The Scranton tribune. [volume] (Scranton, Pa.) 1891-1910, 1902-01-04

| In addition also to the criminal prosecution
| against those who commit breaches OF the Grim.
| inal law, we have also courts of equity who will
enoin all such proceedings as are contrary to law
| and to equity. Our Supreme court bnyc used
| no uncertain language on this subject, The case
| Of 0'Ncil vs. Behanna Os2 Pa o3,) decided in
| 1897, s,istains this. That was case where bill
| in equity was filed avaipst strikors 10 res,rai,,
them from interfering with mon cmnloved in
their places and also fro,, .,ii;n,, ,bon, scohs,,
and "blacklers,, and nsinr othor forcc 70 dstor
| them from worlinv. aud ,iso for d,n,aoos ,,oool,
| to be sustained In conso,,,a,,, =, ,o;, ,,,ia,si
nets And the on;rion of I,a,;oo ,i,oi,o,, ,r,i,,,
| oovors tbis ,vho,n a,a,,n, T., w ,,,as,,,, a,,,
emnbatic tho, o,,e,o na, ,,,. .,o ,"i'S, "' ",
| HE onini,n ,,o 80 ">'V ">"'S '"' ""0'e Vi
|
JUDGE MlTCHELLS OPINION.
| "The le,rncd ;udgo Il, his on;n;o, so,s .,u,
Testimony establsbos tbo ,,n, ,hat oorta;n =, hn
defendants ovorstonnod thoso ho,,nd ,nJ ,soi a,-
| novance Intimidation rid;o,,,o ond oooro;or T.,
nroyert ,on , s.. . 'l" -, w, 'o' =, y
| plaintiH When tho now 7ne, ,oro foI,nnod and
| importuned not 10 vorl fron, ,bo;. ,,o;nt ~,
embarkation IN their ,,es,;ra,inn ani ,,nro ,,ot
by the strikers in co,.dor,hIo n,rohnrs AMI ,nl.
lowed TO thoir lndring ni,nos oil ,ho t;o ho;nr.
| nrcssed and en,roated 10 ret,,rn and oo,,oI
scabs' and .b,ncklegs, and son,ot;,o, nj
and the effort mndc 10 mil tbon, oyo,. m nm.
friendly I,t ,,os,I ,,,,r,,aro - a,nr,on,
fl.Dt fhara xpng ipu
more than mere arr,mnn. aod ,,ors,as'n an, !,
the orderly and 1euitin,,to cond,,ot NJ a etr;tc
This wns rtain,v aor;o,,, ,nnor,,oo ,,d ,,o,l
calculated 10 int;m;dato .,,- aoarao AL thnt
effect was apporentIv nro,,ced IN mora tlop ono
OCCASION Nor did such acts entirely end when
mon ,rara W., Nu u.s"n "o'n' o". Su..'
s va "ii' III .tH puo.le
tervoIs ~ Iahor ,n,, ad,.;saI .,, ,ia,n n,,,1 H.
trouble thor, ,,, +ha,. na, ha,,a" ,oa,,o "
aot,,I ,;a,on,,o "u na'': ... ,."u 80. ,,. e '
..Th; 4, Iii, n',., ,.',,.a,,.. wa, i,,,
man, ~ ,,i,t ,i "; ,;,,. -, e,'., ri,
atritor. " ,,h u"e eue'c e.eas ea'I"tu A.
so,,mo. oa,,,, a. a,,i '..i ~ INN ;'a .ne
shnrt os oa,,,,, ,r'a;,i 49,; w. "'' ,r,,;a as
s.r;o,,s ,,;saoraap,;ea ,r,e e',.,,., -, .o.
s,,,n;a., a'S, .a.lY, e " .:,n.4, 'e' t.c ps'
Az, ,,o, h,,,I r ,,o,1,,o.. ,..a. - Iii, -
rar,,, ,I;ol ~. a,noo,,. ,, I;.,;t =, s,,,"a
rio a;snio, ~ So nn,,.,, as ,, " a.,,an,
,,saJ :; ;n,;,,;l,t;an , - E ,',,'s1 =,
,.ioIanaa ;tsoit "'' 80 ''''-" ''''''' ''' 80
a., -. ., - A.. A.,
on,,. aonn."a,,oJ -" ~, ,,s 80 ~, ~, ti,s
80, 10 =; -, u" Wv ..I =, o' . " ~ wy
a,,d +,; a,,;,.ai -; Ill 80, nm D. ,,,; H.
a;so l., tan a,,s - - h;aa ,I,, o,, ,,,,r,aso ,, -
@ha,. ,os;ro1 l.; ,,oo, s,;tr, t ,,ai ,,a'ooah,,
a,i ,a,s',,l,. sow ,'o ,'' e' ,,a,. eta,,S
I, -, - -, a,:,, -, .'s' ot ~
- s,aa s.o,,, ,'o ', es,,,s' Ill
.I, e - ,':t -, A., ,,
sr a., Vs., "'' M a.''s., ''e 80. ..
