretary of the Typo
graphical union of that city, to Mar
tinsburg today, and he took charge
of the remains and kept the wires
hot in an effort to locate the rela-
tives of the dead man. A telegram
Evening journal. [volume] (Martinsburg, W. Va.) 1907-1913, 1907-11-16
MAY Be CANDIDATE
Henry G. Davis Makes Significant
Admission In Baltimore.
MAY RUN FOR GOVERNOR OF STATE
West virginia's "Grand Old Man"
Also States That He Believes the
Next President Will Be Demo-
crat - What He Says.

Next President Will Be Demo-
crat What He Says.
A special dispatch from Baltimore
says:
Hin. Henry G.. Davis, former United
States senator from West Virginia and
candidate three years ago for vice
president of the United States, was in
Baltimore yesterday. He called upon
President Oscar @. Murray, of the
Baltimore & Ohio railroad, and upon
President Bush, of the Western Mary
land railroad. Mr. Davis, who is
owner of the Coal & Coke railroad,
extending from Elkins to Charleston,
W. Va. has traffic contracts with the
Baltimore & Ohio and Western Mary
land railroads. Hence his visit to
the presidents of the two companies.
Mr. Davis registered at the Hotel
Rennert, and in the dining room of
that hotel he met former Governor
John Walter Smith, the prospective
United States senator from Maryland
Il am glad to meet you, senator"
said the former governor, "and l am
glad to meet the next senator from
Maryland said Mr.. Davis.
Il had the pleasure of voting for
you for vice-president,' said Mr..
Smith.
Yes said Mr.. Davis. "The only
trouble was that there were not
enough democrats at that time who
voted for Mr. Parker and myself to
|elect us. 1t is coming our way though.
Don't mistake yourselves, gentlemen.
THE democrats will elect a president
of the United States one of these days,
and that day is not far distant"
Are you still in favor of the nom
dnation of Judge Gray, of Delaware,
for PRESIDENT"
Judge Gray is most estimable
gentleman and would be an ideal can
didate for president and an ideal pres
ident. l do not think that the Mary
LAND delegates will favor Mr.. Bryan
flor president"
"Will you be candidate for the
democratic nomination for governor
of West Virginia next year?'
Indeed, do not know. You know
the people say / am an old man. There
has been some talk about my being
a candidate for governor next year,
but next year is in the future / wish
you would say for me that the people
of Maryland are fortunate in having
William Pinkney Whyte as their rep
! resentative in the United States SEN
ate. You know Mr. Whyte and myself
are old friends We served in the sem
ate together, and he was counsel for
the West Virginia Central Railway
Co., with which ] was connected, as
you know. Some of my friends call
{ me the Grand Old Man of West vir-
ginia. | am DID, but do not consid-
er myself old. l am what they call
a young old man. for am still in
harness. Senator Whyte is the Grand
Old Man of Maryland. and he is a
young old man, for he, too, is still
in harness. AS | am native of Mary
land, the state may be said to have
two grand old men. Mr.. Whyte and
myself
The burden OF his eighty-odd years
rests lightly on ex-senator Davis. His
brisk step, upright carriage and buoy
ant manner seem to jsutify the oft
expressed belief of his friends that
he will live to be centenarian.
Evening journal. [volume] (Martinsburg, W. Va.) 1907-1913, 1907-11-16
Especial Correspondence

Especial Correspondence
Berkeley Springs, Nov. ia rep
resentative of The Evening Journal
has collected statistics concerning the
output of the tomato canneries in Nor
gan county for the present season,
which show that the value of the out
put was greater than the total value
OF the apple crop Of Berkeley coun-
ty this year. About 22O carloads of
tomatoes were shipped from Morgan
county, the value of which was in
the neighborhood of 100000.
The number of cars shipped by the
individual firms is as follows:
Evening journal. [volume] (Martinsburg, W. Va.) 1907-1913, 1907-11-16
PRESIDENT SIGNS BILL.
And Oklahoma is Now Member Of
The American Union.

special dispatch to the Journal.
Washington, Nov. 16.--The law adj
hitting the Territory OF Oklahoma
to the Union as sovereign state was
|signed by President Roosevelt at 10
o'clock today.
Evening journal. [volume] (Martinsburg, W. Va.) 1907-1913, 1907-11-16
Music For Dancing.

