New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1890-02-05
JUDGES AND LAWYERS DINE
THE CENTENNIAL BANQUET AT THE LENox
HILL LYCEUM

MORE THAN EIGHT HUNDRED MEN At THE
TABLEs-sPEEoHDs BY JAMES CARTER,
JUSTICE HARLAN, THE REV. DIR. HUNT.
INGToN, SETH Low, JOSEPH H.
| oHoATE, CHAUYCEY NJ.
| DEpEw AND OTHERS.
The Judicial Centennial banquet held last
| night in the Lcnox Lyceum under the auspices
| Of The New-Yorh State Bar Association, the Amer
| lean Bar Association, and the Association Of the
Bar of the City Of New-York, was one of the
| most brilliant and successful dinners ever given
| in New-York The attendance was immense
| More than 500 diners were seated at the tables
| and when the speech-making began the boxes
| lof sre big, beautiful finely decorated hall
| were filled with ladies and their escorts
! James C. Carter was the POSTMASTER
| At his right and left at the table of honor sat
| Seth Low, Mr. Semmes, Walter B. Hill, Mayor
| Grant, Chief Justice Paxson, Justice Brewer
Senator Evarts, Justice Lamar, Justice Gray,
Henry Hitchcock, ex-Justice Strong L. r. Coudert,
Justice Field Chief Justice Fuller. ex-President
| Cleveland, Mr. Hale, Justice Miller ex-Judge
| W. H. Arnoux, Justice Bradley, the Attorney
| General Justice Harlan, Justice Blatchford,
Joseph II. Choate, the Rev. DR.. Huntington.
| Chauncey NJ. Depew. and w. A. Butler.
| Among the others present were:
John Larkn C. n. Bovee, IT., Noah c. Rogers Donald
n. Toucey Robert S. Minturn F. Kngsbury Curtis Allan
| McCuloh j. Arthur Barrutt. Howard A. Taylor i. L.
Deaneld W. d. Bristow Julien d. shope, T. S. Bangs
| David r. Butcher John w. Houston, Ernes: l.. Short
| Jabish Holmes jr, w. V. II. Berry, j. A. Hodge, r.
Howard Townsend John j. Chapman, Sherman S. Rogers
g. I. Quinby, Thomas S. Lewis, L. II. Benn, w. T. Put
n nanla
porsett T. S. ormiston, Ernest Hail. f. S. Hatch, II. NJ
North j. w. b. Bausman, A. j. Kaufman, John NJ Serb
| ner Judge Potter, w. H. Peckham Judge N. shipmsn,
L. woodford, David Mason, A. H. Van cott j. NJ.
Van Co.t s. d. Chittenden, Judge Wales, Osborn f.
Bright Governor Davis, George NJ. Diven
A. p. Ketchum Frederick Cromwell, Thomas g. shearman
| William Irwin Thomas Ewing, Arthur Berry, T.. w.
Sheldon, Treadweu Cleveland. G.. b. Alexander, Judge
| Grubb J. NJ Bowers, Judge Williams. II. L. Rowland
Judge H. Green C. A. Dawson, Judge Butler, Charles b.
| Hubbell Irving Brown, II. II. Anderson Judge Einch
William S. Opdybe, Enos s. Taft James s. Stearns f. B.
Jennings E. E. Bayss +. II. Plat, William G.. Davies
| James NJ Field, o. s. Strauss, s. b. Eikins H. w.
BENTLEY Jonathan Marshall Duncan Smith, A. V. Bresen
r. d. Hatch, Judge Houston, G.. q. De Witt IT, Judge
| Mitchell w. n. Cromwell. Judge Clark, Noah Davis
Judge stcrrett, Augustus C. Brown Judge Vann Judge
| Benedict Charles Steele Asa W. Tenney, O. H. Brush,
| Louis Adler, William II. Cohen, E. NJ. Johnson, c. NJ
Marsh Eugene NJ Philbin, r. A. PamenteF, Esek Cowen
A. L. Edwards e. +. De Lancey, W. E. Curtis, Hamilton
ode James Sherman Waldo Hutchins. John WI stewart
| A. p Fitch Judge Hughes Macgrane Coke, Judge BOND,
e. H. Butler william b. Crosby E. S. Rapallo, w. H. L.
| Lee W. D. Guthrie J. Murray Mitchell, W. Morton
Grinnel j. G. shipman, Haley Fiske s. H. Grey. h. o.
| Doardman W. X. Wilson, +. j. Duplgnae, j. H. BISHOP
| A. H. Hsmmersey g. IL. Sullivan. H. s.. Westorook'
d. L. stoyer Everett Smith, w. e.. LathrOp, jr IT, r.
