New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1888-08-03
THE PARNELL DEBATE.
EXCITING SCENES IN THE HOUSE oE COM
MONS
xxrrxxH BITTERNESS DISPLAYED ON BOTH
srpxs-NR- o'sHEAs LETTER BLOW AT
NE. PAMELA LOSS 10 BRITISH ART
--MR. BLAINE's CONFIDENCE UN.
DIMINISHED.
fsr CABLE THE TxBUSE]


allies are fighting against the Commission as AZ
Il were q question of life or death The Irish
leader has the unfinchng support Of Mr.. Glad
stone, Sir William Vernon Harcourt, Mr.. Morley
and the whole Gladstonian wing Of the Liberal
party They have nevertheless, carried resistance
10 point which spois their plan Of campaign.
Mr. Parnell still intends to offer to bring an
ton for libel against The Times as al
Tentative to the inquiry before the Commission.
The offer will be in vain. The Government have
resolved to proceed with o common action, or no
action. When they first made their proposal for
an inquiry by judges, II was open to Mr. Parne1
10 accept or reject il. He declined TO do either.
II he now seeks to go back TO that offer he will
be told it is too late. He had the option and
refused il. The offer was not continuing one,
Is not now open to him, and will not be renewed.
The situation, indeed, has changed in several
respects for the worse The Government and
House Of Commons have steadily rejected every
amendment and refused every concession de-
noanded Their bill remains what it was bill
for unlimited inquiry into every charge msde By
The Times against everybody IN connection
with Parnellism and Crime"
Mr. Parnells counterchsrge against Mr. Cham
berlain has at least for the present broken down.
The debate on the amendments has been so violent
that on neither side is there now any disposition
TO give quarter. The most tremendous mputa-
tons are flung lightly about, and the language
is such as has rarely been heard in the House Of
Commons in its worst days. Mr.. Parnell, once
the coolest Of men, has been at white heat all
the week Twice over he has accused his op-
roncnts Of using poison and dagger. In his pas
slonatc pcroration OF Tuesday night he protested
against the miserable lodges Of the Ministry, and
cried out: oh it is poor; it is cowardly 1t
is loading the dice; it Is poisoning the dagger
T. oAo bod on bp
Of the House: 1T is conspiracy Sir
William Vernon Harcourt observed that the
Government made themselves a mere conduit
pipe for the foul water of The Times. Thcn
changing metaphor he said they had TO deal with
:" the Shiny web of calumny woven by The Times
and its counsel. and to wallow in this slime
Whereupon the Solicitor General for Scotland re-
minded Sir William it was he who once described
the Tories as stcwing in Parnellite Juice Mr..
Hcaly, whose invective amuses the House IN It's
most serious moments, improved on Sir William
Harcourt's Shiny web Of calumny.' The irish
members, according to him. were drcnched from
the hose Of the Attorney-Generals liquid measure
tank and shot at by Ministerial moOnli ghters,
from behind a hedge, with blackened faces The
Home Secretary, whose conduct of his share OF
this business has been even less adroit than Mr.
Smiths insinuated, as Mr.. O'COnnOr cried out,
that Byrne was directed by ADLER wlckeder men
than himself, meaning the Parnelhtes. This Mr..
Matthews promptly denied. Mr. Morley declared
that if Mr. Redmonds story about himself and
The Times was true. The Times had been
guilty of the deepest infamy in suppressing Mr..
Redmonds letter. This mornings issue prints
Mr. Redmonds letter verbatim. Mr.. Morley offers
no explanation.
Mr. Gladstone, whose words arc in common times
studously moderate accuses the Ministry Of shirl-
Ing. of surreptitously shifting the issue. Mr..
Goschen attacked Mr. Gladstone with vehemence
all the more bitter because his words were
guarded An animated wrangle went on across
the table on the point whether Mr.. Gladstone did
or did net believe Mr.. Smiths word Of honor
do" retorted Mr. Gladstone. but Straightway he
qualified his assurance by insisting that the as
sertion he was called on TO believe must be
rational and Ineligible. When the Home Rulers
laughed at Mr. Goschcn he exclaimed; " Oh.
have nothing TO do with members below the gang
way who laugh
Nothing 20 do with them replied Sir Will
lam Vernon Harcourt, yet they represent Il
natlcn7
Nor arc people outside the House cooler than
those inside. The Times itself describes Mcssrs.
Parnell nealy, r. 2. O'Connor and Sexton as
pouring out a food of blackguardsm, and Mr.
into competition with the foul-mouthed oratory Of
the Parncllites.
The most serious Of all the many accusations
against the Ministry are two. The first Is that
they inscrted-for that is what it comes to-the
words other persons in the bill under pressure
from Mr. Walter This has been denied again
and again by Mr.. Smith, Mr. Goschen and other
Ministers. but their opponents will not accept
these denias The second is that Mr. Matthews
has blundered out that the real or primary object
Of The Commission is not as alleged, TO inquire
into The Illness charges but into the history
Of the Land and National Leagues This is what
Mr. Gladstone meant when he charged the Govern
ment with having broken the solemn covenant into
which they had entered There is, of course
great mplaint that closure should be applied
tonight all amendments and the main question
being put without debate at l a. m. Yet every
point has been threshed out three times over.
Mr.. O'Shea's letter TO this mornings Times
is another candid friends contribution to this dis
pute Mr.. O'Shea was formerly Mr.. IarnelIs
right-hand man in his negotiations with the Lib
eral leaders. Having quarrelled with him he
now comes forward TO confirm Mr.. Chamberlain's
account of the Interview between him and Mr..
Parnell after the Phoenix Park murders. Mr..
O'Shea arranged. he tells us that interview.
So Of the National Council scheme: it
Mr.. Parnels very own and exists in
his own handwriting. Mr. ParneIl. however,
has long had, according TO Mr.. O'Shea. a fixed
idea that Mr. Chamberlain did divulge Cabinet
secrets and had long threatened TO accuse hm.
The last advice ! ever gave him. saws Mr.
OSbea "w was that Mr.. Chamberlain would not
object 10 his doing at Charing Cressa Bat
the sting of this letter is in Its tail II is
@bot Dam
TO- even prepared, in os5. Coercion bill Mr..
Chamberlain has Mr.. Iarnelrs draft II is copy
of the original act altered. says Mr.. OShca. by
Mr. parnelrs own hand into the form in which
he proposed il should be passed, with just enough
show OF opposition in the House Of Commons TO
satisfy those concerned Mr. Parnelrs evening
.--.. - .Ln onhnn nress make no reference