The Daily bulletin. [volume] (Honolulu [Hawaii]) 1882-1895, 1888-04-25
WEDNESDAY, April 25.

Court opened at 0 80 a. m.
Mr.. Hatch asked that Mr.. Luce
be recalled for the defence.
The Attorney General objected.
The Court overruled the objec-
ton, and Mr.. Luce was recalled.
Mr.. Luce recalled, said, do not
remember ever telling the Attorney |
General that no part of that liquor
was for MIR. Canavarro' use.
Cross-examined by the Attorney
General: AT the time of this tran
saction had an account with Ha-
ley. Previous to that transaction L
don't remember whether had an
account with Canavarro. If had
an account it wonld probably have
been closed. L think at that time
the account would have been
promptly paid. L cannot remember
whether l had any dealings withlCa-
navarro. Capt. Haley had an ac-
count with me from the time first
started in business. l was acquaint-
ed with Haley before. L was en-
ployed in the house of III. Macfar-
lane for over 10 years. 1 can't
remember if Haley was customer
of that house, but think he was.
/ don't remember what his business
amounted to with me. He was q
fair customer. Say from 500 to
| $500 quarter. Haley had his first
conversation with me in regard to
this order, prior to this date (Jan.
2Sth, 1879 1 can't fix any date.
The order might have been brought
to me that day or the day after.
Haley told me that Canavarro told
him that if he (Haley) brought him
an order he would endorse it, so
that he could get rebate of duties.
Capt. Haley came to me and said
that Canavarro told him that if he
would bring him an order he would
endorse it. He did not say that
Canavarro said that he (Haley)
would secure remission of duties
by so doing have very fair
memory. 1 don't know whether the
conversation was in the office, or in
the street. 1 gave him the order in
the office. 1 don't remember what
time elapsed between the time of
the conversation and the giving
of the order. / stated that
did not know whether Haley was
indebted to me or not. 1 have subse-
quently found out that Haley was
not indebted to me, by the examine
ton of my books. The books are
now in my office.
Here the Attorney-G General asked
the Court for an order for the books,
or else have the evidence struck out.
The motion was argued by both
sides.
The Court ordered that the testi-
mony be stricken out.
By the Court: You said that by
examining your books you found
that Haley did not owe you; have
, you anything more to say about it!
At the interview 1 thought that
perhaps Haley might have balance
to his credit, or it might be the
other way. I then examined my
books and found that he did moi
owe me anything.
!, The Court then instructed the
jury to ignore that part of the testi
mony relating to the Indebtedness
of Haley, to which the attorneys fol
the defence filed exceptions.
Cross examination resumed by the
, Attorney-General. l did not know
t as to Captain Haley's financia
standing. He had a good income
and had $4,000 in the stable com
pany. l did not know that tina
!, $4,000 was in his mothers name
n / know J. w. Luning. During the
h two years l have been in bushes
!. he has been a frequent visitor Il
my store. 1 do not know that Mr.
e Luning had a number of bill
e against Haley that he could not col
Q lect. He never told me his bust
8 ness. / could not have said that
s did not see the erasure, as | nigh
j. have seen it. L only looked at tn
q signature and took it fer grante'
o that it was all right l never sal
). that i read the signature and tn
/. words "for my own uso," and di
d not see the erasure. That was
=. blank order when | gave it to Ills
;, ley. must have filed it in thre
days after, according to the date
u The figures 493 and sol are mine
N | cannot explain those figures. III
G, order explains itself. The dutit
W amount to SOL.
" There are PIG gallons of wine an
or 60 gallons of spirits. / don't r.
G. member the cost of dew drop wifi
or key in bond. think So a gallon
IN The quantity in cask varies.
at Century whiskey is more expel
Il sive than the other, it is worth abo
G. 81 gallon.
ey The Court ruled all this eyiden'
id out.
to / filed the order in at CAP
yn Haley's diotation. 1t was for Il
ae amount of $500 duties, They we