The Hawaiian gazette. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu, Hawaii]) 1865-1918, 1887-05-17
Supreme Cezrt OF the Hawaiian ISL
a2dS---Ia BSae0> April Tersa. 1857 .
HYMAN BSorsERS vs., JoEN NJ. kArxNA.
CoIIScToS GENERAL on CpSroNs.
EzFoSr svrn c. - M'cv11x ,. rSsSroS =.
E-cxEx-oN =
0g5sa1a' = - Ce~r. ~ N'CCLLTL.


Police Court Of Honolulu. Ii Is pre-
scented 10 this Court on the following
Sgreed statement u fSeiS, and the
question reserved.
Thu following fSciS sire Sgree6
upon; ThSt plaintiffs IN the month
Of November, 1885, imported and duly
entered under bond St the Custom
House ST the port Of Honolulu Sn IN
voice of MSnils cigars az the value OF
$952, thst on the third dsyof Deem
her. 1884, plaintiffs withdrew from
bond ten thouSSndof sid cigS-S OF the
value o. S119 Srd pSid u defendant
ten dollSrs per thousand; EhST IN sd
ditlon 10 sid duty defendant exScted
Snd plzinrfs pSid under protest S
further duty Of p per cent upon the
value Of sid ciSSrS amounting 10 the
sum Of 50 20: thSt plSintiffS slSo IN
the month q JsnuGry, 1887, imported
and duly entered nnder bond ST sid
Custom House sn invoice Of HSvSnS
cigars q the vSlue OF $751; thst On
the 24ih dsy Of sid JSnuSry plaintiffs
withdrew from bond Ssid cigars, and
pSSi S duty Of ten per cent ON the
SSne, thSt In Sddton 70 sid duty
defendant e1EeIsd Snd plaintiffs pzi6
under pCotss- s further duty OF . Per
cent upon the vSlue Of sSid eigSS
amounting 10 the sum OF $3.50; thSt
0sfs1dSnt would nos slow sid cigars
70 be withdrawn iron bond without
the payment q sid duties q p per
cent
PlSirtiEs clGim inst the lSv enScssd
~ the session O 1885, 10 VII. 50 much
Is relStss 70 cigars o. Section 2 o. Sn
Act SpproYed 0esobs- 15th. 1885, en-
titled An Act Anenisto-y Q: Section
? Of Chspss- = q the Session Laws
of IS7S relating 70 impo-s duties upon
VINES, being ChSpts< 81 Of SD lSvs,
Is Unconstitutional
Ii Is agreed 30 request the Court 10
reserve the question O. the eocS+iEU-
tio1Slity q sid portion Of sid lSv;
and thst If sSid lSE Is kesd good. iudg-
Dsnt ShSl be entered :o- ths defend
Srt with costs: and L sid lSv Is held
vosd IS tS- Is relStes 70 cigars i1dg-
Esnt shall be entered for the plSIl-
TITS foE the SUN q $1ST25 with costs
The title q the Aes concerning
which the question OF constitution
atty Is Kissed : An Act AneziSso-y
Of Section :. C1SpGs- 3 O: the Session
LSvSot ISIS, resting 70 import duties
upon VINES
The sitle q the Ae. q ISIS which
i referred 70 Is An Acs 20 S-eai 81
Acs entitled An Acs 70 increase the
import duties upon csrIzin goods
Spproved the 9th dzy Of Sspsenbe-,
ISIS
The -cert4ln goods upon which
TIE duties z-e Iccze&Ss6 icy The Ac5
Sre uc-e than t1-ty GrJlclas @ classes
o. zrr1cLas- 1-c-E then three classes
q VINES The Ac- q 1886 imposes
speclEc duties On light classes q
goods including the three classes Of
wines
Article - Of The C,1--s--l- --r--i1a rsaSiS.
10 zvo56 lErzoCs- Influences which
nay result ErO- i-z6r-Ix1cE II one
Sn6 the sane Ae1 such things q have
10 u-upeE rslz-i12 10 each other. ever
lxE shzI ez-1-zce bur one 0b5sc5. zrd
that shall Dc e-brzee,i n Is title
A Ike z-11eIs : fund N The Cozs7I-
tutio1s Of 8 -zl0E1EE q the States Of
the American IC1CC- some a then
using t1s Tern -o1e subject ard
S0-e -o-s 0tIsc-- he pEpQse O.
this pEUvls1C- = E-sz - pEsTsc- hodge
po6Ee q Iog--o-5cE lsgzslz1iocs SEC
Cri 70 ursTscs Surprise q fraud Cuoz
TIE LsElslz--re BY mans q uruT1<-
ionS n bills o. which these titles give
10 rrti-z-loc- Gli third 70 zrc-uTe
the people q proposed Ez-1srs a leg
lslz41C1- See Co1lsy7S C,J1-E L--l-z-
tio1s. page AS
II i cIsE thx1 TIE tl-Is II the pres
ent case / EzS--saizzZ ard would tsr-S-
trz-s The seco1i and third objects
Shoye proposed Il i dee-zre6 -y
this tI-Is 1kxt The lzE lE1ez6s,6 10 b
z-e16ad / oCs rsLz1lzg 10 @purI
duties upC- wras- z-1- IzttsrszlzzLLLLy-
upo1 VINES Only Wien rhs Ac5 \
rpz6 ty us t-tls- tbs E-z-1er L w1zz =
pEessz1s,i u lhs zzleC1llZ q 1hs Leg
rs1z-zre- WIrL1--z the words -rsLLE1-
1ng TO import 6-ziss Upl1 VINES The
ute Gsse-Ices n Ae1 z-sziz-z
suecZsla,3 Ar1 u ISIS EEzzs7sr subject
-zv Be I-tL-.i-z.T En- Il. bun these words
beng za51s,3 --,4 be c,11s-5arsi to
nsslr1e1 the scope II the Acz md u
ths 1Zsc,1Es-1- Says C,l,lLsy 81 page
14S O the w7-EE e5rs6 z5,1Ts- The
Courts csD1G =1zrge TIE supe a
the tlrLs= they g-s vested viii N is
PES p'1EsE= the C,lz.s7lilii77--5lli--. E.z.S
r-z5s the THE The es11..--.szzTE lzslzr 10
the ls-lslz1lve L-lisz q u whz1 sail
have Cp,s-Ell1Z= II L II zzsEsr 10 say
shzt Ehz TILE EIEG- have beez -a5-s
E1re c,EprelzlszT=- Il II taez the
LeglsLz1T--s have MT seen Il u Ezks
Il So
TIE srrur n tbs title : Mt Il N
49, As Al Escl5z-a-ry Ar
Z -rzAE Be- considered sgEss,z=-5 4 II
crEv referred 10 N aclgLzzI Aez h.ET-
Ing q s1zI= properly 6sscrI-Izy tLs
s-eiseS -.ElzE-