The times dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1903-1914, 1905-02-19
A|N||||.N'|||U|||Al..D|'.E.B'.A!IT'|I[::!S
'A'1..U.N|||.I.yI'|.E /
Virginia. Defeats The George.
U. yvashihgto Col
BANoU Ell ITO VISITING TEAM n
Sixty Students From, Visiting.
College Cheer on Their
Companions. s8

| ~
s9ss Especial ID 5 s.!rho Imcs-Dis pntch) 55$,
lyNIvER S1TY3 or vIRGt INA & V4N..
Fob. Is Tho list Or the series of three
annual deba tcssb between the llnlyerslty2of
Virginia and George ,vashing 9 tllvel.s
sity were held sthls evening the l'upll ZIG.
l5hall. II 58 M 5t5;
Sixty Students from, George w sl,it1gtoi i
University occupied reserved sea Is ~ the
rarquet, and cheefed their reprcsl sntatycs
on. a Mrs. ]. s1' Smith, Of Sac Panio, l'r
| I'll, preside N Music was furnished v "
the Cleo Cub orchcst1'a con,sis ting y
twelve pieces, and 9led by Mr.. Eobertl
| Rosscr, Of Harrodsblrg. kS. ,g
The uuesitlo III was: r. sol we'd, Tia t { IA
bor Unions Should Incorporate as p:s con-
dltion5 precedent sdcnlnnd IS lrcosf ition
lty employers WE Tor Virginia, M es '
Carroll q, Walter Of staunton Va.:L, y Y
s., louisville, Ky, slTd Il
gene Rove. o e. tsburgii M ~ az
| the affirmative, while Nessrs G.. Is. Bud y
ger OF Utah; Herbert w. ~ GOD ware, ~ v.
olsl c,ol,necticuts George a. Malcolm. o.
Nilchi san, with Fred r., nodes, Of Ma
Land Il S alternate, presented the negative
of the question Tor George NF ashlngto 't
University. N ga IN Rs x
The Judges we're Alfred B.. Williams:
editor Of d tho News leader. Richmond
VA; Melville W. NJ HER. Assistant Secrc-3
ltary Of the Interior Depart lV ASH
|ington, and Glenn Brown, an N a q e tcct.j
of WA shln g ton!SS FSs8
5T5g5 4. @55 IRGINIA WINS.
After being out for about three min
utcs the jutlgasSreturnel to the hall, and
the result ot their$vo was ~ r1no,incee',
tho decision being vel, TO tue virginia
team which ha the neg tive OF the les.
ton george washington was d dared 70
be tho s,,pcriorfinifo form, but In the Cpl In
ION of4the3 judges her repres led
l5toS prove tt els point. # y: VI Il
M The members Of the Visiting cam de-
an exceedln ely pleasant lmpr Ion alipoll
THE audience, anttt5were heartily cteered
throughout Tor he, clear man merlin which
they presented itlioir side Of the q to1l.s
George a. Malcolm Of Michigan, is
genera.llSs conceded, 9made the ahlestz5ar-'
gument for George Vi Wa shlngtonl 81 ne IN
crporati ion Of labor unions, he contendod.
would work A nstsaipra cticaT remedy y for
cSstingteWlstsylts the 70 utset the lnsgri-2a
sbGlsss Gfttle Virginia team claimed hat:
tho question itself meant compulsory In In
corporation, and was therefore, contrary
tositre Constitution Of the Unltetls states
ana then end eRYolsd q shoW.t,t CORPORA
|stion was ylinWl 81. fs1shgt hen onpulsory Or
livoluntn ry.gsVhAyt ara ued hat tho advail.
{tages a pplcahlcs 10 corporations III gen.
cra do not apply to- Id Dor Unions ss,but,,
on the. othcr lia YdI roye etrimen'
tai. ai I'D 2citeH authorities to show hat
the Unions. themselves were ~ unit against
1t, Incorporation, they said. would not
materially benefit the EMPLOYER Nor de-
fcrea 50 Strikes nor l;lw.lesstle ss during
strikes, 53st r,5 5554{s !. rs
Joseph S. I>awton, who closed for the.
negative. proved the STIR for the local
team reviewing With telling effect he
main points made by his side. Aftcr
the award had been announced the entire
listudent body arose and gave the Vir-.
laglnia yell,PWith that$o g gorge Wa shingi
I9tona appended. Many assembled the sros-
Iftrun to congra tulate Che visiting debaters
s8 THE BANQ LET.
After tile debate a banquet vas rendered
tho visiting team at Mrs. Parklnson's,
Others present were the 1,ld ges, the home
team, the Advisory Committee on Debate
/ from the faculty. tho arrangements Of
both teams. and the members OF the Glee
Club Orchestra Mr.. ] ohn Ashby VIII
liams, OF Washington, was toas tn1aste
Among those responding to toasts were
/ the several Judges Mr., Badger Of the
George Washington team; Mr.. Lawton,
Of the Virginia team, and Mr. Hinton, a
|{lnel,rher OF last year's team at George
| Washington University. Az vs.
I