New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1892-12-09

been honored by such Edwards ana enllcci
and the Hodges and Adams. Ara you VIII I'm, ,n
money for missions, although you agree '"t Inv die in
TIER sins Yon win agree with that the Issue Is
Of Vital importance Men do not pick out Vic'in w.
and then search for errors In his doctrihe.' 40 %
hcreSy But trials for heresy are iOfcfu uPon -
Cbur!b when cerrymcn. In violation of tLcx VOWS
OF ordination and setting defiance the STANDARD oI
doctrine In their own communion peislst ~ aCoiiv
even though they caim that they are NEUTRALITY-SUSPICIOUS.
WHERE THE RESPONSIBILITY RESTS.
Every one Will admit that the necessity for tiAiS
Of this kind is greatly 10 be- depicred lh'S are d
cause Of vexation and disturbance to the Chu'c' anu
temporarily divert the minds Of men from tAal s'e"'
object OF energies and efforts m N"nS "'' ~
of the world T. the likeness OF Christ. hua .r ,,
i0. who are r al to Presbyterian doctrne Dnt
upon VINO are It's as ,aiians. H'n "nau nave
maintain The putty 1i or It', WI T. * ~ bic
no pure faith 10 proclaim to the worn. !, - ,"s :
tnaI rnrh @ bnd thai t.c Church shoald tolerate
differences Oi opinion Wltmh ro" 49, onnrove
We may Tolerate what we 10 IN IN, ne should
freely admit that Intolerance Is DIo 'ns LIB, ,renSnI
be the last to deny that liberty Is srg nd,a nen
But by Intolerance do not understand ioi m5 nn =,
- tb.ir obllgat ons ana by hbeit' uAderSt hu GU"
ior ILL., hond he no attempt 10 obscure the lssne
which IL now before this Judicatory' ~ Is o T,at
tct h,twccn the Old school and the No" @ hu,"h
u.s. @ resi Leaders OF what formerly the new
school marty were among the stancheSt oes' a CHI
the authority Of the S,s Ike Edward Robinson Henry
upon smith oiI and william Adams, TO attribute 10 us Mem
opinions which they would hasy SION and XntiRc
Vision party None OF the points raised III rnS '' Of
have been raised in cQnHeco .n WI" proposed words re
iatnr 10 The truthfanesS of scripture may oo 49,
designed to strengthen Zen ana th anestion be-
tween Scholarship and ignorance unless M rr,Ss
tcan standards ana the 10Y GH nt AK that men Should
He restricted as their methods OF Tscron u ha.
are ready to deal with any new concusons
which contradict the doctrines whch ,,fs nn %,I
oemnly romised to supp IT. tfy By Soo "r doncs
tr else submit 10 the decisions of our courts
COLONEL KETCHAM' PROTEST.
The protest which Colonel Ketcham read was as
follows:
rise to question of privilege. The attention Of
Topographic report of the proceedings OF TINS b'uy
upon December D. So includes about twenty paHcs Vi
tenograplers notes, beginning at the last me ol psr
44o- erased page No. 4ol, T. point below t"c inuuc
OF page 46o-erdscd page W. 49, Whch "on' tn
no,r OF III, Ircsbytcry. and rs - stated 10y ''c
stcnogIaplcr were inserted into the stcnograpnc re-
Ryigc, wib III ABB ovsl Of tn MoOcrt u, nnt ii
this insertion was made 10y the Stenographe aIt'I
Rad been announced to the house mat pan vi Nv
parties had fully presented their evidence and AFTER 'r
argument in behalf OF the Prosecuting Committee Nau
The attention of the JudlcatOry has also been called
to the fact that it appears by pag" % ~ ."c
: +
1S9. that there has been inserted nj page 4d' OF we
Cfcla scnosTnphic report Of the proceedings OF 'hS
body. held on Monday, December D. L1g5, m,rh i, ns
ditonal printed sheets. which fifteen additional pii
shc.ts "a 10 contain words and mlt''r "hcH VIZ
not spoken upon the floor Of the ire AN" ncs
stenographc report of the proceedings, rs the minutes
Of December g. io92 show upon the re"1 or ' ,hc
gcsion OF Professor Briggs, with the approval ol !
Moderator. and that this insertion was m''hr ny ,le
stem graphcr after It had been announced 10 The mouse
that both OF the parties had fully prs,cd ,l' d. "aa
dcncc and after the argument In behalf OF the lTs"
cut { C,mmtee had been begun. ..,...,.,
70 rlcse additions 10 the >cnographcS record above
referred 10. and having taken exception thereto. 'hg'
asked that the said twenty pages OF stcnographrr
note. and the said fifteen additional printed ShrrlS
20 introduced into the official stcnographic record;
should be stricken Pcrefrom. and that the nocused
,houid not be permitted TO refer TO the con
tents Of said twenty pages Of stenotraphcr nol~ oa
said fifteen additional printed sheets, or any OF ihe
extracts documents books in either OF them con
tanned referred TO- as evidence upon me irlai' %,
I'm anv manner whatever before This Judcatory. ana
a motion having been duly made ana seconded va,
the Judica,oly should comply with the request o.
Ihc prosecuting committee and strike ont all tuch
matter said motion declared by the Moderator
20 De ont Of order and was not put TO The house
subsequently, on motion made and seconded the
record upon tle official minutes of the request Of
nocs Of stcnorrphrrs notes and said fifteen additional
exception taken thereto by the Prosecuting Committee.
AZ the question Of integrity and accuracy Of the
matter Of the greatest possible importance not only TO
Me parties to the proceedings bu, also in The in
strained to protest, and l hereby, give notice
Of section orion io Of the ooh Of Discipline. aanns The
proceedings above referred 10. a. mi-chIrvon, aud
crrcneous. and also against the decisions and juds
ments Of the Ircshytrry In relation thereto. now
request such other members Of the Prcsbytcy wish
10 join In the protest To communicate with me, 50
that their names be- added thereto.
As this protest relates 10 matter ~ fundamental
importance 70 these proceedings. the formal protest
with the statement Of the reasons therefor. which
rall ask 10 nave placed upon the record must be
prepared win care and ACCURACY after careful cN,