Arizona republican., 1899-03-01
UDALL VOTED WRONG
(Continued From First Page.)

tion; that it is never heard Of outside the legislature, and that the people are not committed for or against it. He appealed to the council to send the bill back to the education committee that it might draw a pure" bill-some- thing in keeping with the character of woman, and something that would meet with the approval Of the people
 This proposal to give Messrs Olney, Wright and Wolff, as the education committee, an opportunity to produce something pure" in the line of a wo- mans rights bill was a delicious bit of humor, and everybody laughed.
 Mr Murphy came back hot-fOOted and ridiculed the idea of the committee producing anything. The move was only in line of defeating the bill. Any old thing" would do, and MT Bunch had not suggested, even hypnotically, the idea to be embodied in the amend ed or substitute bill proposed.
 The motion to recommit prevailed by a rising vote-those voting aye be- ing Bunch, Finley, Goldberg, Olney and Wolff-5. Those voting nay were Hunt, Murphy Udall and Goldwater- f. MT. Carpenter and MT. Warner failed to vote, and MT. Wright, being in the chair was not obliged to vote, there being no tie. The responsibility for the recommendation that the bill be recommitted rested between MT. Carpenter and MT. Warner, who are understood to be pledged to vote for the bill. It is not understood, how ever, that they are pledged to vote for every motion that tends to bring the bill before the council for fiEal pas sage
 The motion to recommit having been carried in committee. the unin1tiated ladies in the lobby sighed and depart ed, thinking the show was over, when in reality it had just begun. The com mittee considered other bills and arose. The council sat, with Presi- dent Goldwater in the chair Mir. Wright, as chairman of the whole committee, put the motion in accord ance with the report of the committee, and on a rising vote, the question be- ing, shall the bill be recommitted, MT. Udall, the friend of the bill, voted with the five declared enemies-Bunch, Fin ley, Goldberg, Olney and Wolff. MT. Murphy regarded his colleague with horror, and the enemy with delight. The nays being called for, Messrs. Car penter, Hunt, Murphy, Wright and Goldwater arose. MT. Warner refusing to vote. The president declared the motion carried and the bill in the possession of the education committee.
 MT Murphy whispered in MT. UdalIs ear, and that gentleman's face fell. At the first opportunity he moved that the vote by which the bill had been re- committed be reconsidered, and eX- plained that he had voted under a misapprehension of the effect Of his vote. The chair put the motion. There was a sound of aye" and a more viz orous sound of mo- The motion to reconsider was evidently lost. The chair looked at MT. Udall and pause1, waiting for the demand of division" or for the roll call, but MT. UdalI, and MT Murphy, and every other friend of the bill, if there be any, were mute, and the chair declared the motion to reconsider lost.
 During the evening session of the council, MT. Murphy moved to re- consider the vote, hut he made his res Clution during a call of the house, and it was declared out of. order. Just be- fore adjournment, MT. Udall requested that an entry be made in the minutes to the effect that his vote was cast on