Richmond dispatch. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1884-1903, 1889-01-22

called an amendment, bUi TIE lIsusc btu had
osiy bccu iurisdic'onsl. by which the Sen.
ate bad assumed cohtrOl % the subject.
Mr.. llawlcy spoke 10 defence Of the theory
~ the bin. Mr.. Chace anayzed some Of the
st1'em'nts cOnisincd IN the secular reports
from Europe which had been u,ed a. argu.
ment. ~ opposition 20 the bill. and unani-
mons consent wa given 10 Mr. Morrill, to oc.
cupy iwcoiy minutes Tomorrow with some
remarks on the tsriG bin.
The senate then. az o'clock. took re-
cess upti z O'Clock
Tie discussion on he rico question be.
c7nr mixed up with the sugar question, and
Dir. Gibson advocated adequate protection
for boih rice aud sugar.
Nr. llo3r asked Nr. Gibson why II was
ihst instead u speaking OF the rates Of the
duty left on sugar and rice. when were 90
large a. comtaIcd with other things, they
spoke - the bin ii-cii A. 'sODberT." II 10
was iobbey y, were not sugar and rice the
greatest robbers lefli
Nr. Gibson 0iselslmed h,ying character
lied the tariff as robbery. lie md alwafs
said tbat The benefits and burdens Of the
tariff should Do cQu1lzcj. There Should be
40 discrimination. he did no, ask for any
greslef protection for the Interests which he
represented than he was viking 70 sccord 10
the Interests Of other sections. lie was far
from being free trader. L 70 hc was not 10
favor u u.iug the poTor % The Government
t1 favor one interest a. the expense OF tho
other interests, or one section al the expense
o. the other sections.
Sir. AldrlcA asbed Mr.. Builer whether he
theught taat rice required the present pro-
tccuvc dg,y Of ll3 per cent.
Mr. Butler ihought Il I'D not.
Mr.. hisrch: How much duty would you
say ~, rightly
Nr. Bnter: 'bink the rates fixed In the
Mills biil would be "a view OF the rates on
other ariiclesl about right.
Mr.. hlduch: Isi that amount OF protection
necessary Tor tine production " rice?
Mf. Butler: | cannot say thn IL is sbsO-
luteiv necessary. II Won reduce The rates on
everything else we arc willing 90 have The
tarG on rice - per- cent.
SIR. Ncst quoted the statement made by
COiopir9ler Ireoholm before the House
Commttec on Wsys and Means to now that
the cJet Of labor on the rice plantations l.,
equal ID niue.lcntl- % The cost Oi rec. and
he commented upon the fact that OF the pro-
posed reduction ~ The cXistlng duty one
bon would TAN q ION The peculiar wards d
Che senators on The other sdr, who voted
me Republican ti.kct with unsnimity and
p0iinaHfy Undivided ~ political eXpe.
r.ouce.
8fr. Butler susgcrted % Nr. Aldrich That
So need not loec bis ~.ccp by worrying over
Che diforencr- OF opinion between himself
fBuu.D lCl tle ~eustOr from Geareia, nor
should hc indulge in too mrch hllarit7 on
that point senator's on ihe Temperate sac
would be- very apf to "0Op' very closely
together on tnc hul. tic senator from lthoue
Island should rather d vote himself to 10 '0u-
cling some ut'c differences ON his own side I;
Tor Instance, ON lhe iron schedule and on tie
lumber schedule. The senator fiom hsn,2s
fNr. Plumb h't been manliestin- some a.
aIc 60 a' 'uicWuCcnl ana 10 "',I on ni@
orh ho'h.. Ana '"' No uhuefst."u' n@u 'ne
-eha'of from Nffaski lNi' hiuN' SOM
The senator bad Shown o'ch,'pnal spA'm'
% irdr"-unes''' and had ll1"i''t'd some
r.ne 90 sc' tI'a ll-''" cone 10 'u'n ~, '','-
t.INcEoH. -I 'h%' tnr ''u''li ''" r'N'
land hAs sD1u' as m1ch as he ''N.a go -
aftp la'se s'"' cm'H 'i'"iS H. "l,l. 10.
iog TIE hn- and rom'rg 10 'ht it''o'IA 'l'
s'er OF ~ '".V.'TI ID ,',o.' ~,
enres iafrc. Hf ,HF' hu'ei "'u'' 'c ,"U
tO see The b.iI 80 a'f9u-eH 90 TO- uo"ini' rus
i.c lo every industry ne oH'y i"'"1 WIZ, .
h" l-'s'l op l.r nee scheu"'o "~' .u~, ,u'
l'ics pfop.s'1 'n 'n' t"p''i.1ls WIZ " -
uhlsI' euH uNr4utl 'l "fei "'o"'
H''fi lHai l'' INTENTION u. wv ''', .., Z
'''i''''t'e W. I'D "''' '',o" -, o,r
s"s" ""' D'''I .',. ,-o,,,
-'' W.. 49,, .',,,',,. ,,ror,.,,ions
49, .' ,'.,.'.',t,,. on lns I'm
Ti,e, vere fsr.
u'' NV "',''', 1'' ,,.l'' .,.. .,,,,,-..
o'''' "Oni 'F'""'"S W. ."" IT,,
ON i't "ih'I sue .H'" 'e''' ~, '.'.
INC masters Oh 'Ne I'''N"'IcA" '."'' "'."
1855 uus''. ana o"I p'IatV"s "o"" ~
tho'- senators "A'e" ~ 40 '',''.l -
''rh I'D - sta' u' 200" 30 IN, ~
l'N'' Hn0 "'' ''' '"'"E1 'i ~ u" ~.'' ,,..
lhew lo purchase N"','' lpe '.i''' W.
u'''""u 'D,. ,'.''.i.,..', ,o,,a,or tbe
,'"h , - "a ,ro,,,,,.-
ia, h"' &c" "" u ,nr .nN mr..
.tor. I'm tJ,c.s of
wa, ."7 NJ. s.c,.
1--WE w -, 49,. s,r., ~, ,r..
'"'' ".'' ~'..~ '' .,. -, r,,,', t,o
,''i'"t 80 v', ,,,,o ,,,n,fs,.
i'' "'" '''" 'i. DO '"N' 'l, .1.r,t,.
l"t,l'I ""'" ~ ~, l''' a.. ,', -.
u" 49, '' Wv '"S nv -, ".'' W - a., ~
ana oup'ib ""A' We nav ot,i.+, -
'.''. lrH IuI 49, '-. -. -,
inc "','; n'nA'O's " .'5 p"i ,'.rh.I N
'"u'd uol ne 'olut J. .u, ,Ie, ~.