Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1894-02-24
*" again Replies to Professor PauPs
"Rsmlgksb.8 Statements.
THAT QUESTION or LOCATION.
what About Partial Uui1n at Iogan!-
Go o Little SLOW /, the Advice
Now Given Out

Feb. 10Th presents some new variations
on the old themes 10 requires little
attention.
flc cnumemtcs the following as all
,he studies taught in che University and
NOT in The Agricultural College. Eng-
l.h literature third year three Yeas Of
pedagogy. quiicmious. geology prob.
ably O. mispnnt for this is taught loo the
saUegc,l Latin, three ycau Should De
ax.J Greek, i've years, French. two
ye1n. German, two years. and also as
probable advanced tHgouomelry aud
surveying, aud integral calculus Then
hs asks for any educator in Utah TO say
over bis own signature whether, II
rooms. apparatus, etc, being furnished,
twill cost more than fioo51 TO teach
these extra branches, d applied loE Tor
Che nczttw years.
Certainly gSo5o might cover The
salaries required for this additional
work. though this depends upon the
adjustment TO work already cNsung,lnd
ihe writer would bc pleased 90 agree
with this conclusion q the facts ON which
ita based are correctly given. unlur
,unlic.y these alleged facts are utterly
unreliable.
a glance a, the University program
of recitation, during the present torn
shows the following that should have
been included in the lisl given aboye'
Anelosaxon and English phi'ul5ET
aH.lNug. advanced chemistry lthifl
wear counsel French third YClrI Ger.
man third yclL) advanced American
history historical seminary history OF
civilization the present subject English
literature Fourth year, history and
philosophy OF mIihCmJucs protective
redmetn, modern synthetic geometry
mngmlosy and Photography advanced
Counsel psychology advanced clur.I
perhaps some others, as % u difficult t1
pick Uui from the college catalogue the
iUuily of work Iu any subject
So much attention 81 given 90 DIS
statement merely tI show iH unreliable.
i.y. but even % 10 were true Do would
alone DE utterly va.ug.us, 20 show Cue
amount of University work not now
provided no the college d l.tul su1'
iegIs taught tells very IUlH about iuH
radu and Character of % -Cuuu. unless
accompanied by Information about tHg
extent Go which thy subjects afs pursued
aad thc quality OF thg wofE.
Your attention Is invited 10 tAg follow.
Bog partial comparison Oi uudcurl
university aud college work offered, "a
comparison 90 which extent OF suuIyea
h given due prominence.
ln chemistry the College oilers two
years and tic Unycriy three, 10
geology the College one term and tUc
Uuivcmily five. il miu.ll'gsy ug
College three hours pee week lur one
term and two hours iIr second tenn
aud the University, four hours per week
for one term and three hours for O.
second aud third term, Boo botany We
College, two hours Tor one term and tive
Tor second and the University three
hours ior one term and two hours iHr
three subsequent terms. iu mathematics
lhg University provides nineteen COURSES
above the preparatory aud tie College
about ung-.ourh MS many. while the
Freshman and Sophomore malhemai'n
of the College engineering courses col-
respond iu ullg TO thg University pIe.
plraioD uuJ thD entire mathematics of
Che agricultural course go not quite SO
hr 1 thr University preparatory
Special attention b. called 600 these
subjects because here it anywhere the
College should provide as much ur mon.
thln the University aud iu every one %
falls short.
When attention is turned 10 language
literature, history, etc., one finds, ls
mIght be expected, o. sull greater dis.
parity. The University oilers ln Eng
lsh, German, and Fwueh about twice ls
much a. the College, besides Latin and
Greek, which the College does not oigr
at go; in history the University oilers
July twice as much, or more.
Post graduate work Is advertised Ia
both Institutions so that on the face OF IL
honors are even ON this point; but the
marked deficiency Of the College under.
graduate work must cause ils 80 called
postgraduate work 10 be largely an
ysing ont O. previous deficiencies. Il
is not probable, however that provision
Tor postgraduate work amounts to
much as yet iu either institution
The gentleman SAYS
'Ir.se Doc estimate of Che Shit Lake writers.
rHi urfa IS duplication 0i u.ua.igHils o. be
work done hy these .uauwu11l.'
lie conlouuds these two propositions
that nine.tyulhs of the college work IS
done NO the University and that nlne'
tenlhs Of thc University work Us done at
the College. The Though probably
somewhat exaggerated, o. nearly true,
while the second is nowhere near true
U has been shown above,
Alter his imperfect list OF work TO hc
added TO the College in uTdertu provide
ior the University, the gentleman asks
How much should 10 cost 10 supply
teachers for the foregoing branches IN q
school with q present faculty OF twenty
teaCher" A glance 40 Tins faculty lat
viii assist in answering this question,
About une.thrd are assigned 10 sewing,
domestic economy, daiyus and animal
hu.bandry and the Ike, subjects 20
which their services, however valuable
Tor the College would not De % the
slightest degree available 10 assist in
conducting thg University work We
also observe professor oil physics,
geology and mneralugY subjects poo
which the University requires the
services OF between Two and three per,
sons; also professor Of English lnd
modern languages. subjects that require
nearly three institutions In he luiver,
ally OWING 90 the greater amount OF
work conducted in them,
Enough has been presented 10 SHOW
that the College is yct %. high sen13I
grade Tor the mu5t part 90 d" eoIrHl A.
... . o.