davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05
THE NEWS OF THE SPORTING WORLD
 y row

particular hobby nobody seems tt know. but for several years she has devoted great deal of time to learn Ing how to be an expert bookbinder and at last has become one.
 A few months ago several book cov- CTS sent to an exhibition by the name Of Miss Matthews' were favorably noticed by the judges, and received several prizes. Nobody knew who the exhibitor was until the prizes were awarded. Then 1t was discovered that It was the Princess Victoria.
 The princess takes her hobbies very seriously. Following the lead of her mother. Queen Alexandra, who is deeply interested in medicine and hos pital work, Princess Victoria began to study nursing some years ago. She took en examination in theoretical work. and when she passed announced Her intention of becoming hospital nurse.
 It was current gossip in London at the time that the Prince and Princess of Wales had great difficulty in con- vincing her that 1t wouldn't be wise for her to do so. and that Victoria sub- mttted only after many tears.
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05
cRIBBINs GETS DOWN TO WORK
And He Allowed Only 5 Hits,
 Shreveport Saving a Shut-out,

Shreveport, La., June 4.-(Special.)- Selma made 1t horse and horse today in one of the prettiest contests of the season. StultZ and Cribbens both pitched magnificent games, but Crib bens had the advantage of better sup port. Selma took the lead in the third inning and was never headed. Shreve- ports only run was made in the fourth inning, the masterly infielding of the visiting team contributing to the goose eggs, except in the fourth inning. The Selma team has made an excellent im- pression here, as far as playing ball goes. The games they have played were snappy and elicited no little en- thusiasm in the bleachers and grand stands. Haggerty suppIanted Allen at third today and let nothing go by him. There was considerable dissatisfaction with the decisions of Mauck. But as he divided his rankness he cannot be charged with favoritism or partiality. His decisions, however. could not have changed the result of the game. The official score follows:
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05
sewanee Gets First of the Berries

Tuscaloosa, June 4.-(Special l)-The first game of the series between the University of Alabama and Sewanee was played here this afternoon and the score resulted 10 to in favor of Se- vance. Desoite numerous errors. the game was a very interesting one and the large crowd which turned out to see the contest thoroughly enjoyed it. Alabama made several very costly er- TOTS in the third inning and the lead Sewanee obtained then made them hard competitors. The pitching of Ashe. Alabama's phenomenal freshman. was the feature of the game, together with the good fielding of the visitors
 The score by innings was as follows
 Alabama .. ...............120 100 000-4 Sewanee .. ...............00 004 O2O 22s-1O
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05
WHY WOMEN SHOULD WORK.
Mrs. Harper's Very Effective Hand ling of Interesting Social Question.

| Chicago Tribune.
 Ida Husted Harper replies in The Inde- pendent to recent article by MT. Finck | In which he contended that women should not seek work in offices and facto- ries unless driven by poverty to do so. Ms. Harper has the better side of tbe n and she sandes sh bsas her qsM Finck's Idea would place stigma of pow erty. on every feminine employe and would raise higher the old and pernicious barrier between the working woman and her more favored sisters. To the com nt that per cent. of the employees in the factories are women. Mrs Harper re- pies most pertinently that far more than tr-ies has been taken directly away from the women In the household. The wo- men who spun and wove a home a cen tnry ago must now go to the factories to do the same work.
 Tie charge that mems wages have been covered by the entrance of women into lnoustriai pursuits cannot be proved by ssaast,cs. ss s Tor these show that mems wages are higher than ever before If wages were placed again at their old nguies. and if 100000 women now en- gaged in bread-winning employment were witn,arawn I,, and set down in the home, the results would be disastrous. It would mean not only likeness and priyation for the women. but also additional labor and sacrince for the men. who would have to support them. Statistics also refute the statement that the ranks of vice are re- cruited from the women who go outside the home to labor It has been shown re- peatedly that by far the largest percent age of fallen women is furnished from the ranks of domestic servants.
 It Is rather late in the day to contend that the gainful occupations should be monopolized by men and that women should be restricted to the household Probably women would be more willing to do household work if all men were will ing to pay their daughters, sisters and wives definite and adequate wages for the work done in the homes. Financial inde- pendence is as sweet to a woman as to a man. Mrs. Harper touches upon a vi- ta! point in saying that when women must ask for every dollar required for clothes End other necessities-and often grudg- ingly bestowed-they naturally gaze with longing eyes into more fruitful fields of labor.
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05
Games Yesterday.
Games Today.

