The times dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1903-1914, 1903-05-09

" - - =
MtMS q SOESCOl1fLLLbH2A
----------- -----------------
III, 80
Of the shunnaIe nc, case sroc .d was con-
hEh1H i i,ap and regular The Senator re-
S vIoWeS the record Of the cage Of shs
maze mate V9 be,ore re the Court Of Appeals. and
a1ou,nty .d p MI oven though it was read
d tuster court II had but given the appei-
in nan, q d de that grave md serious
im masiion se We're Involved, yet IN no way
iintSrferinr with the action Of the General
Asfcnssly S IN tns o far nm hour and half.
IA Al T; IL Sq IN oI,iyien Of many Of his fellow
sena tors. made one Of the strongest ar ar
1S,nnnr Giscnssion. He closed ut 2 clock.
and the chair was Immediately thereafter
vacated vac. until 4 p. NJ.
Closed ny W.T.. Mc'Fw"'''e.
The debate was closed ut the afternoon
session with the argument OF NE, MI NE Ne
l ,.ilwn,,,tione offered by six Of the Commit
49, fn,. Courts OF Justice, proposing q
Joint committee Of FIVE from each mouse 20
'a nr Ter DEFINING the Issues MIR. ;Mcllwa1ne
scharse,i that thep Constitution or virginia
had been in assasa rnd that not hs ce M
I'M s55anEar siocla Jared that Judge Camp
neil had in no way submitted himself to
f fronJ ~ he i,,dge's answer his protest
a .. all the procedure in tho House. The
Sneaker read from the answer TO SHOW.
e sad hat KS poaMer Whsn wf tRey
rho RI nterized 1t as a mere demurrer TO
e eini M IL those charges against
CnnnbelD should be proved the speaker
declared Tina t1at mt he W the evidence in the
case, he contendcd, is not such as to De
considered by the Senete hs bearers that
he would not argue technicalities; the
speaker quotcd from ana rer nd .en,, iin
argumentsaof his opponents, ana uook np
against ans the superylsors Il s Ea az Bae
county. III this connection no detethiGie e;i
eloquently the Court or Ap apnai, T T1dca
reviewed tho case, ana espeG 6a "a : uuE Ee
L. l., Lewis, than whom ,r,i ne sag sag he
had never met a 1llrn M in, NJ Ms,s ND
judges superior IN nigh eharh Ra s a,1a
citation had endorsed TINS es!ifinte oS
electing him It's president. ne HuoIJe a
from the opinion OF judge o LEWIS M, ues
IN violation Of the Const,1tion and e that
tho case was not considered on Its me iba
because was hela ny .ls TIVE cues
tons involved had already peeh aeclutu
In QUO warranIo prooeedlngS ,h 81 rs
VS., spilman me question mere off Tas ~ az
county Judge for 4 term that naa tiSo
PRED. The court did not pass upon t NE
constitutional auestion, nVSi sa bc cor .na
.ners moot Issue, and there could be n. no
lawful Judgment OF custer Although tne
court did not pass upon the constitu.
tional question involved in the case, AZ
did declare that those questions were
very grave ones: going to the very touh-
"a ''ot' = 81
impeachment and Removal.
Mr. Anderson asked why the Supreme
o ~ non stint law, and VIC had ad-
iudicated them. TO this Mr.. McIlwa!ne
quoted Cooley that tne G t,onait an
clded asainat me ~, ,vn" of nvnisa nee.
act II there De any WE, ,0 o. ~ r.s imdI.
cata was such a reasom u ia ayo ~ hstai,
Mr.. Mcll%aine then revleWsu ~ ue,'
the proceedings IN itnpeacn ts oah Ihs
procedure IN such cases, ahu w Ml'ei az ne .
had LED MS hearers ttromsn al he M sbn hy
or impeaGhnent proceealnss, ne men ~, Ky ~
analOgic1A reasoning ueiidHueu OF ihs
hearers why the same rules mat applle.u
as to evidence IN ,mpeaShmientt, proceed o.
ply toa processing for Joint resolution asnxa1
| dlgressed from his argument TO ATTACK ,Ss
| the contention OF Mr.: walker that Inc
Legislature had the right 70 exercise al a.!
the powers OF the executive, legislative
and judicial departments Of the nno govern eJ m,
B1 Of Nights that these departments, o.
government shall be separate and dis
llnct, asking how, they could be SO II tht
General Assembly might, exercise a.
three, Mr., Walker claimed that he salf
the General Assembly could exercise al
these powers under the Constitution,
] After complimentary alluslon 70 MT
Sears and his quotations Of Webster
the speaker then quoted Webster IN IN
Dartmouth College, case as to what wa
tie law Of the land, and tho GontoGuence
Of ignoring that law, and to whA
lengths 1t Would carry one, ana TO wh.Sl
be be- claimed ihe g., pGsltion iaksn bg MI
The Words nEor Cause.r
ra,,t,, ~ ~ ,,,sa,,,., T., ~ Comet,
Taklng up the insertion N me Cohstl
tuition OF the words Tor cause and n
reasons lheiei9F. Mr, MsliWa aa tec y
ihe taGt lIiat th1 sair'eu a yuage Is,