davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The Scranton tribune. [volume] (Scranton, Pa.) 1891-1910, 1899-05-04
GREEN RIDGE.

Ice Cream Soda at II. NJ Coles
pharmacy, 1888 Capouse avenue ~
Frank Wilcox, of Delaware street, is
in New York city.
Miss May Austin has returned from
a visit in Factoryville.
w. G. Reynolds is visiting friends
in Montrose.
c. w. Erockway, of Monscy avenue,
is at Lake Ariel
Miss Fleta Finch. of Monsey avenue,
has returned home from a visit in
Factoryville.
New York city.
Mrs. Schadt, of New York city. is the
guest of her sister Mrs. Phinney of
Green Ridge street.
c. a. Cranfort, of Capouse avenue,
is spending a few days in New Yorl;
| city.
Only Williams ice cream used with
| soda water drawn at Manners drug
| store. -
| Mrs. Ross Rrooks has returned from
Madisonville, where she was called by
the illness of her sister.
Miss Marion Charlesworth, of Homes
dale, is the guest of Mrs. j. Charles
| Wincke, of Marion street.
Mrs. Cart and daughter, of Elk Lake
are the guests of Mrs Mause, of Penn
avenue
| The Women's Christian Temperance
union will meet this afternoon at $50
o'clock in the library. The question OF
a new drinking fountain will be dis.
! Cussed. A full attendance Is desired
| The rebuilding of DR.. +. f. Arndt's
house on CapOuse avenue, is nearly
completed. The doctor has made some
changes and it is now one of the mos
modern of residences.
w. X. Manners, of MOosic. was here
yesterday, looking after business in,
| terests
Nothing but the purest of fruit juices
and rock candy syrup used in soda
favors at Manners pharmacy 92(
Green Ridge street. ."
The Scranton tribune. [volume] (Scranton, Pa.) 1891-1910, 1899-05-04
GENERAL NEWS NOTES.

The ladies of the First Baptist church
whose names begin with the letters A
and B, will serve supper this evening
from $50 to o'clock at the home of
DIR. b. G. Beddoe, on South Main ave-
nue.. Friends are cordially invited to
attend.
Frank, the young son of William r.
James, of Eynon street, had his arm
caught in wagon wheel last evening
and he suffered dislocation at the
shoulder joint. DR.. George B. Reynolds
was called and attended him.
There was a large attendance at the
meeting in Simpson Methodist Episco-
pal church last evening, when Secre-
tary w. w. Adair, of the Railroad De-
partment of the Young Mems Chris
tian association, made brief address.
Benjamin James, organizer of the
Miners union, addressed a meeting in
Goldens hall, Bellevue. last evening.
Many miners were present and much
interest was manifested in the proceed
ings.
The monthly missionary meeting of
the Epworth league of Simpson Metho-
dist Episcopal church will be held this
evening, when the subject of the
american Indian" will be discussed.
meeting of the members Of the
West Side Social club is called for this
evening, and the members are all ex-
pected to be present.
a dramatic reading will be given by
Mr.. Ebbles at the Electric City Wheel
mems headquarters on THE Prisoner
of Ienda," on Tuesday evening, May 16.
full attendance of the members of
st. Patrick's church choir is requested
for this evening. Rehearsals of Farm
er's mass. which will be sung on Sun
day next, with orchestra aCcompani-
ment, will be held.
A farewell reception will be rendered
the famous Welsh Prize Singers at the
Jackson Street Baptist church on Mon
day evening, May %.
A special meeting of the Franklin
Engine company was held last evening
in their headquarters on North Hyde
Park avenue. Final arrangements were
made for the company's participation
in Mondays parade.
St. Paups Pioneer corps met in st
David's hall last evening and received
instruction under the direction of Cap.
tain Walter McNichols.
An important meeting of Coumhid
Hose company will be held in st
David's hall tomorrow evening. Every
member is requested to be present.
The Scranton tribune. [volume] (Scranton, Pa.) 1891-1910, 1899-05-04
DUN MORE.

