New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1892-03-19
THE VOTE FOR JUDGE WOODS
ONLY ONE MAJORITY IN THE >ECREI
SESSION.
THE PROCEEDINGS MADE PUBLIc-A MIsHAp

THE PROCEEDINGS MADE PUBLlC-A MlsHAp
WITH THE PAIRS.
rBY TELEGRAPH TO THE TkIBUsE.l
Washington, March 1o.-After good deal Oh oo'.
tenton in secret session to-day, the senate uc''uS
TO make public the vote by which Judge NoonS VI
the District Court Of Indiana was yesterday con-
nrmed as an additional Circuit Judge for the seventh
Federal Circuit. 1t also voted TO make puDhc
the testimony given for and against the appointee
during the protfacted hearings held by the senate
Committee on the Judiciary. The vote as uHeh
from the executive clerks tally shows Il baro margin
Of one In Judge Woodss favor, Instead OF majority
Of two as announced yesterday, the totals being 20
for confirmation and ~ against As the norman he-
publican majority in the senate Is SIX, hVe hepuu-
ncan Senators absent without pairs They were
Messrs Jones and Stewart, of Nevada; Washburn, OF
Mime sofa; PetugTew. Of South Dakota and Pernns'
of Kansas It was explained that the vote was taken
AT an earlier hour than had been expected and that at
least two Of the absent Senator's who had gone do"h
Gown on business In the Departments retnrnen 10 the
Capitol too late to be counted. 80 unusual mshhp
with the pairs would probably not have occurred put
for the absence Of Mr.. Casey, Of North Dakota' inc
Republican whip" lie kept at home une1-
pectedly by Illness and no one could take hoiu' up
parently and make good the transfers which he had
undoubtedly planned. The vote In dotal was as
follows:
Ycas-Allson Chandler. Davis Dawes Dixon Dolph'
GaIlInser Hale uansbfOugh Hawey, HIHanb, Hlsooch'
Hoar Mcmillan Manderson Mitchell, Paddock. Proctor
sanders Sawyer, Sherman Shoup Squire and STOCK
br.dge--25
Nays-Bate Berry. Blackburn Blodgett Gull COCK
roll Coke Daniel Faulkner, George Gibson (Ald.),
Harris, Jones (Atk), Kyle. Morgan, Palmer, Pasco'
Pcaer Puph. Ransom. Turpo Villas Voorhees, Waltall-
-.
Tho pairs were: Messrs. Aldrch and HI, Cameron
and Butler Carey and Irby Casey and Vest Cullom and
cray. Dubois and Gibson (.a) Fcltoo and Drlce
Dlnfs nd naffu
Power and White. Quay aud Mcpherson, Stanford and
Vance. Teller and Chiffon, Warren and Gordon. Wilson
and Colauitt. Molcott and Kenua.
II a escape for the judiciary Com
mittce and one that will probably not be allowed TO
cumsanccs.
The testimony taken by the Judiciary COMMITTEES rca-
i've 10 the nomination Of Judge Woods mikes volume
Of 172 printed pages including exhibits II comprises
testimony gwen relative 70 tho Coy-Sullivan trials;
touching the charges OF discrimination b. Judge
Woods against Democrats, and the dsullssal Of
the cases The exhibits made up OF the
r5cords Of the courts In the trial OF the bribery
case-; the opinion Of the supreme Court In
the ssme C.sos Judge WoDis card 30 tho public, de
Justice Harlan N approval Of Judge Woodss ruins
letter froy Judge NiblAok " show tht Judge WOodss
second charge was nos afterhonGht, eY Senator Nc
Donnh's criticisms Of Judge Woods and the laters TO
denunciaory resolution OF the Indiana Democratic Con
ventlon.
The nonlnaton OF william r. Gilbert of Oregon as
additional Circuit Judge In the lXth or Pacific Coast
Circuit held from yesterday. confirmed this
afternoon. This disposes Of the last OF The sina
nominations under the Evarts law