The herald-advance. (Milbank, S.D.) 1890-1922, 1906-12-28

ldTlly W Idhc HlS lIIdl Ou tAc CdplIol
charge. From that charge he had SO
completely vindicated himself that the
Crown had at once and wholly retired
from the intended prosecution. 1t ap-
peared that for seven years the pris-
oner had endured with great fortitude
and heroism an unmerited stigma
which he might at any moment have
removed IL he had laid his suspicious
before the police.
Now, the law in regard to this point
was very satisfactorily clear. No man
Is bound to communicate mere sus-
picion to anybody, and II he should
volunteer to do so 1t was evident he
would incur very serious responsible
ties. So far. then. Mr.. Brangwyn's
conduct was not only justified in the
eye Of the law, but had In 1t some ele-
ments of nobility which could not fail
to extort respect and sympathy. It
was not the case that the Crown de-
sired to make allowances for the pris-
oner's conduct at this trying time.
Rather than strive to free himself
from public odium-an odium which
must have been intensely painful to a
high-minded and honorable manly
transferring the suspicious to another,
he had been content to endure. The
Crown desired to emphasize the self
abnegation Of the prisoner and to do
the fullest justice to his motive.
But then-most unfortunately for
one whose conduct had hitherto been
deserving OF unmixed approval--it
came to pass that the prisoners sus-
picion developed into certainty He
became possessed of proof. He be-
came possessed of knowledge. In re-
fusing to carry that certainty, that
proof, that knowledge to the authority
appointed he had certainly placed
himself in great peril After wilful
murder itself there was no graver
crime than the wilful concealment OF
wilful murder. OF the latter crime the
prisoner openly confessed himself
guilty. He offered no rebutter. He
laid before the authorities at Scotland
never have revealed the real criminal
II he had not himself been exposed to
the risk of an ignominious and de-.
grading death. His excuse was that
the real criminal was one to whom he
had for the larger part OF his life been
attached by ties OF familiarity, affec-
ton, and esteem.
Now that plea might be an excellent
plea in a romance, in drama, In
poem; but It was not a plea which
could be for one instant upheld In a
court Of criminal law. The Crown took
action with deep regret, but it had no
option. They were compelled to ask
for the prisoners committal. 1t was
not the present purpose of the Crown
to indicate the real author Of the
crime apparently as sordid and as foul
as any to be found I'M the whole regis
ter Of those abhOrrent deeds whose
records from time to time startle and
chill the heart OF humanity. They
had every reason to believe that his
almost immediate arrest was assured,
but for the present there were good
and SUFFICIENT reasons why his identity
should not be disclosed. 1t. was the
duty Of the Crown to demand that the
prisoner be committed to take his trial
at the next assize at the Old Bailey.
Then followed some formal evidence.
And next came the advocate Alloy
sius had appointed to conduct his case.
He opened by saying that the attorney
general had offered as cogent, as NOV
ing an argument in favor Of the pris-
oner as any he himself could have
| hoped to lay before the court, and he
advanced 1t with all that eloquence
which was peculiarly his own. For
| his part he was more than content to
leave upon his clients character the
complexion which the skilful hand Of
| his learned friend had laid upon 1t.
| He would enter, by special instruction.
q purely technical plea of mot guilty
and would reserve his defense. He ap
piled that the prisoner be admitted to
| bail.
Did the police offer any objection to
bail? Thus the sitting magistrate
No objection whatever. Thus Inspec
tor Holt, formally representing the po
lice. The prisoner would be liberated
on his own recognizances to appear
and take his trial at the next assize.
And now the Brangwyn mystery
was ablaze indeed. Conjecture and
surmise went mad. but through all the
time Of popular excitement Alcysius
lived cloistered and alone. His docu
ments had been restored to him after
tthe formal and public acknowledg
ment Of his innocence OF the act for
which his arrest had been decided on
ana he spent much time In their pc.
rusal, until at last he seemed to see
the story evolve itself before him as
II the actors In 1t we're veritably pres.
ent ana alive. and alike audible and
visible.
The first Of the documents was writ.
ten ia me stlf1 and Grabbed hand Of
age. but It Wa legible as print. It be.
ran bluntly with the Christian name
Of the recipient:
.Aloysius: The knowledge Of your
\