The Scranton tribune. [volume] (Scranton, Pa.) 1891-1910, 1895-11-20
Carlisle ON The CURRENCY
Sound Money Arguments Before the
Chamber Of Commerce.
LEGAL TENDER NOTE EVIL
Secretary OF the Treasury Rchcnrscs n
Number of the Points Favorable ton
Gold misunderstanding Pictures
of the Silver "Bosie Man,

commerce held it's one hundred and
twenty-seventh banquet tonight at Del
monjco's The Hon John q Carlisle
SECRETARY of tho trea s,i,,, snoi,e ~,
co.,. C,S,,,,o,,,,, D..ie' "po"@ VII
NJ Culii,s .Shes I!ueseloi'
7 .na; VII SaIis.e saiu IN part Two years ago
srii Saiu 20 you that tue disposition anu
, au,.''s VI tne soNeiHniei' 70 maintain its
preserve the integrity of all the forms of
CURRENCY In circulation among the people
o,s! ouSn. no. 10 pe the suDlecI OF iurtner
,, .oL.IonersS. WINE scarceiy any one now
,Sa LOUIS rs ei.hei tne nlsposi'ioif or
.hsy one auiIIty VI .he eNecuuiNe prahch OF the
81 t @ 10 accoiIipnsn tnese oDJects,
an who naVe slVen any attention 10 ihe
supJect must realize that IN the existing
at. iS,e VI % oi, ieslsiatioh sne TASK ~ pOth
ratHou'i rato,, h anu eXpensiSe since tnat aecia-
aa.io,. nete imteres III e 81 bearing bonus 10 tne
a..aour. no, VI Si"-'oi.iVo s nave peeh lssueu 10
p,o.ue soiu iot 'ne reueIlptioh oi OIi.eu
o,,I,ra ,inus a,in IN .,eaSry y nU'eS, anu .ne
og oStSaoons IA @ ot the sovSThment over on account
VI me itotes Wnicn Will remain the same
as a IA my PEE lii,hns. me notes are re-
.,,,e.; neJ,,,ea; pu. tney are u!,pniu' anu IL our
nr,am ,s, 10 NJ ~, 'iaisuu, ~ l,a,.ei nov
So,,,od tey heyy1y tay be p,sSen.eu ,,ii anu re-
.h, ,, W umey VIII remain uhPaiu.
~ !, .n,S @ pu,ieS Vt ieuenip,ioh anu Tissue
~ ,,,;,f Goil''aueu m tHe am,ersst pnarins ueDt
;ntorost ehea,iyyg daht nj, nnt ant MN w
inast S,poinisbt uepb Th VIII mHr pe IN 'ns
sard,,, a ,Snr Sys.., are So opoiots INA. Is
aruiy MI os auosssaas 10 ehuIiera.I then;
nv ii,,,;ea = mas S'iuel.ahem , W KEEP
an,a in vaa aot .n goI1 ~ co notss
eu,,, pua' ~ N";"e ~ So'o suii' a.iu a. tne
sai.e ,ine ~ nas no iesa. authority 10
cplapei p ailyoouy 10 give II soid IN ex-
on' i, ~. We h. "o'ts vi ~ pay Soiu Oh
any demand que 10 II.
Vice in Our Currcncv.
N,o COMMENCEMENT ,,,.o ,r ~,
-. ne iunuu,l'eh.a, I .h i we III our currency
o,Ie IN no,n 'c ;h ,ie ,o,e reueeml- @ IN
issuable @ biz @ under ~ the he law. This tbreatens u
c,,rronn' y " ha ,,'s mnoie wo,u,e ot our
~, a.y ,E,Sy auu mas S i.iiniemse i @ losses
~ " n nuu .uu Az ,Ions & oL when IL ~ ln,posslDle
hep a1e pIDc pthnt ,h awape. NJ was never
,', u, seu INA. i 'ne soyerntieht shouIu
treasury department is simply n public
agency Ior the management OF the fiscal
ai1airs ol the soVerniilent,
ota5es !io.es anu treasury notes mas q
,ssloeluy 70 oLiVe out ol use anu out OF
one .rns,.r Sunn,f 10 saa very Go!ii III wnicn tne
Soser,hieht ~ coI,peiieu 70 redeem tnem;
Sn,, ~ , raS JHu oHpe'ie~ ii.i.ois vi uo!iars
~ iIo,i Jul 'n nu,u ' NJ other soVerhinent
fro,,, trans,,r,, t lily ~ suppy Soiu
i;. LII; ~ i.ss ,,, ~ S5 .ne private
OpiisatioIis oi us cItizens, anu no govern
nen' s Eush. " pe lequiieu " uo 50. me
a. iaos nc ~ su' c, ni.emt 10 Ieduireu 10
DUTroW n iaoney S, ~ an IN in5ury 10 its credit
an anu, rne Itruit VI ~ geop,e, put tne n
jury resulting lloIl thls cause Is insiSnli.
