davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27
DECISION USED AGAINST HIM
Miss Robertson Writes Parker Allepfnp
q Discrimination.

dispatch from Rochester, NJ Y, last
night says: The prevailing opinion in the
action which was brought about two years
ago by Miss Abigail Robertson of Rochester
to restrain manufacturing concern from
the unauthorized use OF her picture was
adverse to the young woman and was writ
ten by Chief Judge Parker Of the court OF
appeals.
Miss Robertson has written an open letter
to the judge. in which she says she has
read that Mrs. Parker has been compelled
by the ubiquitous photographer to leave
home and that the judge is quoted as say
ing: Il reserve the right to put my hands
In my pockets and assume conmfortabIe at
titudes without being everlastingiy afraid
that 1 shall be snapped by some fellow
with a camera"
"I take this opportunity to remind you
that you have no such right as that which
you assert" Miss Robertson wrote in her
letter. II have very high authority for
my statement being nothing less than a
decision OF the court Of appeals Of this
opinion. The action was one in which I
was the plaintiff.
You may recollect that the facts in that
case were admitted that the defendants.
without my knowledge or consent and
knowing that they had no right or author
ity SO to do, had secured my photograph.
and. having caused 1t to be enlarged and
copies thereof as an advertisement: that
such use Of my likeness caused my Illness.
and that desired an injunction against
the defendants restraining the further use
thereof.
1.-THE special term held that I was en-
titled to relief. The appellate division of
the fourth department unanimously affirm
ed that decision. and upon the appeal to
the court OF appeals this latter court was
divided three OF the judges deciding with
you that the facts admitted. furnished no
ground for relief and threa dissenting.
you referred to my cause Of action as
a so-calied right of privacy and admitted
that such publicity. which some find
agreeable Is to PLAINTIFF very distasteful
and that suffered mental distress, when
others would have appreciated the compii-
ment to their beauty. and in an opinion
sixteen pages long you arrived at the con-
clusion that had no rights that could be
protected by your tribunal
ITO be perfectly fair to you. l ought to
say you expressly excepted from the effect
of your decision any publication under SIM
liar circumstances which was In its nature
libedlous.
"It necessarily follows. therefore. when
you now say that you reserve the right
not to be photographed with your hands
in your pockets or In other comfortable
attitudes, either that you are asserting
right for yourself and your family wf1eh
you are unwilling to accord to htigants
before your court or else that there Is
something In the attitude suggested OF
such nature that q reproduction of It with
Photographic exactness would be neces-
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27
LONDON CHESS TOURNEY.
1nsnsh Masters Competing for the
Championship.


me masters tournament of the City Of
LONDON Chess Club opened in London Mon
Gay night with seventeen native and resi-
oeht experts. including W., E. Napier of
ne" York. who is English by birth The
Famous international players. ]. H. Black
ourhe' II. Teichmann. James Mason and
tsioor 1unsberg. are also competing.
All the other thirteen are men OF reputa-
tion' VIZ: F. Brown. A Curnock. w. H.
Gunston. +. ]. Lee, p. 8. Leonhardt, r..
Loman; A J. Mackenzie. ]. Mortimer, O.
=. Muiief. n. w. Shoosmith. c. E. c. Tat
tersail and L. Van Vliet. Sir George
ana the chief cash prize of $50 was present
TO formally open the meeting
IN the nrst undeNafter won from Ma
SON Gunsberg defeated Leonhardt and
Shoosmith outwitted Mortimer. Drawn
games resulted from the encounters be-
tween Gunston and Curnock. Muller and
Lee. Islcnmann and Van YEet. The Black
ourne-Iattersall and yBrown-Loman con-
tests remained unfinished and were adj
tourned. Mackenzie mad a bye
In the second round last night the ex-
perts were paired in1theB following order:
mackenzie VS.. Gunston.- Curnock VS.. Nor
timer, Shoosmith vs.. Muller. Lee VS.. Ma
son, Napier vs.. Blackbufne. Tattersall VS..
BroWn. Loman vs.. Gunsberg. Leonhardt VS..
Teichmann Van Vliet a. bye
All the eight games were played TO con-
clusion' TWO being drawn. viz those be-
tween Lee and Mason and Napier and
beat Gunsberg. Leonhardt beat Teichmann,
Mackenzie beat Gunston, Curnock beat
Mortimer, Shoosmith beat Muller and Tat
tersan beat Brown
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27
MertZ and MertZ Co.
900 F Street.

