Evening times-Republican. [volume] (Marshalltown, Iowa) 1890-1923, 1907-07-20
HANL[Y AND DARRON
GONE N[AR IO BLOWS
Warning of Lawyers Makes
Climax in Argument of
Haywood Case
ACCUSES pARRow OF FALsEHooD
States Attorney Has mo Excuse to
Offer for Orchards Double Dealings
Defense Has Attempted to Make
Much Of Railroad Wrek-Repeats
Testimony Of Plotting.

Boise. Idaho. July 20.-Chief Pros
ecutor Hawley resumed his argument
in the Hayward case this morning
Hawley first devoted his attentions to
the alleged attempt to wreck a train
on the Florence and Cripple Greek
railroad. This matter came out in
Orchards testimony" said Hawley,
but It was absolutely immaterial to
the issue Ore involved. But the de-
fense has taken this incident, and has
tried TO build up out of it a conspiracy
on the part Of the mine owners against
the Western Federation Of miners"
Orchard admitted he had reported
in the employ of the mine owners as
sociation and to the railroad. The de-
fense has brought two women wit
nesses here to testify they saw Orch
ard in one of the detectives room on
many occasions. These women saw
this man but occasionally over Ave
years ago, but they came here and
swear positively as to Orchards
identity, and to the number of his
visits. Such evidence as this speaks
for itself"
Orchard undoubtedly was trying to
secure money from all sources he could
and l am not going to defend him for
his doubt dealing in taking money
from both the federation and the rail-
road company l am not here to paint
Orchard in anything but his true col
ors There is but one claim we make
for him, and that is he has told you
the truth. This fact has been indelibly
fixed by all circumstances in the
case"
Hawley said Immediately after tbs
train wrecking incident Orchard was
of Miners. Taking up the matter Of
the attempted assassination of Cover
nor Peabody, Hawley repeated much
of the testimony of Orchard, as to the
plans he and Steve Adams laid to kill
the governor. Orchards testimony was
amply corroborated the counsel de-
clared, Mrs. Peabody, herself, taking
the stand to testify to one OF the most
important incidents. The attorney told
of Peabody's activities In the Colorado
troubles, and he declared the strongest
move for his taking off was connected
with the Western Federation of
Miners.
Hawley charged wilful perjury
against several witnesses, and argued
the truth of Orchards story. HsS said
two men in particular might have
been brought to contradict him but the
defense was afraid to produce either
Pettibone or Adams. He said Adams
had been brought to Boise the Jail i'll
Shoshone county In order that the de-
fense might use him as witness.
White to the lips. Clarence Darrow
sprang into action. "The statement is
false and the counsel knows it," he
shouted.
Hawley took step closer to the de-
fense table, and shaking his finger
close to Darrow's face, said, when
counsel says that he utters deliber-
ate falsehood.'
"The atmosphere was here charged
with danger. Sheriff Hodgins stood
up alert, his deputies drew closer in,
but Judge Wood, with sharp command
of insistent warning. patched up the
temporary peace. Hawley's argument
this morning was lacking in all at
tempts at oratory. 1t was a dispas-
sionate review Of the evidence with a
bold denunciation of method of the
counsel and testimony Of witness for
defendant.