davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The state chronicle. [volume] (Raleigh, N.C.) 1891-1893, 1892-12-23
BUNGLE FROM BEGINNING
SCIENCE
Is What DR.. NcGtn said About the
Execution of Haliinger AT Jersey
City Yesterday.

JERSEY CITY, N j, Dec. 22-Ed
ward Millington Hallinger, the colored
ex preacher and ex pugilst who mur
dered his paramour. May Paterson, in
jersey City, April 5, 1891, and was ,heIe
for four times sentenced to death, was
hanged in the Hudson county Jail this
forenoon. The drop fell at 10 :O5 o'clock
The knot slipped On the Condemned
mans neck and death resulted from
strangulation. Even after Halinger's
body had been lowered to the fl por OF
the corridor it was question whether
or not life WAS gone bes ond he posi-
hiiity Of resusfication. Dr.. McGill was
heard to say after his examination of thr
body that in his opIn' on ii ,llipger could
have been brought back 70 hte by I'm
ployi1g some of the methods known to
cience. Dr. McGll said: The exc
cltion was an Outrage on modern science
and a hungle from beginning to end"
AT exactly 1906 o'clock Hanemln
VanHise gave q sharp tug at the line d
Hallinger's body shot up into the air on
level with the gallery Iulning along
the north SIDE of the corridor Then it
| dropped back nearly three feet and
Strengthened out Il WAS seen at ohce
| that the moose had not been properly al
| jus'ed The knot had slipped from un
under Hallinger', right ear around under
the angie of his jaw The great shoulders
heaved spa modlrally and the air whis
tied and gurgled from between the
negro's lips The noise Of his labored
breathing could be heard the whole
length of the rr6or ard mary Of the
witnesses turned away with paliid faces
and express Ons OF diss sitisfactlOn with The
| buugling manner in which the execution
was being conducted.
Two minutes after the body had left
the fl 'or Drs. McGiil Chambert aud
Couvers closed around it and each ,ooi
furns Ii tening to the pu,sations of Hal
linger's heart
AT 10:l7, after the body had hung
IL minutes, D.. NJ Gill announced tha
there was faint pulse and the heart bea
showed about two beats a minute. A
1920 there was still percep'ib quiv'r
ing of the heart, but at 10 :25 it was off
ciaily announced that HallDger was deao
The physicians found on examination
that the neck had not been broken.
The state chronicle. [volume] (Raleigh, N.C.) 1891-1893, 1892-12-23
HnW 10 II ach Raleigh.

The CHRONICLE offers To send, free OF
charge, by SPECIAL arrangement with the
Recreation Department Of The Christian
Union, full information and printed mat
ter as 70 reaching R4leigh from your
h. me The time tables and pamphlets
i, ueH by the railroads OF steamship lines
IL would use and The circulars Of the
Raleigh hotels n ~ oe had by addressing
the CaRoHIc1.E. Raleigh. o. 'he Recr, a.
tion Department, the Christian Union,
New York.
The state chronicle. [volume] (Raleigh, N.C.) 1891-1893, 1892-12-23
The Duel Yesterday.

