Evening bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu, Hawaii]) 1895-1912, 1907-11-21
F acts Set Forth
And Lies Nailed
Pinkham's Statement On Cast
ing Deciding Vote In WaIIach
Affair Let's Light OF Truth On
Vicious Measurements Freely
Made.

" HtH II 'dlll' lllllt wv ltol'l'lN
rinkham to cast the deciding vote in
the Wallach controversy before the
Board of Health Wednesday, he made
the following statement
pinkham's Statement.
The contingency may arise in
which the President of the Board OF
Health will be called upon to cast the
deciding vote on the petition from the
Molokai Settlement, hence the prcpa'
ration of this memorandum.
He will not discuss the character
of J. Lor WallaCh for II is hls
opinion J. Lor Wallach has no
character.
He will not discuss the ability of
J. Lor Wallach to cure lcprosy for
IL is his opinion j. LOr WaIlaCh
has no such ability.
He will not discuss the prOpriGty
of giving J. LOr WallaCh an Op.
portunity to attempt the cure of
lcprosy in the person of one or
twelve individuals for in his opin.
ion ]. Lor WallaCh does not wish
such an opportunity.
He believes this man is juggling
with the political schemes of Ger
tain politicians, Is imposing on
the creduliIy Of Hawaiians. is OK.
tracing such sums of money as
he can from Hawaiians. and will
at no distant day unmask himself
and himself expose his own chi.
Canery.
There are three points the PrCsi.
dent of the Board will discuss: list
| The demand for the production of evi.
uCnCC Of cures by J. LOr Wallach.
2nd-Thc part Of the politicians. Bird
! What Is due the people of the Set.
| tlemcnt. 527 of whom believe implic.
! lily the statements written them by
their friends relative to cures of lcp,
rosy by Wallach.
Notley's Wanted Evidence.
"On the 22nd day Of October the
| Committee Of Ten representing all
DulitiCal parties appeared before the
PRESIDENT of the Board of Health, who
| vas alone in his Office, and to him
personally made their representations
| and appeals.
"Onc man only among them claimed
to know of his own positive knowledge
that J. IOr Wallach had and could
GIrc lcprosy. This man was Charles
X. Motley. After much oratory, and
assertions of many cures of lcprosy
by Wallach, almost miraculous In
tneir nature, and in which Motley al
lOst raised Wallach to the heights oi
Divinity, the President of the Board
quietly inquired of Motley: DID YOU
NOT NEED TO SEE THESE CURES
| BEFORE YOU WOULD BELIEVE
IN WALLhCH'S ABILITY TO EFF
! Feet THE CURE OF LEPROSY?
Motley REPLIED THE EVIDENCE
WAS NECESSARY BEFORE liz
! WOULD BELIEVE.
The President then stated that con
Nincing evidence was all that haC
ever been requested by himself, and
rs Motley had made himself the only
responsible spokesman 1t was up tC
i'm, Motley, to grant the same evi
nence he had required for himself tina
the Board OF Health might be con
Nnced of the truth ot-his, Motley S
statements. The assertions of Chas
X. Motley were so positive and Sc
sweeping they challenged the Presi
cent of the Board to demand the pro
duCtiOn of the evidence. After reflec
ton, the President of the Board wal
convinced no other course was opel
IN him md in his message 10 In,
Hoard Octohor 9th no made This do
nnnd and bo oIeo made the doman,
LircctIv and norsouaIIv of Charles X
NotInv who was uresent
Notl.v Than Refused
"Ynu have heiore Won Charles X
NotIov'e formal renIv a refusal
.rbc President heIieved II was III,
duty or tho MoIokoi Settlement Con,
mittee or seven IN usc their infIuenc
IN socuro This evidence and the Iotte
oC Octobor o5tb discloses this fact an,
rIoorIy nntoa Tho nositiop of tho mai
Ter
.,Arr NotIov nj the BOARD of HeaIt
oricns m Octoher 2ath in the mos