The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1892-12-09
rs BYRNES'S TURN AGAIN.
=. MN SUPPOSED THAT PARKHURsT
}" VAS FIGHTING VICE

s,,.r,ntendent says He Womb Gladly
the Minister ms nm Ally Rather Than
r,.my. and Defends His Own Course
Aet,on-Detectivo Gardner Indicted.
-. Grand Jury heard testimony yesterday
Am Inspector Mclaughlin as to the charge
p'. a-,o,,ion preferred against Charles W.
s.,dnsr. chief detective OF Or. Parkhursts
e v'.,.., Tor the Pr vontion OF Crime Inspec-
,mNsIsu.hlin gave his account OF the detec-
w. ". az .,d arrest OF Gardner. after Gardner had
wv 4.vsl sl5o In marked bills from Lille
ne. a, 1:s, West Fifty-third street. on the
. u.u,no o, Dec. I. Police Capt. Devery. Mrs.
s r,,.an and william II. Smith. driver OF the
. .h ~, o, which Gardner and Mrs. Clifton got
'.0 ~. lima OF tho arrest and Detective Ser.
WV Wlchasl crowley. who assisted in
sea ..,,r Gardner. testified. Tho Grand
H NV, found two indictments against Gardner.
S %s. sr.t indictment charges him with extor-
a"o !, accepting $50 from Mrs. Clifton on Oct.
~ ' and assuring her that for $50 month he
-o,id give her better protection than the
.a,i,s could give her. Tho second indictment
.h,rs,s Gardner With attempted extortion in
a.m,ndjur $50 from Mrs. Clifton. on the
waning o! Dec. 4. as tho price OF preventing
h,r prosscution on an indictment charging
h.rv,h keeping disorderly house. Gard
Nv. III h. orraignei in the Genera, Sessions
.'ar b.,ore Judge MARITIME, to plead to tho
,.n.,ren,s.
s.r.rin,endent Byrnes spent good part OF
A.I,v rcsterday in preparing A staten ent in
..,,v :, mr. parkhurst 1t was late in the
,ternocn when he gave it out.
.rh,. s.ntem,nt." he said. 81 want TO mako
l !, ,.nlr 10 the attack Of DIR. Parkhurst," With
~, t,a, Introduction he made tho following
.,,,orsrt.
.Th,y. ro,d ov,r vary corcfuIlv tba stata-
.,,, r,Jo hv III. rarl; burst md ns far n.
,,,,Id -.rh,,s ,xnoct tbsv corroborate what
49,. ,.,, stou, min, and his methods. T
,.r. =. ann, Dr por,:hnrst for maxim, III.
. ..,.n, t,,. r,isod ~ ,.st sh,rr, mud alan. 7
sa' "' IT., nro,,t h.tnr, as :. NV nrmoo,s
MI. t,nm h,s viii, u,,o-nncos IN Mat.
wl'.'I ',o., MS pto,l. ".te."ns. W. p,",,
s'SI.;p..s. we anu e.. ,m, ~. his
" society Nus osS' W. ~ w p unH VIM. mo
Predecessor laborci Tor. DR.. fnrkhurst says
s,tly that Is not his aim, He is not trying to
~a m' ,,or,ii;n,, nr tn ronross tb. social
x Is, 10 in ,I ncd to attach the notice.
| cay. that is a new departure. His prede-
s,ssnr nr howard crosby whom no ono will,
accuse Of lack OF sincerity or honest purpose.
