Morning journal and courier. [volume] (New Haven [Conn.]) 1848-1894, 1890-01-20


1900 -
0fN
9Th
GS
!. .,. 49, ..,.,. 90 "a. -,
:. .....s5.a tI.r. tts,1 i,s,.st.5 o,osslv .
- q. 80 sr .a. 10y ~. - ,,c;,s &,
.,ro5,..,;.v - saprsst;o, srar .aprp,a, ~
Mutn' Anoil ..As WoIS !y.ueS ~ .oI
otnsI you1g p.Itssas VI snss ulsappoln'eu
!s.ues snu We tt nse 'noii 0oDnoo elioi'S ~
Ing psoseus Sts. -
,,,ao;arism that a siandsr move f.Isa and
xrn.Hcior. he. raver hasr -r.S. sneir.t .
,can - sc,anca "s-
Whsn nrsn.r.d INV vo,rm. a., Tho r,aon.
to,n;ths. i ma two sS,a ..sistsrts ~ Iato
C I -. ~ 49, ,GI IL
D De a1sos az. S.S oGol.e D M. III FL
.",5..a5 ;.e ~ IA q. ,se.;r sa...,s
.ol I ;ns NJ M III - 0o.e oa. .o .s
%or d.sn,,,,,;on .od s,,,,ar,is;n,. az worL
~ ths srt;sts vho ii1n.t,stad thar, Thav
ala mnch more than this nnder INV immedi-
ate direction. and am indebted to chem for
many valnabia sncoeesions hath 40 to the
anatomical noints involved and the af;nities
of The .ncisnt form. invsst;cated
Ths Man IF H. vo,nres q, SJorto~r;th.s
10. a,,t;-ai, ~ 60 snS . W Jo..;i =, ;ts
preparation was performed by myself or d.
rr.c,ed Nv nc The eyact ,rathod Nv which
Iec.eo Dy me. lug eAacs Metnoo py wniG .
even notes ana measurements or the epecl-
mems should be made was marked out by me
in a orinted circnlar which has s;nce heen
nsed nv svsrv assistant in the musenm who
has made even rough notes or measurements
Tor my use.
oeslIes .nese SERVICES, when "eIe Mslny
oseficai, uIctateo 10 tnem DOH, az uiHeienI
times, neariy every page OF inc volume. l
olc'a'su 70 M. H..nlel, cr w.o,e VIII ny
own nano, tne IntroGuotion anu nrss anu n
s so cnsPtStsi asv cnapteis :, Q, - ~;
e. ~ anu .n1 ooncluolu. cnaps1ls, ~ 1nu
~, ana 70 tnis ne can testiIy, as ms extensive
knowledge OF recent nlrds MADE MN tsmilar
WIN al tne man oo1ails VI tns uescriPtious
thus prepared and with the relations OF the
living aud extinct forms compared In the
CONCENTRATIONS.
Professor Marsh a. this point pays h1gn
tribute 70 Mr; harger ana spoke OF the que
iecogniuon gwen tne Is'seE services IN the
P,eiace OF tne WORK, ana Mr. nafeers com-
piete sat,staotion tnefewitn. ne also Puo-
lsnes letter from george BIRD drlnnell re-
ceived since the present attack upon Professor
Marsh was made. Mr.. Grinnell was ever
satisfied with the credit given him by Pro-
fessor Marsh and was very indignant over
the attacks upon Professor Marsh, and In his
letter said:
"You dictated to me as your assistant part Of
the description and aii your conclusions Of your
rrn VIZ ne ttr,a thas y, ..s;sisr, IN oetsoioov
in The Psshodv Museum of Vale Coiiees Won dictst
ed to me number Of other papers, and IL was well
snown that you also dictated papers TO others OF
No No one else had spythine to do with writing
this volume and Al! statements to the contrary are
MY next large volume was on the Dinoce-
rata, anc OF this memoir fortunately retain
me orlgna. manuscriPs ano s.i' OF nss!.y al
OF tne hotes ITO" wnicn ~ was uAot0sco.
