davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
St. Paul daily globe. [volume] (Saint Paul, Minn.) 1884-1896, 1895-03-02

Q. Are you still attended by dep.
uty? A. i am by Deputy. Maish.
Q. Where do you board now?
Mr.. Hall objected. Objection sus-
tanned.
Q. Are you still boarding at the ex.
pense of the state?
Objected to, and objection sustained
Q. You say you had nothing to &C
with this murder of Catherine Cling:
A. Nothing whatever.
Q. Where were you on the night OF
the murder? A. Over at Mr.. Cham.
berlain's portion of the evening.
Q. Where were you at 6:15? A. Al
my house
@. Where were you at $50? A. In
my fat
Q. At fifteen minutes to where were
you? A. The same place.
Q. From that time to s?
The Court-This has all been gone
over once.
Mr.. HALT is not proper ground for
Impeachment. I move it all be stricken
out.
The Court-You must object at the
time to the questions, not after.
Q. Between three minutes of and
quarter after on Dec. did you not
come out of the Ozark flats and &C
across Hennepin and walk past Will.
lam Kennedy on Thirteenth street?
Hall objected to this as as immateria
and irrelevent. Objection sustained
Q. Did you not at that time have or
your overcoat?
Objected to and objection sustained
Erwin-Then 1 move to have the testi
mony of Adry Hayward struck out, i
he had nothing to do with the murder
his direct testimony, as l cannot cross
examine on that.
The Court-It will be struck out.
Mr.. Hall-Then move this cross-ex
animation of the same line be strucl
out.
The Court-Yes, 1t will be.
Redirect by Mr.. Hall - You heard
your father say he had a number of S
bills in the safe? A. Yes.
Q. What did you say to Bridell il
the cell at the time your attention has
been called? A. Well, he said to me
Your name is Adry Hayward, ism
it? Now, 1 come from the North, ant
my advice to you is that you JUS
stand pat l said my statement na(
been made public, but he still told me L
stand pat. -
Q. Did you use any such language a:
has been asked you? A. / said 1 die
not know that Harry was guilty, and
don't know it yet
St. Paul daily globe. [volume] (Saint Paul, Minn.) 1884-1896, 1895-03-02
WEIGHTS OF CARTRIDGES.
Different Makes Vary to a Con.
siderable Extent.

Dr. F. A. Dunsmoor, the well-known
physician, was the next witness. The
doctor was examined in regard to the
states theory of the fractures Of Miss
Ging's skull. He gave it as his opin-
ion that the states theory was posi-
bic. After abiding to his twenty
years experience as a physician and
surgeon, the skulls used in the ex-
animation of DR.. Nippert were pro-
duced, and Mr.. Jaeghe, Kennedy
Brothers gun expert, was recalled.
Have you made any further in
designations as to what makes of
cartridges will fit Colts IS revolver"
Il have; the United States Cartridge
company, of Lowell; the American, of
New York; the Manchester Arms COM
pany. and others, all make cartridges
that will fit them"
Can you give us the weight of lead
in the various cartridge ballS?'
The witness had catalogue, but was
not permitted to read from 1t.
The witness had weighed the Union
Metallic company's and the Winchester
Arms company's cartridges, ''3S short
and "38 long" The Union Metallic
Cartridge company's mo So short"
similar to those taken from the re-
volyer, weighed 124 grains; the Win
chester Arms company's "3S short"
weighed 12S grains. The ''38 long, of
the same make weighed $50 grains,
while the "3S long, of the U. NJ. c.
company weighed 153 grains.
Now, is the weight of lead in the
bullets of the uniform make of car
tridges the same, or does it vary?
This was objected to, and Mr.. Hall
turned his attention to the diminution
of weight which pistol balls undergo
after being discharged. But it was
found that this matter had been gone
into previously.
May it please the court" said Err
win, there are some cartridges here
on the table that annoy me. They
were taken from Harry's revolver, and
one of them has already been lost"
To relieve Erwin's mind, the car
tridges were taken and sealed up.
The examination of the skulls hav-
ing been finished by Drs. Dunsmoor
and Nippert, DR.. Dunsmoor was called,
and Mr.. Hall said he wished to read
him a hypothetical question.
St. Paul daily globe. [volume] (Saint Paul, Minn.) 1884-1896, 1895-03-02
Expo and Capitol Talk.

