The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1893-02-26
MANHATTAN A. c. FINANCES.
PREsIDENT CARTS STORY As TO
now THE MONEY Vas HANDLED.

Mr.. Carr Received Money Not rs nm
Individual, but as the C1ub's Afforrey.
The Manhattan A. G. troubles have enGen-
dsrod bad blood among several gentlemen
who are closely connected with that institu-
ton. Money matters. the Cherry Diamonds
ind. are somewhat hard to solve. and where
the amount. as in this case. Is 30 great there Is
n desire to know where 1t all ha' gone to and
how It went. Mr.. Maxwell. in the letter which
he recently made public. reflects somewhat on
the services OF President George W. Carr.
That is, Mr.. Maxwell intimntes that Mr.. carr
received money which. as an individual.
no should not have taken. THIS re.
Election has riled tho calm nature Oh
the Manhattan President. and in a letter to
Mr.. Maxwell he shows that Dominick McSat-
frev's boxing instructions were OF some use
by giving the inouisitive Maxwell a niow
straight from the shoulder. President carr
also attempts to give Receiver Freedman an
interesting resume OF his connection with the
club. and pays his respects to that mucf-'rieo
official in a very positive manner.
President Carr was seen yesterday afternoon
in his office ct 20 Wall street. He had Just
completed writing his letters to Messrs. Max
we'll and Freedman. and was apparently very
much vexed that any one should suppose ina
certain moneys were paid to him as an inhi-
vidnal.
"Mr. MAXWELL" said he. has brought
charges against me which he cannot substnh-
tiate. In my letter to him l have repndiated
these. lie shows personal prejudice wh'ch
is unseemly and which will act against the
club. In tho letter to Mr.. Freedman ] have
endeavored to show just what moneys were
pnid out and how they were paid. My services
verc given freely to the club. The money. as
I said in nv letter to Mr.. Freedman. was turn
ed over to ma for the purpose OF settllhg Inws
suits. have here pointing 10 parsh ,iInr
This letters. which nre in the nature OF both
n club and n personal statement. cover the
who'll. ground Of the discussion. The letter
to Mr.. Maxwell is somewhat personal. and
NV York. Feb 20, 1893.
cscr,,' " Ma1,-eu. Eq, :, ~. OFT, ,r,, and
.n pt, ed i, COY Tsf 'i.T to S Sr. fl 's,sia on on sam. late,
have received from the receiver q copy nI yoms .s..
ter 10 aim aud have sent him u reply. ana herewith en-
statements made by INC about compensation to me for
i.sal services. Sa, the ,.'pe ss sssT n, c Us 1n ih and suS ,sys
not received any moneys for any legal ,ervices ren.
s smSs, by %S ss.n nin =. it cnni,, lie HsEs s,, h stu i have neid
myself at all times subject to the necessities OF tue
' You we'll know that you we're from I,u time ! 70 tim, ;h in:
moneys q me, clnn WERE being sma turned ao 1Ss5 to Ho me a., q.
oP .ps eiab s as ySn b %Ss' You "a't m HHIs i,a rfS% seem { i mat ,asss
snss tso VIII tS.s S. Z YOU had s.sss 1ss %a s%I n s,%s l s"%
Treasurer tsro You Womb !" have received such Information.
-, IT,, s@ a GHanc s@ msn 'sI made &c" by y{ Sf ito in' sna NJ. Perry
"h''h 'nes "''' tGro. W. CARR.
The following letter to Receiver Freedman
that gentleman to President Carr. 1t is in
tended as q tull explanation OF certain trans
actions into which the receiver had inquired.
SEw YORK. Feb. 70. 1898.
AT Ts.s ts,seTr rsss ~ on til. ssa inst. your letter Of
t ena T,.' II Ip' a. s"s,Si, or ,h e s sooptS INST \ and - Wherein y"n
s.En iSs w. T1.' h Ia HssRy to is, 5sse as / ; ,nss i isRis" 'o oa.f CON
so far s 3: M4 an a. s sWsITs eSm sDnSfsns@ IN | ' Msa s" II sss
tina. . a. ! b bad I'd s.r nnS. stis all w ,hs =' ,hs nmssn,, ns spl sns,s ss
ia.rs s. .,:s. &c, and 70" N. Of one FEB .,i I 1sns. r. .ns .,%'e so' i i Sna
fully accounted 'or All such moneys. such sup.
s saap. Which t lid no. pas. through my SaSk. !.
sSs ." I'd en ssP su, was WAS . nsas4ssdl'y over s%'s Sy me- from tn
MIR. Leonard Brunper. ms attorney for Edward +. Little.
