davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
Workmen's advocate. (New Haven, Conn.) 1883-1891, 1889-03-09

root Of any growth, such reason is far
weightler than that of prudence and wis
dom.
Would Prof, Garside destroy any ne
cessary feature of the present system,
such as capitalist or public institution
i'll private hands, for any reason what
ever?
The Professors whole object appears
to be to reconcile anarchists and social
lists, worthy but quite hopeless task.
Such statements as the following are
POOR reconcierS:
''On the other hand the phrase, 'egit-
innate means Of agitation, is lust as
puerile as amy and all means. There are
no Legitimate MEANS if society and
those who oppose us are to Judge; they
would stop meetings, gag speakers, and
stop expression of opinion, if it were not
for fear Of an accidental application of
some statute hidden by the cohwebs
gathered since the antediluvian period"
The socialists know what they are do
ing when they use the term "legitimate
means Speaking and writing, wheth
III condemnation of old methods or sys-
TENS, or in advocacy of new, are legiti-
mate. The law, if enforced, guarantees
and protects them. To prevent the ad-
voCacy of any doctrine except the doc
trne of destruction. is illegitimate. But
anarchists have seen fit to confuse the
law and the maIadministration of it,
making both seem the same evil ele-
ment; and Prof, Garside appears to en-
dorse them.
Those who oppose us" may declare
us outlaws, but that does not make us
SO, when the law is clear. ! might in
Quire how those who declare our agita-
ton illegitlmate, are afraid to stop us.
on account Of some law now covered
with cobwebs) which would prove us
legitimate?
Nor do they go back of the deluge for
the laws that protect us; the Constitu-
ton is sufficient to restrain them, if
they be restrained; if not, they are the
law breakers.
Prof. Garside rejects evolution except
as crystalizer of thought. "rhe change
will occur during IA crisis, he says, "and
1t must be a total change; an absolute
reconstruction We are to fail if "un-
prepared" There is no analogy in his
tory from which to infer such sudden
change. If we attempt any wholesale
reconstruction not warranted by the
gradual processes of evolution, we ought
to fail.
| refuse to believe that the present
system, as a whole, is Fastening to sud
den ruin, Public functions are gradu-
ally being taken from private hands;
hence the doctrine of Malthus could not
be ''inevitabe.' The doctrine of NAL
thus is false, and will be false under
any conditions; for if people starve un-
der monopoly, it is not the unproduc-
uvenes3 of nature that causes want,
which is the real ''dOCtrine Of Malthus."
"The conflict, if any, will be forced
upon the laborer by the governing
classes"
/ This is not soCialistic doctrine. So
cialsts expect to become the political
power, and any rebellion must come
from deposed monopolists and exploit
ers. Prof. Garside reverses the pro-
cess
What is meant by the "preparation"
which is so necessary to suCcess2 How
will lack of preparation be ruin when
"the socialist is on neutral ground; he
simply stands, offering to men the solu-
ton of the problem ?" zENO.
Workmen's advocate. (New Haven, Conn.) 1883-1891, 1889-03-09
COMMUNICATIONS.

NOTICE TO GORREsPoSDE rite pam,
boil down" your letters; make them short,
Write only on one side of the paper Be as good
natured as you can be under the Giro um
stances.
To the Workmen'S AdUOcute
have read Prof. Garside's outline of
his position regarding force in the AD-
vOCATE of the 23d ult., and will say that
if | understand him correctly, | should
refuse to allow him, as official lecturer,
to represent me and the doctrine |
hold. He says:
81 consider force, or propaganda of
deed to be unwise and imprqdent,
Consider the feeble handful of men"
etc.
Shall we infer that he would Justify
''propaganda of deed if lie thought it
prudent,
In the column adjacent to the above,
| read:
"In all things the present arises from
the past; the newer is derived from the
older, the higher has its root IN the
lower"
This seems to me the true doctrine.
If evolution forbids us to destroy the
Workmen's advocate. (New Haven, Conn.) 1883-1891, 1889-03-09

Catholics denounce faith healers, but
are untiring in wheedling people to visit
their shrlnes for miraculous cures.
The difference is that n one case the
money gets into their pocket and in the
other into that Of somebody else. -
Truth Seeker.
The Daily bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Hawaii]) 1882-1895, 1889-05-27
CUR SUM MARY.

