davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07
YOUNG LADIES ENTERTAIN.
Program Presented by Seminary
Class nj Fails Church.
SI'c''ial Correspondence Of The Evening Star.

Src'iai Correspondence Of The Evening" star
FALLS CHURCH, Va. Feb. = is,S
A soiree-musicale was given at the Young
ladies seminary OF this town Friday even
ing by the class of Miss Annie T. Rodefrer
which was entertaining affair aud
largely attended. The exercises were opci-
ed with prayer by Rev. n. l.. Rathbun.
The program was follows: The Hun
ters Chorus. by Misses Mct;iIl Capner
Chapman. Lutirell. Neitch. Russell Phil
lips Kerr. Willis and Coyner: piano duet
FRA pavolo." Misses Kate and Ada Coy
rer; vocal solo. Thine Eyes so Blue and
Tender. Mrs J. T.. Matheny: song. Won't
You Play House With Me- Misses Agnes
Rorebeck, Pearl Neitch. Mabel Poole Rus
sell Willis. Helen and Mamie Russell Sue
Brown; piano solo. "Mazurka' Miss Rus
sell Willis. vocal duet Sing on Sweet
Bird" Misses Rodeffer and Coyner: piano
duet, lie Petit Carnival Misses Iuttrell
and Phillips: vocal trio The Ruelcr'
Misses Ruth, Kate and Ada Coyner: piano
solo. la Chatelaine." Miss Kate Coyner:
piano duet. Les Danes de Seville" Misses
Kate and Ruth Coyner: vocal solo oh
Promise Me-" Miss Kate Coyner: piano
solo. In the Merry Month Of MAY" Miss
Ada Coyner: vocal solo. Beneath the Sum
mer Skies" Miss Annie F.. Rodener: song
Wont You Come TO My Tea Partv2"
Misses Rorebeck Brown. Eeitch. Willis
Poole. Mamie and Helen Russell
Rev. j. G. Butler pastor Of Luther Me-
mortal Church OF Washington made an
interesting address. The exercises closed
with the benediction by Rev. John Mctiill.
Mrs Sarah Buxton. wife Of Mr.. a. ~
Buxton of the Treasury Department died
Thursday morning. after lingering i'll
less.
Mr.. F. ]. Swisher Of Lynchburg. gradu-
ate OF Piedmont Business College has been
appointed a stenograpber in m. office NJ
Mr., NJ. f. Church.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07
DIED.

