davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01
THE COMING CITY ELECTION.

The Salem city election takes place
the first Monday In December. To
get an expression Of the people THE
JOURNAL prints direct nomination
ballot In another colum. We urge
people TO look over the lists carefully
and add new names OF candidates II
they see fit.
The ,day OF prepared states and
bossism ought 10 be at an end In this
community. All the good that can
come from those methods this city
has had, and all the evils as well. The
people have had very little TO say In
the conduct OF their city government
Ia the past and are not responsible
for the deplorable condition OF city
finances.
IL is the duty OF any man who loves
this city TO help nominate men who
are honest, able aud independent. the
Jefrersonian trinity OF qualifications
for public Office.
Is he honest, Is he capable, is he
independent ? That Is the test for a
little city office without a salary, just
as much as for president. VIII the
people elect such men TO oiilce? Then
their first duty Il 10 nominate such.
THE JOURNAL has no candidates
for any city oiflce. IL Is very dlfiicult
thing for the people OF this city 10
lind a man OF the business ability TO
make mayor, OF the political sagac-
ity 10 handle a city administration,
and OF the personal independence TO
not be mere tool OF Others.
The Capital City deserves the abb
est and most enterprlslng men for
city Oficlals. No salaries are paid.
The ability 10 conduct its affairs 10 a
creditable manner, commands big pay
In any private business. Hence the
public are often served by men OF
second or thlrd-class ability while
public affairs are preyed upon by men
ofgreater ability In private life who
are mere putty 10 their hands Is IL
any wonder city government is
failureS How can IL be remedled ?
The people ahould study this ques.
tlon.
Direct nomination isthe first step
70 direct responsibility ia public
affairs. Hence we say TO the people OF
this city. make out a ticket for your
selves. DO not walt for some one 70
put upa candidate FOR ycu. Select
your idea OF proper officials yourself. |
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01
.,Y,nAv,s MARKET.


PORTLAND, Nov. /. Wheat valley
90; Walla Walla, 60c.
Fiour-Portland, s3,45; Superhne
s2.25 per bbl.
Oats White 34(93Sc.
Hay-SS(9l0 per ton.
Hops-l4(617c; old crop &c.
Wool-Valley, 10@l2c; Eastern
Mlilstulf-Bfan, $3.50; shorts, sl4
Ga s15.
Poultry-Chickens, mixed So. 5003.50
turkeys, live, 14(Ql6c,
Eggs-OregOn, 20per .doz... -,
Hides-Green, salted 60 lbs, 898tc.
under go lbs, ,6i(97c;s c;sheep pelts, ,lb(92Oc'
Onions-90c(d$l per sack.
Butter-Best dairy, 40(g45c; fancy
creamery, 50c(d55c per roll.
Potatoes, 50(G60c per sack
Hogs-Heavy, s4.75.
Mutton--W Weathers 34c; dressed, &c
Beef-Yteers, ,s3. .5063.75: cows, 2.5O
(93 dressed, sac.
SALEM MARKET.
Wheat-53
Oats-33c.
Hay-Baled, ,heat, S6.50(6s7.
Flour-In wholesale lots, $3.50: re
tail 81. 60,
Millstuff Bran 1924 without and
Sl34 with sacks; shorts Sl3t@l4 per
ten without sacks.
Hogs-dreased, sc.
Live cattle--21(03c.
Sheep-Liye, s2.506S3.
Veal-5tc,
Butter-Dairy zoe; creamery 25c.
Wool-Best, 15c. Mohair 25c
Hops Best 16(0l7c.
Eggs 20c In cash.
Poultry-chlckens 5(G7c.
Farm smoked meats-Bacon, Sac
ham, 10c shoulder, 6(G7c.
Potatoes-30c.
Apples-30c.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01
Hood1, dill, cure Liver Ills; easy tc
tAVOu AAS take, easy to operate. 2be.
The New French Cabinet.

