davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The Paducah sun. [volume] (Paducah, Ky.) 1898-1906, 1903-12-14
Chicago Court Imposes $1,000
Fine Against Union.
Says the Usual Warfare Made Against
Innocent Workers Cannot
Be Tolerated.
FIRST CASE On RECORD

Chicago, Dec. IL One thousand
dollars fine for illegal acts as corpo-
rate body was imposed upon franklin
union No. 4, Press Feeders, by Judge
Jesse Holdom Saturday. The court
found tho union as n corporation gull
ty of contempt Of court for violating
an injunction restraining 1t rs an or
gam zation from interfering with the
business or employees Of tine printing
firms, members of the Chicago Typa-
thetse.
Judge Holdom's action creates
precedent, it being the first time in
the history Of trades unionists in this
couptry that CONT has fined = union
as a corporation. An immediate APP
peal was taken from the action Of
Judge Holdom.
In giving his decision Judge Hol-
dom said
at appears that Franklin Union No.
4, a corporation, is liable to fine for
violation Of the injunction in this case
il but remains for the determination rs
to what the amount Of that fine shall
be. Punishment 10 melted out in &C.
oordance with the gravity OF the
ofYense committed. The consequence |
Of violation Of the Injunction by the
union have been many. assaults on in
nocent persons seeking to work under
contracts satisfactory to themselves
and their employers.
Continuing, Judge Holdom said:
There has been no discrimination
between the sexes. Women have been
assaulted and terrorized and followed |
to their homes, and their families in
undated. Murder has even resulted |
from the unlawful acts Of the union
and its striking members. From Aft
davits in evidence in this case. it APP
pears that more than 80 people have
been. since the inception OF the diff. |
culties set forth in the bill, assaulted,
intimidsted, called opprobrious cpl
thets and threatened with harm, sim
ply because they worked in place
voluntarily vacated by members Of
Franklin Union No. 4 all the alleged |
aggressors, with,.the exception OF John
Mucher. condemned twice for assault
and unlawful picketing, in company
with members of the union, in viola
tion of the injunction bill, has been
defended by the lawyer for the un.
ion"
Further along the court says: ut
would seem from the evidencial facts
that the action Of the union in the es
tablishing Of strike headquarters, the
payment Of strike benefits ct the strike
heAdq uarters by the union treasurer !
with the union money, and the fact
that no discrimination was made
against the members Of the union
known to be guilty Of acts in them. |
selves criminal. establish the union Is
a co. oonspirator with its offending
mem bers, party and privy to the viola
tlons of the injunction of which its
members stand convicted, and there
fore guilty of violation of the injunc-
tion and amenable to discipline fer
such violation, providing it can be dis.
oiplined under the law"
Again alludiDg to acts Of violence,
Judge Holden declares;
"Such warfare cannot and will not |
be tolerated by the courts IN land of
peace. where people are governed by
the law, and the law would be lacking
in one of its most necessary attributes
if it was impotent to punish for such
violation.
The Paducah sun. [volume] (Paducah, Ky.) 1898-1906, 1903-12-14
FAYORITE FAMILY REMEDY.

Frequently accidents occur in the
household, which cause burns, cuts,
spraips and bruises; foi use in such
cases, Billiards. Snow Liniment has
for many years been the constant ia
vorite family remedy. 25c, 500 and
81 at Dubois, Kolb & Go.
The Paducah sun. [volume] (Paducah, Ky.) 1898-1906, 1903-12-14
'Drys" Badly Beaten in Madi-
sOnville Contest.
Hardin County Officers Acquitted Of
Murder-Slight Cut Causes Death
Of a Tie Man.
NEWS FROM MANY PLACES

Mayfeld, KY, Dec. l4-Mayfield
Lodge OF Elks has been reorganized
following q resignation of all the Off
GERS. District Deputy Pink VARIABLE
effected the reorganization and the fol
lowing officers were elected; II. j.
Norman, exalted ruler; Rudy Nor
row, leading knight; J. It. Dism ukes,
loyal knight; f. L. Harris, lecturing
knight; J. T. McKeel, secretary II.
O. Neale, nsursr; BIC. Bowden and
E. s. Lowe, trustees. Strife and bick-
erings had orept into the local lodge
and as always results in such case the
lodge was divided. Now it seems that
all will come together on equal foot
ing,
The Paducah sun. [volume] (Paducah, Ky.) 1898-1906, 1903-12-14

ASSETS OF THE REPUBLIC.
(From the New York Telegaph).
The Republic Of Panama now con-
sists of NJ. Brunau- Vanilla, q junta. q
flag, a typewriter, q treaty and a gold
pen.
The Paducah sun. [volume] (Paducah, Ky.) 1898-1906, 1903-12-14
MARRIAGE IN GRAVES.

