davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
Richmond dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1884-1903, 1896-12-23
Mr.. Wcrfhnm's Denth,

The death of Mr.. Edwin Workman last
Sunday was a great shock to his many
friends. Mr.. Workman had only been
confined to the house for few days and,
though his health had been failing for
some time. his condition was by no means
regarded as serious.
Mr.. Workman was an earnest Chris
tian gentleman. For many years he had
been a Jealous member of the First Bap-
fist church ana Sunday school. SO re-
served was he, outwardly, that only those
who knew him NEST intimately were
able 10 appreciate his sterling worth.
He was a man OF brilliant intellect and
the highest principles.
For many years he had been book
keeper for the Il. c. Williams Company,
and had the fullest confidence OF his en-
ployers. He was ever faithful in the
discharge of his duty in all things. His
wife, who is daughter OF the late Rich
ard Fuller. Of Caroline county, and one
son, Edwin WORKMAN, Jr., survive him.
Richmond dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1884-1903, 1896-12-23
TEN YEARS FOR MURDER.
Hubbard Case Tried In the Hastings
Court-Sufts and Judgments.

William Hubbard. the negro man who.
on the 10Th Of last August. slew Charles
Robinson, another negro. by striking him
on the head with a piece OF iron. was
tried in the Hastings Court yesterday
on the charge OF murder His case con-
sumed the entire day. The accused was
represented by Messrs Barrow & How
ard. while Mr.. ID. c. Richardson repre-
sented the Commonwealth A number
OF witnesses were examined, and there
were able arguments On both sides. The
jury, however. after being out only a
short time brought i'm verdict OF
Guilty OF murder In the second degree"
and fixed Hubbard's punishment at ten
years I'm the penlteutlary. The prisoner
was sentenced at once
The following marriage licenses were
issued by the Clerk OF the Hastings Court
yesterday: Henry V. h. Moore and Fam
ME $. Dickerson; Julien c. Anderson and
Helen ID. Williams.
The jury I'm the case cf r. f.. Shores
against the Chesapeake and OHIO Rali-
way Company rendered "A very peculiar
verdict yesterday. This was a suit for
$4,000 damages. for personal injuries re-
ceived by the pialntin in being crippled
up in an accident on the Chesapeake and
Ohio. The jury after carefully weigh
ing the testimony. brought in n verdict
for the defendant company, but along
with IT was a communication, signed by
all the jurors asking Mr. Henry +.
Wickham, general counsel for the Cnesa-
peake aud Ohio. TO use his influence 10
secure the plaintiff position on the road.
as compensation for the injuries sus-
tanned by him in an ACCIDENT, which was
no fault OF his. The jury also commend-
ed young Shores very highly, and the
case was concluded.
In the suit Of j. Lee Mosby against
the Chesapeake and Ohio Railway Com
pany. for $1,000 damages the verdict was
rendered for the defendant company.
Judgment was also awarded I'm the cass
NJ August Pohlig against the American
Plant Food Company. for 500.
Gilbert X Pollock qualified TO practice
law in this court yesterday.
Judge Witt yesterday appointed T.. J.
Mccarthy a justice OF the peace I'm Jack
son Ward. 10 succeed George F. Mountz,
resigned.
]. c. Lawton qualified as administrator
I'm the estate Of w. +. Lawton. deceased,
In the Chancery Court.
In the Circuit Court the following judy
ments were rendered In favor OF tho
plaintiffs: Joseph W. Laube against
John F. Walters for the sum % s7957;
Ulman. Boykin n Co. against Mrs. NJ.
S. Smith. for $3.50; A. Il. Lipscomb
against +. F. Carter. for $i75.
The following suit was also instituted:
Louis J. Powers Paper Company against
William H. Mattox Paper Company.
Damages, 500.
The jury adjourned for the term. i,
Richmond dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1884-1903, 1896-12-23
bible for Christmas Present.