The newly-organized cabinet is
composed as follows:
Dupuy, premier and minister Of
the interior.
Gebret, minister Of justice.
DeFreyclnct, minister OF war.
Lockroy, minister of marine.
Delcasse, minister OF foreign af.
fairs.
Peytral, minister OF finance.
Leygus, minister OF public instruc.
tion.
Deloncle, minister OF commerce.
Gillaue, minister OF colonies.
Vigler, minister Of agriculture.
Krantz, minister OF public works.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01
NOMINATE A CITY TICKET.
By Direct Vote of the Resident Qualified
Electors of the City of Salem,
CANDIDATES NAMED.

For MAYOR
A. RICHARDSON, W. T. GRAY, PHIL METsHAN g p. BISHOP
MELA NCHTON W. HUNT.
For RECORDER
Ed N. EDES, c. X. BRANDENBURG, STEVE M'FADDEN, f. A
TURNER, A, o. CONDIT.
For MARSHAL
.. d HUTTON, DOC GIBsoN, J. Q. JOHNSON
For ALDERMAN, FIRST WARD
M LAWRENCE, FRANK WATERS, LOT PEARCE ED
hORGAN.
WARD
B. +. PARKHURsT, FRlzzEbL EBE LAHORE, B. PHIL
BROOK.
WARD
HIRAM SMITH, GEO. GRAY, A. BLossER
FOURTH
JOHN GRAHAM GEO g. BINGHAM.
The JOURNAL will keep standing list Of pubcay named
TOT city omces for information Of its THE cand
dates for Office,
out ticket below cut then nebo do the same
ana let the people name the candidates.,
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01
R;|!|I|[I|slI||I|
IiMi]Illli:lA|
20U Miles

shorter and whole half day Quicker
than any other line TO Omaha. KAN
sas city, ST. Louis and ali other
suthern aud southeastern cities,
TnTee routes east via Denver St
faul, and Billings, Mont. Tickets pf
onces OF connecting lines. III you 90
east via Omaha, you can ston ofT and
see the Trans-Mississippi exposition
A. c. SHELDON.
Oenl agent, Portland Or
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01

ing youth and maturity ne may live 10
q green old age, and still be able to say with
absolute truth, ~ am a child myselfH
Youth Is not matter Of years Happiness
Is not a question OF experiences Youth Il
happiness and health is youth The healthy
person, young or old, will be a happy per.
son. Il Is a simple matter to get the body
into q healthy condition and then 10 keen L
there DR., PieTce's Golden Medical DIS,
covery Ia the greatest OF health makers and
health savers II Is the great blood.makeI
and heah-buiideI IL makes the appetite
keen, the digestion aud assimilation per,
feet, the liver active, the blood pure, the
muscles strong, the brain clear, the nerves
steady and every vital organ in the body
healthy and vigorous. II makea arm,
healthy fesh, but dses not make corpulent
people more corpulent II does not make
habby hesh like cod liver oil II purifes
the blood and drives out the poisOns OF
malaria and rheumatism. II is the best
remedy for blood and skin diseases III
cures 81 per cent Of all cases Of eOnshmp
ton. Gratefnl patients. who had been
given up 10 die, have permitted their expert
ences, names, addresses and photographs
% be reproduced IA Or. Pierce's Common
Sense Medical Adviser. The sufferer who
wishes 20 investigate may write 10 anV OF
these. The Golden Medical Disooyeryi
Is sold by all medicine dealers, aud onl,
unscrupuious dealers will try 20 induce !
customer 20 take some worthless substitute
for the sake Of q few pennies added profit /
Send q one-cent stamps 10 cover cos
OF mailing 0nly, for copy Of Dr.. Pierce,
1908 page illustrated book, "CommOf
Sense Medical Adviser" {" Ia paper cover !
Address Dr. r. V. Pierce, Buffalo, N Y.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01

TO make u apparent 10 thousands.
who think themselves M, that they
are DOT afflicted With any disease, but
that the system simply needs cleans
log, II 20 bring comfort home 10 their
hearts, as costlYe condition Is easily
cured BY using syrup ol Figs. Man-
ufactuIed by the California Fie Syrup
Co., only and sold BY all druggists.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01
ii, r. KINCAID,
Secretary OF State.

