New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1904-12-13
INDICTMENT IN EAST.
III Nay BE Found IN Suf0H COuntE.
Massachusetts,.

Although served with subpoena YESTERDAY
Andrew Carnegie on the advice Of his physician
will not appear before the federal grand iurv
in Cleveland tomorrow.
This viii probably mean that the grand fury
will be unable to file an indictment against Mrs.
Chadwick that day. and that IS the result
Saturdays hearing before United States Com
missioner Shields will have TO be postponed IN
definitely.
Dr. Jasper j. Garmany. the ironmsster's ply
siCian. certihes that his patient IS suffering
from acute 1umbago. and forbids his departure
The certificate viii be forwarded TO The United
States District Attorney Cleveland
In view OF DIT. Garmanys statement that
travelling In a train invariably makes M Car
negie i'll, it is more than possible that Mr.. Car
negte viii go 10 Cleveland at all thereby
seriously retarding, If completely blocking.
the various new forgery proceedings involving
the misuse Of his name
Mrs. Chadwick. according TO her counsel. will
decide to-day whether not she will waive ex-
animation and return TO Cleveland Meanwhile
she remains in the Tombs. and. according 70
Philip Carpenter her attorney, Will no longer
attempt 10 furnish bail
MAY BE INDICTED IN MASSACHUSETTS
a new indictment, which, IT was learned by a
Tribune reporter yesterday is now impending
is to be brought in Suffolk County Mass George
Ryan. counsel for Herbert B Newton. admitted
TO a Tribune reporter last night that IL was
mot improbab BILE" that such an Indictment might
be found on a charge OF grand larceny. Such
a course added Mr.. RyalI was under con-
sideration two weeks ago"
In reference to a recent assertion in the CIeve-
land courts Edmund ". Powers denied 10 A
Tribune reporter that he had ever had any deal
ings with Mr.. Carnegie.
I have never seen Mr.. Carnegie" said he
nor have ever been inside or near his house"
Asked If he had vouched TO Mr.. Beckvith to-
Mrs. Chadwck's securities Mr. Powers said:
Il was asked whether the securities were al
right. ard I replied that, in my opinion. they
We're but that Mrs Chadwick ought not 70 use
them"
Why should she not use them il they wer.
all right" was asked.
Il decline give my reasons for saying So
was the reply but they sufficient for me-"
Asked whether he knew OF any lawyers of IN.
same name who had represented Mrs. Chadwick
at any time Mr.. Powers said ne did not
While thus far Mr Carnegie has not been
served With a subpoena ordering his appearance
before Commissioner Shields. it is entirely prob
able that he viii attend. Asked about the ctr
cumstaHces OF the ironmaster's disability. Dr.
Garmany said 20 the reporter:
Il visited Mr. Carnegie. find that he vvas
suffering from acute lUrlbago- He has been par
ticularly susceptible 70 Iumbago. I advised him
that il would be extremely njudiciOus for him
to attempt 70 start on journey to Cleveland
and ne VIII not 60 I left a certificate at his
house. which i'll be forwarded Cleveland IN
due course
1t may now be safely asserted that Mrs
Chadwick Is under the surveillance of Inspector
McClusky's men night and day. and that should
she attempt 70 leave the Tombs she would be
al once Te9rresteti-
The summons upon Mn Carnegie was served
by William Elliot on behalf Of United States
Marshal HenkeI az the Carnegie home in Fifth
ave. The butler admitted Mr. Elliot and he
went TO the library. In a moment Mr. Carregie's
secretary entered. and the deputy explained
that his business was with Mr. Carnegie alone
The secretary thereupon withdrew. and short
time afterward Mr.. Carnegie appeared.
Elliot introduced himself saying: L the
United States Marshal of this district. I I'm
instructed by the federal grand jury OF the
Northern District Of Ohio to serve YOU with a
subpoena requiring your attendance in Cleveland
before the federal grand jury
SUBPOENA HANDED To MR. CARNEGIE
The subpoena was handed 10 Mr. Carnegie.
who glanced NJ It and replied: In Cleveland.
Ell? Um-1n Cleveland. Very we'll Mr.. Marshal.
very well. sir. Very nasty day out, isn't it7
Sorry to bring you way up here"
The subpla was later indOrscd on the back
as follows:
I. William Henkel. United states Marshal OF the
So11therr District OF \Aw-Nork. hereby certify
that ! have this cay served the within subpoena
personally upOn the within named person
The United States Court or grand jury sub
poenas run" as II is called. anywhere in the
United States. Mr.. Carnegie would have been
allowed 10 cents a mile way. FIVE cents
each way. and 81 80 day for his time. the time
being only counted for the days he was actually
before the grand jury. not for the time coming
and going.
General Henry L. Burnett. Cntted States Dis
trict Attorney IN discussing the case. said thar
the particular charge OF aiding In misappropri-
alton Of a banks funds under which Mrs. Chad
wick was arrested. was unusual one. The
NEW BUFFET-lI5RARY CAR.