davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The Saint Paul globe., 1905-01-22
NAILS TAX SLANDER
Deputy County Auditor Punc-
lures Malicious Statement

MY observation of personal property
assessments in Ramsey county ex-
tending over good many years, leads
me to say that James ]. Hill paws on
a much larger personal property as
sessment than any of our other wealthy
citizens" said John w. Herrick, deputy
county auditor yesterday, when inter.
viewed concerning a recent malicious
publication on. this subject.
Mr.. Hill, it appears, is this year as
sessed on basis of $210,021 on per-
sonal property in Ramsey county. The
schedule shows, that of this amount
$4,000 is returned in diamonds and
JeWelry, $500 in household goods,
$4,000 in moneys, $94,350 in bonds and
stocks other than bank stocks. and
$1,000 is listed as all other personal
property. This is more than twenty
times as much as is returned in per-
sonal property by any of our other
wealthy citizens, and while 1 do not as
sumo to know what Mr.. Hills personal
estate is really worth, 1 do know that
he hab1tually makes q very liberal re-
turn compared to his neighbors."
A gentleman conversant with Mr..
H1lPs affairs declared yesterday that
Mr.. Hills schedule Of personal prop
erty, returned in Ramsey county for
eaAe'IioA' WAS always maze Tor MIN by
men in his employ, and that details
were matter of Indifference to Mr..
Hill. eve make the return to the as
SCISSOR each year on what we believe
to be fair estimate" this man said,
and we always add a good deal for
good measure. Mr.. Hill last year paid
$4,000 in personal property taxes in
Ramsey county. His personal property
assessment this year is on a basis of
2lUO2l and COmnari51or hiC nrfr t0
the persontal estates of his wealthy
neighbors on the hill, he is paying
much more than his share of the ex-
penses of the city"
The Saint Paul globe., 1905-01-22
Decorated by King Oscar

ST. LOUIS, Mo-, Jan. 21.-Frederick
l.. M. Wage, vice consul of Sweden in
st. Louis, today forwarded to Howard
j. Rogers, chief of the department Of
education at the worlds fair, the in
sigma of the Royal Order of the North
Star of Sweden, an honor conferred
upon him by King Oscar II. of Sweden,
in recognition of favors shown the ed
ucational exhibit of Sweden at the
worlds fair. Edmund S. Hoch, as
sistant to the director of exhibits, was
also decorated today by a foreign gov
ernment. Mr.. Hoch received from the
French government the select Order Of
Officer of the Academy of France.
The Saint Paul globe., 1905-01-22
WHAT SULPHUR DOES
For the Human Body in Health and
Disease

UT t'S human oooy IN feattn ana
Disease
The mention Of sulphur will recall to
many Of us the early days when our
mothers and grandmothers gave us our
daily dose of sulphur and moIasses every
1t was the universal spring and fall
"bleod purifier tonic and cure-all and
mind you, this old-fashioned remedy was
not without merit.
+ The idea was good. but the remedy was
crude and unpalatable, and large guam
tity had to be taken to get any effect.
Nowadays we get all the beneficial eff
fects OF sulphur In a palatable, concen-
trated form. so that single grain is far
more effective than tablespoonful of the
crude sulphur.
have proven that the best sulphur for
medicinal use is that obtained from Cal
cium Calcium Sulphide) and sold in drug
stores under the name of Stuart's Calcium
Waters. They are small chocolate coated
pellets and contain the active medicinal
principle of sulphur in a highly concen-
trated, effective form.
Few people are aware of the value OF
this form of sulphur in restoring and
maintaining bodily yigor and health; sui
phar acts directly ", on is the liver; and ex-
the blood by the prompt elimination of
waste material
Our grandmothers knew this when they
dosed Us with sulphur and molaSSes every
spring and fall. but the crudity and i'm
purity of ordinary flowers of sulphur were
often worse than the disease, and cannot
compare with the modern concentrated
preparations of sulphur, of which Stuarts
Calcium Waters is undoubtedly the best
and most widely used.
They are the natural antidote for liver
and kidney troubles and cure constipation
and purify the blood in way that often
surprises patient and physician alike.
DIR. r. NJ. Wilkins while experimenting
with sulphur remedies soon found that the
sulphur from Calcium was superior
to any other form. He says: "For liver,
kidney and blood troubles, especially when
resulting from constipation or malaria,
have been surprised at the results OBJ
tanned from Stuart's Calcium WATERS In
patients suffering from boils and pimples
and even deep-seated carbuncles. have
repeatedly seen them dry up and disappear
: in four or five days, leaving the skin clear
and smooth. Although Stuart's Calcium
Waters is a proprietary article, and sold
by druggists, and for that reason tabooed
by many physicians. yet I know of moth
ing so safe and reliable for constipation,
liver and kidney troubles, and especially
in all forms of skin disease as this rene
dy.''
At any rate people who are tired of pills,
cathartics and so-called blood purifiers g
will find in Stuart's Calcium Waters a
far safer, more palatable and effective
preparation.
The Saint Paul globe., 1905-01-22
Y. NJ. c. A. TO BEGIN
VIGOROUS CAMPAIGN
Directors Issue Letter to Public
in Behalf of Building
Plan

