davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
Newport daily independent., 1905-10-24
ADDITIONAL LOCALS.

supplies at Jacocks'. 53b7t
 Mckinley 10c music at 1. b. Prices. Get a catalogue; over 1000 different pieces. 45btf
 Mrs. Mattie Brown has &C., cepted positi n with Sink & Martin during the fall season.
 The Daughters of the Confed- eracy will meet Wednesday after noon at 3 o'clock with Mrs. T. s. Stephens.
 Juicy Steaks and Boasts that bring you back for another at Pettet & Stiles Meat Market, Con Deans old stand. 46dtf
 w. B. Empie left Tuesday noon for Little Rock, where he will be the guest of H. L. Rem- mel during the visit of the Presi- dent.
 Mrs. Robert Cox left on No. 7 for Searcy to attend the marriage of her friend, Miss Lucia Per cival, which takes place in that city tonight.
 Rev. w. s. Lacey was in the city Tuesday, returning to his home at Batesville from attend ing the Presbyterian Synod at Philadelphia.
 Harry A. Mansfield, of St. Louis, arrived in the city Mon- day morning and will work for the s. L. Wright Brokerage company here this winter.
 John Morrell & Co. 8 famous 'Iowa Pride" Hams and Break fast Bacon are in a class by themselves. You can get them at the Standard Grocer Co. dtf
 Mrs. R. B. Willis came up from Searcy Sunday night, bringing with her Miss Emma Bateman, a student of Willis Institute, who is quite i'll with hemorrhagic ma- larial fever. Mrs. Willis returned home on the early train Monday. Judge M. M. Stuckey is in Fayetteville this week attending the grand lodge of l. o. o. F. in session in that city. There is not more loyal Odd Fellow in Arkansas than Judge Stuckey and he makes most creditable rep resentative of the local lodge. The Independent is in receipt of neatly printed booklet of the Southern Land Company, which is to be used in advertising Jack son county and the land list of this firm, that should bring good results. Both the advertising and descriptive matter pages are alike creditable to the progressive and hustling promoters. In a letter to Arkansas friends Rev. w. B. Kicks, of Louisville, Ky, says he has been returned to the Chestnut street church in that city for the third year and has a bright outlook for sue cessful years work. In closing, he says he likes Kentucky, but . loves Arkansas and his thoughts often go back to the happy days he spent here.
 There will be preaching on next Sabbath morning and even- ing. This will be the fifth Sah- bath of the month and this notice . is given in advance so that it may get well before the mem pership and congregation. Let us make a special effort for a large attendance. Services will be just one hour, from II to 12 a. m,, and 7:30 to 8:30 D. m. Sabbath school opens at 9:45. Let every one make a special effort to add at least one-third to our enrolment for next Sabbath. Note the hours: 9:45 8. m., II a. m., 7:3O p. m. R. B. Willis, pastor.
Arizona republican., 1905-12-12
GRUfS0ME CONTENTS
 OF AN OLD WELL
The Finding of the Bcdy of a Man
 Murdered in Mexico.

Tucson, Ariz., Dec. 11.-(Special.) J. News has been received here of the finding of the body of a man in a we'll six miles east of the town of Llano Sonora. Mexico, the body having been identified as that of Luther H. Jewell of San Diego, who disappeared about six months ago.
 Jewell was a capitalist and mining man whose business took him into Mexico. After his mysterious disap- pearance his brother was in Tucson looking after his affairs. While here the brother stated that he believed Jewell had been murdered and that the murderers were being shielded by the Mexican officials. According to the report the body has been found by a man named H. Glore, who is well known here. MT. Glore's suspicious were aroused by the peculiarly disturb ed surface of the ground and a closer investigation resulted in the finding of the old well and the body.
Arizona republican., 1905-12-12
'' Shus your eyes, open y0ur mouth
 ana sec vsi5af Euck will bring ycu."

Many woman is weak and sick, nervous and discouraged. She suffers from headache, backache and other ills. She wants to be well, but all she does
Arizona republican., 1905-12-12
F0RAkER AMENDMENT
Continued From Page i.