Mr.. Payne Howard, Of Pilot Oak,
and Miss Ollie Wright were married
yesterday at the residence OF the
brides parents, Mr.. and Mrs. Richard
WriSht, near Wingo.
The Paducah sun. [volume] (Paducah, Ky.) 1898-1906, 1903-12-14
COUGHING SPELL

CAUSED DEATH.
Harry Duckwell, aged 26 years,
ohoked to death early yesterday morn
ing at his home, in the presence of his
wife and child. He contracted a slight
cold few days ago and paid but little
attention to IL. Yesterday morning
he was seized with fit Of coughing
which continued for some time. His
wife sent for Q physician, but before
he could arrive, another coughing
spell came on ana Duokwell died from
suffocstion. st. Louis Globe Demo.
crat, Dec. 1, 1901" Billiards. Hore-
hound Syrup would have saved him.
25c, 500 and 81 at Dubois, Kolb & Co
The Paducah sun. [volume] (Paducah, Ky.) 1898-1906, 1903-12-14

When Your Heart
Fails to Pump Your
Blood, Trouble
Results.
Have Su heart trouble?

ItdNe yyu tiOubhCs
You have. II you find II hard TO breathe
after walking up stairs, exercising. etc.
II you have pain in your left side. in
chest. back or shoulder. II you suffer
from cold extremities. pale face. blue
lips. dry cough. swollen ankles.
II you have fainting spells. breast
pane. palpitation. redness Of the face.
discomfort in sleeping on one side.
The only scientific Treatment. for this
whole train Of troubles is DR.. Miles
New Heart Cure
DR.. Miles, New Heart Cure Is the
prescription of n famous specialist.
whose great success in treating obsti-
nate nervous heart disease has made his
name pre-eminent In the medical and
scientific world.
The medicine will cure you. We know
II. We want you to prove it. II first
bottle does not benefit. your druggist
will give you back your money.
81 have for several years suffered at
times with, heart trouble, l got 50
and had to sit up on the side OF the
bed lots of times TO get brea tn. Three
OF my brothers have died Of heart trou-
bic. and Thought / was going the same
way but about two and a half years
ago got a pamphlet about, about pri Miles,
try n few bottles. After using them
recovered, and have had better health
since then than before for several years.
/ can heartily recommend them for heart
trouble. REV. JERRY HURT. Pastor
Baptist Church, Hurt, kans.
EDEr Write TO us for Free Trial
e tGG Package OF Or. Miles Anti
Pain Pills, the New Scientific Remedy
FOR Pain. Also Symptom Blank. Our
Specialist will diagnose your case, tell
Won what is wrong, and how to right Il.
Free DIR MILES MEDICAL CO.,
LABORATORIES, ELIAiART, IND.
The Paducah sun. [volume] (Paducah, Ky.) 1898-1906, 1903-12-14
TO CURE A COLD IN ONE DAY

Take Laxative BTomO Quinine Tablets. All |
drug j. refund ,he money u il tails 10 cure
Il y. Gro.e's sisrauure ~ on each box b.
The Paducah sun. [volume] (Paducah, Ky.) 1898-1906, 1903-12-14
OFFICERS ACQUITTED.

Elizabethtown, KY, Dec. 14-Mar-
shall John II. Cundiff and Deputy Mar
shall William Boles, of Hodgenville,
who had been on trial in the circuit
court here since Tuesday on . change
of venue from Larue county for kill
ing Charles Jeffries Of that county
while resisting arrest, were acquitted.
The Paducah sun. [volume] (Paducah, Ky.) 1898-1906, 1903-12-14
THE WELL KNOWN

From the Chicago News.)
W. J. Bryan, the we'll known father
in.law of MIR. Lsavitt, passed q quiet
day yesterday.
The Paducah sun. [volume] (Paducah, Ky.) 1898-1906, 1903-12-14
LEGISLATOR is ILL.