cant N comparison WIN the run that
,, muutu hiI w "tnoinmen. otne @ & 81 .ne re-
e. al, ",,e a,r o,rrono,, ,,,, ,h,,
d'ood e. ~ o11 tba siI,,ar nSor 'hus DC re-
rSso ,boan;as o,.S .ha, ~ta'uai ia u.
me tneories thai tne government can
n,Yar. tTnt ~ 1 Pinis ,i,,a iaS ~ stamp upon
p,aisa "a na,,s .nnai , ,oS ea t cah
Hniaii,, ~ n6a,sd nr;nas - n",d ~ , ,na. a.u
,r vrany -, u, -, p..on paiu III uepLeciuteu
nnd t,ar;pns o,hpr uoaar;o soau . m iy' iisncy'
iv at,r;h,,ta bIe 70 TIC ion1 nnn,' un ui'eu.- ,,
~ ionai tnndor ,anor i2, So.r.usu , use
VI u teSaa .;s .sueei Papi. me proposition
r nc, p r. ,,no M i = 20 pay
nronosition tbat n nromisa ,N da,;,,a nS u"e
bocse ;s a borsa "a 'o''''e " ueA'eF d
"0'se 10 "o'se.
Same Vicious Principle.
,oaaI tsndcr siiver A. a tio u,hinh ,soIi ~
nnt onIv so cants worth ~ hui,;nn ~ "
siiver do,,ar Is nredicated rnon .Sa saua an q
io;o,s Driroim,a ,Tho TuitI uIot. G.t ,to aa,c t
,ras n farco1 Ioan fro,, ~ naonia g. ~ ~
government. which the government prom
ises TO repay In doniats, put tne Tree com.
~ 70 os n, env otSar ratio cnrrosno,S rar,o Si
ing with the commercial value of the two
metals, would be a forced loan from the
people to the owners of silver mines and
silver bullion without promise OF pay
ment py ivypoay; one loan was Forced
LOT @ ane ,t th y. urs;tinr ,me es IN ti Sine
oa,ns 90 ~ free ro,paDe 10 10 forcs % .nnthor
loan for the benefit Z private individuais
and corporations in a time of profound
peace In principle, the two measures arc
precisely alike.
The tree M coinage OF legal tender silver
Wouiu pe "a, more uhJest than lhe issue
ol ,esn serutr at nv, u,teu ',ra ",atS o t ,, oW
the Question of free coinage think ths
aha ndonment or SUSPENSION of the ageres.
sive movement against this nancial
heresy would be most unwise at this time,
especially IN view OF the fact that con-
certed enort Is evidently now Delng made
III ,nd sou so'h ,r,n anu We Mest 10 iesn,n me
II the friends Of n sound measmrs of
value are vlgilant this effort cannot pos
sibly succeed. But the legal tender notes
system until congress agrees to their re-
tirement ana , SUBSTITUTION OF DINERS IN
ti,, the,i paoe pnanaad ms 30 II cnnnern thn .vei
n1'v fare of ali the people' '"o we"
n,,.,or. c.o,,,, n, C,,..
N
The speaker closed with a nope that
the political platforms OF both the great
parties would hencerorth De ciear ana
unequivocai
III majority OF tne people OF tine
united states are IN IaNor OF tne man. .
tenahce Oh the present stahoaId OF
vaiue ana opposed 10 tne Iree anu un-
limited coinage OF iegal tender silver
they ougnt 10 hail an opportunity 10
say so IN iorlh whlch VIII preciuue an
controversy as 10 Whether they nave
sala SO OF Ro.. on .he otner hanu, II, a
IiaJoIiy vi our people are IN iaVoT OF
aDanaonins .he PIesenI stanuaM OF
value anu estaplshIne SILVER inonomet-
alllsm py tne Tree anu umiimiteu coin
age Oh 'nat hetai mo Iuii Iesai tender
money, tney snou,u nave an .opportum-
IVY ~ sd. .i,a.. Mheh tsis issue Is ui-
recty preseh'eo we heeo not rear the
reS"it' H,,.
.6 Inc % 1.ner .oasts RESPONDED 70 were:
our domestic commerce. by bon