PARIS, Dec % The duel between
Clemenceau and ce r udede took place
as arranged Neither man was iD jured.
General Felix g Slus.ier, the mllitar,
governor of Paris and veteran of service
IN the Crimea. Italy, Mexico ard Africa,
had refused to act as an arbitrator. The
idea of arbitration was riuicued as an
evidence of cowardice ON the part Of Nj
de Rpuidede, who suggested it. NJ de
Staudes was appealed to and he at once
proc. eded TO bring things to a climax.
He decided that NJ de r ludede and VI.
Ciemenceau should have an opportunity
to take six shots at each other and that
the com oatanrs should be placed twenty
five PAGES apart with the privilege Of ad-
vancing three steps during the firing.
The fight took place in the Paddock
If the St. Ouen race course At the
word fire both pistols were discharged
almost Simultaneously. The bullets
fle " wide of the mark Again the com
batants elevated their weapons and fred
This time it was evident that the shots
had gone high. Neither was hurt. NJ
Clemenceau cooliy raised bis weapon
again A friend rushed forward and ex
pressed a hope that tie comb atant-
would consider their honor satisfied An
cease the murderous encounter. Both
declared that they must have auother
shot and the soncitous friend retired
Again the pistols were raised and " 0
putfs of smoke told that two bullets had
started on their deadly missl N No
| harm was doue. The two seconds then
| ran up ana insisted that the duel must
terminate; that both had behaved in d
most heroic manner aud that any out
rage upon honor had been fully VII Die
ted NJ Clemenceau and NJ de Rpul
dedge consented t. accept the decision
and the combat came to close
The parting between der ,ulded and
his friends on his start for the dueling
ground, was very affecting He EN-
oraced and kissed them repeatedly aud
assured them that he woul" die in Il
manner worthy of the Lrgion of Honor
| When one of his friends expressed a hope
that the encounter would nor have ia
tai ending, der >uld-de shook his head
mournfully. He fully expected, he de
clared, to lose his life.
Meanwhile NJ Clemenceau who is
said to have spent the morning witt
| VINE helcnoerSer, likewise pfepaISu 4
90 to the scene of mortal combat. HI
gave directions about the issue of laJus
t,ce, and left orders as to the managemen
of the paper in the event of any fatalit.
occurring to him. The staff crowded
around their chief and he kissed and em
braced them each in turn Some of then
shed tears and begged him no. to expos
himself to more danger than was neces
sary NJ. Clemenceau gently rebuNet
them and said: Il have stood n III
field of honor to often to have any ap
prehension now" He said he preferre
death to dishonor, ana spoke in u tone 0
lesolution that evoked tue admiration c
his assist ants.
The state chronicle. [volume] (Raleigh, N.C.) 1891-1893, 1892-12-23
Rusy Das For AGlai.

ATLANTA, Ga Dec % Mr.. Steven
son and the members of his party have
bad Il busy day Of 1t At 9 o'clock the
gentlemen lefc the K'moall house for the
Aragon, where q delightful breakfast
was given them by the young mems
democratic league Short talks were
made by Mr.. Stevenson, Judge Ewing.
Con4res- m IN Scott and others-of the
vs ;ors 10 resp ,nse to toasts They were
variously enterta nd during the day, and
to night large reception was given
in honor Of the entire party by Governor
and Mrs Northen at the executive man
sion. Mrs Northen was assisted IN re
c.iving 10y many prominent society ladies'
of Atlanta and oth,r parts OF the state.
TO morrow morning early the visitors
will leave for Chicago and home, passing
through Chattanooga and Evansville.
Deiegations are here from North Carolina
10 get them to visit Asneville, nut they
want to get back home in time fol
Christmas.
The state chronicle. [volume] (Raleigh, N.C.) 1891-1893, 1892-12-23
Hanged for Murder.

LONDON Dec % Thomas Edwards
was ,nged this morning at Usk FIR the
murder of Mary Connolly on the 16 h of
Septem ber last E1wardsacknowledged
having killed the woman and III that
he murdered her because she was of i'm
moral character and because he had made
up his mind to Kill as many of her kind
rs possible, because Major Fendall was
killed by such woman in 1887 Ed
wards, 1t appears, was in Maj + F, ndall's
command aud very much attached to
him. He conceived murderous atred
against i'm moral women on account of
Feudall's unhappy fate
The state chronicle. [volume] (Raleigh, N.C.) 1891-1893, 1892-12-23
BONAPARTIST MOVE,
A NANTES TO HAS BEEN DRAFT
ED SECRET
urging tho People of France TO Recall
the IL use of B"naparte to the
Throhe--MOnarchis arc Feared
More Than Imperfa,ists.