- ~ -, a. IL 's . ~ "a %
r.,,nt ,i,o,, noro thora ton an, ,,o; rro,'roo In
Ia it, -, a"t t'
I ut.ae ,".n ieIi ,,''."''one wv P'"'''s ''' any
'''''' '''''"'' y" '''e'' p''' w 0A'''
NO RIGHT TO PERSUADE.
81, is frrthor nr,od that tho strilers t|rouoh
tbo; co,,mittoos onl,. oxorc;sod I.inisted On, is
rho nbroso thoir counsel usc in th;s conrn tbeir
r;nht - t,,, IN tto ,,or ,,,on e.. ,,or,,a,Io tior,
Tbosc men vorc thor, nresumobIv under con.
tr,ct wifi, tho n,a;ntif, and certainly in search
M worl, II NOT yot ,otu,lIv under nay. They
wore not ot loisrrc and their time whcthcr their
own mr. their omnIover's could not lawfully bc
taken nm and their nro.rcss interfcrcd wifi, by
thee or onr othor outs;,,er, nm ony nrei,nso or
,mdor any claim or r;gbt, TO arp1,c or ;,crs,ade
them to breat their contracts Exon thcreSore,
IL Tho ARGUMENTS and ners,,osions had been com
6nod +o lawn, means tbev were cxertel at IN
;,,nr,nor t;n,a and voro an ;nterferonco with tho
nIa;ntif,s rights which made the perpetrators
i;ahIc for any damages Tho nlaintif suffered in
ao,ao,ronoa p,t ;r s,ot .,o;r o,To,ts wore not
,on,;rad 70 Lawful n,o,ne THO reeuIt of tho owl
donno &c s+atod h, tho Ioarned irdgo ia that thc
now, n,on noro .fo1,ovod onI ;mnor,,ned not IN
,vor, IRON, tboir no;nt ~ rkotion "a tbeir
destiro,ion and thero mot bv tbr strikers in con.
siJerahle numbers called .scshs, and blncklers.
eiu,'doP "u"o.'o' "' .a't,' So . H
;S CuH iont1
f.vor,hI. 10 tho defondants and as already said
- hoa,;, ,n; tI.oo ton;n,r orou.d doo, NOT rood ia
,. 70 oot,,,I ,;n,onoo 10 ho ,,,i,ty ~ unlawful
;r,;,;a,,;on nh ants ., those d,;o,donts wore
m ,nIow,nl ;ntorsorcnce with tho rights of the
,au, ,,on arL viii th,so of tho nlaintis In
Coto ys Mrrnbv 15o p, 400 II ia said hv our
noat,s r., ~. i. onn of ,bo ;nd,,onsihro
,,,','4 Dan' ,; t"Ss " ,,horo,, =; t,; oomn,on.
.a,.1 Y. an a'ai "n lie sor,.;oas as bo
go. ,,.on,, ,nJ ,,nda. tho oonstiiuti,n ,bere is
~, d,,or ,odnod ,,,,,h.ro to comneI him 40 yor,
ro. Io"s +hon ho chooses to occent .nor "a tbr
w less .'., ". go, Iii, ra,oronoo a. M,
49, 80 r.o,,o,t he w,rLi,s, Cor such nav ,s bc
80 80 :. - - ~ nit. -. a,aot wo ror,rd +ha
ta. ~. a"a 80 5,s.',; hat ,ro dc,ond,nts
,roro I ci,tv Of an nnla,yfnI combination which.
,',,,;I, rooss;rn t,'" in,ontion and irving 70
maintain an outward appearance OF lawlessness,
was carried out by violent ana threatening con.
duct, which was equally VIOLATION OF tne f'gn's
OF the new men, VINO came 10 Worh ior Tue pam.
tin ana OF the p'aih'lH heist'' anu '''l We!
are ranle IN th'S sun lHr u, '',e a"'1ns'' WIZ
p'aihtiH suherSa ."el'py, ine '',aS,'
reports mat az, oI '',e uplrhua"'S @'T "',"ue"
III t,c 'e,'t N''tNe.S' 80 "'' ~ '''', ~ , ,u
port, anu Tue "s',r"o''H 80 '''ip', V '""" W
Part'clpatcu peISo'aiN ~ WV n''am,' ,,Inn a.
w w III su'n e""'o','t'o' 90 "aue ~" s ,h b
'hc "els ol 'uc o'.''s uo" - h. 1o'", n,oho
so''no" p"' t''.. -, =, sn; h, u ao,,,,
~" +" % "s t ,a non.. thot ,ho n,.o was |
sea a'' ,s.nn t s,,ii,o ,',s o,,or II anncars IN
tu'"'" tt4 m iii va, las ,ioiont and dis |
W ,a'' 'n'' rn' I'i ,',ooa,,oJ n "u
.,',it '''n .,,' A., h,a ,oryadod tbc rnmmun
i,,' avon thn court not hcing entirely exempt |
thnt tho strike brinp over. the subject had bet
,on Ia J,,nnnd rrhi, is NOT f,,v NOR ius,irc A |
,IaintiF ,hn might have becn hur worse than
T." '.as NAV hc inclined mi to nush his claim
for COMPENSATION for The injury actually received |