The times dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1903-1914, 1907-06-25

ETH LOVING.
icl. appeared yesterday In the Baltimore
,ly enlarged d photograph OF Miss Lov-
kffell down, Then Mr.. Estes said Help
Inc. help me. called Nick Reed, and
I'VE went to him" ss5
i Foster testified that Estes was I'M
the south end Of the car, about midway
between the, end and the doNE that
lo made no movement when he heard
LJudge Loving.
| Nick Reed, who was In the wagon
called attention to the fact that Judge
Loving was coming down tho road with
q gun under his arm.
fMr. Lee, on cross examl alton, caught
Foster in one OF his Important state
ments. which went to show that Estes
could have ESCAPED from n the
car, It turned out that Estes
could not have escaped had he wished
to do so. t33 4 5y
Nick Reed, Y q negro, was the next
witness called. He testified that he
\ was standing in q wagon up against
shot Estes.sa that he witnessed the
. deed. Judge Loving walked UP
ana said: II understand yonsisa are
the young man who ,buv rides young
4 ladies and drugs Them. Then lie shot.
Then Mr.. Estes said: NO, no, Judge,
and Judge loving shot agalln and
walked away fa va: q, &
Picked%up Ennpt, shells.
Then Mr. Estes called out and So Ia.
help ME, and 8Fayette and Il went q
him ana he said 4" Lift me up. ''ss1 said.
We can't help him" and i went out
and called Mr. McG innis. The defense
II did no vcrosst examine.
4 Russell c. Brown, q small Viii e boy.
d eleven y ears Of age, testified thaS he
: was ss,tt. thaS car hen p tesS was killed,
and I'll at he fsa W. Judge Loving Are two
shots at EsteRsf tII s,sad d n I'd So Lovinis
!, said to Estes: You are the young man
! who bpggy8ri dess ladies'" and then shot
4 him. TIe saw Estes's dead body five
: minutes after the firing, and he picked
up the empty shells Which Judge Low
!, ing threw out Of his gun. Russell was
not oss-examlned by the defense.
4 L. w. Wood TESTIFIED that he wo;''- et
! at the post-onlce at shlpmans, ant
u that he. saw the. body of Estes Just be-
! fore he died. He was about twenty
Ipatess away when the shooting &C.
! surred He heard the firing, and ther
7 went leisurely to the car, rcachin Z
\ there about two minutes after the
Z shooting and about minute before
lhe died, He said he saw Judge Low
,ling at the livery stable about five min
! utes later, and asked him II the bod,
!, Icould be moved. Judge Loving replied
a|Sthat. the authorities would take ch ff!'g !,
: of the body. He described the posi-
tton Of the body. Tho defense did no
) cross- examine
Did Not Conceal Gun.
+ william Powers, colored, said ~
St,v ~ ~ la q r
a fridge, which la the same as Shlprnan
y on the day Estes was killed. Judg'
V Loving drove up In a buggy and aske'
g him to hold his horse. lie held tn
n horse until Judge Loving returned an
J. took his horse and buggy, He sal
that a gun was in the buggy on IN
o floor OF the buggy, covered ~ iron
"a Iby the lap robe over the drivers knee
and partly in the back by Q coat
some sort Judge Loving took up IN
ligun, making no effort to conceal u
!, and walked off. It was then betwee
3 and 4 clock In the afternoon.
. . On cr1ss- esaminntion, 1t was brough
{ out that Judge Loving made no OF
Z tempt TO conceal his gun. The wit
: ness t,len stood aside. j{1 Vi s.
al Julia Hubbard, an old gcQlored " We
IS man., was next called, She testif1e
% that she saw Judge Loving In Low
l-H ingston on the day Estes was killed
IS He said Judge Loving told her to g
into the Estes store and tell M
II Theodore Estes q to como out. sh
X went towards the Estes store b.
IL mot "A hoy named Porcy. who told he
\, that Theodore Estes was not at II
d store. but was at tho station ST
70 then returned to Judge Loving an
9. told him, and said: 4"Wlll old man i:
l. tos dor" Judge Loving, said: mo
~ That was all she knew She was M
ls Gross-examlned. 5.i i. i s5t5sY5
l. Loving about mile from Oakride
% on tho day Estes was killed. jude
d, Loving was going towards Oakride
and witness was going TO IoVingsto
49, Witness said he saw nothing IN II
SIS manner of Judge Loving TO- arc use u
OF susp!cion that he was on an nnuau
IS mission. Mr.. Lee, on croaA- examlnatlo
20 Judge Loving without stopping. /
ne replied that hc had not stopped,
he LoyIng's Cousin 'rest,hex.
The question at issue here Ia r
AZ garding tho gun In the bottom OF Il
np buggy, ~. O, Loving, cousin
80, Judge Loving was next called. I
-. testified that has sa w j I'd &c Loving
lia the day Estes was lsi lled. Judge Loyil
af passed his place Of business driving
9, a pretty fair trot," Ho said that
ed was a hotel keeper, "a llyeryman,
or blacksmith, wheelwright and I'm "
80 dertaker, and performing the Ia
'or duties. hes took charge Of the body
ha Estes. Witness was going ION to IA
'ot scrlbenhe wounds when Mr.. Moore Q
III. 1ected, and judge Barksdale sustain
he tho objection. Witness was not eros
i'd examined. Ss II, A
nd & John M. shipnan, OF Loyingston, "
of the next witness, He said ho heir
to prepare the body Of Estes for b.
,or ial and took charge of the CLOTH
do. which he Wore when he was shot,
ELS: Witness hsf produce "a theE p!pt
ho stained clothes worn by Estes when
nd y
'e,:: crir,Er, Ir,r, rs,n r Ts1tnSAnE--A q