The sun., 1891-01-23

WQulu VOU0 DhCk 10 tIOuDl0 tn0H.
Mr.. Sherman rep. ohiol argued that oven II
the motion to correct tho journal were n
sHs Sc s.1 aside s & Ss1
Blackburn 1Dem., Ky.i. he admitted .tha. Sir, r.
But he Insisted that. q . motion to correct the
journal was oil SO privileged a character rs to
M"ui 10 i1'n 10 transact nS soa
%f as sH ss as:r TsG m .s s:ass a.
cesa QUESTION ION on tie SaRT raiend%r nGu' 10 pro-
s Mi a.eas Arfs ss% sae
ese ro Tss Non No. As Ihas
the Vice. .President the opportunity OF express.
20 9 ss S ~ o4r h0nH hes
Eon 81 rec deSate and he wanted d. ss eS
Rhoa inG fpf shs s 10 ss an;
Sena, or to order for the manner in which lie was
protested against anybody acting as censor OF
ss ssh SA. 4f'9&ss s, a sse S @ do Nj! a1 a
| man was sreaking by permission OF tho sonntc
nPM b5 not 6y permission of me ss1aor hNss from
mntter.
Once more the Vice. President stated that he
slight. .aitention to the technical question In
oi H1a H. to .ts ss M
friends on Tho other side WOULD consent 70 go
90 with the necessary public business manor, In an or;
Vice. President Coliax. in February. 1872 t9ih he
effect that tho CHAIR could not n restrain Sen; :;
hiMssi; had 70 % The iudss s 81 sbe,s reissaney
ana sMsr! M .s.ed ths hone that Nj, dorMsn
ses .e and Tn Ms G"sn
went on Mi,h hi. remarks In Ms own way: Ho
ss nsss @ t1 .ss
un such matters IS the whole country Is Inter
estel In. wo viii re meet YOU. as w2 h.Ss S done
nsss /; asssea; " SslieSs a ,Ss Eiss,iSa = NJ NJ
sons.rs. aud ws, Win stand hers sIId I
shs 1t D9 p9a'r .ss sssso a.S.s Ss wsh Sna .es be
peal 20 the American people to sustain us.
1 So1s to sssT Fgn
pfscsdents ct tho body. and nothing bas been
presented prs;sI that con sustain him in such
ADDRESSING MIR Edmunds, Mr.. German in;
eses. whish could come The Ssnate
| wss not the approval OF the journal.
M p st sP. n M rHo
esed 70 business before the approval OF the
@r: dorm.n paid tribute tc Mr.; Edmunds's
not . lawyer. and in view Of the ground taken
By the ns Senator he was a sad that he was not
Sr Gormnn. continuing said that at no time
during this C1nngrsss had an there been any OBJ
pn hs Trs woaa
none now f9s the rsmainder 81 The s"sson
Ssfsson II 7 tho s1i %"iorty aesreI o's on
ity would meet it with the patriotic desire to
pass such legislation as may inure to the bene-
II ca Ehsf 1s% ns0Dks said that the Senate
presented was whafher, the Senate would: in
aside a privileged motion..tbe approval Of the
4s .ns 59svs xSst sgSa Ss
= :; +
ssy Srssyampsie1 that tho rfoseeainss q Ii the
NJ ,sns.os ysa and Of ,ss sand
on aSs oou eee
tien Of the Senator from RHODE island was sua- ie
| tained. the result was that rule OF the Senate
oea a0 ey the sy
preside ove. is deliberations, That rule stood
plain and eHpSss as the Inssh
ssSsaS seonsidsrsd until eisposod :' o. 'N '''o 'e
Ths made a He RoRs hs
said. did not ind any rule bearing on the aues.
oa The pfeeeeeanf ds9 and 81 Rss Rss
the motion Of ths he Senator from Rhode Island
IN d. 70 % b
minister the rules OF the Senate as he under
Mr.. Hsrri. appealed from the decision. but
the ruling was sustained-yens IS. nays go as
follows democrats in italics):
Ysss-Nsssra Aldrich. Allen. Blair. Carer Casey,
cuilom. Davis Dixon, Do!ph. Rdmunds. Evsr,a. Par
we'll Frye Hale Hawlsy. Higgins Hiseock. Eoar No
ConnelL Mcmillan. Henderson, Mitchell. Morrill,. Pad.
dock Platt Power. Sanders Sawyer. Sherman. shoup
spoouer stockbridss. Warren, washburu. wilson OF
Iowa-J5.
Nays-Nsssrs Barbour B1te Bern. Blackburn Carlisle
Coekreu Coke Evs Nuukner, G>oroe Gtbson. GornaH.
srav Hampton. Rdrrta Jone' tArkh Hfnna NePherson
Morgan Pasoo Favr4 Pxoh Ra,uona Reagan, Stewart
Teller Turpfs Vancr, WaifhoH wooott-so
Pairs were announced a. follows: Aessra Chandler
and Blodsett Pierce and Brown Cameron and Butler
Psstsrsw and Call Squire and Daniel. Dawes and Col
quits Allison and Ingalls, Stanford and Hearst Plumb
and Vest Moody aHi Voorhees, Quay and Wilson of
Maryland,
Mr.. oorman moved to lay Mr.: Aldrish.s mo;
Se9%sn sTSs1 ,asS e.d tfs H1a e. sf
.ssraR bs bs IN .stsa sssf that
dld not and Any sueh rule: and ,h 20 sn.er!aned
Tho Vice President thon directed tho Clerk
| 70 call tho roll on Mr.. Aldr!ch's motion; hut
Mr. Ransom interjected q point OF order. This
point WAS that as the journal OF the Senate nf
| the day before yesterday road. tho proposition
now submitted to the Senate and upon which
| tho vote was to DO taken, WAS adopted hy the
senate though morally sepa5o. to-. Kew that
the journal declaring thar on, on q" so1L ,d the
was decided in the affirmative.
Tho Woo President Overruled tho point, Rnd
Mr. German demanded that the Chnir should
state tho point OF order. At the Chars request
Mr. Rsnsom re..ta!sd his point; but but. thi. was
President then requested Mr.. Ransnm to put
bis roInt in writing which wns DONE and 1t
"Mr. Tsilar suggested that II tho journal OF
Tuesday was correct the rule wns now bolore
Senator from Khode Island wanted another
vote upnn this proposition.
the decision oe,l tho Chair was affirmed
The vies; ;IrssIsent then stated The question
demanded that y should be put In writing
Tha yotA WAS taken MIR, AIdrlCl6 motion