[ who had stepped back up the aisle and was standing beside Mir. Lamar, each Slaring into the face of the other. Speaker Cannon made vigorous at tempts to call them to order and Mir Shackleford was shouting for recog- milton that he might ask a question During the confusion MT. Lamar shouted: MT. Speaker, he went to the newspapers with it and now he objects to it's consideration here. But I have got it before the house and the house will understand it.
 At this point MT. Payne was recog- niZed to move an adjournment, which was hastily taken, the house having been in session an hour lacking five minutes. The adjournment was until Wednesday.
 THE COMPLETE COMMITTEES.
 The important committees are as follows:
 Ways and means-Payne, Dalzell, GrosvenOr, McCleary, Mccall, Babcock, Hill, Boutelle, Watson, Curtis, Kan sas; Needham, California;; William, Aldem, Smith, Williams, Robinson, Clark, Cochran, Underwood, Granger.
 Appropriations-Taw Bingham, Littauer, Brownlow, Gardner. Gillette, Smith, Graf. Brick, Keller, Madden, Livingston, Taylor, Brundige, Fitz- gerald, Burlesen, Sullivan.
 Foreign affairs-Hitt, Adams, Cous- ins, Charles B. Landis, Perkins, Foster
Arizona republican., 1905-12-12

Towne, Lamar, McNary, Farmer.
 udiciary-Jenkins, Parker, Alexan. der Littlefield, Nevin, Palmer Pearce Gillette of California; Turell, Sterling Birdsall. Foster, DeArmond, Smith I Clayton, Henry, Little, Brantley. | Military affairs-Hull, Ketcham Parker, Capron, Mondel, of Wyoming Prince Holiday, Young, Patterson Sulzer. Hay, Slayden, Broussard, Tal- bolt, Wiley, Mcguire.
 Naval affairs-Foss, Loudenslager Butler, Mudd, Cousins, Roberts, Vree- land, Loud, Bates, Lilley, Thomas Dawson, Meyer, Rixey, w. w. Kitchin Padgett, Garber, Gregg.
 Insular affairs-Cooper, Crumpacker Hamilton, Olmstead, Smith, Fuller Kinkaid. Webber. Graham, Hubbard Parsons, Mckinley, of California Jones. Patterson, Zenor, Fucker Gil bert, Page. Larringa. of Porto Rico.
 Banking and Currency-Fowler Prince, Calderhead. of Kansas; Pow CTS. McMOrran, Weens, McCreary Knowland, of California; Waldo Shortel, Hayes, of California; Weeks Lewis, Pujo, Glass, Gillespie. James Le-are.
 erritories-Hamilton, Brick, Cap ron, Southwick, Powers, Mckinney, Cole, Higgins, Reynolds, Kleffer Moon, Reid. Beall, Webb. Stanley. Me Guire of Oklahoma; Smith of Arizona; Andrews of New Mexico; Kalanianoole of Hawaii.
 Rivers and harbors-Burton, Dove ner, Bishop, Acheson, Alexander, Law renee, Davison, McLachlan of Califor- mia: Lorimer, Jones of Washington; {; Bede, Ellis, Lester, Bankhead, Spark man, Dalzell, Burgess, Humphreys.
 Railways and canals-Davidson, Roberts, Deemer, Knapp, Huff, Wood yard, Cooper, Bannan, Burnett, Smith, Davis, Patterson, Ruppert.
 Agriculture-Wadsw Henry, Haugen Scott, Haskins, Cromer, Lor- inner, Brooks Adams, Davis, LaFean, Cooke, Lamb, Bowie, Lever Trimble, Candler, Field, Andrews.
 Postoffices and postroads-Over- street, Gardner, Sherry, Hedges, Sibley, Knapp, Goebel, Steenerson, Stafford, Darragh, Murmock, Dwight, Moon, Griggs, Finley. Lloyd, Small. Hill. Smith of Arizona.
 Public Lands: Lacey, Miller, Mar tin, Fordney, Volstead, Dixon, Knopf, McCarty. French. Smith Of California. Gronnan, Tyndall, Burnett. Fucker, Gaines, Bird. Van Duser of Nevada, Robinson, Smith of Arizona.
 Indian Affairs: Sherman, Curtis, Lacey, Marshall, Brown. Burke, Knapp, Hermann of Oregon, Buckman, Hinshaw, Hogg. Woodward. Stephens, Zenor, Reid, Claude, Kitchin, Aiken, Van Duser of Nevada, Mcclure.
 Mines and Mining: Brown, Daie, Scott, Huff, Dion, Williamson Of Ore gon, Howell of Utah, Bonyinge, Shor- tel Stanley, Heflin, Lee, Hunt, Reid, Andrews.
 Public Buildings and Grounds: Bar tholdt, Burleigh, Howell, Connor, Mar tin, Minor, Rodenberg, Norris, Fred erick, Landis. Andrews. Bankhead, Brantley, Thomas, Bowers.
Arizona republican., 1905-12-12

