New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1890-10-10

decided that the Commissioners werc not bound by
c'G rules, ana n t'c anpll'ant Was proper per'
Dr.. Crosby haven't seen any such decision, ar
Mr. EiOwne-Tach your cAdinindu0n WAS hot GA
hal>tcd the legal question.
DR.. CrO,Dy-l am not lawyer.
Mr.. browneI!ut YOU have gwen great deai OF
attention 10 this matter IN lis legal, &c well d. III 10
Dr. trosby-As far AS my untuored mind could go.
VI. ErowncCan you instance a case Where , the
Dr. Crosby-I have mol accused them OF it, .,..
Mr.; B"wnc--lIave you not inslnna'ed ''"' ''eS
senator Ea>,ct-I think the testimony OF the com
missioicrs ticm,evcw perfectly clear on thar poi;
sides il the ioard could DC lifted o'.l o: politics.
Mr.. browne to the witac>si-Could any aNhni,su",
ton bc conducted without liiirs under oar FORM vi
CroDyroc, has two meaning n , Ine eve aIH
good polite, and bad politics. HoOu P'A''' WY
Dody ough, to t,hc part Iii 49,, o., roi,ciar
Q.-Wnat is the meaning OF me woru P Win The
A man who attends to affairs connected VIII" INC
OFF commissioners were appointed or eSc'e %ud ir
the purpose Of administering The Exri,r Law w,,
Whatever form. they would s be politicians would
thcy not Ain ,hc good SENSE 1890. .,,,,rs t-,clv
DIN any sense. Ain the bad sense ii'aiS &
Mr. ErJwnc-lou cannot accuse an adinni, a h
until you fnud something ata,r ": noI.tic IN
not given single instance To-Day o' r'"' p'''' "
Dr. crosby somcincr Sn .ah an ev'' w"c"
CI Won think This committee has found an emu
via Of bad politics no, in n. ,n a sa%h.r'''0"
the ''nva hst no" im,, tnS SRI Where did sprns
from A.-Ihere is general feeling 'nr'"S"'"' '"0
''S On woHa y"u condemn man on senrra, n rrn
cIes tia, he " %sd not ,. nS ' men, auh'sr
"G s,uaor ras,rt-I uidcr-tsnd yoHr j.d!ncn; to ~
thu, The 'rou'le with the present '''''o" j '''"
ad"n' WI n 10" b. possible - devise system Of ;li
Ts,r"ved hv ,qd adnini>ir,tion' A. ihint bad n
nIlni,tiY,lio coad be prevented hy n~ W.T." ,''m
GENTLY specific rules Of entoi'e mei''' cpc'N " II
gag 70 H. the last analy>i, IT comes to ti, that
good government IN The eNcl'' apartment ~ WI %
n IN OTHER departments, is primarily rne''"" OF S'''
n,,cnn, ': and "tlrccr Aic>. and thin. 'hc laws
'old lie framed IN uci way a. T." ' ,hs ' isw n
m".ad h, tn" cnminitc" appointed 10y the ""Verhul.
ia a law em,cnilI fitted 10 meet thc ch>r> ~
faired to. and 30 make the excise > s'e'"
TO sun up, ;you substantially recommend the
~ v.dil,d or original A.-rhe original
When cx Judge Browne asked him about penal
cs the witness declared empha'i'Il!y - w"n"' h""
second offence send "a man where his hal: would hc
shaved and striped breaches put on HIM tla"fh'Tf'
H.; added that h. would he perfectly Will'e 10 give II"
c,cis. offender one chance with Il small hne.
senator McNauthton asked him what had become o'
In. >,lon bill lie said il altered III com
,;t,cc in two three important points ana Nc'"" y"
m. ,,ovcr,or Though tho witne cld hot agree VIII"
fine car ec tia, had hecn made III II. h" a1r''en 't
tn,,e was ground for difference OF opinion III reer'
10 them. For El$ part. nc "i'NV" w 49,
nlcnd-,l the original bHl. Ilo"c>r'' nc '"''' ~
would have been good
Then Accountant Tate who plays ProocI" I" all me
committees INvcst-ationS. armed win i"n''oAI'
array, nf figures and tables. took the witness 'f'h
ard ave the result, of his sear hes and SIMS IN III"
County Clerks "ni'c
,c had prepared the following comparative state
,, 81 ola, fa.s r,.ey.d al tie uNcc from January l.
i--u it be- lu,c >aia""d oi :. Ia !I"u 1;,Tt L.
800 and Of expenditures FIR salaries, etc. curing
same Nci->