Mr.. and Mrs. John Schlentz. Of Pine
street, entertained yesterday afternoon
from 4 until s o'clock in honor of its
being the anniversary Of the birthday
of their daughter Miss Elizabeth. a
splendid time was enjoyed by all those
present. who were Genevieve Sioat,
Cora Cramer, Lulu Morris. Jessie
Dings, Lydia Ehrhardt, Grace Miller,
Edith Kenynen, Ida Dings, B assic Ehr-
hardt, Lizzie Paul, Helen Miller, Olive
Harper, Eshter Ehrhardt, Eil Bidwell,
Anna Knynin, Dortha Knynin, Romano
Sloat, Hattie Names, Sadie Sloat, a eah
Names, Minnie Paterson, Fred
Schientz, Harrison Cramer, John Harp
er, Donald Schnell, Frank schnell and
Ray Bidwell. Refreshments were
served at p. IN.
Miss Clara Collins, of Butler street,
entertained few OF her friends Vt her
home last evening. The evening was
passed in the enjoyment of social di-
versions and music. both vocal ana
instrumental. which was furnished by
Misses May Winters and Jennie Sacor.
The guests were the Misses May Win
ters, Bessie Winters, Jennie Sec or,
Clara Collins, Mamie Harper and
Messrs. Howard and Edward Harper
and Arthur Collins.
A number of the young friends Of
Mr.. and Mrs. Alexander Mckay, cf
Green Ridget street, met at their home
last night and had a pleasant time.
Those present were Misses Elsie Pow
ell Marie Van Cleft, Marie Webb ar,
Sallic Price, Ruby Yost. Jessie " ert,
Anna Henwood: Messrs. Joseph Cray
John Vert and William Zeig;er.
Many persons attended the social last
evening given at the home of Mr.. and
Mrs. John Watrous under the auspices
of the Young Peoples Christian En-
deavor union of te Dudley Street Bap-
tist church. A neat sum was realized
from the serving of lirht refreshments
during the evening by the young ladies'.
| Socially, ii was q pronounced success.
The funeral of George Michael, the
young son of Mr.. and Mrs. David j.
Michael of East Drinker street, Spor;
Hill, took place yesterday afternoon
and was we'll attended. The remains
were conveyed from the home by Cun
! eral Director r. p. Letchworth to Dun
more cemetery, where interment was
made.
The Ladies' Aid society of the Tres.
| byterian church will meet at the IN
of Mrs. James Skeoch, Sr., on Clay ave-
nue., this afternoon at the society'S
/ regular meeting time. A good attend
ance is desired
large silk flag was flung to thu
breeze on the Odd Fellows new build.
| ing yesterday morning. 1t was the
! gift of Dunmore odd Fellows, VINO are
! still patriotic and wish ii to he seen
The flag will be raised daily.
large dog belonging to William
Weber, of Throop street, yesterday in
flicted several bites on the body anC
legs of James Joyce, son of Martin
Joyce. The canine was shot by Rue
ben Jones.
Miss May Lewis, of Pittston, is beint
entertained by Miss Kate Dryden, Q
Dudley street.
The Scranton tribune. [volume] (Scranton, Pa.) 1891-1910, 1899-05-04
NORTH SCRANTON.

Simon Thomas, of Reese street fire.
boss at Storrs' No. mine, was slightly
injured by being struck by trip of
cars yesterday.
The members of the ways and means
committee of the Father Whitty soci-
ETY. are urgently requested to meet at
their rooms on Saturday evening.
The funeral of James Murphy, who
died early Monday morning from in
juries received in the Marvinc mine
three weeks ago. will take place this
morning from the home of his parents,
Mr.. and Mrs. Patrick Murphy, Of Hoi-
Ian street At 10 o'clock a requiem
mass will be sung at the Holy Rosary
church, after which interment will be
made in the Cathedral cemetery.
Rev. Thomas DeGruchy will deliver
a lecture on John Bunyon ana Pill
grims' Progress" illustrated with stei =
eopticon views in the Welsh Baptist
church, West Market street, Wednes-
day evening, May TO- Admission IS
cents.
Mrs. j. r. Howell, of Taylor is the
guest Of relatives on Hollistrv avenue.
The Colonel Lewis council will ilit!-
morrow evening in Leonard hall. All
members of the order are invited to at
tend the meeting.
Mrs. William AnnOn, of Wilkes
Barre, who has been the guest of Mr..
and Mrs. d. Y. Williams. of Warren
street, the past week, returned home
yesterday.
Thomas II, Evans. of Wayne ave-
nue., is ill.
The funeral of the late Mrs. Well
Benjamin will take place this after
noon at 8 o'clock from the family resi-
dence on North Main avenue. inter
ment will be made in the Dunmora
cemetery.
Mrs. w. G. Reynolds and daughter
Gertrude, of Montrose, visited friends
here yesterday.
The Welsh Congregational church Of
West Market street has made all ar
rangements for the cantata, Red Rid
ing Hood" to be held June 10.
Mrs. T. ID. Jones, of West Market
street, visited her brother, Edwari
Jones, of Taylor, yesterday.
Miss Annie Kelly, who was visiting
relatives on Short avenue. returned t,
her home in Ashley yesterday.
Mrs. David Lloyd, of Taylor, is VII.
iting her daughter, Mrs, Sidney Lewis
on Mary street.
Next Monday evening the Rev. i. 4
The Scranton tribune. [volume] (Scranton, Pa.) 1891-1910, 1899-05-04
NOT HOSTILE TO THE MAYOR.
Councilman Melvin Explains His
Position in Fire Chief Muddle.