Iarity, It dries deblIitating drainS. It heals inflammation and Liberation and cures female weakness. There is no trusting to luck by those who use "Favorite Prescription"
 rIn the year 1903 my. health was poor.n writes Mrs. J. Hack. of 242 Broadway. Buff falo, N. Y. rI suffered from falling of womb. disagreeable discharge. painful monthly periods, headache baCkache and pains in the limbs Every month was confined to bed for two or three days. Was weak. nervous and hysterical; life was burden to myself and made every one in the family unhappy because 1 was so irritable. My husband got me four bottles of Dr. Pierce's Favorite Pre- scriptiOn, and before 1 had taken the first bottle I was feeling some relief. The medi- cine made me well and strong. free from nerv ousness aches and pain. and I felt like a new woman. Before l used the 'Favorite Pre- scription had been taking another physi- clans medicine for nearly three months, but had received no benefit. Your medicine Is certainly the best in the world"
Arizona republican., 1905-12-12
Nothing Succeeds Llgo Success.

He has the confidence a2d patronage Cf tbf leading business nieu
 and Ill ost prcmineu, citizens oH AIizons.. Ths naotna
Arizona republican., 1905-12-12
DEATH OF A STATlSTICAN.

Boston, Dec. 11.-Edward Atkinson, the well known social and political economist of this city died suddenly today of acute indigestion affecting the heart. He was seventy eight years old
Arizona republican., 1905-12-12
WEATHER TODAY.

Washington, Dec. II. - Arizona: Forecast: Snow and colder in north, rain in southeast, fair in southwest portion Tuesday. Wednesday fair.
Arizona republican., 1905-12-12

We now nave just what you have been looking for, for a long time. Boiled cider for mince meat. Melczer Bros. Phone Main 75.
Arizona republican., 1905-12-12

is to shut her eyes and open her mouth for m e dicine and trust to luck for re esul ts. $ he UdoctOrS" month a f ter m on t h, often year after year. in this same blind, hap haz- ard fashion. and receives no per manent benefit.
 Women take Dr. Pierce's Fa- vorite Prescrip- ton with their eyes open to the fact that it cures womanly ills. It cures irreVu-
Arizona republican., 1905-12-12
Ruby Bread for Health and Wealth

 
  25 O it.
Arizona republican., 1905-12-12

Almost fair time, better save your money to buy Donofrio's Crystallized Cactus Candy.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Oregon) 1903-1919, 1905-10-17
Do You Believe In Signs.

A mark, note, token or symptom
indicates that by which anything may
be known, that is, we are forewarned
if evil is to befall us, or we have the
pleasure Of anticipation IL the signs
betoken a fortunate occurrence. Ac-
eidental occurrences all have their
signs. every disease has its symptoms.
The point is to heed the former, and
eounteract the effect Of the latter.
Spells Of sick headache follow indiges-
tion and stomach disorders, belehing,
biliousness and dyspepsia are signs OF
sickness. People that believe In these
signs and know that they are true from
experience, can got immNdiste relief
and a speedy cure by the Use Of Dr..
Gums Improved LIVER Pilla Sold By
druggists for 96e per box. oN'V one
for q doeA
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Oregon) 1903-1919, 1905-10-17
LET US ALL WASH HANDS.
(From Collier's Weekly.)

