New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1895-06-16
HAS CARLISLE RECANTED d!
HIS STATEMENTS CONTRADICTED By TIE
OFFICIAL RECORD.
HE STARTED OFT AS AN INFLATIONfsT. AND
HAS ALWAYS BEEN AN ENEMY OF THE
NATIONAL BANKING SYSTEM.


tBY TELEGRAPH TO TIE TRIBrSEl
Washington. June l5-some OF Secretary Cars.e's
recent private utteranccs well Of his
public expressions indicate only too clearly that.
whether not he has recanted the silver imitation
opinions which he says in the face OF the ON ial
and public record. that he never he'd. he Is still
ahoa. on a wide sea OF financial imitation vSgaries.
When Mr.. Carlisle first entered Congress. in 1871.
he appeared TO be an ou-anl-out innations'. and II
his hostility to the National banking system has
abaed since that time the fact cannot be perceived
and the evidence OF Its existence is lacking or with
held.
on June 49, 1873 Mr. Carlisle votel in the House Of
Representatives for n motion submitted by General
Ewing OF Ohio 10 suspend the rules and pass. ont
Of hand bill TO retire all the circulating notes OF
National banks Uhen amounting to about S'Z2"'"'l
and in lieu thereof 70 issue an equal amount OF
United States Treasury notes which were - De
receivable for customs dues and all other demands
OF the Government That was more than SIX
months before the resumption OF specie payments
after the Civil War.
In January. 1881. Mr. Carlisle took an active part
IN the consideration OF the Eefunding Dill ana inc
fifth section Of that measure as II passed congress-
was his handlwork That section was the one on
which President Hayes dwelt especially ana deh'
with most severely in his veto message. Among
other things President Hayes declared mat mrs
section would seriously impair the va.uc ANA tenn
to the destruction Of the present National panhhs
system Of the country, than when no ""''' "
more beneficial banking system was ever 's''o-
lishci" After quoting section D. Inc ''S"
served: go -
7, 10 obvious that no additional banks viii mere
after he organized except possibly in few cue.
or localities where the prevailing rates OF ''''''
in ordinary business are extremely low
Such were some Of the criticisms OF M''
isles section OF the kefundins Dh 10y 'i's-'' -
HAYES who had tho sage advice and counSe' {"
|. John sherman who then filled the once Jon" u
Carlisle occupies 49,
In the first session % the Nl'Nllth '"nE'', wa
Anru T. 1851 Mr. Carlisle again showed his p"er
hostility 20 the National banking system. not Only
nv voting against the Grape bill TO enable N"''o'''
banking associations to prolong their corporate ~
stence but also by supporting two amen W
offered by Greenbackers on May !. anu irn
would have virtually killed the system = a.ois
because IL provided that no National pahAhS 49,
ciation should extend It's charter beyond " p"lyi
of three wears. II IS somewhat int'r'SNir - ',
in view Of certain financial TRANSACTIONS oi thr
On, Secretary OF the Treasury that on MARI !.
ISL even before the Refunding ~ 81 Wmoh ~ ! !
Section was the objectionahie feature ma !
been submitted TO tho President. Mr.. Carlisle OF
fered another Reminding bill ana moved 20
,hs rules sss,,o and Of ,his iii pfoyiaed
other things that Of s the Treasury before
fhorzed to "any syndicate Of individuals or b.nk
ers 10 have public su0sfspso nss 0Pf' shall hap,
pen that than the entire amount OF So, i,n
and Treasury notes or OF either OF ,' shai IL ,v,,i
The fu amount subscribed 10 all persons who ."ali
have made bona hdc subscriptions In orier oi "nc
Of said subscriItions ara c AT ,"e '"''' ''''
In those DAVIS Mr. Carlisle was strong iV2'-''r
nientiful supply In these days he IS ANXIOUS - re-
turn to the obsolete and dangeiouS sysdci", ~,
nySrwheimng majority OF the people Of the conn-