Virginian-pilot. (Norfolk, Va.) 1898-1911, 1900-04-12
LONG AND BITTER
STRUGGLE OVER.
Continued From Page {.

proposal to tax Porto Rico's products
had transformed the whole country in
to a Boston tea party. Democratic
applause).
gfnla) and Swanson (Virginia) were
among those who opposed the bill in
brief but vigorous speeches.
LAWYER MACON QUOTED.
Mr.. Richardson Crennessee) the mi
nority leader, aroused great enthusi-
asm among the Democrats by reading
extracts from the original opinion
dated February 22 of Law Officer Ma
COON, of the War Department. Mr..
Alagoon, he said. was but subordi-
nate officer. But what would the coun-
try think Of the Secretary OF War, who
had demanded that he reverse his opin-
ion. prolonged Democratic applause).
Mr. Dolliver Qowa) ridicuied the i'm
portance attached by the Democrats to
the opinion of "a law clerk, who
thought he could override the great
lawyer who presided over the War De-
partment."
Mr.. Payne (New York;. the floor
leader of the majority, closed the de-
bate with a vigorous speech, in which
he said the proudcst act of his life is
his connection with this bill from start
to finish," prolonged applause on the
Republican side).
THE DETAILED VOTE.
AT o'clock The House, under the
terms of the special order. proceeded
to vote The detailed vote follows:
Yeas-The Speaker, Achesen. Adams,
Aldrich, Alexander, Allen (Nalne).
Babcock, Bailey (Kansas), Baker. Bar
ham, Bartholdt Bingham, Bishop,
Boreng. Boutell. Bowersock, Brick,
| Bromwell. Brosius, Brown, Brownlow.
| Run Rnrixa
Burton. Butler. Calderhead, Cannon,
Capron. Clarke (New Hampshire),
Cochrane (New York;, Connell Cooper
| '(Wisconsin). Corliss, Cousins, Cromer,
| Crump. Curtis, Cushman, Dahe, Dali
cell. Davenport (SamueD. Davidson,
Dayton, Dick. Dolliver, Dovener Dris-
coll. Eddy, Emerson, Faris, Fordney,
| ross Fowler, Freer, Gamble, Gardner
| NIichigan). Gardner (New Jersey.
Gibson. Gill, Gillett New York;, Graft,
| Graham, Greene (Massachusetts), Gros-
venor, Grout, Grow, Hamilton, Haugen
Hodge. Hemmenway. Henry. Hepburn,
! Eill, HIT Hoffecller. Hopkins. Howell,
Jack, Jenkins, Jones (Washington)
Joy Kahn, l<etcham. Knox, Lacey,
Lands, Lawrence, Linney, Laitteur
Lon, Loud, Loudenslager lowering
McCleary. Mcpherson. Mann. Marsh
Mercer. Mesick. Metcalf, Miller, Mon
dell, Moody (Massachusetts). Moody
(Oregon), Morgan. Morris. Mudd, Need
ham, O'Grady. Olmsted. Overstrcet,
Parker, Payne. Pearce (MissourD,
Peare. Phillips, Powers, Prince, Pugh,
Roberts, Rodenberg. Russell, Shat
tue, Sheldon. Sherman, Showalter,
Slbley, Smith Qllinols), Smith (South
Dakota). Smith (West Virgnia),
Southland, Spalding, Sperry, Sprague,
steele, Stevens, Stewart (New York;,
Stewart Wisconsin). Sulloway, Taw-
ney. Taylor (OhIo). Thomas Qowa),
Voorhis, Vreeland Wadsworth, Wan
ger, Waters, Watson. Weaver. Weeks,
White, Wise. Wright, Young-161.
Nays.-Adamson, Allen, QNy0: At
water. Ball, Bankhead, Barber Bartlett,
Bell. Ballamy, Benton. Berry Bradley,
Brantley, Breasetle. Brewer, Brunidge
Burleson. Burnett. Caldwell. Campbell
Catchings. CHAMBER Clark, (Mo); Clay
ton. (Ala.): Clayton, IN W; Cooney,
Cowherd, Cox, Crawford Crumpacker.
Cummings. Cusack, Daily. Davenport,
(Stanley); Davis. DeArmond, Degraf-
fenreld. Devries, Denny, Dinsmore,
Dougherty. briggs, Elliott, Finley, Fitz-
gerald, Massachusetts,; Fitzgerald
IN. W; Fitzpatrick, Fleming. Fletcher
Foster, Fox. Gaines. Gayle, Gilbert,
Glynn, Gordon. Green. Qa); Griffith,
Griggs Hall. Heatwole, Henry (Miss.),
Henry. (Texas); Howard, lett Johns
ton, Jones, Na.); Kitchin, Kloberg,
Klutts. Lamb. Lane. Lanham. Latimer
Lcntz, Lester. Levy. Lewis. Little, Lit
tleheld. Livingston. Lloyd, Lorimcr
McAleer. Mccall. Mcclellan. McCulloch.
Mcdowell. Mccain. McRae, Maddox. May
Meekison, Miers, Undiana): Moon,
Muller. Naphen. Neville. Newands
Noonan, Norton, (Ohio); Norton, Is.
Co: Pierece. (Tenn); Quarles, Riordnn,
ls.rA oil ~ ~.
Richardson. Ridgeley. Robb. Robinson.
urdiana); Robinson. (Neb.); Ruckcr.
RUPERT, Ryan On. W: Ryan. PaD !:
Scudder. Shackleford. Shafroth, Shep-
pard. Sims. Slayden, Smith. QKyD
Smith. (Henry CO: Snodgrass. Spark
man, spright, Stark, Stephens, CFexas);
Stokes. Sulzer. sutherland. Swanson,
Thomas. IN. C); Turner. UnderhlT,
Underwood. Vandiver. Warner, Wheel
er. Williams. u. RI; Williams. (Wil-
liam Ed; Williams. (Miss.): Wilson,
Idaho: Wilson, On. W; Wilson. Is. C)
Zenor and Iiegler.--l53
The pairs were as follows. the first
named being I'm favor of the bill: Hull
with Hay; Packer with Polk; Barney
with Allen (MississippD: Weymouth
with Broussard; Gillett (AIassachu-
setts) with Thayer; 1Iawley with
Cooper (Texas): Burlsett with Burke
(Texas); Mahon with Otcy; Miner
wisconsin, with Rixey; Lybrand with
Gaston; Kerr with Carmack; Davy
OemocraD with Crowley: Meyer
(DemocraD with Robinson U.ousiana)
often with Brennor; Wachtcr with
Small: Stewart (Ncw Jersey with
Salmon; Esch with Bailey (Tcxas);
Boutelle (Maine) with Cochran Mis-
sourD.
MISUNDERSTANDING.
al
lican cheers.
The Hawaiian bill was sent to con-