davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1905-05-07
NEW.YORF DAILY TRIBUNE. SUNDAY. MAY Q 1908

and not until, then. can the people Of this coun-
try have legitimate protection from the impo-
siI ~ VI s.t,Inate for the American people that
tbis iUnctmre there stands at the head of this
nation man with the ability to see and the
S 49, s,+tc,sed as an impulse. Upon the con-
trarY r. was only after long and careful con-
st6aT6tion that he reached this conclusion His
position is not radical ne proposes the very
ieasI th"' o''- CHARLES A. PROUTY.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1905-05-07

and is universally understood refer to II
only to make my statement OF these funda'
mental principles complete.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1905-05-07

NJ. rrouty is member OF the Interstate Commerce
Commission which body he argues should be endowed
with complete power and authority 10 fix rates and
enforce their Observance by the railroads
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1905-05-07
A PRACTICAL REMEDY.

II bae heen established by the decision OF
courts without number, including the highest
federal tribunal, that the right to apply this
remedy exists in the government With respect
to traffic entirely within the limits OF single
State this right inheres In the single State. In
case of traffic passing from one State to another
this right has been delegated by the States to the
United States under that provision of the Con-
stitution which gives to Congress the regula-
ton OF commerce.
II YOU ask me what is the remedy for the OIL
Trust or the Beef Trust the Steel Trust.
have none to offer. I would make certain that
no one of these great monopolies enjoyed over
the humblest member OF the public the slight
est advantage in railway service or railway
charges believe that this thing would go fur
Their toward solving the veXed problem OF the
control of these monopoes than any one thing
which could be done. / would enforce, in SO lar
as may be. the laws which to-day stand upon
the statute books against monopoly 1 do not
believe that there is serious danger of a per-
I?anent character under these conditions unless
there he G monopoly in the material with
which labor ard capital must work.
When, however, you ask me what is the rem
edy for railroad monopoy-how shall you pre-
vent that most insidious Of all monopolies from
unfair eXaction-I can give the remedy, rem
edy approved by the courts, tested by expert
ence. susceptible Of easy application and effec-
tive just in proportion it is effectively ap-
piled. The means by which this monopoly ex-
acts or Giscrimnates is the rate, and ii is by
controlling that rate that the evil can be pre-
vented You cannot stop the monopoly, but you
can regulate It. and thereby cure the wrong
The one practical remedy is to create COM
mission of some sort with power to hear COM
plants and prescribe the rate TO be charged
tor the future when the present rate is found
20 be wrong.
This is precisely the ground which che Pres-
DEM has taken upon this subject. He accepts
the commission which ne finds in existence and
he declares that this commission must be vest
ed with authority TO inquire, upon proper COM
plant, whether a published rate is just and rea-
sonable, anc ii il finds injustice or unreasona-
Dleness to prescribe the rate which the carrier
shall observe Cor the future.
Observe exactly what the issue Is. The prOpo-
sitiCn IS not that the government shall make
The railway rates Of this country but simply
that when the rate which the railroads have
themselves put il effect is found unreasonable
that rate shall be made right.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1905-05-19
DIED..