Frankfort, KY, Dec. i4-Informa-
ton received here that the condition
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15

members. who enjoyed pitching their
tents on such i de'ightiul ana historic'l
old place. Miss Alary BToHNn ana Messfsi
among the campers.
from a summer outing With her ren-
tives in L-ewisbuFs' ". ~.
Mrs. John Basel is at Atlantic City
with her daughter, Mrs. l1iieinoh -,
Watson They arr dellshtiply i'e'p'eu
Miss Grace Lee Duncan left today tor
Z~lnesvile' Ohio. where she VIII ne one
guest OF Miss h@ee stanonry untlt ,ne
sister, Miss Columbia Duncan who mas
been spending the summer with MISS
Stanbury.
Miss Brown, Of Louisville ny, have re-
turned from a rev Gays Visit WIN Ni's
Mrs. Thomas w Pettigrew ana son
Charles. of Indianapolis are visiting MIS-
james w. Williams
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15

The get-rich- quick idea that mas seiz-
ed some of the denizens of Point Cont
fort since a few pearls have been found
in the West Fork river, is resulting in
much effort and little benefit. One fell
low gathered together two bushels of
mussel shells, lugged them home. went
through the pile carefully and found
nothing of valuc He might have made
wages that day ut something else, but
that would not have carried out the idea
and he would not have been satisfied.
The fruit of his labors that day, or
rather the lack of fruit, has most likely
cooled his ardor and he win be found
hereafter plodding along in the Gus
tomary way his living to earn and a
surplus to save. The man who does this
usually comes ont winner, while the
other fellow while away his time, wastes
his energy and comes out loser in the
end. The West Fork river is not likely
to make any one rich with its contents,
unless it be the wealth of water that
flows periodically. and then only when
the water is converted into motiyity.
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15

A Kansas woman who made her bus.
tie her mi thought she wa out OF
pocket to the tune of s7,3oo. She be
lieved she had lost her deposits on .
train, but returned home in time to save
it from being burned by tenants as rub
bisl,- Strange place for u bankl Strang
er still that she did not make the dis,
covery sooner! And stranger yet that
she converted a useless thing into some
thing of service, although there are per,
sons who take issue with the statement
tlrnt it is a useless thing, but they very
likely have a knowledge of such things
which warrant them in their estima-
ton of it, n especially may this be
true among tho feminine part Of the hu.
man race.
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15

The Italian ghouls at Adamston are
enthusiastic economists at least. They
don't ike to see anything wasted, which
is in the nature of something to eat
They are welcome to the. meat, but ev.
cry one seriously objects to the way the!
got it. The deed is too rePulsive d
think about and it is hoped they vii.
be taught by h more intelligent Of the
nationality not to repeat the horrifying
ast. :e3R
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15
END OF BITTER FIGHT.

"Two physicians mad a long and stub
born fight with nm ubcess on my right
lung" white j. f. Hughes, Of DUPONT,
Ga, "and gave me up. As a last resort
/ tried DR.. Kings New Discovery for
Consumption, The benefit ! received was
strikig and ! was on my feet in a few
DAYS. Now Tve entirely regained my
health" 1t conquers NIL coughs, colds
md throat and lung trouble. Guaran-
tecd by Frank G. BANDS drug store.
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15

Mrs. Caroline NJ. Jackson IS visiting
relatives at P~arkersburg.
Miss Mary Brown has returned from
Parkersburg, where was the guest this
week Of Mrs. Samuel B. stile-
George c. Lewis, who has been visit
ine his sister. Mrs. Moore jackson, re-
turned to Pittsburg Thursday.
Miss Lille Hart has arrived home from
a months visit in ParkersbTg, where
she was the guest of heF niece. Mrs
MF. and AIRS. Martz, who have been
visiting DR.. and Mrs. Bowcock, nave re-
turned to H~arrisonbmg, Va,
DR.: and. Mrs. Robert [. Morrison have
arrived home from a ten days visit in
Parkersburg.
Colonel and Mrs. Henry Raymond and
their daughter, Mrs. Benjamin r.. Black
ford and little Eleanor, of Petersburg,
are at the Seaside hotel in Atlantic
City,
Mr.. and Mrs. Clarence Parr are visit
ing Mrs. Arson d. Parr.
Mr.. and Mrs. George Lesutherbury and
family have returned from a delightful
D~ojourn at Ocean Grove.
Miss Sadie Baird, OF Wheeling. who
has been visiting her sister, Mrs George
q. oliver, has returned home.
Mrs. stephen Drummond and daughter
Miss jean, of Washington, Pa, are vis-
fling Mr.. Daniel Boughuer and Miss
Laura Boughner, on Chestnut street.
Mrs. Peter Koblegdrd has returned
from a delightful stay of several weeks
With her parents in Buckhannon.
MIR: and Mrs. Richard T Lowndes,
Danville. Ky, left Thursday for Deer
Park, and later will go to some seaside
resort before returning home.
Miss Jean Walker has been visiting
Mrs. sprigg D., Camden in Parkersburg
since the breaking up of the camp on
Blannerhasset Island, of which some Of
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15

