Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1906-08-30
Private Parties Cannot Lay Side.
walk After City Has Acquired
Jurisdiction by Publication.
RULING OF JUDGE J. A. HOWELL
In Case Of i. l.. Carlson and 4. 4. san
born ". Ogden CT, and \ f.
Parker tiiN Engineer


h"N'N "'hu'u """" "'.''''" '"S
tanning the demurrer oi the defendant
I'm tho case NJ Jnsouh I. C,rI.on and
49,, ., ,.,,.,..' ... ,.l... ,t,, anal
''eu y N'"o''" w 'H"'H '.'' ''''
a. J.. Parker. CITY engineer ana DENY
ing the application Tor writ pf man
dat. Tho decision lis M ,ast in,t,ort-
"WcfdS the d'u"u was pI"'sH' I" "'-
tcmine the rights of the property
owner in regard 90 securing % permit
10 lay sidewalk along mis- premises
after the city had made its FIRST pub
licatiou of intention 90 do this WORK.
Briefly stated the history Of the case
rs As follows:
ON Aug Z. 1906. the plaintiffs gave
notice hat they would. ON the 18th day
OF the month. apply 90 the court for q
writ Of mandate 90 issue against the
defendants The petition Tor Inc Nrl
alleged that Joseph l.. Carlson. one OF
the plaintiffs. was the owner "l Ger
tain real estate ON the east side oil
Wall avenue between TWeniy-hith
and Twenty sixth streets mat me dc-
f,Iddnt ogden city had given liS no.
tlce Of intention TO create q sidewalks
district ON Wall avenue from NtnN
attn to TWcuty-seNentn streets ana l"
build therein concrete S'urN"h Ni.n-
Zoo which district was Included the
property of the plamul mat lhe a''g
Of first publication ot the hot,e ol
intention was July ]. 1905. "ud lh'
date OF last publication AUG. y i''''
on July 9 1905. me CITY 'oun'u
passed an ordinance, ploNldlng. ln@l
When notice OF intention 10 punu
sidewalks I'm any district Us puu,lsh,l
| it shall be deemed lhdl JaIlsulOuoIl a.
/ acquired by me Guy W uo ,i., w, y,
1 from the date NJ the hrs' puoHSnns o'
! The notice o' intention anu uuui
! hearing OF the l'olesl Sn'u ",,",E -.
/ termne tho lplsai'uuu ''N "pu' Wy
! date OF the Ilat Pupll'H..ull VI Iii
! notice OF intention no pvln''.S 80.
! issue thereafter ana al peiiH'.S a.
| ISSUED Tor pulal"s VAIN . .''"' Ia
/ trict snal expire anu tha
: This ordinance was
/ MAYOR JUN ,'.' 100, s.,,hor, a,
! carson G'sltou W u. 80, MAJ
: mus "oN '"l ",', ,.,,, his uronert, he
/ he wanted 10 p'eNe"' W, so pU,,,t ana
/ ing haple 20 lnc 49, ~, 80, for nav
the issue ol s'llP W -. ~,
| ment ana prevent n5 'a,,ai
having lleu a''"eHeu W u 'O'
taxes ana seIln' .,,..., ,,,., ,hoy
Inc pia'ilius ''i.,' .'i' s'il,,,,a,e rem,
had no PAIN spe'ul aliu ~, - ~. "a
cay IN 'ht olullais ~ ~, t.s ~ y, a
therefore pIageu 'oi .,'. ~, ~ A.