Only six innings of the St. Louis New York game was played yesterday. but by the grace of the generosity of MT. Jones the Giants had lead which they would probably have held or in- creased, While Philadelphia played the best fielding game yesterday yet Ciark's crowd hit White pretty hard and won out by a close score. the victory putting Pittsburg in third place and showing the Quakers down to fourth. McFadden's slabwork yester- day was burlesque on baseball, eleven bases on balls being enough to lose any game on earth. Donovan pitched a great game and Hanlon's team won in a canter, the Reds getting pretty close to Pittsburg. Brooklyn's victory puts them into fifth place and St. Louis drops to sixth. New York Is more than holding her own on this Western trip so far and Brooklyn looks to be rounding to.
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05

Cribbins pitched great game yes- terday and Shreveport only scratched a run in the fourth inning, saving a shutout. 1t is horse and horse now and todays game will decide which
 team shall have the series. The hol-
 low victory that Charlie Franks team had over poor old Nashville yesterday puts the two Tennessee towns tied for third place. The per centage puts Birmingham a shade ahead of Selma, both the Alabama teams winning yes terday. Selma opens up at home to- morrow for a long series of games. Shreveport being there Thursday, Fri day and Saturday.
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05
American League Standiny.
Games Yesterday,

The prettiest fight of the 1900 season is going on in the American I,eeg1,a now-Chicago and Washington bat tling for the lead.
 It took 10 innings yesterday and Merits S-bagger did the business. The result means a pretty three cornered fight If Detroit can hold up, Washing ton and Detroit being almost tied for second place-one point separa ting them- Baltimore seems to be losing with the most admirable regulaift
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05
Schedule in Effect April 2sth, 1901.

Through train NC. arrives at Mont- gomery at 6:14 p. m.
 No. daily through fast limited train for all points North and Northwest.
 No. 12 daily. except Sunday, for all sta loosa.
 For tickets call upon S. T. surratt. Ticket Agent, Union Depot, Montgom- cry, Ala.
 For further information call upon R. w Smith, Pass. Agent or P. 8. Hay, Southeastern Passenger Agent, No. Commerce Street. Montgomery. Ala.
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05

Summary-Earned runs, Selma, 2; two-base hits. Stouch, Haggerty: stol- er1 base, Harlow, ?; double plays. Val dois to Stouch to Fender; base on balls, off Stultz 3, Cribbens 3; struck out Stultz ?, Cribbens 1: sacrifice hits. ORourke, Longley. Valdois; time of game, 1:22; umpire, Mauck.
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05
Clark orifith,s Great Fieht,

Chicago, June 4.-Chicago won to- days game after a desperate struggle in the tenth inning. Merits, the first man up made a triple to left centre and scored a moment later on Isbells single. Attendance, 1,S00.
 R.H. E. Cnlcago .....O O0O 001 0f0 1-3 9 1 Washington .. 1000 100 O01 0-2 10 ? Batteries-Katoll and Sullivan; Gear and Grady.
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05
THE SLAUGHTER OF SAUNDERS Memphis Gets 23 Hits off of Him
 and Ties Nashville for 2rd p1aca

Memphis. Tenn. June 4-The local team kept up it's winning streak today by winning in the easiest sort of fash ion from Nashville. Saunders was batted for a total of g hits Bussey's home run over left field fence was feature.
 R.H.E. Nashville .. ......12O O2O 200 Il 8 Memphis q. 302 215 42"-19 23 2 Bat-eries-Saunders and Ballantyne: Haley and Swacina
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05
MASONIC.

