The herald., 1894-01-06
a---------------------
NOT WITHOUT A PRECEDENT.


II the United States should decide
upon annexation of the Sandwich isl
ands, there would be ample precedent
for it and that, too, on the part of Eng
land, the most acquisitive of all the
great European powers. There have
been reasons, however, why the acqui-
sition of the Sandwich islands was
deemed undesirable to England, and,
perhaps, some of these selfssme objec-
tions might apply nearly as well to the
United States. England could have
grabbed these islands fiity-two years
ago, had she so desired, but she evil
IDENTIFY preferred to let the dusky island
ers pay their own expenses OF govern
ment and catch all their trade for man
uiactured goods, without putting the
salaries of colonial governors and judges
upon the debit side OF the ledger.
Some time in 1912, Lord George Pow
lett, father OF the famous turfman who
came so near carrying off the honors of
1860 with The Promised Land, was in
command of the Australian squadron of
her msjesty's navy, the cruising grounds
OF which were limited to the Hawaiian
group on the east. He took possession
of the island of Oahu and hoisted the
British flag as evidence of his seizure of
the entire group. 1t is claimed that cer-
tain dissatisfied subjects of Kane
hameha III invited the attack, but on
this subject history is not altogether
clear. Certain it is that Powlett called
cession of the islands in the name OF the
queen, at the same time threatening to
lombard Honolulu (then an American
refitting station for the arctic whaling
feet in the event OF refusal.
Kamehameha was not go much of .
fighter as Lord Powlett, but he was a
good deal more of diplomatist. He at
once acceded to the British sd miral's
demands and at the same time issued a
proclamation that was a curiosity as a
state document. At the same time he
dispatched messenger to California
with orders to make the best OF his way
across the country to Vera Cruz and
thence to England. Lord Powlett had,
OF course, dispatched his own courier to
England by the same route, but they
travelled all the way from Honolulu to
Vera Cruz before Powlett's courier sus-
pected the errand of James Marshall,
who was the messenger of King Kane
hameha. On his arrival in London
Marshall obtained hearing from Lord
Aberdeen, then prime minister, nearly
as soon as did Lieutenant Simpson, whom
Lord Powlett had sent, and was at once
recognized ss the duly accredited agenG
powers.
Whether it was that one monarch feels
sympathy for another or that it be-
hooves all the kings to stand in together,
we are not informed, out it is quite GER
tain that the then young queen of Eng
land did not fancy the over-oficious
loyalty of Admiral Powlett. He got
back letter from Lord Aberdeen that
must have sent tingle to the very tips
of his ears. The home government dis
avowed all endorsement of his course
and gave the throne back to the greatest
of all the Hawaiian kings. Lord Aber.
deems instructions to Lord Powlett were
to evacuste the islands, and, by the with
drawal Of his forces. to allow matters to
assume their original condition. hich.
OF course, they did.
In all probability this is just about
the way Mr.. Cleveland regarded the case
in his removal OF Minister Stevens. The
relations of the United States with the
Hawaiian kingdom had always been of
friendly character and much stronger :,
commercially speaking, than those of
England had been, for the commercial
prosperity of Honolulu and Lahaina, up
to the discovery of petroleum in Penn
sylvanis, had depended wholly upon the
annual visits of the American whaling
feet on its return from Arctic waters.
Hence he probably reasoned that if
England, with her flag already floating
over the city of Honolulu, did not want
to take possession of the islands, why
should America, an equally friendly
power, wish to do go?
At the same time, the situations of
1912 and 1898 are not wholly parallel
Lord Powlett merely took possession OF
the islands in the name of the British
queen. He did not assist the islanders
to abrogate one form of government that
they might establish another one in its
place. And still further. there has been
no military or naval occupation of the
islands by armed forces OF the United
States; and the action of Mr.. Cleveland
has not been repetition of the "hands
off" policy of Lord Aberdeen, but an
attempt at the restoration of a govern
ment which is met with violent oppo-
sition on the part of the ablest and best
people in the Sandwich islands. In
withdrawing the annexation treaty the
president did what was warrantable
enough, but he should have ended his
action there and left subsequent events
to the dictation and behest of congress.
FALSE PROPHET OR FALSIFlER.