r. G. Melvin, a Democratic mem
ber Of the fire department committee
In discussing the session of the pre-
vious evening, said that the commit
tees action was not to be construed
to mean hostility to the mayor. lie
was personally in favor of retaining
Chief Hickey, hut that, he averred,
did not enter into the case at present.
The committee was not satisfied that
the mayors action would stand the test
of law and in the interest of the treas
ury took steps to prevent a recurrence
of the Walsh and Lewis incidents.
Mr.. Melvine had reference to analo-
gous cases that occurred under the
Fellows administration. Anthony
Walsh. patrolman, was dismissed by
Mayor Fellows without the consent of
select council and it was nIne months
before the nomination II his successor
was confirmed. Walsh took n trip to
Ireland and unon his return sued the
city and recovered his salary for the
The Scranton tribune. [volume] (Scranton, Pa.) 1891-1910, 1899-05-04
PRETTY CHURCH WEDDING.

One of the prettiest church weddings
occurring in South Scranton for some
time took place yesterday morning at
$50 o'clock, when Miss Kate Brier, of
Hickory street, was married to Jacob
Goham, of Pittston, at st. Marys
church. The auditorium was thronged
with friends of the young people to
witness the ceremony.
Prof. Ackerman played the wedding
marches. The bride, attended by her
brother, John Brier, proceeded up the
aisle and were met at the sanctuary
railing by the groom, who was attended
by his sister Miss Theresa Goham. The
Misses Lena Rosar and Kate Schriver
escorted by William Gliger and John
Goham, completed the bridal party.
Rev. Father stopper performed the
ceremony.
The nuptial mass concluded the
bridal party repaired to the residence
of the brides parents, Mr.. and Mrs.
Peter Bricr, 617 Hickory street, where
a reception was held and a wedding
dinner served.
The bride wore a handsome gown of
white silk, chiffon and lace trimmings,
and a white veil. The bridesmaids all
wore white organdie, and carried car
nations. Last night Mr.. and Mrs. Co
ham We're rendered a reception at St.
Johns hall. They will reside in Pitts
ton, where Mr. Goham is in the retail
grocery business.
The Scranton tribune. [volume] (Scranton, Pa.) 1891-1910, 1899-05-04
NEW MINING CHIEF.
James E. Roderick, of HazletoD,
Named by Governor Stone to
Succeed Robert Brownlee,
of Lycoming County

Governor Stone has made a change
in the head of a bureau of the de-
partment of internal affairs by reliev-
ing Robert Brownlee. Of I.ycoming
county, chief Of the bureau of mines
and mining, and appointing in his
stead James f. Roderick, of Hazleton.
at present general superintendent of
the Van Wickle interests at Mines
vile and Coleraine, in Luzerne county.
Mr.. Brownlee's term ended with the
expiration of the state senate, his
name having been among the nominal
tions recalled by Governor Stone short
ly after the latter's Inauguration.
Several weeks ago, says the Hazle-
ton Plain Speaker, Mr.. Roderick quiet
ly slipped down to Harrisburg, at
which time it was nofsed about that
he was slated for the head of the min
ing bureau. Yesterdays announcement
confirms the surmises of his friends
and political associates.
The appointment of Mr.. Roderick
| will, of course, mean his resignation
as superintendent for the Van Wickle
| interests. 1t is not vet known wher
| he will assume the duties of his new
position. He will retain his Hazletor
| residence
| Robert Brownlee having been marked
| for decapitation Governor Stone coulC
| not have selected a better qualified
man than Mr.. Roderick, who is a mar
versed in all the details Of mining, his
entire lifetime having been spent il
that occupation, first as common miner
then as foreman, later as mine in
| SDpCtOr and finally as mine Superin
tendent. He is one of HaZleton'G mos
| prominent citizens. His new position
gives him supervision over all the minC
inspectors of the anthracite and btu
minOus coal fields Of the state
The Scranton tribune. [volume] (Scranton, Pa.) 1891-1910, 1899-05-04
NC8S OF NEWS.