Bolts. on Monday. February g is9S ~ 10
o'clock am. John beloved husband "f ''ar,-
leana Botis. al his residence. - Fenton street
northeast.
Weep that his tolls are over
Weep not thai his is run:
God grant that we may rest calmly
When work, like his. is done.
Funeral from the house at 5. 10 a M wc,iu. S,Inv
February 10: thence To st. Mnysius chui,h.
where mass Will lpe said m. for the ~
pose Of his soul. Friends and relatives Invited
TO attend.
ERowN. ON SUNDAY. February g. Isa>. at 3:45
pm. MIIIN BROWN. widuw Of The la,..
James II. Brown and mother Of W X. Brown.
Funeral from the Second Baptist Church. ID street
between II and | streets northwest Tu--.iAy.
February 5. at pm.
ELMs On Wednesday. February ., IssS. In King
George county. Va. JOSEPH FILMS. son 81 the
Interinent at Mount oli'et cemetery. Washington.
II. c.
FOWLER. suddenly. on THURSDAY. February B.
ls.s. at 1o:So O'Clock am. JOSEPH r.. be
:. and the late solomon Fowler. at his r'>i-
dence. NJ. $50 .oth street northwest. NJ Il
thirtytwo years and eight months.
McpoNALD. ON Monday, February :. lsgs;
MARY. the beloved wife Of John Mcdonald
and daughter Of the late Patrick aud Jane
Martin "f Baltimore.
No. 1245 3D. street southwest. "Wednesday. Fob
rrIary .. at $40 O'Clock am. thence 81.
Domintc's Church. where high viii se
said for the repose Of her soul. -
MCDONALD. ON Monday February :. 1895. at
II o'clock. ALBERT b. MCDONALD. youngest
son Of ArabeIla \. and the late Charles j. Nc
Donald. IA his fifteenth month
Funeral from house. sl6 street theast. We'd
nesday, February ., al 10 O'Clock.
MEIIAFFEY. At Lakewood y. j. February ;.
Ises s:,,s q pneumonia pr. WILLIAM N. ME-
Interment a, Boston. Mass
ROBINSON. ON Sunday, FEBRUARY G. 1898 AZ 40
pm. CHAS. H. ROBINSON. at the residence
OF his sonn-law, J. Walter Humphrey. i"6
Rhode Island avenue northwest, in the Gfty-
Services Al the home Tuesday. February s. pm.
Interment NJ Bnghdmton. y. \. tBinghamton,
y. Y. papers please copy
ROCKWELL on Sunday February g. 1898. at @
o'clock pm; SARAH j.. widow Of Henry In
Funeral from her late residence. $50 r street
northwest. Tuesday afternoon February s. a 2
O'clock Friends invited. Kindly omit flowers.
Interment private.
wALSToN. Depart ID this life. February G. l-as.
Funeral VIII take place from her late residence.
21O4 Northwest. thence Trinity
Catholic Church. Tuesday. February 5. al
pm.
In Memorian.
mother. MAsGRETT DOWNS. wh" died Se.en
years ago today. February Z. 1891.
Loved I'm life In death remembered.
BY HER CHILDREN.
RAUIs. In loving remembrance of my dear
father. JOHN RAILS. who departed this life
year ago today. February Z. 1897.
My father is asleep and flee from all pain.
God, in his sufTerings sent down from above
An angel that whispered a message Of love.
By Ills DAUGHTER. SADIE KEY.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07
Kitchen and
Dining Room Chairs.

We have just received splendid
assortment OF Kitchen and Dining
Room Chairs. They are unsur-
passed in quality and finish, and are
unusually low priced.
Two special designs in hard wood nicely finished
highly polished strong and durable.
SOC each.
Two special patterns in hard wood nicely fin
i>hed cane seat bottom. highly polished made
especially for durability.
SIOO each.
We Offer some except ionaliy good values IN pat
terms selected with Unusual care; fnll box seat
cane seat bottom. made Of clean. FRESH selected
esk. highly polished
SI.65 each.
Better grades made and finished
accordingly.
Special attention Is called stock Of IA
and Hishchaifs for children made of selected
oak.
SI.oo to $500 each.
Fourth floor.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07

Rev. Dr. VIM. N. Brodbeck of Boston.
who was to have been admitted to the Bal
timore conference of the NJ. L. Church ut
It's meeting in this city next month. died
suddenly Saturday Of muscular rneuma-
tism.
DIR. Brodbeck was regarded as one OF the
leaders of the denomination IA the United
States, and great results were anticipated
from his pastorate Of the First Church.
Bali 0nore. to which he had accepted a call.
He was at the Tina of his death president
of the New England Deaconess Home
Training School and Hospital secretary of
the board of trustees Of Boston University,
member of the executive committee of the
Methodist City Missionary and Methodist
Extension Society. and Of the Evangeistic
Association of New England, and vice pres
ident Of the Ministers Relief Association
of New England The degree of DID. was
conferred upon him by both the German
Wallace College Of Berea, Ohio, and the
Ohio Wesleyan University of Delaware,
Ohio. He has twice been elected as a rep
resentativc of the New England Conference
to the general conference.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07

Chief OF Police Dyer ot Roanoke. Va.
came Nere Saturday TO receive from n. po-
lice Rev. Leslie Cook. the alleged forger
who escaped from Jail in the Virginia town
several weeks ago. and was arrested in this
city, as heretofore published In The Star
The prisoner waived the right TO have his
case heard on requisition. and returned
last night with the officer.
Ii was stated by the Virginia officer tina
Cook once lad charge of church near
Natural Bridge. Va. and IL was while D..
Vas at this church that he began his al
legged violations of law. The officer SAYS a..
mas information which leads TO the belief
that Cook had two wives. or that he was
living i'm Virginia with female companion
after the departure of his wife
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07
Mems Clothing to Order.

