The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1906-05-17

( BY SIAIEMENl
) HE ORIGINALLY MADE
y Hard Fall Out of Sena-
Lodge in Sarcastic
y Manner.
q rGTON, May Ex-senator Till
, h received from former Senator
n Chandler a statement of his
/ tn Intermediary in the negotia-
C,' ZEN President Roosevelt and
:. Nllman and Bailey on the rail-
NH Tho communication bears
= BIZ Lodges denial for the Pres
ChandlePs statement quoting
: ot as saying he had lost conf
knators Foraker. Spooner and
y las offered in the Senate by
'nhlman and will be printed In
. ISlonal Record,
IN the statement follows:
80 Cannot Ignore 1t.
n -, Tillman: As the telephone
\ Isident Roosevelt sent 10 .he s
" cenator Lodge rem2lns In the
. P,cord OF May II. II seems 10
e mid take some notice or II, "hlch
rr-afrIrtnins tho essential ruth OF
4 n, 4 made 10 you and which you
M sonate. Much as / regret that
ht I-Ron OF Senator Lodgo and inc
ltss forced an issue between the
Isr Tmyself. the extreme language he
, 1cch issue unavoidable and can
nm or cvRdo IT. although l can
! IA the chief executive OF the M
\. u llko his own. Upon our re-
- ~mcnts | submit the controversy
: ucc 10 the judgment OF those VINO
Evidence.
! xho do not know mo there is for
4 ruuutantial evidence OF q high or
: 3onp that tho President could not
y 10 make in substance the state
, he denies, Nor could no have
IN whole statement which no now
uH,Hls impulsiveness has led him
hrrcr upon a point OF no import
= but only as affecting hls at
~ give 10 you a further state"
.znmmond by President.
!, 1rch 81 I had not seen the Prcsi-
I0ng dine. ! did not 80 10 the
As q representative OF Senator
y solcly because the President
Ik fhete by tho letter from Mr..
UEited for him 10 cxprcss hl9 OBJ
nnmistakably stated to be COM
= l-<ith Mr.. rlllman, who had tho
<hnrEc. and other Democrats OF
1E-1r the purpose OF securing tho
;n1 railroad rate bill of a court
- limiting the inquiry TO the
r- ter tho commission had exceeded
;s1ur had violated tho constitutional
" 4cnrric-.
1s anirms Disagreement.
u no know that IL was impossible
-s{-iDEn conferences with Ar. TIL
,- be was fully satisfied that the
& n absolutely given up all inten-
!. PC 70 IN Agreement with tho
= had been making the contest for
court review. and In stating bis
~ that no had parted from them
d1sE Senators Knox, Foraker and
= po 6enators who had made the
fl The Senate to sustain that view.
u Hs nearly as l can recollect tho
Il On In my statement repeated by
tupn Included tho understanding
thaf day reached with Senators
ON, tho fact that not over ono
Nll<cpublican Senators could be re-
Tor the limited court review,
vas Vital that the support of
, X pomoerats should be obtained.
,llman Supicious.
ra. Inter. 1 visited Mr.. Tmman
w ny miesion from the President,
cu uistrustful and suspicious. Ho
D closely as TO what the Presi-
r1p and i related to him, as &c
D y ouid. Tho statement mado by
l-sla 70 me. and convinced him
,s,e2 Nncnt had ceased TO hopc for
~ rItb The Senators named and the
~
- - tfar this was the case h.
!cF We TO Cooperate with the Prosi-
mat he would see Senator Bal
- 10 me the result. which nc
{, 1erc would bc perfect accord
g -uon OF the right of review ~
~ IN connection with a limita-
1t 70 Issue exparto injunctiopg
koody Came In.
q q refs thus begun were on TIM
rk$estion. transferred to Attor-
and at once resulted In an
mi n.s tho effort could be mado
AlWent OF court review as stuted
emenament and in the paper
<pni " by Mr.. Moody and latsr
us s'ssrs Moody, Tillman and Bnl-
~ fesident Is Mistaken.
D0,E The statement which the prs,-
{ " nc made Instead Of the
4 senator Foraker, he
50 <4rasone am quite surc no
IA stors Knox and Spoonrr bo
a vnuoned, but that ali thai ras
% we're. as 10 Senator Kno-
I q aid not agreo with a pnr.
.~r}Xseo amendment. but that n,
uT s strong argument for
Il 2 atvely the jurisdictlon or aU
el, ourt, and as TO Senator Snoou-
. 80 ny was only mentioned By him
,hs . cordial approval a Senatn1 at6n
,.I'ty Up 1as Evidence.
=, HmenGruea, -~as not oneroa =,
nay 10. But I learn that n
~ .as 49, anu SHOWN To the Pres
Ss< ~ certain. that IL tho Pros
night. told me thai he
rflN -rsn OIL II and ! had 40 ree
|lLp ian. thoro would have on
: <pes looking to co-operntIon &.
tIssldcu,. as 10 th,I a a.ion
: Il ennd conversation M soru.
: y Elsh somo other person. a. some
Dar harmless Report.
C. III be borne In mind ,b,, -.
.,cbs Won u comparatively "S SaL,- rresl-
:. ~ Here it is. a.HcS mar harmless
u cn troubled by tho odyon ina !
az ourt rsvlew by sono ooScy go or
$3.50 Senate. naninw l tno
ddrc9 and Fornker iins Az t Senators
sSs ,hs bill by ingenious .ns sopo,,i,, 20 In
i E but that no hnd co rO,'s.itu-
nsflp fFsment with them" ii0 10 q
rr5ds Can Give offense