Wheeling register. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1878-1935, 1886-07-24
voTg FORTY-FOUR TOSEVENTEEN
ss,rs That There Are Other Honest Re-
pubicanS Besides
roGsN. EVARTS AND TELLER
Aiming to Tamplo Out the Foul Ohio
Doodle Gang,
Who Conspired to Blaeksn Senator Henry
B. PAYNE.

. Hg Z
a,,.ou. -, -,
usarjon.
vr T,yrts closed the debate in an argu-
,.~,in,t further investigation. 1t was
-,,, IL. doubted, he said, that the Senate
... n,l,,,.r Of the question presented and
,rJrr mo- Law or restraint except that
...,.,,..l hy the Constitution. But by the
...... r.-,~nnS the scope and boundary Of
.r. >.,,,tr', mastery and duty were fixed
d. ,h.. ~mr firm instruct MS Of the Con-
.,.rrr,nn Whatever rights, or whatever
lr,f.> IN regard to yiudication or the pun
.r,.rYr of those concerned in frauds in
,,,,.. in Senatorial elections vested in the
..n,r, We're liked in the Constitution.
rnr SENATE HAD No POWER
ami nori,ht to investigate the conduct of
,.,Il,irll partya the request OF another.
r,mn.down To the merits ofthisparticu-
rr,,~. he quoted Senator PIyne's letter
T., nm. Chairman OF the Ohio Legislative
j Committee. inviting and challenging the
n..,r thorough and rigid scrutiny, and Of
f...n, for inspection his private correspond
,I..saI b,,kS OF accounts, and Chairman
,.naIl, reply, that il there was any teS-
rrr.at tending 10 lnculpate
U- p,ynr in any degree with
gn. questionable transaction, his
r,.r.-r would De- acceded to. Could any
r,r.,n. he asked, required more prompt
,r more universal proposition
r,ni the senator? The fact that the
uar., legislative committee did not call ON
Nr Hl,nr MS a proof II did not consider
there w., anything before 1t which re-
,u.ryi his examination. Thus the OPINION
OF Uuip about their senator vas clear Ii
wl, clear from one end OfOhiOtO the other.
m an the agitation Ofthe subject no lmpu-
rrlou hli touched the Senator. He was
ughi then ia y,Iyin" the Senate must dis
,.,nI thlt view of the matter from Its con-
>ldrrl,iuH.
EEFERRING To THE EXTRACTS
lrnra Democratic newspapers which had
been presented by Messgs. HOar and Frye,
Nr Eygrts stated that those editorials
u,r,. all published Immediately after the
election, when all Ohio was ablaze, and
thtr when six weeks afterwards MIR. Payne
p.,,rntrd himself, he took his seat IN the
senate aS calmly - a summers morn
.ng. ~ u king would come To his throne
The Senator whom ne succeeded presented
Nj, credentials, and the other Senator from
ohio Mr.. sherman held up the hand of the
sworn senator when he took his seat.
Senator's might talk till they were hOarSe
.,h,ut pnyrr and force and value OF this
u-,~plprr testimony. but it was two years
uN and when il WAS gathered up by the
unpu~itc party the case WAS IN dlfer-
emf situation. When he said, gathered up by
rn.. uppn>itr party, he should say that he
did not know who had collected 1t. lie
hIl never >rtn il in the committee room
amt Iad never dreamed such matters were
Il 10 be. ur~tntrd These Democratic editors
u,tr.lt of meeting, ~ sometimes happened
mupIiural distractions, To have Demo-
rritlr feast ON crow, had decided to hold
\ ROW PARLIAMENT
The parliamentary system of these know
mg birds Wa, extremely simple. They all
~rokr nj the same time and they all said
,h.>,m. thing. They had great power oi
Voice hut very limited vocabulary
The, hld great energy of association, but
great loyrrty ut action. They had great
emphasis in their elOcutiOn, but they
lacked the rising and falling intlec-
trru> that were so recommended
hg IhrturivtluS from Quinulllus down.
oull scholars of that charming art. As Il
,hr opinion which Senator sherman had
gwen of ole Murat HalStead, that his at
urN~ We're ui no consequence, aS hc had AZ
tackled Grant. sherman and Lincoln, a
we'll 20, logan-hr said he would not ven
turr tn >prak ct the editor OF the CIncin
ultl ramu, rriil- Gnzsttr quite in that tone
% would seem from what Mr.. Sherman
hd SAID that this gentleman dIdn
write the words Of a lion. lie was re-
minI,d of that scene in a MidSumme
Nights Dream where the yOunl
FlIsrgs We're intending to entertain tn,
company with the comedy of "Pyrameu'
aad rh,sbrr. " and where they were con
s >gluug J~ To how the lion might be repre-
~ulyd without frightening the ladies. H
IrIrlrrd a portion of this scene VIII
E,Urh comic effect, ending with Bottom
M "''h'r lhl nun Asllltt AAtH iAlAiN INV -
lh.m plain h, iSSnug the joiner. Laugh
u.r
Referring to Mr.. Hoar'S allusion to tn
1,; lhIt Mr. Payne had not previousl
hsrn known aS candidate he mStanceu
THE CASE OF MR.. GARFIELD
rvrIylng the nomination for the Presl
drUry M % convention where he WAS repre-
syuung the interests Of another tavorIt
SON of ohio. and he asked whether II wa
10 br said that that could not be accounte'
Tor except 10y trrIchcry OF use Of money
other Improper means.
Nr Hear said the argument of the Sen
aior from New York, stripped OF itS emo
l.uu, It's passion, its clOquence, its w.t. II
mocll cNhOrtatiOnS (which SCENE
strangely out OF place on the side for whIe
they We're invoked, was reduced to thes
two PROPOSITIONS: First, knowledge shoul
prrgyde Investigation, not follow 1t; Se'
ond, the people Of the whole cOuntr
arr not ~ concerned in the questiO
AZ 10 whether their lawmakers sit in II
S"nltr hy UncOrrupted title ~ they are
thl> question. whether i'm this investigate
the people OF Ohio had been remiSs
tagdy. lftherc was anything else IN q
argument he could not think what It wa
This closed the debate and the Sena
Proceeded to take the vote
SAT DOWN on HEAVILY.
The first vote WAS on the resolution
Ne>SrS. Hoar AMI Frye, for further nye
ug1tion, and it WAS rejected; yeas IL, na!
". Is follows:
Yeas-Messrs. Blair, Conger, DAVE
EdmundS, Frye, Hale, Harrison, H2wle
Moar, NcNlillen, Malone, ManderSo
Mitchell lOTegonl, Palmer, Platt, She
man, and Wilson (IOwa).
Nays-Beck, Berry, Blackburn, Brow
+ Butler, Call, CaRden, Cameron, ChaC
CIoekrell, Coke, COlquitt, CuilOm, Eust
ENartS, Gibson, German, Gray, HamPto
Harris, Hearst, Ingalls,, Jones (ArkanSa:
Jones Jones nevada, Kenna, Logan, Moxe
Miller, Plumb, Pugh, Ransom, Kidd
Berger, Salisbury, Sawyer, Sewell, Sts
lord, Teller, Vance, Van Wyek, We
voorhees,, Waltham, WhitthOrne, and W
son Maryland).