New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1894-05-13

STATEMENTS IN THE LONDON TABLET
TUE CONFLICTING INTERVIEWS AU-
rgoR1zEp BY MoNsIGNoR sATc-LI
AND ARCHBISHOP CORRIGAN-
THE FAILURE TO GIVE DIR.
MGLYNN PARISH
.r,, .,sn down out Of my pulpit after preaching
,-rlst,an charity meekness and brotherly love and
walk over to the Brooklyn Tabernacle. as did on
Thursday evening to signify by my presence the
regard which entertain for the Rev. Dr. Talmage.
a Protestant minister and one OF the most prom'-
nent Of my fellow-citizens. does that mean that
am going 10 become Protestant? AS well might
II be said, because Dr. Talmage visited me ana
wrote ne letter Of congratulation on the hftieth
anniversary Of my ordination as priest that ne
was going to become Catholic.
ut is poor thing indeed. If church cannot
thrive and preserve its doctrines unless by looking
with suspicion upon all others processing different
religion and refusing to associate with them
This is what the Rev. Sylvester Malone. OF BROOK
Iyn said when asked yesterday what ne had to say
regarding the latest phase Of the McGynn- Burtseh-
Corrigan-Satolli controversy. Father Malone was
elected recently by the Legislature to the Board OF
Regents Of the University Of the State OF New
York after struggle in which the old controversy
between the conservative and the progressive ele-
ments in the Catholic Church was revived.
. The news comes now by way Of London In the
form Of an interview in The Tablet" Of that city,
which the official organ Of the Catholic Church IN
England that this election Of Father Malone mas
been powerful means of stirring up anew the o!d
quarrel which threatens. like the apparitions In the
play to stretch out till the crack o DOOM Then
comes a statement about the Pope having ordered
the Rev. DR.. McGiynn to withdraw from New-York
and its vicinity. and to remain In quietude;
statement that the ex-pastor OF st. stephens ais
obeyed Monsignor Sato and then fell out with him.
and series Of other assertions in the same line all
OF which were denied seriatim In an interview from
Washington published in The Tribune yesterday
with the Papal Delegate.
who do you suppose is at the bottom OF these
statements that come from London" Father
Malone asked
GUESS AS TO THE AUTHOR.
The venerable priest thought for a moment and
then answered, deliberately: 1T would not in the
least surprise be told that the author OF that
article Father Vaughan. brother Of the
Cardinal Archbishop OF Westminster. He was here.
you know. few months ago on his way back to
London, and stayed with Archbishop Corr!gan,
where he had excellent opportunity OF learning
the views Of the leader that side OF this pain
ful and protracted controversy 1t is altogether an
ex-parte statement. / met Father Vaughan myself
when he here. and found him tractablc and
reasonable in discussing this topic. but no sooner
mad he come within the sphere OF Archiepiscopal
influence than he changed and the result is seen
IN the partisan and untruthful statement In The
Tablet-f it was he who wrote II. / think II
scandalous. whoever wrote that article that an
cement In the controversy should be imported from
source 5000 miles away. where nothing whatever
Is known OF our laws. our institutions ways
o. NE
TFylr,etary, announced that the statements in The
t au,et We're. in substance, correct and see
further in The Tribune OF to-day that Monsignor
proceeds
prove what he says, paragraph by paragraph.
WHO is TELLING LIE?
NOW somebody is telling lie. Who is II? The
archbishop must surely know that the American
peopie are an intelligent people. and capable Of
'o'ming sound judgment. Really. isn't 1t dis
saceiul that this intriguing should be kept up any
"hser! II Is doing vast amount of harm. which
~asnt nave been put an end to once for all when
Aonsgnor satolli restored DR.. McGlynn TO the
w,esthood II Archbishop Corrgan had followed
Sstor up In spirit Of justice by completing the
Ss so!tation and assigning him, II not to St Ste
nrisd,,. az least 10 some other parish under his
'ssw,sa hS lone. equally as good"
arsa, 40 not know but at liberty to form my
sa SeS ,n The Papal Delegate could do Il II h.
'y5 nsSs ay "a TO- Iii ns that
naSnno ssp leaving II undone every fair-mlnde1
hat S ean see where the blame lies and who it is
neeps this question open
Hojy the absurdity OF the statement that the
New yam issner had ordered Dr. McGynn to leave
Hwssonable enough excuse FOR the formation Of a
ton ynlancnes OF the American Protective Associa-
abs,rr mere only one now exists. The statement II
Be- tat., masmuch. mind you. as the action would
law ~ !, not because DIR. McGlynn had broken any
sconorr,sh e Snurch. but because he had discussed
Now me subjects from a certain point Of view
views oeo.olng to Monsignor Satolll DR.. McG.ynns
four doc, .nese matters were submitted by him TO
that snowwt,s OF divinity and IL acknowledged
Cathosc tdn lung ne DID or said was opposed to the
high in srctrine This talk In ths country by men
DO cer, ecclesiastical authority Of ordering men to
not cons t,niings especially when these things do
and II + within their Jurisdiction, IL un-American,
might no,,. ere an archbishop tomorrow. while l
ceftaiuly shay, make requests in such matters,
CATHOLIC AND FREE MAN
Church am stanch adherent OF the Catholic
4 r. WINCH Is the Church OF my fathers, am
soverpr.s nan and / know that our. experiment OF
bsea..s a oy the people has proved successful
= a. ~ people are permitted to feel and to act
yof ffty 81. have been a reader of The Tribune
XDS fSSsSais, and II was from its patriotic coll |