Ihrohe-- --MOnarchists arc Feared
More Than Emperfa,ists.
PARIS, Dec. % TO day it is the Bo.
napartlsts that are stepping to the front
to take advantage of the difficulties of
the republic. The activity of the royal
lists aroused the jealousy of the imperi.
alist leaders and at recent conclave
they drafted a manifesto addressed to the
people OF France urging them to recall
the house Of B)nsparte to the throne.
This manifesto has not vet been issued
but awaits the appr"va of Prince Victor
the present recognized head of the ex i'm
perial family. Prince Victor is now in
Brussels and the Bonapartist leaders in
Paris have sent agents to that city
to induce him to sign the manifesto.
Should the Banapar;is,s act it is ex
pecttd that they will attempt to strike a
blow IN Paris, rather than in the pro.
vinces They, like the monarchists, a e
being carefully watched and e-ery move
ment is reported to M Ribit and Presi-
dent CaEnot. The proceedings of the
secret conclave, at which the manifesto
was determined upon, were known to
the government almost as soon as the
conciave had adjourned, and the govern
ment is already IN possession OF the terms
of the manifesto
Not so mach importance is attached
by the authorities to Bpnaparti4t as to
monarchist agitation. The government
is greatly gratified by the action of the
Pope, in refusing, at this critical time, tc
become tool of mouarchists' plots and
the friendly relations If church and state
will undoubtedly be strengthened should
the crisis result 10 triumph for the gov
ernment. The newspaper, La Lanterne,
says that the papers discovered yesterja,
In the examination of documents belong.
ing to the company that supplied dyna
mite for the work on the Panama canal
shows that deputies Nsquet, Laguerre
| St Martin, and Laur had received suns
of money from Arton, the go between il
the corruption, for their votes in the
| chamber
The Matin says that fifteen more war
rants have been prepared against sena
tors and deputies, and that pubic prose
cutors in the country districts have beer
instructed to search the residences 0
accused persons and examine aitnesse
for evidence in relation to the charges.
The state chronicle. [volume] (Raleigh, N.C.) 1891-1893, 1892-12-23
PresYdeutialN Nominations.

WASHINGTON, Dec. % The Presi.
dent seat To the senate to day the follow
ing nominat.uns: Frederick j. Grant,
# Washington, as minister to Bolivia ;
Archi alb c Cooli6g., o. Massachusetts,,
secretary of legation at Vienna; George
G. Webb, of New York, secretary of
legation at St Petersburg; ,seph R
Hrrod, of Indiana, second secretary of
legation to Japan Col. John P Hawkins,
assistant commissary general, to be com
missary general of subsistence with the
rank of brigadier general.
The state chronicle. [volume] (Raleigh, N.C.) 1891-1893, 1892-12-23
Two Immigration Bills.

WASHINGTON. Dec % The joint
committee IN immigration will report
two bills-Senator Chapdler's to the
-enate and Mr.. Stump's to the house.
Mr.. Chandler's bill suspends all immigra
,ion for one year; Mr. Stump's bill pro
vides for aquarantine abroad and for
suspension OF immigration whenever the
President deems it necessary to prevent
introduction of contagious diseases.
The state chronicle. [volume] (Raleigh, N.C.) 1891-1893, 1892-12-23

BY vir'ue Of an order OF Superior court
of WaSe 'ounty IN slccial proceedings en-
tit. Il VI l. Fowl.r adm r of " h Hun-
lee Y l. liisn j Hunter and others, | viii
sell on Nnnsav ~, 2d dav of January isq3,
at the court hou~. dor ia Rsegh two
trec II and itnsled in WaEe Forest
oH-nship adjo ulug he lands If Jinsev
rce. & 4 freeman aud Others, md
known as part of LANDS of ia on HuLt.r,
decd. and be- ng the lands set sparl to w .
X HnnfeT aud w r. Hunter I'm be Of
~Ih TO- of the dover lands of :. J Hnn>r,
dec-a-ed. Que tract coutains 81 acres and
- other 3 acres
T,rm-of sale one half cash, balance In
ne year with 5 per cent interest Time
OF sale - M NJ l. FOWLER
n 2u tbs &. MN ssioner
The state chronicle. [volume] (Raleigh, N.C.) 1891-1893, 1892-12-23
Revolution on the Border.

LAREDO, Texas. Dec. 22.-The fight
Yesterday in which several Mexican
soldiers were killed accounts for the vast
amount of tel,graphing going on by mil
itary authorities on both sides OF the
river Parties here who are in touch
with the authorities wear loog faces and
are evidently looking for serious trouble
New Laredo may be attacked at any mo-
ment, and fight may be expected at
Cerelvo. a rich mining town.
The state chronicle. [volume] (Raleigh, N.C.) 1891-1893, 1892-12-23
South CarOlina,s Dispensary.

