davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1903-10-17
.IOHN LANE.

THE an56T Of o4S Se d6 y 8aRh nd HaF2 fm6 RFs
SIX FAIRY PLAYS. BY Meta syrett- Square
16mo 81 net
THE LITTLE PEOPLE. BY l. Allen Ha IoH5d
author of "A Romance Of the Nursery I-iio
IA HUNDRED FABLES OF zsoP Pr, IL IA 4
4 HGNDRED ANECDOTES OF ANIMALS
h3SR TGGme T BY Percy SeS5 BnghuEs
decorative covers Separate volumes 81 g 90 56 each'
L WYMPS. II. ALL THE WAY TO or IN +;
ors F&i airy CoIored nRstratons by Mrs Dear
mer. Square 12mo decorative covers, 3 - 49, aoe
rative box. IS So
HANDBOoKs OF PRACTICAL. GARDENING S,loSt5
Hinder the genera fo 81 met voI2me The following
new volumes will appear this fall:
VOL. XIV. THE BOOK OF SHRUBS. BY George
Gordon, V. NJ. H., Editor Of THE Gardener
vol XVI THE E BOOK E OF THE DAFFoDIL BY
THE COUNTRY HANDBOOKS. A Series of illus
trated Practical HandbOoks Dealing with
sack Under the general edtorship OF Harry
Roberts. 16mo 6iz by inches. Price bound in
limp clotn. 81 net; in limp leather, 81 70 net
Volumes now appearing:
VOL / THE TRAMP's HANDBOOK By h
Roberts.
VOL. II. THE MOTOR BOOK BY r J. Me-
credy.
VOL. V. THE TREE BOOK BY Mary R. Jarvis
THE NEW POCKET LIBRARY. Frlnteo from a
clear type upon a specially thin and OPAQUE
paper. manufactured for the series 16mo. by
80. inches. Price. bound in CLOTH 80 cents net;
in leather 20 cents net u volumes in box, cloth.
s. net leather. 50 net.
THE SCARLET LETTER By Nathaniel Haw-
thorne
THE HOUSE OF THE SEVEN GABLES By
Nathaniel Hawthorne
EUPHRANOR. BY Edward FITZGERALD
ELEANOR DAYTON By Nathaniel Stephenson
author of They That Took the Sword The
Beautiful Mrs. Mouton,' limo, 81 so.
= d.
riott, author of The Column" Love With
Honor" etc 12mo. 81 90
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1903-10-17
L. c. PAGE G. CO.

BELGIUM: ITS CITIES. BY Grant Allen, author
of Paris" Florence Venice" etc Two vol
umes, large l6mo. cloth decorative. profusely
illustrated with full page photogravure and half
tone plates, deckle edge, fiat back. gilt top. a
set, boxed So the same three-Quarters
rocco, s..
GARDENS OF THE CARIBBEES. BY Ida NJ. H.
Starr. Two volumes. large limo. cloth decora-
tive profusely illustrated with full page photo
gravure and half tone plates deckle edge. fiat
back, gilt top, set boxed 50 40 net; the same,
three-QuarterS morocco, IS net.
THE CATHEDRALS OF NORTHERN FRANCE
BY Francis Miltoun, with eighty Illustrations
from original drawings and many minor decora-
tons by Blanche McManus. One volume, oc-
tavo. decorative cover. s. 60 net: the same three
quarters morocco, 81 net.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1903-10-17
G. w. DILLINGHAM; CO,

SIR HENRY MORGAN. BUCCANEER. BY CYRUS
Townsend Brady, author of For Love OF C0un-
try. For the Freedom Of the Sea- The
Southerners," etc. PrOfusely illustrated from
drawings by J. n Marchand and viii Craw-
ford 12mo. cloth bound. 81 30.
RIVERFALL. BY Linn Boyd Porter. limo cloth
bound. Illustrated. s. so
BETHSAIDA a Story Of the Time OF Christ BY
Malcolm Dearborn, author Of Lionel Arion .
Emo. Cloth bound & so
OUT FOR THE COIN. BY the author Of "John
Henry" Down the Line with John Henry %
ITS Up TO YOU Back to the Woods" Illus
Tated from drawings by Gordon Grant Cloth.
gilt top. Is cents
IF1E MERIEAiE BANKS. By Mary ]. Holmes.
3uthor or Tempest and Sunshine" Lena
boTSG ,,, he S2mPtons," etc limo. Cloth
DENSL0W'S PICTURE BOOKS FOR chill.
INEN t9uarto size Price % cents each IN
cespucthe. mounted on linen, so cents each
ga or tnese books W. W. Denslow has revised
tales - '-0 N0N@ Sl"eoiOdA ldHy
THH Lt dItiDS DEGREE BY Charles Ross Jackson.
$50 ''iS' LIMO. Clothbound.
THE NISEl-A9MiFAL OF THE Rite Nv Roland
Burnham Molineux. Author Of Tba ~ BY "a ~
trated. 81 30. "oounu- Illus
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1903-10-17
LEE G. SHEPARD.