sarily libeEous. 1t is not apparent how your
likeness in the attitude suggested could be
libellous, at least not long you kept
your hands In your own pockets.
Miss Robertson points out that in her case
she never courted publicity and was a per-
son in whom the public could have no in
terest. while the Judge. on the contrary is
in the attitude of one soliciting the suffrage
of the American people. and has thereby
invited the curiosity repealed by herself.
and she is more entitled than he to the
right denied her. but now reserved to HIM
self. She adds:
IF you will reread your opinion you will
discover that you laid down very clearly
therein that you have no cause OF COM
plant against these gentlemen armed with
cameraa They are acting strictly within
the rights reserved to them by your de-
cision.
I'm effect you contended that the rights
Of one who obtains a likeness sufrpeti-
tiously are superior to those of one who
buys the right to use 1t for one purpose.
but uses IL for another. Naturally the
camera fiends feel licensed to annoy your
self and family in the manner in which
you yourself suggested, at least within the
borders of this state
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27
ROYAL ARCANUM LEAGUE.
District Council Beat Nationals il
Close Came

Teams representing the District and Ma
tional councils of the Royal Arcanum
League played an interesting game Of ball
the White Lot yesterday afternoon. the
former winning by the score of to 6.
Both teams played good ball and the game
was not decided until the last man was
out in the ninth inning. The Districts play
the Radfords on their grounds. I'd and R
streets northwest. this afternoon. and an
interesting contest is promised. as both
teams are composed Of good material.
The score:
District. ............ II
National. 8 U IN
Batteries-Distrlct Mcknight, Handiboe and
Hunt: National. Wolf Finnegan and Seitz. Um-
pire-Mr. Medford Double plays-HandibOe to Nc
Knight to Clark; Seitz to Finnegan to Seay.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27
Trouble in Giants Camp.

From the New York Journal.
Rain caused a postponement of the games
both at the Polo Grounds and American
League Park yesterday afternoon The
fact that neither Devlin nor Mertes was to
nave played with the Giants yesterday
caused rumors that there was some diff
Guilty between those players and Manager
McGraw but they could not be verified.
Devlin was reported to be injured" and
Mertes under the weather. Devlin was
all right when he arrived from Elmira yes
terday morning.
Roger Bresnahan was wired yesterday to
Toledo to report at once. He may possibly
arrive in time to play today.
If Devlin Mertes Is not able to play
this afternoon probably McGraw will go to
third and Dunn to left.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27
BUILDING ASSOCIATIONS.
Officers Annual Reports Show Popu
larity Of the System.

A dispatch from Sault Ste. Marie. Mich.
last night says: The annual convention Of
the United States League Of Building and
Loan Associations opened here today.
Mayor James L. Lipsett delivered an ad-
dress OF welcome at the opening session.
and then followed the annual address Of
President James Clarency OF Philadelphia
and the annual reports Of the other ofAcers
of the league.
President James Clarency of Philadelphia.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27
MURDER OF TWO MISSIONARIES.
France Demands Full Reparation From
China for the Crime.

A cablegram from Paris last night says:
The Temps correspondent at Tientstn
says the French government. as protector
of the Catholics in the far east, has or
dered Its Picking legation to demand full
reparation for the recent murder OF the
two Belgian missionaries. Bishop YER
happen and Priest Frederick Verhapen,
northward OF Ichang.
cablegram from Picking says: No de-
tails have yet been received here OF the
recent murder by Chinese. near Ichang.
In the province Of HUI Peh. of the Belgian
bishop. Mgr. Varhaegen. and his brother.
the Rev Theotinus varhaegen. II is not
supposed that these acts were connected
with boxerism. but rather that they were
the result Of local riots.
recent dispatch from Shanghai said
that 200 Chinese soldiers had been sent
from Ichang to the scene OF this outrage.
This dispatch said also that these muir
ders had occurred near Singanfu.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27
Laurel Team Wants Games.

The Laurel base ball team has recently
r,organzed and desires challenges from the
bsst local amateur teams. Their first open
date is Saturday, July 80. when they would
Ike to play on their home grounds The
Laurel team is composed principally of ex-
college men and is putting up very strong
game. as the record Of six victories and
no defeats testifies. Challenges should be
addressed to R. c. Harley at Laurel, Md.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27
Library Boys Defeated the Woodward
& Lothrop Team.

