New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1892-03-25
| STRUGGLE OVER SILVER.
Csu,inucd from First Page.

cali his name When the Clerk called VT. CriAP' VI
Georgia. availng himself OF his rights rs Il hcP
esoniovo he cat his vote in the negative. anna the
deafenny applause of the advocates q! the measure,
Mr. Bland not aware that Ms vote -Neu mo
measure from Immediate anuih a'icn changed MS
vote from the negative the Affirmative In order That
he might have opportunity 10 move recohsi"ei''
lion bul being advised in n moment that the mouoh
wa, defeated by tie vote. again changed TO 'ne
negative. $500,
The sneaker refused TO permit Mcssrs. Enloc ana
Herbert 10 have their names recofdeu III 'ho 'o''
they not having been present.
THE VOTE On MR. BURROWS MOTION.
Tn. motion was lost by tie vote Of yeas 1i5, rays
lbs, as follows: ,.o,
ycas-Mes,rs Amerman. Andrew. Atkinson Bacoh'
Barwig Belden. Behnap, Beltthoover' Den"ey bcrsun
bingham Boutec. Bowman, Bfawhy, BnckheG' prosiue
Brunner buchanan ~. j.. Bunting. Burrows Busnn'
Cable Cadmus. Caldwell. Castle. Causey, Chapin' mp
man. Clancy Cobb (Mo.) Coturn, Cochran, Coe'"ei'
Coolidge Coombs. Covert, Cox (N W Craig tfehn,l
Cr,.ny. Cummings Curtis Cutting. Dire'i
Dancll De Forest Dingley. Doan' DoahVer'
nunphv English Fellows Fitch, Flick. Geay Heisseh'
boinar Gillespie Greeneaf Grswod. Grout. Hail. Hal
lowell Hamilton, Hammer, Harter, llaughen my
Iowa. Haynes (Ohio) Henderson iowa Ht'' h"r'
Hooker (New.York). Hopkins (Penn-)' Hopkins ',"1'
Iiouk (Tcnn.) Iun Hull, johnson (ihd'J JUN
son North DakotaI, Ketcham. hnoo'' hs'
Lapham Lind Little Lockwood. Lodge, Loud LIheh'
Wagner McAlccr Mcdonald. McCiann. Mekais' Mch emma
Mckinney Meycs Miller. Mnliken, Mitchell, Mu'cnle,'
Ncwbcrrv o'Douncu O'Nen (Ma's), O'Neii (Penh''.
Cultivate Page (R. IL. Page CMd) Pat'oh Wno''
Payne Perkins Post Powers, 0usckcnbush' hAhe7' "'
dali Ray Ravner Reed. Reyburn. Rife. Robinson 'feu'''
Russell SculI Seerley Smith. Sperry, Stephenson a's
ems C. w Stone Storer Stout stump. TAYLOR lls'J D. ~
Taylor Tucey, Walker. Warner Waugh weaver "heo'
(Mch), Wilcox, Williams (Mass.l wilson th'1' "
tWasl.), Wilson (W. Val, WoINsrt0n, "flShV-ifo'
Nays-Mcssrs Abbott, Anderson. Alexander AIe"'
Arnold Rabbit, Bailey. Baker Bankhead, bafu"e, De-
man. Blanchard, Bland Blount Bowers brancn' h'en
inrdce (Ark) RIeckinridgc (kyJ, Betz broderich'
glookshirc Bryan, buchanan lVah Bullock. Bunh'
Buscy Butler Bynum. ByInes Camlnetti' C"p'h'f'
Caruth Cate Clark tWyOl, Clarke tAla), Cooo tN'J'
Cowles Cox Tenn. Grain (1cN1, Crawford Culbers"h'
Davis Dcalmond Dckerson, DIXON Dockcry DUNCAN
Ednunds EMS Ep,s Everett, fithian, Fofncy, fo"icf
Funston Evan Can't, Goodnight. GorHan, "iidy Hal
yor,on Hare Harrics Hatch Heard, I'mph Hchuc'9""
-. Co. Hermann Holman, Houk (OhioJ johnson tohi'J
Jolcy KEN. Kcor'. Kyle, Lane. Lanham' La"'on l'''
Lawson tulJ. Layton, Lester GA. Lewis LNlns''on
Long Mallory M1nsur. Martin. Mcclellan. Mctrary.
McKcighan, McMlln, Mc;ac, Meredith. Mis- Mont
aomcry. Moore, Noes Motion. 0Fer'1l o Nell MO-,
OTIS owens Parrct Patterson Tenn. Patton PI'h'ef
Pearson Pcndlcion plckler Pierce Pflcc. Reilly Rich
.rd,on Robertson G.a. Rockwell Sayer, Scott. shiNey
simpson snodersks SNOW. StIrkhouse. Stewart (lll'
stewart Cc\.), Stockdalc. stone tkyj' SWEET ' \.
