davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The Hawaiian star. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu]) 1893-1912, 1906-10-02

Basing his decision largely upon the
famous Northern Securities case and
also quoting the decision put recently
given by the Supreme Court of Hawaii
in the Hawaiian-Schuman Carriage
Company case, United States Judge
Dole this afternoon overruled all the
twenty-eight demurrers in the beef
trust case. The court, in a lengthy de-
cision, sustained the governments bill
at all points. Dole held that the COM
plant filed set forth sufficient facts to
show a violation of the Sherman anti
trust law, and the defendants are
therefore called upon to make answer
and prepare for defense Twenty days
of answers.
The case is one which probably en-
gagged more counsel than any other
case ever tried here AS far as the
demurrers were concerned, the attor-
neys opposed to ]. j. Dunno, Assistant
United States Attorney, who appear
ed for the overnment, were Holmes &
Stanley, Ballou & Marx, Kinney, Nc
Clanahan & Cooper Castle & Withing-
ton, c. f. Peterson, H. e. HightOn.
The complaint charged that the Met
ropolitan Meat Company and the cat
tie dealers of the Territory generally
were in a combination whereby they
absolutely controlled this marketing Of
meat, fixed prices and the amount Of
meat to be sent to Honolulu according
TO a regular mutual agreement, and
were generally engaged in carrying on
a combine which prevented any COM
petition in the meat business, Twenty
eight of the defendants filed demurrers
and twenty-five filed answers. With
the overruling of the demurrers, the
case is now ready to be tried on the
issue of facts. The government asks
for an injunction to restrain the many
defendants from continuing to carry
on the alleged trust agreement.
Judge Dole's decision is in part as
follows.
"In this case, however, the bill all
1eges that the combination, trust and
conspiracy charged was to be effected
by means of an agreement between
the Metropolitan and the remaining
The Hawaiian star. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu]) 1893-1912, 1906-10-02

defendants and each of them, whereby
the latter agreed not to engage in the
retail trade in beef cattle and fresh
beef in the Territory as competitors Of
the Metropolitan, nor produce, deal in
or deliver beef cattle and fresh beef to
or for any competitor of the Metropo-
Titan, and would prevent and discour-
age by every possible means and man
ner within their power all importa-
tions of beef cattle and fresh beef into
the Territory by anyone else, to or for
any competitor in the Territory of the
defendants or any fthem; and where
by the Metropolitan agreed with the
remaining defendants and each of
them to purchase it's entire demands
for beef cattle and fresh beef from
them at an agreed price, which should
be the same to each of them and to
apportion the quantities so purchased
among them, and that it would not
produce, deal in, purchase or import
into the Territory any beef cattle and
fresh beef other than sues beef cattle
and fresh beef as it purchased or
should purchase from them, and would
prevent and discourage by every pos
sible means and manner in it's power,
all importations into the Territory of
beef cattle and fresh beep by anyone
else other than the remaining defend
ants or any of them, and that it was
further agreed that the price so fixed
to be paid to each of the remaining de-
PENDANTS should not be changed in any
manner by the demand for fresh beef
in the localities supplies by the Metro
politan, nor by the supply of beef cat
ale available for such localities, save
by the consent of the remaining de-
PENDANTS.
is AN AGREEMENT.
Here is an agreement to do defin!t
things and to refrain from doing de-
finite things in order to effectuate the
alleged combination.
''In the case before the court the
remaining defendants cannot be COM
PEELED to engage in the retail trade of
beef cattle and fresh Beef in tn Terri
tory, but they may be enjoined against
Continued on Page Fivel.
The Hawaiian star. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu]) 1893-1912, 1906-10-02
SACHS, NEW GOODS.

An immense shipment of new goods
direct from the east has just been re-
ceived by the Sachs Dry Goods Co.
These are being opened up as rapidly
as possible and every department will
be complete with an entire new show
ing. Specials for Monday, Tuesday and
wednesday in Printed Bat1stes, Sheets,
Pillow Cases and Whit Lawn Shirt
waists are at big money saving prices.
The millinery opening will be of espe-
cial interest as the Gage new fall hats
will be on display. Panama canal con-
test now on. ~
The Hawaiian star. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu]) 1893-1912, 1906-10-02
CONTINUED on Page Flve).
AN ANTIsEPTIC LINIMENT.