The members OF Mr.. Frank T. Bates
class at Union Station Sunday school
on Sunday presented their teacher with
a very handsome oxford Bible as token
Of their love and esteem. The presentation
speech was made by Mr.. Elbin c. Folkes,
one OF the scholars. Mr.. Folkes in pre-
senting the gift, made very appropriate
speech stating that he knew of no one
VINO would prize the Bible more than MIR.
Bates, and that he hoped in years TO
come. when his locks were silvered and
his eyes were bedimmed. he would turn
the leaves OF this beautiful book and get
therefrom words of comfort that would
make his remaining days on earth nothing
but peace and happiness. Mr.. Bates was
too much overcome by surprise TO make
any lengthy talk, but responded in a
very brief but appropriate speech. There
are between twenty and twenty-five
young men in Mr.. Batess class.
Richmond dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1884-1903, 1896-12-23

attention OF the Surgeon, was instru-
mental in stamping 1t out entirely.
HEALTH AT THE FARM.
Looking to the farm as a sanitarlum.
I have increased the capacity of the
hospital there by adding a consumptive
ward where. with the advice Of the Sur
geon. | have sent such Of the sick as In
his judgment would be benefited. Quite
number have been transferred there.
greatly TO the relief of the hospital here.
As is shown by the report of the farm
surgeon. no case of typhoid-fever has oc-
CURED there.
RELIGIOUS INSTRUCTIONS.
Religious exercises have been held. as
heretofore. in both departments Sunday
morning and afternoon by volunteers to
whom | desire TO express my thanks.
Much that | have said in this report
need not have been written. were 1t in
tended for the eye OF your honorable
board only. or his Excelloncy the Cover
nor, as it has all been done with your
advice and approval, and ! hereby re-
turn thanks for the hearty cooperation
which you have uniformly given to my
effort TO make this the best institution of
its kind. Respectfully submitted.
y. w. LYNN,
Superintendent Virginia Pententiary.
Some Interesting Figures Given.
Accompanying the reports given above
Is this statement, containing some very
interesting figures:
Average number of convicts i'm
prisoned during the fiscal year. 1,G3
Net gain for the year.............. 10
| Comparative Statement for 1895. 1896.
Number Of conviets re-
celNed ..................... Jf 6lS
Cost Of bringing convicts
to the penitentiary and
transportation TO their
homes for those who
were discharged ....... $l2,1s0 @ s, 222 81
Cost Of bringing convicts
to the penitentiary un-
der act of Assembly APP
proved January 30. 1896,
and which was i'm opera
tion during the last
seven months Of the fis-
cal year. including trans
portation for discharged
cOnvicts covering the
same period ............. S.1S Al
Cost Of the same for the
corresponding months OF
1895, under the old law. 6,SGS 81
New convicts:
Married ................... ........ Is,
Single ............. .................. AZ
Read and write .................. 30i
miterate .............. ......... IA
Average term. years months.
Average age. - years Si2 moaths.
Life prisoners:
W hltt men s......s.s.....s........
tOlOred men .......................
Richmond dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1884-1903, 1896-12-23
RICHMOND TOBACCO MARKET.

Richmond. Va, December o. 1896.
No auction sales on Change to-day
Private sales: Filters. 81; wrappers, 10;
dark leaf. u; Tugs, 5; western, >. Total.
"a hogsheads.
Revenue collections: Cigars and cigar
cites. S,1H.17 tobacco, Sl,3l235. Total,
S5,455.52.
Dark loose sales amounted TO only 49,
rs pounds to-day, and 10 l-2c. highest
price. Sales, If any at all. will be ex-
tremely small I'm darks. as no wagons
have yet come I'm thus far.
Bright sales were very large to-day at
Planters Davenport's, and Shelburne's
warehouses, and prices ruled strong on
all grades. Some, very fine crops were
sold, among them being that of Mr.. +.
NJ. Rawlings. who always has good to-
bacco. This gentleman was on sale, and
was well pleased with prices. Large
sales tomorrow.
Messrs. r. NJ c. Glenn. Of South Bos-
ton. Va, and Frank Coleman, of VIM
ston. were here to-day.
Richmond dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1884-1903, 1896-12-23
Christmas at the westmoreIand.

Members OF the Westmoreland Club
who may wish 10 invite a guest TO the
Christmas-ENe entertainment are earn
estly requested TO send In the name OF
the gentleman whom they may wish in
vlted to the secretary to-day, as 1t will
be impossible for him TO send out the
cards Of invitation the day Of the en-
tertanment, and the card will have TO
be shown at the door.
Richmond dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1884-1903, 1896-12-23
CfviI-seryice Examination.