(frOm collier g Weekly.)
Mr.. Rockefeller said, in the celebra-
tion Of his ffty-two years Of citizen
ship in Cleveland, that he hoped the
young men about him would succeed as
the older men have succeeded. We can
not help wishing they may think more
Of other things than Of success but TO
proceed. "Don't think" said Mr..
Rockefeller. "that mere money get
ting is all there is In this world" Who
has done more 10 instil the idea that
money is our greatest orator' "What
shall the fruitago Of your work bef
Hospitals, churches, schools, asylums-
anything and everything for the bet
terment Of your fellows" If you do
this, thinks John d., "when you spend
the quiet days, as ! am doing now un-
der these oaks, you win have great
Joy" II Is a familiar idea that hos
pitfalls can Justify a life i'll spent. What
we need most in America today is TO
lower our regard for money, in pro
portion 20 the other goods Of life. Mr..
Bryan withdrew an article from re-
ligious publication because II would
not allow him sufficiently TO castigate
Mr.. Rockefeller and the power Of gold.
He also drubbed tho lawyers who "sub-
stitute the love Of money for the law
Of conscience" and does not spare his
own profession, declaring that editors
and publishers are 10 be found in
abundance who allow money to affect
their policies. Mr.. Bryan, in the same
issue. prints an advertisement Of team
Ger cured 20 stay no knifel
no paint" Also "eancer cured with
soothing, balmy oils. /" Also "opium
and whisky habits cured at home with
out pain" Is all this for the good
Of the universe, or the cause of truth,
or for the money which these swindlers
payf We have no desire to be hard on
Mr. Bryan, but these foundation troub-
les Of our civilization must be taken
frankly and radically IL any change is
20 be accomplished. What is the diff.
ference in spirit between Mr.. Bryan S
business Office and Mr.. Rockefeller's.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Oregon) 1903-1919, 1905-10-17
MARION COUNTY VERSUS THE
MACHINE.

Marion county aspires to be the best
governed county in Oregon.
Salem aspires to be the best governed
city in tho state
The Marion county ideal Of govern
ment without graft went up against
the Portland machine last week.
II the Marion county ideal could pre-.
vail, there would not be a dollar Of
graft left in state politics.
MARION COUNTY POLITICIANS
WHO GO IN FOR STRAIGHT
GRAFT ARE IN A HOPELESS MI.
NoRITY.
Portland machine politicians cannot
see anything in government but oppor-
tunity for graft
Which will win out in the coming
campaign, Portland machine methods
OF Marion county idealsi
Lot the people Of Oregon take their
choice and follow the flag Of good
government or pursue the anarchy of
graft.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Oregon) 1903-1919, 1905-10-17
FLOWERS AS A MEANS OF AID
VERTIsING.

Mayor Lane has hit upon a prize
idea, an annual rose carnival for Port.
land.
Portland has been advertised as the
Rose City of Oregon, and the idea is a
growing one.
10 will bud and blow in fragrance
and freshness and dollars will literally
grow on the bushes.
FLOWERS GAN BE MADE THE
MOST SUCCESSFUL MEANS OF AID.
vERTIsnG OUR CITY, AS WE'LL
AS PORTLAND.
Lot ms make Salem the Flower City
Of the Northwest It can be done with.
in a year.
A plan should be adopted TO secure
tho cooperation Of our people and
public organizations.
Let us enter upon a general cam
paign Of planting roses, bulbs, shrubs,
vines and all kinds Of towering plants.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Oregon) 1903-1919, 1905-10-17

He is competent to gil any office that
PAYS something.
Toledo Reporter: The business IN
terests Of Salem, Independence and
other valley cities are agitating the
building Of railroad from Salem to
the Yaquina bay by way Of Independ-
enee the Luekiamute, Pedee and siletz
valleys to Yaquina bay. We have ad-
vocated the building Of such road
and we believe that it would not only
be the best investment in railroad
building that could be made, but 1t
would add immensely to the wealth OF
the counties through which it ran and
to the Willamette valley generally
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Oregon) 1903-1919, 1905-10-17
A KIND WORD FOR MIR. ROOKIE.
FELIaER.