These are open to inspection OF any honsst
man who is iuclined to believe any of the
charges that am not its author, IN whole
and In par, or have withheld from any OF my
81. "a H., ~. rrsraration
Mr.. Harrsr was still nv assistant when
the volume was Published, and had done
what he could to aid me. During its whole
ertion was an ever present danger and con-
tinuous work an impossibility He did all
he could faithfully and without complaint,
and the almost entire supervision of the IL
,HN. ~ s.--...S r Ia. e..
nortant notes on the limbs and fesr and
Valuable advice in regard to that part of the
volume were the main assistance he rendered
me. except the clerical work of measure
ments. which in most of nv later publica-
lions had been intrusted to him.
DR.. Baur and DR.. Schlossler were likewise
my assistants during the printing of the vol
ume. and for what assistance they gave me
I endsavored to return them full credit in
my preface.
Or. Williston was with me at the time and
began the preparation of the photography,
which was finished by other hands. BE Also
acted az nv smanuensis for O while, and I
have given MIN due credit for all his work,
as he himself testifies in the letter, of which
this il COPY:
Professor O. G. Marsh:
Dear sir-I have not authorised Professor Cope
sny ONE, 70 aTe ag n On your
your published scientific work you have treated
Mr. Harser and myself with entire fairness I
profe.sor Oona cbaross tina. aaoroa Ran,
d,ctsted all The osnera1izations Of nv vol.
o - T.Sss. -os..J
umo ol x zig c ~ p s..s ms.e1 s.ate'
W enS A Ion 1oon ~. 40" .o,.oa aso 81
Oonn', JANUARY Ao' Aooo' 'niS eon'enoo W
cuts'
hereby certify that dia rot dictate any OF the
-. s,-.h.- s....r,.rt. ,r vr,,,,.eror,
hin, covsr;no othsr nnints
P.osss.or Msr.h than Vail. into prof..so,
cors ssv;ro. 'o'
X p:nfae.o- cor.,. ro;as On ,,r,vst. col
,.ot;ons lii oiva onIv = s,rris ;ilr.tr..
Il -, II a 1..ts, - -. a.taI 1.a5anead
1on. a0 1910 n D-as, o"s9% eaa -:.
SM Ny "O' Ao'o' H'oA'''o' oope "i'es az
s"nd NON Arm. avail sroo;uan. ~.
;.J go 80 v su0 =. ha,,;n" Sa.e .h..as
sd from one of vonr hores a. con,ss ths1
az. vonr, '
TS,s wa. thu frat ;pt;mat;ou had If III.
that, and vss At fr.t inclined ~ hs,,sv.
| tnat or;,tv oorsc,sncs h.d nav az o,,,
| ~ sy 3 a. 800 -s.I
| nccusol' Dus zig .osel. Io.u.nou we1e VI
nttie vaiue, wniIe tnose l ioss IN THIS transac
uon were lmPor!ant.
" the many otner oepfedsuons OF rroies
sor OoPe ou "e Anu my MolA lave no liM'
now 20 speax, .noag" ! na ss ausnen u, ooSu
men.s .o.su.k w ~ VI snou' cugu,u
s.eMp' h. al . sus ~. Soa sas. ns.
VI I'LL, t. -, ~ rm.,aoaa.. "ro,iS ~ .'.a;,
| " NV 0o"'
tn9 n..l tnetoD..
rroisseor Msrsn Inen Proceeus 70 snov
tnas ms VOL on t1s 9enesiosy OF tne nois
eAo,a.y sna ens..oy ~. WIZ -
ms conciu ,o wol1 oAssa On sp sn sm ~
a,e a '. &c. h1 ~. . nM, n H. .un w.
Sssor. p,os..sor Hn,,sv shaw h ,;sit.,
p ps. M.rsh a. NJ. Hsv.r ~ Iare
procs.Ssro Pros...or Hsr.b .sy.. p,os.s.o
Hn~ss~ ;rforrasd nv thst ,h,s M. al M =
IL, 90 .S.t ~ t.a.. da.,"n..s.t.S ~
l ,..s nu s ~ - $500 o....:S -
svo,uI"n =. sno no!se uoy" . 4uoss.ou, sn'
ioI zig ntss .ne .LuSsseu sle u,ieos ,ue ~
oescens VI ~ oAns sI. WIN n -,