The United states Civil Service Com
mission will hold an examination In this
city on Tuesday. February %. for tho
grades OF clerk and carrier in the post
Office service. Only citizens OF the United
States can be examined. and applications
must be made before Wednesday. January
18th. at the post-otiice.
The age limitations for this examina-
ton are: For clerk. is years or over. and
for letter-carrier. over Il years and un-
der 40. Male applicants who are under 5
feet 4 inches in height. or less than 125
pounds in weight. cannot be accepted for
the positions OF clerk or carrier.
Richmond dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1884-1903, 1896-12-23

The funeral OF Mr.. John w. Beveridge.
whose death occurred at his home. No.
lO7 east Clay street, Sunday afternoon.
took place from ST. Marks church yes
terday at noon. The last sad rites were
impressively performed by Right Rev.
Bishop Penick, in the presence OF large
congregation. The interment was IN
Hollywood.
Richmond dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1884-1903, 1896-12-23
LONDON MONEY MARKET

LONDON, December 2.-Bar silver.
% 7-Sd Consols, 10 1916 for money, and
Ill lilo for the account.
Richmond dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1884-1903, 1896-12-23
GRAM AID COTTON EXCHANGE.

Richmond. Va, December p. 1896.
Quotations: Wheat-Longberry ~ TO
DC; mixed. 81 to Soc; shortberry. - to
Sc; No. red, "a to Soc. Corn-White
Virginia. &C: No. white, &c; No. 2
mixed q - to 2Sc. Oats-No. 2 mixed,
winter seed oats. 80 10 36c. Rye, 80 TO 43c.
Richmond dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1884-1903, 1896-12-23
BONDS
Alaoams (Clas A, .
BALTIMORE STOCK MARKET.

BALTIMORE. MD. December o.
Virginia Century bonds. q 3-4d62: Baltl-
more and Ohio "a; Northern Central, 81;
Gas, stocks, 60 IL.
Richmond dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1884-1903, 1896-12-23
MARINE INTELLIGENCE.

PORT OF RICHMOND, DEC. q. iSs-
ARRIVED.
Steamer Virginia. Porter. Baltimore,
merchandise and passengers; Baltimore
Steam-Packet Company.
steamer Poclhontas Graves, Norfolk.
merchandise ana passengers; Virginia
Navigation Company.
SAILED.
Steamer Winyah. Simmons. Philadci-
phia. merchandise and passengers; J. w
McCarrick, agent.
Steamer Virginia. Porter. Baltimore.
merchandise and passengers: Baitimocs
Steam Packet Company.
Schooner William III. Kensee. Soper.
Jersey city: railroad ties.
Schooner Samuel Hart. Hart. Norfolk,
coal; vessel, ID. O'Sulliyan.
PORT OF NEWPORT NEWS. DEC. ga.
usy teiegraph.)
ARRIVED.
British steamship Ludgate. New Or.
leans.
SAILED.
British steamship Calvin. Baltimore.
British steamship Ludgate. Hamburg,
Richmond dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1884-1903, 1896-12-23
MARKET QUOTATIONS.
REPORTS FROM ALL GREAT DUsI-
NESS CENTRES OF THE WORLD.
Prices of Money, bonds, stocks,
Grain, Tobacco, Cotton, Cattle.
Country Prodoce. &C.. Foreign
aud Domestic.
and Domestic.

