davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
Wiarus. (Winona, Minn.) 1895-1919, 1904-06-23
oDouooaoDopppoaooao
6 - CIEkAW RZECzY, 8

dotal AZ do kanalu. Mai ~ u
przeplyna6 przez 6lu Y ], &
BY kanalem dalej d q, sic
do Noteci, gdy stack jego Y
derzyl IA jakaS przeszlklode
j znacznie sic przedziurawiilll.,
DIugo ME trwalo, gdy wod u
zaczela sic gwaltem toczyc.
do wnetrza jego, v kt6rem
znajdowaly sic 1000 ce ''l1'tlr
r6w#cukru j W kr6tkim cza-5
sic stack caiy 2 ladunkSiieemn
zatonal, tax 10 wlasciciel "a
.ledwie poSciel j nieco #domo
wizny 2 kajuty zdazyyl wyra
towac. q szkuty starczy tylko.
daoh kajuty j HAWAI- pokladu
zwody. N1eszczesliWym ira
femsstatek ten zatonal ma po-
prick kanalu i wskutek lego
GAIA zegluga j sp}aW drzeWa,
zwykle W tym czasie bardzo
znaczny, az 90 usuniecia
przeszkody ustac musi. la
dunek byl zabezpieczony, tax
re tylko w1asciciel szkuty
szkode ponosi.
Wiarus. (Winona, Minn.) 1895-1919, 1904-06-23
$4,000 ARROW


Kolej Chicago & North Western
jest prosta 1iinia do Bonesteel przy
rezerwacyi. Kopia pamfletu Move
osady ma zachodzies zawieraiace
mapy j zupelne informacye co do
csatek tego urodzajnego gruntu j
jak je osiegn9c wyrobione przez
kt6regokolwjek agenta kolejiNorth
Western, albo xnstanie wyslany
pod kazdym adresemspo odebraniiu
dw6ch ca centowgvYch znaczk6w
przes A.C. JOHNSON s.
Gen. Agt. g 3 Ry..
Winona,Mmn
Wiarus. (Winona, Minn.) 1895-1919, 1904-06-23


Mlodzlezy stoWarzyszeh
Characterization ko6cio1aEpre-
ST. Joseph Nc. Czerwca
do Lipca 904
3 olejj ChiicugoG Great esternsod
g dose Cserwca wlac1nie aprze-
,daWadbbeedzie tykietyxW1roettne q
ce1ees ieeddlnleaj jaxdy 2.o0dossSt
lJoseeplh 5emffo,rmaloIyYl
Wiarus. (Winona, Minn.) 1895-1919, 1904-06-23


llEl a'sal dla poszulkIiWVasseszy,
P6lnnocno-zach16d
zach6d
EorazIItt'aaniie TatYdla kolonist6w
kolejaN orth-1W7 esten. Tylkiety
1eelx.lkk1uprssyjjne5sp Pc wielcesrniizofnlych IA
i1taach, sc y "A sprzed1az sdo, wye wy
n'enionJJch terytory6W Gl6vny
sPpoociagg waggony sypialne dls tury-
STOW, wo1ne krzesla ro.k1adanr 4
waggonach ,,Najlepszesz, e wszsystlkiie
&C. date gprzedazy zupe}}nule
55sltzzso,zzegg6ly xglosi6 sic do agensow.
.lkIlo1lei Chicago y North Western.
Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1904-08-18
GROWERS PLUMBING.
Sanitary Inspector Makes Discovery
AHd Swears Out Another Complaint,

Special Sanitary Inspector w. ].
korth has sworn out another complaint
against W. n. Cromer. charging him
with failing to connect his premises at
2t6 east Second South street with the
sewer. on April 20, Mr. Cromer was
served with u notice TO connect hls
premises with the sewer aud upon his
failure to DO so complaint was issued
against him On May l6 he took out
"A permit to connect and the case
against him was dropped.
II was thought that tie connection
had been made all right until ycster-
day when Plumbing Inspector l@nker
went to the premises to inspect the
plumbing, A dligent search on his
part failed TO disclose any plumbing at
all. a further search was made ard
II WAS found that the connection hgd
been made with the sewer main md
the pipe was run just inside OF the
fence and at that point the pipe waG
plugged up So that the connection
was merely "A bluff presumably, it Is
thought by the officials, to eyade The
ordinance. Mr.. Cromer viii probably
decide to carry the pipe little farther
and connect with the house by the time
his case Ia settled in court this tine.
Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1904-08-18
SLIGHTLY DIFFERENT.
Is the Story Told by Utah Fuel Non
Regarding N q, U. Incident

