The Caldwell tribune. [volume] (Caldwell, Idaho Territory [Idaho]) 1883-1928, 1897-08-21
Nc Antl-CoIor C1ntterlnel -.

II
We notice that the Chicago daily
papers, almost without exception, are
making comments entirely unfriendly
to the new oleomargarine law passed
BY the legislature of Illinois. The
papers not only criticse it severely, but
trump up charges that have no truth
IN them. In the first place they claim
that the law is entirely in the interests
Oh the farmers. which is not so. The
consumer ia the city is benefited to a
very great extent by the law that
compels o.eomargarine to be sold foE
what 1t is. The consumer is now COM
peiled TO pay butter prices for con-
coctton OF different kinds of grease,
any one of those ingredients sell on
the market and at retail for much less
than 10 cents per pound. In fact the
cost OF pound of cleo ready for eat
ing Is only about cents plus 2 cents
revenue, making cents altogether.
NOW ten cents is a good price for such
compound, and now that it will have
20 De sold for what it is, fancy prices
ior butterine will no longer prevail.
Inc city laborer that wants to eat but
eerlne can get it in its pure state and
Tor low price. If he objects to hav-
ing 1t white he can for a few cents
ouy enough butter color to tint great
many pounds of the stuff to suit him
self. But we know that the dear"
laDorer is not interested. He has to
pay butter prices now for oleo and
would generally prefer the butter, for
ne thinks he is buying butter. The
willing eater of cleo would rather pay
~ cents a pound for white butterine
than 20 cents pound for yellow but
terine. The poor people in the large
cities eat it for economy's sake, and
~ cents per pound extra is rather high
to pay for butter coloring matter in
butterine.
Then, the papers say that the law
ruins a great industry and throws
many men out of employment. Let us
see. Oleo costs 4 cents per pound to
manufacture, that including labor and
materials. But materials only repre-
sent the labor of other men, so that
really the whole cost represents labor
in some form. Butter costs the farmer
all the way from cents per pound
(under the very best of conditions and
with the most profitable of cows) to
30 cents under unfavorable circum-
stances. Some butter costs much more
than that. 1t is safe to assume that
average butter costs at least IL cents
per pound, which means that IL cents
worth of labor is employed in making
butter 1t will therefore be seen that
it takes three times as many labOrers
to make million pounds of butter as
it does to make a like amount of but
terine. Therefore if good many men
are thrown out of employment by the
closing of butterine factories it will
give employment to three times as
many men, on farms and in creameries. |
But what becomes of the money saved |
in the manufacture of butterine over
butter? Do the wealthy manufacture
ers distribute it among their workmen
in some form or other? Not at all. |
The saving in cost of manufacture goes
to help swell the fortunes that are be-
coming a menace to the country.
Another point they attempt to make
Is that the farmers that now supply |
fat from beef, pork or cotton seed will |
lose a market for that much of their
product. This is great reasoning.
Every cents worth of the stuff they
sell stops the sale of ten cents worth
Of butter by the farmers. Even if the
same men that are furnishing the fats
do not furnish butter yet they are hurt
indirectly by the sales they make to
the oleo manufacturers. BY killing of
the sale of millions of pounds of butter
hey force dairymen to abandon dairy
ng and go into stock raising or cotton
growing, and thus raise up additional
to themselves and help
.orce down their own market.
There are other things that might
1e said in favor of the law and against
men to get rich by perpetra+-
ng fraud on the people, but we reserve
hem to another time. Every farmer
hould use his full influence to
trengthen these laws, and to enact
hem in states that now have no anti.
olor laws.
Grass See6ing.-In seeding land IA
.raHs it would be much better If great
~ H ri of DIoDtc vyoro