New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1899-04-25

Mr. Fallows-You have given these up beo4U
they have reference to the serseants assoe'su
.o..TRen why. do you say that is private -
A-Because II II. III ~
INSULT FROM OsULLIvAN. N
Mr. o'suIlivan--lt is the oaIy one he looked svo
he says. You have gone right through his pochc0
and he has not examined them.
Mr.. Fallows-I object to that statement
The Chairman--That is an ungentiemanIy g
mark. and entirely unwarranted. that you sheoJ
so far forget yourself as to make statement 9
that kind. "a
Mr.. Fallows-The witness testified he gave q
papers willingly. Mr.. Chairman. must insist q
a retraction Of that statement
Mr.. 0'sullivan-I said he went through his pct
Voices In the Audience-Oh, Is
preserve order In the back OF the room. Any ne
making demonstration VIII leave the room
think your remark Is entirely out Of order and -
M M ols you think 50, regret f.
to retract what you said. You owe II to q
cG Nm oa and to yourself a: wei ,,-
went through his pockets pulled ou, these pspss
and T had time only to examine this one paper
mat "a, ne gave them up Voluntarily Il that ee.sst
the paper was turned over by him. II
The chairman-He had no objection TO the cor
Mr.. Honman"rhe fact remain. that somssoa
taken from h m mis- n PICKET S and they We
shall have the whole OF them
IN G Glhairman-The record will stand, -
marking and then we viii II" tx It. sersesns 20 a.
any paper you say Is private you will recelW
ne Paps a, : the Sn. Sss
NV VIII see that You have this myself Put that
sOnally as as # can be copied You W, want
witness-Do you want this7
OLD ASSOCIATION WAS DROPPED.
Mr.. clarke-The pink slip we don't care aboul
because we have that
Witness referring to another paper).-That n n
old association &" B.
Mr.. Clarke-You refer to exhibit marked TX" q
the papers which you handed up. and you say the
that has no reference to the matter under inquiry
and relates to the old association AIR. Nos
saio ne didn't want TO know anything about thu
9.aNsver mind what Mr.; Mos. said at the prs
February Il 1854 TO the 's Municipal i Police ssrssss
Benevolent Association Of the City Of New.fcsi
Respectfully, John J. McNally, Precinct NumSs
% Now. sergeant. so late then. FebruaF:
The r, Oh Gha,rma ags that 1894 or 1892 III,
..Q.-At that time the old association was known =
the Municipal Police sergeants Benevolent Assoc
s ss5s.' and you say that has nothing to DO W.T.
Of names names and figures. What are they A.-TSs
9 NWsx JAMIE! R'Y R.y A xaS !: ;: sner
Q;-Isn't he a police sergeant, Al beisv
vQ.-Is John Townsend police sergeant, A.
crossed out, police sersesni 9 XYes. s IT, nsn
.Q.vAnd isn't James O'Bren a police sergeant
.o..-And isn't Dennis oBrien police sergeant
as % G:sss s:eP'p Es 81: nam
.o.1,,And isn't John Cottrell a police sergeant
.s. PRIVATE AND NOT PRIVATE.
Q.-Now, how did those sergeants names get q
gether on that paper? Al appointed them on {
committee
o.-And why do you call 1t private business
Have you caught the bacillus! A.--No
what w; s con Rsos,y was IT, A. commit
When was It t"s apponsea ? 'H Is the sam. CON
mitses that is on this Larger lar. pager No ctr
The i pTC.s: matte. 4 sas
ton? Al don't know.
It i; ;ss,, Prysse matter You are yin
Mr.. Clarke-I understand the committee is oblise
TO- leave en- the s9o train:
like the stenographer to refer to the statement
the remarks, made by Or, o'sullivan, and wouIs
(The stenosrapher re I'D privately to the chairman
taken down by him After discussion among then
selves the following occurred:
Mr.. OSullivan-Mr. Chairman, I ask that thai
portion Of my remarks referring to this centenary
pockets and any one interfering Or going through
them be stricken from the record. had no inten
ton OF saying any such thing.
The Charman-The Chairman will 50 directr
there any more work?
Mr. Ciarke-Unless we can go on to the end. M
Chairman.
The Chairman-You may proceed then for thu
present.
Mr. Clarke-Sergeant, was asking you about
what you said at that meeting In the Murray Hi
Lyceuin and you said that you had exhausted your
memory upon the subjects that you spoke about
Now didn't you say anything at that time about
the creation of q fund? A.-No. sir: except tor
benevolent purpose-for the endowment and benevo
lent purposes
HIS MEMORY REEVES A BIT.
O-Then you did say something about the cres'
ton of a fund? Ayes, sir.
Q-Why didn't you say that before when yoc
gave the account Of what you said? A.-Wen.
said that did not remember that.
Q.-Didn't you remember that you talked about
q fund that night? Ayes. You have Jogged ny
memory
O.-Didn't you remember before I jogged yous
memory? A.-No. sir: not on the spur OF the mo
ment; did not remember.
O-You had quite a while to think about what
YOU said asked you a number OF questions II
regard to H. didn't I? Ayes.
Q-And asked you over and over II that was a