The local morning press was some-
what lurid today over an alleged at
tempt OF the Utah Fuel company TO
prevent by intimidation certain en-.
ployes, members Of the Guard. from
responding to the governors order to
30 into camp. Inquiry AT the Offices IN
thla city OF the Fuel company deyel-
oprs that in the general managers de-
pdilmtht no request from any cmploye
hdd btcn made for leave OF absence To
attend camp but On Auditor Evans de.
phluncnt there are three young men.
Messrs Shepherd, Pomeroy and Nc
'urdy, two OF the battery and one be-
longing TO the troop who are affected
10y the order. These employees have iust
been promoted. and are very busy cs-
tabllshng themselves in their new du-
ties, am breaking In three other clerks
10 MI the positions recently vacated by
mem. SO they voluntarily requested
MI Evans 10 use his influence to have
them excused Il possible from attend
ing camp, as II would greatly Interior.
with their work This Mr. Evans was
very glad 10 do as their absence would
reduce his office force 25 per cent at !,
critical tim, when ne was preparing
his annual report. He wrote 10 Captain
Webb OF the battery who referred him
to the governor, and Mr. Evans has
communicated with the governor stat
lng the facts.
However he says II the boys eau not
he excused why. he aud they viii have
10 make the best OF IT, and the remain
Ing clerks must labor nights to keep
the work up But he never had any
idea Of discharging them II they went
to camp, and their positions win be
kert open FOR them should they be
Obliged TO go.
Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1904-08-18
ITO THE DIVORCE JUDGE"
Strange Letter Received This Morning
From Absent Defendant.

According TO a letter received this
morning addressed to 1.-THE Divorce
Judge Josephine Lyons, from whom
Walter H. Lyons is seeking a divorce In
the district court, was somewhat sur
prised TO learn OF her husbands action.
Mrs. Lyons lives at Winthrop, Mass,
and says IN her letter that she learned
by accident that her husband had in
stitutod divorce proceedings against
her charging her with desertion. She
said that her husband was IN Winthrop
on Saturday. Aug, 6, and stayed with
her until the following Tuesday, when
he left her for Rumford Falls, Me, on
business
The complaint was filed IN the district
court here on May l6. 1904 but as the
defendant Is not resident Of the state
the summons had 90 be published so
there has as yet been no answer or ap-
pearance filed on the part Of Mrs.
Lyons.
She says that she has resided IN Win
thrOp for 10 years and denies that she
has deserted her husband. The letter
states that Lyons has been living with a
cheap actress in Salt Lake as his wife"
and that the woman is n divorced wo-
man whose nome IL IN RoXbury, Mass.
and her name is May Peters or Mrs.
Bigelow. She says that her husband
has taken ont some life Insurance in the
womans name She also said that she
has corresponded with her husband reg
ularly up to the time he came to see her
two weeks ago.
The affidavit for the publication of
the summons filed by Lyons states that
his wife was a resident Of Maine. IL
Is apparent from the letter from Mrs
Lyons that this statement on the part
OF her husband was absolutely false. az
she says that he correspondent with her
regularly and knew where she was ali
the time. II Is very probable that Mrs
Lyons VIII put in her answer 10 the
complaint and that she will make IL
rather hard for him to prove his charge
of dcsertion.
They were married az Brooklyn on
June 22 1898, and have one child. n
Is alleged that the dcsertion occurred
on Aug. 10, 1898 In her letter Mrs.
Lyons states that she and her little
son are heartbroken over the matter
and appeals 10 the court 10 not grant
her husband a divorce.
Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1904-08-18

