davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
Alexandria gazette. [volume] (Alexandria, D.C.) 1834-1974, 1902-02-12
Briaande Attack Miss Stones Captors

Vlenna, FEB. IA dlspstcn IRON
Sofa today Gays that another band Of
nrigands has attacked the csptors OF
Miss Ellen N. Stone, the American
missionary, IL tending to seize her and
secure the ransom for her release. a
desperate encounter occurred between
the two bands, the dispatch ssys, and
twenty Of the brigsnds we're killed and
Injured. Miss stone miraculously es.
capped injury. The account does not
say which band got the American mis-
eiona.y,
Alexandria gazette. [volume] (Alexandria, D.C.) 1834-1974, 1902-02-12

The fields of ice have demolished 300
feet OF the sea end OF the ocean pier
at Cape May.
Alexandria gazette. [volume] (Alexandria, D.C.) 1834-1974, 1902-02-12
FIFTY-SEVENTH CONGRESS.
Washington, D. c., Feb. II.
SENATE.

10 the Senate this morning Mr.. Turn
err 10 presenting q memorial from the
Antitrust League alleging the viola.
ton by certain existing organizations
IF the Sherman antitrust law, aDnounc
ed that upon the charges made therein
against the At orney General be did
10; care TO be- understood as having
taken a position. Owing to the high
Standing, however, of thoJe peiitioninR
Congress- to take such action as would
vlndicate its own laws, he asked permls-
ion to have the memorial printed In
he Record.
Mr. GslliDger objected. He did got
hlnk 1t proper to load up the Record
With uusubt tar tiated charges against b
cabinet officer.
At ~ 80 the Philippine tariff bill was
taken up, Mr.. Teller continuing his
remarks beguu yesterday. Mr.. Teller
believed that there was not court 10
The world that would declare the flo
lonos were technically or actively quits
OF treason, because the natives never
owed us allegiance.
The memorial was referred to the
commit 20 on judiciary.
HOUSE.
Chaplain Cou1en 10 his prayer in the
House today referred feelingly TO the
memory OF Abraham Lincoln. "We
are now a united country; all the Bit
tsrness and strife OF the days OF civil
var have passed; today We thank the
Almighty for giving Us In those trying
lays that noble, loving character who
freed the oppressed aud saved the
nation"
Immediately after the invocation the
House took up the o eomargarioe bill.
The ayes aud nays we're called for
the Allen amendment passed yesterday
by she committee OF the whole, which
provides for the inspection and stamp.
ng OF renovated butter" The amend
mert was carried by q vote OF l52 to
l24.
All other amendments were passed,
whereupon Mr.. Wadsworth offered thu
minority bill of the committee as sub
stitute for the bill.
TIE motion to recommit the bill and
-ubstitute the Wadsworth measure,
vas lost by vots oi 16l to 116. The
DILL was then passed by viva voce
vote, after which the House went into
committee OF the whole to consider
claims.
Alexandria gazette. [volume] (Alexandria, D.C.) 1834-1974, 1902-02-12

Mrs. Elizabeth Hunton died in Fau-
quier county yesterday aged 81 years.
Alexandria gazette. [volume] (Alexandria, D.C.) 1834-1974, 1902-02-12
CITY COUNCIL.

A considerable volume of business,
mos ly 10 reference ID street improve
ments and contemplated sewering, was
disposed OF by the City Council at the
regular meeting Last night. The OH
cial proceedings will be found else
where. The Guy Eogineer submitted
q report on the resolution of iuquiry as
to the cost OF improving Washington
street from Duke TO Oronoco. The
figures range from $4,000 to $50, 542
according to width of roadway and
quality of material used. The lowest
price is for mscadsm and the highesi
for vitrified brick. This plan is under
the S3i section Of the city charter where
the property owners pay two-lhirds OF
the cost.
Alexandria gazette. [volume] (Alexandria, D.C.) 1834-1974, 1902-02-12
The Marker.

Georgetown, Feb. 19.-whost 75as2.
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29
THE VILENESs OF PORT SAID.
A Town Of $4,000 People without TIE n
Righteous Men, Says This
Authority.