subscriptions are still coming in to
aid the scheme of reorganizing the ex-
position company. The stockholders
are proceeding on the theory that they
will have an organization effected if
the other scheme does not pan out and,
If it does, there will be no harm done
by their subscriptions. All are en-
thusiastic over the capitol idea, and
accompany their subscriptions with
the statement that they will gladly do
nate the stock they hold if the offer OF
the company is accepted.
Another good site for a capitol build
ing has been discovered by c. II.
Maxcy, who suggests that Loring park
would make an ideal location and
could be donated to the state entire.
It's location is near the business sec
ton and near some of the finest public
buildings, yet it is roomy and not sur
rounded by press of business houses.
The estimated value of the tract is
81, 200, OG0.
St. Paul daily globe. [volume] (Saint Paul, Minn.) 1884-1896, 1895-03-02
Present For John Day.

Last night George N. Morgan post
assembled a large number of old war
horses, and in the course of the evening
presented John Day Smith with a soken
of their esteem and good will. The gift
was beautiful steel engraving of the
battle of Gettysburg. the only one in
the world of it's kind, and considered
to be the finest picture of that battle in
existence. 1t was procured at great
expense and much trouble, and was a
suitable memoir for the occasion and
one which the recipient will prize high
ly. Mr.. Smith responded in q few appro-
pirate words, after which Capt. Sam
Van SAINT and number of others spoke,
including number of ladies from the
Relief corps.
St. Paul daily globe. [volume] (Saint Paul, Minn.) 1884-1896, 1895-03-02
SAW MISS GING.
Old Man Ford Saw Her on Her
Journey to Death.

James Ford, the old man who keeps
the cigar stand at the northwestern
corner of First avenues north and Fifth
street, was then called. He was SO
infirm that he had to be supported to
the witness chair by three men.
Examined by Mr.. Hall-Did you see
Catherine Cling on the night of Dec.
8? A. Yes.
ness about o'clock? A. Yes, / was,
and, looking out of the window, I saw
a piece of wood fall from a team,
and went out to pick it up. 1 saw the
buggy come by me then, and the horse
passed within two feet of me. She
stopped the horse and said, whoa"
and then drove on again.
@. What direction did she turn as
she came up Fifth street? A. She
passed me at the angle of the road
going towards Sixth street.
Q. What rate of speed was the horse
going? A. AS she passed me she
pulled the horse up, and it almost
stopped, and then, when it started off
again, it went almost into a gallop.
Q. Did you see the rig as it went
down First avenue north? A. Yes, 1
: stood there and watched it.
@. Can you tell anything of the
! description of the horse and rig? A.
The horse was a peculiar-colored one
what I should call a dapple buckskin.
! The top of the buggy was dark, and 1t
had red wheels.
@. What occupant was there in the
buggy? A. A lady.
Q. Who was the lady? A. Miss
Cling.
Q. How was she dressed? A She
had on sailor hat and seal-skin
sacque.
Q. Do you recognize in the court
room any one you ever saw at that
corner?
Erwin objected. objection sus-
tanned.
@. On the 10th of November, did you
St. Paul daily globe. [volume] (Saint Paul, Minn.) 1884-1896, 1895-03-02
HARRY AT SUPPER.
Takes n Sip of Soup and Jumps
for the Door.

