The Pensacola journal. (Pensacola, Fla.) 1898-1985, 1907-07-30

| SdlO.
Il want to thank the people Of
Boise for the kindness to my wife,
my mother, my family and nv
| friends"
There has been widespread svm.
| patty here for Mrs. Carruthers, the
prisoners mother. Senator Borah.
| the verdict, said:
The Charge to Jury.
Inquiry among the jurors after their
| dismissal revealed some of the ele-
ments entering into their decision
Samuel d. Gilman, the last man to be
won over to the defense, declared
that majority of the men seemed
convinced that the general tone Of
the courts instructions indicated that
the defendant should be free. Final
| ly Mclean, who voted consistently
for acquittal from the first, declared
| that the judges instructions seemed
to settle all doubt as to the course
he should take
Juror George Robertson, the good.
natured Scotchman at whose house
here in Boise Gov. Steunenberg board
ed for more than two years. said:
l. HOJ ICCOHC1l6 lily sell 10
voting any other way than with the
think that under the law and the
evidence there was nothing else for
US to do. The last fellow who held
out against acqUittal belongs TO the
same frafernal order that | do There
was some talk of compromise on a
second degree verdict, but we vDuld
not stand for that"
There are many in Boise who are
inclined to the opinion that a con.
trolling Influence with the jury was
their disbelief of Orchards testimony.
Haywood Makes Statement.
In the days of jury selection, a vein
of prejudice against Orchard was IN,
covered Unexpectedly when the tria.
panel was more than half completed
One of the proposed jurymen volul
teered as an excuse the informatiOG
that he would not could not, beliere
Orchard under any circumstance
This was a cause. for his challenge
and removal. and thereafter the At.
torneys for the state inquired careful
~ into the matter of antipathy TO
confessing witness.
Tonight Haywood issued the follow
ing statement:
Il appreciate the support of the
working class extended to Us by work
ingmen throughout the country.
hope to be able during the coming
year to personally express my appce-
citation.
Il have no feeling nor iIl-v'I
toward any person. l am charitaNh
toward ali. My intention is TO 20
back to Denver and take up my wor.
where | left off when | was placed
under arrest. l do appreciate the
kindness and consideration with
which my family has been treated by
the people of Boise. ! do appreoia .,
and in SO stating, express the SENT
ments of my companions in jail. The
courtesy extended to us by Sheriff
Hodgins, Former Sheriff Moseley and
his deputies.
I do not blame Gov. Gooding for
the position he took"
Darrow's Comment.
Clarence barrow of Chicago. whcs7
argument to the jury was largely a
special plea for labor and an attack
on the methods of the state and u
counsel. said:
The trial has been fair: the iud18
and the counsel consider
ate. We have no complaint 10 max"
do not desire TO be understood as
wishing to reflect upon the integrity
OF the state or the people OF IGaao-
HadI been governor at the time S'fn-
nenberg was murdered, and had he
evidence been brought to me that
was brought to the governor Of ta.s
state, l would have done probably
just what Gov. Gooding has done.
Senator Borah has conducted his par
of the case with marked fairness. and
with ability unsurpassed by counsel
in any great murder trial in TINS
country
John Murphy Dying.
JC<1 Murphy. general counsel Tor
the Western Federation of Nine
who, in spite of the fact that be i
wasted TO skeleton by consumDti0n.
has almost daily occupied a place a.
the defense table Throughout jhe
trial. was unable to be present al n"
closing argument or scenes. He K
now dying in the hospital here. Hay,
wood called on him early Sunday am
the scene between the two Is sa-4
to have been most affecting Hat
wood lifted the slight form OF the 4!-
ing man in his arms, and Murphy -
quoted as saying between gaspS:
Bill. in this hour Of your grea'
triumph. be humble and thankful
Murphy is not expected 10 i've
many days.