davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The Pacific commercial advertiser. [volume] (Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands) 1885-1921, 1904-12-09
DUE TOMORROW.

strnr. Kinau, Freeman. from Hilo
and way ports.
O. s transport Logan. Stinsen, from
San Francisco, due.
StInr. Likelil5e, Naopala, from Maui
and Molokai ports, p. m.
SAIL TOMORROW.
P. NJ S. s. Mongolia. Porter. for San
Francisco, a. m.
DUE SUNDAY.
stmr. K-auai, Peterson, from Kukui-
haele at go a. m.
Stmr. ". @. Hall. s Thompson, from
Kauai d rts at 2:S5 ~ m
Schr. Lady, from Koolau ports at II
a. m.
PASSENGERS.
Arrived.
Per stmr. Niihau, Dec. s, from Anaho.
la-E. r. Hendry.
Departed.
Per s. S. sonoma, Dec. s, for the
Colonies-Mrs. H. Friedler, E. NJ
Brown, G. w. Clyde, w. H. Alley and
wifel F. Welfar. A Griggs.
Per stmr. Mikahala, Dec. s, for Kaua
ports-Miss Gray, A. S. Wilcox, wife
and two children. Albert Lyman, Maude
De Bretteville, Paul De Bretteville, j
III. Bale and daughter, Col z. S. Spal-
ding, Rev H. Isenberg, J. Nevin, VIM
Williamson, DR.. Spinola, Mr.. De Lacey
The Pacific commercial advertiser. [volume] (Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands) 1885-1921, 1904-12-09
Good Money-Makins investments

The best and cheapest lots, ready for
building, at Kaimuki, on the most
liberal terms, without interest.
Two fine lots on Kawaiahao street,
Kewalo, $3.50; only little cash re-
quired.
Several good bargains in Nuuanu
Tract, the healthiest and coolest place
about the city.
Have also for rent some nice. cosy
cottages within walking distance from
the postoffice.
II SCHNAHK
The Pacific commercial advertiser. [volume] (Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands) 1885-1921, 1904-12-09
FOR RENT.

STORES AND OFFICES waity
Building. King Street.
sTORE-Fort street, makai Island
Meat Co. store.
SToRE-Fort Street, opposite Catho-
lie Church.
sToRE-Beretania and Fort Streets
WAREHOUSE.
HOUSEKEEPING Heights.
HOUSE-kaimuki.
BISHOP & Co,
Bankers.
The Pacific commercial advertiser. [volume] (Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands) 1885-1921, 1904-12-09
NOTICE.

Don't drug yourself with poisons for
headache and tired feering when a
pleasant draught of "Our Celebrated
Bromo Pop will do the trick.
Our Chocolate Creams, Cal. Lemon
ade, Root Beer, Orange Cider and all
kinds of aerated drinks are the best
on the market.
ARCTIC SODA WORKS.
127 Miller St, Honolulu. H. T.
The Pacific commercial advertiser. [volume] (Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands) 1885-1921, 1904-12-09
FOR SALE.
FOR SALE.

A half acre of ground with fine resi-
dence, stable, carriage shed and ser
wants quarters.
Magnificent view overlooking entire
city.
Buildings almost new
Purchaser can have immediate pos
session.
Apply, BISHOP e CO.,
Bankers.
The Pacific commercial advertiser. [volume] (Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands) 1885-1921, 1904-12-09
NOTICE.

ANY WOMAN OR GIRL NEEDING
help or advice, is invited to commune
cate, either in person or by letter. with
Ensign l. Anderson. matron of the
salvation Army woman's Industrial
Homes No 1850 King street.
The Pacific commercial advertiser. [volume] (Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands) 1885-1921, 1904-12-09
REALTY TRANSACTIONS

Entered for Record Dec. s. 1904.
Rebecca Houghtailing to Mrs Emil
ly Bemrose ..............-......- M
Kaluna Lansing and hsb to F
Schaefef. -........ -.-'...... -
Wong Chong to Ching See. ........ D
E Colt Hebron and VT to F'erdi-
nand West II
Claus SpreckeIs & Co by atty to E
G Hebron -..F II
Julia H Along to William Allen
$500. -. Rev PA
Julia H Along to Albert Along. P. A
KoIoa Sugar Co to D P r Isen-
berg Il
Hawn Realty and M Co. Ltd, TO
Napoe and hsb Observation-Disclosures. Rel
George N Rutherford. and WI to
Alice K Keawe. ................... D
Avery to j A Combs. .........B 5
The Pacific commercial advertiser. [volume] (Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands) 1885-1921, 1904-12-09
Dr.. Hicks FleshgIOw

