The Salt Lake tribune. [volume] (Salt Lake City, Utah) 1890-current, 1906-05-05
A1om and um-phosphate powders are injurious
Do Not Use Them

biting shame of her experience had
worn off" But the leading question
now IS. Where is Emily Knox? and,
Why did Judge Brown abandon her
after the humiliating experiences Of
the day before?
DR., Beatty Talks.
Regarding the part which DR.. Beat
ty took In the examination Of the girl,
there is this to say and DR.. Beatty
himself says IT.
The girl was brought to my Office
with the representation tnat an eXaml
nation was desired by herself for the
purpose Of establishing her innocence
OF charges which had been made
against her. l soon discovered, how
ever. that she would not consent to any
examination, and In spite OF the writ
ten request OF her mother l refused to
do so. Under no circumstances would
l make an examination OF the sort
without the full consent of the indi-
vidual herself The girl was removed
from my office and that was the last
! heard OF the case until later In the
evening, when l was called to the
Deaconness home, being Informed by
the matron that the girl had changed
her mind, and l thereupon compiled
with her request. and for obvious rea-
sons am unable to state for publication
the result ="
And In this connection Judge Brown
stated to The Tribune that the exami-
nation places the young girl above sus-
picion.
Would Use Brute Force.
Now for another phase of that ex-
animation. 1t is stated on good au-
thority that so anxious was Probation
officer E NJ. Clark to have the child
examined that he suggested to DR..
Beatty that he Clark and the police
officer would hold her down while DR..
Beatty made the examination. When
Clark was taxed with this he side
stepped the answer, and stated that he
had resigned, the resignation to take
effect last evening. He is the young
man-very young man-who in his zeal
to see the girl hauled through the
streets TO DR., Beattys office, grabbed
her hand and jerked 1t so forcibly from
the door Of the main entrance that 1t
threw him TO the stone steps.
Emily Struck No One.
Subsequently. he stated that the girl
had hauled off and given him a hard
clip" To this Mrs. Young herself re-
torted that for once he had got what
was coming to him. This would be
good II 1t were true. But Clark ro-
manced when he said the girl struck
MN. SUe pO5llNtly ulu uOl4 &NGllneT
did she attempt to strike him She re-
sisted and screamed for her mother 10
help her, Some have said she used
vile language. This again Is absolutely
untrue. She was wild with anger, but
many in the crowd remarked that "for
an incorrlgibIe she was certainly free
from bad language"
Judge Browns Mistake.
Now. as to Judge Brown. He con-
ceded that he made a mistake; that
he should have held the examination
in chambers, and would do SO hereaf-
ter in such cases. AS to the article
printed In The Tribune, he claimed 1T
misrepresented him. or course. he said,
he had used the language attributed to
him In the examination OF the child,
but that that was the method adopted
by all the Juvenile Judges. and he
would continue to use it. The girl, he
maintained, understood what he meant
and was simply a finished little ac-
tress, Stimulating Indignation and ig-
norance only TO protect the man In the
city jail. He threw the blame on the
girl herself, for how could he know
she was going to defy the court and
make all that hullaballoo." He had
had no conversation with the mother,
but had understood that she wanted
him TO frighten the girl so she would
go home. That was his method of
frightening her. Later. he blamed the
mother for the trouble, claiming she
had not brought the girl up properly.
Mother Wanted No Examination.
In this connection II is we'll To state
that though Judge Brown said in plain
terms that Mrs Knox had asked him
to have the girl examined. she denied
1t In toto. She says she did not know
what was TO be done, had she known
she would never have consented. AS a
matter OF fact, she said, She wanted
the Judge TO have little talk with her
daughter; tell her she must obey, cease
being naughty and go home with her
mother. Judge Browns first question
simply was a slap In the face OF my
daughter. who had never been talked
to In such manner before. and IL
shocked me also. L never asked him
to have her examined. and I was so
rushed onward by the quick action of