There is vet a couple months of
cold weather. Your Overcoat may
be shabby or worn out entirely. One
purchased now at before-spring
prices would be economy looking
toward the future.
We make Overcoats to order. and
guarantee the garments and the
prices, at
$1,000, $1,000 and Upward
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07
GOcarts.

UUOdTES.
Our stock OF Gocarts is very ex-
tensive, and comprises many new
ideas. Scores of styles, from the
plainest to the most elaborate, and
each price represents the best in
trinsic value obtainable.
S2.45 to $1,000 are the prices.
Fourth floor.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07
ssr1ariom Hariand"
Coffee Pots.

Every housekeeper who has used
the Marion Harland Coffee Pot
knows there is nothing better Drip
coffee made in one of these pots is
perfect and will add greatly to a nice
breakfast.
We cali especial attention TO the size suitable
for small and medium-sized families which we
sell
ooc. each.
Other sizes from 75c. to SI.65 EACH
Fifth floor.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07
Special Sale of
Puffled Muslin Curtains.

Dainty Muslin and Bobbinet
Curtains for chamber and library
use. new and beautiful designs at
especially low prices-examples of
the economy that reigns throughout
our Upholstery Department. The
stock abounds with such items OF in
terest
aep pairs Whit, Muslin RufieI Curtains. plain,
coin spots and figured enects-nothins dainty
for the chamber.
$50 pair.
.o pairs I:ufied Muslin Curtains COLONIAL de-
signs-yers attractive.
$500 pair.
5" pairs Runied Boobinet Curtains fine and
dainty.
$500 pair.
- pieces White Curtain Mrslins. in a large line
Of patterns figures. stripes and coin spots.
I2ic. yard.
5" India Seats. plain bottoms. various woods.
SI.Oo each.
%, Japanese Bamboo and Beaded Portieres, pretty
designs.
SI25 each.
lon Oriental Pillows. filled with down-choice
designs.
SIPS each.
IL pieces 5o-inch Furniture Covering. full line
Of attractive eoiorings.
O5c. yard.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07
MARRIED..

CAREY Kinney. I'm November 20 1887 in Bal
timore. by the Rev. J. H. Young. MIR. 4 e
CAREY OF Ohio TO Miss MARI; AltET A LIN
NEf Of Washington. 10. e. toho paI.rs please
copy.p
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07

We are now showing our spring
importation OF Japanese Rugs in all
the popular sizes. The qualities and
designs are better than we have ever
shown. and prices are absolutely the
lowest for this quality.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07

Hugh Hartens pleaded guilty Tuesday
last OF illegally using i've bottles belonging
to member of the Bottlers Protective
Association. and was fined CLIO by Judge
Scott The 6ne was paid
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07
''SOrOsis,' the New Shoe
For Women.

The kind that look different from
the usual run of shoes.
The kind that have style, snap and
art in them.
The kind that fit your feet comfort
ably and are extremely fashionable
at the same time.
The shoe question is almost al
ways a vexatious problem. but YOU
will find the "Sorosis" Shoe can
with truth be called social reformer,
as owing to its peculiar construction
walking is made easy and living a
comfort to those who have 10 use
their feet
$3.50 for All Styles,
And they are as good as the sorts
that are sold for more in many stores.
They are ours for Washington.
Second floor.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07
$3.50 each.