SICK HEADACHE ABSOLUTELY AND
eured by using Moki Tea. A
pleasant herb drink. Cures constipation and
Indigestion, makes you eat, sleep, work and
h'rpy. Satisfaction guaranteed OF money
back. aSC and soc Lunn 4 Brooks druggist
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01
TEE PIONEER LIMrTHD

Is the nameot the only perfect, train in
the world, nowrunning every night between
81, Paul and Chicago, via the Chicago, Nil.
wAakee y 81 Pnul Railwaye-1he pioneer
road Of the West in adopting all improved
facilities tor the safety and ejoyment OF pas.
sengers. An illustrated pamphlet, shaving
views OF beautiful scenery along the route OF
the tio0eeT Limited, will be sent free 10 any
person upon recipe of two-eent postage
stamp, Address Geo. III. HeafoTd, General
Passenger Agent. Chicago. III. w60d
Pain A,A no saov WrsA Dc. hilss' Paia snlA
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01

Many household is saddened because of
failure TO keep safe and certain cure foI
Group such as One Minute Cough Cure, See
that your little ones are protected.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01

constipation prevents the body from rid.
ding itself OF waste matter. DeWitt's Little
Early Risers remove the trouble and cure
sick headache. Biliousness. Small sugar
coated, don't grips or cause nausea. Stones
drug store.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01
Demon Spirits

roamed the streets last night and fate
was ioosed, but the large crowds still
sought those 25c meals at Strong's.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01

The sooner cough or cold is Gu ed the
better. Lingering colds are dangerous,
One Minute Cough Cure quickly eutes il.
Why suffer when such cough cure is
within reAehG Il is pleasant. S'one's Drug
store.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01

DYSPEPSIA CAN BE CUED BY
using Aeker's DyPepsia Tablets. One little
tablet will give immediate relief or money
refunded. Sold in handsome tin boxes at 2sc.
Lunn & Brooks. druggists.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01
A Gate Last.

IL Is common thing today TO hear
people bswailing the loss OF their
front gate, but you hear no one saying
he has lost confidence Ia the Little
&c cigar.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01

Late to led and early to rise prepares a
man Tor his home In the skies. Little Early
Riser, the Fill that makes life longer and
better and wise
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01

Soothing, healing. Gle ,nsing, DeWlts
Witch Hazel Salye, the enemy Of sores,
burns and wounds 1t never fails to cure
piles.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01

When you ask loF DsWiu's Hazel Salve
don't accept a counterfeit There are more
easss Of Plles beng cured by this, than all
others. stones drug store.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01
JOURNAL "x-RAYs.o

Albany Democrat Mr.. Homer
Davenport, the world's greatest carl.
caturist, has arrived IN San Francisco
where he will have charge OF the
pictorial work in the campaign
between Mcclure and Gage for gov
ernor. This is good. The pictures
Of Edgren have been coarse and dis
gusting TO every one with any sense
OF proprIety, aud II may be stated
that Mr.. Davenport i'll never stoop
to the same style of work.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01
Corvallis & Eastern
R, K. Company,

NIE1 2 NVIIIINNI At IhIDdHy with OOuIntT0
Pacific train giving direct service to and from
Newport and adjacent beaches.
Train for the mountains arrives at Detroit
at noon giving ample time to reach camping
grounds on the Breitenbush and Santiam
rivers same day.
EDWIN STONE,
Manager,
ii. L, WALDEN,
T, +. &P.A.
j. TURNER,
Agent Albany.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01

