Lewiston evening teller. [volume] (Lewiston, Idaho) 1903-1911, 1907-11-05
MOUNTAIN AND MOUSE.
National Civic Federation Report
Is Disappointing.

After Two Years of Labor the Com
mittee Brings Forth a Report Which
Proves Little-lnvestigators Allow
Their Prcjudiees to Blind Them to
the Faets.-Labor Unions Are Warned
of Danger.
For two years a committee of the
National Civic federation has been
making a study of municipal owner
ship in the United States and Eng
land, the Investigators having been
selected impartially from the advo.
Gates and opponents of lunicipal own
ership. The report embodying the
findings of this committee will be pub
lished this month in two parts, one
of which will be devoted to the opin-
ions of the Investigators, the other to
the statistical information upon which
those opinions are supposed to be based.
Half Truths.
We use the word supposed" ad-
visedly, for from the advance sections
that have been given to the papers 1t
appears that some at least of the mu-
nicipal ownership members Of the COM
mittee have not considered it neces,
sary to make their opinions square
with the facts For instance, Mr..
Bemis holds up the Wheeling CIV. Va.)
gas plant as an example of successful
municipal ownership because its net
rate Is IS cents while 81 is charged
by the companies in Norfolk, Va, and
Atlanta, Ga. According to the news
paper reports. Mr.. Bemis does not in
form the public that the average price
of coal in Norfolk and Atlanta is at
least 60 per cent higher than in Wheel
ing and that the latter city uses natu-
raj gas as fuel in its retorts, nor does
he call attention to the important fact
that the average candlepower in the
two cities named is % per cent higher
than in Wheeling.
Charity Begins at Home.
Where Mr.. Bemis does use figures
he uses them shrewdly. AS superin-
tendent of the Cleveland waterworks
he Of course knows that in that city
the average death rate from typhoid
In the thirty-two years preceding 1905
was 81 per 100000. So he uses
for comparison with cities that have
private waterworks only the years
19O5-O6, when the typhoid death rate
In Cleveland averaged only 17.6 per
100000. Two years is of course far
too short period upon which to base
such a comparison, since the rates
vary widely in different years, the rate
in Syracuse in 1905, for example, be-
ing only about half what it was in
1916, while Cleveland dropped from
| ia in 1908 to Is in 1905.
Hope Versus Experience.
Professor Parsons, another Of the M.
o. members of the committee, seems
to prefer the future to the past as a
basis for determining results. He ex-
presses his conviction that municipal
ownership would develop a higher
class of2municipal administrators, but
when he is faced with such conditions
as existed In Philadelphia under the
notorious gas ring he promptly side
steps the issue by declaring that Phila-
delphia did not have public owner
ship, but only ownership by political
grafters. The humor Of this is ap-
parent when one considers that one of
the principal objections to municipal
ownership is that 1t tends to result in
Ownership by political grafters."
Politics Versus Efficiency.
On this point the opinions OF Pro-
fessor Commons are worth quoting.
Although he also has prediction
for municipal ownership, he evidently
assumed that it was his duty to give
a verdict in accordance with the facts.
His sincerity must be recognized even
by those who do not accept all Of his
conclusions. He and Mr.. Sullivan, edi-
tor Of the Clothing Trades Bulletin,
consider the labor aspects of the sub
ject. Professor Commons admits that
some municipal plants are politically
honeycombed" and adds:
1.-The appointment, promotion and dis
missal of employees and the wages to
be paid offer peculiar opportunities for
political and personal influence incon-
sistent with efficiency"
! Professor Commons finds that 1t Is
not unusual for public service COM
panies to appoint employees at the
behest of political bosses, but he notes
that in such cases the employee has
to make good in order to hold his po-
sltion, while In the case of city plants
the politicians influence is expected to
keep the man in the position even II
he is incompetent or negligent.
Municipal Employees Pull Together.
In Great Britain Professor Commons
finds that municipalization has pro-
duced "a spurious form of trades union
ISM" which was repudiated by prac-
tically unanimous vote of the trades
union congress in 1905 on the ground
that the Municipal Employees assocla-
ton is class rather than a trade or
ganization. Speaking of the advocacy
by some councillors of the dIsfran-
chisement Of municipal employees be