For wounds. bruises, burns and like
Injuries there is nothing better than
Chamberlain Pain Balm It acts as
an antiseptic, forming a thin, imper-
ceptible film over the injured parts,
which excludes the air and causes the
injury to heal without matter being
formed, and in much less time than by
the usual treatment. In cases ofburns
it allays the pain almost instantly.
Sold by all dealers. Benson, Smith &
Co, agents for Hawaii.
The Hawaiian star. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu]) 1893-1912, 1906-10-02
EACH ARRIVING VESSEL

now brings us new goods all of which
were carefully selected on the ground
by our buyer who reports having
bought the largest and most varied
stock ever brought to Honolulu, which
consists of general stationery, musical
goods, novelties and toys. Your money
savers. Wall, Nichols Co., Ltd,
The Hawaiian star. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu]) 1893-1912, 1906-10-02
POLITICIANS
IN THE AIR
RESULT PROBABLE.

There are some sensational rumOrs
abroad regarding the political situation
and Republican leaders are considerably
disturbed over indications of a party
bolt that is endangering the local ticket
To add to the feeling of CONSERVATION
The Hawaiian star. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu]) 1893-1912, 1906-10-02

Try some of the coffee they serve
with whipped cream at the Star Oys-
ter House. 3lE.MfI
The Hawaiian star. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu]) 1893-1912, 1906-10-02

The best cup OF Hawaiian coffee in
the city. New England Bakery and
Cafe
The Hawaiian star. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu]) 1893-1912, 1906-10-02

it is now the talk that even Cupid is in
some danger, a sudden movement hav-
ing developed with unexpected Nicola
nahan strength. On top of all this is
The Hawaiian star. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu]) 1893-1912, 1906-10-02

HOT LUNCH. COLD DRINK.
You get the best hot lunch in the
city at the Criterion served with a cold
drink for 25c
The Hawaiian star. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu]) 1893-1912, 1906-10-02

Delicious pies and cakes. Candy
fresh every day. New England Bakery.
The Hawaiian star. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu]) 1893-1912, 1906-10-02
BEEF COMBINE AS
CHARGED IS A
TRUST, SAYS DOLE

TWENTY DEMURRERs THE
METROPOLITAN COMPANY AND MANY ISLAND CATTLE
DEALERS OvERRULED DOLE-THE ALLEGA-
TIoNs WHICH CHARGE UNLAWFUL COMBINE.
The Hawaiian star. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu]) 1893-1912, 1906-10-02

On and after Thursday, October
4th registration open from 7 to 9
a. M; II a. m. to Z p. m. and 4 to
8 p. m.
The Hawaiian star. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu]) 1893-1912, 1906-10-02

Continued on Page FiveJ.
The Hawaiian star. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu]) 1893-1912, 1906-10-02
DISARMAMENT
PROCEEDING
ASSOCIATED Press Gable to The Star.)

The disarmament
se at Cenugos but the United sta
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13
ADJUSTMENTS TODAY.
REPUBLICAN COUNTY eRAEr.

About the most disgraceful job Of
juggling bids ever seen here was put
through by the county commissioners
OF Salt Lake county in secret session
Monday afternoon. Having invited
bids for s3500O0 refunding bonds. the
commiss- oners permitted some of the
bidders. who evidently were working
IN collision, TO change their offers aft
OF the bids were opened. and capped
the climax by awarding the bonds to
2 h Rollins & Sons Of Chicago. who
we're not the hest bidders
Sickening as that sort of a deal IS.
the apparent purpose Of the scheme IS
even worse. BY accepting the bid Of
he Society for Savings Of Cleveland the
county would have saved S1,31250 a
year less in interest for twenty years
than ii viii have to pay on the bid ac-
copied Allowing for the bonus Of
$3.50 given by Rollins. the county is
still out Sl7.0G0-a difference which can
not be accounted for i'm any legitimate
wav
So far no explanation worthy the
name has been offered by the commits
sioners for this vautou. not TO say
criminal. abuse of d public trust. The
successful bidders have agreed to pay
che expenses of two of the commits
siCuers to go east, which may explain it
partially, but. in view of the fact that
the transaction viii have TO be closed
finally here, the trip is unnecessary;
and. whether It is necessary or not. the
commissioners have no business accept
ing faVors at the hands of bidders.
To the casual observer the whole
transaction has a crooked look. and if
legal means to prevent its consumma-
ticn can be found, IL ought to be
blocked. More than that. it should be
remembered that the fnefabIe trio
which put the deal through is a part Of
the Republican machine which VIII
have q ticket in the fall this year for
county Offices. The administration of
county affairs has been bad enough.
but this baldfaced defiance of the law
and of common decency ought to be
punished by the retirement Of the men
responsible for it, and the defeat of
the. party that put them IN Office. Sew
eHteen thousand dollars for a county
commissioners pleasure trip is about
the limit in the line Of graft.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13
pHONOGRAPH AND VOICE

