New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1887-12-09
.lyDREw cARyEGIES HorErU1 rIETS

SPEAKING BEFORE THE NINETEENTH CENTURY
CIUB-IAwEENCG GRoTLCND EErLIis.
The American Art Galleries were nei by large a.
semblge Of thoughtful people IN evening drc's last
night the occasion being nj ress before the Nine
teenth Century Club by Andrew Carnegie on "1riuin
phant Democracy" Among those present were Court
landt Palmer, who presided; General Horace Porter.
Ethan Allen. d. g. Thompson. 7. i. Marhury Mrs.
f. A. T. Barnard. Mrs ". Il. Dinsmsrc. Mrs. VI. H. Com
wav. Miss Conway. Ms. t;uel. Cyru. Bn.ler. the Rev
Dr. Newlsnd May ard. Dwight Townsend. Mrs william
Whitney. Jesse Young, H. f. Kcerau T. H. Dixon T. H.
Thurber PaIkc Goodwin b. +. O'Conor i. II. Cabot.
Edmund Kershaw. and Alderman Conklng.
Mr. ,arnc ie drew picture ~ the condi-
ton the United states IN which prosperous edi
catcd proe.ariat ercrtcl political rowcr He r.Pi Ell
briefly to the arguments Of the Rev. Heller newton
against the positions taken in Mr. Carnegcs hooks dis
cussing especally the perils" 10 the Republic IN
their order Inrnigration lie sad. net increasing
faster than the native population. ass@rtcd and
quoted prove It. We do net ssi the scum
Of Eurorc bat tho thrift and amh Ions. a. for 'ho
merrill Ronansm he thought the fact that In ltome II
self the Pope hal been stripped Of temporal power was
indication enough thai American liberty had nothing 10
cncroaoh.ncui, Nor di he fear IT. pr"'e-
lying te records OF all missionary convrrs ons w"r"
the best sh stories ex'1nf an he al not why fath
ocS Shout be Gne cmt T on the rc'' Tue menace OF
Nofnon, to lit;le since in TITAN there
were two Gcn,4les every Norman.
Tho fourth peril! ire.npcrAue, a. aSnSht was not ia
creaslng Tho diminishing collection OF axes 81 liq'or
;raeting attention here aud ~ Great Bthl was
eerioIsly disturbing The budget The tam" VS. when
the man VINO coIll diInk his companions Under
the table stood with the ladies where the chain
pion hase3all player did now. Chorus 81
lasio,: e. so. No. II hay" slii Nj tirne TO-
authority equal 20 the ceAsus FOR tAai statement.
Ia ghtrr' Where does ihc cAp.r'.i"n 'druuk "a u
lod from. II not from the Ira that drhfsehh~'-
.ory r. Socialism. he Iusisf c. ne" pTnh"ci Of
democracy but cNslir 10 ttIcI f,l - q d. 'aoci ~
IN chicago. quoting ON fourtinnIt faiihcrS recent
speech AT al .,nArcl.s ncotiAc Ire -dlI
= ina were true. our president wo1li hs q h~gGat'
instead o. cnipyinr property he did not create tie vain"
Ol which l, ud Istr0u- nsi-hbpis nave ga rdHcl lie
alike o. tie nIqufy Of rsuf and fairly fate on uu-
earned incrsneaL Va won'cr II alter. a. Ir ter rs H.
'rObabs li- fellow Zee goes 10 these meetings ~
stop thlcf Where J.. tao he'll oil nissfy hnd want
" lch ni. -,ui rec lis -
Mr Carnegie SAID there such thing NJ psnprr-
i,mcNcep hat ~praug roiu bal h@hli7 ana
ease 1T -o, hist, DE laws ley Nonli ch"htr
nr..rpt iacs: It wa. tho bi,'cnrs and
he scum who talked othcrvi'c ANA M
Palmer .anci-d tnese wcie Libsr I'o hcA'i"Y innr
peuurn'r Ltlar discussed bN DO" -lr"h,f' WI"
r1.r.i th- r'prr req frui ana ong"i >'fih"' lh
morMci1ai couulrc, ana amons he iS""r"h' J" Ms
couufr-.
tendency toward edisiri' 'i 'ic1 i"f "ur' -
those 81 As.ofs ami Nanirrnit-. some oi wh. -
cudtui- ne tIlfd -enrft.loA ""Hlt hr ""I"'"-
Tor tie gran o. ti-ir prascnt emp o'r1 Is ii
SrniI 70 n.r tisgriccL If4Sdir ihctdiJ was - -"
the fntiiOfc 20 tAu lirftl
co oA,i I.usA =. .lawar, followed vita q paper lI'''
In. ua of mprr ots 81 ger, tAi"h 'nr' ''
prn>fi 81 D~4Io u Its cadr -thr l"i
lIIurc WIN n4I; /, s.,.t.I., tls "a, 1ln''.oh Wv
" low much E. ..,..
Law ruce tfpGinI presented he crirome -"'l''.',
o the topics u.'lar ni-cnas'h. \ Ioe' P''"' ''
OccuDl- the rosf 81 ia" evening.