The Helena independent. [volume] (Helena, Mont.) 1875-1943, 1893-10-12
All Sin, PRO AND CON.
Debate Begun on the McCreary Bill
to Extend Time Of Regis
tration.
Tho Author Declares It Would
Save Billions and Prove Very
Acceptable
Gssry says It Osly TsmpoFizss With I
serious situation = Attorney 0snsrsl
Olnsy Roasted.


WASHINGTON. Oct. lin the house
Outhwsits presented an order for the con.
sidsratioA Of the AcCrsary bill 10 amend
the GeaTy exclusion act from day 70 day
until disposed Of. without division II was
adopted and MoCseaEy open cd debate. The
bill. he said, Affected the contention be-
wssn two great countries. concerned l0O.-
600 Chinese In this country. asd II passed
would save billions of dollars to the United
widespread demand for tho disoontinuAnos
of undesirable Chinese immigration. He
explained at length the provisions of the
bill. which have appeared in the Associated
press reports. and also reviewed the treaties
between China and the United States
and the legislation looking MP to tho pas-
sage Of the Gssry exclusion act. This
bill simply gave ths Chinsse Of shis
country six moaths additional time IN
which to register. shsy having dsolined to
do 10 on the advice of their attorneys.
pending decision Of the supreme court.
The Chinese. he ssid. had able lawyers who
advised them not 10 register. 80 the law
would be declared unconstitutional. The
i"o' en"' ou' ~ =. - An' '0'''
supreme court. said MoCrsarH coulA be
found Of the opinion that the GeaRy law 10
constitutional certainly shows that those
attorneys had good ground for thsir advice.
He said the Chinese who acted on the ad-
vice Of their attorneys should have an op-
poEtunity to register.
To transport tho $1,000 Chinamen who
na'e nos seR..'sl'~ , uou'u so'' '"e sS.e
mena accoIdlna 10 sns esslmAse ~ n oon "t sns Seo.
r.tary of the treasury, $7.OOoOOO. Over
o5OOO. SAID he, are an11ously awAtlng
for congress to decide sneir ia!e.
and thousands OF Anne ioan mlssionaflss
IN China are waiting WIN feas ana Memo'
ling lest, II We IRE precipitous. the Chinese
may: IN their wrath. resaliate epon shem'
McCrenry said, in conolusion. shst .9e Ok
pulsion OF Jews from hussia or tne aueuo-
nots from France was NOS more DAT DatDa. "a 01S o0o
than would be our acslon II ~ lososu o9ooo
Cinnamon TO depors because shsJ haa oeen
deAly, wno .o.l: 1eu. w"' II ou h.s. 'oS "isS
to proceed wiehoue nmlt. ~ Deaan wsn
IN Indignant denial OF Sne Ienee'.on: n"ue
upon the facino COAST poopIe IN snon
on the Chineee; Moors were nos eApeIou.
Jews were nos ofiven ous, hngasaos We.o .e
refused to obey the laws M OF the country In
whion sney iesiaea. uns cnsman s nn w." y. su o
foreign auaifs oomhtseS Sa. wa. no laoo ..'n NJ
name snan No. no mole Cnt.s'au M Ml:N snan No.
Mnne ooh Del.evo S"o ~, e.,s
en1sled 20 any new isnM. ss.u .si.,. 10;
OF snis question: give US an oppo.suny "
regulate snsir stay nero anu " piSs'nI
more from GO - 'nk. % wa:I s.';o, !. ",,-
am aesinss 0eeause :.:I cene'e W. on;H n;i,
temDofines Win me S'uasioI; n.i; W. orid
oner amenamenss wn'o1 w oone :.o..S :ou.S
make ehe Dill eneoslve' IL 'neS "'' '''0'''1
We Will vose aHahss .,.,
He went on TO speak OF we ,a aoverse or1u, ~.
cism OF tho bail thas bore ms name. ne
8. oke OF the tsso!ut'ons aoopseu W uine
ens 1enR'ous nouies. A., ,a;s s ~" ;,n- ~
tho same phraseology uemanu1na G i.. NV W.T.
nea.~so toHe"s 10, "hnr.h :" ..L con.
aress to DO anssn'n9. he nag supposeu
the line between ohplon anu tIa s.ssv S;a va 80
Sharply otaWn ~ ms n;HV ,..;tion hut
deny the sacfeu .,ais ..is;o VI o' ;nd;v;dr.is
ch1rehmen muss pesMon Hs 90 .he nhaush
ana aa1 no. INVOKE 'ns 'nnu'n'' ~ 'A' 'A1''D'
lAppiAuHel. ,ooo A.. r,;..a c.....
Ever since 1882 whom tne Un,sea .n esases s.es
declafea I'VE nGs.r hn '0.S 9.ond "md ' Inn,;oitv
was an nouE when: " ..auu III nnu ~ ho.d.,:
CninesS wore nov .S s.sns ~ "n 1,to th;s
ol tne Oa'SHu o'a'ss n " .h;. .oniS ho.s
couosEy' Sn'na. Anuwk SA... ;. IU hwH rI;n
stopt 60 we v,o'n',0n .Un VI H~s, '.o a ~,
renamed snent: Anc.e ~ ~ ~
sympstns ior .9. on.nu. Shc st.s,a "ss ao -" Thho
snrplns earnings OF sne cs;a Gn,nose, on.sS wn.sS
.noy n"1 o" "". ~ scnn Nnn nn0 sDo
TO ehe enormous sum OF so.o.o1; s;nc eHs y. ns
!ou vnnoei WY we Ion AAo 'Io 0"'A'''
| In Califofnia1 10 asked
| ,oo ~ ~ IN sny ono u. yous 80.
| lOOUV lno0res ooe we're s"ppluR "om you'
wealth SN.Voo a.y ~ sa.pu; Ia 80 .ha,n
wou'o you nos ~sns ~ ke' 81. .
lhey are an 90 u 'o0oSe'' "o' q" "AA
OK iapo ets' .,;-.5 ~,
Havont snev H.ve" velue .s'e'coa. n
askeo bakel, ot NOV ua..ps: .:a
SAID ne peneveo now ~ pIoine0s iii =.
can laoo' neains' pNepeI I iapos 30 VII M 90
the oducs OF peupoE '1oofe's' ln'
pla1se. .....,. ..,a,
henderson. OF iowa, lntoltups'he. .al1 :;
"Thats pretty good rsponnoae ooesI'se.
VII my Pmly ulu NV ...h.. -o.1S init
trine." replied deary. tnsa "oelo qu''
it. bnt ! think 1t does
| why don's you cxseno tue hmiS asked
Baker, so ~ to include osnef 1ofs'ons'a
besides Chinsaer
II have bill IN shis mousse now. rep1ieo
Geary. ITO prevent immiaration. Whl yot
vote for II. a. WI r. lApPlause.
Bake: Il believe In fev'sina our sfsss's'
first"
Geary, consemptuous'y; some peopia
seem TO believe We nave NOS Rot our gown
yet, that before leRislaslnR We muse eonsul'
tho wishes Of foreign countries. LAP
-