Gives the face the natural pink glow
of health. With a magnifying glass
it cannot be detected. Call for a FREE
TRIAL as a sample at Miss Wynn's
Hair Dressing Parlors, Richards street
The Pacific commercial advertiser. [volume] (Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands) 1885-1921, 1904-12-09

IF SO, WHY NOT USE
THE ONLY DOUBLE TRACK
RAILWAY between the Missouri River
and Chicago.
THREE TRAINS DAILY
VIA THE SOUTHERN PACIFIC,
UNION PACIFIC AND CHICAGO
& NORTHWESTERN' RVS.
Overland Limited. Vestibu1ed.
Leaves San Francisco at 10 100 a. m
The most Luxurious Train in the World
Electric Lighted Throughout. Buffet
smoking cars with barber and bath,
Booklovers Library, Dining Cars, Stand
ard and Compartment Sleeping Cars and
Observation Cars. Less than three days
to Chicago without change.
Eastern Express. Vestibuled.
Leaves San Francisco at 600 p. m
Through Standard and Tourist Sleeping
Cars to Chicago. Dining Cars. Free
Reclining Chair Cars.
Atlantic Express. Vestibuled.
Leaves San Francisco at 600 a. m
Standard and Tourist Sleepers.
Personally Conducted Excursions
Wednesdays, Thursdays and Fridays
The best of everything.
r. r. RITCHIE,
q. A. P. C. Chicago & Northwestern
Ry., GIT Market Street palace Ho-
ted, San Francisco.
The Pacific commercial advertiser. [volume] (Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands) 1885-1921, 1904-12-09
VESSELS IN PORT.
ARMY AND NAVY.

ARMY AND NAVY.
U. s. S. Iroquois. Niblack, Station ves-
sell
U. S. S. Petrol, Sherman. Station ves-
sci, San Diego, Dec. s.
MERCHANT VESSELS.
Coronado, Am. bkt., Potter, San Fran
cisco, Nov. %.
Erskine NJ. Phelps. Am. sp.s Graham
Philadelphia, Aug. 81.
Mary E. Foster, Am. sehr., Wi41er. Port
Gamble, Dec. 1.
U. s. WEATHER BUREAU.
Alexander Young Building. Honolulu,
T. H.
December 8. s p. m.
Mean temperatures
Maximum temperature-76
Minimum temperature-67.
Mean barometer-3000
Rainfall, "a hours ending s p. NO
Relative hunidity-s a. m, rs per
cent; 8 p. m. u per cent.
Mean absolute humidity-6.1S2 grs.
per cubic foot.
Prevailing direction of wind-N. E.
Average wind velocity, miles per
hour
Average cloudiness. in tenths-1
ALEX. Nee. ASHLEY,
Section Director, in Charge.
The Pacific commercial advertiser. [volume] (Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands) 1885-1921, 1904-12-09

Note:-Barometer readings are COR
rected for temperature, instrumental
errors, and local gravity, and reduced
to sea level. Average cloudiness stated
In scale from to 10. Direction OF wind
Is prevailing direction during "a hours
ending at 8 p. m. Velocity Of wind Ii
average velocity in miles per hour.
ALEX. McC. ASHLEY,
Section Director, In Charge.
The Pacific commercial advertiser. [volume] (Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands) 1885-1921, 1904-12-09
Classified Advertisements,
WAN

A SMALL Cottage or number of rooms
suitable for light house keeping. Adj
dress d, this office. 1910
The Pacific commercial advertiser. [volume] (Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands) 1885-1921, 1904-12-09

CLERICAL position by young lady.
Experienced. Address W., this Office
6961
The Pacific commercial advertiser. [volume] (Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands) 1885-1921, 1904-12-09
. "A. Il u
RAILWAY & LAND co.
TIME TABLE
October s, 1904

