New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1904-03-27

The Urban Club celebrated its tenth anniversary
bv a luncheon az Deluonico's on Tuesday. March
% Many prominent clubwomen were present,
among them being Mrs. Charlotte Wibour. Dresi-
dent OF Sorosis; Mrs. Camden C.. Dixie. president
Of the Heights branch of the wOman's Munich
pal League Mrs Philip Carpenter. first vice-presi-
dent OF the state Federation OF Womens Clubs;
Mrs Hamilton Orrnsbee regent OF the Long Island
Society Daughters OF the Revolution: Mrs. Darwin
J. Meseroie. OF the Civitas club: Mrs J. o. Car
peuter. president OF tho Associate Packer Nlumuae
Mrs Charles Bartram. president OF the ChirOpRan.
Dr. Mary Mills Patrick: president Gt the american
her work and Of the growing desire among East
ern women for a more liberal education. Mrs.
SAMUEL ts. 0s'e1q a. s icS PT ON ofT 2as
dent. was tOastmStreSs. Miss Grace Wood respond
carpenter to AS Others See rs Mrs charles
Bartram contributed 10 the speechrnaiking giving
was interpreted bv Mrs Katharine G. Parker and
Mrs G. Milton SeIIcck. To Mrs. Andrew j. Perry
the founder and senior director. was presented
handsome silver salad bowl by the members of the
club as 4 token OF their esteem. The decorations
were in yellow. quantities ct tulips being used.
The meeting Of the Civitas club on "Wednesday
March g. az the home Of Mrs. Darwin j. MeseroIe.
No. 16O JoraIemon-st, took the form Of a debate
The subject under discussion was Resolved. That
Trade Unions a Beneficial Factor in the Devel-
opmcnt OF Society The affirmative side was up
held by Miss Elizabeth Butcher Miss Bosamond
Roberts. Miss Grace Palmer Miss Louise Atkin-
son. Mrs. George g. Frank and Mrs. Darwin
Meserole. on the negative side were Mrs Warren
+. Derby. Mrs F. ID. Dodge. Mrs. john Clapper-
ton Kerr end Miss Fighter The affirmative held
that labor and capital must work together that
trade unions all tend toward arbitration. UniOnism
was beneficial TO the iabOrerS because 90 enabled
them secure the rights they are entitled 90 as
class when they cannot secure them as int-
vduals.
THE negative side declared that trade unions were
not beneficial 20 society. Mrs. Dodge spoEs OF the
recent losses account OF strikes. which were
harmful results OF trade unions IN san Fru1Ctscl.
Mrs DODGE said they were morally ard ethCaIly
wrong and degrading to the wOrSiuEma tending
to destroy all sense of personal ~eSDOusibihty.
and Therefore checking the progress OF che iui-
vdvaL Tire judges decided IN favor OF the uegl-
tive.
The ballroom Of tine Hotel st. George was the
scene the latter part Of the week Of the Colonial
bazaar given by tine Fort Greene Chapter Of thu
Daughters Of the Revolution OF which Mrs
Stephen V. White. OF Columbia Heights. is regent
The proceeds viii go TO swell the Continental Hail
fund The large ballroom was decorated with
flags and bunting. and all the girls and young
women taking part We're IN costume. The Colonial
kitchen in charge OF Mrs. Charles Terry Mrs John
Cooney and Mrs. 4 G. FetterroIf proved one %
the most attractive features. There was the hug.
open fireplace filled with logs ard around the
hearth snuffers. s6uets tOasters waffle irons
and candle moulGs and sticks Mr. Terry has A
two hundred years old. Many % the utensils
have been in the families over one hundred years.
The visitors attending the Boston Tea Party
rad served to them choice Daughters of the
American Revolution brand OF tea in the dafntfa-.
OF red white and blue china Presiding OVe- thes-
tables were 2Irs John Van Buren, Thayer. 4irs.