Deseret evening news. [volume] (Great Salt Lake City [Utah]) 1867-1920, 1893-08-11
Contradictory Statements Made By
Him on the WIt1eSS-Stald.
nj WOULD DICTATE 70 THE COURT
The Case Goes over iill Tuesday 10
Enable TIE Court and Counsel
10 visit City Greek Canyon.

"a NANHa-fANAAAAhANANh ~ RNNNAA'A
williams as to whether he was in
stmcicd by Mr.. Ryan to 20 and inspect
the work at the Mogul mine, the wilt
ness answered ia the negative and
added tina, he went to inspect the
work done on the waterwofSs.
Q.--why did you then no to the
miner
Aust to zee 1t.
Q-was there windlass at the
mint?
AL presume there was.
Were there any buckets or tools
tutug
A.-No, saw none.
GLOW much lumber was theru2
Ask or seven pieces
Q-was that all the lumber that
vas seutuI?
Aye, as Jar "a 1 know.
l-Was there n collar round the
rauh Of the mine or any place to rest
Wiudlngs on?
h,--rhere was an old rotten one.
o Was anything sail by shaier
4.sut making collar?
h.-No-yes-(coniusedlyl-Gth think
.nvtr was.
q You sent down an ordorior lum-
o.. 60 Morrison, Merrill & c.?
A.-lus, oent TO Ryau's private
"a .S for an ORDER.
tl-Has Ryan a private clerh9
NHn lNHaVt. a. a Indy Win docs
Nr. kyan's private business and slgns
l., name TO orders.
&, -- Docs she do Ryan's private busi'
Lttsuud does the city pay heiY
Ayes. (lhis answer Of tho wit.
tees created quite n sensation IN COURT
Y Who ~ the private oiofkt
"a Annie Maidison.
q Aui you got an order from hei2
A=-lts.
q -rhu man you sent to get the
Uulrg was In the employ Of the city2
Aye.
q And you sent him on your prl.
vac busiucss 10 get this lumber which
Was 80 bc used In the miuv2
Wines. with C1nsidurable hcsita.
uaD answered "yes"
q HAT you authority from Ryan 10
arud tor the lumuci2
A.-No, l did Il on my own ao.
Csuut.
Q.-whcn did you send for the
cJud lot OF lumber
a About June 18Th ur lO.h.
Q.-ro whom DID you send the
ota,t2
A-ro the Sierra Nevada Lumber
emInuy.
Q-whom dii you send Tor the
second lumuuI2
Al don't remember.
Q.-Was tia regular city employe
npnU2
Very reluctantly the witness an.
twcgoI Ia the affirmative.
Q-iOw much lumber dld you
tilcr the second umt2
N.-rbirlouu pieces.
Q-WhHt did you get the lumber
lyig
Al DON'T know.
@ Yrstion s.ernly repeated,
A.-lO make ladder for the Mogul
u.uc.
Q,--.rho oTderu you sont were con.
vuyyd by men working for the city
uuI the lumber was hauled up the
canyon by men anu teams Ia the en-.
Iluy OF the city?
Al tank 40.
Q.-Can you explain how the lum-
Der came 10 be- charged 10 the city2
A.-Unlcss II WIS by mistake.
Q Why did you not sign your own
rume instead Of Ryau's, NJ you were
Farmer In the miner
Al thought they know Ryan
teller than me- and NO could get credit
while l could not.
Q,-HOu knew he had the City
treasury behind him2
Objected 10 by Mr.. Murphy as
tcandHlOus.
Mr, Williams-Very scandalous that
such state OF things should exisi;that
D. where the scandal Is, andlno in the
uulIng Of 1t out.
j. a. shnfor EXAMINED by Mf.
autphy In tebuttal
Odd you hnvo any conversation
wl.E bruce about the affidavit niL1T II
was published2
Ayes; lac told me he had no cause
90 make the affidavit; that Ryan was
90 man he was after anu was sorry
ta.i DO had Affected me, and he would
10 " he could, but II had Rone too
now Tor that.
NusrGxamnod by Mr.. Van Colt.
Q Dii you hear Mir. Hoko say on
Hul that you we've going 10 90
u"ut work ON the miner
a Yes; l knew we were going 10
"H.rrnmeut work,
% Did Ryan speak 10 you quite
Nntt before you went up about doing
tscHmrnt work?
H.--No.
@ What implements did you tako
u.1 du assessment work with2
"A windlass, "A blaCasmith's
srdrills, picks, shoyols, ammunition
500 PROVISIONS.
q Did you take powder up City
th,k 10 use for the city?
A-No, IL was for private ute In ths
mu,?
@ Were the windlass and the rope
aHt Inc urill for use by tho cityY
Mo, they Were for use ON the
I.u.
q Did you tell bruce you expected
'u 90 work fur you ON the mine?
al told him / expected him
help me ON the mine In over.
o. What did you tell him ut the
WAC you hired him about boaru?
Al told him that the city would
~ kv no arrangements about board
-"l mat We would have to board our.
Q What wages did you agree to
lhN uim2
~ made no arrangement about
N'.tp.
I'D you mean to say that you