The times. (Owosso, Mich.) 1882-1897, 1894-04-27
FROM WATER WORKS FUND.

=. -. n~o. -
r. 20
Citv Attv offered foIJowino renort which
80 o,do,aJ ra, i,,aa a., ,,,,,,,oJ.
was oiueieu rec Neo anu prin'eu'
tn the Honorable Mo,yOy. and Common,
/,,,.,afI - = ~, C,t,, oS O,naaao -
C0uhcu ~ Me cay OF Oao0sso;
Gentlemen; Your attorney would beg lief
tho C;ty of Owosso ~ y -: .aon a., 'o
s e,io ivy VI Owo,oU, daS peen deciueu ny tne
City and our CIV was sustained on every
point of law Ga;,na,, hv nc
- S 1 ~ 10. rn
Yours ETC., Ouell Cnapman,
Dated Apr. 23, '94. City Atty.
= s,,n,,,,, oo,,,,c o,,x,o,
T, ,o;n,r a,' Io NJ fhirt,, enr ,,oars
Pnlt ri ita apo1e ud " S Sats
VI ~, msiS a. nIS wa hnrsa aon n,bI,a strat
carriage draWn Dy one aSrse aong Prpc sdFee'
II, VIC o,'y i, ' tho same irac{,on Nr Pond
WIZ 1870. was -, Us ~ h;, SandarS ,u driy;n~ e.
a.sen,9teu ~ pa ass M nm. pd in ttat;a w. of
GO rbtad his borSa randw FORWARD The narties
raond fnr s a;stanea WHEN Mr. Pond ran over
Ia, s ~, ,d a.; Tie hIrh,ua~ iIs carriaga u,,s
=, s ma io;nt;lf thryu ont and ;ured
Tba nroofs are cIaar that Mr. Pond Knew that
buidng WAS bepr erected by the side s of this
were OUT IN tne sIreet IN iro, a, oi ~ ne sta.ea
the street was incumbered by such materials
anu lioush' siiat soinupou en-; nauo ~, w ioe
onS,e' & ~ ors tie rot 81 ,, me
than SIX miles an n a ~ the street, contrary 10
the ordinances g, OF the CITY: ..rs,, es s.
-, INT cuul. ~ ti; .se yy th ye o u ,d
te .iis oaS St tp s t t pt W nv
not nave been INJURED pui LOT ,lle negiect OF .hs
clly ~ sNo P,oge wais son .i,o pa ,int
Mpuip po @ f ~ ~ nnrtior "s
~ onu " ~ liz r W. a. s,,,
tis s'rSe. anu nee I It o,S e s a
sio amSi nc t MUM an, ~ 6u :o vi so's hosn
si a ~ cart ,.If tbe nIaint in this
ASaliii .e v ~, s"a". a., VIII pta ~ VT,
c.,S rs r, & o. viz pt i %
OIL nd ar fet 8n ~ That 70 him bv vant
Tiy entering ln.o the private conveyance Oh MI,
onu sns auop.eu we an ,D tl,o . ii,
Delng as eI ~ i On =; ~ .u s a
ana care Oh the person guiuing II; % YOU iiiio
tnat MI NE Ioha was negiigenne III urNhs ias'' 'ne
piahtiii coula no. IecoyeI; ,. a., s.on s,,. a.
me Jury re'urheo 'eruic' III i"'oi vi 'ie oe-
iem 1u, ..,o,, ,.,o.o,toa ,,,, tha hr,ae &c
Inc Oily luese,oii Ros s. ny d J oi of
pisii cVuhso, - ~ tt ,iniS,ty73s T,,Js
question que was settled in the Affirmative in Lake
Shore Michigan southern R'y GO. vs.: Miller;
has fv mot not since been DEPARTED from. "'
Counsel claims that some doubt has been cast
upon inns 9octrihe ny some oi ,ne ia'eI @ '
IN tbat case child three Years Of ace was r,ln
over s by y an engine upon railroad operated by
defendant as receiver. The question was raised
Wne,her Ine ~ ~ .e ,'n ,ta
70 ffbe child MI. Justice Morse held that such
negligence was not imputable to the child. The
other Justices expressly no OPINION on tna, Pon..
the a,,esfion whether the negligence of the par.
ents was lmputabe to a child three years of age
was again presented; and upon full hearing L
was I'VE a oos pntahe n tHe cSild ' 0tbl
er cases of like Character have been presented to
this court, Involving that question, and the rule
action ton for negligent Injuries, the negligence of
the parents cannot be imputed TO IT. a,cor,.
oueston Here nerspn Of the ACE of dscretion
voluntarily enters private conveyance of an
other TO ride and by the careiessness Of that per
son - recowar IN bas hae
too long Settled to be now disturbed In Schind-
Ter VS. R'y Co.. 81 Mich. 4io the rule was recog-
nlzed Twas there sad OF tne Miller case 81,
lownS IN ' tbs state The rule was also recoe
nized by this court in Cowan VS.. Muskegon R'y
Co; g Mich. 5ss. ,
The Street Commissioners report for the