The critic., 1890-12-23
TIE DEFENSE CLOSED.
THE OPENING ARGUMENTS TO BE
MADE THIS AFTERNOON.
An Effort to Get the Case to the Jury To-
Morrow-Very Little Testimony OF
fercd In Rebuttal--Thc Prayers Of the
Defense Admitted.


After the close of Tur t'ntrrc's ren,rt of
tbe Ward tr;ol Yesterday aftcrnoan nr
~, w"'. IL ~. S's.ei"y "i.,'noon ~
W. w. 'oudlhgi Supcrintcnuent OF the
Government Hospital for the Insane, was
placed upon the witness stand. The same
.hvnotbot;co, oucv,inps tbat woro nro-
....,.,, ~ 'N,.s,... IT.
pouli"eu 10 IN hernps,er were theh gwen
TO Dr. Godding to answer. He agreed
with Dr. Kcmpster that the condition of
the persou ,lescribed in tho oucstion wopld
,,,,,,oto ,..,,,,,,,,. ,,',,, H., ,.,'.i,
NJ" co., nh g., "'p "'s w."neu uy uIii1k' M
s,r;hoJ ~, ,,a' Wy .,ioui,rs'"ness ,..,, ",
,,,;,I, shnat;,,,, ,,, ni,r ~ INn,'is'
m,;,,;,, m,;m s,oo"ns ''iu iio' al'cr 'hc oocV'r
oiIlIf IInom aross.exan;notior Dr God5;n,
,,,.,,,, -, LII
n;5t Mas aai' 1p19 ~ uo'svsr .nu i'iuviuqm
Mo,,', MIo,u.n,s s su .'oh.'"s "a,m nisal''ty
s1'y ssa,,,y s,,ia " .o Sr ~ ,,, WI, ~ & no II II
c",,id ~. sa,, ti.a, ,I,y .i",,,;s:, Az 4ie e
MN, Ss Icy ',aV ',, Wy a. ,;uS a. VIZ ,,.''
attnn;,,, Il n,, & .mo la ~.
~ :" oo" H., oo,,a,ue'eu l,,.t my ny
of of,on q ,i' i,o ,nam my e Tut a}uur'eo
"inv, m, Wy ocAn,,i,aa,'on i,l,'i III III IT ups
W., f,' a.. 'h oaoSo
,,a suSu ;,i iouay, ai.ur Will Wy uVNei,i
trod,,o W., ,,Stai ~ co H. ~ W
sa,,t ,i';s ,,;ii In do'a IL e., i,,,,,,' w,"'
Il ~ ,a,'ss;,ia .,o, I'll ,,,o a,';,,,, ot'e Nv
.',d an w., iiaJ ng
NAV bo aoJeJ tnrram "' I' st t,,n lm, in', ;r,a
viii ho re,,,;rod 70 s,,a,,1 ha;r ~ c, yns lnrS
W, wui ~ ~, Hi " 1pvnt onv Iili;.lii,s
doa;,Io ,,,sg,, ,,oni;,'. '"ey ''i'''S''''0'y
trhoS ,,Ip''ai upvii ",o,vd nf ,,ot
,rasn,,t %a,, Nv tr;al os s WI ~;
pinor,;r, h,,t i,o -, III, aii,,
ha,a, t e;, ~, s tho a.,,,
'fRcer Ia Wa,ilin, T., wv baSo orr,ssod W.
t,,o Marhia Saino, ,.a, H. d.. ,';t,' J.u ~ ~
caileJ tL;s r,orn;a iIo,,,;Ita,s vi wi,,o hoa,,
exanined at tI,n heg;n;na ~ thn ,,r ~; oGe, u
n witness for tbe Gnvarnmnpt Int Mr
Iv;lsa,, racal,od b;,, ,,,;n ,;,,,, ~. t,l ri,.
fnrthar MN, .'s roardg ,nol,g hot
WarJ sa;d Yyto,, he ,ros arrostod ,osd's """'
,Tho oaioor toat;sni that W., .o;,,
o;tbar .,i,,, d,,o fnr ~ ~ a., \. !,
az III ,,a, IL ~ !, ~, va, uv'ie ~
NOT reman,her % Which o''' 'n' o'''ooi 'o0i'
0aianr Ii,,rh w ~, I, al o,so hoo,, ,.
