New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1896-03-27
Cashmere
Bouquet
SOAP and PERFUME

Mr. Waldo said. They were reasonable IN lheI
p Charter was TO contain before they favored the
bill 1t had been the custom 10 JON dwsntapes
wara n he gained by consolidation. referendum
should be used consolidation for every pe ~ nrn
BROOKLYN ought TO have a chance TO stuu! lne pr ~
| posed charter and ascertain what he would De
! called upon to support
MR. AUsTIN'S REPLY TO Mr.. ROBblNS
Mr. Austin chairman Of the Cities COMMITTEE
hogan his speech by attacking the speech OF MI
Robbins II the Legislature did not pass the Dill.
he said 1t would stultify Itself for 1t had aiowea
the matter to be presented to the people once anu
had agreed to take that vote the feeling OF 'qe
ypr Of T the should be dsregaded
! future referendunis would be farces. ., l.,
ansS Pe o ths b ana nd the e
the amss n PSege ev oeaty
Mr. Robbins had predicted chaos IN Greater ss-
This YOU'D NOT be :o dGT want
until charter could be secured that w9ud me e,
NTH ct hs cSaG Ss e S as unfit ha
| The tax rate in Brooklyn was now mucn nR he
ton Was wa perfeced the tax rate in brooklyn would
be decreased Brooklyn had once favosed con th
for as the charter. when FORMULATED could De
were again submitted, too much politics would DO
brought into the agess ,b Hous. tina, in 1894 every
Kings i County member voted for the pin Even he
nas r Robins had Voted for 1t at that
This Mir. Robbins denied The vote upon the bill
in 1894 had been lOs for and against lie was ono
Continuing speech MI Butts declared that hat
measure in 1894 he favored it now for had not the
people approved 1t? Whoever opposed the scheme
arse ana oh ePp0hsa had Brought politics
discussion. This was unjust as 1t was not
pC Mr Ebbes the bill from business
P r,h St os he Brooklyn did
own OWN its docks 1t had no Board Of Trade; New.
greater city could not but advance Brooklyn's In
teress. Years ago prominent men had ,o,es cen
| had predicted H. For years there had been ten
dency toward consolidation. II was nothing new.
| The change involved In consolidation wouiu nov De
| great. Brooklyn would have the same air ana just
as clean streets as now
THE MINORITY LEADER HEARD.
Mr.. stanchheld then opened his address on the
measure When the session began in January. he
| said. the Assembly had been told that two meas
ures were the principal ones to be considered one
| was the bill regulating the sale OF liquor. when
was now a law-for veal or woe. no one could tel.
| The other was the bill now under consideration.
While II would not have any effect for him TO argue
| either way st he wished to oppose the measure;
The proposition had been accepted by the peope OF
in Which the ballot had been taken was evidence
That hs w Of thu the Would he enta nH'
to the Constitution 10 fit the measure INTO the pouy
While the bill protested to affect only New-YCrk
II reached to the uttermost parts OF the state ne
s sae outside Gt Of Greater New-York s. Of
the 200 members OF the Legislature would cone
t tops outside Of Sew-York if hey continued as
members would repent, in snckclOth and ashes
Mr. stanchdeld then appealed to the rural mem mem
on o 10 II made ;te difference to him.
he said. whether the bill became law or not but
opposition to It was reasonable. FOR by IL BROOKLYN
| would pass from sight forever.
MIR. OGRADY CLOSES THE DEBATE
| NJ ocradv reca,,ed 70 the House that Mr..
| StanchNeld at the opening OF the session had
| charged that the majority did not intend to give
New-York or Brooklyn what they had asked Tor by
| a vote in favor of consolidation. He recaied the
history Of consolidation from Its inception II was
not the fault OF the Legislature OF 1895 that there
| was no consolidation then The Governor mao re-
| peatedy asked for consolidation.
The expression Of the will OF the people was reg
| istered even II it only by 277. Every financial
institution in both cities favored consolidation. Inc
only principle upon which the Legislature could act
| was that the people had decided in favor OF con-
| solidation. Even though the vote was a small one
party votes for candidates always ran higher than
those upon propositions The comm nnrfsc VIM i'm
telligent and capable Of passing upon any art
ton. The people up the State had the best interest
OF Brooklyn at heart, and the bin should pass.
Mr. OGrady moved call of the House, which
was ordered One hundred and forty-hve meinDefs
were apprehended under the call. All proceedings
under the call were suspended ..,o ~ en-.
s, Nov and II was ordered The Storm
amendment exemptng Jamaica ana aiush Ths Mas Ma
| shall referendum substitution was ioat Dy 'o'e
Mr.. Brennan spoke few words against the bill
which then Put upon Us final N Gasssge On Ne
Wilson anf POST expiained their votes. Mr. Audet
voted against the bill because he. thought his con;
st;uenis did not want It, Nj Gudcr representa- Tea
bin and he could not advocate IT, N, nj Mac
good thing and so he would push ii along with
an affirmative vote " WILSON 50 rnSnsa ast .@e
| True il was a good thing from a Democratic point
OF Tb s Repubcan members who opposed the
bill had nothing 10 apologize FOR
FINAL VOTE ON THE BILL.
The bill was then passed without amendment by
q vote Of 81 to &C. as follows:
Aves-Messrs Albeit Adler. Aids. Anderson, H..
r. Andrews p j. Andrews. Armstrong. Aust.h'
parry Barth Bates, Bede. Brann. +. Brown,
u n Drown Brownell Budd Burr, Butts Cain,
| Clark c. c. Cole VI. n. Cole, Corrigan. Costello
| cutler Davidson J. A. Donnely, T. F. Donnelly,
| Downs. Dudley. Ebbets Eddy. Eldridge' Flnn'
Ftzgeald Fritz, Galngan. Giedhill. Goodseii Cor
ham. Graves. Green. Gregory. Hanna hart
Hochie Hoffman, Hustled, Ives. Keenhdts. Kelly
| Xe,sev Kerr Leonard, Lounsbury. MacCabe.
Mackey. Mccoy, McGraw, .McNaughton. Messiter'
~ r Myers Miles, Mittnacht, Newman, Nixon
lOGrady, Rogers, A. D. Sanders f. +. SAUNDERS
scherer. E, L. Schmidt Schllum. Sears, Sheldon
Smith Syringe ytah ss WSad w swfs
Wilson. Whine Witter and the Speaker-?gli:
Noes-Messrs. Audett, Babcock. Bondy. Brennan
ca rlsle C. J. Clark, Coughn, Cromwell, Cullen
DeGraw. Demour. Embiey Finders: rorrei sier
Honsinger Horton, Hughes Kempner, Kline
Roster Iambser, Iannon, LiyngsOn Ma Msys4
Miller, Murphy, Norton. Peeyers. Perkins. Post.
Robbins, Rounds. Rudd, F. schmid, c. Smith
| snrngweiler Stanchfied. Steele Steiner. storm,
WagstaT Waldo. c. W. Wilson, zimmerman ard
, | Zurn-56 o,o, A., ,,.. ...,. -.
: | recess until $50 o'clock tonight
When Mayor Strong was informed OF the passage
of the Greater NewYork bill yesterday ne said: $50
1 they have passed 1t. en-? Well they do things so
fast I'D there that don't get much OF chance 10
keep up with EN- suppose .hey VIII seiu rile t p