- Miss Grace Swartz will furnish the
orchestra music for dancing tonight
from s to 11.3O at the entertainment
and oyster supper in the Hobbs hall :
Evening journal. [volume] (Martinsburg, W. Va.) 1907-1913, 1907-11-16
Painting Residence.

Mrs. Amanda Underdonk, of North
High street, is improving her resi-
idence with new coat of paint, which
adds much to It's beauty.
Evening journal. [volume] (Martinsburg, W. Va.) 1907-1913, 1907-11-16

Underwears-We're headquarters
The Bert Store. I'll
Evening journal. [volume] (Martinsburg, W. Va.) 1907-1913, 1907-11-16

to Front Royal brought the response
that the man had no relatives there.
and another telegram to Lexington,
Va, failed to elicit any satisfactory
information.
A telegram to President James NJ
Lynch Of the International Ty-
biographical union. at indianapolis.
authorized Mr. Walters to take charge 7
of the body and see that it was giY-f
en- proper burial, the expense being
borne by the printers union.
Mr.. Walters stated this afternoon
that the remains would be buried in
Continued on page 60
Evening journal. [volume] (Martinsburg, W. Va.) 1907-1913, 1907-11-16
/. speciaI dispatch from Baltimor

The live merchant advertises.
Evening journal. [volume] (Martinsburg, W. Va.) 1907-1913, 1907-11-16

Advertise your winter goods.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1907-04-14
Pe-ru~na in the Home.


After all, experience is the best
teacher. Some doctors may write in
favor of Peruna. Other doctors may
write against IL. But it is the testi-
mony OF the mothers and fathers who
are rearing families, who love their
chlldren, who must economize as to doc
tor bills, who are raising little boys
and girls into men and women of the
future, 1T is the testimony of such peo-
pie that really counts,
There Is no way to positively ascer-
tam how many families in the United
States rely upon Peruna for the many
climatic ailments to which the family
is subject. The number must be a
great one. Several millions perhaps.
They have learned how to use Peruna
for ordinary ailments, and in that way
are guarding their homes against more
serious diseases.
Such ailments as coughs and colds,
sore throat and catarrh, Group and
cohc, indigestion and loss of appetite,
anemia and nervousness, all these all
ments are promptly relieved by few
doses of Peruna at the right time.
Millions of provident mothers and
fathers are guarding the interests of
the home by using Dr. Hartman s great
remedy. and .pro1iting by his medical
booklets and personal advice.
The plan of furnishing, on large
scale, directly to the people, a remedy
for chronic catarrh, is an immense saw
ing to the people. Peruna is not SIM
ply palliative to relieve some of the
distressing symptoms. 1t brings per-
manent relief
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1907-04-14
Bingham
Society

Special TO The Tribune
BINGHAM, April 13.-The Rebekah
lodge initiated three new members Iues-
day evening. after which an elaborate
supper was served
II. $. Joseph was a camp visitor dur
ing the week, looking after his mining
interests here. ,
Mr. and Mrs Henry Thomas will leave
Tuesday for New York, from where tney
sNl sail Tor London, Paris ana otner
European centers.
Mrs Y. 3. Jones entertained at dinner
Monday In honor OF her mothers sixty
eighth birthday. Covers were iala ior
eight
Mrs w, s. Cannon entertained last
Tuesday in honor OF Dr. and Mrs, Smed-
ley. who leave shortly for the East,
where they intend TO locate.
Father Ryan OF Salt Lake was in camp
curing the week attending the Catholic
church.
Levi II. Fuller. a school teacher Of
Garfield visited here during the week.
Miss Grace Miller entertained at dinner
last Sunday. Covers were laid for ten.
Mrs a j. Minnetu was at the capital
Wednesday. the guest OF her daughter.
Dir. r, c. Smedley. for the past ten
years resident Of Bingham. will leave
april II for Europe, where he wtll enjoy
a short vacation, later locating In the
East. Many people here Will regret the
departure Of the doctor and his wife.
Mrs j. w. Clovis and son OF Gregson
Springs. Mont, are visiting camp, and
intend 10 return to their home early in
May
Mrs Cellventra has arrived from the
hospital at Salt Lake, where she has been
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1907-04-14

with catarrh of the head, throat and
digestive organs. [ consulted many
physicians, but they did me no good.
Zone day | happened TO read some
testimonials in your Pernna almanac.
| decided 10 try Peruna and Manalin.
| bought bottle Of each and after tax
ing them for week L noticed change
for the better. So I kept 1T up and af-
ter using twelve BOTTLES l was perfectly
cured.
81 also gave the medicine to my chill
dren and they had the same beneficial
result, | would never be without these
remedies in the house.
81 highly recommend Peruna and
Manalin to all my friends, and, in fact,
to everybody
Thousands of families have learned
to trust and believe In DR.. Hartman IS
Judgment, anu to rely on his remedy,
Peruna
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1907-04-14
Grip Quickly Knocked Ont.

