The Memphis appeal. [volume] (Memphis, Tenn.) 1886-1890, 1889-02-13
WITNESS BEACH.
His CrOSs-Examinatiou is Continued.
He Recltes His Testimony With
the Ease and Grace
That Marked His Evidence on the
First Days of His Examination,
And for Such Doubtful Stories as
h Tells It is Very Gally.
Tho Full Text OF II Letter From John
Dewey Ia civ ,u-LeCaron Insists
on the Dynamite Proclivities
OF Parnol and His Friends.

LoNnoN, Feb i2-rhc cruys.cvamlnation
Of lie Carou, the witness for the Thas,, was
coutinucc upon the resumption OF the sit-
| ting OF the rurncl Commission today. lilo
said hc had visited Europe five times since
1867, sumctimrd in professional capacity.
aud sometimes unprufcssionally lie re-
ported himself To the authorities ON each
occasion, except In 1861 Neither Mr..
o'kclly nor Mr. rarucll had ever written
To him. The Fcuians expelled Mr. O'Kclly,
| witness said because he had Joined with
! Mr. IarncIl iu the open movement. O'Loary
! denounced Mr. Okclly. Witness believed
| that o'Lcary was a violent opponent of the
! League. Continuing, witness said hc de-
! lNurrd scaled packets from Mr.sfs pcyuy
! and q. Lvary 10 MI l. gan IN Paris iu 1881,
aud ACKNOWLEDGED that the security ui tho
! SEALS alone prevented him from opening the
/ packet, lie again saw Mr. Esau iu Amer.
lea In 1883 Later Mr. Exam introduced
! him Co Mr. flrncll Ia the lobby Ut tho
! House of Commons. ne cou,crscd with
MI PHrnrIl aul was complimtntcd by him
un hi, work The Irish Republican Broth.
rrhu'd W., thDn opposing Mr. rarncll M far
us the homo organization was concerned.
NJ lumrll complained Of thi, opposition.
and ,uil ilut the home and sister urtlniza.
uuus would have been crippled had they not
"O,o,u'd assistance from America Al Mr.
| lArurh request, u,r Nt,uu,. s,y ury.,.,,,J
! sullivan aud two uthrra Wa N,o.,,.., a..
| did not write the result ut Dis conversations
with these men Ia Mr rarucll because he
! had not been requested to. Moreover, E.un
! bad instructed Nitur,, 60 write o. him
Ntuyss', conversations with Parupll had
uu reference CO. I-Iu Tho most important
par. of Mr. PHrurlIs conversation concerned
his views Us % liu,ulutiuuist H. declared
thui hv did not see why 1u Iusurrrcflou
should hu unsuccessful Wiluo,. bad heard
this before from lelu. but. coming from Mr.
laru,'l. % startled him.
Sir charles Russell. counsel Tor Toe Far.
uullitr-. and ~.r Henry james. counsel for
the Imu. here announced TINT they had
agreed mot tp produce the document. which
Wrtr ihu subject ui discussion un friday
| la.t.
The Government u1id viiuc.s f2uoo bc.
] tween February. l-l. to August l,5u ITO
! spent every cent uf thi. Tor pibIic purposes
for instance hc iUok John - Nrillt J. -. 4.
ibr GO ~ ave his reputation and 10 keep
him inum huyuutiuEu dDiaultor This action
gave witness % strong hold upon u'Nrill.
llr hii spUut moro than De- bad received 100
co.. public srtyirr llc had made no M.
engagements lur iutur' rrNuui The v z.
organization. which numbered TiWn utufn.
hrrs deliberately unl knowingly, supported
the dynamite policy IN The convention Il
t.sl lu' ct the delegates prrsCut favored
thr usD ct dynamite The convention held
Doe Madison Square Garden, \. y. in iSSt.
advocated the dynamite policy Sullivan,
luWn.ury, truuIu, ~WN The. Suanluu. nick,
luiluuE Wud Crane were present AZ the con-
Nyutiuu
IYsst was expelled from the organization
| iur iusuhuui nation. lir wanted g. rule ur
| ruin. The connection between The Supreme
| council and the ~. g." wns nptufrI 20
the boston convention iu tssi each ursuui.