Takes Sip OF Soup and Jumps
for the Door.
Mrs. Mathes was next called and ex-
amined by Mr.. Hall.
Q. You have been taking your meals
at the boarding house Thirteenth
street south? A. Yes.
Q. What time did you and your hus-
band go to supper on the evening of
Dec. 3? A. About quarter to 7.
Q. How soon after you sat there did
Mr.. Hayward come in? A. Some time
after.
Q. Was he alone? A. He was.
Q. How long did he stay to supper
that evening? A. a very short time.
Q. Do you know if he left quickly?
A. Yes, he left very hastily.
@. Can you give the time he left? A.
I should think a few minutes after Z
he came in, and he could not have been
/ there more than eight minutes.
Q. Were you surprised at the man
| ner he ate supper? A. Yes, he ate a
| couple of spoonfuls of soup and did
not take anything else, and seemed to
| jump out of the door.
| O. Who was left in the room after
he left? A. Only my husband and my
! self.
@. Did you return to your home i'm
mediately after? A. Yes.
Q. Where did you go that evening
| A. 1 spent the evening at home.
| @. Did you see Adry Hayward?
Erwin objected and the question wa
withdrawn.
Cross-examined by Erwin.
/ Q. Are you sister of Mrs. Adry
Hayward? Al am.
/ Q. Is there a feud between the
Chamberlain and Hayward families
A. 1 don't understand you.
/ @. Do you exchange calls? A. Not
! very frequently.
Q. Between you and Harry there
| has never been much friendship? A.
| AS much as there has been opportunity
for.
@. You left the supper table about
| 7:25? A. 1 reached home at 1920.
Q. How do you remember so dis
| tinctly what time he came there? A.
1 don't remember the exact moment he
entered the dining room.
@. What was his attitude at dinner
that day? A. He was agreeable.
@. What time did he come into din
/ ner? A. Some time after we were
| there.
@. What time did he come to break
fast? A. l don't breakfast with him;
4! @. What time did he come into sup
! per the Saturday evening? A. Late,
it was after we were in.
/ @. How long would it take you to
get home? A. Probably two minutes.
; @. How came you to remember 1t
! was twenty minutes past z when you
| got to your house? A. Because my
! father was there to spend the evening.
| Harry admits himself that he left
| the table at 1922.
Redirect by Mr.. Hall-Was there a
| similar occurrence on the Saturday
| evening?
j Erwin objected and the objection was
sustained.
St. Paul daily globe. [volume] (Saint Paul, Minn.) 1884-1896, 1895-03-02
THAT II RAIL AGAIN.
Father Hayward COntradicted in
an Important Particular.

Father Hayward COntradicted in
an Important Particular.
Hans Ell nghans was the next wit
nees examined by Mr.. Hall.
@. Where cid you work up to June
or July # as. year? A. For w. w.
Hayward at the Ozark flats.
@ What did you do there? A.
had TO clean the CRATES.
Q. Turing the spring time of the
wear the fire was kept up in the fur
naCe? A Yes.
@ Were tn. crates there new or
buried tut? A. They were new.
G. Do you know anything about a
T rail being put in at any time while
you were there? A. Not while 1 was
there
@ But WAS there not an iron put in?
A. Yes. in the Loiler
& Where was that bought? A. At
Manscn's
Q. Did you go with w. w. Hayward
to buy that rail? A. I did.
@. What kind did you get? A. A
piece of plate iron, % by sc.
@. During the latter part of April or
May did you go and look for the iron?
A. Yes, about the first part of May.
@. Where did you go for it? A. We
went to several places before we could
find what we wanted.
Q. Up to the time you left in June
was there any piece of T rail in the
furnace CRATE at the Ozark? A. Yes.
@. When was it put there? Alt
was there when I came. Feb. l. Ic
Q. Was it there when you left? "A.
Yes. st
Erwin ask that the entire testi-
mony of the witness be struck out. BOZ.
The Court denied the motion, but
later ruled out all testimony in regard
to irons for the boiler.
CroSs-Examined by Erwin
Q. Did you have anything to do with
repairing the boilers? a. No, sir.
Q. There is rail in one of the
boilers? A. Yes, sir. -,
Q. How long is that rail? A. About
four feet or a little over btel
Q. Who put it there? A. 1 don't
know. {5a
@. When did you notice It? A. Tie
second night I was there. 'hiA
@. Are you not a drinking man? A
No.
Q. Were you not in the habit of get
ting intoxicated and Mr.. Hayward paid
your wife instead of you, which made
you angry? A. No, sir.
St. Paul daily globe. [volume] (Saint Paul, Minn.) 1884-1896, 1895-03-02
DUNN AND NIPPERT.
Pair of Doctors Called in the Aft
ernoOn.