AID whom Dr. Pnrkhurst hims elf will admit
{, b,yo served his c,ty md his reneratIon
= i"'o hei'eu MS e'' aho ''s sene'a'iou
we'll saw other opportunities. other ends. and
70 found occasion more than once to publicly
thank ,he ro,iro for N !. h.lr tbov ho "a ronIor.
ed him in reaching them. DR.. Patkhurst ia to
DO commended for thus stating his position
without ros,ryn. II 10 .asv for mo now to nm
s. ,.".l. ivIu.ie ~ - easy 'or mo now 20 uh-
cerstand why he has never asked my help or
offered to help Mo. thing which has never
teon clear 10 me before. He "a moi An a,lv. ha
nan enemy. he assumes this attitude with
cut having ever put tho sincerity OF the police,
their willingness to do tho thing which no
Gsue 10 not ooihc. VIZ the suppression OF
cine to the test. and upon the bare evidence
b.. crime exists, that it has not boon sup
vessel. ihat - true. ihe evidence ls there.
d. Parkhurst has found 1t: and any one who
4 VII, sock it long enough and rcrsistontly
illus should be in bod. VIII l., sure to
ta4W.
- rsh1Ifs vent abroad , this
!aope. ! ~ tod. Is A. prepared to Say that
lsl-l 10 lind It there than in New York :! Ii
tass ei IN yst travellers. whose Testimony is to
do .nrSt that New York is cieanor. purer
as than even those foreign colnmunities
vhsre VIE ~, thc S,eoinl form town rd which
Es at,asSs IRE directed is Deliberately licensed
Tor the purp"so o: Keeping it within restrnint.
Ilery IN lDubt uhnllt thiS M Woman
tssd fcar in,nit IN S"E ori's strestS. M
M .u'a r, eaf iusNL IA ~" to,h stfsets' no
sss neea n 'vt utiEer 10 HIS noFais nere un
.x no - CIV ioohisE inr ~. A.,
,,,, ,'n w ~. IaIhhuls!i !ns law spccll-
wv, }.:a'sHs lhs Police WIN tne outy OF sup
~ saWnnI' ioslttut!pn. anu otneT
tS vi, l., u,sS.rG i Ia; 10 also tue. emu
:Si,d;. y, Ws"oinS: Mha' they can. since inc
fn"t ~ i i, iifi','', Mnen perhtnc cupeIlhleh-
hSsr-tbs ,oinn ~. IN seven months ana
ryy cTos,p ' iI h INV" n,;9rT ny orurrs ralteq
:,i;r .,s, ~ npnSrS VI ~ lhne uni hrresteu
p,r,Iin" rrS Mn' M9'5 ihii,ates Oh theui; 81 81
se~y ANS Iou Sc, az" 30 prisonSrsi ana o.
roud have ons ,', notter wit ths wy
NJ sa az society and his snScia! knowl;
mai ,ha t"s ,,s nth,. Nery likely we nave mol
Which Ljs ass.s.I"t"; ~ 9HiMchce OF crime
orn p,Irn"s ".,eft@n ,'ey mseu Tor ti,eir
ZINES p wer" W. " innt unnse pmrnosrS some
Jsscv. IVA Mas s,"we Ia me o. i'is cHiei
brtSt Ir e pa UtGr uty ,or ,i man anu cN
innO,anca IaNnt 81 NAY 7'H' oeite'e III MS
-Ean. h,s ~ OF, an,
aided in u"vo, -, ~ s9'' mo'Ses OF ~ iame
les in Tho liz. nS o 81" s"oae ." n.any
aeir niac"s pnosi,iN NJ NJ Go'hs 70 taks
duty in closi,r ,hnss bnuSo!. an nru WILL
their jnmn,es ;rIoro tIn;r "m. arI aE
soms OF the woman wsrs t,. oMen ,,a s emei.
nil some dischmrged 10 90 ONT ariin ~ ~
world To- earn Iiyin nr W rhurs ~ tne
lived in the world inn, onnncb IN ui, nus
gncharitabc il cnn l." tSwnrd ne ~ ,,nsS n ;
aers how Itls il hn. nrn .,is t'a ass % SIN
Him the woman ssiy"I ~ . ,I'"y oroughe before
how it sc"rns thes, wnm ra %H rhony; neknows
10 pity Let ms ask NJ -, w, ,,,, ~ processes
Of conscirnca, wv u. n'uI - Il question