St. Paul daily globe. [volume] (Saint Paul, Minn.) 1884-1896, 1894-12-20
severe ON CARLISLE.
Strong Opposition to His New
Currency Scheme Is De-
veloping.
DEMOCRATS WHO DENOUNCE
The Measure in the House Are
Rapidly Increasing in
Mum Der.
THE DEBATE GOES ON.
Bland Will Offer a Silver Sub
Stitute--Senate Discusses
Canal.
THE DEBATE GOES ON.

WASHINGTON, Dec. 19.-An uneX-
pectediy strong opposition to the Car
Isle currency bill now before the
house is disclosed by the list of those
who have asked for time to speak on the
measure. Two lists have been made,
one for members of the banking COM
mlttee who wish to be heard, and the
other for members not on the commit
tee. The committee list shows the
members divided on party lines, except
Representative Ellis (Dem., ky.), who
has asked for time to speak against the
bill. The other list shows fourteen
members who will speak for the bill
and thirty against it. Of the thirty
against it eighteen are Democrats. The
list of speakers is as follows:
For the Bill-McCreary, PendletOn
wv. Va.) Bynum, Talbert. Lane, Berry,
Brickner, Sickles, Caruth, Tracey,
Livingston. Gresham, Coombs, Stock
dale.
Against the Bill = Dingley (Rep.).
Sibley Uem.), Hendrix (Den.), Cockran n
Oem,), Bowers (Rep.), Bland Oem.),
Hatch (Dem.), BeltzhOOver (Dem.l,
!,
Bryan Oem.), Daniels (Rep.), Weadock
(Dem.), Powers (RepD, c. w. Stone
(Rep.l, c. K. Bell Oem.), LaceyRep.),
Mcclure (Dem.), Richardson, of Michi-
gan Dem }; Newland (Silverite). Dolli-
yer (Rep. }, Simpson Pop, Pence (POp.),
Boen Pop.), Cooper dem, Tex, Raw
Inns (Dem.l, Holman Dem.). Neill
Dem.). }. c. Bell (POp.(, Little (Dem.)
All of those for the bill are Demo-
Gratis. Those against it are: Democrats.
Is; Republicans, Z; Populists, 4, and
Newlands, silver, l.
Secretary Carlisle was at the capitol
today for some time prior to the assem- b.
ling of the house, where the Carlisle
plan of currency revision is being de-
bated.
The secretary sought Chairman
Springer, of the banking and currency
committee, but as he did not arrive at
the house until late, Mr.. Carlisle joined
Speaker Crisp in his private office. AS
far as could be learned Mr.. Carlisle
made no suggestions as to the length of
the debate or time of taking a vote.
Tie main purpose of Mr.. CarliSle's visit
was to put the Democratic leaders in
possession Of information TO overcome
CcILdlu CTItICISIuS dUYduCGu dndlnS lU6
bill. 1t had been urged on the floor yes
terday and elsewhere that the Car
Isle plan might result in loss
by the government. MIR. Carlisle
pointed out, however, that it was the
universal agreement among bankers
that the so-called Baltimore plan could
occasion no possible loss to the govern
menr. He further pointed out that his
plan had safety fund of 80 per cent
greater than that provided in the Balti-
more plan. From this he showed that
if the bankers were correct in their
unanimous agreement that the Balti-
more plan could occasion no loss to the
government, it was even more certain
that the Carlisle bill, now up, could oc-
casiOn no loss. 1t has been considered
advisable to let the present debate run
along without any rule, as it is proceed
ing satisfactorily thus far. 1t will then
be put under the five-minute rule with
the desire TO have vote Tuesday, Jan.
9. IL case there is opposition to the
vote at that time rule will be brought
in, as there is no purpose to let he de-
bate run beyond that date.