davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The Jennings daily record. [volume] (Jennings, La.) 1900-1903, 1902-03-13

E-15 If in need of a safe see the
louisiana Machine & Well Works
Co., agents for Victor safe. Cliff
The Jennings daily record. [volume] (Jennings, La.) 1900-1903, 1902-03-13

Fine Burbank potatoes just re-
ceived at E. F. w alker grocery. 81
The Tucson citizen., 1902-01-13

I w. e. Murphy, Of the Surveyor Cen
erals office, is firm believer in NUM-
cipals ownership. Mir, Murphy said "A
municipal lighting plant would be the
most economical. Some twelve years
ago | was secretary and treasurer of
an electric light company and we We're
glad to get the contract to light the
city for $l00 an are light and after all
the improvements that have been
made, the company here proposes to
charge $l20 for each arc light. In my
opinion no franchise for commercial
lighting should be granted unless a
maximum charge is fixed, | am in ia
vur Of the city doing commercial light
ing If they can not get good service
from a private company
VI. l.. Freeman. president of the
Consolidated National Bank, said: Il
am In favor OF giving the present com
pany the contract for lighting the
streets of the city and believe that the
city ,oult afford 10 pay them a little
more than it is estimated that the
lights would cost under municipal
ownership as the city would then be
lights Woutd cost under municipal
ownership as the city would then be
taking nu risk.
Dr. Mark Rodgers was asked for his
view on the question and said You
may say for me that III general | am
In favor OF municipal ownership but
have not Investigated this particular
case and could not express an opin-
ion
General Manning expressed himself
very forcihly ON the subject He said
Il not only believe that Mr., Henry
should he given the contract but
believe that the city should offer in
ducements 10 outside capital to In
vest here All one wants to lookout
for is 10 see that they do not rob you,
Rev A. NJ. Gibbons said on the sub
ject. Il am not in favor Of govern
ment paternalism II Is possible that
a municipal lighting plant might be al!
right here When a franchise can be
properly disposed OF tn private indivt-
duals without iuiuring the rights of
the citizens am not in favor %
public ownership There is so much
more opportunity for corruption un~
der this system,
TX Mayor Hon thinks that the ~isy
ought hy all means to operate It's own
light plant Said MIR Hoff. When the
water works were purchased Il was
the intention then to use the addition
IL power for the manufacture OF lights
for the city The only things necessary
would be a dynamo and wires for he
streets. The plant could be operated
at a minimum cost Even II this were
not the case, | would be in favor of the
city owning It's own lighting plant
When l. as Mayor signed the present
lighting franchise IL was because
thought that 1t would be breaking tig
contract with the company and not
because was against the city operat-
ing It's own plant.
Col VIM. Herring was asked for MS
opinion on the subject and said Il
am in favor OF municipalities ownsag
and operating their own lighiuG
plants but | have been too busy Ia in
,estigate the situation here and could
not give an intelligent opinion on me
subject
The Tucson citizen., 1902-01-13
FOreSters Install
Officers at Yuma

YUMA. Arix.. Jan. IA joint in
stallatlon Of officers was held on Fri
day night by Court Olive branch and
Court Yuma branch, l. O. r. Cour; De
putty w. F. Timmons OF Court Yuma
acted as presiding officer Refresh
ments were served and pleasant
evening was spen, The follow were
the otticer installed: Miss Grace Con
nor, chief ranger. Mrs, .. B. Hackett,
junior past chief ranger: Miss Mar
garet Harrington. vice chief ranger:
Mrs, o. w Minch. recording secretary:
Miss Agnes Baisz. financial secretary;
Miss Margaret Walsh. treasurer; Mrs.
T. ID. Molloy, orator. Miss Lillian
sherman. organist Mrs. r. y. Day.
senior woodward: Mrs, Alice Hicks.
junior woodward. Miss Katie Balsz.
senior beadle; Miss Ienora Ref.
Junior beadle; Mrs. Cash NJ. Smith,
Mrs. Thomas Stratton trustees: Mrs.
I, f. Brice. Mrs David Balsz finance
committee
The following were reelected but
installation was not required. r d.
Molloy. chief ranger. A. NJ Foster.
junior chief ranger: o. W Mich. rec
ording secretary; W. H. Shorey. fin-
anical secretary Gus Livingston.
c. NJ White. finance commit
te
The Tucson citizen., 1902-01-13
LET THERE BE LIGHT
ON THE SUBJECT.
Pronosals to illuminate the Old Pueblo Con-
sidered by Councilmen and Citizens

The city council Will meet some even
ing this week to consider the report or
the committee appointed by the mayor
at the last maeting to inN"5tiEr:" the
advisability of installing a municipal
lighting plant and 10 consider the pro
position made by Mr. Henry to light
;he streets OF the city. The committee
has been actively at work securlt
estimates by wire from all over the
country as to the cost OF installing
plant and as to the cost Of lighting IN
other cities where the lights are turn
ished by private individuals. Ih"%
have found that it would cost $@H,oo0
to install an SO arc light plant and mat
il would cost 81 400 TO operate 1t per
month Mr.. Henry has submitted to the
committee an amended proposition ~
furnish lights for the city for i've years
for $40 an arc per month. The city -
paying AT rate of $li 81 per month 1h
The present basis,
An ordinance has been drafted pro-
Nidiug for such contract and Is aoW
In the hands OF the committee IL Also
provides for a different arrangement
Of the lights in the city and for what
Is known as the Philadelphia noon
light schedule The committee met this
afternoon al O'Clock hut do not wish
to make their recommendations dni
report public until it is submitted Ia
the council II was learned from on"
member Of the committee that IL Wa-II
be safe To say that they Will not te-
commend 10 the council the establish
ment OF municipal lighting plart,
Whether they viii recommend N"
Henry proposition or simply submit
the figures and leave the council 10
act. it is not known but 1t is presumed
that they will take the latter course.
The next meeting OF the rouHah
Will be an important one as II will ie
eide whether the city is going 10 em-
bark farther into municipal owner
ship.
There Is wide difference Of opinion
among the prominent citizens OF Tue
son on the question OF installing
municipal lighting plant When the
proposition was at first preached, the
prevailing opinion seemed 10 be
against it, but thorough luvestiga-
tion OF the matter shows that many are
In doubt
Judge Blenman. who returned from
Los Angeles this morning. IS one OF
the strongest advocates OF municipal
ownership. In conversation with
Citizen reporter Judge Blenman said.
Il think the city would be taking
step in the right direction By install
ing a municipal lighting plant. The
taxpayers would then have right 10
complain against the poor service and
the remedy would lay In their hands.
am in favor OF public ownership Of
all public utilities and in my opinion
the city should engage in commercial
lighting as we'll
Mr b, NJ. Jacobs. president of the
Arizona National Bank. Is not In favor
OF municipal ownership and referring
10 this particular case. he said. The
present company should be given the
contract to light the city IL they will
agree TO do it at a fair price but not
until the company has rebuilt the gas
plant and improved the power plant"
The Tucson citizen., 1902-01-13
New York'n Pie Market.

More pies are made in New York
than In any other city In the world.
The daily output of TIE regular pie
factories is in excess Of $4,000. The
pie baking record was held by Boston
until two years ago. The pie habit is
growing on New Workers.
The biggest pie factory In the coun-
try turns out 10000 pies a day. There
are scores of smaller factories which
turn them out by the carload daily.
The work IL under the direction of an
expert baker, who receives a large sal
ary. These factories claim to use the
very best materials in making pies.
Until recently there was prejudice
against factory pies. but this is disap-
pearing
The most popular pie is that made OF
apples. For years its popularity has
not been shaken. The standard pies
next to apple are lemon and custard.
Pumpkin pies are IN great demand In
the fall and mlncc pies In the winter
Peach pies are .he most popular after
these Until the factory made pie ap-
pearcd New York was several times
threatened with serious pie famines.
The Tucson citizen., 1902-01-13
~Hl11u$efflent$~;
ssasaaanee~sse%~~eaeeseas

1he company which will present
me Christian here next April. will be
headed by Etfie Ellser. who succeeded
VIOLA Allen IN the role of Glory QuayIe.
/ The Christian" was considered the
most successful play on the road dur
ing the season of lS99-l900 when II
first appeared as drama. and it was
in this piece that Mis- Allen arose to
her place in the front rank of stars.
| There are two Christian" companies
on the road this year. an eastern and
western company, and 1t is the latter
which will appear here.
Manager Grossetta OF the tucson
Opera House. stated today in answer
to criticism which recently appeared
in The Citizen. that it was not In his
power to fix the price of plays which
show here. In all OF the contracts
which he makes with theatrical man
ayers, they reserve the right to set
the price OF seats when they p!ay IN
Tucson.
communication was received to-
day from the Boston Idea;
Opera Company. formerly the
Andrew Opera Company. stating
that this company would like to plav
here Jan. oath and 25th. They inclos-
ed a subscription list for seats, but
Manager Grossetta refused to put a list
out and the company will not play
here
George Clarke will head the What
Happened to Jones company, which
comes to Tucson next month. He ap-
peared here in the same play two
years ago and drew a crowded house.
DR.. McIvor-Tyndall whose feats of
mind reading have for some time been
a wonder to those who have witnessed
then added another feature to his long
line of successes at Bisbee the other
day.
wager of $40 was made between
two prominent townsmen that McIvor-
Iyndal could not unlock the safe in G.
r. Tomtlson's office. as no one but
Mr., TomilsOn knew the combination
of the safe In the presence of several
Mclvor-Tyndal set about to complete
the task that he undertook, and which
few believed that he ccould accomplish.
''i' olHil5CII idh III OuG IdHu piece
of paper upon which was written the
combination of the safe. while the
other hand was grasped firmly by Nc
lVor-Tyndal. For some time the mind
reader worked with the little knob Of
the combination. and each time came
nearer the combination. But it re-
qured six attempts to successfully
complete the work, when the bolt of
the lock fell and the door was thrown
open
The Tucson citizen., 1902-01-13
BRIEF NEWS ITEMS
OF THE TOWN.

Elders Edward Day and Elias Han
sen OF the Church of Jesus Christ OF
Latter Day Saints announce that thcy
will hold services in the Court Cham
Der at the Court House on Wednesday
and Thursday evenings at Z O'Clock.
These will be the last meetings that
they will hold here.
Capt l., D. Phillips of Prescott, who
represents Douglas. Lacy and COM
pany of New Yor. was in the city yas
terday looking after their mining in
terests, They recently opened an Office
here
E. W. Black. a cattleman from Santa
Margarita. Cal. is here to ship the
1000 head of cattle recently purchased
by W. B. -.se from Tom Wills, who
has ranch on the San Pedro.
The Tucson citizen., 1902-01-13

F. c. Meyers. stenographer at the
Southern Pacific Offices who has been
Ill for some time. was at his desk in
the Office today
f. j. Parkinson, a prominent mining
man from Jerome, stopped in the city
yesterday on his way home from Son
ora where he has large mining inter
ests
The vagrants, who formerly fire.
quented the city are steering clear Of
Tucson, the fame OF Jailer Dufton $
bread and water diet. having spread
abroad. There was only one case in
Police Court this morning. that OF a
Mexican charged with disorderly con-
duct and he was given the usual six
days in Jail
The Tucson citizen., 1902-01-13
f0te/ TrrivaA :
SHzaauaasaasasss~ss@saS

WINDSOR HOTEi.-W. V. Carr,
OXnard; f. Petit. OXnard; A. j..
Brook. Great Sulphide Copper Camp;
Isidor Cohn. San Francisco; 5. j. Ged-
des, Wilcox. Guy Butler, klondike;
Howard T.. Banrs. Azurite; Burk
Friesleben. Cincinnati; *. Epstein,
Kansas City; H. +. Gardner. Vic Han
ney. Bishee; X. y McCrillis, El Paso:
Henry Gatson, st Louis, +. +. Wat
son. Chicago: James Turner St Joe,
+. Fisher san Francisco r. w Black,
Santa Margarita J. NJ Shee. Denver.
ORDNDORFF HOTEI.-WaIter hin,
Phoenix. Mrs l.. + Chaplin. Margaret
Chaplin. Fort Dodge; Myron w. Hayes,
Chicago; J. A. Eide FL Paso; II. Harri
son, Tucson, r J. Heeks. Chicago;
Fred Richmond FL Paso j. V. shee,
Denver r. NJ. Figg and wife, Johnson,
T. H. Miles. Nogales, Homer Pickett,
Naco. " G. keegiu. Washington, d.
C., j, Cochrane. Denver.
SAN XAVIER HOTEL--A W. Ste
wart. Denver Mrs, J. White Denver;
J. Henry Wood, DR. ]. G.. Norton,
Phoenix, VIM. Metczer. Nogales; Mrs.
Charles Waddles. Denver, II. 4. Stone.
NogaIes. L. A. t.atchford. Washington,
d G.. G. W. Cook. Oakland; f. II,
Purcell, Chicago. VIM. Lee; Los An
geles. Francis J. Heney, City; w Il,
Sayre. Canansa c. E. Huston, South
Dakota
PARK VIEW HOTEI.--Gaines Foley,
Patagonia; F. T. Epply, Wilcox: Geo.
Trott. Michigan w Ftgnerroa. Mann
moth Rob Hansen Los Angeles: Mo-
ward McNab. City. Z. A. Thomas.
Nogales. G. W Greenley, City: G. c.
Cation. City; Fred Olsen. Patagonia.
The Tucson citizen., 1902-01-13

Did you see 1t In the Citizen,
fed Ads?
The Tucson citizen., 1902-01-13

Have your eyes tested by Dr. II. A.
Schell Century block.
Not Like Other Men"
The Tucson citizen., 1902-01-13
CROKER RETIRES.

NEW YORK. Jan. 13.--At a meeting
o. the Tammany General COMMITTEES
on Saturday evening Richard Croker.
formally resigned the leadership of the
organization and on his motion Lewis
Nixon was elected to succeed him.
Nixon is native of Virginia and IS
an ex~otficer of the Navy and a gradu-
ate Of the Naval Academy
The Tucson citizen., 1902-01-13
Local Weather Repor
METAL AND HONEY MA,

New York, Jan. ll.-Ner,
lars 44i4 Silver 5534.
LEAD-dull; brokers $3.50,
$i.00,
COPPER weak brokers l3 e1.
The Tucson citizen., 1902-01-13
TIE SECRET OF LONE

THE SECRET OF LONG
Consists in keeping all the I
gans OF the body in healthy
action, and in quickly destroyju
W disease germs, Electric
regulate Stomach. Liver and i
purify the blood. and give a
appetite. Tney work wonders
ing Kidney Troubles. Fema,
plants. Nervous Diseases q
ton. Dyspepsia and Malaria /
health and strength always
their use. Only 50c. guarantee.
druggists.
The Tucson citizen., 1902-01-13

DeWitt's Little Early Risers search
the remotest part of the bowels and
remove the impurities speedily with
no discomfort, They are famous for
their efficacy. Easy to take, never
grippe. On sale at Bells Pharmacy,
% North Church street.
The Tucson citizen., 1902-01-13

We carry an elegant line Of
for ladies man-tailored garme.]
Kline kohn IL Co, the larges1
date ladies tailoring house In d
ed States Smith the Tailor. in
per Wedge.
The Independent. [volume] (Honolulu, H.I.) 1895-1905, 1902-06-06
EyrnHE III TO OAHU PRISON. ,

The Felicitious Meeting Of Three
Friends Within Those Sacred
Portals
What m ateria for Yardley to
make a cartoon for posterity, in the
meeting which took place within
the walls OF Oahu prison laet even
iugl Yndley will pull his hair out
when he bears OF it, Listen: A
knock at the door. Walter g..
Smith enters, Supper is not ready,
yet, 50 the new Territorial guest is
ushered into the yard whore other
guests are patiently awaiting Tor
their daily ration OF hash. His en-
try causes a sensation. Two stripped
fellows rise as they see the new
conner aud dance miniature hula,
as a sign of welcome. McSwilligsn
Gimp Mccarthy embraces Biting
aud Biting embraces McSwilligau |!
Waiter G.. recognizes them aud
bowsl They exchange greetings
but they are interrupted by a
waiter-beg pardon-a guard, who
announces that dinner is ready.
Exit into the dining rooml
The Independent. [volume] (Honolulu, H.I.) 1895-1905, 1902-06-06
FRIDAY, JUNE 8, 1902.
ooNTEMPTUoUs BREEZE.

Was it "habeas corpus" breeze
that bowed softly yesterday morn
ing into the sanctum of the news
paper offices2 Was it smell OF
contempt which was carried on
the wings OF that breeze and set
Editors aud Supreme Court Justices
thinkingi Read the record OF the
day and Judge for yourselves:
Early morning: The Advertiser
publishes an editorial on judicial
spendthrift trusts."
10 a. M: Editor OF TIE INDEPEND-
ENT writes for his paper:
1.-THE public is patiently awaiting
a Supreme Court decision in that
Walter @. Smith habeas corpus
ca e."
At noon the breeze reaches the
Bulletin Office aud here was the
result:
"May it please the court, and if
it 10 not contempt, what has be-
come OF the latest struggle OF the
Supreme Court with habeas corpus
proceedings3'
At 3 p. M: The Justices OF the
Supreme Court filed slowly into
the room and affirmed the decision
of the Circuit Court to send Wal
ter g.. Smith, editor OF the Adver-
tiser. to prison for 30 days for con-
tempt OF Court, Too.tool
The Independent. [volume] (Honolulu, H.I.) 1895-1905, 1902-06-06

at hand these sweltering volcanic
weather days. 1t must be an omen
OF something that msy yet occur,
or mayhap the sweeping away OF
the missionary faction for the de-
secration OF the old "hennery" or
incubator" Surely it was at ran
dom and crazy last night aud the
trustees or the pastor should see
to it that it don't GET off on any
such freakish rackets any more,
otherwise prosecution will be
made for being a common nuisance
for disturbing the quiet OF night.
This is not the first time, but it is
one OF those periodical capers OF a
worn and played out old time
server in which it has seen it's best
days.
The Independent. [volume] (Honolulu, H.I.) 1895-1905, 1902-06-06
TOPICS OF THE DAY.

1t is rumored on the sire cts &C.
day that the attorneys for Walter
g. Smith and the Advertiser have
decided not to apply for a writ OF
habeas corpus in the U. S. Dis
trict Court as it would entail too
much time aud expense. By wait
ing for Governor Dole who will
arrive this afternoon, matters will
be simpli6ed great deal, aud a 10 t
of money saved. But, although the
chief Executive returns with the
hearty endorsement and support OF
the Administration, will he dare
nulliiy the decisions Of the Circuit
The Independent. [volume] (Honolulu, H.I.) 1895-1905, 1902-06-06

The old clock Of old Kswa ahao
Church tolled at midnight last
night as il it was the toll of warn
ing to the dead there slumberipg
10 their peaceful sleep, for it toll
ed the hour Of twelve and more
Increasingly for over ten minutes
What's the matter with the old
clock or rather its keeperi The
exertion must have told when it
was being toIled or tolling 30 that
the dead may be told to rise up
and be judged, for the day Of
wrath and Of judgment was nigh
The Independent. [volume] (Honolulu, H.I.) 1895-1905, 1902-06-06
a eymnasium Exhlbitlon !.

The annual gymnasium exhibition
OF the Young Mems Christian Asso-
citation will take place this evening
at 1880 o'clock. The program will
consist of maze run, bar bell drill
horse and parallel bars, bag punch
ing, high horizontal bare, tree eKer-
cises, and dumb bell drill, low
horizontal bars and springboard
jump, gymnasium games, hand and
Indian wrestling.
The Independent. [volume] (Honolulu, H.I.) 1895-1905, 1902-06-06
TIE HAWAIIAN
JOCKEY CLUB.
Eighteenth Annual Meeting
June nth and 18th, 1902.
Races June 18th.

FIRST RACE-UNION FEED
co. CUP: Oue.half mile dash;
purse, 500.
SECOND RACE = TROTTING
AND PACING: 2:30 class;
best 2 in 3, mile heats; purse,
$3.50.
THIRD RACE-POLO PONY
RACE, owner to ride-Three-
eighths mile dash; $50 cup.
FOURTH RACE = WAIKAPU
CUP: To beat Garteline's time,
1l6: Three.fourths mile dash,
free for all; purse, 500.
FIFTH RACE-RAINIER CUP:
Trottiug and pacing, free for
all; best 3 in 5 heats; purse, $3.50
SIXTH RACE-ROSITA CHAL-
LENGE CUP: Free for all,
Que mile dash; $50 added il
Vioris' time Of 1:45 is beaten;
purse, 5000.
SEVENTH RACE = GENTLE
MEMS DRIVING RACE:
One mile, free for all members
OF the Jockey Club who have
never driven for purse, owners
to drive. First prize, $50 cup
and Toomey cart; second prize,
buggy; third prize, set harness.
EIG nth RACE FIVE
EIGHTHS MILE DASH:
Free for all; purse, 500.
NINTH RACE-OCEANIC S. S.
CO.'S CUP: Three fourths
mile; Hawaiian bred; purse $25.
TENTH RACE-ONE AND ONE.
FOURTH MILE DASH: Free
for all; purse, 500.
The Independent. [volume] (Honolulu, H.I.) 1895-1905, 1902-06-06
W. G. SMITH IN CONTEMPT.
Frear and oalbraith Uphold Action
of the Circuit Court in Contempt
Eaea