Hi'un ,liimiurtu bp tlD legitimate body.
NJ Iuurll requested witness a. write a.
uryuy. sullivan. Hines aud Carroll since
his examination in chief Wituos. had r.
,uINVd from America one ~ bgyuN's orig
iuil lriiun. % was d.trl "OnOu uf James
i,oyuulds. No. iiunngc .ircct, New Haven,
June o.. 1851"
Mr. Asuuitb. q counsel Tor Mr. rancu,
objected fn the introduction ul the letter.
Attorney General Webster explained that
the letter showed what pa,scd between
uryuy aud IT, tarun concerning what Mr..
Ilwrll bad Instructed H. tlrun a. DO.
The letter va. admitted as evidence. II
read
"Dnr Friend Z ann sorry wa OBLIGED 10
goo o. NrW York uu saturday. I dIi not rc.
rrINp your l.iirr until I returned last night
I thank Kuu Tor your Information md for
tHr interest YOU take Boo r. matter INu,iInr Us
900 Hu closely. have boot yyt hr1ri ifum ~.
.mrtuiuH liuu| received yesterday a
short note FROM O. IWytuiur lmHI strongly
urF.uF my tI .Htu. over. but cannot under.
stand Why until I rul your explanation. l
would likr iu conn, il could sp1ru doe Time,
aud II my visit would produce The effect
. 4 81 a fUHH
not spuIt fpF uuyhpiy. no man could speak
iUr ihr ~ e. without authority which 10
would tHLr time tu r,i None UIu guarantee
HuffHiuF Cor chose 900 ihr other side Who are
hostile bIi who ir.l certain, dD not rep.
uaHui thH upiu.uuU Toe humr organization.
There r'u uy Do" chance there until there Is
re- yhluHHul pHruu.. which d. sure iu r1Wr be-
time. An could dp would hr tp i,ll T.. aud
T.. |mpuIus lJrl uiUuu wy own responsible.
itN WHHt will satisfy our friends and make
pfuru.It might iDUl morally certain they
would Ur approved buf I would nl un rr'
count have tbym UIv my ryrfuHH. which
would place mr boo 90 iIIs" position have
asked our friends advice hrrH a' iH NhgIh,r
iIry think it thH right Thing iu uH. They
will consider doc Natter Hut don't ihiuk
NOW Chat .hIlI I" .I advised. lN'N TAR
uUIl aud U|H UUtUI. .lrW 90 WiauHdDui ud
tbr dI..fIIsHrfiuu hrw. 10 ia cau.gl NOT ~
tl,.fu.uHu boo lr land, but 10y t.r action
ulmH Opinions dIIrr little uU essential
points hut Vr cannot tolerate Oh" Kind %
ihing begun n uunllo. ! Will write again.
NuurH. JOIN II'"h
LrClnn sid ihl. "Ihg Kind oi hing be-
eln boo UuuHIo. related tu Che u.uc.aiion
uI 49, uawr|Is friends boo ate" Uius 10
druu.. luI disrupt Goo revolutionary OMAN
l..f.un lf thr hrg UuIug ~ tuc convention.
SO reference was intended tu tur protests
made Ht Buffalo HHH.ust violence aud crime.
Tho Wiur.. tdru.Hri the alleged speech by
~. pH.lL UIyIUus in tho lI..ih dclrf-
m.u4fIuu o. "sIlrf Iuu last link binding Ire.
land DO Eu#nud' II also testified that on
tbH u..I..uu ut Alexander sulliNans trial
mr murder. sheriff ArUcw, who NIs mem.
Der ui Ilu secret Organization, selected hnl
"uNpl the Jury. Sullivan Nu leqniticd
uu the ground that hr shot The m'n KILLED
fur nu,Jntiur bis v,ie, and that % was cAso
OF jusuhahlo homicide.
This ended the examination or the Nit
ness Upon leaving thc stand u lron 'aid
ho wished o. apologize u he hnd been Ia.
pr-iIurpL ilr iii not know thc rules ~
,br court H. thanked al Tor Che courtesy
tIttI.I been shown him. saluied the brueh
and HIf anil Tote thc courtroom.
The court tl,u -iiouncd