The San Francisco call. [volume] (San Francisco [Calif.]) 1895-1913, 1895-06-12

been walking with DR.. Levingston and
when they saw the clinch DR.. Mime,
rushed forward and forcibly separated
them. The tall attorney says that Miner
struck him violent blow on the jaw that
turned him half round, but Miner says he
simply put his open hand on his chin and
forced him away. from Livingston.
They, clinched again and fell upon the
sidewalk, DIR. Livingston on top. A crowd
had quickly gathered, and several men,
among them Rev. DR.. James Woodward,
who was passing, attempted to separate
the combatants, but DR.. Miner prevented
him and would not allow any one to inter
fere.
Livingston and Tum SUDDEN fought
and scratched each other on the sidewalk,
while friends of the former excitedly yelled
was ended by Policemen O'Connell
and Clancy, who placed the two COM
batants and DR.. Miner under arrest and
took them to the City Prison, where they
were booked on charges OF battery.
Reel B. Terry, counsel for DR.. Leving-
ston IN the libel suit against DR.. Ollie and
others, had been apprised of the arrests
and he went to Judge Campbell, who was
holding court, and procured their release
on their own recOgniZanCe.
Attorney tum Students right cheek, be-
low the eve, showed the marks of blow
His hat was covered with dust and his
clothes showed plainly that he had come
in contact with the sidewalk He had not
altogether recovered from his excitement
DR.. Levingston looked very well. He had
confusion on his forehead that raised a
lump about tie size of an egg, and slight
wound on his right hand. DR.. Miner
was serene and smiling, and seemed to
view the affair in the light of a good joke.
81 was walking with Stephen Potter, -
said INN Sndpn hon I mot Tor 7
ston and some of his friends. l walked up
to the doctor and said You
did you make these remarks about me in
the Police Court yesterday? p and he said
he did. struck him slight blow on the
jaw. l did not want to iniure the little
man.
Then he struck me, and DIR. Miner hit
me violent blow on the jaw that turned
me half round. Somebody on the other
side OF me hit me with club and knocked
me down, and while l was down they threw
the doctor on top of me. l got my left
arm round his neck and was jabbing him
on the jaw when the policeman separated
US. w nile was on the ground several of
the doctors friends kept hitting me-
Dr. Levlngston was telling his version of
the row when Tum SUDDEN passed to go out
OF the prison. The doctor had been told of
Tum Students offensive expression, and he
promptly asked the attorney: Did you
Gall lie a
NO" said Tum SUDDEN, II don't think
did. was SO excited don't remember
just what said"
That's all right" said the doctor, with
look IN his eve that foreboded more
trouble If Tum SUDDEN had admitted using
the offensive expression.
Dr.. Livingston appeared to be we'll
pleased with his prowess, and claimed that
he threw the big attorney when they
clinched the second time. His version OF
the trouble is as follows:
About 3:45 O'Clock in the afternoon I
was walking up Market street, when Otto
tum SUDDEN, who was coming the other
way, stepped up to me and said, Il want to
see you about your testimony in Joachim
sens court yesterday where you charac-
terlzed me as liar l replied, Yes, l said
SO, and 1t goes He thereupon struck out
and did the same. felt somebody sepa
rate us and push us both aside. We came
together again. and in minute had him
down on the sidewalk, pummeling away
Tor dear life. All l heard was the mob
shouting, Give the little fellow 1me1
show. After a while several police
whistles were blown and three big police
men separated US. Tum SUDDEN is man who