Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1895-06-29
CONTINUED from Page ono J
DONOVAN'S STORY.

auction which Attorney Zane OBJ.
iretsd TO as leading. Sir. Lipmau de-
n ed tho imputatlou and Commissioner
stephens becoming impatient said
tnat there must DO clEsAUon Of per.
s1nal cross 1fc,
Attorney Llpman (hoiIy)-well. lot
the young man (Mt. Z tuul object IN a
pfuper manner.
Attorney zine--Thnl is tho way
10 object.
Commissioner Siephens--W Well, let
TINS talk stop right now. We must pro-
& cl In an orderly manner.
Attorney Lipman (persIsten,lyl-i
want 10 DO that tut 1 also wRut 10 con.
QUOT my part VI the examination IN my
own way anu object 10 counsel diotat.
ing ne 70 fuon method--he cannot run
the whole city government In AIl liB
departments, Including this iuyes,iga.
ton.
Commis'loner Stephens t'harplyl-
Well, stop now
Attorney Lipman-t iou'l propose
Commissioner Stephen growing
wnrmeD-5tOp nov; fizht lrtu.
Mr.. Lipman bowed to The order hnd
the investigation cOntiruol.
SMOKING AND sEcHEr coNfLABB.
Fireman Berry bad soen the chief
smoking a liIo once on the apparatus
floor % station NJ. !. He was no. iu
uniform. Fireman u. J. Mcdonald
faid wien the Cu.U! visited the Wet
Side department tina, no hUid secret
aud low toned conversations with ME
iavOriloF. The principal reason Tor the
dlscOfd ami trouble was tho overhaul
log manner oi tho Ch.o; towards his
tuuUrdinatos aud the taxing away OF
tuo privileges they ouco enjoyed.
THE AssisrANr cuEF's TESTIMONY.
Whom Assistant Chief Donavan was
called there was stir iu the audi.
t0rium and general crapiug o. npcks.
lie was ilfsJ quutiri by Attorney
Llpmhn and rulusud g. answer, say.
inli ~ obDo0t % giving tesiimoDy in
this catc except hy tho full ana irto
I0Tmiision ana tcqurs. OF tho board.
rucfo have bOou differences between
myself anu the cuiri but they nrr now
adjusted anu / 10 not care ~ Apgra.
waite them"
Chairman Junuings.-Woll, the
board vans 10 near all u can On
this rns'. We certainly vant your
tustlmOuy.
DIuovnu--VoTy we'll.
Atkld ~ 10 now often tho chief
vls.tsI Station 40, he rnpliuI that uo
WI o. 'umouuts every day or two
aud sometimes not f1r month or
uDrc.' THE arrangement Tor tao din.
nur hour wH8 bad at mat station, l,ny-
log only two men Ia charge u the
sppargtus, tho others being out at
lunch.
Judge Povors-Outsido Of those two
froutu what protection would pr0l.
tfty ogncr have ia tuat vicinity Ia
'gsn ~ nit2
Donovan None but wha. they
would get ii0m the citizens,
The wituras hnd been silently Passed
hy when ha met the CHIEF un tue
street. and ia the oHlru alter hu had
E,vtu saluies. lie never tor monthsl
recognized witness In any way unul
tho matter was taken Dui1I, tns board
and then no WIS never rec
gIIz1d " consulted ne second,
nicer IN the department iu nny WY.
The chief had shown iav0rliitm among
toe men. lie would let some OF them
have dayn or amt others funl u im.
I1ssibie 20 90! tuch concession.
CrB' Cx1mined by Attorney Zane
did you ever smoke on tue apparatus
u9ui2
Donayau-l dldn't know that was
being Investigates.
Julge PowoE-O, answer his quCl.
ton.
Donovau-Yos / have.
Attorney u me How often has tho
chief failed tu sgiuts yOu2
DOnOvau-O, tuveTai times.
Attorney Z,ug--Well, how 0fttn2
D1hoyah-Ou toe stfoot anu IN the
pilcc.
Attorney Z,ng-- Did you ever fail to
salute the Chui2
Dou0yau-irs, sir; have failed 10
10 w,
Attorney Zane why?
Douovau- Because got tired Of BE-.
inE Ignored aud sat Gown upon.
D1novan thUn denied 10 detail that
huknew anything about the oHargr5
preferred against the chlui until he
read thum in the newspapers. Hu did
not refuse to figu tho charges nor did
lac say that he would assist In giving
them tho fullest possible publicity OF
anything VI thar character I0f the
reason already stated, that he knew
nothing Of them. They were not
drawn up, presented or read IN HE
Office or sleeping apartment 10 far as
no knew.
Commissioner Stephens then put the
naiistaut through long course Oi
questioning as 10 what frTvlcu could
ho obtained from the apparatus " the
two slations anu how It could bU made
most tiieciual.
UNSAFE APPARATUS.
q. +. Hudson, local accident In
sutauoo sgeut, testified that tho wheels
" hose wagon were very unahte, The
same was trus with reference 10 other
apparatus In the department. HIS
company however, hbu not asked
luctoaaod rniHs on the policies itaued o.
the men on that account.