davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
New-York tribune., 1894-02-28
Toronto, Feb.
CLASS LEGISLATION.
he Editor of The Tribune.

To the Editor of The Tribune
Sir: As American who loves the institutions
OF my fatherland and resents any departure from
the old. true and high tone OF our democracy. /
have patience with this thrusting OF the
idea OF class" into things American. and especially
the attempts being made to recognize. in the legis-
lation OF Congress. that there is such thing as
class here
Such idea does not seem to have entered the
minds OF the writer's OF the Constitution at al. To
be they took that nothing in the nature
Of nobility should ever get foothold here,
but their minds then filled with horror OF the
especial hereditary nobility that had been the worst
adversary Of freedom. They knew nothing of any
antagonism between poor and rch-or they did
not recognize it, Both were, and are now. Amer
leans.
The idea Of "class" and the antagonIsm that has
been kndied and stirred and famed up to such
heat between rich and poor Conesdedy, may be)
are both foreign importatOns. So Is the idea that
legislation should be favorable TO the one at the ex
pense OF the other SO are al ideas tnat tend tow
ard Socla ism whatever may have been their
personal and private fondness or care.essness FOR
one c.ass or tne otner. believe that the men who
tecive Tariff. who have believed in 1t, and won
fame as statesmen in connection with i, were aInD-
tious. IL nothing more TO benefit broadly, and with
respect and class the whole American people.
1t appealed broadly 10 both employer and en-
The income tax IS a measure calculated to favor
recommended because II does 50. Ii is amusing
though a gre. surprlse-that certain ones that
brayed most loudly and set Others Of their kind to
braying likewise about class legislation in the fall
OF 1852 In connection with the Protective Tariff are
now making most favorable brays over the income
They do not seem 10 have Sucn an
adherence Of Class legislation" after ALL now that
1t shines their way.
To one who is jealous for the Old landmarks
which fathers have set up the income tax has
too much OF a foreign smack about II for him to
stomach 1t already--smacks too much OF the kind of
talk one hears from the latest European mpOrta-
ton two DAYS after the landing and the taking
SEVENTY SIN
No Feb 10 1894
New-York tribune., 1894-02-28

expected to know much about 1t. As a mater ti
fact, the non-members showed a surprising knowl
edge OF life insurance They talked of it most en-
tertaningly and advanced ideas which the exreri-
enced agents applauded as interesting anl valuable.
As for the life insurance men themselves, they
talked largely of other subjects.
The toastmaster was George +. Eadley, fetlr nS
president Of the association AT MS SIDE sat Robert
Charles Emory Smith, Minister to RqsSIa Zen
asah ama S9 e. of r. pP4geP GepFfe Pbdp be
Rev. J. W Johnston OF Brooklyn; Calvin We.ls'
h1fe f. Robnson sw n n Gss RaGss am nfra 81 H. o1 Xgr
were also at the table of honor Tiidsn Blodgett
Of the Executive Committee he had borne 50 large
a share of the labors of the dinner that wherever
1t was a business mems dinner. and the speaking
began even before o'cock-ten minutes before.
Mr., Hadey spoke of the valuable work of the as,
Of his gratitude for his election to the presidency
had secured permission for American life insurance
companies to do business in Russia He was loudly
appauded. After some humorous stories he spoke
eloquenty of the good accomplished by the com
Methodist Episcopal Church of Brooklyn. was well
cor sOmd heartily nad when o Mr. HAD Hady n0need that
on his policies. Mr.: Johnston made an earnest adj
dress George T. Wilson was allied on from one OF
the lower tables. and his speech was full OF wit.
Mr. Ashbrook also spoke.
6. 1851. and Is a descendant of the famous gram,
marian. Lndley Murray - Entering the employ. of
the PrONluent l1fc ana Trust Company, as ONCE
boy. in 1868, at s. a week, he steadily worked his
way up, until he was made its New York general
agent in 1884. In this responsible position he has
succeeded in materially increasing his companys
business beyond the record Of any previous decade
of it's history in this city. Mr.. Murray is inde
fatigable worker, not only in the insurance bus-
ness but in whatever he undertakes. He has
served for several years treasurer of the New
York Bible Society, and was made its president In
1891. He is also active member Of various clubs
in New-York, including the Lotos Nineteenth Cent
ury and New-York Canoe. He has been
Der of the Life Insurance Association OF New
York, since Its organization, having served the
Executive Committee and a delegate to the
National Association. Mr.. Murray be de-
pended upon TO fill the chair to which he has been
elected with credit to himself and the association.
New-York tribune., 1894-02-28

