The Hawaiian gazette., 1894-06-08

OPINION o. TEE COURT BY FEEAS, =
This i 50 sppssI from decree
ordering specific p-OfO-uS1ce Of sn
agreement fUr 81 s1chsnge q lsSSss-
Ths defense : tSOflli. first. ihst
there Vas 10 eCrtrsc-. sni secondly,
thss the stsruis q frauds was not
couulisG with
Whether there wSs S eCrirsct CT
ro. 6eusris CpCC whether the WI.
ter Cfs- q April 8, 1898 made by
TIE defendant wss sccsp;sd Cy the
plzinuE 4 lev days 81 81 tie ~
csiu. q tie oEs- by the VlsiutlE
ecrpo-z--c, Is directors held s
nesting s1i voted % sccep. L
I--e6is-s,y G:ssr the meeting the
Z shifts usCsE-r. according 70 his
Csc testimony. called upon tie de-
fs-lE--'s hen pres dent EEl notified
hi- C.S.lv thar the --+a- vs. scc-p;
81 b- the 7. ,---L- he G-ts-LSu-'S
PES dent dos IT remember this
bar s1-ItS that u Csy % tue !
similar -rzl notice = acceptance Sd
p=s-s % czve been given 5 few
weeks later Cy the plaintiff secret
Sry . lie lzts-6srI's president,
si-E-cE1 tEs-s : some GlEarCCcs q
opinion - % JUS; what wzs SID 81
tksc tine There : ne evidence
tEz- OF several sCCssq cent occasions
TIE 6s:rcdzr;'s president inside
sssts--L-s - the plzIutlEs CEcsrs
tending 70 scCE that the tI-ue- con
siSsrsi the contract closed and bird
IrE- Bat q ore occasion II parEIc
ulzr. - sLEu 81 the testimony Of
thrse q the plsiuiIEs CtScsrs, ;
ueelrE US held By these three
oEcs-s 2ud TO q Cefe1dsus's
oEcs-s - the request Of the Isrtsr.
t5e C5i-c- o which vas - obtain s
relss>e from the eocsrsct, the reason
f. this being that the descendant
lad purchased q =zs about 20 pur-
c1zss certain CcCsr property n Zee
simple upon ylfc1 70 erect lis electric
wJ-ks ard -1sre.- - Ez1 70 further
uSs The l-a-eEC.l prem So The
tse,l-1uy q t1s plaintiffs cEcs-s.
eC-rl or s-si - Z : 81 tie conduct
OF iefe-isrt's CE-cers. clearly esizt-
EsEas tie cC--Tscs- Tie Go15s upon
this question II the mind q iefsud-
Srr's Urs-iisC-. EC1 WEs the Ccly
witness f-r tn t=tScss. suUesrs 10
have sr5ssc t-C- his idea that the
sccsC-Erc= ms o n writing II
did Il EI->zlf goes - far - 70 say
ttsr ASIDE fru- tie tz-. TIA. he kzi
received ID written sCsEsE be 6slleF-
81 CEul rscsErsy that the contract
va binding lis b-ICEs = % the
secuui ErJ-ci q defense E1ich :
ths- TIE statute q frauds reo 1Ired
tts contract = t. sigred b. the
plsiC.zE sE-L - D. the defendant
TIE s5ssl.s requires the cCu-
trzcs to -ue slgr=c By the party 70
d eLs-xei tLsreEIlL This can
rsz- Only TIE G-fsC1zEt. EEesLs-
vsci-r q vsc1se. lessor q lessee
b. tbs express terms = sEe statute
II teE o. TIE UCI--d States TIE
c1.trzes mus D s-gu@d 5y the party
EE1 : 70 make the clCTeyzccs-
Eh-th=r uIzIutIE q dsf=ztzEs- B1l
uriz- CTR sisZs1e- a. E=li slUCs5
ur1t1ruIy C-1er SIMILAR stsl1res else
ztzrs. uu5s-s The terms Of the GU
trze- 5-ss-f require tEs siglz.1re q
tc.1 parties q q tie one Wa after
zsr,fs b=auzs uIsi-sIE- The siScs-
turs e The defendant alone :
suEs5s-t- Z 2 Il : the party u &c
charged Tcers must b uCE1zIIsy
Ct co1Erze5. not necessarily U1t1zIlty
q rs-z5F- ms : TIE rue Al lzE.
zrd Il equity Il : ths sane. - far
= tie statute G frauds : cocesrczi-
sI.tC1Ea 81 : rue n OtEer cases
sc1-ty zILl ECt Erz1t relief II fzE-r
q oCe party 4 corresponding relief
cad Tot Dc given against hin II
fzvcr q tie osbsr parry So Reei-
s. 4 Fraud. Secs 80 Il arr ard
B-gzrs- $ = Frs1i>- Secs SO sd
Ard cas-. there eIted
TIE css= fWIlknsoc = E=zTs1-
ri.h- = MIA 80 cited q eo1uzeI
A. h1lticz tEsz ucd=E e sss.zrs
similar q ccrz the eocCrzss U1ss bs
szE-=1 2! O-l1 rs-rsl-= 1lss C44 %
pear 80 u 70 70 - fzE- SJs ocs q
tie u1u=r11- z1icIrIrI=s there cIts1
b tie enzrs s1ppoctz this EI=E5 seT-
erzI A. recogu I'D o. The eJ1ES SIP
PIT The coCEzry VlsEf otners were
decd uuS-r = statute EEIc1 uzds
tEs eoofrses EuIi (15t UerEy II
sefiozzbl=l CEIe=s slgued 81 the
rzrd ? fEgs party 70 b .Gzrgsdl=
b1t tie gTsztsr n1obsr E-rs based
uuou EzEt OF E1EGzlIty q eD1uze1
irrsspecrIF- q Eee sts-1ts u frauds
ScCe q tie IznEuzge q TIE o5orE-
i i tue VOID seem 70 Indicate
fhEt TIE ec1rr IEtscdsc 70 Eold that
TIE slguss1rs q bush parties was
rsgzlzI.-- b0r n = TIE IznEuzgs a =
WI. troo TIE zeEnzl fzet- q tie
case and fun the E1thuEIrsE cL1s1y