The Black Hills union. [volume] (Rapid City, Pennington County, Dakota [S.D.]) 1889-1904, 1892-03-18

PosSu 70 having heard TINS DlOfoe lady az
dress Williams BY Hello Billy
Nellie McCarty deposed that she saw Mi.
Boyd riding with plaintiff, saw her wear
seal skin sacque, and what she supposed wei
diamond ear rings. Gross examined she tie.
tilted that she never saw Mss Boyd act in a
unlady-like manner.
Frank Mcclure, toll-gate keeper, saw
blonde lady and plaintiff driving alone twic
or three times aweek towards Ontario beacl
Cross examined he testified that he had hear
Williams was a married man and separate
from his wife.
Wilhelmina Weigand deposed that Mis-
Boyd and Williams used to Wis
a Miss Leach socially, and that tn
neighbors looked upon Miss Boyd as a pei
son Of bad character.
Edward Weigand. husband Of previous de
ponent, said he heard Miss Leach, Miss Boy,
and plaintiff and others play cards up stair
in his house.
Lizzie Tobin saw plaintiff and Miss Boy,
riding together, saw him come to her hous,
with a satchel and put her hand on hi
shoulder in an affectionate manner.
Benjamin Barnes, head waiter at the Liv
ingston hotel, Rochester, where plaintiff tool
meals. Noticed a blonde lady took dinner
with Williams almost every Sunday, when he
ordered bosses ale.
Frederick w. E. Purchase, clerk at the
hotel, %corroborated the previous. depon.
testimony.
Mary Mcclure attended the toll gate going
to Ontario beach, and saw plaintiff drive
repeatedly.
Mary Cavanaugh made expensive dresses
Miss Boyd, saw her and plaintiff at the
opera together, and riding in a buggy fire.
saw Miss Boyd go up the back stair
way to plaintiffs rooms.
May Holmes saw plaintiffs photograph in
Boyd's room; considered Mrs. Williams
much abused woman; said that she thought
Mr.. Cox ought to be able to pay as much for
,ood evidence as plaintiffs side and that it
vas understood Mr.. Earl was to 60 to the
Hills and get expenses and ten dollars
day.
Phillip S. Townsend, secretary of the
club, a social organization, de-
'osed that plaintiff was still a member of the
and had not resigned, had seen him there
ften lately, and had seep him take supper
lately.
Miss Ella Locke noticed plaintiff go to Miss
house very often during the past three
ears, nearly every night. Cross examination
testified that Miss Boyd made a tea
for her and afterwards stated, when
sked to make another, that she did not sew
ny more.
Ellen Mcclure knew Miss Boyd in the shoe
lctory when she ran a button hole machine
lere.
Alice Faber, music teacher, gave lessons to
Boyd from the fall of 1890 until last
lay at two dollars each. Miss Boyd then
she was about to leave the city and
:opped.
Joseph B. Cox, a brother of Mrs Williams,
lie defendant, deposed that he visited plain
fl to ascertain what the real cause of the diff
Guilty between plaintiff and defendant was.
lr. Williams then stated that Mrs. Williams
ad been in the habit of blessing herself at the
lble, much to his annoyance, as it tended to
lake him the laughing stock eff the dining
'om. He also said that he objected strongly
} having a servant girl sitting at the family
Ible, directing her conversation entirely to
is wife, something Mrs. Williams persisted
doing. The deponent testified that the
|aintiff on the occasion of this visit, said he
ould not live with his wife under any con-
deration.' Deponent believed that the
'rvant girl was now in an insane asylum.
Herbert Harrington deposed that he lived
the same house with Miss Boyd and that
= had never observed her act in an unlady
Ike manner, and had never seen Miss Boyd
aftly undreSsed IN the hall.
Miss Nettie Boyd, attired in a gray faille
ilor made walking dress then took the stand
I'd testified to being thirty years Of age, to
aving lived at No. 20 Chestnut street, Roch-
ter, and to having occupied the front room
n the second floor. She described the loca-
on of the o by means Of a plan of the
submitted by counsel, she admitted
aying received visitors there, to first having
ct plaintiff in the fall of 1885 at her own
Dor, again on the street in the spring of 1886
I'd a third time when she went to learn how
run a button hole machine in the factory.
laintiff never called on her in 1857.
He first called upon witness the latter end
1854 in company with Others. Witness
ever loaned the Wyland girl any of her
caring apparel and never had her do any
undry work for her. She admitted having
lied on Mr.. Williams on Chatham street in
'mpany with Mrs. A. C. Williams; she de-
ed every having met, saluted and kissed
aintiff on the stairway leading to his room
n this building; she denied having kissed
n. Williams on meeting him
Mr.. Earrs house and she denied
aving washed dishes in Mr.. Earrs house. I
ere Judge Fuller asked the witness if the
laintiff ever kissed her on any of these sever
| instances, which she also denied. She de-
led ever have gone to the stairway clad in
er night gown, to take leave of Mr.. Will
ms Of an evening, and to ever having adj
ressed plaintiff as "Old Billy" Miss Boyd
to being a dressmaker, to owning a
al skin sacque, which she bought in 1851
18th her own money, earned at dressmaking,
buying a looking-glass, chairs, jewelry,
c. also with her own money. She admitted
aying received money from her fathers es-
tie during the last seven years.
Miss Boyd proved a good witness and COM
auded the attention and respect Of the
Rumor has it that should Mr..
Villains secure a divorce he will at once
ed her.
Water Pipes.
The question OF the relative amount
I wa~terfurnished by different size pipes,