LAUREL LEAVES FOR LITTLE FOLK Edited
Illustrated and decorated by Mary E. Phillips,
author OF "reminiscences of William Wetmore
story, etc. Edition de luxe. Octave. Sumptu-
ously Illustrated. decorated, printed and bound
Boxed, 81 So net; postpaid. s. 20.
DON'TS FOR MOTHERS. BY Gabrielle z. Jack
SON.. Superby printed in brown ink, high
grade tinted linen paper. and bound In brown
silk, with brown edges and gold title 16mo. 128
pages. Price. 80 cents. net; postpaid. So cents.
THE HERMIT. A Story of the Wilderness BY
Charles Clark Mum author of Uncle Terry
etc. Illustrated by A B. Shute Laid paper,
gilt top. Price. 81 so
ELIJAH KELLOGG: THE MAN AND HIS WORK
Edited by Wllmot b. Mitchell. Professor OF
Rhetoric and Oratory in Bowdoin College Fully
illustrated from photographs. Large limo,
cloth. 81 20 net. Postpaid, 81 s.
THE TENTH COMMANDMENT. By marguerite
Linton Glentworth. author of "A Twentieth
Century Boy" 12mo cloth. fine laid paper gilt
top Photogravure portrait frontispiece Of au-
thor. Price. 81 30.
THE BLOW FROM BEHIND. a Defence Of the
Flag in the Philippines. BY Fred. c. Chamber
lin, IL. B. 12mo, cloth. about 200 pages. Price.
81. net; postpaid. 81 10.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1903-10-17

modelling clay. woodcarving. fret saving
burnt wood work leather decoration. etc.
T. BUCHANAN READS POLITICAL WORKS.
Three Volumes Illustrated 16no. cloth. per
set. net IS 70.
The edition is distinguished by good paper
specially selected type and comedy binding
SHAKESPEARES GARDEN. BY J, Harvey
Bloom. NJ. A. Illustrated with several interest
ing reproductions from photographs 12rnO.
cloth, 81: limp lea Their, net 81 25.
HYPNOTISM-ITS HISTORY. PRACTICE. AND
THEORY BY j. Milne Bramwell. VI. y. Illus
trated. Crown Svo. cloth. net 81 90
The historical part of the book contains much
that is Interesting and little known.
FROM MANASSAS To APPOMATTOX. BY Gen
eraI James Longstreet- Illustrated $40. CLOTH
gilt top. S.
Memoirs Of the Civil War by Of the most
famous Of the Confederate leaders.
IN AND OUT OF BOOK AND JOURNAL BY A
Sydney Roberts. VI. d. Neat limo. cloth, 81
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1903-10-17
Il FAMOUS GROCER'S SHOP.
Where Marie AntOinette Hid a. Varenne,

Where Marie AntOinette Hid at Varennes.
From The Paris Daily Messenger.
The sale the other day OF the historic erocer's
shop Narennes in which the royal family OF
France spent the terrible night OF June 81 1901
recalls Of the most poignant OF the many
tragedies that happened on the long via dolo-
rosa Of Louis Seize and Marie Antolnette which
ended on the Place de Ia Revolution The build
ing IN which the fate OF the fugitives and Of the
ancient French monarchy was sealed ia n very
unpretending erection as may DO imagined OF n
grocer's and chambers shop in little paltrv
village" Carlyle called I, more than a CEN
fury ago. IL stands in the street of tho
Place, and its architectural features II such
ohey can be called. together with its internal
arrangements. have been described by myriads
% pens though never more picturesquely than
Dy AieNnncre Dumas. Ii was built very largely
"a WOOD, and its two windows. divided by "a
--aINe9 ooor The upper portion Of which STOOD
- UiIliis the day. made IL very similar 10 the
- r,, htI,se shops which stu often poen in
80 one VINO has read anything Of tho liter
a a, OF me night TO Varennes is familiar with
,He inferior or that fatal house-the staircase
az nc Iief OF the shop, dark and steep with n
- Io4 h'air -rall; the back room, fifteen feet
by twenty, on the first floor looking ont uron =
courtyard Ia which the King his wife on 3
family were huddled for seven hours ,,h,i
chance after chance OF resouing them ,ra. H..
Inc p!acs Il very little altered 10 this DIV
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1903-10-17
MCCLURE, PHILLIPS & co.