The Capital City League had out the
Woodward & Lothrop and the Library of
Congress teams yesterday. the latter win
ming a loosely played game by the score of
II to Is. The Library boys did the best
batting and fielding but the margin was
small over their opponents. The field was
muddy. which accounts for the poor field
ing only six innings being played in con-
sequence. Clabaugh did the best hitting
for the Woodward Lothrop team, getting
three nice singles while Burhans, Downs
and Kaufman were the leaders for the LII
hra
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27


clement weather. several of the members
remaining home on this account. An ex-
hibition game was played after the let-up
for the benefit of the large crowd of spec
tatOrs who had gathered to witness the
contest. The Takoma team Is scheduled
to play the Wheaton base ball club at the
Forest Glen picnic grounds for the cham
pionship of Montgomery county.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27
AMERICAN LEAGUE GAMES
Chicago, 4; Boston. 8.

The White SOx defeated the CHAMPIONS
in the first game of the home series at
Boston yesterday afternoon With the.
game well in hand. Boston did some Door
fielding In the last inning. and coupled
with timely hitting. Chicago scored the
necessary runs. Altrock held the cham
pions down to three hits outside of the
sixth inning, when a triple. double and
three singles netted the Bostons three runs.
The
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27

First base by errors-Sixth 4: Wesley. 7. Left
ON Harries. 8; of kettler. Q. Struck out-By
Harries. 1: by Kettler: g. Three base hitler
bert. Two-base hits-Rider. LIE Foe. A. Macdon-
aid and D. Wood Stolen bases-Rider. Cheseldine.
Lynham. lie Foe ~. Kettler Quantrelle q, B.
Wood and Champion (2). Double play-L. Sterne
nassisted). Hit by pitcher-By Harrles. 2.
Passed balls-Le Foe. LYMAN (9 and Champion
and 35 minutes
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27
Benefit Game Friday. .

The base ball game between the Hahn &
Co. team and Olympfcs which was sched-
ulsd to take place last Friday was post
poned until Friday Of this week on account
of wet grounds. The game is for the bene-
fit OF N. E. Hoistkamp. the popular anna
teur player Of Georgetown. who had his leg
broken In a game between the above teams.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27
Standing Of American League Clubs.
Standing of National League Clubs.

The dOwnpour of rain yesterday afternoon
about o'clock that swept over the upper
part of the city made American League
Park unfit for ball playing. and the game
Scheduled between Washington and Cleve-
land was called off. The two teams are
playing doubled header today in conse-
guence.
Manager Barnard of the Clevelands and
Manager Donovan of Washington also made
arrangements to play second double head
er on Friday. SO that the two teams can
leave here Friday evening and get to
Cleveland in time for a game there Satur
day afternoon Saturday is a big day in
the west, and it looked like too good a
business proposition to let the opportunity
slip by without entertaining the big crowd
that is expected when the Clevelands return
home. The Blues have been going at a
splendid gait of late. and the Cleveland
people are anxious to show their apprecia-
ton.
In this afternoons games Patten and
Donohue faced each other In the first
game. while Jack Townsend and Bernhard
will probably hook up In the second.
Tomorrow the greatly discussed Sunday
School League game with the Senators will
be pulled off at American League Park. the
Cleveland management being persuaded to
stand aside and witness the fun. The thou
sands of followers of the Sunday School
League in this city will turn out to cheer
on their favorites, and 1t goes without say
ing that there will be plenty of sport at
American League Park tomorrow after
noon. The gates will be opened early, so as
to allow the enthusiasts plenty of OppOr-
tunity to see the players of both teams
practice.
Umpire Belts. who will have charge OF
the Sunday school team, has ordered the
players to report to him at the Ebbitt
House tomorrow afternoon. and they will
be taken to the park In the hig hotel
omnibus
The players of the Sunday School Lea que
team have not been finally decided upon as
yet. but the chances are big that the two
teams will line up follows:
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27

First base on ballS.On BurIingame, 4; Oh Buck
inghum. 1. Struck out BY Burlingame. 3; by
buckingham. o. Three-base hit-Venable Two
base hits-Gates and Hughes. Sacrifice hit-Har-
desty. Stolen bases-Sprigman (2). Hughes t2).
Hoffman,, Powers (2l, Venable and Greaser. Dou-
BILE play-Hughes to Tenable to Sprigman Hit by
pitcher-By Buckingham. 1; by Burlingame. 1.
Passed balls-Campbell 2. Umplre-Mr. Dunn.
Time of game-1 hour and 40 minutes.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27

First base BY errors-Idbrnry. ): Woodward 4
Lothrop. 4. Left ON bases-Lfbrary 0: Woodward
& Lothrop, g.; First base on balls-On Hirshber-
ger. q: % Allison. 3: on Oyster. 4; on Berhans.
Twobsse hits-Downs ~. Kaufman. Stolen bases
-Hirshberger 3D. Barnes, Allison. Bradbury
Ready. ThOrnett. Waters ~. Kaufman CO. Oyster
go. McDermott. Sullivan. Hit by ptcher-By
Hirshberger. 2; by Oyster, l. Wild pitches-By
Berhans, g Umpire--Mr Handiboe Time OF
gnme-l hour and IL minutes.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27
German Chess Masters Tourney.

