Telegram-herald., 1886-06-20

al.i.ssI Ia Ienuarg l>.a o. scat haF aaaY -
Rasrln afl1 ter W.aaFes Aise hg ressta
4I tae ecaiII..l differences t.sf essa eola-
p.altaal all Asa1 tse yaauEer E.aztier
~ defendant ana lae iaes>>4al ealA-
pain ef asr unreT-lts asl0sl-
doa spd naElecf ~ proper ana
reasonable attention 90 ler "a c.alal alaoinaat
o. l4s feen aeI sea O. send tFr ifolu aoaae
60 sclo.I 81 ha' --lsE-sa- ale-l--ae, acre
she Hoa is Au4 a4aIlF on lls lo-h aag Jf
September l>-a Complainant ieft herself
aud a-s most af tae lme sinee. eelu 4o in-
alale al s4ia faiinan faullis. although DE-
ienaznt has. ever slnee s4ia leth 4sH Qf
September lad proper aud suitable aa.oie-
nIad4llon provided iof hsf and lhen. ana
noa hiss d .asFs entertaining great love and
affection fsr her w4s anxious. ana ls ns'~
ior b-r 90 lFe sltn llm as lis slla. ~1icn
she has ever since aud fer = long time before
ana noH doss REFUSE 40 ca.
and it,s deiendant further answering
says that from November lsL ISIS. a.
December l0th. ls7s. and nom DeeeaDef
lst l,73 10 January 5th. l,s0. complainant
vas absent Ia Cory fennsylsanis VITA hls
consent aud desire, visiting her
SICK relatives But when ou tae ass day Of
January. aud when there was Ho neCess-
iiy oi her remaining longer, be Informed
her lhat the necessities 81 his family re-
Quifs-i her return. she replied by- letter
dated January II. lss8 En0s neaning
Enos Putnam is here and wants me o. re-
aain u short ume longer And she did 50
remain. luai on Nay j, $50. complainant
said that she MAS going o. Cory fennsYl-
yania for few weeks rest WITH her sister.
but Was absent Ia Philadelphia and other
places visiting until July /. against the de-
sire and la disregard Of the necessity of her
presence with defendant and his children.
And in April, lo,l. complainant informed
defendant thai she had made arrangements
% visit Ann Arb1r aud OIhtr places, with
a daughter oi AR Putmans. Defendant
attempted TO reason with her. ana insisted
that she should take his daughter Annie
with her. not only Tor the benefit II would
be 70 her, bat that she Was giving 50
much more attention - hr. Putnam
children than 10 his own that IL created ieai-
ousy and dissatisfaction. To which she
replied. Il have promised EEOs 90 take
T Helen and l shall. You can take your
/ children where you wish 10.
That shortly after her return. and ia
June lssl. she again informed defendant
I that she had made arrangements with said
! Putnam 10 accompany him aud his family
I 10 Spring Lake. New Jersey. a seaside resort,
/ 20 spend the summer Aud when de-
/ fendanl objected and demonstrated. telling
/ her that be thought he should az least be
informed before she aud Putnam made
such arrangements. that she had been
/ absent a great deal since their marriage
/ without him or his children. and also that
/ has purpose was 10 take her and the children
10 some resort during the summer himself
she replied. "EnOs is very kind 10 me;
promised han | would 90 with him. and
shall Hatties health is not good. and
wish TO assist herin caring for the children
Aud in disregard of defendants reasonable
wishes, she left with said Pullman and
family on June 26. 1881, and remained
away with them until August 9 following.
On July -, defendant wrote informing
/ her of the necessity Of her return, ID which
she replied by letter, dated at Waldron,
New York, July -, as follows: II shall be
I gOvernei bv the movements OF Enos, and
/ will probably be home August 3. with
Hattie and the children" That immediate
IN upon her return. defendant informed hei
that he had business at Grand Haven foi
one week OF more, and had engaged room.
/ at the Cutler House for the family. and de
sired that she aud the children should accom-
pany him: but she objected 70 taxing the
children. and said: Il will 90 with you a
few days. and you can take the girls after
wards.
This defendant further answering says
that from August, 1881, 10 June. 1852 they
eqioved comparative quiet; al which time
lease OF the house in which they were living
had expired, she had planned 10 store hei
goods and Office furniture, and take A res
with her relatives in Pennsylvania ans
New York till the coming fail. and desire,
defendant 10 obtain rooms and board fO
himself and children until her return
when IL could be better decided what wa'
best for the future. And he, believing he
10 be acting in good faith acquiesced IN the
4 .l.44h
on Bostwick- St, in this city. That afte
the family were settled there, and on sun
day evening, previous 10 her departure, OF
the following Monday, the Rev. DIR. Grave
called upon her and gave her a letter II
relation 70 her standing in the Bapus
Church. And while listening TO their con
ver~ation. defendant learned for tn
first time, that trip had beei
planned 10 Europe. for complainant
passports and letters of creiit obtained
steamer and state rooms engaged and tn
time already fixed for sailing from NeS
York August 10, by the State Line in tn
steamer Florida.
indignant and amazed al the treacherl
and perfidy of the transaction. deiendan
leatned bat little of the particulars in IN
few hours remaining before her leaving
Failing to obtain any information from be
he soon learned from other sources. aud j
50 informed and believes. that she and Emo
/ Putnam secretly and clandestinelv arrange
the scheme, and all its details In such man
ner as TO keep all knowledge of the sam
from defendant That on Monday morn
ing. July 3. iSe2 she left defendant and bi
children for Cory, Pennsylvania. Mr.. Pat
man meeting her AZ the depot and givin
her a sum of money secretly IN two week
thereafter she wrote defendant that sh
should spend the time up 70 August 10 ii
travelling with Mrs Putnam and children
visiting the Thousand Islands. &onirea
and other places. and kindly added TAX
care OF your own children and make eac
other happy"
CA the Isl Of August defendant went &
f New York and endeavored 90 persuade con
plainanf ~ abandon her proposed trip o
Eurnre aud 10 She would do So that th
following summer he wonid accompan
her. if she desired. That. after consultation
she refused and be informed her he shoal
take measures 90 prevent her going on ih
steamer Florida. as he could legally %
That he would not allow her 10 leave bin
SELF and chiil-en IN 50 disgracefli q fnannr
without az least showing proper resentmen
' That be felt perfectly competent when hi
wife desired Ia 60 abroad. % make al Oh
; proper arrangements. with her assistance
him self. without the Interference Of Mr. Pas
man or any one else She then promised hif
81 he would make no further oUposin0
she would refurn 90 three months to hil
and bis family Defendant aceomp8ute
her g. the steamer. and about two hours bf
Z fare the time ~ saisinE. sbe informed hil
she must SAY good bv. ss she desired 6
srena thc remainder ~ flc une Wifh fnn'
Nr ps.f4-l4' t.tre sad fHr rs5i.Iren ffa