New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1887-07-15
DENYING The P0PE,S Right
DR.. McGLYNN SAYS THAT HIS ExCoMMUNr.
CATION WILL NOT STAND,

1 FoUR-coruMN srATrMKNr IN "THE STAND
ARD 1.-THE TEXT OF HIS FTsAL CALL TO
RoME-Hx DRNoUNcEs CARDINAL
sIMEoNI-THE ARcHBrsHoPs
LETTER ANNOUNCING HIS
ExcoMMUNIcATIoN.
Dr. McGlynns first reply to the notice II has On
communication, sslde from the impassioned ad.
dress that he delivered on Sunday night, will
appear in tins weeks Standard, published
to-day. 1t occupies over four columns Of that Pc
per and is in the form OF Oh inter view with rep-
rssentafive of Mr.. Georges paper 1t Is given
herewith in full. except the Latin Of Cardinal
Simeouis letter to the Doctor and few other un-
| important matters
| In general 1t may be said that four Eve days
| reflection has not caused DIR. Mc3Iynn to
! change in the least the defiant attitude
that he assumed on Sunday evening toward his for
| mer ecclesiastical supeuors. At the same time
there is manifest effort throughout what he says
| tojnstify his course from the beginning.
| He gives to the public for the first time his final
summons to Rome. which sent him in May,
| denounces the way IN which he was addressed
IN it by the Cardinal Project of the Propaganda,
but attributes that prelates feeling toward him to
the "onesided and numerous letters" sent to Rvms
against tue Doctor by Archbishop Corrigan. lie
also attempts to prove that which he and his
friends have again and again assersed-that his
case was prejudged at Rome and that he was called
there to be disciplined rather than for trial NJ
Preston declared. The letter sent to him by Arch
bishop Corrigan Last week officially informing him
of his expulsion from the Church is also given and
commented On at length by the uafrocked priest.
The statement opens WIN the letter OF Cardfnai
Simeoni which was delivered to Dr.. McGlynn bv
messenger of the Archbishop on the evening OF
the 22d of May as the Doetor was entering tue
Academy of Music IN Jersey CRY to deliver his
lecture. "The Cross of q New Crusader DR. No
Gvnp placed he ltter in has pocket to he read az
more convenient time, ana up TIL now. wlsnlnEso
keep ms own counse ana leave 70 MS cserfca Gu
en,'.s n si ~" =. :. .ne
world his letters and his affairs has neither ac-
hnowioose" noi uoniou tno 'o0oip. " i' in0
Is IN Latin. Inc traosla alton Is as isnows;
"RgvEREYD SIR: To those shings which through yonr
e kHS hS Of ssn
act of dsobedience by which you nth vain excuses,
Vensrssse command Of the supreme Pontia Of the
OF the l7th Of january, 1852. .s,.
penalties upon ' ycu without asag yet dsaIns win you
benignant and mercfully by the present single mont
term % Of % days to be @ from day Or
you must BY al to Rome and your
self before this sacred congregation under pain OF ex
y yon s 10 nj @ W anu
The sacred congregation chershes the hope that,
montion and begs for you Lord the opportune
assistance. s
sresaton de propassnda ds on the fourth day Of the
A0"'H "a '"'' ~ jobs csHDrsAI saEoSr Project.
"DoMISiCK, Archbishop OF Tyre Secretary"
PERvERsIoNs OF FACT N THE LETTER
representative OF fne Sfdndd~ asked Dr. hc1iyhh
If he would make any upon the letter d. Nc
:, ,n. aud ss,u.. lin which q .aa
thing to sec coming from of the high.
representatives Of that See which is called the chair
of truth
. The sst. r:t words he said imply S wSsn
fault you had committed against the authority of the
that
truth be said 70 have done asainst the Of the
Chickerng Hall the rs OF October last although he
do sou AS sppears from nv stpement In T@e SaHdarS OF
February s. gave him In lister severa grave reasons
why should keep that enssgsmens ana WHILE IN my
ic consented 70 make no more speeches during the
had Tsae the snSase%ens before rssevins his isier
and had bee. S.n;S 70
public scandal and be Of crave injury to he osnse and
wSud pc IN the nature Of breach Of soatsst which,
diffcrent from what would have been If had simply
d,d have to say that the technical offence Of disregard
SION from my ministry for two weeks which
mo by letter the very next morning I respected the
susprneion and only at the end did
resume the exercise Oh mr. urnstrys Now Il 10 "a wise
Itsian legal urcyerb which says An offence punished
Is an offence psrdoned' and therefore Il hardly
fsir of Cardinal smeon Il this IL what he audes tn,
10 comnlan Of the thinss which have Committed
arafnsf fhe authority of the Archbshop of New York
But 81 course the one aided and numerous letters against
me To Rome from Archbisbop Corrfgau must have ned
Csrdnai simconi's mind with mpressons OF all manner
NJ ats Of dsobedienee 10 fbe frcbsop and want of
e.nact for ami svsn oontemn Of his athorty on INV
part couYoss that a. could not admit the right Of
-. rcbtfssssn IN rbft ms "a Ia aid vas NOT caIlsi
npon o Five any but the technical obedicnce
20 tia ieter Of his command and tint only from tho
urpdrntai reason Of avoiding a scapdalo,s conflict
therefore, freely gave Interviews 10 newspaper WRITER'S
And fo conneract the eect OF the political maDifesto adj
dressed nv the Archblshop's vcargeneral Monsignor