The Pacific commercial advertiser. [volume] (Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands) 1885-1921, 1889-01-23
AMERICAN woMeNs VOICES.
A Young English Diplomats Remark.
Throat Gymnastics.

throat Gymnastics.
Considerable discussion has been caused
by n remark of young diplomat belong
Ing to the English fisheries commission.
He said that he was much struck with
the facial and physical loveliness Of
American women, but that his sense of
the harmonious was Jared when they
spoke. "Englishwonlen' 9 information is
musical, low, sympathetic, while that Of
the typical daughter Of America is high,
somewhat harsh, and not grateful" He
added that in repoee the American
woman is more attractive than her
English sister; but that the latter is more
agreeable in conversation.
Throughout the debate which this
candOr has started their is no denial OF
the assertion that American women's
voices are often disagreeable and that
English women's information is more
melodious. But there is no proper effort
to get at the cause of the difference.
There is an error in admitting that the
difference Is due to higher pitch in this
country than in England. Amy one who
has heard English women speaking with
total self-unconsciousness in their own
homes knows that they run TO quite as
high a note as women of any other coun-
try; and that, in proportion as the spirit
the ga1nut as the thermometer ascends
when the icy fetters loosen the mercury.
Miss Terry's voice is perfectly natural on
the stage, and when she Is not tragic it
is in high key. Sontag was noted for
talking as flutes lisp and nightingales
MARBLE" and both are at their best in
high pitch.
The trouble lies not in the pitch, but in
the quality Of voice. When Lear said of
Cordelia, 'Hor voice was ovsr soft,
gentle and low, an excellent thing in
woman" it was quality, not pitch, he
correctly described. When Petruchio
says of Katherine, in Tanning of the
Shrew," Think you a little din can
daunt mine ears2' he describes again the
offensiveness in woman's voice, it's moist
ness, not It's pitch, Chaucer knew that
''small voices, sweet entuned," were
"the sweetest melody he ever heard;"
and once again 1t is quality, not pitch,
that is referred TO. It is undsniable that
In the American AIR all voices are more
or less roughened by the catarrhal mala-
dies, more disagreeable than dangerous.
We can count too easily the singers we
have produced; and the moment voice
Is discovered there is feverish anxiety to
get it out Of the country before our
ers born or bred In Europe return, unless
In extraordinary cases of great laryngeal
pliability, with as even or guave a tonal-
ity as they bring out here.
The voices that are bred among us we
do our best to destroy for musical quail
ity in either singing or speaking by the
elocutionary antics Of our schools. In
England, except among those who are
latterly patrons of the public primary
schools tuition outside the home in
childhood is all but unknown. The gov
erness ia tradition as immovable as the
house OF LORDS or the judges wigs. The
children study and recite in an ordinary
room. The Glow voice Ia naturally and
sweetly developed. because the lining OF
the throat is not scraped by voice forcing.
When singing lessons begin the special
timbre of each voice is carefully watched;
and as rapidly as indications suffice, it is
given the proper education for its natu-
raj register, be that high, low or medium.
Meanwhile we have forty children in a
large schoolroom; the teacher arrange6
them in a row Mt the rear, and stands
herself at the front Of the apartment,
and the child who reads Ioudest is the
highest in order Of merit. It Is con-
sidered particularly commendable If the
entire class can read In concert louder
than any other entire class in all the com
petitive schools-oOmpeting for the ruin
of individual voice quality. The same
unscientific course is followed In music.
All sing the same register for years; all
are urged to shout and "holler" in school.
When they are OK an age to make battle
with the climate in it's ugly moods they
can already say, as Falstaf did to the
chief Justice, and more truly: 'For my
voice, have lost It with holloaing and
singing of anthems"
Doubtless, toe, mental composure has
much 10 do with the quality of the voice.
The eager Of both sexes will shout or
scream. As the best conversers are also
the best listeners, the quality Of voice
which goes SO far to make a good con-
verser is instinctively low and sympa-
thetic. The English girl learns in in
fancy that she is to speak only when
spoken to; that she is to reflect before
speaking, and when abe speaks is to say
as little as possible that will antagonize
her lords and masters. The American
girl is accustomed from childhood TO
speak on everything; to exercise spon-
taneity, if not independence; and the
vices resulting from the abuse of the good
ideas herein involved are loud voice,
harsh quality, and speech, followed by re-
Election, perhaps, but rarely preceded by
it. American girls, as q rule, are poor
listeners. A dozen of them will speak all
together, and the highest pitch is often
reached in a competition to coerce atten-
ton.
Aside from climatic influence, not
easily overcome, whose effects, however,
can be mitigated, the disagreeable quality
in American women's voices Is due to
irrational throat gymnastics in childhood,
ard to deficient mental composure in
maturity. Chicago Times.
A Bath In Washington.