Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1902-02-04
lively DEBATE
IN THE SENATE.
Presentation Of Text Of Philippine
Tariff Bill Caused It
GILMAN AGAIN TO THE FORE
,m.sk Wakes u spirited speech
wv ,.,,dge Takes an Active Part
ID the Discussions


ID the Discussions
washington, Feb. s,--Another spirit
|, asbate with the Philippine tarin p''i
'.,Ds text was precIpltated in the SEN
,odoy as the result of some state
~ W.. made By Mr., carmack CDem''
T.on) in the course of an extended
'ossoh on the general Philippine ques-
.n If was the Tennessee senator's
~, soeeeh in the Senate, and he was
.Iv,p notably good attention on both
Iis, of the chamber. He spoke with
N, manuscript, with earnesIness, force
and clcquence'
4, the conclusion Of his address,
,Olcb had been listened TO by many of
n, former colleagues In the House OF
conservatives Mr., Beyerldge of lndl-
IN, challenged some Of his statements.
The debate which ensued was very
g,oy for d few minutes, taking on Il
,aneal phase which proved partlcu-
KIN interesting to the auditors, who
,ngded the floor as wen as the gal
ydss
INCREASE OF SALARIES.
The measure providing for an in
crease in the salaries Of United States
hdges was under discussion for an
iogr In the course of debate the case
Of Judge Arthur II. Noyes Of the dis
idct court Of Alaska was drawn upon
d show why some judges should not
L siyen the increase.
taking advantage Of the latitude OF
dtate offered by the Senate rules. Mr.
Tlman directed attention TO an artl-
ce in the Washington Post, published
today relative to the case Of Judge
Arthur II. Noyes Of the district court
5l Alaska, who was fined $1,000 recent
N by the circuit court at San Francis.
o. and VI associates Of Judge Noyes,
yto we're involved with him.
Mr. 'rlllman read the article, which
hilaed that Judge Noyes ana his as
socia,es are drawing large salaries
from the United States while the case
sgalrst them Is pending In the courts.
One II the men, according TO the artl-
ce who Is serving his sentence, con-
tnues to draw salary
Mr. Tiilman made running comments
UPON the statements in the article, al
ptng all his sarcasm, rldicule and
nyeciye against Judge Noyes, finally
Htuirlng
10y the way whose business is Il
70 remove this man."
NJ Foraker OF Ohio believed II might
require Impeachment proceedings TO re-
moie Judge Noyes but Mr.. Teller con-
tended that the President had ample
power to remove Il territorial Judge. He
BELIEVED there was no question about
hat He declared the actions of Judge
Soys had been crying shame, and
asserted that "a recital OF his outrages
would aartle the American people"
PHILIPPINE TARIFF BILL.
A o'clock the Philippine tariff bill
Hs lal1 before the Senate. and MIR.
Iarmack Of Tennessee, member of
NE Philippine committee. delivered a
FNh N opposition to the pending
measure he contended that Congress
ea' not prepared to deal understand.
mgy with the Philippine situation in
any Oh It's phases, because Il was not
hmlllar with the facts. The bill he
sald, mad been framed by the Philip.
Ens commission, an autooratic body,
IVY miles away and not change
nal oeen made In 1t by Congress.
THIS BILL" said Mr.. Carmack is
.ansl on the theory that the Philip.
pae stands are a deadly menace TO our
gse tade and that the less we trade
Wy, 'hose Islands and the less we have
40 WIN them the better II will be
~ u.s. Inc only trnde that will flour
sn under such conditions Is that of
, oS eaplollers' and It Is proposed To
,uIn Ihe Islands over to them. II Is
~ NE benefit Of the carpet -baggers
s.u hol Tor the benefit of the American
poPe That a war OF criminal agPres-
tands '"S "'i'Pp''e
Al Ne OF the minority, cannot support
S %s 1u' OF the policy of which IL Is
CENSORSHIP QUESTION.
ns next discussed briefly the subject
y ue censorship Of press dispatches
, %aulla lie declared that il was not
bs ,S.'s'oIshlp for military purposes, but
~ aa vseh established BY for and in
s'eresl OF the Republican party"
n.y. ,ahl Information had been sup
,S IN by the censor he declared. and
Wv, Psople OF this country had been
l,%m ignorance Of the matters TO
pt",ssnlsage Of which they were entitled
a., w'I,lng 10 the Republican support.
M a. ue present Philippine policy,
4, pu ,llt your hands in holy horror
IS. 'os lynchlng Of a colored man in
SguIh ana yet you are engaged in
ws. lOOOO,OOO people who recently
nm. 'out allies and your brothers i'm
cHms unu they have committed no
,o ,,s except the crime upon which this
svu1,s,rnment was foundedn '''
AIN great earnestness no deolared
sts,,. me President of the United
IU,n. had properly characterized
tS Il-,,sldo and his associates as blood
ma persons, then Admiral Dewey
Ana e VINO secured Agulnaldo's help
ehs,S 1sS's.ance could not escape the
hVs y, " deliberately violating the
,hs ., civilized warfare, and he hoped
enargo against Adn,irai pa,,,a.,
'Oula be Investigated "S'