davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
New-York tribune., 1905-02-09
FOR EYTRADITTON.
Hoe United States Nay Get Greene
and GGgR0r.
lay rr1EaRApH TO THE TRIBUNE. J

OTTAWA Ont Feb S-Hon r. w Scott Sec
retary Of State. I'm speaking Of the Greene-Gay-
nor case said the matter had not and would not
come before the Privy Council Of Canada. The
proper course to pursue. he said, was TO have
the country demand extradition I'm formal
way. and make application 10 the Secretary of
State. When the papers were received by him
he said he would submit them to the Minister
of Justice who would give his opinion The
apers with the opinion of the Minister Of JUS
tice would then be forwarded TO Quebec and
there acted upon. In the present the Sec
retary Of state is Of the opinion that the papers
already in the hands of the Canadian courts
Will DO and that Of course. when the case is re-
opened the United States r~ould send to Can
ada their qualified representatives As the case
is Of a particularly serious nature, il may be
taken for granted thai Canada will be guided
by the decisions of the British Privy Council
No doubt the viii be reopened and that
Gaynor and Greene viii be rearrested unless
they win be tried before Judge Lafontaine, OF
Montreal. In the mean time it is believed here
that the United States would do well TO make
a further demand for the extraditiOn of the
fugitives
Montreal. Feb. S-Judge La Fontaine, Extra
dition Commissioner, before whom the case was
being heard on its merits at the time of the
habeas corpus proceedings said to-day:
Unless something unforeseen occurs the Sheriff
of Quebec will now have TO deliver the prisoners
10 Governor Nallee at the Montreal jail, and they
viii then be brought before me and the regular
trial halted by the writ of habeas corpus will be
recommended. shall then upon the evidence
submitted decide whether not there is suffi-
cient grounds for extraditng the accused men
I presume. however. that nothing whatever will
be done until the receipt in Quebec of the official
Committee.
Donald MacMaster, X. c., counsel for the
United States in the Gaynor-Greene case, refused
to discuss the next steps to be taken in the case
New-York tribune., 1905-02-09
WANTS A STRONGER BILL.
The Presidents attitude on Rate
Legislation.
CBy The Associated Press3

Washington, Feb. S.-While President Roose-
velt approves the TOwnsend-Esch Railroad
Freight bill pending before the House of Repre-
sentatives, it Is understood that he would like
to have incorporated in it stronger provisions re-
lating TO private car lines. Representative Bah
cock. of Wisconsin, had a talk with the Presi-
dent to-day about the pending legislation. He
holds the same views regarding private car lines
as the President They discussed the bill for
some time. Senator McComas. of Maryland
also talked with the President about the pending
railroad legislation. The President Is endeavor-
ing to bring about action in the Senate at this
session on the rate question, hoping it may take
up the Townsend-Esch measure when the House
passes 1t.
New-York tribune., 1905-02-09
DEBATE ON RATE BILL.
Both Republicans and Democrats
Claim Credit for Tt.