The Bulletin Weekly Summary
will lie out tomorrow morning, an
exceedingly interesting numrer. 1t
will contain amongst other things
the only complete account of the
ball to the officers of the Cormorant,
the celebration of Queen Victoria's s
birthday, and The memorial service
at Cent al Union Church, the report
in full Of the committee on the new
Central Union Church, The rifle en-
campnient, cricket and baseball
matches, organ recital, news from
the other islands and editorial mat
ter. Several hundred extra copies
are being printed to meet the de-
mand for tAis valual lie summary of
local and island news. Leave your
orders carly so as not to be dis
appointed.
The Daily bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Hawaii]) 1882-1895, 1889-05-27
The SAVINGS DEPOSIT.

Nothing can be more evident than
that the Advertiser finds it impos-
Bible TO break the force of our main
contention regarding the Postal Saw
in9s Bank deposits-namely, that the
existence of so large fund lying
idle in the treasury is serious
wrong to the taxpayers. 1t is pitt
able to see the attempts of that
journal to evade the chief points
at issue. On Saturday it raised a
quibble as TO the cost of the deposit
to the Government, saying the esti-
mate of one percent for running ex-
penses Of the Savings Bank was eX-
cessive. The fact is that, in our
previous remarks, an item was over
looked which when admitted makes
the cost come near seven percent
instead of stopping short of six. All
moneys in hand in excess of three
hundred dollars are liable to taxa
tion of one percent in this kingdom,
but deposits in the Savings Bank
are exempt from taxes. When the
remitted taxes upon all deposits
over three hundred dollars are add
ed to interest paid depositors and
running expenses, it will be found
that six percent is away below the
actual cost of the institution to tn,
taxpayers.
The Daily bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Hawaii]) 1882-1895, 1889-05-27
A COMING SALE.

Mr.. j. f. Morgan will hold an
important sale on Wednesday at his
salesroom, when will be offered
eight cases of stuffed birds, several
volcano pictures and pastels, shells,
curios aud coral, also two of the
moHo or wingless Hawaiian birds.
There is likely to be considerable
competition for the latter, as they
are very rare. The cases of s,uffro
birds are now on exhibition at Mr..
Morgan's rooms and are attracting
considerable attention.
The Daily bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Hawaii]) 1882-1895, 1889-05-27
KAR0LkkI WON.

Quite a number of sportsmen
were out at Kapiolani Park on
Saturday afternoon to witness a
half mile dash for 500 a side, be-
tween Hon. j. A. Cummins' Kaao-
laui and j. Ouderkirk's Rockwell.
Messrs. C. o. Berger, l.. Won
Tempsky and Captain Ahlborn Of
ficiated as judges. A fine start
was effected and the horses ran
even for about fifty yards, when
Kaaolani took the lead and never
being headed won easily by two
lengths. Time / :51 l-5.
The Daily bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Hawaii]) 1882-1895, 1889-05-27

What the actual amount of the
burden is may only be arrived al
approximately, yet with sufficient
exactness for all legitimate arsu-
ment. According to the Finance
Minister'S statement of receipts and
expenditures for the year ending
March 81, 1889, it would appear
that, out Of the Postal Savings Bank
deposit in the treasury, the sum of
Sl92 020.42 had been expended
for general purposes under Sec. 3
of the Appropriation Act. The nu-
merous items to make up this
amount have been expended from
day to day as required, and the in
terest thereon is undoubtedly legi-
innate charge on the revenge for
public works throughout the entire
couRtrE any benefits from which
are felt by the nation more or less
generally. The precise time that
this S192, ,020.42 has been used by
the Government we are unable to
state, but for the purpose of Illus
tration let us say six months. Then,
at six per cent. we have interest to
the amount OF S5.760.6l. Now, the
difference between this Legitimate
charge of 5,760.61 on the revenue
and the amount of SIG, ,475.72, total
interest paid out to Postal Savings
Bank depostors TO April lst, 1889,
is Sl0,715.11, and represents the
actual loss to the treasury on the
surplus deposits held by it and fol
which the Government has no use
This ten or eleven thousand dollars
is therefore in plain terms an indi
rect but heavy tax on the genera
tax payers of Hawaii Nei, for which
they receive not one atom Of return,
to enable The treasury to pay to the
few depositors in the Postal Savings
Bank the five per cent interest on {
capital that is exempt from taxation
and which had piled up in the trea
sury over and above all require
ments, in the sum of $206, ,O05.56 tt
April 1st of this year.
The Daily bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Hawaii]) 1882-1895, 1889-05-27

