Telegram-herald., 1890-03-27
A DUAL CAREER.
4 Daylight Saint and Midnight
sinner Unmaak01
4 JERaI DR.. IEEYIL AND Mr.. HYDE
A FoF0l@r Citissa 81 Menteikir. -. ,.
eapght Ia the Aes 81 Eabbies NoiEh-
ser- ~ f'rexrs ~ Have bees ths
AatkoT ~ Many h0Exlarlsk

cltizens 81 this loWn has been Jsmss
futhill, boss mason he eame here
from Port JARVIS aEe years sgo lie
married and went 10 live IL : Oszy homs
o. bloomfield avenue Hls vile
joiRsd the Monlolair Congregational
Charch snd won the respecs snd
estsea 81 the neiFb6oga Tut
blll became very popular Mia
his fellow -towasmen de joined several
soolsl clubs. and every one Nbo knew
hiU liked him He never drank uor
swore was ever ready 20 help any one
IN need md counted his friends by ths
score. Many of uhs residents q Mont
clair are n.en ~ wealth, dong business
IN New York IsthAl ald NORA Tor
them al GGs MA gecslysa % friendly
terms IA tAeig hemes.
To-Day he Is d prisoner in the Ray
mond-street 5all, Brooklyn. his hand
some wife - locked Up st Newark The
eminently respectable Mr.. Iutbnl Aas
been found out 70 be tie reckless bcr-
glar who FOR The last few years lss leon
r0bb.ng TIE homes q lie wealthy iu
Aontelair, Glen Ridge, Bloomfield,
Orange aud surrounding towps, and bis
vile is suspected OF being hls accom-
plioe.
a week ago last Monday night the
residence OF George Booth. a personal
friend of IuihllL VAS entered 10y
burglar ME Robertson was Mr
Booths guest that night A Tie
village clock was telIlng IL be Was
aroused by his bedroom window being
opened and slim built man nREuy
Jumped into the room from the VerandA.
Mr.. Robertson watched him and ssw
him coolly strike 4 match On the Wall
and look about Then he deit-
ly abstracted Mr.. Roberssons gold watch
from his vest and the match went out
The thief was striking another match
when Nh. Robertson Jumped out oi bed
and grsppled with hin. The cold muz-
zle Of pistol made him let 40 quickly.
and g. be fell back on the bed the burg
lar laughed sarcsstically and swung
himself out OF the window and got away.
Mr. Robertson awoko the house bold
While he was telling his experience the
burglar was less than a block away get
ting into the residence Of John Manuel,
another warm friend Of the good Mr..
Tuthill.
Manuel was aroused by the burglar
getting into his room and gave battle
on the piazza The thiefs mask came
OF in the struggle and Mr.. Manuel
could hardly believe his senses, for the
face he recognized was that Of Lis
friend, the village favorite, jim Tut
hill.
Thursday night in the presence Of
some friends, Manuel said: 81 am sure
the man who robbed NE was Jim
Tuthill, but I'm not sure enough 70
swear it." lie was scofied a. but held
doggedly 70 his opinion. At last IL as
determined 10 give Mr.. Robertson. who
did not know 1uthlll, 3 chance 20 see Il
he could identity him. Robertson
pointed out Tuthill, from among a body
OF men, a. the thief who bad stolen his
watch, and warrant was procured FOR
the searching OF Tuthills residence. In
the cellar was found secreted rings.
watches diamonds. pocke t-books. money.
bracelets, breast-pins, earrings, watch
chains and every kind OF lewelry, repre-
senting many thousands of dollars and
some Of which was stolen years ago.
The burglar had meanwhile jumped
on his horse and ridden furiously 20
Bloomfield, where be took an express
train TO Hoboken. he was traced 20
Brooklyn. was arrested and locked Up.
Tuthill strenuously denied bis guilt
and claimed that IL be were really
guilty be was not responsible, ss be bad
no recollection Of ever robbing any one.
His former friends now believe that be
Is the captain Of robber band and thai
his pretty wife IS bis trusted lieuten-
ant She was arrested Monday morn
ing al ber home ard srraignee and COM
mittcd 70 jail at Newark It Is sad
that she has made full confession