The directors Of the Y. M. c. A. have
prepared a circular letter to the people
of st. Paul which is to serve as the
first gun of the battle that the organ
ization is about to make for an ade-
quate building.
In order to help the initial work, the
state secretary, E. w. Peck, and the
international secretary, w. NJ. Parsons,
have agreed to come here and assist
the directors in the search for funds.
=. They are expected to arrive here to-
morrow. The proposed building will
cost about 100000.
The letter follows:
The undersigned, because deveting much
OF their time as directors of the Young
The Saint Paul globe., 1905-01-22
Coughs Cured by a77"

Hard, Violent Cough-Short Cough
Hoarse Cough Hacking Cough =
Shaking Cough-Dry Cough-Sympa-
thetic Cough - Obstinate Cough =
Whistling Cough-Stubborn Cough
Spasmodie Cough h. Tickling Cough
Croupy Ceugh-Teasing Cough-Irri-
tating Cough-Barking Cough-Loese
Cough - Nervous Cough = Convulsive
Cough-Deep. Hollow Ceugh-C Chronic
Ceugh-Winter Cough-are all cured
by DR.. Humphreys Seventy seven"
.77" breaks up Colds that hang on
Grip.
At Druggists. 25 cents, or mailed.
Humphreys Homeo Medicine Co. Cor.
William and John streets. New York.
The Saint Paul globe., 1905-01-22
Mckinley School Exercise.

The eighth grade graduation exer-
cises at the Mckinley school were held
yesterday. Miss Lennon, principal Of
the school, gave the graduates some
good advice and endowed them with
the class motto. pluck" The pro-
gramme included several papers by pu-
pills and the usual musical and literary
numbers
The Saint Paul globe., 1905-01-22
Wallace Far From Dyino

CRAWFORDSVILLE, Ind. Jan. 21.-
The health of Gen. Lew Wallace today is
better than it has been at any time for
six months. although it is true he is not
robust For the past few days he has
several hours each day.4on his autobieg-
raphy and is not confined to his bed.
The Saint Paul globe., 1905-01-22
Allison Is chamnion

The Junior athletic championship OF
the Y. M. c. A. has been captured by
Phil Allison, with Stewart Irwin sec
ond, Harry Lowering third, and Sidney
Levy fourth. The first prize was q
gold medal.
The Saint Paul globe., 1905-01-22
State of Ohio, City of Toledo Lucas coun-

State of Ohio, City of Toledo Lucas coun-
ty-ss.
Frank J. Cheney makes oath that he is
senior partner of the firm of F. j. Cheney
& Co., doing business in the City of To-
ledo, County and State aforesaid, and that
said firm will pay the sum of ONE HUN
DRED DOLLARS for each and every case
of Catarrh that cannot be cured by the
use of Halls Catarrh Cure.
FRANK J.. CHENEY.
Sworn to before me and subscribed in
my presence. this 9Th day of December.
A d. 1886.
(Seal) A. w. GLEASON,
Notary Public.
Halls Catarrh Cure is taken internally,
and acts directly on the blood and mucous
surfaces of the system. Send for testt-
monials free.
F. ]. CHENEY & CO., Toledo, o.
Sold by all druggists, 75c.
ton.
The Saint Paul globe., 1905-01-22
Sunday School Worker COMING

w. c. Pearce, leading worker in the
Sunday school field, is to deliver a se-
ries of talks in the Twin Cities shortly.
His engagement begins in ST. Paul Jan.
29 at Central Park M. E. church.
The Saint Paul globe., 1905-01-22
Elks Work on Programme

