Lewiston evening teller. [volume] (Lewiston, Idaho) 1903-1911, 1907-07-15

BOISE. July Hilary Orchard,
the principal witness for the state
aoa,nst Haywood was called in rebut-
tsl when the trial of the secretary Of
,ba western Federation OF Miners was
resumed today
orchard was in the chair 20 minutes
; and the questions of the state occupied
,as. than five minutes. Attorney
richardson asked Orchard IL his ma
ternal grandfather was not insane on
the subject of the confession Of inn
apinary crimes. Orchard admitted that
his uncle, Peter Mckinney, who lived
in Canada, hanged himself while in
. 10 espsIMou4 IIB peIuep ana 'sues
grandfather named Patrick.
This examination was based on
letter received by the defense from B.
W. McKinstry. of Alameda, Pa. The
writer claimed he had received in
formation from Mrs. Margaret Bull of
Woller, Ontario, who was a neighbor
Of Patrick Mckinney. grandfather Of
Horsley or orchard. She said Patrick
Mckinney was IAN old styled country
gentleman, but he became insane and
raved of crimes he had committed in
Ireland, and as result Of which his
family kept him chained for years.
Orchard denied he ever introduced
Pnkerton Operative Gratias to Max
Malich or Joe Mehliet or that Pinker-
ton Operative Riddell introduced him
to Joe Barnes. He also denied he was
ever arrested at Butte for arson and
denied he ever had ever told a man
named Brockaw he had been in the
employ of the Pinkerton detective
agency for five years.
Walter Bynum, a plumber of Den
sver, Colo, testified he saw Pat Moran
at Denver in June, 1904. Orchard
testified he sent Moran to Denver to
get $500 from the federation. Moran
denied he had ever gone to Denver in
June for any purpose. Bynum said he
knew Moran well and could not be
mistaken.
e. M. Sabin, an attorney of Idaho
Springs, Colo, said he knew Detective
Lyte Gregory, who was killed by Or
chard Gregory had been engaged by
the prosecution to secure evidence in
the case of conspiracy out Of the at
tack on the Sun and Moon mine. The
defendants were IA members of the
Western Federation of Miners, includ-
ing D. c. Copley, a witness for the
defense in the present case. The de-
Tense has claimed that Gregory had
nothing to do with anything in which
the federation was interested.
The two got into an alteration as to
whether or not there had been dis
cussion among citizens to the effect
that the detectives employed by the
prosecution had not earned their
money
Those men were all given verdict
OF not guilty, weren't they?"
That's true, no one has ever denied
you glory Of that victory" replied sa-
bin.
Tn not asking for glory, I'm asking
the facts" said Richardson.
Well, the facts as I saw them were
mat those men, every one of them
we're guilty"
motion to strike out the last an
swer was denied. Richardson brought
out the fact that Sabin and 80 other of
'ne citizens of Alliance were placed
under bonds to keep the peace, but
uenled that these cases were tried by
a special procedure without the ac-
uon OF the district attorney. who was
as sabin claimed, Richardson said
was "a nonentity."
When the Haywood trial was
resumed today Judge Wood an
Hounced he would sustain the
objection Of the defense to the ad-
nittance in evidence Of the records of
'ne state insane asylum, showing the
commitment to that institution OF John
- Eliiott' witness for the defense, who
'estined to long conversation he had
"ien orchard in November, 1905.
william Dewey. the witness who
'srted the court rom Saturday by
ssing participation In the Coeur
acne riots at the attack OF the
bunker Hill ana Sullivan min was re.
eu further to identity w. r. Davis
'ne man who handed out the guns
u ammunition the day the moi
ss 'eo Tor the min. The defense tool
uSAn'ase Of Dewey's reappeasance t.
suestion him further on his motive 70,
'est'fying at this time.
dewey was asied Il, after testsev.n,
saturday. he had aaIa - .o-.---,.-.