DIR. J. H. Dunn was the first witness
called after recess. Mr.. Hall asked
him a number of questions about lat
eral fractures to the skull caused by
gurshot wound, to which Mr. Erwin op-
{ected and was sustained by the court.
=. Do you know whether the skull
Of q woman is thinner thln that Of
man? A. 1t generally is.
Q. Give your reasons for the answer
you gave to the first question / put to
you. A. 1t is my experience that wher.
a skull is fractured by moderate Vio-f
lence it is not so severe as when there
is more violence.
@. If the skull of the murdered wcIn-.
an had been perforated with bullet it
would be more easy to DE fractured by
fall?-
Erwin objected. Objection sustained.
The witness was not cross-examined.
DIR. Nippert was then called and ex-
amined by Mr.. Hall:
Q. You are the physician who for
| merly testified here and assisted at
the autopsy of Catherine Cling? A.
Yes.
@. Did you discover any evidence
along the track of the bullet of any for
eign substance? A. Yes, I found small
particles of lead.
@. Scattered throughout the head?
A. Yes, about the center of the bullet
wound.
| Q. Was it substance to attract
your attention with the naked eye? A.
| Yes.
Q. These pieces of lead, were they
on the bone?
! Erwin objected.
| @. Then describe the lead. A. They
were small particles lying all around.
| George Henry Payette, an A. D. T.
| messenger boy, was then called and
examined by Mr.. Hail. 9l
| @. You remember being called ION
| the Goth of November to the Oneida
| block to deliver a message? A. Yes.
Q. Who gave you the message there:
| A. The elevator boy.
@. Where did you take that mes
| sage? A. To Room Go, Syndicate
| block. ~
@. What time did you go for it? "A.
| At 2:4O. sa-,is.ua5
@. Did you get an answer? A. Yes.
| @. Who did you deliver the answer
| to? A. Mr.. Harry Hayward. r ie-
| @. Have you the ticket of the mes
sage? A. Yes.
The ticket was produced and put in
| evidence.
@. Who signed that ticket? A. Mr..
! Hayward.
Cross examined by Erwin
| @. Who did you deliver the mes
sage to at 60 Syndicate block? A. To
| Miss Cling.
| Q. Did you deliver any other mes
| sage that day? A. Not to her.
@. How many boys were there en-
| ployed about that time of the day? a.
| About fifteen.
| @. You say you got this note from
the man who ran the elevator? A. Yes,
| sir.
Redirect by Mr.. Hall-was there an
| other message delivered that day to
] Miss Cling? A Not that / know of.
St. Paul daily globe. [volume] (Saint Paul, Minn.) 1884-1896, 1895-03-02