OUTWARD.
For waianae, Waialua, Kahuku and
Way Stations-*9:15 a M, 1920 p. m.
Tor Pearl City, Eva Mill and Way
Stations--f7:30 a. M, 1918 a. M,
sII:05 a. M, s2:15 p. m, 1920 p. H.,
sS:15 p. m, 1880 p. m, f11:15 p. M
INWARD.
Arrive Honolulu from Kahuku, Wal
sIua and Waianae-*S:3S "a M, s5:31
D. m.
Arrive Honolulu rom EVA Mill and
Pearl City-t7:4s a. m, 1885 a M,
s10:3s a. M, "1:40 p. M, "4:31 p. m,
s5:s1 p. M, 1880 p. m.
Daily.
Sunday Excepted.
Sunday Only. 8
q. P. DENISON, F. C. SMITR
Supt. G. p. & T. A.
The Pacific commercial advertiser. [volume] (Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands) 1885-1921, 1904-12-09
FOR RENT.

COTTAGES; Christley lane, off Fort st.
Rent reasonable. Apply Wong Kwai.
The Pacific commercial advertiser. [volume] (Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands) 1885-1921, 1904-12-09

MISS JENNIE ELsNER.-Pisno, sole
representative in Honolulu of the
celebrated "Kelso" method e20 King
ST.
The Pacific commercial advertiser. [volume] (Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands) 1885-1921, 1904-12-09
PHYSICIANS.

DR. T. MITAMURA.-Ofice, ss Kukui
Lane. to IL m; $50 to 1880 D. m.
The Pacific commercial advertiser. [volume] (Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands) 1885-1921, 1904-12-09

OCULIST AND AURIST.
DR. VIM. G. ROGERS-Rooms 80 and
"a, Young building. Phone Main Is.
The Pacific commercial advertiser. [volume] (Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands) 1885-1921, 1904-12-09

S. S. Korea, Seabury. for the Orient,
probably sail in afternoon.
The San Juan islander. [volume] (Friday Harbor, Wash.) 1898-1914, 1904-12-10
CHURC UNION.

Fourteen Denominations Agree TO
Participate In Conference.
Philadelphia. Dec. 6.-Long strides
have been taken toward the practical
federation of the Protestant churches
of the United States. Fourteen demon
nations have already agreed to partio-
ipate in the great conference to be held
in New York City during November of
next year. 1t is understood that the
synods of the Lutheran church will
vote to participate, and the Protestant
Episcopal church, through it's COM
mittee on unity, will do likewise.
If these two denominations assent
seventeen millions of communicative
will be represented. 1t will be the
first time in the history of Christianity
since the Reformation that such uni
ty has been realized.
There will be no union along the
lines Of rules of faith or church organ
ization, but there will be consolidation
of effort in all matters pertaining to
the broad moral and national ques-
tions upon which all scots can meet
on q common basis.
The San Juan islander. [volume] (Friday Harbor, Wash.) 1898-1914, 1904-12-10
MORE TO FOLLOW
LAND FRAUD CONVICTIONS ONLY
A STARTER.
secretary Of the interior Dictate
Statement as to the Policy Of
the Oeparfment-SayS No One
Will Be Shielded, Whether High
or Low, 1t Guilty..

Washington, Dec 8.-The secretary
OF the interior has directed that the
following telegram be sent to F. j.
Heney, special assistant attorney gen.
eral, at Portland, Or:
Sincere congratulations on result of
your mastery work in bringing to JUS
tlce those who have sought to steal the
public domain and have villainously
attempted to thwart the department. in
It's efforts to- protect the same''
He them dictated the folio wing state
ment:
The conviction in Portland, Oregon,
yesterday, of five persons for land
frauds, which will be followed next
week by the trial of several others in
dicted for the same ofense, is but an
other step towards the contamination
of the policy entered upon by the Sec
rotary of the interior when it became
known nearly three years ago that
frauds were being perpetrated in con-
nection with public, to run down and
prosecute the guilty ones to the full
extent of the law without regard to
their positions in life. The depart
ment has encountered many obstacles
while engaged in this work, but has
moved steadily onward and has had
the hearty assistance and cooperation
of the department of justice in bring
ing the land criminals to justice.
''These frauds have been more far
reaching than the country has sup
posed, and the task of unearthing them
and securing necessary proof has been
difficult one, but there has been no
abatement Of the intention to overcome
all difficulties and secure tho convic-
tion of land thieves. No one will be
shielded. whether high or low, and
the work of prosecution will be carried
on vigorously"
The San Juan islander. [volume] (Friday Harbor, Wash.) 1898-1914, 1904-12-10
MANY SHIPS HIT
BOnBARDr1cNT or RUSSIAN FLEET
CONTINUES.
Big Guns MOunted on 2O3-fleter
Hill Promise Destruction Of All
That Is Left OF the Russian
Fleet in the HarbOr at Port
Arthur.

