New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1893-10-16
COLGATE & CO.'S
1906 LAUNDRY SOAP.
70. years exclusively used by tie best ''"'''s''

ro,,o,no, :, tho Controllers office it would
have been Controller WempIes duty 10 SUP
mil Il to his fellow members Oh the 49,
board of Canvassers ana tney Wouiu nave
49,, oo,nneIed 10 issue 4 certitcate of election
10 Gilbert A. Deanc, Republican, instead 0. 20
Edward g. Osborne. Democrat. ma. wa'
,,bat Isaac n MAYNARD was trying 10 pre-
49,, 10 stole the election return giving the
,rue return of the election in Dulchess COUNT!
from the Office Of the Controller III oluer ma.
the state Board of Canvass So ubi,b
have before them the Mylod return, "''o"
falsely stated that Osborne was erected
COMPLETING THE WORK OF 1NFAMf.
,,,r,.rd then completed his offence by Sit
.,, s,,.,t on December 20 in the room
,ro tho state Board of Canvassers was
maat,np and permitting them to canvass the
,tId return Although he sat within a
foot Of the table at which the members OF
,ha State BOARD Of Canvassers were canvassinG
,b;s rcturn he made no protest. lie ala not
tell them that there was return WHICH
trrIthfully told the result OF me e,ect,on III
n,tcbess County. The State Board OF can
vassers WAS informed in his presence ol 'he
existence of a true return but he ana not CON
nrm the news j. Rider Cady, the hepupucail
counsel said to the State Board OF CahVasseis
,,non tbat memorial night. the 18th or Decem-
her 1891. when the State Board or Canvassers
was counting in "A Democratic LEGISLATURE.
.It is within the knowledge OF every one
bara that the corrected election certificate from
Dutchess County, sent here by judge barhaiu,
o,ra here from Duchess County ana was
given to the Secretary of State, TO the Governor
and to the Controller ~
"Well | have no knowledge OF any such GER
tdcate" replied Attorney General IaDor. ,,
"Wili you ask Secretary of state Rice FOR IL:
said Mr. Cady. and then turning to Mr.. Rice ne
said: MIR. Rice, have you received thal COT
rccted return?'
Mir Rice did not reply; would not reply
What Is the reason this corrected eiec,'o,
return from Duchess County has not reached
u.s." said Acknowledgement Tabor.
Because" said Mr.. Cady. ut has been sur
reptltiously removed from this building aiter
being I'm the possession Of Secretary OF
state Rice. Governor Hill and Controller Weni-
pie" til, it, +,
tercsting talk was going forward. ms chei
the Attorney General. was asking FOR the cor
rect election return from Duchess County. lie
did not dare say: Il stole II.
on January II. 1892. Chief Judge Kruger dieu'
Five davs later Associate Judge Earl was ap-
uointed Chief Judge, and Isaac II. Maynard
was appointed "A judge to FIJI the vacancy caused
by Eairs promotion. But at this time MI
Maynards theft Of the election returns OF
Duchess County was not known. 1t was not
revealed until Josiah Allen gave his testimony
before cx-Judge Learned In Albany on FEBRUARY
l. one Of the judges OF the Court or Appears
after that revelation expressed his gratihcatioh
that he sat AT the other end Of the bench from
MAYNARD: and possibly some other members OF
the Court have the same feeling.
Il would seem To b. impossible that the peo-
Die. Of the State. I'm view OF Maynards record
of theft OF election returns, and attempt 10
secure a certificate OF election To a man VINO
was not elected Senator. will now elect nm
member Of the Court Of Appeals