The evening world. [volume] (New York, N.Y.) 1887-1931, 1894-09-29
tx 7 RA.
! 2 O'CLOCK.
HOGAN VS..
ByRNES.
THE Police Justice Becomes
the Champion Of the
Liquor Dealers.
'',.''sM|ssEs EXCISE CASES.
W, |
tn Doing So, He Criticises Byrnes's
l. Methsd Of Getting Evil
denoe.
LAW FOR Poll CEMAN CARLEY
il Was Printed in a Pamphlet Pre-
pared in the Liquor Dealers
Association.
LAW FOR POLICEMAN CARLEY
Ut Was Printed in a Pamphlet Pre-
pared in the Liquor Dealers
Association.

Police Justice Hogan was a very
angry official in Jefferson Market Court
this morning. and he roundly scored a
policeman for asking him to hald a
raloon-keeper he had arrested for violat-
ing the Excise law.
At the same time Justice Hogan de-
livered right aim blow straight from
the shoulder at Supt. Byrnes, who is
engineering the present energetic cru
SADIE against saloon-keepers who violate
the law. Whether the blow will prove
to be Knockout Is a matter for con-
lecture and future development.
Policeman Carley was in citizens
Clothes, and he is among the men de-
tailed under orders from Police Head
quarters.
About 1 o'clock this morning, ne
stated, he went into the saloon at 514
Eleventh avenue, run by ]. Hinckey,
and boz hit drink following the act by
arrests :, the proprietor.
J When Carley took his prisoner before
.;Justxce Hogan in Jefferson Market Po-
nj. his Honor sternly demanded
lUndrssssd !, -. N' S''''' 4 '
fnd Castor man stated the hour and
Gloves, Psrs became the object of a
fl.Tb; insc2,,ure in law by Justice Ho-
cm e.
The Justice first declared that the
q r-'soner was discharged.
rep And now, officer, l don't want you
fetch another prisoner before me
the der similar circumstances" continued
de stice Hogan, and his face was white
latith anger. Hereafter you effect your
arrests according to law. II you don't
'ow what law is, why glance at this"
y Justice Hogan defiantly tossed little
til tmphlet Of perhaps fifty pages at
compliments of the New York State
an, Inc, Liquor and Beer-Dealers' Asso-
Sns he leaf was turned down at section
DC That Is a copy Of the Excise laws of
d, so and 1893" said Justice Hogan.
stifiy. Read itv'
Officer Carley obeyed. and this is
what he saw:
Section irty-elsht-Rights of officers in IL
Every ocer authorized to mike arrests In
y criminal process in any city or town In which
Many licensed premises are situated may entei
psrmltsd BY the license '' to be kept open foi
carrying on the licensed business there.
Policeman Carley gazed at ustice Ho.
y gan in wonder. Then he gasped:
! Il I'VE are detailed from Headquarters
I oolto make arrests, and go in saloons at
0(any hour"
a Justice Hogan ignored him and went
I M .'You 60 and get your evidence and
slHhen you have procured 1t, come to me
Z the arrest"
When shall we procure evidence?
inteTrogated Carley;
tice Hogan. II don't. make it and an
not responsible for 1t being on thu
statute books. There were many wise
framed. and / suppose they had wis
perhaps it was made to keep police,
seemly hours In the morning and sitting
around. The lawmakers possibly haC
.nst phase of the business under advise
Policeman Carley left the courtroom
rather crestfalIen, but there was JOY
among the big batch of saloon-keeper'
and bartenders who were there ethel
under arrest or as spectators.
decided similarly in every case Of tn,
+ Ba{.ancsr Murphy. employed in ex
nley's saloon, at Charles anc
~ is morning" e plpGH cd e eS
eSSss S ss$s 5SsS $ $ SS
LiIs the time"
LadieEi1. Koch, in an interview in III
kerdf' Market Police Court to-day, eus
,,N he position taken bp Supt Byrne
uiat lion to making Excise arrests.
LadistA far as l am concerned" he saiC
BRO Sny duty Whenever the police pr,
E ufficient evidence TO warrant m
ANJ & any one | do It, and in mos
~, the police, are right, and cons,
a. Wy most Of the Excise violatoI
Wrought before me are held"
In the Harlem Police Court this morr
Ing there wore only four alleged vIol'
tons OF the Excise law urralgnrd, The
were all held To answer In SlG1 bal
They we're Hugh BraGy, of Ninet,
ninth street and Third avenue: j.
Connolly, whose place is In Elght-se,
4, ond street: John Dunphy, of l0i Ea!
| Il One Hundred and Thirteenth street, an
4 euMichael Byrnes, OF COL Amsterdam av,