davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The San Francisco call., 1904-11-04
TIGERS GO DOWN ONCE MORE.
Angels Are Now Within One Point of
First Place.

Los ANGELES. Nov. 3.-Los An
geles gave Tacoma a bad beating,
principally because Fitzgerald had an
OFF day. He pitched steady enough for
three innings and then the locals fell
upon him and batted the ball almost
at will. His team went to pieces at
critical stages, which made matters
worse. Lynch relieved Fitzgerald in
the seventh inning. Eagan was hit on
the elbow by pitched ball and had
to give way to Doyle at short. The
locals ran bases in daring style and
Gray pitched splendid ball. To-day's
game puts Los Angeles within one
point of Tacoma in the percentage
table. Score
The San Francisco call., 1904-11-04

and beat 1t to first Then everybody
got tangled. McKuehn tried to catch
Jones at second and overthrew the
base into right field. Jones going to
third. Ganley thought he could reach
second. but was thrown out. With
Jones on third and one out Francks
landed the same kind of a bunt and
Jones started for home. Hogg fielded
the ball and in trying to catch Jones at
the plate threw over the catcher's s
head, Jones scoring. Francks kept
right on going and the ball wobbled
over the field In an effort to nail him at
second. The result was he landed on
third base and then scored on Dun
-leavy's sacrifice. The score:
The San Francisco call., 1904-11-04
FOOTBALL PLAYER LOSES
SENSE OF SMELL AND TASTE
Captain Stangland of the Columbia
University Eleven Strangely In
jured I'm Game With Yale.

NEW YORK. Nov. 3.-Captain
Robert StangIand of the Columbia
University football team is reported
to be suffering greatly from an injury
received in the game last Saturday
with Yale.
Stangland has been hurt in nearly
every game this season and in the
Yale contest was hurt about the head.
He rejoined the team at once, but
soon afterward complained of severe
pains in the head and has since lost
his senses of smell and taste.
The San Francisco call., 1904-11-04
Tenny Meets Driscon To-Nieht.

Six boxing bouts are carded for to-
night at Mechanics Pavilion annex. the
show being the regular monthly exhibit
tion of the Bay City Club. Harry Hawley
and Harry Williams, los Founders. open
the card; Harry Tenny and Barney
Driscoll close it, Both of these bouts
promise well. the last named in. par
ticular being good enough for any card.
The San Francisco call., 1904-11-04
LATONIA SELECTIONS.

BY the New York Morning Telegraph.
First race-AIfred c, Gold Sphinx,
j. Ed GriIIo.
Second race-Athlone. Benckart, Co.
lumbia Girl.
Third race Jake Greenberg,
WainamOinen. COmrade.
Fourth race-Thornhedge, Chara-
wind. Pick Time.
Fifth race-Agnes Virginia. Juchi-
tan, Lady Eileen.
Sixth race-Swiftwing. GIenwood.
Goo Goo.
Condition of the track-Fast.
The San Francisco call., 1904-11-04
HOW THE HORSES
ARE EXPECTED TO
RUN IN THE EAST
AoUEDUCr SELECTIONS.

BY the New York Morning Telegraph.
First race Diamond, Juvenaga,
Merry Lark.
Second race-Champlain. Considera-
ton, Garnish.
Third race-Crown Prince, Roseben,
Monet.
Fourth race - Thirty Third, Coy
Maid. Czaraphine.
Fifth race-The Huguenot, Stuyve.
Consideration.
Sixth race-Thespian. Tom Lawson.
Maie Hanlon.
Condition of the track-Fast.
The San Francisco call., 1904-11-04
SUMMARY

Stolen bases-Flood 2. Sheehan. Errors
Gray Doyle 2. Graham 3 Hits made off
Fitzgerald o. off Lynch 2. Home run-Cravath.
Two-base hits-Bernard. Chase. Lynch Sac
rfice hits-Smith. Flood. Casey. Ross. Bernard,
Gray. First base on errors-Los Angeles ..
Left on bases-Los Angeles 8, Tacoma l. Bases
on balls-On Fitzgerald 5. off Gray 2, off
Lynch L. Struck out-By Gray s. by Fftz-
gerald 2. Hit by pitched baIl-Flood and
Eagan Time of game hours. Umpire
Perrine.
The San Francisco call., 1904-11-04
Haggin Loses Noted stallion.

