The Pacific commercial advertiser. [volume] (Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands) 1885-1921, 1899-03-17

The two brothers having put in the lockcr iru
bar was placed small hachway above ia order
prevent escape uuarned guard stationed
hatcay with instructions give the brothers all the
water they needed to other 81 their.
and to report Captain anything else asked
occasion might otherwise require.
about eight or nine that evening the brothers ak
that their coats he removed on account Of the great
The Captain, upon being informed Of the request
ordered the handouts enable
the men to take off their coats and then put the handouts
again. The did ordered to hbclant, but IA a'
tempting handcuf, T. II. Colcgrove wrists
broken This fact being reported To- the Master
the latter inquired of first if there any file
board with which the handouts could bc The mate
piled that there not and until arrival Ic further
attempt made the handouts Had lac be-"
able to do L Captain would have removed the
handouts either time during that night ar when the
belant taken out of the locker
Ibelan remained in the locker until about
eight o'clock the following morning when they taken
by Captain and confined in Of the second
During the night they asked for and obtained
ice of and taken twice
answer of About midnight friend ON hcSn
brought them lie T. III. Cocgrcvc being IN
good health suffered great inconvenience by OF his
the locker ibelant the other hand had over
himself just prior this aud IN somewhat
and poor of health, and consequently unable
bear well and suffered account Of the
lack proper ventilation and of the heat The degree 81
his suffering has however, believe been greatly
ated by the hbeant his libel and in the testimony
the stand of permanent INJURY health =
unsupported by any evidence
"When taken locker, libcilant in semi
unconscious his confinement and had to %
assisted the The surgeon attended upon him
and the Captain gave beant be furnished
thing might desire in the line of food 1t some
Just long clearly shown by the evdence-bcfcre
fully recovered consciousness The remainder oi that
day. Monday Tuesday until the ship anchored IN
Il,
lean Consul came conduct investigation. the
brothers confined in the second class eroom already
mentioned door of this kept closed and guard
placed on duty, outside
Wheher the blinds kept closed for part at
the time as claimed by libelant my finding i that the
was fairly well ventilated comfortable and that while
therein beant suffered discomfort except that wic
by his previous confinement in the chain ccker
by fact of his being handcufcd; while there lac was
regularly furnished with proper food
"pon arrival at IIic the morning of Tuesday, the 9th
September the Captain ashore and reported to the
American Consul of the lie ut th.
procured from the chief of police key with which
to unlock handouts the brothers In consequence
the received the Consul aboard and there
held an investigation What the findings of the Consul were
the evidence does show further than that hc
did not peremptorly Captain release the
During investigation the handouts were
moved and at the of the proceedings hbeant and
his brother were custody and thereafter
accorded the full privileges of passengers
1T necessary consider, the subject Of usihca
ton few facts occurring prior the assault Bcrncr From
the beginning of the voyage beant paid marked attentions
TO Rose Berner and mother apparently consenng
thereto until about the third fourth
dav out when the first between Berner and bcant
occurred Iibeant was seated deck with Rose and her
mother approached and in the Of short
conversation which followed charged 10y nsnuaon that libel
lants intentions daughter dhonorabc Mrs
Bener part the quarrel against her husband and
said in loud zone that Berlncr not the father
Of Rose and that she could point him If he wanted
girls real father libellan seized chair ana Wa
L r.-Is