at Lagoon Rolling barrel contest,
Wheelbarrow race, blindfolded foot
race, lOO-yard dash; wheelbarrow race,
tug OF war, ogden VS. Salt Lake
baseball Ogden va Salt Lake; broncho-
riding contest, ARIZONA" Joe We TEX
as" Dick; boat race. ogden VS. Salt
Lake bowling contest, ogden vs. Salt
Lake,
The lucky numbers at the Woodmen
outing at Saltalr Tuesday, with the
prizes drawn, are as follows. Prize No.
l. W. o. w. fraternal emblem. drawn
by ticket number 320i7; prize No 2.
soft pillow. by ticket number $1,000,
prize No. 3. w. o. w. fraternal en-
blem, by ticket number 80, 1855: prize No.
4, silver forks. by ticket number S4.05i;
prize No. 8. w. o. w. fraternal en-
blem, by ticket number 31638: prize No.
6, jewelry, by ticket number 32.42t:
prize No Il cigars. by ticket number
S2 I9s prize No. S. piano scarf. by tick
et number 80. s26. Holders OF the lucky
numbers may secure their prizes by
calling on T. w Lawson at the store Of
y. Auerbach &, Bro
Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1904-08-18
MOORE RESIGNS
FROM SAN PEDRO.
Locating Engineer Of the Salt
Lake Route Sewers Connec.
tion With Road.
GOES TO JACOBS new LINE.
He Has Accepted Position of Chief
Engineer for the Bingham Inter.
Urban Proposition.

col. Chas. ID. Moore has resigned as
locating engineer Of the San Pedro, Los
Angeles & Salt Lake railroad. and has
accepted the position OF chief engineer
Of the new Jacobs road to Bingham.
Mir. Moore is a very prominent railroad
engineer, having been connected with
the Burlington, Santa Re, Mexican
Central and others, and was the chief
engineer Of the Salt Lake & Mcrcur.
the task Of laying out the last named
road was one Of the greatest engineer
Ing ieats IN the county. Mr., Moore has
been with the San Pedro from its in
cepticn and for the last year had
charge Of reconstruction Of constructed
lines. Mir. Moore viii commence work
OF survey Of permanent line on Salt
LAKE < Bingham al once.
II is understood that Col Moore
handed in his resignation some time
ago, but It Was not finally accepted by
the San Pedro until yesterday.
Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1904-08-18
WHAT MCCORMICK SAYS.
Director OF san Pedro Says Hartman
Owns Half Interest

w. S. Mccormick, director Of the San
Pedro and the oregon Short Line h
I'm Arizona looking into a mine there
ON Wednesday he was In Los Angeles
and gave out an interview regarding
special dispatch from Los Angeles to
the San Francisco Examiner under
date OF Aug. II, deals with the sub
ject
Regarding the hitherto unsettled
question rs to whether the Hartman
interests are concerned IN the owner.
ship Of the Salt Lake railroad or not,
W. S. Mccormick, a Well known banker
OF Salt Lake city and a director I'm the
salt Lake Railway company stated to-
day I'm an Interview that II is an open
secret that the Hartman and Clark
people are interested Jointly in the
road, each party owning exactly half Of
the stock Of the road.
Mccormick has recently made a trip
over the already completed portion OF
the road, and states that IT Is expected
that the construction Of the line VIII
be finally completed by December /.
About so miles yet remain TO be con-
structed, part of which has already
been graded. The completion OF the
road and its opening to traffic will be
attended with elaborate ceremonies at
the point of juncture Of the two ends
OF the line and at the two terminal
points. The management of the Salt
Lake road expect 20 reduce the running
time between salt Lake and Los Ange-
les to "a hours.
Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1904-08-18
ROSCOE COMBINES BIG FEE.