The marriage is just announced of Rowland
Hoadey, a son Of the late Russell II. Hoadley. OF
this city, and Miss Adele Counsel eldest daughter
of Otto Suter. of Melbourne Victoria, n. s. W..
The wedding took place in August last, in st.
Stephens Church. Sydney, n. s. w, the Rev. Dr.
Langley officiating. Mr.. and Mrs. Hoadley
in this city.
One of the most recent engagements Is that Of
Miss Elizabeth Fish, daughter of Mr.. and Mrs
Nicholas Fish, to Robert Burnside Potter, OF
the late General Robert II. Potter. and nephew Of
Bishop Potter.
The marriage OF Miss Jennie Lyon Hamilton to
Hugh l.. Weber. OF st. Louis. will take place to-
night at the home OF the brides father, John l..
Hamilton, No. 3f6 West Twenty
Miss Sallie Wood Morgan will be married to-mor-
row at the home OF her mother Mrs A: L. Morgan.
No. IS West Fiftieth-st. to Walter Jefferson Levy.
The Rev DR.. Abbott Z. Kittredge. OF the Re-
formed Church, will perform the ceremony.
The engagement Is announced OF Miss Bertha
Allen. daughter OF Dr. Thomas f. Allen. TO Floyd
Ferris of this city
The weddipg Of Miss Mary L. Walker. sister Of
Mrs. II. de Il. Parsons and Mrs j. Howard VAIN
wright. and Charles Grenville Peters, son OF the
late Or. John G. Peters, has been set for April H.
New-York tribune., 1894-02-28
A PROTEST AND A SUGGESTION.

To the Editor OF The Tribune.
Sir The meeting OF the Republican County Com
mttee and the election OF officers last night
fitting climax 10 the greatest farce and most wlfu
deception that ever perpetrated the Repub-
can party OF this city. What a refreshing picture
must have been presented by the Honorable Jacob VI.
Patterson lovingly nesting under the protecting
wings OF the Committee OF Thirty and basklng
in the sunshine OF their smiles! Turn now and
look back upon that memorable night when Edwin
L. Elnstein cracked the whip and observe the Hon
orab.e Jacob covering under the lash How trans
parent the action OF the dignihed Counsel OF
Thirty" appears! These gentlemen feeling that, by
divine right, they were called upon over the
destinies OF their party. raised -. and cry
that the organization was corrupt, the district
leader must go. and that there be more
deals.
The meeting last night proved beyond doubt
that the very men pf whom the committee pre-
tended 10 purge the party were called upon TO fur
nish the list OF enrolling officers. thus practically
placing them in actual control. Does this show
beyond doubt that reorganization merely a
pretence on the part OF these honorable men? How
absurd and ridiculous the words deal" 'disrup-
tlon' and guerilla sound from such lips,
The Straightforward and we'll aning leaders OF
the old committee should discard the leadership OF
the former chairman and gain control OF the organ
ization. which they can easily accomplish II they
but sufficient courage, J. LYONS
NewYOrk. Feb. q. 1894.
New-York tribune., 1894-02-28
TROUBLES OF AN ARTIST AND HIS FAMILY.

An unusually sad case of poverty and sickness
to light Monday. when the wife OF Fred
erick q. Geary. an artist. ana her mother Mrs.
Susan Palmer seventy-five years old. taken
from their rooms at No. 229 West Twenty
and conveyed in ambulance 10 Bellevue Hospital
in the midst of the driving snowstorm. Mrs. Gesry.
who is fifty years old. suffering from melan-
cholia. and her mother was severely afflicted by
asthma and general debility. Mrs. Geary's malady
was brought through her brooding over the mis-
fortune and poverty from which the family
suffering. Mr. Geary. who comes from proinl-
nent family in Boston, able TO provide COM
fortably for his wife and her mother Till about six
months ago. by selling his paintings Since then,
account of the hard times" he has been unable
TO sell pictures enough to provide for them prop
erly and during the last two months a large part
OF the meagre sums he was able to realize was ex
pended for medicine and medical attendance.
They lived az the bOardlng-house OF Mrs William
Brown who kept the family as long she could
afford to- when Mr. Geary was compelled TO re-
move the women 10 the hospital, and seek shelter
for himself elsewhere.
At the hospital last night II decided by the
Medical Board OF Examiners that Mrs Geary was
insane She will be removed to the insane depart
ment Of Blackwels Island to-day.
New-York tribune., 1894-02-28
INCIDENTS IN SOCIETY.

