Middlebury register. (Middlebury, Vt.) 1886-1937, 1886-04-09
CREAMERIES AGAIN.
A REPLY TO MIR. DOUGLAS.
MIpnLEnrRY. VI. Mnrch 30.


S ~, y ~ " t,, 'oSts lUtttI III tlc
ni.in ~ w -; ~, ,, i,,, M i' WIN 9""i per
/ viii sew. tbnt IL v"s uot my. irtontio,, ,ot
tu ,,. -, -! % i,,,, ,,,,. ~ M 81 ,h; S ~ w ~ i @
,,, I -, a ,a 49,. S ,i,i, ' -, IN - a. i
Nr bn,,rirS b,l L,i ,7 - w. ,, Nm, Ky ~ - ,i
ali sn,n,r Ttb E, Wv t V,t IL ] =, i
titrd n, an,- o,Lnr ,,.,,. IL ,,st ,,n - rv..,t ,
i.r,,i,,,, ~ ,,,,,,. ~, 80, 80 i.',. - ''ii,'tt'
nit rirh H., ,,, iI ,,i " I; ~ m
nv nud twitb and ,vr h,v' th .,r,,,
~, h, j. t ta,, ri,i,t "a, M in hi t ~ n
rVtrnt nf ,is ,,,,J i7iIit,. If !. t,ii, Ill INN,
NOR nuI III tho i,,i,t. Me-, , ,,,L
yitLout ono thou,rht nf tIn ,,inui,,,t,. ,l,li,r
which thc most nt ms mortal. arc yynri,ing tor.
| nm tinnl,In Il, n,nurnLn,,d ., ,li irtnr"st,.,i
ness and am sutnrisrd that surh ~ 1o,J ma n
should SO freely nnnly tha rnithrts If ..ti.su,.
of filsrhood. niisrrpicsentation." etc. to one
who docs not agree with him. / think in cv.
cry instance fnvc my authority for nv state.
mcnts and they are in my posScsssion now
and fail to timd Il single denial of ANYTHING
thr nn rtirs snid hntnrn in Nr Dnu,,ios' rrr,Iins
~ p"i , We SUI" pcloIc !" MI b""SH's roplleS
| will now proceed TO answer Mr. Douglas
in detail. He quotes me rs saying that ~.
Whiting x son of Milton y H. Discarded
their separator on account of the poor uunlitv
of the butter" which statement is correct and
| stand ready to prove it Notwithstanding the
quotation which MIR Douglas makes from a
letter of Mr.. Whiting written ut another time.
| will explain further that they offered TO
sell their separator after usinp if less Than n
mouth, for about twothirds its cost, and as
Mr.. Douglas wanted to buy, of course they
could give it II qualified recommend and keep
within the truih In that Letter he uuotps
them rs saving that "if our busin s. was not so
large we would he glad to use it," | am very
glad that Mr.. Douglas uses this quotation, be
cause he and other advocates of the centrifu
ugal have claimed lust the Oppositp WIS trup
that their machines were particularly a,lapted
where there was an immense amount of milk
and this quotation of Whiting x son proves
their claim to he wrong.
The Writings have since discartiing their
centrifugal put in Cooley cream. .vat he ring
and within two weeks ha We ordered tour of
the largest size Cooley cren1nrrs in addition
to those already in use
ID. Whiting K Son writes AS follows. owe
do not think the machine has been running
the full value of one entire month in all we
will sell il TOR 5000,
The WRITINGS are no+ ,,,nninu tbn cantrit1
gal machine ~ thr nrrsrnt tim7 and are usin,r
the Cooley more extensively than ever
Now. lei Us examine what Mr. Douplns SAYS
about Ontmnn Rros What he nubli shrs ,lnns
not contradict fine uuotntious in my letter
in one iota, which SAYS - am satisfied the
mer months when the fires are only wanted
Tor r., IN hn,,rs ',,it -, ~, 49, 81 ,riH ,H , y, -
Douuns GERS un ,gIo,,i ram ,Lt ,''',,,,. WI
Now as TO Mr. Br6sius Mr. Binsits in tbr
lottcr which Nr Fvnrts nuotns In"s not IL,
any way contradict my uuotntion. which was
! conird from thn oX'tor,i pnnu press nt
| March is iSS5 which Nyns os fnliovs 1T
were starting in husiunss o,,,in ,,itl, a dnir,.