Also handsome line of fine Silk aniwo Now
city Cloth. Tartan Plaid and rich Silk skirts silk
lined throughout and superby finished
$3.50 to S45 90 each.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07

Saws Mr.. q. ". LORD. writing from Silver
Lake. Me: My doctor recommended Jaynr's tx
pcctorant and am sure that IL has saved NY
life in one two Instances
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07
Woodward and LOthrOp,
10th. nth and F SITS. n. w.
r1uch of the Spring
Merchandise is Ready.

shelves laden with rich beauty
prene The
Organizes Moussen the Dnies the
readybgl and attractive their
unique petiness. Many enjoying first view"
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07

Hich-class Brocaded eros Grain silk and Satin
Skirts-an entirely new line of spring patterns;
beautifully made and finished Special values at
S7.25 and S8.75 each.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07

High Plain Satin. eros Grain. Brocade
and the Bayadere Striped Silk Skirts. hand
som.y lined and finished-superior goods and an
exceptional value at
SI2.5o each.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07

Fine Black Brocaded Satin and SILK Skirts.
properly lined bound and stiffeneda large va
riety Of choice patterns
SOS each.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07

- pieces White Curtain Mrslns. in a large line
Of patterns figures. stripes and coin spots.
I2ic. yard.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07

5o pairs Eunied Muslin Curtains. colonial de-
signs-vers attractive.
$500 pair.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07
Carriers
Little Liver
Pills.
SICK HEADACHE

POSITIVELY CURED By THESE LITTLE PILLS,
They also relieve distress from Dyspepsin.
indigestion and Too Hearty Eating. per-
feet remedy fot Dizziness. Nausea. Drcw<i-
Bad Taste In the Mouth. Coated
Tongue, Pam In the Side TORPID LIVER.
table.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07
The I'd week of
Hecht's great:
surplus sale.

ust as the beautiful snow
melted before the sun of the
past few days so has the sur-
plus stock melted" before the
demand of thousands of buy
ers. Selling such as would
have been enough for half sea-
son was done in FIVE cold,
blustry days. The varieties
have become depleted so much
that we have had to reinforce
them with lots from our Balti-
more stores. In many in
stances further reductions have
been made to make the great
sale greater. You are welcome
to credit-your bill will be di-
vided. into the smallest parts
to be curtailed each week or
montll-as YOU wish.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07
$1,000 each.

Superior Black and Navy Scotch Cheviot Tailor
made skirts. lined throughout with heavy Black
Tanets SILK. Special value at
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07

5h India Seats. plain bottoms. various woods.
SI.Oo each.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07
New TailOr=Made
Separate Skirts.

\ never-so-worthy assortment OF
Women's High-class Separate Skirts
just received. They embrace all the
latest weaves and most fashionable
fabrics. and are priced on lower
scale than ever before Especially
worthy OF mention are:
Strictly Tailor-msde skirts of fine Black and
Navy Sponged Cheviot extra fine Plain and
Figured Brillianiine-the very best values obtain
able st the low price of
g. % each
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07

IL pieces J0-inch Furniture Covering. full lin
Of attractive colorings.
O5c. yard.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07

-, Japanese Bamboo and Beaded Portieres, pretty
designs
SI.25 each.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07

Third floor.
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07
$500 a pair.

81 pairs Rufied Bobbinet Curtains fine and
dainty
Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1898-02-07
SIPS each

Ia" Oriental Pillows. filled With down-ehoice
designs.
The weekly messenger. [volume] (St. Martinsville [i.e. St. Martinville] La.) 1886-1948, 1898-01-01
THE HURON SOLD.