Mr.. and Mrs. John J. Wysong. Of No. 30 East
Thirty -fourtql-st last night gave dinner party
which the last OF a series Their guests were
Mr. and Mrs. John II. Davis Mr.. and Mrs y.
Mortimer Brooks, Mr.. and Mrs L. Townsend Bur-
den Mr. and Mrs. Frank X. Pende:on. Mr.. ard
Mrs James F. Kernochan. Mr.. and Mrs Stuyvesant
FISH. Mr.. and Mrs Bradish Johnson. Dr. and idFs.
John McG. Woodbury. and G. Meade Tooker.
Frederic j. De Peyster few evenings ago gave a
dinner party at his home. No. 7 East Forty-second-
st.. for the officers of the Society OF Coonial Wars
Trevor Frederic Galiatin.. Dr. f. LIE Roy sattsrlee,
Judge A. r. Lawrence James NJ ysrnum' I; j.
wright s. Victor Constant, Frederick E. Haisht,
Thomas Ludlow Ogden. the Rev. Alexander Hainil,
ton, Charles H. Murray Philip l.. Livingston ana
The musical morning OF Albert Morris Bagby,
in the ballroom of the Waldorf on Monday, again
drew many fashionable people to the hotel Miss
sigrd Wolf, contrato. Of stockhom Arthur Fried s
snssrs msseon Mas sSn Ss1 in IN honor Of Mss wo
M Mrs 1oSiS john al zeTesa Miss Mamie Fled Miss Helen
King Miss Maruna Jonnsone the oWeuisn G 1,,ette to
Prince Lubeck, James j. Harrison ana Otls MY =
An interesting and enjoyable concert for The bene-
given last night at the home Of Mrs Anson Phelps Phelps
shown to seats by the uShfrs T Valentine e. Ha
Norman De r. Whitehouse. Henry Chauncey; ]r:,
fPa Hsnri SSiS MSreau victoT Herbet MIR a5d
Miss Hall In the audience we're Mr. and Mrs Xill-
J. Pierpont Morgan the Misses Morgan, Colonel and
cruser i Mr. ian and Mrs Robert Geeiet NJ and Mrs
W. Bayard cuttins Mrs. Frederic sheldon ,iNs Mr.
Slas ons Fish. dp'sS Mr. and Mrs % Charles pckeX IT,
nd M Mrs GeTap p Bner s !0Sn Mr. a. and Ms
William Rhinelander; General and Mrs j. Watts
q pd Nfra XVillia m, Iselin.
New-York tribune., 1894-02-28
DIED.

