New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1907-01-22

respect what said as to the effect of those utter
II he should utter words which would inspire
the black of the South TO disregard law and
place more dihlcuties In Ine way OF the iti mT
And Senator who could not receive such cru,
cisms without regarding them as a personal attack
Mr.. spooner said some Of Mr.. Tillmans utter
ances as quoted by Senator Patterson had appalled,
and shocked him. If at later date the Senator
had to,daV APPLIED Mr.. spooner should feel then
for the first time he had not known the senator.
tI P IA fn reing Ct the Negro troops If
this was an insult TO the Senator it was not MS
(Spooners). but Timan's words Mr.. Spooner
what he would not have taken with credit had II
iyn ;. ny i'''''''l '''' sou - $40 ,, NJ
Spooner and the world has come to regard how
vital It is not to the man involved but to society
he denied the riebt of any state to delegate
and in anger he did not refer to the South more
Of that doctrine by any man. especially by those
in high places. This was not personal attack Tack
upon any one II was an utter disagreement WIN
any one who advocated lynching. .
appreciation of the situation in the. South He
knew it was delicate one one which would tax
II, for the black man. he knew. must stay there.
The e9rI ~ these races and to his mind 1t
meant applying q torch Leaving ont PolltiGs, MI:
he white and the black man must be equal"
There man so wicked that he was not en-
would not discuss that unspeakable crime com
mitted by both white and black men, he continued:
THE Senator will not claim that the appreciation
Of womanhood and the crown jewel OF Womfn,n 1
The men Of the North. South, East and West
equally low, oye- "a. in the palace or in the cabin
Even this. he said. did not obterate the funda
right to trial in court Of law In all this. he
Ton ns bnt R hGf d aafK the senator from
1T has remained for the Senator to be the only
utterance to any justdcation Of trial by mob"
S9oongr G the t tGoi IN of 1G sH
tor Tillman, He had never heard Hampton utter
had never uttered an insult to the race or advo-
Gated violence to the Dace
again with ali his heart that the solution of the
right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness
CARMACK REsENTs TILLMAN's ATTACK.
When Mr.. Spooner took his seat Senator Teller
obtained recognition but said he would yield briefly
to Mr.. Carmack. who was also addressing the
Chair.
MI President" Mr. Carmack said, 81 was not
in the chamber in the early part OF the speech
made by the Senator from South Carolina. l be-
lieve that no Senator here has given more frequent
or provocation for retort than the Senator
from South Carolina has done, and no Senator has
complained more often or more bitterly Of being
upon either side OF the chamber has made
remarks about the Senator from South Carolina as
Carolina, without any provocation whatever. has
The senator from South Carolina saw fit to in
clude me in his remarks without any provocation
whatever. SO far as can Judge. have no feeling
Carolina. for without making any personal applca-
ton. wish TO say that with respect to some men
not know hoy TO speak the language OF courtesy
THE Senator from South Carolina saw fit to al
lude 10 the fact that had been defeated for re-
within the reach of the most grovelling contro-
yersiail faculty that ! am not SURPRISED that =
the senator from south carolina
The senator from South Carolina did not need
height Of that great retor believe It to be true.
fact that NV service terminates isis is matter Of re-
gret 70 nearly every Senator upon this side OF the
chamber, and, believe, TO most OF the Senators
on ont, the Other side OF the Gham6ST doubt very
respect TO either side II the Senator from South
caT9nf - wgTe IN my my position from south Carolina
sn arsnd of oe nTG i0a , 11 bro s nsse
TO the White House Broken or unbroken that
spear has never been dipped in the Nth OF the gut
win be withdrawn from here unstaincd with dis
honor or unstaned by any act Of mine with any
Mr. Teller interrupted At this point and Mr..
The Goorado Senator s Would Ped no him foP e bre t
reply Ito my friend from Tennessee"
SENATE DOORS SHUT
When Mr. Carmack declared that he might also
want more time Mr.. Teller. In positive language.
declined 10 yield to either. but addressing the
chair. said lie would to close the doors Of the
Senate If he could get second. Several Senators
on the Republican side OF the chamber were heard
to second the motion. and the Vice-President
nounced that. the second Of Senator GallinEer
the motion had been put and carried.
The closed session devoted entirely effort
70 obtain the eXpunging from The Congressional
Record" Of the portion Of Mr. Tillman's remarks
lating to other Senators. whom he characterized
the minstrel show After hours discussion
this brought about by the South Carolina sen
ators agreement to withdraw hts remarks that
subject. Senator Teller made the point that the
portion Of the speech referring other Senators
beneath the dignity OF the Senate. and suggest
ed thar II should be eliminated Other Senators
followed In the same line, but those who had been
alluded at first declared that they would never
consent 20 the withdrawal until they had had an
opportunity to reply. Mr. Tillman assured them
that what he had said intended nothing
than bit OF humOr and pleasantly, and after
a general exchange of views the Senate agreed to
permit him to withdraw the Objectionable remarks.
the time making apology to the offended
and the Senate itself This he did later
in open session.
rvprrT MO cEccT0n oM ThpTCr