John d, Rockefeller has recently eel.
ebrated the 5sd year Of his citizenship
at Cleveland, Ohio.
About 500 people assembled at his
homo 10 show their esteem for the man
who Is much criticized
II Is hard to separate tho man and
his attributes from his reputation for
great wealth aud the questions as TO
the legality Of his possessions.
But let US try 10 think kindly Of
Rockefeller as maR--who has done
no more than the genius within him
impolled him to do-as any one would.
He has furnished our country and
tho world good oil and at fairly cheap
prices. Same with gasoline.
He has tried TO make good use Of his
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Oregon) 1903-1919, 1905-10-17
Full of Tragic Meaning.

Are these lines from J. II. Simmons, Of
Casey, Ia. Think what might have re-
suited from this terrible cought if he
had not taken the medicine about which
ne writes: "I had fearful cough,
that disturbed my nights rest. tried
everything, but nothing would relieve
It, until 1 took DR.. Kings New Dis
covery for Consumption, Coughs and
Colds, which completely cured me. 3"
Instantly relieves and permanently
cures all throat and lung Diseases pre-
vents grip and pneumonia. At J. C..
Perry's Drug Store; guaranteed; SOC
and $l.00. Trial bottle free.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Oregon) 1903-1919, 1905-10-17
rAKE YouR sHARE. BRoTHER.

TAKE YOUR SHARE, BROTHER.
The oregouian is shedding tears
over the deplorable condition Of Ore
gon politics.
II should not fail to take its own
share Of the blame. 1t helped little
In 1902.
When the Multnomah delegation was
turned over to Furnish, the Legislative
delegation was supposed to be turned
over to Scott for senator.
Now, don't dodge Brother Scott.
You did get in bed with the Mitchell
machine, now, didn't yOui
We don't blame you for that as you
are only human and It is mortal to err.
But, take your share Of the blame,
Brother Scott, take your share Of the
blame.
And aren't you in with the machine
todnyi
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Oregon) 1903-1919, 1905-10-17

the meaning and beauty Of nature and
country life.
The Capital Journal editor is accused
Of this and that He makes no defence.
He was in Portland on the day of
the peace conference but did not at
tend the sessions simply for the reason
that he had important private business
that required his attention. He was
pleased at the able way in which Chair
man Davey brought the convention to
harmonious conclusion.
The Eugene city council advertises
for bids on 100000 water bonds and
100000 electric light bonds to con
struct water and lighting plants for
that city. That is o bold step but in
the right direction. The point is this:
Any community will do we'll to en-
courage the investment of all the pri-
vate capital possible in public utilities
If private capital cannot get in and
public ownership is thought desirable
get in and do that.
Just as good pears and winter apples
can be raised on the foothills Of the
Willamette valley as anywhere in the
world. Telegraphic advices from New
York state that a car of Medford pears,
from the orchard of J., w. Perkins, sold
for $3429, the highest price ever real
lied for a carload Of pears in America.
Part Of the car brought $40 per box,
the highest price ever recorded for
single boxes Of the fruit.
Il was a fine compliment for the
Marion coun-y Republicans TO tender
Hon. Frank Davey the chairwanship
Of the state conference at Portland.
He made a fine presiding officer and
kept harmony and good will we'll to
the front. For such a service it takes
ability and Mr.. Davey possessed it.
1t is TO be hoped the party managers
will not overlook 80 able man as Mr..
Dayey when il comes TO handing out
something more than empty honors.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Oregon) 1903-1919, 1905-10-17
WHEN NEWT WILLIAMSON WAS
TRIED.

IhlAOs
Congressman Williamson is under
conviction in the federal courts for
completely with land frauds
THE EDITOR OF THIS PAPER
RECALLS A TIME WHEN PLAIN
JOHN NEWTON WILLIAMSON s
METTLE WAS TRIED.
A few years ago there was great
battle in the legislature to overthrow
the Text Book Trust in Oregon.
II had held unbroken power for
odd years had princely income and
owned things in general.
The textbook commission bin lacked
three votes in the lower house and
was up on reconsideration.
NEWT WILLIAMSON HAD VOTED
AGAINST THE BILL AND THE
TEXTBOOK TRUST HAD DooDLEs
OF MONEY.
He changed his vote for the bill and
saved the measure that meant 50 much
TO all Oregon.
That was a time to try men, and
Newt Williamson stood fire. This re-
cent trial savors Of political job.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Oregon) 1903-1919, 1905-10-17
The Way
To Wealth