NEW YORK, December 2.--After
weak opening and a fractional cecIine in
prices. stocks improved on covering OF
short contracts. The advance. outside Oh
Sugar. which moved up about point
was insignificant. The declaration OF the
usual dividends by the Lake Shore, Michl-
gan Central, and New York Central failed
to exert any influence on the market.
The reduction of the dividend on Canada
Southern, however. started selling
movement, which gathered force as the
day advanced. The bank failures at the
West also had n disturbing effect, and
timid holders cut down their lines. The
suspension of the Bank Of Minnesota, the
Oldest bank in st. Paul, announced short
Is after | o'clock, was followed by the
failure of the State Bank Of st. Paul and
the Union Stock-Yards Bank, of st. Paul.
The fact that the last two institutions
had been compelled to close up was not
generally known on the street until after
o'clock.
The bearish feeling on the market was
aggravated by rumors of reduction IN
the dividend OF the Delaware and Hudson
during the coming year, and to rumors
that the Long Island Company VIII pass
payments on its stock. In the past the
Delaware and Hudson has distributed ,
per cent. per annum and the Long lslahd
4 per cent. Manhattan's weakness was
attributed to liquidations, and the decline
in Sugar to the aggressiveness OF the
Arbuckles. Delaware and Hudson scored
..xrf.4 lAg- a nd - ny
cent. to III SIS. Long Island fell .; New
Jersey Central, AIS; Sugar, 81; Canada
Southern. 2l-2; Burlington and quincy
/ 49, Chicago Gas, II; st. PAU, ~;
Rock Island, 3-S; Consolidated Gas. IL
Louisville and Nashville. Is; Manhat-
tan. PA; Reading, /; Tennessee Coal
ia: Rubber, 1 5-S, and Western Union
Ia.
Speculation closed weak in tone. Net
changes show declines OF l-idl 10 per
cent, outside of Delaware and Hudson
Jersey Central, and Long Island, which
lost 31-Sa5 per cent.
Tobacco made an exceptional gain OF
per cent.
Considering the shrinkage in prices, the
dealings were comparatively small, foot
ing 10 only AIS shares, in which Bur
lington and Quincy figured for 900, SUI
gar for 23600. and st. Paul for l9WO
shares.
Bonds were quiet and steady. The sales
aggregated $4,000.
Treasury balances: Coin, Sl2l,27S,elS;
currency. S0,j2i,766.
MONEY AND EXCHANGE.
Money on call easy, at 1-2d2 per cent.
last loan at 2. and closing offered at :
per cent. Prime mercantile paper, l-2ai
Bar silver, 65 Is. Silver at the board
steady.
Sterling exchange weak, with actual
business in bankers bills at AS -2p
siss-4 for sixty days, and As1a4Sl Ii
for demand Posted rates. AS4 La ASS.
commercial bills. Sts2dA.S3.
Government bonds firm. state bonds
duu Railroad bonds easier.
STOCK QUOTATIONS.
Clo,ny Stocks ,
.ua-totn Cotton Ol.................-....-. ~
Richmond dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1884-1903, 1896-12-23
opening. nisnos- loves Closing.

Cash quotations: Flour quiet and easy;
hard wheat. sDriag patents, uDrNcO. III
wood: soft wheat, patents. $iGSilo; naru,
bakers, ssqxSo in SACKS; so,t %nsa.'
in wood. No spring wheat, JisQfl &c;
No. red. sSisQssyc. No. corn. zsAe;
10 oats. lsnpifc. Mess pork: $3.50
t.so. Lard, sS7sqS.Tis. short-rib sides,
Richmond dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1884-1903, 1896-12-23
RICHMOND STOCK MARKET

RICHMOND December %, 1890
sALEs.-4O shares Citizens Bank stock at
o6i6: IL shares Virginia Fire and Marine stock
at3t
New-York tribune., 1896-12-26
THE STATE or FINANCES.