In the sixth round of the masters tour
nament OF the German Chess Association.
contested at coburg, Germany. Monday,
Bardeleben won from Berger and Swider-
SKI from Schlechter The Fleischmann-
GottschaHL Bernstein Suechtin& Caro-
Marco and Mieses-Wolf games were all
drawn.
In the seventh round played yesterday,
Wolf defeated John, Bardeieben won from
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27
Detroit, Q; Athletics. 1.

Killian pitched grand game of ball at
Philadelphia yesterday afternoon, holding
the Athletics down to four hits in the first
eight innings. three of which were made by
Hartsel In the last inning the Quakers
avoided shut-out on three singles. The
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27
A Bat for Every Run Scored.

Mr.. j. NJ. Truesdell announces that he
will present cane-wrapped bat to every
Church League player making a run to-
morrow In the game played by the Church
League with the Senator'S
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27
SUNDAY SCHOOL LEAGUE.
Standing of the Teams.
Games TODAY.

White Lot-St Adams vs.. st. Stephens.
Mt PIeasant-Fourth Foundry.
Van Ness Park-Mt. Vernon VS.. Mt. Pleasant
Methodist.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27

Two base hit-Wahler. First on balls-On Wah-
Ter. l. First on errors-Mt. Pleasant Methodist 2;
Gcriey. 3. Left on bases-Mt. Pleasant Methodist
D: Guriey. 3. Sacrifice hits-Wahler. Beal Fillius.
StoleE bases-Iord. Woodward (2). Struck out
BY Haring. II: by Waller. 4. Passed bsll-Beau
o.. Wild pltch-wahler o.. Umpire-Mr Belts
Tiue-1 hour and IS minutes
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27
Shot Down in Street by an 1nesriate.

Shot Down In Street BY an Inebriate.
dispatch from Biuefieid. w. Va. last
night says: w. F. Caudill was shot and
fatally wounded at Hallsville today by John
Muse. Muse Is dope" fend and was
drunk and met Mr. Caudill on the street
and asked him for a match. Caudill felt
In his pockets for a match. remarking that
he would give him one IL he had II. Muse
replied that he had wanted to kill some man
for a long time and then fired the shot. The
shooting was without any proyocation
whatever.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27

Suechting and Swiderski from Fleischrnann.
The games between Marco and Mieses.
Berger and Caro-, Gottschall and Bernstein
were drawn Schlechter had a bye. Fol-
lowing are the scores of the competitors
IN date.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27
Rain Prevented Yesterdays
Washington-C Cleveland Game.
DOUBLE-HEADER TODAY
GREAT SUNDAY SCHOOL LEAGUE
CONTEST COMES OFF TOMORROW.
Brighton Beach Races-Grand Circuit
Trots-High-Class Tennis
Base Ball Notes.
American League Games Today.

Cleveland at washington-Two games.
ST Louis at New York-TwO games.
Detroit at Philadelphia.
Chicago at Boston.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27
National League Games Today.

Brooklyn at New York-Two games.
Philadelphia at Boston.
Cincinnati at Chicago.
ST. Louis at Pittsburg
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27
Game Postponed.

The Takoma and Kensington base hall
clubs were scheduled to cross bats yester-
day at Kensington. but owing to the rain
the game was postponed by the managers
until next week. The teams did not muster
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27

at the post The time was .Os 2-5. Four
favorites and two second choices landed
the money. The attendance was 10000.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27
CAPITAL CITY LEAGUE.
Standing Of the Clubs.

Today at $50. White Lot east diamond Library
of Congress vs.. Turner Athletic Club
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27
Yesterdays National League o.msA

New York Brooklyn-Wet grounds
Philadelphia. 4; Boston T.
Chicago. 3: Cincinnati
st. Louis O; Ptttsburv 4
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27

'Batted for Powers In eighth inning. tBatted
for Plank In eighth inning.
Detroit. ............... y o o %
Philadelphia. .......... . D U o o II
base hits-wood. HsrtseIi Sacrifice hits-Grem-
niger. Pickering t2. Stolen bases-Crawford
Left on buses-Detroit 7: Philadelphia g First
base s,, on balls on killIan. 3. Struck out-By
kuhan. .. Wild pitch-PiHnk. Umpres-Nessrs
King aud o'Loughiin. Tune OF game~f hour snJ
As minutes ~ ~' ~"
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27

