Santa Fe daily New Mexican. [volume] (Santa Fe, N.M.) 1885-1897, 1889-10-23
The ORTIZ NINE GRAZ SUIT,
/: eheariug Denied in the Case OF a. H.
CuIErsleevc vs, the New Mex
leo Mining Co.

In the case of G. II. Gildersleeve vs..
the New Mexico Mining company, IN
application by complainant for a rehear-
ing, Judge Whiteman observation-disclosures
handed down an opinion denying the
application. The case has been pending
for years, and involves one-fourth in
terest in the celebrated Ortiz mine grant,
one OF the richest tracts OF mineral land
in Santa Fe county. The attorneys were
Col. Edward L. Bartlett for the company
and Z. A. Fiske, esq, for the complain
ant. Appended is Judge Whiteman's
opinion:
This is an application made by the COM
plaiuant for Il rehearing of this cause.
The cause was heard and determined by
my immediate predecessor, Hon. r. A.
Reeves, on the Goth day of December, 1883,
who gave judgment for the defendants
and dismissed compliments bill. The
petition for n rehearing was filed the same
day, and sets out six causes or grounds
why the rehearing prayed for should be
allowed, viz:
LIST. That the court erred in receiving
and admitting in evidence certified copies
of certain deeds, etc.
I'd. That the court erred in receiving
and admitting in evidence the testimony
of Stepen B. Elkins as to the contents OF
certain deed, etc.
3D. That the court erred in admitting
in evidence the pretended will of Jose
Francisco Ortiz and Mariquita Montoya.
4th. That the court erred in holding
and deciding that the pretended will OF
Jose francesca Ortiz and Mariquita Mon
ioya was ever properly executed or proven.
9Th. That the court erred in holding
and deciding that the pIainant's cause
OF action was barred by the statute OF linn
itaions.
9th. That the court erred in dismissing
the bill Of complaint of complainant.
Upon the arG3"ent nj the application
for rehearing but three points were dis.
Cussed by counsel for complainant, viz:
Those embraced in the third fourth and
fifth grounds OF the petition, and it will be
seen by reading the petition that the only
grounds assigned whya rehearing should
he allowed are errors committed by the
U .oi,ioj a. j.; ~ aso III Tho 1890 ,it;,
- a.'o o.i, d;son'as o
~ o p 1"o " ~ SL 1,1 ia
~ VI " ot, nI;o i, tha4 't to Sniou.o iea
not been fairly and impartially tried and
the fullest latitude given to the complain
81 I ~ ~ eno P'ep"' "'t0i' ANA p'esen'''''i'
"a T I'ta "oocxd = .o,,i,,. oo,.o.;,.
-, "o 1871 30 'oi"niinous' ' tna,;s
omG "a ",oi "sen va ooH. hnIo
s'" ~ S;I;,,t , " I''o 49, 40
SuGFS'iv y, ui, I" ne ha aiu i9
~ p4.t "'"'iU GpVi ooo, Siueo
d INV aoa AZ .,s1 ro 10 81
~, go ,,i co." ,ho $50 1t',nod
u anJ have ,,ot hoSo.o how $3.50 W.
"a I''"' .t o',,u ,.",e NV 49, " H'; tsi.
~ ~ nS 1917 y, d ' ino;dad
tno Juuso wi" VIZ ie1,u uiG utIiutu wv
oause 20 q" "Die any I pu,F iui LUZ y; ion5
10 ! !rTLUse y. oo.s ,i Ia. "iiu
appe."'o 49,. ints? " a. a.io'e
.'"s ellGu,I' nave t',i' d inlutliee upon tle
.;'1lu "a '1'e |o"'' Al ueNi"ins ti4' queo'
'ioi'' ~. ;,a,, ,ht .,,ro :. 10
,riIi;, vo"'t Va juo 49, ;ta "i%"' ~
.'l,ne w. ..;. 'S', ~ us, ,.l.nneS'
"ter ~. T''ln.eu ~ SUI, e'ioi any,
;nG enevt y, 1910 tne onioa n"D Geen ~ siSe
,uus stI a ;tio1 !. p"''s nno Utit.. "t2e
Houio I d. tlti.'eu " iuuslienT ~ iil3
naSnouJ ~ .,;app, " indon f.n .h
auo' icy ~ u ~ I,1ioaent ';ue o eiJ
iG iii, wy nlvo ~ tr'o o S"s~ ,a n",f'
az ;,'Ioa W o. W. H. nt;o .L tnt
oi"l Ju"G' tai'u "i'uet Wy P"o ';. :.,"t
,at o ~ ,.ni S,osa "pp1o
a,o i'dv I f 'maesI nom ih"tGi 10
l,i ~ a." ,, ~ IN 20 ~; VI
~ W. - 'ie ,"v 1890 ~ ~. " ao.tI"
l''mi.u pe.,.on ~ te ,h. tiie
VausG az ny saliie 'iie 'iia' ~ ID
ieTiu upoi' ne T suppieinel' .;i oiiii
Cnuei WV l.hs't'n p'"oI''o ione"iiuso
- cYui'y e"uSes uae bl"n'eu as ilia..ei
~, >. ~. upoit a oeial,i':I' % tiliee Ioiii
~ ',l.o '.'e1I 10 I.toi ~ .n !e'olu, nu'
n'tn p 49, ILL., l,"s ogei' aounu ~ ooe"sioii
nn'I'.o uei"t2 "ilu lhlo'.sG ilienfe9' nnu
sEufT &C. % ae a,aoiU las'mlei Ina.
u 49, 40 'i.ooe .eaaon' ii"' iie'ei oeen
"'oied L ~ ;i'is voun.'y. r,,;oh Kan
e fa;.i "a a e%un1 ",ivA ~ aa1 o,.oI
,vGn ianiy situ e,o I ~. NC aiiUneu
, ',igs SUM- l1ialn "iia ou'tous aaI p;;,
10y 49, w ,onni 80 ~ ", , doo.ao ~ ~
on,e 'ht ~ n"e a,;no - .t .no $50
'lo"gnt " 'i'e hol'ee VI 'ie oo!lt "niCi'
iaI oeio'G eseai,eu w. a.ten'ion. NJ
uoai toiu ~ Vi .le ni",tef mas n zen
ueeesteu III ti.ls eause. ~ ~ Is rue .ilat