Grand Rapids herald. [volume] (Grand Rapids, Mich.) 1892-1959, 1893-12-06
HOT FOR THEM BOTH
Senator Dolph Rips cisssIand's
Policy Wlds Open.
SHOWING UP ns fAlLAcIfs
Its ch4rges That Bioans's h~pors u
Bia-sd ast >os B.-ssi ea f'Act<
polnxs az Coaxra-&

WAssfsaros. Dec. a--WhsD the sen-
ats met today Nf sherman presented
large naashsr of petitions from soldiers
q ths lats waF si.hisut regard to party
praying for an Investigation Bs0 the
psaslon bureau.
Anonz ths pstitions presentsd and
rsfssred stre sotns from the stats Of
Oreson Tor the maiutsaanes % the pres-
cot daty on prun4iss aud Nr. Doiph
gave nOtier that DC would address the
isa4ts on that sableet snd on the tzrsn
generally next ~seA
Ar Hoar oliesrd a resolution request
inr fas pf-sfisaI - give the senate
eopiss ~ al instructions 20 ministers ot
tas ga.Jc,i States IN regard % the pres
eryaJoa 4 pablic osaef in tiawaii or
he prcteciloa x the lives and property
q Auesital cltizeas or tho recognisloa
er sappcss q any gDsefnmeut thereof.
Sir. r.erul4u sad tnat While p Was IL
ftEos ~ tae reso.usi0n. be AoughE II
shoa 4 rot BE- acted on ia the abseace u
Air NaFg4n. ths chairman II the CON
uitfee ou taSeisn sr4ot.1ns. aal IL MAS
a.l1aeil 90 iie oser fas ne pfessaL
DoIph TAI~. Ca Hawaii
Ns Dmph rose ana addressed the
. o. On the seh.ccL Il Hawai-. he
4. rrsse,f has IA Srise az the portion og
iha psgsidents Wefs.is.s read yesterday
r-ieraus - a. Nolg outstanding the
fspost Ok the secretary % state TO the
president. aud notwithstanding the
newspaper report ss - The purpose OF
t-e administration. he had not con
eelvsd IL possible that the adm nisfFa-
fi0n xould dctefulae on the foseibie
overthrow q. the EXISTING government ia
Haxaa aod - the establish meGt u a
native mouaschy. He had uc.Ieved that
egea Y such had been the purpose u
the aim in,strati0n. the expression OF
pauiic opinion ~ the newspaper press.
simosg unanimous against such a course
would have cbangcd its purpose and
have caused tae president % modify bis
Instructions 4. the present minister 20
hasan. Mr. DOlph quoted para
graph fron the presidents message and
took exccptiOl to the assertion that Mr..
Bl0ants report showed beyond all ques-
too that the constitutional goserument
Of Hasaa bad been subverted With tho
active ald ~ the American minister and
81 the presenee of an armed force of the
Unitsd states. landed FOR that purpose.
stevens Report ignored
The message placed the report q the
personal representative Of tho president.
acting nnsler secret Instructions. and
conducting an exparte examination as
enfillssi q more eredence than the OH
ciai report of the minister % Hawaii.
the reports o. naval officers. and the in-
formation received from tho christian
ani intsAigeut people % Hawai-. since
the reyoiufion. IL would have beeo
more satifactory % him Mr.. Dolphi and
g. the country II the president had been
a little more explicit a. 81 how IL was
proposed % undo the alleged wrong and
a. o. how The administration was 20 pro-
ceegi O. ressore the status existing az the
time ~ tue alleged f0Fcible intervention.
tie thought that he Was warranted by
The presidents message IN assuming that
somethiug more than moral suasson vas
% De a-ei % change the government %
Hawai-
i.-vetsnd'. Course Condemned.
Ile considered the utterances % the
president a. most remarkable in view of
use facts. A dissolute. corrupt native
qseeE hsd been depOscd and provis-
tonai goVernncut established which
represented ,bs intel geocs. the wealth.
tie business interests and the educa-
tlonsi. moral and christian elements of
tne Islands. sui If the policy % the ad-
mlai=tration should result IN restoring
tne gueen zrea .sr crime against civili-
Estiuu could cot 20 committed A o.
tie course q he administration there
waa ruom for a Nide difference q 0pin-
inn a. ~ box Tar g bad been caused by
: sosire r the present administration
O. discre,at the action ard policy "a Its
IredeVessor The pf0upt Hithdrawal
oi the treaty ircm ths senate the pend
i1x % a personal representative 10 TIA
vsu uacer secret Instructions. the
secrecy under which The whole
procredinK Rad teen r0rductcd. all
gaze color lo tho idea that the pur-
pose ~ fhe administration bad been
early 'ofmei and that 81 which had
bees s.nce done bad been done ior the
Furpose ~ preparing the announcement
- 20 policy q 'be administration.
f,olph Fsrors AencVstion.
o. tts euufse ~ tie speech. Mr. Vest
ssze,l Nr naiph EEsiher he Wss srzu.
irE in ftr.f ~ fae policy % securing the
Ties sit.n ie-slds 49, haidinz them Rs a
rninng graer Nhat $50 Snusn ~ ths
crrtioanfal Ell sfem of Europe 4 viii
cuae FL tnst directly. sad Mr. Doiph
Il sm ID fsvnf = tar annevsfion e the
is.snda lam a fsFof - zIyax them a
suifstir gsFrrumaaf anfi exercising con
mi over them. fnFcihis intervention
o. resfors tne 1stire government xoaid
~ e. Hszrsnt Violation N the priaci-
ples q inferasfiesai isv and isatice
US. fcreiEn zsserarents would BE- fus
ttat ia laterfsf.cg Z 'af the preserv alton
af .ae sNizfirg government and Per the
praferfnn ~ fereona aud property
rztfs ire nifFi states shnr Z cot
e. aer iftei o. srt fta ins "A fhe nan
sna p We sfii az Interfere - gise
tas hsssHsn .sisnas god aatsru
errf ca ur fert tite AmeTlrsa fnterssta
tarrs. 81 sset sl est ant q fae ssy ald
isaVs fte iafeh sect prerle q TIE 4.
tfoEts o. fnfy sewhrFs Tor Frotecfsua
Pc Haee sense reuit Justify the
u aite'i states 'u s~@eriing tetfsr right
- tne srnrFstaen af the s'4ats ~ - a
rrofssfnfafe over fhen tban am other
tireiEn sDsefnssesl hss. and even ~ n
tertering ee p~Tsr acessioa . give
tae isitnfis 4Qrsi saF-Tnuent
I~,tph So Fat wnh srsv
NJ srsy Ecss the senator frem
Oregon infsr t1st tha rres-nt Saferu
seDi Hsssif = repnuiirr
~ hpigh Be erues - aerlr tetnr
r-rHel'c ~ anFsaffr e,se
Hf ti~aq Hr