OIegonians will do we'll TO stand In
with Blnger Hermann, for II has been
estimated by the departmental at Wash.
ington that in case the Philippine
islands are annexed TO the United
States, together with Porto Rico and
the Ladrones, Mr.. Hermann, as com.
missioner OF the general land office,
will have 300 appointments at his
disposal.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01

Is the state fair local enterprise to
be supported by local subscriptions,
or is the state board Of agriculture a
part OF the state government
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01
Back TO Health

After Long Illness Hoods sarsa-
ParlIla Restored Good FeaIth-
Now ne strong az Ever.
"After an illness OF two years, during
which time underwent several surgical
operations, ! at last began TO improve, but
my improvement was 30 slow that be-
came discouraged. was very much run
down and l did not have any appetite.
did not care TO live. One day 1 met
friend who had taken Hoods sarsaparilIa
and who urged me to try II. consented,
and after / had taken few doses began
to feel better and had better appetite.
gained from two TO three pounds n week
and grew stronger every day. took two
or three bottles OF Hoods Sarsaparilla,
and am as strong as ever was in my life.
Hoods 5arsaparilla has brought me back
to health" EMILY BILLINoER, 10 Grand
Avenue, South Portland, Oregon.
Hoods s1sssT psiiila
Is the best-in fact the One True Blood Purifier
Sold by all druggists. o.; six for e5.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01

The Albany Democrat without its
column or misflt items is not the
Democrat.
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01

in, the ia.
Us sage of
Madison
Square, who
has for thirty
aTs de.
clined the
companion,
ship OF any
O n c b ut
children,
says, II am
"a child my.
self "
II a man
will live
rightly and
take proper
care OF his
health dur
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01

A. V. II. Snyder is an ubiquitous
fellow in the office line. He holds an
Office under the U. S. government
at salary OF 5000 a year, is assistant
chief clerk of the house of the Oregon
legislature at sS day; Is "a recorder
Of the city Of McMlnnvllle at $50 a
mouth; and we suggest that the
county. ought to give him an Office
also. -.McMlnuvllle Telephone Regis
ter.
Why blame Snyder? Don't he sing
patriotic songs and wave the flag for
the boys for all there Is In II? Isn't
the Republican party willing II
howl, pray or die for the stand
ard that keeps them In communica-
tlon with the treasury.9
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01

D. HiIs5 Nerve Pla.sorase slaIIaruss.sA
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01

Is Salem village where any three
boys can claim TO be acting for the
whole Of our 1900?
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01

The OreRonian is having one spell
after another because as IL says, Gov
ernor Tanner OF Illinois is violating
the constitution. Strange, he looks TO
distant lands TO find such small errors
Right here 10 Oregon, only fifty miles
from Portland, Legislators fairly fall
over one another to get TO vote for
laws that are unconstitutional. Even
a man who recently took Official oath
TO support that same constitution,
and was elected TO the highest office
the people of Oregon had TO give away
descended from high seat TO cham
plon the passage of such a law, II
looks like the unconstitutional acts
of some people and the silver planks
Ia many state platforms will yet
cause II TO do something desperate,
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01

out ticket below your neghbor do I'll
and let the people canddates,l
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01

George Francis
rain, the ia.
nous saRe of
Daily capital journal. (Salem, Or.) 1896-1899, 1898-11-01

George Ogle, Of Clackamas'county,a
member OF the notorious hold.up leg
islature Of 1897, has refused to accept
any pay except s24 80, which he says
is all he is entitled to,as the legIsla.
ture failed TO organize. His full
allowance, had he accepted IL, would
have been l29.3U.-ExchanRe.
or course, Mr.. U'Ren. OF Cla ,kamas,
will initiate Mr.. Ogle's example.
Pike County press. (Milford, Pa.) 1895-1925, 1898-07-01
NOTICE OF ELRCTION