Some weeks ago during the severe
winter weather both my wife and my
self contracted severe colds which
speedily developed into the worst kind
OF Ia grippe with all its miserable
symptoms," says Mr.. j. S. Egleston of
Maple Landing, Iowa. Knees and
/ POINTS aching, muscles sore, head
Stopped up, eyes and nose running, with
alternate spells of cnills and fever. We
began using Chamberlain s Cough Rem,
edy, aiding the same with double dose
Of Chamberlain s Stomach and Liver
tablets, and by its liberal use soon com
pletely knocked out the 0rip.' Sold
py all leading druggists.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1907-04-14

81 then tried Peruna, and after us"
ing it for three months was totally
well. / am seyenty-one years old, and
my work on the railroad is hard and
tedious. but ! can work like young
man in all kinds of weather, heat, cold,
rain, snow or storm alike.
"Peruna is the purest and best medi-
cine, and If used according to direc-
tions. it will help any person and cure
any disease for which 1t is recommend
ed. | recommend this medicine by my
own experience to any one suffering
from an ailment on the order OF mine. -
For Herself and Children.
Mrs. Aline DePasse, 7T6 T.. 165th St.,
New York, y. Y, writes:
HIt gives me pleasure TO testify TO
the curative qualities OF Peruna and
Manalin.
81 was afflicted for over seven years
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1907-04-14

wife, sometimes assisted by the apoth-
ecary or the family doctor
Furnishing medical compounds direct
to tho people, through the druggists, is
simply the extension Of the practice be-
gun by the people themselves.
Nervous System a Wreck.
John G, tIlrdler, Garfield, Kas.,
writes.
|'On December >, 1899, 7 was in
Jured by fall on the Santa Fe r. R.,
and my entire nervous system was lnl-
paired by the same, The help of Il
physician was useless. / believe | tried
every enc in the vicinity, but all were
alike and / remained without strength.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1907-04-14
Catarrhal Group.

Few people realize how frequently
Group is caused by catarrhal congestion
of the throat. Probably nine cases out
of ten Of Group are of the catarrhal
variety.
The medical profession recognizes
three forms of Group. The spasmodic
variety, membranous Group and ca
tarrhal Group.
Nearly every case is of the catarrhal
variety. and a few doses of Peruna tax
en- at the first appearance of the ca
tarrhal symptoms is generally sufficient
to avert the attack of Group altogether
Group is frigh;ful disease No dis
ease of children so alarms the house.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1907-04-14

hold. 1t is impossible to estimate how
many homes have been protected
against Group by the proper Use of Pc
runa.
Household Remedies.
which has proven SO popular for ca.
tarrh as Peruna. 1t has been used for
more than thirty years and cured thou
sands OF cases, as proven by our tes-
timonials.
In the early history Of this country
every family had its homemade med
icines. Herb teas, bitters. laXatives
and tonics were to be found in almost
every house, compounded by the house
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1907-04-14
Eor Over Fifty Yanra

uA! An old and we'll. tried remedy, Mrs.
Minslow's Soothing Syrup, has been
S osed Tor over fifty years by millions of
iIothers for their children while teeth
%%g, with perfect success. 1t soothes
~ me child. softens the gums, allays all
rain, cures wind collie and is the best
slsts in every part of tho world, Be
,urs ,un an and ask for Mrs. Winslow's Sooth.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1907-04-14

NoDOL for Dyspepsia clears the
,s0mach ,s and makes the breath as sweet
~ rose KODOL is sold by druggists
-, ~ y guarantee relief plan. 1t conforms
d-.istiy to the national pure food and
ues law- Sold by Ansteo Brice Drug
W. Il Main street.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1907-04-14
REEvEs AU GEoRGEl
" a HEALTHr FAMILY
Kept the Children Well.