Washington, Feb. s-For two hours preceding and
three hours following the count of the electoral
vote the question of freight rate regulation held
full sway in the House to-day.
The discussion was opened by Mr. Tbavar oS
Massachusetts. who congratulated the President
the Republican party the majority of the Com
mittee on Interstate and Foreign Commerce for
adopting what he declared to be a purelv Dar,o.
cratic measure. After character1zing the Hepburn
bill as being also Democratic measure ba oba..
that 1t had been pulled down. at the instance a.,
the President as not meeting his APPRECIATION
MT Bartlett OF Georgia supporting the minority
bill, explained the attitude of the South as NOT ~
Ing radical 1t was. he insisted, conservatives and
he said that when the time came to presArva +ha
country from radicalsm. socialism or anarchy the
South would save it from destruction
Insncerity was ascribed TO the Republicans ~,
Mr.. Cochran, of Missouri in the matter Of rate
legislation He said that It was not intended e.
pass the pending bill, but simply to do soroatbin
to pacfy public sentiment
Mr.. Esch, Of Wisconsin. who assisted I'm fraroIr,x
the bill. summed up the arguments for and against
it up to the present time Some, he said had ra
garded il the important Hesitation sfnca
the Civil War. while others had contended II
amounted to nothing. Such extreme views he ba1d
to be indicative of the fact that bill was what
1: professed to be-a compromise. He then at
length justified the action of the majority of tbe
committee in providing the court of transportation
on which, he said, opposition seemed to be centred
Mr.. Grosvenor ridiculed the Democrats for their
claim to credit for rate legislation He provoked
laughter when he declared that following our
footsteps toe marking our tracks camping To-
night where camped last night and begging TO
be taken board is not policy or princi-
ple of the Democratic party"
Mr.. Grosvenor discussing the relative merit.
OF the several bills when he was interrupted bv
Mr. Shackleford, of Missouri. with the statement
that the Hearst bill had not had an opportunity n
be considered.
"oh." replied Mr.. Grosvenor amid laughter and
Republican applause your party denied II he
did The Hearst bill, he declared was
as dead Julius Caesar. having been sIaughtereS
by a Democratic caucus.
Mr. Vreeland. Of New-York, who voted against
his party the adoption of the rule to take nm
the rate question opposed the pending IeeisIs tio
the ground that it was socialism and not Re-
publican doctrine.
His utterance vigorously controversies hv A1r
Kyle, OF Ohio who said that the Republican Marty
had heard and needed the cry of the people for
rate legislation.
New-York tribune., 1905-02-09

aslc-,Io T1-oaei,r f-o,np7pv charged that the gov
ernn,ent n.d bern dcfrauded ont OF soS''is :"
Nesers. ia yrer and Greene were arrested IN TINS
city and before United states Commissioner
Shields they contested extraditon 20 Georgia
Then bail WAS fixed at $4,000 each. and after the
commissioner decided against them this WAS Tor
fetcd and they fed 10 Canada When they were
,ubseouentlv found 20 be there extradtion pro-
ceedines were begun in Montreal. when the TWO
mon vent 20 Quebec. There was question IN re-
eari 10 their extrsditioH from that city, and de-
tectives kidnapped them and took them PACK 10
Montreal in & fast tug. which was iolioWeo p'
ano:her chartered by friends. and by tast tram
A ouebe. idge granted writ Of haaeas corpus
which was served on their Montreal jailor' VINO
released them without informing the eNhaoipoh
commission. After their return 10 quebec e1orts
TO quash the writ were without result. ana long
legal sQuahbe ensued. the outcome ot wnic1 Wts
the issue Of another writ hy Judge CaIon i Wis.
granted 10 Greene and Ga!nor their treeaom ~a'nh mn
the boundaries CT the Province o. Stet'sc anu ;.5
erlEted them from interference by the ntted
The Privy Council in England Both GayneT and
Greene have their families witt taem in Quebec.
i,iItT Tow door Of ea@h oher the families do
sts nding years ago. 1t IS only when some
matter comes up relative 20 their case that the two
men confer I; is said by those who know them.
Colonel Gaynor has MS house furnished win me ne
occupied when he WAS treasurer OF the stare
iiaF he did not Believe he could ger justice in this
country and preferred 20 take his chances in
Aa-eaca- DeSf1ite TIE oettSi'tl nv
his friends believe that loopholes Of the law may
stiil afford q of escape from eXtraditloh
and every possible legal step VIII be taken 10
avoid he giving UP Of the two n'en 10 the Ihted
States authorities.
colonel Csaynor's first wife died several years ago
in Eune 1889. the announcement was made that ne
had been married to Miss Annie L. Pitney. type
tl,at on Sentefnber 1890 Colonel Gaynor and Miss
Carrie r. Clifford were married and there was tang
OF prosecution for bgamy The case Was settled
bv the granting OF a divorce TO Miss CLIFFORD. a
Miss Starr being the correspondent named, ana IN
December Of the year Colonel Gayror ana
Miss Pitney went through another ceremony. Ihe
Miss Starr who appeared in the case also made a
claim 10 being the wife of Colonel Gaynor. but
while he admitted knowing her he denied any
ceremony or marriage.
New-York tribune., 1905-02-09
COUNT ELECTORAL VOTE.
Continued from first page.

