New-York tribune., 1894-06-12
RIGHT TO STRIKE ARGUE
APPEAL FROM JUDGE JENKINsS DE
CIsION N THE NORTHERN PA
CIFIC CASE.
LABOR LEADERS AND THE REPORT TO CON
cprss SEVERELY SCORED BY COUNSEL
FOR TIE REcEivERs-THE MrFHL~

., Co.,. ,.. ~,
Chlcaso juno 81" '.' ., rr,.t
ApP.H' ~ ,,-..,.,.t ~ r.,.-.,o,l,. I'm
'h'' "r'"D' % '.'' $780, -,I,,y,,, l,bor
slh'ers' anu TIC .''' ,..,.. I'M 30,
~ ''-H - 80 ,',,,-, o., ,b. orga-l-
Tie MI ''''''' t ..t.,.t,,.. ..
zAtohs ''"'''"'' '"' ''','' " ,... ,rt ,.,s
th'ih rom "", 3D.. ,o,,-. T.,
trc spec" "','''' '"' "''.'',. "''. ....., ... ,,r.,
modify the injnn "'n '} 'Np"''''" '''." ,'... -.
The "'F''" ana ''''' .'''''.'''' y, .,1 49,.
quit. WIN or "''ao'' "'''',' '.' ''' .,.'. .,..
ceivcrs win ti' ''j''' "''' "'',"- - ..'.'
property n th'.r custody nr '.Hh-il il'r-'" .' "'''
alton o' s'.4 f'l'r' anu 80 ,...,..,.. ,s.
N'' 81 ' '' ..... ~. ...'...., ,,....
o. ry.cc % 90" stii receivers WIZ ~ " "''''- '
as 20 grippe thc property or hinder the operation
- s,d rair,aI" Justice Ha..au presided and vi,h
~ Sa'1 '".'' ,. , t,.,. ,
him sat judge Woods. ~ Indiana "nl huh"' ''
Wisconsin. Receiver 'ak"s - th' northern f"'ih''
,t ,.o c,,,-..oi ,o- the co.rn-a-lrr were ln the
anu IT" '''''' . ..,~.,
court OAK none o' ",' '. tf,. c,,.,..
Mr spence open i'r we hIi~'''''''' ~" .''''''
30 ,,t4 W.. mon ~ L-l Character ana had acted
and might at again "a n brake np'a NOR ''k'h'-
cations In time ~ trouble. WHAT tney wnnt7i 20
know was "heih'r my ''-'- - .''. ..'' Us -
united cessation ~ 'i"'' '' ''' DID '''''
-, ., g.. -,,,.i-o ,-.-,-,.f,f Tho rl.h. OBJ,
S'"' .'' ,'i l 49,. ,..,,-.t, ,..,-
sl,lon couli not be quesuonei
Judge Harper followed Nr. Spence There were.
len fff44 ltlfl ttFlf g - lf
he sad ABOUT ''' NV" ,' '' - ....
rcpresentci here What they wanted - kno" was
s, ,bov nigh, o,,lt work p.accahly ana IN order.
WI" "''' ''9 .... o., mo rt,,
Dld inc courts "'i'" ''''+' ~ f''' 80 ~
vas what they wanted % know. Congress had
-, ~, ,h.s. ,..,i,,.t had n rich, % existence.
"'''' ''' 49,. 49,, ,,,..,,c., r,,.
How were tn'y 10 '''l"''' ''''
passing resolutions or holding town m'r'4nf7+ were
,beir hands tied or were they frcomen,
.., + ..trs,,,d ,o,, "a saw that Congress
10 "'''''''''' ~, , r
specifically recognizes traces unions. "'"'i JUS
,ice Harlan
49,. .,, ~ rr....,r o., ,,~ot-,,.iv rcu,cl Iudpe
'OtI'dihy' i"'' 4i''''' I''''''' ,,
Harper a. he handed up q copy OF tn' I.'' .,.'l
Statutes for the inspection o. the Court. Al U'
point a recess taken
When the court rcasscinH4cd u was 'f4l'H MON
% listen tD some oi the strongest iahsu"s' 'IDI
heard before such a. tr4Dunil. Hp.t,Hl's -" t t.'
Northern PaclNc Io1d, ana lh. Il'iltI III I"t7 .
jenkins Mr.. Mcknight u Ne"-l ork saIi Una
when the labor oTsinizat.ohS "rtr "ltils 80 con on
cede that violence might Dr t'JJ.n.i' ""' IT,, "1s
strikes. they might a. well ask the court - ''J",t,
the speed o.! bullet after tAe nilnS "i a 7A't II
an Injunction was 10 issue at All u must De D, ior'
the strike. which would bring dcsiru' non N"irhce
and irrepiT&Dle INJURY IN us way. ' ~ ="
possessed neither right nor lawful authority io m
tcrfer. between judge jenkins ana the Officers APP
pointed him. They set IN |lufrF'H w as a gov