ATTERBCRf.On Thursday, May is. laos 81 ~
short illness. Anna NJ. wife of Col. william
Atterbnry. In the saith year OF her age
Funeral services at her late residence. 2on Dean
ST., Brooklyn, on Saturday. May 20. at o clock
1ntermcnt at convenience OF family. Kindly
omit flowers.
DANlS.-on Wednesday. May II. at his lat" res
dcncc AZ West End av. New York. fdwT
McCalla. beloved husband Of Wcnnnah II DAYS
and son OF Emma +. and the late John L. DAVIS
Funeral services at his late residence on Fr'dav
May 10. 1880 A. N. Intrrmcnt West Ls.T''
Hill Cemetery. Philadelphia
KlRCHwEY.-on Wednesday, May IL, lsai, GrorS'
youngest child Of George ". and Dora Wenl'H
Kirchwey in the sth year OF his ag-.
Funeral services on Friday at 10 4, NJ. Pns s.
Nicholas ay.
LETSoN.--A Stciton, y. j., s. Jcnnic. wife o'
Peter r, Ltson. entered into rest TUESDAY
May 10. 1905.
funeral services at her late hom", Frl!aT
May 10. Al o'clock Train leaves New York
Pennsylvania r. r.. i:3o.
hAlN.--At her residence, Port Chester, y
Susan G. Main widow OF Stephen 4. Main
Notice OF funeral hereafter.
PARKER On Thursday. May Is. Alfred NJ, Parser
Of Glen Ridge. n, j.. In his I'D year
Notice OF funeral hereafter. Detroit. Mich paper,
please copy.
RllS.--on THURSDAY. May IA. 1905. Elisabeth, ~
OF Jacob A. Ris OF Richmond Hnl, l. /.
Due notice Of funeral will BE- given.
WlLLtAMSoN.-A Rome, Italy, Thursday April
81. 1905. George Norman Williamson. Of Eng
wood. n. j.. In his SD year.
Funeral services at the Presbyterian Church ~
Eneiewood, OH the arrival of train leaving FIR
Railroad Chamber street, at l0l5 A. M.
West 2sd street 1910, and trolley leaving West
iSoth street ferry al lois A. NJ, Saturday. MAJ
20. lnterment private.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1905-05-19
FOund!
! l..

CA magazine Of the worlds
best fiction" is what " Tales" is
to be. 1t will contain nothing
but stories 49, stories humorous,
pathetic, descriptive, tragic, comic
stories from every language that
possesses literature - stories
from France, Germany, Italy,
Scandinavia stories from Spain,
Hungary, Arabia and Japan-all
translated into English. And the
stories will be the best that those
countries produce-nothing but
the best. In "Tales' every kind
of reader will find the kind of
story he likes best. Each number
will contain a complete novel, one
or two serials, and from fifteen to
twenty short stories. twill give
16o pages Of reading matter-the
largest quantity Of good fiction
ever included in one magazine.
Hadn't you better order it
from your newsdealer ?
~. D.. .o,,nv.d ., S,,s.o,,
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1905-05-19
Union With Cupberland Branch to BE
COnsidered-Dr. MOTat IL Moderator.

Union With Cupberland Branch to BE
Considered-Dr. Morat IL Moderator.
WNoNA LAKE. Ind, May ls.-The con-
teet for the Moderatorship OF the General
Assembly Of the Presbyterian Church,
which held it's first session here to-day,
did not assume the proportions usually
reached when presiding officer is to be
selected. The honor came late this after
noon to the Rev. DR.. James D. Moifat OF
Washington, Pa. by reclamation.
The Rev. John Fenton Henty OF Jetfer-
son City, Mo-, was suggested as candidate
against DR.. Moffat, and in the morning his
supporters made an energetic canvass Of
the commissioners in an effort to secure
votes for him. It developed, however
that DR.. Mofat was the choice Of decided
majority. and when this fact became patent
1t was decided to withdraw the opposition
and make his selection unanimous. The
elect ion was preceded by the sermon OF
the retiring Moderator. Dr. j. Addison
Henry and was followed by the sacrament
Of the Lords Supper.
The overshadowing question before the
General Assembly is that of the proposed
union with the Cumberland Presbyterian
branch. and it is being approached with the
greatest of caution by the commits Sit ners.
The Church in the North has voted almost
unanimously for the union, but there is
strong feeling against it in the Southwest.
and some of the leaders in the assembly
seem to think that there is trouble in store
for the Church if the union is pushed too
strongly. 1t is more than probable that
action may be deferred for the present and
the matter placed in the hands Of COM
mittee with power to act after hearing the
minority's grounds for opposition.
Some of the objectors have gone so far
as to threaten to take the matter to the
courts, and 1t Is this that the assembly
wishes to avoid. That large majority
but they want it to come peaceably and
believe the time will come when all Pres
byterians will receive the Cumberlands with
a genial spirit 90
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1905-05-19
MARRIED.