Columbia, 5. c., Dec ~. Af,er
An al, night session the senate passt d
he Ev ms di-pensary bill TO ITS third
reading at O'Clock this morning. Tnls
bill provides for the dispensing of al
liquors by daily appoin ed officers OF
the state. and in its present position l.
beng referred TO the prohibitionists as
AZ am-ndment to the regular prohibi-
ton bill. as only in this shape is there
anv pos ibility of passing an anti-liquor
law at the pr sent session OF the legls
lature, which adjourns on Satul day.
The state chronicle. [volume] (Raleigh, N.C.) 1891-1893, 1892-12-23
Col. Neville Keprim q IL d d.

WAsHrNGroN Dec. % "A local paper
sat that Col Robert Neville has been
reprimanded by the board of governors
Of the Metropolitan club. He has also
been suspended for one week. This was
the liuhtest sentence that could be i'm
posed upon him under the rules OF the
club MIR. s S Rowland brought
number of charges against Colonel Ne
vile, growing out Of the recent assault
in Madison Square Garden. New York,
during the horse show and endeavored
by every means in his power to have him
expelled from the club.
The state chronicle. [volume] (Raleigh, N.C.) 1891-1893, 1892-12-23
SEiEENADI.IsS ARRESTED.
Winston's Society Boys Declared
NuisHuce.

winston, n G., Dec % Special -
Four ot Wlnston's society young men. s
w. Bnsw.N, late manager Hotel ZiGzrn
dorf, E. III Ray. Hunter Perkinson and
George Hanes, were arrested last night
ard summoned to appear before Mayor
Stockton to day for serenading the pu-
pills Of The Salem college The warran,
charges them with being Il nuisance
Boswell! and Ray, rather tnan stand trial,
left this morning for Richmond.
Rev. c. w hoblnson, Of Gastonia &C.
cepted call to the North Winston Pres
byterian Church and will enter upon his
pastorste duties here the first of the new
year
The state chronicle. [volume] (Raleigh, N.C.) 1891-1893, 1892-12-23
AS AN ERlCAN.
M. Herr Cut Ward McAlllster
SWath In California.


SAN FRANCISCO, Cal, Dec 22.-The
Panama canal investigating committee
at Paris have in their clutches one man
"ho cut quite swath in San Francisco
some years ago. His name is DR.. Cor
neius Herr
Herr came here in 1915 and established
himself as physician, that he was
pupil of the famous DR.. Soulage.
specialist on disea ses of the brain, he
Immediately went to work forming &C
quslntances among the members of the
upper ten in which he was very success.
sui. so much 81. that indeed he was a
sort Of Ward McAlUster. Soon after
his arrival he prevailed upon DR.. Stout,
IN old practitioner of San Francisco to
% into partnership with him. Dr..
scout agreed, but from what he says,
liis experience with Herr was not of the
most pleasant.
DR. Stout was seen last night and said:
THAT man Herr made the fairest repre-
sentations to me and believed him. but
lie left me bankrupt. 1t was too much
for me at my time of life | gave him
everything had l am not surprised
that when he reached Paris he cut igur,
L
now and too infrm to care much. but il
| was stronger and younger | would like
to meet Herr for a few minutes Herr
treated w H LYON. a brewer Of Ia ge
wealth. for some brain affection. II wa-
not known till many weeks after Heiz
suddenly left in 1877 to go t. Pari, how
much be had collec ed Note after note,
each for $40 600 and each bearing the
undoubted signature of Lyon. came
pouring in on the brewer Lawyer
Thomas, who had been Lyons attorney
said the total amount was over 500. 600
| As Lyon was known to be responsible
Herr had an easy job to discount his
notes They were placed with at least
zen different parties. Altogether He z
had csshed in about 800 600 from these
notes. As the signature in each
case was genuine, the notes had to be
paid. Mr.. Lyon was intensely scrupulous
about paying his debts. He insisted on
squaring with the world each day. and
even down TO the smallest domestic ex
penses You can readily understand
nat this avail ,nche of Indebtedness drov,
him almost mad | have not heard OF
Lyon for d zen years. There was a re
port that he had gone to Europe, and
neard later that he had turned mild
lmbecil in his habits and Herr was tax
log care of nlm there. Herr is charged
with mauy other financial transactions,
which, 1t is said, would not bear the
Hght Of T gid investigation. Among
the Sc was tn uttering of notes under The
firm name Of Zelier & Herr electrical ex
perts. z her Is quote 10 a puhIishs
lntervlrw rs having to pay $i3 600 o.
H. St notes. Another transaction IL
which he is said To have figured in al
un adorable highs was the inveigling o.
Mitiiouaire Lutham into an eleotrlc lrgh
: hrme in Paris whereby Herr secured
S23, 600 of the millionair's money"
The state chronicle. [volume] (Raleigh, N.C.) 1891-1893, 1892-12-23
A MISS THAT HURTS.
Where Does tho Trouble Lie and How
Shall IL be Kemedted


