New-York tribune., 1889-10-20
rhrtr nlne Articles of Reaon by beng le.s logieaI

Thirty nine Articles of Religion by being less logical
and less acceptable than that , -,
devout Romanists when once this promise Is conceied
II tere be upon the altar after the words OF con,
secraton no elements OF bread wine, hut Ohly the
true Christ present, thcrc Is sin in alteration But
this modern doctrine which Is now sought to be brought
P OF s 'ns seems Hoon Io nyoSe the Sey es'co Of doa
Now. sir, say that the otce oi IGe Holy Cq'hMnPn
anraon SraI from beginning 10 end There no
room in II for the vcrost suggestion Of Eucharlstic
alteration or solitary mass. Thcferore slr say that
any who, in the face OF the "qrlln3 oi Ge & oiy
which have referred will break TO atoms any rbrio
you may pass.
The Rev DR.. Gibson, of Central New-York, made
a speech in favor OF tho resolution.
I'M Burgwin by an amendment that he moved,
wanted 10 have the discussion postponed In order that
otber resolutions which probably would not binder
the House by 50 much debate should be passed
on. His amendment laid the table.
Tho Rev. Dr. Swope, Of Ncw-iork, SAID In paris
A law that can never be enforced Is a law that would
better never be enacted. There + no preacher In
this church today who, when he begins the ceebra-
ton Of the Holy Communion. knows whether there
VIII be any one TO communicate with him or NOT
The Rev Dr. Morrison moved that the discussion
be closed and the vote taken in minuo. This
was carried and Dr. IIanckol was allowed the minute
He spoke I'm favor Of concurrence. and Only occupied
thirty seconds by actual count
The remaining thirty seconds given 10 Dr.
Hart who was cut or short by the presidents gavel
when he giving the reasons why the committee
had inserted this rubric.
LEAVING THE QUESTION UNSETTLED.
On vote being taken on the question OF non
concurrence. it was found that there was small
majority against it.
Governor Prince Of Now-McXco, then moved the
following amendment: " That every Celebration OF
tho Lords supper sufficient opportunity shall be
given for all those who minded to communicated
At this stage, p. H., the usual hour for adjourn
ment arrived but ib was resolved 10 contlnuD the
session until p. IN.
The Rev. c. W. Dumbell, of TeEn@see hoped that
the amendment would not pass because it appeared
20 be utterly unnecessary. \ motion 10 lay the
amendment on the table was carried
Then DIR. Spaldng, Of California made plea for
fair play He said that II body Werc committed
o TO the sbGd isGt a e. ouche m tie os Gs He &o1ed
for postponement of the matter under consideration.
f. w. Taylor, Of Springfield, pointed out how some
tImes piiost might not find any one 10 commgncate
uncomfortable consciousness that be- had broken the
f Rev Arthur c. l. Hall of Massachusetts said
al wish 10 direct attention to one particular p0lrt
But inst may l say that haze no desire for or sym
nathv wjrI celebrations without communicates
Such rs my practice nor my desire. Aean't sucn
a pracxce l slaH use any iuluence have But
10 concur uecau5, one ~ tlis Church in lonely
Is that priest amid s the dlscouIa cement Of his work
10 be deprived 81 his communion On Sunday or Holy
day because on one Oi these occasions IA" has not
peson Pr pared TO receive Iloly communion
a. MarlAcy ee OF South Carolina. hoped the pro
posed resolution would be- voted down, bocause Il
&as in the line OF doctrine while tie nnder+anlins
that In Prayer Book changes questions Of doctrine
/ should be avoided.
! TIE Row. Dr. spqding Of California spoke against
concurrence. IAcn the dircct question or con
currcnce put 10 the vote by diocese and orders,
with the following result: DoceSes. ci"itcal yeas p
nays. % divided, lay yeas, 10, nays 49, dviGed j.
The resolution was thus lost
THE BISHOPS ALSO DIFFER.
The ninth resolution OF alteration was carried.
message was received from the House Of Bishops
| announcing the noncoucuuencc OF that llOlsc with
the House OF Deputies IN the adoption Of tie short
Office Of prayer introduced by Dr. Huntington
Dr. HUNTINGTON asked for the appointment OF a
Committee OF Conference Oh this message, which was
granted In spite OF an atiempt to LAY the motion o
/ The table.
The Boad of Missions Of the ChuIch VIII meet on
Monday night. and is 10 bc hoped ha TIE attendance
| Will be better than ON the'frst night session.
The Rev. william Il. Nam, of Nutky. H. j., who