New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1898-02-11
VOTED TO CENSURE MURPHY
Continued from first page.

The people Of the State he acted in strict conform;
IN 70 ohe PRINCIPLES OF the Democratic Nate
convention. both OF which had been overwhelming
lace passed in review the prominent members Of
1ae democratic party, and declared that. one by
from gold to silver and Senator Murphy was only
acting Nirg In conformity with them.
there had been no good excuse offered for senator
Murphys conduct although many had been at
Mr. Oliver attempted to introduce several rcsolu-
tlons. but was prevented by the Chair. The reso-
laughter.
mont and other Democrats arragned f for their ST.
yer leanings. You OF the other side" said he.
United INIT. States senate. You have ca.sed Democrats
place Chandler? Where do You place the to?tv
seven Senators who voted for the Teller resolution?
throat and Mark Hanna walks over your PROSTATE
bodiest'
PALMER WANTED TO DROP IT.
Mr. Palmer next spoke. He attempted 10 intro
duce an amendment providing that. in conformity
with the expressed desire OF Governor Black for
early adjournment. the House drop further discus
sion OF the resolution not being Of Importance.
The resolution objected Mr.. Palmer de-
cared that because Senator Murphy had not voted
censure. Nor II he had personally changed MS
opinions should he be censured. Judged by this
Service reform platform and had torn it to pieces
after he had been a short time in Office
SPEAKER o'GRADY TAKES A HAND
Speaker OGrady resigned the chai- to Assembly
man Aids during OF the debate and now
took the floor He began by stating that Mr..
Palmer need not be afraid about early adjourn
ment. There would be one by several weeks earlier
than that OF last year. M. oGrady then went into
question. and asserted that he had shown that Mr..
Murphy fully understood ne import OF his vote
The Legislature had right 20 condemn him
BY what right?" querfed Mr.. Green
Because are the representatives OF the people
OF he ate 81 q
held Tomorrow to Judge Senator MurPhy,s action
"Would you vote condemn a Republican United
States Senator had he voted the sameT asked Mr.
Had q Republican voted for free silver The ma.
tor!ty would have censured him. and II would have
Mr.. oiGrady said there was not a man on the
minority side but repudietef the l6 to theory In
Would you vote TO condemn the other torty-s.x
Senators who voted for The Teller resolution
They are not on trial" answered Nj o'Grady.
Will you give way for another question: asked
q, wiz It i, framed in Ineligible English re-
Mi Collins-I wish to ask you, sir: Il you do not
know that Section OF Article oi me Constt 10
Senator shall be questioned elsewhere IN any place
for his speech and debate In the Uniteh states
MIR O'Grady-We not questioning his action
It has gone beyond the point OF question ana ~, We
are condemning IT. undeserVedy ana without ii''i'
CLOSE OF THE DEBATE
Mr.. Nixon closed tie debate. he reVie"eo INC
silver question and charged that Senator Murphy
baa voted ms ne thought would benefit his inter
ents In tho course of his speech Nj Ni1on asso-
GATED the name of Senator Murphy with Illegal
acts a. polling places in Troy.
Nj Hutton interrupted TO saw that the Troy
trouble had first arisen at Republican caucus
and that Il was the means Of electins FRANK D
Black Chief Executive Of the State
NJ, NIXON concluded by predicting that the sub
-oiss,on ~ the question AT the polls again wou'o
-esult in ar Increased Republican ma1oriy s,-,o,s
~ 5I5 p m the debate ended and the previous
question was moved. The resolution was put 20
voto n. $40 o'clock and passed, q 20 90 .u D,
Al 5lS o'clock the House auJou'Heu u' ~
morrow morning at 10 O'clock