see the defendant enter a buggy with
Catherine Cling at that same corner?
Erwin objected. Objection sus-
tanned.
Cross-examined: How long have you
been sick? a. Since the 9th of Janu-
airy with la grippe.
q. How long ago were you visited
to find out if any one was on that cor
ner? A. A week or ten days ago
Q. Who came to see you? A. A
young man. j don't know his name
O.. After he came were you not Wis
tied by others? A. A deputy sheriff
came.
@. What kind of young man was
he? A. 1 don't remember.
Q. Was his name Ebert? A. I can't
remember that even.
@. Was the night light or dark?
A. 1t was not very dark.
Q. Do you recollect the character of
the weather? A. 1t was not very
! cold.
@. Where Is your place on the cor
! ner? A. Right at the corner of the
| ball park.
@. You were well that day? A. Yes.
@. What time was it the wood
dropped off? A. don't know.
Q. Where did the load come from?
A. 1t came up Fifth street
Q. Where is the livery stable? A.
| Near there.
@. This wood came up Fifth street
towards Hennepin? A. Yes.
| Q. And the stick dropped off where
| A. Halfway between the livery sta
! BILE and First avenue north.
4 ~ Il to- toll
up the wood? Yes, I did.
| Q. You started to go back to your
house with it? A. Yes.
/! Q. On your way back you heard the
| rig coming? A. Yes.
| @. 1t came up near to you so that
you could see who the lady was? A.
| Yes.
Q. You only saw the horse as it
passed you? A. Yes.
+ Q. Is your eyesight pretty good?
A. Yes.
@. You noticed in that short, time
that the occupant was a lady you had
seen before? A. Yes.
Q. Did you notice if she had robe
over her? A. Yes, she had.
Q. What made you watch SO long
after the horse passed you? A. i
wanted to see if the horse was going
to run after it passed me.
Q. After it crossed the car track
where did it go? A. l did not see.
Q. When you saw the horse trotting
nicely, why did you stand and watch
1t? A. Just to see where it went.
Q. 1t must have been moonlight for
you to see two blocks? A. Yes.
@. You never told any one about
this until this young man came to SEQ
you? A. Yes, did. l spoke about IL
the next morning.
Q. Who did you tell? A. Charles
Osgood, a man named Finch and
| others.
@. You never told the mayor or any
! officers? A. The mayor never came
! near me; L told Mr.. Arnold, a police
! man.
Q. What time did you next pick up a
stick of wood? A. 1 don't know that
ever did.
! Q. When do you recollect ever see,
ing horse passing again? A. Every
hour of the day.
Q. Did you notice a buggy go by
there today with lady in it? A. No.
Q. Did you ever give anybody this
| description till you saw this young
man? A. 1 don't know that L ever did.
St. Paul daily globe. [volume] (Saint Paul, Minn.) 1884-1896, 1895-03-02
HAYWARD NOT MENTIONED.
Louis Benin COntradicts the TIES.
timOny of james Ward

LOUIS behm COntraGictS the Tes-
timOny of james Ward.
Frank Smith, who said his real name
was Louis Benin, was the first wit
ness called yesterday morning. He
stated that he was foreman for M. d.
Wilson, the liveryman Benin was
called by the state to discredit James
Wards story Of an alleged conversa-
ton he had with Wilson in which the
latter had told Ward Harry HAYWARD
could never be convicted. Witness
said he was present and heard the con-
Versatlon with Ward, and was positive
Hayward's name was not mentioned
q. What was he talking about.
asked Hall. A. Mr. Ward he brought
IN chain, and wanted to sell that to
Mr.. Wilson.
Q. Was there any other subject Of
conversation talked over or men
toned between Ward and Wilson at
the time he was there? A. No. sir.
they were talking about the chain.
He wanted to sell his chain.
y. Nothing but his chain? A. No.
sir.
On cross-eXamination witness was
asked if he did not change the thill
in the buggy that day, and said he
could not remember. He did not go
out of the office while Ward was
there, and was present when Ward
left.
Q. Did Wilson talk to you yesterday
about it? A No, sir.
y. What brought it back to your
mind? A. Because the day book saws
that we sold horse right that dav.
y. Did you look it up after Won
were subpoenaed? A. No, 1 did not.
q. What I want to get at is this:
HAD you any recollection, or did 1t
ever occur to your mind about whether
there was any conversation between
wilson and Ward until yesterday.
when your attention was called to It
by your employer, Wilson? A. No.
sir, l never thought of 1t.
Q. And yesterday you got out the
book and looked the whole question
up and made up your mind about how
it was? A. I remember that time:
there was man there from North
Branch, and sold him horse that day:
and that day Mr.. Ward was there.
that evening.
Q. Did you hear any talk about fur
A4AIui bdSAiSSo lIldl udy NO, sir.
Earnest G. Gemach was the next
occupant of the witness chair. Ge-
mach was recently disabled in an ac-
cident and did not appear to have the
frame to back the combative DISPOSE
ton he evinced. He was called to i'm
peach the testimony of George Grim
dali, and in a very thin voice stated
that he saw Grindall in front of a
secondhand store on Central avenue
on the night of Dec. at about 7
o'clock
Mr.. Erwin, after being cautioned by
the court not to ask too many oues-
tons, read what purported to be an
account of row between GrindaIl
and other members of the Gemach
family. Witness said the trouble all
occurred in September. He was asked
if he was not chased by the Gemach
boys on the night of the murder, but
located the chase sometime in Sep
TENDER. He was rather hazy in his
recollection of other days than Dec. 3,
but he remembered the 4th very well.
What were you doing that day."
asked Erwin.
"sI was looking for GrindaIl."
what did you want to see him for?"
81 wanted to lick him."
He was asked how it was that the
murder brought SO forcibly TO his mind
his trouble with Grindall, and in reply
St. Paul daily globe. [volume] (Saint Paul, Minn.) 1884-1896, 1895-03-02