the Rev Marshall BuIlard Angler.
In,erment THURSDAY in Newburyport Mas
BESNESaIp Re, BrCoslyn o. Monday F'Sra,ry g isg
Isennsr. aged 10 years. months 10 days
9,h-st WEDNESDAY evening. February 2s. at O'clock
Tnterment at convenience of the family
BoYcE.A, her late residence. si7 West os,hst res-
First Baptist Chorcn. 7sth-si and the Boulevard
TssIasnss No g ws., aSt ssS-st Alexander cosnssi
Funeral services a, Trinity Chapel 2sths,
l, kindly requests. SS that mo- o@s. se cent
DENIKE-on Tuesday. February q, 1884, Emma duysr.
widow Of whit, Denke; in me ;2d year q her age.
on Friday afternoon. March 2. a, 2 o'clock.
FiTSHsIn wsshns'on D. G.. Monday. February y.
ssrSices al the resdsnes Of Ms Harvey sea.
No IL ParS-st.. Norwaik. Conn. Thursday at $40
Nsworeans Gs) Pueblo Cob papers please copy.
s,. FsSTgA ct ,r:ass :s Florence Hdd.
Funeral services her late residence MadisOnav~.
1t is requested flowers be sent.
HuNr-on February a his late residence. $50 PARK:
simmonds Hunt 8 Co. London. and simmonds .
Funeral from Grace Church. Wednesday. $50
riss to srics ics" chuTeh @ station """ '"''''''"''
JoNEs-on Monday. February ID, 1894. Georsianna n.
R:a'Iys: and friends are invited g, g attend The funeral
Thursday March I, at o'clock p
LATHRoP-On Tuesday February 81 1904 At his rcsis
dence No . West lsth-st., Henry Lathrop.
Notice OF funeral hereafter
Som 6 10. at m, bis residence g. we;s s.,n:
Funeral Wednesday at O'Clock
Please omit flowers.
LoYD-At Pianneld. n. j.. Monday February 2s 1894.
Mrs Elizabeth $. wife OF the late Isaac Lloyd. in hss
oath
Fuaerai services her residence Is washnston-
PSin!ield y. j. Thursday. March I. at $50 n
MORRis-Auglstus r. Morris entered Monday
February ~. 1ssi In his I'D
Funeral services his late residence. i2S Broadst.
bloomfield. ~ J.. Thursday March J. ct 80 y. m,
the arrival OF the i20 n train from Zoo, of Barclay.
Interment convenience OF the family.
PowELL-Edwin Powell. sunday February 25 1904 II
his s5th
Funeral services at his late residence whestone Long
Island wednesday. Fehruar, ~. 1894 230 p. M
Carriages VIII be In waiting Whitesone depot the
arrival OF train leaving Ions Isaod city at p. m.
PREYER-suddenly Monday. February ~. Charles II.
Funeral services on Friday March 2 at the Church Of
the intercession. lith-ave. and l5sthst at o'clock
Relatives and friends and members Montgomery Lodge
No. Is. +. and A. NJ Mecca Temple New-york; Hop3
SAINT Democratic Club Mnqua pemocratic Club Tam
many Han General Committee XXvIInh Assembly pis.
spectfuy invited attend
Tntsrment Trinity Cemetery.
Newhurg. n. y, February %, isp<
Amanda cuyier Tiffany, daughter OF the late wslto1
Street Stuotenburyh OF Coxsacke ~ u. and wife g
the late J. c. Tiffany.
Funeral private
VAILr-M New Market. n. j.. on Tuesday morning.
February "a. entered into rest. Duncan r. VAIL NJ D..
Relatives and friends invited attend funeral
services on ThuEday. March J. at 1890 m
Cortlandt or Desbroeses ST.. a. m. Returning leave
NEWMARKET at i2:OS.
New-York tribune., 1894-02-28
THE UNITED PRESS REICHING OUT
PROTECTING IT'S SERVICE AND GETTING NEW
CLIENTS.

PROTECTING ITS SERVICE AND GETTING NEW
CLIENTS.
Another practical step has been taken in the
movement to protect the service OF the United
Press and to continue the distribution of the news
to all clients and customers Four of the original
members OF the old Associated Press have signed
agreement to this effect among themselves and
the last legal paper for its enforcement was exc
cuted yesterday The four papers are THE Her
ald' The Sum-" The Tribune and THE Times"
This step. together with some others under
consideration by the clients and associates of the
United Press will result in the organization of the
leading newspapers OF the Atlantic seaboard into
an association which will not only cover the East
territory thoroughly than from a
news point of view, but will also insure additional
extensions of the service in Western territory.
Since the fact was made known that the United
Press service would be rendered all applicants.
excepting always at points that are protected by
existing franchises or contract relations, the de-
termination being to protect those to the fullest
Clients are ''rhe Baltimore Worlds "The Gin
The The Topeka 1Kan) Daily Press" The Youngs-
town (Ohlo) Vindlcator." The Kansas City World"
The Cleveland World The Aurora dll News"
wV. va5 Gazette" The Los Angeles CaiJ Teie-
gram" THE Chicago National Drovers Journal
and THE Olympia (Wash) Olymplan" The con-
tracts were signed yesterday, and there are other
karsas CITY, Feb H.-"1he World" of this city
a new afternoon paper, which was started here
the United Press. and will abandon the service ii
has been receiving heretofore
gan yesterday to receive the full day service OF
the United Press.
New-York tribune., 1894-02-28
NOTES or THE STAGE.