places at the Speakers desk. and the certificates
were read by each teller in turn.
Alabama came first. the certificate being do
clared in regular form and duly authenticated
1t showed that Alton B. Parker of New-York
and Henry G. Davis, of West Virginia. had re-
ceived the II votes OF that State. The Demo-
Gratis applauded. Mr.. Burrows caused laughter
by announcing that Alabama voted for "Allen"
b. Parker. The other States were called in
alphabetical order. The first mention of Presi-
dent Roosevelts name came when the vote OF
California was announced. and was the signal
Tor applause from the Republican side.
At the suggestion OF Senator Cockrell TO save
time the reading OF subsequent certificates in
detail was dispensed with. the result of the vote
simply being announced. Intense interest was
shown by the occupants of the galleries, which
were densely packed. At every mention of tho
names of the candidates their admirers an
plauded. ~
The announcement that Maryland had et,e,
one vote for Roosevelt and Fairbanks was sraet
ed with applause and handclapping by Renuh
llcans, which was renewed by Democrats vhan
the further announcement was made that parIrer
and Davis had received the remaining votas
There was n marked demonstration by tho ne
publicans when Mlssouris is votes were an
Fairbanks. The applause came mostly from, ,ha
members Of the House. More Republican ar
piause broke forth when the announcement ryau
New-York tribune., 1905-02-09
REFUGEES STILL HAVE HOPE.
Their Counsel Expects Further Contest
Their Homes at Quebec.
lBY TELEGRAPH TO THE TRIBUNE


Ottawa, Ont, FEB. S-The Gaynor and Greene
decision caused excitement throughout Canada
The press devotes columns TO it, and comedies a
victory the American government United
States Secret Service said TO be keeping
the refugees under the closest surveillance. Both
men. who have been accustomed to go often
have been hardly seen the streets of Quebec
FOR three days They took the announcement of
the decision coolly, and referred a correspondent
10 their solicitor. Alexander Tascheau who was
authorized TO talk for them. Asked if his clients
would have go back 70 Montreal. he said
do not understand il that way. This IS merely
al academiCal declaration maintaining the appeal
without indicating of action. 1t does not
mean that they will have 10 before Judge Lafon-
taine. but that the United States government may
The two men. We have not gtvsn UP the fight. by
any means. We hope TO be able 20 continue the
struggle.
Colonel Greene is living in fine house, formerly
occupied by Sir Adoph Caron, and Mr. GaynOr
occupies another handsome building in the fash
fonabe section Of Quebec
Ottawa government officials consider the scene of
the fight for freedom VIII at once shift TO Mon
treal
New-York tribune., 1905-02-09

made that New York's 30 votes had been cast
for the Republican standard bearers
BY coincidence it fell to the lot of Senator
Bailey TO read the vote of his own State TEXAS
A similar coincidence occurred when Mr. Gaines
read the vote Of West Virginia.
THE RESULT DECLARED
AS soon the votes of all States had been
read Senator Frye directed the tellers to make
a FORMAL announcement of the result. When
the total vote was ready to be announced bv
Senator Burrows there complete silence. In
clear voice he announced that the total eIec-
toral vote was 476. of which a majority wa
ZaS. Theodore Roosevelt, for President and
Charles w. Fairbanks for Vice President had
each received 1886. and Alton B. Parker for
President, and Henry Gassaway Davis for vica-
President. had each received 40 votes sa,-
ator Frye recapitulated the vote, ana then r,ada
the following announcement:
This announcement OF the state of vota h, A.
president or the Senate shall be deemed a sufo
nclent declaration of the persons elected praai
dent ana Nice-President OF the United sstaeor
each for the term beginning March 4 Iao5 80
snail be entered. together with liet - e .h
votes on the journals of the Senate ana ~ LII u,e
of Representatives. ~ house
He then declared the purpose for whit. -.
joint convention had been called to baya -
accomplished. dissolved the convention ana -
quested the Senators to return to their oho.1
Der. The proceedings occupied exactly fftv min
utes.
New-York tribune., 1905-02-09
LOBBYING FORBIDDEN.
attorney General Warns Subor-
dinates of His Department.

