New-York tribune., 1906-10-12
FOR EMBOSSED JUDGES.
HUGHES ATTACKS DEAL.
1y@0O Persons at CGnandagua Cheer
Republican Candidate.
TBy Telegraph 70 The Tribune.l

Canandalgua. y. Y. Oct 11.-Denouncfng ths
Murphy-Hearst deal by which the Dernocratio
judiciary ticket in New York was made I'D
Charles 2. Hughes. in his speech IN the David
son Grand opera House here tonight. declared
it was ptiabe thing to think that any man
owed a nomination for so important an Office to
any political boss.
I'VE want our judges selected" he said so
that they will have the hand OF no boss on their
shoulder"
Mr.. Hughes learned Of the judiciary deal when
he received the New York papers IN Geneva. and
he took up the new and important issue at his
first opportunity. The audience OF more than
twelve hundred persons Immediately caught the
significance of the deal as showing Mr.. Hearst's
compact with the bosses. and cheered the
speakers vigorous denunciatiOn of il.
The cheering grew tumultuoUs when he added:
Il have right to speak this question. be-
cause owe my nomination TO boss. and
would not have accepted it from any boss"
MR. HUGHES ON THE DEAL.
Mr.. Hughes said:
1t is a very popular thing to declare fndepend-
ence Of bOsSism but what is the practice? Do
We find de5potic proceedings TO get nominal
ton? Do we find the overrulng of the will Of
the people, expressed in local conventions. In
order to obtain an ambition in the state conven-
ton? II is one thing to talk about Independence
OF bosses. and it is another thing TO be content
with free expression of the popular Will CAP
We have heard some men who seem to hold
the organization of a great community in their
control denounced in the most violent language.
We have heard them denounced as enemies OF
their country. We have heard their personal
liberty threatened We have heard them
Cused Of crime; and then we have seen them
taken By the hand in the furtherancs &c a
friendly arrangement in order that one might
get office (Applause.)
We learned to-day of further eonpacts. do
not know any officer in the community that
should be so free from the suggestion OF political
fV1H1 Of rOIff oh liprlf on qc fudu
Think Of a Judge on the bench being told by
some man in the community whom he shall
appoint referee and whom he shall name as
a receiver; and think of man in the most hon
Orable position of a judge of the highest court OF
original Jurisdiction in the greatest city in tho
Empire State, the metropolis of the union. exc
cutting his orders like a boy.
That is bOssism. That Is very bad kind OF
bossism; and when one is sincere IN attacking
bossism he would nullify that power, and not
enter into agreement with it,
We have heard in the city of New York in re-
cent days of Judiciary nominations The ques-
ton was, ii seemed. how many would be Sc
Iected by Mr.. Murphy and how many would be
selected by Mr. Hearst. We heard very little OF
the wishes OF the delegates. We heard very
little in regard to the opinion Of the community
The question was. whether. at a time when a
large number OF judges were to be elected, IN
. cTeasing the number in order to dispose OF a
great accumulation of legal business, two or
three men were 10 decide who should be Sc
lected
Is that asking for free expression OF the
popular wflI2 Is that the sort Of thing the IN
dependence League stands for? Is that the sort
Of thing that my opponent processes 20 stand
for? And to-day's paper brings the news Of a
series of nominations 70 these important places.
vita so many accredited To Mr.. Hearst and
MANY accredited to Mr. Murphy; and il would
seem. according 70 such light may to
us who are familiar with the details of the ar
rangement. that so many are to be allowed to
one and many TO be allowed 70 the other.
and the people OF that great community are 10
be invited to rattfy the choice. That is bossism-
That is a boss deal. and that is something that
we are against (Great applause)
MEN or ENIINE.NCE AT BAR NEEDED.
We want to see our judges chosen in such 4
manner that tho hand of the boss cannot bs
found upon the shoulder of the nominee. (AD-
plauseD We want TO see our judges selected in
such manner that the suggestion OF a word
from political leader cannot be thought of: men
of eminence at the bar. men who have won pro-
fessional regulations, who enjoy the good opinion
OF me community. put In a position where they
can discharge their important functions without
a suggestion of dictaJiOn. That Is what we want.
1t is a pitiabe thing to find our great words
and our important platform used simply to fool
the people. have spoken of this matter not
with any intention TO reflect upon any individual
who may have been chosen. 1t is a much mora
important subject than the question OF any
individual reputation 1t is the irnDortant
subject OF method. II is the important issue
of political sincerity. 1 have a right To speak
unreservedly on this question because 7 owe
my nomination TO no boss. and would not have
accepted II from any boss Great applause and
cheerngD
I have a right TO speak upon this question.
because no one before the people of this state
can take away my right 70 stand Independently
for what i believe, OF charge 10 me Justly
that I, if Governor, shall Ae under any 0hliga-
tion 70 any person or 70 any corporation. CAP
plause)
And it is. because OF some matters 20 which
/ have alluded and OF the way in which both
independence and the Democracy We're BETRAYED
that I find Joining with in This campaign for
decent government citizens OF all part!es-men
Of different opinions. but uport this fundamental
question united.
GLAD TO BE IN CANANDAIGUA
In opening his speech Mr.. Hughes said:
! am glad 10 be here. 7 was told thar I was
not known upstate; IL is limited that was sOme-
thing OF a mystery. and that you wanted Go see
whether really / flesh and blood Wen 7
have had the pleasure OF visiting Lyons and
Buffalo and Geneva. and now Canandaig1a
and 1 have regarded il the greatest oppor-
tunity OF my life % get acquainted with men
upstate. for there has been feeling OF earnest-
ness and OF genuineness in the response which
has been made TO the positions j have taken
and that has convinced me that whether up-
state men knew me or not they stood for what
I stand for.
Every ill-advised attempt to accomplish sOrl,-
thlng IN a wrong way. and by appealing 10 pas-
SION instead OF % Judgment breeds q reactiol
REDUCED RATES TO NEW ORLEANS
Via PENNSYLVANIA Railroad account HienniaI F,
Sanpinent Knights Of Pythits. Tickets sofd nom
(oM 1oihs Octoper y % 70, good returning -