Tokyo, Dec. 8.-Imperial headquar-
tiers has made the following announce
ment:
"The result of the bonn bardment of
Port Arthur by our large caliber guns
on the 9TH instant was very good.
Many effective hits were made against
the battleships Peresviet and Pobieda
and the protected cruiser Pallada. In
consequence the Peresviet caught fire
and at 3:15 O'Clock the Pobieda listed
to starboard."
St. Petersburg, Dec. 8.-Foreigr tel
egrams received stating that the Jap
anese have succeeded in mounting
heavy guns on 2O3- Meter hill are re-
garded as seriously significant and
have created deep impression at the
war office. If the reports Of the sink
ing of the Russian warships in the
harbor of Port Arthur are confirmed
it destroys the last hope of sortie,
and when the end comes nothing re-
mains but to sink those that are left in
deep water to prevent them from fall.
ing into the hands Of the enemy.
The Importance of 2O3-Meter hill to
the garrison is evidenced by Gen.
Stoessel's desperate efforts to recap
ture it.
Berlin, Dec. S.-According to dis
patch to the Lokal Anzeiger, the plac-
ing of heavy cannon on 2O3- Meter hill
will enable the Japanese to fire on and
sink junks and other craft bringing
supplies Port Arthur forfrom ChefOo
Tokyo, Dec THE commander Of
the japanese naval guns mounted on
2O3-M Meter hill reports today that the
Russian turret battleship Poltava was
sunk and the warship Retvizan so bad
ly damaged as to be in sinking con-
dition, in the bonn bardment of the har-
Dor from Meter hill yesterday.
Seventy nine shots took effect on the
Russian vessels in the harbor. The
Retvizan is today listing heavily to
port.
Besides doing irreparable damage in
the harbor the Japanese succeeded in
dislodging the enemy from another
eminence north of Suerhkou and two
eminences north of San LII Chan.
Another report received this morn
ing states that the Russian cruiser, in
trying to escape from the deadly Jap
artillery fire, ran aground and is still
in precarious position in the harbor.
On December 6, at p. M, in re-
spouse to a request from the Russian
commander, an armistice Of five hours
was granted fol-. removal of the dead.
The San Juan islander. [volume] (Friday Harbor, Wash.) 1898-1914, 1904-12-10
AMERICAN LAKE SITE.
Army Officers Look Over rJaneu-
yer Grounds.

Army OFFICERS Look Over rlsneu-
yer Grounds.
Tacoma, Dec. 5.-Gen. Constant
Williams, commander Of the Depart.
ment Of the Columbia, and Mai. A. X.
Evans, assistant adjutant general Of
the United States army, inspected the
maneuver grounds at American lake
the latter part Of the week, accompa
MED by Secretary Whitehouse, Of the
Tacoma Chamber Of Commerce and
Capt. A. s. Rowan.
The inspection was mnde in an, au-
tomobile. The visit of the officers ID
at the request of the Chamber of Com
omerce, which has secured an option
on all the ground required, and which
will be submitted to the war depart.
ment. Gen. Williams says whether
or not the department will see fit to
recommend to congress the purchase
of this site is problematical.
Nothing has yet been determined.
There are other sites whose claims are
being advanced, and whose supporters
are now actively at work. The gener-
al says he is certain no exorbitant
price will be- paid for any ground. 1t
is said the report of Maj Evans is IA
vorable ito the American lake site.
The San Juan islander. [volume] (Friday Harbor, Wash.) 1898-1914, 1904-12-10
FIRED ON OWN SHIPS.
Admiral ROjesfvensky Tells How u
Happened.

