, 1890-01-23

great npplnusc.
The pfinoinnl n,gup,onts o,,i,,st ,ho
bill were Identical win ibosn .ct forth
In the Judiciary cnmmii,oo's reror,
The friends or tho biIl con,cnd TIM,
now was the limo IN res,r,ct cornorn.
,i,,s nr,i,r,.,. - -, Ii =,
hound. "''' N''f '"o' "''''''
"V''"s'
senator ktnnear did not receive many
compliments on his bill, which Nlessrs.
Clark, plummer and other members dc.
douncod ne thc vort ot Lon,o ,,o,,,,e
Nr ,'I,.,, -, -. ~. =, 49,
~ S'"'N w. ni"uh Us snIo N'At " was
VT, hihnears bid for the govcrnorship
OF Washington. Mr.. kinnear was can
didate before tho Walla Walla conyen.
ton agllnst Governor Ferry last fall,
and .iiIl h,s ,,,,Iarno,o.ioi a =, ;,,s
It,a T., - ,'',, h's' ,'a.o''i vi Il"
"""'' haNo P"Nse" Nv o"e
uUhe, hs IrI'hua were IN hooI 10 hc-
cept 1t without tho provision proh ihiiing
the regulation of Transportation. IL was
strikeu out and rein,erted and that set.
tlod ,ho nm No,srs Eys,, HERE,
All ,,i,s. ~, 49, ,nt. @ 80 - 49,
'''" ''.'',, u'',v,n hp'u '''' '",s Plo''ho.' ""e
""'ons'illNohhl' IN t1'at " atteihpted 70
regulate interstate traffic, IL was con
coded that Mr.. McResyy's amendment.
striking ont tho ctrtnsnortnti,n proyi,ion.
de.irn,,oI ,ha ono,, az a.. Liu
~. ,ue 80. y, '''o o,'n -.
'" NsSN' py 'nv 'oi"s"i w 'ns
the judiciary committees report on the
table, or to adopt IT, While Mr.. Eddy
was talking, MIR. Plummer interrupted
him, and called his attention to- the fact
that the words "monopolics and trusts
shall never be allowed" contained in
section % of article II Of the Constitu.
tion, were omitted In the bill
"And for that reason YOU would kill
the bill2" asked MIR. Eddy.
For that reason would kill tn bill 4"
answered Mr.. Plumnier'
"Umph," was Mr.. Eddys laconic re-
tort.
Mr.. Herren snid that he was Mt first
inclined TO oppose the hill, but, If its bad
features were removed he Thought n
wholesome law could bo made ofit. lie
did not think IL his duty TO siii,port "A
bill drawn in accordance with the pro-
visions of the constitution which was in.
furious to the public He did uur think
the constitution contemplated destroy
ing the business of the country by inter
iering with corporations.
81 want TO ask tho gentleman II he
took the oath TO suppor. the constitu-
ton, or half of it?" said Mr.. Moultray
Before MIR. Herren could an swer tile
chair raped MIR. Mouitray TO or,ier. and
Mr.. Horren resumed his talk. lie held
that the bill rendered unlawful many in.
nocent contracts in any way king the
price of anything.
MIR. Plummer held that the lumber
trust of Puget sound. yhile II had repu
lated prices and systematized matters
had advanced the price OF logs and had
not raised the price of lumber. He said
that no trust could keep prices beyond a
living price, for as soon as the values
went up competition followed,
Mr.. Moultray charged that tine ene-
mics OF the bill were loading the bill
down with amendments to KILT.
Mr.. Ostrnnder moved to reconsider the
vote by which the words cor rcgtllatinp
the TRANSFORMATION" were stricken iroin
the bill. ii was carried by a vote of Al
to 90
The motion to strike the words out
was then lost.
Mr.. Judson. of Pierce. made n motion
to strike out section I which exempts
farm products and live stock In tLo
hands of the producer. and laborers and
artisans from the proyisions of Inc Lii
II was defeated by the folloyinl. vote
Ayes fG, noes "A.
Mr.. Ostrander's motion to add ''pro-
vided 1t IL not Injurious TO the public
to section 7 was defeated BY Vote of
ayes 81 to noes 80.
Mr. Evans then moved to strike out
that part OF section which proyidcs
that "a preponderance of evidence I'm
favor of the state shall he sufticient to
authorize yerrlirt and iudpment for tho
state. The motion was Voted down
Mr. Kandle offered an amendment to
section /, proyiling that ihe nct snail
not prevent Tire Insurance compani"s
from combining To fx rates. IL was
M