A part of the programme to be en-
acted at the annual benefit of the Elks
March f6, II and 1S has been prepared.
Carroll S. Bartram has been named as
interlocutor and a number of the other
performers have been notified to pre-
pare their turns.
The Saint Paul globe., 1905-01-22
MeQljA|[J'S
SEVENTH AND CEDAR

sf.oo Sales Checks free Monday with any
& of the following:
q Purchase of any grade of nr,,ras oso -
e Purchase of any grade of rice .25c or over
Turcnase IN Bakery Dept .....35c or over
Pi, PPurehase in Meat Market ....a5c or over
2 'Eurchase IN Dairy Dept ..... .35c or over
purchase of Breakfast Foods .25c or over
s cans Minnesota Sweet Corn o5c
cans Pride of Pekin Tomatoes -. CSC
purchase of Cranberries 25c or over
Pounds Sweet Potatoes . 25c
Bushel Fancy Burbank Potatoes. Soc
van Rqnkle'S Cocoa. Observation-Disclosures. 25c
Cans Joan of Arc Kidney Beans 25c
= Packages Seeded Raisins 2nc
Packages Cleaned Currants ...... 2oc
$500 Sales Checks free with any of the
I Gallon Pure. Cider Vinegar (your
GalIon White Wine Vinegar (your 1''
Pounds New Fresh Dates ~ ns,; 5 15e
:. 3 Pounds Loose Muscatel Raisirls. -o5c
Pounds New Rolled Oats ...... 20c
Paekages Falcon Pancake Flour. 2oc
: Haf-gallon Can "100r Maple Syrup zoe
POUNDS Popcorn on the Ear - 2oc
3 Pounds Bulk Macaroni . osc
es3 Pounds Bulk Spaghetti ...... 25c
q Cans Green. Peas s........... 22c
foIlowing ~
Gallon Cam MeQuaid's "100' Maple
Syrup z. SIPS
2, Half Sack McQuaids 1902 Flour ST. as
~ pound can MeQuaid's "100'' Baking
Powder VIDE =, ;. -, 4oc
52-ozs Bottle Fancy Queen Olives. csc
S2.oz. Bottle Fancy Stuffed Queen
Olives, s;....,.. ::........ CSC
tRegular price of these olives $1.15 per
bottle.) -
8 4 seozz Bottle Double Lemon Extract 4oc
~ -Eurcnase " OF Benlto Canned California
Fruit in heavy syrup of $500 or more.
Can Franco American Quart Soup 35c
Can Dainty No. 1 Flat Salmon at
per can ,n...,.; 1sc
Cans Highland Condensed Milk per
can @ IL -:.,.-.-..... t5c
per package .....,.-. ......... 30c
49, 10 oDlaih ABOVE extra Sales Checks on
C. O. ID, orders this ad must be attached
to original C. o. d. bill when presented
for Sales Checks.
The Saint Paul globe., 1905-01-22
s NEWS OF THE CITY +
H. l. M. EMPEROR OF GERMANY IS
ASSURED OF MINNESOTA'S ESTEEM

Gov. Johnson Formally
Returns Visit of Herr
Hams e. Grunow in the
German Consulate Where
Evidences of Reciprocal
Good Will Are Exchanged
Teutonic and American
Standards Are Twined
Together as Evidence. of
Ripened Friend S hip
Which Has Long Existed
Between the Empire and
the Commonwealth
The Saint Paul globe., 1905-01-22

st:oo Sales Checks free Monday with any
3. of the following:
z Purchase of any grade of pr,,nes osc or
The Guthrie daily leader. [volume] (Guthrie, Okla.) 1893-1996, 1905-12-20
HOW Times CHANCE.

