The Providence news. (Providence [R.I.]) 1891-1906, 1903-03-12
cont,nued from page One.

Continsed from page one.
NJ T2rovn stated that the bill came
before the house in its present form as
n had been stated by the attorney Tor
the unian BARRIERS the bin. IT applied
10 the tswps, would not pass. The pro-
vis,on including the towns In similar
bnl caused the defeat Of the bill last
year.
Mr.. Maroney took issue with the last
sneaker and said the attorney was not
correctly quoted.
Mr.. Brown reiterated his statement
A MACHINE MEASURE.
MFR. Mccarthy asserted that the Dill
was n Republican machine measure anu
n was drafted and presented by la"yeI
who was a state office holder ana VINO
was TO get fee for what he had uohe'
aarhans an proportion TO his service.
Ne asked Mr.. wilbour " he had any
aennite knowledge OF the statement mace
as 10 the contracting OF disease In OAR
ber shops in Providence.
MIR Wnbour replied that he was repeat
ing what had been stated 70 the COMMIT
tee.
Mr.. Mccarthy asked II Mr.. Wilpour hau 't
made any Investigation 10 satisfy hii'iSe"
of the truth OF the statement
Nj. Wiibour replied that he had not
NJ McHugh stated that the bill In the
suhstitute form had been submitted 10 tne
harberx' representative and had oeen ap.
,rovad. He said that Or. Swarts ana
other physicians had favored the OH, -,
Mr. Mccarthy maintained that tne on,
was framed for the purpose OF os,ensioly
Forcing the minority into PVS''V"
approving the bill. ~, ma.
Judge Johnson asked why the Dill WAS
termed a Republican measure
MR.. JOHNSON ANSWERED.
A. prowr said IN reply that It was a
pSnubiican measure, for IL was the only
,,,ea sure that a committee that conslstyl
of ave Republicans and two DeinocI aes ",
had reported. He said that 'ne sorte pore ~
the committee on what We're l,npoI M 'enI s,,t
labor matters, such as the lO-hour m mplil
for street railway operatives ana .iIe
like, was FIVE Republicans agalnsl .ns 80.
I. porting the bills and two Democrats lot
Mr. Murphy spoke at length In tavor Oh
Mr. palmer believed that the bill was
we'll conceived and he had no oblecuon 70
a. applytng to Cranston provided there
Mr. Carroll charged the majority anc
the COMMITTEES on special iesisiaur15n ,ar5ny "I n,
the bills that were OF state inPoI P. .anoe ~
and attempting to further measure a .na
was intended to operate In cluesi Gspr Ispnr
sihlv in the interest OF organized iapor
He would vote for the bill, but ne pro
tested against the utter inconsistency ~. -
the majority in attempting TO IoIce a un'
minority into position that IL oid no
occupy. ,,,or,r,Sr
Mr. Nolan spoke In a similar line advo
eating the bill. but protesting against tht
bill IN the form OF class legislation.
Mr. Mcdonald Mr.. Brown, Mr. NC
Carthy. Mr.. Aldrich. and Mr.. Murph,
took part in the debate and then TN
amendment was lost on ron cal voe'
by 80 TO 81. Mr.. McHugh VotinB aSai9
the amendment.
Section was then adopted
Mr. Aldrich presented an amendment u
section In effect providing the board Q
examiners shall be elected as provided o.
the hin and In no other way. He said ina
in doing this he did not believe ,ne hcTs s,s
should delegate TO the senate any onie
the governor had no authority 10 nj
such elections should be made In gran
committee or not at all. lie SAID ther
was a question now as 10 the legality
each election by the senate.
VOTED DOWN.
On a roll call vote the amendment wa
iost by a vote OF 81 TO 90. Mr.. McHug
nzair. voting against the amendment.
Sections 2 g. T. 3 and were adopte
without further amendment
Mr.. Fitzgerald offered in amendme'
10 section providing for the advertiser
of notices OF examins tions In same dai
newspaper. which was lost by vote
80 10 :6.
He also made amendment 10 secti
4. changing the phraseology OF the secti
which was adopted, as was the secuo
To section Mr.. Fitzgerald present
an amendment embodying the featur
and provisions OF this section. addi
that the applicant for registration sh
file a certificate by physician that [
applicant Is free from disease; also pr
yiding that he applicant shall pay
of IS for all examinations
on motion OF Mr.. Aldrich the amen
ment was ordered printed and the hou
-, ynotion nv Mr.. Aldrich was adjourn