Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1895-08-31
MERRITT AID BIRCH OEE'
hide z1s Taxes a S'aad VIII
Judge Smith.
urr TEE QUESTION IS SETTLED


81. sprtgma court room was "''
.r.',,,lp ,his afternoon, go the ~.
n',,,,i5p that tho qualification o,
wv -, =, vote In NJysgi4Hr next
mid bo passed upoa hal d''r''..
".' 80, feeling Of certainly. AZ
~'o inc chief justice Hna Associate
i,,,,,,, B,teh anu King ea'rf'd the
m ,Dd Judge N,ug immcN A'e'y
',,sc,i, hs i,clllun In 'uo ease oil
i.m,. chapman VI Uuisn Fae'n'
LEV. an fmlng the iud msH, OF the
ia%,, souft, Ia favor Ct Chapman.
Jl.ss Bafch Announced 'l-l IN tue
..,.. "a. D.. B,nr W ~. D. Cox
s-.sII,ot ulsmcu'a $40 lower ''''.
psstrgeu'a' -......,
IA tbc ep,e OF the F.ut National
hank v, Charles E1l,r UtHn appellant
r,lu ympay ut tho c.uJt below "'h
tGi n d.
In toe ease of s.rHb Il. An.
s.u9p Vi CnaTlv lyrG inNolV'
ips tho question OF w3mca voting,
C,.s, Iu...er Merritt slii tnst Judso
g,rcn and himself mai arrived nj q
r,nelufiou, Judge hiu; ui'Hru'ins on
tb5 utjcat. Mu. Andeuon has
arsed tina. her name 10 placed
ola the fugisuati5u .is'. Judge
AI,,,,t, saiu this Limungt- ecker Law
mad cot been repealed, aud NuuiI ~
main elective MI bltttloJd wac
srbieveu. section Of the uYanliu2
sct mai extended the irar cBiso among
m,lr-. luI hau not fuieTs4 20 iumal,t.
II, allow females 20 vote wGuid be IN
rorutc. with the act, huQ WA iIi-
lda,p. rnurc hsI been u.Ivts latu
gp tuv iouf.l section OF tue enabling
tgt uhyiv toe capitalized Notsss 81
tbB pfuBgsgi STATE were lutnUn2uu
10 VOC. In bic view Ihcio quhhhcl
vytyr were lho,e qualified uuusl exist
llg Laws Anl the rnuUiiug acl. Itcf,
LaI teen no Intention IN tue part Of
Inc Constitutional Convention tgaiiU "
women 10 yslu At the nW. election, u.
November r'..l, but 10 allow them 10
vie mrfrait,I. lhIs VIA, clearly
showuiu 6gvuJI II Di tbs bCHudglr D..
the Constitution. judge huifl.t tslu
IBWUuiu Mo % wrlu.p Opinion, EuNru'
Ing the Jus meat VI the IUW,r court,
JulgH klug uGll uo wac uubolu Il
assent { any VI tuu yiuwu gI thu Ht'
osIOn. lie REGARDED them ~ uHvfiy
T;uglaut 20 tho pTOvisiOun OF tla
enabling Agl tud Of tuu tlua,lu,iuu,
lie regarded that tue EimuuJt. Fucker
act Was not p.1uludiuu VI women
y.tlug ON tuu COuftiIuu0u; ne upasiI,
ETC.. lut view " t.u myuuty % 90,
gJIn ~ absolutely "fDhs. h'
90 not believe tue purputv Ui tht
J. mundi-Iuckcr act was 10 hnyr buy
ttpul upOu yolots Tor SlAtc ufiicJts NJ
0u The Constitution, lat huu Uvvu, u
was ,uprftu4sd uy tho enabling Nei.
That net hAd permitted uiaiILuu Aibe
Clais 10 vito Tor uelegsle' 10 tie CoG'
YelU0n and on the COuaNtusl OD, bViul
~ enlargement OF the iIAuchibc. A
tue election for delegates, only male
could vote, uut uuqutd.O.'
ably Congress delegated to a.,
Constitutional Convention tho pl"el
Of pttsctUinR the oirciniai'
Al the met eivCuun TOT STATE tillDrU
snl on tho Constitution, That was .
lowtf which tu1 people Of tbs S1att
alone had the hight " exercise. ib'
llopO,ed voters Of the STATE, Judg'
hlug thought, were those VIM wut'
eniiAuuhittd by tno Constitution, ~
c.ullng mNlts ana iemnlcs. IL Was Ia
province Of TIC CunsulutiOI- unEeGs 4
uvine tue electorate, ana tnoy ha'
slnt so, classifying men nuJ w0meI
~ c,tGsur. lie regarded Hs ~
sOaurlWy tho ruling that Nomei
Wrtu LiriTnnchised, wntcA Tullul
u'lfiEud every principle OF con
stucugn, aud was WTOng, Ito Tegarg
81 Voc pr0vieD IN stClUu IL VI tll
schedule ia the Constitution 40 r0pug
hAht 10 article I, n II was 70 DO ,gkgl
Ma Elb.IluuDn. However, GB NUul
LoI tAtn u "a such Teslrlullvu, bu
merely 10 dehne that SUCH ponOn
1hould VOTE. 10 ssy That the wUmvl
thlull be dislTanghited NJ this e,vJ
u'n De- regarded W wrong and on Oul
rage.
Judge Bar.ch said no c1ncurrsd /
,ue opinion u thu chief justice, uud q
Tue hdmunuE, uCksr nCt,
NNAb forehisu tOr tbs purpose at "a
uNApllhp gcl, II was repealed iyr q
lulp0aet, lie dlH not bglleyg IN
Llmund'-lucktr act WAS Tsp0Rl0I ,
al' IN tuib special case, the ffAaChli
was extended, but all the acts u
,halheu IN l0ice, auu " the COnstiy'
Uoh ihiled, then this EdmunaB.I uok,
tol remained iu IuTce.
OA houon ui Auuut Brown, A.
hFuDli ol Ogden was admitted 10 u
mar VI the Supreme court.
hemaik Suyhrr WAS "a imil;ed to q
ua.' on tho favorable ToiUr VI tue g!
Em,nlnR commit De-, thiuuEn JUDI
Henderson.
At los, m. '' ~ - '''''' 90
---7==s==