John Philip SOusd, bandmaster. talked
interestingly the other day before the
Joint congressional committee on print
ing. Mr.. SoUsa was present to make an
argument in favor of the passage of an
act to prohibit the reproduction of
copyrighted musical works without the
consent Of the composer. incidentally
he denounced the talking machine. de-
scribing it as the destroyer Of musical
culture Mr.. Sousa said the talking
machine people had pirated many of
his compositions and that ne had not
received a cent for them. But it was to
Mr.. Sousa's theory that the phono-
graph had destroyed musical initiative
that the committee listened most
closely
Il tell YOU the human voice is not
heard as it used to be- said the band
master, and I prophesy that the vocal
cords may become useless for singing
by this disUse- Last summer I was in
one of the largest harbors. which was
filled with yachts went among
them Was there the oId-tine sing
ing2 No; it was nothing but the phon-
ograph. When I was boy it was the
custom for the young folks to sit on
the steps and porches in the evenings
and sing the old songs and the songs of
the day. But YOU don't hear those
songs any more. Go along the street
in the evening-it is nothing but the
phonograph."
Senator Smoot, according to a dis
patch, wanted to know if Mr.. Sousa
didn't think the decline in singing
among young people was brought about
BY the fact that people generally do not
live as close to nature as they once did.
Sousa could see nothing in that theory.
He persisted in laying all the blame on
the monograph. Really there is much
to be said on both sides Of the argu-
ment. Many people regard the phopo-
graph as an unmitigated nuisance
while others get from it almost their
only musical entertainment.
There is no doubt that the phOno-
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13

graph has served and is serving a use
ful purpose. There is no more innocent
form Of amusement, nor is there an
easier way OF acquiring a taste for
good music. We doubt very much that
the monograph has stifled the love
for singing. The trouble with Sousa
Is that he spends practically all Of his
time now in the larger cities. 1t is not
now and never has been the custom for
young people in large cities to sit on
front steps and porches and sing. Let
him go out to the country and he'll
hear the songs just as he used to hear
them when he was a boy.
And the photograph is helpful, rather
than harmful, to the professional must
clans. Sousa's selections played on
monographs have made his name
known where It would never have been
known had the monograph never been
invented. So it is with vocaIists and
instTumentalists Of renOwn- And it
may be set down as a certainty that
those who have heard from a phOno-
graph selections by famous stars will
never miss a favorable opportunity to
hear those stars in the flesh.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13
THE SALT LAKE HERALD: WEDNESDAY, JUNE 49, 1906

time, will leave Saturday for her home
in Colorado Springs to spend the warm
weather
MIS- Ledyard NJ. Bailey and her little
daughter Dorothy will leave the first of
next week for southern California
Mrs. A. G. Hurdman of Denver ana
PISS agnes Ryan Of St. Paul are visiting
Miss Margaret Ryan
The marriage Of Miss Lille Kearns and
Roy l. Barrett was sOlemnized at 8
CLOCK yesterday morning at st. Marys
cathedral, Rev Father CuTran Officiat-
ing. The young people left last evening
Tor an eastern trip. after which they will
be at home at 2426 Third East street.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13
THE MAIN STREET PETITION.

