The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1906-09-19
IlFE INSURANCE TICKETS OUT.
IEERD MUTUAL LIST APPEARS
4 WITH HUGHES Ar HEAD.

NhayVi Nu~uh AOeN"
The tickets nominated in opposition TO
NE present management OF the Mutual
and New York Life insurance oom-
Apanies were fled yesterday at Albany and
"a the companies home Offices In this city.
In the case Of the New York Life there Is
bnly one opposition ticket-that nominated
by the international policyholders' oom-
mAttee. Two polioyholders' tickets were
recorded in the case Of the Mutual. one an
but and out opposition slate selected Jointly
by the international organization and the
Mutual Life Policyholders' Association,
kpown as the 'united ticket and the other
s1=ioa Tickle. made Up largely trcn the
International and the company's regular
Administration nominees.
This fusion ticket is the one to which
fcHu SUN referred yesterday as containing
kfse name Of Charles +. Hughes. Notwith-
MtsudinR Mr.. Hughes's declaration on o
lhRy that he had never consented to run
Ind would not serve IL elected, his name
not only was left on the ticket, but was
RlAced at the head Of it.
n This third ticket in the Mutual Life con-
rims the names of seventeen OF the present
Mana cement, including President Peabody,
md also the names Of two OF the Mutuals
kfhncy managers. Tn full board being
Apemposed OF thirty-six members, a majority
ID the third ticket nominees are therefore
fbonnected with the Mutual at present.
Hhero are fifteen OF the united ticket
nominees on the fusion slate.
The name of JOIN Wanamaker also appears
GA the fusion ticket, and the international
Nommitete officers declared that his name,
like Mr.. Hughes's, had been used without
bis consent or knowledge.
The fusion ticket IL nominated over the
jdgnatures Of 200 p~olicyholders. Thetnter-
national committee officers declared after
fhe ticket had been filed that the Mutual's
management was responsible for the intro
Lduction of this ticket and the unauthorized
Aase OF Mr.. Hughes's name. They said it
WAS merely a ruse on the part of the Mutual
people to split the vote for the united
ticket. The Mutual Life. officers, on the
pther hand, professed to see in the ticket
IAN attempt on the part of the Untermyer
forces to weaken the policyholders' support
sDf the administration ticket.
y Here IL the ticket nominated jointly by
the international organization and the
Mutual Life Policyholders' Association:
ePJemes N. Adam. Mayor OF Buffalo: Charles
Andrews, ex-Chie Justice Of the New York
Court Of Appeals. Syracuse; Samuel 8
Mcclure, the publisher, Ardsley-On-Hudson,
N. H.sCArTOllsS. rage A-0OV6ThOT VI NeTHlOuJ
and president of the Lamoille County National
Bank, Hyde Park. Vt: Edwin A. McAlpin.
president of the Nc Alpin Tobacco Company.
OssIninR. n. Y: Charles A. Smith. lumber
msrchant. Minneapolis. Mimi; Henry P.
Scott, senior member OF Scott & Co.. bankers.
wilmington. Del: William B. Lamar, Con-
gresham OF the Third Florida district. Talla-
hassee; Allen Caperton Braxton. president
Of the Virginia Bar Association. Richmond;
Edward p. Bai!y. manager OF the National
Malleable Hastings Company. Chicago;
George p. Hilton, Nce-president OF the Al
bany Trust Company; Frederick A. Brainerd.
secretary OF the lngersoll-kand Company,
Mount Vernon. N. Y; Stewart Shillito. dry
goods merchant, Cincinnati; Alfred Schiller,
silk manufacturer, New York city; william
Il. Peel, president OF the Maddox-Rucker
Banking Company. Atlanta, Ca: William
,McCarroll, president and director OF the
American Leather Company. Brooklyn: Elias
A. De Lima, member of the firm OF ID. A.
De Lima 4 Co.. New York city; Lyman
C. smith. founder OF the Smith Premier
typewriter Company, syracuse; Herman
.6ielcken, member Of the firm Of Cross
man h SielcEcn, coffee merchants, New
Work city The represents the German pol
,dOyhOiders); Frank Ttlford, vice president
Aof Park 4 Tilford, New York city: Robert J..
NFryer. president Of the Manufacturer and
sHraders' National Bank. Buffalo. william l..
N1uilladeu, president NJ the Did Dominion
NntoAnSnlD~ NOIlDhuYt III iAlh IL
KGratWick, a lumber merchant and president
VSf the Chamber Of Commerce. Buffalo: Cyrus
~. 6ulzberger, president Of N. Erlange
tB1umgart Il Co., New York city; Joseph j.
darlington, lawyer. Washington, II. c.:
nCharles A. Hopkins. former manager Of the
Mutual Life Insurance Company for Massa-
4Chuseuts, Boston. Mass; Cassills G. Shirley.
aex-Attorney-Genera Of Indiana. Indianapolis:
4rames -. Phelan. ex-Mayor OF San Francisco
SRnd president OF the Mutual Savings Bank OF
That city: T.. Reid Pel. president Of the Life
Underwriters Association. New York city;
3Horace Bunch Mcdaniel. president Of the
60nion National Bank. Springfield, Mo: j.
Idanpden Robb, secretary and treasurer OF
4ShO Greenwich Savings Bank. New York city:
ANustus Q. StrawbridE &c. merchant. Philadel-
Nfhia: Herman Ridder. editor. New York city;
HnOorge G. Amyot. president Quebec Board OF
AHrade, Canada; Rowland Winn, Lord st.
I8Oswald, Wakefield. Yorkshire. England Pierre
WBaudin, president OF the American
TBank and ex-Cabinet Minister Of Public
NWorAp. Paris.
The following proxy committee IL named
A2cr the united committees ticket: Benja-
him F. Tracy Of New York, Bernard N,
/DaRer Of Baltimore and A. NJ. Shook oil
&zashville; Tenn.
Here IL the international committed
Nkacket for the,board Of trustees OF the New
KXcrk Life:
VI Frederic r. Coudert Of the law firm Of
SDoudert Bros. New York city; William F
NDrAper, former United States Ambassador
70 Italy, Hopedale, Mass: John W.. Dunn
1president Of the International Steam PumT
Eompany. New York city: Frederick B. Lynch
HNecretary and treasurer OF the Northwestern
HCoIonization Company. st. Paul.. MINI.
,SIsidor Newman. senior member Of the bank
ing firm Of Isidor Newman 4 Sons. New Or
leans: Francis II. Leggett. president Of Fran
CTS H. Leggett 4 Co.. New York city; AdOlpl
Lewisohn representing the German policy
holders), president Of the United Metal
Selling Company. New York city: Hugh Kelly
president Of Hugh Kelly a Co.. commission
merchants, New York city: John D., Di1en
bauRh, president Of the Bricl
and Tile Company. Monmouth. H.: Minor c
Keith, vice-president and director OF tn,
United Fruit Company. New York city: D
Witt Clinton Flanagan, president OF tn,
Zeltner Brewing Company. New York city
John T.. Christie. president Of the ludlov
valve Manufacturing Company. Troy. N. Y.
George Fl. Robinson. vice-president and d.
pootor NJ q l. Howard A. Co New Yorl