The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1892-04-18
4 CRITIC OF sUrLKR,s BOOK Czrr1.
C1SEn
The veteran General Cswes Back Upou n
Abusive Aeea11aNt,

| SoA"
I'll. 60,
h..,r. a.s..,... "P'' d
~
,n,n..a,. I ,1s. OF TIE svN-sr' i nave
-. '',,,. iet my BOOK 70 make ns own
way WIN tne reading public. and to take care
onn LAY. as wen as may 90 without DEFENDING
nno, ~. W.. y, II as REGARDS tne crltieisms
M, ~ ho.a,a - a, wi W.
of itsai, nn,,s,.. - wv pook eahno. Mke euro
rlas 10 own .".e VI ~. ~, var.
Win ~ IN ,i,a . .s .. esery TACT
becorso .hae. n ~. anu appenoices oeeonuly'
tend,S -, ....,a nas 1eeh no susees.,oh OF IN.
,oricoI sotemsnt. .hmc ,..o a.. a"y ot ss ms
tindllnoss with ,r,,t.,. =. ~ To-. ,, 'ie
tba l,oJin, So. ~ ~, nas ISL ho'ieeo oy
,onohaI ~ ~ s y. ,,'e county nus ieit IL un
hnva honnd >e' N's's' ,'"u eou'u
For noarir .,. ,,,.,
nereon,iiv tho tor.a. y, ,o..' , nave oeen
| snons,hia ,,.s.ass soi"n' Tre-
| molovo,ar,o h.. - ets' whose
vitrnarot,on to u,isnosss. o .oc ,. oI
sc,ian ,rh,ah ,nn .ep SSH. n''seil ana my
unnoti,,s No. s go pouieu upon mo- no
comn,oina, ,,a., se y. .neni nave
with n dncl,s hoo. on ,rI,,oh " it, uo."ieu as
no imnrosoion ''''' ""'e' naue
Ono wrIter hor.r.. ,u,,,
crjtic,sr -, ~. "n.sn. W.. WI 'as ue'o,eo ms
NJ - "a.
with in n ma ", tho Tau,,s,, "".cm are aea,t
| I have .et thor, ,,r.S 49, ,n Nv. IA "nic"
his mot,vas Nd h,s 40. We W .'a,e
the suh;octs -, ,rh,,s -. N,. ~ AnoNieuseo,
eanecieiiv -, ~ r,,sh 80 100 y. eAposeu' anu
native Ton ouo "''s- ~ 'o01'' 10 NV h''
Torrn" no,,
| "oukin-l know him by no other
called .ha Vas 'aAeh par' III q newspaper
do vtt tha NJ y anu a at mas something 10
in those two nono. IN ~ 1oe'n' tos, puDhshed
ana tho ., ~ tha. s"e eunio aouslve "atter'
nnner onca sJtsa W. ""e w"', ~ ''o a'.e[ news
What taII % 49, "iiiI"m .ulen BRYANT
linea in rnr s,,,, q. ,,,',"n u'e 70 ASK 10"
Godkln has been writing against ma ,or
nearly quarter Of century He has had one
n DsyIons abuse Before the Mon appeared
being paid to him from the funds raised eV bv
the antl-slavery people Of Massachusetts
newspaper. which he promised should be used
as an advocate o, the cause Of the newly
emancipated slaves. lam told that he got the
money upon that representation. believed
,u a, ,hat ne would not do as he agreed to, but
wou,a make "a paper Tor his own agerandize-
to Know the course Of the paper will deter
si SIM" ths s themselves h hse whether was right
ras ne sss hs"us me with that vim
little minds Under such cIrcnn .tancss eI ~
,, n. from ssts r; ssyth!as II ii: criticism
a. and VIII give few instances to show how lit
t tle no KNOWS concerning the matters Of which
he writes v.n.a t.
,non Erv,. ~. GU GU 'ila' Was cast ashore
competence and neoli1anoa ~, ~. Cs...S.
was Obliged to taka tbo .nn,rsnS - ~.
steamer in nv own hnnda and - adont .nah
methods as were usual IN endesvorino - 800
u shin in such condition GodL;n $50,
"1t LIB, $500,
to get out of the FrVins Pan int WERE t k az.
OF the rebels at Fort Macon. but the sea- |
shin r. Oh uea; Butler saved them. The
upon the sandy shoaI The ~ Tan VAIL w.a ran
traitor or an imbecile. Butler assumed |
sea Iaad a ana ORDERED MN TO get your deep
Captain shouidered the hundred wa,rbt 'n ns
metal and ten score fathoms OF line ana won't |
naea ~ snnnG E1 pehnd US the question what
aboord isic at drsucht OF eiShteen yaat Rnt
why the deep-sea lead! The lghtest Of hand |
haWa az MAJ A. "a nsWtnR me and slnker might
reader that though the Corinfhisns AZ MnphinEs
head indulge In irreverent mirth. there lies
'''''e'n "in'e'eFSo VI the oeep sea-.
The account In the Book is as follows:
Turning again to the Captain Of the vessel.
SAID: Captain what depth OF water have we
don't know.
Well said /. get your dipsy lead fdeen
sea! anc come forward with me. We seem to
ave went Ih foEWard tooatbar and ma. A.,
mate. and ubon Sounding found va Wsra IN
fourteen ieet OF water. We Eere on Q sand |
list abnre the 1oram M ee aTTb IT, rounq pank.
eighteen feet OF water" '''' VIZ"
Godkin savs. "va MT ho,,,a ~ A.,
tion what wac tba naad -, aa,,s,, Ao 'u9s
evidently doesn,t trow ~. $3.50. h.'s, no
NOT deal with MI ba Soasn,t nnnv ouy shali
of that ia innnito vii, al ,L.' W ~. Wv sum
sol ia aground md "a - -" aat ~ "nen YES
necessarv r. tnov ho,r ,sS" ~ 80. =. 30 oute as
tbe vase, os hon, nav, ~ W. "S ,.. 40 uhue,
less than eiobteen fact Int boS, n.',". , me nau
had ond n,het ,na tio $500. ~. w" mucn less we
~ tha Iana - ~ III. anu character