The Daily bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Hawaii]) 1882-1895, 1888-09-12
oa gone outside Of ,uc

e.
,o .e Nidemann said there could
he no possible doubt Nawahine
knew when he was taking milk
uolu THAT Kauhi had put money in
ot- vest pocket for he asked Kauhi
n'hy.bu it was good money.
.n. G.. Brown said every mem
u nujd he perfectly satisfied in
d.. uj before recording his vote.
M NakaIeka was doubted if the
G.. .leu had li-ht to bring in
charges against Luhiaus and Nawa-
hiue. They were only told to in
yestiEate charges against Kauhi and
kamauoha.
Noble Smith read the resolution
showing the power of the commit
tee.
Noble Hitchcock had based the
minority report on the evidence
heard. He then read the evidence
of Nawahine before the committee.
Rep. Paehaole doubted whether
the House had right to eXpel men,
bers under the Constitution.
Noble Widemann said Article 81
of the Constitution reads, "The
| Legislature may punish its own
members for disorderly behavior"
If these charges were not disorderly
behavior, he did not know what was.
If they adopted resolution to tar
and feather and ride on a rail the
guilty ones, he did not think there
would be any objection.
The President announced that the
four members charged could not
vote on the recommendation of the
committee.
A vote was then taken separately
on the first, second and third recon-
mendations of the committee with
the following result on each:
Aycs-Green, Thurston, Ashford,
Wilder, Robinson, Young, Jaeger,
Smith, Waterhouse, Wight, Motley,
Wall, Townsend, Hitchcock, Bailey,
Richardson, ,Widemann, Makec, GIN.
Wilcox, Hustace, Dowsett, jr., Ka-
laukoa, Naone, G. Brown, F. Brown,
Deacon, Kamai, Mcguire, Kauhane,
Paris, Daniels, Helekunihi, Horner,
Kowainui, A. s. Wilcox, Rice, Gay,
Paehaole-3S.
NOes-0.
Rep. Nakaleka, when his name
was called said "Kanalua. He
moved to be excused but the motion
was refused. He would not record
his vote and could find no authority
for the House to make him do so.
The President instructed the
Secretary to make note on the
records Of the House that the mem.
her had refused to vote, and stated
that The member by so doing was in
contempt Of the House.
The President then announced
that Reps. Kauhi aud Kamauoha
were expelled from the House and
their seats declared vacant.
The fourth substitute rccommen-
dation by Minister Thurston was
then read.
Noble Wight failed to see that any
distinction should he made between
LuhIau and Nawahiue. He had
known Luhiau for close on thirty
eight years, and had never heard
anything against his character. At
the poll for Mobiles on Hawaii at tie
last election, Luhiau stood at the
head, which showed the esteem in
which he was held on that island.
He thought he should be censured
but not expelled.
Minister 'lhurston's substitute re-
commentator was then carried on
the following vote:
Ayes: Thurston, Ashford, Will
der, Robinson, Young, Jaeger, Wa
terhousc, Motley, Wall, Townsend,
Hitchcock, Bailey, Richardson, Wi.
demann, Makee, G. N. Wilcox,
Hustace, Dowsett jr., Kalaukoa,
Naone, c. Brown, f. Brown, Dea-
con, Kauhane, Paris, Horner, Ka-
walnut, Rice, Gay, Paehaole-30.
Noes: Smith, Wight, Kamai, Ma
guire, Daniels, Helekunihi, A. S.
Wilcox, Nakaleka.-
The President announced that
Luhau was expelled from the House
and his seat declared vacant.
Minister Thurston's fifth substi-
tute recommendation was adopted
by the following vote:
Ayes: Thurston, Ashford. Robin
son, Smith, Waterhouse, Wight,
Motley, Wall, Bailey, Dowsett, jr.,
kalaukoa, G. Brown, Kamai, Paris,
Daniels, Horner, Helekunihi, Ka-
walnut, A. S. Wilcox, Rice, Gay.
-21.
Noes: Wilder, Young, Jaeger,
Townsend, Hitchcock, Richardson,
Widemann, Makee, G. N. Wilcox,
Hustace, Naone, +. Brown, Deacon,
Mcguire, Kauhane, Paehaole, Ma
kaleka.-17.
The President announced that
Rep. Nawahine would receive the
censure of the House.
Noble Widemann announced that
he had resigned his seat in the
House and left the building.
The sixth recommendation of the
special committee being included in
Minister Thurston's adopted subsli
,utes, no action was taken on it.
Tho .nr,,,itfno,u caunptI pn.cr n,