Albuquerque morning journal. [volume] (Albuquerque, N.M.) 1903-1926, 1907-07-19
Attorneys for Defense Contest
for Same Latitude Allowed
State in Evidence to Show
Conspiracy,
JUDGE WOOD EXPECTED TO
RENDER DECISION TODAY
Bitter Denunciation of Pinker-
ton Detectives and Their
Methods by Mr. Darow the
Feature of the Session.

IBy Morning journal Special Leased Wire.I
Boise. Idaho. July 1S.-A day of ar
rumcnt on the admissibility of points
Of evidence followed the announce
ment from the defense that thew had
mo- further witnesses tO offer in behalf
of William ID. Haywood. The jury
was not brought into court Judge
Wood having been informed by coun-
sci of their decision to rest without
offer of sur-rebuttal testimony. Clar-
ence DarroW spoke for an hour and
half of the morning session. Senator
Borah replied I'm the afternoon ana
was followed by +. f. Richardson.
Judge Wood viii probably announce
his decision tomorrow.
The point argued was the effort H.
exclude from consideration by the jury
the evidence offered by the defense t.
show. 10y proof of deportation of min
ors from and the employment of de-
tectives in the Cripple Creek district
of Colorado, that conspiracy was
formed among the mine owners and
the citizens of the district to prevent
the employment Of members Of the
Western Federation Of Miners and the
position taken by the Haywood de-
Tense that Harry Orchard was em-
ployed by the Mine owners associa-
tion through detectives, to commit
crimes which were charged to the fed
Grafton. and public opinion aroused
against the union workers and Il
therefore followed that if the cOnspir-
a,E. evidence for the state WAS admit
rpdNthe dpiehse nad the rigu t0 SNOW
counter conspiracy
In the absence Of the jury the argu-
ment gave counsel an opportunity to
take a wide range IN commenting on
the methods employed on both sides. |
Mr. Darrow was imprisoned and vi |
n.
chard and the Pinkertons.
Senator Borah confined himself |
largely To the legality of the question |
of ddmissibilitN. He spoke for an |
hour. forcefully reviewing the evidence |
and claims made by the defense which /
of the alleged conspiracy between the !
mine owners and the Pinkertons that
any such conspiracy existed.
Mr.. Richardson argued that a con |
spiracy had been shown by a contrib |
utory effect of an the evidence intro- |
duCcd by the defense and closed with |
the statement that n the court saw III 4
90 exclude the evidence bearing on the |
Colorado situation, introduced by the
state. counsel for the defense would /
ho satisfied to see their evidence /
barred from Introduction.
j. H. Hawley will open the argu-
mcut for the state at 10 O'Clock to-
morrow morning. II is expected th Q
he viii take the entire day.
D1rrow was the first 10 speak t'-
day After referring To the latitu o.
allowed The state by the court, Darr 81
took up the Occur d'Alene troubi
saying that Haywood az that time was
an obscure member nf a local union ~
ihe federation hundreds of miles from
The scene of the disorder
parrow spent some time discussing
and citing authorities az 90 the mater
3D. u #..... A. b.
.raiust Governor Steunenberg on IN"
lnu az Harry Orchard. lie charged
Ihr independence depot explosion tp
Detective Sterling. He charged also
ihat Pinkerton detectives had joined
unions and fostered riot and disorder
We closed with a whirlwind appeal
Tor the right TO show the alleged cone
spilucy against the Western Fedora
Jon. To the employment OF detcc-
lives Darrow declared most or practi-
'tlN an uf the testimony in the cas-"
was secured by the Pinkertons. and Do
would Doe impossible To disassociste
hem and their methods from the iS-
sue.
He said that the defendant was COM
rellcd in rcfutatiou Of the charge of
nc murder Of Governor Steunenhcrg |
Zoo meet an sorts and conditions Of al
legations The state was allowed
through Orchard 90 bring IN something
Z bout an alleged attempt Co wreck n
rain. and of course this defendant was
hold ur as the guilty party.
Was it immaterial for as TO show q
Iaf an attempt was made by detec- 3
ives in the employ Of the railroad
Hmpauy and mine owners association
= cause this wreck? ] think not.
Neither was IL Incompetent FOR as 10
Dow thar the men who perpetrated
ln crime merely wanted o. trump up
Mother charge againss the Western
'rdoration."
A. ta the Bradley explosion Darrow
300 if WAS entirely competent tn pro-
fused by gas 10 was also proper to
how that tho Vindicator incident :
Ent have been an accident rather
Dam design. NJ
senator Borah began his address in (
plY O. Mr Darrow at 1870 p. m. He .
Iu that counsel for the defense ln t
opening address % the jury
aimed that conspiracy existed be- ,
."eu fhe pinkcrtnn deferfiVes. the ,
vino owners assuciation and the Cifl- 4,
OF alliance tu drive the Western !
.lerafiln ~ Miners out of Colorado :
POI that many OF the crimes charged /,
the Western Federation of Miners ,
nre in fact committed as Incidents of e
% conspiracy to get rid 70 the union
"Huf when We came 10 sift the mat
nut continued senator Borah
Nh1f 10 We fnd9 That the cone &
piracy had nothing 20 do with the 7
\ Indicator explosion. That was an ac- 2
.itnL The conspiracy had nothing On 3.
Alih the attempt on BRADLEY That p
gas explosion. The cuuzpira n ] F.
lA4 mHfNiUu a. a. u.ffH che death M ] z