Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1895-04-24

luo CONVENTION 10 tho committee VI
sau whole ps'soI the Judiciary article
practically 10 VISA Al nrt reported
aud A. /. -sas published Ia the NEWS.
TODAN'S PEUCEEntNGs.
L. was D.lU O'CLOCK THIS morning
whom prriiiout smith CalluI the Con.
yuuilJn - order Fiity-slx members
a.fwvrFd ~ tHuir nance. aud prayer
wa 81 l'l 10y Delegate Baruts, OF
Davis. lo'llrlny's journal was read,
Amru.nl ami approved, attor wutoh
AIlru,p. Pluto turauE another sun aye
chestnut oy presenting u petition ask.
INK that equal rights iot women BE-
provided i.riu the Constitution,
NUIuS0 10 Erc1nNr.u.
Tho olmmi.te1 ON mA4ui.tt Igps nnd
c1mmurcr, uy Hyde, VI Juau, reported
aH l.aWt3
Your committee on manufactures and
.HWiNuIunttu whom ras FufuTrUu lIIHsNU.
lIlnfrlUu fUr insertion 900 tine Juu-
HA,u .uu nitu.u uu tUU mn,rc system OF
weights and WItvsTUs, $50. Ii-.p rpl-
HIuuu tu pruiuu. manufacturing UusIno-s
against luHsuH sustained provided yf0hi-
uuuu should uU Inserted 900 tho Cousti.
iuIuu; and no. ITO regulate and
lHunag the manufacture and saIBuf Tor.
muuirh, Vluuuv and snirilu1u- liquors,
l"s cave tH report that VIC had had th0m
uuinf confederation,
We have carefully and thoroughly In
yrslgAtnd each proposition submit,ad To
Co uH uul found nothing that Wo could
soruWmuud 20 Do embodied iu tho Con-
Hutyuuu. We refer clio same back aud
recommend thnl thuy Do u.gl.
EiuhuUr moved that the report be
received Pnd hleu AMI tuat tue Con.
gUutlUH Dc given "a vote o. tbauks Tor
its extensive aud able work. Laugh
teri
Tue motion carried unanimously
nud tue convention then resolved itst {
/ into the committee Of tho whole 20 cou.
elder the article on mining, Nsrian IN
tho chair.
MINES AND uNiNu.
Section 3, declaring that "The neces.
cary use % lauus Tor rights VI way for
| tulnolt, ilumer, piFus, Iltohos, roads,
tramps OF Jump, for tho drainage or
working OF mines ~ means 90 the dy.
vslopment uf tho mineral resources d
| tho Slate, 10 be- 4 public usr; aud suit
| ltcl % the control aud regulation Of the
state caused good zeal Of discut.
slpu, being debated by Malouey, Hart,
/ koarus, Bowdle, Partridge, EichuOf,
lyln', Murdoch, VI Beaver Evans, of
Utah, anu Gibbs.
suusIuUrE ny HOWARD.
Howard, Of Emery, offered the fol.
| lowing A. n substitute for section 80
/ " Tho NECESSARY use Of lands Tor the
] 81 80
] uitchCo, ,auUl', 70 oryOlIT, iOadt, tram
I Wnys ur Dump iOr the development u
| thu farming or mineral resources on
/ the State, IS hereby declared TO be-
| public use aud subject % tho control
AMI regulation Of tho state"
Hart, OF Cache, opposed the FubEtl-
| tute on the ground that It was crude
| anu imperfect, No lay member In
the Convention could VI down ard Ia
an Uii-uAu1 manner write a substitute
that would stand the test NJ the courts.
| The speaker also favored striking ont
he hcctiou no incorporated In tho
/ pfiiclu.
R1lsTts alec spoke against the substl-
] iul1 and tho original section. The 10.
| tygeslB Of miners could, hu said, DO luI
! 10 HE Legislature win Nv much safety
az could those o. the agtiCultuust and
rh0uId 70 10 that body.
! Ju,AUs mguuU p'rs Tor the rlghla OF
way contemplated In section 2. I'm.
] lgEs tLCHr wHtH ensured, he said, dc.
Nrl0pmeut OF many mincs would DO
/ absolutely imgyssIUle. lie was tus
| owner Of numerous patented claims
| himself and unless 10 granted rights
| OF way 20 other miners who owned
valuable ayj cont paUpeIty they would
be- cut On nom Il Ter Hll slime 10 Cpme.
low 10 Op'euJej that mining was no
/ greater public henofit than agriculture
! sId Nh, uli not he 40 cOuIidsTrd In a
constitutional sense. Ono OF these In.
dus,rivs should not Do given protection
[ net guaranteed to the ether.
Evans, Of Weber, HAld the mining
! iuHubty WAS u most important one
| paramount % all othes-,ompoaAry
| however, IN II IL character. While Ii
was oeing carried on, though, Il should
te given the fullest and most literal
encourage
President Smith said It appeared to
| INN that tire COuyoutioG was pre-
ctudlrg strangely. 10 10 anything
with the question now wins a case OF
tgmIerlug with tiro, ltshOuld be len
strlcly alone,
Hammond spoke In favor OF leaving
the question 10 TIE Legislature ana
! tue courts.
Thurman challenged any attorney
on the floor 10 cal his Gttes'lon 90 a
| sluglo case where the courts failed 90
! declare private property Ds public
use when that was necessary. The
ifuad Oi judicial decisions were al In
! that direction,
Pierce said he would accept tho
| challenge but failed 10 DO sO.
! keATEs made tic closing speech In
| Uuhglt OF the section sought 10 bo
stricken cut. The tubstitute WAS lost
on vote OF 40 to As, Gner which tbs
| Troublesome section was stricken out
Ju = vote Of 80 10 30.
WHOLE ARTICLE DEFEATED.
EvauB, Of Weber, moved to Strike