There may be yiler towns than Port
Said. We have never seen them.
Leadville, in its most fiourishing and
fiercest days, could not equal this city
at the mouth of the Suez canal, says
a correspondent Of the Kansas City
Journal. If ten righteous men were
needed to save this town of $4,000 peo-
pie it would go unsaved. The inquiry,
"Do you want anything?" which, in
Egypt. covers multitude of sins, is
met with from small boys upon the
main streets. Vice which in Ameri-
can cities hides itself in the back al
legs here faunts itself in gay gauze
garb and brazen face upon the boule-
wards. 1t Is a made town, on made
earth and its manufacture is not NOR
ally a success. The few decent people
condemned by business necessity to
dwell in Port Said console themselves
by the assertion that all new towns
go through this period of viciousness
and Port Said is not a quarter Of a
century old. After seeing Port Said,
we do not wonder that Moses fed into
the wilderness.
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29
RUSSIA BARRED HIS BOOK.
Ominous Title of an American Au-
thor's Work Made the Authori-
ties Afraid OF 1t.

Press censorship came under discus
sion the other day during a lecture of
Prof Franklin II. Giddings, who occu-
pies the chair of sociology in Column
bia. In dwelling on the attitudes of
different governments the professor
mentioned the oppressive and not al
together Ineligible methods en-
ployed by Russia, and as an instance
he pointed to the fact that his work
on sociology is allowed circulation in
that country, whereas Mr. Lester f.
Wards book entitled Dynamic So
GEOLOGY" is under the ban of the cars
censors.
Turning to one of his students, who
happens to be Slav and who has en-
ioyed life under Russian rule, the pro-
fessor asked him if he could venture
an explanation.
"Why, easily said the young man,
according to the New York Times.
"The title of Mr.. Wards book on its
face condemns it in that country.
Dynamic is so much like dynamite
and Sociology like Socialism that the
average brilliant Russian censor
wouldn't have to think twice to know
his duty"
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29
WHALE FOUND IN ARIZONA.
The skeleton of a Very Large Speci-
men Unearthed in the Desert
Near Yuma.

In the museum at the University of
Arizona at Tucson has just been
placed the skeleton of very large
whale found on the desert south of
Yuma.
The find, says report from Phoenix,
has excited much attention from sci
entists and aroused discussion over
the manner in which the big fish came
so far inland. 1t has been said, and is
doubtless a fact, that virtually all of
southwestern Arizona and southeast
ern California was once covered by the
ocean and some scientists declare that
the whale was left high and dry when
the waters receded from that region.
1t is more likely, however, that the
big fish ventured into the Gulf of Cali
fornia and was washed by ID flood upon
higher land.
Other finds of valre from a scientific
standpoint have been made in the
same region. In the university mu-
scum are the tusks and lower jaw of
an elephant, which were found on the
Yuma desert. The size of the jaw and
tusks proves that the animal was of
larger proportions than the elephant
of to-day.
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29
PRESIDENT NOT so BIG.
cinI Expresses His Opinion of
the Nations Chief.

President Roosevelt was a distinct
disappointment to the young son of a
new government official.
When certain western man moved
to Washington recently to take a post
under the administration his eight
year-old son was eager to see the pres
ident, so the westerner took him to the
white house one morning and present
ed the lad to the president, says the
New York Times.
The boy had been impressed with
the idea that he was to see the biggest
man in the country, and he took it
literally, so when the president shook
hands with him the youngster seemed
to think that there was some mistake
about it, and asked:
"Are you President ROOSEVELT"
yes" said the president.
"Why, you amt so big" blurted ont
the lad, with the candor of youth.
Papa said you were the biggest man
in the country"
The presidents hearty enjoyment
of the lads idea of greatness set the
embarrassed father at ease and Presi-
dent Roosevelt explained to the boy
that it was the Office and not the man
that was big"
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29
Don't Starr Wrong.

Don't start the summer with linger-
ing cough or cold. We all know what
Il summer COLI" is It's the hardest
kind to cure, Often it hangs on
through the entire season. Take it in
hand right now A few doses Of One
Minute Cough Cure will set you right
Sure cure for coughs, colds, Group, grip,
bronchitis, all throat and lung troubles
Absolutely safe. Acts at once. Chill
dren like it. cone Minute Cough Cure
is the best cough medicine / ever used y
says J. II. Bowles Groveton, n H.
Il never found anything else that acted
so safely and quickly
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29
New and Improved Service to st
Paul and minneapolis