stated that he read of it in the papers
and that made him think of it.
Just by reading the paper the next
morning you were reminded of it?''
The face of the witness was study
at this moment. He breathed very
hard and Kissed fiercely: II think of
it and think of it, and God help the
man if ever 1 get WE'LL
St. Paul daily globe. [volume] (Saint Paul, Minn.) 1884-1896, 1895-03-02

tell the difference between sealskin
and black cloth? A Yes.
.. You don't deny you said to Mr..
Barnes you expected to be a witness?
A.. l might have said so.
sons about this light? A. No.
At this stage an adjournment was
taken until this morning at 9:30.
St. Paul daily globe. [volume] (Saint Paul, Minn.) 1884-1896, 1895-03-02
MRS. CHARLOTTE HAYWARD.

She and Adry Were Out Driving
the Night of the Twenty-seventh
of April.
At this stage the box of cartridges
was put in evidence.
The next witness called was Mrs.
Charlotte Hayward, the wife of Adry.
Examined by Mr.. Hall-Have you
any recollection where you We're on
the night Of April q? A. I was out
driving with my husband
Q. What kind Of a vehicle did you
St. Paul daily globe. [volume] (Saint Paul, Minn.) 1884-1896, 1895-03-02

OUR PRICES ON Stoves RANGES AND OUTFITS Few oe edq NsS s sa
in
let Av.M
Alexandria gazette. [volume] (Alexandria, D.C.) 1834-1974, 1895-06-25
sArexa,,taria 6aztttf,
TUESDAY EVENING. JUNE %, 1895.

WOMAN AT A WILD HOG s MERCY
Near Tallahassee, Fla, Saturday alter
noon Mrs. Esther Moore was attacked
by a wild hog, and nearly torn to pieces.
The woman and her little daught-
err had gone out to pick berries, and
were busily engaged when the animal,
with fierce grunts, charged upon them:
The child fed, but her mother tripped
and fell, and in an instant the hog was
upon her, tearing her with its sharp
tusks. Every thrust tore the flesh in a
horrible manner. One thrust entered
near the woman's right ankle, ana e1 t
tended to the thigh, cutting the n Ts !
as razor would have done. ine
little girls screams attracted Mr.. Jonn-
son. who happened to be near, and a ne
rushed to the spot and shot the animal.
The woman had been wounded IN
score of places. One thrust from the
hos tusk had entered the side, and
penetrated the lung, making mortal
wound. Her clothing had been torn
off and her shoes were cut to shreds
The animal was magnificent specimen
of its kind, weighing more than 2o0
pounds. Its tusks were extremely
long, hard as steel and whetted to a
sharp point.