.GELOW-HlMELY.-O Thursday. May is, 1908
at Far Rockaway, l.. l.. by the Rev. Henry
Mesier. lrma Frederick. daughter OF Nj and
Mrs. Henry A. Hmely. TO Richard Bigelo1
OF New York.
MORSE HURSEY On Thursday. May IA. 1914
by the Rev. Henry Marsh Warren Franklin
Morse 10 Garnet V. Hurscy.
NEILSON-RuNYON. On Thursday. May IS. al
Chris, Church, New Brunswick, \. j.. By ehs
Rev. r. b. Joyce Bessie Kellogg, daughter OF
Mr.. and Mrs Garrison Runyou. to Charles
Frederic Nelson.
RAMSEY May Is. 1893, at st
Peters Church Brooklyn. y. y" BY the Rev Dr.
Lindsay Parker, Jane Eliza. daughter OF MI
and Mrs. Charles Parish Thurston TO GeorC.
Read Ramsey, both of Brooklyn. y. y.
REED-OTHEMAN.--O Thursday, May is. 1905
by the Rev. Dr. Wallace MacMulcn, at 81
Fast sd st., New York. Elsie Nj. otheman
daughter of Mr.. and Mrs, Francis Waylsnd
Otheman. TO the Rev, Harry Lathrop Reed Of
Auburn. n. Y.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1905-05-19
MR.. KEEN no MRS. 'ARRIS.
Presides vIslbly at Dickens DInner-Heresy
About Little Neil.


About Little Neil.
There is such person as Charles Ross
Keen, president Of the Manhattan Branch
Of the Dickens Fellowship. Last night
he verified his recent letter to THE Sun,
in which he denied his mythicalness, by
presiding over the Fellowship dinner at
the Hotel Empire. Fifty other wor-
shippers OF Dickens were with him. with
women in the majority They had the
roast beef of Old England. which came
from Kansas City. English muft'ns and
Cheshire cheese, not to speak OF straw
berries and other things that are luxuries
in London at this time of year.
The reason why Ernest H. Crosby was
not elected president Of the branch was
privately explained last night.
Mr. Crosby is a vegetarian, said the
informer, whispering. -and you know IL
would never do to have him preside at
Di kens dinners, where chops and rare
beef are necessary to the spirit
DR.. F. H. Sykes, who is director Of ex-
tension teaching at Columbia, talked about
the art of Dickens. He said that readers
nowadays did not think SO highly Of Dick.
ens's pathos. He referred to the school
children who wrote to Dickens while The
Old Curiosity Shop" was running serialy,
asking him not to let Little Nell die.
Il am inclined to think" he said that
readers Of the present time are ready to
let Nellie die, and die quickly"
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1905-05-19
HERBERT CR0kERS FUNERAL.
Mother Too Ill to AtteDd-Burial Il in
Calvary Cemetery.

The funeral OF Herbert Croker was held
yesterday from the Church Of st. Ignatius
Loyola, at Park avenue and Eighty-fourth
street Mrs. Richard Croker, the mother OF the
young man, did not go to the neral. She
intended to- but shortly before the funeral
procession left her home, at s East Seventy
fourth street, abe collapsed and her physi-
clan had to be summoned
Mrs. Cookers sudden iness delayed the
funeral procession somewhat the hearse
reaching the chI oh some little time before
the mo,lrnerT carriages The mourners
were Richard Croker, Jr., the Misses Ethel
and Florence Croker, Chief Edward Croker
Of the Fire Department, Capt. James Collins.
brother of Mrs. Croker, and Mrs. Cookers
mother. The latter, although not in good
Herbert Croker was her favorite grandson.
low mass at the church. and he was assisted
by Father Mckinnon, the pastor of st.
Ignatius Loyola. There were few persons
in the church outside the members Of the
family and their immediate friends. The
pallbearers were John Fox, Andrew Freed
man, Francis Mailer Thomas Connolly,
j. F. Rogie and Lawrence Mulligan The
interment was in the Croker plot at Calvary.
The church service was simple and there
was no funeral Grafton. There were many
floral tributes. These were taken to the
church and later carte. away. The horse
attached to the wagon which carried the
flowers away bolted near the church and
dumped several Of the floral pieces in the
street. They were recovered.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1905-05-19

