New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1896-03-11

that by its passage we will lose the offices OF GOV
error and United States Senator and help 10
defeat the candidate for President. aithoueh
there do not seem to be many candidates ioi
these offices in the Democratic party
SENATOR PAvEY's SPEECH
In the course of his speech, Senator Pavey
laid:
My reasons for opposition to this measure are o.
First-It is plain violation OF the simplest pfin-
cples of home rule in municipal an hc proceeds OF
Second--It appropriates one-thiTu the 1i,uts 4,
a tax collected from local business ana d,S I'VE, The
into the r saT 2qice the
OF it. no sufficient Justification for TINS gran None
revenue from the large cities mas oee'' gwen
Thrd establishes as gsansaG p pary stands
pledged to take the saloon out OF politics ,o,,cs
about to drag the saloon deeper IN n' DO So be-
cause the machine leaders Of the Republican Pa par
believe that they can l. @s1tan their grip
81 the party MACHINE for years eD this bill
is Opposed Sy the s sre m any nHa way
connected with the liquor trade the res'anrass s ara
hotel-keepers, grocers and merchants rs SI
ported solely by the Whskey Trust and the machine
:sa a no s se d RSpqTaa defeat
se of tni S to on
jet They have been Gagged in caucus and hi iSs
o osr e %ho A2a false
auduent aPpsa 0 psS Il has been bee in
dorsed by any Republican State Convention, II
has the Official ssnc9n Of the ,b Repu9nean
nent Of enough Republican county conventions 10
give majority OF the Republicans in NOR ,n nnS ober
candidate OF the Republican party at the iast eeco
p r,So to election None would have dared do
lisa Senate caucus measure soiely because J.. ma
been made so by the mutual agreement OF a na1oly
he REM members.
Judgment or conscience or party ioyalty OF any ne
stnnv NJ his ssreptabe piece Of legislation
which is to be saddled the Republican party by rs
dominant bosses. is dsgraceful can only appeal pea
to the fairness of the people OF the state 10 as
crminate between the party and the men. 10 snow
n snae APP nj who vote for this
when they come before them as ana
candidates Of the party
THE VOTE TAKEN AT LAST :
On Senator Ellsworth's motion the debate
was closed by a vote Of "a 20 IA, the Democrats
in the negative. Senator G. A. Davis. or Erie
not voting. and Senator Weman. of Kings
being absent Votes were then taken on the
amendments offered by the Democratic Sena-
tors Senator Cantor's amendment that the
cities retain the whole of the excise tax except /
the cost of collection first put and was
lost-lS to 81. Senators Coggeshall u; a. DaNis,
PaveS and Sebert voting with the Democrat
ment that separate and cheaper beer ana
wine license be issued was lost-5o 10 L.
CoggeshaI G. A. Davis and Pavey voting win
the minority, and Daley, Seibert and Wlemah
not voting. =. - . ,,.
Senator GUYS amendment that the twenty
third and Twenty fourth wards or New ork
City be designated towns to come under
the town license fees was lost viva voce Sena-
tor Guys amendment that the special deputies
appointed under the bills must be residents OF
the localities in which they serve was lost
to Ex-senator Pavey Tatmg with the minority
and Coggeshall Daley and Weman not voting.
An amendment offered by Senator McCarren
that aIl-night licenses be issued TO places o.
amusement at an additional charge OF Aoo was
lcst-S2 to-14 Seibert voting with the minority
Coggeshan Guy. White and Wieman not voting
Another amendment by Senator McCarren pro
vidinp that license fees be not exacted from
clubs was also 1osl--35 to 14-Payey and Seiberi
voting with the minority, Guy, Cantor ana Suhl-
van voting with the majority. Senator McCar-
rem offered third amendment. that the annexed
district Of Brooklyn be subject 10 the same
Incense fees as towns 1t was lest, viva voce
fhe bin was then put on final passage without
any amendments and was passed, 81 10 H. Seha-
tor Wieman absent and not voting. senators u
A. Davis and Seibert, OF Erie, and f. D. PaVeE'
of New-York, Republicans, and Senator Cogge-
shall of Oneida voted with the Democrats
against the bill. The vote on hnai passage was
as follows: ~,
Ayes al.antine. Bracket. Brown, Brush Burns'
Chahoon Daley c. Davis Ellsworth. Ford Harr-
son Hgbie. Hiegns Humphrey Johnson, Rum na
Lamy Lexow, Maby, Mullin Nussoauln, rage
Parsons Raines Sheppard. Stewart Stranahan
Tibbi,s White, Wilcox 5Wray.
Noes-Ahearn Cantor. Coffey, Coggesha.i u a.
Davis Featherson, Foley, Gallagher, Grady. Guy
Koehler, Martin McCarren. McNuhy, Munzihger
Pavey. Sebert and sullivan.