The morning call. [volume] (San Francisco [Calif.]) 1878-1895, 1892-08-23
MURDERED MARY CARROLL.
Her Mother Is in the City. and
Will Testify at the Inquest.
Mrs. Nellie Haven has Something More q
ssy-"Dr." Baals Says if She Is His Wife,
Why Does She Not Keep ouisti

malpT6EllSb 1T 4pt 0UlQCiI N"bO a. NA4 ~ ~N'A'S
two weeks ago, arrived in this city yester-
day morning.
Mrs. Carroll has been divorced from her
husband for several wears and has been re-
ceiyipg an alimony OF 500 per month from
him. If all reports are true the mother viii
take the witness stand at the resumption OF
the Coroner's inquest on Thursday next and
will tell startling story.
II has BEEN the belief OF the doctors ever
since the discovery Of young Mary Car
rolls death that the cousin OF the girl,
James McKenna, SaloOn-keeper In viii
lage near Petaluma, was the one who was
to blame for the young woman's condition,
simply because il was almost certainty
that he was the one who took her to 'Dr.
Haven Beale, and who called to see her Oh
The Monday she died at 4O4 Golden Gate
avenue, DIR" Beale-Haven's branch office.
This theory may prove Incorrect. 1T is
more than probable now that James NC
Kenna was acting for some one else. VINO
was the party guilty OF the betrayal OIL tne
girl. and. for rea Ons best known 10 himself,
McKenna agreed TO fud man who would
help the woman out of her trouble. lhlS ne
tried TO do, but the result OF "Dr. Beale-
Ravens treatment was the death OF the
young woman.
The case as it now stands. so say the po
lice. is a strong one against "Dr." Beaie
Haven. and # Mckenna IS identified as the
man who brought her TO the doctors once
is equally strong against him, unless he can
offer some EXPLANATION for his extraordinary
interest in tie deceased girl The father of
tile girl has expressed himself as con-
WINGED of Mchenna's guilt. but he expressed
GREAT anxiety to lave Mchenna saved from
punishment. and Or" Beae-HaYen, bis
alleged accOmplice, convicted.
The mothers story. ii IL is ever told, VIII
h,f q SI19rah.P light the
whole affair W to the time Of Mary Carroll
falling into Or" Beale- Ravens hands.
Just how much Detective Rogers knows
about the mothers Whereabouts and the
story she will tell is impossible TO ind out,
but that he knows some thing of il is certain.
Mrs. Carroll, the mother, is said to abe
deeply affected over the murder of her
daughter and she has come here TO aid in
bringing the parties guilty OF the crime 10
justice.
MRS. HAVEN TALKS.
Mrs. Nellie Haven was much quieter
yesterday tnan when arrested on Sunday
night ana was entirely free from all traces
of liquor. While the woman has been
drinking considerably for the past two
months, any statement that she ia or has
been On the verge Of delirium tremens is
the veTiest b0sh. Worry, Jealousy OF
Hattie Graham, and anxiety for her hus-
band, "Dl." Hunter, alias Beale, alias
Haven, all combined to make the woman
nervous and she resoTted to drink TO fnd
relief
Mrs. MeCue, the landlady at 22S Post
street, speaks of Mrs. Nellie Haven in
terms Of highest praise. She denies en-
phatieally that the woman is drunkard
and says that during the two years she has
been in the house with DR." Haven the
wife WAS always quiet. ladylIke and seldom
went cut alone. She knew that Mrs. Dr.
Haven was 10 trouble and suspected
jealousy as the cause, but gives the Doctors
wife through ali her trouble a good char
acler.
When seen yesterday Mrs Nellie Haven
reiterated The truth Of the statement given
BY The CALL except as to one or two
minor particulars IN which, owing TO her
hySttrical condition at the time Of the in
teryiew. she was probably nisunders God.
DIR Haven cannot put this thing on my
shoulders" she said, nor shall lie blacken
ny character aud destroy my good name.
When he says he did not know Mary Car
roll as Mary Carroll he tells an nutruth.
Mary Carroll and man she called Jim
came % Dr. Ravens Office on that Friday
and l received them. The woman / turned
over to Dr. Haven and be knew her. He
kept her in the back Office some time and
then the man who came with her went away
and 'Dr. Haven took Mary Carroll to 404
Golden Gate avenue.
HER PRACTICE
Now as TO my practice as Mrs. DR. II.
Haven. / am beginning to see all this now,
and am going 10 tell the truth. am inno-
cent of wrong, and Dr. Haven knows Il.
All / ever aid for him WAS 10 sell some med
iclnes he had prepared TO customers and to
receive patients, who were turned over by
me 10 him. Why, when women would come
into the Office and inquire for Mrs. DR..
Haven Dr. Haven would take them In
hand. tell them ! was out for q time and
treat them himself
Il will 20 on the witness-stand Thursday
and tell the truth, let the consequences be
what they may"
Lizzie or Hattie Graham, when told of
Mrs. DR.. Ravens arrest, manifested no sur
prise. Miss Grahamis a remarkably shrewd
young lady, and is beyond question infatu-
sted with 'Dr." Beale. She admitted yes
teTday that she intended going away with
'DT." Beale or Haven without any promise
of marriage, but added that was her own
business. Evidently she proposes to tell
only as much of the truth as she is CON-
PEELED to. One fact which tells strongly
against "Dr" Beale- Haven's story about
Mary Carroll Is Miss Graham's statement
regarding the condition of Miss Carroll on
the Sunday when "Dr." Beale asserts she
went to mass.
SAW MARY CARROLL ONCE.
II only visited Mary Carroll in her room
once, said Mss Graham, land that was on
Sunday afternoon, shortly after dinner,
when took her glass of water. AT that
u,
she had been in bed all day. She was quite
ill.,"
Detective Rogers believes that Miss
Graham did see Mary Carroll constantly.
and while she did not know the nature OF
the woman's Illness, perhaps, there can be
hardly any question but that she helped
'Dr. Besle remove the tell-tale linen from
the bed and arrange the corpse as it was
found.
After admitting that she was going tc
live with DR." Beale-Haven without the
formality OF marriage ceremony Miss
Graham stoutly denies that she and DIR"
beaIe- Haven ever sustained other relations
toward each other than that of friends.
Upon "DT." Beale- Haven Harvey
Hunter. etc. the news of his wife's arrest
fell with the heaviest weight. The doctor
is vlsibly weakening and is certainly very
apprehensiye as 20 the future. When inter.
Viewed yesterday he refused to deny thai
Nellie Haven was his wife or that he mar
ried her under the name of Hunter. All be
would say was:
wHY DOES SHE NoT?"
IF she is my wife why don't she keep be,
mouth shut?"
de insists that his true name Is Harvey
and that ne has no money, but Mrs. Haven
says he has money and plenty of il. DR.
beaie- haven admitted In way that il was
under his instructions ticket for the East
mao Deen purchased for his wife, and added
petulantly:
why didn't she go East?"
wei, she said she proposed to STAY and
see the trouble through was the answer.
II hope she will see the trouble throneh
hope she will be locked up for month o,
Two; u Will do her good. She will ger
when told his wife was sober the docto,
INSISTED she was not, and then gave DR.
Gallagher Of Sacramento a turning over In,
coming here and getting drunk while try
Ing TO help him escape
AN ATTORNEYS VISIT.
Last right an attorney called to see Mrs
Nellie Haven. and secured from her q,
order for $50 to be taken out of the 500
Captain Lees now holds in trust for m,
woman, and for this $50 he was to appea,
only at the inquest