The Seattle post-intelligencer. [volume] (Seattle, Wash. Terr. [Wash.]) 1888-1914, 1889-05-14

ssws e chs cheu ping. sppxnans. ".
the col}eceor al the port of San Frnneieco. /
Yhtr d he xuzs hroueht q tess xlie eonsfd*
tutiuna]Ify 81 the seest txclutdon -.
Shozfsy amer che Scott exclusion oct wepS
into eiEoet. chm ch4u r7us returned g
ne Gated States from china enil cndeAx.
ored ID serure entrances - tlse ppr< 81 san
H1ncisco. He 1clf thin coausrI' s<ncd
win eex<i1ea1t enritzink him - return.
hut the coilecs0x decinxe1 Is inya1 fdkscd ~
| tie Scotx aes The col ec3a,r rc1upe0 EiE
| nssxn31fauce. ana Suis w&z 6t0u&an tn Ne
| Uufssd states court Tor Tho s4zzt}<f 81 tazs-
j ipruln to tc<z ne carx<<t2ett&l<y q kns
4 scott acf. In eocorIarce with proyiNQa
/ pf which the collerfor &f1tsd. tks talz.
4 forn5a court hrl1 tho coksft fnuSpu4i1y o1
nf s5s srs- and from this tctisiola the ease
CONES hers On appe4l
IhSs e0ust a{irms s5At Judgment e
holds thAs congrcss holds The power to
Txhroeate treaty. ana in ssiaisoss of gas -.
4 view cifes surkori11e8 Of the c0lksk "a tne
Il subject. holding thai the prx'prieiy of such
II action u not matter o{ taueisi eeneSFns
hgf fAht It's matter for tie p<,i1tira5 df-
rsr4menf Congress, Is xayS. has power g
exclude 1aiens from the rpnnny wnese
| presence = deemed in1snicsla to our ansef-
90 csnxiderins the case. Jastice Field sra-
! vcreefl Il length the character ~ the urea
! | iies between the two cpuntrsen and the
! seeisiAtion OF coagress 70 carry ahcm anto M
e1sss- The opsnion prossssnii ,sssni.. = eseb rs
ss,.s. saw. or believed they saw, i1
d Tie inciiity II Immigration sno
8 | if the esowdtsd ruiliions 81 Ctana Nnos'
4 s ss.asnee. 1 xresf danger that a. no dtetan
s1av fhnf portion of our country woula q
oxerruu ~ xhein unless fxoznpt &ca2l
!. wss takcu to res,ricf 1ramt9rhtion- ~
|. people. therefore. petifionsd fo'; psofsesis
= 81 isere y rshearsed che treaty ana legials
= i've history of the Chinese question. ems
8 8 lrv with fhc Scott act ~ q the ooycez.o
=. mat fhc act is In cenft5ct with tTeaszes g
u y opinion says ls must be coacs9eaa g g
q treaty Of isoS n in confrayentlon g Nv =
~ ~ ssSs and 81 ire suppiHmsrt
y .al ts,srsx 81 1850, hat Il Il not 9
=. y sksf account invalid Or TO b reauietea
- rs enforcement treaties were q
sI. greater legal oplisAaon tnsn ee1s q a9 g
nrrsnanec thereof ana irestzes msae una
me authority OF the Guitea HAx<e are 3
snurerne law Of the land. Ard No "a
- mount authority i given g one ever : |!
= other. Tho last expression m g .ns s9sslss ns =
he snmesi = - am mar he legislasnse OF she gosxs
80 MONT win lightly pass laws uhich eonnl
~ ~ssh the fresfies ii the country, but g
aet strfs,, ~ nsfancc8 may arise which would
a. o1,ix justify the gosernrnent ~ disrsga
nrs snfesest nf % n sSc county shaf i ahould %
80 80 | rfs~rs fsafs IS no question Whether
~ - sTsvrrnsncrlt ID 1ustifed tn dt1regardlnx
~ 49, srirn re1neuts With another nnfoh g
~ 80 one Tor the determination of the oohryA
Re Continuing, tne epssss!ent ps.s!.t u1aS n sbess 5
ssss 6een nothing Ia the treaky beswcen cn
- snsf the Unitad 6tatesto impair TIE yHlla
/, az fke act ii eoneISsS Of tlet0bess
nts was it on any other x xros
4 al beyond the cotnpetency g ~. s1ns'
~ sssy MI wifhin tie power IL congress- W ]
D.nc 49, hfi,3f (shinevl iabOren who had n GI
i. 80 depsrted frnm the unlfed &istss III ~
- &TSfxS 1hsy IRE nI1Sn1 1s.s.<-s ,k1 =
wv mont 81 the Uniteq e:.sss s..,s",Sneenf
nm uoa u.,'ae a. slIsns from iss terrslofy y 8
limb ex@cinuc @ Men - we do not think ops
end onnom ow~rev The jurIsiiction over ils
eignt o.rsrcxr u. that extent = lntloents 80 ~
aen.s inaepciiiAzt nation y y. - - einae 81
ofted peuuss.sd Il 10 that extent
axniu it WONT - -. control u another y
medy lcc* - - p.as@sre the ruyefumezlt o. the gl
! wes a....sss e. fisroueh is leg1nleflye aeps.s1
-. .eonsiders the presence 2. ..sv sv = - Il
ing olnsessase olnsssss wiih ns, 10 be dangerous
econ aa1. asslIiis,a IA security. their exclusion
q tne - he stayed because ~ ~ $3.50 n
s,sresy actual hcstiliues Mss@ rise cxisfcr
isseas e a,sso.sssi re,ader the netxt<sify g
~. a,,fv more obvious au'1 pfssAn8
!. ,.,s s.on me orressss.ssIty in = less tycsAne
.ssv sriee whau WSf does llot exass !. - I
! Den as,,s,e authority which eoy'laksu t.,1 ~
:. sisv il one case must asts ,a-s.;,s. snaac
"ffer. In both csseA ~ Jssss - ''e'-'-
" ~ concluSiye upon tne " jl.I ! ,..s.,strx az
Hiakc n fhe government "a 2 1..e N. -
he in- .bn torcirners exclu'led az M snu,rsss "
DE VIZ - ee.sss - She executisc head o. OUT
louss y pisx1s ~ resoft f0 An3 otnck y
tempssu msns " sr ifa iudgment. nn =
wn1sG9Lss.s,v Slemerd. aud there hes
% u.scs The rouer Of the govern
'tss's nsss,sxs foreigners from the eoAnss 3,
a. e8eo sxsr IA its Judgment the pvpasm = sas -
he Mem. ssrs,ss Il. has been asserted " ~ TO-
hot and 1ees.res. and never denied y s''1 =
"a then - legislative depeisstasm.,ss s s.,s,,son =
jealousy. In concluas1s. ss.s ~ fofcirners b
'oas.. "A pow ossS.re ~ sovsreignty Of the Hefs
ould gaxn al the un..s- u''ss-s SsIexafcd By tho
II unlons erelxn Pnsssss q, - exercise ~ {
. runs ton. as rs s,<s indxrocnt Of the Cos
wnen n...asesxs ~ a the country
.-s~.. sns nanuof te granted
,ss . - dslss.se,s
sss city the 5snsss1 Ssl'ss 9 sny saeI gs.ssss,
aiding in not be abandoned @ = s,.s ,.srsd % NM
number oi their sxsrsisss a..s,,,s ps coca p by N
'ctlon, nss for tns f usfvets Interest,
ts.---[ 4xs.- = UuUIlE 4t+1t9