Taylor. Teiry. ThIu. To"n.cni, Iuche.' Turner Iu'-
pin. Warwick Washington, Watson. Wcal"ck "her''I
tAial White whiting williams q. c.. Williams tilLl'
Wilson Mo-, VIM " 90 Youmins and the Spcaker-iis
Nh Cultivate. Of Ohio. AZ once moved 10 adjourn
Mr. Bland arising 10 parliamentary Inquiry
asked II the effect Of an adjournment would he TO
make another special order necessary to call UP ic
Till.
The SPEAKER sad IL would.
The vote on adjournment was In no sense party
ne or one indicating which side Of the silver 1u''
lion the voters stood Many Of the most pronounced
an'isverites voted in opposition aud the motion wa~
declared lost by a vote ~ yeas 80 nays. 1913
Mr. Johnson. 81 ohio. moved 10 reconsider the vote
by which the House refused TO tibe The bin. and Mr.
Bland PARKED with "a motion 10 lay that motion ~
the table
Mr. Ercckinrldec. Of Kentucky. moved recess TN
10 O'Clock tomorrow morning. but withdrew H.
Tnf MOTION TO ELCoN>IDFE LOST
The question then REQUIRED on the motion to table
the motion to reconsider. and II was reeccd-yeas i4a
nays 40.
Then it was the turn Of the anti silver TO ap-
plaud and they did with vim aud enthusiasm.
The speaker stated that the vote REQUIRED on the
motion 10 reconsider md Mr. Reed OF Maine, sprang
to HI, feet and demanded the yeas and nays.
Mr. Bland. discouraged at the last vote, moved an
Adjournment but his motion being received with erie
oi No hbusterins.' he Withdrew 1t aud the roll was
called the motion to reconsider
SCENE or WILD CONFUSION.
Then the thu dcisicm which had been broodlne
over The House for the entire day burst in full violence
and for twenty minute or more II ragged through The
House Before the announcement ~ thc vote the
space In front Of the Speakers desk ci6ae with
a jostlng mass Of members desirou, Of knowing how
they were recorded upon the bill
The speaker (witaOut ordering rccapulationl an
nounccd that the motion to reconsider was defeated
by a tie vote Of. yeas li7. nays l47.
scarcely had the word, passed hi, lips when Ncs,rS.
Cochran. Fitch Tracy and Mutchcr were ON their
feet calling halt. Mr Cochran had the most p'wcrfh
voice and amid the confusion he WA. heard to declare
that the vote hid not been recapitulaed ard 10 dc
mand u recapitalation.
The speaker stated that the demand came too late.
Mr. O'Ncu Of Massachusetts. In an excited manner,
exclaimed that 1t not too late TO correct an
error lie had kept tally aud he knew that an error
had been made.
The spcahcr-If any gentleman had asked for The
rccaptuation before the announcement the Chair
would have ordered II. Aftcr the announcement the
Chair would not order II.
Mc,sr,. Cochran. Fitch and O'Hcn vainy endeavored
to make their voices heard The speaker cool
and collected but showing In his countenance symp-
toms anger and impotence. was welding his gavel
and calling upon the sereeantat Arms to maintain
order, the silver men were shouting for tho regular
order7 ard the antsver men were urging Messrs.
Cochran a,d Fitch forward to the fray. There wa
no I.mblancc Of order decorum preserved.
THE sEEGEANT-AT-ARMs oUELLs DISORDER.
Mr.. Fitch finally raised MS NOicc hDoNc INC tuinhl'
and expressed his desire to PROFOUND parliamentary
inouiry but before the inquiry could he heard the
speaker compelled TO call In the services OF the
sergeant at Arms to conduct the excited members To
heir seats.
Then Mr.. Fitch said that he would like 10 ask the
Chair whether IL not IN order 10 ask for re.
capulaiiyn OF the vote. II the thar decided this
IN the negative, he would like 10 ask the Chair under
what rule lie 50 decided
The Chair responded that there was no rule OF the
House requiring a rccapitulaOn to DC made.
Mr.. Cochran inquired whether on the first vote
today speaker had not Of his own motion ordered
rccapituation II that were true, was IL not fair
that members Of the House sholld have right 10
demand a rccaptulation' lie asked Of the Chair II
there was any method known to parliamentary law by
which the vote could be challenged when II had been
announced before members had all opportunity to
demand recapitulatlDn.
The Speaker responded with some warmth that II
was not n parliamentary question: and In this case II
va, not the fact. The gentleman from New York had