Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1907-06-22


direct evidence TO show that Haywood
had anything TO do with the murder
on with tho conspiracy. which It Is
alleged was world-Widc and which
gave TO Orchard a rowing commission
10 80 out and murder anyone Hay
wood wanetd Killed"
quickly passing through the Nindi-
Gator mine and Colorado incident Mir
Richardson named the Witnesses. and
IN each case imprcSSively lnisted that
Haywood had not been connected by
the testimony unless Orchards story
was used to bolster II up.
IAking M the drafts issued by Hay
Wood in favor ~ Jack Simpkins, Rich
ardson said these were Innocent uans-
actions He dWclt at some length on
the draft dated Dec, n, 1905, in favor
of Simpkins
This, too. was an Innocent trans
action. and only Orchard proves any
connection You are obliged TO leave
Orchard ont
y, this point Mr. Richardson's ar
shWeul remained Centrrod for a long
cr time than any he had covered. He
tll''d the draft and concluded that
me evidence wug useless as showing
itlyWood's connection Here Richard
sea- changing his manner. raised his
voice
~ would SAY to your honor" he
shouted, that if Haywood were guilty
OF the blowing up oi the NiulcatOr
mine. which he is not. if Haywood
we're guilty of the conspiracy on the
life OF Peabody which he is not; II
he Killed Wally, which he did not. II
he planned TO kill Bradley, which he
did uot-even if all these things Werr
true. which they are not-all this
would be insufficient to connect him
with q crime on the body of Steuuen-
Hsr "a
miited iu states other than the state
of ldaho. aud this man Haywood
siands charged only with a crime COM
United within tho borders of The state
Of Idaho
We come. therefore, TO the PROPOSE
t0u-by whom does this man stand
connected with the murder OF SteUneu-
berg except by the mouth Of the man
who sat IN that witness chair aud
whose unsupported word is not worthy
OF belief ny any living persona"
Here for the first time Richardson
reached the point of defamation, he
tu,acd 10 the witness chair and shook
his clcnched hand at the place whore
Orchard sat Ton nearly a week under
his cross-eNammatiou. As he referred
iu Orchard he missed the words and
turned from the chair with a gesture
expressive Of the utmost contempt
Coy. Peabody came here. He has
been iutervip wed everywhere in this
Wv, ,gI,',,d H. rbj,,cs hr Nnnld
,,e,tt,. 60 ,,,,a,, be cot %ers Wber
-''tS ,,.t,n, a. no doo lie
M, t,.t ,r,.v ,i,'ir,, i'm oTico ne
,,.1,,, ~, Lis bn,,,e in canon CIV and
commenced To- remodel his house and
that some one pointed out To him a
mau as Thomas Hogan. That's all
From witness TO witness Richard
.,,t ,,ass,,a rontin,imc his ,eview of
MI, ,r.,,ir,,,,,, ana il ench case as
s"rtinc tbat tbern Was nothing 20 con
,,,o+ tIo,-,,,ond ,,,i+b In, murder TAX
d., 49,, ~ o,,idenra ~ X q stuart,
,a6o testi6nd ,rsterdav to having
,,ca,d Hav,vnn6 criticize and deuounce
Stclnenbere i'm 1898. during tho trou-
III ir mo Gno,,. Il, Alcnes Richardson
s.it
%y,r,,. ,,o,,, bono, ,vc can find g.
ooo 49, N, tdabn Gina ARC guilty of
W. ,,,,rda,, NJ sfa,ipsnbera. If a de-
r,,,,,iation n, Stounenborc made a
800 s,,jlt,, az hat ,niirder. Here was
tJntrToo5 v'hose brothers were on
r,asecd ana irrnrlson.d without trial
an5 barSbi,, trn.,ted and i'm strong
i,,,'-,,a,,, b." c,.iticized and denounced
H. a@5ion az IN. man who was re-
~ a.. tbn cnnsitions tben ox
Il,jt,,. .r,,;s 49,, In IS9e and stem
$50, 80 ,uI.d I'm iaOb Whv
enD' ~ ~, s,oinr ia accent
80, -, ~ srcl, tirnc ms owl
5arcn on witch to hang this man >"
~, ,o,,.,w,,in1 Mr. Richardson said.
"Now YOUR honor. have shown
Won he law and | have given YOU ths
facts as to the evidence, have pre-
S'i .,r,i. Ia aase has henn discussed from
ono end of his country to the other
~, t,a neysnaners and bv all peo-
,,1a-nmtil W. round extreme diffi-
eulty in getting a jury. 1t seems 10
~, tbat 70 Leave this case 10 a Jury
~, lie COW n,tIpitv Is TO leave il to
, :, 81 and nreiudice. when the rules
We iau, o,,cht "a Sisnose of it here and
,n,y ~ lbis were an ordinary case.
hoii,I,n nn cor,t would he slow TO
act aiong. the line of the motion we
49, Gi"1 bcrs ant YOUR honor is
h, t,,n,on ne ali ~ MS are human.
I IL vorr honor to separate the
i,,So,a t,,n, The humanity that con-
80 ne ali Hnrn IS thc flattest case
49,. s.rasartoJ 10 /, court of law if
~. l.avo o,,t The testimony of Orch
o,,I nc CyirninaI whose testimony
et, "" liz, "a no the greatest criminal
r., III H. aqas before. Here Is a case
ftot bas fallen hat without Orchard,
ond ali the testimony falls To the
e,N,,,d N,i,b,,it the aid of this foul
aan5 Of numbering crime. and this is
nu thn P5nkertons, can produce to
al' rs s 80 tran year of work.
II ask your honor 10 instruct the
,,,.,i ~ IN sis0 mn verdict acouitting
yyH,ss dafondaut"
''''' u''e'''''''"
BONAH REPL1'
. r,.,L y.ho In hehaIf of