THE SIMPLE LIFE. BY Charles Wagner Trans
lated by Mary Hendee. Cloth. limo. 81 %.
President Roosevelt has made this book the
ethical guide of his administration.
MANS PLACE IN THE UNIVERSE. BY Alfred
Russell Wallace. author of The Wonderful
Century" Net about 81 So
RELIGIONS OF AUTHORITY. BY Augusta
SabatIer. late dean Of Protestant Faculty of
Theology in the University of Paris. Net, s. so.
Postpaid. s. 20.
GREAT MASTERS OF PAINTING. BY John La
Fargo. Illustrated with seventy-two fine half
tone engravings; by 10 fine decorative binding.
Net IS.
These essays pack each mans history his
spiritual life, his artistic entity. into few vivid
thoughtful pages.
THE HOME-ITS WORK AND ITS INFLUENCE.
BY Charlotte Perkins Gilman, author of Con
corning Children Women and Economics -
limo. Postpaid. 81 60. Net 81 90
This book makes fearless and careful investi-
CATION of the home-its evolution its normal and
abnormal tendencies and effects
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1903-10-17
DOOD, MEAD & CO,

WE. THE PEOPLE BY Edward Everett IJala
author OF The Man Without Countrv ..Tar
Times One Is Ten" Memories OF a hundred
Years." etc. limo. CLOTH s. 20 net
A collection OF articles recentlv r,r,,,.r ,or
several Journals OF wide circulation and now o.
the first time published in book form " ii
PLAYS HAVE SEEN. Cloth l2mo 81 ne,
A convenient form In which 10 keen r..o-,
of tho plays one has seen and all the nteres,ir :,
facts connected with each one, including por-
illustrated papers and magazines) as well az
reviews and criticisms. $50 nv
SIXTY BRIDGE HANDS. BY Charles Stunrt
Street: Bound In leather uniform with MIR
Streets well known Fridge up Date and
Sixty Bridge Hands. printed In red and
black. with the necessary notes ana explana-
lions. ~~SN~NN~
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1903-10-17
JOHN DICKINSON.
a Striking Figure in Eighteenth
Century America.

rfr1STTcRs FROM A FARMER IN PENNS1INA-
MA TO THE INHABITANTS OF TIE Bti :
lsH COLONIES. By John Dickinson. Win an
Historical Introduction by X. J. IA faaises. 7'''
DID. ixyiL ls6. The outlook Company.
The twelve successive anonymous Letters OF
a Farmer" reproduced I'm this book. appeared IN
The Pennsylvania Chronicle and Universal Ad-
N-ertiser" in November and December, ltO'.
They were Immediately reprinted in almost al
the colonial newspapers. John Dickinson was
born in Maryland. had a classical education
read law. studied in Middle Temple. practised
I'm Phslaae .rhia was made speaker Of the As
sembly OF Delaware. and later became an IN
ooptlar member OF the Assembly OF Pennsyl-
wanna. Mr.. Halsey in his interesting and SUI
nc;ent introduction TO the reprint, suggests thar
Diclinson's knowledge Of the personality Of the
English ministry gained while abroad led nm
10 the opposition Of Frankns measure for the
revolxiuE OF the Proprietary Charter WHICH
though shown 10 be wise by subsequent events
rsined him at the moment bitter enemies DICK
fnson won a wider esteem soon de publshed
a panlphlet on the taxation questions IN 100
which was freely circulated, and assumed q
leading part in the meeting Of colonial repre-
sentatives in New-York in 1864 The Letters"
Were republished Immediately upon their APP
pesrance Three editions were printed in Phila-
delphia and two in Boston, another in New
York. another in Dublin. and another in Lon
don. with a preface by Franklin, who was also
instrumental in having them translated into
French
The first letter is a quietly reasoned plea
against the suspension OF the legislative assem-
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1903-10-17
CATALOGUE OF BOOKS FOR FALL
READING,
Continued from seventh page.