To the qualified voters Of the Borough
OF Milford Take Notice, that the Town
Council OF said Borough has by it's vote
signilied a desire to make nm increase of
Indebtedness of said borough as provided
under the Act Of Assembly approved 9Th
June, 1891, entitled an Act to regulate tho
manner of increasing the indebtedness of
! municipalities etc
There will be an election hold nt the.
Court House the place for holding nuui-
clpal elections in said Borough Of Milford
County Of Pike, ana State Of Pcnnsylvu-
mia, on the
ELEVENTH DAY OF JULY, A. D.. 1888
between the hours Of 2 p. NJ. and p M
of sold day, to increase or not to increase
the indebtedness of said Borough the sum
of three thousand and five hundred dol
/ lars ts8JOl above one hundred and five,
(sle5j collars indebtedness Said increase
IS TO be rated upon the last assessed valu-
alton OF snid Borough Of one hundred and
eighteen thousand, seven hundred and
eighty one tSllS,7SlD dollars at "a perccn-
| tage Of O029457 on the assessed valua-
tion The purpose for which the indebt
edness is to be increased is purchasing
what is known as the Glen, for the uses of
| the said Borough, at which time and place
/ tickets will be furnished, labeled on the
outside Increase of Debt" and contain-
ing in the inside the words mo Increase
OF Debt, or Debt may by Increased. "
Approved this 9TH day Of June. A. D.,
1897 j. @. CHAMBERLAIN.
Attest. President of Town Council
ID II. HORNBECK. Sccy
Milford, June g. 1893 4w
Pike County press. (Milford, Pa.) 1895-1925, 1898-07-01
Facts worth Knowing.

Adelina Patti received her first
lesson in singing from blind girl
in st. Louis.
Sir Thomas Upton is starting
cheap restaurants in many places
in London where he intends to sup
ply a substantial dinner for about
eight cents.
The Tichbone claimant, whose
death was reported recently, served
ten years in prison He got off
cheap, considering the fact that his
lawyer made speech lasting five
weeks.
M. de Mesquil, Il Frenchman, has
written book on Madagascar in
which he claims that the island was
colonized by the Greeks, and that
Homer was none other than Ulys-
ses himself, great traveller.
Queen Victoria objects both to
electric light and gas-that is, so far
as her own personal use is concern
ed. OH is permitted very slightly
but candles of an extra special make
are still her favorite illuminant.
The pope has never publicly left
the Vatican since his election to st.
Peters chair and is said to have left
the papal palace but once secretly,
and that by night, in order to visit
his brother when he was dying in a
village near Rome
Mark Twain having noticed in an
American newspaper statistics of
the increase of crime in Connecticut
during the last seven years is sor-
rOwfully constrained to admit that
this is just the time that have
been absent from the State.
Pike County press. (Milford, Pa.) 1895-1925, 1898-07-01

ment card This is rather novel
method Of presenting a case to the
voters Last week he explained
that he is in favor of a vigorous pro
secution of the war withSpain, which
should be partisan, and that
we should hold all the territory
taken, and that strong columns
should be dispatched to Mdnila,
Porto Rico and Cuba Probably be-
fore the next Congress is even cleo
ted such progress will be made as to
show that there is no "red tape" in
the matter, and his platform will be
out of date The only living issue
may be the disposition Of the terri
tory acquired, and on that point
there can hardly be a general divi-
sion. No sane politician would
favor throwing away the fruits Of
victory, and no sensible one would
attempt to fritter away advantage
Gus results for partisan purposes.
We do not see that the Colonel has
visibly strengthened his position as
against the Republican party now
in power His declaration of prin-
ciples may be of avail in proving
why he should be the nominee Of
his own party-but whether of the
silver wing or the hard money con
tingent--there are no politics in
tended in this-we leave him to eX-
Dlain.
Pike County press. (Milford, Pa.) 1895-1925, 1898-07-01
Notice of Application For
Incorporation.

