The Hawaiian gazette., 1896-07-24
OPINION OF The COURT BY JUDD
c J. (Frsar. !. dissenting.

c J. lFrsGr, J.. 6iSSsntingl-
At The term OF this Court held in
September. 1895. in everything de-
mu-rsr ws decided many points Of law
raised snG sent The case back 70 the
Circuit Court. First Circuit for trial
The c&S5 came or for trial in Deem
bsr last before Circuit Judgs MagoOr,
jury being waived. who, on January
-Ch las-. 6le5 his decision 6is&ll0wirS
the principal sum sued Tor, but giving
Judgment for the annual payments
STIPULATED 70 Dc in lisa Of interest The
contract sued upon : 81 agreement n
v-lclcE. made IN -SS1. between me lGLs
Doc-or TruuSSs&u and the plaintiff who
gas alleged 70 be his separated vile,
b. which DOc-o- T-OuSSsau defend
ants 6sceGsnyl aGEicrsd IS absolutely
co-Cse- The claims a1d demands proved
h. Madame TrC-SSsGu On The 18th
Nz-cE -SSz amounting 70 l52. So
francs z1t 81 Cs1Cns>. Of which he en-
gzssE 70 paw Immediately 2Q,ld3 francs
and also On the -Sc January Of each year
thereafter. beginning January l. 1854
s sum equal 10 5,Gl9 francs 70 b re-
uitsei by the French Consul 10 Madame
T-U-S>szU- u Paris. and 70 o regarded
Is interest On the capital remaining OF
$50 IS francs ScG - CslcLDeS. Mons
T-OGsS5Gu then engaged. II his cir
Cc-S-accss slow and as soon - they
allow him. 70 discharge The total
2EC-c- Of his Gsb- 20 Madame TrOuS-
ssGu- by paying over 10 her the capital
which VII remain due 10 her There
i also 3 provision thar as soon IS
this capital L reduced 70 10000 francs
the azzrzI sun Of 5000 francs settled
IS above vLIl decrease in proportion Is
the -O-sI debt i exCI-Euishsi- &c
Aco-E5- provision : that IS SCO1 Is
TIE frs IuS-zIlusrC Of Z16ial francs :
paid N46sus Truussssu was 70 Gtsco1-
-iEus : case then pending IL or Court
GEzI1S- Doctor Tr'1usSs2C for : larger
zEGCcr This sun ~as paid and The
case was iiSe0--trusil The last pro
vision = that The articles Of agreement
SE0-IG De performed IN good faith by
bo-E parties and IN The event Of non
payment o any OF the SUNS mentioned
g The date %Ez- Il falls due. Madame
TrU-SsssE vii b 81 lihs-5y 70 rsceE
proceedings mon the mere information
vEz-E SHAH have been s5Vs1 10 hs- ty
TIE Ers-tE Consul q Honolulu that
Ire SUI q E0-sr has C0- bee1 paid Il
tEs 6z-s VIXEN Il falls G-a CTLz eg-se
Dzcr : SCI O-- n full II T-u1SSsGu =
-CC-ssszu ~ Eaw -} ne z-zEzI
r1y-sz-s OF :, 600 francs vsce regular
II uz6e mil Isl lamar 1854 bit
E1zs vas 2zi5 hereafter and 10 part
OF the principal was paid hF Doctor
T-U-sssGC during his lifetime
n order 20 S-s-ztr tEs conditional
r-u-iss q D. Tr0uss5aU that he would
pay he principal sE- If his ei-Cuu-
S-zCEeS allowed hin and Is son 3
CEsE allowed Kim Chs pIzfutzE intro
C-.eC = svitszce O his ability 70 pzT
the principal sun su=i fC- EticE r.
6Ccs6 troo trz1es 70 dollars L szsI1z-
his IzS- vii and tss-z-s--- executed
MzrcE ; 1851 w1s-sL1 h devised 81
his property 70 0zs Mzkz10e- Z native
ECZzc- II =lic1 h declares Z die
pCC-- and an only s1-ry for tz- sake
- c=Tz- lad any love for C0zsT and
E'g--EK - F1rI Ttz-e wzS zrs1
LE--u--ezG i sFiLzz.s tze ezeeEtors-
L-Tz--C-T q EEz G=ce,-s--s u-u-er-T-
sE1E-E he liabilities F=s-red bz
E-EEz and c-1E-Tssf 70 he SIs-
S+3sL and LEz properly rszI and De-
sczz- ss-z-z-=S II Cr= sEs.z-1-s 70 b
EC-rE s-4CL- Wiz you'd leave tt=
Es- assets 70 - s1s.115-4a Ttz cosz O.
tE= G=-sG=z-s property K rC- aE rt=
zr=.E-0-s At SizsIT-sa. bC- hey est
rae me z.rEzI FzI1E % b. IS stated
sae-+E-
Tes rrLzI Court t=I5 that Is II wzz
-sE-rzE=-F U-cs--zfz Ete-tsr n sszzte
VII realize ttE expectation q n e.
ecu-c- scrE--ztzzst ssTErzI uCc-Es be-
tC-s CE= EsssCs tzTz beel CE-u=5 Ecr1
cz1 h co1lt III ElFs Z Gs-L=i01
bass- E-1- sch -=s-T--11T- zc5 ttE-s-
E1-E GzcE-a5 70 Ezz far -hE gIzfr-IE
tn E-In-E1GI sUD- b-1 sTh1E=E rhs AZ
rsGrS a Tia F5ariF in=-EII-=1E q 500
trzz.cs- Tia s1 q s1I5sIs- rs pay
Ezzr Mt tez-= cs5zl55i-lzT-=11 rr,5z ability
70 EaF- -hz 7EzfztI= eLEeg-z 10 thu
Ezz1E q The Cs1--- = GEszEL1Tl-E ira
r-LEi-lCaI S@ N -sT5E=I-E this ezsz
W -@-E rhzr ths Erzzl CourL vas
rEr = t151Eg that TIE p-u-tze q
q Try-sS5zE % raw tEz r-LzsEiuaI VS.
ri zhss1lzzz- On vas cs1zzz-5o1=st EDo1
tS Cr-C-=-zEess zIi1FEg lin % pzF
T. al tEzE zh[E-F ID FaT ElI b
sECEC - F-E-Es-ZzzL-E 70 ressJFE-T-
B- L s=sEz ID u ttEE EE= rial Cozzr-
prucses-EE EEoz Ih= IhsoET Tat Ira
r=s- Of -Es z5EIE-F q z Tr1ZLszs7r WIN
las zh=1 10 paF Il tie 4-1I1r q a.
s=-s EE5.h L. nay hzFVe7 u I=zFE Al
hz Eza-E Ills L 1T EhE test Th=
1LzE1-z= EE=z EECT EEzE EhE ET1ziE-
ss1rTs ez-rs-zz-zzcss zLs1EEsz E7 u pGF-
CErrzfzIF thz sxEEzEzEs q dear zsserz.
oz= al EzbEIfzh=s sa@e5scE u Ghz
sEzrgE III Ehnls z1cE- world y
sT51s1sts- hE- the e1nssrSs Z noC -us