On the 10th Of the present month oc-
Cured the centenary of William
Lloyd Garrison, the great apostle of
abolitiea.sm, and in many portions Of
the North, especially in New England,
the day was celebrated with a warmth
and enthusiasm that seems strange to
us Of the South, just as it seems
strange to us to see them paying honor
to the memory of John Brown. Even
such conservative paper as The Port
laud Oregonian says that he belongs
to the noble Amy of saints and mar
tyrs"
Well. we leg to dissent from both
propositions. He was not martyr be-
cause he died peacefully in New York
in 1879. Still less should he be called
saint for the whole theory OF his be
hef was, to put 1t plainly, robbery.
slayes in the days of his activity were
as much personal property, legally and
constirtionally, as horses we're, yet
the theory and superstructure Of aboli-
tionism as taught by him was taat the
slaves should be liberated If it could
not be dore en m-sss h. helped them
to escape ls assters and find
refuge amos friends of the Garrison
stripe and thus rob their owners. Abo-
lltionism was robbery in its last analy-
sis, and no man of his day did more
to forward the system than did William
Lloyd Garrison,
The mutations OF time and the
changes In human sentiment are striS-
ingly illustrated by some incidents in
Garrison sc areer, That he should have
beerf hated in the South was natural
and logical for his efforts we're directed
to the robbery OF the South II he had
visited any Of the most Southern states
in those days he would probably have
been mobbed, as was nearly done to
him In Baltimore on one occasion.
But Il was in Boston, refined and cul.
tured Boston, almost the center OF the
Antislayery sentiment, and In the
country OF his friends and sympathiz'
ers that he was actually mobbed. This
occurred on October !, 1875. when he
was set upon by an iaforiated popu
lace, beaten, stripped and otherwise
maltreated, and 1t required all the ef
forts OF his friends and the city au
thoritles 10 save his life It was only
saved by getting him TO the Jail, where
he was locked up till he could b'
! spirited out Of the city, II was partl,
because Of his extreme abolition sent
ments and partly because the trade O
the South was extremely profitable Z
, Boston. That the mob failed TO pu
him 10 death was not the mob's faul
, That was the Boston of seventy year
The Guthrie daily leader. [volume] (Guthrie, Okla.) 1893-1996, 1905-12-20
PAYS AFTER MANY YEARS
Cashier Who Fled From
Oklahoma After Crash
bands Over Mneoy.
Special to DAILY Leader.

special to Daily Leader.
Wstonss, okla, Dec. 2o-Frank NJ.
Tyrrel, an attorney from Lincoln, Neb.,
and Miss ArlIe Beacon Of Topeka,
Kas., arrived here to pay all the claims
Of the depositors in the defunct Farm
ers and Merchants bank which failed
here twelve years ago.
Mr.. Tyrrel is acting as attorney for
Charles Beacon, who was cashier Of
the bank when it failed. He says the
money is being paid by Beacon him
self, who has been travelling for a
wholesale house. and not by his moth
er, as was recently reported.
The claims of depositors aggregate
about $4,000 Beacon left town i'm
mediately after the failure, and until
Mr.. Tyrrels arrival no one here had
any idea of his whereabouts. The fail
ure Of the bank and Beacoms hasty
departure affected his father so great
ly that he committed suicide a short
time afterward
The Guthrie daily leader. [volume] (Guthrie, Okla.) 1893-1996, 1905-12-20
Vou cAN EAr ANYrAINo "

" OO GAN EAi NNf FllNS "
a you take CALIFORNIA
PRUNE WAFER after the meal.
CALIFORNIA PRUNE WATERS
will not offend the most deIleats stom-
aeh; they may be given TO young or
old; they are cooling, grateful, re-
freshlns, lnvlgoratins, healthful Th9y
move and regulate the bowels gently
without gripping, without IneonVen-
lenee.
CALIFORNIA PRUNE WATERS
mako the "mornIng after" seem like
the day before They do away with
the evil effect Of an over-ipdulsene'
In tobacco, liquor or the epleurear
joys Of the table.
CALIFORNIA PRUNE WATERS
are recommended by physicians for al
Liver, stomach ard Kidney Disorders
They are a Liver and Bowel Tonic
from Natures Laboratory. 100 wa
fers, 25 cents.
J. N. Wallace, Pharmacist.
Guthrie. okla.
The Guthrie daily leader. [volume] (Guthrie, Okla.) 1893-1996, 1905-12-20

