Wheeling register. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1878-1935, 1889-05-14
PIPES-M'C0Y TRIAL.
[Oontinned froa FonrM Raqe.

Q.-Before that hos much cash did yoI
receive yearly? A.-Wen, last TIVE
years DR.. Reed and / prscticed tOgethe
we took in about $1,000 or $4,000. Tit
receipts the THREE las; years were large
than before. The largest business We eve
did was in 1885.
Q Preceding the three yelrs you men
tioh y hat were the cash rec, ip's: how would
it run? A.-Well it wnuld run, the first
three years, f'om $500 t. So. 500 a year
Q-You we're together six ears? A
Seven.
Q.-When you said your business had
fallen off 81, 900 10 81 500 per year, what
did YOU near? A 1t is that much less.
l used 10 have CASES from ont the r. & O.,
from Pennsylvania and Ohio, and they
have d oppat off. ! attribute it 10 this
trouble.
Odd you meau you ;cok 10 that much
less in cash receipts, or your business fell
ell that much, stree 1887? Any bust
ness has b. en- that much less. Cash re-
ceipts have fallen IF several hundred dol
lars. We we're making about s., 600 each,
ina setual cash receipts. 1t has fallen off a
cool thousand dollars, es near Us | can tell.
. Doctor, what IL your estate worth?
TObiected to by Capt. Dovener; Mr.. Cald-
we'll said he wanted h show the plRiotif,s
general standing; obi ction Overruled.
Al think about $1,000 cash would buy
me out after paying ali debts
Q.-DlctOr, Whist does your estate con
sist Of? Objected 70 by Mr.. Russell; sus-
tanned
Capt DOyener-Now. / move YOU tn he
permitted TO ex amine Mrs Lyle. OBJ
iected to by Mr. Geo B. Caldwell ! Capt.
DOvener-Wait till your turn to reply
comes Mra. Lyle is studying medicine
in Cincinnati, and is about to be examined.
she is detained here
Mr. Geo B. Caldwell said he was re-
lactantly compelled object He did
rot wasn't TO detain the lady here against
her will, but re could no, hat resist the
request. Besides, he did not want %
tumble the case up by calling Wit
nesses ont Of their regular order
The Clurt-What do You expect tC
prove?
Captain DOvcner-The deposition by
MIS-. LYLE did not reach here until the
second day of this trial. We knew the
deposition might be objected to and We
brought the lady on, thus giving the
other side the benefit OF cross-examination.
The deposition is short and deals with the
camp meeting at Independence. Mrs.
Pines told her story of the conduct of Miss
Stephens aud Dr.. Pipes, saying the two
we're together all day, and that, in fact,
she could only catch glimpses Of them
lodging around, etc. Now, We want 10
prove by Mrs. Lyle that there is no truth
in that statement.
Responding. Mr. Caldwell said he
wasn't so sure he wouldn't wait Mrs.
LYLE on his side of the case as we'll. From
what he could learn she might be ma
tsrial witness for the defense. He did
Dot think the trial should be broken in on
aud matters sent along irregulsrly.
After some further discussion on both
sides the Court said the defendant had 3
7 ght to object 10 such Sd irregulsrity, but
at the same time he thought discretion
aad common sense ought to he used. He
would allow the examination of the wit
ness this morning.
DR. M'COY RECALLED
Q-what did Prof Orsgo say? Ale
sud he wanted to talk to me about some
The tes cheers in the school, and asked me
il I had heard Of the intimacy between
Or Pipes ard some of the teachers
said had heard of sn intimacy between
Dr. Pipes and Miss Greenlee He said
that intimacy existed up to the present
time, nd he had learned it had been car.
"a krhf X
Captain Dovener, who thought Prof Cragc
would be tle best witness "a to what ne
knew; argument; allowed. He thought
there ought to be an investigation. He had
heard DR.. Pipes and Miss Greenlee had
been caught IN compromising positions
positions no teacher ought to be found in
and did not want to he connected with
a school in which such teachers were en-
ployed. II she were still employed, be
would no longer remsin in the school as
It's principal
Who did he say he had heard this
from? A.-Mrs Pipes and Dr. Reed.
Odd be mention any other teacher
A -Yez, Miss Stephens. He said one wa'
Is had ~ the others He said DIR. Pipe'
Rad been known to 20 TO Mics Greenlee'
residence, and stay there an ho1r or more
when MS professional duties did not cal
him. He did not specify day or night
He eaid Mrs. Pipes had forbade Mis-
GreeDlee 10 visit her house, that she had
been in the habit of visiting their resi-
dsuce, but that Mrs. Pipes had orderat
her ont Of the house. Motion 10 strik,
cut by Capt Dovener; argument; allowed
Q-Where were the Doctor and Mrs
Pipes liyiuget that timt? A.-They were
- Notion to exclude by Mr.. Russell
argument; allo ged forthe present, but no.
pushed
Q.-Whst, if anything, did Prot. Cragt
sag tba' Mrs Pipes mad told him abou
| Miss Greenlto having any kn wledg'
about when the plaintiffs wife would b'
abssut from home? objection BY MI
Dovener and argument; sustained.
The offer of the defense was then takeT
down, and objected 20, and after argu
meat Court adjourned.