Evening star., 1907-11-17
:AST ONCE MORE
DEFEATS THE west
Pennsylvania 0utpIays Michi-
gan by a Narrow Margin.
Two TouchdoWns Dis
allowed.

ANN ARBOR, Mich, November, 10
Eastern foot ball triurphed once more
over the west this afternoon when Penn
sylvania defeated Michigan on Ferry Field
by the score of 8 to 0. 1t was Michigan $
first defeat on Ferry Field Twice the
Maize and Blue teams have been tied on
their own grounds. but never before de
feated Weather conditions were ideal, and
5000 spectators saw the game. Pennsyl-
vanias score represents one touchdown
and goal, for which a cleverly executed
on-side kick which enabled Gallagher to
cross Michigans goal with the ball was
responsible
Both Michigan and Pennsylvania carried
the ball across the goal lines in the second
half on forward passes, only to have the
referee disalloW the touchdoTns and call
the ball back because of illegalities in
the plays. Both teams were in mag
nificent physical condition. and time was
taken out for injuries less than half
dozen times. 1t was generally conceded
at the close Of the game that Pennsyl-
vanfa showed superiority throughout both
halves. The Red and Blue kept the play
in Michigan's territory more than three
quarters of the time.
Michigan won the toss and elected to
defend the west goal Hollenhack kicked
off for Pennsylvania. and for the first
ten minutes of play the ball was kept
constantly in the field. neither team being
able to obtain decided advantage There
was frequent punting by both sides.
A short on-side kick after Pennsylvania
had worked the ball to within striking dis
tance Of the Michigan goal line brought
Pennsylvania her winning touchdown. Sew
eral men touched the ball and juggled it
before it landed in Gallaghers hands. The
Pennsylvania guard ran across the line
and placed 1t squarely between Michigans
goal posts. Scarlett kicked goal. This
ended the scoring for the afternoon.
Penalties Often Imposed.
Penalties were frequent for holding and
bff-side play, the officials being severe
toward both teams. Pennsylvania was
penalized Is yards once because Hollen-
back hurdled Rumney. Just before the
close Of the first half Michigan made its
irst use of the forward pass. The play
worked we'll and gained 81 yards. A
second trial was not successful Scar
lett breaking up Michigsn's formation.
and pennsylvania securing the ball The
first half ended with the ball in Pennsyl-
Vania possession In midfeld.
Both teams used the forward pass more
freely In the second half and each scored
q touchdown by it's use which was NOT
allowed. Pennsylvania had worked the
ball inside of Michigan's 10-yard line when
keinath made a clever forward pass to
Pauxtis. who carried it across the goal
line. The 80 Pennsylvania supporters
broke into wild cheering. but the officials
ruled that there had been an illegal for
mationNon the part of Pennsylvania and
disallowed the touchdown. Pennsy pro-
tested vigorously. but in vain
Michisans touchdown, which was dis
allowed, followed soon after. Following
an exchange Of punts, Michigan tried a
triangular forward pass which worked
successfully for good gain. Schultz
passed the ball back to Watkins, who
threw it over to Magoffin, drawing
Pennsylvania to that side, and the Michi-
gan captain then passed it to Hammond,
who advanced 1t % yards Another trick
forward pass followed. on which Magof-
goal
Cheers Cut Short.
The Michigan supporters cheered them
selves hoarse. but the effort was wasted,
the officials calling the ball back, declar-
ing that on the forward pass it had not
gone over the line of Scrimmage yards
outside of the point where the bali was
put in play. Michigan made tremendous
protest but it was useless.
Pennsylvania kept the ball in Mchi-
gans territory throughout the rest OF the
game, which ended with the ball in Penn
sylvania's possession on Michigans 90
yard line.
Holenback outpunted Hammond
throughout the game, and Scarlet also
played with marked brilliancy For Mich
igan the work Of Schultz, the giant center
was one of the features of the afternoon
He outplayed Dwyer, and broke through
repeatedly, making number of brilliant
tackles Watkins, at fullback, playing his
first big game. also did remarkably. well
Both teams showed a splendid defense.
Following was the lineup: