davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1902-07-06
SALT LAKER ROBBED.
r. E. Ellsberry Loses Watch and
Money in Denver.

The Denver Republican says:
''R. f. Elisberry, who resides in Salt
Lake City and who was stopping at
the Markham hotel, was held up last
Friday night and robbed OF a watch
and chain and s25 In money He does
not know on what street the robbery
took place, as he is a stranger in Den
YER"
Mr. Ellsberry's name does not appear
in the Salt Lake City directory.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1902-07-06
Leather Runters Meet.

Two crowds OF leather bunters, one
representing the Robinson Shoe com~.
pany and the other playing for the
Vincent-Nott Shoe company met in a
match game Friday. The Vincent team
won the game by a score of IA to s.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1902-07-06
Ready at Henley.

Henley, Eng, July Sin the draw for
the preliminary heats this afternoon the
Arg6nauts were pitted against UniyeF-
sitY college. oxford. Third Trinity rowed
over the full course this evening in Z
minutes 9 seconds, Notwithstanding the
fact that Gibbons, the new stroke, Was
not in training
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1902-07-06
Infants Defeat White Wings.


noon was closely contested, the young
men winning out by score of IS TO Is
The extremely cold weather and high
wind were largely responsible for the big
score. The game has stirred up a good
deal of riyalrx between the teams. and IL
IS probable another game win be played
in the near future
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1902-07-06
Oxford PLAYERS Out.

London. July 5.-The Oxford players in
the annual cricket match with Cambridge
which began Thursday were all out today
for Isl runs in the second inning. Cam
bridge won the match by five wickets-
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1902-07-06
Game at Lagoon Today.

the Lagoon this afternoon, the game
being called at $3.50. A special train
will leave the city for the game at 2:30
and return immediately after the
game is over. Quick will be on the
rubber for Logan and Jensen or Kelly
for the White Wings.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1902-07-06

bases on balls, off Borchers 2 off Hart
zeII 2: hit by pitcher, Kimerer; two-base
hit. Scare; double plays. Brockhoff TO
Stoney TO Ramey, Adams to McNichols to
Huston: struck out, Brockhoff, HartzeH
. Waterbury, Hoffer, Schils, Kelly, Mar
gets 8: stolen bases. Huston, Kimerer 2:
sacrifice hits. Stoney, Brockhoff. Ramey;
left on bases, Salt Lake II, Logan 3. At
tendance, 500. Time, 200. Umpire, Rich
ards
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1902-07-06
RAZOR JACK" CAUGHT.

Chased an Intended Victim Several
Blocks
Jack Richardson. whose pronounced
preference for a razor as d weapon
has gained fer him the name of Razor
Jack at police headquarters, was ar
rested last night on the charge of at
tempted assault with a deadly weapon.
An argument arose between him and
another man on West Temple street
last night and in the fight which fol-
lowed Richardson is said TO have
drawn razor and chased the man for
several blocks He was outdistanced
and the fugitive escaped unhurt.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1902-07-06
WINS RACE AND
BREAKS RECORD
Gold Heels Captures the Rich
Brighton Handicap.
COULD HAVE GONE FASTER
MAKES WONDERFUL PERFORM
ANCE CARRYING I26 POUNDS.

NJ EW YORK, July Son track that
crowd of $4,000 persons. f. c. Nc
Lewe & Co.'S Gold Heels. faEorite in
the betting at 10 to TO- galloped home
an easy winner in the Brighton handi-
cap at Brighton Beach race track to-
day. He not only beat Jack Points
record of 2.04 s-5 made in 1900, but
established a new worlds record for a
circular track.
The time for the mile and a quarter
was 2:o3 As, within i-20 of second
of the worlds record (2:033z, made by
Banquet in 1890 with los pounds up,
on the straight course It the Mon
mouth Park track The performance
of Gold Heels was really wonderful,
considering that he was carrying 126
pounds. There is no telling how fast
this great horse could have run If
Odom had ridden him out.
The big crowd that made the trip to
Brighton today was much surprised
by the appearance of the new Brighton
race track. The new club house, erected
last winter at a cost of $50, 900, COM
pares favorably with any in the coun-
try.
Field Snail But Select.
The field that made up the handicap
was small but select. Gold Heels was
always a consistent fav0rite for the
race at Is TO 10, with Morningside sec
ond choice at to l and the keene
entry, Port Royal, next in demand
at to 1. The start was prompt and
good. Blues was first TO show, with
Gold Heels second. Northern Star third
! and Herbert fourth. AS they came past
the stand the first time, Northern Star
was leading by two lengths, Blues sec
ond, Port Royal third. Turning into
the back stretch, Northern Star still
, had daylight bewteen him and his field,
with Blues still in second position. Her
bert raced up to third place.
This order was maintained down the
back stretch At the three-Quarters
pole Herbert had his nose in front,
! with the favorite following, and Ten
Candies, who was slow to begin, in
third place Turning into the stretch.
Odom got the faVorite In the lead, and
from there to the wire he was never
in doubt. winning easily by half a
length from Blues, who was head in
front OF Argregor, who closed very
gamely. -
First race. the AuteiI stakes, mile
and three quarters, on seven hurdles
McGrathiana won. Charawind second,
Star Chamber third. Time-s:2o.
Second race, mile and an eighth
Bonnibert won, y Keynote second,
! Swamplands third. Time-1:52 2-5.
! Third race, selling, five furlengs--
I Ahuuaada won. Clinque Vale second,
Warte NIGHT third. Times As.
Fourth race, the Brighton. handicap,
mile and a quarter-Gold Heels won,
Blues second, Argregor third. Time
2:03 As. 'o9 lH4
Fifth race, six NEUTRALITY-SUSPICIOUS.
Won. Monte Carlo second, Birsch third.
( Time-1:14 Is.
Sixth race. selling, mile and a SIX
! teenth-Fatalast won, Early Eve Sec
ond Criterion third. Time-1:5O.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1902-07-06
soldier Not Allowed to Fight.

Guthrie, o. T., July 5.-The war de-
partment stopped the boxing contests
at Lawten, scheduled for this week, by
fOrbidding any soldier TO engage in a
fight with q prize offered.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1902-07-06
santrv Gets Decision.

Indianapolis, July Eddie Santry and
Young Aowatt, both OF Chicago, went
ten ROUNDS 10 a decision AT she EInplIs
awarded the decision
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1902-07-06
WESTERN LEAGUE
Standing Of sceams.

AT st. Joseph-Peoria. 4; st. Joe. 8.
At omaha-Denver. 6: Omaha. 3.
At. Kansas City-F1ansas City, IL; Nil
waukee, 10.
At .Des Moines-Colorado Springs, B.;
Des Moines, Q.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1902-07-06

Ephraim. July 5.-The game of baseball
played by the married men and single
men at the baseball park yesterday after
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1902-07-06
A DAUGHTER.

The home of Professor and Mrs Henry
E Giles las Fourth street was frightened
early this morning by the. advent of a
underground girl. All WELL
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1902-07-06
Radon & williams.

40 East Second South Meat market.
None but expert meat cutters employed
here. Phone 12s.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1902-07-06
Slightly Different.
lChicago Pest.l

''She shines in society, they say"
Yes. and she blazes at home, I'm in
formed.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1902-07-06
Diseased Cities.


If cities are diseases, New York is vel
low fever, Philadelphia is old age. Brook
1yn hay fever and Boston acute mania.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1902-07-06
NATIONAL LEAGUE.
Standing of Teams.

Pittsburg. July 5.-Brooklyn's remark
ably fine work in the field defeated Pitts
burg. Several times the locals were in
the Brooklyn fielders pulled down almost
impossible chances. Attendance, 6,09S.
Score:
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1902-07-06
AMERICAN LEAGUE.
Standing Of Teams.

Boston. July a.-Dlneens witness
proved costly today, three Of his four
batted hard in the early innings, but
steadied down toward the close of the
game Kelley and Setback fielded bril-
iiantly Attendance, 1900 Score:
Boston =. 10
Batteries-Dineen and Warner; McGin-
nifty and Robinson.
Detroit. july 5-Detroit hit sudhoff
safely in every inning after the first,
while the st. Louis team could not mt
base hit in the fourth, followed by Wall
iaceis single. scored St Louis run. At
tendance, 100 ScoTe-
Detroit . ...............--..--.-...6 II
ST hegis Mercer ana BueioN; sudhoff
and Donahue-
-P6iIadeIphia. July 5.-Wiltz was inef-
fectiye today and was taken off the slab
In the fifth inning. after Washington had
clinched the game. Attendance, 4,soe-
Score.
washington :. ...-.......-....----- 10
Philadelphia =. .---.--------:
Batteries-Csrrick and Clarke; Witt,
Husting and Schreek,
will and easily won today's game. Piatt
was hit freely. but not eonsecutiVely, ana.
with perfect support. would have shut
out the visitors. Attendance, .5,5so- Score
cs,..ro Il Il 4 Z
Batteries-Piatt and Sullivan; joss and
BemiS.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1902-07-06

Ompire-EmS1e.
Chicago July 5.-After having practice
ally won the game by pretty hitting in
the seventh and eighth, the locals went
to pieces in the ninth and allowed Bos-
ton to tie the score after two outs, on
errors by Lowe and Tinker and three sin
giles. Attendance, $500 Score:
{ 1cago ....---..--.----.--.-->-.- Is
Batteries-Williams and Killing: Pittin-
ger and Moran.
Umpire-Cantillon-
St Louis. July 5.-St. Louis shut out
New York this afternoon after pitchers
battle MattheWson's wild pitch in the
second let in St Louis only tally. At
tendance, 5000. Score:
ST LOUIS (
New York ...........-..-.-.-----r.- " L
Batteries-M ONein and J. ONeill;
MatfheWson and Yeager.
Umpire-0Day.
Cincinnati. July 5.-Cincinnati won to-
dav through comedy of errors on the
part of Philadelphia. Attendance, 100.
Score:
Cincinnati .-.-.--.-.-.-.-...-..o ~
Philadelphia -->-------- --..-..-.
Batteries-P Philips and PETIT; Duggle-
by and Doom.
Tmpires-Power and Brown.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1902-07-06
Pacific Northwest League.

Portland ofs-' jug r. H E.
Sat Batteries-Witbeck and vigneux: Hickey
and Stanley
Umpire-Dexter Smith
Helena, Mont. July 5.-score:
r H L.
Helena -.--a..-.----.-.---- -----
Tacoma $3.50 II 10 :
observation-disclosures, Sullivan and Flan-
merry; Drinkwater and keefe-
pire-Cunniagham.
Attendance-2,5ef.
The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1902-07-06
Sent Free
to Men.

Free Trial Package Of This New Dis
eovery Mailed to Every hAn
Sending Name and Address
Quickly Restores Strength
and Vigor.
Free trial packages Of & most remaTR-
able remedy are being mailed TO all Nns
win Writa the State Medical Lnsdtat4
Atlanta semi-weekly journal. (Atlanta, Ga.) 1898-1920, 1902-07-28
ROME SELLS CANTAL0UPES
TO NORTHERN MARKETS

ROME, Ca, July 25-J. c. Brownlee has
shipped five cars of canteloupes from his
farm near North Rome, and he contem-
plates packing at least twenty more cars
before the season is at an end. The exact
number of melons thus far sent to north
ern markets from this vicinity is, 5S4,3
The cantaloupes bring 80 cents per crate in
Cincinnati and New York Any number
of this fruit can be bought in Rome for
cents a dozen, or Is cents a crate. The
market locally was never so crowded. The
fruit is over ripe and will not do to ship.
The canteloupe industry has become a
decided factor in this section OF the state.
Several parties have recently combined
their land and will plant next year about
175 acres in cantaioupes. The shipments up
to this time from Rome and vicinity have
netted over $1,000. There are those who
predict this enterprise will yet rival the
peach culture and pay much better than
cotton and other staples. There would
have been many hundred cars to leave
Rome loaded with cantaloupes had 1t not
been for the unprecedented long drouth
which has prevailed. Next season will
witness a tremendous shipment of these
melons from north Georgia.
Atlanta semi-weekly journal. (Atlanta, Ga.) 1898-1920, 1902-07-28
EDWARDS is DEAD
FROM PISTOL SHOT

c. L. Edwards died Friday morning at
o'clock at the Elhin-Cooper sanitariuin as
the result C wound inflicted by the ac-
cidental discharge Of his pistol on Tues
day morning at his residence. al Spring
street
From the time Of the accident until his
death there has been practically no hope
for his recovery, and II has been known
that he was slowly sinking. Hemorrhage
followed hemorrhage, and the physicians
were at no time able to control them.
On Tuesday morning Mr.. Edwards was
standing before a dresser in his room
when he accidentally knocked pistol
from where 1t lay on che dresser and dis
charged II. Mrs. Edwards had just left
the room, where she had been to call
her husband for breakfast. On. hearing the
pistol shot she returned Immediately TO
the room and found her husband almost
mad with pain, but able to tell her how
tho accident occurred.
Mr.. Edwards was the southern repre-
sentative of the Hobart NJ. Cable Piano
company He was well known IN Atlanta
and In Opelika, where he formerly lived,
and was highly respected by all who
knew him. His tragic death has caused
great sorrow to his many friends.
Atlanta semi-weekly journal. (Atlanta, Ga.) 1898-1920, 1902-07-28
SUIT IS FILED
AGAINST
ROADS
INMAN & COMPANY WANT $751;
600 DAMAGES FROM COAST
LINE, L. AND N. AND THOMAS
K. SCOTT.

ATHENS, Ga, July %.-Because of al
legged failure to haul shipments Of cotton
from this place to Augusta. Ca, during
the cotton seasons of 1888, 1899 and 1900
suit for $4,000 damages has been filed by
the surviving partners OF the firm fof In
man & Company. against the Louisville
and Nashville Railroad Company. the At
Iantlc Coast Line and Thomas X. Scott.
The suit was filed this morning by
Messrs. Rosser & Brandon and George l..
Bell. of Atlanta, and w. II. Barrett. OF
Augusta. in the ONCE OF the clerk of the
superior court Of Clarke county.
The case viii doubtless attract consid-
cradle attention because OF the promi-
hence of the parties interested in it and
because of the legal questions involved,
which affect all OF the shippers and all
of the railroads doing business in this
state.
The grounds Of complaint in brief are
that Tnman q Company. during the cotton
seasons OF 1885 1899 and 1900, delivered TO
the. railroads in question 1000 bales OF
cotton az Athens Ca. for shipment TO
Augusta, and that the roads accepted IL
and gave their bill OF lading, agreeing to
carry e. Afterwards, says the bill, the
roads refused to carry 1t without any
lawful excuse and in wanton disregard Of
their duty as common carriers under the
statutes OF Georgia and in willful VIOLA
ton OF the rights OF Inman a Company
as shippers.
Inman 4 Company contend in the dec
laration that It was the duty Of the Louis
willie and Nashville and Coast Line, un-
der the laws OF Georgia, to haul the cot
ton in accordance with instructions. and
in accordance with the bill of lading, and
to do so without any unreasonable delay.
The refusal, says the bill, on the part OF
the roads TO carry IL in accordance with
their instructions and in accordance with
the bin OF lading and the consequent de-
lay makes the roads liable for a CONVEX
sion OF the cotton, and for whatever dam
age resulted to Inman e. Company, and
that the damage amounts to $4,000.
II is alleged in the declaration that the
defendant roads knew that their refusal
to carry the cotton would result in IT'S
being delayed. and they knew that the
delay would be injurious to fnman Com
pany, and that Innlan & Company be,
sought them from day TO day not to in
jure them in this manner, and that the
roads by carrying the cotton would have
made a profit out of ii. and that, there
fore, their course was the result OF a de-
lIberate purpose to injure Inman e. Com
pany. Therefore, It is claimed In the dec
laration. Inman & Company are entitled
TO recover punitive as well as actual dam
ages.
Atlanta semi-weekly journal. (Atlanta, Ga.) 1898-1920, 1902-07-28
RIVER AND HARBoR
IMPROVEMENT REPORTS

WASHINGTON, July 24.--The chief en-
gineers today received several annual re-
ports of officers in charge Of river and
haFbor improvements. making estimates
for the fiscal year 1904. Major James b.
Quinn submits the following for the Nor
folk Va, district:
Harbor at Norfolk and its approaches,
s2N, al; improvement of Hampton Roads,
Va, S215,0o0; Appomattox river, Va, $leo,-
900; harbor at Cape Charles City, Va,
$4O, OOe.
Captain J. C. Sanford submits the fol-
lowing for South Carolina:
Waccama and Little Pedee river, $500;
Great Pedee river. $4,000; Winyah Bay,
$3.50, 900; Wateree and Congaree rivers,
SO, 600; inland waterway between Charles
ton harbor and opposite McClellanville,
$50, 600; Charleston harbor. 25-foot project,
s1eO 900, and for 21-foot project. $4,000.
Captain c. S. Richie submits the follow
ing estimates Ior' the Galveston, Tex,
district:
Galveston harboF, $4,000.
Galveston ship channel and Buffalo
Bayou Texas to 100000 to complete the
project, $S4o0.00o.
Brazos River, Texas, $z75, 900; Brazos
River, between Velasco and Richmond.
West Galveston. channel, double bayou
and the mouths of both streams, $4,000.
Arkansas Pass, Texas. $4,000. to COM
plete the projects, Sls4SV,VVV.
Trinity River, Texas, S275,OO0; to complete
the project, $3.50, 0OO
Brazos River from Richmond to Old
Washinton, $4,000.
Galveston channel, 500 900; to complete
the project, $1.s45.0OO.
Captain Richie says that in substituting
oil IN place OF coal for fuel on the de-
cline in Galveston harbor makes a saving
OF 500 10 $1,000 per month.
Captain Spencer Cosby, of Mobile, Ala,
district:
Mobile harbor, $6O0,OOO; Black Warrior
river, from Tuscaloosa to Daniels Creek,
$500 OO0
Warrior and Tombigbee river, Alabama
and Mississippi. $780, Geo; Tombigbee river,
from mouth to Demopolis, $2S0,000.
Pascagoula river and Horn Island har-
Dor, Miss, S4O0O0o
Atlanta semi-weekly journal. (Atlanta, Ga.) 1898-1920, 1902-07-28
IS
SUFFERING
FOR WATER
THE CITYS SUPPLY IS SAID TO
BE UNFIT FOR DRINKING OR
DOMESTIC PURPOSES AND
LIMITED AT THAT.

