Freeland tribune. (Freeland, Pa.) 1888-1921, 1892-06-02
TIN PLATE HUMBUG.
THE CLAIMS OF THE M'KlNLEY BILL
ERS RUDELY PUNCTURED.

American Tin Is Nothing More Than
Dipped Iron-The Canning Industry.
Seriously InJured-The Industry 'Fos-
tered" for the Benefit of MonopoIists.
We have rather impressive plate of
sheet tin before us as we write. 1t is of |
oblong shape, Of easily handled size, and
handsomely coated. We are asked to |
believe that this is American tin. The |
iron that forms its base is probably
American. Where the tin which makes |
Its coating came from it is perhaps not
so easy to say, but we are disposed
strongly to hold that it was not mined
in this country. That there is any
proof in it that the tin manufacture on
any scale Of importance has been estab-
ished In this country; that we owe to
the Mckinley bill aid in the manufacture
of TIN to any considerable extent here,
or that, If we are to have it, it will be at
a less sacrifice than paying good deal
moro money for our tin than if legisla-
tion had let this matter alone, we do not
believe.
As near as we can get to the true in
wardness of this tin plate matter, the
case seems to be about this: A remuner
ative and healthy business was being
carried on in the manufacture of tin
plate for the American markets. The
great bulk of 1t was consumed i'll the
making of tin cans for the preservation
of fruit and the packing of other ma
terial that can be conveniently handled
and kept in this way. Nobody suffered
from 1t; many were benefited. There
was little inducement to change the
conditions on which it was conducted
little desire to do so. 1t is victim to
the cupidity of certain men who did de-
sire to call In the government to help
them in their business In another
production. Certain Pennsylvanians
thought there was way to establish
sheet iron manufacture. They would
have been willing to let this tin produc-
ton alone, SO far as 1t applies to canning,
but 1t was in the way of their sheet iron
business They used timed sheet iron
plates for roofing purposes, and wanted
to get a monopoly Of that business.
We are told that we are manufactur-
ing tin plate. So we are, such tin plate
as that we have made the occasion of
this article. 1t Is composed of iron
dipped in tin. 1t can be manufactured
almost anywhere. The chief thing nee
essary Is to procure a sheet of iron and
dip 1t in solution of tin, and the tin
plate Is made. But those who make 1t,
and those who yaunt themselves upon
having introduced o new article into
American production, are very careful
not to state that it is not new article
90 hoe
produced here for q period of about
fourteen years.
This Is roof tin. Probably considera-
BILE mischief would have been done by
the effort to set up one or two million
aires in Pennsylvania through the aid of
government legislation in this business
Of making plate for roof tin, but not a
tithe as much as If those desiring to en-
gage in 1t could have been induced to let
canning tin alone. To afford an excuse
for this monopoly there was great
parade about introducing the tin manu-
facture generally In America. The great
bulk of the tin manufacture here is the
tin canning branch of it. This tin, such
as we have been considering in this arti-
Gle, does not apply there at all. The
plates that form its basis are steel, not
iron. They are rolled to thinness very
much less than this show tin which Ii
used for political purposes. They have
not been made to any extent in this
country. Of the nineteen firms in this
tin dipping business. which the McKin.
ley bill claims to be its trophy, but
which existed independent of 1t before Ii
was passed, but four make these plates
at all; the bulk are made of iron, while
but few make the steel plates that are
necessary to the tin canning manufac
ture.
1t Is possible to force the country into
its production with sufficiently high du
ties; almost anything might be achieved
in this way; but the effort toward it nov
is grieyous wrong to the tin canning
industry and an inexcusable burden tc
the greet bulk of the American people,
Boston Herald.
A Tariff Lesson for Brooklyn.