New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1887-06-11
AGAINST HOTELKEEPERS.
THEY MUST NOT SELL LIQUORS ON SUNDAY.

WILL TEXT OF JUDGE LAwRESCEs DECISION IN
THEIR TEST CASE IN THE SUPREME COURT.
The test case Of the hotekeepers who souSht 10 op
tain judicial construction OF the law against 'oiH
iiquor on Sunday yesterday decided sgans' 'ne
Justice Lawrence OF the Supreme Court In tue case
James H. Bresn OF the Gilsey House, Jusuce
wrote tie following: .s-, -,
Aieash@er Williams captain Of the municipal police o. tne
e. PrsS ass . June ss
os n YHscn 70 Of the he
taken Of the police ,or % tbe n
hsSss' Ss. me- Upon writ
ssss s ss sc q
ss .Ss r 1 me ser pass upon
ton. winch Tss act Of
.e.Sn Il tina.
sms IN s s5Sa '1'
ssTss. a.
;s NJ ssss 70 snS
becomes dosDg o. this ease TO s'GS So
ssR ss q"cr amy license was
submitted apG re Excise and City
Of aRpica 40 for e nes ssy
sell sTo"g n and 1o snsm IN writing
who SsSs satisfied s tn. aPssH
good that he has snosn. S 70
sS a me
es sssp Of s .s%.
Bes in permitting him to sell and DISPOSE 2. sIsSsI tSan
sg Es .ss. sss e :s ssa
sss;: 's premises '''ssas 70.
y:
soospted upon CONDITION that the Sen'es sn
Of se . sa s scS the
shall mmedstey become null and y0d sailing on
san ss% 81: s; q
c ysn. u ss ss sa1 Witch The sg no
I .a h su ses and Il
t ClIoss that this writ must be dismissed
In regard the of Charles N Was Oh INC f''
Avenue Hotel. the Judge says:
For the stated by the opinion in tho OF
flames IL Bresin. writ In this case must also 10 a''
was late in the afternoon when the decisions were
rendered ssr tn mos made with the points Of
the decision until copy oft was shown them ~ s ,n
sssn,ng py aause in oonpany with Police captain viii
ams SV whom he and M Villas arrested AFTER
the Suggestion Of Mayo Hewitt and making
fest case for dual determination by the courts, ar.
Bresln read tho opinion win many t0aoui"'''"' " ~
gust, and then said
s Sse.SS 81 S% sSn
ms and .Ss GSr %1ssy S ay
Tns Sb ,sGy 11 3, i rssersd am
Mr. Breslin sails for Europe in the Umbria with ms
three daughters this morning at y O'Clock. Japan
Williams said That IN TeS s d't to his departure as
Ke had only been taken custody in order TO make
t o art keep a sse called Ge
House and started with MI Bresn ana Ihh ssrs
Osr to of find T PTce asf se on The complaint
ea ss Williams Ss fST MI S5e s4Ians
the Amsterdam Club in Nest d TEsnIy sod
st. and learning there that Justice VnS nyoceeSed
TO, ,s MoSan House, Where Police Harry Ford
paroed Mr. Bresn and told him una. Se Sraposes TO
DO COLONEL Robert g. Ingersoll one OF the 1ounsei M
the hotel keepers who lives at the homan tSn. ea
gone to Kansas. His associate, pr. Anure"s' 'nuS Ca
presses himself after reading the decision;
"There ha. been no meeting Of the Committee Of the H9s
ton a. has been take the case before 5ne
General on appeal at 9nee and IN asking oi speedy
rns 70 'Sss by va. hs
ce the ma wnG ag2Sa5es
Ss NO. nSa Ssa q re
mens written briefs either the Counsel 70 snS
TS S G Of entire ss5pI'ssb 20
pSi aau IN in his BRET ,ha, he did not
6 se Suppose Sponh That equally
law that q Of he
E.oi:o on e.a aaSp' s
s shS Citizens. character
SDSsT the hotel Keepers the right to sell
sns Ss ar s sss
thus were not 80 1Gs r 81 nj
beers But positively created BY then OF h n
Ss..sa pE .S to sa: say 1SS
10 assertion OF what with all respect
us to radically unsatisfactory . , 4.
Mr. Andrews said he would confer with the coInsei 70
che Cornoraion to-day and he had no doubt that ne
ouId that the order under the decision should
be settled so that an appeal 70 h eeg ahe
Term OF the Supreme Court could DC argued 1us th
nrssent month The matter would be placed before he
General Term by writ Of cerLora which nc enpe
eondence that the decision Of Justice Lawrence wou
BE reversed Mr. Breslin who had conferred WIN n'
Gerried president of the Hotel Keepers Assoclauoh'
md others said that the hotels would not sell o
morrow and would respect the decision until IL was