Indian chieftain. [volume] (Vinita, Indian Territory [Okla.]) 1882-1902, 1886-04-15

WNNt WnN NNTmOU 'fIrINn NntIOnNIIfE.FF NpnNs
i,g itself IN n demand Tor general solf.gov.
ernment In Irish-not imperial affairs.
"The conclusion" Mr. Gladstone said, 'F
triotlsn, which IN itself is not bad, bnt
good" fCheere.i rho Wclahmnn is full OF
local patriotism; W. scotchnan. is full OF
~ strong as II ever was, and n the need were
TO arise, believe II would he Ms ready 60 ns.
sert itsclf os II was IN the days OF Hammock
history Alright misfortune and caiumny have
welded her sons to the soil with an EN-
brace yet closer than = known eisewhcrc.
Irish. But IL docs not follow that be.
cause historical patriotism Il strong that ho
There orc two modes of presenting the
subject which have been argued. One Is to
present what We now recommend 10 good
evils and as the lesser among tho varied
evils With which as possibilities wo are
Well, have nruucd the matter rs ~ IL had
been a choice of evils; have recognized Ms
fncts and as entitled to attention iealousics,
nrgued i on that ground rs the only ground
upon which II can be recommended, not
only 70 mixed auditory but TO
the public mind or to tho country that
can not give minute Investigation to all
portions OF this complicated question. ! do
not know whether 4 mny appear too holf,
hut In my own heart 7 cherish the hope that
this Ia not merely choice OF lessor evils, but
thft u may he proved TO be ere long n good
In itself Loud ard long continued cheers
There u know nm answer TO this, and
what Il the nnswer7 The answer IL only
found In view which rests upon bnsis OF
dc spalr. Of absolute condemnation OF Ire.
and aud Irishmen rs an exception to tho
beneficial provinces which have made In
general, Europeans. and In particnlar En-
Rllshmen and Americans, cnpab' Q Cf self gov.
crnment; that an 1rishnian l. iHWs Hdfurae,
that justice, common sense, moderation and
natural prosperity have no meaning for
can appreciate Is strife aud perpetual dis
sentions.
Now sir; nm not going 10 argue in this
House whether this Wow. this monStrous
Wow icbccrs from tho parnellltesl, Il n cor
rect one. | say nm lrishman Is as capable OF
loyalty as another man frencwt-T 4hccrs
from the Irish membersl, hut N liSs loyalty
has hccn checked, why IL ~ Because tha
laws by which he Is governed do not present
themselves to him Ms they do TO M in En-.
gland or scotland with q native apA con.
genial element
! have no right 20 say thas ireland.
through her constltutlonallv. elected mem.
ors, VIII acce pt tho measure i propose.
nope thUy viii. hut have no rlghA 10 ~.
upon England and Scotland BOT I rely on
the patriotism and sngaclty Of tho Hou-e ON
free and fnli discussion, and more than
all, upon the Just and generous sentiments
OF tile British Nation: anil, looking for.
ward. I ask the House, believing that no
trivial motive could have driven ua TO as
work which wc believe VIII restore Parlin.
ment TO its FREQ and unimpcdcd rourse-I
ASK them TO stay the
WASTE or rnE runuc TREisusE.
under the present system Of royernmcn.
and administration In Ireland, which II not
waste only, hut waste which demoralizcs
while II exhnusts. l ask them 60 show TO
Europe and America that we, too, can face
the political problems which America hadto
face twenty years ago, and which many
countries IN Europe have been called upon
ask that we shall practice as we have often
preached, and TINT In our own ~aso wc
should De firm In applying tho doctrines We
have often inculcutcd IN others That tile
concession OF local self goTernmon, Is not
the way TO sap and impair. but to Strength
en- and consolidate unity
nsk that VIC should learn 10 roly less on
written stinulatons nnd moro on thnsc brt-
ter siinulntions written On the hrurt AMI
mind Of man. ASK that we should tpply N
gained in England ami Scotland. whore
course Of generations has now taught us-
not n dream. theory. hut as nittter ot
practice nui lifc-thnt the best aur surcst
fOuurnt' on we can find 20 huild on is a
foundation Afforded by the anectl1us and
convictions and VIII OF mip. Rnd tlut II IL
thus by the lie, rec of the Almighty thr moro
than bv any other mcthor, we may be en-.
titled to secure nt once ths social harpincsS,
1ss pISc@ E@?wer and the p'rm"0enee OF ''e I'm
Mr.. Gladstone iesumed his seat amid a
burst OF cheers which lasted many u'lnutes.
