davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1897-01-27
CIVIL SERVICE IN BROOKLYN.
Justiee Keogb's DeoisIos Nov Before the
Appeiiate Court.

Justice KeoRb's Dee,sIoa Now Before the
Appellate Court.
Tho appeal Of the Brooklyn municipal author
tiles from tho recent sweeping civil service de-
clsion OF Justice KeoRh Of the Supreme Court.
which has held up" the salaries Of about nifty
subordinate officials not In tho competitive list,
was heard yesterday by the Appellate Division.
The arguments were substantially tho same as
woro mado before Justice Rsogh, Corporation
Counsel Burr appearing for tho appeal and Ed
ward M. Shepard In opposition. Mr.. Burr con-
tended that the fact that there were only about
40 out Of tho 5000 appointees In the city
government who held their places without
competitive examinations showed that the So
called spoils systsm did not prevail to any
alarming extent In Brooklyn. He also commended
that the discretion conferred upon the Governor
to classify places In tho State service and upon
tho Mayors OF cities to classify places in tho
city service. II exercised honestly and In good
faith. may not be reviewed at all by any court.
Mr.. Shepard scored Comptroller, Palmer as
the arch offender against the Civil Service law.
Referring to that Official. he said:
I'VE have never lad q clearer exhibition OF
perJurcd record than the report submitted by
the man who swore, when no took tho oath of
Office. to obey the Constitution, and yet violates
It's provisiona."
As a rcjoinder TO this. Mr.. Burr said:
troller OF tho city Of BROOKLYN. l suppose he
did II because II amused him and hurt nobody
else. This abuse Of the Comptroller has failed
to prove anything"
The decision OF tho Appellate Court is awaited
with interest in Brooklyn.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1897-01-27
BURGLAR HxBHE CoSFESSEs
Captured with BOOTY aad n KIT OF Teois
In HIS Possession.

ELIZABETH, y. j., Jan. 20.-A burglar who
says he Is Albert HAhno OF Third avenue. New
York. was captured At tho South Elizabeth sta
ton. on the Pennsylvania Railroad. at 0 30 this
morning. just as he was about to board a train
for New York. lie had = bundle containing two
overccats and several suits OF clothes. and In
various parts Of his clothes were found silver
forks and spoons marked IL. NJ. s." and a
purse containing $40 in gold. A kit of burElArs'
tools was also found In = pocket This after
noon II was learned that the houses OF Van S.
Roosa. ID. W. Reynolds. and William Decamp
Lewis In Roselle had been entered during the
night. Thos. persons ldentired "a theirs the
articles found in Hahne's possession. Hahno
had on q coat he had stolen from Roosas house.
Late this afternoon liahne confessed the
burglaries. In each case he gained entrance by
boring a hole through the window sash and
showing back the fastening with n piece OF wire.
A number of similar hurglaries have been COM
mitted in this vicinity recently and the police
believe they have the man who did them all.
He had railroad tickets between New York and
Pompton. In n memorandum book was this I'D.
dress, ALBERT Klcmsen. % Atlantic avenue"
aud the number OF a life Insurance policy.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1897-01-27
Cbc.bire Academy Alumni.

Prof. Andrew W. Phillips, Dean OF the Gradu-
ate School Of Yale University, will deliver an
address ON Modern Science at the annual
banquet OF the alumni OF Cheshire Academy, to
he held at tho Waldorf next Tuesday evening.
lie was for many years Professor OF mathema-
ties at the academy. Prof. F.. d. Woodbury.. for
over thirty hears head master aud now prinsi.
academy from It's foundation In 1894.
Among tho alumni who. vii. attend are: j..
pi.rnonI Morgan, the rev. John Williams OF the
Church OF the Heavenly Rest, James b. Dill.
Or, II: Holbrook Curtis, pr. w. 4; simpson
Nb.rne,hy, Roland 4. Robbins. GustavO Preston
OF boston. and Col. =. II, Corr OF Providence.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1897-01-27
InPRovEMESIs AND TAXATION.
lsersased Values Of Lands Oniy should Ne
Assessed for Municipal Purposes.

