The Helena independent. [volume] (Helena, Mont.) 1875-1943, 1890-11-23
MISS ELIZA mccartney.
A Young Woman Who Makes Seri-
GUS Charges Against Dr..
E.S. Kellogg.
John Reed, OF Deer Lodge. Said to
BE tho Unfortunate 0arrs
Betrayer.

- A~Yu
10 Jn0 On1OftunaVe 0
Ra%ravar
M =
rhe Publie Excluded from the Police
c-.A r-.,....p ..,,,~,n.-v Hear.
Oou1s A,el1ns ne As..'-
Ing xeses1oay
...,.,r.+;on
Dr. Aelloggs preliminary eAe's'.
was commenced before Juo9e oanoeEs ~ :,
terday afternoon at two O'Clock. ne small .,,aa
e.A =. - ~ ~. hon. - AZ thu re-
s0Mo ta@es D0A0.o sAe 49, S-.--l.s.
quest Of counsel the 1uoRe a.Ae1 svsay .o a.
r = ~. and "a. r.norter,. Dr.. kellogg game in
asthe iudee took his seat. In chair near
the d6ctor was Mr.. AcMliians oseeeo Y
mourning and nervously lingering white
~, 3. 49, her chair q tha dootor,a aide
~. ~ I%...ss .,ass.rt,, -;th h;,r nv.,,
and ohatted pleasantly VAIN NM wy
sye was ON the county attorney - he opened
the door communicating with tho next
Nom and asked thu complaining witness 60
enter. she vas Eliza Mccartney,
: sen youns .s oman' 49,. ss' .s.. ,,,.h i,
sombre plumes Swallowed her care worn
avas With down cast head and upliftafl
nano sne sWote snas sne Wou.o se.a sas
truth, the whole truth. ana nosninR pus tno
truth. from nef seas A. the JUDGES lefs
the young woman answered the questions
OF the prosecuting omcer Wnaoh nfou2ns
out the story OF confidence N z
Of her Efforts to hide the shame.
It was wonder she did NOS oreek down
under the terrible strain Of laying bare the
entire story IN all Its detaile.
The defendant nefvously oompea nls
thick dark hair With hin fingers a. times;
answers and frequently made whispered
suggeeeions to his counsel, =. ". Alne!ey
and Massena Builard: MI. Ainsiey naa e
work on medical 1urlsprudence open before
nlm WHEN re consulteo 1evelal slmes.
the stand during the examination. She
sspRearea g 20 renewed wnen me ! lswyess
ments over the rules Of evidence. Much OF
Sne tesumony VIII not De pfInted ZOE op-
vlous reasons: During the RECITAL OF nef
experiences snce coming 70 Monsane tne
1oom Mas nuenea AVE ZOE re i0w-sQnso
snSWe1s ano tle quesolons q 1no Ia r1Mye1,s:
=. me wisness give ner name ~ Enza NC
ssn ~ ana ss s sro mat the nnt,
torney, Miss Mccartney stated That sne
came 20 Mentsna me Ssa OF l.ss A el.e ~
saa iesloea ~ v 1M H th unSa tns % oa
CT this month; While there sne WORKED e
cook in hotels and restaurants until some
ZONE me pine u July. .:. ;.., :.
The witness was questioned infinitely as
to her relations WITH her alleged Detrayer,
ana testined that their lnumacy. began IN
June and continued until some time in Sep
TENDER: Col. Nolan then examined her "a g
TO her trip TO Helena and visit 70 IT. kel-
logg:,, - a.,
when diq You say You came 20 delenas'
Ine tnlro Gay OF Novemper. -,
And where did you 60 IN He!enaF
Ol ;6odney street, wnefe was en-
plo{ed. 49,. 10000 =. v.u
ana see whether You nave seen nlm before
Or not.
u nave.
when Was 1t thas you orst saw IL. Ael
loggI =.
- Deneve on s1e 1ourtn OF Novemper.
!. Ana where olo you see n1m az tnat
slmer
In ms ONCE. -,
. About what !, tine ne aid yoa zee hims
.. some ume IN tne afternoon.
Who we're present when you saw him in
sne 81 aite!noonr
oeheve there was young laoy, ana
shlnk another man"
uo you nave Any oonvefeataon W1tn sne
do Il aid g. that ''msf
w; Isil the court the V, c .S ~.