Washington. Feb. S-Attorney General Moody has
addressed the following communication to all dis
trict attorneys, marshals ana others employed in
under the Department of Justice:
It has como to my attention that in the past as
well at the present. time, district attorneys and
marshals and their subordinates have been en-
ployed in their respective States as attorneys or
otherwise in promoting opposing the enactment
of laws by the State legislatures. The work of
legislative counsel where no imprOp:- methods are
used. is recognized as professional duty which
believed that such work ought not to be undertaken
by those who hold federal offices. Therefore dis
tric attorneys assistant district attorneys clerks
TO the district attorneys United States marshals
all others in under this department are instruct
These instructions do not forbid the appeara nee
of such officers before legislative committees as
witnesses or the expression. without compensa-
tion OF their views citizens.
New-York tribune., 1905-02-09
Reaches Moundsville with the Groffs-
Duties Not Yet Assigned.

Moundsville W. Va, Feb s.-August W. Machen,
with Diller B. Grof and Samuel A Gron who
were sentenced to imprisonment in the Moundsville
Penitentiary as result OF the postal investigation
arrived from Washington to-day. Machen and the
Grofrs had nothing to say and Appeared uncon-
cerned.
Owing to the absence OF Warden Haddox the
prisoners will not be assigned their duties until
his return on Thursday, Samuel Gror Is broken
IN health. and Will not likely be put 10 work for
some time. The trip from Washington TO the prison
was made without incident.
Washington, Feb S-Postnaster General Wynne
has ordered investigation of the incident that
occurred at the railway station here YESTERDAY
when carrier said 10 Machen just before the in,
ter's departure for the pententiary that Machen
had the sympathy OF a large number az the Srsa
delivery carriers The Postmaster General feels
that such remark does not represent the sentI-
ment of the carriers
Word reached District Attorney Morgan III Beach
to-day from Toledo. Ohio. that Dr. Lorenz. who was
convicted with Machen and tho Grorfs will he
brought to Washington by his bondsman on Non
day. In view OF l.orenzs severe illness Mr. Baaeh
l. not disposed to have him run any risks IL viii
be necessary Tor Lorenz 10 come to WashInsfon "
be formally surrendered by his bondsman as n nrse
ltminary 10 being sent to Ntoundsyfle III ,s ssats
that a movement is under way with a ylew 10 sst
Ing the President TO pardon DIR. Lorenz - 0N
New-York tribune., 1905-02-09
SALES OF PAINTINGS AND ART WORKS.

Paintings on free view to-day until noon at
The american Art Galleries in Madison Square
south. belonging 10 the estates of Mrs Sarah p
conkline, Samuel B. Sexton Mark Hoyt. Arthur A
Crosby and L. Crist Demonico. They will be sold
tonight and Tomorrow night at $50 O'Clock a.
1endelssohn Hall. in East 4Oth-st A collection
% placques. original bronzes and weapons
And few etciIings. collected by Mrs ConkIng
WIZ be sold this afternonO at 2:so O'Clock AZ tfo
american Art Galleries. on tomorrow and satur
aiy afterioon, n the same hour and pIace . -,
1911 OF arms and armor Of old Japan v,ood
- iiiE. ana other objects gathered nv = NJ
the sales. - N'i'y viii conduct
New-York tribune., 1905-02-09
CONkLIN IN THE LEAD.
Gardner and Sigowney Tied for
Second Place IN Billiards.

