The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1903-11-26


the appointment of senators as mem
bers Of committees. The list was
amended by substituting the name of
Mr.. Morgan OF Alabama for that Of Mr..
Bate as chairman of the committee on
quarantine and public health and by
elecung a new committee Of three 10
dispose Of useless papers in the depart
ments of which Mr.. Pcttus. Dem),
Ala. was made chairman, and Messrs.
Bate, (Dem), Tenn, and Long, (RepJ,
Kan. members.
Mr.. Hale, (Maine) then called up his
motion for the reconsideration of the
vote by which Mr.. NeWlauds' joint res
olution, providing for the annexation
, OF cuba was referred to the committee
ON relations with Cuba. and asked that
vote on the motion be taken forth
with. with the understanding that the
resolution itself should lie ON the Ia
= bic for future discussion. There was
no objection to the request and the
motion was adopted without division
il was the intention of Mr.. SpOoner
To speak today on the motion, but his
address was deferred and he viii speak
on the resolution itself on a later day.
Az the instance of Mr.. Cullom the
Cuban reciprocity bill was read at
length and made the unfinished bust
ness with the understanding that any
2resk ON the measure at any time that
me senate IS i'm session.
Carmack's Sarcasm.
Mr. Carmack took the floor and ad-
> oarcssCd the senate i'm regard TO the
Cuban bill He began by saying that
in his message the president had urged
tho ratification of the Cuban treaty
with reasons which appeal to divers
motives i'm the human heart
He told US" the senator went on,
that we must ratify IL 10 have our
honor and help our trade. 1t was an
opportunity to worship God and get
your money back; to be diHgent IN
business. while serving the Lord. he
presented tine Cuban treaty in the
double aspect of bargain counter ana
a missionary box. You put nickel ID
the slot for sweet charity's sake and
get more than your moneys worth OF
chewing gum end cigars. Happy IS the
Republican administration that was
driven 81, selfish motive 20 righte-
GUS deed and could perform a Christ
> ian duty without exercising any OF the
Christian virtues It is another story
when honor and selhshness come into
cVn1ict."
Continuing Mr.. Carmack said that If
this measure would reduce the price OF
sugar 1t would be an argument in IT'S
favor. but the larger part of the SUI
gar imports would still De subject 20
duty and the tariff would be added TO
all The authors of the sugar tax prom
ised TO reduce it by ten million dol
lars
Solemn Promise Violated.
= I'VE were 10 pay this sum for this
treaty. &c requires us TO give up. not
= only the right to reduce taxes, but
reciprocity with other countries. You
Violate your solemn promise to reduce
Trl cr1fI
name of honor: you sell your right to
make commercial treaties and you do
80 in The name Of reciprocity.
7Ir. CarmaCk referred at length 20
the reciprocity policy Of Blaine'and NC
kinney and quoted from a speech by
0Tr Deliver. Uowa). i'm which the lat
ter had said that every line of the
wisdom Of Blaine had been eliminated
from the statutes. He agreed that this
was true: and. IF 81. who was respon-
sible? IF the Democratic party had
taken &c off. the Republican party had
infused 90 put il back.
FT0ntinuinE. Mr.. Carmack C',.ared
That Mr.. DOlliVer was right when ne
said that his p9rty's failure To carry
ont reciprocity was a blow to protec-
@ionisr3.
But TT would demonstrate TO the peO-
pie" said the speaker that a party
dominated by protected interests would
make no Concessions
Shelter For Monopoly.
lie said Governor Cummius had as
saiicu the t9rin as shelter for mon
s0poiy until the trusts had forced him
10 desist. that Representative Babcock
of Wisconsin had been made 10 feel
the displeasure of his party for utter
auces contrary 90 trust mandates. that
such had been the history of every Re
publican who had revolted against mon
opoly and that such would b. the his
tory of Mr. Dollivcr.
Mr.. Carmack then turned his atten-
ton 90 the president. Six months ago,
ID said. a cry was raised for "Roose-
SYCit. Reciprocity and Revision What
had become of the last two members
OF this blessed triuity?' The trinit-
ariIu propaganda ne went on has
been overwhelmed by the Mohammedan
war cry of Allah ~ Allah. Roosevelt
IS great and the senator from Massa-
Chusetts is his prophet The first word
in this trinity is enough to express the
creed of the Republican party. What
ever that word of multifariOus mean
ing meant last night. that was the pol
ICY OF the Republican party this morn
suE 10 did not mean reciprocity and IL
did not mean revision
ar CarmaCk closed with a plea for
general tariff revision. saying. i'm part:
THE reaeti0uary movement toward
protection I'm England derived its
Strength from the hostile tariff OF the
United States. Mr.. Chamberlain has
played the United States against the
continent or Europe with success. and
is now free to execute a hostile tariff
i'm favor of the British colonies ard
against the United States. This viii
be staggering blow 10 our agricul-
tural industries. but The beginning Of a
more liberal policy shown by the vic
tory Of the Democratic party i'm the
next election I'm the United States would
nut an end to NIr. Chamberlain's
scheme at once"
Newlands on Cuba.
r When lIr CaTmaCk concluded. Mr..
Newlauds OF Nevada made defense
81 his resolution recently introduced for
cuban statehood. He said that Cuba