Increased Values Of Lads OaIy should Ne
Assessed for Municipal Purposes.
To TIE EDITOR OF The SUH-Sr: Mayor
Strong, In his message to the Board OF Alder
men. says: while these extensive improve
msnuA made necessary BY the annually ircreas-
Ing demands upon the resources and develop
menu OF this city. are entniling large expendI.
lures Of money. and consequently Increasing
our public Indebtedness. the people of this city
have steadily shown . desire 10 urge these i'm
provements forward. and . willingness to con-
tribute to the payment Of the Same. recognizing
that By these improvements the increase OF
valuations Of real estate In the sections where
the improvements arc made must bring In
creased valuations to their property. aud make
them consequent liberal contributors to the an
nual fund raised by taxation for the mainte-
nance Of the city and for the payment Of the
public debt as 1t may mature"
The Mayor here endeavors to show that the
incrsas. in the municipal bonded debt is q wise
Investment. because the expenditure Is for
public improvements. which cause an increase
IN real estate values. and consequent increased
asse'sable values. from which the taxes collect
ed will pay current municipal expenses and
produce = fund which ultimately will liquidAte
the bonds.
IL w JUSTIFY tho EuhyOT u buCu
conclusion. Public improvements are desirable
for public convenience: this is sufficient reason
for making them, The expense. however. Is not
met out OF an increase In taxable values due to
these public improvements, but is n charge and
burden on house owners and tenants.
Real estate includes land and everything fas-
tened to. on, In, above. or under the land. These
appurtenances on the land are not increased In
value by public Improvements. improvements
constantly decline In value by drterloration.
ana the chehoened cost OF material and con-
s~tretion. Tho Equitable building cost. when
erected. $40 q cubic foot. and can to-day be
eupllcsted for so cents q cubic foot. The aver
aee modern ONCE building costs about 25 cents
cubic loot and tenement houses about 10
stniteeh years, or even ten years ago.
Public improvements. along with general
progress IN other directions. increases the value
oIiand Alone. and. therefore. should Of right be
madea charge upon the increased land value
resulting from such improvements. Tho In
creased land value Ii now n gratuity TO the land
owner. The expense and burden Of the munici-
20 government, including public improve
Tents, . an upon house owners and tenants.
Li,Commissioner Michael Coleman, testtfylng
ptiore the Fassett INVESTIGATING committee,
men asked why he Increased assessable values
naaeslgnated part OF the city. replied that IL
va because there had been q great deal OF
building In that section.
INA, WIS has heen.. and Is, tho uniform prRc-
we OF the municipality Ia shown by this COM
paIs9n OF the taxable values dded each year
snu Ine stimate cost OF new buildings filed In
~ department: OF Buildings;
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1897-01-27
FOR THE NEW NAM OF RECORDS.
This City'a Delegation Appears Before the
Legislative Committees.

Legislative Committees.
ALBANY. Jan. 26.-An imposing deputation OF
citizens OF the metropolis called on the Senate
and Assembly Cities Committees this after
noon to speak In favor Of measures now before
the Legislature providing for the erection Of a
new Hall OF Records In New York city. Every
department Of trade. commerce. and finance
WAS represented.
John ID. Crimmins. who headed tho delega-
tion as the first speaker, set forth briefly the
need for the Hall OF Records. lie read the his.
tory of tho old hall from revolutionary times
until now. and stated that, save In a few re-
sprcts, the accommodations for tho deposit OF
valuable documents were not much better now
than they were then. MIR. Crimmins diiated on
the reniissness OF n city OF the size OF New
York In delaying 50 long In 80 important =
matter.
Corporation Counsel Clark. In behalf OF New
York. read a number Of amendments that
would be acceptable to tho municipality which
were acquiescrd In by the mem bers OF the dele
CATION. The other members OF the delegation
formally announced that the bodies they repre-
scented agreed with tho statement and petition
TO the committee submitted by Mr.. Crimmins.
Tho Cities Committee. aftor considering
tho bill In executive session. Will report II IA
vorably to the House tomorrow with the
amendmentss suggested at tho hearing TODAY.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1897-01-27
Opera. Th,. Year and Next Year.