LEXINGTON, KY, Nov. 3-whiIe
being led to his stall to-day J. B. Hag-
gins Bathampton, by Hampton out of
The Bat, fell on the concrete floor of
a barn at Elmendorf and was fatally
injured, dying from conclusion of the
brain
The San Francisco call., 1904-11-04
Rain Prevents RECORD TriaIs.

MEMPHIS, Tenn, Nov. 3.-The
matinee trotting events and exhibition
trials of Lou Dillon and Dan Patch
have again been postponed on account
of rain and slow track until to-mor-
row.
The San Francisco call., 1904-11-04

MANY DIARIES RATED.-The Health
Board yesterday posted the names of forty dali
rfes rated 10 be in good sanitary condition and
fifty others. whose standing is poor. This is
decided improvement the returns of two
months ago. when only six dairies were rated
good and about eighty poor.
The San Francisco call., 1904-11-04

Stolen bases-Ganley. Dunleavy. Schlahey
Errors-Srnith. McKuehn. Hall. Hogg, Schlaf-
ley, Devereaux. Two-base hlts-Freeman, Dele
hanty. Sacrifice -Delehanty Dunleavy
First base on errors-Seattie 2. First base en-
called balls-Off Hogg 10. off Jones A. Left on
bases-Seattle r. Oakland g. Struck out-By
Hogg s. by Jones 5. Hit by pitcher-Van Hal
trer. Frisk Smith. Double plays-Francks to
Streib: Duneavy to Francks to Sehlahey
Passed balls-McKuehn 3 Stark l. Slime of
game-Two hours and ten minutes. Umpire
Mcdonald
The San Francisco call., 1904-11-04

PlEPER WILL FILED-The win OF Robert
fleper OF the McMaster-Pieper Machine Com
pdhy, VINO died on October so was fled for
70 wnoni the whole estate is bequeathed. Ii il
stated that the property consists OF realtv
money and shar5es in the companv excaeIs,s,
in value S1G,OCO
The San Francisco call., 1904-11-04

JURY FAILS TO AGREE-The iurv in 49,,
case OF Placido G. Valencia CHARGED vvitb
grand larceny. failed TO agree and was dis
charged by Judge LawlOr. The case was a-air
set Tor trial Monday morning Ths9s.
Iendant was accused Of taking $40 from Fre5
j. Hurst OF 1644 Mission street on Septen1ber a
The San Francisco call., 1904-11-04

I ctOIen bases-Drennan, GOrtOn, Whalen.
Shay. Spencer, Beck, Iberg. Errors-Van
Buren,. Spencer 2. Whalen.s Two-base hit
keilackey Sacrifice hits-Iberg, Kellackey,
Irwin First base on errorsASan Francisco ,
First base called bals-On Whalen g. off
lberg L. Left bases-San Francisco 2.
Portland IL. Struck out-By Whalen 8. Hit
by pitcher-Shay. Hildebrand. Double plays
Anderson to Gochnauer to Van Buren,; Beck to
spencer. Passed ball-Gorton.- Time of game
Il hour and so minutes Umpire-Brown
The San Francisco call., 1904-11-04
Totals. 81 ? 6 "a

Hogan batted for Fitzgerald in the seventh.
RUNS AND HITS BY INNINGS
The San Francisco call., 1904-11-04

RUNS AND HITS BY INNINGS.
The San Francisco call., 1904-11-04

Totals.S4 3 SO Is Totals. 3s 3
The San Francisco call., 1904-11-04
SUMMARY.

Stolen bases-Drennan, Gorton. VIII,
The San Francisco call., 1904-11-04

FIFTH RACE-One and an eighth miles;
selling; for three-year-olds and up:
Betting Horse Weight Jockey. St q Fin
2 10 Lord Badge los (Crimns) / 1 h
70 2-The Southerner. 1O1 CTrav) u "a
TO 2-Glisten, 9s fHildebrand) 5 5h 3h
Time, .53 Is Start fair. Won driving
Winner. W L. divers b. g. by Badge Mock
ing Bird. South Trimble Homestead. Ethics
finished as named
The San Francisco call., 1904-11-04

year ol1s-
Betting Horse. Weight Jockey. St q Fin.
8 10 l-Zeala. 1o5 eHildebrand).- IL
6 70 5-Trapper. I15 DyneD---.-. 1
: 70 1--Escutcheon 1l5 CW. Davs) h h
Tine ] 90 2-5. Start fair Won easily.
Winner s Psgets br (. by Watercress Zeal
sndia Kities Pirate Polly Fancy Dress.
Ranger. Mirthless. Prestige, Occur de Lion,
finished named.
The San Francisco call., 1904-11-04
LAToNLA ENTRIES.