The foregoing remarks, although
called for by the Advertisers fight
at a tangent from the main issue,
are not meant as urging the adop.
tion of a policy of. having public
fluids manipulated by the banks. 1t
is part of our contemporaries dis
honest tactics to misrepresent our
suggestion of an alternative to that
which we most emphatically advo-
Gated, as being the burden of our
discussion of the question regarding
the existing wrong of the Govern
ment's holding a large amount Of
private money in idleness at a
heavy cost to the taxpayers. Our
plan was TO have the money expend-
ed in reproductive public improve
ments, and the Advertiser simply
initiates instead of instructing this
paper in that respect. But adc-
quate provision has not been made
Ivy the Government and Legislature
for such employment of the deposit,
and the result is heavy burden of
unnecessary taxation upon the peo-
pie.
The Daily bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Hawaii]) 1882-1895, 1889-05-27

Perhaps the existing Banking Act
GSS4), making provision for the
chartering of banking companies,
could be amended so as to bring it
up to the requirements of a national
banking system. An item IN the
Appropriation Act would make
banks under such a system avail
able for helping the Government
out of such predicament as the
present one. The Advertiser refers
TO experiences of the Government
with banks (which ought to serve
as an effectual warning" 1t prob
ably refers to the silver currency
matter, but there is not the slightest
doubt that, unless remedy be
promptly applied, the Savings Bank
is going to cost the country as dear
ly as the currency. There was one
experience, however, with private
bankers here, in which the Govern
ment of the day was enabled TO save
the country from impending and,
for the time being, absolute ruin.
In short, the Advertisers attempted
scare against banks acting for the
Government is about as sensible as
would be \ howl against private con-
The Daily bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Hawaii]) 1882-1895, 1889-05-27
NOTICE.

THE par ship her. tofOre existing
between Sa n Quai, Chang Lung
ana ring HIN, doIng carpenter business
under The finn II" me 0I Tick Lang
Chong, has been dissolved, Sam Quai
srllIna on his ln'erel 10 The oih.r Iwo
lhc remaining n.t ers of The said firm
OF Tack Lung ChOng will continue sid
nuslLes Under The finn name of Tuck
Lang Gh"ng, and hereby give notice
'hAl 'hey wi no. lie responsible. TOR any
dch'N contracted by sam Quai in the
name of
TUCK LUNG CHoNG.
Honolulu, Nj. "a, SO 81 lw@
The Daily bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Hawaii]) 1882-1895, 1889-05-27

In this mornings issue the "Ad-
vertiser" devotes a paragraph Of
some length to discussion of what
the BULLETIN means by "local
banks" as if there was any veiled
Specification in the term. The Ad-
vertiser considers he''policy" of en-
ploying the banks as agencies for put
ting Government funds into profitable
use as contrary to every sound busi-
ness principle and entitled to no IA
vorable consideration whatever"
The oracle who utters this dictum
does not give single reason, how
ever, why anybody should accord it
any favorable consideration what
ever" 1t is, indeed, dead against
the policy of the United States and
countries that have adopted her ad-
mittedly best banking system of the
world.
The Daily bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Hawaii]) 1882-1895, 1889-05-27
WANTED

DY Young Portuguese who will give
- good security FIR hi, conduct. u
sitnn' ion r. stone will make himself
useful at any kind of store or office
work. Apply to
GONSALVES & CO.,
lhS lw* Queen street.
The Daily bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Hawaii]) 1882-1895, 1889-05-27
SALE


