Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1893-12-30
THE END VERY NEAR.
Juigo Powers Makes His Closing
Speech For ". h. Irvine
CAREFULLY REVIEWS EyERrraISs
Tie Ease WIN DO Submitlod To Chioi
Justice Zane Late This After.
uoon.-A Crowded Audience.

ing argument Of Juige PJWcfa in the
remarkable divorce su, oi Irvluu vs
Irvine.
The NEWS report oloaod yesterday
afternoon with a portion o. thcurgu'
mont OF Judge Bennett (Bcnuo.b
binnhall q Bradley on hehali oi hri.
Irvine, the defendant He c1nloudei
that, In amy event. Mrs. Irvine was
entitled toh substantial allowance az
suit money, hor CEpeuse8 in thcso pre-
ccedings having been exceedingly
heavy. Hb honest belief however
was that she was not guilty, and taat
theluJcmcut OF the court should pp Ia
her favor. Irvine, be said bad 6ecn
cruel AMI duvilah "a ,ho cz,Iumc to-
wnJd his wife.
Judge Powers then proceeded with
his closing address on bsnali Of lrvin1.
lilo tvmafgod that ibis case was Que
affecting not only thB paruts immrai.
utuly concerned, uut 10 ALDO had an
elect on tho sancIiy u tue home.
Having rcad from the Bible passages
Of tho marriage tc, nr n.id that the
tacreIneas uI llu nome would Do tho
tuume OF his pIc4liu.u iu this case.
Tho scvernuca OF the marriage liO waH
NOS a comedy, hut % tf.ga4y, tuurasl
turned hi attention % Attorney Curus,
whom be- accused VI aupp.aIug ow.
duucp AMI l9csilg Do up 100 O. UuU
fairhol which hB carried AROUND NE
The ark Of the covenant. Next hr
dealt az some length with tho conduct
ui Mrs. Irvine, sud Gsid thc time hrd
not arrived yet when mauicd
woman might accept tie cnrcs Cd y.
matt dozen men, und yet be- tuuu %
hcr husband and Keep her character
ifu8 nom rspfOach. Tie judge de.
n0uuuud Montgomery ~ uumrulufud
terms, nud denied that Mis-. Irvine
was tuu imOgcne which counsel on
thB other side ned sought 10 paiu, htr.
When court lpuuod thlH morning
there was oar larger Attendance OF
spectators than curing tue three
JAYS prcviour-ainge tho commence.
mtut VI the legal ANU uouu. Judge
Mnrahall, u counsel Tor the deiuuuH,
was present again today after Two
days' absence, nul tho parties 90 the
suit (AlG Rud Airs. irvinu) occupied
their accustomed scat. a dozen or
more iadius were accommodate with
seats Within the blb against thu east
window.
Judge Powers resumed his olosils
rouinrlso On behalf OF The plaintiff ".
II. Irvine. he aaiu that while .aont.
geometry talked love 10 Mrs. ifyine 10
was Illicit love, not tho lnTs that bios
eomud into IDarflage, because Ut no
;ime anu ifder no circumstances in
ibis ease gFd ho suggest ~ her that no
would eyer marry her.COuusoi failed 10
tee wlsy the matter OF Irvluu's trial and
nvqni,ial on a charge OF murder had
bsbn intoUootod here, whore u played
no part. rhey we're not rc.iryiug that
matter now. A proper tribunal had
passed upon IL aud this court, not
having heard tho t0stimJny, would
not say that the verdict was wrong.
His Honor Judge Hlu0 was not sitting
now asa court OF appeals, 10 reverse
the action OF that jury. Way should
counsel on this other Hido ridIcuie aud
laugh ut tails mans religious nature
having been touched, buclusu he In
vOked the aid OF tho Almighty when
he was In diatrcssr Tortured hy his
thoughts ia prison, ho mad turned
them towards heaven and hum0loI
himself before bis Maker, Counsel
looked upon that aln remarkable tuiug
for gentlemen on the other eide q
do; for bad not good aud holy
NEE taught ms that he who ~ b.
trouble could nowhere appeal 10 bUttei
advantage than 10 the God who made
himi The alleged viall1 OF Mrs.lryiut
to the Montgomery block AZ LiucolI
came IN for review. Mrs, Irvine, Ia
her testimony, HWnre thEl she nsg
never been Inside that building, anu
yet reputable citizens had sren hel
going there. Talk ABOUT manufacture
teAtimouy, about oaso made 20 order
about circumatantlnl unity with cir,
cumatantlal variety. that was jus
what they had here. 10 would seen
that Mu, Irvine had lived a dUublI
lie. Counsel for tue deiouto said thA
70 her husband she had been truv;nt TO-
same time % was admitted luas shu
was vito 10 another man iu everything
with 0np exception, Mrs. Irvine
association with d.. Gurih-- lfCast
ally described by counsel "as tbs
knight OF truJu"--WcIe raiUrfud to;su,
with regard 90 DT bpochlpy 90 Aslu
coin, whole dispositions were Iua.
during the trial, Judge puwers sat.
tuNt that gentleman, who was a die
iuleIeitsd party bad imI uachuu tul
defendant uIuu material UulUt. TN
read from and criticised thC Cyiiolc
OF various witnesses with tA
object Jl showing certain yOutlRulg
lions OF Mr.. lIyiuUH tesllmIuy ~
THIS connection the Grace hoiel rggl.
trntiOn incident wus mentioned.
was IN the light OF these couiFaIigtl0 .
and iu the light OF Mrs, lryiur's CUu
duct, which phr admitted that b
wanted Go dFcuHH the UuH, ore tread
Ing ON tle heels %, another until thu
reached point whrrD u1t Ou'y hH
human blood been shell uuT O nom
had been destroyed, and nu tXHmpl
oct society that could only 100 con
dtmuuG uy sn h1uust Judge. lu ui
tuTgsQua language Judge Power
taCirnpl the eagly mrrrrl llia o. tu
lIyIuga mud tapr vgUr a.rugslDB {
uiirlu lottur nUs..0n Iu lIie Incl
ruOgUgagut removal 20 Lincoln, Sc
hlgsAa, wus tha nest cIuuu..un UQ
forged uy u0ulUH. lu tHU UEaH IuHllu
uptO tuo W't.'E association with N0U
r1uvel, when "hv JHW. was WI.u D.
tlu hear. di Hu unworthy Wlu.H Iu
coming % lle nayIHa no 6l. L.Eu gu
then taken ul, ANA ono HIHuliIuH.o Iu
ttea written by A!a Irvine 10 ht
husband while she WaB eugmurea
Ooh Montgomery iu4 48gucl 30 aa
'lL Wuul. seem lhil u.u WHs "a IuUta
Hr jnEvll au1 Ir Ey.a.H "DuE
hgr own mUuln,' ue eNela.mud, "W
H.| D. HH