The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1902-11-12
CLOSE or THE CASE.
Final Argument for the People and charge
by the Judge.

i'm the defence there was absolutely no
contradiction Of hiseypert or Law witnesses
He called attention TO the fact that on the
same day tina, the bottle holder wa bought
- -. -. -, IL. 80. Lia l.; T.
me hU'r DON az h"c', WIS n'''u II, 'ne
name of Cornish, and demanded: is il
possible that on the same day two men
should break out in such malcNolcnt hos
tility to Corn~h?'
lie made hH strongest argument on the
first Harp-ter letter, signed I'll CORNISH.
II was written to Stcarn- 4 Co. of'Detroit,
n. said and the evidence showed ahso-
L,,.Ir ia, !, v,,s ia. work or Mnlin.ux
$500 l..,,, -, un.,.,,,.,
II WIS i"lh'uA ""o N'''" VI h"' ps'e'
connection with St"arnS, II was MoiiheuN
who had the egg blue crescent paper and il
v,. u,,Iiu,,y Ln snugLt ia hur, Uarus,ar
H.. I'll rs, man who vrota tim, Ie,,ar
' -, ~. ;,,,.,''s LiIli,,
u" '"p'' '"'''H''''" NV - INV " "','"S
Mrs. Adams and that man was Roland
b MulinouX.
Tho urnsrcu,or declared that the CON
o,.I,J nnrr. I.,,,r and two of the Bar
.,i...1,. Ito. ,,,,.,i,,,,,.
Nv ~ NUS =
"'''
lie writes tn" conceded BinS letter on
the paper OF cornish. put II III IN" 'hNeiol~
Of Barnet and sends Tor the remedy tlhl tau
been % often applied loi IN 'orhi,h nam,
it must point one way II points but one
way ~ tins oa-'. II th1 uti'huhl, Wa nov
abb" to buy ~" hott" holder anu e'' me
poison without having thto' lhlht. tta,',u 70
huu, IA" Wa not III To enter Inc -chonl OF poi--
ourr-. II tnl- Jgry rNI"ct- ~ To trarr ther
bottle holder aud the poison II inlHht ~ Wen
give rIrht NOW immunity to All PRISONERS.
The prosecutor closed with def"nc' of
Cornish and Mr.. Roger.
,-.r,cr ,,vprRr's ou,KGr
lu-'lc" Lambert : 'harg" was AN a''N'-
lwry impartial rcvi"" 81 IN" evidence:
MohuruN and his father amt his counsel
were inclined 10 thlhh thd' any summing
up I' ,' -! a., 10.
H.. H., t,,,.ir faynr and thoy were in great
,.l., ,,...,. ,nn ,,ur,'- pra-,utatiuu of ,ha
- w ,t. ,,,,,.
cas- 70 W. J'H : .,,,,,,,,,. r,,,...
Following In" custom ol supreme 'ohft
Justices from up the state, Justice Lam
bert stood on h!- feet during the two hours
,n,, d, charged the nry, He went over
t ,,.,- - Ri AJan,:'. d,,tb and ,L.
NV '" - -, 't"rc,i ,,,b 49, ,,;,,',
arrest nl h'lll'uN tIdi H''d WIN ,'" ''iH',
and then defined ia" different degrees oil
murder and man-laughter which the de-
f.,Jlui might ha found guilty Of under the
law H. lion laid.
'''' ~ '' -
1ho defendant i. presumed TO be- innocent
10 thu beginning and up Ia "a" clos" Of his
TRIAL or until tine evidence has established
Hl- guilt beyond q reasonable doubt. The
burden "l proGl meyer -ilts ~ j. v",1,aa',a
" " 10 ~ iury ihr i"g,l definition of a
reasonable doubt. Vet II l. essential that YOU
,uuprci1u th,.rNa,t meaning of thHt phrase.