Roesch T. Richardson, William NJ. WINS, Charles Nc
Louth c. T. Libby. Charles T. Bell, j. F. Colby j. NJ
Marshall E. S. Miller. NJ. D. Follett, Lawrence MaAwei
IT,. August Van wyok Elbridge T. Gerry, Judge Allen
Charles COudcrt Peter B. oney, Judge j. f. Daly Judge
Freedman Austin q. Fox, j. II. " Arnold, Judge Norton
Recorder Smyth Charles L. Tracy, Charles E Lydecke
Judge Tlnghast Judge Weldon, g. w. Van Syck, VIII
lam JAY Judge stness, C. j. Richardson, Wager swayne
Horace Russell Judge Peckham Judge Wheeler ex-oy'
ernor Green, c. @. Besman, Chancellor McGill, c. j.
Lewis Francis Lynde Stetson, De Lancey Nicol' H. H.
| Morris Henry Hitchcock. IT.. T.. y. Hyde, e. W. van
Nest J. V. v. olcott. c. H. Woodruff f. W. CoFgeshsu
| S. C. I. Dodd. H. f. Stevens. James Hagerman G. t.
| Rushmore j. G. Gown. j, II. Cook. Alexander Grant
IT,. Russell Benedict, Paul Fuller, John T. Mason j.
| Frank Fort. A. p Thom c. A. Flammer, Leigh Robinson
| George Hill. Judge Booksaver. Edward Lauterbach
Judge Ingraham, exJudge g. p HAYES, Judge o'dorman
Judge Lurton Judge Bartlett, Martin W. Cooke, Edward
Mitchell G.. p. Lowrey, Judge Hailett, Judge Fenner
| John +. Parsons. G.. S. Hubbard, Judge C. Andrews
| Judge II. b. Brown, f. II. Belts, o. M
Da Costa C. J. Ruger, Joseph Larocque,
Thomas l.. ogden, r. g. Munroe L. L. Van Allen f. Der
Foster q. NJ. Pinney, jr s. c. Shuitin Franklin Bien
]. a. Cantor. II. \. Gumhleton. Leslie W. Russell W.
Larremoe, Professor Dwight Fred Potter, Judge Daniels
Judge Thayer Judge Jenkins William Mitchell, Judge
| Webb. Thomas II. Hubbard Charles J. Andrews General
Daniel f. sickes Nelson Smith, John d. Townsend e. T.
| Davidson. w b. Davenport Jefferson Clarke II. f.
Roosevelt c. H. Roosevelt Carlisle NorN ood Judge lsro
j. +. Miller Judge Truax. Judge Darorth j. s. Fassett
APPORTIONMENT OF THE BONES.
Mrs Grover Cleveland, in an exceedingly pretty
| gown, sat in one of the boxes. Some of the
| boxes were sold others were reserved by the
| State Bar Association and the chairman of the
Centennial Committee. The apportionment was
as follows:
J. Carter Hughes Cravath ?. reserved by State Bar
Association Thomas IL. Hubbard L. reserved by State
Bar Association g. Preston Stevenson 6. reserved by
State Bar Association Sullivan Cromwel g. reserved
by State Association o. Ellhu Root; 10. w. n. Co.
hen IL, Samuel Unermyeri ~, James b. btearns H. eN
Judge Henry Hilton; a. Orlando B. Potter; - and II.
f. f. Shepard 16, Chief Judge Il. l.. Larromore; 1S
James F. Dillon 10 to 20, reserved for distribution BY
chairman OF Centennial Committee 20 Herbert f. Dick
son 2s Banquet Committed 90, Macgrave Coke ;
30 NJ. 4. c. Levy; 81, j. j. McCook; 30, j. Thacker
49, r. WAYNE Parker; 81, H. Coffin, IT,. 3d. w. G. Whit
ney; SO, William Allen Butler; 81, H. j. Dawson, r.
s. Clifford a. Hand; 80, q. g. Mercer; 49, Stern
Myers; H. Everett z. Wheeler; A. Francis L. stetson
49, Samuel A. Dutchford a, Austin G. Fox; 10. W. s.
Opydyke; 40. W. Il. lIonblower; 81. A. V. W. van
Yechten 49, Charles Henry Butler 40 Joseph Larocque
So Joseph H. Chtate: 81. II. V. Arnold; 52' Julien L.
Davies SO. II. c. Backus 81 w. c. Tlrl; A. ana C.
| reserved b. charman OF Centennial Committee
The menu was arranged in artistic and APP
propriate form. 1t consisted of cards bound with
pale blue ribbon. AS fr0ntlspiece, theTe were
pictures of John JAY of New-YorlS, the first Chief
Justice of the United States, and of Melville w.
Fuller the latest There was also picture of the
Royal Exchange, New-York in 1900. and of the
seal of the Supreme Court of the United States.
On an inner page were excellent photographs
of the present Associate Justices of the Supreme
Court The dishes at the dinner were learnedly
called the arguments appeal, submitted pur
suant to the twentieth rule" and after coffee
and cigars came the ruling Remanded to inferior
court to supply TRANSACTIONS under the eleventh
| rule. 49,
The other pages of the menu pamphlet were filled
with the toastlSt, lists of the Chief Justices and
Associate Justices of the Supreme Court of the
United States from its constitution and the names
OF the Judiciary Centennial Committeeman.
The POSTMASTER james G. Carter, was received