The Pacific commercial advertiser. [volume] (Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands) 1885-1921, 1899-03-17

the patient, that absolute and freedom from
disturbance of any kind essential recovery. In
luence of this and also for other which need h.
stated and the sufcency Of which need bc considered.
the determined Mr. Ecrncr aud place her
in confinement. Approaching the place where. deck. -hc
seated with her daughter the Hbcau the olcr,
the Mrs. Bcrincr and take her u certain
locker the lower deck be there confined the
officer started with the mother. the daughter
and told the captain that she wanted mother:
the captain first refused finally the girl insisting that
that her desire and that she lid not wish bc separated
from her mother and the mother herself returning the
and declaring that her daughter should be separated
her. yielded and permitted her the small ockcr
in which her mother confined There the libcant
manned for hour perhaps when -he taken her
father, his request he the still being deck After
being with him few minutes she taken To- the
OF Harris her uncle, the latter having expressed desire
speak her there. She with her uncle about five
and then taken second class where she
remained. except below stated o'clock the
morning This chosen by the captain for
the ibeant in consequence the surgeons direction
wounded father have absolute and quiet and because
other vacant stateroom available. Ihclant c>c~
that the door of this locked the outside but IL
the truth of this satisfied The captain did order
the door locked guard however stationed outside 1t
the door, with instructions call the ewarcs whenever
quested to do by the ibclant anil generally any
other requests made by her.
AT about eleven o'clock that night ar perhaps earlier
bclant again visited her father his request this occasion
his stateoom, remaining with him for about fifteen
minutes During this visit upon the urgent request
Beriner, his wife allowed his room AMI she
thereafter separated FROM him.
Returning second class ateroon Hbclant asked the
to bring her book and a pack cards The
cards brought but the book for
About midnight lbelant sleep did not awake until
shortly before o'clock in the morning That room WIS
well ventilated and uncomfortable this fact of itself
At about o'clock she her fathers AMI
manned there until Hlo reached the following morning
y guard stationed outside of the Mr. EcrincrS
with instructions keep the door open
liner constantly in view and permit him
belant at liberty haye her meals table with
other passengers but under the circumstances she preferred
remain in her and brought there
this accordingly done She herself testified that regard
to meals, she had no for complaint.
ITO summarize thus far, them my finding licIaut
any time imprisoned in any
referred certainly in the small locker because she
there of her free WILL in her fathers -tatcroom
while there she liberty do she pleased except
disturb with father; the
class saeroom because the only limitations there placed upon
her that she should occupy night
OF her and that she should father
except with the captains permission. These restrictions her
liberty proper and justabe under the AMI
constitute a of action.
with reference to the alleged interference with ibcau,-
liberty while the ship in the harIor IF o thc facts
that all of the passengers with the exception report
and three residents of IIio we'll -lor.
detained board for three hours pending the
making report by the captain the officers
port and that there discrimination against ibcant
When finally the other passengers allowed land libel
liant also was allowed to and did - ashore.
The of assault upon bcaut. and IF the
of harsh and insulting language her 10y the captain.
shown by the evidence bc mfoundc,l.
with ruCri
The libel Is dismissed and attachment issued herein i-
solved.
Decree accordingly
While recognizing correctness Of general principles