Square svo; 200 Illustrations, largely from
photographs. 81 net. BY mall. SO 30.
The book is popular, though scientifically ac-
urate.
A TEXT BOOK OF GEOLOGY. BY Professors
Thomas c. Chamberlin and Rollin d. Salisbury,
of the University of Chicago. With numerous
Illustrations; vols. svo.
GUIDE TO THE STUDY OF FISHES by
David Starr Jordan. president Of Leland stan
ford University. California.
comprehensive work.
A LABORATORY MANUAL. OF BIOLOGY. BY
NJ. c. Valentine and G.. w. Hunter, OF the New
York City Schools. Cloth. limo 60 cents
PRACTICAL CHEMICAL CALCULATIONS: by
Professor H. L. Wells. Sheffield Scientific SchoOl
of Yale University.
An authoritative modern treatise. compreleii-
slve and scholarly.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1903-10-17

A. S. BARNES & CO.

RECOLLECTIONS, Personal, AND LITE
RARY. BY Richard Henry Stoddard. Edited by
Ripley Hitchcock. with Introduction by Ed
mund Clarence Stedmsn: The most notable vol
ume Of literary biography since the Life and
Letters of Lowell" Illustrated. 12mo. CLOTH
gilt top, deCkel edge. 81 "a net. LARGO Pouer
Edition limited 10 200 copies extra illustrated
with rare portraits and tacsimiles OF letters
from Poe. Hawthorne and many others s. 50 net
WITHIN THE PALE. BY Michael Davitt author
OF Leaves from Prison Diary Life and
Progress in Australasia etc. The true history
of anti-Semitic persecution in Russia A civil
against a and its effect on America
cloth
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1903-10-17
HoUoHToN. MIFFLIN G. co.

TIT COMPLETE WORKS OF RALPH WALDO
EMERSON. Centenary Edition. With a Bio
graphical Introduction and Notes by Edward
Waldo Emerson. ard a General Index. Crown
svo gilt top 81 70 per volume.
Also issued in fine bindings
A feature Of the recent celebration OF Erner-
sons centenary the appearance OF the first
volumes Of the Centenary Edition of mis- works.
now in the c0urse OF publication
CONOUERING SUCCESS. or Life in Earnest By
William Mathews Crown $40. 81 30 net POST
extra
Mr.. Mathews is probably best known as the
author of Getting On in the World"
A READERS HISTORY OF AMERICAN LIT
ERATURE. BY Thomas Wentworth Higginson
and Henry W. Boynton- Crown Svo. 81 % net
Postpaid.
\ friend and contemporary Of many Of the
great American authors, Mr.. HigginsOn Is able
to draw from a rich source of personal remints-
careers Of these man and women.
MY COOKERY BOOKS By Elizabeth Robins
PennelL Illustrated 4to $50 net Limited edi-
ton Of $50 numbered copies of which 80 will be
sale
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1903-10-17
CHARLES scRIBNER's SONS.

THE HORSEWOMAN. A Practical Guide to Side
Saddle Riding. BY Alice y. Hayes. Edited by
NJ. Horace Hayes. The second edition, enlarged
and revised, with 133 Photographic illustrations
added. s.
A standard work by Of the best teachers
of riding in England.
POINTS OF THE HORSE. Familiar Treatise
on Equine Conformation. BY Captain NJ. Hor-
ace HAYES, +. r c. Y. s Third edition, re
vised and enlarged. with 200 reproductions Of
photographs and 2l5 drawings by J. II. Brown.
In preparation.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1903-10-17
SPORTS.
THE BAKER G. TAYLOR CO.

r. F. AND H L. DOHERTY ON LAWN TEN
MS. limo. IS full page illustrations from Pho
tographs of the authors in play. 81 30 net
Giving positions grips. strokes, services, etc.
1t is designed for all who would improve their
play.
HINTS TO GOLFERS By "Niblick. l2mo.
Printed in colors and attractively illus
trated. Net 81 25.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1903-10-17
THE BAKER G. TAYLOR CO.

