New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1893-01-27
..me with the Peoples party. the Prohibition

same with the Peoples party. the Prohibition
party and the Womans Suffrage party.
Mr. Fish was the next OF the Republicans 10
attack the bill. lie said, in answer to the charge
that the Republicans ought to harc prevented the
mistakes of the majority, that he for one' was
Willing to vote rof any kind OF bill that would
do away with the expense and the discomfort OF
spring election. = ] see BY the morning papers,
he said THAT the men who decided upon the
changes in thisAbn called into consultation WITH
them yesterday gentleman who a!ts on inc
Court OF APPEALS bench and who is an adept III
deriving people OF their rights: notice by the
morning papers that the 'c0picIcnce was hcio IN
the Executive Chamber and that u gentleman
who sits in the Court Of Appeals Judge Maynard
was sailed lii
ont OF order State officer" almost shouted
Patrick Henry Roche. of New York City, boiling
over with rage.
AThe gentleman is out Of order! exclaimed the
Speaker
Have not a right to alludc TO the fact that
This gentleman was called?' asked Mr.. Fish.
This is a matter OF public history. as we'll as
Was his action on other matters that are also
public history. / have made no reflection upon
him / refer to the history OF the H'',e. :
wonld like the Speaker to cite the rule uhuctf
which no declares that | am out oil orncf; Wi
take INV seat il am out of order and II tue Cnmf
wil.cite the rule that Will SNOW l"'' an '"' VI
Here there was pause for full1 three minutes.
during which the Speaker made no attchpI 10
find any rule that would sustain MN IN referr"
10 Judge Maynard. Mr. Fish held the Moor or, anu nv
the Speaker finally WIS forced to declare 'ha' lie
81 Nil amend then" said Mr.. Fish by all1dng
70 the pubic documents Of this state which are are
part of the history OF the Sae rG ;ourr NJ of
Last wear / am justified in abiding TO Jndge
MAYNARD In this way, and | doubt II INC ona,r
will call me to order for So a Go hy the Br AssO c
ton of tie City of Ncw-{ork in regard to the ser
vices Of one Of those gentlemen who mas Decil re-
sponsible for eliminating the min0r IL in drdcr
Mp Nnsworth then said ~ TOO, read ap9u,
Tho distinguished State official who was cal.d d
into consultation when this bill was amended
into the shape that it now is ip; do not won.
der that the Democracy trembled IN us nools
when reference was made 10 the 1acu tiat ono oi
with Democratic politics 1t is true hat the
only odium cast upon that court, which has herr
State and of the United Sto'cs. was born OF 81, the
fact that its ermine was dragged III the muu ~
give the present majority 10 the democracy %
this body 1t is fact that because OF 'hot ac.
the Court of Appeals decisions, whenever they
touch political questions, are looked upon WIN
suspicion and disrespeet by inc .ar ANA Tue peUpc
DIE has been called to the fact that now returns
are not to be stolen, but the very Voice OF the
people Is to be snllelcIieu LOT pu'isa" ~
Mr.. Ainsworths amendment was defeated BY
n otr:ct Marty vote and the bill then was hnaHy
passed for the fourth time by the same klnd Oh
vote. 800 J.: a., cno,o
resistance was made 10 its Immediate passage by
Senator McNlahon. Democrat ana ny AL t,G re-
Strong speech against it. He expressed his keen
disappointment at the starting OF the dep1tc oVcI
the fact that minority representation heu On
abandoned Il believe that the Dlii Wicn T's
rascal here the other day was CONSTITUTIONS,
said Senator Mcmahon, =" and moreover. u wa, wa
in the interest of the people, because 1t rccoenzeu
the right of minorities 10 representation IN VIC
Constitutional Convention. IN was an aosolutciH
inst bill There is nothing in the Comstltu'iootn
forbiddinc minority representation. That bill
said that the official ballot should contain Only
ccrsain Names and that constitutional.
want to see New-York stand in the forefront OF
States as she has in the past. Let every element
tion hear il said that the Democratic AND
Republican parties will grant the minority parties
representation by running their Candidates upon
ficir tickets What guarantee have we that uiie
wifi be: deIte l move that We non-concur II.
o. o' a. least that then bill be laid aside for day
until we can thoroughly examine it.
Senator Cantor said that the Objection 70 oena,
cor WcAIahon's plan that 1t would he aniawtai
to say to any great political party that ~ siloa,u
largo when there were thirty-two places 10 DC
Thcrc is no constitutional prohibition to that,
soia Senator McMahon land it has TINS az
santiago. that it gives chance for tne r,o'li oh
tienisfs. the Socialists and tho Popuists 10 3D.
min Representation in the LEGISLATURE
Ifter some further debate Senator Cantor coh-
:onfc1 that the bill should be laid upon the
table The Democrats will make another a'tcmP'
to pass it tomorrow