While farmers institutes are not en-
tirely new in this state, yet they do
not seem to nave been sufficiently long
lived to awaken as much interest as is
desired. There is no question about the
benefits to be derived, and they are grad
urlly arousing the interest Of the farm
ers. There ought to be some way, how
ever, to bring them into quicker Popn
hnrity that the good they are designed
to do may be felt now and not ut some
time in the distant future. \ plan
should be devised to get he people ont
to them and to hold them after they
get there. Better programs and more ex-
~tensive advertising would help out con.
sidcrnbly. For instance. if the state
would secure several prominent agricul,
turalists, men known far md wide for
thcir knowledge and experience in this
pursuit, and have them tour the state,
attending instittttes in the various coun
tics, there would be a much greater inter.
est and the effect would be much more
beneficial. Again, a hindrnnce is the
season of year in which they are held.
When the farmer Is busy he is not going
to throw aside his work and go to thel
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15

The theft of a sewing machine must
have been a difficult thing to do, but
there are a lot of people we snow of
that would not let one come into their
homes as a gift. There is too much work
about it. The man who wanted a ma
chine so badly as to go to all the trou-
BILE he did, deserves to have the oPpor-
4unity to use it, though it be in the
garment department. of the state Peni-
tentiary.
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15

The duh season has reached its height
and the chronicles of society now con-
sist mainly in the comings and goinss
of those who make up the social circles
The seashore seems to be the most pop
ular resort for Clarksburgers. as we henri
Of them being registered at the many
attractive places along the Atlantic
coast, although mountains seem to be
dnly patronizcd as many are rusticnting
at Deer Park, Mountain Lake and Web
ster SPRING.. For the pleasure Of the
stay-at-homes croquet, tennis md golf
seem to be their daily diversion and the
last being more novel, is apparently the
favorite pasttime.
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15

institute, and he is not to be blamed for
for that. One of the great questions
with those in charge of the dates and
places for these institutes yet to solve
is the proper time in the year to hold
them. Careful attention should be de-
voted to this feature, in order that the
success of these Institutes may be Of
the greatest possible degree.
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15

The soldier boys are a brave lot of
lads, Us shown from the narrowing ex-
periences they had at Parkersburg. 1t
takes a heart of great courage to face
the. DANCES of that city, but nothing is
more pleasant to a clarksburger than to
30 1!p against the real stuff.
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15

THE state government evidently has
a poor opinion Of Parkersburg, since il
thinks it wise to assemble the malitia
of the state there once a year at least to
make demonstrations which are calcu
lated to impress the people of that city
that it is not safe to attempt to plot
against the whites,
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15

Easdridge county teachers, most all of
whom did not get No. l certificates, are
really happy because the teachers in
t4..s county did no better and are now
in the sans boat with them. Miser!
loves company and that is the reason
they are glad Harrison county teach
ers fAyed no better.
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15
The Traders Bank

is modern in every respect.
In our fire and burglar proof vaults
money and valuableS are perfectly
safe.
And by our system of cheques and
correspondents payments can be made
at a distance as easily as they can be
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15

II you need any harness for your
teams, no matter of what kind, you
win find it always on hand at Rcy
aolds, Main street. He keeps an up-to-
dae harness establishment, $50
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15

ward Wallis, Rev. and Nfrs. Hilary doodle
Jr., and baby, n Mrs. MeboWefi. of
Richardson's AIRS. Gibson Kuykendall, OF
Charleston, w. Va; Mr.. j. Hornor Da-
us. and Mr.. Hubert Il. Houston
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15
Iargsst Bona I'D esld CIIeuIatlOn!

The Democratic papers IRE booming
General Miles for the Presidency. That
is enough TO retire him to private life
n second time.
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15

This afternoon the Golf club was for
mally opened with n basket picnic ut
their links in Union Land park Mt 4:ao
O'Clock. Owing to the large membership,
numbering $50, there were no formal in
vltations isued, further than the an
nouncement in last evenings Telegram.
The members left on the street cars with
h1nch baskets and took their suppers in
old.fashioned picnic style, under the
trees of the big grove in the park. There
was a large number in the parry and the
members who attended enjoyed them
selves TO the fullest extent.
An enjoyable Finch party was given
by Miss Emma Davis on Tuesday even
ing to n few intimate friends. compli-
mentary to Judge and Mrs. Resin c,
Davis, Of Louisville, Nrs. Rash. of Bal
timore. and Mrs. John Preston, of Lew
sburg. w. Va. Finch was played at
three tables and the guests found their
partners by receiving from the hostess
mink chrvsanthemum. tied with pink
or violet ribbon. This novel and at
tractive game formed a pleasant diver.
zion until o o'clock, when delicious re-
freshments were served. The remainder
+ the evening was devoted to music and
several charmingg selections on the VIC
lin and picna were rendered by Messrs
Hubert T. Houston, John w. Davis and
Mrs. Gibson K~uykendall, Among the in,
vited guests we're MIR. and Mrs. Edward
Martz. of Harrisonburg, Va; Mr.. and
Mrs. George G. Oliver, Mr.. and Mrs. Ed
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15
Banking is Popular

with those who give a little thought
to its advantages.
Chief among these, of course, is the
absolute security afforded by the mod
ern bauk-and
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15

