New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1890-12-11
THE STARTER DISCHARGED.
LAST ROUND OF THE KELLYCALDWELL
SCRAP"
THE PLAINTIFF FAILS TO MAKE OUT CASE
.v~ocEnovxs1 on BOTH SIDES.

~KNoCKDowNs7 OF BOTH SIDES.
The last round in the Kelly caldwell set 90 was
fought in the jefferson Market Ponce court Nc''caS
Justice O'Rcy acted as referee heiS was sc'ohdeG
bv cx senator Thomas +. Grady OF the silver tongue
while for Caldwell a like Office was performed ay
| Abe IIumme Of the great head. Inc 90 lasted
an borr and A half and after dozen knochd0wn~ on
hon sides Kelly was put 70 sleep by swinging right
handler
When time was called Kelly Jet hy with his left.
landing on CaIdwcll's check with WITNESS OF the
name Of Robert II. Andrews. an cN-buder ami
mason who spends his afternoons at "u'ehpefE ana
Clifton irving TO beat the jobs put mp there Andrews
testified that he witnessed the alteration at ihc ~
ra,ncs Hotel on the night # November Il. ana saw
CaIdwoI kick Kelly once or twice. he DIDN'T exactly
remember Which, around the legs Of Jolh Kelly VINO
stood between the two gladiatoT'' nc heard helN
charge Caldwell with having pistol ana saw 'ah
well throw Of his overc0at and o7cr 10 hght hciS
withou: "a pistol .
This statement caused the court TO regard Caldwell
a. a hero of the most brilliant ustrc Fight Kelly
v!rhort pistol, Brave Old bov. fhvalN siill ives
Il i. necessary 10 remark, however. that In cN.s
examining the witness MIR iummel induced him T."
.ay thai he die not in reality sec CaldWcH RICK hclW
he only ,aw him 1T his foot mp and supposed he wac
going to do little Kicking.
Esuy's second blow fell short lie didn't gance
nj, distance. lie tried to get in an upper cat With
Nicholas IIelbig the It. jane barber. bat IclbS''
testimony resolved itself into This child Ike d"claa
ton:
II see some harsh tall
81 thank you very much. very. very much. Mr.
Iclbg" quoth MI IIummel " That jr' the ~1rt Of
tc-tunOuy want
CALDWELL tihns courage, roW forced the lighting
iandind on Kcily'- short ribs with The ie-tmony u u"
testiv1 Conway. Of the II. James llo;" WHO a-.Igd
the court thnj hr at the battle and pierre %; il
f II ON hi- BIZ to". lie Kelly PIT l~ hani n his
hip pocket h- saw Kelly take OIL b., coat b" dd moi
(a,lNeU touch Kelly Ne did not ,"" Cld"c! tli''
n h., coat Nh-n "a" -aw Kelly, hand in h. mp
uucact bee feared there gou- to Doe war. Cd BE- nd
+, the r.c.I.,, maa: Vi. Kelly. ort Of poet -
Cnpt,ih Coapor. won ought not TO have a"r
irouile h~-c." rhcgcupou Kelly permitted h.m-'.i
T., be- I'D 10 80 e,a. without attempting to
blow ont Caldwcr- brains. Aad caldwell an he
While ,,c.d lr- q" Tie iadi,or tossing hi, man.
Nj. Gudy forced conway % admit that Caldwell
might possibly h,y" kicked Kelly without conway
,ccin, 10. Caldwell being h.-i and a -ly Kicker.
Caldwell ti.n swung for Kelly ilw with William
4. Oilan heal bartender 80 the - "ame- Hotel who
.c>Gcd tnai rlldv c did not kch Kelly. t.at caldwell
did uoj pat h. band a his pocket. TINT Caldwell dd
uct 'oach Kelly lu ap wuy. il was Gilman Who
helped John Kelly TO keep the peacc hy scpnlinc tho
warriors.
Caldwell fell snort with the testimony ~ =. =. Nc
Donald. tnc vclihHowu trainer. VINO u.0ru"i tho
court that ac Va~ l go position to SOC t.c ALLEGED
ucAu-. md The ot n'iI almost ti~V hiu.cr down
100 e FOOLISH attempt 80 get 100 body blow "it. one
:homo, M,'o'"tI. re,c-tttc agent, WHOSE 'ict end
lf" t. - ip" the 81 c,' 4 Sc" lor. i0 curious
lso-', 81 Oh, -. Iamc> Hotel IN, odd t asserted
tirt Ctldr 20 dd a"t hlck Kelly. g.. ;. bI'Ain.or.
D. broker testified TINT caldwell! seemed auN.ou- To- 80
At Kelly Notf FRENCH the minstrel and Ian! D...,
I'D not sec Caldwell N.E kc'N, nor did h- H.'nd,
j. C.. Adam. % thca'ti..l agent. see 300; h..l,.
NOW ~ 90 a.d h.o,h mm out,' whispered ~