The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1894-05-09
WILL VIOLATE THEIR OATHS,
,IYs SENATOR HoAR OF ms DEMO
cRzTTC COLLEAGUES,


WARRINGTON. Mar a-Ths debate on the
Tariff bill was taken up In the Senate early
.nd continued throughout the day. Senator
ALIENS resolution ss to the police assault upon
co,., and his two sdiutants having gone
o,sr without discussion or action till to-mor-
row. Senator Hoar rep. Massl spoke for two
and A half hours In opposition to the Tariff
Mill and Mr. Quay tRep, Pal delivered the
.iYth Installment OF his speech against it.
Mr. Hoar's speech was made up largely Of
t,xact,yes against the Chairman OF the Senate
Finance Committee and against the three
doetors" who had prepared the Senate bill
senators Mills (TeIssl. Vest missouri. and
lane. tArkansasL He held up to ridiouls the
position OF the Senator from Tennessee tMr.
H.rrisl who had got as protection for Tonnes
see marble . duty Of 40 cents per cubic foot In
The rough. and 10 cents per cubic foot when
sawed and dressed. and yet favored "a tariff
for revenue only.
couutry and from all occupations come up one
unbroken chorus OF iosthinE and adherence
for the wilson bill. for the man who begot 1t.
and for the men who were its eodfathers.
When he had expressed his conviction that
the Finance Committee did not approve the
bill and that most Of the mon who were to
vote for It. when they did So would violate
their oaths to support the Constitution as thsy
understood It. he was asked by Mr.. Gray
Dem, Deli whether he meant to say that the
parsons who would vote for the bill would vio-
late their oaths
lido" was Mr.. Hoar's blunt answer.
That 10 . very remarkable charge for the
Senator to AXE OF his colleagues in the Sem
ste." Mr.. Gray remarked. with a tinge OF anger
" 1t is a very remarkable thing to do" Mr..
h"f' repeI the charge as unworthy of the Sen:
q Senator in this place" Mr. Gray exclaimed.
WIZ The ie'' Democratic f party" said Mr.. Hoar,
arGumsntatively. acquired the conndenoe OF
s sIsr sSp shst n o ~ was foSbery and
fraud and was violation OF the Constitution.
and they haze got oil new ?, crowded sos,N WITH
they ar. going to Increase. for projection: and
as.s s Il. ssnsscf f rom t$s
am sOifn 4g be, deferred ssr oy loaiss S
s s.Ssis' for l5G% man who say. that duty
for protection is robbery and 10 violation q
the Constitution. and who then comes In and
that pledge and that oath when he puts into
81 f' wh Ga, hi. S dos. sbsn
dence-for the mere purpose Of protection and
Y. S .s. s that fss sSss ssc
Mr.. GrsySDoes ihe Senator think tina, what
he has said 10 entitled to any better destgna-
league: and peers in the Senate with violating
The senator said Mr.. Hoar. is violating
the rules OF the Senate"
to that tribunal bn pal . th9 pS6 H. n mr.
Prietiss and the duties which Senator owes
Alter some further Interchange Of remarks
in the same spirit, Mr. Gray made the point OF
order that Mr.. Hoar had charged his COLI
leagues with violating their oaths By their ac-
me poi1s o order WAS everrslod b she
bali hours; TSs1 ). resumed ii; .sss; M. NJ
presented In taking down the artificial odincs
w sss Would ff have we .aspsd e
& S: r q S:ss s s ss a. sSsra
side py those who had raised a elamor against
and all that had been bred By. years
Of high proteetion. OF the worst feelings
against even the most moderate attempt to
msliorate the conditions Of high protection,
a. soanls
under the provisions Of the Mckinley act. and
ma msrohins on the e1 SishWays and
The WS o. the Il 40
claimed for themselves the ministers OF idle
ness and rapine were claiming for themselves.
They we're claiming that the national Lsgisla;
that they should have the assistance Of Con-
grss.lonal action in order to supplement tho
HSss 81 sS Ma marvel
lous gin OF wrapping himself IN his own virtue
ana q inPutiSE 70 others what he was con-
Here was . bill. Mr. Hoar added. that was
dotted and crowded all over with protection.
cared that the Constitution prohibited such
protection were prepared 70 vote Tor It
for q protsctivs duty on sugar and that ne
.rpDCssd that ne Ssrstor f.GM mss'seaS
Mr.. Palmer Dem. ILL., said he could not
avoid feeling that the speech Of the Senator
gardlsss OF the Interests Of other people Such
saa
communism. i was q err that unless aid was
gwen By law The Industries o. shS sonPsy
lection. Mr. Palmer declared. was the most
de usivs OF all the terms employet in modern
sSVs US or we S1 Ssrs I That was the
Of the Senator from Massachusetts,. The Lam
blood. The Goysrnmsns must furnish days
labor to every man at fair wages" That WAS
Mr. Hale 1Rspi M Nee asked Mr.. Palmer to In
dieate what bill q was that be supPOssssd , the
people favored. Was it the Wilson lllif Was
It the irst draft OF the Senate bill2 Was Il tho
bill introduced by the Senator from Indiana,
Mr.. Voorhees,? Was II the bill ehampioned By
the Senator from Texas Mr.. Millsl or wa: L
the new DILL Just laid before the benate-tne
hill designated By the Senator from Wisconsin
- the sugar Trust bill No two Of these bills;
Mr. Hale added, were alike. The bill reported
yesterday By the senator from Arkansas Mt:
the senator from Indiana than the gayel OF the
presiding offlesr was like an E-nat bugle.
lLAughter.l There was no resemblance De-
tween them. He repeated the qdsstlon as 70
which bill It was that the Senator from Illinois
supposed the people favored.
Nr, Palmer replied that the country had dis;
approved the Mckinley act and would regard
any OF the pending bills as preferable 70 X
MI. quay lRep.. Pa. took the moor and deiiy-
cred the sixth part Of his speech against the
TArin bill, He retained the hoor TIL $40.
when he Yielded for motion to proceed to ex-
seutiye business
The presiding onicer, Mr.. Faulkner Dem.
W. Val laid before the Senate the credentials
q John Patton. JE. appointed as SENATOR from
Michigan In place OF the late Senator stock
bridge and they we're read and laid on the
Thu nrs.iaIna oaiaar aIao laid bafOFa the