Philip RAIDER, of Birch street, has
been removed to his home from the
Scranton private hospital. He was at
that institution for the past two months
where he underwent an operation for
appendicitis. His recovery delights his
many friends.
The following officers were elected by
the st. Irene's Total Abstinence and
Beneficial society at a recent meeting
as follows: President, Mrs T.. c. Con-
nell; vice president, Miss Margaret
Durliin; recording secretary, Miss Liz
zie Durkin; financial secretary, Miss
Ella Gavin; treasurer, Miss Julia Wha-
len; sergeant at arms. Miss Anna Me-
Crea; trustees, Misses Mary McHalc,
Annie Mohtt and Anna Bowling.
The beautiful loon, caught at the new
Scranton lake on No. mountain, by
August Hahn. recently, as mentioned
in The Tribune, has been returned from
the shop of the taXidermist and is now
on exhibition at the business place of
Common Councilman Smith, on Pitts
ton avenue Chief p. ]. Hickey, of the
fire department, has purchased the
beautiful specimen.
At ST. Peters cathedral yesterday
morning at $50 o'clock mass of re-
| quiem was celebrated at the funeral
services Of the late Mrs. d. w. Waugh
an, Of Willow street, Rev. j. B. Cough
was Celebrant and many friends were
| in attendance at the services.
At the conclusion of the mass the re-
mains were borne TO the Cath edral
cemetery, where interment was made,
| The pall-bearers John, William and
| Michael ODonnell, John and Bryan
| Byron and John Williams.
Select and Common Councilmen John
| ]. Schneider and Fred. Phillips, re-
| spectively, have begun to make use OF
| the ward appropriation allotted TO the
| Eleventh ward for the repairing of the
streets in their ward, George Rosar
the retired milk dealer, has been chosen
foreman of the gangs of men employed
| for the work.
The Scranton tribune. [volume] (Scranton, Pa.) 1891-1910, 1899-05-04

w. p. Lynott, or Viewmont street,
left here for New York yesterday.
Jones. of Llwypia, South Wales, will
preach at the Puritan Congregational
church, under the auspices Of the
Wayne Avenue Baptist church. Rev
Mr.. Jones is considered leader among
the great preachers of Wales.
Miss Maud Burdock. Of SprinBflelc,
is visiting Miss Ann Schaier, of Throop
street.
Rev. John Kowala. of HOLSTER ave-
nue., is in Philadelphia.
Thomas Murtaugh has broken ground
on Oak street for the ere 3tio1 of a
handsome new residence.
The employees of the Won Sturch and
Dickson mines received their monthly
salary yesterday.
Mrs. Thomas Gavin, of Kingston, is
visiting her daughter, Mrs. Thomas
Barrett, of Lloyd street.
George Harvey is i'll at his home on
Breaker street.
The Scranton tribune. [volume] (Scranton, Pa.) 1891-1910, 1899-05-04
BANQUET LAST NIGHT.

The members of the X. Of X. club
held a banquet last evening at the
home of Mr.. and Mrs. j. James, 5lS
North Bromley avenue. The toast
master was Peter Lewis and the speak
ers were Emrys Joseph, Gus Eynon
and William II. Robertson.
The banquet was given in honor of
Howard Davis, a member of Company
G, Thirteenth regiment, Pennsylvania
Volunteers, who is a member Of the
club. The house was prettily decor
ated with palms and ferns and flags
Covers were laid for twenty guests
who numbered the members of the club
and their lady friends.
The club will meet next Monday
evening at the home Of Emrys Joseph,
on South Hyde Park avenue, which
will be the last meeting unLil the first
Monday in October.
The Scranton tribune. [volume] (Scranton, Pa.) 1891-1910, 1899-05-04