upon the way in which the Tribune had never
followed the admirable rules laid down In
Mir Reid's speech for newspaper temper
ance in commenting on foreign Affairs.
You can bet your life said Senator Tor
Depew, that the Tribune will go right on
doing as it always has DONE that the Am eri-
can Ambassador will be kept busy disown-
ing what the Tribune says and the English
people will believe what he says while we
will believe what the Tribune says"
Mr.. Depew told Mr.. Reid that President
Roosevelt had once named over for him the
four Offices which seemed to the President
the greatest which an American, citizen
could obtain. These we're Ambassador
to Great Britain, Governor Of the State OF
New York President of the United States
and United States Senator from New York;
"Modesty iorbids me to say continued
Senator Depew: which one OF these he
mentioned first"
William H. McElroy, Melville E. Stone,
Gen. Taylor Of the Boston Globe and Clark
Howell also spoke. The Rev Minot J.
Savage read some verses. In CONCLUSION
Mr.. Reid made little speech of thanks
to his hosts and eulogists.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1905-05-19
GRAPE.NUTS.
~ .----,r-Ns~-y-.~-erN- w.
GREAT CHANGE
From Change In Food.

The brain depends much more on the
stomach than we are apt to suppose until
we take thought in the matter. Feed the
stomach on proper food easy to digest and
containing the proper amount of phos-
pilates and the healthy brain will respond
to all demands. notable housewife in
Buffalo writes:
The doctor diagnosed my trouble as a
nervous affection Of the stomach was
actually so nervous that could not ait still
for five minutes to read the newspaper
and to attend to my household duties was
simply impossible. I doctored all the time
with remedies. but medicine did no good.
MY physician put me on all sorts OF
diet. and tried many kinds Of cereal foods,
but none OF them agreed with me. | was
almost discouraged, and when tried Grape
Nuts I did 40 with many misgivings-I
had no faith that it would succeed where
everything else had failed.
But it did succeed, and you don't know
how glad am that tried It, I feel like
a new person, I have gained in weight
and l don't have that terrible burning
sensation in my stomach any more.
feel 80 strong again that ! am surprised
at myself. The street noises that used
to irT1tate me so never notice now, and
my mind is 80 clear that my household
duties are real pleasure"
Name given by Postum Co., Battle Creek,
Mich.
There's reason.
Now why was this great change made
in this woman?
The stomach and the brain had not been
supplied with the right kind Of food to re-
build and strengthen the nerve centres in
these organs. 1t is absolute folly to try
to do this with medicine There is but
one sure way. and that is to quit the old
food that has failed and take on Grape
Nuts food which is more than half digested
in the process Of manufacture and Is rich
in the phosphate OF potash contained In
the natural grain. which unitee with al
bumen and water-the only three SUBJ
stances t,i.t will make up the soft gray
filing In the thousands OF delicate nerve
centres In the brain and body. Grape
Nuts food Is a sure road back to health in
all such cases.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1905-05-19
SCHOLARSHIPS ron NURSES.
Murry GuEgenheim's Gift To the Mount
Sinai Training School.

