The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1900-11-21

''
pr''''l'1 't'''''' " "'
Dpun.lH un'.'rist IuN. IIl'I" ''' I''''u"
cNr,' ui % d"'i-i"n h'rd'1 Town ''-"'N y, NV
Ap,cilli" DIVISION "l ih" NuIr'u" ' own '' Wv
Third Department, I"~' NAV H"I''I'' ''"''
justice" 'hb-" granted mn "fu't "I"n wv NJ
llCGunn 90 Nf'rh'l- '"N'I'' ''''''' az j."
Ing ,"r Nu--lHIuh- u i'''f'"'" ''' "'''' -"
Dpur'i' Nh'''I'h-' VI" ~ '''''"
upon which IN" N'"tt'N ''I'I"l '""lu 'ns'""
action 10 oru"l ID" charter "' 'h' zee ilus'.
JIsil'" chester Wa "-N'h v" ,"'"'' '"'1 ''"''
appointing ~" referee h"' I' '''".'". Y"
arI"l! va, taken =" iW" Nri"n''' I'N',I'"'
which to-day handed down Il d''','"" ''''""s
the ORDER urr.lntIns h'i"t'" Nu--hann'
The \itIruoy-tcnrr1l VII TAX" an hl1 cal 10
the court al Appeals.
Justice, Kellogg, smith and Parker favored
the vacltlus OF th" order appointing IA" rel
cree. while Justices M"rwIn ana Edwards as
seutcd from such action
justices Kellogg and smith wrote the pr
yailins opinions. In li- opinion Ju~tic" h"l-
logg practically says that the stat" Antl-iru>t
law was framed 10 prevent th" formation oi
trusts through a civil action, ana that a ''NH
action could not lie against a trust wil'h 'N-
i,tel before Proceedings w"r" commenced
against It He then states that the record
shows H." American leo Company was formed
ltItTf NN''l ~ ~ 80
attac: it
Justice smith. IN his opinion. in which jus
81. r.u.,, c,,.,,r. Luld. that the order an
- ~ "',r ,n. .I',i1 LOO y,,,tnd
l'lhllNk h'!'I'' N"~'"'''"' 7",'''
upon the ground that the officers oi Tie Ice
T., .I,,,ld ,nt Iva controlled To testify be-
h"' " - ,,,I,-,
ca,!-" Their answers ih'th' " usei "E.
them In prosecutions under the Federal AMI
Trust law If 1850
There were -'N'rH phl-'7 VI i'r i'uN' ~,
CATION bcfor" the court, which to-day decided
a., r,l,,,ipy rrutositi,r-.
%, =, ~ 49,. ,,,,ir,ir, p,fora.
First Ihlt ,h' 'ra'r up''"'"S "'
s,,,,i rb,t ~, unn,,l 70 the Appellate
" ~" "' -, d. -, Ira,,c,
DIVISION Mou,u ~, W.. ,no nrder onnointtny
a., r.r,ro.
ID" r,t., r,,, ~, snoci,I T.rm had the mower
to grant the writ, of prohibition asked for J. y
a., , ,,r,,,,rv aud IL. officers against further
WV W. '"'''' 80 -, a.I r,, ,ha
PROCEEDINGS before INC rel'ree an" '""' WV
rn,r,3 "Tbat the original applications TO tho
l"",' i"'' ''' =, '"'t In',ran, .n, -.
App'iIat" DIVISION 10y the ice coi"pahE Il 10
officers against further proceedings before the
r,,.r., .hould Ln denied
i'ltI'' S''"'' ~ u'''"
In III opinion on me mann propos''!oh W
49,, -. ,hs nonr.lI, ,nti-Trust law of
h'''o-s al Wv ,Ia ,n,Nrrns, ,ow
1e'o !. 'Ho NaiA' as 'he Inv" :"
tl 1870. ll'llla'b 'llF a. " AlA'' $3.50
,,r m, 0r-, ,bro. -actions of both laws
- 4. i,.,i,o .,r- ,,o, cn,corr,ry
the PROVISIONS, 4t ''r',' -'ttl"h7 no one Idlot@
aqicotl"u' anu ne '"Ii'uli,. hr,a i 18th
oc, me 80 e .'f tn :, 'u matG"I Of procrirrs hy the
Atlorhel -.I"n'ra' i.,,rH,,t.,-N ~" IA htirg nnd
Whic, ,"y,1i . 1n,.I ant t run 3 ~" II Ttr
Acknowledgement und"r hem t,a' TIE r"ntr4-
YER on ',Io apt|a. 30 49, "a If i.r- nnIv IN
w n'w - - = i rnt 'd of 'r"rnGraIre his
TO- tllS ,TG"n II..,,,' ,tnra n. da~.iirod in the
il'ett gu W" laS',r,,'r ., -, is,I !" 'N
justice k'dl"fs r"i,iitrS u" MuIuinH ho ~
~ ~ d, r NJ I'D, ndi 'that the Justice may cxerci.,
M inldnCioni d,.crntion is IN granting a pralitn-
liaTy ilIH.,'"n 80 , 20 avg mi' yTnnaajan, .