DURHAM, n c. Dec Special.
The CHRONICLE failed TO put in its ap
pearance at Durham this morning. and
disappointment Was depicted upon the
countenance OF every subscriber MANY
citizens of Durham would like verv much
lfthese Disappointment could be avoided
Where does the trouble lie7 Is there spy
0av hv which the occurrence NAV not be
repeatedl
Tne marriage bells continue 10 Jingle
here. Last night Rev. w c Tyree, Of
the First Baptist church. unite d
in the holy bonds Of matrimony, Mr..
". A. Billings, Of this city. and Miss
Linnie l. Hester, who lives about two
and half miles from the city An ele
CANT supper WAS given after the wedding
Yes erday at II O'clock, Miss Mary f
Pool, daughter of Mr. J. J. Pool, who
lives about four miles from the city. WAS
united in marriage To Mr.. T. r Newton
A large MI hber of friends witnessed the
nuptials Several parties from Durham
attended ard r-port IA ,vlai time
Last night Rv +. \ Il Bshap was
called up"n t. unite In marriage Mr.
Arthur Viccello and Miss Nodic Gin
ulngs, both Of this cry The happy
event took plscr on Willard street
Rev. t. B Hill. of Wake Forest,
preached at the Second b .p,ist church
last night
MIS- E II Harris died in this city
Yesterday morDirg on Austin Avenue
Tie fur eral services were conducted To-
day a. , u'ciack from the residence by
Rev Il G B aman.
The state chronicle. [volume] (Raleigh, N.C.) 1891-1893, 1892-12-23
NO APPREHENSION
Felt Regarding the Condition of MIR.
Blaine.

WAsHINGT IN. Dec. % ITO day has
been an unrventful enc for Mr. Blaine,"
said Dr. Johnston this evening. when
met ut the door of the Blaine residence.
Il have just come from his bed side and
found HIN holding his own. The fact
III t he does not seem to loose
5 rength is encouraging He converses
whenever permitted to do so-in fact
is Inclined to talk too much for his own
od He assimilates his food, and that
alone gives HIN the necessary strength to
combat the disease and withstand re
IL, ses sh ,uld they come. l can add
nothi more exc pit TO say that L see
thing in bis condition to night to war
rant apprt hon-lnn on the part OF his
fami and friend, Of sny immdlate dan
grr | shalt not go to the house again
10 night unless une xpected comphcatlons
SET in and there we've no outward ,ndica
tions when l left him that he would be
threatened With any; hirg to demand my
| presence
The h use was more brilliantly lighted
/ to night than for me nights past.
The state chronicle. [volume] (Raleigh, N.C.) 1891-1893, 1892-12-23
WAsygINGTON NOTES.

WASHINGTON. Dec 22-The United
States consul at Hamburg to day tele
graphed that there were yesterday two
cases OF cholera; today four, and one
death
Secretary Charles Foster said this
morning that the financial fury. seemed
to have passed Out of the 81 600. 900
gold exported, the treasury had sus
tanned net loss of So 600 600 which
would be. he thought, replaced before
the first of next year.
Numerous letters from bankers, boards
of trade, and chambers Of commerce.
from all parts of the country are being
received at the treasury department
asking that the purchase of silver be
stopped
The supreme court and the court of
claims adjourned to day until January
81
The state chronicle. [volume] (Raleigh, N.C.) 1891-1893, 1892-12-23
The Argument Finished.

New YOaK Dec. %. The argu
m mt in the Briggs Heresy trial was
ti.ished this afternoon and the next
thing is for the court to consider the
evidence and argument and vo;e in de
tail on the charges 1t will begin this
task next Wednesday afternoon in
secret
The state chronicle. [volume] (Raleigh, N.C.) 1891-1893, 1892-12-23
House of Representatives.