trear ana 9albralth Upholu Actlou
of the Circuit Court in Contempt
Case.
After more than two months OF
delberation and study, the Supreme
Court yesterday affirmed the deci-
sion OF the Circuit Court, adjudging
Walter g. Smith, Editor OF the
Advertiser, guilty OF contempt, and
demanding him to the custody of
the High Sheriff to serve term OF
thirty days imprisonment. 1t was
$40 yesterday afternoon when
the three Justices filed into the
room, snd took their places on the
bench. Mr.. Smith was present in
person and was accompanied by
W. o. Smith, A, Lewis, jr. and Lor-
rim Andrews, his attorneys, and
Lorrin A Thurstou, proprietor OF
the Advertiser. George A. Davis
was there on behalf OF the Circuit
Judges. There were besides several
attorneys preeent, and representa-
tives OF the Press. "In the case CT
OK parte Walter G.. Smith, the Court
remands the prisoner TO the custody
OF the High Sheriff; the opinion
OF the Court will be fled" With
these words from Chief Justice
Fresr, Justice Perry dissenting, the
famous contempt case grown out
OF the famous McSwilligan cartoon
reached another stage, and the
Editor OF the Advertiser was sent TO
Jail to there, await for further pro.
ceediugs.
The decision OF the Supreme
Court remanding the prisoner to
the custody Is a yoluminous one. 1t
is written by Chief Justice Frear
and Justice Galbrsilh writes con-
curing opinion. Justice Perry dis
sents In lengthy opinion as we'll,
The following i, the syllabus
governing the opinion of the ma
jority;
"On habeas corpus to test the
validity OF judgement for coz
tempt the Court may consider
questions OF mere irregularity OF
error.p
"All reasonable amendments are
made in favor Of the jurisdiction Of
superior court OF record when their
Judgments are attacked collaterally.
whether an answer under oath
by one cited for contempt operates
as purger or not depends on the
circumstances.
whether all three Judges OF the
First Circuit may sit court or not
is immaterial if, when they do sit
together, the presiding Judge for
the term substantially conducts the
proceedings and finally pronounees
judgment as il he alone constituted
the court, the others being deemed
to sct iu an advisory capacity only"
The Independent. [volume] (Honolulu, H.I.) 1895-1905, 1902-06-06

March 5, t902.-Secretary OF War
Root, with the Gardener report in
his possession, replies to General
Miles, denying that the war is being
conducted with marked severity
and asserting that on the contrary
it is being conducted on humane
lines.
The Independent. [volume] (Honolulu, H.I.) 1895-1905, 1902-06-06
ASSOCIATED PRESS D1 PATCH

MANILA, April rs, 1870 The trial
by court martial OF General jacob
d. Smith on the charge OF conduct
prejudicial to good order and dis.
cipline began today. Colonel
Charles A. Woodruff, counsel for
the defense, said be desired to aim
pity the proceedings. He was
willing to admit General Smith
gave instructions to Major Waller
to kill aud burn and make Samar a
bowling wilderness; that he wanted
everybody killed capable OF bearing
arms and that he did specify all
over ten years OF age, as the S,mar
boys OF that age were equally as
dangerous as their elders.
The Independent. [volume] (Honolulu, H.I.) 1895-1905, 1902-06-06

April s, 1902, Major Waller,
Captain Porter and Lieutenant
Halfofd testify before court martial
in Manila that General Smith or
dered Waller to make Samar q
bowling wilderness and kill all ma
lives over 10 years old.
The Independent. [volume] (Honolulu, H.I.) 1895-1905, 1902-06-06

March 25, 1902, Secretary Root
ridicules General Miles suggestions,
disputes his assertions, scolds him
for mentioning the Gardener report
and seeks to discredit that report
in advance Of investigation,