CINCINNATI, Nov 3.-The entries
for to-morrow's races at Latonia fol-
low
The Daily Ardmoreite. [volume] (Ardmore, Okla.) 1893-current, 1904-06-15
MUSICAL RECITAL.
Miss Flanikens Glass Of Young Ar
lists capture Ardmore audience.


The piano and violin recital Of.
Miss Flaniken's pupils at the c. !.
clurcn last night was a real success
The house was filed. indeed there
was not an available seat left The
musical critics and music lovers Of
Ardmore were there anI were loud
in their praises both Of Miss F1aniken
as a teacher and the splendid work
OF the pupils.
II was the nrstl years work of all
the pupils, some Of them for only a
few months. and yet their lingering
and skill would have been creditable
TO much older pupils Each pupil
showed careful and thoughtful train
ing.
Little Margaret Murphy (aged G)
showed all that little child could
play on as large a thing as a piano
The piano duette of nine win three
pianos speaking out from their many
blending chords was a happy open
inc.
Little Essie Crosby was tender and
sweet on First Melody"
The five violin piece by Ozello
Pugh, Jack London, Mary Flaniken,
George Byrd and Miss Flaniken was
a great rendition and made violin
work a fine introduction.
Myra Murphy showed fine work as
she brought Runaway" from the
ivory keys.
Nellie Dashner rocked the -radle'
with such ease on the piano that the
babies all went to sleep.
Ozello Pugh, made her violin speak
in such sweet tones that she cap
tured the entire audience.
Lucille and Mary Byrd each, gave
the audience piano piece that made
you think of being in the forest
among all the birds, singers and war
blers
Jack London was fully at himself
on his violin and made the house
proclaim him a coming violinist.
Mary F1aniken won great praise
and admiration for her skillful render
ing OF Last Hope"
Miss Flaniken was strongly called
upon for a piece on the violin, but il
her very modest way, asked on &C
count of great labors performed II
the last few weeks, to be excused.
Mrs. Oakley, principal of Weather
ford, Texas, seminary for young la
dies was happy in her little talk OIL
last Hope"
We speak for Miss Flanikens fu
ture success as a musical director
The Daily Ardmoreite. [volume] (Ardmore, Okla.) 1893-current, 1904-06-15
stenOgraphers and EIks Again.

The stenographers and Elks, who
played such a sensational game last
Wednesday will tomorrow afternoon
play a second game. Tomorrow's
game will be played at the new park
and will be called at 4:30 o'clock.
There will be but a slight change
in the stenographer's lineup from
that of last Wednesday. The Elks
however viii have new battery and
expect to secure a victory over the
stenographers.
The following is the line up Of the
teams:
Stenographers Elks.
VIII Gardner catcher T. n. Coleman
Bob Phillips pitcher f. Wolverton
c. Watkins 1st base r. A. Jones
H. Stonum 2nd base Joe Adams
Tom Deem Srd base o. Wolverton
J. J.. Wallace SIS Eb Evans
. George Stowe r.f. John Nichols
, II. Wallace c. +. Joe Smith
p. b. Adams l. T. Frank Schneider
The Daily Ardmoreite. [volume] (Ardmore, Okla.) 1893-current, 1904-06-15
Manager Butts Resigns.

At a meeting Of the directors of the
ball team held last night, Frank Butt
resigned his position as manager OF
the team. Ebb Evans was elected
manager and O. A. Gafford assistant
manager.
The ball team looses a good man
ager in Mr.. Butt, who has successful
ly gotten together team that ha
no equal in the Territory. Mr. Butts
business interests would not allow
him to devote the time TO the team
that was necessary, hence his recog
milton.
The games scheduled so far are
three games with Denton, Thursday
Friday and Saturday, a game with
South McAlester Sunday at that
place the South McAlester team re
turning with the Ardmore boys, and
three games will be played here
Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday.
The Daily Ardmoreite. [volume] (Ardmore, Okla.) 1893-current, 1904-06-15
Socialists in Trouble.

Special TO the Ardmoreite.
Pauls Valley, l. T., June 15.-Tcm
Evans. charged with stealing a horse
from w T. Winn at Davis was
brought up last night, given a hearing
before Commissioner Pfeiffer this
Ioorning and bound over to the grand
jury. lie will be taken to Ardmore to
Jail this afternoon.
Evans, who is strong socialist
does not deny taking the horse He
claims he hal as much right to the
horse, as the party from whom IL was
stolen, Evans is about I5 years of
age and has been almost shot to
pieces, his body being covered wit
scar. from former wounds.
The Daily Ardmoreite. [volume] (Ardmore, Okla.) 1893-current, 1904-06-15
SHOT BY DEPUTY.
Engineer and Fireman Wounded by
Accident at cheeotah. 7.