COLUMBUS. Ga, July 24.-The question
Of water supply in Columbus is becom-
Ing to DO a serious one. For some time
tho water for drinking and domestic pur
poses has been unfit for use and those
who could avoid ii have not used any Of
it for week or two past. There has been
great deal Of complaint and physicians
who have visited the reservoirs during
the past few days pronounce the water
unhealthy and unfit for use. The supply
is not only limited, but the source Of sup
ply to the reservoirs has about disap-
peared.
A few days ago the water commenced to
give out very bad door. and when sew
eral citizens went out to the reservoirs
they were surprised to find that the upper
reservoir was very low and muddy, and
that the supply in the lower one was
stagnant, as the creek which furnishes
tho supply has dried up.
The matter was brought to the attention
of tho city authorities, and yesterday of-
ternoon a number Of aldermen, the mayor
and several members of the board of
health went out to the reservoirs to in
vestigate the matter. They found II as
reported and were generally in favor of
cutting off from this supply and turning
on tho fro service from the river.
The immediate cause OF the scarcity OF
water is tho long continued drouth. The
city. too, is rapidly growing and needs
moro water, while the capacity of the
waterworks is the same that II was years
ago.
A resolution has already passed the city
council instructing the preparation Of an
ordinance ordering an election for bonds
for new waterworks. This win be pushed
and the matter submitted to the people It
the earliest day possible
At the meeting Of the board Of health to-
day an analysis OF the sample OF Column
bus water was received from the state
chemist who decided that the water was
loaded with organic matter in a state Of
putrefaction and was, therefore, unfit for
drinking purposes. The board adopted
resolutions declaring the water unwhole-
some and UNIT for use and appointed a
committee to investigate the advisability
of the city using river water in lieu OF
the present supply.
Atlanta semi-weekly journal. (Atlanta, Ga.) 1898-1920, 1902-07-28
PUTNAM BRADLEE STRONG
DENIES THEFT OF DIAMONDS

NEW YORK. July PA special dis
patch from London to an afternoon paper
says that Putnam Bradlee Strong arrived
at Southampton today on the st. Paul.
sailing under an assumed name. In an in
terview he acknowledged his identity and
denied positively the charge that he pawn
ed May Yohe's Jewels. May Yohe, who
was formerly the wife of Lord Francis
Hope, sailed for Europe today on the
Fuerst Bismarck.
LONDON, July A.-Former Captain
Strong in conversation with a repre-
sentative of The Associated Press
this evening, said he had pawned
about So 400 worth of May Yohes jewelry
at her request and for her benefit after
they returned from japan, and that she
had received the entire proceeds from him
ct the time the jewels were pawned.
II never have had one dollar of May
Yohe's money and no person knows 1t bet
ter than She" he continued. THE money
on which I am now travelling was receiv-
ed from the sale of my library, and of
this fact May Yohe Is also aware. have
done many foolish and most unwise
things but they have not been criminal.
CAS- to my future movements, will say
that purpose living quietly and endeavor-
ing to redeem my good name
"As to the story that l rihed her safety
deposit box that is absurd on it's face.
May Aohe never. had any safety deposit
box that l know OF, and IL she had one
any banker could tell you that without
her authority I could never have had ac-
cess to II. had one in my own name at
the Knickerbocker Trust Company, which
I suppose my family has opened, as gave
them full authority to do so.''
Atlanta semi-weekly journal. (Atlanta, Ga.) 1898-1920, 1902-07-28
DUCKED NATIVES AND
ADMITS THE FACT

MANILA, July 2A-The court martial
of Lieutenant Edwin A. Hickman, Of the
Second cavalry. on charges, of having
ducked in a pond two natives of Taya-
has because they refused to guide him
to the stronghold of the insurgent lead
er Caballes, and with ducking a third
native, who died from the maltreatments
has been concluded after two brief sit
tings, and Lieutenant Hickman is be-
lieved to have been acquitted.
The defense admitted all the specifica-
lions in the first charge. excepting only
to the word unlawful and plead justi-
fication under general order No. 100, and
the conditions prevailing in Tayabas
province. The defense also produced
telegraphic order from General Chaffee
urging the location Of Caballes, regardless
of the measures necessary to do so. The
defense disclaimcd any desire TO shift the
responsibility and said the telegram pro-
duced showed the urgent necessity for
locating Caballes.
Lieutenant Hickman testified regarding
the charge that he had caused the death
Of a third native, and said that witnesses
at the Gardener inquiry testified that this
man died from injuries, that he was not
ducked and that he was not molested.
The prosecution disregarded the latter
charge as being unworthy of credence.
Colonel Smith, who was a witness for
the defense. testified that Major Gardener
was responsible for the charges against
Lieutenant Hickman. and said that Major
Gardener had sought for testimony to be
brought against the lieutenant