New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1887-06-17
TWO FAMOUS JOCKEYS FALL
MCLAUGHLIN AND GARRISON GO DOWN.


RUN.
Fur short while yesterday it looked as If McIangh-
lin and Garrison had met for the last time Ihese
men-the two leading jockeys In Amerca-neVcr NV"
each other as Damon loved Pythlas, ana tneic wac
something Of sensation among seVerA 'nous ALI.
spectators when tho two went down IN uuu. vi y,
dnst and lay for many minutes as If dead But 'ne'
still live and will probably do battle again In the
first race on the programme OF to-diy'
Roth Mclaughlin aud Garrison believe thelr lai
was caused by Church, who was riding W. G. Daily
colt subatcrn In the fifth race. Subaltem was In the
lead. Tampa, strapping chestnut colt, tiieo te
pass him. Mclaughlin, wishing to lie In wait for
Garrison and Billy Brown, pulled his mount BACK
The colt fought furously for his head In his sugee
to DO FREQ he fell out Of his Stride bis legs pecano
cntangled and he went to earth. Billy Browh' "no
was a length behind fell over him, and colts ana
Jockeys wrcstled together in tho dust soon ai'er
ward TAMPA and Billy Brown gaoped past the stano
riderless. Tampa's bride hanging to his neck
and his mouth was dripping blood. In the iaii No
had broken tooth and snapped the side strap Oh Ills
bride.
The two Jockeys were borne to tho Brooklyn Jockey
Club Hotel and surgical aid summoned. Both
were unconscious. Under the free use OF cold watoi
Garrison soon revived, but Mclaughlin da hot 70
cover for nearly half hour. No bones were Drohen
in the body OF either, but both were baby pruseu
Mrs Mclaughlin, who was sitting In the grand sunu
saw her husband fall, and she was soon at his sioe
"Dill, Daly whose colt won the race, owing to
tho tumble was nearly heartbroken over the acci-
deut. He lowered the two Jockeys as mother
hoyers over sick child, and did more to restore
them than anybody else. They were his boys; NJ
had taught them to sit in the saddle When ne was
satisfied that they were all right he ordered
generous quantity Of champagne and shared 1t with
them.
Garrison walked over to his fatherin-law's home
and Mclaughlin was driven to Brooklyn In fathcr
Bilrs" carriage. Both agree that Church' ny pun
Ing in, intenered with Tampa.
Much useless lumber has been cleared away rom
the suburban in the last few days. One especially
big coarse, ungainly, cheap and worthless SUCK
wa thrown aside yesterday. This was Ben ALL IL
is marvellous thoroughly his owner, his trainer
and the friends of the stable were deceived ABOUT
this wretched brute He has never run decent race
since he came East after his Kentucky Derby success
last wear and now seems to be the worst of arrant
hnaves, shirkers and qutters. He Is big ana mus
cular and might be useful In hauling rope 10 lht
heavy weights to drag pig lead on truck Inc
racing column of THE TRIBUNE estimated him at
his true value last year and rated him where he
Observation-Disclosures or fourthclass But it must be
admitted with tears, humiliation and anguish that
tho writer's for this column have been mlsied this
week by the high opinion Mr. Haggin ana MAUI
Eyrnes had of the horse and thought him able 10
run a fair race in fair company. He could possibly
outpace n herd of petted Jersey or Ayrshire cows
but could hardly keep pace with long strhnhe
uolsten heifer. He was beaten In the most us
graceful manner yesterday, not only by the swift
saxOny but also by the slow Oramme and the slower
Royal Arch and beaten wholly On bis merits Wen
ridden by Mclaughlin and driven with whip and spur,
was q wretched fourth, great many lengths from
tho front. He either could not run or would not
Ben ALI then is out of the Suburban problem.
He not all likely TO start, and If he does VIII
be much nearer last than first Mr.. Hagsn will he
forced to rely on Hi1tgo who ran much better than
Ben Ali yesterday, but after all showed no Suburban
form, for he could get nowhere near The Bard
About twenty thirty pounds was the beating The
Gard gave him. As to the amount OF weight much
would be required to bring Ben Ali and The Bard
together careful calculator estimates it at 1O7
pounds, Is ounces.
The Haggiu stable will not be dangerous in the
Suburban nor Captain "Sam' Browns either, as
Blue Wing is unfit to run and "Bob' Fisher belongs
to o common class Of cattle at best 1t looks more
and more as IL the finish would be reduced to dIei
between Rupert and Richmond. Which is the better
of these it is hard TO say Both are in perfect
condition and show great speed. Hayward has been
engaged to tide Rupert and Shauer VIII bestrde Rich
mODd
saxony is now an uncOmmonly fast horse. He led
all the way in the mile and threc-skteenths and won
without turning a hair in time equalling the best
on record at the dhtance--2 :01 1-2.
1t would be hard TO parallel McCarthy's riding of
Hageoletta in the Gazele Stakes for absolute I'M
adulterated idocy. If he was riding to orders, the
orders were unmitigated insanity. Fageoctta and
Mclaughlin in Flageoettas saddle They made a
driving finish and although Mclaughlin did his
utmost, and though HrenA was not ripe for a
hard race, Firenh won by head That
settled for all time the question OF super
iorty of speed between these two
FLIES I'm a driving finish Yesterday Fageoletta
carried ten pounds less than Frenzi Now after the
race at jerome Park it not clear that with the
ten pounds advantage in the weights Flageoetta's
only chance go out and force the pace as fast
as she could and make the weight tell on Frenzl
Any with half an eye and one-tenth OF an Optlc
nerve could see that But incredible as 1t nray
seem McCarty kept double pull on Hageoletta until
no reached the last furlong and then tried to beat
Fremi on q drive. OF Nrenzi won and
she won by a length, too. William L. Scott ought to
probe this matter to the bottom. If Mccarthy did not
ride to orders complaint should be made to the Ex-
ecutlve Committee Of the Brooklyn Jockey Club and
Mccarthy motives and impulses should be analysed
If MIR. scott's trainer gave orders for such diotic
riding as Mccarthy guilty Of Mr. Scott should
Immediately lay hold of that trainer by any loose and
convenient parts of his clothing should conduct him
to the door Of the stable and dismiss him with part
Ing kick to the cold mercies Of an unfceling world.
The Bard ran away from Hidalgo, Barnum and
Elkwood for the st. James Hotel Stakes, for which
Captain william NJ. Conner gave handsome silver
cup valued at 81 900, and the club added 81 500 II
Higgins, The Bands trainer had not sgnaled TO
Hayward on the backstretch to go slower The Bard
woul6 have covered the distance In fast time But he
was under a strong pull all the way, which became
tug after Huggins's signal and the great colt was
slowed down TO canter I'm the homestretch Tho
generous gift Of Captain Connor was on exhibition at
the st. James Hotel last evening and will remain
there today and tomorrow.
Hayward believes that The Bard can beat any horse
In America and would like greatly TO go with him to
England to meet the English flyers But Mr.. Cassatt
ieavrs The Bard here. Even at 1873 pounds (his
present weight with pcnstlcs) The Bard would have
n good chance for Inc Suburban but he VIII not start
IL was reported at the that Kingston worked
q mile in l AZ IL at jerome Park In the morning
FIRST RAcE-PCRsE 5000. SPECIAL WEIGHTS SIX
FURLOSGs.
Iamasney Brothers CHI Climax by John Carter Parides
L. N Mlsrs Harry Russell. 4, llS....... (Hamlton)
=. " Eiuoitsp teiieeS o. a oiAaushun(