Accident at Checotah, u 7.
Muskogee. !. T., June 15.-Engineer
j. T. Williams and Fireman Charles
Young were shot and dangerously
wounded at Checotah tonight when
north bound Missouri, Kansas and
Texas passenger train pulled out
Both men were shot by Deputy
United States Marshal Frank
Jones, who was trying to arrest ne
gro whisky ped Ter. The negro was
running down the platform when the
officer shot at him the same bullet
striking both engineer and fireman.
The wounded men were brought to
, this city TO the company surgeon.
Williams is dangerously wounded. but
Young will recover They were sent
to Sedalia tonight.
The Daily Ardmoreite. [volume] (Ardmore, Okla.) 1893-current, 1904-06-15

Willie Kendall, known TO all our
people, is at present in a hospital at
Austin. Texas, having an operation
performed upon his eyes. A cataract
has been removed from one of his
eyes and hopes are entertainer that
he Will be blest with sight in at least
one of his eyes.
The Daily Ardmoreite. [volume] (Ardmore, Okla.) 1893-current, 1904-06-15
AN AWFUL HORROR
EXCURSION STEAMER ON FIRE
IN NEW YORK HAReoR.
Fourteen Hundred People on Board
Mostly Women and children-AH
are Lost-Sueh is Bulletin
Received Today.

A bulletin received at the Cotton
exchange here today from New YorN
states that the Gen. Slocum. big
passenEor excursion boat = on nrc
and reported lost In the harbor at
New YORK. with 400 people ON beard.
mostly women and children
LATER Not a soul was saved
from tha General Slocum.
The Daily Ardmoreite. [volume] (Ardmore, Okla.) 1893-current, 1904-06-15

= PERSONAL NOTES. =
/: 80 . 4 = = 4 = = =

t+tt . = - = = = +
NJ. Duffey Of Midway is in the city
r. E Hill of Beaumont is in the
city
L. S. Dohnan Of Tishomingo is in
the city
r. {. Richards is in the city from
Chickasha
Cyrus C. Kean is in the city from
wynnewood.
Rev. William Crawford went to
Madill today.
Miss Fannie Gardner left this morn.
ing for Ron.
Bill Munet and family are in the
city from Ron
Jack scanlon came up from Mariet'
ia this morning
J. B. spragins went to Berwyn to-
day on business
Leo Freimel office deputy clerk is
here from Ryan today
p. O. Bingham and W. }. New romo
went TO Lindsay today
G. A. Grsworld Of Oklahoma City
is in the city on business
A. l.. Breeding, NJ. D., of St Louis
Is in the city prospecting
ir. ana Mrs. d. Replog,o lc't for
Durant today to spend the summer.
Mrs John Easley and daughter
Maurinc are visiting friends in Ma
all.
Earl Allen who has charge Of the
telegraph Office at Dougherty is in
the city.
Mrs. !. n. Brown of Mart, Tex, is
in the city the guest o. Mrs. J II
Pennington.
Miss Fannie Campbell, n Dough
erty. is in the city the guest Of Miss
Myrtle Ball.
Miss Eva Ritter has returned from
very pleasant visit Of a week with
friends at Davis
Mrs. w. b. Blanton and son OF
Gainesville are in the city the guest
of Mrs. Lutte Johnson.
G. NJ. Hull of Salina, Kan, ant
w. II. Loomis OF Topeka, Kan, are
in the city prospecting
Mrs. l.. Y. Bonner ieft this morn
ing for Durant where she will visi
relatives for few days.
Miss Alberta Ledbetter left thi'
morning for a months visit wit!
relatives at Granger, Texas.
j. J. Geeks and X. c. Rogers o
Gainesville came up last nignt t,
play with the Ardmore band at Du
rant.
Miss Pearl Nelson of Sulphur wa
IT, the city shopping yesterday ever
ing. and the guest of Miss Mamie Mis-
tott.
r. " LeDow and G. T. II. Brouf
man from the Department of Justic
at Washington, are in the city II
specting the jail.
Joe Price an old Ardmoreite, o
New Mexico is in the city and is col
sidering the probability Of again mai
ing Ardmore his home.
Mrs. Clarence b. Douglas accom-
panied by her little daughter, Sadi
Maud, of Muskogee, are visiting rel;
tives and friends here.
Mrs. ". F. Winstead and Miss Be
sic Scott OF Lake Charles. La mothe
and sister of Mrs. L. r. Marston, ar
here visiting Mrs. Marston.
Mrs. Nellie Mcbride and childre
of Fremont, Texas, and r. F. MEGA
en- of Taylor, Texas, are in the cit
the guests of Mrs. l. Boyer, at NJ
Lish avenue. southwest.
MIR. and Mrs. Glib Gibbins of Da
las, Texas. are in the city visitin
Mrs. Gibbins' sister, Mrs. d.
Butcher. Mr.. and Mrs. Gibbins al
also on the lookout for a place I
establish a large millinery store.
The Daily Ardmoreite. [volume] (Ardmore, Okla.) 1893-current, 1904-06-15
Lexington Defeats Pauls Valley.