Charles Basse;t. the new tenor Of the Boston
ians. made his first appearance in the title part Of
Robin Hood" at the Broadway Theatre Monday
evening
A bronze statuette Of Columbus will be the ap-
propriats souvenir for the 250th performance in
New-York Of 1892" ct the Garden Theatre on Nom
day night.
Miss Lottie Gilson win appear on Monday at Tony
Pastors Theatre and will wear her Worlds Fair
gown This costume received the prize OF the
French exhibit
The Professional Performers Equity Club has
recently been incorporated. and is housed at No "a
West Thirty -hrst-st. In connection with the club
Is a general amusement agency to transact business
for its members without charge or commission.
Miss Laura Louise Waller gave a concert last
evening in the Mendelssohn Glee Club Hall, in
Fortieth-st She was assisted by Perry Ayerill
barytone; Victor Herbert. ceIlst and the Mem
delssohn Quartet Club.
Mrs. Sallie Birch. OF San Francisco was married
on Saturday to E. d. Price, business manager OF
Z. E. Rice's 'rf2' Company. by the Rev. W. C.
Willing. The bride Is the Younger sister Of Mr..
Prices former wife.
New-York tribune., 1894-02-28
ADMIRED BY THOUSANDS.
RECEPTION AT THE METROPOLITAN
CLUBHOUSE
THE MAGNIFICENT BUILDING SHOWN TC
rnfrNna OIL, TIE ,rMnrRs- -sOMH

THE MAGNIFICENT BUILDING SHOWN TO
FRIENDS OF THE MEMBERs-soMB
OF THOSE PRESENT.
The reception given yesterday afternoon and last
night at the new Metropolitan Clubhouse. at Six
ueth-st. and FIfth-ave.a description OF which has
already appeared in The Tribune-was great sue
1t entirely informal, there being no com
mittee 10 receive the guests though A. Newboid
Morris. W. Watts Sherman and William = "hi'-
ney spent part OF the afternoon In looking atter 'he
comfort OF number OF their friends. and escorted
some OF them through the different parts Of the
establishment Mr. Whitney and Colonel ). '. X.
Cruger conducted Mrs Cruger and Mrs Paran
Stevens about the various rooms. while John T..
Alexandra showed the nagnhcence OF the mousse 10
his wife and her mother. Mrs Alexander . "eoD'
The thousands OF guests roamed at Will through
the rooms and Railways. along which. here ana
there were stationed liyeried servants. Many OF
ihem chose linger in the great hall or IN the
large congregation-room overlooking Fifth-ave.
Among the many who visited and inspected the
house in the course OF the day and night were Colo
mel and Mrs William Jay, Mr.. and Mrs william william
about with Miss Cram Mrs. Ferdinand wilmerding.
ovea a and a4rmah Ms SG'f M M fs sG Mrs fa
meyer Mr. and Mrs. Perry Tiffany Mr. and nd Mrs Mrs.
Mrs George Henry Warren Mr. ,sa and Mrs George
and Mrs Robert Goeet. Colonel and Mrs F; d.
Grant. Mr.. and Mrs. Walter Suydam. Mr. and Mrs;
Cannon, Mrs Stuyvesant Fish. Miss Pomeroy.
Joseph Larocque, sr.. Mr.: and Mrs Charles Rus
sci, Hone, Robert Hone, Mr.. and Mrs. w Bacon,
OF London Livingston Beekman, f. G. Potter Mr..
and Mrs. Wilbur Bloodgood. Mr. and Mrs: Clarence
Winthrop Bovine, Mr.. and Mrs. Oliver Hartman.
Mrs. Richard Wallach. Mrs samuel Bargey Miss
Barger. Mr. and Mrs. J. Pierpont Morgan, Mr.. and
Low; Mr.. and Mrs. David King jTi Mrs; Mrs; Dudley
the Misses Sands. NJ. Genadius. the Greek Minis,
ter; Miss Gushing. Dr. and Mrs; Emmet. Mr.. and
Mrs McCoskry Butt. Mr.. and Mrs. Gllat Schroe-
der Mrs. J. Lyon Gardiner Mr and Mrs; James
Lenox Banks. Mr. and Mrs, Salem IL Wales. Mr.
s Day, General John P. woodward; Miss Virginia
Fair, Mr.. and Mrs. George II. Glover. Mr.. and
Mrs Brayton Ives, the Misses Ives, Mr.. and Mrs
H. Van Rensselaer, Kennedy; Mrs Isaac Bronson
Mr. and Mrs. b. Brakeman Miss Furnlss, Mr. and
Mrs l.. Il. Atterbury Mr.. and Mrs Valentine A. |
Blacque. Captain A. p Cooke, Mrs. Heoer Il.
Bishop Miss Bishop Mrs Cadwaader Evans, Mrs. |
Richard irwin Miss Perkins. Mr. and Mrs. c. b: |
Alexander Mr.. and Mrs. Archiband Rogers and |
Miss Morgan.
New-York tribune., 1894-02-28
MARX TWAIN AND mr. RILEY TO READ AGAIN

