The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1906-10-07
JUDICIARY DEAL IS ON AGAIN.
RELATIONS BETWEEN HEARST
AND MURPHY IMPROVE.
II Is Expected New That Five Of the Can
didaics for JudEeShipA VIII ne Hearst
Men and the Rest Murphy Men -Ju-
dir,ar, N0mGnatOrs Decline 20 Deal.

Charles r. Murphy. his friends said yes.
tsrdav. will name the majority Of the can
didates on a combination Murphy Hearst
judiciary ticket. According to these spokes-
men FOR Mr.. Murphy the Tammany leader
had received word FRI ON up Stste hat II
he would nominate men for the Judiciary
ticket who would be Of such character that
they would MT be open to any particular
public criticism Mr.. Hearst would agree
TO a ioin, ticket and would not ask for
more than Eve out Of the thirteen places.
some corroboration OF this report was ,
found at Mr.. Hearst's headquarters ut tins
Cilsev House, where il was said that Mr..
Hearst had never heen anxious 10 put an
Independent, judiciary ticket in the field
and that be had always been willing that
the Independence League and Tammany
Hall tickets should contain the same names
ifMr. Murphy would name men satisfactory
10 Mr.. Hearst. It was this stipulation
against which Mr.. Murphy revolted. He
refused 10 submit his hat Of candidates
10 Mr.. Hearst and il was then that the
threat Was made. by Mr. Hearst to put an
opposing ticket in the field.
BIT from what could be learned Yesterday
A. the Gilssy House Mr.. Hearst will no longer
insist on rhis stipulation. He Is willing to
take Mr.. Murphy's promise that the Tam
many candidates will be as good men rs
the Hearst candidates.
Friends Of Mr.. Murphy said yesterday
that MIR. Hearst had been induced to think
tw.ce over his threat to make up a ticket
Of his own by the knowledge which had
found its way to him that since the middle
OF the week Mr.. Murphy has BEEN stretching
out feeiers to the Judiciary NOminators.
II can be stated positively that Mr.. Murphy
in his fret burst Of resentment at M. Hearst
declared that rather than submit to the
demands OF Mr.. Hearst he would have the
1ammany judicial CONVENTION indorse the
whole Of the Judiciary Nominators' ticket.
IT was said yesterday that Justice Morgan
j. O'Brien, from whom Mr.. Murphy sought
advice. had advised this step as preferable
10 admitting altogether to Mr.. Hearst.
After sleeping over his first impulse. how
ever, Mr.. Murphy came to the conclusion
that he could not as the leader OF a Demo-
cratic organization adopt ell the names
on the lawyers ticket, and he opened up
negotiations with the Judiciary Nominators
and proposed tina il the lawyers would
substitute three Tammany candidates for
three Of the candidates they had already
selected the Tammany organization would
indorse the ticket.
These negotiations. it was said yesterday.
we're conducted through City Court Judge
Mccarthy. 1t was learned yesterday that
on Friday the Judiciary Nominators sent
word to Mr.. Murphy hat as they had already
refuse TO accede to a similar proposal made
by the Republicans they could not accept
the offer made by Mr.. Murphy, and hat
such a deal would stultify them. in view
Of the fact that the, principle for which
they were working was to take the judiciary
ont Of the influence Of politics.
According TO reports heard yesterday
when Mr.. Hearst reaches townthls afternoon
from RIffalo he will open up communica-
TORS directly with Mr.. Murphy with a view
TO reaching some amicable understanding.
This is what Mr.. Murphy wishes for. Mr..
Murphy is said to ha told his friends that
the Misunderstanding which nave arisen
between himself and Mr.. Hearst are due
mainly to the Hearst managers at the Gilsey
House; that there we're too many bosses
al tho Gilsey House. and that as some OF
them wanted places on the Supreme Court
bench thcy had deliberately worked to
bring about confusion between the Tam
E'any organization and Mr.. Hearst.
Among the candidates Mr.. Murphy will
select for the Supreme Court bench. unless
he should change his mind before next
Wednesday night, when the Democratic
judiciary convention meets, will be Justice
Giegerich, Corporation Counsel Delany,
ASSISTANT Corporation Counsel Connolly
NJ. Marley Platzek and Peter A. HAndrick.
Justice Giegerich and Mr.. Connolly are
on the lawyers ticket.
Mr.. Hearst, it is known, has pledged
himself to the support Of John Ford, Samuel
Seabury and Clarence j. Shearn for the
supreme Court. and that would leave two
vacancies on that ticket to be provided for
in the event Of Mr.. Hearst and Mr.. Murphy
coming together. With regard to the two
nominations for the Court Of Genera SEES
sions Mr.. Murphy has always been willing
that these should be left to Mr.. Hearst and
the probability is that the nominations will
go to Thomas Gilleran and John Pamieri.
Whatever may be the outcome Of the con-
f~erences between Mr.. Murphy and Mr..
Hearst the Independence League will put a
full column on the ballot, but this tickle and
the Tammany Hall ticket will he almost
Identical if Mr.. Murphy and Mr.. Hearst
patch up their differences. The Inde-
pendence League will. however, have some
candidates against men nominated by Tam
many on the Congress. Senate and As
sembly tickets. For instance, Mr.. Hearst
has ordered that the League shall fight Dan
kiordan, who was nominated by Tammany
IN the Tenth Senate district. and Chris
Sullivan and John T. Mccall in the Thir-
tenth and Sixteenth.
E1-Judge William N. Cohen. chairman
ot the executive committee OF the Judiciary
Nominators, said yesterday chat IL Mr..
Heart was sincere in his denunciations
OF boss rile he could not without classifying
himself make a judiciary deal with the
boss Of Tammany Hall.
Such a deal Judge Cohen said. would
mean the substitution OF a new boss for
mar the ticket and the retention Of the old
hoSs for the other half. Two half bosses
equal one whole one. Neither can I credit
me Humors that Mr.. Hearst will name
MessS. Ford, Seabury, slIearn. GnIeran
ana Palmierl for places on the Supreme
-