Special TO the ArdmOreitc.
Pauls Valley |. T., June l5.-T.
ball game here yesterday afternoon
between the Pauls Valley and Lex
ington teams resulted s to in favor
of Lexington. At the END of the ninth
inning'the two teams were tied and it
became necessary to play twelve in
nings before the tie could be broken
The Daily Ardmoreite. [volume] (Ardmore, Okla.) 1893-current, 1904-06-15

]. w. kirtley of Lebanon is in the
city, he reports crops in that vicinity
very fine. He says l.. w. Howe has
returned to that place very much i'm
proved in health.
The Daily Ardmoreite. [volume] (Ardmore, Okla.) 1893-current, 1904-06-15

We can extract your teeth absolute.
ly without pain by new method. II
you are from Missouri, We can show
you. DRS. ADAMS & HEFLIN
sc Dentists
The Daily Ardmoreite. [volume] (Ardmore, Okla.) 1893-current, 1904-06-15

Miss Annita Austin, who has been
employed at Miss Russell Shinhol-
ser's for some time, left today for
Winfield, Kan.
The Daily Ardmoreite. [volume] (Ardmore, Okla.) 1893-current, 1904-06-15

Spragins & Co, will furnish you
all the fruit jars you need. They are
Mason's and the best. 15d&w
The Daily Ardmoreite. [volume] (Ardmore, Okla.) 1893-current, 1904-06-15
Wanted.

To buy land filed on by white inter
married citizens, also dead claims.
have land ior sale buy land and
lease land. 23d&wtf
w. p. POLAND, A.jmore.
The Daily Ardmoreite. [volume] (Ardmore, Okla.) 1893-current, 1904-06-15
FOR SALE.

FOR SALE-All my household goods
cheap for cash. Residence Sl3 c
street, northwest. Mrs. KalIsh next
door will show you through house.
Goods must be sold. Rare bargains
in handsome new furniture offered.
Will be at my home at . o'clock
each evening. DR.. w. s. Bechtol.
13-3t
The Daily Ardmoreite. [volume] (Ardmore, Okla.) 1893-current, 1904-06-15

Don't say it's the same old story,
but if you have teeth to extract. let
us show you it can be done absolutely
without pain.
DRS. ADAMS & HELM,
sc Dentists
The Daily Ardmoreite. [volume] (Ardmore, Okla.) 1893-current, 1904-06-15

The way of some transgressors
seems TO be pretty smooth.
The Daily Ardmoreite. [volume] (Ardmore, Okla.) 1893-current, 1904-06-15

Try a 1Oc smoke for sc. Da Costa
cigar. 1O-6
The Daily Ardmoreite. [volume] (Ardmore, Okla.) 1893-current, 1904-06-15

FOR SALE-One 2O-horsepower side
crank Houston, Stanwood & Gam.
BILE engine. Positively good as
new Also one large double-door
Cary safe. Easy payments or
cheap for cash. Apply or write NJ.
Zuckerman, at Cold Storage. 3.1m
The Daily Ardmoreite. [volume] (Ardmore, Okla.) 1893-current, 1904-06-15

Ice for sale every day at Moore &
Co.'S. on North Caddo. l9-1m
The Daily Ardmoreite. [volume] (Ardmore, Okla.) 1893-current, 1904-06-15

Try an Edo cigar, Better than
ever before. 151m.
The Daily Ardmoreite. [volume] (Ardmore, Okla.) 1893-current, 1904-06-15

Save your health, not the bands.
Smoke Da Costa sc cigar. 1916
The Daily Ardmoreite. [volume] (Ardmore, Okla.) 1893-current, 1904-06-15

Da Costa. Nickel.
The Daily Ardmoreite. [volume] (Ardmore, Okla.) 1893-current, 1904-06-15

Mrs S. A. Douglas is reported quite
sick again.
The Daily Ardmoreite. [volume] (Ardmore, Okla.) 1893-current, 1904-06-15

Ice for sale every day at City Fish
Market 20
The Daily Ardmoreite. [volume] (Ardmore, Okla.) 1893-current, 1904-06-15
FOR RENT.

