The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1887-10-23
PRIEST TO PROFESSOR.
A Sharp Retort from Minnesota - .
"Tsrun'' Defence or MoGlynn.

with special reference to Dr.. McGlynn's case.
So far as he keeps to his text he cant help
showing the Church's treatment Of delinquent
members to be most fair and admirable; but
to appear on the side Of Rome" might unfit.
II not his article for popular magazine. him.
self for his chair. and git-edge butter to his
bread. So he must. ad captandum pttlGus, raise
some anti-Popery dust By means OF twisted
phrases questions, and innuendos. all dishon-
est He had written correctly that for OBJ
stinRcy and contumacy In some sin" the
Church claims the right to deprive members
Of the use Of all the public spiritual goods
that come through her Intervention. but not
OF what comes either directly from Christ
Himself or from the good works OF individuals.
And further on. noting tho condition OF the OK.
communicated that are :. uttandi that is,
good. have TO be more particularly let alone.
A. says; None Of the prayers offered BY the
O. bs
Msss cannot be offered In the name OF the
Church Tor pitandi correct translati9ns 50
although Roman divines teach that stipend
tbe II 81 or IS or 5000 may be taken from the
prayers are offered ior iniideis. but not for Tie
poor uitdndi. Mass cannot be offered 10 the
q tn The
A true motheris known BY her love. Where Is
homes Tor the excommunicatedw
ignore and smother it for a confederation
Win not the truest and loyingest mother. II
hes Mhat
him to bed. or to the dark closet or to take his
unto repentance. he sees and owns no has
been wrong and promises to do better2 Can
s e. not
W !s sss sssiss Is! Sosa 4 k
tlsas yssy oId;sstabshsd society iGT pie +:
sSas yia fs9 AND sn. MS IT,
full operation all adown the centuries. 1t
S s ssa
US use Of 't these while he Is contumae
Sayior Il Is iike' no penalty Of sivi life. alto:
gether motheriy measure OF reform. inquired
3nay after Tarnlng snda5ie a. VII h ana WITH tn
neoessaries Of salvation. No one pretends that
\ can override conscience. or shut out from
Inspirations ms i Of the Holy Ghost, or disauaiIs
the soul for PRAYING and being prayed f for 10
Se ' is sin inaocsns and dong rish, the word q
Rome" quietly given, even while for the sake
q the regular order and q those WHO see not
exeommunieates him, + to b. ot good heart
and make for oF e. Of tho
merit Of his lonely bravery.
But this IL iotitIous case and out Of cues
who need to be irowned on. made pncomfort;
able. and kept aware that their mother IL. and and
motRsr and and eager to receive them back on
terms they well know and GOD has set and she
best inerssts so and the nature Of the case and
the highest authority. demand that such rebels
should be treated far otherwise than strangers
and outsiders not to say the duttlui children.
The Professor would surely correct sharply his
own boy for much less than he overlooks In the
he will not hear the Church. Lot him, be to thee
the heather and the
the spirit might be saved. and ordered the 9TH
ers to treat as uitandi and keep aloof from Ger:
at large, but II any one that is called 9 broth
err BIO such. And again q rhess.. iii g. We
jesus CHrl:t f that You Wihdray yoarseSes
to the tradition w shS he haze
return to the way oi rlghteousPess:" 80. too.
this. but instead Of saying 30, as the truth and
tho natural structure Of his sentence demand
ed. he insinuates that the Church OF Rome pre-
Many,a mass I have said or got said for
KKrapotkiae, CARLYLE. sussin sgs ms, HsEr ryy
Willard, tho Pro6ibitionists, the appointment
OF DR.. Walsh 70 the See OF Dublin. the CONVEX
blOn OF Surulnhl 6lDDOub 70 tuo temperance
crusade. All unknown to them, my good will
10 won to these, as to parents brothers. sisters,
frien6s, by what they were, are, do. or could
do for humanity and God: Il Is won 70 Others
spring I received. with q request TO say
to Sioux City endorsed to the widow OF the
Methodist martyr Haddoek. Tho stipend.
when 1t comes. only secures or remunerates
the priests good will In applying. on be-
half Of the donor specially the saeri.
apply for himself Or some relative Of friend;
their spiritual things they ought also in car
nal things minister unto them" But the sti.
pend could not be taken II the mass could not
be said. II would have boon often said by mo
for the uitdndus ldmen,lais. for he was earnest.
and power for good 1t would BIO now for Dr.
McGlynn II he were good for anything better
than feeding his followers wind and getting
three.cheered for nothing or soribolsd about
after by personal calls letters. and even cable
grams OF the kindest and best men OF the
Church but he was rigidly mot at home" or
Bcorned their Efforts as frantic shrleks" al
together behaved not a. the Gospel sheep,
willing to DO taken back, but - WayWard,
--S--A---' s'-'~'-'-S' -- MATTE NAIloHx.