The Hawaiian gazette., 1886-02-16

ss,eat If the United States Of AuerioS,
ard JOSEPH Bse, who Is named IN the wSr'
rant, has No suthority whatever from that
Government.
: The CoUrt on HabeSs Corpus enquire
into the exercise Of Executive discretion
when the right Of personal liberty IS In
yclved
q This GCvCrnmeut Is not Observing g
due respect 20 the United States when It
treats one Of the States In al MS; sets Is
though It were sovereign power,
10 From the warrant Of Grrest and the
affdsyi5 Of the Attorney Gecerl It sp-
peGrS thAt the CRIME alleScd to have been
Committed by John " Mccarthy for
which Is sought 20 be extrutlited Is that q
-E,mbezzls-uert That srubezzleuCut
Committed IN foreign country VIZ. the
United States : not an offence or crime
for vhlch John W. Mccarthy can b. eS,
tratitej
Il Tina: the demAnd for exradiuoa +
made through the Governor Of the State
u California. That there Is 10 authority
IN law for sud Governor 10 make this dc
nGrd
The case wgsS elSbOrately presented by
the leured counsel and the following
authorities iltsr z'ir were cited IN support
Of his cu-tertOrS-
Bishops Or. L, Sec, - 19G, =
L : v. Lancaster. > Mclean 451
Cohen ", Virginia. Wheat. 26t
SpeSr On EStrUiti0D p, = >, ll6, liz,
I95> l96, -, 81
Opinions Of Atty Gerl Vol Fps. Vol
8 p 81, =, 4Sl-
Holmes -. Jeuui>1c. IA Peters $40
The People eI rel Barlgw ". Curtis, ~
\, Y. 81
R5spubGcl -. L0aScha-1vs Dali l-Q-
Re W1rE SOW Haw 5-.t
A TreGty : supreme Law Of the land
Foster v. Nelson Pet. -,
Wheat Int. Law 1894
Shorts case 10 Serjs. EGwls Isl
In II WSshbur-e John Oh. Is, lU6-
Remarks uf Turey. c. J. Rhode Island
y. Massachusetts,. Il Peters IS.
The Attorney General commended that
the HawUilzr Government might under
the authority Of SecaicC 40 Of the Civil
Code and by international Law, altLoUSh
not bound % do -. surrender the accused
uqtwTthStaniir- -EulSZzlsueur' was not
& crime included in the Treaty with the
United States
By rEE CurErs-IL5 IrsJ point we have
60 consider /. whether the Minister Of
Foreign Affairs hG> authority by law 10
issue his warrant % surrender the petl-
toner
L i O disputed question among writers
On international law - to how Tar SOY
sreisr state i gbiiysf 90 deliver up persons
chu-sd with the commission Of eriIagS in
q tCrpiSn country But It = nowhere held
tkEt the Government " g sovereign state
-Sy not in It's discretion deliver up such
fugrtIyes from Justice on requlSltl0n ul.let5
by friendly government.
Ii there be q trgE1y. Of course the CON
tractiu- Suites Grs bound to deliver UP
persons accused u the commission 1T
crimes mentioned IN the TreGty. but it
does not In our opinion follow that States
Gre urecludsd from SurrgulzrlnS persons
accused Of other crimes tLEr thCse spec
fled
The Treaty between tbs Government
and the United States WIS ratified IN Au-
uS5. $50, and by it the contracting powers
mutually agreed CO surrender upon official
rsguiSiti1c. 10 the authorities Of each, AL
persons vino. being Charged with the
crimes Of murder. piracy, Grs1n, robbery,
fcrgsry or the Urrsruucs Of forged paper.
committed within the jurisdiction Of Sithsr.
shall b., fgerf wf5hfr the Territories of
the other
In the case Of Arson VIM. the opinion
of the AtrUrusv- General IJ5r-srir.-f VA.
cited By counsel fur petitioner The At
t1rcsy General slys 1T Is the settled pol
l-ig doctrine rf H., United S-r-z.s chat In
fsusrdsut-vgf .sueclaL cruruac5.r1 Strts Is
r~rlf -1 deliver. rr-l fr-lrTvss F-r7ra 5--ti..s
Of another STATE 1t Is t-rrs. a1v STATE
nav. IN It's discretion. t7 this is q r--sfs-
Of international comfy towards trz for
zi-r state. bat all such discretion Is gf in
Convenient eLerul-s IN @ constitutional re-
public. organized is Is the Federal Union
ste. And similar CuirlgrS have been -fver
bv other ArtCrrav-lfsr5ra[ Of the United
States. and there : IN doubt EI-st Ehe
practice u the Cfove-rrsct Of the United
States and % Great Britain has in gen
eraI been IN accordance with ths policy
stated hv Mr.. CUSHING
But IN the casa 1f Ar-usIL5s. she. C7g7-
eminent Of the United STATES lfflf ssfzs and
surrender 20 the Spanish Government.
with winch there was 10 extra. izri-n treaty.
the person accused Of crime e Is true
Mr. Spear. O. Is saws it WIS nothing but
legal Kidnapping but the Government ez
srciSeG It's discretion.
But the case under cucs-d Grafton stands
u We think. On higher grounds than auv
previously us-tlcued.
The Legislature u tins kingdom bv
one Of its first laws after the rscg-zi51Cc
Of is Independence and sovereign rights.
adopted the principle that 1t l. the d-fy Ct
rhs State 10 surrender f1--5ivss from irs
tee By Article ". Section l. OF the sec
md Act Of kaueLareha the S-Ji. I'm Lct
to arrange the Executive DEPARTMENTS Of
the Hawzi-ac Islands II l. enacted.
The Governors ruCr receiving inform
alton from the Minister Of the Interior.
that any person IN alien iseir- from the
ii7-saics Of foreign Country On account Of
crime committed therein. Is I--kiu- II
their respective stands. szagil1- Justice.
and that formal demand has been made
for his surrender by the re7-ese urs ti7zs Of
such f7rsf-r ccurtrv- OF in ease no de-
uard has been made tha- q public prgcls-
nation has been issued against sI-ch f--.-i-
tive and reward offered for his ru1rnr5r-
SION and surrender. shall have POWER and
=r-1r Ea r---- 1----- Pr ---.9 % --------.---+