The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1890-05-16
D1sCoRD orr THE DIAMOND.
The Philadelphia brotherhood club E4pc-
rIencea Bitter Row.

| IiOnI TIE IaNddsiph,d TIMES.
There is serious trouble in tho Philadcl-
! phia brotherhood Club which may load TO It's
! complete reorganization. Tho great fielder;
| James FoEarty. has resigned us captain ana
"I gniS 3r 6S 1iSS y Win III 6o S e%
on Tuesday. nor did he 20 to New York yester-
| day. ..,,..-,.....,,,
| not play again with tho Brotherhood club OF
this city. lie certainly will not unless tcrp Is
n change in tho direction ns at present constl-
| iuted although a throo years contract EXISTS,
Even tho Bond OF Directors are not al OF QUO
mind, and tho feeling between tlirin Ll13 , US
his wi llngnoss to dispose oil his large hoIuinEs
oi stock. ~ ..,.,
state OF ailuirs happened on last Monday ono
week ago. Tho rlnyers had SRthSrII IN snG
dressing room IN ,9I me- mem ,bot G osarty lad
been III AIDE captain and manager, ana al hah,ls
wero appurcn'ly. we'll sntiiind. loEhtty. uesirii
Ing. as lis friends say, TO hhNo his position hud
duties well defined. said; ,....-
MIR Love II ain to be captain and manager
Of this nino, desire it should hc understood
that there must lie no interference by tho o!il-
CorS with tho players. ,,i i
President Love would not c93nlcodo hIS nm, anf
announced: AS President OF this Cilib want
it to be understood that will interfere "hor-
ever | rlcnso."
troll"
the lrosdont OF tho club and ! viii do WHAT
The captain still contondcG: " You know, Mr..
Love. that managers and captains arc never
interfered with BY tho other officers
Pres ident Love reiterated us STAND IN lot
s sG9 3HnSs hn 2f% Uv SAID s STo
thing sharper, and one word lei 20 nn2ntheF'
until finally tho CAPTAIN requested Tho fresl-
dent to leave tho dressing room ,-
That made President Love ''Ehtng maj.
Going oyerto Where the CAPTAIN stool nos
III want YOU to know that am, your equal
intellectually, morally, or physically.
The captain kent his temper. Dlt tIe lreSl-
dent did not. Turning 20 the payers 10 ue-
-; Boys. this is, all right. Before two weeks
this nj man went he captain or manager ana
With this remark tho President left tho
dressing room.
Fogarty brought charges against the President
of conduct unbecomng an officer and u gentle
man. The main charge made was that me
language used before the mon was preludicial
to good discipline and harmony. Capt, togarty
thought that an 4n9loGy was due 70 nm shd ana
come from the captain. Neither would give in.
and committee on Investigation was ap-
While tho committee was at work Manager
and CAPTAIN Fogarty after constitution with
his friends decided to resign from poth posi-
tons. as matters were UNPLEASANT nj around
He has boon succeeded by Pitcher Butlinton
as manager and First BQseman farrar rs
play with the club. as il is claimed he has
been badly treated. enc o. ne stockmoiders
Is ready TO sell out unless inc ulShgrcelEent ~
settled and 1t il helieyed 1t can pe determined
only by a reorganization which shall include
the retirement OF President Love.
PHILADELPHIA, May l5-Presidcnt Harry NJ.
Love and the other officers OF the Philadelphia
Players League Club were thoroughly dis
gusted set of men to-day, and some very forci-
bic Gonials were made OF the reported disrur-
ton between Jimmy Fogarty and the club. Mr..
Love said: No such conversation ever took
place between FOgarty and myself, and Will
give 800 to charity II any one can prove any
thing to the contrary. fOEarty was not re-
never meddled with the manager of our club or
tho nlaye rs and only nave been in the dressing
room on two occasions when the players were |
present. Bui1inton Inns been placed IN soie !
pointed shannon 10 captain the nine. am not /
at liberty to say why FOgarty resigned. or why /
he Is not playing on the team. AS l said be- |
tore. Manager Buillnton is responsible for |
togarty's actions now.
Manager Bufiinton was equally non commit
tai when questioned us to the cause OF the |
troubles. He, said: There arc many who |
know moro about this affair than | do, but |
what do know l intend to keen 10 myself. |
will come out all right. and Foghrty |
will be back with US before long What else |
can he dor
The concluding question of tho managers |
could have been answered much easier than |
he probably anticipated. as there were some |
very healthy rumorS current among togartyS |
political associates ut Tho Union ReruDlican
Club to night, the septiment ot:which was that |
Jimmy was anxious 10 dispose of his interest |
in the team and transfer his services to !
point where the financial responsibility rested |
On other shoulders than his own. 1t is also TO |
be deducted from Builingtons remarks that |
le Is official ly aware. or has some lntimation |
II the TACT that Fogarty at present is doubt !
III member of the team. The great fielder was
lot to he found at his accustomed haunts to-
hight. and 1t was learned that he had gone 10
Brooklyn to attend the races.