Benjamin Franklin said; "The
Way to Wealth is as plain as the
Way 10 Market" He gives these
directions;
Be honest, work hard, save some.
Excellent sdvise and the last is
as necessary as the first.
Our Savings Department viii help
you save. II win take your savings
in sums as small as one dollar and
make them earn more. Interest
compounded semi,annually at three
per cent
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Oregon) 1903-1919, 1905-10-17
ALL ARouT YOU

Builders are using our lumber for
outside work, for heavy construction
and for interior finishing, TO the salts.
faction Of themselves and patrons.
Why not profit by their example, and
favor us with call. We select only
the best varieties Of lumber, and our
long experience enables us to properly
house and season them. Drop in next
time you re this way
GooDALE LUMBER 90.
Near s. z. Passenger Depot.
Phone 80 Main.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Oregon) 1903-1919, 1905-10-17
CAPITAL NORMAL.
First National Bank BuiIding.

Salem, Oregon.
Normal, Academic. Business, Civil Ser
vice, Music.
We are fortunate in securing the
services Of DR. Parvin for this de-
paEtment. We have also arranged :
Primary department, and shall have
classes in all grades from the first q
the twelfth.
Address,
J. J. KRAPs, salem. Ore
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Oregon) 1903-1919, 1905-10-17

money. He has done the best he could
with il.
We know il is not popular to say a
kind word for John d. Rockefeller. But
let us think Of him as a human being
and a neighbor and friend.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Oregon) 1903-1919, 1905-10-17
Typewriter Smiles.

The Drain Nonpareil attacks the
free pass system.
Claekamas county oranges have been
holding successful country fairs.
80
The klamath Republican is red.
hot paper for the development Of Kla-
math county
Something bright has happened TO
the Albany Demochat man. He had
a good word for somebody the other
day, il il was Heney.
when Pittoek Of the oregonian helps
to make Coos Bay deep sea harbOr
tho aqueous elements Of the internal
regions viii certainly CONCEAL.
Important II true-eolored walters
are to be restored to their inalienable
rights in the Hotel Portland dining
rooms They have been displaced for
the past six months by white walters
Give the eoloFed man a chance. II
makes little difference to Marion eOun-
ty people who mostly camp at the New
Lange
The Eugene Journal, Harrison Kin
eaid's paper, has this; Our country
schools need a stronger tings Of farm
ing sentiment. Studies, text books and
teachers are all keyed to the tune OF
the city. The pupil should be given
at least half q chance to appreciate
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Oregon) 1903-1919, 1905-10-17
BREADMAK1Na TO BE
SUCCESSFUL

Naturally demands a high-grade -four.
That's exactly what the now celebrated
product Of the Salem FIGURING Mills
is-a high grade, Satisfaction giving,
fine bread making -four. Good reason;
Good wheat and good milling. Ask
any bakers opinion Of Wild Rose
flour.
SALEM FIGURING MILLS.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Oregon) 1903-1919, 1905-10-17

Savings Department
CAPITAL NATIONAL
BANK
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Oregon) 1903-1919, 1905-10-17

The Drain Nonpareil attacks the
free pass system.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Oregon) 1903-1919, 1905-10-17

The klamath Republican is red
hot paper for the development Of Kla
math county
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Oregon) 1903-1919, 1905-10-17

J. J. KRAPs, salem. ore.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Oregon) 1903-1919, 1905-10-17

Claekamas county oranges have been
holding successful country fairs.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Oregon) 1903-1919, 1905-10-17

the meaning and beauty Of nature an
country life.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Oregon) 1903-1919, 1905-10-17

SALEM FIGURING MILIs.
The Hawaiian star. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu]) 1893-1912, 1905-02-11
IT WAS FIERCE.

George A. Davis and Former Asso-
ciate Justice Antoine Perry were in the
police court yesterday afternoon in an
action where Attorney Sonny Cunha
sought TO secure a $3.50 attorney fee
from one Vasconcellos. The interest
was centered however in the fact that
Davis and his hated opponent were en-
gagged in the case. Davis lost the case
and noted an appeal, Perry defended
the case for Vasconcellos.