Via the North Western Line To fur
ther accommodate its many patrons en-
route to the Twin Cities from points
north Of Milwaukee, the Chicago x
Northwestern R'y now runs Free Re-
clining Chair Car on the evening train
Milwaukee, Via Fond du Lac, connect
ing at Appleton jet. with train leaving
Manitowoc at 4:20 L. NJ, connecting
with train leaving Appleton Jet 1925
p. NJ. arriving at st, Paul and Mime
apolis early the next morning, and con-
meeting Mt Mcmillan with similarly equ
ped train for Duluth and the Superiors.
Like service southbound, This in addi.
ton to the Pullman Sleeping Cars which
are run ON the same trains daily between
Fon du Lac and Minneapolis. Apply to
agents Chicago andNorth Western.
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29
RAILWAY FARM LAND FREE

In Northern Wisconsin on the North
Western Line. Low rates and easy
ternsof payments. About 400, 600 acres
of choice farm lands Early buyers will
secure the advantage of location on the
many beautiful streams and lakes
which abound with fish and furnish a
never ending and most excellent
water supply both for family and for
stock
Land IS generally well timbered, the
soil fertile and easy of cultivation Chi.
cago, Milwaukee, ST paul, Minneapolis,
Duluth, Superior Ashland and numer.
Gus other thriving cities furnish good
markets for farm produce.
For further particulars address Geo
w Bell Land Commissioner, Hudson
Wis, or g. H. McRca, A. q. =. A., ST
Paul Mimi
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29
The Wisconsin Central Railway

Maintains daily train service be-
tween Chicago Milwaukee, Manitowoc,
st. Paul Minneapolis, Ashland and
Duluth, reaching Eau Claire Chippewa
Falls, Marshiield; Hurley, Ironwood and
Bessemer as well as the principal points
of Wisconsin, nroute. Connections with
roads, running South, East West and
North are made Mt terminal points.
Pullman Sleepers are attached to all
night trains and meals are served A La
Carte. Any agent of the Wisconsin
Central Ry, will be pleased to give you
further information, furnish tickets and
reserve sleeping car accommodations
Jas G. Pond, Pass. Agt,,
Milwaukee, Wis
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29
VERY Low RATES To SAN FRANCISCO

VERY Low RATES To SAN FRANCISCO
AND RETURN,
Via the North Western Line. Tickets
will be sold May 81 to June 3, inclusive
limited to return within sixty 900 days,
on account Imperial Council, Mobiles of
Mystic Shrine. Through Drawing Room
and Observation Private Compartment
Sleeping Cars and Tourist Sleeping Cars
daily, Personally conducted twice II
n week Apply TO agents Chicago &
d North Western Ry. may 30
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29
SPAWN i.iniment.

English Spawn Liniment removes All
Hard, Soft or Calloused Tumps ond Blem.
ishes from horses, Blood Spavins, Curbs,
Splints, Sweeney Ring Bone, Stiles
Sprains, all Swollen Threats Coughs,
etc Save $50 by the use Of one bottle.
Warranted the most wonderful Blenlish
Cure ever known. Sold by f. c. Buer.
static
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29

Now is the time to look over your
Smoky Furnace and have rs remedy the
trouble and worry you've had the past
winter. Phone No - will call The
Rand * Roemer Hdw. Co
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29

The managers Of the Chicago Bras
works ut Kenosha on Saturday posted
a notice in their shops that in the future
half holiday would be granted TO each
Of the 800 men employed i'll the shop
and that the pay would remain the
same M the company has formerly paid
for the full weeks work. The new or.
der will go into effect on June and
continue in effect until the end Of the
heated season.
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29

Because her father objected to the at
tentions shown her by the young man
whom she loved and forbade her to
have anything more to do with him
Florence Putnam, the l7-year.ol
daughter Of II prominent DubuQ lie bust
ness man, eloped with Leonard Evans,
young man 10 wears old, aud at last
reports their whereabouts were I'M.
known. 1t is believed that they have
gone 10 Milwaukee, where Evans form.
erly resided The girls father believes
that he will be- able to locate them in
that city.
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29
RUPTURE!

Cured to stay cur
ed for life. Posi-
lively no knife OPP
GRAFTON or pain
and you can work
every day while
being cured The
strongest proof of
the wonderful Sue
cess Of our treat
ment is the names
of citizens of your
own county whom
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29

we have cured. We have cured humid
reds OF Others and can cure You.
rlanitowoc Co. Cures and Others.
Adam Nuhs, Esq, Manitowoc Rapids;
Edw. Ebert Cato, (son and daughter);
j r., Larrabee; Z. Schaubs, j. Jesse
and Aug. Bruss, Brillion; VIM. Gotter
and A. Stache, Potters; A. G. Maertz,
II. Haberer, G Wordell and F. Bubolz,
Reedsville; DR.. f. w. Nause,. Sheboy
gan; J. d. Kerker, Chiffon; c. Gutenecht
Mosel, and hundreds of Others whose
names we can give you, Write to them
and be convinced that we cure rupture.
We give FREE examination ut
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29
CONQUERS PAIN.

