The sun., 1901-02-06


'sFsa UssH t'stsf - 80 ~s-~s''
utfs ssu.s em fs - f-ssi-ss~ss
......
...-
..,
49,.
...,-.
A..
t....
49,.
.,.u .I
Y ,
t.u -. a.,
...t. ........ ,h. .,,
a.. .-.......,,..
-, -. 80 a..
90. -, -. go,
.,..t
.f ,..,.tt,
-. 80, .,,,,t.
man '' 'r' 'f' 'h'' ''" u'''1r" "aa ''n.''
m'Huu vss Majority Leader Ahd' W.
p.,,.., Rem YIN. .,plsInins hl. vote
sad
,.,', w -, .'r.or,n I,ipl w.. for # do
~, rc.ts,e tho ,o-er of removal by tn.
Governor - constitutional | believe that
pro,',on 80 b" unconstitutional ard had
! d. mot 500 Why "" ,"n'u nov nav hNn
better plll which would hs1. met the situation
"'u P'|'e" "''r," -""ian .pa, w..,c,..,, ~,o NJ,
VI Cooley 'hep Nes'ch'''ef'' Nno UP
TO Mond"y had been zen Undecided s,@ iS as I" no"
no N'"''
! agree WIN Nj. h'hhet ana nan no. IN,
tended to vote foe the bill, but Gov Odeil
49,. ,,,,i,cas ma that IA. resards the mower
70 -, a.. ,t.,.., ,,n,or,a,co to
ol Te""NM a. " nv ~ y"
him, and will therefore vote Tor the oiH
rvep Mr. Kelsey who .pon sored the bill
49,. -. 80, Al, no, .,oaL in ,.vo, n,
the lo"er mousse nIu nov sPeah ia s'"' U,
| the Governors power OF removal and Ignored
ou ouas,tnns az to Con.titutiona nauty merely
-. -, -. "a, 49,, . ,raa, d.ai ~
| trouble over the poACe administration In
| New York city lie was N favor OF q single
- - -, .,t ,ho,sh, a,
heaoeu pohVe '"'A,". "nI
woud serve In placing on larlinany the re-
spon-ibility for conditions In the greater
city, whero theS oeiohseu
The debate wes mot OF unusual interest,"
| All the Iammany. men felt constralned 10
make some kir-l of speech on the biz and
sen"Ta.M went eyer thG sam1 irnri,u HrphH ', tSe
Senate week ago Numerous amendment>
were offered by the Democrat Mr. Mckcown
| wanted the bill amended 10 provide
| tha, In the event OF tho commissioner being
| appoluted from Manhattan the first deputy
,hopd be from aep,y csi ,sfen csas e
while nmendments by Little Tim" sullivan,
Mr. Fitzgerald and Mr. Mclnerney were TO
| The effect that the power Of removal by the
| Governor be eliminated Mr. Dooina wanted
! tba nct 70 take eject on Jan. /. 1902 All
amendment. we're lost hv a etriCt party vote
Win the exception ~ Mr.. McKeown's. which
wns favored by Me.srs Cotton. Blackwell
and Waite (Rep. Of BroGklyn.
| the constitutionalitv Of the bill. say ing
| This rroyisIon granting power of removal
| to the tioveruor Of subordinate OF the Mayor.
Is amcon am' st,ntonal IN thai il violates section
| of Article 10 OF the Constitution OF the State
| Whv should the Legislature continue to enact
| fa,;tsau laws of this character, which have
! n num,r,us cases been held unConstit tutional
| hy the Court of Arveals'
$ an m stance Of such legislation. the Civil
| service law NAV be cited, where the priv.
iege Of making appon tinents from a list OF
,hrca names was hanged to one. acainst tht
,,o,cst ot pemoCrattc LAWYERS and the couri
nn,ont ri, Jared against tisconstitutionality. Il
| 1he Nban, Pol CtAbill AFFORDS another Illus
| ration of leci station which has fallen under
tho han Of The court by reason OF overstepping
| ,he hounts of the Constitution.
'"STLat The proposed New York Police bill
g also unconstitutional - not only voiced
| hv lnyvers of distinction, bur the leading
UcvunnHer reure,entatIvc OF tho Republican
u,o,n n'nchinr rms NFw YORK SuS, whose
nrinion. are antiilcd io much weight has
| ,r,,,tcd out i'm more than one able editorial
aar,icis ,hn fact of its lack ut constituuonality.
:" "rLa roVrr of The Governor to remove
,,,o Navnr i annie 10 cover any contingency
IL. - ari,,. IN. power ur the Governor
~, ,',"r n,ny,t ,,|; III. Navors appointees was not
'" ",t.cem,riteJ nv the CONSTITUTION Such
,,,r.a II entered upon would find its
i.g,,im,te conclusion in the removal by tho
ws,n,nnr ~, street commissioners mark
N"Nri @ ~ or qnv other oflcials elected
t"" ,tn rn",ln or aurointrd by local authors
~ " "doyun ,n town constable thus nullifyin1
IL mia unwm uin Vonc OF the officers elected
,i," ,t .nyer"ign n,ople would be safe in
| ,ho;r ,ornre of oraca Under the 'prateyt
,,het ,hs "ruhlic interest required It, while
lhat Wy, ~ ,,c, Marty et tivencias would
a. ah,,'nrd ',,d' A. rouuiar government would DO