Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1898-06-20


than Che ruling that followed The
motion was simply reminiscent of an
unlawful practice practice COM
dcmn.l as unlawful ~ the supreme
court nj The United States. Hut even
Mr. N1riHu doubted the iawfulnDes OF
the oupu NHnlrc in Judge Inut'a court.
us did other members of the bat. who
wore Invited hy the Judge. ON motion
NJ Mt Nar.au tn discuss the question
W lis lnWfuuess before Doe ruled urUn
H. judge Zauc having ruled that ~
was lawful. and th. United states
supreme court having sustained him.
that settled tho question Of its lave
fulncss. but NOT nf the lawfulnoas of
Judge Mckc1n'a rulings. the unlawful
practices referred to 10y the historian
Those practices remained unlawful.
consequently there was nothing Co roe
tract
Paul, la found with the historian foi
holding up Zoo admiration che acts
and words ~ those who d0N.i the
court 100 the contempt caars cases
100 which men and women. charged with
uolyrumy or unlawful cohahIi1tIlu. Or
summoned zee witnesses FOR tha PROSE.
cutiuu. chose One and imprisonment
rather than promise 90 obey law
aimed ns they believed. nt principle
NJ their religion, ur to give Information
sealuFt their relatives and friends. are
NI|I
lave Why, my lrHr H.r mot only ala
The historian ana hIs ,0ufrtres admire
the herulFm ~ those devoted men ana
women. but Fp dld their judges mud
prosecutors aye. the Tribune itself.
with 90 magn1nImlty that dld % credit.
praised the COURAGE aud mauluass ~
some 20 thos. very men who thus de-
UHu 10" court. Nr tH speak more noe
curltDlv. stood hv their Conscience.
li,r. o. what Doc Tribune slid OF bishop
Brown of ogden. who had declared TINT
before Doc would prove tDrfeuut Goo hls
wives 1ul children and hUtruy Doll trust.
Do would suite BIZ head Co Boz severed
FROM hI1 body o.. 4 Brown. the Nor
mon saint. convicted lu ogden uu Tues.
day hst hy hIs own testimony. had the
courage of DIE convictions However
much One may dpp.1re such wrong
headlines. tho admission must lr
made that hero lH u man. one who docs
not gu'uhly aud llH. and who HcurnH Zoo
show ih. whit. feather surely this
sterilization by the Tribune uf
Browns defiance VI the law. goes
uuIiH HH Gar HH the 'gl1riHcBtiou hv
Tho historian 'uf WriIH'f defiance of the
Laws yet I never heard tho Tribune
found fault with ON that score.
Again, you say; Tho treatment NJ
the Liberal party. ita declarations and
ifIuWuhH. Do uf the most sUurvy and
contemplate sort That the frauds
prattICHd hy members uf that party are
mot hyid W. tu admiration I admit.
but that The party na whole ls con.
dDmnrd. I deny certainly thought. az.
ter hearing Judge Zane dunuunrr the
ballot box Htunur, Allen. aH u rascal
1ud wretch 5idl Tor attempting
t1 reverse tho peoples WIN ut Uuh'H
FIRST fiue school election. that I could
Soy Amen. tp such sentiments with
out being charged with making nu hH-
HluIi upon the rnufta Go plant free
nuu.srytuflhu schools hrra1 and I sup.
posed, tuu that ! could safely follow
ln ih' wake NJ thn Tribune. which was
lWHuE tho nrat tu pUUClac and con.
d uu Liberal members ~ the Salt Lake
city Council fur dishonesty over and
above such STRUCTURES uH these, thu hls-
tory Dr. fUplntp with courteous allu-
HIHna tu mrmh0rs of the Liberal party.
Co governors, Judges. prosecutors. mar.
shnlH aud other doral officials. ,yon
those who were tho most pronounced
no. ill. iHi. a2i 800. 2l, 600. alf gis
500. $780, $780, 1si $780, lls. az. lss s07
Boz iiI 5lg 80 ono Gi5. go. gIl $685.
go. Cas-. $50. IN. ii4 mo- ll7. 1isl There
Do nu abuse ~ tho courts mo- assaults
upon their rulings nn suppression ~
facts ln the cases Though TOT hrryIfyH
sake facts may Boz condensed. both
sides uf the 'pnlyrnmy prosecutions
arr presented platforms and dcclura-
lions NJ the Liberal party are given
without comment tpagra 23G. lOn. and
that party lH credited with tho good
II ala. particularly with ~ enterprise
in Do matter ~ public improvements
tpngc 5ip.
zone charge you make. mud Co DO
CurrpttHthnt ~ mlrHtntemont In rCln-
tiuu 60 the carrying ~ tho Third pre-
rlnct OF salt Lake city by the Liberal
party M the free school election Of
1850 Ny information on that point
was faulty n n not an intentional
misstHtomcnt but one of those errors
that brr liable Co creep into any book.
nu matter how careful the author IL
Co guard against them I thank you
for pointing IL out ana shall pront hy
the correction.
"Nud now. my friend the critic. n
word IN conclusion. The war IL over.
tho Liberal and tho Peoples party are
mo- more. Utah o. IL State. and We ure
living in the latter part ~ the nine
Ties, not iu the early part ~ the
eighties when most uf the events rp-
corded In this history took place Even
the latest volume was written years
uEn. ana has been in print Cor u long
time, awaiting final action hy the puhs
fishers, an undue warmth with
which parts ~ it may have been
pcuncd. has long since departed, and
the author regrets any possible iniuH-
tlCr that he may have done YOU or
your friends You hold that the work
iH not history, ] hold that IL Or, aud
ancient history nt that; nR such IL
pertains 90 The past, and should not be-
made % burning issue ~ the present.
Yours sincerely
q. y, WHITNEY.
salt Lake city. June n. 1885"
Wheat and the Farmers.