The petition of Main street business
men to the city authorities for a bet
ter sprinkling system on the street is
entirely reasonable, and there should
be no occasion for such a request
Apart from the discomfort Of the peo-
pie who have to endure dust and dirt
the damage to stocks of goods from
flying dust is enough to call for prompt
compliance with the request and an
immediate shaking up in the street de-
partment if it fails to remedy the evil
complained Of
While the subject is up. it may be
as we'll for the street department or
some other department to take cogni-
zanCe of the condition Of the paving
in the street. Regular "chUckhoIes'' in
the asphalt on the principal thorough
fare Of the city could hardly be posi-
BILE in any other city of it's size in
America; and it could hardly be posi-
bic here under any other administra-
ton Like other necessary improve
ments, the repairs to street pavements
have been sidetracked for lack of funds
because those funds are needed for ex-
ira salaries and superfluous employees.
1t will be worth watching to see
whether the pressure of a petition from
the business houses Of Main street can
accomplish d reform in the sprinkIing
and cleaning work. Nothing else has
had any effect. and if this plan works
IT will be tried in other directions.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13
MARRIAGE LICENSES.

Road. Salt Lake.
Elizabeth FIierbeck. Salt Lake.
ZSS0-Ge0rge 4. Pf7lps. Salt Lake.
Edna T. '-r sgs. Salt Lake
II IfiuUEley. Cowiey. Wyo.
Jessie T-crart. COwley Wyo
R0wi 'Orpe, Big Cottonwood
Tina Pete~~on. Big Cottonwood.
Clark. Park City.
Minnie Casey. Kansas City, Mo.
Dahl, Mammoth. Utah.
Mary Hagen. Mammoth. Utah
b Sterling. Portland, Ore
Fannie c. Bird. Salt Lake
J. Jones, Salt Lake.
Lille May Condie, Salt Lake
A. Fowler. Provo
Victoria Ottsen. Provo.
II Glover. Lehi.
Maud z. Webb, Lehi
W Packard. salt Lake
LOttle / Smith, Salt Lake.
B. Neal, jr, Cumberland
WyO.
Isabelle NJ. McCune, Salt Lake.
". COlhnger, Paris, Ida.
Amelia POulsen. Liberty, Ida
Hugh May, CardstOn, Alberta.
Ruvy Morris, Cardston, Alberta.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13
SUMMER EXCURSIONS.
Via Oregon Short Line,

Daily June LIST to September 18th. 1906
from Salt Lake City:
Portland or Spokane and return
Cvia Huntington $500. 49,. go. S42. OF
San Francisco and return via Og-
den and 5. P both ways 49,. 20 0r
San Francisco and return via
Portland one way ..-... ..... 81 II
Los Angeles and return via Og-
den & S. P. both ways ..... 81. %
Los Angeles and return via Port
land one way .................... s.. 80
PropOrtionately low rates from other
points.
Final return limit of tickets October
31st.
See agents for further particulars.
City ticket Office 2O1 Main St.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13

As We understand it, the county COM
the S35o,OO0 bonds was meant TO be
published in the joke column, but some
Of the bidders took it seriously.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13

Nj Booth probably thinks il curious
that any one should object to his ap-
pointment as United States district at
torney merely because he is unfit for
the job.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13

It is certainly time to resume the
annual crusade for a noiseIess Fourth
of July. Let US get things going be-
fore the cannon cracker man lays in
a supply of explosives.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13

The girl graduates look sweeter than
ever this year but we haven't heard
any Of them delivering essays on how
to make a home happy on s. a week.
Our girls aspire to a good deal more
than s. a week these times.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13

There might be more cheerful jobs
than being a trust these days The
beef trust was convicted in the United
States court at Kansas City yesterday
of accepting unlawful rebates.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13

It may come out, as some people
prophesy, that Grover Cleveland and
William Randolph Hearst will be
stUmping the country together in 1908
for Bryan, but we doubt it as much as
we ever doubted anything
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13

LaFollette Of Wisconsin lined I'D for
the Indians again in the senate Mon
day. He ought TO; he's a good deal of
an Indian himself
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13

The tariff should be modified from
time to time" says the. South Dakota
Republican platform. to meet changed
conditions" Those South Dakotans
viii shortly find themselves out Of
their party if Standpatter Lands Of
Indiana has anything TO say about it.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13

And another day has passed without
a special presidential message or a
question of veracity between Theodore
and some one else
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13

Mr.. Rockefeller, it is understood, has
kindly consented while on his present
trip abroad, to give the Sphynx a few
lessons in the art Of concealing facts.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13

The executive session Of the Water
melon Petitioners association seems
70 have been a bowling success-for
the Practitioners.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13