III" cvid"lc" need not hr 80 strong and
conNincnG - 10 tA'lud' iH ppe.lp'" conclusion
stN' eHlu nu, ~ u,"S ~, ,,';,, n !,
49, ~ ME-" = r,d tt. d"inud an, entity
-, IL, ,,.,...l..l -. 80,
jus i'" laillnc'l '''u P'o'te' w u'il
Inr the contention pl ~, l,tVN'iru,ioii ,iiai
Moltl,'uN PloT'i'' Wv uo,,c Ii !, w.
y WIN 'N"hIu' pl '''''!"i Pa N'' ~ ~ "a
IMAM DON "'N' ia ,,',,'ia a.,ai'-
,aH wac - -. IA I,.'' ,.J iooi " 49,
nm 'l,N' '"' u, ~ NV ~ -, - ''N
!" secure '"'' '''''' '''' "''' VIZ
hANb"|'i'N' "' Npp'fNN N''N'"
10 one saw Tia" G"i"ndHht procure ''hrt
of these thugs No one saw IA" defendant
seal NJ tit- package, u" one -!W nm ,hhu ~
TO OF" saw hiw Il" on" "i IN" mugs 'ithtt'd
against him H." defendant shy- b." l. not
guilty and, therefore, puts IN issue AL oi the
4!.'HrIo4- Ps.!.,, nm J., inr EGu To
their ca" with III" necessary evidence. On"
al ~" important Questions "a TINS ca" T. H."
claimed hN the u'OpI" tha' III" ~ul"rN, fliilOn
/, iu III" handwriting 81 Tia" d"i"hdhut and
they hoN" -uri"rl"d thHi contention WIN IN"
"Nid"uc" oi "Nl"ii-, bankers ana men a'-
guI,ulrd Mttn ne IIh9Mt,li.s @, me h'.
irnGaIt' lnh' 'I" hl,.nd forn i. . .,n
~. ,nrviCt.d nr anv crime That /, III"
central point for consideration hy YOU
m, I,.,;.,, ,..,,, i,,,, ,l,, ,o.,i,,o,,, -
=. Ia .t.l.
'Ni'I '"' 60 l " va I,.i,t ,'a,,iai ~"
ne i"l9"li ""'l'NH, 'nS .'h i,,',,'' I'LL I,
,,a.sf w '", W. ".a I '" aa, ~ ; 70.
M"HiruN ',pHnH ~" ,n ian.,s
Wv NY ~, ~ " NJ
WIN az NiEi'1' en- "o',''f p nv
Jurors ne 0,'''i '"II'' uo' ',I,l9"", l.' na'
h"' "'t't- w N'''I i,il''t"!E Wv l'n'u" 'ai'S
on IN" pd'haS' ur''H, t''rh IL, H",lSned
themselves ,n1' WI" l"oI.I. nay l'oN'u
M'lll'uN 1"l' M W Iu,t'' 'll'
red~"hdp" "on'. "l'r.p'' ''0ine 'l'
arguments OF ~" oNI".I'9 ON ,'ies' ."llcrs'
Jn>'lo' lhh"'Il Halu' t'r J' MaS elN'
th"r testimony ~" weight 'i''! ''ought
II cntltI"d 10 ne san.
MIGHT THROW OFT EXPERT EVIDENCE.
The evidence of these experts i. not forced
ON Won Won are, under n" legal require
l!wnl 'o ''' "n'i"lhIu ~ !, ~ u. 80 iI -
'li''l - NW'' t'i.''' ,'a'''u'llN w ~ IooIn'~
lhN"i\',i W. NV ~ 'l'l' H,ilu'r ~ 'N-
HiI~ d'II'iE "l'" ",,l ',l.nh '"'f 'N1''N
nil'l''; 'H' . y, 49,. ny Nv ~ "" so
M, &" thrnN " "l. ".l. IhlN hIHS@ YOU !"
Nour obvious n'"' /, " 'N'nni. W. nthu,
NIlilhS, l"Il9'II ~ w. l '1"P' : ,'o' STOOL
on N'l'i NIilht Il'',ii " Nonl,' h'rn'i go 10 ln'
lnr,. !, Np'!' W. '..n'.'@ S =, ~, y j. ,oh-
H. -, ,..-. ..,,d /, ,,n,, Inc .urror,,I h,. 49,
circumstances
The most that could be- said Of Noliucux
having an account M TiFanys, said Justice
lambert, was that il CAV" Molincux an
ntlnrtmity to get the Tiffany box and
envelope that was used in Tia" poison pack
age. Every circ,ims'a ncc Of tho purchase