New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1892-01-21
CoURI OF APPEALS DECISIONS.
MANY HANDED DOWN BY EACH DIyIsIoN-cALEN-
OARS FOR TO-DAY.


MANY HANDED DOWN BY EACH DIvIsIoN-cALEN-
OARS FOR TO-DAY.
Albany, JAN Coin the First Division of the Court
of Appeals today the following decisions were hahdeu
down: ,..,
Charles r. johnson, appellant aSt. the Union switch
and signal Company, respondent, ki'oSd M.t.ii '
respondent, aet the fhenX insurance 'o.Panh
apir1lant; Henry Messenger, respondent, AT. tic
IaI,hattan Railway Company, Appellant SieNtialu A.
FISHER ct al appellant agt. May G. D. Fisher " ILL.,
RESPONDENT Sas l.. GlnJ, appellant aSl' -Ndrc" u
(,en and others, pOidens tredeiloA boos g d.
respondents agt Maiear y. Marion ara olhers' up
isLants; teoIGe T.. bacon, respondent, aSt the New
ilome sewing Macnine Company, Appellant Caiieflne
Heating, respondent, agt JACOB Huehtner' appeio,
EdwarG McSorter, respondent, ast Bran o. iuShs ct
al inpleaded, appellants Jonn . Leavitt ,espouen,,
agt. Lewis Chase appellant tne heoiait E'hv
Rank OF Hinghanton, respondent, agt Seilh hnpS
Fl al, appellants Isaac honinle, reeve rppeil1
agt Micnael Chnuncey ct al respondents Wil.am +
Walton ct al respondents, agt. Albert T. stewart
trustee appellant lewis clSe' apIciian ,een, at
t. Kellogg, respondent, Lizzie hoeleF' respondent, ast
The Manhattan Railroad Company, appellant C"h
Woodwoih respondent ast; Thomas T., oa Van
ll appellants Ilaudle Ii. " ED aPpeiah'' 'e'i an
Wtck Hewlett respondent; Ellen VI. Vunn appellant
at Margaret Mcdonald 81 al, resPoldehs We snie
APPELLANT, age. Annie McDOhald eI d. respondents ;
Alice HOLLAND, appellant, asl the Mayor Oi new orn
respondent; >is.emuhd Opp-nhtimef' Iespohuee az.
lIe Metropolitan EcNa'tu i'di"aS co.npa"'
Charles ii. OTIS, appellant, aGt Andrew l. bertlon
and others, respondents John b. Mcoheiry, iespoluc'
An the Trustees Of lhe Village OF Canandlgui, ap
pellapts: Michael Shcehan. respondent, Az: LizAo
MAYER appellant: Evelne H. liOlnn, agt W. Jennings
WiiIam F. Lehman and others, appellants uwO casesl
rrrd~rlck A. schroeder and others, respondents, as'
iGe .c, Of tlo COgr, eatlona Church, etc
samuel :. Hart. appellant. act. james > Wider re-
spondent: William Nelson, Jr, appellant, ar. tho
Navcr of New-lOrk respondent. Hiram Gilmore ap
pellant agt the city Of Utica, respondent Judgments
Thn PEOPLE. respondents agt. James f. Mnnaugl
appellant. Judgment affirmed ~ VII, ch,oa,o
and St. Louis Railroad Company, appellant the same
agl ,he Fitchburg Railroad Company. Judsment " VI
General Term reversed ana !uu;hrn itb ot '
tbe cu :
kebecca NJ. F. Quackenbusn ag Maize . mar anu
~, cbares r. NacLean and Others Commissioners,
efc: the Manufacturers National bahh az. D"u.oS
lin and anoibcr: Ruana Clark Administrative, ETC.
