The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1893-10-24

4 Ahar p.,A he ~. httaa,, L.. al
steuben dIstrict. WAS clearly Ineligible unde
the campaign; nut thc hepnbllcans conclude'
70 ,gnore u, I ,,y 99eneted tnnt they would b
posed to scat Sherwood whether he was ellGi
Bile or not, ana Notwithstanding the violated
an opinion from, an able Repnblican lawyct
and eSTguhge, OF the Court OF Anpeals, Mr.
sherwood was eligible. Mr.. Maynard took the
contrhry view me Conrt OF appeaiS subso
nmentiy UNANIMOUSLY 81 h. neciued tnat Dnnori
was va, ri Iy,,., nor,or,h s,,,,,c ,n,o 81.
lera! ,dciest, is now engaged in den S Rls
a srs w Hso v nssr an ne othH,
courts. lawyers VINO wore ue'e"'ea III tile
Upon t tho question OF the VALIDITY Of certain
anIprsar pG ~ wnIch containen wrong
law.
Gated legal proceedings which grew eS out Of
mus. injunctions stays Of proceedines' and
other manruvros without number. Every very
conten,ied in the OnondSen case that certnin
| Republican baIlots cnntsinin9 n Wrong W an M
Sphsd that sn hs s
oerntic Senatorial candidate duly elected
asSs ,s sSesthST VIII the result in the
vote Of tho Democratic lieutenant. q vsrnur
rrespeetiye Of any result In the Duchess ia.
trict. N Wv = ''"''' N''
the
Sem democrats In the organization OF tho
=, Thus, 4 the Republicans had been awarded
asta Sad penns tSs as
| ings, IL would have availed them nothing. II
& Ssa and hen given the the
ators. and the Democrats would have still had
the control Of the. senate by means OF their
- Al
Therefore. in any view of the case. the cbarp.
hs the SENATE BY %ny6ody S
conceal the modification OF Ieeal defeat ''' "
sixteen ees and tho
Governors casting vote. and the Duchess
way or the other "s'' '"' '''u"''on 'ne
THE DuTcHEss COUNTY CONTEST
a Maynardi as the general Democratic counsel
eases whien was not technically and strictly
Iet IN sas what h. ala !, tho nr,,,,,.
county nm ease! Sase: ,,o.u.. 49,.
the yaidite uItpse IN ehao case turned upon
Senatorial ballots marked iQr identiiication in
vnss was Sniv mada hv I'm na Il. 9oi; can
,ylsors q that county. whereby these fra4du-
affect Of snch aSton 20 oct oHt ana the
Democratic candidate. The then Republican, can
no RSS H.erk. VINO was OK oncio the clerk OF
testify 70 Tho ratrp ANA neIuseu 70 GER
elected one 81 their plumber tMylodl as clerk
Wns S}v ahd ne III 10 tne return which
". IT, IGou. 1Ie Vaiiu!ty u tnat return was
was not properIy certified. "Ao ''''' !"
IN, Inc thhepubncans then opened their batteries
upon tha Steta o anu mSveo ior manaamus
vent their counting the Myod certificate. and.
board Vas restra;nn5 Vi 'he nianoamus' inc
That stay was granted in violation OF law.
e oid 5he SouTt OF Appeais subsequently 80 de-
Il s'ate HspqrtD. s;s 'e'' De'0N a' "'e 81 ''
HAD not that violation Of law occurred. pro-
SGnst as Nv wfs at Inc and for the
SoI Hi ana %o ,h nnTe been canvassed on Dec
tbs s9yd nd af nan me DatShess county case would
w9 Wtil have aX been declared elected.
nG mon .n1s SITUATION existed me Republican
stipulation , in reference to tho Dutchess case.
daRa cases by the e Of %eh an hnd
Of I,t the Mylod return and the legal questions
n5snf IN ne n. cases were all to be sub
70 p pc sTHspe ,b IN the mean time
Conrf ~ me dec1son OF 5hese cases by the
I0r OF sh 70 hepnnlcans instituted legal proceed.
ca5t 70 pfE S return from Duchess
ar tnat suSn attempf 70 procure an
b r S was IN vioiaton OF the stipulation
70 oe ueteFmined on the point OF tho validity OF |
inc Myt3d return and upon that only, Their
con.enti ' Vas cieariS rlghT As well might
ses ~ new tacts ana make new case In the
os aoe anu ohohuaga cases as IN tho Dutch
REPUBLICAN DESPERATION
submit FIN, tho p.,,,,,,. ~.
neir an on me aileged invaidity OF the Mylod
IT, Good faith 40 renn 70 STANG or ial ny
~. JoJu iaitn 30 required IL. falr dealing de-
thatr IT, Mevertheless IN plain violation OF
tnelr agreement; the other Republican counsel
n oHeG 10 r0mnei hanother return from Dutchess
lh min' ouS upon teehnical points entirely.
Snrad al opeciai Term at iouehkeepsie or
nr inarRed or iraudulent Dean ballots
gwen Dean. the Republican candidate. the
e ev no An appeal was promptly taken
'}ecision ann rs iro a that special Term
os inn anu STAY was asked pending de,
t 81 ~. some Dem9cIatic Judges who wanted
bo rd 80 israaiEht that they leaned over