Notice is hereby given that an applica-
tion will be made to the Governor Of Penn
sylvania on MONDAY, THE ELEVENTH
DAY OF JULY. eighteen hundred and
ninety eight, at two O'clock p NJ of said
day, by Thos. Armstrong, Joseph J. Hart
Lancelot w. Armstrong, James 5. Gale.
and Harry 7. Baker under the Act Of AS
sembly, entitled, "An Act to provide for
the incorporation and regulation of GER
tain corporations, approved April 29th,
1874, and the supplements thereto, for the
charter of an intended corporation to be
called THE MILFORD GAS COMPANY,
the character and object Of which Is the
manufacture and supply Of Acotylene gas.
or other gls for light heat or power to the
public Of the Borough Of Milford, i'm the
County of Pike and State of Pennsyva-
mia, and to such persons, parternerships
and associations residing therein and ad-
1accnt thereto, as may desire the same,
and for these purposes 20 have, possess,
and enjoy all the rights benefits, and priv
ileges Of said Act Of Assembly and supple-
ments thereto. HY Il. BAKER.
Milford, Pa. Solicitor
June IS, 1898 -iw
Pike County press. (Milford, Pa.) 1895-1925, 1898-07-01
EDITORIAL.
HIS LETTER

COL. LEWIS last week in a letter
to our esteemed contemporary
explains at length his meaning in
his first announcement card, and
reaches the general conclusion that
the Senate was mainly responsible
for forcing the issue of arms. So
far as we understand popular senti
ment, we think the President was
upheld by the great mass of the
people, in his position. The Repre-
sentatives in Congress elected di
rectly by the people and supposed
more nearly to reflect the opinions
of the masses were in accord with
him, and subsequent developments
have demonstrated the wisdom of
their course. The opposition in
the Senate was personal and par
tisan, and apparently instigated for
political purposes, and was not sup
ported by the newspapers to any
extent, nor by sober thinking peo
pie. War was declared because of n
glaring and continued wrong TO
humanity, and not because of an
injury, which, while dastardly and
cowardly, was not officially substan-
tiated. Our course and conduct
placed this nation in a proper light,
and upon such a platform of right
as to command the respect and for.
bearance of the nations of the earth.
They cannot effectually and none do
seriously cavil at our position 1t
is far better for us to stand on an
acknowledged broad principle of
human right and justice than on
the narrow margin of an insult
and injury not legally proven.
We think past and present events.
and the cordial support being given
by the people, irrespective of party,
demonstrate completely the conf
denoe IN which the government is
held, The ''phalanxes which arc
moving are composed of men Of
both and all political parties, officer
cd by men of different political
faith. Politics are submerged, and
as the 'phalanx" in the Eighth is
now properly represented by its
chosen representative, and no suffi-
cient reason having been given why
a change should be made, we think
the people will say to the present
incumbent, "Well done, good and
faithful servant" you enjoy our
respect and confidence and, if you
50 desire, can command a large ma
jority of our votes.
Pike County press. (Milford, Pa.) 1895-1925, 1898-07-01
THE GLEN PURCHASE.

IF THERE is authority for tho
ownership of any land for Pub
lie Park purposes hy a municipality
there is also a method prescribed
for its acquisition, on failure TO ag rec
with the owner as to price
1t must be assumed that the Bur-
ough Council has agreed, from the
fact that it is asking to have author
ity given it TO issue bonds to pay a
specified amount. Now without in
timating any opinion as TO tho IL
gality of the proposed method, or NJ,
to the power to hold the land pro
posed TO be purchased, if it is with
in the province of the council to buy
and hold, there is a method provid-
ed to ascertain the value, in the m
ture of condemnation proceedings.
Would it not be wiser for TIN.
Council, assuming that the Borough
has legal right TO hold this lana
for public purposes, to have it's value
ascertained and determined in the
manner provided by the Acts of 'g5
and '97. This would be more salts
factory to the people generally and
would relieve the Council from any
criticism as to price. We might be
compelled to pay more, or we might
secure it for less than SO, 800, but,
in either event there would be the
assurance that disinterested and
competent tribunal had settled the
question,