New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1893-07-28
THE COMMONS ALL AFLIME
SCENES OF WILD DISORDER ATTEND CLOS
IRE ON THE HOME RULE RILL.

SINCE THE DAYS OF PARNELI.--ALL
THE CLAUSES EXCErr THE FIJI.
TEENIn AND SIXTEENTH
ADOPTED.
| London. July 27.-On the Government pro-
gramme o o'clock this evening was the hour set
for the closure Of the debate in committee on the
Home Rule bill. The parts of the bill left over
for the discussions Of the last week and for the
divisions this evening the financial
| clauses the schedules and the preamble The
galleries Of the House were filled with people
expecting an exciting scene at the close OF the
committees labors. Few members were absent
from the benches on the floor of the House.
The proceedings early in the evening tame
enough. John Clancy Parnellite), Member for
North Dublin County, moved an amendment to
the effect that the Imperial Government should
guarantee to Ireland 100000 annually during
the provisional period Of six years.
Mr.. Gladstone declined TO accept the amend
ment The financial scheme under discussion. he
said, provided fully for the equitable, and even
liberal, treatment of the Irish Government.
If the estimates. which had been made with the
greatest care. realized, Ireland would have
G5l 900 annually assured to her
Mr.. Goschen, Chancellor of the Exche,luer in
the last Salisbury Cabinet, also spoke against Mr.
Clancy's motion. Obscure members continued
the debate until :45. just fifteen minutes be-
fore the closure was to be applied.
CHAMBERLAIN's REPLY TO GLADSTONE.
Then Joseph Chamberlain to deliver the
final broadsidc of the Opposition. He was still
smarting under the lash which Mr.. Gladstone
swung on Tuesday evening, and spoke with cor
responding bitterness. After few scorniul AMI
biting words as TO the conduct of the Ministers,
he began giving his opinion OF the closure as ap-
piled by the Government. The members were
about to witness the last scene in discredltable
farce The debate on the financial clauses had
been a mere sham The Government had stood
over friend and foe alike, ready to let fall the
puillotine without regard for justice or constitu
tjonal rights The Irish members as well as thc
I'niOnists were anxious 10 discuss at length inc
important financial questions presented by the new
clauses but such discussion was to be cut snort.
Tho hill had been changed in its most vital fca-
lures; STILL no debate was regarded as necessary
since. whatever was altered. the bill was always
found perfect by the adherents of the Prime MIN
lister.
Jeers from the Irish, cheers from the unionls's
o,d coun,ercbeers from the Liberals interrupted
Mr. Chamberlain at this point. lie waited TWO
or three minutes before the confusion aoat"d
sufnclentlN lot INN w sP'"N
then proceeded thus
The Prime Minister calls black, ana MS
adhcreuts say it is good The Prime Minister calls
white, and they say it is better I'niohis'
laughter 1t is always the voice of God Never
since the time Of Herod has there been---
BREAKING OF THE STORM.
Mr.. Chamberlain got no further lmm"dia'eiy
after resuming his speech he had been warheu
.L., ntnr Uaf
inc. He could hardly have expected the sudden
ness with which it broke, for, with his hal'-
finished reference to ITerod, there came from 'he
Notonalists such a roar of indignation as has not
bo.n heard in the House since the days OF fAr-
neu Mr.. Chamberlain was plainly startled. hn'
be tried to talk on His voice was lnandiple 10
the members on the next bench. He turned toward
the Nationalist. and shrill wells of eXecrauoh
rose above the uproar I. =. .OConhor SpidhS
,o his feet and, leaning toward Mr.. Chamberlain,
shouted Judas 80 loudly that the epithet couio
be heard throughout the House. The rest OF 'he
Irishmen took up the cry. and Tor nan d lninu"
shouted Judas" in chorus.
THE CHA1nMANs VOICE DROWNED BY fELLS'
Meantime the clock struck 10. chairman
Mellor tried TO put the closure, Dut Ills Ho'
could not be heard amid the shouts OF TIE ITS"
and the Unionists. Then came scene nIprc
cedented in parliamentary history. Mr. Mciior
rave in a weak voice the customary directions 10
clear the House for division. As the "iSoi"'r
subsidized preparations were MADE 10 eAcc"" o'''
directions The Conservatives however may
refused TO quit the House. Weary "l"pS' "i"-
son Bowles and William lIanbury shouteu 10 'h'
chairman that he must first call Nr OConnor 10
order for having called Mr.. Chamberlain nam,S'
Mr. Mellor protested that he had not heard the
:. ,os.;on Nobodv told him what
Mr. O,Connor had said, so he sat helpless ana uh-
on,iobtenod before the House. while the members
crowded forward in excited groups, shaking thelr
e,s .rd chanting their demands Gibbs. Bowic>
and Uanbury Qot together and, TO MAKE them-
soves heard. shouted in chorus at Mr. Mcnor
VIII von direct that those words be taken
down."
Iord Pando]pn Churchill and Sir Edwar'
c,,o . hold of Mr. Gibbs and starte1 him Tor
tho front bench 80 that he might eiucioa'e 'hc
couso If the row to Mr.. Mellor. who was making
..,rous bnt vain efforts 10 hear what IN"
oricvance of the Tory trio was Nir. "IppS Tru
% oo forward but in the general ]os'lihs anu
shouting he was pushed about and so confused
,ha, no gave up his purpose, and Mr. Mellor re-
maincd uniformed
TIM, HEALY GETS HIS HAT SMASHED.
Meantime half of the Unoniss had cimbei
n the benches and were shouting Gag "as
Others were struggling in the aislcs or between
the benches with Radical, Liberal or Irish an'aso-
nists Curses ycs of pain and gross insui'S "'r'
heard on every side. John Logan lLiberaD ran
down 10 the first Opposition bench and began up
braidinp Edward Carson Tory. AS he ShooN
his fist under Mr. Carsons nose George Wyhonann
and William Fisher jumped to the assistance "
their party colleague, seized Mr.. Logan oS '"o
neck. threw him to the hooi head hrst' ana ',''',
bundled him under bench. Somebody s'"''"''
Tim" IIealys high hat down over n,' 's''
Healy tore off the hat and spranS ih'o ,nc a's,'
' -. .a...a i,,st as Mr HanburY,