~ undersi med ha> disIrainrd the
go ds ANA cna iels Il Chung Lung,
Nu'"uu ,tmci, fur arrears Ell rent, and
lha he said good, ana chat!eis will he
sod nj Puhllc Auction N he >ale,r0 IN
of las. + MCrga', Honolulu on SATUR
DAY, Junr4j h. ut 10 o'clock A. NJ 10
sa'l.fy said al ears OF enr.
l.. A-EU,
LIST OF ARTICLES:
loilel, cutter, roller, 8 tools, | long
cu'ler, pun hes and chlsels, wise. pipe
ho der, rquare 3 anvils, sci mallets,
| e cutter, Sec. i'o >, 2 hammers, |
wrench, pair cutters, 3 tnngs, l -hovel,
'row bar, dust pans, 81 dish p ms, 4
ketIle', di'hes, IL kettles, milk pans,
7 7milk pm S. Il milk cans, TO ches.
2Ih g.
The Daily bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Hawaii]) 1882-1895, 1889-05-27
NOTICE.

/ HAVE this day sold TO MpssrS.
l. Wight BIOS, my sole right, title
ahu interest in the premises known MS
me "Oid foSe frrmise,," 10 and 8
hing street where my success ,rs W III
accomNlish everything in the carriage
anu blacksmith trade TO the Satisfaction
OF the public. A. X. WEIR.
The Daily bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Hawaii]) 1882-1895, 1889-05-27

Oh, but our contemporary says
the local concerns are constituted
only of "private parties doing a
banking business" s"-tthey are nell
ther of them banks in the ordinary
meaning Of the word" Waving
reference to the absurd and puerie
inaccuracy of the latter quotation,
the argument (O of the Advertiser
is simply begging the question with
a vengeance. In the endeavor to
clinch it's point it even steals one of
the ruling ideas of our suggestion,
and one which we plainly if briefly
expressed. 1t does so in these
words: "They" (the local banks)
"are subject to none of those whole
some and compulsory restraints
which every well-considered bank
ing act throws around the institu-
tions organized under its provis-
ions" We distinctly suggested
legislation as prerequisite to the
possible adoption of the policy in
question. 1t really looks as if the
Advertiser is expressing, what in its
case is traitorous, want of conf
dence in the men who have the di-
rection of the nations finances,
when it cites the absence of legisla-
tion as an insuperable obstacle to q
state banking system.
The Daily bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Hawaii]) 1882-1895, 1889-05-27
NOTICE of REMOVAL.

A LEX. FLOaR, Lock & Gunsmith,
"A has rmpy,d opposite in the pre-.
lis occu led f"ImerIy by Max Eckart
- II very slOle, next door 10 Hof.
sch aeger d Co, in the Damon Block,
Bethel street. 240 1m
The Daily bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Hawaii]) 1882-1895, 1889-05-27
LOST

AsEssa DETWkEN r, bello lane and
20 ID Fort street ,choOl, IL pair
ui =. ocjacles The dnder viii
be rewarded ON leaving the article at
this office, 258 81
The Daily bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Hawaii]) 1882-1895, 1889-05-27

Germs being given contracts for pub
lie works, as security would be ex-
acted m'the former case as rigidly
as in the latter.
The Daily bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Hawaii]) 1882-1895, 1889-05-27

T. S-Writh Bros y ,iill ,rry on
,helr business On or str eL, LeXr -
Lucas's Planning Mill
Honolulu, May 81, 1882 255 Ivy
The Daily bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Hawaii]) 1882-1895, 1889-05-27
SPECIAL NOTICE.

SAN FRANCISCO, CAL,
February 10, 1870
WE herewith certify that Messrs.
thorized and only agents for the Ha-
saiian Islands for the sale of our Lager
Beer H. kegs.
JOHN WIELAND BREWING CO.,
l00tf John Ii. Wieland bies.
The Daily bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Hawaii]) 1882-1895, 1889-05-27
READ THIS +!

