New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1897-06-08
Cashmere
Bouquet
TOILET SOAP and PERFUr1E.
A TARIFF CAUCUS CALLED
CONTINUED from first pngeo


protective duty still"
Mr. Caffery displayed some temper as ne pio-
nounced Mr.. Hoar's statement that ne ia'o'e" q
protective duty on sugar erroneous. lheie was nv
he declared iota of protection IN MS "'"neup,
The Senator from Massachusetts was so inoc"i&'eu
Win tho nro,octtve doctrine that he could not see
the strength of an argument for revenue uu'!'
81 favor n duty on sugar" said MI Canery, en-
phatically because the duty goes INTO inc i'ea'
ury OF the United States You favor pro'ecuon Oh
articles which enables the manufacturers VI ms
articles TO put the equivalent of the duty IN the"
own pockets
ALWAYS CRYING SUGAR"
NJ, paoor ord MIR Cafrery had sharp exchange
of words and seemed about to suoSide' ou' S
a,or Hoar evidently did not desire that Ae"i'
he made some sarcastic references 70 MT td"eiy
inconsistency describing him as free Uauei ""'
cried always Sugar Sugar. sugar anu ""o'
when the Wilson bin was before the Senate was
40 doubtful Of what that BIZ would 90 TOT sue",
tim. he voted Aye" the sugar schedule ana
NO" on the final passage of the Dill. ara .heh
changed 20 Aye" The free-trade senator H'''
louisiana" he concluded, finds only one eNcei
ton 10 the application OF his theorE--sus"'' an"
the free-trade Senator from "e'ie
ception-lumber."
Mr. Bacon protested at being termed Free
Trader He favored duty on all raw materials
IAN raw materials t:at compete with the prooucts
of Georgia" remarked Mr.. Hoar. amid !aus"'e.'
ha
articles which various Senators Of the opposition
seemed 10 desire 10 have protected II we cou'o
commit the framing OF a Tarin Dill 10 thc r''o
Trade Senators who are conducting the oeou'c vi
the other side" said he. If we shut our eyes, opeeu
orr mouths and voted for 1t. after its passage We
would discover that every industry in their reSPec
tive States had been amply protected CLaush'ei,
That's what they did before; that's what they wouid
DO now Morally there is great deai Oh hui"i'
nature in Democrats
The rnerrimen, was SO great as Mr.. Hoar conciuded
that Senator Burrows, who was in the chaH' was
compelled to suppress 1t with his gaVei
HOW ABOUT FREE HIDES?
Mr. Bacon sought 10 counter on his New-Eng!ahd
adversary by asking If In any bill SO iraineu ne
would insist on free hides for Massachusetts.
Mr.. Hoar replied that If the Dill seemcd 10 MN
such measure the present one appeared 10 DC
he would be inclined 10 defer TO the opinion OF MS
colleagues on one particular item. Hides. con-
tnued Mr. Hoar ARE not produced for themselves
alone If you put a duty of cent per pound on
a hide weighing sixty pounds that would be worth
60 cents on animal worth SOL per cent. thinK
a tariff of per cent as matter of protection is an
absurdlty But If could convince my col
leagues that l right should yield my indi'!d-
ual convictions"
After Mr. Caffery had made the statement that
he had no apologies to make for his vote on the
Wilson BILL the debate became desultory. Mt AL
len Pop Neb) touched briefly the subject OF
Der duties in the bill. which, he said. would be
particularly oppressive 10 the people Of Nebraska
who were the victims OF the Lumber Irusl ,,u,
" lille Mr.. Allen speaking OF he great mill
ionaire lumber kings Ct the Atlantic Coast MI
Chandler provoked ianSn by asn'ns , MN nov nov
board 49,. ,,or, oro o,ou,
four thousand. replied Mr' A!!eh. ...1,..,,.,
THE BEST ARG JMENT FOR PROTECTION.
Mr. Thurston (Rep.. Ncb) defended the proposed
duty on lumber Il was not necessary ne said 10
make an argument in support OF the general doc-
,rinc Of protection That argument had been made
during the last four years by the silent spndles,
the rottinC water-wheels, the smokcless chimney'
the rustIng dlnner-pais. the Coxey armies the
ragged men and women and the hungry cnlidieh,
The lumber schedule in the bill would not increase
the cost OF lumber 10 the people of Nebraska one
ce Mr pg tones Dem. Ark characterized absurd
the statement that this countrE wa Oems IN tbe
face Of the fact that only $4,000 worth Of lumber
imported last year agatnS, pmbSg baroms
| Of the Northwest who wanted the people OF shd
country to pay for the alleged high stumpaee paia
fres etc set forth in the petition 10 tne aSs
and Means Commute he dead n; a, Methods
| pursued by certain lumbormcn on indian reserVa
MI Mr spooner Rep WIS., admitted that the report
etate1 CORRECTLY the methods o. certain unscrupu-
Sqs men OF OF the ne on that and
pai3 nigh tribute to their integrity ana pup yl
sPT mr. s d r T S%t appointment which
posed exclude white pine from Inc
@ on 'e Nnd nx shG and % be
'n Mr. Vest dscai,ed any intention Of dssrimpa-
ing He opposed the duty on al caSses ~ dnsn
because Vile Dine went the hear, of hs s sS1
9ysyd to the p nj @mSer on on h free nc %
Prchard RsP n CT - Ga ellie M Nine S S Ken
| tucky West Virginia and Tennessee
MR.. VEST WANTS A TEST VOTE.
| , w.. ,,a no rould he willing 70 withdraw
| his amendment and take the yeas and nays on MI
| Aliens amendment All he wanted was test vote
| on free lumber
| Mr.. spooner expressed his willingness 10 agree
| Ills amendment To put white pine on the free
| list. Mr. Spooner said, would give an undue ad-
s sGai5G 90 of Ih he propery Of
hi side Of the from Rorae Ms F5Sm the
could logic in motion TO put all 10 sIngs
S H %b free pn s anu G%t eSve the Of
land. the south and West protected from Canadian
dcntaiiy that he had no personal interest in any
in sf n sad h bay ns Gn the
ton of the United States, and all my associates
Mr. Mr.. Cray Dem Dci) said that in the interest
the PS9p he op aS he TINS n . such on
against pq q. cene Of ean be d
h ha idea h @f the the sh
tax the great body Of the people before they can
Mr Pritchard declared that he should vote Il
| cnualize conditions and wherever a North Caro-
lima industry was affected he would vote TO place
l.. II possible. In a superior position
! Mir GRAY said he wanted 10 equalize the con-
ditions of the consumers. and said II was an ex
ercse OF the despotsm OF wealth II people aonf
the northern tier Of States were 10 be stayed and
| prevented from crossing the imaginary line which
| separated them from Canada.
| Mr.. Hale remarked that Mr.. Gray was talking
like free trader The latter accepted the term
He said ne had no prejudice against the WORD
free" or the word freedom"
QUESTION FROM TILLMAN.
| Why do you draw the line at the free coinag,
| Of silver" asked Mr.. Tillman. The Senate an(
| galleries roared
| "The protection Senator from South CAROLINE
| takes up the sword Of the Senator from Nevadi
| CMr. Stewart during his absence" replied Mr.
Gray. Free silver. Ike the flowers that bloom II
. | the spring. has nothing 10 do with the case"