Abilene weekly reflector. [volume] (Abilene, Kan.) 1888-1935, 1907-06-13
STORY MISTAKEN
The Cross Examination Of Orchard
at Haywood Trial Has Ae-
cOmplished Little.
CLAIMaEsERvEOBOTHsIDEs
In Employ Of PInkerton Detectives
When He Met Meyer and Hay
wood-MlIItia Did Not Search
His House.

Boise. Idaho, June 8.--Counsel fol
William D. Haywood continued theil
attack on the testimony Of Harry Orch
ard at both sessions Of the trial Fri
day and centered their strongest as
sault on the events beginning with tine
explosion in the Vindicator mine and
ending with the earlier meetings be
tween the witness and the leaders Of
the federation In Denver. To the ex
tent that traffic with "the other side
In war OF labor and capital in Colora'
do was discredible they succeeded In
discrediting the witness.
Taking up the admission that Orch
ard made In direct examination that
be had been treacherous to his COM
rades in Cripple Greek by tipping off
. train wrecking plot, they developed
the fact that Orchard entered the en-
ploy Of D. G. Scott. who had charge Of
the railway detectives. orchard said
that with Scott he had met X. c. Sterl-
S.A..At-. 4 A. ..... - H.
'ns' ue'ooe'' ~ .ao onpios '" sne
Scott had paid his expenses and &C.
companied him to Denver on the trip
when first he had met Meyer and Hay
wood. He said that he had agreed to
report to Scott but that he was lying
W ulm' he'et intenuins J" m@Ae ~
po'V' W nini "nu nov, uiu may So
uine lopui', rug ue,ense a,'o IT, IT,
" DIV" 'na. DeS"Soe NO o'oou ~ WV
NV otler eiue oivnaia was ne'eI Nv
leSVeu Wy tne liiii'ia ~ Srippie oieeA
uuring tne'st.lAe. Urcnaru aum i',1
mat ocott nao told nln' II 'ne nllliIia
ln'erlereu WIN nlin' ne was " Senu
iOr MN anu Inae tne lniiitia never uiu
inVerlere Win nun OF SEARCH nis houSe.
olcnaru saiu tnaC no wen' W ooo''
llrst pecauSe he nau not peen pau loL
MS "ork az tne Vluulcator mlne anu
ne was jealous because no was gwen
nsru WorA IKE tne vnuica'oi JoD
Whi'e o'ner lnen gov me Sinipie 'asA
VI Tram wFecAins ny uiSpiaoins d ran
More CRIMES great ana slnall were au'
ueu 70 orcharos recoru pFiuay' ne
cripple Oreek woman VIII wnom ne
Dlgamy nau tnree SONS;
Orcnaru sUo'e nisn graue ore from
msssmate; ne steie TWO cases VI po"u-
er from Vlndicaeor NINE; ne seole
powoer 70 make one Oh tne pomDs
thrown lnto inc Vinuica'or coai plie
ana ne told q ne
Inc deiense enueavoreu III various
ways 10 tnrow tne snauo" oi uouD'
mo lmproDaoility AROUND inc "noie
'inuicaeor sCory ana tne alieseu oon
lection W. r. LAWS anu Wm' IaS'el
y WIN the aiiair ana tne circun
tances under winch orcnaru testilieu
70 met meyer ana haywood ana was
ald Ior the commission OF tne crime \
nd to discredit Orchards story that E
g was sent back to Cripple Creek =
nth unlimited credit and orders to
ommit any act OF violence that he =
AIRED to. They confronted Orchard i
18th Easterly and Owney Barnes and n
aved the way for the contradiction by
lem Of the story told by Orchard and 4
everal times during the day paved
le way for the contravertion of his :
,stimong on material points. Orch q
I'd stood the strain and test very i
ell and held tenaciously to the story !
. related Thursday and the day be, !,
ire.
Suddenly toward the close Of the
~ the defense took up the trip Orch
I'd made to Southern Colorado with
,owed that Mover feared N % soutb II