The Salt Lake herald. [volume] (Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1870-1909, 1899-04-12
should like to hear from each member
on this"
GIAUQUFS CHARGE.

Mr. Giauque then arose, and without
reference to President Neldens remarks
said one member had recently declared
81 will never vote for Cooper, for he is
the candidate of the clique of the
school board THAT same man." con-
| tinued Mr.. Giauque, lis now support
ing Mr.. Coope-. I do not understand
it, but take it for granted that EVERY
! thing is all right, except that the gen.
| tleman has changed his 'front.'
Mr.. Bamberger interrupted the speak
er. IF the gentleman alludeS to me,
he shouted. 'the statement is a false
hood, first, last and all the time"
II am not without Witness" retail
ated Giauque, and Bamberger repeated
that the statement was false.
The chairman objected to such Ian
guage and prevented further trouble
by declaring the gentlemen out of or
der. Bamberger insisted on speaking,
but was not allowed to proceed.
EXPLANATIONS SHUT OUT.
Mr. Moyle then wanted to explain as
to what he had said regarding the new
superintendent having a fight on his
hands. He was ruled out of order, and
appealed. The chair was sustained by
a vote of six to three, one member hav-
ing left the room. Moyle moved that
Bamberger be allowed to talk, to which
Judge Henderson objected. He thought
it all out of place and bad for, the
future harmony eff the board. New
man took issue with the judge. con-
tending that all should be allowed to
speak. It want every man to have his
say he said, land do not believe in
suppressing explanations. I move you
that the gentleman be allowed to
speak"
THAT is not part of the business be-
fore the house" said Critchlow. still
in the chair The appeal again resulted
in the chair being sustained.
Mr.. Wilson here moved that all re-
marks, including those of President
Nelden, be expunged from the record.
Moyle was on his feet in an instant:
Il shall object to that" he exclaimed,
for it is the most fragrant exhibition
of partisanship we have yet had. l
want it to remain there-al of 1t. -Four
will allow speaking from the floor of
this house; six will not. We want the
record to show that. Mr.. Nelden stood
here and made charges as to what
some member had said, and then he
turns around and votes against the
right of anv one else to speak. He
seems to have no desire to have the
charge refuted. How magnanimous of
him How fair; how broad. Why, [
say it is positively the rankest speci-
men of partisanship We have had.
Mr.. Nelden also said Mr.. Cooper was
the strongest man." he continued, I
say now that j. H. Paul is the strong
est. ablest man we have ever had here.
He better fills the requirements of such
a responsible position. Mr.. Cooper has
no degree, even, he is not graduate
from any college and never did any
work of this kind, to speak OF.
you are out. of order" interposed |
the chair "What you are saying does
not bear on the subject"
COOPER OUT OF DATE.
Il say. it does bear on the subject"
replied Moyle, hOtly. Cooper is not !
even an up-to-date man. by his own
He tells us he hasn't pub |
lished any calendars in his schools for
five years-a wonderfully progressive |
man. Why, Mr.. Paul would have got |
ten out catalogues -
II move, Mr.. President, that he fife !
his speech with the reporters, and cen
slider it delivered put in Wilson.
Ignoring this, Moyle continued: IF
it had not been for DIR. Millspau%h and |
Miss Holton he would not have been
here at ALL The speaker was about |
to read "a number of Mr.. Coopers rec
when Wilson arose to a
point of order. He is not speaking to
the subject. Mr.. President" The chair
appeal being taken.
RESTORES PEACE.
Giauque then wanted Bambarger to
be heard. Henderson objected. This
talk" said he, SIS a great detriment to
the interests we represent. I appeal to
every one of you gentlemen, personally.
[ hope we do not all forget the old
maxim of our school days. Soft words
-urneth away wrath We want no
more of this talk, gentlemen; i is not
good"
The words of Judge Henderson had
the desired effect, and the motion to
expunge was put and carried by a vote
IF to 4.
But little routine business was con-
;idered. The committee on buildings
and grounds recommended the building
If a two-story, siX-room addition TO
he Emerson school. Bids for constrLc-
ion will be asked for.
DIR. COOPER ACCEPTS.
Des Moines Ia. April 11.-Frank B.
Cooper, superintendent of city schools
If West Des Moines, has accepted the
position of city superintendent of Salt
Lake. He is one of the best-kuown
public school men of the west.