Art susau NJ COrwin and another. eXecutrlA .etc aP
Ieilams IL People eX rel the american Enr'rd
Ing and Dredging COMPANY apRT Imad S srt cots
Ese Koher and another ast J9 Mn,4an mei te
implicated. ETC. appellant ;ohm j. .,i,aS comDanv
Appellant: JO-iah }. White asL George Moo1 au al
and another appellant Charles a. Broa at, II11,
oriSl X Ringer, impleadcd ETC. appellant fTiu,'
K Kceler agt Tic Metropolitan Elevated IA ~HE
COMPANY and another appellants: Michac j. fiii"h n
agt The Delaware, Lackawanna and western Ii ~
Company appellant Robert Crossdale agi: Danni
Ianiran. app liant: Nathan Bohm ast the MetiQP(-
tan Elevated hallway COMPANY apPeiis;n. 49,. s.l
s sPancd AGO Cost, t"f to '' abide the event
The people OK rel the Brush Electric illuminate III
Comnony app,lant agt. Edward Wempe, Controller:
Idnnt 81 The G;eneTal Term determination OF
lie Controller reversed. and Controller directed 10 re
settle the account aud TO credit the reiaor IN tne u
count the amount OF tax and penalties paid, WIN III
terest RON the date of the payments, and costs in all
Tb pcope eX rel the Edison Electric Illuminating
Company Of New York, appellant and respondent Igt
FGward Wenplc Controller, respondent and appellant
Judgment of the General Term and the determination
Of the Controller reversed on reiators appeal in,
Conro Ter directed rescttc the account and credit
10 rcIator the amount OF the tax and penalties paid
With costs in all courts , .,,, -. A..
In le application Of Mary walker Tor relief, etc Ap
peal dismissed with costs. $40
PCT The New York Lake Erie and Western Railroad
ComnanV appellant. aGt. the Atlantic Refining Com
nonv' order Of the General Term reversed. and judg
ment entered on verdict affirmed, with costs
Thomas b. Guilford agt the Mayor OF New York. ap
% abide the event CON an!noIy % dTiWer as'' tnS
The Mutual Life Insurance Company Of New;Iork
and Judgment absolute ordered against the plaintiff on
~ WiiIam Sicon appellant agt Charles g. Sands
and others Judgment dismissng complaint affirmed
Warren Bryant and others appellants, agt. Harriet
F. r. Thompson. implicated respondent. MOTION ioi
reargument denied. with $40 costs. ...
Winfield H. Bosscut agt the Rome Waterfowl town and
Ogdensburg Railroad Company appellant Motion u
dismiss granted with costs
The following decisions were handed down In the
Second Division:
Erastus II. Barnes agt. Walter r. Denslow, ap
reliant sylvester Trimmer, appellant agt. the City OF
Rochester Russell W Ostrander, appellant, agt JOSEPH
Hart executor and trustee. Traders National Bank OF
Mary Cnlross, appellant agt Arthur l. Gibbons anl
Others, implicated appellants: Van Allen Pugsley arc
others agt. JOnn DeNnh, alpciihii' "oSefn
appellant. agt. William Moir. James F. Mason and
Others agt George Y smith. and Others; npPei;'',s
PHILIP GOcrlitz. appellant. agt. Charles Malawisa anc
Others: Francis DOugherty and others agt. Henry !
McCiuiken, appellant. Richard Hggott ae Lyman
Uanchett. appellant: Jacob Kent agt. Jacob Grouse
appellant: Emory J. Bishop agt the Agricultural In
snrance Company OF WATERFOWL, appellant judgment
affirmed, with costs. . -
Johann Reichel agt. the NewYork Central and
Hudson River Railroad, appellant Hedwig BlaechlIsN
agt. the Howard Mission, etc, appellant Juugheh
reversed and trial granted. costs to abide The
event
Oliver W. Barnes, appellant. agt. Jesse Selgman am
another executors etc. respondents and George ii
brown, appellant Judgment In favor OF defendants
seligman, executors. otc, modified, affirmed VIII
costs: and the order reversing tie judgment an
granting q new trial against the defendant Brown ~