THE LITTLE TEA BOOK. Compiled by Arthur
Gray. Decorated and illustrated in n novelty
tea case. 81 20 net Postage cents
This book is n companion to Over tho Rlacx
Coffee" holiday gift book of last year
NEW LIBRARY OF POETRY AND soNc
Edited by William Cullen Bryant, Revised edi
ton, % fuil page Illustrations. LOO pages S.
TALKS TO STUDENTS ON THE ART OF
STUDY. BY Frank Cramer. limo. 81 net
careful book. for teachers parent, and SIN
dents on the art OF study. "
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1903-10-17
BRENTANO'S.
MiSCSllhNEOUa

THE LOST KING. BY Henry Shackal-o-a A.,
sd n "F o dealing 1 with LOUIS chsres
n handsome cover s12b suauons and
lish society life. Net. 81 co. Npose or Eng
THE BEGGAR's GARDEN. Verso. ~ ,,,.
Lawrence, author OF Colonial Veysodiis MISS Ruth
trated. Net. 81. O'ses' Illus
FAIR WOMEN OF THE XVIIITTy ryr>,-
Large 4to. Seven reproductions In ooIhNTuRY.
gilt stamping. 81 30. 'oor- Cloth.
THE GHlLD5 Ak ARAb tiA NIGHTS BY Heat,
or s. 60 IN col
BILBERRY WOOD; A Juvenile. BY n =,
Dick Verses. Illustrated IN co}or!!' e NJ.
FORM 81 10. ooions
J. 3. LIPPlNcOTT COMPANY
HOME ARTS AND CRAFTS. Edited h, NJ,
que Marks Illustrated. square svo deea onta,
cloth, net 81 10. orated
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1903-10-17
JAMES POTT G. CO.

BUDAPEST, THE CITY OF THE MAGYAiRSsS, ny ny
+. Berkeley Smith. With introdu .n 81
+. Hopkinson Smith. Copiously illus'ia'e'
Emo. cloth. 81 so
THE NEGRO PROBLEM. BY Booker l: 80
ington principal of Tuskegee: w H. i Pu
hardt Dubois. Paul Laurence Dunbar g. S 55 \ ct
W. Chestnut and others. limo, clolh. % - "
Postage, cents.
series of articles by representative emf 70
can negroes of to-day not publlshed pie'
the issuing of this volume .,,
THE MOON. A and popular editI 9h. md a q
considered a planet, a Woid lanes
satellite. BY. James Nasmth, Z F. d 1t.sI Oh
Carpenter F. r. A s.. late OF the IsO jyiiistra-
servatory, Greenwich. With numerous
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1903-10-17
E. p. DILLON G. CO.

sHAKESPEARE's HOMELAND. sketches and
Stratford-up Avon. the Forest OF <assTIgton
the Avon Valley. BY w. SAT- 20 20 81
F. S A. Fully Illustrated svo, 81 o. ho'- ,,,.
CArJBANS GUIDE TO LETTERS: by r5 1iti 10
BelIoc Author of "Robespierre Inc ra'i' ~
Rome" etc 12mo. 81 % net
This volume is made up OF series S Shd pH'
dealing with the so-called Literary SH'P-
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1903-10-17
D. APPLETON G. co.

THE LIFE AND DEATH OF JOHN MYTTON:
ESQ. BY Nimrod. Illustrated by II. Aiken and
T. J. Rawlins 16mo. cloth. 81 30. Rare and
Famous BoOks)
HANDLEY CROSS. BY r. 5. Surtees. 16nno. CLOTH
81 30. Seventeen colored plates and 100 woodcuts
by John Leech- CSare and Famous BookS)
JORROCk'S JAUNTS AND JOLLITIES. BY r 8
SUrtees. 16mo. cloth. 81 So Fifteen coored illus
trations by Henry Aiken CRare and Famous
BOOkS)
THE VICAR OF WAKEFIELD. By Oliver Gold
smith. 16rno. cloth. 81 80. Twenty-four colored
Illustrations by Thomas Rowlandson- (Rare and
Famous BooKs)
THE TOUR OF DR. SYNTAX. By William Combe
Thirty-one colored Illustrators by Thomas Row
landson limo. cloth, 81 so (Rars and Famous
Books)
THE HISTORY OF JOHNNY NEAL GEEMS. BY
William Combe. Colored illustrations by
Thomas Rowlandson 16mo. CLOTH 81 80. (Rare
and Famous Books)
THE DANCE OF LIFE. BY William Coube. 16mo
cloth. 81 80 Twenty-six colored illustrations by
Thomas Rowlandson. (Fsare and Famous Books)
THE POLITICAL WRITINGS OF WILLIAM Gull
LEN BRYANT. By Henry c. Sturgcs. Roslyn
Edition. Nineteen full page Illustrations svo.
cloth. 81
A new and complete edition. containing fifty
poems not before published.
THE CENTURY COMPANY.
THE TRAINING OF WILD ANIMALS. By Frank
c. Bostock. Edited by Ellen Velvin. T. 2. 8.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1903-10-17
HENRY HOLT q co

