The Fairmont West Virginian. (Fairmont, W. Va.) 1904-1914, 1905-12-22
80. EclsLAl 80 III WEsT n


M Or -, iif,s e IA Ffa,t
4, ~ f 4, ann. * :, c,,JSs5,
s sls,6sI s r,Sii Z n, ,5it, sbt,rg WIN
az, ~; 81 az s, ne Iiassshoid ~
( ~ III M, ~, !, 800
- {, iossg 1870 Z, yia,, 1890
&. 49, "a 49,, ,,l Z Il, AN.
y sst5sy.fI,, hscsii,sa tI,ey helIeved that
H.. ,i.e5,;,sa i.Iao c;aI,,Id NOT
IL 1850, &, az Geo. sorate nj
az ~. ,lSor .a..ona a7r,,erd ~
- ,.,,o,,,,, nrSns,ssd y t.v ne nrodnc.
itso1 ~ e.osI m ,snIs 80 ~ vnv az tar.
~. tba 'Ioaseno,,,s IN nj. stste .noa,
q an. s+,sI arod,,s,.d q 1aassd. int
M 5g.,,S1 o,is,atT, IzI,atber a cornor..
t;6n : ,,s7.son q, !. n.rt,ersS,n 1sascs
III *, !, Lei rn,, "a : ce-tain tr.c+ -
iiand sr;,o tho o,Znar ~ tbo free,bold
ss,,ae,nse ~ nav Mn, :. certa,n ROYALTY
\, s,,,.1I,, -, cents !. Ton for al, .rch coal
mined ana agrteine 10 mine all mer.
.,,.,tatIo .osI 80 r,rolIv agrae,re
=, 49, -, r,S,,o., ~, zoo = co,sidor
thsso 1890 .oIas T. lot Won NAV
..ii tl,s,, conditj,,na1 saIes u Won IKE
.s,,t II sa,t and T. Good Law +bint,
a.. 80 coles aI+toua, ,ho convey.
49, 4 l., an ., -, 80 : 1o,.o .,,, ,,.,,
IN, st,nn,ote. tno+ q 90 IN last For. ,
. ,eIg a. da . +Ine tuertv.ave mr.
4hirt,- ,,sa.s In. add,n3 tho clause
.,ssnd ,,n4t al .ucl, coal is mined y Tbts
isiya. +bo' y,osooo ,,,.o1uto control ovor
tha cooi On limo os be comnlIes with
Inc tarms q, tbe contract or condit,on.
a. solo
.Our snnreme. Court foIlowinp de-
ojs,,+s 4, pennsyIv,rio ord some 9TH.
or States had heId in the case of the
son+b pam on Co VIC tbo circuit
Court ~ Marin, county report ed in 4.
w Va Renorts that u,ch lenses could
NOT be assessed az real estate, but if
assessed at ali would have to be as
sessed nc nersonaI nropertv,
"ranarbertng tb,s decision tbc.
fr,ends If tav reform In tho session of
1aO5 had enacted a law to tax these
leasebold estates ss nersonaI nroncrtv
Tbis v.e +estod bv Certain cool oil md
,os ,n+n-osts hr+ tho Iow wos .unbeid
Nv rnon,mms decision NJ opr s,,.
nrerna Court ~ Anneals os we'll az
nv two If our c;rcuit Judges, Judge
.1obn w Mason Of the Circuit C,onrt
az Mononpalia county delivering n
verv s11a on,n,on IN which ho as we'll
ne +ba sunreme Court unbald the
Ioosebo,5 texotIor Moth no good law
and ,,ood moral, and az neither wrony
a, Ia, 80 wron.. In Irst,oo GO +hot
fba Law IN wesr VIRGINIA row +.xes
oo.i ~, +av,n. .7,a vo1ra y, the froa.
Sol., - nc ownnn tboreof ond The val.
- :. ~ 1ooaoho,5 - t1,o ownar 30 n
T. or5a. 80 tov nc r,holo value ~ the
n1.ore,tr Tha .ama thinr onn,ios f.,
q, 80 "a. -hesa nronnrtIos are tox.
"a 80. saao s :, 40. raIro irst lilo
~, .sso,,a-.., 80 .,aro,onts n.n,s,o
80. r.oob,nio, ond otho, rarsons
49, - = ho.s =, 80 ~, Il :. not i,;s+
49, .Iab+ =. nh ~ sho,I,d IN rosistod
.r,ha ne1, to1 love have o,ro.dv vim,
,,oa+a5 t1,a,rsolvas n +bo roductior or
raxes Tha STATE tax tbIs voor &c twer.
4, a.a,,+s v,horoo, horeto,oro II hoe aI-
-. - -. t4,,,.,, az oonto an Tho e,on
~ .,a,,,otian M ,a,u tax ,ows strIo,
!, !. - az 49, .l,t,,-os wv oo,,,,tias
u 80. "a n,ma,a,nn, oorrora+;ons
"a =, !, 80 - 49, n,t - ~,
~. :, = - e h,,nIso1 49, naHar. ~ +be
sta+o n,naty ~ .han, bovo hod suh
s ss,, -a5Hot1,n. ~ tha,r toxas +his
$50 -, .So-t 80 -. 1,nor ,,,o Wv, low.
-. .. 80 .- ,',,y, 49, GOO thera nil
Is pa' s,,I e -. a ~ lo1,,ot,on
= .1. s 49,. 8 a .S 80 49, ~, 1ovs
i, - =, "@ S-...t ,.n.,th - ttta c,ata oon
ne ~ Q 80, -, ~, - ~ 49, 80 a+
talHeu III COu'' WI anu Saa' WOO HO'
paying anything like just share of
taxes. II this had not been so patent,
tax reform never would have won