OF POO cows would unhcsitatingly use the
| Cooley above all other systems / have any
knowledge of and for a m4,lcrnt,. sizrd cream
rrv would rrcom,nrnd thr Cnolrv. hernus,.
! il makes brttcr buttpr thnn can he ;nnde viii
| thr snnnrntor ~ ~ ~ " ' "'
Mr. bou~Ins saws in his letter that Mr. Nor
scv .sccms TO he very nroud over Tho arhinv
lnonts of the manufacturers in selling from
! 81, 900 TO OnI Cooley crenmers to th, FARMERS
which il another IInstrntion ot mo ,,nIiihiIt,,
OF the American public"
! hardly think the American farmers will
thank Mr. Douplns for exnrnssiu,, s,fb an
opinion in reference to them. If these thirtv
or forty thousnnd crnninnrs bnd hnnn nii;;I
! i'm n short scnson nnrhans tb.ro ,ni,,ht 49,
been some truth in Mr. non,,lns :, rn,nnrL I,nt
as they have been on the market now fornine
they have ever had, shows il seems TO me
rather that the American nnhiic nnnroci.tn
good thing. and makes he old nijat,n I'm"
that the proof OF the pudding is in the ett.
! ing" and he can be sure il the nuddinv is nor
n good one il will MOI stand for ~ rn,,,,7,r A.
! throu,yh nine v.nr. ,y IN ,,n,,'titn' II ,,'
inp lie snrni,s Of sni,, 80, i ,,'b9 ~ C
| icVs have been thrown out. and ms hnve ha
fore remarked, every one Of th Sc was of the
| very rurlirst maEn TbnW 6o,a H in n
verv materially i,nmroved nnG arc no,,, ,nuch
! better than they were in their early introduc.
/ tion.
This is aprogressive age improvements are
constantly taking place. If the disusc of any
improved. is any argument against its merits.
what shall we say OF the tens OF thousands OF
| agricultural machines scattered all over the
! country, ana which would not sell TODAY for
| five per cent. of the cost, simply because they
! have been improvedupo To illustrate, and
| bring this right home to Mr.. Douglas compre.
hension, we will take Hay.Loaders, with
which, believe, Mr.. ID. has had an extensive
experience.
Mr.. Douglas says, "the fact is the Cooley
crcaIners are sold on false representations as
| to the labor and expense of running them"
Now the fact is this assertion is about as false
as can be. as tar as | am concerned, at least,
and presume il is in regard to other
| agents. never sold one except on IA guaran.
tee, and thousands who have used them for
years are ready to say that thoy will more
| than fulfil the guarantee. | sold "a good many
| last year on the recommendation Of those who
| had used them nine years
Captain Franklin and l.. +. Moore, never
had aCooley creamcr, rs Mr.. Douglas writes,
80 that remark in reference to the creamers
| tails to the ground.
Mr.. Douglas says "Now | make the asser.
| ton, without fear of contradiction, that At.
wood Jones patrons did not receive IS cents
per hundred for their milk"
now have Atwood 4 Jones' statement OF
the amount of milk received and the amount
paid the patrons for the same, and ii will he
seen that il is over 7G cents per hundred
pounds. Now let us figure this out so there
Will he no mistake about it.
Atwood S Jones pnid for 504 5i5 lbs
ot min, " .oy,, 90,
Al Mr. Evn,ts G,ctnr,. ,nt 5is H. a., f''''f''
a. r,nts nu,o,;inr t' ''' '''' ~ d, ,-,. .-,
'''''''"
Maxim, thr loss NJ Evorts t,ctor,. .,-t nn