Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1907-07-16
A. J. Holman Described Condl-
tons in indicator Mine I'M
mediately After Explosion.
FLATLY CONTRADlcTED WOOD
In Reply to Richardson, lie said that
Conditions Demanded and Justified
Calling Out Of The Militia.

Boise July I6.--Rebuttal evidence
in the Haywood trial this morning
covered wide range. 1t started in
California, returned to Idaho and fin
ished the session in Colorado. Four
witnesses supported the general att
tack now being made by the prosecu-
tion on the evidence by which the de-
Tense hoped to prove perjury against
Harry Orchard. After Lawrence
Guibbinni had sustained Orchard as
to the condition of the Bradley resi-
dence in 1904. the scene changed 10
the Occur d'Alenes and q physician of
Burke swore to seeing Orchard in
Burke ON the day of the Bunker Hill
ana sullivan mine explosion. Witness
es for the defense have sworn to
playing poker with Orchard at the
same time In Gem many miles away
over the mountain.
A. I, Holman. mine superintend-
ent of Colorado, now manager of the
Golden Cycle mine, and formerly sup
erintendent of the Vindicator mine,
was called to contradict statements
made by the witness. Wood who des-
cribed the condition of the sixth level
of the Vindicator mine Immediately
after the explosion. Holman was ex-
tremely clrcumstantial and careful in
his description, using chart which
was placed on an easel for his con-
Venience. Mr.. Holman also told of
labor conditions and of attacks by
union men upon "scabs.'
In his cross-examination, Il. T., Rich
ardson went closely into the situation
in Colorado during the labor troubles.
Holman strongly supported the con-
tention that conditions We're such as
10 demand the presence of the milf
tary.
DR.. /. /. MCGEE, the witness for the
defense who is charged with perjury.
arrived in Boise this morning. He
readily gave bonds in the sum OF
$4,000. C. f. Aller. the other defense
witness who was arrested yesterday.
was given a preliminary hearing this
morning. He was represented by
Peter Breen of Butte. one of the at
torneys for the defense.
THIRD DAY OF REBuTTAL.
The third day of the states case
in rebuttal against william u. Hay
wood was begun with Lawrence Cub
binni, the San Francisco grocer again
on the stand. He was recalled at the
request of the defense. He was asked
a few additional questions as to geo
graphical locations in the neighhor-
hood of the Bradley apartment house.
A. c. coGswELL.
A. c. Cogswell OF Wallace. Idaho.
followed Guibbinni. He was called
further to impeach Dr. I. l.. McGee.
n witness for the defense who Is an.
der arrest and who has been brought
TO Boise from Spokane where he was
taken into custody, Or. McCiee tes-
tllled as to certain dates by fixing the
date OF county Republican conven-
ton IN Wallace. Mr.. Cogsweli who
was permanent chairman OF the con-
Nention. gave different dates The att
torneys for the defense moved to
strike out the evidence as immaterial.
and when this motion was denied they
declined To cross-eXamino.
while Cogswell was on the stand
the state offered In evidence a copy
Of the Idaho Tribune published at
Wallace ana identified as the officinl
organ OF tho local unions OF the Vest
ern Federation OF Miners at that time.
The paper contained three column
account Of the plowinc-up Of tho Bum
ker Hill and sullivan which tho
state desired 10 place before the jury
H. answer 10 Atty. Darrow's opening
statement that tho defense would
show that the crowd which attacked
the mill was an unorganized mob. In
the argument which arose over tho
admissibilty Of the newspaper. Atty.
Hawley, for the state. and Richardson.
for tho defense had a sharp clash ana
personalities were INDUCED In fer the
first time since tbs trial started
Judge Wood took the matter under
advisemont, Indicating that he prob
ably would not admit the paper in view
Of the fact that the defense had intro
duced no evidence in support ~ tho
opening statement by counsel for the
defense.
DIR. Il, r. AWARD.
Or. Edward n. Award. a druggist OF
Burke, ida, Was called and testified
that he did not sec Harry orchard
about town during the time the mob
had gone 20 Wardner 10 blow up the
Bunker Hin mill He ala see Orchard
however immediately after the train
got back.
ON cross-examinatlon Award said nc
had no personal grudge against the fed
Grafton although he had a member OF
u arrested for ordering him out OF tho
country he denied that he had over
had any trouble on account OF insanity
or that his wife had sued FOR divorce
on that ground. Ho was not living
with his family, however
A. T, HOLMAN.
a r, Holman, mine operator Of
cripple creek next took tho stand Al
the time Of the strike Mr. Holfnnn ,Vaa
In charge of the Golden Cycle mine.
Prior 10 1903 pc was IN the Ylndlnatot
mine. Tho Witness told of some per-
HOaaI elDeflAnlaa With tina at.lf.A -.