New-York tribune., 1886-03-31
THE JUDGE WOULD HAVL DONE THE ~AMi.
CARL IIuM AcQuIII. D-Ml. IuLbY KIis'b J."
Ct!I wIIST- SIS.

ChIL WINE SIS.
Carl Timm. sli2hr, inon'n-Iye looking sailor.
from the German snip kaII "aa trcd >c,triutY
hcfnrc .Iudyc (oeIng on charge of hOWlcldc. lie
and tie other members OF the crew Oh January !
visited tl:c barIOon Of john Span9'uag.' Nhrrr
tne l,turbaucc began which ended 10 me i!r'l "i
Iuulu nl ta.. charge OF murder ~ st.tnl ptiIlci
Attorney lu!ty conducted The prosecutions hu g.
lhrrct testified that he "a" lmn' ch"sr a man
and then saw Thomas toillgan badly ""undrd
and breeding John ~pangcuaBic sud thit th'I"
was "A quarrel in his place and lhdi '"lIie"l N'h'
OUT with 1inm and tie eaI Ofs. Deputy coroner
Hrrrod and Dr. tvru- Eds0n also t'shu'u. "'h
Mr. Purdy said that his case cu-rd. lu' N"s-ia.
Kingsley and Mccall, who d"i"ndcd lHih' H'I' 10
Judge Cowiug: Mr. PuIdy has h"d all ttr Nlil,-S
ga Of This orruri,.ncc in his room and We ask lhtt
they be calcd.' 4 itnc,y named scott Was ''!I.d'
ana then al MI ns-,eNs repeated d'H'Hn W.
PuIdy called MI@. ~Pan&"naglc, VINO sud ma l''
German -ai.or- were ENJOY Ing thrl,@Nc7 Nn'I i
crowd Of young rnilianS broke ITO tr fcdI "I iH1
store As tu"y came throu N the rom room one "i
them who was halt coveted with HoIT a?Pr"I'"
80 ludIcrouS that one OF the Germans laughed. lnc
of the youug men went mp 10 the sailor wHp lad
Laughed and hat him Il severe blow IN tho i!rc.
The gang WAS ordered ont by SpHhGcHdGIc anu I"o
sailor, followed soon after ,
Wow vii you call George Icchman.' said Mr.
"HIo' sad Mr. Purdy, " III call no more. have
made cut my case. -,
Then i Will, sad Judge Cowing quickly.
what wines, 90 Won want, Nr. kIhp7hy
(,rorgc Icc cknlu testified that he saw the taiV "I
rou.hs charge at the sailors with cart ruugs "h'h
tArv had gouc'out oi.thc bdrfooL, and saw '"ilEAh
take Ilmiu jN the collar dl MI MN w Il y Il 'I"''
The prisoner then testified that alter the hdIl"Ib
n ld been assaulted in the barIouu lhrN W'I'
attacked outside. lumm was knocked down WIN
an ash baucl. The you z men attacked the "a I"it
with cart runLS and tolIgan struck IWIh once or
twice until the latter was forced t"' aHth7l ih'
wall and cndcay0gcd To ward oil the blows "l Hl1
:s,:ulant. COilIgHH continued ms HN.auF uhtII
Timlu drew hla sheath knife and stabbed MN
"What 30 you ask for in tins ca-cG asked JHdP'
COGimg of Mr. puIdy. ,o,
Mr.. l'urdy- A verdict for man-alfhtrr III mo H'''
degree. ,...,,., to,.r
Judge Gown g-Tor my part do not kh"" ihat ever
heard "A clear. case Uf self defence. II comes rA"cl
iu the dcriton ~ the Shorter case. The man Whr fo'
uon be- wa, struck relocated a. ihr rs p"nTLl" oNr
against the wall When he c'uli not rcif"n fHt1"f nh
was In danger ~ ui7 nfe he slew hi assN.aht iu'
death ~ the rcgrittabir, but hc nc'"hA'l
brought II on himself. Thc-a uuone1dluS German
sailor, engaged IN the peaceful celebration "i i.,
holiday when they -ot upon lE ms gang hu' !
VIII not characterize them II hdl ic ~ inc same
clrrnrsanre should nave done ~ TINS man dll'
Several of the Jurors raised their hands ana hod
dcd th siT heads approYingy at ihIs point ahd whri
Judge COwing offered 10 read the Ia" 70 tl'll
ana submit the case the foreman saId: " There IL
40 need We all say not gnIIiy.'
JAEHNE'S RESIGNATION ACCEPTED
When the Aldermen were called TO order y"stcr