sIsi,n sa. as on 1h By f hi@. 6 5aHx.; Of oi p eSi. uRn aS@sns of
SS'.s, BEEN. snse ,Sa nnS n ab sns s .Ssrs void of drn .sem n" it 5. ne
sSpinn,a,i"n Ts.!Hired from Re, me 70 you except ,sp to Teter
this answer TO your letter
H. amount = nj rs SrTs Ih to :: having nM, e., been na, PAID % me m
individually, but, as a,t"Tney for the c!Th The checks
81 jaa s1ness. : ::si = The Il. ' siss and IN {, .sd Hss. .s'.! 'h (; i" ~
IsSMrrys p "a ~ e M me M ny sisS w ysssx ns.S Ssi for sn, ,h nu Gn,es
.sss'i for the, ,purps:s only; y, one : sem n q P' ,eeS:s
ss,TsI 81 Pa .sis,s. On 81 ssG m. i snfsfs m., p 3. t to m my 0 6rs
Prior to Jan. 10, for several weeks. ! received club
y. sp the ,,t .rs.sPtsr' through his Fe e
thu i p res@,vea y me up 10 and "a ,%neiaii"s Jan Il r. s.IiessoS s'
had adj BEEN Wholly . esps.ded. and ne shcss to wh hsfa' ass
wh 4. they We're dis n. / in the ss', lie. : .f
The note: were returned to the treasurer. Think
but II you do not l will send you u copy OF 1t. it
Al moneys paid me by club check, since Jan. IL.
,sss. werr, i,xeTise expended n ne s.,.Iemsn. q
other club moneys received from t,r treasurer by me N
asa ".T t tnsy ~ for s. s i.5sG's:: a ."i a : Sss.d ss!ts yG Sll my ~
ssF't,!sa; i I'm YG. The S.s;doiIif sil !. sSs
,%@si.ats 50; 300 Of the s3:4i5. ihe amount stated BY
Itrrei to above. never received a club check for a
st1orney dated Jan. %. 1873 being <" :s..sS. " ans
thMns I d did 4 r .ss %e cn tpn. ia isf as a S De- a1.ti a"i0 Sn ina
i i 4: . SIT. Sn.Sk r fSI s3Sp; "a and i d i. ,.;!y psSoIn'si ir
.hsYk referred 10 ! beg to ADD ~, NJ: Maxwell
to4"t s.G q. II. .s1s SSs"f 81 S is%ss,,s s''""S" H' as ut
|. me me ny by The ns,a .5sas% n NJ Su; NJ. NOT X a s s,1S D,e;S; an.
Inrpose, Of tasinv M a note Of the club which had
b, ginlily been given me for legal service, rendered
a want or frAnkneSS nau ] NOT lone 81. Dlsc,oEIng IL
nscessitates my making an explanation IN justice to
my seIf.
as its attorney. Except what Il paii in connection
the frst mortgage loan and what It has paid me
ms hereinafter stated, 1t has nos paid ono cent Tor legal
For eleven years never charged and never
rece,N we'd one penny for my services. When tho club
bongh' the land upon which it's club house now stands
] gave notice tn the Board should charge for my ser.
vices In The latter part OF 1871 rendered "A bill FOR
services extending from AUGUST. 1888. and IL was au.
lifted Mt The amount rendered. to wit, about So. 400.
and ordered TO bs paid 4 SINAI! amount was
500 IN ciub scrip. and later on the balance about
course ! could have received The cash had | insisted IN
IT, but my desire was to arcO IMMEDIATE the claU. The
note was rene wed two or three times, and the last re-
hewh' was made Dec. 7. lSiIo, for ioar months, In June
rr Juy ! rendered another bill Tor services sunseuuent-
" re derei, and disDur ,enlrnts subsequently, incurred. !
which was audited at SLOAN 6h. Tor wilicI | tOnk a ,
ut four months. IL tell due Nov. lI--o. and the
htNng treasurer desired ITS renewal. II had been dir.
and y Was only us = personal favor to me
W .n ne surely Pa,n at maturity. and The
Mhen the latter fell due, I re.ent,d AMI had 1t again
Renewed. When tho 81 ,otti. 90 note fell due I fell / was
entitied to have II paid. as | couii not take II
up myself aud the bank notified me they would not
renew II. IL was paid, and it, amount tas 1t included
some als~bursemeIltD IL IN excess OF tho Whole anounI
J nave ever actually received from the club for legal
except that ] turned In the SCRIPT for house
mi unless some small! amounts for dues and
LYnse accounts collected prior to Nov. 20. ls.ti. and
hundred suits brought to\enforce sucn clnims. should
the amount of Ruch 1Iaburaarnana III. |