The Washington herald., 1907-07-16
STATE LANDS BLOWS
Days Rebuttal Testimony
Goes Against Haywood.
ORCHARDS CRAZY FOREBEARS
COmmOnveR Ith Gets This Claim in
When Multi-murderer Is Recalled
TO the Stand, but Witness is Cool
and Collected ana R0uts WouId-be
observation-disclosures Have Row.

Boise. Idaho, July 15.-sevcraI pretty
sharp jabs were handed on the defense
to-day by the State when its rebuttal was
resumed.
some OF them struck hard az statements
made by witnesses for the defense's s state
ment that We're intended to destroy Ger
tain features Of Harry Orchards story
On the other hand, the recall Of Orobar5
10 the stand gave the defense a chance 10
read some statements made by man
from ;he vicinity of the place where OR
chard lived In Canada. This man wrote
that Orchards maternal grandfatber
Patricil Mckinney, while he was much
respected by everybody who knew him
lost his mind in his later years and had
10 be put under restraint.
orchard said he knew nothing about
that and never saw his mothers father
Inc deiense's correspondent also wrote
that Orchards uncle, Peter Mckinney
son OF Patrick, had hanged himself or
chard said that was true.
Was he insane2' asked Richards,
He was supposed to be a Iittla do
mented over family troubles g" renl,a5 a.
chard
orchard was not on the witness stand
more than fifteen minutes. but wbiIa n.
was there he produced the same imnres-
sion Of coolress and perfect self-eom-
ihahd that he made when he first told
his story to tie jury.
Doesn't Know Pinkerton Ma,
The State asked him If he had syo-
been called Shorty" a name that Pat
Moran, the Cheyenne saloon-keenar said
he had heard applied to him. Orchard
said nobody had ever called him thar ca
far as he knew. He also denied that he
ever knew A. w. Gratis, one of the PIN
kertOn men.
The State wanted to offer the first ir-
staliment Of an autobiography which
has Just been published in a magazine
10 show that the term Inner circle, as
applied to the leaders Of the Was+er,
Federation, had been taught Orchard
by Mcfarland, but the court held II 10 !
be immaterial
II was Pat Moran whom Orchard testi- |
ned ne sent from Cheyenne to Denver IN |
June 1903, after the Independence ex-
pioslon Of June 6, to get $500 from PETIT |
bone Moran, on the witness stand. de- |
MED this fatty, declaring that he was not |
IN Denver In June, 1904, or anywhere near
that time
&. w. Bynam, Denver plumber who
knew Moran well and used to worl[ v,i+t
him for Pettibone, testified this nornine,
that not only was Moran In Denver IN
June o. that year. but that he saw him
and spoke with him on the fifteenth dav
Of that month.
Lawyers Have Row.
Richardson cross-examined the u,,tro..
at length, but he made absolutely no
Impression on him. There was q fine
row between LAWYERS wber
+. Nj. Sabin. an attorney of Idaho
Springs got into action. The defense had
sought TO prove that the Federation man
had never been bounded by I.yt Gregory
and therefore could have had no interest
In the Gregory murder, which Orchard
swore they hired him and Steve Adams
to commit.
Sabin testified that at Idaho SPRINGS
Gregory was employed to get-testinoonv
against the Federation members ubo
We're accused of conspiring to blow nm
the Sun and Moon Mine, and thar he
would have been a witness in an arson
ease against other Federation men If he
had not been killed before the case could
be brought to trial. Richardson wanted
to know If there had not been some
debate among the members of the Cit
zens' Alliance at Idaho Springs ae 70
whether Gregory and other guards they
employed were worth their wages
only in your mind, think. Mr Ricb-
ardson,' said Sabin. ''o''
The row followed, Hawley. Richardso,
and Sabin all talking at once 60 -, tba.
the court was obliged to interpose Gov, S-,,,'
ng; '-S
one witness at a time, gentlemen"
Dewey Recalled to stand
William Dewey. the nonunion no,,o.
who, on Saturday. testified that w
Davis led the mob of union men +ba+
blew up the Bunker Hill and sullivan
dill at Wardner, April %, 1888. was re-
salled first thing this morning. and testI.
led that the w. F. Davis who was in