Custer County Republican. (Broken Bow, Neb.) 1882-1921, 1904-05-05
FILIPINO A STUDENT
NOT FIT FOR sELF.eoVER NMENT,
SAYS JUDGE TAFT.
He is Opposed to Any Move Which
Would Encourage Their Dssire for
ependence-GraVe Responsibility
Rests on American Voters.

The Philippines independence com
mittee to which Secretary Taft re-
Cerred in his speech at Chicago, con-
sists, as he said, of "a number of eX-
cellent and prominent gentlemen"
Among the members are nearly doZ-
on university presidents, including Ell
lot of Harvard, Schurman of Cornell,
Jordan of Leland Stanford, Jr., King
Of Oberlin, and Alderman of Tulane at
| New Orleans. We select these names
| because they afford convincing evil
denCe that membership is not confined
to any small section OF the country.
Aside from that, the appearance of the
name of the president of Cornell in
the list Is peculiarly interesting be-
cause of DR.. Schurman's service on
one of the Philippines commissions.
Another member is Judge George
Gray of Delaware, who is supposed to
have done some violence to his own
opinions when he signed the treaty
| by which the United States acquired
title to the Philippines. Various
branches OF the Christian church are
represented by Bishop Potter, Bishop
Spalding and Dr. Parlihurst, while
among the other signers to the indie
pendence petition are Charles Francis
Adams, Andrew Carnegie, w. o. How
! ellis and Horace White. 1t will thus
! be seen that the excellent and promi-
nent gentlemen are fairly well dstriD-
uted, not only geographically, but also
as regards their pursuits.
On the other hand 1t would no doubt
be very easy to make up large list
| of representative men who would dis
sent from their views and agree with
Mr. Taft that it is not wise for our
political parties to pledge themselves
| to the independence of the Philippines.
! If we appeal to names for authority
this fact must be taken into account,
and of course very great authority at
! taches to the name of the secretary
| himself.
But where there is such division
of authority on great public question
there are the strongest reasons why
each individual citizen should give it
earnest consideration, and that brings
us to a very difficult aspect of the
Philippines problem. The sovereignty
of the islands is actually reposed in
the voting population of the United
States, which acts in It's own affairs
as a democracy. And while this cleo
torate is very jealous of its own rights
much alive to its own interests, and
thoroughly we'll informed on the sub
iects that Immediately concern it
there is no prospect that 1t can ever
fully comprehend :. strange people re
moved from it by thousands of miles
In other words, If the Filipinos are
generally ignorant from lack OF
schools, we, their governors, are now
and are destined to be exceptionally
ignorant as regards them from lack oil
contact and lack of racial sympathy.
References to the examples of Other
powers do not solve the problem OF
eliminate the serious nature of what
is undoubtedly grave anomaly among
American political institutions. II
would therefore be a most happy es
cape for us If we could dispose of the
| 1HlllDpluGS as We ulopOStu VI Subd
and this is what the independence
committee desires. Secretary Taft
thinks, however, that the time is not
ripe; that the Filipinos cannot learn
government by independent prac
tice, but only under very long course
Of tutelage. He argues, therefore, that
it would be a great mistake for our
political parties to give them the plat
torn encouragement that is advocated
by the committee, because II would in
spire a host of native agitators to a
dangerous activity.
That may be so, but neither the gen
erous impulses of our people as they
are expressed in legislation, nor the
fact that their delegated authority is
temporarily in good hands can be said
to clear the situation of it's perplexi-
ties. This much only is certain, that
If we are to hold the islands we must
give them the benefit OF that eternal
vigilance without which the liberties
of no people are safe.
The Chasm in the Democracy.