uoppSss~Ss
/ st. Petersburg, Dec. An official
statement issued from naval headquar-
ters gives Vice Admiral Rojestvensky g
latest account of the Dogger bank at
fair and explains how the Baltic fleet
fired on their own ships. The state
ment follows:
According to supplementary infor-
nation from Vice Admiral Rojestven-
sky concerning the North sea incident
of October 81, after the Kniaz Souva-
rolf ceased firing, two searchl1ghts OF
the Dmitri Donskoi and Aurora sud-
denly appeared on the left of the iron
clad division. The Dmitri Donskol
showed night signals, whereupon, fear
ing projectiles from the hindmost ships
of our division should hit our own ves-
sells, either direct or by rlcochet, a
general signal to cease firing was made
from the Souvaroff. The order was at
once obeyed. The whole firing lasted
less than ten minutes. Communica-
lions by wireless telegraphy stated that
five projectiles struck the Aurora, some
ricocheting and others striking direct.
The chaplain of the Aurora was seri-
ously injured and petty officer was
slightly wounded. The chaplain sub
sequently succulnbed at Taniger.'
The foregoing statement is the first
official confirmation of the fact, previ-
ously published in these dispatches,
that during the North sea affair five
shells came aboard the cruiser Aurora,
injuring a priest, who subsequently
died at Algiers.
1t appears from reliable sources that
the commander of the Baltic fleet was
moved to make the admission after be-
ing informed that Captain Carl Feodo-
rovitch, commanding the Aurora,
which suffered most under the first
Russian volley and later took promi-
nent part in the bonn bardment of the
fishermen, had made clean breast OF
it in the course of an interview given
to newspaper correspondents at Copen-
hagen.
The vice admiral does not state he
has come to the conclusion that there
were no Japanese vessels near the Dog
ger bank at the time of the incident,
and the general opinion prevails that
he will claim to have fired upon the
enemy and that some Of the shells
went astray and accidentally struck
the Aurora, which was steaming up in
the fog.
The news of this confession has Gre
ated profound sensation here, and
the faith in Russia's side of the inqui-
ry to be conducted in Paris has been
severely shaken.
The San Juan islander. [volume] (Friday Harbor, Wash.) 1898-1914, 1904-12-10
END or PORTLAND TRIALS.
Five Defendants in Land Cases Found
Guilty by the Jury.


Guilty by the Jury.
Portland, Or, Dec. 7.-After DELHI
Grating for thirty-five minutes the jury
in the United States district court re-
turned verdict finding 8. A. D. Pu-
tor, Horace G.. Mckinley, Emma l..
Watson, D. w. 'rarpley and Frank
Wolgamot guilty Of conspiring to de-
fraud the United States government
out of title to portion of it's public
lands.
The day commenced with the argu-
ment Of Special Prosecutor Francis j.
Heney in behalf of the government.
For over two hours Mr.. Heney spoke
without ceasing, while the defendants
withered beneath his scorching words,
pregnant as they were with bitter sar-
casm and denunciation of the alleged
conspirators and their acts. The at
torneys for the prisoners came in for
no little rebuke at the hands Of the
government prosecutor for the man.
ner in which they have conducted
their case. Mr.. Heney closed his ar
gument with an earnest appeal to the
jury to return verdicts convicting the
accused persons of their alleged crimes.
1t was noon when Mr.. Heney fin
ished his address. At 2 O'Clock Judge
Bellinger delivered his charge, who b
consumed but ten minutes. As the
Jury retired to deliberate, the court an
nounced a recess until such time as a
decision should be reached. Men stood
densely packed outside the lobby and
wagered over their shoulders with
friends upon the length Of the inter
mission. The lawyers deserted their
posts where for twelve days they have
clustered around the long table in ear
nest contention and in little groups
discussed the outcome. The defend
ants gathered together and talked in
low tones as they awaited the an
nouncement of their fate.
At ten minutes to 8 O'Clock the jury
| filed back into the room and the hum
of voices was instantly stilled, as If in
pemonition of what was to follow.
| The vedict was handed to the court
and the clerk read as follows:
eve, the jury, find the defendants,
| Emma L. Watson, S. A. D. Puter, Hor,
ace q. Mckinley, D. W. Tapley and
Frank H. Wolgamot, guilty OF the
crime of conspiracy to defraud the
government out of part of its public
lands situated in township south OF
range east, as charged. We find the
defendant, Marie L. Ware, not guilty.
els that your verdict, gentlemen?
asked the court.
cit iA,'' was the reply of the fore
man, and the long trial was q thing
of the past.
There is no doubt that an appeal
will be taken. The attorneys for the
defense are now preparing their motor
and will in all probability present il
at the opening of the next case on De
cember Is.
The San Juan islander. [volume] (Friday Harbor, Wash.) 1898-1914, 1904-12-10
SEATTLE SPECIAL ELECTION.
Portions of the Proposed Bond Is
sue Defeated,

