New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1888-01-07

took up her in this city], and the answer
He was an old ANTIQUE friend Of mine went TO HIM
friend lawyer would have wanted retainer to take the
Judge Fullerton asked few questions and then
rested the case. Mr. Parsons made q formal motion
TO dismiss the case. The answer he said, set up
no denial Of promise to marry. Mr. Arbuckes
silence could not be construed as refusal to
marry.
are iacs IN te the jury may and .
sen, Ter AS TO the Ussfns q Inc o
The motion is denied. Your executions may be noted
OPENING THE c,sE FOR Mr.. ARBUCKLE
Mr.. Parsons opened the for Mr. Arbuckle,
arguing that the correspondence showed that Mr.
Arbucke had always been kind to Miss Campbell
that she had 10 this city with only one letter
aside from that to Theodore Thomas-and that to
an elderly bachelor, and within two months was
engaged to be married TO Mr.. Arbucke. Then Mr..
Parsons added
not here to say that Il not BY his WISH but am
or spoke an word
to answer demand tsr money ID 1c9eer aso wen ne
lovingly Bunnle she vas consulting LAWYER With refer
marriage question was not breach Of promise The Ohio
and before he could back here this suit
begun
The first witness for Mr.. Arbucke was Cornelius
Morrison commission merchant of this city, who
had known Mr.. Arbucke since 1865. had been his
boon companion since 1882 and knew that Mr.
Arbucke had complained of bad stomach malaria
and liver trouble. Mr.. Morrison went to Atlantic
City with Mr.. Arbuckle in February, 1888, when
his friend became sick that the witness brought
aim back TO his family. Mr.. Arbuckle wrote let
tiers while away.
Judge Fulertonwas he not able to letter from
lady which asked If was not time for him to marry her.
Mr. Parsons objected and such confusion followed
that the witness left the chair after exclalmlng:
What can do with these LAWYERS wranglingp
EAGER TO HEAR THE LETTERS READ.
Mr. Parsons then read more letters. One
IN hall nece ml,ar
after saying that the writer had sweats in place of
chiil. ran:
Ills with difficulty that can write my own name with
% hoash DO not az much in three meal. az
70 do and could IN one You cannet have lost your appetite
from You often have not been to church for tire
sweat but lave pIcmf.a 90 tonight
Tor chrisnas gift kiss and what truly.
3, b Baby Bani1gl
Aletter to Miss Campbell at Washington written
January q, 1888 was this:
his and ks hugs and kissesl from me- Lot me know
'''- x q NJ kiss quck.l
NEw-YoRK. April 9, 1888
mn an Supposed to be Answer me quickly
FAT BABY DAUGHTER WHO DRANK GOATS MILK
On April IS. 1888 he wrote to her at Ironton:
cuckoo I mail you SUNDAY papers with X N: Q do
shall this evening and think OF o. K NJ O. Bnnne
A"D = AN '""'' NEw-YoRk. April 10, 1853
you o1 add The o. yoar father PLEASED ms
aSe H who KIND o and to his fat Isv
he look, on her D he thinks a Of 1ns h. %s
yon lust have been Banne an writing you TOO o,n
VIA mink That rritiug me every day which Won
sv something more to write you about Ever truly
"a am in receipt of the letter from Mrs Adams
dces rot mean any hing but il would i for you ''
The following letter written on the blank
pages OF an invitation to the wedding OF Thomas
b.. Morse. w.,
October 9, 1888:
, n PITIsBt,as. oct; 10 1sss ,
liks and again commence getting medicine
ssnaeh good MO kiss me qulcs.l
wHIskEY AND QUIyINE USED
After the sensations in the courtroom had sub
sided. Cyrus X. Small a broker and a friend of MIR.
Arbuckle. corroborated Mr.. Aorrison's testimony
III a general way As to Mr. Arbuckle's stomach, ma
LARA and liver complaint, including the use OF
whIskey and quinine.
Q-Were the two used togetherf Al suppose 50.
Other letters from Mr.. Arbuc6le were next read.
all seasoned with his and ks" and * ~. as"
and malaria. Mr.. Arbucke ended letter of Sep
TENDER D. 1888. follows:
BUNNIE fun Of his AVID ks and am wild 10 and II
' O. our I nesting sD viii be- full 1 Of hs and ks
MISS CAMPBELL SLIPS IN SMALL CUB HUG.
After reading several kilograms from Mr.. Ar
buckle TO Miss Campbell Mr.. Parsons rested his
case but be soon discovers that there mad been
hiatus in the sequence of Miss Campbells letters
between June and October r. 1853. Miss Camp
bell explained tbs f. om her char. admitting that
her lawyers had the letters Judge Fullerton placed
them at Mr.. Parsons's disposal ana be joyfuly read
some of them. One of them was:
nEAEBAsY wrote yo1 last Thurs1sy addre'sns my
ISs's,
all questions cannot be answered
recil n a few Plies of letter paper and
thon sands OF words accomplish much
wEen thirteen wOrds more than you, put L
woxses and small cub hug for you ana
1 yo6 with ul heart longng longing
knoWwhen arrive. 90 can pc III tne
house. o. Baby, I do much BUNNiK
After reading this letter Mr. Parsons said grimly
" That's all" Both sides thought they were ready
u rest and after considerable discussion botn be-
fore recess and after an hours Iutermisslon the
Lawyers concluded to wait until Monday to SUN up
the case as each wanted an hour and half for
talking and the case could not 20 to the jury,
therefore, by D. III