. special communication of IN Montgomery Lodge, No. Il, A ~ A. and A. Masons, will be held NH1AA on Wednesday evening, June N4N 9th, at 8 o'clock. ENN Work in M. M. degree. " Members of Andrew Jackson Lodee, No. 173, and visiting brethren are frafernafly invited.
 By order of the W. M
 VIM. H. DINGI.EY, Secretary.
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05
Detroit Plays Ball.

Detroit. Mich. June 4,-Frazer's g. base hit followed by Geirs flv to Nance. on which the pitcher scored saved Philadelphia from shut. out. In the last three innings Detroit hit Fra ger safely eight times for a total "f thirteen bases. RII.T, Philadelphia .. ..... .00l 900 000-1 1
 Batteries-Siever and Buelow: Fra ger and Powers.
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05
PRINCESS WITH AN ODD HOBBY
That of Victoria of England is Book binding and She is an Expert.

ChIcdgO InIer-Ucean.
 Princess Victoria of Englend. the un- married daughter of Edward VII, has the most curious hobby of any in A family that has several unusual fads. She is deeply interested in bookbind- ing.
 How she happened to choose that
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05
Games Today.

At Shreveport-Selma and Shreve- port. At Little Rock-Birmingham and Lit. tie Rock. At Memphis-Nashville and Memphis At New Orleans-Chatanooga and New Orleans.
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05
SHREVEPORT RALLIED IN ONE
 INNING.
But 5 Hits Were Made off Cribbins While the Team Gave Him Snappy Support--Weikart Did Not
 Get a Hit This Time.
Southern League Standing.
Games Yesterday.

At Shreveport-Selma, 4; Shreve- port, 1. Al Little Rock-Birmingham, 1; Lit | tie Rock. 1. At Memphis-Nashville. q: Mem-
 phis, 19.
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05
McFadden's Comedy Work,

Cincinanti, June 4.-McFadden gave eleven bases on balls and was hit safe ly as many times. while Donovan was effective. For threatening the umpire the police took Schecksrd out of the grounds. Attendance, 2,S00.
 C1ncinnati.. .. .000 200 0tO-3 6 8 Brooklyn .......010 130 020-7 Il 1
 Batteries-McFadde and Peitz, Don- ovan and Mcclure.
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05
Successfully Boarding the Lion.

St. Louis June 4.-Bert Jones gave four bases on balls at critical stages The New Yorks had a lead of two runs but Burkett got two strikes and the game was called on account of rain. St. Louis.. .. .. ....100 001 x--2 6 2 New York. -. ... .000 22O 0--4 T 1
 Batteries-Jones and Schriever: Tay- Tor and Bowerman,
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05
1Y3
FUNERAL NOTICE.

3IARsHALL-The friends and aoquaint- ances of Rev. and Mrs. B. F. Mar shall and Mir. and Mrs Thos. H. De- Loach are respectfully invited to at- tend the funeral of the little son of the former from the residence, 30S Finley Avenue, Bellinger Heights. this morning at 7:30 a. m. The remains win be carried to Demopolis for inter ment.
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05
Pittsburg Jumps to Third Place.

Pittsburg, June 4.-Barrys wild throw in the eighth of Bransford' S rather difficult grounder, letting the latter go to third, gave the home team the victory. Attendance. 2,S0O. Pittsburg.. .. .. ....02G 900 11x-4 2 2 Phiiadelphfa.. .. 1000 200 010--3 12
 Batteries-Tannehill and Zimmer. White and Mcfarland.
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05

For further information address R. L. TODD. Div. Pass Agt,
 Montgomery. B. w. wRENN. Pass. Traffic Mgr, Savannah. Ga.
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05

Timber experts say that California alone has capacity of lumber in her standing forests of over 10000, ,000,00O cubic feet.
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05
Eason Nearly Lost Game.