WE take Photos fer s5 rrr Dozen
w and are srlIing fine ',lnnl views
fol 81 90 per zel wiit ~ very best
finish j. A, G0NSALVES,
800 1m l29 Fort street.
The Daily bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Hawaii]) 1882-1895, 1889-05-27
NOT ICE.

A NY Quarter y Bills to March 81.
N lsS9, due bs the Hawaiian Car
riaae acluriug Co. will lie pad
ON presen alton
f. G. SCHUMAN,
257 lw Manager, II. q. M. Co.
The Daily bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Hawaii]) 1882-1895, 1889-05-27
X. w. WILCOX,
Civil Engineer and Surveyor,

Also sole agent for the Magic Window
Screens, Combined Bevel squares, Stan.
dard, Goodrich e'c., SewIng Machines,
Bicy cles, Iricy cles, Velocipedes, etc.
oliic :, corner of Bethel and King sts,,
upstairs. Apr-l7 S9.1 Y
The Daily bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Hawaii]) 1882-1895, 1889-05-27
David Dayton

Will practice in the lower courts of the
Kingdom as attorney, attend to collect.
,ug In all lis branches, renting of houses
aud any other business entrusted to him.
omce-9l King Street Upstairs.
Feb $50
The Daily bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Hawaii]) 1882-1895, 1889-05-27
FOR SALE

NEW and 81 cnDd hand Billiard
IN Tables, Apply 10
200 j. z. POWEN.
The Daily bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Hawaii]) 1882-1895, 1889-05-27
% LET

.sa a A HOUSE with large and
kS1EGA IA 2 small r" ms with XII
1YTab chen MI ba hroom a'tnchtd
on Alakra ,Ir,eI, opposite DIR. Al ;
Waynr's. A pl, u LOhu Cook, on IRE.
,ni,es ar nj MS office. 2l9t
The Daily bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Hawaii]) 1882-1895, 1889-05-27
REAL ESTATE FOR SALE.

AAA& A va onrIsH wAHaE Of 70, Fort al and md
EfSE4 chool sueets, over 15 of an
acre with one Couag". Apply ="
olaf j. NJ. VIVAS.
The Daily bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Hawaii]) 1882-1895, 1889-05-27
telephones. No. l75.
New Zealand Jams !

UST rectiv' d u cIn iSnment of New
~ z afnnd j m. n->o ted case. For
sale nv low iii'"~ iv
J Z. BROWN & co.,
227 IT % Merchant street.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1889-01-30
citu lJropertp to get.


A --A.s-T0 LIT. --Immedikte possession
"A with steam power, elevators, and FUR
nished throughout with automatic sprlnklefs
fcr putting out IRE. large factory; corner
building i6,Z3o square fest whole 81 part I;
suitable any manufacturing business; als0
4fee otre. hoois s0xe5. MeClaye Building
uth-sys. 2lsL z1d sta
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1889-01-30
pressmakins.

nREssMAKER.-By an experienced dress.
~ maker, work by the GAY eVseihing
"DRESSMAKER,S Tribune Branch. $50
broadway. -
II RESSMARER.-A few more customers
~ BY the day or at home suits 80 up.
} S33 West 20th.st
IN RESSM AKING. Madame Bravoe, 80
- East 19th-st., makes up ball and street
speciality made OF morning ard tea gowns /:
she will be glad TO see old and new patrons.
INEXPERIENCED DREssMAKER would
~ ike more engagements; cut ut,
bias, darts, drape latest style moderate
price per day. 97s 3d-ave.. Sd bell.
II IRST-CLASs DRESSAiAKER wishes
work BY the day or at home prices
st., LIST flat
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1889-01-30
tuork tpantea.