Washiugton Dec % -Immed ately
ter the read ng ard approval of the
j'urnal. Mr. McMiltin, OF Tennes- ZEE
moved and adjournment. This was de-
feated, AZ to 49
The committees were called for reports,
but without important results, and as
there was evidently D" quorum present,
the house At 1915 adjourned unil jan
uary 4 1898.
The state chronicle. [volume] (Raleigh, N.C.) 1891-1893, 1892-12-23
Confirmed by the Senate.

WASHINGTON, Dee. 22-The senate in
executive session to day confirmed the
following nominations: Frederick j.
Grant. Washington, minister to Bolivia;
Col John P. Hawkins, TO be commisary
general of subsistence with the rank of
brigadier general
The state chronicle. [volume] (Raleigh, N.C.) 1891-1893, 1892-12-23
The Kitchen-Satterhe Nuptiafs.

RoxBoRo N. c., Dec % -Specinl.-
At sIA o'clock 20 night in the Methodist
Caurch Mr.. w Kitchen, prominent
young lawyer Of this place aud son Of
don w Ii Kitchen, of Scotland Neck,
va m ,rrie1 10 VI ga Susette S.ttertieid,
one OF Rnxbor"'s charming bellies. The
chu ch d, cpFations were beautiful The
oridal couple will sp'nd Christmas IS IN
Scotland Neck with the groom's parents.
The musical given by Mrs Eden Bit
TON al the RpxDoro institute last night
was attended ty very large audience
and was pronounced success.
The state chronicle. [volume] (Raleigh, N.C.) 1891-1893, 1892-12-23
Holiday Season Among theExchangcs

BALTIM IRE. Dec % AT general
meetlng If the corn and fl ,ur exchange
TO day 1t was decided to adjrurn from
the close of business until Tuesday morn
ing next in vie = cf the Christmas holi-
days. The stock exchange will adj urn
from Saturday until Tuesday. Tue re
will be no speculative trading in the cof-
fee market ON Saturday or Monday.
The state chronicle. [volume] (Raleigh, N.C.) 1891-1893, 1892-12-23
Shooting in Halifax County.

WILMINGTON, N. G, D C. % We'd
nesday gut at Essex, Halifax county, a
mer, hant named Exton shot and killed a
negro named Silver, who was cutting an
old man named Shrarin EXton surfeu-
dered. Shearin will probably die,
The state chronicle. [volume] (Raleigh, N.C.) 1891-1893, 1892-12-23

81. ne ,isI Ibe.k a., ol 81 Louis,
No.. have Just thrown oU the market an
elegant ~tant'aTt. ur'Que Nak &r. q n
IA tnrtatn Desk, coinp p'pt- In every de
tat ~ loEis. for So and II
same style ave nuish for 81 net. s->ot
cash. ~@e [ cir card la tnls issue send
your order dir c or send tor sv,-cia circu-
lar Bank co-nter- ami government work
4 specially sen IN your hoof plans for
designs and prices
The state chronicle. [volume] (Raleigh, N.C.) 1891-1893, 1892-12-23

IA order ~ the Su perior
uat il . cial roceed-
Freeu an administra-
b 9g0u~tJ {. Ere. ma
I'M - ard others / viii
j ~ the court house
las tf- 2d day of Jan
NJ describei land
Wax Forest Town
nj Z Z e lands Of
b = eeman J. 4
4al oth,r r. know n a.
5 4 eigh. and COR
. Z sale, onc-hal'
WEAR With s,er cent In
o. lCck III,
IL. PACE. Com'r.
The state chronicle. [volume] (Raleigh, N.C.) 1891-1893, 1892-12-23
V authority o.

q y authority o.
90 JOIN son an6
as r C 'rdad IL
3 Ok no page 3l2,
Or 'VAk con V
lay OF January. 1898
Ourt hOu - door of
20 t. q ii hest hidier.
Ufl ntan palth-r b an n
axe county BON Ell on the
11's OF = y 1u -uFr ON the
D 4 OF Adel NJ arid :. r.. on
nds Of VI rgtrette Pat. OF
lie auas OF X y WNn q,
res and Gesciioed IN the
tae-
w. y JONES Atty.
The state chronicle. [volume] (Raleigh, N.C.) 1891-1893, 1892-12-23
CarnOt Has tn e List.

PARIS, Dec. 22,-Uount Csfftrelli,
monarchist deputy for Aisne, told the
commission be could contirm the report
that President Carnot had a list of depu'