New-York tribune., 1886-08-25
,.r sroBs IN THE sroCK EXCHANGE

Az oPPRo yors EPrTHsT-PRoMPr
s,srrxsIoS or BOTH BROKERS WHO OFFENDED
tn. Anil hours of qulet speculation at the
rxsnange had their monotony broken yesterday
=, me periodical personal collisions on the noor
-, institution. The principals were Cnftou IL.
- raxtn B. Havebs, and the chief outcome or
r-s.,r Ma. The prompt and wholesome action OF the
-,rv Committee in sGspendng boh men
-. heen some time since the Exchange has enjoyed
-~.,.els OF its members settling disputes by appeal
A' ,.nlv art OF assault ana selfdefence.
yesterday the bOaTd-recm presented the ap-
of scattered groups OF languid brokers bi iiGhg
~ -, a ersetion or down TO the same extent, while
F ,,rguid brokers sat on settees here and there
,~.rs WAS sitting with friend near the Lake
- .-ovrd ana Nc. Smith was oy him- RemarknS to
s.,5 ,ha, Work. strong Go. hsi bought 1900
-. - lake shore stock, Ar. Havens was contra
- by NJ smith Mr.. Havens repeaTed his remark
- n, smith again said shat the firm had bought only
- 80 The former broker said that he knew what
,,ting about and that Mr. smith was misrepre-
-, ,acs Mr. smith wanted TO know II
- r5.~ars called him liar. The latter insin-
,.d nat that Interpretation might lie PM on
=. rsm.rks Thereupon Nc. Smith invited his col
-. % come oatsde and indulge In fsucufS hut Mr.
In. refused to have anything to do with MS ehal-
,.rer usiug an orproniOns epthst OF somewhat LILO
h,.as,er ~ describe him. What next foiowedls - IN
,v, I'm some Doubt sr Ravens claiming that he rose
IA vent away and thar Mr.. Smith followed MN ana
,es b,,p In tho face The weight OF evidence, how
-, seams to show that the assault came almost I'M
.a,.,elv after Mr. Havens uttered his offensive Ian
80 NJ smith striking him three good blows on the
,r ere Members instantly interiered and separ-
"a tho men though Mr. HayeDs displayed
- intense desire 20 return the attack A'Eer
N. encounter Mr Hsvens showed decded discolora-
,cr az lis eft Optic which will probably not be I'M
,-cv-d tc-.av according 70 experts. tie declined 10
,ase any s'aiement 20 TEIBlN reporter. -o
NJ Ravens niued the Exchange on December =, - o.
.,S ass ~ ofNce with Hatch Footc, No. Nassau ST.
Ie ts tai aha Of sght buil0 not over thirty, spDar-
IVY wth blue eyes ana "a blonde MDstache. IL Is moi
enc AT ne be hsd imp casant relations with fe
sncounirr with MI Tilghman. od broker and about
sixty-lve years of axe, by questioning tne
Iaftcr's veraciry. On that occasion Mr. Hsyrns
was suspended for days Mr. smith IL
Hidsie-ssed. short ana thickset. He n Nrgnlan ol
The r rs" and Is well Liked IN he Exchange, out -
oucs ana pulsive lie joined the Exchange on Apfi1
q Sc AMI has ~ office a No. 33 Nassau-st
Promptly az s3;l5 ?. H. the Governing tonin.e ! u1
viih rne Offending bros ers before IDet Aitef
in- both sides the men acre suspended from tne
IxchaBge for days each The acton OF ihe gov
error- ws spp auded Szlatsry lesson Dy thOse "no
heard OF II terwarl mber OF the n-itt~e
We regard a who provOkes \ blow In tAe Doaru-
room A. great offender be who strikes the OlOw
Ne intend TO show dignity and rules OF the Ex-
shsue cannot be violated without punishment or the
one who urOvObes well as the one VINO makes the
An o,d broker remarked " II ts time that The Ex-
,hsrg. d.alt fhe Jaw 10 both parties 20 brswl II no
,n.n was ever called liar the board-rOon. no blow
would be struck"