No one has vel been able 10 discover why Sec
retary Carsle's annual report was delayed ten
DAYS more or less. The story that illness of
exterts selected TO prepare certain figures de-
layed it was laughable. because there was moth
ing in the report which any fair expert could
not have prepared from the records in about on
hour. The best explanation is that the Secrc-
tary wanted TO see how certain Suggestions
struck the public mind, and If he waited for that
reason he might have toned down his report mn
,erially Presumably all sound-money men want
TO give Secretary Carlisle whatever credit they
can But it is the almost universal verdict that
he has not helped any cause for which he con
tends.
At the start. the attempt TO make il appear
that the existing tariff would yield sufficient
revenue was one Of those tactical blundcrs for
which there is no excuse Secretary Carlisle
had 10 reason whatever 10 sacrifice his own
financial reputation in trying TO make it appear
that the fariff of 1891, If let alone. would now
Weld $4,000 600 or Si0OO0OOO more than it
was expected tc yield before the income tax
was torn out of it by the Supreme Court. The
President had not approved it, and there was
no partisan reason for defending it. Yet Secre
tIfN aTllSie SutS III! OHu dll ldlI tAtuSe III up
holding this particular product Of Democratic
foollshness, as If it had never been denounced
by the President himself.
report which flies in the face Of the facts
after this fashion could not command confidence
in dealing with the more distinctly partisan
question of adjustment of tariff. At that point
also the Secretary was lamentably weak. 1t was
wholly unbusinesslike for him to assume that
the imports during the last few years afforded
any indication Of the course Of imports in years
Of fair prosperity. There was not the least oc-
casion to give himself away by any such sugges-
ton General differences drawn from the recent
imports have not substance enough to need close
examination. The statement that the progress
Of one form Of manufacture after another under
protective duties has placed it so far beyond the
reach OF foreign competition that II can thrive
without duties formerly needed for protection
is quite pleasing as an evidence from not
friendly source OF the beneiccnt influence OF
protective duties But practical men will wait
a little before concluding. with Mr.. Carlisle that
this progress renders protective duties unncces-
sary.
1t is pity that n man able to reason so far
seems incapable Of taking another step The
duties which suffice to stimulate an industry to
the utmost in one state Of business, as Mr. Car
Isle really ought to know. do not suffice at all
in a different condition. The range Of duties
New-York tribune., 1896-12-26
rOSTFRJNG ITALIAN COW WWEHtE l.

Jt,lv seons 10 have been intended by Iiiul'
Tn be /, commercial, nation AMI the present '"'
ornmcnt has set out Ia fulfil that destiny! II
fa voriuo LEGISLATION can accomplish H. n III"
has recently been enacted for the encourage
meut of shpbulding by means oi S!S'eN'
of Lourties arranged on Il most generous S'a'''
For every wooden merchantmen Dnll ID! III
Italian in ItaIy n bounty of So 30 ION VIII pe
,,iL and for every iron or steel ship SD !"
ION gross tonnage IN the latter case ~ leaS'
.l,ree-uuuricrs of the material must he oI i'ai
ian orioiu otherwise the bounty VIII ne re-
duc.d by 10 per cent. The boilers ana hi''-
,binery of steamships must also be OF l'hii'i'
mali. M the bounty will be reduced ny Id
,.r cont Rut If they are Of Italian make an
ex,ro hountv Of 81 90 quntal will b" paih
mn the boilers and 50 - Il horse power on the
machinery. ON auxiliary apparatus - ~
animal will be paid.
similar cncouropcment Is offered to naviga-
,,on bv means of an equally generous system
,r bouuties. from one item Of which we may
;udoe the whole 4 bounty Of III GEMS Il 'oii'
ornss Tonnage, is to be paid for every l.ooo
miles uavi.aicd in the first three years "l
v.ssers life This and the other raNi"atloh
hountics will. il Is expected. prove ~ b"nrii-
willsto the shlpbuiliers. and the wh"i" s'h'h'
will enable Italian shipping I" compete S"''
c.s>fully with that OF riVIl Iai,rs. ol course
something is required hy the Goy'rnhrht ~
return II 1, iu bc cpii'lr IL i!'e' "'iil-iii"N
uuou the vessels n ease ~ war. ""l"in.', "a
other extraordinary emergency, ar 40 nav
me roval l. all carried free of 'h..i Se. t'"'S'
r.uuirrmcnis are not likely. however. 10 prove
burJ.nso,ne: certainly not sufficiently >" !"
deter shipbuillcr> AID merchants from tah''S
,Jyantar. of the provision q; the act
The whole syst,n. r. "",aihtable WIN those
uudry hich other l. ..opcar Powers nav" "uii'
M and are maintaining ihcil commercial Heels
and it is reasonable To SUPPOSE lis effect III
Italy will be about The came ns elsewhere.
,,.b.r. will he "A considerable expansion OF the
Italian mercantile marine marking 'no'h'r
s,.n I'm the hot competition between III"
crowded and busy nations of the Old World.
Other nation. may mect it with other measures
for their own advantage. and 40 the strife VIII
On ON However desirable ir might he. iheo-
r.tIcallv. 10 do away with such systems u Is
evidently impossible, IN practice 10 do So ihe
unsnbsidlzed slipping Of one nation cannot
compete with the subsidized shipping or on
other and the prospect of Il UNIVERSAL agree
men, to dispense with subsidies and 10 equallZ"
wages prices of material. and all other fac
Tor, In the problem. Is far more visionary 'hah
one for universal disar'ning.
New-York tribune., 1896-12-26
Not CALLING NiUES.

