The times dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1903-1914, 1906-07-15
Fertilizer en- demanded. u <
J Judge GOff ( i TO g II, the 4
ennie;s J; e;sS6es Court I; d! \ q B
APPEA n X KEhI {: 4 Il T( 4
FiIlC u EST C|OllJ| { |l] 4 JRT q
Tinsley Case Settles Ten Others.
4. All the Dcfcnd dants Give Bond ~
in Sum of5$5,ooo Pending
Appeal, e / United &,
States Supreme
ISl5 Court.


5.s' United u States senior. Circuit udge
Nathan Goff yesterda ftcrnoon. q after fter
y hearing lengthy arg un,ent on the petllf-i pe1lfi
4 ton OF James c. a. 'rlnsley, one Of the In
dicted fertilizer men, for ID writ Of ha beas
corpus and discharge from custody, WI ere
he had been placed by \ the decree of
n Judge Waddiil, .of. the United States Dis
Il trIct Court. rendered a. decls lon 81 miss
Ing the petition ana remandingl tile pc g.
4 tioner TO the custod " OF i he u lied states
Marshal to be transit ferred to the Aiidd,e e
q District OF Tennessee there TO be- tried
b under an Indictment found byts q Jnited !td
Il States court Grand Y. Jury. M
The decision was rendered ant az 30 Y.
Y M. and Immediately counsel u ifonss the de-
4 fendant, Tlnslcy,Eand all the defendants MS
IN the famous case OF 3the 3Unitedt ( Isl tes
\ OF America "a gainst-t ife q irginia- Carolina
4 Chemical Company and Others. gay g m o.
q tice OF an appeal TO the SSuprenle Court
OF the United States. II ,335 II 81 III
Judge tioh "a yes co1,nsel uni u 4 clock
TO prepa re md spresent the pa pers. CO un'
Il sci also announced A.nat thers efendanlt4ss =
Il ten lin number. were read y& to- submit 70
arrest.fnnd5 have their cases take h the
same course as Tinsley' 81 s5t tG y IL.
s8B They we're according elSaS arrested 4 by
warrants issued by Judge WaddlM and
In. the afternoon when Judge tGoff gain.
occupied the bench, the formal PROG +
5ings OF the moving i the cases up TO the
highest court In the land were gone
through, With, and thus, ", for q the first
and all the nther antitrust legislation
/ OF Congress viii get !, 81 duarely beforeSth he
Supreme Court of8lthe United States q
81 America /, for a decision as to their con. !.
stltutionallty.f ;3 f53 q. l5ss
# Judge GoR took, his seat at 10 % clock
yesterday morning and 9inmed dately J, Mr..
Eft. Sanford. special assistant attorney
general OF the United States. took tho.
floor to reply TO Mr. sYertress ofs Ten
the afternoon before, NJ, y sais ei
IS N Mr.. Sandford's argument was brief but
pointed and brilliant, md this closed tho
case for the government, AE Yertress
replying. closed the case for the pet!r
y toner. t5s l & WI. N 4. 3 M 4
While the two speeches We're strong and
very interesting, no new points We're
brought out. Both spea kers3 81 luck closely
TO the old text, Mr.. sandford 3eontending
that the yolllminous Indictment found In
b the Middle District Of Tennessee against
the petitioner and others was sufficient
evidence of probable guilt and that on
this evidence Judge Waddlll was right
IN ordering removal to Tennessee for
< trial. and the other side cOntending that
b Testimony toRproye or disproye the al le-
cations in # the @TenHessee indictment
\ should be admitted before the order Of
committee could Bbe mad d, S hi s5gS
The Decision, .,5
lmmed Hal telys upon 4 he conclusion Of the
p ypeech OF f.5 Mr. Vertress. y ud dge Goft rem.
X az (c,ontinild 8nn sryent ~ PaC A.. II SIs