New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1904-12-22
BITTER AGAINST ACTRESS,
JfR. RAND,S SUMMING UP.
Mr.. Lery Confident Of .f'qa't'al
Defendant T,cice CoVepStS,


l,,ou ,,lat ho~ fate Is 10 be Mir levy Jor tAe he
fence and Mr. Rand. FOR The prosecution W7ae
their final addresses to the jury NrSio'tat hNth
makinr, speeches that the other ha" '0 Waf'S N'
day Justice Davis will charge the iA;'.
The address os Nh Lew ioo6 moro Than ~"
hours and haIc and he address ~ tAc prosecutor
one hour. Through both Of them the defendant SAL
quvering with emotion. Al the t''s ~ ''' l"" ''
her counsel she collapsed ana was leu paN tN nc
Tombs sobbing convulsively. Mr. Ra"ds address
was one OF the most bitter arraigumeuts ever hcyrd
in any courtroom. The defendant ia" n"rN'J h0'-
self 10 meet his denunciatons. but MS "p'''" was
So much scathing than was expected 'h"' *"'
collapsed again lis end and had 10 o' a"siN'r"
from the courtroom. Mr. Levy said he was 'h'''N
confident OF acquttal
Mir. Levy said in part:
II We had some method Of deciding as 10 ne
tru dizziness Of witnesses. yours would oe IN e1sy
were mon aciuated by viu3ctiveness? May they
testimony 50 as to punish TIE woman who has
Xxx defendant has confessed as to her relations
with Young She did not conceal anytnlmG "P Per
mes sd b me StrT % 70 wre a letter to
Young. There no evidence Of this nut me
here smith is not here. If it could have been de-
viscd by the counsel they would have been here.
am not responsive fcr JuIla or 6er usJI t
husband don't know Whst9Gg her n9 9o beF% }
luce says that he went with youns. to Fan
nery's saloon Ia protect Young who aid ne was
afraid something might happen 70 him. II TINS
why did Luce leave her alone win nun
when they went to drive in the park until o CLOCK
in The morning? If she wanted TO take thiS mans
life. does any one suppose that she WoulH ch"Se
the public street when she had 50 many other OPP
One fact that we have established here is that
Young i the cigar store that morning ana
pointrnent the night before and whsn she got word
that he wanted TO soc her she hirTiedE di $3.50
where meet him if he had not telephoned TO her
AS he finished Mis- Patterson collapsed. sobbing
on her fathers breast. She was led from the room
IN a silence that unbroken until Justice Davis
said that the physical condition Of several jurors
made II imperative that there be no night session.
lie would charge the jury to-day. he declared
Mr.. Rand, in his address. said in part:
The theory Of suicide cannot stand. because man
who is preparing TO kill himself usually shows re-
this tragedy? He has shaken from his shoulders
burden that lac had carried for year o.! more
Now Hazeltons story is splendid example OF
what reliance can be placed direct evidence. If
Paterson Shoot CaesarH Young for that is the
only thing that is consistent with the story re
YOU TO convict cat Of stealing cream on Hazel
The defendant is a clever actress Such people as
she is are filed with conceft and they are anxious
was two hours on the stand and she knew she was
called to the stand 10 say that she did not XII!
She noticed you men Of the jury start back at
Ife Would Kin her Or himself and its brazen af-
frontry that induced her 70 correct herself and say
testimony was rehearsed beforehand. Every word
Of il was typewriter and carefully prepared pc
IOrehand.
Mr. Rand then bitterly attacked the defendants
character. He went say:
Mr. Levy said that all the letters from Young to
her showed still retained his affection
and regard They only showed you a of them,
but even those few letters, taken into consdera-
ton with all the circumstances, the letters
Of man who would kill himself for love of her.
They have not printed a letter written after May
g. although she says he wrote to her every day.
Where are they? They do not produce them.
The letter written by Julia Smith TO Young is
he xey- q " Young
that she wanted him TO do the right thing once
She him to her first. else she could
not answer for the consequences.
1 wish that Morgan Smith here. I would
like TO ask that Tacetrack tout what support he
had except what his wife and himself got from
Nan as a result of her shameful relations with
Young Young was going away. They would lose
their means of support II Mans relations with
Young should cease. Then they concOcted this
scheme, which is indicated in this letter.
What the words Of Smith and his wife had
failed do, the blow Of Young himself that night
succeeded in doing-in putting murder in her heart
She had been cast off. Young going TO leave
her. and his shameful life with her. Mr. Levy
says there motive. What greater motive
0 you than that? What greater fury is
there than woman scorned?