New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1893-06-17

about not giyng IN A-No' ''i'
Odd YOU GO there that morning before !oa Went
,,ysy, q morning before the hearing began. Yes,
o.-Now, when you went out did I say to you "ha'e
YOU told her all r. and yoa said. "E'c'y'hhs A.
No. sir. you dill not ,,
C.-Either that morning or any o'ic' '"''""e' "
40. sir.
CEoss.EXAMINATIoY HELPS THE DEFENCE
This ended the direct examination. 1t was disap-
roln,lng Tho witness coed witness, she
bad aided her sisters cause so effectively, that 1t
way rather annoying that greater opportunity mu
not bccn afforded to her. 1t fcIi that Mr. Jcil-
ming, hal done Justice neither to himself nor to the
witness Eut the opportunity los, In the direct cN-
animation made up. and was improved when DIS
trict- Attorney Knowlt0n took her in hand. lie ala
not intend TO give her the chance 10 improve her
testimony TO render It stronger In the affirmative aid
II gave 10 the defence. or dc sir,ctlvc OF the
witnesses foT the prosecution. lie did his best to
prevent these results but the longer he continued the
examination and The more questions he asked, the
worse IL FOR the state and the letter Tor IlzHic
Borden ZONE minutes occupi d in feeling
around the subject, In nquiTlng about her friends
and relations. Then hr addressed himself to The con
dton OF affairs in the Borden household to Lizzie
and her stcpmother. lie asked If Mrs. Borden had
relatives in Fall River. Emma said she had IA half
sister.
GLOW did your s:cprnothcrs sister into pos
session OF the property she occupied Any father pur
,hast d IL and gave 1t to her.
c.-Wes that tran acton agreeable TO yourself ana
Lizzie, A.-No, at all.
Odd you ind faul: with III Ayes sir, did
c'-O'd Lizzie ma i1"'' VIZ" w " '"s ~''' "'''
!t as much a. did.
Q.-That Isn't What asked you. A-Shc found iaul.
with IL.
o-And in consequence of the faut.andIns DID, your
father give yoa money! Ale gave us some
property tina. tme bu, 1t not In consequence
0; TIE fault.nndng.
Q-What property did nc give you'll A.-our gra''u'
.athcrs house.
o-Eut did not you and Lizzie complain that Thu
was not an cqniyalcnti Ave did not.
o-Suge about that Alvey sure.
o-!Iayea't you said that the properly given You was
not a, rcmuncravc in the way properly
given t, you s;epn.ohcrs haIfs..terl A.-No. sir.
Q-,urc sbou: tha, Al couldn't have said 90
for it Isn't true. The reverse il true.
c.-iIa'ft Lizzie said ~ A-No, sir, no; that
EnoW %. l"A%l' haa 10 graz iec'"S III V'- "a'V-''
any how. -
lilo" 'o"s a. WIS '
O. Were the relations cordial bctwecn Lizzie AMI
,o,r .,,.,,o..c- since ths. ,lucl Ayes, air.
q rrt.rIv co,dall Al should say vry cord al.
o nd no, Ii,sc case to call her mothc." a, abou.
h. finn, sh. I'D u.c 10 call her rother" once DIDN'T
-. 10
and sued,.Iy sho s.opnca,
"oVhENoI' ROBINSON iNTf'foSiS'
:Ir.
O''r"' 'o',','' ''''P W., 'r -"
80, 80 - 49, 80 , a., ,. ,,,,.
II NIGH, confuse The Witness ard 1t might possibly
confuse the s;onoTrnphc-. Ills learned brother Oil
have that habit ana oppressed lis regrets tlht he
hAd gwen "''s''" III 'A' "o'''"0' " '' ''
attention 10 H.
q She dll s,op calling her mother DID she no:
,-yc. ..r
o-sudec,lv, Al think not su denly
o-W..,'t Il nj taat ,lr,ol Al don't know. l
can't IA The time
Q-Do you recall! the fact TIN: you testified with
gard 10 til- mater once bcfocl Al have toriilct
several tno,. don't rc,an c,c, particular matter.
o-Iiaven't yog 'ad the: II was about the 'ir' q
Ia im"'a o' that L'''c crao" 10 ''' MT h''1''
II So' u'i - ~ VIZ - "'''
''nN t,ois" 20 so 80 49,. ,
e-Du" you say SUI a. ~" "''"
Mr. knoNlto1 read from The minutes OF ne
Co7oners inquest ana tAey haae "pl'ir "'' '''
h1u haa" We statement 'a'' ~ "'',''"'u ~ NV
Il III You answer uup IL i'lu'''''
Al u.'d to. ,..... ,,..,.
ID yo' '''h Siy 'at 'ne '',''Vns p'"'' '-,
ani N'. fei.on were 'o'-i'' ",-i"' WV 'o-'''
a"i ioI '"' law Wv ''''' - ATT, .
V'-.of 30" may ''"' 80 ~ ~, NV "
con -! NH' 80 w. ~. W. " " 80
G'-n'''' D." -. 'o' , -. ,,,
y" S'u nav Ni'' 30 " - - -. - -,
gym ~ avn l''' -" - ,.,,a, ,, 40
a'd u''t' was h''"''"' - - va 49,,
dsd fo' care h''h 'po~' TIC "'''' "'- ~ 's' ~
" - ''
Mr. kuowlfon concluded TO abandon this Inc OF
examination but ne struck antt.lc: almost amuSneiy
-,
n,-,,,,y 49, -, e,n,n,.,oor,
a NJ. IN ur and ur. nor,cn,.i Ayes sir
q Didn't YOU u.c tn o-e,py tina, rooui A-Ycs.
QAni he occupied the onc yu have now dlln't she
A-Ycs SIR
NJ" ',". s'-' '...'.,, ,.' ~ ~
- -, g., ,,1, ,,.' no., , ,,I,t
- RI, -. 1t. ., t,.,,... ,.o,.., O. 4, mt
u thi' meant anything IL W''n' "'' h"''' H''
Monc" Elihh I" tll' III" ahihr anu ''N '"h'
vrn!cHt room In order that she llh@i') mirht got
where IN" ""ud nave ID" 'pi'r'"i'y "i uoi's h"THi
80.
40, sir she replied " II m.dc III my
,ucgo. ION. | thought that Lizzie might lko To have