Frank Nealis, the 3-year-old son of
Mr.. and Mrs. Z. ]. Nealis. while play
ing on Robinson street, yesterday af-
ternoon, was struck by Taylor-Throop
street car, No. 139, and badly injured.
Two of the fingers on his right hand
were crushed The lad was caught by
the fender and dragged about eight
feet.
The little fellow was picked up and
carried into the house, where Doctors
Reynolds, Hall, Moylan and jenkins
cared for him. His injuries are not
serious. The car was running at the
usual rate of speed. and the boy ran
across the street into the car, appar-
entity not noticing where he was going.
Conductor William Fuller and Motor
man Sthalheber were on the car, and
but for the prompt action of the latter
in stopping his car in about its own
length. the result might have been
worse.
The Scranton tribune. [volume] (Scranton, Pa.) 1891-1910, 1899-05-04
CORONER INVESTIGATES.

Coroner Roberts made an investiEa-
fion of the remains of the late George
Crompton yesterday morning in the
presence of several physicians to de-
termine the exact cause of death. a
slight abrasion of the skin on the head
led to the suspicion that death was due
TO a fracture, but the coroner's exam
ination revealed nothing Of that kind.
Death was due to apopleXy, as stated
in this column yesterday.
The examination was witnessed by
Doctors Jenkins, Beddoe, Hall, Com
eggs, McKeage, Thompson and Gard
ner.
The Scranton tribune. [volume] (Scranton, Pa.) 1891-1910, 1899-05-04
ALDERMANIC CASES.

The hearing in the assault and bat
terry case of Thomas Davis VS.. Job
Whitehouse was held last evening in
Alderman Johns court, and the defend
ant was bound over to appear at court
in the sum OF 5000.
James Reeder. of Aswell court. who
was arrested early yesterday morning
for creating a disturbance at his home,
was given a hearing by Alderman
Moses yesterday and held in $500 bail
for his appearance at court.
The Scranton tribune. [volume] (Scranton, Pa.) 1891-1910, 1899-05-04

tions, and games OF various kinds were
played. Refreshments were served by
the hostess before the guests departed.
Those present were Misses Nellie
Baldwin and Kittle Baldwin, of Ver-
mont; Alice Gallagher, Name Flaherty,
Agnes Gcrrlty, Name Gurrell, Ida Van
stpn, Annie Lavelle, Messrs. Charles
Marion, William Vanston, Robert T..
McNichols, Thomas T.. Murphy, jr.,
James, John and Albert Baldwin and
Michael Madden.
The Scranton tribune. [volume] (Scranton, Pa.) 1891-1910, 1899-05-04
MAYOR is IN EARNEST.
First Offender Against the Slot
Machine Order Under Arrest.

John Luchen, proprietor of the hotel
corner Oak street and Brick avenue,
was arrested by Lieutenant Spellman
last night and given a hearing before
Alderman Fidler, charged with harbor-
ing a gambling device. The prisoner
was held in $500 bail for his appearance
at court.
1t is just ten days since the order
went out that all slot machines, etc,
used for gambling must be removed
from all places where run. Luchen was
notified but apparently did not mind il
much and his arrest followed The
machine is now at the Providence
police station.
The Scranton tribune. [volume] (Scranton, Pa.) 1891-1910, 1899-05-04
FUNERAL OF JAMES TINKHAM
Took Place Yesterday from the
Family Homestead.

The funeral of the late James Tink-
ham took place from the family resi-
dence near Waverly yesterday after.
noon, and was very largely attended
by the friends and relatives Of the de-
ceased.
NJ. 5. Godshall, of the WaVerly MethO-
dist church, assisted by Rev. j. c.
Leacock, of Dalton. A choir from the
Waverly church rendered the funeral
hymns. The burial took place in Hick-
DRY Grove cemetery. which in Other
years had been IA portion of the farm
where Mr.. Tinkham was born, and
TO which he returned in his cid age
TO die.
The Scranton tribune. [volume] (Scranton, Pa.) 1891-1910, 1899-05-04
FIVE O'CLOCK TEA.

