New-York tribune., 1899-07-27
BROOKLYN NEWS.
DADY GETS A SETBACh.
Ex-sHERIFF BUTTLING WINS AN lMroi''
TANT VICTORY.
JUDGE HuRp DECIDES THAT HIS LIST OF PRiS'Ai''
AND ELECTION DISTRICT OFFICIALS Is THE
PROPER ONE TO BE Fn.ED-oNE-

PROPER ONE TO BE F11ED-oNf~
SIDED HARMONY.
Ex-sberir william J. Buttling. Of Kings Coun,o n.y.
Yesterday in the County Court won deciueo "
tory over Michael j. Dady chairman OF the nep' =,
lIcan Executive Committee. and by the ue1''y.
Judge Hurd Mr. Dady will have his aetS "s 20. n1,h
man reviewed 10 the extent OF having 10 ' a,ac-
the Board OF Elections the list OF primary am
ton district officials which Mr.. Butting' as ~
tive member from the Board forWaroeu ho
Dady in June Mr. Buttling made out the hs' a. -
wanted It, and as has been the custom TOT - "a
the executive member from the ward. Dauy
Lieutenant Governor Woodruff have decIareu ~
Buttling, and hence II was that as soon :. 20
Dady received Mr.. Buttlings list he cohs'ene. sark
not TO the waste paper basket, 10 a ueel IT. ou,n
"cubbyhole" in his desk and sent hst Oh ~ ~ 80,
friends 10 the Board OF Elections for hng' l"1 oe
ex-Sheriff says that Mr.. Dady's course Il SUI
along the line OF harmonizng the iaC'iO A.
warmly upheld by Mr. Woodruff and Nj a..
who seem 10 leave Mr.. Buttling out OF all 'ne'' ''
mony schemes. - ~
Mr.. Buttng looked over a copy Of the bylaws y
the Republican County Committee. ana "ie.
amlned the new Elections law, and he sa'u
once that he had a He turned the io' na' 80
over to his counsel. Hugo Hirsh and to'u MIN
fight Mr. Dady - -,
At the time Of the argument by Mr.. hrsh y.
behalf OF his client Judge Hurd expressed ~
that ne nad JURISDICTION. ne no" NO~'N
has Jurisdiction following the case or felhoa0. a,
aet Roosevelt He says that the Iurp0ssee "a
Election law would be frustrated II the no
contention were maintained Indeed he rsxaesc,;tye
power is given TO the chairman OF tne IN IN ne y
Committee nominate at all: Ihe hclV. ~ entered
Is reversed and order is directed TO pe III sts
on one DAYS notice 10 authenticate ana HE 'le '
of the petitioner. r,o,,t,, sre in
hope that Mr. Dady seeing the menlIgS, gYS,,,tiinS il
ness of his position backed up as Mr. B9trhIKf NTH
bv decision Of the courts will gracelq lqilS
draw his list Of officials and allow MI buttiiIs IND
list to be filed There have been OF late hdh! -
and eloquent professions of desire ior at hal MS
In the party in order that the county ~, VII
fan may stand fair chance Of election TS
this love OF harmony does not include tne n,',g ~
III in its scope the independently RepueiI,TnaHS and
Prooklvn cannot understand. Mr.. Buttnnk ao a.
Mr. Woodruff had a bitter quarrel TWO Eea.S ~
and there is no disposition on the part OF gpioh,
hurry the hatchet But the Independent IsraiIb raai ne
cans of Brooklyn naturally ask why a quuxr,teert ~
tween two men should be carried 70 the eH.eit fai
in1uring the party's prospects IN me ,hn Fifth
cempaiRn Mr. Buttlilg Is a power III tio No., "a
War6 hut that is as far az his Influence eH1ehus eHIei
In a potential degree at the present UNI, A.. or
iieutenant Governor Woodruff was asked & udi { %
two ago why the scheme Of harmonzing ~, tne Eis,b
tions Old not include Mr.. ButtIhs anu '''
Ward he said IL was ''imposslbie.