The evening world., 1893-11-28
CASE CLOSED.
Expert CaryaIho Winds Up the
Testimony.
,ounssI VIII Hand in Briefs Within
Ten Days.
ssd Ten Days Aftsrward' They
WIZ sabnit the Case.

The trial ii the Bates against Bates
"a ait before Judge Freedman IN the
N peciaI Term Of The Superior Court was
h n over except for some ODDS and ends
an expert testimony ar 20 the handwrit
3tR Of Charles y Bates. yet there was
, diininution If the crowd Of people
tho sought admission 10 the court
u hamber this morning.
n CONTRARY TO announcement II was after
O'Clock when the trial was resumed
"a lt 100 men had stood up IN the rear VI
I've courtroom for an hour without com
tanning.
II Mana was very fetching. indeed, in a
u E,e. the 6fth Costume Of the series Of
a .Expert carysiho. who boasts "a record
chBrography, WAS recalled 10 the
II and after cross-e1amination. and Tx
1T Daniel T.. Ames. who goes CarYalhy
sree years better. and who is Invariably
n Ited against the younger man in court
f, sntests, watched and listened during
n, 9e croEs-examination.
n Or. Caryalho testified that in the ex-
~ bsnatton Of questioned writings he first
I: soked for internal evidence Of simula-
pm
1hs original Or alleged marriage con
n! 2 ~ Charlie Bates in court yesterday
\. .Mr. caryalho was made to admit tina,
q IhdE0thFI n I'A BlNtt any
~ md: that the spacing was one Of these
Ioaracterfstics. and that IN No. 20 the
rscing was much wider than IN No. 4.
Size expert, Mr.. Peckham asked him II
VI g Ink used in the word ".wife'' was not
4 different shade Of ink 10 that used
IL the last five words OF the letter.
.I tIt IL not promptly replied Mr.. Car
~ Tho. ut does not require an Expert
IA determine that the same color Of ink
fss used. there being only IA different
anfitY OF color I'm wife"
Ntt.,Is II the same color as other words
~ the pager" asked Mr.. Peckham.
ID sDo you mean 10 tell us that the color
n n.wife' is the same as In darling
4, ,RNo. sir; / mean 10 tell you that IL II
" same as In other words on the
no per: for instance. II is the same as In
words that she was a in the bot
n n line. The line above is a shade
tn yfker. There IL M difference In tn"
Y :, ode OF the color Of the words Of the
= Ttter."
How DO you accoun; for the different
III can only surmise that a copying
n ID was used. md that In blOtiing IT
= q greater quantity was left in one
ace than ir another.
X i',If the word wife were written after
OF the other words on the sheet and
in Immediately blotted, that would ac.
{ INT for the different appearance. would
not. supposing .tnat the writer wrote
d, whole page before 1t was blotte1
Iii THAT would be one way to account
III, I, ~" replied Mr.. Carvalho.
stt1Bhow me another H. in the whole
ne, nat Is a1'!sd >? .ihiSe w. d as ' r.
"a The expert looked. but found none.
ne en- he assented TO Mr.. prckham,s
81 ( ,position that his experiences taught
Ill that the forger. always. tried TO
Axe a very close Imitation OF IN" hand
z 1 .tvAs sought to forge. and that experts
IA IRE always very positive IN their de-
" Jons. even when one decided In Il man
~ Y Numerically opposite 10 the other.
III 20 hat there was no other "f' In the
II life." which Bates says II "A forgery.
4 ain another letter, however, th"r" were
Yerai dots Ike The y %9s oysr thG 1is y
lhe dots oyer the 81" IN wife 10 those
III. ar the as" In several letters was con
III lied by Mr.. carvalho.
vi Hded that little iiancce" w0s 40 dis
ALTAR 20 the rest Of the letter az I?
az iract tn; attention OF even a casual
q ierver. but Mr.. cBryalhO said mo.
ri they are quite characteristic"
rust at the close OF the cross-enamina
n Mr., q. Bates entered and stubbsd
", with its tails hitching upon his
dis at every step. There was "a silk
a, too. with, a mourning weed. ana a
u v pair OF Kids TO match the Outfit.
pthat everybody was prepared to zee
y irite Batss's long frock coat Of black
III | ~ NV NV nay vi ~ u
q, In redirect examination. Mr.. Csrvalho
Ill. t,oursed on the undisputed portions Of
letters, and illustrated the eccen-
1ities OF the youth in writing, saying:
drhese things show that Mr.. Bates In
~ errntic In his habits In writing.
GAS no rule for dotting rs and cross,
III his rs; and In spacing, except that
f, .1always leaves a wide space for a
III fital letter. both before and after It.
VI The dots on the IS all differ az to
y l 'ition, angle. shape, form. size. i'm
.Is Fsiop and character" said the cx-
it:s .barIie Bates patted his ~haIf.open
! FIX. and smiled comfortably while
lI 90. who has been at high tension
ing the trial. dashed hystrrical tears
I A. handkerchief. for the slow move
,a.t lat OF expert testimony. dry, and prob
IN y TO her useless. was aggrnvntlng.
.lr TIr, Peckham borrowed the experts
vi ,ss and screwed II into hig eye for IN"
pose OF scrntinizing Il word In one OF
I'd H.. raising his spectaclcs upon his
Judge looked gfavewise, but 1t IL
Jars "a. doughnutH that neither Of
X en could see n thing through III. little
nta percha barrel.
.N n, Horwitz offered a copy Ot an
MI lifaYed reproduction Of the alleged
: Ees made by Bates yesterday, and
. The surprise OF everybody It VAS an
I'll ,nced that the testimony was all In.
III 9dge Freedman said he didn't care to
cr summing up speeches, but was re-
.tfs Ned to his fate II they insisted. The
.H yers finally agreed to exchange briefs
4 hin ten days and to submit the case
HI AIN ten days after that. and the
HI -yd went away with signs OF dlsap-
fiiS 4tment.
Sae only person connected with the
tHh 80 who was not satisfied with the con
ts!n Zion OF the trial was Norlander, the
tth Fdish journalist, whom Lawyer HOr-
tTh b; wanted to cross-eXamine yesterday.
Xxx poor fellow was fearful. his voice
kV m choked as he said:
have been insulted In the news,
s4H mile he was sobbing. Mr.. HorwitZ's
aH ~ was showing IA letter with which
MA ~ proposed TO impeach the character
abe swede, II was as follows:
bHt XII. Dec. I. 1892.
rles W, Gardner. esq.
TIN flear Sir: VIII YOU pay 500 II | go as
illness In your case and testify tina
hus lie Clifton Tor Mrs. Katherine Amos,
ttlh Tlped the money on the street. sc.
tif OF course l was present, so l know
40, let m know II at once. Your.
, ectfully.
CARL o. F. NORLANDER,
kNt "226 East Thirty-second street"
LINN That was my address and my name