The unkindest thing We have seen
about Charles NJ. Schwab lately is the
statement that. by reason of a long run
of hard luck. he was compelled to re-
duce his stakes to five francs at a time
at Monte Carlo. 1t is gratifying, how
ever, to know that Charles received a
fresh supply Of cash and resumed his
former role OF native astonisher.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13

But what's a little matter of $1,000
to the board Of county commissioners
when the members don't have to
pay it?
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13

From BelIeviile, III, comes a report
of a 2-cent contribution TO the con-
science fund. But surely that sum
doesn't square the man who sent it.
If it does he is fortunate beyond the
great majority Of his fellows.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13

II you want the children to eniov
themselves, just send them to Cal
der's.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13

McCOnabay, the jeweler, forced to
vacate by July 1. Big reductions to re-
duce stock.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13

BY the way. weren't you complaining
ago2
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13

Eat your dinner at the Mack Smith
lunch room, 1880 to 2:3O. 271k W. First
South.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13
Lac Monarch Visible TYpewrLter

is the up-to-date typewriter.
Pembroke Stationery Co. sell It.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13
JUNE 18th.
JUNE 18th.

Last date of teachers excursions east
and west via Oregon Short Line. GTe1.-
~ reduced rates to Denver, Omaha.
Kansas City. Chicago, Portland. San
Francisco. Los Angeles and other east
eTn and western points.
SEE AGENTS FOR
FULL PARTICULARS.
CITY TICKET OFFICE POI MAIN ST.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13

Mrs. J. G. NcCIain entertained yester-
day at a tea for her sister, Mrs. George
r. Ring of Beivedere. Cal. who is here
on her way east The hours were from
till o'clock and something over sixty
ladies were invited to meet Mrs. Ring
Mrs. A Fl. Mayne had charge Of the
dining-TOOm and she was assisted by
Miss Mary Mayne, Miss Clifta Msyne
Miss Ivy Snyder and Miss DOllie Davis
Miss Maud McCangar served punch. The
dining-rOOm was al in roses and ivy the
gorgeous flowers forming banks on man
tel and sidebOard- In the parlOrs all
coIOrs Of roses were used and over all
were long stTeamers Of ivy.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13

Mrs Samuel F. Fenton will entertain
today at small and informal luncheon
at her home
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1906-06-13

Mrs George Mathews formerly Of this
CITY, has Just completed a course at Rad
cliff IN special history methods and is TO
be one of the faculty Of Nsssar next year.
She goes abroad to spend the summer
Mrs Mathews was the guest Of Mr. and
Mrs Ledyard NJ Bailey a year or Sc
ago and received a great deal of social
attention.
The diamond drill. (Crystal Falls, Iron County, Mich.) 1887-1996, 1906-03-24

maintenance Of 6rst class ball team
In the field the coming season. and.
with this object in view subscription
list has been prepared by those who
have taken the initiative. The list
will be taken around 10 the fans and
II is 10 be hoped that they will be lib
eral in their contributions
Already and without solicitation.
four well known FAM have contribut-
ed 500 each. making total Of S4oc.
Thus the subscription list sallies forth
10 the faus with an excellent beginning
n the direction Of Intimate rncess
In a letter received several days ago
By Mr.. RYAN. Jack Mackin says he
IL looking for timber for his Crystal
Falls team. which will SO after n re-
cord ia the mining country rs soon as
tho frost leaves the ozone Msckin
may sign nainber OF 500 men, II
there is anybody here who looks good
10 him SEQ News
The diamond drill. (Crystal Falls, Iron County, Mich.) 1887-1996, 1906-03-24
ATax Title Decision.

The Michigan supreme court has
handed down decision affecting tax
titles that will be Of great interest to
attorneys and owners OF tax titles In
the state. as the ruling practically sets
aside q former decision or tine court
when nearly reverse opinion was
given.
The case In point originated IN
Houghton county, and is known on the
supreme court records rs Goodell vs.
Auditor General Goodell had a
number ct descriptions Of land in
Houghton county that were sold for
taxes in December. 1896 The auditor
general took decree IN the circuit
court for the county Of Houghton for
the sale Of lands with others included
IN tire delinquent list. the proceedings
had In the matter being regular so far
as the records showed. However, IL
was contended by Goodell that accord
ing TO the tax law Of the state a decree
could not be- entered until after the ex.
pirution Of five days after the entry
was made. and consequently the pro-
ceedings were void.