Chicago June .4.-Both teams played amateur ball today, Boston's poor fielding helping the locals to all their runs. Eason's gifts and Dolan's huff gave the visitors all their runs.
 chicago. ......100 O03 20x--6 6 DootoH.. 900 GAO 100-5 6
 Batteries-EasQn and Kling, Dineen and Kittredge.
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05
R.H.E F..
BLACKBURN LOSES HIS GAME.
Birmingham Didn't Hit Him Hard,
 but Brandt Had Best Sunport

Little Rock. Ark. June Affirming ham outplayed little Rock at every turn today and won with ease. The locals had eight men left on bases du- ring the game. and could not hit Brandt at opportune times. Attend ance. 1000.
 RH.E. Birmingham .. ..... .0O2 900 O11-4 1 Little Rock .........0 900 100 000-l 5 3 Batteries-Brandt and Culver; Black burn and Lynch.
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05
Remarks.

Temperatures slightly lower in Mont gomery and eastern districts and nearly stationary elsewhere; light to moderate rains general throughout the belt.
 FRANK r. CHAFFEE.
 Section Director.
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05
FRANK LOCKWOOD.
 Architect Office Moses Building.
Sealed Bids Wanted.

MONTGOMERY. Ala, May B. 1901. Sealed bids will be received by the City Treasurer until F o'clock m. Monday, June 17th, 1901. for the purchase of the building and lot No. 12S and 130 Lee Street, now occupied by A. Wilkie as a livery stable. The right to reject any or all bids Is reserved
 R. H. SOMMERvILLE,
 City Treasurer.
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05

THREE SHIPS A WEEK FOR KEY WEST AND HAVANAi IN. Port Tampa. Tuesday. Thursday. Sunday, Il p. n.
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05
Pink Hawley Let Down in Ninth.

Milwaukee. June 4.-After having the Bostons shut out for eight innings, Hawlev let down and allowed four hits in this inning. giving the visitors two earned runs. Attendance. 1000.
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05
Baltimore Made a Rim
Cleveland

Cleveland. June 4.-Baltimole was unable to do anything with Hart.
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05
R.H.E.
National League Standing.

Per
 Played. Won. Lost ct. New York;. .. ..27 IS g .666
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05
Iicates rise. : Indicates faIl
River Forecast.


 River Forecast. The upper Coosa will remain stationary or fasz slowly and the Lower Coosa and Alabama will rise slightly or remain sta- tionary during the next two days
 Weather Conditions.
 IFor past twenty-four hoursl Showers have occurred over a greater portion of the South and in Western New York and the Middle West the lat ter being under influence of a decided depression central over North Dakota, showers have also occurred in Oregon and Washington, in advance of an area of high barometer moving in over the Pacific Northwest. and which is giving rather low temperatures in that region. Generally fair weather now obtains in western. southern and eastern districts, with no very decided temperature changes, though it is generally slightly warmer in the cotton belt; the barometer has risen slightly over the middle east.
 Cotton Region Bulletin. u. s. Department of Agriculture, Weather Bureau.
 For the 14 hours ending at a. m., 18th Meridian time
 MONTGOMERY, Ala, June f.
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05
Cotton Region Rulleti
STATIONS OF MONT GOMERY DISTRICT.

.Received too late to be included in the averages.
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05

Trains arrive at Montgomery s:10 a. m., a.3O a. m., 6:30 D. m.
 Buffet Parlor cars on No. IS between Montgomery and Waycross.
 Pullman sleepers on No. 5S between Montgomery and Jacksonville.
The Montgomery advertiser., 1901-06-05
FREE SAMPLE Eczema Can Be Cured.

Call at E. G. Fowlers, druggist, Mont and receive a free sample of REMICK'S ECZEMA CURE. the great remedy for Eczema, Pimples. Dandruff, skin Erup- finna and Piles -
Bismarck daily tribune. [volume] (Bismarck, Dakota [N.D.]) 1881-1916, 1901-01-03
MAILS AND TRANSPORTATION
MAILS

