Orange County observer., 1898-03-17
you WANT THEMTO TEElR
OWN WAY
Book Publishing House
124 I.KoAARp ST.. y Y. CITY
THE FRAUD ENJOINED.,

THE FRAUD ENJOINED.
Report of Decree The Famous 6o0.'
600 Trademark Case Decided-C.R
Simmons Medi cine Company. ST
Louis, Defeats j. III. Zeiiin q Co.
Philade phia.
[From st. Louis Republic, July T. 1884,
"The Supreme Court Of Tennessee on June % es'
cided the most raport ont Trademark case taa: 40
ever be tried IN that Safe end ono OF the l&etss
ever tried in the Union. Affirming and eniarSias Gs
opinion Of the court beaew. the court he d,
!. That DR.. ii. A. ..mmors, tho predecessor Of
complainant. By extensive advertising of h,I teA
brated remedy known as " Simmons Live, Meti'
cine'' made it a standard remedy for liver citease.
long pri 70 the acquisition By J. Il. Zein & Co. 81
2. That the a.signor Of ). H. Zeiln CO., thrcuss
whom they claimed the nigh: 10 mako the frauduet'
packages enjoinej never derived aay tiAef!on A y.
Summons to make tie medicine nor to use h, ns1s
or picture, and that such use by Zeiiia to h
fraud upon the public, and is therefore enIoned.
8. That Zeisin Co. purposely. fraudaent.' -
beied their medicine in imitation OF co-aI Ain.nls
medicine to unfairly appropriate the traae o. -
Simmons Medicine Com pan =. and the execution 81
this fraudulent purpose and net is enjoinef.
&. Enjoned Zeln Il CO. from usirg taetf COM
limitations thereof. to deceive the public and unaI3
appropriate to themselves tho tEada Of the Q. r.
{. Enjoned ZeiI.n & Co., from oecelr,ns s'd
prscticing fraud upon tho pubic by iabe!.ns men
packages in imitation Of the wrappers and u'""'
6, Enjoned Zeilin & Co. from the rnanutacrars
and eale OF the medicine under the name OF SIM
mons Liver Medicine.' Or. S.rrrons L'Fsi
Medicine" or Liver Medi cine by A. q. sinnon''
and from using the pict1re Of A. g Simmons .
connection herewith. "
T. Enjoined Zei.in & Co.. theIr assignees. AGENTS
and employees from deceiviag and pracucins o y.
upon the public by the sale OF packages tlus las
labeled either upon orders or calls Tor lne fepths
"Simnons Liver Medicine - of complainant, 81
In any package thus falsely labeled.
g. The court stated tia. it vas The purpose O. lhs
court to entirely destroy the ffautueDty iaef "a
iazs eni ariC n
from, the market. aud ordered Iciin & Cot ref
70 the clerk be destroyed. all cats, Ces- eief 70
types, engraviBgs aa1 other paraihernairl e = 70
impressing either OF the above names or the s4eai'
OLA. Q. Simmors.
9. Oecresd tina. Zeilin & Co. pay ell ths ds7eGe.
which have accrued t. complainant ty 20 . . -
these frauiulentiy labeled paeGaees. The csnss"
claimed by Complainant were xAQ 4.
10. Decrecd that ZeI!.n Il O.. ray all tae co.,.
which amount 10 several thousand dollars. u re-
being ono Of the largest ever fed ii tie sap's"'
Court. !"
Chenp Medicine.
Al ru10 "cheap medicine IS inert wortfle" o'
danxerous In ZeiiIn & Co sansser 70 "IT b. t.ey
ea.d the packages enloned were designed es ~
valley" Now. Zeilin & 60 $ -dvesseU.er ~,
alt their ger ewore. tho. all tsesiFer Aei..'
aIch they make is made o. .he safre formula : =
igt conclusive evidence from tAeir sworn le IN. ~
ai Advertisements that & ii ae ltscF IaeflIct
a.ag from them is Cheap Negro aedlci'e' y
Nei.ciner'' Le. tho sfal c,ei aoswer ~ -, 81.
future purchases. DR.. NJ. a. SIMMONS !. ~. y.
Ms1icine, established lstD. 3 nc. oH"a9 - -.
cine ~ 1t is no cure al ~ e. 4 ~ o. ~ :.
menied for these i1dAs2osia ons CAUSED " i-""''~
OF Iae liver.