To the EpiIoR or THE sUS-Sir; I was glad TO
read In q recent issue OF THE Sun a protest against tho
~inartIstlc habit OF cutting and mutilatlDg musical
masterpieces which of late years has been altogether
too prevalent at the Metropolitan opera House. II
an opera 10 worth performing at oil. II should be
given az nearly as possible In accordance with tho
composers intention. No doubt II Ia occasionally de-.
siraUle and even necessary ts In shakcspearean pro.
ductlonsl TO omit unlmportant scenes, but this Ii a
very different thing from cutting out entire acts.
Not only LA TrAviaia,' hut LES Huguenots,"
Faust, " "orfeo," william Tell" aud other operas
have suffered At the Metropolitan during tho past
two or three seasons from tho cutting process. In
the case OF Faust" there Is some excuse, since the
nrocken scene the excelsior OF which would never DO
tolerated In parlsi requires several expert JIcmiArss
dans,uses, ana "A large corps .hc bHhr', features In
which our opera IL llluentnbly deficient, but the
dramatic Significance OF "Orfco -" (which should have
A huppy denourmentl was ruined and some beautiful
Iurudi ce to The shades. Most oprraROtrs viii recall
the fame aud lnpotent conclusion NJ " W lillian Tell"
With SignUr TanlRgnO sthndin alone upon the stage,
when u large nllInOtf ot people ret ained their seats
and could hardly Ne persuaded by the ushers mat the
N'Tns last act Of Les nuguenot." (Which forms
the dramatic though not the musical climax or the
York. was always sung by Nilsson and Campanini
when thoy were here during tbs season OF 1858, ~.
IL 10 still given regularly In. Paris, Vienna, and Bor'
lin, and up 10 u comparatively recent date wAf per
formed ut ioti the opera houses In LONDON.
NJ. Jean de u SIX NrOuii probably decline 10
sling this ~. N.H" io has already stated
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1897-01-27
~ y
s.orse tn, TnIra a. .x,...,.


10 THE EDITOR OF TnE suy.-Sir; Our Am.
or,,"N o' AZ the Court Of st. James and other
s~o' credit and renown who nave afflicted
h,vAl world with twaddle about an alliance
~" The two AnGlo-Saxon nations" are
,,k., a.Nuaws strutting in peacocks' feathers
III from the address made by King George
'ne Hon John Adams shortly after the
,n.,o 'ho Revolution, when a treaty OF COM
w,.a was under consideration. His Majesty
st'ae'ously pleased to observe:
In. n",H me Americans show a disposition 10 give mo
the "''srence' III n at that moment / shall say let
iapvu,aa circumstance OF blood, religion. and
-ssu'Se ave their fulI weight"
Ihackeray said.
No mortal ever hoard b
Any good OF George the Third"
,n,,t 20 That as 1t may. George the Third IL
T'"'a To credit for the origin Of the keynote OF
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1897-01-27
roo ILL TO BE EVTCTED.
Police Persuade Mrs.. Moeven TO Let T-aut-
folder stay . While.

John Trautfcider. n peddler Of l5e johnson
avenue. wnliamsburHh, owed 81 to his land
lady, Mrs. Margaret Hoevcn. for rent. Ie be-
came III three weeks age, and being unable to
pay 1t. Mrs. Hoeven began dispossess proceed
ines. On Monday afternoon = city marshal
went to Trautfelder's room to dlsposssss him.
Mrs. Trautfelder had Just returned from a cor
ner grocery where she was successful In bog.
cling for a pail of coal. When the marshal
began 20 carry out tho fnmilv's things.
Mrs. TrAutfeldcr took her two children. re-
spectiyely q years and I weeks old, to the Stage
street police station, whore she begged the
police rot to permit tho marshal to eviet her
husband. Sergeant Ruthcnberg went to Traut-
field rooms and prevailed on Mrs. Hoeven not
10 put out the sick man. Trautfeldcr was left
lying on two boards, with n soap box for n pill
low. Tho marshal took a stnvo back to tho
peddler's kitchen. The sergeant then took M
n subscription among ncighbOrs, and tho Traut-
felders were provided with food and fuel. They
will move into other rooms to-day.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1897-01-27
O,cott Name. IN. New Deput,c..

