The Birmingham age-herald., 1907-07-16

| first | installmeHt of your story which has ap- | peared in a magazine you devote a para | graph to the inner circle How is that?" An objection from the state was sus- tained by Judge Wood.
 Orchard here left the stand Counsel for the state said he might be recalled once more later on in the case Walter Bynum, a plumber of Denver, | testified that he saw Pat Moran in Dem
 yer in June. 1904. Orchard In his story said he sent Moran to Denver to get $500 from the federation. Moran denied that he had gone to Denver in June for any 1 purpose.
 Sabin Raises Cain.
 E. M. Sabin, an attorney of Idaho Springs, Colo. was the next witness He said. he knew Detective Lyte Gregory,
 who was killed by Harry Orchard. Greg ory had been engaged by the prosecution to secure evidence in the case of conspir- l acy growing out of an attack on the Sun and Moon mine. The defendants were four | teen members of the Western Federation of Miners, including S. D. c. Copey, a witness for the defense in the present case. The defense has claimed that Greg l ory had nothing to do with anything in which the federation was interested.
 The witness Sabin prosecuted the con- | spiracy and Attorney Richardson was | leading counsel for the defense. On cross examination the two got into an alterca- l tion as to whether or not there had been a discussion among the citizens to the eff ! feet that the detectives employed by the 1 prosecution had not earned their money. | Richardson and the witness were at 1t hammer and tongs from the very first. That's true; no one has ever denied you the glory of that victory" replied Sa- | bin.
 Well, the facts, as I understand them, l is that these men, every one, were guilty" | Richardson drew out the fact that at the 1 time of the Sun and Moon explosion, Sa- bin and several other members of the Git | izens Alliance were placed under bonds to keep the peace. The witness denied l that this was the reason the federation l men had been prosecuted. Sabin said he was paid some money
 for his services at the trials by the Sun | and Moon company. Question Ruled Out. After recess in the direct examination of the Witness Sabin, Prosecutor Hawley l began to question the witness as to the reason for organizing the Citizens Alliance i, on which the defense has laid much stress.
 He had gone along for some time when
 the defense objected on the ground of | immateriality.
 "The court thinks it immaterial" said Judge Wood, "and the objection Is sus- 1 tained."
 The witness could not recall any crim- inal act In the Idaho Springs district prior to the summoning of Detectives Gregory 1 and Baird.
 D. c. Scott, former special agent of the Florence and Cripple Creek railroad, was | called to contradict testimony of a tee- l graph operator named Aller who testified | that he saw Orchard in Scott's office in the depot at Cripple Creek in April, 1904. ] Scott said he left the employ of the com pany the last of March, 1904, and gave up his office in the depot at that time.
 He resumed service in August of the | same year, but did not occupy his former office in the depot until later. He de- clared he had not seen Aller during the time he was out of the employ of the 1 railroad.
 How many times have you seen Harry 1 Orchard to talk to him?p asked Darrow l on crosS-eXamination.
 Six or seven times" | "Where?"
 'In the Florence and Cripple Creek de-
 pot at Cripple Creek and at the Adams hotel in Denver"
 Attempts to Wreck Train.
 The first time he met Orchard was
 when he came voluntarily to tell about
 
 "Dld you ever give him any money?'
 ''Yes, $2 at one time and $15 when he | went to Denver to see Bill Easterly for me-"
 "You sent Orchard to headquarters of l the Western Federation of Miners"
 "We talked it over and thought Eas- l terly might be found around there." | Orchard told you he was not acquaint- ed at headquarters, didn't he?' | Yes"
 "So that the first time Harry Orchard | ever went to see Haywood. Mover or | Pettibone, it was money advanced by
 vol and on transportation issued by
 you?"
 ''I gave him a ass and $15 to go to | Denver and see if he could learn any
 thing more from Bill Easterly about the l train wrecking."
 Did you ever see Orchard in the pres-
 ence of K. c. Sterling, detective of the
 Mine Owners association?"
 "Yes, sir twice in my office in the
 Cripple Creek depot. I introduced Or
 chard to Sterling. No, never saw ster- 1 ling give Orchard any money" Scott said he knew Telegraph Operator | Aller and he had dined with him at his house in Cripple Creek
 Objections overrued. lAr. Hawley continued his examination | of Scott in redirect. A number of argu- | ments over objections by the defense to | questions by which Hawley endeavored to bring out the conversations between Or l chcrd and Scott occurred. The conver- l saton was finally admitted. The witness said that when Orchard came to SC him for the first time he in-
 troduced himself as a brother Mason. ! Scott told him to go ahead and tell his
 story. Orchard said that he and 'some of the Bull Hill boys" were going to
 wreck a train; that they had tried 1t | once and would do 1t again that night. l In this conversation Orchard implicated Parged and Davis as having been engaged | in the plans to wreck the train. The claim | of the defense Is that Scott with K. C. | Sterling drew the spikes and that Or | chard was engaged by them to commit many outrages and lay them at the door | of the Western Federation of Miners. | Mrs Lloyd Baker now of Chicago, but | formerly proprietress of the Miles hotel in | Denver, corroborated Scott as to his be- | ing a guest at the hotel April 24. 1904. and | for some time thereafter. The hotel regis ter and cash books were introduced in | evidence.
 Notes Pinned on Door. l On crosse examination Mrs. Baker said | she had special reasons for remembering l about Scott personally Attorney Rich ardson for the defense did not ask what | the particular reasons were, but MT. Haw- l ley did on redirect
 l Richardson objected. | The objection was overruled and Mrs. | pak said.