Mrs. John NJ Edwards, of West Elm
street, gave a five o'clock tea yester-
day afternoon at her home in honor of
her mother, Mrs. David 5. Evans, who
will sail from New York in a few days
for Wales, where she will spend the
summer.
The guests numbered many friends
Of Mrs. Evans, who wished her pleas
ant voyage across the Atlantic and her
safe return. The evening was spent In
sociabiity incidental to assemblies of
that nature, and all had an enjoyable
time
The Scranton tribune. [volume] (Scranton, Pa.) 1891-1910, 1899-05-04

residing at 2O2 North Ninth street, died
yesterday morning. The remains will
be inferred in the cathedral cemetery
this afternoon.
A four-months-old child Of Mr.. and
Mrs. Emmet Nauman, of 1923 SWEET
land street, died yesterday morning.
The funeral will be held tomorrow and
interment will he made in Paradise
Valley.
Martha Gibbons, aged 1s years, of
429 Tenth street, died yesterday morn
ing. The funeral will be held Saturday
afternoon at 2.30 o'clock. Interment
in Washburn street cemetery.
The Scranton tribune. [volume] (Scranton, Pa.) 1891-1910, 1899-05-04
SOUTH SCRANTON.
Fourteen Friends Society Tender
the Ladies cn Informal Dance.
Chicken Thieves at Work.
st. Aloysius Anniversary.

At Hotel Best parlors last night, the
Fourteen Friends society gave an in
formal dancing party to the ladies OF
the committee who aided so materially
for the success of the banquet of the
club Monday night; also to the young
women who assisted at the tables.
The appreciation of the Friends was
manifested in a fitting manner. A
sumptuous luncheon was served, and
the hours were passed in dancing.
The Scranton tribune. [volume] (Scranton, Pa.) 1891-1910, 1899-05-04
Personal PARAGRAPHS.

Rev. j. b. Sweet, pastor of the Simp-
son Methodist Episcopal church, is re-
covering spendidly from the effects OF
an operation for appendicitis.
Miss Lille Miller. of Lafayette street.
is suffering from a serious illness, which
may necessitate an operation.
Thomas H. Roberts, of North Gar
field avenue. is in attendance at the
national convention of the American
Mechanics in Shamolin this week.
Mr.. and Mrs. Thomas Jones. of North
Lincoln avenue, are entertaining John
Morris, of Kngsland. n. Y.
James Mead, of Carbondale, is visit
ing relatives on Scranton street.
The Scranton tribune. [volume] (Scranton, Pa.) 1891-1910, 1899-05-04
CARRIED CONCEALED WEAPONS.

Harry c. Kays a well-known man
about town. was arrested yesterday af
ternoon by Patrolman John Thomas for
creating a disturbance at Simon Thom-
as hotel on North Main avenue. He
was elected several times and insisted
upon re-entering the place.
Kays had in his possession a walk
ing stick, inserted in which was a long
steel blade, and is dangerous-looking
weapon. He was locked up in the police
station and will be given a hearing by
Alderman Moses this morning.
The Scranton tribune. [volume] (Scranton, Pa.) 1891-1910, 1899-05-04
FOURTH ANNIVERSARY.

The fourth anniversary of st. Alloy
sus Young Mems society Of the Twen-
tieth ward, will be observed with fitting
exercises in the basement hall of ST.
Johns church Monday night next.
Rev. p. ]. MacGOldrick, of the CEN
tral city, win be the speaker of the
occasion. An excellent programme has
been arranged for the event.
The Scranton tribune. [volume] (Scranton, Pa.) 1891-1910, 1899-05-04
DEATHS AND FUNERALS.

The funeral of the late George Cromp-
ton will be held this afternoon. Ser
vices will be conducted at the house,
21S North Garfield avenue, at o'clock
by Rev. l.. r. Foster, pastor of the
Sumner Avenue Presbyterian church,
and interment will be made in the
Washburn street cemetery.
Services over the remains of the late
Mrs. William Il. Davis will be held at
the house, 26 Snyder avenue. Bellevue.
this afternoon at 3 o'clock. Burial will
be made in the Washburn street ceme-
terry.
An infant child of d Syrian family
The Scranton tribune. [volume] (Scranton, Pa.) 1891-1910, 1899-05-04

nine months that an "acting patrol
man" was in his place.
The r. V. Lewis case, similar except
that the time OF Suspension WAS short
er and that councils ordered the claim
paid on the strength of the precedent
established by the Walsh case.