District Attorney olcott announced yesterday
the appointment Of the three deputy assistants
named by TnE Sun last Friday-Henry Hard.
wicke, Otto A. Rosalsky. and Antonio c.. Asta-
rita, They will take olllce on Feb. l.. All are
Republicans. ltnsalsky Is a resident OF the
Eighth assembly district, which he represents
in the Republican County Committee. Astarita
rcsid es in the twenty ninth. both were recon-
mcnded for appuintment by the Republican
Gently moved into the I wcnty-hfth bly,
district. Ito Is tho personal choice VI tho Dis
trict Attorney,
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1897-01-27
NATE TROUBLES ~ tine WEsT.
The $500" Lines Cut VIII Re Met by
Some or the Western Road.

CHICAGO, Jan. 90, The 500" limo tariff on
merchandise west from New York, and about
which there has been much discussion for tho
past ten days by the Western lines, is to so into
effect on Jan. 80. A conference was held yes
tcrday between the ChlcnGo-St. Paul roads and
the 800" officials, Mt which an attempt was
made to persuade General Manager Underwood
10 Withdraw the disturbing tariff. He, how
ever. gave notice that his people could not SEQ
their way clear to taxing such action. and IL
Central and the Chicago Great Western roads
Immediately gave notice that they would meet
the cut OF tho 800" and put into effect like
tariffs on tho same date. II was then agreed
that Chicago 81. Paul lines should hold another
conference on Monday next at which the mat
Ter will he further cOnsid cred and some action
taken 10 meet the SuO's" cut.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1897-01-27
Sole E~storfrt:

Sole Exporters:
THE APOLLINAR/S CO., Id.
See that the Label bears the
weli-known RED DIAMOND Mark Of
THE APoLLINARIs COMPANY. Id.
EMPLOYED at Bellevue Hospital,
German Hospital, Gouverneur Hospital.
Harlem Hospital, Hospice F%raocais, Hos
pitaI for the Ruptured and Crippled,
New York Polytechnic Hospital, New York
Post-G graduate Hospital, St Luke's Hos
pital St Elizabeth's Hospital. St. Fran
cis's Hospital. ST. Marks Hospital, St.
Nncents Hospital. etc, and at the lead
ing HOSPITALS Of ENGLAND.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1897-01-27
40 Hurry About Such . Treaty.

To THE EDITOR OF The suS-Sir Your dis
,o,.,y in regard TO the arbitration treaty 40 An
.,,r. judicial assumption Of power. denied
.ren TO the Supreme Court IL worthy the at
tention OF all.
why this haste to ratifyi 1s II all for the pub
lie good The English Premie says that the
treaty will stop all future jingoistic outbursts,
Nj. Cievelaud's only meritorious public act.
Why did they make the term Ave yearss
Can II be that there is a subtle reason. such
p,rhaps rs binding Mr.. McKinley's hands as
regards Englandr
II analogy is needed, did not Mr.. Cleveland
attempt to extend the influence OF his Admins
,s,ion by cleaning out" the Republicans.
appointing ducklings In their places. and then
shutting them in By q general civil service
reclamation
Can il be. after all. as Major Mckinley ex-
meets. that this arch-priest OF Anglo worship
thinks that the American people. who have
be.n so long outraged by his image. will look
ipdulgently toward Princeton four years hence
Nv ali means kill this treaty. or At least let
friend. Of America draft a substitute.
hPeacc and friendship Pretty terms But not
40 noble when. the curtain drawn aside, john
enthusiastically 10 revealed. and up his
,lseye Is seen the trump card OF more trade"
ARTHUR NDA STEARNs.
CHICAGO. Jan. "a.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1897-01-27
More Bunsias strihss.

