The times dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1903-1914, 1906-06-26

Stand ard / Oil i ]. \ 'IM|anipuMla-; u
tod Comic and q !! Had l q!
4 Vision I!'l! j !! Changed, j IAN
3TILLlM! \ I'M I ( q { IS
q HAIR GEL Sc ATE II e |
Lodge Agrees With 4 ''i' ]! South 'I1tl1
Carolinian 4 hat Effect y \: viii y III u
Be TO Let Comb Il lion On &
~ Out Of Operate 81 rtE 4 NJ
Law Anti-P Pass ss93E
Provision. q S3saS3

Provision.
BY Associat ted & I'rcss.)
888t AsH1NGTO .sS June hen the
81 senat teS met to-day the clerk Sofs the House
u an rlo,lrced 4 the action Ssof that body on
1the "a ,lroad rate Bill. .S but sit was all lowed
& to lieS on the Vice y resid dent 's desk until
Il 2:3o G u, M when n was called & up by
"a sena tor Tillman. Mr.. Imam called at e.:
HI Rtention 10 tho fact that his nnme was not
H attached. J. . He said he was opposed To- the
n agreement concerning one amendment 70 Ilt 70 70
s which he would ater m owe that the Sen
y ates disu gree. He u had reference to the
u sMcLaurin amendment diyorcing the ca ~ ~
Is Srying and producing business. which was i
b sar,1ended 4 50 that It does not apply toj tt'
u Pipe lines. s5 he sl ~ st
The change In this amendment the +
n South Carolnian declar ed, ssin plain Eng :.
%lisf,3 meant that tho standard OIL had nd
Il got In Its work ..1,aa The agreement re-
SS lieved the Sta ndard Oh /. Company ON from q
y control and regulation OF the Inter state
II Commerce Commission ss 81 NJ Il 81
Smelt a M ouse.
when tho Bill was sent to conferences
n Tie u second time, Senate T Tillnan said !
Is hef ouna an entirely d. fferent atmosphere
from that of the first conference, as the
Y House conferees insisted upon opening
NJ up the whole sub ject 4; including all mat
n ters hich an ngr nag gee "
% ched. }9ss st3
hen beganlst q smell e 4 g ol4
III ~ Z.
BBsof sSs he ~ words common n carr to-
ttrailroad ds' ,$S would s$ simply estroy the y
effect of making pipe lines common carr ri;
this cha nge 9 me diyorcemen.
1.u'
=, =
y, Ia -
~ 4 4 4tae i,,
~ NO.
~ = fhaf Sin Nj aesti =.
H N sSy f;,ss ta fUr tii6
rnnSa,rndn ss rsport would a l1ayd n
branded 81 IA fore
H ala not mean VI yote Tor y be-
= he aid mot want anybody saying,
head SHen T!llnnan. II .. considered the in
sEdeT,end 4 ent companies, whose interests are
e, rnosed To be Inv Owed ia be my yths.'''8 8
s sS n, . n y g : !, :, = = - f)i,% 4
9 sLet 'lI5 otd!iudtu = Sul: =,
Senator Lodge agreed Win ~
that the purpose o. u tle W " o
carri y e e fa nas
- !, a. hat II u,o,l d con tinue to both
+ and ira oil. Under the
r,,end ment otytha senate he believed that
~. a. Scnnld ha RELIED 10 car
papu ~ - com
- ,,iaa 3S','' Tss i 81
. He nei,esau e"a. - - the ,nSemend
# ~ : ~ ~ bv tho
I'll Gs.sndnrt 0ilN S h, 55
II 35S9' q senntor Bailey took the position that
Il @bs aha = "a mn de- nv the Conference Con,
mIttae ii, the 3cornrnod ity# provision would
,,,iiifs, the nine line 5 provision Il was
n s,,,Ivs 1ant "a 8 making the STANDARD on
n III SnI,ra Tia ona cention@ A 70 the re-
" mi ramen that nrotSucerss shall r.oe trans y
II 49, tbairB nwn a articles. Il He did not
{ charga tho Standard Company with a
ESdirect 4 efrort 4 "a influence Sleglslaton but
s 10 the frightened Independent companies,
n who It had transpired. sell their oil to-
X the Standard. # II SSss 95S5 III Il "a si8g{ & Isl
@..If. a 0leSE said, ''rhe Standard Com
pany wishes to be a producer. trans
g. porter or q retlner, let It en- gage IN either
1 OF those lines OF effort. but 4 don let
Vat monopolize all those branches Of the!
H oil Il lndustry.'''' s Isl
He though ht the e!ndep ependent companies
sho ould embrace t1e Q oPpo'rft3uh1ty 70 70 Tree Tree
Il en1selve Hi. lls t8si i85s
sS Foraker's Defense.
\ 55 aann tor FORAKER con tended that there
S}, D. .,,a 4 ~ nronert analogy between a rail-
s. s. .,oad and . 4. pipa line. AS a rule, he
said. pipe lines are not built, wlth'fthe8
4 n,,rpose of doing a carrying business for
II hire. which Is not the case with rail
4 roads, "a t55 8ta I, Il 81
& D He believed that to retain the commo--
dtty provision Eas.8i passed the House,
would be to COM fiscata the property. and
that, therefore, It would 4 not have been
s,,st mad 81 the cou rts; hence he was
Going 10 4 say that he thought tho con-
ferees had acted wisely az me risk q
Tilhnan as being Influenced by the
~ Ste ndard Oh Company. The Ohio Senator
n called attention to the fact that carriers