New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1890-05-18

"dhj 10 say, now, that accept anu an "IIihs l"
believe that have great confidence in the character
OF Mr. Campbell have in the character Of the gen
teman who makes this attack upon me- tEAcitemehe
and uproarJ
Mr.. Cutcheon demanded that the words be taken
down; while Mr.. Morgan, Of Mississippi stood In 'front.'
of the chairman's desk and appealed that both the
letter and the speech be stricken from The RECORD.
lie feared that they might lead to trouble outside oi
the House.
The offensive words were taken down and reported
from the clerks desk
Mr.. Cucheon moved that the committee rise ana
report the words to the House for its action lIlS
was agreed to-I2O to 90-and Mr. Bayne rose To
for tine motion he greeted with cering crlo'
Of Baync Eaync. Bayne,' from the Democratic SIDE.
The words having been reported 10 the House, MI
Brcchnrdge, Of Kentucky, made the point OF order
that there was nothing in the report Of the committee
to show mat there had been no intervening business
before their utterancc and the report 10 the House
The speaker Ovcrruled the point Of order on the
ground that he must be governed by the report made
To him by the chairman Oi the committee ana tnat Ho
must assume that the committee acted accoruihg 10
rules.
Nr. Brechnrdge appealed from the decision
ON motion Of Mr. etrube. Of Iowa, the appeal was
Of California, asked mat the rccapituation Of the
names be dispensed with, bat Mr.. Brcchnridse OBJ
Iected, suggesting that TIC members of the House
MIR. Cutchcon then offered the following:
Resolved That the member from Indiana. Mr.; Will
Committee of the Whole and taken down and re-
ported To- the House and read AT the clerks DESK laS
been guilty Of Il violation OF the rules ana privileges
of the House and merto the censuIc OF the House
for the same.
Resolved That the said william D. Bynum be now
brought Ia the har Of the House by the sergeant at
arms and there the censure Of the House be ad
mini,tcI'd hy the speaker
Nr. Cu;chcon demanded the previous question. amid
suggestions Of gag law from the Democratic side.
Mr.. springer made the point Of order that before
a resolution Of con>up could be adopted the speaker
must decide that the language Was supplementary.
Beside, this, 1t was the right of a member TO explain
his language before it wa, in order to offer a resolu-
ton Of ccn,urc. TN, resolution without precedent
Mr.. Cutchcon said that he had copied the resolution
from the last resolution of the kind presented in
the House. That resolution had been offered by Mr..
Herbert and lEY been directed AGAINST John Van
Noorhl,. Di New orh, In the XLYItn Congress. The
resolution hld not bee j acted upon because Mr..
Ian oorh, mad made iuI apology to the House
and tl, gentleman attacked. If the gentleman would
make t> ample and manly rctrtcuJn OF ms words, he
xr cut hcoul would withdraw his demand for the
Nr. r.. Bioant remarked that the language Of the
gentleman irom "" York had been without any
The speaker ovrrrulcd the point of order and Mr..
Grsobal.,.. Of Massachusetts, asacd uuannou, con.
sent That Mr.. lyman bee permitted 10 maa" an eN-
pianaton. but lir. Martin Of Indiana, objected.
Mr. springer made th" point oi order that the
language wa not uupail.amrutiIy.
Inc opcatcr over.ul,d the point, Mr. springer ap-
pcacd and the appeal va, tabled yeas l2l nays, 30.
yea. 81 nays. IL Mr.. Cutchcon then demanded
the yeas and nay, on his demand ior tle PIrNIou'
notion TO rrfcr the resolution to thc Committee
Rule, with certain instructions. me speaker ,lshot
u. Mr. springer, notion declared the yeas ana nay
ordered
had heart hi- motion. AID that he need not pretend
Mr ND,Ilm called attention To the fact that the
SSi,,ya. 5ss, sl' nay %" Tue previous ',.''' '' "
Tie speaker nlcrcup,n recognized Mr. springer. ho
Eal'-. with Institutions 10 inquire whether tse Lr',
.t.N.
umc had come !n 81 w of the nnsuage heretofore
used by tl" gentleman from indiana tat the lne
ceased ad violation = the ruIe Of te ion'e be;ta r
w lgnder,oa. OF ioMa. maae pom, oi ccH aTI W
against the motion ana the po,t beng '"'''''eu ''
rnc appeal va, tabled yc.'s III: uay7. =. =.
Tne motion - r,con,dcr was tabled yeas. l22
nav -. the speaker ,Ouuting quorum.
The previous question was ordered on the rG>o, ESQ,
yo,ci IN ne a7~nat.ycl moved to reconsider.
IN" speaker dc,I,ncd 10 recognize the notion ue'
rcn for a few moments thcrc wa, another scene
OBJ, confusion. Nr. Bland declaring tlat m" opcih'I
~ tl.',ul.i. up.u ihe ru., of th" Il0u-c. The con
fusion. however. was only temporary. Hlr 'u',Aooh
xxx IN u,r,rc,lt,,y u-a-, bv nAoin- "a direct and
,, T 'cl por The Gentleman from p,uu-, l,ana.
tl. Question was whether X Wa parliamentary i"i
',c member Substantially - dcnounce another aS a
,rv member could afford - -ay th1t u NtN
'f , Violation pf the rdlcs of thc House.
Mr. Vu,. Of T.,a~ said that The House seemed 20
hr q t"ru.u'l 2" supply WIN >I',, l', a. ....,.,
patience. lie 'oulG hoi >iN a.N'll"- VIM ~, ,'',,
deprive the majority ~ We lhh>tl', ID, t..,lllI
Nr. lynUm for pa "hcnce~. Whrn ne h'i o' '.' M
ihe Nft'ulcAl AM d"-pot, "fN'FN "' t-' y i.,' '
N,d triwrl'd on Ill lul'- OF pMIiahrn',f l'"'
TIE gentleman from Nl,li-ih. wn2 va, r'o'r r i, ii.
4fIr. Nu" Wa ilc rant bower ~ ic -'ull | -.
rcnu-yI'ann. Ad himself n,ul'cd tMo % OF & tnS pgH' .
N'l h INV ~. '.,,,',..u a. ,uicl,lN
that hc would believe 'an'pu'H a. Pu' Nv
20, hc would either one Of U'NT sci!..c
7i"n. The gentlemen from IcnnS' lVaii hiI SIN'u
ihc first offence. Not only that. lui Tor re
first time In the history ~ th' country and ne hopcd
th" la~t mcmlrr - re" lou" of Rcrr'~
81 made hn-rli 'lr lI.t. i1r & nI'II t iI " and ut
H., A. '7,, ,. r,.,r, and whom he encountered the
,i.- ,i.- W "iI , ,lr.,, iafrrcc ~ ,he gentleman hc
,"', 'r, H.. p,i.J liLr a baby Democratic ap-
,,l,r.,I ir NJ Nils had mo- hope on earth that
ihr majority would do ANYTHING except punish hllHH
i,,,,.. tl ,,. the only way it could pull il, beaten
,.,, ,,r, ti,r ,o,fe,t tpcuo.rl'i. applau>cl The
majority mad not forgotten that Nr luUr had char
.t.riIed thc action Il t' speaker IL dc,"rved 20
l,. characterized. and % was for tha that the gentle
man nom Michigan Wi- made the public prosecutor
i t,o mann, pf lc honor and dignity Of the House.
Democratic applau~r and Republican hieSc>l ,
from Nichican l'lr Cutch"on hai n,d "mSufiESe 10