New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1894-07-03

III 81 RE 70 GET GENUINE ARTICLE.
IN the Mckinley act and be made an argument IN
support Of the substitute
HILL DEFEATS THE COMMITTEE.
Mr. Hin Dem. y. " moved TO amend the para
graph by striking ont the words January l. 1870
and Inserting the words Ito take effect on the pass
age Of this act" so that the repeal Of tn sugar
bounty shall 90 into eject Immediately Tn a'neh'-
Inent was agreed to- yeas 80. nays %. as follows:
Ycas--Nlessrs Aldrich. Allison, chandler Coke'
inger. George. Hale. Haw:cy. Hul Hoar, IEoyy;
Jones (Neyl Lodge McMil:@n Manacr'on M pinf,
Power Pugh. Quay. Sherman Shoup' squire 1e"er'
%avs"Mesers. Allen, Bate blackburn. Bancnarl.
J CaNerv. Camden, Cockren, Faulkner Gibson, Cor
Kyle Lindsay, McLaurn, Martin. Mills MSrgas'
Murphy PaSco ransom h03 3b,, H,1"H' i''P'e'
The question REQUIRED on Nj Mardersons subsu-
tute Arguments in favor Of il were made by MI
PETER CPop, KanD. Mr.. Manierson u'ep.. Neo)
end Mr. Chandler Rep, y. H.. Mr Cnan1ier
quoted from new, paper interviews Of February last
IN which Mr.. Alien was represented as stating that
! he would vote agans; the Tariff bill (cven though
| II contained income tax unless IL contained
provision for a continuance Of the sugar bounty.
lie counted. he said, with the utmos; confidence
on the vote Of all the Populis Senators against tho
/ bn now that the sugar bounty had been stricken
.
Mr. Alien denied the authenticity of the stat
monts attributed to him IN those newspaper Inter
/ views. The statements made in them were. he
/ said "the result Of some disorlered or diseased
| magma don" He gave notice OF amendment
: which he would offer paragraph. placing
duty Of l cent pound sugars testing by the
! polariscope rot above 80 degrees. with l-oo cent
additional every additional degree up to 3d. and
! 200 cent above so ard not above %: also with a
provision repeating the provisions OF the Hawaiian
treaty to sugar. AMI with another proviso that
cane or sorghum. grown in the United States, shall
! be paid bounty of 6i-lO) cents a pound.
Mr. Mandersons substitute rejected yeas. 81;
nays g. as follows
Yea, Ye;asIMessrs Aldrichi Allison. Carey, cu.Iom.
! Hansbroush: Haw.ey, higgins. Jones (NevD, Kyle.
ton PETER, PerIins rcttigren. Pistt power quay.
Sherman Shoup, TeNer. Washburn 81.
Gallery Camden Cockrel Coke Faulkner. George
Gibson German, Gordon Harris HI. Hanton,
! TN. Mills, Mitchell (Wis.J. Morgan Pa,co. Ransom
Roach, Smith, Turpe, Vest. Villas. voorhees,, Walsh.
,n Nil M ,5s gS8r then Gnerra ands
Mir Manderson offered anoihrr amsniment d,rn,n.
from 1875 to 1903 ard appcaie> to his colleasaes 70
! yearaei." This ndment was also rc;ectel-ycas
| "A. nays g. Mr.. henderson changed hls vote 70 the
NEGATIVE AMI gave notice that he would at the
| proper time move 70 reconsider the vote.
,n MG N1 fb fSn, men %fr rs 2mendmgnt e
pTbG payToe Sny on sugar made from bets or
Mr Kvl r. ~ was nei !, 10y = cas- 10 30 nay
= dincreniiai given to the sugar reiiners and the
countries where an export bounty is paid on rcancd
! sugar IN discussing his amendment Mr.. Kyle said
10 pass this schedule with these provisions In IT, ana
IL w9uii prove the political death Of any who
M napS S3, he e% a, da uS 5Sniga 5 s
| between raw and refined sugar was solely in the
interest Of the sugar growers and sugar manufnct-
th he. he difeTenilal duty would be retained.
| Mr. Blanchard was mistaken. and that the = cent
a pound dlferental was bounty paid TO the Sugar
dated rather than approved by the legislation OF
DIFFERENTIAL DUTY RETAINED.
