Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1895-07-18
DIR. Miles Nervine
Sold by all Druggists

attacked, bscsuAr gold standard papofa
all over the United States hRd charged
tnat II was forgery, that no such
quotation as was there uael was ever
made from the report Of any monetary
commission or any other ON cisl dOcu'
mont. read from the report Of tho
United States monetary c1mmission Of
1875, not for tho purgoio Of entering
into an argument On the political ocOu-
Omy Of the years 400 10 1900, bus slim.
ply 10 show that all my friends from
New York and sls0whuru who had
accused mo OF forgery were wrong.
Now, l am not going 10 argue with
Mr.. Hofr that the monetary commission
did mol know what they vera talking
about. lie snail not get me at any
point Of this debate TO uIyGTt my mind
from the regular argument and logical
arrangement Of the debate. IL n man
could put together words thst would
convincu an minimizing woTklngman
that ne was better on today by lar than
he was In 1872, anu who can convin o
farmer that lie Ia getting higher
prices now than he was In 1872, would
expect him tn convince crowd who
arc not stuJying hlstOty that prices
rose during the dark agur nj tue very
time they were falling, And that labor.
lag mon were iaTing very well at the
time when they were working NJ the
sviis u tho lords Of Europe.
"Dr. Adam smith, an able historian,
whose work | put into Mf. HoTr'a
hands yesterday, confirms oil that
there IN In that monetary commission.
Page III gives you tho table OF the rise
OF prices that cOntrOiicta everything
thst Mr. Horr has said here.
Mr.. HOTf--Ihe matter we were talk
ing about when we closed last night
was the question whether the trainers
Of the bin OF 1893 Intended to establish
two measures Of value. Mt. Harvey
criticised Judge Vincent for having
decided that case In his remarks Of yea.
tuTdAy, but very tsmely In comparison
with the statements which lac made
ABOUT him Ia print soon after he made
the decision; he even called him dis.
honest In that criticism. Now, Judge
Vincent Ia u reputable citizen, l take
II, OF Chicago, some private indivlc.
uals submitted question to him, and
he decided II ~ he honestly believed
was right, and there IL this popularity
about it-it Is right. Laughter
Mr.. GeslsTjay at the CLOSE,
after had quoted ~ authority for sill.
yer being tho unit, the uttorsnoes Of
Secretary Gallatin, y dsclsion by Chic
Justice Chaso OF the Supreme Court Of
lne United states ami utnor Numerous
authorities, including R0swell q. Hofr
OF Now York, Mr.. Horr then admitted
that the silver dollar was the unit OF
value, ana tho recori OF yesterday
shows that. Now, Ia view Of his vt.
temptj 10 try twlst something back
| Into tho discussion by which We are "a
believe him a. saying one thing yostor-
day ana something else today, ! leave
him TO such iata 40 the readers 81 THIS
debate think proper [ApplAuSc.l
"We agreed 10 take 1p the sitlecl
OF demonstration, tho act Of 1873, ia
todby's debate, mud having wsiIrI fOl
him TO begin, and hs not bogIaning, |
now will starr" Applausr.l
Mr.. HOTT-l bcg paTuoL; you mis-
quote me. stated last ngut That
nad not got through with tee unit Of
value; that h.d come other things 10
submit in 10 many worde, aud W. did
not ~ rec TO take up any other subject
at any particular session, only that We
would taks them In u cei tain order and
let them Tul until We had finished
them.
Nit. Harvcy-And In that order the
crime OF 1873, ~ We will call A., came
next after Ins discussion oi the unit.
MIR. HoTT-l am not through with
thatyVt.
Mr. Harvcy-well, l am, and will
go on. LauB
MT. h.Tvrv thea discussed NJ length
the act Of 1873.
Mr.. HorF followed ON the came suit.
Jeot.
This closed tho debate FOR the day,
GDd questions were In order.
Mr.. Bliss que,tiouod Mir, Harvey rs
10 figures Ia Ihia book relative to the
coinage Ut silver previous to 1873. Mr..
Harvey admitted that hp al efrouc-
| criIy ri 10 the gtnount at $4,000, 900
lets than tho snount 0f silver actually
o. ued before 1919. Howover, " II hai
b1'l to the Interest Of hls argument "a
LtG;' the amount Ut all, It would stand.
v. u. Gum, OF ksusss Cily, caused
- Harvey TO explain at length tht
mount and denomination OF the sil.
yer coinage preylou. to 1873.
| Questions 10y q score OF Others were
.skrd ami answered, bur the discussion
WAS OF a rambling nature. The debate
viii be- resumed NJ 10 O'Clock tomOr,
row morning.