Mark Twain. James Whiicomb Riley and Douglass
sherley entertained another large audience at the
Madison Square Garden Concert Hall last evening
They presented the following programmed 'The
New Cure for Heartbreak." Mr. Sherey; Poems
Here at Home" Mr.. Riley; Innocence Abroad"
Mark Twain: Hoosier verse. Mr. Riley: The Brick
yard Master Dir. Sherley; "a Reminiscence
Mark Twain: "Old-fashioned Roses Mr. Riley
The audience seemed determined 10 enjoy every
thing that was provided for Il, and 1t was not an
especially hard task. The efforts OF the readers
were well directed and met n ready response Mr.
Riey's verse is not hard TO understand when Il Is
printed In book but In hearing him recite IL the
feeling of the moment is that the sound OF his voice
and his method Of expression necessary for the
perfect appreciation OF IL. Mark Twain too is able
to to add good deal 70 the efree, Of what he writes
by his voice ana manner so many people were kept
storm that i has been decided % give another
saturday night. II viii De in Chickering Hail. as
other purpose.
New-York tribune., 1894-02-28
SELECTIONS FROM THE MAIL.
Mn. GoIpwN SMITH AND ST. GEORGES
SOCIETY.
MIR. CAsTELL HOPKINS REITERATEs HIS FORMER
CHARGES.

CHARGES.
To the Editor Of The Tribune.
Sir: Just one word in reference 10 Mr. Goodwin
Smiths last letter He sayc the statement that
he used his nfe membership In ST. Georges So
ciety for political purposes Is absolutely false -
/ reitsrate the charge that he did 40. All the
proof necessary 10 adduce here is contained In his
very next sentence: Il was a member OF ST.
Georges Society at Washington well at To-
ronto. The society has branches on both
sides Of the line"
st. Georges Society has not branches on both
sides Of the line. The Sons OF St. George is an
American organization with charitable objects The
Canadian 81. George Society has the same gen
eral object. but its members are Englishmen and
British subjects. while the American society has Of
late urged its members 10 become American citizens
and very properly so. Efforts have been made by the
leaders OF the United States body 10 ind some
basis for union between the two. but the 81.
Georges societies in Canada have refused to
consider the matter. 20 I submit that when Mr..
Godwln Smith spoke to Englishmen in Washing
ton as he did February 25 OF last year-speak-
Ing in the same breath OF his love for England. his
desire for annexation. and in renee to the ST.
Georges Society and the Sons OF ST. George he
adds that they are not confined societies
to any particular allegiance"-he to all intents
and purposes using his membership for what is to
him political object.
Perhaps the best means Of showing the opinions
hed Dy all alike in the Toronto society is 10 quote
the compromise resolution moved by Mr.. Herbert
Mason. immediate Past President. leading inan-
cer and a social friend Of Mr.. Goldwin Smith. and
seconded by myself:
Whereas. 1t has been brought to the attention
OF ths society thaI Mr. Goodwin Smith, one OF its
life members. has openly proclaimed himself in
favor Of severins Canada from the rest Of the
British Empire, and has also accepted the office
Of honorary president Of association having
for rs object the active promotion OF an agita,
tion for the union Of Canada with the United
States. therefore. this society desires emDhaticdy
TO place on record its strong disapprObaton OF
any SUCH movement. and hereby expresses its
treme regret that tne society should contain In its
ranks a member who Is striving for object which
would cause an irreparable injury to this Domln-
ion. would entail n loss 10 the Mother Land o.
most important part Of ner Empire, and would
deprive Canadians of their birthright British
subjects.
This resolution was carried unanimously, and Il
is pretty hard on his personal friends in the
society that Mr.. Goodwin Smith should speak Of
the "magnity OF the attack" These the facts.
and do not intend to renew the discussion.
J, cASTELL HOPKINS.
Toronto. Feb. 70 l1l