Mr. Elias Cornelius Benedict. whose title to
fame has not hitherto rested on any cOnSpc-
uously Spartan resistance 10 political demands
upon the corporations with which he is connect
ed. but rather upon personal service TO "the
State" as personally embodied. appears pub
licly in opposition to cheaper gas rates on the
ground that the agitation Is simply part OF the
system of legislative backmail. the workings of
which are a matter of common but extremely in
definite knowledge Mr.. Benedict basing his
remarks on his information acquired as di-
rector in many corporations. says: "The gov
..ernment of this State is in the hands of three
"houses and the third house does business on
sthe principle of stand and deliver That's the
"way the Legislature treats corporations. | am
mentioning no names. but Will say that the
"present ruler is as much more expensive than
1.-The former one of different political stripe as
ian educated, skilful. highpriced man is than
IAN ignorant. low-prced one"
Mr. Benedict evidently speaks by the card
He knows how corporations are treated by dif-
ferent managers of the "stand and deliver
business and is able TO compare their work.
He is the man we have been looking for this
long time the person who can make the def
mite exposure Of the traffic which all men know
exists. which those who are charged with prac-
Using it do not deny they are engaged in, which
once dragged into light would be destroyed. Just
as the police extOrton system fell to pieces
when definitely shown up. but which continues
to flourish because its processes are carried on
in secret while only its results are seen. The
logic Of the public belief is clear The argument
from effect TO cause and from instrument 10
method is irresistible. but the blackmailers do
not confess their sins. and hitherto the black
mailed have not revealed their shame. All that
ia needed is for some trustee TO come out and
fell how he has felt constrained to pay poll
ticians to protect the interests Of those who
trusted In him. 1t would not be pleasant. but
after all. nobody would blame him overmuch
for trying to keep his clients from being robbed
by paying the robbers. II Mr. Benedict knows
whereof he speaks. as his words plainly indicate
he does he has the chance 10 serve his country
In A new and even higher capacity than that al
ready filed by him.
But, sad to say. hc is utterly disappointing. He
knows the different biackmaerS and their re-
spectlve prices. He denounces them, but adds:
"I am mentioning no names 1t Is names we
want. Glittering general.tes bring no reforms
To say that some politicians 'act as clearing
house for Doodle" and then announce Il am no,
scaling names. but If the shoe fits any one let
Gus faulty. The kind OF man who runs 'clear-
ing house for DOODLE is not thin-skinned. He
goes barefoot. and the fact that some peculiarly
disgraceful shoes fit him does not in the least
induce him to wear them Just bring out rour
New-York tribune., 1896-12-26

shoes, Mr.. Benedict, and put them on the men
whom they fit. Then we can prove VINO 'he rop'
bers are. so that no man can doubt ana longer
find excuse for toerating them. Blackhai'ers
will not reform themselves: outsiders VINO ON!
see the results of blackmailing cannot stop 'he
business: only the blackmailed can STOP II ny
throwing light on the transactions. Nobody de-
nounces corrupt politicians 80 loudly as 'he cor
poration manager who suffers from thelr ie''s'
but rarely does vlrtuous Indignation assume '"'
form Of cleansing revelation. il is enough I"
make the ungodly mock and the cyhlc gro"
puffed up in his philosophy TO see gas men anu
railroad men and Insurance men spehd h'i'i
their time bewailing the corruption OF poiiiics
and the other half contributing TO the evil re-
sources of the corruptionists. If the corpora
lions want honest legislators they can nave
Them There can be no clearing house iof
Doodle" unless the Doodle is contributed. II
Mr. Benedict knows where that clearing MOUSE
is. let him reveal the secret 10 waiting Na''o'''
or else stop his pretencc of Indignation over 'ne
doings of men whom he protects by not ca"-
;n0 narnps