y;o,sI, orarp;,'ed ns ax ",sy si,a1 pech pru,
stonJ Ha ,a, ,er,s,, w"S ~ W. ~, au, ~ s,o
cposs mr ,,od aih G W%v y;,s, u'ia was
wbetber hn Lod soon Inhn Drou, n ,o,,s v
narcr rorortnr 4, thn Nfarhlo soin,o,, ,,, nbws
q baIf al, ho,,r aftar ~ sLnnt;,,,. NJ ~
ot,icer sa;, i tha, he All ~, no, soo NE nron,
~, ,i,a sni e io ,1;5 I' m sou ,,.ew
n smi S"roV' ;t' nor ,ior uu ; me navc any vom,
sa;5 nhar ho una n a,rostnd """' ""i"
' The e officer e admitted Sns i that he met Drew
~ ~ n,,s ~ NV W., nc ,io. poW ,..
bad .no no taii1 ,u;th ' rnari;g i;g., po
,rnr5a % Wal ,,sod M.s', ,rhan % arraSaad "i'"'
"0G5 0Moon "iu - vs." "mea me-. ",ieo" ,ho''
fron, tba stau5 o,,d W. Wiz, uas',,aste ei
Leave w, W reod NJ % nron,s testnnn ,,;nen
at the exam;nat;on for hail indcye tfooa h, u
bowever nhincted % and ' NJ W;igon Vine iJs, thS
desired that Drew's deposition migbt he
taLnn INT as the Goyornn,ort IT, a.
,nnrrsd ~ Wv tb;s tho dofosa drn,''aJ ",sJ ~
rpnnest Cor the t;,ne be;ng "'ofp0" ''e
lanes McKennv uas tIo noxt u.;t,os.
caIied bnt faii;ny to nrcsent b;ns",f n, o
nrncen,,;nss wore 5eoyod NTH h;s o,.r;,,ai ,j'
ie ,adn b;s ornoaronoo n m'i aftor h,s i'"rt
deiav and was @ rIapdcd p an tLe sts, stand |" s'oi'
NJ Mex ennv Yves resides nj io51 1rrion
street sonthwest and yyos formar,, n,,'l
Ue' sow JIer o,d yVarJ il, tho HSnri,io n
Sajon~ oho,,t o;nht Ja,,s barora T,,ra 10 ~
1880 Ward and y,or ;voro ,natoI;,,sr 80. fo
n hot,Ie nf u;no Tho snr,mar ,,,n,l so,,d "a
then Ad,er said. ..rli match wnr To. for tx aH !,
Ward also won, ,h;s and tho9 dior 90; so;,
that he wanted satisfaction- Ward how.
ever mid no attention To- A dIer,s ides;re hoT
loon ''' Wv % '''' %"
On cross.examination ArcKepnv stataa
tbot the affair ncc,,rred nj niybt s'a,'t1 and
Neither Ward nor Hdlor wore emt;rni,,
snhar ""i" Ao' 1A"''i "eio eh'iio'y
law Nea,r,oyer tho nro,r;otor % ,to
Marble saloon was then recalied IN the
stand Inv Jndre Wilson He was sta,d;no n
close by Ward when % he was @ arrested mre fS afteSS
the ehoot;ng Int Id not Near h;,,, ~,,y. .a ~.
"The 80 -o,- ~ - sbot him - ar .st3, a
lew. 7 shot him - He did not in
fact. hear ANYTHING that Ward said.
He Remembered tbe. circumstance. of
Ward and Adler match;no fnr vine but
could NOT recnIlect the date "''' '''
Newmever was closely cross.exom;nod
by Mr.. Claeett. He admitted that he wac
Very nervous'' and friebtened after tSe
shooting, but denied that he heard Ward
saw anStbinp, His statement now he
said was the same as that made IN tie ax1 Nv
animation for bail.
Mr.. Ginnertv. tho barkeener of the
|. Marble Saloon was recalled hv tho do.
/ Tense. ~
Ginnertv testified tbat be was near Wor5
ON the niSht of tho arrest and heard M
remarks made bv Ward Mr. Wilson
read The exnressions which Ward was said
| ing heard them. N'
f;innertv was the last witness of the do.
fense and Judge W;isnr Observation-Disclosures
the defense rested nj this no;nt aycent for
the nroc,ring Al Mr. Drew,s q danosit;nn
The first Witness called nv lie Cavern.
ment In rebuttai was DIR. Schaeffer who
failed to annear The newt witness Sta.
tion Keener W IT. Rollins Of the Hrst
Precinct station also failed 10 onnear
Mr.. Clageft said that the jovernr m epf had
very little testimony TO offer in rebnttai
and exnlained the n Rsence Of tba win essas
Mr.. Coleman stated that since tho do,
fcnse had shortoneI tbe tr;al as n,ucI os
nnssihIe II, nrier 10 oud y has3ra TI,r;s.
mas tbe counsel sbomld now nrncced VIII