The Saint Paul globe. (St. Paul, Minn.) 1896-1905, 1899-01-18

two Thistle club Kinks. OF Winnipeg.
player in each rink Is a past master
in the science OF curling. and each
exerted every effort to win the victory
The skips. L. r. Mckenzie and w. F.
Payne directed their respective players
like generals. and 1t was anybody's
game until the last stone in the final
end, when McKenzie's lads won out by
a single point by a score of Is to II.
| with the largest aggregate score Of the
bonspiel. The end play was as follows:
Winnipeg Winnipeg
L. r. Mckenzie -. % 0 s o Al OF 0 lis
w. F. Payne ........4 0 o 0 0-l7
In the last games of the second draw
| for the ST Paul Jobbers' union trophy
Lem DefiePS rink, previously the only
local players who had not sustained
| defeat, met their Waterloo at the hands
of the doughty Assinniboine club play
ers, of Winnipeg, thus eliminating St.
Paul as factor in the contest. On the
other hand, the rivals Of st. Paul in
warding off defeat, Sam Harstone's
! Granite club players, met one or the
! best Kinks at the bonspiel. the Chicago
| rink, skipped by E. w. Kibbe, and add
ed another scalp to their belts. This
state of affairs leaves the Jobbers'
union trophy to be contested for en-
Kenzie, Patton and Harstone are now
the only remaining eligibles
WINNIPEG VS.. ST. PAUL.
The st. Paul rink went down fighting
hard Defiel skipped an elegant game
and was ably seconded by his players.
The Assinniboines, however, were also
in good form and played their best
Until the last head was played st. Paul
! was right in the fight, but the
! Winnipegers scored a bunch of four
points on the last end, giving them the
game by score of IL TO 8. The play
by ends:
Patton . -. 1021 0101O01 fl
Defel ............0 0 0 0 2 l. s
WINNIPEG VS.. CHICAGO.
A red hot struggle was anticipated
when Sam Harstone drew with E. w.
Kibbe. and witnesses of the game were
not disappointed. Perhaps no other
game Of the bonspieI has aroused more
interest. Neither the Chicagoans nor
the GRANTEES had anything of a secure
advantage during the game, the score
being very close at the conclusion of
each ends play, and at several stages
it was tie. Then first one rink and
next the other would lead with one or
two points up, only to be tied or head
ed on the next end, but the redoubt-
able Canadian players played a veteran
game and pulled out with a score Of
5 to Z. Following is the play by ends:
Harstone 80 OIL 0102 00111 Is
kibbe ...........1 01011O00 %
KELLY IS DEFEATED.
The first draw in the Pfster trophy
event developed some excellent curling
and one surprise when the Thistle
rink. skipped by L. r. Mckenzie, fell
before the Milwaukee curriers', skipped
by z. ]. Roberts. One OF the best
played games of the bonspiel came off
in this play between me Chicago rink,
skipped by E. W. ktbbe, and Tom
Kelly's strong granite club players, Of
Winnipeg. The score was close all
through the game and the play par
ticularly clever, scarcely a stone being
placed behind the tee line during the
game. Skip Kibbe proved the victor
by score of IA to u. The end scores
were:
Chicago VS.. Winnipeg
E. ". Kibbe ID 1oooo25 OO-14
Tom Kelly ...-....3 O1s110 o0o OIL 2-12
PAYNE LOSES TO MOULD.
Payne's Thistle rink, of Winnipeg,
showed up rather poorly in the game
with NJ H Mould's Baraboo, Wis,
rink. while the Badgers played in first
class form. winning handily by score
of Il to s. End play:
Baraboo vs.. Winnipeg
N. H. Mould .....3 0 0 1 8 Of liz
W. F. Payne ......01 0 1920 o.
PLAYED A CLOSE GAME.
One of the closest games of the day
was played between the Milwaukee
1 til M0K iaf q
Thistles. The score alternated regu-
larry in small figures until the twelfth
end, when the Cream City curriers' scor-
| ed five points, which won them the
game by IA to II. Score by ends as
| follows:
! Milwaukee VS.. Winnipeg
/ E. J. Roberts - 90 0131O1o52 ia
/ L. r. Mckenzie - 0 ell
| SECOND DRAW IN THE PF1STER.
! Three games in the second draw Of
the Pfster trophy contest were played
| late in the afternoon. Great interest
centers in this event, as there is a pos
sibility Of this years bonspiel deter
mining the final ownership Of the
| trophy. The trophy goes TO the rink
winning it the greatest number Of times
| in six years. 1t has been won once
! by the Cambria rink and once by the
| Waupaca rink, of Canada, and twice
| bv the Granite rink. of Winnipeg. This
year the only winners Of the trophy
/ represented at the bonspiel are the
i members of the Granite club. This is
the fifth year the trophy has been con-
tested for, so that If the Granite rink
! is victorious in the finals during the
! present bonspiel the trophy goes to
Winnipeg to stay. The Canadians are
pinning their hopes Of victory on VIM
nipeg's seeming invincibles. But St.
Paul is making just as strong a fight
/ iii the Pister contest through Lem
! Defel's rink, which has an unbeaten
record along with the Canadians. The
! local players are making better scores
every game and playing in more conf
dent form each day and have an even
break u to date with the GRANTEES.
Goth Kinks played their game in the
Pfster second draw at O'Clock yester-
1 day afternoon and quit neck and neck
! as they begun, by each winning out
with relatively almost the same mar
gin over their opponents
| The local rink, skipped by G. NJ.
! Griggs, went I'D against the Defel
! champions and were sent back to the
Warming room with eleven points to
their credit, while Defel's rink piled up
seventeen points. Deep interest was
| taken in the game, particularly by To-
cal curriers', while the Canadians watch
! ed with wOnderment to see if by some
possibility Defiels men might go down.
| The game was close enough to arouse
enthusiasm throughout. The score:
/ ST. Paul VS.. st. Paul
L. Defiel ..-.......1 3 6oo14011@7
! c. N. Griggs ......0 01o31 92I0120I1
CHICAGO LOSES A GAME.