New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1907-02-17

Hale said he had been busy on appropriation bills
sation he had had with Mr. Hale from which he
the M the Hale showed a16 de
cared that it was most unusual to make private
td Res en- the to private
TO stand up here and refer to little interlocutory
Senator into never ot DO II should DAD would get e
nm Mr. III Tmsn replied That he had no suspicion
privately and another way publicly.
The Senator grows more and more offensive
right to intimate that have said anything to him
on this proposition in any way as indicating how L
Mr.. Tillman resented being 'rectured." He
ness and offered to withdraw, If he honoraby could,
Defending the position Of the conference commit
tee Mr. Lodge said that the conferrees had not ex-
Senator Stone addressed himself TO the low vital
nierous Communicative Indicating that in opera
ton this clause would be discrimination against
planned that he understood the objection referred to
was not in the bill.
MR. CULBERSON's OBJECTIONS.
In opposing the passport clause Senator Culber-
son referred to the CaIfornia-Japanese situation
cause the President Of the United States in his
messages to this Congress has seen ut to misstate
japanese and the japanese taking their cue
nsca me Ga resident f assert claim that great In
me Pacf Coast In each Of his MESSAGES to
ton to the effect that the Japanese had been denied
the privilege Of EDUCATION, when the truth is that
the schools the white children of California at
1T. The situation that would result from, the 9doP-
ton Of the provision, Mr.. Cuberson said; would be
clude Japanese laborers and coolies and he VIII
n0ld Ilat authority and the exercise OF II IN aney
nes amd VII Keep out TIE lao9reTs and coolies
admit their children ndiscriminately to the public
schools OF san Francisco"
derstanding Senator Flint replied: 80 far as I
California delegation and the President with refer
ence TO the adjustment of the school matters Of
such agreement nor attended any cdnfeTen S be
wen ~ me Calf4Tnia delegation and the Secretary
s. Mr. Perkins said he wished to make the same
paper reports Of an agreement had been overdrawn.
The agreement. Mr. Culberson said. seemed TO be
and not with the California delegation in Congress
Of California He made an appeal foT the enaot
nsnt Of positive g PROVISION excluding the japanese
Mr.. Patterson regarded II as impossible for the
persons without giving serious offence which might
Mar SaE KIN s that he Win What
speaking plain words that the eject IS that for,
e!gn power has browbeaten the government OF the
this Union into surrender OF It's right to control
us t own afTairs The attitude OF this government
and offensive to the last degree It's attitude toward
One Of the Pesden ana favo2e
aphor1sIns has been to speak softly and carry a
Dig stick He seems TO have interpreted that in
this instance as to speak softly foreign nations
/ and carry a big stick for the backs of his own
people. l object 10 this provision, because believe
II Will and that II is intended to. the ExeCu-
i've with power TO cOerCe the people OF a sovereign
state INTO a surrender OF right control their
own affairs, and this IS being done upon the de-
mand of nation, made without shadow OF re ason
/ without r shadow OF right. without a shadow Of
/ foundaton, based upon any treaty stipulation
! the Constitution OF the United States
| Senator Newlands declared President Roosevelt
to be largely responsible FOR the Japanese situation
/ He has created movement the Pacific Coast
that VIII not rest until II ends IN japanese excu-
sion, he said
/ Mr. Newlands predicted that the United States
would not be able to retain the Philippine Islands
/ unless II retained the friendship Of ia pan
/ Although not liking the OF bringing N
! me legislation Senator Mallory, Florida,
/ ne should vote for the conference report.
/ senator Lodge AT this point asked for n ruling
on his point OF order against the resolution instruct
ing the conferrees to bring in provision positively
I excluding japanese lahoTers from the country
I offered Yesterday by Senator Culberson.
4 The Vice President sustained the point and SEN
atoT arTnack appealed rom the ruling the chair
/ roIlcaIl was had on the motion which Nr. Lodge
! az once made TO lay the appeal the table. The
vote was - TO Law the appeal the table and -
IN the negatiVe. the chair thus being sustained by
practically party vote Senator McE,nerv. Of
I LDusianas voted with the Republicans and Senator
/ La toilette with the Democrats
( rollcall.