Going ont of business.
at cost, Wholesale prices.
COL w. Pike street.
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15
Persona1s


Mr.. and Mrs. Arthur Hopes left Fri
day for Point Pleasant, New Jersey,
where they will spend some time with
Mr.. and Mrs. LIppert, u P~hoenixvile.
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15

Invitations announcing the approach
ing marriage of Miss Mary Mcdonnell,
daughter of Mr.. and Mrs. P. +. Melon
nell. to Mr.. Walter Bolton Wilson, which
viii occur Tuesday, August %, at The
home of the brides parents on West
pike street, have been issued to the
many friends of both h contracting
parties.
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15

No DAILY TELEGRAM can be found on
sale at
showacrs-Bros. news stand. Pike: st.
Ed one's news stand. Pike Sc.
Traders Hotel news stand.
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15

subscribecs failing 70 receIve the DAILY
TELEGRAM regularly Wfn please make
sDeeisc complaint 70 this ONCE
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15

Miss Emily Garrard entertained a few
friends Mt cards on "Wednesday after
noon. The affair was in honor of her
sister. Miss Louise Garrard, of Indian.
apolis. At $3.50 punch, small cakes and
bon.bons were served in the dining
room. after which progressive euchre was
INDUCED in Mt five tables in the parlor
and reception hall. The floral deeofa
tions were hydrangias and golden glow.
At the close Of the game Mrs. Edward
R. Davis was presented with u Gibson
poster for having made the highest score.
Mrs. Elizabeth Hursey Vance had the
largest number of lone hands and pre-
sented her souvenir to Miss Louise Gar
rard. the guest Of honor. A bunch OF
golden glow was captured by Mis-"
Brown. of Louisville. Ky, in the form
Of a consolation prize.
Mr.. and Mrs. Charles b. Alexander.
Miss MIN Wallis, Miss Elizabeth Brown.
Of Louisville, and Messrs. steptoe and
Lynn S. Horror formed Il very pleasant
little party of picnicers nj the park on
Thursday afternoon.
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15

While 1t lasts.
Leonard Lewis,
nnl3.3t
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15
srrRsoRrPrIoN RATES.

tsatty. delivered by carrier. : 10 cts. per week
Denly. delivered by carrier. 20 cts.per month
DAILY. by mail, In county. 3 cts. PCT month
talk, hy mall, out of county. SIX Enono4aSs =
Daily. by mail, out OF county one year y
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15

George C.. Lewis, who has been visit
ing his sister, Mrs. Moore Jackson, re
turned to Pittsburg Thursday.
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15

Miss Roselle EstiiI has arrived home
a summer outing with her rela-
tives in Lewisburg, w. aV-
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15

Miss Jean Walker has been visiting
Mrs. sprigg d, Camden in Parkersburg'
since the breaking up of the camp on
Rlannerhasset Island, Of which some Of
The daily telegram. [volume] (Clarksburg, W. Va.) 1901-1926, 1903-08-15

Mrs. John Basel is at Atlantic City
with her daughter, Mrs. Philemon u.
Watson. They are delightfully."- located
ut Chelsea by the Sea.
The Dawson news. (Dawson, Ga.) 1889-current, 1903-07-15
CITY COURT SOLICITOR TO BE PUT ON SALARY
Bill Putting This Plan Into Effect Will the
islature by Representative Rainey

A bill will be introduced in the leg.
islature during its present session
amending the law establishing the
city court of Dawson so that the solic.
itor of that court will be placed on a
salary instead of the fee system now in
vogue.
Representative Rainey came down
from Atlanta Saturday to spend Sum-
day and Monday with his family, and
while here he announced that when
he introduced the bill to increase the
salary of the city court judge he would
embodY in it clause placing the So
lictor of that court On a salary and fix
ing his compensation, which he says
can be done without the necessity of
it, which would be the
case if introduced under a separate
head. This action will be taken by
Mr.. Rainey in Difference to a recon-
mendation of the grand jury and the