At last the Huron Plantation
and Teche Railroad, situated in
the extreme Northern part of this
parish was sold to Mr.. James
Crangle, of Shreveport, for the
sum of S57 $50.
This sale was made by order of
the United States Chancery Court.
This is valuable piece of pro-
perty, consisting, of we'll equip
ped plantation of 600 acres of cul-
tivable land. a refinery needing
little repairs, and over twenty four
miles of railroad, running from
Carencro, Arnaudville and Breaux
Bridge.
The surrounding countryis we'll
adapted for the cultivation of the
cane, and with fair dealing and
proper encouragement, enough
cane can be raised in the imme-
date neighborhood to supply Sc
veral refneries.
The weekly messenger. [volume] (St. Martinsville [i.e. St. Martinville] La.) 1886-1948, 1898-01-01
OH, HOW SAD e.!

ty of our editor to chronicle the
death of one dear to him-Mrs.
Terville Bienvenu, nee Cecile Ber-
trand, who died at 7:10 O'Clock,
Saturday evening, December 25th,
at the age of40 years and 4 months,
after IN illness of only few days.
Indisposed since the beginning
of the week she was in her room
some times in bed and some times
in rocking chair conversing with
relatives and friends, and the
morning Of her death she had a
bouquet and cake made under her
personal orders for her aged fa-
aher whom she loved SO dearly,
she was in fact in no apparent
danger, but at four O'Clock in the
evening, she felt worse, and in the
course of few short hours, she
was corpse.
Mrs. Bienvenu was one OF those
brave and courageous women,
whose trouble and suffering were
known only to herself, never would
she complain to any one, but bore
her trouble and suffering like a
true, noble christian she was. She
lived for her dear relatives, and
every one of her spare moments
were for them and to relieve the
sick, and she always shared her
own modest possessions with the
poor and needy. When Mrs. Da--
MEL DeBlanc died only six months
ago, leaving an orphan of only
four or five days, this noble wo-
man, seeing that no one was there
to care for this unfortunate child,
she, a perfect stranger, took and
adopted the child, and nursed him
until the time Of her untimely de-
mise.
She was the vice-president of
the society of the Lady Of Promp
Succor, and was beloved and cher
ished by all the members OF the
association.
She leaves a husband and three
grown children, and a host of re-
latives and friends to mourn her
demise.
She was buried the follow
ing day at three o'clock in the
evening, and Notwithstanding the
muddy condition of our sidewalks
and streets, her remains were fol-
lowed to the grave by very large
humber of persons.
Her son being member OF the
Greig Junior Brass Band that mu-
steal organization attended the flu
neral and played some sad marches
during the funeral cortege.
noble women has gone to rest,
And her pure soul is now in Heaven.
II
6sck RED BLOOD is the foun-
N datlOl, of good health That is why
The weekly messenger. [volume] (St. Martinsville [i.e. St. Martinville] La.) 1886-1948, 1898-01-01
ACT OF
TNCORPO7ATION
United States of America,
State of Louisiana, Parish of st. Martin.

Be It known that'o this the Seventeenth day
of November, A. D., Eighteen hundred-and-
ninety-seven.
Before me Dan. W. VOORHEES,. Notary Pu-
bic, duly qualified, and sworn in and for the
Parish of st. Martin. State of Louisiana, and in
presence of the undersigned resident witnesses;
Personally appeared ROBERT MARTIN. of
st. Martin Parish, Louisiana, ALEXANDRA
MOUTON, of Orleans Parish, Louisiana, and 8.
v. MARTIN, of Orleans Parish. Louisiana,
herein represented by said Robert Martin. who
said that awaiting themselves Of the Laws of
this State relative to the organization of Corpo-
rations, and especially of Act 36 Ut 1888, they
have agreed and do hereby agree, bind and obli-
gatethemselves, as we'll as such persons as may
hereafter become associated with them, to con-
stitute a Limited Corporation for the purposes
and under the conditions following, to-wit:
Article I.
The name of this Corporation shall be THE
X. MARTIN SUGAR COMPANY, LIMITED"
its domicile shall be in the Parish of st. Mar
tin, Louisiana. and it shall exist for period of
ninety-nine (9s) years. from this day; and under
its name it shall have the right to acquire pro-
perry of any kind, real or personal, for cash or
on terms mortgage, lease, Sell, pleuSe, W ou'tu
and construct a sugar refinery. for that purpose
to operate brick yards, or to acquire same area-
dy constructed and put up. and for that purpose
to enter into all necessary contracts: to sue and
be sued in its corporate name. and generally to
have and exercise all powers conferred by law
on Corporations. All legal process shall be
served on the President, and in his absence on
the yice-PIesident of this Company. The said
Corporation shall also have the right to borrow
money. and for that purpose to issue bonds
payable in any seriee Of years, interests on the
said bonds not to exceed eight per cent per year.
Article III.
The principal object Of this Company is to
establish Sugar Factory in this Parish. to buy
cane. 70 grind the same, refine syrup and gener-
ally to manufacture. refine and sell sugar cane
The weekly messenger. [volume] (St. Martinsville [i.e. St. Martinville] La.) 1886-1948, 1898-01-01