II is said that one day, when Roscoe
Conkllng was beginning to attain some
measure OF success, he dropped into the
office of Charles O'Couor Of New York,
then one Of the leaders Of the bar.
whats the troubleY" asked the lat
ter, as Conkling excltedly paced the
floor.
'Ive Just been subjected to the worst
insult | ever received. This Is the
first time client ever objected to my
fee.
You know / defended Gibbons for
arson, and put IN some tremendous
work for him. He was convicted at
the trial, but we couldn't help Il, and
took the case TO the superior court and
we lost there tn IN on 10 the supreme
court and that affirmed the conviction
and he has been given 10 years Now
my fee only amounted 10 $4,000, and
the scoundrcl actually had the audacity
70 grumhle about il, saying it's too
high, What do you think Of that for
impudence p"
well" said O'Conor slowly "of
course you did a lot of work, and $4,000
is not big fee; but. 10 be frank with
you, MIR. Conkling, my opinion. found
ed on mature consideration, Is that he
might have been convicted for less
money. Success.
Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1904-08-18
A DOCTORS TROUBLES.

Capt John Rost, the physician who
has proved that common salt Is an ex-
celent remedy for cancer has brus-
que, unexpected sort Of wit" said a
surgeon Of New York
Capt Rost was for time In private
practise. He did well: he effected
some remarkable cures; but he had no
patience with the imaginary ailments
OF a certain type OF rich persons. and,
TO escape treating people who were not
really sick, he turned to original re-
search.
"A matron OF wealth was one Of Capt.
Rosts early patients. She was never
Ill., but eternally she feared that some
dreadful disease was about TO attack
her.
"One afternoon she sent for Rost post
haste. lie found her in a first-rate
health She was only afraid that, on
account OF the dampness, II might be
unwise for her to go TO the theater
that evening
"'Go by all means. II won't hurt
you, said DR.. Rost.
"Then he took his leave But as he
was putting on his gloves in the hall,
a servant called him back The wo-
man wanted 10 see him again.
"'Oh, doctor, she said on his return.
I wanted 10 ask you II ! might eat
some oysters after the theater.'
Yes, madam he answered gravely;
shells and all
Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1904-08-18
cA7' THE RESOR7S.
Observation-Disclosures

Today is Employees day at Saltair,
ana Indications are that by tonight
there viii be a big crowd at the resort.
Fii'y'sX prizes donated by local mer-
ehanls VIII be awarded the lucky tick
e. holders and during the day there will
Pc a bowling contest. guessing bee,
poy races prizes for the heaviest and
me handsomest men, dancing, etc. The
committee m charge OF the outing has
hol YET decided Just how all the prizes
sQall be awarded but they viii arrive
q an understanding this afternoon at
,he beach, when the announcement will
be forthcoming.
The Butchers ana Groccrs of Salt
LAKE announce that stores viii be clos
tl Cd Aug a. on which date high car
nyal VIII be held Accordingly house
yves are duly warned to lay ny sup
pnes next Tuesday on Monday eve
nng by way Of advertising the event
VI Wednesday, the Butchers and Gro
seIs Wlll indulge In a big and charac-
.et,suc parade through the business
lection OF the city. Appropriate cos
tunes ana floats win be among the
features The following program has
osen prepared for their entertainment
Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1904-08-18
ono woman Among the rbou,apau.

We received a lctter from Waycross Ga,
from q woman who had been troubled
with female complaint for d long time,
until she was reduced to almost a shadow
IL affected her mind she could not re-
member anything would get confused and
80 nervous and Irritable che could hardly
sleep. She described her case as one
similar 70 thousands OF other women
and then ends the letter By SAYING she
mad gained is lbs last month and never
iclt better IN her life. having no trace
OF her former troubles, slept well, and ate
her meals with relish She commenced
Tho use Of DR.. Gums Blood and Nerve
Tonic Just six weeks before she wrote the
letter from which We copy the above
This tonic is in tablet form, and should
be taken right after meals Il turns the
FOOD you cat INTO strong, rich blood
FEEDING the nerves and curing disease by
making healthy flesh. Sold By all drug
gists for Zoe. per box, or boxes for S.
Pale, weak, thin people should use this
Tonic. For sale by q. c. NJ. l. Drug Dc
partment
Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1904-08-18
NeYndn Branch.