Building strikes were ordered yesterday by
the Board OF Watkins Delegates in behaifof the
plasterers' Laborers' Union. Tho strikes are d.
rec,ed against Contractor Hartly and Hoig
brothers. who. IL 10 alleged. pay 25 cents n day
less than the union rate of wages. Among tho
buildings involved are . new church In 10Th
street, near the Boulevard. the Teachers Nor
nal College in io0th street. and a nsw building
In Seventeen street. between Madison and Fifth
nyenueA
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1897-01-27
SENT 4 TRAIN FOE THE WOUNDED.
A SIeighing Party Thrown Over aa Eo-
hAAk u Dozen Persons Hurt.

bAakn u Dozen Persons Hurt
ALTOONA. Pa. Feb. 20.-Last night a party OF
about twenty young people who left Tyrone for
Union Furnace in q two-horse sleigh were pro-
cipitatcd over q stone wall fifteen feet high at
Pemberton. four miles east OF Tyrone. Tho
brake refused to work In descending a grade
and the sleigh careened over the wall, throwing
tho occupants To the river bank below.
The vehicle crashed down upon the party:
seriously injurinp the following; MISS Alice
ries; Miss Jessie Slower. Bellefontaine, o., chest
crushed: Eugene Crampton. Tyrone, injury to
spine; William Jones, Tyrone, driver Of the
team. hend injured and arm cut; Edward Levy.
Tyrone, body bruises: Howard Tompleton. Ty-
rome. Commissions OF legs and chest.
When the news OF the accident reached Ty-
rome tho Pennsylvania Railroad Company sent
n special train TO the scene with physicians. Tho
Injured were placed on the train and taken 70
Tyrone,
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1897-01-27
dicasss the character Of the Canadian Pacific ..

dicaess the character Of the Canadian Pacific IS
q competitor.
The Union Pacific 4. indebted to the Govern
mont over and above its sinking fund for $780,
o00. 000. II has certainly lost that sum during
the last ten years from competition with the
Canadian Pacific. The Republican Club OF Now
York at its last regular meeting adopted a reso-
luton demanding the abrogation OF the bonding
regulations under which Canadian railways are
enabled to carry State-t Estate traf1c. IL other
clubs would do likewise they would render a
service to American railways.
1.-THE. Government demands Its pound Of ffesh
of the Union Pacific IL should exert all lawful
and honorable means TO protect it's trsf1c In the
future. FRANCIS WAYLAND GLEN.
IAN. Oh. 1907.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1897-01-27
Esffmdfsd Cost
annua, addltfon oJNep Buildings.
ray ssspg,,.sSt' Buiid'n0 p.na,t,snt

,lnn n London County Council adopted q resolu-
OF InfSiiihg ne Increased land value for the cost
mon psGG.o improvements. The House OF Com.
ths favored na the measure. but II was vetoed by
own.,s ut Lords, composed mainly OF land.
Nav VINO deemed 1t better tina the general
rs,b.ut taxpayers be burdened with the cost,
ben.ss, man pay II themselves out Of the added
W.assusnl improvements secured TO them.
IN ",ate not hindered by such an impeachment
ren tt.pg,ess, and when the home owners and
thsy IN discover what 10 best for their interests,
ana %hn.uo what the Mayor thinks 10 now done,
do. nsat,he London County Council desired to
cost ~ " m mel make the benehciaries pay tho
bel, an, eeuouc improvements. by assessing tho
., Their lands, and exemptins ali private inn.
w" ioRK, Jan. 30.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1897-01-27
A Bui for a New Coun,y JAN Here.

ALRAsy, Jan. ~. -AssemblymAn Charles S.
Adler OF New York introduced to day a bill for
new buildings In place OF the Essex Market
Court and the Ludlow street jail. 1t names
the Mayor. tho Recorder. the Comptroller. tho
sheriff, and the President OF the Charities De-
artme rs n commission to select n site for
the new building in tho Eighth Assembly dis
trict, aud authorizes them to appoint three
Commissioners for condemnation proceedings.
II authorizes the Commissioners to offer prizes
fI the best Ave plans submitted for the build
inpa.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1897-01-27
Trust Investigators Named.

