The Daily bulletin., 1890-11-11
THE LEGISLATURE.
126TH DAY.
TUESDAY. Nov. IL.
The House met at 10 o'clock.

SluerS NODle WlUemann Dill
gross injustice TO the company.
Rep. Paehaole's bill is intended TO
exempt the company from the ohli-
cation of keeping in repair the
statutory two feet on each side of
the track, as the company is losing
5000 a year and 1t is the public
that damages that part of the street.
They recommend the passage Of the
latter bill. Signed by A. p. Pae-
haole and VIM. II. Cornwell. Laid
on the table to be considered with
the bills.
Rep. Nawahi moved that the re-
port of the select committee on DIR.
Lutz be taken up.
Noble Widemann wanted to know
what there was in that report to be
taken up. The committee could not
come to any conclusion on the mat
ter, and simply referred it back to
the House. DIR. Lutz offered to go
back under stiff conditions, but
only for one or two months, or as
long or short time as he pleased.
What could the House do about 1t?
Rep. Hookano said that what the
House wanted to know was what the
hon. Noble had done with the report,
he having had it referred back to
him to get the signature of the Mn
lister of the Interior.
Noble Widemann said he had
done nothing with it, as it was still
born child.
Rep. Nawahi said if it was, the
hon. Noble brought it forth.
Noble Widemann replied not at
all it was brought forth by the hon.
member for Hilo, who brought it to
him and got his signature surrepti-
tiously.
Rep. Nawahi said it was healthy
child, but the hon. Noble undertook
to nurse 1t, and he killed it. The
House should do something with the
report.
Noble Widemann said this baby
of the hon. member for Hilo was the
most dead-sick baby he had ever
seen. On the strength of the hon.
members representations, he had
signed the report. He now with
drew that signature.
Rep. Brown moved that the report
he referred TO the Minister of the
Interior to be transmitted to the
Board of Health. Carried.
RESOLUTIONS.
Rep. Halstead presented resolu-
tion that select committee of three
be appointed to wait on His Majesty,
and inform him that this House will
he ready to be prorogued on Friday
next at.12 O'Clock.
Rep. R.W. Wilcox moved that
the resolution be laid on the table
until the House finds out when it
will be ready to prorogue. Lost.
Rep. Paehaole moved the resolu-
tion be referred to select commit
tee and was speaking, when the
President called him to order. He
asked under what rule he was for
bldden to speak.
The President ruled that the hon.
member had no right to interrupt
the Chair when question was being
put.
Rep. Paehaole appealed against
| the decision OF the Chair.
Noble Wldemann was speaking on
the resolution.
The President called him to order.
Noble Widemann-Good Ged
can't say anything?
The President-Not on the merits
of the resolution. You can only
speak on the ruling of the Chair.
Noble Widemann claimed that be
had the. right to say what he had to
say, and the President had no right
to stop him.
The President asked the hon. No,
BILE to take his seat.
Rep. Hookano supported the ap-
peal.
Rep. Brown said the ruling was in
accordance with the practice through
out the session, and he had never
heard il disputed till this moment.
KEEP. Paehaole argued in favor of
his appeal.
The President said the hon. mem.
ber was perfectly right in claiming
the privilege of making his motion,
but that was only when a matter was
under discussion and not when il
was being voted on.
Rep. Kanealii thought the Presi.
dent should withdraw his ruling, as
he would hate to vote him in the
wrong.
Noble Kauhane held that after the
President rose to put the question
no new motion could be admitted.
Noble Baldwin maintained that
while the rules were defective OF
this point, the practice had beer
that when the President had the
floor putting question, no new mo,
tion could be made. He had Otter
wanted to make a new motion under
such circumstances, but il would bt
against parliamentary practice,
The President wished to say that,
II new motion be entertained wheI
u question was being put, the result
would he that any member, when
ever he saw that his motion failed
could spring up and move an amrnd'
menl, and there would be no end u
| lha hnsiuaGa IN woull nausn andlps,