The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1907-06-16
STATE WILL SOON FINISH
CASE AGAINST HAYWOOD
cnntinnod from Page One.

continued from l. aye Nh'.
of the pistol with which Orchard said the
mine i'm the sixth level was lired Nay
ior round the fragments himself. They
were offered i'm evidence, objected TO and
Navlor also Identified a piece of wire
found wrapped around the guard rail-,
the lifting OF which. orchard said, pulled
the trigger that fred the powder Of the
Vindicator.
the National Guard was called out IN
September. 1906. during the Cripple Creek
strike. He was in charge OF camp
about mile from the Nindicator and a
detail was on duty near the shaft.
Brings in Mine Owners.
Richardson asked the witness If he
knew anything Of the detailing OF Tour
men 10 shoot up the toolshed OF the Eln-
dicator In the course of his eNanina-
ton Richardson mSinuated that Inc DC
fcnse would try 10 show that the Nlhdl-
Gator owners were behind in the payment
nj their assessments TO the Mine own
ers' association and that the soldiers were
employed to create disturbance ana des
association laid to the door of the West
eru Federation of Miners -
Naylor said he knew nothing OF any
arrears due from the Nindicator mine
He is now assistant secretary of The
Mine Owners association, but was not
connected with that organization curing
the strike Inc witness was asked II ne
did not have decided animosity against
members Of the Miners union,
'I don't know that ] have, replied
M Were Yer YOU with Maj Tom McClelland
when he said. To hell with the Constitu-
tion,?"
''or with sherman Bell when he said.
To hell with haheas corpus, well elNS
them post mortems'?
But You heard Of these statements?"
Nayior declared he had nothing 10 do
of ~
ors from Cripple Creek. although he
made many arrests some OF the miners
Sc, arrested being men of family. 90,
Naylor said he succeeded Michael CON
ners as Marshal OF Victor Colo.
And YOU were appointed because ot
your well known hatred and animoSlty
ers?" declared Richardson.
Il don't know that ! was
Marshal Sent to Pen
Naylor was asked as 10 the character
Of various men who served under nm as
Marshal. among them kid Waters, Jim
Warford. Jack Bowman and others
questions as 10 whether or not these
men were known as professional gun
Attorney Richardson developed the fact.
however that Warford is now In the
penitentlary. Naylor denied ever having
known Tom Hogan or Harry Orchard.
Mr. Richardson indicated the purpose
of the defense 10 attempt further 10 con-
meet the Mine Owners association with
with the independence depot explosion
10 which Orchard has confessed on the
stand, duplicating Steve Adams The
attorney wanted To know II Naylor had
not attended a meetieg with Orchard
and others al Victor the evening OF June
;, 1904. and il he had no, informed the
militia To be ready-that something was
going to happen. Naylor denied that ne
had ever attended any such meeting and
said the militia was not on duty at the
s'Ruf vo,, wore anxious To get the mill |
tia back, weren't yoU?'
mo, sir; there was no reason TO have
them there
Richardson next attempted to show
that as Major Of militia, Naylor took all
OF his orders from the Mine owners asso- !
citation, but the witness declared he knew
of no orders coming from the association
al any times
Former Gov. Peabody, who was in of
fee at the time of the Cripple Creek
disturbances. entered the courtroom while
Mai NaYlor was under cross -eNamina-
ton. He was accompanied by his wife
and daughter. They were given seats in
side the bar. Q few feet behind Haywood |
N5vlor said the troops were ordered
into Cripple Creek September T. 1903. but |
wben the spike pulling matter or alleged |
attempt 10 wreck q Florence Cripple |
Greek train, came up.
Heard of Soldiers Looting.
Naylor said he heard about the footing |
of union stores by soldiers, but ne had |
nothing 10 do with IL; in fact the body
Of the militia was not on duty at the !
soldiers in the territory. Some OF these |
soldiers. Naylor added. were blown up on |
the platform Of the independence depot
After the union men We're deported |
from Cripple Creek" asked Richardson. !
did you wear one of those buttons |
which read, They can't come backY'
Did you sing the song that ended up
that way?"
mo sir. never heard Of the song"
Senator Borah questioned the witness |
briefly on redirect |
"Do you wear, or have you worn ne
began. = button entitled, l am one OF
the undesirable citiZens?'
NO, sir said Naylor with a smile; |
i've never seen one OF those
Maybe he doesn't need one. chimed |
in Attorney Darrow Of the defense
ed Senator Borah.
We'll. then. maybe we'd better gel
him one" drawled Darrow.
Naylor said he made an investigation oi
the blowing UP OF the Independence
depot where fourteen, men had beer
wire and n chair round. to which one
end OF the wire was attached. The wire
led some distance up stdetrack from the
depot.
On e-cross- examination. Richardson
wanted 10 know II Clarence Hamlin. sec
rotary OF the Mine Owners association
II tho time. did not start the riot at
Cripple Creek the day of the Independ-
ence depot explosion BY a speech in
which he urged the people 10 drive the
Western Federation men out OF the dis
trict. Naylor said he heard nothing OF
the sort; that Hamlin had spoken only
three minutes when the shooting began
Miners Hall Fired On.
And then the militia rushed out. and
the first thing they cid was 20 riddle the
union hail. wasn't it?" asked Richardso
That was not the first thing, no. sir"
The hall was fred on, wasn't it?''
Yes. sir; but not very many times"
How many?"
"Oh. sixty or a hundred"
You bombarded the place?'
Well the miners boTnbarded us from
the place and we bombarded them in the
place. said Naylor amid a ripple OF
laughter
Naylor said he never heard OF any men
being hogged before deportation. The
major was asked with reference. To the
deportation OF some men in December
l9O4. lie said they were not miners AT
all, but hangers-on
They certainly We're undesirab bic cifi-
Eens, said The witness. 4
=. But You determined their undesirable
, " Nourself?" suggested Richardson
There wasn't any chance to doubt"