No-To-Bac for Fifty Cents.
Guaranteed tobacco habit cure, makes weak
men strong, blood pure. sec, 81. All druggists
The weekly messenger. [volume] (St. Martinsville [i.e. St. Martinville] La.) 1886-1948, 1898-01-01
NOTICE.

BY order of the Board OF Directors OF
the st. Martinville Building and Loan
Association, the undersigned win sell
The weekly messenger. [volume] (St. Martinsville [i.e. St. Martinville] La.) 1886-1948, 1898-01-01

100000
on TUESDAY, Jan. 4th 1895, at 8 O'Clock.
p. m. at Bank Building. C. GREIG.
Secretary & Treasurer.
The times. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1890-1903, 1898-08-28
NEWS NOTES
FOR WHEELMEN

am often asked which IS the best
tire. The best answer 1 have seen or can
give is an editorial in the Cytle Age Tor
August 18th. as follows.
A certain irnpaucnce with insecure tire
ropafrs has been noted this season. end
the elaborate methods prescribed Tor
overcoming this insecurity by seWed-
on patches, vulcauizltlon ana other pro-
cessos for which the rider feels no IN
clination and for which the repaifman
finds II hard to obtain a sufficiently high
price, have not helped the situation
much. They have indeed served % en-
phasize that something was amiss with
cheap single tube tires. The remedy was
sought I'm two directions. Either the cas-
ing was made thick and hard in order TO
reduce the chance II puncture or the
thread fabric was adopted 10 make
mending easier and more secure, but in
the latter case chcapness was out Of
question The trade has divided ifs IA
VOrs between the TWO methods, but the
thickcning Of tire tread leads directly
toward the unpnoumauc spring tire or
the pneumatic hub. The thicker and STIFF
fer the thread portion IS, the more sim
liar is the action 10 that OF a spring tire
Local resilency IN the tire Is renowned
as siiperau0us quality as soon as the
mick tread IS NANl'N"Af anu "a HNNF -
taken. which. II the development contin-
ues. must be suicidal for makers OF such
tires. only a short time will be required
COR the public 90 draw the rational in
ference that mere springiness can be OBJ
tainsd better and more cheaply by other
means.
The thread fabric advocates have the
betfsr side OF the argument when they
insist on Offering the public the comfort
and benefit OF a resilient impressionable
tive which paves the road with seeming
srnoofhness. and imparts sense OF lux
urv 10 riding which is not obtainable
y~ben n sim layer intervenes between
the mobile air and the ground. They are
not threatening their own existence by
o,ferin, goods for which a cheap substl-
int NAV readily be devised. But a large
norton Of the public still objects to the
freouensy OF punctures and the trouble,
however slight OF mending them. Espe-
c,aIlv cuts or gashes are dreaded. for
70 mend them properly Is beyond the
ken OF the average rider The public pre-
,erences are therefore taking third
channel. The detachable tire IS gaining
their favorable consideration in spite Of