city last night looking for victime. and
found plenty Of prey Il took Jailer
Cease to prove their Nemesis. In the
alley south Of the one hundred block
In Harrison avenue Cora Wilson and
Sarah WheaS ~-.a arrested while in
the very act Of robbing ]. b Wills. The
negroes had knocked their victim
down, after he had become too drunk
to maintain anything like stable
equilibrium and one Of the duslSy hold
ups was gong through his pockets
while the other sat upon him. Cease
was attracted to the spot by the out
cries Of Wills and landed the trio al
headquarters. Wills was fined ten dol
lars this morning in court and spent
the afternoon on the rock pile. The
nocturnal nudgers we're turned over to
the county authorities on the charge OF
highway robbery.
M. A. Chatham, the colored porter
o fthe Grand Leader department store,
was fined twenty-five dollars and costs
for stealing a five dollar bill last even
ing from the cash box He will spend
his Christmas and New Year on the
/ festive rock pile.
Governor" Brown, the bad black
coon from the Creek nation, was sent
up for twenty days for flourishing
! oitr s-hilo on, a eurea ,,.ftt c.,,,4t CO.,
ond street Darktown denizens.
The Guthrie daily leader. [volume] (Guthrie, Okla.) 1893-1996, 1905-12-20

Ao-'hbound Haywood car. and that
,vhne waiting there fire alarm was
turned in. the usual fire signals we're
sounded and that at that time the May
wood car was at the corner o. Main AID
Broadway, but failed to stop, contlnu-
ing on eastward on Main street and
turned north on Broadway; that Ste
pheus, with other passengers, went from
the sidewalk, signaled the motorman
to stop the car and that the motorman
failed to do so and continued north
ward "at a rapid rate OF speed" After
the car had passed, the petition states,
that the deceased attempted to return
to the sidewalk and while 50 doing the
FIRE departmets wagons came north on
broadway and the buggy oeeepied by
Chief Keslor. Struck the deceased. in
juring him and resulting in his death a
few hours later.
Flynn & Ames and Mabry & Jones are
the attorneys for the plaintiff.
The Guthrie daily leader. [volume] (Guthrie, Okla.) 1893-1996, 1905-12-20

We think Of nourishment
as food--meats soups, vege-
tables, etc, but that's only half.
It's not the food alone that
counts but the good that we
get from food that furnishes
nourishment A pound Of
steak is of less value to a
weak stomach than a crust Of
bread is to a strong digestion.
But weak stomachs can be
made strong. Begin by eat
ing less; have regular hours
for meals; avoid fancy things
and about a half hour after
eating take a tablespoonful of
SCOTS Emulsion. It's a fact
OF medical history that people
have lived on not much else
but SCOTS Emulsion for a
long time-not only lived but
gained flesh and recovered
their strength and health.
From the pure Norwegian
cod liver oil to the last drop
of glycerine, SCOTS Emulsion
contains just the strength
giving and health-building
elements needed for low vital
ity, weak digestion and poorly
nourished bodies.
SCOTT & BOVINE. 900 Pearl St. new yOsk.
The Guthrie daily leader. [volume] (Guthrie, Okla.) 1893-1996, 1905-12-20

There is a great deal of uneasiness
expressed through fear that the state.
hood bin may contain prohibition
clause We think it hardly probable
that the bill will go through with a
general prohibltory clause in it, as IL
is the, impression Of some of the best
constitutional lawyers that the clause
would not stand test in the courts,
as 1t would be in direct violation of the
constitutional provision that all terri
tories when admitted into the union
must be admitted upon equal rights
with the other states. To force pro.
hibition upon Oklahoma would not be
admitting her upon an equal footing
with other states.
The Guthrie daily leader. [volume] (Guthrie, Okla.) 1893-1996, 1905-12-20
WOODMEN WILL FROLIC
Initiation Of Class of One
Hundred Will be a Mem
Orable Event.

The Modern Woodmen met last
evening and conferred degrees on a
class OF twelve candidates. Undoubted-
ly interest in the order is growing and
the possibility of the local lodge cap
turing the banner at the end OF the
year may become a reality.
The members are planning great
things for the big initiation Of next
Tuesday night when class of one
one hundred will be given degrees
The Chickasha camp viii be here, ac
oompanied by band, as well as sew
erai hundred members from othel
woodmen camps over the territory
who have been invited 10 be here thu
day
The program for Tuesday follows;
Afternoon.
Trolley ride, beginning at nal
and extending oyor ti.e entire city
4.0O-Onicers meeting,
4:8O--Work, Beneficial degree.
Evening.
s.00-work. Fraternal degtee
1O;OO-Lunch and socia entertain
ment.
The Guthrie daily leader. [volume] (Guthrie, Okla.) 1893-1996, 1905-12-20
GRAND JURY DISCHARGED
InquisitoriaI Body Finishes
Work for Term Thomas
Brothers Sentenced.

