Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1895-04-26
,cortiau,dJr rage on')
The FINAL QUIETUS,

t,apy useful, beneficial. or necessary ..,,.,I,
.',rgse. or Tor drainage or loi uts'u
sef mines, VI the "Othlus 'hsI'o''
means OF roade, iallIoaui us-
ws,s. cuts, tunnels, sha's' ho,s'.s
"ogks. dumps Or olhef n,uts,a,y
mean. 10 lnclt complete deNeiul ulvu'
n,spy other use nvcessafy W tnv w
oi.ts development VI the ne'erlal
l,urrss Of the Stale OF the tlesol
,,np oi the health oi lls luneullausi
grrepv declared 10 he puollo us', Iuv
,Y1l,ct to the regulation anu oon'fV' ''
tur statt" -.,.A.t,.., .ryayed
lp Inc mining business iot wv lAa'
t.tny years and that his opeiatlon'
b.I gxtcuIod from the bull7n plal,s-
,i5rs On the north 10 Mexico ON lne
ruth nud never ~ all ms 'Ar'l''I''y,
IA he encountered such an uulust
snJ perniciUus principle ~ con
H. tbs substitute, 10 was slmply W.
g-lrtgirst proposition ne ever hea'u
iii 10. 10 was supplied Uhat suy
,,.yttsr 1i tho convention hhouil give
IL serious confederation ,
Rlwllu said u wac sort ~ hoIu'ul
,yTstltutr that would allow one man
i5 pp au0thcf-iO take property tha'
M nol belong " hiul, without femu H.
iimbar, Of Weber was Of the
auIpi8n that the substitute wa az
!. IN: that thotc was uluei-
epsg IN opinion between Judges
gpI courts east and west OF
tGg Rocky Mountains az 10 Whhl
c.Bfiitutesa "puhuc use" lie woulu
1Eeto have that question settled here
Thatcher SAID ne thought that lht
mining article had been killed IN we
committee OF the whole by an almost
rpapimUus vote. But somehow OF
gtref it had been brought back Into tue
g8uvpntiun tor fudlscutsiOn' to con.
s.lofei tia dangerous proposition Anl
aid hr favored mining uuu agTleu'
trro alike, but dldu't think thty
should be- JtC.atuI public uses ny tue
R56,rts asked who the father ot the
s.ls,iluu clipping was nnd a itllpW
lrlrfntu suggested that II owed is
bIttb to k,atuf, chairman Of tho COM
miticr ou mines aud mining, where
upln Roberts eail'
'"kuuwiug tue gentleman anl hls
character aud reputation ns de- an
hill the more gufpfiFtd that be snuulu
lrsl a.hamcd Of hiB ~ guuy Laugh
trfl as 10 continue 20 hide his Identity
TUia question was killed 10 the c0m'
m.lttr OF tue whole aud should not be
brought back here 10 take up ihu tlmo
u tbis Convention. There ate one
prtvo thIugaI would like 60 bring back
II4usAtrrl cut 1 TOW ~ the majority
u1w ~ did when defeat was ny lot
Ma.1utes must rule aud The sooner
We iraIiz, that this bcltCL Wcshuuliut
tlpnd our time here billing the same
I'D snake time aitur timV. (LAughiet)
snow said that thu question hhl
never been before the Convention
ufl1f 90 this aud lpoiatud that iu order
10 rauy out certain duyelopmcn'ul
work in southern Utan, tue adoption OF
ams such at,lc,O wac absolutely nrces-
tafy,
wins said he knew that In Wash
instlu county 70 was n case OF actual
utesssity 10 have tue question settled.
Itsbsuld not be left without definite
c.rlffurtion. Unleia the substitute "
some similar provision should pass lac
knrw nf numerous canal sud reservoir
projects that would be- retarded u not
Indefinitely postponed.
Howard spoke Ia favor Of the uuosll'
tute anu
Van Horn believed that tho spirit
anu purpose VI the substitute ran In
tho digit direction. but II went on
tlfoly too far. Thu manner IN which
II was separated, punctuatod and word
oil made II exceedingly dangerous and
destructive 10 tue property interests o.
the new State.
Morfis6aii Il was probably crude but
90 strike II out meant "a blow nt the
development Of the sIatt's RESOURCES.
Thurman said u was not In the
rover Of the Convention 20 cay thai
one name property could DO take0
Tor tho benefit OF another, Geutlumeu
had said that mining was a puuiiu ust
that agriculture was such usc. That
was ali right. but this sub titutg
went too far IL would allow a mau
with a dozen head Of sheep anu q
small spring on the foothills 10 drive
Actos. his neighhot's property no mat
ter how much the latter might object.
The right OF eminent domain should
no. be- exercised In bis behalf IL was
all Right to take private properly TOT a
public use. Hut II was not all night u
take private property for a private use.
"Iho duty VI tho convention" said
tho speaker, els To strike out ,his sub
suluto ami say hands oil 10 ell person.
who want to take private property foI
private use"
Kearns-Hssu't Idaho done that?
Thurmau-Yes and Idahos laws on
this question were declared uncOnsti
tIu0ual. / houe the gentleman wont
pllut 20 that state as "a precedent. II
We should do as n has done, New
Mexico and Arizona, when making
constitutions next year Or at ulm'
Utheri might point TO us 40 a precedent
uIF SUBSTITUTE sTRCEES OUT,
The previous question was clamOr
Outly Ollltl Tor aud the substitute We
stricken cut on vote Of ~ 90 80,
n ALL GOEs OUT.
On motion Of Hart, NJ Cache, ihu
remaining sections ani the title u tn
article were stricken out anu again thi
mining article was declared killed
this time absolutely 40.
LAST BLOW AT PROHIBITION.
Hart moved 10 adopt the majority
report Of the committee on schedule
future amendments aud miscellaneous
lvius moved 10 amend by Adopting th,
minority report
The amendment was lost and thu
malorlly report wac adopted on vol0
VI % 10 10,
Trp-p yypUp pnu DENOMINATIONS