Cottonwood report. [volume] (Cottonwood, Idaho) 1893-1901, 1898-07-15
Honesty Is Best.

Inc 0dn JOSS bCh1e has Cdub6u y kTchC
deal of discussion in this country, and
more or less hard feeling among men
that one would suppose above such
feelings. The San Jose scale is a pest
of the first magnitude, as has been
proved by It's ravages in the orchards
OF California Wide areas of citrous
fruits were destroyed by them. 1t is
therefore natural that the appearance
OF the scale on this side of the Rocky
mountains has filled the fruit growers
OF this section with alarm and has
caused both the agricultural journals
and the entomologists of the several
states and of the nation to repeatedly
warn the people of the danger and to
urge all to watch for it and to assist in
its destruction.
The agricultural journals have not
failed to take their place in the ranks
of the enemies of the scale. AS is al
ways the case, there are here and there
men whose business interests are af
fected by the scale, and those do not
want the subject agitated. They say
that it might possibly decrease the sale
Of nursery stock If people became
alarmed as to the scale. They have
even advocated that agricultural papers
that publish much on the scale be boy
cotted in their advertising. Two or
three small papers have even advised
their advertising patrons to do this,
telling them that the said large ad-
vertising papers should have more con-
sideration for the interests of the ad-
vertising than to publish reports that
might result in less sales. This sort
of reasoning is very weak. If the pa
pers do not warn the people and the
people do not stop the advance of the
scale, what would be the result? The
scale would soon get foothold In all
parts of the country and the business
Of the nurseries would be ruined, for
people would cease to buy. We know
the history of the black-knot on the
plums. Previous to the advent of the
black-knot from Europe there were fine
orchards of plum trees all over the
country, especially in New England
and New York. The black-knot came
without warning. The people did not
know how to fight it., and no effective
measures were taken against it. In
a few years 1t had swept like fire all
over the country and had obtained
foothold in every locality. Then what
became of the trade in plum trees from
the nurseries? We have no statistics
of the relative amount of sales of plum
trees, but as people quite generally for
years gave up trying to produce plums
1t may we'll be supposed that the sales
were small. This pest could have been
checked had it been taken in time, as
we are now doing with the scale. Peo-
pie must be kept informed of the seri-
BUSINESS of the situation. Honesty is
the best policy even in fighting the San
Jose scale. We can not stop the ad-
vance of the scale without money from
the treasures of the states. So fa1
both the general government and the
states are doing something in this di-
rection with probability of doing more
in the future. This has been a part OF
the result of the agitation by the agri-
cultural press. Another result has
been that farmers and others have be-
come informed as to the scale and how
to distinguish it and have been able to
report infested localities to the proper
authorities and thus bring about the
checking Of the pest before it has been
able to get beyond control. The full
truth must be told relative to the San
Jose scale as we'll as to every other
pest.