The Pacific commercial advertiser. [volume] (Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands) 1885-1921, 1904-04-19

mated John Q. Lane.
w. II. Rice of Kauai moved the cleo
ton be with rising vote.
Mr.. McCandless moved for ballot
Carried.
Carl S. Smith of Hilo asked if proxies
should vote on this ballot.
John A. Hughes of the Fourth, Oahu,
moved that the proxies vote.
A. G. M. Robertson of the Fourth,
Oahu, thought they were going too far
ahead. They were liable to get into a
tangle. Only delegates present in per-
son should vote for temporary chair
man..
| Senator ]. ID. Paris of the Second,
Hawaii, did not think it was fair to
shut out the votes of the proxies.
| J. C. Quinn of the Fourth, Oahu, be-
iieved Mr.. Paris probably right, but
they must get started
| Samuel Parker said he had a proxy
| from the island Of Hawaii and claimed
the right to use it. How do we know
that Mr.. Robertson himself is a dele
gate? I have something to say about
that"
J. A. Low of the Fifth. Oahu. a few
moments before was in favor of Mr..
Robertson's view, but Mr.. Parker had
squashed his opinion.
Carl Smith insisted on his motion
for a committee on credentials. Mr.
Rice moved TO amend by having the
chairman appoint one member from
each district, and Mr.. Paris to make
the number seven. Thus amended the
motion carried.
Chairman Crahbe named Carl S.
Smith of the 1st Representative Dis
trict, H. l.. Holstein of the End, d. H
Case of the Srd, A. v. Gear of the 4th.
Henry c. Vida of the 5th. e. Olmsted
of the 9Th and Jos. A. Gilman at large.
A recess of ten minutes, which grew
enable the committee to prepare its re-
port.
THOSE FOUND RIGHT
The committee reported having found
the credentials OF ISL delegates in due
form, including twenty-six proxies, and
four delegates absent without proxies.
Following is a list of the delegates
with the proxies:
HAWAII.
First District.
Puma, w. H. c. Campbell; Olaa. S. |
G. Walker; waiakea, George Kaihenui, |
John Bohnenberg, c. N. Prouty; Hilo,
Charles Akau, William H. Beers, S. L.
Desha, M. J, >Gouvea, Carl S. Smith, |
William A. Todd; Papaikou, John T. |
Moir; Honomu, W. K. Andrews; Lau- |
pahoehoe, James Mattoon; Paauilo, AL |
bert Homer; Honokaa, J. w. Moanauli; |
kukuihaele, Charles Williams
Mr.. Prouty held the proxies of Messrs.
Campbell and Walker; Mr.. Smith, of /
Messrs- Bohnenberg, .>Kaihenui and
Horner; Mr3 Desha, the proxy of Mr..
Todd; Mr.. Moir, of Mr.. Andrews; Mr.
Beers, of Mr. Nation; Samuel Parker,
Of Mr.. Williams.
Second District.
Waimea, F. W. Carter; North Ko-
naia, HI. L. Holstein, G. P. Tulloch, E.
Fraser; North Kona, John Mcguire,
J. K. Elemakule, ]. NJ. Koomoa; South
Aona, j. D. Paris, E. p. Kamauoha, ].
(. Nahale; Kau. George c. Kinney,
George c. Hewitt, DR.. w. A SchwaIlie.
Mr.. Laau held the proxy of Mr.. Car ]
er; Mr.. Nahale, the proxies of Messrs.
Mcguire, Kaiilimakuli and Koomoa; | {
Or. Kamauoha, the proxy of Mr.. Kaai; {
Dr. schwallie, the proxies of Messrs. 1
Hewitt and Martin.
MAUI TX
Third District.
Precinct /, Mr. Van Lii and Mr.. :
sruns; Precinct 2. Mr.. Pahuku; Pre- l
met 8, S. Kapu; Precinct 4, r /
). Searle; Precinct 5, Henry Glib q
on; Precinct s. w. T. Robinson, w. Q
). Bal and D. H. Case; Precinct z, r.
Filler and w d. Hardy; Precinct s.
ames Scott; Precinct 9, David Nor @
on; Precinct 10. S. Kalama, G. H. Il
hickey and II. a. Baldwin; Precinct IL. a
7. f. Pogue; Precinct Il, John Kaiwi I
nd j. II. S. Kaleo; Precinct Is, George Y
: Cooper and NJ. H. Reuter-; Precinct G
!, L. Joseph. L
Mr.. Mcyeigh held the proxies of $,
-essrs. Bruins and Van Lii; Mr.. Case. a
lie proxy of Mr.. Scott: Mr.. Kalama. n
Mr. Baldwin; Mr.. Robinson, OF Mr. 60
ogue.
OAHU. 2,
Fourth District. ST
Precinct /. S. X. Kamaiopili, w. W. al
arris, S. NJ. Kanakanui, W. H. Char