"ri OF lhaIlual, G'ls'' ~, - ~ iss',o
''Huah,s' 7,.,'',ii, .i1,@, ~
permit TO nHlN ,n' S'u, '1'1 "' 49,, IN
premises ~ N"' 's"''' 60. 49,, A.,
th'H N'u' uil.S' -, ~, .o,.s,r,,,.
suu'llous NECESSARY wv Wv
'I@h %, ,he S''i ,eos c.,,..., ,,,,iaa "a
Vt Je'N o. 49, .'.,,i,i.., rlli,,.,,tr,.
a. r. Ie' ~. ''t -. 49, ,.s,,Da T.. Fro1 y
sha, ie' i ,i,'. r,r,rac,o- in huiId
0"l,Uul H. q -, 80. - 80 ,.-,.,,,,.,,, az
slleN"iS a. -, ,,''l' ~ rD,,ra ~ inteD.
va ll"' lu'u ~, 49,. ~ .', S.,bo,,, az.
uu", a''u ul 'u. 49,. a.. ,,s,,,i,
pHeu 10 WI, N''S ''l,u. 80, sr,.,,,i,,
,o pu,lu w. ~ ,r,n,.,n,, a,,a nnde,
WIN lne u"''' ~ .''S w.. e..i,'o Inn,
we orr .y'l'. ~, Wy ~ ,o,,,s15 80 ~,
lh' guy "s'"'''' '''N'' ~
su," PEI ,,.. ......, a.. ,..,.i, 90 "a.
~ va ".,el' "a. e 49, ., ail W.,
I.-!n",,S wa, NJ 'l'',' d,s, i'
s''ue le''s su''''I' Nv .,,.,. 49, ,'ist,'
.use %! a'.lvi, ", w v.i',s'e Wy i'l,'
WIS 10 lhr '.l''l ~. 49, I.' 'i'' -, a..
p "a' upv'i ,''' s'ou,,' ~ ',' 80,
CIV 'e.vy Inv" ~ p,V,', ,e, w A.,
au,, u ,'r ~, III ,,,ios .bot a. 80,
.utl', 'V' ~" l",' ,5t,,.,,.
h'u lno 'lsu' W. '.',, ~ ,'l,,,i,
p'o' ."ius lxi VIZ h,''''i''s NJ. iRi ',''''
p" wv 'e' w ii'lI.a' t,,n,t,,- - "a.
contractors lui ,N. uu't','N "a. ~
Walks ana also tna' SUI. po,'i'l'' ','a
%" Ie' "htu' pu' J. va, az ~ ~ -, :.
SCI iof the pla'lllls WA, l.asll'v'n a
thr oidii'eH'e lIg' lurI ''.a' SUI ~,
NUS as ht !ssu,u sl.all 'NPlle " "a
from 'ht cave W lsSualg'' W =" Nv
t.He or 'n' ,'l ba'"Ji ''S,''' w.. ~.
lnal 'ne pe' ''l'N ''''''os ~ ''yN .5, a., l'i'
~ ",. w "' y',i.' Sr,.
10 "ilti lhe nlthiHs w s'u, " am ~
| QYesllon' ih 'uls oas' Wa "a" w
t.f. FOR lht Pui p"se oi ie'VNlls pJ'
Hlls, A,.o' N''ie' Wv W. NJ
W"luS sel"l.s on aOqul'l ne Ju' SUI,
t.'H TO u'ah, ,u' "iPlV s,iI,'' w y,
lne WORN Oh uuIlaIlt SlueN"'h tH& ,
3 ihdl 'I the statu'e p'p'iuihk lul wv
usuls 'l houe,s oi lll.,'l,'oll ~ ,''''..
districts lot lupiN lillp'uN g'l'vv's ol
p providing IoI the levylls ol spe.'a' ,s'
, es the.eiu II seeineu 70 WV vou' VIZ
unaouo'euN 'hS Wy ecu 40 ~ "
D lhere y no ,ohulcl ost"te. 'ne s,alu
ana me oIuiNdi'Ce' tnt opJe'f VI u''
oelhs enuIeE alsslrl i AZ .,..,, -,
q ~ vas also elEueu ,l usl'a,l ~ "
r pialh''ls 'ha' 'he Iequl' '', ~. '''a' ~
? n's "eu'u
. I" the u'ne Nu'n Wv w w wv
lneh'' NoIh ullugl VIZ lV'''' ~ NV
I uon vas an ull 'asollSol, ''''''s" ' ~
7 upDu ."' s.al.'',,s ~ f,' "a.
! 1h'l ,t,.,',i -, 49,, ~. -,
Pyinl 'uub' il'"'', - nc ~ 49,