Eastern VIA N. No. ZOO ID.
Az Western via N. Ps OIL: q. n.
once hours p,oostoflce. general delivery,
9 q: m:,tos Y :sQ5 !: nn,, daily except Sunday;
daily, On Sunday the general delivery Is.
Eopen from ~ into / i. m. General de-
livery Is closed while mail lis being dis
%tributed after arrival of trains each way
WEST BoUND-NORTHERN PACIFIC.
No. 11-Leayes ST. s::S55 d. M; Fargo
jamestown, 7:O5 5p. M; Dawson. S.aSs
I. n. 3%aBismarck,&&s1O:15g m; Mandanr
1890 p. m. *tS aS3&# SS AESS
EAST BOUND-NoRTHERN PACIFIC
No, l2-Leayes Dickinson !. /. a. M; Man.
dan, 1920 al. m. Bismarck,Sl2:3 5 a. M.
a. M; valley City, $50 d. M; Fargo,
$3.50 a. M; st. Paul,& 2:2Oap m.
Passengers can obtain permits Of agent
to ride on some way freights each way.
s NORTH BOUND.
bismarck, Washburn%& Great Falls Ry.15
4 Daily except: Sunday.
Leaves Bismarck at :3Ossa.$Sm M; Arnold.
500 Am; Baldwin, $50 z. m.;;HSWilton,
0.45 a.. n. %a SSS&$S
SOUTH BOUND.
Leaves Wilton at p. M; Baldwin, 2:155
p.,xm.: Arnold. 900 Pm. bismarck
Rates may be had upon application to5
any OF the agents of the B.ys5W. C.
Ry. Co., 4OrFby application to- E. Walker
traffic manager, Bismarck. N. D..
TELEPHONE.
Regular line between Bismarck, Wilton
and Washburn and way points, Bis
marck office at Western Union Tele-2
graph office. ts%%$ h #
%& STAGE LINES.
For Fort Yates, way points and connec-
tons, including Glencoe, Lifona, Camp
bell, LaGrace, Fort Rice, Cannon Ball,
Williamsport, Clayton, Hampton En-
monsburg, WfnOna and Standing Rock:
stage leaves every morning except Sun
day; returning leaves Fort Yates at &
q. NJ. arriving in Bismarck about 6
~ p. NJ. y sYf'H%E .@
For Fort Berthold, Coal Harbor, Turtle
Lake, Weller, Washburn, Painted
Woods, Falconer, ElbowOods, and way
points, stage leaves every morning <
cept Sunday; returning leaves Bertholdi
every morning, arriving in Bismarck
about 5 p. M. 7(see time card B,$%W. &
For Slaughter, sConger, Gsrofte, Cromwell:
and Francis and way points, stage
leaves at 8 a. m. Mondays n Fridays;
returning arrives in Bismarck Tuesdays and
MISSOURI RIVER PACKETS.
Benton Transportation Company. j.
Baker, general superintendent; steamers
leave weekly during navigation season
for Standing Rock, Fort Yates, Cannon
BauGand q points, and to W%ashburn.
Coal Harbor, Mannhavenandf& up river.
NJ points as per special announcement.
Bismarck daily tribune. [volume] (Bismarck, Dakota [N.D.]) 1881-1916, 1901-01-03
Mhen the chtef cook Leaxe..

GEtuyEs LAS fWy
The Importance Of a chief cook be-
comes eyideAt when the time for his
departure arrives. One day last week
the proprietor Of a popular restaurant
on Fifth avenue decided for reasons OF
his own to part with the services of the
man who had for some years looked
after his kitchen. The chef retired
and with him more than 20 Of his as
~sistants. This number included his as
sistant cooks and every man in the
kitchen, even to the unimportant func-
tionary who presides over the refriger.
sators. This exodus did not surprise
the proprietor.
The chef had brought the others with
him, and they were in a way more
closely attached to his service than to
the proprietor who paid them their
wages. When a substitute was hired,
he also brought the same complete
corps Of assistants who are supposed
to know the methods Of their chief bet
ter than any assistants not directly
employed by him.
This manner OF employment exists In
sill hi asge 7restaurants#h he
head cook lis absolute master In the
Kitchen and controls all the branches
of his department down to the most
unimportant. He is held responsible
on this ground for all that may happen
under his direction even IL he was moi
personally concerned In the matter
New York Sum-.
Bismarck daily tribune. [volume] (Bismarck, Dakota [N.D.]) 1881-1916, 1901-01-03
G DIRECTORY.
,FFIcERs OF BuRLEIGH COUNTY.