The old Eureka & PalIsade railroad
running between Pallsade on the line
OF the Southern Pacific company 10
Eureka, is to be extended A party Of
surveyors is now at work IN the field
between Eureka and Ely, I'm White
Pine country. The work Il is under
stood. is being done under the direction
OF the White Pine Copper company.
NJ, l.. Requa ls the president OF this
company He is also the president OF
the Eureka q Palisade company. This
leads to the assumption that the cop
per company has a big body OF ore
and that the road IL 10 be extended 10
afford more economical method OF
handling the ore. In the event that the
Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1904-08-18
KING WAS CAUGHT.
Old Veteran Mournod Loss of Position
And Then Tried to Escape.

This is to be brief story OF how
Tom King, whose summer and winter
boarding place is at 100 east First
South, better known as the city Jail,
tried TO quit the place last night.
Some days ago Jallor Sol Klmball
placed King In charge Of the gang Of
TRUSTEES, with full power 10 act Tom
telt his position and acted according
~. But there came a time when there
were no more TRUSTEES. That was yes
terday, and Tom lost his position
He felt grieyed about II and tried 10
drown his sorrow with bottle of aloo-
hol. Then he decided 20 make his es-
cape from durance vile. He concluded
that the best plan would be for him
TO hide somewhere on the premises un-
an the sensation occasloned by his de-
parture somewhat subsidized. According
~ he hid himself In that portion Of the
basement set apart for the officers as
shooting gallery
Tom crawled into a space about n
foot wide, between a partition and the
stone wall. 1t required much squeezing
and hard work for him to get into the
place. but he finally succeeded and laid
him down for good long rest.
Early this morning Tom awoke with
burning thurst. lie tried to arise
but found himself held as though In
vice. He wrlggled and twisted ana
then began to yell for help. His cries
were heard nj last, and officer Sperry
and several other blue coats fastened
to Toms assistance Sperry took hold
Of the veterans feet, while officers
Johnson, Give. Furster, sullivan, seig-
fus, Armstrong, Davies, Jailor Kimball
and several others. got hold OF Sperry.
At the word "Hol" they began to
pull,
with the loss OF a pair Of overalls
and about yard Of cuticule. King was
at last rescued and carried up stairs.
~ won't do II no more Mr. Kinball,"
he said. and he won't till the next time.
Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1904-08-18
COURT NOTES.

Suit for divorce has been filed In the
district court by Rena Smoot against
G.. p. Smoot on the grounds OF nom
support. They We're married at Provo
on Dec. 90 1895, and have one child, Of
which plaintiff asks the custody.
Susanna Dqxey aged "a years, is the
plaintiff I'm a divorce suit filed In the
district court yesterday afternoon
against William DoXey, whom she mar
ried In this city on April 20, 1893. She
alleges that her husband Is IN the habit
of coming home In an intoxicated con-
dltlon and abusing her by calling her
vile names and violently shaking her
She asks that she be awarded their
home and also a reasonable sum as ALI
mony.
Judge Hall today granted Cordella
Piper divorce from Robert a. Piper
ola the grounds OF drunkenness and
failure 10 support. Mrs. Piper was also
awarded S25 per month as alimony and
$50 as attorneys fees.
Suit for divorce was filed IN the dis
trlct court today by Flora Stamps
Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1904-08-18

sure az 70 whether or not II came from
human being or an animal.
The deputies took about 10 feet OF
rope with them but It was not long
enough 10 reach the bottom Of the
shaft Deputy sheriff BELL was let down
IN by rope as the ladder I'm the shaft
waa thought to be unsafe. As his foot
struck the ladder It gave way and had
he not been held by the rope he would
have mot with serious accident. The
bottom OF the shaft, which was filled
with water, was dragged and the hooks
rtn against somethlng resembling a
body but as the rope was not long
the surface
Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1904-08-18
THEFT OF $40 BOX.
Results in Husband and Wife Being
Put in Another Kind Of Box.

