The Globe-republican. [volume] (Dodge City, Kan.) 1889-1910, 1894-03-02
HAWAIIAN REPORTS.

The Senate Committee On Foreign Res
tions Submits Three Reports Various
Opinions offered
WASHINGTON. Feb Ex-senator Nor
gan. chairman of the senate committee
on foreign relations, has presented to
the senate the. majority report on the
investigation of that committee into
the Hawaiian complications. 1t Was
prepared by Mr.. Morgan and concurred
in by Messrs. Sherman, Frye, Dolph.
and Davis. the republican members of
the committee, who also make a sup
Elementary report, taking more posi-
tive grounds than the Morgan report.
while Messrs Butler, Turpie, Daniel
and Gray (democrats) submit a minor
ity report
Mr.. Morgan first gives a review of
the investigation, declares that the
president has perfect right to act as
he did and the change of policy must
be held to be a change of mind of the
responsible head of the government
He holds that this country exercises
moral suzerainty over Hawaii which
must be entitled to demand of the
United States indulgent consideration.
if not active sympathy. in her efforts
to secure full release from an odiOus
monarchy.
Mr.. Morgan holds that the investiga-
ton showed that when Minister Stevens
ordered the landing of the Boston's
marines there was complete paralysis
of the executive government in Hawaii
and there was reason to fear that Amer
leans and other foreigners might be
put in peril at any moment The
queen. he believes, has. by her act in
deciding to absolve herself from the
constitution of 1887. abdicated COM
pletely, if the people chose to so regard
it, that constitution and the queens
oath to support it being the only
foundation for her regal authority.
She had been kept on her throne only
by the fOrbearance of the whites. who
own $50. 900. 900 worth of the property
of the islands.
The report holds in part that where
there is no legal power to protect
United States citizens no law of ma
tions and no rule of country can right
fully prevent the American flag from
giving shelter under armed protection.
and thus the landing of the Boston's
troops was perfectly justifia bic. 1t de-
clareS that the purposes of Minister
Stevens and Capt. Wiltse We're legiti-
mate and in good faith, despite state
ments to the contrary.
The republican members, after agree
ing to Mr.. Morgan's report, submitted
a minority report as supplemental aud
more fully expressive of their views.
This holds that the appointment
of Mr. Blount without reference
to the senate was unconstitutional;
that the placing of the United States
naval forces at Honolulu under the
control of Mr.. Blount and later of Mr.
Willis was without authority of
law; that Mr.. Blount had no right
to order the lowering of the United
States flag over the Hawaiian govern
ment building and the withdrawal of
the troops, because they We're there
not for protectorate, but to maintain
order and protect Americans, and the
withdrawal created distrust; that the
udt& " Tcoptu
determined questions as to the status
of the provisional government and mon
archy; that the Hawaiian government,
recognized by this and other nations,
had not asked for or consented to the
presidents mediation nor had it been
requested to consent; and that there
was no question of the purpose of the
president to endeavor to reinstate the
ex-queen by constitutional methods
The democratic minority dissents
strongly from that portion of Mr.. Nor
gan's report which holds that the only
substantial irregularity in the conduct
of Mr.. Stevens was declaration of a
protectorate. They hold that there
was no justification for interference in
Hawaii any more than in any other
state or nation
Messrs Butler and Turpie present
brief report in favor of annexation of
Hawaii under proper conditions. though
not under those existing at present
AFTER WILLIS.