New-York tribune., 1889-10-20

yesterday with reference 10 the whole matter be
of each resolution will be first Int b tho House viva
voce. II it is evident that there Is majority in
favor of the resolution, if it is doubted that the
resolution IS lost. the motion shall then be put 10
the House by dioceses and opers But II II is not
doubted that The resolution is lost 1t VIII be recorded
mat this House does not concur with the House of
Bishops
After some discussion the House adopted the frat
part of the resolution That the proposed alterations
in the Book of Common Prayer, which have been
referred to the Committee OF the Whole be recalled
from that committee"
THE FIFTEEN PROPOSED CHANGES.
The House then proceeded to consider the second
BATCH Of alterations in the prayepbook passed by
the House Of Bishops There fifteen of them,
as follows:
|. a prayer for person, or persons, on journey
"Wednesday, rubrc providing that, instead Of tho
Eene. shall be sung or said the anthem from the So
Psalter.
8. Rubrics, etc, before oaertory sentences, :.
4. For the first oflertOry sentence: Remember the
worls Of our Lord Jesus Christ how he SAID. 1T Is
moro blessed R to gys than % Ac;s Xxx $
Thine, Lord, is the greatness" "MelohiEedek, King
Of % brought @ for Rg Pred aud pS TRs and asS he Sn T2s
tithes Of all Gen. KY, 10; 2O.n -.,-.. a..
Ascension SON Day u be used until T wHifsdaday f d
T. That in The PRAYER OF conservation lpsteag OF inc
here be substituted that he may dwell in us and
In him
=.
8. Question In baptismal Office
10. Thanksgiving in baptism Of adults
II. Rubrc at end Of baptism OF adults.
10 HracReted note after first answer in Catochfsm.
u. Lesson in confirmation Office.
IS. That, in the order Of confrrnstiop after. tho
present question and answer there DO an inssrtoi.
The prayer for person or persons on Journey
was originally drawn up:
o everlasting God, we commend to thy Almighty
protection thy servant for whom pray. Defend
him from the dangers OF his Journey guard him nom
going out and BIS coming IN grant him the fruitlon OF
his just desires). and make him grateful for all thy
mer,ies: through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
The House voted To amend by striking out the pc
ttion, grant him the fruton of hts Just desIes7
and by a large majority adopted the prayer as
amended.
DIFFERING WITH THEIR BISHOPS.
Number was thrown out with celebrity: a vote OF
non concurrence with the House of Bishops being
passed by big majority after little
discussion. The rubrics ETC. proposed in
No. 3 were also rejected The resolution of
the Committee on Liturgical Revision on the subtec,
was:
| That in place of the rubric before the oifertory
sentences these two rlbHos be inserted:
minister, when there is a communion shall return to
the Lords Table and say Let make our Offering
Rsh Lo & T'h he s he snS ESS saying
Of the seqnSsi Sn6 Gee a Sss as be in most
used on any other Of public worship whom the
! aims Of the people are to be received
In No Dr. Hart POINTED that the scrpt,lral
| quotation was incorrect The House resolved 10
amend it 10 It's right form Remember the words OF
he Lord Jesus how he said It is blessed 10 pdve
than 10 rcceiven In this orreeted form the resolution
| was adopted.
| Non-concurrence in no 0 was the decided vote of
| the House. The Rev. Arthur C. A. Han, OF MaSsa-
chusetts opposed the alteration proposed in the sixth
resolution on the ground that It was needless aud
without c1mpensa,ing advantages The House
! eeresd with him. voting to non-coDcur
Dr. Hart pointed ont that the alteration provided
for in the seventh resolution made FOR the purpose
| Ct correcting a painful and infelicitols grammatical
| naccuracy After several deputies had aired their
knowledge or otherwise Of tie grammatical oonsiruc-
ton Of the English language, the resolution wss car
| tied.
! EVOKING A lively DISCUSSION.
The Rev Dr. Huntington introduced a long ana
lively discussion on the eighth resolution. The Re
vision Committees resolution is, That at the end OF
the communion Office the following rubric be inserted
after the first rub1c: There shall be no celebration
Of the Lords Supper, except there DO some 10 COM
muDicate With the PRIEST"
| Dr. umapgDn announced that althUngh tho rnbric
vas aimed at q practice which he personally held n
bs the most pernicfous tat had ever crpt into the
ritual worship OF the Church, be was nevertheless
opposed 10 copourenne with the House Of Bishops In
sancioning the robric, addng;
/ Because, in the first place, conceive that .this Il
the bringing IN of disciplinary measure onder cove
OF llturgical enrichment thing which am, by even
pledge that could possibly DO made, bound 10 resist
In the second place, sir, hOld The ru6rc, oven II on
! acted, 10 he bruum iulnen The 0Ice OF the II0lI
| Communion, a. IL stands. IS thoroughly IeiOime-
oGIre from st 10 last It's whole putpori and aim h
n traverse te doctrine OF the Church OF Rome upoI
t1oduce into this Communion dogma with references
10 he Holy Euchsrfs, which appears % many Of us Y
| differ only fron that which Is condemned In ca