New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1890-09-03
JUDGE EARL NOMINATED.
FOR JUDGE OF TIE COURT OF APPEALS.

here Yesterday nominated Judge Robert Earl as the
party candidate for Judge Of the Court Of Appeals
The Judge is Democrat but his nomination
was made unanimously. after free discussion OF
the question. Only three members Of the entire
committee, Messrs. Kellogg. Krum and Perley,
proxy for Police Justice Smith, expressed prefer
encc for another candidate, and these gentlemen
aftcrward joined with the rest in Judge Earls
favor.
There is little surprise at the committees action.
II hnS been fOreshadowed in these columns and
In political circles for some time. The causes
that led to it are generally known. In the first
place his record on the bench is excellent. lie
has never been political judge Thoroughly
free from partisanship in his rliAgs. he has
won the respect of his party foes. and in token Of
this regard it was thought best to make him the
Republican candidate for the high office. In
doing this the Republican leaders feel that they
are dcferrng to that rapidly growing pubic
sentiment in favor of taking the judiciary out OF
partisan politics. Finally. it was known to he
tho intention OF the Democratic leaders to refuse
Judge Earl a denomination. Governor Hill and
Chairman Murphy, of the Democratic State tom-
mittce, having determined to replace him with
II man more pliablc tO their wishes To prevent
the elevation Of Il tool Of Hill TO such high
Office the Republicans decided to act as they did
yesterday. Whether or not the Democratic
leaders will accrpt the situation rcmainS to nc
seen.
As usual the meeting Was held at the Fifth
Avenue Hotel General Knapp presided. There
WAS an unusually fair Attendance, as follows:
Ist District. tcorgr Cromwell: lll. Timothy l."
Woodrua: Hid. Thomas A. McWhinncy; Eth
Francis +. Williams: With, john w. JacobIs
With Mr.. Gregory for Cornelius Van Cott
With. John Collins Nth, George billiard: Nth.
=. Y. K. Crugcr: AI,h. Henry H. Perley for
Solon Il; Smith: XIIIth. Frank Raymond; AiEth
James W. Hustled: NNth. B. Is. Ojell. jr.: XNlth,
J. f.. MiholL,nd for Louis +. Payn: NNllth. Will
lam ~ Hayes, Kingston; Atlllth, John a.
Ouaclcnbush: XlXth, t;c"r-r Campbell; AAth,
John Kellogg: XAist. John NJ. WcIcr; XAlld,
" Wi!liam l.. Proctor: XXllld. &. \. thickrrine
ANINih, Hobart krum; AA\ih, GEORGE v"
Dunn: XNVIIIth, Edward L. Adams; ANlAtt,
William l.. Parkhurst; ANXih, Gcoric ": AID
II.ar: NNXlsi, Frank e.. MouiioI AAAiild'
George Urban. Jr.; AANlNth. ID. ~. Lawrence for
Orsino r.. jones.
After the roll call General Knapp briefly eA-
plaimd the "hrrts Of tic meeting There WAS no
iiyL,on "i opinion OH thr p', ,sti"n oi holding
i St,r onvrnt.un. All asw'd that II wonh bt
supcrauo,Is 10 hold ore tins year. Then mo-
ton made by General Ilu,tcd that eac,i mvm-
her r..r ,..:nr his ci.idat" for tie Jud1eshlp
4 ,lciitc lo.l,wrd Mr.. krum proposed rs sab
.tuic To i,. t"ucrals proposition that the com
mItir' hrsi ':et.'" whether II would nominate Il
Dem ca, or IrpuhlIr'n for The onrc inc
subst.t.ir IS lot accepted. The roll was called
ALI ted for judge Lar. except the three COM
nIttccm.n m"nti,DcI, VINO supported Daniel IT,
Rnlliu, of ihls city. " ~ ~ the result was
ANNOUNCED Mr. Percy pr"poocl tna' Judge E'r
nomination slcu.d De made unanimous. Mr.