II. "concindos TINT the Legislature did not in
trni any r""rri@n % indlE,W M'yr',IoH' ana
n nri. y in n CIs. The nt,rlicarIon shows that The
o,urr ~ a. - r.s"s na".ssarr for
NI.Inr,,.y %,,.I ~ IN. ,ci II thc a]f;rlira.
-, I,na W sI"t, ms necessity the order must
I've r r.fItrd
oto,nrr gnarttgtrnn ~ ,h.. Am.ricnn Ice Com
U Ul,w' ana ia @rrui sition of more than ~ I%r
nn ~, -" a H." t"ta 'Iritol stock of two foreign
c,rrnratnna IN, kliskrrnocEer and Console
Az lee r1mranirs. a. r,cited in the appii-
C,r,inur"'
~ L,y, q, dn b.r, only with tho binding
rr,vi.i,u. Of the Inv Of lSaD, touching ths
800 ,ro d, Ga, tn.,i,nouy Of witnesses hear
In, il, mind ma, tha pc,i,ion states that all tho
- 80 ' '. ,rr,,r'n,ts I,rvn ha.u rnada NJ
r.,dv ma 49,. ,itia f., tho urouprtv +. fixed in
,,,ri.,r IT,, ,outr,pv. Ivcrything has
ta,, nn,.,,'r,Itcd ~ must conclude. from
,,h, .at Tnr,L in tho r.'ifinn that through
!" ~. ,,,i ,,,nagnnrrt nT tho American
.o C"r,nganV ,ithar thr0iiyh ms own directors
Or ,hr",,n mo directors of the other two
o,-nnro, Una whose s,nch; il owns. the
700 cr.r in IN, viutor of 1850 1900
y,thnrad md al the time Of this applica-
in ~ heinz JI.nn-rI ~ The effect Of all
III" ~ thn uctiti6n shows. was TO create in
~. ansricon Ice Cnmp1ny an ownership
W. rr,rtirll r,onnupIv in The di,posil Of thi,
ort i,ia ~ common u.c i'm tho New York mar
Lnt a,d n , rn.ult of such ovnrr-hip and power
disnrsol diving directly from the power
20 80 ,b" "to,k ~ 1tLor rornorItlons. tho price
~ 81. article hos bncn Increased and the con
nv, icon ,rain to nav whatever tho
nuncr bas found II prn,Ita blr To- ask
- n ,birk II nIay he conceded for the pur-
noso - Ii.n"sing ~ This an,oai and The real
question =. bich lies nj Tho threshold, that the
n,sr,n,no,nd ayro.,m.rts stated In The %uptition
ora ,ent,yn,nt 10 rrnyt.ions Of the law of Isqp
~ y ;, '"",tr :, : crna, IN, ar tcndinrto create
,nnn"noliea in articles Of common use. The
n,estirn her" relates tn the remedy, If tho
T 80 "iirrr rnmr,,v or any other ncrsnn
~ Ton hos ~ruinvfnllv offended against
49, ~, rr, -. ~ - mNrr,r /. criminal and the
,a, rrrr,iJ,s a ron,lty aud "a tho nCt declares.
u , I" ~ az, have r,ihiny 10 do.
" "a, MI rc,,,,.d nv ,Iyll action. l. possihle
Il. -" ,, - f,,t-S mi. only r,,rady Of
H., T. = 'y,Ih,rh ,hr NV pntcmrlatc. t.. prrnlv