The vote was taken the frs, part % Mr. Kylcs
| motion 10 strike out the i pound dnerentia
en1 the motion was rejected-yeas a: nays gas
! follows:
,Yeas,,-Aicssrs Alerich Allen. Allison. Carey.
Chandler, Culiom; Dagis, Dixon. Doph. Dubois
Ir6y Jones 1NeyJ Kye ISdee MeMIian' ' Ma HGeT
son, Mitchell Ore) Patton PETER Perkins. Pc,ti-
Grrr%%, Iiatt Power Sherman. shoup Squire. Wash
=. N2ys-Messrs Bate Blackburn Blancharl pricc
Xrk5 Lindsay. McIaurin M ariin JnTys u, J9ngs
sem, NQaSh Smith Turpie Vest Was Voorhees,
The vote the Second part OF Mr. Kye.s
amendment, striking out the provision for an ad-
ditional duty Of lilo cent pound on the sugar
OF any country which pays. directly or Indirectly,
a bounty on the export thereof The amendment
was reiectcd-yeas, %; nays. 81. rs follows:
Yes Messrs Aldrich. Allen. Allison, Carey.
S,nnnnHrr, Davis DIXON. Dolph, DUBOIS. Frye.
5a @nfS55 cv h"TKe ys E sao NJ Md oar F6
Orel. Patton. Peter, Perkins, Pcttisrew. Plat
rover SHERMAN Shoup Squire, Teller. Washburn
oNaysccMesgs Bate. Blackburn Blanchard.
oh an ku4
Jarvis. Jones (ArkJ Lindsay. McLaurn. Martin.
IIugh quay ROACH smith Turpie. Vest Villas.
Mr. Kyle moved to strike ont the words ION
and after January ]. 1885," ana make the section
go into effect the paasage OF the act Mr. Jones
asscntea to thi' ana the change was made.
Mr. Lodge (aor. Mass) moved 20 substitute for
paragraph lN2s the paragraph as originally
reported from the Finance Committee. Rejected
Mr. Fet,isrew (f,cp. s D. moved to strike out
IL provision against abrogating the Hawaiian
aeq re TO IGr ana IN sHn of paTGgrd
that the people OF ne United states had already
and were now paying them at the rate Of 1900, 90
Il year. There were no American laborers. he said
Of American descent were registered voters there.
Thg OF the 2oaaaoGp %%s mad up OF
were contract laborcrs lower in the scale OF civl-
AR sherman G}ep Ohio protested against the
provision IN favor Of the Hawaiian Islands. and
PAU tiIh t'i' Nhn IIo ifhSpH VI puDli' pOii'S ~
Justify the enormous amounts paid 20 the sugar
growers OF the Sandwich Islands The United
States had derived no benefit whatever from r..
The treaty had been wrong ir the beginning, was
wrong now, and would always be wrong
Mr.. Frye Oscp.. Me- protested against Mr.. Shnr-
mans protest. The reciprocity treae had been
made with the Sandwich Islands, and had been
lived under for ten years obtaining all the trade
OF the islands and all their carrying trade. The
Senator from Ohio. he said. did not give cent
OF credit the cesson OF Pearl River Harbor
as a considcra ton for the reciprocity treaty.
Mr.. Sherman cOnten1ed that Hawaii had made an
I absolute. unconditional. unqualified grant OF Pearl
nall %
$23OOO O0 under the reciprocity treaty. and by
tending the treaty for seven years longer
Mr. f'rye argued that the United States would be
, d!sgraccd by abrogation OF the treaty pro-
posed by the Senator from South Dakota.
Mr.. Mills dem. Tex argued In support OF the
Amendment. He glad TO have the opportunity
II vote 10 abrOgate the treaty, which simply put n
Il n.Ll I..tn L. rIrot. nf