sEEAFg. ETtgg&EH
sheriff Sas -. !. !. !. 4, /. !. = Is +. a Bogns
a assniorss ......:.:::W ". .HoorSeass
siarR q Z eogst !, !. SIS. Walt seh ske aGns
Register 81 Deeds .chas. a; Johnson
superintensdent d; Schools &c. D. Msdiek
Surveyor ......... ~. $500. JOIN Harold
County OBSERVATION-DISCLOSURES Welsh, 6
County Board OF Health-Dr. Wa. Bent
ley, q. s. Pierce, +. S. Allen.
Insanity Board. +. Fort, DR.. w. AZ
county Justices1Edgar Tibbals. Edward
Rawlings. Elvis Wood, John CLARK. ss$
County Observation-Disclosures McHugh, John!
Hubert. David Williams. Ole sather.
appointed to&hll unexpired term$3of Far
Yey Harris, deceased. a#es gSS#s
BISMARCK CITY OFFICIALS.
Mayor +. . ..... Edw. g. Patterson
sleik ........... Henry Y: &Rlchhoff
treasurer ..........: $3.50. ...S ~
justice :.-..., 1850. /, /. -: ~ -: NJ =. 81, ~ N s o,,a
.Aldermen-First ward, John white. NJ. i.
Hafloran; Second ward, H.. p. Bogue, e
s. Pierce; Third ward, Walter Shelton
]. Al. Barnes Fourth ward, S. p. Rohrer,
,hief OF Police ...,. -. .P. McHugh
Night #Watchman o Bowman
thief OF Fire Department. .....W RI. Jaeger
aty Surveyor .... .: John Harold
PUBLIC OFFICIALS AND OFFICES.
School Board-Jos. Hare. w r. Cochrane,
II. L. Nicholson, Louis Larson James
Mcdonald. $s55gs E5 ..
state Officiala \. .%s. Of1ces at Capitol
COUNTY Officials-ofices ct courthouse ex.
cept as herein otherwise indicated. 3,
City Council-regular meetings first and
third Tuesdays of each month at council
chambers in Patterson Block.
Chambers of w H. Winchester, district
Judge. First National Bank Building.
)fiics e County Judge ...... Webb Block
o 3dass Of af STATES msyor Attorney Z. p patterson B Bloek
9fhce Of city Treasurer. First Nat. Bank
Office Of City Clerk. :.. Patterson Block
office OF City Justice ...... Webb Block
Office OF supt. Schools. First Nat. Bank Bin
q 8. Land Office -. First Nat. Bank Blk
q. S. Surveyor General $50. Webb Block
!: ;: e Conn isstSs j. i. Gage, s First Va,
Deputy u. s. Marshal. Frank DonnelIy
United States, Weather Bureau, (and state
weather and crop service) E. H.
bronson, director, government reserva-
ton. West Main street.
Postofice, Agatha G. Patterson. postmas.
St. Alexluls Hospital -. Main & Sixth SITS
Acting Assistant us. Marine Hospital Sur
geon, FIR sElyth, First Nat Bank Biz
Fourth streets. %.$5@ EE@-@ %]..
authorized Northern Pacific surgeons-F.
e. Smyth, Bismarck; B. Furniss. Man,
Fort LincolI-In course Of construction,
two miles southeast of Bismarck.
TERMS OF DISTRICT COURT-sIxTH
S DISTRICT. 5G
First subdlvision-At Bismarck, third Tues,
day in May and fourth Tuesday In No,
second subdivision-At Medora, Billings
Bismarck daily tribune. [volume] (Bismarck, Dakota [N.D.]) 1881-1916, 1901-01-03
THE FAYoRITE.

Chamberlain's Cough Remedy Is the
mothers fayorite is pleasant ana
safe children I'd take and always
cures. H IS INTENDED especially for
coughs colds Group and Whooping
cough, and Id the best medicine made
fortnese diseases. There III not the
least danger ii giving II to children
Tor It contains 10 opium Or other In
furious drug and may be given as con-
fdently To babe IL an adult,
For sale Nv Es Beardsley.