The Montgomery advertiser., 1907-07-16
QUESTION OF SANITY New Talk of the De-
 fense. ORCHARD BACK ON STAND Asked as to Condition of Maternal
 Grandfather. Richardson Endeavors to Prove that tAncester Ravea Over Crimes He Had Never Committed-Mur-
 derer Still Calm.
RICHARD BACK ON STAND

Boise, Idaho. July 15-Another war rant charging perjury against a wit ness who has testified for the defense in the case of the State of Idaho against w. D. Haywood. was issued this evening for c. w. Aller. formerly a telegraph operator and ticket agent at the Florence and Cripple Creek Rail- road at Cripple Creek, charged with the offense by the prosecuting attor- ney of Ada County.
 Both Aller and McGee. who was ar rested on the same charge, will be given an opportunity to furnish bonds, and the preliminary hearing will bs set to take place within the next few days.
 Eleven witnesses in rebuttal were ex- amined in the Haywood trial today Harry Orchard reappeared in the stand and was asked a few questions as to his acquaintance with some of the witnesses of the defense who have tes- tified as to his movements. On being turned over for cross examination, he admitted that his uncle. Peter McKin- ney. committed suicide by hanging. thirteen or fourteen years ago. Coun- sel for the defense asked Orchard if this uncle was not insane before he killed himself. and also tried to show by the witness that his maternal grand father was insane. his mania being imaginary crimes committed a long time ago in Ireland. Orchard denied all knowledge of the grandfather. but admitted that his uncle was demented.
 Contradict Aller.
 The entire afternoon session was ta = Ken up with the examination of wit nesses who contradicted the evidence given by c. w. Aller, who testified for the defense in support of the charge Of a conspiracy against the Western Federation of Miners. in which 1t is alleged the mine owners association. the citizens alliance and the Pinkerton detective agency were concerned
 Aller swore that he saw Orchard and C. C. Scott together at the depot of the Florence and Cripple Creek Rail- way on Sunday about three weeks prior to the explosion at the Independ. ence depot on the 9th day of June. 1904. Scott this afternoon swore than he was not in Cripple Creek at this time and a number of witnesses corroborated this AS result of this rebuttal testimony, information was sworn out after court adjourned charging Aller with per- jury.
 The explosion of the residence of Fred Bradley in San Francisco, was again under consideration today. the State undertaking to show that the ef- rect or an explosion of Illuminating gas could not have been that described in the depositions taken for the defense In San Francisco. The general effect of an explosion of Illuminating gas could not have been that described in the dispositions taken for the defense In San Francisco. The general effect of his evidence was that the explosion at the Bradley home could not have been caused by gas.
 Much excitements was caused by a wordy engagement between E. F. Richardson and F.. M. Sabin, an attor- ney of Idaho Springs. Colo. Sabin was engaged in the prosecution of a num- Der Of cases charging members of tho Western Federation of Miners with crime and conspiracy during the labor trouble of 1903
 MT Richardson was the defending counsel in these cases. Sabin inttmat- ed his willingness to tell many things that Richardson appeared anxious to Keep out of the records and 1t kept Haywood's counsel busy heading the witness away from dangerous ground Sabin admitted that Richardson had beaten him and had cleared his clients but he managed to get before the jury his opinion that the defendants were guilty. notwithstanding verdict Of the jury to the contrary.