The Hawaiian gazette. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu, Hawaii]) 1865-1918, 1888-07-31

Ia a1O Win III the @NfNNEeGA hGlNNNA AAAN
Minister Of Interior and Mr., Bowler would
be - properly binding on the Legislature
a. would an order from the Minister
to build i private residence for the hon.
member Tor Hamakus. He was totally
opposed 10 putting anything IN the ApPVo-
p-iStion bills for these claims. NJ. More ;
claim he knew uothinG, about
Noble NiGemSnu cited the rule Of the
House requiring committees 10 report all
obt4inable isCtS bearing upon matters SUI
united 10 them.
Minister ThGrSton raised point Of
order as 10 whether the report was admISS-
2ole under the rule reierred TO.
The President ruled the report mad
miSSShls under the rule, snd stated fur
ther that too many committee reports are
ot the same character. This report gives
no findings Of facts nor conclusions based
upon them.
Noble Smith appealed from the ruling Of
the chSir. He could not speak Of Il without
expressing contempt Ter the ruling. To
say that the report had no statement OF
facts WSS prspoSIerouS, and the President
knows il.
Tine Presiden; ssid the Mobiles Language
was uupArljSnentSry
Noble Smith said If II was he would take
II ag back
TIE President said it was unp2rliamen-
tSry 70 >4y - member Is wrong snd he
SHOWS il.
Noble Srrith-Then I shall say he ought
10 know II
Rep. Ksmsucaa thought the ruling OF
the chair was cs-rect. II looked IS ST some
o; the committee were attorneys FOR the
claimants.
Rep. Brown said ne hsd always agreed
with the Presidents rulings up 70 this
time. He c!Simed that the report was
strictly within the rules.
Noble MiGsmSnn SSi1 an hour Snd hall
had been wasted on the matter snd he
would move the previous question. Carried.
The ruling 81 the chs wSS sustained,
Sad the report returned 10 the Committee
Rep. 7. B7O=u read $ report OF TWO
members Of the Committee On the malt
liquors bill. recommending amendments.
Laid on the table 70 swat the report OF
other members OF Committee.
Noble WidsnSun said be supposed he
would have 10 look out for squalls now. -
he vSs EOjnE 70 reSd : report. Resd = re-
port Of the Committee on double taxation
on the petitions q Manuel MSch2do, Snd
SlveriO Fsrasnde-. June 2l>t, snd Others,
presented lster Lsii on the tSble 10 be
considered with the Appropriation bill.
Noble Townsend rssG ; preliminary re-
pori Of the Committee appointed on mat
G1-tl-4s- - L-lC --l44A4---- l.
pSrtuent, and &Sksi further time for the
Committee Request granted
BILLS AMAZING APPROVAL
Minister Austin reported two bills pre-
scented - His Majesty toT signature.
okDEE OF gzE DAY.
Inrernsl Tzxes-Thiri reading OF the
c.Il, 70 zmsrG Chapter NLlIT- OF the Sss-
sion LzEs Of ISL being Su act entitled
An Ac. 70 consolidate and Smend The law
Resting . In.ernSl tz1e>-
Rep : Brown moved IN amendment.
Ncn.e WSse-aoa>e moved the oil be IN
definitely postponed.
which Reps ? Brown and Kinney. MOBILES
WS.eEhCu>s. Baldwin, NIdeasenn snd
Townsend zE6 Minister Ashford took part
The SrsCuentS for and =Ssiu>t the oil
were VEN fully anticipated 10 the msJurlty
s-i MINORITY reports % the Finance Com
ui.tes. sci fOrih II Ils ADVERTISERS &C
count q proceedings under dates Of the
~ Sld In inst
The zyes AMI noes were called on the
motion for indefinite pO<tPonement, Nnen
there appeared:
Ays-JzeEs-. smith. Ws.=rhouse, IL
h5zI. Wlzh.- WsIl, Baldwin. WideusHn.
g. y. Wilcox. HCStzcs, {. Brown, Hele-
sunihi. Kz~zinui, : : Wlo9I, Rice,
Gsy-I5-
Nos-Thurs.oa. Ashford. Robinson.
Motley. Nzo1e, = Brown Dszcon, Hzmsi,
A5-Eey. hs1z1Jhz, Daniels. HOIRsE, PEe-
hzo.--S
Rep Kinney asked Tor ruling OF the
chzir whether Noble Townsend, Who.
Though : teacher hs1 lot oesu sctuzl.y
engaged - such iOT several months past
ss> entitled 70 vote.
Rule u uroy5 1eS tbSt no one shall b
permitted 10 vote upon sly question
shs-s he shz-l have zny pecCn-=ry Interest
ln the result
Ihs chair ruled IhsI it' the hon. Noble
VS. ECt engaged = : teacher q ne IL d
July. he Fss entitled 70 FCis.
So5-e Smith aFsTss.e1 frorl the railing
O-he- members zlsEed thst there we're
urez5he-s E-eUsl znG members q the
volunteer forces III the House al q whom
Lz1 u5-1ulsTT Interest 70 the sElcunI q
taeir ps-so-zl taxes. IN t-s result
Wide ths questions Il dispute we're
pending
Rep L, P-0El uCys1 the ao1ss 81
51-ru. Carried.
Adjourned - rs 70 10 O'Clock Sz-ur-
day GoruilE-