The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1905-08-31
MANCHURIA FOR THE JEWS.
More About an Interesting Susg estiso ia
the Russian Government.

From the American HebreU of to-day.
You deserve to DO congratulated upon Your
short but very suggestive editorial anent
Manchuria. Prof. Deutsohs statements in
his NO less suggestive epistle Of Aug. II con-
firm me in the stand my self took In my
open letter 10 Mr.. Sergius Witte concel min g
the impro liability Of . satisfactory solu ton
OF the Jewish problem on the soil Of Ru asia
herself.
Let US speak plainly. The overwhelming
majority OF the jews Of central and western
Europe and the New World, In view OF the
sheer impossibilty OF their penetrating the
empire OF the RomsnofYs and their CORFU pied
tchin. know de visu only restricted number
OF their Ru ssian brethren and have q very
indistinct Idea Of the real economical situa-
ton Of the 5.2is.Ooo brethren who were left
behind. Hand aus Hersi How many
among us entertain more than the absolu tely
necessary relations with their own brothers
and sisters nephews and nieces In the old
country. wrapped up as We are In our own
welfare and absorbed by the enervating
struggle for existence3 Months. often years,
are passing without the exchange OF q single
letter between blood relations.
To come now TO my point: Are We really
sincere In our protestations OF pity SYM
pathy and love for that vague and moon CRU :
GUS mass OF millions Of unknown individuals
In Poland and the Pale OF Settlement With
out indorsing absolutely the views on this
point OF DR.. Krauskopfis last presid en- tisl
message to the C. C. A. R., / incline toward
the belief that neither the racial instincts
nor the national feelings, and stu less the
community OF religious convictions, are
indeed strong enoug Oh to draw the irreliglous
Yankee-Ashkenaz Germany or Yankee
sefardi tPortusuese) to the Chassidio (Cabs-
listtc) Polish or Russian Hebrew Of Kovno
or Minsk.
am positive not to be far from the tru tn
in asserting that. for instance. out of the
1850 we'll to do Jewish business men on New
iotks Broadway ,reprssenting fair average
single Jewish paper. showing thereby their
absolute indifference with regard to Jewish
thsaIpen1tIn,,ss beyond the narrow precincts Of
these prosperous business men and bankers
should the solutton Of the Jewish question.
carried hey ond the phase Of platonlo attempts
and vain rhetoric.
tss ss FROM b
- sss,a se CHORDS e
IL Wosa To cant
g.. Ss.1 r; ;:, s'J ~, III III yoS, nssss:s
thus translatina into twentieth century fEH Eng
sa shs cn2a: e lid FL ~ rSess
thereof shall W have peace.
The political Zionistio movement in one
shape or the other has to return sooner or
later to Choveyi tcolonization) Zionism, while
its stepchild. Territorlslism lprincipie OF the
State State without definition Of country to be
nationsstio dreamiand Is destne2 Gun 70 o. Hs
millions Of Jews from their vast Russian
perity. PAW
Manchuria will eventually become not .
for our unfoItunate brethren and the their V dse
ssS,e sn,i There the basic elements Of
shs Chri.tisn. Is from the outset eliminated
strife between Aryan and semitic, Mr rtSs,e
~ ImdisFoyeInmsnt Is to be feared when he
the councils OF the Chinese vlceroy Of Man.
ohurla the Alexieds and Bezobrasotfs OF un-
sAvory memory. - va"
In brief. the Russian Jew will be judred
lor hs real Qualities, he will have to thtnk
chOlio past iniDons assnwssn -
New YoHE AuS L. ""h"'