The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1906-05-03
SEAMY SIDE OF IROTTNG.
explosions or WRONG DOERS by
THE BOARD or REVIEW.
G~.teOnIbe's ssr Against Gle, Glands Grand
Circuit Manage rs shifted to West
Kid Shea, 2:O5 La. Cleared From
an Old Biunder Reinsta a dement's.

An outcome of the declaring of Of tbs
Cleveland Grard Circuit meeting last season
after the closing of entries was the decision by
the Board OF Review AZ the Murray Hill Hotel
yesterday that the case of James Y. Cat
combe. Concord. n. H, versus the Cleveland
Driving Park Company must be adi Indicated
by the American Trotting Associa tIon. the
Western organization. While the Grand Cir
cult had the recognition OF both the National
Trottipg Association and the 4. 7. A.. It had
been published that the racing would be
governed by the A.. T, A.. on which ground
the board shifted the case. All the other
owners and dri vers except GattOmbe Joined
in a mass meeting at the track and ratified
the action OF the Cleveland mans gers. Cat
combe wants damages and may have 10 20
into the civil courts. II. X, Devereaux Of
Cleveland gave testimony on this case, while
Gatcombe testified last winter.
When A. l.. TerwilliRer's Kid Shea won the
2:l9 trot In Albany In 100? in 2:iai, and 2.l7i,.
the latter making his record. the mistnk"
of a clerk caused the first heat TO be set against
the horse at 214l+ and It got into tho year
book. Kid Shea has since trotted in his classes
unquestioned. as the mistake has been eX-
planned. but at Dover, y. Y, last season he
was protested In the ?l8 class. Kid Shea
closed the season with II mark of 2O1l. The
facts. about the mistake were established
legally yesterday and the protest dismissed.
An item OF corroborallye evidence Vas a
marked score card saved from the Albany
meeting by Miss Nina Phelps. who on that
day made a woman's world driving record
TerwilIiser halls from Paterson n. j
iH4%SsSa + + & a.{ ? %sf fsSisi,o Sii{a2; S',, \ \ NJ ~.
S Sds: o4Iqb3 !. y SiSSsr f 1 E5q} I e nS,i EeS ) f i d R5JS:
a aadd' d sf%ae0f s. Nee Fe' w Il 4; H@Llt LICK f Hsysn,,
Pa. RI Gardner, Salem. Ohio, an expelled
l6pst ,temeet vas granted to J, ". Tompkin''
Relief from expulsion was deried the fol-
2. " Cummi1s, shelby Ohio; James, r. gary,
FL, H. B, Throop' 'NoTioiiR%; sanford "
Walker Rochester; GeorseHL Smith, steubens;
e the ''B!nsBPSRton Racina P'r issqS ia'ion'
Elmira. y. y, and its secretary. C.. f. Proctor,
Proctor had associated with him an expelled
the last meeting, which was irreEularly com
Quoted also in other ways, according to tho
Final action In ringing cases, in which
ev dence was taken at the February meeting.
resulted In the expulsion Of the following men
thT n { To{ Graq,t. r sifIse%SG s.s ma Mas ;bo ? 1ij, Moc Gar.
rae out of her class au as hess; J j. epib' F.
Hennessey. Saginaw. Mich. T. n MCLEAN.
Toledo. o., and the PAGER MargerY Wilkes,
PICK fraudulently raced as Sweetheart
THROUGHOUT Alabama and Georgia; J. II
Manton, Gullford. Me-, and the PAGER Betsy
Bugle. 2lS.. raced as Miss Hqrtepse: "
Ia, and PAGER Lady Knapp, ?:09b. raced IA
MMilddred at Johnstown. Pa. and jamestown,
Suspensions were ordered. until returns Of
winnings and further eXohtration. of D. h,
Hodge. sterling. ~, aud Fred Steiner, Gin;
out Of class at Macauoketa, ~; also against
fined s25: and the chestnut GcldinC Baby
Webb, entered In $40 class in an ice meeting
last February; G. X. Sober, Lewisburg. Pa,
and the horse Alvco, alias san Toy;
Harry c. Meister. Bradford, Pa, who drove
the horse at Rimersburg, Pa, was expelled
for swearing falsely as 10 the identiiC alton
Of Dick Berry, alias Surprise, alias Jason
Medium. Charges Of suppression of time at
Rimersburg.- Pa. against the horses Gray
Dick, Lady Watson and Teddy. 6 we're dis
missed also the charges against the timers at
the meeting, Il. S. ,Arma gast,, New Bethlehem,
Pa. II. j. Crawford, Emlcnton, Pa, and
william Neal, PunNsutawny, Pa.
on requests for identification, the horse
ctived a clean bill OF health, but Cassius,
winner al, South. birmingham. Mass, re-
mains unidentified.