The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1903-10-31
BOUNDARY NEUTRALITY-SUSPICIOUS.
WITH CARNEGIE, VINO DEPLORES
THEIR LACK or WELCOME.
The ironmnsicr Thinks Congress Ought
Ia Vote Ledge and Turner Thanks AT
Lcsst-EnKiand Would Have Made Elm
Peers--Turner on the Alaskan Award.


Lesst-EnEiand Would Have Made Elm
Peers-Turner on the Alaskan Award.
United States Senator Henry Cabot
Lodge and Senator George Turner of
spokane, Wash, two OF tho three arbiters
for the United States In the Alaskan boun-
Diary dispute. and Andrew Carnegie were
among the passengers on the White Star
liner Cedric which arrived yesterday.
, Senator Lodge. who left for Boston soon
after the steamer docked. said that he did
not think 1t would be quite within the pro-
pristies for him to discuss the proceedings
before the arbitration commission. Mr..
Turner wasn't 70 particular. He said
TO put it briefly. the whole case rested
on what has come to be known as the Van
couver narrative, the story of ths explorer .
travels as set down by himself. The Cana
dian claim was that the narrative showed
that Vancouver skirted the shores Of the
four islands near the mouth Of Portland
Canal and through the channel to the
mainland
These four islands are in groups Of two
each, with q channel between the groups.
Our claim was that the explorer reached the
MAJ inland by taking the short cut through
the channel between the two groups. Our
argument was that Vancouver, according
TO his own story. would not have had time
to roach his destinai ion had hs sailsd around
the islands.
Lord Alverstone, whose vote gave tho
decision TO the United States, Is an eminent
Iawvar with no wondorf,,liv balanced .
.,i,'a ui. -,
n" 90 80 NV. hS fiusp VI the
cor ct,sior n,'I,. US. a ,h ne Ieaened
p,o.t csr.Sni tnH INV. .he Iees' anu
who cnnrot - rnnvsd srnu, IL. . 80 = ~ na y,
;rsr;oo "a ~ r;aht -. ~ T. ~ 'eaeo Va
Of deen seat.d sS.tr,nt; ~. no w a~ - nian
rs,rd op Il abers w. 70 ha no,,id 1 ", aS ue
Enrio;oI $500 S1n ~ IN S So!u na>e anulu
EnnsSa rould bo ve o M h;s s una ca'"'
As Tor rho ' assa.t;on n's - ,o tSa n,nsa,,,
newsnan.rs that H. Jord Ch;.s nIstiaa
Of y, saed .laI sne iorb me, justice
VI ond ~ Gla a was Wo1 over oy the attentiohs
aat o n'' % sSs o. tnS Amercahs 'Le aile-
sa.iI" As aosuo &Eo an Hsuit 70 great
as a,,n pue a. mater , 81 .acs, .he shoe
sSors a,es sh Oh .he o'ne, Ioo.. LIIa
1870 snoweu us .ne at,entlons; ne
800 80. .ar i. w d. Hls Touatry PiAce Aio WIS
*, p"n.o W US IA AoIluoI'
- t Ing aWNo Vas IN accord with the merits
OF tLe case. ~ marks an epoch In In
t tI ma aruitra.ion and points me way
.oW s inc se.tienent OF disputes between
, nat'ohs oy ehe Hethoos o. peace. from
doD;a tl,no INC MsuinSh's oesan uhsn the
decision was render 90. the best Of FEELING
prevailed and the ret usai OF the Canadian
commissioners 70 sign the award had MOTH
ns VI tne pei sonal eleineht IN IT, IL was
ai! Tnicial act, pure ana simple.
Inc TWO STANDS neaTeS to Portland
Gt.lne', ".noA tns a"arH gives 70 the
rom q sIateglc Polnt OF view. ihoy are
, n,a' uns ni,sish Icluinoiah shore. about
IVY ahu n.,n hnos from the MAINLAND,
an a. AZ eiiiie VI wa ~ might DC annoying 10
r Ios a. " 70 nass IA uniF'ehoiy rover
Rossesseu VI Dase 90 near thelf shorss'
c =, oe MI ra; lsrhs o; 1ne new tans
pnr, S;ro',.,,, 49, 'nouu pe tocateo ~
t rort oimpson, almost opposite the islands,
H. 49, Car saHe Tn eGinerfial vaaue.
M. m S SaIineein ooheu az vigorous ae
sudu ss "a Suin IN, az WE a. tne pest OF spnHs
oi' ~ Its a. uA ~, nc an nnI my summer.
o,aIa "ts !us s,, n,sneo my eighty.nrst trip
rough weather hut I'll. sbin va an stasdn =.
I nrefer the steadv.onins art p' iGi .ran e
ne r. r. ~ ,ba sn,nrney ; Sesotian ond p
took a trir ever tn Irelond '--N '1'0"'
sT,e Irish are a ureat neon,a md now
that tLev lave tho 1and sct 10 Nv NV ro~
viii ba stil greater Won would ". , a,,:
prised at the changed feeling in Ireland
Toward England NV at hannna,
attended in Duhlip tis KIM nanee yv,s
cheered as Justify "A thew cheer n in Ena'
land ~ 49, 1s
What do Won tb,nk ~ tho A,osL.n
ayardp" Mr. Ca,n.ei, ,yas asLad
sIrn;nL This was rho answer. ss.no,or
Icdge and senator T,1rnar ara r.,',,';nr
home on thjs sbin NJ one IL hers ~ rnaaf
them. no demonst ration ia n,sda o,er n.bet
they did 90 much to accomnlish Ware
tbey ret,rnirr 10 EnrIa,J ns,Sn -
drne for her Hhst thae have dona fn a' thss
United States tbev wouId receixe ao ro ,n
welcoms ON their arrival and th.v " u r"yni
rnCeive ,narls ~ es,nn;oI ta,,r =, .o ~
hands Of iber K;na Tha pras;d,ns ,a .n.
maise n ,kes and f.ords ort 90 than, eI h,,t
rnngrees can Give them w and thair ~
10 y,,es a vnta - ,barts uh;ah - vi
H,Igbt 10 de- nj tho first n,'n " rtu,;,, s'ose
What about NJ, Iban,,,.-la;n,a .,h
-, rrasaror,iai tar;nys5s Ne i $1,000 sdlleliie
askad "''o
srha nror,r.,,,,i .oris Go. hoco,o.
IL Gne.i.iai .aL ~ iol the oolonies,
repned 'he Tonmaster, rs not new eT-
same thing in 1924, and an international
tariff war was on Britain capitulated
N we could win a corteet lilo INT ~ r.
da-s of o,,r vn,,tb dn Co. va. Al .iie
Nay VI In yoo"i, ~ yp,' 'lhiih 'uere ls
any meei 10 lear .Ie rssIt In the Gays OF
% .n MJt vo,I h ~. rI a1,,.,tin r,.
,bo Cri, rso ~ ,a shi ie "a slAnu aoor'
.Oh ro., ,,.a ~ haor ,JlnPalyf
,;p,o Lar,ro /, oar,a rb,n Lara,. et,o