Chicago Feb S.-Charles F. Conklin of Chca go,
with five games won and one lost. stands tonight
at the head of the winning column in the amateur
billiard tournament for the championship Of the
United States, now in progress at the Chicago
Athletic Club Edward G. Gardner of Nevy-York
ana W. H. Sigourney OF San Francisco, are tied
for second place. each having won four games and
lost one These two players will meet tomorrow in
the final scheduled game of the tournament and
piOnship
New-York tribune., 1905-02-09
JOINT BALLOT IN DELAWARE.
Deadlock on Senatorship Confirmed - Nine
for Dupont, Twenty-Five for Addicks.

Dover. Feb. s-The first Joint ballot for United
States Senator taken by the Delaware I.egis-
lature in joint session at to-day and showed
no change in the deadlock that was foreshadowed
by the ballot in the two houses separately yeser-
day. The vote was:
J. Edward Addicks. Union Republican %; VII
lard Saulsbury, Democrat. 20; Colonel Henry A. Du-
pont Regular Republican. 8; absent 10: total vote
o.: necessary to choice. 2s - '
The joint assembly then adjourned until noon to-
New-York tribune., 1905-02-09
FIRE IN FERRYBO4T.
Small Blaze Discovered an Time on
the Fulton.

fire was discovered in the mems cabin OF the
ferryboat Fulton. of the Fulton Ferry when she
reached her Brooklyn slip on her O'Clock trip
from Manhattan last evening. There ex-
element. most of the passengers had passed off
the boat when the discovery of the blaze was made
by deckhand. The fire started under seat and
was caused by a lighted match thrown into a pile
or papers by careless passenger. II was put out
by the crew, the damage amounting 10 about s25
New-York tribune., 1905-02-09
MRS. CAROLINE oRNE DEAD.
TBY TELEGRAPH TO THE TRIBUNE

TBY TELEGRAPH THE TRIBUNE.l
Cambridge Mass, Feb S--Caroline Orne. the
poet author of Letters of Marque" and manv
other widely known poems died to-day She was
eighty-seven years old. She a friend of Long
fellow and Holmes and playmate of James Rus
sell Lowell. Her genius early recognized bv
Longfellow and Holmes, and when the former COM
piled his work containing writings OF American
authors he selected Miss Orne's Letters OF
MaTdue."
New-York tribune., 1905-02-09
H H ROGERS AND H C. FRICK ELECTED
Become Members of the Atchison. Topeka
and Santa Fe Road

The directors of the Atehison. Topeka and Santa
re Railway Company yesterday elected Fl. Fl
rogers ana II. [. Frick 10 membership in the
board, to succeed e. d. Kenna and John q McCuI
lough. whose designations were offered ana 40
cepted. Mr. Rogers was elected also rnernbar
ca,,e sne executive conmittee. 10 f the vacancy
'""sed py the resignation of b. p Cheney 10y
New-York tribune., 1905-02-09
rneumonIa and arln rollox .hs s.a.

LAXATIVE BRoMo oUIN1NE prevents pn.,-,-
ture OF 10. w. Grows. CSC wv sigma
New-York tribune., 1905-02-09
G. G. Shayne
OFFERS MANUFACTURED FURS
AT THE FOLLOWING DISCOUNTS.


Chinchma a.Lynx,A asabeC
....
IudsonBa Persia Erninea dMaten..
Mens Ganent of
Ei mined and Paa Lamb Jackets
~ ~ -..-....
ia
paper) of
nd2 vest
Insuran passed
nartdon VII
willie
ntIu finish T above
ce
cen
pete a wbunTn
will
in time % uo
sn
4lSt and 42d Sts
Broadway Sixth Avenue
New-York tribune., 1905-02-09

TO CURE A COLD IN ONE pxy
lake Laxative BroIno oainne Tablet. An ,r,~~,.,.
IeIond the money II 90 SIrs n " eSss.ss
sishAturs u on each " ~AS'''
New-York tribune., 1905-02-09
Ast and 42d Sts.,
MACHEN AT THE PENITENTIARY.

