Evening journal., 1896-02-13


had hold OF his feet2, mo. cir"
Didn't you say before the coroner's
Jury that they took him into the bath
room, and that he was on the floor when
Lynch came inf' mo sir.
Mark that, Mr. Hardesty. Didn't
you also state that you didn't know
whether they laid him down with violerce
or not. II can say that they dropped
him and the man fell heavy. didn't ssy
that they didn't drop him heavily"
"Dldut you stats at the corouer's in
quest that the only violence Lynch used
WAS In taking PlsR's coat Off" no sir
don't recollect ever having said any
such thing"
Didn't you ans yer thatg' mo, Sir. 4"
"How was Pisa put In the bath -tubl"
81 showed you once
"Well, you can do 70 again "He laid
over on his left side Lynch ard Brown
threw nim into the b. tub"
ANY one elssg' No, sir; didn't see
any body else
"whers were your "oataide, In the
hall.
'Dld any body else touch himi' ~
didn't see anybody. There was nobody
In the bathroom but DR. Clayton, Lynch,
Brown, swan and Pisa.
Did Brown aud Lynch touch him2
"Swan didn't and Harry Clayton dida't.
"Did you say anything when they put
him IN the tub2" when | aeen Mike
Lynch put him in. said. My God Look
at the way thsy are using that poor
individual.
"Dld you say that before or after
Lynch called him a cd d--d crRnkf'
AFTER they threw him In Lynch said
He amt anything but a Cd id
crank auyhow.' 1t waa after that that
| spoke"
Then why did you state at the
Bayard Building that you spoke nrstR"
II didn't say anything to any body. |
only iuss spoke to myaelt.
Didn't you state at the Bsvard Build
ing that you said Ny God look AZ
that; Ein't that brutalit,l' aud that
Lynch then said, He Is nothing but &
| Cd id crang. anyhow" II said
what ! said now said It to myself and
not to anybody outside, because what
/ would / say It TO any body fort'
II ask you whether yau said that first
or Lynch spoke hrstf' Lynch spoke
first !"
"Thsn you didn't say It to anybOdyg' p
"No sir"
"Then you didn't say itf Did you ray
anythingg when they threw him into
the tue said, My God look how they
are using this poor Individual >
ITO whom did you say itG' ITO
"Then You never said tf" 81 said II
to myself aud II any body had been
around they could have heard It.
"Did you not state under oath at the
Bayard Building. 1 was outside the docI
and said. MY God look at that; Amt
that brutality"
Mr.. Coopsr-'1 object He has asked
that question over and over again
Mr.. Hayes-No; theHe are different
words"
The court overrulsd the obi lction.
"Dld you say thatf "Yea slr.
Then when did you say ths otherl
(Which othef2' Laughter
"You say here Ia your testimony TO.
day that you said, Ny God lock at the
way they are using that poor individual.
and then at the Bayard Bnildlng you
said, My God look st that; Amt that
brutality p" Il said, Ny God. look al
the way they are using that poor IN
fortunate individual"
"You put In unfortunate now, see
Why didn't you state that before this
ccrouers juryg" "Dldn't /
II ask you why you didn'ti'."l am SURE
/ did"
"WAs Pisa thrown down or did hs fall
down In the bathroom2" "H5 couldn't
fall down II he wasn't strong enough tc
stand mp" Laughter
Il win ask you II they laid him down.
mo sir
Il will ask you II you did not say
before the coroner's jury that they laid
him down IA tho bathroomY They
carried him IN and laid him down. AL
the body seemed to strike the floor at
once
'Dld you not say TO DR.. HAnckor at
Farnhurst, II you discharge me will
make 10 hot for you ard show up th'
institution "No cir "
Now l will ask you whether you did
not hit Pisa behind the the right ear, 10
the day room about a week bsfore his
death aud in the presence Of Shields aud
Mr.. Coopar-"we object. That ha'
nothing to do With this cass.
Oskes waved the Bible aloit and zald
II will take ny solemn oath that
didn't"
Chief Justice Lors-"s,opl stop
siop " has nothing to no With tbs
case. We arc not trying the witness
but the prisoners 81 the bar.
"Where we're you when they put bin
In the bathtubf' 81 was out IN the hall
about three fest from the bathroom
door"
In Mr. Wards Hnnds.
Mr. Hayes then turned him over {
Mr.. Wald who examined him with spscla
reference to the participation Of Brow
and Swan, his clients.
There was no trouble In taking Pls
down the hallwayf' mo, sir.
"Dld you have hold OF Pisa when thi
trip was given hlm2' II was slongsid
Of him. had a hold Of his hand whel
the trip was given him
HAD Pisa struggled just before th
! asylum trip was given hlm2' "No, sir
, l never saw the trip until I went
Farnhurst Brown frequently used It o
man named joseph Mcdowell In hi
room.
: "Dd Pisa move his legs or armsi
"No. sir.
:. Were his legs straight or double
Q up2' "1'hey were straight, didn't Sc