Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1893-12-21

They were near uOiEhU0ss auu uu
knew NfE. lrvinu's treatment %. FIIs-
rIu O. have bUtu lnlt of devoted
IO.hcE lie mover tfW amy miatfcu..
Eynt a. the child ITO ulUryH sup.
posed that aHu conducted hUrpll prop.
uriy a. iuwArIs hur hu band, an bc
had always regarded hur ISL % true aud
devoted vic ami mother Ito had
novUr observed anything wrong uu her
tart, aul i' the pWt.us owes hUi any
lilu "Hniy jnu,n 10 was not within
with .s's Knowledge.
air, Abulo IA. Talbot wife OF the
Above duluaoui, had known the psr.iu,
while they ilvJd Ia Lincoln. Tho two
inmilirs visited rnuh othur aud bhu irU.
quUntly saw FlYasiu. Htu irviuuiH
treatment ~ the child Na4 always, 30
Tar us shu cav, that Of au aiiUcliouatc
mother. Irvine looked very pate,
SEEMED nervous uuI extremely uiuruj.
miudUi, B'tur bis tclutnl uu tho
fhIrsc W mIriur Their home ia Lin.
coin App. Aiai 600 be a happy one. Hhu
had, hove. n, sUeu Mus. Irvine "Whrn
her hear, VHs very full" although tHn
hrf-CN fu4 % thing 600 tcpInout o.. To-
.lu cluft. Slbsrqu iu her tN.
animation, SIR. Ia.uIt stated that Mt.
lsylur moro .nau Unc1 ,UlI hutit was
VERY unpleasant iu regard To MU
Irvine llIH. out 30 much nj nights
uud 10 ma q her very unhappy
Outhr .lpgtlJn ol Attorney Dickson
the CONT UJIHiUi lhU latter paIl VI tuu
t'lfs.rp s'fI'rHu out.
AiH. -. is. futile, Of Lincoln, had
ku.W tho lt3luyB rincc 1855, and
y.situd tDe house, Mother and child
FrUmyd very fond OF rsci other, anu
Iu. isgiuu osmDd always ~ "lago
goat Interest 10 bring her up right"
Irvine amt his vile appeared 10 be on
ihl hyei ~ tormr, anu upp1uCut regard.
ci her us devoted vile.
The dvp9sIugns OF the husband OF
tho last witness, q. j. futile, were also
read. lie, too, testified a- 10 Alrs.
lrvino'h affection for Flussic w lar
gs he had had opportunities OF Obscrv.
iug.
Alm. J. VI. GOODWIN, OF this clty,was
then callgd {, the witutss-stanr. In
answer 20 Mr. Zane bhr said tho
lrVinCH resided near her while Ia Salt
Lake. She frst became acquainted with
Mrs. Irvine Tn the year 1851.
Mt. Nauc-DO you know anything
Of thc habits OF Mt Irvine ne TO loAv-
ing lis vito alone at nlght2
witness answered that che hal never
been there when Irvine remained for
more than iyu minutes. lie was away
ilom homo great deal anu she rarely
saw him Of an evening,
Mr. IinC-Whnt was Ms. Ifvine's
conduct A. "a wife?
WitnCM-fO nue. it seemed "a beautiful
home, and her conduct certainly wac
OF the most tender aud gentle. Her
conduct asa wifi appeared 10 be tN.
vmplsryi aud Bh1 appeared 20 do her
utmost 10 make the home attractive.
Her treatment towards Flussic wan that
VI an aileoliUnatv mother.
Mr.. Diuksln-W We're you afraid 10
get acqua nod with Mis-. Irvine NJ any
limt2
WitnUsl-l was.
Mr.. Dickson-How long after the
family moved into your uuighbOrhOUd
was thE3
Wilnuis-I was afraid TO got ac.
quaiutsl with her lori ono weeks alter
-perhaps Two or thfgo months. she
added, Ia answer 10 other qurhti0ns,
that her evening visits might have
been once week, sometimes Ogtpner,
self ~ soon AS p0ssiDlu alter wituens
went In,
Attorney Zane took exception TO tho
way in when Attorney Dickson was
handling the witness auu remarked
"lou utUd not lecture this lady"
~ am not occurring noL sir TO.
toTtod Mir. Dickson, "nud / DOM Ia.
tend 10 bo lCctufoi ny you oithctn
l. a
ever observe any unkindnOss on Mt.
ITvine's part towards his wiic2
WltuUts-l have heard her talking
anu pleading with him 30 come home.
Mr.. Nhuh2
Witusss-.rimu and timu again, asI
have sal on my porch.
"What dil she nay2" asked counsel.
Wiluess--"Now, W,l, YOU come
home carly, WON'T your" und sue
would always follow MIN 60 Tue gate
aud call after him when he had gone
aCiOas the street UE almost 10 tGu cor
utg,
"rhsl Ia what you call begging anu
pleading with hlm2"
Nies.n
ML IlDu, In redirect examination,
asked lhe witness why she war 1t iirut
afraid TO maze tnu acquaintance 0l
MTF. lryiae.
Witness said she had evidence which
satisfied her shat there wu "s0me.
thing very, very wrong" She then
went on TO state what LoF uuy8 had
told her-lua. IAcy haC ht.id,sCIrnmB
for help coming ifyu .ho Irvine house
ills ~ night.
Mr. Dickson objected TO this tostl-
mony, WHOM tho Judge ordered
stricken out.
Il. l.. Goodwin, son Ut lAe lat wit.
ness, was asked by Mr.. Ztuu- DurIug
the time the lTvlnts hyuu opposite
your house, dii you 500 Anything IN
regard TO the manner VI their married
lifc2
The defense objected 10 Sale question
aud another was substituted which
,licitci fg0m the witness the answer
that Irvine was In the habit Vi return
ing home about midnight. Witness
had known him to return ~ . a. Ia.
Mr. Zaue--Did you ever hsar any
screams proceeding from tho Irvine
r,siduuOt2
WltupFs--He1,
alr. Zauo-A mans or womau's2
WiIutss-A womRnS. lie added
and Chili's also. This was fow
moments after lryine's return home,
but ho dii not hear iFyine's voice.
Tho child screamed az though scared.
He had likewise heard eounds M Of
the bruaEiag Of cfocSery there. Both
tho woman ana child screamed before
ana after The crnah. Both BuemGd
scared.
Mr.. Zane - How often did this
screaming occur?
Nltues8 Worry often; sometimes
fgur and Uyn tIruta N uuHrn