The Daily bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Hawaii]) 1882-1895, 1890-06-18

Mr.. NeumanD-- course Mr..
Creighton knows him. How did Mr..
Creighton know him, since he has
prosecuting attorney? (Laughter).
A. Oh, nothing very bad Murphy
and me was two lunas ON the same
plantation and 80 Of course we were
together; he heard what l said ana
We talked it together on the road.
Q.--ls there anybody else with
whom you spokeI A.--'l'hcre Is
not, only those two Just.
Q.--On what those two told you
and from his being there two months
you swear you weuld not believe
him under oath? A.--Of course |
would not believe him, of course l
would not. Richmond has spoken
to me many times.
Q.---llas Richmond ever lied to
you? Ale never told me the
truth.
Odd he ever lie to you: A
Certainly he lied to me all the time,
sure he never told me the truth.
Q Tell me what lie he told your
A.--Well he never told me any
truth, so what ain to tell You!
Everything he told me was q lie.
Q.-Tell Inc what he told you that
was q lief Ale lied all the
time.
Q.-Tell ne what he told you!
Al paid no attention to what he
said, because a liar ] don't believe.
Q.--You are very smart and
witty fellow? A--No ! amt.
Q.-You say you don't believe
the man under oath. State the in
stance where he told you lie! A.
Yes l will. Now then there do you
suppose liar is talking to me and
suppose 10 or 20 is sitting around
there aud he is sSouting all his lies
and when he is through don't know
VIVA, he has said, ! know he is o
damn fine talker that is oil.
Q--llow do you know he is iiar
il you paid 10 attention 10 him ?
Al know.
Q--Do you know what lar is?
A.--Look AT here since he lef, New
York
Q.-Who! A.--Eichmond, il ne
knows every man and shop and oil
the places where he says he was and
has worked for every man thSt he
says he did from New York to here
he would he four hundred wears old
(laughtel); why should / believe
such man:
| Q.--State TO this jury in what in
stance he ever made statement to
You in which you found him to be q
liar! Al will, l will, l will. lie
told ne that Mr. Albert Horner,
going one night-it is no matter
where We was going-we were walk
ing together, and asked him for
no news, l didn't want none Of his,
| didn't, l didn't want liar news.
When man is telling lies it is easy
to say yes or no to him, and / said
yes or no going along; he told me
that he had $50 or $40 mouth fol-
teaming which | know WAS liz be.
cause no man gets $50 or $40 q
month for teaming; You knCw j, i.
as easy for . man to say Yea rs e
say no, but some people wan,st to bt
contrary all the time and they can't
Then he told me that in thn black.
smith shop he was getting five dol
lars day, of all said yes tina. is
very good Jack, Jack supposed ]
believed everything that he was tell
ing me. supposed he was to bt
called four days week, he WAS uo
called there two dsys month, so
knew that he wasn't getting NOR,
than two dollars day, and ther
there was better man nor him.
have no better recollection than that
Q.-Is that your best rrcollec
ton? Ayes; thee is one thing
but l won't tell you.
Q.-Why: Al won, an.Ne'
you that.
Q,-You will, A.-You can
make me.
Q.--llow will Il he il ask thu
Court to tell you to answer? A..
Oh, we'll witness hangs his heat
and shifts a6ont uneasiiy.
Q.--Why? Al could not tel
the reasons.
Q.-Why cant you, ARE ,her,
none? A. 1t would no, make an,
difference whether did.
Q.-lt might? Al am no in
fOrmer,i am beyond informing bust
: ness; that would push in on inform
ing business and | am no iuformer
He had certain reason for that.
, OOH, you Amt an informer
Mr.. Shane, have you never informe,
on anybody in your life: A..-No
sir, and i hope never will.
: Q.-llavc you never been prose
eating witness in a case? A..-Never
] never took an oath Till two year
, ago in Honolulu.
, What timer "A fellow got int
, fight and he called me 10 prove h
: was not guilty, which he was guilty
, The fellow got clear,
! Q.-rhey didn't believe you il
that? A.-No; 1 didn't care if the
believed me or didn't believe me.
G. b. FIsmER, sworn-I ha,
charge OF store at Paaullo and n