Earned rnns-Boston. Z; Chicago. 2. Two-b
hits Mcfarland ~ and Ferris. Three-base hit
Stshl Sacrifice hit-Davis Struck out-By Tan
nehili. 2 by Altrock. =. Umpire-Mr Connolly
Time OF game hour and 81 minutes
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27

All-Sunday School
Washington. League.
Coughlin. 3b. Atchison. SIS.
Hill, IF. King, Id.
Cassidy. SIS. Herring. CT.
Stah lb. IGelaski. 3b.
O'NeLl. CT Hughes. 2b.
Mccormick. 2b. Langley. If.
Huelsman, If. Ball. IF.
CLARKE Gates, C.
Townsend, D. Wahler. D.
For substitutes Mr.. Belts has Speakman
for behind the bat and Sheckels. Harring
and Hutchinson to back up Waller should
he be hit hard r. Hoffman will be on
hand to go into the outfield In case of need
and the team has very strong look. Each
player will appear In the uniform of the
team of which he Is member. From the
sale of megaphones and bells down town
this morning there is chance of somebody
being put out OF business by the Sunday
School League followers. If the profess
SIGNALS show any signs of getting ratified
there will be enough noise made to make
one think sham battle by the local
militia is
Manager Donovan's injured leg has i'm
proved nicely in the last twenty-f four hours
but for fear of further injury he will stay
out OF the game for the remainder of the
week, Hill taking his place. Pitcher Hughes,
who came here from New York with an in
Jured knee. underwent a thorough exami-
nation last evening and his physician says
he will be able to resume work In a few
days
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1904-07-27

Hoistkamp is now at the Providence Hos
pital. The game will be called at 5:lo.
Indiana tribuÌˆne. (Indianapolis, Ind.) 1878-1907, 1904-12-05
Sretem feine gersnisnnsss
reiien an.

Seute tperben bon Der hiefigen Sail
aus cine Nnsabl Der b~erurtbeilten @e=
faneenen ibren gefimmunssorten su=
oefibrt peroen, Inn eben ibre reipet=
tiben Straftermine ab3ufben.
See Snpbsr, FER isiner3eit in bas
&efiaurant fsines 8ruoers einbrah
unb Der auf griudsn oeheIben psrbaf-
tet tpurbe, obne oaB berielbs cine Nb=
nung bate, baB es iein eigener 8rubsr
lei, Der i'm Der poli5ei iiberlieferte,
se6t FIR 1-3 Sabre in's 3udtbaus
nod Wi6iean Sitp.
Sobn &ilep, Der in Der Na1t beg
4. Stuff hsn &ablerpoli3iften 4iBmiler
idOb uno ben man ipdter Ginning uno
bes &aubes iiberfibrte. muroe alei9
falls 3u einem Sermine bon Is Sab
rem 3u9tbaus nerurtbeilt uno uiro
nit Gnpoer 3uinmmen Die Sahrt untsr=
nebmsn. Als Sritter i'm Bunbe pirb
Norian Saptuarb, bic &eiie mitma9en.
gu9 er erbielt einen Sermil bon 1-3
Sabren. 9apmarb NOR Der 6dli6ung
an9etlaQt. gr felte tleinere gbefs,
9em6bnli9 biz gum getrase bon etpa
$40 aug, taufte bann Waaren. bic er
on cine beftimmte NSrefe absuliefsrn
befabl unb lieB fid ben ueberi6ub in
8aarstlo bann surid3ablen unb Der.
f9wanb, Die polisei bate bereits
ldngsre 3sit nod benz Manne 9efabn.
bet uno nur our9 einen 3ufaa aeIan9
feline gerbaftung. a1e BRET @orae=
nannten tperben burd einsn Deputy
Sheriff nat ibrem Betimmunasort
iiberfiibrt tperben.
Ser Sheriff ielber miro eIeidfals
nit mebreren @efansenen cine @eiie
MAIDEN unb omar nod Seferionbille.
mo bieielben benz &eformatorium iiber-
liefert tperoen.
Sugo gntrid, tpeaea 8%ranbfiftun9
3u einem Sermin bon 1-20 Sahren
berurt beilt. 1T Der Manr,, tpelder feis
nerseit angebli9 ben Stall bes @drt=
ners Stisnefer on Der Of 8ermont
Str. In granb isbte. st ent3os f6
ieiner 0erbaftung our 3eit babur1,
bab er bel einem anoeren @drtner
SteGun9 nabm. wuroe iebod berbaf=
tet. als sr nod stteneder's plab auriid-
febrfe, UNI fsiner bort arbeitenoen 6rau
@elb 81 geben.