The Hawaiian gazette., 1894-10-30

czN-cS q rE cC-zr 81 FEzAz, :,
ms S.s1c- VS. began IN Jciy.
1889. s-i rs rssc tired t-rse times
Il : s5se.-s-5 tc- lS-i 81 hxp&iS.
Exr z-.S-L-- hx-&. covered by f 2
49, L { L SS7I. 10 SSsE1- 0ns
q iEs tac C--EiCSl Gstscd2-1s.
L--S1. G1s,i csswes1 the second Sri
third -r-SLS Ii sSc1 t-Izl there
Es-s rEc EsS-sS-isSssCt Sri Siysrse
uoss,sssl--- the plz-ccLEs clSluloE b
TIE tCcE=z t5;ls. the isfs-isrts By
cc1E cI1lss- I1s Erss triSl resulted
II 5 vs-Gles toC the plaintiffs out
ms Wis set SSiis q The grUcud th&i
Il Exs cccrzry 70 the evidence on
IL 1ss-s y sivs<ss possession ;
L sE- go Ai scs second tr-A the
r-sss3lrE Justice directed 5 verdict
t-- sEs Gsts-isrts q the grUurd
.ksi he c-ss1C- q pedigree hSi
ceec settled II tcs.r tsvc- by DE-
s-se Y Probate Esis Cy Great
I-iEs McBCyiz II 1855 This ysr-
ties ~4s sci s-slis Cc the ground thSt
tss Czrrcii Judge hzi 10 jurisdiction
70 -xks TIE decree II question )
EE~- SIS A. the third trizI the yer
iics Ezs again f0- the plaintiffs
There ~xs sylis-es OF both sides q
sGcc l.s-s. 8-i. <Eo1gn 81 sxcsp
ti-- Ezs taken 20 sEs verdict s. CO..
.rz<y IL tie evlisCee. II Ezs p-zcEic-
sly shcc5C-ei II this Court The
sI.suGlC1 10. relied Cpoa : 10 ths
i-szrccsicc q The Court thzt The
+-y sEc-li Lssye O1t q their c rsId
s-slioc tE= decision u Jcfge No
B-yts II IS6S, tzi t1sy zrs Et Liberty
u consider the testimony q the
ElsEesses oet1-e hin EEo have been
shown 81 this riEl 70 hsEe since de-
ceased
Ire record shows tbzt the tssti-
Ec1y gwen n the p-utats case Ess
rsa.i - the Jury n this case, but
does MT st1= that the decree vas
CEEsi q pCi n eyIdeEee- TIE
trial Judge sri counsel, however.
=TiizEtLy regarded Il s. hsviCg been
ir-u6-ced- s-i sc shall 80 consider
Il especially - the result q O1r
t5czs-C- I'll be the =EEs-
Il : argued that the decree Ess
ziz1=z-c-s t1r shs1 Il AS worth
ECt = co-c-CslTe q peEnsps even
g-Iz15 -.zlS sTLisEcs Of What Il plE
porrs 10 sii1dieste. b1s tCr eeEIsin
C1E=E purposes. -. f1E IIssscee, 20
sl1F the e-z-zctsE II EElch the de-
tsciECt tlcE possession q 10 show
Il G3ClSsiCC - ec91IescsLcs o. the
part q Nlks- tie principal EItCsss
t-C tcs E-sEEiLEs, Ec0 vas sls0
=itE=ss II the pE0bs-s proceedings
and = The tslE=- u The plaintiffs
Ec0 Es-s tEsc UlECrs- q that he
iEsC gave testimony IrcCrsIstsaE
EliE thai EEich h NV giTes, q
tEst II uai= ID objection TO eTi-
1=ccs given ths1 foE the present de-
f=-isrs by CstsE witnesses. o. thst
II ECE tsszEss 10 tsess which th0se
=.iEssses- Il living. eo1Ii eoETUTsEt-
he trial .z1gs sppGr=1tly thought
tEsz tie dsEee sEo7li ts slsLsr si-
lifted q re,=cied SltE11t a1slifes-
t1E, E13 i does E1s sppssr that any
E5ii-4 e,11rse Ike tLsi ro% suggest
Sd by c11rs=l II this Court ~.s
Uos11ai 01t t1 LIN Al least ID IN
strueti11 70 that effect appears TO
EzT= b=e- requested
NJ case Ls= beeu CIts6 10 1= Which
E1as - tzE = 20 hIli that : decree
s-s,5lztzly F15i = 70 sl psrs0Lz i
z5EI=s5b-= f1E 81! p1rPcss what
sF=E. b15 e-Cced1Ig that E1Eh de-
E=e = s3zi=z1Cl=- lit ss eFIdslcs of
tE= Truth q IL o11ts1ts Cr Of the
tEE-= q which Il Ez= b1=e1- bit tJT
tE= U1rpcss q sLCEIEg the UeEs
tzeG that II ES usi= and whatever
= UECpeE.! IEf=Ezbl= fran that fsct-
~ 10 E1t Sc that sufficient cs1zs
RS b==c sEoEc II this ir=tsrez foz
grazing Esz trIzl-
IE= c=c-7s 15TlC1=-! hz= n besr-
Ug 1Co- u1et q tts points above
sc1o=rst5d- suggested by co1C==l -
r=zs1-= f5- Il= siDizsio1- Ire test
C1Cy gFs1 II tE= p-Obzts natter
=z= sICcs relevant ou tLoss poirts-
z1i this - ss have sssu- Fzs sll0--
ai . 20 20 tEs jury Ard e 70 tie
Cstsr p0irts- the dscrss end czr-
tsIuIy sdi b1t IitIs. Il any, to the
-=.gts q tL= othsr sTIdzcc4.-so
IIttle- iCdszi, that thsr= i ID rss-
Ell = beli=Ts that Ls5 tYisl,
Il grated =o7li res7lt II differ
euE Esr1ict- Tnsrs have ben three
iEizl= already Il this case and the
EsZ6ietz II TIE tsO E7buirtsj 70 the
iUF Esrs both f9r the plsintit=s-
Under ths czrca1=tzuces -e would
Eos b justified II further pEolOEg-
Irg tEIs lItIgztIsu- New trials are
TX % - grs ed t9r light rsz=crs,
especially zft=r - usuy trIzls have
zlr=zdy bs=z lad
Ics eIe@pIo1= are OT=ETalsd-
4 Rosa f7r plaintiffs; 4 s Hart
--Ff - T-s----=