The Hawaiian gazette., 1899-01-10

tlen.a state 3 ifat ia anffalfg ta
slss ~ soali uas.f tt,m f,ifosps
g. s~,si.as es.f s i6 b. ri,ss eeisss
hsislaitf inifni in fhr Uunifaff m n
ftard. uf rrtfsfaff impiind tum a
r,r,uns,snt.s Il N, laasaai, g.eh
thB case iN, Legislative inifnt H 20 d
HsthfFtd from DE ianruanf uffd in ti
ltrolpilon hsslf nHi cohrftFs hafim
a ,s,ss, ,.s 's' p, sss. esa ,s ~ . ''9 ,.l..s ss
esospi ~ ihsfrln stated. u musi 10 ~.
snmsd that that huif mfaui What
s.ia without ant fufthef Qualifications 3
any iniusflef 0f hardship ftsuns ftun
thsir asf ihs responsibility thfrrfnf d
,aron ths law .uuk'fs Hni not upon chs
fourt
q q tru, . thins that tho pEIpHTA
ZION ~ thUst ihlusaf. lf auf. lulaWfUI
D in ~. Hawaiian Islands cannot for th.
lfsH'nt D. srfDf,yd, hsf auff d.. statute
requir' that certain proceedings hf hnH
,sfor, United States Judge IN order %
establish ~" unlaWfIlucss Of th,lf Ir,.
sacs, ana no such tribunal ~ sci ssirs
her, Bot lt does not follow that b,.. aus,
thiH L. ~ 'untr'ss did not iutyuu fHai
thr provisions of United States laws r.
sating to the EXCLUSION ~ tHus, nUi
yet w The country should take Imm,IIat,
'H"t 10 may We'll have been th, fact
and : think ihHt 10 vac that '0ugr'ss
while willing Co ALLOW th0s. Iu tho ruuua
uy unlaN fully 10 remain untu further
order. Was anxious Co put aU end af one.
20 any further innuoN
Ind"r ih' terms of ne Resolution,
when Chinese person seeks 20 enter the
iisN aiian lslaHds, the question oi wh'th-
"r or not De- b. entitled TO enter h to be-
d.termin'd IN accordance With the United
States laws, In other words. the United
States laws relating 10 the immigration
and exclusion Of Chinese are now the ru.
nf action here. are IN force here, and APP
My IN my opinion to ALL Chinese who
seek 10 enter
II is urged that no machinery has been
provided by Congress for the enforcement
nf the United States Chinese exclusion
laws IN thee. Islands and that Cons.-
quently II could not have been the In
tention OF Congress to make said laws
applicable In the cases Of those Chinese
who hold return permits issued prior to
July Z, lNN. Assuming that II II true that
thor" II no machinery a. claimed. the oil,
lection. " N u good 50 far as to lead
the Court to hold that II was not the In.
tenilon To give u" Resolution a retro
SI"cuN" operation, must also Of necessity
compel IN. Court to hold that not even
prospective operation can be given 10 II
until Congress shan by further legislation
provide the means for enforcing the laws.
The only logical conclusion Of the argu-
Tnent h. n seems 10 me, that until such
lime niiCd States laws do not apply here
and that Hawaiian laws continue Ia
force. Yet, that the Hawaiian statutes
~ far AZ they are inconsistent with
United States laws on the subject are
repealed by the Resolution and that the
~, S,",s t"MS ~, "1sltcthrlS' az
necessary conclusion as just stated would
,t,, ~, - ~ ~aa.s' ~ 'l' fty'soIuuoh mop
.,,n,t,, ;s, ,a ~, , sloss ~ ,onsftsS had
1901 ui'b r,,,,' "a, ,,ti I as ,l.'s
tion until II should further legtslate, the
clause would have been omitted; the gen
tTal provision continuing existing laws In
force would have been amply sufficient
The language Of the various United
i,,,.,i,,,,, - n" ~, IuoJ,t's VI hln'he
,i,ans ,,.. ~, o"n m,,''t, a,tpn ,h Hl o,her
.s ,h,v r,tHb, I a. %I,i,, H. ,a'',i '"ns uak' ,i
.,"s lS nlS"h ", w HS"hlhb thy i'IdHN.
