Audubon Republican. [volume] (Audubon, Iowa) 1894-1925, 1897-06-03
A TEXAN ON THE JURY
HOW HE WON THE OTHER JURORS
OVER TO HIS OPINION.

OVER TO HIS OPINION.
The Verdict In an italian Homicide Case
Which Astonished the Court and Law
yers In New York-Convincing "KilI or
BE Killed" Logic.
cit was known as the murder Of the
feast of the turkey" said Assistant Dis.
trict Attorney Hal Bell, who handles
all the Italian homicide cases in the
criminal courts. "The murdered man
was Nunzio Iallaz, and he was stabbed
to death on the afternoon of Nov. 26,
1896. The man who killed him was
Giuseppe Ladierre. put Ladierre on
trial in the criminal branch Of the su-
preme court The indictment charged
him with murder in the first degree.
His counsel, Lawyer Palmieri, offered
to enter plea of guilty to manslaugh-
ter in the first degree, but the plea was
not accepted, as it seemed an easy mat
ter to convict the defendant. There was
no denial of the fact that Ladierre
stabbed Iallaz to death with knife Is
inches long.
AFTER the jurymen had been sworn
I learned that one Of them, big, hand
some fellow, was Texan. When I
found this out, became satisfied that !
would have hard job getting convic-
ton, for when you get full fedged,
raw Texan on a jury in murder trial
ho'll simply decide the case according
to his own Judgment, regardless Of law.
He has only to be convinced as to
whether the murdered man ought to
have been killed. The actual crime has
nothing to do with the case. The Texan
has his own ideas about such matters,
and, knowing this, was sorry to think
! had full fledged, raw Texan ON the
jury trying Ladierre.
1.-THE story that the jury got from the
witnesses was that Ladierre met Iallaz
on One Hundred and Fifty-second
street; that the men had a wordy quar-
rel; that Ladierre slapped the face Of
Iallaz; that Iallaz drew big knife
from his belt, and then ensued scuffle,
the knife falling to the sidewalk; that
both men fought to get it, and that La
DEERE, being the quicker of the two,
got hold Of the knife and plunged it in
to Iallaz, who died from the effects of
the stabbing. These were the undis-
puted facts that were given to the jury,
and we all believed that Ladierre would
be convicted of at least manslaughter.
But the jury promptly acquitted the
man after Ladierre showed them on the
witness stand the way in which he did
the killing
Defendants counsel, Lawyer Palm
Teri, was greatly surprised at the YER
dict. Justice Giegerich was unable to
understand such action OH the jury's
part. But believed knew the secret Of
it all, and to satisfy myself I began a
quiet investigation, which has resulted
in my learning that was right in my
first belief The handsome man from
Texas just gave the other jurymen to
understand that he was there. He was
not to be bullied. He was not to be out
voted either. If the jurymen wouldn't
listen to the way they settled trifling
cutting scrapes in Texas, he would see
about it; see to it that they would.
Plunging knife into O mans heart
that was nothing. The question to be
decided was, did the deceased deserve
the plunge? According to the Texan,
he did, or the live man wouldn't be
alive. If Ladierre had not killed Iallaz,
probably Iallaz might have killed La
DEERE. This was case, the Texan ar
gued, where quickness won the battle,
and quickness should be rewarded, not
censured. Ladierre simply got in first
stab, argued the man from Texas, and
he ought to be complimented ON his
stabbing speed.
"There were two little men on that
jury and they believed the verdict
should be murder in the first degree.
The Texan just reared at them, and
| they SUNK away to corner of the
room. The other jurors backed away
toward the wall. The big Texan then
made speech, telling the jurors how
they ran things down in my state, ,
and the other II jurors stood open
mouthed, gazing in wonderment. He
recalled shooting bees, and stabbing
parties, and hanging plcn1cs, and gave
| graphic illustrations Of how Sim Gard
ner cut tn damned gizzard out'n Budd
Allen, when Budd jest said he'd make
Sim eat tn dust.
"Then he asked if there war emmy
man in tn room who'd be man enough
to say this were lie. But there WASH t
a man there who didn't believe 1T, and
the Texan said, Come, boys, tn YER
diets not guilty Then they all got in
line, filed into the courtroom, and the
clerk recorded the verdict. Eight of the
jurors were pale faced when they came
in. The faces of three were very red.
The twelfth man was the Texan. His
face appeared normal, and as he warm,
ly grasped the hand Of the man who die
the deed he remarked:
Yer did right, pard. I'd er did il
meself if war thar