The Scranton tribune. [volume] (Scranton, Pa.) 1891-1910, 1902-08-22


,.,., ,,,, s,oa >osterdav NV
A' op ,,y ,,,,..a 20 yy,,kes-Rarre.
Judge r. w W'e"o' ,.s,.,, To-
with Prothohotars Jun, ,,.!,.,, t.,
the equity case Oh y. w. 1"ein'es ~
which he refuses to continue the pre-
linjnary Injunction restraining M. w.
cra,nsev fro,n usin. the word "Guern-
-, 80, ,,nno, Tha on;nion follows:
eey VII p,,...,.n,, ,n;,nctinn enioins the
.s,,. ne frn,,, so,,ing leasing or hand
ueieua ,,.. ~ a,,,. ,,a,ner nianos with the name
i,ns s ,Ii any ,.ai,a,, nr th,,,,
Wn,h n,a;ntiff and defendant have for
botn plall',l. s'"a sa,ors i' nianos mr..
in,s ~, ,,,,,.,o,i s,,,nIies IN the city of
Scranton. They are not related to each
other. .,o, .,,o
me pi'nt'ii mas @ @ .i.N ,,,,. -. ,,;eforent
Single name ~ ot ,,'ao, ns The C,olum.
times as j. w. 'ue1,,ses, ~, gsn,, .s , ,,,onr;a.
@ @"uo ~, , ,u'. 80 ,iI r w GUERNSEY pro-
tor; Guernsey riall: o. , traaed ,nder
prietor. me uelvnoa,i. .,l n,.,,, ,aa and cmern.
'he nahe vi N'' W. ou'' '''.'
seS p.o.,e'. ',..,e. ,, ,,a,.or hoon -, nonufac-
ihe p."in.lil i''s nv s.r..,on. &C Cuern.
turer OF pianos, t,e ~, 1000 20 1901 on
sc! pro,hHiS Mas fo.,,,a nr ,,;,nos
Easeu III ane Ina. ano t,,e defendant be-
Aoou, one yea, aso ,s to ndii,g an I'm
Eai. sei,.',s' .a7I ..crornsov, This
iisilt pi'.o ,;aot;nn and n ia
piano was .'a,,ant =, tho niono
, .ial''eu ',rp,,t,,rnd m h, tho defendant
~ i's 'rna.,,,oa ~ Now york nv n
!. 10 'I.'1 ..''..a,,n + n,,ns aud de-
tnlro parry, atso,a's ~, ~, rs so,,,a axtent oriri.
s1ehs' claiiie" ~ NC u,.,,;, cmarnsov :.
!a', ue'i'e Ds e,aart ,,,ho testified
.,t nIot'e. VI 'a,,,o "r.mernsev,, stenciled
wa. wy nc. Iu,,,,;n,,,.s, own name and
tne,eo..' l.. MS ~ t,nra hv his authority to
traac-nlark. ,.er lu. .me o,,d ~ ,n,entor Of this
pur'ieu.ai NM ,,,..,, ", P' tn tho hiIl
seS Is nov ,.,5o :" ~ Mic n,no in raised
~. NV H. ,,,ords .f.uernsev Rroth-
ie..ers' &c .c ,',,,,o,, ~. oros ;,
ei9' Vi
DIDN'T USE WORD GUERNSEY.
rr,,, n,,;,t;r never sold. leased or ham
z,os , ,;,nn orran or other musical in
.trm,,,on+ mon which the name Guernsey
a,onn ,v.s nlaccd either by stencil or
n,Lorr,;so
I,,,o,, e. T noro to reiect the Testimony
80 v-;i,;n,,, c:uornsev and If is not con-
.,1;otnr,, ~, ,rd nvon if the nlaintiff had
, ~ ,,,,o c,,ornsev either nv STEM
Ii ~, nthorniso .s a distinctive mark for
49, 49,. " ,a oto by hin tha use Of the
' l.,', . ~ n,,,,...o, H., ti,o dofond.nt without
M WI" .',u.,,a ~. ,,,rrort tho continuance
io,I ,'.a,;,,;,,r,, Injunction
VI .,e - =. ,,.,,o or :. ,orson or of a
.,l. ne ,,v, '., n., ~ rorer,1 ruJe be ammo
IL of
uin''eu a' 90 no,ont;nr anothnr norson
,ne se"ss ~ oa ~ 1--WE -. rns;dinr in the
lawns ,,nto .nu frn,,, ,,sinr it So IN con-
test between persons of the same name
"Darlington' the supreme court says:
"tiad they. the plaintii1s. useu merely
Che name "Darlington, any other per-
son of that name could nave staIpeu u
his butter as Darlingtons putter.
Iratt's Appeal. III Pa. p. AID. tsee also M
Carmichael VS.. Lattlmer, IL II: L. no, 90
Turton VS.. Turton, H. H. 42ch. i,iV l-e,.
Tho plaintiff does not dispute thls as
general proposition or law. out Alleges
that the defendant Is within inc eNcep-
tion to the rule which VIII not permit
man to use even his own name IN
fraudulent manner to the damage or an
other of the same name.
Cases defining the exception are as nn-
merous and as clear. as cases deflnihG the
rule. "They rest upon fradulent use or
name."