The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1905-03-11
NIPPUR'S UNREYEALED LORE.
DIR. HILPRECHT CHALLENGED TO
DISCLOSE TEMPLE TABLETS.


AsSyrtOlosists Accuse pennsylvania 'h'-
yersity Man OF MOnopoil'lns scl'h'
tlnc Maierlal-Sohc doubt fN'e"'
OF Temple Finds-Dr. Peterss We've
.,h. ARCHAEOLOGICAL ,,,ro.rber,,s Of Pbila-
81, ~ ,Ii.,,,rhed bv the
Sps a,,t,s, Dr. Hermann HI
-, 49,, f',,ci int n snonliny broeze
A ,,j,lic,tions in pbiladol-
"a, ani affiliations In New York Phila-
'lo,nbia r,nors hnented the incrcdulity
~ H., ,.i., t.ciic,.nd tho professor OF
arob'aoroc,, of ,ba University of Penn
1T, ,,,,,I,t, ~ ,lo,,, m, ,innrofessionaI
~. NJ Y,-l, critics rc,.,nteft tba charges
~ o,.,l,,ll ,,er, into -, noR lirec, state
"""
picht' .. 49,,
II Is not, sad me New lorN v''uCs' 'ia ,s
Or Hhprecht has appropriated TO himself
,be t,blnt- from the temple Of Nippur found
49,. ...., ,t,, t.,. Ian. I,ncu unity
~ "'"'' '' ~, H., Il
OF the Hih OF IhGl"'' 'i.r .Ea,n7, ~ ','",,
Peters, rector Of ~ Mchlei huTcu' luiS
citv. and an A-syriologist OF note. and
ctiers ,yb,, assisted him in hl- early career.
i.n.,. ia. t,,,ol. and ,,,,-,pblets
iVi - '' '''"' '' '''' I,
ne mas mace EI"N" Ih'77'A'e NV
il simply that he has been Affected win
meralocaphalfis. an allmont more or le-s
co,,,,o,, ,r,o-,. ,-svriolori-ts and that
IL. ,,, t,i ,.,,,, -, co,cc,l from,
the SCIENTIFIC world original material. both
In the University OF Pennsylvania museum
and In tho Imperial Museum al CONSTANT
nop'e .u ords; tN1' bee might use these
materials IL, enhance his own scholarly
ra,,,,,,,,,, .,,b.r .h,r f., ,,rtril,uts TO
,...i.i.,
tho general -'7ph col scientific knowledge
In" charge rs auruarie h"'thcr To- the
common uorfhe statute law but is a serious
thing anon, 1rehtologi-t1
~ p,,or. r.,,..,o,od las, evo-i-, the
~ - '''"'N
h'"icIn'HI 't'' 'H''' o' DIe Vul'Ioil III
tablets OF the So called Temple Library.
claimed hv DR. HilpreCht 10 have been
disco,crei hv him N, Nippir in 1900 we're
rooll4 nrotrih.d h., year. rreyio,isly by
,~,i.. -,.,.b ,,.,.-f ne tfll,,,.lt i,pJ NJ
ne rb,tn,er "a eo and long before the
~ -, ,.,r..J N Ni,,,,,,r
IN ,,, t,e v,.r..'g, sssd Dr pete-s
.tlr, ~ ii.,r. -rrlI.aI. al tabiets ,yero nm.
't.l o.. .r ,,,la - N,,,.,,r M,
tsbic.- core f,unJ liz Dr IIHynns fed
Iiiroctor ~ ina nr,cditior md Dr Haynes
- ,rc,,.r,,. tbs,r ror sbirr,apt ,ybar
H. HuIrr,.t, tban iust onrointeI
director iu charge arrived and took nos
sas.;o,, a. tcr, H.. ,,,,onrCcf A. lrfa
RI ,bo t5i.lai, cr,,rr;te5 tbe FEMME
7 I'm. r~ .,bioi, tho ,,.,,alii.ior hal 80,
ss,rct,,- No, /, tl, Gva vears sip,a
,b1t limo .ba .,pterts Of the fabiets b4,e
w., -, ,,,,t,i,.ir
.7bo I.iv ,ror.,,,;,, Assvr;,1,gista
b,,a r,,-,,,1 4 ~ IN" ,oiIac.i,n M Iae1
nn",,i,,l , ~, 80, 80" r,,r,,i,i,.5
-,,,"r r,- m. ti,i,,,,cS, ii, ,-b * az" 80
,,t,l.,t ,i...',.,.i 49,
iIrbich IT, liI,,r-'i, ,i,i,,, hn e.,,'5 40
W%i i. Ut ,,, aims NE ,,r"', W.
80" -, y 49, -, 60,
i,,or,,.,,l, , ,,, - ~,
D.. - - iI', '',.-.' -
49,, ,', ~ l,as
''f'''' .''.- CO.. '+i'l.''A- N''''''
I,l,r,Si u..i|u y, d n,'I,i lli,al'9u la,le Pqi
T 1s ~ in' WIZ Ht,rlet t"I!ii,reu ~
iIW' Np.+It IIdHVls harper I" 'hi'db' I
.ntnNttaIE.
rIod. rIlS' enc IN 10 i'urtst OF
tc'ehlinc rum nave prVNEht ue7e errors
70 NE alien, ''h %, me 'o4I' on u-.ttes
ol lne 'eI,;lE ~ lenil-y w ,'la : peIait
mem "i aIoh""'"RF ana nave rested
prfsen laG's Whch tIg ,niIeFr1ty % Penn