Mexican Quick Relief price % cents,
conquers all pain, subdues internal ache
and kills external torture. No other
remedy 50 sure to cure, so safe to apply,
Try it, For sale by f. G. Buerstatte.
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29

Just take into consideration the
clothes little Cupid doesn't wear and
You will no longer wonder why love
grows cold
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29

King Edwards cook is said to
draw salary about equal to that Of
a lieutenant general in the British
army. or an admiral of the feet.
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29

A deaf mute of Blackburn, England.
has been bound over to keep the peace,
because he used threatening deaf
and-dumb" language toward his father
and brother.
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29
The Dous of France.

France owns 1854, 900 dogs, 75 to
every 1000 inhabitants. The dogs are
registered and so can be counted Ger
many has 2,2oo 900 dogs.
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29
VERY Low EXCURSION RATES To

VERY Low EXCURSION RATES To
DENVER, Colo,
Via the North w estern Line Excursion
tickets will be sold June %, %, n and
-, with final return limit until Oct. 81,
inclusive, account International S. S.
Convention, Apply to agents Chicago
81 North Western Ry, june r.
EXCURSION TICKETS To ODD FELLOWS
GRAND LODGE AT LA CROSSE, WIS,
Via the North Western Line will be
sold at reduced rates June ., 3 and 4,
limited TO return until June z inclusive,
Apply to agents Chicago x North
Western Ry may %.
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29

The police of Kenosha want an un-
known tramp who committed n muir
derous assault on Jacob Karpen. The
tramp entered the saloon of Karpen,
which is near the limits of the city, and
demanded IA drink He was furnished
with liquot and when the bartender
demanded the pay he drew knife cut
ting Karpen in the wrist. The bar
tender seized "A beer bottle and felled
the tramp. but he was suffering from
the loss OF blood to such an extent that
he could not follow up the advantage.
The wounds Of karpen are serious, but
not necessarily fatal.
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29

district of Wisconsin during Cleveland 3
first term and was the Democratic
candidate for congress in this district
in 1896
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29

At special meeting of the city
council Of Prairie du Chen, Saturday
night contracts for the waterwOrks
system were LET rs follows Batchelder
Crosby * Mead of Lacrosse, for con
struction and reservoir, S8,O-j; United
States Cast Iron, Pipe and Fitting com
pany, for pipe, Sl152G.50; James b.
Glow q Son, Chicago, for hydrants and
valves 81, 1880 The plant complete
will cost $97, tOl The bids were let
subject to the sale Of bonds, but it is
expected that work will be commenced
~ soon as the material can be delivered
on the ground.
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29

The senior law class has succeeded in
obtaining Emlin McClain. A. NJ. LII D.
chief justice Of the Iowa Supreme court
10 deliver the annual address before the
college of law Justice McClain was
formerly the chancellor of The Law de
partment Of the University of Iowa and
is the author of n number of toxt books
on the subjects of criminal law and pro
cedurc and of the law Of common car.
riers. The members of the senior law
class consider themselves fortunate in
securing man like Justice McClaiu
because the committee which has had
the matter In charge has been cone.
spending for months with Senator
Chauncey Dcpew, General Bragg. ex-
President Grover Cleveland aud other
orators Of prominence with no success.
The annual address il II feature Of the
commencement exercises, last yc..g the
orator being w Bourkc Cochran of
New York The address win be given
In the gymnasium June 10
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29

Rasmus Anderson. formerly pro-
fessor in the University of Wisconsin
and now editor of The America at
Madison, Wis, was robbed of 800 by
burglars who entered his room at
Seattle Friday night. Mr. Anderson is
visiting his son in that city.
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29
Victoria Hotel, Manitowoc,
THURSDAY, June 5th

anu cNciy WV WtthS tHciedlOci'
A Rupture destroys your health and
endangers your life Why continue to
carry this burden? We give yon LIE
GAL WRITTEN GUARANTEE to cure you
permanently. We are established 10
years in Milwaukee and the success of
our cure proven beyond doubt or ques-
ton by more than 1000 cured cases. We
want all who are ruptured TO consult us
and learn how they can be rid Of their
dangerous affection forever and without
n knife operation. Write for free book
about rupture.
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29