Mir and Mrs. Thomas Foley are In
the city Jail charged with the larceny
Of boa valued at $40, the property OF
Proprietary Lydley, who conducts
roominghouse near the saltair depot
The Foleys were arrested this morning
by Detective Burt and officer sperry
1t is alleged that the prisoners store
the box several days ago from the land.
lady and attempted 10 snip II out or
town TO confederate When arrested
thls morning Foley said that some
man whose name he could not remem-
her brought the box to them and asked
them 10 ship II TO him az he was un-
able to take It with him. The woman
denied all knowledge of the affair Both
were locked up pending a hearing be-
fore Judge Dlehl.
Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1904-08-18

against Gordon Stamps on the ground
OF non-suppor. They were married at
Pueblo, Colo, on July "A, 1908. and
nave one child OF which plaintiff seeks
me custody She also asks that her
maiden name, Flora Perkins, be restor-
cd to her.
SUIT to forcclose mortgage on the
Marion group OF claims IN Big and
Little Cottonwood districts was filed IN
the district court today by james Cul-
IMAM against ". =. O'AIeara, adminls-
traitor OF the estate OF Joseph Marion.
deceased, ana others. The amount of
Judgment asked Is $1,000 with Interest.
Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1904-08-18
MINING CONGRESS
BUILDING SITE.
rho Council VIII Offer Fine Piece
NJ Ground for a Permanent
Home
oppOSITE THE JOINT BUILDING.
,..., License Agreement May Have
=" o,,o Reached-That Objectionable
ldycrtisement-0ther News.

n,.t'tah delegates to the American
,,a,os congress, who VIII leave for
n'.r,nd ON saturday evening to benz
o6ort 10 secure the permanent
""s ..,ters Of the congress for Salt
W., INV. win have the CITY council
ping them to the extent Of dona-
.s n a fine building lot for the Local
".o If the headquarters. The COM
",,,ocs on public grounds and finance
',no city council last evening decided
.,,ommend 10 the council that the
,ny. lot lust across the street north
.gho clty and county building be do
s.,oaasa cite for the permanent homo
:, ,bs congress, should II decide to
,,ne 10 salt Lake TO establish head
o.,r,ers The lot Is 6Oxl6t feet ana
,ould be an admirable location for
bu0dmg Of such a nature
LIQUOR LICENSE AGREEMENT.
II /, believed that an agreement has
s,,uy been reached IN regard TO the
smsnded LIQUOR license The commit
,tss on municipal laws and license
sosln considered the matter last night
ss8 heard the liquor dealers ana II
~ss decided to amend the ordinance 20
,b,t all saloon men, druggists ana res
wurant Keepers who want 20 transact
retail liquor business shall pay a
rslform license Of 81 200 per anuum.
Tbe serving Of liquor IN private wine
,ooms boxes or stalls IA saloons or
,,siaurants win be prohibited, Drug
rsis who do not want TO take out
Ttlall LIQUOR license viii not be prohib-
I,ed nom using LIQUOR IN prescriptions
Non restaurant men VIII not be pro-
hibIted from serving liquor With meals
10 their customers provided they buy
4 nom the saloons and do not make
profit on the deal The ordinance
In regard to prohibiting women from
entering saloons between the hours of
o'clock IN the evening and Z o'clock
n the morning win not be changed.
OTHER MATTERS.
The committee on streets decided to
grant the petition Of Whitaker and
Dallas, asking that an advertisement
or "a llNllT ullANAl 'iAdA VII Vll' " AliN ivy
waste paper boxes be removed from In
front Of their place Of business.
The public grounds committee will
80 out TO Liberty park tomorrow after.
noon at o'clock to look over the site
asked for a speedway track for fast
horses The Real Estate association
asked that such a track be constructed,
The offer OF W. G. Margetts TO do
the city's garbage work for sl,4i0 per
month and thus save the city about
EiW per year was rejected by the
finance and sanitary committees.
The finance committee referred 10 the
city attorney the claim Of the Home
Finding association for Sj6lO for the
care Of Elmer Rose, the infant child
Of Frank Rose who was executed for
the murder Of his wife The attorney
will be asked to decide as 70 the legal
ny Of the claim