Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1902-05-09
hay OF BITTER
PERSONALITIES.
b,.,0,,Ion Of Philippine Question
A Gets More Acrimonious
r,RNAcK DENoUNcEs SMITH
u,m "The scoundrol, the ""r
4 ,,.,. the Butchcr"-Ho'r Finally
called Him TO order

Ellington, May S.-Dlscussion Oh
philippine bill in the senate 'ou 's.'
5he "a, scarcely abated in boltterhess
Fn,' an amusing phase. In a breezy
OOS .n Afr. Dolliver of Iowa maue suvn
4 ps ,oS paturcd and yet such a so u S,Dn'
sOu Ian Of Mr. Carmack of Ten
o's ,hat senator's and occupants Oh
| ,Nronged galleries were CONFUSE, ',,
NJ ,"oaSter While seemingly cohslo-
fl'n '" ,",nner was aroused by the de-
rap'' GOOD feeling was shown by the
P' ave- participants in the war u
Polu s cordially shook hands ana
l"gbed over the encounter ,., Emo
u vs. prr,on on Kansas concluded the
vi, i, mich he began yesterday lie
fpe'." 40 instances Of atroclous
'elsl ,,,. 10 the battle Of Wounded Knee,
\ w. , Mountain Meadow massacre an, anu
n me Mou of soldiers at fort
. 4. lar
" lne " and contended that the a cSio'
fhlON' S,nerican troops In the fniilp-
~ "" wae In most instances, en' ,re e,'
Ettbln the regulation oil c'''''NO'
Pr is .,snonse TO some statements maui
~ . AN by Mr.. Tillman, Mr. Nest VI
{ss .SnU% delivered q torceful ana e. T,
issou', soeech and made an historical
WYNN, with reference 10 lhe
h n'n,on Roads conference between
presldent Lincoln ana oonisOe
kaders.
o,ovAcK pENoUNcEs SMITH
A. rarmack delivered scathlng
enuciation Of the condsct vi ma na 40,
81 ,Srations in the Philippines, ana u os
Rpnnced Gen. Smith, branding hln, 40 40
N ".conndrel and murderer VINO ~ =
"a sSonored the American army ana hau
q nno nothing but butcher a whole peo-
I'm sarcastic response Mr.. Dolliver
n :" towo scorehlngly arraigned MI.
rr,aclF incidentally reading an eui-
rlal from the Memphis Commerclhl-
Appeal crticising the Ie iiis,, s s,u'S
prs attitude on the Philippine queS-
NIr Carmack's reply was Of such a
4atnre as TO cause him to be called 10
<rder for A statement rejecting upon
IN polIver, but the incident ended IN
pod feeling
81 BURTON CONTINUES SPEECH.
Al the conclusion OF routine business
',Aonslderation OF the Philippine gov
1rnment bill was resumed ana MI
Rurton of Kansas continued nus speech
beeun Yesterday, celebrating his eulO-
mum Of Gen Funston lie lhtllnateu
fbat il was because he had captured
Arunaldo and has assisted materially
al putting down the instruction IN the
philippines that the Democratic min
orlty SO severely crltised Funston.
Isl Discussing the war In the Philippines
An. Burton declared that no more
eruelty was exercised In the war In the
philippines than was absolutely neces-
I3hry He referred TO the battles fought
BIZ Chlyington In Colorado, which sub
te0uently became an issue IN Colorado
politics, and Of Wounded Knee, where
<tVery Indian was killed, entirely, he
aid. within the regulations Of war.
III Instances Of barbarIty are incidents
.nf every war, He referred to the mas.
.3acre OF colored troops at Fort Pillow
which, he said was an act OF a few In
.Iuriated men under the command OF
Sen Forrest In that massacre the
blood OF Union soldiers was shed-not
THAT Of Confederates
IA He also referred to the Mountain
meadow massacre-a massacre which,
1or hdeous atrocity and fendsh devil
5ty had not been eQualed on this con-
flnent. He did not charge, he said.
the Confederates with the Fort Pillow
liamy or the "Mormons" with the
'Nountain Meadow massacre, but we
DUST not charge the United States
Srmy with Isolated instances OF afro
tfty and cruelty in the Philippines.
sAMPsoN's DEATH ANNOUNCED.
81 Mr. Perkins Of California interrupted
+ 70 oner a resolution declaring that the
enale had heard with profound grief
~ the death OF Rear Admiral William
"a Sampson, and providing for the APP
flohtment OF five senator's to Join like
*Eommittee Of the house to attend the
.3uheral, as a mark Of respect 10 the
eau olfcer The resolution was adopt
a ana Messrs, Perkins, GallInger.
fuares Martin and Mallory were
banned as the committee.
continuing, Mr.. Barton referred TO
Ehe remarkable speech" delivered in
~ senate yesterday by Mr.. Tillman.
|2ie paid a tribute to the work being
Hohe by Booker 7. Washington for the
o,ored race, and suggested that II the
Vlored people would follow his advice
Ivy would be successful.
ar burton ridlculed the Democracy
iu declared that during the past 40
eaN had been a party Of obstruc-
son' what have you done In the past
~ y.aS he demanded, dramatically.
the Democratic side. You have
rmnbled, grumbled at everything:
u'naled at everything Tint looked TO
Se auSancement OF civilization every
VEST CITES HISTORIC CONFER
ENCE.
at' Vest Of Missouri called attention
& y ,ne statement Of Mr.. Tlllman made
+ .aeiuay' That az the historic confer
IVY N Hampton Roads In 1864 between
,' .s'iueht Lincoln. William II. Seward.
s, -, se1Iy OF state; Alexander II. steph-
~, vice president Of the Confederate
a ~, ~. H. NJ. T. Hunter formerly Unit
= I'm '' ss senator, and John A. Camp
u 81. IoIinerly justice Of the United
,oln supreme court. President Lin
a NJ rI9le upon piece Of paper, Save
4 a., tVhlon' and then. handing Il 20
t,,puehs said. Alexander take this
81 Az, t.l ana MI up for yourselves the con-
N ties" NV Ve'"eeh the Two coun-
4 ~ ~ vest said the story had been de-
4 vss " John II. Reagan OF Texas who
\ CON- last surviving member OF the
liz s.,se iate cabinet. He knew positive
Il Al ,s ny. ar Vest without having been
4 ipel5s.s. celebrated interview, that the
4 fon,s., was without the slightest
yc r1ilal l,n. III true" said ne. III
4 oer pace the government and Off
q, s,l g the Confederacy in the category
N feds,.,.uals, because II offered the Con-
~ all that Il ever demanded I'm
! n t.ulest hone Of the most extreme