The grand jury finished its work yes
lterday afternoon and the members
we're discharged for the term. A num-
Der of indictments were returned.
Charles Thomas, colored, who was
found guilty of manslaughter, vas SEN
fenced to serve two years in the pen
itentiary. His brother, Richard
Thomas. was found guilty of commit
ting a felonious assault and was given
similar sentence. He was granted
twenty days 20 give bond for $4,000 and
to file a petition in error in supreme
court. The two persons we're charged
with participation in the Coyle killing
about year ago.
william House, charged with forg-
cry. was released upon giving bail for
81, ,OOc.
District court proceedings this morn
ing we're as follows:
Myrtle Hill VS.. ]. o. severns ct al;
damages? defendants demurrer to pc
tition overruled and excepted; twenty
days to answer.
The Oklahoma Bond and Trust com
pany VS.. NJ, X & o. r. r. Co.; in
junction, receiver and money; Dale &
Bierer withdraw appearance of Adel-
bert Hughes.
James Ryan vs.. NJ, X & O. Ry. Co;
recovery Of money; demurrer overrul-
ed and excepted.
Mrs. Charles W. Worth VS.. Ohio Nil
Ter ct al; damages; demurrer over
ruled, leave to answer in twenty days
Milton williams VS.. Guthrie Ice @
Cold Storage Co; appeal from justice
court; plaintiffs motion to dismiss ap-
peal overruled.
The Guthrie daily leader. [volume] (Guthrie, Okla.) 1893-1996, 1905-12-20
RAIN PREVENTS ATTENDANCE.

Because OF the disagreeable weather
the morning session Of the Logan Coun-
" Farmers institute waA not held.
This afternoon at two o'clock Prof
Field, of the experiment station at Still
water spoke on Bermuda Grass"
Prof. Field gave it as his opinion that,
after experimenting with the grass at
the station it had been found that it
was really the best variety for the farm
ers to plant Next spring, TO every per-
son who viii pay the express charges
a crate containing suficient roots 20
plant an acre Of ground will be sent
free
Secretary McNabb also spoke this af-
ternon on "The Value OF Statistics to
the Farmer" The remainder Of thu
program prepared for today was not
given. Tomorrow, however It is hoped
that the weather conditions win have
improved and that the farmers can oct
to town 70 attend the institute session.
Many subjects OF practical beneht to
the farmer viii be discussed and spoken
Of at length by persons who have made
special investigation and experiments
in that particular line.
The Guthrie daily leader. [volume] (Guthrie, Okla.) 1893-1996, 1905-12-20
ZACH MULHALL IS SUED
Shooting ARRAY in St. Louis
Results in $4,000 Dam
age Suit.
specIal to Daily Leader.

Special to Daily Leader
st. Louis, Mo-, Dec 2O.--The trial Of
the suit Of Ernst Morgan against Zach
Mulhall for $4,000 damages for in
juries sustained in a shooting at the
Worlds fair June 1S, 1904, was bagun
yesterday in Judge Ryan's division Of
the circuit court
Morgan is a minor and is suing by
his friend, Joseph Morgan. The shoot
ing in which he was injured took place
between Mulhall and another man. His
big socket and thigh bone were injured
and he was otherwise hurt, it is al
legged,
Mulhall claims that he did not shoot
Morgan. From six to twelve shots were
fred, he asserted. The evidence for the
plaintiff was that only about three
shots were fred
Mulhall claims that Morgan was he
hind him, aud that he, therefore, could
not have shot him
The shooting occurred after the
night exhibition O. Cummings wild
West show, with which Mulhall was
connected Mulhall stated that the
other man was the aggressor in the
affair He had been told he said, that
the man made threats against him. He
went to his room after the show
changed his clothes, and on going out
took no weapons. A man named VIII
lam Jordan stuck a revolver into his
pocket, he said
After going out, he encountered the
other man, who made a motion as II
to draw weapon, Mulhall said He
asked the man not to shoot, and ther
grappled with him. In the struggle
which followed, the shooting occurred
he said.