At the graduating exercises for the class
of 1905 of the Mount Sinai Training School
for Nurses. Madison avenue and l0lst
street. last night it was announced that
hurry Guggenheim has established a
fund to be known as the "Murry Gugaen-
helm Scholarship. Fund, /" the income OF
which will be used for twelve annual scholar
ships Of 500 each for pupils in the training
school. Six will be given to junior
three to senior and three to graduating
pupils. The scholarships will be awarded
to the nurses in each class who stand highest
in rating,
Diplomas were given last night to twenty.
one nurses. Miss NJ. NJ Crawford won
first prize and Miss Edith Chapman second
prize.
The thirteenth annual commencement
exercises of the training school for nurses
Of St. Vincents Hospital took place last
night in the parloH OF the hospital. Mgr
Lavelle of the Cathedral presided and
conferred diplomas; There were nineteen
graduates, among whom was Isabel O'Don-
ovan Rosa Of New Brighton. Staten Island
a daughter Of o'Donovan Rosa
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1905-05-19
Obituary Notes.

Mrs. Elisabeth Ills. wife Of Jacob A. Riis.
died of pneumonia yesterday at their home
in Richmond Hill. l.. !. She was SO years
of age and was born in Kibe, Denmark. the
dau ghter of a country lawyer. who died when
she was three years old. Mr.. Riis was n
native OF the same city and they grew up
together. Their marriage took place in the
Domkirke, kihe. in 1875. afer Mr.. Riis had
been in this country several years, Mrs
Riis possessed much literary ability. but
The MaF "a sn Am a%19
by three son f Edva4d h he sa %
cisco CMonicle. John Of Denver, Col. and
Mliam T 81 Rj W1Il?e Hill and hy Two
Kate Riis. both of Richmond Hill. Edward
V. and John Rus came on from the West on
noe H her aGd haTs nn az Re
evening ys Se daa sS Mrs R asd he ssnt
patty. Mrs, Riis, had on several occasions ms
husband.
William F Kin gsand, for more than twenty
Ave wears a member of the Brooklyn Fire
Department. died Yesterday in his sixtieth
year at his home. lse Java street. Green
he was an ensineer in the Fire DEPARTMENT.
sas ThsP he gf1sd f he
at preamland in Coney Island He leaves
widow. two sons and two daughters.
Mrs Anna N. AtterbuITy. wife Of Col, William
Atterrbury. who was Lieutsnant- Colonel Of
Giyil war. died at her home sos Dean Street .9t
Brooklyn, yesterday, after a short illness. Of
Place Methodist Episcopal Church, She il
survived by Col. Atterbury. who is himself
past 81. and two sons, who are in the paper
business In Manhattan,
Miss Caroline Dresser. principal Of School
?, in Ionkers fer tweRWty ~ one, years. died
home il that city, She was born near Ded;
70 Boston and will be inferred in the family
,hc next few DAYS memorial service is to be
hel1 in Yonkcrs.
Rabbi Moses Recher died suddenly AT the
hospital in Utica on Wednesday night while
preparing to undergo a surgical operation.
RE was member of the Association of Or
thcdox Rabbis of America and as an orator
was widely known throughout the Eastern
States,
Eldridgc G. Keith, president Of the Chca 20
Title and Trust Company and formerly presi-
dent of the Metropolitap National Bank died
on Wed nesday night at his home in Chicago
He had been i'll for several months
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1905-05-19
Application for Benson's Removal,

Application was made yesterday to United
States District Judge Holt by United States
District Attorney Henry l.. Burnett for
warrant Of removal to Washington, D. c.,
for John A. Benson, the wealthy Californian
landowner, under indictment for fraudulent
acquisition OF titles to Government lands In
States Of California, Washington and Ore
gon. Frank II. Platt o2ros, ID and the
argument was hst down for Saturday.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1905-05-19
AUTO Runs 4 MAN DOWN.
DR.. T.. =. Porter Taken TO the Coney Island
Police Station.

