Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1901-01-26
. II5T HEARING -,.,,
ON VACCINATION
s...r ... .: 1 1.,.: ' ,.n1 ''' So
d. ANTS DID not 1AlA'
,,.,..u aud Beat, . and on ~ .
prs , ,,,,I,a. aaa' Arguments ."
Vaeeina'lo"
-rr AVIS DID S0T TAIN

/. ..t aha HOUSE
\ a.l.' '' ... ''S after the adjournment
i NO. !. o, legislature. n,,rs
9 n,ta' l a..''n M answer TO the ars gu.
lala VI. s.I ID ai too high for
,'ll' ' .,s In ,na, he had passed
H .,, ,r .' severe cpIdomI's ST. in L ,ao5
n rs ' ..,,,,.iy enough. he s'la a.. "s
4 a'A.'. p, ", s,ros. any case Of small ~,
4 had a a,,. 'I until few weeks ago ,., hs
n PIX h hs'. ~ s,' thought that vaccination
said 'll' ' I, preventive against
pos ,. :, 4 repeated often enough .....
'a p. P.a, = that he did not believe
.. .s., IN compulsory vaccination.
+ D. ..', ,.lon.red the reasonaOlen'ss Of
pc \, ,ss arguments on the other
.o,.' n me people were all de'.rous OF
Ply. I'D ot me epidemic and quaTah-
we We, an expensive way. the OK
ils 'p u ,bl, way would be something
.l.s , a and it would be harder Oh
t''IasnaoT -,,S ~ han on the rich man.
EDUCATIONAL OFFER.
intake my child, who has been y ,,,l
...S Sa wf.b another man with a chlld
-1 Ia has been subjected to every pre-
utl5n except vaccination We W Wiz. ~
,5s nest house and let the chlllTe,h
rTs moe who are afflicted. II ms
Ina akes he disease let him give ne
r - .rd i'm child takes the disease
n answer TO a question Dr. Mac
+ IA, sald that he looked upon Vaccl-
.,r6, AS an absolute preventive OF
-sllpoy. But It would run out me
-y way 10 check the epidemic Is py
a,.inatIOn.
DIR. BEATTY's DENIAL
Dr. Beatty denied that It was a con-
rs, between the citizens and doctors.
h was no reflection upon the inIfill-
ssnce OF the people 10 refuse 70 rest
he case with them. He told TIE COM
nIttes that II Il passed the bill now BE-
fore Il. Il would take every mean, out OIL
The hands Of the physicians TO p'oylde
against what the doctors feel 10 be a.
impending epidemic that Will be vast
in rs dlretul result.
DIT. Beatty stated tina, he stood be-
fore the Senate two years ago and
asked that body 10 pass q bill giving
the state board OF health the power to
exclude an unvaccinated children from
the schools. The bill was l0s, and an
Immense cost 10 the State Is the result.
Right after that the Deseret News be
gan rs opposition with such an inal
.nce that Tor a long while Il was i'm.
possible 70 yacclnate many people.
IN regard 10 the charge that the
- physicians were prejudiced. Dr. Beat
iy asked Iiii vas prejudice that caused
81 hs health officers Of this State 10 in.
VIE NE enmliy and opposition Of their
patrons He referred TO the statistics
III 10 regard to the Philippine army. which
were presented on Thursday He said
n nat Z he gentleman had looked into
army statistics farther they would have |
"a found iha, In the German army there |
q hil BEEN 10 deaths from smallpox since |
W. IN he Franco.Pussian war. said |
IA be iiIe were 1900 deaths from |
~ smallpox 10 The French army where |
'io..tai.,l was not compulsory while /
ih German army there were only
~, yaIenus the only lay member
.ls health board was accorded
'4 asa'ng He argued that from
l'.I experience and learning the physi.
i,' ought 70 have the power IN do
pay 'ley deem would best conduce
ne health Of the citizens OF tho
'als and protecting them from tbs
ayag.' o. an epidemic.
Iaolas HUI announced that those on
y ale OF the case felt that enopgb /
~ Nsn SAID. and only stated mai
.us bls d committee present from,
lNo Which had a petition from a
as' meeting Of citizens OF ,bot o,,,,
sung against compulsory vaccine
! ,' ROYAL A. Barney briefly al.
a.s me committee stating that bo
'il, ,,d a mass meeting al the cl,t
= o Provo, who were emnba,ioan,.
20 compulsory vacclpation
a nm, s l,',li the schools opened ~
"A ynA4ren. He did not read tbo
a n .''. .l adopted. but was ,nritod
.5 la.m with the commlt,ea W. Wv
va ne sentiments Of b NV, ne
a le people Of Provo wi cent
E gearing then closAa ,,s a.
1--WE -.,, y, WV make Its report within
4 ONE MANS TESTIMONY.
!. =. : y. 4 Helm o., California. an On.
i ,.,,r ~1- .,.'l'lIs expert, who mas Tor
IN, y, ',', .'ls resided IN this civ v,os
--...". eve his testimony beforo "a. ,Ss
-.,s but was not GAIA ' ,,. the
& b, s,l5s sas enough had been said
. gs. 'I,-sAee was taken by a ston
n ,A g.s III. uy the committee n
Il statement is as follows,
H.g on NJ, Jsom 9Iiti Of Senate and
~ IA ~ sas mcmillan bill IA refer
Ara lle Vaccination -
4 Q,gon Vas yaccInated at sa-
ts ~ ~ March, 1872. No
d be No b.S ,aeelnated at the SAM
n % Srh " ~, made arrangemants w
a ,ra ,"','er'ea, and decided 10 he e
: DAD, preventive agsjrs,
\ D. y. .nls was recommendeJ ~
lfs,r.,, reformed the vacclnstt1'oo
ny 49, p Doth 70 BE- successs,I
',isrt.,.all took well bur IN p, -, ~
p BIN r.'used a serious innosa" my
,s. IN the hospital 'e IS, iay-
,r t9,.5,, nelt attended him s ,So
he an. VINO advised amnmio, aiso
Df 20 THIS / would M, 20 o .Io'
Asi re, Zen was called In ana ,a,.
su ,..s.,.oVered, but opr ~ o allu my !
u ty.Sl going to South Iar range
,.., upset In Decs l,,, america
Vll ,rro sas IN Portland. oras ,rre !
log1 y, f ia 10 smallpox In IN /
he aoa'on, ] was taken do ,is I
nv c',, ~ lie most ylrnlent {
rr Oaued 1t Aglatic NJ. Z
ftt. vas ATTENDED ulack ,
i.,o own o.. was SO serious Ii S tbp, /
.,.tell Of L ssaI Tor. aoomely, :
| D ri Y q Nackmlnyjii,oe oregon, ,
5,l sGi month a Siu a. They Z
r. ny s9 I. hsd attended m rTSI hsa,. 9
/. "a lr, ,o.iy sllphate o. yI5pp o Tor 9
|" W s,,.9snd finally fu T1 ana peo6 be- I
however. who at Z