New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1886-10-13
THE TORY HOME RULE PLAN.
NOT ONE BUT THREE IRELANDs.
CHURCHILL L-CHAMBERLAIN SCHEME A'AiNo'
WHICH NATIONALIsTS 1NDiGNAN'Lf
ppoTFsT

frr CABLE TO THE TRIBUNE
Corrrfght; 1886 , NORTH american cable Netos c0s
LONDON, Oct 12.-I have high authority ior say H
tbat the sensational story about the boverh"o"'
toa Rple hill has no other foundation than tue ions
understood intention of the 10 ac' U"
.he line. suggested by Lord Carnarvon and MI Ohaoo
lain which involve the administration OF local ao"
IN Ireland not by four bet by three Natohai
namely: Northern. Middle. and Southern Heiahu'
with the limits of authority clearly denned ano ao'o
lutely subordinate TO the control of the imperiai "
lament There is every reason to believe 'hat 'ne
statements OF The Daily News wlth ieietchoo "
The Tory Home Rule scheme thoroughly authentic,
In so tar at any rate. they reflect the views Vi o
Randolph Churchill who takes upon himseif 10 speak
for all the rest OF the Cabinet, and OF MT
who asnires TO sneak for all the LberaU Unionists'
The anamoly of such communication oeing ihauo "
a Gladstonan and not to Government organ Tho TM
planned py the tact that Mr. Lucy Editor OF Ing Inc
baily News, and Mr. Chamberlain are particular
friends 1t is Mr.. Chamberlain who mas let 'he cav
ont of the bag and he has done so IN order 10 &c. ho
voice of public opinion the scheme before he COLL
mts himself to II definitely. =. -, -.
The Tories are furious at this CHARACTERISTIC trcR Oh
their ally but he is Liberal Unitnlst ana lhcy nus
cin and bear IT, As to how the scheme regarded IN
freland-whch is the main point-there is 10 dlmcuity
Whatsoever in informing you on that l nave Deeh III
Ireland since Saturday, when the revelation was maoe
and haye spoken with several of the Irish leaders on
the subject and wish ii understood that speak wl.
complete and express authority Tnen s tbot oresbaS
owed would be repndated with scorn and contempt
by the NauOnalists OF Ireland. . ,
Il should say at once that the scheme described Is
an old one Ii Is one of Mr. Chamberlains numerous
ofsprings and OF those that he has cast out OF
doors boot. In the course OF the RAPID ana nervous
fermentation in which Mr. Chamberlain mna laouiuu
during the Home Rule bill debate one OF fis utter
ances was to the effect that the time when s1cn
scheme as the provincial council scheme assocsted
his would be applicable to the case OF ireiaf.
had now gone b, and that hencefOrth owing 10 tee
alterations made in the situation by the mtroductlV
of Mr. Gladstone's bill, it was only by very iars
e Dula hat
solved Ii is ON this discarded scheme that Cnamoer
lain and Churchill have fallen back in the hope OF
dshing Gladstone and splitting the parnel'es s ham
/ have learned that Mr.. Chamberlain has oeeh
boasting in private great deal lately about being
able to pin the Irish members 10 this scheme
some of their leaders, he alleges. expressed ther
approyal of IL IN writing when he propounded IL IN
"The Fortnigbtly Review" This is the KIND OF nom
sense which illustrates the dishonesty and oi
the mind OF the English peoples ex-tribune. Pon-
tcian of his experience ought to have less 1ath IN
these little lodges for splitting the Nationalist ana
he probably would have were he less enamored OF te
that has ATTENDED DIS recent eno.' " oi'"
The Nationalsts will act with the same inconvenent
unaninity heretofore II the irlsh members % .,
accept scheme OF this kind, scheme 10 SUBSTITUTE ioi
n real National Parliament. which would orihg tne
mind and IN rges Of the whole country 10 bear on tue
work of regeneration, a OF mosquito Parhaments
in the provinces which would nag the country 10 us
traction. be source OF never ending 1rlcuoh anu anu
degrade provinciaze and disntegrate our puohc
opnion a scheme which leaves out of consideration
the greatest factor in the whole dlmcuity-the
national sentiment of the people-a scheme moreover,
which was conceived in the spirit OF .atesmanshp
hut in spirit of the lowest party trckery. ii the
Irish members accepted such scheme as hnal setue-
mept of the National question they would deserve
and would instantly receive the execraton OF the lsh
people, tor they would have betrayed the trust
ieposed in them by their own constituencies: ana
have wilfuly deceived the people of England into
bargain they had no authority to make.
Depend upon IT, whatever moves tmay be necessary
IN make in the political game OF chess, the Churchill
Chamberlain Home Rule scheme promulgated IN
" The Daily News" will not be the antl-cma OF inc
sevenhundred -year-long tragedy OF Irish PATRIOTISM
Al the same time note to be taken that the mention
of Home Rule IN any shape or form as the new poncy
OF the party that entered office with polcy oil tweny
wears of is a fact of almost revolutionary slg
1ifcance 1t is the beginning of that competition
between the Tory and the Liberal schemes OF Home
Rule which bound TO be the result OF the
nnIess tbe troubles brewing for the winter IN Ireland
slter the prospects considerably. T. p. GILL, NJ. T.