The sun., 1891-07-04
| esntlsmsn.- II was By his hand, by. his hand
alone that Carrie Brown was laid cold in death I
| You know Il eentiemsnl In your hearts yon

each morning. You have, heard the words,
salaa,m sl:ikonm with which M hs has sreetsd ,,
sSsir rulers and judges. So he says, 10 YOU.
seientionsy considering tn. lack Of evidence
against him. l entreat YOU 70 say unto him.
scdn ssr 3. hn d enssd Ss
Of Mr. Lovy. h,neor Bon All looked alter him
Mr. SioSii began S to % s"esk Ben XIt's complies xion
III, s,ssa
times he seemed to he asleep. But close
n his ss s sSss sTsd the Hoor ws
times he cast side glances at the Jury.
DISTRICT ATTORNEY NrcoLI's REPLY.
=, After tho three first sentences Of his speech
o
tated. He sprinkied sentences which should
rsa's and Tsh xSsssS M
ii iefysstly p and. 'f"F the most most part, Win
Attorney had his line OF argumen outlined on
many sheets Of paper. to which \ hs constantly ni
o s cas-. And at hs .Esn e ss sor
Variance with the stammerlns way in which
There were bright spots IN his address, how
ever. and In those he somewhat redeemed him
S sas M fs !s wss ns e
sES s%s SSs$ x. Si2S
lives q iss members yere ogde!ed and reach
the ysry slums s, Of .rs,n, New York; the low, Hh
ana Mohammsd born In, II a snys'ss '
tribe reared in as5ee greed BELIEVING
a was Of anS little s yaue Ii had srce sna ssosny
passions and insatiehle desires dexraded W
Hsf n . H fO aaa dHgn hcs to w iss
all its degrading surroundings. by desire for
white women and for ths gIp,a9tiilcatio.ns Q, hor-
ssrsal ca nSa pssn deny THIS apon the 10
ss s M hsa o% H pEeSS %Ssh
him how necessary It was to him to plead ig-
Of the
Now ,hi. DEFENDANT. having spent all the
money he had when he left Long Island. and
RsxTsS ahss se
hs1s nsh s 1 s ana
room Of some woman thus lot to- sleep: He
have nsrs t i9r thcf T1rpSse %
five cents a night for lodging. wac sought 2piy
BY men in the, company OF women. This
hour on the top floor OF the hotel was proved
by the testimony OF woman whom hen ne hed
aes 9 me
1! was established BY his own admissions
end By the nt OF 9se5 a saT ssn
t. contradict, this except in the address. Of Mlr.
as HIsf he had said : The eandle. burned down 70
within a short distance Of tho bottom proved
ess Wsat s was a.n he oG doing With his candIe shied
ing out. which was suspicious IN the light OF tho
%seds set S Ges eeck T6s the
Coroner found the woman's body stlll warm
l!eht, ard not about midnight Fitzgerald said
that he saw four or ave men come @ dSwn FNn stairs
alone about midnight and GO ost sa aceera %S.
to the custom Of the hotel.
As for the missing man who went up With
He was not the murderer. He had swiftly lett
Shakespeare after remaining with her awhile
from sH% ~ 81. room room and prowlins about the hall
found Shakespeare alone.
II. S.ore IN IL Wen
Stances Ir: House I had : s9 graphically de-
THE BLOOD STAINS.
OF tho lurymen leaned forward. They realize!
5 ss sna shs "a
be asleep but when Mr.; Nicoll slipped upon
name the Recorders voice was swift TO correct
MI. Nicoll said there was blood in room 81.
Re saa hs
ssq DgoTns .ass
Therefore Mr. Houses point fell 70 the ground:
But the experts had said that this blood was
sins' and G in this lay tie strength Of the
against the defendant. These experts did not
.s hnt 1. The osss ~
They swore that 1t was so positively and be- |
n
clover in field; And these experts wore the
The statements of science must be accepted as
evdeuge. and a.. trrefutable evihence. or all
aI Ike 70 ere1nd @ 'sf preo
was clear and not to be controverted. And 1t |
fastened the guilt upon the defendant SO that
The defrnce had said that Frenchy had made
no attempt TO escape and that this was Ia his !
did not always attempt to escare-never at
tempted 10 escape unless SUSPICION was sure
,ase "a so' Of fannug % Who murdered his wife short
time ago. and who meyer made the least en-
sayor 70 get sWay =, FrSnGhy ala no. realize
70 prove q motive. The State did not think
something n had Occurred in the room and the
Arab had stranglsd the woman and had then
hea as SaS sIown c"psSs
of BY his conduct in the eour. room. Il may
have been that the cent found on tho noor OF |
room 81 and Shakespsare's pocket turned
inside out pointed to part OF the motive. and
that the $l.75 IN Frenchy's pockets when he |
WAS arrested were taken from that pocket
It was not permissible to impeach in .
way the Testimony Of The people
from tho slums. II their testimony where
they were not Interested was not 70 be taken.
then all that was necessary in order to kill with
Impunity- WAS TO leave your victim to the
Witnesses were not to be believed. For that
panion not Frenchy rested upon the uncor:
roborated testimony OF the woman who opened
The door at the Fourth Ward Hotel. The tes-
.imony Of the other witnesses was corrob- !
Jrated by Frepchy himself. and by crcum-
stances which tue witnesses could not have
controlled.
RECORDER SMITHS CHARGE,
The Recorder asked the jury whether It pre-
erred to hear his charge before or after dinner.
The Jury asked how long it was 10 be. Tho
Recorder said he could not speak 30 fast as the
earned counsel. and had TO be more precise.
lie therefore wanted plenty OF time. 30 at $40
here was u reoess for dinner.
1t was g 80 o'clock when tho Jury filed back
nto the court room and settled themselves to
iear the charge. Frenchy did not forget his
Ialaam TO the Jury whom he watched with
'ager. nervous eyes. Then he sat down to
tYA.A r.,tAh