FOR RENT-New three-roCm house
Apply Noble Bros. 27tf
The Daily Ardmoreite. [volume] (Ardmore, Okla.) 1893-current, 1904-06-15

Subscribe for the Ardmoreite.
The Birmingham age-herald., 1904-12-07

which was cahled over the entire world. that first thrust the British manufac- turer into international notice. Now that he has won the victory al the polls as against MT. Chamberlain's influence, MT. Have will be watched with interest when he enters the House of Commons
 No review of the important men among the coming leaders in the British Parliament could be d thorough study without a mention of the Right Honor able Sir Edward Henry Carson, M. F.. K c. The fact that he is solicitor gen. eral of England alone speaks for marked legal ability. More than that. in the latter eighties Sir Edward held the of fee of crown prosecutor in Ireland un- der Mr. Balfours 8 previous ministry. MT Carson gained very much the same rep utation in Ireland at that time that Judge Jeffreys did during the Mon mouth rebellion, but the mildest crown prosecutors have been known to assume monstrous shape in Irish eyes.
 Before he was crown prosecutor he had had a rising practice at the Irish bar and was already known as a tren- chant eross-examiner. This power of oss-examining-in which. perhaps, he has no living equal-stood him in splen- did stead as the governments proseeu- tor under the Crimes Act.
 When the Unionist government came back to power MT. Carson found to his fessed it), that he was not included in the list of ministers. This was a little hard on the man who had been MT. Balfour's right hand in Ireland. MT. Carson had a right to expect some rec ognition when Mir Balfour as Lord the making of the new administration in his hands.
 The fact that he was ignored was re- marked on in every quarter, and it was
The Birmingham age-herald., 1904-12-07

at Eton he proceeded subsequently, to the Royal Military Academy, Woolwlch, and obtained his commission at the age of 10 in the Royal Engineers which du- ties he performed with signal success He held the post for almost 10 years His subsequent appointment as finan- cial representative of England Holland and Belgium at the capital of Turkey only meant that he was very speedily appreciated by those whose business 1t was to know such things. It was not Sir Vincent's destiny, however to spend the remainder of his existence in watch ing over the interests of British Dutch and Belgian bcndholders in the Domin- ion of the Sultan and administering the public debt of that much embarrassed empire.
 At the instance of certain leading busi- his knowledge and experience. Sir Vim cent relinquished his duties In this re- spect In lS9S In order to take lip his resi- denee in London. where he quickly found scope for his administrative and financial genius in various important po- sitions. Thus he is the chairman of the London Committee of the National Bank of Egypt. president of the Daira Sanieh Company. the Irrigation Investment Company and Nickers. Sons & Maxim. while the Mexican Central Railway Company is another undertaking in whose direction he assists.
 Mir. Hnye, Who Answered Chamber
 lain.
 Mir. Johnstone Have. who has won Liberal victory in West Dorset. enters the Commons as a marked man because of his personal debates with MT Joseph Chamberlain himself, in which. no mat ter where the palm of eloquenee would lies MT. Haye was extremely victorious
The Birmingham age-herald., 1904-12-07
Fought BaIfour in Commons.

It was late in July, eight years ago, that the famous scene occurred between the First Lord of the Treasury and MT. Carson, as he then was. In biting tones Mr. Carson had asked how the House was to account for the government s transitions of opinion and the words rang like an alarm through MT Bal fours brain. MT. Balfour. remembering the old ties of friendship, was grieved and pained at being accused of incon- ssteney to the principles of the union by the very friend and colleague with whom he had weathered the storms of a great crisis in Ireland. It was like being stabbed in the back by his own pilot.
 My right honorable and learned friend and l." said NJ. Balfour, rising to face MT Carson, with an unmistak- able break In his voice, have been pc litical colleagues. We have fought side by side in times of stress. I have re- garded him in times past with feelings of absolute confidence. I have felt that on his judgment I could rely. But when he turns round and on the subject of this bill makes an attack on me-who am certainly an old colleague. and whom I hope he will still consider an old friend-f admit I cannot allow his observations to pass without some re-