.r'n,,.,,, n'u uu,,s. W w tnulsos' OF
.,,.'',l,r ol ,us,o',s ana "t 'hlnese IN,
a. ,rr.,,,r'' -, "s ,n' 9p'SIe'als % ol
1.,.,' W.. ~, W. ,. i,ot" are sSth ceftalr
p, =" - ',sc ,s,'. ai'a 'tr'alh aut,ts s 70
s III ~, ~ ~ n u't"'', i li'el' 'hn iuily ti
III, @ az Snhutso ,ilt cNNius'oI' Ia"s' Dut JUS
w, ~, un'I,nh ilt,e ptlW''h th.in ~
VII. t al l.SP',.or 'hh "o "lnou'
~. asslsIa,C. OF ,oi.Clof, ~ more
INV. l 10 9.uhr; Ahothtr question no
,s, 'i.',I -, r u,insu''s Thelher the ,oi
o'o, pi ,us.ohs OF tne lia"ailah lslanhi
au'hoIzeu 70 perlorh tn' Nhfioui
I. "s.ph'u " 'o,lcCtprs ny lh'
,.,.,' S'aIss ,n'hes1 Exclusion Laws
onI,,',,Ia' nj ~" ,'nh ~ o'ah mao
% vi Ils''l.' pl tho thlttu Statss
.u w W ianst ii"wah iaMs ON IN
",. ,h' Iol''.Sr ',heiai "i 'uston,
,sh.,har mr. ~, vi Lii, n',,i,,n,, y" ~, ", S,.i ~,
w,i is, o' ny az al'eIi hpP,Slhs l3r aH
,rn a'oI ~ ,n,i''Tn W c.lcr ttsr inI"iiu'
.., . >,~mihnu ~ isspi"'lon hoNm"s Una
',''',l ,., .onsi @ i'ss si,an ploH'uU ior VI
.st,h ,l'"i'mt VI ,s su,i islaiuS an lhs CIV
~, az" .',ii'"Is pvnr'~s Nv. ~ ~oNei.lsru a.
~, i'i ia VI In SiiW ,~N'H,i's ~ b'n'i ~. i,in.hl u
80 81 ,'',.' s'''r -, Iii , III suLn P't
-, W ,' p,'no,'', "'p a''a, ~ ,is'u
EnI,i 'i S,., "s Sii t,'' ~ VI w
-, n s''"n ,, W ~, -, 'iiu lii' Ir's -
49,, 10 al ~ rV"o, r ~ w. " anin i VI "
- "'u III ~ % ~ - ot tN"hloi''u
.i ~ a,"'n,' ,'I s,'ho"i ti,a. tn' nuIi,c
pi rsiH'"i''si s VI ''' ,.,Hn nl'in lSt'hus
nv, Vha'l'" ,I" I'i t!t iu,''i'I,nl " w
$500 ,.. % 'N,nhs",sI'u anu ny IhSoh
e'n'.iI, WIN 'iIS oo'ht N'so'ut'on. no
oh.' a'g 70 'h' ,ons'l.u'iou oi lnr ,n,te
.s s S,an io,,ia," ii w loltr u,tll , ,oI
s,t', ut ny N,i''u p. ..'''s .iai' o.lci WIZ WIZ
.. MN, ~ ,ntu' ,nttt' VI tnis latt.r PI.
Hon, ,hosc ilaMa',n' sl"tul's OF paI'
1, ~ .ia'Ins s =, I,i t,e ,miu'st "ln
~ m@i'i.n @ a. a. ~ ln'oils'at'ht o WI.
"sap "ioit .n' , .m,t.u ota',s Jaws
-, sam yf ..uy,I' 'o,''iiius ". @ ~ @ h'', "
~" 'N''nsioh VI huth .nl''u sta'.
80, 49, w. W.. ,i ,' n,iu t w, q, ei's
I hh e'og ~ ~ w, pl"poHIIoh au
. " oi'' VI ,'Ic "''p' u'se Wlo too
G"S,anLa " rma,, 80 80 ~ ~,
-, ~ % ~, w I'i,i q" 'i ,ua
i,h % ' W. ,na' t,, ,I'a'ius, ,h., ~ N.S'. =
s.h,nII a, A., ., Ir,'t,, 81, - = i . -
49, ax,ni,5 "a h,' Ia ,'io,, ~ ''a, 10,
~ ~ 'ondi,sion "a ~ 49,, W, ~
s,,,,i.,, ~, t,risdic,inT I a., 4, ,,,'y,,cas '
80. -, ,gia ~ '',,' m,,,,i,,, :" :. "''''' va
'''' N'i' ts'S''i, ~"