New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1888-07-11
MIR. HOAR ON THE TREATY.
ARRAIGNING THE ADMINISTRATIONS.
SECRETARY BAYARD ouTWlTIEp Di
DIPLOMATS.
Tar TELEGRAPH TO THE TRIBUNE-

IBr TELEGRAPH TO THE TRIBUNEl
Washington July IO.-The most exhaustive re-
view yet had of the unfortunate dpioina'i0
Munder committed by Mr.. Bayard in the hego'l"-
tion of the Fisheries Treaty was maze III 'ho
Senate to-day by Mr.. Hoar. Strongly as the speech
appealed to the patriotic instincts OF MS auuieo''
il was not by any means a mere rhetoficai choi''
but as n forcible, lucid and and logical prosecute
ton of the case, probably equalled, II mdeeu IL
did not surpass, any speech made on .hc noor
of the Senate on the subject SO far. MI. iioar
had the satisfaction of commanding the UNDIVIDED
attention of the Senate throughout the denNery
of his speech The senile and lrrcleVant interrupt
tons of Mr.. Payne, who, since thc treaty ms
come up for discussion, has seen It 10 poso % I"
dinlomntist and champion of Mr.. Bayards treaty,
gave Mr. IIoar an excellent opportunity 10 yen
the Senator from Ohio some very homely tru,ns,
Almost as ineffective as Mr.. fayhe dcichou NJ" NJ
the objections raised to minor points III vi a.
Hears argument by Senator Gray, tnough 10 w
the latter Justice, he never lost his temper, uliu
evidently recognized that he was unable TO lesscl ~
tbe force of Mr. Hoars scathlng arralgninehb Vi
the Administration. Mr. Hoar said IN part:
The Administration seems TO have consulted hooouy
cannot learn that in the progress OF TINS aug
representative Of the interests to be aneceo mas oen Nv
mit;ed to its confidence. Neither my colleague nor myself
neither Of the distinguished Senators from
Maine no representative Of hshing us
trict in the other House, no member Oh 'hiS uou!,
ia admitted or consumed in this important matter unHi o
Secretary before the public with their declaration
that we have got all by this treaty that we are justly
ana eouitably entitled TO demand
Great Britain and Canada represented by trained
iplomatists The Canadian representative, Sir Nhares
Turner has made fishery interests OF Canaoa he s'uuJ
a, n ufotme Our commission the other hand' was
improvised for occasion Neither OF them pfooaoy
had anv considerable knowledge OF the matter III question
until his Official 1t began The whole OF TINS
treaty recognizes stenuousy deny-he fitness OF
maintaining a discrimination against fishermen. IL con-
stany arms dominion on the part OF Cahaua over 'ho
fishing grounds which from the beginning nave oeeh ou
Joint property. 1t establishes throughout relation u
control Instead OF full, frank, free recognition Oh
eenora commercial rights everything we are to nave is
privilege constantly be the subject OF difference anu
Quarrel until the demands of Canada are fully yielded
You will scarcely find claim of the American opponents
~ this treaty that supported by the sechee OIL
it, friends in tho Canadian Parliament Sir Charles Iup
per begins by appealing TO that body not 10 press MN u
duly to show great advantage OF the treaty 10 Ca
until the Senate has acted The partcuhfe III "i"'" "O
has specay ouwtted MI Bayard he keeps for the pres
ont in his own breast But admits in express terms
that the nshore fishery rights OF Canada are Of great uo
that markets OF greater value sun Una. Urea"
Britain had In practice abandoned the claim 10 cAeuue us
from great bays and headands that he was not conpcu
by Great Britain yield any claim OF Oanaaa' pu' va"
wholly responsible for the treaty himself
Sir Charles Topper appeals to his own people to decine
whether MI Bayards letters and conversation hso ho'
fairly led him to expect that the treaty would be taken
/
his American felow-citzens remote future lie per-
mts Great Britain revive old exploded pretension
settled by a jus depreciation Of the treaty OF iSls
He leaves the obv 1ous Canadian statutes unrepeaed
He gets promise Canada to let us buy supplies anu
tansship cargoes and whenever we admit her 70
our magnificent market without the fishing rights which
she has gladly and eagerly given for 1t heretofore
He admits that Canada has done everything we can
reasonably ask, although vessels are slii 10 DC
seized by petty officials the burden still 10 De put upon
our fishermen OF proving innocence and neither
damages or cost recovered for the retention OF
vessels the OF and the breaking up Oh
VOYAGES lie Great Britain that the objects ana
purposes OF the great Democratic party, OF Presideh'
and House. in harmony with hers, ana estsDiiShes
the claim OF that party to her future sympathy anu sup
mort lie induces his Democratic followers TO reverse
their own policy and the brayest words they ever
SPOKE This is cup President Cleveland submits 10
US This treaty is not the road to honor 10 SAFETY OF
TO peace 1t the road 10 the respect OF Great
Britain or even Canada Where 1t removes one cause
Of dscord it will produce ten We can never have COM
merca reciprocity reciprocity Of justice and courtesy
b