DR.. f. P. Porter of 1 Glenada place,
Brooklyn. ran down a man on Surf avenue,
Coney Island, last night, with his automo-
bile, in which two women and another man
were riding. 1t was a case Of running into
trolley car or running the man down and
DR.. Porter choose the later. The man, who
was run down is John Klininger of Grave
send Beach, He suffered internal injuries
but went home.
DR.. Porter. it is said, didn't stop his ma
chine after the accident, but kept right on.
In a jiffy there were many automobiles
and wagons in pursuit. He stopped then
and was taken TO the Coney Island police
station. There Capt. Dooley listened to
his story and let him go. Dr.. Porter gave
his card to the police and said he would
appear any time he was wanted.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1905-05-19
work at the Eastern End Of Coney Island

There is some misrepresentation as to the
improvements which are under way on the
eastern end OF Coney Island Along the way
from Manhattan Beach will be handsome
board walk with many interesting enter
tainments on the land side. One will he able
to walk from the life saving stationbe-
yond the Oriental Hotel to the Bowery at the
West End; Pain has planned a surprise also.
Port Arthur" is it said, will be the most
elaborate picture ever produced in the
fireworks amphitheater.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1905-05-19
SOITHERNERs FOR FEDERATION.
Their Presbyterian General Assembly
Berins to Debate the Question.

BeEins to Debate the Question.
DALLAS, Tex. May ls.-The forty-fifth
General Assembly Of the Southern Pres
byterian Church opened at Fort Worth
to-day. Approximately 300 commissioners
and 700 visitors were present 20
The Rev. DR.. j. r. Pluakett was
elected Moderator. The committee ap-
pointed at last years assembly reported
in favor of federation with the Northerl
Church. and debate on the question was
begun. 1t will last probably through
next week, The preponderance of opinion
Ia that the assembly will vote in favor of
federation. The Tennessee and Kentucky
commissioners are said to be a unit in favor
of it. Virginia strongly favors it, and
Texas is considered safe for a majority.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1905-05-19
SAYS EBLING WENT roo FAST.
Bicycle Cop Chases Brew cr's Auto aud
Arrests Him In The Bronx.

Louis Ebling, the brewer, who lives at
800 Eagle avenue, The Bronx. was driving
his automobile up Jerome avenue yesterday
afternoon at a gait that Bicycle Policeman
Vanderpool thought was lawless. Vander-
pool chased the brewer a quarter Of mile
on his motor cycle, holding stop watch
the while.
At jerome avenue and 17sth street he
arrested Ebling, who protested that he
was riding at legal rate Of speed. At the
Highbridge station Dr. Charles Kirchoff.
who was riding with Eblins, gave bail.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1905-05-19
SEQ TO LET DRIVER GO.
Bike Cop Says Man In Auto offered II
-Onl, the Driver Arrested.

-OnII the DrIver Arrested.
Bicycle Policeman England rode full
speed after white touring car running
south on Broadway at Fory-ffth street
last night and overhauled it at Thirty
sixth street and arrested the driver He
says that one Of three young men riding
in the car offered him tw 'nty- doilar bill
to let the driver go.
England took the driver to the West
Forty-se venth street station. He said
he was Everett Hudson of the Hotel Gira I'd.
The man who offered the bride got away
before Eng and thought Of arresting him
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1905-05-19
Court singer Here on Bridal Trlp.

Nine. X. Won Frenkell-Nast. court singer
to the King Of Sayony. arrived yesterday
with her husband aboard the Hamburg,
American liner Deutschland. They are
on bridal tour that may last a year. She
said that she might see Herr Conried OF
the Metropolitan before she leaves and
appear here next season in grand opera.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1905-05-19
I'll How do you file

al How do you file
W. your invoices
Our vertical filing plan
brings into one place. in
order of date. all the bills
Of one concern,-- and
makes them instantly ac-
ceSsible.
Unpaid invoices kept in
a separate drawer OF file
by discount date or name.
Library Bureau
Card and Filing Systems
3l6 Broadway.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1905-05-19
BUSINESS NOTICES.

Mrs. Winslow's Soothing Syrup for children
teethng, softens the gums, reduces Inflammation.
aays pain. cures wind collie darrhLa 25c. a bottle,