Krum seconded t..is n tion md II WAS carried
4 committee nsistlng Of General llustrd,
Colonel Cruscr. Mr. Odell, Mr.: Chickcring and Mr
Krum WAC appointed 10 draft m address 70 thc
voters ~ tho State 4 r"-ss of half an hour was
tn6rn 20 enable them =" perform this work pom
re- ,secmbllng they reported the following. which
WIS I'D pied
d"namd, Tor and thu necessity Of non partisan
TG T n"1 " isacss o M ca tS '"s on Appea I%% q"
Eo'r, E,r wh"~c term Is about to cApr.. ,,,1, hav,
d" fDrn,i!;y Of -ta," Convention. to place him in
lomuuluou AID rcoIi'ncnd h., r. election. We hay
no do'b 'hAi ir m'm."iN OF u" p.tn W." ."a",i
lId"i-c tn, au"' A. ia" Inquest eAc"P'''' "'''" -
Ia" ,p.nt Of tNll --rv.'" reform. ,.,,
i., ,omrniitc~ ,o.lhs tine cNrr's>i"n 81 itN party
h",r'lly commend, IL" 'o','N";ivr .asr "n' a't'
plirouc administration "t f:csidrnt nAiri'oI. ~
,"uu""d- 'hc y."F'i~ and ,"''"-,'n rhor, %; s' a"
REPRESENTATION, to .-tan-h iao ti'At The mIoN
IA 'onerr,, l. entitled Ia "H,r''r t.r Ft,,, and
Inc No.cr> "i te nn"iIt,. Il h"nrub connc cnd' thr
h.nl IanA I'm Toy ,hr rl"',m "i Iri ,,, r'r mr.,
I,,l' KIND that hhN 'iiDi u ui,".' w.: r
a.snHltugal .'h'tnir. HE iarn:s "l Hc" u" , ' ~
Ia meet constant aud a--'",,'" '',apv.'.nra "a
tf 'anad Al a-ri'iltni8,t "fV|' IA" entire "'''"'H
to!,irr + th', -'it", ,,.,. ,,.rl,ul,,,,,I
,chriui. g, ui. VI, hiu.y illl oitrr> t." tl"m a, II
on'r' t" H." An"ri'lI w"i"I".m au " ~ ,,,' rio
.,l,r policy. li'-,.ad "f rt>!ne. a. IN ial" ~
'ii''m ,in T. d., '',' nai i Gf, ,' on ri h.
I>t oi agricultural and other l""i"i puI''.s ~,
~ s,+.r, ad. la, .,n, n,,rS r' ~. t",.r lat" tl"
I nd tat. thu m,"r.ait h'-'h'it itr dc"a,," a.
M and IL. p' ct "F ~, I~t t' i''i W pat an End 10
ihN int,ri.ib" ~rds &, the iAr'i'ir W 'm,r 60
other >'A rh" r"i"an an ranI nrmi'S n S,r" ty
vhh viii "p new narh"i, Tor t.r pI"' ,, t,,. va M
farm, ard ia'ioric> whoat jc.hrdAins tf ihr,,,'n
oi either Ne ur." upoa the Federal >rmac tnt gray"
nci Of fair c!riion Ia" To- prevent u' ',"'T. td M
and iorcc We can attention u Tn" lat that ,hc
Irudlng measure before t"nsT>>; "hrh h1, pr,. .
c.i.r with thr ronrol a" boat or state aiiaS IN
ctu", North or 'h u.' IT.. no. no. anl p'Tn '"ro
!an d, Existing law and that IT can "ni, be en-,
forced upon the PETITION Of !mrn,c Hmnrr rrlutuI,y fr
and entirely non sectional tr' proposed Law Is Mru
worth Il trial (, III" end iiat thc Erpnp" a., pa,,!
iur having failed when IN power To pr"posr' or at
ha,t " -ce. an adequate remedy ior cA''u"s "'"'s'
Ut ,"mInrnding a, We do the effort Of the present
Adninl, traion Ia advance tn welfr. AMI proaptrt
Of ;l people by Strengthening ia p'! Vi iiOl 'lo'
Lv ih. extension uf onr comm"rcai rrIu.pnr. III NJ
l,ildlnr uf the American m' ci;t mar ne 'uc uhl'a
lion of A.ricau .ihrni:tl i'rnt' III en- aPtui'E
and extension ~ postal iilit!r the graiiinS "i I>t
and we'll deserved pensions t" hi"n N"idrr,. th'
f,u
ihr ,,mnrrria world IN: mahr air' OF thr hgh 81
.tnudard Of qualification for tn cir srivlrc. wiih
adherence I" the spllii as wc.l i, ,nc ' "l W..
I,y t,u, r,l:,li-In ~ al the power ol tN. rrpT'i'c
state, Ia entirely IrIlai" and control their liquor
tr,Iyr. wr urc ON tn members of tir party the ne
c,.,i'y of rlr,ing in"inhI> of Inc llol~, OF htP
l, sentative, f. IN TIN II at; wi' VIII upioi IN eood
work "f The. \dnu. We call particular atr
ZION io the fat that the incoming lAg-la ufr VIII
,I,.r, , ,u ul,r Of III, upprr bar II oi t"ngrr>. and
mon tic .anr I..r; laurr NAV and probably VIII
drvnIyr im,o,tant du;c, IN hrcri ION with tho r.
apporfi Of the 'oi'r es"Iu districts "t thls
state under the new rcn'r,. ,
and all should earnestly Labor to achieve the pirty's
success. II, - , 49,. -
Much Is at stake. cunning and INSCRIPTIONS on.
eagerly seeks opportunity 10 obtain con r"l
Of ih" Lrg.latur'. IL triumph ~ Thu tnr Womb be-
fraught with untold evil I" th" state and possibly
IA tr Nation. The cycrll'nt record Of tn retiring
i.r.Iotur. STRONGLY evidenced bv Ia" low rate Of
Stat. faxniion houM not l." forcrf:'r neither ehnui
he fact that thi, fall for the fr,f time III ms St'
,hr experiment of the new ana secret ial'h law
viii b. tried Let enter into I'll" conf's drt ~
mined to secure success. brca>" bv thr nonnai"n
Of good men and the support Of wl"lspf" measures
we shall a,,undantv prove that W" de7crv" it,
A.I 4 crptl of