Between Broadway and Sixth Avenue.
Evening bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu, Hawaii]) 1895-1912, 1905-01-14
Hilo BOARD OF TRADE.
IIlilo Tribune.l


The report of the years operations
OF the Hilo Board of Trade has demon.
strated the usefulness of that organiza.
ton in the town and vicinity of lIilu.
The Executive Council has worked in.
dustriously and effectively and has
wide and useful field before IT, lts
purpose Is to bring together more
closely those who are DESTROYS Of study.
ing the needs of the city and com.
munity. The members of the Board
have displayed their interest In the
improvement of our town and are
manifesting such interest in an intel
ligent and practical manner.
The present officers who have work.
ed so faithfully for the past year are
re elected for the ensuing term. This
IL as II should be and those gentle.
men who have the confidence of the
cd as officers can be relied upon to
protect Hilo's and Ilawaii's interest
wherever and whenever IL demands
protection.
Tho Board Of Trade does not pro
pose to take any part in politics or
political elections and should have no
candidates for any political Office. lts
main purpose should be to study the
| economic and social conditions Of the
! community with a view to civic bet
j termcnt suggesting remedies for pres
Cnt evils, such as defects in street
supervision and public improvements,
sanitation, education, public health
| and public morals. Having these OBJ
! jccts in views, such an organization
can and should accomplish great
work in the improvement and up
building of the community in which
| We live,
Evening bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu, Hawaii]) 1895-1912, 1905-01-14
WHAT az ALI. MANS.

The pith of this Pinkham Commits.
sion report discussion is that the Com.
mission has gained facts showing the
exact industrial condition of the is.
lands and has sought to BRING capital.
H. represented by the sugar planters.
and labor as represented by the
mechanics unions together to cooper
ate in strengthening the main indus,
try of this Territory.
Thurston jumps into the situation
with his paper, condemns the report
before he has seen 1t, declares II mis-
represents the small farmer before he
knows what the small farmer says, and
to assist in the wreckage abets the
dissension among the labor men, prac.
tically urging them to throw the whole
proposition overheard and have notll-
ing to do with the planters in their
readiness TO give to citizens the skilled
and semi-skilled labor.
The program laid down by the Pink.
ham Commission cannot possibly in
!ure the small farmer for whom Thurs
ton suddenly shows so much solicitude.
II will aid him by providing wider
local market for his products
The net result OF the Thurston news
paper cutlery is to damage the planta,
ton interests, ruin the cooperative
plan Of labor and capital. and accom-.
plish nothing for the small farmer.
Naturally the community has no sym.
Pathy with the Thurston program and
refuses TO be led into its follles.
Labor has to determine whether 1t
will sell its birthright for a mess Of
false pottage offered in the Thurs.
Ton newspaper plan.
Evening bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu, Hawaii]) 1895-1912, 1905-01-14
ARROYO MURDER CASE TO JURY
Continued from Pace -

Strauss would not accept the time
limit proposition. He would either ar.
cue without any limitation of time or
would have no argument at all.
Andrews said that he was not sure
but that the Supreme Court on an
appeal might hold that Strauss had
prejudiced the case of the defendant
by not arguing, and Andrews did not
propose to be caught by any such
trick.
Strauss objected to the use Of the
word trick, and said that he intended
to do no such thing.
The court stated that If the defense
declined TO argue the case, he though,
that the prosecution had no right to
argue. While this point was under
discussion Juror John Guild stated in
behalf of his fellow jurors that the
jury would gladly give its time to hear
argument in the case.
Strauss then proceeded with his ar.
gument. giving an eloquent and dram.
attic history Of the case from the de.
PENDANTS point Of view. The point ri
his argument was that the defendant,
having been threatened of his life by
his victim and other Porto RiCaus, had
reason to fear RIVERA and in killing
him did SO in sclf.defense.
Andrews in his turn said that muir
ders Of this kind had to be stoEIed
He went through all the details Of tho
defendants statement which he char
acterizcd as improbable and false.
At little after u o'clock the court
began giving its instructions 20 the
jury.
After the instructions had been Civ
en- a recess was taken until 9 p. m. In
order to give the jury time to have
lunch. before considering the verdict