Telegram-herald., 1888-11-05
BURCH TO TAYLOR
sEPLy 10 TIE LATTsRs SIC sFFoRT
a ceartss4s Bas Csaeiasiss anss-r -
tAs srsess Lstlsr- " Eissr ara
slsa Ia fa.ssrssg neEs-
a4xs - sss zlseF.&"

M g ~ Tqy'0r & oar sitter iu -rnday's
Ds,ssocr4l a4s l.ssl ossa arolg-t 70 mg a.
lsauon. TIE report u nlg Hartman Hal
sossoh so ga1.isnsd 90 EoEaag. October
~ ir lns Da-y Elg-e 49, gour bravery .
Fsaaafsa able fn tn.s ihat g0ar sftsr - Duo-
.lsls,i siz sags 4lier All ga 3aadag l-3rn-
i1.. isaQlaz 60 eaalcs Tor retis EaeA
a.a meet sns pao. g eye 8sfors siscuon 90
ears. 40 -ss sueb fslly . prsp4rsd Tor 10
press = illla 90 hours 1f tas time .sAin Q
II g0ar effort 1og Gre YozF 0iaadefDuss
sad ran. e. IDENTIFY sxpscuas taat yoa sil
o. s5ls - Tad sanctuary Ia - Ss5oa'h day
from aay reply. Blt gea seat t9a s-y
ia 8road ,ssas thst ae. 40 put ioftn
your -tsh. in tuis Feu 4n1ou-iedl frA-
soa faat fle Ctouf eanaot 30 iufn.sl7a ahtli
.fsr sIsrfI8a. snI n 60 iol.1s l1a snin ~
.xamole oI n Don "a Dickinson. bar
usitnsf yolr q tempt nor ni1 sA5 original
frr taat parase bas .eeu tas strongest an1
fnn-I common. used afz4uro1 1i tsA9-
erats ever siace J. ca1 remember Permit
ue .a rep. .9 saF sa- af- mistaken.
Ou tls sl1Isct of Yo4r nrat
aussn8n anssersd ~ me ln my spsecn-
a. reply seems II have oeea 50 dire cs.
uniTs4sal approval, ~lla o4s uots SoftAy
sEcsplo1. via. YJaEsef
As lo f1e second parl 0i Your screed The
position 0f tls Usmscfklc party cannot
ssl BE- mistaken a 60 tsEif Tor revenue
onIY. au 1il lud iI in The Michigan
Dsnl4raIio platform fof l.Gt % y04r Sa-
Aonal p.aif1fa Tor Is55. AM in i.'- your
platform In fals state demanded asgr-s-
ave revenue rsfofm in The dlrectlo0 of Tree
Ha So. 40
Nationsl platform GA thls sub Iect 4 refer
you 20 C0lone. IS a.tsrsoo, MAO framed .t.
snt sno says
The democratic party. ~fcept in fhs pr
ssnr ~ tlltrc - aartis uorth melfi0gug IS
not on ths fence 10 g a free 1at- F.DtY "
= = eofiing
Nou are torcei % sdmis that ycu were
wroBg and 1 VA sht as % tus perceu age
of reduction. caused ~ the Mills oil. and
oy tie same reasoning you mast adalit
that WAS correct % the
protective character of The Senate bill. aud
the frse trade tendency OF shs Nils ouL
1 tarlff Tor revenue only does not mean
Fnghsn rec trade Why do you sssk 20
asaN al free traders into your party, and
actually rsceiVs into it smOng them tLe
most sdvsncsd free trade writers an tnls
country. Henry George and Othersf Pro-
fsss0r Suraner asserts that tarr for reVe-
nus only fosters AHd buiids up no protected
Industries, as incidental protection Is 81
smsll that 10 Affords no real protection.
You say that / must have read ms
country's history wholly from Republican
speakers snc writer's. sut / reply that Il
xouid seem from your writings, either that
Yon usVsr have read your country's history
or ynu are rapidly forgetting Il. which
many Democrats seem anxious 20 do Ia
shsss later years. You say that Il IS a false
stsfsmsns that reduction Of protective
Ia reply l quote y0u Professor Perry. the
Professor OF History and Political Economy
In William. Collsxe-a noted free trade
1872 millions of capital we're seduced into
manufactures. particularly Of iron, and
when the nigh duties we're abolished, a.
shrT we're te~ years later, hundreds sns
thousands were pecuniarily ruined
Thisssem suficisut authority 10 show ths
reduction Of protection ruins all protectes
Industries. / DO not depend for authority
sor nv statsmsnt upon Mr.. Carlisle, ba
give ron a writer and teacher OF history il
eus of the leading Institutions oi learnin.
20 Ibis country. II time snf space per
mitted I might give you numerous othe
authorities outside of partisan politics.
Your democratic orators call protection
robbery" and burglary" lride Cox
recent speech a. Hsrsman'3 HALL N0V
n YOU are correct IN claiming that yoa
party does not seek 20 ruin protect ed IN
dustres. but only 20 gently reduce 10
rsv-uus. how much. or What percentage o
.robber7" and burglary ars you willin.
% assent 20. n. q. BURCH.