TREvEtrAN's orrosIrIox.
Mr. George otto TrevolyHn who rrcentiy
resigned the Sccretary-hip Tor SCctiani,
then arose and said he rcstgnce with regret
but without hesitation. ~ - remain In tlie
Cabinet would have been a confession of
aiiiint.on with n home RUE parry. Hc ds-
clRrcd that total separation would &c pre-
ferable to Mr.. Gladstone's scheme.
AH PAHSELL FOLLOWED
Mr. Trcve'yar. Referring 20 tho lattrr's re.
marks, be snid that what Mr.. TrcN"ly tn IA
best understood 1relRnhs neccs-it.e-. Mr..
rarnOll proc ecdei to Justify many ~ his
past uttcrtnces which Mr.. Trovclynh had
critlci cizcd.
Speaking Of America. aud what Trey elyan
called the assassination literature over
there, lac said that most literature was
neither American nor lr sh IL Mr. Ttcvcl.
yam would take the tr1uhle to study Mu'ti-
can literature, he w1uld Ind ~ this mo snsut
American writers were full of symnathy for
III" Just S-ttlrment Of tine grievances of
Irelrnl by cnnsi-tent domcltic legislation.
This feeling was infCad shown Toy MI classes
IN America Native born AmeficNns we're
cspeclilly hopeful that Mr.. Gladstonr's ~.
forts would suit in the ss'nb' tshmcnt OF a
permanent peace between Enslnnd and lro-
Mr.. ParnclI further said that ~ this timo IL
was OF tourse Impossible for him 10 hc thor
ouVhlY familiar with tile prov spus nf tho
bill Which Mr. Gladstone had fast laid before
the House. lie therefore reserved the cN-
PRECISION Of tull opinion on the prcmior's
scheme until be had carefully examined tho
measure In detail, hut he believed the main
poinisof the plln which Mr. Gladstone hal
cNpouhde would. n carried into successful
operation. not only prove beneficial from
an Irish point of view. hut he believed would
also De found 20 be OF equal credit 60 I'm
gland
on some points and would need revision.
The financial propositions especially ha
thought we're unfaynrahie 20 Ireland pnrtic.
ularly with regard 70 the lrish tribute 10 tho
Imperial exchcqucr. Mr.. rurneii also
CntriCtzgD THE PROPOSED "Two ouDERs,"
which Mr Gladstone suggested for
tho composition OF tho iri~h Parlla.
mcnt. Apart from ~ defcct-, fcw
of which he attempted TO enumcratc,
be believed the mcn .iirr would be cheer
fully accepted by the lrlsh people nnd their
representatives. us a satisfactory solution nf
the long stnuiug diHnute between the twp
countries and tending u promote the peace
OF ireland and satisfaction ~ IN lani.
When PArnnll took his scat ~" Irish nom
bers rosc lu u body cheering mndiy for some
time. Thcy wcri Joined by SIR. Gladstonr's
HE Hight Honorable u. H. Piunke.. mem.
her for Dui lin University. In u brief specCh,
predicted that The measure would no meet
with public approval lie pointed out sono
OF iis lnconslsicncicA
on motion ~ Mr.. Chant craln the debate
was adjourned.
Sir WIN Vernon Harcourt stated that Mr.
Gladstone would move tn morrow TO Give
precedence 60 the debate upon his Irish
m assure.
Mr Giadstouc left the House ten mirut 3
after completing his speech lle spft red
somewhat finm the rclciiln after the cK.
cit ment attending tine delivery 81 rs
spccch, and was obliged 10 retire to rest
Immediately after dinr.r. A Cabinet conn
Gil Will 10 held on Friday.
what the London PaperH Say About n.
Tho Times praises Mr Clads'ono's orntorl.
ca edVt, but -ays tlat ftnt vi.rs NUT "A
cause &c smtteu vita. fOrtwh c. evrn Mr.
GiRdrtouc'H energy wins 80 Little cordially,
The IiTes adds thnt j would hc grossy nm
fair 10 assume that tire House VIII consent
10 fcconi iotdinf.
The DaHB NeirS says 80 l. difficult 20
forecast tile fnie OF The Erhcuic or even ~
ssy huW II viii iar@ in IT. pr1rrps. tirnurh
The House SIR TrFvriNnn's attitude was
moro SERIOUS than the tpuacryutlveH and
Orange opposition combined. aud in all