Mrs. K Kane 1876 Sebor St., Flat 1, Chicago ILL., writes
Peruna has been used long family that
know how could get along without it,
'I have given all Of my five children different
they suffered with Group colds and the many ailments that
children subject and pleased say that has kept
them in splendid health.
Il have also used for catarrhal difficulty of long stand
ing and cured short time have every
praise Peruna.
The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1907-04-14
Catarrh of Stomach.

Mr.. John NJ Stansberry Amarillo Tex, writes:
For years had catarrh of the stomach hard
y able do anything and could not with any satisfaction
when commenced using Peruna, weighed only 10
pounds took bottles commencing the spring. and by
following winter had gained 63 pounds.
ct all Peruna 1t cannot be praised too highly
II foryhve years old, and my occupation that of
architect and builder
Iowa County democrat. [volume] (Mineral Point, Wis.) 1877-1938, 1907-05-23
To be continued.
PASSING OF THE GENERALS.

Army and Navy Journal.-The fol
lowing shows what general officers
now in active service will still be on
the active list of the army in the
years named If they are sill living
and do not resign:
1908-Wood, Weston. Grant, Gree
ly, Bell, Funston, Carter, Bliss
Barry, Mills, Edgerly, DuvaI, Per
shing, Myer.
lockwood, Weston, Grant, Bell
Funston, Carter, Bliss, Barry, Mills
Edgerly, Duvall, Pershing, Myer.
lockwood, Grant, Bell, Funston
Carter, Bliss, Barry, Mills, Duvall
Pershing, Myer.
1911-Wood, Grant, Bell, Funston
Carter, Bliss, Barry, Mills, Duva1l
Pershing.
1912-14-Wood, Grant, Bell, Fun
ston, Carter, Bliss, Barry, Mills, Per
shing.
1915-Wood, Bell, Funston, Carter
Bliss, Barry, Mills, Pershing.
1916-Wood Bell, Funston, Bliss
Barry, Mills, Pershing.
1917-1S-Wood, Bell, Funston
Barry, Mills, Pershing.
1919-Wood, Bell, Funston. Barry
Pershing.
1920-Wood, Bell, Funston, Per
shing.
1921-24-Wood, Funston, Pershing
1929-FUnston.
Iowa County democrat. [volume] (Mineral Point, Wis.) 1877-1938, 1907-05-23
A DECISION Of
MUCH IMPORTANCE
FEAR 1T HAS INVALlDATED
STATUS OF ARMY OFFICERS.
WILL BE ENTITLED TO PAY
Court Martialed Soldier Can Draw Sal
airy Until Date Of Expiration of
His Time Because Regular Officer
Holding Volunteer Commission
Sa. in Case.

Washington. May 21.-There IS
grave apprehension at the war de-
partment that the supreme court or
the United States has invalidated
the status Of every regular army Of
ticer who has held at the same tine
a volunteer commission, and has also
lnvalidated the legality of the pro,
ceedings of every court martial of
a volunteer officer or an enlisted man,
on which has sat an officer holding
both regular and volunteer comm s.
siOns.
The court May 13 handed down an
opinion declaring invalid the court
martial Of Lieutenant Lewis E.
Brown, the negro volunteer officer
who was tried and dismissed from
service in Cuba. The court martial
was -nvalidated because an officer of
the regular army, who was also a
volunteer officer, sat in court. Ac,
cording to the decision Brown will
be entitled to draw his pay until tho
date of the mastering out of his reg
iment and the expiration of his COM
miss on.
The war department officials regard
it as logical conclusion to be drawn
from the courts decision that the
findings of every court martial on
which sat regular army omcers who
also held volunteer COMMISSIONS, and
which tried a volunteer officer or en-
listed man are invalidated.
The basis of the courts decision
is that regular army officer holding
a volunteer commission at tue same
time, is not a volunteer but a regular
army officer. The war department
has always held exactly the reverse;
that is, that a regular army officer
holding a volunteer commission, was
during the time he held such COM
mission, a volunteer officer and not
q regular army officer. The pay of
such officers has been regulated on
that basis and many officers of the
low grade were given commissions
TO higher grades in the volunteer SER
vice during the civil war, the Spanish
American war and the instruction in
the Philippines, and by reason of
such commissions, drew largely i'll
creased pay. Under the recent deci.
sion of the court this pay will have
to be returned that is, if the decis on
is really as broad as at present APP
pears