ALRANy. Jan. col Lieut.. Gov, Woodruff has
appointed Senators Lexow OF Rockiand and
Parsons OF Rochester, Republicans, ard Gala
CHER of Brooklyn. Democrat, as tho members to
represent tho Senate on the joint committee
witch Is to investigate trusts in accordance
with tho IeXow resolution.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1897-01-27
Kinsssrisse Extension I.v.us.

Following the decision OF tho Appellate Divi-
sion OF the Supreme Court, Justice Smyth. in
the Supreme Court Yesterday. set aside As In
valid tho purchase by tho Third Avenue Rail-
road Company Of tho Kingsbridge extension.
The Appellate Division held that because more
than one extension was contem plated in tho
franchise IL was invalid. aud Justice Smyth
follows this up In his decision by stating that
the company purchased tho franchise knowing
that the consent Of tho Board of Aldermen
under which tho sale was made WAS invalid.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1897-01-27
WESTMINSTER Ii. Orange suspended.

weIghmAster for the Fire Department Louis
la Grange was formally suspended from duty
az a special meeting OF the Board NJ Fire Com
miss!nnerr yesterday on a charge Of neglect or
duty In relation to the Weighing ~ coal for the
department. La Grange Will DO brought before
the board on trial. He Is n brother OF Fire Com
missioner La Grange.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1897-01-27
TOPICS OF THE DAY.
MOVE $40 WIZ.
.-.o.,,.,ou for n. Arbitration Treaty.

-. nfFAnInu -
r. rpr EDITOR OF THE sUN-Str: The arbi-
.-.,,on treaty ought TO DO rejected because IL
e..tsns greatly our position with reference 10
se~,.nd. and by so doing invites rather than
h".,.n,s dangerous complications between tho
,vo countries.
--,.r bonds to keep the peace with Us. inc
s.ns,r OF provoking war with America, conse-
u.snt,v afording an opportunity for the az
eus..,ons Of England's European rivals and
.,,mies. tends to make that country extremely
ue.,,, in It's dealings with us. II cannot
.Sord a quarrel with America, for that
"..,a invite an assault by those covers
:, british possessions which would en-
,.sr the integrity Of the British empire.
", saw how 1t was In tue case OF .ehehueia'
w. rnplapd backed out ~squarely after a rude
N..a,ns from US. Let the situation remain as
NJ. and peace is better assured than II could
\. by any arbitration treaty.
vn,eoyer. English investments in this coun-
- are enormous. Practically there are no
'm.,iean investments In England. Nor Is
a.. any chance that We will make aggressions
y r,sland. for we arc not like her. . bullying
80, seeking territorial ACKNOWLEDGMENT In
y, a,rsctions. The aggrossions will all come
,,om england: and our only care IL to stop
ham so far rs our rights are concerned.
Hence. there 10 no occasion for the arbitration
,,,.,v. It will provoke trouble rather than
sonduce to peace. by destroying the present
,,rv fortunate advantage enjoyed by American
,,,,r,,ts, with the proposed arbitration Eng
land could 70 ahead with Its usual and general
roley otaggression. taking the chances OF gain
,,om us BY referring Its claims to . tribunal Of
Abstraction dominated by a European influence
..,o,ah,, TO her, NASSAU.
NEW vuRH. Jan. 20.
The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1897-01-27
B-oohiy. Girls High sshee e~-.a..ts.,

Tho lis graduates Of the Girls High School
IN Halsoy street Brooklyn. had their Com
menccment exercises last night, and an I'm.
mense audience was present to greet them.
There w-rs II Of them In the commercial
course. 81 In the English. and 80 In languages.
Miss Helen VI. Wright delivered the snlutatory
and Mas Annie Holbrook Duncan was the val
edlctoriAn. Chairman Nelson J. Gates OF tho
School Committee presented tho diplomas and
DIR, James NJ. Taylor. President OF NAssar Col
lego made tho address TO tho graduAllnR olasa.