Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1907-07-15

Nnt NO1ks.
But that's because the gas is con-
hned?'' was suggested
Yes
suppose 1T wasn't confined, would
you allow smoking?"
No"
4 didn't think 80" commented Rich
ardson.
could Ignite gas was for the smoker 10
puff enough to fan the wrapper Into a
name--even then the wrapper would
nave TO be unusually light and dry.
ORCHARD RECALLED.
Harry Orchard was called to the
stand. AS in tho early stages nr the
trial he was preceded and followed by Il
deputy Today, however, there We're
no gun men" or detectives in the
guarding party.
Were You ever know as or called
shorty at any stage of your careery"
asked Prosecutor Hawley.
mo. SIR
Pat. Moran, the Cheyenne saloonkeep-
er testified that the Nevilles came 70
his saloon with a man called Shorty"
whom he supposed to be Orchard.
Orchard denied that he ever intro
duced Pinkeron Operative Gratias TO
Max Malich or Joe Mehliet or that
Pinkeron Operative Riddle introduced
iiihA ~ jug bdT1leE.
TO SHOW INSANITY.
The cross-eSsmination by the defense
was devoted to an inquiry into the
family history of the famous criminal,
II now being claimed that evidence has
been discovered to show a strong stra in
of insanity on the maternal side.
DO you know Patrick Mckinney"
asked Richardson.
Wasn't your grandfather named
Patrick Mckinney
His name was McKinney--thaps all
know?"
He was insane, wasn't he?"
II don't know"
"He may have been and you couldn't
recall it,"
II don't know. don't remember
him: | think no died before ] was born"
And didn't he hang himself?"
~ don't know"
We'll. didn't you have an uncle who
went insane and imagined he had conv
mitted a crime and hanged him$elf?'
Il never had an uncle who imagined
he committed crime, but did have
one who hanged himself. He had heeu
demented a year and a half His name
was Peter Mckinney-a son or my
grandfather on my mothers side
Were you ever arrested for arson
and burglary In Butter"
''1n Butter queried Orchard, pen~
sively as If TO be sure OF tho location
and not the crime,
Eyes"
mo sir. never was arrested in
Butte"
orchard denied that he had ever told
q man named Brokaw that he had been
IN the employ of the Plnkerton detec-
tive agency for five years.
"On the witness stand you said, Mr..
Orchard, you knew nothing about n So
called inner circle of the Western Fed
Grafton of Miners and yet IN the first
installment OF your story which has APP
peared in magazine you devote par
agraph to the inner circle. How "
that?"
An objection from the state was
quickly sustained by Judge Wood.
I'VE are not going into that matter"
remarked the court.
Orchard here left the stand. Counsel
for the state said he might be recalled
once more later OH in the case.
Walter Bynum, plumber of Denver,
Colo. testified that he saw Pat Moran
in Denver in June. 1904. Orchard in
his story said he sent Moran 10 Denver
10 get $500 from the federation. Moran
denied that he had gone 10 Denver in
June for any purpose. Bynum said he
knew Moran well and could not be
mis- taken.
ATTY. sABIN ON STAND.
Il. NJ. Sabln, an attorney OF Idaho
Springs Colo. was next on the stand.
He said he knew Detective Lyle Gre
CORY, who was killed by Harry Or
ohard. Gregory had been engaged by
the prosecution to secure evidence In
the case of conspiracy growing out Of
an attack on the Sun and Moon mine.
The defendants were IA members of the
Western Federation OF Miners, Include
ing d. c. Copley, witness for the de-
tense In the present case. The defense
has claimed that Gregory had nothing
10 do with anything in which the
federation was interested.
The witness Sabin prosecuted the con-
spiracy case and Atty. Richardson was
leading counsel for the defense. On
cross eXa mination the two got into an
aiterca .lgn as to whether or not there
had been a discussion among the citi-
zens to the effect that the detectives
employed by the prosecution had not
earned r'ieir money. Atty. Hawley
ohJmed IN and Judge Wood after lis
tenlng to a running fire OF questions
and answers among the attorneys.
caused a wave of laughter by announce
Ing In a loud voice: zone witness ut
a time, II you please, gentlemen
Richardson and the witness were at
hammer and tongs from the very first.
"rhose men were all given a verdict
VI not guilty, weren't they?'
That's true; no one has ever denied
you the glory of that victory replied
Sabin.
I'm not asking for glory. I'm asking
tor facts" said Richardson.
We'll, the facts as i saw them were
that these men, every one OF them,
were guilty"
Richardson wanted TO have this last
answer stricken out but the motion
was denied by the court.
Richardson drew out the fact that
ut the time OF the Sun and Moon ex-
plosion, Sabin and so other members
Of the Citizens alliance were placed
under bonds TO keep the peace,
The witness denied that this was the
reason the federation men had been
but those cases were all tried by
special prosecutors and the district at
torney had nothing to do with them
Eyes, but 1t was because the district
attorney was what you called MN at
the trial nonentity'
Sabin said he was paid some money
for his services at the trials by the
Sun and Moon Mining company.
The luncheon recess until 80 y. m.
was taken as the cross-examination be-
gan.
--------s--s-s----------