The Hawaiian gazette., 1886-04-20
Supreme cez-t eF the Hawaiian Islaaas--
AZ CAAaNe-s-Ia Eeeszaeat.
M,Kr $, Roee " HsSss SNura,


1
This * 4 motion On the psrt u the dc.
PENDANT that the plaintiff h OvieCei to
produce fo- irSpsc;ion ~ counsel all desiS
under which plaintiff CLAIMS title "
which she intends % Introduce in evidence,
| ~ furnish : memorandum ~ such rs Sre
u recc-i with dates, names ~ gTSrtosS,
grantees, Sni ts>okS and pSSes q reoovVi
The Compiled Laws pSSe M Section
IS ~ the Evidence Ac. q 1870 authorizes
the Court 10 order Inspection u documents
IN al CASES N which previous 70 thu
! passing ~ this Act, : discovery might
hsye tean Obtained in 3 court ~ equity 81
the instance u the pSyty making the
| SpplScAtsoa,~
Is the present such cSSe The SetS0a
! elsc;nen;, The iefen,isn, II possession
u the land SeekS 5 discovery u ms oppo
nsltS' title, Would this ~ allowed IN
equity
Sso-y, SEXTON l4o0 SSyS IN concluding
she SsotSoa. Nor hiss pNrty right 10
Sry discovery excsp; q facts and deeds
and writings neceSSS-y Il his owp title, u
under which he elSimS; Tor ke i 10; s;
liberty - Ky into the title - the adverse
pNrty
IL Haskell ". Haskell. 5 CuSh.. $40 the
English rule Is sisted 80 hs thSt she plSin-
TT : oaly entitled To 5 discovery u Whist
Spps-sSics 70 q Is Necessary fo- his Own
,ltls, Sni that he hiss 10 night to p<y into
the titls q his adversary.
The tug rules given by WiS-1m 0a
Discovery Sres
!. Il : the right, & : general rule, q 3
p.E,ctlE II equity, 70 ex&ct from the de
PENDANT discovery Upon o9th s. Il al
Eas.sszS q fSct, which. beng well pleStsd
u the b,l E-s u,Sts-iNl 70 the p-oos q the
Plaintiff cSSs Sbc1t - cC-ce c1 fcr triSl.
and which the defendant dos ros by his
to-2 Q; plsSiirs s5zlis.
, Tbe right q plaintiff II e4aity IL the
os-eSs o: the defendants o2th Is limited
- discover q such material tNrsS rs ~
.xts - ths Plaintiffs csSs; and dos rrct
extend IL lie discovery II the manner II
which ihs defendants eSss : 70 be e1clu
szysly established. y - svlie2ce wEieA
rslsSss exclusively a. his (t'steniSHts' !
cSSs- See S-ory On PleSiir.-S- SASH
Bcs defendants coGrSal tlhe mover q
ne Ecoslc2 bs-sici reliss upon Ms.csi; ~
Harvey. ! Nsssy. Sen. 80 where Lord
EE-yiv1eke : reported % have sid. The
question ecEss - this. whether zny PEI
So II possession - ~ sSsSss. - tenant
q oshs-wlSs, nay not b-IrS 5 bsl to dis
cover TIE ute u : ps-so1 bringing Al
siecsEsri SSzizSi HIN - ksve Il st CIT
G-6 Sse whether tESs risis De ms N some
osksr- Il, - oplnso- he Esy - scsbls
hI- - Czks 5 Gsfs-Ss II s5sc5Escs even
considering him w-u-s ioe1
WigTE1 CT Discovery denies the doc
trLrs- L : ss-iocsiy Questioned ty Lord
C1isi BEuz Eyrs- BIT, following this
6sclSSo-. Cex-csLlor Kent II the case a
hIEherlsy " Sis. = John CT. CSS. 4
ISIS slowed 20 bona tie purchaser II
r'1Sssss1o2 q II sS1z.s. discover q the
s-V1riS q wticA kis Kills VS. sc-SE. %
D. 51pegclsi by Gsfsci1as wbo had ~
cslVsG I-iS-,sEs 1E,zi-St the person from
Shoz sEs plaintiff dtrlus,i hLs uils. Sc
Al sI1=icz.lcc q this case shows 8 vs-y
i1Esre-5 safe u fzc5s trU- the case before
~ Ics Ind WIS shout 70 De sold b. the
S1s-LE q sIsc.-zlCz q TIE judgment held
~ EEs dsss-iE-is IND H. the CEslcsllC-
SITs. HERE WIS E-ck sc---y n the cal
CpCC GsSscl1-.s - disclose the S-C12is
y Their clz---- ant L he plaintiff WIS duly
EpprzZsi q tbs elm and On wt-zr II rss=sti
- night bs i1izesi 10 pay ths iaGzoi
under tks i-i---,scs II ur,isE u save him
sell i-or- sEz. less
EE-s u Is gurk o. Discover 2 9l5l
sxys tEz5 tEs issaz1l1 n Mssc.st r. Hsr-
vsT sI-s-,ts n tz-rhsr thar tnss bil
-z-Ssd S--5:5s-s fCl-2iE-ilz f-z discover
WIKI S-SSssss czCse q spu-sLzzSl1C.
izE-. L t1s csks-3EE7 s1-Gli -scuTsE II
&s SIT. the plzI-.lE nay ret b sued By
scEs oihzr reEslC TEs case WIS u the
zE-z-s o. II L-ssrplzasil-S bill suggest
IL the existence q N Ectz-i whc wl-Ii
cs entitled 70 thz ss5E-s E-i prayed that
II E-.c-1. I Il existence l-rs-pisGi az
d MT think tbs ca<s L authority
SSE--Ss ths t1c1-L-s thai svu3zoees . d.
tsoiz-97S nile az protected tru1 d.
c'-Tsry On the Application u tbs plaintiff
wLscs II ether slsEEE1 srS-s. and which
prI-c-uls / cc--roysE1s6 By The z17-sr q
tbs El5a1E
N-rscTsr. We have 3 Registry gE Convey
E-css L tbs hz-c3-E E-t IL cu-usI
discovery @: titles tkE1 nay De zscsrrz5z.a,i
~ <,sLry1 would I-i-E- Be u-Eza-,t o..
See Rebsrrs u OprezE=L-- 81 L I
Rsp- y : - See Bs5izr - Bridges.
3 L F Esp- y ) SIS
rstzss tk= order
Azhs-r,5 L AsEscr5 t1z tie c-5lcz= :
II EE5ch t1c c5z5ra
Er-glzt- NE-.- 9th Is;sS