Males.
TWO .THIRDER, age 20, wishes a s.tua.
ton In good job ONCE TO finish his
i srsoe years experience; e12 ]. j. A.,
w J. MILBANK,
W Accountant and Auditor
Post Office box 1858, New York.
Strictly nrstcass.
WoRK.--By good, respectable man
around club or hotcl take good care
Dl nofses, harness and wagons; will be
NJ. q. "a East iSih.st.
w AEON PAINTER, fast faney.striper
leJtefer and scroilif, lesires change :
oess on references no objection 10 small CT
country shop. WILLIAMS, s3 u. 1oSth-st
WYNN FIRM OF ENGINEERS con.
,.a,,n, asc'oIs or builders In any part Of the
es,D,'u,,nit.isy.-by man cf ability, age 3D. sober
Edgewater, N. j. w. -'' -
w OOD-CARVER.-By . competent and
go, sApefleneed man as foreman thor
Vughly acquainted In ell its branches draw
TX i,v ~ yi iudther particulars address
Young man OF 20 desires position With
business house 70 make himself Qener-
ally useful Address T. O., 2. o. Box $50.
New York. w
VoUNG MAN, willing 70 mako himself
usotul, wants work at anything city
or country BABC0CK, 300 East 2sth.st.
YOUNG MAN, q, desires employment: a
years experience in the dry goods /
years In the banking business best Of
references. Address INDUSTRY, Box 40,
Tribune ONCE.
V0UNG man wishes work Of any kind;
has served 2 years. at csrpentering;
also good driver best references. H. W
STEIhLE, 234 East 10Sth.st
MOUTH OF is wishes a position in whole
n sale house; Al references. g. j..
NOAH. $50 West S4th-st
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1889-01-30
Real estate TO Grrbanpe.

EITY FOR COUNTRY and country for
" city Photographs and particulars at
CONDiTS, 1,179 Broadway, near 2eth-st
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1889-01-30
Countrp l)ropsrip Go fet.


AT SOUTH ORANGE, N. J.-Hcuse,
"A eleven rooms; grounds, garden shade.
stable rent $500 yearly. NJ, L. o. Box
30. South Orange, N. J.
INOR RENT.-The large new stores on the
Il south Side OF MarketSt., east OF 18th
ST., Philadelphia they are stories in
height. with finished basement, and have
steam boilers, hydraulic freight and poasen-
ger elevators, and other modern convent
ences Apply at the ONCE Of Girard estate,
10 South 12th.st, Philadelphia. s. S.
GAVIN, Agent
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1889-01-30

W0.THIRDER, age 20. wishes situa.
5 LAC . Years experience; S12. J. j. A.,
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1889-01-30

TOACHMAH. ny coloted man GOOD.
" careful driver; understands the CIT
OF fine horses ana carriages Strictly r sogo
can riva arstclass city reference. CAL or
address ]. A.. AS 7th.avo., top nooF'
Morning appeal. [volume] (Carson City, Nev.) 1877-1906, 1889-09-14

Mat. McCabe, of New Brunswick
H., offers TO pay five dollars to any
person trorbled with bloody f1ux,
who will take Chamherlain's Collie
Cholera and d arrhoea Remedy ac-
cording to directions and does not
get well in the shortest possible
time. One half OF 25 cent bottle
of this remedy cured him of bloody
fiux, after e tried other medicines
and the prescriptions of physicians
without benefit. Mr.. McCabe is
perfectly safe in making this offer,
as more than thousand bottles of
this remedy are sold each day and
il has never been known to fail in
any case OF collie. cholera morhus,
dysentery diarrhoea or bloody fiux,
when the plain printed directions
were followed. For sale by q. G.
Thaxter.
Morning appeal. [volume] (Carson City, Nev.) 1877-1906, 1889-09-14
FRIEN ADVICE.

The editor Of the Silver State,
selecting portions Of an editorial in
the APPEAL and reversing the order
In which they wer. originally print
cd, stands on his head few min
utes, and then after reading tii>m
backwards sits down with the ut
most gravity and charges the AP-
PEAL with Inconsistency.
We dislike very very much to
charge that man with being drunk
prefsrring 10 give q simple state
ment of facts, while We leave the
readers to judge for themselves.
We hope the Silver State will delay
10 longer, but place the name of
Brother GaTdner's Temperance Ad-
voca on his exchange list. 1t needs
Brother Gardeners paper a good
deal more than it needs the AP-
PEAL.