Mineral Point tribune. (Mineral Point, Wis.) 1869-1938, 1901-04-18

stevens bill, began at 1880 and con-
tinued till 10 o'clock, Senators Arson,
Martin, Fearne and McGillivray speak.
ing for the measure and Senators
kreutzer, Riordan and Whitehead
against it. Senator Arson reviewed
the workings of the makeshift primary
election held in nominating the alder
men and the delegates to the conven.
tons in Milwaukee, saying that it had
proved to be only a slight improve.
ment over the caucus methods. but he
election would be success.
Senator kreutzer, after asking for
unanimous consent to withdraw his
substitute to the Miller bill. said that
1t had been his constant effort to avoid
a conflict. He felt that all legislation
was in the nature of compromise,
therefore he had offered his substi-
tute, and therefore having withdrawn
that one he would now offer an amend
ment to the Hagemeister bill. He did
not believe the conservative people OF
the state wanted primary law. He
was of German parentage, was born in
| Wisconsin as was his father before
him, and he believed that he knew the
sentiment of large per centage of
: the people of the state. He did not
/ believe that the question was any
longer one of principle but one of per
sonality and faction.
Senator Martin, speaking long, ably
and in polished phrase, said he did not
want Wisconsin to follow Minnesota
in the matter of primary elections.
He felt that this state should lead. If
the primary law had been found a
good thing in Minnesota, he wanted
| Wisconsin to go the gopher state one
| better and pass the Stevens bill He
thought it was time that we laid aside
| the skill acquired in the packing of
caucuses and the manipulation Of con-
ventions and restored to the people
their rights in politics. To the
charge that there was no demand for
primary elections, he replied be re-
viewing the history of the pre-con
vention campaign of last fall, saying
that the people wanted Governor La
! Toilette because he stood for some
thing. For years, the present eyecu'
tive had written and spoken on many
occasions, of the principle involved
! in the Stevens bill. He had spoken
sometimes in cities. and many times
! at county fairs, but in all instances
his speeches were published in many
papers and sent broadcast
over the state. Governor La
Toilette, Mr. Martin said, had been
nominated and elected because he
stood for primary elections.
Senator Riordan, like Senator
Kreutzer had hoped for party har-
mony. He was ready to support
reasonable compromise. He was not
prepared to say that primary elections
were a bad thing, but that was his
judgment; therefore he would not
vote to force them on any county out
woa'd support the Hagene.s. sub
stitute when it had been so amended
as to carry the referendum.
S nator Stout spoke only few
words, saying that he should vote for
1t was right and felt under obligation
to keep faith with his constituents.
| Senator Whitehead's speech in clos
| ing was one of the ablest ever heard
in Wisconsin legislative halls. He
said he had been face to face with
this bill for three months and was
no estly opposed to it after having
given it the closest study and careful
cor sideration He did not feel bound
by the party platform to be so radical
as The Stevens bill. He held that
conventions did not have the force of
law, but that legislatures had and the
action of the lawmaking body was
more serious thing than the deciara'
ton Of a convention. # the delegates
In convention in their enthusiasm had
gone too far, the Legislators did roI
need to follow them. In mastery
way and with forceful logic he re-
viewed the growth of election reforms.
He insisted that there was absolute
good in no system, that all good was
in the men. He believed that the sys'
tenn propoNd In the Stevens bill was
such that 1t would be broken down by
bad men.
In ringing speech embellshed With
many funny stories. Senator McGiiliv-
ray closed the debate. He appealed
to all to keep their promise to the PEG.
pie and pass a law that was sincere
effort to give the citizens direct vote
In nominating party candidates.
Senators Miller, Hatton, Weed and
McGillivray each explained their
amendments they had to offer. Sen
ator Weed thought that the judiciary
ought TO be included under the prf-
mary election, plan, so he offered an
amendment TO that effect but II was
voted down IS to 8. Senator Hattoo