Seattle, Dec.7 The special cleo
ton held in the city yesterday resulted
in the defeat of the proposed bond is
sues for the erection of a new city hall
and the purchase of new site. The
propositions to Issue bonds for the
erection of new city Jail and the ex-
tension of the municipal lighting cir
cults to the residence sections of the
city were carried by small majorities.
The voting was light, only about
one-fifth the usual vote being polled.
The lighting bond proposition was
knitted to a far greater extent than
was anticipated, it carrying by only a
majority of 119 votes.
The San Juan islander. [volume] (Friday Harbor, Wash.) 1898-1914, 1904-12-10
COLOSSAL FRAUD.
Prominent Men of Two or More
States Said to Be Involved
in Chadwick Matter.

New York, Dec. 8.-The climax in
the affairs of Mrs. G. L. Chadwick
came last night when she was placed
under arrest in her apartments, at the
Hotel Breslin, charged with aiding
and abetting bank officer in embezz-
ling $12, 800. The arrest was made
after a lengthy conference between
United States Commissioner Shields,
Assistant United States District Attor-
ney E. E. Baldwin, Secret Service
Agent Flynn and United States Mar
shall William Henkel. Commissioner
Shields issued the warranG, which
charges violation Of section 5000 of
the United States federal laws relating
to conspiracy.
One of the prominent men from
Ohio, now here, said:
SIN a day or two revelations will
be made which will show this to be
the most collosal affair of the century
Five prominent New York men, whose
names have not yet been mentioned,
will be involved as deeply as Mrs.
Chadwick.
ga number of wealthy and promi-
nent Western men will also be dragged
into the case and numerous prosecu-
tons will follow. These facts will be
made public through the grand jury
jury investigation just begun at Elyria,
Ohio.
Andrew Carnegie said yesterday that
he had no intention of prosecuting any.
body for forging his signature to notes.
even if further investigation shows
| hat such forgery has been committed
The San Juan islander. [volume] (Friday Harbor, Wash.) 1898-1914, 1904-12-10
SENSATION IN LAND CASES
One Of the Defendants Pleads Gxliltv
Others Depend on Arguments
Of Attorneys.

Portland, Or, Dec 5.-Prolific in
surprises and sensations as have been
the developments in the land fraud
cases, no one was prepared for the eli.
makes Of Saturday. By far the most
important, both because of it's unex.
pectedness and because of the moral
effect it is almost certain to have on
the jury, was the request of defendant
Frank Wolgomot, through his attor.
ney, for leave to withdraw his plea of
not guilty and be allowed to plead
guilty to the crime of conspiracy az
charged. Judge Bellinger took the
matter under advisement.
Almost equally unexpected was the
request on the part OF Special Prose
cutor Francis J. Heney that an orde,
Of acquittal be issued in the case OF
Marie L. Ware, on the ground that the
prosecution did not believe that she,
according to the evidence, had been
proven guilty Of aiding the present
conspiracy. OF hardly less surprise
was the announcement, not more than
twenty minutes after the government
had completed it's case, by the defense,
that it rested, and that the case was
ready for argument by counsel.
Apparently despairing of undertak
ing to batter down the mass of evi
dence which the government had
heaped against them, they are to base
their hopes on an argument to the jury
and if that fails, on a reversal Of judg
ment at the hands of an appellate trib
unal on question of law. Nothing
in the nature of defense of McKin
ley, Puter, Watson and others was at
tempted by the defendants counsel.