THOUGHTLESS THOUGHTS OF CARISABEL-
by lisa Carrington Cabell. 12mo 81 % net
These thirty satires cover matters of such
universal interest THE New Man, - ne
nal Sin" etc.
LAVIGNACS MUSIC AND MUSICIANS. Mar
chant " hrehbiel limo. cloth 81 20 net DS
mail. 81 81.
Mi hrehbieIs new chapter. covering hicnaiu
strauss. Humperdinck, DvOrak, ChaT pem.ie 10
sullivan. Elgar etc. brings this book up ~
date.
DANTE'S INFLUENCE ON ENGLISH POEIfi'
By Professor Oscar Kuhns
THE LAWS OF IMITATION BY Gabriel Iarae.
the eminent French socologist. Translatien ~ ~
Elsie CleWeS Parsons with an int Oh
the eminent American socioogist. IIoiess ag
Franklin H. Giddings. svo. 50 net by Hail.
1920
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1903-10-17

Continued on ninth page.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1903-10-17

rFrr~T-,cRs FROM A FARMER IN PENNSYLNA-
MA TO THE INHABITANTS OF TltE bttl a,
historical Introduction by r.. T. II. halsey. Ato'
pp lsyft ls6. The Outlook Company.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1903-11-20
R4PS SUNDAY SCHOOL.
DR.. Butler Calls Ordinary One q
Pathetic Sight.

"One of the most pathetic sights in America is
the ordinary Sunday school, taught by unframed
persons, not properly coordinate; textbooks the
poorest; ideals the most vague-yet to that we are
supposed to trust the rising generations for their
systematic religious teaching" declared DR.. Nicho-
las Murray Butler, president of Columbia Unver-
sity at a dinner of the Unitarian Club at the Hotel
ST. Denis last night.
The Rev Thomas r. Slicer presided and said that
the subject for discussion THE Unsolved
Problem of Religion in Education" President Butler
was the first speaker. He also said:
In France and the United States have come
to the secular schOOl-in France by law and in this
country by custom In the United States what
forms of religious exercises there are resemble
which is often the signal for outbreak of very
unreligious talk. You cannot educate a man on
science alone; you instruct him You cannot
educate a in art letters; you can instruct
him. If to have secular education, then
we must have partial education. for with the re-
man knows what has gone on in Europe for the last
two thousand years his education is unfinished
DR.. Butler said that the place for the religious
education was in family and in the church, but
that trouble with the church is that ii breaches
much and does not teach enough. If II
taught il would be better for the rising gem
ton" He declared that every time he said that
there little religious teaching in the home he
Bibles this year than the year before. Il don't
care how many Bibles Sold said the doctor.
L want to know what becomes of them. l am
pretty they not read"
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1903-11-20
Y. NC. 4. ANNUAL DINNER.
Major General COrbin Praises Mss
Helen VI. GOaid.

The annual dinner of the international commit
tee Of the Young Mems Christian Association OF
North America was held last night in the Waldorf
Astoria over two hundred members. guests ana
friends Of the association were present, and the
galleries were filled with women when the speak
ing began. A. Z. Marling presided, and welcomed
those present in the name of the executive com
rnittee At each plate printed ofnclal report
tv departments of the years work OF the Young
Mems Christian Association of North America.
At the end of the set speeches MIR Marhng pald
a tribute to the late William Z. Dodge. who was
long Identified with the work Of the organization,
and then called on Rear Admiral Rodgers. who
smoke of the good work Of the Young Mems Chrls-
tian Association in the navy. lie especially COM
nendsd the Woman's Auxiliary for the building II
has erected noar the Brooklyn Navy Yard, which,
he said. often accommodates four hundred, though
il was intended for only two hundred.
Major General Corbin thanked the association Tor
the good it had done for the army. and suggested
that in case of pestilence, the Young Men
Christian Association ought Ito constitute itself a
bodv to co-ordinate assemble and disseminate food
and medicine" in which work he thought il would
prove of great service. He referred TO that brave
and thoughtful woman. Helen Miller Gould" The
work Of such women he continued. contributes
much to the honor Of the Republic and to the hap
piness and contentment of the people
w. A Patton said: Speaking for the Pennsyl-
Vania Railroad, l wish TO say that except for the
work of your committee and your secretaries. 1t
would have been impossible to have accomplished
the work that has been accomplished by the Penn
sylVania Railroad