Attorney w. II Rogers Of Madison
has been notified that A. +. Warden Of
Waukesha, chairman Of the Democrat
Sc state Central committee, had appoint
ed him = member of that committee
and iis treasurer 10 fill the vacancy
caused by the death Of ex Mayor NJ. ].
Hoyen The appointment is regarded
~ victory Of the Bird Rogers Regain
faction Of the party over the Awkward.
Reynolds Bull faction The former re-
present the ultra Bryan element of the
party Mr. Awkward professea 10 be- un
concerned oyCr the appointment The
other member Of the committee from
this district IA J w. Moore Of Water.
town. Mr. Rogers says ne will make a
strong effort 20 secure the state couvcn
ton for Madison Mr. Rogers gradual
ed from the academic department Of
the state university in 1873 aud from
the law schoO! year later. lie has
served A. mayor Of Madison two terms.
was district attorney uf this county
Ia 1871 and 1875. served ~ assistant
United States attorney for the Western
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29

Judge Hastings of the Circuit court
Saturday refused to grant Mrs. Augusta
Parsyczk a divorce from her husband
Mathew Parsyczk who asked it on the
grounds Of cruel and inhuman treat
ment. The Judge in giving his decision
said Of the woman: Her appearance
manner and tongue were enough to sat
isfy me, in the light of other testimony
that she was the disturbing element and
that the man who could live with her
without losing big temper would be
more than ordinary.
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29
STATE NEWS.
Items of Interest Which Happened
In Various Parts of Wisconsin.

His heirs are voluntarily carrying out
his intentions.
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29

Last fall James McMath, night dis
hatcher for the Northwestern railroad
company, located at Amigo. disappear
ed. That was the last seen or heard OF
him until Sunday afternoon, when his
body was found floating in the Fox nv
or. 1t is believed he WAS accidentally
drowned.
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29

The brick makers of Depere and Duck
Creek including members of the Brown
county Brickmakers' association, are
circulating petition asking Governor
La Toilette to withhold his support from
the proposition to conduct a brick yard
in connection with the state reforma-
tory near Green Bay The petitioners
state that they do not much fear the
immediate results, as it is claimed that
most of the brick will be used in the
construction Of tunnel between the
power house and other buildings but
that if the yard is established 1T Will
soon he convenient to send bricks to
other state concerns and finally manu-
facture brick for the trade.
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29

The one crop that never fails is the
dead beat crop.
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29
VERY Low EXCURSION RATES To

DENVER, Colo,
Via the North Western Line. Excur
sion tickets will be sold June %, 23 aud
"a, with final return limit until Oct 81,
inclusive account International 5. $.
Convention Apply to Agents Chicago
& North. Western R'y. june 10.
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29

The man who il accused of passing
bad halfdollars at Appleton and who
was arrested at Menasha early Mon
day morning, rs told in The Sentinel
gave his name as J. p. Donelson.
Donelsons examination was postponed
in Jnstice Heinemann's court to May 20.
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29

One of the most celebrated court
cases in the history of GAINESVILLE was
finally settled Saturday when j. ).
Cunningham, attorney for the plaintiff
in the damage case of Ann Collins
against the city of GAINESVILLE, served
notice on City Attorney Burpee that he
would accept the Judgment of $500,
awarded by Judge Dunwiddie. This
Judgment carries with it the costs and
disbursements in the action, which
amount to Sj15.9l, total of $l,3159l.
The Judgment awarded were for 81, 3l5,
81. The judgments awarded were for
81 700, g., 700 and s., 800 After the
lost trial in the Circuit court motion
TO set aside the verdict and grant new
trial was argued before Judge Dun
widdie, the attorney for the plaintiff
filling an agreement. to remit 5000 Df
the Judgment. In his decision Judge
Dunwiddie ordered the plaintiff 70 take
$500 or have the verdict set aside and
new trial
The Manitowoc pilot. [volume] (Manitowoc, Wis.) 1859-1932, 1902-05-29

Attorney p II. Martin returned to
Green Bay on Saturday having acquit-
ted client Of the charge Of murder,
preferred against him in the Shawano
court. He also cleared him of the
charge of manslaughter Ia the first, sec
ond and third degrees, but the verdict
was guilty in the fourth degree. The
case will be appealed