The evening world., 1895-03-02
LF1ER An AlL-N|GH1 SESSION
The Ex-Oaptaiu Was Charged
With Accepting Brides
for "Protection."
uR4 rHuR0w WAS HIS ACCUsER.
justies Ingraham Laid Great Stress
On Her Evidence In
He Charge.

Fhs fury that has been celebrating
q tho case Of ex-Pohcs Capt Doherty.
vMo was ON trial for bribery, came into
court this morning At 1910 o'clock and
announced that 1t was impossible to
aSree upon . verdict.
Justice Ingraham said he was very
sorry that no verdict had been reached.
but he thought tho defendant was en-
titled to the Judgment Of twelve men.
Then he thanked the Jury and told
The men who composed 1t they could 60.
Malke-Up Of the Jury.
The Jury was - follows:
Msssis l.svy. halter; 1So East Eishty-third
ssssG
sana Mad. dianeads; sls West One Hun
A.sA1 4 Zimmerman. painter; SIS Western
DsslsvarL
Massus Ksuafsad. weoiisns: 1901 Broadway.
HAvasA BAKER, rstirsd real estate dealer; ss5
Hase ons Hundred and Foty-fourth street
nspdus wsnt.. broker: s2s West Seventy
ssvsatA slrssl
,. Lopss Dc ouarasta shipping: u Irving place.
AAArsas Nayr. houss agent; Aos East Fifty
alsA strssG
AnArsw :. Andsfsoa. bonds: 100 West Ninety
SssrtA sErssl
DAVID I. Bsstsfsldsr. carpets: 81 Avenue q.
JeAa Ryan. packing Gases; III East Ninsty-nrst
GisssG
Nasr,s Rsu.AaA shirts: 20 East Seventy. ninth
0sssG
Ceuld Not Have Agreed in a Week.
Norris Levy. the foreman. said that
Il would have been impossible to ha,
reached . decision even IL he and his
colleagues had remained out six days.
The Jury retired after receiving Judge
Ingraham's charge yesterday after
noon. Immediately upon being locked
Up IN the 5ury-room . ballot was taken.
a count Of the votes showed six for
acquittal. three for conviction and three
blanks.
Last nigh after there had been con-
siderable discussion q second ballot was
taken. with the result that the three
previous blanks were changed to ac-
quittaL
That was the last vote taken until this
morning.
Altogether there were three ballots
cast, the last one, which was cast this
morning. showing no change.
The men who stood out for conviction
are James Michel. Edward Baker and
Andrew T. Anderson.
When the ballot had been counted
and II became evident that the opinions
Of the minority could not be changed
II was decided to go into court and an
nounce a disagreement, which was ac-
cordingly done.
D....s .h Jva~. Wa. s.x...
.,-,.,..
EAsp" Done' o
e'eteu oS .he su', s.'e @ 20.
isiecuoh sna' "l"e y, '"e
vo.eo tor III.
- 80 - S,s oh.roa :.
..,, Sa,d,ss -. even ,,,or.
N a 80, r'o,,o,,,s
"uSy s.o.s ~, 49,. ~
80. .hon,, th., ,,,,
80. m. .nd believe
sh.t ,,o,,id have been acquitted ~ the
- 49,, a. ,r,no r,io, ore"
~ Doh.r,v ,vos In court with her
S.so,d -,h.n the ,urv cam. In and
- =. -. n,.,r .h.t bs had .sc.ned
',..... 80 - ,ov c.m. into her
Dohar.,, -.
s,.s ~" con,ra t,,lot,or. a, their
SIS.
- - c..,.
~.
Senator Daniel Bradley. OF the Lexow
COMMITTEES. was there and shook hands
-.rmlv With the Captain. Cant. Berg
- 80. ...snt Ga .x,ardod h;.
CONGRATULATIONS.
~ S,...r..,,.,. =, ~. ,,,r,, a., .,,s
Ene o'sssreehe"l ot TUG !uiS ~ 'i,ie
case means that another trial will take
niana but neither the District-Attor-
-. -, ~. coun.., for Cant Dohertv
NY ~. 'AAe So
would discuss this matter this morning.
aaveral members Of the fury who were
-.,,.- =. .s,,, e. ,h.v had hee, dis
Wilhhs 10 taih ai'ei '"e' "N
charged said that the sentiment or the
majority was decidedly in favor Of ac-
,.., -, ~. ,,a-,, ..,rt
quittal from the very start.
I'VE did not believe the story told
A~ Mr.. Thurow said Morris 8. Raun-
~ ". -. 81.
nsim. tho tweifth juror. ana 'hat was
inc reason "hS we '''aae up Jul minus
auev.
Athoush the JUDGES charse 80. see,nea me-,